AB 3141: Property taxation: possessory interests: seaport environmental improvements.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-03-21
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing property tax law requires that all property subject to tax be assessed at its full cash value, and includes certain possessory interests among those property interests that are subject to tax. Existing property tax law defines a taxable possessory interest to be a use that is independent, durable, and exclusive. Existing property tax law specifies that, specifies, for purposes of the definition of a taxable possessory interest, there is no independent possession or use of land or improvements if various types of possession or use that are not considered independent possession or use of land, including when that possession or use is a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household, as specified.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to the provision relating to publicly owned housing projects.This bill would provide, for the 202526 fiscal year to the 202930 fiscal year, inclusive, that there is no independent or exclusive possession or use of land or improvements if that possession or use is of any infrastructure at a public seaport, as defined, that is newly constructed on or after January 1, 2025, as described, as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement, as defined. The bill would, among other things, deem the construction or installation made or used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment, as defined, to be independent, durable, and exclusive, as specified. The bill would continue to exclude a possessory interest from exclusion under the bills provisions after the 202930 fiscal year, if the interest is excluded prior to the inoperative date of the bills provisions, until there is a subsequent change in ownership of the interest or until the date the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment, whichever is earlier. By requiring local tax officials to administer the bills provisions, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would make related legislative findings and declarations.
Existing law requires any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain, among other things, specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, detailed performance indicators, and data collection requirements.
This bill would specify that it does not authorize a tax expenditure.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law requires the state to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding those provisions, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing property tax law requires that all property subject to tax be assessed at its full cash value, and includes certain possessory interests among those property interests that are subject to tax. Existing property tax law defines a taxable possessory interest to be a use that is independent, durable, and exclusive. Existing property tax law specifies that, for purposes of the definition of a taxable possessory interest, there is no independent possession or use of land or improvements if that possession or use is a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household, as specified.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to the provision relating to publicly owned housing projects.
It is the intent of the Legislature that Section 107.15 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, as added by this act, be enacted to encourage and to provide incentives for the development, construction, and installation of publicly owned infrastructure in support of the improvement of air quality or water quality at intermodal freight transportation systems at public seaports, independent of existing lease terms and revenue bonding capacity, by clarifying when newly constructed infrastructure that is improved, constructed, or installed is not independent and exclusive possession.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Californias public seaports exist on granted state tidelands held in trust for the people of the state and managed for the benefit of all of the people of California as a statewide interest and exist on property managed by a local government or a local port or harbor district as a dedicated use of publicly owned and operated property.
(b)Californias public seaports are enterprise agencies that rely on revenues from cargo volumes and long-term lease revenues to underwrite revenue bonds that finance the infrastructure necessary to facilitate the states and nations commerce and trade. These infrastructure investments also include improvements to real property, which are necessary to better the environment but do not further the independent and exclusive use of seaport property by tenants. Many of these improvements are necessary in order to execute and administer the policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations of the state, which is also the grantor and trustor public owner of the property.
(c)These improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment also typically do not generate additional revenues for the seaports, and often increase the operational expenses of tenants. This means that these are infrastructure expenses that are not directly financed through revenue bonding backed by revenues by leaseholders or a business-driven management or operation of the property separate or apart from the public purposes of the property and its improvements.
(d)In addition, many of these investments are necessary to be made in the middle of an existing lease term or operating agreement with a port tenant. This means that these costs to both the port and the ports tenant were not accounted for in the initial lease terms or associated revenue bonding underwriting and planning separate and apart from the initiation of new policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, or regulations at the time of the lease execution.
(e)Many improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment are not made for the benefit and enjoyment of the tenant and the tenant does not maintain exclusive occupancy of the use of the environmental improvements.
(f)The possessory interests held by port tenants on public seaport property generate substantial property taxes.
(g)Improvements made to the publicly-owned infrastructure at public seaports in support of bettering air quality and water quality, when the improvements are for uses that are not independent and exclusive, are made in order to facilitate improvements to the environment and not to impose higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of a reassessment event during the term of possession of the public property. Higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of these improvements thereby create substantial indirect increases in the costs of improvement of the states environment.
(h)The imposition of higher taxes on tenants may increase costs on discretionary intermodal cargo, which may lead to its diversion to another maritime gateway. This diversion of intermodal cargo may, in turn, both increase greenhouse gases and reduce seaport revenues. These revenues are necessary to fund and finance public seaports infrastructure improvements, which better environmental quality.
(i)The full value of the improvements made by the public seaports in the construction or installation of infrastructure as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement will be captured on the tax rolls at a change in ownership reassessment event where the resulting economic impact of new construction that results in nonindependent and nonexclusive uses will naturally be reflected in either increases or decreases to assessed value.
SEC. 3.Section 107.15 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:107.15.(a)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (b), for purposes of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 107, there is no independent possession or use of land or improvements if that possession or use is of any infrastructure at a public seaport that is newly constructed on or after January 1, 2025, as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (b), for purposes of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 107, there is no exclusive possession or use of land or improvements if that possession or use is of any infrastructure at a public seaport that is newly constructed on and after January 1, 2025, as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement.
(b)(1)This section shall not apply to personal property, including cargo handling equipment, and no tax benefit is intended to be conferred under this section on the basis of ownership or operation of any personal property, including cargo handling equipment.
(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the construction or installation of the real property improvements shall be deemed to be independent, durable, and exclusive if the construction or installation is made or used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment. This paragraph shall not be construed to limit the use of devices that support human-operated cargo handling equipment, including, but not limited to, equipment to evaluate the utilization and environmental benefits of that human-operated equipment.
(c)(1)This section shall not be construed to restrict, and shall not result in any restriction of, any assessment procedures or requirements pursuant to this part for property that is not subject to the payment of a possessory interest tax at the time of the completion of the construction or installation of the improvements.
