AB 2934: Residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program: county health departments: certification.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-06-14
(1)Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to implement and administer a residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program, as specified, including adopting regulations regarding accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work, as defined, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Existing law requires specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued by the department.
This bill would require the department, by February 1, 2019, to request permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement to expand its authority and authorize a county to implement and administer the certification program for persons engaged in lead construction work described above. The bill would authorize the department, if it receives this permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency, to authorize authorize, upon request of the county, a county health department to implement and administer the certification program. The bill would require specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued either by the department or by a county health department, if applicable.
(2)Existing regulations promulgated by the Division of Occupational Safety and Health require an employer to ensure that an employee is not exposed to lead at concentrations greater than 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air averaged over an 8-hour period.
This bill would require the division to complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit for lead in the regulations described above by July 1, 2019. The bill would authorize the division to promulgate emergency regulations as necessary to implement these provisions.
(1)Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to implement and administer a residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program, as specified, including adopting regulations regarding accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work, as defined, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Existing law requires specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued by the department.
This bill would authorize require the department department, by February 1, 2019, to request permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement to expand its authority and authorize a county to implement and administer the certification program for persons engaged in lead construction work described above. The bill would authorize the department, if it receives this permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency, to authorize a local county health department to implement and administer the certification program for persons engaged in lead construction work described above. program. The bill would require specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued either by the department or by a local county health department, if applicable.
(2)Existing regulations promulgated by the Division of Occupational Safety and Health require an employer to ensure that an employee is not exposed to lead at concentrations greater than 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air averaged over an 8-hour period.
This bill would require the division to complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit for lead in the regulations described above by July 1, 2019.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to implement and administer a residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program, as specified, including adopting regulations regarding accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work, as defined, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Existing law requires specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued by the department.
This bill would authorize the department to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification program for persons engaged in lead construction work described above. The bill would require specified persons engaged in lead construction work to have a certificate issued either by the department or by a local health department, if applicable.
Existing law establishes the Department of Parks and Recreation and vests the department with the control of the state park system. Existing law authorizes the Director of Parks and Recreation to negotiate or renegotiate a concession contract within state parks if specified conditions exist and generally requires that a concession contract within state parks for a period of more than 2 years be awarded to the best responsible bidder, as defined. Existing law requires all bids for a concession contract within state parks to be presented under sealed cover.This bill would expressly state that the bids shall be presented under sealed cover in a format specified by the department.Existing law establishes the Department of Parks and Recreation and vests the department with the control of the state park system. Existing law authorizes the Director of Parks and Recreation to negotiate or renegotiate a concession contract within state parks if specified conditions exist and generally requires that a concession contract within state parks for a period of more than 2 years be awarded to the best responsible bidder, as defined. Existing law requires all bids for a concession contract within state parks to be presented under sealed cover.
This bill would expressly state that the bids shall be presented under sealed cover in a format specified by the department.
(a)A program is hereby established within the department to meet the requirements of the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 4851 and following) and Title X of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1992 (Public Law 102-550).
(b)(1)The department shall implement and administer the program. The department shall have powers and authority consistent with the intent of, and shall adopt regulations to establish the program as an authorized state program pursuant to, Title IV, Sections 402 to 404, inclusive, of the Toxic Substances Control Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 and following).
(2)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), the department shall, by February 1, 2019, request permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement with the federal Environmental Protection Agency to expand its authority and authorize a county to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter.
(B)If the department receives permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A), it may authorize a county health department department, upon request of the county, to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter.
(c)Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers that are adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) shall include, but not be limited to, provisions governing accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work as defined in Section 6716 of the Labor Code, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers shall, as a condition of accreditation, require providers to offer training that meets the requirements of Section 6717 of the Labor Code. The department shall, not later than August 1, 1994, adopt regulations establishing fees for the accreditation of training providers, the certification of individuals, and the licensing of entities engaged in lead-related occupations. The fees imposed under this subdivision shall be established at levels not exceeding an amount sufficient to cover the costs of administering and enforcing the standards and regulations adopted under this section. The fees established pursuant to this subdivision shall not be imposed on any state or local government or nonprofit training program.
(d)All regulations affecting the training of employees shall be adopted in consultation with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health. The regulations shall include provisions for allocating to the division an appropriate portion of funds to be expended for the program for the divisions cost of enforcing compliance with training and certification requirements. The department shall adopt regulations to establish the program on or before August 1, 1994.
(e)The department shall review and amend its training, certification, and accreditation regulations adopted under this section as is necessary to ensure continued eligibility for federal and state funding of lead-hazard reduction activities in the state. The department shall not require certification renewal more frequently than once every two years.
(f)All fees collected pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be deposited in the Lead-Related Construction Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury. Moneys in the fund shall be expended by the department upon appropriation by the Legislature for the purposes of this chapter. Moneys in the fund are available for cashflow borrowing pursuant to Sections 16310 and 16381 of the Government Code.
(g)Of the amount appropriated in Item 4265-001-0070 of Section 2.00 of the Budget Act of 2009, five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) from the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account shall be used to administer the program in the 200910 fiscal year. These funds shall be repaid to the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account upon a determination by the Department of Finance that sufficient moneys are available in the Lead-Related Construction Fund. No interest shall be paid by the Lead-Related Construction Fund at the time of repayment.
SEC. 2.Section 105254 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:105254.(a)The following persons engaged in the following types of lead construction work shall have a certificate issued by the department or issued by a county health department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 105250:
(1)Persons who receive pay for doing lead hazard evaluations, including, but not limited to, lead inspections, lead risk assessments, or lead clearance inspections, in residential or public buildings.
(2)Persons preparing or designing plans for the abatement of lead-based paint or lead hazards from residential or public buildings.
(3)Persons doing any work designed to reduce or eliminate lead hazards on a permanent basis (to last 20 years or more) from residential or public buildings.
(4)Persons inspecting for lead or doing lead abatement activities in a public elementary school, preschool, or day care center.
(5)Persons doing lead-related construction work in a residential or public building that will expose a person to airborne lead at or above the eight-hour permissible exposure limit of 50 micrograms per cubic meter.
(b)Persons performing routine maintenance and repairs in housing are not required to have a certificate if they are not performing any of the activities listed under subdivision (a).
(c)The department may adopt regulations to modify certification requirements for persons engaged in lead construction work based on changes to state or federal law, or programmatic need.
(d)The department or any local enforcement agency may, consistent with Section 17972, enter, inspect, and photograph any premises where abatement or a lead hazard evaluation is being conducted or has been ordered, enter the place of business of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations, and inspect and copy any business record of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations to determine whether the person is complying with this section.
(e)A violation of this section shall be punishable by imprisonment for not more than six months in a county jail, a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both that imprisonment and fine.
SEC. 3.Section 105258 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:105258.(a)The Division of Occupational Safety and Health shall complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit for lead in the lead standards of the general industry safety orders (Section 5198 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations) and the construction safety orders (Section 1532.1 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations) by July 1, 2019.
(b)The division may promulgate emergency regulations as necessary to implement this section.
(a)A program is hereby established within the department to meet the requirements of the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 4851 and following) and Title X of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1992 (P.L. (Public Law 102-550).
(b)(1)The department shall implement and administer the program. The department shall have powers and authority consistent with the intent of, and shall adopt regulations to establish the program as an authorized state program pursuant to, Title IV, Sections 402 to 404, inclusive, of the Toxic Substances Control Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 and following).
(2)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), the department may authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter. shall, by February 1, 2019, request permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement with the federal Environmental Protection Agency to expand its authority and authorize a county to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter.
