AB 889: Secrecy agreements.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-01-29
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential; however, existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law also establishes that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney, and it requires the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in any case brought to its attention.
This bill would instead authorize but not require the State Bar to investigate these cases of attorney misconduct. This bill would also provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except that a court or arbitral tribunal may order information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or a trade secret be kept secret in narrow circumstances. The bill would similarly establish that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential; however, existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law also establishes that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney, and it requires the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in any case brought to its attention.
This bill would instead authorize but not require the State Bar to investigate these cases of attorney misconduct. This bill would also provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon specified findings. This bill would permit persons to contest in court a confidentiality provision in a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this prohibition. that a court or arbitral tribunal may order information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or a trade secret be kept secret in narrow circumstances. The bill would similarly establish that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential; however, existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law also establishes that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney, and it requires the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in any case brought to its attention.
This bill would instead authorize but not require the State Bar to investigate these cases of attorney misconduct. This bill would also provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon independent findings, as specified, and specified findings. This bill would permit affected persons to contest in court a confidentiality provision in a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this prohibition. The bill would similarly establish that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential; however, existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law also establishes that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney, and it requires the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in any case brought to its attention.
This bill would instead authorize but not require the State Bar to investigate these cases of attorney misconduct. This bill would also provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon independent findings, as specified, and it would permit affected persons to contest in court a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this prohibition. The bill would similarly establish that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law also generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential. confidential; however, existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law also establishes that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney, and it requires the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in any case brought to its attention.
This bill would instead authorize but not require the State Bar to investigate these cases of attorney misconduct. This bill would also provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon independent findings, as specified. This bill would also specified, and it would permit affected persons to contest in court a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this prohibition. The bill would similarly establish that flouting this prohibition is grounds for professional discipline for an attorney.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law also generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a prevision provision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential.
This bill would provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon independent findings, as specified. This bill would also permit affected persons to contest in court a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this prohibition.
Existing law specifies that certain types of confidential or privileged information shall not be introduced as evidence in a court action. Existing law also generally permits the parties to a civil action to include, as a condition to a settlement, a prevision requiring that information about the settlement or the underlying dispute be kept confidential.
This bill would provide that in an action based upon the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, as defined, information relating to the danger that was discovered during the course of litigation shall not be kept secret pursuant to an agreement of the parties or a court order, except pursuant to a court order based upon independent findings, as specified.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as amended by Section 24 of Chapter 561 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:1002.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a defective product or environmental condition that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death to one or more persons.
(2)Protective order means an order issued by a judge that prevents the disclosure or dissemination of confidential information within documents that are obtained during discovery or in the course of litigation, including an order requiring a party to return documents to an opposing party at the end of the litigation.
(2)(3)Trade secret means a partys proprietary information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process. Trade secret does not mean information or records that concern a defective, hazardous, or obsolete product or environmental condition or that are unlikely to be used to a competitors economic advantage. has the same meaning as set forth in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of fact action for civil damages regarding a defective product or environmental condition that poses a danger to public health or safety.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to a civil action described in this sectionsubdivision (b) or (c) shall not be restricted, and a court or arbitral tribunal shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an a protective order that restricts the disclosure of information described in this section, those subdivisions, except as provided in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e). This subdivision does not prevent a court from issuing a protective order if the documents or information sought to be covered by the order include trade secrets or proprietary information.
(e)(1)Subdivisions (b) and (d) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of an offense listed in subdivision (b) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This paragraph shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(2)Subdivisions (c) and (d) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any of the following relating to a cause of action described in subdivision (c):
(A)Medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding a person injured by a defective product or environmental condition.
(B)The amount of a settlement.
(C)(i)Information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or a trade secret, if the party seeking to prevent its disclosure moves the court or arbitral tribunal for an order of nondisclosure and the order is granted pursuant to clause (ii). a protective order. The order shall be narrowly tailored and narrowly construed. A court is not obligated to review any documents that are subject to a requested protective order if the moving party attests, under penalty of perjury, that the documents do not contain evidence showing that the party responsible for the product or condition knows or should know that the product or condition is an ongoing danger to the public health or safety. If the party moving for a protective order does not attest to this fact, the court may refuse to issue the order or may hold a hearing requiring the moving party to show good cause as to why the protective order should be issued without the attestation.
(ii)A court or arbitral tribunal may grant an order of nondisclosure if the moving party demonstrates that the presumption in favor of disclosure is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest. The order shall be narrowly tailored to restrict no more information than necessary to protect the interest, and it shall be narrowly construed.(f)(1)A provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (b) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(2)A provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (c) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(g)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivisions (b) and (c) that is not otherwise authorized by this section as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as amended by Section 24 of Chapter 561 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:1002.(a)Notwithstanding As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a defective product or environmental condition that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death to one or more persons.
(2)Trade secret means a partys proprietary information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process. Trade secret does not mean information or records that concern a defective, hazardous, or obsolete product or environmental condition or that are unlikely to be used to a competitors economic advantage.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of fact for civil damages regarding a defective product or environmental condition that poses a danger to public health or safety.
(b)(d)Notwithstanding any other law, in there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), this section shall not be restricted, and a court or arbitral tribunal shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a). described in this section, except as provided in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e).
(c)(e)(1)Subdivisions (a) (b) and (b) (d) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the an offense listed in subdivision (a) (b) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision paragraph shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(2)Subdivisions (c) and (d) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any of the following relating to a cause of action described in subdivision (c):
(A)Medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding a person injured by a defective product or environmental condition.
(B)The amount of a settlement.
(C)(i)Information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or a trade secret, if the party seeking to prevent its disclosure moves the court or arbitral tribunal for an order of nondisclosure and the order is granted pursuant to clause (ii).
(ii)A court or arbitral tribunal may grant an order of nondisclosure if the moving party demonstrates that the presumption in favor of disclosure is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest. The order shall be narrowly tailored to restrict no more information than necessary to protect the interest, and it shall be narrowly construed.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a(f)(1)A provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) (b) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(2)A provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (c) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)(g)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) subdivisions (b) and (c) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) this section as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1002.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.SEC. 3.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a defective product or environmental hazard that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.(2)Defective product means a product that may be defective because of a defect in manufacturing, or design, or a failure to adequately warn the consumer of a hazard involved in the foreseeable use of the product, where the defect may result in bodily injury or death to one or more persons.(3)Environmental hazard means a release of a hazardous substance that poses a threat to public health or safety involving danger of death, bodily injury, or health disability to human beings exposed to hazardous substance release.(4)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.(5)Personally identifiable information includes the following:(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.(B)Personal contact information of corporate officers or board members, or information relating to any individuals finances, medical history, health, or similar information.(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information relating to that danger shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c). This subdivision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety caused by a defective product or environmental hazard, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to that danger shall not be restricted, and a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:(A)Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it finds that either of the following conditions is satisfied:(A)The pleadings do not state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety.(B)The presumption in favor of disclosure of the information is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records and the order does not restrict any more information than is necessary to protect that interest. A court shall not base this finding on the existence of a stipulation to keep the information secret.(3)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order. The proponent, in his or her request for the order, shall set forth with particularity the specific information for which protection is sought, the specific and overriding interest necessitating confidentiality, such as that the information relates to a current proprietary customer list, or that the information is a trade secret that would give the proponents competitors valuable proprietary information if revealed.(d)This section does not apply to or affect any of the following:(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.(3)A trade secret, as defined in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code. A trade secret does not include information or records about a product that is defective, hazardous, or unlikely to be used by a competitor to the proponents competitive disadvantage.(4)Personally identifiable information.(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that violates subdivision (b) may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. This section does not prevent an attorney for a party from requesting an order under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c).(f)This section does not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.(g)A person, including a representative of the news media, may bring an action to contest a confidentiality provision in a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:(1)The person makes a prima facie case that the order or settlement restricts information concerning a danger to public health or safety.(2)Public knowledge of the information will decrease the likelihood of harm caused by the danger to public health or safety.(3)The action contesting the confidentiality provision will not delay or prejudice the rights of the parties to the underlying action.It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1002.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
SEC. 3.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a defective product or environmental hazard that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
(2)Defective product means a product that may be defective because of a defect in manufacturing, or design, or a failure to adequately warn the consumer of a hazard involved in the foreseeable use of the product, where the defect may result in bodily injury or death to one or more persons.
(3)Environmental hazard means a release of a hazardous substance that poses a threat to public health or safety involving danger of death, bodily injury, or health disability to human beings exposed to hazardous substance release.
(4)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.
(5)Personally identifiable information includes the following:
(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.
(B)Personal contact information of corporate officers or board members, or information relating to any individuals finances, medical history, health, or similar information.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information relating to that danger shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c). This subdivision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following: safety caused by a defective product or environmental hazard, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to that danger shall not be restricted, and a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
(A)Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it first makes an independent finding either that the finds that either of the following conditions is satisfied:
(A)The order will not restrict the disclosure of information pleadings do not state facts relevant to the protection of existence of a danger to the public health or safety, or that all of the following criteria are met: safety.
(A)(B)The public interest in the disclosure of the information is The presumption in favor of disclosure of the information is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, such as state-of-the-art trade secrets or a current proprietary customer list, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. and the order does not restrict any more information than is necessary to protect that interest. A court shall not base this finding on the existence of a stipulation to keep the information secret.
