AB 3004: Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-01
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)The Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, an initiative measure approved by the voters as Proposition 65 at the November 4, 1986, statewide general election, prohibits a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without giving a specified warning, or from knowingly discharging or releasing such a chemical into water, or into or onto land and passing into any source of drinking water, except as specified. The act imposes civil penalties upon persons who violate those prohibitions, and provides for the enforcement of those prohibitions by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or specified city attorneys or prosecutors. The act also provides for enforcement by an action brought by any person in the public interest, if that private action is commenced more than 60 days after the person has given notice of the violation that is the subject of the action to the Attorney General and the district attorney, the city attorney, or the prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator.
If the notice made by a person bringing an action in the public interest alleges a violation of the acts warning requirement, the act requires that the notice include a certificate of merit stating that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. The act requires factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General. Under the act, a trial court may review a certificate of merits supporting information to determine if an unsuccessful enforcement action is frivolous, and thus sanctionable.
This bill would require a report from a laboratory that is submitted with a certificate of merit to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested and the laboratory testing to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
(2)The act requires a person, other than the Attorney General, who brings an action to enforce the act to submit to the Attorney General a report when the action is subject either to a settlement or a judgment, as provided.
This bill would require the Attorney General, when providing a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report to one party in the litigation, a settlement or judgment, to also provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the litigation. settlement or judgment.
(3)Proposition 65 provides that it may be amended by a statute, passed by a 232/3 vote of each house of the Legislature, to further its purposes.
This bill would find and declare that it furthers the purposes of Proposition 65.
(1)The Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, an initiative measure approved by the voters as Proposition 65 at the November 4, 1986, statewide general election, prohibits a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without giving a specified warning, or from knowingly discharging or releasing such a chemical into water, or into or onto land and passing into any source of drinking water, except as specified. The act imposes civil penalties upon persons who violate those prohibitions, and provides for the enforcement of those prohibitions by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or specified city attorneys or prosecutors. The act also provides for enforcement by an action brought by any person in the public interest, if that private action is commenced more than 60 days after the person has given notice of the violation that is the subject of the action to the Attorney General and the district attorney, the city attorney, or the prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator.
If the notice made by a person bringing an action in the public interest alleges a violation of the acts warning requirement, the act requires that the notice include a certificate of merit stating that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. The act requires factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General. Under the act, a trial court may review a certificate of merits supporting information to determine if an unsuccessful enforcement action is frivolous, and thus sanctionable.
This bill would require a report from a laboratory that is submitted with a certificate of merit to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested and the laboratory testing to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
(2)The act requires a person, other than the Attorney General, who brings an action to enforce the act to submit to the Attorney General a report when the action is subject either to a settlement or a judgment, as provided.
This bill would require the Attorney General, when providing a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report to one party in the litigation, to also provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the litigation.
(3)Proposition 65 provides that it may be amended by a statute, passed by a 23 vote of each house of the Legislature, to further its purposes.
This bill would find and declare that it furthers the purposes of Proposition 65.
(a)A person who violates or threatens to violate Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)(1)A person who has violated Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) per day for each violation in addition to any other penalty established by law. That civil penalty may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(2)In assessing the amount of a civil penalty for a violation of this chapter, the court shall consider all of the following:
(A)The nature and extent of the violation.
(B)The number of, and severity of, the violations.
(C)The economic effect of the penalty on the violator.
(D)Whether the violator took good faith measures to comply with this chapter and the time these measures were taken.
(E)The willfulness of the violators misconduct.
(F)The deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community as a whole.
(G)Any other factor that justice may require.
(c)Actions pursuant to this section may be brought by the Attorney General in the name of the people of the State of California, by a district attorney, by a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in a city or city and county having a full-time city prosecutor, or as provided in subdivision (d).
(d)Actions pursuant to this section may be brought by a person in the public interest if both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The private action is commenced more than 60 days from the date that the person has given notice of an alleged violation of Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 that is the subject of the private action to the Attorney General and the district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator. If the notice alleges a violation of Section 25249.6, the notice of the alleged violation shall include a certificate of merit executed by the attorney for the noticing party, or by the noticing party, if the noticing party is not represented by an attorney. The certificate of merit shall state that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit, including the information identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h), shall be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General.
(2) General. If a report from a laboratory is submitted with a certificate of merit, then the report shall indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested and the laboratory testing shall have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
(3)(2)Neither the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, nor a prosecutor has commenced and is diligently prosecuting an action against the violation.
(e)(1)(A)If, after reviewing the factual information sufficient to establish the basis for the certificate of merit and meeting and conferring with the noticing party regarding the basis for the certificate of merit, the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action, the Attorney General shall serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator stating the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action.
(B)If the Attorney General does not serve a letter pursuant to subparagraph (A), this shall not be construed as an endorsement by the Attorney General of the merit of the action.
(2)A person bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d) and a person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged shall notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed. Neither this subdivision nor the procedures provided in subdivisions (f) to (k), inclusive, affect the requirements imposed by statute or a court decision in existence on January 1, 2002, concerning whether a person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged is required to comply with the requirements of subdivision (d).
(f)(1)A person filing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), a private person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, or a private person settling a violation of this chapter alleged in a notice given pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), shall, after the action or violation is subject either to a settlement or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a reporting form that includes the results of that settlement or judgment and the final disposition of the case, even if dismissed. At the time of the filing of a judgment pursuant to an action brought in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), or an action brought by a private person in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, the plaintiff shall file an affidavit verifying that the report required by this subdivision has been accurately completed and submitted to the Attorney General.
(2)(A)A person bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, shall, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action.
(B)If the Attorney General provides a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report to one party in the litigation, a settlement or judgment, then the Attorney General shall provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the litigation. settlement or judgment.
(3)The Attorney General shall develop a reporting form that specifies the information that shall be reported, including, but not limited to, for purposes of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the date the action was filed, the nature of the relief sought, and for purposes of this subdivision, the amount of the settlement or civil penalty assessed, other financial terms of the settlement, and any other information the Attorney General deems appropriate.
(4)If there is a settlement of an action brought by a person in the public interest under subdivision (d), the plaintiff shall submit the settlement, other than a voluntary dismissal in which no consideration is received from the defendant, to the court for approval upon noticed motion, and the court may approve the settlement only if the court makes all of the following findings:
(A)The warning that is required by the settlement complies with this chapter.
(B)The award of attorneys fees is reasonable under California law.
(C)The penalty amount is reasonable based on the criteria set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(5)The plaintiff subject to paragraph (4) has the burden of producing evidence sufficient to sustain each required finding. The plaintiff shall serve the motion and all supporting papers on the Attorney General, who may appear and participate in a proceeding without intervening in the case.
(6)Neither this subdivision nor the procedures provided in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) and subdivisions (g) to (k), inclusive, affect the requirements imposed by statute or a court decision in existence on January 1, 2002, concerning whether claims raised by a person or public prosecutor not a party to the action are precluded by a settlement approved by the court.
(g)The Attorney General shall maintain a record of the information submitted pursuant to subdivisions (e) and (f) and shall make this information available to the public.
(h)(1)The basis for the certificate of merit required by subdivision (d) is discoverable only to the extent that the information is relevant to the subject matter of the action and not subject to the attorney-client privilege, the attorney work product privilege, or any other legal privilege.
(2)Upon the conclusion of an action brought pursuant to subdivision (d) with respect to a defendant, if the trial court determines that there was no actual or threatened exposure to a listed chemical, the court may, upon the motion of that alleged violator or upon the courts own motion, review the basis for the belief of the person executing the certificate of merit, expressed in the certificate of merit, that an exposure to a listed chemical had occurred or was threatened. The information in the certificate of merit, including the identity of the persons consulted with and relied on by the certifier, and the facts, studies, or other data reviewed by those persons, shall be disclosed to the court in an in-camera proceeding at which the moving party shall not be present. If the court finds that there was no credible factual basis for the certifiers belief that an exposure to a listed chemical had occurred or was threatened, then the action shall be deemed frivolous within the meaning of Section 128.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The court shall not find a factual basis credible on the basis of a legal theory of liability that is frivolous within the meaning of Section 128.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(i)The Attorney General may provide the factual information submitted to establish the basis of the certificate of merit on request to a district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor within whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, or to any other state or federal government agency, but in all other respects the Attorney General shall maintain, and ensure that all recipients maintain, the submitted information as confidential official information to the full extent authorized in Section 1040 of the Evidence Code.