(B)If the department receives permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A), it may authorize a county health department to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter.
(c)Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers that are adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) shall include, but not be limited to, provisions governing accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work as defined in Section 6716 of the Labor Code, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers shall, as a condition of accreditation, require providers to offer training that meets the requirements of Section 6717 of the Labor Code. The department shall, not later than August 1, 1994, adopt regulations establishing fees for the accreditation of training providers, the certification of individuals, and the licensing of entities engaged in lead-related occupations. The fees imposed under this subdivision shall be established at levels not exceeding an amount sufficient to cover the costs of administering and enforcing the standards and regulations adopted under this section. The fees established pursuant to this subdivision shall not be imposed on any state or local government or nonprofit training program.
(d)All regulations affecting the training of employees shall be adopted in consultation with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health. The regulations shall include provisions for allocating to the division an appropriate portion of funds to be expended for the program for the divisions cost of enforcing compliance with training and certification requirements. The department shall adopt regulations to establish the program on or before August 1, 1994.
(e)The department shall review and amend its training, certification, and accreditation regulations adopted under this section as is necessary to ensure continued eligibility for federal and state funding of lead-hazard reduction activities in the state.
(f)All fees collected pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be deposited in the Lead-Related Construction Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury. Moneys in the fund shall be expended by the department upon appropriation by the Legislature for the purposes of this chapter. Moneys in the fund are available for cashflow borrowing pursuant to Sections 16310 and 16381 of the Government Code.
(g)Of the amount appropriated in Item 4265-001-0070 of Section 2.00 of the Budget Act of 2009, five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) from the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account shall be used to administer the program in the 200910 fiscal year. These funds shall be repaid to the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account upon a determination by the Department of Finance that sufficient moneys are available in the Lead-Related Construction Fund. No interest shall be paid by the Lead-Related Construction Fund at the time of repayment.
SEC. 2.Section 105254 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:105254.(a)The following persons engaged in the following types of lead construction work shall have a certificate issued by the department or issued by a local county health department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 105250:
(1)Persons who receive pay for doing lead hazard evaluations, including, but not limited to, lead inspections, lead risk assessments, or lead clearance inspections, in residential or public buildings.
(2)Persons preparing or designing plans for the abatement of lead-based paint or lead hazards from residential or public buildings.
(3)Persons doing any work designed to reduce or eliminate lead hazards on a permanent basis (to last 20 years or more) from residential or public buildings.
(4)Persons inspecting for lead or doing lead abatement activities in a public elementary school, preschool, or day care center.
(5)Persons doing lead-related construction work in a residential or public building that will expose a person to airborne lead at or above the eight-hour permissible exposure limit of 50 micrograms per cubic meter.
(b)Persons performing routine maintenance and repairs in housing are not required to have a certificate if they are not performing any of the activities listed under subdivision (a).
(c)The department may adopt regulations to modify certification requirements for persons engaged in lead construction work based on changes to state or federal law, or programmatic need.
(d)The department or any local enforcement agency may, consistent with Section 17972, enter, inspect, and photograph any premises where abatement or a lead hazard evaluation is being conducted or has been ordered, enter the place of business of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations, and inspect and copy any business record of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations to determine whether the person is complying with this section.
(e)A violation of this section shall be punishable by imprisonment for not more than six months in a county jail, a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both that imprisonment and fine.
SEC. 3.Section 105258 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:105258.The Division of Occupational Safety and Health shall complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit for lead in the lead standards of the general industry safety orders (Section 5198 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations) and the construction safety orders (Section 1532.1 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations) by July 1, 2019.
(a)A program is hereby established within the department to meet the requirements of the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 4851 and following) and Title X of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1992 (P.L. 102-550).
(b)(1)The department shall implement and administer the program. The department shall have powers and authority consistent with the intent of, and shall adopt regulations to establish the program as an authorized state program pursuant to, Title IV, Sections 402 to 404, inclusive, of the Toxic Substances Control Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 and following).
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), the department may authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification program described in this chapter.
(c)Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers that are adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) shall include, but not be limited to, provisions governing accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work as defined in Section 6716 of the Labor Code, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training. Regulations regarding accreditation of training providers shall, as a condition of accreditation, require providers to offer training that meets the requirements of Section 6717 of the Labor Code. The department shall, not later than August 1, 1994, adopt regulations establishing fees for the accreditation of training providers, the certification of individuals, and the licensing of entities engaged in lead-related occupations. The fees imposed under this subdivision shall be established at levels not exceeding an amount sufficient to cover the costs of administering and enforcing the standards and regulations adopted under this section. The fees established pursuant to this subdivision shall not be imposed on any state or local government or nonprofit training program.
(d)All regulations affecting the training of employees shall be adopted in consultation with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health. The regulations shall include provisions for allocating to the division an appropriate portion of funds to be expended for the program for the divisions cost of enforcing compliance with training and certification requirements. The department shall adopt regulations to establish the program on or before August 1, 1994.
(e)The department shall review and amend its training, certification, and accreditation regulations adopted under this section as is necessary to ensure continued eligibility for federal and state funding of lead-hazard reduction activities in the state.
(f)Effective July 1, 2010, all All fees collected pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be deposited in the Lead-Related Construction Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury. Moneys in the fund shall be expended by the department upon appropriation by the Legislature for the purposes of this chapter. Moneys in the fund are available for cashflow borrowing pursuant to Sections 16310 and 16381 of the Government Code.
(g)Of the amount appropriated in Item 4265-001-0070 of Section 2.00 of the Budget Act of 2009, five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) from the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account shall be used to administer the program in the 200910 fiscal year. These funds shall be repaid to the Occupational Lead Poisoning Prevention Account upon a determination by the Department of Finance that sufficient moneys are available in the Lead-Related Construction Fund. No interest shall be paid by the Lead-Related Construction Fund at the time of repayment.
SEC. 2.Section 105254 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:105254.(a)The following persons engaged in the following types of lead construction work shall have a certificate: certificate issued by the department or issued by a local health department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 105250:
(1)Persons who receive pay for doing lead hazard evaluations, including, but not limited to, lead inspections, lead risk assessments, or lead clearance inspections, in residential or public buildings.
(2)Persons preparing or designing plans for the abatement of lead-based paint or lead hazards from residential or public buildings.
(3)Persons doing any work designed to reduce or eliminate lead hazards on a permanent basis (to last 20 years or more) from residential or public buildings.
(4)Persons inspecting for lead or doing lead abatement activities in a public elementary school, preschool, or day care center.
(5)Persons doing lead-related construction work in a residential or public building that will expose a person to airborne lead at or above the eight-hour permissible exposure limit of 50 micrograms per cubic meter.
(b)Persons performing routine maintenance and repairs in housing are not required to have a certificate if they are not performing any of the activities listed under subdivision (a).
(c)The department may adopt regulations to modify certification requirements for persons engaged in lead construction work based on changes to state or federal law, or programmatic need.
(d)The department or any local enforcement agency may, consistent with Section 17972, enter, inspect, and photograph any premises where abatement or a lead hazard evaluation is being conducted or has been ordered, enter the place of business of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations, and inspect and copy any business record of any person who conducts abatement or lead hazard evaluations to determine whether the person is complying with this section.
(e)A violation of this section shall be punishable by imprisonment for not more than six months in the a county jail, a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both that imprisonment and fine.
