AB 1711: University of California: nonresident student enrollment.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-09
Existing law expresses the intent of the Legislature that the University of California establish nonresident student tuition policies that are consistent with their resident student fee policies. The provisions are applicable to the University of California only if the Regents of the University of California act, by resolution, to make them applicable.
This bill would require the University of California, in collaboration with the Academic Senate of the University of California, as a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, to establish a policy to require each campus to admit only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students, as specified, ensure that implementation of any admissions policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students includes guidance that ensures the academic qualifications for admitted nonresident undergraduate students generally exceeds the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students, and would require the University of California to report specified information to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with implementation of the policy.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law expresses the intent of the Legislature that the University of California establish nonresident student tuition policies that are consistent with their resident student fee policies. The provisions are applicable to the University of California only if the Regents of the University of California act, by resolution, to make them applicable.
This bill would require the University of California, as a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, to limit the percentage of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide to 10% of total undergraduate student enrollment, to increase resident undergraduate student enrollment by 5,000 and decrease nonresident undergraduate student enrollment by 1,700 each year for 6 academic years beginning with the 201718 academic year, and would prohibit any campus of the University of California where nonresident undergraduate student enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new nonresident undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year. The bill would require the University of California to annually publish a report with specified information relating to nonresident undergraduate tuition and revenue. The bill would require the University of California to establish a policy to require each campus to admit only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students, as specified, and would require the University of California to annually report specified information to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with the policy.
Existing law expresses the intent of the Legislature that the University of California establish nonresident student tuition policies that are consistent with their resident student fee policies. The provisions are applicable to the University of California only if the Regents of the University of California act, by resolution, to make them applicable.
This bill would require the University of California, as a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, to limit the percentage of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide to 15.5% 10% of total undergraduate student enrollment, to increase resident undergraduate student enrollment by 5,000 and decrease nonresident undergraduate student enrollment by 1,700 each year for 6 academic years beginning with the 201718 academic year, and would prohibit any campus of the University of California where nonresident undergraduate student enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new nonresident undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year. The bill, beginning in the 201718 academic year, would require a certain percentage of revenue generated from new nonresident undergraduate student enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of resident undergraduate students, and bill would require the University of California to annually publish a report with specified information relating to nonresident undergraduate tuition and revenue. The bill would require the University of California to establish a policy to require each campus to admit only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students, as specified, and would require the University of California to annually report specified information to the Legislature to ensure compliance with the policy.
Existing law expresses the intent of the Legislature that the University of California establish nonresident student tuition policies that are consistent with their resident student fee policies. The provisions are applicable to the University of California only if the Regents of the University of California act, by resolution, to make them applicable.
This bill would require the University of California, as a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, to limit the percentage of undergraduate nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide to 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment, and, until July 1, 2021, and would prohibit any campus of the University of California where undergraduate nonresident undergraduate student enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new undergraduate nonresident students. undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year. The bill bill, beginning in the 201718 academic year, would require a certain percentage of revenue generated from undergraduate new nonresident undergraduate student enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident undergraduate students, and would require the University of California to annually publish a report with specified information relating to undergraduate nonresident undergraduate tuition and revenue. The bill would require the University of California to establish a policy to require each campus to admit only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students, as specified, and would require the University of California to annually report specified information to the Legislature to ensure compliance with the policy.
Existing law expresses the intent of the Legislature that the University of California establish nonresident student tuition policies that are consistent with their resident student fee policies. The provisions are applicable to the University of California only if the Regents of the University of California act, by resolution, to make them applicable.
This bill would require the University of California, as a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, to limit the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at the University of California systemwide to 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment, and, until July 1, 2021, would prohibit any campus of the University of California where undergraduate nonresident student enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new undergraduate nonresident students. The bill would require a certain percentage of revenue generated from undergraduate nonresident enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students, and would require the University of California to annually publish a report with specified information relating to undergraduate nonresident tuition and revenue.
As a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, and notwithstanding Section 68134, the University of California shall comply with both of the following:
(a)By July 1, 2017, the University of California shall establish a policy California, in collaboration with the Academic Senate of the University of California, shall ensure that implementation of any admissions policy it adopts regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require that each campus of the University of California admit to that campus only shall include guidance that ensures that the academic qualifications for admitted nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the generally exceeds, on average, the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus and, in that regard, would stand in the upper one-half of the resident undergraduate students admitted at that specific each campus.
(b)The University of California shall report to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with implementation of this policy, including, but not limited to, the mean and median scores on academic indicators used in the admission process, the median score of admitted resident and nonresident undergraduate students for each indicator at each campus, and the number of admitted nonresident undergraduate students who scored below the resident median on each indicator at each campus.
SEC. 2.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to ensure the University of California and the Academic Senate review policies regarding the academic qualifications of nonresident undergraduate students at the earliest possible time, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)As a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, and notwithstanding Section 68134, the University of California shall comply with all both of the following:
(1)The percentage of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide shall not exceed 10 percent of total undergraduate student enrollment by the 202223 academic year.
(2)In each of the 201718, 201819, 201920, 202021, 202122, and 202223 academic years, the University of California shall increase resident undergraduate student enrollment by 5,000 and decrease nonresident undergraduate student enrollment by 1,700.
(3)Any campus of the University of California at which nonresident undergraduate enrollment exceeds 15.5 percent of total student enrollment shall not enroll new nonresident undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year.
(4)The University of California shall annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The nonresident undergraduate tuition and fee level established at each campus.
(B)The amount of revenues generated by nonresident undergraduate enrollment at each campus.
(C)The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various campuses of the university.
(D)For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended.
(5)(A)
(a)By July 1, 2017, the University of California shall establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require that each campus of the University of California admit to that campus only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus and, in that regard, would stand in the upper one-half of the resident undergraduate students admitted at that specific campus.
(B)
(b)The University of California shall report to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with this policy, including, but not limited to, the academic indicators used in the admission process, the median score of admitted resident undergraduate students for each indicator at each campus, and the number of admitted nonresident undergraduate students who scored below the resident median on each indicator at each campus.
(b)The University of California shall not be required to comply with the requirements of paragraph (1), (2), or (3) of subdivision (a) in any year in which the annual Budget Act provides less funding to support the University of California than was provided in the prior budget year.
(c)It is the intent of the Legislature that the enrollment changes specified in this section be funded by a combination of state funding, savings from operating efficiencies implemented by the University of California, and increases in nonresident undergraduate student tuition and fees.
(a)As a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, and notwithstanding Section 68134, the University of California shall comply with all of the following:
(a)
(1)The percentage of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide shall not exceed 15.5 10 percent of total undergraduate student enrollment. enrollment by the 202223 academic year.
(2)In each of the 201718, 201819, 201920, 202021, 202122, and 202223 academic years, the University of California shall increase resident undergraduate student enrollment by 5,000 and decrease nonresident undergraduate student enrollment by 1,700.
(b)
(3)Any campus of the University of California at which nonresident undergraduate enrollment exceeds 15.5 percent of total student enrollment shall not enroll new nonresident undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year.
(c) Beginning in the 201718 academic year, an amount not less than 50 percent of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction generated from new nonresident undergraduate enrollment shall be directed to fund increased enrollment of resident undergraduate students at all campuses of the university with undergraduate students.
(d)
(4)The University of California shall annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
(1)
(A)The nonresident undergraduate tuition and fee level established at each campus.
(2)
(B)The amount of revenues generated by nonresident undergraduate enrollment at each campus.
(3)
(C)The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various campuses of the university.
(4)
(D)For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to subdivision (c). expended.
(e) The University of California shall not be required to comply with the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) in any year in which the annual Budget Act provides less funding to support the University of California than was provided in the prior budget year.
(f)(1)
(5)(A)By July 1, 2017, the University of California shall establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require that each campus of the University of California admit to that campus only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus and, in that regard, would stand in the upper one-half of the resident undergraduate students admitted at that specific campus.
(2)
(B)The University of California shall report to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with this policy, including, but not limited to, the academic indicators used in the admission process, the median score of admitted resident undergraduate students for each indicator at each campus, and the number of admitted nonresident undergraduate students who scored below the resident median on each indicator at each campus.
(b)The University of California shall not be required to comply with the requirements of paragraph (1), (2), or (3) of subdivision (a) in any year in which the annual Budget Act provides less funding to support the University of California than was provided in the prior budget year.
(c)It is the intent of the Legislature that the enrollment changes specified in this section be funded by a combination of state funding, savings from operating efficiencies implemented by the University of California, and increases in nonresident undergraduate student tuition and fees.
As a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, and notwithstanding Section 68134, the University of California shall comply with all of the following:
(a)The percentage of undergraduate nonresident undergraduate students enrolled at the University of California systemwide shall not exceed 15.5 percent of total undergraduate student enrollment.
