AB 450: Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-10-05
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office. Existing law creates the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund, moneys in which, upon appropriation by the Legislature, are available to support the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter nonpublic areas of a place of labor unless the agent provides a judicial warrant, except as specified. Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena or court order, subject to a specified exception. The bill would grant the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General the exclusive authority to enforce these provisions and would require that any penalty recovered be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy the prohibitions described above of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, as defined. The bill would specify circumstances for which penalties do not apply.
The bill, except as required by federal law, would require an employer to provide a current employee notice containing specified information, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide an affected employee a copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, by July 1, 2018, to create a template for these purposes and make it available, as specified. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected current employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection results and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would define affected employee for these purposes. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to provide the notices of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, except as specified, to be collected by the Labor Commissioner.
Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe a penalty of up to $10,000 for a violation of this prohibition to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office. Existing law creates the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund, moneys in which, upon appropriation by the Legislature, are available to support the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter nonpublic areas of a place of labor unless the agent provides a judicial warrant, except as specified. Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena or court order, subject to a specified exception. The bill would grant the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General the exclusive authority to enforce these provisions and would require that any penalty recovered be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy the prohibitions described above of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, as defined. The bill would specify circumstances for which penalties do not apply.
The bill, except as required by federal law, would require an employer to provide a current employee notice containing specified information, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide an affected employee a copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, by July 1, 2018, to create a template for these purposes and make it available, as specified. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected current employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection results and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would define affected employee for these purposes. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to provide the notices of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, except as specified, to be collected by the Labor Commissioner.
Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe a penalty of up to $10,000 for a violation of this prohibition to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office. Existing law creates the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund, moneys in which, upon appropriation by the Legislature, are available to support the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a unless the agent provides a judicial warrant, except as specified. Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer or other person acting on the employers behalf from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena, subpoena or court order, subject to a specified exception. The The bill would grant the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General the exclusive authority to enforce these provisions and would require that any penalty recovered be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy the prohibitions described above of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, as defined. The bill would specify circumstances for which penalties do not apply.
The bill, except as prohibited required by federal law, would require an employer to provide a current employee notice containing specified information, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide an affected employee a copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, by July 1, 2018, to create a form template for these purposes and make it available, as specified. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected current employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection results and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would define affected employee for these purposes. Except The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to provide the notices of $2,000 up to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, except as specified, to be collected by the Labor Commissioner.
Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than a penalty of up to $10,000 for each subsequent violation, a violation of this prohibition to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would specify that the Attorney General may prosecute a civil action for a violation of certain of these prohibitions. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent access to enter nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a warrant, except as specified, and, except as otherwise provided by federal law, specified. Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing voluntary access to a federal government consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena. subpoena, subject to a specified exception. The bill, except as prohibited by federal law, would require an employer to provide a current employee, and the employees authorized representative, if any, a written employee notice containing specified information, by the method and posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide an affected employee a copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, by July 1, 2018, to create a form for these purposes and make it available, as specified. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected current employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection results and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would define affected employee for these purposes. Except as required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would specify that the Attorney General may prosecute a civil action for a violation of certain of these prohibitions. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees authorized representative, if any, upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees authorized representative, if any, before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless otherwise required by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would define an authorized representative, for the purposes described above, as a collective bargaining representative.The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution. The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a warrant warrant, except as specified, and, except as otherwise provided by federal law, would prohibit an employer from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records without a subpoena. The bill, except as prohibited by federal law, would require an employer to provide an a current employee, and the employees authorized representative, if any, a written notice containing specified information, by the method and in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency within 24 72 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, by July 1, 2018, to create a form for these purposes and make it available, as specified. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected current employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection results and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would define affected employee for these purposes. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees representative authorized representative, if any, upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and and the employees authorized representative, if any, before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless otherwise required by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would define an authorized representative, for the purposes described above, as a collective bargaining representative.
The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution. The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a warrant and, except as otherwise provided by federal law, would prohibit an employer from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records without a subpoena. The bill, except as prohibited by federal law, would require an employer to provide an employee, and the employees representative, a written notice containing specified information, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency within 24 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice that provides for the inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees representative upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless otherwise required by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from checking reverifying the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms employee at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution. The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise provided required by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a properly executed warrant and and, except as otherwise provided by federal law, would prohibit an employer from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records without a subpoena. The bill bill, except as prohibited by federal law, would require an employer to provide an employee, and the employees representative, a written notice containing specified information, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. agency within 24 hours of receiving the federal notice of inspection. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or that provides for the inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission Commissioner and the employees representative upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner, among other things, to provide specified information to employees affected by the action. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited otherwise required by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each not less than $2,000 or more than $5,000 for a first violation and not less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise provided by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to a place of labor without a properly executed warrant and would prohibit an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, employer from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records without a subpoena. The bill would require an employer to provide an employee, and the employees representative, a written notice containing specified information, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner, among other things, to provide specified information to employees affected by the action. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
By requiring local officials to perform various actions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.(1)Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity to engage from engaging in, or to direct directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes. Existing law grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions. impose various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Except as otherwise provided by federal law, the bill would prohibit an employer from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to a place of labor without a properly executed warrant and would prohibit an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records without a subpoena. The bill would require an employer to provide an employee, and the employees representative, a written notice containing specified information, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information, of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would require an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner, among other things, to provide specified information to employees affected by the action. The bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited by federal law. The bill would prohibit an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. The bill would prescribe penalties for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
By requiring local officials to perform various actions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law prohibits an employer or other person or entity to engage in, or to direct another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor. This section does not apply if the immigration enforcement agent provides a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to enter a nonpublic area of a place of labor without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of locations affected in a day.
(c)This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search nonpublic areas is given in the process.
(d)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 7285.2 is added to the Government Code, to read:7285.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, and except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena or judicial warrant. This section does not prohibit an employer, or person acting on behalf of an employer, from challenging the validity of a subpoena or judicial warrant in a federal district court.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and other documents for which a Notice of Inspection has been provided to the employer.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of employee records accessed, reviewed, or obtained.
(c)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 7285.3 is added to the Government Code, to read:7285.3.In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 4.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide a notice to each current employee, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employees authorized representative, if any. The posted notice shall contain the following information:
(A)The name of the immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(B)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(C)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(D)A copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms for the inspection to be conducted.
(2)On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a template posting that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency. The posting shall be available on the Labor Commissioners Internet Web site so that it is accessible to any employer.
(3)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide an affected employee a copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
(b)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide to each current affected employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 72 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 72 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees authorized representative, if any, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees authorized representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(A)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written immigration inspection results notice related to the affected employee.
(B)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the immigration agency.
(C)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(D)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an affected employee is an employee identified by the immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
(c)An employer who fails to provide the notices required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means an exclusive collective bargaining representative.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
(f)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 5.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000). The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)The actions of an employer that violate subdivision (a) and result in a civil penalty under paragraph (1) shall not also form the basis for liability or penalty under Section 1019.1.
(c)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 6.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor. This section does not apply if the immigration enforcement agent provides a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to enter a nonpublic area of a place of labor without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of locations affected in a day.
(c)This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search nonpublic areas is given in the process.
(d)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 7285.2 is added to the Government Code, to read:7285.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, and except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena or judicial warrant. This section does not prohibit an employer, or person acting on behalf of an employer, from challenging the validity of a subpoena or judicial warrant in a federal district court.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and other documents for which a Notice of Inspection has been provided to the employer.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of employee records accessed, reviewed, or obtained.
(c)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 7285.3 is added to the Government Code, to read:7285.3.In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 4.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide a notice to each current employee, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employees authorized representative, if any. The posted notice shall contain the following information:
(A)The name of the immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(B)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(C)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(D)A copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms for the inspection to be conducted.
(2)On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a template posting that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency. The posting shall be available on the Labor Commissioners Internet Web site so that it is accessible to any employer.
(3)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide an affected employee a copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
(b)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide to each current affected employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 72 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 72 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees authorized representative, if any, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees authorized representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(A)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written immigration inspection results notice related to the affected employee.
(B)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the immigration agency.
(C)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(D)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an affected employee is an employee identified by the immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
(c)An employer who fails to provide the notices required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of two thousand dollars ($2,000) up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and five thousand dollars ($5,000) up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means an exclusive collective bargaining representative.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
(f)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 5.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000). The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)The actions of an employer that violate subdivision (a) and result in a civil penalty under paragraph (1) shall not also form the basis for liability or penalty under Section 1019.1.
(c)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 6.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without being provided a judicial warrant. labor. This section does not apply if the immigration enforcement agent provides a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner may lower or waive the civil penalty if an immigration enforcement agent accesses the nonpublic areas of a place of labor without the consent of the owner or other person in control of the place of labor. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to enter a nonpublic area of a place of labor without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of locations affected in a day.
(c)This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search nonpublic areas is given in the process.
(d)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(d)(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
(e)An action for relief of a violation of this section may be prosecuted in a court of competent jurisdiction in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General or by the Labor Commissioner. SEC. 2.Section 90.2 7285.2 is added to the LaborGovernment Code, to read:90.2.7285.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, and except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without a subpoena. subpoena or judicial warrant. This section does not prohibit an employer, or person acting on behalf of an employer, from challenging the validity of a subpoena or judicial warrant in a federal district court.
(2)If an employer has been provided a Notice of Inspection, subdivision (a) does not This subdivision shall not apply to I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms. forms and other documents for which a Notice of Inspection has been provided to the employer.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. If a court finds that an immigration enforcement agent was permitted to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records without the consent of the employer or other person in control of the place of labor, the civil penalty shall not apply. Violation means each incident when it is found that subdivision (a) was violated without reference to the number of employees, the number of immigration enforcement agents involved in the incident, or the number of employee records accessed, reviewed, or obtained.
(c)An action for relief of a violation of this section may be prosecuted in a court of competent jurisdiction in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General or by the Labor Commissioner.(c)The exclusive authority to enforce this section is granted to the Labor Commissioner or the Attorney General and enforcement shall be through civil action. Any penalty recovered shall be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 7285.3 is added to the Government Code, to read:7285.3.In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Section 90.25 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.90.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide a notice to each current employee, by posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employees authorized representative, if any. The posted notice shall contain the following information:
(A)The name of the immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(B)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(C)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(D)A copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms for the inspection to be conducted.
(2)On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a form template posting that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by an immigration agency. The form posting shall be available on the Labor Commissioners website Internet Web site so that it is accessible to any employer.
(3)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide an affected employee a copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
(b)(1)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide to each current affected employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 72 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 72 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees authorized representative, if any, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees authorized representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(A)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written immigration inspection results notice related to the affected employee.
(B)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the immigration agency.
(C)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(D)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an affected employee is an employee identified by the immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
(c)An employer who fails to provide the notices required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means an exclusive collective bargaining representative.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
(f)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. ($10,000). The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)The actions of an employer that violate subdivision (a) and result in a civil penalty under paragraph (1) shall not also form the basis for liability or penalty under Section 1019.1.
(c)In accordance with state and federal law, nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employers compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without being provided a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner may lower or waive the civil penalty if a federal government an immigration enforcement agent accesses the nonpublic areas of a place of labor without the consent of the owner or other person in control of the place of labor.
(c)This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the federal government immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the federal government immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search nonpublic areas is given in the process.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
(e)An action for relief of a violation of this section may be prosecuted in a court of competent jurisdiction in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General or by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)(1)Except as otherwise provided required by federal law, and except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review, or obtain the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, records without a subpoena. This section does not prohibit an employer, or person acting on behalf of an employer, from challenging the validity of a subpoena in a federal district court.
(2)If an employer has been provided a Notice of Inspection, subdivision (a) does not apply to I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)An action for relief of a violation of this section may be prosecuted in a court of competent jurisdiction in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General or by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)(1)Except as prohibited otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide a written notice to each current employee, by the method and posting in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal an immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employees authorized representative, if any. The posted notice shall contain the following information:
(A)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(B)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(C)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(D)A copy of the notice of inspection Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records for the inspection to be conducted.
(E)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.(2)On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a form that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal an immigration agency. The form shall be available on the Labor Commissioners website so that it is accessible to any employer.
(3)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide an affected employee a copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
(b)(1)Except as prohibited otherwise required by federal law, an employer shall provide to each current affected employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 72 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 72 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees authorized representative, if any, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees authorized representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(A)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration inspection results notice. notice related to the affected employee.
(B)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration agency.
(C)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(D)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(E)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an affected employee is an employee identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
(c)An employer who fails to provide the notices required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining an exclusive representative.
(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency.(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees authorized representative, if any, upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action.(d)An employer who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.(e)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining representative.SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees authorized representative, if any, before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining representative.SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.SEC. 7.SEC. 4.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An (1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), an employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)The actions of an employer that violate subdivision (a) and result in a civil penalty under paragraph (1) shall not also form the basis for liability or penalty under Section 1019.1.
SEC. 8.SEC. 5.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner may lower or waive the civil penalty if a federal government immigration enforcement agent accesses the nonpublic areas of a place of labor without the consent of the owner or other person in control of the place of labor.
(c)This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the federal government immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the federal government immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search nonpublic areas is given in the process.
(c)(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)Except as otherwise provided by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, without a subpoena.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)(1)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide a written notice to each current employee, and the employees representative, a written notice, by the method and in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency within 24 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employees representative. authorized representative, if any. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)(A)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(2)(B)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(3)(C)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(4)(D)A copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records to be conducted.
(5)(E)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(2)On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a form that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency. The form shall be available on the Labor Commissioners website so that it is accessible to any employer.
(b)(1)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each current affected employee, and to the employees authorized representative, if any, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 24 72 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 24 72 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees authorized representative, if any, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees authorized representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)(A)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration inspection results notice.
(2)(B)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration agency.
(3)(C)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(4)(D)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(5)(E)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an affected employee is an employee identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice to all affected employees or their representatives the notices required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an affected employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining representative.
(d)(e)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency.
(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees representative authorized representative, if any, upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action.
(d)An employer who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(e)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining representative.
SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and and the employees authorized representative, if any, before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)For purposes of this section, an employees authorized representative means a collective bargaining representative.
SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.
SEC. 7.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 8.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner may lower or waive the civil penalty if a federal government immigration enforcement agent accesses the nonpublic areas of a place of labor without the consent of the owner or other person in control of the place of labor.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)Except as otherwise provided by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, without a subpoena.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each employee, and the employees representative, a written notice, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency within 24 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records.
(2)The date that the employer received notice of the inspection.
(3)The nature of the inspection to the extent known.
(4)A copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records to be conducted.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records within 24 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 24 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees representative, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration inspection results notice.
(2)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration agency.
(3)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(4)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice to all affected employees or their representatives shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an affected employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency.
(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees representative upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action.
(d)An employer who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.
SEC. 7.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not check reverify the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit of, or inspection of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 8.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a properly executed judicial warrant.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner may lower or waive the civil penalty if a federal government immigration enforcement agent accesses the nonpublic areas of a place of labor without the consent of the owner or other person in control of the place of labor.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)Except as otherwise provided by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, without a subpoena.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each employee, and the employees representative, a written notice, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, within 24 hours of receiving notice of the immigration worksite enforcement action. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action records conducted by a federal immigration agency. agency within 24 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action, audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other worksite immigration enforcement action. records.
(2)The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action. inspection.
(3)The nature of the worksite enforcement action inspection to the extent known.
(4)A copy of the notice of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action records to be conducted.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement actions records within 24 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 24 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees representative, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the immigration worksite enforcement action. inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration worksite enforcement action inspection results notice.
(2)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action. agency.
(3)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(4)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice to all affected employees or their representatives shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an affected employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency.
(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner and the employees representative upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action.
(d)An employer who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(e)During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Labor Commissioner may elect to have access to the place of employment pursuant to Section 90 and may provide employees affected by the immigration worksite enforcement action with the following information:(1)An employee has the right to remain silent.(2)An employee has the right to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.(3)An employee has the right to speak to his or her foreign consulate.SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.
SEC. 7.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not check the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit of, or inspection of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more than five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation and not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or more ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a properly executed judicial warrant.
(b)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)Except as otherwise provided by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, without a subpoena.
(b)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each employee, and the employees representative, a written notice, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, within 24 hours of receiving notice of the immigration worksite enforcement action. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by a federal immigration agency. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action, audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other worksite immigration enforcement action.
(2)The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
(3)The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
(4)A copy of the notice of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement actions within 24 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 24 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees representative, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the immigration worksite enforcement action. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration worksite enforcement action results notice.
(2)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action.
(3)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(4)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice to all affected employees or their representatives shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an affected employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency. The employer shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may, at its discretion, conduct an investigation of the place of labor pursuant to Section 90.5.
(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action and shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may conduct an investigation of the place of labor as provided for in Section 90.5. action.
(d)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, employer who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(e)(1)During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Labor Commissioner may elect to have access to the place of employment pursuant to Section 90 and may provide employees affected by the immigration worksite enforcement action with the following information:
(A)(1)An employee has the right to remain silent.
(B)(2)An employee has the right to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.
(C)(3)An employee has the right to speak to his or her foreign consulate.
(2)During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Labor Commissioner may elect to ensure that an employer complies with all health and safety requirements prescribed by Part 1 (commencing with Section 6300) of Division 5 as well as the safety standards required by the Health and Safety Code. During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Chief of the Division of Occupational Safety and Health may conduct an inspection of a place of employment as provided for in Section 6314.SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code. The employer shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may conduct an investigation of the place of labor as provided for in Section 90.5.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.
SEC. 7.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not check the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit of, or inspection of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 8.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to a place of labor without a properly executed judicial warrant.
(b)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 2.Section 90.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.2.(a)Except as otherwise provided by federal law, an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, shall not provide voluntary access to a federal immigration enforcement agent to the employers employee records, including, but not limited to, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, without a subpoena.
(b)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(c)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 3.Section 90.25 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.25.(a)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each employee, and the employees representative, a written notice, in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employers worksite, within 24 hours of receiving notice of the immigration worksite enforcement action. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by a federal immigration agency. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action, audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other worksite immigration enforcement action.