SECTION 1.Section 5080.09 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:5080.09.All bids shall be presented under sealed cover in a format specified by the department.All bids shall be presented under sealed cover. cover in a format specified by the department.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 14, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | Referred to Com. on EQ. |
| May 31, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 30, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (May 25). |
| May 16, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 2, 2018 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Re-referred. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 15, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Mar 12, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on W.,P., & W. |
| Mar 8, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on W.,P., & W. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 6, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2018 | AB 2934 STONE Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2018 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 2934 (Mark Stone) - Residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program: county health departments: certification
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
This bill would allow the Department of Public Health (CDPH) to authorize a local health department to implement and administer a program to certify individuals who perform lead hazard evaluations, plan lead-based paint abatement plans, perform lead hazard abatement or remediation, or perform lead-related construction work. It would also require the Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) to adopt regulations establishing a revised permissible exposure limit (PEL) for lead in general industry and construction.
Fiscal Impact:
- Onetime costs of $1.5 million to for CDPH to develop a new data system.
- Ongoing CDPH costs of $175,000 to work with the federal Environmental Protection Agency and local programs.
- $255,000 in annual revenue loss due to renewal every other year.
- Potential costs in the hundreds of thousands for Cal/OSHA to adopt emergency regulations as required in the bill.
Background: Existing law requires the CDPH to administer a residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program, in accordance with federal law. This includes adopting regulations for employee training accreditation for lead-based construction work, and certifying employees/supervisors who have completed the training. CDPH administers lead-related construction employee training and certification programs, since the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting Rule (established in 2010) requires that firms performing renovation, repair, and painting projects that disturb lead-based paint in homes, child care facilities, and pre-schools built before 1978 have their firm certified by EPA (or an EPA authorized state), use certified renovators who are trained by EPA-approved training providers, and follow lead-safe work practices.
Proposed Law:
This bill would allow CDPH to authorize a local health department to implement and administer a program to certify individuals who perform lead hazard evaluations, plan lead-based paint abatement plans, perform lead hazard abatement or remediation, or perform lead-related construction work. It would also require Cal/OSHA to adopt regulations by July 1, 2019 establishing a revised permissible exposure limit (PEL) for lead in general industry and construction, and authorize CAL/OSHA to promulgate emergency regulations as necessary.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 2934
Author: | Mark Stone | ||
Version: | 6/14/2018 | Hearing Date: | 6/20/2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: Residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program: county health departments: certification
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
Under United States regulation Title 40 Chapter I Subchapter R Part 745 Subpart E developed under sections 402 and 406 of the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) (15 U.S.C. 2682 and 2686) also known as the Lead-Based Paint Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP Rule) requires that persons performing renovation, repair, and painting projects for compensation that disturb lead-based paint in homes, child care facilities and pre-schools built before 1978 be certified by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), or a US EPA-authorized state, use certified renovators who are trained by EPA-approved training providers and follow lead safe work practices.
Existing California law:
Requires the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to implement and administer a residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program, as specified, including adopting regulations regarding accreditation of providers of health and safety training to employees who engage in or supervise lead-related construction work, as defined, and certification of employees who have successfully completed that training and to establish and impose fees for those accreditations and certifications and for licensing entities engaged in lead-related occupations, as specified.
This bill: Amends the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Program to authorize the CDPH to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the program that certifies individuals doing lead-related construction work. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires DPH, by February 1, 2019, to request permission from the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to expand its authority under the Lead Related Construction (LRC) program such that it may contract with counties to provide certification to lead-related construction workers.
- Authorizes DPH, if it receives permission from the US EPA, to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification of trained lead-related construction workers.
- Provides that DPH not require certification renewal more frequently than once every two years.
- Requires the California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) to complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit (PEL) for lead for workers by July 1, 2019.
- Provides that the Cal/OSHA may promulgate emergency regulations as necessary to implement this section.
Background
Lead is a well-known toxin: Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that is known to the State of California to cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been listed as a chemical known to cause cancer since 1992. According to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, lead has multiple toxic effects on the human body. Decreased intelligence in children and increased blood pressure in adults are among the more serious non-carcinogenic effects. There is no level of lead that has been proven safe for children or for adults.
Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
Lead-based paint history: Lead-based paint was shipped in Colonial days to what became the United States as a luxury good, and was later used to paint such important structures as the White House, the Capitol, and Mount Vernon.
When lead pigment was used in paints, currently reported risks to children were unknown and unknowable. Medical science has evolved, leading to concerns about childhood health that did not exist when lead-based paint originally was marketed.
Before 1940, paint manufacturers began to use non-lead pigments, such as lithopone, zinc oxide, and titanium dioxide, in many interior paints mixed at the factory. In fact, Sherwin-Williams introduced the first, successful lead-free water-based paint for interior use in 1941. Its easy use, clean-up, and quick drying launched a do-it-yourself paint market.
In 1948, the Baltimore Public Health Department observed an increase in childhood lead poisoning in Baltimore, primarily among those who lived in its substantial number of rundown, neglected row houses amid massive amounts of peeling and flaking lead paint. That led health inspectors to investigate those houses and to learn that children were eating lead from peeling and chipping lead paint in that city’s inner-city housing, poorly maintained during and after World War II.
As soon as those new concerns were raised, the paint industry worked closely with public health officials to investigate the risk. The paint industry provided research funding, which helped guide the Baltimore Public Health Department to issue a ban in 1951 on the use of lead pigment in interior paint in Baltimore housing. That was the first restriction on the use of interior lead paint in the country.
When the same problem was found in the dilapidated housing in older cities in the Northeast and Midwest, the paint industry also worked with the American Academy of Pediatrics, along with other groups interested in child health issues. In 1955, a voluntary national standard was adopted to prohibit, in effect, the use of lead pigments in interior residential paints.
When lead-based paint was marketed before 1978, it was a legal product in great demand because it was washable and durable. It was repeatedly endorsed by the federal, state, and local governments, and specified for use on government buildings until the mid-1970s. For example, the 1950 California Department of Education vocational book on painting endorsed the use of white lead paint.
It was not until 1974 that a new theory emerged on the predominant pathway for children to be exposed to gratuitous levels of lead. In a paper by Dr. James W. Sayre, House and Hand Dust as a Potential Source of Childhood Lead Exposure, Dr. Sayre felt that the major source might be house dust, contaminated with lead from many sources. The theory was that children were licking their hands that had become dirty with lead-contaminated dust. His theory brought about a move beyond the earlier recognition of a risk from chipping and peeling paint. He also observed that average blood lead levels of children living in low-risk areas of Rochester, New York, were in the range then of 18-25 µg/dL.
In 1978, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission banned consumer uses of lead-based paint. However, buildings built prior to the ban still likely have lead paint, as well as commercial, government, and industrial buildings and structures, which are permitted to use lead-based paint.
Lead-based paint, like all paint, inevitably deteriorates: it flakes, chips, and turns to dust and can contaminate the air, soil, floors and other surfaces in the home. This is particularly true of lead paint on windows, doors, and other friction surfaces.
Lead-based paint in California: According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint.
As a case in point, about 75% of Alameda County’s homes were built before 1980, which amounts to 430,000 units. Nearly 174,000 of those units are pre-1950. Lead-based paint hazards in Oakland homes are considered by local health officials to be "coming close to crisis mode." In Oakland, between 80% and 90% of the housing was built pre-1978, which accounts for about 174,000 units.
In Los Angeles County, 77% of the housing was built before 1978, which is more than 2.6 million housing units. More than 900,000 of those housing units are pre-1950. In at least 75% of Los Angeles County's lead poisoning cases, lead-based paint is a potential source of lead poisoning. At least 70% of those cases involve individuals living in pre-1978 housing.
Lead-paint cleanup costs: Lead-based paint removal costs an estimated $8-$15 a square foot, which means removing all lead from a house of 1,200-2,000 square feet could run as much as $9,600-$30,000, according to RealtyTimes.com. The average removal project runs around $10,000 for a typical pre-1978 home.