(B)A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.(C)The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protect the specific and substantial overriding interest asserted, and the order is narrowly tailored to protect the secrecy only of that information for which an overriding specific and substantial overriding interest exist.(D)A less restrictive means to avoid the substantial prejudice to the specific and substantial overriding interest does not exist.(E)The information is to be kept secret no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.(3)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order. The proponent, in his or her request for the order, shall set forth with particularity the specific information for which protection is sought, the specific and overriding interest necessitating confidentiality, such as that the information relates to a current proprietary customer list, or that the information is a trade secret that would give the proponents competitors valuable proprietary information if revealed.
(d)This section does not apply to or affect any of the following:
(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.
(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.
(3)A trade secret, as defined in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code, that is not related to a danger to the public health or safety. Code. A trade secret does not include information or records about a product that is defective, hazardous, or unlikely to be used by a competitor to the proponents competitive disadvantage.
(4)Personally identifiable information.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that violates subdivision (b) may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. This section does not prevent an attorney for a party from requesting an order under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c).
(f)This section does not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
(g)An affected A person, including a representative of the news media, may bring an action to contest a confidentiality provision in a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed. filed, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The person makes a prima facie case that the order or settlement restricts information concerning a danger to public health or safety.
(2)Public knowledge of the information will decrease the likelihood of harm caused by the danger to public health or safety.
(3)The action contesting the confidentiality provision will not delay or prejudice the rights of the parties to the underlying action.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1002.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
SEC. 3.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a device, instrument, manufactured product, substance, defective product or environmental condition hazard that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
(2)Defective product means a product that may be defective because of a defect in manufacturing, or design, or a failure to adequately warn the consumer of a hazard involved in the foreseeable use of the product, where the defect may result in bodily injury or death to one or more persons.
(3)Environmental hazard means a release of a hazardous substance that poses a threat to public health or safety involving danger of death, bodily injury, or health disability to human beings exposed to hazardous substance release.
(2)(4)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.
(3)(5)Personally identifiable information includes the following:
(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.
(B)Personal contact information of corporate officers or board members, or information relating to an any individuals finances, medical history, health, or similar information.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action in which the pleadings allege state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information about a relating to that danger to the public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, tribunal unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c). This subdivision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action in which the pleadings allege state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following with respect to a danger to the public health or safety: following:
(A)Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it first makes an independent finding either that the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health or safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
(A)The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, such as state-of-the-art trade secrets or a current proprietary customer list, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. In applying this factor, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting an individuals personally identifiable information relating to financial, health, or other similar information outweighs the need for disclosure.
(B)A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
(C)The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protect the specific and substantial overriding interest asserted, and the order is narrowly tailored to protect the secrecy only of that information for which an overriding specific and substantial overriding interest exist.
(D)A less restrictive means to avoid the substantial prejudice to the specific and substantial overriding interest does not exist.
(E)The information is to be kept secret no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
(3)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) or (3) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order.
(d)This section does not apply to or affect any of the following:
(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.
(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.
(3)A trade secret, as defined in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code, that is not related to a danger to the public health or safety.
(4)Personally identifiable information.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in violates subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, (b) may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. This section does not prevent an attorney for a party from requesting an order under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c).
(f)This section does not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
(g)An affected person, including a representative of the news media, may bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1002.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Danger to the public health or safety means a device, instrument, manufactured product, substance, or environmental condition that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
(2)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.
(3)Personally identifiable information includes the following:
(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.
(B)Personal contact information of corporate officers or board members, or information relating to an individuals finances, medical history, health, or similar information.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information relating to about a danger to the public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c). This subdivision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following with respect to a danger to the public health or safety:
(A)Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it first makes an independent finding either that the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health or safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
(A)The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. In applying this factor, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting an individuals personally identifiable information relating to financial, health, or other similar information outweighs the need for disclosure.
(B)A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
(C)The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protect the specific and substantial overriding interest asserted, and the order is narrowly tailored to protect the secrecy only of that information for which an overriding specific and substantial overriding interest exist.
(D)A less restrictive means to avoid the substantial prejudice to the specific and substantial overriding interest does not exist.
(E)The information is to be kept secret no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
(3)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) or (3) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order.
(d)This section does not apply to or affect any of the following:
(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.
(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.
(3)A trade secret, as defined in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code, that is not related to a danger to the public health or safety.
(e)An attorney seeking the dismissal with prejudice of a settled action shall certify, at the time he or she seeks dismissal, that the settlement agreement is not void pursuant to subdivision (b).(f)The State Bar shall investigate allegations that an attorney advocated for, or advised a client to sign, a settlement agreement whose provisions are void pursuant to subdivision (b), and it may discipline an attorney for doing so.(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(g)(f)This section does not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
(h)(g)An affected person, including a representative of the news media, may bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products, products and environmental hazards, and individuals or entities that physically harm others, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bodily injury includes psychological trauma resulting from an act, or repetitive acts, of harm.(2)(1)Danger to the public health or safety means an instrumentality, including a device, instrument, substance, person, entity, procedure, or product, or a condition of a device, instrument, substance, person, entity, procedure, or product, a device, instrument, manufactured product, substance, or environmental condition that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
(3)(2)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.
(4)(3)Personally identifiable information includes the following:
(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.
(B)Confidential business information, such as the personal addresses of corporate officers or board members. Personal contact information of corporate officers or board members, or information relating to an individuals finances, medical history, health, or similar information.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings state facts relevant to allege the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information relating to a danger to the public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c). This subdivision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings state facts relevant to allege the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following with respect to a danger to the public health or safety:
(A)Restricts the disclosure of information relating to about the danger.
(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it first makes an independent finding that the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health or safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
(A)The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. In applying this factor, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting an individuals personally identifiable information relating to financial, health, or other similar information outweighs the need for disclosure.
(B)A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
(C)The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protect the specific and substantial overriding interest asserted, and the order is narrowly tailored to protect the secrecy only of that information for which an overriding specific and substantial overriding interest exist.
(D)A less restrictive means to avoid the substantial prejudice to the specific and substantial overriding interest does not exist.
(E)The information is to be kept secret no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
(3)An order entered based pursuant to paragraph (2), other than an order approving a settlement agreement, shall not remain in effect after the entry of final judgment or other final determination, unless at the time of entry the court makes a separate independent finding that the requirements of paragraph (2) continue to exist.(4)(3)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) or (3) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order.
(d)This section does not apply to or affect either any of the following:
(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.
(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.
(3)A trade secret, as defined in Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code, that is not related to a danger to the public health or safety.
(e)An attorney seeking the dismissal with prejudice of a settled action shall certify, at the time he or she seeks dismissal, that the settlement agreement is not void pursuant to subdivision (b).
(e)(f)The State Bar shall investigate allegations that an attorney advocated for, or advised a client to sign, a settlement agreement whose provisions are void pursuant to subdivision (b), and it may discipline an attorney for doing so.
(g)This section does not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
(h)An affected person, including a representative of the news media, may bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed.
It is the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health or safety, including defective products, environmental hazards, and individuals or entities that physically harm others, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information acquired through discovery. This presumption is to apply to settlement and confidentiality agreements, whether or not filed with the court, and to all stipulations for protective orders that would limit the disclosure of information acquired through discovery.
SEC. 2.Section 1002.5 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1002.5.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bodily injury includes psychological trauma resulting from an act, or repetitive acts, of harm.
(2)Danger to the public health or safety means an instrumentality, including a device, instrument, substance, person, entity, procedure, or product, or a condition of a device, instrument, substance, person, entity, procedure, or product, that has caused or is likely to cause significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
(3)Independent finding means a finding by the court based solely on the courts review of the law as applied to the facts of the case, and not based in whole or in part on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret or arguments in support of a stipulation to keep information secret.
(4)Personally identifiable information includes the following:
(A)The identity of, or personal information about, victims of harm, including children and victims of abuse.
(B)Confidential business information, such as the personal addresses of corporate officers or board members.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts the disclosure of information relating to a danger to the public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, unless the agreement is entered by the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c).
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), in any civil action or administrative proceeding in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following with respect to a danger to the public health or safety:
(A)Restricts the disclosure of information relating to the danger.
(B)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
(C)Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
(2)A court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this subdivision if it first makes an independent finding that all of the following criteria are met:
(A)The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. In applying this factor, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting an individuals personally identifiable information relating to financial, health, or other similar information outweighs the need for disclosure.
(B)A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
(C)The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protect the specific and substantial overriding interest asserted, and the order is narrowly tailored to protect the secrecy only of that information for which an overriding specific and substantial overriding interest exist.
(D)A less restrictive means to avoid the substantial prejudice to the specific and substantial overriding interest does not exist.
(E)The information is to be kept secret no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
(3)An order entered based pursuant to paragraph (2), other than an order approving a settlement agreement, shall not remain in effect after the entry of final judgment or other final determination, unless at the time of entry the court makes a separate independent finding that the requirements of paragraph (2) continue to exist.
(4)A party who is the proponent for the entry of an order under paragraph (2) or (3) has the burden of proof in obtaining the order.
(d)This section does not apply to or affect either of the following:
(1)The confidentiality of preagreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1115) of Division 9 of the Evidence Code, or of evidence protected by Section 1153.5 or 1154 of the Evidence Code.
(2)Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all the parties are business entities.
