Assembly Floor
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
The Assembly is now in session. Well, the Assembly Member Wallace notices the absence of a quorum. Therefore, the sergeant arms will prepare the chamber and bring in the absent Members. Clerk will call the roll.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members of quorum is present. We ask our guests and visitors in the rear of the chamber and in the gallery to please stand for today's prayer in our last day of session. Will you all join me in giving a very warm acknowledgment to the Reverend Oshita for all the guidance that they have given us this year? Reverend Oshita.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
Please join me in a moment of reflection. With our last floor session ending before the autumn winter holiday season, I'd like to share this reflection. From Thanksgiving in November to New Year's in January, we enjoy a very special family time of year. During those months, families will often come together again and again.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
A few years ago, a teenage boy sadly said to me, after losing his grandmother, I attended our holiday family gatherings as if they were obligations, maybe even a chore. But after losing grandma, I know that our family gatherings will never be the same.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
I said to him, you honor your grandmother with your tears, for they are tears of love, and she has earned them. And now you, at your young age. You know what we all will learn again and again in living life? It is this. If there is someone who has shown us kindness, let us thank them now.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
If there is someone we love, let us hold them close now. And let us not take for granted even one opportunity to be with those whose lives give meaning to our own. For we enjoy each day of life because of them.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
Through the coming autumn winter holiday, let us remember that we are able to live each day because of the loving support and sacrifice of so many others. And during the coming autumn winter holiday season, as we gather with family again and again, let us not take for granted the people whose lives give meaning to our own.
- Reverend Bob Oshita
Person
Please keep safe and well until we meet again. And let us live together with kindness and gratitude beyond words.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We ask our guests and visitors to remain standing and join us in the flag salute. Assemblymember Ahrens will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
Please join me in saluting our nation's flag. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Join me in welcoming a Happy birthday for Mr. Ahrens. Happy birthday, Assembly Member Ahrens to our guests and visitors today. State law prohibits persons in the gallery from interfering with legislative proceedings or disrupting the orderly conduct of a physician official business. Persons disrupting legislative proceedings are subject to removal, arrest or other appropriate legal remedies. Reading of the previous day's Journal Assembly.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Okay, Majority Leader Aguiar Curry moves and Mr. Flora seconds that the reading of the previous day's journal be dispensed with. Members, let's give a big thanks to Mr. David Bowman. Our reading cler Presentations and petitions. There are none. Introduction and reference of bills will be deferred. Reports of committees will be deemed read and amendments deemed adopted.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Messages from the Governor? There are none. Messages from the Senate? There are none. Moving to motions and resolutions. There are no absences today. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized for your procedural motions.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Good afternoon. I request unanimous consent to suspend Assembly Rule 45.5 to allow Assembly Member Mayor Suchi to speak on an adjournment in Memory today
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
I request unanimous consent to suspend Assembly rule 118A to allow Assembly Members Ahrens, Boerner and Bonta to have guests at the rear of the chamber and for Assemblymember Ramos to have a guest seated At his desk.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There are messages from the Senate for Assembly bills passed by by the Senate yesterday. There is a supplemental file number one with these items so the authors may take them up to today. For purposes of concurring in Senate amendments. I request unanimous consent that we suspend the rules to take up these items that.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
I request unanimous consent to suspend joint rule 62A, the file notice requirement to allow the following committees to meet today upon the call of the chairs Government Organization Committee to hear AB 1246 Hoover and Water, Parks and Wildlife Committee to hear AB 915, Petri Nouris.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker, I move that AB 1207 be moved immediately to the inactive file.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assemblymember DeMaio, would you mind holding back on your motion until we finish with the majority leader's motions? I will recognize you immediately thereafter, Madam majority leader, without objection, such shall be the order. Please continue.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
At the request of the author, please move file item 53 SB542 Limon to the inactive file.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will note just before I recognize you, Mr. Demaio, we have our Attorney General and more importantly former Assembly Member Rob Bonta has joined us here. Assemblymember Demaio, you were recognized.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker, I move that. AB 1207 be moved immediately to the inactive file. Is there a second?
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Seconded by Mr. Wallace. Motion by DeMaio. Seconded by Mr. Wallace. This is a non debatable motion. Clerk will open the roll. Majority leader is asking for a no vote. Mr. DeMaio is asking for an aye vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Majority leader is asking for a no vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Mr. DeMaio is asking for an aye vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Eyes 13, noes 45. The motion fail. Okay, before we begin, let's do a quick run of show for today. We're going to recess for dinner for about an hour.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's. That's roughly 5:15pm during that time we will remain under call for committees to meet. Dinner will be provided. Democratic caucus will be in the Members lounge. Republican caucus will be in the Willie Brown conference room.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
When we reconvene at 6:15 please come back and be ready to work sometime between 10 and 11pm and let's all have a great work day. It okay, we are going to sprinkle in guest introductions as they are ready. None are ready at this time. Moving to business on the daily file. Second reading file items 1 through 3. Clerk will read
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
All bills will be deemed read. All amendments will be deemed adopted. Continuing on business on the daily file we will pass and retain on file items 4 and 19 Members, please be at your desk, be ready to present and vote on measures. We're going to start moving.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We're going to start with the Senate third reading file item number 40. That's SB855 by the Committee on Military and Veterans affairs by Assemblymember Schiava.
