AB 287: Vehicle safety: recalls.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-27
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to include a specified recall disclosure statement with each vehicle registration renewal notice. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the licensed was issued has, among other things, violated provisions relating to issuance of licenses and certificates to manufacturers, transporters, and dealers.
This bill would also authorize the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to the above-mentioned persons upon determining that the person has violated any provision of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to include a specified recall disclosure statement with each vehicle registration renewal notice. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the licensed was issued has, among other things, violated provisions relating to issuance of licenses and certificates to manufacturers, transporters, and dealers.
This bill would also authorize the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to the above-mentioned persons upon determining that the person has violated any provision of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle and, if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, to include a specified recall disclosure statement with the notice of registration renewal. each vehicle registration renewal notice. This requirement would not take effect until the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, as specified, certifying that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include the recall disclosure statement. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distribitor branch upon determining that the person to whom the licensed was issued has done, among other things, violate provisions relating to issuance of licenses and certificates to manufacturers, transporters, and dealers.
This bill would also authorize the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to the above-mentioned persons upon determining that the person has violated any provision of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would become operative on July 1, 2017. The act would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle and, if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, to include a specified recall disclosure statement with the notice of registration renewal. This requirement would not take effect until the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, as specified, certifying that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include the recall disclosure statement. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. recall repair. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law authorizes the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distribitor branch upon determining that the person to whom the licensed was issued has done, among other things, violate provisions relating to issuance of licenses and certificates to manufacturers, transporters, and dealers.
This bill would also authorize the DMV to suspend or revoke the license issued to the above-mentioned persons upon determining that the person has violated any provision of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would become operative on July 1, 2017. The act would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would require a dealer to obtain a recall database report, as defined, before displaying or offering for sale, and every 30 days thereafter, a used vehicle advertised as certified, or any similar descriptive term, that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program. If a recall database report indicates that the used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the act would prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling the vehicle as certified or any similar descriptive term until the recall repair has been made. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle and, if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, to include a specified recall disclosure statement with the notice of registration renewal. This requirement would not take effect until the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, as specified, certifying that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include the recall disclosure statement. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law makes it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if, among other things, the dealer knows the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, the dealer knows the vehicle has sustained frame damage, or the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected prior to sale.
This bill would additionally make it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if the vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would become operative on July 1, 2017. The act would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would require a dealer to obtain a recall database report, as defined, within 30 days of displaying or offering for sale before displaying or offering for sale, and every 30 days thereafter, a used vehicle advertised as certified, or any similar descriptive term, that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program. If a recall database report indicates that the used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the act would prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling the vehicle as certified or any similar descriptive term until the recall repair has been made. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle and, if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, to include a specified recall disclosure statement with the notice of registration renewal. This requirement would not take effect until the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, as specified, certifying that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include the recall disclosure statement. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law makes it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if, among other things, the dealer knows the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, the dealer knows the vehicle has sustained frame damage, or the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected prior to sale.
This bill would additionally make it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if the vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified. A violation of the Vehicle Code is a crime.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would be operative on and after July 1, 2016. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to display notifications of Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls, as defined, on the manufacturers Internet Web site. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to provide a rental or loaner car for a consumer who seeks to have a vehicle repaired because of a recall but the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The act would also require a vehicle manufacturer to compensate its franchisees, as specified, for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair.
The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from displaying or offering for sale at retail a used vehicle, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer. The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from selling or leasing a vehicle at retail if the used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. The act would prohibit a rental car company from renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, as specified. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law establishes the New Motor Vehicle Board in the Department of Motor Vehicles, and requires the board to hear and decide certain protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee in regard to a dispute with the vehicle manufacturer.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, authorize the board to hear and decide protests by franchisees regarding payments for providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
Existing law requires the Department of Motor Vehicles to issue a certificate of ownership to the legal owner of a vehicle upon registering a vehicle, and requires the certificate of ownership to contain specified information, including the information required upon the face of the registration card.
This bill would additionally require the certificate of ownership to contain a provision for a recall disclosure statement, as specified.
Under existing law, a vehicle manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, and distributor branch are prohibited from engaging in specified practices. Existing law makes a violation of these prohibitions a crime.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, include within those prohibited practices, unfairly discriminating among franchisees with respect to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would become operative on July 1, 2017. The act would prohibit a dealer or rental car company, as defined, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, except as specified. The act would require a dealer to obtain a recall database report, as defined, within 30 days of displaying or offering for sale a used vehicle advertised as certified, or any similar descriptive term, that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program. If a recall database report indicates that the used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the act would prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling the vehicle as certified or any similar descriptive term until the recall repair has been made. The act would also require the Department of Motor Vehicles to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle and, if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, to include a specified recall disclosure statement with the notice of registration renewal. This requirement would not take effect until the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, as specified, certifying that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include the recall disclosure statement. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a vehicle franchisor to properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing.
This bill would specify that the warranty obligations include all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The bill would provide, for purposes of the above-described warranty obligations, that a warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to federal motor vehicle safety laws. The bill would state that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
Existing law makes it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if, among other things, the dealer knows the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, the dealer knows the vehicle has sustained frame damage, or the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected prior to sale.
This bill would additionally make it a violation of the Vehicle Code for the holder of a dealers license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified if the vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would be operative on and after July 1, 2016. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to display notifications of Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls, as defined, on the manufacturers Internet Web site. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to provide a rental or loaner car for a consumer who seeks to have a vehicle repaired because of a recall but the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The act would also require a vehicle manufacturer to compensate its franchisees, as specified, for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair.
The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from displaying or offering for sale at retail a used vehicle, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer. The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from selling or leasing a vehicle at retail if the used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. The act would prohibit a rental car company from renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, as specified. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law establishes the New Motor Vehicle Board in the Department of Motor Vehicles, and requires the board to hear and decide certain protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee in regard to a dispute with the vehicle manufacturer.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, authorize the board to hear and decide protests by franchisees regarding payments for providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
Existing law prescribes certain instances when the Department of Motor Vehicles may refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle, including, among others, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement, as specified.
This bill would additionally authorize the department, commencing July 1, 2016, to refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement, as defined.
Existing law requires the Department of Motor Vehicles to issue a certificate of ownership to the legal owner of a vehicle upon registering a vehicle, and requires the certificate of ownership to contain specified information, including the information required upon the face of the registration card.
This bill would additionally require the certificate of ownership to contain a provision for a recall disclosure statement, as specified.
Under existing law, a vehicle manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, and distributor branch are prohibited from engaging in specified practices. Existing law makes a violation of these prohibitions a crime.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, include within those prohibited practices, unfairly discriminating among franchisees with respect to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would be operative on and after July 1, 2016. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to display notifications of Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls, as defined, on the manufacturers Internet Web site. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to provide a rental or loaner car for a consumer who seeks to have a vehicle repaired because of a recall, and recall but the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The act would also require a vehicle manufacturer to compensate its franchisees, as specified, for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair.
The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from displaying or offering for sale at retail a used vehicle, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer. The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from selling or leasing a vehicle at retail if the used vehicle that has is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. The act would prohibit a rental car company from offering a vehicle for rent unless the company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer. The act would prohibit a rental car company from renting a vehicle that has a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall, until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. as specified. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law establishes the New Motor Vehicle Board in the Department of Motor Vehicles, and requires the board to hear and decide certain protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee in regard to a dispute with the vehicle manufacturer.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, authorize the board to hear and decide protests by franchisees regarding payments for providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
Existing law prescribes certain instances when the Department of Motor Vehicles may refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle, including, among others, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement, as specified.
This bill would additionally authorize the department, commencing July 1, 2016, to refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement, as defined.
Under existing law, a vehicle manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, and distributor branch are prohibited from engaging in specified practices. Existing law makes a violation of these prohibitions a crime.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, include within those prohibited practices, unfairly discriminating among franchisees with respect to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect. Existing federal law also prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a vehicle if it has been notified of a safety-related defect by the manufacturer, except as specified.
This bill would enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would be operative on and after July 1, 2016. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to display notifications of Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls, as defined, on the manufacturers Internet Web site. The act would require a vehicle manufacturer to provide a rental or loaner car for a consumer who seeks to have a vehicle repaired because of a recall, and the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The act would also require a vehicle manufacturer to compensate its franchisees, as specified, for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair.
The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from displaying or offering for sale at retail a used vehicle, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer. The act would prohibit a vehicle dealer from selling or leasing a vehicle at retail if the used vehicle that has a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. The act would prohibit a rental car company from offering a vehicle for rent unless the company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer. The act would prohibit a rental car company from renting a vehicle that has a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall until the recalled vehicle has been repaired, subject to exception. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law establishes the New Motor Vehicle Board in the Department of Motor Vehicles, and requires the board to hear and decide certain protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee in regard to a dispute with the vehicle manufacturer.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, authorize the board to hear and decide protests by franchisees regarding payments for providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
Existing law prescribes certain instances when the Department of Motor Vehicles may refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle, including, among others, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement, as specified.
This bill would additionally authorize the department, commencing July 1, 2016, to refuse registration, or renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement, as defined.
Under existing law, a vehicle manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, and distributor branch are prohibited from engaging in specified practices. Existing law makes a violation of these prohibitions a crime.
This bill would, commencing July 1, 2016, include within those prohibited practices, unfairly discriminating among franchisees with respect to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental car and storing a consumers vehicle that is subject to recall if the parts or procedures are not yet available to perform the repair. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would state findings and declarations of the Legislature relative to vehicle recalls.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act to provide comprehensive consumer protections that address the low recall repair completion rate and consumer confusion regarding automotive recalls in California.
Existing law generally regulates the transfer and registration of motor vehicles. Existing federal law requires a motor vehicle manufacturer to notify the owner or purchaser of a motor vehicle when the manufacturer determines that the vehicle contains a safety-related defect or when the manufacturer is ordered by the federal Secretary of Transportation to notify vehicle owners and purchasers that a vehicle has a safety-related defect.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act to provide comprehensive consumer protections that address the low recall repair completion rate and consumer confusion regarding automotive recalls in California.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars and to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11705 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11705.(a)The department, after notice and hearing, may suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the license was issued is not lawfully entitled thereto, or has done any of the following:
(1)Filed an application for the license using a false or fictitious name not registered with the proper authorities, or knowingly made a false statement or knowingly concealed a material fact, in the application for the license.
(2)Made, or knowingly or negligently permitted, an illegal use of the special plates issued to the licensee.
(3)Used a false or fictitious name, knowingly made a false statement, or knowingly concealed a material fact, in an application for the registration of a vehicle, or otherwise committed a fraud in the application.
(4)Failed to deliver to a transferee lawfully entitled thereto a properly endorsed certificate of ownership.
(5)Knowingly purchased, sold, or otherwise acquired or disposed of a stolen motor vehicle.
(6)Failed to provide and maintain a clear physical division between the type of business licensed pursuant to this chapter and any other type of business conducted at the established place of business.
(7)Willfully violated Section 3064, 3065, 3074, or 3075 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(8)Violated any provision of Division 3 (commencing with Section 4000) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto, or subdivision (a) of Section 38200.
(9)Violated any provision of Division 4 (commencing with Section 10500) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(10)Violated any provision of Article 1 (commencing with Section 11700) of, or Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) of, Chapter 4 of Division 5 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(11)Violated any provision of Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(12)Violated any provision of Chapter 2b (commencing with Section 2981) of Title 14 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(13)Submitted a check, draft, or money order to the department for any obligation or fee due the state which was dishonored or refused payment upon presentation.
(14)(A)Has caused any person to suffer any loss or damage by reason of any fraud or deceit practiced on that person or fraudulent representations made to that person in the course of the licensed activity.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, fraud includes any act or omission which is included within the definition of either actual fraud or constructive fraud as defined in Sections 1572 and 1573 of the Civil Code, and deceit has the same meaning as defined in Section 1710 of the Civil Code. In addition, fraud and deceit include, but are not limited to, a misrepresentation in any manner, whether intentionally false or due to gross negligence, of a material fact; a promise or representation not made honestly and in good faith; an intentional failure to disclose a material fact; and any act within Section 484 of the Penal Code.
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, person also includes a governmental entity.
(15)Failed to meet the terms and conditions of an agreement entered into pursuant to Section 11707.
(16)Violated Section 43151, 43152, or 43153 of, or subdivision (b) of Section 44072.10 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(17)Failed to repay a claim paid by the Consumer Motor Vehicle Recovery Corporation as provided in subdivision (i) of Section 11703.
(18)As a buy-here-pay-here dealer, violated any provision of Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 7500) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant to those provisions.
(b)Any of the causes specified in this chapter as a cause for refusal to issue a license to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer applicant is cause to suspend or revoke a license issued to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer.
(c)Except as provided in Section 11707, every hearing provided for in this section shall be conducted pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on each vehicle registration renewal notice:
NOTICE: Many vehicles have been recalled recently for needed repairs. Did you know you can check to see if your vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers safety recall? For most vehicles, manufacturer safety recalls are repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at www.safercar.gov.
11760.
This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
11761.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars and to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11705 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11705.(a)The department, after notice and hearing, may suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the license was issued is not lawfully entitled thereto, or has done any of the following:
(1)Filed an application for the license using a false or fictitious name not registered with the proper authorities, or knowingly made a false statement or knowingly concealed a material fact, in the application for the license.
(2)Made, or knowingly or negligently permitted, an illegal use of the special plates issued to the licensee.
(3)Used a false or fictitious name, knowingly made a false statement, or knowingly concealed a material fact, in an application for the registration of a vehicle, or otherwise committed a fraud in the application.
(4)Failed to deliver to a transferee lawfully entitled thereto a properly endorsed certificate of ownership.
(5)Knowingly purchased, sold, or otherwise acquired or disposed of a stolen motor vehicle.
(6)Failed to provide and maintain a clear physical division between the type of business licensed pursuant to this chapter and any other type of business conducted at the established place of business.
(7)Willfully violated Section 3064, 3065, 3074, or 3075 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(8)Violated any provision of Division 3 (commencing with Section 4000) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto, or subdivision (a) of Section 38200.
(9)Violated any provision of Division 4 (commencing with Section 10500) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(10)Violated any provision of Article 1 (commencing with Section 11700) of, or Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) of, Chapter 4 of Division 5 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(11)Violated any provision of Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(12)Violated any provision of Chapter 2b (commencing with Section 2981) of Title 14 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(13)Submitted a check, draft, or money order to the department for any obligation or fee due the state which was dishonored or refused payment upon presentation.
(14)(A)Has caused any person to suffer any loss or damage by reason of any fraud or deceit practiced on that person or fraudulent representations made to that person in the course of the licensed activity.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, fraud includes any act or omission which is included within the definition of either actual fraud or constructive fraud as defined in Sections 1572 and 1573 of the Civil Code, and deceit has the same meaning as defined in Section 1710 of the Civil Code. In addition, fraud and deceit include, but are not limited to, a misrepresentation in any manner, whether intentionally false or due to gross negligence, of a material fact; a promise or representation not made honestly and in good faith; an intentional failure to disclose a material fact; and any act within Section 484 of the Penal Code.
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, person also includes a governmental entity.
(15)Failed to meet the terms and conditions of an agreement entered into pursuant to Section 11707.
(16)Violated Section 43151, 43152, or 43153 of, or subdivision (b) of Section 44072.10 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(17)Failed to repay a claim paid by the Consumer Motor Vehicle Recovery Corporation as provided in subdivision (i) of Section 11703.
(18)As a buy-here-pay-here dealer, violated any provision of Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 7500) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant to those provisions.
(b)Any of the causes specified in this chapter as a cause for refusal to issue a license to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer applicant is cause to suspend or revoke a license issued to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer.
(c)Except as provided in Section 11707, every hearing provided for in this section shall be conducted pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on each vehicle registration renewal notice:
NOTICE: Many vehicles have been recalled recently for needed repairs. Did you know you can check to see if your vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers safety recall? For most vehicles, manufacturer safety recalls are repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at www.safercar.gov.
11760.
This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
11761.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars and to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11705 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11705.(a)The department, after notice and hearing, may suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the license was issued is not lawfully entitled thereto, or has done any of the following:
(1)Filed an application for the license using a false or fictitious name not registered with the proper authorities, or knowingly made a false statement or knowingly concealed a material fact, in the application for the license.
(2)Made, or knowingly or negligently permitted, an illegal use of the special plates issued to the licensee.
(3)Used a false or fictitious name, knowingly made a false statement, or knowingly concealed a material fact, in an application for the registration of a vehicle, or otherwise committed a fraud in the application.
(4)Failed to deliver to a transferee lawfully entitled thereto a properly endorsed certificate of ownership.
(5)Knowingly purchased, sold, or otherwise acquired or disposed of a stolen motor vehicle.
(6)Failed to provide and maintain a clear physical division between the type of business licensed pursuant to this chapter and any other type of business conducted at the established place of business.
(7)Willfully violated Section 3064, 3065, 3074, or 3075 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(8)Violated any provision of Division 3 (commencing with Section 4000) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto, or subdivision (a) of Section 38200.
(9)Violated any provision of Division 4 (commencing with Section 10500) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(10)Violated any provision of Article 1 (commencing with Section 11700) of, or Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) of, Chapter 4 of Division 5 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(11)Violated any provision of Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(12)Violated any provision of Chapter 2b (commencing with Section 2981) of Title 14 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(13)Submitted a check, draft, or money order to the department for any obligation or fee due the state which was dishonored or refused payment upon presentation.
(14)(A)Has caused any person to suffer any loss or damage by reason of any fraud or deceit practiced on that person or fraudulent representations made to that person in the course of the licensed activity.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, fraud includes any act or omission which is included within the definition of either actual fraud or constructive fraud as defined in Sections 1572 and 1573 of the Civil Code, and deceit has the same meaning as defined in Section 1710 of the Civil Code. In addition, fraud and deceit include, but are not limited to, a misrepresentation in any manner, whether intentionally false or due to gross negligence, of a material fact; a promise or representation not made honestly and in good faith; an intentional failure to disclose a material fact; and any act within Section 484 of the Penal Code.
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, person also includes a governmental entity.
(15)Failed to meet the terms and conditions of an agreement entered into pursuant to Section 11707.
(16)Violated Section 43151, 43152, or 43153 of, or subdivision (b) of Section 44072.10 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(17)Failed to repay a claim paid by the Consumer Motor Vehicle Recovery Corporation as provided in subdivision (i) of Section 11703.
(18)As a buy-here-pay-here dealer, violated any provision of Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 7500) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant to those provisions.
(b)Any of the causes specified in this chapter as a cause for refusal to issue a license to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer applicant is cause to suspend or revoke a license issued to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer.
(c)Except as provided in Section 11707, every hearing provided for in this section shall be conducted pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.(a)Before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, pursuant to Section 1661, the department shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement specified in subdivision (b).
(b)
11758.The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall: each vehicle registration renewal notice:
WARNING. This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers safety recall.
NOTICE: Many vehicles have been recalled recently for needed repairs. Did you know you can check to see if your vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers safety recall? For most vehicles, you can get this recall manufacturer safety recalls are repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at www.safercar.gov.
(c)This section shall become operative on the date that the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, to be retained by the director, in which the director certifies that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The director shall post the declaration on the departments Internet Web site and shall send the declaration to the appropriate committees of the Legislature and to the Legislative Counsel.
11760.This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
11761.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars, cars and to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls, and to safeguard the advertising of certified used cars. recalls.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including all costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. recall repair. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11705 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11705.(a)The department, after notice and hearing, may suspend or revoke the license issued to a dealer, transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch upon determining that the person to whom the license was issued is not lawfully entitled thereto, or has done any of the following:
(1)Filed an application for the license using a false or fictitious name not registered with the proper authorities, or knowingly made a false statement or knowingly concealed a material fact, in the application for the license.
(2)Made, or knowingly or negligently permitted, an illegal use of the special plates issued to the licensee.
(3)Used a false or fictitious name, knowingly made a false statement, or knowingly concealed a material fact, in an application for the registration of a vehicle, or otherwise committed a fraud in the application.
(4)Failed to deliver to a transferee lawfully entitled thereto a properly endorsed certificate of ownership.
(5)Knowingly purchased, sold, or otherwise acquired or disposed of a stolen motor vehicle.
(6)Failed to provide and maintain a clear physical division between the type of business licensed pursuant to this chapter and any other type of business conducted at the established place of business.
(7)Willfully violated Section 3064, 3065, 3074, or 3075 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(8)Violated any provision of Division 3 (commencing with Section 4000) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto, or subdivision (a) of Section 38200.
(9)Violated any provision of Division 4 (commencing with Section 10500) or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(10)Violated any provision of Article 1 (commencing with Section 11700) of of, or Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) of, Chapter 4 of Division 5 or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(11)Violated any provision of Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(12)Violated any provision of Chapter 2b (commencing with Section 2981) of Title 14 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
(13)Submitted a check, draft, or money order to the department for any obligation or fee due the state which was dishonored or refused payment upon presentation.
(14)(A)Has caused any person to suffer any loss or damage by reason of any fraud or deceit practiced on that person or fraudulent representations made to that person in the course of the licensed activity.
For
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, fraud includes any act or omission which is included within the definition of either actual fraud or constructive fraud as defined in Sections 1572 and 1573 of the Civil Code, and deceit has the same meaning as defined in Section 1710 of the Civil Code. In addition, fraud and deceit include, but are not limited to, a misrepresentation in any manner, whether intentionally false or due to gross negligence, of a material fact; a promise or representation not made honestly and in good faith; an intentional failure to disclose a material fact; and any act within Section 484 of the Penal Code.
For
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, person also includes a governmental entity.
(15)Failed to meet the terms and conditions of an agreement entered into pursuant to Section 11707.
(16)Violated Section 43151, 43152, or 43153 of, or subdivision (b) of Section 44072.10 of, the Health and Safety Code.
(17)Failed to repay a claim paid by the Consumer Motor Vehicle Recovery Corporation as provided in subdivision (i) of Section 11703.
(18)As a buy-here-pay-here dealer, violated any provision of Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 7500) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant to those provisions.
(b)Any of the causes specified in this chapter as a cause for refusal to issue a license to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer applicant is cause to suspend or revoke a license issued to a transporter, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, remanufacturer, remanufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or dealer.
(c)Except as provided in Section 11707, every hearing provided for in this section shall be conducted pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(f)The term used vehicle has the same meaning as set forth in Section 665.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.(a)Before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, pursuant to Section 1661, the department shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall:
WARNING. This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers safety recall. You For most vehicles, you can get this recall repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations Internet Web site. www.safercar.gov.
(c)This section shall become operative on the date that the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, to be retained by the director, in which the director certifies that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The director shall post the declaration on the departments Internet Web site and shall send the declaration to the appropriate committees of the Legislature and to the Legislative Counsel.
11760.This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
11761.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
11763.Except as otherwise provided in Section 11758, this article shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls, and to safeguard the advertising of certified used cars.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11713.18 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.18.(a)It is a violation of this code for the holder of any dealers license issued under this article to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program if any of the following apply:
(1)The dealer knows or should have known that the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, has been rolled back or otherwise altered to show fewer miles, or replaced with an odometer showing fewer miles than actually driven.
(2)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle was reacquired by the vehicles manufacturer or a dealer pursuant to state or federal warranty laws.
(3)The title to the vehicle has been inscribed with the notation Lemon Law Buyback, manufacturer repurchase, salvage, junk, nonrepairable, flood, or similar title designation required by this state or another state.
(4)The vehicle has sustained damage in an impact, fire, or flood, that after repair prior to sale substantially impairs the use or safety of the vehicle.
(5)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle has sustained frame damage.
(6)Prior to sale, the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected.
(7)The dealer disclaims any warranties of merchantability on the vehicle.
(8)The vehicle is sold AS IS.
(9)The term certified or any similar descriptive term is used in any manner that is untrue or misleading or that would cause any advertisement to be in violation of subdivision (a) of Section 11713 of this code or Section 17200 or 17500 of the Business and Professions Code.
(10)The vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report required by Section 11756.
(b)A violation of this section is actionable under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act (Title 1.5 (commencing with Section 1750) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code), the Unfair Competition Law (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), Section 17500 of the Business and Professions Code, or any other applicable state or federal law. The rights and remedies provided by this section are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
(c)This section does not abrogate or limit any disclosure obligation imposed by any other law.
(d)This section does not apply to the advertisement or sale of a used motorcycle or a used off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(f)The term used vehicle has the same meaning as set forth in Section 665.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11756.(a)For every used vehicle advertised for sale as certified or any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program, a dealer shall obtain a recall database report before the display or offer and every 30 days thereafter until the vehicle is no longer displayed or offered for sale.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the dealer shall not advertise for sale or sell that vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of the used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program until the recall repair has been made.
11758.(a)Before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, pursuant to Section 1661, the department shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall:
WARNING. This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers recall. You can get this recall repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations Internet Web site.
(c)This section shall become operative on the date that the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, to be retained by the director, in which the director certifies that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The director shall post the declaration on the departments Internet Web site and shall send the declaration to the appropriate committees of the Legislature and to the Legislative Counsel.
11760.This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, 11754 and 11758.
11760.5.11761.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11761.This article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
11763.Except as otherwise provided in Section 11758, this article shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 5.SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of unrepaired recalls on their cars, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles free of any unrepaired recalls, and to safeguard the advertising of certified used cars.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11713.18 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.18.(a)It is a violation of this code for the holder of any dealers license issued under this article to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program if any of the following apply:
(1)The dealer knows or should have known that the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, has been rolled back or otherwise altered to show fewer miles, or replaced with an odometer showing fewer miles than actually driven.
(2)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle was reacquired by the vehicles manufacturer or a dealer pursuant to state or federal warranty laws.
(3)The title to the vehicle has been inscribed with the notation Lemon Law Buyback, manufacturer repurchase, salvage, junk, nonrepairable, flood, or similar title designation required by this state or another state.
(4)The vehicle has sustained damage in an impact, fire, or flood, that after repair prior to sale substantially impairs the use or safety of the vehicle.
(5)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle has sustained frame damage.
(6)Prior to sale, the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected.
(7)The dealer disclaims any warranties of merchantability on the vehicle.
(8)The vehicle is sold AS IS.
(9)The term certified or any similar descriptive term is used in any manner that is untrue or misleading or that would cause any advertisement to be in violation of subdivision (a) of Section 11713 of this code or Section 17200 or 17500 of the Business and Professions Code.
(10)The vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report required by Section 11756.
(b)A violation of this section is actionable under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act (Title 1.5 (commencing with Section 1750) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code), the Unfair Competition Law (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), Section 17500 of the Business and Professions Code, or any other applicable state or federal law. The rights and remedies provided by this section are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
(c)This section does not abrogate or limit any disclosure obligation imposed by any other law.
(d)This section does not apply to the advertisement or sale of a used motorcycle or a used off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010.
SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(f)The term used vehicle has the same meaning as set forth in Section 665.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11756.(a)For every used vehicle advertised for sale as certified or any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program, a dealer shall obtain a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer. before the display or offer and every 30 days thereafter until the vehicle is no longer displayed or offered for sale.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the dealer shall not advertise for sale or sell that vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of the used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program until the recall repair has been made.
11758.(a)Before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, pursuant to Section 1661, the department shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall:
This
WARNING. This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers recall. You can get this recall repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations Internet Web site.
(c)This section shall become operative on the date that the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, to be retained by the director, in which the director certifies that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The director shall post the declaration on the departments Internet Web site and shall send the declaration to the appropriate committees of the Legislature and to the Legislative Counsel.
11760.This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758.
11760.5.The rights and remedies provided by this article are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
11761.This article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
11763.Except as otherwise provided in Section 11758, this article shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 51 million recalls were issued in 2015, 22 million recalls were issued in 2013 2013, and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public. Dealers, rental car companies, and private parties offering vehicles for sale or rent now have greater access to recall information than ever before.
(4)Federal law imposes a requirement not to sell a new vehicle subject to a recall, but neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. It is the intent of this act to address used vehicles subject to a recall that are not yet repaired.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of recalls in the car purchasing and rental process, unrepaired recalls on their cars, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles while their recalled vehicles are being repaired at a new motor vehicle dealer, and to ensure that a recalled vehicle that poses a risk of imminent harm is not sold or rented to Californians until the risk is removed and the vehicle is repaired. free of any unrepaired recalls, and to safeguard the advertising of certified used cars.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affects affect the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)Franchisors sometimes establish programs to reimburse franchisees for loaner or rental cars given to consumers whose vehicles have been recalled, but California franchise laws fail to establish guidelines for rental or loaner vehicle reimbursement.
(4)
(3)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fails fail to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee costs associated with recalled vehicles that cannot be repaired and remain in the franchisees possession. disposal costs associated with hazardous waste generated by repairs on recalled vehicles.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors, that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably reimbursed for providing loaner or rental vehicles to consumers who have recalled vehicles when the parts or procedures to make the recall repair are not available, and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for recalled vehicles at their dealerships that cannot immediately be repaired and must be stored by the franchisee at the dealership. franchisors and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for repairs on recalled vehicles.
SEC. 2.Section 3050 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3050.The board shall do all of the following:
(a)Adopt rules and regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code governing those matters that are specifically committed to its jurisdiction.
(b)Hear and determine, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, an appeal presented by an applicant for, or holder of, a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative when the applicant or licensee submits an appeal provided for in this chapter from a decision arising out of the department.
