SB 40: State Bar of California.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-10
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-10: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Under existing law, the officers of the State Bar are a chair, a vice chair, and a secretary. Existing law requires the chair to preside at all meetings of the State Bar and of the board, and requires the vice chair to preside at those meetings in the event of the chairs absence or inability to act. Existing law authorizes the board to prescribe additional duties of the chair and the vice chair and to prescribe the duties of the secretary. Existing law sets the length of the terms of the chair and the vice chair at one year, and requires them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their appointment.
This bill instead would extend the length of those terms up to 2 years, and would require them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the September meeting following their appointment.
This bill would require the board to appoint an executive director of the State Bar, who would be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board, and to appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline, as specified. The bill would set the length of the term for those appointments at 4 years, and would authorize reappointment for additional 4-year terms. The bill would require the State Bar to notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of those positions, and would make those appointments subject to confirmation by the Senate, as specified. The bill would limit the application of these provisions to persons appointed on or after January 1, 2024.
Existing law exempts the State Bar from laws restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified.
This bill would subject members of the board of trustees and employees of the State Bar to specified conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, which are generally applicable to public officers and employees. By expanding the scope of provisions, the violation of which would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a member of the board to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the board or a committee of the board in which the member has a financial interest, as defined, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Existing law makes an intentional violation of this requirement subject to specified criminal penalties. Existing law also requires a member to disqualify themself when there exists a personal nonfinancial interest that will prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under this bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to decisions in which a member has a financial interest, as described, would be expanded to include any decision of the State Bar. By expanding the scope of this requirement, an intentional violation of which is a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. Under the bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to a members personal interests would also be expanded to include any personal interests that may have that effect on the members making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under existing law, the State Civil Service Act, certain acts, including convictions of certain crimes, are cause for discipline of a state employee or of a person whose name appears on an employment list. Existing provisions of the Penal Code require the Attorney General to furnish state summary criminal history information to various entities, including an agency, officer, or official of the state if the information, among other things, is required to implement a statute or regulation that expressly refers to specific criminal conduct applicable to that person. Existing law authorizes the agency, officer, or official of the state to perform state and federal criminal history information checks, as provided. If a fingerprint-based criminal history information check is required pursuant to any statute, existing law requires the check to be requested from the Department of Justice and requires the applicable agency or entity to submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice, as specified. Existing law requires the Department of Justice to provide a state or federal response or a fitness determination, as appropriate, to the agency or entity, as specified.
This bill would revise and recast these provisions, as applicable to the State Bar, within the State Bar Act. In this regard, the bill would require the State Bar to require all employees and prospective employees to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check. The bill would authorize the State Bar to impose this requirement on volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors.
This bill would also revise and recast similar provisions of the State Bar Act relating to applicants for admission or reinstatement and licensees. In this regard, the bill would require an applicant for admission or reinstatement to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in addition to the Department of Justice, in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
Existing law states legislative intent and findings regarding diversity and inclusion in the practice of law. Existing law requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet specified goals and to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 2019, and every 2 years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, as prescribed.
This bill would change the date for the submission of the report to March 30 every 2 years.
Existing law authorizes the State Bar Court to order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation under specified circumstances and requires the State Bar Court to terminate such an enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first.
This bill would require the State Bar Court to terminate enrollment upon expiration of that described period or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
Existing law provides for the creation of an examining committee within the State Bar with varied responsibilities relating to examinations and other requirements for admission to the practice of law, including, among others, registration of law students, receiving applications for the general bar examination, and collecting fees fixed by the board and paid by applicants to defray the expense of administering existing law relating to admission to practice.
This bill would, with respect to these specified responsibilities, replace the examining committee with the State Bar. The bill would make related conforming changes. The bill would delete obsolete provisions relating to passing the law students examination.
Existing law requires an applicant for admission and licensure to practice law to meet certain requirements, including passing a general bar examination. Existing law gives an unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after they have taken any examination and within 4 months after results have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers.
This bill would delete those inspection provisions and, instead, would require that an applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, including the ability to download, save, and print.
Existing law, except as specified, requires hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, following a notice to show cause.
This bill would, instead, require those proceedings to be public following the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
Existing law requires disciplinary investigations of licensees to be confidential until formal charges are filed, and requires investigations of certain related matters to be confidential until the formal proceeding is instituted. Existing law authorizes waiver of that confidentiality requirement by specified entities under specified circumstances, including by the Chief Trial Counsel or the chair of the board when warranted for the protection of the public.
This bill would revise the circumstances under which the confidentiality of those investigations may be waived. In this regard, the bill would additionally authorize the board to vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The bill would require the board to hold a meeting under these provisions in closed session and to provide notice to a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure. The bill, for the boards assessment whether to waive confidentiality, would establish a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality and establish specified considerations. The bill would provide for related public announcements by the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar and for prior notice of such announcements to the licensee. The bill would authorize a licensee to file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to the waiver. The bill would require the State Bar Court to rule on the motion within 10 court days of the filing.
This bill would also restrict the Chief Trial Counsels and the chair of the boards authority to waive confidentiality of disciplinary investigation. In this regard, the bill would require the Chief Trial Counsel to exercise the authority with the written concurrence of the chair, and would require a determination that disclosure is needed to prevent an immediate harm to the public, as specified, and that the above-described provisions relating to the boards authority to waive confidentiality are inadequate for the protection of the public.
This bill, beginning January 1, 2025, would prohibit the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private reprovals to an attorney accused of misconduct. The bill, by April 1, 2024, would require the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, to provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Existing law requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection, as prescribed.
This bill would change the deadline for that report to November 30 of each year.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill would require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in or has engaged in seditious conspiracy, treason, rebellion, or insurrection, as specified. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement these reporting provisions.
Existing law relating to suspension or disbarment of an attorney requires a court that finds after prescribed proceedings that a crime of which an attorney was convicted or the circumstances of its commission involved moral turpitude, to enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case, or to otherwise dismiss the proceedings.
This bill, in lieu of the alternative of dismissing the proceedings, would require a court to determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee for active licensees for 2023 of up to $390, or of up to $386 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022. Existing law requires the board to charge an annual license fee for inactive licensees of up to $97.40, or of up to $96.40 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390 for active licensees for 2024, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above. The bill, beginning January 1, 2024, would require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above.
Existing law generally requires the State Bar to hold the net proceeds from the sale of real property, as described, without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. Existing law, as an exception to that provision, authorizes up to 10% of the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to be used for improvement of the State Bars discipline system, as specified.
This bill would revise that exception to instead authorize the State Bar to use the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to cover employee salaries and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of active licensees, registered foreign legal consultants, and certain other attorneys, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Existing law requires reimbursement of the fund by an attorney whose actions have caused payment from the fund and provides for collection, as specified.
This bill would further provide that the licensees obligation to reimburse the fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. The bill would also provide that the reimbursement provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the board to increase the annual license fee for active licensees by up to $40 and the annual license fee for inactive licensees by up to $10 for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, as specified.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer an Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, as prescribed, to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety.
Existing law requires moneys for the support of the program, treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs to be paid in whole or part by an annual fee of $10 per active licensee and annual fee of $5 per inactive licensee. Existing law authorizes the board to seek alternative sources for funding the program. Existing law authorizes the transfer of any excess funds not needed to support the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, including reserve funds, to the Client Security Fund if there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish a committee to oversee the operation of the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program with membership and responsibilities as prescribed. Existing law requires the committee to report to the board and to the Legislature annually on March 1 on the implementation and operation of the program, as specified.
This bill would delete that committee report requirement.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.
This bill would require the State Bar to prepare a report on how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fees for active and inactive licensees. The bill would require the report to include, among other things, the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional funding, as specified. The bill would also require the State Bar to provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to submit these reports no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would make findings and declarations relating to the intent of the Legislature to work on issues relating to client trust accounts.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Under existing law, the officers of the State Bar are a chair, a vice chair, and a secretary. Existing law requires the chair to preside at all meetings of the State Bar and of the board, and requires the vice chair to preside at those meetings in the event of the chairs absence or inability to act. Existing law authorizes the board to prescribe additional duties of the chair and the vice chair and to prescribe the duties of the secretary. Existing law sets the length of the terms of the chair and the vice chair at one year, and requires them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their appointment.
This bill instead would extend the length of those terms up to 2 years, and would require them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the September meeting following their appointment.
This bill would require the board to appoint an executive director of the State Bar, who would be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board, and to appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline, as specified. The bill would set the length of the term for those appointments at 4 years, and would authorize reappointment for additional 4-year terms. The bill would require the State Bar to notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of those positions, and would make those appointments subject to confirmation by the Senate, as specified. The bill would limit the application of these provisions to persons appointed on or after January 1, 2024.
Existing law exempts the State Bar from laws restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified.
This bill would subject members of the board of trustees and employees of the State Bar to specified conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, which are generally applicable to public officers and employees. By expanding the scope of provisions, the violation of which would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a member of the board to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the board or a committee of the board in which the member has a financial interest, as defined, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Existing law makes an intentional violation of this requirement subject to specified criminal penalties. Existing law also requires a member to disqualify themself when there exists a personal nonfinancial interest that will prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under this bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to decisions in which a member has a financial interest, as described, would be expanded to include any decision of the State Bar. By expanding the scope of this requirement, an intentional violation of which is a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. Under the bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to a members personal interests would also be expanded to include any personal interests that may have that effect on the members making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under existing law, the State Civil Service Act, certain acts, including convictions of certain crimes, are cause for discipline of a state employee or of a person whose name appears on an employment list. Existing provisions of the Penal Code require the Attorney General to furnish state summary criminal history information to various entities, including an agency, officer, or official of the state if the information, among other things, is required to implement a statute or regulation that expressly refers to specific criminal conduct applicable to that person. Existing law authorizes the agency, officer, or official of the state to perform state and federal criminal history information checks, as provided. If a fingerprint-based criminal history information check is required pursuant to any statute, existing law requires the check to be requested from the Department of Justice and requires the applicable agency or entity to submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice, as specified. Existing law requires the Department of Justice to provide a state or federal response or a fitness determination, as appropriate, to the agency or entity, as specified.
This bill would revise and recast these provisions, as applicable to the State Bar, within the State Bar Act. In this regard, the bill would require the State Bar to require all employees and prospective employees to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check. The bill would authorize the State Bar to impose this requirement on volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors.
This bill would also revise and recast similar provisions of the State Bar Act relating to applicants for admission or reinstatement and licensees. In this regard, the bill would require an applicant for admission or reinstatement to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in addition to the Department of Justice, in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
Existing law states legislative intent and findings regarding diversity and inclusion in the practice of law. Existing law requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet specified goals and to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 2019, and every 2 years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, as prescribed.
This bill would change the date for the submission of the report to March 30 every 2 years.
Existing law authorizes the State Bar Court to order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation under specified circumstances and requires the State Bar Court to terminate such an enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first.
This bill would require the State Bar Court to terminate enrollment upon expiration of that described period or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
Existing law provides for the creation of an examining committee within the State Bar with varied responsibilities relating to examinations and other requirements for admission to the practice of law, including, among others, registration of law students, receiving applications for the general bar examination, and collecting fees fixed by the board and paid by applicants to defray the expense of administering existing law relating to admission to practice.
This bill would, with respect to these specified responsibilities, replace the examining committee with the State Bar. The bill would make related conforming changes. The bill would delete obsolete provisions relating to passing the law students examination.
Existing law requires an applicant for admission and licensure to practice law to meet certain requirements, including passing a general bar examination. Existing law gives an unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after they have taken any examination and within 4 months after results have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers.
This bill would delete those inspection provisions and, instead, would require that an applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, including the ability to download, save, and print.
Existing law, except as specified, requires hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, following a notice to show cause.
This bill would, instead, require those proceedings to be public following the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
Existing law requires disciplinary investigations of licensees to be confidential until formal charges are filed, and requires investigations of certain related matters to be confidential until the formal proceeding is instituted. Existing law authorizes waiver of that confidentiality requirement by specified entities under specified circumstances, including by the Chief Trial Counsel or the chair of the board when warranted for the protection of the public.
This bill would revise the circumstances under which the confidentiality of those investigations may be waived. In this regard, the bill would additionally authorize the board to vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The bill would require the board to hold a meeting under these provisions in closed session and to provide notice to a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure. The bill, for the boards assessment whether to waive confidentiality, would establish a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality and establish specified considerations. The bill would provide for related public announcements by the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar and for prior notice of such announcements to the licensee. The bill would authorize a licensee to file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to the waiver. The bill would require the State Bar Court to rule on the motion within 10 court days of the filing.
This bill would also restrict the Chief Trial Counsels and the chair of the boards authority to waive confidentiality of disciplinary investigation. In this regard, the bill would require the Chief Trial Counsel to exercise the authority with the written concurrence of the chair, and would require a determination that disclosure is needed to prevent an immediate harm to the public, as specified, and that the above-described provisions relating to the boards authority to waive confidentiality are inadequate for the protection of the public.
This bill, beginning January 1, 2025, would prohibit the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private reprovals to an attorney accused of misconduct. The bill, by April 1, 2024, would require the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, to provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Existing law requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection, as prescribed.
This bill would change the deadline for that report to November 30 of each year.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill would require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in or has engaged in seditious conspiracy, treason, rebellion, or insurrection, as specified. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement these reporting provisions.
Existing law relating to suspension or disbarment of an attorney requires a court that finds after prescribed proceedings that a crime of which an attorney was convicted or the circumstances of its commission involved moral turpitude, to enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case, or to otherwise dismiss the proceedings.
This bill, in lieu of the alternative of dismissing the proceedings, would require a court to determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee for active licensees for 2023 of up to $390, or of up to $386 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022. Existing law requires the board to charge an annual license fee for inactive licensees of up to $97.40, or of up to $96.40 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390 for active licensees for 2024, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above. The bill, beginning January 1, 2024, would require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above.
Existing law generally requires the State Bar to hold the net proceeds from the sale of real property, as described, without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. Existing law, as an exception to that provision, authorizes up to 10% of the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to be used for improvement of the State Bars discipline system, as specified.
This bill would revise that exception to instead authorize the State Bar to use the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to cover employee salaries and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of active licensees, registered foreign legal consultants, and certain other attorneys, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Existing law requires reimbursement of the fund by an attorney whose actions have caused payment from the fund and provides for collection, as specified.
This bill would further provide that the licensees obligation to reimburse the fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. The bill would also provide that the reimbursement provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the board to increase the annual license fee for active licensees by up to $40 and the annual license fee for inactive licensees by up to $10 for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, as specified.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer an Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, as prescribed, to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety.
Existing law requires moneys for the support of the program, treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs to be paid in whole or part by an annual fee of $10 per active licensee and annual fee of $5 per inactive licensee. Existing law authorizes the board to seek alternative sources for funding the program. Existing law authorizes the transfer of any excess funds not needed to support the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, including reserve funds, to the Client Security Fund if there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish a committee to oversee the operation of the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program with membership and responsibilities as prescribed. Existing law requires the committee to report to the board and to the Legislature annually on March 1 on the implementation and operation of the program, as specified.
This bill would delete that committee report requirement.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.
This bill would require the State Bar to prepare a report on how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fees for active and inactive licensees. The bill would require the report to include, among other things, the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional funding, as specified. The bill would also require the State Bar to provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to submit these reports no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would make findings and declarations relating to the intent of the Legislature to work on issues relating to client trust accounts.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Under existing law, the officers of the State Bar are a chair, a vice chair, and a secretary. Existing law requires the chair to preside at all meetings of the State Bar and of the board, and requires the vice chair to preside at those meetings in the event of the chairs absence or inability to act. Existing law authorizes the board to prescribe additional duties of the chair and the vice chair and to prescribe the duties of the secretary. Existing law sets the length of the terms of the chair and the vice chair at one year, and requires them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their appointment.
This bill instead would extend the length of those terms up to 2 years, and would require them to assume the duties of their office at the conclusion of the September meeting following their appointment.
This bill would require the board to appoint an executive director of the State Bar to assist the board in carrying out its executive functions of the State Bar Bar, who would be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board, and to appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline, as specified. The bill would set the length of the term for those appointments at 4 years, and would authorize reappointment for additional 4-year terms. The bill would require the State Bar to notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of those positions, and would make those appointments subject to confirmation by the Senate, as specified. The bill would limit the application of these provisions to persons appointed on or after January 1, 2024.
Existing law exempts the State Bar from laws restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified.
This bill would subject members of the board of trustees and employees of the State Bar to specified conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, which are generally applicable to public officers and employees. By expanding the scope of provisions, the violation of which would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a member of the board to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the board or a committee of the board in which the member has a financial interest, as defined, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Existing law makes an intentional violation of this requirement subject to specified criminal penalties. Existing law also requires a member to disqualify themself when there exists a personal nonfinancial interest that will prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under this bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to decisions in which a member has a financial interest, as described, would be expanded to include any decision of the State Bar. By expanding the scope of this requirement, an intentional violation of which is a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. Under the bill, the scope of the disqualification requirement relating to a members personal interests would also be expanded to include any personal interests that may have that effect on the members making or participating in the making of decisions.
Under existing law, the State Civil Service Act, certain acts, including convictions of certain crimes, are cause for discipline of a state employee or of a person whose name appears on an employment list. Existing provisions of the Penal Code require the Attorney General to furnish state summary criminal history information to various entities, including an agency, officer, or official of the state if the information, among other things, is required to implement a statute or regulation that expressly refers to specific criminal conduct applicable to that person. Existing law authorizes the agency, officer, or official of the state to perform state and federal criminal history information checks, as provided. If a fingerprint-based criminal history information check is required pursuant to any statute, existing law requires the check to be requested from the Department of Justice and requires the applicable agency or entity to submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice, as specified. Existing law requires the Department of Justice to provide a state or federal response or a fitness determination, as appropriate, to the agency or entity, as specified.
This bill would revise and recast these provisions, as applicable to the State Bar, within the State Bar Act. In this regard, the bill would require the State Bar to require all employees and prospective employees to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check. The bill would authorize the State Bar to impose this requirement on volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors.
This bill would also revise and recast similar provisions of the State Bar Act relating to applicants for admission or reinstatement and licensees. In this regard, the bill would require an applicant for admission or reinstatement to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in addition to the Department of Justice, in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
Existing law states legislative intent and findings regarding diversity and inclusion in the practice of law. Existing law requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet specified goals and to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 2019, and every 2 years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, as prescribed.
This bill would change the date for the submission of the report to March 30 every 2 years.
Existing law authorizes the State Bar Court to order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation under specified circumstances and requires the State Bar Court to terminate such an enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first.
This bill would require the State Bar Court to terminate enrollment upon expiration of that described period or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
Existing law provides for the creation of an examining committee within the State Bar with varied responsibilities relating to examinations and other requirements for admission to the practice of law, including, among others: giving 2 years notice of certain changes to the bar examination; approving preparatory studies that precede the study of law and the study of law; others, registration of law students; prescribing examinations in professional responsibility or legal ethics; students, receiving applications for and giving the general bar examination; administering a law students examination to subject law students after their first year of law study; certifying to the California Supreme Court that an applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law; examination, and collecting fees fixed by the board and paid by applicants to defray the expense of administering existing law relating to admission to practice.
This bill would would, with respect to these specified responsibilities responsibilities, replace the examining committee with the State Bar. The bill would make related conforming changes. The bill would delete obsolete provisions relating to passing the law students examination.
Existing law requires an applicant for admission and licensure to practice law to meet certain requirements, including passing a general bar examination. Existing law gives an unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after they have taken any examination and within 4 months after results have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers.
This bill would delete those inspection provisions and, instead, would require that an applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, including the ability to download, save, and print.
Existing law, except as specified, requires hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, following a notice to show cause. Existing law excepts disciplinary investigations from that requirement and makes them confidential, as prescribed.
This bill would, instead, require those proceedings to be public following the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
Existing law requires disciplinary investigations of licensees to be confidential until formal charges are filed, and requires investigations of certain related matters to be confidential until the formal proceeding is instituted. Existing law authorizes waiver of that confidentiality requirement by specified entities under specified exceptions. circumstances, including by the Chief Trial Counsel or the chair of the board when warranted for the protection of the public.
This bill would revise the existing exceptions under which confidentiality may be waived. The the circumstances under which the confidentiality of those investigations may be waived. In this regard, the bill would additionally authorize the board, notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, board to vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The bill would require the board to hold a meeting under these provisions in closed session and to provide notice to a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure. The bill, for the boards assessment whether to waive confidentiality, would establish a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality and establish specified considerations. The bill would provide for related public announcements by the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar and for prior notice of such announcements to the licensee. The bill would authorize a licensee to file a motion, to be heard within 10 days of filing, motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to the waiver. The bill would require the State Bar Court to rule on the motion within 10 court days of the filing.
This bill would also restrict the Chief Trial Counsels and the chair of the boards authority to waive confidentiality of disciplinary investigation. In this regard, the bill would require the Chief Trial Counsel to exercise the authority with the written concurrence of the chair, and would require a determination that disclosure is needed to prevent an immediate harm to the public, as specified, and that the above-described provisions relating to the boards authority to waive confidentiality are inadequate for the protection of the public.
This bill, beginning January 1, 2025, would prohibit the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private letters of reprisal reprovals to an attorney accused of misconduct. The bill, by April 1, 2024, would require the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, to provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Existing law requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection, as prescribed.
This bill would change the deadline for that report to November 30 of each year.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill would require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, in or has engaged in, in seditious conspiracy, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. rebellion, or insurrection, as specified. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement these reporting provisions.
Existing law relating to suspension or disbarment of an attorney requires a court that finds after prescribed proceedings that a crime of which an attorney was convicted or the circumstances of its commission involved moral turpitude, to enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case, or to otherwise dismiss the proceedings.
This bill, in lieu of the alternative of dismissing the proceedings, would require a court to determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee for active licensees for 2023 of up to $390, or of up to $386 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022. Existing law requires the board to charge an annual license fee for inactive licensees of up to $97.40, or of up to $96.40 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390 for active licensees for 2024, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above. The bill, beginning January 1, 2024, would require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above.
Existing law generally requires the State Bar to hold the net proceeds from the sale of real property, as described, without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. Existing law, as an exception to that provision, authorizes up to 10% of the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to be used for improvement of the State Bars discipline system, as specified.
This bill would revise that exception to instead authorize the State Bar to use the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to cover employee salaries and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of active licensees, registered foreign legal consultants, and certain other attorneys, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Existing law requires reimbursement of the fund by an attorney whose actions have caused payment from the fund and provides for collection, as specified.
This bill would further provide that the licensees obligation to reimburse the fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. The bill would also provide that the reimbursement provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.Existing law authorizes the board to increase the annual license fee for active licensees by up to $40 and the annual license fee for inactive licensees by up to $10 for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, as specified.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer an Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, as prescribed, to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety. Existing
Existing law requires moneys for the support of the program, treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs to be paid in whole or part by an annual fee of $10 per active licensee and annual fee of $5 per inactive licensee. Existing law authorizes the board to seek alternative sources for funding the program. Existing law authorizes the transfer of any excess funds not needed to support the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, including reserve funds, to the Client Security Fund if there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would authorize the board to disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund. The bill would require funds that are disbursed or transferred pursuant to that authority to first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
Existing law requires the board to establish a committee to oversee the operation of the program, Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program with membership and responsibilities as prescribed. Existing law requires the committee to report to the board and to the Legislature annually on March 1 on the implementation and operation of the program, as specified.
This bill would delete that committee report requirement.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.
This bill would require the State Bar to prepare a report on how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fees for active and inactive licensees. The bill would require the report to include, among other things, the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional funding, as specified. The bill would also require the State Bar to provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to submit these reports no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would make findings and declarations relating to the intent of the Legislature to work on issues relating to client trust accounts.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Under existing law, the officers of the State Bar are a chair, a vice chair, and a secretary. Existing law requires the chair to preside at all meetings of the State Bar and of the board, and requires the vice chair to preside at those meetings in the event of the chairs absence or inability to act. Existing law authorizes the board to prescribe additional duties of the chair and the vice chair and to prescribe the duties of the secretary.
This bill would require the board to appoint an executive director of the State Bar to assist the board in carrying out its executive functions of the State Bar and to appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline, as specified. The bill would set the length of the term for those appointments at 4 years, and would authorize reappointment for additional 4-year terms. The bill would require the State Bar to notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of those positions, and would make those appointments subject to confirmation by the Senate, as specified. The bill would limit the application of these provisions to persons appointed on or after January 1, 2024.
Existing law states legislative intent and findings regarding diversity and inclusion in the practice of law. Existing law requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet specified goals and to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 2019, and every 2 years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, as prescribed.
This bill would change the date for the submission of the report to March 30 every 2 years.
Existing law authorizes the State Bar Court to order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation under specified circumstances and requires the State Bar Court to terminate such an enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first.
This bill would require the State Bar Court to terminate enrollment upon expiration of that described period or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
Existing law provides for the creation of an examining committee within the State Bar with varied responsibilities relating to examinations and other requirements for admission to the practice of law, including, among others: giving 2 years notice of certain changes to the bar examination; approving preparatory studies that precede the study of law and the study of law; registration of law students; prescribing examinations in professional responsibility or legal ethics; receiving applications for and giving the general bar examination; administering a law students examination to subject law students after their first year of law study; certifying to the California Supreme Court that an applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law; and collecting fees fixed by the board to defray the expense of administering existing law relating to admission to practice.
This bill would with respect to these specified responsibilities replace the examining committee with the State Bar. The bill would make related conforming changes. The bill would delete obsolete provisions relating to passing the law students examination.
Existing law requires an applicant for admission and licensure to practice law to meet certain requirements, including passing a general bar examination. Existing law gives an unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after they have taken any examination and within 4 months after results have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers.
This bill would delete those inspection provisions and, instead, would require that an applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, including the ability to download, save, and print.
Existing law, except as specified, requires hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, following a notice to show cause. Existing law excepts disciplinary investigations from that requirement and makes them confidential, as prescribed. Existing law authorizes waiver of that confidentiality requirement by specified entities under specified exceptions.
This bill would revise the existing exceptions under which confidentiality may be waived. The bill would additionally authorize the board, notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, to vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The bill would require the board to hold a meeting under these provisions in closed session and to provide notice to a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure. The bill, for the boards assessment whether to waive confidentiality, would establish a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality and establish specified considerations. The bill would provide for related public announcements by the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar and for prior notice of such announcements to the licensee. The bill would authorize a licensee to file a motion, to be heard within 10 days of filing, to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to the waiver.
This bill, beginning January 1, 2025, would prohibit the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private letters of reprisal to an attorney accused of misconduct. The bill, by April 1, 2024, would require the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, to provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Existing law requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection, as prescribed.
This bill would change the deadline for that report to November 30 of each year.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill would require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement these reporting provisions.
Existing law relating to suspension or disbarment of an attorney requires a court that finds after prescribed proceedings that a crime of which an attorney was convicted or the circumstances of its commission involved moral turpitude, to enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case, or to otherwise dismiss the proceedings.
This bill, in lieu of the alternative of dismissing the proceedings, would require a court to determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee for active licensees for 2023 of up to $390, or of up to $386 if certain conditions are met, for active licensees for 2023. the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022. Existing law, except as specified, law requires the board, on and after January 1, 2022, board to charge an annual license fee for inactive licensees of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees. Existing law, until January 1, 2023, requires that the inactive license fee be $1 lower $97.40, or of up to $96.40 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $391 $390 for active licensees for 2024. 2024, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above. The bill, until beginning January 1, 2024, would require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees. licensees, without the exception relating to the sale of the San Francisco office building described above.
Existing law generally requires the State Bar to hold the net proceeds from the sale of real property, as described, without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. Existing law, as an exception to that provision, authorizes up to 10% of the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to be used for improvement of the State Bars discipline system, as specified.
This bill would revise that exception to instead authorize the State Bar to use the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office to cover employee salaries and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of active licensees, registered foreign legal consultants, and certain other attorneys, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Existing law requires reimbursement of the fund by an attorney whose actions have caused payment from the fund and provides for collection, as specified.
This bill would further provide that the licensees obligation to reimburse the fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. The bill would also provide that the reimbursement provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer an Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, as prescribed, to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety. Existing law requires the board to establish a committee to oversee the operation of the program, with membership and responsibilities as prescribed. Existing law requires the committee to report to the board and to the Legislature annually on March 1 on the implementation and operation of the program, as specified.
This bill would delete that committee report requirement.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing
Existing law states legislative intent and findings regarding diversity and inclusion in the practice of law. Existing law requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet specified goals and to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 2019, and every 2 years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, as prescribed.
This bill would change the date for the submission of the report to March 30 every 2 years.
Existing law authorizes the State Bar Court to order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation under specified circumstances and requires the State Bar Court to terminate such an enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first.
This bill would require the State Bar Court to terminate enrollment upon expiration of that described period or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
Existing law provides for the creation of an examining committee within the State Bar with varied responsibilities relating to examinations and other requirements for admission to the practice of law, including, among others: giving 2 years notice of certain changes to the bar examination; approving preparatory studies that precede the study of law and the study of law; registration of law students; prescribing examinations in professional responsibility or legal ethics; receiving applications for and giving the general bar examination; administering a law students examination to subject law students after their first year of law study; certifying to the California Supreme Court that an applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law; and collecting fees fixed by the board to defray the expense of administering existing law relating to admission to practice.
This bill would with respect to these specified responsibilities replace the examining committee with the State Bar. The bill would make related conforming changes. The bill would delete obsolete provisions relating to passing the law students examination.
Existing law requires an applicant for admission and licensure to practice law to meet certain requirements, including passing a general bar examination. Existing law gives an unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after they have taken any examination and within 4 months after results have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers.
This bill would delete those inspection provisions and, instead, would require that an applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, including the ability to download, save, and print.
Existing law, except as specified, requires hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, following a notice to show cause. Existing law excepts disciplinary investigations from that requirement and makes them confidential, as prescribed. Existing law authorizes waiver of that confidentiality requirement by specified entities under specified exceptions.
This bill would revise the existing exceptions under which confidentiality may be waived. The bill would additionally authorize the board, notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, to vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The bill would require the board to hold a meeting under these provisions in closed session and to provide notice to a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure. The bill, for the boards assessment whether to waive confidentiality, would establish a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality and establish specified considerations. The bill would provide for related public announcements by the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar and for prior notice of such announcements to the licensee. The bill would authorize a licensee to file a motion, to be heard within 10 days of filing, to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to the waiver.
Existing law requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection, as prescribed.
This bill would change the deadline for that report to November 30 of each year.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill would require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement these reporting provisions.
Existing law relating to suspension or disbarment of an attorney requires a court that finds after prescribed proceedings that a crime of which an attorney was convicted or the circumstances of its commission involved moral turpitude, to enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case, or to otherwise dismiss the proceedings.
This bill, in lieu of the alternative of dismissing the proceedings, would require a court to determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390, or $386 if certain conditions are met, for active licensees for 2023. Existing law, except as specified, requires the board, on and after January 1, 2022, to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees. Existing law, until January 1, 2023, requires that the inactive license fee be $1 lower if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to an unspecified amount $391 for active licensees for 2024. The bill, until January 1, 2024, would require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $97.40 for inactive licensees.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek certain agreements, including agreements that misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported or that a complainant shall withdraw a disciplinary complaint or shall not cooperate with the investigation or prosecution conducted by the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.This bill, except as specified, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows, as defined, that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, to inform the State Bar. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would also require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement the bill.Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of active licensees, registered foreign legal consultants, and certain other attorneys, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Existing law requires reimbursement of the fund by an attorney whose actions have caused payment from the fund and provides for collection, as specified.
This bill would further provide that the licensees obligation to reimburse the fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. The bill would also provide that the reimbursement provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Existing law requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with specified experience for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. Existing law requires that a copy of the audit and financial statement be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
This bill would require that submission annually on or before May 31.
Existing law requires the board to establish and administer an Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program, as prescribed, to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety. Existing law requires the board to establish a committee to oversee the operation of the program, with membership and responsibilities as prescribed. Existing law requires the committee to report to the board and to the Legislature annually on March 1 on the implementation and operation of the program, as specified.
This bill would delete that committee report requirement.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390, or $386 if certain conditions are met, for active licensees for 2023.
This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to an unspecified amount for active licensees for 2024.
Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek certain agreements, including agreements that misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported or that a complainant shall withdraw a disciplinary complaint or shall not cooperate with the investigation or prosecution conducted by the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill, except as specified, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows, as defined, that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, to inform the State Bar. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would also require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement the bill.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law, until January 1, 2024, requires the board to charge an annual license fee of up to $390, or $386 if certain conditions are met, for active licensees for 2023.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to the regulation of the State Bar.This bill, until January 1, 2025, would, instead, require the board to charge an annual license fee of up to an unspecified amount for active licensees for 2024.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to the regulation of the State Bar.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The arrest of and ongoing scandals surrounding disgraced former attorney Tom Girardi exposed that the State Bar of Californias existing tools for overseeing attorneys client trust accounts are inadequate and expose everyday Californians to the risk of fraud.
(b)Presently, the State Bar of California estimates that over $14,000,000,000 of clients funds are currently being held on deposit in more than 59,000 attorney client trust accounts.
(c)In the coming year the Legislature intends to work with all stakeholders, including the State Bar of California, financial institutions, and legal organizations, to craft a structure for regulating client trust accounts that minimizes the risk of financial fraud while protecting the consumer and privacy interests of clients and account holders.
SEC. 2.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.(a)The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
(b)The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(1)Make contracts.
(2)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes, and debentures, and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(3)Own, hold, use, manage, and deal in and with real and personal property.
(4)Construct, alter, maintain, and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(5)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise, or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(6)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, or dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from license fees paid or payable by licensees.
(7)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
(c)Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivision (b), it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of March 31, 2018, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
(d)The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its licensees in the annual fees statement and other appropriate communications, including its internet website and electronic communications, that its licensees have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a licensee may exercise the licensees right to prohibit or restrict, at the licensees option, the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that licensees can appropriately limit the use of their licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of licensees choosing to utilize these procedures.
(e)(1)No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, members of the board of trustees of the State Bar and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts in Sections 1090 to 1097.2, inclusive, set forth in Article 4 of Chapter 1 of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
SEC. 3.Section 6001.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.3.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the State Bar maintain its commitment to and support of effective policies and activities to enhance access, fairness, and diversity in the legal profession and the elimination of bias in the practice of law.
(b)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The rich diversity of the people of California requires a justice system that is equally accessible and free of bias and is a core value of the legal profession.
(2)Diversity and inclusion are an integral part of the State Bars public protection mission to build, retain, and maintain a diverse legal profession to provide quality and culturally sensitive services to an ever-increasing diverse population.
(3)Diversity increases public trust and confidence and the appearance of fairness in the justice system and therefore increases access to justice.
(4)The State Bar should continue to increase diversity and inclusion in the legal profession.
(c)The State Bar shall develop and implement a plan to meet the goals set forth in this section, which may include, but is not limited to, an assessment of needed revenue. The State Bar shall prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 30, 2019, and every two years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, including a description of activities undertaken to support the plan, their outcomes, and their effectiveness.
SEC. 4.Section 6001.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6001.5.(a)The State Bar of California shall require that all employees and prospective employees, and may require volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
(b)The State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all employees, prospective employees, volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
SEC. 5.Section 6007 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6007.(a)When a licensee requires involuntary treatment pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of, or Part 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or when under an order pursuant to Section 3051, 3106.5, or 3152 of the Welfare and Institutions Code they have been placed in or returned to inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or when they have been determined insane or mentally incompetent and is confined for treatment or placed on outpatient status pursuant to the Penal Code, or on account of their mental condition a guardian or conservator, for their estate or person or both, has been appointed, the Board of Trustees or an officer of the State Bar shall enroll the licensee as an inactive licensee.
The clerk of any court making an order containing any of the determinations or adjudications referred to in the immediately preceding paragraph shall send a certified copy of that order to the State Bar at the same time that the order is entered.
The clerk of any court with which is filed a notice of certification for intensive treatment pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, upon receipt of the notice, shall transmit a certified copy of it to the State Bar.
The State Bar may procure a certified copy of any determination, order, adjudication, appointment, or notice when the clerk concerned has failed to transmit one or when the proceeding was had in a court other than a court of this state.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar shall terminate the enrollment when the licensee has had the fact of their restoration to capacity judicially determined, upon the licensees release from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches pursuant to Section 3053, 3109, or 3151 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or upon the licensees unconditional release from the medical facility pursuant to Section 5304 or 5305 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; and on payment of all fees required.
When a licensee is placed in, returned to, or released from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or discharged from the narcotics treatment program, the Director of Corrections or their designee shall transmit to the State Bar a certified notice attesting to that fact.
(b)The State Bar Court shall also enroll a licensee of the State Bar as an inactive licensee in each of the following cases:
(1)A licensee asserts a claim of insanity or mental incompetence in any pending action or proceeding, alleging their inability to understand the nature of the action or proceeding or inability to assist counsel in representation of the licensee.
(2)The court makes an order assuming jurisdiction over the licensees law practice, pursuant to Section 6180.5 or 6190.34.