(2)An improvement subject to this section shall be deemed to be constructed or installed on or after January 1, 2025, if the construction or installation is completed on or after that date, regardless of when the construction or installation of the improvement commenced or when the associated building permit was issued for that construction or installation.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Fully automated cargo handling equipment means cargo handling equipment that is remotely operated or remotely monitored with or without the exercise of human intervention or control.
(2)Infrastructure means an improvement to real property.
(3)New construction has the same meaning as in Section 70.
(4)Nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement means any improvement to real property that is all of the following:
(A)The improvement is necessary to facilitate an improvement in air quality or water quality at the seaport or in the environment impacted by seaport operations.
(B)The principal purpose of the improvement does not include producing or otherwise generating revenue for the public seaport.
(C)The improvement is on property that is subject to a possessory interest tax payable by a tenant or lessee of the seaport at the time the construction or installation of the improvement is completed.
(5)Public seaport means any local public agency that owns, operates, or manages seaport, intermodal, rail, industrial transportation, or marine terminal assets on granted state tidelands or within the boundaries of its harbor district established pursuant to the Harbors and Navigation Code.
(e)(1)This section shall apply to property tax lien dates for the 202526 fiscal year to the 202930 fiscal year, inclusive.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), a possessory interest that qualifies for an exclusion under this section prior to the inoperative date of this section pursuant to paragraph (1) shall continue to be excluded after the 202930 fiscal year, until there is a subsequent change in ownership of the interest or until the date the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment, whichever is earlier.
SEC. 4.Notwithstanding Section 41 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, this act does not authorize a tax expenditure.
SEC. 5.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 6.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 7.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
SECTION 1.Section 107.10 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:107.10.For purposes of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 107, there is no independent possession or use of land or improvements if the possession or use is a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, rented at affordable rents as described in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code.For purposes of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 107, there is no independent possession or use of land or improvements if that the possession or use is a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, rented at affordable rents as described in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 29). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to REV. & TAX. suspense file. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 17, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 29, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Pacific Merchant Shipping Association | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3141
Author:(Gipson) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill provides that infrastructure at a public seaport that is newly constructed as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is not subject to property tax.
Specifically, this bill:
- Provides, for lien dates for fiscal year (FY) 2025-26 to FY 2029-30, inclusive, that there is no possessory interest of land if the possession or use is for infrastructure at a public seaport that is newly constructed on or after January 1, 2025, as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement.
- Defines “nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement” to mean an improvement to real property that is all of the following: (a) necessary to facilitate an improvement in air quality or water quality at a seaport or environment impacted by a seaport, (b) does not have the principal purpose of producing or generating revenue for a seaport, and (c) on property subject to a possessory interest tax payable by a tenant or lessee of a seaport at the time the construction or installation of the improvement is completed.
- Deems the construction or installation of real property improvements made or used for the operation of any fully-automated cargo handling equipment to be an independent, durable, and exclusive use.
- Continues the possessory interest exclusion after FY 2029-30 for a property until there is a subsequent change in ownership or the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is used for the operation of fully-automated cargo handling equipment, whichever is earlier.
- Declares the bill does not authorize a tax expenditure, so is not subject to existing law requiring tax expenditure legislation to include specific goals and performance indicators.
- Prohibits the state from reimbursing a local agency for lost property tax revenues.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual property tax revenue loss of approximately $360,000 by excluding certain improvements from property tax. The Board of Equalization (BOE) notes that this revenue estimate may be conservative, as the BOE does not know the breadth of what may qualify as a “nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement” and if such improvements are unrelated to fully-automated cargo handling equipment. Although property tax is a local government revenue source, reductions in property tax revenues increase Proposition 98 General Fund (GF) spending by up to roughly 50% (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee).
- By requiring county assessors to administer a new property tax exclusion, this bill likely creates a state-mandated local program. If the Commission on State Mandates determines the provisions of this bill create a new program or impose a higher level of service for which the state must reimburse local costs, counties could seek reimbursement from the state (GF). Assessors may incur significant costs to determine what comprises a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement and when such an improvement is used for the operation of fully-automated cargo handling equipment.
- Costs of an unknown, but potentially significant, amount to the BOE to revise informational materials and ensure consistent application of the exclusion across counties (GF).
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
While the ports, and businesses revolving around the ports, have been great partners to the legislature and administration in our state wide goals of reduced greenhouse emissions, tenants have seen increased property taxes due to improvements of infrastructure that is relating to increasing air or water quality. AB 3141 seeks to incentivize businesses to continue doing business in California while also participating and investing in our goals to reduce emissions and continue to push California as an environmental leader.
This bill is supported by the Pacific Merchant Shipping Association.
- Background.
Possessory Interest. A possessory interest is a private interest held in public property. The California Constitution provides that public property of state and local governments is not subject to property tax. However, a possessory interest in that state or local property can be considered taxable, with the “taxable possessory interest” being the portion of the property’s value attributed to benefit the private entity. Examples include food and beverage concession agreements at state parks and the rental of government property at convention centers.
California’s Ports. California has 12 ports that vary significantly in size, operations, and finances, 11 of which are publicly owned (the Port of Benicia is privately owned). California has undertaken significant efforts to lower mobile emissions to advance the state’s climate goals. At ports, mobile emissions generally stem from drayage trucks, which transport cargo to and from the state’s intermodal seaports and railyards, as well as from equipment used to offload cargo ships. On April 28, 2023, the Air Resources Board (ARB) released its Advanced Clean Fleets Regulation, which requires all drayage trucks to be zero-emission by 2035 and slowly phases out emitting trucks during the intervening period. In order to facilitate this transition and accommodate zero- or low-emission trucks, port tenants must make additional infrastructure investments, such as building new fueling stations. Under the California Constitution, such new construction improvements can result in reassessment of a property’s base year value. This bill provides that such improvements made at public ports do not constitute a taxable possessory interest, thus excluding the improvements from property tax. However, to the extent such improvements are for fully-automated cargo handling equipment, the exclusion does not apply.
