AB 3088: Continuing care contracts: retirement communities.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-08-31
Existing law regulates life care contracts, also known as continuing care contracts, and imposes certain reporting and reserve requirements on continuing care communities. Existing law requires each provider that has entered into a specified type of continuing care contract with an up-front entrance fee, known as a Type A contract, to submit to the Department of Social Services, at least once every 5 years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition.
This bill, until January 1, 2030, would instead require all providers to file an actuarys findings, report, and opinion with the department, and further require all providers to post a copy of that information in its facility and on its Internet Web site within 10 days of filing with the department. The bill would, on January 1, 2030, reinstate the requirement for providers that entered into Type A contracts to file an actuarys opinion.
The bill would require each provider to conduct, at least once every 5 years, a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified. The bill would require the governing body of each provider to use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements. The bill would require each provider to submit to the department, at least once every 5 years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review and the adjustments the governing body of the provider has made or plans to make as a result of the review. The bill would also require the provider to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in its facility and on its Internet Web site.
Existing law regulates life care contracts, also known as continuing care contracts, and imposes certain reporting and reserve requirements on continuing care communities. Existing law requires each provider that has entered into a specified type of continuing care contract with an up-front entrance fee fee, known as a Type A contract, to submit to the Department of Social Services, at least once every 5 years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition.
This bill bill, until January 1, 2030, would instead require all providers subject to a continuing care contract to file an actuarys opinion, as specified. The bill would findings, report, and opinion with the department, and further require a provider all providers to post a copy of the actuarys opinion at a central and conspicuous location that information in the its facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers on its Internet Web site within 10 days of submitting the opinion to the department. The filing with the department. The bill would, on January 1, 2030, reinstate the requirement for providers that entered into Type A contracts to file an actuarys opinion.
The bill would also require each provider to conduct, at least once every 3 5 years, a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified. The bill would require the board governing body of each provider to use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements. The bill would require each provider to submit, submit to the department, at least once every 3 5 years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review and the adjustments the board governing body of the provider has made or plans to make to as a result of the review. The bill would also require the provider to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the its facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers on its Internet Web site.
Existing law regulates life care contracts, also known as continuing care contracts, and imposes certain reporting and reserve requirements on continuing care communities. Existing law requires each provider that has entered into a specified type of contract with an up-front entrance fee to submit to the Department of Social Services, at least once every 5 years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition.
This bill would instead require all providers subject to a continuing care contract to file an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition every 3 years, opinion, as specified. The bill would require a provider to post a copy of the actuarys opinion at a central and conspicuous location in the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site within 10 days of submitting the opinion to the department. The bill would also require each provider to conduct, at least once every 3 years, a maintenance and replacement study review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified. The bill would require the board of each provider to review this study, or cause it to be reviewed, annually, and to use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements. The bill would require each provider to submit, at least once every 3 years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement study review and the adjustments the board has made or plans to make to as a result of the study. review. The bill would also require the provider to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
Existing law regulates life care contracts, also known as continuing care contracts, and imposes certain reporting and reserve requirements on continuing care communities. Existing law requires each provider that has entered into a specified type of contract with an up-front entrance fee submit to the Department of Social Services, at least once every 5 years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition.
This bill would instead require all providers subject to a continuing care contract to file an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition every 3 years, as specified. The bill would require a provider to post a copy of the actuarys opinion at a central and conspicuous location in the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site within 10 days of submitting the opinion to the department. The bill would also require each provider to conduct, at least once every 3 years, a maintenance and replacement study of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified. The bill would require the board of each provider to review this study, or cause it to be reviewed, annually, and to use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements. The bill would require each provider to submit, at least once every 3 years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement study and the adjustments the board has made or plans to make to as a result of the study. The bill would also require the provider to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
Existing law imposes various notice and planning requirements upon a long-term health care facility before allowing a change in the status of the license or operation of the facility that results in the inability of the facility to care for its patients, including a requirement for written notification to the affected patients or their guardians at least 60 days prior to the change.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to require that a senior living in an assisted living facility be provided with timely advanced notice of the facilitys closure.Existing law imposes various notice and planning requirements upon a long-term health care facility before allowing a change in the status of the license or operation of the facility that results in the inability of the facility to care for its patients, including a requirement for written notification to the affected patients or their guardians at least 60 days prior to the change.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to require that a senior living in an assisted living facility be provided with timely advanced notice of the facilitys closure.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider shall file with the department an actuarys findings, report, and opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 1792.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.7.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall file with the department an actuarys opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
(d)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2030.
SEC. 3.Section 1792.10 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every five years, an actuarys findings, report, and opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, or was not required to file an actuarys opinion prior to January 1, 2018, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys findings, report, and opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion shall state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)A provider shall, within 10 days after filing its actuarys findings, report, and opinion with the department pursuant to this section, post a copy of the actuarys opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 4.Section 1792.10 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall submit to the department, at least once every five years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2030.
SEC. 5.Section 1792.11 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.11.(a)At least once every five years, each provider shall conduct a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility. The governing body of each provider shall use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements.
(b)The review required by this section shall, at a minimum, include all of the following:
(1)Identification of the major components that the provider is obligated to maintain that, as of the date of the review, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
(2)An estimate of the remaining useful life of the components identified in paragraph (1) as of the date of the review.
(3)An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance of the components identified in paragraph (1).
(4)An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components identified in paragraph (1) during, and at the end of, the components useful life.
(5)An estimated funding plan that indicates how the governing body of the provider plans to fund its obligation to repair or replace the major components identified in paragraph (1), with the exception of those components that the governing body has determined it will not replace or repair, as well as a timeline detailing when those repairs or replacements will be made.
(c)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every five years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review required by this section and the necessary adjustments the governing body of the provider has made or plans to make as a result of the review. Within 10 days of filing the summary and adjustment plan with the department, the provider shall post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider shall file with the department an actuarys findings, report, and opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 1792.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.7.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall file with the department an actuarys opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
(d)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2030.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 1792.10 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every five years, an actuarys findings, report, and opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, or was not required to file an actuarys opinion prior to January 1, 2018, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys findings, report, and opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion shall state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)A provider shall, within 10 days after filing its actuarys findings, report, and opinion with the department pursuant to this section, post a copy of the actuarys opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 4.Section 1792.10 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall submit to the department, at least once every five years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2030.
SEC. 3.SEC. 5.Section 1792.11 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.11.(a)At least once every three five years, each provider shall conduct a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility. The board governing body of each provider shall use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements.
(b)The study review required by this section shall, at a minimum, include all of the following:
(1)Identification of the major components that the provider is obligated to maintain that, as of the date of the review, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
(2)An estimate of the remaining useful life of the components identified in paragraph (1) as of the date of the review.
(3)An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance of the components identified in paragraph (1).
(4)An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components identified in paragraph (1) during, and at the end of, the components useful life.
(5)A An estimated funding plan that indicates how the governing body of the provider plans to fund its obligation to repair or replace the major components identified in paragraph (1), with the exception of those components that the board governing body has determined it will not replace or repair, as well as a timeline detailing when those repairs or replacements will be made.
(c)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every three five years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review required by this section and the necessary adjustments the board of that governing body of the provider has made or plans to make as a result of the review. Within 10 days of filing the summary and adjustment plan with the department, the provider shall post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider shall file with the department an actuarys opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
SEC. 2.Section 1792.10 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every three five years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of three five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, or was not required to file an actuarys opinion prior to January 1, 2018, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of three five years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion shall state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)A provider shall, within 10 days after filing its actuarys opinion with the department pursuant to this section, post a copy of the actuarys opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
SEC. 3.Section 1792.11 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.11.(a)At least once every three years, each provider shall conduct a reasonably competent and diligent maintenance and replacement study a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility. The board of each provider shall review this study, or cause it to be reviewed, annually, and shall use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements.
(b)The study required by this section shall, at a minimum, include all of the following:
(1)Identification of the major components that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain that, as of the date of the study, review, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
(2)Identification of the probable An estimate of the remaining useful life of the components identified in paragraph (1) as of the date of the study. review.
(3)An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance of the components identified in paragraph (1).
(4)An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components identified in paragraph (1) during, and at the end of, the components useful life.
(5)A funding plan that indicates how the provider plans to fund its obligation to repair and or replace the major components that have an expected remaining useful life of 20 years or less, identified in paragraph (1), with the exception of those components that the board has determined it will not replace or repair. repair, as well as a timeline detailing when those repairs or replacements will be made.
(c)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every three years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement study review required by this section and the necessary adjustments the board of that provider has made or plans to make as a result of the study. review. Within 10 days of filing the summary and adjustment plan with the department, the provider shall post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In continuing care contracts, providers offer a wide variety of living accommodations and care programs for an indefinite or extended number of years in exchange for substantial payments by residents.
(2)The annual reporting and reserve requirements for each continuing care provider should include a report that summarizes the providers recent and projected performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department.
(3)Certain providers enter into life care contracts or similar contracts with their residents. Periodic actuarial studies that examine the actuarial financial condition of these providers will help to assure their long-term financial soundness.
(b)Each provider shall annually file with the department a report that shows certain key financial indicators for the providers past five years, based on the providers actual experience, and for the upcoming five years, based on the providers projections. Providers shall file their key indicator reports in the manner required by Section 1792.9 and in a form prescribed by the department.
(c)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall file with the department an actuarys opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the providers continuing care operations in the manner required by Section 1792.10.
SEC. 2.Section 1792.10 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1792.10.(a)Each provider that has entered into Type A contracts shall submit to the department, at least once every five three years, an actuarys opinion as to the providers actuarial financial condition. The actuarys opinion shall be based on an actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuarys opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to, and opine on the providers actuarial financial condition as of a specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is provided to the department.