(3)After notice and opportunity to be heard before the State Bar Court, the State Bar Court finds that the licensee, because of mental infirmity or illness, or because of the habitual use of intoxicants or drugs, is (i) unable or habitually fails to perform their duties or undertakings competently, or (ii) unable to practice law without substantial threat of harm to the interests of their clients or the public. No proceeding pursuant to this paragraph shall be instituted unless the State Bar Court finds, after preliminary investigation, or during the course of a disciplinary proceeding, that probable cause exists therefor. The determination of probable cause is administrative in character and no notice or hearing is required.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the enrollment upon proof that the facts found as to the licensees disability no longer exist and on payment of all fees required.
(c)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon a finding based on all the available evidence, including affidavits, that the attorney has not complied with Section 6002.1 and cannot be located after reasonable investigation.
(2)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney if it finds, based on all the available evidence, including affidavits:
(A)The attorney has caused or is causing substantial harm to the attorneys clients or the public.
(B)There is a reasonable probability that the chief trial counsel will prevail on the merits of the underlying disciplinary matter, and that the attorney will be disbarred.
(3)In the case of an enrollment under paragraph (2), the underlying matter shall proceed on an expedited basis.
(4)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon the filing of a recommendation of disbarment after hearing or default. For purposes of this section, that attorney shall be placed on involuntary inactive enrollment regardless of the license status of the attorney at the time.
(5)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney who is sentenced to incarceration for 90 days or more as a result of a criminal conviction for at least the period of time in which the attorney is incarcerated.
(6)The State Bar Court shall order attorneys who are placed on inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision to comply with Rule 9.20 of the California Rules of Court.
(7)The board shall formulate and adopt rules of procedure to implement this subdivision.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment upon proof that the attorneys conduct no longer poses a substantial threat of harm to the interests of the attorneys clients or the public or where an attorney who could not be located proves compliance with Section 6002.1.
(d)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(A)The attorney is under a suspension order any portion of which has been stayed during a period of probation.
(B)The State Bar Court finds that probation has been violated.
(C)The State Bar Court recommends to the Supreme Court that the attorney receive an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate an enrollment under this subdivision upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
(3)If the Supreme Court orders a period of actual suspension in the probation matter, any period of involuntary inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited against the period of actual suspension ordered.
(e)(1)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary, inactive enrollment of a licensee whose default has been entered pursuant to the State Bar Rules of Procedure if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The notice was duly served pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 6002.1.
(B)The notice contained the following language at or near the beginning of the notice, in capital letters:
IF YOU FAIL TO FILE AN ANSWER TO THIS NOTICE WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED BY STATE BAR RULES, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS, OR IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE STATE BAR COURT TRIAL, (1) YOUR DEFAULT SHALL BE ENTERED, (2) YOU SHALL BE ENROLLED AS AN INVOLUNTARY INACTIVE LICENSEE OF THE STATE BAR AND WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PRACTICE LAW UNLESS THE DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE ON MOTION TIMELY MADE UNDER THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE STATE BAR, (3) YOU SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE FURTHER IN THESE PROCEEDINGS UNLESS YOUR DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE, AND (4) YOU SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL DISCIPLINE.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision when the licensees default is set aside on motion timely made under the State Bar Rules of Procedure or the disciplinary proceedings are completed.
(3)The enrollment under this subdivision is administrative in character and no hearing is required.
(4)Upon the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision, the notice required by subdivision (b) of Section 6092.5 shall be promptly given.
(f)The pendency or determination of a proceeding or investigation provided for by this section shall not abate or terminate a disciplinary investigation or proceeding except as required by the facts and law in a particular case.
(g)No license fees shall accrue against the licensee during the period they are enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to this section.
(h)The State Bar Court may order a full range of interim remedies or final discipline short of involuntary inactive enrollment, including, but not limited to, conditions of probation following final discipline, or directly ordered interim remedies, to restrict or supervise an attorneys practice of law, as well as proceedings under subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), or under Section 6102 or 6190. They may include restrictions as to scope of practice, monetary accounting procedures, review of performance by probation or other monitors appointed by the board, or such other measures as may be determined, after hearing, to protect present and future clients from likely substantial harm. These restrictions may be imposed upon a showing as provided in subdivision (c).
SEC. 6.Section 6011 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6011.(a)The board shall appoint an executive director of the State Bar, who shall be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as the executive director of the State Bar. The executive director shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The executive director shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The executive director shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of an executive director.
(c)The appointment of the executive director is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed as the executive director on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 7.Section 6012 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6012.(a)The board shall appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as general counsel of the State Bar. The general counsel shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The general counsel shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The general counsel shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of a general counsel.
(c)The appointment of the general counsel is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed general counsel on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 8.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)The selection of the chair and vice chair of the board shall be made by appointment of the Supreme Court.
(b)The chair and the vice chair shall each be appointed for a term not to exceed two years. The chair and vice chair shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the September meeting following their appointment. The chair and vice chair shall not serve more than two terms, except that a chair or vice chair who is appointed to fill a vacancy for the balance of a term is eligible to serve two full terms in addition to the remainder of the term for which they were appointed.
SEC. 9.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to any of the following:
(1)Appeals from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
(3)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of the California Bar Examination or the First-Year Law Students Examination.
(4)Matters related to the Committee of Bar Examiners consideration of moral character, including allegations of criminal or professional misconduct, competence, or physical or mental health of an individual, requests by applicants for testing accommodations in connection with an application for admission to practice law, or appeals of the Committee of Bar Examiners determinations.
(5)Information about a law schools operations that constitutes a trade secret as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code.
(6)Matters related to the boards consideration of waiving confidentiality related to records of disciplinary proceedings under subdivision (c) of Section 6086.1.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 11125.7 of the Government Code, the State Bar shall accept public comment in open session on all matters that are agendized for discussion or decision by the board of trustees, whether in an open or a closed session.
SEC. 10.Section 6036 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6036.(a)Any member of the board of trustees shall disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest, as that term is defined in Section 87103 of the Government Code, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision.
(b)Any member of the board of trustees shall likewise disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), no member shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the members participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made. The fact that a members vote is needed to break a tie does not make the members participation legally required for the purposes of this section.
(d)A member required to disqualify themself because of a conflict of interest shall (1)immediately disclose the interest, (2)withdraw from any participation in the matter, (3)refrain from attempting to influence another member, and (4)refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
(e)For purposes of this article and unless otherwise specified, member means any appointed or elected member of the board of trustees.
SEC. 11.Section 6037 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6037.No action or decision of the State Bar shall be invalid because of the participation therein by a member or members of the board of trustees in violation of Section 6036. However, any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 6036 is guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding five days, or by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both, and, if the member is an attorney member of the board, a certified copy of the record of conviction shall be transmitted to the Supreme Court for disposition as provided in Sections 6101 and 6102. Upon entry of final judgment of conviction, the members term of office on the board of trustees, and duties and authority incidental thereto, shall automatically terminate. Any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 6036 shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500) for each violation, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action in a court of competent jurisdiction brought in the name of the state only by a district attorney of a county in which the member resides or maintains offices and the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of that county.
SEC. 12.Section 6054 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6054.(a)State and local law enforcement and licensing bodies and departments, officers and employees thereof, and officials and attaches of the courts of this state shall cooperate with and give reasonable assistance and information, including the providing of state summary criminal history information and local summary criminal history information, to the State Bar of California or any authorized representative thereof, in connection with any investigation or proceeding within the jurisdiction of the State Bar of California, regarding the admission to the practice of law or discipline of attorneys or their reinstatement to the practice of law.
(b)The State Bar of California shall require that an applicant for admission or reinstatement to the practice of law in California, or may require a licensee, to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
(c)(1)Pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code, the State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all persons applying for admission to the State Bar of California for all applicants for reinstatement, and for licensees that are required to be fingerprinted under Rule 9.9.5 of the California Rules of Court, as it read on January 1, 2023. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
(2)As used in this subdivision, applicant for reinstatement means individuals initiating reinstatement proceedings with the State Bar after resignation with or without charges pending and after disbarment.
(d)The State Bar may use the information obtained from the Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation as a result of the fingerprinting of an applicant or licensee, and the State Bars use of that information shall be limited to the official use of the State Bar in establishing the identity of the applicant and in determining the character and fitness of the applicant for admission or reinstatement, and in discovering prior and subsequent criminal arrests of an applicant, licensee, or applicant for reinstatement. The State Bar shall notify the Department of Justice about individuals who are no longer licensees and applicants who are denied admission to the State Bar within 30 days of any change in status of a licensee or denial of admission. All fingerprint records of applicants admitted or licensees reinstated, or provided by a licensee, shall be retained thereafter by the Department of Justice for the limited purpose of criminal arrest notification to the State Bar.
(e)If required to be fingerprinted pursuant to this section, a licensee of the State Bar who fails to be fingerprinted may be enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to rules adopted by the board of trustees.
SEC. 13.Section 6060 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission and a license to practice law, a person who has not been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency or in a foreign country shall:
(a)Be at least 18 years of age.
(b)(1)Be of good moral character.
(2)(A)In reviewing whether an applicant is of good moral character under this subdivision, the staff of the State Bar or the members of the examining committee shall not review or consider the persons medical records relating to mental health, except
if the applicant seeks to use the record for either of the following purposes:
(i)To demonstrate that the applicant is of good moral character.
(ii)As a mitigating factor to explain a specific act of misconduct.
(B)The staff of the State Bar and members of the examining committee shall not request or seek to review any medical records relating to mental health, including by obtaining the consent of the applicant to disclose such records, except as requested by an applicant and for a purpose specified in subparagraph (A).
(c)Before beginning the study of law, have done either of the following:
(1)Completed at least two years of college work, which college work shall be at least one-half of the collegiate work acceptable for a bachelors degree granted on the basis of a four-year period of study by a college or university approved by the examining committee.
(2)Have attained in apparent intellectual ability the equivalent of at least two years of college work by taking examinations in subject matters and achieving the scores as are prescribed by the examining committee.
(d)Have registered with the State Bar as a law student within 90 days after beginning the study of law. The State Bar, upon a showing of good cause, may permit a later registration.
(e)Have done either of the following:
(1)Had conferred upon them a juris doctor (J.D.) degree or a bachelor of laws (LL.B.) degree by a law school accredited by the examining committee or approved by the American Bar Association.
(2)Studied law diligently and in good faith for at least four years in any of the following manners:
(A)(i)In a law school that is authorized or approved to confer professional degrees and requires classroom attendance of its students for a minimum of 270 hours a year.
(ii)A person who has received their legal education in a foreign state or country where the common law of England does not constitute the basis of jurisprudence shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the State Bar that the persons education, experience, and qualifications qualify them to take the examination.
(B)In a law office in this state and under the personal supervision of a licensee of the State Bar of California who is, and for at least the last five years continuously has been, engaged in the active practice of law. It is the duty of the supervising attorney to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(C)In the chambers and under the personal supervision of a judge of a court of record of this state. It is the duty of the supervising judge to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(D)By instruction in law from a correspondence law school authorized or approved to confer professional degrees by this state, which requires 864 hours of preparation and study per year for four years.
(E)By any combination of the methods referred to in this paragraph.
(f)Have passed any examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the examining committee may prescribe.
(g)Have passed the general bar examination given by the examining committee.
(h)(1)Have passed a law students examination administered by the examining committee after completion of their first year of law study. Those who pass the examination within its first three administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination, shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed. Those who do not pass the examination within the number of administrations allowed by this subdivision, upon becoming eligible to take the examination, but who subsequently pass the examination, shall receive credit for one year of legal study only.
(2)(A)This requirement does not apply to a student who has satisfactorily completed their first year of law study at a law school accredited by the examining committee and who has completed at least two years of college work prior to matriculating in the accredited law school, nor shall this requirement apply to an applicant who has passed the bar examination of a sister state or of a country in which the common law of England constitutes the basis of jurisprudence.
(B)The law students examination shall be administered twice a year at reasonable intervals.
SEC. 14.Section 6060.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.3.(a)An application to take the California bar examination administered in February must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding November, and an application to take the California bar examination administered in July must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding April. However, an applicant who was unsuccessful on the examination last administered shall be allowed 10 business days from the date of the general announcement of results of that examination in which to timely file an application to take the next scheduled examination.
(b)The State Bar may accept applications to take the California bar examination filed after the timely deadlines specified in subdivision (a) from applicants if the application is accompanied by the timely application fee and the late filing fee fixed by the board as follows:
(1)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the first and last business days in November for the February examination or between the first and last business days of April for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed fifty dollars ($50).
(2)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the last business day of November and January 1 for the February examination or between the last business day of April and June 1 for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(3)An application to take the California bar examination filed after January 1 for the February examination and after June 1 for the July examination shall not be accepted.
(c)Application fees for the California bar examination, including fees for late filing, shall be refunded if the applicant does not take the California bar examination because of the death of an immediate family member or the serious illness or disabling injury of the applicant or a member of their immediate family. A deduction may be made from the refund for administrative costs. The board shall adopt regulations for the administration of this subdivision. This subdivision shall not be construed to prohibit the refund of fees in instances other than those specified.
SEC. 15.Section 6063 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6063.Applicants for admission to practice shall pay such reasonable fees, fixed by the board, as may be necessary to defray the expense of administering the provisions of this chapter, relating to admission to practice. These fees shall be collected by the State Bar and paid into the treasury of the State Bar.
SEC. 16.Section 6065 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6065.Any applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, shall have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, which shall include the ability to download, save, and print.
SEC. 17.Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.1.(a)(1)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court shall be public, following the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
(2)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of the following matters shall be public:
(A)Filings for involuntary inactive enrollment or restriction under subdivision (a), (c), (d), or (e) of Section 6007.
(B)Petitions for reinstatement under Section 6078.
(C)Proceedings for suspension or disbarment under Section 6101 or 6102.
(D)Payment information from the Client Security Fund pursuant to Section 6140.5.
(E)Actions to cease a law practice or assume a law practice under Section 6180 or 6190.
(b)All disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time that formal charges are filed and all investigations of matters identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) are confidential until the formal proceeding identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) is instituted. These investigations shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). This confidentiality requirement may be waived under any of the following exceptions:
(1)The licensee whose conduct is being investigated or has been investigated consents to a public announcement or disclosure.
(2)(A)The Chief Trial Counsel, with the written concurrence of the chair of the board, may waive confidentiality, but only if both of the following are met:
(i)Disclosure is warranted for protection of the public and the provisions of subdivision (c) are inadequate for the protection of the public.
(ii)It is determined that disclosure is necessary to prevent an immediate harm to the public, including, but not limited to, ongoing fraud, theft, or embezzlement.
(B)Under the circumstances in this paragraph, after private notice to the licensee, the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities. Any disclosure made under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(i)Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(ii)Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(iii)Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)If the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board for any reason self-disqualifies from acting under this paragraph or is otherwise unavailable to act under this paragraph, the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board shall designate someone to act on their behalf.
(3)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chief Trial Counsels designee may waive confidentiality pursuant to Section 6044.5.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the board may vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The board shall hold a meeting under this subdivision in closed session.
(A)The board shall provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may, in advance of the meeting, submit a written statement to the board for the boards consideration at the meeting. The licensee shall not be permitted to attend the closed session meeting of the board.
(B)When assessing whether to waive confidentiality and to what extent the board shall, at a minimum:
(i)Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality.
(ii)Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are generally known to the public.
(iii)Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public.
(iv)Consider the potential for harm to the reputation of the licensee.
(C)All materials for the boards consideration pursuant to this subdivision, including the written statement from the licensee, shall be confidential and not disclosed as a public record under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)If the board votes to waive confidentiality pursuant to paragraph (1) and only after complying with the requirements in paragraph (3), the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities. Any disclosure under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(A)Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(B)Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(3)Before making any public announcements pursuant to paragraph (2), the State Bar shall provide notice to the licensee via email at the address shown on the licensees registration records of the State Bar and via United States mail to the physical address shown on the licensees registration records of all of the following:
(A)The fact that the board has voted to waive confidentiality.
(B)A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public.
(C)That the licensee has five business days from the date of the notice to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
(d)(1)A licensee may file a motion with the State Bar Court to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to subdivision (c). The motion shall be filed within seven court days from the date of the notice issued to the licensee under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c).
(2)If a licensee files a motion under paragraph (1) the proceeding shall be afforded priority on the State Bar Court calendar, and the court shall issue a ruling within 10 court days from the filing of the motion.
(3)The State Bar shall adopt procedures to enact the provisions of this subdivision via the rulemaking process.
(4)All hearings on motions pursuant to this subdivision shall be confidential.
(e)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the State Bar shall disclose to any member of the public so inquiring, any information reasonably available to it pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068, and to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, and 6101, concerning a licensee of the State Bar that is otherwise a matter of public record, including civil or criminal filings and dispositions.
SEC. 18.Section 6086.15 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.15.(a)The State Bar shall issue an Annual Discipline Report by November 30 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Except as set forth in subdivision (d), the report shall cover the period from July 1 of the previous calendar year to June 30 of the year in which the report is issued and shall include accurate and complete descriptions of all of the following:
(1)The inventory of cases within the Office of Chief Trial Counsel which were open at the start of the reporting period, were opened during the reporting period, remain pending with the office at the close of the reporting period, or were disposed of during the reporting period by closure, by filing of a stipulation with the State Bar Court, by filing of a notice of disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court, or by transmittal of a criminal conviction to the State Bar Court. The State Bar shall also report on its success in meeting the case processing goals set forth in Section 6094.5, including, but not limited to, tables showing the number and percentage of cases meeting each goal, the number and percentage of those cases not disposed of within the case processing goals, and a high-level explanation of the reasons for failing to meet those case processing goals. The inventory of cases shall not be limited to case types that could result in the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court, but shall also include Nonattorney Unauthorized Practice of Law (NA-UPL), Section 6007 matters, moral character matters, resignations with charges pending, and mini-reinstatements.
(2)The number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition.
(3)The number, average pending times, and types of matters self-reported by licensees of the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068 and subdivision (c) of Section 6086.8.
(4)The number, average pending times, and types of matters reported by other sources pursuant to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, 6091.1, subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6101, and Section 6175.6.
(5)The speed of complaint handling and dispositions by type, measured by the median and the average processing times.
(6)The number, average pending times, and types of filed notices of disciplinary charges and formal disciplinary outcomes.
(7)The number, average pending times, and types of other matters, including petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180 or 6190, interim suspensions and license restrictions pursuant to Section 6007, motions to enforce a binding arbitration award, judgment, or agreement pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 6203, motions to revoke probation, letters of warning, private reprovals, admonitions, and agreements in lieu of discipline.
(8)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints involving a State Bar licensee who has been disbarred or who has resigned, and is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities, or petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180.
(9)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints against nonattorneys engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities; petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6126.3; or referrals to prosecuting authorities or actions by the State Bar pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(10)A description of the condition of the Client Security Fund, including an accounting of payouts.
(11)An accounting of the cost of the discipline system by function.
(12)Compliance with the requirement of Section 6101 to transmit, within 30 days of receipt, the record of any criminal conviction which involves or may involve moral turpitude to the Supreme Court, or to close the matter if transmittal to the Supreme Court is not appropriate.
(b)The Annual Discipline Report shall include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison.
(c)The Annual Discipline Report shall be presented to the Chief Justice of California, to the Governor, to the Speaker of the Assembly, to the President pro Tempore of the Senate, and to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees, for their consideration and shall be considered a public document.
(d)(1)All data relating to the items set forth in subdivision (a) shall also be reported, if available, for the preceding five years. Data from 2020 and prior years shall be reported for the calendar year. Except as specified in paragraph (2), data from 2021 and future years shall be reported based on the state fiscal year.
(2)The Annual Discipline Report due on October 31, 2022, shall include data from both the prior state fiscal year and the prior calendar year.
SEC. 19.Section 6086.20 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6086.20.(a)Commencing January 1, 2025, the Chief Trial Counsel shall not issue private reprovals to any attorney accused of misconduct.
(b)On or before April 1, 2024, the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, shall provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
SEC. 20.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in or has engaged in any of the following shall inform the State Bar:
(A)Seditious conspiracy as prohibited under Section 2384 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(B)Treason as prohibited under Section 37 of the Penal Code or Section 2381 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(C)Rebellion or insurrection as prohibited under Section 2383 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(2)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SEC. 21.Section 6102 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6102.(a)Upon the receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, the Supreme Court shall suspend the attorney until the time for appeal has elapsed, if no appeal has been taken, or until the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or has otherwise become final, and until the further order of the court. Upon its own motion or upon good cause shown, the court may decline to impose, or may set aside, the suspension when it appears to be in the interest of justice to do so, with due regard being given to maintaining the integrity of, and confidence in, the profession.
(b)For the purposes of this section, a crime is a felony under the law of California if it is declared to be so specifically or by subdivision (a) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, unless it is charged as a misdemeanor pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, irrespective of whether in a particular case the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings, including proceedings resulting in punishment or probation set forth in paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code.
(c)After the judgment of conviction of an offense specified in subdivision (a) has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code or similar statutory provision, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence, the Supreme Court shall summarily disbar the attorney if the offense is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, and either: (1) an element of the offense is the specific intent to deceive, defraud, steal, or make or suborn a false statement, or involved moral turpitude, or (2) the facts and circumstances of the offense involved moral turpitude.
(d)For purposes of this section, a conviction under the laws of another state or territory of the United States shall be deemed a felony if both of the following apply:
(1)The judgment or conviction was entered as a felony irrespective of any subsequent order suspending sentence or granting probation and irrespective of whether the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings.
(2)The elements of the offense for which the licensee was convicted would constitute a felony under the laws of the State of California at the time the offense was committed.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), if after adequate notice and opportunity to be heard (which hearing shall not be had until the judgment of conviction has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence), the court finds that the crime of which the attorney was convicted, or the circumstances of its commission, involved moral turpitude, it shall enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case; otherwise it shall determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline. In determining the extent of the discipline to be imposed in a proceeding pursuant to this article, any prior discipline imposed upon the attorney may be considered.
(f)The court may refer the proceedings or any part thereof or issue therein, including the nature or extent of discipline, to the State Bar for hearing, report, and recommendation.
(g)The record of the proceedings resulting in the conviction, including a transcript of the testimony therein, may be received in evidence.
(h)The Supreme Court shall prescribe rules for the practice and procedure in proceedings conducted pursuant to this section and Section 6101.
(i)The other provisions of this article providing a procedure for the disbarment or suspension of an attorney do not apply to proceedings pursuant to this section and Section 6101, unless expressly made applicable.
SEC. 22.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding three hundred ninety dollars ($390).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 23.Section 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.5.(a)The board shall establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of licensees of the State Bar, foreign legal consultants registered with the State Bar, and attorneys registered with the State Bar under the Multijurisdictional Practice Program, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Any payments from the fund shall be discretionary and shall be subject to regulation, conditions, and rules as the board shall prescribe. The board may delegate the administration of the fund to the State Bar Court, or to any board or committee created by the board of trustees.
(b)Upon making a payment to a person who has applied to the fund for payment to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of a licensee, the State Bar is subrogated, to the extent of that payment, to the rights of the applicant against any person or persons who, or entity that, caused the pecuniary loss. The State Bar may bring an action to enforce those rights within three years from the date of payment to the applicant.
(c)Any licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund shall owe those funds to the State Bar and reimburse the Client Security Fund for all moneys paid out as a result of the licensees conduct with interest, in addition to payment of the assessment for the procedural costs of processing the claim. The State Bar may collect any money paid out by the Client Security Fund pursuant to this subdivision through any means provided by law. The licensees obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund pursuant to this section is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California, a public corporation created pursuant to Article VI of the California Constitution, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
(d)For a publicly reproved or suspended licensee, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of continued practice. This amount shall be added to and become a part of the license fee of a publicly reproved or suspended licensee.
(e)For a licensee who resigns with disciplinary charges pending or a licensee who is resigned or disbarred, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of applying for reinstatement of the licensees license to practice law or return to active license status.
(f)Any assessment against an attorney pursuant to subdivision (c) that is part of an order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is part of an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or any reimbursed amount that is part of a final determination by the Client Security Fund, may also be enforced as a money judgment. This subdivision does not limit the power of the Supreme Court to alter the restitution amount owed pursuant to an order imposing public reproval on a licensee or an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or to authorize the State Bar Court to do the same.
(g)To obtain a money judgment pursuant to subdivision (f) that is not part of a court order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is not part of a court order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, the State Bar shall file a certified copy of the Notice of Payment of the Client Security Fund with the clerk of the superior court of any county. The clerk shall immediately enter judgment in conformity with the Notice of Payment. The judgment shall have the same force and effect as a judgment in a civil action and may be enforced in the same manner as any other judgment.
(h)The defense of laches shall not be raised by the licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund with respect to any payment owed to the State Bar, or with respect to any collections efforts by the State Bar for those payments.
(i)Subdivisions (c), (f), and (h) have, and shall have, retroactive application, as well as prospective application.
(j)As used in this section, licensee shall include a foreign legal consultant registered with the State Bar.
SEC. 24.Section 6140.55 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the board may disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 25.Section 6140.55 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 26.Section 6140.9 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation, established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (d), the board may also disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 27.Section 6140.9 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one-dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 28.Section 6141 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6141.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding ninety-seven dollars and forty cents ($97.40). The annual license fee for inactive licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year.
(b)An inactive licensee shall not be required to pay the annual license fee for inactive licensees for any calendar year following the calendar year in which the licensee attains 70 years of age.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 29.Section 6144.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6144.1.(a)The net proceeds from the sale of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. The net proceeds from the lease of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be used by the State Bar for the protection of the public.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, may be utilized by the State Bar to cover employee salaries, and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
(c)All proceeds expended not consistent with subdivision (b) shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
SEC. 30.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the chief financial officer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted annually, on or before May 31, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory fees are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)For the 2023 audit required pursuant to subdivision (b), the California State Auditors Office shall conduct a performance audit of the State Bar as set forth in this subdivision. The State Bar shall provide technical assistance, data, or information as requested by the California State Auditor. It is the intent of the Legislature that this audit may be reviewed in conjunction with the legislation that authorizes the State Bars licensing fee in 2023.
(2)The audit shall evaluate each program or division of the State Bar receiving support from the annual State Bar licensing fees and other fees required of active and inactive licensees.
(3)The audit shall, at minimum, include all of the following for each program or division described by paragraph (2):
(A)An assessment of how much fee revenue, staff, and resources are currently budgeted and subsequently expended to perform existing tasks and responsibilities.
(B)An assessment of whether the State Bar has appropriate program performance measures in place and how these measures are used for budgeting purposes.
(C)An assessment of the usage of any real property sold by the State Bar.
(D)A review of the State Bars cost allocation plan used to allocate administrative costs.
(E)A review of any proposals for additional funding or resources requested by the State Bar to determine whether these proposals are necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function, as well as the accuracy of identified associated funding needs, after reviewing how existing resources are used.
(F)A calculation of how much fee revenue would be needed from each State Bar active and inactive licensee to fully offset State Bar costs to perform existing tasks and responsibilities and to support additional proposed expenditures determined to be necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function. This calculation shall take into account any proposed business process reengineering, reallocations, or efficiencies identified by the California State Auditor.
(4)The audit shall include an evaluation of how the State Bar administers discipline cases that require an outside investigator or prosecutor and how that process can be improved, including the cost-effectiveness and timeliness of such investigations and prosecutions.
(5)The audit required by this subdivision shall be submitted by April 15, 2023, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(6)The State Bar shall use existing resources to reimburse the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit required by this subdivision.
SEC. 31.Section 6145.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to immediately follow Section 6145, to read:6145.1.(a)(1)The California State Bar shall prepare a report providing written justification for how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fee authorized by Section 6140 for active licensees and Section 6141 for inactive licensees. It is the intent of the Legislature to review this report in conjunction with legislation authorizing the State Bars licensing fee in 2025.
(2)This report shall include the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and provide clear justification for any differences from the amounts calculated by the California State Auditor in its April 2023 audit.
(3)This report shall also include the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional support from the annual license fee. For each program and activity, this assessment shall include all of the following:
(A)A detailed description of the program and activity.
(B)The projected, budgeted, and actual expenditures in 2023, 2024, and 2025 assuming no increase in the annual fee.
(C)The estimated deficit and the reason for the deficit.
(D)What aspects of the programs or activities would not be achievable if a fee increase was not provided.
(E)Complete, actual data for 2023.
(4)This report shall also include information on how the State Bar proposes to use any potential additional funding resulting from any potential increase in the mandatory annual license fee. Specifically, for every twenty-five-dollar ($25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for active licensees and corresponding six dollars and twenty-five-cent ($6.25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for inactive licenses the State Bar shall report, at a minimum, the following:
(A)The total amount of revenue estimated to be generated from the incremental increase.
(B)A description of which State Bar programs and activities would be funded by the revenue generated from the incremental increase and any recent major operational or procedural changes implemented in those programs and activities.
(C)In cases where a program or activity identified pursuant to paragraph (3) is proposed to receive funding, detailed justification for the amount of funding proposed to be used to support the program or activity, how that amount was calculated along with any key assumptions made, what outcomes are expected to be achieved, and what, if any, deficit would remain for the activity or program along with what aspects of the activity or program would be unachievable due to the deficit. This justification shall also clearly specify the extent to which the funding is or will be used to complete business process reengineering, improve processes, or improve efficiencies.
(5)The information provided pursuant to paragraph (4) shall reflect the State Bars actual planned use of the funding for each potential incremental increase and the State Bar shall not assume that it may redirect the funding for other purposes should an increase in the annual fee be approved.
(6)This report shall be submitted no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(b)In addition to the report required by subdivision (a), the State Bar shall provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, which shall be submitted pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a). This progress report shall include, but is not limited to, the following:
(1)The status of changes made to case disciplinary processes and an assessment of how those changes are impacting case processing times.
(2)A discussion of how concerns related to operational efficiency raised by the California State Auditor and the Legislative Analysts Office have been addressed or are planned to be addressed.
(3)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed average case processing standards. This assessment shall also include data on the timeliness of the completion of the hearing stage in order to provide a comprehensive picture of case processing times.
(4)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed backlog standards, as well as the proposed standards calculated using pending rather than closed workload as discussed by the Legislative Analysts January 2023 report.
SEC. 32.Section 6238 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 33.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 9 and 17 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Due to the confidential nature of the information that the Board of Trustees will be considering, it is necessary that their consideration of the information be done in closed session.
SEC. 34.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The arrest of and ongoing scandals surrounding disgraced former attorney Tom Girardi exposed that the State Bar of Californias existing tools for overseeing attorneys client trust accounts are inadequate and expose everyday Californians to the risk of fraud.
(b)Presently, the State Bar of California estimates that over $14,000,000,000 of clients funds are currently being held on deposit in more than 59,000 attorney client trust accounts.
(c)In the coming year the Legislature intends to work with all stakeholders, including the State Bar of California, financial institutions, and legal organizations, to craft a structure for regulating client trust accounts that minimizes the risk of financial fraud while protecting the consumer and privacy interests of clients and account holders.
SEC. 2.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.(a)The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
(b)The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(1)Make contracts.
(2)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes, and debentures, and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(3)Own, hold, use, manage, and deal in and with real and personal property.
(4)Construct, alter, maintain, and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(5)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise, or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(6)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, or dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from license fees paid or payable by licensees.
(7)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
(c)Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivision (b), it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of March 31, 2018, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
(d)The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its licensees in the annual fees statement and other appropriate communications, including its internet website and electronic communications, that its licensees have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a licensee may exercise the licensees right to prohibit or restrict, at the licensees option, the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that licensees can appropriately limit the use of their licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of licensees choosing to utilize these procedures.
(e)(1)No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, members of the board of trustees of the State Bar and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts in Sections 1090 to 1097.2, inclusive, set forth in Article 4 of Chapter 1 of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
SEC. 3.Section 6001.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.3.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the State Bar maintain its commitment to and support of effective policies and activities to enhance access, fairness, and diversity in the legal profession and the elimination of bias in the practice of law.
(b)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The rich diversity of the people of California requires a justice system that is equally accessible and free of bias and is a core value of the legal profession.
(2)Diversity and inclusion are an integral part of the State Bars public protection mission to build, retain, and maintain a diverse legal profession to provide quality and culturally sensitive services to an ever-increasing diverse population.
(3)Diversity increases public trust and confidence and the appearance of fairness in the justice system and therefore increases access to justice.
(4)The State Bar should continue to increase diversity and inclusion in the legal profession.
(c)The State Bar shall develop and implement a plan to meet the goals set forth in this section, which may include, but is not limited to, an assessment of needed revenue. The State Bar shall prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 30, 2019, and every two years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, including a description of activities undertaken to support the plan, their outcomes, and their effectiveness.
SEC. 4.Section 6001.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6001.5.(a)The State Bar of California shall require that all employees and prospective employees, and may require volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
(b)The State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all employees, prospective employees, volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
SEC. 5.Section 6007 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6007.(a)When a licensee requires involuntary treatment pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of, or Part 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or when under an order pursuant to Section 3051, 3106.5, or 3152 of the Welfare and Institutions Code they have been placed in or returned to inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or when they have been determined insane or mentally incompetent and is confined for treatment or placed on outpatient status pursuant to the Penal Code, or on account of their mental condition a guardian or conservator, for their estate or person or both, has been appointed, the Board of Trustees or an officer of the State Bar shall enroll the licensee as an inactive licensee.
The clerk of any court making an order containing any of the determinations or adjudications referred to in the immediately preceding paragraph shall send a certified copy of that order to the State Bar at the same time that the order is entered.
The clerk of any court with which is filed a notice of certification for intensive treatment pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, upon receipt of the notice, shall transmit a certified copy of it to the State Bar.
The State Bar may procure a certified copy of any determination, order, adjudication, appointment, or notice when the clerk concerned has failed to transmit one or when the proceeding was had in a court other than a court of this state.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar shall terminate the enrollment when the licensee has had the fact of their restoration to capacity judicially determined, upon the licensees release from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches pursuant to Section 3053, 3109, or 3151 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or upon the licensees unconditional release from the medical facility pursuant to Section 5304 or 5305 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; and on payment of all fees required.
When a licensee is placed in, returned to, or released from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or discharged from the narcotics treatment program, the Director of Corrections or their designee shall transmit to the State Bar a certified notice attesting to that fact.
(b)The State Bar Court shall also enroll a licensee of the State Bar as an inactive licensee in each of the following cases:
(1)A licensee asserts a claim of insanity or mental incompetence in any pending action or proceeding, alleging their inability to understand the nature of the action or proceeding or inability to assist counsel in representation of the licensee.
(2)The court makes an order assuming jurisdiction over the licensees law practice, pursuant to Section 6180.5 or 6190.34.
(3)After notice and opportunity to be heard before the State Bar Court, the State Bar Court finds that the licensee, because of mental infirmity or illness, or because of the habitual use of intoxicants or drugs, is (i) unable or habitually fails to perform their duties or undertakings competently, or (ii) unable to practice law without substantial threat of harm to the interests of their clients or the public. No proceeding pursuant to this paragraph shall be instituted unless the State Bar Court finds, after preliminary investigation, or during the course of a disciplinary proceeding, that probable cause exists therefor. The determination of probable cause is administrative in character and no notice or hearing is required.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the enrollment upon proof that the facts found as to the licensees disability no longer exist and on payment of all fees required.
(c)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon a finding based on all the available evidence, including affidavits, that the attorney has not complied with Section 6002.1 and cannot be located after reasonable investigation.
(2)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney if it finds, based on all the available evidence, including affidavits:
(A)The attorney has caused or is causing substantial harm to the attorneys clients or the public.
(B)There is a reasonable probability that the chief trial counsel will prevail on the merits of the underlying disciplinary matter, and that the attorney will be disbarred.
(3)In the case of an enrollment under paragraph (2), the underlying matter shall proceed on an expedited basis.
(4)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon the filing of a recommendation of disbarment after hearing or default. For purposes of this section, that attorney shall be placed on involuntary inactive enrollment regardless of the license status of the attorney at the time.
(5)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney who is sentenced to incarceration for 90 days or more as a result of a criminal conviction for at least the period of time in which the attorney is incarcerated.
(6)The State Bar Court shall order attorneys who are placed on inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision to comply with Rule 9.20 of the California Rules of Court.
(7)The board shall formulate and adopt rules of procedure to implement this subdivision.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment upon proof that the attorneys conduct no longer poses a substantial threat of harm to the interests of the attorneys clients or the public or where an attorney who could not be located proves compliance with Section 6002.1.
(d)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(A)The attorney is under a suspension order any portion of which has been stayed during a period of probation.
(B)The State Bar Court finds that probation has been violated.
(C)The State Bar Court recommends to the Supreme Court that the attorney receive an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate an enrollment under this subdivision upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
(3)If the Supreme Court orders a period of actual suspension in the probation matter, any period of involuntary inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited against the period of actual suspension ordered.
(e)(1)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary, inactive enrollment of a licensee whose default has been entered pursuant to the State Bar Rules of Procedure if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The notice was duly served pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 6002.1.
(B)The notice contained the following language at or near the beginning of the notice, in capital letters:
IF YOU FAIL TO FILE AN ANSWER TO THIS NOTICE WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED BY STATE BAR RULES, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS, OR IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE STATE BAR COURT TRIAL, (1) YOUR DEFAULT SHALL BE ENTERED, (2) YOU SHALL BE ENROLLED AS AN INVOLUNTARY INACTIVE LICENSEE OF THE STATE BAR AND WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PRACTICE LAW UNLESS THE DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE ON MOTION TIMELY MADE UNDER THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE STATE BAR, (3) YOU SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE FURTHER IN THESE PROCEEDINGS UNLESS YOUR DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE, AND (4) YOU SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL DISCIPLINE.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision when the licensees default is set aside on motion timely made under the State Bar Rules of Procedure or the disciplinary proceedings are completed.
