AB 414: Suspension and allocation of vacant judgeships.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-03-16
Existing law specifies the number of judges for the superior court of each county. Existing law allocates additional judgeships to the various counties in accordance with uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on specified criteria, including, among others, workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type.
This bill would require the suspension of 5 4 vacant judgeships, as defined, from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need and would require the allocation of 5 4 judgeships to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. The bill would require the suspension to be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council, as specified, and would require the determination of a superior courts assessed judicial need to be in accordance with the above uniform standards and be based on the criteria described above. and allocation of judgeships to be based on a superior courts assessed judicial need in accordance with the uniform standards described above. The bill would require the Judicial Council, if a vacant judgeship is eligible for suspension, to promptly notify the applicable courts, court with the vacant judgeship, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship will be suspended. is subject to suspension, provide an adequate opportunity for public comment, and, after consideration of any comments received, determine if the vacant judgeship should be suspended. The bill would require the Judicial Council to promptly notify the court with the vacant judgeship, the Legislature, and the Governor of its decision regarding suspension of the judgeship. The bill would provide that a court in which a vacant judgeship is suspended will not have its funding allocation reduced or any of its funding shifted or transferred as a result of, or in connection with, the suspension of a vacant judgeship.
This bill would also make a statement of legislative intent regarding the authority of the Legislature, the Governor, and the Chief Justice of California.
Existing law specifies the number of judges for the superior court of each county. Existing law allocates additional judgeships to the various counties in accordance with uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on specified criteria, including, among others, workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type.
This bill would require the allocation of up to suspension of 5 vacant judgeships, as defined, from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need need and would require the allocation of 5 judgeships to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. The bill would require the allocation suspension to be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council, as specified, and would require the determination of a superior courts assessed judicial need to be in accordance with the above uniform standards and be based on the criteria described above. The bill would require the Judicial Council, if a vacant judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court, suspension, to promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship shall be allocated to another court. will be suspended. The bill would provide that a court in which a vacant judgeship is suspended will not have its funding allocation reduced or any of its funding shifted or transferred as a result of, or in connection with, the suspension of a vacant judgeship.
This bill would also make a statement of legislative intent regarding the authority of the Legislature, the Governor, and the Chief Justice of California.
Existing law specifies the number of judges for the superior court of each county. Existing law allocates additional judgeships to the various counties in accordance with uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on specified criteria, including, among others, workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type.
This bill would require the allocation of up to 5 vacant judgeships, as defined, from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. The bill would require the allocation to be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council, as specified, and would require the determination of a superior courts assessed judicial need to be in accordance with the above uniform standards and be based on the criteria described above. The bill would require the Judicial Council, if a vacant judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court, to promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship shall be allocated to another court.
This bill would also make a statement of legislative intent regarding the authority of the Legislature, the Governor, and the Chief Justice of California.
It is the intent of the Legislature that this act shall not be construed to limit any of the following:
(a)The authority of the Legislature to create and fund new judgeships pursuant to Section 4 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(b)The authority of the Governor to appoint a person to fill a vacancy pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 16 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(c)The authority of the Chief Justice of California to assign judges pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 6 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 2.Section 69614.6 is added to the Government Code, to read:69614.6.(a)To provide for a more equitable distribution of judgeships and upon notice to the applicable courts, five pursuant to the process set forth in subdivision (b), four vacant judgeships shall be suspended in superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need and five four judgeships shall be allocated to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need.
(b)(1)The suspension of vacant judgeships and the allocation of judgeships pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council after solicitation of public comments. The determination of based on a superior courts assessed judicial need shall be in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on the criteria set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 69614.
(c)(2)If a judgeship in a superior court becomes vacant, the Judicial Council shall determine whether the judgeship is eligible for suspension under the methodology, standards, and criteria standards and criteria described in subdivision (b). paragraph (1). If the judgeship is eligible for suspension, the Judicial Council shall promptly notify the applicable courts, court with the vacant judgeship, the Legislature, and the Governor that the vacant judgeship shall be suspended. is subject to suspension, provide an adequate opportunity for public comment, and, after consideration of any comments received, determine if the vacant judgeship should be suspended. The Judicial Council shall promptly notify the court with the vacant judgeship, the Legislature, and the Governor of its decision regarding suspension of the judgeship.
(d)(c)(1)For purposes of this section only, a judgeship shall become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office through resignation, retirement, death, removal, or confirmation to an appellate court judgeship during either of the following:
(A)At any time before the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code.
(B)After the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code if no candidate submits qualifying nomination papers by the deadline pursuant to Section 8020 of the Elections Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, a judgeship shall not become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office as a result of being defeated in an election for that office.
(e)(d)For purposes of this section only, the suspension of a vacant judgeship means that the vacant judgeship may not be filled by appointment or election, notwithstanding any other law, unless an appropriation by the Legislature is made for the judgeship.
(f)(e)A court in which a vacant judgeship is suspended shall not have its funding allocation reduced or any funding shifted or transferred as a result of, or in connection with, the suspension of a vacant judgeship pursuant to this section.