(c)Consider any matter concerning the activities or practices of any person applying for or holding a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 submitted by any person. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide any matter considered by the board pursuant to this subdivision that involves a dispute between a franchisee and franchisor. After that consideration, the board may do any one or any combination of the following:
(1)Direct the department to conduct investigation of matters that the board deems reasonable, and make a written report on the results of the investigation to the board within the time specified by the board.
(2)Undertake to mediate, arbitrate, or otherwise resolve any honest difference of opinion or viewpoint existing between any member of the public and any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative.
(3)Order the department to exercise any and all authority or power that the department may have with respect to the issuance, renewal, refusal to renew, suspension, or revocation of the license of any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative as that license is required under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5.
(d)Hear and decide, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, a protest presented by a franchisee pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide, any matter involving a protest filed pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060), unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (c) and (d), the courts have jurisdiction over all common law and statutory claims originally cognizable in the courts. For those claims, a party may initiate an action directly in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SEC. 3.Section 3065.2 is added to the Vehicle Code, to read:3065.2.(a)A claim made by a franchisee for payment under Section 11760 shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after receipt by the franchisor. When a claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt shall be deemed approved on the 30th day.
(b)Franchisee claims for compensation under Section 11760 shall not be disapproved unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(c)The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the written disapproval notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(d)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(e)Following the disapproval of a claim, a franchisee shall have six months from receipt of the written notice described in either subdivision (a) or (d), whichever is later, to file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (d). In any hearing pursuant to this subdivision or subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)A claim made by franchisees under this section shall be paid within 30 days following approval. Failure to approve or pay within the time limits specified in this section, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, is not a violation of this section.
(g)(1)Audits of franchisee records for payment under Section 11760 may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis, and for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved and charged back unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure any material noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after the franchisee receives the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later. If the franchisee cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim, the franchisor shall not chargeback the dealer for that claim. Any chargeback to a franchisee under Section 11760 shall be made within 90 days after the franchisee receives that written notice. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after receipt of the written notice described in either paragraph (3) or (4), a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(i)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 4.Section 3066 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3066.(a)Upon receiving a protest pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the board shall fix a time within 60 days of the order, and place of hearing, and shall send by registered mail a copy of the order to the franchisor, the protesting franchisee, and all individuals and groups that have requested notification by the board of protests and decisions of the board. Except in a case involving a franchisee who deals exclusively in motorcycles, the board or its executive director may, upon a showing of good cause, accelerate or postpone the date initially established for a hearing, but the hearing may not be rescheduled more than 90 days after the boards initial order. For the purpose of accelerating or postponing a hearing date, good cause includes, but is not limited to, the effects upon, and any irreparable harm to, the parties or interested persons or groups if the request for a change in hearing date is not granted. The board or an administrative law judge designated by the board shall hear and consider the oral and documented evidence introduced by the parties and other interested individuals and groups, and the board shall make its decision solely on the record so made. Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Sections 11507.3, 11507.6, 11507.7, 11511, 11511.5, 11513, 11514, 11515, and 11517 of the Government Code apply to these proceedings.
(b)In a hearing on a protest filed pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3070, or 3072, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause to modify, replace, terminate, or refuse to continue a franchise. The franchisee shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause not to enter into a franchise establishing or relocating an additional motor vehicle dealership.
(c)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, in a hearing on a protest alleging a violation of, or filed pursuant to, Section 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the franchisee shall have the burden of proof, but the franchisor has the burden of proof to establish that a franchisee acted with intent to defraud the franchisor when that issue is material to a protest filed pursuant to Section 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3075, or 3076.
(d)A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, or advise other members upon, or decide, a matter involving a protest filed pursuant to this article unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
SEC. 5.Section 4451 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:4451.(a)The certificate of ownership shall contain all of the following:
(1)Not less than the information required upon the face of the registration card.
(2)Provision for notice to the department of a transfer of the title or interest of the owner or legal owner.
(3)Provision for application for transfer of registration by the transferee.
(4)Provision for an odometer disclosure statement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 32705 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(5)Commencing July 1, 2016, or as soon thereafter as the department exhausts its supply of existing certificate of ownership forms, provision for a recall disclosure statement pursuant to Section 11758.
(b)Notwithstanding paragraph (5) of subdivision (a), a certificate of ownership previously issued by the department prior to July 1, 2016, and in the possession of a registered owner remains valid for the transfer of registration of a vehicle.
SEC. 6.Section 11713.3 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.3.It is unlawful and a violation of this code for a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch licensed pursuant to this code to do, directly or indirectly through an affiliate, any of the following:
(a)To refuse or fail to deliver in reasonable quantities and within a reasonable time after receipt of an order from a dealer having a franchise for the retail sale of a new vehicle sold or distributed by the manufacturer or distributor, a new vehicle or parts or accessories to new vehicles as are covered by the franchise, if the vehicle, parts, or accessories are publicly advertised as being available for delivery or actually being delivered. This subdivision is not violated, however, if the failure is caused by acts or causes beyond the control of the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(b)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a change in the capital structure of a dealership or the means by or through which the dealer finances the operation of the dealership, if the dealer at all times meets reasonable capital standards agreed to by the dealer and the manufacturer or distributor, and if a change in capital structure does not cause a change in the principal management or have the effect of a sale of the franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor.
(c)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, a dealer to change the executive management of a dealership, other than the principal dealership operator or operators, if the franchise was granted to the dealer in reliance upon the personal qualifications of that person.
(d)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (t), to prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a dealer, or an officer, partner, or stockholder of a dealership, the sale or transfer of a part of the interest of any of them to another person. A dealer, officer, partner, or stockholder shall not, however, have the right to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise, or a right thereunder, without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor except that the consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.
(2)(A)For the transferring franchisee to fail, prior to the sale, transfer, or assignment of a franchisee or the sale, assignment, or transfer of all, or substantially all, of the assets of the franchised business or a controlling interest in the franchised business to another person, to notify the manufacturer or distributor of the franchisees decision to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall include all of the following:
(i)The proposed transferees name and address.
(ii)A copy of all of the agreements relating to the sale, assignment, or transfer of the franchised business or its assets.
(iii)The proposed transferees application for approval to become the successor franchisee. The application shall include forms and related information generally utilized by the manufacturer or distributor in reviewing prospective franchisees, if those forms are readily made available to existing franchisees. As soon as practicable after receipt of the proposed transferees application, the manufacturer or distributor shall notify the franchisee and the proposed transferee of information needed to make the application complete.
(B)For the manufacturer or distributor, to fail, on or before 60 days after the receipt of all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A), or as extended by a written agreement between the manufacturer or distributor and the franchisee, to notify the franchisee of the approval or the disapproval of the sale, transfer, or assignment of the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall be personally served or sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by guaranteed overnight delivery service that provides verification of delivery and shall be directed to the franchisee. A proposed sale, assignment, or transfer shall be deemed approved, unless disapproved by the franchisor in the manner provided by this subdivision. If the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer is disapproved, the franchisor shall include in the notice of disapproval a statement setting forth the reasons for the disapproval.
(3)In an action in which the manufacturers or distributors withholding of consent under this subdivision or subdivision (e) is an issue, whether the withholding of consent was unreasonable is a question of fact requiring consideration of all the existing circumstances.
(e)To prevent, or attempt to prevent, a dealer from receiving fair and reasonable compensation for the value of the franchised business. There shall not be a transfer or assignment of the dealers franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or conditioned upon the release, assignment, novation, waiver, estoppel, or modification of a claim or defense by the dealer.
(f)To obtain money, goods, services, or another benefit from a person with whom the dealer does business, on account of, or in relation to, the transaction between the dealer and that other person, other than for compensation for services rendered, unless the benefit is promptly accounted for, and transmitted to, the dealer.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (3), to obtain from a dealer or enforce against a dealer an agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel that does any of the following:
(A)Modifies or disclaims a duty or obligation of a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative, or a right or privilege of a dealer, pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 or Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 3000) of Division 2.
(B)Limits or constrains the right of a dealer to file, pursue, or submit evidence in connection with a protest before the board.
(C)Requires a dealer to terminate a franchise.
(D)Requires a controversy between a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative and a dealer to be referred to a person for a binding determination. However, this subparagraph does not prohibit arbitration before an independent arbitrator, provided that whenever a motor vehicle franchise contract provides for the use of arbitration to resolve a controversy arising out of, or relating to, that contract, arbitration may be used to settle the controversy only if, after the controversy arises, all parties to the controversy consent in writing to use arbitration to settle the controversy. For the purpose of this subparagraph, the terms motor vehicle and motor vehicle franchise contract shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 1226 of Title 15 of the United States Code. If arbitration is elected to settle a dispute under a motor vehicle franchise contract, the arbitrator shall provide the parties to the arbitration with a written explanation of the factual and legal basis for the award.
(2)An agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel prohibited by this subdivision shall be unenforceable and void.
(3)This subdivision does not do any of the following:
(A)Limit or restrict the terms upon which parties to a protest before the board, civil action, or other proceeding can settle or resolve, or stipulate to evidentiary or procedural matters during the course of, a protest, civil action, or other proceeding.
(B)Affect the enforceability of any stipulated order or other order entered by the board.
(C)Affect the enforceability of any provision in a contract if the provision is not prohibited under this subdivision or any other law.
(D)Affect the enforceability of a provision in any contract entered into on or before December 31, 2011.
(E)Prohibit a dealer from waiving its right to file a protest pursuant to Section 3065.1 if the waiver agreement is entered into after a franchisor incentive program claim has been disapproved by the franchisor and the waiver is voluntarily given as part of an agreement to settle that claim.
(F)Prohibit a voluntary agreement supported by valuable consideration, other than granting or renewing a franchise, that does both of the following:
(i)Provides that a dealer establish or maintain exclusive facilities, personnel, or display space or provides that a dealer make a material alteration, expansion, or addition to a dealership facility.
(ii)Contains no waiver or other provision prohibited by subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1).
(G)Prohibit an agreement separate from the franchise agreement that implements a dealers election to terminate the franchise if the agreement is conditioned only on a specified time for termination or payment of consideration to the dealer.
(H)(i)Prohibit a voluntary waiver agreement, supported by valuable consideration, other than the consideration of renewing a franchise, to waive the right of a dealer to file a protest under Section 3062 for the proposed establishment or relocation of a specific proposed dealership, if the waiver agreement provides all of the following:
(I)The approximate address at which the proposed dealership will be located.
(II)The planning potential used to establish the proposed dealerships facility, personnel, and capital requirements.
(III)An approximation of projected vehicle and parts sales, and number of vehicles to be serviced at the proposed dealership.
(IV)Whether the franchisor or affiliate will hold an ownership interest in the proposed dealership or real property of the proposed dealership, and the approximate percentage of any franchisor or affiliate ownership interest in the proposed dealership.
(V)The line-makes to be operated at the proposed dealership.
(VI)If known at the time the waiver agreement is executed, the identity of the dealer who will operate the proposed dealership.
(VII)The date the waiver agreement is to expire, which may not be more than 30 months after the date of execution of the waiver agreement.
(ii)Notwithstanding the provisions of a waiver agreement entered into pursuant to the provisions of this subparagraph, a dealer may file a protest under Section 3062 if any of the information provided pursuant to clause (i) has become materially inaccurate since the waiver agreement was executed. Any determination of the enforceability of a waiver agreement shall be determined by the board and the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)To increase prices of motor vehicles that the dealer had ordered for private retail consumers prior to the dealers receipt of the written official price increase notification. A sales contract signed by a private retail consumer is evidence of the order. In the event of manufacturer price reductions, the amount of the reduction received by a dealer shall be passed on to the private retail consumer by the dealer if the retail price was negotiated on the basis of the previous higher price to the dealer. Price reductions apply to all vehicles in the dealers inventory that were subject to the price reduction. Price differences applicable to new model or series motor vehicles at the time of the introduction of new models or series shall not be considered a price increase or price decrease. This subdivision does not apply to price changes caused by either of the following:
(1)The addition to a motor vehicle of required or optional equipment pursuant to state or federal law.
(2)Revaluation of the United States dollar in the case of a foreign-make vehicle.
(i)To fail to pay to a dealer, within a reasonable time following receipt of a valid claim by a dealer thereof, a payment agreed to be made by the manufacturer or distributor to the dealer by reason of the fact that a new vehicle of a prior year model is in the dealers inventory at the time of introduction of new model vehicles.
(j)To deny the widow, widower, or heirs designated by a deceased owner of a dealership the opportunity to participate in the ownership of the dealership or successor dealership under a valid franchise for a reasonable time after the death of the owner.
(k)To offer refunds or other types of inducements to a person for the purchase of new motor vehicles of a certain line-make to be sold to the state or a political subdivision of the state without making the same offer to all other dealers in the same line-make within the relevant market area.
(l)To modify, replace, enter into, relocate, terminate, or refuse to renew a franchise in violation of Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060) of Chapter 6 of Division 2.
(m)To employ a person as a representative who has not been licensed pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 11900) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(n)To deny a dealer the right of free association with another dealer for a lawful purpose.
(o)(1)To compete with a dealer in the same line-make operating under an agreement or franchise from a manufacturer or distributor in the relevant market area.
(2)A manufacturer, branch, or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by, a manufacturer, branch, or distributor, shall not, however, be deemed to be competing in the following limited circumstances:
(A)Owning or operating a dealership for a temporary period, not to exceed one year at the location of a former dealership of the same line-make that has been out of operation for less than six months. However, after a showing of good cause by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor that it needs additional time to operate a dealership in preparation for sale to a successor independent franchisee, the board may extend the time period.
(B)Owning an interest in a dealer as part of a bona fide dealer development program that satisfies all of the following requirements:
(i)The sole purpose of the program is to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualities ordinarily required of prospective franchisees and the dealer development candidate is an individual who is unable to acquire the franchise without assistance of the program.
(ii)The dealer development candidate has made a significant investment subject to loss in the franchised business of the dealer.
(iii)The program requires the dealer development candidate to manage the day-to-day operations and business affairs of the dealer and to acquire, within a reasonable time and on reasonable terms and conditions, beneficial ownership and control of a majority interest in the dealer and disassociation of any direct or indirect ownership or control by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor.
(C)Owning a wholly owned subsidiary corporation of a distributor that sells motor vehicles at retail, if, for at least three years prior to January 1, 1973, the subsidiary corporation has been a wholly owned subsidiary of the distributor and engaged in the sale of vehicles at retail.
(3)(A)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns or operates a dealership in the manner described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, within 10 days, each time it commences or terminates operation of a dealership and each time it acquires, changes, or divests itself of an ownership interest.
(B)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns an interest in a dealer in the manner described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, annually, of the name and location of each dealer in which it has an ownership interest, the name of the bona fide dealer development owner or owners, and the ownership interests of each owner expressed as a percentage.
(p)To unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to warranty reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees to make warranty adjustments with retail customers.
(q)To sell vehicles to a person not licensed pursuant to this chapter for resale.
(r)To fail to affix an identification number to a park trailer, as described in Section 18009.3 of the Health and Safety Code, that is manufactured on or after January 1, 1987, and that does not clearly identify the unit as a park trailer to the department. The configuration of the identification number shall be approved by the department.
(s)To dishonor a warranty, rebate, or other incentive offered to the public or a dealer in connection with the retail sale of a new motor vehicle, based solely upon the fact that an autobroker arranged or negotiated the sale. This subdivision shall not prohibit the disallowance of that rebate or incentive if the purchaser or dealer is ineligible to receive the rebate or incentive pursuant to any other term or condition of a rebate or incentive program.
(t)To exercise a right of first refusal or other right requiring a franchisee or an owner of the franchise to sell, transfer, or assign to the franchisor, or to a nominee of the franchisor, all or a material part of the franchised business or of the assets of the franchised business unless all of the following requirements are met:
(1)The franchise authorizes the franchisor to exercise a right of first refusal to acquire the franchised business or assets of the franchised business in the event of a proposed sale, transfer, or assignment.
(2)The franchisor gives written notice of its exercise of the right of first refusal no later than 45 days after the franchisor receives all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(3)The sale, transfer, or assignment being proposed relates to not less than all or substantially all of the assets of the franchised business or to a controlling interest in the franchised business.
(4)The proposed transferee is neither a family member of an owner of the franchised business, nor a managerial employee of the franchisee owning 15 percent or more of the franchised business, nor a corporation, partnership, or other legal entity owned by the existing owners of the franchised business. For purposes of this paragraph, a family member means the spouse of an owner of the franchised business, the child, grandchild, brother, sister, or parent of an owner, or a spouse of one of those family members. This paragraph does not limit the rights of the franchisor to disapprove a proposed transferee as provided in subdivision (d).
(5)Upon the franchisors exercise of the right of first refusal, the consideration paid by the franchisor to the franchisee and owners of the franchised business shall equal or exceed all consideration that each of them were to have received under the terms of, or in connection with, the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer, and the franchisor shall comply with all the terms and conditions of the agreement or agreements to sell, transfer, or assign the franchised business.
(6)The franchisor shall reimburse the proposed transferee for expenses paid or incurred by the proposed transferee in evaluating, investigating, and negotiating the proposed transfer to the extent those expenses do not exceed the usual, customary, and reasonable fees charged for similar work done in the area in which the franchised business is located. These expenses include, but are not limited to, legal and accounting expenses, and expenses incurred for title reports and environmental or other investigations of real property on which the franchisees operations are conducted. The proposed transferee shall provide the franchisor a written itemization of those expenses, and a copy of all nonprivileged reports and studies for which expenses were incurred, if any, within 30 days of the proposed transferees receipt of a written request from the franchisor for that accounting. The franchisor shall make payment within 30 days of exercising the right of first refusal.
(u)(1)To unfairly discriminate in favor of a dealership owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by the manufacturer or distributor. Unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A)The furnishing to a franchisee or dealer that is owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor of any of the following:
(i)A vehicle that is not made available to each franchisee pursuant to a reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly, and a part or accessory that is not made available to all franchisees on an equal basis when there is no reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly.
(ii)A vehicle, part, or accessory that is not made available to each franchisee on comparable delivery terms, including the time of delivery after the placement of an order. Differences in delivery terms due to geographic distances or other factors beyond the control of the manufacturer, branch, or distributor shall not constitute unfair competition.
(iii)Information obtained from a franchisee by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor concerning the business affairs or operations of a franchisee in which the manufacturer, branch, or distributor does not have an ownership interest. The information includes, but is not limited to, information contained in financial statements and operating reports, the name, address, or other personal information or buying, leasing, or service behavior of a dealer customer, and other information that, if provided to a franchisee or dealer owned or controlled by a manufacturer or distributor, would give that franchisee or dealer a competitive advantage. This clause does not apply if the information is provided pursuant to a subpoena or court order, or to aggregated information made available to all franchisees.
(iv)Sales or service incentives, discounts, or promotional programs that are not made available to all California franchises of the same line-make on an equal basis.
(B)Referring a prospective purchaser or lessee to a dealer in which a manufacturer, branch, or distributor has an ownership interest, unless the prospective purchaser or lessee resides in the area of responsibility assigned to that dealer or the prospective purchaser or lessee requests to be referred to that dealer.
(2)This subdivision does not prohibit a franchisor from granting a franchise to prospective franchisees or assisting those franchisees during the course of the franchise relationship as part of a program or programs to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualifications ordinarily required of prospective franchisees.
(v)(1)To access, modify, or extract information from a confidential dealer computer record, as defined in Section 11713.25, without obtaining the prior written consent of the dealer and without maintaining administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the security, confidentiality, and integrity of the information.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(w)(1)To use electronic, contractual, or other means to prevent or interfere with any of the following:
(A)The lawful efforts of a dealer to comply with federal and state data security and privacy laws.
(B)The ability of a dealer to do either of the following:
(i)Ensure that specific data accessed from the dealers computer system is within the scope of consent specified in subdivision (v).
(ii)Monitor specific data accessed from or written to the dealers computer system.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(x)(1)To unfairly discriminate against a franchisee selling a service contract, debt cancellation agreement, maintenance agreement, or similar product not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate. For purposes of this subdivision, unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Express or implied statements that the dealer is under an obligation to exclusively sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(B)Express or implied statements that selling or offering to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, or the failure to sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate will have any negative consequences for the dealer.
(C)Measuring a dealers performance under a franchise agreement based upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(D)Requiring a dealer to actively promote the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(E)Conditioning access to vehicles or parts, or vehicle sales or service incentives upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(2)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a manufacturer from, offering an incentive program to vehicle dealers who voluntarily sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, if the program does not provide vehicle sales or service incentives.
(3)This subdivision does not prohibit a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch from requiring a franchisee that sells a used vehicle as certified under a certified used vehicle program established by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch to provide a service contract approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(4)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a franchisor from requiring a franchisee to provide, the following notice prior to the sale of the service contract if the service contract is not provided or backed by the franchisor and the vehicle is of the franchised line-make:
Service Contract Disclosure
The service contract you are purchasing is not provided or backed by the manufacturer of the vehicle you are purchasing. The manufacturer of the vehicle is not responsible for claims or repairs under this service contract.
_____________________
Signature of Purchaser
(y)To take or threaten to take any adverse action against a dealer pursuant to an export or sale-for-resale prohibition because the dealer sold or leased a vehicle to a customer who either exported the vehicle to a foreign country or resold the vehicle in violation of the prohibition, unless the export or sale-for-resale prohibition policy was provided to the dealer in writing prior to the sale or lease, and the dealer knew or reasonably should have known of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle in violation of the prohibition at the time of sale or lease. If the dealer causes the vehicle to be registered in this or any other state, and collects or causes to be collected any applicable sales or use tax due to this state, a rebuttable presumption is established that the dealer did not have reason to know of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle.
(z)For purposes of this section, the term area of responsibility means a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(aa)Commencing July 1, 2016, to unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) of Section 11760.
SEC. 2.Section 3065 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3065.(a)Every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, and servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation. obligation, including all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall. The reasonableness of the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be determined by the board if a franchisee files a protest with the board. A franchisor shall not replace, modify, or supplement the warranty reimbursement schedule to impose a fixed percentage or other reduction in the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for warranty repairs not attributable to a specific repair. A franchisor may reduce the allowed time and compensation applicable to a specific warranty repair only upon 15 days prior written notice to the franchisee. Any protest challenging a reduction in time and compensation applicable to specific parts or labor operations shall be filed within six months following the franchisees receipt of notice of the reduction, and the franchisor shall have the burden of establishing the reasonableness of the reduction and adequacy and fairness of the resulting compensation.
(b)In determining the adequacy and fairness of the compensation, the franchisees effective labor rate charged to its various retail customers may be considered together with other relevant criteria. If in a protest permitted by this section filed by any franchisee the board determines that the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula fails to provide adequate and fair compensation or fails to conform with the other requirements of this section, within 30 days after receipt of the boards order, the franchisor shall correct the failure by amending or replacing the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula and implementing the correction as to all franchisees of the franchisor that are located in this state.
(c)If any franchisor disallows a franchisees claim for a defective part, alleging that the part, in fact, is not defective, the franchisor shall return the part alleged not to be defective to the franchisee at the expense of the franchisor, or the franchisee shall be reimbursed for the franchisees cost of the part, at the franchisors option.
(d)(1)All claims made by franchisees pursuant to this section shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after their receipt by the franchisor. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt by the franchisor shall be deemed approved on the 30th day. All claims made by franchisees under this section and Section 3064 for labor and parts shall be paid within 30 days after approval.
(2)A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(3)When any claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. The franchisor shall provide for a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to provide additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)Failure to approve or pay within the above specified time limits, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, shall not constitute a violation of this article.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with the requirements of this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(e)(1)Audits of franchisee warranty records may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved or charged back to the franchisee unless the claim is false or fraudulent, repairs were not properly made, repairs were inappropriate to correct a nonconformity with the written warranty due to an improper act or omission of the franchisee, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after receipt of the written notice described in paragraph (3) or paragraph (4), whichever is later. Any chargeback to a franchisee for warranty parts or service compensation shall be made within 90 days of receipt of that written notice. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after either receipt of the written disapproval notice or completion of the franchisors appeal process, whichever is later, a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(g)For purposes of this section, warranty includes a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code. This subdivision is declaratory and not amendatory of existing law.
SEC. 3.Section 11713.18 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.18.(a)It is a violation of this code for the holder of any dealers license issued under this article to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program if any of the following apply:
(1)The dealer knows or should have known that the odometer on the vehicle does not indicate actual mileage, has been rolled back or otherwise altered to show fewer miles, or replaced with an odometer showing fewer miles than actually driven.
(2)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle was reacquired by the vehicles manufacturer or a dealer pursuant to state or federal warranty laws.
(3)The title to the vehicle has been inscribed with the notation Lemon Law Buyback, manufacturer repurchase, salvage, junk, nonrepairable, flood, or similar title designation required by this state or another state.
(4)The vehicle has sustained damage in an impact, fire, or flood, that after repair prior to sale substantially impairs the use or safety of the vehicle.
(5)The dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle has sustained frame damage.
(6)Prior to sale, the dealer fails to provide the buyer with a completed inspection report indicating all the components inspected.
(7)The dealer disclaims any warranties of merchantability on the vehicle.
(8)The vehicle is sold AS IS.
(9)The term certified or any similar descriptive term is used in any manner that is untrue or misleading or that would cause any advertisement to be in violation of subdivision (a) of Section 11713 of this code or Section 17200 or 17500 of the Business and Professions Code.
(10)The vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturers recall described in a recall database report required by Section 11756.
(b)A violation of this section is actionable under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act (Title 1.5 (commencing with Section 1750) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code), the Unfair Competition Law (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), Section 17500 of the Business and Professions Code, or any other applicable state or federal law. The rights and remedies provided by this section are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
(c)This section does not abrogate or limit any disclosure obligation imposed by any other law.
(d)This section does not apply to the advertisement or sale of a used motorcycle or a used off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010.
SEC. 7.SEC. 4.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.). Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.). A manufacturers recall does not include a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall. Code.
(c)The term new motor vehicle dealer has the same meaning as in Section 426.
(d)
(c)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific Stop Sale Stop Drive recall and manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)
(d)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)
(e)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(f)The term used vehicle has the same meaning as set forth in Section 665.
(g)A Stop Sale Stop Drive recall is a recall notice provided to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration informs the dealer to stop the sale of the vehicle or contains any precaution advice to the owner to stop operating the vehicle.
(h)A vehicle manufacturer is a person who manufactures, assembles, or distributes new motor vehicles, sold or leased, that are subject to registration under this code.
11754.(a)A dealer shall not display or offer for sale at retail a used vehicle, as defined in Section 665, that is subject to registration under this code, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the dealer shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is of the same line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer, the dealer shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(d)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is not of the same line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer or the dealer does not have a franchise, the dealer may sell or lease the vehicle at retail if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The dealer discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to sale or lease.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle has a manufacturers recall and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicles line-make.
(e)To comply with subdivision (d), and notwithstanding Section 2981.9 of the Civil Code, a recall database report, that indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the recall repair has not been made, shall be disclosed and the disclosure signed by the consumer in a document separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
(f)The disclosure by a dealer, and receipt and acknowledgment by the consumer, of the information specified in subdivisions (d) and (e) has no legal effect other than to demonstrate compliance by the dealer with the requirements prescribed in those subdivisions. Nothing in this article shall be interpreted to place consumers in a less advantageous legal position for having received or signed the disclosures provided pursuant to this article than if no disclosure had been made.
11756.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), or sooner if practicable, a rental car company is prohibited from renting or offering for rent any vehicle subject to that recall.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the rental vehicle becomes available to the rental car company, the rental car company may not rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.Commencing July 1, 2016, or as soon thereafter as the department exhausts its supply of existing certificate of ownership forms, the department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the certificate of ownership and bill of sale form for private transactions:
This vehicle may have an unrepaired manufacturers recall. Please ask the seller if there is an unrepaired manufacturers recall on this vehicle. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations website.
11760.(a)A vehicle manufacturer shall clearly and conspicuously display on its Internet Web site and in all recall notifications pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), whether a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(b)When a consumer seeks to repair a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall as identified in a recall database report and the parts or procedures for the repair are not yet available, the vehicle manufacturer shall, upon request by the consumer, provide a rental or loaner vehicle to the consumer at no cost to the consumer until the recall repair has been made. The consumer shall not be provided with a rental or loaner vehicle that is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or a manufacturers recall.
(c)If a vehicle manufacturer requires a franchisee to provide a rental or loaner vehicle to a consumer under subdivision (b), the vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate the franchisee for all costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental vehicle to a consumer. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily rental amount of____ dollars ($____) for each day a consumer uses a loaner or rental vehicle.
(d)A vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for all costs incurred in storing vehicles with a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall in the franchisees possession if the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily amount of ____ dollars ($_____) for each day a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall is in the franchisees possession, the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle, and the recall repair has not been made.
11762.(a)This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758. Nothing in this article shall affect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law.
(b)The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(c)This article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
(d)This article shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11756.(a)For every used vehicle advertised for sale as certified or any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program, a dealer shall obtain a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the dealer shall not advertise for sale or sell that vehicle as certified or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of the used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program until the recall repair has been made.
11758.(a)Before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, pursuant to Section 1661, the department shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall:
This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturers recall. You can get this recall repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations Internet Web site.
