Hearings

Assembly Floor

May 19, 2025
  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Assembly is now in session. Assemblymember Sanchez notices the absence of a quorum. Sergeant in arms will prepare the chamber and bring in the absent Members. Clerk will call the roll.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    [Roll Call]

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Members, the quorum is present. We ask our guests and visitors in the rear of the chamber and in the gallery to please stand for the daily prayer. Today's prayer will be offered by Reverend Oshita. Reverend Oshita.

  • Reverend Bob Oshita

    Person

    Please join me in a moment of reflection. I had a dear friend in Winters, California, Mrs. Helen Hiramatsu. Over our 30 years of friendship, I had officiated her daughter's wedding, her son's memorial, and her husband's funeral. She was extended family. Helen once told me that she kept and reread my monthly newsletter.

  • Reverend Bob Oshita

    Person

    After that, I wrote every month with Helen in mind. I visited her while her husband Roy, struggled with dementia and was pleased that I remained in his fading memory. They had endured, overcome ,and accomplished so much together. When Helen was battling cancer, we would visit.

  • Reverend Bob Oshita

    Person

    I tried to be what she was to me, an encouraging, positive friend. And when her life was being measured in days instead of years. I still recall our last visit. She was too weak to turn her head, but she smiled when she saw me.

  • Reverend Bob Oshita

    Person

    Hoping to bring warm memories to mind, I asked her, Helen, when was the best time of your life? She looked at me with her bright smile and said softly, every moment of my life, even this moment now. Then she added, I wouldn't change a thing. I share this today to join Helen's life to all of ours.

  • Reverend Bob Oshita

    Person

    Her words, her spirit, and her smile have never left me. How amazing it would be to live so that we may feel like Helen with our last breath. To feel every moment has been the best time and I wouldn't change a thing. With kindness and gratitude beyond words.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We ask our guests and visitors to remain standing and to join us in the flag salute. Assembly Member Mark Gonzalez will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    Members and guests, please rise if you are able and join me in the flag salute. I pledge allegiance to the flag.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    You may be seated. To our guests and visitors today, state law prohibits persons in the gallery from interfering with legislative proceedings or disrupting the orderly conduct of official business. Persons disrupting legislative proceedings are subject to removal, arrest, or other appropriate legal remedies. Reading of the previous day's journal.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly chamber Sacramento, Wednesday, May 14, 2025. The assembly met at 7:00am. The Honorable Juan Alanis, Assembly Member, 22nd District presiding, Chief Clerk.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assistant Majority Leader Garcia moves, and Mr. Lackey seconds that the reading of the previous day's journal be dispensed with. Presentations and petitions, there are none. Introduction and reference of bills will be deferred. Reports of committees will be deemed read and amendments deemed adopted. Messages from the governor? There are none. Messages from the senate? There are none. We're moving on to motions and resolutions.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The absences for the day. For legislative business, Assembly Members Dixon and Jeff Gonzalez. For personal business, Assembly Member Papan. For illness, Assembly Member Flora. Mr. Assistant Majority Leader, you are recognized for your procedural motions.

  • Robert Garcia

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I request unanimous consent to suspend Assembly Rule 118A to allow Assembly Members Lee, Bryan and Ransom to have guests in the rear of the chamber today.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Without objection, such shall be the order. Okay. We are. Okay. Assembly Member Elhawary, you are recognized for your guest introductions.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker and members. I am so excited to introduce my guests who are here from Jack and Jill, the far west region, all throughout California, including my district. They are teenagers who are doing amazing work to learn about leadership and advocacy.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    And we want to give it up for our amazing young people who are our future leaders. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Welcome to the California Assembly. Assembly Member Tangipa, you are recognized for your guest introductions.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    All right. Today I rise to proudly recognize two incredible football programs from Tuolumne County, Sonora High School and Summerville High School for their outstanding championship seasons. You guys want to get up?

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    The Sonora Wildcats captured the 2014 CIF Division 4A state championship, finishing with a 13-2 record and earning their first title in program history under the leadership of coach Kirk Clifton. Meanwhile, the Summerville Bears claimed the Division 6A state championship, defeating Monte Vista High School, 38 to 21, capping off a phenomenal season.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Guided by coach, Sean Leveroos. These teams embody the grit, discipline, and spirit of our rural communities. And I am thrilled to welcome them to the Capitol as champions both on and off the field. As somebody who holds football close to its heart, it's truly a pleasure to honor these remarkable students.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Their hard work, determination, and sportsmanship represents the best of our community. Please join me in congratulating Sonora and Summerville High Schools on their historic achievement. And just for context, Tuolumne County is the only other county that has two state football championships.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    The other one is Orange County, and they did it with a population of less than 60,000 from that. So they, thank you boys for representing. To the boys of fall.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Let's go, champions. Let's go. Welcome. Thank you for joining us today. Okay. We have further announcements, we're going to be coming back to. For now, we are going to be moving on to business on the Daily File. There is no second reading today. We're moving on to the third, assembly third reading. We're going to pass, retain on file item number one.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Go to file item number two. Assembly Bill 578 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 578 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan and accolades of business practices.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, you are recognized.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and members. I'm proud to present AB 578. This is a measure that protects consumers from unfair refund and customer services, practices by food delivery platforms. This was born out of my own experience and my daughter's Bat Mitzvah. We ordered 10 pizzas and lo and behold, we got one.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    Not only did I have a room full of hungry teenagers, which no parent wants, but I only had one of the pizzas I delivered. When I went to get my money back, the platform said I could not have my money back, that they would only give me a credit and it was a lot of money.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    And so I realized that everyday Californians that are living paycheck to paycheck, if they don't get the goods that they ordered, they should get a refund. That's what this bill does. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 47. No's, 2. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Members, would you help me, join me in a warm welcome for a retired Assembly Member. Cheryl Brown is on the floor here. Members, we're going to pass and retain on file items 3 through file item 8. Which brings us to file item 9. AB 344 by Assembly Member Valencia. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 344 by Assembly Member Valencia, an act relating to alcoholic beverages.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Valencia, you are recognized.

  • Avelino Valencia

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker. Muy buenas tardes, Members. AB 344 updates and clarifies the definition of successor beer manufacturer to reflect present day businesses and entities regardless of their license status or whether the entity has brewed beer. This update will uphold fair and competitive business practices. With that, I respectfully ask for a yes vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Valencia. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Ayes, 61. No's 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Members, before we continue business on the daily file, we are going to go back to guest Introductions. And I'm going to recognize Assembly Member Ransom for her special guest introductions.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    All right. Good morning. Thank you, Speaker and members. Members, today you may have noticed quite a bit of color in the Capitol. Those are the ladies donning pink and green.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Today, the halls of the Capitol, the LOB and the Swing Space will be filled with members of the incredible black institutions that made me the woman that I am today. For those of you who are not aware, I am a proud Member of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Incorporated.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    And while, that's right, and while Deltas are not here today, myself and Senator Akilah Weber do represent them here in the Capitol. And we are proud to recognize another Divine Nine organization. Alpha Kappa Alpha Far West Regional Director is here with us today. That is Ms. Nicole Jordan here in the back.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    The AKAs have a day of capital, and day at the Capitol today. Their cochairs are Ms. LaNiece Jones, Ms. Patrice Marshall Mckenzie, and NAACP Board Member Ms. LaJuana Bivens from Assembly District 13 that I represent. Along with these amazing women, please also join me in recognizing Black Women Organized for Political Action President, Mother, Dezie Woods-Jones

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    The National Coalition of 100 Black Women, Oakland Bay Area President, Ms. Shari Wooldridge, founder of the California Black Women's Collective, Ms. Kellie Todd Griffin, California Black Media Executive Director, Ms. Regina Wilson. These individuals and the many members with them today are representative of what black collective action looks like.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    This is the AKA's 26th annual day at the Capitol. And as they meet with your offices, please make sure that you give them the respect and the attention that they deserve.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    As the first black brief letter organization founded by African American College Educated Women, AKA Sorority Incorporated has led with distinction since 1908, championing scholarship, civic engagement, and service to the underserved. Your enduring commitment to advancing equity and justice continues to uplift communities across California and beyond.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    This year, their theme, My Voice, Our Power, AKA Women Leading Legislative Change, is timely and inspiring and reminds us that our collective voices are vital. At the California Legislative Black Caucus, our 2025 legislative priorities are rooted in the same spirit.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    From protecting and advancing voting rights to championing reparative justice, public safety reform, and equity based policies, our caucus is steadfast in our mission to create a California where every voice is heard, valued and empowered. We look forward to our continued partnership with Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority Incorporated as we push for meaningful change together.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Please know that these offices remain in support of your efforts and to uplift your leadership and calibrate and collaborate in collective good. Members on behalf of the California Legislative Black Caucus, please join me in welcoming these amazing guests to our State Capitol.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Welcome AKA. Welcome, welcome. Thank you for your activism.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, members. Can you please take your desks? Thank you, members. I know it's a busy time, members, but we should show grace to the authors who have worked so hard while they're presenting their bills.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 454 by Assembly Member Kalra and others inaccurate to migratory birds and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're continuing on the business of the Daily File item number 10 AB454 by Assemblymember Kalra. The clerk will read.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Kalra, you are recognized.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and members. AB454 will remove the California Migratory Bird Protection Act sunset date, making it permanent. For over a century, the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act, or MBTA, had have allowed the federal government to act against the unauthorized take of more than a thousand native bird species.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    However, in 2017, the federal government issued a legal opinion that set the stage for significant rollbacks of the MBTA. Specifically, the opinion indicated that the MBTA should no longer apply to incidental take, that is, the killing, capturing, transporting, trading, or selling of birds that results from activities that are not explicitly meant to take birds.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    These activities are often perpetuated by industrial entities that harm birds and their nests when they build and utilize their facilities.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    In response to this policy shift, California enacted the California Migratory Bird Protection Act, which codified at the state level the version of MBTA that was in place on January 1st, 2017, and had been in place for over a century.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Unfortunately, the California Migratory Bird Protection Act expired in January, leaving our migratory birds susceptible to the effects of renewed MBTA rollbacks, including the recent reinstitution of the 2017 legal opinion invalidating the MBTA's jurisdiction over incidental take.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    AB454 addresses this issue by removing the sunset date from the California Migratory Bird Protection Act, ensuring that our state's migratory birds will always enjoy comprehensive protection against all forms of unauthorized take. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Kalra. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Members, there is an urgency clause on this bill; it requires 54 votes. Absent members, please return to the floor and vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Ayes, 55, Noes, 12 measure passes. Moving on to file item number 11. AB 482 by Assemblymember Solache. The Clerk will read

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Assembly Bill 482. By Assemblymember Salache and acclaim to food and agriculture and making it appropriation.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Therefore, Assemblymember Solache, you are recognized.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present AB482. This bill will update and modernize the provisions of the California Table Grape Commission. The commission was created by the legislature in 1967 and has only been amended once since then, in 1982. That is over four decades ago.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    The commission plays a prominent role in helping the California table grape industry market grapes around the world. And these modernizations will be more consistent with current practices. The industry is mostly located in the around disadvantaged communities, San Joaquin and Coachella Valleys. A strong table industry allows for jobs and economic development in these areas.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Thank you, speaker and members. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on AB482.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    [Roll Call]

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file items 12, 13, 14, 15, 16. That brings us to file item number 17, Assembly Joint Resolution three by Assemblymember Schiavo. Members near Ms. Schiavo, can you please show some grace? The clerk will read.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The clerk will read, the clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Joint Resolution three by Assemblymember Schiavo and others relative to public social services.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Schiavo, you are recognized.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present AJR3, a resolution to send a strong message to Congressional Leadership Council, California's Congressional Delegation, the President, and the President that Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are foundational to our communities and their proposed cuts to these programs will create irreparable harm to seniors, children, the disabled and families.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Social Security is our nation's most important source of retirement, income, disability, and life insurance. For over six million Californians, including veterans, the program provides monthly support and health insurance. Seniors are the fastest growing population forced into homelessness, and Social Security is the only safety net some older adults have. Like my grandmother.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    It's unconscionable to threaten eliminating a system that they have contributed to their whole lives. We must remember the Social Security system is one where those receiving benefits paid into the system their entire working life on the promise that when the time comes, they should receive benefits that they are entitled to.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Eliminating these benefits is now going back on a promise made to those hard-working people, many who rely on this for their income later in life. And like Social Security, Medicare is also a critical lifeline for seniors and people living with disabilities.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    The health care provided under Medicare makes sure the population with the highest health costs are provided care at a fraction of the cost of private insurance healthcare plans. Current federal proposals could change how care is delivered under Medicare, resulting in the reduction of care and an increase in costs.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And this is another program that people have paid into their entire lives, depending on it being there when they hit 65. And finally, AJR calls for the representatives to protect Medicaid or Medi-Cal in California.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    For nearly 15 million Californians, including children and families, Medi-Cal is their only source of health care, providing primary care services, dental, vision, mental health care, substance use disorder services, and long-term care. Medi-Cal is already caring for working people in our state. With one in five California workers enrolled.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Congress is currently proposing a 715 billion dollar cut to Medicaid and health care coverage, creating barriers to health care and exacerbating already existing inequities. These deep cuts to Medicaid will hurt everyone, whether they rely on Medi-Cal or not.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Because these cuts will result in hospitals closed, clinics closed, increasing health care costs, and reducing access to health care for every single person in California. For example, Ridgecrest Regional Hospital serves a remote community surrounding the Naval Air Weapons Station at China Lake.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And as the chair of Military and Veteran Affairs, I have met with them directly and their concerns about this hospital's ability to stay open. About a third of the hospital's patients rely on Medi-Cal.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And any of the cuts to Medicaid would not only limit the residents' crucial health care, but it would compromise the hospital's ability to have a fully functioning hospital. And the next nearest hospital is nearly 80 miles away. The residents who rely on Ridgecrest Regional Hospital include thousands of civilian scientists and engineers who work at China Lake.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Their ability to live and work in this isolated high desert region is critical to national defense, and as Ridgecrest Regional Hospital's ability to support that mission. So join me in urging the federal administration to reconsider these cuts and not only threaten lives, but our national security.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    For so many, these three programs are the difference between life and death. It is more important than ever that we defend Social Security. We defend these programs that are creating a lifeline for people in our community, and that any cuts or disruptions to their programs because they will simply devastate the lives of seniors, children, and families.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    I ask for the first roll call to be open to coauthors and respectfully request an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Schiavo. Assemblymember Tangipa, you are recognized.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Colleagues, I rise and I actually join my colleague in a lot of the concerns that she stated. But if we're truly concerned about Medi-Cal, we forgot who to actually address this to. We really need to start by writing this letter to Governor Newsom because he is actively sabotaging Californians' benefits.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Californians overwhelmingly supported Prop 35 because they understood the stakes. They knew that increasing medical reimbursement rates meant better access to doctors, hospital, and care when they or their families needed it most. But in the May revise, Governor Newsom is raiding the money voters approved for those reimbursement rate increases.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Instead of honoring the will of the people, he's using it to backfill reckless spending. And we've got to talk about that in this letter. And it only gets worse. He's proposing cutting Medi-Cal dental reimbursement rates by 43%. The governor is doing that, which means dentists are getting paid less than minimum wage for essential cleaning.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    What do you think that means for access? All this while leaving federal dollars on the table because of poor planning and failure to hold DHCS accountable. California hasn't even submitted the paperwork needed to draw down on all the available federal funds.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    So we're facing a double hit, bait and switch funding that breaks faith with California voters and a failure to claim millions in federal money that could help keep our hospitals open. Yes, we must keep advocating with our federal partners, but that advocacy means nothing if California doesn't follow through on its end.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    It's time we address this letter to the governor to stop sabotaging Medi-Cal funding.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Tangipa. Assemblymember Macedo, you are recognized.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise with the same concerns of my colleague from Clovis.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    Governor Newsom's administration missed a key March 31st deadline to submit a proposal to the federal government, forfeiting millions, if not billions, in federal matching dollars for Medi-Cal. This failure undermines Prop 35, which was passed by 68% of voters and promised increased reimbursement rates for doctors and hospitals serving Medi-Cal patients.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    Without this funding, doctors and hospitals may not receive the rate increases they were promised, jeopardizing care for patients across California, especially in rural and underserved areas like mine. Insurance does not mean access. The Central Valley already faces severe health care access issues.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    Low reimbursement rates make it nearly impossible for providers to stay open or serve patients in these areas. While some here in Sacramento are focused on Washington, Governor Newsom has already failed to secure money that was available and ready to support Californians.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    We should hold the governor accountable and ask for his plan to uphold the will of the voters. The state cannot afford another missed opportunity as we face a 12 billion dollar deficit. I wrote a letter on April 21st to the governor asking for this plan, and he has yet to respond.

  • Alexandra Macedo

    Legislator

    So why would the president respond to us if our own governor won't?

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Macedo. Assemblymember Bains, you are recognized.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    Thank you, speaker and members. Look, Democrats don't control the White House, the US Senate, or the House of Representatives. This resolution shows us why we cannot continue to be the party that alienates regular people. What's happening in Washington right now should make the blood boil in the veins of every decent person in this country.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    A group of billionaires have the audacity to tell us that cutting health care for poor people, denying basic medical care to those who can least afford it, will make our country better off. They're proposing to slash billions of dollars for Medicaid, a program that exclusively serves vulnerable people living in poverty, including children, seniors, and people with disabilities.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    The result will be 14 million people losing their health care insurance, local hospitals and clinics forced to close their doors, and Americans in every state, regardless of their income level or immigration status, left with less access to care. Is the key to our prosperity really denying a single mother working two jobs access to a doctor?