(3)The enrollment under this subdivision is administrative in character and no hearing is required.
(4)Upon the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision, the notice required by subdivision (b) of Section 6092.5 shall be promptly given.
(f)The pendency or determination of a proceeding or investigation provided for by this section shall not abate or terminate a disciplinary investigation or proceeding except as required by the facts and law in a particular case.
(g)No license fees shall accrue against the licensee during the period they are enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to this section.
(h)The State Bar Court may order a full range of interim remedies or final discipline short of involuntary inactive enrollment, including, but not limited to, conditions of probation following final discipline, or directly ordered interim remedies, to restrict or supervise an attorneys practice of law, as well as proceedings under subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), or under Section 6102 or 6190. They may include restrictions as to scope of practice, monetary accounting procedures, review of performance by probation or other monitors appointed by the board, or such other measures as may be determined, after hearing, to protect present and future clients from likely substantial harm. These restrictions may be imposed upon a showing as provided in subdivision (c).
SEC. 6.Section 6011 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6011.(a)The board shall appoint an executive director of the State Bar, who shall be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as the executive director of the State Bar. The executive director shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The executive director shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The executive director shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of an executive director.
(c)The appointment of the executive director is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed as the executive director on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 7.Section 6012 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6012.(a)The board shall appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as general counsel of the State Bar. The general counsel shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The general counsel shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The general counsel shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of a general counsel.
(c)The appointment of the general counsel is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed general counsel on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 8.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)The selection of the chair and vice chair of the board shall be made by appointment of the Supreme Court.
(b)The chair and the vice chair shall each be appointed for a term not to exceed two years. The chair and vice chair shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the September meeting following their appointment. The chair and vice chair shall not serve more than two terms, except that a chair or vice chair who is appointed to fill a vacancy for the balance of a term is eligible to serve two full terms in addition to the remainder of the term for which they were appointed.
SEC. 9.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to any of the following:
(1)Appeals from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
(3)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of the California Bar Examination or the First-Year Law Students Examination.
(4)Matters related to the Committee of Bar Examiners consideration of moral character, including allegations of criminal or professional misconduct, competence, or physical or mental health of an individual, requests by applicants for testing accommodations in connection with an application for admission to practice law, or appeals of the Committee of Bar Examiners determinations.
(5)Information about a law schools operations that constitutes a trade secret as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code.
(6)Matters related to the boards consideration of waiving confidentiality related to records of disciplinary proceedings under subdivision (c) of Section 6086.1.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 11125.7 of the Government Code, the State Bar shall accept public comment in open session on all matters that are agendized for discussion or decision by the board of trustees, whether in an open or a closed session.
SEC. 10.Section 6036 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6036.(a)Any member of the board of trustees shall disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest, as that term is defined in Section 87103 of the Government Code, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision.
(b)Any member of the board of trustees shall likewise disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), no member shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the members participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made. The fact that a members vote is needed to break a tie does not make the members participation legally required for the purposes of this section.
(d)A member required to disqualify themself because of a conflict of interest shall (1)immediately disclose the interest, (2)withdraw from any participation in the matter, (3)refrain from attempting to influence another member, and (4)refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
(e)For purposes of this article and unless otherwise specified, member means any appointed or elected member of the board of trustees.
SEC. 11.Section 6037 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6037.No action or decision of the State Bar shall be invalid because of the participation therein by a member or members of the board of trustees in violation of Section 6036. However, any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 6036 is guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding five days, or by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both, and, if the member is an attorney member of the board, a certified copy of the record of conviction shall be transmitted to the Supreme Court for disposition as provided in Sections 6101 and 6102. Upon entry of final judgment of conviction, the members term of office on the board of trustees, and duties and authority incidental thereto, shall automatically terminate. Any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 6036 shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500) for each violation, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action in a court of competent jurisdiction brought in the name of the state only by a district attorney of a county in which the member resides or maintains offices and the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of that county.
SEC. 12.Section 6054 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6054.(a)State and local law enforcement and licensing bodies and departments, officers and employees thereof, and officials and attaches of the courts of this state shall cooperate with and give reasonable assistance and information, including the providing of state summary criminal history information and local summary criminal history information, to the State Bar of California or any authorized representative thereof, in connection with any investigation or proceeding within the jurisdiction of the State Bar of California, regarding the admission to the practice of law or discipline of attorneys or their reinstatement to the practice of law.
(b)The State Bar of California shall require that an applicant for admission or reinstatement to the practice of law in California, or may require a licensee, to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
(c)(1)Pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code, the State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all persons applying for admission to the State Bar of California for all applicants for reinstatement, and for licensees that are required to be fingerprinted under Rule 9.9.5 of the California Rules of Court, as it read on January 1, 2023. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
(2)As used in this subdivision, applicant for reinstatement means individuals initiating reinstatement proceedings with the State Bar after resignation with or without charges pending and after disbarment.
(d)The State Bar may use the information obtained from the Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation as a result of the fingerprinting of an applicant or licensee, and the State Bars use of that information shall be limited to the official use of the State Bar in establishing the identity of the applicant and in determining the character and fitness of the applicant for admission or reinstatement, and in discovering prior and subsequent criminal arrests of an applicant, licensee, or applicant for reinstatement. The State Bar shall notify the Department of Justice about individuals who are no longer licensees and applicants who are denied admission to the State Bar within 30 days of any change in status of a licensee or denial of admission. All fingerprint records of applicants admitted or licensees reinstated, or provided by a licensee, shall be retained thereafter by the Department of Justice for the limited purpose of criminal arrest notification to the State Bar.
(e)If required to be fingerprinted pursuant to this section, a licensee of the State Bar who fails to be fingerprinted may be enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to rules adopted by the board of trustees.
SEC. 13.Section 6060 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission and a license to practice law, a person who has not been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency or in a foreign country shall:
(a)Be at least 18 years of age.
(b)(1)Be of good moral character.
(2)(A)In reviewing whether an applicant is of good moral character under this subdivision, the staff of the State Bar or the members of the examining committee shall not review or consider the persons medical records relating to mental health, except
if the applicant seeks to use the record for either of the following purposes:
(i)To demonstrate that the applicant is of good moral character.
(ii)As a mitigating factor to explain a specific act of misconduct.
(B)The staff of the State Bar and members of the examining committee shall not request or seek to review any medical records relating to mental health, including by obtaining the consent of the applicant to disclose such records, except as requested by an applicant and for a purpose specified in subparagraph (A).
(c)Before beginning the study of law, have done either of the following:
(1)Completed at least two years of college work, which college work shall be at least one-half of the collegiate work acceptable for a bachelors degree granted on the basis of a four-year period of study by a college or university approved by the examining committee.
(2)Have attained in apparent intellectual ability the equivalent of at least two years of college work by taking examinations in subject matters and achieving the scores as are prescribed by the examining committee.
(d)Have registered with the State Bar as a law student within 90 days after beginning the study of law. The State Bar, upon a showing of good cause, may permit a later registration.
(e)Have done either of the following:
(1)Had conferred upon them a juris doctor (J.D.) degree or a bachelor of laws (LL.B.) degree by a law school accredited by the examining committee or approved by the American Bar Association.
(2)Studied law diligently and in good faith for at least four years in any of the following manners:
(A)(i)In a law school that is authorized or approved to confer professional degrees and requires classroom attendance of its students for a minimum of 270 hours a year.
(ii)A person who has received their legal education in a foreign state or country where the common law of England does not constitute the basis of jurisprudence shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the State Bar that the persons education, experience, and qualifications qualify them to take the examination.
(B)In a law office in this state and under the personal supervision of a licensee of the State Bar of California who is, and for at least the last five years continuously has been, engaged in the active practice of law. It is the duty of the supervising attorney to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(C)In the chambers and under the personal supervision of a judge of a court of record of this state. It is the duty of the supervising judge to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(D)By instruction in law from a correspondence law school authorized or approved to confer professional degrees by this state, which requires 864 hours of preparation and study per year for four years.
(E)By any combination of the methods referred to in this paragraph.
(f)Have passed any examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the examining committee may prescribe.
(g)Have passed the general bar examination given by the examining committee.
(h)(1)Have passed a law students examination administered by the examining committee after completion of their first year of law study. Those who pass the examination within its first three administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination, shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed. Those who do not pass the examination within the number of administrations allowed by this subdivision, upon becoming eligible to take the examination, but who subsequently pass the examination, shall receive credit for one year of legal study only.
(2)(A)This requirement does not apply to a student who has satisfactorily completed their first year of law study at a law school accredited by the examining committee and who has completed at least two years of college work prior to matriculating in the accredited law school, nor shall this requirement apply to an applicant who has passed the bar examination of a sister state or of a country in which the common law of England constitutes the basis of jurisprudence.
(B)The law students examination shall be administered twice a year at reasonable intervals.
SEC. 14.Section 6060.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.3.(a)An application to take the California bar examination administered in February must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding November, and an application to take the California bar examination administered in July must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding April. However, an applicant who was unsuccessful on the examination last administered shall be allowed 10 business days from the date of the general announcement of results of that examination in which to timely file an application to take the next scheduled examination.
(b)The State Bar may accept applications to take the California bar examination filed after the timely deadlines specified in subdivision (a) from applicants if the application is accompanied by the timely application fee and the late filing fee fixed by the board as follows:
(1)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the first and last business days in November for the February examination or between the first and last business days of April for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed fifty dollars ($50).
(2)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the last business day of November and January 1 for the February examination or between the last business day of April and June 1 for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(3)An application to take the California bar examination filed after January 1 for the February examination and after June 1 for the July examination shall not be accepted.
(c)Application fees for the California bar examination, including fees for late filing, shall be refunded if the applicant does not take the California bar examination because of the death of an immediate family member or the serious illness or disabling injury of the applicant or a member of their immediate family. A deduction may be made from the refund for administrative costs. The board shall adopt regulations for the administration of this subdivision. This subdivision shall not be construed to prohibit the refund of fees in instances other than those specified.
SEC. 15.Section 6063 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6063.Applicants for admission to practice shall pay such reasonable fees, fixed by the board, as may be necessary to defray the expense of administering the provisions of this chapter, relating to admission to practice. These fees shall be collected by the State Bar and paid into the treasury of the State Bar.
SEC. 16.Section 6065 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6065.Any applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, shall have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, which shall include the ability to download, save, and print.
SEC. 17.Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.1.(a)(1)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court shall be public, following the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
(2)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of the following matters shall be public:
(A)Filings for involuntary inactive enrollment or restriction under subdivision (a), (c), (d), or (e) of Section 6007.
(B)Petitions for reinstatement under Section 6078.
(C)Proceedings for suspension or disbarment under Section 6101 or 6102.
(D)Payment information from the Client Security Fund pursuant to Section 6140.5.
(E)Actions to cease a law practice or assume a law practice under Section 6180 or 6190.
(b)All disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time that formal charges are filed and all investigations of matters identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) are confidential until the formal proceeding identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) is instituted. These investigations shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). This confidentiality requirement may be waived under any of the following exceptions:
(1)The licensee whose conduct is being investigated or has been investigated consents to a public announcement or disclosure.
(2)(A)The Chief Trial Counsel, with the written concurrence of the chair of the board, may waive confidentiality, but only if both of the following are met:
(i)Disclosure is warranted for protection of the public and the provisions of subdivision (c) are inadequate for the protection of the public.
(ii)It is determined that disclosure is necessary to prevent an immediate harm to the public, including, but not limited to, ongoing fraud, theft, or embezzlement.
(B)Under the circumstances in this paragraph, after private notice to the licensee, the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities. Any disclosure made under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(i)Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(ii)Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(iii)Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)If the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board for any reason self-disqualifies from acting under this paragraph or is otherwise unavailable to act under this paragraph, the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board shall designate someone to act on their behalf.
(3)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chief Trial Counsels designee may waive confidentiality pursuant to Section 6044.5.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the board may vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The board shall hold a meeting under this subdivision in closed session.
(A)The board shall provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may, in advance of the meeting, submit a written statement to the board for the boards consideration at the meeting. The licensee shall not be permitted to attend the closed session meeting of the board.
(B)When assessing whether to waive confidentiality and to what extent the board shall, at a minimum:
(i)Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality.
(ii)Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are generally known to the public.
(iii)Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public.
(iv)Consider the potential for harm to the reputation of the licensee.
(C)All materials for the boards consideration pursuant to this subdivision, including the written statement from the licensee, shall be confidential and not disclosed as a public record under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)If the board votes to waive confidentiality pursuant to paragraph (1) and only after complying with the requirements in paragraph (3), the Chief Trial Counsel or chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities. Any disclosure under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(A)Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(B)Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(3)Before making any public announcements pursuant to paragraph (2), the State Bar shall provide notice to the licensee via email at the address shown on the licensees registration records of the State Bar and via United States mail to the physical address shown on the licensees registration records of all of the following:
(A)The fact that the board has voted to waive confidentiality.
(B)A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public.
(C)That the licensee has five business days from the date of the notice to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
(d)(1)A licensee may file a motion with the State Bar Court to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to subdivision (c). The motion shall be filed within seven court days from the date of the notice issued to the licensee under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c).
(2)If a licensee files a motion under paragraph (1) the proceeding shall be afforded priority on the State Bar Court calendar, and the court shall issue a ruling within 10 court days from the filing of the motion.
(3)The State Bar shall adopt procedures to enact the provisions of this subdivision via the rulemaking process.
(4)All hearings on motions pursuant to this subdivision shall be confidential.
(e)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the State Bar shall disclose to any member of the public so inquiring, any information reasonably available to it pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068, and to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, and 6101, concerning a licensee of the State Bar that is otherwise a matter of public record, including civil or criminal filings and dispositions.
SEC. 18.Section 6086.15 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.15.(a)The State Bar shall issue an Annual Discipline Report by November 30 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Except as set forth in subdivision (d), the report shall cover the period from July 1 of the previous calendar year to June 30 of the year in which the report is issued and shall include accurate and complete descriptions of all of the following:
(1)The inventory of cases within the Office of Chief Trial Counsel which were open at the start of the reporting period, were opened during the reporting period, remain pending with the office at the close of the reporting period, or were disposed of during the reporting period by closure, by filing of a stipulation with the State Bar Court, by filing of a notice of disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court, or by transmittal of a criminal conviction to the State Bar Court. The State Bar shall also report on its success in meeting the case processing goals set forth in Section 6094.5, including, but not limited to, tables showing the number and percentage of cases meeting each goal, the number and percentage of those cases not disposed of within the case processing goals, and a high-level explanation of the reasons for failing to meet those case processing goals. The inventory of cases shall not be limited to case types that could result in the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court, but shall also include Nonattorney Unauthorized Practice of Law (NA-UPL), Section 6007 matters, moral character matters, resignations with charges pending, and mini-reinstatements.
(2)The number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition.
(3)The number, average pending times, and types of matters self-reported by licensees of the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068 and subdivision (c) of Section 6086.8.
(4)The number, average pending times, and types of matters reported by other sources pursuant to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, 6091.1, subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6101, and Section 6175.6.
(5)The speed of complaint handling and dispositions by type, measured by the median and the average processing times.
(6)The number, average pending times, and types of filed notices of disciplinary charges and formal disciplinary outcomes.
(7)The number, average pending times, and types of other matters, including petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180 or 6190, interim suspensions and license restrictions pursuant to Section 6007, motions to enforce a binding arbitration award, judgment, or agreement pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 6203, motions to revoke probation, letters of warning, private reprovals, admonitions, and agreements in lieu of discipline.
(8)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints involving a State Bar licensee who has been disbarred or who has resigned, and is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities, or petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180.
(9)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints against nonattorneys engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities; petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6126.3; or referrals to prosecuting authorities or actions by the State Bar pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(10)A description of the condition of the Client Security Fund, including an accounting of payouts.
(11)An accounting of the cost of the discipline system by function.
(12)Compliance with the requirement of Section 6101 to transmit, within 30 days of receipt, the record of any criminal conviction which involves or may involve moral turpitude to the Supreme Court, or to close the matter if transmittal to the Supreme Court is not appropriate.
(b)The Annual Discipline Report shall include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison.
(c)The Annual Discipline Report shall be presented to the Chief Justice of California, to the Governor, to the Speaker of the Assembly, to the President pro Tempore of the Senate, and to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees, for their consideration and shall be considered a public document.
(d)(1)All data relating to the items set forth in subdivision (a) shall also be reported, if available, for the preceding five years. Data from 2020 and prior years shall be reported for the calendar year. Except as specified in paragraph (2), data from 2021 and future years shall be reported based on the state fiscal year.
(2)The Annual Discipline Report due on October 31, 2022, shall include data from both the prior state fiscal year and the prior calendar year.
SEC. 19.Section 6086.20 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6086.20.(a)Commencing January 1, 2025, the Chief Trial Counsel shall not issue private reprovals to any attorney accused of misconduct.
(b)On or before April 1, 2024, the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, shall provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
SEC. 20.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in or has engaged in any of the following shall inform the State Bar:
(A)Seditious conspiracy as prohibited under Section 2384 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(B)Treason as prohibited under Section 37 of the Penal Code or Section 2381 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(C)Rebellion or insurrection as prohibited under Section 2383 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(2)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SEC. 21.Section 6102 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6102.(a)Upon the receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, the Supreme Court shall suspend the attorney until the time for appeal has elapsed, if no appeal has been taken, or until the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or has otherwise become final, and until the further order of the court. Upon its own motion or upon good cause shown, the court may decline to impose, or may set aside, the suspension when it appears to be in the interest of justice to do so, with due regard being given to maintaining the integrity of, and confidence in, the profession.
(b)For the purposes of this section, a crime is a felony under the law of California if it is declared to be so specifically or by subdivision (a) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, unless it is charged as a misdemeanor pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, irrespective of whether in a particular case the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings, including proceedings resulting in punishment or probation set forth in paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code.
(c)After the judgment of conviction of an offense specified in subdivision (a) has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code or similar statutory provision, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence, the Supreme Court shall summarily disbar the attorney if the offense is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, and either: (1) an element of the offense is the specific intent to deceive, defraud, steal, or make or suborn a false statement, or involved moral turpitude, or (2) the facts and circumstances of the offense involved moral turpitude.
(d)For purposes of this section, a conviction under the laws of another state or territory of the United States shall be deemed a felony if both of the following apply:
(1)The judgment or conviction was entered as a felony irrespective of any subsequent order suspending sentence or granting probation and irrespective of whether the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings.
(2)The elements of the offense for which the licensee was convicted would constitute a felony under the laws of the State of California at the time the offense was committed.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), if after adequate notice and opportunity to be heard (which hearing shall not be had until the judgment of conviction has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence), the court finds that the crime of which the attorney was convicted, or the circumstances of its commission, involved moral turpitude, it shall enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case; otherwise it shall determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline. In determining the extent of the discipline to be imposed in a proceeding pursuant to this article, any prior discipline imposed upon the attorney may be considered.
(f)The court may refer the proceedings or any part thereof or issue therein, including the nature or extent of discipline, to the State Bar for hearing, report, and recommendation.
(g)The record of the proceedings resulting in the conviction, including a transcript of the testimony therein, may be received in evidence.
(h)The Supreme Court shall prescribe rules for the practice and procedure in proceedings conducted pursuant to this section and Section 6101.
(i)The other provisions of this article providing a procedure for the disbarment or suspension of an attorney do not apply to proceedings pursuant to this section and Section 6101, unless expressly made applicable.
SEC. 22.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding three hundred ninety dollars ($390).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 23.Section 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.5.(a)The board shall establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of licensees of the State Bar, foreign legal consultants registered with the State Bar, and attorneys registered with the State Bar under the Multijurisdictional Practice Program, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Any payments from the fund shall be discretionary and shall be subject to regulation, conditions, and rules as the board shall prescribe. The board may delegate the administration of the fund to the State Bar Court, or to any board or committee created by the board of trustees.
(b)Upon making a payment to a person who has applied to the fund for payment to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of a licensee, the State Bar is subrogated, to the extent of that payment, to the rights of the applicant against any person or persons who, or entity that, caused the pecuniary loss. The State Bar may bring an action to enforce those rights within three years from the date of payment to the applicant.
(c)Any licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund shall owe those funds to the State Bar and reimburse the Client Security Fund for all moneys paid out as a result of the licensees conduct with interest, in addition to payment of the assessment for the procedural costs of processing the claim. The State Bar may collect any money paid out by the Client Security Fund pursuant to this subdivision through any means provided by law. The licensees obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund pursuant to this section is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California, a public corporation created pursuant to Article VI of the California Constitution, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
(d)For a publicly reproved or suspended licensee, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of continued practice. This amount shall be added to and become a part of the license fee of a publicly reproved or suspended licensee.
(e)For a licensee who resigns with disciplinary charges pending or a licensee who is resigned or disbarred, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of applying for reinstatement of the licensees license to practice law or return to active license status.
(f)Any assessment against an attorney pursuant to subdivision (c) that is part of an order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is part of an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or any reimbursed amount that is part of a final determination by the Client Security Fund, may also be enforced as a money judgment. This subdivision does not limit the power of the Supreme Court to alter the restitution amount owed pursuant to an order imposing public reproval on a licensee or an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or to authorize the State Bar Court to do the same.
(g)To obtain a money judgment pursuant to subdivision (f) that is not part of a court order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is not part of a court order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, the State Bar shall file a certified copy of the Notice of Payment of the Client Security Fund with the clerk of the superior court of any county. The clerk shall immediately enter judgment in conformity with the Notice of Payment. The judgment shall have the same force and effect as a judgment in a civil action and may be enforced in the same manner as any other judgment.
(h)The defense of laches shall not be raised by the licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund with respect to any payment owed to the State Bar, or with respect to any collections efforts by the State Bar for those payments.
(i)Subdivisions (c), (f), and (h) have, and shall have, retroactive application, as well as prospective application.
(j)As used in this section, licensee shall include a foreign legal consultant registered with the State Bar.
SEC. 24.Section 6140.55 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the board may disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 25.Section 6140.55 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 26.Section 6140.9 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation, established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (d), the board may also disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 27.Section 6140.9 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one-dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 28.Section 6141 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6141.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding ninety-seven dollars and forty cents ($97.40). The annual license fee for inactive licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year.
(b)An inactive licensee shall not be required to pay the annual license fee for inactive licensees for any calendar year following the calendar year in which the licensee attains 70 years of age.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 29.Section 6144.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6144.1.(a)The net proceeds from the sale of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. The net proceeds from the lease of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be used by the State Bar for the protection of the public.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, may be utilized by the State Bar to cover employee salaries, and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
(c)All proceeds expended not consistent with subdivision (b) shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
SEC. 30.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the chief financial officer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted annually, on or before May 31, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory fees are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)For the 2023 audit required pursuant to subdivision (b), the California State Auditors Office shall conduct a performance audit of the State Bar as set forth in this subdivision. The State Bar shall provide technical assistance, data, or information as requested by the California State Auditor. It is the intent of the Legislature that this audit may be reviewed in conjunction with the legislation that authorizes the State Bars licensing fee in 2023.
(2)The audit shall evaluate each program or division of the State Bar receiving support from the annual State Bar licensing fees and other fees required of active and inactive licensees.
(3)The audit shall, at minimum, include all of the following for each program or division described by paragraph (2):
(A)An assessment of how much fee revenue, staff, and resources are currently budgeted and subsequently expended to perform existing tasks and responsibilities.
(B)An assessment of whether the State Bar has appropriate program performance measures in place and how these measures are used for budgeting purposes.
(C)An assessment of the usage of any real property sold by the State Bar.
(D)A review of the State Bars cost allocation plan used to allocate administrative costs.
(E)A review of any proposals for additional funding or resources requested by the State Bar to determine whether these proposals are necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function, as well as the accuracy of identified associated funding needs, after reviewing how existing resources are used.
(F)A calculation of how much fee revenue would be needed from each State Bar active and inactive licensee to fully offset State Bar costs to perform existing tasks and responsibilities and to support additional proposed expenditures determined to be necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function. This calculation shall take into account any proposed business process reengineering, reallocations, or efficiencies identified by the California State Auditor.
(4)The audit shall include an evaluation of how the State Bar administers discipline cases that require an outside investigator or prosecutor and how that process can be improved, including the cost-effectiveness and timeliness of such investigations and prosecutions.
(5)The audit required by this subdivision shall be submitted by April 15, 2023, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(6)The State Bar shall use existing resources to reimburse the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit required by this subdivision.
SEC. 31.Section 6145.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to immediately follow Section 6145, to read:6145.1.(a)(1)The California State Bar shall prepare a report providing written justification for how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fee authorized by Section 6140 for active licensees and Section 6141 for inactive licensees. It is the intent of the Legislature to review this report in conjunction with legislation authorizing the State Bars licensing fee in 2025.
(2)This report shall include the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and provide clear justification for any differences from the amounts calculated by the California State Auditor in its April 2023 audit.
(3)This report shall also include the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional support from the annual license fee. For each program and activity, this assessment shall include all of the following:
(A)A detailed description of the program and activity.
(B)The projected, budgeted, and actual expenditures in 2023, 2024, and 2025 assuming no increase in the annual fee.
(C)The estimated deficit and the reason for the deficit.
(D)What aspects of the programs or activities would not be achievable if a fee increase was not provided.
(E)Complete, actual data for 2023.
(4)This report shall also include information on how the State Bar proposes to use any potential additional funding resulting from any potential increase in the mandatory annual license fee. Specifically, for every twenty-five-dollar ($25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for active licensees and corresponding six dollars and twenty-five-cent ($6.25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for inactive licenses the State Bar shall report, at a minimum, the following:
(A)The total amount of revenue estimated to be generated from the incremental increase.
(B)A description of which State Bar programs and activities would be funded by the revenue generated from the incremental increase and any recent major operational or procedural changes implemented in those programs and activities.
(C)In cases where a program or activity identified pursuant to paragraph (3) is proposed to receive funding, detailed justification for the amount of funding proposed to be used to support the program or activity, how that amount was calculated along with any key assumptions made, what outcomes are expected to be achieved, and what, if any, deficit would remain for the activity or program along with what aspects of the activity or program would be unachievable due to the deficit. This justification shall also clearly specify the extent to which the funding is or will be used to complete business process reengineering, improve processes, or improve efficiencies.
(5)The information provided pursuant to paragraph (4) shall reflect the State Bars actual planned use of the funding for each potential incremental increase and the State Bar shall not assume that it may redirect the funding for other purposes should an increase in the annual fee be approved.
(6)This report shall be submitted no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(b)In addition to the report required by subdivision (a), the State Bar shall provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, which shall be submitted pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a). This progress report shall include, but is not limited to, the following:
(1)The status of changes made to case disciplinary processes and an assessment of how those changes are impacting case processing times.
(2)A discussion of how concerns related to operational efficiency raised by the California State Auditor and the Legislative Analysts Office have been addressed or are planned to be addressed.
(3)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed average case processing standards. This assessment shall also include data on the timeliness of the completion of the hearing stage in order to provide a comprehensive picture of case processing times.
(4)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed backlog standards, as well as the proposed standards calculated using pending rather than closed workload as discussed by the Legislative Analysts January 2023 report.
SEC. 32.Section 6238 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 33.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 9 and 17 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Due to the confidential nature of the information that the Board of Trustees will be considering, it is necessary that their consideration of the information be done in closed session.
SEC. 34.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The arrest of and ongoing scandals surrounding disgraced former attorney Tom Girardi exposed that the State Bar of Californias existing tools for overseeing attorneys client trust accounts are inadequate and expose everyday Californians to the risk of fraud.
(b)Presently, the State Bar of California estimates that over $14,000,000,000 of clients funds are currently being held on deposit in more than 59,000 attorney client trust accounts.
(c)In the coming year the Legislature intends to work with all stakeholders, including the State Bar of California, financial institutions, and legal organizations, to craft a structure for regulating client trust accounts that minimizes the risk of financial fraud while protecting the consumer and privacy interests of clients and account holders.
SEC. 2.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.(a)The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
The(b)The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(a)(1)Make contracts.
(b)(2)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes, and debentures, and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(c)(3)Own, hold, use, manage, and deal in and with real and personal property.
(d)(4)Construct, alter, maintain, and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(e)(5)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise, or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(f)(6)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, or dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from license fees paid or payable by licensees.
(g)(7)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
Pursuant(c)Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, subdivision (b), it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of March 31, 2018, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
The(d)The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its licensees in the annual fees statement and other appropriate communications, including its internet website and electronic communications, that its licensees have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a licensee may exercise the licensees right to prohibit or restrict, at the licensees option, the sale or disclosure of licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that licensees can appropriately limit the use of their licensee information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of licensees choosing to utilize these procedures.
No(e)(1)No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Notwithstanding the foregoing
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) or any other law, members of the board of trustees of the State Bar and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts in Sections 1090 to 1097.2, inclusive, set forth in Article 4 of Chapter 1 of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 6001.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.3.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the State Bar maintain its commitment to and support of effective policies and activities to enhance access, fairness, and diversity in the legal profession and the elimination of bias in the practice of law.
(b)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The rich diversity of the people of California requires a justice system that is equally accessible and free of bias and is a core value of the legal profession.
(2)Diversity and inclusion are an integral part of the State Bars public protection mission to build, retain, and maintain a diverse legal profession to provide quality and culturally sensitive services to an ever-increasing diverse population.
(3)Diversity increases public trust and confidence and the appearance of fairness in the justice system and therefore increases access to justice.
(4)The State Bar should continue to increase diversity and inclusion in the legal profession.
(c)The State Bar shall develop and implement a plan to meet the goals set forth in this section, which may include, but is not limited to, an assessment of needed revenue. The State Bar shall prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 30, 2019, and every two years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, including a description of activities undertaken to support the plan, their outcomes, and their effectiveness.
SEC. 4.Section 6001.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6001.5.(a)The State Bar of California shall require that all employees and prospective employees, and may require volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, to submit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish identity and to determine whether the individual has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states, including through a national criminal history check.
(b)The State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all employees, prospective employees, volunteers, contractors, and subcontractors, pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
SEC. 2.SEC. 5.Section 6007 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6007.(a)When a licensee requires involuntary treatment pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of, or Part 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or when under an order pursuant to Section 3051, 3106.5, or 3152 of the Welfare and Institutions Code they have been placed in or returned to inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or when they have been determined insane or mentally incompetent and is confined for treatment or placed on outpatient status pursuant to the Penal Code, or on account of their mental condition a guardian or conservator, for their estate or person or both, has been appointed, the Board of Trustees or an officer of the State Bar shall enroll the licensee as an inactive licensee.
The clerk of any court making an order containing any of the determinations or adjudications referred to in the immediately preceding paragraph shall send a certified copy of that order to the State Bar at the same time that the order is entered.
The clerk of any court with which is filed a notice of certification for intensive treatment pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, upon receipt of the notice, shall transmit a certified copy of it to the State Bar.
The State Bar may procure a certified copy of any determination, order, adjudication, appointment, or notice when the clerk concerned has failed to transmit one or when the proceeding was had in a court other than a court of this state.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar shall terminate the enrollment when the licensee has had the fact of their restoration to capacity judicially determined, upon the licensees release from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches pursuant to Section 3053, 3109, or 3151 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or upon the licensees unconditional release from the medical facility pursuant to Section 5304 or 5305 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; and on payment of all fees required.
When a licensee is placed in, returned to, or released from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or discharged from the narcotics treatment program, the Director of Corrections or their designee shall transmit to the State Bar a certified notice attesting to that fact.
(b)The State Bar Court shall also enroll a licensee of the State Bar as an inactive licensee in each of the following cases:
(1)A licensee asserts a claim of insanity or mental incompetence in any pending action or proceeding, alleging their inability to understand the nature of the action or proceeding or inability to assist counsel in representation of the licensee.
(2)The court makes an order assuming jurisdiction over the licensees law practice, pursuant to Section 6180.5 or 6190.34.
(3)After notice and opportunity to be heard before the State Bar Court, the State Bar Court finds that the licensee, because of mental infirmity or illness, or because of the habitual use of intoxicants or drugs, is (i) unable or habitually fails to perform their duties or undertakings competently, or (ii) unable to practice law without substantial threat of harm to the interests of their clients or the public. No proceeding pursuant to this paragraph shall be instituted unless the State Bar Court finds, after preliminary investigation, or during the course of a disciplinary proceeding, that probable cause exists therefor. The determination of probable cause is administrative in character and no notice or hearing is required.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the enrollment upon proof that the facts found as to the licensees disability no longer exist and on payment of all fees required.
(c)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon a finding based on all the available evidence, including affidavits, that the attorney has not complied with Section 6002.1 and cannot be located after reasonable investigation.
(2)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney if it finds, based on all the available evidence, including affidavits:
(A)The attorney has caused or is causing substantial harm to the attorneys clients or the public.
(B)There is a reasonable probability that the chief trial counsel will prevail on the merits of the underlying disciplinary matter, and that the attorney will be disbarred.
(3)In the case of an enrollment under paragraph (2), the underlying matter shall proceed on an expedited basis.
(4)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon the filing of a recommendation of disbarment after hearing or default. For purposes of this section, that attorney shall be placed on involuntary inactive enrollment regardless of the license status of the attorney at the time.
(5)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney who is sentenced to incarceration for 90 days or more as a result of a criminal conviction for at least the period of time in which the attorney is incarcerated.
(6)The State Bar Court shall order attorneys who are placed on inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision to comply with Rule 9.20 of the California Rules of Court.
(7)The board shall formulate and adopt rules of procedure to implement this subdivision.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment upon proof that the attorneys conduct no longer poses a substantial threat of harm to the interests of the attorneys clients or the public or where an attorney who could not be located proves compliance with Section 6002.1.
(d)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(A)The attorney is under a suspension order any portion of which has been stayed during a period of probation.
(B)The State Bar Court finds that probation has been violated.
(C)The State Bar Court recommends to the Supreme Court that the attorney receive an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate an enrollment under this subdivision upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
(3)If the Supreme Court orders a period of actual suspension in the probation matter, any period of involuntary inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited against the period of actual suspension ordered.
(e)(1)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary, inactive enrollment of a licensee whose default has been entered pursuant to the State Bar Rules of Procedure if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The notice was duly served pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 6002.1.
(B)The notice contained the following language at or near the beginning of the notice, in capital letters:
IF YOU FAIL TO FILE AN ANSWER TO THIS NOTICE WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED BY STATE BAR RULES, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS, OR IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE STATE BAR COURT TRIAL, (1) YOUR DEFAULT SHALL BE ENTERED, (2) YOU SHALL BE ENROLLED AS AN INVOLUNTARY INACTIVE LICENSEE OF THE STATE BAR AND WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PRACTICE LAW UNLESS THE DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE ON MOTION TIMELY MADE UNDER THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE STATE BAR, (3) YOU SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE FURTHER IN THESE PROCEEDINGS UNLESS YOUR DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE, AND (4) YOU SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL DISCIPLINE.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision when the licensees default is set aside on motion timely made under the State Bar Rules of Procedure or the disciplinary proceedings are completed.
(3)The enrollment under this subdivision is administrative in character and no hearing is required.
(4)Upon the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision, the notice required by subdivision (b) of Section 6092.5 shall be promptly given.
(f)The pendency or determination of a proceeding or investigation provided for by this section shall not abate or terminate a disciplinary investigation or proceeding except as required by the facts and law in a particular case.
(g)No license fees shall accrue against the licensee during the period they are enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to this section.
(h)The State Bar Court may order a full range of interim remedies or final discipline short of involuntary inactive enrollment, including, but not limited to, conditions of probation following final discipline, or directly ordered interim remedies, to restrict or supervise an attorneys practice of law, as well as proceedings under subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), or under Section 6102 or 6190. They may include restrictions as to scope of practice, monetary accounting procedures, review of performance by probation or other monitors appointed by the board, or such other measures as may be determined, after hearing, to protect present and future clients from likely substantial harm. These restrictions may be imposed upon a showing as provided in subdivision (c).
SEC. 3.SEC. 6.Section 6011 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6011.(a)The board shall appoint an executive director of the State Bar to assist the board in carrying out its executive functions of the State Bar. Bar, who shall be responsible for the leadership and management of the State Bar according to the strategic direction set by the board.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as the executive director of the State Bar. The executive director shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The executive director shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The executive director shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of an executive director.
(c)The appointment of the executive director is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed as the executive director on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 4.SEC. 7.Section 6012 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6012.(a)The board shall appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as general counsel of the State Bar. The general counsel shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The general counsel shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The general counsel shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of a general counsel.
(c)The appointment of the general counsel is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed general counsel on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 5.Section 6046.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6046.6.(a)The State Bar shall not alter the bar examination in a manner that requires the substantial modification of the training or preparation required for passage of the examination, except after giving two years notice of that change. This requirement does not apply to a change in the bar examination that is applicable only at the option of the applicant.(b)The examining committee shall communicate and cooperate with the Law School Council.(c)Scaling may be used on the bar examination for the purpose of maintaining an examination of uniform difficulty from year to year.SEC. 8.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)On the effective date of the measure adding this subdivision, the The selection of the chair and vice chair of the board shall be made by appointment of the Supreme Court.