(j)In an action brought by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, or a prosecutor pursuant to this chapter, the Attorney General, district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor may seek and recover costs and attorneys fees on behalf of a party who provides a notice pursuant to subdivision (d) and who renders assistance in that action.
(k)Any person who serves a notice of alleged violation pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) for an exposure identified in subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1) shall complete, as appropriate, and provide to the alleged violator at the time the notice of alleged violation is served, a notice of special compliance procedure and proof of compliance form pursuant to subdivision (l) and shall not file an action for that exposure against the alleged violator, or recover from the alleged violator in a settlement any payment in lieu of penalties or any reimbursement for costs and attorneys fees, if all of the following conditions have been met:
(1)The notice given pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) was served on or after the effective date of the act amending this section during the 201314 Regular Session and alleges that the alleged violator failed to provide clear and reasonable warning as required under Section 25249.6 regarding one or more of the following:
(A)An exposure to alcoholic beverages that are consumed on the alleged violators premises to the extent onsite consumption is permitted by law.
(B)An exposure to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity in a food or beverage prepared and sold on the alleged violators premises primarily intended for immediate consumption on or off premises, to the extent of both of the following:
(i)The chemical was not intentionally added.
(ii)The chemical was formed by cooking or similar preparation of food or beverage components necessary to render the food or beverage palatable or to avoid microbiological contamination.
(C)An exposure to environmental tobacco smoke caused by entry of persons (other than employees) on premises owned or operated by the alleged violator where smoking is permitted at any location on the premises.
(D)An exposure to chemicals known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity in engine exhaust, to the extent the exposure occurs inside a facility owned or operated by the alleged violator and primarily intended for parking noncommercial vehicles.
(2)Within 14 days after service of the notice, the alleged violator has done all of the following:
(A)Corrected the alleged violation.
(B)(i)Agreed to pay a civil penalty for the alleged violation of Section 25249.6 in the amount of five hundred dollars ($500), to be adjusted quinquennially pursuant to clause (ii), per facility or premises where the alleged violation occurred, of which 75 percent shall be deposited into the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund, and 25 percent shall be paid to the person that served the notice as provided in Section 25249.12.
(ii)On April 1, 2019, and at each five-year interval thereafter, the dollar amount of the civil penalty provided pursuant to this subparagraph shall be adjusted by the Judicial Council based on the change in the annual California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, published by the Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Labor Statistics and Research, for the most recent five-year period ending on December 31 of the year preceding the year in which the adjustment is made, rounded to the nearest five dollars ($5). The Judicial Council shall quinquennially publish the dollar amount of the adjusted civil penalty provided pursuant to this subparagraph, together with the date of the next scheduled adjustment.
(C)Notified, in writing, the person that served the notice of the alleged violation, that the violation has been corrected. The written notice shall include the notice of special compliance procedure and proof of compliance form specified in subdivision (l), which was provided by the person serving notice of the alleged violation and which shall be completed by the alleged violator as directed in the notice.
(3)The alleged violator shall deliver the civil penalty to the person that served the notice of the alleged violation within 30 days of service of that notice, and the person that served the notice of violation shall remit the portion of the penalty due to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund within 30 days of receipt of the funds from the alleged violator.
(l)The notice required to be provided to an alleged violator pursuant to subdivision (k) shall be presented as follows:
PRINTER PLEASE NOTE: TIP-IN MATERIAL TO BE INSERTED(m)An alleged violator may satisfy the conditions set forth in subdivision (k) only one time for a violation arising from the same exposure in the same facility or on the same premises.
(n)Nothing in subdivision (k) shall prevent the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, or a prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred from filing an action pursuant to subdivision (c) against an alleged violator. In any such action, the amount of any civil penalty for a violation shall be reduced to reflect any payment made by the alleged violator for the same alleged violation pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (k).
(o)If a violation of this chapter is alleged or the application or construction of this chapter is at issue in a proceeding in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court, each party shall serve a copy of the partys brief or petition and brief, on the Attorney General. Service on the Attorney General shall be accomplished by serving the brief, or petition and brief, on the Proposition 65 coordinator at the service address designated on the Attorney Generals internet website for Proposition 65 enforcement reporting. A brief shall not be accepted or filed unless the proof of service shows service on the Attorney General. A party failing to comply with this subdivision shall be given a reasonable opportunity to cure the failure before the court imposes sanction, and, in that instance, the court shall allow the Attorney General reasonable additional time to file a brief in the matter.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes of the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 25249.5) of Division 20 of the Health and Safety Code).
(a)A person who violates or threatens to violate Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)(1)A person who has violated Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) per day for each violation in addition to any other penalty established by law. That civil penalty may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(2)In assessing the amount of a civil penalty for a violation of this chapter, the court shall consider all of the following:
(A)The nature and extent of the violation.
(B)The number of, and severity of, the violations.
(C)The economic effect of the penalty on the violator.
(D)Whether the violator took good faith measures to comply with this chapter and the time these measures were taken.
(E)The willfulness of the violators misconduct.
(F)The deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community as a whole.
(G)Any other factor that justice may require.
(c)Actions pursuant to this section may be brought by the Attorney General in the name of the people of the State of California, by a district attorney, by a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in a city or city and county having a full-time city prosecutor, or as provided in subdivision (d).
(d)Actions pursuant to this section may be brought by a person in the public interest if both of the following requirements are met:
(1)The private action is commenced more than 60 days from the date that the person has given notice of an alleged violation of Section 25249.5 or 25249.6 that is the subject of the private action to the Attorney General and the district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator. If the notice alleges a violation of Section 25249.6, the notice of the alleged violation shall include a certificate of merit executed by the attorney for the noticing party, or by the noticing party, if the noticing party is not represented by an attorney. The certificate of merit shall state that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit, including the information identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h), shall be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General.
(2)If a report from a laboratory is submitted with a certificate of merit, then the report shall indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested and the laboratory testing shall have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
(2)(3)Neither the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, nor a prosecutor has commenced and is diligently prosecuting an action against the violation.
(e)(1)(A)If, after reviewing the factual information sufficient to establish the basis for the certificate of merit and meeting and conferring with the noticing party regarding the basis for the certificate of merit, the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action, the Attorney General shall serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator stating the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action.
(B)If the Attorney General does not serve a letter pursuant to subparagraph (A), this shall not be construed as an endorsement by the Attorney General of the merit of the action.
(2)A person bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d) and a person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged shall notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed. Neither this subdivision nor the procedures provided in subdivisions (f) to (k), inclusive, affect the requirements imposed by statute or a court decision in existence on January 1, 2002, concerning whether a person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged is required to comply with the requirements of subdivision (d).
(f)(1)A person filing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), a private person filing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, or a private person settling a violation of this chapter alleged in a notice given pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), shall, after the action or violation is subject either to a settlement or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a reporting form that includes the results of that settlement or judgment and the final disposition of the case, even if dismissed. At the time of the filing of a judgment pursuant to an action brought in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), or an action brought by a private person in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, the plaintiff shall file an affidavit verifying that the report required by this subdivision has been accurately completed and submitted to the Attorney General.
(2)(A)A person bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to subdivision (d), or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of this chapter is alleged, shall, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action.
(B)If the Attorney General provides a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report to one party in the litigation, then the Attorney General shall provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the litigation.
(3)The Attorney General shall develop a reporting form that specifies the information that shall be reported, including, but not limited to, for purposes of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the date the action was filed, the nature of the relief sought, and for purposes of this subdivision, the amount of the settlement or civil penalty assessed, other financial terms of the settlement, and any other information the Attorney General deems appropriate.
(4)If there is a settlement of an action brought by a person in the public interest under subdivision (d), the plaintiff shall submit the settlement, other than a voluntary dismissal in which no consideration is received from the defendant, to the court for approval upon noticed motion, and the court may approve the settlement only if the court makes all of the following findings:
(A)The warning that is required by the settlement complies with this chapter.
(B)The award of attorneys fees is reasonable under California law.
