AB 859: Elders and dependent adults: abuse or neglect.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-09-15
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorneys fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
This bill would instead apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the above provisions, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. The bill would make conforming changes to a related provision.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorneys fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
This bill would instead apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the above provisions, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. The bill would make conforming changes to a related provision.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorneys fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
This bill would instead apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the above provisions, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. The bill would make conforming changes to a related provision.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorneys fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
The
This bill would instead apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any case brought under this act that alleges physical abuse or neglect claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the above provisions, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. The bill would make conforming changes to a related provision.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorneys fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
The bill would apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any case brought under this act that alleges physical abuse or neglect upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. The bill would make conforming changes to a related provision.
If it is proven by clear and convincing evidence, or by a preponderance of the evidence pursuant to Section 15657.02, that a defendant is liable for physical abuse as defined in Section 15610.63, or neglect as defined in Section 15610.57, and that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse, the following shall apply, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law:
(a)The court shall award to the plaintiff reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The term costs includes, but is not limited to, reasonable fees for the services of a conservator, if any, devoted to the litigation of a claim brought under this article.
(b)The limitations imposed by Section 377.34 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the damages recoverable shall not apply. However, the damages recovered shall not exceed the damages permitted to be recovered pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3333.2 of the Civil Code.
(c)The standards set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code regarding the imposition of punitive damages on an employer based upon the acts of an employee shall be satisfied before any damages or attorneys fees permitted under this section may be imposed against an employer.
SEC. 2.Section 15657.02 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:15657.02.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the standard of evidence in any claim for remedies sought under Section 15657 shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
(1)The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2023.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
(2)A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
(b)(1)This section applies only to claims brought against a residential care facility licensed pursuant to the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act (Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569) of Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code), or a skilled nursing facility as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1250 of the Health and Safety Code, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2).
(2)This section does not apply to either of the following:
(A)A facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of, an acute psychiatric hospital, as defined in subdivision (b) of, or a special hospital, as defined in subdivision (f) of, Section 1250 of, and licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(B)A facility that holds a valid license issued pursuant to subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 1254 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, spoliation of evidence means the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
(d)For purposes of this section, the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation shall be material to the claim brought under this article and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation.
(e)Nothing in this section modifies the standard of evidence for cases brought under Section 15657.03.
If it is proven by clear and convincing evidence, or by a preponderance of the evidence pursuant to Section 15657.02, that a defendant is liable for physical abuse as defined in Section 15610.63, or neglect as defined in Section 15610.57, and that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse, the following shall apply, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law:
(a)The court shall award to the plaintiff reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The term costs includes, but is not limited to, reasonable fees for the services of a conservator, if any, devoted to the litigation of a claim brought under this article.
(b)The limitations imposed by Section 377.34 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the damages recoverable shall not apply. However, the damages recovered shall not exceed the damages permitted to be recovered pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3333.2 of the Civil Code.
(c)The standards set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code regarding the imposition of punitive damages on an employer based upon the acts of an employee shall be satisfied before any damages or attorneys fees permitted under this section may be imposed against an employer.
SEC. 2.Section 15657.02 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:15657.02.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the standard of evidence in any claim for remedies sought under Section 15657 shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
(1)The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2023.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
(2)A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
(b)(1)This section applies only to claims brought against a residential care facility licensed pursuant to the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act (Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569) of Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code), or a skilled nursing facility as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1250 of the Health and Safety Code, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2).
(2)This section does not apply to either of the following:
(A)A facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of, an acute psychiatric hospital, as defined in subdivision (b) of, or a special hospital, as defined in subdivision (f) of, Section 1250 of, and licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(B)A facility that holds a valid license issued pursuant to subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 1254 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, spoliation of evidence means the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced. produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
(d)For purposes of this section, the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation shall be relevant material to the claim brought under this article. article and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation.
(e)Nothing in this section modifies the standard of evidence for cases brought under Section 15657.03.
If it is proven by clear and convincing evidence, or by a preponderance of the evidence pursuant to Section 15657.02, that a defendant is liable for physical abuse as defined in Section 15610.63, or neglect as defined in Section 15610.57, and that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse, the following shall apply, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law:
(a)The court shall award to the plaintiff reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The term costs includes, but is not limited to, reasonable fees for the services of a conservator, if any, devoted to the litigation of a claim brought under this article.
(b)The limitations imposed by Section 377.34 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the damages recoverable shall not apply. However, the damages recovered shall not exceed the damages permitted to be recovered pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3333.2 of the Civil Code.
(c)The standards set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code regarding the imposition of punitive damages on an employer based upon the acts of an employee shall be satisfied before any damages or attorneys fees permitted under this section may be imposed against an employer.
SEC. 2.Section 15657.02 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:15657.02.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the standard of evidence in any claim described in subdivision (c) for remedies sought under Section 15657 shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
(a)(1)The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2023.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
(b)(2)A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
(c)(b)(1)This section applies only to claims brought against a residential care facility licensed pursuant to the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act (Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569) of Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code), or a skilled nursing facility as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1250 of the Health and Safety Code, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2).
(2)This section does not apply to either of the following:
(A)A facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of, an acute psychiatric hospital, as defined in subdivision (b) of, or a special hospital, as defined in subdivision (f) of, Section 1250 of, and licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(B)A facility that holds a valid license issued pursuant to subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 1254 of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)(c)For purposes of this section, spoliation of evidence means the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced.
(e)(d)For purposes of this section, the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation shall be relevant to the claim brought under this article.
(f)(e)Nothing in this section modifies the standard of evidence for cases brought under Section 15657.03.
Where If it is proven by clear and convincing evidence, or by a preponderance of the evidence pursuant to Section 15657.02, that a defendant is liable for physical abuse as defined in Section 15610.63, or neglect as defined in Section 15610.57, and that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse, the following shall apply, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law:
(a)The court shall award to the plaintiff reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The term costs includes, but is not limited to, reasonable fees for the services of a conservator, if any, devoted to the litigation of a claim brought under this article.
(b)The limitations imposed by Section 377.34 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the damages recoverable shall not apply. However, the damages recovered shall not exceed the damages permitted to be recovered pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3333.2 of the Civil Code.
(c)The standards set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code regarding the imposition of punitive damages on an employer based upon the acts of an employee shall be satisfied before any damages or attorneys fees permitted under this section may be imposed against an employer.
SEC. 2.Section 15657.02 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:15657.02.Notwithstanding any other law, the standard of evidence in any case brought under this act that alleges physical abuse or neglect claim described in subdivision (c) for remedies sought under Section 15657 shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
(a)The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2023.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
(b)A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
(c)(1)This section applies only to claims brought against a residential care facility licensed pursuant to the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act (Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569) of Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code), or a skilled nursing facility as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1250 of the Health and Safety Code, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2).
(2)This section does not apply to either of the following:
(A)A facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of, an acute psychiatric hospital, as defined in subdivision (b) of, or a special hospital, as defined in subdivision (f) of, Section 1250 of, and licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(B)A facility that holds a valid license issued pursuant to subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 1254 of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)For purposes of this section, spoliation of evidence means the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced.
(e)For purposes of this section, the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation shall be relevant to the claim brought under this article.
(f)Nothing in this section modifies the standard of evidence for cases brought under Section 15657.03.
Where it is proven by clear and convincing evidence evidence, or by a preponderance of the evidence pursuant to Section 15657.02, that a defendant is liable for physical abuse as defined in Section 15610.63, or neglect as defined in Section 15610.57, and that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse, the following shall apply, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law:
(a)The court shall award to the plaintiff reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The term costs includes, but is not limited to, reasonable fees for the services of a conservator, if any, devoted to the litigation of a claim brought under this article.
(b)The limitations imposed by Section 377.34 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the damages recoverable shall not apply. However, the damages recovered shall not exceed the damages permitted to be recovered pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3333.2 of the Civil Code.
(c)The standards set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code regarding the imposition of punitive damages on an employer based upon the acts of an employee shall be satisfied before any damages or attorneys fees permitted under this section may be imposed against an employer.
SEC. 2.Section 15657.02 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:15657.02.Notwithstanding any other law, the standard of evidence in any case brought under this act that alleges physical abuse or neglect shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
(a)The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2023.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
(b)A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 12, 2018 | Stricken from file. |
| Jan 3, 2018 | Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Oct 2, 2017 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 6, 2017 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 8 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 6, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (September 1). |
| Aug 28, 2017 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 23, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 19, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (July 18). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 28, 2017 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 15, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 5, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 43. Noes 17. Page 2087.) |
| May 30, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 26, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (May 26). |
| May 17, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 2, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (May 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 27, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 24, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 29, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2017 | AB 859 EGGMAN Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB859 Eggman By Mitchell | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB859 Eggman By Mitchell Reconsider | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB859 Eggman By Mitchell | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2017 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 18, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2017 | AB 859 EGGMAN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 859
Author:(Eggman)
As Enrolled Ver:September 15, 2017
2/3 vote
ASSEMBLY: | 43-17 | (June 1, 2017) | SENATE: | 26-12 | (September 6, 2017) |
ASSEMBLY: | 41-21 | (September 13, 2017) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: If a defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed relevant evidence, changes the standard of proof required for an action for abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult, from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence. Specifically, this bill:
- Changes the standard of proof required in elder or dependent adult physical abuse or neglect cases brought under Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) from clear and convincing to a preponderance of the evidence for actions brought against assisted living or skilled nursing facilities if, with respect to evidence relevant to the claim:
- The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of the evidence by the defendant; or
- A judge or arbitrator determines at any time during the litigation or arbitration that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
- Defines "spoliation" as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
- Requires that evidence that is the subject of spoliation be material to the claim and specifically requires it be maintained or preserved by the defendant.
- Specifically exempts from this bill any facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
- Specifically provides that this bill does not modify the standard of evidence for seeking a protective order to protect an elder or dependent adult from abuse, as provided.
The Senate amendments add to the definition of spoliation that the other party has been materially prejudiced and that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation claim must be required to be maintained by the defendant.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 15600 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
- Provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. Requires, in order to receive any damages or attorney's fees against an employer, the standards set forth in 3), below, must be satisfied. (Section 15657)
- Requires a plaintiff, in order to receive punitive damages against an employer for the acts of an employee, to make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with a conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Civil Code Section 3294)
- Provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified. (Section 15657.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, potential increased Medi-Cal costs to pay for skilled nursing facility services in the hundreds of thousands per year (General Fund and federal funds). Skilled nursing facilities are reimbursed by the Medi-Cal program on a cost-basis. Assuming that the potential for increased legal costs to skilled nursing facility operators increases their professional liability insurance costs by 1%, and that the average cost per day for professional liability insurance is about $3, the annual cost of the bill to Medi-Cal would be about $600,000 per year.