(b)For 2018, the Supreme Court shall appoint a chair and a vice chair to serve a term that commences upon appointment and ends at the conclusion of the annual meeting in 2018. Thereafter, the term of the The chair and the vice chair shall be one year, and the each be appointed for a term not to exceed two years. The chair and vice chair shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the annual September meeting following their appointment. The chair and vice chair shall not serve more than two terms, except that a chair or vice chair who is appointed to fill a vacancy for the balance of a term is eligible to serve two full terms in addition to the remainder of the term for which he or she was they were appointed.
(c)The president and vice president in place on the effective date of the measure adding this subdivision shall retain their positions until the chair and vice chair are appointed.SEC. 9.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to any of the following:
(1)Appeals from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
(3)The preparation of examination materials, the approval, the grading, or the security of test administration of the California Bar Examination or the First-Year Law Students Examination.
(4)Matters related to the Committee of Bar Examiners consideration of moral character, including allegations of criminal or professional misconduct, competence, or physical or mental health of an individual, requests by applicants for testing accommodations in connection with an application for admission to practice law, or appeals of the Committee of Bar Examiners determinations.
(5)Information about a law schools operations that constitutes a trade secret as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 3426.1 of the Civil Code.
(6)Matters related to the boards consideration of waiving confidentiality related to records of disciplinary proceedings under subdivision (c) of Section 6086.1.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 11125.7 of the Government Code, the State Bar shall accept public comment in open session on all matters that are agendized for discussion or decision by the board of trustees, whether in an open or a closed session.
SEC. 10.Section 6036 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6036.(a)Any member of the board of trustees shall disqualify himself or herself themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the board or a committee of the board State Bar in which he or she the member has a financial interest, as that term is defined in Section 87103 of the Government Code, that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision.
(b)Any member of the board of trustees shall likewise disqualify himself or herself themself when there exists a personal nonfinancial interest that will may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), no member shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent his or her that the members participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made. The fact that a members vote is needed to break a tie does not make his or her the members participation legally required for the purposes of this section.
(d)A member required to disqualify himself or herself themself because of a conflict of interest shall (1)immediately disclose the interest, (2)withdraw from any participation in the matter, (3)refrain from attempting to influence another member, and (4)refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that he or she the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
(e)For purposes of this article and unless otherwise specified, member means any appointed or elected member of the board of trustees.
SEC. 11.Section 6037 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6037.No action or decision of the board or committee of the board State Bar shall be invalid because of the participation therein by a member or members of the board of trustees in violation of Section 6036. However, any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 6036 is guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding five days, or by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both, and, if the member is an attorney member of the board, a certified copy of the record of conviction shall be transmitted to the Supreme Court for disposition as provided in Sections 6101 and 6102. Upon entry of final judgment of conviction, the members term of office on the board of trustees, and duties and authority incidental thereto, shall automatically terminate. Any member who intentionally violates the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 6036 shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500) for each violation, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action in a court of competent jurisdiction brought in the name of the state only by a district attorney of a county in which the member resides or maintains offices and the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of that county.
SEC. 12.Section 6054 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6054.(a)State and local law enforcement and licensing bodies and departments, officers and employees thereof, and officials and attaches of the courts of this state shall cooperate with and give reasonable assistance and information, including the providing of state summary criminal history information and local summary criminal history information, to the State Bar of California or any authorized representative thereof, in connection with any investigation or proceeding within the jurisdiction of the State Bar of California, regarding the admission to the practice of law or discipline of attorneys or their reinstatement to the practice of law.
(b)The State Bar of California shall require that an applicant for admission or reinstatement to the practice of law in California, or may require a licensee licensee, to submit or resubmit fingerprints to the Department of Justice and to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in order to establish the identity of the applicant and in order to determine whether the applicant or licensee has a record of criminal conviction in this state or in other states. The states, including through a national criminal history check.
(c)(1)Pursuant to subdivision (u) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code, the State Bar shall submit to the Department of Justice fingerprint images and related information required by the Department of Justice for all persons applying for admission to the State Bar of California for all applicants for reinstatement, and for licensees that are required to be fingerprinted under Rule 9.9.5 of the California Rules of Court, as it read on January 1, 2023. The Department of Justice shall provide a state or federal level response pursuant to subdivision (p) of Section 11105 of the Penal Code.
(2)As used in this subdivision, applicant for reinstatement means individuals initiating reinstatement proceedings with the State Bar after resignation with or without charges pending and after disbarment.
(d)The State Bar may use the information obtained from the Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation as a result of the fingerprinting of an applicant or licensee licensee, and the State Bars use of that information shall be limited to the official use of the State Bar in establishing the identity of the applicant and in determining the character and fitness of the applicant for admission or reinstatement, and in discovering prior and subsequent criminal arrests of an applicant, licensee, or applicant for reinstatement. The State Bar shall notify the Department of Justice about individuals who are no longer licensees and applicants who are denied admission to the State Bar within 30 days of any change in status of a licensee or denial of admission. All fingerprint records of applicants admitted or licensees reinstated, or provided by a licensee, shall be retained thereafter by the Department of Justice for the limited purpose of criminal arrest notification to the State Bar.
(c)The State Bar shall request from the Department of Justice subsequent arrest notification service, as provided pursuant to Section 11105.2 of the Penal Code, for applicants to, and licensees of, the State Bar.(d)(e)If required to be fingerprinted pursuant to this section, a licensee of the State Bar who fails to be fingerprinted may be enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to rules adopted by the board of trustees.
(e)The State Bar shall report to the Supreme Court and the Legislature by March 15, 2018, regarding its compliance with the requirements of this section.SEC. 6.SEC. 13.Section 6060 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission and a license to practice law, a person who has not been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency or in a foreign country shall:
(a)Be at least 18 years of age.
(b)(1)Be of good moral character.
(2)(A)In reviewing whether an applicant is of good moral character under this subdivision, the staff of the State Bar or the members of the examining committee shall not review or consider the persons medical records relating to mental health, except
if the applicant seeks to use the record for either of the following purposes:
(i)To demonstrate that the applicant is of good moral character.
(ii)As a mitigating factor to explain a specific act of misconduct.
(B)The staff of the State Bar and members of the examining committee shall not request or seek to review any medical records relating to mental health, including by obtaining the consent of the applicant to disclose such records, except as requested by an applicant and for a purpose specified in subparagraph (A).
(c)Before beginning the study of law, have done either of the following:
(1)Completed at least two years of college work, which college work shall be at least one-half of the collegiate work acceptable for a bachelors degree granted on the basis of a four-year period of study by a college or university approved by the State Bar. examining committee.
(2)Have attained in apparent intellectual ability the equivalent of at least two years of college work by taking examinations in subject matters and achieving the scores as are prescribed by the State Bar. examining committee.
(d)Have registered with the State Bar as a law student within 90 days after beginning the study of law. The State Bar, upon a showing of good cause, may permit a later registration.
(e)Have done either of the following:
(1)Had conferred upon them a juris doctor (J.D.) degree or a bachelor of laws (LL.B.) degree by a law school accredited by the examining committee or approved by the American Bar Association.
(2)Studied law diligently and in good faith for at least four years in any of the following manners:
(A)(i)In a law school that is authorized or approved to confer professional degrees and requires classroom attendance of its students for a minimum of 270 hours a year.
(ii)A person who has received their legal education in a foreign state or country where the common law of England does not constitute the basis of jurisprudence shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the State Bar that the persons education, experience, and qualifications qualify them to take the examination.
(B)In a law office in this state and under the personal supervision of a licensee of the State Bar of California who is, and for at least the last five years continuously has been, engaged in the active practice of law. It is the duty of the supervising attorney to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(C)In the chambers and under the personal supervision of a judge of a court of record of this state. It is the duty of the supervising judge to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(D)By instruction in law from a correspondence law school authorized or approved to confer professional degrees by this state, which requires 864 hours of preparation and study per year for four years.
(E)By any combination of the methods referred to in this paragraph.
(f)Have passed any examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar examining committee may prescribe.
(g)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar. examining committee.
(h)(1)Have passed a law students examination administered by the State Bar examining committee after completion of their first year of law study. Those who pass the examination within its first three administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination, shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed. Those who do not pass the examination within the number of administrations allowed by this subdivision, upon becoming eligible to take the examination, but who subsequently pass the examination, shall receive credit for one year of legal study only.
(2)(A)This requirement does not apply to a student who has satisfactorily completed their first year of law study at a law school accredited by the examining committee and who has completed at least two years of college work prior to matriculating in the accredited law school, nor shall this requirement apply to an applicant who has passed the bar examination of a sister state or of a country in which the common law of England constitutes the basis of jurisprudence.
(B)The law students examination shall be administered twice a year at reasonable intervals.
SEC. 7.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).(b)Subject to existing state and federal laws protecting education records, subdivision (a) does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:(1)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the State Bar.(2)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.(3)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements. Beginning with the release of results from the July 2018 bar examination, the information provided to a law school shall also include the bar examination results of the law schools graduates allocated to the law school and the scores of any graduate allocated to the law school who did not pass the bar examination and who consents to the release of the graduates scores to the law school. Consent of a law school graduate to the release of the graduates scores may be obtained by a check-off on the graduates application to take the bar examination. For purposes of this paragraph, scores means the same scores reported to a graduate who did not successfully pass the bar examination.(4)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.(5)This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 7921.505 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other law except existing state and federal laws protecting education records, any information received from an educational or testing entity that is collected by the State Bar for the purpose of conducting a Law School Bar Exam Performance Study as the State Bar has been directed to do by the California Supreme Court by letter dated February 28, 2017, other than aggregate, summary, or statistical data that does not identify any person and does not provide substantial risk of identification of any person, shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).(2)Nothing in this subdivision is intended to impact any litigation pending on the effective date of the measure that added this subdivision.SEC. 8.SEC. 14.Section 6060.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.3.(a)An application to take the California bar examination administered in February must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding November, and an application to take the California bar examination administered in July must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding April. However, an applicant who was unsuccessful on the examination last administered shall be allowed 10 business days from the date of the general announcement of results of that examination in which to timely file an application to take the next scheduled examination.
(b)The State Bar may accept applications to take the California bar examination filed after the timely deadlines specified in subdivision (a) from applicants if the application is accompanied by the timely application fee and the late filing fee fixed by the board as follows:
(1)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the first and last business days in November for the February examination or between the first and last business days of April for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed fifty dollars ($50).
(2)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the last business day of November and January 1 for the February examination or between the last business day of April and June 1 for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(3)An application to take the California bar examination filed after January 1 for the February examination and after June 1 for the July examination shall not be accepted.
(c)Application fees for the California bar examination, including fees for late filing, shall be refunded if the applicant does not take the California bar examination because of the death of an immediate family member or the serious illness or disabling injury of the applicant or a member of their immediate family. A deduction may be made from the refund for administrative costs. The board shall adopt regulations for the administration of this subdivision. This subdivision shall not be construed to prohibit the refund of fees in instances other than those specified.
SEC. 9.Section 6062 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6062.(a)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency the United States may hereafter acquire shall:(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.(2)Be of good moral character.(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar. However, if that person has been an active licensee in good standing of the bar of the admitting sister state or United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for, they may elect to take the Attorneys Examination rather than the general bar examination. Attorneys admitted less than four years and attorneys admitted four years or more in another jurisdiction but who have not been active licensees in good standing of their admitting jurisdiction for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for must take the general bar examination administered to general applicants not admitted as attorneys in other jurisdictions.(4)Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar may prescribe.(b)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a jurisdiction other than in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory shall:(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.(2)Be of good moral character.(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar.(4) Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar may prescribe.(c)The amendments to this section made at the 199798 Regular Session of the Legislature shall be applicable on and after January 1, 1997, and do not constitute a change in, but are declaratory of, existing law.SEC. 10.SEC. 15.Section 6063 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6063.Applicants for admission to practice shall pay such reasonable fees, fixed by the board, as may be necessary to defray the expense of administering the provisions of this chapter, relating to admission to practice. These fees shall be collected by the State Bar and paid into the treasury of the State Bar.
SEC. 11.Section 6064 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6064.(a)Upon certification by the State Bar that the applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit the applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.(b)Upon certification by the State Bar that an applicant who is not lawfully present in the United States has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit that applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.SEC. 12.SEC. 16.Section 6065 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6065.Any applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, shall have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, which shall include the ability to download, save, and print.
SEC. 13.SEC. 17.Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.1.(a)(1)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court shall be public, following a notice to show cause. the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges.
(2)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of the following matters shall be public:
(A)Filings for involuntary inactive enrollment or restriction under subdivision (a), (c), (d), or (e) of Section 6007.
(B)Petitions for reinstatement under Section 6078.
(C)Proceedings for suspension or disbarment under Section 6101 or 6102.
(D)Payment information from the Client Security Fund pursuant to Section 6140.5.
(E)Actions to cease a law practice or assume a law practice under Section 6180 or 6190.
(b)All disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time that formal charges are filed and all investigations of matters identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) are confidential until the formal proceeding identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) is instituted. These investigations shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). This confidentiality requirement may be waived under any of the following exceptions:
(1)The licensee whose conduct is being investigated or has been investigated consents to a public announcement or disclosure.
(2)(A)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar Counsel, with the written concurrence of the chair of the board, may waive confidentiality, but only when if both of the following are met:
(i)Disclosure is warranted for protection of the public and the allegation is based upon provisions of subdivision (c) are inadequate for the protection of the public.
(ii)It is determined that disclosure is necessary to prevent an immediate harm to the public, including, but not limited to, ongoing fraud, theft, or embezzlement.
(B)Under the circumstances in this paragraph, after private notice to the licensee, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities in a manner that preserves the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any entities. Any disclosure made under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(i)Confirms Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(ii)Provides Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(iii)Provides that Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)If the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar chair of the board for any reason declines to exercise the authority provided by this paragraph, or self-disqualifies from acting under this paragraph, paragraph or is otherwise unavailable to act under this paragraph, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar chair of the board shall designate someone to act in that persons on their behalf. Conduct of a licensee that is being inquired into by the State Bar but that is not the subject of a formal investigation shall not be disclosed to the public.
(3)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chief Trial Counsels designee may waive confidentiality pursuant to Section 6044.5.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the board may vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The board shall hold a meeting under this subdivision in closed session.
(A)The board shall provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may may, in advance of the meeting, submit a written statement to the board in writing. for the boards consideration at the meeting. The licensee shall not be permitted to attend the closed session meeting of the board.
(B)When assessing whether to waive confidentiality and to what extent the board shall, at a minimum:
(i)Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality.
(ii)Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public.
(iii)Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public.
(iv)Consider the potential for harm to the reputation of the licensee.
(C)All materials for the boards consideration pursuant to this subdivision, including the written statement from the licensee, shall be confidential and not disclosed as a public record under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)If the board votes to waive confidentiality pursuant to paragraph (1) and only after complying with the requirements in paragraph (3), the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar chair of the board may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public in a manner that preserves the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any generally or to specified individuals or entities. Any disclosure under this paragraph shall include a statement defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and shall be limited to doing some or all of the following:
(A)Confirms Confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(B)Provides Providing a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)Provides that Providing the status of the investigation or proceeding.
(3)Before making any public announcements pursuant to paragraph (1), (2), the State Bar shall provide notice to the licensee pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 413.10) of Title 5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure via email at the address shown on the licensees registration records of the State Bar and via United States mail to the physical address shown on the licensees registration records of all of the following:
(A)The fact that the board has voted to waive confidentiality.
(B)A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public.
(C)That the licensee has five business days from the date of the notice to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
(d)(1)A licensee may file a motion with the State Bar Court to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to subdivision (c). The motion shall be filed within seven court days from the date of the notice issued to the licensee under paragraph (3) of subdivision (c).
(2)If a licensee files a motion under paragraph (1) the proceeding shall be afforded priority on the court State Bar Court calendar, and the matter court shall be heard issue a ruling within 10 court days from the filing of the motion.
(3)The State Bar shall adopt procedures to enact the provisions of this subdivision via the rulemaking process.
(4)All hearings on motions pursuant to this subdivision shall be confidential.
(e)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the State Bar shall disclose to any member of the public so inquiring, any information reasonably available to it pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068, and to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, and 6101, concerning a licensee of the State Bar that is otherwise a matter of public record, including civil or criminal filings and dispositions.
SEC. 14.SEC. 18.Section 6086.15 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.15.(a)The State Bar shall issue an Annual Discipline Report by November 30 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Except as set forth in subdivision (d), the report shall cover the period from July 1 of the previous calendar year to June 30 of the year in which the report is issued and shall include accurate and complete descriptions of all of the following:
(1)The inventory of cases within the Office of Chief Trial Counsel which were open at the start of the reporting period, were opened during the reporting period, remain pending with the office at the close of the reporting period, or were disposed of during the reporting period by closure, by filing of a stipulation with the State Bar Court, by filing of a notice of disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court, or by transmittal of a criminal conviction to the State Bar Court. The State Bar shall also report on its success in meeting the case processing goals set forth in Section 6094.5, including, but not limited to, tables showing the number and percentage of cases meeting each goal, the number and percentage of those cases not disposed of within the case processing goals, and a high-level explanation of the reasons for failing to meet those case processing goals. The inventory of cases shall not be limited to case types that could result in the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court, but shall also include Nonattorney Unauthorized Practice of Law (NA-UPL), Section 6007 matters, moral character matters, resignations with charges pending, and mini-reinstatements.
(2)The number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition.
(3)The number, average pending times, and types of matters self-reported by licensees of the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068 and subdivision (c) of Section 6086.8.
(4)The number, average pending times, and types of matters reported by other sources pursuant to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, 6091.1, subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6101, and Section 6175.6.
(5)The speed of complaint handling and dispositions by type, measured by the median and the average processing times.
(6)The number, average pending times, and types of filed notices of disciplinary charges and formal disciplinary outcomes.
(7)The number, average pending times, and types of other matters, including petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180 or 6190, interim suspensions and license restrictions pursuant to Section 6007, motions to enforce a binding arbitration award, judgment, or agreement pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 6203, motions to revoke probation, letters of warning, private reprovals, admonitions, and agreements in lieu of discipline.
(8)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints involving a State Bar licensee who has been disbarred or who has resigned, and is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities, or petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180.
(9)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints against nonattorneys engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities; petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6126.3; or referrals to prosecuting authorities or actions by the State Bar pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(10)A description of the condition of the Client Security Fund, including an accounting of payouts.
(11)An accounting of the cost of the discipline system by function.
(12)Compliance with the requirement of Section 6101 to transmit, within 30 days of receipt, the record of any criminal conviction which involves or may involve moral turpitude to the Supreme Court, or to close the matter if transmittal to the Supreme Court is not appropriate.
(b)The Annual Discipline Report shall include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison.
(c)The Annual Discipline Report shall be presented to the Chief Justice of California, to the Governor, to the Speaker of the Assembly, to the President pro Tempore of the Senate, and to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees, for their consideration and shall be considered a public document.
(d)(1)All data relating to the items set forth in subdivision (a) shall also be reported, if available, for the preceding five years. Data from 2020 and prior years shall be reported for the calendar year. Except as specified in paragraph (2), data from 2021 and future years shall be reported based on the state fiscal year.
(2)The Annual Discipline Report due on October 31, 2022, shall include data from both the prior state fiscal year and the prior calendar year.
SEC. 15.SEC. 19.Section 6086.20 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6086.20.(a)Commencing January 1, 2025, the Chief Trial Counsel shall not issue private letters of reprisal reprovals to any attorney accused of misconduct.
(b)On or before April 1, 2024, the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, shall provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
SEC. 16.SEC. 20.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, in or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, in any of the following shall inform the State Bar. Bar:
(A)Seditious conspiracy as prohibited under Section 2384 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(B)Treason as prohibited under Section 37 of the Penal Code or Section 2381 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(C)Rebellion or insurrection as prohibited under Section 2383 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
(2)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SEC. 17.SEC. 21.Section 6102 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6102.(a)Upon the receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, the Supreme Court shall suspend the attorney until the time for appeal has elapsed, if no appeal has been taken, or until the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or has otherwise become final, and until the further order of the court. Upon its own motion or upon good cause shown, the court may decline to impose, or may set aside, the suspension when it appears to be in the interest of justice to do so, with due regard being given to maintaining the integrity of, and confidence in, the profession.
(b)For the purposes of this section, a crime is a felony under the law of California if it is declared to be so specifically or by subdivision (a) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, unless it is charged as a misdemeanor pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, irrespective of whether in a particular case the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings, including proceedings resulting in punishment or probation set forth in paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code.
(c)After the judgment of conviction of an offense specified in subdivision (a) has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code or similar statutory provision, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence, the Supreme Court shall summarily disbar the attorney if the offense is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, and either: (1) an element of the offense is the specific intent to deceive, defraud, steal, or make or suborn a false statement, or involved moral turpitude, or (2) the facts and circumstances of the offense involved moral turpitude.
(d)For purposes of this section, a conviction under the laws of another state or territory of the United States shall be deemed a felony if: if both of the following apply:
(1)The judgment or conviction was entered as a felony irrespective of any subsequent order suspending sentence or granting probation and irrespective of whether the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings.
(2)The elements of the offense for which the licensee was convicted would constitute a felony under the laws of the State of California at the time the offense was committed.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), if after adequate notice and opportunity to be heard (which hearing shall not be had until the judgment of conviction has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence), the court finds that the crime of which the attorney was convicted, or the circumstances of its commission, involved moral turpitude, it shall enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case; otherwise it shall determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline. In determining the extent of the discipline to be imposed in a proceeding pursuant to this article, any prior discipline imposed upon the attorney may be considered.
(f)The court may refer the proceedings or any part thereof or issue therein, including the nature or extent of discipline, to the State Bar for hearing, report, and recommendation.
(g)The record of the proceedings resulting in the conviction, including a transcript of the testimony therein, may be received in evidence.
(h)The Supreme Court shall prescribe rules for the practice and procedure in proceedings conducted pursuant to this section and Section 6101.
(i)The other provisions of this article providing a procedure for the disbarment or suspension of an attorney do not apply to proceedings pursuant to this section and Section 6101, unless expressly made applicable.
SEC. 18.SEC. 22.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding three hundred ninety dollars ($390).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 19.SEC. 23.Section 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.5.(a)The board shall establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of licensees of the State Bar, foreign legal consultants registered with the State Bar, and attorneys registered with the State Bar under the Multijurisdictional Practice Program, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Any payments from the fund shall be discretionary and shall be subject to regulation, conditions, and rules as the board shall prescribe. The board may delegate the administration of the fund to the State Bar Court, or to any board or committee created by the board of trustees.
(b)Upon making a payment to a person who has applied to the fund for payment to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of a licensee, the State Bar is subrogated, to the extent of that payment, to the rights of the applicant against any person or persons who, or entity that, caused the pecuniary loss. The State Bar may bring an action to enforce those rights within three years from the date of payment to the applicant.
(c)Any licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund shall owe those funds to the State Bar and reimburse the Client Security Fund for all moneys paid out as a result of the licensees conduct with interest, in addition to payment of the assessment for the procedural costs of processing the claim. The State Bar may collect any money paid out by the Client Security Fund pursuant to this subdivision through any means provided by law. The licensees obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund pursuant to this section is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California, a public corporation created pursuant to Article VI of the California Constitution, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
(d)For a publicly reproved or suspended licensee, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of continued practice. This amount shall be added to and become a part of the license fee of a publicly reproved or suspended licensee.
(e)For a licensee who resigns with disciplinary charges pending or a licensee who is resigned or disbarred, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of applying for reinstatement of the licensees license to practice law or return to active license status.
(f)Any assessment against an attorney pursuant to subdivision (c) that is part of an order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is part of an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or any reimbursed amount that is part of a final determination by the Client Security Fund, may also be enforced as a money judgment. This subdivision does not limit the power of the Supreme Court to alter the restitution amount owed pursuant to an order imposing public reproval on a licensee or an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or to authorize the State Bar Court to do the same.
(g)To obtain a money judgment pursuant to subdivision (f) that is not part of a court order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is not part of a court order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, the State Bar shall file a certified copy of the Notice of Payment of the Client Security Fund with the clerk of the superior court of any county. The clerk shall immediately enter judgment in conformity with the Notice of Payment. The judgment shall have the same force and effect as a judgment in a civil action and may be enforced in the same manner as any other judgment.
(h)The defense of laches shall not be raised by the licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund with respect to any payment owed to the State Bar, or with respect to any collections efforts by the State Bar for those payments.
(i)Subdivisions (c), (f), and (h) have, and shall have, retroactive application, as well as prospective application.
(j)As used in this section, licensee shall include a foreign legal consultant registered with the State Bar.
SEC. 24.Section 6140.55 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the board may disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the Client Security Fund, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 25.Section 6140.55 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.55.(a)The board may increase the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6140 by an additional amount per active licensee not to exceed forty dollars ($40), and the annual license fees fixed by it pursuant to Section 6141 by an additional amount per inactive licensee not to exceed ten dollars ($10), in any year, the additional amount to be applied only for the purposes of the Client Security Fund and the costs of its administration, including, but not limited to, the costs of processing, determining, defending, or insuring claims against the fund.
(b)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 26.Section 6140.9 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation, established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (d), the board may also disburse or appropriate any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, to the State Bars general fund.
(2)Any funds disbursed or transferred pursuant to paragraph (1) shall first be used to cover salaries and benefits of employees in bargaining units for which a memorandum of understanding has been agreed to by the State Bar before being used for any other purpose.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 27.Section 6140.9 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.9.(a)Moneys for the support of the program established pursuant to Article 15 (commencing with Section 6230), treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay, and related programs approved by the committee established pursuant to Section 6231 shall be paid in whole or part by a fee of ten dollars ($10) per active licensee per year, and by a fee of five dollars ($5) per inactive licensee per year, except that for 2020 only, the fee shall be one dollar ($1) per active licensee and zero dollars ($0) per inactive licensee. The State Bar is not required to expend any additional funds to either support those programs or to provide treatment services for those who cannot afford to pay.
(b)On and after January 1, 2019, one dollar ($1) of the ten-dollar ($10) fee paid by each active licensee pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be transferred by the State Bar to a statewide nonprofit corporation established by attorneys that has, for the last 25 years or more, provided peer support to attorneys recovering from alcohol and substance abuse in a confidential and anonymous manner, to fund the support of recovery efforts of the nonprofit corporation. In 2020 only, the statewide nonprofit corporation shall receive the one-dollar ($1) fee paid by each active licensee.
(c)Any nonprofit corporation that receives funds pursuant to subdivision (b) shall submit an annual report to the State Bar accounting for the use of the funds. The report shall be submitted to the State Bar no later than March 1, 2020, and no later than March 1 of each year thereafter. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(1)An accounting of all receipts and expenditures of the funds.
(2)The balance of the funds as of the end of the previous calendar year.
(3)A brief narrative describing the goals of the work supported by the expenditures.
(4)A summary of the number of clients served, the modality of treatment, and any outcome data on the impact of the treatment.
(d)The board may seek alternative sources for funding the program. Any excess funds not needed to support the program, including reserve funds, may be transferred to fund the Client Security Fund established pursuant to Section 6140.5, provided there are sufficient funds available to fully support the program.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 20.SEC. 28.Section 6141 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6141.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding ninety-seven dollars and forty cents ($97.40). The annual license fee for inactive licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year.
(b)An inactive licensee shall not be required to pay the annual license fee for inactive licensees for any calendar year following the calendar year in which the licensee attains 70 years of age.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 21.SEC. 29.Section 6144.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6144.1.(a)The net proceeds from the sale of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. The net proceeds from the lease of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be used by the State Bar for the protection of the public.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, may be utilized by the State Bar to cover employee salaries, and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
(c)All proceeds expended not consistent with subdivision (b) shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
SEC. 22.SEC. 30.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the chief financial officer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted annually, on or before May 31, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory fees are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)For the 2023 audit required pursuant to subdivision (b), the California State Auditors Office shall conduct a performance audit of the State Bar as set forth in this subdivision. The State Bar shall provide technical assistance, data, or information as requested by the California State Auditor. It is the intent of the Legislature that this audit may be reviewed in conjunction with the legislation that authorizes the State Bars licensing fee in 2023.
(2)The audit shall evaluate each program or division of the State Bar receiving support from the annual State Bar licensing fees and other fees required of active and inactive licensees.
(3)The audit shall, at minimum, include all of the following for each program or division described by paragraph (2):
(A)An assessment of how much fee revenue, staff, and resources are currently budgeted and subsequently expended to perform existing tasks and responsibilities.
(B)An assessment of whether the State Bar has appropriate program performance measures in place and how these measures are used for budgeting purposes.
(C)An assessment of the usage of any real property sold by the State Bar.
(D)A review of the State Bars cost allocation plan used to allocate administrative costs.
(E)A review of any proposals for additional funding or resources requested by the State Bar to determine whether these proposals are necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function, as well as the accuracy of identified associated funding needs, after reviewing how existing resources are used.
(F)A calculation of how much fee revenue would be needed from each State Bar active and inactive licensee to fully offset State Bar costs to perform existing tasks and responsibilities and to support additional proposed expenditures determined to be necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function. This calculation shall take into account any proposed business process reengineering, reallocations, or efficiencies identified by the California State Auditor.
(4)The audit shall include an evaluation of how the State Bar administers discipline cases that require an outside investigator or prosecutor and how that process can be improved, including the cost-effectiveness and timeliness of such investigations and prosecutions.
(5)The audit required by this subdivision shall be submitted by April 15, 2023, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(6)The State Bar shall use existing resources to reimburse the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit required by this subdivision.
SEC. 31.Section 6145.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to immediately follow Section 6145, to read:6145.1.(a)(1)The California State Bar shall prepare a report providing written justification for how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fee authorized by Section 6140 for active licensees and Section 6141 for inactive licensees. It is the intent of the Legislature to review this report in conjunction with legislation authorizing the State Bars licensing fee in 2025.
(2)This report shall include the State Bars calculation of the necessary fee increase to maintain its existing operations and service levels and provide clear justification for any differences from the amounts calculated by the California State Auditor in its April 2023 audit.
(3)This report shall also include the State Bars assessment of all programs and activities that require additional support from the annual license fee. For each program and activity, this assessment shall include all of the following:
(A)A detailed description of the program and activity.
(B)The projected, budgeted, and actual expenditures in 2023, 2024, and 2025 assuming no increase in the annual fee.
(C)The estimated deficit and the reason for the deficit.
(D)What aspects of the programs or activities would not be achievable if a fee increase was not provided.
(E)Complete, actual data for 2023.
(4)This report shall also include information on how the State Bar proposes to use any potential additional funding resulting from any potential increase in the mandatory annual license fee. Specifically, for every twenty-five-dollar ($25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for active licensees and corresponding six dollars and twenty-five-cent ($6.25) incremental increase in the mandatory annual license fee for inactive licenses the State Bar shall report, at a minimum, the following:
(A)The total amount of revenue estimated to be generated from the incremental increase.
(B)A description of which State Bar programs and activities would be funded by the revenue generated from the incremental increase and any recent major operational or procedural changes implemented in those programs and activities.
(C)In cases where a program or activity identified pursuant to paragraph (3) is proposed to receive funding, detailed justification for the amount of funding proposed to be used to support the program or activity, how that amount was calculated along with any key assumptions made, what outcomes are expected to be achieved, and what, if any, deficit would remain for the activity or program along with what aspects of the activity or program would be unachievable due to the deficit. This justification shall also clearly specify the extent to which the funding is or will be used to complete business process reengineering, improve processes, or improve efficiencies.
(5)The information provided pursuant to paragraph (4) shall reflect the State Bars actual planned use of the funding for each potential incremental increase and the State Bar shall not assume that it may redirect the funding for other purposes should an increase in the annual fee be approved.
(6)This report shall be submitted no later than April 1, 2024, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(b)In addition to the report required by subdivision (a), the State Bar shall provide a progress report on the Office of Chief Trial Counsels case processing standards, which shall be submitted pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a). This progress report shall include, but is not limited to, the following:
(1)The status of changes made to case disciplinary processes and an assessment of how those changes are impacting case processing times.
(2)A discussion of how concerns related to operational efficiency raised by the California State Auditor and the Legislative Analysts Office have been addressed or are planned to be addressed.
(3)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed average case processing standards. This assessment shall also include data on the timeliness of the completion of the hearing stage in order to provide a comprehensive picture of case processing times.
(4)An assessment of how recent case processing times compare to the State Bars proposed backlog standards, as well as the proposed standards calculated using pending rather than closed workload as discussed by the Legislative Analysts January 2023 report.
SEC. 23.SEC. 32.Section 6238 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 24.SEC. 33.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 13 Sections 9 and 17 of this act, which amends Section amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code, imposes impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Due to the confidential nature of the information that the Board of Trustees will be considering, it is necessary that their consideration of the information be done in closed session.
SEC. 34.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the State Bar maintain its commitment to and support of effective policies and activities to enhance access, fairness, and diversity in the legal profession and the elimination of bias in the practice of law.
(b)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The rich diversity of the people of California requires a justice system that is equally accessible and free of bias and is a core value of the legal profession.
(2)Diversity and inclusion are an integral part of the State Bars public protection mission to build, retain, and maintain a diverse legal profession to provide quality and culturally sensitive services to an ever-increasing diverse population.
(3)Diversity increases public trust and confidence and the appearance of fairness in the justice system and therefore increases access to justice.
(4)The State Bar should continue to increase diversity and inclusion in the legal profession.
(c)The State Bar shall develop and implement a plan to meet the goals set forth in this section, which may include, but is not limited to, an assessment of needed revenue. The State Bar shall prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 30, 2019, and every two years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, including a description of activities undertaken to support the plan, their outcomes, and their effectiveness.
SEC. 2.Section 6007 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6007.(a)When a licensee requires involuntary treatment pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of, or Part 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or when under an order pursuant to Section 3051, 3106.5, or 3152 of the Welfare and Institutions Code they have been placed in or returned to inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or when they have been determined insane or mentally incompetent and is confined for treatment or placed on outpatient status pursuant to the Penal Code, or on account of their mental condition a guardian or conservator, for their estate or person or both, has been appointed, the Board of Trustees or an officer of the State Bar shall enroll the licensee as an inactive licensee.
The clerk of any court making an order containing any of the determinations or adjudications referred to in the immediately preceding paragraph shall send a certified copy of that order to the State Bar at the same time that the order is entered.
The clerk of any court with which is filed a notice of certification for intensive treatment pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, upon receipt of the notice, shall transmit a certified copy of it to the State Bar.
The State Bar may procure a certified copy of any determination, order, adjudication, appointment, or notice when the clerk concerned has failed to transmit one or when the proceeding was had in a court other than a court of this state.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar shall terminate the enrollment when the licensee has had the fact of their restoration to capacity judicially determined, upon the licensees release from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches pursuant to Section 3053, 3109, or 3151 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or upon the licensees unconditional release from the medical facility pursuant to Section 5304 or 5305 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; and on payment of all fees required.
When a licensee is placed in, returned to, or released from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or discharged from the narcotics treatment program, the Director of Corrections or their designee shall transmit to the State Bar a certified notice attesting to that fact.
(b)The State Bar Court shall also enroll a licensee of the State Bar as an inactive licensee in each of the following cases:
(1)A licensee asserts a claim of insanity or mental incompetence in any pending action or proceeding, alleging their inability to understand the nature of the action or proceeding or inability to assist counsel in representation of the licensee.
(2)The court makes an order assuming jurisdiction over the licensees law practice, pursuant to Section 6180.5 or 6190.34.
(3)After notice and opportunity to be heard before the State Bar Court, the State Bar Court finds that the licensee, because of mental infirmity or illness, or because of the habitual use of intoxicants or drugs, is (i) unable or habitually fails to perform their duties or undertakings competently, or (ii) unable to practice law without substantial threat of harm to the interests of their clients or the public. No proceeding pursuant to this paragraph shall be instituted unless the State Bar Court finds, after preliminary investigation, or during the course of a disciplinary proceeding, that probable cause exists therefor. The determination of probable cause is administrative in character and no notice or hearing is required.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the enrollment upon proof that the facts found as to the licensees disability no longer exist and on payment of all fees required.
(c)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon a finding based on all the available evidence, including affidavits, that the attorney has not complied with Section 6002.1 and cannot be located after reasonable investigation.
(2)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney if it finds, based on all the available evidence, including affidavits:
(A)The attorney has caused or is causing substantial harm to the attorneys clients or the public.
(B)There is a reasonable probability that the chief trial counsel will prevail on the merits of the underlying disciplinary matter, and that the attorney will be disbarred.
(3)In the case of an enrollment under paragraph (2), the underlying matter shall proceed on an expedited basis.
(4)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon the filing of a recommendation of disbarment after hearing or default. For purposes of this section, that attorney shall be placed on involuntary inactive enrollment regardless of the license status of the attorney at the time.
(5)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney who is sentenced to incarceration for 90 days or more as a result of a criminal conviction for at least the period of time in which the attorney is incarcerated.
(6)The State Bar Court shall order attorneys who are placed on inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision to comply with Rule 9.20 of the California Rules of Court.
(7)The board shall formulate and adopt rules of procedure to implement this subdivision.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment upon proof that the attorneys conduct no longer poses a substantial threat of harm to the interests of the attorneys clients or the public or where an attorney who could not be located proves compliance with Section 6002.1.
(d)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(A)The attorney is under a suspension order any portion of which has been stayed during a period of probation.
(B)The State Bar Court finds that probation has been violated.
(C)The State Bar Court recommends to the Supreme Court that the attorney receive an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate an enrollment under this subdivision upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
(3)If the Supreme Court orders a period of actual suspension in the probation matter, any period of involuntary inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited against the period of actual suspension ordered.