The following chart provides an estimate of the number of pre-1978 housing units in ten jurisdictions around the state. The estimated costs for cleanup in these jurisdictions alone are $400 million.
Judgment against paint industry: In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers to hold former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation: the County of Alameda, the City of Oakland, the City and County of San Francisco, the City of San Diego, the County of Los Angeles, the County of Monterey, the County of San Mateo, the County of Solano, and the County of Ventura.
After a six-week trial in 2013, the trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions by promoting lead paint for interior use, despite knowing the substantial harms that would result from the use of lead paint. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties. The three paint manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to inspect for and abate lead paint in all homes constructed through 1980. (The court did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance.)
Manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion to fund inspection for, and abatement of, lead paint and lead-contaminated dust from the interiors of homes and lead-contaminated soil around homes built in 1980 or earlier in the ten cities and counties; remediation of any structural deficiencies in the homes that would cause the lead control measures to fail; and, public education and outreach necessary for the program.
The ten cities and counties were designated to oversee the lead inspection and abatement program in their respective jurisdictions. Property owners’ participation would be entirely voluntary, and any funds unspent after four years would revert back to the manufacturers.
In 2017, the Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s determination that Manufacturers were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th at p. 51.). However, the Court of Appeal limited the judgment to homes built before 1951.
On February 14, 2018, the California Supreme Court denied requests by the manufacturers to review the appellate court decision requiring those three companies to pay several hundred million dollars to identify and clean up lead paint from millions of homes built before 1951 in Santa Clara County and nine other California cities and counties, meaning that People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. can be considered a precedent by California courts in any future litigation against lead paint manufacturers. The manufacturers plan to further appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court. In the meantime, however, the case is returning to the Superior Court in order for the trial court to do both of the following: (1) calculate the amount that manufacturers must pay for pre-1951 homes only, and (2) decide on a receiver to administer the fund and distribute the monies to the ten cities and counties.
Lead paint initiative: In response to the court's findings in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., the paint manufacturers are proposing the ballot measure titled "Eliminates Certain Liability for Lead-Paint Manufacturers. Authorizes Bonds to Fund Structural and Environmental Remediation Projects" for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint on California homeowners.
The measure would authorize the state to issue bonds to "Fund Structural and Environmental Remediation Projects"; authorize $2 billion in general obligation bonds to remediate homes for various hazards (mold, asbestos, pests, radon, and lead); declare that lead-based paint is not a "public nuisance;" and, retroactively nullify all cases pending or pending on appeal as of November 1, 2017.
According to the Legislative Analysist's Office, if the bonds were sold at an average interest rate of 5%, the cost to the state’s taxpayers would be $3.9 billion to pay off both principal ($2 billion) and interest ($1.9 billion).
This measure would vacate the aforementioned appellate court decision, upholding a trial court’s ruling that paint manufacturers are liable for cleaning up the lead paint crisis in California and instead create a taxpayer-funded bond for abatement.
What the court decision does not do, despite industry arguments to the contrary: As previously noted, the Court of Appeal's decision in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. upheld the lower court's determination that the paint companies were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties that brought the lawsuit, and ordered the paint companies to pay $1.15 billion to fund a large-scale inspection and abatement program for lead paint in those communities, as specified. In addition to understanding what the court decision stands for, it is just as important to understand what the decision does not stand for.
The decision does not "red tag" homes by making each and every home a public nuisance for which the homeowner is now individually liable. Since the launch of their campaign to place an initiative on the November ballot to overturn the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision, the paint companies have publically argued that the decision "'red tags' millions of California homes . . . by finding that pre-1981 homes with old lead paint are a public nuisance . . . putting the home investment of millions of California's working families at risk."
(www.notanuisance.com). Proponents, including the lead paint manufacturers found to be liable in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., contend that homeowners are now exposed to civil and criminal liability for not addressing the public nuisance that is their homes, following the court's decision. However, this alarming characterization is simply not supported by a close reading of the court's decision.
First, the court did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared to be a public nuisance as a result of the litigation. The court held that the collective presence of lead paint in the affected homes in the 10 cities and counties constituted a single public nuisance, for which the defendant companies Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries are responsible to remediate.
The court addressed this argument directly when it was raised by the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) in an amici brief supporting the paint companies' position. In responding to PLF's claims, the court specifically and authoritatively set forth what the judgment does and does not do, as follows:
PLF contends that the judgment improperly affects the rights of individual property owners without notice. It does not. (emphasis added.) The abatement plan ordered by the trial court is premised on voluntary participation by property owners. No property owners will be forced to participate, and therefore their rights will not be involuntarily impacted. . . PLF insists that the court’s abatement order has "declared a nuisance" on individual properties without notice to the property owners. Not so. (emphasis added.) The trial court ordered defendants to abate the public nuisance they had created, but it did not identify any specific properties. The abatement plan itself is designed to identify and remediate the individual properties upon which defendants’ public nuisance exists. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th, at p. 134.)
In short, the judgment cannot, as a matter of law, be used to establish criminal or civil liability on the part of any California homeowner. To the extent that any such liability, as described by the paint companies, exists for homeowners, it should be noted that California homeowners were subject to these same theoretical risks of liability for a public nuisance before the judgment, and that the judgment does not create any new theory of liability for homeowners, according to the court's own explanations. The only thing that changed as a result of the court's decision is that the defendant paint companies were found newly liable for the costs of abatement for the public nuisance which they were found to have caused.
2. The decision does not automatically threaten the property values of millions of California homeowners. The argument that the court decision burdened millions of homes in California with the designation of them being a "public nuisance" is being used by proponents of the initiative, including the three paint companies found to be liable for the cost of remediating the nuisance created by the lead paint they produced, to sound that alarm. As a result, the proponents claim that the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision is "putting the home investment of millions of California's working families at risk." This argument has apparently instantly resonated with many homeowners struggling to understand the legal complexities of the case, judging from the large number of email messages received by the Legislature that were generated through a website operated by the paint companies. However, this argument also is a mischaracterization of the appellate court decision.
Again, it should be emphasized that the Court of Appeal did not find in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance as a result of the litigation. Instead, the court held that the collective presence of lead paint in the affected homes in the 10 cities and counties constitute a single public nuisance. As a result, the presence of interior residential lead-based paint has existed as a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions that were party to the legal case against the paint manufacturers for some time now. Because these 10 jurisdictions contain approximately 47% of the state’s population, any effect on property values due to the court's decision would be relatively easy to detect in such a large proportion of the state. However, there has apparently been no evidence, empirical or otherwise, documenting any decrease in property values tied to the court’s finding.
It should also be noted that homebuyers and renters have long been required to be given notice that any dwelling constructed prior to January 1, 1978 is presumed to contain lead paint. According to the California Association of Realtors, any risk of sudden loss of value has been reflected in property values for years, and thus the court decision does not suddenly threaten current property values. According to a recent article in the Los Angeles Times:
"The rulings created a huge burden for homeowners," Klingler (a spokeswoman for the ballot initiative) said. "It labeled millions of homes public nuisances, which can cause a loss of property value."
Not so, countered the California Association of Realtors.
"We don't think that's the case at all," said June Barlow, the organization's general counsel. She said the state already requires disclosure of lead paint during home sales, so the risk has been reflected in property values for years. Barlow also said a close reading of November's court decision indicates that lead paint in general is being labeled a public nuisance, not the presence of lead paint in individual homes. (David Lazarus. "It's deceptively called the Healthy Homes and Schools Act, and it's a taxpayer ripoff." Los Angeles Times (March 30, 2018).)
