AB 2803: Public nuisance: residential lead-based paint.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-04-23
Existing law establishes an action for a public nuisance, which affects an entire community or neighborhood, or a considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal. Existing law authorizes a private party or a public body to bring an action to abate a public nuisance.
This bill would provide that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons constitutes a public nuisance. Under the bill, a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if that party promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable, as specified. The bill would provide that, in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint, causation may be established without presenting evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence, as specified.
The bill would provide legislative findings and declarations in support of these provisions.
Existing law, the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substance Account Act, imposes liability for hazardous substances removal or remedial actions and requires the Attorney General to recover from the liable person, as defined, certain costs incurred by the Department of Toxic Substances Control or a California regional water quality control board, upon the request of the department or regional board. The act authorizes a party found liable for any costs or expenditures recoverable under the act for those actions to establish, as specified, that only a portion of those costs or expenditures are attributable to the party, and requires the party to pay only for that portion. If each party does not establish its liability, the act requires a court to apportion those costs or expenditures, as specified, among the defendants, and the remaining portion of the judgment is required to be paid from the Toxic Substances Control Account. Existing law authorizes the money deposited in the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to be appropriated to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for specified purposes, including the payment of the costs incurred by the state for those actions.This bill would define hazardous substance for purposes of the act to include lead-based paint that is bioavailable. The bill would, for a residential property contaminated with lead-based paint that is bioavailable, exclude from the definition of responsible party or liable person owners and former owners of the property for purposes of the act.Existing law, the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substance Account Act, imposes liability for hazardous substances removal or remedial actions and requires the Attorney General to recover from the liable person, as defined, certain costs incurred by the Department of Toxic Substances Control or a California regional water quality control board, upon the request of the department or regional board. The act authorizes a party found liable for any costs or expenditures recoverable under the act for those actions to establish, as specified, that only a portion of those costs or expenditures are attributable to the party, and requires the party to pay only for that portion. If each party does not establish its liability, the act requires a court to apportion those costs or expenditures, as specified, among the defendants, and the remaining portion of the judgment is required to be paid from the Toxic Substances Control Account. Existing law authorizes the money deposited in the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to be appropriated to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for specified purposes, including the payment of the costs incurred by the state for those actions.
This bill would define hazardous substance for purposes of the act to include lead-based paint that is bioavailable. The bill would, for a residential property contaminated with lead-based paint that is bioavailable, exclude from the definition of responsible party or liable person owners and former owners of the property for purposes of the act.
Existing law provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the public has a right to know about acutely hazardous materials accident risks that may affect their health and safety, as provided, and a right to participate in decisions about risk reduction options and measures to be taken to reduce the risk or severity of acutely hazardous materials accidents.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those findings and declarations.Existing law provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the public has a right to know about acutely hazardous materials accident risks that may affect their health and safety, as provided, and a right to participate in decisions about risk reduction options and measures to be taken to reduce the risk or severity of acutely hazardous materials accidents.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those findings and declarations.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)Lead is highly toxic.
(b)At high levels of exposure, lead causes seizures, comas, brain swelling, and death.
(c)At low levels of exposure, lead causes decreased IQ, difficulty with problem solving, memory impairment, attention-related disorders, and antisocial behavior.
(d)Exposure to lead causes serious health harms that are irreversible and cumulative. As the American Academy of Pediatrics explained in 2016, [n]o treatments have been shown to be effective in ameliorating the permanent developmental effects of lead toxicity.
(e)Young children are especially susceptible to lead exposure due to their smaller sizes, the vulnerability of their developing nervous systems, and their high rates of lead absorption.
(f)Government agencies and health organizations, including the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the World Health Organization, and the American Academy of Pediatrics, agree that there is no safe level of lead exposure.
(g)Once applied to the surface of a building or residence, lead-based paint becomes a permanent feature of that building or residence until and unless that paint has been abated.
(h)Deteriorating lead-based paint on the surfaces of a building or residence, especially high-friction surfaces like windows and doors, poses a serious health hazard to any young child who enters or lives in that building or residence.
(i)Studies indicate that lead-based paint is the source of approximately 70 percent of childhood exposure to lead.
(j)Virtually all government agencies, scientists, and public health officials agree that lead-based paint on residential surfaces is the predominant source of lead exposure in young children.
(k)Millions of residences in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to contain lead-based paint.
(l)Each year, the State of California identifies tens of thousands of young children in California whose health has been irreversibly harmed due to lead exposure. These children represent the minimum number of children in California whose health has been irreversibly harmed due to lead exposure.
(m)The economic costs of childhood lead exposure are substantial. These costs include: (1) health care costs associated with health problems caused by lead exposure, (2) special education costs incurred due to slower development, lower educational success, and behavioral problems caused by lead exposure, (3) loss of tax revenue due to decreased lifetime earnings resulting from decreased intelligence caused by lead exposure, and (4) costs of criminal activity connected to lead exposure. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, the estimated annual cost of childhood lead exposure in the United States is $50 billion.
(n)The substantial economic costs of childhood lead exposure fall disproportionately on the state and local governments in California. Because young children who suffer from lead exposure are often poor, their health care and special education costs are typically borne by the state and local governments. Likewise, many of the economic costs of criminal behavior closely connected to lead exposure are shouldered by the state and local governments. Finally, the costs to the state and local governments in California from childhood lead exposure are exacerbated by the loss of tax revenues due to loss of income associated with childhood lead exposure.
(o)As the American Academy of Pediatrics explained in 2016, the only way to prevent the serious and irreversible health harms associated with childhood lead exposure caused by lead-based paint is to abate that paint before a young child is exposed to it.
(p)As the American Academy of Pediatrics explained in 2016, [f]or every $1 dollar invested to reduce lead hazards in housing units, society would benefit by an estimated $17 to $221, a cost-benefit ratio that is comparable to the cost-benefit ratio for childhood vaccines.
(q)In 2006, a California appellate court found that lead-based paint in residences may constitute a public nuisance and that lead pigment paint manufacturers may be held liable for public nuisance if they promoted lead-based paint for residential use with sufficient knowledge of the health hazards that would result to render their promotions unreasonable (County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292).
(r)Based on extensive evidence presented at trial, a California judge in 2010 found that certain lead pigment paint manufacturers caused lead-based paint to be applied on certain residential surfaces by promoting that paint for use on those surfaces even though they knew about the serious health harms to children that would result (County of Santa Clara v. Superior Court (2010) 50 Cal.4th 35).
(s)A California appellate court in 2017 unanimously affirmed that finding by the judge (People v. Conagra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51).
(t)Certain lead pigment paint manufacturers now contend that these court decisions misstate Californias public nuisance law as applied to lead-based paint in residences in California.
(u)This act clarifies existing public nuisance law as applied to lead-based paint.
SEC. 2.Section 3497 is added to the Civil Code, to read:3497.(a)Residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right.
(b)A party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
(c)To prove causation in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence. Causation may be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
SEC. 3.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SECTION 1.Section 25316 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25316.Hazardous substance means:(a)A substance designated pursuant to Section 1321 (b)(2)(A) of Title 33 of the United States Code.(b)An element, compound, mixture, solution, or substance designated pursuant to Section 102 of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 9602).(c)A hazardous waste having the characteristics identified under or listed pursuant to Section 6921 of Title 42 of the United States Code, but not including any waste the regulation of which under the Solid Waste Disposal Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 6901 et seq.) has been suspended by act of Congress.(d)A toxic pollutant listed under Section 1317 (a) of Title 33 of the United States Code.(e)A hazardous air pollutant listed under Section 7412 of Title 42 of the United States Code.(f)An imminently hazardous chemical substance or mixture with respect to which the Administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency has taken action pursuant to Section 2606 of Title 15 of the United States Code.(g)A hazardous waste or extremely hazardous waste as defined by Sections 25117 and 25115, respectively, unless expressly excluded.(h)Lead-based paint that is bioavailable.SEC. 2.Section 25323.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25323.5.(a)(1)Responsible party or liable person, for the purposes of this chapter, means those persons described in Section 107(a) of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 9607(a)).(2)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), but except as provided in subparagraph (B), a person is not a responsible party or liable person, for purposes of this chapter, for the reason that the person has developed or implemented innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology with regard to a release site, if the use of the technology has been approved by the department for the release site and the person would not otherwise be a responsible party or liable person. Upon approval of the use of the technology, the director shall acknowledge, in writing, that, upon proper completion of the innovative investigative or innovative remedial action at the release site, the immunity provided by this subparagraph shall apply to the person.(B)Subparagraph (A) does not apply in any of the following cases:(i)Conditions at the release site have deteriorated as a result of the negligence of the person who developed or implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology.(ii)The person who developed or implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology withheld or misrepresented information that was relevant to the potential risks or harms of the technology.(iii)The person who implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology did not follow the implementation process approved by the department.(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), for a residential property contaminated with lead-based paint that is bioavailable, a person who owned or owns the property is not a responsible party or liable person for purposes of this chapter.(b)For the purposes of this chapter, the defenses available to a responsible party or liable person shall be those defenses specified in Sections 101(35) and 107(b) of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Secs. 9601(35) and 9607(b)).(c)Any person who unknowingly transports hazardous waste to a solid waste facility pursuant to the exemption provided in subdivision (e) of Section 25163 shall not be considered a responsible party for purposes of this chapter solely because of the act of transporting the waste. This subdivision does not affect the liability of this person for his or her negligent acts. REVISIONS: HeadingLine 3.Hazardous substance means:
(a)Any A substance designated pursuant to Section 1321 (b)(2)(A) of Title 33 of the United States Code.
(b)Any An element, compound, mixture, solution, or substance designated pursuant to Section 102 of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 9602).
(c)Any A hazardous waste having the characteristics identified under or listed pursuant to Section 6921 of Title 42 of the United States Code, but not including any waste the regulation of which under the Solid Waste Disposal Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 6901 et seq.) has been suspended by act of Congress.
(d)Any A toxic pollutant listed under Section 1317 (a) of Title 33 of the United States Code.
(e)Any A hazardous air pollutant listed under Section 7412 of Title 42 of the United States Code.
(f)Any An imminently hazardous chemical substance or mixture with respect to which the Administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency has taken action pursuant to Section 2606 of Title 15 of the United States Code.
(g)Any A hazardous waste or extremely hazardous waste as defined by Sections 25117 and 25115, respectively, unless expressly excluded.
(h)Lead-based paint that is bioavailable.
SEC. 2.Section 25323.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25323.5.(a)(1)Responsible party or liable person, for the purposes of this chapter, means those persons described in Section 107(a) of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 9607(a)).
(2)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), but except as provided in subparagraph (B), a person is not a responsible party or liable person, for purposes of this chapter, for the reason that the person has developed or implemented innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology with regard to a release site, if the use of the technology has been approved by the department for the release site and the person would not otherwise be a responsible party or liable person. Upon approval of the use of the technology, the director shall acknowledge, in writing, that, upon proper completion of the innovative investigative or innovative remedial action at the release site, the immunity provided by this subparagraph shall apply to the person.
(B)Subparagraph (A) does not apply in any of the following cases:
(i)Conditions at the release site have deteriorated as a result of the negligence of the person who developed or implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology.
(ii)The person who developed or implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology withheld or misrepresented information that was relevant to the potential risks or harms of the technology.
