AB 2067: Financial institutions: service of process.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-12
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-12: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 222, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Enforcement of Judgments Law, governs the enforcement of, among other things, money judgments and judgments for possession of personal property in civil actions. Existing law requires a writ, notice, order, or other paper relating to the enforcement of a judgment to be served on the judgment creditor or, if applicable, the judgment creditors attorney. Under existing law, a financial institution is permitted, and if it has more than nine branches or offices within the state is required, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. Except as specified, service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution is effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution, or in a safe-deposit box if, among other conditions, the deposit accounts or properties are held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within the state.
This bill would permit a financial institution to designate a third-party agent, as defined, as a central location for service of legal process, as specified. If the financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the bill would require the financial institution to designate another central location. The bill would prohibit each central location from being located in the same county as another designated central location.
Existing law, the Enforcement of Judgments Law, governs the enforcement of, among other things, money judgments and judgments for possession of personal property in civil actions. Existing law requires a writ, notice, order, or other paper relating to the enforcement of a judgment to be served on the judgment creditor or, if applicable, the judgment creditors attorney. Under existing law, a financial institution is permitted, and if it has more than nine branches or offices within the state is required, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. Except as specified, service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution is effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution, or in a safe-deposit box if, among other conditions, the deposit accounts or properties are held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within the state.
This bill would permit a financial institution to designate a third-party agent, as defined, as a central location for service of legal process, as specified. If the financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the bill would require the financial institution to designate another central location. The bill would prohibit each central location from being located in the same county as another designated central location.
Existing law, the Enforcement of Judgments Law, governs the enforcement of, among other things, money judgments and judgments for possession of personal property in civil actions. Existing law requires a writ, notice, order, or other paper relating to the enforcement of a judgment to be served on the judgment creditor or, if applicable, the judgment creditors attorney. Under existing law, a financial institution is permitted, and if it has more than nine branches or offices within the state is required, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. Except as specified, service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution is effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution, or in a safe-deposit box if, among other conditions, the deposit accounts or properties are held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within the state.
This bill would permit a financial institution to designate a third-party agent, as defined, as a central location for service of legal process, as specified. If the financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the bill would require the financial institution to designate another central location. The bill would prohibit each central location from being located in the same county as another designated central location.
Existing law, the Enforcement of Judgments Law, governs the enforcement of, among other things, money judgments and judgments for possession of personal property in civil actions. Existing law requires a writ, notice, order, or other paper relating to the enforcement of a judgment to be served on the judgment creditor or, if applicable, the judgment creditors attorney. Under existing law, a financial institution is permitted, and if it has more than nine branches or offices within the state is required, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. Except as specified, service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution is effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution, or in a safe-deposit box if, among other conditions, the deposit accounts or properties are held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within the state.
This bill would permit a financial institution, and if the institution has more than nine branches or offices within the state require it, to designate four or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. institution to designate a third-party agent, as defined, as a central location for service of legal process, as specified. If the financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the bill would require the financial institution to designate another central location. The bill would prohibit each central location from being located in the same county as another designated central location.
Existing law, the Enforcement of Judgments Law, governs the enforcement of, among other things, money judgments and judgments for possession of personal property in civil actions. Existing law requires a writ, notice, order, or other paper relating to the enforcement of a judgment to be served on the judgment creditor or, if applicable, the judgment creditors attorney. Under existing law, a financial institution is permitted, and if it has more than nine branches or offices within the state is required, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. Except as specified, service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution is effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution, or in a safe-deposit box if, among other conditions, the deposit accounts or properties are held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within the state.
This bill would permit a financial institution, and if the institution has more than nine branches or offices within the state require it, to designate four or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. The bill would prohibit each central location from being located in the same county as another designated location.
(a)At the time of service of a copy of the writ of attachment and a notice of attachment on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the request is made, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any property of the defendant sought to be attached that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(4)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the attached property or obligation that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(5)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the plaintiff and attach the original to the writ when it is returned to the court. If a garnishees memorandum is not received from the third person, the levying officer shall so state in the return.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a) or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), where a deposit account or property in a safe-deposit box is attached, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum need provide information with respect only to property which is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made, unless the levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, in which case the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at that central location is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be attached.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the defendant that was attached and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
SEC. 2.Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:684.115.(a)A financial institution may, and if it has more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within this state shall, designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within this state. Each designated location shall be referred to as a central location. A financial institution may designate a third-party agent as a central location for service of legal process. If a financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the financial institution shall designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location. The financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple central locations for service of legal process if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
(b)If a financial institution elects or is required to designate a central location for service of legal process, pursuant to subdivision (a), the financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation which filing shall be effective upon filing and shall contain all of the following:
(1)The physical address of the central location.
(2)The days and hours during which service will be accepted at the central location and, if the central location is a third-party agent, the name of the third party agent.
(3)If the central location will not accept service of legal process directed at deposit accounts maintained or property held at all of the financial institutions branches or offices within this state, or if the service accepted at the central location will not apply to safe-deposit boxes or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor, the filing shall also contain sufficient information to permit a determination of the limitation or limitations, including, in the case of a limitation applicable to certain branches or offices, an identification of the branches or offices as to which service at the central location will not apply and the nature of the limitation applicable to those branches or offices. If the limitation will apply to all branches or offices of the financial institution within this state, the filing may indicate the nature of the limitation and that it applies to all branches or offices, in lieu of an identification of branches or offices as to which the limitation applies. To the extent that a financial institutions designation of a central location for service of legal process covers the process directed at deposit accounts, safe-deposit boxes, or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor at a particular branch or office located within this state, the branch or office shall be a branch or office covered by central process.
(c)Should a financial institution required to designate a central location fail to do so, each branch of that institution located in this state shall be deemed to be a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institutions branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
(d)Subject to any limitation noted pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b), service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution shall be effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box if the same is described in the legal process and held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within this state. However, while service of legal process at the central location will establish a lien on all property, if any property other than deposit accounts is physically held by the financial institution in a county other than that in which the designated central location is located, the financial institution shall include in its garnishees memorandum the location or locations of the property, and the judgment creditor shall obtain a writ of execution covering the property and directed to the levying officer in that county to accomplish the turnover of the property and shall forward the writ and related required documentation to the levying officer in the county in which the property is held.
(e)A financial institution may modify or revoke any designation made pursuant to subdivision (a) by filing the modification or revocation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. The modification or revocation shall be effective when the Department of Financial Protection and Innovations records have been updated to reflect the modification or revocation, provided that the judgment creditor may rely upon the superseded designation during the 30-day period following the effective date of the revocation or modification.
(f)(1) The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall update its online records to reflect a filing by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) or a modification or revocation filed by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (e) within 10 business days following the filing by the financial institution. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovations internet website shall reflect the date its online records for each financial institution have most recently been updated.
(2)The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall provide any person requesting it with a copy of each current filing made by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b). The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may satisfy its obligation under this subdivision by posting all current designations of a financial institution, or the pertinent information therein, on an internet website available to the public without charge, and if that information is made available, the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may impose a reasonable fee for furnishing that information in any other manner.
(g)As to deposit accounts maintained or property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box at a branch or office covered by central process, service of legal process at a location other than a central location designated by the financial institution shall not be effective unless the financial institution, in its absolute discretion, elects to act upon the process at that location as if it were effective. In the absence of an election, the financial institution may respond to the legal process by mailing or delivery of the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer within the time otherwise provided therefor, with a statement on the garnishees memorandum that the legal process was not properly served at the financial institutions designated location for receiving legal process, and, therefore, was not processed, and the address at which the financial institution is to receive legal process.
(h)If any legal process is served at a central location of a financial institution pursuant to this section, all related papers to be served on the financial institution shall be served at that location, unless agreed to the contrary between the serving party and the financial institution.
(i)This subdivision shall apply whenever a financial institution operates within this state at least one branch or office in addition to its head office or main office, as applicable, or a financial institution headquartered in another state operates more than one branch or office within this state, and no central location has been designated or deemed to have been designated by the institution for service of legal process relating to deposit accounts maintained at the financial institutions head office or main office, as applicable, and branches located within this state. If a judgment creditor reasonably believes that, pursuant to Section 700.140 and, if applicable, Section 700.160, any act of enforcement would be effective against a specific deposit account maintained at a financial institution described in this subdivision, the judgment creditor may file with the financial institution a written request that the financial institution identify the branch or office within this state at which a specified account might be maintained by the financial institution. The written request shall contain the following statements or information:
(1)The name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands.
(2)If the name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands is not a judgment debtor identified in the writ of execution, a statement that a person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands will be appropriately identified in the legal process to be served pursuant to Section 700.160, including any supplementary papers, such as a court order or affidavit if the same will be required by Section 700.160.
(3)The specific identifying number of the account reasonably believed to be maintained with the financial institution and standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person.
(4)The address of the requesting party.
(5)An affidavit by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel stating substantially the following:
I hereby declare that this deposit account location request complies with Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the account or accounts of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process and specified herein are subject to a valid writ of execution, or court order, that I have a reasonable belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, that the financial institution receiving this deposit account location request has an account standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process, and that information pertaining to the location of the account will assist the judgment creditor in enforcing the judgment.
(j)The affidavit contemplated by subdivision (i) shall be signed by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel and filed at the financial institutions head office located within this state or, if the financial institutions head office is in another state, at one of its branches or offices within this state. Failure to comply with the requirements of subdivision (i) and this subdivision shall be sufficient basis for the financial institution to refuse to produce the information that would otherwise be required by subdivision (k).
(k)Within 10 banking days following receipt by a financial institution at the applicable location specified in subdivision (j) of a request contemplated by subdivision (i), as to each specific deposit account identified in the request contemplated by subdivision (i), the financial institution shall respond by mailing, by first-class mail with postage prepaid, to the requesters address as specified in the request a response indicating the branch or office location of the financial institution at which the specified deposit account might be maintained, or, if the specified deposit account, if it exists, would not be maintained at a specific location, at least one place within this state at which legal process relating to the deposit account should or may be served. The response to be furnished pursuant to this subdivision shall not require the financial institution to determine whether an account exists or, if an account does exist, whether it would be reached by the legal process, rather, the branch or office location shall be determined and reported by the financial institution based solely upon its determination that an account with the identifying number provided by the requester would be maintained at that branch if an account did exist, and the response shall not contain any information about the name in which the account stands or any other information concerning the account, if it exists. If more than one account number is specified in the request, the financial institutions responses as to some or all of those account numbers may be combined in a single writing.
