AB 3138: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-07
Existing law requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to implement a unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program. Existing law requires every county to apply to the secretary to be certified to implement the unified program and allows a city or local agency to implement the unified program as a unified program agency, or UPA.
Existing law requires a stationary source, as defined, with one or more processes that have certain substances present in more than a threshold quantity to prepare and submit a risk management plan, if the UPA makes a specified determination. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a stationary source submitting a risk management plan to submit the plan to the UPA after the plan is certified as complete, and requires the UPA to review the plan. Existing law imposes various requirements related to the submission and contents of a risk management plan. Existing law imposes civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates these provisions in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs if the person or stationary source knowingly violates these provisions after reasonable notice of the violation.
This bill, for violations of those provisions that occur on or after January 1, 2019, would increase the lesser maximum amount of civil or administrative liability imposed on a person or stationary source for a violation to $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and would authorize the greater maximum civil or administrative liability to be imposed on a person or stationary source that knowingly violates those provisions regardless of whether the violation was committed after reasonable notice.
Existing law requires a local implementing agency, as defined, to develop an integrated alerting and notification system that includes specified components to be used to notify the community surrounding a petroleum refinery in the event of an incident at the refinery warranting the use of the automatic notification system. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a petroleum refinery or a petrochemical manufacturing facility, as provided, with one or more covered processes requiring a risk management plan, when contracting for the performance of certain work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. Existing law exempts from that requirement contracts awarded before January 1, 2014, and requires the owner or operator claiming that exemption to file with the administering agency a complete copy of the contract, as provided.
This bill would exempt a violation of those provisions that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, from the civil and administrative liability described above.
Existing law requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to implement a unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program. Existing law requires every county to apply to the secretary to be certified to implement the unified program and allows a city or local agency to implement the unified program as a unified program agency, or UPA.
Existing law requires a stationary source, as defined, with one or more processes that have certain substances present in more than a threshold quantity to prepare and submit a risk management plan, if the UPA makes a specified determination. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a stationary source submitting a risk management plan to submit the plan to the UPA after the plan is certified as complete, and requires the UPA to review the plan. Existing law imposes various requirements related to the submission and contents of a risk management plan. Existing law imposes civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates these provisions in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs if the person or stationary source knowingly violates these provisions after reasonable notice of the violation.
This bill, for violations of those provisions that occur on or after January 1, 2019, would increase the lesser maximum amount of civil or administrative liability imposed on a person or stationary source for a violation to $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and would authorize the greater maximum civil or administrative liability to be imposed on a person or stationary source that knowingly violates those provisions regardless of whether the violation was committed after reasonable notice.
Existing law requires a local implementing agency, as defined, to develop an integrated alerting and notification system that includes specified components to be used to notify the community surrounding a petroleum refinery in the event of an incident at the refinery warranting the use of the automatic notification system. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a petroleum refinery or a petrochemical manufacturing facility, as provided, with one or more covered processes requiring a risk management plan, when contracting for the performance of certain work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. Existing law exempts from that requirement contracts awarded before January 1, 2014, and requires the owner or operator claiming that exemption to file with the administering agency a complete copy of the contract, as provided.
This bill would exempt a violation of those provisions that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, from the civil and administrative liability described above.
Existing law requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to implement a unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program. Existing law requires every county to apply to the secretary to be certified to implement the unified program and allows a city or local agency to implement the unified program as a unified program agency, or UPA.
Existing law requires a stationary source, as defined, with one or more processes that have certain substances present in more than a threshold quantity to prepare and submit a risk management plan, if the UPA makes a specified determination. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a stationary source submitting a risk management plan to submit the plan to the UPA after the plan is certified as complete, and requires the UPA to review the plan. Existing law imposes various requirements related to the submission and contents of a risk management plan. Existing law imposes civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates these provisions in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs if the person or stationary source knowingly violates these provisions after reasonable notice of the violation.
This bill bill, for violations of those provisions that occur on or after January 1, 2019, would increase the lesser maximum amount of civil or administrative liability imposed on a person or stationary source that violates those provisions for a violation to $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and would authorize the greater maximum civil or administrative liability to be imposed on a person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, violates those provisions regardless of whether the violation was committed after reasonable notice.
Existing law requires a local implementing agency, as defined, to develop an integrated alerting and notification system that includes specified components to be used to notify the community surrounding a petroleum refinery in the event of an incident at the refinery warranting the use of the automatic notification system. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a petroleum refinery or a petrochemical manufacturing facility, as provided, with one or more covered processes requiring a risk management plan, when contracting for the performance of certain work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. Existing law exempts from that requirement contracts awarded before January 1, 2014, and requires the owner or operator claiming that exemption to file with the administering agency a complete copy of the contract, as provided.
This bill would exempt a violation of those provisions that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, from the civil and administrative liability described above.
Existing law requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to implement a unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program. Existing law requires every county to apply to the secretary to be certified to implement the unified program and allows a city or local agency to implement the unified program as a unified program agency, or UPA.
Existing law requires a stationary source, as defined, with one or more processes that have certain substances present in more than a threshold quantity to prepare and submit a risk management plan, if the UPA makes a specified determination. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a stationary source submitting a risk management plan to submit the plan to the UPA after the plan is certified as complete, and requires the UPA to review the plan. Existing law imposes various requirements related to the submission and contents of a risk management plan. Existing law imposes civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates these provisions in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs if the person or stationary source knowingly violates these provisions after reasonable notice of the violation.
This bill would impose increase the lesser maximum amount of civil or administrative liability imposed on a person or stationary source that violates those provisions in an amount of not more than $25,000 to $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and would authorize the greater maximum civil or administrative liability to be imposed on a person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, those provisions regardless of whether the violation was committed knowingly or after reasonable notice.
Existing law requires a local implementing agency, as defined, to develop an integrated alerting and notification system that includes specified components to be used to notify the community surrounding a petroleum refinery in the event of an incident at the refinery warranting the use of the automatic notification system. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a petroleum refinery or a petrochemical manufacturing facility, as provided, with one or more covered processes requiring a risk management plan, when contracting for the performance of certain work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. Existing law exempts from that requirement contracts awarded before January 1, 2014, and requires the owner or operator claiming that exemption to file with the administering agency a complete copy of the contract, as provided.
This bill would exempt a violation of those provisions from the civil and administrative liability described above.
Existing law requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to implement a unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program. Existing law requires every county to apply to the secretary to be certified to implement the unified program and allows a city or local agency to implement the unified program as a unified program agency, or UPA.
Existing law requires a stationary source, as defined, with one or more processes that have certain substances present in more than a threshold quantity to prepare and submit a risk management plan, if the UPA makes a specified determination. Existing law requires the owner or operator of a stationary source submitting a risk management plan to submit the plan to the UPA after the plan is certified as complete, and requires the UPA to review the plan. Existing law imposes various requirements related to the submission and contents of a risk management plan. Existing law imposes civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates these provisions in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, and in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs if the person or stationary source knowingly violates these provisions after reasonable notice of the violation.
This bill would impose civil or administrative liability on a person or stationary source that violates those provisions in an amount of not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, regardless of whether the violation was committed knowingly or after reasonable notice.
(a)A person or stationary source that violates this article shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in one of the following amounts, as applicable:
(1)For a violation that occurs on or before December 31, 2018, not more than two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each day in which the violation occurs, unless paragraph (3) applies.
(2)For a violation that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, not more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for each day in which the violation occurs, unless paragraph (4) applies.
(3)For a violation committed knowingly after reasonable notice on or before December 31, 2018, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(4)For a violation committed knowingly on or after January 1, 2019, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(b)If a violation of this article results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials, in addition to the applicable amount require pursuant to subdivision (a).(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not apply for a violation of Section 25536.6, 25536.7, or 25536.9 that occurs on or after January 1, 2019.
(d)When a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for a violation of this article, the unified program agency shall utilize the administrative enforcement procedures, including the hearing procedures, specified in Sections 25404.1.1 and 25404.1.2.
(a)A person or stationary source that violates this article shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in one of the following amounts, as applicable:
(1)For a violation that occurs on or before December 31, 2018, not more than two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each day in which the violation occurs, unless paragraph (3) applies.
(2)For a violation that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, not more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for each day in which the violation occurs, unless paragraph (4) applies.
(3)For a violation committed knowingly after reasonable notice on or before December 31, 2018, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(4)For a violation committed knowingly on or after January 1, 2019, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(b)If a violation of this article results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials, in addition to the applicable amount require pursuant to subdivision (a).(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not apply for a violation of Section 25536.6, 25536.7, or 25536.9 that occurs on or after January 1, 2019.
(d)When a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for a violation of this article, the unified program agency shall utilize the administrative enforcement procedures, including the hearing procedures, specified in Sections 25404.1.1 and 25404.1.2.
(a)A person or stationary source that violates this article, except for Sections 25536.6, 25536.7, and 25536.9, article shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of not one of the following amounts, as applicable:
(1)For a violation that occurs on or before December 31, 2018, not more than two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each day in which the violation occurs, unless paragraph (3) applies.
(2)For a violation that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, not more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials. occurs, unless paragraph (4) applies.
(3)For a violation committed knowingly after reasonable notice on or before December 31, 2018, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(4)For a violation committed knowingly on or after January 1, 2019, not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs.
(b)A person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, this article, except for Sections 25536.6, 25536.7, and 25536.9, shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of no more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the a violation of this article results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials. materials, in addition to the applicable amount require pursuant to subdivision (a).(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not apply for a violation of Section 25536.6, 25536.7, or 25536.9 that occurs on or after January 1, 2019.
(c)(d)When a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for a violation of this article, the unified program agency shall utilize the administrative enforcement procedures, including the hearing procedures, specified in Sections 25404.1.1 and 25404.1.2.
(a)A person or stationary source that violates this article article, except for Sections 25536.6, 25536.7, and 25536.9, shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) five thousand dollars ($5,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of the any hazardous materials.
(b)A person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, this article, except for Sections 25536.6, 25536.7, and 25536.9, shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of no more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials.
(b)(c)When a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for a violation of this article, the unified program agency shall utilize the administrative enforcement procedures, including the hearing procedures, specified in Sections 25404.1.1 and 25404.1.2.
(a)Any A person or stationary source that violates this article shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of not more than two twenty-five thousand dollars ($2,000) ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of the hazardous materials.
(b)Any person or stationary source that knowingly violates this article after reasonable notice of the violation shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each day in which the violation occurs. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials.(c)(b)When a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for a violation of this article, the unified program agency shall utilize the administrative enforcement procedures, including the hearing procedures, specified in Sections 25404.1.1 and 25404.1.2.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 308, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 7, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 22, 2018 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 21, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 28, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 27, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 26). |
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 7, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and JUD. |
| May 30, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 25, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 9, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (May 8). |
| May 3, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 2, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 11, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 12, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 21, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB3138 Muratsuchi By Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2018 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2018 | AB 3138 MURATSUCHI Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 3138
:
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 6/20/18
AYES: Wieckowski, Gaines, Hill, Lara, Skinner, Stern
NOES: Stone
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/26/18
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 52-22, 5/29/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Association of Environmental Health Administrators
DIGEST:
This bill restructures civil and administrative penalties for California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) violations.
ANALYSIS: Existing law provides the following under CalARP:
- Requires businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP).
- Establishes penalties for violations of CalARP as follows, but not limited to:
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $25,000 per day the violation occurs for cases where a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation.
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $2,000 per day the violation occurs for other cases where an entity violates CalARP.
- Requires a person or stationary source to be assessed the full cost of an emergency response and the cost of cleaning up of and disposing of the hazardous materials if the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including fire.
This bill restructures civil and administrative penalties for CalARP violations. Specifically, this bill:
- Raises the maximum civil or administrative penalty for CalARP violations from $2,000 to $5,000 per violation per day.
- Changes the criteria a CalARP violation must meet in order to be subject to a maximum penalty of $25,000 per violation per day such that any person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP is subject to this higher penalty.
- Exempts from CalARP penalty provisions in Health and Safety Code (HSC) Section 25540 violations that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
- Specifies that the changes in 1-3 only apply to violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
Background
- Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs): The Unified Program was created by SB 1082 (Calderon, Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993) to unify administration, permits, inspections, and enforcement of hazardous waste and hazardous materials management programs across the state. The Unified Program manages six programs: California's Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program (HWCA), the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP.
- CalARP: CalARP's purpose is to prevent accidental releases of substances that can cause serious harm to the public and the environment, to minimize the damage if releases do occur, and to satisfy community right-to-know laws. This is accomplished by requiring businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a RMP. An RMP is a detailed engineering analysis of the potential accident factors present at a stationary source and the mitigation measures that can be implemented to reduce this accident potential. The RMP contains safety information, a hazard review, operating procedures, training requirements, maintenance requirements, compliance audits, and incident investigation procedures. The CUPAs determine the level of detail in the RMPs, review the RMPs, conduct facility inspections, and provide public access to most of the information.