- Committee Secretary
Person
The Senate Bill 855 by the Senate Committee on Military and Veterans Affairs, an act relating to armories.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. Today I rise to present SB 855, a Senate Military and Veteran Affairs Committee bill that authorizes the Director of the Department of General Services with the approval of the Adjutant General of the California Military Department to transfer, exchange, or sell seven armory properties.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
California has approximately 86 active armory sites and the Military Department has determined that six armory properties are no longer fit for the assembly or training of National Guard soldiers and requires legislative approval for their sale.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
Selling armory properties generates vital revenue for the Armory Fund and supports the state in its duty to house National Guard and maintain mission operational facilities for California's Army National Guard and provides benefits to California's communities as well. Respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Schiavo. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61, noes zero. The measure passes. We are going to skip to file item number 42. That's SB 57 by Senator Padilla, presented by Assembly Member Hart.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 57 by Senator Padilla and others, an act relating to electricity.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present Senate Bill 57 on behalf of Senator Padilla to create the Ratepayer and Technological Innovation Protection Act. California is undergoing an AI revolution powered by massive data centers. These facilities consume large amounts of energy and water, strain our electrical grid, and require significant infrastructure upgrades.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
The Department of Energy has reported that data centers are expected to consume 12% of total US electricity by 2028. Many analysts, however, are warning that this rapid build out of data centers may outpace demand, with some centers closing early or using less energy than expected.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
When data centers shut down before contract terms end, ratepayers are left to absorb the significant cost of transmission and interconnection. SB 57 will allow the CPUC to study these risks and ensure that we understand the true impacts of data centers on California ratepayers. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Hart. Assembly Member Jeff Gonzalez, you are recognized.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in opposition to SB 57. I understand what my colleague is going with, but unfortunately in my district, we are depending on data centers to come in, and these obstacles prevent that from happening. With a 20% unemployment rate, we need data centers in. And just another obstacle for California businesses is not what we need today. So with that, I rise in opposition.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gonzalez. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Hart, do you wish to close?
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
This legislation is a study bill to give us the information we need to have to properly evaluate the impacts of the data centers. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Hart. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 46, noes 14. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, if I could draw your attention to the rear of the chamber. Please join me in recognizing Assemblymember Aarons Capitol intern and district staff in the rear of the chamber. Thank you for all of your service and hard work over this legislative session. Welcome to the California Assembly Members. Another guest introduction. Very important one.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
On behalf of our Majority Leader, please join me in recognizing Members of Silver Wings International in the gallery. Please stand. Silver Wings was founded in 1987 by a group of TWA flight attendants to celebrate the pride and dignity of their chosen career. Thank you for all of your work over the years. Welcome to the California Assembly.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Welcome it. Okay, if I could have a clear path to the end of the chamber. Please rear the chamber, Ms. Addis. Members, Assemblymember Borner would like to recognize her Capitol intern, Daphne in the rear of the chamber for her service the past few weeks. Your work has been integral to getting legislation to the governor's desk.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Daphne. Welcome to the California Assembly. It Members, we are going to be taking up file item 74. File item 74. That's SB614 by Senator Stern. Presented by Assemblymember Petrie Norris.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 614 by Senator Stern and others, an act relating to public resources.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise today to present SB 614 on behalf of our colleague, Senator Stern. This measure ensures that California can meet its climate goals by supporting the safe transport of captured carbon by pipelines. Carbon capture, utilization, and sequestration technologies are a vital part of our strategy to decarbonize California's economy.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Recognizing the importance of these technologies, California has set ambitious carbon removal goals. 20 million metric tons by 2030 and 100 million metric tons by 2045. And in 2022, this Legislature passed SB 905 to establish a foundation to enable carbon capture in California. This bill will enable carbon capture to happen in the State of California by, as I said, supporting the safe transport of captured carbon by pipelines.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
This measure will also leverage billions of dollars in federal support to meet California's climate goals and create thousands of high road green jobs. I respectfully ask for your aye vote. And Mr. Speaker, I respectfully ask that the measure for immediate transmittal to the Senate of this measure. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Petrie-Norris. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58, noes 0. The measure passes, immediate transmittal to the Senate. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There is a message from the Senate at the desk. I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow Assembly Member Gabriel to take up AB 144 and AB 149 without reference to file for the purpose of concurrence in Senate amendments.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. Seconded by Assembly Member Ortega. Assembly Member Flora, you are recognized.