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    No, it doesn't stop there. Because why stop at denying poor people health care when you can also deny access to food? One in five children rely on federal food assistance, yet the GOP believes we are better off if fewer hungry children get to eat lunch and if working-class families cannot afford groceries.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    Who the hell thinks of this? If you think that this is about fiscal responsibility, think again. Because this plan increases the national deficit by trillions of dollars. How can that be? How can this plan include so many spending cuts but increase the deficit? Follow the money and look at who comes out ahead. These are not spending cuts.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    They are spending redirections. Instead of feeding hungry children and letting poor people get to see a doctor, we're giving Elon Musk and his billionaire buddies a tax cut. Billionaires are cutting taxes for billionaires by billions of dollars. That's not a talking point. That's really what they are doing.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    And that's why the next vote on these cuts has just been scheduled for one o'clock in the morning on Wednesday. Because let's face it, only good decisions get made at one o'clock in the morning. Look, too many Americans are struggling. Too many parents don't see a brighter future for their kids.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    Too many seniors cannot afford their medications. Too many full-time workers can't pay their rent and the electric bill in the same week. But we need to be clear that turning our backs on our most vulnerable is not the solution. Feeding fewer hungry children does not bring the cost of eggs down.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    Cutting health care from poor people hurts all of us when our local hospital is forced to lay off staff, reduce services, or close down entirely. As Democrats, I know we care about working at middle class people, but they don't trust us. They think we're too busy fighting the culture war to fight for them.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    30 seconds.

  • Jasmeet Bains

    Legislator

    We need to be clear about who we are fighting for. We need to show America that we remain the party of hope and change. And don't just say it. Prove it. And let's start right now.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Bains. Assemblymember Demaio, you are recognized.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Mr. Speaker, I've only been a member of this august body for a little over five months, and in that time, I've seen a whole lot of hypocrisy on this floor, a lot of hypocritical and dishonest resolutions like the one we are debating today, AGR3. This one, however, has to take the cake.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    It is the top of the list of the most hypocritical language and political posturing I have ever seen to try to shift the blame for bad policies approved and imposed by this legislature and this governor. My colleague from Central Valley, she's correct. Democrats do not control the White House or the Congress, thank God.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    But they do control this state government. They have supermajority control of this state government. And we have a Medicaid program in our state. It's called Medi-Cal. And right now, what have you done under your management? You've put it on the brink of financial collapse.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And you were warned that this would happen a year ago when you said.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Mr. Demaio, we are speaking on this resolution, aren't we? We are speaking on the resolution before us. We're not speaking about a year ago. We're speaking on the merits of the resolution in front of us.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We are speaking on what everyone in this body says this resolution stands for. And that is safeguarding Medicaid program in the State of California. And so, Mr. Speaker, I will absolutely raise threats to the Medicaid program, Medi-Cal, imposed by this body because we are directing a resolution at the wrong party that is threatening the health care coverage of hundreds of thousands of poor families in the State of California.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Mr. Demaio, I don't believe that a party is referenced in this resolution.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    This resolution is about Medicaid and Medicare.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    This resolution is about the federal government, and you're speaking of the state government, which is very appropriate. Excuse me, Mr. Demaio. Which is very appropriate. We're not referencing political parties.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Okay. Good to know that we have that new rule in effect. And that's fine. I will confine my comments to not political parties. But what this majority and this governor have done to the Medi-Cal program, you've put it on the brink of financial insolvency. And that was a choice you made.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And that's also a choice that two weeks ago you had an opportunity to reverse. We offered an amendment to save Medi-Cal for poor people in our state, and you unanimously rejected that amendment. That amendment would have said no more illegal immigrants should be given free taxpayer-funded health care in our budget.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    The only threat we have to Medicaid Medi-Cal in our state is a threat created by this body.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We are seeing the federal government now go through every invoice that the State of California has submitted for reimbursement on Medi-Cal for the past several years, and it is quite possible, quite probable, that the State of California taxpayers are going to be penalized for decisions made by this body and this governor.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And that will further erode the financial stability of Medi-Cal. And yet we are doing nothing to prepare for that. We're talking billions of dollars in reimbursements that are likely going to be clawed back.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    The Department of Health and Human Services at the federal level, rightfully so, is doing an investigation and audit of the State of California Medi-Cal program. You know it, I know it, but the media doesn't report on it.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And if that audit shows that we, the State of California, the governor, misappropriated funds, covered ineligible people with federal funds, guess what? Those dollars will have to now be absorbed by the State General Fund, and we don't have the money.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    So that means more doctors, more nurses, more hospitals, more health clinics, not being reimbursed for services for citizens. That means poor people going without health care coverage, not being able to see a doctor or nurse. Oh, spare me the grandstanding with a resolution like this when you're given clear evidence that Medi-Cal is headed for collapse.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    So much so that the governor had to rush not one, but two emergency loans in the dead of night. You want to talk about the dead of night? 6.4 billion dollars in emergency loans, and this body didn't even do an oversight hearing on that nonsense.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    You stand here with a resolution, and you hope that the voters aren't paying attention to the policies that you have approved and that you had an opportunity to reverse just two weeks ago, and you chose to play politics. I'm voting against a resolution that does not accurately reflect the crisis we face, not imposed by the federal government.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    They're simply holding us to account for breaking the law, for breaking the rules of Medicaid. That was a decision, a choice willingly done by this state government and this governor. And this legislature sat by and rubber-stamped it two weeks ago.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    30 seconds.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    The sooner you wake up and change that policy, the sooner we can safeguard Medicaid, Medi-Cal, health services for the most neediest of Californians. Until then, you'll continue to play politics.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Demaio. Assemblymember Schultz, you are recognized.

  • Nick Schultz

    Legislator

    Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. With all due respect to my colleague from San Diego, I hope that everyone in the chamber is watching. I hope the whole world is watching this vote. A lot of discussion about what is in this resolution and what it's about. Let me be extraordinarily clear.

  • Nick Schultz

    Legislator

    In my short time here in the legislature, there are very few easy decisions. I think this is an easy decision.

  • Nick Schultz

    Legislator

    If you believe that Social Security and Medicare, and Medicaid are critical lifelines covenants to the current and future generations of this country, and if you believe that we should be doing everything in our power to ensure that they are not cut or privatized, if you believe in those things, vote aye.

  • Nick Schultz

    Legislator

    And if you don't believe in those things, if you believe that privatization is the answer, if you believe in cuts to seniors and those who are on the margins of our society, if you believe that's the answer, vote no. And God help you explaining that to your constituents. I'm voting aye.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Schultz. Assemblymember Lee, you are recognized.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I just want to address that there's been a lot of grandstanding and misinformation, and deflection that has been happening right now on this floor.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    It is undoubtedly, and the American people understand this, is that the people that control the purse springs, the federal government for Social Security, Medi-Cal, Medicare is the federal government and they have been openly talking about cutting basic health care for our seniors and our families and our citizens across the country while they take a chainsaw to the to the economy, all fueled by their billionaire friends.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    The most wealthy man in the history of the planet is recommending to this radical right-wing regime they should cut basic services and health care for poor Americans just so they can pay for unprecedented amount of billionaire tax cuts. Billionaire tax cuts. And I'm sick of hearing of deflections. It is important.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Yes, I don't disagree that we ought to push back with our own administration, and we should be shoulder to shoulder in making sure that Medi-Cal is protected for all of our families in California, immigrants, citizens, undocumented alike. And it is the point of our California Legislature that we prioritize the well-being of all Californians.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Not just arbitrary math and figures on a financial scale to that very point, even at the federal level, they have not been able to course correct their deficit. In fact, by cutting services to poor people, threatening Social Security, all it is to just pay for tax breaks for billionaires and millionaires, and also balloon the defense budget.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    It is not true fiduciary responsibility. It is just making people suffer, the American working class suffer. And I respectfully ask your aye vote if you care about the working class, Californians, and Americans.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Lee. Assemblymember Patterson, you are recognized.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Great, thank you. Mr. Speaker. I have the opportunity to sit on the Budget Committee dealing with California's health care budget. And I can't really speak to what's happening on the federal level because you know, I'm really concerned about what's happening on the state level. And I did read about.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    And by the way, I'm an elected state representative, and we Republicans have supported a lot of legislation, a lot of resolutions such as this one, where we've asked Congress and the president to do certain things. But I have to agree with my colleague from San Diego on some of the hypocrisy that we might have today.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Maybe we can write a letter or do a resolution to the governor as well. Because actually his budget that he proposed just last week has 10 billion dollars more in federal funds allocated towards health care than the current budget year. So in other words, he's expecting the federal government to give California 10 billion dollars more.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Despite what he says to the media and despite his press and despite everybody wants to say he's expecting, he's budgeting for 10 billion dollars more. So either he's lying or he's setting California up for failure. And maybe both.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Also, just to go over some of these cuts, because I've received a lot of emails on them already, and I'm sure you have as well. 94 million dollars this year, or, sorry, next budget year to, in home support services, some of the most vulnerable individuals in the state. 540 million next, the following budget year.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    That's a half a billion dollars in cuts to some of the most vulnerable individuals in California and nearly 800 million dollars more on an ongoing basis. Now, I'm hopeful that my colleagues in this chamber will reject and act with the same passion and join Republicans in supporting eliminating the governor's draconian cuts to the most vulnerable population in California.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Because we've done that before. We've worked together to do that. And just as Republicans have joined with you on many of these resolutions, which are just statements to the to the federal government, by the way.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    We can actually take action on a bipartisan basis and reject these draconian cuts to some of the most vulnerable populations in the state. And whenever session ends, maybe later this evening, there will be a budget hearing in room 1100, where we will discuss these exact issues. And it's in room 1100, usually it's in the Capitol.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    And so I expect that we're going to have a very long line of individuals impacted by the governor's draconian cuts that are actually proposed and on paper and that we will be voting on for any day now.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Patterson. Assemblymember Bryan, you are recognized.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Thank you. Mr. Speaker and colleagues, I rise the strong support of AJR3. In case you weren't keeping count, we have been debating this measure for 19 minutes and 21 seconds. That means for four minutes and 21 seconds, we debated longer than Elon Musk paid into Social Security this year.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    It took him 15 minutes to max out his Social Security contribution this year because the cap is too low. Everything about this administration is set to make people's lives harder. When you cut people's health care, when you cut their Social Security, you make their lives harder. That is not the role of government.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    I believe that we are not put here to make people's lives harder. In fact, I believe we have a responsibility to improve the conditions of life wherever we can. That is why California is stepping up. And I want to thank the federal government, as my colleague mentioned, for reimbursing us with our own money.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    I pointed it out many times. California pays 80 billion dollars more in federal taxes than we get back. We are the donor nation. We are the donor state to this nation.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    In fact, there are many poorly run states that should pick themselves up by their own bootstraps instead of relying on the taxpayers of California who are making up for the deficits that are being created by the actions happening in D.C., the cuts to our foundational social safety nets.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    While all this is happening, he is making it harder for folks to receive the same basic benefits others have before. Pell Grants, for example, used to be 12 credits as full time. They've raised it to 15, making it harder for students to get an education and harder to pay it back.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Under President Biden, if you were over 62 years old and you defaulted on your loans, your student loans were for hard times because you shouldn't have had to bear the cost of your education to that degree anyway. Because we defunded education in this country, the lowest Social Security payment you could get was 1,800 dollars a month.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    This administration just slashed it to 750 dollars. You cannot live on 750 dollars a month. It's insulting, it's shameful, it's borderline evil. This is a simple resolution. It's about standing up for Californians no matter what's happening in the federal government. That should be bipartisan. We have seniors in every single one of our districts.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    We have poor folks who need and deserve health care in every single one of our districts. We shouldn't be debating this. We certainly shouldn't be debating it longer than Elon Musk paid into Social Security this year. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Bryan. Members of the gallery, applause is inappropriate. Assemblymember Schiavo seeing and hearing no further debate, would you like to close?

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Yes. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I appreciate the robust conversation on this issue, and I would imagine for much of that 19 minutes, it was probably only about four minutes that was actually talked about this resolution and our federal government's impact.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And to be able to deflect and simply brush away 715 billion dollars with a B being cut from Medicare is or Medicaid is convenient to just ignore. To just ignore 715 billion dollars disappearing to pay for health care for the poorest people. And that is what this resolution is about.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    I happen to sit on the budget subcommittee that deals on health. I have raised all of the issues raised by those on the other side of the aisle. And one of the reasons that the budget sub health committee is in a larger hearing room today is because it is open to everyone.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And I hope that all of those who have not come and talked about these important issues actually shows up and raises these issues because I raise them at every single one, as my colleague in Rockland knows. So you know, this is.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    There were a lot of important points made today and there's been a lot of rhetoric by our president about giving things back to the state. We would happily take those 80 billion dollars that we donate to other states back.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    We would happily take that to make sure that we can pay for health care that we are struggling to pay for right now in this state. But instead, they are not giving those 80 billion dollars back to us. They are cutting 715 billion dollars from health care, from Social Security, from Medicare.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    I challenge anyone in this room to try to survive on 750 dollars a month and say that that's enough for our seniors to live on.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    So we have to, as a state, send a clear message that we will fight every single day here in the State of California and send a clear message to our federal government that they are not allowed to cut health care and basic needs for seniors on the backs of tax breaks to billionaires.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    That is a line we should all agree on, and I hope that we do. I urge your support of AJR3. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Schiavo. Assemblymember Schiavo has asked for the first roll to be open for co-authors. Seeing and hearing no further debate. The clerk will open the roll for co-authors. [Roll Call]

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. There are 52 co-authors added. Because this is a joint resolution, we cannot have a voice vote. The clerk will now open the roll on the resolution itself. [Roll Call]

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes ayes 53 nos. 2. The resolution is adopted. Members, I'm going to recognize Mr. Ta for his guest introduction. Before I do that, just a level set for everybody that's in here. Speaking about the Administration is above board.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Speaking about the Federal Government and leadership in the Federal Government is above board. Speaking against political parties is not. I may have missed that in conversation. Speaking with the chief. I am imperfect and as you know, I try to keep things fair. Please restrict your comments to be about leadership.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    If you're making critiques the Administration itself and not about political parties. Mr. Ta, you are recognized for your guest introduction.

  • Tri Ta

    Legislator

    Good afternoon. Mr. Speaker, it's my honor to welcome Mr. Robert Kapp, Director of Asia Pacific, Geo Economist and Business Initiative and he's a Secretary MBA student from Chapman University. These are our future business leader of. California and I hope that have A. Wonderful experience in Sacramento as I learn. About the political process. Please all stand.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Welcome Chapman University. Okay Members, we're continuing on business on the Daily File File item number 18 A.B. 1237 by Assemblymember McKinner.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1237. By Assembly McKenna and others an act. Relating to transportation and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Somebody Member McKinnor, you are recognized Good.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    As the host of host Assembly Members of the upcoming 2026 FIFA World Cup, Assembly Member Aarons and I are pleased to present AB 1237 which will authorize the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority LA Metro and the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority VTA to access a $5 fee on primary official game ticket purchases for the 2026 FIFA World cup game in order to provide sports fans with an all day transit pass during the games.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    The upcoming 2026 FIFA World cup games present a unique opportunity to showcase the vibrant and diverse cultures of Los Angeles County, Santa Clara County and its surrounding communities to the world Members, California is not new to playing host to some of the largest sports or entertainment events in the world.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    As we look to the future, we must start thinking and taking action on how to better integrate transit use beyond its traditional uses like how we get to and from work or school, and begin to fully integrate transit use into all aspects of our lives, including participating in sporting and entertainment events.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    I will be amending this measure in the Senate to further expand transit opportunities and options at sports and entertainment venues and to make it easier for sports, music and entertainment fans to better integrate transit use when planning their next sporting and entertainment outing.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    Members, integrating a transit pass with your ticket to a sports or entertainment event will make it easier for local and international fans visiting our cities to use our transit systems, reduce our road congestions, improve local air quality, and provide critical resources needed to support our local transit system.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    I respectfully ask for your aye vote for on AB 1237.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember McKinner. Assemblymember Ahrens, you are recognized.

  • Patrick Ahrens

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker, I rise in. Strong support of AB 1237. I want to thank my colleague from Los Angeles for bringing up this important. Measure of supporting our public transportation agencies and doing everything that we can to welcome the world to these major sporting events.

  • Patrick Ahrens

    Legislator

    The super bowl and the World Cup are coming to my district next year at Levi's Stadium, home to the greatest football team in the world, the San Francisco 49ers. And I am delighted to be supporting this measure. I urge your aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ahrens. Assemblymember Bonta, you are recognized.

  • Mia Bonta

    Legislator

    Thank you. Members, I urge your support in AB 1237 as the mother of and mother in law of not one, but two national team players on the women's side in soccer, a strong believer in our ability to make sure that we are fully representing the State of California in this unique opportunity for us.

  • Mia Bonta

    Legislator

    I respectfully request your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Bonta. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Mckinnon, would you like to close?

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    Yes. I would like to thank my two Assembly Members from the North. We all know that we also are going to have the super bowl at the SoFi. And we know that the Rams is one of the greatest teams going.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    This is just a way for us to help make sure that our transit is taken care of and that we can make sure that we have a very, very successful World Cup. Because we all know when we host this World Cup, we'll have people from all around the world. And this World Cup is.

