AB 915: Planning and zoning: density bonus: affordable housing ordinances: City and County of San Francisco.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-08-21
The Planning and Zoning Law requires, when an applicant proposes a housing development within the jurisdiction of a local government, that the city, county, or city and county provide the developer with a density bonus and other incentives or concessions for the production of lower income housing units or for the donation of land within the development if the developer, among other things, agrees to construct a specified percentage of units for very low, low-, or moderate-income households or qualifying residents.
This bill would require authorize the City and County of San Francisco, if it has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to these provisions, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance. after there has been an affirmative declaration made by the Department of Housing and Community Development that the affordable housing minimum percentage required is broadly feasible for density bonus projects, as provided. The bill would provide that it would not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the City and County of San Francisco.
The Planning and Zoning Law requires, when an applicant proposes a housing development within the jurisdiction of a local government, that the city, county, or city and county provide the developer with a density bonus and other incentives or concessions for the production of lower income housing units or for the donation of land within the development if the developer, among other things, agrees to construct a specified percentage of units for very low, low-, or moderate-income households or qualifying residents.
This bill would require the City and County of San Francisco, if it has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to these provisions, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance. The bill would provide that it would not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the City and County of San Francisco.
The Planning and Zoning Law requires, when an applicant proposes a housing development within the jurisdiction of a local government, that the city, county, or city and county provide the developer with a density bonus and other incentives or concessions for the production of lower income housing units or for the donation of land within the development if the developer, among other things, agrees to construct a specified percentage of units for very low, low-, or moderate-income households or qualifying residents.
This bill would require a city, county, or city and county that the City and County of San Francisco, if it has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments developments, to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to these provisions, unless the city, county, or city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the City and County of San Francisco.
The Planning and Zoning Law requires, when an applicant proposes a housing development within the jurisdiction of a local government, that the city, county, or city and county provide the developer with a density bonus and other incentives or concessions for the production of lower income housing units or for the donation of land within the development if the developer, among other things, agrees to construct a specified percentage of units for very low, low-, or moderate-income households or qualifying residents.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would authorize local governments to require an applicant for a permit for a housing development to include affordable housing units in that development without receiving a density bonus or other incentives or concessions provided pursuant to the above-described provisions.This bill would require a city, county, or city and county that has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to these provisions, unless the city, county, or city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
The Planning and Zoning Law requires, when an applicant proposes a housing development within the jurisdiction of a local government, that the city, county, or city and county provide the developer with a density bonus and other incentives or concessions for the production of lower income housing units or for the donation of land within the development if the developer, among other things, agrees to construct a specified percentage of units for very low, low-, or moderate-income households or qualifying residents.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would authorize local governments to require an applicant for a permit for a housing development to include affordable housing units in that development without receiving a density bonus or other incentives or concessions provided pursuant to the above-described provisions.
(a)If the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, the city and county shall may apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Section 65915, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance. after there has been an affirmative declaration made by the Department of Housing and Community Development that the affordable housing minimum percentage required is broadly feasible for density bonus projects, which the department shall make by June 30, 2018. The feasibility assessment shall include, but not be limited to, confirmation that the minimum percentage will not reduce the amount of total housing produced pursuant to the density bonus, and will not reduce the amount of affordable housing produced pursuant to the density bonus. Any affirmative declaration by the department shall expire on June 30 of the following calendar year, at which point it may be reauthorized by the department for one year, as provided above. This reauthorization shall be sent with the departments response to the City and County of San Franciscos annual production report, outlined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 65400. If the department fails to issue an affirmative or negative declaration to reauthorize by June 30 of the following calendar year, the City and County of San Francisco may apply that ordinance to development for a one-time, one-year grace period, after which the authorization shall lapse until the department issues an affirmative declaration.
(b)This section does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the uniquely severe shortage of affordable housing within the City and County of San Francisco.(a)If the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, the city and county shall apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Section 65915, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
(b)This section does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the uniquely severe shortage of affordable housing within the City and County of San Francisco.
If a city, county, or city and county the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, the city, county, or city and county shall apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Section 65915, unless the city, county, or city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the uniquely severe shortage of affordable housing within the City and County of San Francisco.
If a city, county, or city and county has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing developments, the city, county, or city and county shall apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Section 65915, unless the city, county, or city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would authorize local governments to require an applicant for a permit for a housing development to include affordable housing units in that development without receiving a density bonus or other incentives or concessions provided pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would authorize local governments to require an applicant for a permit for a housing development to include affordable housing units in that development without receiving a density bonus or other incentives or concessions provided pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2017 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 28, 2017 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 22, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| Aug 21, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 20, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 4.) (July 18). |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Referred to Com. on T. & H. |
| Jun 5, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 41. Noes 28. Page 2057.) |
| May 15, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 11, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 3.) (May 10). |
| May 3, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| May 2, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. Read second time and amended. |
| May 2, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| May 1, 2017 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 27, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 26). |
| Mar 16, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Mar 15, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on H. & C.D. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 9, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and L. GOV. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 18, 2017 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2017 | AB 915 TING Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 10, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2017 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Local Government] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 915 (Ting) - Planning and zoning: density bonus: affordable housing ordinances: City and County of San Francisco
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 915 would authorize San Francisco to apply its inclusionary housing ordinance to the total number of housing units in a proposed development, including any additional units granted under the Density Bonus Law, but only after the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) has determined that the ordinance is broadly feasible for density bonus projects, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- HCD estimates one-time contract costs in the range of $400,000 to $500,000 to conduct a feasibility study to determine the feasibility of San Francisco’s inclusionary ordinance for density bonus projects. See staff comments. (General Fund)
Background:
Existing law requires a city or county to adopt an ordinance that specifies how it will implement state Density Bonus Law, which requires the grant of a specified density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of 5 or more units agrees to construct a project with at least any of the following: (1) 10% of housing units dedicated for lower income households; (2) 5% of units for very low-income households; (3) a senior citizen development or mobilehome park; or (4) 10% of units in a common interest development for moderate income households. The applicant must ensure the units remain affordable for at least 55 years. A density bonus generally allows the developer to increase density of by up to 20% over the otherwise maximum allowable residential density under the applicable zoning ordinance.