- Heath Flora
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Withhold consent and ask for a roll call vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Flora. Members, this motion is not debatable. It takes 41 votes. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Majority Leader is asking for an aye vote. Mr. Flora is asking for a no vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 45, noes 17. The motion carries.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Members. Without reference to file AB 144 by the Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, presented by Assembly Member Gabriel. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 144 by the Committee on Budget, an act relating to health and making an appropriation therefore to take effect immediately. Bill related to the budget.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, I'm pleased to present AB 144, our healthcare trailer bill. This measure is part of a broader package responding directly to the harmful federal actions that have threatened public health and patient care.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
This bill addresses the ongoing turmoil at the CDC to ensure that we safeguard public health in California. And to do so, it shifts responsibility for immunization and preventive healthcare recommendations to the California Department of Public Health, reducing our reliance on uncertain and potentially dangerous federal guidelines.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
The bill also safeguards critical health care services under attack by the federal government by continuing funding for reproductive health providers and protecting existing gender affirming health care benefits. In addition, SB 144 includes key health care provisions.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Such as preparing California's medical infrastructure to support the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games in Los Angeles. I want to thank our Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health for their hard work and respectfully request an aye vote on AB 144.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gabriel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 50, noes 15. The measure passes. Without objection, immediate transmittal to the Governor. Without reference to file, AB 149 by the Committee on Budget, presented by Assembly Member Gabriel.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 140 by the Committee on Budget and accoladed the public resources making an appropriation, therefore to take effect immediately be related to the budget.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I'm pleased to present AB124, our resources trailer bill.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Major components of this bill include technical changes to implement Proposition for bond funding, streamlining measures for hosting the upcoming 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games, establishing the regional farm worker equipment and cooperative resource assistance program, and taking decisive action to present the state's water supply by stopping the spread of invasive golden mussels.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
To carry that work forward, I respectfully ask your Aye vote on AB149. Oh, wrong bill.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, decorum, please. Decorum, please. I actually mean it. Decorum, please. Tell me, Member Dixon, you are recognized Member. Members.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
May I Clarify, is this SB or AB149? Are they one in the. I don't have it on my Ipad.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
It is not. Okay. AB149. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 50, Noes 12. Without objection. Immediate transmittal to the Governor. Okay. Folks, we are going to start from the top. We're going to go to concurrence and Senate amendments. We have already passed and retained on file item four. We're going to pass and retain them. File item five.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
File item six. File item seven. That brings us to file item number eight. That's AB7 by Assembly Member Bryan.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 7 by Assembly Member Bryan and others, an act relating to post-secondary education.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. AB 7 is back from the Senate on concurrence amendments. This is part of the California Legislative Black Caucus's repair package this year. For 13 generations in this country, people who were enslaved were prevented from reading and writing.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In fact, if you learn to read and write, you could be mutilated, put to death, beaten. If you taught another slave how to read and write, 39 lashes. Following emancipation, we prevented the descendants of those who were enslaved from also learning to read and write.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
We barred access to institutions of higher learning while simultaneously asking them to build the institutions of higher learning. Georgetown University is a perfect example of a university built by slaves who were unable to go there. The manifestations of this legacy are evident in society today.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And it's shameful. Because right now, while we like to pretend access to institutions of higher learning is fair and merit based and equal, we know that it is not. In fact, all across this country, legacy admissions have been and continue to be commonplace. They were commonplace here in California until just last year.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And by legacy admissions I mean if you are the relative or the descendant of somebody who is rich or powerful or well connected or an alumni of one of these illustrious institutions, you got priority consideration for admittance. here in California, we canceled legacy admissions last year by saying, hey, if you participate in legacy admissions, you can no longer receive Cal Grants.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And one of our private universities said, that's cool, we'll pass on the Cal Grants. That's how powerful legacy admissions into our institutions of higher learning have been. That's how powerful the economic driver of receiving an advanced degree in a California institution could be. But there's a legacy that we don't ever acknowledge in education. And that is the legacy I spoke about a minute ago.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
That is the legacy of exclusion, of harm. And today we're going to speak about it. AB 7 is a bill that would allow for California institutions of higher learning to consider whether somebody is the descendant of somebody who was enslaved in this country during their admissions process. As was articulated very clearly in the Senate Judiciary analysis, this bill has no constitutional concerns.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In fact, it codifies the authority many believe that the universities in California already have. It bolsters that authority by making it very clear that the state legislature and the Governor also believe that this is the authority of the universities. And it's important now more than ever, as the President of the United States is weaponizing our institutions of higher learning.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In fact, just before he entered office, he talked about reparations for white students in colleges because there were so many people of color at these universities. This is an important moment in our history. It's an important moment in California. And on behalf of the entire California Legislative Black Caucus, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bryan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 48, noes 14. Senate amendments are concurred in. Assembly Member Dixon, you are recognized for your parliamentary inquiry.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I appreciate it. Just wanted to make a comment on AB149.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assembly Member Dixon. Without objection. The Chair mistakenly did not recognize Assembly Member Dixon on the budget debate. She had some comments to make. Without objection, please make your parliamentary inquiry.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
I appreciate that. Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I was going to rise today to speak in opposition to SB or AB 149, and it's just an example. I'm frustrated by this last minute budget process, which is shared by many of my colleagues and the public.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
While I plan to vote no, which I did vote no, on this budget bill, it does contain provisions that I strongly support, strongly support and have been vocal during this legislative session. One such provision is critical funding to combat the invasive golden mussel infestations that are threatening both our water systems and natural aquatic ecosystems alike.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
I joined many legislators earlier this year on a bipartisan letter requesting this exact funding to address this issue affecting California's waterways. However, this bill, like many of the budget bills that we will discuss and vote on today, contains additional... All right. Okay, thank you. Contains additional provisions that make it completely untenable to support.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
This is an issue that regularly arises during our budget process. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Where bills are negotiated and agreed upon behind closed doors. What do they say? All right. The negotiated language will then contain numerous provisions, some that garner broad bipartisan support and others that are completely unsupportable.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
For example, this budget bill includes an arbitrary mandate increasing minimum fees on boat owners for invasive mussel prevention this mandate will increase fees on boaters by 50% next year and will also raise the total cap on these fees by over 100%. I mean, that's huge increase.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
As a representative of one of the most beautiful coastal districts in California, and I would say the nation, these types of fee increases are a non starter for boaters in my district and throughout the entire state. This is especially true when no rationale has been offered to support the necessity or the size of these fee increases increases.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
Then the bill includes broad CEQA exemptions for the Olympic Games. Obviously that's important to all of us. While these are all important issues in this bill, I simply cannot support the entire bill. But I cannot strip out or do any line item rejection.