(e)The State Bar shall investigate allegations that an attorney advocated for, or advised a client to sign, a settlement agreement whose provisions are void pursuant to subdivision (b), and it may discipline an attorney for doing so.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2018 | Died on third reading file. |
| Jan 29, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 8, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 4, 2018 | From inactive file. |
| Jan 3, 2018 | Notice of intention to remove from inactive file given by Assembly Member Mark Stone. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Assembly Member Mark Stone. |
| May 30, 2017 | Assembly Rule 69(b) suspended. (Ayes 53. Noes 23. Page 1851.) |
| May 4, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 3, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 3.) (May 2). |
| Apr 24, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 17, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 6, 2017 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (April 4). |
| Apr 3, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 30, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 2, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 4, 2017 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 889
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:January 29, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-3 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Cunningham, Kiley, Maienschein |
Privacy | 6-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into settlement agreements or obtain protective orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, except as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages regarding a defective product or environmental condition that poses a danger to public health or safety. A provision within a settlement entered into on or after January 1, 2019, that violates this provision is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Provides that in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages regarding a defective product or environmental condition, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to that danger shall not be restricted and a court or arbitral tribunal shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, issue an order that restricts disclosure of the information, except as specified.
- Exempts from the provisions above an agreement preventing the disclosure of any of the following:
- Medical or personal identifying information, as defined;
- The amount of the settlement; or
- Information relating to a proprietary interest or trade secret.
- Specifies that if a party seeks an order to prevent disclosure of information in relation to a trade secret, the order shall be narrowly tailored and construed. Specifies that a court is not obligated to review any documents subject to the order if the moving party attests, under penalty of perjury, that the documents do not contain evidence showing that the party responsible for the product or condition knows or should know that the product or condition is an ongoing danger to public health or safety. If the party refuses to attest to this fact, the court may refuse to grant the order or may order a hearing, as specified.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: 1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; 2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; 3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; 4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and 5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d).)
Notwithstanding the presumption of open access, existing law permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation under wraps under certain circumstances. There are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret. First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550(d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court. Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. Sometimes the orders require a party to return discovery documents to the other party at the end of the litigation. In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 United States 20.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. (Where a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract; the court role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.) In many cases, litigants may use more than one method. For example, a settlement agreement may be conditioned on parties obtaining a protective order to keep discovery materials secret or a sealing order to shield filed documents.
This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements. First, this bill prohibits provisions within settlement agreements that restrict disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety, and declares that such provisions are void as a matter of law and against public policy. This bill would only apply to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of evidence of a public danger; the court could, for example, still approve or enforce an agreement that kept confidential trade secrets, sensitive personal information, or the amount of the settlement.
In addition, this bill would prohibit protective orders that prevent the disclosure of evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Specifically, this bill creates a presumption in favor of disclosure in such cases and would prohibit a court from issuing an order that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health and safety. Contrary to the claims of opponents, this bill would not "ban" or "prohibit" settlements that contain a secrecy provision or court orders that prohibit disclosure of litigation documents or court records. This bill's restrictions only apply where the information covered by a court order or agreement contains evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Moreover, this bill expressly allows the court, consistent with the test provided in CRC 2.550(d) for sealing filed documents, to issue protective orders or enforce secrecy agreements if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure. As recently amended, this bill addressed concerns raised by the California Judges Association that this bill would impose a burden on the courts by requiring judges to review a voluminous number of documents in order to ensure that the documents did not contain evidence of a public danger. As amended, however, this bill expressly states that the court is not obligated to review any documents so long as the defendant, as the party responsible for the product or condition, attests, under penalty of perjury, that the documents do not contain evidence of an ongoing danger to public health or safety.
This bill presumes that denying access to court records is sometimes necessary and appropriate, especially when access to documents could undermine legitimate trade secrets, disclose sensitive personal information, or reveal the amount of the settlement. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety.
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002569
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 889
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:January 8, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-3 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Cunningham, Kiley, Maienschein |
Privacy | 6-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into agreements or obtain court orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, as defined, unless a court makes certain independent findings. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of act for civil damages regarding a defective product or environmental condition that poses a danger to public health or safety.
- Provides that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety caused by a defective product or environmental condition, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to that danger shall not be restricted and a court or arbitral tribunal shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts disclosure of the information, except as specified in 3), below.
- Exempts from the provisions above an agreement preventing the disclosure of any of the following:
- Medical or personal identifying information, as defined;
- The amount of the settlement; or
- Information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or trade secret.
- Specifies that a court or arbitral tribunal may grant an order of nondisclosure of information relating to a current, proprietary customer list or trade secret if the party moving for the order demonstrates that the presumption in favor of disclosure is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest. Specifies that the order shall be narrowly tailored to restrict no more information than necessary to protect the interest.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: 1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; 2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; 3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; 4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and 5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d).)
Notwithstanding the presumption of open access, existing law permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation under wraps under certain circumstances. There are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret. First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550(d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court. Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. Sometimes the orders require a party to return discovery documents to the other party at the end of the litigation. In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 United States 20.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. (Where a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract; the court role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.) In many cases, litigants may use more than one method. For example, a settlement agreement may be conditioned on parties obtaining a protective order to keep discovery materials secret or a sealing order to shield filed documents.
This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements. First, this bill declares that any settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety is as a matter of law and against public policy. This bill would only apply to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of evidence of a public danger; the court could, for example, still approve or enforce an agreement that kept confidential trade secrets, sensitive personal information, or the amount of the settlement. In addition, this bill applies to court orders that prohibit the disclosure of evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Specifically, this bill creates a presumption in favor of disclosure in such cases and would prohibit a court from issuing an order that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health and safety. Contrary to the claims of opponents, the purpose of this bill is not to "ban" or "prohibit" settlements that contain a secrecy provision or court orders that prohibit disclosure of litigation documents or court records. The bill's restrictions only apply where the information covered by a court order or agreement contains evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Moreover, the bill expressly allows the court, consistent with the test provided in CRC 2.550(d) for sealing filed documents, to issue protective orders or enforce secrecy agreements if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure.
This bill presumes that denying access to court records is sometimes necessary and appropriate, especially when access to documents could undermine legitimate trade secrets, disclose sensitive personal information, or reveal the amount of the settlement. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety.
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002509
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 889
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:May 30, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-3 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Cunningham, Kiley, Maienschein |
Privacy | 6-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into agreements or obtain court orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, as defined, unless a court makes certain independent findings. Specifically, this bill:
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health and safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information obtained through discovery.
- Provides that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, except as provided. Specifies that this provision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
- Provides, excepts as specified, that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety caused by a defective product or environmental hazard, there shall be a presumption that disclosure of information relating to that danger shall not be restricted and a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
- Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
- Notwithstanding 3) above, a court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this bill if it finds that either of the following conditions is satisfied:
- The pleadings do not state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to the public health or safety.
- The presumption in favor of disclosure of the information is clearly outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records and the order does not restrict any more information than is necessary to protect that interest.
- Requires any party who is the proponent of a court order described in 4), above, has the burden of proof in obtaining the order and must set forth with particularity the specific information for which protection is sought; the specific and overriding interest necessitating confidentiality.
- Specifies that this bill does not apply to or affect any of the following:
- The confidentiality of pre-agreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants, or certain evidence deemed inadmissible under the Evidence Code.
- Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all of the parties are business entities.
- A trade secret, as defined. A trade secret, however, specifically does not include information or records about a product that is defective, hazardous, or unlikely to be used by a competitor.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention. Makes a conforming change to the Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002 subdivision (e).
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill do not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
- Permits a person to bring an action to contest the confidentiality provision of a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates this section in the court in which the case was filed if all of the following are true:
- The person bringing the action makes a prima facie case that the order or settlement restricts information concerning a danger to public health and safety.
- Public knowledge of the information will decrease the likelihood of harm caused by the danger to public health and safety.
- The action will not delay or prejudice the rights of the parties to the underlying action.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: 1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; 2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; 3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; 4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and 5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d).)
Notwithstanding the presumption of open access, existing law permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation under wraps under certain circumstances. There are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret. First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550(d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court. Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. Sometimes the orders require a party to return discovery documents to the other party at the end of the litigation. In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 U.S. 20.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. (Where a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract; the court role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.) In many cases, litigants may use more than one method. For example, a settlement agreement may be conditioned on parties obtaining a protective order to keep discovery materials secret or a sealing order to shield filed documents.
This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements, albeit in different ways. First, the bill declares that any settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety is contrary to public policy, and is therefore void and unenforceable unless the court finds that an interest in secrecy that overrides the presumption favoring disclosure. The bill would only apply to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of evidence of a public danger; the court could, for example, still approve or enforce an agreement that kept confidential trade secrets, sensitive personal information, or the amount of the settlement. In addition, this bill applies to court orders that prohibit the disclosure of evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Specifically, the bill would prohibit a court from issuing an order that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health and safety (e.g. a protective order); approve a settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger; or restrict access to court records containing information about a danger (e.g. a sealing order.) Contrary to the claims of opponents, the purpose of this bill is not to "ban" or "prohibit" settlements that contain a secrecy provision or court orders that prohibit disclosure of litigation documents or court records. The bill's restrictions only apply where the information covered by a court order or agreement contains evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Moreover, the bill expressly allows the court, consistent with the test provided in CRC 2.550(d) for sealing filed documents, to issue protective orders or enforce secrecy agreements if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure.
