AB 730: Transit districts: prohibition orders.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-07-10
Existing law prohibits certain acts by a person with respect to the property, facilities, or vehicles of a transit district. A violation is generally an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $75 on a first offense, or on a subsequent offense by a fine not exceeding $250 or by community service.
Existing law authorizes the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, and, until January 1, 2018, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District to issue a prohibition order to any person cited for committing one or more of certain prohibited acts in specified transit facilities. Existing law prohibits a person subject to the prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for specified periods of time. Existing law establishes notice requirements in that regard and provides for initial and administrative review of the order.
This bill would permanently apply these provisions to the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
Existing law prohibits certain acts by a person with respect to the property, facilities, or vehicles of a transit district. A violation is generally an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $75 on a first offense, or on a subsequent offense by a fine not exceeding $250 or by community service.
Existing law authorizes the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, and, until January 1, 2018, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District to issue a prohibition order to any person cited for committing one or more of certain prohibited acts in specified transit facilities. Existing law prohibits a person subject to the prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for specified periods of time. Existing law establishes notice requirements in that regard and provides for initial and administrative review of the order.
This bill would permanently apply these provisions to the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
Existing law prohibits certain acts by a person with respect to the property, facilities, or vehicles of a transit district. A violation is generally an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $75 on a first offense, or on a subsequent offense by a fine not exceeding $250 or by community service.
Existing law authorizes the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, and, until January 1, 2018, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District to issue a prohibition order to any person cited for committing one or more of certain prohibited acts in specified transit facilities. Existing law prohibits a person subject to the prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for specified periods of time. Existing law establishes notice requirements in that regard and provides for initial and administrative review of the order.
This bill would permanently apply these provisions to the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
(a)(1)A transit district may issue a prohibition order to any person to whom either of the following applies:
(A)On at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, the person is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or train or light rail station of the transit district for any act that is a violation of paragraph (2) or (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 99170 of this code or paragraph (1), (2), (3), or (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 640 or Section 640.5 of the Penal Code.
(B)The person is arrested or convicted for a misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance.
(C)The person is convicted of a violation of Section 11532 of the Health and Safety Code or Section 653.22 of the Penal Code.
(2)A person subject to a prohibition order may not enter the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of a prohibition order shall not exceed the following, as applicable:
(A)Thirty days if issued pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), provided that a second prohibition order within one year may not exceed 90 days, and a third or subsequent prohibition order within one year may not exceed 180 days.
(B)Thirty days if issued pursuant to an arrest pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1). Upon conviction of a misdemeanor offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed 180 days. Upon conviction of a felony offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed one year.
(3)No prohibition order issued under this subdivision shall be effective unless the transit district first affords the person an opportunity to contest the transit districts proposed action in accordance with procedures adopted by the transit district for this purpose. A transit districts procedures shall provide, at a minimum, for the notice and other protections set forth in subdivisions (b) and (c), and the transit district shall provide reasonable notification to the public of the availability of those procedures.
(b)(1)A notice of a prohibition order issued under subdivision (a) shall set forth a description of the conduct underlying the violation or violations giving rise to the prohibition order, including reference to the applicable statutory provision, ordinance, or transit district rule violated, the date of the violation, the approximate time of the violation, the location where the violation occurred, the period of the proposed prohibition, and the scope of the prohibition. The notice shall include a clear and conspicuous statement indicating the procedure for contesting the prohibition order. The notice of prohibition order shall be personally served upon the violator. The notice of prohibition order, or a copy, shall be considered a record kept in the ordinary course of business of the transit district and shall be prima facie evidence of the facts contained in the notice establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence. For purposes of this paragraph, clear and conspicuous means in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols or other marks that call attention to the language.
(2)For purposes of this section, personal service means any of the following:
(A)In-person delivery.
(B)Delivery by any form of mail providing for delivery confirmation, postage prepaid, to at least one address provided by the person being served, including, but not limited to, the address set forth in any citation or in court records.
(C)Any alternate method approved in writing by the transit district and the person being served.
(3)If a person served with a notice of prohibition order is not able, or refuses, to provide a mailing address, the notice of prohibition order shall set forth the procedure for obtaining any letters, notices, or orders related to the prohibition order from the administrative offices of the transit district. For purposes of this section, delivery shall be deemed to have been made on the following date, as applicable:
(A)On the date of delivery, if delivered in person.
(B)On the date of confirmed delivery, for any delivery by mail.
(C)For any alternate method of service, as provided in the writing specifying the alternate method.
(4)Proof of service of the notice shall be filed with the transit district.
(5)If a person contests a notice of prohibition order, the transit district shall proceed in accordance with subdivision (c). If the notice of prohibition order is not contested within 10 calendar days after delivery by personal service, the prohibition order shall be deemed final and shall go into effect, without further action by the transit district, for the period of time set forth in the order.
(6)All prohibition orders shall be subject to an automatic stay and shall not take effect until the latest of the following:
(A)Eleven calendar days after delivery of the prohibition order by personal service.
(B)If an initial review is timely requested under paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), 11 calendar days after delivery by personal service of the results of the review.
(C)If an administrative hearing is timely requested under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c), the date the hearing officers decision is delivered by personal service.
(c)(1)For a period of 10 calendar days from the delivery of the prohibition order by personal service, the person may request an initial review of the prohibition order by the transit district. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. There shall be no charge for this review. In conducting its review and reaching a determination, the transit district shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order is not adequately supported or that extenuating circumstances make dismissal of the prohibition order appropriate in the interest of justice, the transit district shall cancel the notice. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order should be upheld in whole or in part, the transit district shall issue a written statement to that effect, including any modification to the period or scope of the prohibition order. The transit district shall serve the results of the initial review to the person contesting the notice by personal service.