(2)The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
(3)The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
(4)A copy of the notice of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, an employer shall provide to each affected employee, and to the employees representative, a copy of the written federal government immigration agency notice that provides the results of the immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement actions within 24 hours of its receipt of the notice. Within 24 hours of its receipt of this notice, the employer shall also provide to each affected employee, and to the affected employees representative, written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the results of the immigration worksite enforcement action. The notice shall relate to the affected employee only and shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and to the employees representative. The notice shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration worksite enforcement action results notice.
(2)The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action.
(3)The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
(4)Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
(5)Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice to all affected employees or their representatives shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to provide notice to an affected employee at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(d)This section applies to public and private employers.
SEC. 4.Section 90.8 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.8.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as prohibited by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action from the federal immigration agency. Immigration worksite enforcement action includes audits or inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action conducted by the federal immigration agency. The employer shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may, at its discretion, conduct an investigation of the place of labor pursuant to Section 90.5.
(c)Except as prohibited by federal law, if an employer does not receive advance notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action and a federal immigration agent appears on or near the employers place of employment, the employer shall immediately notify the Labor Commissioner upon learning of the immigration worksite enforcement action and shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may conduct an investigation of the place of labor as provided for in Section 90.5.
(d)An employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, who fails to provide a notice required by this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
(e)(1)During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Labor Commissioner may elect to have access to the place of employment pursuant to Section 90 and may provide employees affected by the immigration worksite enforcement action with the following information:
(A)An employee has the right to remain silent.
(B)An employee has the right to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.
(C)An employee has the right to speak to his or her foreign consulate.
(2)During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Labor Commissioner may elect to ensure that an employer complies with all health and safety requirements prescribed by Part 1 (commencing with Section 6300) of Division 5 as well as the safety standards required by the Health and Safety Code. During an immigration worksite enforcement action, the Chief of the Division of Occupational Safety and Health may conduct an inspection of a place of employment as provided for in Section 6314.
SEC. 5.Section 90.9 is added to the Labor Code, to read:90.9.(a)This section applies to public and private employers.
(b)Except as otherwise required by federal law, every employer shall notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code. The employer shall provide access to the Labor Commissioner to the place of labor as required by Section 90. The Labor Commissioner may conduct an investigation of the place of labor as provided for in Section 90.5.
(c)An employer who fails to provide notice shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. This section does not require a penalty to be imposed upon an employer or person who fails to notify the Labor Commissioner of the immigration worksite enforcement action at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government or if otherwise required by federal law. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 6.Section 98.85 is added to the Labor Code, to read:98.85.If the Labor Commissioner determines that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution for the collection of wages, penalties, other compensation, or for the return of workers tools as set forth in Section 98.3, or that the employee is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution of a discrimination charge as set forth in Sections 98.6 and 98.7, the Labor Commissioner shall issue a certification to the employee complainant or employee witness stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint for violations of this code and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution of the violations.
SEC. 7.Section 1019.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:1019.2.(a)Except as otherwise required by federal law, a public or private employer, or a person acting on behalf of a public or private employer, shall not check the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit of, or inspection of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms, at a time or in a manner not required by Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code.
(b)An employer who violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000), but not more than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), for each violation. The penalty shall be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
SEC. 8.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 1019 of the Labor Code is amended to read:1019.(a)It is unlawful for an employer or other person or entity to engage in, or to direct another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for the purpose of, or with the intent of, retaliating against a person for exercising a right protected under this code or by local ordinance applicable to employees. Exercising a right protected by this code or local ordinance includes the following:(1)Filing a complaint or informing any person of an employers or other partys alleged violation of this code or local ordinance, so long as the complaint or disclosure is made in good faith.(2)Seeking information regarding whether an employer or other party is in compliance with this code or local ordinance.(3)Informing a person of his or her potential rights and remedies under this code or local ordinance, and assisting him or her in asserting those rights.(b)(1)As used in this chapter, unfair immigration-related practice means any of the following practices, when undertaken for the retaliatory purposes prohibited by subdivision (a):(A)Requesting more or different documents than are required under Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code, or a refusal to honor documents tendered pursuant to that section that on their face reasonably appear to be genuine.(B)Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required under Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code, or not authorized under any memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.(C)Threatening to file or the filing of a false police report, or a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency.(D)Threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities.(2)Unfair immigration-related practice does not include conduct undertaken at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government.(c)Engaging in an unfair immigration-related practice against a person within 90 days of the persons exercise of rights protected under this code or local ordinance applicable to employees shall raise a rebuttable presumption of having done so in retaliation for the exercise of those rights.(d)(1)An employee or other person who is the subject of an unfair immigration-related practice prohibited by this section, or a representative of that employee or person, may bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties.(2)Upon a finding by a court of applicable jurisdiction of a violation of this section, upon application by a party or on its own motion, a court may do the following:(A)For a first violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend all licenses that are held by the violating party for a period of up to 14 days. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall suspend the licenses according to the courts order.(B)For a second violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend all licenses that are held by the violating party for a period of up to 30 days. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall immediately suspend the licenses.(C)For a third or subsequent violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend for a period of up to 90 days all licenses that are held by the violating party. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall immediately suspend the licenses.(3)In determining whether a suspension of all licenses is appropriate under this subdivision, the court shall consider whether the employer knowingly committed an unfair immigration-related practice, the good faith efforts of the employer to resolve any alleged unfair immigration-related practice after receiving notice of the violations, as well as the harm other employees of the employer, or employees of other employers on a multiemployer job site, will suffer as a result of the suspension of all licenses.(4)An employee or other person who is the subject of an unfair immigration-related practice prohibited by this section, and who prevails in an action authorized by this section, shall recover his or her reasonable attorneys fees and costs, including any expert witness costs.(e)As used in this chapter:(1)License means any agency permit, certificate, approval, registration, or charter that is required by law and that is issued by any agency for the purposes of operating a business in this state and that is specific to the business location or locations where the unfair immigration-related practice occurred. License does not include a professional license.(2)Violation means each incident when an unfair immigration-related practice was committed, without reference to the number of employees involved in the incident. REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)It is unlawful for an employer or any other person or entity to engage in, or to direct another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against any a person for the purpose of, or with the intent of, retaliating against any a person for exercising any a right protected under this code or by any local ordinance applicable to employees. Exercising a right protected by this code or local ordinance includes the following:
(1)Filing a complaint or informing any person of an employers or other partys alleged violation of this code or local ordinance, so long as the complaint or disclosure is made in good faith.
(2)Seeking information regarding whether an employer or other party is in compliance with this code or local ordinance.
(3)Informing a person of his or her potential rights and remedies under this code or local ordinance, and assisting him or her in asserting those rights.
(b)(1)As used in this chapter, unfair immigration-related practice means any of the following practices, when undertaken for the retaliatory purposes prohibited by subdivision (a):
(A)Requesting more or different documents than are required under Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code, or a refusal to honor documents tendered pursuant to that section that on their face reasonably appear to be genuine.
(B)Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required under Section 1324a(b) of Title 8 of the United States Code, or not authorized under any memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
(C)Threatening to file or the filing of a false police report, or a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency.
(D)Threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities.
(2)Unfair immigration-related practice does not include conduct undertaken at the express and specific direction or request of the federal government.
(c)Engaging in an unfair immigration-related practice against a person within 90 days of the persons exercise of rights protected under this code or local ordinance applicable to employees shall raise a rebuttable presumption of having done so in retaliation for the exercise of those rights.
(d)(1)An employee or other person who is the subject of an unfair immigration-related practice prohibited by this section, or a representative of that employee or person, may bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties.
(2)Upon a finding by a court of applicable jurisdiction of a violation of this section, upon application by a party or on its own motion, a court may do the following:
(A)For a first violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend all licenses that are held by the violating party for a period of up to 14 days. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall suspend the licenses according to the courts order.
(B)For a second violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend all licenses that are held by the violating party for a period of up to 30 days. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall immediately suspend the licenses.
(C)For a third or subsequent violation, order the appropriate government agencies to suspend for a period of up to 90 days all licenses that are held by the violating party. On receipt of the courts order and notwithstanding any other law, the appropriate agencies shall immediately suspend the licenses.
(3)In determining whether a suspension of all licenses is appropriate under this subdivision, the court shall consider whether the employer knowingly committed an unfair immigration-related practice, the good faith efforts of the employer to resolve any alleged unfair immigration-related practice after receiving notice of the violations, as well as the harm other employees of the employer, or employees of other employers on a multiemployer job site, will suffer as a result of the suspension of all licenses.
(4)An employee or other person who is the subject of an unfair immigration-related practice prohibited by this section, and who prevails in an action authorized by this section, shall recover his or her reasonable attorneys fees and costs, including any expert witness costs.
(e)As used in this chapter:
(1)License means any agency permit, certificate, approval, registration, or charter that is required by law and that is issued by any agency for the purposes of operating a business in this state and that is specific to the business location or locations where the unfair immigration-related practice occurred. License does not include a professional license.
(2)Violation means each incident when an unfair immigration-related practice was committed, without reference to the number of employees involved in the incident.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 5, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 492, Statutes of 2017. |
| Oct 5, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Assembly Rule 77(a) suspended. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 15 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 12, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2017 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (September 1). |
| Aug 21, 2017 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 18, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 17, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (July 11). |
| Jun 28, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 3. Noes 1.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 21, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on L. & I.R. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on L. & I.R. and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 50. Noes 24. Page 1999.) |
| May 30, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 26, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 6.) (May 26). |
| May 17, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 27, 2017 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 26, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (April 25). |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 17, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 28, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 27, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Mar 23, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Feb 14, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2017 | AB 450 Chiu Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 12, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB450 Chiu et al. By Lara | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2017 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 21, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2017 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2017 | AB 450 CHIU Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2017 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2017 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 450
Author:(Chiu)
As Amended Ver:September 8, 2017
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 50-24 | (May 31, 2017) | SENATE: | 27-10 | (September 12, 2017) |
Original Committee Reference: L. & E.
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer from providing access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any non-public areas of a place of labor if the agent does not have a warrant.
The Senate amendments:
- Grant the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner the exclusive authority to enforce the provision of the bill that prohibit an employer or a person acting on behalf of an employer from:
- Providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant.
- Providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to access, review or obtain the employer's employee records without a subpoena or judicial warrant.
- Require any penalty recovered by the Attorney General or the Labor Commissioner be deposited in the Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund.
- Clarify that the notice requirements of the bill only apply to a current employee or the employee's authorized representative and extends the period of time in which to provide that notice from 24 to 72 hours.
- Require the Labor Commission by July 1, 2018, to create a template for these notice requirements.
- Define an authorized representative for these purposes as a collective bargaining representative.
- Require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide an affected employee a copy of the notice of inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
- Prohibit, except as required by federal law, an employer from re-verifying the employment eligibility of a current employee, at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Provide that a violation of the provisions of the bill prohibiting the reverification of employment eligibility shall not also form the basis for liability or penalty under Labor Code Section 1019.1
- Strike the provision of the bill that required an employer to notify the Labor Commission of a federal government immigration worksite enforcement action.
- Strike the provisions of the bill that would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, as specified, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
- Clarify that nothing in the bill shall be interpreted, construed, or applied to restrict or limit an employer's compliance with a memorandum of understanding governing the use of the federal E-Verify system.
- Provide that the provisions of the bill are severable.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in California.
- Provides that a State may provide that an individual who is not lawfully present in the United States is eligible for any State or local public benefit for which such alien would otherwise be ineligible through the enactment of a State law which affirmatively provides for such eligibility.
- Prohibits any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
- Requires that employers must attest, under penalty of perjury and on a form designated or established by the federal Attorney General by regulation, that it has verified that the individual is not an unauthorized alien by examining specified documents, which include a United States passport, resident alien card, and an identification card with a photograph that contains security features that prevents counterfeit or fraud. The worker must also attest, under the penalty of perjury, that he or she can legally work in the United States. These attestations and records are commonly known as I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms/records.
- Requires that employers retain a copy of the attestations discussed above and make available for inspection by officers of the Service, the Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices, or the Department of Labor during a period beginning on the date of the hiring, recruiting, or referral of the individual and ending with 1 year of a worker's termination.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Industrial Relations would likely incur annual costs minimally in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
COMMENTS: Recent executive actions from the new federal administration have signaled that all immigrants here without permission are now enforcement priorities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Nationwide, there are reports of ICE agents descending on worksites for mass round-ups of immigrants. Additionally, the Trump administration has called for hiring 10,000 more ICE agents to expedite deportations.
This bill seeks to ensure that all California workers, regardless of immigration status, enjoy the protections afforded to them under state law "without fear of harassment, detention, or deportation." According to the author, this bill will help achieve this by insisting that federal immigration enforcement agents meet the full procedural requirements of federal law and by making affected workers aware of federal enforcement actions and cognizant of their rights during such actions.
The California Labor Federation and SEIU California, the co-sponsors of this bill, assert that "millions of union members are immigrants and worksite immigration raids undermine workers' rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers' ability freely to exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws."
While recent amendments remove opposition from the Chamber of Commerce and other business interests, the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) remains opposed. According to SHRM, the bill, "while well intentioned, will add a host of unnecessary burdensome requirements, create many logistical challenges, and could possibly force human resource professionals to decide between abiding by federal law or state law."
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Richard / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002262
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 450
:
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 3-1, 6/28/17
AYES: Bradford, Atkins, Jackson
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Mitchell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 7/11/17
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 50-24, 5/31/17 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Labor Federation
SEIU California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits an employer from providing access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any non-public areas of a place of labor if the agent does not have a warrant.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/8/17 clarify enforcement authority and civil penalty applicability in the event of a violation.
Existing law:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in California.
(Labor Code §1171.5) - Provides that a State may provide that an individual who is not lawfully present in the United States is eligible for any State or local public benefit for which such alien would otherwise be ineligible through the enactment of a State law which affirmatively provides for such eligibility.
(8 U.S. Code § 1621(d)) - Prohibits any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
(Labor Code §1019.1) - Requires that employers must attest, under penalty of perjury and on a form designated or established by the federal Attorney General by regulation, that it has verified that the individual is not an unauthorized alien by examining specified documents, which include a United States passport, resident alien card, and an identification card with a photograph that contains security features that prevents counterfeit or fraud. The worker must also attest, under the penalty of perjury, that he or she can legally work in the United States. These attestations and records are commonly known as I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms/records. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
- Requires that employers retain a copy of the attestations discussed above and make available for inspection by officers of the Service, the Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices, or the Department of Labor during a period beginning on the date of the hiring, recruiting, or referral of the individual and ending with 1 year of a worker’s termination. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
This bill creates various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency worksite enforcement actions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without being provided a judicial warrant.
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, from providing an immigration enforcement agent voluntary consent to access, review, or obtain the employer’s employee records without a subpoena, unless the employer has been provided a Notice of Inspection to inspect I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and other records.
- Clarifies that, if a court finds that, if a court finds that if an immigration enforcement agent was permitted access to an employee’s records or to a non-public area in a workplace, civil penalties shall not apply.
- Clarifies that, if a court finds that, if a court finds that if an immigration enforcement agent was permitted access to an employee’s records or to a non-public area in a workplace, civil penalties shall not apply.
- States that exclusive enforcement lies with the Labor Commissioner or Attorney General and is through civil action.
- States that exclusive enforcement lies with the Labor Commissioner or Attorney General and is through civil action.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, to provide a current employee, and the employee’s authorized representative, a posted notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by an immigration agency at the employer’s worksite. That notice must be posted in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information within 72 hours of receiving the notice of inspection and contain:
- The name of the immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
- The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
- A copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s exclusive collective bargaining representative, a copy of the written immigration agency notice describing the results of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice must be provided within 72 hours and shall contain the following information:
- A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written immigration inspection results notice.
- The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the immigration agency.
- The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
- Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
- Prohibits an employer from re-verifying employment eligibility of a current employee, at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law. Each violation is subject to a civil penalty of up to $10,000.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions described in this bill of $2,000-$5,000 for a first violation, or $5,000-$10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the LC.
- Provides that the provisions of AB 450 are severable.
Comments
- Immigration, Federal Policy, and the California Legislature:
“Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
MOTHER OF EXILES. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she
With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
- Emma Lazarus, “The New Colossus”
In popular culture, it is common to hear the United States of America be referred to as a “Nation of Immigrants”. As many Americans can trace their roots to ancestors who voluntarily immigrated to this country, this sentiment has particular currency. Moreover, as touched on by Lazarus’s poem, it evokes a powerful image: oppressed and exiled, my ancestors were welcomed into a land of freedom and plenty. Today, because of their sacrifices, I am able to enjoy everything that America has to offer, and I will be able to extend that gift to those who come after me.
Unfortunately, the historical record shows many instances where America fell short in extending the light of freedom to the exiled and huddled masses of the world. For example, in the Naturalization Act of 1790, which was passed by a Congress made up of many Founding Fathers and signed by President George Washington, naturalization was limited to “a free white person” who resided in the United States for two years. The Naturalization Act of 1795 kept the restriction of naturalization to “a free white person”, but extended the residency period to 5 years. It wasn’t until 1870 that individuals born in Africa could naturalize as American citizens. However, exclusions from naturalization were kept in place for Asians.
In 1913, building off of this exclusion, the California State Legislature passed the Alien Land Law, which excluded “aliens” who are not eligible for citizenship from owning land, specifically targeting Japanese farmers. The bill passed 35-2 in the Senate (where it was introduced) and 72-3 in the Assembly. The bill was signed into law by Governor Hiram Johnson. The bill that became law was actually a compromise measure, and the Legislature had considered several bills that were much more stringent. During the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on one of the more stringent bills, farmers testified “with tears streaming down their faces” of white farmers being driven off the land by Japanese farmers and the inevitability of violence if nothing is done.[1] Prior to the passage of the final Alien Land Law, one Assemblyman offered amendments to make the measure more stringent, stating “This is not a question of dollars and cents but of civilization.”[2]
Then, in 1920, the Alien Land Law was further strengthened by an initiative, which passed 668,483 (75%) to 222,086 (25%), that inhibited the ability of Japanese farmers to lease agricultural land. The California State Legislature went on to strengthen and expand the Alien Land Law in 1923 and 1927. Despite this, Japanese farmers circumvented the law by developing complex ownership arrangements. These ownership arrangements, however, were illegal and could result in enforcement actions where the State would seize and sell the land or fine the Japanese immigrant due to the violation of the law. For example, the State Attorney General reported to the Legislature that, in the period between 1943 and 1945, he has secured a $100,000 penalty from one farming concern alone, which is the equivalent of approximately $1.45 million in today’s dollars.
