AB 2123: District-based elections.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-06
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) prohibits the use of an at-large election in a political subdivision if it would impair the ability of a protected class, as defined, to elect candidates of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. The CVRA permits a voter who is a member of a protected class to bring an action in superior court to enforce the provisions of the CVRA. Before commencing an action, existing law requires a prospective plaintiff to send a written notice to the political subdivision asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. If the political subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition to district-based elections within a specified time, existing law prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
This bill would permit a political subdivision and a prospective plaintiff to enter into a written agreement to extend the time period during which a prospective plaintiff is prohibited from commencing an action for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The bill would require the written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than 6 months before the political subdivisions next regular election to select governing board members, except as specified. The bill would also require a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, no later than 10 days after entering into the agreement, to prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings to be held.
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) prohibits the use of an at-large election in a political subdivision if it would impair the ability of a protected class, as defined, to elect candidates of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. The CVRA permits a voter who is a member of a protected class to bring an action in superior court to enforce the provisions of the CVRA. Before commencing an action, existing law requires a prospective plaintiff to send a written notice to the political subdivision asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. If the political subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition to district-based elections within a specified time, existing law prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
This bill would permit a political subdivision and a prospective plaintiff to enter into a written agreement to extend the time period during which a prospective plaintiff is prohibited from commencing an action for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The bill would require the written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than 6 months before the political subdivisions next regular election to select governing board members, except as specified. The bill would also require a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, no later than 10 days after entering into the agreement, to prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings to be held.
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) prohibits the use of an at-large election in a political subdivision if it would impair the ability of a protected class, as defined, to elect candidates of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. The CVRA permits a voter who is a member of a protected class to bring an action in superior court to enforce the provisions of the CVRA. Before commencing an action, existing law requires a prospective plaintiff to send a written notice to the political subdivision asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. If the political subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition to district-based elections within a specified time, existing law prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
This bill would permit a political subdivision and a prospective plaintiff to enter into a written agreement to extend the time period during which a prospective plaintiff is prohibited from commencing an action for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The bill would require the written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than 6 months before the political subdivisions next general election. regular election to select governing board members, except as specified. The bill would also require a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, no later than 10 days after entering into the agreement, to prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings to be held.
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) prohibits the use of an at-large election in a political subdivision if it would impair the ability of a protected class, as defined, to elect candidates of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. The CVRA permits a voter who is a member of a protected class to bring an action in superior court to enforce the provisions of the CVRA. Before commencing an action, existing law requires a prospective plaintiff to send a written notice to the political subdivision asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. If the political subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition to district-based elections within a specified time, existing law prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
This bill would permit a political subdivision and a prospective plaintiff to enter into a written agreement to extend the time period during which a prospective plaintiff is prohibited from commencing an action for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The bill would require the written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than 6 months before the political subdivisions next general election. The bill would also require a political subdivision who entered that enters into a written agreement to prepare, agreement, no later than 10 days after entering into the agreement, to prepare and make available on its Internet Web site, site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings to be held.
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) prohibits the use of an at-large election in a political subdivision if it would impair the ability of a protected class, as defined, to elect candidates of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. The CVRA permits a voter who is a member of a protected class to bring an action in superior court to enforce the provisions of the CVRA. Before commencing an action, existing law requires a prospective plaintiff to send a written notice to the political subdivision asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. If the political subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition to district-based elections within a specified time, existing law prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
This bill would permit a political subdivision and a prospective plaintiff to enter into a written agreement to extend the time period during which a prospective plaintiff is prohibited from commencing an action for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The bill would require the written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than 6 months before the political subdivisions next general election. The bill would also require a political subdivision who entered into a written agreement to prepare, and make available on its Internet Web site, a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings to be held.
Existing law sets forth the procedures for military or overseas voters, as defined, to register to vote, apply for voting ballots, and vote. Existing law requires the Secretary of State to develop standardized military or overseas voter voting materials and prescribe the form and content of a declaration for use by military or overseas voters.This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.Existing law sets forth the procedures for military or overseas voters, as defined, to register to vote, apply for voting ballots, and vote. Existing law requires the Secretary of State to develop standardized military or overseas voter voting materials and prescribe the form and content of a declaration for use by military or overseas voters.
This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.
(a)A political subdivision that changes from an at-large method of election to a district-based election, or that establishes district-based elections, shall do all of the following before a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
(1)Before drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of the districts, the political subdivision shall hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the composition of the districts. Before these hearings, the political subdivision may conduct outreach to the public, including to non-English-speaking communities, to explain the districting process and to encourage public participation.
(2)After all draft maps are drawn, the political subdivision shall publish and make available for release at least one draft map and, if members of the governing body of the political subdivision will be elected in their districts at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the potential sequence of the elections. The political subdivision shall also hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the content of the draft map or maps and the proposed sequence of elections, if applicable. The first version of a draft map shall be published at least seven days before consideration at a hearing. If a draft map is revised at or following a hearing, it shall be published and made available to the public for at least seven days before being adopted.
(b)In determining the final sequence of the district elections conducted in a political subdivision in which members of the governing body will be elected at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the governing body shall give special consideration to the purposes of the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, and it shall take into account the preferences expressed by members of the districts.
(c)This section applies to, but is not limited to, a proposal that is required due to a court-imposed change from an at-large method of election to a district-based election.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)At-large method of election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 14026.
(2)District-based election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 14026.
(3)Political subdivision has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 14026.
(e)(1)Before commencing an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028, a prospective plaintiff shall send by certified mail a written notice to the clerk of the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the California Voting Rights Act of 2001.
(2)A prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 45 days of the political subdivisions receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Before receiving a written notice described in paragraph (1), or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, a political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, specific steps it will undertake to facilitate this transition, and an estimated time frame for doing so.
(B)If a political subdivision passes a resolution pursuant to subparagraph (A), a prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
(C)(i)A political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sends a notice pursuant to paragraph (1) may enter into a written agreement to extend the time period described in subparagraph (B) for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The written agreement shall include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next regular election to select governing board members. However, in a political subdivision that holds a primary election as part of its process for selecting governing board members, the written agreement shall include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next regular primary election.
(ii)No later than 10 days after a political subdivision enters into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i), the political subdivision shall prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings held pursuant to this section. If a political subdivision does not maintain an Internet Web site, the political subdivision shall make the tentative schedule available to the public upon request.
(f)(1)If a political subdivision adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections pursuant to subdivision (a), a prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) before the political subdivision passed its resolution of intention may, within 30 days of the ordinances adoption, demand reimbursement for the cost of the work product generated to support the notice. A prospective plaintiff shall make the demand in writing and shall substantiate the demand with financial documentation, such as a detailed invoice for demography services. A political subdivision may request additional documentation if the provided documentation is insufficient to corroborate the claimed costs. A political subdivision shall reimburse a prospective plaintiff for reasonable costs claimed, or in an amount to which the parties mutually agree, within 45 days of receiving the written demand, except as provided in paragraph (2). In all cases, the amount of the reimbursement shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(2)If more than one prospective plaintiff is entitled to reimbursement, the political subdivision shall reimburse the prospective plaintiffs in the order in which they sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e), and the 45-day time period described in paragraph (1) shall apply only to reimbursement of the first prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice. The cumulative amount of reimbursements to all prospective plaintiffs shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(3)The amount of reimbursement required by this section is capped at $30,000, as adjusted annually to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, United States city average, as published by the United States Department of Labor.
(a)A political subdivision that changes from an at-large method of election to a district-based election, or that establishes district-based elections, shall do all of the following before a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
(1)Before drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of the districts, the political subdivision shall hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the composition of the districts. Before these hearings, the political subdivision may conduct outreach to the public, including to non-English-speaking communities, to explain the districting process and to encourage public participation.
(2)After all draft maps are drawn, the political subdivision shall publish and make available for release at least one draft map and, if members of the governing body of the political subdivision will be elected in their districts at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the potential sequence of the elections. The political subdivision shall also hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the content of the draft map or maps and the proposed sequence of elections, if applicable. The first version of a draft map shall be published at least seven days before consideration at a hearing. If a draft map is revised at or following a hearing, it shall be published and made available to the public for at least seven days before being adopted.
(b)In determining the final sequence of the district elections conducted in a political subdivision in which members of the governing body will be elected at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the governing body shall give special consideration to the purposes of the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, and it shall take into account the preferences expressed by members of the districts.
(c)This section applies to, but is not limited to, a proposal that is required due to a court-imposed change from an at-large method of election to a district-based election.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)At-large method of election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 14026.
(2)District-based election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 14026.
(3)Political subdivision has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 14026.
(e)(1)Before commencing an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028, a prospective plaintiff shall send by certified mail a written notice to the clerk of the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the California Voting Rights Act of 2001.
(2)A prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 45 days of the political subdivisions receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Before receiving a written notice described in paragraph (1), or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, a political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, specific steps it will undertake to facilitate this transition, and an estimated time frame for doing so.
(B)If a political subdivision passes a resolution pursuant to subparagraph (A), a prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
(C)(i)A political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sends a notice pursuant to paragraph (1) may enter into a written agreement to extend the time period described in subparagraph (B) for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The written agreement shall include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next regular election to select governing board members. However, in a political subdivision that holds a primary election as part of its process for selecting governing board members, the written agreement shall include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next regular primary election.
(ii)No later than 10 days after a political subdivision enters into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i), the political subdivision shall prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings held pursuant to this section. If a political subdivision does not maintain an Internet Web site, the political subdivision shall make the tentative schedule available to the public upon request.
(f)(1)If a political subdivision adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections pursuant to subdivision (a), a prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) before the political subdivision passed its resolution of intention may, within 30 days of the ordinances adoption, demand reimbursement for the cost of the work product generated to support the notice. A prospective plaintiff shall make the demand in writing and shall substantiate the demand with financial documentation, such as a detailed invoice for demography services. A political subdivision may request additional documentation if the provided documentation is insufficient to corroborate the claimed costs. A political subdivision shall reimburse a prospective plaintiff for reasonable costs claimed, or in an amount to which the parties mutually agree, within 45 days of receiving the written demand, except as provided in paragraph (2). In all cases, the amount of the reimbursement shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(2)If more than one prospective plaintiff is entitled to reimbursement, the political subdivision shall reimburse the prospective plaintiffs in the order in which they sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e), and the 45-day time period described in paragraph (1) shall apply only to reimbursement of the first prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice. The cumulative amount of reimbursements to all prospective plaintiffs shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(3)The amount of reimbursement required by this section is capped at $30,000, as adjusted annually to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, United States city average, as published by the United States Department of Labor.
(a)A political subdivision that changes from an at-large method of election to a district-based election, or that establishes district-based elections, shall do all of the following before a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
(1)Before drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of the districts, the political subdivision shall hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the composition of the districts. Before these hearings, the political subdivision may conduct outreach to the public, including to non-English-speaking communities, to explain the districting process and to encourage public participation.