(2)The transit district may modify or cancel a prohibition order in the interest of justice. The transit district shall cancel a prohibition order if it determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(3)If the person is dissatisfied with the results of the initial review, the person may request an administrative hearing of the prohibition order no later than 10 calendar days after the results of the initial review are delivered by personal service. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. An administrative hearing shall be held within 30 calendar days after the receipt of a request for an administrative hearing. The person requesting the hearing may request one continuance, not to exceed seven calendar days.
(4)The administrative hearing process shall include all of the following:
(A)The person requesting the hearing shall have the choice of a hearing by mail or in person. An in-person hearing shall be conducted within the jurisdiction of the transit district.
(B)The administrative hearing shall be conducted in accordance with written procedures established by the transit district and approved by the governing body or chief executive officer of the transit district. The hearing shall provide an independent, objective, fair, and impartial review of the prohibition order.
(C)The administrative review shall be conducted before a hearing officer designated to conduct the review by the transit districts governing body or chief executive officer. In addition to any other requirements, a hearing officer shall demonstrate the qualifications, training, and objectivity prescribed by the transit agencys governing body or chief executive officer as are necessary to fulfill and that are consistent with the duties and responsibilities set forth in this subdivision. The hearing officers continued service, performance evaluation, compensation, and benefits, as applicable, shall not be directly or indirectly linked to the number of prohibition orders upheld by the hearing officer.
(D)The person who issued the notice of prohibition order shall not be required to participate in an administrative hearing, unless participation is requested by the person requesting the hearing. The request for participation must be made at least five calendar days prior to the date of the hearing and may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. The notice of prohibition order, in proper form, shall be prima facie evidence of the violation or violations pursuant to subdivision (a) establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence.
(E)In issuing a decision, the hearing officer shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. Based upon these findings, the hearing officer may uphold the prohibition order in whole, determine that the prohibition order is not adequately supported, or cancel or modify the prohibition order in the interest of justice. The hearing officer shall cancel a prohibition order if he or she determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(F)The hearing officers decision following the administrative hearing shall be delivered by personal service.
(G)A person aggrieved by the final decision of the hearing officer may seek judicial review of the decision within 90 days of the date of delivery of the decision by personal service, as provided by Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(d)A person issued a prohibition order under subdivision (a) may, within 10 calendar days of the date the order goes into effect under paragraph (6) of subdivision (b), request a refund for any prepaid fare media rendered unusable in whole or in part by the prohibition order, including, but not limited to, monthly passes. If the fare media remain usable for one or more days outside the period of the prohibition order, the refund shall be prorated based on the number of days the fare media will be unusable. The issuance of a refund may be made contingent on surrender of the fare media.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
SEC. 2.Section 99172 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:99172.(a)Prior to exercising the authority given in subdivision (a) of Section 99171 to issue prohibition orders, a transit district shall do all of the following:
(1)Establish an advisory committee for the purpose of evaluating the procedures for and issuance of prohibition orders and recommending a course of training for personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders.
(2)Ensure that personnel to be charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders have received training as recommended by the advisory committee.
(3)Provide reasonable notification to transit district riders that persons who engage in disorderly conduct may be subject to a prohibition order barring the person from the transit districts property, facilities, or vehicles for a period of up to one year. Reasonable notification may include, but is not limited to, information on the transit districts Internet Web site, in written materials, at transit stations, and on citations issued by the transit district of the types of conduct that may result in issuance of a prohibition order.
(b)The advisory committee shall be composed of at least five members appointed by the legislative body of the transit district. At least one of the members of the advisory committee shall have experience working with individuals with psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities, at least one member shall be a youth advocate, and at least one member shall have law enforcement experience.
(c)The advisory committee shall be tasked, at a minimum, with all of the following:
(1)Providing recommendations, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, regarding the type and extent of training that should be undertaken by individuals with responsibility for issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders, with particular emphasis on training designed to assist those individuals in identifying and interacting with persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities.
(2)Identifying, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, services and programs to which persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities may be referred by transit district enforcement personnel prior to or in conjunction with issuance of a prohibition order.
(3)Monitoring the issuance of prohibition orders to assist the transit district in ensuring compliance with Section 51 of the Civil Code.
(4)Providing the governing board of the transit district and the Legislature with an annual report summarizing the number of prohibition orders that were issued by the transit district during the preceding year, including, but not limited to, the types and numbers of citations by category, and the number of exclusion orders appealed, the appeals granted, the reasons granted, and other relevant information directly related to those orders.
(d)The transit district may use an existing advisory committee to fulfill the requirements of this section, provided that the composition and purpose of the existing advisory committee meet or are modified to meet the requirements of this section.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
(a)(1)A transit district may issue a prohibition order to any person to whom either of the following applies:
(A)On at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, the person is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or train or light rail station of the transit district for any act that is a violation of paragraph (2) or (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 99170 of this code or paragraph (1), (2), (3), or (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 640 or Section 640.5 of the Penal Code.
(B)The person is arrested or convicted for a misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance.
(C)The person is convicted of a violation of Section 11532 of the Health and Safety Code or Section 653.22 of the Penal Code.
(2)A person subject to a prohibition order may not enter the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of a prohibition order shall not exceed the following, as applicable:
(A)Thirty days if issued pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), provided that a second prohibition order within one year may not exceed 90 days, and a third or subsequent prohibition order within one year may not exceed 180 days.
(B)Thirty days if issued pursuant to an arrest pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1). Upon conviction of a misdemeanor offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed 180 days. Upon conviction of a felony offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed one year.
(3)No prohibition order issued under this subdivision shall be effective unless the transit district first affords the person an opportunity to contest the transit districts proposed action in accordance with procedures adopted by the transit district for this purpose. A transit districts procedures shall provide, at a minimum, for the notice and other protections set forth in subdivisions (b) and (c), and the transit district shall provide reasonable notification to the public of the availability of those procedures.