Upheld by the United States Supreme Court as constitutional in 1923 and 1933, the Alien Land Law continued to be enforced throughout the 1940s. As Japanese individuals were released from internment camps, Governor Earl Warren signed into law SB 415 (Chapter 1136, Statutes of 1945), which clarified that there was no statute of limitations on seizing “alien” land, while another bill passed the same year created a trust fund and appropriation for the enforcement of the Alien Land Act. Declared unconstitutional in 1948 and 1952 by the U.S. Supreme Court and California Supreme Court respectively, it wasn’t until 1955 that the California State Legislature put on the ballot an initiative to repeal the Alien Land Law, which was overwhelmingly passed by the voters in 1956 (66.8% to 33.2%).
From the vantage point of contemporary California, it is difficult to comprehend how our government could privilege and enforce a system of naked racial animus upon a group of immigrants for more than 40 years. Forced to circumvent a fundamentally unjust law in order to make a living, Japanese farmers sought to improve their lives and the lives of their children, just like other immigrants. The difference, unfortunately, was that Japanese individuals not born in the United States were unable to become citizens due to federal immigration policy. Fortunately, this is no longer the case for Japanese immigrants: a federal immigration reform bill in 1952 created a path for Japanese immigrants to become naturalized citizens, ending decades of discrimination. Finally, after Congress took action, the lamp was raised a bit higher by the golden door.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis on a prior version of the bill, the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) indicates that the bill would likely result in increased administrative costs of $3 million to $5 million annually (special fund). The bill would require DIR to receive and keep records of notifications, respond as necessary, and both enforce and defend its enforcement of the bill’s provisions. This amount would likely be offset by penalty revenue, the magnitude of which is unknown, but likely minor in comparison.
California Labor Federation (co-source)
SEIU California (co-source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Bet Tzedek Legal Services
Brightline Defense
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Domestic Workers Coalition
California Federation of Teachers
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
CHIRLA
City and County of San Francisco
San Francisco Labor Council
San Mateo Labor Council
State Building and Construction Trades Council
UAW Local 5810
United Domestic Workers
United Farm Workers
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Worksafe
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/17)
California Citrus Mutual
California Fresh Fruit Association
Construction Employers’ Association
Family Business Association of California
National Federation of Independent Businesses
Society for Human Resource Management
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Proponents argue that “immigration raids undermine workers’ rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers’ ability to freely exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws.” The author also notes that “past experience with worksite raids demonstrates the likelihood of raids violating employee due process. ICE has routinely violated basic constitutional rights, such as the 4th amendment's protections against unreasonable search and seizure. ICE has detained all workers, without any individualized suspicion, regardless of status when conducting workplace raids. For example, in prior worksite raids, ICE has used individual arrest warrants and administrative warrants to question and detain every single worker - including U.S. citizens & lawfully present workers - in a workplace without individualized suspicion.” Proponent argue that AB 450, through notices to the employees and Labor Commissioner, will ensure that workers understand their rights and are aware of what enforcement actions are taking place. Further, by requiring a warrant or subpoena before certain ICE enforcement actions, proponents argue that AB 450 will ensure that ICE’s enforcement actions do not violate the due process rights of both employers and employees.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) opposes AB 450, arguing:
“Compliance with the provision in the bill requires multiple employees at the employers’ place of work to understand fully federal law regarding ICE agents’ access and puts employers in a bind. For example, an administrative assistant who is approached by an ICE agent is likely to comply with what the uniformed officer asks. If the ICE officer is asking for access beyond what is provided for in federal law, it is highly unlikely that the administrative assistant will be aware. It is unreasonable to expect many people within organizations (administrative, HR professionals, security staff, etc.) to have such detailed knowledge of federal law that would be required to comply. Training these employees would require major resource expenditures from employers.”
SHRM also argues that the I-9 notices to the employee and the Labor Commissioner are burdensome, noting: “This could be the entire workforce for the company, as well as those who have left the company in the last year. Federal law requires the retention of I-9s for three years after hire or one year after termination of employment, whichever is later. Getting notice out in a 3-day window would be an administrative challenge requiring significant resources, particularly for large employers who have thousands in their workforce.”
SHRM also argues that the requirement to notify the Labor Commissioner before a self-audit of I-9 verification forms “to mean that an employer is required to notify the state every time they re-verify an employee who needs to be re-verified for a legitimate reason, such as an H-1B visa holder who receives an extension. This is highly burdensome because the new requirement is on-going and could happen more than once with the same employee. Additionally, self-audits of I-9 files performed by our members are reasonable and should be encouraged, not discouraged. There is a distinction to be made between an audit of forms to ensure they are filled out correctly in compliance with federal law, and situations where employers actually go back and look at documents again or ask employees for new documentation – practices that are already prohibited by law.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 50-24, 5/31/17
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Acosta, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Maienschein, Mayes, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Choi, Eggman, Grayson, Mathis, Melendez, Salas
9/11/17 20:46:16
**** END ****
“We have a dead line at Elk Grove now, beyond with the brown man cannot pass. If we are denied relief from the situation that confronts us, I will not be responsible for what will surely happen. “ M.A. Mitchell, Elk Grove farmer, March 19, 1913. From Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1913 by Franklin Hichborn, pg. 225. ↑
Ibid., Pg. 271. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 450
:
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 3-1, 6/28/17
AYES: Bradford, Atkins, Jackson
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Mitchell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 7/11/17
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/17
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 50-24, 5/31/17 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Labor Federation
SEUI California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits an employer from providing access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any non-public areas of a place of labor if the agent does not have a warrant.
Existing law:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in California.
(Labor Code §1171.5) - Provides that a State may provide that an individual who is not lawfully present in the United States is eligible for any State or local public benefit for which such alien would otherwise be ineligible through the enactment of a State law which affirmatively provides for such eligibility.
(8 U.S. Code § 1621(d)) - Prohibits any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
(Labor Code §1019.1) - Requires that employers must attest, under penalty of perjury and on a form designated or established by the federal Attorney General by regulation, that it has verified that the individual is not an unauthorized alien by examining specified documents, which include a United States passport, resident alien card, and an identification card with a photograph that contains security features that prevents counterfeit or fraud. The worker must also attest, under the penalty of perjury, that he or she can legally work in the United States. These attestations and records are commonly known as I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms/records. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
- Requires that employers retain a copy of the attestations discussed above and make available for inspection by officers of the Service, the Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices, or the Department of Labor during a period beginning on the date of the hiring, recruiting, or referral of the individual and ending with 1 year of a worker’s termination. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
This bill creates various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency worksite enforcement actions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing voluntary consent to an immigration enforcement agent to enter any nonpublic areas of a place of labor without being provided a judicial warrant.
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, from providing an immigration enforcement agent voluntary consent to access, review, or obtain the employer’s employee records without a subpoena, unless the employer has been provided a Notice of Inspection to inspect I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, to provide a current employee, and the employee’s authorized representative, a notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by an immigration agency at the employer’s worksite. That notice must be posted in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information within 72 hours of receiving the notice of inspection and contain:
- The name of the immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
- The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
- A copy of the Notice of Inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise required by federal law, to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written immigration agency notice describing the results of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice must be provided within 72 hours and shall contain the following information:
- A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written immigration inspection results notice.
- The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the immigration agency.
- The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
- Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
- Prohibits an employer from re-verifying employment eligibility of a current employee, at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions described in this bill of $2,000-$5,000 for a first violation, or $5,000-$10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the LC.
- Allows for a civil action to be brought in the name of the People of the State of California by either the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner, and provides that the provisions of AB 450 are severable.
Comments
- Immigration, Federal Policy, and the California Legislature:
“Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
MOTHER OF EXILES. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she
With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
- Emma Lazarus, “The New Colossus”
In popular culture, it is common to hear the United States of America be referred to as a “Nation of Immigrants”. As many Americans can trace their roots to ancestors who voluntarily immigrated to this country, this sentiment has particular currency. Moreover, as touched on by Lazarus’s poem, it evokes a powerful image: oppressed and exiled, my ancestors were welcomed into a land of freedom and plenty. Today, because of their sacrifices, I am able to enjoy everything that America has to offer, and I will be able to extend that gift to those who come after me.
Unfortunately, the historical record shows many instances where America fell short in extending the light of freedom to the exiled and huddled masses of the world. For example, in the Naturalization Act of 1790, which was passed by a Congress made up of many Founding Fathers and signed by President George Washington, naturalization was limited to “a free white person” who resided in the United States for two years. The Naturalization Act of 1795 kept the restriction of naturalization to “a free white person”, but extended the residency period to 5 years. It wasn’t until 1870 that individuals born in Africa could naturalize as American citizens. However, exclusions from naturalization were kept in place for Asians.
In 1913, building off of this exclusion, the California State Legislature passed the Alien Land Law, which excluded “aliens” who are not eligible for citizenship from owning land, specifically targeting Japanese farmers. The bill passed 35-2 in the Senate (where it was introduced) and 72-3 in the Assembly. The bill was signed into law by Governor Hiram Johnson. The bill that became law was actually a compromise measure, and the Legislature had considered several bills that were much more stringent. During the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on one of the more stringent bills, farmers testified “with tears streaming down their faces” of white farmers being driven off the land by Japanese farmers and the inevitability of violence if nothing is done.[1] Prior to the passage of the final Alien Land Law, one Assemblyman offered amendments to make the measure more stringent, stating “This is not a question of dollars and cents but of civilization.”[2]
Then, in 1920, the Alien Land Law was further strengthened by an initiative, which passed 668,483 (75%) to 222,086 (25%), that inhibited the ability of Japanese farmers to lease agricultural land. The California State Legislature went on to strengthen and expand the Alien Land Law in 1923 and 1927. Despite this, Japanese farmers circumvented the law by developing complex ownership arrangements. These ownership arrangements, however, were illegal and could result in enforcement actions where the State would seize and sell the land or fine the Japanese immigrant due to the violation of the law. For example, the State Attorney General reported to the Legislature that, in the period between 1943 and 1945, he has secured a $100,000 penalty from one farming concern alone, which is the equivalent of approximately $1.45 million in today’s dollars.
Upheld by the United States Supreme Court as constitutional in 1923 and 1933, the Alien Land Law continued to be enforced throughout the 1940s. As Japanese individuals were released from internment camps, Governor Earl Warren signed into law SB 415 (Chapter 1136, Statutes of 1945), which clarified that there was no statute of limitations on seizing “alien” land, while another bill passed the same year created a trust fund and appropriation for the enforcement of the Alien Land Act. Declared unconstitutional in 1948 and 1952 by the U.S. Supreme Court and California Supreme Court respectively, it wasn’t until 1955 that the California State Legislature put on the ballot an initiative to repeal the Alien Land Law, which was overwhelmingly passed by the voters in 1956 (66.8% to 33.2%).
From the vantage point of contemporary California, it is difficult to comprehend how our government could privilege and enforce a system of naked racial animus upon a group of immigrants for more than 40 years. Forced to circumvent a fundamentally unjust law in order to make a living, Japanese farmers sought to improve their lives and the lives of their children, just like other immigrants. The difference, unfortunately, was that Japanese individuals not born in the United States were unable to become citizens due to federal immigration policy. Fortunately, this is no longer the case for Japanese immigrants: a federal immigration reform bill in 1952 created a path for Japanese immigrants to become naturalized citizens, ending decades of discrimination. Finally, after Congress took action, the lamp was raised a bit higher by the golden door.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Industrial Relations would likely incur annual costs minimally in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
California Labor Federation (co-source)
SEIU California (co-source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Bet Tzedek Legal Services
Brightline Defense
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Domestic Workers Coalition
California Federation of Teachers
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
CHIRLA
City and County of San Francisco
San Francisco Labor Council
San Mateo Labor Council
State Building and Construction Trades Council
UAW Local 5810
United Domestic Workers
United Farm Workers
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Worksafe
Agricultural Council of California
Associated General Contractors of California
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bankers Association
California Bean Shippers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Framing Contractors Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Pool & Spa Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Seed Association
California Trucking Assn
California Warehouse Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chambers of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Grower-Shipper Association of Central California
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Businesses
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau
Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce
Society for Human Resource Management
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
The Chamber of Commerce of the Santa Barbara Region
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Vacaville Chamber of Commerce
Ventura County Agricultural Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Yuba-Sutter Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Proponents argue that “immigration raids undermine workers’ rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers’ ability to freely exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws.” The author also notes that “past experience with worksite raids demonstrates the likelihood of raids violating employee due process. ICE has routinely violated basic constitutional rights, such as the 4th amendment's protections against unreasonable search and seizure. ICE has detained all workers, without any individualized suspicion, regardless of status when conducting workplace raids. For example, in prior worksite raids, ICE has used individual arrest warrants and administrative warrants to question and detain every single worker - including U.S. citizens & lawfully present workers - in a workplace without individualized suspicion.” Proponent argue that AB 450, through notices to the employees and Labor Commissioner, will ensure that workers understand their rights and are aware of what enforcement actions are taking place. Further, by requiring a warrant or subpoena before certain ICE enforcement actions, proponents argue that AB 450 will ensure that ICE’s enforcement actions do not violate the due process rights of both employers and employees.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) opposes AB 450, arguing:
“Compliance with the provision in the bill requires multiple employees at the employers’ place of work to understand fully federal law regarding ICE agents’ access and puts employers in a bind. For example, an administrative assistant who is approached by an ICE agent is likely to comply with what the uniformed officer asks. If the ICE officer is asking for access beyond what is provided for in federal law, it is highly unlikely that the administrative assistant will be aware. It is unreasonable to expect many people within organizations (administrative, HR professionals, security staff, etc.) to have such detailed knowledge of federal law that would be required to comply. Training these employees would require major resource expenditures from employers.”
SHRM also argues that the I-9 notices to the employee and the Labor Commissioner are burdensome, noting: “This could be the entire workforce for the company, as well as those who have left the company in the last year. Federal law requires the retention of I-9s for three years after hire or one year after termination of employment, whichever is later. Getting notice out in a 3-day window would be an administrative challenge requiring significant resources, particularly for large employers who have thousands in their workforce.”
SHRM also argues that the requirement to notify the Labor Commissioner before a self-audit of I-9 verification forms “to mean that an employer is required to notify the state every time they re-verify an employee who needs to be re-verified for a legitimate reason, such as an H-1B visa holder who receives an extension. This is highly burdensome because the new requirement is on-going and could happen more than once with the same employee. Additionally, self-audits of I-9 files performed by our members are reasonable and should be encouraged, not discouraged. There is a distinction to be made between an audit of forms to ensure they are filled out correctly in compliance with federal law, and situations where employers actually go back and look at documents again or ask employees for new documentation – practices that are already prohibited by law.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 50-24, 5/31/17
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Acosta, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Maienschein, Mayes, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Choi, Eggman, Grayson, Mathis, Melendez, Salas
9/3/17 17:53:49
**** END ****
“We have a dead line at Elk Grove now, beyond with the brown man cannot pass. If we are denied relief from the situation that confronts us, I will not be responsible for what will surely happen. “ M.A. Mitchell, Elk Grove farmer, March 19, 1913. From Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1913 by Franklin Hichborn, pg. 225. ↑
Ibid., Pg. 271. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 450 (Chiu) - Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on September 1, 2017
Bill Summary:
AB 450 would impose various requirements upon employers related to federal immigration worksite enforcement actions.
Fiscal Impact:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would likely incur annual costs minimally in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Author Amendments:
Delete several reporting requirements to the Labor Commissioner, remove the requirement the Labor Commissioner develop documentation for employees who are witness in an investigation and are going through a deportation proceeding, and reduce new requirements on employers.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 450 (Chiu) - Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 450 would impose various requirements upon employers related to federal immigration worksite enforcement actions.
Fiscal Impact:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) indicates that the bill would likely result in increased administrative costs of $3 million to $5 million annually (special fund). The bill would require DIR to receive and keep records of notifications, respond as necessary, and both enforce and defend its enforcement of the bill’s provisions. This amount would likely be offset by penalty revenue, the magnitude of which is unknown, but likely minor in comparison.
Background:
Current estimates are that about 2.6 million undocumented immigrants reside in California. They make up a large fraction of the State’s workforce and contribution to economic output. For example, undocumented workers are believed to comprise 45 percent of California’s agricultural workforce and to hold 21 percent of construction jobs.
Under current federal law and regulations, immigration officers are precluded from entering the non-public areas of a business or farm for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant, or the consent of the owner, or some agent of the owner who has authority to grant consent. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. Moreover, federal agents sometimes come to the workplace not to conduct a search of the premise, but to inspect business and employee records. In such a case, federal agents must provide the employer with a subpoena and a three-day notice before inspecting any records.
Previously, federal immigration officers, when conducting workplace raids and audits of employee work authorization records, had focused on detaining serious criminals. In contrast, broader, less discerning net is currently being cast. Recent executive actions have signaled that all immigrants in the State without permission are now enforcement priorities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Nationwide, there are reports of ICE agents descending on worksites for mass round-ups of immigrants. Additionally, the federal administration has proposed hiring 10,000 more ICE agents to expedite deportations.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Prohibit employers (public and private), except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a properly executed warrant.
- Provide that the employer can take the ICE agent to a non-public part of the business for the purpose of verifying the warrant only.
- Prohibit an employer, except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent voluntary access to the employer’s employee records without a subpoena.
- Require an employer, except as prohibited by federal law, to provide a written notice to each current employee, by the method and in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment-related information to the employee, of any inspections of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency within 72 hours of receiving notice of the inspection. Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours to the employee’s
authorized representative (as defined), if any. The notice shall contain specified information. - Require the Labor Commissioner, on or before July 1, 2018, to develop a form that employers may use to comply with the notification requirements related to an inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency. The form shall be available on the Labor Commissioner’s website so that it is accessible to any employer.