COMMENTS: Abuse of nursing home residents is nothing new. In 2002, the United States General Accounting Office (GAO) prepared a report on nursing home resident abuse. The GAO found that 30 percent of the 17,000 nursing homes in the United States were cited for deficiencies involving actual harm to the nursing home residents, or for placing the residents at risk of death or serious injury. (GAO, Nursing Homes: More Can Be Done to Protect Residents from Abuse, GAO-02-312 (March 1, 2002).) This report stated that "relatively few prosecutions result from allegations of physical and sexual abuse of nursing home residents because allegations of abuse were not always referred to local law enforcement or MFCUs [Medicaid Fraud Control Units]. When referrals were made, the referral often occurred days or weeks after the incident, compromising the integrity of any limited evidence might have still been available. Second, a lack of witnesses to instances of abuse made prosecutions difficult and convictions unlikely." (Ibid. at 17.)
In 1991, the Legislature enacted EADACPA in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder and dependent adult physical and financial abuse or neglect. (SB 679 (Mello), Chapter 774, Statutes of 1991.) At that time, the standard of proof necessary to establish a claim under EADACPA was set high through the use of the clear and convincing standard of proof. In 2004, the Legislature enacted AB 2611 (Simitian), Chapter 886, Statutes of 2004, which separated out the provisions for elder and dependent adult financial abuse and reduced the standard of proof necessary to establish financial elder abuse to the more typical civil preponderance of the evidence standard of proof. The evidentiary standard for proving physical abuse or neglect remained at the higher standard of clear and convincing evidence.
This bill seeks to better protect elder and dependent adults by making a relatively modest change to the evidentiary standard. According to the author, some nursing home defendants, who often hold all or most of the evidence necessary to prove the claim of elder abuse, are purposefully destroying evidence and thereby making the victim's case that much harder to prove. This bill does not lower the overall evidentiary standard. Rather, it only seeks to lower the standard of proof from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence when the court determines that the defendant intentionally destroyed or concealed evidence material to the claim, that materially prejudices the plaintiff, and that the defendant was required to maintain. Further limiting the reach of this bill, it only applies to claims brought against assisted living and skilled nursing facilities. It does not, by its own terms, apply to hospitals and facilities owned by hospitals.
Current Law Allows a Defendant to Intentionally Destroy Evidence With Potentially Limited Consequences: As specifically defined by this bill, spoliation is the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent to prevent the evidence from being produced. The California Supreme Court, in deciding not to create a separate tort for spoliation, did nonetheless find that it causes significant harm:
No one doubts that the intentional destruction of evidence should be condemned. Destroying evidence can destroy fairness and justice, for it increases the risk of an erroneous decision on the merits of the underlying cause of action. Destroying evidence can also increase the costs of litigation as parties attempt to reconstruct the destroyed evidence or to develop other evidence, which may be less accessible, less persuasive, or both. (Cedars-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior Court (1998) 18 Cal.4th 1, 10.)
Under California law today, a defendant who intentionally destroys evidence needed to prove a plaintiff's case may not necessarily face significant consequences. A judge can, should the judge so choose, issue discovery sanctions and sanction a party who "misuses the discovery process," which includes making an evasive response to discovery, or failing to respond to a discovery request, and order the party to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, or holding the party in contempt of court (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2023.010 et seq.). However, these remedies are discretionary and the existing burden of proof still requires the plaintiff to prove her case with the higher evidentiary threshold of clear and convincing evidence.
Spoliation Narrowly Defined in the Bill: This bill limits – in three ways – how spoliation can be used to reduce the evidentiary burden in an elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect case. First, the bill defines spoliation narrowly as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced and that has materially prejudiced the other party. The reduced evidentiary standard does not apply if evidence is inadvertently or negligently destroyed. The defendant must intentionally destroy or conceal the evidence. Second, the evidence that has been intentionally concealed or destroyed must be material to the claim and the defendant must specifically be required to maintain or preserve that evidence. Finally, it is not enough for the plaintiff to allege that key evidence was intentionally concealed or destroyed, the court must find that the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation or a judge or arbitrator must determine that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
This Bill Does Not in Any Way Change MICRA: Enacted in 1975 and not updated for inflation since then, the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) established a $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages that may be awarded to an injured plaintiff in a medical malpractice case and a limit on attorney's fees.
Elder and dependent adult abuse under the Welfare and Institutions Code is distinct from medical malpractice. (See Covenant Care v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771, 785; Smith v. Ben Bennett, Inc. (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 1507, 1519-20.) Medical malpractice, or professional negligence, is defined as a negligent act or omission of a healthcare provider in the rendering of professional services. (See Civil Code Sections 3333.1 and 3333.2 and Code of Civil Procedure Section 340.5.) Elder abuse is a separate tort claim brought to protect elderly and dependent adults from physical abuse or neglect. Elder abuse involves significantly more than mere negligence, rather it must involve recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice. "Recklessness, unlike negligence, involves more than 'inadvertence, incompetence, unskillfulness, or a failure to take precautions' but rather rises to the level of a 'conscious choice of a course of action . . . with knowledge of the serious danger to others involved in it.'" (Delaney v. Baker (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 23, 32-33 (citation omitted).) If an elder or dependent adult is abused or neglected by a healthcare provider and such bad acts are proved, by clear and convincing evidence, to be reckless or done with oppression, fraud, or malice, then such conduct is not considered medical malpractice or professional negligence. It is considered elder abuse within EADACPA. (Ibid. at 35.)
If it is established, by clear and convincing evidence, that a healthcare provider has physically abused or neglected an elder or dependent adult and that the provider has done so with recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice, then the plaintiff can recover EADACPA's heightened remedies, which include attorney fees and costs and pre-death pain and suffering, the latter of which is capped at $250,000. (See Welfare and Institutions Code 15657.) If the elder or dependent adult is seeking these remedies against an employer, then he or she must also prove, again by clear and convincing evidence, that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee who committed the acts and employed that person with a knowing disregard of the rights or safety of others, or the employer authorized the conduct of the employee, or knew of the wrongful conduct and approved the conduct after it occurred. (Ibid.; Civil Code Section 3294(b).) By contrast this bill simply allows for the enhanced remedies under the lower preponderance standard only if the defendant has willfully destroyed or withheld the evidence needed to prove the case. The plaintiff will still need to prove recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice and, if an employer is involved, the employer's culpability.
This bill lowers the standard of proof for claims of elder physical abuse or neglect made against a skilled nursing facility or residential care facility for the elderly when a judge has found intentional destruction of evidence.
Intentional destruction or concealment of evidence, known as spoliation, is illegal. Currently when judges find spoliation, they have numerous sanctions at their disposal which they can impose against an offending party. In appropriate circumstances, this will facilitate establishing a claim of abuse. Accordingly, I don't believe changing the standard of proof is warranted.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002436 FN:
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 859
Author:(Eggman)
As Amended Ver:June 15, 2017
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 43-17 | (June 1, 2017) | SENATE: | 26-12 | (September 6, 2017) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: If a defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed relevant evidence, changes the standard of proof required for an action for abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult, from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence. Specifically, this bill:
- Changes the standard of proof required in elder or dependent adult physical abuse or neglect cases brought under Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) from clear and convincing to a preponderance of the evidence for actions brought against assisted living or skilled nursing facilities if, with respect to evidence relevant to the claim:
- The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of the evidence by the defendant; or
- A judge or arbitrator determines at any time during the litigation or arbitration that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
- Defines "spoliation" as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
- Requires that evidence that is the subject of spoliation be material to the claim and specifically requires it be maintained or preserved by the defendant.
- Specifically exempts from this bill any facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
- Specifically provides that this bill does not modify the standard of evidence for seeking a protective order to protect an elder or dependent adult from abuse, as provided.
The Senate amendments add to the definition of spoliation that the other party has been materially prejudiced and that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation claim must be required to be maintained by the defendant.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15600 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
- Provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. Requires, in order to receive any damages or attorney's fees against an employer, the standards set forth in 3), below, must be satisfied. (Section 15657)
- Requires a plaintiff, in order to receive punitive damages against an employer for the acts of an employee, to make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with a conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Civil Code Section 3294)
- Provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified. (Section 15657.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, potential increased Medi-Cal costs to pay for skilled nursing facility services in the hundreds of thousands per year (General Fund and federal funds). Skilled nursing facilities are reimbursed by the Medi-Cal program on a cost-basis. Assuming that the potential for increased legal costs to skilled nursing facility operators increases their professional liability insurance costs by 1%, and that the average cost per day for professional liability insurance is about $3, the annual cost of the bill to Medi-Cal would be about $600,000 per year.
COMMENTS: Abuse of nursing home residents is nothing new. In 2002, the United States General Accounting Office (GAO) prepared a report on nursing home resident abuse. The GAO found that 30 percent of the 17,000 nursing homes in the United States were cited for deficiencies involving actual harm to the nursing home residents, or for placing the residents at risk of death or serious injury. (GAO, Nursing Homes: More Can Be Done to Protect Residents from Abuse, GAO-02-312 (March 1, 2002).) This report stated that "relatively few prosecutions result from allegations of physical and sexual abuse of nursing home residents because allegations of abuse were not always referred to local law enforcement or MFCUs [Medicaid Fraud Control Units]. When referrals were made, the referral often occurred days or weeks after the incident, compromising the integrity of any limited evidence might have still been available. Second, a lack of witnesses to instances of abuse made prosecutions difficult and convictions unlikely." (Ibid. at 17.)
In 1991, the Legislature enacted EADACPA in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder and dependent adult physical and financial abuse or neglect. (SB 679 (Mello), Chapter 774, Statutes of 1991.) At that time, the standard of proof necessary to establish a claim under EADACPA was set high through the use of the clear and convincing standard of proof. In 2004, the Legislature enacted AB 2611 (Simitian), Chapter 886, Statutes of 2004, which separated out the provisions for elder and dependent adult financial abuse and reduced the standard of proof necessary to establish financial elder abuse to the more typical civil preponderance of the evidence standard of proof. The evidentiary standard for proving physical abuse or neglect remained at the higher standard of clear and convincing evidence.
This bill seeks to better protect elder and dependent adults by making a relatively modest change to the evidentiary standard. According to the author, some nursing home defendants, who often hold all or most of the evidence necessary to prove the claim of elder abuse, are purposefully destroying evidence and thereby making the victim's case that much harder to prove. This bill does not lower the overall evidentiary standard. Rather, it only seeks to lower the standard of proof from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence when the court determines that the defendant intentionally destroyed or concealed evidence material to the claim, that materially prejudices the plaintiff, and that the defendant was required to maintain. Further limiting the reach of this bill, it only applies to claims brought against assisted living and skilled nursing facilities. It does not, by its own terms, apply to hospitals and facilities owned by hospitals.