(b)Until July 1, 2021, any Any campus of the University of California at which undergraduate nonresident undergraduate enrollment exceeds 15.5 percent of total student enrollment shall not enroll new undergraduate nonresident students. undergraduate students in excess of the number of new nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in the 201516 academic year.
(c)An Beginning in the 201718 academic year, an amount not less than 50 percent of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction generated from undergraduate new nonresident undergraduate enrollment shall be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident undergraduate students at all campuses of the university with undergraduate students.
(d)The University of California shall annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The undergraduate nonresident undergraduate tuition and fee level established at each campus.
(2)The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident undergraduate enrollment at each campus.
(3)The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various campuses of the university.
(4)For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to subdivision (c).
(e)The University of California shall not be required to comply with the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) in any year in which the annual Budget Act provides less funding to support the University of California than was provided in the prior budget year.
(f)(1)By July 1, 2017, the University of California shall establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require that each campus of the University of California admit to that campus only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus and, in that regard, would stand in the upper one-half of the resident undergraduate students admitted at that specific campus.
(2)The University of California shall report to the Legislature annually regarding actions taken to ensure compliance with this policy, including, but not limited to, the academic indicators used in the admission process, the median score of admitted resident undergraduate students for each indicator at each campus, and the number of admitted nonresident undergraduate students who scored below the resident median on each indicator at each campus.
As a condition of receipt of funds appropriated in the annual Budget Act, and notwithstanding Section 68134, the University of California shall comply with all of the following:
(a)The percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at the University of California systemwide shall not exceed 15.5 percent of total undergraduate student enrollment.
(b)Until July 1, 2021, any campus of the University of California at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5 percent of total student enrollment shall not enroll new undergraduate nonresident students.
(c)An amount not less than 50 percent of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction generated from undergraduate nonresident enrollment shall be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students at all campuses of the university with undergraduate students.
(d)The University of California shall annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus.
(2)The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus.
(3)The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various campuses of the university.
(4)For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to subdivision (c).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 4861.) |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (August 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | (pending re-refer to Com. on APPR.) |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| Aug 9, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 29, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 2. Page 5087.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 2.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 19. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 11, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 3.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HIGHER ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2016 | In committee: Reconsideration granted. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Jan 27, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 26. |
| Jan 26, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Jun 29, 2016 | [First] hearing set for [06-29-2016]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Jun 29, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Failed |
|
| Jun 1, 2016 | AB 1711 MCCARTY Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2016 | Reconsideration. | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
|
| Mar 15, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Carol Liu, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1711
Author: | McCarty | ||
Version: | August 9, 2016 Hearing Date: August 11, 2016 | ||
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Olgalilia Ramirez | ||
Subject: University of California: nonresident student enrollment
Note: This bill was previously heard by this Committee on June 29, 2016, failed passage by a vote of 3-4, and was granted reconsideration. The bill has subsequently been amended to respond to concerns raised in the committee analysis for the June 29th hearing. This analysis has been updated to reflect these amendments.
SUMMARY
This bill, an urgency measure, as a condition of receipt of annual Budget Act funding, requires the University of California (UC), in collaboration with the Academic Senate, to ensure that implementation of any admissions policy it adopts regarding nonresident undergraduate students to include guidance that ensures that the academic qualifications of these students generally exceeds, on average, the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted at each campus.
BACKGROUND
The California Constitution establishes the UC, a public trust to be administered by the Regents of the UC and grants the Regents full powers of organization and government, subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure security of its funds, compliance with the terms of its endowments, statutory requirements around competitive bidding and contracts, sales of property and the purchase of materials, goods and services. (Article IX, Section (9)(a) of the California Constitution)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- As a condition of receipt of annual Budget Act funding requires the UC to:
- In collaboration with the Academic Senate, ensure by July 1,
2017, that implementation of any admissions policy it adopts regarding
nonresident undergraduate students to include guidance that ensures that the academic qualifications of these students generally exceeds, on average, the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted at each campus.
- Report to the Legislature annually regarding implementation of the policy,
including but not limited to, the mean and median scores on academic indicators of admitted resident and nonresident undergraduate students at each campus.
- Declares the bill an urgency measure in order to ensure the UC and the Academic Senate review policies regarding the academic qualifications of nonresident undergraduate students at the earliest possible time.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend in the University of California (UC) to enroll more out-of-state and international students at the expense of California students. Systemwide nonresident enrollment at the UC was 5 percent in 2007 and is currently at its highest level of 15.5 percent while resident enrollment has remained stagnant. In March 2016, a report by the State Auditor found that UC’s admissions policies have disadvantaged and undermined their commitment to California students in favor of nonresidents. This bill implements recommendations from the report by requesting that the UC ensure that any admissions policy it adopts regarding nonresident undergraduate students includes guidance that ensures that nonresidents generally exceed the academic standards of California residents who are admitted at each campus.
- Current status of out-of-state admissions. The UC reports that for the 2015-16 academic year, 15.5 percent of its undergraduates systemwide were nonresidents. According to the UC, nonresident enrollment for 2015-16 was capped at those campuses that had seen the largest growth, Berkeley (25 percent), Los Angeles (19 percent). San Diego (17 percent) was directed to cap their enrollment of nonresidents at 20 percent.
- Related budget activity. The 2015 Budget Act provided $25 million to the UC contingent on increasing California resident enrollment by 5,000 students, holding resident tuition flat in 2015-16 and 2016-17, and redirecting nonresident institutional aid to support resident students.
The 2016 Budget Act provided an additional $18.5 million to the UC contingent upon enrolling 2,500 more California residents by the 2017-18 school year and upon the UC regent’s adoption of a university-wide policy capping the enrollment of nonresidents.
- BSA Audit. On March 29, 2016, the California State Auditor released a report, The University of California, Its Admissions and Financial Decisions have Disadvantaged California Resident Students. The report lists as its key findings that the university has undermined its commitment to residents in an effort to increase its revenue by recruiting and enrolling nonresidents. The report specifically cites that:
- Despite a 52 percent increase in resident applicants, resident enrollment increased by only 10 percent over the last 10 years while nonresident enrollment increased by 432 percent.
- The University lowered the admission standard for nonresidents and admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents over the past three years with academic scores that fell below the median of admitted residents.
- Admitted residents were increasingly denied their campus of choice, yet admitted nonresidents were always admitted to one of their campuses of choice.
- Mandatory fees doubled for residents while they increased for nonresidents at a much lower rate.
Among other things, the Bureau of State Audits recommended that the University of California (UC) revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the residents it admits.
In response, the UC asserts that its admissions policies overwhelmingly favor Californians, and that state funding determines how many California residents the UC enrolls.
- UC Admissions policy. The Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools (BOARS) oversees all matters relating to the admissions of undergraduate students. BOARS regulates the policies and practices used in the admissions process and recommends and directs efforts to improve the admissions process. According to the UC, its Comprehensive Review Policy governs the admission and selection of undergraduates at its nine campuses. Freshmen applications are assessed using multiple measures of achievement (high school course completion, grade point average, and standardized test scores) and promise while considering applicants’ educational context. Comprehensive review involves consideration of 14 factors, utilized by all campuses, but the specific evaluation process and weight given to each factor differ from campus to campus, and year to year, based on campus-specific goals and needs.
According to the UC this same comprehensive review is applied to nonresident applicants.
- UC Admission Guarantee. UC’s admission guarantee policy, applicable to all California resident high school graduates, includes Statewide Eligibility (SE), Eligibility in the Local Context (ELC), and Entitled to Review (ETR). The UC guarantees admission to the system (though not necessarily to the first-choice campus) to all California applicants who are in the top 9 percent of California high school graduates (SE), or in the top 9 percent of their respective high school class (ELC). The top 9 percent is determined by a formula based on grade point average (GPA) and standardized test scores.
In 2012, the University of California (UC) implemented a new freshman admissions policy, Entitled to Review (ETR). Under this policy, students are not guaranteed admission, but are guaranteed a comprehensive review of their application if they have completed 11 of 15 required a-g courses with a weighted GPA of at least 3.0 by the end of their junior year. The intent was to confer the right to a full application review to a broader pool of college-going California students while ending the practice of excluding many high-achieving students solely on the basis of UC’s extensive standardized testing requirements.
According to the UC, it does not provide a similar guarantee of admission to nonresident students.