(C)The penalty amount is reasonable based on the criteria set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(5)The plaintiff subject to paragraph (4) has the burden of producing evidence sufficient to sustain each required finding. The plaintiff shall serve the motion and all supporting papers on the Attorney General, who may appear and participate in a proceeding without intervening in the case.
(6)Neither this subdivision nor the procedures provided in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) and subdivisions (g) to (k), inclusive, affect the requirements imposed by statute or a court decision in existence on January 1, 2002, concerning whether claims raised by a person or public prosecutor not a party to the action are precluded by a settlement approved by the court.
(g)The Attorney General shall maintain a record of the information submitted pursuant to subdivisions (e) and (f) and shall make this information available to the public.
(h)(1)The basis for the certificate of merit required by subdivision (d) is discoverable only to the extent that the information is relevant to the subject matter of the action and not subject to the attorney-client privilege, the attorney work product privilege, or any other legal privilege.
(2)Upon the conclusion of an action brought pursuant to subdivision (d) with respect to a defendant, if the trial court determines that there was no actual or threatened exposure to a listed chemical, the court may, upon the motion of that alleged violator or upon the courts own motion, review the basis for the belief of the person executing the certificate of merit, expressed in the certificate of merit, that an exposure to a listed chemical had occurred or was threatened. The information in the certificate of merit, including the identity of the persons consulted with and relied on by the certifier, and the facts, studies, or other data reviewed by those persons, shall be disclosed to the court in an in-camera proceeding at which the moving party shall not be present. If the court finds that there was no credible factual basis for the certifiers belief that an exposure to a listed chemical had occurred or was threatened, then the action shall be deemed frivolous within the meaning of Section 128.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The court shall not find a factual basis credible on the basis of a legal theory of liability that is frivolous within the meaning of Section 128.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(i)The Attorney General may provide the factual information submitted to establish the basis of the certificate of merit on request to a district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor within whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, or to any other state or federal government agency, but in all other respects the Attorney General shall maintain, and ensure that all recipients maintain, the submitted information as confidential official information to the full extent authorized in Section 1040 of the Evidence Code.
(j)In an action brought by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, or a prosecutor pursuant to this chapter, the Attorney General, district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor may seek and recover costs and attorneys fees on behalf of a party who provides a notice pursuant to subdivision (d) and who renders assistance in that action.
(k)Any person who serves a notice of alleged violation pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) for an exposure identified in subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1) shall complete, as appropriate, and provide to the alleged violator at the time the notice of alleged violation is served, a notice of special compliance procedure and proof of compliance form pursuant to subdivision (l) and shall not file an action for that exposure against the alleged violator, or recover from the alleged violator in a settlement any payment in lieu of penalties or any reimbursement for costs and attorneys fees, if all of the following conditions have been met:
(1)The notice given pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) was served on or after the effective date of the act amending this section during the 201314 Regular Session and alleges that the alleged violator failed to provide clear and reasonable warning as required under Section 25249.6 regarding one or more of the following:
(A)An exposure to alcoholic beverages that are consumed on the alleged violators premises to the extent onsite consumption is permitted by law.
(B)An exposure to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity in a food or beverage prepared and sold on the alleged violators premises primarily intended for immediate consumption on or off premises, to the extent of both of the following:
(i)The chemical was not intentionally added.
(ii)The chemical was formed by cooking or similar preparation of food or beverage components necessary to render the food or beverage palatable or to avoid microbiological contamination.
(C)An exposure to environmental tobacco smoke caused by entry of persons (other than employees) on premises owned or operated by the alleged violator where smoking is permitted at any location on the premises.
(D)An exposure to chemicals known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity in engine exhaust, to the extent the exposure occurs inside a facility owned or operated by the alleged violator and primarily intended for parking noncommercial vehicles.
(2)Within 14 days after service of the notice, the alleged violator has done all of the following:
(A)Corrected the alleged violation.
(B)(i)Agreed to pay a civil penalty for the alleged violation of Section 25249.6 in the amount of five hundred dollars ($500), to be adjusted quinquennially pursuant to clause (ii), per facility or premises where the alleged violation occurred, of which 75 percent shall be deposited in into the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund, and 25 percent shall be paid to the person that served the notice as provided in Section 25249.12.
(ii)On April 1, 2019, and at each five-year interval thereafter, the dollar amount of the civil penalty provided pursuant to this subparagraph shall be adjusted by the Judicial Council based on the change in the annual California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, published by the Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Labor Statistics and Research, for the most recent five-year period ending on December 31 of the year preceding the year in which the adjustment is made, rounded to the nearest five dollars ($5). The Judicial Council shall quinquennially publish the dollar amount of the adjusted civil penalty provided pursuant to this subparagraph, together with the date of the next scheduled adjustment.
(C)Notified, in writing, the person that served the notice of the alleged violation, that the violation has been corrected. The written notice shall include the notice of special compliance procedure and proof of compliance form specified in subdivision (l), which was provided by the person serving notice of the alleged violation and which shall be completed by the alleged violator as directed in the notice.
(3)The alleged violator shall deliver the civil penalty to the person that served the notice of the alleged violation within 30 days of service of that notice, and the person that served the notice of violation shall remit the portion of the penalty due to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund within 30 days of receipt of the funds from the alleged violator.
(l)The notice required to be provided to an alleged violator pursuant to subdivision (k) shall be presented as follows:
PRINTER PLEASE NOTE: TIP-IN MATERIAL TO BE INSERTED(m)An alleged violator may satisfy the conditions set forth in subdivision (k) only one time for a violation arising from the same exposure in the same facility or on the same premises.
(n)Nothing in subdivision (k) shall prevent the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, or a prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred from filing an action pursuant to subdivision (c) against an alleged violator. In any such action, the amount of any civil penalty for a violation shall be reduced to reflect any payment made by the alleged violator for the same alleged violation pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (k).
(o)If a violation of this chapter is alleged or the application or construction of provisions of this chapter is at issue in a proceeding in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court, each party shall serve a copy of the partys brief or petition and brief, on the Attorney General. Service on the Attorney General shall be accomplished by serving the brief, or petition and brief, on the Proposition 65 coordinator at the service address designated on the Attorney Generals internet website for Proposition 65 enforcement reporting. A brief shall not be accepted or filed unless the proof of service shows service on the Attorney General. A party failing to comply with this subdivision shall be given a reasonable opportunity to cure the failure before the court imposes sanction, and, in that instance, the court shall allow the Attorney General reasonable additional time to file a brief in the matter.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes of the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 25249.5) of Division 20 of the Health and Safety Code).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jun 19, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 5). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 22, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.Q. and JUD. |
| May 9, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 65. Noes 0. Page 5161.) |
| May 2, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 1, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 16). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 11, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 5, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2024 | AB 3004 Mike Fong Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2024 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Asian Food Trade Association | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 3004 (Mike Fong) - Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require a person, when filing an action under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), to include the brand name of the product tested with the certificate of merit.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) estimates unquantifiable but potentially significant ongoing costs (General Fund) to, when providing a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report to one party in a settlement or judgment, also provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
Background:
Proposition 65. In 1986, California voters approved a ballot initiative, the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, commonly referred to as Proposition 65, to address their concern that "hazardous chemicals pose a serious potential threat to their health and well-being, [and] that state government agencies have failed to provide them with adequate protection…" Proposition 65 requires the state to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. This list, which must be updated at least once a year, currently includes approximately 800 chemicals. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) administers the Proposition 65 program, including an evaluation of all currently available scientific information on substances considered for placement on the Proposition 65 list.
Under Proposition 65, businesses in California are required to provide a "clear and reasonable" warning before knowingly and intentionally exposing anyone to a Proposition 65-listed chemical. Warnings can be made in many ways, including labeling a consumer product, posting signs, distributing notices, or publishing notices in a newspaper. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 12 months to comply with warning requirements.
Proposition 65 also prohibits companies that do business within California from knowingly discharging listed chemicals into sources of drinking water. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 20 months to comply with the discharge prohibition.