(c)This section shall become operative on the date that the Director of Motor Vehicles executes a declaration, to be retained by the director, in which the director certifies that the department has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The director shall post the declaration on the departments Internet Web site and shall send the declaration to the appropriate committees of the Legislature and to the Legislative Counsel.
11760.This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758.
11761.This article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
11762.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
11763.Except as otherwise provided in Section 11758, this article shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 8.SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 22 million recalls were issued in 2013 and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and to the public. Dealers, rental car companies, and private parties offering vehicles for sale or rent now have greater access to recall information than ever before.
(4)Federal law imposes a requirement not to sell a new vehicle subject to a recall, but neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. It is the intent of this act to address used vehicles subject to a recall that are not yet repaired.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of recalls in the car purchasing and rental process, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles while their recalled vehicles are being repaired at a new motor vehicle dealer, and to ensure that a recalled vehicle that poses a risk of imminent harm is not sold or rented to Californians until the risk is removed and the vehicle is repaired.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affects the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)Franchisors sometimes establish programs to reimburse franchisees for loaner or rental cars given to consumers whose vehicles have been recalled, but California franchise laws fail to establish guidelines for rental or loaner vehicle reimbursement.
(4)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fails to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee costs associated with recalled vehicles that cannot be repaired and remain in the franchisees possession.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors, that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably reimbursed for providing loaner or rental vehicles to consumers who have recalled vehicles when the parts or procedures to make the recall repair are not available, and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for recalled vehicles at their dealerships that cannot immediately be repaired and must be stored by the franchisee at the dealership.
SEC. 2.Section 3050 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3050.The board shall do all of the following:
(a)Adopt rules and regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code governing those matters that are specifically committed to its jurisdiction.
(b)Hear and determine, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, an appeal presented by an applicant for, or holder of, a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative when the applicant or licensee submits an appeal provided for in this chapter from a decision arising out of the department.
(c)Consider any matter concerning the activities or practices of any person applying for or holding a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 submitted by any person. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide any matter considered by the board pursuant to this subdivision that involves a dispute between a franchisee and franchisor. After that consideration, the board may do any one or any combination of the following:
(1)Direct the department to conduct investigation of matters that the board deems reasonable, and make a written report on the results of the investigation to the board within the time specified by the board.
(2)Undertake to mediate, arbitrate, or otherwise resolve any honest difference of opinion or viewpoint existing between any member of the public and any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative.
(3)Order the department to exercise any and all authority or power that the department may have with respect to the issuance, renewal, refusal to renew, suspension, or revocation of the license of any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative as that license is required under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5.
(d)Hear and decide, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, a protest presented by a franchisee pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide, any matter involving a protest filed pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060), unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (c) and (d), the courts have jurisdiction over all common law and statutory claims originally cognizable in the courts. For those claims, a party may initiate an action directly in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SEC. 3.Section 3065.2 is added to the Vehicle Code, to read:3065.2.(a)A claim made by a franchisee for payment under Section 11760 shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after receipt by the franchisor. When a claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt shall be deemed approved on the 30th day.
(b)Franchisee claims for compensation under Section 11760 shall not be disapproved unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(c)The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the written disapproval notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(d)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(e)Following the disapproval of a claim, a franchisee shall have six months from receipt of the written notice described in either subdivision (a) or (d), whichever is later, to file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (d). In any hearing pursuant to this subdivision or subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)A claim made by franchisees under this section shall be paid within 30 days following approval. Failure to approve or pay within the time limits specified in this section, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, is not a violation of this section.
(g)(1)Audits of franchisee records for payment under Section 11760 may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis, and for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved and charged back unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim or charge back chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure any material noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not charge back chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not charge back chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after the franchisee receives the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later. If the franchisee cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim, the franchisor shall not charge back chargeback the dealer for that claim. Any chargeback to a franchisee under Section 11760 shall be made within 90 days after the franchisee receives that written notice. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after receipt of the written notice described in either paragraph (3) or (4), a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(i)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 4.Section 3066 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3066.(a)Upon receiving a protest pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the board shall fix a time within 60 days of the order, and place of hearing, and shall send by registered mail a copy of the order to the franchisor, the protesting franchisee, and all individuals and groups that have requested notification by the board of protests and decisions of the board. Except in a case involving a franchisee who deals exclusively in motorcycles, the board or its executive director may, upon a showing of good cause, accelerate or postpone the date initially established for a hearing, but the hearing may not be rescheduled more than 90 days after the boards initial order. For the purpose of accelerating or postponing a hearing date, good cause includes, but is not limited to, the effects upon, and any irreparable harm to, the parties or interested persons or groups if the request for a change in hearing date is not granted. The board or an administrative law judge designated by the board shall hear and consider the oral and documented evidence introduced by the parties and other interested individuals and groups, and the board shall make its decision solely on the record so made. Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Sections 11507.3, 11507.6, 11507.7, 11511, 11511.5, 11513, 11514, 11515, and 11517 of the Government Code apply to these proceedings.
(b)In a hearing on a protest filed pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3070, or 3072, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause to modify, replace, terminate, or refuse to continue a franchise. The franchisee shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause not to enter into a franchise establishing or relocating an additional motor vehicle dealership.
(c)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, in a hearing on a protest alleging a violation of, or filed pursuant to, Section 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the franchisee shall have the burden of proof, but the franchisor has the burden of proof to establish that a franchisee acted with intent to defraud the franchisor when that issue is material to a protest filed pursuant to Section 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3075, or 3076.
(d)A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, or advise other members upon, or decide, a matter involving a protest filed pursuant to this article unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
SEC. 5.Section 4751 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:4751.The department may refuse registration, or the renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle in any of the following events:
(a)If the department is not satisfied that the applicant is entitled thereto under this code.
(b)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with information required in the application or reasonable additional information required by the department.
(c)If the department determines that the applicant has made or permitted unlawful use of any registration certificate, certificate of ownership, or license plates.
(d)If the vehicle is mechanically unfit or unsafe to be operated or moved on the highways.
(e)If the department determines that a manufacturer or dealer has failed during the current or previous year to comply with the provisions of this code relating to the giving of notice to the department of the transfer of a vehicle during the current or previous year.
(f)If the department determines that a lien exists, pursuant to Section 9800, against one or more other vehicles in which the applicant has an ownership interest.
(g)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 32705 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(h)Commencing July 1, 2016, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement pursuant to Section 11758.
SEC. 5.Section 4451 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:4451.(a)The certificate of ownership shall contain all of the following:
(a)
(1)Not less than the information required upon the face of the registration card.
(b)
(2)Provision for notice to the department of a transfer of the title or interest of the owner or legal owner.
(c)
(3)Provision for application for transfer of registration by the transferee.
(d)
(4)Provision for an odometer disclosure statement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 32705 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(5)Commencing July 1, 2016, or as soon thereafter as the department exhausts its supply of existing certificate of ownership forms, provision for a recall disclosure statement pursuant to Section 11758.
(b)Notwithstanding paragraph (5) of subdivision (a), a certificate of ownership previously issued by the department prior to July 1, 2016, and in the possession of a registered owner remains valid for the transfer of registration of a vehicle.
SEC. 6.Section 11713.3 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.3.It is unlawful and a violation of this code for a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch licensed pursuant to this code to do, directly or indirectly through an affiliate, any of the following:
(a)To refuse or fail to deliver in reasonable quantities and within a reasonable time after receipt of an order from a dealer having a franchise for the retail sale of a new vehicle sold or distributed by the manufacturer or distributor, a new vehicle or parts or accessories to new vehicles as are covered by the franchise, if the vehicle, parts, or accessories are publicly advertised as being available for delivery or actually being delivered. This subdivision is not violated, however, if the failure is caused by acts or causes beyond the control of the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(b)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a change in the capital structure of a dealership or the means by or through which the dealer finances the operation of the dealership, if the dealer at all times meets reasonable capital standards agreed to by the dealer and the manufacturer or distributor, and if a change in capital structure does not cause a change in the principal management or have the effect of a sale of the franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor.
(c)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, a dealer to change the executive management of a dealership, other than the principal dealership operator or operators, if the franchise was granted to the dealer in reliance upon the personal qualifications of that person.
(d)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (t), to prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a dealer, or an officer, partner, or stockholder of a dealership, the sale or transfer of a part of the interest of any of them to another person. A dealer, officer, partner, or stockholder shall not, however, have the right to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise, or a right thereunder, without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor except that the consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.
(2)(A)For the transferring franchisee to fail, prior to the sale, transfer, or assignment of a franchisee or the sale, assignment, or transfer of all, or substantially all, of the assets of the franchised business or a controlling interest in the franchised business to another person, to notify the manufacturer or distributor of the franchisees decision to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall include all of the following:
(i)The proposed transferees name and address.
(ii)A copy of all of the agreements relating to the sale, assignment, or transfer of the franchised business or its assets.
(iii)The proposed transferees application for approval to become the successor franchisee. The application shall include forms and related information generally utilized by the manufacturer or distributor in reviewing prospective franchisees, if those forms are readily made available to existing franchisees. As soon as practicable after receipt of the proposed transferees application, the manufacturer or distributor shall notify the franchisee and the proposed transferee of information needed to make the application complete.
(B)For the manufacturer or distributor, to fail, on or before 60 days after the receipt of all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A), or as extended by a written agreement between the manufacturer or distributor and the franchisee, to notify the franchisee of the approval or the disapproval of the sale, transfer, or assignment of the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall be personally served or sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by guaranteed overnight delivery service that provides verification of delivery and shall be directed to the franchisee. A proposed sale, assignment, or transfer shall be deemed approved, unless disapproved by the franchisor in the manner provided by this subdivision. If the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer is disapproved, the franchisor shall include in the notice of disapproval a statement setting forth the reasons for the disapproval.
(3)In an action in which the manufacturers or distributors withholding of consent under this subdivision or subdivision (e) is an issue, whether the withholding of consent was unreasonable is a question of fact requiring consideration of all the existing circumstances.
(e)To prevent, or attempt to prevent, a dealer from receiving fair and reasonable compensation for the value of the franchised business. There shall not be a transfer or assignment of the dealers franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or conditioned upon the release, assignment, novation, waiver, estoppel, or modification of a claim or defense by the dealer.
(f)To obtain money, goods, services, or another benefit from a person with whom the dealer does business, on account of, or in relation to, the transaction between the dealer and that other person, other than for compensation for services rendered, unless the benefit is promptly accounted for, and transmitted to, the dealer.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (3), to obtain from a dealer or enforce against a dealer an agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel that does any of the following:
(A)Modifies or disclaims a duty or obligation of a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative, or a right or privilege of a dealer, pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 or Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 3000) of Division 2.
(B)Limits or constrains the right of a dealer to file, pursue, or submit evidence in connection with a protest before the board.
(C)Requires a dealer to terminate a franchise.
(D)Requires a controversy between a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative and a dealer to be referred to a person for a binding determination. However, this subparagraph does not prohibit arbitration before an independent arbitrator, provided that whenever a motor vehicle franchise contract provides for the use of arbitration to resolve a controversy arising out of, or relating to, that contract, arbitration may be used to settle the controversy only if, after the controversy arises, all parties to the controversy consent in writing to use arbitration to settle the controversy. For the purpose of this subparagraph, the terms motor vehicle and motor vehicle franchise contract shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 1226 of Title 15 of the United States Code. If arbitration is elected to settle a dispute under a motor vehicle franchise contract, the arbitrator shall provide the parties to the arbitration with a written explanation of the factual and legal basis for the award.
(2)An agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel prohibited by this subdivision shall be unenforceable and void.
(3)This subdivision does not do any of the following:
(A)Limit or restrict the terms upon which parties to a protest before the board, civil action, or other proceeding can settle or resolve, or stipulate to evidentiary or procedural matters during the course of, a protest, civil action, or other proceeding.
(B)Affect the enforceability of any stipulated order or other order entered by the board.
(C)Affect the enforceability of any provision in a contract if the provision is not prohibited under this subdivision or any other law.
(D)Affect the enforceability of a provision in any contract entered into on or before December 31, 2011.
(E)Prohibit a dealer from waiving its right to file a protest pursuant to Section 3065.1 if the waiver agreement is entered into after a franchisor incentive program claim has been disapproved by the franchisor and the waiver is voluntarily given as part of an agreement to settle that claim.
(F)Prohibit a voluntary agreement supported by valuable consideration, other than granting or renewing a franchise, that does both of the following:
(i)Provides that a dealer establish or maintain exclusive facilities, personnel, or display space or provides that a dealer make a material alteration, expansion, or addition to a dealership facility.
(ii)Contains no waiver or other provision prohibited by subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1).
(G)Prohibit an agreement separate from the franchise agreement that implements a dealers election to terminate the franchise if the agreement is conditioned only on a specified time for termination or payment of consideration to the dealer.
(H)(i)Prohibit a voluntary waiver agreement, supported by valuable consideration, other than the consideration of renewing a franchise, to waive the right of a dealer to file a protest under Section 3062 for the proposed establishment or relocation of a specific proposed dealership, if the waiver agreement provides all of the following:
(I)The approximate address at which the proposed dealership will be located.
(II)The planning potential used to establish the proposed dealerships facility, personnel, and capital requirements.
(III)An approximation of projected vehicle and parts sales, and number of vehicles to be serviced at the proposed dealership.
(IV)Whether the franchisor or affiliate will hold an ownership interest in the proposed dealership or real property of the proposed dealership, and the approximate percentage of any franchisor or affiliate ownership interest in the proposed dealership.
(V)The line-makes to be operated at the proposed dealership.
(VI)If known at the time the waiver agreement is executed, the identity of the dealer who will operate the proposed dealership.
(VII)The date the waiver agreement is to expire, which may not be more than 30 months after the date of execution of the waiver agreement.
(ii)Notwithstanding the provisions of a waiver agreement entered into pursuant to the provisions of this subparagraph, a dealer may file a protest under Section 3062 if any of the information provided pursuant to clause (i) has become materially inaccurate since the waiver agreement was executed. Any determination of the enforceability of a waiver agreement shall be determined by the board and the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)To increase prices of motor vehicles that the dealer had ordered for private retail consumers prior to the dealers receipt of the written official price increase notification. A sales contract signed by a private retail consumer is evidence of the order. In the event of manufacturer price reductions, the amount of the reduction received by a dealer shall be passed on to the private retail consumer by the dealer if the retail price was negotiated on the basis of the previous higher price to the dealer. Price reductions apply to all vehicles in the dealers inventory that were subject to the price reduction. Price differences applicable to new model or series motor vehicles at the time of the introduction of new models or series shall not be considered a price increase or price decrease. This subdivision does not apply to price changes caused by either of the following:
(1)The addition to a motor vehicle of required or optional equipment pursuant to state or federal law.
(2)Revaluation of the United States dollar in the case of a foreign-make vehicle.
(i)To fail to pay to a dealer, within a reasonable time following receipt of a valid claim by a dealer thereof, a payment agreed to be made by the manufacturer or distributor to the dealer by reason of the fact that a new vehicle of a prior year model is in the dealers inventory at the time of introduction of new model vehicles.
(j)To deny the widow, widower, or heirs designated by a deceased owner of a dealership the opportunity to participate in the ownership of the dealership or successor dealership under a valid franchise for a reasonable time after the death of the owner.
(k)To offer refunds or other types of inducements to a person for the purchase of new motor vehicles of a certain line-make to be sold to the state or a political subdivision of the state without making the same offer to all other dealers in the same line-make within the relevant market area.
(l)To modify, replace, enter into, relocate, terminate, or refuse to renew a franchise in violation of Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060) of Chapter 6 of Division 2.
(m)To employ a person as a representative who has not been licensed pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 11900) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(n)To deny a dealer the right of free association with another dealer for a lawful purpose.
(o)(1)To compete with a dealer in the same line-make operating under an agreement or franchise from a manufacturer or distributor in the relevant market area.
(2)A manufacturer, branch, or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by, a manufacturer, branch, or distributor, shall not, however, be deemed to be competing in the following limited circumstances:
(A)Owning or operating a dealership for a temporary period, not to exceed one year at the location of a former dealership of the same line-make that has been out of operation for less than six months. However, after a showing of good cause by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor that it needs additional time to operate a dealership in preparation for sale to a successor independent franchisee, the board may extend the time period.
(B)Owning an interest in a dealer as part of a bona fide dealer development program that satisfies all of the following requirements:
(i)The sole purpose of the program is to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualities ordinarily required of prospective franchisees and the dealer development candidate is an individual who is unable to acquire the franchise without assistance of the program.
(ii)The dealer development candidate has made a significant investment subject to loss in the franchised business of the dealer.
(iii)The program requires the dealer development candidate to manage the day-to-day operations and business affairs of the dealer and to acquire, within a reasonable time and on reasonable terms and conditions, beneficial ownership and control of a majority interest in the dealer and disassociation of any direct or indirect ownership or control by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor.
(C)Owning a wholly owned subsidiary corporation of a distributor that sells motor vehicles at retail, if, for at least three years prior to January 1, 1973, the subsidiary corporation has been a wholly owned subsidiary of the distributor and engaged in the sale of vehicles at retail.
(3)(A)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns or operates a dealership in the manner described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, within 10 days, each time it commences or terminates operation of a dealership and each time it acquires, changes, or divests itself of an ownership interest.
(B)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns an interest in a dealer in the manner described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, annually, of the name and location of each dealer in which it has an ownership interest, the name of the bona fide dealer development owner or owners, and the ownership interests of each owner expressed as a percentage.
(p)To unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to warranty reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees to make warranty adjustments with retail customers.
(q)To sell vehicles to a person not licensed pursuant to this chapter for resale.
(r)To fail to affix an identification number to a park trailer, as described in Section 18009.3 of the Health and Safety Code, that is manufactured on or after January 1, 1987, and that does not clearly identify the unit as a park trailer to the department. The configuration of the identification number shall be approved by the department.
(s)To dishonor a warranty, rebate, or other incentive offered to the public or a dealer in connection with the retail sale of a new motor vehicle, based solely upon the fact that an autobroker arranged or negotiated the sale. This subdivision shall not prohibit the disallowance of that rebate or incentive if the purchaser or dealer is ineligible to receive the rebate or incentive pursuant to any other term or condition of a rebate or incentive program.
(t)To exercise a right of first refusal or other right requiring a franchisee or an owner of the franchise to sell, transfer, or assign to the franchisor, or to a nominee of the franchisor, all or a material part of the franchised business or of the assets of the franchised business unless all of the following requirements are met:
(1)The franchise authorizes the franchisor to exercise a right of first refusal to acquire the franchised business or assets of the franchised business in the event of a proposed sale, transfer, or assignment.
(2)The franchisor gives written notice of its exercise of the right of first refusal no later than 45 days after the franchisor receives all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(3)The sale, transfer, or assignment being proposed relates to not less than all or substantially all of the assets of the franchised business or to a controlling interest in the franchised business.
(4)The proposed transferee is neither a family member of an owner of the franchised business, nor a managerial employee of the franchisee owning 15 percent or more of the franchised business, nor a corporation, partnership, or other legal entity owned by the existing owners of the franchised business. For purposes of this paragraph, a family member means the spouse of an owner of the franchised business, the child, grandchild, brother, sister, or parent of an owner, or a spouse of one of those family members. This paragraph does not limit the rights of the franchisor to disapprove a proposed transferee as provided in subdivision (d).
(5)Upon the franchisors exercise of the right of first refusal, the consideration paid by the franchisor to the franchisee and owners of the franchised business shall equal or exceed all consideration that each of them were to have received under the terms of, or in connection with, the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer, and the franchisor shall comply with all the terms and conditions of the agreement or agreements to sell, transfer, or assign the franchised business.
(6)The franchisor shall reimburse the proposed transferee for expenses paid or incurred by the proposed transferee in evaluating, investigating, and negotiating the proposed transfer to the extent those expenses do not exceed the usual, customary, and reasonable fees charged for similar work done in the area in which the franchised business is located. These expenses include, but are not limited to, legal and accounting expenses, and expenses incurred for title reports and environmental or other investigations of real property on which the franchisees operations are conducted. The proposed transferee shall provide the franchisor a written itemization of those expenses, and a copy of all nonprivileged reports and studies for which expenses were incurred, if any, within 30 days of the proposed transferees receipt of a written request from the franchisor for that accounting. The franchisor shall make payment within 30 days of exercising the right of first refusal.
(u)(1)To unfairly discriminate in favor of a dealership owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by the manufacturer or distributor. Unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A)The furnishing to a franchisee or dealer that is owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor of any of the following:
(i)A vehicle that is not made available to each franchisee pursuant to a reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly, and a part or accessory that is not made available to all franchisees on an equal basis when there is no reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly.
(ii)A vehicle, part, or accessory that is not made available to each franchisee on comparable delivery terms, including the time of delivery after the placement of an order. Differences in delivery terms due to geographic distances or other factors beyond the control of the manufacturer, branch, or distributor shall not constitute unfair competition.
(iii)Information obtained from a franchisee by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor concerning the business affairs or operations of a franchisee in which the manufacturer, branch, or distributor does not have an ownership interest. The information includes, but is not limited to, information contained in financial statements and operating reports, the name, address, or other personal information or buying, leasing, or service behavior of a dealer customer, and other information that, if provided to a franchisee or dealer owned or controlled by a manufacturer or distributor, would give that franchisee or dealer a competitive advantage. This clause does not apply if the information is provided pursuant to a subpoena or court order, or to aggregated information made available to all franchisees.
(iv)Sales or service incentives, discounts, or promotional programs that are not made available to all California franchises of the same line-make on an equal basis.
(B)Referring a prospective purchaser or lessee to a dealer in which a manufacturer, branch, or distributor has an ownership interest, unless the prospective purchaser or lessee resides in the area of responsibility assigned to that dealer or the prospective purchaser or lessee requests to be referred to that dealer. For purposes of this subparagraph, the term area of responsibility means a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(2)This subdivision does not prohibit a franchisor from granting a franchise to prospective franchisees or assisting those franchisees during the course of the franchise relationship as part of a program or programs to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualifications ordinarily required of prospective franchisees.
(v)(1)To access, modify, or extract information from a confidential dealer computer record, as defined in Section 11713.25, without obtaining the prior written consent of the dealer and without maintaining administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the security, confidentiality, and integrity of the information.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(w)(1)To use electronic, contractual, or other means to prevent or interfere with any of the following:
(A)The lawful efforts of a dealer to comply with federal and state data security and privacy laws.
(B)The ability of a dealer to do either of the following:
(i)Ensure that specific data accessed from the dealers computer system is within the scope of consent specified in subdivision (v).
(ii)Monitor specific data accessed from or written to the dealers computer system.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(x)(1)To unfairly discriminate against a franchisee selling a service contract, debt cancellation agreement, maintenance agreement, or similar product not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate. For purposes of this subdivision, unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Express or implied statements that the dealer is under an obligation to exclusively sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(B)Express or implied statements that selling or offering to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, or the failure to sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate will have any negative consequences for the dealer.
(C)Measuring a dealers performance under a franchise agreement based upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(D)Requiring a dealer to actively promote the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(E)Conditioning access to vehicles or parts, or vehicle sales or service incentives upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(2)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a manufacturer from, offering an incentive program to vehicle dealers who voluntarily sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, if the program does not provide vehicle sales or service incentives.
(3)This subdivision does not prohibit a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch from requiring a franchisee that sells a used vehicle as certified under a certified used vehicle program established by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch to provide a service contract approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(4)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a franchisor from requiring a franchisee to provide, the following notice prior to the sale of the service contract if the service contract is not provided or backed by the franchisor and the vehicle is of the franchised line-make:
Service Contract Disclosure
The service contract you are purchasing is not provided or backed by the manufacturer of the vehicle you are purchasing. The manufacturer of the vehicle is not responsible for claims or repairs under this service contract.
_____________________
Signature of Purchaser
(y)To take or threaten to take any adverse action against a dealer pursuant to an export or sale-for-resale prohibition because the dealer sold or leased a vehicle to a customer who either exported the vehicle to a foreign country or resold the vehicle in violation of the prohibition, unless the export or sale-for-resale prohibition policy was provided to the dealer in writing prior to the sale or lease, and the dealer knew or reasonably should have known of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle in violation of the prohibition at the time of sale or lease. If the dealer causes the vehicle to be registered in this or any other state, and collects or causes to be collected any applicable sales or use tax due to this state, a rebuttable presumption is established that the dealer did not have reason to know of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle.
(z)For purposes of this section, the term area of responsibility means a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(z)
(aa)Commencing July 1, 2016, to unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) of Section 11760.
SEC. 7.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.).
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.). A manufacturers recall does not include a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(c)The term new motor vehicle dealer has the same meaning as in Section 426.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific Stop Sale Stop Drive recall and manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(g)A Stop Sale Stop Drive recall is a recall notice provided to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration informs the dealer to stop the sale of the vehicle or contains preremedy any precaution advice to the owner to stop operating the vehicle.
(h)A vehicle manufacturer is a person who manufactures, assembles, or distributes new motor vehicles, sold or leased, that are subject to registration under this code.
11754.(a)A dealer shall not display or offer for sale at retail a used vehicle, as defined in Section 665, that is subject to registration under this code, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the dealer shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is of the same line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer, the dealer shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(d)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is not of the same line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer or the dealer does not have a franchise, the dealer may sell or lease the vehicle at retail if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The dealer discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to sale or lease.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle has a manufacturers recall and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicles line-make.
(e)To comply with subdivision (d), and notwithstanding Section 2981.9 of the Civil Code, a recall database report, that indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the recall repair has not been made, shall be disclosed and the disclosure signed by the consumer in a document separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
(f)The disclosure by a dealer, and receipt and acknowledgment by the consumer, of the information specified in subdivisions (d) and (e) has no legal effect other than to demonstrate compliance by the dealer with the requirements prescribed in those subdivisions. Nothing in this article shall be interpreted to place consumers in a less advantageous legal position for having received or signed the disclosures provided pursuant to this article than if no disclosure had been made.
11756.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), or sooner if practicable, a rental car company is prohibited from renting or offering for rent any vehicle subject to that recall.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the rental vehicle becomes available to the rental car company, the rental car company may not rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.(a)The department may refuse transfer of registration of a motor vehicle under this code unless the transferee, in submitting an application to the department for title, includes with the application a statement signed and dated by the transferor acknowledging that all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls were disclosed to the transferee as provided in subdivision (c).
(b)If the title to a motor vehicle issued to a transferor is in the possession of a lienholder when the transferor transfers ownership of the vehicle, the transferor may use a written power of attorney in making the recall disclosure required under subdivision (c).
(c)A transferor transferring registration of a motor vehicle shall disclose, in writing, to the transferee all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls. A person acquiring the vehicle shall not accept a vehicle transfer and reassignment document unless it is complete.
(d)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) do not apply to the transfer of a motor vehicle to a dealer or wholesaler.
11758.Commencing July 1, 2016, or as soon thereafter as the department exhausts its supply of existing certificate of ownership forms, the department shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the certificate of ownership and bill of sale form for private transactions:
This vehicle may have an unrepaired manufacturers recall. Please ask the seller if there is an unrepaired manufacturers recall on this vehicle. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrations website.
11760.(a)A vehicle manufacturer shall clearly and conspicuously display on its Internet Web site and in all recall notifications pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), whether a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(b)When a consumer seeks to repair a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall as identified in a recall database report and the parts or procedures for the repair are not yet available, the vehicle manufacturer shall, upon request by the consumer, provide a rental or loaner vehicle to the consumer at no cost to the consumer until the recall repair has been made. The consumer shall not be provided with a rental or loaner vehicle that is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or a manufacturers recall.
(c)If a vehicle manufacturer requires a franchisee to provide a rental or loaner vehicle to a consumer under subdivision (b), the vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate the franchisee for all costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental vehicle to a consumer. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily rental amount of____ dollars ($____) for each day a consumer uses a loaner or rental vehicle.
(d)A vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for all costs incurred in storing vehicles with a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall in the franchisees possession if the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily amount of ____ dollars ($_____) for each day a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall is in the franchisees possession, the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle, and the recall repair has not been made.
11762.(a)This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758. Nothing in this article shall affect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law.
(b)The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(c)This article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
(d)This article shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 8.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 22 million recalls were issued in 2013 and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others others, about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and available to the public. Dealers, rental car companies, and private parties offering vehicles for sale or rent now have greater access to recall information than ever before.
(4)Federal law imposes a requirement not to sell a new vehicle subject to a recall, but neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. It is the intent of this act to address used vehicles subject to a recall that are not yet repaired.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of recalls in the car purchasing and rental process, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles while their recalled vehicles are being repaired at a new motor vehicle dealer, and to ensure that a recalled vehicle that poses a risk of imminent harm is not sold or rented to Californians until the risk is removed and the vehicle is repaired.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affects the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)Franchisors sometimes establish programs to reimburse franchisees for loaner or rental cars given to consumers whose vehicles have been recalled, but California franchise laws fail to establish guidelines for rental or loaner vehicle reimbursement.
(4)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fails to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee costs associated with recalled vehicles that cannot be repaired and remain in the franchisees possession.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors, that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably reimbursed for providing loaner or rental vehicles to consumers who have recalled vehicles when the parts or procedures to make the recall repair are not available, and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for recalled vehicles at their dealerships that cannot immediately be repaired and must be stored by the franchisee at the dealership.