(l)A response furnished in good faith by the financial institution pursuant to subdivision (k) shall not be deemed to violate the privacy of any person in whose name the specified deposit account stands nor the privacy of any other person, and shall not require the consent of the person in whose name the account stands nor that of any other person.
(m)A financial institution shall not notify the person in whose name the specified deposit account stands or any other person related to the specified account of the receipt of any request made pursuant to subdivision (i) and affecting that persons or persons accounts at the financial institution, provided that the financial institution shall have no liability for its failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
(n)For purposes of this section, third-party agent means a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses. Third-party agent does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
SEC. 3.Section 701.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:701.030.(a)At the time of service of a copy of the legal process on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the legal process is served, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information, as applicable:
(1)A description of any property of the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A description of any property of the judgment debtor not sought to be levied upon that is in the possession or under the control of the third person at the time of levy.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer, and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(4)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(5)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor at the time of levy not sought to be levied upon.
(6)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the property or obligation levied upon that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(7)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall retain a copy and promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the judgment creditor.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a), or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), when the levy is made upon a deposit account or upon property in a safe-deposit box, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum needs to provide information with respect only to property that is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made provided that if a levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at those central locations is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be levied upon.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the judgment debtor that was levied upon, and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
(g)The garnishee may electronically transmit the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 263) of Title 4 of Part 1.
(a)At the time of service of a copy of the writ of attachment and a notice of attachment on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the request is made, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any property of the defendant sought to be attached that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(4)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the attached property or obligation that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(5)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the plaintiff and attach the original to the writ when it is returned to the court. If a garnishees memorandum is not received from the third person, the levying officer shall so state in the return.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a) or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), where a deposit account or property in a safe-deposit box is attached, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum need provide information with respect only to property which is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made, unless the levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, in which case the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at that central location is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be attached.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the defendant that was attached and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
SEC. 2.Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:684.115.(a)A financial institution may, and if it has more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within this state shall, designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within this state. Each designated location shall be referred to as a central location. A financial institution may designate a third-party agent as a central location for service of legal process. If a financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the financial institution shall designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location. The financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple central locations for service of legal process if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
(b)If a financial institution elects or is required to designate a central location for service of legal process, pursuant to subdivision (a), the financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation which filing shall be effective upon filing and shall contain all of the following:
(1)The physical address of the central location.
(2)The days and hours during which service will be accepted at the central location and, if the central location is a third-party agent, the name of the third party agent.
(3)If the central location will not accept service of legal process directed at deposit accounts maintained or property held at all of the financial institutions branches or offices within this state, or if the service accepted at the central location will not apply to safe-deposit boxes or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor, the filing shall also contain sufficient information to permit a determination of the limitation or limitations, including, in the case of a limitation applicable to certain branches or offices, an identification of the branches or offices as to which service at the central location will not apply and the nature of the limitation applicable to those branches or offices. If the limitation will apply to all branches or offices of the financial institution within this state, the filing may indicate the nature of the limitation and that it applies to all branches or offices, in lieu of an identification of branches or offices as to which the limitation applies. To the extent that a financial institutions designation of a central location for service of legal process covers the process directed at deposit accounts, safe-deposit boxes, or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor at a particular branch or office located within this state, the branch or office shall be a branch or office covered by central process.
(c)Should a financial institution required to designate a central location fail to do so, each branch of that institution located in this state shall be deemed to be a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institutions branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
(d)Subject to any limitation noted pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b), service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution shall be effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box if the same is described in the legal process and held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within this state. However, while service of legal process at the central location will establish a lien on all property, if any property other than deposit accounts is physically held by the financial institution in a county other than that in which the designated central location is located, the financial institution shall include in its garnishees memorandum the location or locations of the property, and the judgment creditor shall obtain a writ of execution covering the property and directed to the levying officer in that county to accomplish the turnover of the property and shall forward the writ and related required documentation to the levying officer in the county in which the property is held.
(e)A financial institution may modify or revoke any designation made pursuant to subdivision (a) by filing the modification or revocation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. The modification or revocation shall be effective when the Department of Financial Protection and Innovations records have been updated to reflect the modification or revocation, provided that the judgment creditor may rely upon the superseded designation during the 30-day period following the effective date of the revocation or modification.
(f)(1) The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall update its online records to reflect a filing by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) or a modification or revocation filed by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (e) within 10 business days following the filing by the financial institution. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovations internet website shall reflect the date its online records for each financial institution have most recently been updated.
(2)The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall provide any person requesting it with a copy of each current filing made by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b). The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may satisfy its obligation under this subdivision by posting all current designations of a financial institution, or the pertinent information therein, on an internet website available to the public without charge, and if that information is made available, the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may impose a reasonable fee for furnishing that information in any other manner.
(g)As to deposit accounts maintained or property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box at a branch or office covered by central process, service of legal process at a location other than a central location designated by the financial institution shall not be effective unless the financial institution, in its absolute discretion, elects to act upon the process at that location as if it were effective. In the absence of an election, the financial institution may respond to the legal process by mailing or delivery of the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer within the time otherwise provided therefor, with a statement on the garnishees memorandum that the legal process was not properly served at the financial institutions designated location for receiving legal process, and, therefore, was not processed, and the address at which the financial institution is to receive legal process.
(h)If any legal process is served at a central location of a financial institution pursuant to this section, all related papers to be served on the financial institution shall be served at that location, unless agreed to the contrary between the serving party and the financial institution.
(i)This subdivision shall apply whenever a financial institution operates within this state at least one branch or office in addition to its head office or main office, as applicable, or a financial institution headquartered in another state operates more than one branch or office within this state, and no central location has been designated or deemed to have been designated by the institution for service of legal process relating to deposit accounts maintained at the financial institutions head office or main office, as applicable, and branches located within this state. If a judgment creditor reasonably believes that, pursuant to Section 700.140 and, if applicable, Section 700.160, any act of enforcement would be effective against a specific deposit account maintained at a financial institution described in this subdivision, the judgment creditor may file with the financial institution a written request that the financial institution identify the branch or office within this state at which a specified account might be maintained by the financial institution. The written request shall contain the following statements or information:
(1)The name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands.
(2)If the name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands is not a judgment debtor identified in the writ of execution, a statement that a person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands will be appropriately identified in the legal process to be served pursuant to Section 700.160, including any supplementary papers, such as a court order or affidavit if the same will be required by Section 700.160.
(3)The specific identifying number of the account reasonably believed to be maintained with the financial institution and standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person.
(4)The address of the requesting party.
(5)An affidavit by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel stating substantially the following:
I hereby declare that this deposit account location request complies with Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the account or accounts of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process and specified herein are subject to a valid writ of execution, or court order, that I have a reasonable belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, that the financial institution receiving this deposit account location request has an account standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process, and that information pertaining to the location of the account will assist the judgment creditor in enforcing the judgment.
(j)The affidavit contemplated by subdivision (i) shall be signed by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel and filed at the financial institutions head office located within this state or, if the financial institutions head office is in another state, at one of its branches or offices within this state. Failure to comply with the requirements of subdivision (i) and this subdivision shall be sufficient basis for the financial institution to refuse to produce the information that would otherwise be required by subdivision (k).
(k)Within 10 banking days following receipt by a financial institution at the applicable location specified in subdivision (j) of a request contemplated by subdivision (i), as to each specific deposit account identified in the request contemplated by subdivision (i), the financial institution shall respond by mailing, by first-class mail with postage prepaid, to the requesters address as specified in the request a response indicating the branch or office location of the financial institution at which the specified deposit account might be maintained, or, if the specified deposit account, if it exists, would not be maintained at a specific location, at least one place within this state at which legal process relating to the deposit account should or may be served. The response to be furnished pursuant to this subdivision shall not require the financial institution to determine whether an account exists or, if an account does exist, whether it would be reached by the legal process, rather, the branch or office location shall be determined and reported by the financial institution based solely upon its determination that an account with the identifying number provided by the requester would be maintained at that branch if an account did exist, and the response shall not contain any information about the name in which the account stands or any other information concerning the account, if it exists. If more than one account number is specified in the request, the financial institutions responses as to some or all of those account numbers may be combined in a single writing.
(l)A response furnished in good faith by the financial institution pursuant to subdivision (k) shall not be deemed to violate the privacy of any person in whose name the specified deposit account stands nor the privacy of any other person, and shall not require the consent of the person in whose name the account stands nor that of any other person.
(m)A financial institution shall not notify the person in whose name the specified deposit account stands or any other person related to the specified account of the receipt of any request made pursuant to subdivision (i) and affecting that persons or persons accounts at the financial institution, provided that the financial institution shall have no liability for its failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
(n)For purposes of this section, third-party agent means a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses. Third-party agent does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
SEC. 3.Section 701.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:701.030.(a)At the time of service of a copy of the legal process on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the legal process is served, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information, as applicable:
(1)A description of any property of the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A description of any property of the judgment debtor not sought to be levied upon that is in the possession or under the control of the third person at the time of levy.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer, and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(4)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(5)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor at the time of levy not sought to be levied upon.
(6)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the property or obligation levied upon that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(7)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall retain a copy and promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the judgment creditor.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a), or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), when the levy is made upon a deposit account or upon property in a safe-deposit box, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum needs to provide information with respect only to property that is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made provided that if a levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at those central locations is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be levied upon.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the judgment debtor that was levied upon, and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
(g)The garnishee may electronically transmit the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 263) of Title 4 of Part 1.