Changes to Proposition 65 warning requirements. Since the original warning requirements took effect in 1988, most Proposition 65 warnings simply stated that a chemical is present that causes cancer or reproductive harm, but the warning did not identify the chemical or provide specific information about how a person may be exposed or ways to reduce or eliminate exposure to it. OEHHA regulations, adopted in August 2016 and that took full effect in August 2018, change the warning requirements in several important ways. The new warnings for consumer products need to: include the verbiage that the product "can expose you to" a Proposition 65 chemical rather than saying the product "contains" the chemical; name at least one chemical present in the product that is listed on the Proposition 65 list; provide the internet address for OEHHA’s new Proposition 65 warnings website which provides additional information about the health effects of the chemicals on the Proposition 65 list; and, include a triangular yellow warning symbol.
Multiple avenues of enforcement of Proposition 65. Proposition 65 authorizes the California AG, as well as any district attorney or city attorney (for cities whose population exceeds 750,000), to enforce Proposition 65. In addition, a person may bring an action acting in the public interest if both of the following requirements are met: 1) the private action is commenced more than 60 days after the person filing the action has provided the notice of the alleged violation to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator including the certificate of merit and the factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit, and 2) neither the AG nor district attorney has commenced prosecuting an action against the violation.
It is important to note that Proposition 65 only allows enforcement through the courts. Unlike other environmental laws, there is not a state department or state or local agency that is authorized to oversee and enforce Proposition 65 using administrative penalties. If found guilty through the courts, penalties for violating Proposition 65 by failing to provide warning notices can be as high as $2,500 per violation per day.
Exemption from enforcement. Businesses with fewer than 10 employees and government agencies are exempt from Proposition 65’s warning requirements and prohibition on discharges into drinking water sources. Businesses are also exempt from the warning requirement and discharge prohibition if the exposures they cause are so low as to create no significant risk of cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm.
Certificate of merit. Current law requires any person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide a notice of alleged violation, 60 days before taking the action, to the AG, including a certificate of merit. The certificate of merit states that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Additionally, factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit must be attached to the certificate that is served on the AG. The law also requires the AG, after reviewing the certificate of merit, including the factual basis supporting the certificate of merit, to, if she or he finds that there is no merit to the action, serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator that the AG believes there is no merit to the action.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require a person, when filing an action under Proposition 65, to include the brand name of the product tested with the certificate of merit. Specifically, this bill would:
- Require a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested. It also requires any testing done to support the certificate of merit to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Require the Attorney General (AG), if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
Related Legislation:
AB 1521 (Mike Fong, 2023) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65, when providing factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to the AG to additionally include information supporting the certificate of merit, including dates and studies related to the product that is the subject of the notice of the alleged violation. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 2743 (Mike Fong, 2022) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide the notice of the alleged violation and factual information for the basis for the certificate of merit to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 693 (Chau, 2021) would have required that any compensation received by a plaintiff of a Proposition 65 suit be disclosed to a court and would have allowed food suppliers and distributors 14 days to label products in violation of Proposition 65 without penalties. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 2849 (Chau, 2020) would have authorized a person employing fewer than 10 employees to waive his or her exemption under Proposition 65 and provide this in writing to the person bringing an action under Proposition 65 and to the AG. This bill died in the Senate on Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 1123 (Reyes, Chapter 187, Statutes of 2019) requires certain notice be provided to the AG before certain proceedings involving Proposition 65 are filed in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 3004 (Author:Mike Fong)
Version: April 1, 2024
Hearing Date: June 18, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications
DIGEST
This bill requires any product testing conducted in support of a certificate of merit to have been conducted within one year of the submission of the certificate of merit, and requires any report from a laboratory that is submitted with the certificate of merit to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested on the certificate. The bill also requires the Attorney General (AG), if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (“the Act”), Proposition 65, provides protections for Californians, including requiring a person doing business in California to provide clear and reasonable warning to individuals before knowingly and intentionally exposing them to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity. Actions for violations of the Act can be brought by the AG or specified local prosecutors and by individuals in the public interest, subject to certain conditions, including providing a certificate of merit. This bill seeks to ensure that a certificate of merit is current that it includes the brand name of the product tested, as specified. The bill also requires the AG to provide any comment, suggestion, or other communication made to all parties in a settlement or judgment. This bill is supported the Asian Food Trade Association. No timely opposition was received by the Committee. This bill passed the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on a vote of 7 to 0. This bill requires a two-thirds vote because it amends an initiative statue.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Prohibits a person in the course of doing business from knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity into water or onto or into land where such chemical passes or probably will pass into any source of drinking water, except as specified. (Health and Saf. Code § 25249.5.[1])
- Prohibits a person from knowingly and intentionally, in the course of doing business, exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. (§ 25249.6.)
- Provides that any person who violates the provisions of 1) or 2), above, is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 per day for each violation in addition to any other penalty established by law. The civil penalty may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in any court of competent jurisdiction. (§ Section 25249.7(b)(1).)
- Authorizes the AG, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or, with the consent of the district attorney, a city prosecutor in a city or city and county having a full-time city prosecutor, or a private individual representing the public interest to bring an action to seek civil penalties. (Id. at (c).)
- Authorizes a private individual to bring a private action so long as neither the AG, a district attorney, a city attorney, nor a prosecutor has commenced and is diligently prosecuting an action against the violation.
- The action must be commenced more than 60 days from the date that the person has given notice of an alleged violation to the AG and the district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator. (Id. at (d).)
- If the notice alleges a violation of the provisions in 2), above, the notice must include a certificate of merit, as provided.
- The certificate of merit must state that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action.
- Factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit must be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General. (Ibid.)
- Requires the AG, if the AG believes there is no merit to the action, to serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator stating the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action. Provides that not serving a letter does not serve as an endorsement of the action. (Id. at (e)(1).)
- Requires a private individual bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to 6) to notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed. (Id. at (e)(2).)
- Requires a private person bringing an action in the public interest or a private person settling a violation of this law to, after the action or violation is subject either to a settlement or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a reporting form that includes the results of that settlement or judgment and the final disposition of the case, even if dismissed. (Id. at (f)(1).)
- Requires that a person bringing an action in the public interest, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, to submit to the Attorney General a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action. (Id. at (f)(2).)
- Requires the Attorney General to maintain a record of the information submitted, as required, and make that record available to the public. (Id. at (g).)
- Authorizes, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the Legislature may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without their approval. (Cal. Const., art. II, Sec. 10.)
- Proposition 65 from the November 4, 1986, election provides that it may be amended by statute to further its purposes if passed in each house by a two-thirds vote.
This bill:
- Requires any product testing conducted in support of the certificate of merit to have been conducted within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Requires the AG, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
- Requires, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested on the certificate.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
AB 3004 makes minor changes to Proposition 65 to ensure that the Act is carried out as intended – to ensure that consumers are aware of products containing certain chemicals. Private enforcers who are simply seeking settlement money may reuse the same laboratory test on multiple products over a number of years. This hurts small businesses who must pay sometimes thousands of dollars to settle the claim while possibly not receiving credible information. They may put the label on a product, but they will not know if the product indeed contained the chemicals. This bill ensures that the laboratory test is current and identifies the brand name of the product that was tested. The bill also ensures that communication from the Attorney’s General’s office to one party is shared with all parties involved in a settlement.
- Proposition 65: Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986
Proposition 65, a state initiative measure, was approved on November 4, 1986, and became effective on January 1, 1987. It added the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (“the Act”), Health and Safety Code Section 25249.5 et seq., to state law. The Act places two main requirements on businesses. The first is a prohibition on knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity (hereinafter “chemical”) into water or onto land where the chemical has a certain likelihood of passing into a source of drinking water. The second is the more well-known warning requirement. It prohibits any person, in the course of doing business, to knowingly and intentionally expose any individual to a chemical without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. Both have exemptions enumerated in the Act and neither applies to persons employing fewer than 10 employees in the person’s business or to most governmental entities. The Act is administered by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA).
The Act provides a cause of action to enforce its provisions and to seek certain specified remedies, including injunctive relief and civil penalties. The AG, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or, with the consent of the district attorney, a city prosecutor in a city or city and county having a full-time city prosecutor, can bring an action against a person who has violated or threatens to violate the Act. In addition, a person can also bring an action in the public interest pursuant to the Act if the AG or a local prosecutor has not already commenced and is diligently litigating claims based on the alleged violation.
- Private actions pursuant to the Act
Before a private action can be filed, a person must provide notice to the Attorney General, the local prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator. The private action cannot commence until 60 days after such notice has been provided.