It is the intent of the Legislature that this act shall not be construed to limit any of the following:
(a)The authority of the Legislature to create and fund new judgeships pursuant to Section 4 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(b)The authority of the Governor to appoint a person to fill a vacancy pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 16 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(c)The authority of the Chief Justice of California to assign judges pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 6 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 2.Section 69614.6 is added to the Government Code, to read:69614.6.(a)To provide for a more equitable distribution of judgeships and upon notice to the applicable courts, up to five vacant judgeships shall be allocated from suspended in superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need pursuant to the requirements of this section. and five judgeships shall be allocated to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need.
(b)The allocation suspension of vacant judgeships pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council after solicitation of public comments. The determination of a superior courts assessed judicial need shall be in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on the criteria set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 69614.
(c)If a judgeship in a superior court becomes vacant, the Judicial Council shall determine whether the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court suspension under the methodology, standards, and criteria described in subdivision (b). If the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court, suspension, the Judicial Council shall promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship vacated in one court shall be allocated to another court. vacant judgeship shall be suspended.
(d)(1)For purposes of this section only, a judgeship shall become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office through resignation, retirement, death, removal, or confirmation to an appellate court judgeship during either of the following:
(A)At any time before the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code.
(B)After the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code if no candidate submits qualifying nomination papers by the deadline pursuant to Section 8020 of the Elections Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, a judgeship shall not become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office as a result of being defeated in an election for that office.
(e)For purposes of this section only, the suspension of a vacant judgeship means that the vacant judgeship may not be filled by appointment or election, notwithstanding any other law, unless an appropriation by the Legislature is made for the judgeship.
(f)A court in which a vacant judgeship is suspended shall not have its funding allocation reduced or any funding shifted or transferred as a result of, or in connection with, the suspension of a vacant judgeship pursuant to this section.
It is the intent of the Legislature that this act shall not be construed to limit any of the following:
(a)The authority of the Legislature to create and fund new judgeships pursuant to Section 4 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(b)The authority of the Governor to appoint a person to fill a vacancy pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 16 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
(c)The authority of the Chief Justice of California to assign judges pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 6 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 2.Section 69614.6 is added to the Government Code, to read:69614.6.(a)To provide for a more equitable distribution of judgeships and upon notice to the applicable courts, up to five vacant judgeships shall be allocated from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need pursuant to the requirements of this section.
(b)The allocation of vacant judgeships pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council after solicitation of public comments. The determination of a superior courts assessed judicial need shall be in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on the criteria set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 69614.
(c)If a judgeship in a superior court becomes vacant, the Judicial Council shall determine whether the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court under the methodology, standards, and criteria described in subdivision (b). If the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court, the Judicial Council shall promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship vacated in one court shall be allocated to another court.
(d)(1)For purposes of this section only, a judgeship shall become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office through resignation, retirement, death, removal, or confirmation to an appellate court judgeship during either of the following:
(A)At any time before the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code.
(B)After the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office pursuant to Section 8023 of the Elections Code if no candidate submits qualifying nomination papers by the deadline pursuant to Section 8020 of the Elections Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, a judgeship shall not become vacant when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office as a result of being defeated in an election for that office.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 13, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 10, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 74. Noes 0. Page 1143.) |
| Apr 6, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (April 5). |
| Mar 21, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (March 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 20, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 16, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 9, 2017 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 7, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 6, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 21, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 10, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 12. |
| Feb 9, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 20, 2017 | Favorable (Education Committee) | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 5, 2017 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 21, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 414 (Author:Medina)
Version: March 16, 2017
Hearing Date: June 13, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MS
SUBJECT
Suspension and allocation of vacant judgeships
DESCRIPTION
This bill would require that up to four vacant judgeships be allocated from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. This bill would also require that the allocation of vacant judgeships be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council, as specified.
BACKGROUND
This bill, along with SB 39 (Roth, 2017) and SB 38 (Roth, 2017), is the latest in a series of bills attempting to increase the number of judgeships in the superior courts that have the most need. This bill would require that up to four vacant judgeships be allocated from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. This bill would also require that the allocation of vacant judgeships be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council, as specified. This bill is almost identical to last year’s AB 2341 (Obernolte), which was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Last year, this committee was the author of Senate Bill 1023 which aimed to appropriate $5 million from the General Fund for the purpose of funding 12 of the 50 previously authorized superior court judgeships and accompanying staff. This bill was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee. Prior to that, the Governor vetoed SB 229 (Roth, 2015), a bill that was almost identical to SB 1023 and SB 38. In his veto message, the Governor stated that he intended to work with the Judicial Council to develop a system wide approach to balance the workload and the distribution of judgeships around the state. As part of the Governor’s 2016 proposed budget, the Governor proposed a budget trailer bill to reallocate two vacant judgeships each to the counties of Riverside and San Bernardino. This proposal was not part of the final 2016 Budget.