(b)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, shall file its actuarys opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five three years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(c)Each provider required to file an actuarys opinion under subdivision (a) that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, or was not required to file an actuarys opinion prior to January 1, 2018, shall file its first actuarys opinion within 45 days following the due date for the providers annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its required actuarys opinion before the expiration of five three years following the date it last filed an actuarys opinion with the department.
(d)The actuarys opinion required by subdivision (a) shall comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board. The actuarys opinion shall also include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. The actuarys opinion must shall state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the providers financial condition is actuarially sound.
(e)A provider shall, within 10 days after filing its actuarys opinion with the department pursuant to this section, post a copy of the actuarys opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
SEC. 3.Section 1792.11 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1792.11.(a)At least once every three years, each provider shall conduct a reasonably competent and diligent maintenance and replacement study of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility. The board of each provider shall review this study, or cause it to be reviewed, annually, and shall use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements.
(b)The study required by this section shall, at a minimum, include all of the following:
(1)Identification of the major components that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain that, as of the date of the study, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
(2)Identification of the probable remaining useful life of the components identified in paragraph (1) as of the date of the study.
(3)An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance of the components identified in paragraph (1).
(4)An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components identified in paragraph (1) during, and at the end of, the components useful life.
(5)A funding plan that indicates how the provider plans to fund its obligation to repair and replace the major components that have an expected remaining useful life of 20 years or less, with the exception of those components that the board has determined it will not replace or repair.
(c)Each provider shall submit to the department, at least once every three years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement study required by this section and the necessary adjustments the board of that provider has made or plans to make as a result of the study. Within 10 days of filing the summary and adjustment plan with the department, the provider shall post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan in a central and conspicuous location at the facility and in a conspicuous location on the providers Internet Web site.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to require that a senior living in an assisted living facility be provided with timely advanced notice of the facilitys closure.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to require that a senior living in an assisted living facility be provided with timely advanced notice of the facilitys closure.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 18, 2018 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 7, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 29 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 21, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 20, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 2, 2018 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 21, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 24, 2018 | Referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| May 15, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 14, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 10, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 9, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (May 9). |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on AGING & L.T.C. |
| Apr 12, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 11, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on AGING & L.T.C. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Apr 2, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on HUM. S. and AGING & L.T.C. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2018 | AB 3088 CHU Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB3088 Chu By Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| May 14, 2018 | AB 3088 CHU Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Aging and Long-Term Care |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Aging and Long-Term Care] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 3088
Author:(Chu)
As Enrolled Ver:September 7, 2018
2/3 vote
ASSEMBLY: | 64-1 | (May 14, 2018) | SENATE: | 30-9 | (August 27, 2018) |
ASSEMBLY: | 74-1 | (August 29, 2018) |
|
|
|
Original Committee Reference: HUM. S.
SUMMARY: Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every five years, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every five years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the reference to entrance into Type A contracts as a condition under which certain CCRC providers must file an actuarial findings, report, and opinion with DSS, thereby applying this requirement to providers regardless of contract type offered, and further requires each provider who was not required to file an actuary's opinion prior to January 1, 2018, to file its actuary's opinion within 45 days after a provider's annual report was due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary's opinion at the facility and on the provider's Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary's opinion with DSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider, at least once every five years, to conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain, and requires the review be used for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires the review to include at least all of the following:
- Identification of components a provider is obligated to maintain that have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years as of the date of the review, and an estimate of the remaining useful life of those components;
- An estimate of the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components;
- An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the costs of repairing, replacing, restoring, or maintaining those components both during and at the end of their useful life; and
- An estimated funding plan describing how the governing body of the provider intends to fund the obligations of repairing or replacing the identified components, as specified, and a timeline detailing when those replacements will be made.
- Requires each provider to submit, at least once every five years, a summary of the review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment being filed with DSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Repeals the provisions of this bill related to the filing of actuarial findings, reports, and opinions, as of December 31, 2029, and reverts to current law as of January 1, 2030.
- Makes technical changes.
The Senate amendments:
- Includes an actuary's findings and report among the items that a provider shall file with DSS.
- Extend from three to five years the frequency with which a CCRC must conduct a review of the accessible areas of the facility for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Add language that repeals the provisions of this bill related to the filing of actuarial findings, reports, and opinions, as of December 31, 2029, and reverts to current law as of January 1, 2030.
- Make technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensure and regulation of Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs) as a separate category within the existing licensing structure of DSS. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) 1569 et seq.)
- Provides for the certification and regulation of CCRCs by DSS. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of DSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a promise by a provider to provide one or more elements of care to an elderly resident, as specified, in exchange for an entrance fee and/or the payment of periodic charges. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Defines a "refundable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor's unit, as specified when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident's sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(2))
- Defines a "repayable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unity previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to DSS. (HSC 1792.6(a))
- Makes Legislative findings and declaration that require each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with DSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified in HSC 1792.10. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" as a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" as an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to DSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations. Further requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider's annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, this bill will result in negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs): United States (U.S.) Census data indicates that on July 1, 2015, approximately 47.8 million people in the United States were age 65 or older; that number is projected to reach 98.2 million by the year 2060. As the nation's population ages, seniors are faced with a variety of options for retirement living. One such option, CCRCs, provide long-term care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care, and are an attractive option for seniors as these services are provided in one location. California currently has 110 CCRCs, nearly 50% of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and it is the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) that is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The Branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
Contract types: CCRCs offer several types of contracts. Typically the parameters of the contracts require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, which can range from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to any ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs are referred to by three "types":
- Type A: Also known as life care contracts, Type A contracts are often the most expensive contract type, but are also the most inclusive as they cover the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age, and current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuary report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B: Also called modified contracts, Type B contracts typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees and offer limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may, for a short period of time, stay in a skilled nursing facility without experiencing increased costs. Extended stays, however, may be subject to increased fees depending on the circumstances.
- Type C: Also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, however the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care with the resident are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable vs. repayable contracts: CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident's death) to receive the cost of his or her initial entrance fee when terminating his or her contract. Contracts are classified as either "repayable" or "refundable." Repayable contracts include a promise by the provider to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee; however, that repayment is conditional upon the reoccupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed. In contrast, refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund to the resident, and are required to maintain a reserve fund, which is required to be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each individual resident holding a refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident's unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from an existing reserve account.
It is important to note that the type of contract a resident enters into, be it Type A, B, or C, pertains only to the services provided to residents and the associated fees for those services, if applicable. The type of contract does not dictate whether a contract is refundable or repayable; whether a contract is refundable or repayable is denoted in the contract itself, and current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time he or she signs the contract.
Actuarial opinions: Actuaries are responsible for assessing and issuing opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Unlike an accountant, who is responsible for compiling and comparing financial records in order to ensure businesses and governments run accurately and efficiently, actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or company enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
It is the unique nature of Type A contracts that trigger the need for an actuarial study, as these contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the costs of increased care for these residents. It should be noted, however, that current law requires an actuarial study to contain a summary of the financial condition of the provider, not just the financial liability of a provider's contractual obligation to finance the ongoing healthcare costs of residents with Type A contracts. In short, current law requires CCRCs to review the financial liabilities of all contracts at the facility, be they Type A, B, C, or a combination thereof.
Need for this bill: According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risks and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden. Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately [this bill] promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement."
This bill requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities to obtain an actuarial study every five years.
These communities, which combine housing with long term health care services and supports, have a wide range of ownership interests, business models and facilities. An actuarial study may be one indication of financial viability, but the Department of Social Services uses a variety of methods to monitor the long term fiscal health of these communities.
Instead of mandating an actuarial study be done by every Continuing Care Retirement Community, the department will continue to work with residents and management to determine appropriate means to measure fiscal viability.
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0005251
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 3088
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:August 20, 2018
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 64-1 | (May 14, 2018) | SENATE: | 30-9 | (August 27, 2018) |
Original Committee Reference: HUM. S.
SUMMARY: Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every five years, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every five years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the reference to entrance into Type A contracts as a condition under which certain CCRC providers must file an actuarial findings, report, and opinion with DSS, thereby applying this requirement to providers regardless of contract type offered, and further requires each provider who was not required to file an actuary's opinion prior to January 1, 2018, to file its actuary's opinion within 45 days after a provider's annual report was due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary's opinion at the facility and on the provider's Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary's opinion with DSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider, at least once every five years, to conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain, and requires the review be used for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires the review to include at least all of the following:
- identification of components a provider is obligated to maintain that have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years as of the date of the review, and an estimate of the remaining useful life of those components;
- an estimate of the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components;
- an estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the costs of repairing, replacing, restoring, or maintaining those components both during and at the end of their useful life; and
- an estimated funding plan describing how the governing body of the provider intends to fund the obligations of repairing or replacing the identified components, as specified, and a timeline detailing when those replacements will be made.
- Requires each provider to submit, at least once every five years, a summary of the review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment being filed with DSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Repeals the provisions of this bill related to the filing of actuarial findings, reports, and opinions, as of December 31, 2029, and reverts to current law as of January 1, 2030.
- Makes technical changes.
The Senate amendments:
- Includes an actuary's findings and report among the items that a provider shall file with DSS.
- Extend from three to five years the frequency with which a CCRC must conduct a review of the accessible areas of the facility for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Add language that repeals the provisions of this bill related to the filing of actuarial findings, reports, and opinions, as of December 31, 2029, and reverts to current law as of January 1, 2030.
- Make technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensure and regulation of Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs) as a separate category within the existing licensing structure of DSS. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) 1569 et seq.)