- Diane Dixon
Legislator
While I'm just one voice, I believe many of my colleagues on both sides of the aisle would agree that we should do a better job of separating issues rather than voting on omnibus style bills that try to corner legislators into voting for legislation they would never support as a single issue bill. So Members, I would have urged you to oppose this measure. But thank you very much, Mr. Speaker and Members, for indulging me. I would have voted no and I did. So thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you for your point of inquiry. Appreciate it. Members, we're continuing on with file item number nine. That's AB 1400 by Assembly Member Soria. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1400 by Assembly Member Soria and others, an act relating to post-secondary education.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I'm excited that AB 1400 is back on concurrence. This bill establishes a pilot program for allowing community colleges to create nursing and bachelor degree programs in 10 college districts. Senate amendments added co-authors and reduce our number of participating districts from 15 to 10. This is my number one priority bill and the second time introducing this bill. I appreciate the bipartisan support it has received, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Soria. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 10, AB 460 by Assembly Member Chen.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 460 by Assembly Member Chen an act relating to the public health.
- Phillip Chen
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. This bill is back on concurrence. The changes are technical in nature. I respectfully ask for Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Chen. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We'll pass and retain on file items 11, 12, 13, 14, 15. File item number 16 is AB 770 by Assemblymember Mark Gonzalez. Members, this is a 54 vote Bill. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 770 by Assemblymember Mark Gonzalez and others an act relating to outdoor advertising declaring the urgency to take effect immediately.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I am pleased to present AB770, which is back on concurrence. A Bill that I wanted when I was a toddler. This Bill would build upon existing law and authorize the City of Los Angeles to establish a flexible signage framework at Los Angeles Convention Center.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
This framework will allow the city to unlock a critical revenue stream to support the long planned renovation modernization of the convention center. A key revenue for 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games. This Bill has received bipartisan support. Thank you and respectfully ask your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Gonzalez. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61, Noes 0 on the urgency. Ayes 61 Noes 0, on the measure.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 17. That's AB 831 by Assembly Member Valencia. Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 831 by Assembly Member Valencia, an act relating to gambling.
- Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Buenas tardes, Members. AB 831 is back on concurrence. A very important bill to me personally. Respectfully ask for a yes vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Valencia. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Aye 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Assembly Member Flora, you are recognized, sir.
- Heath Flora
Legislator
There's a sergeant on this floor today who serves us all the time who's talking to the chief. But today is Harrison Durreau's birthday. So I just want to go ahead. And say happy birthday, Harrison.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Your point is well taken. Members, we are going to the supplemental concurrence file. Supplemental file 1 concurrence and Senate amendments we're going to pass temporarily on File item number 102. File item number 103. That's AB 91 by Assemblymember Harabedian. The Clerk will read
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 91 by Assembly Member Harbidian and others an act relating to state and local government.
- John Harabedian
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB91 is back on concurrence. It's a support support Bill. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That is how we do it. Thank you Assemblymember Harabedian. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 64. Noes 0 Senate.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Amendments are concurred in. We're going to go back. We're going to go back. One Bill. File item number 102. That's AB56 by Assemblymember Bauer Cahan.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 56 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan and others an act relating to social media platforms.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 56 is a bill that will provide for California's children a warning label on social media that will allow them to understand the mental health impacts it has on them when they use use it for an extended period of time. Amendments in the Senate limit the bill to children only.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
With that I respectfully ask for your Aye vote it has bipartisan support.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 47, Noes 5. Senate amendments are concurred in file item number 104. That's A.B.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
245 by Assemblymember Gipson. Members, this is a 54 vote bill.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 245 by Assembly Member Gipson, an act relating to taxation and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker and Members. Assembly Bill 245 is back. This bill received support support. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gipson. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to Vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61. Excuse me. Ayes 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 105.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 253 by Assemblymember Ward. Members this is a 54 vote Bill. Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 253 by Assembly Member Ward and others an act relating to housing and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I'm pleased to present back on concurrence AB 253. Senate amendments address implementation and liability concerns for local governments and strengthen qualification requirements for those eligible to conduct building Plan reviews under AB253.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
I want to acknowledge the work that was done by our colleague from Fullerton who's my joint author on the Bill. She introduced AB 2433 last year and got the ball rolling starting the conversation on this important issue.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
And of course, for the support and joint authorship of Mr. Speaker, who helped to expedite not just this, but a variety of bills that are helping us to address housing affordability this session.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
Colleagues, this Bill has received broad bipartisan support and will help ensure timely plan checking, significantly addressing a major bottleneck in housing production, making sure that California can build homes faster and thus more affordably. I respectfully request your aye vote on concurrence.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Ward. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. It's Clerk will close the roll tally the vote Ayes 54. Noes 0. Senate Amendments are concurred in file item 106. AB 265 by Assembly Member Caloza.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 265 by Assembly Member Caloza and others an act relating to economic recovery.
