Hearings

Senate Floor

April 24, 2023
  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Madam Secretary, please call the roll.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    [Roll call].

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    A quorum is present. Members, we're going to get ready to start. If you could please take your seats. Would the Members and our guests beyond the rail and in the gallery please rise.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    We will be led in prayer this afternoon by our guest chaplain, arch-priest Father Datev Harutyunian. After which, please remain standing for the presentation of the colors by the Homenetmen Color Guard, followed by the pledge of allegiance to the flag, led by Senator Deruzo. Father.

  • Datev Harutyunian

    Person

    Almighty God, we lift up our prayers to you with reverence and trust to guide us and strengthen us all in our calling to serve and protect the people of God. We praise you for blessing us with a gift of life, bestowing upon us all bounties of the world and challenging us to become your good hands in our communities.

  • Datev Harutyunian

    Person

    Almighty God, we know well that the honorable Members of this Senate have responded to your call to bring their wisdom for the well-being of the State of California. We are here today with dual responsibilities to guard and cherish their God-given gifts. And we are also here as citizens of United States of America, wheeled with the spirit of the founding fathers of this great nation to become exemplary leaders of our communities.

  • Datev Harutyunian

    Person

    The United States of America has inspired us to cherish the true value of democracy and freedom, as well as the universal respect for humanity as the reflection of God's love. Today we pray for the 120,000 Armenians, including women, children, the elderly, and the disabled, who have been under the blockade for over 100 days in our homeland of Artsak, cut off from life's most basic necessities, including food, fuel and medicine. We pray for world peace and beseech you, guidance and mercy.

  • Datev Harutyunian

    Person

    Enlighten our hearts with your love and compassion in order that we may serve with the justice and prudence in mind. Almighty God, bless this Senate with their Members and their mission. Grant them divine wisdom and love to carry on their duties diligently, to uphold from justice for the past, and be the part of the justice for all generations to come. Amen.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Color Guard, please post the colors. We will now be led in the pledge of allegiance to the flag by Senator Durazo.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Colleagues and guests, please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, liberty, and justice for all.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Color guard, please retire the colors. How about a Senate welcome to the Color Guard for joining us here today. Members, without objection, we will now move to Senate third reading to take up file item 70, Senate Resolution 28 by Senator Portantino. Madam Secretary, please read.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Resolution 28 by Senator Portantino relative to the commemoration of the anniversary of the Armenian genocide of 1915 through 1923.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senator Portantino, the floor is yours.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President and Members, it is an honor to commemorate, sad honor to commemorate the 108th anniversary of the Armenian genocide and to be one of the authors of Senate Resolution 28, which reaffirms California's recognition of the Armenian genocide. Some of us have heard the first-hand accounts of the genocide, and some of us may not. And so I will share some of those observations from genocide survivors. With your permission, Madam President.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    It was a nightmare in Dalvor when a 12-year-old's family were warned of the proximity of the Ottoman soldiers. She fled with her mother and her eight-year-old brother to a hill above the village to hide their valuables and wait for the rest of their family to join them. But as dawn came, a massacre erupted. They watched as soldiers beheaded her father and stabbed her two-year-old nephew before turning on the boy's mother, who was seven months pregnant.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    The three of them returned to the village the following night to bury the dead. Quote, the scene was hellish. We put the killed baby on my sister's chest and covered them with stones, but we couldn't find my father's corpse, wrote the woman, recounting the story told to her by her grandmother. When asked about his mother, a survivor said, my dreams cannot mourn her. They are deferred. I did not have enough energy to mourn her.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Another survivor said she didn't shed a tear when her family was slaughtered. And years later, when she was asked why, she said, have you ever seen a stone crying? Have you ever seen a stone crying? These are just a few firsthand experiences that were published in the Guardian in 2015, and many of them are similar to what the people of Artsakh have been experiencing since the 2020 war.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    108 years later, the successor states of the genocide perpetrators, Turkey and Azerbaijan, continue their aggression against the Armenian people. While Armenia and Artsak have tried to recover from the 2020 war. Attacks on the border and violations of human rights have not stopped the imprisonment of Armenian POWs and civilians and the systematic destruction of Armenian cultural and religious sites is part of this ongoing, brutal campaign and frankly, ethnic cleansing against the indigenous Armenian population of Artsakh. Artsakh has been under blockade for over 90 days.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    And just yesterday, just yesterday, on the eve of April 24, which is the day the genocide started 108 years ago, on the eve, Azerbaijan set up their own checkpoint at the Lashian corridor, the only road connecting Armenia with Artsakh, to continue this inhumane blockade. Now, as the only state or federal elected representative from the U.S., who has actually gone to Artsakh since the 44-day war, I witnessed firsthand the destructive impact of the war had on a peaceful people.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    I met with wounded soldiers and I prayed at memorials sadly filled with weeping mourning families. It was a deeply emotional experience that has me angry and determined to speak up. And earlier this year, I worked with colleagues in the Armenian community to lead efforts calling on the White House to take action against Azerbaijan by immediately ending military assistance and requesting humanitarian aid.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    So the lessons from 108 years ago, the lessons of the genocide, the reason why we're here today to again commemorate and proclaim California's solidarity, is critical that we move beyond these words and take action to help. Now, California is home to the largest Armenian American population in the country. And this community has made significant contributions to the 25th Senate District and our great state. And I'm honored to represent this vibrant community and stand in solidarity with all those who continue to advocate for justice and peace.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    We have a moral obligation to not only condemn all genocides and violations of human rights, but also to hold the perpetrators accountable in order to have a more peaceful and just world for generations. This one and future ones. He shumenk yev bahanjum oddsvats orna. With that, I respectfully ask for an Aye vote on Senate resolution 28.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senator Archuleta.