(b)(1)A notice of a prohibition order issued under subdivision (a) shall set forth a description of the conduct underlying the violation or violations giving rise to the prohibition order, including reference to the applicable statutory provision, ordinance, or transit district rule violated, the date of the violation, the approximate time of the violation, the location where the violation occurred, the period of the proposed prohibition, and the scope of the prohibition. The notice shall include a clear and conspicuous statement indicating the procedure for contesting the prohibition order. The notice of prohibition order shall be personally served upon the violator. The notice of prohibition order, or a copy, shall be considered a record kept in the ordinary course of business of the transit district and shall be prima facie evidence of the facts contained in the notice establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence. For purposes of this paragraph, clear and conspicuous means in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols or other marks that call attention to the language.
(2)For purposes of this section, personal service means any of the following:
(A)In-person delivery.
(B)Delivery by any form of mail providing for delivery confirmation, postage prepaid, to at least one address provided by the person being served, including, but not limited to, the address set forth in any citation or in court records.
(C)Any alternate method approved in writing by the transit district and the person being served.
(3)If a person served with a notice of prohibition order is not able, or refuses, to provide a mailing address, the notice of prohibition order shall set forth the procedure for obtaining any letters, notices, or orders related to the prohibition order from the administrative offices of the transit district. For purposes of this section, delivery shall be deemed to have been made on the following date, as applicable:
(A)On the date of delivery, if delivered in person.
(B)On the date of confirmed delivery, for any delivery by mail.
(C)For any alternate method of service, as provided in the writing specifying the alternate method.
(4)Proof of service of the notice shall be filed with the transit district.
(5)If a person contests a notice of prohibition order, the transit district shall proceed in accordance with subdivision (c). If the notice of prohibition order is not contested within 10 calendar days after delivery by personal service, the prohibition order shall be deemed final and shall go into effect, without further action by the transit district, for the period of time set forth in the order.
(6)All prohibition orders shall be subject to an automatic stay and shall not take effect until the latest of the following:
(A)Eleven calendar days after delivery of the prohibition order by personal service.
(B)If an initial review is timely requested under paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), 11 calendar days after delivery by personal service of the results of the review.
(C)If an administrative hearing is timely requested under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c), the date the hearing officers decision is delivered by personal service.
(c)(1)For a period of 10 calendar days from the delivery of the prohibition order by personal service, the person may request an initial review of the prohibition order by the transit district. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. There shall be no charge for this review. In conducting its review and reaching a determination, the transit district shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order is not adequately supported or that extenuating circumstances make dismissal of the prohibition order appropriate in the interest of justice, the transit district shall cancel the notice. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order should be upheld in whole or in part, the transit district shall issue a written statement to that effect, including any modification to the period or scope of the prohibition order. The transit district shall serve the results of the initial review to the person contesting the notice by personal service.
(2)The transit district may modify or cancel a prohibition order in the interest of justice. The transit district shall cancel a prohibition order if it determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(3)If the person is dissatisfied with the results of the initial review, the person may request an administrative hearing of the prohibition order no later than 10 calendar days after the results of the initial review are delivered by personal service. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. An administrative hearing shall be held within 30 calendar days after the receipt of a request for an administrative hearing. The person requesting the hearing may request one continuance, not to exceed seven calendar days.
(4)The administrative hearing process shall include all of the following:
(A)The person requesting the hearing shall have the choice of a hearing by mail or in person. An in-person hearing shall be conducted within the jurisdiction of the transit district.
(B)The administrative hearing shall be conducted in accordance with written procedures established by the transit district and approved by the governing body or chief executive officer of the transit district. The hearing shall provide an independent, objective, fair, and impartial review of the prohibition order.
(C)The administrative review shall be conducted before a hearing officer designated to conduct the review by the transit districts governing body or chief executive officer. In addition to any other requirements, a hearing officer shall demonstrate the qualifications, training, and objectivity prescribed by the transit agencys governing body or chief executive officer as are necessary to fulfill and that are consistent with the duties and responsibilities set forth in this subdivision. The hearing officers continued service, performance evaluation, compensation, and benefits, as applicable, shall not be directly or indirectly linked to the number of prohibition orders upheld by the hearing officer.
(D)The person who issued the notice of prohibition order shall not be required to participate in an administrative hearing, unless participation is requested by the person requesting the hearing. The request for participation must be made at least five calendar days prior to the date of the hearing and may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. The notice of prohibition order, in proper form, shall be prima facie evidence of the violation or violations pursuant to subdivision (a) establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence.
(E)In issuing a decision, the hearing officer shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. Based upon these findings, the hearing officer may uphold the prohibition order in whole, determine that the prohibition order is not adequately supported, or cancel or modify the prohibition order in the interest of justice. The hearing officer shall cancel a prohibition order if he or she determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(F)The hearing officers decision following the administrative hearing shall be delivered by personal service.
(G)A person aggrieved by the final decision of the hearing officer may seek judicial review of the decision within 90 days of the date of delivery of the decision by personal service, as provided by Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(d)A person issued a prohibition order under subdivision (a) may, within 10 calendar days of the date the order goes into effect under paragraph (6) of subdivision (b), request a refund for any prepaid fare media rendered unusable in whole or in part by the prohibition order, including, but not limited to, monthly passes. If the fare media remain usable for one or more days outside the period of the prohibition order, the refund shall be prorated based on the number of days the fare media will be unusable. The issuance of a refund may be made contingent on surrender of the fare media.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
SEC. 2.Section 99172 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:99172.(a)Prior to exercising the authority given in subdivision (a) of Section 99171 to issue prohibition orders, a transit district shall do all of the following:
(1)Establish an advisory committee for the purpose of evaluating the procedures for and issuance of prohibition orders and recommending a course of training for personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders.
(2)Ensure that personnel to be charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders have received training as recommended by the advisory committee.
(3)Provide reasonable notification to transit district riders that persons who engage in disorderly conduct may be subject to a prohibition order barring the person from the transit districts property, facilities, or vehicles for a period of up to one year. Reasonable notification may include, but is not limited to, information on the transit districts Internet Web site, in written materials, at transit stations, and on citations issued by the transit district of the types of conduct that may result in issuance of a prohibition order.