This year the Governor’s budget proposal again contains a proposal to reallocate judges. In his 2017 proposed budget, the Governor proposes a total funding of $3.6 billion for the Judicial Branch. Additionally, the Administration proposes to reallocate four vacant superior court judgeships. This change “will shift judgeships to the areas of the state where workload is highest without increasing the overall number of judges.” (Governor’s Budget Summary 2017-18, Judicial Branch, p. 14.)
According to the Judicial Council’s November 2016 report, “a critical shortage of judges relative to the workload needs in California’s trial courts” remains, with nearly 189 additional judges needed. (Jud. Council of Cal., Rep. on the Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 2016 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment (Nov. 2016), p. 2.)
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that the Legislature shall prescribe the number of judges and provide for the officers and employees of each superior court. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 4.)
Existing law specifies the number of superior court judges in each of the 58 counties. (Gov. Code Secs. 69580-69611.)
Existing law establishes that in the County of:
- Alameda there are 69 superior court judges. (Gov. Code Sec. 69580.)
- Santa Clara there are 79 superior court judges. (Gov. Code Sec. 69600.)
- San Bernardino there are 63 superior court judges. (Gov. Code Sec. 69594.)
- Riverside there are 49 superior court judges. (Gov. Code Sec. 69592.)
- Orange there are 109 superior court judges. (Gov. Code Sec. 69591.)
Existing law authorizes 50 additional superior court judges to be allocated to the various superior courts pursuant to uniform criteria adopted by the Judicial Council, upon appropriation in the 2007-08 fiscal year. (Gov. Code Sec. 69614.2)
Existing law requires that the uniform criteria for determining additional judicial need take into account the following: (1) court filings data averaged over a three-year period; (2) workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and non-bench work required to resolve each case type; and (3) a ranking methodology that provides consideration for courts that have the greatest need relative to their current complement of judicial officers. (Gov. Code Sec. 69614)
Existing law specifies the composition and duties of the Judicial Council (Council), requires judges to report to the Council as the Chief Justice directs concerning the condition of judicial business in their courts, requires judges to cooperate with the Council and hold court as assigned, and specifies that the Chief Justice:
- shall seek to expedite judicial business and to equalize the work of judges;
- may provide for the assignment of any judge to another court but only with the judge’s consent if the court is of lower jurisdiction; and
- may assign a retired judge who consents to any court. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 6.)
Existing law specifies the process for electing superior court Judges, and for their appointment by the Governor. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 16).
This bill would state that is the intent of the Legislature that this act shall not be construed to limit the authority of:
- the Legislature to create and fund new judgeships pursuant to Section 4 of Article VI of the California Constitution;
- the Governor to appoint a person to fill a vacancy pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 16 of Article VI of the California Constitution; or
- the Chief Justice of California to assign judges pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 6 of Article VI of the California Constitution.
This bill would require that up to four vacant judgeships be allocated from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to provide for a more equitable distribution of judgeships and upon notice to the applicable courts.
This bill would require that the allocation of vacant judgeships be in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council after solicitation of public comments, and that the determination of a superior court’s assessed judicial need be in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on the criteria set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 69614.
This bill would provide that if a judgeship in a superior court becomes vacant, the Judicial Council shall determine whether the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court under the methodology, standards, and criteria described above, and if the judgeship is eligible for allocation to another superior court, the Judicial Council must promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor that the judgeship vacated in one court shall be allocated to another court.
This bill would provide that the Judicial Council shall, following notification to the applicable courts, the Legislature, and the Governor, provide an adequate opportunity for public comment, consider any comments received, and then determine if the vacant judgeship should be suspended. The Judicial Council shall then promptly notify the court with the vacant judgeship, the Legislature, and the Governor of its decision regarding suspension of the judgeship.
This bill would specify that a judgeship becomes “vacant” when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office through resignation, retirement, death, removal, or confirmation to an appellate court judgeship during either of the following:
- at any time before the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office, as specified; or
- after the deadline to file a declaration of intention to become a candidate for a judicial office if no candidate submits qualifying nomination papers by the deadline.
This bill would provide that a judgeship shall not become “vacant” when an incumbent judge relinquishes the office as a result of being defeated in an election for that office.
COMMENT
- Stated need for this bill
According to the Author:
The Legislature has not kept pace with the courts workload, leaving many with shortfalls between the numbers of judgeships needed compared to the number that has been authorized. The assessed need, according to the report, is greatest in San Bernardino County and Riverside County. These counties are 40% to 60% short of judges to adequately handle the court workload. In contrast, some courts have more judges than their assessed need.
The public’s right to timely access to justice should not be contingent on the resource levels in the county in which they reside or bring their legal disputes. All Californians deserve the proper number of judicial officers needed to handle the workload.