  • Bob Archuleta

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam Chair. Senators, those with us this morning, this afternoon, I rise today as a proud co-sponsor of Senate Bill Resolution or Senate Resolution 28, commemorating the anniversary of the Armenian genocide. As you've heard the atrocities, but as a member of the California Armenian Legislative Council and Caucus, I am grateful and proud that our nation now formally recognizes the Armenian genocide. Sanctioned by the Ottoman Empire, 1915, the Armenian genocide was the first state-sponsored genocide in modern times.

  • Bob Archuleta

    Legislator

    Entire communities were forcibly marched to their deaths or murdered in an attempt to erase their presence from a region they had peacefully resided in for over 4,000 years. California is home to the largest Armenian American population in the United States. We must continue to support the Armenian community to ensure future generations learn from this genocide and prevent any atrocity like this ever to happen again.

  • Bob Archuleta

    Legislator

    I am eternally grateful to the Armenian American community and the descendants of the survivors across the globe for their perseverance and their dedication to the Armenian cause. In order for us to present and present the future generations to them to learn about the injustices that has befallen their ancestors, we must be in complete and accurate account of history. And as you heard earlier, it is happening as we speak. Only then can we prevent the issues of today from compounding and developing into the injustices of tomorrow.

  • Bob Archuleta

    Legislator

    For these reasons, I respectfully ask your Aye vote.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam Chair. I rise in support of SR 28, and I thank the author on this 108th anniversary of the Armenian genocide. My heart is with the Armenian people as they continue their struggle for justice and peace. Despite the lessons of history, Azerbaijan's ongoing ethnic cleansing campaign in Artsakh serves as a stark reminder of the need for unwavering solidarity.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senator Durazo.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    As we stand together, I am proud to represent little Armenia and to reaffirm California's commitment to the Armenian people, as demonstrated by our recognition of Artsakh's Independence in 2014. Thank you.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senator Menjivar.

  • Caroline Menjivar

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. Good afternoon, colleagues. I rise today as a proud coauthor of SR 28, commemorating the 105 million lives lost of the 1915 Armenian genocide. And often, when we speak about these horrific events, we don't speak about it in present terms - present tense. But that's exactly what's happening right now. About 120,000 Armenians right now are being blocked in Artsakh by the Azerbaijanian government. They're being blocked from water, food, and medicine, necessary items to survive.

  • Caroline Menjivar

    Legislator

    We spoke last week regarding the Holocaust memorial and how Hitler got his idea, if you will, from this very incident, the Armenian genocide. And we often say, and we repeat, if we don't know our history, we're going to repeat it. But it's happening again right now to the Armenian population. I am so honored to represent a large Armenian population in my district. I thank them for sharing their rich culture with us, for their extensive advocacy work performed by many Armenian organizations in my district.

  • Caroline Menjivar

    Legislator

    That is why I ask, and I ask all of my Members to stand with Armenians as they continue to endure oppression in Artsakh. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote on SR 28.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senator Wiener.