- Provides for the certification and regulation of CCRCs by DSS. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of DSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a promise by a provider to provide one or more elements of care to an elderly resident, as specified, in exchange for an entrance fee and/or the payment of periodic charges. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Defines a "refundable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor's unit, as specified when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident's sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(2))
- Defines a "repayable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unity previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to DSS. (HSC 1792.6(a))
- Makes Legislative findings and declaration that require each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with DSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified in HSC 1792.10. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" as a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" as an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to DSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations. Further requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider's annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, this bill will result in negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs): United States (U.S.) Census data indicates that on July 1, 2015, approximately 47.8 million people in the United States were age 65 or older; that number is projected to reach 98.2 million by the year 2060. As the nation's population ages, seniors are faced with a variety of options for retirement living. One such option, CCRCs, provide long-term care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care, and are an attractive option for seniors as these services are provided in one location. California currently has 110 CCRCs, nearly 50% of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and it is the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) that is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The Branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
Contract types: CCRCs offer several types of contracts. Typically the parameters of the contracts require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, which can range from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to any ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs are referred to by three "types":
- Type A: Also known as life care contracts, Type A contracts are often the most expensive contract type, but are also the most inclusive as they cover the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age, and current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuary report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B: Also called modified contracts, Type B contracts typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees and offer limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may, for a short period of time, stay in a skilled nursing facility without experiencing increased costs. Extended stays, however, may be subject to increased fees depending on the circumstances.
- Type C: Also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, however the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care with the resident are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable vs. repayable contracts: CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident's death) to receive the cost of his or her initial entrance fee when terminating his or her contract. Contracts are classified as either "repayable" or "refundable." Repayable contracts include a promise by the provider to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee; however, that repayment is conditional upon the reoccupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed. In contrast, refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund to the resident, and are required to maintain a reserve fund, which is required to be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each individual resident holding a refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident's unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from an existing reserve account.
It is important to note that the type of contract a resident enters into, be it Type A, B, or C, pertains only to the services provided to residents and the associated fees for those services, if applicable. The type of contract does not dictate whether a contract is refundable or repayable; whether a contract is refundable or repayable is denoted in the contract itself, and current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time he or she signs the contract.
Actuarial opinions: Actuaries are responsible for assessing and issuing opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Unlike an accountant, who is responsible for compiling and comparing financial records in order to ensure businesses and governments run accurately and efficiently, actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or company enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
It is the unique nature of Type A contracts that trigger the need for an actuarial study, as these contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the costs of increased care for these residents. It should be noted, however, that current law requires an actuarial study to contain a summary of the financial condition of the provider, not just the financial liability of a provider's contractual obligation to finance the ongoing healthcare costs of residents with Type A contracts. In short, current law requires CCRCs to review the financial liabilities of all contracts at the facility, be they Type A, B, C, or a combination thereof.
Need for this bill: According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risks and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden. Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately [this bill] promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement."
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0004984
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 3088
:
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/12/18
AYES: Wiener, Glazer, Leyva, McGuire, Nguyen, Portantino
NO VOTE RECORDED: Berryhill
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-1, 5/14/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Continuing Care Residents Association
DIGEST:
This bill expands a requirement for Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) at least once every five years to include all CCRCs, not just those that offer Type A contracts, until January 1, 2030. This bill also requires each CCRC to conduct a review of its facility at least once every five years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/20/18 refine actuarial reporting requirements for retirement communities that offer continuing care contracts and establish a sunset date thereof.
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of CCRCs by CDSS to enact minimum requirements to protect the wellbeing and financial security of CCRS residents. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a continuing care promise made in exchange for an entrance fee, the payment of periodic charges, or both types of payments, and permits that a continuing care contract may consist of one agreement or a series of agreements and other writings incorporated by reference. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of CDSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Provides that the components of care provided by the facility must be separately licensed as otherwise required by state law, including Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly and Skilled Nursing care. (HSC 1771.5)
- Makes a series of legislative findings and declarations regarding continuing care contracts and that each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with CDSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" to mean a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" to mean an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to CDSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
- Requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board, as specified, and sets other requirements for the contents of the actuary’s opinion. (HSC 1792.10 (d))
This bill:
- Expands the requirement that CCRC providers that have entered into Type A contracts must file an actuarial opinion with CDSS to also require that all CCRCs (regardless of the contract type offered) file an actuary’s findings, report and opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider’s operation at least once every five years and that the report be posted at the facility, as specified.
- Provides that actuarial reporting requirement described in 1) above shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
- Reinstates the requirements in existing law that each CCRC provider that has entered into Type A contracts must file with CDSS an actuary’s opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider’s continuing care operations, effective January 1, 2030, as specified.
- Requires each CCRC provider to, at least once every five years, conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified, and requires the facility’s governing body to use the review for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements, as specified.
- Requires each provider to submit to CDSS, at least once every five years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review. Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment plan being filed with CDSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
Background
According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risk and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities, senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden.” Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. “Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately, this bill promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement,” per the author.
Continuing Care Retirement Communities
CCRCs offer people age 60 and older a long-term continuing care option that pairs their current health and resources with an individualized contract that provides community life and a wide range of care. CCRCs provide housing, residential services, and nursing care within one location. Typically, this is offered in a campus-like community setting, and usually for a resident’s lifetime, and always for at least one year. There are currently 109 CCRCs operating in California.
A CCRC is defined as a facility where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided in exchange for an entrance fee and/or payment of ongoing periodic charges. A continuing care contract may consist of one agreement for continuous care, or a series of agreements describing care, conditions for that care, and payment of it, if and when it becomes necessary.
CCRCs are permitted to offer a broad range of contract options so that they have the flexibility to offer a range of services that meet their consumers’ varying needs. Each potential consumer has different health, long-term care, and financial risks and needs that require contract flexibility. Each CCRC offers differing options on costs of service, payment methods, services provided, and other elements, including lifestyle choices.
Continuing care contracts typically require an individual to pay an entrance fee and monthly fees. These fees vary significantly and depend on the level of services included in the contract and other factors associated with location, exclusivity, business plan variations, and more. Entrance fees can range from $50,000 to more than $2 million.
While there is no standardized contract, there are certain defined contract elements that must be in place. CDSS approves basic elements of the contract and the CCRC facility uses that structure to create more individualized contracts with residents.
CCRCs contracts are referred to by three "types." They are as follow:
- Type A contracts, also known as life care contracts, are typically the most expensive because they are offer the most inclusive services as they include increasing housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age. Current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuarial report to CDSS once every five years.
- Type B contracts, also called modified contracts, typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees than Type A contracts and limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may enter a skilled nursing facility within the CCRC without experiencing increased costs. Under this contract type, extended stay may be subject to increased fees.
- Type C contracts, also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, and the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Current law allows residents to access substantial financial information about all CCRCs, including a key indicator report, which is an annual report submitted to CDSS that includes (1) the provider's payment of the annual provider free and fee calculation forms, (2) certification by the provider's chief executive officer that the reports are correct, (3) evidence of the provider's fidelity bond, (4) the provider's audited financial statements, (5) the provider's audited reserve reports, (6) the provider's "Continuing Care Retirement Community Disclosure Statement" for each community, and (7) the provider's report on CCRC monthly services fee for each community.
Actuarial Opinions
California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to CDSS once every five years because those contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the increasing costs of care for residents who have Type A contracts. The law requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board, which proscribe the content of an actuarial opinion to disclose the actuarial balance sheet, the cohort pricing analysis, and the cash and investment balances at the beginning and end of each projection year, and state whether or not each condition is met. The law further requires that the actuary’s opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the provider’s financial condition is actuarially sound. According to CDSS, there are currently 109 CCRS operated by 77 different providers in California. Ten of which currently offer Type A contracts.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2661 (Burke, 2016) would have allowed for CCRC contracts that condition lump-sum payments based upon resale of “any” unit – as opposed to the unit previously occupied by the resident - to not be considered a “refundable contract,” making the refund reserve requirements inapplicable in such circumstances. The bill was referred to but not heard by the Assembly Human Services Committee.
SB 939 (Monning, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2016) required that continuing care contracts that contain lump sum contract termination payments conditioned on resale of the unit must meet a series of requirements and timelines, must pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and must meet other requirements
SB 475 (Monning, 2015) would have required prospective and future CCRC contracts which condition lump sum contract termination payments on resale of the unit to meet a series of requirements and timelines, to pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and to meet other requirements. SB 475 was vetoed by the Governor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, this bill would likely generate minor and absorbable costs to CDSS (GF) to review additional reports.
California Continuing Care Residents Association (source)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
Consumer Federation of California
Eight individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified: 8/21/18)
California Assisted Living Association
California Department of Social Services
Leading Age California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Continuing Care Residents Association, which is the sponsor of AB 3088, writes the following in support of this bill, “Residents have prioritized and strongly support AB 3088 because this consumer protection helps ensure that the long-term promises that their CCRC’s have made can be realized. Actuarial studies and maintenance reviews are vitally important to ensuring the fiscal solvency of the CCRC, regardless of the type of contract that the provider offers. All CCRC’s maintain independent living, assisted living and skilled nursing units on campus. All CCRC’s promise to accommodate their residents as they age, and all CCRC’s should be required to use strategic planning tools to ensure that they can uphold that promise.”
The Consumer Federation of California supports this bill because, “When residents are already paying substantial amounts to enter CCRCs and paying additional monthly fees, fees that are subject to increases at the discretion of the provider’s board, California should ensure that the facilities are managing their finances in the most responsible way…Actuarial studies will help CCRC providers identify long-term financial risks and develop policies and solutions that minimize the impact of those risks on residents. Without these important assessments, a CCRC may appear financially stable in the short term yet still face significant threats in its long-term viability. These elements of risk exist in every CCRC contract and it is the function of the actuary to bring these risks into focus and project the financial future of the organization.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition to this bill, Leading Age California states, "We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident's monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to CDSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.”
