AB 1793: Contractors: license requirements: recovery actions.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-30
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met, including that the contractor did not know or should not reasonably have known, that he or she was not duly licensed when the performance under the contract occurred. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would revise certain of the criteria for a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements, including removing the condition that the contractor did not know or should not have reasonably have known, that he or she was unlicensed during performance of the contract.
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met, including that the contractor did not know or should not reasonably have known, that he or she was not duly licensed when the performance under the contract occurred. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would revise certain of the criteria for a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements, including removing the condition that the contractor did not know or should not have reasonably have known, that he or she was unlicensed during performance of the contract.
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met. met, including that the contractor did not know or should not reasonably have known, that he or she was not duly licensed when the performance under the contract occurred. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would instead require revise certain of the criteria for a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met. The bill, for purposes of a person seeking recovery of moneys paid to an unlicensed contractor, also would remove the requirement that the contractor be duly licensed at all times during the performance of the work in order for the contractor to receive compensation. The bill instead would authorize a contractor to retain compensation for the portion of the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed. requirements, including removing the condition that the contractor did not know or should not have reasonably have known, that he or she was unlicensed during performance of the contract.
Existing law authorizes a person who provides work authorized for a site improvement to have a lien against the property equal to the value of the work. Existing law provides that a security interest taken to secure payment for site improvements is unenforceable if the contractor was not licensed during all times during the performance of the improvements.
The bill would make the security interest enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would instead require a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met. The bill, for purposes of a person seeking recovery of moneys paid to an unlicensed contractor, also would delete remove the requirement that the contractor be duly licensed at all times during the performance of the work in order for the contractor to receive compensation. The bill instead would authorize a contractor to retain compensation for the portion of the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
Existing law authorizes a person who provides work authorized for a site improvement to have a lien against the property equal to the value of the work. Existing law provides that a security interest taken to secure payment for site improvements is unenforceable if the contractor was not licensed during all times during the performance of the improvements.
The bill would make the security interest enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would instead require a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met. The bill, for purposes of a person seeking recovery of moneys paid to an unlicensed contractor, also would delete the requirement that the contractor be duly licensed at all times during the performance of the work in order for the contractor to receive compensation. The bill instead would authorize a contractor to retain compensation for the portion of the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
The bill would declare that its provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law, the Contractors State License Law, creates the Contractors State License Board within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors. Existing law authorizes a person who utilizes an unlicensed contractor to bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state for recovery of compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. Existing law authorizes a court to determine that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if specified conditions are met. Existing law also requires a contractor to demonstrate that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid in order to meet substantial compliance of these licensure requirements.
This bill would instead require a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with the licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met.
The bill would declare that its provisions are declaratory of existing law.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person, except that this prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors at all times during the performance of any act or contract covered by the action. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court may determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person, except that this prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors at all times during the performance of any act or contract covered by the action. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court may determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract for which compensation is sought, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person. This person, except that this prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed. contract.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed. unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors at all times during the performance of any act or contract for which compensation is sought. covered by the action. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court shall may determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor during the performance of that act or contract for which compensation is sought, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person. This prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract. enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors during the performance of any act or contract for which compensation is sought. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court shall determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract, contract for which compensation is sought, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person, except that this person. This prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors at all times during the performance of any act or contract covered by the action. for which compensation is sought. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court shall determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements under this section upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
SEC. 2.The amendment of Section 7031 of the Business and Professions Code made by this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
.
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (e), no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required by this chapter without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person, except that this prohibition shall not apply to contractors who are each individually licensed under this chapter but who fail to comply with Section 7029.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract.
(c)A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract.
(d)If licensure or proper licensure is controverted, then proof of licensure pursuant to this section shall be made by production of a verified certificate of licensure from the Contractors State License Board which establishes that the individual or entity bringing the action was duly licensed in the proper classification of contractors at all times during the performance of any act or contract covered by the action. Nothing in this subdivision shall require any person or entity controverting licensure or proper licensure to produce a verified certificate. When licensure or proper licensure is controverted, the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure shall be on the licensee.
(e)The judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply under this section where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 143, the court may shall determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, (3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act or contract commenced, and (4) and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements under this section upon learning of the failure.
(f)The exceptions to the prohibition against the application of the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance found in subdivision (e) shall apply to all contracts entered into on or after January 1, 1992, and to all actions or arbitrations arising therefrom, except that the amendments to subdivisions (e) and (f) enacted during the 1994 portion of the 199394 Regular Session of the Legislature shall not apply to either of the following:
(1)Any legal action or arbitration commenced prior to January 1, 1995, regardless of the date on which the parties entered into the contract.
(2)Any legal action or arbitration commenced on or after January 1, 1995, if the legal action or arbitration was commenced prior to January 1, 1995, and was subsequently dismissed.
SEC. 2.The amendment of Section 7031 of the Business and Professions Code made by this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 244, Statutes of 2016. |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 5809.). |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 4878.). |
| Aug 11, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 14 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 3, 2016 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Jun 20, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 6, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 6). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 19, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E.D. and JUD. |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 4784.) |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0.) |
| May 12, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 4, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 3, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 3). |
| Apr 26, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 26). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on B. & P. and JUD. |
| Feb 5, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 6. |
| Feb 4, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2016 | AB 1793 HOLDEN Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Special Consent AB1793 Holden | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 6, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2016 | AB 1793 HOLDEN Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 3, 2016 | Do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1793
Author:(Holden)
As Amended Ver:August 2, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 78-0 | (May 12, 2016) | SENATE: | 37-0 | (August 11, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: B. & P.
SUMMARY: Requires a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements, as specified.
- Requires a contractor to provide evidence that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with licensure requirements upon learning of the failure, in addition to other specified requirements.
The Senate amendments delete authorization for a contractor to retain compensation for only the portion of work performed while he or she was duly licensed in the event that action is brought against the contractor for a lapse in licensure, and instead delete the requirement for a contractor to provide evidence that he or she did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act or contract commenced.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: Purpose. This bill is author-sponsored. According to the author, "[This bill] aims to protect licensed contractors from the harsh disgorgement provisions of the Contractors' State License Law [(CSLL)]. This bill requires the court to determine if a contractor substantially complied with the law when a contractor inadvertently, and in good faith, falls out of compliance and makes immediate corrective action."
Background. The CSLL permits an individual that hires a contractor, and later discovers the contractor to be unlicensed, to seek recovery for the cost of all construction-related work performed by the unlicensed contractor. In cases in which a previously valid contractors' license simply expired, the contractors may assert in defense that they made a "good faith" effort to comply with the licensing requirements and corrected their licensure status immediately upon discovering a lapse.
In the Contractors' State License Board's (CSLB's) 2014 Sunset Review Report, submitted as part of its sunset review by the Legislature, the CSLB stated, "existing law requires that a contractor must be a 'duly licensed contractor at all times' while working on a contracted project in order to receive compensation (Business and Professions Code (BPC) Section 7031). The CSLB indicates that the courts have interpreted the provisions of BPC Section 7031 to deny all compensation to contractors who are in violation of the licensing requirements even though the failure to comply occurred during a brief period during which work was performed."
The terms "duly licensed" (as used in subdivision (a)) and "unlicensed" are not defined in CSLL, but are decisive terms under BPC Section 7031. Consequently, the legal profession lacks clear guidelines when judging the license status of a contractor, and the disgorgement provisions authorized by subdivision (b) are being misinterpreted and maliciously applied for personal gain, even when there is no issue regarding the quality of work performed. CSLB claims that the application of this statute in this manner may facilitate "unjust enrichment" to public agencies, prime contractors, and/or commercial/industrial project owners, an unacceptable outcome within the spirit of the law.
