AB 394: Tribal gaming: compact ratification.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-10-03
Existing federal law, the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988, provides for the negotiation and execution of tribal-state gaming compacts for the purpose of authorizing certain types of gaming on Indian lands within a state. The California Constitution authorizes the Governor to negotiate and conclude tribal-state gaming compacts, subject to ratification by the Legislature. Existing law expressly ratifies a number of tribal-state gaming compacts, and amendments of tribal-state gaming compacts, between the State of California and specified Indian tribes.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project, as defined, that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment, as defined, or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California executed on August 31, 2017. The bill would provide that, in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions related to that amended compact are not projects for purposes of CEQA.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing federal law, the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988, provides for the negotiation and execution of tribal-state gaming compacts for the purpose of authorizing certain types of gaming on Indian lands within a state. The California Constitution authorizes the Governor to negotiate and conclude tribal-state gaming compacts, subject to ratification by the Legislature. Existing law expressly ratifies a number of tribal-state gaming compacts, and amendments of tribal-state gaming compacts, between the State of California and specified Indian tribes.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project, as defined, that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment, as defined, or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California executed on August 31, 2017. The bill would provide that, in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions related to that amended compact are not projects for purposes of CEQA.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing federal law, the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988, provides for the negotiation and execution of tribal-state gaming compacts for the purpose of authorizing certain types of gaming on Indian lands within a state. The California Constitution authorizes the Governor to negotiate and conclude tribal-state gaming compacts, subject to ratification by the Legislature. Existing law expressly ratifies a number of tribal-state gaming compacts, and amendments of tribal-state gaming compacts, between the State of California and specified Indian tribes.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project, as defined, that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment, as defined, or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California executed on August 31, 2017. The bill would provide that, in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions related to that amended compact are not projects for purposes of CEQA.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law establishes the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, as one of the public postsecondary institutions of higher education in the state.This bill would require the California State University to implement, on or before August 1, 2018, additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students, as specified.Existing law establishes the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, as one of the public postsecondary institutions of higher education in the state.
This bill would require, as a condition of receipt of state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, the trustees to approve, by require the California State University to implement, on or before August 1, 2018, a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use multiple additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students, as specified.
Existing law establishes the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, as one of the public postsecondary institutions of higher education in the state.
This bill would require, as a condition of receipt of state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, the trustees to approve, by August 1, 2018, a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use multiple measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students, as specified.
(a)The tribal-state gaming compact entered into in accordance with the federal Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 (18 U.S.C. Secs. 1166 to 1168, inclusive, and 25 U.S.C. Sec. 2701 et seq.) between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, executed on August 31, 2017, is hereby ratified.
(b)(1)In deference to tribal sovereignty, none of the following shall be deemed a project for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code):
(A)The execution of an amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(B)The execution of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(C)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and a county or city government negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(D)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and the Department of Transportation, or other state agency, negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(E)The on-reservation impacts of compliance with the terms of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(2)Except as expressly provided in this section, this subdivision does not exempt a city, county, or city and county, or the Department of Transportation, or any state agency or local jurisdiction, from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act.
SEC. 2.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to enhance the economic development, stability, and self-sufficiency of the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, and to protect the interests of the tribe and its members, the surrounding community, and the California public at the earliest possible time, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)The tribal-state gaming compact entered into in accordance with the federal Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 (18 U.S.C. Secs. 1166 to 1168, inclusive, and 25 U.S.C. Sec. 2701 et seq.) between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, executed on August 31, 2017, is hereby ratified.
(b)(1)In deference to tribal sovereignty, none of the following shall be deemed a project for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code):
(A)The execution of an amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(B)The execution of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(C)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and a county or city government negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(D)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and the Department of Transportation, or other state agency, negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(E)The on-reservation impacts of compliance with the terms of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(2)Except as expressly provided in this section, this subdivision does not exempt a city, county, or city and county, or the Department of Transportation, or any state agency or local jurisdiction, from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act.
SEC. 2.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to enhance the economic development, stability, and self-sufficiency of the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, and to protect the interests of the tribe and its members, the surrounding community, and the California public at the earliest possible time, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)The tribal-state gaming compact entered into in accordance with the federal Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 (18 U.S.C. Secs. 1166 to 1168, inclusive, and 25 U.S.C. Sec. 2701 et seq.) between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, executed on August 31, 2017, is hereby ratified.
(b)(1)In deference to tribal sovereignty, none of the following shall be deemed a project for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code):
(A)The execution of an amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(B)The execution of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(C)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and a county or city government negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(D)The execution of an intergovernmental agreement between a tribe and the Department of Transportation, or other state agency, negotiated pursuant to the express authority of, or as expressly referenced in, the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(E)The on-reservation impacts of compliance with the terms of the tribal-state gaming compact ratified by this section.
(2)Except as expressly provided in this section, this subdivision does not exempt a city, county, or city and county, or the Department of Transportation, or any state agency or local jurisdiction, from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act.
SEC. 2.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to enhance the economic development, stability, and self-sufficiency of the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, and to protect the interests of the tribe and its members, the surrounding community, and the California public at the earliest possible time, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
SECTION 1.Section 89012 is added to the Education Code, to read:89012.On or before August 1, 2018, the California State University shall implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students. The multiple measures approach shall include, but not be limited to, placing significant weight on high school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates, on community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students, and on those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students to English and mathematics coursework.As a condition of receipt of state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, by On or before August 1, 2018, the trustees shall approve a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use multiple California State University shall implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students. The multiple measures approach shall place include, but not be limited to, placing significant weight on high school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates, on community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students, and on those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students to English and mathematics coursework.
As a condition of receipt of state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, by August 1, 2018, the trustees shall approve a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use multiple measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students. The multiple measures approach shall place significant weight on high school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates, on community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students, and on those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students to English and mathematics coursework.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 3, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 440, Statutes of 2017. |
| Oct 3, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 26, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 15, 2017 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 14, 2017 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 12, 2017 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 31, 2017 | From inactive file. |
| Jul 13, 2017 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Mendoza. |
| Jun 27, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 26, 2017 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 7, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 18, 2017 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 4, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 4, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 1389.) |
| Apr 27, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 26, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 26). |
| Apr 3, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 30, 2017 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 29, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (March 28). |
| Feb 21, 2017 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Feb 10, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 12. |
| Feb 9, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 15, 2017 | AB 394 Mathis Concurrence - Urgency Added | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 14, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB394 Mathis et al. By Vidak Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 7, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 4, 2017 | AB 394 MEDINA Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2017 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 28, 2017 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Catholic Conference, Inc. | ** Support | Jun 27, 2017 |
| California Nations Indian Gaming Association | ** Support | Sep 12, 2017 |
| California State University | ** Support | Jun 27, 2017 |
| Campaign For College Opportunity | ** Support | Jun 27, 2017 |
| Tule River Indian Tribe of California | ** Support | Sep 12, 2017 |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Mathis)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2017
2/3 vote. Urgency
ASSEMBLY: |
| (May 4, 2017) | SENATE: | 40-0 | (September 14, 2017) |
(vote not relevant)
Original Committee Reference: HIGHER ED.
SUMMARY: Ratifies a tribal-state Class III gaming compact (Compact) entered into between the State of California (State) and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California (Tribe), executed on August 31, 2017. Additionally, this bill provides that, in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions are not deemed projects for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA); and, stipulates, except as expressly provided, that none of the provisions shall be construed to exempt a city, county, or city and county, or the Department of Transportation from CEQA requirements.
The Senate amendments delete the Assembly version of the bill, and instead:
- Ratify a tribal-state Class III gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, a federally recognized Indian tribe, executed on August 31, 2017.
- Authorizes the Tribe to operate a maximum of 1,500 gaming devices (slot machines) at no more than two gaming facilities located within its existing Indian lands, as defined.
- States the Tribe has agreed to pay the State its pro rata share of costs the State incurs for the performance of its duties under this Compact, as specified.
- Provides the Tribe will contribute 6% of Net-Win from gaming devices, minus credits, to the Revenue Sharing Trust Fund (RSTF) and the Tribal Nation Grant Fund (TNGF), as specified.
- Provides the Tribe with annual credits of up to 100% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into the RSTF or the TNGF, if the Tribe operates 1,200 gaming devices, or less, or 80% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into these funds if the Tribe operates more than 1,200 gaming devices. These credits can be used for infrastructure improvements that benefit local jurisdictions and Tulare County, fire, law enforcement, public transit, education, tourism, and other services including renewable energy and conservation projects, as well as, payments to support capital improvements or operating expenses for facilities that provide health care services to tribal members and other members of the local community.