CDSS also opposes this bill because CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts, “have significantly different financial structures, which may be better measured through enhancing the Key Indicator Reports and the use of key performance ratios and other financial assessment tools.” CDSS also indicates that they are engaging an “independent financial expert to determine which tools or combination of tools for other facility types would be the best means to measure financial risk of a CCRC community.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-1, 5/14/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Brough
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Chávez, Cooper, Flora, Fong, Cristina Garcia, Gray, Harper, Kiley, Mayes, Medina, Patterson
8/21/18 19:02:54
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 3088
:
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/12/18
AYES: Wiener, Glazer, Leyva, McGuire, Nguyen, Portantino
NO VOTE RECORDED: Berryhill
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-1, 5/14/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Continuing Care Residents Association
DIGEST:
This bill expands a requirement for Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) at least once every five years to include all CCRCs, not just those that offer Type A contracts, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every three years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of CCRCs by CDSS to enact minimum requirements to protect the wellbeing and financial security of CCRS residents. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a continuing care promise made in exchange for an entrance fee, the payment of periodic charges, or both types of payments, and permits that a continuing care contract may consist of one agreement or a series of agreements and other writings incorporated by reference. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of CDSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Requires a CCRC provider to hold a certificate of authority from CDSS permitting the provider to contract for the provision of continuing care, including medical care, in which a resident over the age of 60 has paid in advance for more than one year for that care. (HSC 1771.2)
- Provides that the components of care provided by the facility must be separately licensed as otherwise required by state law, including Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly and Skilled Nursing care. (HSC 1771.5)
- Defines a "refundable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor's unit, as specified, when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident's sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(2))
- Defines a "repayable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unit previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law, as specified. (HSC 1771(r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract, or any other entity assuming responsibility for refundable contracts, to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to CDSS. (HSC 1792.6(a))
- Makes a series of Legislative findings and declarations regarding continuing care contracts and that each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with CDSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" to mean a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" to mean an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to CDSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
- Requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board, as specified, and sets other requirements for the contents of the actuary’s opinion. (HSC 1792.10 (d))
This bill:
- Removes the condition that only CCRC providers that have entered into Type A contracts must file an actuarial opinion with CDSS, thereby making the requirement applicable to all CCRC providers, regardless of the contract type offered.
- Requires each provider that was not required to file an actuary's opinion with CDSS prior to January 1, 2018, to file an actuary's opinion within 45 days after each provider’ annual report is due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary's opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the CCRC facility and on the provider's Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary's opinion with CDSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider to, at least once every three years, conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility, as specified, and, requires the facility’s board to use the review for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires each provider to submit to CDSS, at least once every three years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review. Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment plan being filed with CDSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
Background
According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risk and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities, senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden.” Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. “Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately, this bill promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement,” per the author.
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs)
CCRCs offer people age 60 and older a long-term continuing care option that pairs their current health and resources with an individualized contract that provides community life and a wide range of care. CCRCs provide housing, residential services, and nursing care within one location. Typically, this is offered in a campus-like community setting, and usually for a resident’s lifetime, and always for at least one year. There are currently 109 CCRCs operating in California.
A CCRC is defined as a facility where services promised in a “continuing care contract” are provided in exchange for an entrance fee and/or payment of ongoing periodic charges. A continuing care contract may consist of one agreement for continuous care, or a series of agreements describing care, conditions for that care, and payment of it, if and when it becomes necessary.
CCRCs are permitted to offer a broad range of contract options so that they have the flexibility to offer a range of services that meet their consumers’ varying needs. Each potential consumer has different health, long-term care, and financial risks and needs that require contract flexibility. Each CCRC offers differing options on costs of service, payment methods, services provided, and other elements, including lifestyle choices.
Continuing care contracts typically require an individual to pay an entrance fee and monthly fees, these fees vary significantly and depend on the level of services included in the contract and other factors associated with location, exclusivity, business plan variations, and more. Entrance fees can range from $50,000 to more than $2 million.
While there is no standardized contract, there are certain defined contract elements that must be in place. CDSS approves basic elements of the contract and the CCRC facility uses that structure to create more individualized contracts with residents.
CCRCs contracts are referred to by three "types." They are as follow:
- Type A contracts, also known as life care contracts, are typically the most expensive because they are offer the most inclusive services as they include increasing housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age. Current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuarial report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B contracts, also called modified contracts, typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees than Type A contracts and limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may enter a skilled nursing facility within the CCRC without experiencing increased costs. Under this contract type, extended stay may be subject to increased fees.
- Type C contracts, also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, and the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Current law allows residents to access substantial financial information about all CCRCs, including a key indicator report, which is an annual report submitted to CDSS that includes (1) the provider's payment of the annual provider free and fee calculation forms, (2) certification by the provider's chief executive officer that the reports are correct, (3) evidence of the provider's fidelity bond, (4) the provider's audited financial statements, (5) the provider's audited reserve reports, (6) the provider's "Continuing Care Retirement Community Disclosure Statement" for each community, and (7) the provider's report on CCRC monthly services fee for each community.
Actuarial Opinions
California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to CDSS once every five years because those contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the increasing costs of care for residents who have Type A contracts. The law requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board, which proscribe the content of an actuarial opinion to disclose the actuarial balance sheet, the cohort pricing analysis, and the cash and investment balances at the beginning and end of each projection year, and state whether or not each condition is met. The law further requires that the actuary’s opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the provider’s financial condition is actuarially sound. According to CDSS, there are currently 109 CCRS operated by 77 different providers in California. Ten of which currently offer Type A contracts.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2661 (Burke, 2016) would have allowed for CCRC contracts that condition lump-sum payments based upon resale of “any” unit – as opposed to the unit previously occupied by the resident - to not be considered a “refundable contract,” making the refund reserve requirements inapplicable in such circumstances. This bill was referred to but not heard by the Assembly Human Services Committee.
SB 939 (Monning, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2016) required that continuing care contracts that contain lump sum contract termination payments conditioned on resale of the unit must meet a series of requirements and timelines, must pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and must meet other requirements
SB 475 (Monning, 2015) would have required prospective and future CCRC contracts which condition lump sum contract termination payments on resale of the unit to meet a series of requirements and timelines, to pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and to meet other requirements. SB 475 was vetoed by the Governor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Continuing Care Residents Association (source)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
The Consumer Federation of California
8 individuals
Leading Age California
The California Assisted Living Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumer Federation of California supports this bill because “When residents are already paying substantial amounts to enter CCRCs and paying additional monthly fees, fees that are subject to increases at the discretion of the provider’s board, California should ensure that the facilities are managing their finances in the most responsible way…Actuarial studies will help CCRC providers identify long-term financial risks and develop policies and solutions that minimize the impact of those risks on residents. Without these important assessments, a CCRC may appear financially stable in the short term yet still face significant threats in its long-term viability. These elements of risk exist in every CCRC contract and it is the function of the actuary to bring these risks into focus and project the financial future of the organization.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition to this bill, Leading Age California states, "We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident's monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to CDSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-1, 5/14/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Brough
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Chávez, Cooper, Flora, Fong, Cristina Garcia, Gray, Harper, Kiley, Mayes, Medina, Patterson
7/3/18 17:23:57
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Wiener, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 3088
Author: | Chu | ||
Version: | April 12, 2018 | Hearing Date: | June 12, 2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Taryn Smith | ||
Subject: Continuing care contracts: retirement communities
SUMMARY
This bill expands a requirement for Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) at least once every five years to include all CCRCs, not just those that offer Type A contracts, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every three years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
ABSTRACT
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of CCRCs by CDSS to enact minimum requirements to protect the wellbeing and financial security of CCRS residents. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a continuing care promise made in exchange for an entrance fee, the payment of periodic charges, or both types of payments, and permits that a continuing care contract may consist of one agreement or a series of agreements and other writings incorporated by reference. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of CDSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Requires a CCRC provider to hold a certificate of authority from CDSS permitting the provider to contract for the provision of continuing care, including medical care, in which a resident over the age of 60 has paid in advance for more than one year for that care. (HSC 1771.2)
- Provides that the components of care provided by the facility must be separately licensed as otherwise required by state law, including Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly and Skilled Nursing care. (HSC 1771.5)
- Defines a "refundable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor's unit, as specified, when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident's sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(2))
- Defines a "repayable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unit previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law, as specified. (HSC 1771(r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract, or any other entity assuming responsibility for refundable contracts, to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to CDSS. (HSC 1792.6(a))
- Makes a series of Legislative findings and declarations regarding continuing care contracts and that each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with CDSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" to mean a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" to mean an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to CDSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations. Further requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider's annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
- Requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board and that it include statements that the data and assumptions used in the underlying actuarial study are appropriate and that the methods employed in the actuarial study are consistent with sound actuarial principles and practices. Further requires that the actuary’s opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the provider’s financial condition is actuarially sound. (HSC 1792.10 (d))
This bill:
- Removes the condition that only CCRC providers that have entered into Type A contracts must file an actuarial opinion with CDSS, thereby making the requirement applicable to all CCRC providers, regardless of the contract type offered.
- Requires each provider that was not required to file an actuary's opinion with CDSS prior to January 1, 2018, to file an actuary's opinion within 45 days after each provider’ annual report is due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary's opinion in a central and conspicuous location at the CCRC facility and on the provider's Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary's opinion with CDSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider to, at least once every three years, conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility and, requires the facility’s board to use the review for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires that the review shall, at a minimum, include all of the following:
- Identification of the major components that the provider is obligated to maintain that, as of the date of the review, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
- An estimate of the remaining useful life of the major components as of the date of the review.
