AB 3027: California Environmental Quality Act: attorney’s fees.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-04-16
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant impact on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that impact. CEQA establishes procedures by which certain parties may file an action or proceeding challenging the lead agencys action on the ground of noncompliance with CEQA.
Existing law authorizes the court, upon the motion of a party, to award attorneys fees to a prevailing party in an action that has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest if 3 specified conditions are met.
This bill would, for a prevailing party that is a plaintiff or petitioner in an action or proceeding under CEQA, limit the awarding of attorneys fees to certain persons or entities.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant impact on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that impact. CEQA establishes procedures by which certain parties may file an action or proceeding challenging the lead agencys action on the ground of noncompliance with CEQA.
Existing law authorizes the court, upon the motion of a party, to award attorneys fees to a prevailing party in an action that has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest if 3 specified conditions are met.
This bill would, for a prevailing party that is a plaintiff or petitioner in an action or proceeding under CEQA, limit the awarding of attorneys fees to certain entities.
In an action or proceeding brought pursuant to this division, a court may award attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure only to a prevailing plaintiff or petitioner that only if the prevailing plaintiff or petitioner is either of the following:
(a)A homeowner, property owner, or business owner owner, or a residential or commercial tenant whose tenancy is effective at the time the project application is submitted to the public agency, that is located within one of the following:
(1)The mailing radius established pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65091 of the Government Code.
(2)A mailing radius otherwise established by the public agency for purposes of providing notice pursuant to this division.
(b)A nonprofit organization that qualifies under Section 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code with an active membership of at least 50,000 formed solely primarily for the purpose of protecting the environment.
In an action or proceeding brought pursuant to this division, a court may award attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure only to a prevailing plaintiff or petitioner that is either of the following:
(a)A homeowner, property owner, or business owner located within one of the following:
(1)The mailing radius established pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65091 of the Government Code.
(2)A mailing radius otherwise established by the public agency for purposes of providing notice pursuant to this division.
(b)A nonprofit organization that qualifies under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code with an active membership of at least 50,000 formed solely for the purpose of protecting the environment.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2018 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 17, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 12, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on NAT. RES. and JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Al Muratsuchi, Acting Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3027 (
Author:Chávez) – As Amended Ver:April 16, 2018
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: attorney’s fees
SUMMARY: Limits award of attorney's fees in California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) lawsuits to prevailing parties who are adjacent property owners, business owners, tenants, or large environmental organizations.
EXISTING LAW:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines).
- Authorizes judicial review of CEQA actions taken by public agencies, following the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR doesn't comply with CEQA, must be filed in the Superior Court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions.
- Generally prohibits a person from bringing a CEQA lawsuit unless that person objected to the approval of the project orally or in writing during the public comment period or prior to the close of the public hearing on the project before the filing of the notice of determination.
- Authorizes a court, upon motion, to award attorney's fees to a prevailing party in any action that has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest, if the following conditions are met: (1) a significant benefit, whether pecuniary or nonpecuniary, has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons; (2) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and (3) those fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5)
THIS BILL authorizes a court, in a CEQA lawsuit, to award attorney's fees only to prevailing party that is either:
- A homeowner, property owner, or business owner, or a residential or commercial tenant as of the date of project application, located within 300 feet (presumably of the project) or a mailing radius otherwise established by the public agency.
- A nonprofit 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) organization with an active membership of at least 50,000 formed primarily for the purpose of protecting the environment.
FISCAL EFFECT: Non-fiscal
COMMENTS:
- Background. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
CEQA is enforced through judicial review. CEQA actions taken by public agencies can be challenged in Superior Court once the agency approves or determines to carry out the project. CEQA appeals are subject to unusually short statutes of limitations. Under current law, court challenges of CEQA decisions generally must be filed within 30 to 35 days, depending on the type of decision. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. The petitioner must request a hearing within 90 days of filing the petition and, generally, briefing must be completed within 90 days of the request for hearing. There is no deadline specified for the court to render a decision.