Current Law Allows a Defendant to Intentionally Destroy Evidence With Potentially Limited Consequences: As specifically defined by this bill, spoliation is the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent to prevent the evidence from being produced. The California Supreme Court, in deciding not to create a separate tort for spoliation, did nonetheless find that it causes significant harm:
No one doubts that the intentional destruction of evidence should be condemned. Destroying evidence can destroy fairness and justice, for it increases the risk of an erroneous decision on the merits of the underlying cause of action. Destroying evidence can also increase the costs of litigation as parties attempt to reconstruct the destroyed evidence or to develop other evidence, which may be less accessible, less persuasive, or both. (Cedars-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior Court (1998) 18 Cal.4th 1, 10.)
Under California law today, a defendant who intentionally destroys evidence needed to prove a plaintiff's case may not necessarily face significant consequences. A judge can, should the judge so choose, issue discovery sanctions and sanction a party who "misuses the discovery process," which includes making an evasive response to discovery, or failing to respond to a discovery request, and order the party to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, or holding the party in contempt of court (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2023.010 et seq.). However, these remedies are discretionary and the existing burden of proof still requires the plaintiff to prove her case with the higher evidentiary threshold of clear and convincing evidence.
Spoliation Narrowly Defined in the Bill: This bill limits – in three ways – how spoliation can be used to reduce the evidentiary burden in an elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect case. First, the bill defines spoliation narrowly as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced and that has materially prejudiced the other party. The reduced evidentiary standard does not apply if evidence is inadvertently or negligently destroyed. The defendant must intentionally destroy or conceal the evidence. Second, the evidence that has been intentionally concealed or destroyed must be material to the claim and the defendant must specifically be required to maintain or preserve that evidence. Finally, it is not enough for the plaintiff to allege that key evidence was intentionally concealed or destroyed, the court must find that the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation or a judge or arbitrator must determine that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
This Bill Does Not in Any Way Change MICRA: Enacted in 1975 and not updated for inflation since then, the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) established a $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages that may be awarded to an injured plaintiff in a medical malpractice case and a limit on attorney's fees.
Elder and dependent adult abuse under the Welfare & Institutions Code is distinct from medical malpractice. (See Covenant Care v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771, 785; Smith v. Ben Bennett, Inc. (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 1507, 1519-20.) Medical malpractice, or professional negligence, is defined as a negligent act or omission of a healthcare provider in the rendering of professional services. (See Civil Code Sections 3333.1 and 3333.2 and Code of Civil Procedure Section 340.5.) Elder abuse is a separate tort claim brought to protect elderly and dependent adults from physical abuse or neglect. Elder abuse involves significantly more than mere negligence, rather it must involve recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice. "Recklessness, unlike negligence, involves more than 'inadvertence, incompetence, unskillfulness, or a failure to take precautions' but rather rises to the level of a 'conscious choice of a course of action . . . with knowledge of the serious danger to others involved in it.'" (Delaney v. Baker (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 23, 32-33 (citation omitted).) If an elder or dependent adult is abused or neglected by a healthcare provider and such bad acts are proved, by clear and convincing evidence, to be reckless or done with oppression, fraud, or malice, then such conduct is not considered medical malpractice or professional negligence. It is considered elder abuse within EADACPA. (Ibid. at 35.)
If it is established, by clear and convincing evidence, that a healthcare provider has physically abused or neglected an elder or dependent adult and that the provider has done so with recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice, then the plaintiff can recover EADACPA's heightened remedies, which include attorney fees and costs and pre-death pain and suffering, the latter of which is capped at $250,000. (See Welfare & Institutions Code 15657.) If the elder or dependent adult is seeking these remedies against an employer, then he or she must also prove, again by clear and convincing evidence, that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee who committed the acts and employed that person with a knowing disregard of the rights or safety of others, or the employer authorized the conduct of the employee, or knew of the wrongful conduct and approved the conduct after it occurred. (Ibid.; Civil Code Section 3294(b).) By contrast this bill simply allows for the enhanced remedies under the lower preponderance standard only if the defendant has willfully destroyed or withheld the evidence needed to prove the case. The plaintiff will still need to prove recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice and, if an employer is involved, the employer's culpability.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001815
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 859
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 7/18/17
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/17
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 43-17, 6/1/17 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Consumer Attorneys of California
DIGEST:
This bill applies a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except when operated by an acute care hospital as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified.
Existing law:
- Provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15600 et seq.)
- Provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.)
- Provides that in order to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer for the acts of an employee, the plaintiff make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657; Civ. Code Sec. 3294.)
- Provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.5.)
This bill:
- Provides that the standard of evidence in any claim for remedies sought for physical abuse of an elder or dependent adult shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
- The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant; or
- A judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
- Provides that this preponderance of the evidence standard would apply only to claims brought against a licensed residential care facility or licensed skilled nursing facility.
- Provides that the preponderance of the evidence standard does not apply to a facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
- Defines “spoliation of evidence” for the purposes of this bill as meaning the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
- Provides that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation must be material to the claim brought and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation.
Comments
Purpose of this bill. California’s elder abuse statute, EADACPA, was enacted to protect elderly and dependent adults from abuse. (Welfare & Institutions Code § 15600 et seq.) It defines civil elder abuse to mean physical or financial abuse, neglect, isolation, abandonment, abduction or other treatment resulting in physical harm, pain or mental suffering. (Welfare & Institutions Code § 15610.07). Other than financial elder abuse, these claims all require the higher standard of “clear and convincing” proof and are thus difficult to pursue.
Some nursing homes intentionally destroy evidence after an abused person files a civil suit. In California, a party has a duty to preserve evidence at the point in which the party has been served with discovery demands after the civil suit has been filed. California law, however, is weak in its treatment of spoliation, and a party may not be sued under a separate cause of action for the intentional destruction of evidence. The only remedy is a discretionary sanction or an instruction by the judge to the jury that it “may consider whether one party intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence.”
The California Legislature has the right and duty to modify the burden of proof to prevent wrongdoers from taking advantage of their own illegal conduct. AB 859 gives the elderly and their families a chance at justice after the intentional destruction of evidence.
Lowering the evidentiary standard of proof. This bill lowers the evidentiary standard of proof to a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a care facility, as provided, for remedies sought pursuant to EADACPA, when spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. A standard of proof is a threshold level of reliability of evidence that must be met to be considered dispositive of the thing to be proven. (11-56 Moore's Federal Practice, Civil § 56.42 (2017).) A clear and convincing standard of proof requires the party to prove to the trier of fact that it is substantially more likely than not that the thing to be proven is in fact true. A preponderance of the evidence standard of proof requires less proof than the clear and convincing standard. (Colorado v. New Mexico (1984) 467 U.S. 310, 316.) To satisfy a preponderance standard, the party must prove to the trier of fact that there is a greater than 50 percent chance that the thing to be proven is true. (Id.)
Existing law, under EADACPA, requires a victim of elder or dependent adult abuse or neglect to prove by clear and convincing evidence, or that it is substantially more likely than not, that the defendant’s conduct caused harm to the victim. Where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.)
Where the plaintiff is seeking remedies for financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult, existing law requires an evidentiary standard of a preponderance of the evidence. If the financial abuse is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.5.) If in order to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer for the acts of an employee, the plaintiff must make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657; Civ. Code Sec. 3294.) This clear and convincing evidence standard is required to be met for a victim to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer, regardless of whether the underlying abuse was financial or physical.
This bill provides for the lower evidentiary standard for claims brought against a residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) or skilled nursing facility, as defined, under the EADACPA only in the following instances:
- When the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion, as provided, due to the spoliation of evidence by the defendant; or
- If a judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
Additionally, this bill defines “spoliation of evidence” as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party. This bill also requires that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation must be material to the claim brought under this article and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation. These provisions arguably limit the application of the lower evidentiary standard to instances where it is needed for the plaintiff to have any chance of access to justice.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, potential increased Medi-Cal costs to pay for skilled nursing facility services in the hundreds of thousands per year (General Fund and federal funds). Skilled nursing facilities are reimbursed by the Medi-Cal program on a cost-basis. Assuming that the potential for increased legal costs to skilled nursing facility operators increases their professional liability insurance costs by 1%, and that the average cost per day for professional liability insurance is about $3, the annual cost of the bill to Medi-Cal would be about $600,000 per year.
Consumer Attorneys of California (source)
AARP
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Retired Teachers Association
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
Congress of California Seniors
Disability Rights California
Institute on Aging
WISE & Healthy Aging Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program
American Insurance Association
California Assisted Living Association
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Physician Groups
California Chamber of Commerce
California Chapter of American College of Emergency Physicians
California Dental Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Cooperative of American Physicians
Doctors Company
LeadingAge California
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumer Attorneys of California, the sponsor of this bill, writes:
Normally, in order to prove physical elder abuse or neglect, the victim must show “reckless neglect” by a very high standard known as “clear and convincing.” Almost all other cases, about 99% of civil actions in California, are required to be proven by the lower standard of “preponderance of the evidence.” So, elder abuse victims have this unique burden of having this much higher legal standard to overcome before they can prove their case.
Unfortunately, some nursing homes and RCFEs intentionally destroy legal evidence after the abused senior files a civil suit. Even after such an illegal act by the nursing home or RCFE, the elder or their family is still forced to prove abuse at the higher standard (clear and convincing), but often cannot as the needed evidence was intentionally destroyed by the wrongdoer facility.
It isn’t fair to require the abused victim to prove the case at the higher standard when it was the defendant facility itself that destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case.
AB 859 states that when a judge or arbitrator has found that a nursing home has intentionally destroyed legal evidence, the victim’s burden of proving the case is by the lower preponderance of evidence standard, and not the higher clear and convincing standard. The California Legislature has the right and duty to modify the burden of proof to prevent wrongdoers from taking advantage of their own illegal conduct.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The author agreed to accept amendments on the Assembly Floor that are reflected in the current version of this bill. Opposition to this bill requests one further amendment that would result in a court being able to decide whether the preponderance of an evidence standard would apply when the other requirements provided for by this bill have been met. In other words, the requested amendment would allow the court to determine whether or not the standard of proof should be lowered, instead of requiring the standard to be lowered.
In opposition, the California Assisted Living Association, the California Association of Health Facilities, the American Insurance Association, LeadingAge California, the California Chamber of Commerce, the Civil Justice Association of California, the Cooperative of American Physicians, the Doctors Company, the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, the California Dental Association, and the California Association of Physician Groups write:
While we appreciate the author’s June 15th amendments, we are still opposed to any premise that takes away discretion from the judge in dealing with these various motions. AB 859 automatically lowers, without any judge’s discretion, the current evidentiary standard for obtaining enhanced remedies available under EADACPA from “clear and convincing” to a lower “preponderance of the evidence” standard. This would have a devastating impact on the health care community.