- Penalties for CUPA program violations: CUPAs assess administrative penalties based both on statutorily allowed ranges and on the severity and circumstances of the violation. CUPAs are required by law to take into consideration the "nature, circumstances, extent, and gravity of the violation, the violator's past and present efforts to prevent, abate, or clean up conditions posing a threat to the public health or safety or the environment, the violator's ability to pay the penalty, and the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community." Administrative penalties may be appealed, and each CUPA has an enforcement plan laying out enforcement procedures, including the criteria for which a case may be referred for prosecution. Civil and administrative penalties collected by the CUPAs are put towards enhancing program and enforcement capabilities.
CUPA programs use a variety of penalty schemes. For example, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act sets a maximum civil penalty of $5,000 per day of violation for first time violations and $10,000 per day of violation for subsequent violations while the HWCA simply sets the maximum allowable penalty at $70,000 per day of violation.
In the case of CalARP, current law requires that a stationary source cover the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations. Furthermore, if a violation was committed "knowingly after reasonable notice," penalties for that specific violation are set at a maximum of $25,000 per day. Otherwise, penalties for CalARP violations are set at a maximum of $2,000 per day per violation no matter how major the violation.
This bill does not change that a stationary source covers the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations and does not change that the maximum penalty for CalARP violations is $25,000 per day. However, it makes significant changes to the structure of CalARP violation penalties in HSC Section 25540. First, it clarifies that any penalties levied are in addition to the cost of emergency response and/or clean up. Second, it specifies that any violation committed "knowingly" would be subject to the maximum $25,000 per day penalty. Third, for all other violations, it increases the maximum penalty from $2,000 to $5,000 per day per violation. Finally, the bill exempts from HSC Section25540's penalty provisions sections of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner. The bill specifies that all of these changes will take effect for violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities, to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This bill raises penalties for these facilities that are consistent to recent increases to similar penalties to provide greater deterrence for violators. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities."
- Big problems, small fines: This bill allows the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty to be applied to a stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP. The problem with the current standard (which applies the lower maximum of $2,000 per violation per day unless a violation is committed "after reasonable notice") is that this lower penalty applies even for major violations associated with significant risk to workers and communities surrounding a stationary source. For example, the Chevron Richmond Refinery fire of 2012 was due to the failure of a weak, corroded pipe and the ineffective implementation of internal recommendations designed to prevent these failures. It endangered the lives of 18 workers and caused 15,000 people in the surrounding communities to seek medical attention. Had liability for the fire been pursued under CalARP according to existing statute, it is very likely that $2,000 per violation per day would have been the maximum allowable penalty.
Another problem with the current penalty scheme is that the lower penalty applies even if a stationary source has already violated CalARP. For example, CalARP violations were discovered at the same Praxair facility over three consecutive years, 2013, 2014, and 2015. Because different CalARP violations were discovered in 2014 than in 2013, the $2,000 maximum fine was applicable both years. However, in 2015, a repeat violation was discovered, and Praxair was issued a single $25,000 fine. Records available in the California Environmental Reporting System reflect no further releases in 2016, 2017, or, to date, in 2018.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators (source)
Coalition for Clean Air
County of Contra Costa
County of Los Angeles
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/29/18)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 52-22, 5/29/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cunningham, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Brough, Cervantes, Chávez, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Fong, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Salas, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooper, Dahle, Flora, Mullin
6/29/18 15:49:28
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 3138 (Author:Muratsuchi)
Version: May 25, 2018
Hearing Date: June 26, 2018
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
DESCRIPTION
This bill would increase the penalties for violation of the California Accidental Release Prevention program.
BACKGROUND
A “stationary source” means any buildings, structures, equipment, installations, or substance emitting stationary activities which belong to the same industrial group, which are located on one or more contiguous properties, which are under the control of the same person, and from which an accidental release of hazardous substances into the ambient air may occur.
The federal Clean Air Act (CAA) provides that owners and operators of stationary sources have a duty to identify hazards which may result from accidental releases of hazardous substances using appropriate hazard assessment techniques, to design and maintain a safe facility taking such steps as are necessary to prevent releases, and to minimize the consequences of accidental releases which do occur. As part of these duties, owners and operators of stationary sources are required to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP). An RMP is a document that is created by the owner or operator of a stationary source containing detailed information about the source and its policies and procedures. This includes information about the regulated substances that are stored at the site, the accident history of the source, its emergency response program, and its incident investigation. The goal of an RMP is to provide basic information that may be used by first responders in order to prevent or mitigate damage to the public health and safety and to the environment from a release or threatened release of a hazardous material and to satisfy federal and state Community Right-To-Know laws.
The California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) is the federal RMP program with additional state requirements, including an additional list of regulated substances and thresholds. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25531 et seq.) CalARP subjects persons and stationary sources that violate its provisions to administrative and civil penalties. This bill would increase those penalties. This bill passed out of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on a 6 to 1 vote.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law creates the California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) with the goal of reducing regulated hazardous substances accident risks and eliminating duplication of regulatory programs. CalARP implements the federal risk management program, as provided in Section 112(r) of the federal Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Section 7412 (r)) and as promulgated by the Federal Environmental Protection Agency, in the state, with certain amendments that are specific to the state. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25531 et seq.)
Existing law provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates this article after reasonable notice of the violation is guilty of a misdemeanor and may, upon conviction, be punished by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year. If the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of any hazardous materials. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540.1.)
Existing law provides that any person or stationary source who violates any rule or regulation, emission limitation, permit condition, order, fee requirement, filing requirement, duty to allow or carry out inspection or monitoring activities, or duty to allow entry, established pursuant to this article and for which delegation or approval of implementation and enforcement authority has been obtained pursuant to subsections (l) and (r) of Section 112 of the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Sections 7412(l) and 7412(r)) or the regulations adopted pursuant thereto, is strictly liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $10,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540.5.)
Existing law provides that any person or stationary source that violates CalARP shall be civilly or administratively liable to the unified program agency in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. If the person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation, they shall be civilly or administratively liable in an amount not to exceed $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540(a), (b).)
Existing law provides that if the above violations result in, or significantly contribute to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source shall also be assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of the hazardous materials. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540(a), (b).)
Existing law provides that when a unified program agency issues an enforcement order or assesses an administrative penalty, or both, for such violations, the unified program agency must utilize specified administrative enforcement procedures. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540(c).)
This bill would amend the penalty structure for violations of CalARP. It would provide that a person or stationary source that violates these provisions regarding hazardous materials management is liable for one of the following amounts, as applicable:
- for a violation that occurs on or before December 31, 2018, not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, unless the violation was committed knowingly after reasonable notice, in which case the penalty shall be not more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs; or
- for a violation that occurs on or after January 1, 2019, not more than $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, unless the violation was committed knowingly, in which case the penalty shall not be more than $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs.
Existing law requires a local implementing agency to develop an integrated alerting and notification system for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery. A petroleum refinery is required to immediately call the emergency 9-1-1 telephone number and notify the unified program agency, pursuant to Section 25510, in the event of an incident warranting the use of the integrated alerting and notification system. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25536.6.)
Existing law requires an owner or operator of a stationary source when contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25536.7.) If the stationary source claims an exemption from this requirement, it must file a complete copy of the contract that includes, at minimum, the identity of the contractor, the scope of the work covered by the contract, the date of execution of the contract, and the term of the contract. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25536.9.)
This bill would provide that these penalties do not apply to violations of Section 25536.6, 25536.7, or 25536.9 that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
AB 3138 will hold facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities.
2. Increasing the penalties for certain violations and eliminating them for others
Under current law, any person or stationary source that violates CalARP can be held civilly or administratively liable for up to $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. These penalties can be increased up to $25,000 per day if the person or stationary source knowingly violated CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 25540(a), (b).) In addition to this liability, if the above violations result in, or significantly contribute to, an emergency, including a fire, the person or stationary source is assessed the full cost of the county or city emergency response, as well as the cost of cleaning up and disposing of the hazardous materials.
This bill would amend these penalty provisions for violations of CalARP that occur after this bill would take effect, January 1, 2019. For all violations occurring before that date, the penalty provisions would remain unchanged. Under the new penalty structure, violations would be subject to a maximum amount of $5,000 for each day in which the violation occurs, increased from the current $2,000 penalty. However, if the violation is committed knowingly, the maximum amount is $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs.
Although this latter provision is set at the same amount as for current “knowing” violations, it makes a subtle, but important change. Under existing law, the enhanced penalty only applies “after reasonable notice.” That means that even for extremely significant violations where the responsible party knows it is violating CalARP, the increased penalty only applies once the regulating agency has provided the party notice of the very violation that the party knows it committed. This bill would subject violators to the increased penalty for knowing violations, without this additional, and arguably unnecessary, element.
This bill would provide moderate extensions of the existing penalties. These changes would further the important policy goals of the state to deter and prevent the accidental release of hazardous materials.
However, this bill would also remove existing penalties for future violations of specific sections of CalARP. It would provide that the penalties “shall not apply for a violation of Section 25536.6, 25536.7, or 25536.9 that occurs on or after January 1, 2019.” These sections involve the implementation of integrated alerting and notification systems for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery and requirements regarding contracting for certain work using a skilled and trained workforce. The author asserts that these provisions should be exempt because:
CalARP violations are specific to violations in each facility’s Risk Management Plan. The industry has asked to be exempted from enforcement from HSC Sections 25536.6, 25536.7, and 25536.9 as these sections relate to obligations on government to comply and the focus of CalARP penalties are on businesses that are not complying with Risk Management Plan requirements.
Support: Coalition for Clean Air; Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: California Association of Environmental Health Administrators
Related Pending Legislation: AB 1980 (Quirk, 2018) would extend the statute of limitations for violations of the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act from one year to five years from the date of discovery of the relevant violation. This bill is currently on the Senate Floor.
Prior Legislation: AB 305 (Nava, Ch. 429, Stats. 2009) extended from one to five years the statute of limitations for commencing civil enforcement actions in the case of violations of hazardous material release response plans, Chapter 6.95 (commencing with Section 25500) of the Health and Safety Code. It also increased penalties for violations.
Prior Vote:
Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 52, Noes 22)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 2)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 3138
Author: | Muratsuchi | ||
Version: | 5/25/2018 | Hearing Date: | 6/20/18 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Rachel Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Under the California Accidental Release Prevention Program (CalARP):
- Requires businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP).
- Establishes penalties for violations of CalARP as follows, but not limited to:
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $25,000 per day the violation occurs for cases where a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation.
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $2,000 per day the violation occurs for other cases where an entity violates CalARP.
- Requires a person or stationary source to be assessed the full cost of an emergency response and the cost of cleaning up of and disposing of the hazardous materials if the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including fire.
This bill: Restructures civil and administrative penalties for California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) violations. Specifically, this bill:
- Raises the maximum civil or administrative penalty for CalARP violations from $2,000 to $5,000 per violation per day.
- Changes the criteria a CalARP violation must meet in order to be subject to a maximum penalty of $25,000 per violation per day such that any person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP is subject to this higher penalty.
- Exempts from CalARP penalty provisions in Health and Safety Code (HSC) Section 25540 violations that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
- Specifies that the changes in 1-3 only apply to violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
Background
- Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs): The Unified Program was created by SB 1082 (Calderon), Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993, to unify administration, permits, inspections, and enforcement of hazardous waste and hazardous materials management programs across the state. The Unified Program manages six programs: California's Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program (HWCA), the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP.
- California Accidental Release Prevention (CalARP) program: CalARP's purpose is to prevent accidental releases of substances that can cause serious harm to the public and the environment, to minimize the damage if releases do occur, and to satisfy community right-to-know laws. This is accomplished by requiring businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP). An RMP is a detailed engineering analysis of the potential accident factors present at a stationary source and the mitigation measures that can be implemented to reduce this accident potential. The RMP contains safety information, a hazard review, operating procedures, training requirements, maintenance requirements, compliance audits, and incident investigation procedures. The CUPAs determine the level of detail in the RMPs, review the RMPs, conduct facility inspections, and provide public access to most of the information.
- Penalties for CUPA program violations: CUPAs assess administrative penalties based both on statutorily allowed ranges and on the severity and circumstances of the violation. CUPAs are required by law to take into consideration the "nature, circumstances, extent, and gravity of the violation, the violator's past and present efforts to prevent, abate, or clean up conditions posing a threat to the public health or safety or the environment, the violator's ability to pay the penalty, and the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community." Administrative penalties may be appealed, and each CUPA has an enforcement plan laying out enforcement procedures, including the criteria for which a case may be referred for prosecution. Civil and administrative penalties collected by the CUPAs are put towards enhancing program and enforcement capabilities.
CUPA programs use a variety of penalty schemes. For example, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act sets a maximum civil penalty of $5,000 per day of violation for first time violations and $10,000 per day of violation for subsequent violations while the HWCA simply sets the maximum allowable penalty at $70,000 per day of violation.