In addition to the density bonus, a local agency must also provide concessions and incentives based on the number of below market-rate units included in the project, as specified. Concessions may include a reduction in site development standards, modification of zoning or design requirements that exceed minimum building standards, approval of mixed-use zoning if such uses are compatible, or other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city or county that result in identifiable cost reductions.
Some local agencies have also adopted “inclusionary” ordinances that require a minimum amount of units in a residential development to be available at specified affordable prices for low- and/or moderate-income households. Recent lawsuits have determined that inclusionary ordinances fail to comply with the Density Bonus Law if they don’t credit affordable units towards density bonus requirements until the requirements of an inclusionary ordinance are satisfied.
Proposed Law:
AB 915 would authorize the City and County of San Francisco to apply an adopted inclusionary ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted under the Density Bonus Law, after HCD has made an affirmative declaration that the affordable housing minimum requirement in the inclusionary ordinance is broadly feasible for density bonus projects.
HCD must make the feasibility assessment by June 30, 2018, and it must include confirmation that the minimum percentage will not reduce the amount of total housing or affordable housing produced pursuant to the density bonus. The affirmative declaration would expire on June 30, 2019, at which point HCD may reauthorize the declaration for an additional year. If HCD fails to issue an affirmative or negative declaration by June 30 of the following year, San Francisco may apply the ordinance to development for a one-time grace period of one year, after which the affirmation would lapse until HCD issues an affirmative declaration.
The bill would not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if the application was submitted or processed before January 1, 2018.
Related Legislation:
AB 2501 (Bloom), Chap. 578/2016, made a number of changes to density bonus law, including clarifications regarding the processing of density bonus applications.
Staff Comments:
HCD indicates that it lacks in-house expertise to determine the economic feasibility of whether San Francisco’s inclusionary ordinance would have a negative impact on housing production, including affordable housing, if it were applied to density bonus projects, and calculated based on the total number of units, including those added through the density bonus. According to HCD, the complexity of the variables in making a determination, the specific nature of the local housing market, and the value of any concessions or incentives provided under the Density Bonus Law would require a contract with an outside consultant at an estimated cost of $400,000 to $500,000.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 915 Hearing Date: 7/18/2017
Author: | Ting | ||
Version: | 5/2/2017 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Alison Hughes | ||
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: density bonus: affordable housing ordinances: City and County of San Francisco
DIGEST: This bill requires the City and County of San Francisco, if it has adopted an inclusionary ordinance, to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to density bonus law, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires all local governments to adopt an ordinance that specifies how they will implement state density bonus law and requires local governments to grant a density bonus, when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project, that will contain at least any one of the following:
- 10% of the total units for lower-income households
- 5% of the total units of a housing for very low-income households
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park
- 10% of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households
- Requires that the applicant agree to, and the local government to ensure, continued affordability of all low- and very low-income units that qualified the applicant for the density bonus for at least 55 years
- Requires the local government to allow an increase in density of 20% over the otherwise maximum allowable residential density under the applicable zoning ordinance and land-use element of the general plan for low-income, very low-income, or senior housing, and by 5% for moderate-income housing in a CID.
- Requires that the density bonus for low-, very low-, and moderate-income units increase incrementally according a set formula.
- Requires cities and counties to provide an applicant for a density bonus with concessions and incentives based on the number of below market-rate units included in the project as follows:
- One incentive or concession, if the project includes at least 10% of the total units for low-income households, 5% for very low-income households, or 10% for moderate-income households in a CID
- Two incentives or concessions, if the project includes at least 20% of the total units for low-income households, 10% for very low-income households, or 20% for moderate-income households in a CID
- Three incentives or concessions, if the project includes at least 30% of the total units for low-income households, 15% for very low-income households, or 30% for moderate-income households in a CID
- Specifies that concessions or incentives may include the following:
- A reduction in site development standards;
- A modification of zoning code requirements or architectural design requirements that exceed the minimum building standards — including a reduction in setbacks, square footage requirements, or parking requirements — that results in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions;
- Approval of mixed-use zoning in conjunction with the housing project, if commercial, office, industrial, or other land uses will reduce the cost of the housing development, and if such nonresidential uses are compatible with the project;
- Other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city or county that result in identifiable cost reductions.
This bill:
- Requires the City and County of San Francisco, if it has adopted an inclusionary ordinance, to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to density bonus law, unless the city and county exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
- Provides that (1) does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “housing costs are skyrocketing in San Francisco. We need to flip the switch so that local planning leads to more affordable housing by default. By linking housing density with affordability, we will get more affordable housing to ease the exodus of working families from our neighborhoods. No community does this and it’s time for us to show the state how it’s done.”
- Density Bonus Law. Given California’s high land and construction costs for housing, it is extremely difficult for the private market to provide housing units that are affordable to low- and even moderate-income households. Public subsidy is often required to fill the financial gap on affordable units. Density bonus is a tool to encourage the production of affordable housing by market rate developers, although it is used by developers building 100% affordable developments as well. In return for inclusion of affordable units in a development, developers are given an increase in density over a city's zoned density and concessions and incentives. The increase in density and concessions and incentives are intended to financially support the inclusion of the affordable units. Additionally, density bonus law allows public entities to reduce or even eliminate subsidies for a particular project by allowing a developer to include more total units in a project than would otherwise be allowed by the local zoning in exchange for affordable units. Allowing more total units permits the developer to spread the cost of the affordable units more broadly over the market-rate units. The idea of density bonus law is to cover at least some of the financing gap of affordable housing with regulatory incentives, rather than additional subsidy.