Virtually every personal injury lawsuit involving a health care profession and/or a health facility to an elder includes a filing under professional negligence/medical malpractice and under EADACPA – it is not uncommon to have a filing under EADACPA because of tactical purposes by the plaintiff attorney. By filing a claim for relief under the Act, plaintiff’s attorneys attempt to circumvent the limits on non-economic damages and attorney’s fees under the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA). This bill would add new incentives and tactics for attorneys to include claims of elder abuse in every complaint and pursue numerous spoliation motions in order to skirt MICRA, and secure attorney fees, costs and uncapped punitive damages. Even though the sponsor and author carved out two of the numerous associations who are affected by MICRA, this bill remains a MICRA issue, as it has been since introduction. Associations and companies opposed to this bill understand the important protections and directly feel the impact on any end run around MICRA.
The Elder Abuse Act defines neglect as “The negligent failure of any person having the care or custody of an elder or dependent adult to exercise that degree of care that a reasonable person in a like position would exercise.” Only where such neglect is proven by clear and convincing evidence, and the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice in the commission of the neglect, the plaintiff may recover attorney’s fees and costs, and other heightened remedies unlike unlimited punitive damages. Other civil causes of actions that have the same clear and convincing evidentiary standard of proof include claims of fraud, cases of wills and inheritances, and cases involving certain family matters. If the standard is lowered as suggested by AB 859, acts of mere negligence would qualify for enhanced remedies, fees and unlimited punitive damages; thereby increasing the risk of litigation, dodging existing rules governing medical professional liability disputes and exacerbating the shortage of homes, health facilities, doctors, nurses and other medical professionals willing to treat this growing elderly population.
Under current law, our coalition members readily experience plaintiff attorneys who characterize alleged professional negligence among healthcare providers treating elderly or dependent adults as “neglect” under the EADACPA in order to qualify for the enhanced remedies available under this statute. Lowering the evidence standard as suggested in AB 859 will further encourage this practice, thereby weakening the MICRA protections and other caps for healthcare providers and assisted living facilities serving this population. AB 859 will lead to higher litigation costs and increased liability insurance, at the expense of the Medi-Cal program and residents, only to put more money in plaintiff attorneys’ pockets.
While this coalition can further provide options and explore proper remedies for the aggrieved party and justified penalties against the plaintiff or defendant who destroyed or tampered with the evidence, it is imperative that the judge has discretion on a motion-by-motion, case-by-case basis.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 43-17, 6/1/17
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Dababneh, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Caballero, Chávez, Chen, Dahle, Harper, Kiley, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Acosta, Travis Allen, Bocanegra, Cervantes, Choi, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gipson, Grayson, Medina, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago
Prepared by: Marisa Shea / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/5/17 18:01:53
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 859 (Eggman) - Elders and dependent adults: abuse or neglect
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 859 would lower the standard of evidence for claims of elder abuse made against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, when there has been a spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
Fiscal Impact:
Potential increased Medi-Cal costs to pay for skilled nursing facility services in the hundreds of thousands per year (General Fund and federal funds). Skilled nursing facilities are reimbursed by the Medi-Cal program on a cost-basis. Assuming that the potential for increased legal costs to skilled nursing facility operators increases their professional liability insurance costs by 1%, and that the average cost per day for professional liability insurance is about $3, the annual cost of the bill to Medi-Cal would be about $600,000 per year.
Background:
Under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, a victim of elder or dependent adult abuse or neglect must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant’s conduct caused harm to the victim. Where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000.
Under existing case law, the “clear and convincing evidence” standard is interpreted to mean that an assertion must be substantially more likely to be true than not true. This is a more strict evidentiary threshold than the “preponderance of evidence” standard which is interpreted to require there to be a greater than fifty-percent chance that an assertion is true.
In the Medi-Cal program, the state reimburses skilled nursing facility operators for care of Medi-Cal patients based on actual facility costs. Reimbursement rates are developed based on categories of cost, including professional liability insurance costs. The rate setting methodology is cost-based, but also relies on percentile caps. In other words, the reimbursement rate paid to a given facility is based on their actual expenditures in several categories, but those costs are capped at specified percentiles of the costs incurred by similar facilities in each category.
Proposed Law:
AB 859 would lower the standard of evidence for claims of elder abuse made against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, when there has been a spoliation of evidence by the defendant.
Specifically, the bill would:
- Lower the standard of evidence for elder abuse cases to a preponderance of the evidence if a “spoliation of evidence” has been found, as specified;
- Limit the changes in the bill to elder abuse cases brought against residential care facilities for the elderly or skilled nursing facilities;
- Exempt certain types of facilities;
- Define “spoliation of evidence” to be the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence, with the intent to prevent evidence from being produced, that has materially prejudiced the other party.
Related Legislation:
SB 558 (Simitian, 2011) would have more broadly changed the evidentiary standard for elder abuse to a preponderance of the evidence That bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s Suspense File.
Staff Comments:
Under this bill, it would be easier for plaintiffs to prove that elder abuse had occurred when there has been a spoliation of evidence. Under that circumstance, the plaintiff would be able to recover attorney’s fees and damages that would not be otherwise be recoverable. It is likely that the passage of this bill will result in larger legal judgments against skilled nursing facilities, larger settlements of claims, and increased legal costs. All of those costs are typically covered by professional liability insurance carried by skilled nursing facility operators. Therefore, it is likely that the bill would result in an increase in professional liability insurance premiums for skilled nursing facility operators. As noted above, even a small percentage increase in premiums would result in a significant cost to the state under the Medi-Cal cost-based reimbursement system.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 859 (Author:Eggman)
Version: June 15, 2017
Hearing Date: July 18, 2017
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: MS
SUBJECT
Elders and dependent adults: abuse or neglect
DESCRIPTION
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, provides for the award of attorney’s fees and costs to, and the recovery of damages by, a plaintiff when it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is liable for physical abuse or neglect, and the defendant has also been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse.
This bill would instead apply a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly or a skilled nursing facility, except when operated by an acute care hospital as specified, for remedies sought pursuant to the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, upon circumstances in which spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified.
BACKGROUND
In 1992, the Legislature enacted the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (SB 679 (Mello, Ch. 774, Stats. 1991).) EADACPA was established in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder or dependent adult physical and financial abuse and neglect. In 2005, the Legislature enacted AB 2611 (Simitian, Ch. 886, Stats. 2004), which separated out the provisions for elder and dependent adult financial abuse. AB 2611 imposed a different standard of proof than the clear and convincing evidentiary standard necessary to prove physical abuse or neglect.
In 2002, the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) prepared a report on nursing home resident abuse. This report was presented to the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging. The GAO found that 30 percent of the 17,000 nursing homes in the United States were cited for deficiencies involving actual harm to the nursing home residents or for placing the residents at risk of death or serious injury. (Nursing Homes: More Can Be Done to Protect Residents from Abuse (March 2002), GAO-02-312, <http://www.gao. gov/new.items/d02312.pdf> [as of July 7, 2017].) This report stated that “relatively few prosecutions result from allegations of physical and sexual abuse of nursing home residents because allegations of abuse were not always referred to local law enforcement or MFCUs [Medicaid Fraud Control Units]. When referrals were made it was often days or weeks after the incident occurred, compromising the integrity of what limited evidence might have still been available. Second, a lack of witnesses to instances of abuse made prosecutions difficult and convictions unlikely.” (Id. at p. 17.)
In 2011, SB 558 (Simitian) would have changed the evidentiary standard of proof for elder and dependent adults in physical abuse and neglect civil cases from a clear and convincing standard to a preponderance of the evidence standard. This bill sought to lower the standard of proof because the Author and supporters felt that the clear and convincing evidence standard had proven to be insurmountable when abuse occurred in a care facility. The Author argued “that the lower standard of proof of preponderance of the evidence proposed by this bill would serve to curb the physical abuse and neglect because employers will strive for better care of seniors and dependent adults, as well as give the victims of physical abuse and neglect a fighting chance when bringing their civil actions.” (SB 5558 (Simitian, 2011), Senate Judiciary Committee Analysis (April 26, 2011).) This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
This bill would change the evidentiary standard of proof to a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) or skilled nursing facility (SNF), as defined, for remedies sought pursuant to the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, when spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15600 et seq.)
Existing law provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.)
Existing law provides that in order to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer for the acts of an employee, the plaintiff make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657; Civ. Code Sec. 3294.)
Existing law provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.5.)
This bill would provide that the standard of evidence in any claim for remedies sought for physical abuse of an elder or dependent adult shall be a preponderance of the evidence under either of the following circumstances:
- the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of evidence by the defendant; or
- a judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
This bill would provide that this preponderance of the evidence standard would apply only to claims brought against a licensed residential care facility or licensed skilled nursing facility.
This bill would provide that the preponderance of the evidence standard does not apply to a facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
This bill would define “spoliation of evidence” for the purposes of this bill as meaning the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party.
This bill would provide that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation must be material to the claim brought and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation.
COMMENT
- Stated need for this bill
According to the author:
California’s elder abuse statute, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), was enacted to protect elderly and dependent adults from abuse. (Welfare & Institutions Code § 15600 et seq.) It defines civil elder abuse to mean physical or financial abuse, neglect, isolation, abandonment, abduction or other treatment resulting in physical harm, pain or mental suffering. (Welfare & Institutions Code § 15610.07). Other than financial elder abuse, these claims all require the higher standard of “clear and convincing” proof and are thus difficult to pursue.
Some nursing homes intentionally destroy evidence after an abused person files a civil suit. This is especially pernicious, given abuse must be proved at the higher standard.
The intentional and willful destruction of evidence (legally known as “spoliation”) is illegal. In California, a party has a duty to preserve evidence at the point in which the party has been served with discovery demands after the civil suit has been filed. California law, however, is weak in its treatment of spoliation, and a party may not be sued under a separate cause of action for the intentional destruction of evidence. The only remedy is a discretionary sanction or an instruction by the judge to the jury that it “may consider whether one party intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence.”
We should not require the abused victim to prove the case at the higher clear-and-convincing standard when it was the defendant facility itself that destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case.
The California Legislature has the right and duty to modify the burden of proof to prevent wrongdoers from taking advantage of their own illegal conduct. AB 859 gives the elderly and their families a chance at justice after the intentional destruction of evidence.