  • Scott Wiener

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. I rise as co-chair of the Legislative Jewish Caucus in support of SR 28. Every genocide is completely unique, and the hatreds are unique. But there are some commonalities, and one of those commonalities is that after the fact, there are people who try to convince the world that it never happened. You have huge number of people in Armenia massacred, just massacred, murdered, and then you have people years later saying, well, it never really happened. It's all made up.

  • Scott Wiener

    Legislator

    It's happening with the Holocaust, too. People who say, it never really happened. It's all made up. And people do that for a number of different reasons to try to reduce their own or their community's culpability. But it is so incredibly harmful and toxic, and it makes it more likely that genocides will happen in the future when you try to have that kind of erasure. So I urge an aye vote.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Senators, is there any further discussion or debate? Senator Bradford?

  • Steven Bradford

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President. I, too, rise as vice chair of the Legislative Black Caucus in strong support of SR 28. And as my colleagues have stated, if we do not know our history, we're doomed to repeat it. And for so long, many of the tragedies, not only here in America but around the world, have been denied, as we've heard and learned about this Armenian genocide.

  • Steven Bradford

    Person

    So, I think it's imperative that we all take this opportunity to educate ourselves of some of the horrific incidents that have happened around the world. And it parallels much of what we've seen here in this country with the annihilation of our Native Americans, the enslavement of blacks, and the exploitation of our Asian communities. So, we do ourselves a great service by educating ourselves and not letting the whitewashing of history continue.

  • Steven Bradford

    Person

    So bringing recognition to this tragedy will hopefully put us in a better position to make sure that it never repeats itself. So, I respectfully ask for aye vote.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Is there any further discussion or debate on this item saying, none. Senator Portantino, you may conclude.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President, and thank you, colleagues, for your words of support and recognition of this important resolution. As my colleagues have referenced, genocide denial continues. Just last week, many of our offices received a letter from the Turkish consulate denying that this happened. So when people say, why are we doing this?

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    That's why we're doing this, because there is the perpetrator out there, continuing to deny a historical fact, continuing to deny that 1.5 million people were put to death during the first generation - genocide of the 20th century. And that phrase we've often used, the first genocide of the 20th century, is implicit, that there were genocides to follow.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    And had we learned the lesson during World War I, we wouldn't have had the holocaust of World War II, we wouldn't have had Rwanda, we wouldn't have had the genocides that came subsequent to that historic lesson. And so it's appropriate that California stands in solidarity, speaks out, and I appreciate the comments and respectfully ask for an aye vote on SR 28.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Madam Secretary, please call the roll.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    [Roll Call]

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Please call the absent Members.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    [Roll Call]

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Aye, 39, No, 0. The Senate Resolution is adopted. Members, we're going to move on to privileges of the floor. Senator Portantino at the majority leader's desk.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Thank you. Madam President and Members, it is indeed an honor to acknowledge our special guests who have joined us today for this important 108th commemoration of the Armenian genocide. First, we were joined by Archpriest Father Datev Harutyuian, Reverend Father Krikor Zakaryan, Reverend Father Mesrop Ash, Reverend Father Yeghishe Ksachikyan, and Father Smpd Saboudjian. So we want to acknowledge our clergy. We also want to acknowledge the Homenetmen Scouts who provided our color guard.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    And on a special note, all of those who are supportive, our young people, in particular, our special needs young people. The Homenetmen created a scouting chapter just for children of special needs, and they called it the Hrashq Chapter, which means miracle. And when you go to their jamborees and you see 150 special needs scouts marching alongside the other children, it is a sight to see. So I always have a soft spot for the Homenetmen for their recognition of our children with special needs.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    We also have with us Armenian Assembly of America, Valina Agbabian, Norjan Kevranian, Lori Agbabian. We have, from the Armenian National Committee of America, Pasadena, David Gavorkyan, Armenian National Committee of America, Matt Senekeremian from San Francisco. Armenian National Committee of America, Aram Sarkisian, who's from Sacramento, Armenian National Committee of America, Khatchig Tazian. Armenian National Committee of America, Western Region Chair Nora Hovsepian. We have from the California Armenian Legislative Caucus Foundation, the Sahabi family, and the Carpetian family.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    And we have many additional guests up in the gallery representing multiple Armenian American organizations. So please give a warm Senate welcome to our special guests. Maybe indulge in a photo.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Absolutely. Members who would like to be included in the photo. Now's your opportunity to join. Members, we're ready to proceed with our floor session and Senator Portantino at his desk.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President. Under privileges of the floor, I would just like to thank the floor staff, the Majority Leader staff, the Pro Tem staff, and my staff as we come back to normal and reengage the community. It was wonderful to see and thank you, everybody, for making this happen today.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Thank you very much. We're going to move on to privileges of, continued privileges of the floor. Senator Cortese at the Majority Leader's desk with guests.