- Jessica Caloza
Legislator
Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. AB 265 is back from the Senate for concurrence. AB 265 establishes a fund upon appropriation to help small businesses recover and rebuild after a disaster. Amendments in the Senate were narrow to the scope of small businesses. This Bill has received bipartisan unanimous support in the Legislature. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Caloza. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 62, Noes 0. Senate.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Amendments are concurred in. File item 107 is AB 301 by Assembly Member Schiavo. Members, this is a 54 vote bill. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 301 by Assembly Member Schiavo and others, an act relating to housing and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediate.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I am grateful to present AB 301. We are facing a severe housing crisis and it's imperative that we take decisive action to streamline the process of delivering an adequate supply of homes. The devastation from the Eaton, Palisades, and Hughes Fire demand swift reconstruction, fueling economic growth, revitalizing neighborhoods, and restoring stability.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
This bill, AB 301, establishes clear, consistent timelines ensuring that the state agencies adhere to the same permitting deadlines as local jurisdictions. There were technical amendments taken in the Senate for clarification, and the committee's fiscal analysis indicates that the costs associated with the legislation are minor and absorbable. This bill has no no votes, has passed unanimously, and I am proud to have the Speaker as a co-author. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Schiavo. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 108.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 325 by Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry and others, an act relating to business regulations.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 325 is back on concurrence. And I'd like to thank my legislative aide, Loyal Terry, for his heart and soul that he's put into this bill. This bill updates California's antitrust laws to make sure that they address modern tools for illegal price fixing pricing. Senate amendments strengthen the definition of common pricing algorithm to address concerns raised in Senate Judiciary. As amended, CalChamber has removed this bill from its cost driver list. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 44, noes 15. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We will pass and retain on File item number 109. File item 110. That's AB 357 by Assemblymember Alvarez. Clerk will read
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 357 by Assembly Member Alvarez an act relating to coastal resources.
- David Alvarez
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. AB357 is back on concurrence from the Senate. Appreciate your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Alvarez. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 66 Noes 0 Senate Amendments are concurrent, it. File item number 110. Excuse me. 111.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 400 by Assembly Member Pacheco. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 400 by Assembly Member Pacheco and others an accolade to the Commission on Peace Officer standards and Training.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
Thank you and good afternoon. Mr. Speaker and Members. Today I rise to present Assembly Bill 400 which is back for concurrence. Amendments require posts to study police canine use and provide recommendations to the Legislature by July 1st, 2028 this bill has received bipartisan support and I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Pacheco. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, can I draw your attention to the rear of the chamber? Will you please join me in recognizing Assembly bond? Assemblymember Bontus CLCA fellow in the rear of the chamber. Thank you for all your hard work, your service over this last legislative session and welcome to the California Assembly. File item number 112.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 445 by Assembly Member Aguiar Curry an act relating to alcoholic beverages.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 445 is back at concurrence. Senate amendments resolved chapter and conflicts. I want to thank my fellow who's worked on this as well as many other bills this year. Sophia Lucio, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes Ayes 63 Noes 0, Senate Amendments are concurred in file item number 113.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 451 by Assemblymember Petrie Norris. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 451 by Assembly Member Petrie Norris an act relating to law enforcement.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, AB451 is back from the Senate on concurrence. This Bill has received bipartisan support and no no votes. I respectfully ask for your aye vote signal for the debate.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 65. Noes 0 Senate amendments are concurred in item number 114, AB 462 by Assembly Member Lowenthal.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 462 by Assembly Member Lowenthal and others, an act relating to land use and declaring thereof to effect immediately.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. AB 462 is back for concurrence. Amendments that were taken in the Senate address concerns raised by groups in opposition, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 115 by Assembly Member Gabriel, AB 468.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 468 by Assembly Member Gabriel and others, an act relating to crimes.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Good afternoon, Madam Speaker and colleagues. I rise to present AB 468, which is back on concurrence. Amendments taken in the Senate made passage of this bill contingent on the passage of SB 571, creating a bicameral bipartisan package of legislation to provide better tools to protect communities during fires and other natural disasters.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
This legislation enjoys bipartisan support and is backed by a broad statewide coalition that includes the California Professional Firefighters, the fire chiefs, the fire districts, the cities of Los Angeles, the mayors of San Francisco, San Diego, and Sacramento, and the League of California Cities. Thank you, and respectfully request your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gabriel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Ayes 58, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 116. That's AB 476 by Assembly Member Mark González.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 476 by Assembly Member Mark Gonzalez and others an act relating to metal theft.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. AB 630 is back on concurrence. The Bill seeks to aid local governments in addressing the complicated issue of inoperable RVs that often present significant public health and safety risk.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
The sentiments are technical in nature, limits the Bill to LA and Alameda County, expands the existing notification requirements and provides towing and storage fee relief for RVs that are wrongfully impounded. This Bill has received bipartisan support. Thank you and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Gonzalez. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 63 Noes 0 Senate amendments are concurred in file item number 117.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly 478 by Assembly Member Zbur and others, an act relating to local government.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 478 is back on concurrence. This bill is rooted in compassion, common sense, and real experience. The bill has enjoyed bipartisan support throughout its journey, reflecting our shared belief that, when disaster strikes, no one should have to choose between their own safety and their pet's survival.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This bill will ensure that pets are accounted for during emergencies and and that cities and counties develop clear procedures in advance to support pet owners during evacuations. I want to thank our sponsors, Social Compassion in Legislation, for their unwavering commitment and hard work on this bill. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Zbur. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 65, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 118. That's AB 562 by Assembly Member Solache. Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 562 by Assembly Member Solache and others an act relating to foster care.