- Lowering the evidentiary standard of proof
This bill would lower the evidentiary standard of proof to a preponderance of the evidence standard to any claim brought against a care facility, as provided, for remedies sought pursuant to the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), when spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant, as specified. A standard of proof is a threshold level of reliability of evidence that must be met to be considered dispositive of the thing to be proven. (11-56 Moore's Federal Practice, Civil § 56.42 (2017).) A clear and convincing standard of proof requires the party to prove to the trier of fact that it is substantially more likely than not that the thing to be proven is in fact true. A preponderance of the evidence standard of proof requires less proof than the clear and convincing standard. (Colorado v. New Mexico (1984) 467 U.S. 310, 316.) To satisfy a preponderance standard, the party must prove to the trier of fact that there is a greater than 50 percent chance that the thing to be proven is true. (Id.)
Existing law, under EADACPA, requires a victim of elder or dependent adult abuse or neglect to prove by clear and convincing evidence, or that it is substantially more likely than not, that the defendant’s conduct caused harm to the victim. Where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.)
Where the plaintiff is seeking remedies for financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult, existing law requires an evidentiary standard of a preponderance of the evidence. If the financial abuse is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657.5.) If in order to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer for the acts of an employee, the plaintiff must make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 15657; Civ. Code Sec. 3294.) This clear and convincing evidence standard is required to be met for a victim to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer, regardless of whether the underlying abuse was financial or physical.
This bill would provide for the lower evidentiary standard for claims brought against a residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) or skilled nursing facility (SNF), as defined, under the EADACPA only in the following instances:
- when the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion, as provided, due to the spoliation of evidence by the defendant; or
- if a judge or arbitrator determines at any point during litigation or arbitration that spoliation of evidence has been committed by the defendant.
Additionally, this bill would define “spoliation of evidence” as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence that is done by a party, with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced, and that has materially prejudiced the other party. This bill would also require that the evidence that is the subject of the spoliation must be material to the claim brought under this article and specifically required to be maintained or preserved by the defendant under applicable law or regulation. These provisions arguably limit the application of the lower evidentiary standard to instances where it is needed for the plaintiff to have any chance of access to justice.
The Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC), the sponsor of this bill, writes:
Normally, in order to prove physical elder abuse or neglect, the victim must show “reckless neglect” by a very high standard known as “clear and convincing.” Almost all other cases, about 99% of civil actions in California, are required to be proven by the lower standard of “preponderance of the evidence.” So, elder abuse victims have this unique burden of having this much higher legal standard to overcome before they can prove their case.
Unfortunately, some nursing homes and RCFEs intentionally destroy legal evidence after the abused senior files a civil suit. Even after such an illegal act by the nursing home or RCFE, the elder or their family is still forced to prove abuse at the higher standard (clear and convincing), but often cannot as the needed evidence was intentionally destroyed by the wrongdoer facility.
It isn’t fair to require the abused victim to prove the case at the higher standard when it was the defendant facility itself that destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case.
AB 859 states that when a judge or arbitrator has found that a nursing home has intentionally destroyed legal evidence, the victim’s burden of proving the case is by the lower preponderance of evidence standard, and not the higher clear and convincing standard. The California Legislature has the right and duty to modify the burden of proof to prevent wrongdoers from taking advantage of their own illegal conduct.
- Spoliation of Evidence
Spoliation of evidence is the intentional and willful destruction of evidence. According to the Judicial Council’s Civil Jury Instruction 204, a member of the jury “may consider whether one party intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence” and if they “decide that a party did so, [they] may decide that the evidence would have been unfavorable to that party.” Spoliation is additionally considered a misuse of discovery. According to the California Code of Civil Procedure, a party may seek a variety of sanctions including monetary sanctions, contempt sanctions, issue sanctions ordering that designated facts be taken as established or precluding the offending party from supporting or opposing designated claims or defenses, evidence sanctions prohibiting the offending party from introducing designated matters into evidence, and terminating sanctions that include striking part or all of the pleadings, dismissing part or all of the action, or granting a default judgment against the offending party for misuse of discovery. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2032.030.) The Supreme Court of California has determined that all of these sanctions may be faced by a party for spoliation of evidence. (Ceders-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior Court (1998) 18 Cal. 4th 1, 12.)
The Court of Appeals has held that there is no cause of action for either intentional or negligent spoliation of evidence. (See Coprich v. Superior Court (May 19, 2000) 80 Cal. App. 4th 1081.) CAOC argues that, in general, California law is “weak in its treatment of spoliation, and a party may not be sued under a separate cause of action for the intentional destruction of evidence. The only remedy is a discretionary sanction or an instruction by the judge to the jury that it ‘may consider whether one party intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence’ remedies that are rarely employed by the judiciary.”
In support, the California School Employees Association (CSEA) writes:
AB 859 changes the current standard of proof for elder abuse from “clear and convincing” to “preponderance of the evidence” when nursing homes intentionally destroy evidence. This change in the standard of proof will discourage nursing homes from destroying evidence and provides needed protection to our vulnerable seniors who live in their care.
- Opposition Arguments
The Author agreed to accept amendments on the Assembly Floor that are reflected in the current version of this bill. Opposition to this bill requests one further amendment that would result in a court being able to decide whether the preponderance of an evidence standard would apply when the other requirements provided for by this bill have been met. In other words, the requested amendment would allow the court to determine whether or not the standard of proof should be lowered, instead of requiring the standard to be lowered.
In opposition, the California Assisted Living Association, the California Association of Health Facilities, the American Insurance Association, LeadingAge California, the California Chamber of Commerce, the Civil Justice Association of California, the Cooperative of American Physicians, the Doctors Company, the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, the California Dental Association, and the California Association of Physician Groups writes:
While we appreciate the author’s June 15th amendments, we are still opposed to any premise that takes away discretion from the judge in dealing with these various motions. AB 859 automatically lowers, without any judge’s discretion, the current evidentiary standard for obtaining enhanced remedies available under EADACPA from “clear and convincing” to a lower “preponderance of the evidence” standard. This would have a devastating impact on the health care community.
Virtually every personal injury lawsuit involving a health care profession and/or a health facility to an elder includes a filing under professional negligence/medical malpractice and under EADACPA – it is not uncommon to have a filing under EADACPA because of tactical purposes by the plaintiff attorney. By filing a claim for relief under the Act, plaintiff’s attorneys attempt to circumvent the limits on non-economic damages and attorney’s fees under the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA). This bill would add new incentives and tactics for attorneys to include claims of elder abuse in every complaint and pursue numerous spoliation motions in order to skirt MICRA, and secure attorney fees, costs and uncapped punitive damages. Even though the sponsor and author carved out two of the numerous associations who are affected by MICRA, this bill remains a MICRA issue, as it has been since introduction. Associations and companies opposed to this bill understand the important protections and directly feel the impact on any end run around MICRA.
The Elder Abuse Act defines neglect as “The negligent failure of any person having the care or custody of an elder or dependent adult to exercise that degree of care that a reasonable person in a like position would exercise.” Only where such neglect is proven by clear and convincing evidence, and the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice in the commission of the neglect, the plaintiff may recover attorney’s fees and costs, and other heightened remedies unlike unlimited punitive damages. Other civil causes of actions that have the same clear and convincing evidentiary standard of proof include claims of fraud, cases of wills and inheritances, and cases involving certain family matters. If the standard is lowered as suggested by AB 859, acts of mere negligence would qualify for enhanced remedies, fees and unlimited punitive damages; thereby increasing the risk of litigation, dodging existing rules governing medical professional liability disputes and exacerbating the shortage of homes, health facilities, doctors, nurses and other medical professionals willing to treat this growing elderly population.
Under current law, our coalition members readily experience plaintiff attorneys who characterize alleged professional negligence among healthcare providers treating elderly or dependent adults as “neglect” under the EADACPA in order to qualify for the enhanced remedies available under this statute. Lowering the evidence standard as suggested in AB 859 will further encourage this practice, thereby weakening the MICRA protections and other caps for healthcare providers and assisted living facilities serving this population. AB 859 will lead to higher litigation costs and increased liability insurance, at the expense of the Medi-Cal program and residents, only to put more money in plaintiff attorneys’ pockets.
While this coalition can further provide options and explore proper remedies for the aggrieved party and justified penalties against the plaintiff or defendant who destroyed or tampered with the evidence, it is imperative that the judge has discretion on a motion-by-motion, case-by-case basis.
This Committee has not been provided with information regarding how judicial discretion would prevent the alleged weakening of MICRA protections and other caps for health care providers and assisted living facilities. The CAOC provides the following response:
AB 859 amends the Elder and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA or Elder Abuse Act) which is found in the Welfare and Institutions Code § 15600 et seq. These actions are typically brought against a nursing facility or RCFE.
On the other hand, actions for medical negligence are brought against a healthcare provider (like a physician or hospital). MICRA, which limits a patient’s damages for pain and suffering to $250,000, is found in the Civil Code (§ 3333.4) and specifically applies to medical negligence actions against a “health care provider.”
“Medical malpractice” or “professional negligence” is defined as simple, ordinary negligence by a healthcare provider in the rendition of medical services. (See Code Civ. Proc. §340.5, Civil Code §§3333.1, 3333.2.) A medical professional is negligent if she fails to use the level of skill, knowledge, and care in diagnosis and treatment that other reasonably careful [insert type of medical practitioners] would use in the same or similar circumstances. This level of skill, knowledge, and care is sometimes referred to as “the standard of care.” CACI No. 501 (2017).
In contrast, elder abuse is a separate and distinct tort applicable where a particularly vulnerable portion of the population has been subject to gross mistreatment in the form of physical abuse or custodial neglect that involves “more than inadvertence, incompetence, unskillfulness, or a failure to take precautions.” (Delaney v. Baker (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 23, 31-33.)
If an elder is subjected to such acts of egregious abuse or neglect by a healthcare provider that are proven to be reckless or done with oppression, fraud or malice by clear and convincing evidence, i.e., acts or omissions performed with some state of culpability greater than mere negligence, then such conduct is not considered medical malpractice or professional negligence – it is considered elder abuse within the scope of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act. (Id. at 35.)
If the elder can prove by clear and convincing evidence that a healthcare provider is liable for physical abuse or neglect and that the provider has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse/neglect, only then may the elder recover enhanced remedies in the form of attorney fees and costs and pre-death pain and suffering (capped at $250,000) in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law. (See Cal. Welf. & Inst. Code § 15657.)
Notably, however, if the elder is seeking these enhanced remedies against an employer, then the elder must also prove by clear and convincing evidence that either the abuse or neglect was committed by an officer, director or managing agent of the employer, that an officer, director or managing agent of the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee who committed the acts and employed that person with a knowing disregard of the rights or safety of others, that an officer, director or managing agent authorized the conduct of the employee, or that an officer, director or managing agent knew of the wrongful conduct of the employee and adopted or approved the conduct after it occurred.