- Require an employer, except as otherwise prohibited by federal law, to provide to an affected employee (as defined), and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice shall contain specified information:
- Require an employer, except as otherwise prohibited by federal law, to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting an audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, in a manner not required by federal law.
- Prohibit an employer from re-verifying employment eligibility of a current employee, at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Require the LC, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
- Prescribe penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions described in this bill of $2,000-$5,000 for a first violation, or $5,000-$10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the Labor Commissioner.
Related Legislation:
- SB 1001 (Mitchell, Chapter 782, Statutes of 2016) prohibits, among other things, any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
- SB 666 (Steinberg, Chapter 577, Statutes of 2013) prohibits employer from making, adopting, or enforcing any rule, regulation, or policy preventing an employee from disclosing information to a government or law enforcement agency, as provided, and would extend those prohibitions to preventing an employee from, or retaliating against an employee for, providing information to, or testifying before, any public body conducting an investigation, hearing, or inquiry.
Staff Comments:
This bill would enact a series of measures designed to address issues associated with immigration enforcement activity in the workplace. First, the bill would prevent California employers from inadvertently undermining the constitutional and legal rights of their employees by consenting to warrantless searches of non-public areas or providing access to personnel records without a subpoena. Second, the bill would create a series of four notification requirements related to immigration enforcement activity in the workplace. Two of these notices would go from employer to employee before and after immigration enforcement activity, letting workers know what is going on and if they need to do anything in response. The remaining two notices would go to the Labor Commissioner, enabling the office to track and respond to workplace immigration enforcement activity in the State. Third, it would require the Labor Commissioner to provide complainants and witnesses with certification of their participation in the resolution of a pending matter. This provision is intended to help immigration officials know when they might be detaining or deporting someone who is critical to the resolution of a California labor dispute. Finally, the bill would subject California employers to state fines if they abuse the work eligibility verification process by re-verifying the eligibility of employees at a time or in a manner not required by federal law.
DIR has no empirical data to estimate the number of federal immigration enforcement actions (both records request and workplace raids) that would be impacted by the bill. Additionally, the number of potential employer violations cannot be determined. Enforcement of these cases would likely require extensive staff time, both due to the nature of the enforcement mechanism (a lawsuit), and the complexity of such cases which are outside the normal scope of the Labor Commissioner’s jurisdiction. Thus, cases would require substantive knowledge of immigration and constitutional law.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 450 (Author:Chiu)
Version: June 21, 2017
Hearing Date: July 11, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
TSGConsultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
DESCRIPTION
This bill would enact a set of restrictions on California employers to ensure that the assistance they give to federal immigration enforcement activity in the workplace goes no further than what is required by law and that workers have sufficient notice and opportunity to correct any inaccuracies in their employment eligibility records before employers take adverse action against them in connection with immigration enforcement audits.
BACKGROUND
It is estimated that more than 2.6 million undocumented immigrants reside in California. They make up a large fraction of California’s workforce and represent a significant factor in California’s economy. For example, undocumented workers are believed to comprise 45 percent of California’s agricultural workforce and to hold 21 percent of construction jobs. Across the board, almost 1 in every 10 workers in California is undocumented.
An increase in workplace raids and audits of employee work authorization records will have a dramatic impact on California workers and businesses. Yet such an increase in workplace immigration enforcement activity is likely and may already have begun under new immigration enforcement priorities ushered in on the heels of President Trump’s inauguration. Whereas, previously, federal immigration officers had focused on detaining serious criminals, the new policies cast a much broader, less discerning net. [1] All immigrants, including the many who toil daily in California’s low-wage labor force, now have a target on their backs.
As we do in the case of other law enforcement authorities, all Californians – including undocumented immigrants – enjoy important constitutional and legal protections that prohibit immigration enforcement officers from trampling on our privacy or inhibiting our liberty. Fourth Amendment restrictions, for example, prevent immigration officers from conducting unreasonable searches and seizures, just as they do the police. Outside of points of entry into the country, everyone generally has the right to refuse to respond to questions directed at them by immigration officers, with the possible exception of a request for a name.
These same rights apply in the workplace, though during workplace immigration enforcement actions in the past, federal immigration officials have shown limited regard for them.[2] Moreover, as a practical matter, since the employer controls the workspace, the employer can consent to waive some of these rights. Such consent eviscerates many protections that workers would otherwise have and gives immigration officers access to people and documents that they would otherwise be required to leave alone.
Immigration enforcement activity frequently has a secondary effect on workers as well. Confronted by the prospect of immigration officers interviewing worker or rifling through personnel records, employers sometimes feel compelled to take unusual steps to scrutinize those records, subject employees to additional documentation requirements, or even fire certain employees. For the reasons explained in Comment 6 of this analysis, such steps are generally unnecessary and frequently illegal. The reality is, however, that employers often undertake such steps nonetheless.
This bill would enact a series of measures designed to combat the problems associated with immigration enforcement activity in the workplace comprehensively. First, the bill would prevent California employers from inadvertently undermining the constitutional and legal rights of their employees by consenting to warrantless searches of non-public areas or providing access to personnel records without a subpoena.
Second, the bill would create four notification requirements related to immigration enforcement activity in the workplace. Two of these notices would go from employer to employee before and after immigration enforcement activity, letting workers know what is going on and if they need to do anything in response. The remaining two notices would go to the California Labor Commission, enabling it to track and respond to workplace immigration enforcement activity in the state and its effect on California workers.
Third, the bill would require the Labor Commission provide complainants and witnesses with certification of their participation in the resolution of a matter pending before the Labor Commission. This provision is intended to help immigration officials know when they might be detaining or deporting someone who is critical to the resolution of a California labor dispute.
Finally, the bill would subject California employers to state fines if they abuse the work eligibility verification process by re-verifying the eligibility of employees at a time or in a manner not required by federal law.
This bill passed out of the Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations on a 3 to 1 vote.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides, under federal law, that an immigration officer may not enter into the non-public areas of a business or a farm or other outdoor agricultural operation for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant or the consent of the owner. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. Existing law further specifies that nothing in this provision prohibits an immigration officer from entering into any area of a business to which the general public has access or onto open fields that are not farms or other outdoor agricultural operations without a warrant or consent. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1357; 8 C.F.R. Secs. 287.8(f)(2) and (4).)
Existing law requires an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. It specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1324a(b).)
Existing law makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for any person or entity to do any of the following: (a) discriminate against any individual, except as provided, with respect to the hiring, recruitment, or referral of the individual for employment or the discharging of the individual from employment; or (b) request, with the intent of discriminating against an individual, more or different documents than are required under law or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1342a(a)(1)-(6).)
Existing law prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising his or her rights under state or local labor law. These protected rights include the following: a) filing a complaint or informing any person of an employer’s or other party’s alleged violation of a state or local labor law, so long as the complaint or disclosure is made in good faith; b) seeking information regarding whether an employer or other party is in compliance with state or local labor law; and c) informing a person of his or her potential rights and remedies under state or local labor law, or assisting him or her in asserting those rights. (Lab. Code Sec. 1019(a).)
Existing law defines “unfair immigration-related practice,” for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government: (a) requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine; (b) using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law; (c) threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, or threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities. (Lab. Code Sec. 1019(b).)
Existing law specifies that engaging in an unfair immigration-related practice against a person within 90 days of the person’s exercise of a protected right shall raise a rebuttable presumption of having done so in retaliation for the exercise of those rights. (Lab. Code Sec. 1019(c).)
Existing law permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney’s fees. (Lab. Code Sec. 1019(d)(1).)
Existing law prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or re-verify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. (Lab. Code Sec. 1019.1.)
This bill would prohibit an employer, or a person acting on behalf of an employer, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to any non-public areas of a place of labor without a properly executed warrant, except as otherwise required by federal law.
This bill would prohibit an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent with access to employee records without a subpoena.
This bill would require an employer to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of a federal immigration worksite enforcement action at the employer’s worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. That notice must be in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information and contain the following: a) the name of the federal immigration agency conducting the enforcement action; b) the date that the employer received notice of the enforcement action; c) the nature of the enforcement action to the extent known; d) a copy of the notice of an immigration enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted; and e) any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
This bill would require an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice shall contain the following information: a) a description of all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration enforcement action results notice; b) the time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action; c) the time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct deficiencies; d) notice that the employee has the right to representation, as specified; e) any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
This bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law.
This bill would require an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited by federal law.
This bill would prohibit an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
This bill would prescribe penalties against employers for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of between $2,000 and $5,000 for initial violations and between $5,000 and $10,000 for each subsequent violation, though the Labor Commissioner would have discretion to lower or waive the fines if the violation is based on immigration enforcement officials gaining access to non-public parts of the workplace without a warrant and consent was not given by the owner or anyone else with control over the workspace.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
It is a frightening time to be an immigrant in the United States. With the President’s proposal of hiring 10,000 new ICE agents, we anticipate worksite raids are next. Unfortunately, California has not had a good history with worksite raids. In the past, ICE routinely violated constitutional rights such as the 4th amendment’s protections against illegal searches and seizures. For example, ICE would use individualized arrest warrants to question and detain other workers without individualized suspicion.
AB 450, the Immigrant Worker Protection Act, addresses these concerns and establishes a clear standard to ensure disruptive raids are conducted legally. To ensure that a workplace raid is as minimally disruptive as possible and employee privacy is protected, an employer needs to ask ICE for a judicial warrant before allowing worksite access and ask for a subpoena before sharing confidential employee information. AB 450 also requires employers who receive notice of a worksite enforcement action to notify the Labor Commissioner and employee’s representative; and provides workers who are critical to the investigation of a labor claim the right to receive certification from the Labor Commissioner that the worker is central to this investigation.
In an environment of division and fear, California must continue to defend our workers and to ensure that our laws protect all Californians.
In support, the California Labor Federation and SEIU California write:
In recent executive actions, this Administration has signaled that all immigrants here without permission are now enforcement priorities. California has already seen a jump in immigration enforcement raids and it is widely anticipated that worksite raids are next.
Both workers and employers need clear rules for worksite enforcement. Immigrants are the backbone of so many California industries and widespread worksite raids will be disruptive and cause chaos. Employers need straightforward guidelines to know when to permit access to the worksite and to confidential employee information.
In further support, Bet Tzedek Legal Services writes:
In the past, ICE agents have routinely conducted mass work-site sweeps without warrants and based on racial profiling, violating basic constitutional rights. These raids impact all employees, and could cause all workers, citizen and undocumented, to be detained in harsh conditions at a worksite or could lead to the exposure of confidential personal information held by the employer. By requiring employers to allow access to the workplace to immigration authorities only when they have a judicial warrant, or to share confidential information only when presented with a subpoena, AB 450 will establish worker safeguards to ensure that employees’ due process and privacy rights are protected at the workplace.
In further support, Jim Cochran, Founder and General Manager of Swanton Berry Farms, Inc., writes:
I have been reading about “raids” by ICE that appear to be quite disruptive and unsettling to all workers, citizens and non-citizens alike. As you know, this has made it more difficult to hire and retain workers. While I know that ICE has a difficult job to do, I am hoping that they can proceed with their work in a measured way, using appropriate warrants and subpoenas. I believe that AB 450 will provide us with a good framework to work with immigration officers. The last thing we need is to create panic in the ag worker community.
2. Expressed concerns with the bill
In opposition to the bill, the Society for Human Resource Management writes:
From the Human Resource professional’s perspective, AB 450, while well intentioned, will add a host of unnecessary and burdensome requirements, create many logistical challenges, and could possibly force human resource professionals to decide between abiding by federal law or state law.
Compliance with AB 450 requires multiple employees at the employers’ place of work to understand fully federal law regarding ICE agents’ access and puts employers in a bind. For example, an administrative assistant who is approached by an ICE agent is likely to comply with what the uniformed officer asks. If the ICE officer is asking for access beyond what is provided for in federal law, it is highly unlikely that the administrative assistant will be aware. […]
Additionally, self-audits of I-9 files performed by our members are reasonable and should be encouraged, not discouraged. There is a distinction to be made between an audit of forms to ensure they are filled out correctly in compliance with federal law, and situations where employers actually go back and look at documents again or ask employees for new documentation – practices that are already prohibited by law.
In further opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce, about 50 of its local affiliates, and a variety of trade associations write:
[AB 450] penalizes an employer for choosing to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement authorities, thereby denying the employer the right to determine the best course of action for its business under these difficult circumstances [when an immigration enforcement action occurs at its place of employment]. Believing its employment eligibility verification and recordkeeping practices are in full compliance with federal law, an employer may determine that cooperation with federal enforcement officials is its best course of action. Unfortunately, AB 450 forbids an employer from cooperating with federal enforcement officials and instead requires the employer to demand “a judicial warrant.” […]
[AB 450] imposes complex written notice requirements on the employer to be provided to each employee and the employee’s representative regarding I-9 audits by federal authorities. […] Who is the employee’s representative – is an employer thus required to obtain the name and contact information from each employee of who their representative would be in the event of a notice issued under this legislation? […] How does an employer determine who is an affected employee?
3. What ICE can and cannot do at workplaces now
Absent a judicial warrant, a subpoena, exigent circumstances, or consent, there are constitutional and legal limits on where Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers may go and what documents they can demand to see.
- Workplace immigration raids
Pursuant to federal regulations and consistent with Fourth Amendment prohibitions on unreasonable search and seizure, there are significant restraints on ICE agents’ access to worksites. Although there are some exceptions (under exigent circumstances, for example), the dominant rule is as follows:
An immigration officer may not enter into the non-public areas of a business, a residence including the curtilage of such residence, or a farm or other outdoor agricultural operation, except as provided in section 287(a)(3) of the Act, for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States unless the officer has either a warrant or the consent of the owner or other person in control of the site to be inspected. When consent to enter is given, the immigration officer must note on the officer's report that consent was given and, if possible, by whom consent was given. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. (8 C.F.R. Sec. 287.8(f)(2).)
In order to obtain such a warrant, ICE agents must comply with Fourth Amendment requirements. In other words, to conduct the search, the ICE agents must convince a magistrate judge that they have “probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.” (U.S. Const., Amend. IV). In the case of immigration enforcement, federal courts generally apply a relaxed standard. Blackie’s House of Beef, Inc. v. Castillo (D.C. Cir. 1981.) 659 F.2d 1211. Still, the application for the warrant must have “sufficient specificity to enable the judge to make an independent determination of whether probable cause exists and to prevent the agents from having uncontrolled discretion to rummage everywhere in search of seizable items once lawfully within the premises.” International Molders’ and Allied Workers’ Local No. 164 v. Nelson (9th Cir. 1986) 643 F.2d 547, 553 (9th Cir. 1986), citing United States v. Condo (9th Cir. 1986) 782 F.2d 1502, 1505. And, the warrant must still be signed by a magistrate judge.
Without such a warrant, ICE agents are limited to public areas of a business. There, as in any public location, ICE agents can question any individual “believed to be an alien” about his or her right to be in the United States. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1357(a)(1).) If that questioning leads to sufficient probable cause, the ICE agents may proceed with an arrest. On the other hand, unless the ICE agents have such probable cause, the individual must be permitted to walk away and has the right not to answer questions, apart from a request for a name. (U.S. Const., Amend. 5; Matter of Guevara (BIA 1991) 20 I&N Dec. 238; but see Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial District Court of Nevada (2004) 542 U.S. 177 (holding that people may be required to identify themselves to state law enforcement when so required by state law; California has no such state law).)
- Inspection of employment records
Immigration officers have the power to inspect employee records. However this authority is not unlimited. First, by law ICE must give employers three days’ notice before inspecting employee records and I-9 forms. Second, an employer is not legally obligated to provide access for the inspection unless the demand for inspection is accompanied by a subpoena. Immigration officers have the power to issue subpoenas. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1225(d)(4); 8 C.F.R. Sec. 287.4.) Thus, when ICE gives an employer notice that it intends to inspect the employer’s work eligibility records, it can do so with a subpoena, and the employer is then legally obliged to comply. Absent the subpoena, ICE can only access the records if the employer consents to it.
Section 2 of AB 450 would add a Labor Code provision requiring employers not provide access to employee records to ICE in the absence of a subpoena.
4. Supremacy clause and preemption considerations
Whenever federal and state laws conflict, the federal law governs. (U.S. Const., art. VI.) “Under the Supremacy Clause, from which our pre-emption doctrine is derived, any state law, however clearly within a State’s acknowledged power, which interferes with or is contrary to federal law, must yield.” (Gade v. National Solid Waste Management Association (1992) 505 U.S. 88, 108.)
U.S. Supreme Court precedent identifies three types of pre-emption: express, field, and conflict. Express pre-emption applies where Congress explicitly states that a federal statute is intended to pre-empt state legislation. Field pre-emption occurs when federal legislation is so pervasive in an area of law that Congress has left no room for the states to supplement it. Conflict pre-emption takes place when a state and federal statute are so at odds that it is impossible to comply with both at once. (Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law Principles and Policy, Fifth Edition, p. 414.)
In Arizona v. United States (2012) 567 U.S. 387, the U.S. Supreme Court indicated that this analysis applies to state laws that bear some relationship to immigration matters. In that case, the Court upheld some provisions of an Arizona statute that only related indirectly to immigration enforcement, while striking other provisions that more directly interfered.
Applying a similar analysis to AB 450 arguably suggests that the bill is not preempted. There is nothing express in federal law telling states they cannot place limitations on the ability of employers to consent to workplace immigration raids.
As to field preemption, immigration law is the province of the federal government. Nonetheless, as the Arizona case made clear, the federal government’s sweeping power to govern the field of immigration law itself does not prohibit states from enacting laws that have some connection to immigration, so long as they do not attempt to regulate immigration itself. AB 450 does not purport to regulate who may or may not be in the country lawfully and it does not attempt to change the rules regarding who is legally authorized to work. As a result, it does not appear that AB 450 would encroach upon the field of immigration regulation such as to trigger preemption.
