SB 242: Property Assessed Clean Energy program: program administrator.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-10-04
Existing law, known commonly as a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program, authorizes a public agency, by making specified findings, to authorize public agency officials and property owners to enter into voluntary contractual assessments to finance the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources or energy or water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property. Existing law similarly authorizes a community facilities district to be formed pursuant to an alternative procedure under which the district initially consists solely of territory proposed for annexation to the community facilities district in the future and territory is annexed and subjected to special taxes only upon unanimous approval of the owners, to finance and refinance the acquisition, installation, and improvement of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements. Existing law authorizes a public agency, or an entity that administers a PACE financing program on behalf of and with the written consent of a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements.
The bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner executes an assessment contract, as defined, to make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of specified documents and forms related to the contract, and to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner on the call or an authorized representative of the owner on the call that contains specified information. The bill would require a program administrator to record the oral confirmation, and to retain that recording for a specified period of time. The bill would require a program administrator to ask if the property owner would prefer the oral confirmation be provided in a language other than English, and would require the program administrator to deliver the oral confirmation in the property owners language or via an interpreter chosen by the property owner in order for the contract to proceed, and would require the program administrator to provide the property owner with the translation of specified documents. This bill would prohibit a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract, and would require that a property owners first assessment payment be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator, contractor, or other 3rd party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property. The bill would prohibit a contractor from providing a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
Existing law prohibits a public agency from permitting a property owner to participate in a PACE program unless the property owner satisfies certain conditions and the property owner is given the right to cancel the contractual assessment at any time before midnight on the 3rd business day after certain events occur, without penalty or obligation, consistent with certain requirements. Existing law requires a home improvement contract to be in writing and to contain certain information, notices, and disclosures, including a statement that a consumer has a right to cancel or rescind the contract within 3 days, and authorizes the consumer to waive that right to cancel in the case of an emergency or immediately necessary repairs.
The bill would make it unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract if the property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program, and the property owner rescinds the PACE financing within the 3-day time period described above. The bill would require a contractor who violates that provision to restore the property to its original condition, and to return any money, property, and other consideration back to the property owner. The bill would authorize a property owner to waive his or her right to cancel for a contract that the property owner initiated for emergency repair or immediately necessary repair, as provided.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit reports to the public agency by a specified time that contains specified information regarding that program.
This bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern, and therefore shall apply to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
Existing law, known commonly as a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program, authorizes a public agency, by making specified findings, to authorize public agency officials and property owners to enter into voluntary contractual assessments to finance the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources or energy or water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property. Existing law similarly authorizes a community facilities district to be formed pursuant to an alternative procedure under which the district initially consists solely of territory proposed for annexation to the community facilities district in the future and territory is annexed and subjected to special taxes only upon unanimous approval of the owners, to finance and refinance the acquisition, installation, and improvement of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements. Existing law authorizes a public agency, or an entity that administers a PACE financing program on behalf of and with the written consent of a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements.
The bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner executes an assessment contract, as defined, to make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of specified documents and forms related to the contract, and to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner on the call or an authorized representative of the owner on the call that contains specified information. The bill would require a program administrator to record the oral confirmation, and to retain that recording for a specified period of time. The bill would require a program administrator to ask if the property owner would prefer the oral confirmation be provided in a language other than English, and would require the program administrator to deliver the oral confirmation in the property owners language or via an interpreter chosen by the property owner in order for the contract to proceed, and would require the program administrator to provide the property owner with the translation of specified documents. This bill would prohibit a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract, and would require that a property owners first assessment payment be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator, contractor, or other 3rd party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property. The bill would prohibit a contractor from providing a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
Existing law prohibits a public agency from permitting a property owner to participate in a PACE program unless the property owner satisfies certain conditions and the property owner is given the right to cancel the contractual assessment at any time before midnight on the 3rd business day after certain events occur, without penalty or obligation, consistent with certain requirements. Existing law requires a home improvement contract to be in writing and to contain certain information, notices, and disclosures, including a statement that a consumer has a right to cancel or rescind the contract within 3 days, and authorizes the consumer to waive that right to cancel in the case of an emergency or immediately necessary repairs.
The bill would make it unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract if the property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program, and the property owner rescinds the PACE financing within the 3-day time period described above. The bill would require a contractor who violates that provision to restore the property to its original condition, and to return any money, property, and other consideration back to the property owner. The bill would authorize a property owner to waive his or her right to cancel for a contract that the property owner initiated for emergency repair or immediately necessary repair, as provided.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit reports to the public agency by a specified time that contains specified information regarding that program.
This bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern, and therefore shall apply to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
Existing law, known commonly as a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program, authorizes a public agency, by making specified findings, to authorize public agency officials and property owners to enter into voluntary contractual assessments to finance the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources or energy or water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property. Existing law similarly authorizes a community facilities district to be formed pursuant to an alternative procedure under which the district initially consists solely of territory proposed for annexation to the community facilities district in the future and territory is annexed and subjected to special taxes only upon unanimous approval of the owners, to finance and refinance the acquisition, installation, and improvement of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements. Existing law authorizes a public agency, or an entity that administers a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) PACE financing program on behalf of and with the written consent of a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements.
ThisThe bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner executes an assessment contract, as defined, to make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of specified documents and forms related to the contract, and to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner on the call or an authorized representative of the owner on the call that contains specified information. The bill would require a program administrator to record the oral confirmation, and to retain that recording for a specified period of time. The bill would require a program administrator to ask if the property owner would prefer the oral confirmation be provided in a language other than English, and would require the program administrator to deliver the oral confirmation in the property owners language or via an interpreter chosen by the property owner in order for the contract to proceed, and would require the program administrator to provide the property owner with the translation of specified documents. This bill would prohibit a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract, and would require that a property owners first assessment payment be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses, bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator, contractor, or other 3rd party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property. The bill would prohibit a contractor from providing a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
Existing law prohibits a public agency from permitting a property owner to participate in a PACE program unless the property owner satisfies certain conditions and the property owner is given the right to cancel the contractual assessment at any time before midnight on the 3rd business day after certain events occur, without penalty or obligation, consistent with certain requirements. Existing law requires a home improvement contract to be in writing and to contain certain information, notices, and disclosures, including a statement that a consumer has a right to cancel or rescind the contract within 3 days, and authorizes the consumer to waive that right to cancel in the case of an emergency or immediately necessary repairs.
The bill would make it unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract if the property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program, and the property owner rescinds the PACE financing within the 3-day time period described above. The bill would require a contractor who violates that provision to restore the property to its original condition, and to return any money, property, and other consideration back to the property owner. The bill would authorize a property owner to waive his or her right to cancel for a contract that the property owner initiated for emergency repair or immediately necessary repair, as provided.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit reports to the public agency by a specified time that contains specified information regarding that program.
This bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern, and therefore shall apply to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
Existing law authorizes a public agency, or an entity that administers a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program on behalf of and with the written consent of a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements.
This bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the contract, subject to specified requirements. The bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements. prohibit a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract, and would require that a property owners first assessment payment be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses, as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator administrator, contractor, or other 3rd party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.This bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern, and therefore shall apply to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
Existing law authorizes a public agency, or an entity that administers a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program on behalf of and with the written consent of a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements.
This bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the contract, subject to specified requirements. The bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other third 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses expenses, as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property.
The bill would authorize a property owner to assert specified types of claims against the program administrator that the property owner could assert against a seller of goods or services that were obtained with the proceeds of a PACE assessment, provided that the seller meets one of 2 requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to establish a reasonable review process for receiving and evaluating those claims, and would require the property owner to comply with specified requirements in submitting those claims. The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance or a payment holiday for a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process to request a payment forbearance or payment holiday, and to establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or a payment holiday. The bill would require a program administrator to grant a modification to a PACE assessment if specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from limiting a property owners right to initiate legal action for 2 categories of claims specified. The bill would provide that a program administrator is not liable under either of those categories of claims if the program administrator can demonstrate that the error or omission that gave rise to the claim was unintentional, as provided, or that the program administrator notified the property owner of the error within a specified amount of time, as provided. The bill would prohibit a property owner from initiating legal proceedings against a program administrator on the basis of an unrelated claim, as defined.The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering a public agency, or an entity that administers a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs program on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, a public agency, to issue PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property. improvements.
This bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the contract, subject to specified requirements. The bill would require a program administrator, before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd third party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property.
The bill would authorize a property owner to assert specified types of claims against the program administrator that the property owner could assert against a seller of goods or services that were obtained with the proceeds of a PACE assessment, provided that the seller meets one of 2 requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to establish a reasonable review process for receiving and evaluating those claims, and would require the property owner to comply with specified requirements in submitting those claims. The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance or a payment holiday for a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process to request a payment forbearance or payment holiday, and to establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or a payment holiday. The bill would require a program administrator to grant a modification to a PACE assessment if specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from limiting a property owners right to initiate legal action for 2 categories of claims specified. The bill would provide that a program administrator is not liable under either of those categories of claims if the program administrator can demonstrate that the error or omission that gave rise to the claim was unintentional, as provided, or that the program administrator notified the property owner of the error within a specified amount of time, as provided. The bill would prohibit a property owner from initiating legal proceedings against a program administrator on the basis of an unrelated claim, as defined.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property.
TheThis bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to obtain a sworn declaration of income containing specified financial information from each property owner, and would provide that a declarant who willfully states as true a material fact on that declaration that he or she knows to be false be subject to a civil penalty of a specified amount. The bill would require a program administrator to underwrite an assessment contract, and would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make payments on that contract. unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the contract, subject to specified requirements. The bill would require a program administrator, before a PACE assessment is consummated and in addition to other disclosures, a property owner consummates an assessment contract, to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE Program program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses specified information relating to the property owner or the property.
The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance or a payment holiday for a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process to request a payment forbearance or payment holiday, and to establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or a payment holiday. The bill would require a program administrator to grant a modification to a PACE assessment if specified requirements are met.
The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property.
The bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to obtain a sworn declaration of income containing specified financial information from each property owner, and would provide that a declarant who willfully states as true a material fact on that declaration that he or she knows to be false be subject to a civil penalty of a specified amount. The bill would require a program administrator to underwrite an assessment contract, and would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make payments on that contract. The bill would require a program administrator administrator, before a PACE assessment is consummated and in addition to other disclosures, to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner before authorizing a contractor to commence work to install the measure. owner. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE Program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property has been approved to a contractor or 3rd party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts for that program administrator. specified information relating to the property owner or the property.
The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance of a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property.
The bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to obtain a sworn statement, signed under penalty of perjury, containing specified financial information from a property owner and declaration of income containing specified financial information from each property owner, and would provide that a declarant who willfully states as true a material fact on that declaration that he or she knows to be false be subject to a civil penalty of a specified amount. The bill would require a program administrator to underwrite an assessment contract, and would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make payments on that contract. By requiring that statement to be sworn under penalty of perjury this bill would expand the crime of perjury and would therefore impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require a program administrator to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner before authorizing a contractor to commence work to install the measure. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE Program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property has been approved to a contractor or 3rd party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts for that program administrator.
The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance of a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property.
The bill would require a program administrator that administers a PACE program on behalf of a public agency to comply with certain requirements when approving an assessment contract for the installation of an eligible measure, as well as the administration of that contract, including requiring the contract to comply with specified criteria and requirements. The bill would require a program administrator to obtain a sworn statement, signed under penalty of perjury, containing specified financial information from a property owner and to underwrite an assessment contract, and would prohibit a program administrator from approving an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make payments on that contract. By requiring that statement to be sworn under penalty of perjury this bill would expand the crime of perjury and would therefore impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require a program administrator to provide an oral confirmation of the key terms of an assessment contract with the property owner or an authorized representative of the property owner before authorizing a contractor to commence work to install the measure. The bill would require a program administrator for each PACE Program that it administers to establish and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and would prohibit the program administrator from approving PACE assessments for a measure that is not included on that list, unless the program administrator establishes a custom measure in accordance with specified requirements.
The bill would prohibit a contractor or other 3rd party from advertising the availability of an assessment contract that is administered by a program administrator, or from soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless specified requirements are met. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a contractor or 3rd party that is in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale or installation of measures financed by an assessment contract, except for reimbursement of expenses as provided. The bill would also prohibit a program administrator from providing direct or indirect cash payments or anything of a material value to a property owner that is explicitly conditioned upon the property owner entering into the assessment contract. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with applicable state and federal law. The bill would prohibit a program administrator from providing information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property has been approved to a contractor or 3rd party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts for that program administrator.
The bill would require a program administrator to provide the property owner payment forbearance of a PACE assessment if the property owner and a mortgage lender had reached an agreement to provide forbearance, as specified. The bill would require a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report, at least annually, to the public agency that contains specified information regarding that program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This bill would state that it is the intent of the Legislature, in order to ensure that PACE programs continue to effectively meet their public purposes, to enact legislation to enhance the requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by 3rd parties must conform.Existing law authorizes applicants, defined as including specified public agencies, entities administering Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing programs on behalf of and with the written consent of public agencies, or financial institutions, to assist property owners in financing the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements through the issuance of PACE bonds that are secured by voluntary contractual assessments, voluntary special taxes, or special taxes on property.
This bill would state that it is the intent of the Legislature, in order to ensure that PACE programs continue to effectively meet their public purposes, to enact legislation to enhance the requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by 3rd parties must conform.
The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more efficiency improvements on the real property in accordance with a PACE program, specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(b)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(c)Efficiency improvement means one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property.
(d)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(e)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of efficiency improvements on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(f)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(g)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(h)Public agency means a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
5913.(a)(1)Before a property owner executes an assessment contract the program administrator shall do the following:
(A)Make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of the contract assessment documents required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or Section 53328.1 of the Government Code, as applicable, with all the key terms completed, the financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17, and the right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16, with hard copies available upon request.
(B)Make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract, in plain language, with the property owner on the call or to a verified authorized representative of the owner on the call and shall obtain acknowledgment from the property owner on the call to whom the oral confirmation is given.
(2)The oral confirmation required pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include, but is not limited to, all the following information:
(A)The property owner on the call has the right to have other persons present for the call, and an inquiry as to whether the property owner would like to exercise the right to include anyone else on the call. This shall occur at the onset of the call, after the determination of the preferred language of communication.
(B)The property owner on the call is informed that they should review the assessment contract and financing estimate and disclosure form with all other owners of the property.
(C)The efficiency improvement being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(D)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(E)The total estimated average monthly amount of funds the property owner would have to save in order to pay the annual costs under the PACE assessment, including applicable fees.
(F)That the county annual secured property tax bill, which will include the installment of the PACE lien, will be mailed by the county tax collector no later than November 1 each year, and that if the lien is recorded after the fiscal year closes but before the bill is mailed, the first installment may not appear on the county tax bill until the following year.
(G)The term of the assessment contract.
(H)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through an additional annual assessment on the property and paid either directly to the county tax collectors office as part of the total annual secured property tax bill, or through the property owners mortgage impound account, and that if the property owner pays his or her taxes through an impound account he or she should notify their mortgage lender to discuss adjusting his or her monthly mortgage payment by the estimated monthly cost of the PACE assessment.
(I)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract and that the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(J)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property, if known to and understood by the property owner.
(K)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(L)That the program administrator and contractor do not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding tax credits, tax deductibility, or of other tax impacts on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(M)That if that property tax payment is delinquent within the fiscal year, the county tax collector will assess a 10-percent penalty and may assess related costs, as required by state law. A delinquent payment also subjects the property to foreclosure. If the delinquent payment continues past June 30 of a given year and defaults, the county tax collector will assess penalties at the rate of 1 12 percent per month (18 percent per year), and the property will continue to be subject to foreclosure and may become subject to the county tax collectors right to sell the property at auction.
(N)That the property owner has a three-business day right to cancel the assessment contract pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16, and that canceling the assessment contract may also cancel the home improvement contract under Section 5940.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(3)Recording of an oral confirmation shall be retained by the program administrator for a period of at least five years from the time of the recording.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
(d)At the commencement of the oral confirmation, the program administrator shall ask if the property owner on the call would prefer to communicate during the oral confirmation primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code. If the preferred language is supported by the program administrator, the oral confirmation shall be given in that primary language, except where the property owner on the call chooses to communicate through his or her own interpreter. If the preferred language is not supported and an interpreter is not chosen by the property owner on the call, the PACE assessment transaction shall not proceed. For purposes of this subdivision, his or her own interpreter means a person, who is not a minor, is able to speak fluently and read with full understanding both the English language and any of the languages specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, and who is not employed by, and whose services are not made available through, the program administrator, the public agency, or the contractor.
(e)(1)Beginning on January 1, 2019, if the oral confirmation was conducted primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, the program administrator shall deliver in writing the disclosures and contract or agreement required by law, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Assessment contract documents specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(B)The financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17.
(C)The right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16.
(2)Before the execution of any contract or agreement described in paragraph (1), the program administrator shall deliver a translation of the disclosures, contract, or agreement in the language in which the oral confirmation was conducted, that includes a translation of every term and condition in that contract or agreement.
5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
5923.(a)A program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator shall not reimburse a contractor or third party for expenses for advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral. A program administrator may reimburse a contractors bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, provided that:
(1)The training expenses are actually incurred by the contractor.
(2)The reimbursement does not exceed one hundred dollars ($100) per each salesperson or agent of the contractor who participated in the training.
(3)The reimbursement is paid directly to the contractor, and is not paid to its salespersons or agents.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.A program administrator, contractor, or a third party shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.A contractor shall not provide a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
5940.(a)It shall be unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract, and the home improvement contract shall be unenforceable, if both of the following occur:
(1)The property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program.
(2)The property owner applies for, accepts, and cancels the PACE financing within the right to cancel period set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16.
(b)If work has commenced in violation of subdivision (a), then:
(1)The contractor is entitled to no compensation for that work.
(2)The contractor shall restore the property to its original condition at no cost to the property owner.
(3)The contractor shall immediately and without condition return all money, property, and other consideration given by the property owner. If the property owner gave any property as consideration and the contractor does not or cannot return it for whatever reason, the contractor shall immediately return the fair market value of the property or its value as designated in the contract, whichever is greater.
(c)(1)If the contractor has delivered any property to the property owner pursuant to a contract that is unenforceable under subdivision (a), the property owner shall make the property available to the contractor for return within 90 days of execution of the contract provided that:
(A)The provisions of subdivision (b) have been met.
(B)The property can be practically returned to the contractor and removed, at the contractors expense, without leaving any damage to the property owners property.
(2)Failure of the contractor to comply with this subdivision shall allow the property owner to retain without obligation in law or equity any property provided pursuant to the unenforceable contract.
(d)The property owner may waive the requirements in subdivision (a) if all the following are met:
(1)The contract is executed in connection with the making of emergency or immediately necessary repairs to protect persons or real or personal property.
(2)The property owner initiated the contract for the emergency repair or immediately necessary repair.
(3)The property owner provides a separate statement that is handwritten in ink by a property owner and dated and signed by each property owner, describing the situation that requires immediate remedy, and expressly acknowledges that the contractor has informed them of his or her right to cancel and that he or she waive the right to cancel the sale.
(e)If the property owner waives his or her right to cancel on the home improvement contract to allow the home improvement contractor to proceed with installation, and then cancels his or her PACE financing, it shall not invalidate the home improvement contract.
5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report to the public agency no later than February 1 for the activity that occurred between July 1st through December 31st of the previous year, and another report no later than August 1 for the activity that occurred between January 1st through June 30th of that year. Those reports shall contain the following information, along with all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in preparing the report:
(1)The number of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(4)The categories of installed efficiency improvements whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(5)The definition of default used by the program administrator.
(6)For each delinquent assessment:
(A)The total delinquent amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(7)For each defaulted assessment:
(A)The total defaulted amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(D)The percentage the defaults represent of the total assessments within each ZIP Code.
(E)The total number of parcels defaulted and the number of years in default for each property.
(8)The estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of those savings by property owners by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of energy savings improvements, and number of improvements installed that are qualified for the Energy Star program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(9)The estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of renewable energy installations, including the average and median system size.
(10)The estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of water savings improvements, the number of efficiency improvements that are qualified for the WaterSense program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(11)The estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(12)The estimated number of jobs created.
(13)The average and median amount of annual and total PACE assessments based on ZIP Code, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(14)The number and percentage of homeowners over 60 years old by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(b)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
(c)A public agency that receives a report pursuant to this section shall make the data publicly available on its Internet Web site.
(d)This section does not limit another governmental or regulatory entity from establishing reporting requirements.
SEC. 2.This act addresses a matter of statewide concern and therefore shall apply equally to all cities and counties, including charter cities.The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more efficiency improvements on the real property in accordance with a PACE program, specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(b)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(c)Efficiency improvement means one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property.
(d)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(e)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of efficiency improvements on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(f)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(g)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(h)Public agency means a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
5913.(a)(1)Before a property owner executes an assessment contract the program administrator shall do the following:
(A)Make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of the contract assessment documents required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or Section 53328.1 of the Government Code, as applicable, with all the key terms completed, the financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17, and the right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16, with hard copies available upon request.
(B)Make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract, in plain language, with the property owner on the call or to a verified authorized representative of the owner on the call and shall obtain acknowledgment from the property owner on the call to whom the oral confirmation is given.
(2)The oral confirmation required pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include, but is not limited to, all the following information:
(A)The property owner on the call has the right to have other persons present for the call, and an inquiry as to whether the property owner would like to exercise the right to include anyone else on the call. This shall occur at the onset of the call, after the determination of the preferred language of communication.
(B)The property owner on the call is informed that they should review the assessment contract and financing estimate and disclosure form with all other owners of the property.
(C)The efficiency improvement being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(D)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(E)The total estimated average monthly amount of funds the property owner would have to save in order to pay the annual costs under the PACE assessment, including applicable fees.
(F)That the county annual secured property tax bill, which will include the installment of the PACE lien, will be mailed by the county tax collector no later than November 1 each year, and that if the lien is recorded after the fiscal year closes but before the bill is mailed, the first installment may not appear on the county tax bill until the following year.
(G)The term of the assessment contract.
(H)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through an additional annual assessment on the property and paid either directly to the county tax collectors office as part of the total annual secured property tax bill, or through the property owners mortgage impound account, and that if the property owner pays his or her taxes through an impound account he or she should notify their mortgage lender to discuss adjusting his or her monthly mortgage payment by the estimated monthly cost of the PACE assessment.
(I)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract and that the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(J)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property, if known to and understood by the property owner.
(K)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(L)That the program administrator and contractor do not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding tax credits, tax deductibility, or of other tax impacts on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(M)That if that property tax payment is delinquent within the fiscal year, the county tax collector will assess a 10-percent penalty and may assess related costs, as required by state law. A delinquent payment also subjects the property to foreclosure. If the delinquent payment continues past June 30 of a given year and defaults, the county tax collector will assess penalties at the rate of 1 12 percent per month (18 percent per year), and the property will continue to be subject to foreclosure and may become subject to the county tax collectors right to sell the property at auction.