  • Tina McKinnor

    Legislator

    This is an investment as well. Because we know that the World Cup is going to bring lots of revenue to the State of California. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Mckinnon. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. zero, excuse me. This. This Bill requires. It has urgency clause on it requires 54 votes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    All Members vote who desire to.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Miss McKinnor, mind coming up to the dais? Can you mind coming up to the dais for a moment?

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Clerk will close the roll tally the votes Iz 56 nos 15 ize 56 knows 15 on the urgency I's 56 knows 15 on the measure Measure passes going to pass temporarily on file item number 19. We're going to pass and retain on file items 2021. That brings us to file item number 22. AB 738 by Assemblymember Tangipa.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 738 by Assembly Member Tangipa and others and.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Accolades or energy Assembly Member Tangipa you are recognized.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Right Good afternoon Mr. Speaker. Thank you for the opportunity to present AB3 or 738. Prior to being elected, I was a field Rep for Fresno county. And in 2020 our community faced a devastating wildfire known as the Creek Fire. I saw firsthand the impacts that these these disasters have on homeowners and entire communities.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Rebuilding after a fire is a difficult and costly process that doesn't need to include unnecessary regulatory burdens that only make it harder for survivors to get back on their feet. AB738 provides a simple, practical solution by offering a limited exemption to homeowners whose properties were affected by disasters that have been declared an emergency by the Governor.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    This Bill allows them to rebuild their homes under the solar energy standards that were in place when their homes were originally constructed, without the added financial burden of meeting newer, more expensive regulations. This exemption is not a blanket change.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    It's a narrowly focused measure that ensures that only those who have already suffered the dramatic effects of a disaster can benefit from it. It's so narrowly focused that the income limits on this Bill disqualifies every single one of us in this room.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    If that was to happen to you, that's how tight we wanted to to provide relief for the seniors for those who bought their homes 50 years ago to make sure they have the chance to get back on their feet.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    I have a friend of mine who purchased their home back in the 1970s for less than $50,000 and the solar requirement on that is more expensive than for than what they bought their home for in the 1970s.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    And they have been on a fixed income of less than $2,000 a month and they cannot rebuild and currently live in a trailer. The goal is not to undermine California's clean energy goals, but to recognize that in a time of crisis, wildfire survivors need flexibility, not additional costs that delay their recovery.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Rebuilding isn't just about restoring homes it's about restoring communities and giving people the chance to reclaim their lives.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Tangipa seeing and hearing no further debate. The Clerk will open the Mr. Allen, excuse me, Mr. Alanis. Mr. Tangipa is tough to see through. Mr. Alanis, you're recognized.

  • Juan Alanis

    Legislator

    I was just reviewing his bill. I wanted to ask him a question about one of them. About the state energy, resources and conservation. Will that expand their authority in your bill? Do you know? You can say it in your closing if you want, but just wondering. Curious. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Alanis. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Mr. Tangipa, would you like to close.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Yes, it will not expand that authority and I respectfully ask for your aye vote on this very important Bill.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    All debate having ceased on this support support Bill. The Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to. Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Eyes 42 knows two measure passes the pass and retain on File item number 23 brings us to file item number 24. AB 1460 by Assemblymember Rogers.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1460 by Assembly Member Rogers and others and accolades of Prescription Drug Pricing Summit.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Member Rogers, you were recognized.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    Thank you so much. Mr. Speaker, what we have established at today's floor session are two things. One is that while there is a lot of faith in the 49ers and in the Rams, nobody has faith in the Chargers. The second is that we all agree that we need better access to health care.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    AB 1460 will help address health equity and access to care issues in California by protecting the ability of clinics and health centers to dispense 340b medications to their patients. The May revise was a wake up call on the State of healthcare in California as we face a major budget deficit and weeks of difficult conversations around cuts.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    It's more critical than ever that we protect our social safety net providers and their ability to collect savings that help Fund their services. During the pandemic, drug manufacturers started rolling out contract pharmacy restrictions meant to limit access to the 340B program.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    These restrictions limited clinic systems, not individual clinics, the entire system to one single pharmacy location for dispensing 340b medications. Again, for folks as context, my district is 312 miles long. We have a clinic system that spans multiple counties and they've been limited to one specific pharmacy, not type of pharmacy, one specific pharmacy.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    This means clinic systems that cover multiple counties and single counties cannot access this program that is keeping the doors open. The purpose of the federal 340B program is to furnish clinics with discount drugs for two reasons. The first is that they can dispense medications to uninsured and underinsured individuals at a reduced cost.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    This is extremely important for vulnerable communities and especially for undocumented folks. The second is to provide pass through savings to clinics when they dispense discount medications at full price to patients with insurance.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    These new contract pharmacy restrictions have had major impacts on clinic systems that rely on 340B pass through savings to Fund important and often underfunded services like extended hours of operation, new medical equipment, staff, transportation services, and meal services. The contract pharmacy restrictions also mean clinic systems can't contract with multiple pharmacies that cover the areas they serve.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    It's slowly strangling local providers by forcing people to use the big conglomerates that are typically out of state. AB 1460 simply states that drug manufacturers cannot place discriminatory restrictions on access to 340b medications. This will allow clinics to contract with more pharmacies in the areas that they serve.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    This Bill was severely narrowed in Committee and it now only applies to clinics and federally qualified health centers, not to hospitals. I urge you to vote eye on this important measure to support our safety net providers. Again, it's critical for our communities, especially in rural areas.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Rogers. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in support of AB 1460. Clinic Clinics are at the heart of our health care system, including in my district. They serve everyone, no matter their insurance, income or immigration status. These clinics rely on the 340B program to keep their doors open.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    While I'm not happy that the most recent amendment stripped hospitals from the Bill, this is still a step forward for clinics and it gives them some protection. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. Assemblymember Bonta, you are recognized.

  • Mia Bonta

    Legislator

    Thank you. Members, I rise in support of AB 1460.

  • Mia Bonta

    Legislator

    This bill was under discussion for many months and we've been able to arrive, I think, at a very good compromise at the moment right now to ensure that in this moment in time, particularly our clinics, our rural community clinics, our federally qualified health clinics who are under siege right now, have the ability to earn the revenue that they so desperately need through and that ultimately we can ensure that our patients and our constituents have lower healthcare costs as it relates to their pharmacy costs.

  • Mia Bonta

    Legislator

    So with that, I respectfully request your aye vote on behalf of our Assembly Member.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Bontas. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assemblymember Rogers, do you wish to close?

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    Yeah. Thank you so much. 340B, like many programs, is not perfect. There have been calls for reform on certain aspects of the program. Those are being discussed at the federal level, as they should be, as it's a federal program. The bill in front of you today is about access.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    It's about allowing uninsured folks the chance to afford medications they need to be healthy. It's about protecting an important source of funding for the clinics that serve our constituents. Regardless of how much funding flows in from the Federal Government, the need for health care remains the same and our clinics need funding to keep their doors open.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    We have committed to and will continue to work on issues to make sure that there is better transparency so that folks who are not intended to use the program cannot use the program.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    That has not been an issue that we have seen with the clinics, but we will continue to work with folks on that as this Bill moves forward. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Rogers. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote it. Clerk will close the roll and Tally the vote. Size 41 noes 5. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    That brings us to File item number 25, Assembly Concurrent Resolution 65 by Assembly Member Ward.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read. Assembly Concurrent Resolution 65 by Assembly Member Ward relative to California Tourism Month.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Ward, you are recognized.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. As chair of the Assembly Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism, I am proud to present here ACR 65, recognizing May 2025 as California Tourism Month. This industry supports our local hotels and hospitality sectors, restaurants and many small businesses and families visit.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    California recently reported that There was over $157 billion spent on travel in our state during 2024, representing a 3% increase over the previous year.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    The tourism industry continues to be a significant driver of our state's economy, creating 24,000 new jobs in 2024 and employing close to 1.2 million Californians and generating an amazing $12.6 billion in state and local tax revenue.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    I expect these numbers to grow even more in the coming years with many hugely significant international events happening right here in California. As we heard earlier, including the FIFA World Cup matches, the LA20 Olympics and Paralympic Games, as well as Super Bowls, NCAA tournaments and more.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    These events will provide opportunities for travelers from all around the world to experience California's breathtaking attractions places, parks, beaches and locations up and down the state, including many beautiful and the best city we have Sunny San Diego California Tourism Month is an excellent time to highlight the strength and resilience that the industry provides to the state.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    I respectfully ask for your aye vote on ACR 65.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ward. Assemblymember Haney, you are recognized.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to rise today alongside my colleague from San Diego to celebrate California Tourism Month. I represent another one of our cities, our state's important destinations for tourists. San Francisco continues to be one of the top global destinations, drawing visitors from every corner of the globe.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Just this last year, we welcomed over 23 million visitors, generating more than $9.2 billion in total visitor spending. As chair of the Select Committee on Downtown Recovery, we've met with mayors, downtown Association leaders, business owners and tourism advocates across the state, and the message is clear.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Downtown's economic recovery in our state is not possible without a robust tourism and visitor base. We know that after the COVID 19 pandemic, we have had challenges bringing tourists back to our state, but thankfully our city is beginning to see the comeback that we have long hoped for.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Hotel occupancy rates, international travel and conventions are all rebounding, but future projections aren't as bright. Visit California's Forecast anticipates a 1% dip in overall visitation and a 9.2% decline in international visitation in 2025. In direct response to federal economic policy and an impending Trump slump, we have to double down on tourism here in our state.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Our budget relies on it. Tens of thousands of jobs in San Francisco. I know many hundreds of thousands of jobs across our state rely on it. And I think it is critical that on this tourism month that we continue our commitment to invest in this industry.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    And I want to thank my colleague from San Diego and respectfully ask for your aye vote on ACR 65.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Haney. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Ward, would you like to close?

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank my colleague from San Francisco for raising such important points apart.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    As part of this, I'll build on that and just note that we are certainly very nervous about what the effect that we're having from national policies, national dialogues, are doing in the interest for people to be able to come to America, but specifically to come to California.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    And by passing this resolution, we want all of those would be visitors to know that California certainly stands apart from our beaches to Yosemite Valley, to Hollywood, to San Francisco. And of course Right back in San Diego, across the Golden State, we have a lot to be able to see, celebrate and visit.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    So I hope that you can pass this resolution with the spirit of California in mind. We certainly support all of our workers that make tourism sector work really well. And I know there's a lot of local conversations happening around that.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    But I'll underscore again as well how important transit occupancy tax is and the potential decimation of that for all of our city's budgets as they are also facing some of their budget challenges right now. We should be doubling down, as my colleague from San Francisco said, on supporting our tourism sector.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    And with that, I respectfully ask for the first roll to be open for co authors and respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Ward. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. Members, this is for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Members, this is for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    There are 63 co authors added without objection. We will now take a voice vote on the resolution. All in favor say aye. All opposed no. The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. Okay, we are going to pass and retain. Excuse me.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass temporarily on File item number 26 brings us to file item number 27. AB 750 by Assembly Member Quirk-Silva.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 750 by Assembly Member Quirk-Silva and others in act IAN to housing.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Quirk-Silva, you are recognized.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. AB750 enhances the implementation of AB362, a bill that I did on homeless shelters in 2021, by ensuring greater accountability, transparency and enforcement of health and and safety standards across California's estimated 13,000 homeless shelters.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    This bill addresses the critical gaps in oversight and compliance to better protect the rights and welfare of unhoused individuals.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Clerk Silva. Seeing here no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes ayes 49 knows one. The measure passes. Going to file item number 28.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    AB 1061 also by assemblymember Quirk-Silva.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1061 by Assembly Member Quirk-Silva and others and applying to land use.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Quirk-Silva, you are recognized.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 1061 removes barriers to housing development by allowing the California Home Act SB 9 of 2021 to apply in historic districts as long as projects do not demolish existing historic structures.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    This change prevents the misuse of historic preservation laws to block new housing and expands opportunities for homeownership and multi unit housing in more neighborhoods.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Quirk Silva. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Size 41, noes 13. The measure passes. Going to pass and retain on file items 29 and 30. Pass temporarily on file item 31. Pass and retain on file items 32 and 33. That brings us to file item 34, AGR number five by Assemblymember Lee.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Joint Resolution 5 by Assembly Member Lee and others relative to birthright citizenship.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Member Lee, you are recognized.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Today, in the year of 2025, we have to be discussing and debating Assembly Joint Resolution 5, which states a very simple principle, a reality which has been understood and accepted as the American dream for over 150 years, is that all babies born in America are American citizens. But why are we here today?

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    It's because on the first day in office, President Donald Trump, among many different Executive orders, this order was so blatantly unconstitutional, is trying to seek to redefine the 14th Amendment, which says and made very clear that all babies born in America are American citizens, with the exception of diplomats.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    While the White House is trying to unilaterally reinterpret the 14th Amendment, I think it's important to remember where the 14th Amendment originally came from. Above us is the portrait of President Abraham Lincoln, the great emancipator. The Congress at the time, the Republican Congress, made sure that emancipated former slaves were guaranteed the right to citizenship.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And then in 1898, it was a San Franciscan, a California born Chinese American, who sued all the way to the Supreme Court to make sure that the 14th Amendment applied evenly to all Americans.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    That person's name was Wong Kim Ark from California, from San Francisco, who worked with the Benevolent Associations of Chinatown to go all the way to the Supreme Court. And, and mind you, this was the era of the Chinese Exclusion act, of rampant racism.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    But he won and made that right so concrete and so evident that there are generations, including all the way up to today myself, that benefited from this. If birthright citizenship was not the law of the land at the time of my birth, I may not have been a citizen.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Many of us here and many of my constituents who come from mixed status households, whether they be on legal visas or they're undocumented, would not become citizens.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    But today, the Trump Administration is weaponizing their interpretation of the 14th Amendment, which is so blatantly unconstitutional, so blatantly unconstitutional that during the scotus, the Supreme Court hearings this last week, even conservative judges were scratching their head.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    It's so unconstitutional, in fact, that the government, the Trump Administration, does not even seek to defend the merits of their reinterpretation 14th Amendment. Instead, they're undermining the power of the courts.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And as we know, the power of the courts is one of the last barriers we have to save the civil rights of citizens and immigrants alike in this country. We already know that the rhetoric began with undocumented and illegal, and we are already arresting judges, deporting legal residents, and scaring even citizens out of this country.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And so the rhetoric is not just about a specific salacious class of person. It is about all those who seek to have the American dream. And I come to think about it this way too, as Justice Kavanaugh, a Trump appointee, even scratch his head about what would the Trump Administration do should this come to pass?

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Will parents, newborn parents at the hospital, will they say, congratulations to your baby. Now show us your papers. Will there be millions of stateless Children Now who are assumed to be citizens but now not given the right to ever naturalize and become citizens? What will happen to them?