  • Dave Cortese

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. And with your permission, Senator Wahab is joining me to make very brief comments on this recognition. We want to recognize the Indo-American Community Federation, also known as IACF, which is present for its annual Unity Day. The IACF members are here with us today in the gallery and if I can ask for them to be acknowledged before we continue with some very brief comments. They are here in the gallery.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    If you'd like to stand up.

  • Dave Cortese

    Legislator

    They will be presented this resolution very shortly as we reconvene with them. But the organization is a nonprofit organization. It's based in Fremont, actually in Senator Wahab's district. Founded in 1993 by Jeevan Zutshi, it encourages Indo-Americans to work together to address issues that impact their community. The organization works to promote unity and embrace diversity through seminars, conventions, and even financial assistance.

  • Dave Cortese

    Legislator

    It is engaged in many fundraising efforts to support those kinds of initiatives and others that help local youth, people in refugee camps, and even an orphanage in India. IACF's Unity Day serves to highlight the importance of unity. This year's theme is unity and diversity with a focus on reclaiming a sense of connection. Since 2002, they've hosted an annual unity dinner which occurred last Friday night. And there they discussed youth mental health and gun violence.

  • Dave Cortese

    Legislator

    I want to thank them for all of their work and service to the community. And I want to turn the microphone over to Senator Wahab at this.

  • Aisha Wahab

    Legislator

    Thank you, Senator Cortese. You know, I just want to highlight the fact that this organization has been hosting a Unity Day dinner for years and it's incredibly important. So I'm proud to support the Indo-American Community Federation's celebration of Unity Day. When I consider this year's theme of unity and diversity, I think of all the ways the Indo-American community is integrated across the fabric of our communities.

  • Aisha Wahab

    Legislator

    From involvement in local education, youth programs, civic engagement as well as their efforts to support small businesses across the district. The Indo-American community demonstrates a level of community involvement I both respect and admire. I extend my gratitude to the Indo-American Community Federation's commitment to their community and look forward to continued collaboration and engagement with their work. Thank you.

  • Dave Cortese

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Members moving on to further privileges of the floor. Senator Skinner at the majority leader's desk.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President. Members, while the players are lining up, you may have heard references to Oakland being referred to as the City of champions because of Oakland's various NBA and World Series championships. And speaking of the NBA, we're all watching with bated breath that yesterday was a nail biter with first time California's four teams competing in the basketball champions, or championships, meaning NBA. But today we have California champions right here in the Senate's house, in the house of the people.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    And today I ask you to join me in honoring Oakland's two newest champions. The California State high school basketball championship winners, Oakland, Tex Lady Bulldogs and Oakland highs Wildcats. Now, we've got here behind me, the starting five players from each team, along with their coaches. But up in the gallery, we have more of the coaches, more of the players. So welcome them in the gallery also. And those of us, my friends here behind me on the floor, from Oakland Tech Lady Bulldogs, we have Nia Hunter.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    You can wave. Mari Somvichian, Erin Sellers, Sophia Askew Gonzalez, Jada Williams and coach Jasmine Bragg. And from the Oakland High Wildcats, we have Anthony Lacey, money Williams, Joshua Clark, Tayshan Gamble, Jamone Campbell and coach Angel Macedon. So let me tell you a little bit first about the Wildcats. Oakland High has a storied basketball history. Its most famous alumnus, Damon Lillard. And Damien. Damien, yes, Damien. Thank you for that correction. He's an all star guard now for the Portland Trailblazers.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    But this 2023 group is very, very special because it is the first Oakland High boys team to ever win a state title. Wildcats, you deserve to be very proud of your accomplishment. You had some struggles this year, but you never gave up. And that hard work paid off with a 5943 victory over Buena High of Ventura in that state championship game. Now, I'd like to quote Oakland High star player money Williams, who scored a game-high 22 points and nine rebounds in that title game.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    Money said, we did this for Oakland, for the youth. I want the youth to look at this and be like, I can do this. Don't let nobody tear you down. Stay true to yourself. Trust God and you can accomplish your goals. And Lady Bulldogs, we've welcomed you to the Capitol before because this is your third state championship. The last time you were here, four years ago, prior to the pandemic, you and the Oakland High girls team came after you both won state championships that year.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    So this is your third straight title. It's amazing achievement. The Oakland Tech seniors never lost a playoff game. You are truly the best high school girls basketball team in Oakland and in the state, and either has ever produced. And I wouldn't be surprised to see if to see many of you who are carrying on to play again next year, to be back here as state title championships again. So these student athletes, their coaches, their families, their fans, they deserve huge congratulations. Senate, join me in saying, go, Wildcats. Go, Bulldogs. Go, Oakland.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    Congratulations to the players and their coaches and the family members that are here. And if you'd like to take a picture with them, now would be a good time. One, two. Thank you very much for joining us here today. Congratulations to all of the team players.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator McGuire, want to ask Members to please take your seats. We're not finished with session yet. Senator McGuire, the floor is yours.