(2)After all draft maps are drawn, the political subdivision shall publish and make available for release at least one draft map and, if members of the governing body of the political subdivision will be elected in their districts at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the potential sequence of the elections. The political subdivision shall also hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the content of the draft map or maps and the proposed sequence of elections, if applicable. The first version of a draft map shall be published at least seven days before consideration at a hearing. If a draft map is revised at or following a hearing, it shall be published and made available to the public for at least seven days before being adopted.
(b)In determining the final sequence of the district elections conducted in a political subdivision in which members of the governing body will be elected at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the governing body shall give special consideration to the purposes of the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, and it shall take into account the preferences expressed by members of the districts.
(c)This section applies to, but is not limited to, a proposal that is required due to a court-imposed change from an at-large method of election to a district-based election.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)At-large method of election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 14026.
(2)District-based election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 14026.
(3)Political subdivision has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 14026.
(e)(1)Before commencing an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028, a prospective plaintiff shall send by certified mail a written notice to the clerk of the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the California Voting Rights Act of 2001.
(2)A prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 45 days of the political subdivisions receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Before receiving a written notice described in paragraph (1), or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, a political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, specific steps it will undertake to facilitate this transition, and an estimated time frame for doing so.
(B)If a political subdivision passes a resolution pursuant to subparagraph (A), a prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
(C)(i)A political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sends a notice pursuant to paragraph (1) may enter into a written agreement to extend the time period described in subparagraph (B) for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The written agreement shall include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next general election. regular election to select governing board members. However, in a political subdivision that holds a primary election as part of its process for selecting governing board members, the written agreement shall include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next regular primary election.
(ii)No later than 10 days after a political subdivision enters into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i), the political subdivision shall prepare and make available on its Internet Web site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings held pursuant to this section. If a political subdivision does not maintain an Internet Web site, the political subdivision shall make the tentative schedule available to the public upon request.
(iii)This subparagraph applies only to a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement for a time extension pursuant to clause (i) when changing from at-large to district-based elections.(f)(1)If a political subdivision adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections pursuant to subdivision (a), a prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) before the political subdivision passed its resolution of intention may, within 30 days of the ordinances adoption, demand reimbursement for the cost of the work product generated to support the notice. A prospective plaintiff shall make the demand in writing and shall substantiate the demand with financial documentation, such as a detailed invoice for demography services. A political subdivision may request additional documentation if the provided documentation is insufficient to corroborate the claimed costs. A political subdivision shall reimburse a prospective plaintiff for reasonable costs claimed, or in an amount to which the parties mutually agree, within 45 days of receiving the written demand, except as provided in paragraph (2). In all cases, the amount of the reimbursement shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(2)If more than one prospective plaintiff is entitled to reimbursement, the political subdivision shall reimburse the prospective plaintiffs in the order in which they sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e), and the 45-day time period described in paragraph (1) shall apply only to reimbursement of the first prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice. The cumulative amount of reimbursements to all prospective plaintiffs shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(3)The amount of reimbursement required by this section is capped at $30,000, as adjusted annually to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, United States city average, as published by the United States Department of Labor.
(a)A political subdivision that changes from an at-large method of election to a district-based election, or that establishes district-based elections, shall do all of the following before a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
(1)Before drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of the districts, the political subdivision shall hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the composition of the districts. Before these hearings, the political subdivision may conduct outreach to the public, including to non-English-speaking communities, to explain the districting process and to encourage public participation.
(2)After all draft maps are drawn, the political subdivision shall publish and make available for release at least one draft map and, if members of the governing body of the political subdivision will be elected in their districts at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the potential sequence of the elections. The political subdivision shall also hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the content of the draft map or maps and the proposed sequence of elections, if applicable. The first version of a draft map shall be published at least seven days before consideration at a hearing. If a draft map is revised at or following a hearing, it shall be published and made available to the public for at least seven days before being adopted.
(b)In determining the final sequence of the district elections conducted in a political subdivision in which members of the governing body will be elected at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the governing body shall give special consideration to the purposes of the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, and it shall take into account the preferences expressed by members of the districts.
(c)This section applies to, but is not limited to, a proposal that is required due to a court-imposed change from an at-large method of election to a district-based election.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)At-large method of election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 14026.
(2)District-based election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 14026.
(3)Political subdivision has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 14026.
(e)(1)Before commencing an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028, a prospective plaintiff shall send by certified mail a written notice to the clerk of the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the California Voting Rights Act of 2001.
(2)A prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 45 days of the political subdivisions receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Before receiving a written notice described in paragraph (1), or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, a political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, specific steps it will undertake to facilitate this transition, and an estimated time frame for doing so.
(B)If a political subdivision passes a resolution pursuant to subparagraph (A), a prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
(C)(i)A political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sends a notice pursuant to paragraph (1) may enter into a written agreement to extend the time period described in subparagraph (B) for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The written agreement shall include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next general election.
(ii)A No later than 10 days after a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i) (i), the political subdivision shall prepare, prepare and shall make available on its Internet Web site, site a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings held pursuant to this section. If a political subdivision does not maintain an Internet Web site, the political subdivision shall make the tentative schedule available to the public upon request.
(iii)This subparagraph applies only to a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement for a time extension pursuant to clause (i) when changing from at-large to district-based elections.
(f)(1)If a political subdivision adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections pursuant to subdivision (a), a prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) before the political subdivision passed its resolution of intention may, within 30 days of the ordinances adoption, demand reimbursement for the cost of the work product generated to support the notice. A prospective plaintiff shall make the demand in writing and shall substantiate the demand with financial documentation, such as a detailed invoice for demography services. A political subdivision may request additional documentation if the provided documentation is insufficient to corroborate the claimed costs. A political subdivision shall reimburse a prospective plaintiff for reasonable costs claimed, or in an amount to which the parties mutually agree, within 45 days of receiving the written demand, except as provided in paragraph (2). In all cases, the amount of the reimbursement shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(2)If more than one prospective plaintiff is entitled to reimbursement, the political subdivision shall reimburse the prospective plaintiffs in the order in which they sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e), and the 45-day time period described in paragraph (1) shall apply only to reimbursement of the first prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice. The cumulative amount of reimbursements to all prospective plaintiffs shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(3)The amount of reimbursement required by this section is capped at $30,000, as adjusted annually to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, United States city average, as published by the United States Department of Labor.
(a)A political subdivision that changes from an at-large method of election to a district-based election, or that establishes district-based elections, shall do all of the following before a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
(1)Before drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of the districts, the political subdivision shall hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the composition of the districts. Before these hearings, the political subdivision may conduct outreach to the public, including to non-English-speaking communities, to explain the districting process and to encourage public participation.
(2)After all draft maps are drawn, the political subdivision shall publish and make available for release at least one draft map and, if members of the governing body of the political subdivision will be elected in their districts at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the potential sequence of the elections. The political subdivision shall also hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days, at which the public is invited to provide input regarding the content of the draft map or maps and the proposed sequence of elections, if applicable. The first version of a draft map shall be published at least seven days before consideration at a hearing. If a draft map is revised at or following a hearing, it shall be published and made available to the public for at least seven days before being adopted.
(b)In determining the final sequence of the district elections conducted in a political subdivision in which members of the governing body will be elected at different times to provide for staggered terms of office, the governing body shall give special consideration to the purposes of the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, and it shall take into account the preferences expressed by members of the districts.
(c)This section applies to, but is not limited to, a proposal that is required due to a court-imposed change from an at-large method of election to a district-based election.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)At-large method of election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 14026.
(2)District-based election has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (b) of Section 14026.
(3)Political subdivision has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 14026.
(e)(1)Before commencing an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028, a prospective plaintiff shall send by certified mail a written notice to the clerk of the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivisions method of conducting elections may violate the California Voting Rights Act of 2001.
(2)A prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 45 days of the political subdivisions receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Before receiving a written notice described in paragraph (1), or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, a political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, specific steps it will undertake to facilitate this transition, and an estimated time frame for doing so.
(B)If a political subdivision passes a resolution pursuant to subparagraph (A), a prospective plaintiff shall not commence an action to enforce Sections 14027 and 14028 within 90 days of the resolutions passage.
(C)(i)A political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sends a notice pursuant to paragraph (1) may enter into a written agreement to extend the time period described in subparagraph (B) for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. The written agreement shall include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivisions next general election.
(ii)A political subdivision that enters into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i) shall prepare, and shall make available on its Internet Web site, a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings held pursuant to this section. If a political subdivision does not maintain an Internet Web site, the political subdivision shall make the tentative schedule available to the public upon request.
(iii)This subparagraph applies only to a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement for a time extension pursuant to clause (i) when changing from at-large to district-based elections.
(f)(1)If a political subdivision adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections pursuant to subdivision (a), a prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) before the political subdivision passed its resolution of intention may, within 30 days of the ordinances adoption, demand reimbursement for the cost of the work product generated to support the notice. A prospective plaintiff shall make the demand in writing and shall substantiate the demand with financial documentation, such as a detailed invoice for demography services. A political subdivision may request additional documentation if the provided documentation is insufficient to corroborate the claimed costs. A political subdivision shall reimburse a prospective plaintiff for reasonable costs claimed, or in an amount to which the parties mutually agree, within 45 days of receiving the written demand, except as provided in paragraph (2). In all cases, the amount of the reimbursement shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(2)If more than one prospective plaintiff is entitled to reimbursement, the political subdivision shall reimburse the prospective plaintiffs in the order in which they sent a written notice pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e), and the 45-day time period described in paragraph (1) shall apply only to reimbursement of the first prospective plaintiff who sent a written notice. The cumulative amount of reimbursements to all prospective plaintiffs shall not exceed the cap described in paragraph (3).
(3)The amount of reimbursement required by this section is capped at $30,000, as adjusted annually to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, United States city average, as published by the United States Department of Labor.
SECTION 1.Section 3101 of the Elections Code is amended to read:3101.(a)The Secretary of State shall see that this chapter is enforced pursuant to Section 12172.5 of the Government Code.(b)The Secretary of State shall make available to a person who qualifies as a military or overseas voter information regarding voter registration procedures for military or overseas voters and procedures for casting ballots by military or overseas voters.(c)The elections official for each district shall ensure that his or her jurisdiction has available a system that would allow a military or overseas voter to electronically request and receive a vote by mail ballot application, an unvoted ballot, and other information pursuant to this chapter.(d)The Secretary of State shall develop standardized military or overseas voter voting materials as required by this chapter.(e)The Secretary of State shall prescribe the form and content of a declaration for use by a military or overseas voter to swear or affirm specific representations pertaining to the voters identity, eligibility to vote, and status as a military or overseas voter, and shall further prescribe requirements for the timely and proper completion of a military or overseas voters ballot. The declaration shall be based on the declaration prescribed to accompany a federal write-in absentee ballot, as modified to be consistent with this chapter. The elections official for each jurisdiction shall ensure that a form for the execution of the declaration, including an indication of the date of execution of the declaration, is a prominent part of all balloting materials for which the declaration is required.(a)The Secretary of State shall see that this chapter is enforced pursuant to Section 12172.5 of the Government Code.