(N)That the property owner has a three-business day right to cancel the assessment contract pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16, and that canceling the assessment contract may also cancel the home improvement contract under Section 5940.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(3)Recording of an oral confirmation shall be retained by the program administrator for a period of at least five years from the time of the recording.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
(d)At the commencement of the oral confirmation, the program administrator shall ask if the property owner on the call would prefer to communicate during the oral confirmation primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code. If the preferred language is supported by the program administrator, the oral confirmation shall be given in that primary language, except where the property owner on the call chooses to communicate through his or her own interpreter. If the preferred language is not supported and an interpreter is not chosen by the property owner on the call, the PACE assessment transaction shall not proceed. For purposes of this subdivision, his or her own interpreter means a person, who is not a minor, is able to speak fluently and read with full understanding both the English language and any of the languages specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, and who is not employed by, and whose services are not made available through, the program administrator, the public agency, or the contractor.
(e)(1)Beginning on January 1, 2019, if the oral confirmation was conducted primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, the program administrator shall deliver in writing the disclosures and contract or agreement required by law, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Assessment contract documents specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(B)The financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17.
(C)The right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16.
(2)Before the execution of any contract or agreement described in paragraph (1), the program administrator shall deliver a translation of the disclosures, contract, or agreement in the language in which the oral confirmation was conducted, that includes a translation of every term and condition in that contract or agreement.
5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
5923.(a)A program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator shall not reimburse a contractor or third party for expenses for advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral. A program administrator may reimburse a contractors bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, provided that:
(1)The training expenses are actually incurred by the contractor.
(2)The reimbursement does not exceed one hundred dollars ($100) per each salesperson or agent of the contractor who participated in the training.
(3)The reimbursement is paid directly to the contractor, and is not paid to its salespersons or agents.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.A program administrator, contractor, or a third party shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.A contractor shall not provide a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
5940.(a)It shall be unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract, and the home improvement contract shall be unenforceable, if both of the following occur:
(1)The property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program.
(2)The property owner applies for, accepts, and cancels the PACE financing within the right to cancel period set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16.
(b)If work has commenced in violation of subdivision (a), then:
(1)The contractor is entitled to no compensation for that work.
(2)The contractor shall restore the property to its original condition at no cost to the property owner.
(3)The contractor shall immediately and without condition return all money, property, and other consideration given by the property owner. If the property owner gave any property as consideration and the contractor does not or cannot return it for whatever reason, the contractor shall immediately return the fair market value of the property or its value as designated in the contract, whichever is greater.
(c)(1)If the contractor has delivered any property to the property owner pursuant to a contract that is unenforceable under subdivision (a), the property owner shall make the property available to the contractor for return within 90 days of execution of the contract provided that:
(A)The provisions of subdivision (b) have been met.
(B)The property can be practically returned to the contractor and removed, at the contractors expense, without leaving any damage to the property owners property.
(2)Failure of the contractor to comply with this subdivision shall allow the property owner to retain without obligation in law or equity any property provided pursuant to the unenforceable contract.
(d)The property owner may waive the requirements in subdivision (a) if all the following are met:
(1)The contract is executed in connection with the making of emergency or immediately necessary repairs to protect persons or real or personal property.
(2)The property owner initiated the contract for the emergency repair or immediately necessary repair.
(3)The property owner provides a separate statement that is handwritten in ink by a property owner and dated and signed by each property owner, describing the situation that requires immediate remedy, and expressly acknowledges that the contractor has informed them of his or her right to cancel and that he or she waive the right to cancel the sale.
(e)If the property owner waives his or her right to cancel on the home improvement contract to allow the home improvement contractor to proceed with installation, and then cancels his or her PACE financing, it shall not invalidate the home improvement contract.
5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report to the public agency no later than February 1 for the activity that occurred between July 1st through December 31st of the previous year, and another report no later than August 1 for the activity that occurred between January 1st through June 30th of that year. Those reports shall contain the following information, along with all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in preparing the report:
(1)The number of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(4)The categories of installed efficiency improvements whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(5)The definition of default used by the program administrator.
(6)For each delinquent assessment:
(A)The total delinquent amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(7)For each defaulted assessment:
(A)The total defaulted amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(D)The percentage the defaults represent of the total assessments within each ZIP Code.
(E)The total number of parcels defaulted and the number of years in default for each property.
(8)The estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of those savings by property owners by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of energy savings improvements, and number of improvements installed that are qualified for the Energy Star program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(9)The estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of renewable energy installations, including the average and median system size.
(10)The estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of water savings improvements, the number of efficiency improvements that are qualified for the WaterSense program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(11)The estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(12)The estimated number of jobs created.
(13)The average and median amount of annual and total PACE assessments based on ZIP Code, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(14)The number and percentage of homeowners over 60 years old by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(b)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
(c)A public agency that receives a report pursuant to this section shall make the data publicly available on its Internet Web site.
(d)This section does not limit another governmental or regulatory entity from establishing reporting requirements.
SEC. 2.This act addresses a matter of statewide concern and therefore shall apply equally to all cities and counties, including charter cities.The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more efficiency improvements on the real property in accordance with a PACE program. program, specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(b)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(b)(c)Efficiency improvement means one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property.
(c)(d)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(d)(e)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of efficiency improvements on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(e)(f)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(f)(g)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(g)(h)Public agency means a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
5913.(a)(1)Before a property owner executes an assessment contract the program administrator shall do the following:
(A)Make an oral confirmation that at least one owner of the property has a copy of the contract assessment documents required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or Section 53328.1 of the Government Code, as applicable, with all the key terms completed, the financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17, and the right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16, with hard copies available upon request.
(B)Make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract, in plain language, with the property owner on the call or to a verified authorized representative of the owner on the call and shall obtain acknowledgment from the property owner on the call to whom the oral confirmation is given.
(2)The oral confirmation required pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include, but is not limited to, all the following information:
(A)The property owner on the call has the right to have other persons present for the call, and an inquiry as to whether the property owner would like to exercise the right to include anyone else on the call. This shall occur at the onset of the call, after the determination of the preferred language of communication.
(B)The property owner on the call is informed that they should review the assessment contract and financing estimate and disclosure form with all other owners of the property.
(C)The efficiency improvement being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(D)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(E)The total estimated average monthly amount of funds the property owner would have to save in order to pay the annual costs under the PACE assessment, including applicable fees.
(F)That the county annual secured property tax bill, which will include the installment of the PACE lien, will be mailed by the county tax collector no later than November 1 each year, and that if the lien is recorded after the fiscal year closes but before the bill is mailed, the first installment may not appear on the county tax bill until the following year.
(G)The term of the assessment contract.
(H)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through an additional annual assessment on the property and paid either directly to the county tax collectors office as part of the total annual secured property tax bill, or through the property owners mortgage impound account, and that if the property owner pays his or her taxes through an impound account he or she should notify their mortgage lender to discuss adjusting his or her monthly mortgage payment by the estimated monthly cost of the PACE assessment.
(I)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract and that the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(J)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property, if known to and understood by the property owner.
(K)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(L)That the program administrator and contractor do not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding tax credits, tax deductibility, or of other tax impacts on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(M)That if that property tax payment is delinquent within the fiscal year, the county tax collector will assess a 10-percent penalty and may assess related costs, as required by state law. A delinquent payment also subjects the property to foreclosure. If the delinquent payment continues past June 30 of a given year and defaults, the county tax collector will assess penalties at the rate of 1 12 percent per month (18 percent per year), and the property will continue to be subject to foreclosure and may become subject to the county tax collectors right to sell the property at auction.
(N)That the property owner has a three-business day right to cancel the assessment contract pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16, and that canceling the assessment contract may also cancel the home improvement contract under Section 5940.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(3)Recording of an oral confirmation shall be retained by the program administrator for a period of at least five years from the time of the recording.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
(d)At the commencement of the oral confirmation, the program administrator shall ask if the property owner on the call would prefer to communicate during the oral confirmation primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code. If the preferred language is supported by the program administrator, the oral confirmation shall be given in that primary language, except where the property owner on the call chooses to communicate through his or her own interpreter. If the preferred language is not supported and an interpreter is not chosen by the property owner on the call, the PACE assessment transaction shall not proceed. For purposes of this subdivision, his or her own interpreter means a person, who is not a minor, is able to speak fluently and read with full understanding both the English language and any of the languages specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, and who is not employed by, and whose services are not made available through, the program administrator, the public agency, or the contractor.
(e)(1)Beginning on January 1, 2019, if the oral confirmation was conducted primarily in a language other than English that is specified in Section 1632 of the Civil Code, the program administrator shall deliver in writing the disclosures and contract or agreement required by law, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Assessment contract documents specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 or Section 5899 or 5899.3, or a special tax described in Section 53328.1 of the Government Code.
(B)The financing estimate and disclosure form specified in Section 5898.17.
(C)The right to cancel form specified in Section 5898.16.
(2)Before the execution of any contract or agreement described in paragraph (1), the program administrator shall deliver a translation of the disclosures, contract, or agreement in the language in which the oral confirmation was conducted, that includes a translation of every term and condition in that contract or agreement.
5903.5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the efficiency improvement is completed.
5904.5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
5905.5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a A program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to shall not reimburse documented a contractor or third party for expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded for advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events. collateral. A program administrator may reimburse a contractors bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing, provided that:
(1)The training expenses are actually incurred by the contractor.
(2)The reimbursement does not exceed one hundred dollars ($100) per each salesperson or agent of the contractor who participated in the training.
(3)The reimbursement is paid directly to the contractor, and is not paid to its salespersons or agents.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5906.5924.A program administrator, contractor, or a third party shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5907.5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.A contractor shall not provide a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
5940.(a)It shall be unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract, and the home improvement contract shall be unenforceable, if both of the following occur:
(1)The property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program.
(2)The property owner applies for, accepts, and cancels the PACE financing within the right to cancel period set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 5898.16.
(b)If work has commenced in violation of subdivision (a), then:
(1)The contractor is entitled to no compensation for that work.
(2)The contractor shall restore the property to its original condition at no cost to the property owner.
(3)The contractor shall immediately and without condition return all money, property, and other consideration given by the property owner. If the property owner gave any property as consideration and the contractor does not or cannot return it for whatever reason, the contractor shall immediately return the fair market value of the property or its value as designated in the contract, whichever is greater.
(c)(1)If the contractor has delivered any property to the property owner pursuant to a contract that is unenforceable under subdivision (a), the property owner shall make the property available to the contractor for return within 90 days of execution of the contract provided that:
(A)The provisions of subdivision (b) have been met.
(B)The property can be practically returned to the contractor and removed, at the contractors expense, without leaving any damage to the property owners property.
(2)Failure of the contractor to comply with this subdivision shall allow the property owner to retain without obligation in law or equity any property provided pursuant to the unenforceable contract.
(d)The property owner may waive the requirements in subdivision (a) if all the following are met:
(1)The contract is executed in connection with the making of emergency or immediately necessary repairs to protect persons or real or personal property.
(2)The property owner initiated the contract for the emergency repair or immediately necessary repair.
(3)The property owner provides a separate statement that is handwritten in ink by a property owner and dated and signed by each property owner, describing the situation that requires immediate remedy, and expressly acknowledges that the contractor has informed them of his or her right to cancel and that he or she waive the right to cancel the sale.
(e)If the property owner waives his or her right to cancel on the home improvement contract to allow the home improvement contractor to proceed with installation, and then cancels his or her PACE financing, it shall not invalidate the home improvement contract.
5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report to the public agency no later than February 1 for the activity that occurred between July 1st through December 31st of the previous year, and another report no later than August 1 for the activity that occurred between January 1st through June 30th of that year. Those reports shall contain the following information, along with all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in preparing the report:
(1)The number of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(4)The categories of installed efficiency improvements whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(5)The definition of default used by the program administrator.
(6)For each delinquent assessment:
(A)The total delinquent amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(7)For each defaulted assessment:
(A)The total defaulted amount.
(B)The number and dates of missed payments.
(C)ZIP Code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located.
(D)The percentage the defaults represent of the total assessments within each ZIP Code.
(E)The total number of parcels defaulted and the number of years in default for each property.
(8)The estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of those savings by property owners by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of energy savings improvements, and number of improvements installed that are qualified for the Energy Star program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(9)The estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by the efficiency improvements installed in the calendar year, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of renewable energy installations, including the average and median system size.
(10)The estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners, by city, county, and ZIP Code. In addition, the report shall state the total number of water savings improvements, the number of efficiency improvements that are qualified for the WaterSense program of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, including the overall average efficiency rating of installed units for each product type.
(11)The estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(12)The estimated number of jobs created.
(13)The average and median amount of annual and total PACE assessments based on ZIP Code, by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(14)The number and percentage of homeowners over 60 years old by city, county, and ZIP Code.
(b)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
(c)A public agency that receives a report pursuant to this section shall make the data publicly available on its Internet Web site.
(d)This section does not limit another governmental or regulatory entity from establishing reporting requirements.
SEC. 2.This act addresses a matter of statewide concern and therefore shall apply equally to all cities and counties, including charter cities.The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.(b)(a)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures efficiency improvements on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.(d)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.(e)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.(f)Energy utility means an electrical corporation as defined in Section 218, a gas corporation as defined in Section 222, a local publicly owned electric utility as defined in Section 224.3 of the Public Utilities Code, and a local publicly owned gas utility. Energy utility also means a community choice aggregator or other entity, other than an electrical corporation or gas corporation, approved by the Public Utilities Commission to administer programs providing energy efficiency-related services or incentives for eligible solar energy systems to end users using moneys collected by an electrical corporation or gas corporation from ratepayers or moneys made available pursuant to Section 748.5 of the Public Utilities Code. (g)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.(b)Efficiency improvement means one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property.
(h)(c)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(i)(d)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures efficiency improvements on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(j)(e)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(k)(f)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(l)(g)Public agency means a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
(m)Public water system has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 116275 of the Health and Safety Code.2. Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the following criteria are met:(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current. The property owner shall also certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes on the property for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.(b)The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).(d)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.(e)The property owner has not been a party to any bankruptcy proceedings within the last seven years, except that the property owner may have been party to a bankruptcy proceeding that was discharged or dismissed between two and seven years before the application date and the property owner has had no payments more than 30 days past due on any mortgage debt or nonmortgage debt (excluding medical debt) during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.(f)The property owner is current on all mortgage debt on the subject property, and has been late on such payments no more than once during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.(h)The measures to be installed pursuant to the assessment contract are eligible under the terms of the applicable PACE program.(i)The total amount of PACE assessments on the property, inclusive of any preexisting assessments, shall be no more than 15 percent of the market value of the property.(j)The total PACE assessments and the mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the PACE assessment will not exceed 961/2 percent of the market value of the property.(k)The term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the estimated useful life of the measure to which the greatest portion of funds disbursed under the assessment contract is attributable. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.(l)The property owner shall notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall not invalidate an assessment contract or any obligations thereunder, notwithstanding where the combined amount of the PACE assessments exceed the criteria set forth in subdivision (j) or (k).5911.(a)A program administrator may derive market value using one of the following:(1)An automated valuation model, which is a computerized property valuation system that is used to derive a reasonable real property value.(2)A brokers price opinion conducted by a real estate broker licensed pursuant to Part 1 (commencing with Section 10000) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.(3)An appraisal conducted by a state-licensed real estate appraiser licensed pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 11300) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.(4)The assessed value of the property. If the assessed value is used, the determination of market value shall be deemed valid on its face.(b)The market value determination by the program administrator shall be disclosed to the property owner.5912.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that, at the time the assessment contract is signed, the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessment based on the property owners income, assets and current debt obligations.(a)The property owner shall state his or her income to the program administrator as a condition of application.(b)The program administrator shall obtain one or more credit reports on the property owner from a consumer reporting agency in connection with underwriting the PACE assessment, and may use a credit report prepared by a credit reporting agency that is transmitted electronically.(c)If the annual PACE assessment payments will exceed 1.5 percent of the market value of the property subject to the assessment, the program administrator shall verify the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.(d)In evaluating the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner, the equity of the property that will secure the assessment shall not be considered.5913.(a)Before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract to at least one owner of the property or authorized representative of the property owner, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the oral confirmation is given. Such oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.(4)The term of the assessment contract.(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.(7)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property.(8)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to his or her other expenses.(9)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.(10)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the tax impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.(11)That the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.5914.5903.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the measure efficiency improvement is completed.
5915.Except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 5913, a PACE program administered by a program administrator shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.16 or paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code to the extent any requirement in those paragraphs are inconsistent with any provision of this article.3. Eligible Projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:(1)Permanently affixed to real property.(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:(1)A name or description.(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.(3)Expected useful life. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. A measure may comply with this paragraph if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment.(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.(e)The provisions of this section shall not apply to measures that are seismic strengthening improvements authorized under Section 5899.5922.5904.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
5923.5905.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures efficiency improvements financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.5906.A program administrator administrator, contractor, or a third party shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.5907.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts. 4. Reporting 5930.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information for the preceding calendar year:(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis.(5)Rates of default, including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.(6)Estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of those savings by property owners by measures installed in the calendar year.(7)Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by measures installed in the calendar year.(8)Estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners.(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.(10)Estimated number of jobs created.(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.SEC. 2.This act addresses a matter of statewide concern and therefore shall apply equally to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(d)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(e)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.
(f)Energy utility means an electrical corporation as defined in Section 218, a gas corporation as defined in Section 222, a local publicly owned electric utility as defined in Section 224.3 of the Public Utilities Code, and a local publicly owned gas utility. Energy utility also means a community choice aggregator or other entity, other than an electrical corporation or gas corporation, approved by the Public Utilities Commission to administer programs providing energy-efficiency-related energy efficiency-related services or incentives for eligible solar energy systems to end users using moneys collected by an electrical corporation or gas corporation from ratepayers or moneys made available pursuant to Section 748.5 of the Public Utilities Code.
(g)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(h)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(i)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(j)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(k)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(l)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
(m)Public water system has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 116275 of the Health and Safety Code.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the following criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current. The property owner shall also certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes on the property for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(d)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(e)The property owner has not been a party to any bankruptcy proceedings within the last seven years, except that the property owner may have been party to a bankruptcy proceeding that was discharged or dismissed between two and seven years before the application date and the property owner has had no payments more than 30 days past due on any mortgage debt or nonmortgage debt (excluding medical debt) during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(f)The property owner is current on all mortgage debt on the subject property, and has been late on such payments no more than once during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The measures to be installed pursuant to the assessment contract are eligible under the terms of the applicable PACE program.
(i)The total amount of PACE assessments on the property, inclusive of any preexisting assessments, shall be no more than 15 percent of the market value of the property.
(j)The total PACE assessments and the mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the PACE assessment will not exceed 961/2 percent of the market value of the property.
(k)The term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the estimated useful life of the measure to which the greatest portion of funds disbursed under the assessment contract is attributable. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(l)The property owner shall notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall not invalidate an assessment contract or any obligations thereunder, notwithstanding where the combined amount of the PACE assessments exceed the criteria set forth in subdivision (j) or (k).
5911.(a)A program administrator may derive market value using one of the following:
(1)An automated valuation model, which is a computerized property valuation system that is used to derive a reasonable real property value.
(2)A brokers price opinion conducted by a real estate broker licensed pursuant to Part 1 (commencing with Section 10000) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(3)An appraisal conducted by a state-licensed real estate appraiser licensed pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 11300) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)The assessed value of the property. If the assessed value is used, the determination of market value shall be deemed valid on its face.
(b)The market value determination by the program administrator shall be disclosed to the property owner.
5912.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that, at the time the assessment contract is signed, the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessment based on the property owners income, assets and current debt obligations.
(a)The property owner shall state his or her income to the program administrator as a condition of application.
(b)The program administrator shall obtain one or more credit reports on the property owner from a consumer reporting agency in connection with underwriting the PACE assessment, and may use a credit report prepared by a credit reporting agency that is transmitted electronically.
(c)If the annual PACE assessment payments will exceed 1.5 percent of the market value of the property subject to the assessment, the program administrator shall verify the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.
(d)In evaluating the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner, the equity of the property that will secure the assessment shall not be considered.
5913.(a)Before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract to at least one owner of the property or authorized representative of the property owner, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the oral confirmation is given. Such oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property.
(8)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to his or her other expenses.
(9)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(10)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the tax impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(11)That the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
5915.Except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 5913, a PACE program administered by a program administrator shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.16 or paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code to the extent any requirement in those paragraphs are inconsistent with any provision of this article.
3.Eligible Projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. A measure may comply with this paragraph if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
(e)The provisions of this section shall not apply to measures that are seismic strengthening improvements authorized under Section 5899.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Reporting5930.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information for the preceding calendar year:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis.
(5)Rates of default, including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.
(6)Estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of those savings by property owners by measures installed in the calendar year.
(7)Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by measures installed in the calendar year.