By definition, these are two mutually exclusive theories under which a person can be sued, and do not simply go hand-in-hand, as the opponents suggest.
Support: AARP; California Retired Teachers Association; California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO; Disability Rights California
Opposition: American Insurance Association; California Assisted Living Association; California Association of Health Facilities; California Association of Physician Groups; California Chamber of Commerce; California Chapter of American College of Emergency Physicians; California Dental Association; Civil Justice Association of California; Cooperative of American Physicians; Doctors Company; LeadingAge California; National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
HISTORY
Source: Consumer Attorneys of California; California Alliance for Retired Americans; Congress of California Seniors
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SB 558 (Simitian, 2011) See Background.
AB 2611 (Simitian, Ch. 886, Stats. 2004) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 43, Noes 17)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 4)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 1)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 859
Author:(Eggman)
As Amended Ver:
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-1 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Kiley |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, McCarty, Quirk, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Muratsuchi, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: If a defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed relevant evidence, changes the standard of proof required for an action for abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult, from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence. Specifically, this bill:
- Changes the standard of proof required in elder or dependent adult physical abuse or neglect cases brought under Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) from clear and convincing to a preponderance of the evidence for actions brought against assisted living or skilled nursing facilities if, with respect to evidence relevant to the claim:
- The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of the evidence by the defendant; or
- A judge or arbitrator determines at any time during the litigation or arbitration that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
- Defines "spoliation" as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced.
- Specifically exempts from the bill any facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
- Specifically provides that this bill does not modify the standard of evidence for seeking a protective order to protect an elder or dependent adult from abuse, as provided.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15600 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
- Provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. Requires, in order to receive any damages or attorney's fees against an employer, the standards set forth in 3), below, must be satisfied. (Section 15657)
- Requires a plaintiff, in order to receive punitive damages against an employer for the acts of an employee, to make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with a conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Civil Code Section 3294)
- Provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as specified. (Section 15657.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the fiscal effect of this bill is unknown, but potentially non-trivial, as it could lead to slightly higher Medi-Cal reimbursement rates to skilled nursing facilities (SNFs).
The change in evidentiary standards could result in additional convictions, which could result in increased liability and legal costs to certain SNFs. These costs would be captured in the individual cost reports the Department of Health Care Services uses to calculate facility-specific Medi-Cal reimbursement rates. Professional liability insurance (PLI) costs for providers are reported as a separate line item, and feed directly into the rate.
Based on prior experience, facilities expect this bill to result in a 1% to 1.5% increase in reimbursed PLI on a base of approximately $65 million, which would translate to $650,000 to $975,000 (GF/federal). It is unclear whether costs would be that high, as it would depend on behavior of actors in the marketplace. But it cannot be ruled out that a new, lower evidentiary standard in cases where spoliation could be proved could increase liability and legal defense costs somewhat. Based on the current annual number of Medi-Cal bed-days in freestanding facilities (nearly 22 million), for every $0.01 increase, on average, in reimbursed daily PLI costs to these providers on a base of $2.99 per day, total Medi-Cal costs would increase by over $200,000 (50% GF/50% federal funds).
The bill is fairly narrowly crafted. It would apply a lower evidentiary standard in instances where spoliation of evidence, as defined, had occurred. This could have the following effects, all of which could put upward pressure on liability and legal defense costs:
- Deter spoliation of evidence needed to prove a case, which would presumably make cases easier to prove at a clear and convincing standard, increasing the likelihood of successful cases.
- Even in cases where spoliation cannot be proved, if spoliation is alleged, it could result in increased legal defense costs to defend against such motions.
- If spoliation is proved, it would lower the evidentiary standard to a preponderance of the evidence, increasing the likelihood of successful cases.
COMMENTS: Abuse of nursing home residents is nothing new. In 2002, the United States General Accounting Office (GAO) prepared a report on nursing home resident abuse. The GAO found that 30 percent of the 17,000 nursing homes in the United States were cited for deficiencies involving actual harm to the nursing home residents, or for placing the residents at risk of death or serious injury. (GAO, Nursing Homes: More Can Be Done to Protect Residents from Abuse, GAO-02-312 (March 1, 2002).) This report stated that "relatively few prosecutions result from allegations of physical and sexual abuse of nursing home residents because allegations of abuse were not always referred to local law enforcement or MFCUs [Medicaid Fraud Control Units]. When referrals were made, the referral often occurred days or weeks after the incident, compromising the integrity of any limited evidence might have still been available. Second, a lack of witnesses to instances of abuse made prosecutions difficult and convictions unlikely." (Ibid. at 17.)
In 1991, the Legislature enacted EADACPA in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder and dependent adult physical and financial abuse or neglect. (SB 679 (Mello), Chapter 774, Statutes of 1991.) At that time, the standard of proof necessary to establish a claim under EADACPA was set high through the use of the clear and convincing standard of proof. In 2005, the Legislature enacted AB 2611 (Simitian), Chapter 886, Statutes of 2004, which separated out the provisions for elder and dependent adult financial abuse and reduced the standard of proof necessary to establish financial elder abuse to the more typical civil preponderance of the evidence standard of proof. The evidentiary standard for proving physical abuse or neglect remained at the higher standard of clear and convincing evidence.
This bill seeks to better protect elder and dependent adults by making a relatively modest change to the evidentiary standard. According to the author, some nursing home defendants, who often hold all or most of the evidence necessary to prove the claim of elder abuse, are purposefully destroying evidence and thereby making the victim's case that much harder to prove. This bill does not lower the overall evidentiary standard. Rather, it only seeks to lower the standard of proof from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence when the court determines that the defendant intentionally destroyed or concealed evidence relevant to the claim. Further limiting the reach of this bill, it only applies to claims brought against assisted living and skilled nursing facilities. It does not, by its own terms, apply to hospitals and facilities owned by hospitals.
Current Law Allows a Defendant to Intentionally Destroy Evidence With Potentially Limited Consequences: As specifically defined by this bill, spoliation is the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent to prevent the evidence from being produced. The California Supreme Court, in deciding not to create a separate tort for spoliation, did nonetheless find that it causes significant harm:
No one doubts that the intentional destruction of evidence should be condemned. Destroying evidence can destroy fairness and justice, for it increases the risk of an erroneous decision on the merits of the underlying cause of action. Destroying evidence can also increase the costs of litigation as parties attempt to reconstruct the destroyed evidence or to develop other evidence, which may be less accessible, less persuasive, or both. (Cedars-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior Court (1998) 18 Cal.4th 1, 10.)
Under California law today, a defendant who intentionally destroys evidence needed to prove a plaintiff's case may not necessarily face significant consequences. A judge can, should the judge so choose, issue discovery sanctions and sanction a party who "misuses the discovery process," which includes making an evasive response to discovery, or failing to respond to a discovery request, and order the party to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, or holding the party in contempt of court (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2023.010 et seq.). However, these remedies are discretionary and the existing burden of proof still requires the plaintiff to prove her case with the higher evidentiary threshold of clear and convincing evidence.
Spoliation Narrowly Defined in the Bill: This bill limits – in three ways – how spoliation can be used to reduce the evidentiary burden in an elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect case. First, the bill defines spoliation narrowly as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced. The reduced evidentiary standard does not apply if evidence is inadvertently or negligently destroyed. The defendant must intentionally destroy or conceal the evidence. Second, the evidence that has been intentionally concealed or destroyed must be relevant to the claim. Finally, it is not enough for the plaintiff to allege that key evidence was intentionally concealed or destroyed, the court must find that the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation or a judge or arbitrator must determine that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
This Bill Does Not in Any Way Change MICRA: Enacted in 1975 and not updated for inflation since then, the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) established a $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages that may be awarded to an injured plaintiff in a medical malpractice case and a limit on attorney's fees.
Elder and dependent adult abuse under the Welfare & Institutions Code is distinct from medical malpractice. (See Covenant Care v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771, 785; Smith v. Ben Bennett, Inc. (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 1507, 1519-20.) Medical malpractice, or professional negligence, is defined as a negligent act or omission of a healthcare provider in the rendering of professional services. (See Civil Code Sections 3333.1 and 3333.2 and Code of Civil Procedure Section 340.5.) Elder abuse is a separate tort claim brought to protect elderly and dependent adults from physical abuse or neglect. Elder abuse involves significantly more than mere negligence, rather it must involve recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice. "Recklessness, unlike negligence, involves more than 'inadvertence, incompetence, unskillfulness, or a failure to take precautions' but rather rises to the level of a 'conscious choice of a course of action . . . with knowledge of the serious danger to others involved in it.'" (Delaney v. Baker (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 23, 32-33 (citation omitted).) If an elder or dependent adult is abused or neglected by a healthcare provider and such bad acts are proved, by clear and convincing evidence, to be reckless or done with oppression, fraud, or malice, then such conduct is not considered medical malpractice or professional negligence. It is considered elder abuse within EADACPA. (Ibid. at 35.)
If it is established, by clear and convincing evidence, that a healthcare provider has physically abused or neglected an elder or dependent adult and that the provider has done so with recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice, then the plaintiff can recover EADACPA's heightened remedies, which include attorney fees and costs and pre-death pain and suffering, the latter of which is capped at $250,000. (See Welfare & Institutions Code 15657.) If the elder or dependent adult is seeking these remedies against an employer, then he or she must also prove, again by clear and convincing evidence, that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee who committed the acts and employed that person with a knowing disregard of the rights or safety of others, or the employer authorized the conduct of the employee, or knew of the wrongful conduct and approved the conduct after it occurred. (Ibid.; Civil Code Section 3294(b).) By contrast this bill simply allows for the enhanced remedies under the lower preponderance standard only if the defendant has willfully destroyed or withheld the evidence needed to prove the case. The plaintiff will still need to prove recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice and, if an employer is involved, the employer's culpability.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000619
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 859
Author:(Eggman) – As Amended Ver:April 27, 2017
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 8 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill, if a defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed relevant evidence, changes the standard of proof required for an action for abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult, from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The fiscal effect of this bill is unknown, but potentially non-trivial, as it could lead to slightly higher Medi-Cal reimbursement rates to skilled nursing facilities (SNFs).
The change in evidentiary standards could result in additional convictions, which could result in increased liability and legal costs to certain SNFs. These costs would be captured in the individual cost reports the Department of Health Care Services uses to calculate facility-specific Medi-Cal reimbursement rates. Professional liability insurance (PLI) costs for providers are reported as a separate line item, and feed directly into the rate.