The bill presumes that denying access to court records is sometimes necessary and appropriate, especially when access to documents could undermine legitimate trade secrets, disclose sensitive personal information, or reveal the amount of the settlement. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety.
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000871
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 889
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:April 20, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-3 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Cunningham, Kiley, Maienschein |
Privacy | 6-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Kalra, Reyes | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into agreements or obtain court orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, as defined, unless a court makes certain independent findings. Specifically, this bill:
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health and safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information obtained through discovery.
- Provides that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, except as provided. Specifies that this provision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
- Provides, excepts as specified, that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
- Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
- Notwithstanding 3) above, a court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this bill if it first makes a finding that either the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health and safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
- The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. Specifies that in applying this factor here shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting personally identifiable information outweighs the need for disclosure.
- A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
- The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protecting the interest asserted.
- A less restrictive means to avoid substantial prejudice does not exist.
- The information is to be kept no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
- Specifies that this bill does not apply to or affect any of the following:
- The confidentiality of pre-agreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants, or certain evidence deemed inadmissible under the Evidence Code.
- Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all of the parties are business entities.
- A trade secret, as defined, that is not related to a danger to public health and safety.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention. Makes a conforming change to the Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002 subdivision (e).
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill do not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
- Permits an affected person, including a representative of the news media, to bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates the provisions of this bill, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: 1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; 2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; 3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; 4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and 5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d).)
Notwithstanding the presumption of open access, existing law permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation under wraps under certain circumstances. There are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret. First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550(d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court. Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. Sometimes the orders require a party to return discovery documents to the other party at the end of the litigation. In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 U.S. 20.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. (Where a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract; the court role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.) In many cases, litigants may use more than one method. For example, a settlement agreement may be conditioned on parties obtaining a protective order to keep discovery materials secret or a sealing order to shield filed documents.
This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements, albeit in different ways. First, the bill declares that any settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety is contrary to public policy, and is therefore void and unenforceable unless the court finds that an interest in secrecy that overrides the presumption favoring disclosure. The bill would only apply to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of evidence of a public danger; the court could, for example, still approve or enforce an agreement that kept confidential trade secrets, sensitive personal information, or the amount of the settlement. In addition, this bill applies to court orders that prohibit the disclosure of evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Specifically, the bill would prohibit a court from issuing an order that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health and safety (e.g. a protective order); approve a settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger; or restrict access to court records containing information about a danger (e.g. a sealing order.) Contrary to the claims of opponents, the purpose of this bill is not to "ban" or "prohibit" settlements that contain a secrecy provision or court orders that prohibit disclosure of litigation documents or court records. The bill's restrictions only apply where the information covered by a court order or agreement contains evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Moreover, the bill expressly allows the court, consistent with the test provided in CRC 2.550(d) for sealing filed documents, to issue protective orders or enforce secrecy agreements if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure.
The bill presumes that denying access to court records is sometimes necessary and appropriate, especially when access to documents could undermine legitimate trade secrets, disclose sensitive personal information, or reveal the amount of the settlement. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety.
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000276
Date of Hearing: May 2, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 889 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:April 20, 2017
SUBJECT: Secrecy agreements
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into settlement agreements or obtain court orders that keep evidence of a danger to public health and safety a secret, unless a court makes certain independent findings. Specifically, this bill:
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health and safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information obtained through discovery.
- Defines “danger to the public health or safety” as a defective product or environmental hazard that has caused or is likely to cause repeated significant or substantial bodily injury or death.
- Defines “defective product” to include products that are defective due to a manufacturing defect, a design defect or a failure to adequately warn a consumer of a hazard involved in the use of a product, where the defect may result in bodily injury or death.
- Defines “environmental hazard” as a release of a hazardous substance that poses a threat to public health or safety involving danger of death, bodily injury, or disability.
- Defines “independent finding” as a finding by the court based solely on the court’s review of the law, as applied to the facts of the case, and not based on a stipulation of the parties to keep information secret.
- Defines “personally identifiable information” as the identity of a person; personal information about victims of harm; information about a person’s finances, medical history, health or similar information; or contact information of corporate officers or board members.
- Provides that in any civil action in which the pleadings state facts relevant to the existence of a danger to public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts disclosure of information relating to that danger shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court, unless the court makes an independent finding.
- Allows a court to make an independent finding that either the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health and safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
- The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. Specifies that in applying this factor here shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting personally identifiable information outweighs the need for disclosure.
- A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
- The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protecting the interest asserted.
- A less restrictive means to avoid substantial prejudice does not exist.
- The information is to be kept no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
- Specifies that a “substantial overriding interest” may include a “state-of-the-art trade secret” or a “current proprietary customer list.”
- Specifies that the bill does not prohibit parties from keeping the dollar amount of the settlement confidential and does not apply to the confidentiality of pre-agreement negotiations, settlement discussions, actions relating to a business dispute in which all the parties are business entities, trade secret cases that are not related to a danger to the public health and safety, or personally identifiable information.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill do not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
- Permits an affected person, including a representative of the news media, to bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates the provisions of this bill, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for the confidentiality of trade secrets in an action under the Uniform Trade Secrets Act, by authorizing the court to issue a discovery protective order which prohibits the disclosure of a trade secret or limits its disclosure without prior court approval. (Civil Code Section 3426.5.)
- Provides, upon a showing of good cause, that courts may issue protective orders to prevent the public distribution of subpoenaed documents, writings or papers. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2031 (f).)
- Provides that upon motion by a party from whom discovery is sought, and for good cause shown, the court may make any order which justice requires to protect a party or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or expense, including that a trade secret, confidential research, or commercial information not be disclosed or be disclosed only in a designated way. (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 26 (c))
- Provides the court with authority to control or limit the enforcement of confidentiality agreements, settlement agreements, or protective orders. (Mary R. v. B & R Corp. (1983) 149 Cal. App.3d 308.)
- Provides the public with a long-standing right to inspect and review court records "where there is no contrary statute or countervailing public policy." (Craemer v. Superior Court (1968) 265 Cal.App.2d 216.) "Since court records are public records, the burden rests on the party seeking to deny public access to those records to establish compelling reasons why and to what extent these records should be made private." (Estate of Hearst (1977) 67 Cal. App.3d 777.)
- Provides, under the California Rules of Court (CRC), that court records are presumed to be open unless confidentiality is required by law. Provides that a court may order a record sealed only if it expressly finds that: (a) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; (b) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; (c) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; (d) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and (e) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (CRC Rule 2.550 (d); see also NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill is intended to reduce unnecessary and potentially dangerous secrecy in litigation by prohibiting protective orders and settlement agreements in civil litigation that conceal evidence of a danger to public health or safety. This bill is author-sponsored.
- Author’s statement: According to the author's office, “Secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or private settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety. Many of these dangers eventually become public, but that is only because news organizations have obtained leaked documents or advocacy groups have brought actions to unseal documents. We cannot know how many lives could have been saved if information about an ongoing public danger had never been kept from public view in the first place, or how many undisclosed dangers still remain. This bill seeks to remedy this continuing problem by limiting the ability of litigants to obtain court orders or enter into secrecy agreements that hide evidence of a danger to public health or safety, unless there is an overriding interest in favor of maintaining secrecy.”
- Court records are presumptively open to the public: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. California courts have consistently affirmed this presumption of openness by requiring the party that seeks to deny access to show "compelling reasons why and to what extent [court] records should be made private." (Estate of Hearst (1977) 67 Cal. App. 3d 777.) Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: (1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; (2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; (3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; (4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and (5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; see also California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d), a rule that was derived from the NBC Subsidiary decision.)
- Some mechanisms for shielding documents from public scrutiny already exist: Existing law already permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation confidential under certain circumstances. Generally speaking, there are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret.
First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550 (d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court.
Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 U.S. 20 held that a party does not have a First Amendment right to disseminate information obtained during discovery that is covered by a protective order, meaning there is a right to disseminate information that is not covered by a protective order.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. Note that if a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract, and the court’s role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.
- Impacts on court orders and settlement agreements: This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements. As to settlement agreements, this bill declares that any settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a product defect or environmental hazard that poses a danger to public health or safety is contrary to public policy, and is therefore void and unenforceable unless the court finds that an interest in secrecy that overrides the presumption favoring disclosure.
The bill would not apply to the entire agreement, but rather only to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of such a danger. This bill also specifically allows a court to approve or enforce an agreement that keeps trade secrets, sensitive personal information, and the amount of the settlement confidential.
As to court orders, this bill would prohibit a court from issuing an order (i.e., a protective order or a sealing order) that restricts disclosure of information or evidence about a product defect or environmental hazard that poses a danger to public health and safety. But the bill expressly allows the court to issue such an order if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure.
While the author contends that secrecy in litigation – whether in a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety, the author has created exceptions to this rule to protect legitimate trade secrets, sensitive personal information, and dollar amounts of settlements.
- The Legislature has already prohibited secrecy in elder abuse, child abuse, and sex offense cases: AB 634 (Steinberg), Chapter 242, Statutes of 2003, prohibited secret settlements that keep the abuse of an elder or dependent adult confidential. AB 634 was enacted in response to reports of abuse at nursing homes, and it was grounded in the belief that people have the right to know both the facts that led to a settlement in these cases, and the name of the involved institution, so they can make a fully informed decision when choosing a nursing facility for themselves or loved ones.