All local governments are required to adopt an ordinance that provides concessions and incentives to developers that seek a density bonus on top of the a city's zoned density in exchange for including extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income housing. Failure to adopt an ordinance does not relieve a local government from complying with state density bonus law. Under existing law, if a developer proposes to construct a housing development with a specified percentage of affordable units, the city or county must provide all of the following benefits: a density bonus, incentives, or concessions (hereafter referred to as incentives); waiver of any development standards that prevent the developer from utilizing the density bonus or incentives; and reduced parking standards.
- Latinos Unidos del Valle De Napa y Solano v. County of Napa. In 2013, the First District Court of Appeal heard a suit brought by low income farmworkers in Napa County (Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013)). The lawsuit attacked the validity of the housing element, the County’s density bonus ordinance and the discrimination against affordable housing and minorities allegedly caused by the County’s zoning laws. The Court of Appeal reversed in part the trial court judgment and held that the county's density bonus ordinance unlawfully conflicts with the state Density Bonus Law.
In 2010, Napa County adopted an ordinance implementing state Density Bonus Law, which required local governments to grant a density bonus and certain incentives and concessions when a developer agrees to include a certain percentage of affordable units. At the same time, Napa also adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance that required up to 20% of new dwelling units in a residential development project to be made available at prices affordable to moderate-income households. However, the inclusionary ordinance stated that affordable units that qualify a project for a density bonus must be provided in addition to the affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. So, for example, if a developer includes 10% low- income units to qualify for a density bonus (as required by state law), this would not count towards the percentage of affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. The court, looking at previous case law and legislative history, agreed with plaintiffs that Napa County's density bonus ordinance was invalid in that it would require a developer to go above and beyond state law requirements to obtain a density bonus. The court noted that "[a] handful of local jurisdictions have argued since 1979 that the density bonus law does not apply until inclusionary requirements have been met. The vast majority of cities, counties and experts take the opposite view, as do I." The county's ordinance, which failed to credit affordable units satisfying the county's inclusionary requirement toward satisfying the density bonus requirements, failed to comply with state law.
- Impact on Density Bonus Law. Density bonus law prohibits a city from requiring a developer to include more affordable units in a development than is required by statute in return for the increase in density. The intent of the law is to provide a strong enough incentive in the form of a density bonus and incentives and concessions to encourage developers to use the law and build the affordable units. Most jurisdictions take density bonus law into account in their planning ordinances including their inclusionary ordinance, if they have one. The majority of cities interpreted the law prior to Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013) to require them to count the affordable housing units required under an inclusionary ordinance toward satisfying density bonus requirements.
This bill will require developers to provide more affordable units than is required under density bonus law to receive the density bonus, unless the city takes steps to exempt those units. In cities without inclusionary ordinances, this bill would not affect density bonus projects. In cities with inclusionary ordinances, this bill could have the effect of increasing the percentages of affordable housing for density bonus projects, unless the city exempts those additional units from the ordinance.
For example: Under density bonus law, if a developer agrees to make 11% of the units in a 100 unit development restricted to very-low income, the developer gets a density bonus of 35%. The total number of units in the development becomes 135. The developer provides 11 very-low income affordable units and, in return, gets 35 extra market rate units to help offset the cost of the very-low income units. If the local jurisdiction has an inclusionary ordinance of 25%, this ordinance would only apply to the 100 units in the base project, requiring the developer to provide a total of 25 affordable units. If this bill were to pass, the 25% inclusionary ordinance would apply to the final project, which includes the extra density bonus units (135 units). As a result, the developer would be required to provide 34 affordable units (25% of 135).
- Impacts on housing developments. It's unclear what impact this would have on developers' willingness to use density bonus. The end result could lead to a reduction in the number of affordable units the state is able to gain from private developers. In addition, cities who do not wish to encourage housing production, density, and the inclusion of affordable housing in mixed-income developments could impose on-site inclusionary requirements or in lieu inclusionary fees specifically on units awarded as a density bonus that could make construction of units economically infeasible. This bill is also structured as an opt-out, so any city with an inclusionary ordinance would have to amend their ordinance to explicitly exempt density bonus units even though they have no issue with the status quo. The committee may wish to consider that the unintended consequences of the passage of this bill could result in the production of less housing, particularly for the lower income households that most desperately need it. The committee may also wish to consider adding a sunset in 3 years and require City and County to provide a report to HCD and the Legislature within 6 months following the sunset that provides an analysis of the number of housing developments approved prior to and after the passage of this bill.
- Opposition. A coalition including the California Apartment Association, California Association of Realtors, California Building Industry Association, California Chamber of Commerce, – California Renters Legal Advocacy and Education Fund, San Francisco Housing Action Coalition, and Yes in My Backyard Tenant Action San Francisco writes that this bill “imposes even more below-market rate unit requirements on the density bonus granted to the developer, thereby completely defeating the purpose of the density bonus. A density bonus is a way to ensure that a development will ‘pencil’ once completed and rents are calculated. By forcing an additional number of affordable units in exchange for a density bonus, AB 915 renders the density bonus useless and makes new housing developments financially infeasible. AB 915 will increase the cost of housing by make projects financially infeasible, delaying them, and increasing their costs. In a city like San Francisco, which already has the highest inclusionary requirements, many proposed housing developments are only financially feasible if they receive density bonus units under the current law program.”
