AB 1591: Energy: petroleum pricing.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-02-17
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act requires operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline that month. Existing law requires the commission to post the reported data, in aggregate, on its internet website within 45 calendar days of the end of each calendar month.
This bill would require the commission to post and regularly update a dashboard on its internet website that includes the difference in average gasoline prices in California compared to national average gasoline prices, the identification of California-specific taxes, fees, regulations, and policies and their individual contribution to gasoline prices in the state, and any substantiated evidence of price gouging or other anticompetitive behavior within the petroleum industry and its contribution to the price differential.
The commission shall post and regularly update a dashboard on its internet website that includes all of the following information:
(a)The difference in average gasoline prices in California compared to national average gasoline prices.
(b)The identification of all California-specific taxes, fees, regulations, and policies that directly or indirectly contribute to higher gasoline prices within the state, and the relative contribution of each individual tax, fee, regulation, or policy to the price difference identified in subdivision (a), including taxes, fees, regulations, and policies that contribute to higher costs for entities subject to Section 25354, to the extent that these higher costs are passed on to consumers.
(c)Any substantiated evidence of price gouging or other anticompetitive behavior within the petroleum industry, and the relative contribution of this behavior to the price difference identified in subdivision (a).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2024 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 18, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Luz Rivas, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1591 (
Author:Wallis) – As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
SUBJECT: Energy: petroleum pricing
SUMMARY: Requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission (CEC) to post and regularly update a dashboard on its internet website that includes the difference in average gasoline prices in California compared to national average gasoline prices, the identification of California-specific taxes, fees, regulations, and policies and their individual contribution to gasoline prices in the state, and any substantiated evidence of price gouging or other anticompetitive behavior within the petroleum industry and its contribution to the price differential.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 to require each refiner and major marketer to submit information each month to the CEC on their feedstock inputs, origin of petroleum receipts, imports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, including the source of those imports, exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, including the destination of those exports, refinery outputs, refinery stocks, and finished product supply and distribution, including all gasoline sold unbranded by the refiner, blender, or importer. Requires each major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, and oil storer to annually submit information to the CEC on transportation and storage capacity, among other things. (Public Resources Code (PRC) § 25353-25354)
- Establishes the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act to require operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to CEC containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline in that month. Requires the CEC to post those reported data, in aggregate, within 45 days of the end of each calendar month, on its internet website. (PRC § 25355(c))
THIS BILL:
- Requires the CEC to post and regularly update a dashboard on its internet website that includes all of the following information:
- The difference in average gasoline prices in California compared to national average gasoline prices.
- The identification of all California-specific taxes, fees, regulations, and policies that directly or indirectly contribute to higher gasoline prices within the state, and the relative contribution of each individual tax, fee, regulation, or policy to the identified price differences, including taxes, fees, regulations, and policies that contribute to higher costs for covered entities, to the extent that these higher costs are passed on to consumers.
- Any substantiated evidence of price gouging or other anticompetitive behavior within the petroleum industry, and the relative contribution of this behavior to the identified price difference.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Need for the bill. According to the author,
California’s high gas prices create a burden on low-income and middle class families. When prices spike, these households have no options to escape the higher cost. Whenever prices increase, fingers start pointing and we begin playing the blame game. Some say it is price gouging, some say it is the taxes and some say it is decades of policy decisions that increase costs and reduce supply. AB 1591 will give Californians the transparency they need to understand why they are paying more than the rest of the country for gas.
- California’s gas prices. The cost of a gallon of gasoline is tethered to a number of different variables, including:
- Taxes:
Federal Excise Tax: 18.4 cents per gallon
State Excise Tax: 53.9 cents per gallon
Sales Tax (estimated): 10 cents per gallon (can vary by location) - Fees:
Low Carbon Gas Programs: 22 cents per gallon
Greenhouse Gas Programs: 15 cents per gallon
Underground Tank Storage: 2 cents per gallon - Imbedded cost of compliance with environmental regulations: California has some of the strictest environmental regulatory requirements on oil extraction and refinement, in addition to the state’s ambitious climate emission reduction goals, which contribute to the cost of doing business in the state.
- Industry profit margins: how profits are calculated into the price of a gallon per gasoline are speculative, but truly unknown. The price of gasoline in California is unregulated and companies can charge prices based on what consumers are willing to pay.
California is notorious for having some of the most expensive gas in the country. Oil refiners refer the added costs to taxes and fees for environmental programs, but those added costs are less than half the delta between U.S. and California pump prices.
The CEC found growth of the average retail margin in California has exceeded growth of the national margin, especially since 2012. From 2004 to 2010, the average retail margin in California was either equivalent to or below the national margin. From 2015 to 2017, however, the California retail margin increased to an average of 19 cents greater than the national margin.
More recently, since Russia invaded Ukraine in February of last year, oil prices have increased. The U.S. and other Western nations introduced financial sanctions that made it difficult to clear Russian oil transactions through Western banks. Russian oil normally accounts for about 10% of global oil supply. It’s still being traded, but not to the same degree, resulting in a gap in supply, and increased demand – and prices – for gas.
Last October, CEC chair David Hochschild released a statement saying,
Over the course of 10 days, oil companies increased gas prices by a record 86 cents per gallon. At the end of August, crude oil prices were roughly $100 per barrel, and the average gas price in California was $5.06. Now, even though the price of oil has decreased to $90 per barrel, today the average gas price at the pump has surged to $6.43 … Data show even as crude oil prices decreased and state fees and taxes remained unchanged, the price at the pump still went up because refinery costs and profits more than tripled, now accounting for $2.18 for every gallon of gas that Californians buy.