- BOARS policy change on admission of nonresidents. In 2011, BOARS approved new guidelines regarding the admission of nonresident and international students that eliminated wording that nonresidents "should demonstrate stronger admission criteria than CA residents by generally being in the upper half of those ordinarily eligible" for admission. BOARS revised its principles to state that admitted nonresidents should "compare favorably to California residents admitted.” In addition, a December 2011 resolution by BOARS resolves that to the fullest extent possible campuses should evaluate and select residents and nonresidents according to the same criteria and scores, enrollment targets for nonresidents should be set such that admitted nonresidents compare favorably at each campus, campus Senate admissions committees should work with local campus administration, and if needed BOARS and systemwide administration to ensure these principles are being met. At the end of each admission cycle BOARS resolved that each campus provide an assessment of the extent to which the compare favorable rule is being met to include a description of, the evaluation/selection criteria, measures, and supporting data.
- Current policy for admission of nonresidents. The UC reports that the current policy for admissions of nonresidents includes the following provisions:
- Nonresident applicants must have a higher GPA than resident applicants.
- There is no guarantee of admission for nonresidents, while there is for California residents.
- Nonresident students must be at least as qualified, on average, as admitted students across the system.
In addition, the UC indicates that the President of the University will ask the Academic Senate to review its current policy regarding nonresident admission and the University is committed to full transparency on their compliance with the policy by reporting annually on the relative qualifications of admitted residents and nonresidents.
- Similar legislation. SCA 12 (Runner and Huff) proposed to modify Article IX of the State Constitution to require the UC Regents to ensure that priority in admissions is given to applicants who are California residents. SCA 12 was heard and passed by this Committee on April 20, 2016, but was subsequently held in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SUPPORT
None received on this version.
OPPOSITION
University of California
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Carol Liu, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No:
Author: | McCarty | ||
Version: | Hearing Date: June 29, 2016 | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
SUMMARY
This bill, as a condition of receipt of annual Budget Act funding, requires the University of California (UC) to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require that the academic qualifications of these students stand in the upper one-half of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus, as specified, and requires the UC to report to the Legislature annually regarding actions to ensure compliance with the policy, as specified.
BACKGROUND
The California Constitution establishes the UC, a public trust to be administered by the Regents of the UC and grants the Regents full powers of organization and government, subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure security of its funds, compliance with the terms of its endowments, statutory requirements around competitive bidding and contracts, sales of property and the purchase of materials, goods and services. (Article IX, Section (9)(a) of the California Constitution)
ANALYSIS
This bill, as a condition of receipt of annual Budget Act funding:
- Requires the UC to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students by July 1, 2017. It:
- Requires that the policy require each campus of the UC admit only nonresident undergraduate students who exceed the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus.
- Requires that a nonresident undergraduate student admitted to a campus stand in the upper one-half of resident undergraduate students admitted to that campus.
- Requires the UC to report to the Legislature annually regarding actions to ensure compliance with the policy. Specifically, it requires the report to include but not be limited to:
- The academic indicators used in the admission process.
- The median score of admitted resident undergraduate students for each indicator at each campus.
- The number of admitted nonresident undergraduate students who scored below the resident median on each indicator at each campus.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend in the University of California (UC) to enroll more out-of-state and international students at the expense of California students. Systemwide nonresident enrollment at the UC was 5 percent in 2007 and is currently at its highest level of 15.5 percent while resident enrollment has remained stagnant. On March 2016, a report by the State Auditor found that UC’s admissions policies have disadvantaged and undermined their commitment to California students in favor of nonresidents. This bill implements recommendations from the report by requesting that the UC adopt a policy that ensures that nonresidents meet the same academic standards as the top 50 percent of California residents who are admitted at each campus.
- Current status of out-of-state admissions. The UC reports that for the 2015-16 academic year, 15.5 percent of its undergraduates systemwide were non-residents. According to the UC, nonresident enrollment for 2015-16 was capped at those campuses that had seen the largest growth, Berkeley (25 percent), Los Angeles (19 percent). San Diego (17 percent) was directed to cap their enrollment of nonresidents at 20 percent.
- Related budget activity. The 2015 Budget Act provided $25 million to the UC contingent on increasing California resident enrollment by 5,000 students, holding resident tuition flat in 2015-16 and 2016-17, and redirecting nonresident institutional aid to support resident students.
The 2016 Budget Act provided an additional $18.5 million to the UC contingent upon enrolling 2,500 more California residents by the 2017-18 school year and upon the UC regent’s adoption of a university-wide policy capping the enrollment of nonresidents.
- BSA Audit. On March 29, 2016, the California State Auditor released a report, The University of California, Its Admissions and Financial Decisions have Disadvantaged California Resident Students. The report lists as its key findings that the university has undermined its commitment to residents in an effort to increase its revenue by recruiting and enrolling nonresidents. The report specifically cites that:
- Despite a 52 percent increase in resident applicants, resident enrollment increased by only 10 percent over the last 10 years while nonresident enrollment increased by 432 percent.
- The University lowered the admission standard for non-residents and admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents over the past three years with academic scores that fell below the median of admitted residents.
- Admitted residents were increasingly denied their campus of choice, yet admitted nonresidents were always admitted to one of their campuses of choice.
- Mandatory fees doubled for residents while they increased for nonresidents at a much lower rate.
Among other things the Bureau of State Audits recommended that the University of California (UC) revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the residents it admits.
In response, the UC asserts that its admissions policies overwhelmingly favor Californians, and that state funding determines how many California residents the UC enrolls.
- UC Admissions policy. The Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools (BOARS), oversees all matters relating to the admissions of undergraduate students. BOARS regulates the policies and practices used in the admissions process and recommends and directs efforts to improve the admissions process. According to the UC, its Comprehensive Review Policy governs the admission and selection of undergraduates at its nine campuses. Freshmen applications are assessed using multiple measures of achievement (high school course completion, grade point average, and standardized test scores) and promise while considering applicants’ educational context. Comprehensive review involves consideration of 14 factors, utilized by all campuses, but the specific evaluation process and weight given to each factor differ from campus to campus, and year to year, based on campus-specific goals and needs.
According to the UC this same comprehensive review is applied to nonresident applicants.
- UC Admission Guarantee. UC’s admission guarantee policy, applicable to all California resident high school graduates, includes Statewide Eligibility (SE), Eligibility in the Local Context (ELC), and Entitled to Review (ETR). The UC guarantees admission to the system (though not necessarily to the first-choice campus) to all California applicants who are in the top 9 percent of California high school graduates (SE), or in the top 9 percent of their respective high school class (ELC). The top 9 percent is determined by a formula based on grade point average (GPA) and standardized test scores.
In 2012, the University of California (UC) implemented a new freshman admissions policy, Entitled to Review (ETR). Under this policy, students are not guaranteed admission, but are guaranteed a comprehensive review of their application if they have completed 11 of 15 required a-g courses with a weighted GPA of at least 3.0 by the end of their junior year. The intent was to confer the right to a full application review to a broader pool of college-going California students while ending the practice of excluding many high-achieving students solely on the basis of UC’s extensive standardized testing requirements.
According to the UC, it does not provide a similar guarantee of admission to nonresident students.
- BOARS policy change on admission of nonresidents. In 2011, BOARS approved new guidelines regarding the admission of non-resident and international students that eliminated wording that nonresidents "should demonstrate stronger admission criteria than CA residents by generally being in the upper half of those ordinarily eligible" for admission. BOARS revised its principles to state that admitted nonresidents should "compare favorably to California residents admitted.” In addition, a December 2011 resolution by BOARS resolves that to the fullest extent possible campuses should evaluate and select residents and nonresidents according to the same criteria and scores, enrollment targets for nonresidents should be set such that admitted nonresidents compare favorably to at each campus, campus Senate admissions committees should work with local campus administration, and if needed BOARS and systemwide administration to ensure these principles are being met. At the end of each admission cycle BOARS resolved that each campus provide an assessment of the extent to which the compare favorable rule is being met to include a description of, the evaluation/selection criteria, measures, and supporting data.
- Compromise? According to the UC, inconsistent with the central tenet of their admissions policy of comprehensive review, this bill would frame UC’s approach to admissions in a manner overly reliant on test scores and GPAs to compare the relative merits of students. The UC reports that the current policy on nonresidents includes the following provisions:
- Nonresident applicants must have a higher GPA than resident applicants.
- There is no guarantee of admission for nonresidents, while there is for California residents.
- Nonresident students must be at least as qualified, on average, as admitted students across the system.
In addition the UC indicates that the President of the University will ask the Academic Senate to review its current policy regarding nonresident admission and the University is committed to full transparency on their compliance with the policy by reporting annually on the relative qualifications of admitted residents and non-residents.
If it is the desire of the committee to advance this bill, staff recommends the bill be amended beginning on page 3, line 10 to strike the current language and insert the following:
- The University of California (UC), in collaboration with the Academic Senate, shall ensure that implementation of any admissions policy it adopts regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students shall include guidance that ensures that the academic qualifications for admitted nonresident undergraduate students generally exceeds, on average, the academic qualifications of resident undergraduate students admitted at each campus.