Finally, AB 450 would not conflict with federal law because it would be perfectly possible to comply with AB 450’s provisions and federal law at the same time. Simply put, AB 450 would not prevent the federal government from doing anything it is not already prevented from doing. What AB 450 eliminates is an employer’s discretion to consent to allow the federal government to go beyond what it would otherwise be legally prohibited from doing. As the Assembly Committee on the Judiciary’s analysis of this bill concluded:
Existing federal law already requires immigration agents to obtain a warrant to search a worksite and a subpoena to access employee records, unless the employer grants consent. This bill effectively takes away the employer's option to grant consent. Taking away this option to consent may or may not be fair to the employer, or it may or may not be good policy, but it does not “conflict” with federal law as that term is used in federal preemption analysis. That is, it is still possible for the employer to comply with both state and federal law. If the employer complies with the state law by asking to see a warrant, he or she is not violating any federal law. The employer, by asking to see a warrant, is simply doing something that he or she clearly has a right to do under federal law. (Analysis of AB 450, March 23, 2017 Version (April 25, 2017, Hearing Date) Assembly Committee on the Judiciary, p. 7)
5. The employee-in-the-headlights problem
Earlier versions of this bill sustained criticism on the ground that employers could be subjected to fines in circumstances in which immigration enforcement officers obtained consent from employees who either lacked sufficient training to demand to see a warrant, or knew better, but felt too intimidated in the moment to request a warrant. A newly hired greeter at a restaurant, for example, might panic at the sudden appearance of federal agents at reception and, not wanting to cause a scene with diners, might quickly acquiesce to a request to be escorted back to the kitchen, instead of referring the matter to the manager or asking to see legal authority in the form of a judicial warrant.
To address this concern without eliminating the strong incentive for employers to train all staff on how to respond appropriately to the presence of immigration enforcement officers, the bill has been amended to allow the Labor Commissioner to reduce or waive the fines under certain circumstances. Specifically, the fines can be lowered or waived if immigration officers gain access to non-public parts of the workplace without the consent of the business owner or someone with control over the workspace. This compromise still incentivizes employers to ensure that all employees are well trained on proper procedure in response to the presence of immigration authorities, but puts the primary responsibility on owners and managers. It also acknowledges the reality of how quickly a workplace immigration raid can unfold and the level of pressure and intimidation that workers may feel when confronted by federal agents.
6. Employment eligibility verification and reverification: the I-9 process and its abuses
To grasp the purpose and function of AB 450’s notification requirements, it is helpful to put them in the context of the basic law behind establishing eligibility to work. In broad strokes, that law works as follows.[3]
All employers are required to verify that new hires are authorized to work in the United States. To do so, they must have the employee fill out Section 1 of an I-9 form, providing basic information about their identity and attested to their citizenship or immigration status in the United States. This step is supposed to happen after a job offer has been accepted, but before the employee completes the employee’s first day of work.
Within three business days of starting work, the new hire must present evidence, in the form of one or a combination of specified documents, that the new hire is eligible to work in the United States. As the employer is not expected to be a forensic expert or to act as an immigration authority, the employer must simply confirm that the documents presented appear, on their face, reasonably genuine and relate to the person who is presenting them. The employer makes notes about the documents reviewed in Section 2 of the I-9 form, may take copies of the documents if the employer chooses to do so, and then the process is done. Employers must keep I-9 forms on file for three years after the person is hired or one year after the person is terminated, whichever is later.
As a default matter, once an employer has verified an employee’s eligibility to work at the time of hire, there is no need to re-verify that eligibility ever. Re-verification is only necessary in certain specific circumstances, such as when the employee initially establishes eligibility using a document that only confers temporary eligibility to work, such as an H1-B visa, for example. In that case, the employer should re-verify the employee’s eligibility to work prior to the expiration of the temporary document by going through the I-9 process again.
Federal and state law prohibit the improper use of the I-9 work eligibility process. Among the abuses forbidden are discriminatory application of the process (demanding more, or particular, documentation of people from certain countries, for instance) and retaliatory use of the I-9 process (suddenly re-verifying the eligibility of an employee who has expressed concern about safety at the worksite, for example.)
When ICE officers inspect an employer’s I-9 records, they may be looking for information about a particular person, for evidence that fraudulent documents have been used, or for examples of temporary eligibility that has expired. What the ICE officers discover may indeed indicate that a worker used false documents or is no longer eligible to work. Not infrequently, however, there is a more innocent explanation. Employers and employees sometimes forget to re-verify when new eligibility documents come in or the basis for their eligibility changes (when they naturalize, for example.)
The purpose of the notice from employers to employees about ICE audits of I-9 information is to provide notice and an opportunity to employees to address the situation. Of course, if the employee is not or never was eligible to work, there may be nothing that the employee can do and the employer may have to fire that employee. In other cases, however, the notifications may enable employees to update the basis for their work eligibility.
The employer notice to the Labor Commission serves a related purpose. State law prohibits employers from using the eligibility verification process in a discriminatory or retaliatory fashion. By requiring employers to notify the Labor Commissioner whenever they intend to check an employee’s eligibility status outside of the time and manner prescribed by law, the Labor Commissioner will have the opportunity to ensure that the employer is not engaging the practice for abusive purposes.
7. Amendments
The notification requirements that this bill creates impose a burden on employers at what may already be a pressure-filled time. Nearly all parties agree that comprehensive immigration reform would be a vastly superior solution. In the absence of federal action on that front, however, and confronted by a new set of immigration enforcement priorities that target a large part of the workforce that California counts on to make its economy go each day, these notification requirements serve a compelling purpose. Still it may be possible to streamline them somewhat to make them as simple as possible to follow, while still achieving their purpose. With that in mind, the author may wish to consider the following amendments, which may be summarized as follows:
- The employer can take the ICE agent to a non-public part of the business for purposes of verifying the warrant only.
- The notification requirements have been modified to make it less burdensome on employers to comply. They will have more time; do not have to give individualized notice to all employees; only have to hand deliver notices to employees who ICE has marked as having problematic documents; and will be have a standardized form available to them from the Labor Commissioner to make the notification easier.
Amendment 1
On page 3, after line 16, insert:
(c) This section shall not preclude an employer or person acting on behalf of an employer from taking the federal government immigration enforcement agent to a nonpublic area, where employees are not present, for the purpose of verifying whether the federal government immigration enforcement agent has a judicial warrant, provided no consent to search non-public areas is given in the process.
Amendment 2
On page 3, in line 17, strike “(c)” and insert:
(d)
Amendment 3
On page 4, in line 7, after “(a)” insert
(1)
Amendment 4
On page 4, in line 8, after “provide” insert:
written notice
Amendment 5
On page 4, in line 8, after “each” insert:
current
Amendment 6
On page 4, in lines 8 and 9, strike “employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice,” and insert:
employee, by the method and
Amendment 7
One page 4, in line 13, strike out “24” and insert:
72
Amendment 8
On page 4, in lines 13 through 16, strike out “inspection. The notice shall be delivered by hand at the workplace if possible and, if hand delivery is not possible, by mail and email, if the email address of the employee is known, and” insert:
Written notice shall also be given within 72 hours
Amendment 9
On page 4, in line 16, after “employee’s” insert:
authorized
Amendment 10
On page 4, in line 17, strike out “representative” and insert:
representative, if any
Amendment 11
On page 4, in line 18, strike out “(1)” and insert:
(A)
Amendment 12
On page 4, in line 21, strike out “(2)” and insert:
(B)
Amendment 13
On page 4, in line 22, strike out “(3)” and insert:
(C)
Amendment 14
On page 4, in line 23, strike out “(4)” and insert:
(D)
Amendment 15
On page 4, in line 26, strike out “(5)” and insert:
(E)
Amendment 16
On page 4, after line 27 insert:
(2) On or before July 1, 2018, the Labor Commissioner shall develop a form that employers may use to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a) to inform employees of a notice of inspection to be conducted of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records conducted by a federal immigration agency. The form shall be available on the Labor Commissioner’s website so that it is accessible to any employer.
Amendment 17
On page 4, on line 28, after “(b)” insert:
(1)
Amendment 18
On page 4, in line 29, after “each” insert:
current
Amendment 19
On page 4, in line 29 after “employee’s” insert:
authorized
Amendment 20
On page 4, in line 30, after “representative,” insert:
if any,
Amendment 21
On page 4, in line 33, strike out “24” and insert:
72
Amendment 22
On page 4, in line 34, strike out “24” and insert:
72
Amendment 23
On page 4, in line 36, after “employee’s” insert:
authorized
Amendment 24
On page 4, in line 36, after “representative,” insert:
if any,
Amendment 25
On page 5, in line 3, after “employee’s” insert:
authorized
Amendment 26
On page 5, in line 5, strike out “(1)” and insert:
(A)
Amendment 27
On page 5, in line 8, strike out “(2)” and insert:
(B)
Amendment 28
On page 5, in line 10, strike out “(3)” and insert:
(C)
Amendment 29
On page 5, in line 12, strike out “(4)” and insert:
(D)
Amendment 30
On page 5, in line 14, strike out “(5)” and insert:
(E)
Amendment 31
On page 5, after 15 insert:
(2) For purposes of this subdivision, an “affected employee” is an employee identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection results to be an employee who may lack work authorization, or an employee whose work authorization documents have been identified by the federal government immigration agency inspection to have deficiencies.
Amendment 32
On page 5, in lines 16 and 17, strike out “notice to all affected employees or their representatives” and insert:
the notices required by this section
Amendment 33
On page 5, in line 23, strike out “affected”
Amendment 34
On page 5, after line 25, insert:
(d) For purposes of this section, an “employee’s authorized representative” means a collective bargaining representative.
Amendment 35
On page 5, in line 26, strike out “(d)” and insert:
(e)
Amendment 36
On page 6, in line 3 after “employee’s” insert:
authorized
Amendment 37:
On page 6, in line 3, strike out “representative” and insert:
representative, if any,
Amendment 38
On page 6, after line 15 insert:
(e) For purposes of this section, an “employee’s authorized representative” means a collective bargaining representative.
Amendment 39
On page 6, in lines 19-21, strike out “before conducting a self audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and” and insert:
and the employee’s authorized representative, if any,
Amendment 40
On page 6, after line 35 insert:
(d) For purposes of this section, an “employee’s authorized representative” means a collective bargaining representative.
Support: Alliance of Boys and Men of Color; Asian Americans Advancing Justice -California; Bet Tzedek Legal Services; Brightline Defense Project; California Association of Local Conservation Corps; California Domestic Workers Coalition; California Federation of Teachers; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Labor Federation; California Professional Firefighters; California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation; Ceja Vineyards; the City and County of San Francisco; Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights; Robledo Family Winery; San Francisco Labor Council; San Mateo County Central Labor Council; the Santa Clara County Wage Theft Coalition; SEIU California; State Building and Construction Trades Council; United Auto Workers – Local 5810; Swanton Berry Farm; United Domestic Workers of America – AFSCME Local 3930; United Domestic Workers of America – AFSCME Local 3930/AFL-CIO; United Farm Workers; United Food and Commercial Workers Union – Western States Council; Western Center on Law & Poverty; Worksafe; 7 individuals
Opposition: Agricultural Council of California; Associated General Contractors of California; Association of California Egg Farmers; Bay Area HR Executives Council; California Association of Wheat Growers; California Association of Winegrape Growers; California Bankers Association; California Bean Shippers Association; California Building Industry Association; California Business Properties Association; California Chamber of Commerce; California Citrus Mutual; California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.; California Employment Law Council; California Farm Bureau Federation; California Framing Contractors Association; California Fresh Fruit Association; California Grain and Feed Association; California League of Food Processors; California Manufacturers and Technology Association; California Pear Growers Association; California Pool & Spa Association; California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors; California Restaurant Association; California Retailers Association; California Seed Association; California Trucking Association; California Warehouse Association; Camarillo Chamber of Commerce; Central Coast HR Association; Central Valley HR Management Association; Chambers of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties; The Chamber of Commerce of the Santa Barbara Region; Construction Employers’ Association; El Centro Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau; Family Business Association of California; Family Winemakers of California; Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce; Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce; Grower-Shipper Association of Central California; HR Association of Central California; Inland Empire Society for HR Association Management; Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce; Murrieta Chamber of Commerce; National Federation of Independent Businesses; North Orange County Chamber of Commerce; Oceanside Chamber of Commerce; Official Police Garages of Los Angeles; Oxnard Chamber of Commerce; Professionals in Human Resources Association; Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau; Sacramento Area HR Association; San Joaquin Human Resource Association; Santa Barbara HR Association; Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce; Sierra Human Resources Association; Society for Human Resource Management; Society for Human Resource Management - California State Council; Society for Human Resource Management – Central California; Society for Human Resource Management – Kern County; Society for Human Resource Management – Northstate; Society for Human Resource Management – San Diego; Society for Human Resource Management – Tulare/Kings County; Society for Human Resource Management – Wine Country; South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce; Southwest California Legislative Council; Tulare Chamber of Commerce; Vacaville Chamber of Commerce; Ventura County Agricultural Association; Western Agricultural Processors Association; Western Carwash Association; Western Growers Association; Wine Institute; Yuba-Sutter Chamber of Commerce
HISTORY
Source: California Labor Federation; SEIU California
Related Pending Legislation:
AB 291 (Chiu, 2017) would establish stronger legal protections for tenants against landlords who may disclose, or threaten to disclose, a tenant’s immigration status to federal authorities as part of a pattern of harassment and retaliation. AB 291 is currently pending consideration on the Assembly Floor.
SB 54 (De León, 2017) would create the California Values Act that would bar state or local resources from being used for immigration enforcement and prohibit state or local law enforcement agencies from detaining or transferring anyone for deportation without a judicial warrant. SB 54 is currently pending consideration in the Assembly Committee on the Judiciary.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1001 (Mitchell, Chapter 782, Statutes of 2016) prohibited, among other things, any attempt to reinvestigate or re-verify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
SB 666 (Steinberg, Chapter 577, Statutes of 2013) prohibited employers from making, adopting, or enforcing any rule, regulation, or policy preventing an employee from disclosing information to a government or law enforcement agency, as provided, and extended those prohibitions to preventing an employee from, or retaliating against an employee for, providing information to, or testifying before, any public body conducting an investigation, hearing, or inquiry.
AB 622 (Hernández, Chapter 696, Statutes of 2015) prohibited an employer or any other person or entity from using the E-Verify system at a time or in a manner not required by a specified federal law or not authorized by a federal agency memorandum of understanding to check the employment authorization status of an existing employee or an applicant who has not received an offer of employment, except as required by federal law or as a condition of receiving federal funds.
AB 1236 (Fong, Chapter 691, Statutes of 2011) set forth a series limitations on the use of electronic employment eligibility verification systems.
Prior Vote:
Senate Labor and Industrial Relations Committee (Ayes 3, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 50, Noes 24)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 6)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
**************
Compare Johnson, Policies for the Apprehension, Detention and Removal of Undocumented Immigrants (Nov. 20, 2014) U.S. Department of Homeland Security <https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/
publications/14_1120_memo_prosecutorial_discretion.pdf> (as of June 18, 2017), with Kelly, Enforcement of the Immigration Laws to Serve the National Interest (Feb. 20, 2017) U.S. Department of Homeland Security p.2 < https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/17_0220_S1_Enforcement-of-the-Immigration-Laws-to-Serve-the-National-Interest.pdf> (as of June 18, 2017). ↑
The author notes, for example, incidents in 2008 when ICE raided the Van Nuys Micro Solutions Enterprises (MSE) facility. ICE had eight criminal arrest warrants when it raided the plant and detained 800 workers at the facility. In 2007, ICE raided a Michael Bianco, Inc. (MBI) facility in Massachusetts. ICE had arrest warrants for five individuals when it blocked exits and detained 500 workers. ↑
The information contained in this Comment is based on the U.S. Customs and Immigration Services’ Handbook for Employers – Guidance on Completing Form I-9 (Jan. 22, 2017), available at <https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Verification/E-Verify/E-Verify_Native_Documents/E-Verify%20Manuals%20and%20Guides/M-274-Handbook-for-Employers.pdf> (as of July 1, 2017). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 450 Hearing Date: June 28, 2017
Author: | Chiu | ||
Version: | June 21, 2017 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gideon Baum | ||
Subject: Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
KEY ISSUES
Should the Legislature prohibit an employer from providing access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to any non-public areas of a place of labor if the agent does not have a warrant?
Should the Legislature prohibit an employer from providing access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to I-9 employment records if the agent doesn’t have a subpoena?
Should the Legislature require notices to employees and the Labor Commissioner from the employer in the event of an immigration enforcement action at the worksite?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in California. (Labor Code §1171.5)
- Provides that a State may provide that an individual who is not lawfully present in the United States is eligible for any State or local public benefit for which such alien would otherwise be ineligible through the enactment of a State law which affirmatively provides for such eligibility. (8 U.S. Code § 1621(d))
- Prohibits any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. (Labor Code §1019.1)
- Requires that employers must attest, under penalty of perjury and on a form designated or established by the federal Attorney General by regulation, that it has verified that the individual is not an unauthorized alien by examining specified documents, which include a United States passport, resident alien card, and an identification card with a photograph that contains security features that prevents counterfeit or fraud. The worker must also attest, under the penalty of perjury, that he or she can legally work in the United States. These attestations and records are commonly known as I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms/records. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
- Requires that employers retain a copy of the attestations discussed above and make available for inspection by officers of the Service, the Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices, or the Department of Labor during a period beginning on the date of the hiring, recruiting, or referral of the individual and ending with 1 year of a worker’s termination. (8 U.S. Code § 1324a)
AB 450 creates various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency worksite enforcement actions.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a properly executed warrant.
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent voluntary access to the employer’s employee records without a subpoena.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise prohibited by federal law, to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employer’s worksite. That notice must be in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information and contain:
- The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
- The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
- A copy of the notice of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner (LC) deems material and necessary.
This notice must be hand delivered or, if not possible, mailed or emailed to the employee within 24 hours.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise prohibited by federal law, to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice shall contain the following information:
- A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration worksite enforcement action results notice.
- The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
- Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
This notice must be hand delivered or, if not possible, mailed or emailed to the employee within 24 hours.
- Requires an employer, except as otherwise prohibited by federal law, to notify the LC of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Requires an employer to notify the LC before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, in a manner not required by federal law.