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    The government, the Trump White House has no answers to those things. They only seek to deny the American dream to those who have legally able to enter this country or as asylum seekers or cross continents to brave so many dangers to be here to give their children a sense of the American dream.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And so if you believe in 150 plus years of legal precedent that every American baby is an American citizen, then I will heartfully ask you to to support this measure and send a clear message to the Federal Government that every child born in America is a citizen.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Lee. Assemblymember Kalra, you are recognized.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I want to thank my colleague from San Jose. I rise on behalf of the API legislative caucus and as a proud joint author of AJR5, which opposes the unlawful Executive order to end birthright citizenship.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    In 1868, the 14th Amendment was adopted and established birthright citizenship through the citizenship clause, overturning the disgraceful decision in Dred Scott vs Sanford. For years, birthright citizenship has remained a critical pathway for Asian immigrants to establish roots and build thriving futures for their families in the United States.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    30 years after the passage of of the 14th Amendment, the Supreme Court recognized Wong Kim Ark's legal claim to birthright citizenship and confirmed that the citizenship clause applied to all children born in the United States, regardless of the parents immigration status.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    For over a century, the courts and Congress have long settled and affirmed the meaning of birthright citizen citizenship. The attempt to terminate birthright citizenship and is an attack on our immigrant communities and only further seeks to deepen the divides.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Anti immigrant hate and anti AAPI racism have always been intertwined and if birthright citizenship were to be revoked, we would surely see a dramatic rise in hate. And let's be clear, like so many other long standing rights that we have enjoyed as Americans, by overturning it, the federal Administration is not going to overturn it for everyone.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    It will become selective as it was prior to the 14th Amendment, where winners and losers were chosen oftentimes based on the color of their skin or what country they were immigrating from.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    California must take a stand against these tired and misleading attacks and protect the very communities that have always enriched our state and our nation's economy, history and culture. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on AJR5.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Kalra, Assemblymember Elhawary, you are recognized.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise today on behalf of the California Legislative LGBTQ Caucus and Black Caucuses in support of AJR5. Rejecting President Trump's unlawful attempt to end birthright citizenship. The 14th Amendment makes clear anyone born on U.S. soil is a citizen. This is more than a law.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    It's a promise that every child born here belongs, counts and is protected. For both the black and LGBTQ communities that fight to belong, to be seen fully as part of this country, fully and equally hits close to home. We know what it means to have our existence questioned, our families attacked, and our place in this nation denied.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Birthright citizenship was written into our Constitution to correct one of the greatest injustices in our nation's history, the Dred Scott decision, which once declared black Americans could never be become citizens.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    The 14th Amendment guarantees that everyone born here is recognized as a full citizen, affirming their place, their belonging and their rights, no matter who they are, where they come from or who they love.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Today we see those same tired arguments resurfacing this time targeting immigrant communities, especially our Latino neighbors, trying to decide who gets to belong and and who doesn't. Birthright citizenship is our nation's declaration that America is not a country of bloodlines, but of values.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    It says no Executive order, no hateful policy, no fear driven politics can erase your right to belong. This is bigger than just birthright citizenship. It's about reopening old wounds and walking back the hard won progress black Americans and immigrants, LGBTQ people and so many others fought for to be seen to belong, to be treated as fully human.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    On behalf of both the LGBTQ Caucus and the Black Caucus, I thank the author and the AAPI Caucus for bringing this Critical resolution forward and ask for your aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Al Hawari. Assembly Member Carrillo, you are recognized.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    Thank you. Mr. Speaker and Members, as the Southern California Vice Chair of the Latino Caucus, it is my pleasure to rise in strong support of AGR5, which states the legislation opposition to President Trump's Executive order seeking to dismantle birthright citizenship.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    I stand firmly in support of our state legislative opposition to the reckless and unconstitutional attempt to end birthright citizenship. This Executive order is not just legally flawed, but morally wrong.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    To be clear, the 14th Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees that all persons born or naturalized in the United States are citizens, regardless of their immigration status or their parents. No Executive order can override the Constitution. This is not just about the law. It's about who we are as a country.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    Birthright citizenship is a form of national promise of equality. It's part of what makes our nation a beacon of hope for families seeking a better life. Millions of Latino families contribute every day to the strength and spirit of this country.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    To question the citizenship of their US Born children is an insult to their sacrifices and to our nation's principles. California is not going to stand by while federal overreach attacks our communities. We will challenge this order in the courts, in the Legislature, and continue to stand with our communities against these continuous attacks.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    I offer my strong support of AGR5 and I respect Gliazra and I vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Carrillo. Assemblymember Haney, you are recognized.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise as a proud joint author of AJR 5 and as the representative of the City of San Francisco, which is the birthplace and home of Wong Kim Ark. My city, just like every part of California, is one that was shaped by and built by immigrants.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    At the heart of that commitment and at the center of what made that possible, was birthright citizenship guaranteed by the 14th Amendment of the United States Constitution. For over 100 years, this has been a centerpiece of our states and our country's commitment to immigrants.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Every single person born in this country, on this soil, has a right to be here as a citizen. This is something that has been challenged and targeted for as long as it has been in existence.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    In 1873, Wong Kim Ark was born to Chinese immigrants who, like many at the time, had been denied the opportunity to naturalize due to racist exclusion laws. But the 14th Amendment had guaranteed him the right to be a citizen. But in attack on that, the Chinese Exclusion act attempted to undo that.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    And he fought that law all the way up to the Supreme Court. After traveling to China for a brief visit, Wong Kim Ark was denied re entry in the United States despite being born here simply because of his Chinese heritage.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    The United States Supreme Court affirmed the 14th Amendment in his decision guaranteeing citizenship to every person born on American soil, regardless of the nationality of their parents.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Because of Wong Kim Ark's courage, because of the support that he had from the Chinatown community, including the Chinese six companies, we have had this right established by the Supreme Court ever since that decision in 1898. These attempts to undo birthright citizenship from children born on the US Soil are unconstitutional.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    And they also attempt to divide us, devaluing the American identity of entire communities. And in doing over a century of legal precedent in California, we know the stakes. We've lived the consequences of exclusions, and we've seen what it means to of these attempts to deny the rights of immigrants and children born on our soil.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    But we also know the strength and power of diversity, the incredible contributions of immigrants and their children. And we honor Wong Kim Ark and support the constitutional right of birthright citizenship by passing this resolution today. I respectfully ask for your aye vote on AJR5.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Haney. Assemblymember Rubio, you're recognized.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    Thank you. Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise today on behalf of the California Legislative Jewish Caucus in support of AJR5, reaffirming our constitutional values and standing by birthright citizenship. The law we are fighting for today is not just another statute to be debated by our parties or ideological factions. It is the very embodiment of the American dream.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    The dream ingrained in this right to freedom, the right to opportunity and the right to prosperity is in the stories of those who came in search for a better life for their children 250 years ago and those who have come since. The same promise for a better life for our children is what makes this country great.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    It is a promise we must protect for those who came after us, for those who come after us. It is the promise the great Jewish poet Emma Lazarus wrote about, which was enshrined on the pedestal of the Statue of Liberty. She wrote, quote, give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    It is why our state must stand with newcomers and afford them the same rights that allowed our families to prosper and allowed us in this room to make our way to the Legislature. These stories are also not so far away from our Jewish families.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    For many, it is our parents and grandparents who fled some of the world's most horrific moments of bigotry, violence and terror. They come with nothing and lay roots for their children.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    In fact, it was just last week I was personally moved by my colleague from Clovis, mother being present and their story of citizenship, which she secured just last year. A story which resonates with many families, families of Members here on this floor.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    Citizenship, as my colleague and his mother can attest to, is one of the most joyful and prideful aspects of being an immigrant to both this state and this country. Like California, efforts to defend the fundamental constitutional principle of birthright citizenship are being championed federally by Jewish Congressmember Jamie Raskin and the Congressional Jewish Caucus.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    Alongside the chairs of the Congressional Black, Hispanic and Asian Pacific American Caucuses, our leaders are standing united for what is right and for what is fundamentally American. In the same fashion, we are standing arm in arm with our colleagues from the diversity caucuses today to remind detractors of who's still here to uphold the Constitution.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    As we stand together on the shoulders of our elders who brought our families to the American dream, we are here to affirm to California's newest citizens, we will not let that dream be taken away from you. In that spirit and on behalf of the Jewish Caucus, I respectfully ask for your aye vote on ACR 5. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Rubio. Assemblymember Demaio, you are recognized.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. When these resolutions come up, I read them carefully because when I vote on these resolutions, I'm speaking on behalf of nearly half a million constituents. I want to make sure that the resolution is accurate and that the resolution reflects our values.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We have a situation here where supporters of this resolution would like to pretend like if you don't support the resolution, you're somehow anti immigrant. Our colleague from Central Valley even said that if you don't support the resolution, you're anti gay. That surprised me.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    The reality is the United States, with the 14th Amendment, with birthright citizenship, this policy, we are quite unique among the community of nations. In fact, we are one of the only countries that afford citizenship just by birthright. The 1898 case that was brought up in this resolution.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I appreciate the author laying out some of the details of Mr. Arc's situation. He had been here for 20 years. A policy imposed by China prevented him from enjoying citizenship. The U.S. Supreme Court in 1898, I believe, correctly decided that he deserved citizenship based upon the facts of the case.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We have a variety of people here that I don't think understand the law. I don't think they understand the 1898 case.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And perhaps the media doesn't want to actually cover the 1898 case, but I think it's actually quite healthy for our country to raise the question because the 14th amendment and birthright citizenship has been a topic of debate and confusion and misrepresentations.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    To sit here and say that you can confidently say that anyone who wants this to go to the Supreme Court for another review, that somehow those people are anti immigrant or anti lgbt. Seriously, that is simply inflaming the conversation. I have no concern about the process that the Supreme Court is taking.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I listened to the arguments made, and frankly, I think every government teacher should actually have their students listen to some of the arguments made to the Supreme Court in last week's hearing. Heck, they're not getting a whole lot of education on the Constitution, but perhaps they may learn something from this process.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I'm going to hold out and wait to see what the Supreme Court, in its considered judgment, has to say about this dispute. I don't think they're waiting for any sort of input from a body like this.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Dubaio, seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Excuse me, Assemblymember Lee. Assembly Member Ramos, you are recognized.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And first of all, this nation is home to Native Americans. Everyone else that has come to this country is from a different country. So that birth, citizenship, right, actually equates to the bodies that are in here and across this nation.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    If you aren't from this country from the beginning, talking about history, talking about government classes, let's go way back to where this country was and who the rightful people are.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    We sit here today to talk about these things, the issues that we're bringing up on this dais and in this body, from this caucus that's truly diversified to bring up our issues to be the voices of those that were out there, that were tried to be drowned out by others that are there.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    No longer are we going to be able to stand for that.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    We are unified, culturally unified, together to make sure that the voices, the voices are crying out in our nation that it's time for us to take that stage, to make sure that all those that have come here searching for a better life have the right to be called citizens of the United States when those that are trying to change it aren't even from this country.

  • James Ramos

    Legislator

    It's time that we band together and stand together and support AJR5.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ramos. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assemblymember Lee, do you wish to close?

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First, I'd like to thank My colleagues from San Jose, South Los Angeles, South Central Valley, Palmdale, the City of San Francisco, Baldwin park, and of course San Bernardino. I would like to thank you all for your incredibly profound and insightful comments about why this resolution is so important.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And just for the record, if I may read just one of the paragraphs in the AGR just to make it clear what the text of the language is is that we resolve that the Legislature affirms its commitment to birthright citizenship and recognizes and honors Wong Kim Ark's fight to affirm the fundamental right of birthright citizenship under the 14th Amendment of the United States of the Constitution.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And I hope the Supreme Court does take notice of her state because our Attorney General and also city attorneys part a multi state lawsuit that brought this question to the courts and have prevented this blatantly unconstitutional order from taking effect across hospitals and birthing rooms across the country.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    It is important that we share our values and that we stand up steadfast in the court system because it actually does matter. As my colleague from Los Angeles said, we are not a country of bloodlines, we are a country of values.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And it is profoundly insulting to the American Dream and our immigrant families that the Federal Government could take away the citizenship of their innocent American born babies. So I really appreciate today our conversation. I do appreciate that this moment can be a teaching lesson for many generations in history classes down the line.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And I would like to ask for the first role to be open for co authors.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Lee. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll for co authors Members. This is for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. This is for co authors. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    There are 55 co authors added as a joint resolution there cannot be a voice vote. Clerk will now open the roll on the resolution. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Eyes58 knows one.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The resolution is adopted.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Lee, you are recognized for your guest introduction.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker. I have a guest introduction today. Much was discussed today about Wong Kim Ark who was born in San Francisco, California. When he when he tried to return home in 1895 after visiting China, a Collector of Customs barred him entry because his parents were Chinese, not American.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    The Chinatown Committee, including a Chinese Consolidate Consolidated Benefit Benevolent Association, rallied to support Wong Kim Ark's lawsuit which affirmed birthright citizenship in the 14th Amendment. Now, of course, we are not bringing Wong Kim Ark to the Assembly floor, but we are bringing his descendant, Norman Wong, to the floor of the Assembly.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    Norman Wong is a descendant of Wong Kim ark, whose landmark 1898 Supreme Court case affirmed birthright citizenship. Norman's Japanese American mother also experienced racial injustice by the Federal Government, along with 120 other 120,000 other Japanese Americans. Norman's mother was incarcerated during World War II, and she spent her years in Topaz, Utah.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    In his college years, Norman striked for ethnic studies at UC Berkeley as part of the Third World Liberation Front. Norman Wong was born and raised in San Francisco, and I believe this is also where he met his wife, Maureen, who joins him at UC Berkeley.

  • Alex Lee

    Legislator

    And together, to this day, they are still champions for change, progress, and liberation for all. Please welcome to the Assembly Maureen and Norman Wang.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Members, while the photography is being completed in the back, I just want to let you know we're going to go backwards a little bit on a few items that we passed temporarily. On the first will be file item number 26, that is AB761 by Assemblymember Addis.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 761 by Assembly Member Addis and acclaim to Transportation Member Addis.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    You are recognized.

  • Dawn Addis

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present AB 761 which will give the Monterey Salinas Transit District the opportunity to fund vital programs and operations that serve vulnerable populations across Monterey County.

  • Dawn Addis

    Legislator

    In 2014, MST proposed Measure Q, a county wide 18 cent sales tax ballot measure to support public transit and Measure Q has generated approximately $7 million annually which has funded transportation services and equip for veterans, senior citizens and people with disabilities. However, Measure Q is set to expire in 2030 unless it is renewed by voters.

  • Dawn Addis

    Legislator

    AB761 would authorize the MST board to propose a sales tax ballot measure to voters upon arrival of 2/3 - upon approval of 2/3 of its board of directors. So to be clear, MST would not have the power to impose a tax. It would simply allow the agency to propose a ballot measure.

  • Dawn Addis

    Legislator

    This Bill also specifies that an increase in MST sales tax would not count toward the 2% combined rate limit for local taxes. This is a district bill with very minor implications and I respectfully request your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Addis. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 47, noes 12. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We are going to continue on to File item number 31. ACR 62 by Assemblymember Hart. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Concurrent Resolution 62 by Assemblymember Hart relative to California Nonprofits Day.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Hart, you are recognized.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to proudly present ACR 62 and recognize May 21, 2025 as California Nonprofits Day. This day honors the vital role that nonprofit organizations play in our economy, our communities and the well being of all Californians. California's nonprofits are essential partners in delivering critical services.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    Our nonprofits also have an incredible impact on on California's economy. Nonprofits are the fourth largest industry by employment in California, employing more than 1.2 million people. That means one in every 14 jobs in California is in the nonprofit sector.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    From housing and healthcare to education and the arts, the state depends on thousands of nonprofit organizations to deliver high quality services across California.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    At a time when nonprofits face increasing threats from the Federal Government, it's more important than ever that we stand with them here at home. California is committed to supporting and partnering with nonprofits to build resilient communities and create lasting, positive change.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    On Wednesday, we will welcome over 100 nonprofit leaders from across the state for our annual Nonprofit Day Luncheon. Now in its 10th year, California Nonprofits Day has recognized the work of over a thousand organizations and honors their invaluable contributions to our great state.

  • Gregg Hart

    Legislator

    Colleagues are urged your support of this resolution to celebrate and strengthen California's nonprofit sector.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Hart. Mr. Hart, do you wish the first roll to be open for coauthors? All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. Members this is for coauthors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. There are 65 coauthors added without objection. We will now take a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed no. The resolution...the ayes have it. The resolution is adopted.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Getting back to file order we are going to pass and retain on file items 35 and 36. Mr. Kalra. Mr. Kalra. We're now on file item number 37, AB 1523 by the Committee on Judiciary.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1523 by the Committee on Judiciary and acclaim to Civil Procedure.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Kara, you are recognized.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker. AB 1523 is a Judiciary Committee Bill that reflects a compromise between numerous stakeholders that will increase the amount in controversy cap for referring civil cases to mandatory mediation from 50,000 to 75,000.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    The Bill also reflects stakeholder input based on 30 years of experience with the existing law to add safeguards to the existing law to ensure that only cases with a high likelihood of amicable resolution are sent to mediation.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    This compromise bill strikes a balance between stakeholders to ensure that courts can continue to use mediation as a tool for resolving disputes before trial. With the need to ensure all Californians get their day in court, this Bill received bipartisan support in Committee and I respectfully request an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Kalra. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally the votes. Ayes 65, noes 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Moving to file item 38. AB 316 by Assemblymember Krell.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 316 by Assemblymember Crell in acclaim to civil actions.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Krell, you are recognized.

  • Maggy Krell

    Legislator

    Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. I rise to present you today with Assembly Bill 316. This is a very simple bill, but it's an important one.

  • Maggy Krell

    Legislator

    All it states is that in an action against a defendant that developed or used artificial intelligence that is alleged to have caused harm to a person, it shall not be a defense and the defendant may not assert that the artificial intelligence autonomously caused the harm to the person.

  • Maggy Krell

    Legislator

    This doesn't create any new defenses. This doesn't create any new liabilities. It's a simple guardrail provision that will incentivize companies that are benefiting from AI to also present to also prevent that same AI from cause - that same AI from causing harm.

  • Maggy Krell

    Legislator

    This Bill has a broad coalition of support, bipartisan support, children's advocacy organizations as well as labor and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Krell. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 56, Noes 0. The measure passes. Gonna pass and retain on file item 39. Brings us to file item number 40. AB 571 by Assemblymember Quirk-Silva.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 571 by Assemblymember Quirk-Silva and others in acclimating to environmental quality and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Quirk-Silva, you're recognized.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker and Members. Today I am proud to present AB 571 which provides a targeted CEQA exemption with an urgency clause for the Southern California Veterans Cemetery at Gypsum Canyon in the City of Anaheim.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Members, this project has been a decade in the making and is a project I have worked on with bipartisan support since I was first elected to the Assembly in 2012. Members, this is also a testament to slow and steady wins the race. To keep at it. To sometimes you win and sometimes you don't.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Members, I hope you'll pay attention because as you are, many of you first-time members are presenting legislation. You're going to find that sometimes your bills fly off the floor, sometimes you get to 41 and you squeak out a vote. And yet sometimes you have to keep going back over and over.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Members, this is the fourth Bill that I have done in a sequence to bring a Southern California Veterans Cemetery to Orange County. It is also deeply personal to me as my family includes proud members of the United States Army, Air Force, and Marines.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    Today we are closer than ever to delivering on the promise of a final resting place for Orange County's veterans, a place of honor, dignity, and peace. I want to thank the members that are standing by me in this, bipartisan support.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    And this is meaningful because too often on this floor we know that there are divisions, we know that we don't all agree and sometimes we bitterly disagree and yet we have to find places where we can agree.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    And simply honoring our veterans, those who have served, and defining a final resting place for them in Southern California is certainly something that I'm proud to acknowledge these Members here as coauthors. One more bit of information. In order to move a project like this forward, it has not only taken legislation, but it's taken funding.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    And I'm proud to say that over the years of step-by-step, not only myself, but Senator Tom Umberg, has helped provide almost $50 million for us to the Cal Vet account to bring forward a first phase. AB 571 will help us move this project across the finish line.