Generally, tax incentives are conferred to encourage voluntary behavior deemed beneficial for the public good. To the extent that existing ARB regulations necessitate property improvements to comply with zero-emission policies, this bill potentially creates a windfall for legally mandated behavior, on top of other existing incentives provided to support the transition to clean energy. If the state wants to help private entities offset the costs of compliance, a direct appropriation of funds would be a simpler way to achieve this outcome. Additionally, the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee’s analysis of this bill notes:
This bill, however may extend beyond the constitutional authority of the Legislature. The Constitution provides that all property is taxable…Generally, possessory interests cannot be exempt from taxation unless their value is so low that the cost to collect those taxes would outweigh the revenue gained. The improvements required to comply with the state’s environmental goals, however, would be in the hundreds of millions to billions of dollars according to supporters, and would almost certainly not be below that threshold to qualify for that exemption.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Jacqui Irwin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3141 (
Author:Gipson) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUSPENSE
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Property taxation: possessory interests: seaport environmental improvements
SUMMARY: Provides that no independent or exclusive possession or use of land exists if that possession or use results from newly constructed "nonrevenue-generating environmental equipment," with certain restrictions. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that no independent or exclusive possession or use of land or improvements exists if that possession or use is of any "infrastructure" at a "public seaport" that is newly constructed on or after January 1, 2025, as part of a "nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement."
- Prohibits this bill from applying to personal property, including cargo handling equipment, and provides that this bill does not intend to confer a tax benefit on the basis of ownership or operation of any personal property.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to the construction or installation of real property improvements if the construction or installation is made or used for the operation of any "fully automated cargo handling equipment," but that this bill must not be construed to limit the use of devices that support human-operated cargo handling equipment, including, but not limited to, equipment to evaluate the utilization and environmental benefits of that human-operated equipment.
- Provides that this bill is not to be construed to restrict, and shall not result in any restriction of, any assessment procedures or requirements pursuant to existing property tax law if property is not subject to taxation as a possessory interest at the time of the completion of the construction or installation of the improvement.
- Requires that an improvement subject to this bill is deemed constructed or installed on or after January 1, 2025, if the construction or installation is completed on or after that date, regardless of when the construction or installation of the improvement commenced or when the associated building permit was issued for that construction or installation.
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, the following terms:
- "Fully automated cargo handling equipment" as cargo handling equipment that is remotely operated or remotely monitored with or without the exercise of human intervention or control;
- "Infrastructure" as an improvement to real property;
- "New construction" as that term is defined in existing law; and,
- "Nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement" as any improvement to real property that is necessary to facilitate an improvement in air quality or water quality at the seaport or in the environment impacted by seaport operations, the principal purpose of which does not include producing or otherwise generating revenue for the public seaport, and that is on property subject to a possessory interest tax payable by a tenant or lessee of the seaport at the time the construction or installation of the improvement is completed.
- Provides that this bill applies to property tax lien dates from the 2025-2026 fiscal year to the 2029-30 fiscal year, inclusive. A possessory interest that qualifies for this bill's exclusion prior to this bill's inoperative date shall continue to be excluded after the 2029-30 fiscal year, until there is a subsequent change in ownership of the interest or until the date the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment, whichever is earlier.
- Provides that this bill does not authorize a new tax expenditure.
- Provides that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to existing law.
- Provides that no appropriation is made by this bill and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it resulting from this bill.
- Finds and declares that:
- California's public seaports exist on granted state tidelands held in trust for the people of the state and managed for the benefit of all of the people of California as a statewide interest and exist on property managed by a local government or a local port or harbor district as a dedicated use of publicly owned and operated property;
- California's public seaports are enterprise agencies that rely on revenues from cargo volumes and long-term lease revenues to underwrite revenue bonds that finance the infrastructure necessary to facilitate the state's and nation's commerce and trade. These infrastructure investments also include improvements to real property, which are necessary to better the environment but do not further the independent and exclusive use of seaport property by tenants. Many of these improvements are necessary in order to execute and administer the policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations of the state, which is also the grantor and trustor public owner of the property;
- These improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment also typically do not generate additional revenues for the seaports, and often increase the operational expenses of tenants. This means that these are infrastructure expenses that are not directly financed through revenue bonding backed by revenues by leaseholders or a business-driven management or operation of the property separate or apart from the public purposes of the property and its improvements;
- In addition, many of these investments are necessary to be made in the middle of an existing lease term or operating agreement with a port tenant. This means that these costs to both the port and the port's tenant were not accounted for in the initial lease terms or associated revenue bonding underwriting and planning separate and apart from the initiation of new policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, or regulations at the time of the lease execution;
- Many improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment are not made for the benefit and enjoyment of the tenant and the tenant does not maintain exclusive occupancy of the use of the environmental improvements;
- The possessory interests held by port tenants on public seaport property generate substantial property taxes;
- Improvements made to the publicly-owned infrastructure at public seaports in support of bettering air quality and water quality, when the improvements are for uses that are not independent and exclusive, are made in order to facilitate improvements to the environment and not to impose higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of a reassessment event during the term of possession of the public property. Higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of these improvements thereby create substantial indirect increases in the costs of improvement of the state's environment;
- The imposition of higher taxes on tenants may increase costs on discretionary intermodal cargo, which may lead to its diversion to another maritime gateway. This diversion of intermodal cargo may, in turn, both increase greenhouse gases and reduce seaport revenues. These revenues are necessary to fund and finance public seaports’ infrastructure improvements, which better environmental quality; and,
- The full value of the improvements made by the public seaports in the construction or installation of infrastructure as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement will be captured on the tax rolls at a change in ownership reassessment event where the resulting economic impact of new construction that results in non-independent and nonexclusive uses will naturally be reflected in either increases or decreases to assessed value.