(8)Estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
4.Property Owner Recourse5930.(a)Subject to Section 5931, a property owner may assert all claims against a program administrator for a breach of a representation or warranty that the property owner could assert against a seller of goods or services that were obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment, where such seller either:(1)Referred the property owner to the program administrator.(2)Was affiliated with the program administrator by common control, contract, or business arrangement.(b)Any modification of a PACE assessment made pursuant to a claim asserted under this section shall not affect the validity or enforceability of such PACE assessment or any bonds issued in connection with such PACE assessment.5931.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish and make available to property owners a reasonable review process for receiving, evaluating, and remedying claims made against it by property owners as described in Section 5930. A program administrator shall make publicly available the process that it uses to determine appropriate remedies for property owners making such claims.(b)A property owner seeking remedy against a program administrator for a claim arising under Section 5930 shall file a formal claim using the review process established by the program administrator pursuant to subdivision (a). The program administrator and the property owner shall have 45 days to resolve the claim from the time of being formally filed, excepting extensions by mutual agreement. Thereafter, the property owner may assert such claim against a program administrator through arbitration, litigation, or some other dispute resolution procedure. Even after a property owner completes the review process, such property owner maintains the right to participate in any legal action against a program administrator with respect to such a claim. Notwithstanding the above, a property owner shall have no standing to pursue or participate in any legal action (individually or as part of a class) against a program administrator with respect to a claim described in Section 5930 if the property owner fails to exhaust the remedies established by the program administrator under this section.(c)A property owner may not file a formal claim against a program administrator as set forth in this section after the later of:(1)One year from the date of the recordation of the assessment contract.(2)The date that the first payment under the PACE assessment becomes due.(d)Liability for any claim or cause of action arising under this article shall not exceed the amount of the PACE assessment.(e)A property owner that has filed a formal claim pursuant to this section does not expand or limit any legal rights or causes of action otherwise available to the property owner against a contractor or third party, or that a program administrator may have against a contractor or third party.5932.During the pendency of any review process pursuant to Section 5931, the program administrator shall provide forbearance to the property owner if the property owner so requests in writing and meets the criteria established in subdivision (b) of Section 5941.5.Forbearance5940.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner for any monthly mortgage payment amount or portion thereof, the program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance or payment holiday for the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices.5941.(a)For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, for each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process for property owners to request payment forbearance or payment holiday for a PACE assessment.(b)A program administrator shall establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or payment holiday for a property owners PACE assessment. A program administrator shall grant forbearance to a property owner if the program administrator receives credible evidence that the property owner does both of the following:(1)Experiences a significant reduction of income as a result of involuntary unemployment, temporary disability, a natural disaster, or other unplanned and economically detrimental event.(2)That such property owner is able to meet all property tax and real estate-secured debt obligations associated with the property, excluding the obligations under the PACE assessment.5942.(a)For each PACE assessment, a property owner is entitled to an aggregate of either:(1)One annual forbearance payment (comprising a single fiscal year).(2)Semiannual forbearance payments for the lifetime of the assessment.(b)Forbearance granted pursuant to Section 5932 shall not count toward the lifetime total. 5943.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, and notwithstanding any provision of this division or the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)), if a property owner receives a permanent modification of a mortgage encumbering a property on which the public agency has caused an assessment to be recorded, and such modification results in a reduction of the unpaid principal balance of such mortgage, upon presentation of the agreement of permanent modification, the program administrator shall promptly reduce the unpaid principal balance of the PACE assessment by no less than a percentage equal to the percentage by which the mortgage balance was reduced.5944.(a)For any PACE assessment for which a program administrator provides forbearance, payment holiday, or modification to a property owner, the payments due on the assessment contract during such forbearance or payment holiday or as a result of such modification shall be satisfied by the program administrator, and the program administrator shall be liable for any penalty, late charge, or loss arising from its failure to make such payments during the forbearance or payment holiday.(b)Any forbearance that results in a delay or deferment of the repayment obligation that results in the timing of the repayment being extended shall not be deemed a violation of any useful life determination used in the assessment term, so long as the useful life determination and assessment term were valid at origination.(c)The period during which the payment has been deferred or delayed shall not accrue interest.5945.The forbearance, payment holiday, or modification of any PACE assessment shall not affect the validity or enforceability of such PACE assessment or any bonds issued in connection with such PACE assessment, and shall not constitute a violation of any provision of the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)).6.Legal Rights5950.A program administrator shall not preclude or otherwise limit, whether by agreement to submit to mandatory arbitration or to waive the right to participate in a class or representative action, or by any other method, a property owners right to initiate legal action, with respect to the following:(a)A claim related to any right established pursuant to this chapter and Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10).(b)A claim for which the property owner has exhausted the remedies established by the program administrator under Section 5931.5951.A program administrator shall not be liable for any claim as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 5950 if the program administrator does both of the following:(a)Shows by a preponderance of evidence that an error or omission that gave rise to the claim was unintentional and resulted from a bona fide error notwithstanding the maintenance of procedures reasonably adapted to avoid any such error.(b)Within 60 days of discovering the error notifies the property owner of the error, or within 60 days of being notified by the property owner of the error and before the institution of an action under thereunder, makes appropriate changes or adjustments to the applicable documents or account or takes other action necessary to rectify the error.5952.A property owner shall not be entitled to initiate legal proceedings against a program administrator on the basis of an unrelated claim. The term unrelated claim shall mean:(a)A claim relating to any manufacturer defect of any product obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment.(b)A claim relating to any manufacturer representation regarding the performance of any product obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment.(c)A claim subject to manufacturers or other warranties.(d)A claim against a property owner.5953.A program administrator and property owner may agree to alternative dispute resolution procedures to resolve a claim not established by this chapter.7.Reporting5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information for the preceding calendar year:(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis.(5)Rates of default including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.(6)Estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners by measures installed in the calendar year.(7)Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by measures installed in the calendar year.(8)Estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners.(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.(10)Estimated number of jobs created.(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(d)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(e)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.
(f)Energy utility means an electrical corporation as defined in Section 218, a gas corporation as defined in Section 222, a local publicly owned electric utility as defined in Section 224.3 of the Public Utilities Code, and a local publicly owned gas utility. Energy utility also means a community choice aggregator or other entity, other than an electrical corporation or gas corporation, approved by the Public Utilities Commission to administer programs providing energy-efficiency-related services or incentives for eligible solar energy systems to end users using moneys collected by an electrical corporation or gas corporation from ratepayers or moneys made available pursuant to Section 748.5 of the Public Utilities Code.
(g)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(h)PACE assessment means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(i)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(j)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(k)Property owner means all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(l)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
(m)Public water system has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 116275 of the Health and Safety Code.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the following criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current. The property owner shall also certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes on the property for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(d)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(e)The property owner has not been a party to any bankruptcy proceedings within the last seven years, except that the property owner may have been party to a bankruptcy proceeding that was discharged or dismissed between two and seven years before the application date and the property owner has had no payments more than 30 days past due on any mortgage debt or nonmortgage debt (excluding medical debt) during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(f)The property owner is current on all mortgage debt on the subject property, and has been late on such payments no more than once during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The measures to be installed pursuant to the assessment contract are eligible under the terms of the applicable PACE program.
(i)The total amount of PACE assessments on the property, inclusive of any preexisting assessments, shall be no more than 15 percent of the market value of the property.
(j)The total PACE assessments and the mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the PACE assessment will not exceed 961/2 percent of the market value of the property.
(k)The term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the estimated useful life of the measure to which the greatest portion of funds disbursed under the assessment contract is attributable. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(l)The property owner shall notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall not invalidate an assessment contract or any obligations thereunder, notwithstanding where the combined amount of the PACE assessments exceeds exceed the criteria set forth in subdivision (j) or (k).
5911.(a)A program administrator may derive market value using one of the following:
(1)An automated valuation model, which is a computerized property valuation system that is used to derive a reasonable real property value.
(2)A brokers price opinion conducted by a real estate broker licensed pursuant to Part 1 (commencing with Section 10000) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(3)An appraisal conducted by a state-licensed real estate appraiser licensed pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 11300) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)The assessed value of the property. If the assessed value is used, the determination of market value shall be deemed valid on its face.
(b)The market value determination by the program administrator shall be disclosed to the property owner.
5912.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that, at the time the assessment contract is signed, the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessment based on the property owners income, assets and current debt obligations.
(a)The property owner shall state his or her income to the program administrator as a condition of application.
(b)The program administrator shall obtain one or more credit reports on the property owner from a consumer reporting agency in connection with underwriting the PACE assessment, and may use a credit report prepared by a credit reporting agency that is transmitted electronically.
(c)If the annual PACE assessment payments will exceed 1.5 percent of the market value of the property subject to the assessment, the program administrator shall verify the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.
(d)In evaluating the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner, the equity of the property that will secure the assessment shall not be considered.
5913.(a)Before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract to at least one owner of the property or authorized representative of the property owner, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the oral confirmation is given. Such oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property.
(8)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to his or her other expenses.
(9)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(10)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the tax impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(11)That the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
5915.Except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 5913, a PACE program administered by a program administrator shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.16 or paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code to the extent any requirement in those paragraphs are inconsistent with any provision of this article.
3.Eligible Projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. A measure may comply with this paragraph if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
(e)The provisions of this section shall not apply to measures that are seismic strengthening improvements authorized under Section 5899.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable law. laws.
5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Property Owner Recourse5930.(a)Subject to Section 5931, a property owner may assert all claims against a program administrator for a breach of a representation or warranty that the property owner could assert against a seller of goods or services that were obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment, where such seller either:
(1)Referred the property owner to the program administrator.
(2)Was affiliated with the program administrator by common control, contract, or business arrangement.
(b)Any modification of a PACE assessment made pursuant to a claim asserted under this section shall not affect the validity or enforceability of such PACE assessment or any bonds issued in connection with such PACE assessment.
5931.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish and make available to property owners a reasonable review process for receiving, evaluating, and remedying claims made against it by property owners as described in Section 5930. A program administrator shall make publicly available the process that it uses to determine appropriate remedies for property owners making such claims.
(b)A property owner seeking remedy against a program administrator for a claim arising under Section 5930 shall file a formal claim using the review process established by the program administrator pursuant to subdivision (a). The program administrator and the property owner shall have 45 days to resolve the claim from the time of being formally filed, excepting extensions by mutual agreement. Thereafter, the property owner may assert such claim against a program administrator through arbitration, litigation, or some other dispute resolution procedure. Even after a property owner completes the review process, such property owner maintains the right to participate in any legal action against a program administrator with respect to such a claim. Notwithstanding the above, a property owner shall have no standing to pursue or participate in any legal action (individually or as part of a class) against a program administrator with respect to a claim described in Section 5930 if the property owner fails to exhaust the remedies established by the program administrator under this section.
(c)A property owner may not file a formal claim against a program administrator as set forth in this section after the later of:
(1)One year from the date of the recordation of the assessment contract.
(2)The date that the first payment under the PACE assessment becomes due.
(d)Liability for any claim or cause of action arising under this article shall not exceed the amount of the PACE assessment.
(e)A property owner that has filed a formal claim pursuant to this section does not expand or limit any legal rights or causes of action otherwise available to the property owner against a contractor or third party, or that a program administrator may have against a contractor or third party.
5932.During the pendency of any review process pursuant to Section 5931, the program administrator shall provide forbearance to the property owner if the property owner so requests in writing and meets the criteria established in subdivision (b) of Section 5941.
4.5.Forbearance5940.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner for any monthly mortgage payment amount or portion thereof, the program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance or payment holiday for the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices.
5941.(a)For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, for each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process for property owners to request payment forbearance or payment holiday for a PACE assessment.
(b)A program administrator shall establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or payment holiday for a property owners PACE assessment. A program administrator shall grant forbearance to a property owner if the program administrator receives credible evidence that the property owner does both of the following:
(1)Experiences a significant reduction of income as a result of involuntary unemployment, temporary disability, a natural disaster, or other unplanned and economically detrimental event.
(2)That such property owner is able to meet all property tax and real estate-secured debt obligations associated with the property, excluding the obligations under the PACE assessment.
5942.(a)For each PACE assessment, a property owner is entitled to an aggregate of either:
(a)(1)One annual forbearance payment (comprising a single fiscal year).
(b)(2)Semiannual forbearance payments for the lifetime of the assessment.
(b)Forbearance granted pursuant to Section 5932 shall not count toward the lifetime total.
5943.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, and notwithstanding any provision of this division or the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)), if a property owner receives a permanent modification of a mortgage encumbering a property on which the public agency has caused an assessment to be recorded, and such modification results in a reduction of the unpaid principal balance of such mortgage, upon presentation of the agreement of permanent modification, the program administrator shall promptly reduce the unpaid principal balance of the PACE assessment by no less than a percentage equal to the percentage by which the mortgage balance was reduced.
5944.(a)For any PACE assessment for which a program administrator provides forbearance, payment holiday, or modification to a property owner, the payments due on the assessment contract during such forbearance or payment holiday or as a result of such modification shall be satisfied by the program administrator, and the program administrator shall be liable for any penalty, late charge, or loss arising from its failure to make such payments during the forbearance or payment holiday.
(b)Any forbearance that results in a delay or deferment of the repayment obligation that results in the timing of the repayment being extended shall not be deemed a violation of any useful life determination used in the assessment term, so long as the useful life determination and assessment term were valid at origination.
(c)The period during which the payment has been deferred or delayed shall not accrue interest.
5945.The forbearance, payment holiday, or modification of any PACE assessment shall not affect the validity or enforceability of such PACE assessment or any bonds issued in connection with such PACE assessment, and shall not constitute a violation of any provision of the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)).
6.Legal Rights5950.A program administrator shall not preclude or otherwise limit, whether by agreement to submit to mandatory arbitration or to waive the right to participate in a class or representative action, or by any other method, a property owners right to initiate legal action, with respect to the following:
(a)A claim related to any right established pursuant to this chapter and Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10).
(b)A claim for which the property owner has exhausted the remedies established by the program administrator under Section 5931.
5951.A program administrator shall not be liable for any claim as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 5950 if the program administrator does both of the following:
(a)Shows by a preponderance of evidence that an error or omission that gave rise to the claim was unintentional and resulted from a bona fide error notwithstanding the maintenance of procedures reasonably adapted to avoid any such error.
(b)Within 60 days of discovering the error notifies the property owner of the error, or within 60 days of being notified by the property owner of the error and before the institution of an action under thereunder, makes appropriate changes or adjustments to the applicable documents or account or takes other action necessary to rectify the error.
5952.A property owner shall not be entitled to initiate legal proceedings against a program administrator on the basis of an unrelated claim. The term unrelated claim shall mean:
(a)A claim relating to any manufacturer defect of any product obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment.
(b)A claim relating to any manufacturer representation regarding the performance of any product obtained with proceeds of a PACE assessment.
(c)A claim subject to manufacturers or other warranties.
(d)A claim against a property owner.
5953.A program administrator and property owner may agree to alternative dispute resolution procedures to resolve a claim not established by this chapter.
5.7.Reporting5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information for the preceding calendar year:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis.
(5)Rates of default including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.
(6)Estimated total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners by measures installed in the calendar year.
(7)Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced by measures installed in the calendar year.
(8)Estimated total amount of water saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with three four or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency. agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Authorized representative means an attorney-in-fact, as defined in Section 4014 of the Probate Code, or conservator of the estate, as defined in Section 2400 of the Probate Code, of the property owner.
(c)(d)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(d)(e)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.
(e)(f)Energy utility means an electrical corporation as defined in Section 218, a gas corporation as defined in Section 222, a local publicly owned electric utility as defined in Section 224.3, 224.3 of the Public Utilities Code, and a local publicly owned gas utility. Energy utility also means a community choice aggregator or other entity, other than an electrical corporation or gas corporation, approved by the Public Utilities Commission to administer programs providing energy-efficiency-related services or incentives for eligible solar energy systems to end users using moneys collected by an electrical corporation or gas corporation from ratepayers or moneys made available pursuant to Section 748.5 of the Public Utilities Code.
(f)(g)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(g)(h)PACE assessment has the same meaning as Property Assessed Clean Energy Bond or PACE Bond as defined in means a voluntary contractual assessment, voluntary special tax, or special tax, as described in subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) of Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(h)(i)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roose Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(i)(j)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(j)(k)Property owner means an owner all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(k)(l)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
(l)(m)Public water system has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 116275 of the Health and Safety Code.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless that assessment contract complies with paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code and Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17 of this code, and the following additional criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current current. The property owner shall also certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes on the property for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(b)(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)(d)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(d)Any property owner that will execute the assessment contract is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.(e)The property owner has not been a party to any bankruptcy proceedings within the last seven years, except that the property owner may have been party to a bankruptcy proceeding that was discharged or dismissed between two and seven years before the application date and the property owner has had no payments more than 30 days past due on any mortgage debt or nonmortgage debt (excluding medical debt) during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(e)(f)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is current on all mortgage debt that is secured by the property that will be subject to the assessment contract. on the subject property, and has been late on such payments no more than once during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date.
(f)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The PACE assessment will be for less than 15 percent of the current market value of the property, up to the first seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000) of the current market value of the property, and for less than 10 percent of the remaining current market value of the property above seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000). Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code.(h)The measures to be installed pursuant to the assessment contract are eligible under the terms of the applicable PACE program.
(i)The total amount of PACE assessments on the property, inclusive of any preexisting assessments, shall be no more than 15 percent of the market value of the property.
(i)(j)The total PACE assessment assessments and the mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the PACE assessment contract will not exceed 961/2 percent of the market value of the property. Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code.
(j)(k)The maximum term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the estimated useful life of the measure being installed. to which the greatest portion of funds disbursed under the assessment contract is attributable. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(k)(l)The property owner shall agree to place the lien on the title report, and shall agree to notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall entitle the program administrator to recover from the property owner the amount of any funds that the program administrator has advanced to or on behalf of that property owner. not invalidate an assessment contract or any obligations thereunder, notwithstanding where the combined amount of the PACE assessments exceeds the criteria set forth in subdivision (j) or (k).
5911.A program administrator shall obtain a sworn declaration of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract. A declarant that willfully states as true any material fact he or she knows to be false shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000). Any public prosecutor may bring a civil action to impose the civil penalty. The program administrator shall underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owners ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator shall not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.5911.(a)A program administrator may derive market value using one of the following:
(1)An automated valuation model, which is a computerized property valuation system that is used to derive a reasonable real property value.
(2)A brokers price opinion conducted by a real estate broker licensed pursuant to Part 1 (commencing with Section 10000) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(3)An appraisal conducted by a state-licensed real estate appraiser licensed pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 11300) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)The assessed value of the property. If the assessed value is used, the determination of market value shall be deemed valid on its face.
(b)The market value determination by the program administrator shall be disclosed to the property owner.
5912.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that, at the time the assessment contract is signed, the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessment based on the property owners income, assets and current debt obligations.
(a)The property owner shall state his or her income to the program administrator as a condition of application.
(b)The program administrator shall obtain one or more credit reports on the property owner from a consumer reporting agency in connection with underwriting the PACE assessment, and may use a credit report prepared by a credit reporting agency that is transmitted electronically.
(c)If the annual PACE assessment payments will exceed 1.5 percent of the market value of the property subject to the assessment, the program administrator shall verify the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.
(d)In evaluating the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner, the equity of the property that will secure the assessment shall not be considered.
5912.5913.(a)Before a PACE assessment is consummated, in addition to providing the written disclosure pursuant to Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code, a property owner consummates an assessment contract, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract with to at least one owner of the property owner or authorized representative of the property owner. That owner, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the oral confirmation is given. Such oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property.
(7)(8)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to their his or her other expenses.
(9)That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
(8)(10)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the tax impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(9)(11)That the obligations under the assessment contract may (A) remain on the property or (B) be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with both of the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the confirmation is given of the confirmation. laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
(c)The provisions of this section shall be in addition to the documents required to be provided to the property owner under Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17.
5913.5914.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the tax fiscal year following the tax fiscal year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
5915.Except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 5913, a PACE program administered by a program administrator shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.16 or paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code to the extent any requirement in those paragraphs are inconsistent with any provision of this article.
3.Eligible projects; Projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a PACE assessment is consummated, program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. A measure may comply with this paragraph if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure. measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment. measure.
(e)The provisions of this section shall not apply to measures that are seismic strengthening improvements authorized under Section 5899.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractor contractors or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable law.
5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, leads, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Notwithstanding the above, programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates to property owners are neither a direct cash payment or other thing of value, provided that the reduced fee or interest rate is reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the Internal Revenue Service, representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency, representations, statements, or opinions agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of PACE financing funds for which a property owner is eligible for, under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in the property, or any other indication of the maximum or potential amount of financing available to a property owner. a property.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Forbearance5940.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner for any monthly mortgage payment amount or portion thereof, the program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance or payment holiday for the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices.
5941.(a)For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, for each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish and make available to property owners a reasonable process for property owners to request payment forbearance or payment holiday for a PACE assessment.
(b)A program administrator shall establish reasonable criteria for timely receiving, evaluating, and providing forbearance or payment holiday for a property owners PACE assessment. A program administrator shall grant forbearance to a property owner if the program administrator receives credible evidence that the property owner does both of the following:
(1)Experiences a significant reduction of income as a result of involuntary unemployment, temporary disability, a natural disaster, or other unplanned and economically detrimental event.
(2)That such property owner is able to meet all property tax and real estate-secured debt obligations associated with the property, excluding the obligations under the PACE assessment.
5942.For each PACE assessment, a property owner is entitled to an aggregate of either:
(a)One annual forbearance payment (comprising a single fiscal year).
(b)Semiannual forbearance payments for the lifetime of the assessment.
5943.For any assessment contract entered on or after January 1, 2018, and notwithstanding any provision of this division or the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)), if a property owner receives a permanent modification of a mortgage encumbering a property on which the public agency has caused an assessment to be recorded, and such modification results in a reduction of the unpaid principal balance of such mortgage, upon presentation of the agreement of permanent modification, the program administrator shall promptly reduce the unpaid principal balance of the PACE assessment by no less than a percentage equal to the percentage by which the mortgage balance was reduced.
5944.(a)For any PACE assessment for which a program administrator provides forbearance, payment holiday, or modification to a property owner, the payments due on the assessment contract during such forbearance or payment holiday or as a result of such modification shall be satisfied by the program administrator, and the program administrator shall be liable for any penalty, late charge, or loss arising from its failure to make such payments during the forbearance or payment holiday.
(b)Any forbearance that results in a delay or deferment of the repayment obligation that results in the timing of the repayment being extended shall not be deemed a violation of any useful life determination used in the assessment term, so long as the useful life determination and assessment term were valid at origination.
(c)The period during which the payment has been deferred or delayed shall not accrue interest.
5945.The forbearance, payment holiday, or modification of any PACE assessment shall not affect the validity or enforceability of such PACE assessment or any bonds issued in connection with such PACE assessment, and shall not constitute a violation of any provision of the Improvement Bond Act of 1915 (Division 10 (commencing with Section 8500)).
4.5.Reporting5931.5954.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information: information for the preceding calendar year:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type type, on a number and dollar basis.
(5)Rates of default including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.
(6)Estimated amount of energy savings as expressed in monetary and energy use savings. total amount of energy saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners by measures installed in the calendar year.
(7)Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced. produced by measures installed in the calendar year.
(8)Estimated total amount of water savings as expressed in monetary and energy use savings. saved, and the estimated total dollar amount of such savings by property owners.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with three or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between one or more all property owners of record on real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(d)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.(e)Energy utility means an electrical corporation as defined in Section 218, a gas corporation as defined in Section 222, a local publicly owned electric utility as defined in Section 224.3, of the Public Utilities Code, and a local publicly owned gas utility. Energy utility also means a community choice aggregator or other entity, other than an electrical corporation or gas corporation, approved by the Public Utilities Commission to administer programs providing energy-efficiency-related services or incentives for eligible solar energy systems to end users using moneys collected by an electrical corporation or gas corporation from ratepayers or moneys made available pursuant to Section 748.5 of the Public Utilities Code.
(e)(f)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(f)(g)PACE assessment means the provision of funds by a public agency for the installation of one or more measures pursuant to an assessment contract that is secured by a lien on the real property. has the same meaning as Property Assessed Clean Energy Bond or PACE Bond as defined in Section 26054 of the Public Resources Code.
(g)(h)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roose Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(h)(i)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(j)Property owner means an owner of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment.
(i)(k)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
(l)Public water system has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 116275 of the Health and Safety Code.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless that assessment contract complies with paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code and Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17 of this code, and the following additional criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(d)Any property owner that will execute the assessment contract is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.
(e)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is current on all mortgage debt that is secured by the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(f)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The PACE assessment will be for less than 15 percent of the current market value of the property, up to the first seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000) of the current market value of the property, and for less than 10 percent of the remaining current market value of the property above seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000). Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner. accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code.
(i)The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the assessment contract will not exceed the market value of the property. Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner. accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code.
(j)The maximum term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the useful life of the measure being installed. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(k)The property owner agrees shall agree to place the lien on the title report, and shall agree to notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall entitle the program administrator to recover from the property owner the amount of any funds that the program administrator has advanced to or on behalf of that property owner.
5911.A program administrator shall obtain a sworn declaration of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract. A declarant that willfully states as true any material fact he or she knows to be false shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000). Any public prosecutor may bring a civil action to impose the civil penalty. The program administrator shall underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owners ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator shall not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.
5912.(a)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, PACE assessment is consummated, in addition to providing the written disclosure pursuant to Section 5898.17 of the Streets and Highways Code, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract with at least one property owner or authorized representative of the property owner. That oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to their other expenses.