  • Mike McGuire

    Legislator

    Thank you so much, Madam President and Members, ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, we are so thrilled to be able to welcome Francisco Hernandez Valdez to the Senate today. Francisco, out of literally thousands of California Conservation Corps Members, has been selected as the 2022 Corps Member of the Year for the entire Golden State. Francisco is a true California success story, and I think that you will agree he is an inspiration to all of us. He's always known what he's wanted.

  • Mike McGuire

    Legislator

    Francisco came to the United States at the age of 17 in search of a better life. Like so many before him, he migrated to the United States without his parents or his siblings. He did it by himself. He's a self-starter. Since arriving, he's now put himself through school and has always focused on giving back. He's the former President of the Solano California Conservation Corps Advisory Board. He's been a leader in the Forestry Corps program.

  • Mike McGuire

    Legislator

    And now, which we are so thrilled to announce, he's about to graduate from the Santa Rosa Junior College Fire Academy this Friday and will be serving this state as a Member of the fire service. He is. Just give him a round of applause, please. Francisco is tenacious. He's dedicated, hardworking, and committed to California. And, Members, please join all of us in congratulating Francisco Hernandez Valdez on this well-deserved honor as Corpse Member of the Year.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Members, if you would like to join the awardee in the picture, you can join Senator McGuire as well. Congratulations to Jose Francisco Hernandez Valdez for his work with the Conservation Corps. Members, we're going to move on to. Messages from the Governor will be deemed read, messages from the Assembly will be deemed read. Reports of Committee will be deemed read, and amendments adopted. Members moving on to motions, resolutions, and notices.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Without objection, the Senate journals for April 172023 through April 202023 will be approved as corrected by the minute Clerk. Senator Nguyen.

  • Janet Nguyen

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President. Under motion resolution, I wish to remove SCR f5 and SCR 7 from the inactive file and place onto second reading, please.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    So ordered. Thank you, Senator Seyarto

  • Kelly Seyarto

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. I would like to remove item number five, SR 15, from the inactive file.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    So ordered. Remember, we're going to move on to consideration of the daily file, second reading file, please read.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 625 with amendments 47. With amendments 770. With amendments 67. With amendments 786. With amendments 85, with amendments eight.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Members, we're going to move on to the Senate, third reading. We'll start with file item number 31, SB 467 by Senator Portantino. Madam Secretary, please read.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 467 by Senator Portantino. An act relating to community colleges.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator Portantino, the floor is yours.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President and colleagues, today I'm presenting SB 467 which will prohibit a California community college from denying a student access to an internship or an apprenticeship training program based on their use of an individual tax identification number when applying for these programs. In the past, we've made great strides to increase access to education for undocumented students, making significant investments that incentivize completion and promote job placement.

  • Anthony Portantino

    Person

    The Faculty Association for California Community Colleges brought to our attention that some colleges have denied admission to students into certain career, technical, education, or workforce programs because of their immigration status, resulting in not being able to complete the program and secure employment. This Bill provides an important next step in correcting this inequity and ensures immigration status does not present a barrier to obtaining a higher education for all our students. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any discussion or debate on this item? Any discussion or debate saying none. Please call. This item is eligible for unanimous consent. Is there any objection? Unanimous roll call. I don't know what I said. Ayes 39. No, zero. Moving on to file item number 32, SB 486 by Senator Hurtado. She is prepared. Please read.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 486 by Senator Hurtado in accolade to interscholastic athletics.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator Hurtado, the floor is yours.