(b)The Secretary of State shall make available to any a person who qualifies as a military or overseas voter information regarding voter registration procedures for military or overseas voters and procedures for casting ballots by military or overseas voters.
(c)The elections official for each district shall ensure that his or her jurisdiction has available a system that would allow a military or overseas voter to electronically request and receive a vote by mail ballot application, an unvoted ballot, and other information pursuant to this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State shall develop standardized military or overseas voter voting materials as required by this chapter.
(e)The Secretary of State shall prescribe the form and content of a declaration for use by a military or overseas voter to swear or affirm specific representations pertaining to the voters identity, eligibility to vote, and status as a military or overseas voter, and shall further prescribe requirements for the timely and proper completion of a military or overseas voters ballot. The declaration shall be based on the declaration prescribed to accompany a federal write-in absentee ballot, as modified to be consistent with this chapter. The elections official for each jurisdiction shall ensure that a form for the execution of the declaration, including an indication of the date of execution of the declaration, is a prominent part of all balloting materials for which the declaration is required.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 6, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 277, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 6, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 20, 2018 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 20, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jul 5, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (July 3). |
| Jun 20, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 24, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A. and JUD. |
| May 10, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 10, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 9, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (May 8). |
| May 1, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 17, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 11). |
| Apr 3, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on E. & R. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E. & R. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on E. & R. |
| Mar 20, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E. & R. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on E. & R. and JUD. |
| Feb 9, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 11. |
| Feb 8, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2123 Cervantes By Cannella | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2018 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| May 10, 2018 | AB 2123 CERVANTES Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2123
:
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/19/18
AYES: Stern, Anderson, Allen, Hertzberg, Leyva
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 7/3/18
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-3, 5/10/18 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend the deadline by up to 90 days for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system in accordance with the California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA).
Existing law:
- Prohibits, pursuant to the CVRA, an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or its ability to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of a protected class.
- Requires a court, upon finding a violation of the CVRA, to implement appropriate remedies, including the imposition of district-based elections, which are tailored to remedy the violation.
- Permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and who resides in a political subdivision where a violation of the CVRA is alleged to file an action in the superior court of the county in which the political subdivision is located.
- Requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivision’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. Prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the written notice.
- Permits a political subdivision, before receiving a written notice described above or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, as specified. Prohibits a prospective plaintiff from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of such a resolution.
- Requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- After draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and,
- After publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps, as specified.
- Permits a prospective plaintiff to receive reimbursement from a political subdivision for the work product generated to support a written notice, as described above, if that notice was sent to the political subdivision before it passed its resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, and the subdivision subsequently adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections, as specified. Caps the amount of reimbursement at $30,000, as adjusted annually to reflect inflation, as specified. Based on the inflation measurement specified in existing law, the current cap on reimbursement is approximately $30,650.
- Requires a jurisdictional boundary change to be made at least 125 days prior to an election in order for that boundary change to be in effect for that election.
This bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that first sends the subdivision a specified pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision's method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that the subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA.
- Allows the agreement to extend the time period for up to 90 days to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires such a written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision's next regular election to select governing board members, as specified.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
Background
California Voting Rights Act of 2001. SB 976 (Polanco, Chapter 129, Statutes of 2002) enacted the CVRA to address racial block voting in at-large elections for local office in California. In areas where racial block voting occurs, an at-large method of election can dilute the voting rights of minority communities if the majority typically votes to support candidates that differ from the candidates who are preferred by minority communities. In such situations, breaking a jurisdiction up into districts can result in districts in which a minority community can elect the candidate of its choice or otherwise have the ability to influence the outcome of an election. Accordingly, the CVRA prohibits an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class.
The first case brought under the CVRA was filed in 2004, and the jurisdiction that was the target of that case -- the City of Modesto -- challenged the constitutionality of the law. Ultimately, the City of Modesto appealed that case all the way to the United States Supreme Court, which rejected the city's appeal in October 2007. The legal uncertainty surrounding the CVRA may have limited the impacts of that law in the first five years after its passage.
Since the case in Modesto was resolved, however, many local jurisdictions have converted or are in the process of converting from an at-large method of election to district-based elections due to the CVRA. In all, at least 200 local government bodies have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections since the enactment of the CVRA. While some jurisdictions did so in response to litigation or threats of litigation, other jurisdictions proactively changed election methods because they believed they could be susceptible to a legal challenge under the CVRA, and they wished to avoid the potential expense of litigation.
Prior legislation. At the time the CVRA was enacted, local government bodies generally were required to receive voter approval to move from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election for selecting governing board members. That voter approval requirement made it difficult for jurisdictions to proactively transition to district-based elections to address potential liability under the CVRA. If a jurisdiction attempted to transition from at-large to district-based elections to address CVRA concerns, but the voters rejected the proposal, the jurisdiction nonetheless would remain subject to a lawsuit under the CVRA. Furthermore, to the extent that there was racially polarized voting on the question of whether to transition from at-large to district-based elections, the results of the vote on that question could provide further evidence for a lawsuit under the CVRA.
As the number of jurisdictions that faced lawsuits or threats of lawsuits under the CVRA increased, many jurisdictions sought ways to transition from at-large to district-based elections without having to receive voter approval for such a change. Most notably, many school districts have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval in an effort to avoid potential liability under the CVRA. Even though state law generally requires such a transition to be approved by the voters in a school district, existing law also permits the State Board of Education (SBE) to waive all or part of any section of the Education Code, with certain identified exceptions, upon request by the governing board of a school district or county board of education. The SBE generally is required to approve any and all requests for waivers unless it makes a finding that one of seven enumerated conditions exists. Since 2009, the SBE has approved waivers to permit approximately 158 school districts to change from at-large to district elections without receiving voter approval, as would otherwise be required by the Education Code.
In response to concerns that community college districts were subject to liability under the CVRA but were unable to change from at-large to district-based elections without voter approval, AB 684 (Block, Chapter 614, Statutes of 2011) established a process under which a community college district could transition from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval if such a transition was approved by the Board of Governors (BOG) of the California Community Colleges, among other provisions. Since the enactment of AB 684, the BOG has approved requests from approximately 28 community college districts to change from at-large to district elections.
During the 2015-2016 Legislative Session, the Legislature took further steps to facilitate transitions from at-large to district elections. Specifically, SB 493 (Cannella, Chapter 735, Statutes of 2015) permitted a city with a population of fewer than 100,000 people to change the method of electing council members to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval if such a change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA. AB 278 (R. Hernandez, Chapter 736, Statutes of 2016) expanded on SB 493 by allowing any city, regardless of population, to change from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval. Similarly, AB 2389 (Ridley-Thomas, Chapter 754, Statutes of 2016) permitted a special district to change the method of electing its governing board members from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval, if the change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA.
In addition to taking steps to make it easier for local governments to comply with the CVRA by transitioning from at-large to district based elections, the Legislature also enacted new laws designed to encourage greater public participation in that process, and to provide a more formal mechanism for prospective plaintiffs and local jurisdictions to address at-large election systems that are potentially unlawful under the CVRA prior to litigation being filed. Specifically, AB 1440 (Campos, Chapter 873, Statutes of 2014) required any political subdivision that was switching from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election to hold at least two public hearings on the proposed district boundaries prior to adopting those boundaries, among other provisions.
More recently, AB 350 (Alejo, Chapter 737, Statutes of 2016) required a political subdivision that changed to, or established, district-based elections to hold at least two public hearings both before and after drawing a preliminary map or maps of the proposed district boundaries, as specified. Additionally, AB 350 required that written notice be provided before an action can be brought against a political subdivision under the CVRA, and capped the amount of attorney’s fees that a prospective plaintiff could recover from a political subdivision under the CVRA if the subdivision promptly transitioned from an at-large to a district-based method of election upon receiving such a written notice.
Under the provisions of AB 350, once a jurisdiction receives a written notice from a prospective plaintiff alleging that the jurisdiction’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA, the jurisdiction has 45 days to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections (a jurisdiction may also choose to enact such a resolution before receiving any such written notice). If a jurisdiction has passed such a resolution, no legal action may be filed against the jurisdiction alleging a CVRA violation within 90 days of the resolution’s passage. To take full advantage of the cap on attorney’s fees to prospective plaintiffs that is provided in AB 350, a jurisdiction would have a maximum of 135 days (45 days to pass a resolution plus 90 days to adopt districts) from the time it received a written notice from the prospective plaintiffs until it had to finalize the new district boundaries.
This bill allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sent a written notice to that political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend the time period during which no legal action could be filed against the political subdivision for up to an additional 90 days (for a total of 180 days).
While nothing in existing law prevents a prospective plaintiff from reaching a voluntary agreement with a political subdivision to refrain from filing a CVRA lawsuit while that subdivision takes steps to adopt a district-based method of election, such a voluntary agreement would not prevent any other prospective plaintiff from filing such a lawsuit once more than 90 days elapsed after the jurisdiction passed a resolution indicating its intent to transition from at-large to district-based elections. This bill effectively allows the prospective plaintiff that first sent a written notice in accordance with the procedures outlined in AB 350 to reach an agreement with the jurisdiction that would prevent any plaintiff from filing a lawsuit for up to 180 days after the jurisdiction’s adoption of the resolution. To ensure that such an agreement does not delay relief from a method of election that is unlawful under the CVRA, this bill allows such agreements only if they include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the jurisdiction’s next general election.
Comments
According to the author, in recent years, many local governments in California have been subject to litigation alleging that their existing at-large election systems violate CVRA. The enactment of AB 350 established a framework which governs local governments’ transitions from at-large to district-based elections.
However, after the enactment of AB 350, local governments and voting rights organizations have both found that additional time is often needed to implement a successful transition to district-based elections. With additional time to mobilize, underrepresented communities would be better equipped to advocate for their interests in the drawing of district boundaries. Additional time would also allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn.
AB 2123 builds upon the existing framework by providing for a mutually agreed-upon extension of up to 90 additional days to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections. During this time extension, the existing AB 350 prohibition against commencing CVRA litigation against a local government due to its at-large election system would also be extended.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2231 (Brough, 2018) would have made numerous significant changes to the CVRA that generally would make it harder for plaintiffs to successfully challenge at-large voting systems under the CVRA. AB 2231 failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
AB 2432 (Obernolte, 2018) prohibits a court from imposing district-based elections upon a finding of a violation of the CVRA unless the plaintiff has established that the district-based elections would remedy the dilution or abridgment of voting rights and that alternatives to district-based elections would not achieve greater voting rights and other benefits. The hearing for AB 2432 in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting was canceled by the author.