(a)At the time of service of a copy of the writ of attachment and a notice of attachment on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the request is made, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information:
(1)A description of any property of the defendant sought to be attached that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the defendant sought to be attached that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(4)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the attached property or obligation that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(5)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the plaintiff and attach the original to the writ when it is returned to the court. If a garnishees memorandum is not received from the third person, the levying officer shall so state in the return.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a) or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), where a deposit account or property in a safe-deposit box is attached, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum need provide information with respect only to property which is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made, unless the levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, in which case the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at that central location is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be attached.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the defendant that was attached and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:684.115.(a)A financial institution may, and if it has more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within this state shall, designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within this state. Each designated location shall be referred to as a central location. A financial institution may designate a third-party agent as a central location for service of legal process. If a financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the financial institution shall designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location. The financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple central locations for service of legal process if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
(b)If a financial institution elects or is required to designate a central location for service of legal process, pursuant to subdivision (a), the financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation which filing shall be effective upon filing and shall contain all of the following:
(1)The physical address of the central location.
(2)The days and hours during which service will be accepted at the central location and, if the central location is a third-party agent, the name of the third party agent.
(3)If the central location will not accept service of legal process directed at deposit accounts maintained or property held at all of the financial institutions branches or offices within this state, or if the service accepted at the central location will not apply to safe-deposit boxes or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor, the filing shall also contain sufficient information to permit a determination of the limitation or limitations, including, in the case of a limitation applicable to certain branches or offices, an identification of the branches or offices as to which service at the central location will not apply and the nature of the limitation applicable to those branches or offices. If the limitation will apply to all branches or offices of the financial institution within this state, the filing may indicate the nature of the limitation and that it applies to all branches or offices, in lieu of an identification of branches or offices as to which the limitation applies. To the extent that a financial institutions designation of a central location for service of legal process covers the process directed at deposit accounts, safe-deposit boxes, or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor at a particular branch or office located within this state, the branch or office shall be a branch or office covered by central process.
(c)Should a financial institution required to designate a central location fail to do so, each branch of that institution located in this state shall be deemed to be a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institutions branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
(d)Subject to any limitation noted pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b), service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution shall be effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box if the same is described in the legal process and held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within this state. However, while service of legal process at the central location will establish a lien on all property, if any property other than deposit accounts is physically held by the financial institution in a county other than that in which the designated central location is located, the financial institution shall include in its garnishees memorandum the location or locations of the property, and the judgment creditor shall obtain a writ of execution covering the property and directed to the levying officer in that county to accomplish the turnover of the property and shall forward the writ and related required documentation to the levying officer in the county in which the property is held.
(e)A financial institution may modify or revoke any designation made pursuant to subdivision (a) by filing the modification or revocation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. The modification or revocation shall be effective when the Department of Financial Protection and Innovations records have been updated to reflect the modification or revocation, provided that the judgment creditor may rely upon the superseded designation during the 30-day period following the effective date of the revocation or modification.
(f)(1) The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall update its online records to reflect a filing by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) or a modification or revocation filed by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (e) within 10 business days following the filing by the financial institution. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovations internet website shall reflect the date its online records for each financial institution have most recently been updated.
(2)The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall provide any person requesting it with a copy of each current filing made by a financial institution pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b). The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may satisfy its obligation under this subdivision by posting all current designations of a financial institution, or the pertinent information therein, on an internet website available to the public without charge, and if that information is made available, the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may impose a reasonable fee for furnishing that information in any other manner.
(g)As to deposit accounts maintained or property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box at a branch or office covered by central process, service of legal process at a location other than a central location designated by the financial institution shall not be effective unless the financial institution, in its absolute discretion, elects to act upon the process at that location as if it were effective. In the absence of an election, the financial institution may respond to the legal process by mailing or delivery of the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer within the time otherwise provided therefor, with a statement on the garnishees memorandum that the legal process was not properly served at the financial institutions designated location for receiving legal process, and, therefore, was not processed, and the address at which the financial institution is to receive legal process.
(h)If any legal process is served at a central location of a financial institution pursuant to this section, all related papers to be served on the financial institution shall be served at that location, unless agreed to the contrary between the serving party and the financial institution.
(i)This subdivision shall apply whenever a financial institution operates within this state at least one branch or office in addition to its head office or main office, as applicable, or a financial institution headquartered in another state operates more than one branch or office within this state, and no central location has been designated or deemed to have been designated by the institution for service of legal process relating to deposit accounts maintained at the financial institutions head office or main office, as applicable, and branches located within this state. If a judgment creditor reasonably believes that, pursuant to Section 700.140 and, if applicable, Section 700.160, any act of enforcement would be effective against a specific deposit account maintained at a financial institution described in this subdivision, the judgment creditor may file with the financial institution a written request that the financial institution identify the branch or office within this state at which a specified account might be maintained by the financial institution. The written request shall contain the following statements or information:
(1)The name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands.
(2)If the name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands is not a judgment debtor identified in the writ of execution, a statement that a person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands will be appropriately identified in the legal process to be served pursuant to Section 700.160, including any supplementary papers, such as a court order or affidavit if the same will be required by Section 700.160.
(3)The specific identifying number of the account reasonably believed to be maintained with the financial institution and standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person.
(4)The address of the requesting party.
(5)An affidavit by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel stating substantially the following:
I hereby declare that this deposit account location request complies with Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the account or accounts of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process and specified herein are subject to a valid writ of execution, or court order, that I have a reasonable belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, that the financial institution receiving this deposit account location request has an account standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process, and that information pertaining to the location of the account will assist the judgment creditor in enforcing the judgment.
(j)The affidavit contemplated by subdivision (i) shall be signed by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel and filed at the financial institutions head office located within this state or, if the financial institutions head office is in another state, at one of its branches or offices within this state. Failure to comply with the requirements of subdivision (i) and this subdivision shall be sufficient basis for the financial institution to refuse to produce the information that would otherwise be required by subdivision (k).
(k)Within 10 banking days following receipt by a financial institution at the applicable location specified in subdivision (j) of a request contemplated by subdivision (i), as to each specific deposit account identified in the request contemplated by subdivision (i), the financial institution shall respond by mailing, by first-class mail with postage prepaid, to the requesters address as specified in the request a response indicating the branch or office location of the financial institution at which the specified deposit account might be maintained, or, if the specified deposit account, if it exists, would not be maintained at a specific location, at least one place within this state at which legal process relating to the deposit account should or may be served. The response to be furnished pursuant to this subdivision shall not require the financial institution to determine whether an account exists or, if an account does exist, whether it would be reached by the legal process, rather, the branch or office location shall be determined and reported by the financial institution based solely upon its determination that an account with the identifying number provided by the requester would be maintained at that branch if an account did exist, and the response shall not contain any information about the name in which the account stands or any other information concerning the account, if it exists. If more than one account number is specified in the request, the financial institutions responses as to some or all of those account numbers may be combined in a single writing.
(l)A response furnished in good faith by the financial institution pursuant to subdivision (k) shall not be deemed to violate the privacy of any person in whose name the specified deposit account stands nor the privacy of any other person, and shall not require the consent of the person in whose name the account stands nor that of any other person.
(m)A financial institution shall not notify the person in whose name the specified deposit account stands or any other person related to the specified account of the receipt of any request made pursuant to subdivision (i) and affecting that persons or persons accounts at the financial institution, provided that the financial institution shall have no liability for its failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
(n)For purposes of this section, third-party agent means a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses. Third-party agent does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
SEC. 3.Section 701.030 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:701.030.(a)At the time of service of a copy of the legal process on a third person, the levying officer shall request the third person to give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum containing the information required by this section. Within 10 days after the legal process is served, the third person shall mail or deliver the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer whether or not the levy is effective.
(b)The garnishees memorandum shall be executed under oath and shall contain the following information, as applicable:
(1)A description of any property of the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not delivered to the levying officer and the reason for not delivering the property.
(2)A description of any property of the judgment debtor not sought to be levied upon that is in the possession or under the control of the third person at the time of levy.
(3)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is due and payable and is not paid to the levying officer, and the reason for not paying the obligation.
(4)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor sought to be levied upon that is not due and payable at the time of levy.
(5)A statement of the amount and terms of any obligation to the judgment debtor at the time of levy not sought to be levied upon.
(6)A description of claims and rights of other persons to the property or obligation levied upon that are known to the third person and the names and addresses of those other persons.
(7)A statement that the garnishee holds neither any property nor any obligations in favor of the judgment debtor.
(c)If a garnishees memorandum is received from the third person, the levying officer shall retain a copy and promptly mail or deliver a copy of the memorandum to the judgment creditor.
(d)Except as provided in subdivisions (e) and (f), if a third person does not give the levying officer a garnishees memorandum within the time provided in subdivision (a), or does not provide complete information, the third person may, in the courts discretion, be required to pay the costs and reasonable attorneys fees incurred in any proceedings to obtain the information required in the garnishees memorandum.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), when the levy is made upon a deposit account or upon property in a safe-deposit box, the financial institution need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if the financial institution fully complies with the levy and, if a garnishees memorandum is required, the garnishees memorandum needs to provide information with respect only to property that is carried on the records available at the office or branch where the levy is made provided that if a levy has been served at a central location designated by a financial institution in accordance with Section 684.115, the garnishees memorandum shall apply to all offices and branches of the financial institution except to the extent acceptance of the levy at those central locations is limited pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) (b) of Section 684.115.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the third person need not give a garnishees memorandum to the levying officer if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)The third person has delivered to the levying officer all of the property sought to be levied upon.
(2)The third person has paid to the levying officer the amount due at the time of levy on any obligation to the judgment debtor that was levied upon, and there is no additional amount that thereafter will become payable on the obligation levied upon.
(g)The garnishee may electronically transmit the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 263) of Title 4 of Part 1.
(a)A financial institution may, and if it has more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within this state shall, designate four one or more central locations for service of legal process within this state. Each designated location shall be referred to as a central location, and shall not be located in the same county as another designated location. If location. A financial institution may designate a third-party agent as a central location for service of legal process. If a financial institution designates a third-party agent as a central location, the financial institution shall designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location. The financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple central locations for service of legal process if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
(b)If a financial institution elects or is required to designate a central location for service of legal process, process, pursuant to subdivision (a), the financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation which filing shall be effective upon filing and shall contain all of the following:
(1)The physical address of the central location.