  • Sharon Quirk-Silva

    Legislator

    It ensures that after more than a decade of effort, the Southern California Veterans Cemetery can finally become a reality. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Quirk-Silva. Seeing in the hearing of all debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll on Assembly Bill 571. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Ayes 64, noes 0 on the urgency. Ayes 64, noes 0 on the measure. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Pass and retain on file item number 41 and 42. Brings us to file item number 43. Going to temporarily pass on file item number 43. Brings us to file item number 44. AB 1466 by Assemblymember Hart. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1466 by Assemblymember Hart in acclaim to groundwater adjudication.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Excuse me. We're going to pass temporarily on file item 44. Going to pass and retain on file item number 45. That brings us to file item number 46. AB 656 by Assemblymember Schiavo. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 656 by Assemblymember Schiavo in acclaim to social media platforms.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Schiavo, you are recognized.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present AB 656, an easy way for California to help teens escape social media addiction and protect their mental health. As a mother, I worry about social media because I know the terrible impacts mental health on mental health it can have.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    And many of our colleagues have shared their own stories as parents on this floor. Personalized algorithms, endless scrolling, like buttons and other strategies play on psychology to strengthen addiction, even if the content harms mental health. Unfortunately, many platforms intentionally make users go through a maze of options to delete their account.

  • Pilar Schiavo

    Legislator

    We need to make it easier, not harder, to escape this addiction. And AB 656 ensures platforms make it clear as day how to delete your account and your personal data. There are no no votes on this Bill. My office continues to work on language improvements with the opposition, and I respectfully request an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Schiavo. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 60, noes 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Going to pass and retain on file item 47. Gets us to file item number 48. AB 1374 by Assemblymember Berman. Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1374 by Assemblymember Berman and others in acclaim to rental passenger vehicle transactions.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Berman, you are recognized.

  • Marc Berman

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. To ensure price transparency across the rental car industry, AB 1374 would require that the real price of a rental car be disclosed as soon as consumers select dates, rental location, and vehicle type.

  • Marc Berman

    Legislator

    This ensures that the upfront price is the real price consumers pay, enabling consumers to make informed choices and comparison shop. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Berman. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members voted. Desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 16, noes 1. The measure passes. Brings us to file item number 49 AB 1223 by Assemblymember Nguyen. Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1223 by Assemblymember Nguyen and others in acclaim to transportation.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Nguyen, you are recognized.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise today to present AB 1223 which modernizes the Sacramento Transportation Authority's legal authority without impacting any other self help counties. AB 1223 is a district driven Bill that gives Sacramento Transportation Authority the flexibility to propose transportation funding measures in specific areas when they are ready...

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Rather than requiring a countywide vote every time, it ensures that revenue is used within the area where the voters approve the measure. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assembly Member Nguyen. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 45, no's 13. The measure passes. We will pass and retain on file items 5051.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    That brings us to file item 52, ACR 78 by Assembly member Patel. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly the concurrent Resolution 78 by Assembly Member Patel Relative to Maternal Mental Health Awareness Month.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Patel, you are recognized.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise today to present ACR 78, which designates May 2025 as maternal mental Health Awareness Month. Maternal mental health is deeply personal. Whether you've experienced a maternal mental health issue, watched a loved one struggle, or heard the silence surrounding it, you know how isolating it can be.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    In the US, one in five women experience a maternal mental health disorder during or after pregnancy. And yet, too often, these women suffer in silence. Postpartum depression, anxiety and other disorders can bring on overwhelming feelings of fear, sadness, even despair. Left untreated, they can lead to tragic outcomes. And the impacts don't stop with the mother.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Maternal mental health affects bonding infants development, long term emotional health, and brings real financial and emotional strain to our families. Yet, far too many mothers face these challenges alone, held back by stigma, silence and the lack of support. And let's be clear, this isn't just a matter of feeling overwhelmed at the new addition in your family.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    These disorders are often triggered by a rapid and dramatic drop in estrogen and progesterone after childbirth, hormonal shifts that alter the very chemistry of our brains. If we genuinely care about the well being of children and families, we must confront the root causes, the ones that start with breaking the silence.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We must acknowledge the pain and normalize the conversation, support the science that helps us better understand all of it, and even ensure that mothers know that they are not alone, that we are not alone.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Unfortunately, the May revise proposes to cut Prop 56 provider rates for family planning and contraception and abortion services, resulting in over half a billion in funding cuts for women's maternal and reproductive health care. We must maintain investments in this critical care if we want mothers to feel safe and families to be vibrant.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I'm proud to author this resolution because maternal mental health is not just peripheral, it is central to the strength of our communities, our families and our future. Let's stand with mothers. Let's say clearly, without shame. You are seen, you are supported, and you deserve care. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I respectfully ask for your aye vote today on behalf of all the mothers in this room and all those that have mothers. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Ms. Patel, do you wish the first roll to be open for co authors?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yes, I would like the roll to be open. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Patel, Assemblymember Sharp-Collins. You are recognized.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker. I would like to thank my colleague from San Diego for bringing forth this particular resolution. Thank you for confronting an urgent and too often overlooked public health crisis, maternal mental health, particularly as it impacts women of color in America.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Earlier this year, I introduced ACR 18 maternal health awareness Day, and it is imperative that we continue to have this overall discussion. Pregnancy and childbirth should be a joyous and empowering experience, but for too many Black mothers, they are overshadowed by systemic failures that compromise both physical and mental well being.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Each year in the United States, nearly one in five women experience a maternal mental health condition such as postpartum depression, anxiety and even PTSD. For women of color, and especially Black mothers, these rates are even higher. Almost 1 in 3 black mothers represent symptoms consistent with maternal mental health conditions.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Yet despite this disproportionate burden, Black mothers are nearly twice as likely to receive no treatment or support at all. Latina and indigenous mothers also experience higher rates of postpartum depression, often compound by language barriers, immigration stress or generational trauma. The reasons are layered and deeply rooted in systemic inequities.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    When a Black mother experiences and even expresses that she's struggling mentally or even emotionally, I can tell you from my own personal experience. Too often she is ignored, she is misdiagnosed or even labeled as a strong woman and a resilient woman because that's how we're often seen.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    As if strength is an excuse for a Doctor to neglect you. Mental health professionals who understand the black experience, who look like us, who listen without judgment, who know how to hold space for trauma rooted in racism are far few in between.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Indigenous women also face alarming high rates of maternal mortality and mental health conditions, but are often treated with deep cultural insensitivity and a lack of access to culturally rooted healing.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    And across all groups, structural inequities from food insecurity to environmental racism to lack of paid leave, create chronic stress that begins long before pregnancy even continues and long after birth. We also cannot talk about maternal mental health without acknowledging the impact of loss.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Black women are nearly three times more likely to die from pregnancy related causes than white women. And when a mother is lost, trust me, it leaves the entire family, children, the partner, the parents, grappling with that trauma and that overall grief. For those who survive near death experiences during childbirth, that psychological aftermath can be just as devastating.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Trust me, I know. We need to invest in community led maternal health organizations and community doulas who also already is doing that life saving work. We need to train health care providers in the implicit biases in trauma informed care.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    We need to normalize conversations around maternal health in our communities so no mother feels ashamed for seeking help. Maternal health, it is truly a racial justice issue, it is a reproductive issue and it is a public health crisis. So to every single mother who has suffered in silence, I say to you, you are not alone.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Your pain is real. Your healing, it is possible. But I need you to know that your story truly, truly matters. So let's move forward with urgency, with empathy and with unwavering commitment to ensure that every mother not only survives but truly thrives. Truly, truly thrives.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    And with that I respectfully ask for your aye vote and I truly encourage others to please sign on to this resolution. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Sharpe-Collins. Assembly Member Bauer Kahan, you're recognized.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise in support of ACR 78. I want to start by thanking our colleague from San Diego for introducing this resolution. And I also want to thank our other colleague from San Diego for her important words on the equities related to childbirth.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    And I just wanted to rise at a moment when we are deciding where our dollars in our state budget are going to go because it is very easy as we look at the cuts to cut women's health care. It's on the table right now.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    And this highlights the value of taking care of women at every point in the reproductive journey because we must be cared for when we are pregnant, but we also need to be cared for afterwards for our children to thrive and be healthy.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    Those first few months when so many women are struggling with mental health, challenges are critical in ensuring that our children get the food, the caring, and the love they need to thrive in the years that come. And so this is incredibly important. But I hope it translates into. Into the results we see in the coming months.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Patel, do you wish to close?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yes. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And many thanks to my colleague from San Diego and my colleague for Orinda in joining and breaking the silence on maternal mental health needs and concerns and standing with me to ensure that our mothers out there are are strong before, during and after pregnancy. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Patel. The Clerk will now open the roll for co authors. Members. This is for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. There are 67 co authors added without objection.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We'll now move to a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. All oppose, no, the ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. Going to pass and retain and file item 53. Folks, I'm going to be moving at a more frantic pace if that's alright. So support, support, bills should be moved quickly.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Please File item number 54 HR 34 by Assembly Member Salache.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    House Resolution 34 by Assembly Member Solache and others relative to Harvey Milk Day.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Solache, you are recognized.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise on behalf of the California Legislative LGBTQ caucus to present HR34, recognizing the legacy of Harvey Milk. Harvey Milk was born in Woodmere, New York on May 22,1930.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk was a visionary civil and human rights leader who became the first openly gay man to be elected to major public office in the United States. This was a result of continued persistence and importantly, hope for true equality and equity. His victory inspired others and continues to help increase diversity and representation in public service.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk believed that advancing the rights of our LGBTQ community helps to advance rights for all people. Elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors 1977, he championed anti discrimination laws, labor rights, and civic engagement. Harvey Milk was assassinated in 1978 at the San Francisco City Hall.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    This horrific crime did not put an end to the work Milk had begun. His mission carries forward in the leaders and advocates he has inspired, especially the largest LGBT class in this Legislature. 14, to be exact. His increased visibility help others find the courage to live and speak their truths.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Visibility leads to representation, and representation that all levels of government matters. Today, California has approximately 198 LGBTQ plus elected officials. Harvey Make Harvey Milk pave the path for others to follow. His legacy reminds us that we must not let hate diminish our truth or extinguish our hope.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk's life on social contributions have left a mark on the history of our nation and state. Please join me in supporting HR34 to commemorate May 22, 2025 as Harvey Milk Day. I respectfully ask that the first row be open for co authors. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Salache. Assembly Members, board, you are recognized.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    Mr. Speaker, Members, colleagues, I rise today on behalf of the Latino Caucus to honor the life and legacy of Harvey Milk, a trailblazing advocate for justice, equity, and visibility. If you've been to my office, you'll see that there's a portrait of Harvey Milk right above my desk, right next to a portrait of Dolores Huerta and Cesar Chavez.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    As the Latino Caucus, we recognize Harvey Milk's vision transcended across communities. His fight for inclusion resonates deeply with our ongoing struggle for dignity, opportunity, and representation. Our Latino and LGBTQ plus communities share a history of resilience in the face of discrimination, marginalization, and systemic injustice.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk's legacy reminds us that we are stronger when we build together and fight for each other's rights. His presence in public office paved the way for countless leaders, including many LGBTQ Latinos who now profoundly serve across our state and our nation, and in this body. Honoring Harvey Milk means more than remembering his words.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    It means continuing his work. Harvey changed my life and the lives of countless other people and kids, showing us that we belong, but that we also have agency and responsibility to act and engaged to make the world a better place for everyone. And he reminded us that, "hope will never be silent...

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    And later, you can't live on hope alone. But life is not worth living without hope."

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    He showed me and many of our colleagues in this body and thousands of other people across the country and world that we belong, including in the halls of government, in a world that he did not and still does not, in a world that did not and still does not ensure equality or social justice for all.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    Harvey's impact as a trailblazer and civil rights advocate moves us to continue the fight and to finish what he started. The Latino Caucus recommits itself to uplifting policies that advance all communities. On Harvey Milk Day, let us honor his legacy with action and his vision with unity. Thank you, colleagues.

  • Rick Chavez Zbur

    Legislator

    And on behalf of the Latino Caucus, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Zbur. Assembly Member Nguyen, you are recognized.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On behalf of the Asian American and Pacific Islander Legislative Caucus, I rise in support of HR 34, Harvey Milk Day. Harvey Milk was one of the first openly gay elected officials in the country and a powerful voice for equality and representation.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Today, we honor his leadership and the hope he gave to so many, including Members of the AA and HPI LGBTQ plus community. More than 685,000 Americans identify as both AA and HPI and LGBTQ plus. Many still face stigma, discrimination, and invisibility, both in public and in their own families.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    As AA and HPI legislators, we want to make sure those voices are seen, heard, and supported. That is how we continue Harvey Milk's legacy. May the legacy of Harvey Milk's advocacy for the LGBTQ plus community live on. May his hope continue to touch the hearts of all Americans. With that, I ask for your support of HR 34.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Nguyen. Assembly Member Demaio, you are recognized.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On behalf of the Republican Caucus, I rise in support of HR34. Harvey Milk gets accolades today, but he was a very complicated individual. We should expand upon some of the whereas clauses in this resolution to make sure that we're fully accurate.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk actually entered politics as a Republican, campaigning for Barry Goldwater in 1964. As I mentioned, a very complicated man. And while celebrated by the gay community today, LGBT Democrats, he was actually opposed for office by what I sometimes refer to as the gay mafia.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    They put up roadblocks to Harvey Milk in a variety of his races, but he persevered. He stuck it out. He fought. I will tell you that while I don't agree with all of Harvey Milk's views, I don't think you'll ever find anyone today who will agree with everyone's views and stop pretending that we do.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And if you're in disagreement, you're not a bad person. You just disagree. But I will say something that may shock my colleagues on the other side of the aisle. I do gain inspiration from Harvey Milk fighting in California today. And let me tell you why.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk when he would address crowds, crowds of gay men and women who were fearful. Who... were hopeless. He would end every speech telling people that would gather, follow me, join my fight, go out and give them hope.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    And when I travel the State of California, my friends today, when I speak to crowds, that's exactly what I'm telling Californians who are fearful, who are hopeless.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Every time I tell them to stay in this state and fight, fight to fix our state, fight to fix the wrongs, fight to lessen the burdens on working families rather than fleeing to another state and giving up on a state they once loved so much. I said, you know what you have to do?

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    You have to go out and find people just like you. And you gotta give them hope. You gotta convince them not to flee the state. You gotta convince them to get into the fight. So, yes, today I rise in support of Harvey Milk. A complicated man, controversial to some. I don't know why.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Because what he stood for at its core was human rights, dignity, fairness, equality. Something that, notwithstanding many representations to the contrary, I am proud that California adheres to today. I ask for your aye vote on HR 34.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Demaio. Assembly Member Haney, you are recognized.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Thank you. Speaker and Members, I rise on behalf of the California Legislative Jewish Caucus in support of HR34 to celebrate and commemorate the pioneering life and career of Harvey Milk. Harvey Milk was a middle class Jewish kid from New York whose grandfather founded a synagogue.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    He came to California and to San Francisco and became one of our most important and iconic community and political leaders. He actually first ran for the State Assembly. That was the first office that he ran for. He ran for the seat that I currently hold and did so unsuccessfully. But he ran as an openly gay candidate.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    One of the first candidates for the state Legislature who ran openly gay and mounted a serious campaign. He didn't win that campaign. But his legend and his status as a leader only grew as a result.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    He later became one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States when he won a seat on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977. He fought for LGBT residents and he fought for renters and seniors and small business owners for improving the quality of life our city.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    As supervisor, he successfully passed a landmark Gay Rights ordinance that banned discrimination in housing, employment and public accommodations based on sexual orientation. The first of its kind that became a model for cities and states across the country. He was inspired by his own brand of Jewish values and culture.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    He joined a Jewish fraternity in college and attended events at campus Hillel. And would often interspersed bits of Yiddish when he spoke with close friends. He represented the Jewish tradition. That every human being is created in the image of God, or the divine image. And it was this value that underpins the Jewish commitment.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    To human rights and dignity for all. And his insistence that all people deserve equal rights, respect and full participation in society. He appealed to all Californians in his work in fighting against Proposition 6. Which would have banned gay and Lesbian people, and anyone who supported them from working in California public schools.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    He spoke to all Californians and said that this was not a fight for the gay community. But it was a fight for anyone who has ever been told that they don't belong. And if we lose this, they'll come for someone else next.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    These words ring true today and as always, as we fight to protect the rights of all people in our state, to live safely and fully as themselves. In that spirit, and on behalf of the Jewish Caucus and thank you to my colleague from Lynwood, I respectfully ask for your aye vote on HR 34.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Haney. Assembly Member Elhawary. You are recognized.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues, I rise on behalf of the California Legislative Black Caucus in support of HR 34. Rights are won only by those who make their voices heard. Like many of our civil rights heroes, Harvey Milk understood that visibility is the first step toward liberation.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk was a man who led with courage, who led with conviction, and who fought for a state that respects the diversity of Californians, that works to protect equity under law, and that strives for an inclusive society where each person is able to engage their talents and abilities to thrive and flourish. Civil rights are intersectional rights.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    The black civil rights movement and the LGBTQ plus rights movement share profound similarities in their quests for justice and recognition. Both movements have challenged America to live up to its founding promise that all people are created equal. The black. He also recognized that building lasting change demands building bridges across communities.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    As one of the first openly gay elected officials in our nation, Harvey Milk demonstrated what was possible for LGBTQ plus Americans. He encouraged political engagement and representation for marginalized communities, including African Americans. He supported candidates and community leaders in San Francisco and beyond, believing in increased representation in government.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Harvey Milk often marched and spoke at events that were not exclusively about gay rights. His speeches and rallies sometimes included broader calls for justice, economic equality, and racial equity, placing him alongside other progressive leaders of the time. We honor Harvey Milk

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    With a renewed commitment to justice and inclusion, to visibility and power, and to never give up the fight for what is right, simply because it is hard.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    When communities are demonized, when the humanity of our fellow human beings is questioned and denied, and when fear and anger and hate seem ascendant, Harvey reminds us that hope will never be silent. Please join the California Legislative Black Caucus in being loud and proud and casting your eye vote on this measure.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Elhawary. Alright, seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Solache, would you like to close?