  • Melissa Hurtado

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. I rise here today to present SB 486, which requires the California Interscalastic Federation to hold all state football championship games for all divisions at comparable neutral locations. Under CIF, California currently holds 15 state football championship games for our high school football teams.

  • Melissa Hurtado

    Legislator

    However, only a select few games, those typically reserved for schools from top divisions that will bring in bigger crowds and drive up ticket revenue, were played at neutral facilities with updated fields and almost perfect field conditions which made for a memorable and positive experience for the students. The rest of the CIF state championship games were played at schools of the higher ranking team, with facility and field conditions that varied across the board.

  • Melissa Hurtado

    Legislator

    While all winning teams can equally claim to be a California State champion, the conditions under which the games were played are less than equal. SB 486 aims at providing an equitable experience for all student athletes who have earned the opportunity to compete and be forever known as a California State champion. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any discussion or debate on this item? Any discussion or debate saying none. This is eligible for unanimous roll call. Is there any objection? Saying none. Ayes, 39. No, zero. The measure is adopted. Members, we're going to move on. Okay, we'll move on to file item number 36, SB 457 by Senator Menjivar. She is prepared.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 457 by Senator Menjivar in accolade to minors.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator Menjivar, the floor is yours.

  • Caroline Menjivar

    Legislator

    Thank you, ma'am. President, Members, they arise on behalf of SB 457 looking to create a simple fix. Right now, unaccompanied homeless minors cannot access vision care. Current law allows them to get medical and dental care, but because of this missing piece, they are unable to get vision care. Again, these are only for unaccompanied homeless minors who are 15 years and older and are managing their own financial affairs.

  • Caroline Menjivar

    Legislator

    It closed the gap because at schools, they're not meeting near half the percent of, or catching near half of the percent of items when doing an eye care exam. SB 457 will make it clear that an unaccompanied homeless minor is able to consent to vision care services. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any discussion or debate on this item, Senator Ashby?

  • Angelique Ashby

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. I rise as joint author of SB 457 and thank the author for her leadership. State law already allows for youth aged 15 and older to consent to medical and dental care without their parent or Guardian's consent. SB 457 simply adds vision to the list. A child's ability to see and access regular eye exams are foundational needs that are vital to a child's learning and reading comprehension.

  • Angelique Ashby

    Legislator

    If a child cannot see and cannot consent to their own vision care, it will impact their education heavily. California has the lowest literacy rate in the nation, and we cannot allow another barrier to learning to stay on the books. For youth in our state, it's important that unaccompanied youth, and especially foster youth or youth experiencing homelessness, have the agency to consent to their own care, particularly vision care, should be no different. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any further discussion or debate? Further discussion or debate? Saying none, this is eligible for unanimous roll call. Is there any objection? Any objection? Seeing no objection. Ayes 39 no, zero. The measure is adopted. Moving on to file item number 41. Senator Laird, SB 280. He has prepared.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 280 by Senator Laird in accolading to conservatorships.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator Laird, the floor is yours.

  • John Laird

    Legislator

    Thank you very much, madam President. Senate Bill 280 will require a conservator to submit a care plan in certain instances. I've taken amendments to address a lot of the concerns. There's support on both sides. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any discussion or debate on this item? Any discussion or debate? Seeing none. Ayes 39, zero no. I guess I have to ask you if there's any objection to a unanimous roll call. First, is there any objection to unanimous roll call? Saying none. Ayes 39 no, zero. The measure is adopted. Moving on to file item number 55. Senator Jones is ready. Please read.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Bill 654 by Senator Jones in accolade to aviation.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Senator Jones, the floor is yours.