- José Solache
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Members AB562 is back in concurrence. It passed out of the Senate on consent and has received unanimous support so far. The Bill seeks to increase kinship placemen rates for our state's foster youth. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Solache. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61 Noes 0 Senate Amendments are concurred in. We will pass temporarily on file item 119.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We're passed and retained on file item 120. File item 121. That's AB 670 by Assemblymember Quirk-Silva. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 670 by Assembly Member Quirk-Silva an act relating to housing.
- Sharon Quirk-Silva
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. AB 670 is back on concurrence. AB 670 strengthens housing stability for low income renters and promotes affordable housing preservation. This Bill has a support support position and no opposition. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Quirk Silva. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58 Noes 0 Senate Amendments are concurred in file item 122.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 726 by Assembly Member Ávila Farías. Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 726 by Assembly Member Ávila Farías, an act relating to land use.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 726 is back on concurrence. Amendments made by the Senate address chaptering issues. This bill has no opposition, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Ávila Farías. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 64, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. We'll pass temporarily on file item 123.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We're going to get to file item 124. That's AB 841 by Assemblymember Patel. The Clerk will read
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 841 by Assemblymember Patel and others an act relating to the state fire marshal.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 841 is back on concurrence. It received unanimous support on both the Assembly and Senate floors. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Patel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61 Noes 0 Senate Amendments are concurred in file item 125.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 849 by Assembly Member Soria and others an act relating to health providers.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members. ABA 49 is back in concurrence. I respect. I really ask for your Aye vote and I appreciate the bipartisan support.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Soria. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 60, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in file item 126. That's AB 853 by Assemblymember Wicks.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 853 by Assembly Member Wicks and others an act relating to artificial intelligence.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members AB853 is back on concurrence. Has bipartisan support. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wicks. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 45, Noes 4 Senate Amendments are concurred in file.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
File item 127 is AB 896 by Assembly Member Elhawary. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 896 by Assembly Member Elhawary and others, an act relating to child welfare services.
- Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise today to present AB 896, which is back on concurrence. This bill has no opposition and now enjoys a support support recommendation. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Elhawary. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Members, we're going to go backwards. We're going to go backwards. File item 119. File item 119. That's AB 607 by our Assistant Speaker Pro Tem Rodriguez.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 607 by Assembly Member Celeste Rodriguez, an act relating to public social services.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, AB 607 is back on concurrence. Senate amendments for technical assistance and clarifying language. This bill supports services to improve family health and well being. It has received strong bipartisan support. I respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Rodriguez. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 70, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. We have already dispensed with 121 and 122. That gets us to file item 123, also by our Assistant Speaker Pro Tem, AB 799.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 799 by Assembly Member Celeste Rodriguez an act relating to prisons.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you. Members. AB77 is back on concurrence. This Bill ensures that families who lose a loved one participating in the California Conservation Camp receive a survivor's death benefit. AB799 is proud to be one of the measures of the firefighting to freedom Bill package. Senate amendments were technical assistance from the Department and this Bill received strong bipartisan support. I respectfully request your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Rodriguez. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll tally the votes. Ayes 68. Nose 0. Senate Amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We have already dispensed with file items 124 through 127. We're going to pass and retain on file item 128. File item 129 is AB969, also by our Assembly Speaker Pro Tem.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 969 by Assembly Member Celeste Rodriguez and others and accolade the CalWORKS.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB969.9 is back on concurrence. Senate amendments include technical assistance and cost saving amendments to align implementation with automation of the department's program. AB969 ensures that domestic violence survivors have the support they need to rebuild their lives. This bill is support. Support. And I respectfully request your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Rodriguez. I'll debate having cease. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. It's getting awfully chatty in here. It's beginning to sound like a slumber party. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 66 Noes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Glad everyone's paying attention. I'm getting sleepy up here. Decorum, please. It's a hat trick. We call that a hat trick. File item number 130. That's AB 979 by Assembly Member Irwin. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 979 by Assembly Member Irwin and others, an act relating to technology.