As of this month, the statewide average is $4.90 – nearly $1.50 per gallon greater than U.S. gasoline prices, according to the latest data from AAA.
- Market price volatility. In 2014, the Legislature passed SB 448 (Leno) to require CEC to investigate suspected motor vehicle fuel price manipulation and make recommendations to the Legislature on how to limit motor vehicle fuel price volatility. The bill was vetoed by Governor Brown, who said: “I am directing [CEC] to work with the Attorney General to evaluate market trends and ways to respond to price volatility. We need to have a plan and a rapid response team in place with the capability to respond when sudden and untoward price fluctuations occur.”
In response to this direction, CEC established the Petroleum Market Advisory Committee (PMAC) in 2014 to provide expertise on factors leading to price increases and strategies for addressing price volatility. The energy economists and experts on PMAC provided CEC and state regulators with independent advice and insights on issues affecting the market, from local policies to global events. The final report, issued in 2017, found several gasoline market anomalies that appeared to be new trends in California, including increasing retail margins for California gasoline, and increasing retail price differentials between the California and U.S. average, among others.
- Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act. PIIRA, which the Legislature enacted in 1980, requires qualifying petroleum industry companies to submit weekly, monthly, and annual data to the CEC. Analysis of data collected under PIIRA is an important part of the CEC’s responsibility to create a thorough understanding of the operations of the petroleum industry in California. Businesses that ship, receive, store, process and sell crude oil and petroleum products in California file PIIRA reports.
PIIRA has confidentiality protections for refinery data collected by CEC, but they are very restrictive and limit the extent to which information covered by this bill can be publicly reported. The only way to get public reporting for info under PIIRA is to mandate public reporting or exempt it from PIIRA’s confidentiality requirements.
- New transparency requirements. Last year, the Legislature enacted the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act SB 1322 (Allen), Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022 to require the CEC to publicly report specified pricing data from each oil refinery operating in the state, including the “gross gasoline refining margin,” or the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the volume-weighted average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received by the refinery.
The Associated Press reported on March 14 that four of the five oil companies that provide 97% of the state's gasoline met the March 2 deadline under SB 1322 for disclosing how much money they are making from selling gasoline in the state: Marathon, PBF Energy, Phillips 66, and Valero, according to the CEC. Chevron, which accounts for about 30% of all gasoline sold in the state giving it the largest share of the market, had not yet complied.
- Industry profits. In the third quarter of 2022, from July to September, oil companies reported record high profits. According to Governor Newsom, Phillips 66 reported $5.4 billion in profits, a 1,243% increase over last year’s $402 million; BP posted $8.2 billion in profits, its second-highest on record; Marathon Petroleum profits were reported at $4.48 billion, a 545% increase over last year’s $694 million; Valero’s $2.82 billion in profits that were 500% higher than the year before; PBF Energy’s $1.06 billion that was 1700% higher than the year before; Shell reported a $9.45 billion haul that sent $4 billion to shareholders for stock buybacks; Exxon reported their highest-ever $19.7 billion in profits; and, Chevron reported $11.2 billion in profits, their second-highest quarterly profit ever.
A 2019 CEC report concluded that “the primary cause of the residual price increase is simply that California’s retail gasoline outlets are charging higher prices than those in other states… The overall California increase in retail margins, above that experienced by the rest of the U.S., has resulted in California gasoline consumers paying an estimated additional $1.5 billion in 2018 and $11.6 billion over the last five years.”
- Special session. Last November, Governor Gavin Newsom called for a special session of the Legislature to investigate last fall’s unprecedented spike in gasoline prices. The spike in gasoline prices, Newsom alleges, resulted in record refiner profits of $63 billion in just 90 days. Last fall’s spike occurred while crude oil prices dropped, state taxes and fees remained unchanged, and gas prices did not increase outside the western U.S., and major refiners failed to explain the reasoning behind the price increases at the pump.
The burden of high gas prices is borne disproportionately by lower-income Californians, many of whom must drive to commute long distances for work and have less ability to absorb higher gas prices in their budgets and have been disproportionately impacted by inflation generally.
In the Governor’s proclamation for the special session, he acknowledged the enactment of SB 1322, and said “even greater transparency is needed in light of oil companies' recent pricing decisions, particularly with respect to information regarding the timing and production impact of refinery maintenance and timely information about inventory levels.”
On March 28, the Governor signed SBx1 2 (Skinner), Chapter 1, Statutes of 2023 to expand and significantly update both PIIRA and the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act of 2022, to mandate extensive reporting from various specified entities along California's oil and gasoline supply chain. The bill also authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (max margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state, pursuant to certain findings. Included is a price-gouging penalty that would fine oil companies for making excessive profits; if oil companies do engage in price gouging, then SBx1 2 will collect penalties and deposit them in the Price Gouging Penalty Fund to "address any consequences of price gouging on Californians."
In addition, the bill creates a new division and advisory committee at the CEC, and requires various reports and assessments by the CEC to be submitted to the Legislature regarding the current status and future managed decline of transportation fuels.
- This bill. AB 1591 proposes requiring the CEC to make information available about the difference in average gasoline prices in California compared to national average gasoline prices, the identification of California-specific taxes, fees, regulations, and policies and their individual contribution to gasoline prices in the state, and any substantiated evidence of price gouging or other anticompetitive behavior within the petroleum industry and its contribution to the price differential.
As it relates to California’s price at the pump compared to the national average, AAA maintains a national gas price data inventory, including average gas prices per state.
As it relates to the various taxes and fees that go into the cost of a gallon of gas, the CEC provides the estimated gasoline price breakdown and margins on its website.
More notably, though, SBx1 2 checks the box for codifying policies to identify and substantiate evidence of profits and price gouging.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / NAT. RES. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):