SEC. 2.Section 3050 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3050.The board shall do all of the following:
(a)Adopt rules and regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code governing those matters that are specifically committed to its jurisdiction.
(b)Hear and determine, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, an appeal presented by an applicant for, or holder of, a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative when the applicant or licensee submits an appeal provided for in this chapter from a decision arising out of the department.
(c)Consider any matter concerning the activities or practices of any person applying for or holding a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 submitted by any person. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide any matter considered by the board pursuant to this subdivision that involves a dispute between a franchisee and franchisor. After that consideration, the board may do any one or any combination of the following:
(1)Direct the department to conduct investigation of matters that the board deems reasonable, and make a written report on the results of the investigation to the board within the time specified by the board.
(2)Undertake to mediate, arbitrate, or otherwise resolve any honest difference of opinion or viewpoint existing between any member of the public and any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative.
(3)Order the department to exercise any and all authority or power that the department may have with respect to the issuance, renewal, refusal to renew, suspension, or revocation of the license of any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative as that license is required under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5.
(d)Hear and decide, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, a protest presented by a franchisee pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide, any matter involving a protest filed pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060), unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (c) and (d), the courts have jurisdiction over all common law and statutory claims originally cognizable in the courts. For those claims, a party may initiate an action directly in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SEC. 3.Section 3065.2 is added to the Vehicle Code, to read:3065.2.(a)A claim made by a franchisee for payment under Section 11760 shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after receipt by the franchisor. When a claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt shall be deemed approved on the 30th day.
(b)Franchisee claims for compensation under Section 11760 shall not be disapproved unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(c)The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the written disapproval notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(d)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(e)Following the disapproval of a claim, a franchisee shall have six months from receipt of the written notice described in either subdivision (a) or (d), whichever is later, to file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (d). In any hearing pursuant to this subdivision or subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)A claim made by franchisees under this section shall be paid within 30 days following approval. Failure to approve or pay within the time limits specified in this section, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, is not a violation of this section.
(g)(1)Audits of franchisee records for payment under Section 11760 may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis, and for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved and charged back unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim or chargeback charge back a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure any material noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback charge back the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback charge back the franchisee until 45 days after the franchisee receives the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later. If the franchisee cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim, the franchisor shall not chargeback charge back the dealer for that claim. Any chargeback to a franchisee for under Section 11760 shall be made within 90 days after the franchisee receives that written notice. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after receipt of the written notice described in either paragraph (3) or (4), a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(i)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 4.Section 3066 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3066.(a)Upon receiving a protest pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the board shall fix a time within 60 days of the order, and place of hearing, and shall send by registered mail a copy of the order to the franchisor, the protesting franchisee, and all individuals and groups that have requested notification by the board of protests and decisions of the board. Except in a case involving a franchisee who deals exclusively in motorcycles, the board or its executive director may, upon a showing of good cause, accelerate or postpone the date initially established for a hearing, but the hearing may not be rescheduled more than 90 days after the boards initial order. For the purpose of accelerating or postponing a hearing date, good cause includes, but is not limited to, the effects upon, and any irreparable harm to, the parties or interested persons or groups if the request for a change in hearing date is not granted. The board or an administrative law judge designated by the board shall hear and consider the oral and documented evidence introduced by the parties and other interested individuals and groups, and the board shall make its decision solely on the record so made. Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Sections 11507.3, 11507.6, 11507.7, 11511, 11511.5, 11513, 11514, 11515, and 11517 of the Government Code apply to these proceedings.
(b)In a hearing on a protest filed pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3070, or 3072, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause to modify, replace, terminate, or refuse to continue a franchise. The franchisee shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause not to enter into a franchise establishing or relocating an additional motor vehicle dealership.
(c)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, in a hearing on a protest alleging a violation of, or filed pursuant to, Section 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the franchisee shall have the burden of proof, but the franchisor has the burden of proof to establish that a franchisee acted with intent to defraud the franchisor when that issue is material to a protest filed pursuant to Section 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3075, or 3076.
(d)A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, or advise other members upon, or decide, a matter involving a protest filed pursuant to this article unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
SEC. 5.Section 4751 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:4751.The department may refuse registration, or the renewal or transfer of registration, of a vehicle in any of the following events:
(a)If the department is not satisfied that the applicant is entitled thereto under this code.
(b)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with information required in the application or reasonable additional information required by the department.
(c)If the department determines that the applicant has made or permitted unlawful use of any registration certificate, certificate of ownership, or license plates.
(d)If the vehicle is mechanically unfit or unsafe to be operated or moved on the highways.
(e)If the department determines that a manufacturer or dealer has failed during the current or previous year to comply with the provisions of this code relating to the giving of notice to the department of the transfer of a vehicle during the current or previous year.
(f)If the department determines that a lien exists, pursuant to Section 9800, against one or more other vehicles in which the applicant has an ownership interest.
(g)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 32705 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(h)Commencing July 1, 2016, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement pursuant to Section 11758.
SEC. 6.Section 11713.3 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.3.It is unlawful and a violation of this code for a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch licensed pursuant to this code to do, directly or indirectly through an affiliate, any of the following:
(a)To refuse or fail to deliver in reasonable quantities and within a reasonable time after receipt of an order from a dealer having a franchise for the retail sale of a new vehicle sold or distributed by the manufacturer or distributor, a new vehicle or parts or accessories to new vehicles as are covered by the franchise, if the vehicle, parts, or accessories are publicly advertised as being available for delivery or actually being delivered. This subdivision is not violated, however, if the failure is caused by acts or causes beyond the control of the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(b)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a change in the capital structure of a dealership or the means by or through which the dealer finances the operation of the dealership, if the dealer at all times meets reasonable capital standards agreed to by the dealer and the manufacturer or distributor, and if a change in capital structure does not cause a change in the principal management or have the effect of a sale of the franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor.
(c)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, a dealer to change the executive management of a dealership, other than the principal dealership operator or operators, if the franchise was granted to the dealer in reliance upon the personal qualifications of that person.
(d)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (t), to prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a dealer, or an officer, partner, or stockholder of a dealership, the sale or transfer of a part of the interest of any of them to another person. A dealer, officer, partner, or stockholder shall not, however, have the right to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise, or a right thereunder, without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor except that the consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.
(2)(A)For the transferring franchisee to fail, prior to the sale, transfer, or assignment of a franchisee or the sale, assignment, or transfer of all, or substantially all, of the assets of the franchised business or a controlling interest in the franchised business to another person, to notify the manufacturer or distributor of the franchisees decision to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall include all of the following:
(i)The proposed transferees name and address.
(ii)A copy of all of the agreements relating to the sale, assignment, or transfer of the franchised business or its assets.
(iii)The proposed transferees application for approval to become the successor franchisee. The application shall include forms and related information generally utilized by the manufacturer or distributor in reviewing prospective franchisees, if those forms are readily made available to existing franchisees. As soon as practicable after receipt of the proposed transferees application, the manufacturer or distributor shall notify the franchisee and the proposed transferee of information needed to make the application complete.
(B)For the manufacturer or distributor, to fail, on or before 60 days after the receipt of all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A), or as extended by a written agreement between the manufacturer or distributor and the franchisee, to notify the franchisee of the approval or the disapproval of the sale, transfer, or assignment of the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall be personally served or sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by guaranteed overnight delivery service that provides verification of delivery and shall be directed to the franchisee. A proposed sale, assignment, or transfer shall be deemed approved, unless disapproved by the franchisor in the manner provided by this subdivision. If the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer is disapproved, the franchisor shall include in the notice of disapproval a statement setting forth the reasons for the disapproval.
(3)In an action in which the manufacturers or distributors withholding of consent under this subdivision or subdivision (e) is an issue, whether the withholding of consent was unreasonable is a question of fact requiring consideration of all the existing circumstances.
(e)To prevent, or attempt to prevent, a dealer from receiving fair and reasonable compensation for the value of the franchised business. There shall not be a transfer or assignment of the dealers franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or conditioned upon the release, assignment, novation, waiver, estoppel, or modification of a claim or defense by the dealer.
(f)To obtain money, goods, services, or another benefit from a person with whom the dealer does business, on account of, or in relation to, the transaction between the dealer and that other person, other than for compensation for services rendered, unless the benefit is promptly accounted for, and transmitted to, the dealer.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (3), to obtain from a dealer or enforce against a dealer an agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel that does any of the following:
(A)Modifies or disclaims a duty or obligation of a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative, or a right or privilege of a dealer, pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 or Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 3000) of Division 2.
(B)Limits or constrains the right of a dealer to file, pursue, or submit evidence in connection with a protest before the board.
(C)Requires a dealer to terminate a franchise.
(D)Requires a controversy between a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative and a dealer to be referred to a person for a binding determination. However, this subparagraph does not prohibit arbitration before an independent arbitrator, provided that whenever a motor vehicle franchise contract provides for the use of arbitration to resolve a controversy arising out of, or relating to, that contract, arbitration may be used to settle the controversy only if, after the controversy arises, all parties to the controversy consent in writing to use arbitration to settle the controversy. For the purpose of this subparagraph, the terms motor vehicle and motor vehicle franchise contract shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 1226 of Title 15 of the United States Code. If arbitration is elected to settle a dispute under a motor vehicle franchise contract, the arbitrator shall provide the parties to the arbitration with a written explanation of the factual and legal basis for the award.
(2)An agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel prohibited by this subdivision shall be unenforceable and void.
(3)This subdivision does not do any of the following:
(A)Limit or restrict the terms upon which parties to a protest before the board, civil action, or other proceeding can settle or resolve, or stipulate to evidentiary or procedural matters during the course of, a protest, civil action, or other proceeding.
(B)Affect the enforceability of any stipulated order or other order entered by the board.
(C)Affect the enforceability of any provision in a contract if the provision is not prohibited under this subdivision or any other law.
(D)Affect the enforceability of a provision in any contract entered into on or before December 31, 2011.
(E)Prohibit a dealer from waiving its right to file a protest pursuant to Section 3065.1 if the waiver agreement is entered into after a franchisor incentive program claim has been disapproved by the franchisor and the waiver is voluntarily given as part of an agreement to settle that claim.
(F)Prohibit a voluntary agreement supported by valuable consideration, other than granting or renewing a franchise, that does both of the following:
(i)Provides that a dealer establish or maintain exclusive facilities, personnel, or display space or provides that a dealer make a material alteration, expansion, or addition to a dealership facility.
(ii)Contains no waiver or other provision prohibited by subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1).
(G)Prohibit an agreement separate from the franchise agreement that implements a dealers election to terminate the franchise if the agreement is conditioned only on a specified time for termination or payment of consideration to the dealer.
(H)(i)Prohibit a voluntary waiver agreement, supported by valuable consideration, other than the consideration of renewing a franchise, to waive the right of a dealer to file a protest under Section 3062 for the proposed establishment or relocation of a specific proposed dealership, if the waiver agreement provides all of the following:
(I)The approximate address at which the proposed dealership will be located.
(II)The planning potential used to establish the proposed dealerships facility, personnel, and capital requirements.
(III)An approximation of projected vehicle and parts sales, and number of vehicles to be serviced at the proposed dealership.
(IV)Whether the franchisor or affiliate will hold an ownership interest in the proposed dealership or real property of the proposed dealership, and the approximate percentage of any franchisor or affiliate ownership interest in the proposed dealership.
(V)The line-makes to be operated at the proposed dealership.
(VI)If known at the time the waiver agreement is executed, the identity of the dealer who will operate the proposed dealership.
(VII)The date the waiver agreement is to expire, which may not be more than 30 months after the date of execution of the waiver agreement.
(ii)Notwithstanding the provisions of a waiver agreement entered into pursuant to the provisions of this subparagraph, a dealer may file a protest under Section 3062 if any of the information provided pursuant to clause (i) has become materially inaccurate since the waiver agreement was executed. Any determination of the enforceability of a waiver agreement shall be determined by the board and the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)To increase prices of motor vehicles that the dealer had ordered for private retail consumers prior to the dealers receipt of the written official price increase notification. A sales contract signed by a private retail consumer is evidence of the order. In the event of manufacturer price reductions, the amount of the reduction received by a dealer shall be passed on to the private retail consumer by the dealer if the retail price was negotiated on the basis of the previous higher price to the dealer. Price reductions apply to all vehicles in the dealers inventory that were subject to the price reduction. Price differences applicable to new model or series motor vehicles at the time of the introduction of new models or series shall not be considered a price increase or price decrease. This subdivision does not apply to price changes caused by either of the following:
(1)The addition to a motor vehicle of required or optional equipment pursuant to state or federal law.
(2)Revaluation of the United States dollar in the case of a foreign-make vehicle.
(i)To fail to pay to a dealer, within a reasonable time following receipt of a valid claim by a dealer thereof, a payment agreed to be made by the manufacturer or distributor to the dealer by reason of the fact that a new vehicle of a prior year model is in the dealers inventory at the time of introduction of new model vehicles.
(j)To deny the widow, widower, or heirs designated by a deceased owner of a dealership the opportunity to participate in the ownership of the dealership or successor dealership under a valid franchise for a reasonable time after the death of the owner.
(k)To offer refunds or other types of inducements to a person for the purchase of new motor vehicles of a certain line-make to be sold to the state or a political subdivision of the state without making the same offer to all other dealers in the same line-make within the relevant market area.
(l)To modify, replace, enter into, relocate, terminate, or refuse to renew a franchise in violation of Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060) of Chapter 6 of Division 2.
(m)To employ a person as a representative who has not been licensed pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 11900) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(n)To deny a dealer the right of free association with another dealer for a lawful purpose.
(o)(1)To compete with a dealer in the same line-make operating under an agreement or franchise from a manufacturer or distributor in the relevant market area.
(2)A manufacturer, branch, or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by, a manufacturer, branch, or distributor, shall not, however, be deemed to be competing in the following limited circumstances:
(A)Owning or operating a dealership for a temporary period, not to exceed one year at the location of a former dealership of the same line-make that has been out of operation for less than six months. However, after a showing of good cause by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor that it needs additional time to operate a dealership in preparation for sale to a successor independent franchisee, the board may extend the time period.
(B)Owning an interest in a dealer as part of a bona fide dealer development program that satisfies all of the following requirements:
(i)The sole purpose of the program is to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualities ordinarily required of prospective franchisees and the dealer development candidate is an individual who is unable to acquire the franchise without assistance of the program.
(ii)The dealer development candidate has made a significant investment subject to loss in the franchised business of the dealer.
(iii)The program requires the dealer development candidate to manage the day-to-day operations and business affairs of the dealer and to acquire, within a reasonable time and on reasonable terms and conditions, beneficial ownership and control of a majority interest in the dealer and disassociation of any direct or indirect ownership or control by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor.
(C)Owning a wholly owned subsidiary corporation of a distributor that sells motor vehicles at retail, if, for at least three years prior to January 1, 1973, the subsidiary corporation has been a wholly owned subsidiary of the distributor and engaged in the sale of vehicles at retail.
(3)(A)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns or operates a dealership in the manner described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, within 10 days, each time it commences or terminates operation of a dealership and each time it acquires, changes, or divests itself of an ownership interest.
(B)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns an interest in a dealer in the manner described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, annually, of the name and location of each dealer in which it has an ownership interest, the name of the bona fide dealer development owner or owners, and the ownership interests of each owner expressed as a percentage.
(p)To unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to warranty reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees to make warranty adjustments with retail customers.
(q)To sell vehicles to a person not licensed pursuant to this chapter for resale.
(r)To fail to affix an identification number to a park trailer, as described in Section 18009.3 of the Health and Safety Code, that is manufactured on or after January 1, 1987, and that does not clearly identify the unit as a park trailer to the department. The configuration of the identification number shall be approved by the department.
(s)To dishonor a warranty, rebate, or other incentive offered to the public or a dealer in connection with the retail sale of a new motor vehicle, based solely upon the fact that an autobroker arranged or negotiated the sale. This subdivision shall not prohibit the disallowance of that rebate or incentive if the purchaser or dealer is ineligible to receive the rebate or incentive pursuant to any other term or condition of a rebate or incentive program.
(t)To exercise a right of first refusal or other right requiring a franchisee or an owner of the franchise to sell, transfer, or assign to the franchisor, or to a nominee of the franchisor, all or a material part of the franchised business or of the assets of the franchised business unless all of the following requirements are met:
(1)The franchise authorizes the franchisor to exercise a right of first refusal to acquire the franchised business or assets of the franchised business in the event of a proposed sale, transfer, or assignment.
(2)The franchisor gives written notice of its exercise of the right of first refusal no later than 45 days after the franchisor receives all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(3)The sale, transfer, or assignment being proposed relates to not less than all or substantially all of the assets of the franchised business or to a controlling interest in the franchised business.
(4)The proposed transferee is neither a family member of an owner of the franchised business, nor a managerial employee of the franchisee owning 15 percent or more of the franchised business, nor a corporation, partnership, or other legal entity owned by the existing owners of the franchised business. For purposes of this paragraph, a family member means the spouse of an owner of the franchised business, the child, grandchild, brother, sister, or parent of an owner, or a spouse of one of those family members. This paragraph does not limit the rights of the franchisor to disapprove a proposed transferee as provided in subdivision (d).
(5)Upon the franchisors exercise of the right of first refusal, the consideration paid by the franchisor to the franchisee and owners of the franchised business shall equal or exceed all consideration that each of them were to have received under the terms of, or in connection with, the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer, and the franchisor shall comply with all the terms and conditions of the agreement or agreements to sell, transfer, or assign the franchised business.
(6)The franchisor shall reimburse the proposed transferee for expenses paid or incurred by the proposed transferee in evaluating, investigating, and negotiating the proposed transfer to the extent those expenses do not exceed the usual, customary, and reasonable fees charged for similar work done in the area in which the franchised business is located. These expenses include, but are not limited to, legal and accounting expenses, and expenses incurred for title reports and environmental or other investigations of real property on which the franchisees operations are conducted. The proposed transferee shall provide the franchisor a written itemization of those expenses, and a copy of all nonprivileged reports and studies for which expenses were incurred, if any, within 30 days of the proposed transferees receipt of a written request from the franchisor for that accounting. The franchisor shall make payment within 30 days of exercising the right of first refusal.
(u)(1)To unfairly discriminate in favor of a dealership owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by the manufacturer or distributor. Unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A)The furnishing to a franchisee or dealer that is owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor of any of the following:
(i)A vehicle that is not made available to each franchisee pursuant to a reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly, and a part or accessory that is not made available to all franchisees on an equal basis when there is no reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly.
(ii)A vehicle, part, or accessory that is not made available to each franchisee on comparable delivery terms, including the time of delivery after the placement of an order. Differences in delivery terms due to geographic distances or other factors beyond the control of the manufacturer, branch, or distributor shall not constitute unfair competition.
(iii)Information obtained from a franchisee by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor concerning the business affairs or operations of a franchisee in which the manufacturer, branch, or distributor does not have an ownership interest. The information includes, but is not limited to, information contained in financial statements and operating reports, the name, address, or other personal information or buying, leasing, or service behavior of a dealer customer, and other information that, if provided to a franchisee or dealer owned or controlled by a manufacturer or distributor, would give that franchisee or dealer a competitive advantage. This clause does not apply if the information is provided pursuant to a subpoena or court order, or to aggregated information made available to all franchisees.
(iv)Sales or service incentives, discounts, or promotional programs that are not made available to all California franchises of the same line-make on an equal basis.
(B)Referring a prospective purchaser or lessee to a dealer in which a manufacturer, branch, or distributor has an ownership interest, unless the prospective purchaser or lessee resides in the area of responsibility assigned to that dealer or the prospective purchaser or lessee requests to be referred to that dealer. For purposes of this subparagraph, the term area of responsibility means a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(2)This subdivision does not prohibit a franchisor from granting a franchise to prospective franchisees or assisting those franchisees during the course of the franchise relationship as part of a program or programs to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualifications ordinarily required of prospective franchisees.
(v)(1)To access, modify, or extract information from a confidential dealer computer record, as defined in Section 11713.25, without obtaining the prior written consent of the dealer and without maintaining administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the security, confidentiality, and integrity of the information.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(w)(1)To use electronic, contractual, or other means to prevent or interfere with any of the following:
(A)The lawful efforts of a dealer to comply with federal and state data security and privacy laws.
(B)The ability of a dealer to do either of the following:
(i)Ensure that specific data accessed from the dealers computer system is within the scope of consent specified in subdivision (v).
(ii)Monitor specific data accessed from or written to the dealers computer system.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(x)(1)To unfairly discriminate against a franchisee selling a service contract, debt cancellation agreement, maintenance agreement, or similar product not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate. For purposes of this subdivision, unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Express or implied statements that the dealer is under an obligation to exclusively sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(B)Express or implied statements that selling or offering to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, or the failure to sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate will have any negative consequences for the dealer.
(C)Measuring a dealers performance under a franchise agreement based upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(D)Requiring a dealer to actively promote the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(E)Conditioning access to vehicles or parts, or vehicle sales or service incentives upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(2)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a manufacturer from, offering an incentive program to vehicle dealers who voluntarily sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, if the program does not provide vehicle sales or service incentives.
(3)This subdivision does not prohibit a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch from requiring a franchisee that sells a used vehicle as certified under a certified used vehicle program established by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch to provide a service contract approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(4)Unfair
discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a franchisor from requiring a franchisee to provide, the following notice prior to the sale of the service contract if the service contract is not provided or backed by the franchisor and the vehicle is of the franchised line-make:
Service Contract Disclosure
The service contract you are purchasing is not provided or backed by the manufacturer of the vehicle you are purchasing. The manufacturer of the vehicle is not responsible for claims or repairs under this service contract.
_____________________
Signature of Purchaser
(y)To take or threaten to take any adverse action against a dealer pursuant to an export or sale-for-resale prohibition because the dealer sold or leased a vehicle to a customer who either exported the vehicle to a foreign country or resold the vehicle in violation of the prohibition, unless the export or sale-for-resale prohibition policy was provided to the dealer in writing prior to the sale or lease, and the dealer knew or reasonably should have known of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle in violation of the prohibition at the time of sale or lease. If the dealer causes the vehicle to be registered in this or any other state, and collects or causes to be collected any applicable sales or use tax due to this state, a rebuttable presumption is established that the dealer did not have reason to know of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle.
(z)Commencing July 1, 2016, to unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) of Section 11760.
SEC. 7.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This chapter article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this chapter, article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.).
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.). A manufacturers recall does not include a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(c)The term new motor vehicle dealer has the same meaning as in Section 426.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific Stop Sale Stop Drive recall and manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line make. line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(g)A Stop Sale Stop Drive recall is a recall notice provided to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration informs the dealer to stop the sale of the vehicle or contains preremedy precaution advice to the owner to stop operating the vehicle.
(h)A vehicle manufacturer is a person who manufactures, assembles, or distributes new motor vehicles, sold or leased, that are subject to registration under this code.
11754.(a)A dealer shall not display or offer for sale at retail a used vehicle, as defined in Section 665 and 665, that is subject to registration under this code, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the dealer is prohibited from selling or leasing shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is of the same line make line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer, the dealer is prohibited from selling or leasing shall not sell or lease that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(d)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is not of the same line make line-make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer or the dealer does not have a franchise, the dealer may sell or lease the vehicle at retail if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The dealer discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to sale or lease.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle has a manufacturers recall and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicles line make. line-make.
(e)To comply with subdivision (d), and notwithstanding Section 2981.9 of the Civil Code, a recall database report, that indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the recall repair has not been made, shall be disclosed and the disclosure signed by the consumer in a document separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
(f)The disclosure by a dealer, and receipt and acknowledgment by the consumer, of the information specified in subdivisions (d) and (e) has no legal effect other than to demonstrate compliance by the dealer with the requirements prescribed in those subdivisions. Nothing in this article shall be interpreted to place consumers in a less advantageous legal position for having received or signed the disclosures provided pursuant to this article than if no disclosure had been made.
11756.(a)A rental car company shall not offer a vehicle for rent unless the rental car company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a rental car company indicates that a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the rental car company is prohibited from renting that vehicle until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a rental car company that a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the rental car company may rent the vehicle if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The rental car company discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to rental.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall.
11756.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), or sooner if practicable, a rental car company is prohibited from renting or offering for rent any vehicle subject to that recall.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the rental vehicle becomes available to the rental car company, the rental car company may not rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
11758.(a)The department may refuse transfer of registration of a motor vehicle under this code unless the transferee, in submitting an application to the department for title, includes with the application a statement signed and dated by the transferor acknowledging that all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls were disclosed to the transferee as provided in subdivision (c).
(b)If the title to a motor vehicle issued to a transferor is in the possession of a lienholder when the transferor transfers ownership of the vehicle, the transferor may use a written power of attorney in making the recall disclosure required under subdivision (c).
(c)A transferor transferring registration of a motor vehicle shall disclose, in writing, to the transferee all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls. A person acquiring the vehicle shall not accept a vehicle transfer and reassignment document unless it is complete.
(d)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) do not apply to the transfer of a motor vehicle to a dealer or wholesaler.
11760.(a)A vehicle manufacturer shall clearly and conspicuously display on its Internet Web site and in all recall notifications pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), whether a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(b)When a consumer seeks to repair a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall as identified in a recall database report and the parts or procedures for the repair are not yet available, the vehicle manufacturer shall, upon request by the consumer, provide a rental or loaner vehicle to the consumer at no cost to the consumer until the recall repair has been made. The consumer shall not be provided with a rental or loaner vehicle that is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or a manufacturers recall.
(c)If a vehicle manufacturer requires a franchisee to provide a rental or loaner vehicle to a consumer under subdivision (b), the vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate the franchisee for all costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental vehicle to a consumer. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily rental amount of____ dollars ($____) for each day a consumer uses a loaner or rental vehicle.
(d)A vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for all costs incurred in storing vehicles with a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall in the franchisees possession if the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily amount of ____ dollars ($_____) for each day a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall is in the franchisees possession, the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle, and the recall repair has not been made.
11762.(a)This chapter article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758. Nothing in this article shall affect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law.
(b)The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(c)This chapter article does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
(d)This chapter article shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 8.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Over the past one-half decade, automakers and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have issued more recalls on new and used motor vehicles than ever before. The year 2014 set the record for the most recalls on vehicles in United States history with over 63.8 million vehicles recalled. The rate of vehicle recalls has exponentially grown over this past one-half decade as 22 million recalls were issued in 2013 and 16.2 million were issued in 2012. The increase of recalls in 2014 is a 190 percent increase from 2013 and a 293.8 percent increase from 2012.
(2)While federal motor vehicle safety standards are more demanding now than at any other point in time and new vehicles sold today are the safest in history, the exponential growth of recalls issued on motor vehicles has caused confusion and apathy for far too many Californians. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicles owner.
(3)Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide motor vehicle safety recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and available to the public. Dealers, rental car companies, and private parties offering vehicles for sale or rent now have greater access to recall information than ever before.
(4)Federal law imposes a requirement not to sell a new vehicle subject to a recall, but neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. It is the intent of this act to address used vehicles subject to a recall that are not yet repaired.
(b)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to increase consumer awareness of recalls in the car purchasing and rental process, to ensure that consumers have access to loaner and rental vehicles while their recalled vehicles are being repaired at a new motor vehicle dealer, and to ensure that a recalled vehicle that poses a risk of imminent harm is not sold or rented to Californians until the risk is removed and the vehicle is repaired.
(c)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The distribution, sale, and service of new motor vehicles in the State of California vitally affects the general economy of this state and the public welfare.
(2)The new motor vehicle franchise system, which operates within a strictly defined and highly regulated statutory scheme, assures the consuming public of a well-organized distribution system for the availability and sale of new motor vehicles throughout the state, provides a network of quality warranty, recall, and repair facilities to maintain those vehicles, and creates a cost-effective method for the state to police those systems through the licensing and regulation of private sector franchisors and franchisees.
(3)Franchisors sometimes establish programs to reimburse franchisees for loaner or rental cars given to consumers whose vehicles have been recalled, but California franchise laws fail to establish guidelines for rental or loaner vehicle reimbursement.
(4)California franchise laws require manufacturers to provide reasonable reimbursement to dealers for warranty and recall work, but fails to establish guidelines for compensating franchisee costs associated with recalled vehicles that cannot be repaired and remain in the franchisees possession.
(d)Accordingly, it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this act to ensure that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are treated fairly by their franchisors, that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably reimbursed for providing loaner or rental vehicles to consumers who have recalled vehicles when the parts or procedures to make the recall repair are not available, and that new motor vehicle dealer franchisees are reasonably compensated for recalled vehicles at their dealerships that cannot immediately be repaired and must be stored by the franchisee at the dealership.
SEC. 2.Section 3050 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3050.The board shall do all of the following:
(a)Adopt rules and regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code governing those matters that are specifically committed to its jurisdiction.
(b)Hear and determine, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, an appeal presented by an applicant for, or holder of, a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative when the applicant or licensee submits an appeal provided for in this chapter from a decision arising out of the department.
(c)Consider any matter concerning the activities or practices of any person applying for or holding a license as a new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 submitted by any person. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide any matter considered by the board pursuant to this subdivision that involves a dispute between a franchisee and franchisor. After that consideration, the board may do any one or any combination of the following:
(1)Direct the department to conduct investigation of matters that the board deems reasonable, and make a written report on the results of the investigation to the board within the time specified by the board.