- Jacqui Irwin
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 979, which is back on concurrence, directs California to develop its own AI cybersecurity playbook. Senate amendments give more time for development. This bill has enjoyed unanimous bipartisan support. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Irwin. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 63, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 131. That's AB 986 by Assembly Member Muratsuchi.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 986 by Assembly Member Muratsuchi and others, an act relating to emergency services.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. When I was a toddler, I used to complain about people leaving California. But then someone started talking crap about Newsom, and so I decided to introduce AB 986, which is a common sense proposal to add landslides to the list of conditions that may constitute a state of emergency. Bipartisan support. No opposition. No no votes. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Muratsuchi. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 63, noes 1. Senate amendments are concurred in. We will pass and retain on file item 132. File item number 133.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1007 by Assembly Member Blanca Rubio an act relating to land use.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise to present AB1007 back in concurrence, which streamlines the permitting process for housing projects by reducing the time it takes for responsible agencies to act on completed housing permit applications from 90 days to 45 days.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
AB1007 is part of the fast track housing Bill package and is one of many several proposed solutions to build more housing in California with unnecessary delays. Amendments exempt two types of permits under the state water resources board jurisdiction from the 45 day timeline and instead retains the current 90 day timeline. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Rubio. Assembly Member Solache, you are recognized.
- José Solache
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I really wanted to oppose this Bill but I reconsider and I will be supporting it today. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Solache. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61, Noes 0, Senate Amendments are concurred in file item 134.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 1009, also by Assembly Member Rubio. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1009 by Assembly Member Blanca Rubio, an act relating to teacher credentialing.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members, for allowing me to present AB 1009, which is back for concurrence. This bill will authorize occupational and physical therapists to obtain an administrative service credential, allowing qualified personnel an opportunity to move into administrative roles and share their unique expertise at a leadership level within our schools.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Amendments taken in the Senate were at the direction of the administration and the State Board of Education and are technical in nature. AB 1009 has a joint bipartisan unanimous support, which I hope to see continue as we send this bill to the governor's desk. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Rubio. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Aye 65, noes zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item number 135.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's AB 1032 by Assembly Member Harabedian. Members, this is a 54 vote bill. Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1032 by Assembly Member Harabedian and others, an act relating to health care coverage and declaring the urgency thereof to effect immediately.
- John Harabedian
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 1032 is back on concurrence. It is a vital lifeline with bipartisan support. It ensures that wildfire victims get the mental health care that they deserve. I would like to thank the Speaker for his partnership on this bill. I would like to thank his staff who made it possible for it to get here. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Harabedian. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 65, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 136. That's AB 1089 by Assembly Member Carrillo.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1089 by Assemblymember Carrillo an act relating to the Western Joshua Tree.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I rise today to present AB 1089 which is back on concurrence. The Senate amendments have removed opposition and this district Bill has received bipartisan support. I respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Carrillo. Debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 64 Noes 0 Senate Amendments are concurred in file item number 137. That's AB 1181 by Assemblymember Haney.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assembly Bill 1181 by Assemblymember Haney and others an act relating to employment.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Thank you speaker. Members AB 1181 is back for concurrence which will protect our firefighters from cancer. By ensuring their gear will be free of cancer causing chemicals. The bill has received unanimous bipartisan support. And I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you assemblymember Haney. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes Ayes 64 no 0. Senate amendments are concurred in going to pass and retain on file item 138.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
File item 139 has been dispensed with. File item number 140. That's AB 1263 by Assembly Member Gipson. Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1263 by Assembly Member Gipson and others, an act relating to firearms.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Members, Assembly Bill 1263 aims to establish a ratio safety measure to address emerging threats from the ghost gun industry. Amendments have been made in the Senate to allow... Assembly 1263 is back on for concurrence. Respectfully ask for an aye vote on 1263.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gipson. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 50, noes 11. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 141. That's AB 1264 by Assembly Member Gabriel.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1264 by Assembly Member Gabriel and others an accolade to people nutrition.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much Mr. Speaker and colleagues. I'm pleased today to present AB 1264, the Real Food Healthy Kids act which is back on concurrence. Colleagues, this bill would create a first in the nation definition of ultra processed foods and help us to face ultra processed foods out of school meals in California by 2035.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want to express my gratitude to colleagues, particularly those of you that represent agricultural interests, for coming and working with us on the bill.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I'm proud to say that with a lot of hard work we have crafted a definition that has moved much of opposition, agricultural stakeholders and others into support on this measure so that we can make sure that we are getting more healthy food and healthy nutritious California grown foods into our schools.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I'm also very proud that this measure is supported by public health advocates, teachers, doctors, nurses, farmers and chefs and passed the Senate yesterday with a bipartisan vote of 40 to 0. With that I want to thank you all and respectfully request your Aye vote on AB 1264.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Gabriel. Members, can I have decorum please? We lower our voices please. Thank you so much somebody. Member Macedo, you are recognized.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I just want to thank the author that I've spoken to many agriculture groups and oftentimes AG voice, AG's voice does not feel heard on this floor. So the fact that you listened and now this is a great bill that bipartisan I'm really excited to send to the Governor's desk.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
I just want to thank you. This is truly a model of how we should work in a bipartisan fashion and make sure that AG's voices is heard. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Macedo. Assemblymember Gallagher, you are recognized.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Yes, thank you Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise as a co author of this legislation and really enjoyed working with the authority on this important issue.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And it is this that we do have an epidemic in our country, that our kids have some of the highest rates of diabetes, they are not healthy and we need to do things in our policy to ensure that our kids are eating the best food and that we're getting that into not only educating our kids on better eating habits, but ensuring that those foods are in their schools.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And for me, the dichotomy of being a farmer, a California farmer, and growing some of the healthiest food in the world, and yet seeing that that is not necessarily what's being served in our schools. And so with this legislation, where I think we've worked really hard to address a lot of the different concerns, you know, from.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
From industry and others, but I think we come up with a really good Bill that navigates that and ensures that those two things really happen, that we ensure that we're doing better by our kids and that our school lunch program is going to be something in many jurisdictions.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
By the way, I think it's really worth pointing out there's some really great programs that are out there. One that I'm aware of is right here in Sacramento county, in Placer County. I know there's several programs as well. And we want to continue to grow that. And we want to.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Ultimately, what we want to see is California growing food, getting directly to our kids, because we know that by farmers. You know, we've heard of the farm to fork movement, right?