(8)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(9)That the obligations under the assessment contract may (A) remain on the property or (B) be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with both of the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws. laws, and shall obtain acknowledgment from the person to whom the confirmation is given of the confirmation.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
5913.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the tax year following the calendar tax year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
3.Eligible projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, PACE assessment is consummated, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life. The program administrator shall determine useful life for purposes of this subdivision based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. A measure may comply with this paragraph if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure. measure, and the total amount financed including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work does not exceed 15 percent of the market value of the property subject to the PACE assessment.
5922.A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(b)The program administrator obtains the contractor or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable law.
5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, leads, reasonable entertainment expenses, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the Internal Revenue Service, or applicable state tax agency, representations, statements, or opinions with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property owner has been approved. amount of PACE financing a property owner is eligible for, or the amount of equity in the property, or any other indication of the maximum or potential amount of financing available to a property owner.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Forbearance5930.Upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner, a program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance of the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices, not to exceed 12 months.5.4.Reporting5931.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The installed measures.(3)The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(4)The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements and the percentage of assessments represented by each category type on a number and dollar basis.
(4)(5)Rates of default and delinquency. including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency.
(5)Data pertaining to homeowner eligibility.(6)Estimated amount of energy savings. savings as expressed in monetary and energy use savings.
(7)Estimated amount of renewable energy produced.
(8)Estimated amount of water savings. savings as expressed in monetary and energy use savings.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with three or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between one or more owners of real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(d)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.
(e)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(f)PACE assessment means the provision of funds by a public agency for the installation of one or more measures pursuant to an assessment contract that is secured by a lien on the real property.
(g)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roose Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(h)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(i)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless that assessment contract complies with paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code and Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17 of this code, and the following additional criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(d)Any property owner that will execute the assessment contract is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.
(e)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is current on all mortgage debt that is secured by the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(f)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The PACE assessment will be for less than 15 percent of the current market value of the property, up to the first seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000) of the current market value of the property, and for less than 10 percent of the remaining current market value of the property above seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000). Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
(i)The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the assessment contract will not exceed the market value of the property. Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
(j)The maximum term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the useful life of the measure being installed.
(k)The property owner agrees to notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall entitle the program administrator to recover from the property owner the amount of any funds that the program administrator has advanced to or on behalf of that property owner.
5911.A program administrator shall obtain a sworn statement, signed under penalty of perjury, of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract, and declaration of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract. A declarant that willfully states as true any material fact he or she knows to be false shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000). Any public prosecutor may bring a civil action to impose the civil penalty. The program administrator shall underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owners ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator shall not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.
5912.(a)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract with at least one property owner or authorized representative of the property owner. That oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to their other expenses.
(8)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(9)That the obligations under the assessment contract may (A) remain on the property or (B) be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with both of the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
5913.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the tax year following the calendar year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
3.Eligible projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
5922.(a)A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)(a)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(2)(b)The program administrator obtains the contractor or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable law.
(b)A program administrator shall not be liable for the failure of a contractor or other third party to maintain applicable licenses, permits, or registrations or to act in accordance with applicable law.5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, leads, reasonable entertainment expenses, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the Internal Revenue Service, or applicable state tax agency, representations, statements, or opinions with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property owner has been approved.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Forbearance5930.Upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner, a program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance of the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices, not to exceed 12 months.
5.Reporting5931.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The installed measures.
(4)Rates of default and delinquency.
(5)Data pertaining to homeowner eligibility.
(6)Estimated amount of energy savings.
(7)Estimated amount of renewable energy produced.
(8)Estimated amount of water savings.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.SEC. 3.In order to ensure that Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs continue to effectively meet their public purposes, it is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to enhance the requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by third parties must conform.The provisions of this article shall apply exclusively to residential real property with three or fewer units.
5901.The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any public agency.
5902.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Ancillary work means the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure.
(b)Assessment contract means an agreement entered into between one or more owners of real property and a public agency in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, the public agency provides a PACE assessment for the installation of one or more measures on the real property in accordance with a PACE program.
(c)Custom measure means a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program.
(d)Eligible measure list means, for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator.
(e)Measure means one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program.
(f)PACE assessment means the provision of funds by a public agency for the installation of one or more measures pursuant to an assessment contract that is secured by a lien on the real property.
(g)PACE program means a program in which financing is provided for the installation of measures on real property and funded through the use of property assessments, as well as other program components defined in this section, established pursuant to any of the following:
(1)Chapter 29 (commencing with Section 5898.10) of Part 3 of this code.
(2)The Mello-Roose Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(3)A charter citys constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
(h)Program administrator means an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency.
(i)Public agency means a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority, sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district, as defined in Section 20200 of the Water Code, that has established or participates in a PACE program, and utilizes a program administrator.
2.Assessment Contract Requirements5910.A program administrator shall not submit, present, or otherwise approve for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless that assessment contract complies with paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code and Sections 5898.16 and 5898.17 of this code, and the following additional criteria are met:
(a)All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter.
(b)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(c)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract has no notices of default outstanding.
(d)Any property owner that will execute the assessment contract is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.
(e)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is current on all mortgage debt that is secured by the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(f)The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property that will be subject to the assessment contract.
(g)The property that will be subject to the assessment contract is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
(h)The PACE assessment will be for less than 15 percent of the current market value of the property, up to the first seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000) of the current market value of the property, and for less than 10 percent of the remaining current market value of the property above seven hundred thousand dollars ($700,000). Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
(i)The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property subject to the assessment contract will not exceed the market value of the property. Market value for purposes of this subdivision shall be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
(j)The maximum term of the assessment contract shall not exceed the useful life of the measure being installed.
(k)The property owner agrees to notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property. The failure of a property owner to comply with this subdivision shall entitle the program administrator to recover from the property owner the amount of any funds that the program administrator has advanced to or on behalf of that property owner.
5911.A program administrator shall obtain a sworn statement, signed under penalty of perjury, of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract, and shall underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owners ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator shall not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.
5912.(a)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator shall make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract with at least one property owner or authorized representative of the property owner. That oral confirmation shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(1)The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment.
(2)The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees.
(3)The estimated date that the first payment will be due.
(4)The term of the assessment contract.
(5)That payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessors office or through the property owners mortgage impound account.
(6)That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract.
(7)That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to their other expenses.
(8)That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions regarding the impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract.
(9)That the obligations under the assessment contract may (A) remain on the property or (B) be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
(b)The program administrator shall comply with both of the following when giving the oral confirmation described in subdivision (a):
(1)The program administrator shall record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
(2)The program administrator may not comply with the requirement in subdivision (a) through the use of a prerecorded message, or other similar device or method.
5913.A program administrator may not waive or defer the first payment on an assessment contract. A property owners first assessment payment shall be due no later than the tax year following the calendar year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
3.Eligible projects; Contractor Oversight; Transfer of Bonds5920.(a)A program administrator shall not offer a PACE assessment for a measure that is not both of the following:
(1)Permanently affixed to real property.
(2)Consistent with criteria of the PACE program through which the assessment contract is made available.
(b)Before a program administrator authorizes a contractor to commence work to install a measure, the program administrator or contractor shall confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5921.
5921.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, and shall establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. The eligible measure list shall at minimum include the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
(1)A name or description.
(2)Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
(3)Expected useful life.
(b)A measure shall not be included on an eligible measure list unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
(1)It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program.
(2)It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure.
(c)A program administrator may offer PACE assessments for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
(1)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure.
(2)Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines, that have been approved by the sponsoring public agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Those guidelines shall identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met in order for a custom measure to be approved, and shall be consistent with subdivision (b).
(d)A PACE assessment shall not be used for ancillary work unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure.
(2)The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
5922.(a)A program administrator shall not permit contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to solicit property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required for engaging in its business in the jurisdiction where it operates, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage pursuant thereto.
(2)The program administrator obtains the contractor or third partys written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable law.
(b)A program administrator shall not be liable for the failure of a contractor or other third party to maintain applicable licenses, permits, or registrations or to act in accordance with applicable law.
5923.(a)Except as provided for in subdivision (b), a program administrator shall not provide any direct or indirect cash payment or other thing of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
(b)A program administrator is permitted to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, leads, reasonable entertainment expenses, training, and training events.
(c)A program administrator shall not provide any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract.
5924.A program administrator shall not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the Internal Revenue Service, or applicable state tax agency, representations, statements, or opinions with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
5925.A program administrator shall not provide to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property owner has been approved.
5926.This chapter does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
(a)Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
(b)Securitizing its interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts.
(c)Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued pursuant to one or more assessment contracts, or securities backed by assessment contracts.
4.Forbearance5930.Upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner, a program administrator shall provide to the property owner a payment forbearance of the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the program administrators customary servicing practices, not to exceed 12 months.
5.Reporting5931.(a)For each PACE program that it administers, a program administrator shall submit a report at least annually to the public agency that shall contain the following information:
(1)The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
(2)The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received.
(3)The installed measures.
(4)Rates of default and delinquency.
(5)Data pertaining to homeowner eligibility.
(6)Estimated amount of energy savings.
(7)Estimated amount of renewable energy produced.
(8)Estimated amount of water savings.
(9)Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions.
(10)Estimated number of jobs created.
(b)The program administrator shall make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
(c)All reports submitted pursuant to this section shall include only aggregate data, and shall not include any nonpublic personal information.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(a)Existing law authorizes the legislative body of a public agency to determine that it would be convenient, advantageous, and in the public interest to designate an area within the public agency within which authorized public agency officials and property owners may enter into voluntary contractual assessments to finance specified improvements, including the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, energy or water efficiency improvements, seismic strengthening improvements, and electric vehicle charging infrastructure that are permanently fixed to real property, as specified.(b)These programs operate as Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs, which have been identified by the Legislature since 2008 as important to helping the state achieve its energy and climate change goals by increasing the deployment of renewable energy, decreasing greenhouse gas emissions by increasing the energy efficiency of homes, helping reduce dependence on groundwater and other water resources during the drought, and increasing the availability of non-carbon-emitting vehicles on the road.(c)Since 2008, PACE programs have operated at the direction of hundreds of municipalities or government agencies, have facilitated efficiency and energy generation improvements to over 50,000 residential properties in California, with financing totaling more than one billion dollars ($1,000,000,000), and have facilitated efficiency and energy generation improvements to hundreds of commercial properties as well. These improvements support thousands of jobs in California.(d)Improvements facilitated through PACE programs have reduced greenhouse gas emissions in California by billions of tons, reduced energy usage by billions of kilowatts, and conserved billions of gallons of water.(e)PACE programs are important to helping the state achieve its targeted goals for energy efficiency, renewable energy generation, and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, as described in the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Chapter 488 of the Statutes of 2006) and the Clean Energy and Pollution Reduction Act of 2015 (Chapter 547 of the Statutes of 2015).SEC. 2.SEC. 3.In order to ensure that Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs continue to effectively meet their public purposes, it is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to enhance the requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by third parties must conform.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Existing law authorizes the legislative body of a public agency to determine that it would be convenient, advantageous, and in the public interest to designate an area within the public agency within which authorized public agency officials and property owners may enter into voluntary contractual assessments to finance specified improvements, including the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, energy or water efficiency improvements, seismic strengthening improvements, and electric vehicle charging infrastructure that are permanently fixed to real property, as specified.
(b)These programs operate as Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs, which have been identified by the Legislature since 2008 as important to helping the state achieve its energy and climate change goals by increasing the deployment of renewable energy, decreasing greenhouse gas emissions by increasing the energy efficiency of homes, helping reduce dependence on groundwater and other water resources during the drought, and increasing the availability of non-carbon-emitting vehicles on the road.
(c)Since 2008, PACE programs have operated at the direction of hundreds of municipalities or government agencies, have facilitated efficiency and energy generation improvements to over 50,000 residential properties in California, with financing totaling more than one billion dollars ($1,000,000,000), and have facilitated efficiency and energy generation improvements to hundreds of commercial properties as well. These improvements support thousands of jobs in California.
(d)Improvements facilitated through PACE programs have reduced greenhouse gas emissions in California by billions of tons, reduced energy usage by billions of kilowatts, and conserved billions of gallons of water.
(e)PACE programs are important to helping the state achieve its targeted goals for energy efficiency, renewable energy generation, and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, as described in the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Chapter 488 of the Statutes of 2006) and the Clean Energy and Pollution Reduction Act of 2015 (Chapter 547 of the Statutes of 2015).
SEC. 2.In order to ensure that Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs continue to effectively meet their public purposes, it is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to enhance the requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by third parties must conform.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 4, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 484, Statutes of 2017. |
| Oct 4, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 15, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 35. Noes 4.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 8, 2017 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 7, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 28, 2017 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jul 20, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 19, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 18). |
| Jul 13, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Jul 12, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & F. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (July 12). Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Jul 3, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 22, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 22, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and B. & F. |
| May 31, 2017 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 34. Noes 1. Page 1258.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2017 | Read third time and amended. |
| May 8, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 4, 2017 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| May 4, 2017 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| Apr 27, 2017 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Apr 26, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Apr 25, 2017 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 6. Noes 1. Page 744.) (April 19). |
| Apr 17, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Mar 29, 2017 | Re-referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and RLS. |
| Mar 20, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 7, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2017 | Unfinished Business SB242 Skinner et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 7, 2017 | SB 242 Skinner Senate Third Reading By TING | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 18, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Banking and Finance] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SB242 Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 242
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/19/17
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara
NOES: Moorlach
SENATE FLOOR: 34-3, 5/30/17
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Berryhill, Bradford, Cannella, De León, Dodd, Gaines, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Lara, Leyva, McGuire, Mendoza, Mitchell, Monning, Nguyen, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Anderson, Moorlach, Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Fuller, Newman
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 9/7/17 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill establishes requirements for third-party program administrators of Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs.
Assembly Amendments
narrow the bill to only include oral confirmation requirements, home improvement work and right to cancel standards, and reporting requirements for program administrators.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs that rely on voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes for repayment of the loans.
This bill:
- Requires the provisions of this bill to apply exclusively to residential property with four or fewer units and prohibits the provisions of this bill from applying to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
- Provides that it is unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract and that the home improvement contract is unenforceable, if both of the following occur:
- The property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program; and,
- The property owner applies for, accepts, and cancels PACE financing within the three day right to cancel period established in existing law.
- Provides that if work has commenced in violation of above requirements then the contractor is entitled to no compensation for that work and requires the contractor to restore the property to its original condition at no cost to the property owner. Requires the contractor to return all money, property, and consideration given by the property owner.
- Requires the property owner to make the property available to the contractor for return within 90 days of execution of the contract, if the contractor has delivered any property to the property owner pursuant to a contract that is unenforceable.
- Authorizes the property owner to waive the above requirements if all of the following are met:
- The contract is executed in connection with the making of emergency repair or immediately necessary repairs to protect persons or real or personal property;
- The property owner initiated the contract for the emergency repair or immediately necessary repair; and,
- The property owner provides a separate statement, as specified, describing the situation that requires immediate remedy, and expressly acknowledges that the contractor has informed them of the right to cancel and that they waive the right to cancel the sale.
- Requires a program administrator, before a property owner executes an assessment contract, to make an oral confirmation that at least one property owner has a copy of the contractual assessment documents, the financing estimate and disclosure form, and the right to cancel form. Requires the oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract, in plain language, to include, but not be limited to, the following information:
- The property owner is informed that they should review the assessment contract and financing estimate and disclosure form with all other owners of the property;
- The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment;
- The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees;
- The total estimated average monthly amount of funds the property owner would have to save in order to pay the annual costs under the PACE assessment, including applicable fees;
- That the county annual secured property tax bill, which will include the installment of the PACE lien, will be mailed by the county tax collector no later than November 1 each year, and that if the lien is recorded after the fiscal year closes but before the bill is mailed, the first installment may not appear on the county tax bill until the following year;
- The term of the assessment contract;
- That payments on the assessment contract will be made through an additional annual assessment on the property and paid either directly to the county tax collector's office as part of the total annual secured property tax bill, or through the property owner's mortgage impound account, and if paid through an impound account, the property owner should notify their mortgage lender to discuss adjusting the monthly mortgage payment by the estimated monthly cost of the PACE assessment;
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract that the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property;
- That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property, if known to and understood by the property owner;
- That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payment or total assessment amount;
- That the program administrator and contractor do not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice with questions regarding tax credits, tax deductibility, or other tax impacts on the PACE assessment;
- That if that property tax payment is delinquent within the fiscal year, the county tax collector will assess a 10% penalty and related costs as required by existing law, that a delinquent payment subjects a property to foreclosure, and that if the delinquent payment continues past June 30 and defaults, the tax collector will assess penalties specified under existing law and the property will continue to be subject to foreclosure and may become subject to the tax collector's right to sell the property at auction; and,
- That the property owner has a three business day right to cancel the assessment contract.
- Requires the program administrator to record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws. Prohibits the program administrator from complying with the oral confirmation requirement through the use of a prerecorded message or other similar device or method. Requires the program administrator to retain the recording of an oral confirmation call for at least five years from the time of recording.
- Requires the program administrator, at the commencement of the oral confirmation call, to do the following:
- Ask if the property owner would like to communicate in a language other than English (Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean). Requires the oral confirmation to be given in that language, if the preferred language is supported by the program administrator. Prohibits the PACE assessment transaction from proceeding if the preferred language is not supported and an interpreter is not chosen by the property owner on the call. Defines the term "interpreter" to mean a person who is not a minor and is not employed by or whose services are not made available through the program administrator, public agency or the contractor; and,
- Inform the property owner of the right to have other persons present for the call and to make an inquiry as to whether the property owner would like to exercise that right.
- Requires the program administrator, beginning on January 1, 2019, to deliver in writing the assessment contract if the oral confirmation was conducted primarily in a language other than English, the financing estimate and disclosure form, and the right to cancel form. Requires the program administrator to deliver a translation of the disclosures, contract or agreement, prior to the execution of any contract, in the language in which the oral confirmation was conducted.
- Requires a program administrator, for each program that it administers, to submit a report to the public agency no later than February 1 and August 1 of each year that contains the methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources used to prepare the report, and the following information:
- The number, aggregate dollar amount, and average dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP code;
- The categories of installed improvements whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, by number and dollar, by city, county, and ZIP code;
- The definition of default used by the program administrator;
- The total delinquent amount, the number and dates of missed payments, and the ZIP code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located for each delinquent assessment;
- The total defaulted amount, the number and dates of missed payments, and the ZIP code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located for each defaulted assessment, the percentage the defaults represent of the total assessments within each ZIP code, the total number of parcels defaulted and the number of years in default for each property;
- The estimated total amount of energy saved, renewable energy produced, water saved, and greenhouse gas emissions reduced;
- The estimated number of jobs created; and,
- The average and median amount of annual and total PACE assessments based on ZIP code, and the number and percentage of homeowners over 60-years-old by city, county, and ZIP code.
- Requires all reports to include only aggregate data, and prohibits the reports from including any nonpublic personal information.
- Requires a public agency to make the data publicly available on its Internet Web site.
- Provides that the reporting section in this bill does not limit another governmental or regulatory entity from establishing reporting requirements.
- Prohibits a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract. Requires a property owner's first assessment payment to be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the measure installation is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from permitting contractors or other third parties from advertising the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
- The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors' State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage; and,
- The program administrator obtains a written agreement with a contractor or third party that they will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct or indirect cash payments or other things of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the proposed owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
- Prohibits a program administrator from reimbursing a contractor or third party for expenses for advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral. Authorizes a program administrator to reimburse a contractor for bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing provided that:
- The training expenses are actually incurred by the contractor;
- The reimbursement does not exceed $100 per each salesperson or agent of the contractor who participated in the training; and,
- The reimbursement is paid directly to the contractor, and is not paid to its salespersons or agents.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Provides that programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates are neither a direct cash payment nor "other things of value" provided they are reflected in the assessment contract and under no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
- Prohibits a program administrator, contractor, or third party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
- Prohibits a contractor from providing a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
Background
PACE financing programs allow local governments to offer loans to private property owners to cover the initial costs of renewable energy, energy efficiency, water efficiency, and other improvements to private property that offer public benefits. Property owners repay the loans through voluntary assessments or parcel taxes, which are secured by priority liens and appear annually on property tax bills until the loans are repaid.
State law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs: voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, "With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including that PACE contractors are properly licensed. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California's PACE program continues to be a national leader."
Remaining issues. It is clear that there is an immediate need to provide additional parameters around the PACE program to ensure consumer protections. At the inception of the PACE program, the presence of third party administrators and the accompanying complex financing structures were not contemplated by the Legislature. Nearly all local governments utilize the JPA and program administrator model for PACE programs, and as PACE continues to evolve, the realities are very different than those imagined at the outset of legislative authorization. For example, one of the key features of the PACE program is that not only does the efficiency improvement remain with the property, but so does the obligation to repay the contractual assessment. Homeowners, mortgage and realtor industry stakeholders, PACE administrators, local governments including tax collectors, and now consumer groups have seen the consequences when homeowners are forced to repay the entire PACE assessment in order to sell or refinance their homes or cannot afford to make the payments on their property tax bills.
The Legislature continues to grapple with laws which govern local government assessments, including lien priority, unpaid payments, foreclosure, forbearance, underwriting, data collection, oversight, noticing requirements, and lending practices in determining which requirements PACE should be subject to in light of the current realities of the program. To ensure that this bill provides meaningful protections for consumers and to allow for important discussions to continue among stakeholders, this bill was significantly narrowed in the policy committee process.
Following a stakeholder process convened during summer recess, the current version of this bill includes provisions regarding oral confirmation, home improvement work, and reporting all which were met with stakeholder consensus. Additional provisions that did not achieve consensus through the stakeholder process include eligible improvements and contract requirements which are significant changes to public policy require further discussion in policy committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Advanced Energy Economy
Association of Energy Engineers
Build it Green
Calasian Chamber of Commerce
California Energy Efficiency Industry Council
California Solar Energy Industries Association
California State Association of Counties
Center for Sustainable Energy
City of Indian Wells
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Thousand Oaks
Cleantech San Diego
Climate Action Campaign
Efficiency First California
League of California Cities
Natural Resources Defense Council
Renew Financial
Renovate America
Vote Solar
WattzOn
Ygrene Energy Fund
California Association of Treasurers and Tax Collectors
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 9/7/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Choi, Steinorth
9/8/17 10:36:29
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 242
Author:(Skinner)
As Amended Ver:August 28, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 34-3
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Local Government | 8-1 | Aguiar-Curry, Waldron, Bloom, Caballero, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Lackey, Voepel | Ridley-Thomas |
Banking | 9-0 | Dababneh, Chen, Burke, Cervantes, Grayson, Limón, Ridley-Thomas, Mark Stone, Weber | > |
SUMMARY: Establishes requirements for third-party program administrators of Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the provisions of this bill to apply exclusively to residential property with four or fewer units and prohibits the provisions of this bill from applying to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
- Defines numerous terms used throughout the bill, including the following terms:
- "Assessment contract" to mean "an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency, in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, in accordance with a PACE program;"
- "Efficiency improvement" to mean "one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property;"
- "Program administrator" to mean "an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency;"
- "Property owner" to mean "all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment;"
- "Public agency" to mean "a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority (JPA), sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district;" and,
- "Authorized representative" to mean "an attorney-in-fact or conservator of the estate of the property owner."