Related Legislation:
AB 2501 (Bloom, Chapter 578, Statutes of 2016) — made a number of changes to density bonus law, including clarifying the processing of a density bonus application.
Assembly Votes
Floor: 41-28
L.Gov: 6-3
H&CD: 5-2
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
July 12, 2017.)
SUPPORT:
Council of Community Housing Organizations
Homeownership San Francisco
Livable City
Mission Economic Development Agency
PODER
San Francisco Mayor, Ed Lee
Santa Monicans for Renters’ Rights
Senior and Disability Action
Tenants Together
OPPOSITION:
Bay Area Renters Federation
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Renters Legal Advocacy and Education Fund
East Bay Forward
Grow the Richmond
Progress Noe
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Tech for Housing
YIMBY Action
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 915
Author:(Ting)
As Amended Ver:May 2, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Housing | 5-2 | Chiu, Bocanegra, Chau, Kalra, Limón | Steinorth, Choi |
Local Government | 6-3 | Aguiar-Curry, Bloom, Caballero, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Ridley-Thomas | Waldron, Lackey, Voepel |
SUMMARY: Requires, if the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance, that the City and County apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units, including any additional housing units granted under a density bonus, unless the city, county or city and county exempts those additional units from the ordinance. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, if the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing development, the City and County to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Density Bonus law, unless the City and County exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
- Specifies that 1), above, does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
- Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of California Constitution Article IV Section 16 because of the uniquely severe shortage of affordable housing within the City and County of San Francisco.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all cities and counties to adopt an ordinance that specifies how they will implement state density bonus law.
- Requires cities and counties to grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Ten percent of the total units for lower income households;
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
- Requires that the density bonus for low-, very low-, and moderate-income units increase incrementally according to the following formula:
- For each 1% increase above 10% for low-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1.5% to a maximum of 35%;
- For each 1% increase above 5% for very low income units, the density bonus shall increase by 2.5% to a maximum of 35%; and,
- For each 1% increase above 10% for moderate-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1% to a maximum of 35%.
- Requires cities and counties to provide an applicant for a density bonus concessions and incentives based on the number of below market-rate units included in the project as follows:
- One incentive or concession if the project includes at least 10% of the total units for low-income households, 5% for very low-income households, or 10% for moderate-income households in a CID;
- Two incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 20% of the total units for low-income households, 10% for very low-income households, or 20% for moderate-income households in a CID; and
- Three incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 30% of the total units for low-income households, 15% for very low-income households, or 30% for moderate-income households in a CID.
- Specifies that concessions or incentives may include the following:
- A reduction in site development standards;
- A modification of zoning code requirements or architectural design requirements that exceed the minimum building standards, including a reduction in setbacks, square footage requirements, or parking requirements, that results in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions.
- Approval of mixed-use zoning in conjunction with the housing project if commercial, office, industrial, or other land uses will reduce the cost of the housing development, and if such nonresidential uses are compatible with the project; or
- Other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city or county that result in identifiable cost reductions.
- Requires the local government to grant the incentive or concession requested by the developer unless the city or county makes written findings that:
- The concession or incentive is not needed to provide the affordable housing; or
- That the concession or incentive would have a specific adverse impact on health and safety, the environment, or an historical resource.
- Prohibits a city or county from applying any development standard that will have the effect of precluding the construction of housing that qualifies for a density bonus at the densities or with the concessions or incentives required by density bonus law.
- Allows a developer to request a waiver or reduction of development standards.
- Specifies that the developer must show that the requested waiver or modification of development standards is necessary to make the housing units economically feasible.
- Defines "development standard" to include site and construction conditions that apply to a residential development pursuant to any ordinance, general plan element, specific plan, charter amendment, or other local condition, law, policy, resolution, or regulation.
- Requires a city or county to grant either an additional density bonus or and additional concession or incentive when the applicant proposes to include a child care facility in or adjacent to the housing development.
- Provides a 15% density bonus to the developer of any market-rate housing project who donates land to a city or county that could accommodate housing for very low-income households equal to at least 10% of the number of units in the market-rate development. For each one percent increase above the 10% the density bonus shall increase by one percent up to a maximum combined density increase of 35%.
FISCAL EFFECT: None.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill: According to the author, "housing costs are uprooting families and reducing access to high-wage jobs of the future. Across California, families overpay for housing and are commuting great distances from what they can affordable. This bill will mean communities get more affordable housing when awarding developers bonus units for greater housing density." The author included an example of a project in San Francisco, in which a developer of a 200-unit market rate project at 333 12th Street added two full floors and 52 additional market rate units per the state density bonus, reducing the inclusionary housing obligation from 18% to 13%.
Background: Density bonus law was originally enacted in 1979, to help address the affordable housing shortage and to encourage development of more low- and moderate-income housing units. Nearly 40 years later, the Legislature faces the same challenges. Density bonus is a tool to encourage the production of affordable housing by market rate developers, although it is used by developers building 100% affordable developments as well. In return for inclusion of affordable units in a development, developers are given an increase in density over a city's zoned density and concessions and incentives. The increase in density and concessions and incentives are intended to financially support the inclusion of the affordable units.
All local governments are required to adopt an ordinance that provides concessions and incentives to developers that seek a density bonus on top of the a city's zoned density in exchange for including extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income housing. Failure to adopt an ordinance does not relieve a local government from complying with state density bonus law. Local governments must grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low income households;
- Ten percent of the total units for lower income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
A developer can submit a request to a local government as part of their density bonus application for incentives and concessions. Developers can receive the following number of incentives or concessions:
- One incentive or concession for projects that include at least 10% of the total units for lower income households, at least 5% for very low income households, or at least 10% for moderate income households in a common interest development
- Two incentives or concessions for projects with at least 20% lower income households, at least 10% for very low income households, or at least 20% for moderate income households in common interest developments.