(e)(1)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary, inactive enrollment of a licensee whose default has been entered pursuant to the State Bar Rules of Procedure if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The notice was duly served pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 6002.1.
(B)The notice contained the following language at or near the beginning of the notice, in capital letters:
IF YOU FAIL TO FILE AN ANSWER TO THIS NOTICE WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED BY STATE BAR RULES, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS, OR IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE STATE BAR COURT TRIAL, (1) YOUR DEFAULT SHALL BE ENTERED, (2) YOU SHALL BE ENROLLED AS AN INVOLUNTARY INACTIVE LICENSEE OF THE STATE BAR AND WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PRACTICE LAW UNLESS THE DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE ON MOTION TIMELY MADE UNDER THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE STATE BAR, (3) YOU SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE FURTHER IN THESE PROCEEDINGS UNLESS YOUR DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE, AND (4) YOU SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL DISCIPLINE.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision when the licensees default is set aside on motion timely made under the State Bar Rules of Procedure or the disciplinary proceedings are completed.
(3)The enrollment under this subdivision is administrative in character and no hearing is required.
(4)Upon the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision, the notice required by subdivision (b) of Section 6092.5 shall be promptly given.
(f)The pendency or determination of a proceeding or investigation provided for by this section shall not abate or terminate a disciplinary investigation or proceeding except as required by the facts and law in a particular case.
(g)No license fees shall accrue against the licensee during the period they are enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to this section.
(h)The State Bar Court may order a full range of interim remedies or final discipline short of involuntary inactive enrollment, including, but not limited to, conditions of probation following final discipline, or directly ordered interim remedies, to restrict or supervise an attorneys practice of law, as well as proceedings under subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), or under Section 6102 or 6190. They may include restrictions as to scope of practice, monetary accounting procedures, review of performance by probation or other monitors appointed by the board, or such other measures as may be determined, after hearing, to protect present and future clients from likely substantial harm. These restrictions may be imposed upon a showing as provided in subdivision (c).
SEC. 3.Section 6011 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6011.(a)The board shall appoint an executive director of the State Bar to assist the board in carrying out its executive functions of the State Bar.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as the executive director of the State Bar. The executive director shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The executive director shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The executive director shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of an executive director.
(c)The appointment of the executive director is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed as the executive director on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 4.Section 6012 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6012.(a)The board shall appoint a general counsel of the State Bar to serve as the chief legal advisor to the board on issues not related to attorney discipline.
(b)The board shall appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as general counsel of the State Bar. The general counsel shall be appointed for a term of four years and may be reappointed for additional four-year terms. The general counsel shall serve at the pleasure of the board. The general counsel shall not engage in private practice. The State Bar shall notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of a general counsel.
(c)The appointment of the general counsel is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in Section 1774 of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office are applicable to the appointment.
(d)This section applies to persons appointed general counsel on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.SEC. 5.Section 6046.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6046.6.(a)The State Bar shall not alter the bar examination in a manner that requires the substantial modification of the training or preparation required for passage of the examination, except after giving two years notice of that change. This requirement does not apply to a change in the bar examination that is applicable only at the option of the applicant.
(b)The examining committee shall communicate and cooperate with the Law School Council.
(c)Scaling may be used on the bar examination for the purpose of maintaining an examination of uniform difficulty from year to year.
SEC. 4.SEC. 6.Section 6060 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission and a license to practice law, a person who has not been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency or in a foreign country shall:
(a)Be at least 18 years of age.
(b)(1)Be of good moral character.
(2)(A)In reviewing whether an applicant is of good moral character under this subdivision, the staff of the State Bar or the members of the examining committee shall not review or consider the persons medical records relating to mental health, except
if the applicant seeks to use the record for either of the following purposes:
(i)To demonstrate that the applicant is of good moral character.
(ii)As a mitigating factor to explain a specific act of misconduct.
(B)The staff of the State Bar and members of the examining committee shall not request or seek to review any medical records relating to mental health, including by obtaining the consent of the applicant to disclose such records, except as requested by an applicant and for a purpose specified in subparagraph (A).
(c)Before beginning the study of law, have done either of the following:
(1)Completed at least two years of college work, which college work shall be at least one-half of the collegiate work acceptable for a bachelors degree granted on the basis of a four-year period of study by a college or university approved by the State Bar.
(2)Have attained in apparent intellectual ability the equivalent of at least two years of college work by taking examinations in subject matters and achieving the scores as are prescribed by the State Bar.
(d)Have registered with the State Bar as a law student within 90 days after beginning the study of law. The State Bar, upon a showing of good cause, may permit a later registration.
(e)Have done either of the following:
(1)Had conferred upon them a juris doctor (J.D.) degree or a bachelor of laws (LL.B.) degree by a law school accredited by the examining committee or approved by the American Bar Association.
(2)Studied law diligently and in good faith for at least four years in any of the following manners:
(A)(i)In a law school that is authorized or approved to confer professional degrees and requires classroom attendance of its students for a minimum of 270 hours a year.
(ii)A person who has received their legal education in a foreign state or country where the common law of England does not constitute the basis of jurisprudence shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the State Bar that the persons education, experience, and qualifications qualify them to take the examination.
(B)In a law office in this state and under the personal supervision of a licensee of the State Bar of California who is, and for at least the last five years continuously has been, engaged in the active practice of law. It is the duty of the supervising attorney to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(C)In the chambers and under the personal supervision of a judge of a court of record of this state. It is the duty of the supervising judge to render any periodic reports to the State Bar as required.
(D)By instruction in law from a correspondence law school authorized or approved to confer professional degrees by this state, which requires 864 hours of preparation and study per year for four years.
(E)By any combination of the methods referred to in this paragraph.
(f)Have passed any examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar may prescribe.
(g)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar.
(h)(1)Have passed a law students examination administered by the State Bar after completion of their first year of law study. Those who pass the examination within its first three administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination, shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed. Those who do not pass the examination within the number of administrations allowed by this subdivision, upon becoming eligible to take the examination, but who subsequently pass the examination, shall receive credit for one year of legal study only.
(2)(A)This requirement does not apply to a student who has satisfactorily completed their first year of law study at a law school accredited by the examining committee and who has completed at least two years of college work prior to matriculating in the accredited law school, nor shall this requirement apply to an applicant who has passed the bar examination of a sister state or of a country in which the common law of England constitutes the basis of jurisprudence.
(B)The law students examination shall be administered twice a year at reasonable intervals.
SEC. 5.SEC. 7.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)Subject to existing state and federal laws protecting education records, subdivision (a) does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(1)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the State Bar.
(2)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(3)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements. Beginning with the release of results from the July 2018 bar examination, the information provided to a law school shall also include the bar examination results of the law schools graduates allocated to the law school and the scores of any graduate allocated to the law school who did not pass the bar examination and who consents to the release of the graduates scores to the law school. Consent of a law school graduate to the release of the graduates scores may be obtained by a check-off on the graduates application to take the bar examination. For purposes of this paragraph, scores means the same scores reported to a graduate who did not successfully pass the bar examination.
(4)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(5)This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 7921.505 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other law except existing state and federal laws protecting education records, any information received from an educational or testing entity that is collected by the State Bar for the purpose of conducting a Law School Bar Exam Performance Study as the State Bar has been directed to do by the California Supreme Court by letter dated February 28, 2017, other than aggregate, summary, or statistical data that does not identify any person and does not provide substantial risk of identification of any person, shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)Nothing in this subdivision is intended to impact any litigation pending on the effective date of the measure that added this subdivision.
SEC. 6.SEC. 8.Section 6060.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.3.(a)An application to take the California bar examination administered in February must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding November, and an application to take the California bar examination administered in July must be filed with the State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding April. However, an applicant who was unsuccessful on the examination last administered shall be allowed 10 business days from the date of the general announcement of results of that examination in which to timely file an application to take the next scheduled examination.
(b)The State Bar may accept applications to take the California bar examination filed after the timely deadlines specified in subdivision (a) from applicants if the application is accompanied by the timely application fee and the late filing fee fixed by the board as follows:
(1)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the first and last business days in November for the February examination or between the first and last business days of April for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed fifty dollars ($50).
(2)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the last business day of November and January 1 for the February examination or between the last business day of April and June 1 for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(3)An application to take the California bar examination filed after January 1 for the February examination and after June 1 for the July examination shall not be accepted.
(c)Application fees for the California bar examination, including fees for late filing, shall be refunded if the applicant does not take the California bar examination because of the death of an immediate family member or the serious illness or disabling injury of the applicant or a member of their immediate family. A deduction may be made from the refund for administrative costs. The board shall adopt regulations for the administration of this subdivision. This subdivision shall not be construed to prohibit the refund of fees in instances other than those specified.
SEC. 7.SEC. 9.Section 6062 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6062.(a)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency the United States may hereafter acquire shall:
(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.
(2)Be of good moral character.
(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar. However, if that person has been an active licensee in good standing of the bar of the admitting sister state or United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for, they may elect to take the Attorneys Examination rather than the general bar examination. Attorneys admitted less than four years and attorneys admitted four years or more in another jurisdiction but who have not been active licensees in good standing of their admitting jurisdiction for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for must take the general bar examination administered to general applicants not admitted as attorneys in other jurisdictions.
(4)Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar may prescribe.
(b)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a jurisdiction other than in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory shall:
(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.
(2)Be of good moral character.
(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the State Bar.
(4) Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the State Bar may prescribe.
(c)The amendments to this section made at the 199798 Regular Session of the Legislature shall be applicable on and after January 1, 1997, and do not constitute a change in, but are declaratory of, existing law.
SEC. 8.SEC. 10.Section 6063 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6063.Applicants for admission to practice shall pay such reasonable fees, fixed by the board, as may be necessary to defray the expense of administering the provisions of this chapter, relating to admission to practice. These fees shall be collected by the State Bar and paid into the treasury of the State Bar.
SEC. 9.SEC. 11.Section 6064 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6064.(a)Upon certification by the State Bar that the applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit the applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.
(b)Upon certification by the State Bar that an applicant who is not lawfully present in the United States has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit that applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.
SEC. 10.SEC. 12.Section 6065 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6065.Any applicant for admission to practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, shall have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, which shall include the ability to download, save, and print.
SEC. 11.SEC. 13.Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.1.(a)(1)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court shall be public, following a notice to show cause.
(2)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of the following matters shall be public:
(A)Filings for involuntary inactive enrollment or restriction under subdivision (a), (c), (d), or (e) of Section 6007.
(B)Petitions for reinstatement under Section 6078.
(C)Proceedings for suspension or disbarment under Section 6101 or 6102.
(D)Payment information from the Client Security Fund pursuant to Section 6140.5.
(E)Actions to cease a law practice or assume a law practice under Section 6180 or 6190.
(b)All disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time that formal charges are filed and all investigations of matters identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) are confidential until the formal proceeding identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) is instituted. These investigations shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). This confidentiality requirement may be waived under any of the following exceptions:
(1)The licensee whose conduct is being investigated or has been investigated consents to a public announcement or disclosure.
(2)(A)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. public and the allegation is based upon an immediate harm to the public, including, but not limited to, ongoing fraud, theft, or embezzlement.
(B)Under the circumstances in this paragraph, after private notice to the licensee, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public generally or to specified individuals or entities that defends in a manner that preserves the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
(i)Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(ii)Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(iii)Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)If the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar for any reason declines to exercise the authority provided by this paragraph, or self-disqualifies from acting under this paragraph, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar shall designate someone to act in that persons behalf. Conduct of a licensee that is being inquired into by the State Bar but that is not the subject of a formal investigation shall not be disclosed to the public.
(3)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chief Trial Counsels designee may waive confidentiality pursuant to Section 6044.5.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the board may vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The board shall hold a meeting under this subdivision in closed session.
(A)The board shall provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may submit a written statement to the board in writing.
(B)When assessing whether to waive confidentiality and to what extent the board shall, at a minimum:
(i)Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality.
(ii)Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public.
(iii)Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public.
(iv)Consider the potential for harm to the reputation of the licensee.
(2)If the board votes to waive confidentiality and only after complying with the requirements in paragraph (3), the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public that defends in a manner that preserves the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
(A)Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(B)Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
(3)Before making any public announcements pursuant to paragraph (1), the State Bar shall provide notice to the licensee pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 413.10) of Title 5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure of all of the following:
(A)The fact that the board has voted to waive confidentiality.
(B)A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public.
(C)That the licensee has five days to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
(d)(1) A licensee may file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to subdivision (c).
(2)If a licensee files a motion under paragraph (1) the proceeding shall be afforded priority on the court calendar, and the matter shall be heard within 10 days from the filing of the motion.
(e)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the State Bar shall disclose to any member of the public so inquiring, any information reasonably available to it pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068, and to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, and 6101, concerning a licensee of the State Bar that is otherwise a matter of public record, including civil or criminal filings and dispositions.
SEC. 12.SEC. 14.Section 6086.15 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.15.(a)The State Bar shall issue an Annual Discipline Report by November 30 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Except as set forth in subdivision (d), the report shall cover the period from July 1 of the previous calendar year to June 30 of the year in which the report is issued and shall include accurate and complete descriptions of all of the following:
(1)The inventory of cases within the Office of Chief Trial Counsel which were open at the start of the reporting period, were opened during the reporting period, remain pending with the office at the close of the reporting period, or were disposed of during the reporting period by closure, by filing of a stipulation with the State Bar Court, by filing of a notice of disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court, or by transmittal of a criminal conviction to the State Bar Court. The State Bar shall also report on its success in meeting the case processing goals set forth in Section 6094.5, including, but not limited to, tables showing the number and percentage of cases meeting each goal, the number and percentage of those cases not disposed of within the case processing goals, and a high-level explanation of the reasons for failing to meet those case processing goals. The inventory of cases shall not be limited to case types that could result in the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court, but shall also include Nonattorney Unauthorized Practice of Law (NA-UPL), Section 6007 matters, moral character matters, resignations with charges pending, and mini-reinstatements.
(2)The number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition.
(3)The number, average pending times, and types of matters self-reported by licensees of the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068 and subdivision (c) of Section 6086.8.
(4)The number, average pending times, and types of matters reported by other sources pursuant to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, 6091.1, subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6101, and Section 6175.6.
(5)The speed of complaint handling and dispositions by type, measured by the median and the average processing times.
(6)The number, average pending times, and types of filed notices of disciplinary charges and formal disciplinary outcomes.
(7)The number, average pending times, and types of other matters, including petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180 or 6190, interim suspensions and license restrictions pursuant to Section 6007, motions to enforce a binding arbitration award, judgment, or agreement pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 6203, motions to revoke probation, letters of warning, private reprovals, admonitions, and agreements in lieu of discipline.
(8)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints involving a State Bar licensee who has been disbarred or who has resigned, and is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities, or petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180.
(9)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints against nonattorneys engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities; petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6126.3; or referrals to prosecuting authorities or actions by the State Bar pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(10)A description of the condition of the Client Security Fund, including an accounting of payouts.
(11)An accounting of the cost of the discipline system by function.
(12)Compliance with the requirement of Section 6101 to transmit, within 30 days of receipt, the record of any criminal conviction which involves or may involve moral turpitude to the Supreme Court, or to close the matter if transmittal to the Supreme Court is not appropriate.
(b)The Annual Discipline Report shall include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison.
(c)The Annual Discipline Report shall be presented to the Chief Justice of California, to the Governor, to the Speaker of the Assembly, to the President pro Tempore of the Senate, and to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees, for their consideration and shall be considered a public document.
(d)(1)All data relating to the items set forth in subdivision (a) shall also be reported, if available, for the preceding five years. Data from 2020 and prior years shall be reported for the calendar year. Except as specified in paragraph (2), data from 2021 and future years shall be reported based on the state fiscal year.
(2)The Annual Discipline Report due on October 31, 2022, shall include data from both the prior state fiscal year and the prior calendar year.
SEC. 15.Section 6086.20 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6086.20.(a)Commencing January 1, 2025, the Chief Trial Counsel shall not issue private letters of reprisal to any attorney accused of misconduct.
(b)On or before April 1, 2024, the board, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel, shall provide to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
SEC. 13.SEC. 16.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, shall inform the State Bar.
(2)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SEC. 14.SEC. 17.Section 6102 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6102.(a)Upon the receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, the Supreme Court shall suspend the attorney until the time for appeal has elapsed, if no appeal has been taken, or until the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or has otherwise become final, and until the further order of the court. Upon its own motion or upon good cause shown, the court may decline to impose, or may set aside, the suspension when it appears to be in the interest of justice to do so, with due regard being given to maintaining the integrity of, and confidence in, the profession.
(b)For the purposes of this section, a crime is a felony under the law of California if it is declared to be so specifically or by subdivision (a) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, unless it is charged as a misdemeanor pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, irrespective of whether in a particular case the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings, including proceedings resulting in punishment or probation set forth in paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code.
(c)After the judgment of conviction of an offense specified in subdivision (a) has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code or similar statutory provision, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence, the Supreme Court shall summarily disbar the attorney if the offense is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, and either: (1) an element of the offense is the specific intent to deceive, defraud, steal, or make or suborn a false statement, or involved moral turpitude, or (2) the facts and circumstances of the offense involved moral turpitude.
(d)For purposes of this section, a conviction under the laws of another state or territory of the United States shall be deemed a felony if:
(1)The judgment or conviction was entered as a felony irrespective of any subsequent order suspending sentence or granting probation and irrespective of whether the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings.
(2)The elements of the offense for which the licensee was convicted would constitute a felony under the laws of the State of California at the time the offense was committed.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), if after adequate notice and opportunity to be heard (which hearing shall not be had until the judgment of conviction has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence), the court finds that the crime of which the attorney was convicted, or the circumstances of its commission, involved moral turpitude, it shall enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case; otherwise it shall determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline. In determining the extent of the discipline to be imposed in a proceeding pursuant to this article, any prior discipline imposed upon the attorney may be considered.
(f)The court may refer the proceedings or any part thereof or issue therein, including the nature or extent of discipline, to the State Bar for hearing, report, and recommendation.
(g)The record of the proceedings resulting in the conviction, including a transcript of the testimony therein, may be received in evidence.
(h)The Supreme Court shall prescribe rules for the practice and procedure in proceedings conducted pursuant to this section and Section 6101.
(i)The other provisions of this article providing a procedure for the disbarment or suspension of an attorney do not apply to proceedings pursuant to this section and Section 6101, unless expressly made applicable.
SEC. 15.SEC. 18.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding three hundred ninety-one ninety dollars ($391). ($390).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 16.SEC. 19.Section 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.5.(a)The board shall establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of licensees of the State Bar, foreign legal consultants registered with the State Bar, and attorneys registered with the State Bar under the Multijurisdictional Practice Program, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Any payments from the fund shall be discretionary and shall be subject to regulation, conditions, and rules as the board shall prescribe. The board may delegate the administration of the fund to the State Bar Court, or to any board or committee created by the board of trustees.
(b)Upon making a payment to a person who has applied to the fund for payment to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of a licensee, the State Bar is subrogated, to the extent of that payment, to the rights of the applicant against any person or persons who, or entity that, caused the pecuniary loss. The State Bar may bring an action to enforce those rights within three years from the date of payment to the applicant.
(c)Any licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund shall owe those funds to the State Bar and reimburse the Client Security Fund for all moneys paid out as a result of the licensees conduct with interest, in addition to payment of the assessment for the procedural costs of processing the claim. The State Bar may collect any money paid out by the Client Security Fund pursuant to this subdivision through any means provided by law. The licensees obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund pursuant to this section is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California, a public corporation created pursuant to Article VI of the California Constitution, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
(d)For a publicly reproved or suspended licensee, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of continued practice. This amount shall be added to and become a part of the license fee of a publicly reproved or suspended licensee.
(e)For a licensee who resigns with disciplinary charges pending or a licensee who is resigned or disbarred, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of applying for reinstatement of the licensees license to practice law or return to active license status.
(f)Any assessment against an attorney pursuant to subdivision (c) that is part of an order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is part of an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or any reimbursed amount that is part of a final determination by the Client Security Fund, may also be enforced as a money judgment. This subdivision does not limit the power of the Supreme Court to alter the restitution amount owed pursuant to an order imposing public reproval on a licensee or an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or to authorize the State Bar Court to do the same.
(g)To obtain a money judgment pursuant to subdivision (f) that is not part of a court order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is not part of a court order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, the State Bar shall file a certified copy of the Notice of Payment of the Client Security Fund with the clerk of the superior court of any county. The clerk shall immediately enter judgment in conformity with the Notice of Payment. The judgment shall have the same force and effect as a judgment in a civil action and may be enforced in the same manner as any other judgment.
(h)The defense of laches shall not be raised by the licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund with respect to any payment owed to the State Bar, or with respect to any collections efforts by the State Bar for those payments.
(i)Subdivisions (c), (f), and (h) have, and shall have, retroactive application, as well as prospective application.
(j)As used in this section, licensee shall include a foreign legal consultant registered with the State Bar.
SEC. 17.SEC. 20.Section 6141 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6141.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding ninety-seven dollars and forty cents ($97.40). The annual license fee for inactive licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year.
(b)An inactive licensee shall not be required to pay the annual license fee for inactive licensees for any calendar year following the calendar year in which the licensee attains 70 years of age.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 21.Section 6144.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6144.1.(a)The net proceeds from the sale of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. The net proceeds from the lease of real property, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall be used by the State Bar for the protection of the public.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bars San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonable costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, if any, shall may be utilized by the State Bar to cover employee salaries, and to cover operational costs associated with the State Bars discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam.
(c)All proceeds expended not consistent with subdivision (b) shall be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute. However, up to 10 percent of the net proceeds may be used every fiscal year for improvement of the State Bars discipline system. These moneys shall not supplant any funds that are already being spent on the discipline system or that have been planned in the prior fiscal year to spend on the discipline system.
SEC. 18.SEC. 22.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the chief financial officer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted annually, on or before May 31, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory fees are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)For the 2023 audit required pursuant to subdivision (b), the California State Auditors Office shall conduct a performance audit of the State Bar as set forth in this subdivision. The State Bar shall provide technical assistance, data, or information as requested by the California State Auditor. It is the intent of the Legislature that this audit may be reviewed in conjunction with the legislation that authorizes the State Bars licensing fee in 2023.
(2)The audit shall evaluate each program or division of the State Bar receiving support from the annual State Bar licensing fees and other fees required of active and inactive licensees.
(3)The audit shall, at minimum, include all of the following for each program or division described by paragraph (2):
(A)An assessment of how much fee revenue, staff, and resources are currently budgeted and subsequently expended to perform existing tasks and responsibilities.
(B)An assessment of whether the State Bar has appropriate program performance measures in place and how these measures are used for budgeting purposes.
(C)An assessment of the usage of any real property sold by the State Bar.
(D)A review of the State Bars cost allocation plan used to allocate administrative costs.
(E)A review of any proposals for additional funding or resources requested by the State Bar to determine whether these proposals are necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function, as well as the accuracy of identified associated funding needs, after reviewing how existing resources are used.
(F)A calculation of how much fee revenue would be needed from each State Bar active and inactive licensee to fully offset State Bar costs to perform existing tasks and responsibilities and to support additional proposed expenditures determined to be necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function. This calculation shall take into account any proposed business process reengineering, reallocations, or efficiencies identified by the California State Auditor.
(4)The audit shall include an evaluation of how the State Bar administers discipline cases that require an outside investigator or prosecutor and how that process can be improved, including the cost-effectiveness and timeliness of such investigations and prosecutions.
(5)The audit required by this subdivision shall be submitted by April 15, 2023, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(6)The State Bar shall use existing resources to reimburse the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit required by this subdivision.
SEC. 19.SEC. 23.Section 6238 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 20.SEC. 24.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 11 13 of this act, which amends Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Due to the confidential nature of the information that the Board of Trustees will be considering, it is necessary that their consideration of the information be done in closed session.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the State Bar maintain its commitment to and support of effective policies and activities to enhance access, fairness, and diversity in the legal profession and the elimination of bias in the practice of law.
(b)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The rich diversity of the people of California requires a justice system that is equally accessible and free of bias and is a core value of the legal profession.
(2)Diversity and inclusion are an integral part of the State Bars public protection mission to build, retain, and maintain a diverse legal profession to provide quality and culturally sensitive services to an ever-increasing diverse population.
(3)Diversity increases public trust and confidence and the appearance of fairness in the justice system and therefore increases access to justice.
(4)The State Bar should continue to increase diversity and inclusion in the legal profession.
(c)The State Bar shall develop and implement a plan to meet the goals set forth in this section, which may include, but is not limited to, an assessment of needed revenue. The State Bar shall prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, by March 15, 30, 2019, and every two years thereafter, on the plan and its implementation, including a description of activities undertaken to support the plan, their outcomes, and their effectiveness.
SEC. 2.Section 6007 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6007.(a)When a licensee requires involuntary treatment pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of, or Part 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or when under an order pursuant to Section 3051, 3106.5, or 3152 of the Welfare and Institutions Code he or she has they have been placed in or returned to inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or when he or she has they have been determined insane or mentally incompetent and is confined for treatment or placed on outpatient status pursuant to the Penal Code, or on account of his or her their mental condition a guardian or conservator, for his or her their estate or person or both, has been appointed, the Board of Trustees or an officer of the State Bar shall enroll the licensee as an inactive licensee.
The clerk of any court making an order containing any of the determinations or adjudications referred to in the immediately preceding paragraph shall send a certified copy of that order to the State Bar at the same time that the order is entered.
The clerk of any court with which is filed a notice of certification for intensive treatment pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, upon receipt of the notice, shall transmit a certified copy of it to the State Bar.
The State Bar may procure a certified copy of any determination, order, adjudication, appointment, or notice when the clerk concerned has failed to transmit one or when the proceeding was had in a court other than a court of this state.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar shall terminate the enrollment when the licensee has had the fact of his or her their restoration to capacity judicially determined, upon the licensees release from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches pursuant to Section 3053, 3109, or 3151 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or upon the licensees unconditional release from the medical facility pursuant to Section 5304 or 5305 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; and on payment of all fees required.
When a licensee is placed in, returned to, or released from inpatient status at the California Rehabilitation Center or its branches, or discharged from the narcotics treatment program, the Director of Corrections or his or her their designee shall transmit to the State Bar a certified notice attesting to that fact.
(b)The State Bar Court shall also enroll a licensee of the State Bar as an inactive licensee in each of the following cases:
(1)A licensee asserts a claim of insanity or mental incompetence in any pending action or proceeding, alleging his or her their inability to understand the nature of the action or proceeding or inability to assist counsel in representation of the licensee.
(2)The court makes an order assuming jurisdiction over the licensees law practice, pursuant to Section 6180.5 or 6190.3. 6190.34.
(3)After notice and opportunity to be heard before the State Bar Court, the State Bar Court finds that the licensee, because of mental infirmity or illness, or because of the habitual use of intoxicants or drugs, is (i) unable or habitually fails to perform his or her their duties or undertakings competently, or (ii) unable to practice law without substantial threat of harm to the interests of his or her their clients or the public. No proceeding pursuant to this paragraph shall be instituted unless the State Bar Court finds, after preliminary investigation, or during the course of a disciplinary proceeding, that probable cause exists therefor. The determination of probable cause is administrative in character and no notice or hearing is required.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the enrollment upon proof that the facts found as to the licensees disability no longer exist and on payment of all fees required.
(c)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon a finding based on all the available evidence, including affidavits, that the attorney has not complied with Section 6002.1 and cannot be located after reasonable investigation.
(2)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney if it finds, based on all the available evidence, including affidavits:
(A)The attorney has caused or is causing substantial harm to the attorneys clients or the public.
(B)There is a reasonable probability that the chief trial counsel will prevail on the merits of the underlying disciplinary matter, and that the attorney will be disbarred.
(3)In the case of an enrollment under paragraph (2), the underlying matter shall proceed on an expedited basis.
(4)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney upon the filing of a recommendation of disbarment after hearing or default. For purposes of this section, that attorney shall be placed on involuntary inactive enrollment regardless of the license status of the attorney at the time.
(5)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney who is sentenced to incarceration for 90 days or more as a result of a criminal conviction for at least the period of time in which the attorney is incarcerated.
(6)The State Bar Court shall order attorneys who are placed on inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision to comply with Rule 9.20 of the California Rules of Court.
(7)The board shall formulate and adopt rules of procedure to implement this subdivision.
In the case of an enrollment pursuant to this subdivision, the State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment upon proof that the attorneys conduct no longer poses a substantial threat of harm to the interests of the attorneys clients or the public or where an attorney who could not be located proves compliance with Section 6002.1.
(d)(1)The State Bar Court may order the involuntary inactive enrollment of an attorney for violation of probation upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(A)The attorney is under a suspension order any portion of which has been stayed during a period of probation.
(B)The State Bar Court finds that probation has been violated.
(C)The State Bar Court recommends to the Supreme Court that the attorney receive an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate an enrollment under this subdivision upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation effective date of a Supreme Court order imposing an actual suspension on account of the probation violation or other disciplinary matter, whichever occurs first.
(3)If the Supreme Court orders a period of actual suspension in the probation matter, any period of involuntary inactive enrollment pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited against the period of actual suspension ordered.
(e)(1)The State Bar Court shall order the involuntary, inactive enrollment of a licensee whose default has been entered pursuant to the State Bar Rules of Procedure if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The notice was duly served pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 6002.1.
(B)The notice contained the following language at or near the beginning of the notice, in capital letters:
IF YOU FAIL TO FILE AN ANSWER TO THIS NOTICE WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED BY STATE BAR RULES, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS, OR IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE STATE BAR COURT TRIAL, (1) YOUR DEFAULT SHALL BE ENTERED, (2) YOU SHALL BE ENROLLED AS AN INVOLUNTARY INACTIVE LICENSEE OF THE STATE BAR AND WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PRACTICE LAW UNLESS THE DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE ON MOTION TIMELY MADE UNDER THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE STATE BAR, (3) YOU SHALL NOT BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE FURTHER IN THESE PROCEEDINGS UNLESS YOUR DEFAULT IS SET ASIDE, AND (4) YOU SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL DISCIPLINE.
(2)The State Bar Court shall terminate the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision when the licensees default is set aside on motion timely made under the State Bar Rules of Procedure or the disciplinary proceedings are completed.
(3)The enrollment under this subdivision is administrative in character and no hearing is required.
(4)Upon the involuntary inactive enrollment of a licensee under this subdivision, the notice required by subdivision (b) of Section 6092.5 shall be promptly given.
(f)The pendency or determination of a proceeding or investigation provided for by this section shall not abate or terminate a disciplinary investigation or proceeding except as required by the facts and law in a particular case.
(g)No license fees shall accrue against the licensee during the period he or she is they are enrolled as an inactive licensee pursuant to this section.
(h)The State Bar Court may order a full range of interim remedies or final discipline short of involuntary inactive enrollment, including, but not limited to, conditions of probation following final discipline, or directly ordered interim remedies, to restrict or supervise an attorneys practice of law, as well as proceedings under subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), or under Section 6102 or 6190. They may include restrictions as to scope of practice, monetary accounting procedures, review of performance by probation or other monitors appointed by the board, or such other measures as may be determined, after hearing, to protect present and future clients from likely substantial harm. These restrictions may be imposed upon a showing as provided in subdivision (c).
SEC. 3.Section 6046.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6046.6.(a)The examining committee State Bar shall not alter the bar examination in a manner that requires the substantial modification of the training or preparation required for passage of the examination, except after giving two years notice of that change. This requirement does not apply to a change in the bar examination that is applicable only at the option of the applicant.
(b)The examining committee shall communicate and cooperate with the Law School Council.
(c)Scaling may be used on the bar examination for the purpose of maintaining an examination of uniform difficulty from year to year.
SEC. 4.Section 6060 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission and a license to practice law, a person who has not been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency or in a foreign country shall:
(a)Be at least 18 years of age.
(b)(1)Be of good moral character.
(2)(A)In reviewing whether an applicant is of good moral character under this subdivision, the staff of the State Bar or the members of the examining committee shall not review or consider the persons medical records relating to mental health, except
if the applicant seeks to use the record for either of the following purposes:
(i)To demonstrate that the applicant is of good moral character.
(ii)As a mitigating factor to explain a specific act of misconduct.
(B)The staff of the State Bar and members of the examining committee shall not request or seek to review any medical records relating to mental health, including by obtaining the consent of the applicant to disclose such records, except as requested by an applicant and for a purpose specified in subparagraph (A).
(c)Before beginning the study of law, have done either of the following:
(1)Completed at least two years of college work, which college work shall be at least one-half of the collegiate work acceptable for a bachelors degree granted on the basis of a four-year period of study by a college or university approved by the examining committee. State Bar.
(2)Have attained in apparent intellectual ability the equivalent of at least two years of college work by taking examinations in subject matters and achieving the scores as are prescribed by the examining committee. State Bar.
(d)Have registered with the examining committee State Bar as a law student within 90 days after beginning the study of law. The examining committee, State Bar, upon a showing of good cause, may permit a later registration.
(e)Have done either of the following:
(1)Had conferred upon them a juris doctor (J.D.) degree or a bachelor of laws (LL.B.) degree by a law school accredited by the examining committee or approved by the American Bar Association.
(2)Studied law diligently and in good faith for at least four years in any of the following manners:
(A)(i)In a law school that is authorized or approved to confer professional degrees and requires classroom attendance of its students for a minimum of 270 hours a year.
(ii)A person who has received their legal education in a foreign state or country where the common law of England does not constitute the basis of jurisprudence shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the examining committee State Bar that the persons education, experience, and qualifications qualify them to take the examination.
(B)In a law office in this state and under the personal supervision of a licensee of the State Bar of California who is, and for at least the last five years continuously has been, engaged in the active practice of law. It is the duty of the supervising attorney to render any periodic reports to the examining committee as the committee may require. State Bar as required.
(C)In the chambers and under the personal supervision of a judge of a court of record of this state. It is the duty of the supervising judge to render any periodic reports to the examining committee as the committee may require. State Bar as required.
(D)By instruction in law from a correspondence law school authorized or approved to confer professional degrees by this state, which requires 864 hours of preparation and study per year for four years.
(E)By any combination of the methods referred to in this paragraph.
(f)Have passed any examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the examining committee State Bar may prescribe.
(g)Have passed the general bar examination given by the examining committee. State Bar.
(h)(1)Have passed a law students examination administered by the examining committee State Bar after completion of their first year of law study. Those who pass the examination within its first three administrations, or within the first four administrations as provided in paragraph (3), administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination, shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed. Those who do not pass the examination within the number of administrations allowed by this subdivision, upon becoming eligible to take the examination, but who subsequently pass the examination, shall receive credit for one year of legal study only.
(2)(A)This requirement does not apply to a student who has satisfactorily completed their first year of law study at a law school accredited by the examining committee and who has completed at least two years of college work prior to matriculating in the accredited law school, nor shall this requirement apply to an applicant who has passed the bar examination of a sister state or of a country in which the common law of England constitutes the basis of jurisprudence.
(B)The law students examination shall be administered twice a year at reasonable intervals.
(3)If any of the first three administrations of the law students examination described in paragraph (1) includes the June 2020 administration, the applicant shall be permitted to pass the examination within its first four administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination and shall receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination is passed.SEC. 5.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)Subject to existing state and federal laws protecting education records, subdivision (a) does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(1)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the Committee of Bar Examiners. State Bar.
(2)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(3)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements. Beginning with the release of results from the July 2018 bar examination, the information provided to a law school shall also include the bar examination results of the law schools graduates allocated to the law school and the scores of any graduate allocated to the law school who did not pass the bar examination and who consents to the release of the graduates scores to the law school. Consent of a law school graduate to the release of the graduates scores may be obtained by a check-off on the graduates application to take the bar examination. For purposes of this paragraph, scores means the same scores reported to a graduate who did not successfully pass the bar examination.
(4)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(5)This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 7921.505 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other law except existing state and federal laws protecting education records, any information received from an educational or testing entity that is collected by the State Bar for the purpose of conducting a Law School Bar Exam Performance Study as the State Bar has been directed to do by the California Supreme Court by letter dated February 28, 2017, other than aggregate, summary, or statistical data that does not identify any person and does not provide substantial risk of identification of any person, shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)Nothing in this subdivision is intended to impact any litigation pending on the effective date of the measure that added this subdivision.
SEC. 6.Section 6060.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.3.(a)An application to take the California bar examination administered in February must be filed with the examining committee State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding November, and an application to take the California bar examination administered in July must be filed with the examining committee State Bar not later than the first business day of the preceding April. However, an applicant who was unsuccessful on the examination last administered shall be allowed 10 business days from the date of the general announcement of results of that examination in which to timely file an application to take the next scheduled examination.
(b)The examining committee State Bar may accept applications to take the California bar examination filed after the timely deadlines specified in subdivision (a) from applicants if the application is accompanied by the timely application fee and the late filing fee fixed by the board as follows:
(1)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the first and last business days in November for the February examination or between the first and last business days of April for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed fifty dollars ($50).
(2)An application to take the California bar examination filed between the last business day of November and January 1 for the February examination or between the last business day of April and June 1 for the July examination shall be accepted if it is accompanied by the timely filing fee and a late fee not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(3)An application to take the California bar examination filed after January 1 for the February examination and after June 1 for the July examination shall not be accepted.