Similarly, AB 2875 (Pavley), Chapter 151, Statutes of 2006, prohibited secret settlements in civil actions alleging conduct that could be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. AB 2875 was passed in the wake of highly publicized news reports, as well as a 2004 study commissioned by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, that 11,000 people in the United States had made credible accusations of child sexual abuse against more than 5,000 clergy since 1950. According to a series published by the Boston Globe, the Catholic Church reportedly paid more than $1 billion for claims and reached countless confidential out-of-court settlements. The Boston Globe found that from 1992 to 2002, the Archdiocese of Boston alone secretly settled child molestation claims involving 70 priests and at least 200 victims.
AB 1682 (Stone), Chapter 876, Statutes of 2016, also prohibited secret settlements and court orders restricting disclosure in civil actions alleging acts of childhood sexual abuse, sexual exploitation of a minor, sexual assault of an elder or dependent adult, as well as any act that could be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
- Prior attempts to limit secrecy in public health and safety cases have failed: While anti-secrecy legislation aimed at elder abuse, child abuse, and sexual abuse has been enacted, bills attempting to extend the policy disfavoring secrecy to dangers to public health and safety more broadly have been less successful. SB 11 (Escutia, 2001), AB 36 (Steinberg, 2001), and AB 1700 (Pavley, 2005), which attempted to limit secret settlements in cases alleging personal injury or wrongful death caused by product defects or environmental hazards, all failed.
AB 36 was introduced in response to the then-recent Firestone/Bridgestone tragedies in which more than 150 people died and more than 500 were injured while driving on defective tires. In the decade before the Firestone/Bridgestone tires were finally recalled in 2000, more than 200 cases were settled and subject to secrecy orders. These secrecy provisions allegedly muzzled attorneys and victims from warning the public about these ongoing, and potentially fatal, dangers associated with the tires.
- Protective orders and secrecy agreements have hidden other public dangers as well: Public Justice, a national public interest law firm with an office in Oakland, recently posted thousands of previously-sealed documents showing a defect in Remington rifles that caused the guns to discharge without anyone pulling the trigger. Though that information is now available, for several years protective orders and confidentiality agreements kept the dangerous defect from public view.
In 2005, Montana passed the "Gus Barber Anti-Secrecy Act" named for the nine-year old boy killed by a defective Remington trigger. The boy's father worked tirelessly for the legislation after he discovered that Remington had previously settled suits with secrecy provisions.
As another example, there have been more than 500 settlements involving defective Cooper tires. Most of these settlements included secrecy provisions, as did other lawsuits involving car ignition and airbag failures, illegally shortened guard rails, fertilizers that cause plant explosions, window shade cords that strangle, and front seatbacks that collapse in a rear-end collision. Although information about some of these dangers is now public, that is largely because news organizations have obtained leaked documents or advocacy groups have brought actions to unseal or otherwise gain access to documents.
In light of these ongoing dangers, the author contends California should join at least eleven states that have enacted anti-secrecy legislation similar to AB 889. Florida passed the first "Sunshine in Litigation" Act in 1991. The Florida law is similar in scope to this bill. (Fla. Statutes 69.081) Louisiana, Texas, Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina, Nevada, Oregon, South Carolina, Washington, and Montana have enacted similar statutes since then.
- Recent amendments address some concerns while keeping consumer protections intact: This bill is opposed by a coalition of business groups and the California Judges Association, who contend that the bill will discourage settlement, lead to prolonged litigation, and impose an unmanageable burden on our courts.
The author has taken a number of amendments in an effort to address these concerns. The most recent set of amendments narrow the bill to apply only in cases involving a defective product or an environmental hazard where there is an ongoing danger that could cause repeated physical injury or death. The recent amendments also clarify that the bill does not apply to “state-of-the-art trade secrets,” a “current proprietary customer list,” or personally identifiable information, so that the privacy of such information can be protected.
The author made changes to the attorney discipline provisions of the bill to make them discretionary rather than mandatory in order to address concerns raised by the State Bar and Judicial Council.
The author has not yet addressed opponents’ questions about the provision of the bill that gives standing to contest an order that shields a public danger to any "affected person," including a member of the news media. This language is modeled after the Montana anti-secrecy statute. In a product liability case, a person may be an "affected person" because he or she owns or uses a product that has caused repeated injury or death. But an "affected person" could also be any person denied his or her right to access records that would otherwise be open and accessible. The harm in the second instance is not a physical harm caused by the danger, per se, but the civic harm of not having access to records that should be accessible. The author has indicated his willingness to continue working with the opposition to determine who should have standing to challenge an order or agreement that allegedly violates the provisions of this bill.
- Arguments in support: Consumers Union (CU) writes in support of this bill that "on too many occasions corporations settle product liability cases with victims and their families, and use secrecy, in the form of protective orders and sealed documents, to wrongfully and repeatedly conceal injuries and deaths associated with their defective products." CU argues that "secrecy agreements regarding dangers from everyday consumer products, such as automobile airbags, ignition switches and tires, medical devices, toys, and prescription drugs, keep consumers in the dark about the risks to their safety, and inevitably lead to additional and avoidable harm."
The California Newspaper Publishers Association (CNPA) supports this bill because it will "limit parties' ability to settle cases secretly when they relate to public dangers like toxic or environmental hazards, or defective products." CNPA argues that allowing parties "to contract for confidentiality in these cases hides critical information about dangerous risks that stay secret to the public's detriment." Making this information public, as AB 889 proposes to, "allows the news media to report on potential hazards, and spurs the public to take steps to protect against these dangers." AB 889, CNPA concludes, will "shed light on lawsuits related to public dangers and increase access to related courts records, while balancing the need for confidentiality on a case-by-case basis."
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) states in support that, "There are many cases where courts are sealing incriminating evidence, protective orders that seek discovery information secret and settlement agreements that prohibit parties from disclosing the facts of the case." CAOC argues that while secrecy is appropriate to protect trade secrets and sensitive personal information, "it is not appropriate if it shields evidence of a danger from public scrutiny."
The Consumer Federation of California (CFC) states this bill “will enhance public safety by reducing unnecessary and overly broad protective orders or secrecy provisions in settlement agreements." CFC adds that in the dozen states that have adopted anti-secrecy laws, "there is no corresponding evidence that such legislation discourages settlements, exposes proprietary interests or trade secrets, or imposes burdens on the courts."
- Arguments in opposition: A coalition of business groups led by the California Chamber of Commerce opposes this bill because "it unfairly leverages businesses to either settle lawsuits that allege a danger to the public health and safety or disclose confidential information during civil litigation." Opponents claim that AB 889 would "essentially ban the use of protective orders during civil litigation by setting the standard upon which a court may grant a protective order so high that it is unattainable." If businesses are unable to obtain protective orders, the opposition claims, they will be forced to defend "allegations of danger to the public health and safety and file numerous motions and petitions with the court to avoid disclosure of confidential information, or settle an unmeritorious claim to protect such information."
Opponents also claim that AB 889 "basically requires the disclosure of trade secret information [if…] the trade secret is in any way related to the alleged danger to public health or safety […] AB 889 basically forces the disclosure of trade secret information that 'relates' to a public danger to health or safety unless the party can prove there is a 'specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records,' which is an impossible standard to achieve."
In addition, opponents claim that the bill is unnecessary because the public already has access to information about the danger to public health and safety because the complaint is filed with the court and is never confidential. It is also unnecessary, opponents contend, because the California Code of Civil Procedure already requires "a court to analyze the proposed information sought to be covered by a protective order during discovery to determine whether good cause exists to keep it from public disclosure." Finally, the coalition argues that settlement agreements rarely contain evidence of a danger to public health or safety.
The California Defense Counsel (CDC) opposes this bill for some of the same reasons put forth by the Chamber-led coalition, but CDC's opposition focuses more on the likely practical impact of the bill on complex products liability cases. While CDC writes that it has "no quarrel with the goal of protecting Californians from death or serious injury, the practical effect of AB 899 as it will be amended will be to impede discovery, slow cases, expose lawyers to second-guessing by the State Bar, and interfere with the finality of judgments in civil cases." CDC especially opposes the provision of the bill that will require courts to make an independent finding about whether the information is related to a danger to public health and safety before issuing a protective order, "even where the opposing parties have stipulated to the issuance of the order." CDC believes that judges have "neither the time nor expertise to 'look behind' every stipulation in order to make an independent assessment of public danger. The test for issuing the order is so difficult that it could make protective orders almost impossible to obtain."
Finally, the California Judges Association (CJA) argues that the bill “would result in an entirely new, extensive, and burdensome role for the courts. First, it is not clear how, without looking behind sometimes thousands or even millions of pages of documents, a court would know of the existence of a defective product or environmental hazard danger disclosed in those documents that would preclude entry of an order by stipulation or otherwise, or that would invoke the proposed independent finding exception. […] Next, if any issues were identified, the court would then be tasked with exercising its independent judgement about possible dangers, and perhaps weighing conflicting opinions of expert witnesses to make that determination […] Additionally, AB 889 appears to grant broad standing to object to settlements and judgements, allowing “an affected person, including a representative of the news media” standing to contest a final order, judgement, or written final settlement agreement […]”
- Prior legislation: AB 1700 (Pavley) of 2005 would have restricted the use of secrecy settlements in cases involving a public danger, which the bill defined as cases where an instrumentality caused and is likely to further cause significant or substantial bodily injury or death. AB 1700 died on the Assembly Floor.