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank the Members of Elk Grove, South Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Diego, and West Hollywood.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    And to all of us today, it's not every day that you get all the caucuses, including our good friends of the Republicans, endorsing such a big day, a day that we are highlighting of someone that broke barriers.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    And for me, on a very personal level, it's about making sure that our humanity is first and foremost at the forefront. Humanity that accepts everyone for who you are. And we just want to say thank you for uplifting Harvey Milk Day, someone that symbolizes so much for the LGBTQ community. You know, I won eight...

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    Seven of my elections, six local elections, state office. And it's no secret that my first election 2003 as a 23 year old first openly election was not openly gay. At 23 I was a closeted young man and until 2007 is when I first ran as an openly school board Member in the gay community.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    And so people like Harvey Milk have made a path for someone like myself that was not always open. So I want to thank those that have been such a support system throughout my life because I'm able to provide hope for many other people in California because people gave me hope like Harvey Milk.

  • José Solache

    Legislator

    So with that I ask for first roll to be co authors again. Thank you Mr. Speaker.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Solache. The Clerk will now open the roll for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. Members this is for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    There are 61 co authors added without objection will now move to a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed no. The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. Now moving to File item number 55 AGR 11 by Assemblymember Ransom, the Clerk will read.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Assembly Joint Resolution 11 by Assembly Member Ransom relative to disaster funding.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Ransom, you are recognized.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. Today I rise to present an Assembly Joint Resolution which will surely bring every party together and face zero opposition.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Assembly Joint Resolution 11, which is a nonpartisan effort to urge President of the United States and Congress to restore funding to FEMA's Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities grant program to avoid predictable, costly and preventable disasters.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    The cancellation of the approved BRIC Program Hazard Mitigation Project applications from fiscal years 2020 to 2023 retroactively harms communities and leaves Californians vulnerable to disasters that could otherwise be prevented.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Eliminating these critical projects will result in a divestment of over $870 million of federal funding and will disrupt hundreds of millions of dollars in local, state and private sector matching funds. This decision will have severe consequences for our local communities that are counting on the funds to reduce the impact of our natural disasters.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    As example, Napa County will lose over $35 million. Mendocino County will lose up to $37.8 million. Santa Cruz County will lose $11.2 million for wildfire mitigation projects. The list goes on with San Bernardino county losing over $100 million and the City of Riverbank losing $50 million for various water projects.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    This divestment disproportionately affects the the Central Valley, Southern California and our rural communities. Additionally, the California Earthquake Authority will lose over $40 million allocated for seismic retrofits in urban areas. The Paradise Irrigation District is also set to lose $37.5 million for critical safety improvements to the Magalia Dam.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    This is at a time when we are already working really hard to fill critical prevention gaps and we cannot afford to be handicapped by the cancellation of pre designated funding.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    With that I thankfully appreciate everyone's support and respectfully ask for your aye vote in adopting this resolution and I request that we open the first roll for co authors.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assembly Member Ransom. Assembly Member Rogers, you are recognized.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    Thanks much. Mr. Speaker, I I rise in support of AJR 11 and I want to thank my colleague for not just bringing this resolution but really using her chairship to be able to highlight some of these impacts that will have on California.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    As was mentioned in my district, 37 million in projects to rebuild Santa Rosa and Sonoma county in a stronger and more resilient manner. Gone. 37.8 million from Mendocino County Gone. 6 million from Healdsburg Gone. 11.5 million from the Karuk Tribe to create a Fire Adaptive Reuse center that that focuses on indigenous trainings for fire management. Gone.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    And then outside of my district but was mentioned 35 million from the County of Napa which is the majority leaders district. But as we oftentimes say in Sonoma county we don't typically start the fires. They just find their way towards us because of the top topography and the way that the wind blows.

  • Chris Rogers

    Legislator

    It highlights that this isn't just one offs from each of these communities but really creating an atmosphere where in which we are all less safe. And I want to thank my colleague for highlighting that fact and urge an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assembly Member Rogers. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Ransom, do you wish to close?

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Yes Mr. Speaker, as I previously mentioned this, these are funds that were previously allocated to and this disproportionately affects the Central Valley, Southern California and our rural communities. This is at a time where we need to be proactive, responsive and effective to how we handle our natural disasters.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    It is important that we have our voices heard that we reach out across the aisle at the federal level to the President and to our friends in Congress and ask for their support in keeping our communities safe. With that I again ask for it to be open for co authors and for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assembly Member Ransom. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will Open the roll. Members. This is for co authors. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. There are 62 co authors added without objection.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We'll now move to a voice vote on the resolution. I stand corrected. This is a joint resolution. We cannot have a voice vote. Clerk will now open the roll on the resolution. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Thank you, Madam Clerk. All Members vote who desire to vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes. 65. No 0. The resolution is adopted. Moving on to file item 56, AB 46 by Assembly Member Nguyen. Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 46 by Assembly Member Nguyen and others and accolades to diversion.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Nguyen, you are recognized.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I rise today to ask for your support for AB46, which restores judicial discretion in mental health diversion cases. This Bill has bipartisan support and passed Assembly Public Safety Committee with no no votes.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Today, if a defendant meets certain clinical criteria, the court is required to to grant diversion even when the judge believes that individual possesses a serious risk to public safety. AB46 does not take away access to treatment. It does not roll back diversion.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    What it does is allows judges to weigh all the facts, including the severity of the offense, the risk to the community and the rights of the victim. In People v. Whitmill, the Court of Appeal made it clear the law ties judges hands even when public safety is at stake.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    AB46 corrects that; it allows courts to deny diversion when treatment in the community would endanger others. We need a justice system that supports rehabilitation, but not at the expense of safety, truth or accountability. Colleagues, this is about balance. It's about trusting our courts to use their discretion to do what's right.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    With that, I ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Summary Member Nguyen. Assembly Member Elhawary, you are recognized.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today in respectful opposition to AB46, authored by my colleague from Sacramento. California is in the midst of a mental health crisis. Now more than ever, we must ensure that our policies support, not hinder, access to care and justice for those experiencing mental illness.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    This Bill raises the burden of proof for individuals, excuse me, seeking diversion, making it significantly more difficult for those with mental health conditions to qualify. Many Californians, especially those from underserved communities, do not have the privilege of timely or formal diagnoses.

  • Sade Elhawary

    Legislator

    AB46 risks denying these individuals the opportunity for diversion programs that are better and adept at lowering recidivism. This Bill sets a troubling precedent, one that may contribute to the further criminalization of mental illness and the unnecessary incarceration of vulnerable individuals. For these reasons, I must oppose AB46 and ask my colleagues to consider doing the same. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Elhawary. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assembly Member Nguyen, do you wish to close?

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank my colleague for sharing her concerns. And I just want to clarify that this doesn't take away the diversion program by any means at all. It's really just giving the discretion for the judges to do what they were elected to do or appointed to do.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    And that is to ensure that, taking a look at everything, ensuring that if there is a threat to the public that the judge can deny the mental health diversion program. That's all it does. It's putting this back into the court system. It's not necessarily taking anything away other than if there is a serious threat.

  • Stephanie Nguyen

    Legislator

    And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Nguyen. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 46 no's 7. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Going to pass and retain on file item 57 brings us to file item number 58, AB260 by our majority leader. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 260 by Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry and others relating to sexual and reproductive health care.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members. Members, AB 260 is an important proposal to protect safe and legal reproductive health here; health care here in California. Access to reproductive health care, including abortion, continues to be under threat across the country.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Since the Dobbs decision, a other states have been restricting or banning abortion care and people's ability to make decisions over their own bodies. The Federal Government has already made cuts to critical funding for family planning in an effort to further restrict the ability of states to provide essential health care.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Just last week, the U.S. Health and Human Services secretary said he's directed the FDA to reevaluate its approval of safe abortion medications. AB 260 is response to these very real threats. It protects access to medication abortion here in California. Specifically mifepristone, a common and safe medication abortion drug first approved by the FDA in 2000. Yes, that would be 25 years ago.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Medication abortion is the least invasive option for abortion care based on decades of FDA research. Access to the full scope of reproductive health care is critical for Californians and their health care providers so they can make decisions that are best for their health and the health of their families.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    This is especially true for people living in areas with few providers or those who have to travel long distances to get care. This Bill further helps Californians in rural and underserved areas by expanding access to telehealth services, making sure they have access to safe, reliable, remote health care.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    This Bill also provides critical protection for California for medical professionals, pharmacies and hospitals, helping their patients get the health care they need. Given the Federal Government's intentions to roll back access and funding for reproductive health care, it is more important than ever that we stand strong in protecting the rights of Californians and their health care providers.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    AB 260 helps us do just that. It it protects patients, providers and facilities while expanding access through telehealth. Members, please join me in supporting this proactive step to make sure our people can keep accessing reproductive care regardless of changes in the federal level.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes ayes 57 no's 10. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Moving on to file item 59 AB 290 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 290 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan and others and I play into insurance.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, you are recognized.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    I'm proud to rise to present AB 290 a very simple Bill that helps people like me who have ended up on California's Fair plan use it in a more consumer friendly fashion so it allows for simple auto pay on the Fair Plan so that people are not kicked off the Fair Plan in which case they either have an incident and have no coverage or their premiums get tripled if they get kicked off for failure to pay and have to go back on.

  • Rebecca Bauer-Kahan

    Legislator

    And so this Bill is critically important the Californians living in communities like mine that are not voluntarily but must be on the Fair plan and making sure it works for them. With that I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assembly Member Bauer Cahan. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes aye 70 no 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file item 60, 61, 62, that gets us to file item 63, AB 445 by our majority leader. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 445 by Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry accolades alcoholic beverages.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Madam Majority leader, you are recognized.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, this is a very important district Bill for Colusa County, a rural part of my district. Under the current licensing system, Colusa County hasn't qualified for any new alcoholic beverage licenses for over 20 years.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    As a result, the demand exceeds the availability of licenses in the county and small businesses are forced to pay up to $400,000 for licenses. This Bill will grant Colusa County 10 on sale liquor licenses to support local economic development empower small community rooted businesses.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam majority leader. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes aye 68. No 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file item 64 to 67. That brings us to file item 68, AB 609 by Assembly Member Wicks. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 609 by Assembly Member Wicks and others. Accolades to environmental quality.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Wicks, you are recognized.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I am proud to present AB 609 today, which is part of my fast track housing package that we put together at the end of a very exhaustive deliberative process that I did, a Select Committee on permitting reform, which started about two years ago.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    And what we were really intending to do in that Select Committee is try to understand why it's so damn hard to build anything in California, not just housing, but our renewable energy projects and everything else. We did about four hearings. Many of you were part of that. We had over 100 interviews.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    And what we determined in the course of that process is along with the Little Hoover Commission as well as every Governor since this law has been signed into effect, is that we do need reforms around the California Environmental Quality Act. Now, CEQA, as it's known, has been a really important landmark law in our state.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    It has created clean air, it has protected our open space, it has really served our needs. However, it has also become problematic when it comes to building housing. We know that CEQA is used over and over and over again to delay much needed housing projects.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    We know that it can be harmful to what our communities desperately need, which is housing. So how Does CEQA hurt these projects? Well, one, CEQA does not distinguish between good things for the environment and things that are not so great for the environment.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    So, for instance, CEQA is used at the same level for stopping fracking as it is for multifamily housing for our teachers and our nurses who desperately need the housing in our communities. We also know that CEQA is incredibly redundant. CEQA is required already on the General plan, on area plans, on specific plans.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    And even when all of those thresholds have been met and all those rules and regulations have been passed through and understood by the developer, they still have to go through CEQA at the individual project level. So it's incredibly redundant, which ends up costing a lot of money and delays in order to get the housing that we need.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    We also know that CEQA is very easy to weaponize. For a nominal fee, anyone can challenge the validity of a CEQA analysis for years and years and years and years.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    And we know that then when a project is stopped on a piece of land because of CEQA, no one else picks up the mantle to try to develop on that land. And so we have a lot of empty vacant lots that are never going to get repurposed for what we need.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    So this creates a major affordability issue in our state. Right. It's incredibly expensive to live here. The effect of this is that we have 200,000 folks experiencing homelessness in California, is that we have some of the lowest homeownership rates in the country, 49th out of 50th.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    It's that we're 2.5 million homes shy of where we need to be in this state. And we need to have a really honest conversation about why this is. It is on us. We have created the regulatory environment that has led us to where we are now.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Many of those laws have been well intended, and I understand where that comes from. The good news is we can fix this, and we've started to do that. If you look at what we've done around ADUs, we've made it a lot easier to build ADUs. And guess what? We have more ADUs in California. Right?

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    We've started to, to turn the tides on this. But this Bill that you will be voting on today, I think represents one of the biggest, most important seismic changes, structural changes on the issue of housing in our state.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    And as someone who's been in this house now for seven years trying to push this boulder up the hill, I'm excited to be joined by many enthusiastic freshmen who are co authors and excited about this legislation. And as well as some of our veterans who are on the Committee who've been pushing for it as well.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Now, I also want to let you know, some of you, I think, might think this Bill is scary, you know, and it represents too big of a shift in housing policy in California. Well, take comfort in the fact that cities can still, you know, ensure that the area has to be zoned for housing.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    It has to be zoned in order to qualify. Right. That cities can still do inclusionary zoning to require affordability requirements for the housing. You know, this doesn't touch height limits or the other things that cities have the tools in their toolbox. It just says, if this project meets all these needs, then why shouldn't we build it faster?

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Because I can tell you, I have teachers who live in, who grew up in Oakland, who want to teach in Oakland. And the realtors tell them, drive till you qualify. Drive out to Tracy and Stockton and keep going where you can afford to live, because you can't afford to live in Oakland anymore.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Teachers there can't afford to live there. I know my colleague from Oakland knows that. But if we make it easier to build there, I want those folks to live there. Because also, our climate change policy is our housing and transportation policy. When they say drive till you qualify, that means people are in their cars four hours a day.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    30 seconds.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    It's not good for them. It's not good for the communities in which they're working. It's not good for the communities in which they're living. So I present to you today a pretty simple Bill that basically just says, we want housing in California. So that is what you are ultimately voting on today. And with that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Wicks. Members, a subtle reminder that brevity is key. We have 14 more bills to get through, and we have subcommittees that are meeting immediately upon adjournment. With that, Assembly Member Ortega, you are recognized.

  • Liz Ortega

    Legislator

    Members, I rise and support AB 609. And while I will support today's Bill, I have strong concerns that there are no labor protections or minimum affordable unit requirements. We cannot use the housing crisis as a reason to build housing with no minimum labor standards or requirements for affordable units.

  • Liz Ortega

    Legislator

    I trust that the author will continue conversations with the opposition to address these concerns. I also encourage the author to consider streamlining language that will help with some of the affordable housing that we have sitting vacant for six months to two years because they cannot be connected to the grid.

  • Liz Ortega

    Legislator

    For those reasons, I support this bill today.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ortega. Assemblymember Harabedian, you are recognized.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I want to thank the author. I am one of those freshmen legislators who is a co author and is proud to support this bill. California is in a generational housing crisis. We all know that. And it gets worse every year.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    We haven't kept up to our housing starts and none of our communities are doing enough. Some of our communities are doing more than others, but none of us are doing enough. Every year it gets worse. The consequences are dire. Homelessness gets worse. Our families are priced out.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    Young people who we grew up with are forced to move out of state. And that isn't a result that any of us want. We don't want it for our kids, for our grandkids.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    And I think why so many of us who are new here are so adamant about this is because we have watched for years as many, like the author, the Member from Oakland, have fought so hard on this issue. But many have not fought. And I think that many of us in this new class are ready to fight.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    And we're ready to fight for years until we get it right. So why is this such a good Bill? Well, first, it's simple. It says if there is a lot that is clean and safe and surrounded by development, you can build housing on that rather than being drug into court to litigate a CEQA lawsuit for years.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    And make no mistake, the threat of a CEQA lawsuit will kill a project. Many folks here will say, well look, there aren't that many CEQA lawsuits that are filed on these types of projects. Well, of course many aren't filed because all you have to do is say, I will file and the developers will go away.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    Secondly, for all the originalists in this house, anyone who actually cares about the intent of a law that is passed on any level, CEQA is never meant for projects like this, for housing projects, for those in need, but for housing Projects. Generally, CEQA is meant for public projects, not private projects.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    Anyone who wants to go and look at the original law can see that we have court made law. Many of my friends on both sides of the aisle will rail against court made law. Rogue judges all the time. This is one of the worst examples of it.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    Lastly, for the environmentalists in this house, 80 of us, I hope everyone here recognizes and holds themselves out to be an environmentalist. Infill development is the most environmental friendly development of any kind. It reduces car trips. It allows us to work and live near each other. It creates thriving walkable communities. It fights climate change.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    So anyone who believes and says that they're an environmentalist would say yes to 609. It's very clear. Any study, any data, any evidence will support this Bill on the environmental side. And I will tell you if we are going to solve this problem. It's about restoring balance.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    The balance is not there because people are weaponizing CEQA for good housing projects. And I will not sit back and watch my kids and your kids and our grandkids be left out to dry because of a flawed regulatory system. So I strongly encourage an Aye vote for all those reasons.