(b)The advisory committee shall be composed of at least five members appointed by the legislative body of the transit district. At least one of the members of the advisory committee shall have experience working with individuals with psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities, at least one member shall be a youth advocate, and at least one member shall have law enforcement experience.
(c)The advisory committee shall be tasked, at a minimum, with all of the following:
(1)Providing recommendations, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, regarding the type and extent of training that should be undertaken by individuals with responsibility for issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders, with particular emphasis on training designed to assist those individuals in identifying and interacting with persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities.
(2)Identifying, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, services and programs to which persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities may be referred by transit district enforcement personnel prior to or in conjunction with issuance of a prohibition order.
(3)Monitoring the issuance of prohibition orders to assist the transit district in ensuring compliance with Section 51 of the Civil Code.
(4)Providing the governing board of the transit district and the Legislature with an annual report summarizing the number of prohibition orders that were issued by the transit district during the preceding year, including, but not limited to, the types and numbers of citations by category, and the number of exclusion orders appealed, the appeals granted, the reasons granted, and other relevant information directly related to those orders.
(d)The transit district may use an existing advisory committee to fulfill the requirements of this section, provided that the composition and purpose of the existing advisory committee meet or are modified to meet the requirements of this section.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District, the Fresno Area Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
(a)(1)A transit district may issue a prohibition order to any person to whom either of the following applies:
(A)On at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, the person is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or train or light rail station of the transit district for any act that is a violation of paragraph (2) or (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 99170 of this code or paragraph (1), (2), (3), or (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 640 or Section 640.5 of the Penal Code.
(B)The person is arrested or convicted for a misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance.
(C)The person is convicted of a violation of Section 11532 of the Health and Safety Code or Section 653.22 of the Penal Code.
(2)A person subject to a prohibition order may not enter the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of a prohibition order shall not exceed the following, as applicable:
(A)Thirty days if issued pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), provided that a second prohibition order within one year may not exceed 90 days, and a third or subsequent prohibition order within one year may not exceed 180 days.
(B)Thirty days if issued pursuant to an arrest pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1). Upon conviction of a misdemeanor offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed 180 days. Upon conviction of a felony offense, the duration of the prohibition order for the conviction, when added to the duration of the prohibition order for the initial arrest, if any, may not exceed one year.
(3)No prohibition order issued under this subdivision shall be effective unless the transit district first affords the person an opportunity to contest the transit districts proposed action in accordance with procedures adopted by the transit district for this purpose. A transit districts procedures shall provide, at a minimum, for the notice and other protections set forth in subdivisions (b) and (c), and the transit district shall provide reasonable notification to the public of the availability of those procedures.
(b)(1)A notice of a prohibition order issued under subdivision (a) shall set forth a description of the conduct underlying the violation or violations giving rise to the prohibition order, including reference to the applicable statutory provision, ordinance, or transit district rule violated, the date of the violation, the approximate time of the violation, the location where the violation occurred, the period of the proposed prohibition, and the scope of the prohibition. The notice shall include a clear and conspicuous statement indicating the procedure for contesting the prohibition order. The notice of prohibition order shall be personally served upon the violator. The notice of prohibition order, or a copy, shall be considered a record kept in the ordinary course of business of the transit district and shall be prima facie evidence of the facts contained in the notice establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence. For purposes of this paragraph, clear and conspicuous means in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols or other marks that call attention to the language.
(2)For purposes of this section, personal service means any of the following:
(A)In-person delivery.
(B)Delivery by any form of mail providing for delivery confirmation, postage prepaid, to at least one address provided by the person being served, including, but not limited to, the address set forth in any citation or in court records.
(C)Any alternate method approved in writing by the transit district and the person being served.
(3)If a person served with a notice of prohibition order is not able, or refuses, to provide a mailing address, the notice of prohibition order shall set forth the procedure for obtaining any letters, notices, or orders related to the prohibition order from the administrative offices of the transit district. For purposes of this section, delivery shall be deemed to have been made on the following date, as applicable:
(A)On the date of delivery, if delivered in person.
(B)On the date of confirmed delivery, for any delivery by mail.
(C)For any alternate method of service, as provided in the writing specifying the alternate method.
(4)Proof of service of the notice shall be filed with the transit district.
(5)If a person contests a notice of prohibition order, the transit district shall proceed in accordance with subdivision (c). If the notice of prohibition order is not contested within 10 calendar days after delivery by personal service, the prohibition order shall be deemed final and shall go into effect, without further action by the transit district, for the period of time set forth in the order.
(6)All prohibition orders shall be subject to an automatic stay and shall not take effect until the latest of the following:
(A)Eleven calendar days after delivery of the prohibition order by personal service.
(B)If an initial review is timely requested under paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), 11 calendar days after delivery by personal service of the results of the review.
(C)If an administrative hearing is timely requested under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c), the date the hearing officers decision is delivered by personal service.
(c)(1)For a period of 10 calendar days from the delivery of the prohibition order by personal service, the person may request an initial review of the prohibition order by the transit district. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. There shall be no charge for this review. In conducting its review and reaching a determination, the transit district shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order is not adequately supported or that extenuating circumstances make dismissal of the prohibition order appropriate in the interest of justice, the transit district shall cancel the notice. If, following the initial review, based on these findings, the transit district determines that the prohibition order should be upheld in whole or in part, the transit district shall issue a written statement to that effect, including any modification to the period or scope of the prohibition order. The transit district shall serve the results of the initial review to the person contesting the notice by personal service.
(2)The transit district may modify or cancel a prohibition order in the interest of justice. The transit district shall cancel a prohibition order if it determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(3)If the person is dissatisfied with the results of the initial review, the person may request an administrative hearing of the prohibition order no later than 10 calendar days after the results of the initial review are delivered by personal service. The request may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. An administrative hearing shall be held within 30 calendar days after the receipt of a request for an administrative hearing. The person requesting the hearing may request one continuance, not to exceed seven calendar days.