- The UC shall annually report to the Legislature regarding the implementation of this policy, including the mean and median scores on academic indicators of admitted nonresident and resident undergraduate students at each campus.
- Similar legislation. SCA 12 (Runner and Huff) proposed to modify Article IX of the State Constitution to require the UC Regents to ensure that priority in admissions is given to applicants who are California residents. SCA 12 was heard and passed by this Committee on April 20, 2016, but was subsequently held in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SUPPORT
None received on this version.
OPPOSITION
University of California
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:
Author:(McCarty and Medina)
As Amended Ver:May 27, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Higher Education | 10-3 | Medina, Baker, Chávez, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Linder, Low, Olsen, Santiago, Weber | Bloom, Levine, Williams |
Appropriations | 19-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood | Bloom, Levine, Williams |
SUMMARY: Revises provisions governing the nonresident tuition at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to comply with the following:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 10% of total undergraduate student enrollment by the 2022-23 academic year;
- Provides that in each year between 2017-18 and 2022-23, the UC shall increase resident undergraduate student enrollments by 5,000 and decrease nonresident student enrollment by 1,700.
- Prohibits any UC campus at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling a number of new nonresidents in excess of the number of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in 2015-16.
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
- The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus;
- The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus;
- The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various UC campuses; and,
- For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended.
- Requires, by July 1, 2017, UC to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require each campus to only admit undergraduate nonresidents that stand in the upper half of those admitted undergraduate resident students at that campus. Requires related annual reporting, as specified.
- Provides that UC will not be required to comply with the nonresident/resident enrollment requirements in any year where the Budget Act provides less funding than was provided to UC in the prior year.
- Provides Legislative intent that the enrollment changes will be funded by a combination of state funding, savings from operational efficiencies implemented by the UC, and increases in nonresident undergraduate student tuition and fees.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that a student classified as a nonresident pay nonresident tuition. Current law authorizes both the UC and the California State University (CSU) to establish nonresident student tuition policies and methodologies to be developed by each institution's governing body. The annual fee rate is prohibited from falling below the marginal cost of instruction and the rates at comparison institutions, as identified by the California Postsecondary Education Commission, must be considered. (Education Code Sections 68050-68052)
- Establishes UC as a public trust and confers the full powers of the UC upon the UC Regents. The Constitution establishes that the UC is subject to legislative control only to the degree necessary to ensure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of its endowments. Judicial decisions have held that there are three additional areas in which there may be limited legislative intrusion into university operations: authority over the appropriation of state moneys; exercise of the general police power to provide for the public health, safety and welfare; and, legislation on matters of general statewide concern not involving internal university affairs. (California Constitution, Article IX, Section 9)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, General Fund costs for increased enrollment growth are about $20 million in 2019-20, and $200 million in 2022-23. The enrollment growth is also projected to be funded with $50 million worth of operating efficiencies and $250 million in revenue for increased nonresident tuition increases.
COMMENTS: Purpose of this bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to tuition and fee revenues. As of the 2015-16 academic year, tuition and fees for nonresidents is $38,108 and for resident students is $13,400 a year. All additional revenue derived from out of state students stays with the local campus. The author points to recent enrollment numbers, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, and increased nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the reduction proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
Background. Historically, the state provided UC (and CSU) with funding each year to support enrollment growth. Enrollment targets were generally set by using forecasts for high school graduation rates and the overall population of 18- to 24-year-olds, and through negotiation with the segments as to an appropriate per-student amount of funding, referred to as the marginal cost. The most recent marginal cost rate for UC is approximately $10,000 for each additional student. Due to recession-era budget cuts and current administration preference, enrollment targets have been eliminated from the budget. No enrollment targets have been included in the past two Budget Acts.
The 2015-16 Budget Act provides UC incentive funding of $25 million General Fund if UC increases enrollment by 5,000 California undergraduate students by 2016-17. UC was also directed to use financial aid previously awarded to nonresident students ($36.8 million in 2014‑15) to support increased enrollment of California students. While the Fall 2015 enrollment data shows a slight drop in California resident undergraduate enrollment, UC has indicated it intends to meet the Budget Act requirement and increase California undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 students over the next three academic years.
The state has traditionally considered only resident students when determining enrollment for UC because the state does not provide funding for nonresident students. Current law allows UC to set nonresident enrollment levels and fees, requiring that nonresident fees, at minimum, cover marginal costs. UC policy also allows campuses to keep the extra revenue generated by nonresident tuition. Thus, campuses have a major incentive to admit and enroll more nonresident students.
In Fall 2015, systemwide, California freshman admissions were reduced by 2.1% (1,319 students) from 2014 while nonresident admissions increased by 13.2% (3,513) from 2014.
Nonresident students received 34% of offers at UC Berkeley, 41% at UCLA, 39% at UC San Diego and 35% at UC Davis. Fall 2015 enrollment figures show that UC admitted 1,319 fewer California freshmen, but increased (new and continuing) nonresident enrollments by about 4,700 systemwide (new nonresidents grew 1,182).
While UC has sought to limit nonresident enrollment at the Berkeley and UCLA, other UC campuses have significantly increased nonresident student numbers. The Davis, Irvine, San Diego and Santa Cruz campuses all report significant increases in nonresident admissions during the past three years. Nonresidents are currently 15.5% of undergraduate enrollments.
California State Auditor Report. On March 28, 2016, the California State Auditor (CSA) released Report 2015-107, entitled "The University of California: Its Admissions and Financial Decisions Have Disadvantaged California Resident Students." According to the CSA report, among other findings:
- UC's decision to increase the enrollment of nonresidents has made it more difficult for California residents to gain admission to the university.
- Since 2011, UC has required nonresidents to "compare favorably" to residents; formerly, it had required nonresidents to meet the standards of the upper half of admitted Californians. Since the change, UC admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents whose scores fell below the median scores for admitted residents at the same campus on every academic test score and grade point average evaluated.
- UC could have taken additional steps to generate savings and revenue internally to mitigate the impact of its admissions and financial decisions on residents. For example, spending on employee salaries increased in eight of the last nine fiscal years. UC publicly claimed that it redirected $664 million to its academic and research missions through an initiative it developed called Working Smarter; it could not substantiate the asserted savings or revenue amounts or demonstrate how much of this amount directly benefited students.
- "Rebenching" has not completely resolved its unequal distribution of per-student state funding across its campuses, resulting in certain campuses continuing to receive less state funds per student than others.
- Even though UC asserts that the additional revenue from its increased enrollment of nonresidents allows it to improve education quality and enroll more residents, the university does not give campuses spending guidance or track how they use these funds. Lacking such guidance or oversight, we found campuses spend these funds in an inconsistent manner.
The CSA recommended, among other items, that UC revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the residents it admits, and that the Legislature amend state law to limit the percentage of nonresidents that the university can enroll each year.
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Metune / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0003093
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:
Author:(McCarty and Medina)
As Amended Ver:May 27, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Higher Education | 10-3 | Medina, Baker, Chávez, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Linder, Low, Olsen, Santiago, Weber | Bloom, Levine, Williams |
Appropriations | 19-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood | Bloom, Levine, Williams |
SUMMARY: Revises provisions governing the nonresident tuition at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to comply with the following:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 10% of total undergraduate student enrollment by the 2022-23 academic year;
- Provides that in each year between 2017-18 and 2022-23, the UC shall increase resident undergraduate student enrollments by 5,000 and decrease nonresident student enrollment by 1,700.
- Prohibits any UC campus at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling a number of new nonresidents in excess of the number of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in 2015-16.
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
- The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus;
- The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus;
- The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various UC campuses; and,
- For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended.
- Requires, by July 1, 2017, UC to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require each campus to only admit undergraduate nonresidents that stand in the upper half of those admitted undergraduate resident students at that campus. Requires related annual reporting, as specified.
- Provides that UC will not be required to comply with the nonresident/resident enrollment requirements in any year where the Budget Act provides less funding than was provided to UC in the prior year.