SB 11 (Escutia) of 2001 would have prohibited secret settlements in cases where injury, wrongful death or financial loss was caused by a defective product or an environmental hazard. The bill also would have made void and unenforceable any provision in a settlement agreement that restricted a party from disclosing evidence of a public hazard to a government agency with enforcement authority of that public hazard, unless the information was a trade secret or otherwise privileged. SB 11 died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 36 (Steinberg) of 2001 was similar to and a companion measure of SB 11 of 2001. AB 36 passed the Assembly Floor on a 41-4 vote but was held in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Double-referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee, where it was heard on April 4, 2017, and passed on an 8-3 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Newspaper Publisher Associations
Conference of California Bar Associations
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Consumers Union
Opposition
California Chamber of Commerce
American Coatings Association
American Insurance Association
California Association of Health Facilities
California Attractions and Parks Association, Inc.
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Defense Counsel
California Forestry Association
California Hospital Association
California Judges Association
California League of Food Processors
California New Car Dealers Association
California Paint Council
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association – CompTIA
LeadingAge California
National Federation of Independent Business
Orange County Business Council
Personal Care Products Council
Southwest California Legislative Council
TechNet
Western States Petroleum Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Jennie Bretschneider / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: April 4, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 889
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:March 30, 2017
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Secrecy in litigation: public dangers
KEY ISSUES:
- Should courts be prohibited from issuing orders that conceal information showing an ongoing danger to public health AND safety, unless the court finds that the interest in keeping the information confidential outweighs the public interest in disclosure?
- should settlement agreements that conceal documents showing an ongiong danger to public health and safety be void and unenforceable, unless the court makes findings that an interest in keeping the information confidential outweighs the public interest in disclosure?
SYNOPSIS
In an open and democratic society, court records are presumptively open to public inspection. As discussed in the analysis, California courts have consistently affirmed this presumption of openness by requiring the party seeking to deny access to show a "compelling reasons why and to what extent [court] records should be made private." Under certain circumstances, however, the law permits civil litigants to make agreements or obtain "protective orders" that prohibit the disclosure or sharing of information discovered during litigation. The author acknowledges that denying access to court records and discovery material is sometimes appropriate, especially when secrecy is justified to protect legitimate trade secrets or sensitive personal information. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or private settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety. Many of these dangers eventually become public, but that is only because news organizations have obtained leaked documents or advocacy groups have brought actions to unseal documents. We cannot know how many lives could have been saved if information about an ongoing public danger had never been kept from public view in the first place, or how many undisclosed dangers still remain. This bill seeks to remedy this continuing problem by limiting the ability of litigants to obtain court orders or enter into secrecy agreements that hide evidence of a danger to public health or safety, unless there is an overriding interest in favor of maintaining secrecy. Some opponents argue that this measure will effectively "ban" or "prohibit" protective orders or secret settlements; in fact, the bill only applies to cases in which the pleadings suggest that a manufactured product, substance, or environmental condition has caused or is likely to cause repeated death or bodily injury. Moreover, the bill does not prohibit orders or agreements that shield legitimate trade secrets, sensitive personal or financial information, or the dollar amount of a settlement. The bill is opposed by a coalition of business groups and supported by several consumer rights groups. The bill was recently amended to address many, but not all, concerns raised by opponents. The author will take additional amendments in this Committee that are reflected in the summary and analysis below.
SUMMARY: Limits the ability of litigants to enter into agreements or obtain court orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, as defined, unless a court makes certain independent findings. Specifically, this bill:
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to better protect Californians from death or substantial injury caused by any danger to the public health and safety, including defective products and environmental hazards, by creating a presumption against secrecy that protects the openness of information obtained through discovery.
- Provides that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety, an agreement between the parties that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety shall be void as contrary to public policy and shall not be enforced by a court or tribunal, except as provided. Specifies that this provision does not prohibit parties from keeping confidential the settlement amount.
- Provides, excepts as specified, that in any civil action in which the pleadings allege the existence of a danger to public health or safety, a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
- Restricts the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information about the danger.
- Restricts access to court records containing information about the danger.
- Notwithstanding 3) above, a court may enter an order otherwise prohibited by this bill if it first makes a finding that either the order will not restrict the disclosure of information relevant to the protection of public health and safety, or that all of the following criteria are met:
- The public interest in the disclosure of the information is outweighed by a specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records in question, and the overriding interest supports keeping the information secret. Specifies that in applying this factor here shall be a rebuttable presumption that protecting personally identifiable information outweighs the need for disclosure.
- A substantial probability exists that the specific and substantial interest will be substantially prejudiced if the information is not kept secret.
- The request for an order is no broader than necessary to protecting the interest asserted.
- A less restrictive means to avoid substantial prejudice does not exist.
- The information is to be kept no longer than necessary to meet the requirements of this paragraph.
- Specifies that this bill does not apply to or affect any of the following:
- The confidentiality of pre-agreement negotiations, settlement discussions between mediation participants, or certain evidence deemed inadmissible under the Evidence Code.
- Actions relating to a business dispute, including actions for breach of contract, in which all of the parties are business entities.
- A trade secret, as defined, that is not related to a danger to public health and safety.
- Provides that an attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, as specified, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention. Makes a conforming change to subdivision (e) of Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill do not eliminate or supplant existing legal standards governing protective orders, the sealing of court records, or confidential settlements, but, rather, imposes additional requirements that must be independently satisfied.
- Permits an affected person, including a representative of the news media, to bring an action to contest a final order, judgment, or written settlement agreement that violates the provisions of this bill, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides the court with authority to control or limit the enforcement of confidentiality agreements, settlement agreements, or protective orders. (Mary R. v. B & R Corp. (1983) 149 Cal. App.3d 308.)
- Provides the public with a long-standing right to inspect and review court records "where there is no contrary statute or countervailing public policy." (Craemer v. Superior Court (1968) 265 Cal.App.2d 216.) "Since court records are public records, the burden rests on the party seeking to deny public access to those records to establish compelling reasons why and to what extent these records should be made private." (Estate of Hearst (1977) 67 Cal. App.3d 777.)
- Provides, upon a showing of good cause, that courts may issue protective orders to prevent the public distribution of subpoenaed documents, writings or papers. (Code of Civil Procedure section 2031 (f).)
- Provides, under the California Rules of Court (CRC), that court records are presumed to be open unless confidentiality is required by law. Provides that a court may order a record sealed only if it expressly finds that: (a) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; (b) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; (c) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; (d) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and (e) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (CRC Rule 2.550 (d); see also NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178.)
- Provides for the confidentiality of trade secrets in an action under the Uniform Trade Secrets Act, by authorizing the court to issue a discovery protective order which prohibits the disclosure of a trade secret or limits its disclosure without prior court approval. (Civil Code section 3426.5.)
- Provides that upon motion by a party from whom discovery is sought, and for good cause shown, the court may make any order which justice requires to protect a party or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or expense, including that a trade secret, confidential research, or commercial information not be disclosed or be disclosed only in a designated way. (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 26 (c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Court records are presumptively open to public inspection. California courts have consistently affirmed this presumption of openness by requiring the party that seeks to deny access to show "compelling reasons why and to what extent [court] records should be made private." (Estate of Hearst (1977) 67 Cal. App. 3d 777.) Because of this presumption, a court may only take the rare step of sealing documents if it expressly finds facts that establish the following: (1) there exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record; (2) the overriding public interest supports sealing the record; (3) a substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed; (4) the proposed sealing is narrowly tailored; and (5) no less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest. (NBC Subsidiary (KNBC-TV), Inc. v. Superior Court (1999) 20 Cal. 4th 1178; see also California Rule of Court (CRC) rule 2.550 (d), a rule that was derived from the NBC Subsidiary decision.)
Existing mechanisms for shielding documents from public scrutiny: Notwithstanding the presumption of open access, existing law permits civil litigants to keep certain documents related to litigation under wraps under certain circumstances. Generally speaking, there are three ways in which documents or other evidence may be kept secret. First, a court may grant a motion to seal records filed with the court, but only if the court expressly finds facts establishing "an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access" and meets other conditions required by California Rule of Court (CRC) Rule 2.550 (d). However, this rule only applies to documents that have been filed. It does not apply to documents that have been obtained in discovery but not filed with the court. Second, whether by motion of one party, or by stipulation of both, a court may issue a "protective order" that prevents the sharing or disclosure of documents obtained during discovery. Sometimes the orders require a party to return discovery documents to the other party at the end of the litigation. (See e.g. "Model Protective Order" for California superior courts, at http://www.alameda.courts.ca.gov/dept17/Model%20Protective%20Order%20-%20Complex.pdf) In the absence of such protective orders, litigants are presumed to have a First Amendment right to disclose information contained in those documents or to use them in subsequent litigation. (Seattle Times Co. v. Rhinehart (1984) 467 U.S. 20 held that a party does not have a First Amendment right to disseminate information obtained during discovery that is covered by a protective order, meaning there is a right to disseminate information that is not covered by a protective order.)