- Provides that it is unlawful to commence work under a home improvement contract and that the home improvement contract is unenforceable, if both of the following occur:
- The property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program; and,
- The property owner applies for, accepts, and cancels PACE financing within the three day right to cancel period established in existing law.
- Provides that if work has commenced in violation of 3), above, then the contractor is entitled to no compensation for that work and requires the contractor to restore the property to its original condition at no cost to the property owner. Requires the contractor to return all money, property, and consideration given by the property owner, as specified.
- Requires the property owner to make the property available to the contractor for return within 90 days of execution of the contract, if the contractor has delivered any property to the property owner pursuant to a contract that is unenforceable pursuant to 3), above.
- Authorizes the property owner to waive the requirements in 3), above, if all of the following are met:
- The contract is executed in connection with the making of emergency repair or immediately necessary repairs to protect persons or real or personal property;
- The property owner initiated the contract for the emergency repair or immediately necessary repair; and,
- The property owner provides a separate statement, as specified, describing the situation that requires immediate remedy, and expressly acknowledges that the contractor has informed them of the right to cancel and that they waive the right to cancel the sale.
- Requires a program administrator, before a property owner executes an assessment contract, to make an oral confirmation that at least one property owner has a copy of the contractual assessment documents, the financing estimate and disclosure form, and the right to cancel form, pursuant to existing law. Requires the oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract, in plain language, to include, but not be limited to, the following information:
- The property owner is informed that they should review the assessment contract and financing estimate and disclosure form with all other owners of the property;
- The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment;
- The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees;
- The total estimated average monthly amount of funds the property owner would have to save in order to pay the annual costs under the PACE assessment, including applicable fees;
- That the county annual secured property tax bill, which will include the installment of the PACE lien, will be mailed by the county tax collector no later than November 1 each year, and that if the lien is recorded after the fiscal year closes but before the bill is mailed, the first installment may not appear on the county tax bill until the following year;
- The term of the assessment contract;
- That payments on the assessment contract will be made through an additional annual assessment on the property and paid either directly to the county tax collector's office as part of the total annual secured property tax bill, or through the property owner's mortgage impound account, and if paid through an impound account, the property owner should notify their mortgage lender to discuss adjusting the monthly mortgage payment by the estimated monthly cost of the PACE assessment;
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract that the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property;
- That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and has disclosed all other PACE assessments or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property, if known to and understood by the property owner;
- That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payment or total assessment amount;
- That the program administrator and contractor do not provide tax advice, and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice with questions regarding tax credits, tax deductibility, or other tax impacts on the PACE assessment;
- That if that property tax payment is delinquent within the fiscal year, the county tax collector will assess a 10% penalty and related costs as required by existing law, that a delinquent payment subjects a property to foreclosure, and that if the delinquent payment continues past June 30 and defaults, the tax collector will assess penalties specified under existing law and the property will continue to be subject to foreclosure and may become subject to the tax collector's right to sell the property at auction; and,
- That the property owner has a three business day right to cancel the assessment contract pursuant to existing law which may also cancel the home improvement contract subject to 3), above.
- Requires the program administrator to record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws. Prohibits the program administrator from complying with the oral confirmation requirement through the use of a prerecorded message or other similar device or method. Requires the program administrator to retain the recording of an oral confirmation call for at least five years from the time of recording.
- Requires the program administrator, at the commencement of the oral confirmation call, to do the following:
- Ask if the property owner would like to communicate in a language other than English (Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean). Requires the oral confirmation to be given in that language, if the preferred language is supported by the program administrator. Prohibits the PACE assessment transaction from proceeding if the preferred language is not supported and an interpreter is not chosen by the property owner on the call. Defines the term "interpreter" to mean a person who is not a minor and is not employed by or whose services are not made available through the program administrator, public agency or the contractor; and,
- Inform the property owner of the right to have other persons present for the call and to make an inquiry as to whether the property owner would like to exercise that right.
- Requires the program administrator, beginning on January 1, 2019, if the oral confirmation was conducted primarily in a language other than English to deliver in writing the assessment contract, the financing estimate and disclosure form, and the right to cancel form. Requires the program administrator to deliver a translation of the disclosures, contract or agreement, prior to the execution of any contract, in the language in which the oral confirmation was conducted.
- Requires a program administrator, for each program that it administers, to submit a report to the public agency no later than February 1 and August 1 of each year that contains the methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources used to prepare the report, and the following information:
- The number, aggregate dollar amount, and average dollar amount of PACE assessments funded, by city, county, and ZIP code;
- The categories of installed improvements whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and the percentage of PACE assessments represented by each category type, by number and dollar, by city, county, and ZIP code;
- The definition of default used by the program administrator;
- The total delinquent amount, the number and dates of missed payments, and the ZIP code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located for each delinquent assessment;
- The total defaulted amount, the number and dates of missed payments, and the ZIP code, city, and county in which the underlying property is located for each defaulted assessment, the percentage the defaults represent of the total assessments within each ZIP code, the total number of parcels defaulted and the number of years in default for each property;
- The estimated total amount of energy saved, renewable energy produced, water saved, and greenhouse gas emissions reduced;
- The estimated number of jobs created; and,
- The average and median amount of annual and total PACE assessments based on ZIP code, and the number and percentage of homeowners over 60-years-old by city, county, and ZIP code.
- Requires all reports to include only aggregate data, and prohibits the reports from including any nonpublic personal information.
- Requires a public agency to make the data publicly available on its Internet Web site.
- Provides that the reporting section in this bill does not limit another governmental or regulatory entity from establishing reporting requirements.
- Prohibits a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract. Requires a property owner's first assessment payment to be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the measure installation is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from permitting contractors or other third parties from advertising the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
- The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors' State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage; and,
- The program administrator obtains a written agreement with a contractor or third party that they will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct or indirect cash payments or other things of material value to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the proposed owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract.
- Prohibits a program administrator from reimbursing a contractor or third party for expenses for advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral. Authorizes a program administrator to reimburse a contractor for bona fide and reasonable training expenses related to PACE financing provided that:
- The training expenses are actually incurred by the contractor;
- The reimbursement does not exceed $100 per each salesperson or agent of the contractor who participated in the training; and,
- The reimbursement is paid directly to the contractor, and is not paid to its salespersons or agents.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Provides that programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates are neither a direct cash payment nor "other things of value" provided they are reflected in the assessment contract and under no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
- Prohibits a program administrator, contractor, or third party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
- Prohibits a contractor from providing a different price for a project financed by a PACE assessment than the contractor would provide if paid in cash by the property owner.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- History and Statutory Authorization. Utilizing the authority to create a financing district as a charter city, the City of Berkeley, in 2007, established a citywide voluntary program to allow residential and commercial property owners to install solar energy systems and make energy efficiency improvements to their buildings and to repay the cost over 20 years via an assessment on the property tax bill. In 2008, the Legislature granted the statutory authority to cities and counties to provide up-front financing to property owners to install renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to their properties, which is repaid through the property tax bill.
Most PACE programs are implemented and administered under two statutory frameworks:
AB 811 (Levine), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2008, which amended the Improvement Act of 1911, to allow for voluntary contractual assessments to finance PACE projects, and SB 555 (Hancock), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2011, which amended the Mello-Roos Community Facilities District Act to allow for Mello-Roos special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance PACE projects.
The Legislature has expanded PACE for residential and commercial property owners as an option to pay for renewable energy upgrades, energy and water efficiency retrofits, seismic improvements, and other specified improvements for their homes or buildings. The intent of the program is that the assessment or parcel tax remains with the property even if it is sold or transferred, and the improvements must be permanently fixed to the property.
In California, there are several models available to local governments in administering a PACE program. Only the counties of Sonoma and Placer administer their own PACE programs. The majority of local governments contract with a private third-party or join a JPA, which contracts with a private third-party to carry out their PACE programs.
- Bill Summary. This bill establishes requirements specifically for PACE programs that are administered by a third-party program administrator for residential real properties with four or fewer units. This bill does not apply to any local government (Placer and Sonoma) that does not use a program administrator for their PACE program. This bill is author-sponsored.
- Home Improvement Work and Right to Cancel. This bill states that it is unlawful for work to commence under a home improvement contract and that a home improvement contract is unenforceable if a property owner entered into the home improvement contract based on the reasonable belief that the work would be covered by the PACE program and that the property owner cancels PACE financing within the three day right to cancel period established under existing law. This bill outlines remedies if work has commenced pursuant to an unenforceable home improvement contract, and authorizes a property owner to waive the three day right to cancel under specified circumstances.
- Oral Confirmation. Under this bill, a program administrator must make an oral confirmation of key terms of the contract to at least one owner of the property prior to a property owner executing an assessment contract. This bill specifies information that must be included in the oral confirmation.
- Program Administrators. This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including: i) permitting contractors to advertise PACE assessments or solicit property owners, unless specified requirements are met; ii) providing direct or indirect cash payment or other things of value to a contractor or property owner; iii) making representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract; and, iv) providing information to a contractor that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible or the amount of equity in a property.
- Reporting Requirements. This bill requires a program administrator, for each PACE program, to submit a report biannually to the public agency. This bill outlines the information that must be in the report which includes the number of properties, dollar amounts of PACE assessments, categories of measures, delinquencies and defaults, energy savings, and jobs created.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including that PACE contractors are properly licensed. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California's PACE program continues to be a national leader."
- Current Issues and Related Legislation. Following a series of news articles in the Wall Street Journal, the filing of two class action lawsuits, and the introduction of legislation at the Federal level, the topic of residential PACE and expression of concerns over the lack of oversight and protections for consumers continue.
Last session, AB 2693 (Dababneh), Chapter 618, Statutes of 2016, established a number of consumer notice requirements and sought to tighten financing standards for PACE assessments for residential properties. AB 2693 prohibits a local agency from allowing a homeowner to participate in PACE, unless the homeowner is provided both the right to cancel and a financing estimate and disclosure document. The financing estimate and disclosure must include specified information, including product costs, financing costs, additional information to use to compare to other financing options, and a number of statements that require the homeowner to initial. AB 2693 applies to all PACE programs, regardless of whether local agencies use a PACE administrator, for residential properties with four or fewer units.
AB 271 (Caballero) of the current legislative session, pending in the Senate, authorizes a county tax collector to direct the county auditor to remove a delinquent installment based on a PACE assessment that arises from a contract entered into on or after January 1, 2018, from the county's tax rolls.
AB 1284 (Dababneh) of the current legislative session, pending in the Senate, requires a program administrator to be licensed by the Commissioner of Business Oversight under the California Finance Lenders Law, and establishes requirements for "PACE solicitors."
- Policy Consideration. It is clear that there is an immediate need to provide additional parameters around the PACE program to ensure consumer protections. At the inception of the PACE program, the presence of third party administrators and the accompanying complex financing structures were not contemplated by the Legislature. Nearly all local governments utilize the JPA and program administrator model for PACE programs, and as PACE continues to evolve, the realities are very different than those imagined at the outset of legislative authorization. For example, one of the key features of the PACE program is that not only does the efficiency improvement remain with the property, but so does the obligation to repay the contractual assessment. Homeowners, mortgage and realtor industry stakeholders, PACE administrators, local governments including tax collectors, and now consumer groups have seen the consequences when homeowners are forced to repay the entire PACE assessment in order to sell or refinance their homes or cannot afford to make the payments on their property tax bills.
The Legislature continues to grapple with laws which govern local government assessments, including lien priority, unpaid payments, foreclosure, underwriting, data collection, oversight, noticing requirements, and lending practices in determining which requirements PACE should be subject to in light of the current realities of the program. To ensure that this bill provides meaningful protections for consumers and to allow for important discussions to continue among stakeholders, this bill was significantly narrowed in the policy committee process.
Following a stakeholder process convened during summer recess, the current version of the bill includes provisions regarding oral confirmation, home improvement work, and reporting all which were met with stakeholder consensus. Additional provisions that did not achieve consensus through the stakeholder process include eligible improvements and contract requirements which are significant changes to public policy which would require further discussion in policy committee.
- Arguments in Support. A coalition letter signed by proponents, including Renovate America, Renew Financial, Ygrene Energy Fund, and California Solar Energy Industries Association, states, "As it has matured, the PACE industry has repeatedly shown a willingness to strengthen its consumer protections. Most recently, the industry's work with state lawmakers last year on AB 2693 (Dababneh) resulted in the passage of the most comprehensive PACE consumer protection and disclosure law in the nation. SB 242 seeks to build on those improvements by enacting a comprehensive set of program requirements that will further protect homeowners and ensure the integrity of PACE programs."
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Association of County Treasurers and Tax Collectors, in their "oppose unless amended" position, argues that any bill that is intended to enhance consumer protections should include the ability to repay.
Analysis Prepared by: Misa Lennox / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0001490
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 242
Author:(Skinner)
As Amended Ver:July 13, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 34-3
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Local Government | 8-1 | Aguiar-Curry, Waldron, Bloom, Caballero, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Lackey, Voepel | Ridley-Thomas |
Banking | 9-0 | Dababneh, Chen, Burke, Cervantes, Grayson, Limón, Ridley-Thomas, Mark Stone, Weber |
SUMMARY: Establishes requirements for third-party program administrators of Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the provisions of this bill to apply exclusively to residential property with four or fewer units and prohibits the provisions of this bill from applying to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
- Defines numerous terms used throughout the bill, including the following terms:
- "Assessment contract" to mean "an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency, in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, in accordance with a PACE program;"
- "Efficiency improvement" to mean "one or more permanent improvements fixed to real property;"
- "Program administrator" to mean "an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency;"
- "Property owner" to mean "all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment;" and,
- "Public agency" to mean "a city, including a charter city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority (JPA), sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district."
- Prohibits a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract. Requires a property owner's first assessment payment to be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the measure installation is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from permitting contractors or other third parties from advertising the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
- The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors' State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage; and,
- The program administrator obtains a written agreement with a contractor or third party that they will act in accordance will applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct or indirect cash payments or other things of material value to either of the following:
- A contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the proposed owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract. Authorizes a program administrator to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events; or,
- A property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Provides that programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates are neither a direct cash payment nor "other things of value" provided they are reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
- Prohibits a program administrator, contractor, or third party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- History and Statutory Authorization. Utilizing the authority to create a financing district as a charter city, the City of Berkeley, in 2007, established a citywide voluntary program to allow residential and commercial property owners to install solar energy systems and make energy efficiency improvements to their buildings and to repay the cost over 20 years via an assessment on the property tax bill. In 2008, the Legislature granted the statutory authority to cities and counties to provide up-front financing to property owners to install renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to their properties, which is repaid through the property tax bill.
Most PACE programs are implemented and administered under two statutory frameworks:
AB 811 (Levine), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2008, which amended the Improvement Act of 1911, to allow for voluntary contractual assessments to finance PACE projects, and SB 555 (Hancock), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2011, which amended the Mello-Roos Community Facilities District Act to allow for Mello-Roos special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance PACE projects.
The Legislature has expanded PACE for residential and commercial property owners as an option to pay for renewable energy upgrades, energy and water efficiency retrofits, seismic improvements, and other specified improvements for their homes or buildings. Local agencies create PACE assessment districts under AB 811 or establish a Community Facilities District (CFD) under SB 555, allowing the local agency to issue bonds to finance the up-front costs of improvements. In turn, property owners enter into a voluntary contractual assessment agreement with the local agency or agree to annex their property into a CFD to re-pay the bonds via an assessment or special tax, secured by a priority lien, on their property tax bill. The intent of the program is that the assessment or parcel tax remains with the property even if it is sold or transferred, and the improvements must be permanently fixed to the property.
In California, there are several models available to local governments in administering a PACE program. Only the counties of Sonoma and Placer administer their own PACE programs. The majority of local governments contract with a private third-party or join a JPA, which contracts with a private third-party to carry out their PACE programs. The cost of third-party administration is not borne by the local agency, but is built into PACE loan financing. Some of these programs focus on residential projects, others target commercial projects, and some handle both residential and commercial portfolios.
- Messages from the Federal Government. In 2010, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which oversees the nation's largest mortgage finance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, raised concerns that residential PACE financing could pose a risk for federal mortgage enterprises (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac), because PACE loans are a first-priority lien in the case of foreclosure, and outstanding PACE assessments would be paid before mortgage costs. FHFA specifically pointed to the underwriting for PACE programs, which results in collateral-based lending, rather than lending based upon ability to pay. FHFA statements also reference the absence of Truth in Lending Act and other consumer protections. In August of 2010, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac announced they would not purchase mortgages for homes with first lien priority PACE obligations which triggered many local governments to suspend their residential PACE programs.
SB 96 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee), Chapter 356, Statutes of 2013, sought to address FHFA's decision, and tasked the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) with administering a PACE loss reserve program of $10 million to keep mortgage interests whole during a foreclosure or a forced sale. CAEATFA established regulations, and is undergoing a process to update regulations.
The loss reserve launched in June 2014 initialing enrolling eight PACE programs with a total of 17,401 residential PACE financings valued at over $350 million. The loss reserve currently supports 115,332 PACE financings with an outstanding value of over $2.68 billion from 14 PACE programs. The PACE Loss Reserve Program is designed to compensate first mortgage lenders for losses resulting from the existence of a PACE lien in a foreclosure or forced sale. The program covers PACE payments made during foreclosure, if a mortgage lender forecloses on a home that has a PACE lien, and any losses to a first mortgage lender up to the amount of outstanding PACE payment, if a county conducts a forced sale on a home for unpaid taxes. The intent of the Program is to put the first mortgage lender in the same position it would be in without a PACE lien. To date, FHFA has maintained its position against first-priority PACE liens.
- Consumer Protections. Last session, AB 2693 (Dababneh), Chapter 618, Statutes of 2016, established a number of consumer notice requirements and sought to tighten financing standards for PACE assessments for residential properties. AB 2693 prohibits a local agency from allowing a homeowner to participate in PACE, unless the homeowner is provided both the right to cancel and a financing estimate and disclosure document. The financing estimate and disclosure must include specified information, including product costs, financing costs, additional information to use to compare to other financing options, and a number of statements that require the homeowner to initial. AB 2693 applies to all PACE programs, regardless of whether local agencies use a PACE administrator, for residential properties with four or fewer units.
- Bill Summary. This bill establishes requirements specifically for PACE programs that are administered by a third-party program administrator for residential real properties with four or fewer units. This bill does not apply to any local government (Placer and Sonoma) that does not use a program administrator for their PACE program. This bill is author-sponsored.
This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including: 1) permitting contractors to advertise PACE assessments or solicit property owners, unless specified requirements are met; 2) providing direct or indirect cash payment or other things of value to a contractor or property owner; 3) making representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract; and, 4) providing information to a contractor that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible or the amount of equity in a property.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including that PACE contractors are properly licensed. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader."
- Pending Issues. Following a series of news articles in the Wall Street Journal, the filing of two class action lawsuits, and the introduction of legislation at the Federal level, the topic of residential PACE and expression of concerns over the lack of oversight and protections for consumers continue. PACE administrators and supporters of PACE continue to point to energy savings and the fact that the industry is still relatively new and experiencing growing pains.
AB 271 (Caballero), pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee, authorizes a county tax collector to direct the county auditor to remove a delinquent installment based on a PACE assessment that arises from a contract entered into on or after January 1, 2018, from the county's tax rolls.
- Policy Consideration. It is clear that there is an immediate need to provide additional parameters around the PACE program to ensure consumer protections. Maintaining local control of the PACE program comes at a cost. Absent a statewide regulatory body to provide oversight, this bill seeks to reform a number of elements of PACE.
At the inception of the PACE program, the presence of third party administrators and the accompanying complex financing structures were not contemplated by the Legislature. Nearly all local governments utilize the JPA and program administrator model for PACE programs, and as PACE continues to evolve, the realities are very different than those imagined at the outset of legislative authorization. For example, one of the key features of the PACE program is that not only does the efficiency improvement remain with the property, but so does the obligation to repay the contractual assessment. Homeowners, mortgage and realtor industry stakeholders, PACE administrators, local governments including tax collectors, and now consumer groups have seen the consequences when homeowners are forced to repay the entire PACE assessment in order to sell or refinance their homes or cannot afford to make the payments on their property tax bills.
The Legislature continues to grapple with laws which govern local government assessments, including lien priority, unpaid payments, foreclosure, underwriting, data collection, oversight, noticing requirements, and lending practices in determining which requirements PACE should be subject to in light of the current realities of the program. To ensure that this bill provides meaningful protections for consumers and to allow for important discussions to continue among stakeholders, this bill was significantly narrowed in the policy committee process. Some of the removed provisions include oral confirmation, eligible improvements, reporting, and contract requirements, and are significant changes to public policy which would require further discussion in policy committee.
- Arguments in Support. A coalition letter signed by proponents including Renovate America, Renew Financial, Ygrene Energy Fund, and California Solar Energy Industries Association, states, "As it has matured, the PACE industry has repeatedly shown a willingness to strengthen its consumer protections. Most recently, the industry's work with state lawmakers last year on AB 2693 (Dababneh) resulted in the passage of the most comprehensive PACE consumer protection and disclosure law in the nation. SB 242 seeks to build on those improvements by enacting a comprehensive set of program requirements that will further protect homeowners and ensure the integrity of PACE programs."
- Arguments in Opposition. None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Misa Lennox / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0001278
Date of Hearing: July 18, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Matthew Dababneh, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 242
Author:(Skinner) – As Amended Ver:July 13, 2017
SENATE VOTE: 34-3
SUBJECT: Property Assessed Clean Energy program: program administrator
SUMMARY: Make changes to the Property Assessed Clean Energy program (PACE) establishing prohibitions for program administrators, contractors and third parties, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract.
- Prohibits contractors or other third parties from advertising or soliciting on behalf of the program administrator unless the following requirements are met:
- The contractor or third party maintains an appropriate license in good standing from the Contractor’s State Licensing Board including the required bond and insurance coverage, as specified.
- The program administrator obtains the contractor’s or third party’s written agreement that the contractor or third party will act in accordance with applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct or indirect cash payment to a contractor or third party in excess of that amount provided as compensation for work performed in the assessment contract.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct cash payment or other thing of value to a property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract.
- Prohibits a program administrator, contractor, or a third party from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with Internal Revenue Service and applicable state tax agency policy with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on behalf of the program administrator any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
- Adds charter cities to the list of entities as defined by “public agency.”
- Adds language stating that the act addresses a matter of statewide concern and therefore shall apply equally to all cities and counties, including charter cities.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “Property Assessed Clean Energy bond” or “PACE bond” as a bond that is secured by any of the following:
- A voluntary contractual assessment on property authorized pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 5898.20 of the Streets and Highways (S&H) Code;
- A voluntary contractual assessment or a voluntary special tax on property to finance the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, or energy or water efficiency improvements that is levied pursuant to a chartered city’s constitutional authority under Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution; or,
- A special tax on property authorized pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 53328.1 of the Government Code. (Public Resources (PR) Code Section 26054)
- Authorizes cities, counties, and other local public agencies and utility districts to provide up-front financing to property owners to install renewable energy-generating devices, make specified water or energy efficiency improvements, or install electric vehicle charging infrastructure on their properties through a system of voluntary contractual assessments which is repaid, with interest, through property tax assessments. The programs are commonly referred to as the PACE programs. (S&H Code Section 5898.10 et seq.)