(NOTE: See the Background section, above, for a discussion of prior legislation related to this bill.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Advancement Project
American Civil Liberties Union of California Center for Advocacy and Policy
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
California Common Cause
League of California Cities
League of California Cities, Los Angeles County Division
League of California Cities, Riverside County Division
Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund
OPPOSITION: (Verified 7/16/18)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-3, 5/10/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Gallagher, Harper, Kiley
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson
8/1/18 14:11:58
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2123 (Author:Cervantes)
Version: April 17, 2018
Hearing Date: July 3, 2018
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
District-based elections
DESCRIPTION
This bill would permit a prospective plaintiff in a California Voting Rights Act case, and the political subdivision that would be subject to the lawsuit, to agree on up to a 90 day extension of the time for the political subdivision to transition from an at-large to a district-based elections system, where the political subdivision has passed a resolution indicating its intent to make such a transition.
BACKGROUND
In “at-large” elections, candidates for public office are elected by voters from the entire jurisdiction. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(a).) In a “district-based” election, voters from each district cast their ballots only for candidates who reside in that district and are running to represent that district. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(b).) Where there is a big subgroup of voters within a jurisdiction, but that subgroup does not constitute the overall majority of the jurisdiction, at-large elections will prevent the subgroup from having any representation among the people elected to office; while district-based elections greatly increase the chance that the subgroup will be represented, depending somewhat on how the district lines are drawn.
In Thornburg v. Gingles (1986) 478 U.S. 30, the United States Supreme Court ruled that when at-large elections prevent racial subgroups from obtaining representation among elected officials, such at-large elections violate the U.S. Constitution and the federal Voting Rights Act, because they dilute voting power and representation based on race.
The California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) of 2001 (Polanco, Ch. 129, Stats. 2002) expanded upon this concept. In California, the CVRA prohibits local jurisdictions from using at-large elections when that method impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election. (Elec. Code 14027.) For purposes of the CVRA, a “protected class” is one defined by race, color, or language minority group. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(d).)
The CVRA contains a private right of action. Voters who are members of an aggrieved protected class may sue the local jurisdictions they reside in, if that jurisdiction uses at-large elections. (Elec. Code Sec. 14032.) If those voters can establish that the at-large elections violate the CVRA by diluting the voting power of their protected class, then the voters are entitled to a court order remedying the situation, including a requirement that the local jurisdiction transition to district-based elections. (Elec. Code Sec. 14029.) Plaintiffs prevailing on a CVRA claim are also entitled to an attorney’s fees award as well. (Elec. Code Sec. Sec. 14030.)
Through this private right of action, numerous Californians have brought suit against their local jurisdictions to challenge at-large elections methods. Whether the plaintiffs prevailed or the local jurisdictions agreed to switch to district-based elections in order to settle the cases, the plaintiffs’ attorneys often obtained hefty attorney fee awards. In part because of this, an increasing number of local jurisdictions began to try to transition from at-large to district-based elections proactively, before being confronted with CVRA lawsuits.
Initially, however, many of these local jurisdictions encountered barriers to making the transition proactively. In particular, in many instances, making the transition from at-large elections to district-based elections required approval from the voters, through the very method that was the source of the potential lawsuit to begin with. The jurisdictions could wait to transition until ordered to do so by a court, of course, but they would incur liability for significant attorney’s fees in the process.
In response to this problem, the Legislature enacted a series of laws that facilitate a local jurisdiction’s ability to transition from at-large to district-based elections. Among other things, cities can now transition to district-based elections by passing an ordinance, without the need for voter approval. At the same time, the Legislature sought to spur greater public consultation in the formation of districts during the transition to district-based election. (See Prior Related Legislation, below, for details on the specific legislation summarized here.)
These three themes – facilitating proactive compliance with CVRA, avoiding exorbitant attorney’s fees awards, and encouraging community participation – came together in the form of AB 350 (Alejo, Ch. 737, Stats. 2016). AB 350 enacted three major changes to the procedures around CVRA lawsuits and transitions from at-large to district-based elections. First, it required jurisdictions proposing to transition from at-large to district-based elections to hold two sets of consultations with the public: one prior to drawing maps and rules for the new district-based elections, and another once draft rules and maps have been drawn up for consideration. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(a).) Second, AB 350
required plaintiffs interested in suing a jurisdiction for violating the CVRA to provide the jurisdiction with notice of their intent to sue in advance, triggering a 45 day period in which the jurisdiction can avoid the lawsuit by passing a resolution agreeing to transition to district-based elections and laying out steps for doing so. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(e).) Finally, AB 350 provided that, if a jurisdiction agrees to transition to district-based elections, then the prospective plaintiff who had notified the jurisdiction of the plaintiff’s intent to sue may still recover attorney’s fees, but only up to a maximum of $30,000 as adjusted by inflation. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(f).)
Of particular relevance to this bill, AB 350 set out a timeline for jurisdictions to complete the transition to district-based elections once they pass a resolution agreeing to do so in response to notice of a prospective plaintiff’s intent to sue under CVRA. Specifically, no legal action based on the CVRA may be filed against the jurisdiction within 90 days of the resolution’s passage.
Given AB 350’s requirement that the jurisdiction conduct multiple public hearings in connection with the transition to district-based voting, however, this 90 day window is quite narrow. According to the author and proponents of the bill, more time may be needed in many instances, especially in order to conduct the sort of robust outreach that would result in genuine public participation in the community consultations mandated by AB 350.
With all of this in mind, this bill would allow a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sent a written notice to that political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend the time period during which no legal action could be filed against the political subdivision for up to an additional 90 days. If this bill is enacted, therefore, a jurisdiction voluntarily transitioning from at-large to district based elections could potentially have as many as 180 days to complete the process.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, under the 15th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, provides that the rights of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of race, color, or previous condition or servitude. (U.S. Const., Amend. XV)
Existing federal law, under the federal Voting Rights Act, states that no voting qualification or prerequisite to voting or standard, practice, or procedure shall be imposed or applied by any State or political subdivision in a manner which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizens of the United States to vote on account of race or color, or language minority group. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 1973 et seq.)
Existing state law defines an “at-large method of election” as one which: (1) members of the governing body are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; (2) candidates are required to reside in an election district and are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; or (3) an at-large election method is combined with a district-based election. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(a).)
Existing state law defines a “district-based method of election” as one in which candidates are required to reside in an election district (a divisible part of the political subdivision) and elected only by voters residing within that election district. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(b).)
Existing state law, under the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA), establishes that an at-large election method may not impair the ability of a protected class, defined as a class of voters who are members of a race, color, or language minority group, to elect candidates of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of dilution or abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class. (Elec. Code Secs. 14026(d) and 14207.)
Existing state law defines “racially polarized voting” as voting in which there is a difference in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters of the protected class and in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters in the rest of the electorate. (Elec. Code Sec. 14026(e).)
Existing state law provides that a violation of the CVRA is established if racially polarized voting occurs in an election of members to the governing body of a political subdivision or in elections incorporating other electoral choices by voters of the political subdivision. (Elec. Code Sec. 14028.)
Existing state law provides that upon a violation of the CVRA, the court shall implement appropriate remedies that are tailored to remediate the violation, including the imposition of district-based elections. (Elec. Code Sec. 14029.)
Existing state law permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and who resides in the political subdivision where a violation has occurred to file an action in superior court alleging violation of the CVRA. (Elec. Code Sec. 14032.)
Existing state law entitles the prevailing plaintiff in a CVRA action to reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses, while costs only may be awarded to a prevailing defendant only upon a finding that the suit was frivolous or unreasonable. (Elec. Code Sec. 14030.)
Existing state law requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the relevant political subdivision and prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the notice. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(e)(1) and (2).)
Existing state law permits a political subdivision to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections in response to a notice of intent to sue under the CVRA from a prospective plaintiff and prohibits anyone from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of such a resolution. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(e) and (f).)
Existing state law requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts;
- after draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and
- after publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps. (Elec. Code Sec. 10010(a) and (c).)
This bill would allow a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that first sent a pre-litigation notice of intent to sue under the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend, for up to a period of 90 days, the amount of time between when the jurisdiction passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from an at-large to a district-based elections system and the moment that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA.
This bill would mandate that an agreement to extend the time between passage of a resolution to transition to district-based elections and commencement of a CVRA lawsuit must include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision’s next general election.
This bill would require a political subdivision that enters into an extension pursuant to this bill to prepare and make available on its website, within 10 days of the execution of the written agreement, a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings that the jurisdiction will hold. If the jurisdiction has no Web site, the schedule shall be available from the jurisdiction upon request.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
In recent years, many local governments in California have been subject to litigation alleging that their existing at-large election systems violate the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA). The enactment of AB 350 (Alejo, 2016) established a framework which governs local governments’ transitions from at-large to district-based elections.
However, after the enactment of AB 350, local governments and voting rights organizations have both found that additional time is often needed to implement a successful transition to district-based elections. With additional time to mobilize, underrepresented communities would be better equipped to advocate for their interests in the drawing of district boundaries. Additional time would also allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn.
AB 2123 would build upon the existing framework by providing for a mutually agreed-upon extension of up to 90 additional days to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections. During this time extension, the existing AB 350 prohibition against commencing CVRA litigation against a local government due to its at-large election system would also be extended.
In support of the bill, the Mexican American Legal Defense Fund writes:
[E]xperience has shown that the short timeline for completing districting remains a barrier keeping some communities from fully engaging in the process. Underrepresented communities are often, because of their historical disenfranchisement, among the least politically engaged communities in a jurisdiction. As a result, it can be very difficult, in only the 90 days allowed under law, for a local government or civil rights or community-based organizations to identify these underrepresented communities, educate them about districting and its importance, and encourage and facilitate their participation in the process.
In further support of the bill, the League of California Cities writes:
The by-ordinance option allows cities to be proactive and quickly switch to district elections before a lawsuit is brought. This process is much quicker and less expensive than placing the question on the ballot for voter approval.
The League supports increased civic outreach and is committed to encouraging our cities to provide outreach to minority and non-English speaking communities throughout this process. AB 2123 will boost outreach efforts to all communities. By providing additional time for a city to convert to districts, cities are incentivized to work with all stakeholders on district conversion through increased public outreach without the fear of soaring legal fees.
2. Why a statute is needed to allow for a mutually agreed upon extension
This bill would enable a prospective CVRA plaintiff and the jurisdiction that is allegedly in violation to enter into a voluntary agreement extending the time that the jurisdiction has before the prospective plaintiff can file suit in court. On quick review, it may seem strange that a statute would be required to authorize a mutual, voluntary agreement of this kind.
The problem is that while nothing stops one prospective plaintiff from agreeing to refrain from filing a CVRA lawsuit even after the 90 day post-resolution deadline has passed, nothing necessarily stops a different plaintiff from jumping into the fray and filing a lawsuit once the 90 day deadline has elapsed. Were that to happen, it would undermine the basic bargain: that by voluntarily undertaking to transition to district-based elections, the jurisdiction is limiting its exposure to a CVRA lawsuit and associated attorney’s fees.
To deal with that problem, this bill allows the first prospective plaintiff that sent a written notice in accordance with the procedures outlined in AB 350 to reach an agreement with the jurisdiction that would prevent any plaintiff from filing a lawsuit for up to 180 days after the jurisdiction’s adoption of the resolution. To ensure that such an agreement does not delay relief from a method of election that is unlawful under the CVRA, this bill allows such agreements only if they include a requirement that district boundaries will be established no later than six months before the jurisdiction’s next general election.