- Three incentives or concessions for projects with at least 30% lower income households, at least 15% for very low income households, or at least 30% for moderate income households in common interest developments.
Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa: In 2013, the First District Court of Appeal heard a suit brought by low income farmworkers in Napa County (Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013)). The suit attacked the validity of the housing element, the County’s density bonus ordinance and the discrimination against affordable housing and minorities allegedly caused by the County's zoning laws. The Court of Appeal reversed in part the trial court judgment and held that the county's density bonus ordinance unlawfully conflicts with the state Density Bonus Law.
In 2010, Napa County adopted an ordinance implementing state Density Bonus Law, which required local governments to grant a density bonus and certain incentives and concessions when a developer agrees to include a certain percentage of affordable units. At the same time, Napa also adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance that required up to 20% of new dwelling units in a residential development project to be made available at prices affordable to moderate-income households. However, the inclusionary ordinance stated that affordable units that qualify a project for a density bonus must be provided in addition to the affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. So, for example, if a developer includes 10% low- income units to qualify for a density bonus (as required by state law), this would not count towards the percentage of affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. The court, looking at previous case law and legislative history, agreed with plaintiffs that Napa County's density bonus ordinance was invalid in that it would require a developer to go above and beyond state law requirements to obtain a density bonus. The court noted that "[a] handful of local jurisdictions have argued since 1979 that the density bonus law does not apply until inclusionary requirements have been met. The vast majority of cities, counties and experts take the opposite view, as do I." The county's ordinance, which failed to credit affordable units satisfying the county's inclusionary requirement toward satisfying the density bonus requirements, failed to comply with state law.
Example: Under density bonus law, if a developer agrees to make 11% of the units in a 100 unit development restricted to very-low income, the developer gets a density bonus of 35%. The total number of units becomes 135. The developer provides 11 very-low income affordable units and, in return, gets 35 extra market rate units to help offset the cost of the very-low income units. If the local jurisdiction has an inclusionary ordinance of 25%, this ordinance would only apply to the base project of 100 units requiring the developer to provide a total of 25 affordable units. If this bill were to pass, the 25% inclusionary ordinance would apply to the final project, extra density bonus units included – 135 units. As a result, the developer would be required to provide 34 affordable units.
Arguments in support: According to supporters, "current law allows housing developments to have density bonus units added to a project through the density bonus statutes, and these units are completely outside the affordability requirements of a city. Density bonus and affordability requirements can work together, which is critical as California struggles to meet housing needs and affordability. AB 915 strikes a commonsense balance that the total number of units in a housing development are subject to the affordability requirements of a city, unless the jurisdiction chooses otherwise. CCHO [Council of Community Housing Organizations] has been an active leader in the affordable housing movement for more than three decades and our organization is proud to have been directly involved in crafting San Francisco's inclusionary housing policy 15 years ago, which is why we strongly support AB 915."
Arguments in opposition: According to opponents, this bill would undermine California State Density Bonus, which is a critical part in helping to address California's chronic housing shortage. "The State Density Bonus Law was created as a means of increasing the production of affordable housing and of removing the impediments to such production. We understand the intent of AB 915 is to bring on line more affordable units by including the calculation the added units granted the developer through a density bonus. As you know, density bonus law was created as incentive for a developer to agree to include a minimum number of affordable units in exchange for more market rate units; it was to ensure that the development would 'pencil' once completed and rents are calculated. By forcing an additional number of affordable units in exchange for a density bonus, AB 915 will create a disincentive for developers to enter into an agreement with the local government at all."
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0000369
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 915 (
Author:Ting) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2017
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: density bonus: affordable housing ordinances: City and County of San Francisco.
SUMMARY: Requires, if the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance, that the City and County apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units, including any additional housing units granted under a density bonus, unless the city, county or city and county exempts those additional units from the ordinance. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, if the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing development, the City and County to apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Density Bonus law, unless the City and County exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance.
- Specifies that 1), above, does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
- Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the uniquely severe shortage of affordable housing within the City and County of San Francisco.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all cities and counties to adopt an ordinance that specifies how they will implement state density bonus law.
- Requires cities and counties to grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Ten percent of the total units for lower-income households;
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low-income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
- Requires that the density bonus for low-, very low-, and moderate-income units increase incrementally according to the following formula:
- For each 1% increase above 10% for low-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1.5% to a maximum of 35%;
- For each 1% increase above 5% for very low-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 2.5% to a maximum of 35%; and,
- For each 1% increase above 10% for moderate-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1% to a maximum of 35%.
- Requires cities and counties to provide an applicant for a density bonus concessions and incentives based on the number of below market-rate units included in the project as follows:
- One incentive or concession if the project includes at least 10% of the total units for low-income households, 5% for very low-income households, or 10% for moderate-income households in a CID;
- Two incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 20% of the total units for low-income households, 10% for very low-income households, or 20% for moderate-income households in a CID; and,
- Three incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 30% of the total units for low-income households, 15% for very low-income households, or 30% for moderate-income households in a CID.
- Specifies that concessions or incentives may include the following:
- A reduction in site development standards;
- A modification of zoning code requirements or architectural design requirements that exceed the minimum building standards, including a reduction in setbacks, square footage requirements, or parking requirements, that results in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions;
- Approval of mixed-use zoning in conjunction with the housing project if commercial, office, industrial, or other land uses will reduce the cost of the housing development, and if such nonresidential uses are compatible with the project; or,
- Other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city or county that result in identifiable cost reductions.
- Requires the local government to grant the incentive or concession requested by the developer, unless the city or county makes written findings that:
- The concession or incentive is not needed to provide the affordable housing; or,
- That the concession or incentive would have a specific adverse impact on health and safety, the environment, or an historical resource.