(iii)The person who implemented the innovative investigative or innovative remedial technology did not follow the implementation process approved by the department.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), for a residential property contaminated with lead-based paint that is bioavailable, a person who owned or owns the property is not a responsible party or liable person for purposes of this chapter.
(b)For the purposes of this chapter, the defenses available to a responsible party or liable person shall be those defenses specified in Sections 101(35) and 107(b) of the federal act (42 U.S.C. Secs. 9601(35) and 9607(b)).
(c)Any person who unknowingly transports hazardous waste to a solid waste facility pursuant to the exemption provided in subdivision (e) of Section 25163 shall not be considered a responsible party for purposes of this chapter solely because of the act of transporting the waste. Nothing in this subdivision shall This subdivision does not affect the liability of this person for his or her negligent acts.
SECTION 1.Section 25531.1 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25531.1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the public has a right to know about acutely hazardous materials accident risks that may affect their health and safety, and that this right includes full and timely access to hazard assessment information, including offsite consequence analysis for the most likely hazards, that identifies the offsite area that may be required to take protective action in the event of an acutely hazardous materials release.(b)The Legislature further finds and declares that the public has a right to participate in decisions about risk reduction options and measures to be taken to reduce the risk or severity of acutely hazardous materials accidents. REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the public has a right to know about acutely hazardous materials accident risks that may affect their health and safety, and that this right includes full and timely access to hazard assessment information, including offsite consequence analysis for the most likely hazards, which hazards, that identifies the offsite area which that may be required to take protective action in the event of an acutely hazardous materials release.
The(b)The Legislature further finds and declares that the public has a right to participate in decisions about risk reduction options and measures to be taken to reduce the risk or severity of acutely hazardous materials accidents.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on EQ. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (June 12). Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| May 30, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on JUD., EQ. and APPR. |
| May 22, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 2, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2018 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 24, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 23, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 19, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 11, 2018 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 23, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 20, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2018 | AB 2803 LIMÓN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 2803
Author: | Limón | ||
Version: | 4/23/2018 | Hearing Date: | 6/20/2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: Public nuisance: residential lead-based paint
ANALYSIS:
Existing law: Establishes an action for a public nuisance, which affects an entire community or neighborhood, or a considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal. Existing law authorizes a private party or a public body to bring an action to abate a public nuisance.
This bill: provides that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right. It would further provide that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable. This bill would also allow a plaintiff in an abatement action involving residential lead-based paint to establish causation without presenting evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence. Rather, this bill would allow causation to be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
Background
Lead is a well-known toxin: Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that is known to the State of California to cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been listed as a chemical known to cause cancer since 1992. According to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, lead has multiple toxic effects on the human body. Decreased intelligence in children and increased blood pressure in adults are among the more serious non-carcinogenic effects. There is no level of lead that has been proven safe for children or for adults.
Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
Lead-based paint history: Lead-based paint was shipped in Colonial days to what became the United States as a luxury good, and was later used to paint such important structures as the White House, the Capitol, and Mount Vernon.
When lead pigment was used in paints, currently reported risks to children were unknown and unknowable. Medical science has evolved, leading to concerns about childhood health that did not exist when lead-based paint originally was marketed.
Before 1940, paint manufacturers began to use non-lead pigments, such as lithopone, zinc oxide, and titanium dioxide, in many interior paints mixed at the factory. In fact, Sherwin-Williams introduced the first, successful lead-free water-based paint for interior use in 1941. Its easy use, clean-up, and quick drying launched a do-it-yourself paint market.
In 1948, the Baltimore Public Health Department observed an increase in childhood lead poisoning in Baltimore, primarily among those who lived in its substantial number of rundown, neglected row houses amid massive amounts of peeling and flaking lead paint. That led health inspectors to investigate those houses and to learn that children were eating lead from peeling and chipping lead paint in that city’s inner-city housing, poorly maintained during and after World War II.
As soon as those new concerns were raised, the paint industry worked closely with public health officials to investigate the risk. The paint industry provided research funding, which helped guide the Baltimore Public Health Department to issue a ban in 1951 on the use of lead pigment in interior paint in Baltimore housing. That was the first restriction on the use of interior lead paint in the country.
When the same problem was found in the dilapidated housing in older cities in the Northeast and Midwest, the paint industry also worked with the American Academy of Pediatrics, along with other groups interested in child health issues. In 1955, a voluntary national standard was adopted to prohibit, in effect, the use of lead pigments in interior residential paints.
When lead-based paint was marketed before 1978, it was a legal product in great demand because it was washable and durable. It was repeatedly endorsed by the federal, state, and local governments, and specified for use on government buildings until the mid-1970s. For example, the 1950 California Department of Education vocational book on painting endorsed the use of white lead paint.
It was not until 1974 that a new theory emerged on the predominant pathway for children to be exposed to gratuitous levels of lead. In a paper by Dr. James W. Sayre, House and Hand Dust as a Potential Source of Childhood Lead Exposure, Dr. Sayre felt that the major source might be house dust, contaminated with lead from many sources. The theory was that children were licking their hands that had become dirty with lead-contaminated dust. His theory brought about a move beyond the earlier recognition of a risk from chipping and peeling paint. He also observed that average blood lead levels of children living in low-risk areas of Rochester, New York, were in the range then of 18-25 µg/dL.
In 1978, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission banned consumer uses of lead-based paint. However, buildings built prior to the ban still likely have lead paint, as well as commercial, government, and industrial buildings and structures, which are permitted to use lead-based paint.
Lead-based paint, like all paint, inevitably deteriorates: it flakes, chips, and turns to dust and can contaminate the air, soil, floors and other surfaces in the home. This is particularly true of lead paint on windows, doors, and other friction surfaces.
Lead-based paint in California: According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint.
As a case in point, about 75% of Alameda County’s homes were built before 1980, which amounts to 430,000 units. Nearly 174,000 of those units are pre-1950. Lead-based paint hazards in Oakland homes are considered by local health officials to be "coming close to crisis mode." In Oakland, between 80% and 90% of the housing was built pre-1978, which accounts for about 174,000 units.
In Los Angeles County, 77% of the housing was built before 1978, which is more than 2.6 million housing units. More than 900,000 of those housing units are pre-1950. In at least 75% of Los Angeles County's lead poisoning cases, lead-based paint is a potential source of lead poisoning. At least 70% of those cases involve individuals living in pre-1978 housing.
Lead-paint cleanup costs: Lead-based paint removal costs an estimated $8-$15 a square foot, which means removing all lead from a house of 1,200-2,000 square feet could run as much as $9,600-$30,000, according to RealtyTimes.com. The average removal project runs around $10,000 for a typical pre-1978 home.
The following chart provides an estimate of the number of pre-1978 housing units in ten jurisdictions around the state. The estimated costs for cleanup in these jurisdictions alone are $400 million.
Judgment against paint industry: In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers to hold former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation: the County of Alameda, the City of Oakland, the City and County of San Francisco, the City of San Diego, the County of Los Angeles, the County of Monterey, the County of San Mateo, the County of Solano, and the County of Ventura.
After a six-week trial in 2013, the trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions by promoting lead paint for interior use, despite knowing the substantial harms that would result from the use of lead paint. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties. The three paint manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to inspect for and abate lead paint in all homes constructed through 1980. (The court did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance.)
Manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion to fund inspection for, and abatement of, lead paint and lead-contaminated dust from the interiors of homes and lead-contaminated soil around homes built in 1980 or earlier in the ten cities and counties; remediation of any structural deficiencies in the homes that would cause the lead control measures to fail; and, public education and outreach necessary for the program.
The ten cities and counties were designated to oversee the lead inspection and abatement program in their respective jurisdictions. Property owners’ participation would be entirely voluntary, and any funds unspent after four years would revert back to the manufacturers.
In 2017, the Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s determination that Manufacturers were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th at p. 51.). However, the Court of Appeal limited the judgment to homes built before 1951.
On February 14, 2018, the California Supreme Court denied requests by the manufacturers to review the appellate court decision requiring those three companies to pay several hundred million dollars to identify and clean up lead paint from millions of homes built before 1951 in Santa Clara County and nine other California cities and counties, meaning that People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. can be considered a precedent by California courts in any future litigation against lead paint manufacturers. The manufacturers plan to further appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court. In the meantime, however, the case is returning to the Superior Court in order for the trial court to do both of the following: (1) calculate the amount that manufacturers must pay for pre-1951 homes only, and (2) decide on a receiver to administer the fund and distribute the monies to the ten cities and counties.
Lead paint initiative: In response to the court's findings in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., the paint manufacturers are proposing the ballot measure titled "Eliminates Certain Liability for Lead-Paint Manufacturers. Authorizes Bonds to Fund Structural and Environmental Remediation Projects" for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint on California homeowners.
The measure would authorize the state to issue bonds to "Fund Structural and Environmental Remediation Projects"; authorize $2 billion in general obligation bonds to remediate homes for various hazards (mold, asbestos, pests, radon, and lead); declare that lead-based paint is not a "public nuisance;" and, retroactively nullify all cases pending or pending on appeal as of November 1, 2017.
According to the Legislative Analysist's Office, if the bonds were sold at an average interest rate of 5%, the cost to the state’s taxpayers would be $3.9 billion to pay off both principal ($2 billion) and interest ($1.9 billion).
This measure would vacate the aforementioned appellate court decision, upholding a trial court’s ruling that paint manufacturers are liable for cleaning up the lead paint crisis in California and instead create a taxpayer-funded bond for abatement.
What the court decision does not do, despite industry arguments to the contrary: As previously noted, the Court of Appeal's decision in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. upheld the lower court's determination that the paint companies were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties that brought the lawsuit, and ordered the paint companies to pay $1.15 billion to fund a large-scale inspection and abatement program for lead paint in those communities, as specified. In addition to understanding what the court decision stands for, it is just as important to understand what the decision does not stand for.
The decision does not "red tag" homes by making each and every home a public nuisance for which the homeowner is now individually liable. Since the launch of their campaign to place an initiative on the November ballot to overturn the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision, the paint companies have publically argued that the decision "'red tags' millions of California homes . . . by finding that pre-1981 homes with old lead paint are a public nuisance . . . putting the home investment of millions of California's working families at risk."
(www.notanuisance.com). Proponents, including the lead paint manufacturers found to be liable in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., contend that homeowners are now exposed to civil and criminal liability for not addressing the public nuisance that is their homes, following the court's decision. However, this alarming characterization is simply not supported by a close reading of the court's decision.
First, the court did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared to be a public nuisance as a result of the litigation. The court held that the collective presence of lead paint in the affected homes in the 10 cities and counties constituted a single public nuisance, for which the defendant companies Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries are responsible to remediate.
The court addressed this argument directly when it was raised by the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) in an amici brief supporting the paint companies' position. In responding to PLF's claims, the court specifically and authoritatively set forth what the judgment does and does not do, as follows:
PLF contends that the judgment improperly affects the rights of individual property owners without notice. It does not. (emphasis added.) The abatement plan ordered by the trial court is premised on voluntary participation by property owners. No property owners will be forced to participate, and therefore their rights will not be involuntarily impacted. . . PLF insists that the court’s abatement order has "declared a nuisance" on individual properties without notice to the property owners. Not so. (emphasis added.) The trial court ordered defendants to abate the public nuisance they had created, but it did not identify any specific properties. The abatement plan itself is designed to identify and remediate the individual properties upon which defendants’ public nuisance exists. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th, at p. 134.)