Support: Advancement Project California; American Civil Liberties Union of California; Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California; League of California Cities; Los Angeles County Division of the League of California Cities; Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund; Riverside County Division of the League of California Cities
Opposition: None known
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation:
AB 2231 (Brough, 2018) would have made numerous significant changes to the CVRA that, generally, would have made it harder for plaintiffs to successfully challenge at-large voting systems under the CVRA. AB 2231 failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
AB 2432 (Obernolte, 2018) would have prohibited a court from imposing district-based elections upon a finding of a violation of the CVRA unless the plaintiff has established that the district-based elections would remedy the dilution or abridgment of voting rights and that alternatives to district-based elections would not achieve greater voting rights and other benefits. AB 2432 was pulled from consideration in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting by the author.
Prior Legislation:
AB 350 (Alejo, Ch. 737, Stats. 2016) required a political subdivision that transitions to, or establishes, district-based elections to hold at least two public hearings both before and after drawing a preliminary map or maps of the proposed district boundaries, as specified. Additionally, AB 350 required that written notice be provided before an action can be brought against a political subdivision under the CVRA, and capped the amount of attorney’s fees that a prospective plaintiff could recover from a political subdivision under the CVRA if the subdivision promptly transitioned from an at-large to a district-based method of election upon receiving such a written notice.
AB 278 (R. Hernandez, Ch. 736, Stats. 2016) expanded on SB 493 by allowing any city, regardless of population, to change from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval.
AB 2389 (Ridley-Thomas, Ch. 754, Stats. 2016) permitted a special district to change the method of electing its governing board members from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval, if the change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA.
SB 493 (Cannella, Ch. 735, Stats. 2015) permitted a city with a population of fewer than 100,000 people to change the method of electing council members to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval if such a change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA.
AB 1440 (Campos, Ch. 873, Stats. 2014) required any political subdivision that was switching from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election to hold at least two public hearings on the proposed district boundaries prior to adopting those boundaries, among other provisions.
AB 684 (Block, Ch. 614, Stats. 2011) established a process under which a community college district could transition from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval if such a transition was approved by the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges, among other provisions.
SB 976 (Polanco, Ch. 129, Stats. 2002) enacted the California Voting Rights Act to address racial block voting in at-large elections for local office in California. The bill prohibited an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class.
Prior Vote:
Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 60, Noes 3)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 1)
Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 1)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 6/19/18
Author: | |||
Version: | 4/17/18 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Darren Chesin | ||
Subject: District-based elections
DIGEST
This bill permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend the deadline by up to 90 days for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system in accordance with the California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA).
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Prohibits, pursuant to the CVRA, an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or its ability to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of a protected class.
- Requires a court, upon finding a violation of the CVRA, to implement appropriate remedies, including the imposition of district-based elections, which are tailored to remedy the violation.
- Permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and who resides in a political subdivision where a violation of the CVRA is alleged to file an action in the superior court of the county in which the political subdivision is located.
- Requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivision’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. Prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the written notice.
- Permits a political subdivision, before receiving a written notice described above or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, as specified. Prohibits a prospective plaintiff from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of such a resolution.
- Requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- After draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and,
- After publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps, as specified.
- Permits a prospective plaintiff to receive reimbursement from a political subdivision for the work product generated to support a written notice, as described above, if that notice was sent to the political subdivision before it passed its resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, and the subdivision subsequently adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections, as specified. Caps the amount of reimbursement at $30,000, as adjusted annually to reflect inflation, as specified. Based on the inflation measurement specified in existing law, the current cap on reimbursement is approximately $30,650.
- Requires a jurisdictional boundary change to be made at least 125 days prior to an election in order for that boundary change to be in effect for that election.
This bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that first sends the subdivision a specified pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision's method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that the subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA.
- Allows the agreement to extend the time period for up to 90 days to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires such a written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision's next regular election to select governing board members, as specified.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
BACKGROUND
California Voting Rights Act of 2001. SB 976 (Polanco), Chapter 129, Statutes of 2002, enacted the CVRA to address racial block voting in at-large elections for local office in California. In areas where racial block voting occurs, an at-large method of election can dilute the voting rights of minority communities if the majority typically votes to support candidates that differ from the candidates who are preferred by minority communities. In such situations, breaking a jurisdiction up into districts can result in districts in which a minority community can elect the candidate of its choice or otherwise have the ability to influence the outcome of an election. Accordingly, the CVRA prohibits an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class.
The first case brought under the CVRA was filed in 2004, and the jurisdiction that was the target of that case -- the City of Modesto -- challenged the constitutionality of the law. Ultimately, the City of Modesto appealed that case all the way to the United States Supreme Court, which rejected the city's appeal in October 2007. The legal uncertainty surrounding the CVRA may have limited the impacts of that law in the first five years after its passage.
Since the case in Modesto was resolved, however, many local jurisdictions have converted or are in the process of converting from an at-large method of election to district-based elections due to the CVRA. In all, at least 200 local government bodies have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections since the enactment of the CVRA. While some jurisdictions did so in response to litigation or threats of litigation, other jurisdictions proactively changed election methods because they believed they could be susceptible to a legal challenge under the CVRA, and they wished to avoid the potential expense of litigation.
Previous Legislation. At the time the CVRA was enacted, local government bodies generally were required to receive voter approval to move from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election for selecting governing board members. That voter approval requirement made it difficult for jurisdictions to proactively transition to district-based elections to address potential liability under the CVRA. If a jurisdiction attempted to transition from at-large to district-based elections to address CVRA concerns, but the voters rejected the proposal, the jurisdiction nonetheless would remain subject to a lawsuit under the CVRA. Furthermore, to the extent that there was racially polarized voting on the question of whether to transition from at-large to district-based elections, the results of the vote on that question could provide further evidence for a lawsuit under the CVRA.
As the number of jurisdictions that faced lawsuits or threats of lawsuits under the CVRA increased, many jurisdictions sought ways to transition from at-large to district-based elections without having to receive voter approval for such a change. Most notably, many school districts have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval in an effort to avoid potential liability under the CVRA. Even though state law generally requires such a transition to be approved by the voters in a school district, existing law also permits the State Board of Education (SBE) to waive all or part of any section of the Education Code, with certain identified exceptions, upon request by the governing board of a school district or county board of education. The SBE generally is required to approve any and all requests for waivers unless it makes a finding that one of seven enumerated conditions exists. Since 2009, the SBE has approved waivers to permit approximately 158 school districts to change from at-large to district elections without receiving voter approval, as would otherwise be required by the Education Code.
In response to concerns that community college districts were subject to liability under the CVRA but were unable to change from at-large to district-based elections without voter approval, AB 684 (Block), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2011, established a process under which a community college district could transition from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval if such a transition was approved by the Board of Governors (BOG) of the California Community Colleges, among other provisions. Since the enactment of AB 684, the BOG has approved requests from approximately 28 community college districts to change from at-large to district elections.
During the 2015-2016 Legislative Session, the Legislature took further steps to facilitate transitions from at-large to district elections. Specifically, SB 493 (Cannella), Chapter 735, Statutes of 2015, permitted a city with a population of fewer than 100,000 people to change the method of electing council members to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval if such a change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA. AB 278 (R. Hernandez), Chapter 736, Statutes of 2016, expanded on SB 493 by allowing any city, regardless of population, to change from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval. Similarly, AB 2389 (Ridley-Thomas), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2016, permitted a special district to change the method of electing its governing board members from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval, if the change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA.
In addition to taking steps to make it easier for local governments to comply with the CVRA by transitioning from at-large to district based elections, the Legislature also enacted new laws designed to encourage greater public participation in that process, and to provide a more formal mechanism for prospective plaintiffs and local jurisdictions to address at-large election systems that are potentially unlawful under the CVRA prior to litigation being filed. Specifically, AB 1440 (Campos), Chapter 873, Statutes of 2014, required any political subdivision that was switching from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election to hold at least two public hearings on the proposed district boundaries prior to adopting those boundaries, among other provisions.
More recently, AB 350 (Alejo), Chapter 737, Statutes of 2016, required a political subdivision that changed to, or established, district-based elections to hold at least two public hearings both before and after drawing a preliminary map or maps of the proposed district boundaries, as specified. Additionally, AB 350 required that written notice be provided before an action can be brought against a political subdivision under the CVRA, and capped the amount of attorney’s fees that a prospective plaintiff could recover from a political subdivision under the CVRA if the subdivision promptly transitioned from an at-large to a district-based method of election upon receiving such a written notice.
Under the provisions of AB 350, once a jurisdiction receives a written notice from a prospective plaintiff alleging that the jurisdiction’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA, the jurisdiction has 45 days to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections (a jurisdiction may also choose to enact such a resolution before receiving any such written notice). If a jurisdiction has passed such a resolution, no legal action may be filed against the jurisdiction alleging a CVRA violation within 90 days of the resolution’s passage. To take full advantage of the cap on attorney’s fees to prospective plaintiffs that is provided in AB 350, a jurisdiction would have a maximum of 135 days (45 days to pass a resolution plus 90 days to adopt districts) from the time it received a written notice from the prospective plaintiffs until it had to finalize the new district boundaries.
This bill would allow a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sent a written notice to that political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend the time period during which no legal action could be filed against the political subdivision for up to an additional 90 days (for a total of 180 days).
While nothing in existing law prevents a prospective plaintiff from reaching a voluntary agreement with a political subdivision to refrain from filing a CVRA lawsuit while that subdivision takes steps to adopt a district-based method of election, such a voluntary agreement would not prevent any other prospective plaintiff from filing such a lawsuit once more than 90 days elapsed after the jurisdiction passed a resolution indicating its intent to transition from at-large to district-based elections. This bill effectively allows the prospective plaintiff that first sent a written notice in accordance with the procedures outlined in AB 350 to reach an agreement with the jurisdiction that would prevent any plaintiff from filing a lawsuit for up to 180 days after the jurisdiction’s adoption of the resolution. To ensure that such an agreement does not delay relief from a method of election that is unlawful under the CVRA, this bill allows such agreements only if they include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the jurisdiction’s next general election.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: In recent years, many local governments in California have been subject to litigation alleging that their existing at-large election systems violate the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA). The enactment of AB 350 (Alejo, 2016) established a framework which governs local governments’ transitions from at-large to district-based elections.
However, after the enactment of AB 350, local governments and voting rights organizations have both found that additional time is often needed to implement a successful transition to district-based elections. With additional time to mobilize, underrepresented communities would be better equipped to advocate for their interests in the drawing of district boundaries. Additional time would also allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn.