In the case of CalARP, current law requires that a stationary source cover the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations. Furthermore, if a violation was committed "knowingly after reasonable notice," penalties for that specific violation are set at a maximum of $25,000 per day. Otherwise, penalties for CalARP violations are set at a maximum of $2,000 per day per violation no matter how major the violation.
This bill does not change that a stationary source covers the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations and does not change that the maximum penalty for CalARP violations is $25,000 per day. However, it makes significant changes to the structure of CalARP violation penalties in HSC Section 25540. First, it clarifies that any penalties levied are in addition to the cost of emergency response and/or clean up. Second, it specifies that any violation committed "knowingly" would be subject to the maximum $25,000 per day penalty. Third, for all other violations, it increases the maximum penalty from $2,000 to $5,000 per day per violation. Finally, the bill exempts from HSC Section25540's penalty provisions sections of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner. The bill specifies that all of these changes will take effect for violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities, to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This bill raises penalties for these facilities that are consistent to recent increases to similar penalties to provide greater deterrence for violators. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities."
- Big problems, small fines: This bill would allow the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty to be applied to a stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP. The problem with the current standard (which applies the lower maximum of $2,000 per violation per day unless a violation is committed "after reasonable notice") is that this lower penalty applies even for major violations associated with significant risk to workers and communities surrounding a stationary source. For example, the Chevron Richmond Refinery fire of 2012 was due to the failure of a weak, corroded pipe and the ineffective implementation of internal recommendations designed to prevent these failures. It endangered the lives of 18 workers and caused 15,000 people in the surrounding communities to seek medical attention. Had liability for the fire been pursued under CalARP according to existing statute, it is very likely that $2,000 per violation per day would have been the maximum allowable penalty.
Another problem with the current penalty scheme is that the lower penalty applies even if a stationary source has already violated CalARP. For example, CalARP violations were discovered at the same Praxair facility over three consecutive years, 2013, 2014, and 2015. Because different CalARP violations were discovered in 2014 than in 2013, the $2,000 maximum fine was applicable both years. However, in 2015, a repeat violation was discovered, and Praxair was issued a single $25,000 fine. Records available in the California Environmental Reporting System reflect no further releases in 2016, 2017, or, to date, in 2018.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SOURCE:
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators (sponsor)
SUPPORT:
Coalition for Clean Air
County of Los Angeles
OPPOSITION:
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the sponsor, “AB 3138 is intended to hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities before releases, fires and other accidents arise. It will ensure that the enforcement agencies have an effective tool to ensure due diligence in the preparation and implementation of critical Risk Management Plans.”
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3138
Author:(Muratsuchi)
As Amended Ver:May 25, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Environmental Safety | 4-2 | Quirk, Friedman, Holden, Muratsuchi | Melendez, Brough |
Judiciary | 7-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Maienschein |
SUMMARY: Restructures civil and administrative penalties for California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) violations. Specifically, this bill:
- Raises the maximum civil or administrative penalty for CalARP violations from $2,000 to $5,000 per violation per day.
- Changes the criteria a CalARP violation must meet in order to be subject to a maximum penalty of $25,000 per violation per day such that any person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP is subject to this higher penalty.
- Exempts from CalARP penalty provisions in Health and Safety Code (HSC) Section 25540 violations that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
- Specifies that the changes in 1-3 only apply to violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
EXISTING LAW:
- Implements, through the creation of CalARP, federal Clean Air Act (CAA) amendments enacted in 1990 for the prevention of accidental releases of hazardous substances in the state.
- Requires a person or stationary source to establish and implement a Risk Management Plan (RMP) for emergency response to a release or threatened release of a hazardous material if the business meets certain criteria.
- Establishes penalties for violations of CalARP as follows, but not limited to:
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $25,000 per day the violation occurs for cases where a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation.
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $2,000 per day the violation occurs for other cases where an entity violates CalARP.
- Requires a person or stationary source to be assessed the full cost of an emergency response and the cost of cleaning up of and disposing of the hazardous materials if the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including fire.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities, to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This bill raises penalties for these facilities that are consistent to recent increases to similar penalties to provide greater deterrence for violators. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities."
Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs): The Unified Program was created by SB 1082 (Calderon), Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993, to unify administration, permits, inspections, and enforcement of hazardous waste and hazardous materials management programs across the state. The Unified Program manages six programs: California's Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program (HWCA), the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP.
California Accidental Release Prevention (CalARP) program: CalARP's purpose is to prevent accidental releases of substances that can cause serious harm to the public and the environment, to minimize the damage if releases do occur, and to satisfy community right-to-know laws. This is accomplished by requiring businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP). An RMP is a detailed engineering analysis of the potential accident factors present at a stationary source and the mitigation measures that can be implemented to reduce this accident potential. The RMP contains safety information, a hazard review, operating procedures, training requirements, maintenance requirements, compliance audits, and incident investigation procedures. The CUPAs determine the level of detail in the RMPs, review the RMPs, conduct facility inspections, and provide public access to most of the information.
Penalties for CUPA program violations: CUPAs assess administrative penalties based both on statutorily allowed ranges and on the severity and circumstances of the violation. CUPAs are required by law to take into consideration the "nature, circumstances, extent, and gravity of the violation, the violator's past and present efforts to prevent, abate, or clean up conditions posing a threat to the public health or safety or the environment, the violator's ability to pay the penalty, and the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community." Administrative penalties may be appealed, and each CUPA has an enforcement plan laying out enforcement procedures, including the criteria for which a case may be referred for prosecution. Civil and administrative penalties collected by the CUPAs are put towards enhancing program and enforcement capabilities.
CUPA programs use a variety of penalty schemes. For example, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act sets a maximum civil penalty of $5,000 per day of violation for first time violations and $10,000 per day of violation for subsequent violations while the HWCA simply sets the maximum allowable penalty at $70,000 per day of violation.
In the case of CalARP, current law requires that a stationary source cover the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations. Furthermore, if a violation was committed "knowingly after reasonable notice," penalties for that specific violation are set at a maximum of $25,000 per day. Otherwise, penalties for CalARP violations are set at a maximum of $2,000 per day per violation no matter how major the violation.
This bill does not change that a stationary source covers the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations and does not change that the maximum penalty for CalARP violations is $25,000 per day. However, it makes significant changes to the structure of CalARP violation penalties in HSC Section 25540. First, it clarifies that any penalties levied are in addition to the cost of emergency response and/or clean up. Second, it specifies that any violation committed "knowingly" would be subject to the maximum $25,000 per day penalty. Third, for all other violations, it increases the maximum penalty from $2,000 to $5,000 per day per violation. Finally, the bill exempts from HSC Section25540's penalty provisions sections of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner. The bill specifies that all of these changes will take effect for violations that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
Big problems, small fines: This bill would allow the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty to be applied to a stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP. The problem with the current standard (which applies the lower maximum of $2,000 per violation per day unless a violation is committed "after reasonable notice") is that this lower penalty applies even for major violations associated with significant risk to workers and communities surrounding a stationary source. For example, the Chevron Richmond Refinery fire of 2012 was due to the failure of a weak, corroded pipe and the ineffective implementation of internal recommendations designed to prevent these failures. It endangered the lives of 18 workers and caused 15,000 people in the surrounding communities to seek medical attention. Had liability for the fire been pursued under CalARP according to existing statute, it is very likely that $2,000 per violation per day would have been the maximum allowable penalty.
Another problem with the current penalty scheme is that the lower penalty applies even if a stationary source has already violated CalARP. For example, CalARP violations were discovered at the same Praxair facility over three consecutive years, 2013, 2014, and 2015. Because different CalARP violations were discovered in 2014 than in 2013, the $2,000 maximum fine was applicable both years. However, in 2015, a repeat violation was discovered, and Praxair was issued a single $25,000 fine. Records available in the California Environmental Reporting System reflect no further releases in 2016, 2017, or, to date, in 2018.
Knowingly violates: This bill expands the contexts in which the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty may apply by changing the knowledge standard to "known." For example, given that a stationary source develops its own RMP, they presumably know what is in the plan and therefore could be subject to the higher penalty for deviation from it. However, this maximum will not be sought in all cases where it is statutorily permissible because CUPAs take into account the severity and circumstances of any violations.
Analysis Prepared by: Amy Gilson / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003016
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3138
Author:(Muratsuchi)
As Amended Ver:May 2, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Environmental Safety | 4-2 | Quirk, Friedman, Holden, Muratsuchi | Melendez, Brough |
Judiciary | 7-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Maienschein |
SUMMARY: Restructures civil and administrative penalties for California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) violations. Specifically, this bill:
- Raises the maximum civil or administrative penalty for CalARP violations from $2,000 to $5,000 per violation per day.
- Changes the criteria a CalARP violation must meet in order to be subject to a maximum penalty of $25,000 per violation per day so that any person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, CalARP is subject to this higher penalty.
- Exempts from certain CalARP penalty provisions violations that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency's integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
EXISTING LAW:
- Implements, through the creation of CalARP, federal Clean Air Act (CAA) amendments enacted in 1990 for the prevention of accidental releases of hazardous substances in the state.
- Requires a person or stationary source to establish and implement a Risk Management Plan (RMP) for emergency response to a release or threatened release of a hazardous material if the business meets certain criteria.
- Establishes penalties for violations of CalARP as follows, but not limited to:
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $25,000 per day the violation occurs for cases where a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation.
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $2,000 per day the violation occurs for other cases where an entity violates CalARP.
- Sets misdemeanor criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year of imprisonment, if a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation.
- Requires a person or stationary source to be assessed the full cost of an emergency response and the cost of cleaning up of and disposing of the hazardous materials if the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including fire.
- Sets civil or criminal liability at up to $10,000 for each day of violation for violations of CalARP related to specific sections of the CAA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities, to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This bill raises penalties for these facilities that are consistent to recent increases to similar penalties to provide greater deterrence for violators. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities."
Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs): The Unified Program was created by SB 1082 (Calderon, Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993), to unify administration, permits, inspections, and enforcement of hazardous waste and hazardous materials management programs across the state. The Unified Program manages six programs: California's Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program (HWCA), the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP.
California Accidental Release Prevention (CalARP) program: CalARP's purpose is to prevent accidental releases of substances that can cause serious harm to the public and the environment, to minimize the damage if releases do occur, and to satisfy community right-to-know laws. This is accomplished by requiring businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a Risk Management Plan (RMP). An RMP is a detailed engineering analysis of the potential accident factors present at a stationary source and the mitigation measures that can be implemented to reduce this accident potential. The RMP contains safety information, a hazard review, operating procedures, training requirements, maintenance requirements, compliance audits, and incident investigation procedures. The CUPAs determine the level of detail in the RMPs, review the RMPs, conduct facility inspections, and provide public access to most of the information.
Penalties for CUPA program violations: CUPAs assess administrative penalties based both on statutorily allowed ranges and on the severity and circumstances of the violation. CUPAs are required by law to take into consideration the "nature, circumstances, extent, and gravity of the violation, the violator's past and present efforts to prevent, abate, or clean up conditions posing a threat to the public health or safety or the environment, the violator's ability to pay the penalty, and the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community." Administrative penalties may be appealed, and each CUPA has an enforcement plan laying out enforcement procedures, including the criteria for which a case may be referred for prosecution. Civil and administrative penalties collected by the CUPAs are put towards enhancing program and enforcement capabilities.
CUPA programs use a variety of penalty schemes. For example, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act sets a maximum civil penalty of $5,000 per day of violation for first time violations and $10,000 per day of violation for subsequent violations while the HWCA simply sets the maximum allowable penalty at $70,000 per day of violation.
In the case of CalARP, current law requires that, in addition to any penalties levied, a stationary source covers the cost of emergency response and/or clean-up resulting from their CalARP violations. This provision is not changed by this bill. Furthermore, if a violation was committed "knowingly after reasonable notice," penalties for that specific violation are set at a maximum of $25,000 per day. Otherwise, penalties for CalARP violations are set at a maximum of $2,000 ($5,000 under this bill) per day per violation no matter how major the violation. This bill does not change the maximum penalty for CalARP violations; they remain $25,000 per day of violation.
Big problems, small fines: This bill would allow the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty to be applied to a stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known it was violating, CalARP. The problem with the current standard (which applies the lower maximum of $2,000 per violation per day unless a violation is committed "after reasonable notice") is that this lower penalty applies even for major violations associated with significant risk to workers and communities surrounding a stationary source. For example, the Chevron Richmond Refinery fire of 2012 was due to the failure of a weak, corroded pipe and the ineffective implementation of internal recommendations designed to prevent these failures. It endangered the lives of eighteen workers and caused 15,000 people in the surrounding communities to seek medical attention. Had liability for the fire been pursued under CalARP according to existing statute, it is very likely that $2,000 per violation per day would have been the maximum allowable penalty.
Another problem with the current penalty scheme is that the lower penalty applies even if a stationary source has already violated CalARP. For example, CalARP violations were discovered at the same Praxair facility over three consecutive years, 2013, 2014, and 2015. Because different CalARP violations were discovered in 2014 than in 2013, the $2,000 maximum fine was applicable both years. However, in 2015, a repeat violation was discovered, and Praxair was issued a single $25,000 fine. Records available in the California Environmental Reporting System reflect no further releases in 2016, 2017, or, to date, in 2018.