- This Compact: a) provides a regulatory framework that respects the role of the tribal gaming agency as the primary regulator while also ensuring that state gaming regulators fulfill their responsibilities; b) requires the Tribe to conduct its gaming activities pursuant to an internal control system that implements minimum internal controls that are no less stringent than those in federal regulations; c) requires the Tribe to adopt a Tribal Labor Relations Ordinance (TLRO), as specified; and, d) contains provisions to protect the health and safety of patrons, guests, and employees.
- Provide that, in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions are not deemed projects for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA); and, stipulate, except as expressly provided, that none of the provisions shall be construed to exempt a city, county, or city and county, or the Department of Transportation from CEQA requirements.
- Provide once effective, this Compact shall be in full force and effect for 25 years following the effective date.
- Contain an urgency clause, allowing this bill to take effect immediately upon enactment.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), for the negotiation and conclusion of compacts between federally recognized Indian tribes and the State for the purpose of conducting Class III gaming activities on Indian lands within a State as a means of promoting tribal economic development, self-sufficiency, and strong tribal governments.
- Authorizes expressly a number of tribal-state gaming compacts between the State of California and specified Indian tribes.
- Authorizes the conduct of Class III gaming activities to the extent such activities are permitted by state law, a gaming compact has been concluded by a federally recognized tribe and the State, and the compact has been approved by the Secretary of the Interior.
- Limits the operation of Class III gaming activities to Indian lands acquired on or before October 17, 1988. Provides for certain exceptions to conduct gaming activities on Indian lands acquired after October 17, 1988.
- Defines Indian lands to mean all lands within the limits of any Indian reservation, and any lands title to which is either held in trust by the United States (U.S.) for the benefit of any Indian tribe, or individual, or held by any Indian tribe or individual subject to restriction by the U.S. against alienation and over which an Indian tribe exercises governmental power.
- Requires the State to negotiate to conclude a compact in good faith with an Indian tribe having jurisdiction over the Indian lands upon which the Class III gaming activity is to be conducted. Provides the U.S. district courts with jurisdiction over any cause of action initiated by a tribal government alleging that the State failed to negotiate in good faith to conclude a compact. Prescribes the remedy, mediation supervised by the courts, if it is found that the State failed to negotiate in good faith to conclude a compact.
- Authorizes the Governor, under the California Constitution, to negotiate and conclude compacts, subject to ratification by the Legislature.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: On September 12, 2017, the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee held an informational hearing on the tribal-state gaming compact between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe.
Brief History and Background:
The Tule River Indian Tribe is a federally recognized tribe of Native Americans. The Tule River Reservation is the name of the Tribe's reservation, which is located in Tulare County, California. Currently, the Tribe has 1,866 members. A nine member Tribal Council governs the Tribe.
The Tribe historically inhabited lands in central California occupying the territory along the rivers and creeks flowing from the Sierras and around Tulare Lake. The Tribe's reservation was established in 1873 and encompasses over 90 square miles of land. The two nearest cities of size are Fresno, approximately 70 miles north of Porterville, and Bakersfield, which is approximately 50 miles south of Porterville. The Reservation is accessible only by one winding paved road that follows the meandering South Fork of the Tule River. The Tribe also owns 40 acres in the Porterville Airport Industrial Park and 79.9 acres in the foothill scenic development corridor along Highway 190. It has begun the process of obtaining a "two-part" determination that would make the land near the Airport eligible for gaming.
In 2000, the Tribe and the State entered into 2000 Compact. The gaming facility recently celebrated its twentieth anniversary, is one of the largest employers in Tulare County, and contributes revenue to fund critical tribal government services including healthcare, education, public safety, public works, social services, cultural, elder, youth and veteran's programs. The Eagle Mountain Casino operates nearly 1,200 slots, 10 table games including three poker tables, a gift shop, the Yokut's Coffee House and an Entertainment Center.
Besides the casino, the Tribe operates the Tule River Aero Industries (TRAI), which is a 20,000-square-foot facility that is an FAA major engine and airframe repair station equipped with a full line aircraft sales department. TRAI offers service expertise in both general and business aviation aircraft. In addition, the Tribe operates the Eagle Feather Trading Post, which is one of the largest convenience stores in Tulare County.
The Tribe operates a health center to meet the healthcare and health education needs of the Native American communities in Tulare County. An advisory board composed of Tribal members governs the health center.
The Governor's office states, "the provisions of this Compact are consistent with most of the recently ratified compacts." This Compact will help to assure the continued economic viability of the Tribe while also providing greater partnerships with the surrounding localities and services. It provides financial incentives to offset the impacts of the gaming facility including law enforcement and fire protection while also providing a means for the Tribe to develop local infrastructure (including water) for Tribal residents and the surrounding communities.
The Compact's preamble states, "This Compact will afford the Tribe primary responsibility over the regulation of its gaming facility and will enhance the Tribe's economic development and self-sufficiency.
Key Provisions of the Compact:
Scope of Class III Gaming Authorized: The Tribe is authorized to operate up to 1,500 gaming devices (slot machines), banking or percentage card games, and any devices or games that are authorized under state law to the California State Lottery, provided that the Tribe will not offer such games through use of the Internet unless others in the state are permitted to do so under state and federal law. The Tribe shall not be prohibited from offering Class II gaming or precluded from negotiating a separate compact governing the conduct of off-track wagering at the Tribe's gaming facility. The Tribe shall not engage in Class III gaming that is not expressly authorized in the Compact.
Authorized Gaming Facility: The Tribe may establish and operate not more than two gaming facilities and engage in Class III gaming only on lands that are, as of the execution date of this Compact, in trust and eligible for gaming under IGRA. If the Tribe chooses to operate more than one (1) gaming facility, then one (1) of the two (2) gaming facilities shall have no more than three hundred (300) gaming devices and shall have a primary purpose other than gaming authorized under IGRA. If additional land is placed in trust for the Tribe pursuant to 25 U.S.C. Section 2719(b)(1)(A) (federal "land-into-trust" process), the Tribe may request and the State shall agree to enter into negotiations to allow the Tribe to operate a gaming facility on that trust land.
Exclusivity: Provides that in the event the exclusive right of Indian tribes to operate Class III gaming in California pursuant to the California Constitution is lost and other non-Indian entities are able to engage in Class III gaming the Tribe shall have the right to terminate this Compact, in which case the Tribe will lose the right to operate Class III gaming authorized by this Compact; or continue under this Compact, as defined.
Tribal Ownership, Management, and Control of Gaming Operation: The gaming operation authorized under this Compact shall be owned solely by the Tribe.
Payments to the RSTF or the TNGF: The Compact provides that, if the Tribe operates more than 350 gaming devices at any time in a given calendar year, it shall 6% of the Net-Win from its operation of gaming devices in excess of 350 into the RSTF and TNGF.
The Tribe may apply annual credits against its payments to the RSTF and TNGF for its cost of services provided by the Tribe or payments by the Tribe to the County, the City, state agency, local jurisdictions and non-profit and civic organizations operating facilities or providing services within the County for fire, emergency medical services, law enforcement, public transit, road improvements, education, tourism, and other services and infrastructure improvements intended to serve off-reservation needs of local residents or the environment. The Compact provides that such payments shall be subject to approval by the State and at least 20% of the annual credits must be utilized for these purposes. Other purposes include:
- Payments made by the Tribe pursuant to agreements with Tulare County or Local Jurisdictions for reimbursement for any loss of property tax revenues, sales tax revenues and or transient occupancy tax that would otherwise be due for retail sales at the Tribe's gaming facility;
- Payments to support operating expenses and capital improvements for non-tribal governmental agencies or facilities operating within Tulare County or Local Jurisdictions;
- Investments by the Tribe and any funds paid to the State in renewable energy projects that, in part, serve the gaming facility or any improvements incorporating renewable energy technology on real property owned by the Tribe, or its members, and lineal descendants, and projects that incorporate charging stations for electric or other zero emission vehicles that are available to patrons and employees of the gaming facility, and the Tribe, its members and lineal descendants;
- Investments by the Tribe for infrastructure projects in furtherance of making potable water, water treatment, sewer, or conservation services available to the Tribe and the local community, or (ii) are in furtherance of potable water, water treatment, sewer or conservation projects that, in part, serve the Gaming Facility or the local community;
- Payments to support capital improvements and operating expenses for facilities within California that provide health care services to tribal members, Indians, and non-Indians;
- Payments to Indians who are not members of the Tribe, for educational, cultural or vocational purposes, or to other federally-recognized tribes for governmental or general welfare purposes;
- Payments to reimburse Tulare County or City of Porterville for any loss of property tax revenues by virtue of the loss of taxing authority over land subject to a federal trust acquisition, the existence of any tribal operations on federal trust land held for the benefit of the Tribe, sales tax revenues to Tulare County or the City of Porterville that would otherwise be due for retail sales at the Tribe's gaming facility or related business operations, transient occupancy tax, or utility users tax.