In 1977, the Legislature enacted Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5, which appeared to be "in significant measure an explicit reaction to the United States Supreme Court's Alyeska decision," which held that legislatures may enact laws to authorize awards of attorney's fees to prevailing parties. (Woodland Hills Residents Assn., Inc. v. City Council (1979) 23 Cal.3d 917, 934.) Section 1021.5 authorizes courts to award attorney's fees in actions to enforce important rights in the public interest. Section 1021.5 was intended to encourage litigation deemed to be in the public interest by persons acting as a private attorney general.
The private attorney general statute allows for the award of attorney's fees to the prevailing party in order to promote actions to enforce rights affecting an important public interest. But the standard for awarding attorney's fees is demanding; the plaintiff must not only prevail, he or she must further prove that: (1) a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons; (2) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and (3) those fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any.
- Author's statement:
CEQA was designed and set up to protect the environment from development abuses. Over the years, some intervenors have found it a convenient payday, intervening and holding up the CEQA process solely for their financial gain. This abuse has led to frivolous and costly delays to the CEQA process. The bad actors need to be removed from the system.
- Bill proposes to base award of attorney's fees on plaintiffs' location or association, rather than solely on merit. This bill apparently is intended to deny attorney's fees to the vexatious lawyer filing actions without a "legitimate" client with standing. To the extent this is a problem, the courts have tools to address it under current law, and have recently used them. For example, in CREED-21 v. City of Wildomar (4th Dist., Div. 2, 2017) 18 Cal.App.5th 690, the state Supreme Court denied a request by San Diego attorney Cory Briggs and his nonprofit client, CREED-21, to unpublish an opinion involving CEQA and a Wal-Mart project in Riverside County. Wal-Mart argued that CREED-21 lacked standing and asked Briggs to produce a client for deposition. Briggs refused and said the group’s membership was irrelevant. The court then ordered CREED-21 to produce a member. Briggs did not comply, so the court issued a sanction that resulted in ending the case.
It's not clear if the approach proposed by this bill would address the purported problem more effectively than current law, as an enterprising attorney may be able to recruit a local property owner or tenant, or environmental group, as a client to sidestep the bill. Meanwhile, the bill would exclude legitimate plaintiffs including employees and smaller environmental or community groups. It’s not clear these individuals and groups should be prohibited from recovering attorney's fees for their work, assuming it is shown to provide an important public benefit, as current law requires.
- Double referral. This bill has also been referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Strata Equity Group (sponsor)
ALOR
AM1 Properties
Associated Builders and Contractors of Northern California
Benchmark Pacific
BizFed
Building Industry Association of Southern California
California Building Industry Association
Capstone Advisors
City of Wildomar
Civil Justice Association of California
ColeyDocter
Cornerstone Communities
Destiny Strategies
Global Investment and Development
GriBio
Hitzke Development Corporation
Hoffman Company
Integral Communities
Lansing Companies
LLJ Ventures
Mar Group of Companies
Marker Company
Meridian Land Development Company
NAIOP Inland Empire
Pathfinder Partners
Pinnacle Property Management Services
Proforma Investments
R.K.E. Companies
Rancon Group
Sea Breeze Properties
Southwest California Legislative Council
SPATHCO
Strategic Land Partners
Terranova Equity
Town of Apple Valley
Trammell Crow Residential
WL Investments
6 individuals
Opposition
California League of Conservation Voters
Planning and Conservation League
Sierra Club California
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Al Muratsuchi, Acting Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3027 (
Author:Chávez) – As Introduced Ver:February 16, 2018
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: attorney’s fees
SUMMARY: Limits award of attorney's fees in California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) lawsuits to prevailing parties who are either adjacent property/business owners or large environmental organizations.
EXISTING LAW:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines).
- Authorizes judicial review of CEQA actions taken by public agencies, following the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR doesn't comply with CEQA, must be filed in the Superior Court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions.
- Generally prohibits a person from bringing a CEQA lawsuit unless that person objected to the approval of the project orally or in writing during the public comment period or prior to the close of the public hearing on the project before the filing of the notice of determination.
- Authorizes a court, upon motion, to award attorney's fees to a prevailing party in any action that has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest, if the following conditions are met: (1) a significant benefit, whether pecuniary or nonpecuniary, has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons; (2) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and (3) those fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5)
THIS BILL authorizes a court, in a CEQA lawsuit, to award attorney's fees only to prevailing party that is either:
- A homeowner, property owner, or business owner located within 300 feet (presumably of the project) or a mailing radius otherwise established by the public agency.