AB 2123 would build upon the existing framework by providing for a mutually agreed-upon extension of up to 90 additional days to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections. During this time extension, the existing AB 350 prohibition against commencing CVRA litigation against a local government due to its at-large election system would also be extended.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 2231 (Brough) of 2018 makes numerous significant changes to the CVRA that generally would make it harder for plaintiffs to successfully challenge at-large voting systems under the CVRA. AB 2231 failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting
AB 2432 (Obernolte) of 2018 prohibits a court from imposing district-based elections upon a finding of a violation of the CVRA unless the plaintiff has established that the district-based elections would remedy the dilution or abridgment of voting rights and that alternatives to district-based elections would not achieve greater voting rights and other benefits. The hearing for AB 2432 in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting was canceled by the author.
(See the BACKGROUND section, above, for a discussion of prior legislation related to this bill.)
PRIOR ACTION
Assembly Floor: | |
Assembly Judiciary Committee: Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee: | 9 - 1
|
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: Advancement Project
American Civil Liberties Union of California Center for Advocacy and Policy
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
California Common Cause
League of California Cities
League of California Cities, Los Angeles County Division
League of California Cities, Riverside County Division
Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF)
Oppose: None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2123
Author:(Cervantes)
As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Elections | 6-1 | Berman, Calderon, McCarty, Mullin, Steinorth, Weber | Harper |
Judiciary | 9-1 | Mark Stone, Cunningham, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes | Kiley |
SUMMARY: Permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend the deadline by up to 90 days for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system in accordance with the California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that first sends the subdivision a specified pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision's method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that the subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA.
- Allows the agreement to extend the time period for up to 90 days to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires such a written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision's next regular election to select governing board members, as specified.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: According to the author, "In recent years, many local governments in California have been subject to litigation alleging that their existing at-large election systems violate the [CVRA]. The enactment of AB 350 [(Alejo), Chapter 737, Statutes of 2016] established a framework which governs local governments' transitions from at-large to district-based elections.
"However, after the enactment of AB 350, local governments and voting rights organizations have both found that additional time is often needed to implement a successful transition to district-based elections…
"AB 2123 would build upon the existing framework by providing for a mutually agreed-upon extension of up to 90 additional days to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections."
SB 976 (Polanco), Chapter 129, Statutes of 2002, enacted the CVRA to address racial block voting in at-large elections for local office in California. In areas where racial block voting occurs, an at-large method of election can dilute the voting rights of minority communities if the majority typically votes to support candidates that differ from the candidates who are preferred by minority communities. In such situations, breaking a jurisdiction up into districts can result in districts in which a minority community can elect the candidate of its choice or otherwise influence the outcome of an election. Accordingly, the CVRA prohibits an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class.
Among other provisions, AB 350, required that written notice be provided before an action can be brought against a political subdivision under the CVRA, and capped the amount of attorney's fees that a prospective plaintiff could recover from a political subdivision under the CVRA if the subdivision promptly transitioned from an at-large to a district-based method of election upon receiving such a written notice. Under the provisions of AB 350, once a jurisdiction receives a written notice from a prospective plaintiff alleging that the jurisdiction's method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA, the jurisdiction has 45 days to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections. If a jurisdiction has passed such a resolution, no legal action may be filed against the jurisdiction alleging a CVRA violation within 90 days of the resolution's passage. To take full advantage of the cap on attorney's fees that is provided in AB 350, a jurisdiction has a maximum of 135 days (45 days to pass a resolution plus 90 days to adopt districts) from the time it receives a written notice until it has to finalize the new district boundaries.
This bill allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sent a written notice to that political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend the time period during which no legal action could be filed against the political subdivision for up to an additional 90 days (for a total of 180 days). To ensure that such an agreement does not delay relief from a method of election that is unlawful under the CVRA, this bill allows such agreements only if they include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the jurisdiction's next regular election to select governing board members.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0002811
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2123
Author:(Cervantes) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
SUBJECT: CALIFORNIA VOTING RIGHTS ACT: District-based elections
KEY ISSUE: Should a political subdivision and a person alleging that the subdivision's at-large election system violates the California Voting Rights Act be allowed to extend, by mutual agreement, a deadline for transitioning to district-based elections, if the reason for the extension is to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input?
SYNOPSIS
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) permits members of a "protected class" to bring an action to challenge an at-large election system that impairs the ability of the protected class to elect candidates of its choice or influence the outcome of an election. (A "protected class" generally means any racial, ethnic, or linguistic group that constitutes a minority of a political subdivision.) If a court finds that the at-large election system did indeed abridge the voting rights of members of the protected class, the court must implement appropriate remedies, including the imposition of a district-based election system. However, before filing a CVRA action in court, a prospective plaintiff must first provide written notice to the political subdivision that the subdivision's at-large election system may violate CVRA and give the subdivision the opportunity to pass a resolution outlining a plan to transition from at-large elections to district-based elections. Once the resolution is passed, the political subdivision must complete the transition within 90 days and the prospective plaintiff is barred from filing a CVRA action with the court during that period. This bill would allow the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend this 90 day time period for an additional 90 days for the purpose of conducting public outreach, encouraging public participation, and receiving public input. According to the author and sponsors, the current 90 day timeline can be a barrier to full community engagement because of the difficulties in engaging historically disenfranchised groups. The bill is supported by the ACLU and the Advancement Project California. There is no opposition to this sensible measure, which recently passed out of the Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee on a 6-1 vote.
SUMMARY: Permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend by 90 days the deadline for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system under the California Voting Rights of 2001 (CVRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that sent a pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision’s method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend, for up to a period of 90 days, the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that it passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from an at-large to a district-based elections system and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA. Specifies that the purpose of the extension is to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires the above-referenced written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision’s next general election.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement with a prospective plaintiff, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the written agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the 15th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, that “[t]he rights of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of race, color, or previous condition or servitude.” (U.S. Const., 15th Amend.)
- Provides, under the federal Voting Rights Act, that “[n]o voting qualification or prerequisite to voting or standard, practice, or procedure shall be imposed or applied by any State or political subdivision in a manner which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizens of the United States to vote on account of race or color, [or language minority group.]” (42 U.S.C. Sec. 1973 et seq.)
- Provides, under the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA), that an at-large election method may not impair the ability of a protected class to elect candidates of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of dilution or abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class. Defines "protected class" for this purpose to mean a class of voters who are members of a minority race, color, or language group, consistent with definitions in the federal Voting Rights Act. (Elections Code Sections 14027 and 14026 (d).)
- Defines an "at-large method of election" as one which: (1) members of the governing body are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; (2) candidates are required to reside in an election district and are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; or (3) an at-large election method is combined with a district-based election. Defines a "district-based method of election" as one in which candidates are required to reside in an election district (a divisible part of the political subdivision) and elected only by voters residing within that election district. (Elections Code Section 14026 (a)-(b).)
- Provides that a violation of the CVRA is established if racially polarized voting occurs in an election of members to the governing body of a political subdivision or in elections incorporating other electoral choices by voters of the political subdivision. Defines "racially polarized voting" for this purpose to mean voting in which there is a difference in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters of the protected class and in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters in the rest of the electorate. Permits use of methodologies for estimating group voting behavior as approved in federal case law enforcing the federal Voting Rights Act. (Elections Code Section 14028 and 14026 (e).)
- Provides that upon a violation of the CVRA, the court shall implement appropriate remedies that are tailored to remediate the violation, including the imposition of district-based elections. (Elections Code Section 14029.)
- Permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and resides in the political subdivision where a violation has occurred to file an action in superior court. Provides for reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses for the prevailing plaintiff. Provides for costs for the prevailing defendant only upon a frivolous or unreasonable action. (Elections Code Section 14030 and 14032.)
- Requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the relevant political subdivision and prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the notice. Permits a political subdivision, as prescribed, to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, as specified. Prohibits a prospective plaintiff from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of the resolution. (Elections Code Section 10010 (e)-(f).)
- Requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- After draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and,
- After publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps, as specified. (Elections Code Section 11001 (a)-(c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (Elections Code Sections 14025-14032) permits a member of a "protected class" to legally challenge an at-large election system if that system impairs the ability of the protected class to elect candidates of its choice or influence the outcome of an election. (A "protected class" means any racial, ethnic, or linguistic group that constitutes a minority of a political subdivision.) When the CVRA was enacted, it had long been recognized that at-large elections, coupled with racially polarized voting patterns, worked to the detriment of racial and ethnic minorities. In such situations, the majority could elect all members of the governing body. District-based elections, on the other hand, allowed racial and ethnic minorities to elect at least some members of the governing body. In order to prevail in a CVRA action, the plaintiff must show that racially polarized voting occurs in elections for members of the jurisdiction's governing body. Proving the existence of racially polarized voting usually requires a statistical analysis of past election results showing that members of the protected class consistently vote differently than the rest of the electorate. A plaintiff bringing a CVRA challenge does not need to prove that elected officials or anyone else intended to discriminate against the protected class. A system that results in the dilution of voting rights of the protected class constitutes a violation, regardless of intent.
CVRA allows an affected person – a member of a protected class who resides in the district – to bring an action in superior court alleging a violation of the CVRA, subject to pre-litigation notice and cure requirements discussed below. If the court finds a violation of CVRA, it must impose remedies appropriate to correct the violation. The CVRA does not say precisely what these remedies should be, although it does specify that in forging remedies the courts may look to federal case law enforcing the federal Voting Rights Act. One common remedy under CVRA is to have the political subdivision shift from an at-large election system to a district-based election system, where members of the governing body reside in a particular district and are chosen by voters living in that district.
Pre-Litigation Notice Requirement and Resolution: Before a commencing a CVRA action, the prospective plaintiff must first provide the relevant political subdivision with a written notice that its method of at-large election may violate CVRA. Within 45 days after receiving this notice, the political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from an at-large to district-based elections and providing an estimated time line for doing so. The prospective plaintiff may not bring a CVRA action in court during the 45 days. If the political subdivision does not pass a resolution, the plaintiff may then file the CVRA action with a court. If the political subdivision does, however, pass a resolution, the political subdivision has 90 days to complete the transition, during which time the prospective plaintiff is barred from filing the CVRA action in court.
This bill would allow the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision, by mutual agreement, to extend the original 90-day time period by an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. According to the author, extending this time period is necessary in order "to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections." The author also believes that additional time will "allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn." It is important to stress that this bill does not allow one side to impose the extension on the other. The extension can only be made by mutual agreement between the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision. Once this additional period has expired, the prospective plaintiff is free to bring an action in superior court and, if the court finds a violation, it will impose a remedy. However, a mutually agreed upon extension, to the extent that it results in a fair solution in which all interested persons have provided input, may prevent the need for costly litigation.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The ACLU of California supports this bill because the flexibility of an additional 90 days will "provide underrepresented communities more time and opportunity to engage in the inaugural districting process, and can help ensure a local jurisdiction has the information it needs to draw fair maps that redress the harm" caused by the existing system. ACLU contends that "underrepresented communities are often, because of historical disenfranchisement, among the least politically engaged communities in a jurisdiction." This can make it "very difficult for a local government or for civil rights or community-based organizations to identify these underrepresented communities, educate them about districting and its importance, and encourage and facilitate their participation in the process."