The CSLB sponsored SB 263 (Monning), of 2013 to modify BPC Section 7031, which would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. The amendments to BPC Section 7031 were removed in part because of the Senate Committee on Judiciary's concerns about weakening the consumer protection provided by this section. That bill was substantially amended to address an unrelated topic.
The 2008 Housing Crisis. As a result of the 2008 housing crisis in California, large segments of the state's construction industry underwent a period of mergers, acquisitions and corporate reorganizations. Oftentimes, the newly merged or reorganized firms would internally shift or obtain new contractors' licenses while allowing the valid license for the defunct entity to lapse upon its expiration. Through the normal course of construction related payment disputes, customers started challenging the validity of contractor licenses following mergers or corporate reorganizations. Plaintiffs sought to force construction firms to disgorge millions of dollars in revenue despite a firm's maintaining a valid license at all times, albeit not the license listed on the contract when the contract first commenced.
According to the author, "A California appellate court ruled that although a reorganizing construction firm internally transferred construction work from one subsidiary with a valid contractors' license to another, the failure to maintain or explicitly transfer the original license of the entity listed on the construction contract violated the CSLL. Although no construction work was performed without a valid license and the parent company remained consistent, the court ordered the firm to disgorge all revenue from the contract."
State Litigation. In MW Erectors, Inc. v Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., the California Supreme Court held, in relevant part: "The words 'at all times' convey the Legislature's obvious intent to impose a stiff all-or-nothing penalty for unlicensed work by specifying that a contractor is barred from all recovery for such an 'act or contract' if unlicensed at any time while performing it." (Refer MW Erectors, Inc. v. Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., Supreme Court of California, 30 Cal.Rptr.3d 755 (2005)]
In Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Project Management, Co., the appellate court acknowledged that penalizing construction firms for "a technical transgression only indirectly serves the CSLL's larger purpose of preventing the delivery of services by unqualified contractors." As a result of this decision, the firm nearly lost nearly $20 million in revenue resulting from the work performed between the lapse of the license and a renewal of the construction contract under the new subsidiary's name."
Analysis Prepared by: Gabby Nepomuceno / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0003836
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1793 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1793
Amended: 8/2/16 in Senate
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 8-0, 6/6/16
AYES: Hill, Bates, Block, Gaines, Galgiani, Hernandez, Mendoza, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jackson
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/12/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Contractors: license requirements: recovery actions
DIGEST: This bill provides that a contractor may pursue or obtain compensation for any work performed on the contract while duly licensed, as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) within the Department of Consumer Affairs to implement and enforce the Contractors State License Law (Contractors Law). (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 7000, et seq.)
- Requires the CSLB to investigate complaints and enforce the provisions of the Contractors Law, prohibit all forms of unlicensed activity, and enforce the obligation to secure the payment of valid and current workers’ compensation insurance in accordance with Labor Code Section 3700.5. (BPC § 7011.4; 7011.7)
- Defines “contractor” to include any person, consultant to an owner-builder, firm, association, organization, partnership, business, trust, corporation, or company, who or which undertakes, offers to undertake, purports to have the capacity to undertake, or submits a bid to construct any building or home improvement project, or part thereof. (BPC § 7026.1(a)(2)(A))
- Provides that no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor may bring or maintain any action for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was duly licensed. (BPC § 7031(a))
- Provides that action may be brought against a contractor during the performance of any act or contract during which the contractor was unlicensed. (BPC § 7031(b))
- Provides that proof of licensure is made by producing a verified certificate of licensure from the CSLB that is valid during all times of the performance of any act or contract; provides that the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure is on the licensee. (BPC § 7031(d))
- Authorizes a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if the contractor: a) had been duly licensed as a contractor prior to performing the act or contract; b) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; c) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when commencing the act or contract; and, d) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid.
(BPC § 7031(e)) - Provides that no license shall be issued to a corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or other combination or organization if a responsible officer or director of the corporation, or other combination or organization, or a partner of the partnership, or a manager or officer of the limited liability company, or any member of an organization seeking licensure does not meet the qualifications required of an applicant other than those qualifications relating to knowledge and experience. (BPC § 7071)
This bill provides that the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, the court shall determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements if it is shown that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor: (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract; (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
Background
The Contractors Law permits an individual that hires a contractor, and later discovers the contractor to be unlicensed, to seek recovery for the cost of all construction-related work performed by the unlicensed contractor. In cases in which a previously valid contractors’ license simply expired, the contractor may assert in defense that they made a “good faith” effort to comply with the licensing requirements and corrected their licensure status immediately upon discovering a lapse.
In the CSLB’s 2014 Sunset Review Report, submitted as part of its sunset review by the Legislature, the CSLB stated, “existing law requires that a contractor must be a ‘duly licensed contractor at all times’ while working on a contracted project in order to receive compensation (BPC Section 7031). The CSLB indicates that the courts have interpreted the provisions of BPC Section 7031 to deny all compensation to contractors who are in violation of the licensing requirements even though the failure to comply occurred during a brief period during which work was performed.”
The terms “duly licensed” (as used in subdivision (a)) and “unlicensed” are not defined in the Contractors Law, but are decisive terms under BPC Section 7031. Consequently, the legal profession lacks clear guidelines when judging the license status of a contractor, and the disgorgement provisions authorized by subdivision (b) are being misinterpreted and maliciously applied for personal gain, even when there is no issue regarding the quality of work performed.
CSLB claims that the application of this statute in this manner may facilitate “unjust enrichment” to public agencies, prime contractors, and/or commercial/industrial project owners, an unacceptable outcome within the spirit of the law. The CSLB sponsored SB 263 (Monning, 2013) to modify BPC Section 7031, which would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. The amendments to BPC Section 7031 were removed in part because of the Senate Committee on Judiciary’s concerns about weakening the consumer protection provided by this section. That bill was substantially amended to address an unrelated topic.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Air Conditioning Sheet Metal Association
Associated General Contractors
California Association of Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors National Association
California Building Industry Association
California Chapters of the National Electrical Contractors Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California Legislative Conference of the Plumbing, Heating and Piping Industry
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
Construction Employers Association
Northern California Allied Trades
Southern California Contractors Association
State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO
United Contractors
Wall and Ceiling Alliance
Western Line Constructors Chapter
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: A coalition of several contracting, construction, and building trade associations support this bill because “AB 1793 clarifies existing law to ensure that properly licensed and law abiding construction firms are not placed at fatal monetary risk, by limiting the recovery time and disgorgement amount to monies paid to the contractor for work performed while the contractor was not properly licensed. To be clear, nothing in this measure allows an unlicensed contractor to seek or retain any monies paid to them for the performance of a construction contract while they were not duly licensed.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/12/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Burke, Jones-Sawyer
8/3/16 19:22:36
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1793 (Author:Holden)
Version: May 4, 2016
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TH
SUBJECT
Contractors: License Requirements: Recovery Actions
DESCRIPTION
This bill would modify conditions under which a contractor may bring an action to recover compensation for the performance of an act or contract regulated by the Contractors’ State License Law.