Known or should have known: This bill expands the contexts in which the maximum $25,000 per violation per day penalty may apply by changing the knowledge standard to "known, or should have known." For example, given that a stationary source develops its own RMP, they presumably know what is in the plan and therefore could be subject to the higher penalty for deviation from it. However, this maximum will not be sought in all cases where it is statutorily permissible because CUPAs take into account the severity and circumstances of any violations.
Analysis Prepared by: Amy Gilson / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0002868
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3138
Author:(Muratsuchi) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2018
SUBJECT: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE ADMINISTRATIVE AND CIVIL PENALTIES FOR A VIOLATION OF THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE INCREASED FROM $2,000 TO $5,000 PER DAY?
- SHOULD A PARTY BE SUBJECT TO THE $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY IF THEY KNOW OR SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT THEY WERE VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM?
- SHOULD THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PARTY BE PROVIDED REASONABLE NOTICE OF A VIOLATION BEFORE A $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY CAN BE ASSESSED FOR VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE ELIMINATED?
SYNOPSIS
To improve adherence with existing standards for the production, management, and storage of hazardous substances, this bill seeks to modify the penalty levels and liability standards for violations of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program. The California Accidental Release Prevention Program requires stationary sources that produce or handle a specified level of a substance deemed hazardous by existing state and federal law to develop a risk management plan designed to prevent the accidental release of the hazardous substances into the environment. Should a person or stationary source fail to adhere to the existing law or the requirements of the risk management plan, they may be assessed a penalty. As the author notes, many of these stationary source facilities are located in highly urbanized areas where an accidental release of a hazardous substance would pose a significant and immediate risk to public health and environmental safety.
To increase compliance with the California Accidental Release Prevention Program, this bill proposes increasing the penalty for any violation from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day, eliminating the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice before a $25,000 penalty can be imposed, and permitting the imposition of the maximum penalty anytime a person or stationary source knew or should have known about a violation. The author justifies this increase by highlighting the prior incidents at several stationary source facilities, including several facilities found to be repeatedly violating their own risk management plans. This measure is sponsored by the California Association of Environmental Health Associates on behalf of the Certified Unified Program Agencies. The California Association of Environmental Health Associates contend that this measure is a modest and overdue adjustment of existing penalty levels given that the existing statute serves to mitigate risk in situations involving hazardous substances, and is necessary to protect workers and surrounding communities from fires, accidental releases, and other dangers that arise when stationary sources mishandle hazardous substances. Meanwhile, in opposition to this bill, a coalition of manufacturing and refining organizations contend that existing law provides sufficient deterrence to bad actors, that the known or should have known standard imposed by this bill is inappropriate for a regulatory enforcement statute, and that it is not sensible given the nature of the industry and the existing regulatory approach to managing hazardous materials. This bill was previously heard in the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials where it was approved by a 4-2 vote.
SUMMARY: Increases the minimum daily civil penalty for a violation of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program (CalARP), modifies standards for imposing a maximum daily penalty for a violation of CalARP, and eliminates the requirement that a party be provided reasonable notice of a violation before the maximum daily penalty can be assessed. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases the daily penalty for a person or stationary source that commits any violation of CalARP from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known they were violating, CalARP may be subject to a maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Eliminates the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice of the violation before that person or stationary source can be assessed the maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Provides that the maximum penalties that apply to persons or stationary sources do not apply to CalARP violations that are the result of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system, and apprenticeship workforce standards and reporting for contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source.
EXISTING LAW:
- The federal Clean Air Act requires the owners and operators of stationary sources producing, processing, handling, or storing hazardous substances to take steps to prevent the accidental release of those substances and provides owners and operators of stationary sources have a general duty to identify hazards which may result from such releases using appropriate hazard assessment techniques, to design and maintain a safe facility taking such steps as are necessary to prevent releases, and to minimize the consequences of accidental releases which do occur. (42 U.S.C. Section 7412(r).)
- Defines “stationary source” as any buildings, structures, equipment, installations, or substance emitting stationary activities which belong to the same industrial group, which are located on one or more contiguous properties, which are under the control of the same person (or persons under common control), and from which an accidental release may occur. (40 C.F.R Section 68.3.)
- Authorizes the creation of CalARP to carry out the Clean Air Act’s requirements of 1), above and apply state management requirements to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances. (Health and Safety Code Section 25531.)
- Requires a person or stationary source that handles a hazardous material or a mixture containing a hazardous material that has a quantity at any one time during the reporting year that is equal to, or greater than, 55 gallons for materials that are liquids, 500 pounds for solids, or 200 cubic feet for compressed gas to adopt a risk management plan. (Health and Safety Code Section 22507 (a)(1)(A).)
- Provides that in addition to the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (CalOES), the CalARP program is managed by local agencies designated as a Certified Unified Program Agency (CUPA). (Health and Safety Code 25532 (b).)
- Provides that a CUPA must be certified by the Secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency. (Health and Safety Code Section 25501 (e).)
- Requires the local CUPA inspect every stationary source required to be registered under CalARP at least once every three years to determine whether the stationary source is in compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25537.)
- Provides that within 15 days of a CUPA’s certification of a person or stationary source’s risk management plan, CUPA shall post the risk management plan for public review and comment for a period of at least 45 days. Requires that a notice briefly describing and stating that the risk management plan is available for public review at a certain location be placed in a daily local newspaper or placed on an administering agency’s Internet web site, and mailed to interested persons and organizations. (Health and Safety Code Section 25535.2.)
- Requires the CUPA to implement an integrated alerting and notification system for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.6.)
- Requires an owner or operator of a stationary source when contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.7.)
- Provides that a stationary source claiming an exemption from the requirements of 10), above to file with the CUPA a complete copy of the contract that includes, at minimum, the identity of the contractor, the scope of the work covered by the contract, the date of execution of the contract, and the term of the contract. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.9.)
- Provides that person or stationary source that violates CalARP shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (a).)
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount not to exceed $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (b).)
- Provides that misdemeanor criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year of imprisonment, may apply if a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540.1.)
- Provides criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year imprisonment and/or not more than $25,000 per day of violation for first time violations or up to three years imprisonment and/or fines within the range $2,000 to $50,000 for each day of violation for convictions based on violations committed after a first conviction, for a person or stationary source who knowingly makes a false materials statement on documents maintained for the purpose of CalARP, who destroys or alters such documents, or who carries out other specified actions related to the integrity of information maintained for compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.)
- Prohibits civil and criminal enforcement actions from being brought for the same CalARP offenses. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to modify a statutory provision that placed significant procedural hurdles on a CUPA’s ability to impose the maximum daily penalty for CalARP violations, even in the event of egregious conduct by a stationary source, and generally improve accountability and management of facilities that handle highly flammable or hazardous substances. In support of this measure, the author notes that the Legislature has taken steps in recent years to improve the risk management standards imposed by CalARP; however, enforcement remedies have not been modified. The author states:
Unfortunately, stricter regulations without adequate penalties for non-compliance will result in less effective enforcement of the requirements. AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities.
Regulating hazardous waste and hazardous materials in California. Existing law provides a unified regulatory structure for six areas of hazardous materials management in California to ensure that these materials are managed safely. The overall structure provides for local regulatory control with state oversight. Accordingly, subject to the approval and oversight of the California Environmental Protection Agency, CUPAs are responsible for overseeing compliance with California’s Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program, the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP. Currently, there are 81 CUPAs operating in California.
Specific to this bill, and CalARP, the CUPAs work in conjunction with CalOES to review, approve, and ensure compliance with the risk management plans developed by stationary sources that handle quantities of hazardous substances that existing law deems a risk. Typically, CalARP applies to chemical manufacturers, chemical processors, and hydrocarbon refiners. The overall purpose of CalARP and the risk management plans is to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances into the environment, minimize the impact if such releases do occur, and ensure that the public is properly notified of risks associated with hazardous substances and their release. The risk management plan includes a detailed engineering analysis of the facility, and requires a stationary source to identify all regulated hazardous materials at the site, provide general accidental release prevention and emergency response plans, provide chemical specific-management plans, conduct offsite consequence assessments involving potential releases, and provide a five-year accident history and any improvements to the risk management plan developed as a result of an accident.
Overall the risk management plans are designed to ensure the safe operation of stationary sources and provide local first responders and emergency services officials with the information necessary to safely handle an emergency or accidental release at a facility.
Existing law significantly limits CUPAs’ ability to impose maximum daily penalties for violating the law. Existing law provides that a stationary source can be administratively or civilly liable for up to $2,000 per day for any violation of CalARP, no matter how minor. Existing law also provides that a person or stationary source may be held liable for civil or administrative penalties of up to $25,000 per day if they are knowingly violating CalARP and are provided reasonable notice of such a violation. The reasonable notice provisions impose significant, and somewhat nonsensical, barriers to the imposition of the maximum daily penalty.
As applied to CalARP, the “knowingly violates” standard of existing law requires a stationary source to be acutely aware of the situation that constitutes a violation of CalARP before a $25,000 can be imposed. Furthermore, the existing law also requires a CUPA to notify the stationary source of such a violation, even if the stationary source already knows they are violating the law, and subsequently wait a “reasonable” period of time after that notice before imposing a $25,000 penalty. The notice provisions apply even if the violation could be deemed a violation of the stationary source’s own risk management plan and in cases of significant violations of the law, for example an explosion at a refinery or large-release at a chemical plant. The notice provisions essentially preclude the CUPAs from imposing maximum daily penalties, even in egregious situations.
Despite risk management efforts, significant incidents do occur. The author notes that despite California’s strict regulation of stationary sources containing hazardous materials accidents do occur, and frequently result in significant environmental impacts. In recent memory, the most widely publicized incident occurred when oil vapor escaped from a ruptured pipeline at Chevron’s refining facility in Richmond, California. When the flammable gas ignited, as it is wont to do, the ensuing explosion and fire burned for five hours, caused 15,000 local residents to seek medical attention for breathing problems and related medical issues, and injured six Chevron employees. When the Chemical Safety Board and the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health investigated the incident, they determined that the explosion was caused by a corroded pipe that should have been identified had Chevron’s own internal protocols been implemented properly. Because the fire was extinguished quickly, it is unlikely the existing law would have permitted a recovery by a CUPA above $2,000, as the fire was out and violation remedied well before the time period necessary for the CUPA to provide Chevron reasonable notice that the Chevron’s refinery had exploded in violation of the law.
Under the existing law, even repeat offenders may escape significant liability. As noted in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, industrial gas manufacturer Praxair was involved in three separate releases of highly toxic anhydrous ammonia between 2013 and 2015. The first two releases involved two different violations, including failure to properly notify local authorities of the release. Because both releases were stopped prior to the CUPA’s issuance of a notice, Praxair could only be assessed penalties of $2,000. Only after Praxair, again, failed to notify local authorities of a release in 2015 was the company fined $25,000 because the company knew that they must report the violation based on the notice provided in issuing the company a fine for the 2013 release.
This bill. To remedy the existing issue whereby a stationary source must be provided notice of a violation that it is, presumably, aware of, prior to imposing higher penalties, this bill proposes to delete the notice requirement from existing law. Further, the bill proposes modifying the existing “knowingly violates” standard for the maximum penalty and instead permits a CUPA to impose a maximum penalty any time a person or stationary source knowingly violates the law, or should have known their conduct was a violation. The author notes that this provision is designed to prevent a person or stationary source from avoiding higher penalties as a result of their own ignorance of the law, their risk management plan, or the conditions at a facility containing hazardous substances. Finally, the bill would increase the maximum penalty for all violations from $2,000 to $5,000, to deter repeat offenders like Praxair, and exempt from the penalty provisions violations of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
The risks associated with hazardous materials management justify a range of penalties. The existing statutory scheme and the modifications envisioned by this bill create strict liability for all stationary sources for any violation of the section. The CUPAs indicate that basic violations of the statute, for example a failure to properly post emergency contact information or to perform a routine inspection as provided in the risk management plan, would be subject to the lower tier penalty, $5000 as proposed by this bill. They suggest that these violations should not occur at any stationary source, but nonetheless, may occur due to an inadvertent oversight and do not cause serious harm.
Conversely, unlike minor violations which impose a strict liability standard, the statutory scheme envisions that serious violations require a higher penalty. The existing law, notwithstanding the notice language discussed above, requires a person or stationary source to knowingly violate the law before the $25,000 penalty applies. Although any stationary source should presumably know they are failing to comply with the law and their own risk management plans, the CUPAs indicate that the higher penalty is reserved for serious violations, for example intentionally and repeatedly mishandling hazardous substances in an attempt to save costs or time. In these cases, especially if a release of hazardous substances were to accompany violations, the CUPAs suggest the higher penalty should apply.