  • Brian Jones

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. Members, current law prohibits a local agency from offering a lease on an airport for longer than 50 years. Unfortunately, some counties misrepresent the law to mean that they are unable to have a lease for 50 years total. Not at a time. This Bill provides much needed clarity and will encourage new investment in our local airports. I ask for an aye vote.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Is there any discussion or debate on this item? Any discussion or debate saying none? This is also eligible for a unanimous roll call. Is there any objection to using a unanimous roll call? Saying none. Ayes 39 no, zero. The measure is adopted. Members, we are returning to privileges of the floor, and we have Senator Durazo with introductions at the majority leader's desk. Senator Durazo.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. Good afternoon. It's such a pleasure to introduce to the Senate Floor a delegation of Members from the 2022 Major League Soccer support Shield and league champion Los Angeles Football Club. Yes, we are joined today by goalkeeper Max Crippu, former player Jordan Harvey, owners Bennett Rosenthal, Brandon Beck and Peter Goober, co presidents John Thorrington and Larry Friedman, CFO and COO Stacey Johns, Executive Vice President of corporate strategy Bennett Tran, Director of communications Crystal Ryder and Senior Vice President of communications Seth Burton.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    One of the newest sport teams in Los Angeles kicking off in 2018, the LAFC has quickly captured the support and the imagination for the world's game in Los Angeles. There have been a number of football superstars whom have donned the now-famous black and gold and contributed to the already rich history of this club. Mexican superstar and club captain Carlos Vela.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Max Crepe's late game heroics in the MLS Championship match helped secure the title as he stopped a potential game winning goal for Philadelphia Union in stoppage time. Despite sustaining a major injury, he helped rally his team to win the match in an exciting penalty kick finish. Jordan Harvey, whom helped build the strong culture of the club and was pivotal to helping the club secure one of the club's first major titles, the 2019 supporters shield for having the best regular season.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    In addition to the ownership and management whom have dedicated themselves to providing a team that we can all be proud of, I do want to take a moment to highlight those who are not here, but just as important and those are the fans. The 12th man led by the famous Section 3252 who if they were here, they would have probably have the capital jumping with the same energy and passion that they provide to this football club. Jumping and chanting the whole match.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Dale, dale, dale, black and gold. Above all, with what is the first of many more titles, I want to highlight how this football club has captured the heart and the soul of a fierce and passionate, diverse fan base composed of peoples from all walks of life. They brought people together to cheer for this team unity across the diversity of our great, wonderful city.

  • María Elena Durazo

    Legislator

    Further, they are also contributing to help build the women's game by supporting their sister club, Angel City FC, which is in their second season and has us just as excited about the ongoing growth of popularity of the women's game moving forward. Overall, we are excited to be hosting them here today to show off that trophy and to celebrate their success, their contributions to our community. We wish the club much, much more success as they have just begun the 2023 season. Congratulations to our black and gold.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Members. If we can take the first picture with Senator Durazo, if the first picture can be with Senator Gerazzo, and then the second picture can be for the LA delegation, that is just they want to get in there right away. And then the third picture is the plebe. Anybody who wants to join? Okay, now anybody from the LA delegation? So if there's anyone else who would like a picture, now's your time. It okay.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    If we can get ready to return to business Members, we celebrate the black and gold and are getting back to the red carpet. Now. Moving on in the file, we're actually going to move back in the file to file item number 34, SCR 44 by Senator Caballero Senator Caballero.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Senate Concurrent Resolution 44 by Senator Caballero, relative to sexual assault.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present Senate Concurrent Resolution number 44, which declares the month of April a sexual assault awareness month and recognizes April 26 as denim Day in California. In 1998, the Supreme Court of Cassette in Italy overturned the conviction of a man who sexually assaulted an eight year old woman.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    The court determined that, quote, because the victim wore very tight jeans, she had to have helped him remove them, and by voluntarily removing the jeans, it was no longer rape, but a consensual act. Enraged by the court decision, the women in the Italian parliament launched into immediate action and protested by wearing jeans to work and called for a demonstration and a day of action.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    In opposition to this ruling, women all over the world have followed the lead of the women in the Italian parliament and designated a denim day to raise public awareness about rape and sexual assault and the lack of consent involved in those actions. This month long observation is a time to increase the awareness of sexual assault and highlight the importance of prevention and recovery to support the well being of those affected. In 202144,000 individuals received intervention services from California Rape Crisis Center. 44,000 people. Individuals.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Sexual assault and rape impact people of all racial, cultural and economic backgrounds, and moreover, all genders and age groups. Nearly one in two women and one in five men experience sexual violence other than rape during their lifetime. It is our responsibility to support all survivors by treating them with dignity, compassion and respect. Furthermore, it's crucial to hold perpetrators responsible for sexual attacks and to prevent sexual violence at every opportunity.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    For these reasons, we recognize the month of April as sexual assault Awareness Month and designate April 26, 2023 as Denim Day in California and encourage everyone to wear jeans on that day and stand in solidarity with survivors. I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you, Senator Skinner. You are recognized.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    Thank you, Madam President. Members, I rise on behalf of the Legislative Women's Caucus in support of the Senator from Mercedes resolution and as she described to you what the origins of Denim Day, which is to show solidarity to survivors of sexual assault. We know that, as she mentioned, that women, girls, gender-inclusive and everyone has endured some form of sexual assault. I don't mean each of us as individuals, I mean every demographic.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    And we are still in a circumstance where people have to worry whether they are walking to school, doing their jobs, caring for their families, or going about their daily lives, whether they will be harassed or assaulted. Rape, one form of sexual assault, is still pervasive, and it is underreported. So the number that the Senator mentioned regarding the number of people who have approached rape crisis centers is larger than the number who've reported a rape. And why? Because victims do not, by and large, report rapes.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    They do not because they feel that oftentimes they're treated dismissively by law enforcement. Their evidence, if they go to the trouble of going to a hospital and getting it collected, which is a very intrusive exam, is then not always put in the national database. So there's little to no hope to find their persecute or prosecute their rapist. And this discourages then that reporting. And yet, for those who are convicted of rape, we find often that it's an average of six or more rapes that they've committed.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    So this is essential that we create conditions for people to feel comfortable reporting their sexual assault to make sure that law enforcement takes it seriously and that the evidence is put in that national database and that sexual assault perpetrators are caught and convicted. Permission to read this is an excerpt from you asked for it by Julia Francisco Rodis. Overwhelmed, ashamed, and feeling guilty. She believed she was filthy. So I lifted her chin, reassured her she hadn't sinned, told her it wasn't your fault.