Third, even in the absence of a court order, the parties may enter into a private settlement agreement that prohibits the sharing or disclosing documents, or even discussing the facts of the case or the terms of the settlement. When a settlement is reached after the action is filed but before judgment, one or both parties may file a motion to dismiss the action with prejudice and, depending upon the nature of the case or the desire of the parties, a court may need to approve the settlement. (Where a settlement is reached prior to filing an action, it is treated as a contract; the court role is limited to enforcing the agreement, if and when it is breached.) In many cases, litigants may use more than one method. For example, a settlement agreement may be conditioned on parties obtaining a protective order to keep discovery materials secret or a sealing order to shield filed documents.
This bill would apply to court orders as well as settlement agreements, albeit in different ways. First, the bill declares that any settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health or safety is contrary to public policy, and is therefore void and unenforceable unless the court finds that an interest in secrecy that overrides the presumption favoring disclosure. The bill would only apply to those provisions of the settlement agreement that restrict disclosure of evidence of a public danger; the court could, for example, still approve or enforce an agreement that kept confidential trade secrets, sensitive personal information, or the amount of the settlement. In addition, this bill applies to court orders that prohibit the disclosure of evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Specifically, the bill would prohibit a court from issuing an order that restricts disclosure of information about a danger to public health and safety (e.g. a protective order); approve a settlement agreement that restricts disclosure of information about a danger; or restrict access to court records containing information about a danger (e.g. a sealing order.) Contrary to the claims of opponents, the purpose of this bill is not to "ban" or "prohibit" settlements that contain a secrecy provision or court orders that prohibit disclosure of litigation documents or court records. The bill's restrictions only apply where the information covered by a court order or agreement contains evidence of a danger to public health and safety. Moreover, the bill expressly allows the court, consistent with the test provided in CRC 2.550 (d) for sealing filed documents, to issue protective orders or enforce secrecy agreements if it finds an interest in secrecy that overrides the public interest in disclosure.
The bill presumes that denying access to court records is sometimes necessary and appropriate, especially when access to documents could undermine legitimate trade secrets, disclose sensitive personal information, or reveal the amount of the settlement. However, the author believes that secrecy in litigation – whether it takes the form of a court order or a settlement agreement – is not appropriate when it hides evidence of a known and ongoing danger to public health and safety.
History of Prior Legislation Recognizing the Dangers of Secrecy: This is not the first time that the Legislature has attempted to limit secrecy in litigation, but such measures have generally only succeeded where they have targeted very specific types of actions. For example, AB 634 (Chapter 242, Statutes of 2003) prohibits settlement agreements that prohibit disclosure of information in a civil action alleging abuse of an elder or dependent adult. This measure was enacted in response to reports of abuse at nursing homes, and it was grounded in the belief that people have the right to know both the facts that led to a settlement in these cases, and the name of the involved institution, so they can make a fully informed decision when choosing a nursing facility for themselves or loved ones.
Three years later AB 2875 (Chapter 151, Statutes of 2006) prohibited secrecy agreements in civil actions alleging conduct that could be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. This measure came in the wake of highly publicized news reports, as well as a 2004 study commissioned by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, that 11,000 people in the United States had made credible accusations of child sexual abuse against more than 5,000 clergy since 1950. According to a series published by the Boston Globe, the Catholic Church reportedly paid more than $1 billion for claims and reached countless confidential out-of-court settlements. The Boston Globe found that from 1992 to 2002, the Archdiocese of Boston alone secretly settled child molestation claims involving 70 priests and at least 200 victims. (See Assembly Judiciary Committee, Analysis of AB 2875, April 25, 2006.) Last year's AB 1682 (Chapter 876, Statutes of 2016) strengthened and extended the statute created by AB 2875 to prohibit settlement agreements and court orders that restrict disclosure of information relating to civil actions alleging acts of childhood sexual abuse, sexual exploitation of a minor, sexual assault of an elder or dependent adult, as well as any act that could be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. (See Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002.)
While anti-secrecy legislation aimed at elder abuse, child abuse, and sexual abuse has been enacted, bills attempting to extend the policy disfavoring secrecy to dangers to public health and safety more broadly have been less successful. For example, AB 1700 (Pavley, 2005), SB 11 (Escutia, 2001), and AB 36 (Steinberg, 2001) all failed. These measures were similar to the bill under consideration, generally applying to cases alleging personal injury or wrongful death caused by product defects or environmental hazards. AB 36, the bill perhaps most similar to the measure under review, passed out of committees and off the Assembly Floor only to die in the Senate Judiciary Committee. AB 36, in particular, was introduced in response to the then-recent Firestone/Bridgestone tragedy. According to the Assembly Judiciary Committee Analysis of AB 36, as of 2001 more than 150 people had died and more than 500 had been injured while driving on defective tires. However, in the decade before the tires were finally recalled in 2000, more than 200 cases were settled subject to secrecy orders. These secrecy provisions allegedly muzzled attorneys and victims from warning the public about these ongoing, and potentially fatal, dangers associated with the tires. (See Assembly Judiciary Committee, Analysis of AB 36, May 8, 2001.)
While the exposure of the Firestone/Bridgestone tragedy may seem like ancient history now, there have been many more recent examples of injuries and deaths caused by product defects and environmental hazards, many of which were settled subject to protective orders and secrecy provisions. For example, Public Justice, a national public interest law firm with an office in Oakland, recently posted thousands of previously-sealed documents showing a defect in Remington rifles that caused the guns to discharge without anyone pulling the trigger. Though that information is finally available, for several years protective orders and confidentiality agreements kept the dangerous defect from public view. In 2005, Montana passed the "Gus Barber Anti-Secrecy Act" named for the nine-year old boy killed by a defective Remington trigger. The boy's father worked tirelessly for the legislation after he discovered that Remington had previously settled suits with secrecy provisions.
Protective orders and secrecy agreements have hidden other public dangers as well. For example, researchers have uncovered over 500 settlements involving defective Cooper Tires. Most of these settlements included secrecy provisions, as did lawsuits involving car ignition and airbag failures, illegally shortened guard rails, fertilizers that cause plant explosions, window shade cords that strangle, and front seatbacks that collapse in a rear-end collision. Although information about some of these dangers is now public, that is largely because news organizations have obtained leaked documents or advocacy groups have brought actions to unseal or otherwise gain access to documents. It is impossible to calculate how many lives could have been saved if information of public dangers had never been shielded from public view in the first place, or how many undisclosed dangers still remain. In light of these ongoing dangers, the author believes that California should join at least eleven states that have enacted anti-secrecy legislation similar to AB 889. Florida passed the first "Sunshine in Litigation" Act in 1991. The Florida law is similar in scope to this bill. (Fla. Stat. 69.081.) Louisiana, Texas, Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina, Nevada, Oregon, South Carolina, Washington, and Montana have enacted statutes since then. For the last two decades, Congress has attempted to enact a federal "Sunshine in Litigation Act" that is quite similar to the various state laws and the bill under consideration. The most recent federal bipartisan effort, Senate Bill 2364 (113th Cong. 2d Sess.) is co-authored by Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal and Republican Senator Lindsay Graham. Prohibiting concealment of evidence of a public danger is apparently a principle embraced by both Democrats and Republicans, in red states and in blue states.
The author has taken, or will take today, several amendments to address opposition concerns. This bill is opposed by a coalition of business groups. Although their arguments are detailed below, in general, their principal objections appear to be that the bill will "essentially ban" the protective orders and secrecy provisions in settlements and, as such, discourage settlement and lead to prolonged litigation. They also contend that this bill will make it almost impossible to obtain protective orders that are necessary to protect trade secret information. Needless to say, the author disagrees with this assessment, and his position is amply supported by many legal scholars and judges alike. [See e.g. Joseph F. Anderson, "Hidden from the Public by Order of the Court: The Case Against Government-Enforced Secrecy," 55 S.C. L. Rev 711 (2004). Anderson is the Chief Judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina. Judge Anderson rebuts common criticisms of anti-secrecy rules and argues in support of a local rule adopted by the South Carolina District Court that prohibits secrecy in settlement agreements unless necessary to protect a legitimate privacy interest.]
The bill, as most recently amended, reflects amendments addressing opposition concerns. Specifically, the bill was recently amended to (1) narrow the definition of "danger to public health and safety; (2) permit parties to keep the amount of the settlement secret; (3) create an exemption for legitimate trade secrets; and (4) eliminate a provision that would have ended the protective order upon a final judgement. The author will address additional concerns by taking the following amendments today that: (1) delete the bill's application to "administrative proceedings"; (2) remove a requirement that an attorney certify that he or she did not violate provisions related to prohibited settlement agreements; and (3) revise a provision relating to attorney discipline so as eliminate a mandatory investigation by the State Bar. The bill makes a conforming change to subdivision (e) of Code of Civil Procedure, so that both provisions provide that the State Bar "may," as opposed to "shall," investigate an attorney.
Remaining Issues Should the Bill Pass out of Committee: The amendments already taken do not remove all of the opposition to this bill; however, the author, opposition, and committee staff have identified many areas of potential compromise should the bill move on to its next stop, the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
First, the author recognizes that the trade secret exemption added by the most recent amendments may need refinement. To simply provide a blanket exemption for trade secrets, as opponents of the bill prefer, would create a loophole by which a party could identify virtually all documents as "trade secrets" and thereby conceal a danger to public health and safety that should be disclosed because it is only tangentially related to a trade secret, or not related at all. On the other hand, to say, as the bill in print says, that a trade secret is exempt only if it does not relate to a danger to public health and safety may arguably swallow up the exemption, for a trade secret that is not related to the danger to public health and safety would not be subject to the bill's restrictions. The practical problem, however, is that it may be difficult to distinguish a legitimate trade secret about how a product is manufactured from a manufacturing defect that poses a public danger. The author maintains that such distinctions can and must be made. For example, the design of a tire tread may be a legitimate trade secret; however, the fact that the tread separates from the tire, causing hundreds of accidents resulting in death or substantial bodily injury, is most decidedly not a trade secret. The author has indicated his willingness to continue working with the opposition to find a way to separate evidence of a legitimate trade secret from evidence of a danger that the public has a right to know about.