  • John Harabedian

    Legislator

    And I hope to see many of you who haven't been there before there today. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Harabedian and Assemblymember Hoover, you are recognized.

  • Josh Hoover

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues, I rise as a co author of this important legislation. I want to make it clear that this is a bipartisan priority in California to reduce the cost of housing. How do we reduce the cost of housing? We bring down the cost by increasing the supply of our housing.

  • Josh Hoover

    Legislator

    And we increase supply and reduce these costs by making it easier to build in California. I am very grateful for this very important piece of legislation from my colleague from Oakland. And I respectfully asked for an Aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Hoover, Assemblymember Haney, you are recognized.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members. We have the lowest homeownership rates, some of the highest rent burdens, some of the highest home prices, and the most homeless people in the entire country. We have that situation because frankly, we have not built enough homes in California. We have a massive home shortage.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    And as you've heard from folks already, I want to thank my colleague from Oakland. The most important thing that we can do is build faster where we know it is safe to build. And infill development is the best way for us to do this. We have to make it cheaper, faster and more straightforward. Right now.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    CEQA, a law that has many good uses is being weaponized to stop one of the most important solutions to the affordability and and climate challenges we are facing, which is faster and easier infill development. I saw it firsthand in my district. There was a project on a valet parking lot, a Nordstrom's valet parking lot.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Union labor, 500 units, 25% affordable, right one block away from Market street, right down the street from BART station. And it was stopped on CEQA grounds by the Board of Supervisors, despite the fact that our city said there was no CEQA issue. This is happening all over our state.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    It's stopping housing we desperately need and it's stopping this housing from even being proposed or pursued because people know these lawsuits are coming. This is a solution. Thank you to my colleague and all the authors. And as the housing chair respectfully asked for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Haney, Assemblymember Demaio, you are recognized.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I absolutely agree with so many of the sentiments and remarks made by my colleagues on both sides of the aisle on CEQA. And we've had more than 25 years of a rising chorus, a growing chorus of people who have basically said CEQA is a sham, CEQA has failed.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I can't think of many projects that have been improved by CEQA. I mean, if you put pen to paper in recent years, I don't think you could find many good environmental impacts from CEQA. And frankly, you probably find more damage to the environment from CEQA.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I appreciate the fact that many of my colleagues have acknowledged that CEQA has been weaponized against Californians not for the purpose of protecting the environment, but for lining pockets for advancing agendas, which has never been. CEQA was never intended for many of the ends that have been achieved through these abusive lawsuits.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    In this body, we have a number of pieces of legislation that would reform ceqa. I support many of these as I do this bill today. But we're nibbling around the edges. And for every one bill that's proposed, there's a mountain of arguments, well, if we do this, what's going to happen here? And it could be misconstrued.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    It could be misused by some actor somewhere out there. Because the reality is CEQA has allowed bad actors to do bad things and we can't hold them accountable because if they are able to prevail on just one comma, one semicolon that's wrong or missed, they get a payday.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    They profit from these frivolous lawsuits, typically trying to advance an agenda. And they always agree that they'll drop the lawsuit. Not for an improvement in the environment. No, no, no, no, no. They will drop their lawsuit if they get, for their interest, a massive concession. Now, you know what?

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    You know what actually does get a quick CEQA exemption? Government projects. NFL stadiums. Boy, they get their CEQA exemptions full stock, but it's the small medium projects that are crushed. And as my colleagues have acknowledged, it's having a major impact on the cost of living for all Californians because they cannot afford housing.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    So while I will support this bill today, and I will likely vote in favor of a variety of CEQA reforms in the coming months and years, and many of you will continue to struggle trying to advance CEQA reform, let me leave you with a provocative idea. Maybe we need to stop nibbling around the edges.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Maybe we should just leave CEQA as is. But maybe we should limit the people who are able to use CEQA to people who can actually be held accountable by the people, the voters.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Why not amend CEQA to stipulate that only an elected District Attorney for a county for a period of just five years, for the next five years, that only the elected District Attorney may observe a detriment to the environment and bring a CEQA case. Now, I'm just asking it for five years.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We could take all these wonderful bills and kind of set them aside and give some input to the district attorneys.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    But if you had one person accountable every time, they either didn't bring a CEQA lawsuit for good cause or they brought a frivolous lawsuit that increased the cost and delayed the project, perhaps we might get better housing outcomes. I know that this is not the subject of today's bill.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I'm rising simply to state that maybe the small nibbling around the edges won't get us to where we need to be faster.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    30 seconds.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I will ask for an Aye vote on AB609. Nonetheless.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Demaio, Assemblymember Tangipa, you are recognized.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Yes. I just want to rise and say thank you to the author from Oakland. As the youngest Member of this legislative body, this is a conversation I have had with every single one of my friends who feel like the American dream of owning a home here in California is unattainable.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    This is something that I've made a passion of mine in my real estate business, helping first time home buyers, low income individuals and and myself who less than 10 years ago was homeless, sleeping on my teammate's couch.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    This is something that I am proud to support and just want to thank everybody that takes thiss up, putting a lot of the Californians, the next generation, first in a work and an effort to make housing affordable. Again, thank you. And I ask for your Aye on this.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembler Tangipa. Assemblymember Bennett, you are recognized.

  • Steve Bennett

    Legislator

    Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. California needs a good, strong CEQA. And the way to keep CEQA strong is to make sure we're trying to apply it in the most appropriate places, and we're not applying it where it's not appropriate.

  • Steve Bennett

    Legislator

    And I think the author has done an excellent job of trying to narrow this down to infill projects, which is the focus and the major solution for us in California.

  • Steve Bennett

    Legislator

    It's infill projects that are going to give us the most environmentally sensitive projects and will also help keep CEQA strong because you won't increase frustration with CEQA over stopping, inappropriately stopping some infill projects. So. So with that, I encourage an Aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Bennett. Assemblymember Patterson, you are recognized.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Great. Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of this bill. One of the provisions of the bill, it's very. It is a narrowed bill and I support it. And I would definitely support a more broad bill.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    But one of the critical elements of this bill requires that the project is consistent with applicable General plan and zoning ordinances. The reason why that's important is because in order to get a general plan in zoning, you already have to have prepared a secret document that's been approved by the local agencies and probably already litigated.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    And so why are we requiring a developer to do an additional CEQA document on top of a project that has already had a CEQA document? So I appreciate that this is a very narrow bill.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    Just boggles my mind that a lot of times developers are doing additional CEQA documents just to prevent lawsuits, but then they get sued anyways. So we really. This could be a much more.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    At some point, hopefully we'll have a much more broad solution to this, that if something is consistent with the general plan, the community has already opined on it, the elected officials have already opined on it that something should be built in a particular area.

  • Joe Patterson

    Legislator

    And if something's consistent with that, why are we requiring them to do yet another CEQA document? So this is a step in the right direction and I look forward to supporting it. Kind of surprised I'm not a co author, but maybe we'll fix that in the future. With that, I ask for an Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Patterson. Assembly Member Ransom, you are recognized.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    Yes. Mr. Speaker, very briefly, I would like to add my support to Assembly Bill 6. For those of you who know me, you know that I served on a planning Commission longer than I served in the City Council.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    I would like to say that when it comes to this bill it addresses the issue of the moving target that sometimes takes place with CEQA. It also addresses situations where we have the not in my backyard communities that don't want to see infill projects, don't want to see additional buildings.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    So I appreciate that this bill helps us deliver on our promise to addressing the housing crisis in our community. It helps me address, you know my children and their generation giving more opportunities for housing.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    This also addresses our environmental impacts as we will see more info projects that will help cut down on vehicle vehicle miles traveled helps with things like Transit Oriented Development. These are all things that unfortunately sometimes folks try to oppose in our communities as we are trying to solve problems.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    And and yes while we know we have to do something at large in regards to ceqa, I appreciate this common sense approach that deals with what we know we can do because as we you know sometimes we put laws in place and we look back and say we could do better.

  • Rhodesia Ransom

    Legislator

    So when we know better we do better. And this is a do better bill. So I do appreciate Assemblymember from Oakland for bringing this bill and with that I strongly ask for your support. I support.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Ransom. Assemblymember Bryan, you are recognized.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker and colleagues, I rise in support of AB 609. First I just want to address a couple quick things that have been said. CECO has improved many projects. The UC Davis extension which required affordable housing and job training. It protected school children and public health in South Fresno.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Reduced air and noise pollution in our ports and Longbo and Long Beach while boosting economic productivity at spurred climate action plans in Stockton and many other places. It is very important that California protect the proper use of our CEQA laws.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    CEL was designed, passed and implemented for the purpose of making sure that the short sided politics of the day don't lead to lasting consequences for future generations that we can't roll back on. That is important and that is worth defending.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    I also want to give my colleague from Piedmont a credit for bringing this measure through this Committee and the Members of the Natural Resource Committee.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Make no mistake, this is the most ambitious housing bill to ever come through the Assembly Natural Resource Committee and was able to do that because of the courage of the Members on the Committee to recognize the intersection of the need to protect our environment, the need to make sure that California is sustainable for future generations and the need to meet the urgency of that our housing crisis demands.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    And I want to be clear, this bill is not perfect. Nothing transformative is. And I think the author knows that as well. But it does strike at one of the most pressing issues we're dealing with. We are millions of units behind, and we have to catch up.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    I want to touch on something some of my colleagues have said earlier. This bill will not answer all of our housing problems. We don't just have low homeownership rates. Black folks in California have the lowest home ownership rates. We're not just rent burdened. Black folks in California are the highest rent burden.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    We're not just the state with the highest unhoused population. We have the most black people in the country sleeping on our streets. This Bill will not solve that. It will not also solve the commodification of housing as a good to be traded, bought and sold instead of as the human right that it should be for people.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Those are some of the things that we all have to work on together. And I know the author shares those goals. But this is an incredibly important bill, and it wouldn't be here without your courage. And I look forward to supporting it here on the floor today.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Bryan. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Wicks, would you like to close?

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Just. I want to thank everyone for the robust conversation and the support on this bill from a wide variety of political spectrums here. I want to thank both the Housing chair and the Natural Resources Chair for their leadership in this space because it hasn't been easy.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    I would also note that I'm from Oakland and not Piedmont, but, you know, and I hear some of the concerns that were raised as well from some of my other colleagues. I'm committed to getting this right. This is the top issue for me, for many of us. I know we all go back to our districts.

  • Buffy Wicks

    Legislator

    Every single one of us goes back to our districts every weekend. And what do we hear about housing, homelessness, mortgages, all the things we can't afford. So I'm honored to be working on this. I welcome continued conversation. And with that, I would respectfully ask for an Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Wicks. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Aye, 63. No, 0. The measure passes pass and retain on file.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Item 69 gets us to file item number 70 A.B. 645 by Assemblymember Carrillo.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 645 by Assembly Member Carrillo and others, an act relating to emergency medical services.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Carrillo, you are recognized.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and members. I rise to present Assembly Bill 645. This bill seeks to improve emergency medical services by requiring EMS dispatchers to complete emergency medical dispatch training. Dispatchers are often the first of the first responders, the first voice a person hears from a life or dead emergency.

  • Juan Carrillo

    Legislator

    EMD trained dispatchers can talk to people through how to perform life-saving steps like CPR and the Heimlich maneuver. As the saying goes, seconds saves lives and the steps that are taken while waiting for emergency responders is very often the difference between life and death. I also want to acknowledge to recognize that May 18th through the 24th is EMS Week, and with that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Carrillo. All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Ayes: 60; noes: zero. The measure passes. We're going to pass and retain on File Item 71 through 75; gets us to File Item Number 76: AB 828 by Assembly Member Mark Gonzalez.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 828 by Assembly Member Mark Gonzalez an act relating to alcoholic beverages.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Gonzalez, you are recognized.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    As we approach happy hour, our rise to present AB 828 which will create a new original neighborhood Restricted special on Sale General Alcohol License and allow the ABC up to 12 of these licenses per year until a total of 40 have been issued to restaurants located within designated census tracts in the great City of Los Angeles.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    The current state licensing structure is too expensive for small business in Los Angeles and fails to consider the size and the scale of LA's tourism economy since 2020. Tourism had steadily increased in 2023. LA welcomes 49.1 million visitors.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    These numbers will only grow as LA prepares to host major national international events including the 2026 FIFA World Cup, 2026 NBA All Star Game, the 2026 US Women's Open and the 2028 Olympic A Paralympic Games. This bill will offer much needed relief to restaurants and is more than a policy. It's a promise.

  • Mark Gonzalez

    Legislator

    It's a promise to support economic development and provide small businesses, especially minority owned restaurants and in historic neighborhoods like Koreatown, Little Tokyo, Chinatown, historic Filipino Town, PICO Union and Boyle Heights. It's a promise that the flavors, the stories and the dreams will not only endure, but flourish. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assemblymember Gonzalez. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Aye, 67. No, 0. The measure passes. Going to pass and retain on file.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Item 77 gets us to file. Item 78. AB881 by Assembly Member Petrie Norris.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 881 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris and others, an act relating to public resources.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Petrie-Norris, you're recognized.

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, proud to present AB 881, a bill that will enable the safe deployment of carbon pipelines in California. I've worked with many of you and many of you know my interest in carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies. These technologies are absolutely pivotal for California to achieve our climate targets both here and around the globe.

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    Recognizing the importance of carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies, in 2022, the Legislature passed a bill, SB 905, that established a policy framework for carbon capture in California. At that time, the federal government was in the midst of developing federal regulations for pipeline safety, and so we included as part of that measure a moratorium on carbon pipelines in California until the Feds could complete that work.

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    In January of this year, the Biden Administration released draft guidelines for carbon dioxide pipeline safety. However, three days later, the Trump Administration was inaugurated and that work was paused and has been paused indefinitely.

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    So we find ourselves in an uncertain position and in a bit of limbo, so one thing really is clear: that at this point it is important for California to take our destiny in our own hands and to develop safety guidelines here in California to enable these important technologies to succeed here in California.

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    So AB 881 picks up where the federal administration left off to enable the safe deployment of carbon pipelines here in California, leverage billions of dollars in potential federal support for these projects and initiatives, and in the process, we also have the opportunity to create thousands of good, high-paying jobs in this emerging sector. So appreciate the support I've had of my many co-authors and respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Petrie-Norris. Leader Gallagher, you are recognized.

  • James Gallagher

    Legislator

    Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Speaker and members. I rise in support of AB 881 and appreciate my colleague for bringing this bill forward. I also have talked a lot about how there is a better path forward for us in meeting our climate goals and I believe carbon capture technology is one of those things, and we need to further develop that, and part of that is updating and having these new guidelines with regard to pipelines and definition and matching that up with federal definitions so that we can continue this work.

  • James Gallagher

    Legislator

    This will allow us to meet emissions goals, but do it in an affordable way, and that should be a key thing that we are, that we are working on as a body. There's other things we should be talking about, too--hydrogen and other things that can help us meet those goals but do it in a more affordable way, but this is definitely one of them and so I rise in support.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Leader Gallagher. Assembly Member Bennett, you are recognized.

  • Steve Bennett

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in support of this bill. Wherever you stand on the issue of carbon capture, I think it's most important to realize that we should be in control of the regulations dealing with carbon pipelines, not the federal government, and right now, without this legislation, we are dependent upon the federal government, and if they come in, it will be much more difficult for us to exercise the control we should have on these pipelines. So I applaud the author and recommend an aye vote. Thank you very much.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Bennett. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assembly Member Petrie-Norris, would you like to close?

  • Cottie Petrie-Norris

    Legislator

    Well, thank you to my colleagues for your statements in support. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Petrie-Norris. All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll; tally the votes. Ayes: 64; no: zero. The measure passes. Going to pass and retain on File Item 79. That brings us to File Item Number 80: AB 904 by our Majority Leader.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 904 by Assemblymember Aguiar-Curry and accolade in the child care services.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members California's child care subsidy program is a correct critical support for working families. But under current law, families can lose access to subsidized care due to gaps in the eligibility rules.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    If a parent is not actively working or in training, they can lose their care even if they are on pregnancy leave or caring for a family member or searching for employment. This bill will clarify child care eligibility rules to better support families when they are taking family leave or searching for employment.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    It also reduces bureaucratic barriers and making it easier for parents to verify their status and maintain their child care during these important times. By improving eligibility and reducing paperwork, AB904 will reduce disruptions for working families and provide stability for our children. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Eyes 54. noes 4. The measure passes. Moving to file item number 81.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    AB 920 by Assembly Member Coloza. The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 920 by Assembly Member Coloza and others in act relating to housing.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Coloza, you are recognized.