This bill would modify the knowledge standard to expand enforcement. As noted, and notwithstanding the notice provisions, the existing law requires a person or stationary source to “knowingly violate” CalARP’s requirements before the higher penalty can be imposed. Under California law, such an actual knowledge standard requires that “circumstances are such that the defendant "must have known” and not “should have known” of a violation. (Romero v. Superior Court (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1068, 1082.) This bill seeks to permit the CUPA to impose the higher penalty if the stationary source not only had actual knowledge of a violation but if it “should have known it was violating the law.” This known or should have known standard is not applied elsewhere in the law related to CalARP or most other hazardous substance laws within the Health and Safety Code. However, the standard proposed by this bill represents a duty of care typically applied in tort liability.
The common law tort most similar to this bill would likely be premises liability. As much like the issues covered by this bill, premises liability involves unsafe conditions at a location controlled by the person being assessed the penalty. California courts have held that the know or should have known standard means that actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition is a key to establishing liability. As applied in the business context to retailers, California courts have noted that the premises owner, similar to the stationary source under this bill, “must have either actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition or have been able by the exercise of ordinary care to discover the condition.” (Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200, 1206.)
In opposition to this measure, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups contend that this bill should only impose the higher penalty when a stationary source has actual knowledge of a violation of the law. They note that “the bill eliminates the distinction between "knowing" violations, or violations where the person "should have known," and those inadvertent violations which may have been of less serious consequence, including paper violations,” and that, “the coalition supported the increase of penalties from $2,000 to $5,000” which was contingent upon a distinction between negligent violations, and knowing violations.
The opposition’s contention is not without merit. Due to the high degree of regulation imposed on most industries that may cause environmental harm, negligence standards are not usually imposed. Furthermore, the standard of care that would be imposed on a stationary source in applying the “should have known” standard would likely be the stationary source’s own risk management plan. Given that the plan is required by law and produced by the stationary source, it is likely that any violation of the plan would meet the knowing standard, as the stationary source presumably knows what is in its own documents.
In response to the opposition, the author suggests that occasions may occur where the stationary source follows the letter but not the spirit of the plan, and such actions should result in a more serious violation. For example, utilizing the facts of the Chevron refinery explosion, a stationary source may be following their risk management plan conducting all tests of pipelines on a regular schedule and yet may fail to detect corrosion that subsequently resulted in an explosion. In the event that the stationary source missed the corrosion because they failed to properly train staff to conduct inspection or applied inappropriate techniques, they should have discovered the violation but for their own mistake. In such a scenario, a “should have known” standard would allow an adjudicatory body to assess facts underpinning the validity of imposing a $25,000 per day penalty better than a strict actual knowledge standard would.
Although the standard proposed by this bill is not typically applied to regulatory enforcement statutes, it is not unreasonable in light of the significant harm a violation of CalARP may inflict on the communities surrounding a stationary source in the event of a serious release. While the author may wish to continue working with the opposition as this bill progresses to develop a standard all parties are comfortable with, the current imposition of a known or should have known standard on violations of CalARP is not inappropriate.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, the California Association of Environmental Health Administrators notes that since CUPAs started implementing CalARP, the number of inspections of facilities has increased dramatically and accidental releases have significantly decreased. They note:
AB 3138 is intended to hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities BEFORE releases, fires and other accidents arise. It will ensure that the enforcement agencies have an effective tool to ensure due diligence in the preparation and implementation of critical Risk Management Plans.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups note that, while recent amendments to the bill are appreciated, they still oppose the current known or should have known standard for imposing heightened fine amounts. They note:
By eliminating the distinction between intentional and unintentional violations, AB 3138 treats all violations of law identically. We fail to understand the justification for this radical departure from well-established norms of jurisprudence. Our organizations object to the notion that minor violations that result from simple error should be treated similarly to intentional violations.
Furthermore, they believe the bill is unnecessary and that existing law provides sufficient incentive to deter malfeasance on the part of stationary sources.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators (sponsor)
Opposition
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Chemical Industry Council of California
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3138
Author:(Muratsuchi) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2018
SUBJECT: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE ADMINISTRATIVE AND CIVIL PENALTIES FOR A VIOLATION OF THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE INCREASED FROM $2,000 TO $5,000 PER DAY?
- SHOULD A PARTY BE SUBJECT TO THE $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY IF THEY KNOW OR SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT THEY WERE VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM?
- SHOULD THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PARTY BE PROVIDED REASONABLE NOTICE OF A VIOLATION BEFORE A $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY CAN BE ASSESSED FOR VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE ELIMINATED?
SYNOPSIS
To improve adherence with existing standards for the production, management, and storage of hazardous substances, this bill seeks to modify the penalty levels and liability standards for violations of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program. The California Accidental Release Prevention Program requires stationary sources that produce or handle a specified level of a substance deemed hazardous by existing state and federal law to develop a risk management plan designed to prevent the accidental release of the hazardous substances into the environment. Should a person or stationary source fail to adhere to the existing law or the requirements of the risk management plan, they may be assessed a penalty. As the author notes, many of these stationary source facilities are located in highly urbanized areas where an accidental release of a hazardous substance would pose a significant and immediate risk to public health and environmental safety.
To increase compliance with the California Accidental Release Prevention Program, this bill proposes increasing the penalty for any violation from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day, eliminating the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice before a $25,000 penalty can be imposed, and permitting the imposition of the maximum penalty anytime a person or stationary source knew or should have known about a violation. The author justifies this increase by highlighting the prior incidents at several stationary source facilities, including several facilities found to be repeatedly violating their own risk management plans. This measure is sponsored by the California Association of Environmental Health Associates on behalf of the Certified Unified Program Agencies. The California Association of Environmental Health Associates contend that this measure is a modest and overdue adjustment of existing penalty levels given that the existing statute serves to mitigate risk in situations involving hazardous substances, and is necessary to protect workers and surrounding communities from fires, accidental releases, and other dangers that arise when stationary sources mishandle hazardous substances. Meanwhile, in opposition to this bill, a coalition of manufacturing and refining organizations contend that existing law provides sufficient deterrence to bad actors, that the known or should have known standard imposed by this bill is inappropriate for a regulatory enforcement statute, and that it is not sensible given the nature of the industry and the existing regulatory approach to managing hazardous materials. This bill was previously heard in the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials where it was approved by a 4-2 vote.
SUMMARY: Increases the minimum daily civil penalty for a violation of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program (CalARP), modifies standards for imposing a maximum daily penalty for a violation of CalARP, and eliminates the requirement that a party be provided reasonable notice of a violation before the maximum daily penalty can be assessed. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases the daily penalty for a person or stationary source that commits any violation of CalARP from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known they were violating, CalARP may be subject to a maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Eliminates the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice of the violation before that person or stationary source can be assessed the maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Provides that the maximum penalties that apply to persons or stationary sources do not apply to CalARP violations that are the result of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system, and apprenticeship workforce standards and reporting for contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source.
EXISTING LAW:
- The federal Clean Air Act requires the owners and operators of stationary sources producing, processing, handling, or storing hazardous substances to take steps to prevent the accidental release of those substances and provides owners and operators of stationary sources have a general duty to identify hazards which may result from such releases using appropriate hazard assessment techniques, to design and maintain a safe facility taking such steps as are necessary to prevent releases, and to minimize the consequences of accidental releases which do occur. (42 U.S.C. Section 7412(r).)
- Defines “stationary source” as any buildings, structures, equipment, installations, or substance emitting stationary activities which belong to the same industrial group, which are located on one or more contiguous properties, which are under the control of the same person (or persons under common control), and from which an accidental release may occur. (40 C.F.R Section 68.3.)
- Authorizes the creation of CalARP to carry out the Clean Air Act’s requirements of 1), above and apply state management requirements to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances. (Health and Safety Code Section 25531.)
- Requires a person or stationary source that handles a hazardous material or a mixture containing a hazardous material that has a quantity at any one time during the reporting year that is equal to, or greater than, 55 gallons for materials that are liquids, 500 pounds for solids, or 200 cubic feet for compressed gas to adopt a risk management plan. (Health and Safety Code Section 25507 (a)(1)(A).)
- Provides that in addition to the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (CalOES), the CalARP program is managed by local agencies designated as a Certified Unified Program Agency (CUPA). (Health and Safety Code 25532 (b).)
- Provides that a CUPA must be certified by the Secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency. (Health and Safety Code Section 25501 (e).)
- Requires the local CUPA inspect every stationary source required to be registered under CalARP at least once every three years to determine whether the stationary source is in compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25537.)
- Provides that within 15 days of a CUPA’s certification of a person or stationary source’s risk management plan, CUPA shall post the risk management plan for public review and comment for a period of at least 45 days. Requires that a notice briefly describing and stating that the risk management plan is available for public review at a certain location be placed in a daily local newspaper or placed on an administering agency’s Internet web site, and mailed to interested persons and organizations. (Health and Safety Code Section 25535.2.)
- Requires the CUPA to implement an integrated alerting and notification system for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.6.)
- Requires an owner or operator of a stationary source when contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.7.)
- Provides that a stationary source claiming an exemption from the requirements of 10), above to file with the CUPA a complete copy of the contract that includes, at minimum, the identity of the contractor, the scope of the work covered by the contract, the date of execution of the contract, and the term of the contract. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.9.)
- Provides that person or stationary source that violates CalARP shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (a).)
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount not to exceed $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (b).)
- Provides that misdemeanor criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year of imprisonment, may apply if a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540.1.)
- Provides criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year imprisonment and/or not more than $25,000 per day of violation for first time violations or up to three years imprisonment and/or fines within the range $2,000 to $50,000 for each day of violation for convictions based on violations committed after a first conviction, for a person or stationary source who knowingly makes a false materials statement on documents maintained for the purpose of CalARP, who destroys or alters such documents, or who carries out other specified actions related to the integrity of information maintained for compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.)
- Prohibits civil and criminal enforcement actions from being brought for the same CalARP offenses. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to modify a statutory provision that placed significant procedural hurdles on a CUPA’s ability to impose the maximum daily penalty for CalARP violations, even in the event of egregious conduct by a stationary source, and generally improve accountability and management of facilities that handle highly flammable or hazardous substances. In support of this measure, the author notes that the Legislature has taken steps in recent years to improve the risk management standards imposed by CalARP; however, enforcement remedies have not been modified. The author states:
Unfortunately, stricter regulations without adequate penalties for non-compliance will result in less effective enforcement of the requirements. AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities.
Regulating hazardous waste and hazardous materials in California. Existing law provides a unified regulatory structure for six areas of hazardous materials management in California to ensure that these materials are managed safely. The overall structure provides for local regulatory control with state oversight. Accordingly, subject to the approval and oversight of the California Environmental Protection Agency, CUPAs are responsible for overseeing compliance with California’s Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program, the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP. Currently, there are 81 CUPAs operating in California.
Specific to this bill, and CalARP, the CUPAs work in conjunction with CalOES to review, approve, and ensure compliance with the risk management plans developed by stationary sources that handle quantities of hazardous substances that existing law deems a risk. Typically, CalARP applies to chemical manufacturers, chemical processors, and hydrocarbon refiners. The overall purpose of CalARP and the risk management plans is to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances into the environment, minimize the impact if such releases do occur, and ensure that the public is properly notified of risks associated with hazardous substances and their release. The risk management plan includes a detailed engineering analysis of the facility, and requires a stationary source to identify all regulated hazardous materials at the site, provide general accidental release prevention and emergency response plans, provide chemical specific-management plans, conduct offsite consequence assessments involving potential releases, and provide a five-year accident history and any improvements to the risk management plan developed as a result of an accident.
Overall the risk management plans are designed to ensure the safe operation of stationary sources and provide local first responders and emergency services officials with the information necessary to safely handle an emergency or accidental release at a facility.
Existing law significantly limits CUPAs’ ability to impose maximum daily penalties for violating the law. Existing law provides that a stationary source can be administratively or civilly liable for up to $2,000 per day for any violation of CalARP, no matter how minor. Existing law also provides that a person or stationary source may be held liable for civil or administrative penalties of up to $25,000 per day if they are knowingly violating CalARP and are provided reasonable notice of such a violation. The reasonable notice provisions impose significant, and somewhat nonsensical, barriers to the imposition of the maximum daily penalty.
As applied to CalARP, the “knowingly violates” standard of existing law requires a stationary source to be acutely aware of the situation that constitutes a violation of CalARP before a $25,000 can be imposed. Furthermore, the existing law also requires a CUPA to notify the stationary source of such a violation, even if the stationary source already knows they are violating the law, and subsequently wait a “reasonable” period of time after that notice before imposing a $25,000 penalty. The notice provisions apply even if the violation could be deemed a violation of the stationary source’s own risk management plan and in cases of significant violations of the law, for example an explosion at a refinery or large-release at a chemical plant. The notice provisions essentially preclude the CUPAs from imposing maximum daily penalties, even in egregious situations.