(2)Undertake to mediate, arbitrate, or otherwise resolve any honest difference of opinion or viewpoint existing between any member of the public and any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative.
(3)Order the department to exercise any and all authority or power that the department may have with respect to the issuance, renewal, refusal to renew, suspension, or revocation of the license of any new motor vehicle dealer, manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative as that license is required under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5.
(d)Hear and decide, within the limitations and in accordance with the procedure provided, a protest presented by a franchisee pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076. A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, advise other members upon, or decide, any matter involving a protest filed pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060), unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (c) and (d), the courts have jurisdiction over all common law and statutory claims originally cognizable in the courts. For those claims, a party may initiate an action directly in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SEC. 3.Section 3065.2 is added to the Vehicle Code, to read:3065.2.(a)A claim made by a franchisee for payment under Section 11760 shall be either approved or disapproved within 30 days after receipt by the franchisor. When a claim is disapproved, the franchisee who submits it shall be notified in writing of its disapproval within the required period, and each notice shall state the specific grounds upon which the disapproval is based. Any claim not specifically disapproved in writing within 30 days from receipt shall be deemed approved on the 30th day.
(b)Franchisee claims for compensation under Section 11760 shall not be disapproved unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements.
(c)The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee at least 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval. If disapproval is based upon noncompliance with documentation or administrative claims submission requirements, the franchisor shall allow the franchisee at least 30 days from the date of receipt of the written disapproval notice to cure any material noncompliance. If the disapproval is rebutted, and material noncompliance is cured before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall approve the claim.
(d)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(e)Following the disapproval of a claim, a franchisee shall have six months from receipt of the written notice described in either subdivision (a) or (d), whichever is later, to file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (d). In any hearing pursuant to this subdivision or subdivision (a), (b), (c), or (d), the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(f)A claim made by franchisees under this section shall be paid within 30 days following approval. Failure to approve or pay within the time limits specified in this section, in individual instances for reasons beyond the reasonable control of the franchisor, is not a violation of this section.
(g)(1)Audits of franchisee records for payment under Section 11760 may be conducted by the franchisor on a reasonable basis, and for a period of nine months after a claim is paid or credit issued. A franchisor shall not select a franchisee for an audit, or perform an audit, in a punitive, retaliatory, or unfairly discriminatory manner. A franchisor may conduct no more than one random audit of a franchisee in a nine-month period. The franchisors notification to the franchisee of any additional audit within a nine-month period shall be accompanied by written disclosure of the basis for that additional audit.
(2)Previously approved claims shall not be disapproved and charged back unless the claim is false or fraudulent, the claim is ineligible under the statute, or for material noncompliance with reasonable and nondiscriminatory requirements of the franchisor, including documentation and administrative claims submission requirements. A franchisor shall not disapprove a claim or chargeback a claim based upon an extrapolation from a sample of claims, unless the sample of claims is selected randomly and the extrapolation is performed in a reasonable and statistically valid manner.
(3)If the franchisor disapproves of a previously approved claim following an audit, the franchisor shall provide to the franchisee, within 30 days after the audit, a written disapproval notice stating the specific grounds upon which the claim is disapproved. The franchisor shall provide a reasonable appeal process allowing the franchisee a reasonable period of not less than 30 days after receipt of the written disapproval notice to respond to any disapproval with additional supporting documentation or information rebutting the disapproval and to cure any material noncompliance, with the period to be commensurate with the volume of claims under consideration. If the franchisee rebuts any disapproval and cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim before the applicable deadline, the franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee for that claim.
(4)If the franchisee provides additional supporting documentation or information purporting to rebut the disapproval, attempts to cure noncompliance relating to the claim, or otherwise appeals denial of the claim, and the franchisor continues to deny the claim, the franchisor shall provide the franchisee with a written notification of the final denial within 30 days of completion of the appeal process, which shall conspicuously state Final Denial on the first page.
(5)The franchisor shall not chargeback the franchisee until 45 days after the franchisee receives the written notice described in paragraph (3) or (4), whichever is later. If the franchisee cures any material noncompliance relating to a claim, the franchisor shall not chargeback the dealer for that claim. Any chargeback to a franchisee for under Section 11760 shall be made within 90 days after the franchisee receives that written notice. If the board sustains the chargeback or the protest is dismissed, the franchisor shall have 90 days following issuance of the final order or the dismissal to make the chargeback, unless otherwise provided in a settlement agreement.
(6)Within six months after receipt of the written notice described in either paragraph (3) or (4), a franchisee may file a protest with the board for determination of whether the franchisor complied with this subdivision. If the franchisee files a protest pursuant to this subdivision prior to the franchisors chargeback for denied claims, the franchisor shall not offset or otherwise undertake to collect the chargeback until the board issues a final order on the protest. In any protest pursuant to this subdivision, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)If a false claim was submitted by a franchisee with the intent to defraud the franchisor, a longer period for audit and any resulting chargeback may be permitted if the franchisor obtains an order from the board.
(i)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 4.Section 3066 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:3066.(a)Upon receiving a protest pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3070, 3072, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the board shall fix a time within 60 days of the order, and place of hearing, and shall send by registered mail a copy of the order to the franchisor, the protesting franchisee, and all individuals and groups that have requested notification by the board of protests and decisions of the board. Except in a case involving a franchisee who deals exclusively in motorcycles, the board or its executive director may, upon a showing of good cause, accelerate or postpone the date initially established for a hearing, but the hearing may not be rescheduled more than 90 days after the boards initial order. For the purpose of accelerating or postponing a hearing date, good cause includes, but is not limited to, the effects upon, and any irreparable harm to, the parties or interested persons or groups if the request for a change in hearing date is not granted. The board or an administrative law judge designated by the board shall hear and consider the oral and documented evidence introduced by the parties and other interested individuals and groups, and the board shall make its decision solely on the record so made. Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Sections 11507.3, 11507.6, 11507.7, 11511, 11511.5, 11513, 11514, 11515, and 11517 of the Government Code apply to these proceedings.
(b)In a hearing on a protest filed pursuant to Section 3060, 3062, 3070, or 3072, the franchisor shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause to modify, replace, terminate, or refuse to continue a franchise. The franchisee shall have the burden of proof to establish that there is good cause not to enter into a franchise establishing or relocating an additional motor vehicle dealership.
(c)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, in a hearing on a protest alleging a violation of, or filed pursuant to, Section 3064, 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3074, 3075, or 3076, the franchisee shall have the burden of proof, but the franchisor has the burden of proof to establish that a franchisee acted with intent to defraud the franchisor where when that issue is material to a protest filed pursuant to Section 3065, 3065.1, 3065.2, 3075, or 3076.
(d)A member of the board who is a new motor vehicle dealer may not participate in, hear, comment, or advise other members upon, or decide, a matter involving a protest filed pursuant to this article unless all parties to the protest stipulate otherwise.
SEC. 5.Section 4751 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:4751.The department may refuse registration registration, or the renewal or transfer of registration registration, of a vehicle in any of the following events:
(a)If the department is not satisfied that the applicant is entitled thereto under this code.
(b)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with information required in the application or reasonable additional information required by the department.
(c)If the department determines that the applicant has made or permitted unlawful use of any registration certificate, certificate of ownership, or license plates.
(d)If the vehicle is mechanically unfit or unsafe to be operated or moved on the highways.
(e)If the department determines that a manufacturer or dealer has failed during the current or previous year to comply with the provisions of this code relating to the giving of notice to the department of the transfer of a vehicle during the current or previous year.
(f)If the department determines that a lien exists, pursuant to Section 9800, against one or more other vehicles in which the applicant has an ownership interest.
(g)If the applicant has failed to furnish the department with an odometer disclosure statement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 32705 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(h)Commencing July 1, 2016, if the applicant has failed to furnish the department with a recall disclosure statement pursuant to Section 11758.
SEC. 6.Section 11713.3 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11713.3.It is unlawful and a violation of this code for a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch licensed pursuant to this code to do, directly or indirectly through an affiliate, any of the following:
(a)To refuse or fail to deliver in reasonable quantities and within a reasonable time after receipt of an order from a dealer having a franchise for the retail sale of a new vehicle sold or distributed by the manufacturer or distributor, a new vehicle or parts or accessories to new vehicles as are covered by the franchise, if the vehicle, parts, or accessories are publicly advertised as being available for delivery or actually being delivered. This subdivision is not violated, however, if the failure is caused by acts or causes beyond the control of the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(b)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a change in the capital structure of a dealership or the means by or through which the dealer finances the operation of the dealership, if the dealer at all times meets reasonable capital standards agreed to by the dealer and the manufacturer or distributor, and if a change in capital structure does not cause a change in the principal management or have the effect of a sale of the franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor.
(c)To prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, a dealer to change the executive management of a dealership, other than the principal dealership operator or operators, if the franchise was granted to the dealer in reliance upon the personal qualifications of that person.
(d)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (t), to prevent or require, or attempt to prevent or require, by contract or otherwise, a dealer, or an officer, partner, or stockholder of a dealership, the sale or transfer of a part of the interest of any of them to another person. A dealer, officer, partner, or stockholder shall not, however, have the right to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise, or a right thereunder, without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor except that the consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.
(2)(A)For the transferring franchisee to fail, prior to the sale, transfer, or assignment of a franchisee or the sale, assignment, or transfer of all, or substantially all, of the assets of the franchised business or a controlling interest in the franchised business to another person, to notify the manufacturer or distributor of the franchisees decision to sell, transfer, or assign the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall include all of the following:
(i)The proposed transferees name and address.
(ii)A copy of all of the agreements relating to the sale, assignment, or transfer of the franchised business or its assets.
(iii)The proposed transferees application for approval to become the successor franchisee. The application shall include forms and related information generally utilized by the manufacturer or distributor in reviewing prospective franchisees, if those forms are readily made available to existing franchisees. As soon as practicable after receipt of the proposed transferees application, the manufacturer or distributor shall notify the franchisee and the proposed transferee of information needed to make the application complete.
(B)For the manufacturer or distributor, to fail, on or before 60 days after the receipt of all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A), or as extended by a written agreement between the manufacturer or distributor and the franchisee, to notify the franchisee of the approval or the disapproval of the sale, transfer, or assignment of the franchise. The notice shall be in writing and shall be personally served or sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by guaranteed overnight delivery service that provides verification of delivery and shall be directed to the franchisee. A proposed sale, assignment, or transfer shall be deemed approved, unless disapproved by the franchisor in the manner provided by this subdivision. If the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer is disapproved, the franchisor shall include in the notice of disapproval a statement setting forth the reasons for the disapproval.
(3)In an action in which the manufacturers or distributors withholding of consent under this subdivision or subdivision (e) is an issue, whether the withholding of consent was unreasonable is a question of fact requiring consideration of all the existing circumstances.
(e)To prevent, or attempt to prevent, a dealer from receiving fair and reasonable compensation for the value of the franchised business. There shall not be a transfer or assignment of the dealers franchise without the consent of the manufacturer or distributor, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or conditioned upon the release, assignment, novation, waiver, estoppel, or modification of a claim or defense by the dealer.
(f)To obtain money, goods, services, or another benefit from a person with whom the dealer does business, on account of, or in relation to, the transaction between the dealer and that other person, other than for compensation for services rendered, unless the benefit is promptly accounted for, and transmitted to, the dealer.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (3), to obtain from a dealer or enforce against a dealer an agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel that does any of the following:
(A)Modifies or disclaims a duty or obligation of a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative, or a right or privilege of a dealer, pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11700) of Division 5 or Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 3000) of Division 2.
(B)Limits or constrains the right of a dealer to file, pursue, or submit evidence in connection with a protest before the board.
(C)Requires a dealer to terminate a franchise.
(D)Requires a controversy between a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, distributor branch, or representative and a dealer to be referred to a person for a binding determination. However, this subparagraph does not prohibit arbitration before an independent arbitrator, provided that whenever a motor vehicle franchise contract provides for the use of arbitration to resolve a controversy arising out of, or relating to, that contract, arbitration may be used to settle the controversy only if, after the controversy arises, all parties to the controversy consent in writing to use arbitration to settle the controversy. For the purpose of this subparagraph, the terms motor vehicle and motor vehicle franchise contract shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 1226 of Title 15 of the United States Code. If arbitration is elected to settle a dispute under a motor vehicle franchise contract, the arbitrator shall provide the parties to the arbitration with a written explanation of the factual and legal basis for the award.
(2)An agreement, provision, release, assignment, novation, waiver, or estoppel prohibited by this subdivision shall be unenforceable and void.
(3)This subdivision does not do any of the following:
(A)Limit or restrict the terms upon which parties to a protest before the board, civil action, or other proceeding can settle or resolve, or stipulate to evidentiary or procedural matters during the course of, a protest, civil action, or other proceeding.
(B)Affect the enforceability of any stipulated order or other order entered by the board.
(C)Affect the enforceability of any provision in a contract if the provision is not prohibited under this subdivision or any other law.
(D)Affect the enforceability of a provision in any contract entered into on or before December 31, 2011.
(E)Prohibit a dealer from waiving its right to file a protest pursuant to Section 3065.1 if the waiver agreement is entered into after a franchisor incentive program claim has been disapproved by the franchisor and the waiver is voluntarily given as part of an agreement to settle that claim.
(F)Prohibit a voluntary agreement supported by valuable consideration, other than granting or renewing a franchise, that does both of the following:
(i)Provides that a dealer establish or maintain exclusive facilities, personnel, or display space or provides that a dealer make a material alteration, expansion, or addition to a dealership facility.
(ii)Contains no waiver or other provision prohibited by subparagraph (A), (B), (C), or (D) of paragraph (1).
(G)Prohibit an agreement separate from the franchise agreement that implements a dealers election to terminate the franchise if the agreement is conditioned only on a specified time for termination or payment of consideration to the dealer.
(H)(i)Prohibit a voluntary waiver agreement, supported by valuable consideration, other than the consideration of renewing a franchise, to waive the right of a dealer to file a protest under Section 3062 for the proposed establishment or relocation of a specific proposed dealership, if the waiver agreement provides all of the following:
(I)The approximate address at which the proposed dealership will be located.
(II)The planning potential used to establish the proposed dealerships facility, personnel, and capital requirements.
(III)An approximation of projected vehicle and parts sales, and number of vehicles to be serviced at the proposed dealership.
(IV)Whether the franchisor or affiliate will hold an ownership interest in the proposed dealership or real property of the proposed dealership, and the approximate percentage of any franchisor or affiliate ownership interest in the proposed dealership.
(V)The line-makes to be operated at the proposed dealership.
(VI)If known at the time the waiver agreement is executed, the identity of the dealer who will operate the proposed dealership.
(VII)The date the waiver agreement is to expire, which may not be more than 30 months after the date of execution of the waiver agreement.
(ii)Notwithstanding the provisions of a waiver agreement entered into pursuant to the provisions of this subparagraph, a dealer may file a protest under Section 3062 if any of the information provided pursuant to clause (i) has become materially inaccurate since the waiver agreement was executed. Any determination of the enforceability of a waiver agreement shall be determined by the board and the franchisor shall have the burden of proof.
(h)To increase prices of motor vehicles that the dealer had ordered for private retail consumers prior to the dealers receipt of the written official price increase notification. A sales contract signed by a private retail consumer is evidence of the order. In the event of manufacturer price reductions, the amount of the reduction received by a dealer shall be passed on to the private retail consumer by the dealer if the retail price was negotiated on the basis of the previous higher price to the dealer. Price reductions apply to all vehicles in the dealers inventory that were subject to the price reduction. Price differences applicable to new model or series motor vehicles at the time of the introduction of new models or series shall not be considered a price increase or price decrease. This subdivision does not apply to price changes caused by either of the following:
(1)The addition to a motor vehicle of required or optional equipment pursuant to state or federal law.
(2)Revaluation of the United States dollar in the case of a foreign-make vehicle.
(i)To fail to pay to a dealer, within a reasonable time following receipt of a valid claim by a dealer thereof, a payment agreed to be made by the manufacturer or distributor to the dealer by reason of the fact that a new vehicle of a prior year model is in the dealers inventory at the time of introduction of new model vehicles.
(j)To deny the widow, widower, or heirs designated by a deceased owner of a dealership the opportunity to participate in the ownership of the dealership or successor dealership under a valid franchise for a reasonable time after the death of the owner.
(k)To offer refunds or other types of inducements to a person for the purchase of new motor vehicles of a certain line-make to be sold to the state or a political subdivision of the state without making the same offer to all other dealers in the same line-make within the relevant market area.
(l)To modify, replace, enter into, relocate, terminate, or refuse to renew a franchise in violation of Article 4 (commencing with Section 3060) of Chapter 6 of Division 2.
(m)To employ a person as a representative who has not been licensed pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 11900) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(n)To deny a dealer the right of free association with another dealer for a lawful purpose.
(o)(1)To compete with a dealer in the same line-make operating under an agreement or franchise from a manufacturer or distributor in the relevant market area.
(2)A manufacturer, branch, or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by, a manufacturer, branch, or distributor, shall not, however, be deemed to be competing in the following limited circumstances:
(A)Owning or operating a dealership for a temporary period, not to exceed one year at the location of a former dealership of the same line-make that has been out of operation for less than six months. However, after a showing of good cause by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor that it needs additional time to operate a dealership in preparation for sale to a successor independent franchisee, the board may extend the time period.
(B)Owning an interest in a dealer as part of a bona fide dealer development program that satisfies all of the following requirements:
(i)The sole purpose of the program is to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualities ordinarily required of prospective franchisees and the dealer development candidate is an individual who is unable to acquire the franchise without assistance of the program.
(ii)The dealer development candidate has made a significant investment subject to loss in the franchised business of the dealer.
(iii)The program requires the dealer development candidate to manage the day-to-day operations and business affairs of the dealer and to acquire, within a reasonable time and on reasonable terms and conditions, beneficial ownership and control of a majority interest in the dealer and disassociation of any direct or indirect ownership or control by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor.
(C)Owning a wholly owned subsidiary corporation of a distributor that sells motor vehicles at retail, if, for at least three years prior to January 1, 1973, the subsidiary corporation has been a wholly owned subsidiary of the distributor and engaged in the sale of vehicles at retail.
(3)(A)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns or operates a dealership in the manner described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, within 10 days, each time it commences or terminates operation of a dealership and each time it acquires, changes, or divests itself of an ownership interest.
(B)A manufacturer, branch, and distributor that owns an interest in a dealer in the manner described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) shall give written notice to the board, annually, of the name and location of each dealer in which it has an ownership interest, the name of the bona fide dealer development owner or owners, and the ownership interests of each owner expressed as a percentage.
(p)To unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to warranty reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees to make warranty adjustments with retail customers.
(q)To sell vehicles to a person not licensed pursuant to this chapter for resale.
(r)To fail to affix an identification number to a park trailer, as described in Section 18009.3 of the Health and Safety Code, that is manufactured on or after January 1, 1987, and that does not clearly identify the unit as a park trailer to the department. The configuration of the identification number shall be approved by the department.
(s)To dishonor a warranty, rebate, or other incentive offered to the public or a dealer in connection with the retail sale of a new motor vehicle, based solely upon the fact that an autobroker arranged or negotiated the sale. This subdivision shall not prohibit the disallowance of that rebate or incentive if the purchaser or dealer is ineligible to receive the rebate or incentive pursuant to any other term or condition of a rebate or incentive program.
(t)To exercise a right of first refusal or other right requiring a franchisee or an owner of the franchise to sell, transfer, or assign to the franchisor, or to a nominee of the franchisor, all or a material part of the franchised business or of the assets of the franchised business unless all of the following requirements are met:
(1)The franchise authorizes the franchisor to exercise a right of first refusal to acquire the franchised business or assets of the franchised business in the event of a proposed sale, transfer, or assignment.
(2)The franchisor gives written notice of its exercise of the right of first refusal no later than 45 days after the franchisor receives all of the information required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(3)The sale, transfer, or assignment being proposed relates to not less than all or substantially all of the assets of the franchised business or to a controlling interest in the franchised business.
(4)The proposed transferee is neither a family member of an owner of the franchised business, nor a managerial employee of the franchisee owning 15 percent or more of the franchised business, nor a corporation, partnership, or other legal entity owned by the existing owners of the franchised business. For purposes of this paragraph, a family member means the spouse of an owner of the franchised business, the child, grandchild, brother, sister, or parent of an owner, or a spouse of one of those family members. This paragraph does not limit the rights of the franchisor to disapprove a proposed transferee as provided in subdivision (d).
(5)Upon the franchisors exercise of the right of first refusal, the consideration paid by the franchisor to the franchisee and owners of the franchised business shall equal or exceed all consideration that each of them were to have received under the terms of, or in connection with, the proposed sale, assignment, or transfer, and the franchisor shall comply with all the terms and conditions of the agreement or agreements to sell, transfer, or assign the franchised business.
(6)The franchisor shall reimburse the proposed transferee for expenses paid or incurred by the proposed transferee in evaluating, investigating, and negotiating the proposed transfer to the extent those expenses do not exceed the usual, customary, and reasonable fees charged for similar work done in the area in which the franchised business is located. These expenses include, but are not limited to, legal and accounting expenses, and expenses incurred for title reports and environmental or other investigations of real property on which the franchisees operations are conducted. The proposed transferee shall provide the franchisor a written itemization of those expenses, and a copy of all nonprivileged reports and studies for which expenses were incurred, if any, within 30 days of the proposed transferees receipt of a written request from the franchisor for that accounting. The franchisor shall make payment within 30 days of exercising the right of first refusal.
(u)(1)To unfairly discriminate in favor of a dealership owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer or distributor or an entity that controls or is controlled by the manufacturer or distributor. Unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A)The furnishing to a franchisee or dealer that is owned or controlled, in whole or in part, by a manufacturer, branch, or distributor of any of the following:
(i)A vehicle that is not made available to each franchisee pursuant to a reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly, and a part or accessory that is not made available to all franchisees on an equal basis when there is no reasonable allocation formula that is applied uniformly.
(ii)A vehicle, part, or accessory that is not made available to each franchisee on comparable delivery terms, including the time of delivery after the placement of an order. Differences in delivery terms due to geographic distances or other factors beyond the control of the manufacturer, branch, or distributor shall not constitute unfair competition.
(iii)Information obtained from a franchisee by the manufacturer, branch, or distributor concerning the business affairs or operations of a franchisee in which the manufacturer, branch, or distributor does not have an ownership interest. The information includes, but is not limited to, information contained in financial statements and operating reports, the name, address, or other personal information or buying, leasing, or service behavior of a dealer customer, and other information that, if provided to a franchisee or dealer owned or controlled by a manufacturer or distributor, would give that franchisee or dealer a competitive advantage. This clause does not apply if the information is provided pursuant to a subpoena or court order, or to aggregated information made available to all franchisees.
(iv)Sales or service incentives, discounts, or promotional programs that are not made available to all California franchises of the same line-make on an equal basis.
(B)Referring a prospective purchaser or lessee to a dealer in which a manufacturer, branch, or distributor has an ownership interest, unless the prospective purchaser or lessee resides in the area of responsibility assigned to that dealer or the prospective purchaser or lessee requests to be referred to that dealer. For purposes of this subparagraph, the term area of responsibility means a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(2)This subdivision does not prohibit a franchisor from granting a franchise to prospective franchisees or assisting those franchisees during the course of the franchise relationship as part of a program or programs to make franchises available to persons lacking capital, training, business experience, or other qualifications ordinarily required of prospective franchisees.
(v)(1)To access, modify, or extract information from a confidential dealer computer record, as defined in Section 11713.25, without obtaining the prior written consent of the dealer and without maintaining administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect the security, confidentiality, and integrity of the information.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(w)(1)To use electronic, contractual, or other means to prevent or interfere with any of the following:
(A)The lawful efforts of a dealer to comply with federal and state data security and privacy laws.
(B)The ability of a dealer to do either of the following:
(i)Ensure that specific data accessed from the dealers computer system is within the scope of consent specified in subdivision (v).
(ii)Monitor specific data accessed from or written to the dealers computer system.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not limit a duty that a dealer may have to safeguard the security and privacy of records maintained by the dealer.
(x)(1)To unfairly discriminate against a franchisee selling a service contract, debt cancellation agreement, maintenance agreement, or similar product not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate. For purposes of this subdivision, unfair discrimination includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Express or implied statements that the dealer is under an obligation to exclusively sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(B)Express or implied statements that selling or offering to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products not approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, or the failure to sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, maintenance agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate will have any negative consequences for the dealer.
(C)Measuring a dealers performance under a franchise agreement based upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(D)Requiring a dealer to actively promote the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(E)Conditioning access to vehicles or parts, or vehicle sales or service incentives upon the sale of service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate.
(2)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a manufacturer from, offering an incentive program to vehicle dealers who voluntarily sell or offer to sell service contracts, debt cancellation agreements, or similar products approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch or affiliate, if the program does not provide vehicle sales or service incentives.
(3)This subdivision does not prohibit a manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch from requiring a franchisee that sells a used vehicle as certified under a certified used vehicle program established by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch to provide a service contract approved, endorsed, sponsored, or offered by the manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, or distributor branch.
(4)Unfair discrimination does not include, and nothing shall prohibit a franchisor from requiring a franchisee to provide, the following notice prior to the sale of the service contract if the service contract is not provided or backed by the franchisor and the vehicle is of the franchised line-make:
Service Contract Disclosure
The service contract you are purchasing is not provided or backed by the manufacturer of the vehicle you are purchasing. The manufacturer of the vehicle is not responsible for claims or repairs under this service contract.
_____________________
Signature of Purchaser
(y)To take or threaten to take any adverse action against a dealer pursuant to an export or sale-for-resale prohibition because the dealer sold or leased a vehicle to a customer who either exported the vehicle to a foreign country or resold the vehicle in violation of the prohibition, unless the export or sale-for-resale prohibition policy was provided to the dealer in writing prior to the sale or lease, and the dealer knew or reasonably should have known of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle in violation of the prohibition at the time of sale or lease. If the dealer causes the vehicle to be registered in this or any other state, and collects or causes to be collected any applicable sales or use tax due to this state, a rebuttable presumption is established that the dealer did not have reason to know of the customers intent to export or resell the vehicle.
(z) As used in this section, area of responsibility is a geographic area specified in a franchise that is used by the franchisor for the purpose of evaluating the franchisees performance of its sales and service obligations.
(z)Commencing July 1, 2016, to unfairly discriminate among its franchisees with respect to reimbursement or authority granted to its franchisees pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) of Section 11760.
SEC. 7.Article 1.1 (commencing with Section 11750) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 5 of the Vehicle Code, to read:1.1.Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act11750.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act).
11752.As used in this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.).
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.). A manufacturers recall does not include a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(c)The term new motor vehicle dealer has the same meaning as in Section 426.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific Stop Sale Stop Drive recall and manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
(g)A Stop Sale Stop Drive recall is a recall notice provided to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration informs the dealer to stop the sale of the vehicle or contains preremedy precaution advice to the owner to stop operating the vehicle.
(h)A vehicle manufacturer is a person who manufactures, assembles, or distributes new motor vehicles, sold or leased, that are subject to registration under this code.
11754.(a)A dealer shall not display or offer for sale at retail a used vehicle, as defined in Section 665 and subject to registration under this code, unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display or offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the dealer is prohibited from selling or leasing that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is of the same line make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer, the dealer is prohibited from selling or leasing that vehicle at retail until the recall repair has been made.
(d)If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the used vehicle is not of the same line make as the franchise of the new motor vehicle dealer or the dealer does not have a franchise, the dealer may sell or lease the vehicle at retail if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The dealer discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to sale or lease.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle has a manufacturers recall and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicles line make.
(e)To comply with subdivision (d), and notwithstanding Section 2981.9 of the Civil Code, a recall database report, that indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and the recall repair has not been made, shall be disclosed and the disclosure signed by the consumer in a document separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
11756.(a)A rental car company shall not offer a vehicle for rent unless the rental car company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer.
(b)If a recall database report obtained by a rental car company indicates that a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall, the rental car company is prohibited from renting that vehicle until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a recall database report obtained by a rental car company that a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, the rental car company may rent the vehicle if all of the following are satisfied:
(1)The rental car company discloses the manufacturers recall by providing a copy of the recall database report to the consumer prior to rental.
(2)The consumer signs the disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall.
11758.(a)The department may refuse transfer of registration of a motor vehicle under this code unless the transferee, in submitting an application to the department for title, includes with the application a statement signed and dated by the transferor acknowledging that all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls were disclosed to the transferee as provided in subdivision (c).
(b)If the title to a motor vehicle issued to a transferor is in the possession of a lienholder when the transferor transfers ownership of the vehicle, the transferor may use a written power of attorney in making the recall disclosure required under subdivision (c).
(c)A transferor transferring registration of a motor vehicle shall disclose, in writing, to the transferee all Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls and manufacturers recalls. A person acquiring the vehicle shall not accept a vehicle transfer and reassignment document unless it is complete.
(d)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) do not apply to the transfer of a motor vehicle to a dealer or wholesaler.
11760.(a)A vehicle manufacturer shall clearly and conspicuously display on its Internet Web Site and in all recall notifications pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.), whether a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall.