- Superior court judge shortage throughout California
Under existing law, the Judicial Council is required to report to the Legislature on or before November 1st of every even-numbered year on the need for new judgeships in each superior court. (Gov. Code Sec. 69614.) The most recent report, The Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 206 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment, found that a critical need for new judgeships remains and that nearly 189 new judgeships are needed to meet the workload-based need in the trial courts. (Jud. Council of Cal., Rep. on the Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 2016 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment (Nov. 2016), p. 2.) The report goes on to explain that:
Consistent with reports submitted in previous years, the 2016 Judicial Needs Assessment shows that there is a critical shortage of judges relative to the workload needs in California’s trial courts. [The report] summarizes the statewide judicial need compared to available resources based on a three year average of filings from fiscal years 2012-2013 through 2014-2015, showing that 2,048.6 [full-time equivalent judicial positions (FTEs)] judicial officers are needed statewide, compared to 1,960.1 FTE authorized and funded positions. … While Assembly Bill 159 (Stats. 2007, ch. 722) authorized 50 new judgeships for the superior courts, those positions have neither been funded nor filled. (Id.)
Staff notes that this year’s assessment shows the overall statewide need for judicial officers has declined by 122.7 FTEs since the 2014 Judicial Needs Assessment. The assessment states this is due to overall lower filing counts occurring in recent years. (Id.) This statewide decrease has not changed the severe need faced in particular counties. For example, Riverside County and San Bernardino County together account for half of the entire statewide need, with Riverside County needing 46.8 FTEs and San Bernardino needing 48.1 FTEs. The Judicial Needs Assessment shows how disproportionate the need of this Inland Southern California region is from the rest of the state by looking to the next three largest deficits in terms of FTEs. They are Kern County at 13.8, Fresno County at 12.8, and Sacramento County at 10.4.
In response to the continued need for additional judgeships, and faced with the reality that the Legislature’s recent attempts to fund authorized judgeships have failed, this bill seeks to allow the Judicial Council to move up to four vacant judgeships from superior courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need to superior courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need.
- The Legislature has the Constitutional authority to prescribe the number of judges in each superior court
The California Constitution vests the Legislature with the duty to “prescribe the number of judges and provide for the officers and employees of each superior court.” (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 4.) In opposition, the Alliance of California Judges writes “[t]he allocation of judgeships is best decided after vigorous and public debate by our elected representatives, not according to some obscure calculation performed by unelected and unaccountable bodies using a formula that can be tweaked at will.” They further assert that this bill “violates Article VI, section 4 of the California Constitution which gives
to the Legislature – not the Judicial Council or the Administrative Office of the Courts – the authority to decide how many judges should sit in each county.”
The Legislature has set the number of superior court judges in each of the 58 counties. However, the Legislature has also authorized new superior court judgeships without specifying in which particular counties those judges should be allocated. The Legislature has previously given the Judicial Council a role in determining where new judicial positions would be located. Indeed, current law authorizes 50 new superior court judgeships, upon funding, and authorizes the allocation of the judgeships to particular counties to be determined pursuant to uniform criteria as updated and approved by the Judicial Council. Existing law requires that the uniform criteria for determining additional judicial need take into account the following: (1) court filings data averaged over a three-year period; (2) workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and non-bench work required to resolve each case type; and (3) a ranking methodology that provides consideration for courts that have the greatest need relative to their current complement of judicial officers. (Gov. Code Secs. 69614, 69614.2.)
Support: None Known
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Judicial Council of California
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 39 (Roth, 2017) is almost identical to this bill. SB 39 differs from AB 414 in that it would require proposed suspensions be approved by the Governor in compliance with subdivision (c) of Section 16 of Article VI of the California Constitution. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 38 (Roth, 2017) would appropriate $14,813,000 from the General Fund to the judicial branch to fund the cost of 10 new superior court judgeships and accompanying staff. As well as increase the number of appellate court justices from seven to eight in Division 2 of the Court of Appeal for the Fourth Appellate District, with an appropriation of $1,202,000 for the funding of this appellate judge and accompanying staff. This bill is in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1023 (Committee on Judiciary, 2016) See Background.
AB 2341 (Obernolte, 2016) See Background.
SB 229 (Roth, 2015) See Background.
AB 1519 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 416, Stats. 2015), among other things, authorized Judicial Council to convert 10 subordinate judicial officer positions, as specified.
AB 1313 (Donnelly, 2014) would have required allocation of additional judges to courts with the greatest disparity between their current judicial allocation and their assessed judicial need. This bill failed to pass through the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 159 (Jones, Ch. 722, Stats. 2007) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 74, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 17, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing: April 5, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 414
Author:(Medina) – As Amended Ver:March 16, 2017
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill suspends four vacant judgeships (suspended judgeships may not be filled by appointment or election) in superior courts that are determined to have more authorized judgeships than assessed need, and allocates the judgeships to superior courts with fewer judgeships than the assessed need. The determination of suspended and allocated judgeships would be based on an assessment of judicial needs that includes uniform standards for determining needs, and is in accordance with a methodology approved by the Judicial Council after the solicitation of public comments. This bill also specifies that courts with judgeships that are suspended under this bill will not have a reduction in funding as a result of a suspended judgeship.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No increase in costs because (1) the judgeships to be reallocated are already authorized and funded and, (2) funding for associated court staff is already redistributed among courts based on workload needs according to the Workload-based Allocation and Funding Methodology (WAFM).