In short, the judgment cannot, as a matter of law, be used to establish criminal or civil liability on the part of any California homeowner. To the extent that any such liability, as described by the paint companies, exists for homeowners, it should be noted that California homeowners were subject to these same theoretical risks of liability for a public nuisance before the judgment, and that the judgment does not create any new theory of liability for homeowners, according to the court's own explanations. The only thing that changed as a result of the court's decision is that the defendant paint companies were found newly liable for the costs of abatement for the public nuisance which they were found to have caused.
2. The decision does not automatically threaten the property values of millions of California homeowners. The argument that the court decision burdened millions of homes in California with the designation of them being a "public nuisance" is being used by proponents of the initiative, including the three paint companies found to be liable for the cost of remediating the nuisance created by the lead paint they produced, to sound that alarm. As a result, the proponents claim that the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision is "putting the home investment of millions of California's working families at risk." This argument has apparently instantly resonated with many homeowners struggling to understand the legal complexities of the case, judging from the large number of email messages received by the Legislature that were generated through a website operated by the paint companies. However, this argument also is a mischaracterization of the appellate court decision.
Again, it should be emphasized that the Court of Appeal did not find in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance as a result of the litigation. Instead, the court held that the collective presence of lead paint in the affected homes in the 10 cities and counties constitute a single public nuisance. As a result, the presence of interior residential lead-based paint has existed as a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions that were party to the legal case against the paint manufacturers for some time now. Because these 10 jurisdictions contain approximately 47% of the state’s population, any effect on property values due to the court's decision would be relatively easy to detect in such a large proportion of the state. However, there has apparently been no evidence, empirical or otherwise, documenting any decrease in property values tied to the court’s finding.
It should also be noted that homebuyers and renters have long been required to be given notice that any dwelling constructed prior to January 1, 1978 is presumed to contain lead paint. According to the California Association of Realtors, any risk of sudden loss of value has been reflected in property values for years, and thus the court decision does not suddenly threaten current property values. According to a recent article in the Los Angeles Times:
"The rulings created a huge burden for homeowners," Klingler (a spokeswoman for the ballot initiative) said. "It labeled millions of homes public nuisances, which can cause a loss of property value."
Not so, countered the California Association of Realtors.
"We don't think that's the case at all," said June Barlow, the organization's general counsel. She said the state already requires disclosure of lead paint during home sales, so the risk has been reflected in property values for years. Barlow also said a close reading of November's court decision indicates that lead paint in general is being labeled a public nuisance, not the presence of lead paint in individual homes. (David Lazarus. "It's deceptively called the Healthy Homes and Schools Act, and it's a taxpayer ripoff." Los Angeles Times (March 30, 2018).)
By contrast, it seems that the People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc. decision will more likely reduce the risk of liability for California homeowners, particularly for those who could not otherwise afford to clean up their lead paint, by giving them a means to abate the lead paint in their homes and eliminate their future risk of liability. In other words, properties may rise in value if property owners can affirmatively prove that lead-based paints have been safely removed from their property, and access to abatement funds under the judgment make such removal far more likely.
3. Participation in the abatement program created by the court decision does not increase liability to individual homeowners or necessarily subject them to local nuisance enforcement. The paint companies have also argued, regarding People v. ConAgra Grocery Products, Inc., , that participating homeowners will have their addresses entered into a public database which then can be used by local jurisdictions to target individual properties for enforcement of nuisance law and to issue other fines and penalties.
It is true that the judgment requires the creation of a public database of properties that enroll in the abatement program, as well as a list of all properties that fail to enroll in the inspection and abatement program or subsequently fail to undergo lead hazard control. However, the court directly dispels the paint companies' arguments by reinforcing that participation in the program is voluntary, and that inclusion in this database should only help those homeowners, not hurt them. According to the appellate court:
While it is true that the abatement plan contemplates that the 10 jurisdictions will make publicly available a list of properties that have not been enrolled in the abatement plan, this provision alone does not substantially impact the rights of individual property owners. Already, any property built before 1978 is presumed to contain lead paint. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 17, § 35043.) That presumption eliminates any impact on a property owner from a publicly available list of only those presumptively lead-paint-containing properties that have not been enrolled in the abatement plan. Property owners can only gain from enrollment in the plan; they have nothing to lose. (People v. ConAgra, at 134.)
In conclusion, the court's decision in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. will reduce the risk of liability for California homeowners, particularly for those who could not otherwise afford to clean up their lead paint, by giving them a means to abate the lead paint in their homes and eliminate their future risk of liability.
Clarifications in the Law to Safeguard Participation in a Lead Paint Abatement Program. While the court decision definitively determined that the lead paint makers were responsible, it has been represented that one passage of the court's opinion suggests that lead paint companies could sue homeowners who participate in the abatement program for comparative fault. The court wrote, "[N]othing precludes a defendant from testing the lead paint at specific locations during the remediation process and seeking to hold a fellow defendant liable for a greater share of the responsibility. The same is true of evidence that the hazardous condition is ‘the owner’s fault’ or that it is not hazardous." (Ibid.)
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author: “AB 2803 would remove a significant hurdle to holding paint manufacturers accountable for the harm caused by their production of lead-based paint. Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child’s health. Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
In 2000, a complaint was filed and won on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers that found the former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic.
In spite of the court's findings, the three main paint manufacturers are proposing an initiative for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility on California homeowners for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint. If enacted, the initiative would cost taxpayers $3.9 Billion.
AB 2803 would only codify certain portions of the Court of Appeal’s decision in People of the State of California v. ConAgra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51 to make it easier for similar public nuisance cases to be brought in the future. It would also extend liability to parties that promoted lead-based paint for a particular use if those parties should have known that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2074 (Bonta, 2018) removes a significant hurdle to homeowners holding poison paint manufacturers legally accountable for injuries by establishing that lead paint companies are responsible to prove they did not produce, sell, distribute or promote the lead-based paint used during a particular time or area, and allowing homeowners to hold companies jointly liable if there were multiple companies selling or distributing paint at that time and area. Codifying this "risk contribution" theory in statute allows those poisoned by lead-based paint, who are unable to identify the exact manufacturer of the lead paint pigment, a new avenue to litigate cases they may not otherwise be able to litigate. This bill is on the Assembly Floor.
AB 2934 (Stone) would allow the California Department of Public Health to contract with counties to certify lead paint inspectors. This bill helps fill a shortage of inspectors to help bring homes up to safe standards. Additional qualified, lead paint inspectors will be needed as work proceeds to remove toxic paint from homes under the judgement. This bill is set to be heard in the Senate Environmental Quality on June 20, 2018.
AB 2995 (Carrillo) classifies the presence of lead-based paint in a home or building as a physical injury to the property, enabling property owners to sue for the cost of abating or removing lead paint to prevent the further deterioration of peoples’ health. Secondly, the bill delays the start of the clock on the statute of limitations to when property owners become aware that lead paint is present, rather than starting the clock at the time of purchase. This bill failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AB 3009 (Quirk) would enact a fee on paint manufacturers for all paint sold in California to create a fund for residents of single-family or multi-family dwellings to clean up lead paint that has contaminated their homes. This fee will only be imposed if an initiative passes that states that lead paint is not a public nuisance. This bill is on the Assembly Floor.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Bay Area Legal Aid
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California League of Conservation Voters
California State Association of Counties
City of Oakland
Clean Water Action
Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations, Inc.
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
County of Monterey Board of Supervisors
County of Santa Clara
OPPOSITION:
California Business Properties Association
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Cal Chamber
National Federation of Independent Business
West Coast Lumber &Building Material Association
Western Plant Health Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Supporters argue that “AB 2803 would provide that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right and is a public nuisance. A party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it is promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with knowledge that such use would cause health hazards.
AB 2803, by clarifying public nuisance law in California as applied to lead-based paint, will help ensure that residents will be able to hold accountable the companies that created the nuisance and remediate and abate the hazards caused by lead paint.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The opposition argues that AB 2803 will have horrifying impacts on California homeowners: turn 8 million homes in public nuisance, subject homeowners to potential liens, foreclosures, decreased property values, criminal sanctions and more, decrease state and local government revenue and reward slumlords and penalize law abiding homeowners.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2803 (Author:Limón)
Version: April 23, 2018
Hearing Date: June 12, 2018
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Public nuisance: residential lead-based paint
DESCRIPTION
This bill would provide that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right. It would further provide that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable. This bill would also allow a plaintiff in an abatement action involving residential lead-based paint to establish causation without presenting evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence. Rather, this bill would allow causation to be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
BACKGROUND
In People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51, 65-67, 78-79 (ConAgra), the People of the State of California (Plaintiff) brought suit against defendants ConAgra Grocery Products Company, NL Industries, Inc., and The Sherwin-Williams Company (collectively Defendants). Plaintiff alleged that presence of lead in residential buildings was a public nuisance and asserted that Defendants were liable “because they had created or assisted in the creation of this public nuisance.” Plaintiff sought abatement, injunctive relief, and costs and fees.
At trial, Plaintiff presented evidence of the following:
- lead is a toxin and causes irreversible brain damage;
- lead poisoning is the number one environmental health problem for children in California;
- children are more vulnerable to the toxic effects of lead because their biological systems are still developing;
- lead-based paint is the most common source of lead exposure to children in California;
- through the 1940s, lead paint contained as much as 50 percent lead. (Id. at 65-67.)
The trial court “expressly found that, ‘[s]ince antiquity, it has been well known that lead is highly toxic and causes severe health consequences when ingested’ and that ‘[e]ven relatively low levels of lead exposure have severe health consequences.’” (Id. at 79.) Focusing on the ten jurisdictions represented by Plaintiff, the trial court found that lead paint is prevalent there, inevitably deteriorates, and is the primary source of lead exposure for young children living in pre-1978 housing.” The trial court found children continued to be exposed to lead despite the 1978 ban on lead paint. The trial court further found that Defendants “each had ‘actual knowledge of the hazards of lead paint,’ ‘including childhood lead poisoning,’ when they promoted lead paint for interior residential use.”
Based on its findings, the trial court ordered Defendants to pay $1.15 billion into an abatement fund that would pay for lead inspections, education about lead hazards, and remediation of particular lead hazards inside residences in the 10 jurisdictions. (Id.) On appeal, the ConAgra court found that the judgment should only apply to pre-1951 homes, however, it otherwise upheld the ruling of the trial court. The case was remanded back to the trial court to appoint a receiver and to recalculate the proper amount of the abatement fund. The California Supreme Court denied a petition to review the judgment.
This bill would codify some of the holdings in ConAgra, specifically providing that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right, detailing the basis upon which parties can be held liable in abatement actions, and providing a basis for establishing causation in such actions.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, is a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479.)
Existing law provides that a public nuisance is one which affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal. (Civ. Code Sec. 3480.) All other nuisances are private. (Civ. Code Sec. 3481.)
Existing law provides that the abatement of a nuisance does not prejudice the right of any person to recover damages for its past existence. (Civ. Code Sec. 3484.) Furthermore, no lapse of time can legalize a public nuisance, amounting to an actual obstruction of public right. (Civ. Code Sec. 3490.)
Existing law provides that a private person may maintain an action for a public nuisance, if it is specially injurious to himself, but not otherwise. (Civ. Code Sec. 3493.) An action may be brought by any person whose property is injuriously affected, or whose personal enjoyment is lessened by a nuisance and by the judgment in that action the nuisance may be enjoined or abated as well as damages recovered therefor. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 731.)