In addition, if there is an alleged violation of the notice requirement, Section 25249.6, the notice must include a certificate of merit executed by the person or the person’s attorney. The certificate must indicate that the person executing the certificate has consulted with experts that have reviewed facts, studies, or other relevant data regarding the alleged exposure to a listed chemical underlying the action. The certificate of merit must further state that based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. For the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General only, factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate must be attached, including the identity of the persons consulted with and relied on by the certifier, and the facts, studies, or other data reviewed by those persons. If, after reviewing such materials, the Attorney General finds there is no merit to the action, the Attorney General must serve a letter to the noticing party and alleged violator stating that finding.
This bill requires any product testing conducted in support of the certificate of merit to have been conducted within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit. If a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, the report is required to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested on the certificate. Lastly, the bill requires the AG, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
- Statements in support
The Asian Food Trade Association, the sponsor of the bill, writes in support stating:
One of the biggest challenges API owner-operators face, is the abuse of Prop 65 (Clean Water Bill) and how it is being weaponized against all types of businesses and their products. In the food industry, the national FDA has already done more than enough to protect American consumers from reasonable levels of chemicals. However, the loophole that Prop 65 gives a few bad lawyers the legal protection to stretch the law and extorting money from California’s hardworking small businesses.
If passed, we’re only asking that reasonable evidence be given to defendants so they can compare accredited lab reports they should be presenting to the AG, and also to defendants upon request. Our group feeds tens of millions of California consumers every month, and seeing over labeling is actually causing more harm than informative benefits.
SUPPORT
Asian Food Trade Association
OPPOSITION
None received
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1521 (Mike Fong, 2023) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65, when providing factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to the AG, to additionally include information supporting the certificate of merit, including dates and studies related to the product that is the subject of the notice of the alleged violation. This bill was never set for a hearing in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
AB 2743 (Mike Fong, 2022) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide the notice of the alleged violation and factual information for the basis for the certificate of merit to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator. This bill was never set for a hearing in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
AB 1123 (Reyes, Ch. 187, Stats. 2019) required that a specified notice be provided to the Attorney General before certain proceedings involving the Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 are filed in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court.
AB 1583 (Chau, Ch. 510, Stats. 2017) required the AG to serve a letter on a notifying party and the alleged violator when it determines, after reviewing a certificate of merit and accompanying evidence regarding an alleged violation of the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, that the relevant allegations have no merit. This bill reorganized the provision governing the discoverability of certificates of merit. It also required the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development to post a disclaimer regarding the requirements the Act places on businesses.
AB 1252 (Jones, 2015) would have prohibited any person from bringing an enforcement action against a company that employs 25 people or less for failure to provide a warning for an exposure to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity, in violation of Proposition 65, unless certain conditions are met. This bill died in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
AB 227 (Gatto, Ch. 581, Stats. of 2013) provided for the remediation of lawsuits alleging a violation of the clear and reasonable warning requirement for four specified circumstances. It prohibited the person who filed an action from exposure from doing so until 14 days after they have served the alleged violator with a notice of alleged violation.
AB 1756 (Committee on Budget, Ch. 228, Stats. 2003) established the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund in the State Treasury and authorized the director of the lead agency, who is designated by the Governor to implement the Act, to expend the funds in the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund upon appropriation by the Legislature, to implement and administer the Act.
SB 471 (Sher, Ch. 578, Stats. 2001) requires a court, in assessing the amount of a civil penalty for a violation of the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), to consider specified factors. It also required a certificate of merit to be filed with the appropriate parties before a private action could be filed.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 65, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 14, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
All further references are to the Health and Safety Code unless specified otherwise. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 3004
Author: | Mike Fong | ||
Version: | 4/1/2024 | Hearing Date: | 6/5/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications
DIGEST: Requires a person, when filing an action under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), to include the brand name of the product tested with the certificate of merit.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Prohibits, under Proposition 65, a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity into water or onto or into land where such chemical passes or probably will pass into any source of drinking water. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 25249.5)
- Prohibits a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. (HSC § 25249.6)
- Provides that any person who violates the above provisions may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction and be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 per day for each violation, in addition to any other penalty established by law. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Provides for a specified course of remediation for lawsuits alleging a violation of the clear and reasonable warning requirement for four specified exposures (lawfully permitted alcoholic beverages; chemicals resulting from food or beverage preparation; environmental tobacco smoke on premises where smoking is permitted; and, engine exhaust in parking facilities, as specified). Prohibits the person who files an action from exposure from doing so until 14 days after she or he has served the alleged violator with a notice of alleged violation. Authorizes the person who served the notice of violation to file an action if the alleged violator failed to correct the alleged violation or failed to pay a civil penalty of $500. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Requires the person filing an action to serve the notice of violation to the alleged violator, the AG, and the local District Attorney, and to also include with the notice a certificate of merit and sufficient factual information to establish the basis of merit. Authorizes the AG to establish whether or not there is merit to the action, and if the AG determines there is no merit to the action, requires the AG to notify both the person bringing the action and the alleged violator. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Requires a person bringing an action in the public interest under Proposition 65, or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of Proposition 65 is alleged, to, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the AG a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action. (HSC 25249.7 § (f) (2))
- Exempts a person employing fewer than 10 employees from the warning requirement under Proposition 65. (HSC § 25249.11)
- Authorizes amendments to Proposition 65, provided that they are passed in each house of the Legislature by a two-thirds vote and further the purposes of Proposition 65. (Initiative Measure, Proposition 65, Sec. 7, Nov. 4, 1986.)
This bill:
- Requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested. It also requires any testing done to support the certificate of merit to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Requires the Attorney General (AG), if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
Background
- Proposition 65. In 1986, California voters approved a ballot initiative, the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, commonly referred to as Proposition 65, to address their concern that "hazardous chemicals pose a serious potential threat to their health and well-being, [and] that state government agencies have failed to provide them with adequate protection…" Proposition 65 requires the state to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. This list, which must be updated at least once a year, currently includes approximately 800 chemicals. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) administers the Proposition 65 program, including an evaluation of all currently available scientific information on substances considered for placement on the Proposition 65 list.
Under Proposition 65, businesses in California are required to provide a "clear and reasonable" warning before knowingly and intentionally exposing anyone to a Proposition 65-listed chemical. Warnings can be made in many ways, including labeling a consumer product, posting signs, distributing notices, or publishing notices in a newspaper. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 12 months to comply with warning requirements.
Proposition 65 also prohibits companies that do business within California from knowingly discharging listed chemicals into sources of drinking water. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 20 months to comply with the discharge prohibition.
- Changes to Proposition 65 warning requirements. Since the original warning requirements took effect in 1988, most Proposition 65 warnings simply stated that a chemical is present that causes cancer or reproductive harm, but the warning did not identify the chemical or provide specific information about how a person may be exposed or ways to reduce or eliminate exposure to it. OEHHA regulations, adopted in August 2016 and that took full effect in August 2018, change the warning requirements in several important ways. The new warnings for consumer products need to: include the verbiage that the product "can expose you to" a Proposition 65 chemical rather than saying the product "contains" the chemical; name at least one chemical present in the product that is listed on the Proposition 65 list; provide the internet address for OEHHA’s new Proposition 65 warnings website which provides additional information about the health effects of the chemicals on the Proposition 65 list; and, include a triangular yellow warning symbol.
- Multiple avenues of enforcement of Proposition 65. Proposition 65 authorizes the California AG, as well as any district attorney or city attorney (for cities whose population exceeds 750,000), to enforce Proposition 65. In addition, a person may bring an action acting in the public interest if both of the following requirements are met: 1) the private action is commenced more than 60 days after the person filing the action has provided the notice of the alleged violation to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator including the certificate of merit and the factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit, and 2) neither the AG nor district attorney has commenced prosecuting an action against the violation.
It is important to note that Proposition 65 only allows enforcement through the courts. Unlike other environmental laws, there is not a state department or state or local agency that is authorized to oversee and enforce Proposition 65 using administrative penalties. If found guilty through the courts, penalties for violating Proposition 65 by failing to provide warning notices can be as high as $2,500 per violation per day.
- Exemption from enforcement. Businesses with fewer than 10 employees and government agencies are exempt from Proposition 65’s warning requirements and prohibition on discharges into drinking water sources. Businesses are also exempt from the warning requirement and discharge prohibition if the exposures they cause are so low as to create no significant risk of cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm.