COMMENTS:
- Background. Historically, courts were county-funded entities and funding levels varied significantly among individual courts. As a result, the state assumed responsibility for funding the courts in 1997 as authorized by the Lockyer-Isenberg Trial Court Funding Act, AB 233 (Escutia and Pringle), Chapter 850, Statutes of 1997. After the state took over funding, the courts in general received significant increases in funding and historically underfunded courts saw even greater increases. However, most of the state funding continued to be distributed based on historical allocations. In 2013, the Judicial Council—the statewide policymaking body of the courts—approved the WAFM formula to base funding levels for court staff and resources on workload.
However, the allocation of judgeships—the actual judges that preside in the courts—is not changed by WAFM. In order to understand how the number of authorized judges in each court compares to workload, Judicial Council conducts a judicial workload assessment every other year. The most recent such assessment in 2016 found that overall California courts need more judges than the currently authorized level. However, some courts have more judgeships than the assessed need and others have significantly fewer judgeships than the assessed need.
- Purpose. This bill would partially address the imbalance between authorized judgeships and assessed need by suspending four vacant judgeships in courts with more judgeships than assessed judicial need and allocating them to courts with fewer judgeships than the assessed need. The author notes that some courts in particular, such as Riverside and San Bernardino, have only roughly 60 percent of the judgeships needed. Further, the author states “the public’s right to timely access to justice should not be contingent on the resource levels in the county in which they reside or bring their legal disputes. All Californians deserve the proper number of judicial officers needed to handle the workload.”
- Prior Legislation. AB 159 (Jones), Chapter 722, Statutes of 2007, authorized, upon appropriation, an additional 50 judgeships. However, these judgeships have never been funded. SB 229 (Roth), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, would have allocated the funding for the 50 judgeships, but was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message, the Governor stated “I am aware that the need for judges in many courts is acute—Riverside and San Bernardino are two clear examples. However, before funding any new positions, I intend to work with the Judicial Council to develop a more systemwide approach to balance the workload and the distribution of judgeships around the state.
- Related Legislation/ Budget Proposal. SB 39 (Roth), which is pending in the Senate, is nearly identical to this bill. In addition, the Governor’s 2017-18 budget package includes proposed trailer legislation that would reallocate four judgeships by reducing the number of authorized judgeships in Alameda and Santa Clara counties by two each and providing an increase of two judges each to Riverside and San Bernardino counties.
Analysis Prepared by: Jessica Peters / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUBJECT: SUSPENSION AND ALLOCATION OF VACANT JUDGESHIPS
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD FOUR JUDGESHIPS, WHEN VACANT, BE SUSPENDED FROM COURTS WITH BETTER THAN AVERAGE JUDICIAL ALLOCATION AND ALLOCATED TO COURTS WITH WORSE THAN AVERAGE JUDICIAL ALLOCATION TO HELP ENSURE EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE ACROSS THE STATE?
SYNOPSIS
Historically, trial courts in California were county entities, funded by the counties. Not only did funding levels vary greatly across the trial courts, but so did the number of judgeships. As a result, courts have varying needs for additional judges. According to the Judicial Council's 2016 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment, adopted by the Judicial Council in October of last year, California currently needs an additional 88.5 judges statewide. Considering specific courts, 31 courts need a total of 188.5 judges, based on workload, with the greatest need in Riverside and San Bernardino, while 14 courts have at least one more judge than their assessed need, with the greatest excess capacity in Alameda and Santa Clara.
Currently 50 trial court judges have been authorized by the Legislature (AB 159 (Jones), Chap. 722, Stats. 2007), but funding for those positions has not yet been appropriated. The last bill to attempt to get funding for those additional judgeships -- SB 229 (Roth, 2015) -- passed the Legislature, but was vetoed by the Governor, who wrote: "I am aware that the need for judges in many courts is acute - Riverside and San Bernardino are two clear examples. However, before funding any new positions, I intend to work with the Judicial Council to develop a more systemwide approach to balance the workload and the distribution of judgeships around the state." This bill seeks to do just that by suspending four vacant judgeships in courts with more judgeships than their assessed need and allocating four judgeships to courts with fewer judgeships than their assessed need, based on the most recent Judicial Needs Assessment and a process set forth in the bill. It is likely that, under the process set forth in this bill, vacant judgeships in Alameda and Santa Clara Counties would be suspended and additional judgeships allocated to courts in Riverside and San Bernardino Counties.
In support of the bill, the author states: "The public’s right to timely access to justice should not be contingent on the resource levels in the county in which they reside or bring their legal disputes. All Californians deserve the proper number of judicial officers needed to handle the workload." The Alliance of California Judges opposes the bill, arguing that "allocation of judgeships is best decided after vigorous and public debate by our elected representatives, not according to some obscure calculation performed by unelected and unaccountable bodies using a formula that can be tweaked at will." Santa Clara Superior Court had opposed an earlier version of the bill that would have suspended five judgeships, but does not oppose this version of the bill.