BACKGROUND
The Contractors State License Board (CSLB) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) licenses and regulates approximately 300,000 contractors in California pursuant to the Contractors’ State License Law (CSLL). Under that law, a person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor must be a “duly licensed contractor at all times” while working on a project for which a license is required in order to receive compensation for that work. (See Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7031.) The California Supreme Court, reviewing this provision, has found that “[s]ince the CSLL was adopted in 1939 . . . [this provision] has declared that, except as expressly otherwise provided, a contractor may not sue to collect compensation for performance of any act or contract requiring a license without alleging that he or she was duly licensed at all times during the performance of that act or contract.” (MW Erectors, Inc. v. Niederhauser Ornamental & Metal Works Co., Inc. (2005) 36 Cal.4th 412, 425 [internal quotation marks omitted].) “In 1989,” the Court notes, this provision “was amended to make clear that the bar extends to actions in law or equity and applies regardless of the merits of the cause of action.” (Id.) According to the Court:
[t]he words “at all times” convey the Legislature’s obvious intent to impose a stiff all-or-nothing penalty for unlicensed work by specifying that a contractor is barred from all recovery for such an “act or contract” if unlicensed at any time while performing it. This all-or-nothing philosophy is directly at odds with the premise that contractors with lapses in licensure may nonetheless recover partial compensation by narrowly segmenting the licensed and unlicensed portions of their performance. (Niederhauser, 36 Cal.4th at 426.)
In 2003, the Legislature revised the conditions under which contractors with lapsed licenses may bring actions to recover compensation due for the performance of unlicensed work. AB 1386 (Horton, Ch. 289, Stats. 2003) authorized a court to apply the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance to allow an action for recovery to proceed where a previously licensed contractor: (1) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; (2) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act or contract commenced; and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid.
This bill would authorize a contractor to recover compensation for the performance of any act or contract for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed, thereby allowing contractors with lapsed licenses to receive partial compensation by segmenting the licensed and unlicensed portions of their performance.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the Contractors’ State License Law, regulates the licensure and performance of persons engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7000 et seq.)
Existing law specifies that “contractor” is synonymous with “builder” and refers to any person who undertakes to or offers to undertake to, or purports to have the capacity to undertake to, or submits a bid to, or does himself or herself or by or through others, construct, alter, repair, add to, subtract from, improve, move, wreck or demolish any building, highway, road, parking facility, railroad, excavation or other structure, project, development or improvement, or to do any part thereof, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7026.)
Existing law provides that it is a misdemeanor for any person to advertise for construction work or a work of improvement covered by the Contractors’ State License Law unless that person holds a valid license in the classification so advertised, except that a licensed building or engineering contractor may advertise as a general contractor. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7027.1.) However, a person who is not licensed may advertise for construction work or a work of improvement only if the aggregate contract price for labor, material, and all other items on a project or undertaking is less than five hundred dollars ($500), and he or she states in the advertisement that he or she is not licensed. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7027.2.)
Existing law provides that, unless exempted, it is a misdemeanor for a person to engage in the business of, or act in the capacity of, a contractor within this state if the person is not licensed. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7028.)
Existing law provides that no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person, except as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7031(a).)
Existing law states, except as provided, a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7031(b).)
Existing law provides that a security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7031(c).)
Existing law states that the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, the court may determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements if it is shown that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor: (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract; (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; (3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act or contract commenced; and (4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 7031(e).)
This bill would instead provide that no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor, may bring or maintain any action, or recover in law or equity in any action, in any court of this state for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor during the performance of that act or contract for which compensation is sought, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by the person.
This bill would instead provide that a person who utilizes the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction in this state to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed.
This bill would instead provide that a security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
This bill would instead provide that the judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply where the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor has never been a duly licensed contractor in this state. However, the court shall determine that there has been substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown that the person who engaged in the business or acted in the capacity of a contractor: (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract; (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure.
This bill makes other conforming changes to existing law.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
AB 1793 clarifies existing law to ensure that courts provide back payments or deny disgorgement for any construction work performed by an entity that possess a valid license. This bill authorizes a contractor to retain compensation for the portion of the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed. Additionally, AB 1793 requires California courts to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with a contract, and is entitled to compensation, so long as:
- the contractor held a valid license when initially contracting for service;
- the contractor acted in “good faith” to maintain a valid license at all times while performing the work; and
- the contractor acted promptly and in good faith to remedy any errors or deficiencies in the license immediately upon learning of any issue.
California’s construction industry remains a dynamic industry that creates thousands of good paying jobs across the state. When a general contractor is forced to disgorge millions of dollars in revenue, it results in financial hardship for all workers on a project, including subcontractors, plumbers, electricians, and other skilled craftsmen. Providing the flexibility for future growth and expansion is essential for the preservation of this vital sector of the California economy. AB 1793 will ensure that properly licensed contractors do not lose millions in revenue because of technical errors that inadvertently occur during a corporate restructuring.
- Softening consequences of licensure lapses
This bill responds, in part, to an appellate decision issued last year by the First Appellate District in San Francisco concerning disgorgement of compensation from a company that allowed its contractor’s license to lapse after a corporate reorganization and, consequently, did not strictly comply with the Contractors’ State License Law (CSLL). In Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Facilities, Inc. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 882, plaintiff Judicial Council of California (Judicial Council) entered into a contract with defendant Jacobs Facilities, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of defendant Jacobs Engineering Group Inc., for contracted work that required licensure under the CSLL. During the course of the parties’ contract, the defendant transferred the employees responsible for performing the contract to another wholly owned subsidiary, and allowed the license for Jacobs Facilities, Inc., who remained the named contracting party for nearly a year after the reorganization, to lapse. Judicial Council sued Jacobs Engineering Group and its two subsidiaries under the CSLL seeking disgorgement under Business and Professions Code Section 7031, which requires unlicensed contractors to disgorge compensation for work that can only be performed by a licensed contractor. In reversing a lower court order that would have prevented disgorgement, the court stated:
[W]e acknowledge penalizing the Jacobs entities for these technical transgressions only indirectly serves the CSLL’s larger purpose of preventing the delivery of services by unqualified contractors, since the Jacobs entities were neither dishonest nor incompetent. For better or worse, however, this is beside the point. The doctrine of substantial compliance, as developed by the courts, attempted to limit the forfeiture remedy to circumstances in which that remedy served the larger statutory purpose. In that form, the doctrine was rejected by the Legislature. It is preserved in a restricted statutory form; thus, courts can no longer exercise discretion in the application of the doctrine. To avoid forfeiture for a CSLL violation, a contractor must now satisfy the terms of section 7031, subdivision (e). To the extent the contractor fails to satisfy that exception, the courts have no choice but to allow forfeiture, regardless of the nature of the violation or its relation to the larger ends of the CSLL. . . . While we appreciate the potentially great harshness of this legislation in these circumstances, any argument for expansion of the substantial compliance doctrine must be directed to the Legislature. (Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Facilities, Inc. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th at 899-900 [internal citations omitted].)
By restricting the disgorgement provision of the CSLL to apply only for those periods during which a contractor was unlicensed, this bill arguably avoids the harsh consequences visited upon contractors who fail to maintain their license for technical reasons and otherwise stand to lose the entirety of their contracted compensation under existing law.
- Segmenting licensed and unlicensed performance
In addition to softening the potential consequences that arise in cases of technical non-compliance with the CSLL (discussed in Comment 2), the changes proposed in this bill would additionally allow for the segmentation of periods of compliance and non-compliance with respect to disgorgement of compensation from unlicensed contractors. Under existing law, Section 7031 of the Business and Professions Code prevents a contractor from bringing an action to recover compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of that act or contract, regardless of the merits of the cause of action brought by that contractor. The requirement that a licensed contractor must be licensed at all times in order to claim compensation “convey[s] the Legislature’s obvious intent to impose a stiff all-or-nothing penalty for unlicensed work by specifying that a contractor is barred from all recovery for such an “act or contract” if unlicensed at any time while performing it.” (Niederhauser, 36 Cal.4th at 426.)