(c)Application fees for the California bar examination, including fees for late filing, shall be refunded if the applicant does not take the California bar examination because of the death of an immediate family member or the serious illness or disabling injury of the applicant or a member of his or her their immediate family. A deduction may be made from the refund for administrative costs. The board shall adopt regulations for the administration of this subdivision. This subdivision shall not be construed to prohibit the refund of fees in instances other than those specified.
SEC. 7.Section 6062 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6062.(a)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, territory, or dependency the United States may hereafter acquire shall:
(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.
(2)Be of good moral character.
(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the examining committee. State Bar. However, if that person has been an active licensee in good standing of the bar of the admitting sister state or United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for, he or she they may elect to take the Attorneys Examination rather than the general bar examination. Attorneys admitted less than four years and attorneys admitted four years or more in another jurisdiction but who have not been active licensees in good standing of their admitting jurisdiction for at least four years immediately preceding the first day of the examination applied for must take the general bar examination administered to general applicants not admitted as attorneys in other jurisdictions.
(4)Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the examining committee State Bar may prescribe.
(b)To be certified to the Supreme Court for admission, and a license to practice law, a person who has been admitted to practice law in a jurisdiction other than in a sister state, United States jurisdiction, possession, or territory shall:
(1)Be of the age of at least 18 years.
(2)Be of good moral character.
(3)Have passed the general bar examination given by the examining committee. State Bar.
(4) Have passed an examination in professional responsibility or legal ethics as the examining committee State Bar may prescribe.
(c)The amendments to this section made at the 199798 Regular Session of the Legislature shall be applicable on and after January 1, 1997, and do not constitute a change in, but are declaratory of, existing law.
SEC. 8.Section 6063 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6063.Applicants for admission to practice shall pay such reasonable fees, fixed by the board, as may be necessary to defray the expense of administering the provisions of this chapter, relating to admission to practice. These fees shall be collected by the examining committee State Bar and paid into the treasury of the State Bar.
SEC. 9.Section 6064 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6064.(a)Upon certification by the examining committee State Bar that the applicant has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit the applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.
(b)Upon certification by the examining committee State Bar that an applicant who is not lawfully present in the United States has fulfilled the requirements for admission to practice law, the Supreme Court may admit that applicant as an attorney at law in all the courts of this state and may direct an order to be entered upon its records to that effect. A certificate of admission thereupon shall be given to the applicant by the clerk of the court.
SEC. 10.Section 6065 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6065.(a)(1)Any unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after he or she has taken any examination and within four months after the results thereof have been declared, has the right to inspect his or her examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. practice who did not pass the California bar examination, for 30 days following the release of examination results, shall have electronic access to their answers to the written sessions of the bar examination, which shall include the ability to download, save, and print.
(2)The applicant also has the right to inspect the grading of the papers whether the record thereof is marked upon the examination or otherwise.(b)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2009.SEC. 11.Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.1.(a)(1)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court shall be public, following a notice to show cause.
(2)Subject to subdivision (b), and except as otherwise provided by law, hearings and records of the following matters shall be public:
(A)Filings for involuntary inactive enrollment or restriction under subdivision (a), (c), (d), or (e) of Section 6007.
(B)Petitions for reinstatement under Section 6078.
(C)Proceedings for suspension or disbarment under Section 6101 or 6102.
(D)Payment information from the Client Security Fund pursuant to Section 6140.5.
(E)Actions to cease a law practice or assume a law practice under Section 6180 or 6190.
(b)All disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time that formal charges are filed and all investigations of matters identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) are confidential until the formal proceeding identified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) is instituted. These investigations shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). This confidentiality requirement may be waived under any of the following exceptions:
(1)The licensee whose conduct is being investigated may waive confidentiality. or has been investigated consents to a public announcement or disclosure.
(2)(A)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. Under those circumstances,
(B)Under the circumstances in this paragraph, after private notice to the licensee, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public confirming the fact of an investigation or proceeding, clarifying the procedural aspects and current status, and defending the right of the licensee to a fair hearing. If generally or to specified individuals or entities that defends the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
(i)Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(ii)Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(iii)Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)If the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar for any reason declines to exercise the authority provided by this paragraph, or self-disqualifies from acting under this paragraph, the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar shall designate someone to act in that persons behalf. Conduct of a licensee that is being inquired into by the State Bar but that is not the subject of a formal investigation shall not be disclosed to the public.
(3)The Chief Trial Counsel or Chief Trial Counsels designee may waive confidentiality pursuant to Section 6044.5.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the board may vote to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. The board shall hold a meeting under this subdivision in closed session.
(A)The board shall provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may submit a written statement to the board in writing.
(B)When assessing whether to waive confidentiality and to what extent the board shall, at a minimum:
(i)Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality.
(ii)Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public.
(iii)Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public.
(iv)Consider the potential for harm to the reputation of the licensee.
(2)If the board votes to waive confidentiality and only after complying with the requirements in paragraph (3), the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar may issue, if appropriate, one or more public announcements or make information public that defends the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
(A)Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding.
(B)Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding.
(C)Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
(3)Before making any public announcements pursuant to paragraph (1), the State Bar shall provide notice to the licensee pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 413.10) of Title 5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure of all of the following:
(A)The fact that the board has voted to waive confidentiality.
(B)A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public.
(C)That the licensee has five days to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
(d)(1) A licensee may file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to subdivision (c).
(2)If a licensee files a motion under paragraph (1) the proceeding shall be afforded priority on the court calendar, and the matter shall be heard within 10 days from the filing of the motion.
(c)(e)Notwithstanding the confidentiality of investigations, the State Bar shall disclose to any member of the public so inquiring, any information reasonably available to it pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068, and to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, and 6101, concerning a licensee of the State Bar that is otherwise a matter of public record, including civil or criminal filings and dispositions.
SEC. 12.Section 6086.15 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.15.(a)The State Bar shall issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 November 30 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Except as set forth in subdivision (d), the report shall cover the period from July 1 of the previous calendar year to June 30 of the year in which the report is issued and shall include accurate and complete descriptions of all of the following:
(1)The inventory of cases within the Office of Chief Trial Counsel which were open at the start of the reporting period, were opened during the reporting period, remain pending with the office at the close of the reporting period, or were disposed of during the reporting period by closure, by filing of a stipulation with the State Bar Court, by filing of a notice of disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court, or by transmittal of a criminal conviction to the State Bar Court. The State Bar shall also report on its success in meeting the case processing goals set forth in Section 6094.5, including, but not limited to, tables showing the number and percentage of cases meeting each goal, the number and percentage of those cases not disposed of within the case processing goals, and a high-level explanation of the reasons for failing to meet those case processing goals. The inventory of cases shall not be limited to case types that could result in the filing of a notice of disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court, but shall also include Nonattorney Unauthorized Practice of Law (NA-UPL), Section 6007 matters, moral character matters, resignations with charges pending, and mini-reinstatements.
(2)The number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition.
(3)The number, average pending times, and types of matters self-reported by licensees of the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 6068 and subdivision (c) of Section 6086.8.
(4)The number, average pending times, and types of matters reported by other sources pursuant to Sections 6086.7, 6086.8, 6091.1, subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6101, and Section 6175.6.
(5)The speed of complaint handling and dispositions by type, measured by the median and the average processing times.
(6)The number, average pending times, and types of filed notices of disciplinary charges and formal disciplinary outcomes.
(7)The number, average pending times, and types of other matters, including petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180 or 6190, interim suspensions and license restrictions pursuant to Section 6007, motions to enforce a binding arbitration award, judgment, or agreement pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 6203, motions to revoke probation, letters of warning, private reprovals, admonitions, and agreements in lieu of discipline.
(8)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints involving a State Bar licensee who has been disbarred or who has resigned, and is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities, or petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6180.
(9)The number, average pending times, and outcomes of complaints against nonattorneys engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, including referrals to district attorneys, city attorneys, or other prosecuting authorities; petitions to terminate practice pursuant to Section 6126.3; or referrals to prosecuting authorities or actions by the State Bar pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(10)A description of the condition of the Client Security Fund, including an accounting of payouts.
(11)An accounting of the cost of the discipline system by function.
(12)Compliance with the requirement of Section 6101 to transmit, within 30 days of receipt, the record of any criminal conviction which involves or may involve moral turpitude to the Supreme Court, or to close the matter if transmittal to the Supreme Court is not appropriate.
(b)The Annual Discipline Report shall include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison.
(c)The Annual Discipline Report shall be presented to the Chief Justice of California, to the Governor, to the Speaker of the Assembly, to the President pro Tempore of the Senate, and to the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees, for their consideration and shall be considered a public document.
(d)(1)All data relating to the items set forth in subdivision (a) shall also be reported, if available, for the preceding five years. Data from 2020 and prior years shall be reported for the calendar year. Except as specified in paragraph (2), data from 2021 and future years shall be reported based on the state fiscal year.
(2)The Annual Discipline Report due on October 31, 2022, shall include data from both the prior state fiscal year and the prior calendar year.
SECTION 1.SEC. 13.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, shall inform the State Bar. (2)6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, shall inform the State Bar.
(3)(2)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SEC. 14.Section 6102 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6102.(a)Upon the receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, the Supreme Court shall suspend the attorney until the time for appeal has elapsed, if no appeal has been taken, or until the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or has otherwise become final, and until the further order of the court. Upon its own motion or upon good cause shown, the court may decline to impose, or may set aside, the suspension when it appears to be in the interest of justice to do so, with due regard being given to maintaining the integrity of, and confidence in, the profession.
(b)For the purposes of this section, a crime is a felony under the law of California if it is declared to be so specifically or by subdivision (a) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, unless it is charged as a misdemeanor pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code, irrespective of whether in a particular case the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings, including proceedings resulting in punishment or probation set forth in paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 17 of the Penal Code.
(c)After the judgment of conviction of an offense specified in subdivision (a) has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code or similar statutory provision, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence, the Supreme Court shall summarily disbar the attorney if the offense is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof, and either: (1) an element of the offense is the specific intent to deceive, defraud, steal, or make or suborn a false statement, or involved moral turpitude, or (2) the facts and circumstances of the offense involved moral turpitude.
(d)For purposes of this section, a conviction under the laws of another state or territory of the United States shall be deemed a felony if:
(1)The judgment or conviction was entered as a felony irrespective of any subsequent order suspending sentence or granting probation and irrespective of whether the crime may be considered a misdemeanor as a result of postconviction proceedings.
(2)The elements of the offense for which the licensee was convicted would constitute a felony under the laws of the State of California at the time the offense was committed.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), if after adequate notice and opportunity to be heard (which hearing shall not be had until the judgment of conviction has become final or, irrespective of any subsequent order under Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code, an order granting probation has been made suspending the imposition of sentence), the court finds that the crime of which the attorney was convicted, or the circumstances of its commission, involved moral turpitude, it shall enter an order disbarring the attorney or suspending him or her them from practice for a limited time, according to the gravity of the crime and the circumstances of the case; otherwise it shall dismiss the proceedings. determine if the facts and circumstances surrounding the conviction involve other misconduct warranting discipline, and if so, impose the appropriate discipline. In determining the extent of the discipline to be imposed in a proceeding pursuant to this article, any prior discipline imposed upon the attorney may be considered.
(f)The court may refer the proceedings or any part thereof or issue therein, including the nature or extent of discipline, to the State Bar for hearing, report, and recommendation.
(g)The record of the proceedings resulting in the conviction, including a transcript of the testimony therein, may be received in evidence.
(h)The Supreme Court shall prescribe rules for the practice and procedure in proceedings conducted pursuant to this section and Section 6101.
(i)The other provisions of this article providing a procedure for the disbarment or suspension of an attorney do not apply to proceedings pursuant to this section and Section 6101, unless expressly made applicable.
SEC. 2.SEC. 15.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding ____ three hundred ninety-one dollars ($____). ($391).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 16.Section 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.5.(a)The board shall establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of licensees of the State Bar, foreign legal consultants registered with the State Bar, and attorneys registered with the State Bar under the Multijurisdictional Practice Program, arising from or connected with the practice of law. Any payments from the fund shall be discretionary and shall be subject to regulation, conditions, and rules as the board shall prescribe. The board may delegate the administration of the fund to the State Bar Court, or to any board or committee created by the board of trustees.
(b)Upon making a payment to a person who has applied to the fund for payment to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by the dishonest conduct of a licensee, the State Bar is subrogated, to the extent of that payment, to the rights of the applicant against any person or persons who, or entity that, caused the pecuniary loss. The State Bar may bring an action to enforce those rights within three years from the date of payment to the applicant.
(c)Any licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund shall owe those funds to the State Bar and reimburse the Client Security Fund for all moneys paid out as a result of the licensees conduct with interest, in addition to payment of the assessment for the procedural costs of processing the claim. The State Bar may collect any money paid out by the Client Security Fund pursuant to this subdivision through any means provided by law. The licensees obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund pursuant to this section is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California, a public corporation created pursuant to Article VI of the California Constitution, to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
(d)For a publicly reproved or suspended licensee, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of continued practice. This amount shall be added to and become a part of the license fee of a publicly reproved or suspended licensee.
(e)For a licensee who resigns with disciplinary charges pending or a licensee who is resigned or disbarred, the reimbursed amount by the Client Security Fund, plus applicable interest and costs, shall be paid as a condition of applying for reinstatement of the licensees license to practice law or return to active license status.
(f)Any assessment against an attorney pursuant to subdivision (c) that is part of an order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is part of an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or any reimbursed amount that is part of a final determination by the Client Security Fund, may also be enforced as a money judgment. This subdivision does not limit the power of the Supreme Court to alter the restitution amount owed pursuant to an order imposing public reproval on a licensee or an order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, or to authorize the State Bar Court to do the same.
(g)To obtain a money judgment pursuant to subdivision (f) that is not part of a court order imposing a public reproval on a licensee or is not part of a court order imposing discipline or accepting a resignation with a disciplinary matter pending, the State Bar shall file a certified copy of the Notice of Payment of the Client Security Fund with the clerk of the superior court of any county. The clerk shall immediately enter judgment in conformity with the Notice of Payment. The judgment shall have the same force and effect as a judgment in a civil action and may be enforced in the same manner as any other judgment.
(h)The defense of laches shall not be raised by the licensee whose actions have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund with respect to any payment owed to the State Bar, or with respect to any collections efforts by the State Bar for those payments.
(i)Subdivisions (c), (f), and (h) have, and shall have, retroactive application, as well as prospective application.
(j)As used in this section, licensee shall include a foreign legal consultant registered with the State Bar.
SEC. 17.Section 6141 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6141.(a)On January 1, 2022, and thereafter, the The board shall fix the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding ninety-seven dollars and forty cents ($97.40), except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum shall not exceed ninety-six dollars and forty cents ($96.40). ($97.40). The annual license fee for inactive licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year.
(b)An inactive licensee shall not be required to pay the annual license fee for inactive licensees for any calendar year following the calendar year in which the licensee attains 70 years of age.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2023. 2024.
SEC. 18.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the chief financial officer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year annually, on or before May 31, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory fees are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)For the 2023 audit required pursuant to subdivision (b), the California State Auditors Office shall conduct a performance audit of the State Bar as set forth in this subdivision. The State Bar shall provide technical assistance, data, or information as requested by the California State Auditor. It is the intent of the Legislature that this audit may be reviewed in conjunction with the legislation that authorizes the State Bars licensing fee in 2023.
(2)The audit shall evaluate each program or division of the State Bar receiving support from the annual State Bar licensing fees and other fees required of active and inactive licensees.
(3)The audit shall, at minimum, include all of the following for each program or division described by paragraph (2):
(A)An assessment of how much fee revenue, staff, and resources are currently budgeted and subsequently expended to perform existing tasks and responsibilities.
(B)An assessment of whether the State Bar has appropriate program performance measures in place and how these measures are used for budgeting purposes.
(C)An assessment of the usage of any real property sold by the State Bar.
(D)A review of the State Bars cost allocation plan used to allocate administrative costs.
(E)A review of any proposals for additional funding or resources requested by the State Bar to determine whether these proposals are necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function, as well as the accuracy of identified associated funding needs, after reviewing how existing resources are used.
(F)A calculation of how much fee revenue would be needed from each State Bar active and inactive licensee to fully offset State Bar costs to perform existing tasks and responsibilities and to support additional proposed expenditures determined to be necessary to meet the State Bars public protection function. This calculation shall take into account any proposed business process reengineering, reallocations, or efficiencies identified by the California State Auditor.
(4)The audit shall include an evaluation of how the State Bar administers discipline cases that require an outside investigator or prosecutor and how that process can be improved, including the cost-effectiveness and timeliness of such investigations and prosecutions.
(5)The audit required by this subdivision shall be submitted by April 15, 2023, to the board of trustees, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
(6)The State Bar shall use existing resources to reimburse the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit required by this subdivision.
SEC. 19.Section 6238 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6238.The committee shall report to the Board of Trustees and to the Legislature not later than March 1, 2003, and annually thereafter, on the implementation and operation of the program. The report shall include, but is not limited to, information concerning the number of cases accepted, denied, or terminated with compliance or noncompliance, and annual expenditures related to the program.SEC. 20.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 11 of this act, which amends Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Due to the confidential nature of the information that the Board of Trustees will be considering, it is necessary that their consideration of the information be done in closed session.
(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, shall inform the State Bar.
(2)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, shall inform the State Bar.
(3)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding ____ dollars ($____).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
(a)The board shall fix the annual license fee for active licensees for 2023 2024 at a sum not exceeding three hundred ninety dollars ($390), except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum shall not exceed three hundred eighty-six dollars ($386). ____ dollars ($____).
(b)The annual license fee for active licensees is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or by other means, and may charge licensees choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2023. This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, and as of that date is repealed.
SECTION 1. It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to the regulation of the State Bar.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to the regulation of the State Bar.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 10, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 8. Page 2735.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 60. Noes 14. Page 3249.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Read third time and amended. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (July 11). |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 22, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 11, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 11, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 1053.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 4, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| May 3, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0. Page 1011.) (May 2). |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 2. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Dec 6, 2022 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2023 | Unfinished Business SB40 Umberg Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 12, 2023 | SB 40 Umberg Senate Third Reading By Maienschein | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2023 | Consent Calendar SB40 Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2023 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 40 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 40
Author: Umberg (D)
Amended: 9/7/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 5/2/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0, 5/11/23 (Consent)
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-14, 9/12/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: State Bar of California
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the State Bar of California (State Bar) to collect annual license fees for 2024 in the same amount as 2023, and makes various other changes to the State Bar Act.
Assembly Amendments
(1) strengthen conflict of interest statutes; (2) clarify that the Chair and Vice Chair of the board can serve a term of up to two years; (3) authorize the transfer of excess funds from certain special funds to the State Bar’s general funds and authorize the proceeds from the sale of a specified building to be used for core operating expenses; (4) enact changes to existing statutes related to background checks of licensees and employees to comply with federal regulations; (5) require Senate confirmation of the executive director and general counsel of the State Bar; (6) prohibit the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC) from issuing private letters of reprisal and require recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program; (7) require a licensee who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection to inform the State Bar, except as specified; and (8) make various other technical changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- The Legislature sets the annual fees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140, 6141.)
- The State Bar is governed by the Board of Trustees of the State Bar (Board). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6010 et seq.; § 6016.)
- Establishes that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public is to be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect a $390 annual license fee from active licensees for the year 2023
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect a $97.40 annual license fee from inactive licensees for the year 2023.
- Provides that the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC), with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar; the acts or practices of a person whom the CTC has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of the State Bar Act; and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6044.)
- Allows applicants to be permitted to pass the admittance exam within its first four administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination and receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination has passed if any of the first three administrations of the law students’ examination includes the June 2020 examination. (Section 6060 (h)(3).)
- Grants any unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after he or she has taken any examination and within four months after the results thereof have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. (Section 6065.)
- Directs hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, except as specified. Authorizes a licensee whose conduct is being investigated to waive confidentiality. (Section 6086.1 (a), (b)(1).) Authorizes the CTC or Chair of the State Bar to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. (Section 6086.1 (b)(2).)
- Requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year. (Section 6086.15 (a).)
- Requires the Supreme Court to suspend an attorney upon receipt of a certified copy of a record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof. (Section 6102 (a).)
- Requires the Board of Trustees to establish and administer the Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active licensees of the State Bar, as specified. (Section 6140.5.)
- Requires the State Bar to report to the Board of Trustees and Legislature on an annual basis regarding the implementation and operation of the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program. (Section 6238.)
This bill:
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect annual license fees for licensees in 2024 in the same amount as 2023. Requires the State Bar to prepare a report for the Legislature on how it would use revenue generated by an increase in the mandatory annual license fees for active and inactive licensees, as specified.
- Repeals the annual statutory report regarding the Lawyer Assistance Program, and modifies the deadline by which the State Bar must submit an annual discipline report from October 31 to November 30. Requires submission of audit and financial statement to be annually submitted on or before May 31.
- Clarifies that the Supreme Court, rather than the State Bar Court, is authorized to order an attorney suspended for misconduct, and clarifies that the Supreme Court of the State of California may discipline an attorney who is convicted of a crime that did involve moral turpitude, which conforms to existing case law.
- Specifies that a licensee’s obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund arising from actions that have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. Establishes that this subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as Executive Director of the State Bar or General Counsel to the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate. Provides that the Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Rules Committee and the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an Executive Director.
- Authorizes examinees who did not pass the California State Bar Exam to access their answers electronically for 30 days to allow for review, download, or printing of the exam answers.
- Modifies the circumstances under which the CTC or Chair of the State Bar may make information public relating to an investigation of a licensee, and provides a process for the board to release such information and for a licensee to contest that decision, as provided.
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United states, to inform the State Bar, except as specified.
- Prohibits the CTC from issuing private letters of reprisal to any attorney accused of misconduct beginning January 1, 2025.
- Requires the Board, on or before April 1, 2024, in consultation with the CTC to provide the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Authorizes the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bar’s San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonably costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, to be used by the Bar to cover employee salaries, and operational costs associated with the State Bar’s discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam, and requires that all proceeds not expended consistent with this subdivision to be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
Comments
As a constitutional matter, the judicial power of California is vested in the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal, and superior courts. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 1.) (In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, 592; Obrien v. Jones (2000) 23 Cal.4th 40, 48.) In addressing this inherent authority to regulate the practice of law, the Supreme Court has explained: “The important difference between regulation of the legal profession and regulation of other professions is this: Admission to the bar is a judicial function, and members of the bar are officers of the court, subject to discipline by the court. Hence, under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, the court has inherent and primary regulatory power.” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 593.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.)
Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Bar of California is a public corporation. Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) At the same time, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of license fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1) and subjecting the CTC of the State Bar to Senate confirmation (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6079.5).
The State Bar’s highest priority is the protection of the public, which includes quickly finding and disciplining dishonest or incompetent attorneys. As the May and Lazar reports show, the State Bar has utterly failed at fulfilling its mission. In 2021, Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. As the Lazar report demonstrates, serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against him were reported to the State Bar over decades, but the State Bar did not take action against him until 2021 when he was disbarred by the California Supreme Court after a disciplinary hearing by the State Bar.[1] This only occurred after a federal court found that he had misappropriated $2 million that was awarded to victims’ families in the Lion Air flight 610 plane crash of 2018, and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. This incident triggered numerous further accusations against Girardi for stealing client funds and the true scope of his malfeasance finally began to materialize. Eventually, Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, were forced into bankruptcy. This year Girardi was indicted by federal grand juries in Los Angeles and Chicago on charges that he embezzled more than $18 million from his clients.
The State Bar refused to release information about complaints, closed cases, or investigations it had conducted on Girardi citing to confidentiality provisions in Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code. The L.A. Times sued the State Bar and eventually the State Bar agreed to release roughly 40 years of disciplinary records that showed Girardi had over 200 complaints filed against him since 1983, many of which alleged misappropriation of client finds. In the wake of this, the State Bar initiated the Lazar and May reports.[2] The findings from the reports were alarming and detailed a history of weak internal enforcement of conflict of interests and troubling relationships between employees of the State Bar and Girardi. The Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees held a joint oversight hearing of the State Bar in May 2023 that demonstrated the State Bar still has a ways to go to gain back public trust and correct issues with its disciplinary system. As such, the bill does not provide a fee increase for the State Bar this year and requires the State Bar to provide a report to the Legislature on how it would use revenue generated by any requested increase in license fees.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/11/23)
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/23)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-14, 9/12/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Chen, Hoover, Pacheco, Joe Patterson, Schiavo
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/12/23 19:26:39
**** END ****
Lazar report (released Mar. 10, 223), available at https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/reports/Lazar-Report-and-Attachment-Redacted.pdf. ↑
For a full detail of both the Lazar Report and the May Report refer to the Judiciary Committee’s Background Paper for the joint Oversight Hearing held on May 234, 2023, available at https://sjud.senate.ca.gov/sites/sjud.senate.ca.gov/files/background_paper_final_letterhead.pdf. ↑
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 40
Author:(Umberg)
As Amended Ver:September 7, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Reauthorizes the State Bar to charge the annual licensing fees for attorneys in California and makes other changes regarding the leadership structure of the State Bar and other changes regarding the regulation of attorneys.
Major Provisions
- Fixes the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding $390.
- Fixes the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding $97.50.
- Corrects improper references to "the examining committee" to correctly identify "the State Bar."
- Clarifies that the Supreme Court, rather than the State Bar Court, is authorized to order an attorney suspended for misconduct.
- Authorizes examinees who did not pass the California State Bar Exam to access their answers electronically for 30 days to allow for review, download, or printing of the exam answers.
- Modifies the circumstances under which the Chief Trial Council or Chair of the State Bar may make information public relating to an investigation of a licensee to include the following:
- Confirm the fact of an investigation or proceeding;
- Provide a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding; and
- Provide the status of the investigation or proceeding.
- Authorizes the Board to vote to waive confidentiality when warranted for protection of the public subject to a vote of the Board in closed session.
- Requires the Board to provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days' notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may submit a written statement to the board in writing.
- Establishes the following requirements for the Board when assessing whether to waive confidentiality:
- Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality;
- Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public;
- Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public; and
- Consider the potential harm to the reputation of the licensee.
- Authorizes the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar to issue, if appropriate and only after compliance with 9), above, one or more public announcements or make information public in a manner that defends the right of the licensee to a fair hearing, as specified.
- Requires the State Bar to provide notice to the licensee before making any public announcements of all of the following:
- The fact that the Board has voted to waive confidentiality;
- A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public; and
- That the licensee has five business days to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
- Authorizes a licensee to file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to 8), above.
- Requires that, if a licensee files a motion pursuant to 12), above, the proceeding be afforded priority on the court calendar, and that the matter be heard within 10 court days from the filing of the motion.
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, to inform the State Bar, as specified.
- For the purposes of 14), above, defines "knows" to mean actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensee's knowledge may be inferred from the circumstances.
- Clarifies that 14), above, does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
- Establishes that a licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to 14), above, with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
- Specifies that a licensee's obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund arising from actions that have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California to promote rehabilitation and protect the public.
- Repeals the annual statutory report regarding the Lawyer Assistance Program.
- Clarifies the that the executive director of the State Bar is to be responsible for leading and managing the organization in accordance with the strategic director established by the Board of Trustees.
- Provides that the chair and vice chair of the State Bar Board of Trustees may serve terms not to exceed two years.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as Executive Director of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an Executive Director.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as General Counsel of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the General Counsel serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an General Counsel.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, prohibits the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private letters of reporval to any attorney accused of misconduct.
- Requires the Board, on or before April 1, 2024, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel to provide the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Requires members of the State Bar Board of Trustees and employees to adhere to the same conflict of interest laws regarding government contracting that apply to other state employees.
- Revise and recast various fingerprinting requirements for prospective employees and applicants for admission to the State Bar to align with new standards promulgated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
- Authorizes the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bar's San Francisco office building, to be used by the Bar to cover employee salaries, and operational costs associated with the State Bar's discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam, and authorizes the transfer of funds from various accounts with a surplus to assist in paying employee salaries and benefits.
- Requires, on or before April 1, 2024, the State Bar to submit to the Legislature a report regarding the potential use of a potential fee increase, as specified.
- Makes various technical amendments.
- Makes various findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
In an effort to address some of the concerns raised regarding the Bar over the last few years, this bill proposes a number of reform efforts. In addition to a number of provisions that clarify or correct existing law, the bill requires the Executive Director and General Counsel to be appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the Board, and be confirmed by the California State Senate. The bill also authorizes the Board to vote to release limited information regarding ongoing investigations into attorney misconduct. The bill also requires an attorney who knows that another attorney has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States to report that attorney to the Bar. The bill also seeks to add transparency to the discipline system by eliminating private letters of reproval and instead directs the State Bar to propose to the Legislature a diversion system to retrain, rather than punish, attorneys who commit minor violations of the Rule of Professional Conduct. Finally, the bill authorizes the Bar to utilize proceeds from the sale of real estate for limited purposes focused on their primary functions. This bill maintains the 2023 fee levels for attorneys.
According to the Author
This bill will make changes to the State Bar Act to increase Legislative oversight and address deficiencies in the discipline system that have been highlighted by the Legislative Analyst Office, State Auditor, and the May and Lazar Reports.
The State Bar's most basic function is to protect California consumers. Unfortunately, the State Bar as a whole not only utterly failed this task, but also conspired to conceal obvious misconduct on the part of at least one specific lawyer—Tom Girardi. The revelations in the recent May report and Joint Legislative Informational Hearing this Spring have shown that Tom Girardi's financial web and sphere of influence reached so far within the State Bar, that he was essentially bankrolling an employee in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) and the Executive Director's Office and said employee's family to the tune of close to $1 million while he was being investigated by the same organization. Every subsequent report about Tom Girardi and the State Bar's activities over the last two decades seems to be more alarming than the next. The Girardi debatable is just one known example of the need for increased oversight and regulation of this entity.
Due to overwhelming concerns about the Bar's corruption and mismanagement, the 2024 fee will be $390 – same as last year. Instead, this bill will allow the State Bar to use building proceeds to pay for operating expenses and to ensure the economic well-being of their staff.
Arguments in Support
No support on file.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Grove
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, McKinnor
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: September 7, 2023
CONSULTANT: Manuela Boucher-de la Cadena and Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001878
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 40
Author:(Umberg)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Reauthorizes the State Bar to charge the annual licensing fees for attorneys in California and makes other changes regarding the leadership structure of the State Bar and other changes regarding the regulation of attorneys.
Major Provisions
- Fixes the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding $390.
- Fixes the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding $97.50.
- Modifies the deadline by which the State Bar must submit a biennial diversity report from March 15 to March 30.
- Corrects improper references to "the examining committee" to correctly identify "the State Bar."
- Clarifies that the Supreme Court, rather than the State Bar Court, is authorized to order an attorney suspended for misconduct.
- Authorizes examinees who did not pass the California State Bar Exam to access their answers electronically for 30 days to allow for review, download, or printing of the exam answers.
- Modifies the circumstances under which the Chief Trial Council or Chair of the State Bar may make information public relating to an investigation of a licensee to include the following:
- Confirm the fact of an investigation or proceeding;
- Provide a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding; and
- Provide the status of the investigation or proceeding.
- Authorizes the Board to vote to waive confidentiality when warranted for protection of the public subject to a vote of the Board in closed session.
- Requires the Board to provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days' notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may submit a written statement to the board in writing.
- Establishes the following requirements for the Board when assessing whether to waive confidentiality:
- Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality;
- Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public;
- Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public; and
- Consider the potential harm to the reputation of the licensee.
- Authorizes the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar to issue, if appropriate and only after compliance with 10), above, one or more public announcements or make information public in a manner that defends the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
- Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding;
- Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding; or
- Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
- Requires the State Bar to provide notice to the licensee before making any public announcements of all of the following:
- The fact that the Board has voted to waive confidentiality;
- A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public; and
- That the licensee has five days to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
- Authorizes a licensee to file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to 8), above.
- Requires that, if a licensee files a motion pursuant to 13), above, the proceeding be afforded priority on the court calendar, and that the matter be heard within 10 days from the filing of the motion.
- Modifies the deadline by which the State Bar must submit an annual discipline report from October 31 to November 30.
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United states, to inform the State Bar.
- For the purposes of 16), above, defines "knows" to mean actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensee's knowledge may be inferred from the circumstances.
- Clarifies that 16), above, does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
- Establishes that a licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to 16), above, with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
- Authorizes the board to amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and requires them to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement 16), above.
- Clarifies that, in conformity with existing case law, the Supreme Court of the State of California may discipline an attorney who is convicted of a crime that did involve moral turpitude.
- Specifies that a licensee's obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund arising from actions that have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. Establishes that this subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
- Repeals the annual statutory report regarding the Lawyer Assistance Program.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as Executive Director of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an Executive Director.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as General Counsel of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the General Counsel serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an General Counsel.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, prohibits the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private letters of reprisal to any attorney accused of misconduct.
- Requires the Board, on or before April 1, 2024, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel to provide the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Authorizes the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bar's San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonably costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, to be used by the Bar to cover employee salaries, and operational costs associated with the State Bar's discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam, and requires that all proceeds not expended consistent with this subdivision to be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
COMMENTS
In an effort to address some of the concerns raised regarding the Bar over the last few years, this bill proposes a number of reform efforts. In addition to a number of provisions that clarify or correct existing law, the bill requires the Executive Director and General Counsel to be appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the Board, and be confirmed by the California State Senate. The bill also authorizes the Board to vote to release limited information regarding ongoing investigations into attorney misconduct. The bill also requires an attorney who knows that another attorney has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States to report that attorney to the Bar. The bill also seeks to add transparency to the discipline system by eliminating private letters of reproval and instead directs the State Bar to propose to the Legislature a diversion system to retrain, rather than punish, attorneys who commit minor violations of the Rule of Professional Conduct. Finally, the bill authorizes the Bar to utilize proceeds from the sale of real estate for limited purposes focused on their primary functions. This bill maintains the 2023 fee levels for attorneys.
According to the Author
This bill will make changes to the State Bar Act to increase Legislative oversight and address deficiencies in the discipline system that have been highlighted by the Legislative Analyst Office, State Auditor, and the May and Lazar Reports.
The State Bar's most basic function is to protect California consumers. Unfortunately, the State Bar as a whole not only utterly failed this task, but also conspired to conceal obvious misconduct on the part of at least one specific lawyer—Tom Girardi. The revelations in the recent May report and Joint Legislative Informational Hearing this Spring have shown that Tom Girardi's financial web and sphere of influence reached so far within the State Bar, that he was essentially bankrolling an employee in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) and the Executive Director's Office and said employee's family to the tune of close to $1 million while he was being investigated by the same organization. Every subsequent report about Tom Girardi and the State Bar's activities over the last two decades seems to be more alarming than the next. The Girardi debatable is just one known example of the need for increased oversight and regulation of this entity.
Due to overwhelming concerns about the Bar's corruption and mismanagement, the 2024 fee will be $390 – same as last year. Instead, this bill will allow the State Bar to use building proceeds to pay for operating expenses and to ensure the economic well-being of their staff.
Arguments in Support
No support on file.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Grove
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, McKinnor
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: July 3, 2023
CONSULTANT: Manuela Boucher-de la Cadena and Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001214
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 40
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2023
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 39-0
SUBJECT: STATE BAR: ANNUAL LICENSE FEES AND REPORTING PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AND GENERAL COUNSEL TO THE STATE BAR BE APPOINTED BY AND, upon confirmation by the california state senate, SERVE AT THE PLEASURE OF THE BOARD OF trustees, IN CONFORMITY WITH THE CHIEF TRIAL COUNSEL OF THE BAR AND the leadership of most OTHER STATE AGENCies?
- SHOULD THE CHIEF TRIAL COUNSEL TO THE STATE BAR BE PROHIBITED FROM ISSUING PRIVATE LETTERS OF REPROVAL TO ANY ATTORNEY ACCUSED OF MISCONDUCT BEGINNING JANUARY 1, 2025?
- SHOULD THE state bar BOARD OF TRUSTEES, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE CHIEF TRIAL COUNSEL, BE REQUIRED BY APRIL 1, 2024, TO PROVIDE THE ASSEMBLY AND SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEES WITH RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CODIFYING A FORMAL DISCIPLINARY DIVERSION PROGRAM FOR ATTORNEYS WHO ARE ACCUSED OF MINOR VIOLATIONS OF THE RULES OF PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT?
- SHOULD THE STATE BAR BOARD OF trustees BE AUTHORIZED TO RELEASE INFORMATION REGARDING ONGOING INVESTIGATIONS OF ATTORNEY MISCONDUCT IF IT IS IN THE INTEREST OF THE PROTECTION OF THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA?
- SHOULD THE STATE BAR BE AUTHORIZED TO USE NET proceeds RESULTING FROM THE SALE OF ITS REAL ESTATE FOR SPECIFIED CORE PURPOSES?
- SHOULD ATTORNEYS WHO KNOW THAT ANOTHER ATTORNEY HAS CONSPIRED TO ENGAGE IN, OR HAS ENGAGED IN, TREASON, SEDITION, OR INSURRECTION AGAINST THE STATE OR UNITED STATES BE REQUIRED TO REPORT THAT ATTORNEY to the state bar?
SYNOPSIS
This measure is the annual bill that reauthorizes the fees imposed on attorneys licensed in California and serves as a tool for implementing policy reforms for the agency. The annual bill allows the Legislature to review the performance and operation of the State Bar in the past year and determine if any statutory changes are needed to improve the Bar’s functioning, as well as approve annual licensing fees for attorneys in the state. Yet again, this measure finds the State Bar facing significant turmoil and public scrutiny, most notably as a result of the revelations regarding the influence that now-disgraced attorney Tom Girardi wielded at the organization, allowing his serious misconduct to continue unabated and unpunished.