(4)The administrative hearing process shall include all of the following:
(A)The person requesting the hearing shall have the choice of a hearing by mail or in person. An in-person hearing shall be conducted within the jurisdiction of the transit district.
(B)The administrative hearing shall be conducted in accordance with written procedures established by the transit district and approved by the governing body or chief executive officer of the transit district. The hearing shall provide an independent, objective, fair, and impartial review of the prohibition order.
(C)The administrative review shall be conducted before a hearing officer designated to conduct the review by the transit districts governing body or chief executive officer. In addition to any other requirements, a hearing officer shall demonstrate the qualifications, training, and objectivity prescribed by the transit agencys governing body or chief executive officer as are necessary to fulfill and that are consistent with the duties and responsibilities set forth in this subdivision. The hearing officers continued service, performance evaluation, compensation, and benefits, as applicable, shall not be directly or indirectly linked to the number of prohibition orders upheld by the hearing officer.
(D)The person who issued the notice of prohibition order shall not be required to participate in an administrative hearing, unless participation is requested by the person requesting the hearing. The request for participation must be made at least five calendar days prior to the date of the hearing and may be made by telephone, in writing, or in person. The notice of prohibition order, in proper form, shall be prima facie evidence of the violation or violations pursuant to subdivision (a) establishing a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence.
(E)In issuing a decision, the hearing officer shall determine whether the prohibition order meets the requirements of subdivision (a) and, unless the person has been convicted of the offense or offenses, whether the offense or offenses for which the person was cited or arrested are proven by a preponderance of the evidence. Based upon these findings, the hearing officer may uphold the prohibition order in whole, determine that the prohibition order is not adequately supported, or cancel or modify the prohibition order in the interest of justice. The hearing officer shall cancel a prohibition order if he or she determines that the person did not understand the nature and extent of his or her actions or did not have the ability to control his or her actions. If the person is dependent upon the transit system for trips of necessity, including, but not limited to, travel to or from medical or legal appointments, school or training classes, places of employment, or obtaining food, clothing, and necessary household items, the transit district shall modify a prohibition order to allow for those trips. A person requesting a cancellation or modification in the interest of justice shall have the burden of establishing the qualifying circumstances by a preponderance of the evidence.
(F)The hearing officers decision following the administrative hearing shall be delivered by personal service.
(G)A person aggrieved by the final decision of the hearing officer may seek judicial review of the decision within 90 days of the date of delivery of the decision by personal service, as provided by Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(d)A person issued a prohibition order under subdivision (a) may, within 10 calendar days of the date the order goes into effect under paragraph (6) of subdivision (b), request a refund for any prepaid fare media rendered unusable in whole or in part by the prohibition order, including, but not limited to, monthly passes. If the fare media remain usable for one or more days outside the period of the prohibition order, the refund shall be prorated based on the number of days the fare media will be unusable. The issuance of a refund may be made contingent on surrender of the fare media.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District or District, the Fresno Area Express. Until January 1, 2018, for purposes of this section, transit district also means Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
SEC. 2.Section 99172 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:99172.(a)Prior to exercising the authority given in subdivision (a) of Section 99171 to issue prohibition orders, a transit district shall do all of the following:
(1)Establish an advisory committee for the purpose of evaluating the procedures for and issuance of prohibition orders and recommending a course of training for personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders.
(2)Ensure that personnel to be charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders have received training as recommended by the advisory committee.
(3)Provide reasonable notification to transit district riders that persons who engage in disorderly conduct may be subject to a prohibition order barring the person from the transit districts property, facilities, or vehicles for a period of up to one year. Reasonable notification may include, but is not limited to, information on the transit districts Internet Web site, in written materials, at transit stations, and on citations issued by the transit district of the types of conduct that may result in issuance of a prohibition order.
(b)The advisory committee shall be composed of at least five members appointed by the legislative body of the transit district. At least one of the members of the advisory committee shall have experience working with individuals with psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities, at least one member shall be a youth advocate, and at least one member shall have law enforcement experience.
(c)The advisory committee shall be tasked, at a minimum, with all of the following:
(1)Providing recommendations, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, regarding the type and extent of training that should be undertaken by individuals with responsibility for issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders, with particular emphasis on training designed to assist those individuals in identifying and interacting with persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities.
(2)Identifying, in consultation with the county mental health director within the service area of the transit district, services and programs to which persons who are homeless or who have psychiatric, developmental, or other disabilities may be referred by transit district enforcement personnel prior to or in conjunction with issuance of a prohibition order.
(3)Monitoring the issuance of prohibition orders to assist the transit district in ensuring compliance with Section 51 of the Civil Code.
(4)Providing the governing board of the transit district and the Legislature with an annual report summarizing the number of prohibition orders that were issued by the transit district during the preceding year, including, but not limited to, the types and numbers of citations by category, and the number of exclusion orders appealed, the appeals granted, the reasons granted, and other relevant information directly related to those orders.
(d)The transit district may use an existing advisory committee to fulfill the requirements of this section, provided that the composition and purpose of the existing advisory committee meet or are modified to meet the requirements of this section.
(e)For purposes of this section, transit district means the Sacramento Regional Transit District or District, the Fresno Area Express. Until January 1, 2018, for purposes of this section, transit district also means Express, or the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 46, Statutes of 2017. |
| Jul 10, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jun 26, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Jun 20, 2017 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jun 19, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 33. Noes 0. Page 1612.). |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 13, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (June 13). |
| May 10, 2017 | Referred to Com. on T. & H. |
| Apr 17, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 17, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 1017.) |
| Apr 5, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 4, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 4). |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 19, 2017 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB730 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 13, 2017 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2017 | Favorable (Appropriations Committee) | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 4, 2017 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 730
:
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 13-0, 6/13/17
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Atkins, Bates, Gaines, McGuire, Mendoza, Morrell, Roth, Skinner, Wieckowski, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 4/17/17 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill repeals the sunset that allows the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to issue prohibition orders, as specified.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the Sacramento Regional Transit District and Fresno Area Express to issue prohibition orders as specified below. Furthermore, until January 1, 2018, authorizes BART to similarly issue prohibition orders, as specified.