By contrast, it seems that the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision will more likely reduce the risk of liability for California homeowners, particularly for those who could not otherwise afford to clean up their lead paint, by giving them a means to abate the lead paint in their homes and eliminate their future risk of liability. In other words, properties may rise in value if property owners can affirmatively prove that lead-based paints have been safely removed from their property, and access to abatement funds under the judgment make such removal far more likely.
3. Participation in the abatement program created by the court decision does not increase liability to individual homeowners or necessarily subject them to local nuisance enforcement. The paint companies have also argued, regarding People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., , that participating homeowners will have their addresses entered into a public database which then can be used by local jurisdictions to target individual properties for enforcement of nuisance law and to issue other fines and penalties.
It is true that the judgment requires the creation of a public database of properties that enroll in the abatement program, as well as a list of all properties that fail to enroll in the inspection and abatement program or subsequently fail to undergo lead hazard control. However, the court directly dispels the paint companies' arguments by reinforcing that participation in the program is voluntary, and that inclusion in this database should only help those homeowners, not hurt them. According to the appellate court:
While it is true that the abatement plan contemplates that the 10 jurisdictions will make publicly available a list of properties that have not been enrolled in the abatement plan, this provision alone does not substantially impact the rights of individual property owners. Already, any property built before 1978 is presumed to contain lead paint. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 17, § 35043.) That presumption eliminates any impact on a property owner from a publicly available list of only those presumptively lead-paint-containing properties that have not been enrolled in the abatement plan. Property owners can only gain from enrollment in the plan; they have nothing to lose. (People v. ConAgra, at 134.)
In conclusion, the court's decision in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. will reduce the risk of liability for California homeowners, particularly for those who could not otherwise afford to clean up their lead paint, by giving them a means to abate the lead paint in their homes and eliminate their future risk of liability.
Clarifications in the Law to Safeguard Participation in a Lead Paint Abatement Program. While the court decision definitively determined that the lead paint makers were responsible, it has been represented that one passage of the court's opinion suggests that lead paint companies could sue homeowners who participate in the abatement program for comparative fault. The court wrote, "[N]othing precludes a defendant from testing the lead paint at specific locations during the remediation process and seeking to hold a fellow defendant liable for a greater share of the responsibility. The same is true of evidence that the hazardous condition is ‘the owner’s fault’ or that it is not hazardous." (Ibid.)
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "AB 2934 allows the California Department of Public Health to partner with counties to certify lead-paint inspectors. By allowing counties to administer this certification, more inspectors will be made available in counties that have identified a shortage of certified individuals. Without the ability to increase the amount of those able to inspect and perform the abatement of lead paint, homes will remain contaminated and a potential hazard. AB 2934 will provide the best path forward for those local jurisdictions that need more inspectors."
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2074 (Bonta, 2018) removes a significant hurdle to homeowners holding poison paint manufacturers legally accountable for injuries by establishing that lead paint companies are responsible to prove they did not produce, sell, distribute or promote the lead-based paint used during a particular time or area, and allowing homeowners to hold companies jointly liable if there were multiple companies selling or distributing paint at that time and area. Codifying this "risk contribution" theory in statute allows those poisoned by lead-based paint, who are unable to identify the exact manufacturer of the lead paint pigment, a new avenue to litigate cases they may not otherwise be able to litigate. This bill is on the Assembly Floor.
AB 2803 (Limon, 2018) would provide additional liability protection for homeowners by redefining the definition of "hazardous substance" to include lead-based paint for purposes of the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner-Hazardous Substance Account Act, otherwise known as California’s Superfund law. This would allow homeowners to seek damages for clean-up or otherwise implement their own clean-up without fear of liability lawsuits. This bill is set to be heard in the Senate Environmental Committee on June 20, 2018.
AB 2995 (Carrillo) classifies the presence of lead-based paint in a home or building as a physical injury to the property, enabling property owners to sue for the cost of abating or removing lead paint to prevent the further deterioration of peoples’ health. Secondly, the bill delays the start of the clock on the statute of limitations to when property owners become aware that lead paint is present, rather than starting the clock at the time of purchase. This bill failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AB 3009 (Quirk) would enact a fee on paint manufacturers for all paint sold in California to create a fund for residents of single-family or multi-family dwellings to clean up lead paint that has contaminated their homes. This fee will only be imposed if an initiative passes that states that lead paint is not a public nuisance. This bill is on the Assembly Floor.
Related/Prior Legislation
SOURCE:
County of Santa Clara
SUPPORT:
California State Association of Counties
County of Monterey
County of Santa Clara
Monterey County Board of Supervisors
Ventura Board of Supervisors
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2934
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:April 26, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Rules | 6-0 | Cooley, Brough, Cervantes, Grayson, Salas, Waldron | |
Environmental Safety | 5-0 | Quirk, Arambula, Bloom, Holden, Muratsuchi | |
Appropriations | 13-0 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Obernolte, Quirk, Reyes |
|
SUMMARY: Amends the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Program to authorize the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the program that certifies individuals doing lead-related construction work. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CDPH, by February 1, 2019, to request permission from the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to expand its authority under the Lead Related Construction (LRC) program such that it may contract with counties to provide certification to lead-related construction workers.
- Authorizes CDPH, if it receives permission from the US EPA, to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification of trained lead-related construction workers.
- Requires the California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) to complete rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit (PEL) for lead for workers by July 1, 2019.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, should this bill be enacted, it will result in one-time costs of $1.5 million to CDPH to develop a new data system and ongoing costs to CDPH of $125,000 to work with the US EPA and local programs.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 2934 allows the California Department of Public Health to partner with counties to certify lead-paint inspectors. By allowing counties to administer this certification, more inspectors will be made available in counties that have identified a shortage of certified individuals. Without the ability to increase the amount of those able to inspect and perform the abatement of lead paint, homes will remain contaminated and a potential hazard. AB 2934 will provide the best path forward for those local jurisdictions that need more inspectors."
Lead is a well-known toxin: Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child's health. Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce intelligence quotient and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, and hearing and speech problems.
Lead-based paint in California: According to the Legislative Analysist's Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint.
Judgment against paint industry: In 2014, Santa Clara Court (Court) held that three paint manufacturers who sold lead contaminated paint, knowing that it posed a serious health threat to residents in California, are responsible for paying to remove or abate the lead paint. The Court found the paint manufacturers had created a public nuisance and ordered them to pay into a fund to inspect for and abate lead paint in specified homes in 10 local jurisdictions involved in the lawsuit.
Abatement program required by the court: Under the 2014 judgment from the Court, the ten local jurisdictions are required to create lead-paint abatement programs to be funded by the three paint manufacturers, and are given four years to spend the funds. Property owners who enroll in a local jurisdiction's abatement program will be screened to see if they own a pre-1951 property that qualifies for inspection and services. Properties will then be prioritized for inspection as described in the court's decision.
Workforce needs: There is a significant shortage of certified lead-paint inspectors and abatement contractors who are certified by the state to carry out this work. The need for licensed lead inspectors and abatement contractors is likely to be intensified because the upheld settlement means ten jurisdictions will be simultaneously competing for a scarce number of contractors to conduct large-scale abatement projects throughout California under a tight 4-year time frame.
According to CDPH, as of April 5, 2018, there are 910 actively certified lead-related construction certified inspector and assessors statewide.
However, those inspectors are spread across all 58 counties, likely leaving gaps in some regions where more inspectors are needed. For instance, there are only 12 certified lead inspectors in Santa Clara County. Many more certified lead inspectors will be needed to inspect the approximate 633,349 homes with lead paint in the county within a four year period.