Despite risk management efforts, significant incidents do occur. The author notes that despite California’s strict regulation of stationary sources containing hazardous materials accidents do occur, and frequently result in significant environmental impacts. In recent memory, the most widely publicized incident occurred when oil vapor escaped from a ruptured pipeline at Chevron’s refining facility in Richmond, California. When the flammable gas ignited, as it is wont to do, the ensuing explosion and fire burned for five hours, caused 15,000 local residents to seek medical attention for breathing problems and related medical issues, and injured six Chevron employees. When the Chemical Safety Board and the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health investigated the incident, they determined that the explosion was caused by a corroded pipe that should have been identified had Chevron’s own internal protocols been implemented properly. Because the fire was extinguished quickly, it is unlikely the existing law would have permitted a recovery by a CUPA above $2,000, as the fire was out and violation remedied well before the time period necessary for the CUPA to provide Chevron reasonable notice that the Chevron’s refinery had exploded in violation of the law.
Under the existing law, even repeat offenders may escape significant liability. As noted in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, industrial gas manufacturer Praxair was involved in three separate releases of highly toxic anhydrous ammonia between 2013 and 2015. The first two releases involved two different violations, including failure to properly notify local authorities of the release. Because both releases were stopped prior to the CUPA’s issuance of a notice, Praxair could only be assessed penalties of $2,000. Only after Praxair, again, failed to notify local authorities of a release in 2015 was the company fined $25,000 because the company knew that they must report the violation based on the notice provided in issuing the company a fine for the 2013 release.
This bill. To remedy the existing issue whereby a stationary source must be provided notice of a violation that it is, presumably, aware of, prior to imposing higher penalties, this bill proposes to delete the notice requirement from existing law. Further, the bill proposes modifying the existing “knowingly violates” standard for the maximum penalty and instead permits a CUPA to impose a maximum penalty any time a person or stationary source knowingly violates the law, or should have known their conduct was a violation. The author notes that this provision is designed to prevent a person or stationary source from avoiding higher penalties as a result of their own ignorance of the law, their risk management plan, or the conditions at a facility containing hazardous substances. Finally, the bill would increase the maximum penalty for all violations from $2,000 to $5,000, to deter repeat offenders like Praxair, and exempt from the penalty provisions violations of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
The risks associated with hazardous materials management justify a range of penalties. The existing statutory scheme and the modifications envisioned by this bill create strict liability for all stationary sources for any violation of the section. The CUPAs indicate that basic violations of the statute, for example a failure to properly post emergency contact information or to perform a routine inspection as provided in the risk management plan, would be subject to the lower tier penalty, $5000 as proposed by this bill. They suggest that these violations should not occur at any stationary source, but nonetheless, may occur due to an inadvertent oversight and do not cause serious harm.
Conversely, unlike minor violations which impose a strict liability standard, the statutory scheme envisions that serious violations require a higher penalty. The existing law, notwithstanding the notice language discussed above, requires a person or stationary source to knowingly violate the law before the $25,000 penalty applies. Although any stationary source should presumably know they are failing to comply with the law and their own risk management plans, the CUPAs indicate that the higher penalty is reserved for serious violations, for example intentionally and repeatedly mishandling hazardous substances in an attempt to save costs or time. In these cases, especially if a release of hazardous substances were to accompany violations, the CUPAs suggest the higher penalty should apply.
This bill would modify the knowledge standard to expand enforcement. As noted, and notwithstanding the notice provisions, the existing law requires a person or stationary source to “knowingly violate” CalARP’s requirements before the higher penalty can be imposed. Under California law, such an actual knowledge standard requires that “circumstances are such that the defendant "must have known” and not “should have known” of a violation. (Romero v. Superior Court (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1068, 1082.) This bill seeks to permit the CUPA to impose the higher penalty if the stationary source not only had actual knowledge of a violation but if it “should have known it was violating the law.” This known or should have known standard is not applied elsewhere in the law related to CalARP or most other hazardous substance laws within the Health and Safety Code. However, the standard proposed by this bill represents a duty of care typically applied in tort liability.
The common law tort most similar to this bill would likely be premises liability. As much like the issues covered by this bill, premises liability involves unsafe conditions at a location controlled by the person being assessed the penalty. California courts have held that the know or should have known standard means that actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition is a key to establishing liability. As applied in the business context to retailers, California courts have noted that the premises owner, similar to the stationary source under this bill, “must have either actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition or have been able by the exercise of ordinary care to discover the condition.” (Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200, 1206.)
In opposition to this measure, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups contend that this bill should only impose the higher penalty when a stationary source has actual knowledge of a violation of the law. They note that “the bill eliminates the distinction between "knowing" violations, or violations where the person "should have known," and those inadvertent violations which may have been of less serious consequence, including paper violations,” and that, “the coalition supported the increase of penalties from $2,000 to $5,000” which was contingent upon a distinction between negligent violations, and knowing violations.
The opposition’s contention is not without merit. Due to the high degree of regulation imposed on most industries that may cause environmental harm, negligence standards are not usually imposed. Furthermore, the standard of care that would be imposed on a stationary source in applying the “should have known” standard would likely be the stationary source’s own risk management plan. Given that the plan is required by law and produced by the stationary source, it is likely that any violation of the plan would meet the knowing standard, as the stationary source presumably knows what is in its own documents.
In response to the opposition, the author suggests that occasions may occur where the stationary source follows the letter but not the spirit of the plan, and such actions should result in a more serious violation. For example, utilizing the facts of the Chevron refinery explosion, a stationary source may be following their risk management plan conducting all tests of pipelines on a regular schedule and yet may fail to detect corrosion that subsequently resulted in an explosion. In the event that the stationary source missed the corrosion because they failed to properly train staff to conduct inspection or applied inappropriate techniques, they should have discovered the violation but for their own mistake. In such a scenario, a “should have known” standard would allow an adjudicatory body to assess facts underpinning the validity of imposing a $25,000 per day penalty better than a strict actual knowledge standard would.
Although the standard proposed by this bill is not typically applied to regulatory enforcement statutes, it is not unreasonable in light of the significant harm a violation of CalARP may inflict on the communities surrounding a stationary source in the event of a serious release. While the author may wish to continue working with the opposition as this bill progresses to develop a standard all parties are comfortable with, the current imposition of a known or should have known standard on violations of CalARP is not inappropriate.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, the California Association of Environmental Health Administrators notes that since CUPAs started implementing CalARP, the number of inspections of facilities has increased dramatically and accidental releases have significantly decreased. They note:
AB 3138 is intended to hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities BEFORE releases, fires and other accidents arise. It will ensure that the enforcement agencies have an effective tool to ensure due diligence in the preparation and implementation of critical Risk Management Plans.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups note that, while recent amendments to the bill are appreciated, they still oppose the current known or should have known standard for imposing heightened fine amounts. They note:
By eliminating the distinction between intentional and unintentional violations, AB 3138 treats all violations of law identically. We fail to understand the justification for this radical departure from well-established norms of jurisprudence. Our organizations object to the notion that minor violations that result from simple error should be treated similarly to intentional violations.
Furthermore, they believe the bill is unnecessary and that existing law provides sufficient incentive to deter malfeasance on the part of stationary sources.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators (sponsor)
Opposition
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Chemical Industry Council of California
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3138
Author:(Muratsuchi) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2018
SUBJECT: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE ADMINISTRATIVE AND CIVIL PENALTIES FOR A VIOLATION OF THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE INCREASED FROM $2,000 TO $5,000 PER DAY?
- SHOULD A PARTY BE SUBJECT TO THE $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY IF THEY KNOW OR SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT THEY WERE VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM?
- SHOULD THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PARTY BE PROVIDED REASONABLE NOTICE OF A VIOLATION BEFORE A $25,000 MAXIMUM DAILY PENALTY CAN BE ASSESSED FOR VIOLATING THE CALIFORNIA ACCIDENTAL RELEASE PREVENTION PROGRAM BE ELIMINATED?
SYNOPSIS
To improve adherence with existing standards for the production, management, and storage of hazardous substances, this bill seeks to modify the penalty levels and liability standards for violations of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program. The California Accidental Release Prevention Program requires stationary sources that produce or handle a specified level of a substance deemed hazardous by existing state and federal law to develop a risk management plan designed to prevent the accidental release of the hazardous substances into the environment. Should a person or stationary source fail to adhere to the existing law or the requirements of the risk management plan, they may be assessed a penalty. As the author notes, many of these stationary source facilities are located in highly urbanized areas where an accidental release of a hazardous substance would pose a significant and immediate risk to public health and environmental safety.
To increase compliance with the California Accidental Release Prevention Program, this bill proposes increasing the penalty for any violation from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day, eliminating the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice before a $25,000 penalty can be imposed, and permitting the imposition of the maximum penalty anytime a person or stationary source knew or should have known about a violation. The author justifies this increase by highlighting the prior incidents at several stationary source facilities, including several facilities found to be repeatedly violating their own risk management plans. This measure is sponsored by the California Association of Environmental Health Associates on behalf of the Certified Unified Program Agencies. The California Association of Environmental Health Associates contend that this measure is a modest and overdue adjustment of existing penalty levels given that the existing statute serves to mitigate risk in situations involving hazardous substances, and is necessary to protect workers and surrounding communities from fires, accidental releases, and other dangers that arise when stationary sources mishandle hazardous substances. Meanwhile, in opposition to this bill, a coalition of manufacturing and refining organizations contend that existing law provides sufficient deterrence to bad actors, that the known or should have known standard imposed by this bill is inappropriate for a regulatory enforcement statute, and that it is not sensible given the nature of the industry and the existing regulatory approach to managing hazardous materials. This bill was previously heard in the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials where it was approved by a 4-2 vote.
SUMMARY: Increases the minimum daily civil penalty for a violation of the California Accidental Release Prevention Program (CalARP), modifies standards for imposing a maximum daily penalty for a violation of CalARP, and eliminates the requirement that a party be provided reasonable notice of a violation before the maximum daily penalty can be assessed. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases the daily penalty for a person or stationary source that commits any violation of CalARP from $2,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates, or should have known they were violating, CalARP may be subject to a maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Eliminates the requirement that a person or stationary source be provided reasonable notice of the violation before that person or stationary source can be assessed the maximum daily penalty of $25,000.
- Provides that the maximum penalties that apply to persons or stationary sources do not apply to CalARP violations that are the result of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system, and apprenticeship workforce standards and reporting for contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source.
EXISTING LAW:
- The federal Clean Air Act requires the owners and operators of stationary sources producing, processing, handling, or storing hazardous substances to take steps to prevent the accidental release of those substances and provides owners and operators of stationary sources have a general duty to identify hazards which may result from such releases using appropriate hazard assessment techniques, to design and maintain a safe facility taking such steps as are necessary to prevent releases, and to minimize the consequences of accidental releases which do occur. (42 U.S.C. Section 7412(r).)
- Defines “stationary source” as any buildings, structures, equipment, installations, or substance emitting stationary activities which belong to the same industrial group, which are located on one or more contiguous properties, which are under the control of the same person (or persons under common control), and from which an accidental release may occur. (40 C.F.R Section 68.3.)
- Authorizes the creation of CalARP to carry out the Clean Air Act’s requirements of 1), above and apply state management requirements to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances. (Health and Safety Code Section 25531.)
- Requires a person or stationary source that handles a hazardous material or a mixture containing a hazardous material that has a quantity at any one time during the reporting year that is equal to, or greater than, 55 gallons for materials that are liquids, 500 pounds for solids, or 200 cubic feet for compressed gas to adopt a business management plan. (Health and Safety Code Section 25507 (a)(1)(A).)
- Provides that in addition to the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (CalOES), the CalARP program is managed by local agencies designated as a Certified Unified Program Agency (CUPA). (Health and Safety Code 25532 (b).)
- Provides that a CUPA must be certified by the Secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency. (Health and Safety Code Section 25501 (e).)
- Requires the local CUPA inspect every stationary source required to be registered under CalARP at least once every three years to determine whether the stationary source is in compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25537.)
- Provides that within 15 days of a CUPA’s certification of a person or stationary source’s risk management plan, CUPA shall post the risk management plan for public review and comment for a period of at least 45 days. Requires that a notice briefly describing and stating that the risk management plan is available for public review at a certain location be placed in a daily local newspaper or placed on an administering agency’s Internet web site, and mailed to interested persons and organizations. (Health and Safety Code Section 25535.2.)
- Requires the CUPA to implement an integrated alerting and notification system for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.6.)
- Requires an owner or operator of a stationary source when contracting for the performance of construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, or maintenance work at the stationary source, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a skilled and trained workforce to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.7.)
- Provides that a stationary source claiming an exemption from the requirements of 10), above to file with the CUPA a complete copy of the contract that includes, at minimum, the identity of the contractor, the scope of the work covered by the contract, the date of execution of the contract, and the term of the contract. (Health and Safety Code Section 25536.9.)
- Provides that person or stationary source that violates CalARP shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount of not more than $2,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (a).)