Existing law provides that a civil action may also be brought in the name of the people of the State of California to abate a public nuisance by the district attorney or county counsel of any county in which the nuisance exists, or by the city attorney of any town or city in which the nuisance exists. Each of those officers shall have concurrent right to bring an action for a public nuisance existing within a town or city. The district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney of any county or city in which the nuisance exists shall bring an action whenever directed by the board of supervisors of the county, or whenever directed by the legislative authority of the town or city. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 731; Civ. Code Sec. 3494.)
Existing case law provides that a public nuisance cause of action is established by proof that a defendant knowingly created or assisted in the creation of a substantial and unreasonable interference with a public right. (County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292, 305-306.)
Existing law provides that the remedies against a public nuisance are an indictment or information, pursuant to the Penal Code, a civil action, or abatement. (Civ. Code Secs. 3491, 3492.) Any person may abate a public nuisance which is specially injurious to the person by removing, or, if necessary, destroying the thing which constitutes the same, without committing a breach of the peace, or doing unnecessary injury. (Civ. Code Sec. 3495.)
This bill would provide that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right.
This bill would provide that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
This bill would provide that, to prove causation in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence. Causation may be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
This bill would include a severability clause.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
AB 2803 would remove a significant hurdle to holding paint manufacturers accountable for the harm caused by their production of lead-based paint. Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child’s health. Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
In 2000, a complaint was filed and won on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers that found the former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic.
In spite of the court's findings, the three main paint manufacturers are proposing an initiative for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility on California homeowners for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint. If enacted, the initiative would cost taxpayers $3.9 Billion.
AB 2803 would only codify certain portions of the Court of Appeal’s decision in People of the State of California v. ConAgra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51 to make it easier for similar public nuisance cases to be brought in the future. It would also extend liability to parties that promoted lead-based paint for a particular use if those parties should have known that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
2. Residential lead-based paint interferes with a public right
A public nuisance is one which “affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal.” (Civ. Code Sec. 3480.) All other nuisances are private. (Civ. Code Sec. 3481.) In order to establish a public nuisance cause of action, it must be proven that a “defendant knowingly created or assisted in the creation of a substantial and unreasonable interference with a public right.” (County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292, 305-306.)
In ConAgra, the Defendants argued that residential lead-based paint does not interfere with any “public right” as needed to establish a public nuisance “because it causes only private harms in private residences.” (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51, 112.) The court rejected this contention:
Interior residential lead paint that is in a dangerous condition does not merely pose a risk of private harm in private residences. The community has a collective social interest in the safety of children in residential housing. Interior residential lead paint interferes with the community’s “public right” to housing that does not poison children. This interference seriously threatens to cause grave harm to the physical health of the community’s children. Defendants cite no California authority for their claim that no public right is threatened by interior residential lead paint, and we reject their reliance on Rhode Island and Illinois cases applying those states’ laws, which they seem to concede are not as broad as California’s.
Defendants argue that “[t]he ‘public’ has no right to be present inside a private home, and thus, any possible lead exposure inside a private home cannot occur in the exercise of any public right.” Most members of the “public” reside in residential housing, and we do not accept defendants’ claim that, unlike streets, residential housing is not a shared community resource. Residential housing, like water, electricity, natural gas, and sewer services, is an essential community resource. Indeed, without residential housing, it would be nearly impossible for the “public” to obtain access to water, electricity, gas, and sewer services. Pervasive lead exposure in residential housing threatens the public right to essential community resources. We reject defendants’ contention that interior residential lead paint cannot interfere with a public right.
(Id.)
This bill would provide that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right. This codifies the finding of the ConAgra court with some expansion. First, the court in ConAgra was focused on interior residential lead paint, specifically indicating that the “judgment requires remediation of soil lead only where the home itself contains interior lead paint.” This bill would apply to all residential lead-based paint, including that on the exterior of homes. Although interior lead-based paint is more problematic from a health perspective, such paint on the exterior of homes would always pose the possibility of danger from, for example, the weathering of paint on the exterior of a home from the elements, causing it to deteriorate and contaminate the soil surrounding the home.
In addition, as with the other elements, this provision would apply the holding in ConAgra to all homes in California, whereas the judgment in ConAgra only applies to homes in the 10 jurisdictions involved in the case. According to a report by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, about 60 percent of homes in California were constructed before 1978. Existing law provides that all buildings constructed before 1978 are presumed to contain lead-based paint unless testing reveals otherwise. (17 C.C.R. Sec. 35043.)
Many in opposition claim this bill would turn millions of homes into public nuisances individually. This misstates the effect of this bill. A public nuisance must affect “a considerable number of persons” or “an entire community or neighborhood” at the same time. This bill would not provide a basis to hold individual homeowners liable for public nuisance. In response to these claims, the author states:
Neither the ConAgra case nor AB 2803 declare any individual home with lead-based paint, on its own, to be a public nuisance. And neither the ConAgra case nor AB 2803 provide any basis for such a declaration. Instead, the ConAgra case held that the presence of lead-based paint in the interiors of pre-1951 homes across all ten cities and counties involved in that lawsuit, together, constituted a single public nuisance.
The court in ConAgra also responded to this argument:
Property owners can only gain from enrollment in the plan; they have nothing to lose. [The Pacific Legal Foundation] insists that the court’s abatement order has “declared a nuisance” on individual properties without notice to the property owners. Not so. The trial court ordered defendants to abate the public nuisance they had created, but it did not identify any specific properties. The abatement plan itself is designed to identify and remediate the individual properties upon which defendants’ public nuisance exists.
(ConAgra at 167, emphasis added.)
3. Establishing causation in an abatement action
The Defendants in ConAgra also contended that their promotions could not be found to have caused the presence of interior lead paint in the relevant homes “without proof that paint made by each of them is currently present in those homes.” (ConAgra at 108.)
The court ruled:
This contention misconstrues the basis for defendants’ liability. Defendants are liable for promoting lead paint for interior residential use. To the extent that this promotion caused lead paint to be used on residential interiors, the identity of the manufacturer of that lead paint is irrelevant. Indeed, the LIA’s promotions did not refer to any manufacturer of lead paint, but were generic. What matters is whether defendants’ promotions were a substantial factor in leading to the use of lead paint on residential interiors. Substantial evidence supports the court’s causation finding on that basis.
(Id.)
This bill would provide that to prove causation in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence. Causation may be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
Therefore, a direct causal link between a specific party and a particular home is unnecessary to establish the requisite element of causation for a public nuisance abatement action. This codifies the basis of the court’s opinion in ConAgra on the issue of causation. Causation in such cases, where a significant period of time has lapsed, is extremely difficult, hence justifying the alternative theories of liability allowed for by this bill. In any event, this bill would only allow for these alternative theories to apply in actions seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint, not any other cause of action. In addition, this would only apply to the element of causation. A plaintiff would still need to establish the other elements of an abatement claim.
4. Actual Knowledge
This bill would also provide that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable. As indicated by the author, although this generally tracks with the holding in ConAgra, it allows for a finding of liability based solely on constructive knowledge, something specifically addressed by the court:
Constructive knowledge would not be sufficient to support plaintiff’s public nuisance cause of action. The standard set by this court in [County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292, 309-310] is actual knowledge, not constructive knowledge. “[L]iability is premised on defendants’ promotion of lead paint for interior use with knowledge of the hazard that such use would create. This conduct is distinct from and far more egregious than simply producing a defective product or failing to warn of a defective product . . . . [¶] . . . A public nuisance cause of action is not premised on a defect in a product or a failure to warn but on affirmative conduct that assisted in the creation of a hazardous condition. Here, the alleged basis for defendants’ liability for the public nuisance created by lead paint is their affirmative promotion of lead paint for interior use, not their mere manufacture and distribution of lead paint or their failure to warn of its hazards.” (Santa Clara I, supra, 137 Cal.App.4th 292, 309–310, boldface & some italics added.) By tethering the public nuisance cause of action to affirmative promotion for a use defendants knew to be hazardous, this court necessarily set forth an actual knowledge standard. If the standard had been only constructive knowledge, the affirmative promotion of a product for a particular use that was hazardous would not have been “far more egregious” than simply failing to warn of a defective product.
(ConAgra at 83-84.) The court went on to address the difference between the two standards: “This distinction between what a defendant must have known and what a defendant should have known is crucial. Proof of actual knowledge focuses on what information a defendant must have been aware of, while proof of constructive knowledge rests on a defendant’s duty to discover information.” (Id. at 84-85.)
This bill would allow for a finding of liability for public nuisance based on constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards. Clearly this provision would go beyond the holding in ConAgra. However, in the general tort arena, constructive knowledge is generally deemed sufficient.
Although the ConAgra court required the higher standard, the constructive knowledge standard is consistent with general tort law principles. Constructive knowledge means “knowledge that one using reasonable care or diligence should have, and therefore is attributed by law to a given person,” and it “encompasses a variety of mental states, ranging from one who is deliberately indifferent in the face of an unjustifiably high risk of harm to one who merely should know of a dangerous condition.” (John B. v. Superior Court (2006) 38 Cal.4th 1177, 1190-1191, internal quotations and citations omitted.) The California Supreme Court has reiterated that constructive knowledge generally suffices in claims based on negligence:
Indeed, the “very concept of negligence presupposes that the actor either does foresee an unreasonable risk of injury, or could foresee it if he conducted himself as a reasonably prudent person.” (3 Harper et al., The Law of Torts (2d ed. 1986) § 16.5, p. 397; accord, Prosser & Keeton on Torts (5th ed. 1984) § 32, pp. 182–185; Rest.2d Torts, §§ 289, 290; Nolte, The Spoliation Tort: An Approach to Underlying Principles (1994) 26 St. Mary’s L.J. 351, 380 [“negligence law regularly utilizes the concept of constructive knowledge as the requisite notice”].) Because “‘[a]ll persons are required to use ordinary care to prevent others being injured as a result of their conduct’” (Rowland v. Christian [(1968) 69 Cal.2d 108, 112]), this court has repeatedly recognized a cause of action for negligence not only against those who have actual knowledge of unreasonable danger, but also against those who have constructive knowledge of it. (See, e.g., Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200, 1210; Toland v. Sunland Housing Group, Inc. (1998) 18 Cal.4th 253, 260, fn. 1; Kentucky Fried Chicken of Cal., Inc. v. Superior Court (1997) 14 Cal.4th 814, 823; Garcia v. Superior Court (1990) 50 Cal.3d 728, 735; Hasson v. Ford Motor Co. (1982) 32 Cal.3d 388, 407.)
(Id.) Therefore, there is precedent for holding parties liable for conduct based on a constructive knowledge standard. The author makes the case:
Although the plaintiffs in the case were held to an actual knowledge standard (which they ultimately met), the intent of this bill is to make it easier for other plaintiffs to hold defendants responsible in the future in similar actions.
Proponents contend that a defendant paint company shouldn’t be allowed to escape liability just because a plaintiff can’t establish from historical records that the company had actual knowledge when the evidence shows that they should have known. Writing to distinguish the two concepts, the appellate court noted, “proof of actual knowledge focuses on what information a defendant must have been aware of, while proof of constructive knowledge rests on a defendant’s duty to discover information.” (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th at p. 27.) The constructive knowledge standard would facilitate holding lead-based paint manufacturers liable in future cases since it is easier to show that a party had a duty to discover relevant information than it is to demonstrate that the party actually had or must have had some relevant information.