Certification of lead-related workers: Under CDPH's LRC Program, certification means that CDPH has evaluated and approved a person's qualifications to perform lead-related construction work in residential and public buildings. CDPH evaluates applicants to make sure they have completed state-approved training and have relevant experience and education to perform lead work.
Local agencies currently cannot certify individuals in LRC, including inspector/assessors and individuals seeking to perform lead abatement. Only CDPH has the authority to certify LRC individuals in California.
On February 26, 2018, the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services had an oversight discussion on CDPH's lead construction certification processing delays. In its analysis, the Subcommittee notes that labor has complained about the amount of time it takes CDPH to certify individuals, thereby allegedly leading to significant delays in construction projects. CDPH informed the Subcommittee that the current average application turn-around time is approximately 60 days, while state regulations allow for up to 120 days.
If CDPH has limited resources, or any other challenges preventing faster certification, enabling counties to provide certification would multiply the entities who could certify, thereby increasing worker certification statewide.
Solution: This bill would authorize CDPH to enable local governments to implement the certification provision of the LCR at the local level. Doing so would authorize local agencies to certify individuals doing lead construction related work.
Before CDPH can bequeath authority to counties to administer the certification program for inspectors/assessors, it must first request permission from the federal government. CDPH would have to obtain authority from the US EPA to give LRC authority to the counties because US EPA provides funding to LRC and any modifications to the agreement need to be approved by US EPA. Therefore, in order to effectuate the intent of this bill, this bill will require CDPH to request permission to give authority to the counties.
Permissible exposure limit for lead: Cal/OSHA maintains a permissible exposure limit (PEL) for occupation lead poisoning prevention. Since 2011, Cal/OSHA has been working on revising the PEL, known as the General Industry Lead Standard and Construction Industry Lead Standard for the protection of workers who are exposed to lead on the job.
Timing of the revised PEL is relevant to the context of this bill. Lead-paint certified construction workers cannot be certified under a more appropriate and scientifically supported PEL for lead until a revised PEL is established. It is imperative to get a timely approval of the revised PEL, so that workers certified to inspect, assess, or abate/remediate the lead-based paint contaminated homes are just as protected as the public/homeowners the court ruling wants protected. This bill would require the rulemaking for a lowered PEL for lead to be complete by July 2019.
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003101
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2934
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:April 26, 2018
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
| |||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Department of Public Health (DPH) to request permission from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, by February 1, 2019, to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement to expand its authority to allow the ability to contract with counties to provide certification to lead construction workers. Additionally, this bill requires Cal/OSHA to complete its rulemaking to establish a revised permissible exposure limit (PEL) for lead by July 1, 2019.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time costs of $1.5 million to for DPH to develop a new data system.
- Ongoing DPH costs of $125,000 to work with US EPA and local programs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 2934 allows the California Department of Public Health to partner with counties to certify lead-paint inspectors. By allowing counties to administer this certification, more inspectors will be made available in counties that have identified a shortage of certified individuals. Without the ability to increase the amount of those able to inspect and perform the abatement of lead paint, homes will remain contaminated and a potential hazard. AB 2934 will provide the best path forward for those local jurisdictions that need more inspectors.
- Workforce Needs. There is a significant shortage of licensed lead paint inspectors and abatement contractors who are approved by the state to carry out this work. The need for licensed lead inspectors and abatement contractors is likely to be intensified because of an upheld legal settlement that provides several hundreds of millions of dollars to identify and clean-up lead paint from millions of homes built before 1951 in 10 cities and counties. Property owners participate voluntarily and any funds unspent after four years revert to the manufacturers.
According to DPH, as of April 5, 2018, there are 910 certified lead-related construction inspectors and assessors statewide. However, those inspectors are spread across all 58 counties, likely leaving gaps in some regions where more inspectors are needed. For instance, there are only 12 certified lead inspectors in Santa Clara County, one of the counties involved in the settlement. Many more certified lead inspectors will be needed to inspect the approximate 633,349 homes with lead paint in the County within the four year period.
- Permissible Exposure Limit. Cal/OSHA maintains a permissible exposure limit (PEL) for occupation lead poisoning prevention. Since 2011, Cal/OSHA has been working on revising the PEL, known as the General Industry Lead Standard and Construction Industry Lead Standard for the protection of workers who are exposed to lead on the job.
The current standard requires that every employer shall assure that no employee is exposed to lead at concentrations greater than 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air (50 μg/m3) averaged over an 8-hour period. That standard is based on medical and scientific information that is more than 35 years old. Over this time much has been learned about the effects of lead among adults at lower exposure levels.
The PEL is proposed to be updated to reflect current medical science and establish a more protective standard for lead construction professionals, but it has been 7 years since the rulemaking was opened and no revisions have been made. Cal/OSHA is working with an external consultant to estimate the economic impact of the regulation – the contract with that consultant appears to be open-ended with no deadline in sight. When it is complete, Cal/OSHA will still then need to enter formal rulemaking, which can take an additional year before the revised standard is final.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2934 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:March 8, 2018
SUBJECT: Residential lead-based paint hazard reduction program: local health departments: certification
SUMMARY: Amends the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Program to authorize the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to authorize a local health department to implement and administer the certification program to certify individuals doing lead construction work.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the federal Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention Act to create a prohibition against the future use of lead-based paint. (42 United States Code § 4851)
- Establishes the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (US EPA) Lead-Based Paint Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) Rule to require workers to be certified and trained in the use of lead-safe work practices, and requires renovation, repair, and painting firms to be US EPA-certified. (Title 40 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) § 745)
- Establishes the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Program to require any person offering lead-related construction courses to meet CDPH certificate requirements. (Health & Safety Code § 105250)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 2934 allows the California Department of Public Health to partner with counties to certify lead-paint inspectors. By allowing counties to administer this certification, more inspectors will be made available in counties that have identified a shortage of certified individuals. Without the ability to increase the amount of those able to inspect and perform the abatement of lead paint, homes will remain contaminated and a potential hazard. AB 2934 will provide the best path forward for those local jurisdictions that need more inspectors."
Lead is a well-known toxin: Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been listed as a chemical known to cause cancer since 1992. According to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, lead has multiple toxic effects on the human body. Decreased intelligence in children and increased blood pressure in adults are among the more serious non-carcinogenic effects. There is no level of lead that has been proven safe, either for children or for adults.
The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found, based on the U.S. Census Bureau 2010 count of the number of children between the ages of 1 and 5 years old, that approximately 2.6% of U.S. children in that age group have high levels of lead in their blood (blood lead levels ≥ 5 micrograms per deciliter (µg/dL)).
Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child’s health. Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
The CDC's 2012 Advisory Committee on Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention statement Low Level Lead Exposure Harms Children: A Renewed Call for Primary Prevention found that the adverse health effects of blood lead levels less than 10 μg/dL in children extend beyond cognitive function to include cardiovascular, immunological, and endocrine effects.
Lead-based paint history: Lead-based paint was shipped in Colonial days to what became the United States as a luxury good, and was later used to paint such important structures as the White House, the Capitol, and Mount Vernon.
When lead pigment was used in paints, currently reported risks to children were unknown and unknowable. Medical science has evolved, leading to concerns about childhood health that had not existed when lead-based paint was marketed.
Before 1940, paint manufacturers began to use non-lead pigments, such as lithopone, zinc oxide, and titanium dioxide, in many interior paints mixed at the factory. In fact, Sherwin-Williams introduced the first, successful lead-free water-based paint for interior use in 1941. Its easy use, clean-up, and quick drying launched a do-it-yourself paint market.