- Provides that it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill is to encourage and to provide incentives for the development, construction, and installation of publicly owned infrastructure in support of the improvement of air quality or water quality at intermodal freight transportation systems at public seaports, independent of existing lease terms and bonding capacity, by clarifying when newly constructed infrastructure that is improved, constructed, or installed is not independent and exclusive possession.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all property is taxable, unless otherwise provided by the California Constitution or laws of the United States. (California Constitution, Article XIII, Section 1.)
- Limits the amount of any ad valorem tax on real property to no more than 1% of the property's full cash value. The full cash value of real property is, generally, the appraised value when that property is purchased, newly constructed, or changes ownership. This value is referred to as the base year value, and may adjust upwards at an annual rate of 2% or inflation, whichever is less. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 1.)
- Requires the assessor to increase a property's assessment to reflect the full cash value of "new construction" when substantial additions or alterations occur. New construction is assigned its own distinct base year value, and the remainder of the property's base year value is unaffected. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 2.)
- Excludes from the definition of new construction an active solar energy system, as defined. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 2 and Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 73.)
- Exempts certain property from taxation, including property owned by the state or a local government, as provided. (California Constitution, Article XIII, Section 3.)
- Defines "real property" as the possession of, claim to, ownership of, or right to the possession of land, all mines, as specified, and improvements. (R&TC Section 105.)
- Defines "personal property" as all property except real property, as restricted. (R&TC Section 106.)
- Defines a "possessory interest" as the possession of, claim to, or right to the possession of land or improvements that is "independent", "durable", "and exclusive" of rights held by others in the property, except when coupled with ownership of the land or improvements in the same person. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "independent" as the ability to exercise authority and exert control over the management or operation of the property or improvements, separate and apart from the policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations of the public owner of the property or improvements. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "durable" as a determinable period with a reasonable certainty that the use, possession, or claim with respect to the property or improvements will continue for that period. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "exclusive" as the enjoyment of a beneficial use of land or improvements, together with the ability to exclude from occupancy by means of legal process others who may interfere with that enjoyment, as specified. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Provides that the possession or use of a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household rented at affordable rents is not an independent possession or use that would constitute a possessory interest. (R&TC Section 107.10.)
- Authorizes the formation of port districts, and stipulates the power and authority vested in the district. (Harbors and Navigation Code Section 6200 et seq.)
- Defines "affordable rents" as no more than 30% of a tenant's income. (Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50093.)
- Defines "low-income household" as a household that does not exceed 80% of the area median income (AMI). (H&SC Section 50079.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Staff from the State Board of Equalization (BOE) note that a definitive revenue estimate is indeterminable, but that there is a likelihood of decreased revenues. Committee staff notes that these losses are likely significant, qualifying this bill for this Committee's Suspense File.
COMMENTS:
- The author has submitted the following statement in support of this bill:
AB 3141 seeks to help the state reach its climate and energy goals by creating a property tax exemption for nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements for port terminal leases. While the ports, and businesses revolving around the ports, have been great partners to the legislature and administration in our state wide goals of reduced greenhouse emissions, tenants have seen increased property taxes due to improvements of infrastructure that is relating to increasing air or water quality. AB 3141 seeks to incentivize businesses to continue doing business in California while also participating and investing in our goals to reduce emissions and continue to push California as an environmental leader.
- The Pacific Merchant Shipping Association, writing in support of this bill, states, in part:
All possessory interest taxes will ultimately be captured in the assessed value of a new lease at a change of tenancy event, but this bill would ensure that an existing tenant's taxes do not increase in the middle of a lease because of an air quality or water quality project. This bill is consistent with the same legal mechanisms that were adopted for affordable housing possessory interests earlier this session and does not run afoul of any Constitutional protections for taxpayers. AB 3141 will not reduce any tax revenues, instead it simply addresses the re-assessment events which could result in additional future tax increments.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- State ports: The state currently has 12 ports that vary significantly in size, operations, and finances, including two of the nation's largest ports, the Port of Los Angeles and the Port of Long Beach. Of these 12 ports, 11 are publicly owned, and one, the Port of Benicia, is privately owned. According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, California ports process approximately 40% of all containerized imports into, and 30% of all exports from, the United States. Thus, these ports play a central role in the economic vitality of California, and the Nation.
- Possessory interests: A possessory interest is a private interest held in public property and constitutes that portion of a public property that is exclusively, independently, and durably vested in a private entity. The California Constitution provides that property of the state and of local governments is not taxable. However, a possessory interest in that state or local government property can be considered taxable. In these instances, the portion of the property's value that can be attributed to benefit a private entity is taxed. This situation is often referred to as a "taxable possessory interest."
- Tenancies in public ports: California law allows for the establishment of port districts if approved by voters, as specified. As such, the public ports in California lease space on their property to private companies that engage in the actual business of goods movement. These companies range from offloading cargo ships themselves, to transporting those offloaded goods to other means of cargo distribution, such as rail stations. These tenants generally have a taxable possessory interest equal to the value of the improvements owned by tenants that are situated on port property.
- Emissions reductions at ports: Over the last decade, California has undergone efforts to lower mobile emissions. In ports, these mobile emissions generally refer to drayage trucks, which transport cargo to and from the state's intermodal seaports and railyards, and equipment used to offload cargo ships. Last year, on April 28, the California Air Resources Board, the state entity responsible for overseeing California's air quality, released the Advanced Clean Fleets Regulation, which requires all drayage trucks to be zero emission by 2035 and slowly phases out emitting trucks in the intervening period. To facilitate this transition, additional infrastructure investments must be made in order to fuel whatever type of zero- or low-emission vehicles port tenants choose to purchase.