  • Jessica Caloza

    Legislator

    Good evening, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. I rise to present AB920, a bill that will streamline housing approvals in California by creating a centralized application portal to track housing projects in cities and counties with over 150,000 residents. Disjointed permitting systems and processes delay projects, drive up costs, and ultimately increase housing prices.

  • Jessica Caloza

    Legislator

    AB920 directly responds to a lack of transparency in the permitting process by requiring local governments to offer a centralized application portal that allows applicants to track and manage their permits all in one place. Several cities across California already have similar portals in place.

  • Jessica Caloza

    Legislator

    This is a cost conscious reform that delivers real value without adding new burdens to the state. As lawmakers, we have a responsibility to reduce unnecessary delays in the housing approval process. Not just to help builders, but to deliver homes faster for Californians who desperately need them.

  • Jessica Caloza

    Legislator

    I hope you'll join me in being part of the solution for our housing crisis and support AB920. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Coloza. Assemblymember Tangipa, you're recognized.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    I just wanted to rise and thank the author for bringing this forward. We've had many conversations about considering some of the smaller counties that can't always do a lot of what the state asked for and respectfully asked for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you. Assembly Member Tangipa, seeing and hearing no further debate. Do you wish to close? Ms. Cloza?

  • Jessica Caloza

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you to my colleague for your support. It has received bipartisan and unanimous support in the Committee process. I respectfully ask my colleagues for Aye vote today.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Coloza. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 66. No, 0. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file items 8283 that gets us to file item 84, AB930 by assemblymember Ward.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 930 by Assembly Member Ward an act relating to elections.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Ward, you are recognized.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB930 modernizes California's election code to reflect how people actually vote. Today I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ward. Assemblymember Demaio, you were recognized.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    Mr. Speaker, I rise in strong opposition to AB930. It does not modernize the way people vote. It adds the ability for non citizens to serve as recount board Members. I'm not sure why a non citizen should have any business serving on a board overseeing a U.S. election. That's not how people vote in America.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I don't, I don't know where you hang out, but it's not where people vote how most people vote that I talk to on both sides of the aisle.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Mr. Demaio, Mr. Demaio, just a moment. Mr. Berman, state your point of order please.

  • Marc Berman

    Legislator

    I asked my colleague from San Diego not to hurl insults at fellow Assembly Members on the Assembly floor.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Mr. Excuse me, Mr. Demaio. Mr. Berman, your point is well taken. Mr. Demaio, please use decorum.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I think most Californians would wonder how it can be a modern election if non citizens are serving on an election board overseeing the election. That's not an insult, that's common sense.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    I think it would be insulting to suggest that Californians wouldn't have grave concerns about that and perhaps that's why we see so many election related measures passed by this body that are unhinged from popular points of view in this state. But secondly, this bill also extends the amount of time for ballots to be returned in an election.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    We already are the laughing stock of the world when it comes to counting ballots. Most third world countries have something called an election day, not an election month. We're actually on track to having an election quarter here in California because our elections actually start 30 days prior to election day through mail in ballots.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    So a month out people can vote and then of course they are able to count ballots for 30 days after an election. That's a 60 day period. What this Bill would do is it would allow ballots to be returned up to seven days after, after election day. That only sows the seeds of doubt.

  • Carl DeMaio

    Legislator

    It undermines public trust and confidence in our democracy when ballots mysteriously appear after election day. So I urge this body, let's put the health of our democracy first. Let's do everything we can to restore public trust and confidence in our democracy. This is not the way to do it. I urge a no vote on AB 930.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Demaio seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Ward, would you like to close?

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The hour is late and I tried. But I would like to respond to some of the comments that were made on the floor because I believe there's some disinformation about what this bill does. First of all, it does two things.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    It makes sure that any ballot that was postmarked by election Day, that voter voted by election day. They put it in the postmail by election day. It got stamped by election day that if it is received by the registrar within seven days, if that vote is counted.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    And this is particularly important for our overseas service members who as we know, have to mail that back into the registrars here in their home counties. And unfortunately, somebody has been slowing down the U.S. postal Service. Gee, I wonder who that is.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    So I'm here to be able to stand up for them to make sure that their vote is counted as well. And then secondly, only voters, registered voters can participate in many of the programs. That was referred to by the first series of comments from my colleague of San Diego. Registered voters, of course, are citizens.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    So it is blasphemy to say otherwise. All these points have been debated in Committee and this bill has the support of the California Association of Clerks and Election Officials. I respectfully request your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Ward. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 51. No, 16. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file items 85 through 87. Brings us to file item 88, AB8. Excuse me. AB987 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 987 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins and others, an act relating to vehicles.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Sharp-Collins, you are recognized.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Thank you. Thank you once again, Mr. Speaker. AB 987 protects Californians against the growing issue of unreasonable tow fees. While California leads in many consumer protections, there's a glaring gap in protections against unreasonable tow fees that must be addressed.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Every day, hardworking Californians face the risk of having their vehicles towed, often in situations that is beyond their control. Now, I want you to imagine having your car towed during a holiday and being charged excessive fees or paying storage fees for days when the facility is not open. These practices aren't just unfair, they make it harder for everyday Californians.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    AB 987 takes a stand against those that are exploiting the overall practices by clearly defining what constituents' unreasonable tow fees are. It protects drivers during emergencies and natural disasters, prevents charging storage fees when facilities are closed, and eliminates excessive holiday surcharges. This isn't just about saving money.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    It's about protecting our most vulnerable residents who can least afford these unexpected costs. For many people, an unexpected tow can mean choosing between trying to either retrieve your vehicle and paying for your basic necessities. When working families cannot afford to retrieve their towed vehicles, we are creating barriers to their success and stability in our communities.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    So as we have made affordability one of our top priorities, let us take another step to making California more affordable and also protecting our residents. By supporting AB 987, we are standing up for consumer rights and ensuring that Californians aren't being exploited during their vulnerable moments. This bill strikes a fair balance.

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    It doesn't prevent the legitimate towing operations from doing their job, but it establishes reasonable limits that also protects our consumers. So let's please do what we can to pass AB 987 and protect drivers from predatory towing practices. So with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Sharp-Collins. Assembly Member Bryan, you are recognized.

  • Isaac Bryan

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question for the author. Is this in fact your first bill on the floor and does it help poor people? You can answer in your close.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Bryan. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assembly Member Sharp-Collins, do you wish to close?

  • Lashae Sharp-Collins

    Legislator

    Yes, I do. The answer is yes and yes. So once again, thank you all so much for allowing me to present my very first bill here on the floor, and I would like to note that this bill did receive bipartisan unanimous support, and with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll; tally the votes. Ayes: 68; no: 0. The measure passes. We're going to pass and retain on File Items 89 through 92. That brings us to File Item 93: AB 1103 by Assembly Member Ward. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1103 by Assembly Member Ward, an act relating to controlled substances.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Ward, you are recognized.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    Good evening, Mr. Speaker. AB 1103 expedites the state's review and approval of federally sanctioned drug trials and clinical research in California until January 2028.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    This includes clinical trials for evaluating psychedelic compounds to treat opioid use disorders, traumatic brain injury, ptsd, major depressive disorders and other mental health conditions, fueling the disproportionate increase in suicide among California veterans and daily rates of suicide among Californians generally.

  • Chris Ward

    Legislator

    The expedited review process responds to the state's approval process, delaying the commencement of vital clinical research in California and the effect of those delays on the ability of California institutes to compete for research and investment in talent. This Bill has received no no votes and I respectfully ask for your aye vote

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    thank you Assemblymember Ward all debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Tally the votes aye 68 no 0 the measure passes. We're going to pass and retain on file items 94,95 gets us to file item 96 AB 1190 by Assemblymember Haney. Clerk will read

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1190 by Assembly Member Haney and others an act related to the Department of Motor Vehicles.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Member Haney, you are recognized.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    Thank you Mr. Speaker. Tens of millions of Californians rely on DMV services to ensure that their vehicles are properly registered and taken care of.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    But unfortunately what is happening right now is that many of those Californians are going online and instead of going into the DMV to get those services googling California DMV or Title Transfer Car Registration and instead of finding themselves on the DMV website, they find themselves on another third party website that looks exactly like the DMV website that uses the same language, that uses the same fonts, and with little to no transparency.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    They find themselves doing the same process that they could get on the DMV through these third party websites, but doing so at a huge markup, sometimes $150 or more than the actual DMV fee.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    AB 1190 will stop these junk fees by capping what partners can charge at no more than 5% of the DMV rates and require clear disclosure and a direct link to the DMV site.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    If you are getting a service that the DMV provides, you should know you're getting it from them or from someone else and you should know that you can get it from the DMV, often at a cheaper rate. This is a process that is already required with car dealers and dismantlers by the DMV.

  • Matt Haney

    Legislator

    It simply extends a similar Standard to online partners. It is a straightforward consumer protection Bill and has gotten bipartisan support. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Haney. Seeing and hearing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 66, noes one. The measure passes. We're moving on to file item 97, AB 1220, by Assembly Member Arambula.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1220 by Assembly Member Arambula and accolade to Developmental Services.

  • Joaquin Arambula

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. Californians with developmental disabilities deserve the right to live independent and full lives. Assembly Bill 1220 would require our Regional Centers to document on their individual program plans all consumers, denials of services, notices of actions and appeals.

  • Joaquin Arambula

    Legislator

    It would also require the Department and Regional Centers to report on those notices of actions, denials and appeals on a yearly report. This enhanced oversight will allow us to reduce inequities and to strengthen public trust in our Developmental Services system. And I respectfully ask for. For an aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Rambula. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. I66, noes one. The measure passes. Moving on to file item number 98. AB 1303 by Assemblymember Valencia. Clerk will read

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1303 by Assemblymember Valencia and others. An act relating to communications.

  • Avelino Valencia

    Legislator

    Buenas noches, Gracias. Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 1303 aims to increase participation in the California Lifeline program by specifying that a Social Security number is not needed to qualify. This Bill is a Latino caucus party Bill. I respectfully asked for a yes vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Valencia. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes Ayes51 knows 12. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to pass and retain on file items 99 through 103. That brings us to file item 104. AB 1504 by Assemblymember Berman. Clerk will read

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1504 by Assembly Member Berman and act relating to healing arts.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Berman, you are recognized.

  • Marc Berman

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 1504 is the Sunset Bill for the California Massage Therapy Council this bill would reauthorize the existing council by an additional four years with additional reforms developed in collaboration with the Senate, the Council and other stakeholders through this sunset review process. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Berman. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Aye, 63. No, 0.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    The measure passes onto file item 105 AB3 1532 by the Committee on Communications and Conveyance. Clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1532 by the Committee on Communications and Conveyance and acclaim to the Public Utilities Commission and making it appropriation therefore.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Boerner, you are recognized.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Good evening, Mr. Speaker and members. Today I rise to present AB 1532, on behalf of the Committee on Communications and Conveyance. This committee omnibus bill includes several policies relevant to the jurisdiction of the CP--or the C&C Committee.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    First of all, this bill extends the funding authority for two existing programs: the Deaf and Disabled Communications program and the Transportation Network Company Access for All program. Both programs, administered by the California Public Utilities Commission, benefit disabled Californians with accessing telecommunications and wheelchair-accessible transportation.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    This bill does not increase any existing surcharges or consumer fees and is revenue-neutral. Lastly, this bill also includes two accountability measures for CPUC commissioners. This bill would require a CPUC commissioner to be available at the request of a legislative committee chair.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Unfortunately, over the last several years, the CPUC has refused to make the commissioners available when requested for oversight hearings. This bill would also require the CPUC to adopt rules governing commissioner attendance at meetings to encourage greater participation in the agency's own hearings. I respectfully ask for your aye vote on this bill.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assembly Member Boerner. All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll; tally the votes. Ayes: 59; noes: one. The measure passes. Members, we're going to be going back to File Item Number 19.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Which we passed on temporarily, that is AB 1071 by Assemblymember Kalra. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 1071 by Assembly Member Kara and accolades of Criminal procedure.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assemblymember Kalra, you are recognized.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 1071 makes several clarifying changes to the procedures for claims under the Racial justice act to ensure more uniform implementation. In 2020, the Legislature passed the RJA to address racial discrimination and bias in criminal proceedings across the state.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    However, despite cleanup legislation, there continue to be examples of procedural barriers that impede incarcerated individuals, attempts to raise legitimate RJA claims, and instances where the original intent of the RJA is not being followed.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    For example, although the RJA's threshold for appointing a lawyer is currently extremely low, many courts have applied the higher standards from ordinary post conviction habeas proceedings. This has denied incarcerated individuals access to counsel and the discovery materials needed to establish a claim leading to blanket denials, only a few substantive claims being heard.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    In another example, there have been cases where although there was a finding of an RJA violation, no remedy was imposed despite existing law mandating a remedy. AB 1071 directly responds to feedback from the courts and practitioners to ensure RJA claims are processed consistently across the state.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Specifically, this bill affirms the Legislature's intent to create a low threshold for the appointment of counsel, ensures access to discovery for petitioners, approve their claims, cleans up and improves processes for habeas petitions, explicitly allows a post conviction challenge through a motion and makes several changes to ensure a remedy is applied and provides more judicial discretion on the range of appropriate remedies when a violation is found.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Ultimately, AB 1071 will help ensure RJA cases are heard based on merit or rather than inadvertently stalled by procedure, and thereby make it much more efficient and reduce court costs by focusing on the underlying claims and not procedural hearings.

  • Ash Kalra

    Legislator

    Time and again, this bill builds upon the work of this Legislature to ensure that the communities that have disproportionately been harmed by racism, our courts, like our black, Latino, native and tribal communities, can access a fair system of justice. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you Assemblymember Kalra. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 46. No, 16. The measure passes.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    With that we are going to pass and retain on file item 106. I don't think I called that out. And that concludes the Assembly third reading. We're now moving on to the Senate third reading file. Item 107, SB 49 by Senator Grove. Presented by Assemblymember Tangipa. The clerk will read.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Senate Bill 49 by Senator Grove and others inactivating the tribal gaming and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Assembly Member Tangipa, you are recognized.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Today I rise to present SB 49 by Senator Grove. This bill would ratify amendments to the Tribal State Gaming Compact between the State of California and Big Sandy Rancheria of Western Mono Indians.

  • David Tangipa

    Legislator

    The new compact represents a critical step towards economic development and self sufficiency for the tribe and and will bring needed jobs and revenue to the surrounding community. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Thank you, Assemblymember Tangipa. Members, this is a 54 vote bill. This is a 54 vote bill. There is an urgency clause on it. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Aye, 69. No, 0.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    No: zero on the urgency. Ayes: 69; no: zero on the measure. The measure passes. Madam Majority Leader? Members, just a moment. Quorum call is not lifted. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized for your procedural motion.

  • Cecilia Aguiar-Curry

    Legislator

    I request unanimous consent to suspend Joint Rule 62a, the file notice requirement, to allow the subcommittee--the Budget Subcommittee Number One on Health to meet Wednesday, May 21 upon the call of the chair.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Without objection, such shall be the order. Members, we're going to be moving on to a vote on the Consent Calendar. Does any member wish to remove the item, any item from the Consent Calendar? Seeing and hearing none, the clerk will read the second day Consent Calendar.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Assembly Bill 334 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris, an act relating to transportation.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Clerk will open the roll on the Consent Calendar. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. This is the Consent Calendar. All members vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll; tally the votes. Ayes: 72; no: zero. The Consent Calendar is adopted.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Moving on to announcements. The following committees meet right now. Moment, members. Okay, members, pursuant to the motion that was just made--members, can I have decorum, please? Just a moment. The Budget Subcommittee on Health is now taking place on Wednesday per the motion that we just made. Is not meeting right now.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Budget Subcommittee Six on Public Safety in Capitol Room 447 is meeting right now upon adjournment. Session schedules as follows: Tuesday, May 20: check-in session, Wednesday, May 21: check-in session, Thursday, May 22: check-in session, Friday, May 23: floor session at 9:00 a.m. Seeing and hearing no further--

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Hold on. Time out. Pause again.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Pausing yet again.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    We're going to do some vote changes while we're waiting, folks. Quorum call has not been lifted. Members, can I have your attention, please? Members, only will take a second. Budget Subcommittee One on Health in Swing Space 1100 is meeting today right now in Swing Space 1100 and we'll meet additionally on Wednesday.

  • Josh Lowenthal

    Legislator

    Subcommittee Six is also meeting right now, Capitol Room 447. That's it. Seeing and hearing no further business, I'm ready to entertain a motion to adjourn. Madam Majority Aguiar-Curry moves and Ms. Rubio seconds that this House stands adjourned till Friday, May 23 at 9:00 a.m. Quorum call's lifted and we are adjourned.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Vote change, Boerner, AB 1220. No to aye.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Vote change, Assembly Member Boerner, Assembly Bill 1220. No to aye.

  • Blanca Rubio

    Legislator

    Vote change, Rubio, AB 1071 from an aye to a not voting.

  • Reading Clerk

    Person

    Vote change, Assembly Member Blanca Rubio, Assembly Bill 1071. Aye to not voting.

Currently Discussing

No Bills Identified