In 1948, the Baltimore Public Health Department observed an increase in childhood lead poisoning in Baltimore, primarily among those who lived in its substantial number of rundown, neglected row houses amid massive amounts of peeling and flaking lead paint. That led health inspectors to investigate those houses and to learn that children were eating lead from peeling and chipping lead paint in that city’s inner-city housing, poorly maintained during and after World War II.
As soon as those new concerns were raised, the paint industry worked closely with public health officials to investigate the risk. The paint industry provided research funding, which helped lead to the Baltimore Public Health Department issuing a ban in 1951 on the use of lead pigment in interior paint in Baltimore housing. That was the first restriction on the use of interior lead paint in the country.
When the same problem was found in the dilapidated housing in older cities in the Northeast and Midwest, the paint industry also worked with the American Academy of Pediatrics, along with other groups interested in child health issues. In 1955, a voluntary national standard was adopted to prohibit, in effect, the use of lead pigments in interior residential paints.
When lead-based paint was marketed before 1978, it was a legal product in great demand because it was washable and durable. It was repeatedly endorsed by the federal, state, and local governments, and specified for use on government buildings until the mid-1970s. For example, the 1950 California Department of Education vocational book on painting endorsed the use of white lead paint.
It was not until 1974 that a new theory emerged on the predominant pathway for children to be exposed to gratuitous levels of lead. In a paper by Dr. James W. Sayre, House and Hand Dust as a Potential Source of Childhood Lead Exposure, Dr. Sayre felt that the major source might be house dust, contaminated with lead from many sources. The theory was that children were licking their hands that had become dirty with lead-contaminated dust. His theory brought about a move beyond the earlier recognition of a risk from chipping and peeling paint. He also observed that average blood lead levels of children living in low-risk areas of Rochester, New York, were in the range then of 18-25 µg/dL.
In 1978, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission banned consumer uses of lead-based paint. However, buildings built prior to the ban still likely have lead paint, as well as commercial, government, and industrial buildings and structures, which are permitted to use lead-based paint.
Lead-based paint, like all paint, inevitably deteriorates: it flakes, chips, and turns to dust and can contaminate the air, soil, floors and other surfaces in the home. This is particularly true of lead paint on windows, doors, and other friction surfaces.
Lead-based paint in California: According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint.
As a case in point, about 75% of Alameda County’s homes were built before 1980, which amounts to 430,000 units. Nearly 174,000 of those units are pre-1950. Lead-based paint hazards in Oakland homes are considered by local health officials to be "coming close to crisis mode." In Oakland, between 80% and 90% of the housing is pre-1978, which accounts for about 174,000 units.
In Los Angeles County, 77% of the housing was built before 1978, which is more than 2.6 million housing units. More than 900,000 of those housing units are pre-1950. In at least 75% of Los Angeles County's lead poisoning cases, lead-based paint is a potential source of the lead poisoning. At least 70% of those cases involve individuals living in pre-1978 housing.
Regulation of lead-paint cleanup: Title X of the federal Housing and Community Development Act of 1992, also known as the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 (Title X) was enacted to develop a national strategy to build an infrastructure necessary to eliminate lead-based paint hazards in housing and to establish a workable framework for lead-based paint hazard evaluation and reduction.
In 1995, the California Legislature enacted SB 1360 (Chapter 415, Statutes of 1995) to establish a program within the State Department of Health Services (DHS, which is now the CDPH) to meet the requirements of Title X. That state program required DHS to adopt regulations regarding the accreditation of training providers that engage in or supervise lead-related construction work, and required the establishment of fees for the accreditation of training providers, the certification of individuals, and the licensing of entities engaged in lead-related occupations.
In 2003, the Legislature enacted SB 460 (Ortiz, Chapter 931, Statutes of 2002) to establish the requirement that lead safe work practices be used in pre-1978 buildings. SB 460 added lead hazards to the conditions that make premises uninhabitable and substandard. It also prohibited an individual from disturbing more than a "de minimis" amount of lead-based paint without "containment."
In 2008, under the Lead-Based Paint Renovation Program (Section 402(a) of the federal Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)), the US EPA issued the Lead-Based Paint Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) Rule governing lead-based paint activities to ensure that individuals engaged in such activities are properly trained; that training programs are accredited; and, that contractors engaged in such activities are certified.
TSCA provides that any state that wishes to administer and enforce these regulations may submit an application to the Administrator for authorization of such a program. Subsequently, with federal approval, California enacted and CDPH administers the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Program, known as the Lead-Related Construction (LRC) Program, to require any person offering lead-related construction courses to meet CDPH's certificate requirements. (HSC § 105250, et seq.)
Judgment against paint industry: In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers to hold former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation: the County of Alameda, the City of Oakland, the City and County of San Francisco, the City of San Diego, the County of Los Angeles, the County of Monterey, the County of San Mateo, the County of Solano, and the County of Ventura.
After a six-week trial in 2013, the trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions by promoting lead paint for interior use despite knowledge of the substantial harms that would result. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties.
Manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion to fund inspection for, and abatement of, lead paint and lead-contaminated dust from the interiors of homes and lead-contaminated soil around homes built in 1980 or earlier in the ten cities and counties; remediation of any structural deficiencies in the homes that would cause the lead control measures to fail; and, public education and outreach necessary for the program.
The ten cities and counties were designated to oversee the lead inspection and abatement program in their respective jurisdictions. Property owners’ participation would be entirely voluntary, and any funds unspent after four years would revert back to the manufacturers.
In 2017, the Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s determination that the manufacturers were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51.). However, the Court of Appeal limited the judgment to homes built before 1951.
On February 14, 2018, the California Supreme Court denied requests by the manufacturers to review a decision requiring those companies to pay several hundred million dollars to identify and clean up lead paint from millions of homes built before 1951 in Santa Clara County and nine other California cities and counties. In the meantime, however, the case is returning to the trial court to (1) calculate the amount that manufacturers must pay for pre-1951 homes only and (2) decide on a receiver to administer the fund and distribute the monies to the ten cities and counties.
Abatement program required by the court: Under the 2014 judgment from the trial court, property owners who enroll in the local jurisdiction's abatement program will be screened to see if they own a pre-1951 property that qualifies for inspection and services. Certain types of properties are excluded from the abatement program, including, but not limited to correctional facilities, day care centers, elderly housing facilities, and all homes constructed after 1980. Properties will then be prioritized for inspection as described in the court’s decision.
Workforce needs: There is a significant shortage of licensed lead paint inspectors and abatement contractors who are approved by the state to carry out this work. The need for licensed lead inspectors and abatement contractors is likely to be intensified because the upheld settlement means ten jurisdictions will be simultaneously competing for a scare number of contractors to conduct large-scale abatement projects throughout California under a tight 4-year time frame.
The following chart provides an estimate of the number of pre-1978 housing units in each of the ten jurisdictions involved in the lawsuit:
According to CDPH, as of April 5, 2018, there are 910 actively certified lead-related construction certified inspector and assessors statewide.
However, those inspectors are spread across all 58 counties, likely leaving gaps in some regions where more inspectors are needed. For instance, there are only 12 certified lead inspectors in Santa Clara County. Many more certified lead inspectors will be needed to inspect the approximate 633,349 homes with lead paint in the County within a four year period.
Certification of lead-related workers: Under CDPH's LRC Program, certification means that CDPH has evaluated and approved a person's qualifications to perform lead-related construction work in residential and public buildings. CDPH evaluates applicants to make sure they have completed State-approved training and have relevant experience and education to perform lead work. As of February 20, 2018, there are 20 accredited training providers and 6,842 certified individuals broken down as follows:
- 910 Inspector/Assessor;
- 69 Project Designers;
- 390 Project Monitors;
- 598 Sampling Technicians;
- 629 Supervisors; and
- 4,246 Workers.