- Prohibits a city or county from applying any development standard that will have the effect of precluding the construction of housing that qualifies for a density bonus at the densities or with the concessions or incentives required by density bonus law.
- Allows a developer to request a waiver or reduction of development standards.
- Specifies that the developer must show that the requested waiver or modification of development standards is necessary to make the housing units economically feasible.
- Defines "development standard" to include site and construction conditions that apply to a residential development pursuant to any ordinance, general plan element, specific plan, charter amendment, or other local condition, law, policy, resolution, or regulation.
- Requires a city or county to grant either an additional density bonus or an additional concession or incentive when the applicant proposes to include a child care facility in or adjacent to the housing development.
- Provides a 15% density bonus to the developer of any market-rate housing project who donates land to a city or county that could accommodate housing for very low-income households equal to at least 10 % of the number of units in the market-rate development. For each one percent increase above the 10 % the density bonus shall increase by one percent up to a maximum combined density increase of 35 %.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- Bill Summary. This bill requires, if the City and County of San Francisco has adopted an ordinance requiring an affordable housing minimum percentage for housing development, that the City and County apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units in the development, including any additional housing units granted pursuant to Density Bonus law, unless the City and County exempts those additional housing units from the ordinance. The bill specifies that this does not apply to an applicant seeking a density bonus for a proposed housing development if his or her application was submitted to, or processed by, the City and County of San Francisco before January 1, 2018.
This bill is sponsored by the author.
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “Housing costs are uprooting families and reducing access to high-wage jobs of the future. Across California, families overpay for housing and commute great distances from what they can afford. This bill will mean communities get more affordable housing when awarding developers bonus units for greater housing density.”
- Background on Density Bonus Law. Density bonus law was originally enacted in 1979, to help address the affordable housing shortage and to encourage development of more low- and moderate-income housing units. Nearly forty years later, the Legislature faces the same challenges. Density bonus is a tool to encourage the production of affordable housing by market rate developers, although it is used by developers building 100% affordable developments as well. In return for inclusion of affordable units in a development, developers are given an increase in density over a city's zoned density and concessions and incentives. The increase in density and concessions and incentives are intended to financially support the inclusion of the affordable units.
All local governments are required to adopt an ordinance that provides concessions and incentives to developers that seek a density bonus on top of a city's zoned density in exchange for including extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income housing. Failure to adopt an ordinance does not relieve a local government from complying with state density bonus law. Local governments must grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low-income households;
- Ten percent of the total units for lower-income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
A developer can submit a request to a local government as part of their density bonus application for incentives and concessions. Developers can receive the following number of incentives or concessions:
- One incentive or concession for projects that include at least 10% of the total units for lower income households, at least 5% for very low-income households, or at least 10% for moderate-income households in a common interest development.
- Two incentives or concessions for projects with at least 20% lower-income households, at least 10% for very low-income households, or at least 20% for moderate-income households in common interest developments.
- Three incentives or concessions for projects with at least 30% lower-income households, at least 15% for very low-income households, or at least 30% for moderate-income households in common interest developments.
- Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa: In 2013, the First District Court of Appeal heard a suit brought by low-income farmworkers in Napa County (Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013)). The suit attacked the validity of the housing element, the County’s density bonus ordinance and the discrimination against affordable housing and minorities allegedly caused by the County’s zoning laws. The Court of Appeal reversed in part the trial court judgment and held that the county's density bonus ordinance unlawfully conflicts with the state Density Bonus Law.
In 2010, Napa County adopted an ordinance implementing state Density Bonus Law, which required local governments to grant a density bonus and certain incentives and concessions when a developer agrees to include a certain percentage of affordable units. At the same time, Napa also adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance that required up to 20% of new dwelling units in a residential development project to be made available at prices affordable to moderate-income households. However, the inclusionary ordinance stated that affordable units that qualify a project for a density bonus must be provided in addition to the affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. So, for example, if a developer includes 10% low- income units to qualify for a density bonus (as required by state law), this would not count towards the percentage of affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. The court, looking at previous case law and legislative history, agreed with plaintiffs that Napa County's density bonus ordinance was invalid in that it would require a developer to go above and beyond state law requirements to obtain a density bonus. The court noted that "[a] handful of local jurisdictions have argued since 1979 that the density bonus law does not apply until inclusionary requirements have been met. The vast majority of cities, counties and experts take the opposite view, as do I." The county's ordinance, which failed to credit affordable units satisfying the county's inclusionary requirement toward satisfying the density bonus requirements, failed to comply with state law.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that the bill strikes a commonsense balance that the total number of units in a housing development are subject to the affordability requirements of the city, unless the jurisdiction chooses otherwise.
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents believe that forcing an additional number of affordable units in exchange for a density bonus will create a disincentive for developers to enter into an agreement with the local government at all.
- Double-Referral. The March 15, 2017, version of this bill, which was applicable to all cities and counties, was heard in the Housing and Community Development Committee on April 26, 2017, and passed on a 5-2 vote. Amendments taken in that Committee narrowed the scope of the bill to only include the City and County of San Francisco.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION (All letters received from groups below were referencing the March 15, 2017, version of the bill):
Support
Council of Community Housing Organizations
Homeownership San Francisco
Mission Economic Development Agency
PODER
Santa Monicans for Renters’ Rights
Senior and Disability Action
Tenants Together
Opposition
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
CalChamber
California Renters Legal Advocacy and Education Fund
East Bay Forward
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Grow the Richmond
North Valley Property Owner Association
Progress Noe
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Tech for Housing
YIMBY Action
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 915 (
Author:Ting) – As Amended Ver:March 15, 2017
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: density bonus: affordable housing ordinances
SUMMARY: Provides that if a city, county, or city and county has adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance then the city, county, or city and county shall apply that ordinance to the total number of housing units, including any additional housing units granted under a density bonus, unless the city, county or city and county exempts those additional units from the ordinance.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all cities and counties to adopt an ordinance that specifies how they will implement state density bonus law.