Seeking to both reform the agency and begin stabilizing its finances, this year’s fee bill adopts several important reforms to the governance of the State Bar. First, seeking to better align the State Bar with other regulatory agencies, this bill require the State Bar’s Executive Director and General Counsel to obtain Senate confirmation. Seeking to formalize the discipline process, this bill will end the private reproval letter process and begin formalizing a diversionary process for minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Similarly, the bill adopts a formal process for the State Bar’s Board of Trustees to publically disclose information about attorney misconduct that poses a significant risk to the public’s welfare prior to the filing of formal disciplinary charges against the attorney. To address the State Bar’s budget deficit, this bill removes existing limits on the use of proceeds from the sale of State Bar property and directs those proceeds to be used to fund staff salaries, administration of the bar exam, and the discipline system. Finally, this bill clarifies attorney reporting requirements, and makes various other technical amendments to the State Bar’s governing statutes. As currently in print, and as proposed to be amended, this bill has no formal support or opposition.
SUMMARY: Reauthorizes the State Bar to charge the annual licensing fees for attorneys in California and makes other changes regarding the leadership structure of the State Bar and other changes regarding the regulation of attorneys. Specifically, this bill:
- Fixes the annual license fee for active licensees for 2024 at a sum not exceeding $390.
- Fixes the annual license fee for inactive licensees at a sum not exceeding $97.50.
- Modifies the deadline by which the State Bar must submit a biennial diversity report from March 15 to March 30.
- Corrects improper references to “the examining committee” to correctly identify “the State Bar.”
- Clarifies that the Supreme Court, rather than the State Bar Court, is authorized to order an attorney suspended for misconduct.
- Authorizes examinees who did not pass the California State Bar Exam to access their answers electronically for 30 days to allow for review, download, or printing of the exam answers.
- Modifies the circumstances under which the Chief Trial Council or Chair of the State Bar may make information public relating to an investigation of a licensee to include the following:
- Confirm the fact of an investigation or proceeding;
- Provide a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding; and
- Provide the status of the investigation or proceeding.
- Authorizes the Board to vote to waive confidentiality when warranted for protection of the public subject to a vote of the Board in closed session.
- Requires the Board to provide a licensee whose confidential information is being considered for disclosure five days’ notice of the fact that the board will be meeting to consider waiving confidentiality and that the licensee may submit a written statement to the board in writing.
- Establishes the following requirements for the Board when assessing whether to waive confidentiality:
- Apply a presumption in favor of maintaining confidentiality;
- Consider the extent to which the allegations or issues involved in the investigation are already publically disclosed or generally known to the public;
- Consider the gravity of the underlying allegation and potential for continued harm to the public; and
- Consider the potential harm to the reputation of the licensee.
- Authorizes the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar to issue, if appropriate and only after compliance with 10), one or more public announcements or make information public in a manner that defends the right of the licensee to a fair hearing and does any of the following:
- Confirms the fact of an investigation or proceeding;
- Provides a brief factual summary to identify the subject matter of the investigation or proceeding; or
- Provides that status of the investigation or proceeding.
- Requires the State Bar to provide notice to the licensee before making any public announcements of all of the following:
- The fact that the Board has voted to waive confidentiality;
- A description of the information that may be disclosed to the public; and
- That the licensee has five days to notify the State Bar that they are contesting the release of the information.
- Authorizes a licensee to file a motion to prevent the State Bar from disclosing information pursuant to 8).
- Requires that, if a licensee files a motion pursuant to 13), the proceeding be afforded priority on the court calendar, and that the matter be heard within 10 days from the filing of the motion.
- Modifies the deadline by which the State Bar must submit an annual discipline report from October 31 to November 30.
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United states, to inform the State Bar.
- For the purposes of 16) defines “knows” to mean actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensee’s knowledge may be inferred from the circumstances.
- Clarifies that 16) does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
- Establishes that a licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to 16) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
- Authorizes the board to amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and requires them to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement 16).
- Clarifies that, in conformity with existing case law, the Supreme Court of the State of California may discipline an attorney who is convicted of a crime that did involve moral turpitude.
- Specifies that a licensee’s obligation to reimburse the Client Security Fund arising from actions that have caused the payment of funds to an applicant from the Client Security Fund is imposed as a penalty, payable to and for the benefit of the State Bar of California to promote rehabilitation and protect the public. Establishes that this subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
- Repeals the annual statutory report regarding the Lawyer Assistance Program.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as Executive Director of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an Executive Director.
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2024, that any appointee of the Board of Trustees selected to serve as General Counsel of the State Bar is subject to confirmation by the Senate.
- Provides that, commencing January 1, 2024, the General Counsel serves at the pleasure of the Board, and that the State Bar must notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or appointment of an General Counsel.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, prohibits the Chief Trial Counsel from issuing private letters of reprisal to any attorney accused of misconduct.
- Requires the Board, on or before April 1, 2024, in consultation with the Chief Trial Counsel to provide the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees recommendations for codifying a formal disciplinary diversion program for attorneys accused of minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Authorizes the net proceeds from the sale of the State Bar’s San Francisco office building, after payment of obligations and encumbrances and the minimally reasonably costs of acquiring and relocating its facilities, to be used by the Bar to cover employee salaries, and operational costs associated with the State Bar’s discipline system and administration of the biannual admissions exam, and requires that all proceeds not expended consistent with this subdivision to be held by the State Bar without expenditure or commitment for any purpose until approved by the Legislature by statute.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensees of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, requires the annual mandatory membership fee set by the Board to pay for discipline and other functions to be ratified by the Legislature. (Business and Professions Code Section 6000 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references refer to the Business and Professions Code.)
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority of the State Bar and its Board of Trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, provides that the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Section 6001.1.)
- Requires the State Bar to develop and implement a plan to meet goals regarding diversity and inclusion, including an assessment of needed revenue. Requires the State Bar to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature by March 15, 2019. (Section 6001.3.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to enroll a licensee as an inactive licensee under specified circumstances. Requires the State Bar to terminate such enrollment upon expiration of a period equal to the period of stayed suspension in the probation matter, or until the State Bar Court makes an order regarding the recommended actual suspension in the probation matter, whichever occurs first. (Section 6007.)
- Allows applicants to be permitted to pass the admittance exam within its first four administrations upon becoming eligible to take the examination and receive credit for all law studies completed to the time the examination has passed if any of the first three administrations of the law students’ examination includes the June 2020 examination. (Section 6060 (h)(3).)
- Grants any unsuccessful applicant for admission to practice, after he or she has taken any examination and within four months after the results thereof have been declared, the right to inspect their examination papers at the office of the examining committee located nearest to the place at which the applicant took the examination. (Section 6065.)
- Directs the Board to appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as chief trial counsel. Requires the appointment to be for a term of four years and authorizes reappointment for additional four-year periods. Specifies that the chief trial counsel serves at the pleasure of the board, and prohibits them from engaging in private practice. Requires the State Bar to notify the Senate Committee on Rules and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary within seven days of the dismissal or hiring of a chief trial counsel. Makes appointment of the chief trial counsel subject to confirmation by the Senate, and the time limits prescribed in specified sections of the Government Code for Senate confirmation and for service in office applicable to the appointment. (Section 6079.5 (a).)
- Directs hearings and records of original disciplinary proceedings in the State Bar Court to be public, except as specified. Authorizes a licensee whose conduct is being investigated to waive confidentiality. (Section 6086.1 (a), (b)(1).)
- Authorizes the Chief Trial Counsel or Chair of the State Bar to waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. (Section 6086.1 (b)(2).)
- Requires the State Bar to issue an Annual Discipline Report by October 31 of each year. (Section 6086.15 (a).)
- Requires the Supreme Court to suspend an attorney upon receipt of a certified copy of a record of conviction, if it appears therefrom that the crime of which the attorney was convicted involved, or that there is probable cause to believe that it involved, moral turpitude or is a felony under the laws of California, the United States, or any state or territory thereof. (Section 6102 (a).)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect up to $390 in annual licensing fees from active members for a total annual fees bill of up to $465 for the year 2023, and an additional $75 authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $10 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6140, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect up to $97.40 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of up to $137.40, and $40 authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $5 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6141, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Requires the Board of Trustees to establish and administer the Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active licensees of the State Bar, as specified. (Section 6140.5.)
- Requires the board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each year, and a copy of the audit to be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year. (Section 6145 (a).)
- Requires the State Bar to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bar’s operations every two years. (Section 6145 (b).)
- Directs the State Auditor to conduct an independent audit to determine whether the State Bar’s attorney complaint and discipline process adequately protects the public from misconduct by licensed attorneys or those who wrongfully hold themselves out as licensed attorneys; and specifically provides that the audit analyze whether the State Bar takes reasonable steps to determine the existence and extent of alleged misconduct, if the State Bar has sufficient management controls, including conflict of interest policies, to ensure complaint investigations are not compromised by undue influence, and examine any data trends that could suggest racial or gender inequities in outcomes from the discipline process. Also provides that the audit include consideration of possible options for the State Bar to more proactively protect the public and be submitted no later than April 15, 2022 to the Board of Trustees, the Chief Justice, and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees. (Section 6145 (c).)
- Requires the State Bar to report to the Board of Trustees and Legislature on an annual basis regarding the implementation and operation of the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program. (Section 6238.)
- Provides that the chief trial counsel, with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: (a) the discipline of State Bar licensees; (b) the acts or practices of a person whom the chief trial counsel has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision regarding the unlawful practice of law or unlawful solicitations; (c) and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Section 6044.)
- States that it is the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss a complaint, admonish the attorney, or forward a completed investigation to the Office of Trial Counsel within six months after receipt of a written complaint. As to complaints designated as complicated matters by the chief trial counsel, states the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss, terminate by admonition, or forward those complaints to the Office of Trial Counsel within 12 months. (Section 6094.5 (a).)
- Requires the State Bar, no later than October 31, 2022, to propose case processing standards for competently, accurately, and timely resolving cases with the Office of Chief Trial Counsel. Sets forth what the case processing standards must be based upon and what they must take into account. Requires the State Bar to provide its analysis to the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO), and requires the LAO to report to the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees on its review of the proposal. States the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to codify case processing goals. (Section 6094.5 (b).)
- Requires the State Bar to issue an annual discipline report by October 31 of each year describing the performance and condition of the State Bar discipline system, including all matters that affect public protection. Requires that the annual discipline report include, among other things, the existing backlog of cases in the discipline system; the number of inquiries and complaints and their disposition; the speed of complaint handling and disposition, by type; and a description of the condition of the Client Security Fund. Requires that the report include statistical information presented in a consistent manner for year-to-year comparison and compare the previous five years. (Section 6086.15 (a).)
- Requires that the mandatory State Bar outreach for its Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program include continuing legal education courses relating to the prevention, detection, and treatment of substance abuse. (Section 6236.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state by the State Bar. (Cal. Const., Art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country, with approximately 195,155 active licensees and 64,000 inactive licensees. The total number of State Bar licensees is listed at 271,275, which includes 2,221 judge members, 16,976 licensees who are “Not Eligible to Practice Law,” and approximately 73,886 inactive members. (State Bar of Cal, Attorney Status, (current as of April 22, 2023), available at https://members.calbar.ca.gov/search/demographics.aspx.)
The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.”
Over the past few years, the Bar has been a topic of concern within the Legislature and legal community. Recently, these concerns have appropriately focused on seemingly irresponsible management of the agency’s funds and a failure to implement an effective disciplinary process, highlighted by the downfall of Thomas Girardi and his law firm. These issues have engendered significant skepticism about the State Bar and have triggered renewed calls for reform. This bill begins the process of implementing several of these reforms and seeks to address some of the budgetary constraints faced by the agency. In support of the measure the author states:
This bill will make changes to the State Bar Act to increase Legislative oversight and address deficiencies in the discipline system that have been highlighted by the Legislative Analyst Office, State Auditor, and the May and Lazar Reports.
The State Bar’s most basic function is to protect California consumers. Unfortunately, the State Bar as a whole not only utterly failed this task, but also conspired to conceal obvious misconduct on the part of at least one specific lawyer—Tom Girardi. The revelations in the recent May report and Joint Legislative Informational Hearing this Spring have shown that Tom Girardi’s financial web and sphere of influence reached so far within the State Bar, that he was essentially bankrolling an employee in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) and the Executive Director’s Office and said employee’s family to the tune of close to $1 million while he was being investigated by the same organization. Every subsequent report about Tom Girardi and the State Bar’s activities over the last two decades seems to be more alarming than the next. The Girardi debatable is just one known example of the need for increased oversight and regulation of this entity.
Due to overwhelming concerns about the Bar’s corruption and mismanagement, the 2024 fee will be $390 – same as last year. Instead, this bill will allow the State Bar to use building proceeds to pay for operating expenses and to ensure the economic well-being of their staff.
The State Bar’s troubled past includes failures to prioritize protection of the public and reflects dubious financial decisions. In 2012, the State Bar purchased a building in Los Angeles. However, according to the State Auditor, the State Bar did not perform a cost-benefit analysis to determine if the purchase was appropriate and warranted before receiving approval from its Board to purchase the building; did not fully inform the Legislature of its plans; and potentially risked public safety by doing so and not prioritizing other areas, such as attorney discipline. The Auditor found that the decision to purchase the Los Angles building jeopardized the State Bar’s core function to protect public safety: "Rather than using its financial resources to improve its attorney discipline system, the State Bar dedicated a significant portion of its funds to purchase and renovate a building in Los Angeles in 2012." (Cal. State Auditor, State Bar of California: It Has Not Consistently Protected the Public Through its Attorney Discipline Process and Lacks Accountability (June 2015) at 43.) Even more troubling, the State Bar chose to secure the additional funding for the Los Angeles building, in part, through a loan that required the State Bar to use $4.6 million of its Public Protection Fund as collateral for the loan. The sole purpose of the Public Protection Fund is to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency. However, without any notification to its members or the Legislature, the State Bar decided, unilaterally, to tie up over 70 percent of the Public Protection Fund for the 15-year life of the loan. The State Auditor noted that the use of money in the Public Protection Fund was part of a larger pattern in which the State Bar had been transferring money between its various funds and using the money on unrelated items. The Auditor found that the State Bar made 50 transfers between funds involving a total of $64.2 million from 2009 through 2012. (Id. at p. 13.)
Several years later, in 2016, the State Bar took out a $10 million loan to make upgrades and tenant improvements on its San Francisco building at 180 Howard Street. The State Bar did this without any input or approval from the Legislature. In order to use some of the loan as security for repayment, the State Bar chose to secure the loan through a security interest in future member dues, again without consulting the Legislature. The loan was secured on future license fees and was entered on March 1, 2016 for a term of ten years. Before receiving approval from the Board to take out the loan, the State Bar requested an opinion from its staff on the legality of the revenue pledge. Although staff found the loan to be legally permitted, legal staff suitably warned that the pledge could have unintended negative consequences, cautioning that the financial arrangement could do the following:
. . . impact the Bar's regulatory functions, could additionally be deemed inconsistent with the later adoption of Business & Professions Code, section 6001.1, which provides that the Bar must place public protection as its highest priority and additionally states, “[w]henever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interest sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.” … [S]uch a pledge could subject the Bar to criticism on the basis that it could place funds that govern its core regulatory activities at what may be deemed to be unnecessary risk. (Id. at 43.)
When the proposal was presented to the Board for approval, these risks were not included in the materials presented to the Board. Furthermore, this decision was taken just one year after the Auditor questioned the State Bar's decision to purchase its Los Angeles building on the basis that the Bar had not considered whether the resources to repay the loan would be better spent on improving the discipline system and posed a potential risk to public protection.
The State Bar also had a pattern of disconcerting spending on various expenses as identified in the 2017 audit by the State Auditor. (Cal. State Auditor, The State Bar of California: It Needs Additional Revisions to its Expense Policies to Ensure That It Uses Funds Prudently (June 2017).) For example, the State Bar spent $156,900 on alcohol between January 2015 and September 2016, and paid $768,000 for lobbying activities between 2014 and 2016. Further reports showed that the State Bar paid for various trips to El Salvador, Mexico, Guatemala, Nicaragua, Peru, and Mongolia according to documents compiled by The Recorder. (Ibid.) All of these property transactions and expensive trips were occurring while Tom Girardi was evading scrutiny for his activates. To its credit, in response to these reports and the deunification of the Bar, the State Bar has reduced its expenses in many of these areas and prohibited the purchase of alcohol for its events and meetings. Just this year, the State Bar decided to not renew its long-time contract with a lobbyist and move this function in-house, like all other state agencies. (Cheryl Miller, State Bar Nixes Contract With Its Capitol Lobbyist, The Recorder (Jan. 6. 2023).)
The State Bar’s existing disciplinary process. The State Bar Act provides that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar and that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, protection of the public is to be paramount. (Business & Professions Code Sec. 6001.1.) The Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) is charged with receiving complaints against attorneys, conducting investigations, determining whether to file formal charges, and prosecuting cases in the State Bar Court. OCTC is headed by a Chief Trial Counsel (CTC), who is appointed by the Board and subject to confirmation by the Senate. The CTC is appointed for a four-year term and may be reappointed for additional terms. The State Bar Court is an independent professional court that hears cases regarding attorney discipline and makes recommendations to the Supreme Court regarding suspension or disbarment of an attorney for violations constituting professional misconduct or conviction of serious crimes. The Supreme Court makes the ultimate decision regarding suspension or disbarment of a licensed attorney. California is the only state that has an independent court dedicated to ruling on attorney discipline cases.
Phases of the discipline process – intake, investigation, charging, and hearing. The discipline process consists of four phases. The first is the intake phase where the OCTC receives a complaint that an attorney has violated a rule of professional conduct or ethical requirement. Additionally, the OCTC may initiate an investigation on its own based on information it has received. OCTC conducts an initial review and gathers some information on the complaint. It then will either close the complaint or refer it for further investigation. The State Bar has reported that 63 percent of complaints are closed at the intake phase and that, on average it takes 42 days to close a complaint at this stage. (Legis. Analyst, The California State Bar: Assessment of Proposed Disciplinary Case Processing Standards (Jan. 2023), p. 6.) The second phase is where OCTC investigators, under the supervision of OCTC attorneys, conduct an investigation into the complaint by conducting interviews, issuing subpoenas, reviewing documents, and taking other actions to determine whether there is clear and convincing evidence of attorney misconduct, or if a case should be closed. The State has reported that 33 percent of complaints are closed at the investigation phase and on average take 230 days to close cases at this stage. (Ibid.) The closing of a case at this phase can be due to lack of evidence or because the State Bar has reached an agreement with the attorney in lieu of discipline for violations that are considered low-level. (Ibid.)
At the charging phase, OCTC evaluates the evidence collected and begins documenting potential charges and discipline to seek. If it is determined that there is sufficient evidence to file charges against an accused attorney, OCTC notifies the attorney in writing of its intent to file formal charges with the State Bar Court. The accused attorney is entitled to request a confidential meeting, referred to as an Early Neutral Evaluation Conference (ENEC), before formal charges are filed. An ENEC is where the attorney and OCTC appear before a State Bar Court hearing judge to evaluate the evidence and charges and to attempt to resolve the case by negotiating a settlement. If requested by an accused attorney, an ENEC is mandatory; however, informal negotiations may still occur between the accused attorney and OCTC even if the attorney has not requested an ENEC. Additionally, OCTC can close a case or come to a settlement with an accused attorney during this phase. The State Bar has reported that about 4 percent of complaints handled by OCTC were closed at the charging phase, reached negotiated settlement, or resulted in the filing of charges, and that on average these actions took 449 days. (Ibid.) At any point prior to filing charges with the State Bar Court, a matter may be closed with no public disclosure and the issuance of a private letter of reproval to the licensee. The final stage of the discipline process is the hearing phase when OCTC files disciplinary charges with the State Bar Court and prosecutes the case. The case is adjudicated by a State Bar Court hearing judge who imposes discipline based on the misconduct committed, ranging from dismissal, public or private reprovals, probation, suspension, or disbarment. The State Bar Court also reviews settlement terms reached at the end of the charging phase. If the proposed discipline involves the suspension or disbarment of the attorney, the California Supreme Court reviews the findings and recommended disciplinary action and issues a final order.
The State Bar discipline process suffers from a backlog of cases. The State Bar discipline process has suffered from a backlog of cases (cases that are not processed within six months of receipt) for a very long time. In the 2021 audit, the Auditor found that changes made to improve the State Bar’s discipline system had significantly reduced its efficiency, noting that “the State Bar’s backlog grew by 87 percent from the end of December 2015, to the end of June 2020.” (Cal. State Auditor, The State Bar of California: It Is Not Effectively Managing Its System for Investigating and Disciplining Attorneys Who Abuse the Public Trust (April 2021) at 11.) As pointed out by the Auditor, this “growing backlog allows attorneys who are under investigation more time to continue practicing law while their cases are pending, increasing the risk for potential harm to the public.” (Ibid.) The Auditor’s “analysis indicates that both higher- and lower-priority cases are taking significantly longer to resolve.” (Ibid.) Additionally, as the Auditor highlights, the “State Bar is also disciplining attorneys at a drastically lower rate for reasons it cannot adequately explain. From 2015 through 2019, the total number of cases that resulted in discipline—including reprovals, suspensions, and disbarments—declined by 54 percent.” (Ibid.)
The impact of the Thomas Girardi Scandal and resulting investigations into corruption within the Bar. In 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, who allegedly embezzled millions of dollars from his clients. The history of Girardi’s misconduct spans decades and includes the following tragic examples:
- In 2010, a massive leak in a PG&E gas main line in San Bruno, California led to a massive explosion and fire that destroyed a neighborhood, injured 58 people, and killed eight. Joe Ruigomez, who suffered burns over 80% of his body, was one of the area residents who was severely injured. Girardi represented Ruigomez in litigation against PG&E and, despite obtaining a $53 million settlement on his behalf, lied to Ruigomez and his family that the settlement amount was just over $7 million. (Hamilton and Ryan, Tom Girardi, disgraced L.A. lawyer and ‘Real Housewives’ spouse, indicted on fraud charges, Los Angeles Times (February 1. 2023) available at: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-02-01/tom-girardi-indictment-la-lawyer.) After concluding that Girardi had misappropriated millions of dollars of their settlement, and fearing that his funds might not be recoverable in the future, Ruigomez signed an agreement with the lawyer to receive just $12 million. Ruigomez received one million dollars of the agreed-upon settlement, and then the payments by Girardi stopped. Ruigomez will need a lifetime of extensive costly medical treatments that the settlement was intended to pay for.
- In 2011, Girardi settled a case on behalf of 138 women who claimed to have developed breast cancer as a result of taking a hormone-replacement therapy. However, the amount the women received did not match the expectations communicated to them by Girardi. By 2014, 28 of those women had filed suit against their former attorney, claiming Girardi and his firm had failed to appropriately detail the terms of the settlement or provide accurate accounting records. (Bronstad, Plaintiffs Lawyer Tom Girardi’s Finances Pried Open in Misappropriation Suit, The National Law Journal (May 11, 2016) available at: https://www.law.com/nationallawjournal/almID/1202757360760/. )
- In 2015, Girardi represented Josie Hernández in a suit against the manufacturer of a surgical instrument that made her sick. Despite winning a $135,000 settlement on her behalf, as of 2019, Ms. Hernandez had yet to see a single cent of the settlement amount. Instead, Girardi appears to have lied to Ms. Hernández claiming that the firm had not received any of the settlement while he was in fact using the funds to pay for personal expenses. (Hamilton and Ryan, Tom Girardi, disgraced L.A. lawyer and ‘Real Housewives’ spouse, indicted on fraud charges, supra.)
- Beginning at least as early as 2015, Girardi began borrowing large sums of money from a variety of banks and lenders to pay settlements with complaining clients, pointing to his substantial amounts of real property and wealth to make himself appear to be a safe investment. Well aware of his reputation as a lawyer who obtained impressive settlement amounts, these creditors expected repayment promptly following Girardi’s legal victories. However, Girardi failed to pay his creditors the amounts he owed them.
In response to the scandal, the State Bar initiated an investigation into Girardi. It is unclear when the State Bar began its comprehensive investigation of Girardi (and its own role in allowing hundreds of complaints against him to go uninvestigated and his egregious ethical violations to be unpunished). But the scandal of the Bar’s involvement with Girardi came to public attention in March of 2021, when the Los Angeles Times published a series of articles detailing how “the powerful lawyer cultivated close relationships with investigators and bar executives and showered them with gifts, including private plane rides, boozy lunches at Morton’s, free legal representation and Vegas shindigs.” (Hamilton and Ryan, Another legacy for Tom Girardi: Tighter regulation of California lawyers,” (Dec. 28, 2022), available at https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-12-28/another-legacy-for-tom-girardi-tighter-regulation-of-california-lawyers.) In June of 2021, the State Bar made what was described as a “stunning public admission” that an audit of Girardi’s disciplinary file “revealed mistakes made in some investigations over the many decades of Mr. Girardi’s career going back some 40 years and spanning the tenure of many Chief Trial Counsels.” (Ryan and Hamilton, State Bar admits ‘mistakes’ in handling complaints against ‘Real Housewives’ Tom Girardi (June 10, 2021), available at: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-06-10/tom-girardi-california-state-bar-admits-mistakes.)
According to the State Bar, it began investigating its own misconduct related to Girardi on an unspecified date “in 2021.” In an Open Letter from the State Bar in November of 2022, the State Bar described its efforts to get to the bottom of what the State Bar did and did not do vis-à-vis Girardi and how it handled repeated complaints from the public about Girardi’s serious misconduct as follows:
The State Bar began the process of righting the wrongs brought to light by the Girardi matters in 2021, when we conducted an audit of all closed disciplinary matters concerning Girardi. That was followed by the launch of a comprehensive investigation (still ongoing), into prior actions taken by any staff or other State Bar affiliated persons, to determine whether the State Bar’s handling of matters involving Girardi was affected by his connections to, or relationships or influence with these individuals. (Open Letter Regarding the State Bar’s Thomas V. Girardi Disclosure (Nov. 3, 2022), Page 2, available at: https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/Open-Letter-Girardi-Disclosure-11-03-22.pdf.)
Throughout the decades, Girardi’s clients and colleagues submitted reports of misconduct to the State Bar. Despite attempts to raise the alarms, the Bar failed to issue any form of discipline against Girardi until 2021. Girardi’s law license was ordered inactive on March 9, 2021, and he was ultimately disbarred by the California Supreme Court in July of the same year. It appears that this discipline occurred only after a federal judge found that Girardi had embezzled at least two million dollars of client funds and referred the matter to the U.S. Attorney’s office for further criminal investigation. (Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP, Independent Investigation for the State Bar of California: Report of Investigation, supra, at p. 14.)
Lazar Report. In order to obtain an outside investigation about the matter, the State Bar commissioned a report by attorney Alyse Lazar to examine State Bar files regarding Girardi in early 2021. The Lazar investigation was conducted between March and May 2021. (State Bar of Cal., Frequently Asked Questions: May and Lazar Reports on Past Handling of Girardi Complaints, Q. 12, available at: https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/News/FAQ-May-and-Lazar-Reports-on-Handling-of-Girardi-Complaints.) Lazar reviewed 115 Bar investigative files of past closed complaints against Girardi. (Id. at q. 5.) “The purpose was to determine whether anything in the files indicated that case-handling decisions were influenced by personal or financial relationships with or benefit to any of the individuals who were involved, including State Bar employees and outside counsel assigned to handle cases when staff have conflicts of interest.” (Ibid.)
Not surprisingly, the Bar’s investigative files did not include documentation of misconduct by State Bar staff or leadership within the files. Therefore, also not surprisingly, the Lazar investigation also “found no evidence of influence by Girardi in the files themselves.” (Ibid.) In the report prepared after the investigation (known as the Lazar Report), however, Lazar noted “errors in how cases were handled over the four decades of Girardi’s career” and “significant issues regarding the investigation and evaluation of high-dollar, high-volume trust accounts.” (Ibid.) In response, the State Bar’s Board of Trustees hired the Los Angeles law firm Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to conduct an in-depth investigation of the State Bar’s handling of the Girardi matters. (While it is unclear when the State Bar retained Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP, the State Bar announced in January of 2022 that it had hired the firm to conduct the investigation. (See FAQs: May and Lazar Reports on Past Handling of Girardi Complaints, Q1.).)
The May Report. More than 18 months after the first Los Angeles Times stories about Girardi were published, the State Bar’s investigation of the Girardi scandal apparently was still ongoing. As of late December 2022, legislators expressed frustration that the investigation had not yet been completed and the Bar had not shared any of their preliminary findings with the Legislature. Former Assembly Judiciary Committee Chair Mark Stone said in an interview with the Los Angeles Times published on December 28, 2022, that he was disappointed that the agency had not updated legislators on the investigation’s progress. “Those are the kinds of things that need to happen to build back trust,” Stone said. “They have erred on the side of everything being confidential as a way of hiding malfeasance or bad actions for such a long time. Maybe they need to err on the side of openness.” (Matt Hamilton, Harriet Ryan, Another legacy for Tom Girardi: Tighter regulation of California lawyers, supra.) On March 9, 2023, Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Thomas Umberg said in an interview that he would not include a fee in the annual State Bar licensing bill he is carrying this year, “until the state bar demonstrates they’ve taken adequate steps to address transparency and conflicts of interest.” (Cheryl Miller, “Key Lawmaker Threatens to Eliminate State Bar Licensing Fees for 2024,” (March 10, 2023), available at: https://www.law.com/therecorder/2023/03/10/key-lawmaker-threatens-to-eliminate-state-bar-licensing-fees-for-2024/.) On the same day that it released the Lazar report, the State Bar also released a heavily redacted version of the May Report that included significantly more details about the Bar’s past mishandling of complaints against Girardi.
Firm partner Aaron May interviewed 74 witnesses; reviewed over 950,000 documents; issued 23 subpoenas; gathered evidence about activities of Girardi (who by the time was disbarred and bankrupt) and the conduct of Bar staff and officials in relation to Girardi; and wrote a report about the investigation and his findings. The report (known as the May Report) uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.” (Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP, Independent Investigation for the State Bar of California: Report of Investigation, supra.) In brief, the alleged conduct of each of these officials constituted significant corruption and unlawful actions. Highlights included then-Executive Director Joe Dunn’s decision to turn a blind eye to complaints of an improper relationship between Girardi and Thomas Layton; Dunn’s decision to fire four attorneys within OCTC, including two who had actively advocated for investigations to continue into Girardi; Layton’s acceptance of one million dollars’ worth of gifts from Girardi for both himself and his wife; Layton’s improper involvement in Girardi’s matters before the State Bar; Robert Hawley’s decision to intervene on behalf of Girardi and ghost write a decision in one of Girardi’s matters on behalf of a special deputy trial counsel (SDTC); and Sean SeLegue’s failure to disclose that, prior to becoming a member of the Board of Trustees for the Bar, he had worked on a team at his law firm that was assigned to research whether a Ninth Circuit decision to discipline Girardi was sufficient punishment which resulted in a recommendation for no further discipline of Girardi.
2022 Audit of the State Bar’s Discipline System by the State Auditor. In light of the Girardi revelations, SB 211 (Umberg) Chap. 723, Stats. 2021, required an independent audit by the State Auditor of the State Bar’s attorney complaint and discipline process to determine if it adequately protects the public from attorney misconduct. That audit found that “weak policies limits [the State Bar’s] ability to protect the public from attorney misconduct.” (Cal. State Auditor, The State Bar of California’s Attorney Discipline Process: Weak Policies Limit Its Ability to Protect the Public From Attorney Misconduct, Report 2022-030 (April 14, 2022).) The audit discovered that many cases (64.5 percent) are closed during the State Bar’s intake process, with another 22.2 percent closed during the investigation process, leaving only 5.3 percent of cases receiving formal discipline, which can include formal or private discipline. (Id. at p. 11.) Additionally, the audit indicated that a disproportionate number of many cases appeared to be closed by private discipline and without further investigation. This private discipline, according to the audit, may not deter some attorneys from further misconduct and can potentially allow some to commit misconduct. The audit stated:
A State Bar study from July 2021 showed that a significant number of attorneys were investigated for misconduct within two years after being disciplined. It also showed that nearly 26 percent of attorneys whose cases were closed with a warning letter in 2019 had a new complaint about their professional conduct investigated by the State Bar within two years of the original case being closed. […]
Notwithstanding these steps, patterns of attorney misconduct suggest that the State Bar is overusing nonpublic measures. [..] Our review of a selection of cases associated with five […] attorneys [whose cases were closed through nonpublic measures] determined that State Bar staff closed cases through nonpublic measures despite indications in its case files that further investigation or actual discipline may have been warranted. Of the five attorneys, four had at least one previous complaint for similar misconduct that was closed through nonpublic measures. (emphasis added) (Id. at p. 14.)
The audit provided a specific example of a case that used private discipline that highlighted the issues with the practices of the State Bar:
An attorney exhibited a pattern of failing to provide settlement payments or to provide files to clients until the client complained. The State Bar closed cases against this attorney 28 times over 16 years using nonpublic measures and all of the other closed cases were closed outright. However, complaints against the attorney continued to increase. From 2014 to 2021, the attorney was the subject of 165 complaints. Despite the high number of complaints, many for similar matters, the State Bar has imposed no discipline, and the attorney still maintains an active license. In one early case, the State Bar issued a warning letter to the attorney for failing to release a client’s case file for nearly a year. However, the attorney has continued to generate complaints from other clients for this same issue. In the 11 years since the State Bar issued that warning letter, complaints have led the State Bar to issue 11 directional letters requiring the attorney to return client files. (Id. at p. 17 [emphasis added].)
The audit also found that the State Bar places too great an emphasis on closing cases quickly. The audit concluded that, “the State Bar’s actions have failed to prevent additional misconduct of a similar nature, leading to an increase in the volume of subsequent complaints about a specific attorney for the same misconduct. In turn, this has increased the State Bar’s workload, which makes it more difficult for it to address its backlog and fulfill its primary mission of protecting the public.” (Id. at pp. 18 – 19.) The audit also found that the practices and policies of the State Bar limited its ability to identify patterns of complaints, which if identified could prevent future misconduct. (Id. at p. 25.) A quarter of all attorney complaints involve client trust accounts, yet the State Bar closed many cases because the amounts involved were de minimis (under $50). Sometimes these complaints were closed without even notifying the attorneys involved, even if those closures were not in the best interest of the public. (Id. at p. 2.) The audit provided several recommendations to address the issues identified. (Id. at pp. 5- 7.) The State Bar generally agreed with the recommendations by the Auditor and began implementing some of the recommendations. Other recommendations, most notably the monitoring of client trust funds, require input from other stakeholders, including banks, are still in development.
2022 LAO Report Regarding the Bar’s Proposed Changes to its Discipline System. The State Auditor is not the only agency to highlight inconsistent practices and issues within the Bar’s discipline system. In reviewing a State Bar proposal to update its case processing standards, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) noted that the organizational changes within the OCTC actually decreased efficiency within the organization and resulted in greater case processing delays. (LAO, The California State Bar: Assessment of Proposed Disciplinary Case Processing Standards (Jan. 2023) at p. 11, available at: https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4655.) The LAO also highlighted potential misallocation of staffing resources within OCTC, in that existing staffing levels show that the office may be disproportionately overstaffed with attorneys (who tend to require greater financial resources to employ), while underutilizing non-attorney investigators. (Id., at p. 10.) Based on the LAO findings, it may be prudent for the Legislature to withhold significant new resources until the State Bar and the OCTC can better justify its organization, staffing, and case processing metrics.
This bill. In an effort to address some of the concerns raised regarding the Bar over the last few years, this bill proposes a number of reform efforts. In addition to a number of amendments to clarify or correct existing law, the bill requires the Executive Director and General Counsel to be appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the Board, and be confirmed by the California State Senate. The bill also authorizes the Board to vote to release limited information regarding ongoing investigations into attorney misconduct. The bill also requires an attorney who knows that another attorney has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States to report that attorney to the Bar. The bill also seeks to add transparency to the discipline system by eliminating private letters of reproval and instead directs the State Bar to propose to the Legislature a diversion system to retrain, rather than punish, attorneys who commit minor violations of the Rule of Professional Conduct. Finally, the bill authorizes the Bar to utilize proceeds from the sale of real estate for limited purposes focused on their primary functions.
Conforming the Process for Appointing State Bar Leaders with the Process for Appointing Leaders at State Agencies. The attorney leadership of the State Bar generally consists of the Executive Director, the General Counsel, and the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC). All three parties independently report to the Board. (State Bar of Cal. Organizational Chat, available at: https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/Who-We-Are/Organizational-Chart.) Although the Executive Director is ostensibly the public-facing leader of the organization, only the CTC is subject to the appointment and confirmation process in the California State Senate. Instead of being confirmed by the State Senate, the Executive Director and General Counsel are simply appointed by the Board for a period of time specified in a contract with the Board. This contract also makes both offices different from nearly every other appointee to every position in state service who serves at the pleasure of the appointing entity and can be terminated at any time without cause.