SUMMARY: Requires suspension of four vacant judgeships from courts with more authorized judgeships than assessed need and allocation of four judgeships to courts with fewer authorized judgeships than assessed need. Specifically, this bill:
- In order to provide for a more equitable distribution of judgeships, provides that four vacant judgeships, as defined, be suspended in courts with more authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need and four judgeships be allocated to courts with fewer authorized judgeships than their assessed judicial need. Provides that this shall be done in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial needs in each county, as updated and approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the Update of Judicial Needs Study, based on specified criteria.
- If a judgeship become vacant, as defined, requires the Judicial Council to determine whether the judgeship is eligible for suspension under 1), above, and, if so, to:
- Promptly notify the applicable court, the Legislature and the Governor that the vacant judgeships is subject to suspension;
- Provide an adequate opportunity for public comment;
- After consideration of any comments received, determine if the judgeship should be suspended; and
- Promptly notify the applicable court, the Legislature and the Governor of the decision regarding suspension of the judgeship.
- Provides that "suspension" of a vacant judgeship means that the vacancy may not be filled by appointment or election, unless an appropriation is made for the judgeship by the Legislature.
- Provides that a court in which a vacant judgeship is suspended may not have its funding allocation reduced or any funding shifted or transferred as a result of the suspension.
- States the intent of the Legislature that this bill not be construed to limit (a) the authority of the Legislature to create and fund new judgeships; (b) the authority of the Governor to appoint judges to fill judicial vacancies; and (c) the authority of the Chief Justice to assign judges as provided.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the Legislature shall prescribe the number of judges of each superior court. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 4.)
- Provides that the Legislature may allow the trial courts to appoint officers such as commissioners to perform subordinate judicial duties. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 22.)
- Specifies the process for electing superior court judges, and for their appointment by the Governor. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 16.)
- Specifies the composition and duties of the Judicial Council, requires judges to report to the Judicial Council as the Chief Justice directs concerning the condition of judicial business in their courts, requires judges to cooperate with the Judicial Council and hold court as assigned, and specifies that the Chief Justice:
- Shall seek to expedite judicial business and to equalize the work of judges;
- May provide for the assignment of any judge to another court but only with the judge’s consent if the court is of lower jurisdiction; and
- May assign a retired judge who consents to any court. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 6.)
- Authorizes the courts to appoint subordinate judicial officers, and sets forth their duties and titles. (Government Code Section 71622.)
- Sets forth the specific number of trial court judges in each county. (Government Code Section 9580 et seq.)
- Authorizes 50 new trial court judgeships pursuant to appropriation by the Legislature in 2006-07. Requires the Judicial Council to update its Judicial Needs Study every other year, based on the most recent prior three years’ filings data, and report that information to the Legislature. Provides that judges shall be allocated, in accordance with the uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, based on the following criteria:
- Court filings data averaged over a period of three years;
- Workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type; and
- A ranking methodology that provides consideration for courts that have the greatest need relative to their current complement of judicial officers. (Government Code Section 69614.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to suspend four vacant judgeships in courts with more judgeships than their assessed need and allocate four judgeships to courts with fewer judgeships than their assessed need in order to provide more equal access to justice across the state. In support of the bill, the author writes:
The Legislature has not kept pace with the courts workload, leaving many with shortfalls between the numbers of judgeships needed compared to the number that has been authorized. The assessed need, according to the report, is greatest in San Bernardino County and Riverside County. These counties are 40% to 60% short of judges to adequately handle the court workload. In contrast, some courts have more judges than their assessed need.
The public’s right to timely access to justice should not be contingent on the resource levels in the county in which they reside or bring their legal disputes. All Californians deserve the proper number of judicial officers needed to handle the workload.
Historically, Courts Were County-Funded Entities and Funding Levels Varied Enormously Across the State: Historically, trial courts in California were county entities, funded by the counties. Funding levels varied greatly across the state. While visiting all 58 county courts, then-Chief Justice Ronald George discovered that chronic under-funding of many courts in the county-based court system substantially impaired statewide access to justice, including “woefully inadequate facilities, insufficient staff, unavailable interpreter services, and antiquated information processing systems.” In his first year as chief justice, Chief Justice George twice had to seek emergency funding from the Legislature in order to prevent the shutdown of some county trial court operations. In 1997, after significant problems came to light with the county-based court funding model, the Legislature passed the Lockyer-Isenberg Trial Court Funding Act (the Act), AB 233 (Escutia and Pringle), Chap. 850, Stats. 1997. Under that legislation, the state assumed responsibility for funding the courts and helping ensure equal access to a quality judicial system statewide.
After the state took over funding, the courts in general received significant funding increases and the historically underfunded courts saw even greater increases. However, most of the state funding continued to be distributed based on the courts' historical allocations, so courts that had been better funded by their counties remained better funded, and courts that had been underfunded by their counties remained underfunded.