(b)When a consumer seeks to repair a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall as identified in a recall database report and the parts or procedures for the repair are not yet available, the vehicle manufacturer shall, upon request by the consumer, provide a rental or loaner vehicle to the consumer at no cost to the consumer until the recall repair has been made.
(c)If a vehicle manufacturer requires a franchisee to provide a rental or loaner vehicle to a consumer under subdivision (b), the vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate the franchisee for all costs incurred in providing a loaner or rental vehicle to a consumer. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily rental amount of____ dollars ($____) for each day a consumer uses a loaner or rental vehicle.
(d)A vehicle manufacturer shall adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for all costs incurred in storing vehicles with a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall in the franchisees possession if the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle. For purposes of this paragraph, adequate and fair compensation shall be the average daily amount of ____ dollars ($_____) for each day a vehicle subject to a Stop Sale Stop Drive recall or manufacturers recall is in the franchisees possession, the parts or procedures are not yet available to repair the recall of the vehicle, and the recall repair has not been made.
11762.(a)This chapter shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754, 11756, and 11758.
(b)The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(c)This chapter does not apply to the sale of a recreational vehicle, a motorcycle, an off-highway motor vehicle subject to identification under Section 38010, a vehicle sold by a dismantler after being reported for dismantling pursuant to Section 11520, or a vehicle sold by a salvage pool after obtaining a salvage pool certificate pursuant to Section 11515 or a nonrepairable vehicle certificate issued pursuant to Section 11515.2.
(d)This chapter shall become operative on July 1, 2016.
SEC. 8.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act to provide comprehensive consumer protections that address the low recall repair completion rate and consumer confusion regarding automotive recalls in California.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act to provide comprehensive consumer protections that address the low recall repair completion rate and consumer confusion regarding automotive recalls in California.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 6433.). |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 25, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 28 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 5308.). |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 8, 2016 | Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 21). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on T. & H. |
| Jun 6, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on T. & H. |
| Jun 11, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on T. & H. and JUD. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 1799.) |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 1, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 28, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 28, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (May 28). |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| May 13, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 5, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 4, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 21). |
| Apr 14, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 13). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Mar 24, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on TRANS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on TRANS. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 12, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 11, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | AB 287 GORDON Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 23, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB287 Gordon By Beall | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 8, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2015 | AB 287 GORDON Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 21, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 13, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Transportation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 287
Author:(Gordon, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: |
| (June 2, 2015) | SENATE: | 39-0 | (August 23, 2016) |
(vote not relevant)
Original Committee Reference: TRANS.
SUMMARY: Enacts the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (Act), which would prohibit a dealer or car rental company from loaning or renting a vehicle is subject to a recall until the repair has been made.
The Senate amendments largely delete the language passed by the Assembly, and would instead:
- Require the warranty reimbursement schedule or formula used by every franchisor to be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for costs directly associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall repair.
- Authorize the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to suspend a dealer's license for violation of any provision of the Act, or any rule or regulation adopted pursuant thereto.
- Require that, no later than 48 hours after receiving notice of a manufacturer's recall or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
- Authorize the dealer or rental car company, if a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, to loan or rent the vehicle after having the repairs completed.
- Prohibit the dealer or rental car company from loaning or renting the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired, once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company.
- Require DMV to include in each vehicle registration renewal notice the following recall disclosure statement:
NOTICE: Many vehicles have been recalled recently for needed repairs. Did you know you can check to see if your vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturer's safety recall? For most vehicles, manufacturer's safety recalls are repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at www.safercar.gov.
- Define the terms "warranty," "dealer," "manufacturer's recall," "recall database," "recall database report," and "rental car company."
- Revise the legislative findings and declarations
- Declare that the Act does not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report.
- Declare that the rights and remedies provided by the Act are cumulative and shall not be construed as restricting any right or remedy that is otherwise available.
- Declare the provisions of the Act to be severable.
- Declare that no reimbursement is required pursuant to the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this bill creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, or changes the definition of a crime.
- Make other clarifying or nonsubstantive changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Likely minor one-time DMV costs, potentially as high as $50,000, related to the printing of the recall disclosure statement on vehicle registration renewal documents. Ongoing administrative costs would be minor and absorbable. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- Potential DMV costs beginning in 2017-18 for ongoing dealership inspections and enforcement activities. Staff estimates any additional activities would result in minor costs. (Motor Vehicle Account)
COMMENTS: This bill is intended to address the danger posed by consumers driving cars with unknown or unremedied recall notices by requiring smaller dealers and rental car companies (those with fleets of 34 or fewer cars) to ground automobiles with outstanding recall notices no later than 48 hours after receipt of notice, and either fix or temporarily repair the car before making it available to a consumer.
Analysis Prepared by: Hank Dempsey / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0004899
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 287 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 287
Author: Gordon (D), Eggman (D) and Mark Stone (D), et al.
Amended: 8/19/16 in Senate
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/21/16
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Bates, Gaines, Galgiani, Leyva, McGuire, Mendoza, Roth, Wieckowski
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/2/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Vehicle safety: recalls
DIGEST: This bill establishes various consumer and car dealer protections for recalled vehicles.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/19/16 require that a notice by the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) be provided with every vehicle registration renewal notice that gives information about determining whether a vehicle is subject to a recall. The prior version of the bill required that a more definitive version of this notice be provided only to vehicles which are under recall.
Existing federal law:
- Sets forth in federal regulations the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard.
- Prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a new vehicle subject to a recall, as specified, unless and until the defect is repaired. Federal law does not afford similar prohibitions to used vehicles.
- Requires motor vehicle safety recall information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and vehicle identification number (VIN).
- Prohibits vehicles which are subject to recall from being rented, provided the company renting the cars has a fleet of at least 35 vehicles.
Existing state law requires manufacturers to properly fulfill every warranty agreement and fairly compensate their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing and all other conditions of that obligation.
This bill:
- Includes the cost of disposing of hazardous materials in the compensation required of the manufacturer to the dealer.
- Prohibits the renting or loaning of a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Requires the DMV, when mailing a notice of registration renewal, to notify a vehicle owner of a specific mechanism to determine if their vehicle is subject to recall.
Comments
- Purpose. According to the author, California already has the strongest consumer protection laws in the country for car buyers. While federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle with an unrepaired recall; neither federal nor California law specifically requires the disclosure or repair of a used vehicle subject to a recall. This bill would further enhance those protections by ensuring that automobile dealers, rental car companies, automobile manufacturers, and the government all have a role in improving the auto recall and repair process.
- Recalls increasing, millions affected. From 1995 to 2015, the number of vehicle recalls has almost tripled, from 348 to 973, with more than 87 million vehicles affected in 2015. The recall of Takata airbags impacts as many as 68.8 million airbags in what the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) called the largest and most complex safety recall in history.
- Reimbursing dealers. Existing law requires auto manufacturers to reimburse their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of that obligation. Airbags are considered hazardous waste because of the inflation mechanism. This bill specifically identifies the cost of disposing of hazardous waste as a cost the manufacturers must reimburse to the dealers.
- Fixing rentals and loaners. New federal law prohibits rental car companies and dealers with 35 or more available vehicles from renting or loaning cars with an unremedied manufacturer’s recall. This bill extends that prohibition to all rental car companies and dealers, regardless of how many vehicles they have available. While the bill is silent on an enforcement mechanism for this provision, the author intends to allow the DMV to impair the dealer’s license as the penalty, as is the case with similar provisions of the Vehicle Code.
- DMV recall notice. The track record for fixing recalled vehicles is mediocre. NHTSA has estimated that only 70% of recalled vehicles are repaired. To improve that record, the NHTSA established a website where the public can determine whether a vehicle is subject to recall: www.safercar.gov. This bill tries to improve on that record by requiring the DMV to indicate on the annual registration renewal notice that many vehicles are subject to recall and that recall information about individual vehicles can be obtained from a specified website.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis for a prior version of the bill containing provisions which have since been deleted:
- Unknown one-time DMV costs, potentially in the range of $75,000 to $150,000, to contract with an outside entity to provide vehicle recall database reports for vehicles subject to registration renewal. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- One-time DMV programming costs of approximately $125,000 to make IT changes to the vehicle registration database systems to provide for the vehicle recall disclosure. Timing of the programming would depend upon when the DMV declares that it has access to a recall database and funding available to provide the disclosure on vehicle registration renewals. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- Ongoing DMV costs of approximately $580,000 for field office and call center staff time to respond to inquiries about the recall notices, assuming a small percentage of the 4.5 – 5 million registration renewal customers request additional information.
- Potential DMV costs beginning in 2017-18 for ongoing dealership inspections and enforcement activities. Staff estimates any additional activities would result in minor costs. (Motor Vehicle Account)
California New Car Dealers Association
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/22/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/2/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bonta, Chávez, Grove, Williams
Prepared by: Randy Chinn / T. & H. / (916) 651-4121
8/22/16 20:38:02
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 287
:
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/21/16
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Bates, Gaines, Galgiani, Leyva, McGuire, Mendoza, Roth, Wieckowski
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/2/15 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill establishes various consumer and car dealer protections for recalled vehicles.
Existing federal law:
- Sets forth in federal regulations the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard.
- Prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a new vehicle subject to a recall, as specified, unless and until the defect is repaired. Federal law does not afford similar prohibitions to used vehicles.
- Requires motor vehicle safety recall information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and vehicle identification number (VIN).
- Prohibits vehicles which are subject to recall from being rented, provided the company renting the cars has a fleet of at least 35 vehicles.
Existing state law requires manufacturers to properly fulfill every warranty agreement and fairly compensate their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing and all other conditions of that obligation.
This bill:
- Includes the cost of disposing of hazardous materials in the compensation required of the manufacturer to the dealer.
- Prohibits the renting or loaning of a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Requires the California Department of Motor Vehicles ( DMV), when mailing a notice of registration renewal, to notify a vehicle owner if their vehicle is subject to recall. This provision shall become operative when the DMV has access to a recall database and sufficient funding.
Comments
- Purpose. According to the author, California already has the strongest consumer protection laws in the country for car buyers. While federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle with an unrepaired recall, neither federal nor California law specifically requires the disclosure or repair of a used vehicle subject to a recall. This bill would further enhance those protections by ensuring that automobile dealers, rental car companies, automobile manufacturers, and the government all have a role in improving the auto recall and repair process.
- Recalls increasing, millions affected. From 1995 to 2015, the number of vehicle recalls has almost tripled, from 348 to 973, with more than 87 million vehicles affected in 2015. The recall of Takata airbags impacts as many as 68.8 million airbags in what the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) called the largest and most complex safety recall in history.
- Reimbursing dealers. Existing law requires auto manufacturers to reimburse their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing and all other conditions of that obligation. Airbags are considered hazardous waste because of the inflation mechanism. This bill specifically identifies the cost of disposing of hazardous waste as a cost the manufacturers must reimburse to the dealers.
- Fixing rentals and loaners. New federal law prohibits rental car companies and dealers with 35 or more available vehicles from renting or loaning cars with an unremedied manufacturer’s recall. This bill extends that prohibition to all rental car companies and dealers, regardless of how many vehicles they have available. While the bill is silent on an enforcement mechanism for this provision, the author intends to allow the DMV to impair the dealer’s license as the penalty, as is the case with similar provisions of the Vehicle Code.
- DMV recall notice. The track record for fixing recalled vehicles is mediocre. NHTSA has estimated that only 70% of recalled vehicles are repaired. To improve that record, the NHTSA established a website where the public can determine whether a vehicle is subject to recall: www.safercar.gov. This bill tries to improve on that record by requiring the DMV to indicate on the annual registration renewal notice when a car is subject to recall. This provision shall be effective when the DMV director certifies that the department has adequate funding and access to the appropriate database. The author’s intent is for California to participate in a recently established federal grant program to fund pilot projects for state notification to consumers of vehicle recalls.
Implementing this provision may take a while because the DMV is currently working on a number of IT projects. However, there is precedent for doing this, as the DMV has an ongoing program of notifying owners when their vehicle is subject to an air emissions-related recall and withholding registration renewal until the equipment is repaired.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown one-time DMV costs, potentially in the range of $75,000 to $150,000, to contract with an outside entity to provide vehicle recall database reports for vehicles subject to registration renewal. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- One-time DMV programming costs of approximately $125,000 to make IT changes to the vehicle registration database systems to provide for the vehicle recall disclosure. Timing of the programming would depend upon when the DMV declares that it has access to a recall database and funding available to provide the disclosure on vehicle registration renewals. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- Ongoing DMV costs of approximately $580,000 for field office and call center staff time to respond to inquiries about the recall notices, assuming a small percentage of the 4.5 – 5 million registration renewal customers request additional information.
- Potential DMV costs beginning in 2017-18 for ongoing dealership inspections and enforcement activities. Staff estimates any additional activities would result in minor costs. (Motor Vehicle Account)
California New Car Dealers Association
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/16/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/2/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bonta, Chávez, Grove, Williams
8/16/16 17:21:26
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 287 (Gordon) - Vehicle safety: recalls
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 11, 2016
Bill Summary:
AB 287 would require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to notify vehicle owners on their registration renewal notices if a vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, as specified. The bill would also prohibit a dealer or car rental company from loaning or renting a vehicle is subject to a recall until the repair has been made.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown one-time DMV costs, potentially in the range of $75,000 to $150,000, to contract with an outside entity to provide vehicle recall database reports for vehicles subject to registration renewal. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- One-time DMV programming costs of approximately $125,000 to make IT changes to the vehicle registration database systems to provide for the vehicle recall disclosure. Timing of the programming would depend upon when the DMV declares that it has access to a recall database and funding available to provide the disclosure on vehicle registration renewals. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- Ongoing DMV costs of approximately $580,000 for field office and call center staff time to respond to inquiries about the recall notices, assuming a small percentage of the 4.5 – 5 million registration renewal customers request additional information.
- Potential DMV costs beginning in 2017-18 for ongoing dealership inspections and enforcement activities. Staff estimates any additional activities would result in minor costs. (Motor Vehicle Account)
Author Amendments:
- Add a provision that authorizes DMV to suspend a dealer’s license for failure to comply with the bill (applies to provisions that prohibit a dealer from loaning or renting a vehicle subject to a recall).
- Specify that the prohibition against dealers and rental car companies from renting or loaning a vehicle subject to a recall only applies to dealers or companies with a fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles.
- Revise the language that DMV would include on registration renewal documents.
- Delete the delayed operative date of July 1, 2017.
- Make a clarifying change.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 287 (Gordon) - Vehicle safety: recalls
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 287 would require the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to notify vehicle owners on their registration renewal notice if a vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, as specified. The bill would also prohibit a dealer or rental car company from loaning or renting a vehicle is subject to a recall until the repair has been made.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown one-time DMV costs, potentially in the range of $75,000 to $150,000, to contract with an outside entity to provide vehicle recall database reports for vehicles subject to registration renewal. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- One-time DMV programming costs of approximately $125,000 to make IT changes to the vehicle registration database systems to provide for the vehicle recall disclosure. Timing of the programming would depend upon when the DMV declares that it has access to a recall database and funding available to provide the disclosure on vehicle registration renewals. (Motor Vehicle Account)
- Ongoing DMV costs of approximately $580,000 for field office and call center staff time to respond to inquiries about the recall notices, assuming a small percentage of the 4.5 – 5 million registration renewal customers request additional information.
- Potential DMV costs beginning in 2017-18 for ongoing dealership inspections and enforcement activities. Staff estimates any additional activities would result in minor costs. (Motor Vehicle Account)
Background:
Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has the authority under federal law to require manufacturers to recall vehicles that have safety defects or do not meet safety standards. If a safety defect is identified, manufacturers are required to notify the NHTSA, owners, dealers and distributors, and, correct the defect at no change (unless the vehicle is more than 10 years old), and vehicle dealers are prohibited from selling a new vehicle subject to a recall, unless the defect is repaired. Federal law requires motor vehicle safety information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and vehicle identification number (VIN). Federal law also prohibits rental car companies and vehicle dealers with 35 or more available vehicles from renting or loaning vehicles that are subject to a safety recall.
From 1995 to 2015, the number of vehicle recalls has almost tripled, from 348 to 973, with more than 87 million vehicles affected in 2015. The recall of Takata airbags impacts as many as 68.8 million airbags in what NHTSA called the largest and most complex safety recall in history. Despite the large number of affected vehicles, NHTSA has estimated that only 70% of recalled vehicles are repaired. To improve that record, the NHTSA established a website where the public can determine whether a vehicle is subject to recall: www.safercar.gov.
Proposed Law:
AB 287 would prohibit the renting or loaning of vehicles subject to a recall, and require DMV to notify vehicle owners on registration renewal documents if their vehicle is subject to a recall. Specifically, this bill would:
- Prohibit a dealer or rental car company from loaning or renting a vehicle subject to a recall until the recall repair is performed. If a remedy is not immediately available but a temporary repair is available to eliminate the safety risk, the dealer or rental company may rent or loan a vehicle after the repair is made, but must make the recall repair when the remedy is available.
- Require DMV to include a specified recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal for a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Require DMV to obtain a recall database report before mailing a notice of registration renewal, and require DMV to notify the registered owner if a vehicle is subject to a recall by checking a box next to the recall disclosure statement.
- Specify that the DMV recall disclosure requirements are operative on the date the director of DMV executes a declaration certifying that DMV has appropriate access to the necessary data within a recall database and available funding to include a recall disclosure statement on registration renewal documents. The declaration must be posted on the DMV website and sent to the Legislature.
- Clarify that automobile manufacturers are liable for costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials associated with a recall through a specified reimbursement of dealer costs to make the recall repair.
- Specify that the bill would become operative on July 1, 2017, except as specified.
Related Legislation:
SB 686 (Jackson) would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling, leasing, or loaning a used vehicle if the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, unless repairs are made to correct the defect have been performed. This bill failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee in 2014.
AB 753 (Monning) would have expressly prohibited a rental car company from renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall notice unless the vehicle has been repaired as specified in the notice. This bill was held without a hearing in this committee in 2011 at the request of the author.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 287 (Author:Gordon)
Version: June 13, 2016
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TH
SUBJECT
Vehicle Safety: Recalls
DESCRIPTION
This bill would restrict the rental, loaning, advertising, and sale of vehicles subject to an automobile manufacturer’s recall as follows:
- vehicles may not be advertised or sold as “certified” if subject to an unremediated manufacturer’s recall; and
- vehicle dealers and rental car companies may not loan or rent vehicles subject to an unremediated manufacturer’s recall;
This bill would also clarify that automobile manufacturers shall be liable for costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials associated with a recall, and would require the Department of Motor Vehicles to notify registered owners of an unrepaired recall in a notice of registration renewal, as specified.
BACKGROUND
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has the authority under federal law to issue vehicle safety standards and to require manufacturers to recall vehicles that have safety defects or do not meet safety standards. If a safety defect is identified, manufacturers are required to notify the NHTSA, owners, dealers and distributors, and, correct the defect at no change (unless the vehicle is more than 10 years old). Recently, concerns have been raised about the risks of purchasing or renting a car subject to a safety recall and, as a result, steps that could be taken to reduce those risks.
As an example of the serious risks posed by safety recalls, a 2012 article published on Edmunds.com entitled “Recalled but Unrepaired Cars Are a Safety Risk to Consumers,” reported:
In April 2009, General Motors [(GM)] began sending registered letters to owners of more than 1.4 million of its cars equipped with 3.8-liter V6 engines, notifying them of a recall for 1997-2003 V6-equipped Chevrolets, Buicks, Oldsmobiles and Pontiacs to address a potential engine fire hazard. The previous year, the company had sent letters to owners of 207,000 Buicks and Pontiacs with turbocharged versions of the same engine for the same problem.
By the time the 2009 recall was issued, there had been reports filed with the [NHTSA] of almost 250 fires in such cars. The problem was thought to be caused by oil that had spilled or leaked onto heated exhaust manifold surfaces. In some cases, the oil caught fire and the flames spread to plastic parts, including the spark plug wiring channel and the upper intake manifolds and engine covers.
As almost all car-fire warnings do, the letters also urged owners not to park the cars in their garages or near homes or other flammable structures until the recall work had been completed. But not every owner of a fire-prone GM vehicle has seen that letter. Although the rate of incidents is steadily declining, there have been at least 250 additional engine fires since the recall was announced three years ago, according to reports filed with NHTSA.
In many cases, the owners of the burned-up cars said they were not aware that there had been a recall. Most had purchased the vehicles used. Many didn't know if the required repair work had ever been done. Some of the cars that were parked in garages are believed in several cases to have caused structural damage or damage to other vehicles as flames spread. (John O'Dell, Recalled But Unrepaired Cars Are a Safety Risk to Consumers, Edmunds (August 20, 2014) <http://www.edmunds.com/car-safety/recalled-but-unrepaired-cars-are-a-safety-risk-to-consumers.html> [as of June 25, 2016].)
In response to concerns about unrepaired recalled vehicles, this bill would generally prohibit the renting and loaning of vehicles subject to a manufacturer’s recall, and would prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling a used vehicle as “certified” if it is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall. This bill would also direct the Department of Motor Vehicles to inform registered owners of unrepaired recalls via a statement on their annual vehicle registration renewal notice.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, Part 577 of 49 C.F.R. 577.1, sets forth the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard. (49 C.F.R. 577.1 et seq.)
Existing state law prohibits any person from acting as a dealer, remanufacturer, manufacturer, or transporter, as specified, without having first been issued a license or temporary permit, as specified. (Veh. Code Sec. 11700.)
Existing law prohibits a holder of a license from, among other things, making or disseminating any statement which is untrue or misleading and which is known, or which by the reasonable exercise of case should be known to be untrue or misleading, as specified. (Veh. Code Sec. 11713(a).)
Existing law provides that it is a violation of the Vehicle Code for a holder of any dealer’s license to advertise or sell a used vehicle as “certified” or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program if any of the following apply: (1) the dealer knows or should have known that the odometer does not indicate actual mileage; (2) the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle was reacquired by a dealer or manufacturer pursuant to state or federal warranty laws; (3) the title has been inscribed with “lemon law buyback,” “manufacturer repurchase,” “salvage,” “ junk,” “nonrepairable,” “flood,” or similar title designation; (4) the vehicle has sustained damage, as specified, that after repair substantially impairs the use or safety of the vehicle; (5) the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle has sustained frame damage; (6) the dealer fails to provide a completed inspection report; (7) the dealer disclaims any warranties of merchantability; (8) the vehicle is sold “AS IS” or (9) the term “certified” or any similar term is used in a manner that is untrue or misleading. (Veh. Code Sec. 11713.18.)
Existing law prohibits a dealer or person holding a retail seller’s permit from selling a new or used vehicle that is not in compliance with the Vehicle Code and departmental regulations, unless the vehicle is sold to another dealer, sold for the purpose of being legally wrecked or dismantled, or sold exclusively for off-highway use, as specified. (Veh. Code Sec. 24007 (a)(1).)
Existing law provides that when a federal motor vehicle standard is established under federal law, as specified, no dealer shall sell or offer for sale a vehicle to which the standard is applicable, and no person shall sell or offer for an item of equipment sale for use upon a vehicle to which the standard is applicable unless: (1) the vehicle conforms to the applicable federal standard; or (2) the vehicle or equipment bears a certification, as specified. (Veh. Code Sec. 24011.)
Existing law provides that every franchisor shall properly fulfill every warranty agreement made by it and adequately and fairly compensate each of its franchisees for labor and parts used to fulfill that warranty when the franchisee has fulfilled warranty obligations of diagnostics, repair, and servicing and shall file a copy of its warranty reimbursement schedule or formula with the board. The warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, and servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation. (Veh. Code Sec. 3065.)
This bill provides that a warranty reimbursement schedule or formula shall be reasonable with respect to the time and compensation allowed to the franchisee for the warranty diagnostics, repair, servicing, and all other conditions of the obligation, including all costs associated with the disposal of hazardous materials that are associated with a recall.
This bill prohibits the holder of any dealer’s license to advertise for sale or sell a used vehicle as “certified” or use any similar descriptive term in the advertisement or the sale of a used vehicle that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program if the vehicle is subject to an unremedied manufacturer’s recall, as specified.
This bill provides that no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made. If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle, however once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
This bill states that for every used vehicle advertised for sale as “certified” or any similar descriptive term that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program, a dealer shall obtain a recall database report before the display or offer and every 30 days thereafter until the vehicle is no longer displayed or offered for sale. If a recall database report obtained by a dealer indicates that a used vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, the dealer shall not advertise for sale or sell that vehicle as “certified” or use any similar descriptive term that implies the vehicle has been certified to meet the terms of a used vehicle certification program until the recall repair has been made.
This bill provides that before mailing a notice of registration renewal to the registered owner of a vehicle, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall obtain a recall database report for that vehicle. If the recall database report indicates that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, the department shall notify the registered owner by checking the box next to the recall disclosure statement, and shall include the following recall disclosure statement on the notice of registration renewal:
“WARNING. This vehicle has an unrepaired manufacturer’s recall. You can get this recall repaired for free. You can check for any recalls and how to get the recall repaired at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Internet Web site.”
This bill states that its provisions shall become operative on July 1, 2017, except as specified.
This bill makes related findings and declarations.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
While vehicles have become safer, the number of vehicles subject to a recall has grown dramatically. Over the past decade, the number of traffic-related deaths has dropped significantly; however, 2014 saw a new record number of recalls in the U.S. with more than 63.8 million recalls. This number of recalls is more than twice as many recalls as any previous year and is equivalent to roughly 25 [percent] of the vehicles on the road today. While slightly lower, 2015 saw 51 million recalls and 2016 is on pace to compare to the past two years, as manufacturers face potential fines from federal regulators, threats of increased litigation, and as the issue receives greater coverage in mainstream media.
Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and available to the public. Federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle with an unrepaired recall. However, neither federal nor California law specifically requires the disclosure or repair of a used vehicle subject to a recall.
The CARS Act [AB 287] would help address problems related to recalls in four important ways, and ensure that car dealers, rental car companies, manufacturers, and the government all have “skin in the game” to enhance consumer protection:
1. Truth in Advertising: Recalls
AB 287 would expand consumer protection law to prohibit a new or used car dealer from advertising for sale or selling a used vehicle as “certified” if it has an unrepaired manufacturer's recall.
2. Rental & Loaner Car Protections
In December 2015, Congress passed and the President signed a five year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act). The measure included a provision that prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
AB 287 would close the fewer than 35 vehicle loophole and prohibit a rental car company or car dealer from renting or loaning any vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
3. Government Responsibility to Notify Owners
[It] is estimated that 30 [percent] of all vehicles subject to a manufacturer recall are never repaired. Moreover, with the increased frequency of notifications from manufacturers, as well as notifications attempting to sell warranties that appear official, vehicle owners may receive a lot of paper. . . . AB 287 would direct the Department of Motor Vehicles to establish a means to notify the owners of vehicles subject to recall at the time of annual registration that there is a recall and how to get it repaired. This requirement would be conditioned upon a determination that the department has access to the necessary data and funds to implement.
4. Manufacturer Responsibility for Proper Disposal of Its Recalled Parts
Currently, when there is a manufacturer recall, the repair can be completed by a manufacturer-authorized facility, typically a franchised new car dealer, at no cost to the consumer. The manufacturer will reimburse the repairing dealer for the necessary new part(s) and for the cost of labor to make the repair. However, if the recall repair includes removal of a part that is considered hazardous material and cannot be disposed of through waste pick-up, the dealer is responsible for that expense. Federal regulations specify how manufacturers shall reimburse the vehicle owner, who pays to have service done on their vehicle and later the part that is replaced is recalled. The federal regulations include reimbursing vehicle owners for “miscellaneous fees such as disposal of waste.”
AB 287 would require that the automobile manufacturer take financial responsibility for this additional expense associated with repairing its recalled vehicles, thereby conforming state law for reimbursing dealers to federal regulations for reimbursing vehicle owners.
- Safety recalls
Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that “[g]enerally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that: (1) poses a risk to motor vehicle safety; and (2) may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture.” Sample defects provided by the NHTSA include steering components that break and cause a loss of control, problems with fuel system components that may cause vehicle fires, accelerator controls that may stick, and child safety seats that contain defective safety belts that create a risk of injury. (See Motor Vehicle Defects and Safety Recalls: What Every Vehicle Owner Should Know, U.S. Department of Transportation <http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm> [as of June 25, 2013].)
This bill takes a multi-faceted approach toward limiting the sale and use of vehicles with unrepaired safety recalls. At the point of sale, this bill would prohibit dealers from selling used vehicles as “certified” if they have an unrepaired recall. Outside the sale context, dealers and rental car companies would be prohibited from renting or loaning vehicles subject to recall. Finally, at the point of registration, this bill would require the Department of Motor Vehicles to inform owners of the fact that their vehicle is part of a recall campaign and has not been repaired. While not a complete prohibition on the sale of used vehicles subject to recall, this bill would arguably help take some proportion of unrepaired recalled vehicles off the road, thereby making the driving environment safer for all drivers.
- “Certified” vehicles
As noted above, this bill would prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling a used vehicle as “certified” if the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall. Considering that “certified” vehicles are generally perceived as being superior to other non-certified vehicles, applying this sale prohibition to certified vehicles arguably aligns the law with the expectation of consumers in the marketplace. Under this bill, a dealer would have the duty to obtain a specified report from a vehicle recall database before the vehicle is displayed or offered for sale, and again every 30 days thereafter, until the vehicle is no longer displayed or offered for sale. If the report indicates that the vehicle is subject to an unrepaired recall, this bill would prohibit its sale.