Based on prior experience, facilities expect this bill to result in a 1% to 1.5% increase in reimbursed PLI on a base of approximately $65 million, which would translate to $650,000 to $975,000 (GF/federal). It is unclear whether costs would be that high, as it would depend on behavior of actors in the marketplace. But it cannot be ruled out that a new, lower evidentiary standard in cases where spoliation could be proved could increase liability and legal defense costs somewhat. Based on the current annual number of Medi-Cal bed-days in freestanding facilities (nearly 22 million), for every one cent increase, on average, in reimbursed daily PLI costs to these providers on a base of $2.99 per day, total Medi-Cal costs would increase by over $200,000 (50% GF/50% federal funds).
The bill is fairly narrowly crafted. It would apply a lower evidentiary standard in instances where spoliation of evidence, as defined, had occurred. This could have the following effects, all of which could put upward pressure on liability and legal defense costs:
- Deter spoliation of evidence needed to prove a case, which would presumably make cases easier to prove at a clear and convincing standard, increasing the likelihood of successful cases.
- Even in cases where spoliation cannot be proved, if spoliation is alleged, it could result in increased legal defense costs to defend against such motions.
- If spoliation is proved, it would lower the evidentiary standard to a preponderance of the evidence, increasing the likelihood of successful cases.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, the state should not require a victim to prove an elder abuse case at a clear and convincing standard when a defendant facility itself destroys the evidence necessary to prove the case.
- Background. In 1991, the Legislature enacted Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder and dependent adult physical and financial abuse or neglect. The standard has since been relaxed for financial abuse cases, and the clear and convincing evidentiary standard for proving physical abuse or neglect is higher than the preponderance of the evidence standard used in most civil cases. The EADACPA provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court must award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000.
- Support. Supporters believe that the clear and convincing standard creates an unnecessarily high hurdle when the defendant has intentionally destroyed evidence necessary to prove the case, particularly for elderly and dependent adults who, due to their disabilities, may not be able to verbalize adequately what happened to them in order to satisfy the clear and convincing standard. Co-sponsors include the California Alliance for Retired Americas, Congress of California Seniors, and the Consumer Attorneys of California. Nurses, consumer advocates, and other advocates for the elderly and disabled also support this bill.
- Opposition. Opponents, including the California Association of Health Facilities, the Civil Justice Association of California, and the California Chamber of Commerce, as well as insurers and long-term care providers argue that this bill will have a devastating impact on the healthcare community. They argue this bill is an attempt to circumvent the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA), which limits awards for non-economic damages. Opponents believe that this bill will increase litigation, and increase costs for the Medi-Cal program. The Civil Justice Association of California adds that lowering the standard of proof in these cases will lead to an unnecessary increase in litigation and will ultimately reduce services for the elderly.
- Related Legislation. SB 558 (Simitian) of 2011, a broader bill than the current one, would have changed the evidentiary standard for elder abuse to a preponderance of the evidence for elder abuse and neglect under EADACPA. SB 558 was held on this Committee's Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 2, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 859
Author:(Eggman) – As Amended Ver:April 27, 2017
SUBJECT: Elder and dependent adult ABUSE OR NEGLECT: STANDARD OF PROOF when defendAnt WILLFULLY destroys or CONCEALS evidence
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO BETTER PROTECT VULNERABLE ELDERS AND DEPENDENT ADULTS FROM ABUSE AND NEGLECT, WHERE THE DEFENDANT INTENTIONALLY CONCEALS OR DESTROYS EVIDENCE, SHOULD THE STANDARD OF PROOF NECESSARY FOR A CASE INVOLVING ELDER OR DEPENDENT ADULT ABUSE BE REDUCED FROM THE HEIGHTENED CLEAR AND CONVINCING STANDARD TO THE MORE TYPICAL PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE STANDARD?
SYNOPSIS
This bill, sponsored by the California Alliance for Retired Americans, Congress of California Seniors, and Consumer Attorneys of California, seeks to ensure that defendants in elder and dependent abuse and neglect cases brought under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) are not able to avoid liability by intentionally destroying or concealing evidence that is critical to the plaintiff's case. This bill does so by changing the heightened evidentiary standard of proof needed for EADACPA abuse and neglect cases from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence in those cases where a court or an arbitrator has determined that a defendant has intentionally destroyed or concealed evidence relevant to the claim.
Supporters include California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform, California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association, California Nurses Association/National Nurses United, Consumer Federation of California, and Disability Rights California. They believe that the clear and convincing standard creates an unnecessarily high hurdle when the defendant has intentionally destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case, particularly for elderly and dependent adults who, due to their disabilities, may not be able to adequately verbalize what happened to them in order to satisfy the clear and convincing standard.
Opponents include the California Association of Health Facilities, the Civil Justice Association of California, and the California Chamber of Commerce, as well as insurers and long-term care providers. They argue that this bill will only increase litigation and costs for patients and the state, and will result in an end run around the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA). However, as discussed in the analysis, this bill does not change the MICRA professional negligence law. To receive the enhanced remedies under an EADACPA abuse or neglect case, a plaintiff will still be required to prove that a health care provider is liable for physical abuse or neglect and that the provider has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of that abuse or neglect. As a result of recent amendments, the California Medical Association is now neutral on the bill.
SUMMARY: If a defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed relevant evidence, changes the standard of proof required for an action for abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult, from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence. Specifically, this bill:
- Changes the standard of proof required in elder or dependent adult physical abuse or neglect cases brought under Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA) from clear and convincing to a preponderance of the evidence for actions brought against assisted living or skilled nursing facilities if, with respect to evidence relevant to the claim:
- The plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation of the evidence by the defendant; or
- A judge or arbitrator determines at any time during the litigation or arbitration that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
- Defines "spoliation" as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced.
- Specifically exempts from the bill any facility owned or operated by a general acute care hospital, including beds separately housed from that facility, as provided, an acute psychiatric hospital, or a special hospital, all as defined.
- Specifically provides that this bill does not modify the standard of evidence for seeking a protective order to protect an elder or dependent adult from abuse, as provided.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), civil protections and remedies for victims of elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15600 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
- Provides that where physical abuse or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is proven by clear and convincing evidence and the defendant has been found guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, in addition to all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified, and damages for pre-death pain and suffering up to $250,000. Requires, in order to receive any damages or attorney’s fees against an employer, the standards set forth in 3), below, must be satisfied. (Section 15657.)
- Requires a plaintiff, in order to receive punitive damages against an employer for the acts of an employee, to make a showing of clear and convincing evidence that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee and employed him or her with a conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others or authorized or ratified the wrongful conduct for which the damages are awarded or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice. (Civil Code Section 3294.)
- Provides that where financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is proven by a preponderance of the evidence, in addition to compensatory damages and all other remedies otherwise provided by law, the court shall order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. (Section 15657.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Abuse of nursing home residents is nothing new. In 2002, the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) prepared a report on nursing home resident abuse. The GAO found that 30 percent of the 17,000 nursing homes in the United States were cited for deficiencies involving actual harm to the nursing home residents, or for placing the residents at risk of death or serious injury. (GAO, Nursing Homes: More Can Be Done to Protect Residents from Abuse, GAO-02-312 (March 1, 2002).) This report stated that “relatively few prosecutions result from allegations of physical and sexual abuse of nursing home residents because allegations of abuse were not always referred to local law enforcement or MFCUs [Medicaid Fraud Control Units]. When referrals were made, the referral often occurred days or weeks after the incident, compromising the integrity of any limited evidence might have still been available. Second, a lack of witnesses to instances of abuse made prosecutions difficult and convictions unlikely.” (Ibid. at 17.)
In 1991, the Legislature enacted EADACPA in order to provide enhanced remedies to ensure adequate representation of victims in cases of elder and dependent adult physical and financial abuse or neglect. (SB 679 (Mello), Chap. 774, Stats. 1991.) At that time, the standard of proof necessary to establish a claim under EADACPA was set high through the use of the clear and convincing standard of proof. In 2005, the Legislature enacted AB 2611 (Simitian), Chap. 886, Stats. 2004, which separated out the provisions for elder and dependent adult financial abuse and reduced the standard of proof necessary to establish financial elder abuse to the more typical civil preponderance of the evidence standard of proof. The evidentiary standard for proving physical abuse or neglect remained at the higher standard of clear and convincing evidence. In 2013, AB 558 (Simitian) sought to reduce the standard of proof for elder and dependent adult physical abuse and neglect civil cases from the clear and convincing standard to the more usual civil standard of preponderance of the evidence. That bill passed the Senate and this Committee, but was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
This bill seeks to better protect elder and dependent adults by making a relatively modest change to the evidentiary standard. According to the author, some nursing home defendants, who often hold all or most of the evidence necessary to prove the claim of elder abuse, are purposefully destroying evidence and thereby making the victim's case that much harder to prove. This bill does not lower the overall evidentiary standard. Rather, it only seeks to lower the standard of proof from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence when the court determines that the defendant intentionally destroyed or concealed evidence relevant to the claim. Further limiting the reach of this bill, it only applies to claims brought against assisted living and skilled nursing facilities. It does not, by its own terms, apply to hospitals and facilities owned by hospitals.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
Some nursing homes intentionally destroy evidence after an abused person files a civil suit. This is especially pernicious, given abuse must be proved at the higher standard
The intentional and willful destruction of evidence (legally known as “spoliation”) is illegal. In California, a party has a duty to preserve evidence at the point in which the party has been served with discovery demands after the civil suit has been filed. California law, however, is weak in its treatment of spoliation, and a party may not be sued under a separate cause of action for the intentional destruction of evidence. The only remedy is a discretionary sanction or an instruction by the judge to the jury that it “may consider whether one party intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence.”
We should not require the abused victim to prove the case at the higher clear-and-convincing standard when it was the defendant facility itself that destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case.
The California Legislature has the right and duty to modify the burden of proof to prevent wrongdoers from taking advantage of their own illegal conduct. AB 859 gives the elderly and their families a chance at justice after the intentional destruction of evidence.
In support of the bill, the author and sponsors provide examples of cases where facilities abused patients and then destroyed or withheld evidence that was needed in order to prove the cases against the facilities. In one example, Billie Underwood, a former minister placed in a skilled nursing center in Stockton, died after the facility failed to change the bandages for an injury to her hand and tissue actually grew around the bandages. The facility records stated that the wound was cleaned and the bandages were changed every day and that Ms. Underwood received sufficient fluid. A judge in that case later determined that the nursing home had falsified its records. A second example involved Ms. Fitzpatrick, a 90-year-old patient with dementia who died after escaping through an alarmed door and then falling while outside. Apparently, despite the alarm that went off when Ms. Fitzpatrick opened the outside door, no one looked for her as she crawled around on the ground with fractured face bones and a subdural hematoma for 45 minutes. According to the sponsors, the facility tried to hide the circumstances of her death, destroying a video and written records that would have demonstrated the facility's actual response to the alarm, as well as records of prior problems involving residents escaping the facility and a letter from a former employee indicating he had been fired for refusing to cover-up the incident. No individual or facility should be able to avoid civil liability by covering up incidents of abuse or neglect to elder or dependent adults.