- An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance of the major components.
- An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the major components during, and at the end of, the components’ useful life.
- A funding plan that indicates how the provider plans to fund its obligation to repair or replace the major components with the exception of those components that the board has determined it will not replace or repair, as well as a timeline detailing when those repairs or replacements will be made.
- Requires each provider to submit to CDSS, at least once every three years, a summary of the maintenance and replacement review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment plan being filed with CDSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
FISCAL IMPACT
According the Assembly Appropriations Committee on May 9, 2018, this bill may result in minor and absorbable costs to CDSS (General Fund) to review additional reports.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the bill:
According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risk and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities, senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden.” Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise.
“Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately, this bill promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement,” per the author.
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs)
According to the Department of Finance, 5.5 million Californians were age 65 and older in 2016. That number is expected to grow to 10.3 million by 2036. CCRCs offer people age 60 and older a long-term continuing care option that pairs their current health and resources with an individualized contract that provides community life and a wide range of care. CCRCs offer long-term care contracts that provide housing, residential services, and nursing care within one location. Typically this is offered in a campus-like community setting, and usually for a resident’s lifetime, and always for at least one year. Most CCRCs require substantial entrance fees, along with monthly fees. Entrance fees can range from $50,000 to more than $2 million. There are currently 109 CCRCs operating in California.
A CCRC is defined as a facility where services promised in a “continuing care contract” are provided. A continuing care contract includes a continuing care promise made, in exchange for an entrance fee and/or payment of ongoing periodic charges. A continuing care contract may consist of one agreement for continuous care, or a series of agreements describing care, conditions for that care, and payment of it, if and when it becomes necessary.
CCRCs are permitted to offer a broad range of contract options so that they have the flexibility to offer a range of services that meet their consumers’ varying needs. Each potential consumer has different health, long-term care, and financial risks and needs that require contract flexibility. Each CCRC offers differing options on costs of service, payment methods, services provided, and other elements, including lifestyle choices.
Continuing care contracts typically require an individual to pay an entrance fee and monthly fees. Entrance fees and monthly fees can vary significantly and depend on the level of services included in the contract and other factors associated with location, exclusivity, business plan variations, and more.
While there is no standardized contract, there are certain defined contract elements that must be in place. CDSS approves basic elements of the contract and the CCRC facility uses that structure to create more individualized contracts with residents.
Current law allows residents to access substantial financial information about all CCRCs, including a key indicator report, which is an annual report submitted to CDSS that includes (1) the provider's payment of the annual provider free and fee calculation forms, (2) certification by the provider's chief executive officer that the reports are correct, (3) evidence of the provider's fidelity bond, (4) the provider's audited financial statements, (5) the provider's audited reserve reports, (6) the provider's "Continuing Care Retirement Community Disclosure Statement" for each community, and (7) the provider's report on CCRC monthly services fee for each community.
CCRCs contracts are referred to by three "types." They are as follow:
- Type A contracts, also known as life care contracts, are typically the most expensive because they are offer the most inclusive services as they include increasing housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age. Current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuarial report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B contracts, also called modified contracts, typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees than Type A contracts and limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may enter a skilled nursing facility within the CCRC without experiencing increased costs. Under this contract type, extended stay may be subject to increased fees.
- Type C contracts, also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, and the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable and Repayable Contracts
CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident's death) to receive some, or all, of the initial entrance fee when the contract is terminated. These contracts are classified as either "repayable" or "refundable."
Repayable contracts include a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee, conditional upon the re-occupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed.
Refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to refund the entrance fee and are not conditioned upon re-occupancy or resale of the unit. Refundable contracts require the facility to maintain a reserve fund, which, must be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident's unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from a reserve account.
The type of contract (Type A, B, or C) does not dictate whether that contract is refundable or repayable. Whether a contract is refundable or repayable is spelled out in the contract itself. Therefore, Type A, B, and C contracts can be designed as refundable or repayable. Current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time the resident signs the contract.
Actuarial Opinions
California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to CDSS once every five years because those contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the increasing costs of care for residents who have Type A contracts.
Actuaries apply their expertise in economics, statistics and mathematics to perform risk assessments and estimation of premiums, typically for an insurance business. A 2008 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report entitled "Older Americans: Continuing Care Retirement Communities Can Provide Benefits, but Not Without Some Risk" states that "According to industry participants, only an actuarial study incorporates mortality, morbidity, and other information unique to a CCRC to help it anticipate and make plans to address risks to its long-term viability, such as lower-than-expected occupancy levels and higher-than-expected costs."
The law requires the actuary’s opinion to comply with generally accepted actuarial principles and the standards of practice adopted by the Actuarial Standards Board, which proscribe the content of an actuarial opinion to disclose the actuarial balance sheet, the cohort pricing analysis, and the cash and investment balances at the beginning and end of each projection year, and state whether or not each condition is met. The law further requires that the actuary’s opinion must state whether the provider has adequate resources to meet all its actuarial liabilities and related statement items, including an appropriate surplus, and whether the provider’s financial condition is actuarially sound.
According to CDSS, there are currently 109 CCRS operated by 77 different providers in California. Ten of which currently offer Type A contracts.
Related legislation:
AB 2661 (Burke, 2016) allows for CCRC contracts that condition lump-sum payments based upon resale of “any” unit – as opposed to the unit previously occupied by the resident - to not be considered a “refundable contract,” making the refund reserve requirements inapplicable in such circumstances. This bill was referred to but not heard by the Assembly Human Services Committee.
SB 939 (Monning, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2016) requires that continuing care contracts that contain lump sum contract termination payments conditioned on resale of the unit must meet a series of requirements and timelines, must pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and must meet other requirements
SB 475 (Monning, 2015) would have required prospective and future CCRC contracts which condition lump sum contract termination payments on resale of the unit to meet a series of requirements and timelines, to pay interest after a specified period of vacancy, and to meet other requirements. SB 475 was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 2550 (Steinberg, Chapter 129, Statutes of 2004) implemented recommendations of the Actuarial Study Review Panel (created by AB 2077 (Ortiz, Chapter 820, Statutes of 2000) regarding requirements for actuarial studies, operating expense reserves, and annual financial reports for continuing care providers. Required that facilities using Type A continuing care contracts to submit to CDSS an actuary’s opinion as to the provider’s actuarial financial condition at least every five years.
SB 2077 (Ortiz, Chapter 820, Statutes of 2000), recast the law dealing with continuing care contracts and continuing care community rights. Among other things, the bill created an Actuarial Study Review Panel to explore viable means of validating the financial viability of continuing care retirement facilities, given the potential for fluctuating costs of health care and residential living and the serious impact upon vulnerable residents of financial failure of these facilities. SB 2077 also required CDSS to implement a four-year trial program assessing long-term care provider solvency and to report to the Legislature.
Arguments in Support:
The Consumer Federation of California supports this bill because “When residents are already paying substantial amounts to enter CCRCs and paying additional monthly fees, fees that are subject to increases at the discretion of the provider’s board, California should ensure that the facilities are managing their finances in the most responsible way…Actuarial studies will help CCRC providers identify long-term financial risks and develop policies and solutions that minimize the impact of those risks on residents. Without these important assessments, a CCRC may appear financially stable in the short term yet still face significant threats in its long-term viability. These elements of risk exist in every CCRC contract and it is the function of the actuary to bring these risks into focus and project the financial future of the organization.”
Arguments in Opposition:
Writing in opposition to this bill, Leading Age California states, "We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident's monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to DSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.
PRIOR VOTES
Assembly Floor: | 64 - 1 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 0 |
Assembly Human Services Committee: | 5 - 0 |
POSITIONS
Support:
California Continuing Care Residents Association (Sponsor)
The Consumer Federation of California
8 individuals
Oppose:
Leading Age California
The California Assisted Living Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3088
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:April 12, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Human Services | 5-0 | Rubio, Arambula, Reyes, Mark Stone, Thurmond | |
Aging | 5-0 | Kalra, Voepel, Gipson, Gloria, Rubio | |
Appropriations | 11-0 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes |
SUMMARY: Continuing care contracts: retirement communities
SUMMARY: Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary's opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every five years, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every three years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the reference to entrance into Type A contracts as a condition under which certain CCRC providers must file an actuarial report with DSS, thereby applying this requirement to providers regardless of contract type offered, and further requires each provider who was not required to file an actuary's opinion prior to January 1, 2018, to file its actuary's opinion within 45 days after a provider's annual report was due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary's opinion at the facility and on the provider's Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary's opinion with DSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider, at least once every three years, to conduct a review of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain, and requires the review be used for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires the study to include at least all of the following:
- identification of components a provider is obligated to maintain that have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years as of the date of the review, and an estimate of the remaining useful life of those components;
- an estimate of the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components;
- an estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the costs of repairing, replacing, restoring, or maintaining those components both during and at the end of their useful life; and
- a funding plan describing how the provider intends to fund the obligations of repairing or replacing the identified components, as specified, and a timeline detailing when those replacements will be made.
- Requires each provider to submit, at least once every three years, a summary of the review, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the review.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment being filed with DSS, to post a copy of the summary and adjustment plan at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensure and regulation of Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs) as a separate category within the existing licensing structure of DSS. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) 1569 et seq.)