While relying on the recall database makes compliance with this provision easier for automobile dealers, there could be instances where a dealer learns directly that a vehicle is subject to a recall through other means, such as a recall notification sent from NHTSA. If the dealer learns of an unrepaired recall after running the database report, but fails to consider that separate firsthand knowledge as sufficient to stop the sale of a vehicle as “certified,” such conduct would arguably border on fraud. The Committee may, therefore, wish to consider amending this bill to include actual knowledge of a recall as sufficient to invoke this bill’s “stop-sale” provision to sell that vehicle as “certified.”
Additionally, while the recall database is a useful tool to screen vehicles that can be marketed as “certified,” there is a risk that vehicles initially clear of unrepaired recalls could become subject to a recall campaign before they are sold, but before 30 day recall re-check provision in this bill kicks in. This potential gap between a recall issuing and the re-check provision could lead to vehicles being sold as “certified” even though they have open safety recalls. The Committee may, therefore, wish to consider amending this bill to require more frequent checks of the recall database, including at the point of sale.
- Comments from rental car industry
While not taking a position on this bill, the American Car Rental Association (ACRA) has submitted suggested amendments to this bill in order to harmonize certain aspects of it with federal law pertaining to rental car companies. ACRA states:
ACRA is concerned that the current draft of AB 287 inadvertently conflicts with the language of the federal car rental recall statute. Such conflicts will, if left unaddressed, cause confusion among the car renting and buying public, as well as among car rental companies charged with compliance with both the federal and state statutes, and perhaps among used car dealers as well.
To address its concerns, ACRA suggests the following amendments:
- exclude car rental companies with 35 or more vehicles in their fleets, which are already regulated by the federal statute, from coverage by the provisions of AB 287;
- change the timetable for “grounding” rental vehicles after receipt of a manufacturer’s recall notice to 24 hours, which is consistent with the federal statute’s mandate; and
- clarify that the recall database report provisions which respectively apply to dealers and the Department of Motor Vehicles, do not apply to car rental companies.
Support: California New Car Dealers Association; Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: California New Car Dealers Association
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SB 686 (Jackson, 2013) would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling, leasing, renting, loaning, or otherwise transferring ownership of a used vehicle if the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, unless the repairs required to correct the defect have been performed. This bill died in the Assembly Business, Professions and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 964 (Bonta, 2013) would have included manufacturer’s safety recalls on the list of prohibited conditions for certified vehicles. This bill also would have added a required pre-sale disclosure for all used vehicles regarding manufacturer’s recalls and the other safety and warranty issues. This bill died on the Assembly Floor inactive file.
Prior Vote:
Senate Transportation and Housing Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 16, Noes 0)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Transportation Committee (Ayes 16, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 6/21/2016
Author: | Gordon | ||
Version: | 6/13/2016 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Randy Chinn | ||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill establishes various consumer and car dealer protections for recalled vehicles.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Sets forth in federal regulations the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard.
- Establishes restrictions on when used vehicles may be advertised as “certified.”
- Requires manufacturers to properly fulfill every warranty agreement and fairly compensate their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing and all other conditions of that obligation.
- Federal law prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a new vehicle subject to a recall, as specified, unless and until the defect is repaired. Federal law does not afford similar prohibitions to used vehicles.
- Federal law requires motor vehicle safety recall information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and vehicle identification number (VIN).
- Federal law prohibits vehicles which are subject to recall from being rented, provided the company renting the cars has a fleet of at least 35 vehicles.
This bill:
- Includes the cost of disposing of hazardous materials in the compensation required of the manufacturer to the dealer.
- Prohibits the advertising of a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall as being “certified.”
- Prohibits the renting or loaning of a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Requires the California Department of Motor Vehicles ( DMV), when mailing a notice of registration renewal, to notify a vehicle owner if their vehicle is subject to recall.
- Becomes effective July 1, 2017, with the exception that the DMV notification requirement becomes effective when the DMV director declares that the DMV has access to the necessary recall databases and has available funding to include the recall disclosure statement in the notice of registration renewal.
- Exempts recreational vehicles, motorcycles, and off-highway motor vehicles from the provisions regarding the use of “certified” in advertising, the renting or loaning prohibitions, and the DMV notification provisions.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, California already has the strongest consumer protection laws in the country for car buyers. While federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle with an unrepaired recall, neither federal nor California law specifically requires the disclosure or repair of a used vehicle subject to a recall. This bill would further enhance those protections by ensuring that automobile dealers, rental car companies, automobile manufacturers, and the government all have a role in improving the auto recall and repair process.
- Recalls increasing, millions affected. From 1995 to 2015, the number of vehicle recalls has almost tripled, from 348 to 973, with more than 87 million vehicles affected in 2015. The recall of Takata airbags impacts as many as 68.8 million airbags in what the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) called the largest and most complex safety recall in history.
- Reimbursing dealers. Current law requires auto manufacturers to reimburse their dealers for the diagnostics, repair, servicing and all other conditions of that obligation. Airbags are considered hazardous waste because of the inflation mechanism. This bill specifically identifies the cost of disposing of hazardous waste as a cost the manufacturers must reimburse to the dealers.
- Certified, or not? Current law prohibits the use of the term “certified” in the sale of used vehicles under certain conditions, including the following:
- The dealer knows or should have known the odometer reading is incorrect, the vehicle was reacquired pursuant to federal or state warranty laws, or the vehicle has frame damage
- The vehicle title is noted as salvage, flood, or unrepairable
This bill also prohibits using the term “certified” to describe a vehicle with an unremedied manufacturer’s recall. This bill does not prohibit the sale of vehicles subject to recall.
- Fixing rentals and loaners. New federal law prohibits rental car companies and dealers with 35 or more available vehicles from renting or loaning cars with an unremedied manufacturer’s recall. This bill extends that prohibition to all rental car companies and dealers, regardless of how many vehicles they have available. While the bill is silent on an enforcement mechanism for this provision, the author intends to allow the DMV to impair the dealer’s license as the penalty, as is the case with similar provisions of the Vehicle Code.
- DMV recall notice. The track record for fixing recalled vehicles is mediocre. NHTSA has estimated that only 70% of recalled vehicles are repaired. To improve that record, the NHTSA established a website where the public can determine whether a vehicle is subject to recall: www.safercar.gov. This bill tries to improve on that record by requiring the DMV to indicate on the annual registration renewal notice when a car is subject to recall. This provision shall be effective when the DMV director certifies that the department has adequate funding and access to the appropriate database. The author’s intent is for California to participate in a recently established federal grant program to fund pilot projects for state notification to consumers of vehicle recalls.
Implementing this provision may take a while because the DMV is currently working on a number of IT projects. However, there is precedent for doing this, as the DMV has an ongoing program of notifying owners when their vehicle is subject to an air emissions-related recall and withholding registration renewal until the equipment is repaired.
- Double-referral. This bill has also been referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee. Any amendments will need to be adopted in that committee.
Related Legislation:
SB 686 (Jackson of 2014) — would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling a used vehicle if the dealer knew or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall and failed to correct the defect. SB 686 failed in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 753 (Monning of 2011) — would have prohibited rental car companies from renting a vehicle that is subject to a federal safety recall unless specific conditions are met. AB 753 would have also prohibited a rental car company from selling a vehicle subject to a federal safety recall. This bill failed in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Assembly Votes:
Floor: 76-0
Appr: 16-0
P&CP: 11-0
Trans: 16-0
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 15, 2016.)
SUPPORT:
California New Car Dealers Association
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
OPPOSITION:
(all prior version)
Consumer Action
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Calpirg
Consumer Watchdog
Courage Campaign
-- END --
AB 287
Page 3
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 287
(Gordon, et al.)
As Amended May 28, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Transportation |
16-0 |
Frazier, Achadjian, Baker, Bloom, Campos, Chu, Daly, Dodd, Eduardo Garcia, Gomez, Kim, Linder, Medina, Melendez, Nazarian, O'Donnell |
|
Privacy |
11-0 |
Gatto, Wilk, Baker, Calderon, Chang, Chau, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Gordon, Low |
|
Appropriations |
16-0 |
Gomez, Bigelow, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gordon, Holden, Jones, Quirk, Rendon, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY: Enacts the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (Act) which requires a motor vehicle dealer to obtain a recall database report within 30 days before sale or offer of a used car, generally requires a used car to be repaired prior to transfer or accepted by the consumer unrepaired after providing informed consent, and prohibits the rental of vehicles subject to a recall. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits a dealer from displaying or offering for sale a used vehicle unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display of offer.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall until the recall repair has been made.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall and the line-make is the same as the franchise of the dealer, until the recall repair has been made.
Allows a dealer to sell or lease a used vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified, if the vehicle is not the same line-make as the franchise of the dealer if the following conditions are satisfied:
The dealer provides the recall database report to the consumer disclosing the manufacturer's recall prior to sale or lease; and,
The consumer signs a disclosure agreement acknowledging the manufacturer's recall, and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicle’s line-make.
Clarifies that the disclosure by a dealer and acknowledgment by the consumer has no legal effect other than to demonstrate compliance with the law by the dealer, and should not be interpreted to place consumers in a less advantageous legal position than if no disclosure had been made.
Specifies that a recall database report and the disclosure agreement signed by the consumer must be provided separate from the conditional sales contract or other purchase agreement.
Prohibits a rental car company from renting a vehicle subject to a recall no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a recall, or sooner if practicable.
Allows a rental car company, if a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, to rent the vehicle after having the interim repairs completed.
Specifies that once the remedy for the rental vehicle subject to recall becomes available to the rental car company, the rental car company may not rent the vehicle until repaired.
Requires the seller of a motor vehicle, including private party sales, to disclose all recalls related to the vehicle being sold and requires the buyer to provide an acknowledgment form to the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) indicating the buyer has received all recall information in order to transfer vehicle registration, as specified, and authorizes the DMV to refuse transfer or registration without that acknowledgment.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to clearly and conspicuously display all recall notifications on its Web site.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to provide, upon request, a consumer seeking to repair a recalled vehicle a rental or loaner vehicle at no cost until the parts and/or procedures become available, as specified.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to adequately and fairly compensate a dealer for costs associated with providing a rental or loaner vehicle and storing a recalled vehicle waiting to be repaired, as specified.
Specifies that a vehicle manufacturer shall not provide a consumer with a rental or loaner vehicle that is subject to a Stop Sale- Stop Drive recall or a manufacturer’s recall.
Provides that a dealer, rental car company, or private seller are not legally responsible for any errors, inaccuracies or omissions contained in the recall database report, nor do such parties have any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the required recall database report.
Further provides that nothing in this bill shall affect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law.
Establishes a claims and appeals process, as specified, between vehicle dealers and manufacturers regarding payment requirements and obligations identified in the Act.
Directs the DMV's New Motor Vehicle Board (Board) to hear and decide disputes between vehicle dealers and manufacturers related to the Act's payment requirements and obligations.
Requires the certificate of ownership for an automobile to contain a provision for a recall disclosure, as specified, as of July 1, 2016, or as soon as the DMV exhausts its existing supply of certificate of ownership forms.
Proclaims that it is unlawful and a misdemeanor violation for a manufacturer, as specified, to unfairly discriminate against a dealer based on certain provisions specified in the Act.
Excludes recreational vehicles, motorcycles, off-highway motor vehicles, vehicles sold by a salvage pool, and non-repairable vehicles as excluded from the provisions of this bill.
Defines the term "area of responsibility" as it pertains to dealer franchise agreements.
Declares that the consumer-related provisions of this bill shall become operable as of July 1, 2016, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor absorbable cost for the DMV to include the disclosure statement on new certificates of ownership and bills of sale. [Motor Vehicle Account]
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill. This bill is intended to provide a comprehensive solution to the dangers of recalled automobiles by requiring used car dealers to check for outstanding recalls, and then either repair the car before transfer, if the car is the same line-make as the dealer or if the defect is particularly dangerous, or allow the consumer to provide informed consent and take the unrepaired car if it is a different line-make. Rental car companies would be prohibited from renting a vehicle if they received notice of the recall at least 48 hours in advance. This bill is sponsored by the California New Car Dealers Association.
Substantial number of recalls announced annually. According to the author, "[w]hile vehicles have become safer, the number of vehicles subject to a recall has grown dramatically.…2014 saw a new record number of recalls in the United States with more than 63.8 million recalls. This number of recalls is more than twice as many recalls as any previous year and is equivalent to roughly 25% of the vehicles on the road today. Officials predict that 2015 could see another record year, as manufacturers face potential fines from federal regulators, threats of increased litigation, and as the issue receives greater coverage in mainstream media."
Analysis Prepared by: Hank Dempsey / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000825
AB 287
Page 3
Date of Hearing: May 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 287
(Gordon) – As Amended May 4, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Transportation |
Vote: |
16 - 0 |
|
Privacy and Consumer Protection |
|
11 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill enacts the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (Act), effective July 1, 2016, which establishes specified prohibitions and conditions, on the sale or lease of used vehicles and on vehicle rentals, with regard to vehicles subject to manufacturer recall. This bill also:
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle—if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall or the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall and the line-make is the same as the franchise of the dealer—until the recall repair has been made.
Requires, if a vehicle subject to a recall is not the same line-make as the dealer's franchise, the dealer may sell the vehicle if the dealer discloses the recall to the buyer prior to the sale and the buyer signs a disclosure acknowledging that the vehicle is subject to the recall.
Prohibits the renting of a vehicle subject to a safety-related recall until the vehicle is repaired. If the remedy for the recall is not immediately available, but the recall notice provides for a temporary repair to eliminate the safety-related issue, the vehicle can be rented once this repair is accomplished.
Requires a private party selling a motor vehicle to disclose in writing to the buyer all Stop Sale-Stop Drive recall and manufacturer recalls, prohibits a buyer from accepting the vehicle transfer document without this disclosure, and authorizes the DMV to refuse transfer of title if the buyer does not also submit his or her written acknowledgement of receiving the seller's disclosure.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to clearly and conspicuously display all recall notifications on its website, to provide, upon request from a consumer seeking to repair a recalled vehicle, a rental or loaner vehicle at no cost until the parts and/or procedures become available, and to adequately and fairly compensate a dealer for costs associated with providing a rental or loaner vehicle and storing a recalled vehicle waiting to be repaired.
Directs the DMV's New Motor Vehicle Board (Board) to hear and decide on disputes between vehicle dealers and manufacturers related to the Act's payment requirements and obligations.
Stipulates that nothing in the Act shall effect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The DMV will incur additional costs associated with verifying the inclusion of the recall disclosure and suspending registration transfer on those transactions that do not contain the disclosure pending resolution of such cases. Given the number of transactions involved, costs could be up to several hundred thousand dollars annually. [Motor Vehicle Account]
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is intended to provide a comprehensive solution to the dangers of recalled automobiles by requiring used car dealers to check for outstanding recalls, and then either repair the car before transfer, if the car is the same line make as the dealer or if the defect is particularly dangerous, or allow the consumer to provide informed consent and take the unrepaired car if it is a different line make. Supporters generally argue that this bill improves consumer protection by taking the most dangerous cars off the road while increasing consumer awareness, while opponents claim the bill misleads consumers about the dangers of the remaining automobiles while shifting other burdens and risks onto the consumer. AB 287 is sponsored by the California New Car Dealers Association.
According to the author, "Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and available to the public. While federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle subject to a recall, neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. Unfortunately, studies have shown that about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicle’s owner…AB 287, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act) would help address problems related to the sale, lease or rental of used cars subject to recall.
Opposition. Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS) in part argues that the distinction between manufacturer recalls and Stop Sale-Stop Drive recalls would lead to bad outcomes: "[T]his bill would create a new, unprecedented, dangerous and misleading distinction among auto safety recalls – based not on science, or any federally-established standard, or on any other objective criteria….Instead, it would expressly allow dealers to sell any used vehicle, no matter how imminent the threat to public safety, or how many deaths and injuries the safety defect has caused, or will cause, unless the auto manufacturer – in its sole, subjective discretion – has chosen to designate the recall as a “Stop Sale-Stop Drive” recall. This would create the false, misleading, and dangerous impression that only “Stop Sale – Stop Drive” safety recalls need to be addressed promptly."
The Association of Global Automakers argues that recalls are an issue that should be addressed at the federal level, and notes that the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is current reviewing federal regulations in this regard.
Prior Legislation. In 2014, SB 686 (Jackson), which would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling a used vehicle if the dealer knew or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall and failed to correct the defect, failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 287
Page 14
Date of Hearing: April 21, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Mike Gatto, Chair
AB 287
(Gordon) – As Amended March 23, 2015
SUBJECT: Vehicle safety: recalls
SUMMARY: Enacts the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (Act), which requires a motor vehicle dealer or rental car company to obtain a recall database report within 30 days before sale or offer of a car, and generally requires the car to be repaired prior to transfer or accepted by the consumer unrepaired after providing informed consent. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits a dealer from displaying or offering for sale a used vehicle unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display of offer.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall until the recall repair has been made.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall and the line make is the same as the franchise of the dealer, until the recall repair has been made.
Allows a dealer to sell or lease a used vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified, if the vehicle is not the same line make as the franchise of the dealer if the following conditions are satisfied:
The dealer provides the recall database report to the consumer disclosing the manufacturer's recall prior to sale or lease; and,
The consumer signs a disclosure agreement acknowledging the manufacturer's recall, and that the consumer can get the recall repaired at no cost to the consumer at a new motor vehicle dealer of the vehicle’s line make.
Specifies that a recall database report and the disclosure agreement provided and signed by the consumer are to be provided separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
Prohibits a rental car company from renting a vehicle unless the company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer.
Prohibits a rental car company from renting a vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall until the recall repair has been made.
Allows a rental car company to rent a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified, if the following conditions are satisfied:
The rental car company discloses the recall database report to the consumer disclosing the manufacturer's recall prior to rental; and,
The consumer signs a disclosure agreement acknowledging the manufacturer's recall, as specified.
Requires the seller of a motor vehicle, including private party sales, to disclose all recalls related to the vehicle being sold and requires the buyer to provide an acknowledgement form to the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) indicating the buyer has received all recall information in order to transfer vehicle registration, as specified, and authorizes the DMV to refuse transfer or registration without that acknowledgement.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to clearly and conspicuously display all recall notifications on its website.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to provide, upon request, a consumer seeking to repair a recalled vehicle a rental or loaner vehicle at no cost until the parts and/or procedures become available, as specified.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to adequately and fairly compensate a dealer for costs associated with providing a rental or loaner vehicle and storing a recalled vehicle waiting to be repaired, as specified.
Provides that a dealer, rental car company, or private seller are not legally responsible for any errors, inaccuracies or omissions contained in the recall database report, nor do such parties have any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, franchisee, rental car company, or private seller obtained the required recall database report.
Establishes a claims and appeals process, as specified, between vehicle dealers and manufacturers regarding payment requirements and obligations identified in the Act.
Directs the DMV's New Motor Vehicle Board (Board) to hear and decide on disputes between vehicle dealers and manufacturers related to the Act's payment requirements and obligations.
Authorizes the DMV to refuse to accept the initial, renewal, or transfer of a vehicle registration if the buyer fails to provide the DMV with a recall disclosure statement as specified in the Act.
Proclaims that it is unlawful and a misdemeanor violation for a manufacturer, as specified, to unfairly discriminate against a dealer based on certain provisions specified in the Act.
Defines the terms "dealer," "manufacturer's recall," "new motor vehicle dealer," "recall database," "recall database report," "rental car company," "Stop Sale – Stop Drive recall," and "vehicle manufacturer."
Declares that the consumer-related provisions of this bill are severable.
Excludes recreational vehicles, motorcycles, off-highway motor vehicles, vehicles sold by a salvage pool, and non-repairable vehicles as excluded from the provisions of this bill, as specified.
Declares that the consumer-related provisions of this bill shall become operable as of July 1, 2016, as specified.
Makes legislative findings and declarations pertaining to the increasing number of vehicle recalls, the safety and economic impacts associated with vehicle recalls, and the importance of reimbursing auto dealers for the costs associated with recalls.
Makes other technical or non-substantive amendments.
Declares that no reimbursement is required by this bill because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, or changes the definition of a crime.
EXISTING LAW:
Prohibits any person from acting as a dealer, remanufacturer, manufacturer, or transporter, as specified, without having first been issued a license or temporary permit, as specified. (Vehicle Code (VC) Section 11700)
Prohibits a holder of a license from, among other things, making or disseminating any statement which is untrue or misleading and which is known, or which by the reasonable exercise of care should be known, to be untrue or misleading, as specified. (VC 11713(a))
Establishes the Car Buyer's Bill of Rights and prohibits a car dealer from selling or advertising for sale a used car as "certified" under certain conditions, including if the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle was reacquired by the vehicle's manufacturer or a dealer pursuant to state or federal warranty laws, or if the term “certified” or any similar descriptive term is used in any manner that is untrue or misleading or that would cause any advertisement to be in violation of the provisions prohibiting a car dealer from scheming to sell a vehicle or service at a price other than advertised in accordance with the VC, or the unfair competition laws contained in the Business and Professions Code. (VC 11713.18.)
Prohibits a dealer or person holding a retail seller’s permit from selling a new or used vehicle that is not in compliance with the VC and departmental regulations, unless the vehicle is sold to another dealer, sold for the purpose of being legally wrecked or dismantled, or sold exclusively for off-highway use, as specified. (VC 24007 (a)(1))
Provides that when a federal motor vehicle standard is established under federal law, as specified, no dealer shall sell or offer for sale a vehicle to which the standard is applicable, and no person shall sell or offer an item of equipment for sale for use upon a vehicle to which the standard is applicable unless: (a) the vehicle conforms to the applicable federal standard; or (b) the vehicle or equipment bears a certification, as specified. (VC 24011)
Establishes the Board within DMV and requires the Board to hear and decide on certain appeals and protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee pertaining to a dispute with a vehicle manufacturer. (VC 3050)
Establishes the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (MAP-21), and requires the Secretary of the United States Department of Transportation (U.S. DOT) to promulgate regulations by July 6, 2013, requiring motor vehicle safety recall information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). (Public Law 112-141, 112th Congress, Section 31301)
Sets forth in federal regulations the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard. (49 Code of Federal Regulations 577.1 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill. This bill is intended to provide a comprehensive solution to the dangers of recalled automobiles by requiring used car dealers and rental car companies to check for outstanding recalls, and then either repair the car before transfer, if the car is the same line make as the dealer or if the defect is particularly dangerous, or allow the consumer to provide informed consent and take the unrepaired car if it is a different line make or a rental car. Supporters generally argue that this bill improves consumer protection by taking the most dangerous cars off the road while increasing consumer awareness, while opponents claim the bill misleads consumers about the dangers of the remaining automobiles while shifting other burdens and risks onto the consumer. AB 287 is sponsored by the California New Car Dealers Association.
Author's statement. According to the author, "Federal regulations now require most vehicle manufacturers to provide recall information applicable to the vehicles they manufacture on the Internet and available to the public. While federal law prohibits the sale of a new vehicle subject to a recall, neither federal nor California law addresses used vehicles subject to a recall. Unfortunately, studies have shown that about one-third of all recalled vehicles are never repaired by the vehicle’s owner…
"AB 287, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act) would help address problems related to the sale, lease or rental of used cars subject to recall in [the following ways]: AB 287 would require auto manufacturers to conspicuously display on their website and in all recall notifications to consumers when a vehicle is subject to a Stop Drive/Stop Sale recall. AB 287 would prohibit new car dealers, used car dealers, and rental car companies from selling, leasing, or renting any used car in California subject to a Stop Drive/Stop Sale recall. For recalls not designated as Stop Drive/Stop Sale by either NHTSA or the auto manufacturer, AB 287 would require new and used car dealers and rental car companies to check a qualified recall database within 30 days prior to selling, leasing or renting any used vehicle to consumers. For all used vehicle sales, if a vehicle is of the same line make as a dealer’s franchise, AB 287 would prohibit new car dealers from selling/leasing a vehicle at retail until the recall issue is repaired.
"For recalls not designated as Stop Drive/Stop Sale: If a vehicle is not of the same line make as the dealer’s franchise or the dealer does not have a franchise, AB 287 would require the dealer to take the following steps prior to sale or lease of a used vehicle subject to recall: Disclose the recall to the consumer; Provide a copy of the recall notice to the consumer; Inform the consumer that he or she can get the recall repaired at no cost at a car dealer of the vehicle’s line make. AB 287 would require rental car companies to disclose the recall to consumers prior to renting the used vehicle subject to recall and to provide a copy of the recall notice to the consumer. AB 287 would [also] require private party sellers to inform potential buyers of any and all recalls prior to sale, similar to the current odometer disclosure.
"[Finally,] AB 287 would require auto manufacturers to provide consumers with a loaner vehicle at their request and at no cost, when consumers seek to get a recall corrected and the parts or procedures are not available for repair."
Understanding motor vehicle safety recalls. The National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act gives the U.S. DOT's National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) authority to issue motor vehicle safety standards and to require manufacturers to recall vehicles that have safety-related defects or do not meet federal safety standards.
Manufacturers voluntarily initiate most recalls, while others may be influenced by NHTSA investigations. If a safety defect is discovered, the manufacturer must notify NHTSA, as well as vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors, plan a recall campaign to remedy it, send repair guidance to franchised dealerships, send notices to vehicle owners, and monitor the effectiveness of the recall campaign and provide to NHSTA data on the status of the recall campaign. The manufacturer is required to remedy the problem at no charge to the owner (for vehicles sold up to 10 years before the recall). After a car is brought to a franchised dealership for repair, the dealer will perform the recall remedy and submit claims to the manufacturer for reimbursement. NHTSA is responsible for monitoring the manufacturer’s corrective action to ensure successful completion of the recall campaign. However, NHTSA cannot require car dealers to notify potential buyers of an outstanding safety defect or require that they get the defect remedied prior to a sale.
Conversely, if NHTSA receives enough complaints and information about the operation of a vehicle that it finds there is a significant threat to public safety, then it can initiate a mandatory recall. NHTSA can perform an investigation with a review by engineers and experts and work with the vehicle manufacturer to recall vehicles. These recalls are facilitated through direct relationships between manufacturers, franchised dealerships, and owners who purchased the new vehicles. According to NHTSA, from 2000 to 2011, all safety defect recalls for passenger vehicles were conducted voluntarily by manufacturers, although some of those recalls were based on NHTSA’s investigations of safety defects.
The process of alerting owners of used vehicles is more difficult because the vehicles may have changed hands several times, and manufacturers may not have established communications with used vehicle dealers who buy and sell multiple different types of cars.
GAO report finds lack of recall information for used cars a “significant risk.” According to a June 2011 U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report that examined the federal safety recall process, "NHTSA cannot require used-car dealers (or franchised dealerships that sell used vehicles) to notify potential buyers of an outstanding safety defect or require that they get the defect remedied prior to sale." The report pointed out that, with 35 million used cars sold in used and franchised dealerships in 2009 alone, unknown recalls "could pose a significant risk to the safety of millions of vehicle drivers and may have a negative impact on recall completion rates." It adds, "NHTSA also currently lacks the authority to require manufacturers to notify used-car dealerships – which sold 11 million cars in 2009 – of recalls or require these dealerships to notify potential buyers of an outstanding recall. As a result, many consumers may be unknowingly putting their lives at risk by purchasing a defective vehicle."
According to a February 11, 2014, press release by private-sector vehicle information provider Carfax, "[M]ore than 3.5 million cars were listed for sale online with an open safety recall. Texas, California, Missouri, Florida and Ohio led the nation with the most recalled cars for sale online last year."
Substantial number of recalls announced annually. According to the author, "[w]hile vehicles have become safer, the number of vehicles subject to a recall has grown dramatically. Over the past decade, the number of traffic-related deaths has dropped significantly; however, 2014 saw a new record number of recalls in the U.S. with more than 63.8 million recalls. This number of recalls is more than twice as many recalls as any previous year and is equivalent to roughly 25% of the vehicles on the road today. Officials predict that 2015 could see another record year, as manufacturers face potential fines from federal regulators, threats of increased litigation, and as the issue receives greater coverage in mainstream media."
According to the Los Angeles Times, "[A]utomakers have issued almost 20 million vehicle safety announcements so far this year. No, the world's cars aren’t falling apart. But headlines and lawsuits over slow recalls have made auto manufacturers more vigilant… Automakers that were slow to recall defective vehicles in the past have been hit with increasing large federal fines and costly product-liability lawsuits. Meanwhile, [NHTSA] faces growing congressional criticism for not forcing car companies to recall vehicles quickly." ("Auto recalls speed up, are on track to break a record," May 15, 2014, Los Angeles Times)
The sponsor, the California New Car Dealers Association (CNCDA), notes that the pace of recalls continues to grow: "In 2014, 63.8 million vehicle recalls were issued in the United States, more than two times the number of recalls issued in any previous year. [NHTSA] expects an even higher number of recalls to be issued this year as auto manufacturers respond to threats of increased litigation and fines and potential damage to their reputations. If true this means that nearly 50% of all vehicles on the road in California and throughout the nation will have been recalled in less than two years."