- SB 734 (Rubio): Committee staff understands this bill is prompted by a bill the Legislature authorized last year, SB 734 (Rubio), Chapter 785, Statutes of 2023. SB 734 provided that there was no independent possession or use of land or improvement related to affordable housing rented to low-income tenants. SB 734 and this bill materially differ. SB 734 was the codification of an existing BOE interpretation that possessory interests created from units rented to low-income households on public property do not constitute an independent use or possession that would trigger taxation if those units would otherwise qualify for the low-income rental welfare exemption. Thus, there is a Constitutional basis for codifying the exemption provided in SB 734 that does not exist for this bill's provisions.
- Impetus for this bill: The author and supporters note that this bill is intended to prevent cost increases resulting from additional property taxes that port tenants would pass on to the customers they service, such as companies that own cargo ships. Supporters indicate that California ports have seen a recent decline in the amount of cargo they process, and are concerned about property tax increases resulting from compliance with California environmental regulations and requirements. The Pacific Merchant Shipping Association, in its West Coast Trade Report, notes a 2% drop in the total amount of inbound cargo from 2019. The drop in inbound cargo to seaports, which generally take in significant amounts of Chinese export goods, may be due to economic, not policy, factors. According to an article published by the New York Times in early February 2024, in 2023 Mexico surpassed China as the largest origin source for United States imports. Additionally, the increased cost to ship a fully loaded 40-foot container to Texas ports, rather than California ports, is approximately $1,000. The approximate number of 40-foot containers a ship can hold is between 9,000 to 10,000. Thus, the increased cost to divert one fully loaded container ship from California ports, through the Panama Canal, and into Texas, could be as much as $9 million to $10 million. As ad valorem property taxes are capped at 1% in California, property taxes on improvements covered by this bill could range from $1 million if the aggregate value of improvements is assessed as $100 million, up to $10 million if aggregate improvements are valued at $1 billion. As noted below, supporters indicate that the total cost of environmental improvements could range from the hundreds of millions of dollars to billions of dollars.
- This bill: As currently drafted, this bill provides that there is no independent use or possession of land or improvements if that use or possession is related to nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements. Improvements at ports will need to be made over the next decade in order to comply with the state's efforts to improve water and air quality. Regarding the efforts to reduce emissions noted above, these improvements will often take the form of refueling infrastructure for zero- or low-emission vehicles. These improvements can result in a reassessment as the California Constitution stipulates that the base year value of a property is reassessed upon new construction occurring on the property. Thus, the environmental improvements at ports would generally trigger an increase in value, and the private owners of those improvements would hold a taxable possessory interest.
This bill, however, may extend beyond the constitutional authority of the Legislature. The Constitution provides that all property is taxable, and that real property shall be taxed at no more than 1% of its value, as defined. There are limited exceptions to this general requirement that affirmatively give the Legislature authority to exempt certain types of real property from taxation. Generally, possessory interests cannot be exempt from taxation unless their value is so low that the cost to collect those taxes would outweigh the revenue gained. The improvements required to comply with the state's environmental goals, however, would be in the hundreds of millions to billions of dollars according to supporters, and would almost certainly not be below that threshold to qualify for that exemption.
- Treatment of existing possessory interests: The author has indicated that they do not intend to modify any possessory interest in existing improvements to which port tenants may already be subject. This bill, however, would exempt a more intensive use of this property. This bill acknowledges that existing uses constitute a possessory interest, but that certain further uses do not. It could be considered as incongruent that a base possessory interest would exist, but that higher uses of that land would not trigger a use or possession that constitutes a possessory interest.
In property tax law, properties that are put to similar uses tend to be subject to similar treatment. This bill would provide that certain types of improvements, such as refueling stations, would not constitute a possessory interest. If that use is narrowed to servicing fully automated cargo handling equipment, however, then a taxable possessory interest occurs. This provision may counter the application of sound property tax law, which endeavors to provide consistent, uniform assessment of properties.
- Administrative issues: A nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement would not be subject to property taxation under this bill. Yet, this bill does not specify the entity to make the determination that an improvement is not for the primary purpose of generating revenue. Would assessors be responsible for making that determination? Would the owners of that property self-attest to that fact? It is unclear, and the author and Committee may wish to consider providing specificity.
Fully automated cargo handling equipment would be a use of the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements that would disqualify property from this bill's exclusion. While this provision is ostensibly included to protect dock workers from losing employment, it is unclear how this provision would be administered. How would an assessor know when an ineligible use of that improvement occurred to appropriately correct the roll? Would the assessor need to assign staff to monitor the property? The author and Committee may wish to address how this provision is to be administered.
- Alternative solution: It appears this bill is attempting to achieve a similar objective to the existing exclusion from the definition of new construction for an active solar energy system, as specified. That exclusion is intended, as is this bill, to reduce the cost of improving property to address environmental impacts and remove the disincentive created from higher taxes when improving property. That exclusion, however, is explicitly authorized in the Constitution. As noted previously, no such consideration is given by the Constitution to a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement at a port. The author and Committee may wish to consider whether this bill would be best implemented through a constitutional amendment excluding nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements from the definition of new construction.