- Prohibits an employer from re-verifying employment eligibility of a current employee, at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Requires the LC, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution, to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions described in this bill of $2,000-$5,000 for a first violation, or $5,000-$10,000 for each subsequent violation, to be recoverable by the LC.
- Provides that the provisions of AB 450 are severable.
COMMENTS
1. Immigration, Federal Policy, and the California Legislature:
“Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
MOTHER OF EXILES. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she
With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
- Emma Lazarus, “The New Colossus”
In popular culture, it is common to hear the United States of America be referred to as a “Nation of Immigrants”. As many Americans can trace their roots to ancestors who voluntarily immigrated to this country, this sentiment has particular currency. Moreover, as touched on by Lazarus’s poem, it evokes a powerful image: oppressed and exiled, my ancestors were welcomed into a land of freedom and plenty. Today, because of their sacrifices, I am able to enjoy everything that America has to offer, and I will be able to extend that gift to those who come after me.
Unfortunately, the historical record shows many instances where America fell short in extending the light of freedom to the exiled and huddled masses of the world. For example, in the Naturalization Act of 1790, which was passed by a Congress made up of many Founding Fathers and signed by President George Washington, naturalization was limited to “a free white person” who resided in the United States for two years. The Naturalization Act of 1795 kept the restriction of naturalization to “a free white person”, but extended the residency period to 5 years. It wasn’t until 1870 that individuals born in Africa could naturalize as American citizens. However, exclusions from naturalization were kept in place for Asians.
In 1913, building off of this exclusion, the California State Legislature passed the Alien Land Law, which excluded “aliens” who are not eligible for citizenship from owning land, specifically targeting Japanese farmers. The bill passed 35-2 in the Senate (where it was introduced) and 72-3 in the Assembly. The bill was signed into law by Governor Hiram Johnson. The bill that became law was actually a compromise measure, and the Legislature had considered several bills that were much more stringent. During the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on one of the more stringent bills, farmers testified “with tears streaming down their faces” of white farmers being driven off the land by Japanese farmers and the inevitability of violence if nothing is done.[1] Prior to the passage of the final Alien Land Law, one Assemblyman offered amendments to make the measure more stringent, stating “This is not a question of dollars and cents but of civilization.”[2]
Then, in 1920, the Alien Land Law was further strengthened by an initiative, which passed 668,483 (75%) to 222,086 (25%), that inhibited the ability of Japanese farmers to lease agricultural land. The California State Legislature went on to strengthen and expand the Alien Land Law in 1923 and 1927. Despite this, Japanese farmers circumvented the law by developing complex ownership arrangements. These ownership arrangements, however, were illegal and could result in enforcement actions where the State would seize and sell the land or fine the Japanese immigrant due to the violation of the law. For example, the State Attorney General reported to the Legislature that, in the period between 1943 and 1945, he has secured a $100,000 penalty from one farming concern alone, which is the equivalent of approximately $1.45 million in today’s dollars.
Upheld by the United States Supreme Court as constitutional in 1923 and 1933, the Alien Land Law continued to be enforced throughout the 1940s. As Japanese individuals were released from internment camps, Governor Earl Warren signed into law SB 415 (Chapter 1136, Statutes of 1945), which clarified that there was no statute of limitations on seizing “alien” land, while another bill passed the same year created a trust fund and appropriation for the enforcement of the Alien Land Act. Declared unconstitutional in 1948 and 1952 by the U.S. Supreme Court and California Supreme Court respectively, it wasn’t until 1955 that the California State Legislature put on the ballot an initiative to repeal the Alien Land Law, which was overwhelmingly passed by the voters in 1956 (66.8% to 33.2%).
From the vantage point of contemporary California, it is difficult to comprehend how our government could privilege and enforce a system of naked racial animus upon a group of immigrants for more than 40 years. Forced to circumvent a fundamentally unjust law in order to make a living, Japanese farmers sought to improve their lives and the lives of their children, just like other immigrants. The difference, unfortunately, was that Japanese individuals not born in the United States were unable to become citizens due to federal immigration policy. Fortunately, this is no longer the case for Japanese immigrants: a federal immigration reform bill in 1952 created a path for Japanese immigrants to become naturalized citizens, ending decades of discrimination. Finally, after Congress took action, the lamp was raised a bit higher by the golden door.
2. Staff Comments:
The Basic Components of AB 450
Broadly speaking, AB 450 requires employers to do three things: first, ask immigration enforcement officers for a warrant before granting access to non-public areas of employment; second, requiring immigration enforcement officers to have a subpoena before accessing employee records; and third, requiring that notice of immigration enforcement actions be communicated to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement and workers, including affected workers if necessary. Each provision will be discussed in detail below.
Warrants
As noted above, AB 450 requires employers to request a judicial warrant before granting access to non-public areas of a workplace. Under federal regulations, an immigration officer needs to secure either the consent of the employer or a warrant in order to access a non-public area of the workplace, with certain exceptions (such as exigent circumstances). As with other warrants, an immigration officer would need to show probable cause of the presence of an illegally employed worker before securing a warrant from a judge. However, unlike other judicial warrants, immigration officers have a relaxed standard for a valid warrant, and it does not need to include the names of the individuals who are employed at the specific location or factory. This is frequently referred to as a “Blackie’s warrant” after the case which originated it (Blackie’s House of Beef v. Castillo, 659 F. 2d 1211 (D.C. Cir. 1981)). In short, the impact of AB 450 is to require that the employer request a judicial warrant before granting immigration enforcement officials access to non-public areas to ensure that the immigration enforcement action is lawful, rather than consenting to an immigration enforcement action without ascertaining legality.
Subpoenas
Unlike warrants, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which is part of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, can issue its own subpoenas under federal law. As such, the requirement in AB 450 that a request to inspect I-9 documents be accompanied with a subpoena would not require ICE to contact a judge. Moreover, an employer must comply with a subpoena from ICE. If an employer does not comply, ICE can compel compliance through the court system.
Notice
As discussed above, AB 450 has four separate notice requirements: one for workers when ICE inspects I-9 employment records; one for affected workers after ICE inspects I-9 employment records; one for the Labor Commissioner when ICE conducts an enforcement action, including the inspection of I-9 employment records; and one for the Labor Commissioner when the employer self-audits I-9 OR when the employer checks I-9 verification in a manner not required by federal law. Each of these notices must be provided within 24 hours. Otherwise, an employer would face penalties of $2,000 to $10,000 per violation, depending on prior violations.
Noting that an employer is getting ready for the ICE enforcement action, reaching out to workers, contacting the Labor Commissioner AND operating the business in as normal a manner as possible, such truncated timelines may not be feasible for many employers. Additionally, as an employer may wish to shred expired I-9 employment information, requiring a notice be given to the Labor Commissioner prior to the destruction of sensitive, out-of-date documents may not lead to superior policy outcomes. Finally, while AB 450 requires the Labor Commissioner be notified if the employer is checking I-9 verification forms outside of federal requirements, it does not require such notice be given to the employee’s labor representative, who may be in a position to give assistance to the worker.
Possible Amendments
Therefore, the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- In Labor Code Section 90.25(a) of the bill, lengthening the timeline for an employer to notify his or her employees of an upcoming inspection of I-9 employment records from “within 24 hours” to “within 72 hours”;
- In Labor Code Section 90.25(b) of the bill, lengthening the timeline for an employer to notify his or her employees affected by an I-9 employment records from “within 24 hours” to “within 48 hours”; and
- In Labor Code Section 90.9(b) of the bill, strike “before conducting a self-audit of, inspection of, or review of, I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms and” from the bill and insert “employee’s labor representative”.
3. Proponent Arguments:
Proponents argue that “immigration raids undermine workers’ rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers’ ability to freely exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws.” The author also notes that “past experience with worksite raids demonstrates the likelihood of raids violating employee due process. ICE has routinely violated basic constitutional rights, such as the 4th amendment's protections against unreasonable search and seizure. ICE has detained all workers, without any individualized suspicion, regardless of status when conducting workplace raids. For example, in prior worksite raids, ICE has used individual arrest warrants and administrative warrants to question and detain every single worker - including U.S. citizens & lawfully present workers - in a workplace without individualized suspicion.” Proponent argue that AB 450, through notices to the employees and Labor Commissioner, will ensure that workers understand their rights and are aware of what enforcement actions are taking place. Further, by requiring a warrant or subpoena before certain ICE enforcement actions, proponents argue that AB 450 will ensure that ICE’s enforcement actions do not violate the due process rights of both employers and employees.
4. Opponent Arguments:
The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) opposes AB 450, arguing:
“Compliance with the provision in the bill requires multiple employees at the employers’ place of work to understand fully federal law regarding ICE agents’ access and puts employers in a bind. For example, an administrative assistant who is approached by an ICE agent is likely to comply with what the uniformed officer asks. If the ICE officer is asking for access beyond what is provided for in federal law, it is highly unlikely that the administrative assistant will be aware. It is unreasonable to expect many people within organizations (administrative, HR professionals, security staff, etc.) to have such detailed knowledge of federal law that would be required to comply. Training these employees would require major resource expenditures from employers.”
SHRM also argues that the I-9 notices to the employee and the Labor Commissioner are burdensome, noting: “This could be the entire workforce for the company, as well as those who have left the company in the last year. Federal law requires the retention of I-9s for three years after hire or one year after termination of employment, whichever is later. Getting notice out in a 3-day window would be an administrative challenge requiring significant resources, particularly for large employers who have thousands in their workforce.”
SHRM also argues that the requirement to notify the Labor Commissioner before a self-audit of I-9 verification forms “to mean that an employer is required to notify the state every time they re-verify an employee who needs to be re-verified for a legitimate reason, such as an H-1B visa holder who receives an extension. This is highly burdensome because the new requirement is on-going and could happen more than once with the same employee. Additionally, self-audits of I-9 files performed by our members are reasonable and should be encouraged, not discouraged. There is a distinction to be made between an audit of forms to ensure they are filled out correctly in compliance with federal law, and situations where employers actually go back and look at documents again or ask employees for new documentation – practices that are already prohibited by law.”
5. Double Referral:
This bill has been double-referred and, if approved by this committee, will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
6. Prior Legislation:
SB 1001 (Mitchell), Chapter 782, Statutes of 2016, prohibits, among other things, any attempt to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice.
SB 624 (Lara), Chapter 290, Statutes of 2015, restates and reinforces existing law on the right of undocumented workers to be eligible for benefits from the Uninsured Employers Benefits Trust Fund (UEBTF) and the Subsequent Injuries Benefit Trust Fund (SIBTF).
SB 666 (Steinberg), Chapter 577, Statutes of 2013, prohibits employer from making, adopting, or enforcing any rule, regulation, or policy preventing an employee from disclosing information to a government or law enforcement agency, as provided, and would extend those prohibitions to preventing an employee from, or retaliating against an employee for, providing information to, or testifying before, any public body conducting an investigation, hearing, or inquiry.
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation (Co-sponsor)
SEIU California (Co-sponsor)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Bet Tzedek Legal Services
Brightline Defense
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Domestic Workers Coalition
California Federation of Teachers
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
CHIRLA
City and County of San Francisco
San Francisco Labor Council
San Mateo Labor Council
State Building and Construction Trades Council
UAW Local 5810
United Domestic Workers
United Farm Workers
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Worksafe
OPPOSITION
Agricultural Council of California
Associated General Contractors of California
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bankers Association
California Bean Shippers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Framing Contractors Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Pool & Spa Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Seed Association
California Trucking Assn
California Warehouse Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chambers of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Grower-Shipper Association of Central California
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Businesses
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce and Tourist Bureau
Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce
Society for Human Resource Management
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
The Chamber of Commerce of the Santa Barbara Region
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Vacaville Chamber of Commerce
Ventura County Agricultural Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Yuba-Sutter Chamber of Commerce
-- END --
“We have a dead line at Elk Grove now, beyond with the brown man cannot pass. If we are denied relief from the situation that confronts us, I will not be responsible for what will surely happen. “ M.A. Mitchell, Elk Grove farmer, March 19, 1913. From Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1913 by Franklin Hichborn, pg. 225. ↑
Ibid., Pg. 271. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 450
Author:(Chiu)
As Amended Ver:May 30, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Labor | 5-2 | Thurmond, Chiu, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, McCarty | Flora, Harper |
Judiciary | 8-3 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Cunningham, Kiley, Maienschein |
Appropriations | 10-6 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, McCarty, Quirk, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Imposes various requirements upon employers related to federal immigration worksite enforcement actions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer from providing federal immigration enforcement agents access to either nonpublic areas of work place without a properly executed warrant, except as otherwise provided by federal law, or to employee records without a subpoena.
- Requires an employer to provide certain notifications to an employee and an employee's representative, regarding federal immigration worksite enforcement actions or the results of those actions, and requires an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner (LC) of these actions within a defined timeframe.
- Prohibits employers from checking the employment eligibility of current employees, except as required by federal law, and requires them to notify LC before conducting these checks in instances when they have to as required by federal law.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions, specified of $2,000 to $5,000 for a first violation and $5,000 to $10,000 for subsequent violations.
- Authorizes the LC to waive or lower the fine for permitting access to nonpublic areas of a place of labor without a judicial warrant, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes.
- Grants the LC access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
- Provides, under federal law, that an immigration officer may not enter into the non-public areas of a business or a farm or other outdoor agricultural operation for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant or the consent of the owner. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. Specifies that nothing in this provision prohibits an immigration officer from entering into any area of a business to which the general public has access or onto open fields that are not farms or other outdoor agricultural operations without a warrant or consent.
- Requires, under federal law, an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. Specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, increased costs to the Division of Labor Standards and Employment (DLSE) in excess of $2.5 million. While there is considerably uncertainty about the precise fiscal impacts of this bill, DLSE would likely need new enforcement and legal staff to review worksite incidents and potentially seek remedies in civil court.
COMMENTS: Recent executive actions from the new federal administration have signaled that all immigrants here without permission are now enforcement priorities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Nationwide, there are reports of ICE agents descending on worksites for mass round-ups of immigrants. Additionally, the Trump administration has called for hiring 10,000 more ICE agents to expedite deportations.
This bill seeks to ensure that all California workers, regardless of immigration status, enjoy the protections afforded to them under state law "without fear of harassment, detention, or deportation." According to the author, this bill will help achieve this by insisting that federal immigration enforcement agents meet the full procedural requirements of federal law and by making affected workers aware of federal enforcement actions and cognizant of their rights during such actions.
The California Labor Federation and SEIU California, the co-sponsors of this bill, assert that "millions of union members are immigrants and worksite immigration raids undermine workers' rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers' ability freely to exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws."
The California Chamber of Commerce and others write, "While the intent of the bill is to protect the rights of workers, the bill instead places employers who are not violating worker rights in serious legal jeopardy. The bill does not differentiate between good and bad employers; instead, it assumes the employer has committed violations by opening the door to an inspection by the Labor Commissioner where no just cause is present." They continue that an employer, who is in full compliance with federal immigration laws and chooses to minimize disruption of business operations by federal officials, will be penalized for choosing to cooperate with federal enforcement officials instead of exercising their right to a warrant from federal authorities.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Richard / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000757
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 450
Author:(Chiu) – As Amended Ver:April 27, 2017
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
Judiciary | 8 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill imposes various requirements upon employers related to federal immigration worksite enforcement actions. In summary, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer from providing federal immigration enforcement agents access either to certain work areas without a properly executed warrant, except as otherwise provided by federal law, or to employee records without a subpoena.
- Requires an employer to provide certain notifications to an employee, or an employee’s representative, regarding federal immigration worksite enforcement actions or the results of those actions, and requires an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of these actions within a defined timeframe.
- Prohibits employers from checking the employment eligibility of current employees, except as required by federal law, and requires them to notify Labor Commissioner before conducting these checks in instances when they have to as required by federal law.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy the requirements and prohibitions, specified of $10,000 to $25,000 for each violation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Increased costs to the Division of Labor Standards and Employment (DLSE) in the range of $6.5 million to $11.5 million. While there is considerably uncertainty about the precise fiscal impacts of this bill, DLSE would likely need “on call” staff across the 17 DLSE regional office as well as significant legal resources to review worksite incidents and potentially seek remedies in civil court.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Under existing federal law and regulations, immigration officers are prohibited from entering the non-public areas of a business or a farm for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant, or the consent of the owner, or some agent of the owner who has authority to grant consent. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. Moreover, federal agents sometimes come to the workplace not to search the premises, but to inspect business and employee records. In such a case, federal agents must provide the employer with a subpoena and a three-day notice before inspecting any records.
- Recent federal actions. Recent executive actions from the new federal administration have signaled that all immigrants here without permission are now enforcement priorities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Nationwide, there are reports of ICE agents descending on worksites for mass round-ups of immigrants. Additionally, the Trump administration has called for hiring 10,000 more ICE agents to expedite deportations.
- Purpose. This bill seeks to ensure that all California workers, regardless of immigration status, enjoy the protections afforded to them under state law “without fear of harassment, detention, or deportation." According to the author, AB 450 will help achieve this by insisting that federal immigration enforcement agents meet the full procedural requirements of federal law and by making affected workers aware of federal enforcement actions and cognizant of their rights during such actions.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 450
Author:(Chiu) – As Amended Ver:March 23, 2017
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
KEY ISSUES:
- Should employers be required to demand that federal agents conducting an immigration enforcement action at the employer’s workplace present a warrant to search the premises, or a subpoena to inspect records held at the premises?
- Should employers be required to notify workers and the Labor Commissioner, as specified, when they know that an immigration enforcement action will occur at their workplace?
- should the labor commissioner, upon receiving notice of an action, be authorized to inform affected workers of their rights?