Great Recession Forced Cuts For All Courts: Unfortunately, the recession forced significant reductions in state’s General Fund support for the courts. While "one-time" fixes, backfills and new revenues spared the court system the full brunt of these General Fund reductions, trial courts nonetheless had their budgets cut and had to take dramatic and painful steps to address those cuts, including (1) closing courthouses and courtrooms, some on selected days and others completely; (2) laying off or furloughing employees; and (3) reducing services, including substantial cuts to self-help and family law facilitator assistance, and providing fewer court reporters and court interpreters. Particularly hard hit have been those courts that were historically underfunded, as well as courts in counties with the largest growth, including courts in Riverside and San Bernardino Counties.
Funding Slowly Being Equalized Between Trial Courts: In 2012, Governor Brown and Chief Justice Cantil-Sakauye jointly created the Trial Court Funding Workgroup (TCFWG) to evaluate the state's progress in achieving the goals of the Trial Court Funding Act, which included more uniform and equitable funding to the trial courts to help ensure access to justice across the state. The TCFWG, which issued its final report in April 2013, found that the judicial branch substantially complied with the objectives of the Act, but that improvement was needed to the trial court funding allocation. The TCFWG recommended that a new allocation methodology be developed to improve equal access to justice, guided by "the principles of uniformity, equality, accountability, and flexibility." However the TCFWG recognized that funding alone does not account for all the differences in the courts:
Ensuring that resources are allocated in a more fair and equitable manner based on the trial courts’ respective workloads, though critical, is not the sole answer to equal access to the courts statewide. The Director of the Department of Finance explained . . . that the administration saw some inconsistencies when it examined the judicial branch budget over the past two years. The department asked why some courts were better able to manage the budget reductions than others. Why did some courts have to close courtrooms or courthouses when others were able to continue public services with little or no change or were able to provide salary increases to court employees? . . . Court discretion and management, labor costs, different filing practices and priorities by county law enforcement or other county entities, and other similar factors can make for unequal access even where there is equity in funding. But without equity in funding there is no opportunity for equal access.
While this workgroup worked more generally on reviewing the Act and recommending a fairer allocation methodology, the Judicial Council's Trial Court Budget Working Group, Funding Methodology Subcommittee developed the new funding allocation methodology, known as Workload-based Allocation and Funding Methodology (WAFM), and a process for its implementation. The methodology, which is based on weighted case filings, as well as other factors, such as cost-of-living differentials, is designed to equalize funding between the courts based on actual need. As of this budget year, 50 percent of trial court funding is allocated based on WAFM, while the remaining 50 percent continues to be allocated based on historical funding. Any new money appropriated for the trial courts will be allocated based on the WAFM formula.
Need for Additional Trial Court Judges: Beginning in 2005, the Judicial Council began a quest for additional trial court judges to address judicial shortfalls resulting from population growth. At that time, the Judicial Council reported that the state faced a "judicial gap" that portended a number of disturbing long-term consequences: a significant decrease in Californians' access to the courts; compromised public safety; an unstable business environment; and, in some courts, enormous backlogs that would inhibit fair, timely and equitable justice. According to the Judicial Council, that judicial gap arose because the number of trial court judges did not keep pace with population growth, and the resulting increased demand on the courts. Between 1990 and 2000, for example, California's population grew by over 16 percent; yet, as the Judicial Council noted, the number of new judgeships created by the Legislature during that same period increased by less than three percent.
At that time, the Judicial Council pointed out that its uniform and objective assessment criteria contained in its 2001 and 2004 Judicial Needs Studies identified a statewide need for 355 new trial court judgeships. However, in consideration of the state's ongoing fiscal crisis, the Council initially suggested a need for 150 new judgeships over that next three years. In response to the need, the Legislature passed SB 56 (Dunn), Chap. 390, Stats. 2006, which authorized, upon appropriation, 50 new trial court judgeships. Funding for those positions was provided in the budget that year.
The next 50 trial court judges were authorized in AB 159 (Jones), Chap. 722, Stats. 2007, but funding for those positions has not yet been appropriated. Authorization for the last 50 judges has been attempted three times – in SB 1150 (Corbett, 2008), AB 377 (Corbett, 2009), and AB 1405 (Judiciary, 2011), but none of those bills made it through the entire legislative process. SB 229 (Roth, 2015), which sought to allocate funds for the judicial positions that had been created, but not yet funded, made it the farthest. It was passed by the Legislature, but vetoed by the Governor, who wrote:
I am aware that the need for judges in many courts is acute - Riverside and San Bernardino are two clear examples. However, before funding any new positions, I intend to work with the Judicial Council to develop a more systemwide approach to balance the workload and the distribution of judgeships around the state.
In his proposed budget for 2016-17, the Governor reiterated his goal of promoting the redistribution of judgeships based on workload need:
[T]he Administration is proposing to work with the Judicial Council to reallocate up to five vacant superior court judgeships and the staffing and security complements needed to support and implement the proposal. This will shift judgeships where the workload is highest without needing to increase the overall number of judges.