- A nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization with an active membership of at least 50,000 formed solely for the purpose of protecting the environment.
FISCAL EFFECT: Non-fiscal
COMMENTS:
- Background. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
CEQA is enforced through judicial review. CEQA actions taken by public agencies can be challenged in Superior Court once the agency approves or determines to carry out the project. CEQA appeals are subject to unusually short statutes of limitations. Under current law, court challenges of CEQA decisions generally must be filed within 30 to 35 days, depending on the type of decision. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. The petitioner must request a hearing within 90 days of filing the petition and, generally, briefing must be completed within 90 days of the request for hearing. There is no deadline specified for the court to render a decision.
In 1977, the Legislature enacted Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5, which appeared to be "in significant measure an explicit reaction to the United States Supreme Court's Alyeska decision," which held that legislatures may enact laws to authorize awards of attorney's fees to prevailing parties. (Woodland Hills Residents Assn., Inc. v. City Council (1979) 23 Cal.3d 917, 934.) Section 1021.5 authorizes courts to award attorney's fees in actions to enforce important rights in the public interest. Section 1021.5 was intended to encourage litigation deemed to be in the public interest by persons acting as a private attorney general.
The private attorney general statute allows for the award of attorney's fees to the prevailing party in order to promote actions to enforce rights affecting an important public interest. But the standard for awarding attorney's fees is demanding; the plaintiff must not only prevail, he or she must further prove that: (1) a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons; (2) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and (3) those fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any.
- Author's statement:
CEQA was designed and set up to protect the environment from development abuses. Over the years, some intervenors have found it a convenient payday, intervening and holding up the CEQA process solely for their financial gain. This abuse has led to frivolous and costly delays to the CEQA process. The bad actors need to be removed from the system.
- Bill proposes to base award of attorney's fees on property ownership and association, rather than solely on merit. This bill apparently is intended to deny attorney's fees to the vexatious lawyer filing actions without a "legitimate" client with standing. To the extent this is a problem, the courts have tools to address it under current law, and have recently used them. For example, in CREED-21 v. City of Wildomar (4th Dist., Div. 2, 2017) 18 Cal.App.5th 690, the state Supreme Court denied a request by San Diego attorney Cory Briggs and his nonprofit client, CREED-21, to unpublish an opinion involving CEQA and a Wal-Mart project in Riverside County. Wal-Mart argued that CREED-21 lacked standing and asked Briggs to produce a client for deposition. Briggs refused and said the group’s membership was irrelevant. The court then ordered CREED-21 to produce a member. Briggs did not comply, so the court issued a sanction that resulted in ending the case.
It's not clear if the approach proposed by this bill would address the purported problem more effectively than current law, as an enterprising attorney may be able to recruit a local property owner or environmental group as a client to sidestep the bill. Meanwhile, the bill would exclude many legitimate plaintiffs including renters, employees, and smaller environmental or community groups, and create an additional barrier to the justice system for lower-income populations. It’s not clear these individuals and groups should be prohibited from recovering attorney's fees for their work, assuming it is shown to provide an important public benefit, as current law requires.
- Double referral. This bill has also been referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Strata Equity Group (sponsor)
ALOR
AM1 Properties
Associated Builders and Contractors of Northern California
Benchmark Pacific
BizFed
California Association of Realtors
Capstone Advisors
City of Wildomar
Civil Justice Association of California
ColeyDocter
Cornerstone Communities
Destiny Strategies
Global Investment and Development
GriBio
Hoffman Company
Hitzke Development Corporation
Integral Communities
Lansing Companies
LLJ Ventures
Mar Group of Companies
Marker Company
Meridian Land Development Company
NAIOP Inland Empire
Pathfinder Partners
Pinnacle Property Management Services
Proforma Investments
Rancon Group
R.K.E. Companies
Sea Breeze Properties
Southwest California Legislative Council
Strategic Land Partners
SPATHCO
Terranova Equity
Town of Apple Valley
Trammell Crow Residential
WL Investments
6 individuals
Opposition
California League of Conservation Voters
Planning and Conservation League
Sierra Club California
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):