- Provides for the certification and regulation of CCRCs by DSS. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of DSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Defines a "continuing care contract" to mean a contract that includes a promise by a provider to provide one or more elements of care to an elderly resident, as specified, in exchange for an entrance fee and/or the payment of periodic charges. (HSC 1771(c)(8))
- Defines a "continuing care retirement community" as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents' own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771(c)(10))
- Defines a "refundable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor's unit, as specified when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident's sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(2))
- Defines a "repayable contract" as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unity previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law. (HSC 1771(r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to DSS. (HSC 1792.6(a))
- Makes Legislative findings and declaration that require each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with DSS an actuary's opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations, as specified in HSC 1792.10. (HSC 1792.7(c))
- Defines a "Type A contract" as a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8(c))
- Defines an "actuarial study" as an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8(a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to DSS, at least once every five years, an actuary's opinion as to the provider's actuarial financial condition of the provider's continuing care operations. Further requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary's opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider's annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According the Assembly Appropriations Committee on May 9, 2018, this bill may result in minor and absorbable costs to DSS (General Fund) to review additional reports.
COMMENTS:
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs): United States (U.S.) Census data indicates that on July 1, 2015, approximately 47.8 million people in the United States were age 65 or older; that number is projected to reach 98.2 million by the year 2060. As the nation's population ages, seniors are faced with a variety of options for retirement living. One such option, CCRCs, provide long-term care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care, and are an attractive option for seniors as these services are provided in one location. California currently has 110 CCRCs, nearly 50% of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and it is the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) that is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The Branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
Contract types: CCRCs offer several types of contracts. Typically the parameters of the contracts require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, which can range from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to any ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs are referred to by three "types":
- Type A: Also known as life care contracts, Type A contracts are often the most expensive contract type, but are also the most inclusive as they cover the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age, and current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuary report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B: Also called modified contracts, Type B contracts typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees and offer limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may, for a short period of time, stay in a skilled nursing facility without experiencing increased costs. Extended stays, however, may be subject to increased fees depending on the circumstances.
- Type C: Also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, however the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care with the resident are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable vs. repayable contracts: CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident's death) to receive the cost of his or her initial entrance fee when terminating his or her contract. Contracts are classified as either "repayable" or "refundable." Repayable contracts include a promise by the provider to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee; however, that repayment is conditional upon the reoccupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed. In contrast, refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund to the resident, and are required to maintain a reserve fund, which is required to be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each individual resident holding a refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident's unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from an existing reserve account.
It is important to note that the type of contract a resident enters into, be it Type A, B, or C, pertains only to the services provided to residents and the associated fees for those services, if applicable. The type of contract does not dictate whether a contract is refundable or repayable; whether a contract is refundable or repayable is denoted in the contract itself, and current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time he or she signs the contract.
Actuarial opinions: Actuaries are responsible for assessing and issuing opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Unlike an accountant, who is responsible for compiling and comparing financial records in order to ensure businesses and governments run accurately and efficiently, actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or company enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary's opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
It is the unique nature of Type A contracts that trigger the need for an actuarial study, as these contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the costs of increased care for these residents. It should be noted, however, that current law requires an actuarial study to contain a summary of the financial condition of the provider, not just the financial liability of a provider's contractual obligation to finance the ongoing healthcare costs of residents with Type A contracts. In short, current law requires CCRCs to review the financial liabilities of all contracts at the facility, be they Type A, B, C, or a combination thereof.
Need for this bill: According to the author, "When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risks and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden. Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately [this bill] promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement."
Opposition: Writing in opposition to this bill, Leading Age California states, "We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident's monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to DSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC."
Staff comments: Health and Safety Code Section 1771 allows residents to access substantial financial information about a CCRC. Some stakeholders have voiced concerns that the additional information CCRC residents would gain as a result of this bill is unclear. The sponsor of the bill states that actuarial studies go beyond assessing the financial liability of providing long-term, ongoing care for residents with Type A contracts, and can take into account additional factors. A 2008 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report entitled "Older Americans: Continuing Care Retirement Communities Can Provide Benefits, but Not Without Some Risk" states that "…one CCRC we reviewed uses actuarial studies with mortality and morbidity rates to assess the likely inflow, outflow and turnover of the CCRC occupants. Other CCRCs use some combination of resident statistics, Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates, marketing needs, and operating costs." The report also states that "According to industry participants, only an actuarial study incorporates mortality, morbidity, and other information unique to a CCRC to help it anticipate and make plans to address risks to its long-term viability, such as lower-than-expected occupancy levels and higher-than-expected costs." However, California statute is silent on the components an actuarial study of a CCRC must contain. California Health and Safety Code Section 1792.10 states that an actuarial study of a CCRC must be conducted every five years, however, the factors upon which the study is based are not described in statute. It should also be noted that, currently, DSS does not promulgate regulations dictating the operational administration of CCRCs, such that any regulation of CCRCs must be explicitly written in statute. Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to clarify in statute the components an actuarial study must contain in order to make clear the additional information that a CCRC resident would receive should this bill become law.
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0002902
Date of Hearing: May 9, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3088
Author:(Chu) – As Amended Ver:April 12, 2018
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
Aging and Long Term Care | 5 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires every Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every five years regarding the provider’s actuarial financial condition. The bill further requires each CCRC to post a copy of the actuary’s opinion at the CCRC facility and on its website within 10 days of filing with DSS. The bill also requires each CCRC to conduct a review of its facility at least once every three years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs to DSS (GF) to review additional reports.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to protect seniors who reside at CCRCs by requiring CCRCs to use an actuarial and maintenance/repair review to assess the risk of future events that could harm financial soundness, and, as a result, residents. According to the author:
When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risks and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment.
- Background. Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) provide long-term-care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care to seniors. CCRCs are an attractive option because they provide services in one location. California has 110 CCRCs, nearly half of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
CCRC contracts typically require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, ranging from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs contracts are of three “types,” A, B, and C, which pertain to the level of services provided to residents and the associated fees. Type A contracts are often the most expensive, but are also the most inclusive, covering the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age.
- Actuarial opinions. Actuaries assess and issue opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or organization enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary’s opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
Every CCRCs must submit to DSS an annual report consisting of audited financial statements and required reserve calculations, with certified public accountants’ opinions, additional reserve information, and evidence of fidelity bond, if applicable. These reports include details on reserves, disclosure of any amounts accumulated or expended for identified projects, and full details on any increase in monthly care fees, among other things. The annual report is intended to summarize the provider’s performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and DSS. If DSS determines that a provider’s annual audited report needs further analysis and investigation, the provider must reimburse DSS for costs incurred.
Existing law also mandates an annual “Key Indicators Repor”t that discloses key financial ratios and other key indicators determined by DSS. The report covers indicators for the past five years, based on actual experience, and projected for the upcoming five years. If, upon review of these reports and other information, DSS believes there is financial distress, it may require a financial plan to correct the situation.
- Arguments in Support. According to the California Continuing Care Residents Association:
Actuaries analyze data to estimate the probability of events and their likely short and long-term costs to the provider, this includes analyzing population projections and cash flow projections for the CCRC. The risk that an actuary measures is inherent in all CCRC’s because all CCRC’s offer the same underlying promise – to accommodate residents as their healthcare needs change. It is the function of the actuary to bring these risks into focus and project the financial future of the organization.
- Arguments in Opposition. LeadingAge California states:
We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident’s monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to DSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON AGING AND LONG-TERM CARE
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3088 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:April 12, 2018
SUBJECT: Continuing care contracts: retirement communities.
SUMMARY: Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every five years regarding the provider’s actuarial financial condition. Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the reference to entrance into Type A contracts as a condition under which certain CCRC providers must file an actuarial report with DSS, thereby applying this requirement to providers regardless of contract type offered.
- Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities to file an actuary opinion with the Department of Social Services at least once every five years regarding the provider’s actuarial financial condition.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary’s opinion at the facility and on the provider’s Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary’s opinion with DSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider, at least once every three years, to conduct a review of the accessible areas that the provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility. The board of each provider shall use the review to consider and implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account requirements.
- Requires the study to include at least all of the following:
- Identification of components a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain that have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years as of the date of the study, and the probable remaining useful life of those components;
- An estimate of the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components;
- An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the costs of repairing, replacing, restoring, or maintaining those components both during and at the end of their useful life; and,
- A funding plan describing how the provider intends to fund the obligations of repairing and replacing the identified components, as specified.
- Requires each provider to submit, at least once every three years, a summary of the study, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the study.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment being filed with DSS, to post a copy of the study at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensure and regulation of Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs) as a separate category within the existing licensing structure of DSS.
2) Defines a “continuing care retirement community” as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents’ own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC.
3) Provides for the certification and regulation of CCRCs by DSS.
4) Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of DSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified.
5) Defines an “actuarial study” as an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions.
6) Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to DSS, at least once every five years, an actuary’s opinion as to the provider’s actuarial financial condition of the provider’s continuing care operations.
- Requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary’s opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary’s opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider’s annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: “When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risk and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities, senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden.
“Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment.
“It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen cost. Ultimately, this bill promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement.”
BACKGROUND:
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs):
CCRCs, provide long-term care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care, and are an attractive option for seniors as these services are provided in one location.
California currently has 110 CCRCs, nearly 50% of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and it is the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) that is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The Branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
Contract Types: CCRCs offer several types of contracts. Typically the parameters of the contracts require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, which can range from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to any ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs are referred to by three types.
Type A: Also known as life care contracts, Type A contracts are often the most expensive contract type, but are also the most inclusive as they cover the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age, and current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuary report to DSS once every five years.
Type B: Also called modified contracts, Type B contracts typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees and offer limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may, for a short period of time, stay in a skilled nursing facility without experiencing increased costs. Extended stays, however, may be subject to increased fees depending on the circumstances.