SYNOPSIS
This is one of many bills that have come before the Committee this session with the goal of protecting immigrants from an expected increase in federal immigration enforcement actions. This particular bill seeks to protect employees in the workplace by requiring employers to ensure that federal immigration agents have properly executed search warrants and subpoenas in order to search worksites or examine documents, as is already required under federal law. In addition, this bill requires employers, to the extent permitted under federal law, to notify employees of an immigration enforcement action that is to be conducted at the worksite and to notify the employee about the results of any immigration audit or inspection. The bill also requires the employer to notify the California Labor Commissioner within 24 hours of receiving notice of a planned enforcement action or, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to notify the Commissioner upon learning of the action. Finally, the bill authorizes the Commissioner, when notified that an enforcement action will occur, to provide affected employees with information about their rights under the law. The bill is co-sponsored by SEIU California and the California Labor Federation. The bill is opposed by several business, agricultural, and manufacturing groups who argue that this bill would deny a property owner the fundamental right to determine who may or may not enter the owner's property; that it will prevent businesses from cooperating with federal authorities when doing so would result in the least interruption of the business or workplace; and that it will unfairly place them in the crosshairs of competing state and federal policies objectives. While the opposition raises important and fundamental questions that warrant careful consideration, the Committee believes that the provisions of this bill are well within the legitimate powers of the state and are appropriately mindful of federal authority over immigration matters. The bill asserts the state's right and obligation to protect all California residents who call California home, raise families here, and work and contribute mightily to the state's economic prosperity and rich cultural tapestry. The author will take a number of clarifying amendments in this Committee. The bill summary and analysis reflect those amendments.
SUMMARY: Imposes various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration worksite enforcement actions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer, or a person acting on behalf of an employer, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to any non-public areas of a place of labor without a properly executed warrant, except as otherwise required by federal law.
- Prohibits an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent with the employer’s employee records without a subpoena.
- Requires an employer to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of a federal immigration worksite enforcement action at the employer’s worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. That notice must be in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information and contain the following:
- The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the enforcement action.
- The date that the employer received notice of the enforcement action.
- The nature of the enforcement action to the extent known.
- A copy of the notice of an immigration enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
- Requires an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice shall contain the following information:
- A description of all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration enforcement action results notice.
- The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct deficiencies.
- Notice that the employee has the right to representation, as specified.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
- Requires an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner of a federal government immigration agency immigration enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner, during a workplace enforcement action, to access the place of employment and provide the following information to employees affected by the action:
- An employee has the right to remain silent.
- An employee has the right to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.
- An employee has the right to speak to his or her foreign consulate.
- Requires an employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit or inspection of employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Prohibits an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Requires the Labor Commissioner, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under federal law, that an immigration officer may not enter into the non-public areas of a business or a farm or other outdoor agricultural operation for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant or the consent of the owner. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. Specifies that nothing in this provision prohibits an immigration officer from entering into any area of a business to which the general public has access or onto open fields that are not farms or other outdoor agricultural operations without a warrant or consent. (8 USC Section 1357; 8 CFR Section 287.8 (f) (2) and (4).)
- Requires an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. Specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. (8 USC Section 1324a (b).)
- Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for any person or entity to do any of the following:
- Discriminate against any individual, except as provided, with respect to the hiring, recruitment, or referral of the individual for employment or the discharging of the individual from employment.
- Request, with the intent of discriminating against an individual, more or different documents than are required under law or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine. (8 USC Section 1342a (a)(1)-(6).)
- Prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising his or her rights under state or local labor law. These protected rights include the following:
- Filing a complaint or informing any person of an employer’s or other party’s alleged violation of a state or local labor law, so long as the complaint or disclosure is made in good faith.
- Seeking information regarding whether an employer or other party is in compliance with state or local labor law.
- Informing a person of his or her potential rights and remedies under state or local labor law, or assisting him or her in asserting those rights. (Labor Code Section 1019 (a).)
- Defines "unfair immigration-related practice," for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government:
- Requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine.
- Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law.
- Threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, or threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities. (Labor Code Section 1019 (b).)
- Specifies that engaging in an unfair immigration-related practice against a person within 90 days of the person’s exercise of a protected right shall raise a rebuttable presumption of having done so in retaliation for the exercise of those rights. (Labor Code Section 1019 (c).)
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney's fees. (Labor Code Section 1019 (d) (1).)
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. (Labor Code Section 1019.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, like others that have come before the Committee this session, is a response to recent federal Executive Orders and memoranda that have signaled the current administration's desire to step up immigration enforcement. The author contends that, should this occur, California will be profoundly affected, citing estimates of over 2.6 million undocumented immigrants in the state. Immigration workplace raids, the author believes, will present a number of problems. For example, the threat of immigration worksite raids decreases the likelihood that workers will report labor violations or exercise workplace rights. Employers, the author believes, to the detriment of their workers, take an overly permissive approach with immigration agents at the expense of the workers' due process and privacy rights. Generally, this bill seeks to ensure that all workers in California will enjoy the rights and protections afforded to them under California law "without fear of harassment, detention, or deportation." The author hopes to achieve this primarily by insisting that federal agents meet the full procedural requirements of federal law and by making affected workers aware of federal enforcement actions and cognizant of their rights during such actions.
Specifically, AB 450 will require employers to do the following: (1) ensure that federal immigration agents have properly executed warrants and subpoenas to search worksites or examine documents; (2) notify employees, to the extent permitted by federal law, about immigration enforcement actions and any results of such action; and (3) notify the California Labor Commissioner within 24 hours of receiving notice of a planned enforcement action or, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to notify the Commissioner upon learning of the action. The bill authorizes the Commissioner, once notified of an enforcement action, to take certain actions. Among other things, the Commissioner may elect to exercise its existing authority to enter any workplace to provide affected employees with information about their rights under the law. In addition, the bill refines existing state regulations regarding an employer's ability to perform audits or request re-verification or other documents of prospective or current employees. Existing state law already imposes limits on "unfair immigration related practices" that, consistent with federal law, imposes limits on the time, manner, or purposes of requesting work authorization documents. For example, existing state law generally prohibits employers from requesting more or different documentation than is required by federal law, or to request documents or re-verification for retaliatory purposes. This bill extends these basic objectives by prohibiting self-audits or inspection of related verification forms in a time or manner that is not required by federal law.
Existing Federal Law: Existing federal statutes and regulations set forth the procedures by which federal immigration officers conduct immigration enforcement actions, which include both worksite inspections (in which the agents search the non-public workplace premises) and demands to see records or documents, including I-9 work authorization forms and related documents. First, and perhaps most relevant to this bill, federal law and regulations prohibit an immigration officer from entering the non-public areas of a business or a farm for the purpose of questioning the occupants or employees concerning their right to be or remain in the United States, unless the officer has either a warrant, or the consent of the owner, or some agent of the owner who has authority to grant consent. If the immigration officer is denied access to conduct a site inspection, a warrant may be obtained. (8 USC Section 1357; 8 CFR Section 287.8 (f) (2) and (4).) Second, federal agents sometimes come to the workplace not to search the premises, but to inspect business and employee records. In such a case, federal agents must provide the employer with a subpoena and a three-day notice before inspecting any records. This bill, therefore, is consistent with federal law except in that it eliminates the employer's ability to grant access to premises and records by consent. The Committee is not aware of any data as to how often immigration officers show up at a workplace with a warrant, or the number of times that immigration officers show up without a warrant assuming that employers will grant consent, thereby obviating the need for a warrant. Nor is the Committee aware of any data on how often employers exercise their right to insist upon a warrant, and how often they grant consent in the absence of a warrant. Without this data, it is difficult to fully evaluate the impact of this bill.
In addition, existing federal law requires employers to verify that all of their employees are eligible to work in the United States, and permits various documents or combinations of documents to be used to demonstrate citizenship, legal permanent resident status, or, if neither a citizen nor a permanent legal resident, authorization to work in the United States. Federal law also protects against abuse of these requirements by making it an "unfair immigration-related practice" to request more or different documents than are required under law, or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine, if these additional requests or refusals are for the purpose of discrimination or intimidation.
U.S. v. Arizona: Federal Preemption and State Police Power: U.S. immigration policy has, since at least the late nineteenth century, been the exclusive domain of the federal government. (Chy Lung v. Freeman (1876) 92 U.S. 275.) Nonetheless, the states, in the exercise of their police powers, may enact laws and regulations that impact immigrants and immigration, so long as those laws do not conflict with or frustrate the purpose of federal law. The U.S. Supreme Court spoke most recently on the tensions between state law and federal immigration policy in United States v. Arizona (2012), a decision that upheld some parts, but struck down other parts, of Arizona's SB 1070. Convinced that the federal government was not doing enough to enforce immigration laws, the Arizona legislature passed and Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed, SB 1070. That measure, among other things, (1) created a state-law crime for being unlawfully present in the United States, (2) created a state-law crime for working or seeking work while not authorized to do so, (3) required state and local officers to verify the citizenship or alien status of anyone who was lawfully arrested or detained, and (4) authorized warrantless arrests of aliens believed to be removable from the United States. A federal district court enjoined all of these provisions, and the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court confirmed the district court ruling. Arizona appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court ruled that (1) and (2) were pre-empted because they created new state-law crimes that directly conflicted with federal registration requirements and enforcement provisions, respectively. The Court ruled that (4) was preempted because it usurped the federal government's authority to use discretion in the removal process. However, the Court upheld (3) because it simply allowed state law enforcement officials to communicate with federal immigration officials during otherwise lawful arrests and detentions. (United States v. Arizona (2012) 565 U.S. 1092.)
If constitutional law is, as Berkeley Law Professor John Yoo has suggested, just "politics by other means," the proponents of this bill will likely argue that AB 450 is more like the provisions in SB 1070 that the U.S. Supreme court upheld. Opponents will likely argue that AB 450 is more like the parts of SB 1070 that the U.S. Supreme Court struck down. [John Yoo, "The Continuation of Politics by Other Means: Original Understanding of the War Powers," 84 Cal. L. Rev. 167 (1986.)] However, in striking down three of the four provisions in SB 1070, the Court stressed that those three provisions directly "conflicted" with federal law: that is, the federal government sets the standards of who can be lawfully present in the United States; the federal government establishes the framework about who is authorized to work in the United States; and the federal government has the exclusive power to arrest persons for purposes of deportation, unless the federal government formally enlists the support of and authorizes state officials to act as immigration officers. (8 USC 1357 (g).) AB 450 does not "conflict" with any federal law, as that term is understood in federal preemption analysis. Under that analysis, a state law conflicts with a federal law if it is impossible to comply with both laws and fundamentally frustrates the purpose of federal law. (Gade v. National Solid Wastes Mgmt. Associations (1992) 505 U.S. 88.) Existing federal law already requires immigration agents to obtain a warrant to search a worksite and a subpoena to access employee records, unless the employer grants consent. This bill effectively takes away the employer's option to grant consent. Taking away this option to consent may or may not be fair to the employer, or it may or may not be good policy, but it does not "conflict" with federal law as that term is used in federal preemption analysis. That is, it is still possible for the employer to comply with both state and federal law. If the employer complies with the state law by asking to see a warrant, he or she is not violating any federal law. The employer, by asking to see a warrant, is simply doing something that he or she clearly has a right to do under federal law.
Policy and Fairness Concerns Raised by the Opposition: Even if AB 450 is not preempted by federal law, it does not mean that it is good policy or that it does not raise other concerns about the due process and property rights of employers. Perhaps the most fundamental argument raised by the opposition is that this bill takes away the employer's fundamental right, as a property owner, to determine who can and cannot enter the owner's property. As every first year law student learns, one of the "sticks" in the property rights "bundle" is the "right to exclude," and the necessary corollary of the right to exclude is the right to say who shall be allowed entry. However, the other thing that every first year law student learns is that property rights, like all other rights, are not absolute. This is especially true when it comes to the state's "police power" – which Black's Law Dictionary defines as the "power of the State to place restrictions on the personal freedom and property rights of persons for the protection of the public safety, health, and morals." (5th Ed., p. 1041.) One existing example of how state police power infringes upon property rights, especially the "right to exclude," is the provision of the Labor Code that gives the Labor Commission "free access" to any workplace in order to enforce labor laws. (Labor Code Section 90 and 90.5.) One of the opponents directly asks: Can the state prohibit an employer from giving consent to federal agents to enter the employer's workplace? The answer appears to be "yes."
Returning with "an Attitude". In addition, opponents raise a number of other points about the practical consequences of this bill. In particular, opponents argue that there are often good reasons for an employer to provide consent, rather than demand that federal agents obtain a warrant to enter non-public areas of their premises. For example, given that the employer is dealing with a federal agency that has the power, and some discretion, to impose penalties, employers do not want to antagonize federal agents if they believe they have complied with immigration employment requirements and have nothing to hide. Most employers prefer that workplace enforcement actions take place with as little disruption as possible, and under certain circumstances, it might be least disruptive for them to grant consent. In addition, opponents fear that demanding a warrant will be seen by federal agents as non-cooperation. This non-cooperation will only delay, not prevent, the enforcement action; and will simply mean that immigration agents will return with a warrant and "an attitude." This is a reasonable concern. However, as the author and co-sponsors reasonably point out, federal agents will not see the employers as being "un-cooperative" if they know – which they will – that the demand is required by state law. Indeed, in some cases, this bill would provide an employer who is not prepared, or simply does not want, to grant access to federal agents with a valid reason for withholding consent: they are required to do so by state law.
The Problem of Employees Granting Access: Another practical problem which opponents point to concerns the likelihood that it will often be an employee, rather than an employer, who is confronted with the question of whether to grant consent or demand a warrant. Consider, for example, the 18-year old waiter or waitress in a restaurant who is confronted with several uniformed and armed ICE officers who demand access to the kitchen, or some other place that is not open to the public. Suppose further that the employer is not on the premises. Even if the employer informed his employees of their legal obligations under this bill, would the young employee, confronted with federal officers, be likely to demand a warrant? Would the young employee know, if a warrant were presented, whether the warrant was valid and properly executed? Clearly, the author does not intend for the employee to be subjected to a fine for allowing access, and one of the author’s amendments addresses that issue. However, this leaves a related issue unresolved. If the young employee granted access without a warrant, would the employer be subject to the substantial $10,000 to $25,000 fine, even if the employer had provided training to employees to ask for a warrant, but in the pressure of the moment, the employee was not brave or calm-minded enough to ask for one? Perhaps this means that the employer will need to designate a managerial-level person, to whom federal agents would be directed, and it would be the employer's responsibility to ensure that that person understood the law. Nonetheless, the Committee may wish to explore with the author whether an employer who provides reasonable training to employees and managers should be subject to a lesser fine in the event that access is granted by an employee, despite the training.
Proposed Author Amendments: The author will take amendments in this Committee that will address some, but by no means all, of the opposition's other practical concerns. For example, the prohibition on granting access to the workplace without a warrant will be amended to clarify that an employer can only demand a warrant in order for immigration officers to search the "non-public" areas of the workplace. In other words, immigration agents are free—under current law, as well as under the provisions of the bill—to enter that part of the workplace that is open to the general public. This amendment not only is consistent with the federal warrant requirement, but also addresses a concern raised by some opponents who argue that agents could not even enter the premises to provide the employer with a subpoena for records unless they also had a warrant to enter the property in the first place. This clearly was not the intent of the author, and this amendment will make that clear.
The author will also amend the bill to clarify that the civil penalty does not apply to an employee who grants access without a warrant or subpoena.
Finally, the amendments remove provisions of the bill in print that purported to give authority to the Labor Commissioner, upon receiving notice of an enforcement action, to access workplaces to conduct “investigations.” The Commissioner already has authority to access any workplace to conduct investigations on any matter within the Commission's jurisdiction. Therefore, the author will delete these provisions as they are redundant and potentially confusing. However, the bill retains those provisions which authorize the Commissioner to access the workplace to inform workers of their rights, and maintains the provisions that require the employer to provide certain notices to the Labor Commissioner, regarding immigration enforcement actions and employer self-audits.
The specific amendments are as follows:
- On page 3, line 4, after "to" insert: any non-public areas of
- On page 3, line 7, delete "or a person acting on behalf of the employer"
- On page 3, line 20, delete "or a person acting on behalf of the employer"
- On page 6 line 10 delete "The employer shall provide access to the Labor" and delete lines 11-13.
- On page 6, line 19, insert a period after "action" and delete "and shall provide access to Labor" and delete lines 20-22.
- On page 6, line 23 delete "or a person acting on behalf of the employer"
- On page 6, line 33 delete "(1)"
- On page 7, delete lines 3-11
- On page 7, line 20, delete "The employer shall provide access to the Labor" and delete lines 21-23.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
Immigration worksite raids present a number of problems. They decrease the likelihood of undocumented workers reporting labor violations or exercising workplace rights. Further, when ICE acts on information provided by unscrupulous employers seeking to intimidate workers, the government becomes complicit in the infringement of workers’ labor rights. The promise of increased worksite raids also creates the fear that employers may take misguided steps, outside of what is required under federal or state law, which could violate workers’ due process rights, labor rights, or their privacy rights. For example, employers unnecessarily allowing access to a worksite could cause all workers, citizen and undocumented, to be detained in harsh conditions at a worksite or could lead to the exposure of confidential personal information held by the employer.
Past experience with worksite raids demonstrates the likelihood of raids violating employee due process. ICE has routinely violated basic constitutional rights, such as the 4th amendment's protections against unreasonable search and seizure. ICE has detained all workers, without any individualized suspicion, regardless of status when conducting workplace raids. For example, in prior worksite raids, ICE has used individual arrest warrants and administrative warrants to question and detain every single worker - including U.S. citizens & lawfully present workers - in a workplace without individualized suspicion.
In California, workers have reported employers threatening to call immigration authorities when workers attempt to exercise their rights to minimum wages, meal breaks, or organizing activities that are protected by California law regardless of status.
The California Labor Federation and SEIU California, the co-sponsors of this bill, claim that “millions of union members are immigrants and worksite immigration raids undermine workers’ rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers’ ability freely to exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws.”
The California Immigrant Policy Center (CIPC), like many of the supporters of this bill, point to the recent presidential election and change in policy that it portends. CICP writes: "Recent executive actions by the federal Government have confirmed that all undocumented immigrants are enforcement priorities. California has already seen a jump in immigration enforcement action that have torn apart families and terrorized local communities. It is widely anticipated that worksite raids will increase as part of the deportation activities prioritized by the federal government. Immigrants are the backbone of so many California industries and widespread worksite raids will be disruptive and cause confusion and potential chaos. Guidelines for employers and clear protections for employees is critical to reduce the harm of worksite enforcement activities.”