(2)The days and hours during which service will be accepted at the central location. location and, if the central location is a third-party agent, the name of the third party agent.
(3)If the central location will not accept service of legal process directed at deposit accounts maintained or property held at all of the financial institutions branches or offices within this state, or if the service accepted at the central location will not apply to safe-deposit boxes or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor, the filing shall also contain sufficient information to permit a determination of the limitation or limitations, including, in the case of a limitation applicable to certain branches or offices, an identification of the branches or offices as to which service at the central location will not apply and the nature of the limitation applicable to those branches or offices. If the limitation will apply to all branches or offices of the financial institution within this state, the filing may indicate the nature of the limitation and that it applies to all branches or offices, in lieu of an identification of branches or offices as to which the limitation applies. To the extent that a financial institutions designation of a central location for service of legal process covers the process directed at deposit accounts, safe-deposit boxes, or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor at a particular branch or office located within this state, the branch or office shall be a branch or office covered by central process.
(b)(c)Should a financial institution required to designate a central location fail to do so, each branch of that institution located in this state shall be deemed to be a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institutions branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
(c)(d)Subject to any limitation noted pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), (b), service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution shall be effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box if the same is described in the legal process and held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within this state. However, while service of legal process at the central location will establish a lien on all property, if any property other than deposit accounts is physically held by the financial institution in a county other than that in which the designated central location is located, the financial institution shall include in its garnishees memorandum the location or locations of the property, and the judgment creditor shall obtain a writ of execution covering the property and directed to the levying officer in that county to accomplish the turnover of the property and shall forward the writ and related required documentation to the levying officer in the county in which the property is held.
(d)(e)A financial institution may modify or revoke any designation made pursuant to subdivision (a) by filing the modification or revocation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. The modification or revocation shall be effective when the Department of Financial Protection and Innovations records have been updated to reflect the modification or revocation, provided that the judgment creditor may rely upon the superseded designation during the 30-day period following the effective date of the revocation or modification.
(e)(f)(1) The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall update its online records to reflect a filing by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision subdivisions (a) and (b) or a modification or revocation filed by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (d) (e) within 10 business days following the filing by the financial institution. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovations internet website shall reflect the date its online records for each financial institution have most recently been updated.
(2)The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall provide any person requesting it with a copy of each current filing made by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (a). subdivisions (a) and (b). The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may satisfy its obligation under this subdivision by posting all current designations of a financial institution, or the pertinent information therein, on an internet website available to the public without charge, and if that information is made available, the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may impose a reasonable fee for furnishing that information in any other manner.
(f)(g)As to deposit accounts maintained or property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box at a branch or office covered by central process, service of legal process at a location other than a central location designated by the financial institution shall not be effective unless the financial institution, in its absolute discretion, elects to act upon the process at that location as if it were effective. In the absence of an election, the financial institution may respond to the legal process by mailing or delivery of the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer within the time otherwise provided therefor, with a statement on the garnishees memorandum that the legal process was not properly served at the financial institutions designated location for receiving legal process, and, therefore, was not processed, and the address at which the financial institution is to receive legal process.
(g)(h)If any legal process is served at a central location of a financial institution pursuant to this section, all related papers to be served on the financial institution shall be served at that location, unless agreed to the contrary between the serving party and the financial institution.
(h)(i)This subdivision shall apply whenever a financial institution operates within this state at least one branch or office in addition to its head office or main office, as applicable, or a financial institution headquartered in another state operates more than one branch or office within this state, and no central location has been designated or deemed to have been designated by the institution for service of legal process relating to deposit accounts maintained at the financial institutions head office or main office, as applicable, and branches located within this state. If a judgment creditor reasonably believes that, pursuant to Section 700.140 and, if applicable, Section 700.160, any act of enforcement would be effective against a specific deposit account maintained at a financial institution described in this subdivision, the judgment creditor may file with the financial institution a written request that the financial institution identify the branch or office within this state at which a specified account might be maintained by the financial institution. The written request shall contain the following statements or information:
(1)The name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands.
(2)If the name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands is not a judgment debtor identified in the writ of execution, a statement that a person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands will be appropriately identified in the legal process to be served pursuant to Section 700.160, including any supplementary papers, such as a court order or affidavit if the same will be required by Section 700.160.
(3)The specific identifying number of the account reasonably believed to be maintained with the financial institution and standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person.
(4)The address of the requesting party.
(5)An affidavit by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel stating substantially the following:
I hereby declare that this deposit account location request complies with Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the account or accounts of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process and specified herein are subject to a valid writ of execution, or court order, that I have a reasonable belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, that the financial institution receiving this deposit account location request has an account standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process, and that information pertaining to the location of the account will assist the judgment creditor in enforcing the judgment.
(i)
(j)The affidavit contemplated by subdivision (h) (i) shall be signed by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel and filed at the financial institutions head office located within this state or, if the financial institutions head office is in another state, at one of its branches or offices within this state. Failure to comply with the requirements of subdivision (h) (i) and this subdivision shall be sufficient basis for the financial institution to refuse to produce the information that would otherwise be required by subdivision (j). (k).
(j)(k)Within 10 banking days following receipt by a financial institution at the applicable location specified in subdivision (i) (j) of a request contemplated by subdivision (h), (i), as to each specific deposit account identified in the request contemplated by subdivision (h), (i), the financial institution shall respond by mailing, by first-class mail with postage prepaid, to the requesters address as specified in the request a response indicating the branch or office location of the financial institution at which the specified deposit account might be maintained, or, if the specified deposit account, if it exists, would not be maintained at a specific location, at least one place within this state at which legal process relating to the deposit account should or may be served. The response to be furnished pursuant to this subdivision shall not require the financial institution to determine whether an account exists or, if an account does exist, whether it would be reached by the legal process, rather, the branch or office location shall be determined and reported by the financial institution based solely upon its determination that an account with the identifying number provided by the requester would be maintained at that branch if an account did exist, and the response shall not contain any information about the name in which the account stands or any other information concerning the account, if it exists. If more than one account number is specified in the request, the financial institutions responses as to some or all of those account numbers may be combined in a single writing.
(k)(l)A response furnished in good faith by the financial institution pursuant to subdivision (j) (k) shall not be deemed to violate the privacy of any person in whose name the specified deposit account stands nor the privacy of any other person, and shall not require the consent of the person in whose name the account stands nor that of any other person.
(l)(m)A financial institution shall not notify the person in whose name the specified deposit account stands or any other person related to the specified account of the receipt of any request made pursuant to subdivision (h) (i) and affecting that persons or persons accounts at the financial institution, provided that the financial institution shall have no liability for its failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
(n)For purposes of this section, third-party agent means a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses. Third-party agent does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
(a)A financial institution may, and if it has more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within this state shall, designate one four or more central locations for service of legal process within this state. Each designated location shall be referred to as a central location. location, and shall not be located in the same county as another designated location. If a financial institution elects or is required to designate a central location for service of legal process, the financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation which filing shall be effective upon filing and shall contain all of the following:
(1)The physical address of the central location.
(2)The days and hours during which service will be accepted at the central location.
(3)If the central location will not accept service of legal process directed at deposit accounts maintained or property held at all of the financial institutions branches or offices within this state, or if the service accepted at the central location will not apply to safe-deposit boxes or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor, the filing shall also contain sufficient information to permit a determination of the limitation or limitations, including, in the case of a limitation applicable to certain branches or offices, an identification of the branches or offices as to which service at the central location will not apply and the nature of the limitation applicable to those branches or offices. If the limitation will apply to all branches or offices of the financial institution within this state, the filing may indicate the nature of the limitation and that it applies to all branches or offices, in lieu of an identification of branches or offices as to which the limitation applies. To the extent that a financial institutions designation of a central location for service of legal process covers the process directed at deposit accounts, safe-deposit boxes, or other property of the judgment debtor held by or for the judgment debtor at a particular branch or office located within this state, the branch or office shall be a branch or office covered by central process.
(b)Should a financial institution required to designate a central location fail to do so, each branch of that institution located in this state shall be deemed to be a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institutions branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
(c)Subject to any limitation noted pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), service of legal process at a central location of a financial institution shall be effective against all deposit accounts and all property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box if the same is described in the legal process and held by the financial institution at any branch or office covered by central process and located within this state. However, while service of legal process at the central location will establish a lien on all property, if any property other than deposit accounts is physically held by the financial institution in a county other than that in which the designated central location is located, the financial institution shall include in its garnishees memorandum the location or locations of the property, and the judgment creditor shall obtain a writ of execution covering the property and directed to the levying officer in that county to accomplish the turnover of the property and shall forward the writ and related required documentation to the levying officer in the county in which the property is held.
(d)A financial institution may modify or revoke any designation made pursuant to subdivision (a) by filing the modification or revocation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. The modification or revocation shall be effective when the Department of Financial Protection and Innovations records have been updated to reflect the modification or revocation, provided that the judgment creditor may rely upon the superseded designation during the 30-day period following the effective date of the revocation or modification.
(e)(1) The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall update its online records to reflect a filing by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (a) or a modification or revocation filed by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (d) within 10 business days following the filing by the financial institution. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovations internet website shall reflect the date its online records for each financial institution have most recently been updated.
(2)The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation shall provide any person requesting it with a copy of each current filing made by a financial institution pursuant to subdivision (a). The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may satisfy its obligation under this subdivision by posting all current designations of a financial institution, or the pertinent information therein, on an internet website available to the public without charge, and if that information is made available, the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation may impose a reasonable fee for furnishing that information in any other manner.
(f)As to deposit accounts maintained or property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box at a branch or office covered by central process, service of legal process at a location other than a central location designated by the financial institution shall not be effective unless the financial institution, in its absolute discretion, elects to act upon the process at that location as if it were effective. In the absence of an election, the financial institution may respond to the legal process by mailing or delivery of the garnishees memorandum to the levying officer within the time otherwise provided therefor, with a statement on the garnishees memorandum that the legal process was not properly served at the financial institutions designated location for receiving legal process, and, therefore, was not processed, and the address at which the financial institution is to receive legal process.