- Provides Legislative intent that the enrollment changes will be funded by a combination of state funding, savings from operational efficiencies implemented by the UC, and increases in nonresident undergraduate student tuition and fees.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that a student classified as a nonresident pay nonresident tuition. Current law authorizes both the UC and the California State University (CSU) to establish nonresident student tuition policies and methodologies to be developed by each institution's governing body. The annual fee rate is prohibited from falling below the marginal cost of instruction and the rates at comparison institutions, as identified by the California Postsecondary Education Commission, must be considered. (Education Code Sections 68050-68052)
- Establishes UC as a public trust and confers the full powers of the UC upon the UC Regents. The Constitution establishes that the UC is subject to legislative control only to the degree necessary to ensure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of its endowments. Judicial decisions have held that there are three additional areas in which there may be limited legislative intrusion into university operations: authority over the appropriation of state moneys; exercise of the general police power to provide for the public health, safety and welfare; and, legislation on matters of general statewide concern not involving internal university affairs. (California Constitution, Article IX, Section 9)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, General Fund costs for increased enrollment growth are about $20 million in 2019-20, and $200 million in 2022-23. The enrollment growth is also projected to be funded with $50 million worth of operating efficiencies and $250 million in revenue for increased nonresident tuition increases.
COMMENTS: Purpose of this bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to tuition and fee revenues. As of the 2015-16 academic year, tuition and fees for nonresidents is $38,108 and for resident students is $13,400 a year. All additional revenue derived from out of state students stays with the local campus. The author points to recent enrollment numbers, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, and increased nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the reduction proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
Background. Historically, the state provided UC (and CSU) with funding each year to support enrollment growth. Enrollment targets were generally set by using forecasts for high school graduation rates and the overall population of 18- to 24-year-olds, and through negotiation with the segments as to an appropriate per-student amount of funding, referred to as the marginal cost. The most recent marginal cost rate for UC is approximately $10,000 for each additional student. Due to recession-era budget cuts and current administration preference, enrollment targets have been eliminated from the budget. No enrollment targets have been included in the past two Budget Acts.
The 2015-16 Budget Act provides UC incentive funding of $25 million General Fund if UC increases enrollment by 5,000 California undergraduate students by 2016-17. UC was also directed to use financial aid previously awarded to nonresident students ($36.8 million in 2014‑15) to support increased enrollment of California students. While the Fall 2015 enrollment data shows a slight drop in California resident undergraduate enrollment, UC has indicated it intends to meet the Budget Act requirement and increase California undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 students over the next three academic years.
The state has traditionally considered only resident students when determining enrollment for UC because the state does not provide funding for nonresident students. Current law allows UC to set nonresident enrollment levels and fees, requiring that nonresident fees, at minimum, cover marginal costs. UC policy also allows campuses to keep the extra revenue generated by nonresident tuition. Thus, campuses have a major incentive to admit and enroll more nonresident students.
In Fall 2015, systemwide, California freshman admissions were reduced by 2.1% (1,319 students) from 2014 while nonresident admissions increased by 13.2% (3,513) from 2014.
Nonresident students received 34% of offers at UC Berkeley, 41% at UCLA, 39% at UC San Diego and 35% at UC Davis. Fall 2015 enrollment figures show that UC admitted 1,319 fewer California freshmen, but increased (new and continuing) nonresident enrollments by about 4,700 systemwide (new nonresidents grew 1,182).
While UC has sought to limit nonresident enrollment at the Berkeley and UCLA, other UC campuses have significantly increased nonresident student numbers. The Davis, Irvine, San Diego and Santa Cruz campuses all report significant increases in nonresident admissions during the past three years. Nonresidents are currently 15.5% of undergraduate enrollments.
California State Auditor Report. On March 28, 2016, the California State Auditor (CSA) released Report 2015-107, entitled "The University of California: Its Admissions and Financial Decisions Have Disadvantaged California Resident Students." According to the CSA report, among other findings:
- UC's decision to increase the enrollment of nonresidents has made it more difficult for California residents to gain admission to the university.
- Since 2011, UC has required nonresidents to "compare favorably" to residents; formerly, it had required nonresidents to meet the standards of the upper half of admitted Californians. Since the change, UC admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents whose scores fell below the median scores for admitted residents at the same campus on every academic test score and grade point average evaluated.
- UC could have taken additional steps to generate savings and revenue internally to mitigate the impact of its admissions and financial decisions on residents. For example, spending on employee salaries increased in eight of the last nine fiscal years. UC publicly claimed that it redirected $664 million to its academic and research missions through an initiative it developed called Working Smarter; it could not substantiate the asserted savings or revenue amounts or demonstrate how much of this amount directly benefited students.
- "Rebenching" has not completely resolved its unequal distribution of per-student state funding across its campuses, resulting in certain campuses continuing to receive less state funds per student than others.
- Even though UC asserts that the additional revenue from its increased enrollment of nonresidents allows it to improve education quality and enroll more residents, the university does not give campuses spending guidance or track how they use these funds. Lacking such guidance or oversight, we found campuses spend these funds in an inconsistent manner.
The CSA recommended, among other items, that UC revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the residents it admits, and that the Legislature amend state law to limit the percentage of nonresidents that the university can enroll each year.
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Metune / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0003093
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1711
Author:(McCarty) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 10 - 3 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill places limits on nonresident undergraduate enrollment at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires UC to comply with the following, as a condition of receiving state funds:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment.
- Prohibits any UC campus where undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling any more such students than were enrolled at that campus in 2015-16.
- Beginning in the 2017-18 academic year, requires not less than 50% of the revenues, in excess of the marginal cost of instruction, from newly-enrolled undergraduate nonresident students to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students at all campuses serving undergraduates.
- Requires UC to report annually on nonresident undergraduate tuition levels, tuition revenue, distribution of these revenues among campuses, and uses of these funds, including the number of undergraduate resident students admitted per (1)(c) above.
- Stipulates that UC is not required to comply with (1)(a) and (1)(b) when the Budget Act provides less state support to UC than in the prior fiscal year.
- Requires, by July 1, 2017, UC to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require each campus to only admit undergraduate nonresidents that stand in the upper half of those admitted undergraduate resident students at that campus. Requires related annual reporting, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT:
To the extent the limits in this bill reduce the number of nonresident undergraduates that would otherwise attend UC, the university will forego about $18,000 per student in net revenue—the amount paid by these students in excess of the marginal cost of their instruction. UC notes that, because ever larger classes of nonresidents have been admitted in recent years, if all UC campuses maintained the enrollment of new nonresidents at current levels, total nonresident enrollment at UC would grow above systemwide 15.5% cap in AB 1711. Therefore, all campuses would have to reduce new nonresident enrollments below 2015-16 levels in order to achieve the systemwide cap. For every 1,000 additional nonresidents that UC would otherwise enroll absent this cap, the university would forego about $18 million in net revenue.
UC estimates that when compared to a scenario where nonresident enrollment would otherwise grow at current trends, but not exceed the current 24.3% of enrollment at UC Berkeley, the system would have to reduce enrollments by about 5,300 students in 2017-18—a revenue loss of about $96 million. By 2020-21, UC estimates the impact would be $226 million, based on assumed higher nonresident tuition charges at that time.
The requirement in the bill to redirect 50% of the net revenue from new nonresident undergraduate to fund resident enrollment growth would result in the reallocation of about $74 million in 2017-18, increasing to $120 million in 20-21. The 2017-18 amount would provide funding to enroll about 8,200 new students in 2017-18. (UC is already planning to increase resident undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 over the next three years.) This requirement would result in a reallocation of these resources among campuses and also a diversion of these resources from their current uses.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to the additional tuition and fee revenues paid by nonresidents. For 2015-16, tuition and fees are $38,105 for nonresidents and $13,400 for resident students. Formerly, UC required the supplemental nonresident tuition to be collected centrally and redistributed back to all campuses based on systemwide priorities. Since 2007-08, however, UC has allowed individual campuses to retain the revenue associated with their nonresident supplemental tuition. The author points out that, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, while increasing nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the ratio and budgetary language as proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
This bill prohibits the systemwide undergraduate nonresident enrollment from exceeding the current level of 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment, and prohibits any campus where nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling more new nonresident students than it did in 2015-16. Currently the Berkeley, Irvine, Los Angeles and San Diego campuses are above the 15.5% rate. Under the provisions of this bill, those campuses would only be authorized to enroll the same number of new nonresidents as were enrolled in 2015-16. This provision is intended to allow nonresident enrollment at these campuses but also ensure that, as systemwide resident enrollment increases, nonresident growth (and associated revenue) can occur at campuses with lower nonresident rates.
- State Auditor Report. On March 28, 2016, the California State Auditor (CSA) released Report 2015-107, entitled "The University of California: Its Admissions and Financial Decisions Have Disadvantaged California Resident Students." According to the Auditor’s findings, since 2011, UC has required nonresidents to “compare favorably” to residents; formerly, it had required nonresidents to meet the standards of the upper half of admitted Californians. Since the change, UC admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents whose scores fell below the median scores for admitted residents at the same campus on every academic test score and grade point average evaluated.
The auditor recommended, and this bill requires, that UC revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the admitted residents.