Fourteen years ago, this Committee considered AB 2693 (Wyman, 2002), which, like this bill, would have provided that an action against an unlicensed contractor for recovery of monies paid to the unlicensed contractor is limited to payments made for work done during the time the contractor was unlicensed. The Committee’s analysis of that bill stated:
The bill would provide that the right of action against unlicensed contractors would apply only to payments made for work done during the time the contractor was actually unlicensed. Supporters argue that existing law creates the potentially unfair scenario where a license inadvertently lapses for a brief period of time, and the contractor’s customers are entitled to recovery of all payments made on the job.
Existing law already provides for a substantial compliance defense for licensed contractors, if three factors are met: a) that the contractor had been duly licensed prior to the performance of the act/contract, b) the contractor acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and c) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed. The existing defense appears to cover most of the situations supporters describe, with two possible exceptions.
First, supporters cite the situation where a surety company maintaining a licensee’s mandatory license bond goes out of business. Committee staff is informed by CSLB staff that only three surety companies have gone out of business since the inception of the CSLB, and that in two of those situations sufficient advance notice was given to licensees to seek new bonds. In the other instance, CSLB, through administrative action, protected the licensees’ licenses from expiring until new bonds could be obtained. In addition, CSLB staff informs Committee staff that they are close to finalizing a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the Insurance Commissioner to provide for advance notice of sureties that are going out of business. As a result, it appears that subcontractors are adequately protected from this scenario.
Second, supporters cite the situation where a license lapses because of the death of a partner. This scenario is resolved by a separate section of the bill described in Comment 3 [omitted].
As a result, the scenarios cited by proponents do not appear to necessitate the bill’s limitation on existing law. In addition, the bill’s language would reduce the liability of contractors who knowingly started jobs while an application was pending, as well as contractors who knowingly continued work on jobs even after their license had expired. In addition, the bill’s language would reduce the deterrent effect the existing broad liability has on unlicensed contractors. (Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of Assem. Bill No. 2693, as amended April 15, 2002, pp. 5-6.)
The Committee may wish to consider whether more targeted changes that would not result in the segmentation of licensed and unlicensed performance for the purpose of recovery actions, and that would not undermine the deterrent effect existing law has toward unlicensed contractors, would be more appropriate and more protective of consumers.
Suggested Amendments:
- eliminate the segmentation provisions from this bill and instead liberalize the ability of reviewing courts to apply the doctrine of substantial compliance
Support: Air Conditioning Sheet Metal Association; Air Conditioning Trade Association; American Fire Sprinkler Association; Associated Builders and Contractors, San Diego Chapter; Associated General Contractors; California Association of Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors National Association; California Building Industry Association; California Chapters of the National Electrical Contractors Association; California Legislative Conference of the Plumbing, Heating and Piping Industry; California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors; Construction Employers Association; Northern California Allied Trades; Plumbing – Heating - Cooling Contractors Association of California; Southern California Contractors Association; State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO; United Contractors; Wall and Ceiling Alliance; Western Line Constructors Chapter; Western Electrical Contractors Association
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Jacobs Engineering
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SB 263 (Monning, 2013) would have clarified penalties for persons engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor to also include a person who has never been a licensed contractor, or a person who was licensed but who acts under a license that is inactive, expired, revoked, or under suspension for any reason. This bill would have stated that entering into a contract with any person when that contract is performed during a period in which that person’s license was inactive, expired, revoked, or under suspension is a cause for discipline if the purpose of the contract is for that person to perform an act subject to licensure under the law. This bill was amended to address a different subject.
AB 1386 (Horton, Ch. 289, Stats. 2003) revised the conditions under which contractors with lapsed licenses may bring an action to recover compensation due for the performance of work, or defend against an action to recover compensation previously paid for the performance of work. Specifically, this bill authorized a court to determine that a contractor substantially complied with licensure requirements if the contractor was previously licensed and both (1) did not know, or reasonably should not have known, that he or she was not licensed when performing acts subject to licensure, and (2) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid.
AB 2693 (Wyman, 2002) would have, among other things, provided that an action against an unlicensed contractor for recovery of monies paid to the unlicensed contractor is limited to payments made for work done during the time the contractor was unlicensed.
AB 678 (Papan, Ch. 226, Stats. 2001) authorized persons who use the services of an unlicensed contractor to bring an action to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract.
Prior Vote:
Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 78, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
Assembly Business and Professions Committee (Ayes 16, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 6, 2016
Author: | |||
Version: | May 4, 2016 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Mark Mendoza | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Provides that a contractor may pursue or obtain compensation for any work performed on the contract while duly licensed, as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to implement and enforce the Contractors State License Law (Contractors Law). (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 7000, et seq.)
- Requires the CSLB to investigate complaints and enforce the provisions of the Contractors Law, prohibit all forms of unlicensed activity, and enforce the obligation to secure the payment of valid and current workers’ compensation insurance in accordance with Labor Code § 3700.5. (BPC § 7011.4; 7011.7)
- Defines “contractor” to include any person, consultant to an owner-builder, firm, association, organization, partnership, business, trust, corporation, or company, who or which undertakes, offers to undertake, purports to have the capacity to undertake, or submits a bid to construct any building or home improvement project, or part thereof. (BPC § 7026.1(a)(2)(A))
- Provides that no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor may bring or maintain any action for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was duly licensed. (BPC § 7031(a))
- Provides that action may be brought against a contractor during the performance of any act or contract during which the contractor was unlicensed. (BPC § 7031(b))
- Provides that proof of licensure is made by producing a verified certificate of licensure from the CSLB that is valid during all times of the performance of any act or contract; provides that the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure is on the licensee. (BPC § 7031(d))
- Authorizes a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if the contractor: 1) had been duly licensed as a contractor prior to performing the act or contract; 2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; 3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when commencing the act or contract; and, 4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. (BPC § 7031(e))
- Provides that no license shall be issued to a corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or other combination or organization if a responsible officer or director of the corporation, or other combination or organization, or a partner of the partnership, or a manager or officer of the limited liability company, or any member of an organization seeking licensure does not meet the qualifications required of an applicant other than those qualifications relating to knowledge and experience. (BPC § 7071)
This bill:
- Provides that a contractor may not bring an action to recover compensation for the performance of any act or contract unless he or she was a duly licensed contractor during the performance of that act or contract for which compensation is sought.
- Permits a person who uses the services of an unlicensed contractor to bring an action to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for any performance of an act or contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed.
- Provides that a security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of a contract for which a license is required is enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
- Modifies the showing that must be made to demonstrate that a contractor is in "substantial compliance" with licensing requirements. Specifically, existing law requires showing that the contractor (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure,
(3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act commenced; and (4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. Under this bill the contractor would, instead, need to show that he or she (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements under this section upon learning of the failure.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is not keyed “fiscal” by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “[This bill] aims to protect licensed contractors from the harsh disgorgement provisions of the [Contractors Law]. This bill requires the court to determine if a contractor substantially complied with the law when a contractor inadvertently, and in good faith, falls out of compliance and makes immediate corrective action.”
- Background. The Contractors Law permits an individual that hires a contractor, and later discovers the contractor to be unlicensed, to seek recovery for the cost of all construction-related work performed by the unlicensed contractor. In cases in which a previously valid contractors’ license simply expired, the contractor may assert in defense that they made a “good faith” effort to comply with the licensing requirements and corrected their licensure status immediately upon discovering a lapse.