"Net-Win" is defined as the drop from gaming devices, plus the redemption value of expired tickets, less fills, less payouts, less that portion of the gaming operation's payments to a third-party wide-area progressive jackpot system provider that is contributed only to the progressive jackpot amount.
Payments to the Special Distribution Fund: Requires the Tribe to pay its pro-rata share into the SDF to cover the costs incurred by the State in the performance of its regulatory duties based upon the following formula: the maximum number of gaming devices operated in the casino for the previous fiscal year, divided by the maximum number of gaming devices operated by all federally recognized tribes in California pursuant to tribal-state Class III gaming compacts during the previous fiscal year, multiplied by the total costs the State incurs for the performance of all its duties under this Compact, equals the Tribe's pro rata share. Any increases in the pro-rata share are caped at no more than five-percent of the Tribes previous year pro-rata payment.
Additional Compact Components:
Gaming Ordinance and Regulations: All gaming activities conducted under this Compact shall, at a minimum, comply with: 1) a gaming ordinance duly adopted by the Tribe and approved in accordance with IGRA, 2) all rules, regulations, procedures, specifications, and standards duly adopted by the National Indian Gaming Commission (NIGC), the Tribal Gaming Agency, and the California Gambling Control Commission (CGCC), and 3) the provisions of this Compact, as specified.
Licensing Requirements and Procedures: The Compact provides that a copy of the Gaming Ordinance and all of its rules, regulations, procedures, specifications, ordinances, or standards applicable to the gaming activities and Gaming Operation shall be provided to the CGCC and Bureau upon request. Notice shall be given to the CGCC or Bureau of any change or amendments to any of the, rules, regulations, procedures, specifications, ordinances, or standards applicable to the gaming activities and gaming operation, no later than thirty (30) days after the change or amendment.
Additionally, the Compact compels all persons connected with the gaming operation or facility in any way, who are required to be licensed or to submit to a background investigation under IGRA, must be licensed by the Tribal Gaming Agency and cannot have had any determination of suitability denied or revoked by the CGCC. This includes all gaming employees, gaming resource suppliers, financial sources, and any other person having a significant influence over the gaming operation.
Minimum Internal Control Standards: The Compact requires the Tribe to conduct its gaming activities pursuant to an internal control system that implements MICS that are no less stringent than specified MICS of the NIGC. It requires gaming to operate pursuant to a written internal control system that reasonably assures that assets are safeguarded and accountability over assets is maintained, liabilities are properly recorded and contingent liabilities are properly disclosed, financial records are accurate and reliable, transactions are performed in accordance with the Tribe's authorization.
The Tribe is required to provide to the CGCC, upon written request, a copy of the independent certified public accountant agreed-upon procedures report conducted annually for submission to the NIGC pursuant to federal law. This report verifies that the gaming operation is in compliance with the NIGC's minimum internal control standards.
Patron Disputes: The Tribal Gaming Agency must promulgate regulations governing patron disputes over the play or operation of any game, including any refusal to pay to a patron any alleged winnings from any gaming activities that includes specified minimum standards.
A patron must make a written complaint to personnel of the Gaming Operation over the play or operation of any game within seven days of the play. The Gaming Operation must provide the patron with a written decision within 15 days of receipt of the initial complaint, and must provide written notice of the patron's right to request resolution of the dispute by the Tribal Gaming Agency if the Initial Complaint is not resolved to the patron's satisfaction. The patron must make the request to the Tribal Gaming Agency within 15 days of receiving the Gaming Operation’s written notice.
If dissatisfied with the resolution, the patron may seek resolution either in the Tribe's tribal court system, once a tribal court system is established, or before a three-member tribal claims commission. Any party dissatisfied with the award of the arbitrator may at the party's election invoke the JAMS Optional Arbitration Appeal Procedure.
The cost and expenses of arbitration shall be initially borne equally by the Tribe and the patron but the JAMS arbitrator shall award to the prevailing party its costs and expenses (but no attorney fees). The Tribe consents to the jurisdiction of the tribal court, tribal claims commission, JAMS Optional Appeal Procedure and any action to enforce their judgments or the obligations in this section.
Public and Workplace Liability: Requires the Tribe to obtain and maintain a commercial general liability insurance policy, which provides coverage of no less than $10 million. The Tribe must adopt a Tort Liability Ordinance stipulating that California tort law governs claims. The Tribe must consent to jurisdiction in the Tribe's tribal court system, once a tribal court system is established, or before a three-member tribal claims commission.
Any party dissatisfied with the award of the tribal venue may invoke the JAMS Optional Arbitration Appeal Procedure. The appeal will be based solely on the record developed in the tribal court or tribal claims commission proceedings. Factual determinations will not be set aside if supported by substantial evidence. The cost and expenses of arbitration shall be initially borne equally by the parties but the JAMS arbitrator shall award to the prevailing party its costs and expenses (but no attorney fees). The Tribe consents to the jurisdiction of the tribal court, tribal claims commission, JAMS Optional Appeal Procedure and any action to enforce their judgments or the obligations in this section.
Environmental Protections: The Tribe must prepare a Tribal Environmental Impact Report (TEIR) and negotiate mitigation of any off-reservation impacts, including an evaluation of energy efficiency, prior to initiating the development of a project for a facility. The Compact provides procedures regarding the (1) Notice of Preparation of Draft TEIR, (2) Notice of Completion of Draft TEIR, and (3) Issuance of Final TEIR.
The Tribe's failure to prepare an adequate TEIR when required may warrant an injunction where appropriate. Before commencement of a Project, and no later than the issuance of the final TEIR, the Tribe shall negotiate an intergovernmental agreement with the California Department of Transportation if state roads are impacted.
A binding agreement must also be negotiated with Imperial County to, amongst other things, provide for the timely mitigation of any significant effect on the off-reservation environment. This includes provisions relating to compensation for law enforcement, fire protection, emergency medical services and any other public services to be provided by the County to the Tribe as a consequence of the project.
Health and Safety Standards: The Tribe has agreed to comply with federal water quality and safe drinking water standards applicable in California. The Tribe has agreed to adopt and comply with tribal health standards for food and beverage handling that is no less stringent than State public health standards. The Tribe must also adopt and comply with federal and state laws forbidding harassment, including sexual harassment, discrimination and retaliation. In addition, the Tribe must maintain a $3 million insurance policy for these purposes and adopt an ordinance that includes a dispute resolution process.
Building Codes and Fire Safety: In order to assure the protection of the health and safety of all gaming facility patrons, guests, and employees, the Tribe shall adopt and shall maintain throughout the term of this Compact, an ordinance that requires any covered gaming facility construction to meet or exceed the applicable codes. Gaming facility construction, expansion, improvement, modification or renovation must also comply with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.
Emergency Services Accessibility: The Tribe shall make reasonable provisions for adequate emergency fire, medical, and related relief and disaster services for patrons and employees of the gaming facility.
Enhanced Audit and Compliance Review Procedures: In addition to providing for an annual independent audit, the Compact allows the state to conduct its own annual audit and compact compliance review of the gaming operation, gaming facility, and gaming activities to ensure compliance with all provisions of this Compact.
Inspection and Testing of Slot Machines: Gaming devices will have to be tested, approved and certified by an independent gaming test laboratory or state governmental gaming test laboratory to ensure they are being operated according to specified technical standards. Also, requires the CGCC to maintain adequate records that demonstrate compliance with software and hardware specifications. The CGCC would be authorized to annually conduct up to four random inspections of slot machines in operation to confirm that the slot machines are operating in conformance with these standards.
Labor Provisions: Provides that the gaming activities authorized by this Compact may only commence after the Tribe has adopted an ordinance identical to the Tribal Labor Relations Ordinance (TRLO) provided for in the Appendix of the Compact, and the gaming activities may only continue as long as the Tribe maintains the ordinance. If the Tribe employs 250 or more persons in a tribal casino facility, then the provisions of the TLRO become effective. The TLRO provides for a secret ballot election.
The TLRO provides for union neutrality. The Tribe will not oppose union but can advocate the benefits of working for the Tribe. A union must issue a Notice of Intent or Organize (NOIO). For a period of 365 days following delivery of a NOIO, the union shall not engage in strikes, picketing, boycotts, attack websites, or other economic activity at or in relation to the tribal casino or related facility. During the 365 days after the Tribe received the NOIO, the union must collect dated and signed authorization cards and complete the secret ballot election. Failure to complete the secret ballot election within 365 days shall preclude the union from delivering another NOIO for a period of 730 days.