- Requires cities and counties to grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Ten percent of the total units for lower income households;
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
- Requires that the density bonus for low-, very low-, and moderate-income units increase incrementally according to the following formula:
- For each 1% increase above 10% for low-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1.5% to a maximum of 35%;
- For each 1% increase above 5% for very low income units, the density bonus shall increase by 2.5% to a maximum of 35%; and,
- For each 1% increase above 10% for moderate-income units, the density bonus shall increase by 1% to a maximum of 35%.
- Requires cities and counties to provide an applicant for a density bonus concessions and incentives based on the number of below market-rate units included in the project as follows:
- One incentive or concession if the project includes at least 10% of the total units for low-income households, 5% for very low-income households, or 10% for moderate-income households in a CID;
- Two incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 20% of the total units for low-income households, 10% for very low-income households, or 20% for moderate-income households in a CID; and
- Three incentives or concessions if the project includes at least 30% of the total units for low-income households, 15% for very low-income households, or 30% for moderate-income households in a CID.
- Specifies that concessions or incentives may include the following:
- A reduction in site development standards;
- A modification of zoning code requirements or architectural design requirements that exceed the minimum building standards, including a reduction in setbacks, square footage requirements, or parking requirements, that results in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions.
- Approval of mixed-use zoning in conjunction with the housing project if commercial, office, industrial, or other land uses will reduce the cost of the housing development, and if such nonresidential uses are compatible with the project; or
- Other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city or county that result in identifiable cost reductions.
- Requires the local government to grant the incentive or concession requested by the developer unless the city or county makes written findings that:
- The concession or incentive is not needed to provide the affordable housing; or
- That the concession or incentive would have a specific adverse impact on health and safety, the environment, or an historical resource.
- Prohibits a city or county from applying any development standard that will have the effect of precluding the construction of housing that qualifies for a density bonus at the densities or with the concessions or incentives required by density bonus law.
- Allows a developer to request a waiver or reduction of development standards.
- Specifies that the developer must show that the requested waiver or modification of development standards is necessary to make the housing units economically feasible.
- Defines "development standard" to include site and construction conditions that apply to a residential development pursuant to any ordinance, general plan element, specific plan, charter amendment, or other local condition, law, policy, resolution, or regulation.
- Requires a city or county to grant either an additional density bonus or and additional concession or incentive when the applicant proposes to include a child care facility in or adjacent to the housing development.
- Provides a 15% density bonus to the developer of any market-rate housing project who donates land to a city or county that could accommodate housing for very low-income households equal to at least 10 percent of the number of units in the market-rate development. For each one percent increase above the 10 percent the density bonus shall increase by one percent up to a maximum combined density increase of 35 percent.
FISCAL EFFECT: None.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill: According to the author, "housing costs are uprooting families and reducing access to high-wage jobs of the future. Across California, families overpay for housing and are commuting great distances from what they can affordable. This bill will mean communities get more affordable housing when awarding developers bonus units for greater housing density." The author included an example of a project in San Francisco, in which a developer of a 200-unit market rate project at 333 12th Street added two full floors and 52 additional market rate units per the state density bonus, reducing the inclusionary housing obligation from 18% to 13%.
Background: Density bonus law was originally enacted in 1979, to help address the affordable housing shortage and to encourage development of more low- and moderate-income housing units. Nearly forty years later, the Legislature faces the same challenges. Density bonus is a tool to encourage the production of affordable housing by market rate developers, although it is used by developers building 100% affordable developments as well. In return for inclusion of affordable units in a development, developers are given an increase in density over a city's zoned density and concessions and incentives. The increase in density and concessions and incentives are intended to financially support the inclusion of the affordable units.
All local governments are required to adopt an ordinance that provides concessions and incentives to developers that seek a density bonus on top of the a city's zoned density in exchange for including extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income housing. Failure to adopt an ordinance does not relieve a local government from complying with state density bonus law. Local governments must grant a density bonus when an applicant for a housing development of five or more units seeks and agrees to construct a project that will contain at least any one of the following:
- Five percent of the total units of a housing for very low income households;
- Ten percent of the total units for lower income households;
- A senior citizen housing development or mobilehome park; and,
- Ten percent of the units in a common-interest development (CID) for moderate-income households.
A developer can submit a request to a local government as part of their density bonus application for incentives and concessions. Developers can receive the following number of incentives or concessions:
- One incentive or concession for projects that include at least 10% of the total units for lower income households, at least 5% for very low income households, or at least 10% for moderate income households in a common interest development
- Two incentives or concessions for projects with at least 20% lower income households, at least 10% for very low income households, or at least 20% for moderate income households in common interest developments.
- Three incentives or concessions for projects with at least 30% lower income households, at least 15% for very low income households, or at least 30% for moderate income households in common interest developments.
Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa: In 2013, the First District Court of Appeal heard a suit brought by low income farmworkers in Napa County (Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013)). The suit attacked the validity of the housing element, the County’s density bonus ordinance and the discrimination against affordable housing and minorities allegedly caused by the County’s zoning laws. The Court of Appeal reversed in part the trial court judgment and held that the county's density bonus ordinance unlawfully conflicts with the state Density Bonus Law.