In the CSLB’s 2014 Sunset Review Report, submitted as part of its sunset review by the Legislature, the CSLB stated, “existing law requires that a contractor must be a ‘duly licensed contractor at all times’ while working on a contracted project in order to receive compensation (BPC Section 7031). The CSLB indicates that the courts have interpreted the provisions of BPC Section 7031 to deny all compensation to contractors who are in violation of the licensing requirements even though the failure to comply occurred during a brief period during which work was performed.”
The terms “duly licensed” (as used in subdivision (a)) and “unlicensed” are not defined in the Contractors Law, but are decisive terms under BPC Section 7031. Consequently, the legal profession lacks clear guidelines when judging the license status of a contractor, and the disgorgement provisions authorized by subdivision (b) are being misinterpreted and maliciously applied for personal gain, even when there is no issue regarding the quality of work performed.
CSLB claims that the application of this statute in this manner may facilitate “unjust enrichment” to public agencies, prime contractors, and/or commercial/industrial project owners, an unacceptable outcome within the spirit of the law. The CSLB sponsored SB 263 (Monning) of 2013 to modify BPC Section 7031, which would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. The amendments to BPC Section 7031 were removed in part because of the Senate Committee on Judiciary’s concerns about weakening the consumer protection provided by this section. That bill was substantially amended to address an unrelated topic.
- The 2008 Housing Crisis. As a result of the 2008 housing crisis in California, large segments of the state’s construction industry underwent a period of mergers, acquisitions and corporate reorganizations. Oftentimes, the newly merged or reorganized firms would internally shift or obtain new contractors’ licenses while allowing the valid license for the defunct entity to lapse upon its expiration. Through the normal course of construction related payment disputes, customers started challenging the validity of contractor licenses following mergers or corporate reorganizations. Plaintiffs sought to force construction firms to disgorge millions of dollars in revenue despite a firm’s maintaining a valid license at all times, albeit not the license listed on the contract when the contract first commenced.
According to the Author, “A California appellate court ruled that although a reorganizing construction firm internally transferred construction work from one subsidiary with a valid contractors’ license to another, the failure to maintain or explicitly transfer the original license of the entity listed on the construction contract violated the Contractors Law. Although no construction work was performed without a valid license and the parent company remained consistent, the court ordered the firm to disgorge all revenue from the contract.”
State Litigation. In MW Erectors, Inc. v Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., the California Supreme Court held, in relevant part: “The words ‘at all times’ convey the Legislature's obvious intent to impose a stiff all-or-nothing penalty for unlicensed work by specifying that a contractor is barred from all recovery for such an ‘act or contract’ if unlicensed at any time while performing it.” (Refer MW Erectors, Inc. v. Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., Supreme Court of California, 30 Cal.Rptr.3d 755 (2005)]
In Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Project Management, Co., the appellate court acknowledged that penalizing construction firms for “a technical transgression only indirectly serves the Contractors Law’s larger purpose of preventing the delivery of services by unqualified contractors.” As a result of this decision the firm nearly lost nearly $20 million in revenue resulting from the work performed between the lapse of the license and a renewal of the construction contract under the new subsidiary’s name.”
- Prior Related Legislation. SB 263 (Monning) of 2013 sought to modify BPC § 7031 and would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. (Status: This measure was substantially amended to address a different issue.)
AB 1386 (Horton, Chapter 289, Statutes of 2003) clarified the meaning of substantial compliance as it related to the disgorgement provisions of the Contractors Law.
- Arguments in Support. A coalition of several contracting, construction, and building trade associations support this bill because “AB 1793 clarifies existing law to ensure that properly licensed and law abiding construction firms are not placed at fatal monetary risk, by limiting the recovery time and disgorgement amount to monies paid to the contractor for work performed while the contractor was not properly licensed. To be clear, nothing in this measure allows an unlicensed contractor to seek or retain any monies paid to them for the performance of a construction contract while they were not duly licensed.”
The California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors underscores that “there are times when a contractor inadvertently is temporarily in violation of a law or regulation. AB 1793 brings important clarity to an area of contractors’ license laws, whereby an unintentional and inadvertent act should not have large financial consequences. This proposed law would provide a fair remedy for all parties, when an unexpected issue with a contractor’s state license has been resolved in good faith, in a reasonable and timely manner.”
NOTE:
Double-referral to the Senate Committee on Judiciary.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Air Conditioning Sheet Metal Association
Associated General Contractors
California Association of Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors National Association
California Building Industry Association
California Chapters of the National Electrical Contractors Association
California Legislative Conference of the Plumbing, Heating and Piping Industry
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
Construction Employers Association
Northern California Allied Trades
Southern California Contractors Association
State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO
United Contractors
Wall and Ceiling Alliance
Western Line Constructors Chapter
Opposition:
None on file as of May 31, 2016.
-- END --
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended)
SUBJECT:
KEY ISSUE: Should a contractor be permitted to seek or retain compensation for work performed during the period of time in which the contractor was duly licensed, even if the contractor performs part of the work after his or her license has lapsed?
SYNOPSIS
This author-sponsored bill seeks to soften a harsh rule. The Contractors State License Law (CSLL) requires a person who performs contracting work to obtain a license from a licensing board within the Department of Consumer Affairs. The penalty for acting without a license is severe. A person who uses the services of an unlicensed contractor may bring an action to recover all compensation that was paid to the unlicensed contractor, and correspondingly a contractor may not bring an action to recover compensation for work performed unless the contractor was licensed "at all times" during the performance of the contract. Similarly, any lien that a contractor records to secure payment for work performed is unenforceable unless the contractor was duly licensed "at all times" during the performance of the contract. For example, if a contractor commences the work while duly licensed and performs 90% of the work before the license lapses, the contractor would be barred from bringing an action for any compensation; and if the person for whom the work was performed has already made payment, that person could bring an action to recover all of the compensation paid to the contractor, even if the work was performed to the client's complete satisfaction. For many years, the courts applied the doctrine of "substantial compliance" in order to avoid the inequity and unjust enrichment that results from such a rule. However, in 1989 the Legislature amended the law to state expressly that the doctrine of substantial compliance did not apply to violations of the licensing law unless certain requirements were met. If those requirements are not met, the contractor cannot receive any compensation even if most of the work is performed under a valid license. Last year, a California Court of Appeal denied a contractor's right to collect any compensation, but the court simultaneously noted the inequity of the rule, writing: "While we appreciate the potentially great harshness of this legislation in these circumstances," any effort to change the rule "must be directed to the Legislature." This bill follows the appellate court's advice. Although the bill makes relatively minor changes to the "substantial compliance" requirements, it more substantively changes the existing requirement that the contractor be licensed "at all times" in order to recover or retain any compensation; instead, under this bill, the contractor would be permitted to seek and retain compensation for that portion of the work performed while duly licensed. The author will take an amendment in this Committee to make a similar change to an existing provision that authorizes a contractor to record a lien to secure payment. The summary and analysis reflect that amendment. The bill is supported by several contractors' associations. There is no opposition to this bill, which recently passed out of the Assembly Business & Professions Committee on consent.
SUMMARY: Provides that a contractor may pursue or obtain compensation for any work performed on the contract while duly licensed, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a contractor may not bring an action to recover compensation for the performance of any act or contract unless he or she was a duly licensed contractor during the performance of that act or contract for which compensation is sought.
- Permits a person who uses the services of an unlicensed contractor to bring an action to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for any performance of an act or contract, except that this right to recover from an unlicensed contractor shall not apply to any compensation paid to the contractor for work performed during a time when the contractor was duly licensed.