After the certification that 30% of the employees have expressed an interest in the union, a notice of election shall be issues and the election shall be concluded within 30 calendar days thereafter. Secret ballot elections shall be held at workplace and at least one neutral location. Employee may mail ballots so long as received by election day. Union representation requires an affirmative vote of 50% plus one of all votes cast.
Mediation for any collective bargaining agreement impasse shall be resolved exclusively through the binding dispute resolution by three members of the Tribal Labor Panel, consisting of ten arbitrators appointed by a mutual selection of the parties. However, if arbitrator schedules cannot be coordinated within 30 days of submission, a single arbitrator shall decide the dispute. The arbitrators will generally follow the American Arbitration Association's procedural rules relating to labor dispute resolution.
Workers' Compensation: The Tribe agrees to participate in the state's workers' compensation program with respect to employees at the casino. All disputes arising from the workers' compensation laws shall be heard by the State Workers' Compensation Appeals Board pursuant to the California Labor Code. In lieu of participating in the State's workers' compensation system, the Tribe may create and maintain a system that provides redress for employee work-related injuries through requiring insurance or self-insurance, which system must include a scope of coverage, provision of up to $10,000 in medical treatment for an alleged injury until the date that liability for the claim is accepted or rejected. Furthermore, the Tribe agrees that it will participate in the state's unemployment compensation program for providing benefits and unemployment compensation disability benefits to employees at the gaming facility. The Tribe shall withhold all taxes due to the state, except for Tribal members living on the Tribe's reservation, and forward such amounts to the state.
Prohibitions Regarding Minors: The Tribe shall prohibit persons under the age of eighteen (18) years from being present in any room or area in which gaming activities are being conducted unless the person is en route to a non-gaming area of the gaming facility, or is employed at the Gaming Facility in a capacity other than as a gaming employee. If the Tribe permits the consumption of alcoholic beverages in the gaming facility, the Tribe shall prohibit persons under the age of twenty-one (21) years from purchasing, consuming, or possessing alcoholic beverages. The Tribe shall also prohibit persons under the age of twenty-one (21) years from being present in any room or area in which alcoholic beverages may be consumed, except to the extent permitted by the State Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control for other commercial establishments serving alcoholic beverages.
Alcoholic Beverage Service: Purchase, sale, and service of alcoholic beverages by or to patrons shall be subject to state alcoholic beverage laws.
Tobacco Provisions: The Tribe agrees to provide a non-smoking area in the gaming facility and to utilize a ventilation system throughout the gaming facility that exhausts tobacco smoke to the extent reasonably feasible. The Tribe agrees not to offer or sell tobacco or e-cigarettes to anyone younger than the minimum age of 18.
Problem Gambling: The gaming operation must establish a program, approved by the Tribal Gaming Agency, to mitigate pathological and problem gaming by implementing specified measures.
Amendment by Agreement: The terms and conditions of this Compact may be amended at any time by the mutual and written agreement of both parties during the term of this Compact, as specified, provided that each party voluntarily consents to such negotiations, including the scope of such negotiations, in writing. Any amendments to this Compact shall be deemed to supersede, supplant and extinguish all previous understandings and agreements on the subject.
Effective Date: The Compact shall not be effective unless and until all of the following have occurred: (a) the Compact is ratified by statute in accordance with state law and, (b) notice of approval or constructive approval is published in the Federal Register. Once effective, this Compact shall be in full force and effect until 25 years (2042) following the effective date.
Additional Background Information:
Compact Ratification: The State Constitution, as amended by Proposition 1A of March 2000, permits Indian tribes to conduct and operate slot machines, lottery games, and banked and percentage card games on Indian land. These gambling activities shall only occur if:
- The Governor and an Indian tribe reach agreement on a compact;
- The Legislature approves the compact, and
- The federal government approves the compact.
The Governor is the designated State officer responsible for negotiating and executing, on behalf of the State, Tribal-State gaming compacts with federally recognized Indian tribes located within the State of California. Following completion of negotiations, the Governor shall submit a copy of any executed Tribal-State compact to both houses of the Legislature for ratification and shall submit a copy of the executed compact to the Secretary of State. This Compact provides that it shall not be presented to the Legislature for a ratification vote until the Tribe has provided the written proof and will provide written proof to the Governor the tribal governing body has ratified it.
The Federal Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) of 1988: In 1988, Congress enacted the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) to provide a statutory basis for the operation and regulation of gaming on Indian lands. IGRA provides that an Indian tribe may conduct gaming activity on Indian lands if the activity "is not specifically prohibited by federal law and is conducted within a State which does not prohibit such gaming activity."
IGRA distinguishes between three classes of gaming (Class I, Class II, and Class III) and provides for different forms of regulation for each class. Class I gaming includes "social games" for minor prizes or "traditional forms of Indian gaming." Class II gaming is defined to include bingo and card games that are explicitly authorized by the laws of the state, or that are not explicitly prohibited by the laws of the state and are played at any location in the State, so long as the card games are played in conformity with those laws and regulations. Class III gaming includes such things as slot machines, casino games and banked card games such as black jack and baccarat. Class III gaming may only be conducted under terms of a compact negotiated between an Indian tribe and a State.
IGRA was enacted against a legal background in which Indian tribes and individuals generally are exempt from state taxation within their own territory. IGRA provides that with the exception of assessments permitted under the statute, to defray the State's costs of regulating gaming activity, IGRA shall not be interpreted as conferring upon a State authority to impose any tax, fee, charge, or other assessment upon an Indian tribe to engage in Class III activity. Nor may a State refuse to enter into negotiations based on the lack of authority to impose such a tax, fee, charge, or other assessment.
When a tribe requests negotiations for a Class III compact, IGRA requires the State to negotiate with the Indian tribe in good faith. IGRA provides a comprehensive process to prevent an impasse in compact negotiations, which is triggered when a tribe files suit alleging that the State has refused to negotiate or has failed to negotiate in good faith.
Rincon Decision: In 2004, the Rincon Band of Mission Indians sued the State in federal court after negotiations for a new gambling agreement with then-Governor Schwarzenegger came to a standstill. The Tribe believed the Governor was violating federal law by insisting that tribes pay money into the state's General Fund in exchange for more slot machines.
In July 2011, the United States Supreme Court declined to review a Ninth Circuit Court's decision that ruled the state could not require the Rincon Band tribe to pay a percentage of slot machine revenue into California's General Fund for more gaming devices. The Ninth Circuit had affirmed a lower court decision that the new financial concessions were nothing more than a state tax on tribal casino revenues, which is prohibited by IGRA. The court concluded that a "non-negotiable, mandatory payment of 10% of net win into the State treasury for unrestricted use yields public revenue and is [therefore] a tax and that the court was therefore required to consider the State's demand as evidence of bad faith under IGRA's statutes."
The Rincon decision has changed the dynamics of tribal-state compact negotiations in California.
Special Distribution Fund (SDF): Existing law creates the SDF in the State Treasury for the receipt of revenue contributions made by tribal governments pursuant to the terms of the 1999 model Tribal-State Gaming compacts and authorizes the Legislature to appropriate money from the SDF for the following purposes: 1) grants for programs designed to address gambling addiction; 2) grants for the support of state and local government agencies impacted by tribal government gaming; 3) compensation for regulatory costs incurred by CGCC and the DOJ in connection with the implementation and administration of compacts; 4) payment of shortfalls that may occur in the Indian Gaming RSTF; 5) disbursements for the purpose of implementing the terms of tribal labor relations ordinances promulgated in accordance with the terms of the 1999 compacts; and, 6) any other purpose specified by law. The distribution formula "sunsets" on January 1, 2021.
Revenue Sharing Trust Fund: Existing law also creates in the State Treasury the RSTF for the receipt and deposit of moneys derived from gaming device license fees that are paid into the RSTF pursuant to the terms of specified tribal-state gaming compacts for the purpose of making distributions to non-compacted tribes (e.g., federally-recognized non-gaming and tribes that operate casinos with fewer than 350 slot machines). Revenue in the RSTF is available to CGCC, upon appropriation by the Legislature, for making distributions of $1.1 million annually to non-compact tribes. The RSTF was created as part of the 1999 compacts, which, in conjunction with the passage of Proposition 1A (2000), created gaming compacts with approximately 60 California tribes. Non-compact tribes are considered third-party beneficiaries of the 1999 compacts.
Tribal Nation Grant Fund: The TNGF was created in the Graton Rancheria compact (AB 517 (Hall), Chapter 12, Statutes of 2012), as a new destination for gaming revenue for distribution of funds to non-gaming and limited-gaming tribes, upon application of such tribes for purposes related to effective self-governance, self-determined community, and economic development. The fund is designed to be fluid and payments are intended to be made to non-gaming tribes on a "need" basis, upon application by non-gaming tribes. The TNGF currently does not receive funding.