The California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association represents ombudsmen statewide who are in assisted living facilities and nursing homes across the state every day, helping and protecting residents of these facilities. Other than the residents themselves or their families and friends, the ombudsmen have the most direct knowledge of abuse and neglect occurring in these facilities, as well as possible efforts by the facilities to falsify or withhold evidence. In support of the bill, the Association writes that it hears "from local Ombudsman about the difficulties they face when trying to substantiate a complaint made by a resident.” They provide examples, such as when the ombudsman uncovers that a facility has falsified medical records, made after-the-fact amendment to care plans, and had inconsistencies in special incident reports, and go on to say, “Ombudsman representatives meet with families who shared stories of great hardship of both physical and emotional stress associated with taking a licensed long-term care facility to court only to be faced with falsified chart records.”
High Evidentiary Standard Required for Proof for Elder and Dependent Adult Physical Abuse and Neglect Cases: A standard of proof is a threshold level of amount and the reliability of evidence that must be met in order for a fact to be considered proven. There are three general evidentiary standards of proof – the highest beyond a reasonable doubt standard that is used in criminal cases; the preponderance of the evidence standard; and the clear and convincing standard. The preponderance of the evidence standard of proof is used in most civil cases. To satisfy the preponderance standard, a party must provide evidence showing that the existence of a fact at issue is more likely true than not. The clear and convincing standard of proof requires a party to prove that the fact is highly probable to be true. This bill lowers the standard of proof in civil elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect cases where the court has determined that the defendant has intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence needed to prove the case from the plaintiff from clear and convincing to preponderance of the evidence.
Current law, under EADACPA, requires an elderly or disabled victim of financial abuse to prove that case by a preponderance of the evidence, while a victim of elder or dependent adult abuse or neglect must prove her case by clear and convincing evidence, or that it is highly probable, that the defendant’s conduct caused harm to the victim. This standard of proof can be particularly difficult to prove in elder and dependent adult abuse cases because these elderly, ill, or disabled victims may be unable to testify about the specific facts of the abuse or neglect they suffered. In some cases, they may already be deceased by the time the case is filed on their behalf.
It is important to note that although this bill lowers the evidentiary standard of proof where a defendant intentionally conceals or withholds relevant evidence, EADACPA would still require that for an elder or dependent adult to be successful in court, he or she must prove that the physical abuse or neglect was the result of recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice, on the part of the defendant.
Current Law Allows a Defendant to Intentionally Destroy Evidence With Potentially Limited Consequences: As specifically defined by this bill, spoliation is the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent to prevent the evidence from being produced. The California Supreme Court, in deciding not to create a separate tort for spoliation, did nonetheless find that it causes significant harm:
No one doubts that the intentional destruction of evidence should be condemned. Destroying evidence can destroy fairness and justice, for it increases the risk of an erroneous decision on the merits of the underlying cause of action. Destroying evidence can also increase the costs of litigation as parties attempt to reconstruct the destroyed evidence or to develop other evidence, which may be less accessible, less persuasive, or both. (Cedars-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior Court (1998) 18 Cal.4th 1, 10.)
Under California law today, a defendant who intentionally destroys evidence needed to prove a plaintiff's case may not necessarily face significant consequences. A judge can, should the judge so choose, issue discovery sanctions and sanction a party who "misuses the discovery process," which includes making an evasive response to discovery, or failing to respond to a discovery request, and order the party to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, or holding the party in contempt of court (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2023.010 et seq.). However, these remedies are discretionary and the existing burden of proof still requires the plaintiff to prove her case with the higher evidentiary threshold of clear and convincing evidence. A judge could decide, as a discretionary discovery sanction, to render a default judgment against the defendant, although there is no evidence that such an outcome has ever occurred. Similarly, while Penal Code Section 135 makes it a misdemeanor to conceal or destroy evidence, it is unlikely that a district attorney would bring such a case against a nursing home, except perhaps in the most egregious case. Even then, that would not provide an injured elder or dependent adult with any recompense for their damages. Additionally a court could direct a jury to draw adverse evidentiary inferences, but that could potentially have minimal impact if the standard of proof is clear and convincing evidence, and again that possible remedy is discretionary.
Unfortunately, as Consumer Attorneys of California, one of the bill's sponsors, notes, "sanctions based on spoliation are rarely issued against bad actors and our members report that even in clear cases of spoliation, the court does not order sanctions."
Spoliation Narrowly Defined in the Bill: This bill limits—in three ways—how spoliation can be used to reduce the evidentiary burden in an elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect case. First, the bill defines spoliation narrowly as the intentional concealment or destruction of evidence by a party with the intent of preventing the evidence from being produced. The reduced evidentiary standard does not apply if evidence is inadvertently or negligently destroyed. The defendant must intentionally destroy or conceal the evidence. Second, the evidence that has been intentionally concealed or destroyed must be relevant to the claim. Finally, it is not enough for the plaintiff to allege that key evidence was intentionally concealed or destroyed, the court must find that the plaintiff prevails on a discovery motion due to spoliation or a judge or arbitrator must determine that the defendant committed spoliation of the evidence.
Opponents Argue That This Bill is an End Run Around MICRA, But This Bill Does Not in Any Way Change MICRA: Enacted in 1975 and not updated for inflation since then, the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) established a $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages that may be awarded to an injured plaintiff in a medical malpractice case and a limit on attorney’s fees. Opponents, including Californians Allied for Patient Protection (CAPP) argue that lowering the standard of proof in cases involving spoliation would allow plaintiffs to circumvent MICRA limits on attorney fees and damages for pain and suffering:
While we do not condone improper destruction of evidence or unjust discovery practices by any party, we believe that lowering the standard of proof for any [EADACPA] case further enhances a law that is already being used to get around the MICRA protections.
Under current law, our coalition members are already seeing plaintiff attorneys characterize professional negligence or malpractice among healthcare providers treating elderly or dependent adults as "neglect" under EADACPA in order to qualify for the enhanced remedies available under this statute. Lowering the evidence standard as suggested in AB 859 is likely to further encourage this practice, thereby weakening the MICRA protections for healthcare providers serving this population.
Elder and dependent adult abuse under the Welfare & Institutions Code is distinct from medical malpractice. (See Covenant Care v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771, 785; Smith v. Ben Bennett, Inc. (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 1507, 1519-20.) Medical malpractice, or professional negligence, is defined as a negligent act or omission of a healthcare provider in the rendering of professional services. (See Civil Code Sections 3333.1 and 3333.2 and Code of Civil Procedure Section 340.5.) Elder abuse is a separate tort claim brought to protect elderly and dependent adults from physical abuse or neglect. Elder abuse involves significantly more than mere negligence, rather it must involve recklessness, oppression, fraud or malice. "Recklessness, unlike negligence, involves more than 'inadvertence, incompetence, unskillfulness, or a failure to take precautions' but rather rises to the level of a 'conscious choice of a course of action . . . with knowledge of the serious danger to others involved in it.'" (Delaney v. Baker (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 23, 32-33 (citation omitted).) If an elder or dependent adult is abused or neglected by a healthcare provider and such bad acts are proved, by clear and convincing evidence, to be reckless or done with oppression, fraud, or malice, then such conduct is not considered medical malpractice or professional negligence. It is considered elder abuse within EADACPA. (Ibid. at 35.)
If it is established, by clear and convincing evidence, that a healthcare provider has physically abused or neglected an elder or dependent adult and that the provider has done so with recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice, then the plaintiff can recover EADACPA's heightened remedies, which include attorney fees and costs and pre-death pain and suffering, the latter of which is capped at $250,000. (See Welfare & Institutions Code 15657.) If the elder or dependent adult is seeking these remedies against an employer, then he or she must also prove, again by clear and convincing evidence, that the employer had advance knowledge of the unfitness of the employee who committed the acts and employed that person with a knowing disregard of the rights or safety of others, or the employer authorized the conduct of the employee, or knew of the wrongful conduct and approved the conduct after it occurred. (Ibid.; Civil Code Section 3294 (b).) By contrast this bill simply allows for the enhanced remedies under the lower preponderance standard only if the defendant has willfully destroyed or withheld the evidence needed to prove the case. The plaintiff will still need to prove recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice and, if an employer is involved, the employer's culpability.
It is worth noting that as a result of recent amendments to the bill, the California Medical Association, one of the most ardent supporters of MICRA, has removed its opposition and is now neutral on the bill.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters believe that the clear and convincing standard creates an unnecessarily high hurdle when the defendant has intentionally destroyed the evidence necessary to prove the case, particularly for elderly and dependent adults who, due to their disabilities, may not be able to verbalize adequately what happened to them in order to satisfy the clear and convincing standard. WISE & Healthy Aging Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program (LTC Ombudsman), the long-term care ombudsman in Los Angeles writes:
With the failure of the regulatory enforcement system to adequately enforce and protect residents in nursing homes the necessity for strong civil legal protections is crucial. Law enforcement often tells residents that the abuse they are suffering is a civil matter, further supporting the case for strong civil legal protections. . . . The LTC Ombudsman have seen firsthand willful material falsification of records at the hands of nursing home staff trying to protect their interest.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents, including the California Association of Health Facilities, the Civil Justice Association of California, and the California Chamber of Commerce, as well as insurers and long-term care providers argue that this bill will have "a devastating impact on the healthcare community." In addition to the argument that this bill is an attempt to circumvent MICRA, discussed in detail above, opponents believe that this bill will increase litigation, and as "litigation increases, the cost of these services will inevitably be higher for consumers and have a direct fiscal impact on the strained State of California, Medi-Cal program." The Civil Justice Association of California succinctly adds that "lowering the standard of proof in these cases will lead to an unnecessary increase in litigation and will ultimately reduce services for the elderly."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Alliance for Retired Americas (co-sponsor)
Congress of California Seniors (co-sponsor)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-sponsor)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Nurses Association/National Nurses United
California Retired Teachers Association
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
Coalition for Elder & DisAbility Rights
Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations
Consumer Federation of California
Disability Rights California
Institute on Aging's Elder Abuse Prevention Program
WISE & Healthy Aging Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program
Opposition
American Insurance Association
Association of California Healthcare Districts (unless amended)
California Assisted Living Association
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Physician Groups
California Chamber of Commerce
Californians Allied for Patient Protection
CDA Foundation
Civil Justice Association of California
Cooperative of American Physicians
Leading Age California
The Doctors Company
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):