- Provides that a security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of a contract for which a license is required is enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
- Modifies the showing that must be made to demonstrate that a contractor is in "substantial compliance" with licensing requirements. Specifically, existing law requires showing that the contractor (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, (3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act commenced; and (4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. Under this bill the contractor would, instead, need to show that he or she (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements under this section upon learning of the failure.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to implement the Contractors State License Law (CSLL). All businesses and individuals who construct or alter, or offer to construct or alter, any building, highway, road, parking facility, railroad, excavation, or other structure in California must be licensed by the CSLB if the total cost (labor and materials) of one or more contracts on the project is $500 or more. (Business and Professions Code Section 7000 et seq.; subsequent citations refer to this Code.)
- Defines “contractor” to include any person, consultant to an owner-builder, firm, association, organization, partnership, business, trust, corporation, or company, who or which undertakes, offers to undertake, purports to have the capacity to undertake, or submits a bid to construct any building or home improvement project, or part thereof. (Section 7026.1 (a)(2)(A).)
- Provides that no contractor may bring or maintain any action for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was duly licensed at all times during the performance of the contract. (Section 7031 (a).)
- Permits a person who uses the services of an unlicensed contractor to bring an action to recover all compensation paid to the unlicensed contractor for performance of any act or contract. (Section 7031 (b).)
- Provides that proof of licensure is made by producing a verified certificate of licensure from the CSLB that is valid during all times of the performance of any act or contract; provides that the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure is on the licensee. (Section 7031 (d).)
- Authorizes a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if the contractor: (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor prior to performing the act or contract; (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; (3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when commencing the act or contract; and, (4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. (Section 7031 (e).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to amend the Contractors State License Law (CSLL) in order to better serve its original purpose of protecting consumers from unqualified contractors, while at the same time ensuring that licensed contractors are fairly compensated for the work that they perform. In particular, according to the author, this bill "aims to protect licensed contractors from the harsh disgorgement provisions of the (CSLL)" where a contractor "inadvertently, and in good faith, falls out of compliance and makes immediate corrective action." The bill also responds to a recent court decision suggesting that the harshness of an existing rule that denies a contractor compensation for work performed can only be addressed by the Legislature, not the courts.
Background: The CSLL sets out a comprehensive scheme for licensing contractors engaged in the business of constructing, remodeling, or repairing any structure, project, development, or other work of improvement. The courts have held that "the purpose of the licensing law is to protect the public from incompetence and dishonesty in those who provide building and construction services. The licensing requirements provide minimal assurance that all persons offering such services in California have the requisite skill and character, understand the applicable laws and codes, and know the rudiments of administering a contracting business." (Hydrotech Systems v. Oasis Waterpark (1991) 52 Cal. 3d 988, 995.) In order to ensure that contractors doing business in California obtain and maintain a proper license, CSLL creates substantial repercussions for contractors who conduct business without a license.
At issue in this measure is Civil Code Section 7031, which (a) prohibits a contractor from bringing an action to recover compensation for work performed if the contractor was not licensed "at all times" during the performance of the work; and (b) permits a person who uses the services of an unlicensed contractor to bring an action to disgorge or recover all compensation already paid to the unlicensed contractor. These two provisions are two sides of the same coin. The unlicensed contractor essentially forfeits any claim to compensation if he or she performs contracting work without a license. Similarly, existing law provides if a contractor records a lien to secure payment for work performed, the lien is not enforceable unless the contractor was licensed "at all times" during the performance of the contract. The purpose of this provision is clear enough: to discourage persons from offering contracting services without a license by denying them the right to collect compensation or allowing a person for whom the work was performed to bring an action to recover all compensation already paid to an unlicensed contractor.
However, many courts and commentators, like the supporters of this bill, have observed that the words "at all times" in Section 7031 of the CSLL can lead to harsh and inequitable results. That is, in order to seek or retain compensation for work performed, the contractor must have been duly licensed "at all times," that is, throughout the entire period of the contract performance. If the contractor allowed a license to lapse, even for a day, the contractor would be barred from brining an action for any compensation, and the person for whom the work was performed could bring an action to recover all compensation already paid to the contractor, regardless of the quality of the work and what portion of the work was performed after the license had lapsed. For example, if a contractor commenced the work while duly licensed and performed 90% of the work before the license lapsed, the contractor would be barred from bringing an action for any compensation; and if the person for whom the work was performed had already made payment, that person could bring an action to recover all of the compensation paid to the contractor, even if the work was performed to the client's complete satisfaction.
Under the common law of contracts, allowing the contractor's client to avoid paying compensation while still benefiting from the work performed was generally frowned upon because it led to the "unjust enrichment" of one person at the expense of another. In order to address this inequity, in the decades prior to 1990, the courts invoked the doctrine of "substantial compliance" if strict adherence to the letter of the law would lead to an obvious injustice and did not further the overall purpose of CSLL. (Asdourian v. Araj (1985) 38 Cal. 3d 276.) If the purpose of the law was to prevent unlicensed persons, who might lack requisite skill and character from offering their services for sale, this purpose was not furthered if a licensed contractor doing quality work was denied any compensation just because some part of the contract was performed during a period when the license had lapsed. However, the ability of the courts to use the "substantial compliance" doctrine to reach more equitable results was greatly restricted in 1989 when the Legislature amended Section 7031 to say that the "judicial doctrine of substantial compliance shall not apply to this section," unless the contractor could prove that he or she had been duly licensed when the performance commenced; that he or she acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, did not know that he or she was not duly licensed, and acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply upon learning of the failure. (Business & Professions Code Section 7031 (e).)
Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Facilities: In August of 2015, the California Court of Appeal for the First District considered whether a contractor that satisfactorily performed a contract while holding a license for the majority of work performed could retain compensation for that work. This case did not involve a simple matter of a contractor inadvertently allowing a license to lapse; indeed, the work was arguably done under a valid license for the entire period of the contract performance. In this case, Jacobs Facilities, a subsidiary of the Jacobs Engineering Group, was duly licensed when it commenced work on buildings for the Judicial Council of California. While Jacobs Facilities was still performing the contract, the parent company, as part of a corporate reorganization, transferred employees of Jacobs Facilities to another subsidiary of the group. That new subsidiary had obtained a license prior to the transfer, and sometime after the transfer occurred the license for Jacobs Facilities was allowed to lapse. While the new licensed subsidiary performed the work, the Judicial Council of California continued to make payments to, and was still formally under contract with, Jacobs Facilities. When the Judicial Council learned that the license for Jacobs Facilities had lapsed, it sued to recover all of the compensation that it had already paid to Jacobs Facilities. At the trial court, the jury found that Jacobs Facilities had substantially complied with the licensing requirement by "internally" assigning the contract and the work to the licensed subsidiary. The jury refused to require the contractor to disgorge the amount (over $18 million) that the Judicial Council had paid to Jacobs Facilities. The Judicial Council appealed.
The Court Appeal reversed the trial court ruling. While it was true that Jacobs Facilities performed part of the work while it was duly licensed, and the subsidiary performed the remainder of the work while it was duly licensed, it was also true that the Judicial Council continued making payments to Jacobs Facilities throughout the entire period of the contract performance, even after the license of Jacobs Facilities has lapsed. In short, Jacobs Facilities had contracted to provide services that required a license, allowed its license to expire, and continued to be the named party to the contract even after the license expired. Jacobs Facilities argued that this was merely a "technical" violation, especially given that the subsidiary actually performing the work was licensed, but the Court of Appeal reasoned that this was essentially an argument for "substantial compliance," and that Section 7031 expressly stated that the doctrine of substantial compliance did not apply unless the conditions specified in the statute had been met. It was not clear, after all, that Jacobs Facilities acted "in good faith to maintain proper licensure" or "acted promptly to reinstate the license." Indeed it deliberately allowed the license to lapse (albeit believing that the subsidiary license sufficed). As such, the Court reversed the trial court ruling and remanded the case back to the trial court to determine if the contractor had complied with requirements in Section 7031.