- Authorizes the abovementioned transit districts to issue a prohibition order to any person who, on at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for any of the following acts:
- Interfering with the operator or operation of a transit vehicle, or impeding the safe boarding or alighting of passengers;
- Committing any act or engaging in any behavior that may, with reasonable foreseeability, cause harm or injury to any person or property;
- Willfully disturbing others on or in a transit facility or vehicle by engaging in boisterous or unruly behavior;
- Carrying an explosive, acid, or flammable liquid in a public transit facility or vehicle;
- Urinating or defecating in a transit facility or vehicle, except in a lavatory;
- Willfully blocking the free movement of another person in a transit facility or vehicle; or,
- Defacing with graffiti the interior or exterior of the facilities or vehicles of a public transportation system.
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person arrested or convicted for any misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district, for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance.
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person convicted of loitering with the intent to commit specified drug offenses or loitering with intent to commit prostitution.
- Prohibits a person subject to a prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of the prohibition order does not exceed the following specified time limits:
- 30 days for a first order, 90 days for a second order within one year, and 180 days for a third order within one year related to infractions; or,
- 30 days if issued pursuant to an arrest for a misdemeanor or felony offense. Upon conviction for the offense, the order may be extended to a total of 180 days for a misdemeanor and one year for a felony.
- Specifies prohibition processes, notification procedures, and hearing and appeal procedures.
- Requires the transit district to establish an advisory committee and to ensure that personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders receive training as emphasized and as recommended by the advisory committee. Tasks the advisory committee with responsibilities, as specified. Authorizes existing advisory committees to be used if appropriate.
This bill repeals the sunset that allows BART to issue prohibition orders, as specified.
Comments
- Purpose. According to the author, “Rider comfort and safety is a priority for BART personnel. In an effort to respond to growing public safety concerns, BART was allowed to enter into a pilot program to issue prohibition orders. These were to be issued as a last result when other efforts to protect the public failed. Safeguards were added to protect against abuse. Over the last three years, data tells us that although the number of prohibitions orders issued fluctuated from year to year, overall reports of violent crime dropped between 2013 and 2016. This reduction in violent crime occurred during a period of steady BART ridership growth. Safety should not be an issue when it comes to public transportation. By permanently granting BART the authority to issue prohibition orders, will continue to provide BART with the tools it needs to make sure all Californians are provided with a safe and comfortable environment when traveling.”
- BART and prohibition orders. AB 716 (Dickinson, Chapter 534, Statutes of 2011) authorized the creation of a three-year pilot program under which BART could issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities. In 2013, BART initiated its AB 716 program, which also required BART to provide the Legislature with annual reports on the program.
The annual report for 2013 indicated that BART issued 146 prohibition orders between May 6, 2013, and December 31, 2013. None of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty-five percent of those orders were related to domestic violence.
For 2014, the annual report indicated that BART issued 281 prohibition orders. Six of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty percent of the prohibition orders issued involved domestic violence cases, a decrease from 2013.
SB 1154 (Hancock, Chapter 559, Statutes of 2014) permitted BART to continue issuing these prohibition orders until January 1, 2018. The bill also clarified that BART Police Officers have the authority to issue emergency protective orders for individuals in a stalking situation within the transit system, and that they have the authority to take custody of weapons while investigating domestic violence situations.
The most recent annual report for 2015 indicated that BART issued 255 prohibition orders. Five of the alleged violators contested the order. The report reflects a reduction in the issuance of prohibition orders in the areas of robbery, batteries/threats involving patrons and threats/batteries involving employees (including officers). Violent crimes committed on the district property declined from 158 in 2014, to 123 in 2015. At the same time, overall ridership increased.
The report reflected that 25 percent of the prohibition orders in 2015 were related to domestic violence, a slight increase from 2014. The report attributes this to stations being used for a child custody exchange location as directed by the courts. The report stated that these meetings sometimes lead to domestic violence. These incidents may decrease with the authority granted to BART police to issue emergency protective orders at stations under SB 1154, along with continued outreach and public awareness efforts.
- Remove sunset? BART, in support of this bill, contends that prohibition orders are one of several effective enforcement tolls to ensure the safety of its passengers. While prohibition orders have assisted in serving as an effective deterrent, criminal activity remains an issue. For example, in November 2016, a BART rider was arrested after sexually assaulting a minor. Additionally, in May 2017, a BART rider was asserted for battering a female BART employee. In both instances, prohibition orders were issued to these individuals. Thus, removal of the sunset provision while maintaining the existing oversight and contesting mechanisms is a reasonable measure to ensure public safety remains a priority for BART.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/14/17)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 4/17/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Brough, Cunningham, Cristina Garcia, Mathis
6/14/17 16:01:18
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 6/13/2017
Author: | Quirk | ||
Version: | 2/15/2017 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Manny Leon | ||
SUBJECT: .
DIGEST: This bill repeals the sunset that allows the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to issue prohibition orders, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing Law:
- Authorizes the Sacramento Regional Transit District and Fresno Area Express to issue prohibition orders as specified below. Furthermore, until January 1, 2018, authorizes BART to similarly issue prohibition orders, as specified.