- Certificate of merit. Current law requires any person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide a notice of alleged violation, 60 days before taking the action, to the AG, including a certificate of merit. The certificate of merit states that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Additionally, factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit must be attached to the certificate that is served on the AG. The law also requires the AG, after reviewing the certificate of merit, including the factual basis supporting the certificate of merit, to, if she or he finds that there is no merit to the action, serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator that the AG believes there is no merit to the action.
- This bill. AB 3004 requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65 if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested. It also requires any testing done to support the certificate of merit to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Report to the AG. Existing law requires a person bringing an action in the public interest under Proposition 65 or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of Proposition 65 is alleged, to, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the AG a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action.
- This bill. AB 3004 requires the AG, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "AB 3004 makes minor changes to Proposition 65 to ensure that the Act is carried out as intended – to ensure that consumers are aware of products containing certain chemicals. Private enforcers who are simply seeking settlement money may reuse the same laboratory test on multiple products over a number of years. This hurts small businesses who must pay sometimes thousands of dollars to settle the claim while possibly not receiving credible information. They may put the label on a product, but they will not know if the product indeed contains the chemicals. This bill ensures that the laboratory test is current and identifies the brand name of the product that was tested."
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1521 (Mike Fong, 2023) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65, when providing factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to the AG to additionally include information supporting the certificate of merit, including dates and studies related to the product that is the subject of the notice of the alleged violation. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 2743 (Mike Fong, 2022) would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide the notice of the alleged violation and factual information for the basis for the certificate of merit to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 693 (Chau, 2021) would have required that any compensation received by a plaintiff of a Proposition 65 suit be disclosed to a court and would have allowed food suppliers and distributors 14 days to label products in violation of Proposition 65 without penalties. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
AB 2849 (Chau, 2020) would have authorized a person employing fewer than 10 employees to waive his or her exemption under Proposition 65 and provide this in writing to the person bringing an action under Proposition 65 and to the AG. This bill died in the Senate on Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 1123 (Reyes, Chapter 187, Statutes of 2019) requires certain notice be provided to the AG before certain proceedings involving Proposition 65 are filed in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court.
SOURCE:
Asian Food Trade Association
SUPPORT:
None received
OPPOSITION:
None received
Positions reflect letters received by noon one week prior to the hearing.
-- END --
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3004
Author:(Mike Fong) – As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Judiciary | 12 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill updates various notice requirements for parties seeking to file a private right of action to enforce Proposition 65’s requirements related to chemical disclosures.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested.
- Requires any product testing conducted in support of the certificate of merit to have been conducted within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Requires the Attorney General, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The Department of Justice (DOJ) anticipates minor and absorbable costs as a result of this bill but notes as numerous bills this session may result in no significant impact to DOJ, should an aggregate of these bills become law, DOJ would need to request additional resources to process the increase to its workload.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the author:
Private enforcers who are simply seeking settlement money may reuse the same laboratory test on multiple products over a number of years. This hurts small businesses who must pay sometimes thousands of dollars to settle the claim while possibly not receiving credible information. They may put the label on a product, but they will not know if the product indeed contains the chemicals. This bill ensures that the laboratory test is current and identifies the brand name of the product that was tested.
2) Background. In 1986, California voters approved the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986. The act, more commonly referred to as Proposition 65, requires the state to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. This list, which must be updated at least annually, currently includes approximately 900 chemicals. Once a chemical is listed, most businesses must post a Proposition 65 warning on their premises, labeling or packaging, or other prominent places to inform consumers of the potential exposure to a known toxin. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) administers the Proposition 65 program, including evaluating all currently available scientific information on substances considered for placement on the Proposition 65 list.
Existing law requires the Attorney General to actively engage with the pre-litigation process and track all court filings and settlements. Recognizing Proposition 65’s dual public-private enforcement scheme, the law requires certain notices be transmitted to the Attorney General prior to the commencement of litigation, including factual evidence and data to justify the plaintiff’s contention that they have a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action, known as the certificate of merit. Upon receipt of the certificate, the Attorney General is required to weigh in on the merits of the matter before lawsuits are filed.
There is little statutory guidance as to what content a certificate of merit must include beyond a certification that the would-be plaintiff has consulted with one or more persons “with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action.” In practice, these certificates are accompanied by laboratory data highlighting the toxicity of the targeted product. Seeking to bolster the relevance and detail of the information provided to the Attorney General, this bill requires parties submitting laboratory reports with their certificate of merit to include the actual brand name of the product that was tested and to certify that testing was conducted on that product within the prior year. Additionally, this bill requires communications from the Attorney General regarding settlements or other proposed litigation outcomes to be transmitted to all parties to ensure that all litigants are aware of the Attorney General’s viewpoint on the merits of a proposed settlement.
Analysis Prepared by: Nikita Koraddi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 16, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3004
Author:(Mike Fong) – As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications
KEY ISSUE: should various aspects of THE certificate of merit process associated with proposition 65 notices be updated to ensure all parties have access to up-to-date technical information?
SYNOPSIS
In order to ensure that the rights of Californians to safe drinking water, food, products, and living accommodations can be protected, this bill guarantees that California’s Attorney General will be appraised of all appellate litigation impacting the Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, more commonly known as Proposition 65. Beyond prompting the proliferation of the well-known warning signs and labels, Proposition 65 provides the Attorney General as well as local district attorneys and city attorneys, with the right to enforce the Proposition’s requirements that Californians be protected against exposure to chemicals that are known to the State of California to cause cancer or reproductive harm. In addition to state law enforcement, Proposition 65 provides individual citizens with the right to enforce the law, so long as none of the above-mentioned public officials simultaneously seeks enforcement for the same violation. In the private lawsuits, existing law requires the parties to notify the Attorney General before filing suit, at the commencement of an action, and upon settlement. However, beyond basic certifications there is little statutory guidance regarding these notices. While many would-be plaintiffs submit laboratory reports along with the initial certifications, such submissions are not required.
This bill seeks to improve the communication between the Attorney General and Proposition 65 litigants. First, this measure provides that if a party opts to submit a laboratory report to the Attorney General, the report must be no more than one year old and specifically identify the brand name of the product tested. Additionally, this measure requires the Attorney General to transmit to all parties to litigation any comments it provides on a proposed settlement agreement.
This bill is sponsored by the Asian Food Trade Association who contend that these additional notices will better inform all parties to litigation and may stop “frivolous” lawsuits. This bill has no known opposition and was previously heard and approved by the Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials by a vote of 7 to 0.
SUMMARY: Updates various notice requirements for parties seeking to file a private right of action to enforce Proposition 65’s requirements related to chemical disclosures. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested.
- Requires any product testing conducted in support of the certificate of merit to have been conducted within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
- Requires the Attorney General, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person in the course of doing business from knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity into water or onto or into land where such chemical passes or probably will pass into any source of drinking water, except as provided. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.5.)
- Prohibits a person in the course of doing business from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.6.)
- Provides that any person who violates the provisions of 1) or 2) is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 per day for each violation in addition to any other penalty established by law. Provides that the civil penalty may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in any court of competent jurisdiction. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (b)(1).)
- Requires that in assessing the amount of a civil penalty under 3), the court to consider all of the following:
- The nature and extent of the violation;
- The number of, and severity of, the violations;
- The economic effect of the penalty on the violator;
- Whether the violator took good faith measures to comply with the law at the time the measures were taken;
- The willfulness of the violator’s misconduct;
- The deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community as a whole; and
- Any other factor that justice may require. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (b)(2).)
- Provides that an action to seek civil penalties may be brought by the Attorney General, by a district attorney, by a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in a city or city and county having a full-time city prosecutor, or a private individual representing the public interest. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (c).)
- Provides that a private individual may bring a private action so long as neither the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, nor a prosecutor has commenced and is diligently prosecuting an action against the violation, and it is commenced more than 60 days from the date that the person has given notice of an alleged violation to the Attorney General and the district attorney, city attorney, or prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and to the alleged violator. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (d).)