The Court acknowledged the inequity of the outcome and conceded that the result did not serve the purpose of CSLL. That purpose, after all, was "preventing the delivery of services by unqualified contractors," but by all accounts "the Jacobs entities were neither dishonest nor incompetent." Its two subsidiaries were duly licensed at the time each performed, and the Judicial Council apparently had no complaint about the quality of the work. The Court, however, looked to the history of Section 7031 and its amendments. The original statute appeared to create an unduly harsh rule in order to ensure compliance with licensing requirements. The courts tried to soften this rule by applying the "substantial compliance" doctrine. The Legislature, however, responded in 1989 by expressly stating that the substantial compliance doctrine did not apply unless the requirements of the statute were met. If those requirements were not met, the contractor could not obtain any compensation even if most of the work had been performed while the contractor was duly licensed. The Court concluded that the Legislature must have intended a harsh rule and it was up to the Legislature to change it: "While we appreciate the potentially great harshness of this legislation in these circumstances, any argument for expansion of the substantial compliance doctrine must be directed to the Legislature." (Judicial Council of California v. Jacob Facilities, Inc. (2015) 239 Cal. App. 4th 882, 899-901.)
This bill effectively follows the court's advice. First, the bill makes relatively minor changes to the "substantial compliance" requirements. Specifically, under existing law the court may determine that there has been substantial compliance if, at an evidentiary hearing, it finds that the contractor (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, (3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when performance of the act commenced; and (4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. Under this bill the court would need to find that the contractor (1) had been duly licensed prior to performing the contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, and (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with the licensure requirements upon learning of the failure. The most significant difference between the existing requirements and the requirements under this bill appear to be the elimination of the requirement that the contractor "did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed." But this would not seem to change the requirement significantly, because whatever the contractor knew or did not know, under both existing law and this bill once the contractor learns of the problem he or she must act promptly to remedy the situation. The more substantive part of this bill changes the existing requirement that the contractor be licensed "at all times" in order to recover or retain any compensation; instead, under this bill, the contractor would be permitted to pursue and retain compensation for that portion of the work performed while duly licensed.
Proposed Author's Amendment: As currently in print, this bill modifies subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 7031. Existing subdivision (a) says that a contractor may not bring an action to recover compensation unless he or she was duly licensed "at all times" during the performance of the contract. Subdivision (b) allows the person for whom the work was performed to bring an action to recover compensation paid to a contractor if the contractor was not duly licensed at any time during the performance of the contract. This bill, as noted, changes both these provisions by eliminating the requirement that contractor can only seek or retain compensation if he or she was duly licensed "at all times." Instead, this bill would allow the contractor to seek and retain compensation for the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed, but not for any period of time that the contractor was not duly licensed. However, the bill in print does not amend subdivision (c) of Section 7031, which says that a lien recorded by the contractor to secure payment is enforceable if the contractor was not duly licensed "at all times" during the performance of the contract. As pointed out in the analysis prepared by the Assembly Business & Professions Committee, which heard this bill last week, if the purpose of this bill is to allow a contractor to be compensated for work performed while duly licensed, then it would seem to follow that the contractor should also be permitted to enforce a lien for the value of the work performed while the contractor was duly licensed. This Committee and the author concur with that analysis. Therefore, the author wishes to take the following amendments, as author's amendments, in this Committee:
- On page 2, lines 23-27 amend subdivision (c) to read as follows:
(c) A security interest taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required by this chapter is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract. is enforceable for work performed while the contractor was duly licensed.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: A coalition of several contracting, construction, and building trade associations support this bill because it "strikes a fair and thoughtful balance between upholding high consumer protection within the construction industry, while not unfairly punishing contractors who may have an inadvertent licensing lapse due to clerical or technical errors. They note that under existing law any individual, corporation, or public agency that uses a contractor and "later discovers that the contractor to be unlicensed at any time during the project (for even just one day), to seek recovery and disgorge from the contractor the cost of all construction related work performed by the contractor on the project." The coalition contends that "AB 1793 clarifies existing law to ensure that properly licensed and law abiding construction firms are not placed at fatal monetary risk, by limiting recovery . . . and disgorgement amount to monies paid to the contractor for work performed while the contractor was not properly licensed." The coalition concludes by stressing that "nothing in this measure allows an unlicensed contractor to seek or retain any monies paid to them for the performance of a construction contract while not duly licensed."
Prior Related Legislation: SB 263 (Monning) of 2013, similar to the bill under review, sought to modify Business & Professions Code Section 7031 and would have permitted a contractor to pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed. This bill was amended to address a different topic.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Air Conditioning Sheet Metal Association
Associated General Contractors
California Association of Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors
California Building Industry Association
California Chapters of the National Electrical Contractors Association
California Legislative Conference of the Plumbing, Heating, and Piping Industry
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California State Building and Construction Trades Council
Construction Employers’ Association
Northern California Allied Trades
Southern California Contractors Association
United Contractors
Wall and Ceiling Alliance
Western Line Constructors Chapter
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by:
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Rudy Salas, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1793
Author:(Holden) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
NOTE: This bill is double-referred, and if passed by this Committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
SUBJECT: Contractors: license requirements: recovery actions.
SUMMARY: Requires a court to find that a contractor is in substantial compliance with licensure requirements if prescribed evidentiary standards are met; clarifies that action can be brought against a contractor during the performance of any act or contract for which compensation is sought; deletes the requirement for a contractor to be licensed at all times to receive compensation, and instead authorizes a contractor to retain compensation for the portion of work performed while he or she was duly licensed.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to implement and enforce the Contractors State License Law (CSLL); the laws and regulations related to the licensure, practice and discipline of the construction industry in California. All businesses and individuals who construct or alter, or offer to construct or alter, any building, highway, road, parking facility, railroad, excavation, or other structure in California must be licensed by the CSLB if the total cost (labor and materials) of one or more contracts on the project is $500 or more. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) Section 7000, et seq.)
- Requires the CSLB to investigate complaints and enforce the provisions of the CSLL, prohibit all forms of unlicensed activity, and enforce the obligation to secure the payment of valid and current workers’ compensation insurance in accordance with Labor Code Section 3700.5. (BPC Sections 7011.4, 7011.7)
- Defines “contractor” to include any person , consultant to an owner-builder, firm, association, organization, partnership, business, trust, corporation, or company, who or which undertakes, offers to undertake, purports to have the capacity to undertake, or submits a bid to construct any building or home improvement project, or part thereof. (BPC Section 7026.1(a)(2)(A))
- Provides that no person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of a contractor may bring or maintain any action for the collection of compensation for the performance of any act or contract where a license is required without alleging that he or she was duly licensed; provides that action can be brought against a contractor during the performance of any act or contract during which the contractor was unlicensed. (BPC Section 7031(a) and (b))
- Provides that proof of licensure is made by producing a verified certificate of licensure from the CSLB that is valid during all times of the performance of any act or contract; provides that the burden of proof to establish licensure or proper licensure is on the licensee. (BPC Section 7031(d))
- Authorizes a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements if the contractor: 1) had been duly licensed as a contractor prior to performing the act or contract; 2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure; 3) did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when commencing the act or contract; and, 4) acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid. (BPC Section 7031(e))
- Provides that no license shall be issued to a corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or other combination or organization if a responsible officer or director of the corporation, or other combination or organization, or a partner of the partnership, or a manager or officer of the limited liability company, or any member of an organization seeking licensure does not meet the qualifications required of an applicant other than those qualifications relating to knowledge and experience. (BPC Section 7071)
- Provides that no license, regardless of type or classification, can be transferred to any other person or entity under any circumstances; provides that a license number may be reissued after cancellation, revocation, suspension, or expiration beyond the renewal period only under specified circumstances; provides that a license number may be reissued or reassigned to a different entity only under specified conditions, including when a parent corporation, or limited liability company has merged or created a subsidiary, the subsidiary has merged into the parent corporation or limited liability company, or the corporation or limited liability company has changed its filing status with the Secretary of State from a domestic entity to a foreign entity or from a foreign entity to a domestic entity, and the new entity is being formed to continue the business of the formerly licensed corporation; or when a limited liability company is formed by a corporation to continue the business of the corporation subsequent to the cancellation of the corporate entity’s license, provided the personnel listed for each entity are the same. (BPC Section 7075.1)
THIS BILL:
- Clarifies that an act or contract performed by a contractor is subject to action by a court of competent jurisdiction, including providing evidence of licensure, during the time that the act or contract would be compensated.