- Requires the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) to develop and administer a PACE Reserve program to reduce overall costs to the property owners of PACE bonds issued by an applicant by providing a reserve of no more than 10 percent of the initial principal amount of the PACE bond. Requires the CAEATFA to develop and administer a PACE risk mitigation program for PACE financing to increase its acceptance in the marketplace and protect against the risk of default and foreclosure. (PR Code Section 26060)
- Allows a community facilities district to finance and refinance the acquisition, installation, and improvement of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements that are affixed, as specified in Section 660 of the Civil Code, to or on real property and in buildings, whether the real property or buildings are privately or publicly owned. Energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements financed by a district may only be installed on a privately owned building and on privately owned real property with the prior written consent of the owner or owners of the building or real property. This chapter shall not be used to finance installation of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements on a privately owned building or on privately owned real property in connection with the initial construction of a residential building unless the initial construction is undertaken by the intended owner or occupant. (Government (GOV) Code Section 53313.5)
- Requires PACE financing to add consumer notice requirements and tighten financing standards for PACE loans for residential properties. (GOV Code Section 53328)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- Background: In 2008, California enacted the first statewide PACE program through AB 811 (Levine), Chapter 159. Since 2008, at least 31 other states have created their own programs with variations. PACE is an innovative financing tool that residential or commercial property owners can use to pay for renewable energy upgrades, energy, or water efficiency, or electric vehicle charging stations for their homes or buildings. Local agencies create PACE assessment districts in their jurisdictions via a resolution of their legislative body, allowing the local agency to issue bonds to finance the up-front costs of improvements. In turn, property owners enter into a voluntary contractual assessment agreement with the local agency to re-pay the bonds via an assessment on their property tax bill. The assessment remains with the property even if it is sold or transferred, and the improvements must be permanently fixed to the property.
PACE programs typically are more attractive to borrowers and lenders because they can offer a longer pay-back period (up to 20 years) with smaller payments than other types of loans, and they are securitized by the property assessment rather than the borrower.
- PACE: Generally, PACE programs begin with a local public agency (such as a city, county or municipal utility district) adopting a resolution to create a Joint Power Authority (JPA) to authorize the creation of a PACE loan program. The JPA administers the program directly or may contract with a private entity to administer it. The JPA may authorize either local governments or third parties to make loans to homeowners for the conservation improvements.
When created, it was presumed that public agencies would run the PACE program themselves; instead the majority of cities or counties have contracted out the services to new unregulated private entities to administer the PACE program.
The programs are funded by either private or public sources, or a combination of both. For example, Sonoma County has generally used public funds for their residential PACE program. The residential PACE program in Sonoma County, Sonoma County Energy Independence Program, borrows money from the County, which is then paid back with interest as the lien is paid off by the homeowner. In other areas, it is primarily private funding. In PACE programs administered by private entities the bonds are typically issued to private investors to pay the cost of the of the conservation improvements.
- How does PACE work? Although details vary between the programs, generally a homeowner who is interested in adding a conservation improvement to his or her home is first advised and sometimes required to have an energy audit conducted on the property to identify areas of potential conservation improvements. After that, a homeowner contacts a contractor, who typically has to be approved or certified by the PACE program to be eligible to work on the project. The contractor provides an estimate of the costs of the conservation improvement(s) the homeowner wishes to add. The homeowner then applies to the program for approval. Typically there are costs associated with the application. Only once the improvement application is approved, will the work begin.
If the project is approved, the entity administering the program will enter into an agreement with the property owner where the entity agrees to pay the cost of the improvement. An assessment lien is placed on the property for the amount owed plus interest. After the work is performed, the PACE program entity pays the contractor. The property owner repays the entity for the improvements as a special tax assessment on the property tax bill, generally over a five to 20 year period. The property owner pays the lien in the same manner as he or she would pay property taxes.
- Who uses PACE? PACE financing is available to property owners in certain cities or counties that have adopted a program. In California, over 400 cities and counties participate in PACE. To qualify, homeowners need to have equity in their home. The homeowner must have no judgment liens or federal or state tax liens. The homeowner cannot be in bankruptcy. The property cannot be subject to a bankruptcy proceeding. The homeowner must not be delinquent on any mortgages.
- Discussion: Since the inception of the PACE program it has been clear to all parties that additional consumer protections needed to be built into the program. Throughout California and across the nation cases of predatory sales practices, inappropriate contract measures and property owners not understanding the provisions of the program remained problematic. The author’s office has provided the following statement:
With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including ensuring that projects financed achieve the intended public purposes, and that PACE contractors are properly licensed. By doing so, SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader.
- This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including:
- Permitting contractors to advertise PACE assessments or solicit property owners, unless specified requirements are met.
- Waiving payments as a financial inducement.
- Providing direct or indirect cash payment or other things of value to a contractor or property owner.
- Making representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract.
- Providing information to a contractor that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible or the amount of equity in a property.
- This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including:
- Previous Legislation:
- AB 2693 (Dababneh), Chapter 618, Statutes of 2016: Amends statutes governing PACE financing to add consumer notice requirements and tighten financing standards for PACE loans for residential properties.
- AB 1883 (Skinner), Chapter 599, Statutes of 2014: Allows a public agency to transfer voluntary contractual assessments, if bonds have not been issued, as specified.
- SB 96 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 356, Statutes of 2013: Requires the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) to develop and administer a risk mitigation program for PACE loans.
- SB 555 (Hancock), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2011: Adds the acquisition, installation, and improvement of energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements that are affixed to the types of facilities that a community facilities district may finance, or refinance, regardless of whether the buildings or property are privately or publicly owned.
- SB 1340 (Kehoe), Chapter 649, Statutes of 2010: Expands the use of voluntary contractual assessments to finance electric vehicle charging infrastructure and correspondingly expanded the PACE bond reserve program.
- SB 77 (Pavley), Chapter 15, Statutes of 2010: Authorizes CAEATFA to develop and administer a state PACE bond reserve program to pay bondholders in the event a PACE program had insufficient funds, which would reduce risk to bondholders and facilitate smaller interest rates. CAEATFA has suspended development of this program pending resolution of Federal Housing Finance Agency’s concerns described above.
- AB 44 (Blakeslee), Chapter 564, Statutes of 2010: Expands the use of voluntary contractual assessments to include financing of power purchase agreements, and prohibited contractual assessments if the total amount of the assessments and taxes on the property exceeds 5% of the property’s market value.
- AB 474 (Blumenfield), Chapter 444, Statutes of 2009: Expands local agencies’ PACE authorization to include water efficiency projects.
- AB 811 (Levine), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2008: Authorizes all cities and counties in California to designate areas within which city officials and willing property owners may enter into contractual assessments to finance the installation of distributed generation renewable energy sources and energy efficiency improvements.
- Double Referral: This bill has been double referred, having been heard in the Assembly Local Government Committee on July 12, 2017, and passed on a vote of 8-1.
Support/Opposition: This bill has undergone significant amendments just a few days prior to the Assembly Banking and Finance Committee hearing. Accordingly, the following list of support and opposition reflects the letters received by this committee as of the July 3, 2017, version of this bill, unless otherwise noted.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
SUPPORT:
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California League of Conservation Voters
California Solar Energy Industries Association
California State Association of Counties
Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
League of California Cities (confirmed July 14, 2017)
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Rancho Cucamonga; City of
Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD)
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
United States Green Building Council
WattzOn
OPPOSITION:
California Association of County Treasurers & Tax Collectors (unless amended)
California Bankers Association (unless amended)
California Credit Union League (unless amended)
California Escrow Association (unless amended)
California Land Title Association (unless amended)
California Mortgage Association (unless amended)
California Mortgage Bankers Association (unless amended)
United Trustees Association (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: William Herms / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
Date of Hearing: July 12, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 242
Author:(Skinner) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2017
SENATE VOTE: 34-3
SUBJECT: Property Assessed Clean Energy program: program administrator.
SUMMARY: Establishes requirements for contracts, efficiency improvements, disclosures, and reporting for Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs administered by a third-party program administrator. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the provisions of this bill to apply exclusively to residential property with four or fewer units and prohibits the provisions of this bill from applying to any public agency that does not use a program administrator to administer a PACE program.
- Defines numerous terms used throughout the bill, including the following terms:
- "Ancillary work" to mean "the improvement of real property made in connection with the installation of a measure;"
- "Assessment contract" to mean "an agreement entered into between all property owners of record on real property and a public agency, in which, for voluntary contractual assessments imposed on the real property, in accordance with a PACE program;"
- "Authorized representative" to mean "an attorney-in-fact or conservator of the estate of the property owner;"
- "Custom measure" to mean "a measure that is not on the eligible measure list of a program administrator for a PACE program;"
- "Eligible measure list" to mean "for each PACE program, a list of all measures other than custom measures that have been approved for a PACE assessment by a program administrator;"
- "Measure" to mean "one or more improvements on real property that may be made pursuant to an assessment contract under a PACE program;"
- "Program administrator" to mean "an entity administering a PACE program on behalf of, and with the written consent of, a public agency;"
- "Property owner" to mean "all property owners of record on the property subject to the PACE assessment;" and,
- "Public agency" to mean "a city, county, city and county, municipal utility district, community services district, community facilities district, joint powers authority (JPA), sanitary district, sanitation district, or water district."
- Prohibits a program administrator from submitting, presenting, or otherwise approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract, unless the following criteria are met:
- All property taxes for that property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current. Requires the property owner to certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes in the three previous years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever period is shorter;
- The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of $1,000;
- The property has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of $1,000;
- The property has no notices of default outstanding;
- The property has not been party to any bankruptcy proceedings within the last seven years, except as specified;
- The property owner is current on all mortgage debt and has been late on payments no more than once during the 12 months preceding the application date;
- The property is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program;
- The measures to be installed, pursuant to the assessment contract, are eligible under the terms of the applicable PACE program;
- The total amount of PACE assessments on the property, inclusive of any preexisting assessments, does not exceed 15% of the market value of the property;
- The total PACE assessments and the mortgage-related debt on the property does not exceed 96.5% of the market value of the property;
- The term of the assessment contract does not exceed the estimated useful life of the measure to which the greatest portion of funds disbursed under the assessment contract are attributable. Requires the program administrator to determine useful life based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations; and,
- Requires the property owner to notify the program administrator if the property owner has authorized additional PACE assessments on the same subject property, as specified.
- Authorizes a program administrator to derive market value using one of the following:
- An automated valuation model, which is a computerized property valuation system that is used to derive a reasonable real property value;
- A broker's price opinion conducted by a licensed real estate broker;
- An appraisal conducted by a state-licensed real estate appraiser; or
- The assessed value of the property. Requires the determination of market value to be deemed valid on its face if the assessed value is used.
- Requires the market value determination by the program administrator to be disclosed to the property owner.
- Prohibits a program administrator from submitting, presenting, or otherwise approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract, unless the program administrator makes a good faith determination that, at the time the contract is signed, the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessment based on the property owner's income, assets and current debt obligations.
- Requires the property owner to state his or her income to the program administrator as a condition of application.
- Requires the program administrator to obtain one or more credit reports on the property owner from a consumer reporting agency in connection with underwriting the PACE assessment, and allows the program administrator to use a credit report prepared by a credit reporting agency that is transmitted electronically.
- Requires the program administrator, if the annual PACE assessment payments exceeds 1.5% of the market value of the property, to verify the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.
- Prohibits the equity of the property from being considered in evaluating the income, assets, and current debt obligations of the property owner.
- Requires the program administrator, before a property owner consummates an assessment contract, to make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract to at least one owner of the property or authorized representative of the property owner, and requires the program administrator to obtain acknowledgment from the person whom the oral confirmation is given. Requires the oral confirmation to include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
- The measure being installed is being financed by a PACE assessment;
- The total estimated annual costs the property owner will have to pay under the assessment contract, including applicable fees;
- The estimated date the first payment will be due;
- The term of the assessment contract;
- That the payment on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the property and paid either directly to the county assessor's office or through the property owner's mortgage impound account;
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the assessment contract;
- That the property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments and all other PACE assessment or special taxes that are or about to be placed on the property;
- That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the assessment contract in addition to other expenses;
- That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed, and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount;
- That the program administrator does not provide tax advice and that the property owner should seek professional tax advice for questions regarding the tax impact on the PACE assessment or assessment contract; and,
- That the obligations under the assessment contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
- Requires the program administrator to comply with the following when giving the oral confirmation, pursuant to 11), above:
- Requires the program administrator to record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws;
- Prohibits the program administrator from complying with the oral confirmation requirements through the use of a prerecorded message or other similar device or method; and,
- Requires the oral confirmation requirements to be in addition to the documents required by existing law to be provided to the property owner.
- Prohibits a program administrator from waiving or deferring the first payment on an assessment contract. Requires a property owner's first assessment payment to be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the measure installation is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from offering a PACE assessment for a measure that is not permanently affixed to real property, and consistent with criteria of the PACE program.
- Requires the program administrator or contractor to confirm that the measure is included on the applicable eligible measures list or has been approved as a custom measure.
- Requires a program administrator to establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency. Requires a program administrator to establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the eligible measure list. Requires the eligible measure list to include, at minimum, the following information for each measure appearing on that list:
- A name or description;
- Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria; and,
- Expected useful life. Requires the useful life to be based upon credible third-party standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies or nationally recognized standards and testing organizations.
- Prohibits a measure from being included on an eligible measure list, unless the program administrator has determined that the measure complies with both of the following:
- It is consistent with the scope of the PACE program; and,
- It meets one or more standards or certification criteria that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate and credible third-party private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards with respect to the measure. Provides that a measure may comply with this requirement if it is an improvement eligible for rebate by at least one public utility, energy utility, or public water system that provides services to that property owner.
- Authorizes a program administrator to offer a PACE assessment for a measure not included in the eligible measure list if that administrator does both of the following:
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process, that has been approved by a sponsoring public agency, to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom measure; and,
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines that have been approved by the sponsoring agency, by which the program administrator shall review and approve the application for a custom measure. Requires those guidelines to identify minimum requirements and criteria that must be met for a custom measure to be approved.
- Prohibits a PACE assessment from being used for ancillary work, unless both of the following requirements are met:
- The scope of the ancillary work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of a measure, and the total amount financed, including both the eligible measure and the ancillary work, does not exceed 15% of the market value of the property; and
- The cost of the ancillary work does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
- Exempts seismic strengthening improvements from requirements described in 16) through 19), above.
- Prohibits a program administrator from permitting contractors or other third parties from advertising the availability of assessment contracts that are administered by the program administrator, or to soliciting property owners on behalf of the program administrator, unless both of the following requirements are met:
- The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors’ State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage; and,
- The program administrator obtains a written agreement with a contractor or third party that they will act in accordance will applicable advertising and marketing laws and regulations, and all other applicable laws.
- The contractor or third party maintains in good standing an appropriate license from the Contractors’ State Licensing Board, as well as any other permits, licenses, or registrations required, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage; and,
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing any direct or indirect cash payments or other things of material value to either of the following:
- A contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged by that contractor or third party to the proposed owner for the sale and installation of one or more measures financed by an assessment contract. Authorizes a program administrator to reimburse documented expenses to a contractor or third party for approved cobranded advertising and marketing campaigns and collateral, training, and training events; or,
- A property owner explicitly conditioned upon that property owner entering into an assessment contract. Provides that programs or promotions that offer reduced fees or interest rates are neither a direct cash payment nor "other things of value" provided they are reflected in the assessment contract and in no circumstance provided to the property owner as cash consideration.
- Prohibits a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, unless that representation is consistent with representations, statements, or opinions of the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency with regard to the tax treatment of PACE assessments.
- Prohibits a program administrator from providing to a contractor or third party engaged in soliciting assessment contracts on its behalf any information that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible under a PACE assessment or the amount of equity in a property.
- Provides that this bill does not prevent a program administrator, at its discretion and sole expense, from doing any of the following:
- Assigning to a third party its right to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract;
- Securitizing its interest in bonds issued, pursuant to one or more assessment contracts; or,
- Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued, pursuant to one or more assessment contracts or securities backed by assessment contracts.
- Requires a program administrator, for each PACE program that it administers, to submit a report at least annually, to the public agency. Requires the report to contain the following information for the preceding calendar year:
- The number of properties that received PACE assessments;
- The aggregate dollar amount of PACE assessments received;
- The average dollar amount of PACE assessments received;
- The categories of installed measures whether energy or water efficiency, renewable energy, or seismic improvements, and assessments represented by each category type, on a number and dollar basis;
- Rates of default, including the number of parcels defaulted and defaulted amount and the number of years in default for each property within the jurisdictional boundaries of the public agency;
- Estimated total amount of renewable energy produced;
- Estimated total amount of water saved;
- Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emissions reductions; and,
- Estimated number of jobs created.
- Requires the program administrator to make available to the public agency all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report.
- Requires all reports submitted, pursuant to 26), above, to include only aggregate data and prohibits the report from including any nonpublic personal information.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- History and Statutory Authorization. Utilizing the authority to create a financing district as a charter city, the City of Berkeley, in 2007, established a citywide voluntary program to allow residential and commercial property owners to install solar energy systems and make energy efficiency improvements to their buildings and to repay the cost over 20 years via an assessment on the property tax bill. In 2008, the Legislature granted the statutory authority to cities and counties to provide up-front financing to property owners to install renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to their properties, which is repaid through the property tax bill.
Most PACE programs are implemented and administered under two statutory frameworks:
AB 811 (Levine), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2008, which amended the Improvement Act of 1911, to allow for voluntary contractual assessments to finance PACE projects, and SB 555 (Hancock), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2011, which amended the Mello-Roos Community Facilities District Act to allow for Mello-Roos special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance PACE projects.
The Legislature has expanded PACE for residential and commercial property owners as an option to pay for renewable energy upgrades, energy and water efficiency retrofits, seismic
improvements, and other specified improvements for their homes or buildings. Local agencies create PACE assessment districts under AB 811 or establish a Community Facilities District (CFD) under SB 555, allowing the local agency to issue bonds to finance the up-front costs of improvements. In turn, property owners enter into a voluntary contractual assessment agreement with the local agency or agree to annex their property into a CFD to
re-pay the bonds via an assessment or special tax, secured by a priority lien, on their property tax bill. The intent of the program is that the assessment or parcel tax remains with the property even if it is sold or transferred, and the improvements must be permanently fixed to the property.
- PACE Models. In California, there are several models available to local governments in administering a PACE program. Only the counties of Sonoma and Placer administer their own PACE programs. The majority of local governments contract with a private third-party or join a JPA, which contracts with a private third-party to carry out their PACE programs. The cost of third-party administration is not borne by the local agency, but is built into PACE loan financing. Some of these programs focus on residential projects, others target commercial projects, and some handle both residential and commercial portfolios.
- Messages from the Federal Government. In 2010, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which oversees the nation's largest mortgage finance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, raised concerns that residential PACE financing could pose a risk for federal mortgage enterprises (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac), because PACE loans are a first-priority lien in the case of foreclosure, and outstanding PACE assessments would be paid before mortgage costs. FHFA specifically pointed to the underwriting for PACE programs, which results in collateral-based lending, rather than lending based upon ability to pay. FHFA statements also reference the absence of Truth in Lending Act and other consumer protections. In August of 2010, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac announced they would not purchase mortgages for homes with first lien priority PACE obligations which triggered many local governments to suspend their residential PACE programs.
The State of California and several other parties sued FHFA for not conducting a formal rulemaking before its decision; however, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in FHFA’s favor in March of 2013. (County of Sonoma, et al. v. Federal Housing Finance Agency, 710 F.3d 987 (2013)).
SB 96 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 356, Statutes of 2013, sought to address FHFA's decision, and tasked the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) with administering a PACE loss reserve program of $10 million to keep mortgage interests whole during a foreclosure or a forced sale. CAEATFA established regulations, and is undergoing a process to update regulations.
The loss reserve launched in June 2014 initialing enrolling eight PACE programs with a total of 17,401 residential PACE financings valued at over $350 million. The loss reserve currently supports 115,332 PACE financings with an outstanding value of over $2.68 billion from 14 PACE programs. The PACE Loss Reserve Program is designed to compensate first mortgage lenders for losses resulting from the existence of a PACE lien in a foreclosure or
forced sale. The program covers PACE payments made during foreclosure, if a mortgage lender forecloses on a home that has a PACE lien, and any losses to a first mortgage lender up to the amount of outstanding PACE payment, if a county conducts a forced sale on a home for unpaid taxes. The intent of the Program is to put the first mortgage lender in the same position it would be in without a PACE lien.
The FHFA issued clarity to their position following the creation of the PACE Loss Reserve Program, in a letter to Governor Brown dated May 1, 2014, which states, "The Reserve Fund is not an adequate substitute for Enterprise mortgages maintaining a first lien position and FHFA also has concerns about the Reserve Fund's ongoing sustainability."
In July 2016, the Clean Energy Savings for All Americans initiative, included guidelines from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Department of Veterans Affairs as to how properties with residential PACE assessments can be purchased and refinanced with Federal Housing Administration (FHA) mortgage insurance and VA insured mortgages. Key requirements include: (1) the PACE obligation is collected and secured by the creditor in the same manner as a special assessment against the property, pursuant to state law; (2) only the delinquent PACE assessment payments take a first lien position ahead of the mortgage; and, (3) the assessment transfers from one property owner to the next, including through a foreclosure sale.
To date, FHFA has maintained its position against first-priority PACE liens.
In November 2016, the Department of Energy released the "Best Practice Guidelines for Residential PACE Financing Programs." These guidelines state, "PACE Assessment Non-Acceleration upon Property Owner Default: In the event of a sale of a property with an outstanding PACE Assessment, including a foreclosure sale, the obligation remains with the property and the new homeowner will be responsible for paying the remaining PACE financing balance. A PACE assessment should survive the foreclosure process. After a foreclosure, the subsequent owners are responsible for future assessment payments, and could be responsible for any delinquent amounts that remain if foreclosure proceeds were insufficient to pay-off the delinquent amount."
PACE financing provides creditors security that they would be repaid because property tax liens are super priority liens that are senior to mortgage debt. If a house is sold in a foreclosure or tax sale, the PACE lien holder will be paid before other lienholders, like mortgage lenders. In response to FHFA's decision not to purchase mortgages with PACE liens, some third party PACE providers offered an option to homeowners who are unable to refinance or sell their homes called "Limited Subordination" or "Contractual Subordination." These contractual lien subordinations are an agreement between the PACE lien holder and a mortgage lender, where the PACE lien holder "subordinates" their right to foreclose on a home for non-payment of PACE assessments, and to the proceeds from foreclosure, until the mortgage lender has been paid in full for amounts due under its mortgage. This practice is not utilized by all PACE providers in the industry, and not addressed in state statute. According to Renovate America, subordination agreements are no longer offered.
- Consumer Protections. Last session, AB 2693 (Dababneh), Chapter 618, Statutes of 2016, established a number of consumer notice requirements and sought to tighten financing standards for PACE assessments for residential properties. AB 2693 prohibits a local agency from allowing a homeowner to participate in PACE, unless the homeowner is provided both the right to cancel and a financing estimate and disclosure document. The financing estimate and disclosure must include specified information, including product costs, financing costs, additional information to use to compare to other financing options, and a number of
statements that require the homeowner to initial. AB 2693 applies to all PACE programs,
regardless of whether local agencies use a PACE administrator, for residential properties with four or fewer units.