Judicial Council Biannual Judicial Needs Assessment: Judicial Council is required, biannually, to determine uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial needs for each trial court county based on the following criteria:
- Court filings data averaged over a period of three years;
- Workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type; and
- A ranking methodology that provides consideration for courts that have the greatest need relative to their current complement of judicial officers. (Government Code Section 69614.)
According to the Judicial Council's 2016 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment, adopted by the Judicial Council in October of last year, California currently needs an additional 88.5 judges statewide, compared with its authorized positions (2,048.6 needed judicial positions, but just 1,960.1 authorized and funded judgeships and authorized SJO positions). Considering each specific court, 31 courts need a total of 188.5 judges, based on workload, with the greatest need in Riverside and San Bernardino, while 14 courts have at least one more judge than their assessed need, with the greatest excess capacity in Alameda and Santa Clara. Thus, it is likely that, under the process set forth in this bill, four vacant judgeships would be suspended in Alameda and Santa Clara, and four judgeships would be allocated to Riverside and San Bernardino.
This Bill Sets Forth a Process to Suspend and Allocate Judges: This bill seeks to address the Governor's concern in the veto message for SB 229 (Roth) and suspend four judges in the courts with the most judges compared than demonstrated need and allocate four judges to those courts with the fewest judges based on demonstrated need. To do so, the bill creates a process for Judicial Council to follow each time a judgeship becomes vacant. First, Judicial Council must determine whether the judgeship is eligible for suspension based on the latest Judicial Needs Assessment. If so, Judicial Council must:
- Promptly notify the applicable courts, the Legislature and the Governor that the vacant judgeships is subject to suspension;
- Provide an adequate opportunity for public comment;
- After consideration of any comments received, determine if the judgeship should be suspended; and
- Promptly notify the applicable county, the Legislature and the Governor of the decision regarding suspension of the judgeship.
This process ensures that the initial determination is based on the uniform needs assessment, but that all interested parties can weigh in before a suspension actually occurs.
While this bill suspends and allocates judgeships, it does not, by its own terms, reduce or shift any funding from a court with a suspended judge to a court with a newly allocated judge. The court with the suspended judge will maintain its funding, based on historical funding and the WAFM formula. It has been argued that the new WAFM allocation already distributed funding based on workload, so any further reduction in funding based on judicial allocation would be a double hit for "donor" courts. Likewise, this bill does not seek to reallocate funding for the county sheriff for court security, although court security needs will change based on the suspension and allocation of judgeships under this bill.
This bill is nearly identical to SB 39 (Roth): This bill is nearly identical to SB 39 (Roth), which is pending before the Senate Judiciary Committee. The key difference between the bills is that SB 39 allows the Governor to approve of the suspension and this bill provides for notice to the Governor, but does not require approval.
Both this bill and SB 39 are very similar to AB 2341 (Obernolte), 2016, which would have allocated up to 5 vacant judgeships from courts with more judges than their assessed need to court with few judges than their assessed need. That bill passed the Senate Judiciary Committee (it was a gut and amend and therefore was not heard in the Assembly), but was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Other Pending Legislation: SB 38 (Roth) would increase the number of judges in the division of the 4th Appellate District of the Court of Appeal located in the San Bernardino/Riverside area from seven to eight judges and would appropriate $14,813,000 from the General Fund to the judicial branch for the purpose of funding the cost of 10 of the previously authorized but not yet funded 50 judgeships and accompanying staff.
Additional Prior Legislation: AB 1313 (Donnelly), 2013-14, would have required allocation of additional judges to courts with the greatest disparity between their current judicial allocation and their assessed judicial need. That bill failed passage in this Committee.
SB 1150 (Corbett), 2008, would have authorized another 50 trial court judges, subject to an appropriation. That bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee. AB 377 (Corbett), 2009, would have authorized another 50 trial court judges, subject to an appropriation. That bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee. AB 1405 (Judiciary), 2011, would have authorized another 50 trial court judges, subject to an appropriation. That bill was later amended to address a different subject.
AB 159 (Jones), Chap. 722, Stats. 2007, authorized, upon appropriation, another 50 new superior court judgeships. While these positions were authorized, they have never been funded.
SB 56 (Dunn), Chap. 390, Stats. 2006, authorized, upon appropriation, 50 new trial court judgeships. Required the judges to be allocated in accordance with uniform standards developed by the Judicial Council in a needs assessment study.
SB 1857 (Burton), Chap. 998, Stats. 2000, created 20 new trial court judgeships and 12 new appellate court judgeships.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Alliance of California Judges opposes the bill because it believes the bill "violates Article VI, section 4 of the California Constitution which gives to the Legislature -- not the Judicial Council or the Administrative Office of the Courts -- the authority to decide how many judges should sit in each county." The Alliance writes:
The allocation of judgeships is best decided after vigorous and public debate by our elected representatives, not according to some obscure calculation performed by unelected and unaccountable bodies using a formula that can be tweaked at will.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
Alliance of California Judges
Santa Clara Superior Court (to a prior version of the bill)
Analysis Prepared by:
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):