- Specifies that action may be brought against a contractor for the period of time that the contractor was unlicensed; provides that a person’s right to recover compensation paid to a contractor is not subject to action for the period of time that the contract was duly licensed.
- Replaces the requirements for providing evidence that shows the contractor did not know or reasonably should not have known that he or she was not duly licensed when commencing an act or contract and that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to reinstate his or her license upon learning it was invalid; instead, a contractor must provide evidence that he or she acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with licensure requirements upon learning of the failure, in addition to other specified requirements.
- Requires a court to determine at an evidentiary hearing that a contractor has substantially complied with licensure requirements, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is author-sponsored. According to the author, “[This bill] aims to protect licensed contractors from the harsh disgorgement provisions of the [CSLL]. This bill requires the court to determine if a contractor substantially complied with the law when a contractor inadvertently, and in good faith, falls out of compliance and makes immediate corrective action.”
Background. The CSLL permits an individual that hires a contractor, and later discovers the contractor to be unlicensed, to seek recovery for the cost of all construction-related work performed by the unlicensed contractor. In cases in which a previously valid contractors’ license simply expired, the contractor may assert in defense that they made a “good faith” effort to comply with the licensing requirements and corrected their licensure status immediately upon discovering a lapse.
In the CSLB’s 2014 Sunset Review Report, submitted as part of its sunset review by the Legislature, the CSLB stated, “existing law requires that a contractor must be a ‘duly licensed contractor at all times’ while working on a contracted project in order to receive compensation (BPC Section 7031). The CSLB indicates that the courts have interpreted the provisions of BPC Section 7031 to deny all compensation to contractors who are in violation of the licensing requirements even though the failure to comply occurred during a brief period during which work was performed.”
The terms “duly licensed” (as used in subdivision (a)) and “unlicensed” are not defined in CSLL, but are decisive terms under BPC Section 7031. Consequently, the legal profession lacks clear guidelines when judging the license status of a contractor, and the disgorgement provisions authorized by subdivision (b) are being misinterpreted and maliciously applied for personal gain, even when there is no issue regarding the quality of work performed.
CSLB claims that the application of this statute in this manner may facilitate “unjust enrichment” to public agencies, prime contractors, and/or commercial/industrial project owners, an unacceptable outcome within the spirit of the law.
The CSLB sponsored SB 263 (Monning) of 2013 to modify BPC Section 7031, which would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. The amendments to BPC Section 7031 were removed in part because of the Senate Committee on Judiciary’s concerns about weakening the consumer protection provided by this section. That bill was substantially amended to address an unrelated topic.
The 2008 Housing Crisis. As a result of the 2008 housing crisis in California, large segments of the state’s construction industry underwent a period of mergers, acquisitions and corporate reorganizations. Oftentimes, the newly merged or reorganized firms would internally shift or obtain new contractors’ licenses while allowing the valid license for the defunct entity to lapse upon its expiration. Through the normal course of construction related payment disputes, customers started challenging the validity of contractor licenses following mergers or corporate reorganizations. Plaintiffs sought to force construction firms to disgorge millions of dollars in revenue despite a firm’s maintaining a valid license at all times, albeit not the license listed on the contract when the contract first commenced.
According to the author, “A California appellate court ruled that although a reorganizing construction firm internally transferred construction work from one subsidiary with a valid contractors’ license to another, the failure to maintain or explicitly transfer the original license of the entity listed on the construction contract violated the CSLL. Although no construction work was performed without a valid license and the parent company remained consistent, the court ordered the firm to disgorge all revenue from the contract.”
State Litigation. In MW Erectors, Inc. v Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., the California Supreme Court held, in relevant part: “The words ‘at all times’ convey the Legislature's obvious intent to impose a stiff all-or-nothing penalty for unlicensed work by specifying that a contractor is barred from all recovery for such an ‘act or contract’ if unlicensed at any time while performing it.” (Refer MW Erectors, Inc. v. Niederhauser Ornamental and Metal Works Co., Inc., et al., Supreme Court of California, 30 Cal.Rptr.3d 755 (2005)]
In Judicial Council of California v. Jacobs Project Management, Co., the appellate court acknowledged that penalizing construction firms for “a technical transgression only indirectly serves the CSLL’s larger purpose of preventing the delivery of services by unqualified contractors.” As a result of this decision the firm nearly lost nearly $20 million in revenue resulting from the work performed between the lapse of the license and a renewal of the construction contract under the new subsidiary’s name.”
Related Prior Legislation. SB 263 (Monning) of 2013 sought to modify BPC Section 7031 and would have provided that a contractor may pursue payment for any work on the contract while duly licensed, but preclude payment for work performed in a classification in which the contractor was not licensed, was under license suspension, or was under an expired or inactive license when the work was performed. This bill was substantially amended to address a different jurisdiction.
AB 1386 (Horton), Chapter 289, Statutes of 2003, sought to clarify the meaning of substantial compliance as it related to the disgorgement provisions of the CSLL.
POLICY ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION:
Subdivision (c) of Section 7031 states that a security interest (i.e. a lien) taken to secure any payment for the performance of any act or contract for which a license is required is unenforceable if the person performing the act or contract was not a duly licensed contractor at all times during the performance of the act or contract. It is unclear if this provision can be interpreted in a way that makes the security interest void in situations that this bill is attempting to mitigate. The author may need to work with the Legislative Counsel to clarify the language and provide consistency in throughout this section.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The Construction Employers’ Association (CEA) writes in support, “Mandates that a court determine substantial compliance with licensure requirements under this section if it is shown at an evidentiary hearing that the contractor (1) had been duly licensed as a contractor in this state prior to the performance of the act or contract, (2) acted reasonably and in good faith to maintain proper licensure, (3) acted promptly and in good faith to remedy the failure to comply with licensure requirements upon learning of the failure. We believe that this gives contractors who experience an inadvertent lapse of license, a reasonable remedy given their prior good standing.”
The California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors (CALPASC) writes in support, “Federal and state laws and regulations are myriad, and keeping in perfect compliance at all times is the goal, but is very hard to achieve. There are times when a contractor inadvertently is temporarily in violation of a law or regulation. [This bill] brings important clarity to an area of contractors’ license laws, whereby an unintentional and inadvertent act should not have large financial consequences. This proposed law would provide a fair remedy for all parties, when an unexpected issue with a contractor’s state license has been resolved in good faith, in a reasonable and timely manner.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
The Construction Employers’ Association (CEA)
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors (CALPASC)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Gabby Nepomuceno / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):