(g)If any legal process is served at a central location of a financial institution pursuant to this section, all related papers to be served on the financial institution shall be served at that location, unless agreed to the contrary between the serving party and the financial institution.
(h)This subdivision shall apply whenever a financial institution operates within this state at least one branch or office in addition to its head office or main office, as applicable, or a financial institution headquartered in another state operates more than one branch or office within this state, and no central location has been designated or deemed to have been designated by the institution for service of legal process relating to deposit accounts maintained at the financial institutions head office or main office, as applicable, and branches located within this state. If a judgment creditor reasonably believes that, pursuant to Section 700.140 and, if applicable, Section 700.160, any act of enforcement would be effective against a specific deposit account maintained at a financial institution described in this subdivision, the judgment creditor may file with the financial institution a written request that the financial institution identify the branch or office within this state at which a specified account might be maintained by the financial institution. The written request shall contain the following statements or information:
(1)The name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands.
(2)If the name of the person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands is not a judgment debtor identified in the writ of execution, a statement that a person reasonably believed by the judgment creditor to be a person in whose name the specified deposit account stands will be appropriately identified in the legal process to be served pursuant to Section 700.160, including any supplementary papers, such as a court order or affidavit if the same will be required by Section 700.160.
(3)The specific identifying number of the account reasonably believed to be maintained with the financial institution and standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person.
(4)The address of the requesting party.
(5)An affidavit by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel stating substantially the following:
I hereby declare that this deposit account location request complies with Section 684.115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the account or accounts of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process and specified herein are subject to a valid writ of execution, or court order, that I have a reasonable belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, that the financial institution receiving this deposit account location request has an account standing in the name of the judgment debtor or other person or persons appropriately identified in the legal process, and that information pertaining to the location of the account will assist the judgment creditor in enforcing the judgment.
(i)The affidavit contemplated by subdivision (h) shall be signed by the judgment creditor or the judgment creditors counsel and filed at the financial institutions head office located within this state or, if the financial institutions head office is in another state, at one of its branches or offices within this state. Failure to comply with the requirements of subdivision (h) and this subdivision shall be sufficient basis for the financial institution to refuse to produce the information that would otherwise be required by subdivision (j).
(j)Within 10 banking days following receipt by a financial institution at the applicable location specified in subdivision (i) of a request contemplated by subdivision (h), as to each specific deposit account identified in the request contemplated by subdivision (h), the financial institution shall respond by mailing, by first-class mail with postage prepaid, to the requesters address as specified in the request a response indicating the branch or office location of the financial institution at which the specified deposit account might be maintained, or, if the specified deposit account, if it exists, would not be maintained at a specific location, at least one place within this state at which legal process relating to the deposit account should or may be served. The response to be furnished pursuant to this subdivision shall not require the financial institution to determine whether an account exists or, if an account does exist, whether it would be reached by the legal process, rather, the branch or office location shall be determined and reported by the financial institution based solely upon its determination that an account with the identifying number provided by the requester would be maintained at that branch if an account did exist, and the response shall not contain any information about the name in which the account stands or any other information concerning the account, if it exists. If more than one account number is specified in the request, the financial institutions responses as to some or all of those account numbers may be combined in a single writing.
(k)A response furnished in good faith by the financial institution pursuant to subdivision (j) shall not be deemed to violate the privacy of any person in whose name the specified deposit account stands nor the privacy of any other person, and shall not require the consent of the person in whose name the account stands nor that of any other person.
(l)A financial institution shall not notify the person in whose name the specified deposit account stands or any other person related to the specified account of the receipt of any request made pursuant to subdivision (h) and affecting that persons or persons accounts at the financial institution, provided that the financial institution shall have no liability for its failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 12, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 222, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 12, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 77. Noes 0. Page 6360.). |
| Aug 12, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 14 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 12, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 5043.). |
| Aug 6, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 19). |
| Jun 12, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & F.I. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 11). Re-referred to Com. on B. & F.I. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 30, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 1, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and B. & F.I. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 72. Noes 0.) |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Mar 19, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (March 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 6, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 7. |
| Feb 5, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2024 | AB 2067 Dixon Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2024 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB2067 Dixon | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions |
Passed |
|
| Jun 11, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Banking and Financial Institutions] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2024 | AB 2067 Dixon Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2024 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 19, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2067
Author:(Dixon)
As Amended Ver:June 24, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Permits a financial institution to designate a third-party agent as its central location for service of legal process. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines "third-party agent" as a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses.
- Establishes that "third-party agent" does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
- Provides that a financial institution may designate, as its central location for service of legal process, a third-party agent.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, the financial institution must designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location.
- Provides that, in designating the second location, the financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple locations if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, it must file notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation.
- Updates cross-references in the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
Senate Amendments
Clarify the process for a financial institution's designation of a central location for service of legal process and make other nonsubstantive conforming changes.
COMMENTS
In 2012, the Legislature amended the law to require all financial institutions with ten or more California branches to designate a central location at which they will accept service of levies and other process that would be effective as to all accounts statewide. Before that change, a plaintiff or judgment creditor seeking to levy on an account had to identify and separately serve each branch of a bank at which the defendant or judgment debtor maintained accounts to reach all of those deposits. During and in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department experienced staffing and resource limitations, which affected their ability to serve levies and attachments on many of the financial institutions that designated their downtown Los Angeles branch to receive legal process. Despite recent changes to the Department's policies, the growing backlog of writs and levies remains significant and continues to be troublesome for the timely issuance of valid writs and levies.
Background on attachment and execution of levy. Attachment is an order by a court, while a civil action is pending, directing that money or property of the defendant be held as security for the eventual satisfaction of a judgment, if one is obtained. In other words, attachment is a provisional remedy to aid the plaintiff in the collection of a money judgment by seizure of the defendant's money or property in advance of a trial or judgment. It is ordered when a court, after a hearing on an application for a writ of attachment, finds that the plaintiff has established the probable validity of the claim, and that other requirements have been met. In contrast, writs of execution are issued only after judgment is entered by the court. They permit the judgment creditor to collect against the property of the judgment debtor, including deposit accounts held by a financial institution. In short, attachment can be seen as a pre-judgment security device, while execution of levy is a post-judgment collection device. This bill expands the number of central locations designated to receive service of process for both attachment to and execution of levies upon accounts, safe deposit boxes, and other property held by the debtor or defendant's bank.
Original legislation sought to fix problems in connection with service of attachment and execution of levies against financial institutions. In 2012, AB 2364 (Wagner) Chapter 484, Statutes of 2012, intended to modernize the procedures applicable to service of attachment and execution of levies against financial institutions. Among other things, that bill required all financial institutions with ten or more California branches, and permitted smaller financial institutions, to designate a central location at which they will accept service of levies and other process that would be effective as to all accounts statewide. Before this measure was signed into law, a plaintiff or judgment creditor seeking to levy on an account had to identify and separately serve each branch of a bank at which the defendant or judgment debtor maintained accounts to reach all of those deposits. According to proponents of that measure, the requirement that the judgment creditor serve the proper branch also facilitated the concealment of assets by a dishonest judgment debtor, because an examination of the debtor to identify the branch prompted a bad-faith debtor to move the funds and game the system.
According to the Consumer Financial Services Committee of the Business Law Section of the State Bar, AB 2364's sponsor, those pre-2012 rules "reflect[ed] the pre-Information Age practice by which all of a bank's customer records were maintained locally at the branch at which the account was maintained, often on index cards. One branch of a bank did not have the tools to readily identify bank-customer relationships at other locations of the same bank. Hence,[the prior rules were] crafted to require service of levies on the particular branch at which the account was maintained and serviced."
By facilitating service of process at a central location instead of at individual branches, AB 2364 was intended to reduce unnecessary expenses on collection, and prevent unscrupulous debtors from manipulating the rules to avoid their obligations. The animating idea behind AB 2364 was that given the relatively concentrated nature of the banking industry, a creditor serving levies on the central locations designated by just a handful of the largest banks would probably capture a sizable majority of all of the deposit accounts and safe deposit boxes in California. According to the author, the law needs further updating to keep pace with changing conditions.
The Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in a backlog of writs and levies. Several large financial institutions have designated one location in downtown Los Angeles as their central location to receive legal process, including nationally recognized financial institutions. Of the 188 financial institutions that have designated locations for service of legal process, 14 have designated Los Angeles as their central location for service of legal process. (DFPI, Central Locations for Service of Legal Process, available at https://dfpi.ca.gov/central-locations-for-service-of-legal-process/ (last accessed Mar. 6, 2024).)
According to the author, during and after the pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department limited the number requests for issuance of bank levies to 70 per day, primarily due to staffing and resource limitations. Despite recent changes to the Department's policies, the author argues that the growing backlog of writs and levies remains significant and continues to be troublesome for the timely issuance of valid writs and levies. If the writ or levy is not timely, then a judgment debtor could just move the money out of their bank accounts and thus avoid payment.
This bill provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent, as defined, to serve as a central location for service of legal process, the financial institution must designate at least one other central location which must be located in a different county than the third-party agent.
According to the Author
AB 2067 seeks to provide more flexibility to legal service of process by expanding on the number of financial institutions which wish to limit the number of branches eligible to receive legal process. Existing law allows financial institutions, with ten or more California branches, with the option to designate one or more central locations for receiving legal process, such as service of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies, for all deposit accounts. This bill is in direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic which limited Sheriff Departments' ability to timely issue writs and levies, particularly in Los Angeles County. This growing backlog could be alleviated by allowing more than just one location to receive legal service of process and AB 2067 seeks to make such change.
Arguments in Support
The bill's sponsors, the California Association of Legal Support Professionals, write:
AB 2067 seeks to increase the number of locations a large financial institution would need to designate to receive legal service of process. Specifically, this bill increases the designation from at least one location to at least four locations in different counties. This bill will help sheriffs with the timely issuance of writs and levies by allowing process to be spread amongst several counties while also helping prevent judgment debtors from dodging payment.