- Provides that a person or stationary source that knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation shall be civilly or administratively liable to the CUPA in an amount not to exceed $25,000 for each day in which the violation occurs. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540 (b).)
- Provides that misdemeanor criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year of imprisonment, may apply if a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (Health and Safety Code Section 25540.1.)
- Provides criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year imprisonment and/or not more than $25,000 per day of violation for first time violations or up to three years imprisonment and/or fines within the range $2,000 to $50,000 for each day of violation for convictions based on violations committed after a first conviction, for a person or stationary source who knowingly makes a false materials statement on documents maintained for the purpose of CalARP, who destroys or alters such documents, or who carries out other specified actions related to the integrity of information maintained for compliance with CalARP. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.)
- Prohibits civil and criminal enforcement actions from being brought for the same CalARP offenses. (Health and Safety Code Section 25541.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to modify a statutory provision that placed significant procedural hurdles on a CUPA’s ability to impose the maximum daily penalty for CalARP violations, even in the event of egregious conduct by a stationary source, and generally improve accountability and management of facilities that handle highly flammable or hazardous substances. In support of this measure, the author notes that the Legislature has taken steps in recent years to improve the risk management standards imposed by CalARP; however, enforcement remedies have not been modified. The author states:
Unfortunately, stricter regulations without adequate penalties for non-compliance will result in less effective enforcement of the requirements. AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities.
Regulating hazardous waste and hazardous materials in California. Existing law provides a unified regulatory structure for six areas of hazardous materials management in California to ensure that these materials are managed safely. The overall structure provides for local regulatory control with state oversight. Accordingly, subject to the approval and oversight of the California Environmental Protection Agency, CUPAs are responsible for overseeing compliance with California’s Hazardous Material Release Response Plans and Inventories, the Underground Storage Tank Program, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act, the Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Program, the Hazardous Material Management Plan and Material Inventory provisions of the California Uniform Fire Code, and CalARP. Currently, there are 81 CUPAs operating in California.
Specific to this bill, and CalARP, the CUPAs work in conjunction with CalOES to review, approve, and ensure compliance with the risk management plans developed by stationary sources that handle quantities of hazardous substances that existing law deems a risk. Typically, CalARP applies to chemical manufacturers, chemical processors, and hydrocarbon refiners. The overall purpose of CalARP and the risk management plans is to prevent the accidental release of hazardous substances into the environment, minimize the impact if such releases do occur, and ensure that the public is properly notified of risks associated with hazardous substances and their release. The risk management plan includes a detailed engineering analysis of the facility, and requires a stationary source to identify all regulated hazardous materials at the site, provide general accidental release prevention and emergency response plans, provide chemical specific-management plans, conduct offsite consequence assessments involving potential releases, and provide a five-year accident history and any improvements to the risk management plan developed as a result of an accident.
Overall the risk management plans are designed to ensure the safe operation of stationary sources and provide local first responders and emergency services officials with the information necessary to safely handle an emergency or accidental release at a facility.
Existing law significantly limits CUPAs’ ability to impose maximum daily penalties for violating the law. Existing law provides that a stationary source can be administratively or civilly liable for up to $2,000 per day for any violation of CalARP, no matter how minor. Existing law also provides that a person or stationary source may be held liable for civil or administrative penalties of up to $25,000 per day if they are knowingly violating CalARP and are provided reasonable notice of such a violation. The reasonable notice provisions impose significant, and somewhat nonsensical, barriers to the imposition of the maximum daily penalty.
As applied to CalARP, the “knowingly violates” standard of existing law requires a stationary source to be acutely aware of the situation that constitutes a violation of CalARP before a $25,000 can be imposed. Furthermore, the existing law also requires a CUPA to notify the stationary source of such a violation, even if the stationary source already knows they are violating the law, and subsequently wait a “reasonable” period of time after that notice before imposing a $25,000 penalty. The notice provisions apply even if the violation could be deemed a violation of the stationary source’s own risk management plan and in cases of significant violations of the law, for example an explosion at a refinery or large-release at a chemical plant. The notice provisions essentially preclude the CUPAs from imposing maximum daily penalties, even in egregious situations.
Despite risk management efforts, significant incidents do occur. The author notes that despite California’s strict regulation of stationary sources containing hazardous materials accidents do occur, and frequently result in significant environmental impacts. In recent memory, the most widely publicized incident occurred when oil vapor escaped from a ruptured pipeline at Chevron’s refining facility in Richmond, California. When the flammable gas ignited, as it is wont to do, the ensuing explosion and fire burned for five hours, caused 15,000 local residents to seek medical attention for breathing problems and related medical issues, and injured six Chevron employees. When the Chemical Safety Board and the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health investigated the incident, they determined that the explosion was caused by a corroded pipe that should have been identified had Chevron’s own internal protocols been implemented properly. Because the fire was extinguished quickly, it is unlikely the existing law would have permitted a recovery by a CUPA above $2,000, as the fire was out and violation remedied well before the time period necessary for the CUPA to provide Chevron reasonable notice that the Chevron’s refinery had exploded in violation of the law.
Under the existing law, even repeat offenders may escape significant liability. As noted in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, industrial gas manufacturer Praxair was involved in three separate releases of highly toxic anhydrous ammonia between 2013 and 2015. The first two releases involved two different violations, including failure to properly notify local authorities of the release. Because both releases were stopped prior to the CUPA’s issuance of a notice, Praxair could only be assessed penalties of $2,000. Only after Praxair, again, failed to notify local authorities of a release in 2015 was the company fined $25,000 because the company knew that they must report the violation based on the notice provided in issuing the company a fine for the 2013 release.
This bill. To remedy the existing issue whereby a stationary source must be provided notice of a violation that it is, presumably, aware of, prior to imposing higher penalties, this bill proposes to delete the notice requirement from existing law. Further, the bill proposes modifying the existing “knowingly violates” standard for the maximum penalty and instead permits a CUPA to impose a maximum penalty any time a person or stationary source knowingly violates the law, or should have known their conduct was a violation. The author notes that this provision is designed to prevent a person or stationary source from avoiding higher penalties as a result of their own ignorance of the law, their risk management plan, or the conditions at a facility containing hazardous substances. Finally, the bill would increase the maximum penalty for all violations from $2,000 to $5,000, to deter repeat offenders like Praxair, and exempt from the penalty provisions violations of CalARP that are the result of a failure of a local implementing agency’s integrated alerting and notification system or are otherwise enforced by the Labor Commissioner.
The risks associated with hazardous materials management justify a range of penalties. The existing statutory scheme and the modifications envisioned by this bill create strict liability for all stationary sources for any violation of the section. The CUPAs indicate that basic violations of the statute, for example a failure to properly post emergency contact information or to perform a routine inspection as provided in the risk management plan, would be subject to the lower tier penalty, $5000 as proposed by this bill. They suggest that these violations should not occur at any stationary source, but nonetheless, may occur due to an inadvertent oversight and do not cause serious harm.
Conversely, unlike minor violations which impose a strict liability standard, the statutory scheme envisions that serious violations require a higher penalty. The existing law, notwithstanding the notice language discussed above, requires a person or stationary source to knowingly violate the law before the $25,000 penalty applies. Although any stationary source should presumably know they are failing to comply with the law and their own risk management plans, the CUPAs indicate that the higher penalty is reserved for serious violations, for example intentionally and repeatedly mishandling hazardous substances in an attempt to save costs or time. In these cases, especially if a release of hazardous substances were to accompany violations, the CUPAs suggest the higher penalty should apply.
This bill would modify the knowledge standard to expand enforcement. As noted, and notwithstanding the notice provisions, the existing law requires a person or stationary source to “knowingly violate” CalARP’s requirements before the higher penalty can be imposed. Under California law, such an actual knowledge standard requires that “circumstances are such that the defendant "must have known” and not “should have known” of a violation. (Romero v. Superior Court (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1068, 1082.) This bill seeks to permit the CUPA to impose the higher penalty if the stationary source not only had actual knowledge of a violation but if it “should have known it was violating the law.” This known or should have known standard is not applied elsewhere in the law related to CalARP or most other hazardous substance laws within the Health and Safety Code. However, the standard proposed by this bill represents a duty of care typically applied in tort liability.
The common law tort most similar to this bill would likely be premises liability. As much like the issues covered by this bill, premises liability involves unsafe conditions at a location controlled by the person being assessed the penalty. California courts have held that the know or should have known standard means that actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition is a key to establishing liability. As applied in the business context to retailers, California courts have noted that the premises owner, similar to the stationary source under this bill, “must have either actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition or have been able by the exercise of ordinary care to discover the condition.” (Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200, 1206.)
In opposition to this measure, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups contend that this bill should only impose the higher penalty when a stationary source has actual knowledge of a violation of the law. They note that “the bill eliminates the distinction between "knowing" violations, or violations where the person "should have known," and those inadvertent violations which may have been of less serious consequence, including paper violations,” and that, “the coalition supported the increase of penalties from $2,000 to $5,000” which was contingent upon a distinction between negligent violations, and knowing violations.
The opposition’s contention is not without merit. Due to the high degree of regulation imposed on most industries that may cause environmental harm, negligence standards are not usually imposed. Furthermore, the standard of care that would be imposed on a stationary source in applying the “should have known” standard would likely be the stationary source’s own risk management plan. Given that the plan is required by law and produced by the stationary source, it is likely that any violation of the plan would meet the knowing standard, as the stationary source presumably knows what is in its own documents.
In response to the opposition, the author suggests that occasions may occur where the stationary source follows the letter but not the spirit of the plan, and such actions should result in a more serious violation. For example, utilizing the facts of the Chevron refinery explosion, a stationary source may be following their risk management plan conducting all tests of pipelines on a regular schedule and yet may fail to detect corrosion that subsequently resulted in an explosion. In the event that the stationary source missed the corrosion because they failed to properly train staff to conduct inspection or applied inappropriate techniques, they should have discovered the violation but for their own mistake. In such a scenario, a “should have known” standard would allow an adjudicatory body to assess facts underpinning the validity of imposing a $25,000 per day penalty better than a strict actual knowledge standard would.
Although the standard proposed by this bill is not typically applied to regulatory enforcement statutes, it is not unreasonable in light of the significant harm a violation of CalARP may inflict on the communities surrounding a stationary source in the event of a serious release. While the author may wish to continue working with the opposition as this bill progresses to develop a standard all parties are comfortable with, the current imposition of a known or should have known standard on violations of CalARP is not inappropriate.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, the California Association of Environmental Health Administrators notes that since CUPAs started implementing CalARP, the number of inspections of facilities has increased dramatically and accidental releases have significantly decreased. They note:
AB 3138 is intended to hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities BEFORE releases, fires and other accidents arise. It will ensure that the enforcement agencies have an effective tool to ensure due diligence in the preparation and implementation of critical Risk Management Plans.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition, a coalition of manufacturing and refining trade groups note that, while recent amendments to the bill are appreciated, they still oppose the current known or should have known standard for imposing heightened fine amounts. They note:
By eliminating the distinction between intentional and unintentional violations, AB 3138 treats all violations of law identically. We fail to understand the justification for this radical departure from well-established norms of jurisprudence. Our organizations object to the notion that minor violations that result from simple error should be treated similarly to intentional violations.
Furthermore, they believe the bill is unnecessary and that existing law provides sufficient incentive to deter malfeasance on the part of stationary sources.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators (sponsor)
Opposition
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Chemical Industry Council of California
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3138 (
Author:Muratsuchi) – As Introduced Ver:February 16, 2018
SUBJECT: Hazardous materials: management: civil liability
SUMMARY: Makes the maximum civil or administrative liability $25,000 per day for any California Accidental Release Prevention program (CalARP) violation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Implements, through the creation of CalARP (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §25531 et seq.), federal Clean Air Act (CAA) amendments enacted in 1990 for the prevention of accidental releases of hazardous substances in the state. (42 United States Code (USC) §7412 (r))
- Requires a person or stationary source to establish and implement a Risk Management Plan (RMP) for emergency response to a release or threatened release of a hazardous material if the business meets certain criteria. (HSC § 25507 (a))
- Specifies what must be included in an RMP, including, but not limited to:
- Regulated substances held onsite at the stationary source;
- Offsite consequences of an accidental release of a regulated substance;
- Accident history of the stationary source;
- Emergency response program for the stationary source;
- Coordination with local emergency responders;
- Hazard review or process hazard analysis;
- Operating procedures at the stationary source;
- Training of the stationary source’s personnel;
- Maintenance and mechanical integrity of the stationary source’s physical plant; and,
- Incident investigation.