Second, opponents have raised very legitimate questions about the provision of the bill that gives standing to contest an order that shields a public danger to any "affected person," including a member of the news media. This language is modeled after the Montana anti-secrecy statute. The issue here is that someone can be an "affected person" in at least two ways. First, in a product liability case, a person may be an "affected person" because he or she owns or uses a product that has caused repeated injury or death. Second, to the extent that court records are presumptively open, an "affected person" could be any person denied his or her right to access records that would otherwise be open and accessible. The harm in the second instance is not a physical harm caused by the danger, per se, but the civic harm of not having access to records that should be accessible. The author has indicated his willingness to continue working with the opposition to determine who should have standing to challenge an order or agreement that allegedly violates the provisions of this bill.
Third, some opponents have argued that the court's obligation to make an "independent finding" as to whether the pleadings allege a danger to public health and safety, and to then balance competing interests before approving an order or settlement, will impose an undue burden on the courts. Here, there are reasonable differences of opinion on whether this bill would add to the burden on the courts. As noted below, the California Judges Association believes that it will. On the other hand, Judge Joseph Anderson, Chief Judge of U.S. District Court for the South Carolina circuit, argues that an anti-secrecy rule adopted by that court has increased efficiency by decreasing, rather than increasing, the amount of time devoted to discovery. For example, protective orders on discoverable documents simply mean that subsequent litigants must replicate the discovery process in order to obtain the same documents. Sometimes even the same attorney, in another case against the same defendant, must seek to discover the same documents that he or she was forced, by a protective order, to return to the same defendant. (See Anderson, supra.)
PROPOSED AUTHOR AMENDMENTS: As detailed above, the author will take the following amendments in Committee:
- On page 3, lines 3-4, delete "or administrative proceeding"
- On page 3, line 7 delete "relating to" and insert: about
- On page 3, line 14, delete "or administrative proceeding"
- On page 3, line 26 after "finding" insert: either
- On page 4, delete lines 29-31 and re-letter subdivisions accordingly
- On page 4, delete lines 33-36 in insert: (e) An Attorney's failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that violates subdivision (b) may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California may investigate and take appropriate action in any such action that is brought to its attention.
- On page 5 after line 4 insert: Insert SEC. 2 of the bill to amend subdivision (e) of Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure to read:
(e) An attorney’s failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall may investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, AB 889 "will reduce inefficient, unnecessary, and dangerous secrecy in litigation by preventing civil litigants from using overly broad protective orders or secrecy provisions in settlement agreements. Specifically, AB 889 will prohibit orders and agreements that conceal a danger to public health or safety. Secrecy in litigation is too often been a matter of life and death." The author argues that "from the injuries and deaths caused by Bridgestone/Firestone tires, to more recent deaths and injuries caused by collapsing seatbacks and faulty triggers in Remington rifles, the pattern is all too familiar. People are killed or injured by public hazards that were shielded by a prior secrecy agreement between the parties or was barred from public view by a protective order." The author believes that AB 889 will prohibit any order or agreement that conceals evidence of a danger to public health and safety, unless a court finds that the interest in secrecy outweighs the public interest in disclosure. The author stresses that the bill is "narrowly tailored, applying only to information about a danger to public health or safety that has already caused, or is likely to cause repeated injury or death." Finally the author challenges California to "join nearly a dozen states that have enacted anti-secrecy legislation similar to AB 889. Contrary to the fears of critics, there is no evidence that such legislation discourages settlements, exposes proprietary interests or trade secrets, or imposes undue burdens on the courts."
Consumers Union (CU) supports this bill because on "too many occasions corporations settle product liability cases with victims and their families, and use secrecy, in the form of protective orders and sealed documents, to wrongfully and repeatedly conceal injuries and deaths associated with their defective products." CU argues that "secrecy agreements regarding dangers from everyday consumer products, such as automobile airbags, ignition switches and tires, medical devices, toys, and prescription drugs, keep consumers in the dark about the risks to their safety, and inevitably lead to additional and avoidable harm." AB 889, CU believes, "will motivate corporations to correct the errors that brought them into court in the first place, rather than hiding behind secrecy orders and continuing business as usual until scores of unsuspecting consumers are injured or killed, and recalls are required. Instead of investing in fixing their dangerous products, corporations like GM, Firestone/Bridgestone, and Ford, to name just a few, settled hundreds of cases with victims over several years, requiring silence and secrecy as a condition of the settlements, while continuing to sell their dangerous products."
The California Newspaper Publishers Association (CNPA) supports this bill because it will "limit parties' ability to settle cases secretly when they relate to public dangers like toxic or environmental hazards, or defective products." CNPA argues that allowing parties "to contract for confidentiality in these cases hides critical information about dangerous risks that stay secret to the public's detriment." Making this information public, as AB 889 proposes to, "allows the news media to report on potential hazards, and spurs the public to take steps to protect against these dangers." AB 889, CNPA concludes, will "shed light on lawsuits related to public dangers and increase access to related courts records, while balancing the need for confidentiality on a case-by-case basis."
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) notes that, even though court records are presumptively open to public inspection, "There are many cases where courts are sealing incriminating evidence, protective orders that seek discovery information secret and settlement agreements that prohibit parties from disclosing the facts of the case." CAOC argues that while secrecy is appropriate to protect trade secrets and sensitive personal information, "it is not appropriate if it shields evidence of a danger from public scrutiny." AB 889, CAOC concludes, will ensure that evidence of a danger "is not shielded from public scrutiny in the future."
The Consumer Federation of California (CFC) supports this bill because the presumption of openness is "particularly true in cases involving a public danger, such as a defective consumer product or environmental hazard. . . AB 889 will enhance public safety by reducing unnecessary and overly broad protective orders or secrecy provisions in settlement agreements." CFC adds that in the dozen states that have adopted anti-secrecy laws, "there is no corresponding evidence that such legislation discourages settlements, exposes proprietary interests or trade secrets, or imposes burdens on the courts."
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of business groups led by the California Chamber of Commerce opposes this bill because "it unfairly leverages businesses to either settle lawsuits that allege a danger to the public health and safety or disclose confidential information during civil litigation." Opponents claim that AB 889 would "essentially ban the use of protective orders during civil litigation by setting the standard upon which a court may grant a protective order so high that it is unattainable." If businesses are unable to obtain protective orders, the opposition claims, they will be forced to defend "allegations of danger to the public health and safety and file numerous motions and petitions with the court to avoid disclosure of confidential information, or settle an unmeritorious claim to protect such information."
Opponents also claim that AB 889 "basically requires the disclosure of trade secret information [if] . . . the trade secret is in any way related to the alleged danger to public health or safety. . . AB 889 basically forces the disclosure of trade secret information that 'relates' to a public danger to health or safety unless the party can prove there is a 'specific and substantial overriding interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the information or records,' which is an impossible standard to achieve."
In addition, opponents claim that the bill is unnecessary because the public already has access to information about the danger to public health and safety because the complaint is filed with the court and is never confidential. It is also unnecessary, opponents contend, because the California Code of Civil Procedure already requires "a court to analyze the proposed information sought to be covered by a protective order during discovery to determine whether good cause exists to keep it from public disclosure." Finally, the coalition argues that settlement agreements rarely contain evidence of a danger to public health or safety.
The California Defense Counsel (CDC) opposes this bill for some of the same reasons put forth by the Chamber-led coalition, but CDC's opposition focuses more on the likely practical impact of the bill on complex products liability cases. While CDC writes that it has "no quarrel with the goal of protecting Californians from death or serious injury, the practical effect of AB 899 as it will be amended will be to impede discovery, slow cases, expose lawyers to second-guessing by the State Bar, and interfere with the finality of judgments in civil cases." CDC especially opposes the provision of the bill that will require courts to make an independent finding about whether the information is related to a danger to public health and safety before issuing a protective order, "even where the opposing parties have stipulated to the issuance of the order." CDC believes that judges have "neither the time nor expertise to 'look behind' every stipulation in order to make an independent assessment of public danger. The test for issuing the order is so difficult that it could make protective orders almost impossible to obtain."
Finally, the California Judges Association (CJA) argues that the bill will "result in an entirely new, extensive, and burdensome role for the courts. How would the court know of the existence of a danger to public health and safety? Under AB 889, the court would be required to review sua sponte the files in every case with a stipulated protective order or other order to determine whether or not there are facts relevant to the existence of a danger to public health or safety."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Newspaper Publisher Associations
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Consumers Union
Opposition
California Chamber of Commerce
California Association of Health Facilities
California Building Industry Association
California Defense Counsel
California Forestry Association
California Hospital Association
California Judges Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Paint Council
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association – CompTIA
LeadingAge California
National Federation of Independent Business
Orange County Business Council
Southwest California Legislative Council
The American Coatings Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):