AB 2067 is not in its final form, and we acknowledge the bill needs refinement. We have been meeting with the California Bankers Association, California Credit Union League, California Community Banking Network, and others. We commit to continuing to work with all stakeholders and the committee to find a fair solution.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 12-0-0
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez, Waldron
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-1
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Wendy Carrillo
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-0-8
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Essayli, Mathis
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-2
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Umberg
UPDATED
VERSION: June 24, 2024
CONSULTANT: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003838
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2067 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 2067
Author: Dixon (R)
Amended: 6/24/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/11/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Niello, Roth, Stern, Wahab
SENATE BANKING & F.I. COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/19/24
AYES: Limón, Niello, Caballero, Min, Nguyen, Portantino
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-0, 4/18/24 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Financial institutions: service of process
SOURCE: California Association of Legal Support Professionals
DIGEST:
This bill provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent, as defined, to serve as a central location for service of legal process, the financial institution must designate at least one other central location which must be located in a different county than the third-party agent.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides for prejudgment attachment of property in connection with an action on a claim for money, where the party seeking the attachment applies for and obtains a writ of attachment, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedures (Code Civ. Proc.), pt. 2, tit. 6.5, §§ 481.010 et seq.)
- Permits a range of property to be attached pursuant to 1), including:
- Monies in a deposit account. (Code Civ. Proc., § 488.455)
- Property in a safe-deposit box. (Code Civ. Proc., § 488.460)
- Establishes the Enforcement of Judgments Law, which sets forth the procedures for enforcing a civil judgment. (Code Civ. Proc., pt. 2, tit. 9, div. 1, §§ 680.010 et seq.)
- Provides that, when legal process is required to be personally served in connection with a civil judgment, the service shall be made in the same manner as provided for the service of civil summons, with specific exceptions, including:
- If legal process is required to be personally served on a financial institution in connection with a deposit account or with property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box, service must be made at the office or branch that has actual possession of the property levied upon, or at which a deposit levied upon is carried, or at which the financial institution maintains the account, except as provided in 5)-7). Service on the specific office or branch shall be made upon the officer, manager, or other person in charge of the office or branch at the time of service. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.110(c))
- Requires a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within the state to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state, as follows:
- Each designated location shall be referred to as a “central location.”
- The financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), which is effective upon filing, that includes the physical address of the central location, the days and hours during which the central location will accept service, and information relating to any limitations on the service of process the central location will accept (e.g., if the central location will not accept service of process related to safe-deposit boxes held at other locations).
- If a financial institution that is required to designate a central location fails to do so, each branch of that institution located in the state shall be deemed a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institution’s branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
- DFPI must provide on its website the central locations designated by each financial institution, and must update the records within 10 days of a financial institution making a modification or revocation. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.115)
- Permits, but does not require, a financial institution with fewer than ten branches or offices at which it conducts its business within the state to designate one or more central locations for service, under the same terms as 5). (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.115)
- Provides that, where legal process is served on a financial institution other than at a designated central location, the office may, but is not required to, act upon the service, even if the property is located at the location served. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.110(d)(e))
This bill:
- Defines “third-party agent” as a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses; “third-party agent” does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
- Provides that a financial institution may designate, as its central location for service of legal process, a third-party agent.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, the financial institution must designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location.
- In designating the second location, the financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple locations if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, it must provide the name of the third-party agent to the DFPI for posting on the DFPI’s service website.
- Updates cross-references in the Code of Civil Procedure to reflect the changes made in 1)-4).
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
Comments
Under current law, a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices in the state must designate a central location to accept all service of legal process in the state. This requirement was intended to avoid the need for creditors to serve multiple branches of the same bank with a writ of attachment or writ of execution, and to give financial institutions more certainty regarding where they might be served. Financial institutions with nine or fewer branches or offices may, but are not required to, designate a central location for service as well. The DFPI maintains a list of the designated locations on its website.
According to the author California Association of Legal Support Professionals (CALSPro), the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department has severely curtailed its availability to issue writs for service at multiple financial institutions in the state, due to a combination of factors arising from the COVID-19 pandemic and staffing shortages. The author and sponsor state that, because many of the financial institutions have designated, as their central location for service, a third-party service agent located within the County of Los Angeles, this has led to a backlog in the service of writs on financial institutions. This bill is intended to alleviate the backlog by specifying that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent, as defined by the bill, as its central location for service, the financial institution must designate at least one other central location, which must be located in a different county than the designated third-party agent.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/5/24)
California Association of Legal Support Professionals (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/5/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to CALSPro, the sponsor of the bill:
During the pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department began limiting the number of requests for issuance of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies. Like many agencies during and after the pandemic, the department made these changes due primarily to staffing and resource limitations. CALSPro has worked collaboratively with the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department to address this limitation; unfortunately, the existing backlog continues. This backlog is a significant problem for the timely execution of valid writs and levies.
AB 2067 directs large financial institutions who designate a third-party agent to receive legal service of process to designate another location in a different county. Specifically, this bill allows a financial institution to designate a third-party agent as a non-financial institution who is in the business of accepting legal process on behalf of the institution. By requiring one additional location in a different county, this bill helps sheriffs with the timely issuance of writs and levies by allowing process to be spread amongst several counties while also helping prevent judgment debtors from dodging payment….
We acknowledge and appreciate the stakeholders for working with us, specifically the California Bankers Association, California Credit Union League, and California Community Banking Network. We believe that this compromise is a fair solution for all – financial institutions, legal support professionals, and parties seeking to enforce a writ or levy.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-0, 4/18/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Essayli, Mathis
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/6/24 16:10:43
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BANKING AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Senator Monique Limón, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 2067 Hearing Date: June 19, 2024
Author: | Dixon | ||
Version: | June 3, 2024 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Michael Burdick | ||
Subject: Financial institutions: service of process
SUMMARY
This bill requires a financial institution that designates a third-party agent, as defined, to serve as a central location for service of legal process to also designate at least one other central location in a different county.
EXISTING LAW
- Provides the Enforcement of Judgments Law, which sets forth the processes and enforcement of judgments, i.e., amounts owed to a prevailing party in a civil action. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 680.010 et seq.)
- Requires that, if the legal process is required to be personally served on a financial institution in connection with a deposit account or with property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box, service be made at the office or branch that has actual possession of the property levied upon or at which a deposit account levied upon is carried, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 684.110)
- Requires a financial institution with ten or more branches to designate one or more central location for service of legal process within the state, and provides express authority to institutions with nine or fewer branches to do the same. Requires a financial institution that designates a central location for service of legal process to file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 684.115(a))
THIS BILL
- Defines “third-party agent” as a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses. Provides that a third-party agent does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
- Authorizes a financial institution to designate a third-party agent as a central location for service of legal process. Requires a financial institution that so designates a third-party agent to designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location.
- Authorizes a financial institution to designate the same third-party agent as multiple central locations for service of legal process if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
- Requires a financial institution that designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of legal process to include in its notice filed with DFPI the name of the third-party agent.
COMMENTS
- PURPOSE
According to the author:
AB 2067 seeks to provide more flexibility to legal service of process by directing large financial institutions which designate a third-party agent to receive legal service of process to designate another location in a different county. Existing law allows financial institutions, with ten or more California branches, with the option to designate one or more central locations for receiving legal process, such as service of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies, for all deposit accounts. This bill is in direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic which limited Sheriff Departments’ ability to timely issue writs and levies, particularly in Los Angeles County. This growing backlog could be alleviated by allowing more than just one location to receive legal service of process for third-party agents and AB 2067 seeks to make such change.
- BACKGROUND
As explained in the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis of this bill, which is incorporated here by reference:
California law permits a party to exercise control—temporarily or permanently—over another party’s property to satisfy a debt or judgment, or in anticipation of a judgment. A “writ of execution” is a court order directing a sheriff or other officer to enforce a judgment, thereby allowing the judgment creditor to take or seize property in execution of a judgment that has been issued against the debtor. A “writ of attachment” allows a creditor to seize the debtor’s property while an action for a judgment in excess of $500 is pending so that, if a judgment is entered, the creditor is able to use that property to satisfy the judgment. Both types of writs may be executed against property held by a financial institution, including money, financial instruments, and items held in safety deposit boxes.
In the event that a creditor needs to execute a writ against property held at a financial institution, the writ must be served on that financial institution. Prior to 2013, a creditor would have to determine the specific branch at which the property was held or the monies were deposited, which could require service at multiple locations of the same bank. In 2012, to simplify the process and prevent gamesmanship in the judgment collection process, the Legislature passed AB 2364 (Wagner, Ch. 484, Stats 2012), which required financial institutions with more than nine branches or offices in the state to designate a single branch for the service of all writs of execution or attachment, and permits financial institutions with nine or fewer branches or offices in the state to do the same. Under the regime implemented by AB 2364, the financial institution must provide its designated location to the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), and the DFPI must post the location, along with any limitations on the designation (e.g., excluding property kept in safety deposit boxes from attachment through service at the designated location) on its website
Until recently, the process provided by AB 2364 seemed to be working well. According to the author, several large financial institutions designated one location in downtown Los Angeles as their central location to receive legal process, including nationally recognized financial institutions. This means that many judgments issued by California courts are enforced through the LA County Sheriff’s Department, even for property held at bank branches outside of LA County.
When the COVID pandemic hit and in its aftermath, the LA County Sheriff’s Department limited the number of writs that it will serve to financial institutions due primarily to staffing and resource limitations. This decision has led to a material backlog of writs and levies that are not being served timely, which may allow a judgment debtor to move money out of their bank account in an attempt to avoid paying the judgment.
- HOW THIS BILL ADDRESSES THE PROBLEM
The California Association of Legal Support Professionals (CALSPro) sponsored this bill with the intent of clearing the backlog in LA County and avoiding this problem in the future. CALSPro has worked with the LA County Sheriff’s Department to address the resource limitations that are contributing to the backlog, but the problem persists. Amending state law is the sponsor’s next step in attempting to address the problem.