The Advancement Project California (APC) also supports this bill because it will "provide a more appropriate amount of time to engage and mobilize underrepresented communities." APC adds that district-based elections "have greatly improved the core values of democracy such as fair representation" and "empower underrepresented communities . . . [to] have a voice in the political process." APC points to many factors in underrepresented communities, including poverty, inflexible work hours, and poor access to transportation, that create barriers to full political engagement and participation. By allowing for an extension of up to 90 days, APC believes that AB 2123 will allow for a "smoother and more robust transition" that will simultaneously "encourage public and civic engagement."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Advancement Project California
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2123
Author:(Cervantes) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
SUBJECT: CALIFORNIA VOTING RIGHTS ACT: District-based elections
KEY ISSUE: Should a political subdivision and a person alleging that the subdivision's at-large election system violates the California Voting Rights Act be allowed to extend, by mutual agreement, a deadline for transitioning to district-based elections, if the reason for the extension is to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input?
SYNOPSIS
The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA) permits members of a "protected class" to bring an action to challenge an at-large election system that impairs the ability of the protected class to elect candidates of its choice or influence the outcome of an election. (A "protected class" generally means any racial, ethnic, or linguistic group that constitutes a minority of a political subdivision.) If a court finds that the at-large election system did indeed abridge the voting rights of members of the protected class, the court must implement appropriate remedies, including the imposition of a district-based election system. However, before filing a CVRA action in court, a prospective plaintiff must first provide written notice to the political subdivision that the subdivision's at-large election system may violate CVRA and give the subdivision the opportunity to pass a resolution outlining a plan to transition from at-large elections to district-based elections. Once the resolution is passed, the political subdivision must complete the transition within 90 days and the prospective plaintiff is barred from filing a CVRA action with the court during that period. This bill would allow the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend this 90 day time period for an additional 90 days for the purpose of conducting public outreach, encouraging public participation, and receiving public input. According to the author and sponsors, the current 90 day timeline can be a barrier to full community engagement because of the difficulties in engaging historically disenfranchised groups. The bill is supported by the ACLU and the Advancement Project California. There is no opposition to this sensible measure, which recently passed out of the Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee on a 6-1 vote.
SUMMARY: Permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend by 90 days the deadline for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system under the California Voting Rights of 2001 (CVRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that sent a pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision’s method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend, for up to a period of 90 days, the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that it passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from an at-large to a district-based elections system and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA. Specifies that the purpose of the extension is to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires the above-referenced written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision’s next general election.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement with a prospective plaintiff, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the written agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the 15th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, that “[t]he rights of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of race, color, or previous condition or servitude.” (U.S. Const., 15th Amend.)
- Provides, under the federal Voting Rights Act, that “[n]o voting qualification or prerequisite to voting or standard, practice, or procedure shall be imposed or applied by any State or political subdivision in a manner which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizens of the United States to vote on account of race or color, [or language minority group.]” (42 U.S.C. Sec. 1973 et seq.)
- Provides, under the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA), that an at-large election method may not impair the ability of a protected class to elect candidates of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of dilution or abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class. Defines "protected class" for this purpose to mean a class of voters who are members of a minority race, color, or language group, consistent with definitions in the federal Voting Rights Act. (Elections Code Sections 14027 and 14026 (d).)
- Defines an "at-large method of election" as one which: (1) members of the governing body are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; (2) candidates are required to reside in an election district and are elected by voters of the entire jurisdiction; or (3) an at-large election method is combined with a district-based election. Defines a "district-based method of election" as one in which candidates are required to reside in an election district (a divisible part of the political subdivision) and elected only by voters residing within that election district. (Elections Code Section 14026 (a)-(b).)
- Provides that a violation of the CVRA is established if racially polarized voting occurs in an election of members to the governing body of a political subdivision or in elections incorporating other electoral choices by voters of the political subdivision. Defines "racially polarized voting" for this purpose to mean voting in which there is a difference in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters of the protected class and in the choice of candidates or other electoral choices that are preferred by voters in the rest of the electorate. Permits use of methodologies for estimating group voting behavior as approved in federal case law enforcing the federal Voting Rights Act. (Elections Code Section 14028 and 14026 (e).)
- Provides that upon a violation of the CVRA, the court shall implement appropriate remedies that are tailored to remediate the violation, including the imposition of district-based elections. (Elections Code Section 14029.)
- Permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and resides in the political subdivision where a violation has occurred to file an action in superior court. Provides for reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses for the prevailing plaintiff. Provides for costs for the prevailing defendant only upon a frivolous or unreasonable action. (Elections Code Section 14030 and 14032.)
- Requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the relevant political subdivision and prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the notice. Permits a political subdivision, as prescribed, to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, as specified. Prohibits a prospective plaintiff from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of the resolution. (Elections Code Section 10010 (e)-(f).)
- Requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- After draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and,
- After publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps, as specified. (Elections Code Section 11001 (a)-(c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: The California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (Elections Code Sections 14025-14032) permits a member of a "protected class" to legally challenge an at-large election system if that system impairs the ability of the protected class to elect candidates of its choice or influence the outcome of an election. (A "protected class" means any racial, ethnic, or linguistic group that constitutes a minority of a political subdivision.) When the CVRA was enacted, it had long been recognized that at-large elections, coupled with racially polarized voting patterns, worked to the detriment of racial and ethnic minorities. In such situations, the majority could elect all members of the governing body. District-based elections, on the other hand, allowed racial and ethnic minorities to elect at least some members of the governing body. In order to prevail in a CVRA action, the plaintiff must show that racially polarized voting occurs in elections for members of the jurisdiction's governing body. Proving the existence of racially polarized voting usually requires a statistical analysis of past election results showing that members of the protected class consistently vote differently than the rest of the electorate. A plaintiff bringing a CVRA challenge does not need to prove that elected officials or anyone else intended to discriminate against the protected class. A system that results in the dilution of voting rights of the protected class constitutes a violation, regardless of intent.
CVRA allows an affected person – a member of a protected class who resides in the district – to bring an action in superior court alleging a violation of the CVRA, subject to pre-litigation notice and cure requirements discussed below. If the court finds a violation of CVRA, it must impose remedies appropriate to correct the violation. The CVRA does not say precisely what these remedies should be, although it does specify that in forging remedies the courts may look to federal case law enforcing the federal Voting Rights Act. One common remedy under CVRA is to have the political subdivision shift from an at-large election system to a district-based election system, where members of the governing body reside in a particular district and are chosen by voters living in that district.
Pre-Litigation Notice Requirement and Resolution: Before a commencing a CVRA action, the prospective plaintiff must first provide the relevant political subdivision with a written notice that its method of at-large election may violate CVRA. Within 45 days after receiving this notice, the political subdivision may pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from an at-large to district-based elections and providing an estimated time line for doing so. The prospective plaintiff may not bring a CVRA action in court during the 45 days. If the political subdivision does not pass a resolution, the plaintiff may then file the CVRA action with a court. If the political subdivision does, however, pass a resolution, the political subdivision has 90 days to complete the transition, during which time the prospective plaintiff is barred from filing the CVRA action in court.
This bill would allow the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision, by mutual agreement, to extend the original 90-day time period by an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input. According to the author, extending this time period is necessary in order "to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections." The author also believes that additional time will "allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn." It is important to stress that this bill does not allow one side to impose the extension on the other. The extension can only be made by mutual agreement between the prospective plaintiff and the political subdivision. Once this additional period has expired, the prospective plaintiff is free to bring an action in superior court and, if the court finds a violation, it will impose a remedy. However, a mutually agreed upon extension, to the extent that it results in a fair solution in which all interested persons have provided input, may prevent the need for costly litigation.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The ACLU of California supports this bill because the flexibility of an additional 90 days will "provide underrepresented communities more time and opportunity to engage in the inaugural districting process, and can help ensure a local jurisdiction has the information it needs to draw fair maps that redress the harm" caused by the existing system. ACLU contends that "underrepresented communities are often, because of historical disenfranchisement, among the least politically engaged communities in a jurisdiction." This can make it "very difficult for a local government or for civil rights or community-based organizations to identify these underrepresented communities, educate them about districting and its importance, and encourage and facilitate their participation in the process."
The Advancement Project California (APC) also supports this bill because it will "provide a more appropriate amount of time to engage and mobilize underrepresented communities." APC adds that district-based elections "have greatly improved the core values of democracy such as fair representation" and "empower underrepresented communities . . . [to] have a voice in the political process." APC points to many factors in underrepresented communities, including poverty, inflexible work hours, and poor access to transportation, that create barriers to full political engagement and participation. By allowing for an extension of up to 90 days, APC believes that AB 2123 will allow for a "smoother and more robust transition" that will simultaneously "encourage public and civic engagement."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Advancement Project California
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 11, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2123 (
Author:Cervantes) – As Amended Ver:April 2, 2018
SUBJECT: District-based elections.
SUMMARY: Permits a prospective plaintiff and a political subdivision to agree to extend the deadline by up to 90 days for completing the transition from an at-large to a district-based election system in accordance with the California Voting Rights Act of 2001 (CVRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff that first sends the subdivision a specified pre-litigation notice asserting that the subdivision’s method of election violates the CVRA to enter into a written agreement to extend the amount of time that the subdivision has between the time that the subdivision passes a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections and the time that a prospective plaintiff may commence a legal action to enforce the CVRA.
- Allows the agreement to extend the time period for up to an additional 90 days in order to provide additional time to conduct public outreach, encourage public participation, and receive public input.
- Requires such a written agreement to include a requirement that the district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision’s next general election.
- Requires a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement with a prospective plaintiff, as described above, within 10 days of the execution of the written agreement, to prepare and make available on its website a tentative schedule of the public outreach events and the public hearings that it will hold in accordance with existing law. Requires a political subdivision that does not have a website to make the tentative schedule available upon request.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits, pursuant to the CVRA, an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or its ability to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of a protected class.
- Requires a court, upon finding a violation of the CVRA, to implement appropriate remedies, including the imposition of district-based elections, which are tailored to remedy the violation.
- Permits any voter who is a member of a protected class and who resides in a political subdivision where a violation of the CVRA is alleged to file an action in the superior court of the county in which the political subdivision is located.
- Requires a prospective plaintiff, before commencing an action to enforce the CVRA, to send a written notice by certified mail to the political subdivision against which the action would be brought asserting that the political subdivision’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA. Prohibits the prospective plaintiff from commencing an action to enforce the CVRA within 45 days of the political subdivision’s receipt of the written notice.
- Permits a political subdivision, before receiving a written notice described above or within 45 days of receipt of a notice, to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, as specified. Prohibits a prospective plaintiff from commencing a legal action against a political subdivision to enforce the CVRA within 90 days of the political subdivision’s passage of such a resolution.
- Requires a political subdivision that is changing from at-large to district-based elections to do all of the following before holding a public hearing at which the governing body of the political subdivision votes to approve or defeat an ordinance establishing district-based elections:
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- After draft maps are drawn, publish and make available for release at least one draft map and the potential sequence of elections in situations where elections to the governing body will be staggered; and,
- After publishing a draft map or maps, hold at least two additional hearings over a period of no more than 45 days to receive public input regarding the content of the draft map or maps, as specified.