This Committee, jointly with the Banking and Finance Committee, held an oversight hearing, in June 2016, to provide oversight on the current administration of PACE programs and to gain a better understanding on concerns expressed over residential PACE and the impacts on the financial market.
- Bill Summary. This bill establishes requirements specifically for PACE programs that are administered by a third-party program administrator for residential real properties with four or fewer units. This bill does not apply to any local government (Placer and Sonoma) that does not use a program administrator for their PACE program. This bill is author-sponsored.
- Contract Requirements. This bill prohibits a program administrator from submitting or approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract, unless specified criteria are met: 1) The property owner has notified the program administrator of additional PACE assessments on the property, has no delinquent tax obligations over $1,000, and is current on all mortgage debt; 2) The property has no recorded involuntary liens over $1,000, has no notices of default outstanding, has not been party to bankruptcy within the last seven years, is within the boundaries of the PACE program, and property taxes are current; and, 3) The total amount of PACE assessments does not exceed 15% of the market value of the property, the total PACE assessment and mortgage related debt on the property does not exceed 96.5% of the market value of the property, and the term of the assessment contract does not exceed the useful life of the measure.
Additionally, this bill requires a program administrator to make a good faith determination that the property owner has a reasonable ability to meet the annual payment obligations for the PACE assessments based on the property owner’s income, assets, and current debt obligation. A program administrator must obtain a credit report and must verify income, assets, and current debt obligations if the annual PACE assessment payments exceed 1.5% of the market value of the property. This bill provides several determinations that may be used to determine market value. This bill also requires the property owner to state their income as a condition of application.
Under this bill, a program administrator must make an oral confirmation of key terms of the contract to at least one owner of the property prior to a property owner consummating an assessment contract. This bill specifies information that must be included in the oral confirmation.
- Program Administrators. This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including: 1) permitting contractors to advertise PACE assessments or solicit property owners, unless specified requirements are met; 2) providing direct or indirect cash payment or other things of value to a contractor or property owner;
3) making representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract; and, 4) providing information to a contractor that discloses the amount of funds for which a property owner is eligible or the amount of equity in a property. - Eligible Improvements. This bill requires a program administrator to establish an eligible measure list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency publicly available. A program administrator must establish suitable procedures for the inclusion, maintenance, and removal of information included on the list and specifies information for each measure that must be included. This bill also authorizes a program administrator to offer a PACE assessment for a measure not included on the eligible measure list if the administrator complies with specified requirements.
- Program Administrators. This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities, including: 1) permitting contractors to advertise PACE assessments or solicit property owners, unless specified requirements are met; 2) providing direct or indirect cash payment or other things of value to a contractor or property owner;
This bill prohibits PACE assessments from being used for ancillary work, improvements to the property in connection with the installation of a measure, unless these requirements for the ancillary work are met: 1) It is directly related to and necessary for the measure; 2) It does not exceed 15% of the market value of the property; and, 3) It does not exceed the cost of the eligible measure.
- Reporting Requirements. This bill requires a program administrator, for each PACE program, to submit a report annually to the public agency. This bill outlines the information that must be in the report which includes the number of properties, dollar amounts of PACE assessments, categories of measures, rates of default, energy savings, and jobs created.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including ensuring that projects financed achieve the intended public purposes, that PACE contractors are properly licensed, that consumers are properly evaluated for their ability to pay back the assessment. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader."
- Pending Issues. Following a series of news articles in the Wall Street Journal, the filing of two class action lawsuits, and the introduction of legislation at the Federal level, the topic of residential PACE and expression of concerns over the lack of oversight and protections for consumers continue. PACE administrators and supporters of PACE continue to point to energy savings and the fact that the industry is still relatively new and experiencing growing pains.
AB 271 (Caballero), pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee, authorizes a county tax collector to direct the county auditor to remove a delinquent installment based on a PACE assessment that arises from a contract entered into on or after January 1, 2018, from the county's tax rolls.
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following:
- Evolution of PACE. It is clear that there is an immediate need to provide additional parameters around the PACE program to ensure consumer protections. Maintaining local control of the PACE program comes at a cost. Absent a statewide regulatory body to provide oversight, this bill seeks to reform a number of elements of PACE.
At the inception of the PACE program, the presence of third party administrators and the accompanying complex financing structures were not contemplated by the Legislature. Nearly all local governments utilize the JPA and program administrator model for PACE programs, and as PACE continues to evolve, the realities are very different than those imagined at the outset of legislative authorization. For example, one of the key features of the PACE program is that not only does the efficiency improvement remain with the property, but so does the obligation to repay the contractual assessment. Homeowners, mortgage and realtor industry stakeholders, PACE administrators, local governments including tax collectors, and now consumer groups have seen the consequences when homeowners are forced to repay the entire PACE assessment in order to sell or refinance their homes or cannot afford to make the payments on their property tax bills. The Legislature continues to grapple with laws which govern local government assessments, including lien priority, unpaid payments, foreclosure, and noticing requirements, and lending practices in determining which requirements PACE should be subject to in light of the current realities of the program.
The Legislature has continued to attempt to catch up not only with the advances in energy efficiency technology, but to the evolving methods of financing utilized by these companies in this vastly growing and thriving industry. The Committee may wish to consider if a single bill in one year can accomplish this goal.
- Contested Provisions. The Committee may wish to note that there are a number of provisions included in this bill that are still subject to contested debate among stakeholders:
- Ability to Repay. A coalition of consumer groups argue, “…we know from the most recent foreclosure crisis that income and debt obligations must not be merely stated, but verified, to protect consumers. And yet, SB 242 creates a two-tiered system, requiring income verification only if ‘the annual PACE assessment payments will exceed 1.5% of the market value of the property…in our experience, low income clients harmed by PACE loans would seldom, if ever, trigger the proposed verified income requirement.” Additional requirements in this bill, which seek to govern eligibility, remain contested among stakeholders. This bill places a number of requirements on a property owner to disclose information. The Committee may wish to consider if these requirements are not more appropriately assigned to the local agency or the program administrator.
- Contractors. This bill prohibits program administrators from engaging in a number of activities specifically aimed at what a program administrator can or cannot provide to a contractor. Opponents argue that this bill does not go far enough to curb the unsavory advertising, upselling, and false information that has endangered homeowners and put them at risk of losing their homes. A coalition of consumer groups states, “Under current law, PACE program administrators are in a ‘heads they win, tails they win’ position: they bear none of the risk of contractor misrepresentation and are rewarded for each loan that contractors originate, whether it is repaid through a property tax assessment or through a foreclosure or tax sale.
SB 242 must shift the incentives so that program administrators bear the risk of fraudulent contractor conduct.” While this bill is targeted at program administrators, the Committee may wish to consider if this is the most effective approach to protecting consumers. - Reporting. Opposition argues that the reporting requirements contained in this bill should be expanded to include information specific to property owners that participate in the PACE program in light of concerns that this program is disproportionally affecting certain populations and the absence of publicly available data. Currently, PACE programs report specified information to both CAETFA and to their administering JPA. The Committee is not aware of any data provided by the program administrators that has been audited by any of the current oversight entities, CAETFA for loan loss reserve, or the local governments.
- Outstanding Issues. The Committee may wish to note a number of outstanding issues raised in discussions with stakeholders that are not included in this bill:
- Noticing and Recording. A number of outstanding issues, with noticing and ensuring debt obligations are transparent, complicate and prevent the most appropriate entity from ensuring appropriate consumer protections, like whether a homeowner already has a PACE assessment or outstanding involuntary lien, since these are important factors to protect a homeowner from entering into a PACE assessment without having the ability to repay.
- Language Barriers. A coalition of consumer groups state, “SB 242 should require, if a contractor negotiates with a homeowner primarily in a language other than English, that the program administrator give the homeowners an accurate written translation of the PACE loan documents in the language of the negotiations. In the absence of such requirements, PACE administrators and contractors will continue to defraud and mislead homeowners and thereby profit at the expense of vulnerable, low-income consumers and seniors on fixed incomes.”
- Delinquencies. Absent one oversight entity to collect or provide statewide data this Committee has received varying numbers and data regarding the number of homeowners that are delinquent on their PACE assessments. Regardless of the discrepancies, there is one common factor. The delinquency rate for PACE assessments is rising. The Committee may wish to note the challenges to ensuring that homeowners are protected prior to entering into assessments and to providing
adequate relief in instances when homeowners cannot make PACE assessment payments on their property tax bills in absence of verified statewide data. At the request of stakeholders, this Committee is waiting to receive additional data from program administrators. - Additional Provisions. There are a number of additional provisions included in previous versions of this bill that have been removed by the author. Some of these provisions, which include forbearance and legal rights, are significant changes to public policy which would require further discussion in this policy committee, should such provisions be amended back into the bill.
- Contested Provisions. The Committee may wish to note that there are a number of provisions included in this bill that are still subject to contested debate among stakeholders:
- Committee Amendments. To ensure that this bill provides meaningful protections for consumers and to allow for important discussions to continue among stakeholders, the Committee may wish to ask the author to accept the amendments outlined below. For the purposes of timing, these Committee amendments will be taken in Assembly Banking and Finance Committee.
- Narrow the Scope. The Committee may wish to ask the author to narrow the scope of the bill to only the sections that have consensus among stakeholders. Committee amendments would strike out in their entirety the following sections from the bill:
5910, 5911, 5912, 5913, 5920, 5921, and 5930. - Additional Clarifying Amendments. The Committee may wish to ask the author to accept Committee amendments to address the following two issues:
- Representation. This bill prohibits a program administrator from making any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract, as specified. The Committee may wish to ask the author to accept an amendment that has been met with consensus to Section 5924 to extend this prohibition to contractors.
- Consistency and Clarity. The frameworks of AB 811 and SB 555, the statutes which govern PACE, are already contained in several places in existing law. This bill establishes a separate section solely for PACE programs administered by third party providers. The Committee may wish to consider making definitions consistent with the statutes that authorized PACE and deleting any duplicative or unnecessary sections, which include 5915 and 5926. Additionally, the Committee may wish to ensure if local jurisdictions opt to establish a PACE program that is administered by a PACE administrator that the provisions of this bill apply to all cities, including charter cities.
- Narrow the Scope. The Committee may wish to ask the author to narrow the scope of the bill to only the sections that have consensus among stakeholders. Committee amendments would strike out in their entirety the following sections from the bill:
- Arguments in Support. A coalition letter signed by proponents including Renovate America, Renew Financial, Ygrene Energy Fund, and California Solar Energy Industries Association, states, "As it has matured, the PACE industry has repeatedly shown a willingness to strengthen its consumer protections. Most recently, the industry's work with state lawmakers last year on AB 2693 (Dababneh) resulted in the passage of the most comprehensive PACE consumer protection and disclosure law in the nation. SB 242 seeks to build on those improvements by enacting a comprehensive set of program requirements that will further protect homeowners and ensure the integrity of PACE programs." The California State Association of Counties argues, "While the industry has evolved over the last few years, cities and counties remain the cornerstone of the program and strongly support increased disclosure, education and program oversight."
- Arguments in Opposition. A coalition letter signed by organizations opposed unless amended, including the California Low-Income Consumer Coalition, Bet Tzedek Legal Services, and the Center for Responsible Lending, states, "If adopted as written, the bill would do little to protect low-income Californians from what we are seeing on the ground: abusive loan practices that mislead homeowners into assuming debt obligations they cannot repay. Under current law, PACE providers are not required to determine whether a consumer has the ability to repay a PACE loan. As a result, PACE providers frequently place low-income Californians, particularly seniors living on fixed incomes, into PACE loans even when they cannot afford to make the payments. We are aware of numerous cases, across the state, in which homeowners did not understand that they were taking out a loan, the amount of the loan, that their property taxes would increase, or that they could lose their home if they failed to make timely payments on their PACE loan."
- Double Referral. This bill is double-referred to the Banking and Finance Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Advanced Energy Economy
Brightline Defense
Build it Green
CalAsian Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Efficiency + Demand Management Council
California League of Conservation Voters
California State Association of Counties
California Solar Energy Industries Association
Center for Sustainable Energy
Cities of Indian Wells, Rancho Cucamonga, Thousand Oaks
Cleantech San Diego
Climate Action Campaign
Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
League of California Cities
Marin Clean Energy
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Renew Financial
Renovate America
SMUD
South Bay Cities Council of Governments
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Support (continued)
U.S. Green Building Council
Vote Solar
WattzOn
Ygrene Energy Fund
Opposition
Bet Tzedek Legal Services (unless amended)
California Association of Treasurers and Tax Collectors (unless amended)
California Land Title Association (unless amended)
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition (unless amended)
California Reinvestment Coalition (unless amended)
Center for Responsible Lending (unless amended)
Consumers Union (unless amended)
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates (HERA) (unless amended)
Public Counsel (unless amended)
Public Law Center (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Misa Lennox / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 242
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/19/17
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara
NOES: Moorlach
DIGEST:
This bill enacts consumer protections to Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs.
Senate Floor Amendments of 5/18/17 add specific property owner review standards, add a forbearance process, and make numerous clarifying and technical changes.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs that rely on voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes for repayment of the loans.
This bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Ancillary work.”
- “Measure.”
- “Custom measure.”
- “Assessment contract.”
- “PACE assessment.”
- “PACE program.”
- “Program administrator.”
- “Public agency.”
- “Authorizes representative.”
- “Property owner.”
- “Energy utility.”
- “Eligible measures list.”
- “Public water system.”
- Bars a PACE program administrator from submitting, presenting, or otherwise approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the contract complies with the following provisions:
- All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current. The property owner must certify that there has been no more than one late payment of property taxes on the property for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever is shorter.
- The property owner has no delinquent federal or state tax obligations in excess of $1,000.
- The property has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of $1,000.
- The property has no outstanding notices of default.
- The property owner is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding within the last seven years, except that the property owner may have been party to a bankruptcy proceeding that was discharged or dismissed between two and seven years before the application date and the property owner has had no payments more than 30 days past due on any mortgage debt or nonmortgage debt (excluding medical debt) during the 12 months immediately preceding the application date..
- The property owner is current on all mortgage debt and has been late on such payments no more than once during the 12 months preceding the application date.
- The improvements to be installed are eligible projects.
- The total amount of PACE assessments on the property must not be more than 15% of the market value of the property.
- The property is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
- The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property must not exceed 96.5% of the market value of the property.
- The maximum term of the assessment contract must not exceed the estimated useful life of the improvement being installed.
- The property owner must agree to notify the program administrator if additional PACE assessments exist on the same property.
- Requires the program administrator to make a good faith determination on each property owner’s ability to make payments on that assessment contract. This includes obtaining credit reports, and in some cases, verifying income, assets, and debt obligations.
- Requires a program administrator to make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the contract with at least one property owner before authorizing a contractor to begin work to install improvements. The oral confirmation must include the following contract terms:
- The type of measure being installed that is being financed.
- The total estimated costs the property owner will have to pay under the contract.
- The estimated date that the first payment must be made.
- The total term of the contract.
- That the payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessor’s office or through the property owner’s mortgage impound account.
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the contract.
- The property owner has disclosed whether the property has received or is seeking additional PACE assessments.
- That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the contract.
- That any potential utility savings are not guaranteed and will not reduce the assessment payments or total assessment amount.
- That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions to the impact of the PACE contract.
- That the obligations under the contract may be required to be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
The program administrator must follow both of the following when giving the oral confirmation:
- Record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
- The oral confirmation must not be provided through the use of a prerecorded message.
- States that the program administrator cannot waive or defer the first payment on a contract and the first payment must be due no later than the fiscal year following the fiscal year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from offering a PACE assessment for an improvement if it is neither permanently affixed to the property nor consistent with the criteria of the related PACE program. The program administrator must confirm the improvement is eligible before the contractor is authorized to commence installation.
- Requires that a program administrator must establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible improvement list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency. The eligible improvement list must include the following information for each improvement:
- A name and description of the improvement.
- Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
- Expected useful life of the improvement.
Before placing a measure on the eligible improvement list, the program administrator must determine the improvement is both consistent with the scope of the PACE program and that it meets the standards that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, or the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards.
If approved by the sponsoring public agency, this bill allows a program administrator to offer a PACE assessment for an improvement not included on the eligible list if does either of the following:
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom improvement.
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines for the review and approval of a custom improvement.
A PACE assessment cannot be used for ancillary work unless the scope of the work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of an improvement and the cost of work does not exceed 15% of the market value of the property. This requirement applies unless the improvements are for seismic strengthening.
- Requires that a program administrator must not allow contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of an assessment contract or solicit to property owners unless the contractor or third party maintains an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, any local permits, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage.
The program administrator must also obtain a written agreement from the contractor or third party stating they will act in accordance with advertising and marketing laws.
- States that program administrator must not provide any cash payment to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more improvements.
- Specifies that the program administrator must not provide specific information to a contractor or third party.
- Does not prevent a program administrator from doing any of the following:
- Allowing a third party to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
- Securitizing its interest in bonds issued.
- Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued because of one or more assessment contracts or securities backed by assessment contracts.
- Requires that for each PACE program, the program administrator must submit a report with specific information annually to the sponsoring public agency.
- Requires each program administrator, on contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2018, to provide a property owner with forbearance or payment holiday on the PACE assessment under specific circumstances.
Background
PACE financing programs allow local governments to offer loans to private property owners to cover the initial costs of renewable energy, energy efficiency, water efficiency, and other improvements to private property that offer public benefits. Property owners repay the loans through voluntary assessments or parcel taxes, which are secured by priority liens and appear annually on property tax bills until the loans are repaid.
State law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs: voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes.
Voluntary Contractual Assessment PACE Financing. A benefit assessment is an involuntary charge that property owners pay for a public improvement or service that provides a special benefit to their property. As an alternative to benefit assessments, and only with the free and willing consent of affected property owners, state law lets public agencies use voluntary contractual assessments to finance:
- Renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 811, Levine, 2008).
- Water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 474, Blumenfield, 2009).
- Electric vehicle charging infrastructure (SB 1340, Kehoe, 2010).
- Seismic strengthening improvements (AB 184, Swanson, 2011).
Mello-Roos Parcel Tax PACE Financing. The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act allows counties, cities, special districts, and school districts to levy special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance a wide variety of public works, including parks, recreation centers, schools, libraries, child care facilities, and utility infrastructure. A Mello-Roos Community Facilities District (CFD) issues bonds against these special taxes to finance the public works projects. State law establishes an alternative process by which a local government can form a CFD to finance only energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements that are affixed to or on real property and in buildings, whether the real property or buildings are privately or publicly owned (SB 555, Hancock, 2011). Under the alternative formation process, a CFD can initially consist solely of territory proposed for future annexation to the CFD, with the condition that a parcel or parcels within that territory may be annexed to the CFD and subjected to the special tax only with the unanimous approval of the parcel owner or owners at the time of annexation.
In addition to these two statutory frameworks for providing PACE loans, charter cities can establish their own PACE financing programs under California Constitution’s grant of authority to charter cities to control their own “municipal affairs.”
In 2010, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which oversees the nation's largest mortgage finance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, raised concerns that residential PACE financing could pose a risk for these companies, because PACE loans are a first-priority lien and outstanding PACE assessments must be paid before mortgage obligations. As a result, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac stated that they would no longer purchase mortgage loans secured by properties with outstanding PACE loans.
The concerns raised by federal housing finance regulators threatened the viability of PACE financing for residential properties. In response, the Legislature passed SB 96 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2013), which required the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) to administering a PACE loss reserve program of $10 million. CAEATFA established regulations, and the majority of PACE administrators participate in the program. The PACE Loss Reserve Program compensates first mortgage lenders for losses resulting from PACE liens in a foreclosure or tax sale. The Program is intended to cover PACE payments made during foreclosure, or if a county conducts a tax sale on a home for unpaid taxes. The Program seeks to put the first mortgage lender in the same position it would be in without a PACE lien. CAEATFA’s PACE Loss Reserve Program covers more than 56,000 residential PACE financings valued at about $1.2 billion. Through the beginning of June, 2016 CAEATFA, had not received any claims on the loss reserve.
However, the PACE Loss Reserve Program has not resolved federal officials’ concerns about PACE financing. In a May, 2014 letter an FHFA official wrote, “FHFA has carefully reviewed the Reserve Fund created by the State of California and while, I appreciate that it is intended to mitigate these increased losses, it fails to offer full loss protection to the Enterprises. The Reserve Fund is not an adequate substitute for Enterprise mortgages maintaining a first lien position and FHFA also has concerns about the Reserve Fund's ongoing sustainability.”
Federal housing officials, mortgage lenders, and other stakeholders in residential real property transactions remain concerned about the complications that priority liens for PACE loans can create for residential property owners who seek to refinance or sell their properties. They worry about a lack of consumer disclosures and protections for residential PACE program borrowers and a lack of financing criteria to protect the equity on homeowners’ properties. Reports have also pointed to aggressive contracting techniques, misinformation and misunderstanding on the part of the homeowner, and a lack of savings due to high interest rates, and challenges. In response to these concerns, AB 2693 (Dababneh, 2016) was adopted by the Legislature to expand consumer disclosure requirements for PACE loans offered to residential property owners and tighten financing standards for PACE loans. The author of SB 242 wants to continue strengthening these consumer protections.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including ensuring that projects financed achieve the intended public purposes, that PACE contractors are properly licensed, that consumers are properly evaluated for their ability to pay back the assessment, and that payment relief and protection is provided if the loan recipient faces temporary hardship. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Advanced Energy Economy
California Solar Energy Industries Association
California State Association of Counties
Center for Sustainable Energy
City of Indian Wells
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Thousand Oaks
Efficiency First California
League of California Cities
Natural Resources Defense Council
Renew Financial
Renovate America
Vote Solar
WattzOn
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/23/17)
California Association of Treasurers and Tax Collectors
5/25/17 9:39:34
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 242
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/19/17
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara
NOES: Moorlach
DIGEST:
This bill enacts consumer protections to Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs that rely on voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes for repayment of the loans.
This bill:
- Defines the following terms, including:
- “Ancillary work.”
- “Measure.”
- “Custom measure.”
- “Assessment contract.”
- “PACE assessment.”
- “PACE program.”
- “Program administrator.”
- “Public agency.”
- Bars a PACE program administrator from submitting, presenting, or otherwise approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the contract complies with the following provisions:
- All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever is shorter.
- The property has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of $1,000.
- The property has no outstanding notices of default.
- The property owner is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.
- The property owner is current on all mortgage debt that is secured.
- The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property.
- The property is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
- The PACE assessment is less than 15% of the current market value, up to the first $700,000 of the property, and for less than 10% of the remaining current market value of the property. Market value must be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
- The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property must not exceed the market value of the property.
- The maximum term of the assessment contract must not exceed the useful life of the improvement being installed.
- Requires a program administrator to obtain a sworn declaration of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract. A person that willfully states as true any material fact he or she knows to be false shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to $10,000. Any public prosecutor may bring a civil action to impose the civil penalty.
- Requires the program administrator to underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owner’s ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator must not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.