Overall, this bill would ensure that more of the homes in California that contain lead-based paint are eligible for, and receive, abatement assistance. Ultimately, this bill would make it easier for those affected to bring actions against companies that should have known of the grave risks posed by this poisonous product, and yet continued to promote its use in homes across the state.
5. Support and Opposition
The Consumer Federation of California writes in support that this bill, along with others introduced this year, is “necessary to pick up where the courts left off to protect the next generation of children from lead paint dangers, while ensuring paint companies don’t push their liability onto homeowners.”
Writing in support, the California League of Conservation Voters states that this bill is part of a package that “safeguards children from the health consequences of toxic lead paint” and “helps hold paint manufacturers responsible for poisoning children.”
Bay Area Legal Aid (BayLegal) explains their support for the bill:
BayLegal is committed to protecting the health and safety of low-income California residents. Support for the lead paint six-bill package is consistent with our mission because the adverse health impacts from lead paint have been mostly concentrated in low-income neighborhoods with racial and/or ethnic minority populations. (“Trial evidence suggested that the [lead paint manufacturing] industry saw the risk of health effects from lead paint to be chiefly a PR problem, with the dangers mostly concentrated in low-income ethnic neighborhoods.” – Los Angeles Times, 11/15/2017).
Writing in opposition, the Paint Council Network and the American Coatings Association states [emphasis in original]:
AB 2803 imposes liability upon parties that “promoted lead-based paint” without any direct link between the product at issue and the person making the claim. In addition, AB 2803 ignores decades of work conducted by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) on the risks associated with lead-based paint hazards.
The direct link between a consumer’s harm and the product that caused the harm is fundamental to the constitutional protections of due process and of liberty and property. Without this fundamental element, due process, a right so cherished in the law, is completely denied. AB 2803, however, goes even farther – applying this collective theory of liability to anyone who promoted the use of lead-based paint. It is unclear as to whether the act of “promotion” includes all of the entities, public and private, that required the use of lead-based paint in building and maintenance specifications. Indeed, this bill goes even further by stating that it is not necessary for a claimant to show that they relied on the “promotion” of any such product.
Finally, AB 2803 ignores the work conducted by hundreds of public health and environmental professionals that have studied the impacts of residential lead-based paint and have clearly defined the hazards associated with it. Once defined, EPA and HUD have lead [sic] the effort to develop standards that are appropriate to protect the environment and public health. AB 2803 completely undermines this work and will result in confusion in the housing industry, the construction industry, and the home improvement industry to name just a few.
Support: Asian Pacific Environmental Network; Bay Area Legal Aid; Brightline Defense Project; California Environmental Justice Alliance; California League of Conservation Voters; California State Association of Counties; Center for Environmental Health; City of Emeryville; City of Oakland; Clean Water Action; Children’s Advocacy Institute; Cloverdale Indivisible; Consumer Attorneys of California; Consumer Federation of California; County of Monterey; County of Santa Clara; Environmental Working Group; Indivisible CA: StateStrong; Indivisible CA-33; Indivisible CA-43; Indivisible, Change Begins with ME; Indivisible SF; Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors; Orinda Progressive Action Alliance; Physicians for Social Responsibility, Los Angeles; Physicians for Social Responsibility, San Francisco Bay Area; SmartOakland
Opposition: American Coatings Association; California Business Properties Association; California Chamber of Commerce; California Construction and Industrial Materials Association; California Manufacturers and Technology Association; National Federation of Independent Business; Paint Council Network; West Coast Lumber and Building Material Association; Western Plant Health Association
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation:
AB 2073 (Chiu, 2018) would provide that any property owner, or agent thereof, who participates in a program to abate lead-based paint created as a result of a judgment or settlement in any public nuisance or similar litigation shall be immune from liability in any lawsuit seeking to recover inspection, abatement, or any other costs associated with that abatement program and the activities conducted pursuant to that abatement program. This bill is currently in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 2934 (Stone, 2018) would require the Department of Public Health to request permission from the federal Environmental Protection Agency to modify its Lead Related Construction Program agreement to expand its authority and authorize a county to implement and administer the certification program for persons engaged in lead construction work. This bill would allow for the certification of additional lead-paint inspectors. This bill is currently in the Senate Rules Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2074 (Bonta, 2018) would have provided that an injured party in a suit to recover damages caused by lead-based paint may establish a prima facie case that a particular lead paint manufacturer is the cause of the injury if the injured party proves by a preponderance of the evidence that the manufacturer sold, distributed, or promoted in California either the type of lead paint pigment that caused the injury or a product containing the type of lead paint pigment that caused the injury. This bill died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 2995 (Carrillo, 2018) would have provided that the presence of lead-based paint on a building constitutes a physical injury to property. The statute of limitations for bringing an action to remedy such an injury would have been extended to three years from the date the plaintiff has actual knowledge of the presence of lead-based paint on the property. This bill failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AB 3009 (Quirk, 2018) would have enacted a fee on paint manufacturers for every gallon of paint sold in California. The bill would have created the Lead-Based Paint Cleanup Fund into which the fees would be deposited. Such funds would have gone toward abatement programs. This bill died on the Assembly Floor.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 41, Noes 27)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2803
Author:(Limón)
As Amended Ver:April 23, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Environmental Safety | 5-2 | Quirk, Arambula, Friedman, Holden, Muratsuchi | Melendez, Brough |
Judiciary | 7-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Kalra, Reyes | Cunningham, Kiley |
SUMMARY: Clarifies existing public nuisance law in California as applied to lead-based paint, including codifying several aspects of the Court of Appeal's decision in People v. Conagra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right.
- Subjects a party to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
- Provides that, in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence in order to prove causation. Instead, causation may be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, is a nuisance.
- Establishes that a public nuisance is one which affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal.
- Allows a public nuisance to be abated by any public body or officer authorized by law.
- Defines a lead hazard in a human habitable building to include deteriorating lead paint, lead-contaminated dust, lead-contaminated soil, or a disturbance of lead-based paint without containment; provides that any residence with a lead hazard is in violation of the code.
- Establishes that all buildings constructed before January 1, 1978, are presumed to contain lead-based paint unless testing reveals lead content of less than one milligram per square centimeter or less than .5% by weight.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: In 2017, an appellate court concluded that three paint manufacturers were responsible for the health hazards of lead-based paint in many homes in California, and upheld a lower court order that they pay for abatement of these hazards. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51.) This bill, like several others introduced in the Legislature this session, seeks to ensure robust lead-based paint abatement in California, through the abatement program created by the judgment and by other means to help homeowners sue to recover abatement costs from lead-based paint manufacturers, if necessary. These bills also address issues raised by a subsequent ballot initiative, proposed for the November 2018 election and sponsored by the lead paint companies, which would vacate the court's decision to hold paint manufacturers liable for cleaning up the lead-based paint crisis in California and instead create a taxpayer-funded bond for abatement.
This bill provides that residential lead-based paint interferes with a public right while also establishing that a party may be liable for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint with actual or constructive knowledge that it was hazardous. Additionally, this bill would establish that an aggrieved party does not need to identify the specific party which caused the injury, but instead may infer causation from other evidence. Except for the extension of liability to a person having constructive knowledge, these provisions largely codify principles established in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., the aforementioned 2017 court decision that held three paint manufacturers responsible for creating a public nuisance.
Judgment against paint industry: In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers to hold former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead-based paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation
After a six-week trial in 2013, the trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance in the ten jurisdictions by promoting lead-based paint for interior use despite knowledge of the substantial harms that would result. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead-based paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties. The three paint manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to inspect for and abate lead-based paint in all homes constructed up through 1980.
Manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion to fund inspection for, and abatement of, lead-based paint and lead-contaminated dust from the interiors of homes and lead-contaminated soil around homes built in 1980 or earlier in the ten cities and counties; remediation of any structural deficiencies in the homes that would cause the lead control measures to fail; and, public education and outreach necessary for the program.
The ten cities and counties were designated to oversee the lead inspection and abatement program in their respective jurisdictions. Property owners' participation would be entirely voluntary, and any funds unspent after four years would revert back to the manufacturers.
In 2017, the Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court's determination that Manufacturers were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties. However, the Court of Appeal limited the judgment to homes built before 1951.
On February 14, 2018, the California Supreme Court denied requests by the manufacturers to review a decision requiring those companies to pay several hundred million dollars to identify and clean up lead-based paint from millions. The case is returning to the Superior Court to 1) calculate the amount that manufacturers must pay for pre-1951 homes only and 2) decide on a receiver to administer the fund and distribute the monies to the ten cities and counties.
Safe Homes and Schools Act: In spite of the court's findings, the lead paint manufacturers are proposing an initiative for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility on California homeowners for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint.
Specifically, the ballot measure, titled The Safe Homes and Schools Act, would authorize $2 billion in general obligation bonds to remediate homes for various hazards (mold, asbestos, pests, radon, and lead); declare that lead-based paint is not a "public nuisance;" and, would retroactively nullify all cases pending or pending on appeal as of November 1, 2017. According to the Legislative Analysist's Office, if the bonds were sold at an average interest rate of 5%, the cost would be $3.9 billion to pay off both principal ($2 billion) and interest ($1.9 billion), which would be paid for by taxpayers.
This bill provides that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable. The author concedes that one aspect in which this bill departs from the Court of Appeal's decision is that it allows a party to be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards. Although the plaintiffs in the case were held to an actual knowledge standard (which they ultimately met), it is the author's intent that this bill make it easier for other plaintiffs to hold defendants responsible in the future in similar actions.
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0002770
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2803
Author:(Limón) – As Amended Ver:April 23, 2018
SUBJECT: PUBLIC NUISANCE: RESIDENTIAL LEAD-BASED PAINT
KEY ISSUES:
- Shall a party be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use, despite having actual or constructive knowlEdge that such use would be hazardous to human health?
- In an action solely seeking abatement of residential lead-based paint, should an injured party be able to infer that parties who promoted the use of lead-based paint with actual or conSTRUCTIVE knowledge of its haZARDs caused the NUISANCE that requires abatement, rather than being required to present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied at a specific residence?
SYNOPSIS
Every year thousands of California children are subject to irreversible harm from lead exposure. Despite the fact that consumer lead-based paint has been banned in the U.S. since 1978, it continues to present a serious risk to human health and well-being. According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint. A recent court decision, People v. Conagra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51, found several manufacturers of lead-based paints to be liable for creating a public nuisance across 10 jurisdictions due to their efforts to sell, manufacture, distribute, and promote lead-based paint despite having actual or constructive knowledge that the paint presented a hazard to human health. The three paint manufacturers named in the case were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to inspect for and abate lead paint in all homes constructed up through 1980, though an appellate court later ruled that the manufacturers were only liable for lead-based paint in homes built before 1951. This bill, like several others brought before the legislature this session, seeks to address issues surrounding lead-based paint brought up in the court case and in a subsequent ballot initiative proposed for the November 2018 election which would vacate the court’s decision to hold them liable and create a bond for abatement using tax-payer money.
This bill clarifies existing public nuisance law in California as applied to lead-based paint, including codifying several aspects of the Court of Appeal's decision in ConAgra. First, this bill provides that residential lead-based paint interferes with a public right if it affects the health of a considerable number of people. The bill also establishes that a party may be liable for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint with actual or constructive knowledge that it was hazardous. Additionally, the bill would establish that an aggrieved party does not need to identify the specific party which caused the injury, but instead may infer causation from other evidence. Several nonprofits and environmental groups support this bill because it codifies several strong aspects of the appellate decision, and they wish to encourage more public entities to bring public nuisance claims against lead paint companies. The bill is opposed by paint manufacturers, business groups, and construction organizations, who object, among other things, to the bill’s imposition of liability on parties that “promoted lead-based paint” without any direct link between the product at issue and the person making the claim. They contend that this would violate constitutional due process protections by applying collective liability to anyone who promoted the use of lead-based paint. This bill was previously heard in the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and passed with a vote of 5-2, though it has since been substantially amended to deal with a different policy question than the one considered by the earlier Committee.