- Provides that if the notice alleges a violation of the provisions of 2), the notice of the alleged violation must include a certificate of merit executed by the attorney for the noticing party, or by the noticing party, if the noticing party is not represented by an attorney. The certificate of merit must state that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit must be attached to the certificate of merit that is served on the Attorney General. (Ibid.)
- Provides that if, after reviewing the factual information sufficient to establish the basis for the certificate of merit and meeting and conferring with the noticing party regarding the basis for the certificate of merit, the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action, the Attorney General must serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator stating the Attorney General believes there is no merit to the action. Provides that not serving a letter does not serve as an endorsement of the action. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (e)(1).)
- Requires a private individual bringing an action in the public interest pursuant to 6) to notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (e)(2).)
- Requires a private person bringing an action in the public interest or a private person settling a violation of this law to, after the action or violation is subject either to a settlement or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a reporting form that includes the results of that settlement or judgment and the final disposition of the case, even if dismissed. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (f)(1).)
- Requires that a person bringing an action in the public interest, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, to submit to the Attorney General a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (f)(2).)
- Requires the Attorney General to develop a reporting form that specifies the information that shall be reported, including, but not limited to, the date the action was filed, the nature of the relief sought, the amount of the settlement or civil penalty assessed, other financial terms of the settlement, and any other information the Attorney General deems appropriate. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (f)(3).)
- Requires the Attorney General to maintain a record of the information submitted, as required, and make that record available to the public. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (g).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Seeking to improve the communication between the state and private plaintiffs involved in litigation surrounding the Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, more commonly referred to as Proposition 65, this bill modifies various notice requirements of existing law. First, this measure requires any certificate of merit filed with the Attorney General prior to commencing a Proposition 65 lawsuit containing a laboratory report to (1) identify the specific product tested, and (2) verify that the laboratory testing was conducted within the prior year. Additionally, the bill requires any comment, suggestion, or other communication provided by the Attorney General in response to a report regarding the end of litigation provided to one party in the suit, to be transmitted to all parties. In support of this bill, the author states:
AB 3004 makes minor changes to Proposition 65 to ensure that the Act is carried out as intended – to ensure that consumers are aware of products containing certain chemicals. Private enforcers who are simply seeking settlement money may reuse the same laboratory test on multiple products over a number of years. This hurts small businesses who must pay sometimes thousands of dollars to settle the claim while possibly not receiving credible information. They may put the label on a product, but they will not know if the product indeed contains the chemicals. This bill ensures that the laboratory test is current and identifies the brand name of the product that was tested.
Seeking to reduce the exposure to known toxins and other carcinogens, the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 requires extensive consumer disclosure. In 1986, California voters, by passing Proposition 65, approved the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986. The Act, more commonly referred to as Proposition 65, requires the state to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. This list, which must be updated at least once a year, currently includes approximately 900 chemicals. Once a chemical is listed, most businesses must post the ubiquitous Proposition 65 warning on their premises, labeling or packaging, or other prominent places to inform consumers of the potential exposure to a known toxin. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) administers the Proposition 65 program, including evaluating all currently available scientific information on substances considered for placement on the Proposition 65 list. In the past three decades, abundant litigation has quarreled over the contents of the list and the adequacy of the substance of posted Proposition 65 warnings. In order to better monitor the litigation, existing law requires the Attorney General to actively engage with the pre-litigation process and track all court filings and settlements.
In response to the perceived threat of frivolous litigation, the Attorney General now tracks Proposition 65 claims and provides public data. Since the passage of Proposition 65, recognizing the dual public-private enforcement scheme, the law has required certain notices to be transmitted to the Attorney General prior to the commencement of litigation. In order to ensure that a private party would not pursue a claim being filed by the government, as originally approved by the voters, Proposition 65 required a potential litigant to give notice of a violation to the Attorney General, their local district attorney or city attorney, and the alleged violator 60 days in advance of filing the lawsuit. In the intervening 30 years, responding to concerns about the abuse of the private right of action, the Legislature has expanded the notice requirements to include the submission of factual evidence and data to justify the plaintiff’s contention that they have a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action, known as the Certificate of Merit. Upon receipt of the certificate, the Attorney General is now required to weigh in on the merits of the matter before lawsuits are filed.
Beyond forcing evaluations of the merits of a potential claim, since the late 1980’s, additional amendments to Proposition 65 aim to better track the scope of litigation surrounding the law. Although the Attorney General has no affirmative duty to act on the information, parties must now provide notice to the Attorney General any time a Proposition 65 lawsuit is filed and upon the settlement of such matters. The Attorney General must maintain records of all of these notices and provide the records to the public.
This bill recognizes that there is little statutory guidance as to what substance must be included in a Certificate of Merit beyond a certification that the would-be plaintiff, “has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action.” (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.7 (d)(1).) In practice, these certificates are accompanied by laboratory data highlighting the toxicity of the targeted product. Seeking to bolster the relevance and detail of the information provided to the Attorney General, this bill would require parties submitting laboratory reports with their Certificate of Merit to include the actual brand name of the product that was tested and to certify that testing was conducted on that product within the prior year.
Additionally, this bill would require communications from the Attorney General regarding settlements or other proposed litigation outcomes to be transmitted to all parties. These provisions ensure that all litigants are aware of the Attorney General’s viewpoint on the merits of a proposed settlement.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is sponsored the Asian Food Trade Association. In support of the bill they write:
Since 1992, the Asian Food Trade Association has served as the leading organization representing the Asian Pacific Islander food importer community in the Golden State and throughout the nation, speaking out and helping to solve challenges and help this community to thrive. We play a pivotal role working to create smoother import processes for our members, notably small to medium sized enterprises, by building relationships and fostering stronger policy that will keep the transaction of goods thriving and growing.
One of the biggest challenges API owner-operators face, is the abuse of Prop 65and how it is being weaponized against all types of businesses and their products. In the food industry, the national FDA has already done more than enough to protect American consumers from reasonable levels of chemicals. However, the loophole that Prop 65 gives a few bad lawyers the legal protection to stretch the law and extorting money from California’s hardworking small businesses.
If passed, we’re only asking that reasonable evidence be given to defendants so they can compare accredited lab reports they should be presenting to the AG, and also to defendants upon request.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Asian Food Trade Association (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3004 (
Author:Mike Fong) – As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
SUBJECT: Proposition 65: certificates of merit: Attorney General communications
SUMMARY: Requires a person, when filing an action under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), to include the brand name of the product tested with the certificate of merit. Specifically, this bill:
1) Requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, then the report shall indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested. Requires any testing done to support the certificate of merit to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
2) Requires the Attorney General (AG), if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits, under Proposition 65, a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity into water or onto or into land where such chemical passes or probably will pass into any source of drinking water. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 25249.5)
- Prohibits a person, in the course of doing business, from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. (HSC § 25249.6)
- Provides that any person who violates the above provisions may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction and be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 per day for each violation, in addition to any other penalty established by law. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Provides for a specified course of remediation for lawsuits alleging a violation of the clear and reasonable warning requirement for four specified exposures (lawfully permitted alcoholic beverages; chemicals resulting from food or beverage preparation; environmental tobacco smoke on premises where smoking is permitted; and, engine exhaust in parking facilities, as specified). Prohibits the person who files an action from exposure from doing so until 14 days after she or he has served the alleged violator with a notice of alleged violation. Authorizes the person who served the notice of violation to file an action if the alleged violator failed to correct the alleged violation or failed to pay a civil penalty of $500. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Requires the person filing an action to serve the notice of violation to the alleged violator, the AG and the local District Attorney, and to also include with the notice a certificate of merit and sufficient factual information to establish the basis of merit. Authorizes the AG to establish whether or not there is merit to the action, and if the AG determines there is not merit to the action, requires the AG to notify both the person bringing the action and the alleged violator. (HSC § 25249.7)
- Requires a person bringing an action in the public interest under Proposition 65, or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of Proposition 65 is alleged, to, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the AG a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action. (HSC 25249.7 § (f) (2))
- Exempts a person employing fewer than 10 employees from the warning requirement under Proposition 65. (HSC § 25249.11)
- Authorizes amendments to Proposition 65, provided that they are passed in each house of the Legislature by a two-thirds vote and further the purposes of Proposition 65. (Initiative Measure, Proposition 65, Sec. 7, Nov. 4, 1986.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 3004 makes minor changes to Proposition 65 to ensure that the Act is carried out as intended – to ensure that consumers are aware of products containing certain chemicals. Private enforcers who are simply seeking settlement money may reuse the same laboratory test on multiple products over a number of years. This hurts small businesses who must pay sometimes thousands of dollars to settle the claim while possibly not receiving credible information. They may put the label on a product, but they will not know if the product indeed contains the chemicals. This bill ensures that the laboratory test is current and identifies the brand name of the product that was tested."