- Requires a program administrator to make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the contract with the property owner before authorizing a contractor to begin work to install improvements. The oral confirmation must include the following contract terms:
- The type of measure being installed that is being financed.
- The total estimated costs the property owner will have to pay under the contract.
- The estimated date that the first payment must be made.
- The total term of the contract.
- That the payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessor’s office or through the property owner’s mortgage impound account.
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the contract.
- That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the contract.
- That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions to the impact of the PACE contract.
- That the obligations under the contract may remain connected to the property or must be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
The program administrator must follow both of the following when giving the oral confirmation:
- Record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
- The oral confirmation must not be provided through the use of a prerecorded message.
- States that the program administrator cannot waive or defer the first payment on a contract and the first payment must be due no later than the tax year following the calendar year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
- Prohibits a program administrator from offering a PACE assessment for an improvement if it is neither permanently affixed to the property nor consistent with the criteria of the related PACE program. The program administrator must confirm the improvement is eligible before the contractor is authorized to commence installation.
- Requires that a program administrator must establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible improvement list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency. The eligible improvement list must include the following information for each improvement:
- A name and description of the improvement.
- Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
- Expected useful life of the improvement.
Before placing a measure on the eligible improvement list, the program administrator must determine the improvement is both consistent with the scope of the PACE program and that it meets the standards that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards.
If approved by the sponsoring public agency, this bill allows a program administrator to offer a PACE assessment for an improvement not included on the eligible list if does either of the following:
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom improvement.
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines for the review and approval of a custom improvement.
A PACE assessment cannot be used for ancillary work unless the scope of the work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of an improvement and the cost of work does not exceed the cost of the eligible improvement.
- Requires that a program administrator must not allow contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of an assessment contract or solicit to property owners unless the contractor or third party maintains an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, any local permits, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage.
The program administrator must also obtain a written agreement from the contract or third party stating they will act in accordance with advertising and marketing laws.
- States that program administrator must not provide any cash payment to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more improvements.
The program administrator must not provide any direct cash payment to a property owner entering into an assessment contract. The program administrator must not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the statements or opinions on the tax treatment of the PACE assessment by the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency.
- Specifies that the program administrator must not provide specific information to a contractor or third party.
- Does not prevent a program administrator from doing any of the following:
- Allowing a third party to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
- Securitizing its interest in bonds issued.
- Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued because of one or more assessment contracts or securities backed by assessment contracts.
- Requires that for each PACE program, the program administrator must submit a report with specific information annually to the sponsoring public agency.
Background
PACE financing programs allow local governments to offer loans to private property owners to cover the initial costs of renewable energy, energy efficiency, water efficiency, and other improvements to private property that offer public benefits. Property owners repay the loans through voluntary assessments or parcel taxes, which are secured by priority liens and appear annually on property tax bills until the loans are repaid.
State law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs: voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes.
Voluntary Contractual Assessment PACE Financing. A benefit assessment is an involuntary charge that property owners pay for a public improvement or service that provides a special benefit to their property. As an alternative to benefit assessments, and only with the free and willing consent of affected property owners, state law lets public agencies use voluntary contractual assessments to finance:
- Renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 811, Levine, 2008).
- Water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 474, Blumenfield, 2009).
- Electric vehicle charging infrastructure (SB 1340, Kehoe, 2010).
- Seismic strengthening improvements (AB 184, Swanson, 2011).
Mello-Roos Parcel Tax PACE Financing. The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act allows counties, cities, special districts, and school districts to levy special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance a wide variety of public works, including parks, recreation centers, schools, libraries, child care facilities, and utility infrastructure. A Mello-Roos Community Facilities District (CFD) issues bonds against these special taxes to finance the public works projects. State law establishes an alternative process by which a local government can form a CFD to finance only energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements that are affixed to or on real property and in buildings, whether the real property or buildings are privately or publicly owned (SB 555, Hancock, 2011). Under the alternative formation process, a CFD can initially consist solely of territory proposed for future annexation to the CFD, with the condition that a parcel or parcels within that territory may be annexed to the CFD and subjected to the special tax only with the unanimous approval of the parcel owner or owners at the time of annexation.
In addition to these two statutory frameworks for providing PACE loans, charter cities can establish their own PACE financing programs under California Constitution’s grant of authority to charter cities to control their own “municipal affairs.”
In 2010, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which oversees the nation's largest mortgage finance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, raised concerns that residential PACE financing could pose a risk for these companies, because PACE loans are a first-priority lien and outstanding PACE assessments must be paid before mortgage obligations. As a result, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac stated that they would no longer purchase mortgage loans secured by properties with outstanding PACE loans.
The concerns raised by federal housing finance regulators threatened the viability of PACE financing for residential properties. In response, the Legislature passed SB 96 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2013), which required the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) to administering a PACE loss reserve program of $10 million. CAEATFA established regulations, and the majority of PACE administrators participate in the program. The PACE Loss Reserve Program compensates first mortgage lenders for losses resulting from PACE liens in a foreclosure or tax sale. The Program is intended to cover PACE payments made during foreclosure, or if a county conducts a tax sale on a home for unpaid taxes. The Program seeks to put the first mortgage lender in the same position it would be in without a PACE lien. CAEATFA’s PACE Loss Reserve Program covers more than 56,000 residential PACE financings valued at about $1.2 billion. Through the beginning of June, 2016 CAEATFA, had not received any claims on the loss reserve.
However, the PACE Loss Reserve Program has not resolved federal officials’ concerns about PACE financing. In a May, 2014 letter an FHFA official wrote, “FHFA has carefully reviewed the Reserve Fund created by the State of California and while, I appreciate that it is intended to mitigate these increased losses, it fails to offer full loss protection to the Enterprises. The Reserve Fund is not an adequate substitute for Enterprise mortgages maintaining a first lien position and FHFA also has concerns about the Reserve Fund's ongoing sustainability.”
Federal housing officials, mortgage lenders, and other stakeholders in residential real property transactions remain concerned about the complications that priority liens for PACE loans can create for residential property owners who seek to refinance or sell their properties. They worry about a lack of consumer disclosures and protections for residential PACE program borrowers and a lack of financing criteria to protect the equity on homeowners’ properties. Reports have also pointed to aggressive contracting techniques, misinformation and misunderstanding on the part of the homeowner, and a lack of savings due to high interest rates, and challenges. In response to these concerns, AB 2693 (Dababneh, 2016) was adopted by the Legislature to expand consumer disclosure requirements for PACE loans offered to residential property owners and tighten financing standards for PACE loans. The author of SB 242 wants to continue strengthening these consumer protections.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including ensuring that projects financed achieve the intended public purposes, that PACE contractors are properly licensed, that consumers are properly evaluated for their ability to pay back the assessment, and that payment relief and protection is provided if the loan recipient faces temporary hardship. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader.”
Underwriting. SB 242 requires the program administrator to underwrite each assessment contract but does not specify the underwriting standards that must be followed. No requirement to underwrite assessment contracts currently exists and is a point of contention between different stakeholders. While introducing the concept of underwriting, SB 242 is unclear if there should be a strict standard that all program administrators must follow or if they have general flexibility to make determinations on a case-by-case basis.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Advanced Energy Economy
California Solar Energy Industries Association
California State Association of Counties
Center for Sustainable Energy
City of Indian Wells
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Thousand Oaks
Efficiency First California
League of California Cities
Natural Resources Defense Council
Renew Financial
Renovate America
Vote Solar
WattzOn
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/10/17)
California Association of Treasurers and Tax Collectors
5/10/17 15:41:01
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 242 | Hearing Date: | 4/19/17 |
Author: | Skinner | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 4/17/17 | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | MacDonald | ||
Property Assessed Clean Energy program: program administrator
Enacts consumer protections to Property Assessed Clean Energy Program loans.
Background
Property assessed clean energy (PACE) financing programs allow local governments to offer loans to private property owners to cover the initial costs of renewable energy, energy efficiency, water efficiency, and other improvements to private property that offer public benefits. Property owners repay the loans through voluntary assessments or parcel taxes, which are secured by priority liens and appear annually on property tax bills until the loans are repaid.
State law establishes two distinct statutory frameworks under which local governments can implement and administer PACE loan programs: voluntary contractual assessments or parcel taxes.
Voluntary Contractual Assessment PACE Financing. A benefit assessment is an involuntary charge that property owners pay for a public improvement or service that provides a special benefit to their property. As an alternative to benefit assessments, and only with the free and willing consent of affected property owners, state law lets public agencies use voluntary contractual assessments to finance:
- Renewable energy sources or energy efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 811, Levine, 2008).
- Water efficiency improvements that are permanently fixed to real property (AB 474, Blumenfield, 2009).
- Electric vehicle charging infrastructure (SB 1340, Kehoe, 2010).
- Seismic strengthening improvements (AB 184, Swanson, 2011).
Mello-Roos Parcel Tax PACE Financing. The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act allows counties, cities, special districts, and school districts to levy special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance a wide variety of public works, including parks, recreation centers, schools, libraries, child care facilities, and utility infrastructure. A Mello-Roos Community Facilities District (CFD) issues bonds against these special taxes to finance the public works projects. State law establishes an alternative process by which a local government can form a CFD to finance only energy efficiency, water conservation, and renewable energy improvements that are affixed to or on real property and in buildings, whether the real property or buildings are privately or publicly owned (SB 555, Hancock, 2011). Under the alternative formation process, a CFD can initially consist solely of territory proposed for future annexation to the CFD, with the condition that a parcel or parcels within that territory may be annexed to the CFD and subjected to the special tax only with the unanimous approval of the parcel owner or owners at the time of annexation.
In addition to these two statutory frameworks for providing PACE loans, charter cities can establish their own PACE financing programs under California Constitution’s grant of authority to charter cities to control their own “municipal affairs.”
In 2010, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), which oversees the nation's largest mortgage finance companies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, raised concerns that residential PACE financing could pose a risk for these companies, because PACE loans are a first-priority lien and outstanding PACE assessments must be paid before mortgage obligations. As a result, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac stated that they would no longer purchase mortgage loans secured by properties with outstanding PACE loans.
The concerns raised by federal housing finance regulators threatened the viability of PACE financing for residential properties. In response, the Legislature passed SB 96 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2013), which required the California Alternative Energy and Advanced Transportation Financing Authority (CAEATFA) to administering a PACE loss reserve program of $10 million. CAEATFA established regulations, and the majority of PACE administrators participate in the program. The PACE Loss Reserve Program compensates first mortgage lenders for losses resulting from PACE liens in a foreclosure or tax sale. The program is intended to cover PACE payments made during foreclosure, or if a county conducts a tax sale on a home for unpaid taxes. The Program seeks to put the first mortgage lender in the same position it would be in without a PACE lien. CAEATFA’s PACE Loss Reserve Program covers more than 56,000 residential PACE financings valued at about $1.2 billion. Through the beginning of June, 2016 CAEATFA, had not received any claims on the loss reserve.
However, the PACE Loss Reserve Program has not resolved federal officials’ concerns about PACE financing. In a May, 2014 letter an FHFA official wrote, “FHFA has carefully reviewed the Reserve Fund created by the State of California and while, I appreciate that it is intended to mitigate these increased losses, it fails to offer full loss protection to the Enterprises. The Reserve Fund is not an adequate substitute for Enterprise mortgages maintaining a first lien position and FHFA also has concerns about the Reserve Fund's ongoing sustainability.”
Federal housing officials, mortgage lenders, and other stakeholders in residential real property transactions remain concerned about the complications that priority liens for PACE loans can create for residential property owners who seek to refinance or sell their properties. They worry about a lack of consumer disclosures and protections for residential PACE program borrowers and a lack of financing criteria to protect the equity on homeowners’ properties. Reports have also pointed to aggressive contracting techniques, misinformation and misunderstanding on the part of the homeowner, and a lack of savings due to high interest rates, and challenges. In response to these concerns, AB 2693 (Dababneh, 2016) was adopted by the Legislature to expand consumer disclosure requirements for PACE loans offered to residential property owners and tighten financing standards for PACE loans. The author od SB 242 wants to continue strengthening these consumer protections.
Proposed Law
Definitions. Senate Bill 242 defines the following terms, including:
- “Ancillary work.”
- “Measure.”
- “Custom measure.”
- “Assessment contract.”
- “PACE assessment.”
- “PACE program.”
- “Program administrator.”
- “Public agency.”
Contract Requirements. SB 242 bars a PACE program administrator from submitting, presenting, or otherwise approving for signature by a public agency an assessment contract unless the contract complies with the following provisions:
- All property taxes for the property that will be subject to the assessment contract are current for the previous three years or since the current owner acquired the property, whichever is shorter.
- The property has no recorded involuntary liens in excess of $1,000.
- The property has no outstanding notices of default.
- The property owner is not a party to any bankruptcy proceeding.
- The property owner is current on all mortgage debt that is secured.
- The property owner that will execute the assessment contract is the title holder of record on the property.
- The property is within the geographical boundaries of the applicable PACE program.
- The PACE assessment is less than 15% of the current market value, up to the first $700,000 of the property, and for less than 10% of the remaining current market value of the property. Market value must be determined in a reasonable and good faith manner.
- The total PACE assessment and mortgage-related debt on the property must not exceed the market value of the property.
- The maximum term of the assessment contract must not exceed the useful life of the improvement being installed.
- The property owner agrees to notify the program administrator if they have authorized an additional PACE assessment on the same property. If the owner does not notify the administrator, the administrator can recover the amount of any funds that were advanced to the owner, if any.
SB 242 requires a program administrator to obtain a sworn declaration of income and debt obligations from each property owner seeking an assessment contract. A person that willfully states as true any material fact he or she knows to be false shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to $10,000. Any public prosecutor may bring a civil action to impose the civil penalty.
This bill requires the program administrator to underwrite each assessment contract to determine the property owner’s ability to make payments on that assessment contract. A program administrator must not approve an assessment contract if it determines that the property owner is unlikely to be able to make all payments on the assessment contract.
SB 242 requires a program administrator to make an oral confirmation of the key terms of the contract with the property owner before authorizing a contractor to begin work to install improvements. The oral confirmation must include the following contract terms:
- The type of measure being installed that is being financed.
- The total estimated costs the property owner will have to pay under the contract.
- The estimated date that the first payment must be made.
- The total term of the contract.
- That the payments on the assessment contract will be made through taxes assessed on the real property and paid either directly to the county assessor’s office or through the property owner’s mortgage impound account.
- That the property will be subject to a lien during the term of the contract.
- That the property owner understands and affirms the financial information that he or she has provided, and that he or she has the financial means to make payments on the contract.
- That the program administrator does not provide tax advice, and the property owner should seek professional tax advice if he or she has questions to the impact of the PACE contract.
- That the obligations under the contract may remain connected to the property or must be paid in full before the property owner sells or refinances the property.
The program administrator must follow both of the following when giving the oral confirmation:
- Record the oral confirmation in an audio format in accordance with applicable laws.
- The oral confirmation must not be provided through the use of a prerecorded message.
This measures states that the program administrator cannot waive or defer the first payment on a contract and the first payment must be due no later than the tax year following the calendar year in which the installation of the measure is completed.
Eligible projects. This bill prohibits a program administrator from offering a PACE assessment for an improvement if it is neither permanently affixed to the property nor consistent with the criteria of the related PACE program. The program administrator must confirm the improvement is eligible before the contractor is authorized to commence installation.
SB 242 requires that a program administrator must establish, maintain, and make publicly available an eligible improvement list that has been approved by the sponsoring public agency. The eligible improvement list must include the following information for each improvement:
- A name and description of the improvement.
- Eligibility criteria, including performance thresholds, certification requirements, and installation criteria.
- Expected useful life of the improvement.
Before placing a measure on the eligible improvement list, the program administrator must determine the improvement is both consistent with the scope of the PACE program and that it meets the standards that have been established by appropriate government agencies, such as the United States Department of Energy, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the California Energy Commission, or by appropriate private organizations that publish generally acceptable standards.
If approved by the sponsoring public agency, this bill allows a program administrator to offer a PACE assessment for an improvement not included on the eligible list if does either of the following:
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available an application process to permit a contractor or property owner to request a PACE assessment for a custom improvement.
- Establishes, maintains, and makes publicly available guidelines for the review and approval of a custom improvement.
A PACE assessment cannot be used for ancillary work unless the scope of the work is directly related to and necessary for the installation of an improvement and the cost of work does not exceed the cost of the eligible improvement.
Contractor oversight. A program administrator must not allow contractors or other third parties to advertise the availability of an assessment contract or solicit to property owners unless the contractor or third party maintains an appropriate license from the Contractors State Licensing Board, any local permits, and maintains the required bond and insurance coverage.
The program administrator must also obtain a written agreement from the contract or third party stating they will act in accordance with advertising and marketing laws.
Program administrators. This bill states that program administrator must not provide any cash payment to a contractor or third party in excess of the actual price charged to the property owner for the sale and installation of one or more improvements.
The program administrator must not provide any direct cash payment to a property owner entering into an assessment contract. The program administrator must not make any representation as to the tax deductibility of an assessment contract unless that representation is consistent with the statements or opinions on the tax treatment of the PACE assessment by the Internal Revenue Service or applicable state tax agency.
This measure specifies that the program administrator must not provide to a contractor or third party any information that discloses the maximum PACE assessment amount for which a property owner has been approved.
This bill does not prevent a program administrator from doing any of the following:
- Allowing a third party to close, fund, or administer an assessment contract.
- Securitizing its interest in bonds issued.
- Purchasing, selling, assigning, or taking assignment of an interest in bonds issued because of one or more assessment contracts or securities backed by assessment contracts.
Forbearance. SB 242 requires that upon presentation of an agreement of forbearance or payment holiday between a mortgage lender and a property owner, a program administrator must provide a payment forbearance of the PACE assessment for the same term as the mortgage lender in accordance with the administrator’s customary servicing practices, not to exceed a period of 12 months.
Reporting requirements. This bill requires that for each PACE program, the program administrator must submit a report annually to the sponsoring public agency. The report must contain the following information:
- The number of properties that received PACE assessments.
- The aggregate dollar amount of the PACE assessment received.
- The installed improvements.
- Rates of default and delinquency.
- Data pertaining to homeowner eligibility.
- Estimated amount of energy saving.
- Estimated amount of renewable energy produced.
- Estimated amount of water savings.
- Estimated amount of greenhouse gas emission reductions.
- Estimated number of jobs created.
SB 242 requires that all methodologies and supporting assumptions or sources relied upon in the report must be made available to the sponsoring public agency. All reports must only include aggregate data and not include any nonpublic personal information.
SB 242 declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that PACE programs to effectively meet their public purpose by enhancing requirements, guidelines, and procedures to which PACE programs administered by third parties must conform.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “With the growing use of PACE financing, last May PACE Nation, a non-profit representing PACE providers, local governments and environmental organizations, published a comprehensive set of recommended consumer protection policies for PACE. Additionally last November the Federal Department of Energy published Best Practices Guidelines for Residential PACE Programs. SB 242 incorporates many of the consumer protections and best practices recommended by PACE Nation and US DOE, including ensuring that projects financed achieve the intended public purposes, that PACE contractors are properly licensed, that consumers are properly evaluated for their ability to pay back the assessment, and that payment relief and protection is provided if the loan recipient faces temporary hardship. By doing so SB 242 will ensure that California’s PACE program continues to be a national leader.”
- Conflicts with existing law. AB 2693 instituted a number of consumer protections for residential PACE borrowers just last year. SB 242 builds upon these consumer protections by proposing the addition of new sections of law. However, these changes conflict with existing statute, including:
- SB 242 defines “assessment contract” as an agreement between one more owners of real property and a public agency. Existing law expressly requires all property owners of record on real property to approve an assessment contract.
- Creates a conflicting definition of “PACE assessment.”
- Uses a different methodology for determining a property’s market value.
- Requires the program administrator to give the consumer an oral confirmation of the key terms of the assessment contract but does not refer to the written disclosure, required by AB 2693, which must also be provided to the consumer.
Conflicts between SB 242 and existing law could create confusion when public agencies, program administrators, and contractors are managing PACE programs. This could ultimately undermine the PACE program and harm the consumer. The Committee may wish to consider amending SB 242 to make its provisions consistent with existing statute.
- Property tax forbearance. Property taxes, including any PACE assessment, are due on December 10 and April 10 of every year where the collected revenue is allocated to all other relevant taxing entities. Most other public agencies rely upon the collected property tax to provide services, including fire, health, police protection, and drinking water, among many others. SB 242 institutes a PACE assessment forbearance program where a property owner would not have to pay the assessment for up to 12 months. As written the bill is unclear whether the program administrator is required to pay the assessment on the property owner’s behalf or if the property owner is given a 12 month reprieve from paying the assessment to the county. If the latter, a widespread tax forbearance program does not currently exist, and establishing one could have far reaching consequences if individuals do not pay these taxes for an extended period of time. A very limited form of forbearance program exists under the Senior Citizens and Disabled Citizens Property Tax Postponement Law. However, this program does not stop the flow of revenues to local agencies as it allows the State Controller to pay property taxes to county tax collectors on behalf of individuals over the age of 62 or disabled persons making less than $35,500 in income per year. The Controller secures repayment by recording a lien against the claimant’s property, which is satisfied when the home is sold or refinanced. As liens are repaid out of sales proceeds, revenue flows back to the Controller, who in turn uses these funds to pay property taxes for new applicants. If not repaid in a timely manner, significant interest can accrue and property owners could eventually lose their property. Because SB 242’s forbearance program would potentially apply to significantly more property owners, and to avoid cuts to local government revenues, the Committee may wish to consider amending SB 242 to remove the PACE assessment forbearance program.
- Useful life. SB 242 uses the term “useful life” of an improvement on two occasions but does not define the meaning or which entities determine what “useful life” actually denotes. This ambiguity could lead to confusion or potential abuses when contractors describe a measure and the duration in which the energy or water efficiency improvement is estimated to last. The Committee may wish to consider amending SB 242 to define which entities and standards dictate the “useful life” of efficiency improvements.
- Financing information. SB 242 prohibits a program administrator from disclosing the maximum PACE assessment amount for which the property owner has been approved. This is a safeguard that protects the consumer from being oversold on efficiency improvements. For example, if a contractor knows the total amount in which a property owner may borrow, the contractor may sell improvements up to that amount that the property owner does not want or need. While this provision will help protect the consumer, information such as the amount of equity in the property could lead to overselling improvements to property owners. The Committee may wish to consider amending SB 242 to strengthen the prohibition against disclosing financial information to contractors.
- Underwriting. SB 242 requires the program administrator to underwrite each assessment contract but does not specify the underwriting standards that must be followed. No requirement to underwrite assessment contracts currently exists and is a point of contention between different stakeholders. While introducing the concept of underwriting, SB 242 is unclear if there should be a strict standard that all program administrators must follow or if they have general flexibility to make determinations on a case-by-case basis.
Support and Opposition
(4/14/17)
Support: Advanced Energy Economy; California Solar Energy Industries Association; California State Association of Counties; Center for Sustainable Energy; City of Indian Wells; City of Rancho Cucamonga; City of Thousand Oaks; Efficiency First California; League of California Cities; Natural Resources Defense Council; Renew Financial; Renovate America; Vote Solar; WattzOn.
Opposition: California Association of Treasurers and Tax Collectors.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Senate Floor
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):