In 2010, Napa County adopted an ordinance implementing state Density Bonus Law, which required local governments to grant a density bonus and certain incentives and concessions when a developer agrees to include a certain percentage of affordable units. At the same time, Napa also adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance that required up to 20% of new dwelling units in a residential development project to be made available at prices affordable to moderate-income households. However, the inclusionary ordinance stated that affordable units that qualify a project for a density bonus must be provided in addition to the affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. So, for example, if a developer includes 10% low- income units to qualify for a density bonus (as required by state law), this would not count towards the percentage of affordable units required by the inclusionary ordinance. The court, looking at previous case law and legislative history, agreed with plaintiffs that Napa County's density bonus ordinance was invalid in that it would require a developer to go above and beyond state law requirements to obtain a density bonus. The court noted that "[a] handful of local jurisdictions have argued since 1979 that the density bonus law does not apply until inclusionary requirements have been met. The vast majority of cities, counties and experts take the opposite view, as do I." The county's ordinance, which failed to credit affordable units satisfying the county's inclusionary requirement toward satisfying the density bonus requirements, failed to comply with state law.
The impact of this bill on density bonus law: Density bonus law prohibits a city from requiring a developer to include more affordable units in a development than is required by statute in return for the increase in density. The intent of the law is to provide a strong enough incentive in the form of a density bonus and incentives and concessions to encourage developers to use the law and build the affordable units. Most jurisdictions take density bonus law into account in their planning ordinances including their inclusionary ordinance, if they have one. The majority of cities interpreted the law prior to the Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013) to require them to count the affordable housing units required under an inclusionary ordinance toward satisfying density bonus requirements.
The impact of AB 915 would be to require developers to provide more affordable units than is required under density bonus law to receive the density bonus, unless the city takes steps to exempt those units. In cities without inclusionary ordinances, this bill would not affect density bonus projects. In cities with inclusionary ordinances, this bill could have the effect of increasing the percentages of affordable housing for density bonus projects, unless the city exempts those additional units from the ordinance. It's unclear what impact this would have on developers' willingness to use density bonus. The end result could lead to a reduction in the number of affordable units the state is able to glean from private developers. In addition, cities who do not wish to encourage housing production, density, and the inclusion of affordable housing in mixed-income developments could impose on-site inclusionary requirements or in lieu inclusionary fees specifically on units awarded as a density bonus that could make construction of units economically infeasible. This bill is also structured as an opt-out so any city with an inclusionary ordinance would have to amend their ordinance to explicitly exempt density bonus units even though they have no issue with the status quo.
Example: Under density bonus law, if a developer agrees to make 11% of the units in a 100 unit development restricted to very-low income, the developer gets a density bonus of 35%. The total number of units becomes 135. The developer provides 11 very-low income affordable units and, in return, gets 35 extra market rate units to help offset the cost of the very-low income units. If the local jurisdiction has an inclusionary ordinance of 25%, this ordinance would only apply to the base project of 100 units requiring the developer to provide a total of 25 affordable units. If this bill were to pass, the 25% inclusionary ordinance would apply to the final project, extra density bonus units included – 135 units. As a result, the developer would be required to provide 34 affordable units.
Arguments in support: According to the Council of Community Housing Organizations, "current law allows housing developments to have density bonus units added to a project through the density bonus statutes, and these units are completely outside the affordability requirements of a city. Density bonus and affordability requirements can work together, which is critical as California struggles to meet housing needs and affordability. AB 915 strikes a commonsense balance that the total number of units in a housing development are subject to the affordability requirements of a city, unless the jurisdiction chooses otherwise. CCHO has been an active leader in the affordable housing movement for more than three decades and our organization is proud to have been directly involved in crafting San Francisco's inclusionary housing policy 15 years ago, which is why we strongly support AB 915."
Arguments in opposition: The California Association of Realtors, California Apartment Association, California Building Industry Association, and California Chamber of Commerce are opposed to AB 915 because they contend that it undermines California State Density Bonus, which is a critical part in helping to address California's chronic housing shortage. "The State Density Bonus Law was created as a means of increasing the production of affordable housing and of removing the impediments to such production. We understand the intent of AB 915 is to bring on line more affordable units by including the calculation the added units granted the developer through a density bonus. As you know, density bonus law was created as incentive for a developer to agree to include a minimum number of affordable units in exchange for more market rate units; it was to ensure that the development would 'pencil' once completed and rents are calculated. By forcing an additional number of affordable units in exchange for a density bonus, AB 915 will create a disincentive for developers to enter into an agreement with the local government at all."
Staff comments: The predominant support for this bill is from San Francisco based organizations, although to be clear there are also organizations in San Francisco who are opposed. No other communities with an inclusionary ordinance are requesting this change and yet they will all be impacted by it. Since the concerns with how density bonus law impacts an inclusionary housing ordinance are centered in San Francisco, the committee may wish to consider limiting this bill to San Francisco. Prior to the Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa, 217 Cal. App. 4th 1160 (2013) case, San Francisco interpreted density bonus as optional. San Francisco is in the process of reconciling their inclusionary ordinance with density bonus law. If the committee chooses to take this approach, it may wish to evaluate the impact that this change would have on projects that have pending applications for density bonus. According to data provided by the San Francisco city planning department there are eight formal density bonus applications under review and several developers who have expressed interest in applying.
Double referred: If AB 915 passes this committee, the bill will be referred to the Committee on Local Government.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto
Council of Community Housing Organizations
Homeownership of San Francisco
Mission Economic Development Agency
PODER
Public Advocates
Santa Monicans for Renters' Rights
Senior and Disability Action
Tenants Together
Opposition
Apartment Association, California Southern Cities
Apartment Association of Orange County
Bay Area Renters Federation
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Renters Legal Advocacy and Education Fund
East Bay Forward
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Grow the Richmond
North Valley Property Owner Association
Progress Noe
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Tech for Housing
YIMBY Action
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):