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, United States Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each of them (in the form of forgone revenues). This bill would provide that certain taxable possessory interests do not exist, thereby creating a tax expenditure and subjecting this bill to this Committee's policy on tax expenditures.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added R&TC Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. AB 263 (Burke), Chapter 743, Statutes of 2019, extended the requirements in R&TC Section 41 to all tax expenditure measures under the Personal Income Tax Law, the Corporation Tax Law, and the Sales and Use Tax Law introduced on or after January 1, 2020. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. While these statutory requirements do not apply to property tax law, this Committee has consistently subjected property tax expenditures to the general treatment of tax expenditures. In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote[1]. Sunsets are required because eliminating a tax expenditure generally requires a 2/3 vote. These requirements must be satisfied before a bill can receive a vote in this Committee. This bill does contain an appropriate five-year sunset, but does not include provisions complying with the requirements of R&TC Section 41.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Pacific Merchant Shipping Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Harrison Bowlby / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
An "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean 10 years. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Jacqui Irwin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3141 (
Author:Gipson) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Property taxation: possessory interests: seaport environmental improvements
SUMMARY: Provides that no independent or exclusive possession or use of land exists if that possession or use results from newly constructed "nonrevenue-generating environmental equipment," with certain restrictions. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that no independent or exclusive possession or use of land or improvements exists if that possession or use is of any "infrastructure" at a "public seaport" that is newly constructed on or after January 1, 2025, as part of a "nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement."
- Prohibits this bill from applying to personal property, including cargo handling equipment, and provides that this bill does not intend to confer a tax benefit on the basis of ownership or operation of any personal property.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to the construction or installation of real property improvements if the construction or installation is made or used for the operation of any "fully automated cargo handling equipment," but that this bill must not be construed to limit the use of devices that support human-operated cargo handling equipment, including, but not limited to, equipment to evaluate the utilization and environmental benefits of that human-operated equipment.
- Provides that this bill is not to be construed to restrict, and shall not result in any restriction of, any assessment procedures or requirements pursuant to existing property tax law if property is not subject to taxation as a possessory interest at the time of the completion of the construction or installation of the improvement.
- Requires that an improvement subject to this bill is deemed constructed or installed on or after January 1, 2025, if the construction or installation is completed on or after that date, regardless of when the construction or installation of the improvement commenced or when the associated building permit was issued for that construction or installation.
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, the following terms:
- "Fully automated cargo handling equipment" as cargo handling equipment that is remotely operated or remotely monitored with or without the exercise of human intervention or control;
- "Infrastructure" as an improvement to real property;
- "New construction" as that term is defined in existing law; and,
- "Nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement" as any improvement to real property that is necessary to facilitate an improvement in air quality or water quality at the seaport or in the environment impacted by seaport operations, the principal purpose of which does not include producing or otherwise generating revenue for the public seaport, and that is on property subject to a possessory interest tax payable by a tenant or lessee of the seaport at the time the construction or installation of the improvement is completed.
- Provides that this bill applies to property tax lien dates from the 2025-2026 fiscal year to the 2029-30 fiscal year, inclusive. A possessory interest that qualifies for this bill's exclusion prior to this bill's inoperative date shall continue to be excluded after the 2029-30 fiscal year, until there is a subsequent change in ownership of the interest or until the date the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement is used for the operation of any fully automated cargo handling equipment, whichever is earlier.
- Provides that this bill does not authorize a new tax expenditure.
- Provides that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to existing law.
- Provides that no appropriation is made by this bill and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it resulting from this bill.
- Finds and declares that:
- California's public seaports exist on granted state tidelands held in trust for the people of the state and managed for the benefit of all of the people of California as a statewide interest and exist on property managed by a local government or a local port or harbor district as a dedicated use of publicly owned and operated property;
- California's public seaports are enterprise agencies that rely on revenues from cargo volumes and long-term lease revenues to underwrite revenue bonds that finance the infrastructure necessary to facilitate the state's and nation's commerce and trade. These infrastructure investments also include improvements to real property, which are necessary to better the environment but do not further the independent and exclusive use of seaport property by tenants. Many of these improvements are necessary in order to execute and administer the policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations of the state, which is also the grantor and trustor public owner of the property;
- These improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment also typically do not generate additional revenues for the seaports, and often increase the operational expenses of tenants. This means that these are infrastructure expenses that are not directly financed through revenue bonding backed by revenues by leaseholders or a business-driven management or operation of the property separate or apart from the public purposes of the property and its improvements;
- In addition, many of these investments are necessary to be made in the middle of an existing lease term or operating agreement with a port tenant. This means that these costs to both the port and the port's tenant were not accounted for in the initial lease terms or associated revenue bonding underwriting and planning separate and apart from the initiation of new policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, or regulations at the time of the lease execution;
- Many improvements to real property for investments to improve the environment are not made for the benefit and enjoyment of the tenant and the tenant does not maintain exclusive occupancy of the use of the environmental improvements;
- The possessory interests held by port tenants on public seaport property generate substantial property taxes;
- Improvements made to the publicly-owned infrastructure at public seaports in support of bettering air quality and water quality, when the improvements are for uses that are not independent and exclusive, are made in order to facilitate improvements to the environment and not to impose higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of a reassessment event during the term of possession of the public property. Higher tax burdens upon the tenants at public seaports as a result of these improvements thereby create substantial indirect increases in the costs of improvement of the state's environment;
- The imposition of higher taxes on tenants may increase costs on discretionary intermodal cargo, which may lead to its diversion to another maritime gateway. This diversion of intermodal cargo may, in turn, both increase greenhouse gases and reduce seaport revenues. These revenues are necessary to fund and finance public seaports’ infrastructure improvements, which better environmental quality; and,
- The full value of the improvements made by the public seaports in the construction or installation of infrastructure as part of a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement will be captured on the tax rolls at a change in ownership reassessment event where the resulting economic impact of new construction that results in non-independent and nonexclusive uses will naturally be reflected in either increases or decreases to assessed value.
- Provides that it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill is to encourage and to provide incentives for the development, construction, and installation of publicly owned infrastructure in support of the improvement of air quality or water quality at intermodal freight transportation systems at public seaports, independent of existing lease terms and bonding capacity, by clarifying when newly constructed infrastructure that is improved, constructed, or installed is not independent and exclusive possession.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all property is taxable, unless otherwise provided by the California Constitution or laws of the United States. (California Constitution, Article XIII, Section 1.)