SUMMARY: Clarifies existing public nuisance law in California as applied to lead-based paint, including codifying several aspects of the Court of Appeal's decision in People v. Conagra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that residential lead-based paint that affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right.
- Subjects a party to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable.
- Provides that, in an action seeking solely abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence in order to prove causation. Instead, causation may be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
- Makes a number of Legislative findings and declarations, including the following:
- In 2006, a California appellate court found that lead-based paint in residences may constitute a public nuisance and that lead pigment paint manufacturers may be held liable for public nuisance if they promoted lead-based paint for residential use with sufficient knowledge of the health hazards that would result to render their promotions unreasonable. (County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292).
- Based on extensive evidence presented at trial, a California judge in 2010 found that certain lead pigment paint manufacturers caused lead-based paint to be applied on certain residential surfaces by promoting that paint for use on those surfaces even though they knew about the serious health harms to children that would result. (County of Santa Clara v. Superior Court (2010) 50 Cal.4th 35.)
- A California appellate court in 2017 unanimously affirmed that finding by the judge. (People v. Conagra Grocery Products Company (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51.)
- Certain lead pigment paint manufacturers now contend that these court decisions misstate California’s public nuisance law as applied to lead-based paint in residences in California.
- This act clarifies existing public nuisance law as applied to lead-based paint.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, is a nuisance. (Civil Code Section 3479. All further statutory references are to this code unless otherwise stated.)
- Establishes that a public nuisance is one which affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal. (Section 3480.)
- Provides that no lapse of time can legalize a public nuisance, amounting to an actual obstruction of public right. (Section 3490.)
- Authorizes a private person to maintain an action for a public nuisance, if it is specially injurious to himself, but not otherwise. (Section 3493.)
- Allows a public nuisance to be abated by any public body or officer authorized by law. (Section 3494.)
- Authorizes any person to abate a public nuisance which is specially injurious to him by removing, or, if necessary, destroying the thing which constitutes the same, without committing a breach of the peace, or doing unnecessary injury. (Section 3495.)
- Defines a lead hazard in a human habitable building to include deteriorating lead paint, lead-contaminated dust, lead-contaminated soil, or a disturbance lead paint without containment; provides that any residence with a lead hazard is in violation of the code. (Health and Safety Code Section 17920.10.)
- Authorizes a government enforcement agency to take actions to abate any nuisance or violation related to a building used for human habitation. (Health and Safety Code Sections 17980 et seq.)
- Establishes that all buildings constructed before January 1, 1978 are presumed to contain lead-based paint unless testing reveals lead content of less than 1 milligram per square centimeter or less than .5% by weight. (California Code of Regulations, Title 17, Section 35043.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 2017, an appellate court concluded that three paint manufacturers were responsible for the health hazards of lead paint in many homes in California, and upheld a lower court order that they pay for abatement of these hazards. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51.) This bill, like several others introduced in the Legislature this session, seeks to ensure robust lead paint abatement in California, through the abatement program created by the judgment and by other means to help homeowners sue to recover abatement costs from lead paint manufacturers, if necessary. These bills also address issues raised by a subsequent ballot initiative, proposed for the November 2018 election and sponsored by the lead paint companies, which would vacate the court’s decision to hold paint manufacturers liable for cleaning up the lead paint crisis in California and instead create a taxpayer-funded bond for abatement.
This measure provides that residential lead-based paint interferes with a public right while also establishing that a party may be liable for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint with actual or constructive knowledge that it was hazardous. Additionally, the bill would establish that an aggrieved party does not need to identify the specific party which caused the injury, but instead may infer causation from other evidence. Except for the extension of liability to a person having constructive knowledge, these provisions largely codify principles established in People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., the aforementioned 2017 court decision that held three paint manufacturers responsible for creating a public nuisance. (17 Cal.App.5th 51.)
Pervasive, ongoing threats to health and safety posed by lead-based paint in California: A short background. Lead poisoning in children is a common, pervasive phenomenon in California and across the nation. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), there is no safe blood lead level identified for children. The CDC estimates that approximately 2.6% of U.S. children aged 1 - 5 years old have high levels of lead in their blood (blood lead levels ≥ 5 micrograms per deciliter (µg/dL)). Childhood lead exposure most often occurs because of aging lead-based paint. Like all paint, lead-based paint inevitably deteriorates: it flakes, chips, and turns to dust and can contaminate the air, soil, floor, and other surfaces in the home. This is particularly true of lead paint on windows, doors, and other friction surfaces. Because children are especially likely to play on the ground and put things in their mouths, lead paint presents a larger risk for them than it does for adults living in the same space.
Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child’s health, including by creating damage to the brain and nervous system, slowing growth and development, and causing learning, behavior, hearing, and speech problems. Even a slight elevation in blood lead levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Decreased intelligence in children and increased blood pressure in adults are among the more serious non-carcinogenic effects of lead. Warnings about the tendency for children to gnaw on painted surfaces and become poisoned with lead were common in medical journals by the 1920s. By the 1930s, parents were warned to avoid using lead-based decorative materials in nurseries and bedrooms. Yet by most accounts, the industry kept promoting residential lead paint by advertising its durability.
In 1948, the Baltimore Public Health Department observed an increase in childhood lead poisoning, primarily in communities living in neglected row houses which contained massive amounts of peeling and flaking lead paint. Health inspectors found that children were eating lead from peeling and chipping lead-based paint in that city’s housing, and in response, the Baltimore Public Health Department issued the country’s first ban on interior lead-based paint in 1951. This would be followed in 1978 with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission prohibiting all consumer uses of lead-based paint across the country. Additionally, in California since 1987, lead has been listed under Proposition 65 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects, and has been listed as a chemical known to cause cancer since 1992.
Lead-based paint in California is also responsible for ongoing economic and social costs. Despite the federal ban on consumer uses for lead-based paints in 1978, millions of existing structures across the state still contain lead paint. According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint. Removal costs an estimated $8-$15 a square foot, which means removing all lead from a house of 1,200-2,000 square feet could run as much as $9,600-$30,000, according to RealtyTimes.com.
Judgment against Lead-Based Paint Manufacturers. In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation: the County of Alameda, the City of Oakland, the City and County of San Francisco, the City of San Diego, the County of Los Angeles, the County of Monterey, the County of San Mateo, the County of Solano, and the County of Ventura. Collectively, there are 18.7 million individuals living in the 10 jurisdictions which brought the case, which represent approximately 46.9% of the population of California.
The trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance by promoting lead paint for interior use despite knowledge of the substantial harms that would result. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties. The three paint manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to abate lead paint in all homes constructed up through 1980, though a later Court of Appeal decision reduced the scope of the abatement to only include pre-1951 residences. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51.)
Establishes that residential lead-based paint may interfere with a public right. Defendants in the ConAgra case argued, among other things, that: (1) a public nuisance can exist only if it harms people in their exercise of a public right; (2) interior residential lead paint does not interfere with any “public right” because it causes only private harms in private residences; and (3) the ‘public’ has no right to be present inside a private home, and thus, any possible lead exposure inside a private home cannot occur in the exercise of any public right. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th at p. 63.)
The court expressly rejected the contention that interior residential paint cannot interfere with a public right. (Ibid.) The court stated:
Interior residential lead paint that is in a dangerous condition does not merely pose a risk of private harm in private residences. The community has a collective social interest in the safety of children in residential housing. Interior residential lead paint interferes with the community’s “public right” to housing that does not poison children. This interference seriously threatens to cause grave harm to the physical health of the community’s children. . . Most members of the “public” reside in residential housing, and we do not accept defendants’ claim that, unlike streets, residential housing is not a shared community resource. Residential housing, like water, electricity, natural gas, and sewer services, is an essential community resource. Indeed, without residential housing, it would be nearly impossible for the “public” to obtain access to water, electricity, gas, and sewer services. Pervasive lead exposure in residential housing threatens the public right to essential community resources. (Ibid.)
Consistent with the court's position, this bill provides that residential lead-based paint can interfere with a public right, and more specifically, that it does interfere with a public right when it affects the health of a considerable number of persons. By codifying this in state law, the bill goes further than the court decision by extending the reach of the court’s holding to all residences with lead-based paint, not just those located in the 10 jurisdictions which brought the suit against the paint manufacturers. Thus, the bill would make it easier for other cities and counties to bring a lawsuit against paint manufacturers in order to provide lead paint abatement to their residents as well. Given that an estimated 47% of the state population resides in the jurisdictions that were party to the court case, even if pre-1978 houses were not equally distributed throughout the state, it is likely that this measure would approximately double the number of dwellings with lead-based paint that are collectively considered to be a public nuisance.
Standards in considering lead-based paint in the court case and under existing statutes. The bill is opposed by the California Paint Council and the American Coatings Association, two trade associations representing the paint and coatings industry. Opponents note that while the court opinion refers to only interior residential lead-based paint, this bill captures all residential lead-based paint, whether interior or exterior. While the greatest risks to human health are from interior residential lead-based paint, there are some reasons to justify including exterior paint within this rule. For example, exterior lead-based paint may contribute to more indirect risks, such as lead contamination of soil and water, and can still become a potential hazard in cases where it is not properly contained (e.g., during a remodel or renovation of a structure that involves tearing down an exterior wall which contains lead-based paint).
Additionally, while opponents argue that the classification of lead-based residential paint as a public nuisance is overly broad and ignores existing health and safety code standards of what constitutes a “lead hazard,” there are several reasons to consider lead-based residential paint in any form as potentially interfering with a public right. For example, lead-based paint on a residential dwelling, even if currently contained according to health and safety code standards, always has the potential to be unsafe in the future if it becomes exposed due to deterioration or removal of the top layers of paint.
Consider the example of an elderly homeowner who has diligently kept lead-based paint covered for years and avoided creating any lead hazard in her house. If she becomes ill and falls behind on repairs due to lack of physical mobility or lack of money, then the lead-based paint could easily become a hazard over time. The only way to avoid the potential hazard posed by lead-based paint is to abate it by removal using practices that can contain the lead-based paint during the removal process. Otherwise, residents of the state must have constant vigilance against the risks created by lead-based paint, despite the fact that the three manufacturers named in the case continued promoting, manufacturing, distributing, and selling lead-based paint long after they knew of its detrimental effects on health.
Liability with either actual knowledge or constructive knowledge. The Court of Appeal held that the plaintiff's public nuisance cause of action must be supported by an actual knowledge standard, not constructive knowledge. The court explained:
[L]iability is premised on defendants’ promotion of lead paint for interior use with knowledge of the hazard that such use would create. This conduct is distinct from and far more egregious than simply producing a defective product or failing to warn of a defective product . . . By tethering the public nuisance cause of action to affirmative promotion for a use defendants knew to be hazardous, this court necessarily set forth an actual knowledge standard.
The court then evaluated the evidence in the case and concluded that the plaintiffs demonstrated that defendant companies had actual knowledge of the dangers associated with residential uses of interior lead-based paint. Despite actually knowing of the harmful effect of their product, the manufacturers continued to sell and promote their product for interior residential use; thus, liability for public nuisance was justified.