Improvements in accessing recall information. According to a June 25, 2013, letter from NHTSA, "An auto dealer (or any vehicle owner) today may easily access up-to-date, VIN [vehicle identification number]-specific information regarding the safety recall status of a used car. Such information may be accessed through the manufacturer's publicly accessible VIN-look up website, through a commercial VIN-look up service for registered owners, or through the manufacturer's toll-free number."
In 2012, Congress enacted the MAP-21 Act, a funding and authorization bill to govern federal transportation spending that contains a provision requiring motor vehicle safety recall information about outstanding recalls to be posted online in a format that preserves consumer privacy and is searchable by vehicle make, model, and VIN. The MAP-21 Act required U.S. DOT to promulgate regulations by July 6, 2013, requiring each vehicle manufacturer to provide vehicle recall information on a public website and to car dealers.
On August 14, 2013, NHTSA issued a final rule that will require all major manufacturers (those who produce more than 25,000 vehicles per year) to provide the public with online access to recall information searchable by VIN and without requiring additional information to allow consumers to instantly determine whether action is required to address an uncompleted safety recall. This information will be required to be updated at least weekly. While many automakers already make this information available, those who do not will be required to comply by August 14, 2014.
Understanding what constitutes a "recall." According to NHTSA, the Act defines motor vehicle safety as "the performance of a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment in a way that protects the public against unreasonable risk of accidents occurring because of the design, construction, or performance of a motor vehicle, and against unreasonable risk of death or injury in an accident, and includes nonoperational safety of a motor vehicle.” A defect includes “any defect in performance, construction, a component, or material of a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment.” Generally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that poses a risk to motor vehicle safety, and may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture.
According to the 2011 GAO report, there are two types of safety recalls. Compliance recalls occur when vehicles or vehicle equipment is determined to be noncompliant with applicable federal safety standards, as identified by NHTSA or a manufacturer. Compliance recalls range from design issues with seatbelts to improper placement of warning labels for airbags, and from 2000 to 2009, accounted for 18% of vehicle recalls.
The other 82% of recalls were safety defect recalls, which occur when a defect in a vehicle creates an unreasonable safety risk as determined by NHTSA or a manufacturer. Examples may include problems with ignition switches, steering components, fuel systems, accelerator controls, air bags, wiring or child safety seats, among other things, that have the potential to cause harm or increase the risk of a crash. NHTSA also provides a partial list of what would not constitute a safety-related defect: air conditioners and radios that do not operate properly, ordinary wear of equipment that must be periodically maintained or repaired, nonstructural rust, paint or cosmetic blemishes, and excessive oil consumption.
This bill makes a distinction between the standard "manufacturer recall" (excluding service campaigns and emission recalls) and a "Stop Sale – Stop Drive" recall, where the vehicle manufacturer or NHTSA informs the dealer to stop the sale of the vehicle or provides precaution advice to the owner to stop operating the vehicle. According to CNCDA, Stop Drive, Stop Sale recalls comprise about 6% to 8% of all safety recalls and represent the most serious threat to the safety of the motoring public. Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS) differs in this view, stating that this distinction is subjective and made by the manufacturer, and used only in extreme cases (approximately 1% of all recalls).
This bill in practice. As noted above, the primary provisions of this bill are the requirements that all used car dealers and rental car companies check the recall database at least every 30 days and then either hold the car until repaired if the car is the same line make as the dealer, or sell/rent the car with the consumer's informed consent if the car is a rental or a different line make than the dealer. The only exception is if the vehicle is subject to a much more urgent "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall, in which case a car may not be sold or rented until repaired, regardless of the nature of the company holding the car.
Furthermore, private parties selling a car need only get the informed consent of the buyer. Consumers seeking to repair a recalled vehicle who are delayed by the lack of parts or proper procedures must be provided a loaner/rental car by the vehicle manufacturer. The effective date of these provisions would also be delayed by six months, becoming operational on July 1, 2016.
This bill also contains multiple provisions pertaining to the franchisee/franchisor relationship between manufacturers and dealers, and procedures for reimbursement and dispute resolution, but as those elements of the bill are outside of the jurisdiction of this Committee, they will not be discussed in detail here.
Arguments in support. According to the sponsor, CNCDA, "AB 287, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act), ….is bipartisan, comprehensive consumer protection legislation that would make California the first state in the nation to comprehensively address recalls of used cars.
"California already has the strongest consumer protection laws in the country for car buyers, but neither California nor federal law address[es] the sale, lease or rental of a recalled used vehicle. The CARS Act would comprehensively enhance California’s existing consumer protections by ensuring the most pressing safety issues are fixed in a timely manner, improving the information made available to consumers about cars subject to recall and providing consumers with access to loaner vehicles at no cost if their vehicle is subject to recall and parts are not available to repair the vehicle.
"The CARS Act improves vehicle safety and increases recall disclosure to consumers when buying, leasing or renting a used car subject to recalls in three important ways.
"[First,] [u]nlike other proposals, AB 287 applies to car dealers and rental car companies to ensure that the most dangerous vehicles get fixed. Under the CARS Act, car dealers and rental car companies would be prohibited from selling, leasing or renting any used car in California subject to a Stop Drive, Stop Sale recall.
"[Second,] [u]nder AB 287, franchised dealers of the same line make (such as a Toyota dealer selling a used Prius) will fix any and all recalls prior to sale. For all other vehicles, the CARS Act increases the disclosure requirements for car dealers, rental car companies and private sellers, so consumers will be made aware of recalls prior to purchase or rental. The new disclosure requirement would ensure that consumers are told that a recall exists on the vehicle and provide[d] a copy of the recall notice.
"[Third,] roughly 60% of all used cars sales in California
are made by private sellers, not car dealers. If private sellers are
excluded from any recall consumer protection proposal then
unsuspecting private buyers will be left unaware of the recall status
of the car they wish to purchaser. The CARS Act addresses this
problem by ensuring private sellers provide to any potential buyer
notice of all recalls on the car prior to sale. This new consumer
protection would operate similarly to the current odometer disclosure
on the certificate of ownership.
"AB 287 comprehensively covers sales by new car dealers, used
car dealers, rental car companies and private sellers…Finally, AB
287 directly addresses the biggest hurdle for most consumers in
getting their recalled vehicles repaired: the cost and inconvenience
of being without their vehicle while the recall work is being
performed.…The CARS Act addresses this issue by granting consumers
with the ability to request a loaner or rental vehicle at no cost
from the automaker until the recall repairs can be completed.
"In
sum, AB 287 is groundbreaking legislation that will enhance
California’s already strong consumer protection laws by leading to
more recalled vehicles getting fixed and better informing consumers
when purchasing or renting vehicles."
Arguments in opposition. CARS opposes the bill on a number of major grounds, which are echoed by other opponents as well:
Concerns about misleading distinctions between types
of safety recalls. CARS argues that the distinction between
manufacturer recalls and Stop Sale Stop Drive recalls would lead to
bad outcomes: "[T]his bill would create a new, unprecedented,
dangerous and misleading distinction among auto safety recalls –
based not on science, or any federally-established standard, or on
any other objective criteria….Instead, it would expressly allow
dealers to sell any used vehicle, no matter how imminent the threat
to public safety, or how many deaths and injuries the safety defect
has caused, or will cause, unless the auto manufacturer – in its
sole, subjective discretion – has chosen to designate the recall as
a “Stop Sale – Stop Drive” recall. This would create the
false, misleading, and dangerous impression that only “Stop Sale –
Stop Drive” safety recalls need to be addressed
promptly."
"According to a letter the Alliance
of Automobile Manufacturers submitted last November to [NHTSA], on
behalf of over a dozen leading auto manufacturers, during the years
2000- 2013, only approximately 1% of recalled vehicles involved a
blanket warning from the manufacturer advising owners not to drive
their cars. In some years, no manufacturer issued such a warning.
However, that does not mean that the other recalls during those years
did not involve safety defects that pose a serious risk to the
American public. In fact, during that time, the other 99% of recalled
vehicles during included cars with obviously life-threatening safety
defects, many of which did claim lives and cause debilitating
injuries.
"Drawing this false distinction between 'do
not drive' recalls and other safety recalls would also inevitably
send a confusing, contradictory message to consumers, telling them
that, according to the state of California, recalled cars are safe
enough for a dealer to sell, while expecting the buyers to get the
recall repairs performed themselves."
CARS also
points out that the danger of driving a potentially unsafe car
extends beyond that individual to family, and even to strangers
driving on the same roads.
Concerns about shifting of the disclosure and repair burden
to the consumer. CARS and others argue that this bill would harm
consumers by burdening them with the responsibility of managing or
accepting most recall repairs instead of imposing those costs on the
dealer, manufacturer or rental car company (although consumers
currently bear that burden under existing law). Opponents point to
the finding that roughly one-third of recalled vehicles are never
repaired, in large part because of problems with parts shortages,
technician shortages, insufficient numbers of dealers, and the
transaction costs for consumers to arrange the repairs.
Moreover,
the disclosures required for cars sold by different line make dealers
or rented by rental car companies are viewed as ineffective at
usefully informing the consumer of the risks associated with the
recall. The complexity of the transaction, the large amount of
paperwork written in 'technical jargon,' the lack of accommodation
for non-English language speakers, the consumer's expectation that
dealers would be prohibited by the state from selling unsafe cars
when most other products cannot be sold once recalled, and claims by
dealers of multi-point inspections that don’t include recall
checks, combine to weaken the real-world impact of the disclosure
required by this bill. CARS writes, "In essence, the bill would
require consumers – if they do happen to see the notices and
actually read them – to make life-or-death decisions under
pressure, with little time to deliberate, on the basis of incomplete
information."
Concerns that standards are lowered for rental cars. CARS
contends that this bill "would be far worse than the prevailing
practices in the rental car industry (with the exception of
Rent-a-Wreck). This bill would allow rental car companies to
rent approximately 99% of unsafe recalled cars to consumers,
regardless how unsafe the cars are, unless the manufacturer has, in
its sole discretion, chosen to warn its customers not to drive the
car, pending repairs."
CARS points to pending federal
legislation (S.2819 by Senator Boxer), that would prohibit rental car
companies from renting or selling recalled cars to the public until
the safety recall repairs have been performed. According to CARS,
"the rental car industry" supports the legislation, and
that this bill would potentially disrupt those efforts. At the same
time, "all of the major rental car companies, including
Enterprise, Hertz, Avis, Dollar-Thrifty, and many smaller rental car
companies have already voluntarily adopted policies that are more
consumer-friendly and safety-oriented than AB 287. For years, they
have been grounding recalled cars until they are repaired, rather
than renting or selling them to the public. Therefore, AB 287 would
represent a giant step backwards in terms of safety."
Additionally, the provisions of AB 287 that would require
manufacturers to provide loaner or rental cars to consumers while
waiting for recall repairs to be completed, do not require that those
cars be free of recall defects. As CARS puts it, "[t]his
totally defeats the entire purpose of proving a loaner in the first
place – to mitigate the risks to the vehicle owner, their family
and other passengers, and others who share the roads."
Moreover, the bill fails to ensure that consumers are meaningfully
alerted to the fact that manufacturers are required to provide
loaner/rental cars upon request.
Concerns that AB
287's provisions are worse than existing law. A number of
opponents contend that the consumer notice and consent provisions of
this bill would actually reduce the level of consumer protection
available under existing law by permitting manufacturers to make the
argument, in future personal injury cases, that a consumer who was
injured in a crash is partially at fault for the injury because he or
she accepted the car knowing it had an outstanding recall.
Representative of those concerns is Consumer Attorneys of
California (CAOC), which writes: "If the consumer, after being
advised of the recall, and signing an acknowledgement, fails to take
the vehicle in for the repair, defendants will argue that the
consumer had some responsibility in any subsequent legal action
involving injury or death. While this would not absolve the
manufacturer of liability for the defect, it could certainly reduce
recovery through the legal doctrine of comparative fault. This
approach is commonly seen by CAOC members in recall cases, in that
the manufacturer presents evidence that Notice of the Recall was sent
to the registered owner, and the owner did not take the vehicle in
for the repairs. Often there is a dispute about whether the Notice
was received. This bill would eliminate that dispute in those
instances where there was a signed acknowledgement, as required by
the bill. Therefore, in every instance where a consumer is harmed by
the product and a legal action results, the dealer will argue that
the consumer was comparatively at fault. This may or may not be
successful, but the litigation surrounding this issue will be
expensive and drawn out, harming the consumer’s best chance of a
fair result."
Furthermore, the International
Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers argues that "For
decades, California has had a number of state laws on the books aimed
at protecting used car buyers from such practices, such as those that
prohibit dealers from violating express or implied warranties,
engaging in fraud (concealing a material fact), engaging in false
advertising, or engaging in bait-and-switch; plus, if injuries or
fatalities occur as a result of the dealer's malfeasance, the
potential of facing claims for reckless endangerment, negligence or
strict liability….Unfortunately, instead of improving protections
for car buyers, [AB 287] would weaken existing law, and give dealers
who engage in these prohibited practices a new 'safe harbor' under
state law."
Questions for the Committee and proposed amendments. As discussed above, there are a number of issues where the Committee may wish to consider the amendments provided below as a means to address valid concerns raised by opponents and to improve the overall consumer protection provided by this bill.
One concern is the differential treatment of used cars for sale and cars for rent. While it would be ideal if all used and rental cars were held to an identical standard where all cars under recall are held back from consumers until repaired, the author contends that such an approach would cause used car dealers to buy fewer used cars with outstanding recalls, leading to an even larger number of recalled cars being sold on the private market with only minimal disclosure. However, there are important distinctions between the used car market and the rental car market.
Opponents have argued that the major rental car companies have already adopted voluntary policies to hold and repair rental cars under recall. Moreover, the federal legislation proposed by CARS (S.2819 by Senator Boxer) would generally require rental car companies to such requirements, and CARS contends that those rental car companies support that legislation. If that is true, the Committee may wish to consider an amendment to delete the provision authorizing rental car companies to rent recalled cars with notice and consent, and instead hold them to standards similar to those currently contained in S.2819.
On page 26, strike out lines 12 through 25, and add the following:
"rent as soon as practicable but no later than 48 hours after receiving notice of a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, the National Highway Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101, et seq.).
(b) If a notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily alter the vehicle that eliminate the safety risk posed by the recall, the rental car company, after causing the specified actions to be performed, may rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the rental vehicle becomes available to the rental car company, the rental car company may not rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired."
In that same vein, if rental cars should be held to the higher standard, so should the loaner and rental replacement vehicles provided to consumers during recall repairs to be themselves under recall at the same time.
On page 27, line 16, after the word "made." add "The consumer shall not be provided with a rental or loaner vehicle, as prescribed in this paragraph, subject to a Stop Sale – Stop Drive recall or manufacturer’s recall."
Finally, the possibility that a 'notice and consent' regime for the sale or rental of used cars could potentially erode consumers' protection under existing law and their remedies in the event of an accident should be taken seriously. One option suggested by CAOC would be to limit the legal effect of the disclosure and acknowledgment. The following amendments would be one means to explicitly limit the admissibility of the disclosure and acknowledgment, while clarifying that the disclosure and acknowledgement do not reduce or otherwise negatively affect a consumer's existing rights or remedies under law:
On page 26, line 10, after the word "agreement." Add "(f) Transmission by dealers and receipt and signing by consumers of the disclosures specified in subdivisions (d) and (e) shall have no legal effect other than to demonstrate compliance by the dealer with the requirements prescribed in subdivisions (d) and (e). Nothing in this article shall be interpreted to place consumers in a less advantageous legal position for having received or signed the disclosures provided pursuant to this chapter than if no disclosure had been made."
On page 28, line 2, after the word "11758." add "Nothing in this chapter shall affect any legal rights, claims, or remedies otherwise available under law."
Related legislation. AB 1178 (Achadjian) would recast the provisions relating to export and sale-for-resale prohibitions to prohibit taking or threaten to take any adverse action against a dealer because the dealer sold or leased a vehicle to a customer who either exported the vehicle to a foreign country or resold the vehicle in violation of the prohibition if the dealer causes the vehicle to be registered in this or any other state, and collects or causes to be collected any applicable sales or use tax due to this state. AB 1178 is currently pending in the Assembly Transportation Committee.
Previous legislation. SB 686 (Jackson) of 2014 would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling a used vehicle if the dealer knew or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall and failed to correct the defect. SB 686 failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
SB 155 (Padilla) Chapter 512, Statutes of 2013, modified the
relationship between motor vehicle dealers and manufacturers by,
among other things, making changes regarding the use of flat-rate
time schedules for warranty reimbursement, warranty and incentive
claims, audits, protest rights, export policies, performance
standards, and facility improvements.
AB 964 (Bonta) of
2013 would have prohibited a vehicle from being advertised or sold if
the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle is subject to
a manufacturer's safety recall, and would have required written
disclosure of specified problems with the vehicle. AB 964 was held
on the inactive file on the Assembly Floor.
SB 990
(Vargas) of 2012 would have allowed a car dealer selling a used car
to obtain data from a commercial entity, rather than the federal
government, to provide required information to consumers on the
vehicle’s title history. SB 990 failed passage in the Senate
Transportation and Housing Committee.
AB 753 (Monning) of
2011 would have expressly prohibited a rental car company from
renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall notice unless the
vehicle has been repaired as specified in the notice. AB 753 failed
passage in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1215 (Blumenfield), Chapter 329, Statutes of 2011, required new
car dealers to participate in a program to electronically title and
register vehicles that they sell and to post specified warning
notices on some used cars.
AB 68 (Montañez), Chapter 128,
Statutes of 2005, enacted the Car Buyer's Bill of Rights, which
provided that a car dealer may not advertise of sell as "certified"
a used or pre-owned motor vehicle unless specified conditions are
satisfied, and further provided that vehicles sold as "certified"
may not be sold "as is," or if the dealer has disclaimed
any warranties.
SB 114 (Bowen) of 2005 would have enhanced
the process by which attempts are made to notify an owner of a motor
vehicle of a required safety-related vehicle recall. SB 114 was held
on the suspense file in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Double referral. This bill was double- referred to the Assembly Transportation Committee where it was heard on April 13, 2015, and passed out on a 16-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California New Car Dealers Association
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
Opposition
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
Association of Global Automakers
California Conference of Machinists
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
CALPIRG
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Watchdog
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Consumers Union
Courage Campaign
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates (HERA)
International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, District Lodge 190
National Association of Consumer Advocates
The Sturdevant Law Firm
The Trauma Foundation
Analysis Prepared by: Hank Dempsey / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
AB 287
Page 6
Date of Hearing: April 13, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION
Jim Frazier, Chair
AB 287
(Gordon) – As Amended March 23, 2015
SUBJECT: Vehicle safety: recalls
SUMMARY: Establishes the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (Act) and prohibits a motor vehicle dealer or rental car company from displaying, selling, or renting a used or rental vehicle unless specific conditions are met. Further establishes additional requirements and procedures to the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) and vehicle manufacturers relative to implementation of the Act. Specifically, this bill:
Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the increasing number of vehicle recalls and the safety and economic impacts associated with vehicle recalls.
Requires the provisions specified in the Act to commence on or after July 1, 2016.
Establishes a claims and appeals process, as specified, between vehicle dealers and manufacturers regarding payment requirements and obligations identified in the Act.
Directs the DMV's New Motor Vehicle Board (Board) to hear and decide on disputes between vehicle dealers and manufacturers related to the Act's payment requirements and obligations.
Prohibits DMV from accepting the initial, renewal, or transfer of a vehicle registration if the applicant fails to provide DMV with a recall disclosure statement as specified in the Act.
Proclaims that it is unlawful and a misdemeanor violation for a manufacturer, as specified, to unfairly discriminate against a dealer based on certain provisions specified in the Act.
Provides clarifying definitions for a variety of terms relative to how they are applied in the Act.
Prohibits a dealer from displaying or offering for sale a used vehicle unless the dealer has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the display of offer.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall until the recall repair has been made.
Prohibits a dealer from selling or leasing a used vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall and the line make is the same as the dealer, until the recall repair has been made.
Allows a dealer to sell or lease a used vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified, if the vehicle is not the same line make as the dealer if the following conditions are satisfied:
The dealer provides the recall database report to the consumer disclosing the manufacturer's recall; and,
The consumer signs a disclosure agreement acknowledging the manufacturer's recall, as specified.
Specifies that a recall database report and the disclosure agreement provided and signed by the consumer are to be provided separate from the conditional sales contract or other vehicle purchase agreement.
Prohibits a rental car company from renting a vehicle unless the company has obtained a recall database report within 30 days of the offer.
Prohibits a rental car company from renting a vehicle if the recall database report indicates the vehicle is subject to a "Stop Sale-Stop Drive" recall until the recall repair has been made.
Allows a rental car company to rent a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified, if the following conditions are satisfied:
The rental car company discloses the recall database report to the consumer disclosing the manufacturer's recall prior to rental; and,
The consumer signs a disclosure agreement acknowledging the manufacturer's recall, as specified.
Requires the seller of a motor vehicle, including private party sales, to disclose all recalls related to the vehicle being sold and requires the buyer to provide the an acknowledgement form to DMV indicating they have received all recall information in order to transfer vehicle registration, as specified.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to provide all recall notifications on its website, as specified, and whether a vehicle is subject to a Stop Sale-Stop Drive recall.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to provide a consumer, upon request, a rental or loaner vehicle when the consumer's vehicle is subject to a recall and the parts and/or procedures are not available, as specified.
Requires a vehicle manufacturer to compensate a dealer for costs associated with providing a rental or loaner vehicle and the storage of a recalled vehicle waiting to be repaired, as specified.
Provides that a dealer, rental car company, or private seller is not legally responsible for any errors or inaccuracies contained in the recall database report, as specified. Further identifies several vehicles not subject to provisions of the Act, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires DMV to oversee motor vehicle registrations.
Prohibits any person from acting as a dealer, remanufacturer, manufacturer, or transporter, as specified, without having first been issued a license or temporary permit from DMV, as specified.
Requires new car dealers to enroll in the DMV-administered Business Automation Program and electronically transfer vehicle registration and titling transactions to DMV, as specified.
Establishes the New Motor Vehicle Board within DMV and requires the Board to hear and decide on certain appeals and protests presented by a motor vehicle franchisee pertaining to a dispute with a vehicle manufacturer.
Prescribes specific instances when DMV may refuse the initial registration, renewal, or transfer of registration for a vehicle, as specified.
Prohibits a vehicle manufacturer, manufacturer branch, distributor, and distributor branch, as defined, from engaging in specific practices and makes a violation of these prohibitions a misdemeanor.
Sets forth in federal regulations the requirements for when manufacturers must notify vehicle owners, dealers, and distributors about a defect that relates to motor vehicle safety or noncompliance with a federal motor vehicle safety standard.
At the federal level, prohibits a motor vehicle dealer from selling a new vehicle subject to a recall, as specified, unless and until the defect is repaired. Federal law does not afford similar prohibitions to used vehicles.
At the federal level, establishes the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (MAP-21), and requires the Secretary of the United States Department of Transportation (U.S. DOT) to promulgate regulations by July 6, 2013, requiring motor vehicle safety recall information to be publicly available online and searchable by vehicle make, model, and vehicle identification number (VIN).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: In 2014, more than 60 million motor vehicles were subject to recalls totaling more than the prior three years combined. In total, 803 recalls were announced with 123 resulting from investigations from the Nation Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the remaining 680 recalls initiated by auto manufacturers. These recalls encompassed a wide variety of vehicle defects; however, two of the more notable recalls involved faulty ignitions in General Motor vehicles and defects in Takata airbags used in a variety of vehicle models.
The federal government's ability to set and administer vehicle safety standards was established in 1966 under the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (NTMVSA). Specifically, NTMVSA created NHTSA and granted the agency the authority to investigate and require auto manufacturers to recall vehicles that have safety-related defects or do not meet federal safety standards. Generally, a safety-related defect is determined when a defect poses a risk to motor vehicle safety and exists in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture.
Under a NHTSA-initiated safety recall, the agency may have received enough complaints and information about the operation of a vehicle that it finds there is a significant threat to public safety and initiates a mandatory recall. NHTSA may perform an investigation with a review by engineers and experts and work with the vehicle manufacturer to recall vehicles. These safety recalls are facilitated through direct relationships between manufacturers, franchised dealerships, and owners who purchased the new vehicles. Manufacturers may dispute a mandatory recall by petitioning NHTSA or bringing suit in court.
Conversely, auto manufacturers also have the ability to voluntary initiate both safety and non-safety recalls. Auto manufacturers carry out their own vehicle testing and inspection procedures and run information gathering systems to evaluate vehicle performance. If a safety defect is discovered, the manufacturer must notify NHTSA, as well as vehicle or equipment owners, dealers, and distributors. The manufacturer is then required to remedy the problem at no charge to the owner (for vehicles sold up to 10 years before the recall). NHTSA is responsible for monitoring the manufacturer’s corrective action to ensure successful completion of the recall campaign. Additionally, a manufacturer may administer a non-safety recall such as a recalling a vehicle for defective air conditioners or radios. The process is similar to safety recalls in that the manufacturer notifies the appropriate parties, the defect is repaired at no cost to the owner, and the manufacturer provides information of the recall on its website.
Aside from the recall notification processes described above, vehicle owners and consumers also have the opportunity to research vehicles through various recall databases. In 2012, Congress enacted MAP-21, a funding and authorization bill to govern federal transportation spending that contains a provision requiring motor vehicle safety recall information about outstanding recalls to be posted online in a format that preserves consumer privacy and is searchable by vehicle make, model, and VIN. In August of 2013, NHTSA issued a final rule that will require all major manufacturers (those who produce more than 25,000 vehicles per year) to provide the public with online access to recall information searchable by a VIN and without requiring additional information to allow consumers to instantly determine whether action is required to address an uncompleted safety recall. The online database, www.safercar.gov, is required to be updated with vehicle recall information on a weekly basis. Additional online recall research tools include an auto manufacturer's website or obtaining a vehicle history report through a variety of providers.
This bill aims to establish a process that will prohibit the sale of motor vehicles for the most serious safety-related recalls, provide consumers with motor vehicle recall information under certain circumstances, and when recall parts are not available, provide motor vehicle owners the option of leaving their vehicle at the dealership and using a rental vehicle. Respectively, this bill also includes provisions that would expand the Board's oversight obligations and prohibits DMV from approving motor vehicle registration if specific recall information is not provided under certain circumstances.
Created in 1967 as the New Car Dealers Policy and Appeals Board, the Board's initial functions were limited to hearing appeals that arose from final decisions made by the DMV. In 1973, the Legislature passed the California Automobile Franchise Act, which gave the Board its present name and tasked it with regulating and settling disputes in the new motor vehicle industry. The Board's current mission is to enhance relations between dealers and manufactures of automobiles, RV's, and motorcycles by resolving disputes in the industry in an efficient, fair, and cost-effective manner. Under this bill, the Board would additionally be authorized to hear and decide on storage and vehicle rental reimbursement claims between dealers and manufacturers, which is consistent with the Board's existing practices.
Furthermore, the bill requires DMV to refuse the transfer of motor vehicle registration if the applicant transferring the registration fails to include, with all other required documentation, a signed statement acknowledging all motor vehicle recall information was disclosed to the applicant prior to acquiring the motor vehicle. Should this bill pass, several implementation provisions will need to be further clarified in the next policy committee.
Writing in support of this bill, the California New Car Dealers Association notes, "California already has the strongest consumer protection laws in the country for car buyers, but neither California nor federal law address the sale, lease, or rental of a recalled used vehicle. The CARS Act would comprehensively enhance California's existing consumer protections by ensuring the most pressing safety issues are fixed in a timely manner, improving the information made available to consumers about cars subject to recall and providing consumers with access to loaner vehicles at no cost if their vehicle is subject to recall and parts are not available to repair the vehicle."
In opposition, Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety writes, "AB 287 would weaken existing consumer protection against unscrupulous car dealers who sell unsafe, recalled used cars to consumers; undermine progress being made at the federal level in addressing rental car and used car safety; create even more confusion among owners of recalled cars regarding the seriousness of lethal safety defects; and set a harmful precedent for allowing retailers to foist unsafe products onto consumers." Additionally, "allowing for dealers to sell unsafe, recalled cars to consumers with ‘disclosure,’ AB 287 fails to recognize the broader public interest in ensuring that cars are safe to operate on public roads. Even if a consumer happens to see the recall notice prior to completing the sale, reads it, fully understands the risks involved, and decides to drive the car anyway, there is a strong public interest in protecting the safety of their passengers, others who share the roads, pedestrians, bicyclists, and potentially many other individuals."
Previous legislation: SB 686 (Jackson) of 2014, would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling a used vehicle if the dealer knew or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall and failed to correct the defect. SB 686 failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 753 (Monning) of
2011, would have prohibited rental car companies from renting a
vehicle that is subject to a federal safety recall unless specific
conditions are met. AB 753 would have also prohibited a rental car
company from selling a vehicle subject to a federal safety recall.
AB 753 was referred to the Senate Appropriations Committee
but was not heard at the request of the author.
Double referral: This bill will be referred to the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee should it pass out of this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California New Car Dealers Association (Sponsor)
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California
Opposition
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
CALPIRG
California Conference of Machinists
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Consumers Union
Consumer Watchdog
Courage Campaign
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers
The Sturdevant Law Firm
The Trauma Foundation
Analysis Prepared by: Manny Leon / TRANS. / (916) 319-2093
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):