- Limits the amount of any ad valorem tax on real property to no more than 1% of the property's full cash value. The full cash value of real property is, generally, the appraised value when that property is purchased, newly constructed, or changes ownership. This value is referred to as the base year value, and may adjust upwards at an annual rate of 2% or inflation, whichever is less. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 1.)
- Requires the assessor to increase a property's assessment to reflect the full cash value of "new construction" when substantial additions or alterations occur. New construction is assigned its own distinct base year value, and the remainder of the property's base year value is unaffected. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 2.)
- Excludes from the definition of new construction an active solar energy system, as defined. (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, Section 2 and Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 73.)
- Exempts certain property from taxation, including property owned by the state or a local government, as provided. (California Constitution, Article XIII, Section 3.)
- Defines "real property" as the possession of, claim to, ownership of, or right to the possession of land, all mines, as specified, and improvements. (R&TC Section 105.)
- Defines "personal property" as all property except real property, as restricted. (R&TC Section 106.)
- Defines a "possessory interest" as the possession of, claim to, or right to the possession of land or improvements that is "independent", "durable", "and exclusive" of rights held by others in the property, except when coupled with ownership of the land or improvements in the same person. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "independent" as the ability to exercise authority and exert control over the management or operation of the property or improvements, separate and apart from the policies, statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations of the public owner of the property or improvements. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "durable" as a determinable period with a reasonable certainty that the use, possession, or claim with respect to the property or improvements will continue for that period. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Defines "exclusive" as the enjoyment of a beneficial use of land or improvements, together with the ability to exclude from occupancy by means of legal process others who may interfere with that enjoyment, as specified. (R&TC Section 107.)
- Provides that the possession or use of a tenancy in a residential unit of a publicly owned housing project by a low-income household rented at affordable rents is not an independent possession or use that would constitute a possessory interest. (R&TC Section 107.10.)
- Authorizes the formation of port districts, and stipulates the power and authority vested in the district. (Harbors and Navigation Code Section 6200 et seq.)
- Defines "affordable rents" as no more than 30% of a tenant's income. (Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50093.)
- Defines "low-income household" as a household that does not exceed 80% of the area median income (AMI). (H&SC Section 50079.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Staff from the State Board of Equalization (BOE) note that a definitive revenue estimate is indeterminable, but that there is a likelihood of decreased revenues. Committee staff notes that these losses are likely significant, qualifying this bill for this Committee's Suspense File.
COMMENTS:
- The author has submitted the following statement in support of this bill:
AB 3141 seeks to help the state reach its climate and energy goals by creating a property tax exemption for nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements for port terminal leases. While the ports, and businesses revolving around the ports, have been great partners to the legislature and administration in our state wide goals of reduced greenhouse emissions, tenants have seen increased property taxes due to improvements of infrastructure that is relating to increasing air or water quality. AB 3141 seeks to incentivize businesses to continue doing business in California while also participating and investing in our goals to reduce emissions and continue to push California as an environmental leader.
- The Pacific Merchant Shipping Association, writing in support of this bill, states, in part:
All possessory interest taxes will ultimately be captured in the assessed value of a new lease at a change of tenancy event, but this bill would ensure that an existing tenant's taxes do not increase in the middle of a lease because of an air quality or water quality project. This bill is consistent with the same legal mechanisms that were adopted for affordable housing possessory interests earlier this session and does not run afoul of any Constitutional protections for taxpayers. AB 3141 will not reduce any tax revenues, instead it simply addresses the re-assessment events which could result in additional future tax increments.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- State ports: The state currently has 12 ports that vary significantly in size, operations, and finances, including two of the nation's largest ports, the Port of Los Angeles and the Port of Long Beach. Of these 12 ports, 11 are publicly owned, and one, the Port of Benicia, is privately owned. According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, California ports process approximately 40% of all containerized imports into, and 30% of all exports from, the United States. Thus, these ports play a central role in the economic vitality of California, and the Nation.
- Possessory interests: A possessory interest is a private interest held in public property and constitutes that portion of a public property that is exclusively, independently, and durably vested in a private entity. The California Constitution provides that property of the state and of local governments is not taxable. However, a possessory interest in that state or local government property can be considered taxable. In these instances, the portion of the property's value that can be attributed to benefit a private entity is taxed. This situation is often referred to as a "taxable possessory interest."
- Tenancies in public ports: California law allows for the establishment of port districts if approved by voters, as specified. As such, the public ports in California lease space on their property to private companies that engage in the actual business of goods movement. These companies range from offloading cargo ships themselves, to transporting those offloaded goods to other means of cargo distribution, such as rail stations. These tenants generally have a taxable possessory interest equal to the value of the improvements owned by tenants that are situated on port property.
- Emissions reductions at ports: Over the last decade, California has undergone efforts to lower mobile emissions. In ports, these mobile emissions generally refer to drayage trucks, which transport cargo to and from the state's intermodal seaports and railyards, and equipment used to offload cargo ships. Last year, on April 28, the California Air Resources Board, the state entity responsible for overseeing California's air quality, released the Advanced Clean Fleets Regulation, which requires all drayage trucks to be zero emission by 2035 and slowly phases out emitting trucks in the intervening period. To facilitate this transition, additional infrastructure investments must be made in order to fuel whatever type of zero- or low-emission vehicles port tenants choose to purchase.
- SB 734 (Rubio): Committee staff understands this bill is prompted by a bill the Legislature authorized last year, SB 734 (Rubio), Chapter 785, Statutes of 2023. SB 734 provided that there was no independent possession or use of land or improvement related to affordable housing rented to low-income tenants. SB 734 and this bill materially differ. SB 734 was the codification of an existing BOE interpretation that possessory interests created from units rented to low-income households on public property do not constitute an independent use or possession that would trigger taxation if those units would otherwise qualify for the low-income rental welfare exemption. Thus, there is a Constitutional basis for codifying the exemption provided in SB 734 that does not exist for this bill's provisions.