The certification numbers fluctuate throughout the year, as individuals apply for initial or renewal certification. To meet the qualifications for certification, an individual seeking to become an Inspector/Assessor would need to take a class from an accredited training provider, meet minimum education and experience requirements, and pass a state exam before submitting an application to CDPH for certification. The average time it takes an individual to complete the requirements for certification varies person to person based on education and experience of the individual applying.
Under the LCR, local agencies/counties may apply to be accredited training providers to teach LRC courses, including for inspector/assessors and for those seeking to perform lead abatement. (HSC § 105252) Although at least one county had been a CDPH LRC accredited training provider in the past, there are no counties currently accredited.
Local agencies/counties currently cannot certify individuals in LRC including inspector/assessors and individuals seeking to perform lead abatement. Only CDPH has the authority to certify LRC individuals in California.
On February 26, 2018, the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services had an oversight discussion on CDPH's lead construction certification processing delays.
In the analysis, the Subcommittee notes that labor has complained about the amount of time it takes CDPH to certify individuals, thereby allegedly leading to significant delays in construction projects. CDPH told that Subcommittee that the current average application turn-around time is approximately 60 days, while state regulations allow for up to 120 days.
Oddly, CDPH informed this Committee that, once the individual's completed application is submitted, current turn-around time for LRC certification is an average of 37 days.
In any case, if CDPH has limited resources, or any other challenges preventing faster certification, enabling counties to provide certification would multiply the entities who could certify, thereby greatly increasing worker certification statewide.
Solution: AB 2934 would authorize CDPH to enable local governments to implement the certification provision of the LCR at the local level. Doing so would authorize local agencies to certify individuals doing lead construction related work.
But first, permission: Before CDPH can bequeath authority to counties to administer the certification program for inspectors/assessors, it must first request permission from the federal government. CDPH would have to obtain authority from the USEPA to give LRC authority to the counties because US EPA provides funding to LRC and any modifications to the agreement need to be approved by US EPA.
Therefore, in order to effectuate the intent of this bill, CDPH will need to request, and be granted, permission to give authority to the counties, as provided by this bill.
The Committee may wish to consider including language in the bill requiring CDPH to request this permission by a date certain. While this step will cause a significant delay in certifying inspectors at the local level, it is necessary before the bill can be implemented.
Permissible exposure limit for lead: The California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) maintains a permissible exposure limit (PEL) for occupation lead poisoning prevention. Since 2011, Cal/OSHA has been working on revising the PEL, known as the General Industry Lead Standard and Construction Industry Lead Standard for the protection of workers who are exposed to lead on the job.
The current standard requires that every employer shall assure that no employee is exposed to lead at concentrations greater than 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air (50 μg/m3) averaged over an 8-hour period. That standard is based on medical and scientific information that is more than 35 years old. Over this time much has been learned about the effects of lead among adults at lower exposure levels.
According to CDPH, current science from the Environmental Health Perspectives, the National Toxicology Program, and the US EPA strongly indicates that worker blood lead levels should not exceed 5 to 10μg/dL over a working lifetime, yet existing standards allow workers to have blood lead levels up to 50 - 60 μg/dL before they have to be removed from significant lead exposure.
The PEL is proposed to be updated to reflect current medical science and establish a more protective standard for lead construction professionals, but it has been 7 years since the rulemaking was opened and no revisions have been made. Cal/OSHA is working with an external consultant to estimate the economic impact of the regulation – the contract with that consultant appears to be open-ended with no deadline in sight. Worse yet, when it is complete, Cal/OSHA will still then need to enter formal rulemaking, which can take an additional year before the revised standard is final.
Timing of the revised PEL is relevant to the context of this bill. Lead-paint certified construction workers cannot be certified under a more appropriate and scientifically supported PEL for lead until a revised PEL is established. It is imperative to get a timely approval of the revised PEL, so that workers certified to inspect, assess, or abate/remediate the lead-based paint contaminated homes are just as protected as the public/homeowners the court ruling wants protected.
Unfortunately, the timing of doing the actual lead-paint cleanup is tight – the counties have four years to encumber the funds – but without an approved PEL and a certified workforce, cleanup will be delayed. Therefore, the author may consider including language instructing Cal/OSHA to complete its rulemaking by July 2019 on the proposed revisions to PEL for lead.
Committee amendments:
- Add (h) to HSC § 105250 to require CDPH, by February 1, 2019, to request permission from the US EPA to modify its LCR agreement with the US EPA to expand its authority and contract with counties to provide certification to lead construction workers.
- Add a new section to the bill requiring Cal/OSHA to complete rulemaking by July 2019 on the proposed revisions to the Lead Standards in the General Industry Safety Orders (Chapter 4, subchapter 7, Section 5198) and Construction Safety Orders (Chapter 4, subchapter 4, Section 1532.1)
Related legislation: Lead-based paint is still in many California homes built before 1978, putting another generation of kids at risk. A package of legislation has been introduced to address the proposed policy provisions in the pending ballot measure, as well as set up frameworks for implementing the settlement funds should the ballot measure fail. The package includes the following bills:
- AB 2073 (Chiu) protects homeowners from frivolous lawsuits threatened by the lead paint manufacturers if the homeowners participate in the abatement program created by the judgement. This legislation delivers needed assurance that homeowners, who do the right thing by removing toxic paint from their homes, will not be victimized by frivolous litigation from deep-pocketed paint companies. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- AB 2934 (Stone) would allow the California Department of Public Health to contract with counties to certify lead paint inspectors. This bill helps fill a shortage of inspectors to help bring homes up to safe standards. Additional qualified, lead paint inspectors will be needed as work proceeds to remove toxic paint from homes under the judgement.
- AB 2074 (Bonta) removes a significant hurdle to homeowners holding poison paint manufacturers legally accountable for injuries by establishing that lead paint companies are responsible to prove they did not produce, sell, distribute or promote the lead-based paint used during a particular time or area, and allowing homeowners to hold companies jointly liable if there were multiple companies selling or distributing paint at that time and area. Codifying this "risk contribution" theory in statute allows those poisoned by lead-based paint, who are unable to identify the exact manufacturer of the lead paint pigment, a new avenue to litigate cases they may not otherwise be able to litigate. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- AB 2995 (Carrillo) classifies the presence of lead-based paint in a home or building as a physical injury to the property, enabling property owners to sue for the cost of abating or removing lead paint to prevent the further deterioration of peoples’ health. Secondly, the bill delays the start of the clock on the statute of limitations to when property owners become aware that lead paint is present, rather than starting the clock at the time of purchase. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- AB 2803 (Limon) would provide additional liability protection for homeowners by redefining the definition of "hazardous substance" to include lead-based paint for purposes of the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner-Hazardous Substance Account Act, otherwise known as California’s Superfund law. This would allow homeowners to seek damages for clean-up or otherwise implement their own clean-up without fear of liability lawsuits. Should this bill be approved by this Committee, it will be heard next in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- AB 3009 (Quirk) would enact a fee on paint manufacturers for all paint sold in California to create a fund for residents of single-family or multi-family dwellings to clean up lead paint that has contaminated their homes. This fee will only be imposed if an initiative passes that states that lead paint is not a public nuisance. This bill passed out of this committee on April 10th and will be heard in the Assembly Revenue & Taxation Committee on April 30th.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Bay Area Legal Aid
California League of Conservation Voters
City of Oakland
Clean Water Action
Consumer Federation of California
Environmental Working Group
Santa Clara County
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. /
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):