This existing framework is generally a vestige of the pre-2017 governance of the State Bar, when the Bar served as both a regulator and trade association. The existing framework for appointing and managing the State Bar’s Executive Director and General Counsel has three primary deficiencies. First, by bypassing the Stat Senate’s confirmation process, unlike the Chief Trial Counsel, neither the Executive Director nor General Counsel are required to share their vision and goals for the agency with the Legislature, and thus should those goals not be achieved, have no accountability to the people’s elected representatives. Second, because the Executive Director and General Counsel are provided with a right to employment protected by contract, short of corruption or outright insubordination, it is difficult to remove either officeholder should they prove to be ineffective. The State Bar encountered this very issue when it sought to terminate then-Executive Director Joe Dunn for misusing State Bar resources. Finally, due to the nature of the contractual hiring processes, the State Bar’s salary structure, particularly for the Executive Director, is woefully out-of-line with other high-ranking government officials. According to the Los Angeles Times, thanks to a recent (contractually guaranteed) raise, the Executive Director of the State Bar now makes $344,000 annually. (Harriet Ryan, California State Bar, under scrutiny for Tom Girardi scandal, gives director $43,000 raise, LA Times (Aug 24, 2022) available at: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-08-24/troubled-state-bar-gives-top-official-43-000raise#:~:text=The%20pay%20hike%20brought%20Leah,named%20chief%20justice%20(%24293%2C286).) This amount is more than $100,000 more than Governor Gavin Newsom earns each year ($218,556); and nearly $50,000 per year more than the Chief Justice of the State Supreme Court ($293,286), even though the Chief Justice and the State Supreme Court technically oversee the State Bar. The current General Counsel enjoys a salary of $328,000.
Thus, to boost public confidence in the Legislature’s oversight of the State Bar and ensure that State Bar resources are allocated in a responsible manner, this bill makes both the Executive Director and the General Counsel subject to appointment and removal in the same manner as the CTC.
Modifications to existing transparency measures to provide greater opportunity for transparency. Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code provides that all disciplinary investigations are confidential until the time when formal charges are filed and all investigations are confidential until a formal proceeding is instituted. The statute provides that the CTC or the Chair of the Board may waive confidentiality, but only when warranted for protection of the public. As noted above, the LA Times sought the release of documents related to any complaints and discipline of Girardi from the State Bar, and had to sue the State Bar because it refused to release the records claiming the statute only applied to active investigations, not closed investigations. Eventually the State Bar released records related to Girardi, but it was more than 20 months after the initial request by the Times. The Chair of the Board at the time of the request was Sean SeLegue, who according to the May Report, did not disclose his membership on a team at his law firm that was assigned to research the sufficiency of a prior investigation of Girardi. His involvement in the investigation provided a clear conflict of interest in his ability to make a determination regarding whether or not to release the requested records about investigations against Girardi, such as the one his firm conducted.
Existing law regarding the confidentiality of Bar investigations is crafted in such a way as to promote the greatest degree of protection possible for attorneys who are accused of misconduct. On the one hand, this ensures that individuals are able to defend their licenses and their ability to earn a living. On the other hand, it makes it practically impossible for the general public to be aware of bad actors—even when their continuing practice endangers the public. Considering the significant backlog of disciplinary matters facing the State Bar, that backlog arguably facilitates the continued bad behaviors of some attorneys, providing a balanced disclosure of information regarding licensees who may be engaging in misconduct seems a reasonable approach. In order to promote greater transparency, while still remaining mindful of continuing to protect the privacy and due process rights of licensees, this bill proposes a new structure by which the Board may vote, in closed session, to release limited information regarding an ongoing investigation. The bill specifies that the CTC and Board may elect to waive confidentiality and release limited information when (1) warranted for protection of the public and importantly (2) when the allegation is based upon an immediate harm to the public, including ongoing fraud, theft, or embezzlement. By clarifying that CTC and Board may proactively waive confidentiality in circumstances where they know an attorney poses an ongoing threat to the public, these provisions will grant greater latitude to the State Bar to immediately carry out its mission and ultimately should provide more protection to the public.
Eliminating the use of private letters of reproval and establishing a new diversion program for minor offenses. As exemplified by the 2022 report by the LAO, discussed above, it seems that a disproportionate number of complaints submitted to the Bar are resolved through private disciplinary methods. In order to ensure that the Bar’s disciplinary process provides a greater degree of protection for the public, the Legislature must ensure that the Office of Chief Trial Counsel modifies its practices and becomes a more efficient, effective, and even-handed regulator. The LAO has noted that the State Bar’s current practice of treating all potential disciplinary cases similarly does not effectively weigh the seriousness of potential offenses in a manner that protects the public. (LAO, The California State Bar: Assessment of Proposed Disciplinary Case Processing Standards, supra, at pp. 11-12.) Although the State Bar does dispose of some relatively minor offenses with private reprisal letters, this process is opaque and inconsistent.
In order to ensure that the disciplinary process is more transparent and fair, this bill proposes to revise Office of Chief Trial Counsel’s practices in several ways. First, it eliminates the use of private letters of reproval starting in 2025. Second, it directs the Board, in coordination with the Office of Chief Trial Counsel, to develop a diversionary program for minor violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Theoretically, this new program could allow low-level violations to be diverted into a training and mentoring program to correct attorney’s behavior without a full-fledged disciplinary proceeding. This program could function in a manner similar to the Traffic School program for traffic violations or diversion of low-level criminal offenders pursuant to Penal Code Section 1000, whereby offenders are retrained and, so long as no additional offenses are committed within a specific time period and the conduct is not serious, the offense is dismissed and the offender’s record remains private.
Require attorneys to report other members of the Bar who they know participated in or plan to participate in acts of treason. The attack on the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021, was the culmination of a months-long effort to utilize spurious legal theories and misguided political strategies to overturn the results of the November 2020 U.S. Presidential Election and place former Donald J. Trump back into office, despite his clear loss of both the popular vote and the Electoral College. One of the leading legal advocates behind the effort was prominent former attorney and law professor John Charles Eastman. Eastman advocated for the theory that then-Vice President Mike Pence could singlehandedly reject the counting of electors from states in which Trump claimed votes were “stolen” from him. When Pence refused to go along with Eastman’s theory, he sparked the now infamous chants of “hang Mike Pence” by angry Capitol insurrectionists. Eastman’s legal theory was largely derided by other experts as far-fetched. Indeed, in light of the harm caused by Eastman’s ill-conceived legal plan, in January, the State Bar moved to initiate formal disciplinary actions against Eastman as a result of his, “false and misleading statements regarding purported election fraud,” and his advocacy for legal theories that were, “unsupported by law, based on false and misleading assertions of fact, and designed for the purpose of keeping Trump in office.” (State Bar of California-Office of Communications, Attorney John Eastman Charged with Multiple Disciplinary Counts by the State Bar of California, Jan. 26, 2023, available at: https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/News/News-Releases/attorney-john-eastman-charged-with-multiple-disciplinary-counts-by-the-state-bar-of-california.) Under existing law, none of Eastman’s colleagues would have been required to take action to deter Eastman’s conduct or to inform the State Bar of his efforts to advance the dangerous and suspect legal theories that underpinned the January 6th Insurrection.
This bill proposes to build upon the State Bar’s newly enacted Rule of Professional Conduct that requires lawyers to report fraud, misappropriation of funds and other criminal acts or conduct that reflect adversely on lawyers' "honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness,” by fellow attorneys. This bill would specifically mandate that attorneys also report conduct by fellow attorneys that is tantamount to treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States of America. By codifying this standard, this bill seeks to ensure that any attorney peddling Eastman-like legal theories that undermine the core tenants of democracy are immediately reported to authorities.
The State Bar’s budget faces significant financial difficulties. The inflationary pressures of recent years have spared few areas of the economy. The State Bar’s budget is no exception. As a result of increased costs and the provision of necessary cost-of-living adjustments for staff, including the Executive Director, the State Bar’s budget is facing a significant operating deficit. While many of the State Bar’s budgetary woes are related to the prior, questionable, decisions by the Bar’s leadership (discussed above), the State Auditor has confirmed that the State Bar’s is facing significant and legitimate financial hardships. (California State Auditor, The State Bar of California- It Will Need a Mandatory Licensing Fee Increase in 2024 to Support Its Operations (Apr. 13, 2023) available at: https://www.bsa.ca.gov/reports/2022-031/index.html.)
Notwithstanding the need, the State Bar has provided this Committee with widely varying accounts of how much funding it needs over the past several months, making it challenging to fully assess the Bar’s true financial state. At the Board meeting held on June 12, 2023, the State Bar reflected a proposed fee increase of $98. (State Bar of California, Open Session Agenda Item 701 June 2023 available at: https://board.calbar.ca.gov/Agenda.aspx?id=16974&tid=0&show=100035621&s=true#10044198.) According to the most recent documents provided to Committee staff by the State Bar, however, the Bar now is advocating for a fee increase of $107.
Given the wide variations in fee increase needs estimated by the Bar; the discrepancy between those estimates and the assessments of the State Auditor; continuing and long-standing critiques from outside auditors of the Bar’s internal accounting and budgeting process; and the fact that this Committee’s expertise is on policy and not budgetary matters, the Legislature, the State Bar, and the Governor may wish to consider including the State Bar in the annual budget process. Inclusion in the budget process would enable the State Bar to better present its needs to state financial experts, have their proposals vetted by the Department of Finance, and considered by the Legislature’s fiscal experts. Not only would this boost the Legislature’s understanding of the agency’s finances, but it also would add another degree of accountability to the State Bar’s budgeting process.
However, given that the State Bar is not presently part of the budget process, the determination of the fee imposed upon attorneys rests with the Judiciary Committees. According to the State Auditor, the State Bar may need a fee increase of up to $24 to fund operations. While the Legislature may wish to consider authorizing such an increase to better stabilize the Bar’s finances, the Legislature may also conclude that a fee increase may not be the only available means of balancing the State Bar’s budget in the short term. The State Bar’s Board recently approved the sale of the Bar’s office building in downtown San Francisco. The proceeds of that sale appear to be sufficient to fund operations for at least the next year. Accordingly, this bill will authorize the Bar to utilize those funds to pay for staff salaries, administer the biannual bar exam, and the operation of the Office of Chief Trial Counsel. Additionally, an amendment will be taken to correct a drafting error in the current bill’s fee authority to ensure that the 2024 fee will be the same as the 2023 fee for active licensees of the State Bar.
The Commission on Judicial Nominees Evaluation and potential additional costs savings for the State Bar. For much of its history, the State Bar provided informal input to the Governor regarding appointments to the bench. However, when then-Lieutenant Governor Mike Curb opted to appoint a judge to the bench when Governor Jerry Brown was out of the state, the Commission on Judicial Nominees Evaluation (hereafter the Commission) was created in 1979 to ensure such an instance could not happen again. (https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/Who-We-Are/Committees/Judicial-Nominees-Evaluation.) The Commission was codified, and the statute essentially mandated the State Bar do what it had been informally doing for decades.
However, in the nearly 45 years since it was created, the workload imposed on the State Bar by the Commission has grown significantly in conjunction with the growth of California’s judiciary. As a result, the State Bar is now financially burdened by the Commission. To the extent that these financial burdens divert resources away from attorney discipline, the Commission’s continued presence under the auspices of the State Bar is undermining the agency’s core mission. Given that the Commission generally assists the Governor, and not the judicial branch or the individual attorney licensees who pay for the Commission out of the annual licensing fee, the Commission’s continued presence at the State Bar may even violate the tax and fee provisions of Proposition 26. Accordingly, the Legislature and Governor should strongly consider moving the Commission out of the State Bar and into the Executive Branch it is designed to serve.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Manuela Boucher-de la Cadena & Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 40 |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 40
Author: Umberg (D)
Amended: 3/21/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 5/2/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SUBJECT: State Bar: annual license fees
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the State Bar of California (State Bar) to collect an unspecified amount of annual license fees for active licensees for 2024.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- The Legislature sets the annual fees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140, 6141.)
- The State Bar is governed by the Board of Trustees of the State Bar (Board). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6010 et seq.; § 6016.)
- Establishes that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public is to be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect the following fees from active licensees for the year 2023:
- $39 annual license fee, except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum is not to exceed $386. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.)
- $40 fee for the Client Security Fund. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.55.)
- $25 fee for the costs of the disciplinary system. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.6.)
- $10 fee for the attorney diversion and assistance program. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect the following fees from inactive licensees for the year 2023:
- $97.40 annual license fee, except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum is not exceed $96.40. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6141(a).)
- $10 fee for the Client Security Fund. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.55)
- $25 fee for the costs of the disciplinary system. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.6.)
- $5 fee for the attorney diversion and assistance program. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.9.)
- An inactive licensee who is 70 years old or older is not required to pay an annual license fee. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6141(b).)
- Requires the State Bar to charge a $45 fee in addition to the annual license fee for active and inactive licensees for the purposes of funding legal services for persons of limited means, as provided, unless a licensee elects not to support those activities in which case the licensee can deduct the amount from the annual license fee. Requires $5 of the $45 fee to be allocated to qualified legal services projects or qualified support centers, as defined, to hire law school graduates with a temporary provisional license issued by the State Bar, as provided. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.03.)
- Requires the State Bar to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bar’s operations every two years. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6145 (b).)
- Provides that the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC, with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar; the acts or practices of a person whom the CTC has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of the State Bar Act; and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6044.)
- Provides that it shall be the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss a complaint, admonish the attorney, or forward a completed investigation to the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) within six months after receipt of a written complaint. As to complaints designated as complicated matters by the chief trial counsel, it shall be the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss, terminate by admonition, or forward those complaints to the OCTC within 12 months. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6094.5(a).)
This bill authorizes the State Bar to collect an unspecified amount for the annual license fee for active licensees in 2024.
Comments
As a constitutional matter, the judicial power of California is vested in the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal, and superior courts. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 1.) (In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, 592; Obrien v. Jones (2000) 23 Cal.4th 40, 48.) In addressing this inherent authority to regulate the practice of law, the Supreme Court has explained: “’The important difference between regulation of the legal profession and regulation of other professions is this: Admission to the bar is a judicial function, and members of the bar are officers of the court, subject to discipline by the court. Hence, under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, the court has inherent and primary regulatory power.’” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 593.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.)
Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Bar of California is a public corporation. Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) At the same time, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of license fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1) and subjecting the CTC of the State Bar to Senate confirmation (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6079.5).
The State Bar’s highest priority is the protection of the public, which includes quickly finding and disciplining dishonest or incompetent attorneys. As the May and Lazar reports show, the State Bar has utterly failed at fulfilling its mission. In 2021, Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. As the Lazar report demonstrates, serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against him were reported to the State Bar over decades, but the State Bar did not take action against him until 2021 when he was disbarred by the California Supreme Court after a disciplinary hearing by the State Bar.[1] This only occurred after a federal court found that he had misappropriated $2 million that was awarded to victims’ families in the Lion Air flight 610 plane crash of 2018, and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. This incident triggered numerous further accusations against Girardi for stealing client funds and the true scope of his malfeasance finally began to materialize. Eventually, Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, were forced into bankruptcy. This year Girardi was indicted by federal grand juries in Los Angeles and Chicago on charges that he embezzled more than $18 million from his clients.
The State Bar refused to release information about complaints, closed cases, or investigations it had conducted on Girardi citing to confidentiality provisions in Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code. The L.A. Times sued the State Bar and eventually the State Bar agreed to release roughly 40 years of disciplinary records that showed Girardi had over 200 complaints filed against him since 1983, many of which alleged misappropriation of client finds. In the wake of this, the State Bar initiated the Lazar and May reports.
The State Bar hired the law firm of Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to examine how the State Bar handled complaints filed against disbarred attorney Girardi, and whether that process was affected by Girardi’s connections, to or influence, at the State Bar. During the 16-month investigation, Aaron May and his team reviewed over 950,000 documents, issued 23 subpoenas, and interviewed, either voluntarily or under compulsion, 74 witnesses. The May report is lengthy and includes numerous revelations that show that Girardi maintained an extensive network of connections at all levels of the State Bar. The report stated:
Our investigation determined that Girardi cultivated contacts on the Board, in the Executive Director’s Office, and in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (“OCTC”), both at the managerial and line prosecutor and investigator level. Girardi’s ties to the State Bar spanned decades and appear to have been intentional. We found evidence indicating that Girardi was involved in the appointment of at least one State Bar Court judge and the attempted appointment of a Chief Trial Counsel (“CTC”). And we also found evidence that Girardi made offers of career assistance to people in State Bar leadership, apparently seeking to make additional connections when and where he could. We have evidence—both documentary and testimonial—showing that at least nine former State Bar employees or Board members had connections to or accepted items of value, travel, or meals from Girardi while they were working at the State Bar or State Bar Court or were on the Board, although not all of these individuals were involved in the handling of cases against Girardi. We did not find any connections between Girardi and any current State Bar employees, jurists, or Board members. (at p. 3.)
Highlights of findings from the May report include:
- One employee and his family received almost $1 million from Girardi during the employee’s tenure at the State Bar.
- That two former OCTC employees had conflicts-of-interest at the time they worked on Girardi cases as a result of their connections to Girardi. These employees’ conflicts tainted the discretionary decisions they made on behalf of the State Bar and, therefore, the Girardi cases they worked on were improperly handled.
- The report concludes the State Bar had a historical lack of robust conflicts of interest policies and found numerous instances of Form 700s not being filed for employees and/or Board members. When ones were filed they were incomplete, unsigned, or indicated no gifts were accepted when evidence clearly shows otherwise.
- The Executive Director’s Office and the Office of General Counsel received multiple reports of Girardi’s inappropriate connections at the State Bar that were not investigated.
- Two senior attorneys in OCTC were terminated by the then Executive Director during the same time period when those attorneys were advocating for serious charges to be brought against Girardi in pending State Bar cases.
- The then Acting Executive Director had been ghostwriting case analysis memorandums for conflict cases, which were supposed to be referred out to independent counsel under State Bar Rule 2201, and passing them off as the work product of the independent conflict counsel, including on a Girardi case.
In light of the revelations in these two reports, this Committee and the Assembly Judiciary Committee will be holding a joint oversight hearing into the State Bar. Real evidence that the State Bar has addressed the numerous systemic failures outlined in these two reports must be demonstrated before a fee amount will be amended into this bill.
In 2019, based largely on recommendations from the California State Auditor and the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the 2020 annual license fee was increased to $438 for active licensees and $108 for inactive licensees. The 2022 annual license fee was the same as the license fee for 2021. (SB 211 (Umberg, Chapter 723, Statutes of 2021.) The 2023 annual license fees were the same as 2022, except it provided that the active license fee is to be reduced by $4 and the inactive licensee fee by $1 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
The State Bar is planning to sell the building it owns and operates out of in San Francisco up for sale sometime this year. Various estimates of revenue from that sale have been predicted; however, the estimates fluctuate broadly due to numerous factors, such as if the State Bar purchases or leases another building and the conditions in the local commercial real estate market. When the license fee was increased in 2020, it provided for a $4 increase to be used by the State Bar for capital improvements needed at its San Francisco building. If the building is sold, obviously the State Bar will no longer need these funds for capital improvements.
The State Bar has stated it is faced with a structural operating deficit in both the General and Admissions Funds and shrinking reserves. They point to the fact that the licensing fee has only been increased once in the last 25 years. The State Bar assumes that they will close on the sale of the building they own and operate out of San Francisco. They indicate that if the building does not sell this year, they may not be able to sustain their regular operations in 2024.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/4/23)
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/4/23)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
The State Bar’s most basic function is to protect California consumers. It is mind boggling that the State Bar as a whole not only utterly failed this task, but also conspired to conceal obvious misconduct on the part of at least one specific lawyer—Tom Girardi. The revelations in the May report show that Tom Girardi’s financial web and sphere of influence reached so far within the State Bar, that he was essentially bankrolling an employee in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel and the Executive Director’s Office and said employee’s family to the tune of close to $1 million while he was being investigated by the same organization. Every subsequent report about Tom Girardi and the State Bar’s activities over the last two decades seems to be more alarming than the next.
This Committee and the Assembly Committee on Judiciary will be holding an oversight hearing of the State Bar this year to get answers to the troubling questions raised by the May and Lazar reports, and ensure nothing like this can happen again. I will withhold making any decision on what amount, if any, the State Bar’s 2024 annual license fees should be. It took the withholding of funds in 2021 in my SB 211 to get the State Bar to finally appoint a Chief Trial Counsel that the California Senate felt comfortable confirming, after nearly five
years of that key position being vacant. If this crucial position had not been left
vacant for so long, this malfeasance may have been uncovered sooner.
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/5/23 13:17:49
**** END ****
Lazar report (released Mar. 10, 223), available at https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/reports/Lazar-Report-and-Attachment-Redacted.pdf. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 40 (Author:Umberg)
Version: March 21, 2023
Hearing Date: May 2, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
State Bar: annual license fees
DIGEST
This bill authorizes the State Bar of California (State Bar) to collect an unspecified amount of annual license fees for active licensees for 2024.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The State Bar of California (State Bar) is a public corporation and the largest state bar in the country. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9.) This bill is the annual State Bar licensing fee bill. The State Bar has been embroiled in scandal over its handling, or lack thereof, of investigation and discipline of once prominent trial attorney Thomas Girardi (hereafter Girardi). This year the State Bar released redacted versions of the two audits or investigations they commissioned. The first was an audit of all closed disciplinary cases pertaining to complaints filed with the State Bar against Girardi (hereafter Lazar audit). The second was an independent investigation into whether the State Bar’s handling of past discipline and complaints against Girardi was affected by his connections and influence at the State Bar (hereafter May report). The revelations disclosed in these reports were astounding and raise very troubling questions about the ability of the State Bar to perform its core mission of protection of the public through disciplining attorneys licensed in this state.
The bill is author sponsored. There is no known support or opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- The Legislature sets the annual fees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140, 6141.)
- The State Bar is governed by the Board of Trustees of the State Bar (Board). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6010 et seq.; § 6016.)
- Establishes that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public is to be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect the following fees from active licensees for the year 2023:
- $39 annual license fee, except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum is not to exceed $386. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.)
- $40 fee for the Client Security Fund. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.55.)
- $25 fee for the costs of the disciplinary system. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.6.)
- $10 fee for the attorney diversion and assistance program. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect the following fees from inactive licensees for the year 2023:
- $97.40 annual license fee, except that if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022, the sum is not exceed $96.40. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6141(a).)
- $10 fee for the Client Security Fund. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.55)
- $25 fee for the costs of the disciplinary system. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.6.)
- $5 fee for the attorney diversion and assistance program. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.9.)
- An inactive licensee who is 70 years old or older is not required to pay an annual license fee. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6141(b).)
- Requires the State Bar to charge a $45 fee in addition to the annual license fee for active and inactive licensees for the purposes of funding legal services for persons of limited means, as provided, unless a licensee elects not to support those activities in which case the licensee can deduct the amount from the annual license fee. Requires $5 of the $45 fee to be allocated to qualified legal services projects or qualified support centers, as defined, to hire law school graduates with a temporary provisional license issued by the State Bar, as provided. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.03.)
- Requires the State Bar to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bar’s operations every two years. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6145 (b).)
- Provides that the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC, with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar; the acts or practices of a person whom the CTC has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of the State Bar Act; and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6044.)
- Provides that it shall be the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss a complaint, admonish the attorney, or forward a completed investigation to the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) within six months after receipt of a written complaint. As to complaints designated as complicated matters by the chief trial counsel, it shall be the goal and policy of the State Bar to dismiss, terminate by admonition, or forward those complaints to the OCTC within 12 months. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6094.5(a).)
This bill:
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect an unspecified amount for the annual license fee for active licensees in 2024.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
The State Bar’s most basic function is to protect California consumers. It is mind boggling that the State Bar as a whole not only utterly failed this task, but also conspired to conceal obvious misconduct on the part of at least one specific lawyer—Tom Girardi. The revelations in the May report show that Tom Girardi’s financial web and sphere of influence reached so far within the State Bar, that he was essentially bankrolling an employee in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel and the Executive Director’s Office and said employee’s family to the tune of close to $1 million while he was being investigated by the same organization. Every subsequent report about Tom Girardi and the State Bar’s activities over the last two decades seems to be more alarming than the next.
This Committee and the Assembly Committee on Judiciary will be holding an oversight hearing of the State Bar this year to get answers to the troubling questions raised by the May and Lazar reports, and ensure nothing like this can happen again. I will withhold making any decision on what amount, if any, the State Bar’s 2024 annual license fees should be. It took the withholding of funds in 2021 in my SB 211 to get the State Bar to finally appoint a Chief Trial Counsel that the California Senate felt comfortable confirming, after nearly five years of that key position being vacant. If this crucial position had not been left vacant for so long, this malfeasance may have been uncovered sooner.
- State Bar of California functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline
As a constitutional matter, the judicial power of California is vested in the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal, and superior courts. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 1.) (In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, 592; Obrien v. Jones (2000) 23 Cal.4th 40, 48.) In addressing this inherent authority to regulate the practice of law, the Supreme Court has explained: “’The important difference between regulation of the legal profession and regulation of other professions is this: Admission to the bar is a judicial function, and members of the bar are officers of the court, subject to discipline by the court. Hence, under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, the court has inherent and primary regulatory power.’” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 593.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.)
Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Bar of California is a public corporation. Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) The State Bar’s regulatory assistance is an integral part of the judicial function. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) Emphasizing the sui generis nature of the State Bar as its administrative arm, the Supreme Court has made clear that “express legislative recognition of reserved judicial power over admission and discipline is critical to the constitutionality of the State Bar Act.” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 600, citing Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6087.)
At the same time, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of license fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1) and subjecting the CTC of the State Bar to Senate confirmation (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6079.5).
The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country. As of April 22, 2023, the total State Bar membership is 288,238, which includes 195,155 active licensees, 2,221 judge members, 16,976 licensees who are “Not Eligible to Practice Law,” and approximately 73,886 inactive members.[1] The State Bar’s programs are financed mostly by annual license fees paid by attorneys as well as other fees paid by applicants seeking to practice law. The State Bar is governed by a Board of Trustees (Board). Pursuant to SB 36 (Jackson, Ch. 422, Stats. 2017), the Board was required to transition to a 13 member board comprised of Governor, Supreme Court, Assembly, and Senate appointees.
- Audit reports show systemic failure, over decades, of State Bar to fulfill its role as watchdog of the legal profession
The State Bar’s highest priority is the protection of the public, which includes quickly finding and disciplining dishonest or incompetent attorneys. As the May and Lazar reports show, the State Bar has utterly failed at fulfilling its mission. In 2021, Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. As the Lazar report demonstrates, serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against him were reported to the State Bar over decades, but the State Bar did not take action against him until 2021 when he was disbarred by the California Supreme Court after a disciplinary hearing by the State Bar.[2] This only occurred after a federal court found that he had misappropriated $2 million that was awarded to victims’ families in the Lion Air flight 610 plane crash of 2018, and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. This incident triggered numerous further accusations against Girardi for stealing client funds and the true scope of his malfeasance finally began to materialize. Eventually, Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, were forced into bankruptcy. This year Girardi was indicted by federal grand juries in Los Angeles and Chicago on charges that he embezzled more than $18 million from his clients.
The State Bar refused to release information about complaints, closed cases, or investigations it had conducted on Girardi citing to confidentiality provisions in Section 6086.1 of the Business and Professions Code. The L.A. Times sued the State Bar and eventually the State Bar agreed to release roughly 40 years of disciplinary records that showed Girardi had over 200 complaints filed against him since 1983, many of which alleged misappropriation of client finds. In the wake of this, the State Bar initiated the Lazar and May reports.
- May report[3]
The State Bar hired the law firm of Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to examine how the State Bar handled complaints filed against disbarred attorney Girardi, and whether that process was affected by Girardi’s connections, to or influence, at the State Bar. During the 16-month investigation, Aaron May and his team reviewed over 950,000 documents, issued 23 subpoenas, and interviewed, either voluntarily or under compulsion, 74 witnesses. The May report is lengthy and includes numerous revelations that show that Girardi maintained an extensive network of connections at all levels of the State Bar. The report stated:
Our investigation determined that Girardi cultivated contacts on the Board, in the Executive Director’s Office, and in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (“OCTC”), both at the managerial and line prosecutor and investigator level. Girardi’s ties to the State Bar spanned decades and appear to have been intentional. We found evidence indicating that Girardi was involved in the appointment of at least one State Bar Court judge and the attempted appointment of a Chief Trial Counsel (“CTC”). And we also found evidence that Girardi made offers of career assistance to people in State Bar leadership, apparently seeking to make additional connections when and where he could. We have evidence—both documentary and testimonial—showing that at least nine former State Bar employees or Board members had connections to or accepted items of value, travel, or meals from Girardi while they were working at the State Bar or State Bar Court or were on the Board, although not all of these individuals were involved in the handling of cases against Girardi. We did not find any connections between Girardi and any current State Bar employees, jurists, or Board members. (at p. 3.)
Highlights of findings from the May report include:
- That two former OCTC employees had conflicts-of-interest at the time they worked on Girardi cases as a result of their connections to Girardi. These employees’ conflicts tainted the discretionary decisions they made on behalf of the State Bar and, therefore, the Girardi cases they worked on were improperly handled.
- The report concludes the State Bar had a historical lack of robust conflicts of interest policies and found numerous instances of Form 700s not being filed for employees and/or Board members. When ones were filed they were incomplete, unsigned, or indicated no gifts were accepted when evidence clearly shows otherwise.
- The Executive Director’s Office and the Office of General Counsel received multiple reports of Girardi’s inappropriate connections at the State Bar that were not investigated.
- Two senior attorneys in OCTC were terminated by the then Executive Director during the same time period when those attorneys were advocating for serious charges to be brought against Girardi in pending State Bar cases.
- The then Acting Executive Director had been ghostwriting case analysis memorandums for conflict cases, which were supposed to be referred out to independent counsel under State Bar Rule 2201, and passing them off as the work product of the independent conflict counsel, including on a Girardi case.
The most egregious example of an inappropriate relationship between a staff person of the State Bar and Girardi uncovered by the May report was in regards to former State Bar employee Tom Layton. Layton worked in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) from 1999 to 2013, but was moved into the Executive Director’s office in 2013. The May report did not find any evidence that Thomas Layton worked on any of Girardi cases. But the report did find the following:
- That Layton and his wife Rose received almost $1,000,000 in gifts or items of value from Girardi.
- Girardi employed two of Layton’s children at his firm while Layton worked at the State Bar.
- Girardi Keese paid $600,000 to Layton and his wife while Layton worked at the State Bar. Some payments were made out directly to Layton and others directly to his wife, while others were to a business entity owned jointly by the Laytons. .
- In 2011, Girardi provided Layton with a Girardi Keese American Express credit card, which Layton admitted to using for personal expenses. The report estimates Layton charged $315,114 to this card between December of 2013 and December of 2020.
- Girardi paid for leased cars for Layton while he was employed by the State Bar, beginning likely in 2011.
- Girardi guaranteed a bank loan of $150,000 to Layton through his law firm and made payments on the loan.
- Layton ate with Girardi on numerous occasions and Girardi paid for the meals.
- Layton flew on Girardi’s private jet for personal travel. In 2011 when Layton was in OCTC. Girardi paid for four rooms for Layton at the Orleans hotel in Las Vegas. Layton admitted Girardi paid for other trips for him as well.
- Layton accepted tickets for box seats at the Staples Center for various concerts and events.
- Layton asked Girardi to pay for his participation in charity events – such as gold tournaments and dinners.
- Girardi represented Layton in four separate legal matters while he worked at the State Bar.
- It was reported that Layton repeatedly introduced State Bar employees to Girardi
- Lazar report
The Lazar report concluded that there were 130 complaints filed against Girardi with the State Bar from 1982 to January 2021, and 115 of them were reviewed in the audit as 15 older files could not be located in off-site storage. The auditor found no documentation in any files to support a finding of improper influence by Girardi on either State Bar employees or outside examiners in the resolution of these cases. The complaints reviewed involved a myriad of alleged violations: 44 raised possible client trust account issues in violation of Rule of Professional Conduct (RPC) 1.15; 38 alleged failures to competently or diligently perform legal services (RPC 1.1; 1.3), to communicate with the client (RPC 1.4), and/or to take appropriate actions when withdrawing from employment (RPC 1.16). The remainder of the complaints were regarding other ethics violations including dishonesty (RPC 8.4), failing to comply with conflicts rules (RPC 1.7, 1.8.1), violating reporting requirements of Business and Professions Code §6068(o), and interfering with other attorneys’ representation of their clients (RPC 3.10; 4.2). The auditor did find numerous errors in the handling of some of these files both by the OCTC staff and by some referred out to independent counsel under State Bar Rule 2201. The auditor concluded that many of these errors appear to be the result of strict compliance with office practices which, in this case, required flexibility in order to properly address patterns of misconduct.
- Future oversight hearing
In light of the revelations in these two reports, this Committee and the Assembly Judiciary Committee will be holding a joint oversight hearing into the State Bar. Real evidence that the State Bar has addressed the numerous systemic failures outlined in these two reports must be demonstrated before a fee amount will be amended into this bill.
- Attorney licensee fees
In 2019, based largely on recommendations from the California State Auditor and the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the 2020 annual license fee was increased to $438 for active licensees and $108 for inactive licensees. This fee increase consisted of a $71 increase on an ongoing basis and a onetime fee increase of $52 for active licensees, and a $20 increase on an ongoing basis and a onetime fee increase of $13 for inactive licensees. The 2021 annual license fee was decreased to $395 for active licensees and $97.40 for inactive licensees through AB 3362 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 360, Stats. 2020). The decrease included the cessation of several of the onetime fee increases imposed in 2020. When all fees were added together, excluding the optional legal services fee, the total license fee for 2021 was $470 for active licensees and $137.40 for inactive licensees.[4] The 2022 annual license fee was the same as the license fee for 2021. (SB 211 (Umberg, Ch. 723, Stats. 2021.) The 2023 annual license fees were the same as 2022, except it provided that the active license fee is to be reduced by $4 and the inactive licensee fee by $1 if the State Bar has entered into a contract to sell its San Francisco office building by October 31, 2022.
The State Bar is planning to sell the building it owns and operates out of in San Francisco up for sale sometime this year. Various estimates of revenue from that sale have been predicted; however, the estimates fluctuate broadly due to numerous factors, such as if the State Bar purchases or leases another building and the conditions in the local commercial real estate market. When the license fee was increased in 2020, it provided for a $4 increase to be used by the State Bar for capital improvements needed at its San Francisco building. If the building is sold, obviously the State Bar will no longer need these funds for capital improvements.
- State Bar requests a licensing fee increase
The State Bar has requested a licensing fee increase stating it is faced with a structural operating deficit in both the General and Admissions Funds and shrinking reserves. They point to the fact that the licensing fee has only been increased once in the last 25 years. The State Bar assumes that they will close on the sale of the building they own and operate out of San Francisco. They indicate that if the building does not sell this year, they may not be able to sustain their regular operations in 2024.
- Other issues to address
As the bill continues to move through the legislative process, the author intends to address other issues related to the State Bar’s disciplinary process, including, among others, its disparate impact on licensees of color, providing a mechanism for licensees to have records of discipline related to substance abuse issues removed from public view after the completion of an assistance and diversion program and demonstration of no further violations, and reviewing proposed processing case standards submitted by the State Bar and reviewed by the Legislative Analyst’s Office. The author also intends to address the confidentiality statutes related to the handling and release of confidential information regarding investigations by the State Bar.
SUPPORT
None known
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: SB 42 (Umberg, 2023) requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar, except as specified. SB 42 is set to be heard by this Committee on the same day as this bill.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2958 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 419, Stats. 2022) authorized the State Bar to collect annual licensing fees of $395 for active licensees and $97.40 for inactive licensees and enacted other reforms.
SB 211 (Umberg, 2021, Ch. 723, Stats. 2021) authorized the State Bar to collect annual licensing fees of $395 for active licensees and $97.40 for inactive licensees and enacted other reforms. The bill required the Auditor’s Office to conduct an independent audit to determine if the discipline process adequately protects the public from misconduct by licensed attorneys or those who wrongfully hold themselves out as licensed attorneys.
AB 3362 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 360, Stats. 2020) authorized the State Bar to collect annual licensing fees of $395 for active licensees and $97.40 for inactive licensees and enacted other reforms.
SB 176 (Jackson, Ch. 698, Stats. 2019) authorized the State Bar to collet annual licensing fees of $438 for 2020 and enacted other reforms.
AB 3249 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 659, Stats. 2018) authorized the State Bar to collect annual licensing fees of $390 for 2019 and enacted other reforms, including a strengthening of the attorney discipline system.
SB 36 (Jackson, 2017, Ch. 422, Stats. 2017) authorized the State Bar to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for the year 2018; reformed the State Bar Act by separating the sections from the State Bar and creating what is now the California Lawyers Association; changed the composition of the State Bar Board; and enacted various reforms to remove politics from the Board.
AB 2878 (Committee on Judiciary, 2016) would have authorized bar dues for 2017 and enacted numerous reforms. The bill died on concurrence on the Assembly Floor.
SB 387 (Jackson, Ch. 537, Stats. 2015) authorized the State to collect active licensee fees of up to $390 for the year 2016; required the State Bar to develop and implement a specified workforce plan for its discipline system; required the State Bar to conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for the annual membership fee, as specified; required the State Bar to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct an in-depth financial audit of the State Bar; and made the State Bar subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified.
**************
Attorney Status, State Bar of Cal. (current as of April 22, 2023), available at https://members.calbar.ca.gov/search/demographics.aspx. ↑
Lazar report (released Mar. 10, 223), available at https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/reports/Lazar-Report-and-Attachment-Redacted.pdf. ↑
May report (released Mar. 10, 2023), available at file:///C:/Users/mattsoam/Desktop/2023/State%20Bar%202023/May-Report-and-Addendum-Redacted.pdf. ↑
This amount includes the fee for the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program of $10 for active licensees and $5 for inactive licensees, which last year was only $1 and $0, respectively. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140.9(a).). ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):