- UC Concerns. UC asserts that, "AB 1711 is based primarily on the faulty premise that nonresidents displace California students and that, therefore, capping nonresident enrollment will create opportunity for more Californians to attend UC. This assumption is inaccurate, as nonresidents are admitted over and above the University’s targets for funded Californians." UC believes that the loss of revenue, as outlined above, will be a detriment to all students. UC argues that the proposed change in admissions policy is inconsistent with its existing admissions policies and will undermine its comprehensive review process.
- Related Legislation. AB 1370 (Medina), pending in Senate Education, prohibits the number of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at any UC campus from exceeding the number enrolled in 2015-16 and requires that, by the 2018-19 and each academic year thereafter, not less than 50% of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction, generated from undergraduate nonresident enrollment, be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students across all campuses with undergraduate students.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1711 (
Author:McCarty and Medina) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
SUBJECT: University of California: nonresident student enrollment
SUMMARY: Revises provisions governing the nonresident tuition at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to comply with the following:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment;
- Prohibits any UC campus at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling a number of new nonresidents in excess of the number of nonresident undergraduate students enrolled in 2015-16; and,
- Beginning in the 2017-18 academic year, requires not less than 50% of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction from new undergraduate nonresident enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students at all campuses serving undergraduates.
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
- The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus;
- The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus;
- The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various UC campuses; and,
- For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to the aforementioned requirements.
- Requires, by July 1, 2017, UC to establish a policy regarding admission of nonresident undergraduate students to require each campus to only admit undergraduate nonresidents that stand in the upper half of those admitted undergraduate resident students at that campus. Requires related annual reporting, as specified.
- Provides that the nonresident enrollment limitations outlined in (1)(a) and (1)(b) shall be set aside in any year where the Budget Act provides less funding than was provided to UC in the prior year.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that a student classified as a nonresident pay nonresident tuition. Current law authorizes both the UC and the California State University (CSU) to establish nonresident student tuition policies and methodologies to be developed by each institution's governing body. The annual fee rate is prohibited from falling below the marginal cost of instruction and the rates at comparison institutions, as identified by the California Postsecondary Education Commission, must be considered. (Education Code Sections 68050-68052)
- Establishes UC as a public trust and confers the full powers of the UC upon the UC Regents. The Constitution establishes that the UC is subject to legislative control only to the degree necessary to ensure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of its endowments. Judicial decisions have held that there are three additional areas in which there may be limited legislative intrusion into university operations: authority over the appropriation of state moneys; exercise of the general police power to provide for the public health, safety and welfare; and, legislation on matters of general statewide concern not involving internal university affairs. (Constitution of California, Article IX, Section 9)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Purpose of this bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to tuition and fee revenues. As of the 2015-16 academic year, tuition and fees for nonresidents is $38,108 and for resident students is $13,400 a year. All additional revenue derived from out of state students stays with the local campus. The author points to recent enrollment numbers, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, and increased nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the ratio and budgetary language as proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
Background. Historically, the state provided UC (and CSU) with funding each year to support enrollment growth. Enrollment targets were generally set by using forecasts for high school graduation rates and the overall population of 18- to 24-year-olds, and through negotiation with the segments as to an appropriate per-student amount of funding, referred to as the marginal cost. The most recent marginal cost rate for UC is approximately $10,000 for each additional student. Due to recession-era budget cuts and current administration preference, enrollment targets have been eliminated from the budget. No enrollment targets have been included in the past two Budget Acts.
The 2015-16 Budget Act provides UC incentive funding of $25 million General Fund if UC increases enrollment by 5,000 California undergraduate students by 2016-17. UC was also directed to use financial aid previously awarded to nonresident students ($36.8 million in 2014‑15) to support increased enrollment of California students. While the Fall 2015 enrollment data shows a slight drop in California resident undergraduate enrollment, UC has indicated it intends to meet the Budget Act requirement and increase California undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 students over the next three academic years.
The state has traditionally considered only resident students when determining enrollment for UC because the state does not provide funding for nonresident students. Current law allows UC to set nonresident enrollment levels and fees, requiring that nonresident fees, at minimum, cover marginal costs. UC policy also allows campuses to keep the extra revenue generated by nonresident tuition. Thus, campuses have a major incentive to admit and enroll more nonresident students. UC increased nonresident tuition for 2015-16; undergraduate nonresidents now pay $24,708 more than California students in tuition.
In Fall 2015, systemwide, California freshman admissions were reduced by 2.1% (1,319 students) from 2014 while nonresident admissions increased by 13.2% (3,513) from 2014.
Nonresident students received 34% of offers at UC Berkeley, 41% at UCLA, 39% at UC San Diego and 35% at UC Davis. Fall 2015 enrollment figures show that UC admitted 1,319 fewer California freshmen, but increased (new and continuing) nonresident enrollments by about 4,700 systemwide (new nonresidents grew 1,182).
While UC has sought to limit nonresident enrollment at the Berkeley and UCLA, other UC campuses have significantly increased nonresident student numbers. The Davis, Irvine, San Diego and Santa Cruz campuses all report significant increases in nonresident admissions during the past three years. Nonresidents are currently 15.5% of undergraduate enrollments.
The chart below shows the change in new UC enrollments between Fall 2008 and 2015.
University Enrollment | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 |
CA Freshmen | 34,410 | 32,425 | 31,891 | 32,159 | 33,111 | 33,224 | 34,240 | 32,923 |
CCC Transfers | 12,428 | 13,523 | 14,963 | 14,979 | 14,353 | 14,476 | 14,587 | 14,223 |
Non-residents | 3,623 | 3,580 | 4,450 | 6,259 | 7,766 | 9,185 | 9,885 | 11,433 |
% Non-resident | 7% | 7% | 9% | 12% | 14% | 16% | 17% | 20% |
Concerns over nonresident growth. On August, 26, 2015, the Assembly Higher Education Committee and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee No. 2 on Education Finance held a joint oversight hearing to review nonresident student enrollment at UC. Testimony was presented by Ozan Jacquette, assistant professor at the University of Arizona, College Of Education, and coauthor of the working paper "Tuition rich, mission poor: Nonresident enrollment and the changing proportions of low-income and underrepresented minority students at public research universities," (Tuition Rich). According to Jacquette, increases in nonresident enrollment generate more tuition revenue and increase academic profiles. However, nonresident students are more likely to come from high-income families and less likely to be Black or Latino. Jacquette notes that increases in nonresident enrollment may exacerbate access inequalities.
UC nonresident enrollment limitation. In 2009, former-UC President Yudof announced the creation of the UC Commission on the Future, charged with developing a vision for the future of the UC that would reaffirm its role in sustaining California's economy and cultural life while recognizing that limited state resources required the UC to be creative and strategic in meeting that mission. The final report of the Commission was released in November 2010, and included recommendations regarding resident and nonresident enrollment, including that the UC President ensure that the proportion of nonresidents systemwide did not exceed 10%. UC Regents did not adopt the recommendations.
This bill would prohibit the systemwide undergraduate nonresident enrollment from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment and prohibit any campus at which nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling more new nonresident students that it did in 2015-16. Currently UC Berkeley, UC Irvine, UC Los Angeles and UC San Diego are above the 15.5% rate. Under the provisions of this bill, those campuses would only be authorized to enroll the same number of new nonresidents as were enrolled in 2015-16. This provision is intended to allow nonresident enrollment at these campuses but also ensure that, as systemwide resident enrollment increases, nonresident growth (and associated revenue) can occur at campuses with lower nonresident rates.
Funding directed toward California resident access. Formerly, UC required supplemental nonresident tuition to be collected centrally and redistributed back to all campuses based on systemwide priorities. Since 2007-08, UC has allowed individual campuses to retain the revenue associated with nonresident supplemental tuition. UC argues that excess funding generated by nonresident enrollment is used to improve services and access for California students. Under the current UC nonresident tuition structure, only those campuses that enroll nonresidents benefit from the revenue generated by those nonresident enrollments. The author aims to ensure all campuses enrolling additional resident undergraduate students benefit from the revenue generated from nonresidents. This bill would require, beginning in 2017-18, of the revenue generated from new undergraduate nonresident enrollment (about $36,000), in excess of the cost of instruction (about $22,000), 50% to be used to support enrollment of resident students at all UC undergraduate campuses (approximately $7,000 per nonresident).
UC Concerns. UC has issued a letter of deep concern and notes, "last year, President Napolitano directed that nonresident enrollment remain flat at UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles. The University will again limit nonresidents at UC Berkeley and UCLA for 2016-17 and will also impose a limit at UC San Diego for the first time. However, the 15.5 percent limit proposed in this legislation would require reductions in nonresident enrollment at those campuses as well as UC Irvine. The University would have to reduce nonresident enrollment at those four campuses by a collective 4,591 students at a total tuition revenue loss of $179 million—a significant sum that would impair our ability to provide a quality educational experience for California students."