This bill amends the process established by AB 2364 in 2012. The bill requires a financial institution that designates a third-party agent as its central location to also identify a second central location in another county. This requirement should ease the pressure on the LA County Sheriff’s Department, alleviating the current backlog and preventing such a backlog from building up in the first place.
- ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
CALSPro sponsored this bill for the reasons stated above.
- AMENDMENTS
Recent amendments restructured Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 684.115 by adding a new subdivision (b), but conforming changes were not made to references to this section in CCP Section 701.030 or CCP Section 488.610. Committee staff recommends the committee adopt technical amendments to make these conforming changes.
- DOUBLE-REFERRAL
This bill was heard by the Committee on Judiciary on June 11, 2024, where it was approved 11-0.
LIST OF REGISTERED SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Support
California Association of Legal Support Professionals (sponsor)
Opposition
None received
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2067 (Author:Dixon)
Version: June 3, 2024
Hearing Date: June 11, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AWM
SUBJECT
Financial institutions: service of process
DIGEST
This bill provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent, as defined, to serve as a central location for service of legal process, the financial institution must designate at least one other central location which must be located in a different county than the third-party agent.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under current law, a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices in the state must designate a central location to accept all service of legal process in the state. This requirement was intended to avoid the need for creditors to serve multiple branches of the same bank with a writ of attachment or writ of execution, and to give financial institutions more certainty regarding where they might be served. Financial institutions with nine or fewer branches or offices may, but are not required to, designate a central location for service as well. The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) maintains a list of the designated locations on its website.
According to the author and sponsor of the bill, the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department has severely curtailed its availability to issue writs for service at multiple financial institutions in the state, due to a combination of factors arising from the COVID-19 pandemic and staffing shortages. The author and sponsor state that, because many of the financial institutions have designated, as their central location for service, a third-party service agent located within the County of Los Angeles, this has led to a backlog in the service of writs on financial institutions. This bill is intended to alleviate the backlog by specifying that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent, as defined by the bill, as its central location for service, the financial institution must designate at least one other central location, which must be located in a different county than the designated third-party agent.
This bill is sponsored by the California Association of Legal Support Professionals (CALSPro). The Committee has not received timely opposition to this bill. If this bill is passed by this Committee, it will then be heard by the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides for prejudgment attachment of property in connection with an action on a claim for money, where the party seeking the attachment applies for and obtains a writ of attachment, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc., pt. 2, tit. 6.5, §§ 481.010 et seq.)
- Permits a range of property to be attached pursuant to 1), including:
- Monies in a deposit account. (Code Civ. Proc., § 488.455.)
- Property in a safe-deposit box. (Code Civ. Proc., § 488.460.)
- Establishes the Enforcement of Judgments Law, which sets forth the procedures for enforcing a civil judgment. (Code Civ. Proc., pt. 2, tit. 9, div. 1, §§ 680.010 et seq.)
- Provides that, when legal process is required to be personally served in connection with a civil judgment, the service shall be made in the same manner as provided for the service of civil summons, with specific exceptions, including:
- If legal process is required to be personally served on a financial institution in connection with a deposit account or with property held for safekeeping, as collateral for an obligation owed to the financial institution or in a safe-deposit box, service must be made at the office or branch that has actual possession of the property levied upon, or at which a deposit levied upon is carried, or at which the financial institution maintains the account, except as provided in 5)-7). Service on the specific office or branch shall be made upon the officer, manager, or other person in charge of the office or branch at the time of service. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.110(c).)
- Requires a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices at which it conducts its business within the state to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state, as follows:
- Each designated location shall be referred to as a “central location.”
- The financial institution shall file a notice of its designation with the DFPI, which is effective upon filing, that includes the physical address of the central location, the days and hours during which the central location will accept service, and information relating to any limitations on the service of process the central location will accept (e.g., if the central location will not accept service of process related to safe-deposit boxes held at other locations).
- If a financial institution that is required to designate a central location fails to do so, each branch of that institution located in the state shall be deemed a central location at which service of legal process may be made, and all of the institution’s branches or offices located within this state shall be deemed to be a branch or office covered by central process.
- DFPI must provide on its website the central locations designated by each financial institution, and must update the records within 10 days of a financial institution making a modification or revocation. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.115.)
- Permits, but does not require, a financial institution with fewer than ten branches or offices at which it conducts its business within the state to designate one or more central locations for service, under the same terms as 5). (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.115.)
- Provides that, where legal process is served on a financial institution other than at a designated central location, the office may, but is not required to, act upon the service, even if the property is located at the location served. (Code Civ. Proc., § 684.110(d), (e).)
This bill:
- Defines “third-party agent” as a non-financial institution entity, such as a corporation, that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses; “third-party agent” does not include a licensed attorney or law firm acting on behalf of a financial institution.
- Provides that a financial institution may designate, as its central location for service of legal process, a third-party agent.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, the financial institution must designate at least one additional central location that is not located in the same county as another designated central location.
- In designating the second location, the financial institution may designate the same third-party agent as multiple locations if the third-party agent maintains physical locations in multiple counties.
- Provides that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process, it must provide the name of the third-party agent to the DFPI for posting on the DFPI’s service website.
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
COMMENTS
- Author’s comment
According to the author:
AB 2067 seeks to provide more flexibility to legal service of process by expanding on the number of financial institutions which wish to limit the number of branches eligible to receive legal process. Existing law allows financial institutions, with ten or more California branches, with the option to designate one or more central locations for receiving legal process, such as service of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies, for all deposit accounts. This bill is in direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic which limited Sheriff Departments’ ability to timely issue writs and levies, particularly in Los Angeles County. This growing backlog could be alleviated by allowing more than just one location to receive legal service of process and AB 2067 seeks to make such change.
2. Background: executing a writ of attachment or judgment against property held by a financial institution
California law permits a party to exercise control—temporarily or permanently—over another party’s property to satisfy a debt or judgment, or in anticipation of a judgment. A “writ of execution” is a court order directing a sheriff or other officer to enforce a judgment, thereby allowing the judgment creditor to take or seize property in execution of a judgment that has been issued against the debtor.[1] A “writ of attachment” allows a creditor to seize the debtor’s property while an action for a judgment in excess of $500 is pending so that, if a judgment is entered, the creditor is able to use that property to satisfy the judgment.[2] Both types of writs may be executed against property held by a financial institution, including money, financial instruments, and items held in safety deposit boxes.[3]
In the event that a creditor needs to execute a writ against property held at a financial institution, the writ must be served on that financial institution. Prior to 2013, a creditor would have to determine the specific branch at which the property was held or the monies were deposited, which could require service at multiple locations of the same bank. In 2012, to simplify the process and prevent gamesmanship in the judgment collection process, the Legislature passed AB 2364 (Wagner, Ch. 484, Stats 2012), which required financial institutions with more than nine branches or offices in the state to designate a single branch for the service of all writs of execution or attachment, and permits financial institutions with nine or fewer branches or offices in the state to do the same. Under the regime implemented by AB 2364, the financial institution must provide its designated location to the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), and the DFPI must post the location, along with any limitations on the designation (e.g., excluding property kept in safety deposit boxes from attachment through service at the designated location) on its website.[4]
3. This bill requires a financial institutions that designates a third-party agent as its central location for service of process to designate at least one other central location, which must be located in a different county
According to the author and sponsors of the bill, the AB 2364 regime has hit a snag: many of the state’s financial institutions have designated, as their central service locations, a third-party agent for service of process in the County of Los Angeles, and the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department is severely backlogged in its ability to serve writs of execution or attachment.[5] As a result, there is a statewide slowdown on the service of writs of execution and attachment, even for property held at a branch or office located outside the County of Los Angeles.
This bill is intended to circumvent the service logjam in Los Angeles by specifying that, if a financial institution designates a third-party agent as its central location, the financial institution must additionally designate a second central location; that second central location must be located in a different county than the first central location. The bill defines a third-party agent as a non-financial entity that is in the business of accepting service of legal process on behalf of financial institutions and other businesses, and expressly excludes attorneys and law firms from the definition; this definition appears adequate to ensure that financial institutions are designating only those entities that are adequately equipped to accept service. The bill also clarifies that a financial institution that designates a third-party agent as its central location must provide the name of the third-party agent to the DFPI for inclusion on the DFPI’s website.
4. Arguments in support
According to CALSPro, the sponsor of the bill:
During the pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department began limiting the number of requests for issuance of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies. Like many agencies during and after the pandemic, the department made these changes due primarily to staffing and resource limitations. CALSPro has worked collaboratively with the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department to address this limitation; unfortunately, the existing backlog continues. This backlog is a significant problem for the timely execution of valid writs and levies.
AB 2067 directs large financial institutions who designate a third-party agent to receive legal service of process to designate another location in a different county. Specifically, this bill allows a financial institution to designate a third-party agent as a non-financial institution who is in the business of accepting legal process on behalf of the institution. By requiring one additional location in a different county, this bill helps sheriffs with the timely issuance of writs and levies by allowing process to be spread amongst several counties while also helping prevent judgment debtors from dodging payment….
We acknowledge and appreciate the stakeholders for working with us, specifically the California Bankers Association, California Credit Union League, and California Community Banking Network. We believe that this compromise is a fair solution for all – financial institutions, legal support professionals, and parties seeking to enforce a writ or levy.
SUPPORT
CALSPro
OPPOSITION
None received
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending legislation: None known.