Worksafe argues that “California will be greatly impacted by a policy shift toward workplace raids. Over 2.6 million undocumented immigrants reside in California. Undocumented workers make up 45 percent of California’s agricultural workforce and 21 percent of construction. In fact, almost 1 in every 10 workers in California is undocumented.” Given this likely impact for California, in particular, Worksafe concludes that California "has an obligation to ensure that any worksite enforcement is conducted hand-in-hand with labor enforcement and worker protections. California should adopt policies that promote, rather than suppress, workers’ ability to exercise their workplace rights without fear of reprisal. Employers should have clear rules about how to respond to worksite raids. Additionally, the Labor Commissioner must have the necessary tools to protect workers’ rights in the face of increased federal enforcement.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Manufacturers and Technology Association (CMTA) argue that AB 450 "would place manufacturers in the precarious position of having to choose which government body to comply with or face hefty penalties and potential legal consequences." CMTA adds that, under this bill, "a manufacturer who is in full compliance with federal immigration laws but elects to cooperate with enforcement agents because they determine at the time that the best course of action to minimize impact on business operations and preserve the safety of all their workers could end up being subject to steep fines [of $10,000 to $25,000 per violation.] Additionally, the response demanded under the bill could arguably be deemed "illegal" under federal law and ultimately place the employer or someone acting on their behalf (i.e. shift supervisor, operations manager, receptionist, etc.) in legal jeopardy for noncompliance with a federal enforcement action." CMTA also objects to the provision in the bill that permits the Labor Commissioner, upon notice of an action, to "enter the work facility and conduct a wall-to-wall investigation of worksite absent any evidence." Finally, CMTA asserts that "as immigration law is exclusively the jurisdiction of the federal government, it is questionable whether AB 450 offends the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution and would thereby be preempted by federal law."
The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) writes that "from the human resource professional’s perspective, AB 450, while well intentioned, will add a host of unnecessary burdensome requirements, create many logistical challenges, and could possibly force human resource professionals to decide between abiding by federal law or state law." SHRM claims that most employees, who will often be the ones to interact with immigration officers, typically lack the knowledge to identify a proper warrant or subpoena and training these employees would require major undertaking. SHRM believes that employees "will also be put in a position of having to make impulsive judgments to decide whether ICE access is specifically allowed by federal law, and could face consequences under federal or state law if they are wrong.” SHRM argues that, “If ICE officers overstep the bounds of federal law, ICE officers should be held accountable. It is unfair to hold any employee liable for the missteps of a federal agency. “
SHRM also argues that requiring an employer to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employer’s worksite "would require employers to provide notice to all employees whose I-9s are on file at the location where the inspection occurs, with written notice that the inspection will occur. This could be the entire workforce for the company, as well as those who have left the company in the last year. Along the same lines, SHRM argues that the bill’s requirement for the employer to notify the Labor Commissioner before conducting a self-audit is overly burdensome. SHRM believes the bill as currently drafted requires an employer to notify the state every time they re-verify an employee who needs to be re-verified for a legitimate reason.
The California Chamber of Commerce, writing on behalf of several business groups, opposes for many of the same reasons cited by CMTA and SHRM. The Chamber generally contends that the bill "places the employer in a no-win situation between federal immigration enforcement and state enforcement by punishing employers – rather than providing tools and resources for employees when federal immigration enforcement appears at their workplace regardless of whether a violation of law has been committed by the employer." The Chamber adds: “While the intent of the bill is to protect the rights of workers, the bill instead places employers who are not violating worker rights in serious legal jeopardy. The bill does not differentiate between good and bad employers; instead, it assumes the employer has committed violations by opening the door to an inspection by the Labor Commissioner where no just cause is present."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO (co-sponsor)
SEIU California (co-sponsor)
Asian American Advancing Justice-California
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
State Building and Construction Trades Council
United Farm Workers
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Worksafe
Opposition
Agricultural Council of California
Associated General Contractors of California
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bean Shippers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Retailers Association
California Seed Association
California Warehouse Association
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
National Federation of Independent Businesses
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Society for Human Resource Management
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Tony Thurmond, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 450 (
Author:Chiu) – As Amended Ver:March 23, 2017
SUBJECT: Employment regulation: immigration worksite enforcement actions
SUMMARY: Imposes various requirements on public and private employers with regard to federal immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement actions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer, except as otherwise provided by federal law, from providing a federal immigration enforcement agent access to a place of labor without a properly executed warrant
- Prohibits an employer, or a person acting on behalf of the employer, from providing voluntary access to a federal government immigration enforcement agent to the employer’s employee records without a subpoena.
- Requires an employer to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employer’s worksite, unless prohibited by federal law. That notice must be in the language the employer normally uses to communicate employment information and contain:
- The name of the federal immigration agency conducting the immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The date that the employer received notice of the worksite enforcement action.
- The nature of the worksite enforcement action to the extent known.
- A copy of the notice of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection of I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification forms or other employment records, worksite investigations, worksite interviews of employees, worksite raids, or any other immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner (LC) deems material and necessary.
- Requires an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action, as specified. The notice shall contain the following information:
- A description of any and all deficiencies or other items identified in the written federal immigration audit or immigration worksite enforcement action results notice.
- The time period for correcting any potential deficiencies identified by the federal immigration worksite enforcement action.
- The time and date of any meeting with the employer to correct any identified deficiencies.
- Notice that the employee has the right to representation during any meeting scheduled with the employer.
- Any other information that the Labor Commissioner deems material and necessary.
- Requires an employer to notify the LC of a federal government immigration agency immigration worksite enforcement action within 24 hours of receiving notice of the action and, if the employer does not receive advance notice, to immediately notify the Labor Commission upon learning of the action, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Authorizes the LC, among other things, to provide the following information to employees affected by the action:
- An employee has the right to remain silent.
- An employee has the right to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.
- An employee has the right to speak to his or her foreign consulate.
- Requires an employer to notify the LC before conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms, and before checking the employee work authorization documents of a current employee, unless prohibited by federal law.
- Prohibits an employer from checking the employment eligibility of a current employee, including conducting a self-audit or inspection of specified employment eligibility verification forms at a time or in a manner not required by specified federal law.
- Requires the LC, upon a determination that an employee complainant or employee witness is necessary to conduct an investigation or prosecution to issue a certification to the employee stating that he or she has submitted a valid complaint and is cooperating in the investigation and prosecution.
- Prescribes penalties against employers for failure to satisfy requirements and prohibitions of not less than $10,000, and not more than $25,000, for each violation, to be recoverable by the LC.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits an employer or other person or entity from engaging in, or to directing another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against a person for exercising specified rights. Existing law defines unfair immigration-related practices for these purposes.
- Grants the Labor Commissioner access to places of labor and authorizes the commissioner to conduct investigations and prosecute actions in relation to the prescribed duties of the office.
FISCAL EFFECT: unknown
COMMENTS:
According to the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), undocumented immigrants are not directly identified in any representative national or state surveys. But the best estimates suggest that in 2014, the year of the most recent data available, California was home to between 2.35 million and 2.6 million undocumented immigrants. According to 2014 data from the Pew Research Center, 1.7 million undocumented immigrants were working in California, which represented 9% of all workers in the state in 2014. According to PPIC, undocumented workers make up 45 percent of California’s agricultural workforce and hold 21 percent of construction jobs.
Recent executive actions from the new federal administration have signaled that all immigrants here without permission are now enforcement priorities for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Nationwide, there are reports of ICE agents descending on worksites for mass round-ups of immigrants. Additionally, the Trump administration has called for hiring 10,000 more ICE agents to expedite deportations.
In congressional testimony submitted to the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration Policy and Enforcement in 2011, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) asserted that immigration raids drive down workplace conditions for all workers and undermine labor enforcement. In that testimony the ACLU argued:
- U.S. workers often lose their jobs in the wake of immigration raids.
- Immigration worksite raids have a chilling effect on the ability of undocumented workers to report workplace violation and/or exercise their workplace rights.
- In recent years, Immigrations and Customs Enforcement has conducted numerous immigration raids without coordinating, consulting with, or even informing state and federal labor agencies, including when ICE knew of ongoing labor disputes and workplace violations. By taking such unilateral action, ICE’s worksite raids significantly undermine and frustrate the efforts of state and federal labor enforcement agencies to improve working conditions, including the very conditions that perpetuate the hiring of unauthorized workers.
- Immigration raids erect barriers to employer accountability and workers’ access to justice. By arresting and placing workers in removal proceedings prior to conclusion of any criminal or civil investigation of an employer, ICE raids can result in deportation of victims and witnesses before they are able to testify.
The ACLU concluded that ICE raids, “interfere with workers’ exercise of labor rights and frustrate government efforts to curb abusive employers. Unscrupulous employers are motivated by raids to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the employers’ credible threats of being able to summon immigration enforcement prevent workers from complaining. State and federal labor agencies working to enforce labor and employment laws are stymied by ICE taking actions, often unconstitutionally, that damage their investigations and hamper the creation of a climate in which workers can trust they have a safe outlet to report wage, hour, and safety violations.
In testimony before a 2013 Assembly Labor and Employment Committee special hearing on protecting immigrant workers from retaliation, the National Employment Law Project asserted that immigrant workers are at significant risk of retaliation when asserting their rights. NELP testified about an employer in Garden Grove, who after refusing to pay a day laborer his day’s pay, filed a false police report of robbery against the laborer, leading to the laborer’s arrest and deportation proceedings in 2012. NELP also testified that after the LC found in 2013 that an employer in San Jose owed an immigrant worker over $50,000 for unpaid wages, the employer visited the worker’s home multiple times, harassed him, and threated to call ICE. NELP also testified that increases in worksite immigration enforcement and I-9 audits encourage employers to “self-audit” during labor disputes. Where workers are engaged in union organizing or enforcement of labor or health and safety protections, employers may suddenly claim that they must re-verify employees’ I-9 forms, even when not required under federal or state law.
Arguments in Support
The author argues “Immigration worksite raids present a number of problems. They decrease the likelihood of undocumented workers reporting labor violations or exercising workplace rights. Further, when ICE acts on information provided by unscrupulous employers seeking to intimidate workers, the government becomes complicit in the infringement of workers’ labor rights.
The promise of increased worksite raids also creates the fear that employers may take misguided steps, outside of what is required under federal or state law, which could violate workers’ due process rights, labor rights, or their privacy rights. For example, employers unnecessarily allowing access to a worksite could cause all workers, citizen and undocumented, to be detained in harsh conditions at a worksite or could lead to the exposure of confidential personal information held by the employer.
Past experience with worksite raids demonstrates the likelihood of raids violating employee due process. ICE has routinely violated basic constitutional rights, such as the 4th amendment's protections against unreasonable search and seizure. ICE has detained all workers, without any individualized suspicion, regardless of status when conducting workplace raids. For example, in prior worksite raids, ICE has used individual arrest warrants and administrative warrants to question and detain every single worker - including U.S. citizens & lawfully present workers - in a workplace without individualized suspicion.
In California, workers have reported employers threatening to call immigration authorities when workers attempt to exercise their rights to minimum wages, meal breaks, or organizing activity that are protected by California law regardless of status.”
Co-Sponsors of the bill, the California Labor Federation and SEIU California argue, “Millions of union members are immigrants and worksite immigration raids undermine workers’ rights in significant ways: they drive down wages and labor conditions for all workers, regardless of immigration status; they interfere with workers’ ability freely to exercise their workplace rights; they incentivize employers to employ undocumented workers in substandard conditions because the threat of immigration enforcement prevents workers from complaining; they undermine the efforts of the state to enforce labor and employment laws.”
The California Immigrant Policy Center asserts, “Recent executive actions by the federal Government have confirmed that all undocumented immigrants are enforcement priorities. California has already seen a jump in immigration enforcement action that have torn apart families and terrorized local communities. It is widely anticipated that worksite raids will increase as part of the deportation activities prioritized by the federal government. Immigrants are the backbone of so many California industries and widespread worksite raids will be disruptive and cause confusion and potential chaos. Guidelines for employers and clear protections for employees is critical to reduce the harm of worksite enforcement activities.”
Worksafe, argues that “California will be greatly impacted by a policy shift toward workplace raids. Over 2.6 million undocumented immigrants reside in California. Undocumented workers make up 45 percent of California’s agricultural workforce and 21 percent of construction. In fact, almost 1 in every 10 workers in California is undocumented.” Worksafe continues, “The State has an obligation to ensure that any worksite enforcement is conducted hand-in-hand with labor enforcement and worker protections. California should adopt policies that promote, rather than suppress, workers’ ability to exercise their workplace rights without fear of reprisal. Employers should have clear rules about how to respond to worksite raids. Additionally, the Labor Commissioner must have the necessary tools to protect workers’ rights in the face of increased federal enforcement.”
Asian Americans Advancing Justice argue, “the promise of increased worksite raids also creates the fear that employers may take misguided steps, outside of what is required under federal or state law, which could violate workers; due process rights, labor rights, or their privacy rights. For example employers unnecessarily allowing access to a worksite could cause all workers, regardless of documentation status, to be detained in harsh conditions at a worksite.”
Arguments in Opposition
The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) writes, “ From the human resource professional’s perspective, AB 450, while well intentioned, will add a host of unnecessary burdensome requirements, create many logistical challenges, and could possibly force human resource professionals to decide between abiding by federal law or state law.
SHRM’s argues that compliance with the provision in the bill would require multiple employees at the employers’ place of work to fully understand federal law regarding ICE agents’ access. SHRM asserts that most employees do not have the detailed knowledge of federal law that would be required to comply with this law and training these employees would require major resource expenditures from employers. SHRM believes, “Employees will also be put in a position of having to make impulsive judgments to decide whether ICE access is specifically allowed by federal law, and could face consequences under federal or state law if they are wrong.” SHRM argues that, “If ICE officers overstep the bounds of federal law, ICE officers should be held accountable. It is unfair to hold any employee liable for the missteps of a federal agency. “
SHRM also argues that requiring an employer to provide an employee, and the employee’s representative, a written notice of an immigration worksite enforcement action to be conducted by a federal immigration agency at the employer’s worksite, unless prohibited by federal law is overly burdensome. SHRM argues that, “This provision would require employers to provide notice to all employees whose I-9s are on file at the location where the inspection occurs, with written notice that the inspection will occur. This could be the entire workforce for the company, as well as those who have left the company in the last year. Federal law requires the retention of I-9s for three years after hire or one year after termination of employment, whichever is later. Getting notice out in a 3-day window would be an administrative challenge requiring significant resources, particularly for large employers who have thousands in their workforce.”
Similarly, SHRM argues that requiring an employer to provide to an affected employee, and to the employee’s representative, a copy of the written federal immigration agency notice describing the results of an immigration worksite enforcement audit or inspection, and written notice of the obligations of the employer and the affected employee arising from the action would be administratively burdensome, as it does not exclude notice to employees that their I-9’s were inspected and that they were found to be eligible to work in the United States.
SHRM also argues that the bill’s requirement for the employer to notify the LC before conducting a self-audit is overly burdensome. SHRM believes the bill as currently drafted requires an employer to notify the state every time they re-verify an employee who needs to be re-verified for a legitimate reason, such as an H-1B visa holder who receives an extension. Additionally, SHRM asserts, there is a distinction to be made between an audit of forms to ensure they are filled out correctly in compliance with federal law, and situations where employers actually go back and look at documents again or ask employees for new documentation – practices that are already prohibited by law.
The California Chamber of Commerce and others write, “While the intent of the bill is to protect the rights of workers, the bill instead places employers who are not violating worker rights in serious legal jeopardy. The bill does not differentiate between good and bad employers; instead, it assumes the employer has committed violations by opening the door to an inspection by the Labor Commissioner where no just cause is present.
The Chamber and others further assert that an employer, who is in full compliance with federal immigration laws and chooses to minimize disruption of business operations by federal officials, will be penalized for choosing to cooperate with federal enforcement officials instead of exercising their right to a warrant from federal authorities.
Previous and Related Legislation
AB 291 (Chiu), 2017, would establish stronger legal protections for tenants against landlords who may disclose, or threaten to disclose, a tenant’s immigration status to federal authorities as part of a pattern of harassment and retaliation.
SB 54 (De Leon), 2017, would create the California Values Act that would bar state or local resources from being used for immigration enforcement and prohibit state or local law enforcement agencies from detaining or transferring anyone for deportation without a judicial warrant.
AB 622 (Hernandez), Chapter 696, Statutes of 2015, expanded the definition of an unlawful employment practice under current law to prohibit an employer or any other person or entity from using the E-Verify system at a time or in a manner not required by a specified federal law or not authorized by a federal agency memorandum of understanding to check the employment authorization status of an existing employee or an applicant who has not received an offer of employment, except as required by federal law or as a condition of receiving federal funds. The bill also requires an employer that uses the E-Verify system to provide to the affected employee any notification issued by the Social Security Administration or the United States Department of Homeland Security containing information specific to the employee’s E-Verify case or any tentative nonconfirmation notice. Finally, the law provided for a civil penalty of $10,000 for an employer for each violation of these provisions.
AB 1236 (Fong), Chapter 691, Statutes of 2011, created the Employment Acceleration Act of 2011 to enact provisions of law related to the use by employers of specified federal electronic employment verification systems. Specifically, this law: (1) except as required by federal law or as a condition of receiving federal funds, prohibits the state, a city, county, city and county, or special district from requiring an employer to use an electronic employment verification system, including under the following circumstances: (a) as a condition of receiving a government contract; (b) as a condition of applying for or maintaining a business license; and, (c) as a penalty for violating licensing or other similar laws, (2) defines an “electronic employment verification system” as a system that allows employers to electronically verify workers’ employment authorization with the federal government, including the Basic Pilot (renamed in 2007 as E-Verify) Program. However, this term does not include the I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification form or any other employment verification systems that are required by federal law, and (3) makes several findings and declarations pertaining to the deficiencies of electronic employment verification programs.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Asian American Advancing Justice-California
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO (co-sponsor)
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
SEIU California (co-sponsor)
State Building and Construction Trades Council
United Farm Workers
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Worksafe
Oppose Unless Amended
Construction Employers' Association
Oppose
Agricultural Council of California
Associated General Contractors of California
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bean Shippers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Retailers Association
California Seed Association
California Warehouse Association
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
National Federation of Independent Businesses
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Society for Human Resource Management
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Richard / L. & E. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):