This bill provides that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable. The author concedes that one aspect in which this bill departs from the Court of Appeal’s decision is that it allows a party to be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint for a particular use with constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards. Although the plaintiffs in the case were held to an actual knowledge standard (which they ultimately met), it is the author's intent that this bill make it easier for other plaintiffs to hold defendants responsible in the future in similar actions.
Proponents contend that a defendant paint company shouldn’t be allowed to escape liability just because a plaintiff can’t establish from historical records that the company had actual knowledge when the evidence shows that they should have known. Writing to distinguish the two concepts, the appellate court noted, “proof of actual knowledge focuses on what information a defendant must have been aware of, while proof of constructive knowledge rests on a defendant’s duty to discover information.” (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co., supra, 17 Cal.App.5th at p. 27.) The constructive knowledge standard would facilitate holding lead-based paint manufacturers liable in future cases since it is easier to show that a party had a duty to discover relevant information than it is to demonstrate that the party actually had or must have had some relevant information.
Liability without "direct link" causation. In an action to recover damages for injury attributable to lead-paint exposure, history has shown that proving causation under traditional theories of liability is difficult. The factual scenarios that typically apply in lead paint cases (e.g. shared culpability among multiple actors for marketing a harmful product; an innocent plaintiff unable to identify the precise manufacturer of the product that caused the injury; the passage of time) suggest that alternative theories of liability—in which the burden of proof is shifted to the defendant —might be necessary to ensure an innocent injured party has some right to redress.
This bill takes a small step in that direction in public nuisance cases. Specifically, the bill provides that in an action solely seeking abatement of residential lead-based paint that has been found to interfere with a public right, an aggrieved party need not present evidence that a particular party caused a particular lead-based paint to be applied in a particular residence in order to prove causation. Instead, the bill would allow causation to be inferred from evidence that does not itself constitute direct evidence of reliance on an individual basis.
The California Paint Council and the American Coatings Association oppose these provisions of the bill because they do not adhere to the traditional "direct link" notion of causation. They write:
The direct link between a consumer’s harm and the product that caused the harm is fundamental to the constitutional protections of due process and of liberty and property. Without this fundamental element, due process, a right so cherished in the law, is completely denied. AB 2803, however, goes even farther – applying this collective theory of liability to anyone who promoted the use of lead-based paint. It is unclear as to whether the act of “promotion” includes all of the entities, public and private, that required the use of lead-based paint in building and maintenance specifications. Indeed, this bill goes even further by stating that it is not necessary for a claimant to show that they relied on the “promotion” of any such product.
There are several problems with opponents' argument. First, it is false to say that the bill applies a collective theory of liability to "anyone who promoted the use of lead-based paint." In fact, the bill specifically states that a party may be subject to liability for public nuisance if it promoted lead-based paint "for a particular use with actual or constructive knowledge that such use would cause health hazards sufficiently serious to render that use unreasonable." It is not promotion per se, but promotion with knowledge that such use would cause serious health hazards that makes the party liable under this bill. "Here, the alleged basis for defendants’ liability for the public nuisance created by lead paint is their affirmative promotion of lead paint for interior use, not their mere manufacture and distribution of lead paint or their failure to warn of its hazards.” (Id. at p. 35, citing County of Santa Clara v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 292, 309.)
Opponents' argument that the bill imposes liability upon parties that promoted lead-based paint without any direct link between the product at issue and the person making the claim is off-base, and previously addressed by the court in ConAgra when similar arguments were made:
Defendants contend that their promotions cannot be found to have caused the presence of interior lead paint in homes in the 10 jurisdictions without proof that paint made by each of them is currently present in those homes. This contention misconstrues the basis for defendants’ liability. Defendants are liable for promoting lead paint for interior residential use. To the extent that this promotion caused lead paint to be used on residential interiors, the identity of the manufacturer of that lead paint is irrelevant (emphasis added) . . . What matters is whether defendants’ promotions were a substantial factor in leading to the use of lead paint on residential interiors. Substantial evidence supports the court’s causation finding on that basis. (ConAgra, 17 Cal.App.5th 51, 57.)
Potential effect of a public nuisance upon property values. Opponents also contend that declaring residential lead-based paint to be a public nuisance could hurt property values. It should be emphasized that the Court of Appeal last year did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance as a result of the litigation. Furthermore, given that the presence of interior residential lead-based paint has already been declared a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions that were party to the legal case against the paint manufacturers, this claim seems questionable. As previously noted, these 10 jurisdictions contain 47% of the state’s population and, in the time following the appellate court’s decision, the Committee is unaware of any information or news articles documenting any decrease in property values tied to the court’s finding.
Additionally, home buyers and renters are already required to be given notice that any dwelling constructed prior to January 1, 1978 is presumed to contain lead paint. If anything, a statute stating that residential lead-based paint interferes with a public right could have the potential to increase property values. Since homeowners and apartment owners may be more likely to have access to abatement funds if more local jurisdictions are successful in suing paint manufacturers, properties may rise in value if property owners can affirmatively prove that lead-based paints have been safely removed from their property.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters of the measure argue that it will remove a significant hurdle to holding paint manufacturers accountable for the harm caused by their production of lead-based paint. In particular, those in favor of the bill contend that it will provide that residential lead-based paint which affects the health of a considerable number of persons interferes with a public right and is a public nuisance. Supporters also argue that AB 2803 will make it easier for public entities to bring a public nuisance claim against lead paint companies.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of the bill from the paint and coating industries argue that the bill will impose liability on parties that “promoted lead-based paint” without any direct link between the product at issue and the person making the claim. They contend that this would violate constitutional due process protections by applying collective liability to anyone who promoted the use of lead-based paint. Finally, they argue that this bill ignores the work conducted by public health and environmental professionals who have clearly defined the standards for what constitutes a lead-based paint hazard. These arguments are discussed and refuted in more detail above.
In a joint letter of opposition from several business, manufacturing, and construction groups, these opponents claim the bill would deem eight million homes to be a public nuisance and subject homeowners to potential liens, foreclosures, decreased property values, and criminal sanctions. Additionally, they note that decreased property values could negatively impact state and local government revenues due to decreased property tax revenues.
Pending Related Legislation: Lead-based paint is still in many California homes built before 1978 and continues to present a serious threat to public health. This year a package of legislation has been introduced to address various issues on lead-based paint, including liability, abatement, and the legal classification of lead-based paint. The package includes the following bills:
AB 2073 (Chiu) provides immunity from liability to property owners who participate in a lead paint abatement program if they are sued for recovery of costs associated with such a program. AB 2074 (Bonta) codifies a "risk contribution" theory of liability which allows those poisoned by lead-based paint, who are unable to identify the exact manufacturer of the lead paint pigment, a new avenue to litigate cases they may not otherwise be able to litigate. AB 2995 (Carrillo) defines lead-based paint on a residence or other building as a physical injury to property, and provides that civil actions to recover damages to property due to the presence of lead-based paint do not accrue until the aggrieved party has actual knowledge of the lead-based paint. All three of the bills are being heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee at the same hearing as this bill.
AB 2934 (Stone) would allow the California Department of Public Health to contract with counties to certify lead paint inspectors in order to help fill a shortage of inspectors to help bring homes up to safe standards. Additional qualified, lead paint inspectors will be needed as work proceeds to remove toxic paint from homes under the judgement. AB 2934 is currently on the Assembly Floor. AB 3009 (Quirk) would enact a fee on paint manufacturers for all paint sold in the state and would create a fund for residents of single-family or multi-family dwellings to abate lead-based paint in their homes. This measure will only be enacted if the proposed ballot proposition removing liability for paint manufacturers passes in November of 2018. AB 3009 is currently in the Assembly Revenue and Tax Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
A. Philip Randolph Institute – San Francisco
Bay Area Legal Aid
Brightline Defense Project
California League of Conservation Voters
City of Oakland
Clean Water Action
Community Youth Center
Consumer Federation of California
Environmental Working Group
Los Angeles County
Santa Clara County
SmartOakland
Opposition
American Coatings Association
California Business Properties Association
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Paint Council Network
West Coast Lumber and Building Material Association
Western Plant Health Association
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew and Sandra Nakagawa / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2803 (
Author:Limón) – As Amended Ver:March 23, 2018
SUBJECT: Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substance Account Act
SUMMARY: Adds "lead-based paint that is bioavailable" to the definition of a hazardous substance and states that a residential property owner with contaminated lead-based paint is not a responsible party under the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substance Account Act (HSAA).
EXISTING LAW:
1) Establishes the HSAA to provide for response authority for releases of hazardous substances, including spills and hazardous waste disposal sites that pose a threat to the public health or the environment. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 25300 et seq.)
2) Defines "hazardous substance" as a substance, element, compound, mixture, or solution designated under federal law; a hazardous waste listed or designated under federal law; a toxic pollutant or hazardous air pollutant listed under federal law; or, a hazardous waste or extremely hazardous waste as defined in state law. (HSC § 25316)
3) Defines "responsible party or liable person" as those persons described in federal law; however, a responsible party does not include a person that has developed or implemented investigative or remedial technology for a release site, if that technology has been approved by the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). (HSC § 25323.5)
4) Creates a Federal "Superfund" to clean up uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites, as well as accidents, spills, and other emergency releases of pollutants and contaminants into the environment, under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). Provides the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) with the authority to seek out those parties responsible for any release and assure their cooperation in the cleanup. (42 United States Code (U.S.C.) § 9601 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 2803 would provide liability protection for homeowners whose homes are contaminated with lead based-paint; which has been recognized by California to be a hazardous substance and a human risk. This would allow homeowners to seek damages for clean-up or otherwise implement their own clean-up without fear of liability lawsuits."
Hazardous substances/hazardous waste: Information provided by the US EPA advises that over the next several decades, federal, state, and local governments and private industry will commit billions of dollars annually to clean up sites contaminated with hazardous waste and petroleum products from a variety of industrial sources. Accordingly, in the United States, there could be as many as 355,000 contaminated sites that will require cleanup over the next 30 years and that the cost of this cleanup may amount to as much as $250 billion.
Hazardous substance is a broad term that includes many chemicals and materials that present an imminent and substantial danger to public health or welfare. Improper use and disposal of these products can result in hazardous waste. According to the US EPA, hazardous wastes or substances are potentially hazardous to human health or the environment when they are improperly managed. They possess at least one of following characteristics: ignitability, corrosiveness, reactivity, or toxicity, or they appear on special US EPA lists.
The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA): CERCLA or Superfund provides a Federal "Superfund" to clean up uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites as well as accidents, spills, and other emergency releases of pollutants and contaminants into the environment. Through CERCLA, the US EPA was given authority to seek out those parties responsible for any release and assure their cooperation in the cleanup.
The US EPA cleans up orphan sites when potentially responsible parties cannot be identified or located, or when they fail to act. Through various enforcement tools, the US EPA obtains private party cleanup through orders, consent decrees, and other small party settlements. The US EPA also recovers costs from financially viable individuals and companies once a response action has been completed. CERCLA defines liable parties as current owners and operators of a facility, former owners and operators of a facility at the time of disposal, persons who arranged for treatment or disposal of hazardous substances, and transporters of hazardous substances who selected the disposal site. A person who falls within the definition of one of these classes may be held liable under CERCLA.
Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substances Account Act (HSAA): State law provides DTSC with general administrative responsibility for overseeing the state’s responses to spills or releases of hazardous substances and for hazardous waste disposal sites that pose a threat to public health or the environment. DTSC uses the HSAA for cleanup of contaminated sites and the Hazardous Waste Control Law for the regulation of hazardous waste sites. The HSAA is intended to provide compensation for out‑of‑pocket medical expenses and lost wages or business incomes resulting from injuries caused by exposure to hazardous substances. The HSAA provides DTSC with the authority, procedures, and standards to investigate, remove, and remediate contamination at sites; to issue and enforce a removal or remedial action order to any responsible party; and, to impose administrative or civil penalties for noncompliance with an order. Federal and state law also authorizes DTSC to recover costs and expenses it incurs in carrying out these activities.
Lead is a well-known toxin: Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been listed as a chemical known to cause cancer since 1992. According to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, lead has multiple toxic effects on the human body. Decreased intelligence in children and increased blood pressure in adults are among the more serious non-carcinogenic effects. There is no level of lead that has been proven safe, either for children or for adults.
The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found, based on the U.S. Census Bureau 2010 count of the number of children between the ages of 1 and 5 years old, that approximately 2.6% of U.S. children in that age group have high levels of lead in their blood (blood lead levels ≥ 5 micrograms per deciliter (µg/dL)).
Exposure to lead can seriously harm a child’s health. Even a slight elevation in blood levels can reduce IQ and stunt development. Millions of children are being exposed to lead in their homes through aging lead-based paint, increasing their risks for damage to the brain and nervous system, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, hearing, and speech problems.
The CDC's 2012 Advisory Committee on Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention statement Low Level Lead Exposure Harms Children: A Renewed Call for Primary Prevention found that the adverse health effects of blood lead levels less than 10 μg/dL in children extend beyond cognitive function to include cardiovascular, immunological, and endocrine effects.
Lead-based paint history: Lead-based paint was shipped in Colonial days to what became the United States as a luxury good, and was later used to paint such important structures as the White House, the Capitol, and Mount Vernon.
When lead pigment was used in paints, currently reported risks to children were unknown and unknowable. Medical science has evolved, leading to concerns about childhood health that had not existed when lead-based paint was marketed.
Before 1940, paint manufacturers began to use non-lead pigments, such as lithopone, zinc oxide, and titanium dioxide, in many interior paints mixed at the factory. In fact, Sherwin-Williams introduced the first, successful lead-free water-based paint for interior use in 1941. Its easy use, clean-up, and quick drying launched a do-it-yourself paint market.
In 1948, the Baltimore Public Health Department observed an increase in childhood lead poisoning in Baltimore, primarily among those who lived in its substantial number of rundown, neglected row houses amid massive amounts of peeling and flaking lead paint. That led health inspectors to investigate those houses and to learn that children were eating lead from peeling and chipping lead paint in that city’s inner-city housing, poorly maintained during and after World War II.
As soon as those new concerns were raised, the paint industry worked closely with public health officials to investigate the risk. The paint industry provided research funding, which helped lead to the Baltimore Public Health Department issuing a ban in 1951 on the use of lead pigment in interior paint in Baltimore housing. That was the first restriction on the use of interior lead paint in the country.
When the same problem was found in the dilapidated housing in older cities in the Northeast and Midwest, the paint industry also worked with the American Academy of Pediatrics, along with other groups interested in child health issues. In 1955, a voluntary national standard was adopted to prohibit, in effect, the use of lead pigments in interior residential paints.
When lead-based paint was marketed before 1978, it was a legal product in great demand because it was washable and durable. It was repeatedly endorsed by the federal, state, and local governments, and specified for use on government buildings until the mid-1970s. For example, the 1950 California Department of Education vocational book on painting endorsed the use of white lead paint.
It was not until 1974 that a new theory emerged on the predominant pathway for children to be exposed to gratuitous levels of lead. In a paper by Dr. James W. Sayre, House and Hand Dust as a Potential Source of Childhood Lead Exposure, Dr. Sayre felt that the major source might be house dust, contaminated with lead from many sources. The theory was that children were licking their hands that had become dirty with lead-contaminated dust. His theory brought about a move beyond the earlier recognition of a risk from chipping and peeling paint. He also observed that average blood lead levels of children living in low-risk areas of Rochester, New York, were in the range then of 18-25 µg/dL.
In 1978, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission banned consumer uses of lead-based paint. However, buildings built prior to the ban still likely have lead paint, as well as commercial, government, and industrial buildings and structures, which are permitted to use lead-based paint.
Lead-based paint, like all paint, inevitably deteriorates: it flakes, chips, and turns to dust and can contaminate the air, soil, floors and other surfaces in the home. This is particularly true of lead paint on windows, doors, and other friction surfaces.
Lead-based paint in California: According to the Legislative Analysist’s Office, about 60% of houses in California were built before 1978 and are presumed to have lead-based paint.
As a case in point, about 75% of Alameda County’s homes were built before 1980, which amounts to 430,000 units. Nearly 174,000 of those units are pre-1950. Lead-based paint hazards in Oakland homes are considered by local health officials to be "coming close to crisis mode." In Oakland, between 80% and 90% of the housing is pre-1978, which accounts for about 174,000 units.
In Los Angeles County, 77% of the housing was built before 1978, which is more than 2.6 million housing units. More than 900,000 of those housing units are pre-1950. In at least 75% LA County's lead poisoning cases, lead-based paint is a potential source of the lead poisoning. At least 70% of those cases involve individuals living in pre-1978 housing.
Lead-paint cleanup costs: Lead-based paint removal costs an estimated $8-$15 a square foot, which means removing all lead from a house of 1,200-2,000 square feet could run as much as $9,600-$30,000, according to RealtyTimes.com. The average removal project runs around $10,000 for a typical pre-1978 home.
Judgment against paint industry: In 2000, a complaint was filed on behalf of the People of the State of California against three major paint manufacturers to hold former lead paint manufacturers responsible for promoting lead paint for use in homes despite their knowledge that the product was highly toxic. The case was filed by Santa Clara County, and nine other cities and counties subsequently joined the litigation: the County of Alameda, the City of Oakland, the City and County of San Francisco, the City of San Diego, the County of Los Angeles, the County of Monterey, the County of San Mateo, the County of Solano, and the County of Ventura.
After a six-week trial in 2013, the trial court issued its order in 2014, finding that Sherwin-Williams, ConAgra, and NL Industries (collectively, the "manufacturers") had created a public nuisance in the 10 jurisdictions by promoting lead paint for interior use despite knowledge of the substantial harms that would result. The public nuisance created by these manufacturers consists of the collective presence of lead paint in the interiors of homes in the ten cities and counties. The three paint manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion into a fund to inspect for and abate lead paint in all homes constructed up through 1980. (The court did not find that lead paint on any individual property is a public nuisance, and thus no individual homes were declared a public nuisance.)
Manufacturers were ordered to pay $1.15 billion to fund inspection for, and abatement of, lead paint and lead-contaminated dust from the interiors of homes and lead-contaminated soil around homes built in 1980 or earlier in the ten cities and counties; remediation of any structural deficiencies in the homes that would cause the lead control measures to fail; and, public education and outreach necessary for the program.
The ten cities and counties were designated to oversee the lead inspection and abatement program in their respective jurisdictions. Property owners’ participation would be entirely voluntary, and any funds unspent after four years would revert back to the manufacturers.
In 2017, the Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s determination that Manufacturers were liable for creating a public nuisance in the ten cities and counties. (People v. ConAgra Grocery Products Co. (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 51). However, the Court of Appeal limited the judgment to homes built before 1951.
On February 14, 2018, the California Supreme Court denied requests by the manufacturers to review a decision requiring those companies to pay several hundred million dollars to identify and clean up lead paint from millions of homes built before 1951 in Santa Clara County and nine other California cities and counties. The manufacturers plan to further appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court. In the meantime, however, the case is returning to the Superior Court to (1) calculate the amount that manufacturers must pay for pre-1951 homes only and (2) decide on a receiver to administer the fund and distribute the monies to the ten cities and counties.
Safe Homes and Schools Act: In spite of the court's findings, the paint manufacturers are proposing an initiative for the November 2018 statewide ballot that would relieve paint manufacturers of liability, undo the actions by multiple courts, and put the sole financial responsibility on California homeowners for cleaning up lead-contaminated paint.
Specifically, the ballot measure, titled The Safe Homes and Schools Act would authorize $2 billion in general obligation bonds to remediate homes for various hazards (mold, asbestos, pests, radon, and lead); declare that lead-based paint is not a "public nuisance;" and, would retroactively nullify all cases pending or pending on appeal as of November 1, 2017. According to the Legislative Analysist's Office, if the bonds were sold at an average interest rate of 5%, the cost would be $3.9 billion to pay off both principal ($2 billion) and interest ($1.9 billion), which would be paid for by taxpayers.
AB 2803 achieves two objectives: First, it ensures that homeowners that have lead-based paint cannot be sued by the lead paint manufacturers. Second, it ensures that the lead paint manufacturers remain and will still be liable for their lead contamination regardless of the failure or passage of the initiative. Based on the judgements of the courts, this seems to be a reasonable proposal.
Related legislation: Lead-based paint is still in many California homes built before 1978, putting another generation of kids at risk. A package of legislation has been introduced to address the proposed policy provisions in the pending ballot measure, as well as set up frameworks for implementing the settlement funds should the ballot measure fail. The package includes the following bills:
AB 2073 (Chiu) protects homeowners from frivolous lawsuits threatened by the lead paint manufacturers if the homeowners participate in the abatement program created by the judgement. This legislation delivers needed assurance that homeowners, who do the right thing by removing toxic paint from their homes, will not be victimized by frivolous litigation from deep-pocketed paint companies. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2934 (Stone) would allow the California Department of Public Health to contract with counties to certify lead paint inspectors. This bill helps fill a shortage of inspectors to help bring homes up to safe standards. Additional qualified, lead paint inspectors will be needed as work proceeds to remove toxic paint from homes under the judgement. This bill will be heard in this Committee on April 24th.
AB 2074 (Bonta) removes a significant hurdle to homeowners holding poison paint manufacturers legally accountable for injuries by establishing that lead paint companies are responsible to prove they did not produce, sell, distribute or promote the lead-based paint used during a particular time or area, and allowing homeowners to hold companies jointly liable if there were multiple companies selling or distributing paint at that time and area. Codifying this "risk contribution" theory in statute allows those poisoned by lead-based paint, who are unable to identify the exact manufacturer of the lead paint pigment, a new avenue to litigate cases they may not otherwise be able to litigate. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2995 (Carrillo) classifies the presence of lead-based paint in a home or building as a physical injury to the property, enabling property owners to sue for the cost of abating or removing lead paint to prevent the further deterioration of peoples’ health. Secondly, the bill delays the start of the clock on the statute of limitations to when property owners become aware that lead paint is present, rather than starting the clock at the time of purchase. This bill will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2803 (Limon) would provide additional liability protection for homeowners by redefining the definition of "hazardous substance" to include lead-based paint for purposes of the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner-Hazardous Substance Account Act, otherwise known as California’s Superfund law. This would allow homeowners to seek damages for clean-up or otherwise implement their own clean-up without fear of liability lawsuits. Should this bill be approved by this Committee, it will be heard next in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Double referral: Should this bill be approved by this Committee, it will be heard next in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California League of Conservation Voters
City of Oakland
Clean Water Action
Opposition
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Industrial Environmental Association
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. /
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):