- Authorizes the abovementioned transit districts to issue a prohibition order to any person who, on at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for any of the following acts:
- Interfering with the operator or operation of a transit vehicle, or impeding the safe boarding or alighting of passengers;
- Committing any act or engaging in any behavior that may, with reasonable foreseeability, cause harm or injury to any person or property;
- Willfully disturbing others on or in a transit facility or vehicle by engaging in boisterous or unruly behavior;
- Carrying an explosive, acid, or flammable liquid in a public transit facility or vehicle;
- Urinating or defecating in a transit facility or vehicle, except in a lavatory;
- Willfully blocking the free movement of another person in a transit facility or vehicle; or,
- Defacing with graffiti the interior or exterior of the facilities or vehicles of a public transportation system.
- Interfering with the operator or operation of a transit vehicle, or impeding the safe boarding or alighting of passengers;
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person arrested or convicted for any misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district, for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance.
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person convicted of loitering with the intent to commit specified drug offenses or loitering with intent to commit prostitution.
- Prohibits a person subject to a prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of the prohibition order does not exceed the following specified time limits:
- 30 days for a first order, 90 days for a second order within one year, and 180 days for a third order within one year related to infractions; or,
- 30 days if issued pursuant to an arrest for a misdemeanor or felony offense. Upon conviction for the offense, the order may be extended to a total of 180 days for a misdemeanor and one year for a felony.
- 30 days for a first order, 90 days for a second order within one year, and 180 days for a third order within one year related to infractions; or,
- Specifies prohibition processes, notification procedures, and hearing and appeal procedures.
- Requires the transit district to establish an advisory committee and to ensure that personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders receive training as emphasized and as recommended by the advisory committee. Tasks the advisory committee with responsibilities, as specified. Authorizes existing advisory committees to be used if appropriate.
This bill repeals the sunset that allows BART to issue prohibition orders, as specified.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, “Rider comfort and safety is a priority for BART personnel. In an effort to respond to growing public safety concerns, BART was allowed to enter into a pilot program to issue prohibition orders. These were to be issued as a last result when other efforts to protect the public failed. Safeguards were added to protect against abuse. Over the last three years, data tells us that although the number of prohibitions orders issued fluctuated from year to year, overall reports of violent crime dropped between 2013 and 2016. This reduction in violent crime occurred during a period of steady BART ridership growth. Safety should not be an issue when it comes to public transportation. By permanently granting BART the authority to issue prohibition orders, will continue to provide BART with the tools it needs to make sure all Californians are provided with a safe and comfortable environment when traveling.”
- BART and prohibition orders. AB 716 (Dickinson) Chapter 534, Statutes of 2011 authorized the creation of a three-year pilot program under which BART could issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities. In 2013, BART initiated its AB 716 program, which also required BART to provide the Legislature with annual reports on the program.
The annual report for 2013 indicated that BART issued 146 prohibition orders between May 6, 2013, and December 31, 2013. None of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty-five percent of those orders were related to domestic violence.
For 2014, the annual report indicated that BART issued 281 prohibition orders. Six of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty percent of the prohibition orders issued involved domestic violence cases, a decrease from 2013.
SB1154 (Hancock) Chapter 559, Statutes of 2014, permitted BART to continue issuing these prohibition orders until January 1, 2018. The bill also clarified that BART Police Officers have the authority to issue emergency protective orders for individuals in a stalking situation within the transit system, and that they have the authority to take custody of weapons while investigating domestic violence situations.
The most recent annual report for 2015 indicated that BART issued 255 prohibition orders. Five of the alleged violators contested the order. The report reflects a reduction in the issuance of prohibition orders in the areas of robbery, batteries/threats involving patrons and threats/batteries involving employees (including officers). Violent crimes committed on the district property declined from 158 in 2014, to 123 in 2015. At the same time, overall ridership increased.
The report reflected that 25 percent of the prohibition orders in 2015 were related to domestic violence, a slight increase from 2014. The report attributes this to stations being used for a child custody exchange location as directed by the courts. The report stated that these meetings sometimes lead to domestic violence. These incidents may decrease with the authority granted to BART police to issue emergency protective orders at stations under SB 1154, along with continued outreach and public awareness efforts.
- Remove Sunset? The sponsors of this bill, BART, contend that prohibition orders are one of several effective enforcement tolls to ensure the safety of its passengers. While prohibition orders have assisted in serving as an effective deterrent, criminal activity remains an issue. For example, in November 2016, a BART rider was arrested after sexually assaulting a minor. Additionally, in May 2017, a BART rider was asserted for battering a female BART employee. In both instances, prohibition orders were issued to these individuals. Thus, removal of the sunset provision while maintaining the existing oversight and contesting mechanisms is a reasonable measure to ensure public safety remains a priority for BART.
Related Legislation:
AB 468 (Santiago, 2017) — adds the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority to the transit districts authorized to issue prohibition orders to passengers committing certain illegal behaviors. This bill is scheduled to be heard by this committee at the June 20th hearing.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 7, 2017.)
SUPPORT:
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART)
OPPOSITION:
None received.
-- END --
Date of Hearing:
Counsel: Cheryl Anderson
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 730
Author:(Quirk) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2017
SUMMARY:
Repeals the sunset on the law that allows San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to issue prohibition orders to passengers committing certain illegal behaviors, making BART’s authority to do so permanent.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes BART to issue a prohibition order to any person who, on at least three separate occasions within a period of 90 consecutive days, is cited for an infraction committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district for any of the following acts:
- Interfering with the operator or operation of a transit vehicle, or impeding the safe boarding or alighting of passengers;
- Committing any act or engaging in any behavior that may, with reasonable foreseeability, cause harm or injury to any person or property;
- Willfully disturbing others on or in a transit facility or vehicle by engaging in boisterous or unruly behavior;
- Carrying an explosive, acid, or flammable liquid in a public transit facility or vehicle;
- Urinating or defecating in a transit facility or vehicle, except in a lavatory;
- Willfully blocking the free movement of another person in a transit facility or vehicle; or,
- Defacing with graffiti the interior or exterior of the facilities or vehicles of a public transportation system. (Pub. Util. Code, § 99171, subd. (a)(1)(A).)