- Defines an "administering agency" as a certified unified program agency (CUPA). (HSC § 25532 (b))
- Requires a CUPA to inspect every CalARP facility at least once every three years to evaluate compliance with law, regulation, and the provisions set out in the site’s RMP. Sets out a procedure for CUPAs to perform an audit to review the adequacy of the RMP itself. (HSC §25537, Code of Federal Regulations Title 40 §68.22)
- Requires a CUPA, within 15 days of determining that an RMP is complete, to make the RMP available to the public for review and comment for at least 45 days. Requires the CUPAs to distribute a notice of the public’s right to review the RMP and place the notice in a local newspaper, on the administering agency’s website, and to interested persons and organizations via the mail. (HSC § 25535.2)
- Requires an RMP to be made available to the public, except for offsite consequence analysis data. Requires the administering agency to insure that any member of the public has access, by appointment, to a copy of the offsite consequence analysis data. Allows a member of the public to read, but not remove, reproduce, print, scan, or image the documents relating to the offsite consequence analysis data. (California Code of Regulations Title 19, Division 2, Chapter 4.5, Section 2775.5)
- Requires a CUPA to implement an integrated alerting and notification system for communities surrounding petroleum refineries in case of an incident at the refinery in accordance with AB 1646 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 588, Statutes of 2017) effective January 1, 2018. Pays for this system through fees levied by the CUPA on the petroleum refinery. (HSC §25536.6)
- Requires an owner or operator of stationary sources required to submit an RMP and that are petroleum refineries or petrochemical manufacturing facilities, when contracting for the performance of construction, maintenance, and related work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a "skilled and trained workforce," as defined, to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades, except as specified. (HSC §25536.7)
- Establishes penalties for violations of CalARP as follows:
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $25,000 per day the violation occurs for cases where a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (HSC §25540(b))
- Sets the maximum civil or administrative liability at $2,000 per day the violation occurs for other cases where an entity violates CalARP. (HSC §25540(a))
- Sets misdemeanor criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year of imprisonment, if a person or stationary source knowingly violates CalARP after reasonable notice of the violation. (HSC §25540.1)
- Sets criminal penalties, punishable by up to one year imprisonment and/or not more than $25,000 per day of violation for first time violations or up to three years imprisonment and/or fines within the range $2,000 to $50,000 for each day of violation for convictions based on violations committed after a first conviction under this section, for a person or stationary source who knowingly makes a false materials statement on documents maintained for the purpose of CalARP, who destroys or alters such documents, or who carries out other specified actions related to the integrity of information maintained for compliance with CalARP. (HSC §25541)
- Requires, for all of the above (a-d), a person or stationary source to be assessed the full cost of an emergency response and the cost of cleaning up of and disposing of the hazardous materials if the violation results in, or significantly contributes to, an emergency, including fire. (HSC §25540(b), §25540(a), §25540.1, and §25541)
- Sets civil or criminal liability at up to $10,000 for each day of violation for violations of CalARP related to specific sections of the CAA. (HSC §25540.5 and HSC §25541.3, 42 USC §7412(l) and 7412(r))
- Requires that civil and criminal enforcement actions may not be brought for the same CalARP offences. (HSC §25541.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 3138 will hold refineries and other facilities that handle highly toxic or flammable chemicals accountable for the safety of workers and communities, to better anticipate problems and prevent accidents that might pose serious risks to the public and environment. This bill raises penalties for these facilities that are consistent to recent increases to similar penalties to provide greater deterrence for violators. This ensures California leads the nation in protecting the safety and health of workers and people in nearby communities."
Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs): The Unified Program was created by SB 1082 (Calderon, Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993), to unify administration, permits, inspections, and enforcement of hazardous waste and hazardous materials management programs across the state. Hazardous materials include petroleum. CUPAs implementing these programs are certified by the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA). Currently, there are 81 CUPAs in California. The Unified Program manages the following programs:
- Hazardous Materials Release Response Plans and Inventories (HMBP);
- CalARP;
- Underground Storage Tank Program;
- Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act;
- Hazardous Waste Generator and Onsite Hazardous Waste Treatment Programs (HWCA); and,
- California Uniform Fire Code: Hazardous Material Management Plans and Hazardous Material Inventory Statements.
State agencies involved in the implementation of the Unified Program are responsible for setting program element standards, working with CalEPA to ensure program consistency, and providing technical assistance to the CUPAs. The following state agencies are involved with the Unified program:
- CalEPA: The Secretary of CalEPA is directly responsible for coordinating and evaluating the administration of the Unified Program and certifying CUPAs. CUPAs are accountable for carrying out responsibilities previously handled by approximately 1,300 different state and local agencies.
- Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (Cal OES): The Cal OES evaluates and provides technical assistance for CalARP, HMBP (Business Plan), and the Area Plan Programs.
California Accidental Release Prevention (CalARP) program: CalARP was implemented on January 1, 1997 and replaced the California Risk Management and Prevention Program. The purpose of the CalARP program is to prevent accidental releases of substances that can cause serious harm to the public and the environment, to minimize the damage if releases do occur, and to satisfy community right-to-know laws. This is accomplished by requiring businesses that handle more than a threshold quantity of a regulated substance listed in the regulations to develop a RMP. An RMP is a detailed engineering analysis of the potential accident factors present at a business and the mitigation measures that can be implemented to reduce this accident potential. The RMP contains safety information, a hazard review, operating procedures, training requirements, maintenance requirements, compliance audits, and incident investigation procedures. The RMP has four program levels where the lowest program level applies to businesses that do not present an offsite impact to the community, and the highest program level applies to petroleum refineries.
The CalARP program is implemented at the local government level by CUPAs and is designed so that the CUPAs work directly with the regulated businesses. The CUPAs determine the level of detail in the RMPs, review the RMPs, conduct facility inspections, and provide public access to most of the information.
CalARP covers the most dangerous chemicals and processes: Similar to CalARP, the HMBP requires emergency planning and reporting of types and amounts of hazardous chemicals, location, and storage information. However, the two programs are separate and distinct: HMBP applies to a broad category of hazardous substances HSC §25501 while CalARP only applies to a distinct set of substances that are extremely hazardous or extremely hazardous when used in large quantities as listed in CCR Title 19 §2770.5. Furthermore, requirements under CalARP also go beyond those shared with the HMBP as described above. Examples of extremely hazardous substances and their threshold levels in California include more than 500 pounds of anhydrous ammonia, more than 100 pounds hydrogen fluoride, or more than 10,000 pounds for flammable substances including hydrogen and methane.
Examples of CalARP violations:
Chevron Richmond Refinery fire: On August 6, 2012, light gas oil vapor escaped from a ruptured pipe forming a flammable cloud that ignited and burned for approximately five hours. Eighteen workers escaped through the gas cloud minutes before the fire erupted and a Chevron firefighter escaped through the fire, surviving because of his full fire gear. Six employees suffered minor injuries. Fifteen thousand people from the surrounding communities sought medical treatment at nearby medical facilities for ailments including breathing problems, chest pain, shortness of breath, sore throat, and headaches. According to the Chemical Safety Board’s investigation, the release was due to the failure of a weak, corroded pipe and ineffective implementation of internal recommendations designed to prevent these failures. California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) settled with Chevron for a $1 million fine and ordered upgrades possibly amounting to $20 million. Had liability for the fire been pursued under CalARP, according to existing statutes, it is very likely that $2,000 per violation per day would have been the maximum allowable penalty.
Gibson Wine Co. ammonia release: In September 2012, 284 pounds of anhydrous ammonium escaped after a worker opened the wrong valve on the winery’s refrigeration system. This worker called for an evacuation of the building. However, one worker was overcome by the ammonia cloud. Other employees attempted to rescue him but were unable to locate the necessary emergency equipment. This worker died from ammonia inhalation. The United States (US) Department of Justice and US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) sought civil penalties against Gibson Wine Co. for violations of 42 U.S.C. §7412(r)(l) and (7), the sections of the CAA pursuant to which CalARP was formed as well as violations of other federal laws. The CAA violations alleged in the 2016 US complaint against Gibson Wine Co. include failure to comply with good engineering practices, failure to adequately train employees, inadequate component labeling, inaccurate ammonia inventory, and many others. Under the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act of 1990 and the US EPA’s Civil Monetary Penalty Inflation Adjustment Rule, CAA maximum civil penalties enacted $25,000 per day of violation reached a maximum of $44,539 per day for each violation that occurred on or after November 2, 2015. In February 2018, the US Department of Justice and US EPA reached a settlement with Gibson Wine Co. for $330,000.
Praxair ammonia release: Anhydrous ammonia was accidentally released on three separate occasions in 2013, 2014, and 2015 at the same Praxair facility. The 2013 release involved a number of violations, including failure to immediately report the release, and $6,300 in administrative penalties were imposed. The second accident was the largest of the three. More than 8,000 pounds of ammonia escaped, requiring workers at an adjacent refinery to shelter in place. The CUPA inspector observed Class I and minor violations; a notice of violation was issued for failure to implement site specific operating procedures that resulted in the release, and for failure to properly inspect and test piping systems and other components. Even though this was not the facility’s first accidental release, the two incidences involved different violations. Therefore, the maximum of $2,000 per day of violation applied to the violations in the 2014 case as well, and $6,900 in administrative penalties were imposed. Praxair once again failed to immediately report the release in 2015 and was issued a single $25,000 fine. Records available in the California Environmental Reporting System reflect no further releases in 2016, 2017, or, to date, in 2018.
Notably, the 2015 Torrance Refinery explosion was not associated with any CalARP violations, but resulted in a near miss of the refinery’s alkylation unit, which uses modified hydrofluoric acid, an extremely hazardous chemical mixture covered under CalARP.
Penalties for CUPA program violations: Civil and administrative penalties collected by the CUPAs are put towards enhancing program and enforcement capabilities. Current CalARP law provides some level statutorily mandated tiered enforcement by designating separate maximum penalties for CalARP violations before or after reasonable notice of a violation. Other CUPA programs have different penalty schemes. For example, the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act sets a maximum civil penalty of $5,000 per day of violation for first time violations and $10,000 per day of violation for subsequent violations while the HWCA simply sets the maximum allowable penalty at $70,000 per day of violation. Different maximum penalties may also be set for major and minor violations. There is significant variability in the penalty structures and maximum penalties set for different CUPA programs for several reasons. In part, they are justifiable reflection of the different dangers posed by violations of the different laws. However, the varied origins of the laws before they were unified under the CUPAs also explain the variability. Where penalties have been changed, they have been changed in only one or a subset of programs rather than coordinated across programs.
Setting in statute the maximum allowable penalty for CalARP violations at $25,000 per day of violation, regardless of whether reasonable notice has been given, removes some statutory clarity and assurance around how penalties will be levied. However, it does not mean that the maximum will be sought in all cases. CUPAs assess administrative penalties based both on statutorily allowed ranges and on the severity and circumstances of the violation. CUPAs are required by law to take into consideration the "nature, circumstances, extent, and gravity of the violation, the violator’s past and present efforts to prevent, abate, or clean up conditions posing a threat to the public health or safety or the environment, the violator’s ability to pay the penalty, and the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community." (HSC §25404.1.1(b)) Administrative penalties may be appealed, and each CUPA has an enforcement plan laying out enforcement procedures, including the criteria for which a case may be referred for prosecution.
As enacted in 1986, civil liability under the section amended by this bill (HSC §25540) was maximum $2,000 per day of violation or, if a business commits a violation knowingly after reasonable notice, maximum of $5,000 per day of violation. In 1988, $5,000 was increased to $25,000. CalARP penalties have not since been changed or adjusted for inflation. Other penalties are also set out in CalARP but are not affected by AB 3138. For comparison, the maximum allowable penalties under HMBP is $2,000 or, if a business commits a violation knowingly after reasonable notice, maximum $5,000 per day of violation (HSC §25515). Furthermore, as discussed above, the maximum civil penalty for HWCA violations is $70,000 per day of violation (HSC §25188). AB 245 (Quirk, Chapter 499, Statutes of 2017) raised the maximum penalty for HWCA violations from $25,000 per day to $70,000 per day, synchronizing it approximately with federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act maximum penalty levels.
AB 3138 does not increase the maximum civil and administrative penalties for CalARP beyond $25,000 per day of violation, though CalARP specifically serves to mitigate risk in the highest stakes situations involving hazardous substances, to protect workers and surrounding communities from fires, accidental releases, and other dangers that arise when stationary sources handle extremely hazardous substances.
Related legislation:
- AB 245 (Quirk, Chapter 499, Statutes of 2017). This bill increased the maximum allowable administrative and civil penalties from $25,000 to $70,000 for violations of the HWCA.
- AB 1646 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 588, Statutes of 2017). This bill required an implementing agency to develop an integrated alerting and notification system, in coordination with local emergency management agencies, unified program agencies, local first response agencies, and the public, to be used to notify the community surrounding a petroleum refinery in the event of an incident at the refinery.
- SB 54 (Hancock, Chapter 795, Statutes of 2013). This bill required an owner or operator of stationary sources required to submit an RMP and that are petroleum refineries or petrochemical manufacturing facilities, when contracting for the performance of construction, maintenance and related work, to require that its contractors and any subcontractors use a "skilled and trained workforce," to perform all onsite work within an apprenticeable occupation in the building and construction trades, except as specified.
Double-referral: Should this bill pass the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee, it will be re-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators
Opposition
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California manufacturers & Technology Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Amy Gilson / E.S. & T.M. /
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):