Type C: Also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, however the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care with the resident are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable vs. Repayable Contracts: CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident’s death) to receive the cost of his or her initial entrance fee when terminating his or her contract. Contracts are classified as either “repayable” or “refundable.” Repayable contracts include a promise by the provider to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee; however, that repayment is conditional upon the re-occupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed. In contrast, refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund to the resident, and are required to maintain a reserve fund, which is required to be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each individual resident holding a refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident’s unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from an existing reserve account.
It is important to note that the type of contract a resident enters into, be it Type A, B, or C, pertains only to the services provided to residents and the associated fees for those services, if applicable. The type of contract does not dictate whether a contract is refundable or repayable; whether a contract is refundable or repayable is denoted in the contract itself, and current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time he or she signs the contract.
Actuarial Opinions: Actuaries are responsible for assessing and issuing opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Unlike an accountant, who is responsible for compiling and comparing financial records in order to ensure businesses and governments run accurately and efficiently, actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or company enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary’s opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
It is the unique nature of Type A contracts that trigger the need for an actuarial study, as these contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the costs of increased care for these residents. It should be noted, however, that current law requires an actuarial study to contain a summary of the financial condition of the provider, not just the financial liability of a provider’s contractual obligation to finance the ongoing healthcare costs of residents with Type A contracts. In short, current law requires CCRCs to review the financial liabilities of all contracts at the facility, be they Type A, B, C, or a combination thereof.
All CCRCs are required to submit an annual report consisting of audited financial statements and required reserve calculations, with certified public accountants’ opinions, additional reserve information, and evidence of fidelity bond, if applicable. These reports include details on reserves, disclosure of any amounts accumulated or expended for identified projects, and full details on any increase in monthly care fees, among other things. The Annual Report is intended to summarize the provider’s performance in a form useful to residents, prospective residents, and the department. If the department determines that a provider’s annual audited report needs further analysis and investigation, the provider shall reimburse DSS for costs incurred.
Required Key Indicators Report is also mandated annually and discloses key financial ratios and other key indicators, including operational data, margin ratios, liquidity indicators, and annual capital expenditures, among others. The formulas are determined by DSS. The report covers indicators for the past five years, based on actual experience, and projected for the upcoming five years. If, upon review of these reports and other information, DSS has reason to believe there is financial distress, it may require a financial plan to correct the situation.
Argument in Support: According to the California Continuing Care Residents Association, “Actuarial studies help CCRC providers identify long-term financial risks and develop policies and solutions that minimize the impact of those risks on residents. Actuaries analyze data to estimate the probability of events and their likely short and long-term costs to the provider, this includes analyzing population projections and cash flow projections for the CCRC. All of these estimates and projections are important in maintaining the financial solvency of the CCRC.
“It is important to note that these risks exist regardless of the type of contract that is offered at the CCRC. The risk that an actuary measures is inherent in all CCRC’s because all CCRC’s offer the same underlying promise – to accommodate residents as their healthcare needs change. It is the function of the actuary to bring these risks into focus and project the financial future of the organization.”
Argument in Opposition: LeadingAge California states, “We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident’s monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to DSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.”
A 2008 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report entitled “Older Americans: Continuing Care Retirement Communities Can Provide Benefits, but Not Without Some Risk” states that “…one CCRC we reviewed uses actuarial studies with mortality and morbidity rates to assess the likely inflow, outflow and turnover of the CCRC occupants. Other CCRCs use some combination of resident statistics, Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates, marketing needs, and operating costs.” The report also states that “According to industry participants, only an actuarial study incorporates mortality, morbidity, and other information unique to a CCRC to help it anticipate and make plans to address risks to its long-term viability, such as lower-than-expected occupancy levels and higher-than-expected costs.”
California statute is silent on the components an actuarial study of a CCRC must contain. Section 1792.10 of the California Health and Safety Code states that an actuarial study of a CCRC must be conducted every five years, however, the factors upon which the study is based are not described in statute. It should also be noted that, currently, DSS does not promulgate regulations dictating the operational administration of CCRCs, such that any regulation of CCRCs must be explicitly written in statute.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Continuing Care Residents Association – Sponsor
Opposition
California Assisted Living Association (CALA)
LeadingAge California
Analysis Prepared by: Barry Brewer / AGING & L.T.C. / (916) 319-3990
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Blanca Rubio, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3088 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2018
SUBJECT: Continuing care contracts: retirement communities
SUMMARY: Requires all Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to file an actuary opinion with the Department of Social Services (DSS) at least once every three years, and requires each CCRC to conduct a study of the facility at least once every three years for purposes of estimating maintenance costs.
Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the reference to entrance into Type A contracts as a condition under which certain CCRC providers must file an actuarial report with DSS, thereby applying this requirement to providers regardless of contract type offered, and further revises requirements as follows:
- Increases the frequency with which various providers must submit an actuary’s opinion regarding the provider’s actuarial financial condition from once every five years to once every three years, as specified; and
- Requires each provider who was not required to file an actuary’s opinion prior to January 1, 2018, to file its actuary’s opinion within 45 days after a provider’s annual report was due, as specified.
- Requires a CCRC provider to post a copy of the actuary’s opinion at the facility and on the provider’s Internet Web site, as specified, within 10 days of filing the actuary’s opinion with DSS.
- Requires each CCRC provider, at least once every three years, to conduct a maintenance and replacement study of the accessible areas that a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain, and requires the study to be reviewed annually, as specified, for purposes of considering and implementing adjustments to the reserve account requirements.
- Requires the study to include at least all of the following:
- identification of components a provider is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain that have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years as of the date of the study, and the probable remaining useful life of those components;
- an estimate of the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the components;
- an estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to defray the costs of repairing, replacing, restoring, or maintaining those components both during and at the end of their useful life; and
- a funding plan describing how the provider intends to fund the obligations of repairing and replacing the identified components, as specified.
- Requires each provider to submit, at least once every three years, a summary of the study, as well as any necessary adjustments the provider has made or intends to make, as a result of the study.
- Requires a provider, within 10 days of the summary and adjustment being filed with DSS, to post a copy of the study at the facility and on its Internet Web site, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensure and regulation of Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs) as a separate category within the existing licensing structure of DSS. (HSC 1569 et seq.)
- Provides for the certification and regulation of CCRCs by DSS. (HSC 1770 et seq.)
- Authorizes the Continuing Care Contracts Branch of DSS to enforce certain health and safety regulations, as specified. (HSC 1771.1)
- Defines a “continuing care contract” to mean a contract that includes a promise by a provider to provide one or more elements of care to an elderly resident, as specified, in exchange for an entrance fee and/or the payment of periodic charges. (HSC 1771 (c)(8))
- Defines a “continuing care retirement community” as a facility located in the state where services promised in a continuing care contract are provided. Further allows that, when services are provided in residents’ own homes, the homes into which the provider takes those services are to be considered a part of the CCRC. (HSC 1771 (c)(10))
- Defines a “refundable contract” as a continuing care contract that includes a promise, expressed or implied, by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund or to repurchase the transferor’s unit, as specified when the promise to refund some or all of the initial entrance fee extends beyond the resident’s sixth year of residency, and further specifies that providers that enter into refundable contracts shall be subject to the refund reserve requirements specified in current law. (HSC 1771 (r)(2))
- Defines a “repayable contract” as a continuing care contract that includes a promise to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee that is conditioned upon reoccupancy or resale of the unity previously occupied by the resident, and further specifies that a repayable contract shall not be considered a refundable contract for purposes of the refund reserve requirements described in current law. (HSC 1771 (r)(3))
- Requires any provider offering a refundable contract to maintain a refund reserve in trust for the residents, which is to be revised annually by the provider, and further requires the provider to submit its calculations to DSS. (HSC 1792.6 (a))
- Makes Legislative findings and declaration that require each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to file with DSS an actuary’s opinion as to the actuarial financial condition of the provider’s continuing care operations, as specified in HSC 1792.10. (HSC 1792.7 (c))
- Defines a “Type A contract” as a continuing care contract that has an up-front entrance fee and includes provisions for housing, residential services, amenities, and unlimited specific health-related services with little or no substantial increases in monthly charges, except for normal operating costs and inflation adjustments. (HSC 1792.8 (c))
- Defines an “actuarial study” as an analysis that address the current financial condition of a provider that is performed by an actuary, and includes: an actuarial report, a statement of actuarial opinion, an actuarial balance sheet, a cohort pricing analysis, a cash flow projection, and a description of the actuarial methodology, formulae, and assumptions. (HSC 1792.8 (a))
- Requires each provider that has entered into Type A contracts to submit to DSS, at least once every five years, an actuary’s opinion as to the provider’s actuarial financial condition of the provider’s continuing care operations. Further requires providers that held a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary’s opinion before the expiration of five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or opinion, and requires providers that did not hold a certificate of authority on December 31, 2003, to file their actuary’s opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider’s annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its certificate of authority. (HSC 1792.10 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs): U.S. Census data indicates that on July 1, 2015, approximately 47.8 million people in the United States were age 65 or older; that number is projected to reach 98.2 million by the year 2060. As the nation’s population ages, seniors are faced with a variety of options for retirement living. One such option, CCRCs, provide long-term care contracts that offer housing, residential services, and nursing care, and are an attractive option for seniors as these services are provided in one location. California currently has 110 CCRCs, nearly 50% of which are nonprofit. DSS is responsible for the licensure and oversight of these facilities, and it is the Continuing Care Branch within the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) that is responsible for reviewing and approving applications to operate a CCRC. The Branch also monitors the ongoing financial condition of all CCRC providers in addition to their ability to fulfill long-term contractual obligations to residents.