Related legislation: SB 6 (Hueso) of the current legislative session, would ratify the amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Quechan Tribe of the Fort Yuma Indian Reservation, executed on August 31, 2017.
SB 626 (Dodd) of the current legislative session, would ratify the amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, executed on August 18, 2017.
SB 585 (Mendoza and McGuire) of the current legislative session, would ratify the amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Dry Creek Rancheria Band of Pomo Indians, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 174 (Bigelow) of the current legislative session, would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the United Auburn Indian Community, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 253 (Bigelow) of the current legislative session, would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tuolumne Band of Me-Wuk Indians, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 891 (Mayes) of the current legislative session, would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Morongo Band of Mission Indians, executed on September 6, 2017.
AB 1606 (Cooper) of the current legislative session, would ratify the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Wilton Rancheria, executed on July 19, 2017.
AB 1378 (Gray) of the current legislative session, would ratify an amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians, executed on August 18, 2017.
Prior legislation: Proposition 1A (Adopted by the People of California on March 7, 2000) modified the prohibition against casinos and lotteries in the California Constitution to authorize the Governor to negotiate compacts, subject to legislative ratification, for the operation of slot machines, lottery games, and banking and percentage card games by federally recognized Indian tribes on Indian lands in California, in accordance with federal law. Authorized slot machines, lottery games, and banking and percentage card games to be conducted and operated on Indian lands subject to the compacts.
AB 1385 (Battin), Chapter 874, Statutes of 1999, designated the Governor as the state officer responsible for negotiating and executing compacts between the state and federally recognized Indian tribes located in the state. Also, ratified 57 compacts (Tule River Indian Tribe of California) and created two special funds in the State Treasury (SDF and RSTF), as specified.
Proposition 5 (Adopted by the People of California on November 3, 1998) specified the terms and conditions of mandatory compacts between the State and tribal governments for class III gambling on Indian lands; amended California law to allow slot machines and banked card games at tribal casinos; provided for contributions to trust funds benefiting non-gaming tribes, statewide emergency medical care programs, and programs benefiting communities near tribes; and, allowed tribes to retain a monopoly on authorized gambling. Proposition 5 was found to be unconstitutional because it amended a provision of the Government Code and did not amend the Constitution. The proposition was invalidated in its entirety, save the final sentence of Government Code Section 98005, containing the state's consent to federal suits brought by California tribes pursuant to IGRA.
SB 287 (Burton), Chapter 409, Statutes of 1998, ratified 11 compacts negotiated between the State of California and Indian tribes that permitted class III video gaming devices on tribal lands and established a process for ratifying other compacts.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Johnson / G.O. / (916) 319-2531 FN: 0002320
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 394
:
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
NOTE: On September 12, 2017, the Senate Governmental Organization Committee held an informational hearing on the tribal-state gaming compact between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California, executed on August 31, 2017.
DIGEST:
This bill ratifies the tribal-state compact (Compact) entered into between the State of California and the Tule River Indian Tribe of California (hereafter “Tribe”) executed on August 31, 2017.
Existing law:
- Provides, under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), for the negotiation and conclusion of compacts between federally recognized Indian tribes and the State for the purpose of conducting Class III gaming activities on Indian lands within a State as a means of promoting tribal economic development, self-sufficiency, and strong tribal governments.
- Authorizes expressly a number of tribal-state gaming compacts between the State of California and specified Indian tribes.
- Authorizes the conduct of Class III gaming activities to the extent such activities are permitted by state law, a gaming compact has been concluded by a federally recognized tribe and the State, and the compact has been approved by the Secretary of the Interior.
- Limits the operation of Class III gaming activities to Indian lands acquired on or before October 17, 1988. Provides for certain exceptions to conduct gaming activities on Indian lands acquired after October 17, 1988.
- Defines “Indian lands” to mean all lands within the limits of any Indian reservation, and any lands title to which is either held in trust by the United States for the benefit of any Indian tribe, or individual, or held by any Indian tribe or individual subject to restriction by the U.S. against alienation and over which an Indian tribe exercises governmental power.
- Requires the State to negotiate to conclude a compact in good faith with an Indian tribe having jurisdiction over the Indian lands upon which the Class III gaming activity is to be conducted. Provides the U.S. district courts with jurisdiction over any cause of action initiated by a tribal government alleging that the State failed to negotiate in good faith to conclude a compact. Prescribes the remedy, mediation supervised by the courts, if it is found that the State failed to negotiate in good faith to conclude a compact.
- Authorizes the Governor, under the California Constitution, to negotiate and conclude compacts, subject to ratification by the Legislature.
This bill:
- Ratifies the Compact between the State of California and the Tribe executed on August 31, 2017.
- Provides that in deference to tribal sovereignty, certain actions are not deemed projects for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
- Stipulates, except as expressly provided, that none of the provisions shall be construed to exempt a city, county, or city, and county, or the Department of Transportation, or any state agency or local jurisdictions, from CEQA requirements.
- Contains an urgency clause.
Background
The Compact between the State of California and the Tribe was executed on August 31, 2017.
The Compact authorizes the Tribe to operate a maximum of 1,500 slot machines at no more than two gaming facilities located on eligible Indian lands held in trust for the Tribe, and located within the boundaries of the Tribe’s reservation.
The Tribe has agreed to pay the State its pro rata share of costs the State incurs for the performance of its duties under the Compact. The State agrees to provide the Tribe with annual credits for up to 100% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into the Revenue Sharing Trust Fund (RSTF) or Tribal Nation Grant Fund (TNGF) if the Tribe operates 1,200 slot machines, or less, or 80% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into these funds if the Tribe operates more than 1,200 slot machines for infrastructure improvements that benefit city and county residents, fire, law enforcement, public transit, education, tourism, and other services including renewable energy and conservation projects, as well as, payments to support capital improvements or operating expenses for facilities that provide health care services to tribal members and other members of the local community. According to the Governor’s Office, the Tribe currently pays approximately $500,000 to the RSTF.
According to the Governor’s Office, certain terms of the Compact related to licensing, regulatory, environmental mitigation, patron protection, labor, public health and safety provisions are substantially the same as recent compacts.
The Compact’s preamble notes that this Compact protects the interests of the Tribe and its members, the surrounding community, and the California public, and will promote and secure long-term stability, mutual respect, and mutual benefits.
The Compact’s preamble also notes that the Eagle Mountain Casino, which is operated by the Tribe, recently celebrated its 20th anniversary. The Casino is one of the largest employers in Tulare County (County), and contributes revenue to fund critical tribal government services including healthcare, education, public safety, public works, social services, cultural, elder, youth and veteran’s programs.
Once effective (legislative ratification and federal approval required), this Compact will be in full force and effect for 25 years following the effective date.
Brief History of the Tule River Indian Tribe of California. Established in 1873, the Tule River Tribe Reservation includes about 58,000 acres situated on the western slope of the Sierra Nevada Mountains, east of Porterville, and lies almost entirely within the South Fork Tule River drainage basin. The topography is generally steep, with elevations ranging from about 900 to 7,500 feet above sea level.
Most of the inhabited land is along the lower reach of the South Fork Tule River on the western side of the Reservation. The Tribe also owns 40 acres in the Porterville Airport Industrial Park and 80 acres in the foothill scenic development corridor along Highway 190.
Tribal members are descendants of the Yokuts Indians, a large group of linguistically-related people who occupied the vast San Joaquin Valley, and most of the adjoining foothills that surround the Valley in California for thousands of years prior to contact with Euroamerican settlers. Historically there were over 50 independent clans of Yokuts, each with its own territory and dialect of the Yokuts language.
The Tribe has been plagued with unemployment and mortality rates substantially higher and a standard of living substantially lower, than is experienced by the surrounding non-Indian communities. While the on-Reservation socio-economic conditions have improved over time, to this day, Reservation residents generally continue to suffer from a relatively low standard of living.
There are approximately 1,800 members currently enrolled in the Tribe. The Tribe is governed by a nine-member council. The council oversees 31 different departments including Natural Resources, Fire, and Public Safety. Aside from the casino, 389 people are employed by the Tribe with 257 being Native American. The Tribe currently operates the Eagle Mountain Casino which includes approximately 1,100 slot machines, 10 table games, a gift shop, the Yokut’s Coffee House and an entertainment Center. The Casino is one of the largest employers in Tulare County and provides family wages to its 486 employees.