  • Nancy Skinner

    Person

    It wasn't your clothes, it wasn't your friendliness, it wasn't your response, it wasn't you. You did not ask for it. She did not ask for it. He did not ask for it. They did not ask for it. We did not ask for it. No one ever asks for it because there is never an excuse or invitation to harass, abuse, assault, or rape. And with that, I ask for your aye vote.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    Senator Rubio, you are recognized.

  • Susan Rubio

    Legislator

    Thank you, Madam President and ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, today I rise as a proud co author to SCR 44, which proclaims April 2023 as Sexual Assault Awareness Month. The National Intimate partner in Sexual Violence Survey reports that there are over 22 million survivors of rape, with 2 million of those survivors living in the State of California. As already shared, in 1998, the Italian Supreme Court overturned the conviction of a man who sexually assaulted an 18 year old young woman because she wore tight jeans.

  • Susan Rubio

    Legislator

    It is never okay to blame a victim, and clothing is never an invitation to sexually assault anyone. Nations and states throughout the world have followed the lead of the Italian parliament by designing their own denim day to raise public awareness about rape and sexual assault. And I'm glad California continues to highlight this issue and supports victims. This resolution encourages all Californians to wear jeans on Denim Day, which helps communicate the message that there is no excuse for and never an invitation to commit rape.

  • Susan Rubio

    Legislator

    Rape and sexual assault impacts everyone, not just the person assaulted, but their families as well. Harmful attitudes about rape and sexual assault allowed these crimes to persist and forced survivors to be revictimized through victim blaming attitudes. Denim Day is an opportunity for people to wear jeans for a purpose, to support survivors and educate themselves about the different forms of sexual assault. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    Thank you. Seeing no other Members wishing to be recognized, Senator Caballero, you may close.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Thank you very much to my colleagues who joined in making a statement, and I appreciate your support and ask for your aye vote today.

  • Anna Caballero

    Legislator

    Thank you very much. This is eligible for unanimous roll call if there are no objections. Seeing none, 39 to zero. Measure confirmed. That concludes Senate third reading. Moving on now to Committee announcements. Senator Bradford, you are recognized.

  • Steven Bradford

    Person

    Thank you. Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications. Will meet in room 1200 at three, let's say 3:40.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    Senator Wiener?

  • Scott Wiener

    Legislator

    The Senate Committee on Housing will meet in room 2200, also at 3:40.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    Senator Alvarado-Gil.

  • Marie Alvarado-Gil

    Legislator

    Human Services Committee will be meeting in room 2100 at 3:40. Actually, less than 3 hours. 2 hours and a half. Yeah.

  • Susan Talamantes Eggman

    Person

    If there is no other business. Senator Atkins? The desk is clear.

  • Toni Atkins

    Person

    Madam President. Thanks so much. Our next floor session, colleagues, will be this Thursday, April 272023 at 09:00 a.m. The Senate will be in recess until 330, at which time the adjournment motion will be made. We will reconvene Thursday, April 27, at 09:00 a.m.

Currently Discussing

No Bills Identified