- Hold at least two public hearings over a period of no more than 30 days prior to drawing a draft map or maps of the proposed boundaries of districts, in order to receive public input regarding the composition of the districts, as specified;
- Permits a prospective plaintiff to receive reimbursement from a political subdivision for the work product generated to support a written notice, as described above, if that notice was sent to the political subdivision before it passed its resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections, and the subdivision subsequently adopts an ordinance establishing district-based elections, as specified. Caps the amount of reimbursement at $30,000, as adjusted annually to reflect inflation, as specified. Based on the inflation measurement specified in existing law, the current cap on reimbursement is approximately $30,650.
- Requires a jurisdictional boundary change to be made at least 125 days prior to an election in order for that boundary change to be in effect for that election.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
In recent years, many local governments in California have been subject to litigation alleging that their existing at-large election systems violate the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA). The enactment of AB 350 (Alejo, 2016) established a framework which governs local governments’ transitions from at-large to district-based elections.
However, after the enactment of AB 350, local governments and voting rights organizations have both found that additional time is often needed to implement a successful transition to district-based elections. With additional time to mobilize, underrepresented communities would be better equipped to advocate for their interests in the drawing of district boundaries. Additional time would also allow local governments to engage in more outreach to ensure that public input is heard while prospective districts are being drawn.
AB 2123 would build upon the existing framework by providing for a mutually agreed-upon extension of up to 90 additional days to allow a local government and plaintiff to continue negotiating a transition to district-based elections. During this time extension, the existing AB 350 prohibition against commencing CVRA litigation against a local government due to its at-large election system would also be extended.
- California Voting Rights Act of 2001: SB 976 (Polanco), Chapter 129, Statutes of 2002, enacted the CVRA to address racial block voting in at-large elections for local office in California. In areas where racial block voting occurs, an at-large method of election can dilute the voting rights of minority communities if the majority typically votes to support candidates that differ from the candidates who are preferred by minority communities. In such situations, breaking a jurisdiction up into districts can result in districts in which a minority community can elect the candidate of its choice or otherwise have the ability to influence the outcome of an election. Accordingly, the CVRA prohibits an at-large method of election from being imposed or applied in a political subdivision in a manner that impairs the ability of a protected class of voters to elect the candidate of its choice or to influence the outcome of an election, as a result of the dilution or the abridgement of the rights of voters who are members of the protected class.
The first case brought under the CVRA was filed in 2004, and the jurisdiction that was the target of that case—the City of Modesto—challenged the constitutionality of the law. Ultimately, the City of Modesto appealed that case all the way to the United States Supreme Court, which rejected the city's appeal in October 2007. The legal uncertainty surrounding the CVRA may have limited the impacts of that law in the first five years after its passage.
Since the case in Modesto was resolved, however, many local jurisdictions have converted or are in the process of converting from an at-large method of election to district-based elections due to the CVRA. In all, at least 200 local government bodies have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections since the enactment of the CVRA. While some jurisdictions did so in response to litigation or threats of litigation, other jurisdictions proactively changed election methods because they believed they could be susceptible to a legal challenge under the CVRA, and they wished to avoid the potential expense of litigation. - Previous Legislation to Facilitate Changes from At-Large to District-Based Elections: At the time the CVRA was enacted, local government bodies generally were required to receive voter approval to move from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election for selecting governing board members. That voter approval requirement made it difficult for jurisdictions to proactively transition to district-based elections to address potential liability under the CVRA. If a jurisdiction attempted to transition from at-large to district-based elections to address CVRA concerns, but the voters rejected the proposal, the jurisdiction nonetheless would remain subject to a lawsuit under the CVRA. Furthermore, to the extent that there was racially polarized voting on the question of whether to transition from at-large to district-based elections, the results of the vote on that question could provide further evidence for a lawsuit under the CVRA.
As the number of jurisdictions that faced lawsuits or threats of lawsuits under the CVRA increased, many jurisdictions sought ways to transition from at-large to district-based elections without having to receive voter approval for such a change. Most notably, many school districts have transitioned from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval in an effort to avoid potential liability under the CVRA. Even though state law generally requires such a transition to be approved by the voters in a school district, existing law also permits the State Board of Education (SBE) to waive all or part of any section of the Education Code, with certain identified exceptions, upon request by the governing board of a school district or county board of education. The SBE generally is required to approve any and all requests for waivers unless it makes a finding that one of seven enumerated conditions exists. Since 2009, the SBE has approved waivers to permit approximately 158 school districts to change from at-large to district elections without receiving voter approval, as would otherwise be required by the Education Code.
In response to concerns that community college districts were subject to liability under the CVRA but were unable to change from at-large to district-based elections without voter approval, AB 684 (Block), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2011, established a process under which a community college district could transition from at-large to district-based elections without receiving voter approval if such a transition was approved by the Board of Governors (BOG) of the California Community Colleges, among other provisions. Since the enactment of AB 684, the BOG has approved requests from approximately 28 community college districts to change from at-large to district elections.
During the 2015-2016 Legislative Session, the Legislature took further steps to facilitate transitions from at-large to district elections. Specifically, SB 493 (Cannella), Chapter 735, Statutes of 2015, permitted a city with a population of fewer than 100,000 people to change the method of electing council members to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval if such a change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA. AB 278 (R. Hernandez), Chapter 736, Statutes of 2016, expanded on SB 493 by allowing any city, regardless of population, to change the method of electing its governing board members from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval. Similarly, AB 2389 (Ridley-Thomas), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2016, permitted a special district to change the method of electing its governing board members from at-large to a by-district method of election without receiving voter approval, if the change was made in furtherance of the purposes of the CVRA.
In addition to taking steps to make it easier for local governments to comply with the CVRA by transitioning from at-large to district based elections, the Legislature also enacted new laws designed to encourage greater public participation in that process, and to provide a more formal mechanism for prospective plaintiffs and local jurisdictions to address at-large election systems that are potentially unlawful under the CVRA prior to litigation being filed. Specifically, AB 1440 (Campos), Chapter 873, Statutes of 2014, required any political subdivision that was switching from an at-large method of election to a district-based method of election to hold at least two public hearings on the proposed district boundaries prior to adopting those boundaries, among other provisions.
More recently, AB 350 (Alejo), Chapter 737, Statutes of 2016, required a political subdivision that changed to, or established, district-based elections to hold at least two public hearings both before and after drawing a preliminary map or maps of the proposed district boundaries, as specified. Additionally, AB 350 required that written notice be provided before an action can be brought against a political subdivision under the CVRA, and capped the amount of attorney’s fees that a prospective plaintiff could recover from a political subdivision under the CVRA if the subdivision promptly transitioned from an at-large to a district-based method of election upon receiving such a written notice.
Under the provisions of AB 350, once a jurisdiction receives a written notice from a prospective plaintiff alleging that the jurisdiction’s method of conducting elections may violate the CVRA, the jurisdiction has 45 days to pass a resolution outlining its intention to transition from at-large to district-based elections (a jurisdiction may also choose to enact such a resolution before receiving any such written notice). If a jurisdiction has passed such a resolution, no legal action may be filed against the jurisdiction alleging a CVRA violation within 90 days of the resolution’s passage. To take full advantage of the cap on attorney’s fees to prospective plaintiffs that is provided in AB 350, a jurisdiction would have a maximum of 135 days (45 days to pass a resolution plus 90 days to adopt districts) from the time it received a written notice from the prospective plaintiffs until it had to finalize the new district boundaries.
This bill would allow a political subdivision and the prospective plaintiff who first sent a written notice to that political subdivision to enter into an agreement to extend the time period during which no legal action could be filed against the political subdivision for up to an additional 90 days (for a total of 180 days). While nothing in existing law prevents a prospective plaintiff from reaching a voluntary agreement with a political subdivision to refrain from filing a CVRA lawsuit while that subdivision takes steps to adopt a district-based method of election, such a voluntary agreement would not prevent any other prospective plaintiff from filing such a lawsuit once more than 90 days elapsed after the jurisdiction passed a resolution indicating its intent to transition from at-large to district-based elections. This bill effectively allows the prospective plaintiff that first sent a written notice in accordance with the procedures outlined in AB 350 to reach an agreement with the jurisdiction that would prevent any plaintiff from filing a lawsuit for up to 180 days after the jurisdiction’s adoption of the resolution. To ensure that such an agreement does not delay relief from a method of election that is unlawful under the CVRA, this bill allows such agreements only if they include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the jurisdiction’s next general election. - Technical Amendments: To correct a drafting error, and to ensure that this bill covers all the types of election systems used by various political subdivisions in California, committee staff recommends the following technical amendment:
On page 4, line 11, strike out “general election.” and insert:
regular election to select governing board members. However, in a political subdivision that holds a primary election as part of its process for selecting governing board members, the written agreement shall include a requirement that district boundaries be established no later than six months before the political subdivision’s next regular primary election.
Furthermore, certain language that this bill proposes to add to existing law appears to be unnecessary. Specifically, page 4, lines 20-22 of this bill read as follows:
(iii) This subparagraph applies only to a political subdivision that enters into a written agreement for a time extension pursuant to clause (i) when changing from at-large to district-based elections.
The prior two clauses in the subparagraph in which that clause is found, however, clearly apply only to political subdivisions that enter into a written agreement pursuant to clause (i). Because this language does not appear to have a substantive effect and may create confusion, committee staff recommends that it be deleted. - Arguments in Support: In support of this bill, California Common Cause writes:
Underrepresented communities are often, because of their historical disenfranchisement, among the least politically engaged communities in a jurisdiction. As a result, it can be very difficult, in only the 90 days allowed under law, for a local government or civil rights or community-based organizations to identify these underrepresented communities, educate them about districting and its importance, and encourage and facilitate their participation in the process.
AB 2123 will allow an extension of up to another 90 days, for a total of 180 days, to complete the districting process, which provides a more generous timeframe for engaging and mobilizing underrepresented communities. The bill requires local jurisdictions and CVRA prospective plaintiffs to both agree to the extension, to ensure the transition is done in a way that encourages public engagement. The bill also prevents extensions from resulting in districts being adopted with fewer than six months before the next regular election to ensure all candidates have ample time to run a campaign that reaches all communities of the newly formed districts.
- Related Legislation: AB 2231 (Brough), which is set for hearing in this committee on April 25, 2018, makes numerous significant changes to the CVRA that generally would make it harder for plaintiffs to successfully challenge at-large voting systems under the CVRA.
AB 2432 (Obernolte), which is set for hearing in this committee on April 25, 2018, prohibits a court from imposing district-based elections upon a finding of a violation of the CVRA unless the plaintiff has established that the district-based elections would remedy the dilution or abridgment of voting rights and that alternatives to district-based elections would not achieve greater voting rights and other benefits. - Double-Referral: This bill is double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Civil Liberties Union of California Center for Advocacy and Policy
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
California Common Cause
League of California Cities
League of Women Voters of California
Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF)
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):