KEY PROVISIONS OF THE COMPACT
Scope of Class III Gaming Authorized. The Tribe is authorized to operate up to 1,500 slot machines, banking or percentage card games, and any devices or games that are authorized under state law to the California State Lottery, provided that the Tribe will not offer such games through use of the Internet unless others in the state not affiliated with or licensed by the California State Lottery are permitted to do so under state and federal law. The Tribe shall not engage in Class III Gaming that is not expressly authorized in the Compact.
Authorized Gaming Facility. The Tribe may establish and operate no more than two gaming facilities and engage in Class III gaming only on eligible Indian lands held in trust for the Tribe, located within the boundaries of the Tribe’s reservation. If the Tribe chooses to operate more than one gaming facility, then one of the two gaming facilities shall have no more than 300 slot machines and shall have a primary purpose other than gaming.
Payments to the Special Distribution Fund (SDF). The Tribe shall pay to the State, on a pro rata basis, the costs the State incurs for the performance of all its duties under this Compact, as established by the monies appropriated in the annual Budget Act for the performance of their duties under the Class III Gaming Compacts.
Payments to the RSTF or the TNGF. The Tribe shall pay into the RSTF or the TNGF an amount equal to 6% of the Net Win, as defined, on slot machines in excess of 350 slot machines. According to the Governor’s Office, the Tribe currently operates approximately 1,100 slot machines under their 1999 tribal state compact.
“Net Win” is defined as the drop from gaming devices (slot machines), plus the redemption value of expired tickets, less fills, less payouts, less that portion of the gaming operation’s payment to a third-party wide-area progressive jackpot system provider that is contributed only to the progressive jackpot amount. Generally, the difference between patron wagers and the payouts made on winning wagers.
Credits Applied to the RSTF or the TNGF. The State agrees to provide the Tribe with annual credits for up to 100% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into the RSTF or TNGF if the Tribe operates 1,200 slot machines, or less, or 80% of the payments otherwise due to be paid into these funds if the Tribe operates more than 1,200 slot machines for infrastructure improvements that benefit city and county residents, fire, law enforcement, public transit, education, tourism, and other services including renewable energy and conservation projects, as well as, payments to support capital improvements or operating expenses for facilities that provide health care services to tribal members and other members of the local community.
ADDITIONAL COMPACT COMPONENTS
Gaming Ordinance and Regulations. All gaming activities conducted under this Compact shall, at a minimum, comply with a gaming ordinance duly adopted by the Tribe and approved in accordance with IGRA and all applicable rules, regulations, procedures, specifications, and standards duly adopted by the National Indian Gaming Commission, the Tribal Gaming Agency, and the State Gaming Agency, and with the provisions of this Compact, as specified.
Prohibitions Regarding Minors. The Tribe shall prohibit persons under the age 18 years from being present in any room or area in which gaming activities are being conducted unless the person is en route to a non-gaming area of the gaming facility, or is employed at the gaming facility in a capacity other than as a gaming employee. If the Tribe permits the consumption of alcoholic beverages in the Gaming Facility, the Tribe shall prohibit persons under the age of 21 from purchasing, consuming, or possessing alcoholic beverages. The Tribe shall also prohibit persons under the age of 21 from being present in any room or area in which alcoholic beverages may be consumed.
Problem Gambling. The gaming operation must establish a program, approved by the Tribal Gaming Agency, to mitigate pathological and problem gaming by implementing specified measures.
Patron Disputes. The Tribal Gaming Agency must promulgate regulations governing patron disputes over the play or operation of any game, including any refusal to pay to a patron any alleged winnings from any gaming activities that includes specified minimum standards.
Environmental Protections. The Tribe is required to prepare a comprehensive and adequate tribal environmental impact report (TEIR), analyzing the potentially significant off-reservation environmental impacts of the project. The TEIR is required to provide detailed information about the significant effects on the environment that the project is likely to have and shall include a detailed statement of specified information. The Compact provides procedures regarding the Notice of Preparation of Draft TEIR, Notice of Completion of Draft TEIR, and Issuance of Final TEIR.
Tobacco Provisions. The Tribe agrees to provide a non-smoking area in the gaming facility and to utilize a ventilation system throughout the gaming facility that exhausts tobacco smoke to the extent reasonably feasible under state-of-the-art technology existing as of the date of the construction or significant renovation of the gaming facility, and further agrees not to offer or sell tobacco products, including but not limited to smokeless tobacco products or e-cigarettes, to anyone under 18 years of age in the gaming facility.
Alcohol Provisions. Makes it explicit that the purchase, sale, and service of alcoholic beverages shall be subject to state law – the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act.
Labor Provisions. Provides that the gaming activities authorized by this Compact may only commence after the Tribe has adopted an ordinance identical to the Tribal Labor Relations Ordinance (TRLO), referenced as Appendix B of the Compact, and the gaming activities may only continue as long as the Tribe maintains the ordinance. If the Tribe employs 250 or more persons in a tribal casino facility, then the provisions of the TLRO become effective. The TLRO provides for a secret ballot election and union neutrality. After the certification that 30% of the eligible employees in a bargaining unit have expressed an interest in the union, a notice of election shall be issued and the election shall be concluded within 30 calendar days thereafter. Employees may mail in ballots provided they are received by election day. Union representation requires an affirmative vote of 50% plus one of all votes cast.
Effective Date. This Compact shall not be effective unless and until all of the following have occurred: the Compact is ratified by statute in accordance with state law and notice of approval or constructive approval is published in the Federal Register. Once effective, this Compact shall be in full force and effect for 25 years following the effective date.
Amendment by Agreement. The terms and conditions of this Compact may be amended at any time by the mutual and written agreement of both parties, provided that each party voluntarily consents to such negotiations in writing. Any amendments to this Compact shall be deemed to supersede, supplant and extinguish all previous understandings and agreements on the subject.
ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND INFORMATION
IGRA. In 1988, Congress enacted IGRA to provide a statutory basis for the operation and regulation of gaming on Indian lands. IGRA provides that an Indian tribe may conduct gaming activity on Indian lands if the activity “is not specifically prohibited by federal law and is conducted within a State which does not prohibit such gaming activity.”
IGRA distinguishes between three classes of gaming (Class I, Class II, and Class III) and provides for different forms of regulation for each class. Class I gaming includes “social games” for minor prizes or “traditional forms of Indian gaming.” Class II gaming is defined to include bingo and card games that are explicitly authorized by the laws of the state, or that are not explicitly prohibited by the laws of the state and are played at any location in the State, so long as the card games are played in conformity with those laws and regulations. Class III gaming includes such things as slot machines, casino games, and banked card games such as black jack and baccarat. Class III gaming may only be conducted under terms of a compact negotiated between an Indian tribe and a State.
IGRA was enacted against a legal background in which Indian tribes and individuals generally are exempt from state taxation within their own territory. IGRA provides that with the exception of assessments permitted under the statute, to defray the State’s costs of regulating gaming activity, IGRA shall not be interpreted as conferring upon a State authority to impose any tax, fee, charge, or other assessment upon an Indian tribe to engage in Class III activity. Nor may a State refuse to enter into negotiations based on the lack of authority to impose such a tax, fee, charge, or other assessment.
When a tribe requests negotiations for a Class III compact, IGRA requires the State to negotiate with the Indian tribe in good faith. IGRA provides a comprehensive process to prevent an impasse in compact negotiations, which is triggered when a tribe files suit alleging that the State has refused to negotiate or has failed to negotiate in good faith.
Before 2000, the California Constitution prohibited Class III gaming. In 2000, California voters approved Proposition 1A, which had been proposed by the Governor and passed by the Legislature. Proposition 1A amended the California Constitution to permit the State to negotiate compacts with federally recognized Indian tribes for certain Class III gaming activities. Because non-Indian parties were still forbidden from operating gaming facilities, Proposition 1A granted Indian tribes a “constitutionally protected monopoly on most types of Class III games in California.”
SDF. Existing law creates the SDF in the State Treasury for the receipt of revenue contributions made by tribal governments pursuant to the terms of the 1999 model Tribal-State Gaming Compacts and authorizes the Legislature to appropriate money from the SDF for the following purposes: grants for programs designed to address gambling addiction; grants for the support of state and local government agencies impacted by tribal government gaming; compensation for regulatory costs incurred by the California Gambling Control Commission (CGCC) and Department of Justice in connection with the implementation and administration of compacts; payment of shortfalls that may occur in the RSTF; disbursements for the purpose of implementing the terms of tribal labor relations ordinances promulgated in accordance with the terms of the 1999 compacts; and, any other purpose specified by law. (Pursuant to compact renegotiations that took place with several of the larger gaming tribes during the Schwarzenegger administration, revenue from those tribes is directed into the state General Fund, instead of the SDF.)