Proposition 65: In 1986, California voters approved a ballot initiative, the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, commonly referred to as Proposition 65, to address their concern that "hazardous chemicals pose a serious potential threat to their health and well-being, [and] that state government agencies have failed to provide them with adequate protection…" Proposition 65 requires the state to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. This list, which must be updated at least once a year, currently includes approximately 800 chemicals. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) administers the Proposition 65 program, including an evaluation of all currently available scientific information on substances considered for placement on the Proposition 65 list.
Under Proposition 65, businesses in California are required to provide a "clear and reasonable" warning before knowingly and intentionally exposing anyone to a Proposition 65-listed chemical. Warnings can be made in many ways, including labeling a consumer product, posting signs, distributing notices, or publishing notices in a newspaper. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 12 months to comply with warning requirements.
Proposition 65 also prohibits companies that do business within California from knowingly discharging listed chemicals into sources of drinking water. Once a chemical is listed, businesses have 20 months to comply with the discharge prohibition.
Changes to Proposition 65 warning requirements: Since the original warning requirements took effect in 1988, most Proposition 65 warnings simply stated that a chemical is present that causes cancer or reproductive harm, but the warning did not identify the chemical or provide specific information about how a person may be exposed or ways to reduce or eliminate exposure to it. OEHHA regulations, adopted in August 2016 and that took full effect in August 2018, change the warning requirements in several important ways. The new warnings for consumer products need to: include the verbiage that the product "can expose you to" a Proposition 65 chemical rather than saying the product "contains" the chemical; name at least one chemical present in the product that is listed on the Proposition 65 list; provide the internet address for OEHHA’s new Proposition 65 warnings website which provides additional information about the health effects of the chemicals on the Proposition 65 list; and, include a triangular yellow warning symbol.
Multiple avenues of enforcement of Proposition 65: Proposition 65 authorizes the California AG, as well as any district attorney or city attorney (for cities whose population exceeds 750,000), to enforce Proposition 65. In addition, a person may bring an action acting in the public interest if both of the following requirements are met: 1) the private action is commenced more than 60 days after the person filing the action has provided the notice of the alleged violation to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator including the certificate of merit and the factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit, and 2) neither the AG nor district attorney has commenced prosecuting an action against the violation.
It is important to note that Proposition 65 only allows enforcement through the courts. Unlike other environmental laws, there is not a state department or state or local agency that is authorized to oversee and enforce Proposition 65 using administrative penalties. If found guilty through the courts, penalties for violating Proposition 65 by failing to provide warning notices can be as high as $2,500 per violation per day.
Exemption from enforcement: Businesses with fewer than 10 employees and government agencies are exempt from Proposition 65’s warning requirements and prohibition on discharges into drinking water sources. Businesses are also exempt from the warning requirement and discharge prohibition if the exposures they cause are so low as to create no significant risk of cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm.
Certificate of merit: Current law requires any person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide a notice of alleged violation, 60 days before taking the action, to the AG, including a certificate of merit. The certificate of merit states that the person executing the certificate has consulted with one or more persons with relevant and appropriate experience or expertise who has reviewed facts, studies, or other data regarding the exposure to the listed chemical that is the subject of the action, and that, based on that information, the person executing the certificate believes there is a reasonable and meritorious case for the private action. Additionally, factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit must be attached to the certificate that is served on the AG. The law also requires the AG, after reviewing the certificate of merit, including the factual basis supporting the certificate of merit, to, if she or he finds that there is not merit to the action, serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator that the AG believes there is not merit to the action.
This bill: AB 3004 requires a person filing an action under Proposition 65, if a report from a laboratory is submitted with the certificate of merit, to indicate the brand name, if any, of the product tested. It also requires any testing done to support the certificate of merit to have occurred within one year of the submittal of the certificate of merit.
Report to the AG: Existing law requires a person bringing an action in the public interest under Proposition 65 or a private person bringing an action in which a violation of Proposition 65 is alleged, to, after the action is either subject to a settlement, with or without court approval, or to a judgment, submit to the Attorney General a report that includes information on any corrective action being taken as a part of the settlement or resolution of the action.
This bill: AB 3004 requires the AG, if they provide a comment, suggestion, or any other communication in response to the report provided to them by one of the parties in a settlement or judgment under Proposition 65, to provide that comment, suggestion, or other communication to all parties to the settlement or judgment.
Arguments in Support: According to the Asian Food Trade Association, "Since 1992, the Asian Food Trade Association (AFTA) has served as the leading organization representing the Asian Pacific Islander (API) food importer community in the Golden State and throughout the nation, speaking out and helping to solve challenges and help this community to thrive. We play a pivotal role working to create smoother import processes for our members, notably small to medium sized enterprises, by building relationships and fostering stronger policy that will keep the transaction of goods thriving and growing.
One of the biggest challenges API owner-operators face, is the abuse of Prop 65 (Clean Water Bill) and how it is being weaponized against all types of businesses and their products. However, the loophole that Prop 65 gives a few bad lawyers the legal protection to stretch the law and extorting money from California’s hardworking small businesses.
If passed, we’re only asking that reasonable evidence be given to defendants so they can compare accredited lab reports they should be presenting to the AG, and also to defendants upon request."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
Double referral: Should the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials approve this bill, it will be referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Related legislation:
- AB 1521 (Mike Fong, 2023). Would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65, when providing factual information sufficient to establish the basis of the certificate of merit to the AG to additionally include information supporting the certificate of merit, including dates and studies related to the product that is the subject of the notice of the alleged violation. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
- AB 2743 (Mike Fong, 2022). Would have required a person bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide the notice of the alleged violation and factual information for the basis for the certificate of merit to the AG, local district attorney, and the alleged violator. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
- AB 693 (Chau, 2021). Would have required that any compensation received by a plaintiff of a Proposition 65 suit be disclosed to a court, and would have allowed food suppliers and distributors 14 days to label products in violation of Proposition 65 without penalties. This bill was not heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and subsequently died on file.
- AB 2849 (Chau, 2020). Would have authorized a person employing fewer than 10 employees to waive his or her exemption under Proposition 65 and provide this in writing to the person bringing an action under Proposition 65 and to the AG. This bill died in the Senate on Environmental Quality Committee.
- AB 1123 (Reyes, Chapter 187, Statutes of 2019). Requires certain notice be provided to the AG before certain proceedings involving Proposition 65 are filed in the Supreme Court, court of appeal, or the appellate division of the superior court.
- AB 1583 (Chau, Chapter 510, Statutes of 2017). Requires the AG, after reviewing the certificate of merit filed under an action under Proposition 65, to, if, after reviewing the certificate of merit, she or he finds that there is not merit to the action, serve a letter to the noticing party and the alleged violator that the AG believes there is not merit to the action. Requires the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development to post on its internet website information relating to a business's obligations under Proposition 65.
- AB 1621 (Travis Allen, 2017). Would have required anyone bringing an action under Proposition 65 to provide the certificate of merit that is required to be provided to the and and also to the alleged violator. This bill was held in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
- AB 1252 (Jones, 2015). Would have prohibited any person from bringing an enforcement action against a company that employs 25 people or fewer for failure to provide a warning for an exposure to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity, in violation of Proposition 65, unless certain conditions are met. This bill was held in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
- AB 2361 (Jones, 2014). Would have prohibited any person from bringing an enforcement action against a company that employs 25 people or fewer for failure to provide a warning for an exposure to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity, in violation of Proposition 65, unless certain conditions are met. This bill was held in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee.
- AB 227 (Gatto, Chapter 581 Statutes of 2013). Changes the enforcement provisions of Proposition 65 by limiting recovery by private citizen enforcement actions for specified types of exposures to chemicals causing cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm, in those circumstances when the failure to provide clear and reasonable warnings has been remedied and a penalty has been paid.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Asian Food Trade Association
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):