Contract types: CCRCs offer several types of contracts. Typically the parameters of the contracts require residents to pay substantial entrance fees, which can range from $100,000 to $1 million, in addition to any ongoing monthly fees. CCRCs are referred to by three “types”:
- Type A: Also known as life care contracts, Type A contracts are often the most expensive contract type, but are also the most inclusive as they cover the housing, services, and healthcare needs of a resident. Under Type A contracts, a CCRC absorbs the cost of increased care residents may need as they age, and current law requires facilities that provide Type A contracts to submit an annual actuary report to DSS once every five years.
- Type B: Also called modified contracts, Type B contracts typically offer lower entrance and monthly fees and offer limited health care services to a resident without an increase in his or her monthly fees. For example, if a resident needs skilled nursing services for a short period of time, he or she may, for a short period of time, stay in a skilled nursing facility without experiencing increased costs. Extended stays, however, may be subject to increased fees depending on the circumstances.
- Type C: Also known as fee-for-service contracts, include similar residential services, housing, and amenities offered by Type A and B contracts, but require residents to pay market rates for any necessary health-related services. Type C contracts typically offer lower entry and monthly fees, however the responsibility of increases in expenses for long-term care with the resident are not the financial responsibility of the facility.
Refundable vs. repayable contracts: CCRCs often offer contracts to residents that enable a resident (or his or her estate, in the event of the resident’s death) to receive the cost of his or her initial entrance fee when terminating his or her contract. Contracts are classified as either “repayable” or “refundable.” Repayable contracts include a promise by the provider to repay all or a portion of an entrance fee; however, that repayment is conditional upon the reoccupancy or resale of the unit that was previously occupied by the resident to whom the entrance fee is owed. In contrast, refundable contracts include a promise by the provider to pay an entrance fee refund to the resident, and are required to maintain a reserve fund, which is required to be revised on an annual basis in order to ensure adequate funds to cover the costs of each individual resident holding a refundable contract. The key difference between repayable and refundable contracts is the source of the funds; repayable contracts generate the required funds as a result of reselling the resident’s unit, while refundable contracts appropriate funds from an existing reserve account.
It is important to note that the type of contract a resident enters into, be it Type A, B, or C, pertains only to the services provided to residents and the associated fees for those services, if applicable. The type of contract does not dictate whether a contract is refundable or repayable; whether a contract is refundable or repayable is denoted in the contract itself, and current law requires that residents be made aware of whether their contract is refundable or repayable at the time he or she signs the contract.
Actuarial opinions: Actuaries are responsible for assessing and issuing opinions regarding the financial obligations and risks of businesses and organizations, such as insurance companies or businesses that sell insurable products. Unlike an accountant, who is responsible for compiling and comparing financial records in order to ensure businesses and governments run accurately and efficiently, actuaries and their subsequent opinions regarding the financial obligations of a business or company enable those entities to gauge the risk of various financial liabilities. California law requires all CCRCs that enter into Type A contracts to submit an actuary’s opinion to DSS once every five years. These opinions predict the potential financial obligations of a CCRC should the facility find it necessary to cover the costs of increased care for residents with Type A contracts.
It is the unique nature of Type A contracts that trigger the need for an actuarial study, as these contracts explicitly require CCRCs to cover the costs of increased care for these residents. It should be noted, however, that current law requires an actuarial study to contain a summary of the financial condition of the provider, not just the financial liability of a provider’s contractual obligation to finance the ongoing healthcare costs of residents with Type A contracts. In short, current law requires CCRCs to review the financial liabilities of all contracts at the facility, be they Type A, B, C, or a combination thereof.
Need for this bill: According to the author, “When CCRCs do not properly evaluate financial risks and plan to ensure sustainability of their communities senior residents living in those facilities bear a significant burden. Moving into a CCRC is a costly decision, requiring advanced planning for residents and their families. CCRCs require a substantial entrance fee and a contract, along with the promise of future benefits in return similar to an insurance promise. Like any insurance policy, there are elements of risk. However, existing law only requires a handful of CCRCs to conduct a formal study primarily on risk assessment. It is only logical for these studies to be required for all CCRCs to protect owners and operators as well as minimize the need to increase monthly fees residents would have to pay to cover unforeseen costs. Ultimately [this bill] promotes sensible business practices and protects seniors ready to enter into retirement.”
Opposition: Writing in opposition to this bill, Leading Age California states, “We believe that this proposal is costly and unnecessary for CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts. Non-Type A contracts do not include a promissory note of care, which significantly limits the financial risk borne by the CCRC. Requiring CCRCs that do not offer Type A contracts to complete an actuarial analysis will, at best, provide a nominal benefit at a significant expense, which could lead to an increase in current resident’s monthly fees. Furthermore, current law already requires all CCRCs in California to provide substantial financial information to DSS on an annual basis, including audited financial statements, detailed explanations on any monthly fee increases and detailed key indicators on the financial health of the community. This information, which both DSS and residents have unfettered access to, provides a transparent and comprehensive picture that ensures the financial stability and solvency of the CCRC.”
Staff comments: Section 1771 of the Health and Safety Code allows residents to access substantial financial information about a CCRC. Some stakeholders have voiced concerns that the additional information CCRC residents would gain as a result of this bill is unclear. The sponsor of the bill states that actuarial studies go beyond assessing the financial liability of providing long-term, ongoing care for residents with Type A contracts, and can take into account additional factors. A 2008 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report entitled “Older Americans: Continuing Care Retirement Communities Can Provide Benefits, but Not Without Some Risk” states that “…one CCRC we reviewed uses actuarial studies with mortality and morbidity rates to assess the likely inflow, outflow and turnover of the CCRC occupants. Other CCRCs use some combination of resident statistics, Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates, marketing needs, and operating costs.” The report also states that “According to industry participants, only an actuarial study incorporates mortality, morbidity, and other information unique to a CCRC to help it anticipate and make plans to address risks to its long-term viability, such as lower-than-expected occupancy levels and higher-than-expected costs.” However, California statute is silent on the components an actuarial study of a CCRC must contain. Section 1792.10 of the California Health and Safety Code states that an actuarial study of a CCRC must be conducted every five years, however, the factors upon which the study is based are not described in statute. It should also be noted that, currently, DSS does not promulgate regulations dictating the operational administration of CCRCs, such that any regulation of CCRCs must be explicitly written in statute. Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to clarify in statute the components an actuarial study must contain in order to make clear the additional information that a CCRC resident would receive should this bill become law.
Recommended amendments: In order to reduce the potential costs of conducting actuarial studies at an increased frequency, committee staff recommends the following amendments:
- Beginning on line 15 on page 3 of the bill, make the following amendments:
13
1792.10. (a) Each provider that has entered into Type A
14
contracts shall submit to the department, at least once every five
15
three five years, an actuary’s opinion as to the provider’s actuarial
16
financial condition. The actuary’s opinion shall be based on an
17
actuarial study completed by the opining actuary in a manner that
18
meets the requirements described in Section 1792.8. The actuary’s
19
opinion, and supporting actuarial study, shall examine, refer to,
20
and opine on the provider’s actuarial financial condition as of a
21
specified date that is within four months of the date the opinion is
22
provided to the department.
23
(b) Each provider required to file an actuary’s opinion under
24
subdivision (a) that held a certificate of authority on December
25
31, 2003, shall file its actuary’s opinion before the expiration of
26
five years following the date it last filed an actuarial study or
27
opinion with the department. Thereafter, the provider shall file its
28
required actuary’s opinion before the expiration of five three five years
29
following the date it last filed an actuary’s opinion with the
30
department.
31
(c) Each provider required to file an actuary’s opinion under
32
subdivision (a) that did not hold a certificate of authority on
33
December 31, 2003, or was not required to file an actuary’s
34
opinion prior to January 1, 2018, shall file its first actuary’s
35
opinion within 45 days following the due date for the provider’s
36
annual report for the fiscal year in which the provider obtained its
37
certificate of authority. Thereafter, the provider shall file its
38
required actuary’s opinion before the expiration of five three five years
39
following the date it last filed an actuary’s opinion with the
40
department.
- Beginning on line 20 on page 4 of the bill, make the following amendments:
17
SEC. 3. Section 1792.11 is added to the Health and Safety
18
Code, to read:
19
1792.11. (a) At least once every three years, each provider
20
shall conduct a reasonably competent and diligent maintenance
21
and replacement study a review of the accessible areas that the provider is
22
obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain within the facility.
23
The board of each provider shall review this study, or cause it to
24
be reviewed, annually, and shall use the review to consider and
25
implement necessary adjustments to its reserve account
26
requirements.
27
(b) The study required by this section shall, at a minimum,
28
include all of the following:
29
(1) Identification of the major components that the provider is
30
obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain that, as of the
31
date of the study review, have a remaining useful life of less than 20 years.
32
(2) Identification of the probable An estimate of the remaining useful life of the
33
components identified in paragraph (1) as of the date of the study review.
34
(3) An estimate of the cost of repair, replacement, restoration,
35
or maintenance of the components identified in paragraph (1).
36
(4) An estimate of the total annual contribution necessary to
37
defray the cost to repair, replace, restore, or maintain the
38
components identified in paragraph (1) during, and at the end of,
39
the components’ useful life.
P5 1
(5) A funding plan that indicates how the provider plans to fund
2
its obligation to repair and or replace the major components that
3
have an expected remaining useful life of 20 years or less identified in paragraph (1), with
4
the exception of those components that the board has determined
5
it will not replace or repair, as well as timeline detailing when those repairs or replacement will be made.
DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill has been double-referred. Should this bill pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Aging and Long Term Care Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Continuing Care Residents Association, sponsor
223 Individuals
Opposition
California Assisted Living Association
Leading Age California
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Human Services
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Aging and Long-Term Care
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):