Current law establishes a method of calculating the distribution of appropriations from the SDF for grants to local government agencies impacted by tribal gaming. This method includes a requirement that the State Controller, in consultation with the CGCC, deposit funds into County Tribal Casino Accounts and Individual Tribal Casino Accounts based upon a process that takes into consideration whether the county has tribes that pay, or do not pay, into the SDF.
RSTF. Existing law creates in the State Treasury the RSTF for the receipt and deposit of moneys derived from gaming device license fees that are paid into the RSTF pursuant to the terms of specified tribal-state gaming compacts for the purpose of making distributions to non-compacted California tribes (e.g., federally-recognized non-gaming tribes and tribes that operate casinos with fewer than 350 slot machines). Revenue in the RSTF is available to CGCC, upon appropriation by the Legislature, for making distributions of $1.1 million annually to non-compact tribes. The RSTF was created as part of the 1999 compacts, which, in conjunction with the passage of Proposition 1A, created gaming compacts with approximately 60 California tribes. Non-compact tribes are considered third-party beneficiaries of the 1999 compacts.
TNGF. This particular fund (referenced in recent compacts) was created to complement the RSTF and provides for the distribution of funds to non-gaming tribes, upon application of such tribes for purposes related to effective self-governance, self-determined community, and economic development. Payments from this fund are intended to be made to non-gaming tribes on a “need” basis, upon application. Payments from the TNGF are expected to begin in 2018.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 6 (Hueso, 2017) ratifies the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Quechan Tribe of the Fort Yuma Indian Reservation.
SB 585 (McGuire, 2017) ratifies the tribal state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Dry Creek Rancheria Band of Pomo Indians, executed on August 18, 2017.
SB 626 (Dodd, 2017) ratifies the amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 174 (Bigelow, 2017) ratifies the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the United Auburn Indian Community, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 253 (Bigelow, 2017) ratifies the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Tuolumne Band of Me-Wuk Indians, executed on August 18, 2017.
AB 891 (Mathis, 2017) ratifies the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Morongo Band of Mission Indians, executed on September 6, 2017.
AB 1606 (Cooper, 2017) ratifies the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the Wilton Rancheria, executed on July 19, 2017.
AB 1378 (Gray, 2017) ratifies the amendment to the tribal-state gaming compact entered into between the State of California and the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians executed on August 18, 2017.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
Tule River Indian Tribe of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/12/17)
None received
9/12/17 21:25:18
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 394
:
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/7/17
AYES: Allen, Wilk, Galgiani, Leyva, Mendoza, Pan, Vidak
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/4/17 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill requires, by August 1, 2018, the California State University (CSU) to implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Donahoe Higher Education, setting forth the mission of the CSU (Education Code (EC) § 66010, et seq.).
- Requires that the CSU be administered by a board designated as the Trustees of the CSU (EC § 66600).
This bill:
- Requires, by August 1, 2018, the CSU to implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students.
- Requires the multiple measures approach to include, but not limited to, placing significant weight on:
- High school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates.
- Community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students.
- Those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students English and mathematics coursework.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “studies show that nearly one-third of students are misplaced when they enter higher education due to the use of placement assessments that are not comprehensive enough, and end up placing students in lower courses than they should be enrolled in, or the incorrect courses altogether, which sets them up for potential failure to earn a college degree or credential.” This bill seeks to ensure the use of high school transcript data when assessing a student for course placement at a CSU in order to improve the accuracy of that student’s placement.
- Remedial education. Remedial education is intended to help students who are assessed as “unprepared” to succeed in college-level work. The traditional approach to remedial education is based on placement test scores. Colleges place a student who underperforms on placement tests into a sequence of developmental/college-prep courses prior to that student enrolling in college-level English and math courses. Concerns have been raised that this approach results in college-ready students being misplaced into remedial courses and extends time in school. According to the Campaign for College Opportunity, a growing body of research is finding that students are not nearly as “unprepared” for college-level work as believed and that the reliance solely on placement tests is a weak predictor of student success. A better way to assess college readiness is to use multiple measures, where student placement is determined by high school grades and other measures — not just a single test score.
- CSU Early Assessment/Early Start Program. In 2010, to address concerns regarding the large number of incoming freshmen at the CSU requiring remediation, Executive Order 1048 was issued, creating the Early Start Program. Entering freshmen not proficient in math or “at risk” in English are required to start the remediation process before their first term at CSU. Students are given a menu of options to determine the best approach to start their remedial instruction, including senior year high school courses, courses offered in the summer at any one of their local California Community College or CSU campuses and online courses. Legislation enacted in 2012 (AB 2497, Solorio, Chapter 430, Statutes of 2012) required the CSU to work with the Legislative Analyst’s office (LAO) on an ongoing series of reports showing the impact of CSU’s Early Start Program on students needing remediation.
Additionally, CSU’s Early Assessment Program (EAP) provides a measure of college readiness to high school students in their junior year. If junior–year students demonstrate proficiency in both English and math based on the EAP (includes several standardized exam options), they are deemed college ready. Students who receive a score of “conditional” or “conditionally ready” on the EAP can demonstrate proficiency by enrolling in an approved math or English course during their senior year and earning a C grade or better. If students do not demonstrate proficiency “not yet ready” or “not ready” through the EAP, they are required to take an additional math and/or English placement exam. Finally if a student fails passage on those exams the student is required to participate in the CSU Early Start program. This series of placement measures is intended to provide students with several opportunities to demonstrate college readiness prior to attending their first college term.
- Use of multiple measures for placement. As noted, CSU campuses utilize multiple measures of assessment to determine readiness and competencies in English and Math which includes the use of tests already taken by students in high school including the ACT, Advance Placement Scores, SAT or EAP as well as courses taken in the senior year in English and Mathematics. Multiple assessment opportunities occur over time which begins in 11th grade and extends through the summer before in the first fall term at a CSU campus. Concerns have been raised that although multiple measures of assessment are utilized, these measures are primarily based on test results with few exceptions.
This bill requires CSU multiple measure approach to include and place significant weight on high school transcript data or community college transcript data (i.e. GPA or course grades) to determine college readiness.
- Remediation rates at CSU. On March 1, 2017, the Senate Education Committee convened an oversight hearing on remedial education in California. The background paper for the hearing provided by the LAO, “Overview of Remedial Education at the State’s Higher Education Segments,” noted that more than 40 percent of first time CSU students are identified as unprepared. The paper also revealed that unprepared students are less likely to graduate with a 20 percentage point difference in graduation rates between incoming students assessed as college-ready versus not college-ready.
According to CSU, “the policy and timeline outlined in this bill align with CSU’s intent to develop an enhanced set of academic preparation policies that will help more students achieve CSU academic standards and position themselves for academic success and degree completion.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California State University
California Catholic Conference, INC.
Campaign for College Opportunity
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/26/17)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/4/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte,
O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Cristina Garcia, Patterson
6/27/17 17:04:46
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Benjamin Allen, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 7, 2017
Author: | |||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
SUMMARY
This bill requires, by August 1, 2018, the California State University (CSU) to implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students.
BACKGROUND
- Establishes the Donahoe Higher Education, setting forth the mission of the CSU (Education Code (EC) § 66010, et seq.).
- Requires that the CSU be administered by a board designated as the Trustees of the CSU (EC § 66600).
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires, by August 1, 2018, the CSU to implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students.
- Requires the multiple measures approach to include, but not limited to, placing significant weight on:
- High school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high
school graduates.
- Community college transcript data in the assessment of community
college transfer students.
- Those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students English
and mathematics coursework.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “studies show that nearly one-third of students are misplaced when they enter higher education due to the use of placement assessments that are not comprehensive enough, and end up placing students in lower courses than they should be enrolled in, or the incorrect courses altogether, which sets them up for potential failure to earn a college degree or credential.” This bill seeks to ensure the use of high school transcript data when assessing a student for course placement at a California State University (CSU) in order to improve the accuracy of that student’s placement.
- Remedial education. Remedial education is intended to help students who are assessed as “unprepared” to succeed in college-level work. The traditional approach to remedial education is based on placement test scores. Colleges place a student who underperforms on placement tests into a sequence of developmental/college-prep courses prior to that student enrolling in college-level English and math courses. Concerns have been raised that this approach results in college-ready students being misplaced into remedial courses and extends time in school. According to the Campaign for College Opportunity, a growing body of research is finding that students are not nearly as “unprepared” for college-level work as believed and that the reliance solely on placement tests is a weak predictor of student success. A better way to assess college readiness is to use multiple measures, where student placement is determined by high school grades and other measures — not just a single test score.