California State Auditor Report. On March 28, 2016, the California State Auditor (CSA) released Report 2015-107, entitled "The University of California: Its Admissions and Financial Decisions Have Disadvantaged California Resident Students." According to the CSA report, among other findings:
- UCs decision to increase the enrollment of nonresidents has made it more difficult for California residents to gain admission to the university.
- Since 2011, UC has required nonresidents to “compare favorably” to residents; formerly, it had required nonresidents to meet the standards of the upper half of admitted Californians. Since the change, UC admitted nearly 16,000 nonresidents whose scores fell below the median scores for admitted residents at the same campus on every academic test score and grade point average evaluated.
- UC could have taken additional steps to generate savings and revenue internally to mitigate the impact of its admissions and financial decisions on residents. For example, spending on employee salaries increased in eight of the last nine fiscal years. UC publicly claimed that it redirected $664 million to its academic and research missions through an initiative it developed called Working Smarter, it could not substantiate the asserted savings or revenue amounts or demonstrate how much of this amount directly benefited students.
- "Rebenching" has not completely resolved its unequal distribution of per-student state funding across its campuses, resulting in certain campuses continuing to receive less state funds per student than others.
- Even though UC asserts that the additional revenue from its increased enrollment of nonresidents allows it to improve education quality and enroll more residents, the university does not give campuses spending guidance or track how they use these funds. Lacking such guidance or oversight, we found campuses spend these funds in an inconsistent manner.
The CSA recommended, among other items, that UC revise its admission standard for nonresidents to require campuses to admit only nonresidents with admissions credentials that place them in the upper half of the residents it admits, and that the Legislature amend state law to limit the percentage of nonresidents that the university can enroll each year.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Federation of Teachers
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Metune / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Date of Hearing: April 12, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1711 (
Author:McCarty and Medina) – As Introduced Ver:January 26, 2016
SUBJECT: University of California: nonresident student enrollment
SUMMARY: Revises provisions governing the nonresident tuition at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to comply with the following:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment;
- Until July 1, 2021, prohibits any UC campus at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new undergraduate nonresident students; and,
- Requires not less than 50% of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction from undergraduate nonresident enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students at all campuses serving undergraduates.
- Requires UC to annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
- The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus;
- The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus;
- The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various UC campuses; and,
- For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to the aforementioned requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that a student classified as a nonresident pay nonresident tuition. Current law authorizes both the UC and the California State University (CSU) to establish nonresident student tuition policies and methodologies to be developed by each institution's governing body. The annual fee rate is prohibited from falling below the marginal cost of instruction and the rates at comparison institutions, as identified by the California Postsecondary Education Commission, must be considered. (Education Code Sections 68050-68052)
- Establishes UC as a public trust and confers the full powers of the UC upon the UC Regents. The Constitution establishes that the UC is subject to legislative control only to the degree necessary to ensure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of its endowments. Judicial decisions have held that there are three additional areas in which there may be limited legislative intrusion into university operations: authority over the appropriation of state moneys; exercise of the general police power to provide for the public health, safety and welfare; and, legislation on matters of general statewide concern not involving internal university affairs. (Constitution of California, Article IX, Section 9)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Purpose of this bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to tuition and fee revenues. As of the 2015-16 academic year, tuition and fees for nonresidents is $38,108 and for resident students is $13,400 a year. All additional revenue derived from out of state students stays with the local campus. The author points to recent enrollment numbers, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, and increased nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the ratio and budgetary language as proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
Background. Historically, the state provided UC (and CSU) with funding each year to support enrollment growth. Enrollment targets were generally set by using forecasts for high school graduation rates and the overall population of 18- to 24-year-olds, and through negotiation with the segments as to an appropriate per-student amount of funding, referred to as the marginal cost. The most recent marginal cost rate for UC is approximately $10,000 for each additional student. Due to recession-era budget cuts and current administration preference, enrollment targets have been eliminated from the budget. No enrollment targets have been included in the past two Budget Acts.
The 2015-16 Budget Act provides UC incentive funding of $25 million General Fund if UC increases enrollment by 5,000 California undergraduate students by 2016-17. UC was also directed to use financial aid previously awarded to nonresident students ($36.8 million in 2014‑15) to support increased enrollment of California students. While the Fall 2015 enrollment data shows a slight drop in California resident undergraduate enrollment, UC has indicated it intends to meet the Budget Act requirement and increase California undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 students over the next three academic years.
The state has traditionally considered only resident students when determining enrollment for UC because the state does not provide funding for nonresident students. Current law allows UC to set nonresident enrollment levels and fees, requiring that nonresident fees, at minimum, cover marginal costs. UC policy also allows campuses to keep the extra revenue generated by nonresident tuition. Thus, campuses have a major incentive to admit and enroll more nonresident students. UC increased nonresident tuition for 2015-16; undergraduate nonresidents now pay $24,708 more than California students in tuition.
In Fall 2015, systemwide, California freshman admissions were reduced by 2.1% (1,319 students) from 2014 while nonresident admissions increased by 13.2% (3,513) from 2014.
Nonresident students received 34% of offers at UC Berkeley, 41% at UCLA, 39% at UC San Diego and 35% at UC Davis. Fall 2015 enrollment figures show that UC admitted 1,319 fewer California freshmen, but increased (new and continuing) nonresident enrollments by about 4,700 systemwide (new nonresidents grew 1,182).
While UC has sought to limit nonresident enrollment at the Berkeley and UCLA, other UC campuses have significantly increased nonresident student numbers. The Davis, Irvine, San Diego and Santa Cruz campuses all report significant increases in nonresident admissions during the past three years. Nonresidents are currently 15.5% of undergraduate enrollments.
Concerns over nonresident growth. On August, 26, 2015, the Assembly Higher Education Committee and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee No. 2 on Education Finance held a joint oversight hearing to review nonresident student enrollment at UC. Testimony was presented by Ozan Jacquette, assistant professor at the University of Arizona, College Of Education, and coauthor of the working paper "Tuition rich, mission poor: Nonresident enrollment and the changing proportions of low-income and underrepresented minority students at public research universities," (Tuition Rich). According to Jacquette, increases in nonresident enrollment generate more tuition revenue and increase academic profiles. However, nonresident students are more likely to come from high-income families and less likely to be Black or Latino. Jacquette notes that increases in nonresident enrollment may exacerbate access inequalities.
UC concerns. UC has issued a letter of deep concern and notes, "last year, President Napolitano directed that nonresident enrollment remain flat at UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles. The University will again limit nonresidents at UC Berkeley and UCLA for 2016-17 and will also impose a limit at UC San Diego for the first time. However, the 15.5 percent limit proposed in this legislation would require reductions in nonresident enrollment at those campuses as well as UC Irvine. The University would have to reduce nonresident enrollment at those four campuses by a collective 4,591 students at a total tuition revenue loss of $179 million—a significant sum that would impair our ability to provide a quality educational experience for California students."
Proposed Amendments.
- UC nonresident enrollment limitation. This bill would prohibit the systemwide undergraduate nonresident enrollment from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment and prohibit any campus at which nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new nonresidents. Currently UC Berkeley, UC Irvine, UC Los Angeles and UC San Diego are above the 15.5% rate.
The author has agreed to accept amendments to allow any campus at which nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% to enroll the same number of new nonresident students that it did in 2015-16.
- Funding directed toward California resident access. This bill would require, of the revenue generated from undergraduate nonresident enrollment (about $36,000), in excess of the cost of instruction (about $22,000), 50% to be used to support enrollment of resident students at all UC undergraduate campuses (approximately $7,000 per nonresident).
The author has agreed to accept amendments to provide for a phase-in of this requirement. Under this phase-in, the requirement would begin in 2017-18 and apply only to new undergraduate nonresident enrollments.
- Budget cut set aside. Currently the bill does not provide for an exception to the nonresident ratios and limitations when necessary to address fiscal imbalance.
The author has agreed to accept an amendment to specify that the nonresident enrollment ratio and limitation shall not be enforced in any budget year where the annual budget has provided the UC less funding as was provided in the prior year.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Federation of Teachers
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Metune / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Date of Hearing: March 15, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1711 (
Author:McCarty and Medina) – As Introduced Ver:January 26, 2016
SUBJECT: University of California: nonresident student enrollment
SUMMARY: Revises provisions governing the nonresident tuition at the University of California (UC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, as a condition of receipt of Budget Act funds, UC to comply with the following:
- Prohibits the percentage of undergraduate nonresident students enrolled at UC systemwide from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment;
- Until July 1, 2021, prohibits any UC campus at which undergraduate nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new undergraduate nonresident students; and,
- Requires not less than 50% of the revenues in excess of the marginal cost of instruction from undergraduate nonresident enrollment to be directed to fund increased enrollment of undergraduate resident students at all campuses serving undergraduates.