- Impetus for this bill: The author and supporters note that this bill is intended to prevent cost increases resulting from additional property taxes that port tenants would pass on to the customers they service, such as companies that own cargo ships. Supporters indicate that California ports have seen a recent decline in the amount of cargo they process, and are concerned about property tax increases resulting from compliance with California environmental regulations and requirements. The Pacific Merchant Shipping Association, in its West Coast Trade Report, notes a 2% drop in the total amount of inbound cargo from 2019. The drop in inbound cargo to seaports, which generally take in significant amounts of Chinese export goods, may be due to economic, not policy, factors. According to an article published by the New York Times in early February 2024, in 2023 Mexico surpassed China as the largest origin source for United States imports. Additionally, the increased cost to ship a fully loaded 40-foot container to Texas ports, rather than California ports, is approximately $1,000. The approximate number of 40-foot containers a ship can hold is between 9,000 to 10,000. Thus, the increased cost to divert one fully loaded container ship from California ports, through the Panama Canal, and into Texas, could be as much as $9 million to $10 million. As ad valorem property taxes are capped at 1% in California, property taxes on improvements covered by this bill could range from $1 million if the aggregate value of improvements is assessed as $100 million, up to $10 million if aggregate improvements are valued at $1 billion. As noted below, supporters indicate that the total cost of environmental improvements could range from the hundreds of millions of dollars to billions of dollars.
- This bill: As currently drafted, this bill provides that there is no independent use or possession of land or improvements if that use or possession is related to nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements. Improvements at ports will need to be made over the next decade in order to comply with the state's efforts to improve water and air quality. Regarding the efforts to reduce emissions noted above, these improvements will often take the form of refueling infrastructure for zero- or low-emission vehicles. These improvements can result in a reassessment as the California Constitution stipulates that the base year value of a property is reassessed upon new construction occurring on the property. Thus, the environmental improvements at ports would generally trigger an increase in value, and the private owners of those improvements would hold a taxable possessory interest.
This bill, however, may extend beyond the constitutional authority of the Legislature. The Constitution provides that all property is taxable, and that real property shall be taxed at no more than 1% of its value, as defined. There are limited exceptions to this general requirement that affirmatively give the Legislature authority to exempt certain types of real property from taxation. Generally, possessory interests cannot be exempt from taxation unless their value is so low that the cost to collect those taxes would outweigh the revenue gained. The improvements required to comply with the state's environmental goals, however, would be in the hundreds of millions to billions of dollars according to supporters, and would almost certainly not be below that threshold to qualify for that exemption.
- Treatment of existing possessory interests: The author has indicated that they do not intend to modify any possessory interest in existing improvements to which port tenants may already be subject. This bill, however, would exempt a more intensive use of this property. This bill acknowledges that existing uses constitute a possessory interest, but that certain further uses do not. It could be considered as incongruent that a base possessory interest would exist, but that higher uses of that land would not trigger a use or possession that constitutes a possessory interest.
In property tax law, properties that are put to similar uses tend to be subject to similar treatment. This bill would provide that certain types of improvements, such as refueling stations, would not constitute a possessory interest. If that use is narrowed to servicing fully automated cargo handling equipment, however, then a taxable possessory interest occurs. This provision may counter the application of sound property tax law, which endeavors to provide consistent, uniform assessment of properties.
- Administrative issues: A nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement would not be subject to property taxation under this bill. Yet, this bill does not specify the entity to make the determination that an improvement is not for the primary purpose of generating revenue. Would assessors be responsible for making that determination? Would the owners of that property self-attest to that fact? It is unclear, and the author and Committee may wish to consider providing specificity.
Fully automated cargo handling equipment would be a use of the nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements that would disqualify property from this bill's exclusion. While this provision is ostensibly included to protect dock workers from losing employment, it is unclear how this provision would be administered. How would an assessor know when an ineligible use of that improvement occurred to appropriately correct the roll? Would the assessor need to assign staff to monitor the property? The author and Committee may wish to address how this provision is to be administered.
- Alternative solution: It appears this bill is attempting to achieve a similar objective to the existing exclusion from the definition of new construction for an active solar energy system, as specified. That exclusion is intended, as is this bill, to reduce the cost of improving property to address environmental impacts and remove the disincentive created from higher taxes when improving property. That exclusion, however, is explicitly authorized in the Constitution. As noted previously, no such consideration is given by the Constitution to a nonrevenue-generating environmental improvement at a port. The author and Committee may wish to consider whether this bill would be best implemented through a constitutional amendment excluding nonrevenue-generating environmental improvements from the definition of new construction.
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, United States Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each of them (in the form of forgone revenues). This bill would provide that certain taxable possessory interests do not exist, thereby creating a tax expenditure and subjecting this bill to this Committee's policy on tax expenditures.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added R&TC Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. AB 263 (Burke), Chapter 743, Statutes of 2019, extended the requirements in R&TC Section 41 to all tax expenditure measures under the Personal Income Tax Law, the Corporation Tax Law, and the Sales and Use Tax Law introduced on or after January 1, 2020. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. While these statutory requirements do not apply to property tax law, this Committee has consistently subjected property tax expenditures to the general treatment of tax expenditures. In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote[1]. Sunsets are required because eliminating a tax expenditure generally requires a 2/3rd vote. These requirements must be satisfied before a bill can receive a vote in this Committee. This bill does contain an appropriate five-year sunset, but does not include provisions complying with the requirements of R&TC Section 41.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Pacific Merchant Shipping Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Harrison Bowlby / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
An "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean 10 years. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):