Prior legislation: AB 2364 (Wagner, Ch. 484, Stats 2012) required a financial institution with more than nine locations in the state to designate a single location for the service of writs. AB 2364 is discussed in greater detail in Part 2 of this analysis.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 72, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 14, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
**************
Code Civ. Proc., § 699.510. ↑
Id, § 483.010. ↑
Id, §§ 488.455, 488.460, 699.710. ↑
Id., § 684.115. ↑
A private registered process server may serve a writ on a financial institution, but before doing so they must deposit a copy of the writ with, and pay a fee to, the Sheriff’s Office in the county in which the writ will be served. (Code Civ. Proc., § 699.080.) Accordingly, the backlog cannot be avoided through the use of private process servers. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2067
Author:(Dixon) – As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2024
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices in the state to designate at least four locations at which the institution will receive service of process and requires that each designated location be in a different county.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Likely minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) to process additional designation notices.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 2067 seeks to provide more flexibility to legal service of process by expanding on the number of financial institutions which wish to limit the number of branches eligible to receive legal process… This bill is in direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic which limited Sheriff Departments’ ability to timely issue writs and levies, particularly in Los Angeles County. This growing backlog could be alleviated by allowing more than just one location to receive legal service of process and AB 2067 seeks to make such change.
- Background. Existing law requires a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices in the state to designate one central location at which it will accept service of process for legal proceedings. An institution must file notice of its designated location with DFPI. DFPI must publish an institution’s designated location on its website and provide a copy of an institution’s current filing with a member of the public upon request, either by publishing the filing on DFPI’s website or in another format in exchange for a reasonable fee. Financial institutions with nine or fewer branches may, but are not required to, designate a central location and file notice with DFPI.
This bill increases the number of locations that a qualifying financial institution must designate for service of process, from one location to four locations. Each designated location must be in a different county.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 19, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2067
Author:(Dixon) – As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Financial institutions: service of process
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS IN THE STATE DESIGNATE FOUR OR MORE CENTRAL LOCATIONS FOR SERVICE OF LEGAL PROCESS, RATHER THAN JUST ONE LOCATION?
SYNOPSIS
In 2012, the Legislature amended the law to require all financial institutions with ten or more California branches to designate a central location at which they will accept service of levies and other process that would be effective as to all accounts statewide. Before that change, a plaintiff or judgment creditor seeking to levy on an account had to identify and separately serve each branch of a bank at which the defendant or judgment debtor maintained accounts to reach all of those deposits. During and in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department experienced staffing and resource limitations, which affected their ability to serve levies and attachments on many of the financial institutions that designated their downtown Los Angeles branch to receive legal process. Despite recent changes to the Department’s policies, the growing backlog of writs and levies that need to be served remains significant and continues to be troublesome for the timely issuance of valid writs and levies.
This bill requires a financial institution with more than nine branches within the state, and permits a smaller financial institution, to designate four or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. According to the author, this bill is intended to alleviate the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department backlog, and more broadly help sheriffs across the state with the timely issuance of writs and levies by allowing process to be spread amongst several counties. It is sponsored by the CA Association of Legal Support Professionals and has no opposition.
SUMMARY: Alters the number of central locations for service of legal process a financial institution may designate within the state. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits a financial institution to designate four or more central locations for service of legal process within the state.
- Requires a financial institution with more than nine branches or offices within the state to designate four or more central locations for service of legal process within the state.
- Prohibits a financial institution from designating more than one central location for service of legal process in the same county.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for pre-judgment attachment of a defendant’s deposit accounts and safe-deposit boxes in banks and other financial institutions by personal service of a copy of the writ of attachment and a notice of attachment on the financial institution with which the deposit account is maintained. (Code of Civil Procedure Sections 488.455 (deposit accounts) and 488.460 (safe-deposit boxes). All further statutory references are to this code unless otherwise noted.)
- Requires personal service of writs, notices, orders, or other legal process, if on a bank or financial institution, to be made at the office or branch that has actual possession of the property levied upon or at which the deposit account levied upon is carried. (Section 684.110.)
- Requires a bank or financial institution that has more than nine branch offices in this state, and authorizes those with less than nine, to designate one or more central locations for service of legal process within the state. (Section 684.115 (a).)
- Requires the bank to file a notice of its designation with the Department of Financial Institutions (DFI), containing information regarding its address, hours during which service will be accepted, and any limitations on service. (Ibid.)
- Provides that if the institution with more than nine branches or offices in the state fails to make the designation, then each branch within the state is deemed to be a central location at which service may be made. (Section 684.115 (b).)
- Requires DFI to update its online records to reflect current designations within 10 days of filing. Further provides that DFI shall provide this information to any person requesting it, and may satisfy this requirement by making the information available for free to the public on its web site. (Section 684.115 (e).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 2012, the Legislature amended the law to require all financial institutions with ten or more California branches to designate a central location at which they will accept service of levies and other process that would be effective as to all accounts statewide. Before that change, a plaintiff or judgment creditor seeking to levy on an account had to identify and separately serve each branch of a bank at which the defendant or judgment debtor maintained accounts to reach all of those deposits. During and in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department experienced staffing and resource limitations, which affected their ability to serve levies and attachments on many of the financial institutions that designated their downtown Los Angeles branch to receive legal process. Despite recent changes to the Department’s policies, the growing backlog of writs and levies remains significant and continues to be troublesome for the timely issuance of valid writs and levies. The author explains how this bill will help alleviate the backlog:
AB 2067 seeks to provide more flexibility to legal service of process by expanding on the number of financial institutions which wish to limit the number of branches eligible to receive legal process. Existing law allows financial institutions, with ten or more California branches, with the option to designate one or more central locations for receiving legal process, such as service of writs of attachment and execution of bank levies, for all deposit accounts. This bill is in direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic which limited Sheriff Departments’ ability to timely issue writs and levies, particularly in Los Angeles County. This growing backlog could be alleviated by allowing more than just one location to receive legal service of process and AB 2067 seeks to make such change.
Background on attachment and execution of levy. Attachment is an order by a court, while a civil action is pending, directing that money or property of the defendant be held as security for the eventual satisfaction of a judgment, if one is obtained. In other words, attachment is a provisional remedy to aid the plaintiff in the collection of a money judgment by seizure of the defendant’s money or property in advance of a trial or judgment. It is ordered when a court, after a hearing on an application for a writ of attachment, finds that the plaintiff has established the probable validity of the claim, and that other requirements have been met. In contrast, writs of execution are issued only after judgment is entered by the court. They permit the judgment creditor to collect against the property of the judgment debtor, including deposit accounts held by a financial institution. In short, attachment can be seen as a pre-judgment security device, while execution of levy is a post-judgment collection device. This bill expands the number of central locations designated to receive service of process for both attachment to and execution of levies upon accounts, safe deposit boxes, and other property held by the debtor or defendant’s bank.
Original legislation sought to fix problems in connection with service of attachment and execution of levies against financial institutions. In 2012, AB 2364 (Wagner) Chap. 484, Stats. 2012, intended to modernize the procedures applicable to service of attachment and execution of levies against financial institutions. Among other things, that bill required all financial institutions with ten or more California branches, and permitted smaller financial institutions, to designate a central location at which they will accept service of levies and other process that would be effective as to all accounts statewide. Before this measure was signed into law, a plaintiff or judgment creditor seeking to levy on an account had to identify and separately serve each branch of a bank at which the defendant or judgment debtor maintained accounts to reach all of those deposits. According to proponents of that measure, the requirement that the judgment creditor serve the proper branch also facilitated the concealment of assets by a dishonest judgment debtor, because an examination of the debtor to identify the branch prompted a bad-faith debtor to move the funds and game the system.
According to the Consumer Financial Services Committee of the Business Law Section of the State Bar, AB 2364’s sponsor, those pre-2012 rules “reflect[ed] the pre-Information Age practice by which all of a bank’s customer records were maintained locally at the branch at which the account was maintained, often on index cards. One branch of a bank did not have the tools to readily identify bank-customer relationships at other locations of the same bank. Hence,[the prior rules were] crafted to require service of levies on the particular branch at which the account was maintained and serviced.”
By facilitating service of process at a central location instead of at individual branches, AB 2364 was intended to reduce unnecessary expenses on collection, and prevent unscrupulous debtors from manipulating the rules to avoid their obligations. The animating idea behind AB 2364 was that given the relatively concentrated nature of the banking industry, a creditor serving levies on the central locations designated by just a handful of the largest banks would probably capture a sizable majority of all of the deposit accounts and safe deposit boxes in California. According to the author, the law needs further updating to keep pace with changing conditions.
The Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in a backlog of writs and levies. Several large financial institutions have designated one location in downtown Los Angeles as their central location to receive legal process, including nationally recognized financial institutions. Of the 188 financial institutions that have designated locations for service of legal process, 14 have designated Los Angeles as their central location for service of legal process. (DFPI, Central Locations for Service of Legal Process, available at https://dfpi.ca.gov/central-locations-for-service-of-legal-process/ (last accessed Mar. 6, 2024).)
According to the author, during and after the pandemic, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department limited the number requests for issuance of bank levies to 70 per day, primarily due to staffing and resource limitations. Despite recent changes to the Department’s policies, the author argues that the growing backlog of writs and levies remains significant and continues to be troublesome for the timely issuance of valid writs and levies. If the writ or levy is not timely, then a judgment debtor could just move the money out of their bank accounts and thus avoid payment.
This bill seeks to increase the number of branches that a large financial institution must designate to receive legal service of process from at least one branch to at least four branches in different counties. This change in law should help alleviate the apparent backlog in Los Angeles County, and more broadly help sheriffs with the timely issuance of levies across the state. The author may wish to consider limiting the application of this bill to large financial institutions that have more than nine offices/branches in more than four counties. The bill in print assumes that all large institutions have locations in more than four counties. It is unclear whether or how many financial institutions only have locations clustered together in the same, or at least fewer than four counties, and therefore may be unable to comply with the bill’s mandate.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The bill’s sponsors, the California Association of Legal Support Professionals, write:
AB 2067 seeks to increase the number of locations a large financial institution would need to designate to receive legal service of process. Specifically, this bill increases the designation from at least one location to at least four locations in different counties. This bill will help sheriffs with the timely issuance of writs and levies by allowing process to be spread amongst several counties while also helping prevent judgment debtors from dodging payment.
AB 2067 is not in its final form, and we acknowledge the bill needs refinement. We have been meeting with the California Bankers Association, California Credit Union League, California Community Banking Network, and others. We commit to continuing to work with all stakeholders and the committee to find a fair solution.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The California Association of Legal Support Professionals (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):