- Requires UC to annually publish a report that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, all of the following information:
- The undergraduate nonresident tuition and fee level established at each campus;
- The amount of revenues generated by undergraduate nonresident enrollment at each campus;
- The method by which these revenues were distributed among the various UC campuses; and,
- For each campus, the purposes for which these revenues were expended, including, but not limited to, the number of California resident undergraduate students admitted pursuant to the aforementioned requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that a student classified as a nonresident pay nonresident tuition. Current law authorizes both the UC and the California State University (CSU) to establish nonresident student tuition policies and methodologies to be developed by each institution's governing body. The annual fee rate is prohibited from falling below the marginal cost of instruction and the rates at comparison institutions, as identified by the California Postsecondary Education Commission, must be considered. (Education Code Sections 68050-68052)
- Establishes UC as a public trust and confers the full powers of the UC upon the UC Regents. The Constitution establishes that the UC is subject to legislative control only to the degree necessary to ensure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of its endowments. Judicial decisions have held that there are three additional areas in which there may be limited legislative intrusion into university operations: authority over the appropriation of state moneys; exercise of the general police power to provide for the public health, safety and welfare; and, legislation on matters of general statewide concern not involving internal university affairs. (Constitution of California, Article IX, Section 9)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Purpose of this bill. According to the author, there has been a growing trend at UC to enroll more out of state and international students (nonresidents) at the expense of California students (residents). The author argues that the main reason for this shift in enrollment is due to tuition and fee revenues. As of the 2015-16 academic year, tuition and fees for nonresidents is $38,108 and for resident students is $13,400 a year. All additional revenue derived from out of state students stays with the local campus. The author points to recent enrollment numbers, in the fall of 2015, UC admitted 1,600 fewer resident freshmen compared to fall 2014, and increased nonresident enrollment by 4,700. According to the author, without the cap and budgetary language as proposed in this bill, the UC will continue to grow its non-resident student population at the expense of resident Californians.
Background. Historically, the state provided UC (and CSU) with funding each year to support enrollment growth. Enrollment targets were generally set by using forecasts for high school graduation rates and the overall population of 18- to 24-year-olds, and through negotiation with the segments as to an appropriate per-student amount of funding, referred to as the marginal cost. The most recent marginal cost rate for UC is approximately $10,000 for each additional student. Due to recession-era budget cuts and current administration preference, enrollment targets have been eliminated from the budget. No enrollment targets have been included in the past two Budget Acts.
The 2015-16 Budget Act provides UC incentive funding of $25 million General Fund if UC increases enrollment by 5,000 California undergraduate students by 2016-17. UC was also directed to use financial aid previously awarded to nonresident students ($36.8 million in 2014‑15) to support increased enrollment of California students. While the Fall 2015 enrollment data shows a slight drop in California resident undergraduate enrollment, UC has indicated it intends to meet the Budget Act requirement and increase California undergraduate enrollment by 10,000 students over the next three academic years.
The state has traditionally considered only resident students when determining enrollment for UC because the state does not provide funding for nonresident students. Current law allows UC to set nonresident enrollment levels and fees, requiring that nonresident fees, at minimum, cover marginal costs. UC policy also allows campuses to keep the extra revenue generated by nonresident tuition. Thus, campuses have a major incentive to admit and enroll more nonresident students. UC increased nonresident tuition for 2015-16; undergraduate nonresidents now pay $24,708 more than California students in tuition.
In Fall 2015, systemwide, California freshman admissions were reduced by 2.1% (1,319 students) from 2014 while nonresident admissions increased by 13.2% (3,513) from 2014.
Nonresident students received 34% of offers at UC Berkeley, 41% at UCLA, 39% at UC San Diego and 35% at UC Davis. Fall 2015 enrollment figures show that UC admitted 1,319 fewer California freshmen, but increased (new and continuing) nonresident enrollments by about 4,700 systemwide (new nonresidents grew 1,182).
While UC has sought to limit nonresident enrollment at the Berkeley and UCLA, other UC campuses have significantly increased nonresident student numbers. The Davis, Irvine, San Diego and Santa Cruz campuses all report significant increases in nonresident admissions during the past three years. Nonresidents are currently 15.5% of undergraduate enrollments.
The chart below shows the change in new UC enrollments between Fall 2008 and 2015.
University Enrollment | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 |
CA Freshmen | 34,410 | 32,425 | 31,891 | 32,159 | 33,111 | 33,224 | 34,240 | 32,923 |
CCC Transfers | 12,428 | 13,523 | 14,963 | 14,979 | 14,353 | 14,476 | 14,587 | 14,223 |
Non-residents | 3,623 | 3,580 | 4,450 | 6,259 | 7,766 | 9,185 | 9,885 | 11,433 |
% Non-resident | 7% | 7% | 9% | 12% | 14% | 16% | 17% | 20% |
Concerns over nonresident growth. On August, 26, 2015, the Assembly Higher Education Committee and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee No. 2 on Education Finance held a joint oversight hearing to review nonresident student enrollment at UC. Testimony was presented by Ozan Jacquette, assistant professor at the University of Arizona, College Of Education, and coauthor of the working paper "Tuition rich, mission poor: Nonresident enrollment and the changing proportions of low-income and underrepresented minority students at public research universities," (Tuition Rich). According to Jacquette, increases in nonresident enrollment generate more tuition revenue and increase academic profiles. However, nonresident students are more likely to come from high-income families and less likely to be Black or Latino. Jacquette notes that increases in nonresident enrollment may exacerbate access inequalities.
UC nonresident enrollment limitation. In 2009, former-UC President Yudof announced the creation of the UC Commission on the Future, charged with developing a vision for the future of the UC that would reaffirm its role in sustaining California's economy and cultural life while recognizing that limited state resources required the UC to be creative and strategic in meeting that mission. The final report of the Commission was released in November 2010, and included recommendations regarding resident and nonresident enrollment, including that the UC President ensure that the proportion of nonresidents systemwide did not exceed 10%. UC Regents did not adopt the recommendations.
This bill would prohibit the systemwide undergraduate nonresident enrollment from exceeding 15.5% of total undergraduate student enrollment and would, until July 1, 2021, prohibit any campus at which nonresident enrollment exceeds 15.5% from enrolling new nonresident students. Currently UC Berkeley, UC Irvine, UC Los Angeles and UC San Diego are above the 15.5% rate. Under the provisions of this bill, in the absence of reducing undergraduate nonresidents or increasing undergraduate residents to achieve a rate below 15.5%, campuses would, until July 1, 2021, be prohibited from enrolling new nonresidents. This provision is intended to ensure that, as nonresident students at campuses above 15.5% graduate, nonresident growth (and associated revenue) can occur at campuses with lower nonresident rates.
Funding directed toward California resident access. Formerly, UC required supplemental nonresident tuition to be collected centrally and redistributed back to all campuses based on systemwide priorities. Since 2007-08, UC has allowed individual campuses to retain the revenue associated with nonresident supplemental tuition. UC argues that excess funding generated by nonresident enrollment is used to improve services and access for California students. Under the current UC nonresident tuition structure, only those campuses that enroll nonresidents benefit from the revenue generated by those nonresident enrollments. The author aims to ensure all campuses enrolling additional resident undergraduate students benefit from the revenue generated from nonresidents. This bill would require at least 50% of the revenue generated from undergraduate nonresident enrollment, in excess of the cost of instruction, to be used to support enrollment of resident students at all UC undergraduate campuses.
UC Concerns. UC has issued a letter of deep concern and notes, "last year, President Napolitano directed that nonresident enrollment remain flat at UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles. The University will again cap nonresidents at UC Berkeley and UCLA for 2016-17 and will also impose a cap at UC San Diego for the first time. However, the 15.5 percent limit proposed in this legislation would require reductions in nonresident enrollment at those campuses as well as UC Irvine. The University would have to reduce nonresident enrollment at those four campuses by a collective 4,591 students at a total tuition revenue loss of $179 million—a significant sum that would impair our ability to provide a quality educational experience for California students."
Moving forward, in response to the concerns raised by UC, the author may wish to consider an amendment to specify that this provision shall be set aside when necessary to address fiscal imbalance. Additionally, the author may wish to consider an amendment to allow a limited amount of new nonresident enrollment at campuses above the 15.5% threshold. For example, UC campuses above the cap could be allowed to enroll new nonresidents, but that the total number of undergraduate nonresidents must be a specified number or percentage less than the number enrolled in the prior academic year.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Federation of Teachers
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Metune / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):