- Interfering with the operator or operation of a transit vehicle, or impeding the safe boarding or alighting of passengers;
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person arrested or convicted for any misdemeanor or felony committed in or on a vehicle, bus stop, or light rail station of the transit district, for acts involving violence, threats of violence, lewd or lascivious behavior, or possession for sale or sale of a controlled substance. (Pub. Util. Code § 99171, subd. (a)(1)(B).)
- Authorizes a prohibition order to be issued to a person convicted of loitering with the intent to commit specified drug offenses or loitering with intent to commit prostitution. (Pub. Util. Code § 99171, subd. (a)(1)(C).)
- Prohibits a person subject to a prohibition order from entering the property, facilities, or vehicles of the transit district for a period of time deemed appropriate by the transit district, provided that the duration of the prohibition order does not exceed the following specified time limits:
- 30 days for a first order, 90 days for a second order within one year, and 180 days for a third order within one year related to infractions; or,
- 30 days if issued pursuant to an arrest for a misdemeanor or felony offense. Upon conviction for the offense, the order may be extended to a total of 180 days for a misdemeanor and one year for a felony. (Pub. Util. Code § 99171, subd. (a)(2)).
- 30 days for a first order, 90 days for a second order within one year, and 180 days for a third order within one year related to infractions; or,
- Specifies prohibition processes, notification procedures, and hearing and appeal procedures. (Pub. Util. Code § 99171, subds. (a)(3), (b) & (c).)
- Requires the transit district to establish an advisory committee and to ensure that personnel charged with issuance and enforcement of prohibition orders receive training as emphasized and as recommended by the advisory committee. Tasks the advisory committee with responsibilities, as specified. Authorizes existing advisory committees to be used if appropriate. (Pub. Util. Code, § 99172.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement: According to the author, “Rider comfort and safety is a priority for BART personnel. In an effort to respond to growing public safety concerns, BART was allowed to enter into a pilot program to issue prohibition orders. These were to be issued as a last result when other efforts to protect the public failed. Safeguards were added to protect against abuse. Over the last three years, data tells us that although the number of prohibitions orders issued fluctuated from year to year, overall reports of violent crime dropped between 2013 and 2016. This reduction in violent crime occurred during a period of steady BART ridership growth. Safety should not be an issue when it comes to public transportation. By permanently granting BART the authority to issue prohibition orders, will continue to provide BART with the tools it needs to make sure all Californians are provided with a safe and comfortable environment when traveling.”
- BART and Prohibition Orders: AB 716 (Dickinson) Chapter 534, Statutes of 2011 authorized the creation of a three-year pilot program under which BART could issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities. In 2013, BART initiated its AB 716 program, which also required BART to provide the Legislature with annual reports on the program. (Public Utilities Code § 99172.)
The annual report for 2013 indicates that BART issued 146 prohibition orders between May 6, 2013, and December 31, 2013. None of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty-five percent of those orders were related to domestic violence.
The annual report for 2014 indicates that BART issued 281 prohibition orders that year. Six of the alleged violators contested the order. Twenty percent of the prohibition orders issued involved domestic violence cases, a decrease from 2013.
SB1154 (Hancock) Chapter 559, Statutes of 2014, permitted BART to continue issuing these prohibition orders until January 1, 2018. The bill also clarified that BART Police Officers have the authority to issue emergency protective orders for individuals in a stalking situation within the transit system, and that they have the authority to take custody of weapons while investigating domestic violence situations.
The annual report for 2015 indicates that BART issued 255 prohibition orders that year. Five of the alleged violators contested the order. The report reflects a reduction in the issuance of prohibition orders in the areas of robbery, batteries/threats involving patrons and threats/batteries involving employees (including officers). These violent crimes committed on the district property declined from 158 in 2014, to 123 in 2015. At the same time, overall ridership increased.
The report reflects that 25 percent of the prohibition orders in 2015 were related to domestic violence, a slight increase from 2014. The report attributes this to stations being used for a child custody exchange location for the courts. These meetings sometimes lead to domestic violence. These incidents may decrease with the authority granted to BART police to issue emergency protective orders at stations under SB 1154, along with continued outreach and public awareness efforts.
The 2016 report is being completed and not yet available.
This bill makes BART’s authority to issue these prohibition orders permanent.
- Argument in Support: According to BART, the sponsor of this bill, “In 2011, AB 716 (Dickerson) authorized the creation of a three-year pilot program allowing BART to exclude individuals from using the system for specified periods of time, depending on the nature and frequency of offenses. BART began issuing prohibition orders in 2013, and although the issuance of prohibitions [sic.] orders has fluctuated, there has been an overall decrease in violent crimes committed on BART property.
“Your introduction of AB 730 would allow BART to permanently continue this important effort to reduce crime and make BART a safer system for riders and employees. Prohibition orders are one of many safety measures BART utilizes and have been a great asset to implementing an effective public safety strategy.” - Related Legislation: AB 468 (Santiago) would authorize the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority to issue a prohibition order to any person cited for committing one or more of certain prohibited acts in specified transit facilities. SB 468 was amended by the author and re-referred to the Assembly Committee on Transportation.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 1154 (Hancock) Chapter 559, Statutes of 2014, in part, extended the sunset on the law that allows BART to issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities, until January 1, 2018.
- AB 716 (Dickinson) Chapter 534, Statutes of 2011, in part, authorized the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District, until January 1, 2015, to issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities. AB 716 also removed the sunset provisions for Sacramento Regional Transit District and the Fresno Area Express, making their related authority permanent.
- SB 1561 (Steinberg) Chapter 528, Statutes of 2008, authorized the Sacramento Regional Transit District and the Fresno Area Express, until January 1, 2012, to issue prohibition orders denying passengers committing certain illegal behaviors entry onto transit vehicles and facilities. SB 1561 also described the kinds of behaviors according to their potential severity and prescribes the progressive penalties based upon the severity and frequency of violations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (Sponsor)
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by:
Cheryl Anderson / PUB. S. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):