- CSU Early Assessment/Early Start Program. In 2010, to address concerns regarding the large number of incoming freshmen at the CSU requiring remediation, Executive Order 1048 was issued, creating the Early Start Program. Entering freshmen not proficient in math or “at risk” in English are required to start the remediation process before their first term at CSU. Students are given a menu of options to determine the best approach to start their remedial instruction, including senior year high school courses, courses offered in the summer at any one of their local California Community College or CSU campuses and online courses. Legislation enacted in 2012 (AB 2497, Solorio), required the CSU to work with the Legislative Analyst’s office (LAO) on an ongoing series of reports showing the impact of CSU’s Early Start Program on students needing remediation.
Additionally, CSU’s Early Assessment Program (EAP) provides a measure of college readiness to high school students in their junior year. If junior–year students demonstrate proficiency in both English and math based on the EAP (includes several standardized exam options), they are deemed college ready. Students who receive a score of “conditional” or “conditionally ready” on the EAP can demonstrate proficiency by enrolling in an approved math or English course during their senior year and earning a C grade or better. If students do not demonstrate proficiency “not yet ready” or “not ready” through the EAP, they are required to take an additional math and/or English placement exam. Finally if a student fails passage on those exams the student is required to participate in the CSU Early Start program. This series of placement measures is intended to provide students with several opportunities to demonstrate college readiness prior to attending their first college term.
- Use of multiple measures for placement. As noted, California State University (CSU) campuses utilize multiple measures of assessment to determine readiness and competencies in English and Math which includes the use of tests already taken by students in high school including the ACT, Advance Placement Scores, SAT or California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (EAP) as well as courses taken in the senior year in English and Mathematics. Multiple assessment opportunities occur over time which begins in 11th grade and extends through the summer before in the first fall term at a CSU campus. Concerns have been raised that although multiple measures of assessment are utilized, these measures are primarily based on test results with few exceptions.
This bill requires California State University (CSU) multiple measure approach to include and place significant weight on high school transcript data or community college transcript data (i.e. GPA or course grades) to determine college readiness.
- Remediation rates at CSU. On March 1, 2017, the Senate Education Committee convened an oversight hearing on remedial education in California. The background paper for the hearing provided by the Legislative Analyst Office, “Overview of Remedial Education at the State’s Higher Education Segments,” noted that more than 40 percent of first time CSU students are identified as unprepared. The paper also revealed that unprepared students are less likely to graduate with a 20 percentage point difference in graduation rates between incoming students assessed as college-ready versus not college-ready.
According to CSU, “the policy and timeline outlined in this bill align with CSU’s intent to develop an enhanced set of academic preparation policies that will help more students achieve CSU academic standards and position themselves for academic success and degree completion.”
SUPPORT
California State University
California Catholic Conference, INC.
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Medina) – As Amended Ver:March 30, 2017
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California State University (CSU), to implement additional measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students by August 1, 2018.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No cost to CSU to implement this bill. The CSU notes that the CSU Board of Trustees adopted an item to consider course placement assessments systemwide that would incorporate multiple measures.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, "Studies show that nearly one third of students are “misplaced” when they enter higher education due to the use of placement assessments that are not comprehensive enough, and end up placing students in lower courses than they should be enrolled in, or the incorrect courses altogether, which sets them up for potential failure to earn a college degree or credential."
- Background. A report by the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) February 2017 report, “The 2017-18 Budget: Higher Education Analysis,” concludes that CSU could improve its assessment and placement policies. The LAO report found that the CSU relies primarily on placement tests when assessing college readiness. Based on the placement test results, the CSU deems more than 40 percent of its admitted freshmen as unprepared for college-level math, English, or both; leading those admitted freshmen having to take remedial course work.
- Staff Comment. CSU notes that the intent of this bill is in line with action taken by the Trustees of the CSU. At the March 21-22, 2017 meeting, the board expressed their commitment to evaluating their course placement assessment and considering multiple measures. “In order to build on this progress and achieve the Graduation Initiative 2025 goals of improving completion rates and closing equity gaps, we must improve our current systemwide policies, procedures and strategies related to academic preparation. The CSU will promote the completion of four years of coursework in mathematics and quantitative reasoning during high school, improve and expand our methods for assessing and placing students, strengthen our Early Start Program to include opportunities to complete college-level coursework and fundamentally restructure our approaches to developmental education.”
Analysis Prepared by: Daisy Gonzales / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 28, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 394 (
Author:Medina) – As Introduced Ver:February 9, 2017
SUBJECT: California State University: assessment and course placement of admitted students.
SUMMARY: Requires the California State University (CSU) Trustees, as a condition of receiving state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, by August 1, 2018, to approve a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use multiple measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students; and, specifies that the multiple measures approach shall place significant weight on high school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates, on community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students, and on those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students to English and mathematics coursework.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Donahoe Higher Education, setting forth the mission of the CSU (Education Code (EC) Section 66010, et seq.).
- Requires that the CSU shall be administered by a board designated as the Trustees of the CSU (EC Section 66600).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Background. According to the Education Commission of the States, in its May 2016, "Blueprint for College Readiness," a slow but steady movement is emerging to rethink – and revise – the single test, single cut score approach that places new college and/or transfer students into remedial or credit-level courses. To counter the shortcomings of a potentially limiting and high-stakes practice, several states and postsecondary systems are beginning to use additional indicators to gauge students’ college readiness.
The Commission contends that multiple measures could offer a more accurate way for students to demonstrate their potential to succeed in college-level courses and reduce the chance they will be placed in remedial courses.
California State University's current efforts with multiple measures. According to the CSU, there are multiple measures that CSU looks at for readiness in a college level course, including:
- Tests taken by students in high school (e. g. SAT, ACT, Advanced Placement, or California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress);
- Passing approved senior year courses with a grade of 'C' or better;
- Use of the CSU’s English Placement Test or Entry Level Math exam, from which students can be exempt by demonstrating proficiency via numbers one and two above; and/or,
- Participation in the CSU Early Start program or other similar summer programs.
The CSU contends that through these efforts, as well as working to engage with community colleges, high schools, and even elementary/middle schools, they have made significant progress in the number of students entering CSU fully prepared in both English and math.
To note, it is important to highlight that it appears as if the CSU is referring to approved courses for “conditionally ready” students and that these courses do not even count for placement unless students get a particular score on a test, like the Early Assessment Program. This appears to be misaligned with what Committee staff understands the community colleges have been scaling up – using high school grade point average and/or high school transcripts in key courses (like algebra) for consideration when making placements.
According to the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) February 2017 report, "The 2017-18 Budget: Higher Education Analysis", the CSU could improve its assessment and placement policies. The LAO report found that the CSU relies primarily on placement tests when assessing college readiness. Based on the placement test results, the CSU deems more than 40 percent of its admitted freshmen as unprepared for college-level math, English, or both; leading those admitted freshmen having to take remedial course work.
Additionally, according to the LAO analysis, national research shows reliance solely on placement tests routinely results in college-ready students being misplaced into remedial courses; leading to increased education costs for students and reducing their chances of graduating on time. Lastly, the LAO analysis found that 30 percent of incoming community college students to the CSU are put into remedial courses based on placement test results when they could have succeeded in college-level coursework.
Purpose this measure. According to the author, "Studies show that nearly one third of students are “misplaced” when they enter higher education due to the use of placement assessments that are not comprehensive enough, and end up placing students in lower courses than they should be enrolled in, or the incorrect courses altogether, which sets them up for potential failure to earn a college degree or credential."
This measure seeks to ensure that, as the CSU begins to utilize multiple measures in course placement of its students, high school and or community college transcript data be given a level of priority.
Committee comments and amendments. Committee staff understands that the CSU is already in the process directing all its campuses to incorporate more than just the assessment in determining course placement. Should this measure remain a pilot if all campuses are in the process of utilizing multiple measures?
Additionally, since the entire system is beginning to move in the direction of incorporating additional measures when determining course placement, should CSU's receipt of state funds for its Graduation Initiative 2025 be conditional to their implementing this measure?
Lastly, Committee staff understands that the CSU will be able to implement the changes to their multiple measures program to incorporate the requirements established by this measure via an executive order from the Chancellor.
Therefore, the Committee recommends, and the author has agreed to accept, the following amendments:
89012. As a condition of receipt of state funding for the Graduation Initiative 2025, By August 1, 2018, the California State University shall approve a pilot program where a minimum of 10 campuses use implement additional multiple measures for the assessment and course placement of admitted students. The multiple measures approach shall include, but not be limited to, place significant weight on high school transcript data in the assessment of recent California high school graduates, on community college transcript data in the assessment of community college transfer students, and on those transcripts in the subsequent assignment of these students to English and mathematics coursework.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Catholic Conference
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Jeanice Warden / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):