- James Gallagher
Legislator
We want to get the farm to school movement growing more and more in California, and truly to ensure that our kids are healthy, because that is the ultimate thing, is that we want to ensure that we're. We've seen that our kids are. There is this epidemic, there is this health crisis in our.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
In our society, and we can do better by all working together. And so I appreciate the author, and I believe we've found the right path on this bill today, and I encourage everyone to support it. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Leader Gallagher. Assemblymember Ahrens, you are recognized.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I have just one quick question to the author. I'm just wondering, in this bill, are we protecting the color of our Skittles? Without objection. You can answer in your close.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assemblymember Gabriel, do you wish to close?
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Yeah. Thank you very much. Mr. Speaker, I just want to say first, thank you to my colleagues on this side of the aisle for your support. And it's really been a pleasure and fun to work on a bill that is co authored by James Gallagher and Ash Kalra and Alex Lee. That's a special. That's a special combination.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I just want to thank. I want to thank all of the colleagues for their thoughtful feedback on that. To our birthday boy I will say wild Berry Skittles are the best. I will die on that hill. They are delicious and I love them.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
But I'm also glad that we've been able to come together around this very common sense, bipartisan notion, science based notion that we should be mindful of what we are serving our kids and that what we serve our kids deeply can deeply impact their physical health, their mental health, their emotional well being.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I'm really proud that California is going to be leading the nation once again in doing that. Respectfully request an Aye vote on AB 1264.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assemblymember Gabriel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 72, Noes 1. Senate amendments are concurred in. Members, if I could have your attention. Everyone's attention please.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We're going to take a brief recess under call for the following committees to meet immediately. Governmental organization in Capitol Room 437. Water, Parks and Wildlife in Capital Room 444. Members, those of those committees please report to those hearings immediately. Once Committee hearings conclude, please return to the floor immediately so that we can continue our business.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Madam Majority Leader. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There is a letter of legislative intent at the desk relative to AB723 pelerin. I request unanimous consent to print the letter in the Journal pursuant to Assembly Rule 42c.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Without objection, the letter will be published in the Journal.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
I move to re refer the following bills to the Budget Committee pursuant to Assembly Rule 97, Item 79, SB144 and Item 80, SB149, .
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Without objection. Is Solache here? Sorry. Members returning to business. Item 22, SB760 by Senator Allen, presented by Assembly Member Solache. The Clerk will read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 760 by Senator Allen and others an act relating to the Political Reform Act of 1974.
- José Solache
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, in the wake of the wildfires in Los Angeles, nonprofit organizations activated to aid in the immediate response and long term recovery of fire victims. Elected officials in the region could have played a valuable role by using their platforms to support and amplify charitable efforts in the community during this time.
- José Solache
Legislator
But behest the payment reporting requirements made it difficult to make any public statements through to encourage support of these worthy charities. Under current law, a contribution is considered a behest even if it's made in a simple suggestion of an elected official without any coordination with a potential contributor.
- José Solache
Legislator
SB 760 seeks to provide flexibility for elected officials to make broad public appeals on social media, television, or radio to support worthy charities without requiring reporting. The bill includes important protections to prevent abuse and maintain transparency.
- José Solache
Legislator
A report continues to be required if the official learns that a contribution was made and if the official, an immediate family member, or member of staff hold a position with a direct interest of nonprofit. I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debates, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 57, noes 0.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The measure passes. We'll pass temporarily on item 28. We'll pass and retain on items 23 through 27. Item 29, SB 271 by Senator Reyes, presented by Assembly Member Fong. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 271 by Senator Reyes, an act relating to public post-secondary education.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Today I rise to present SB 271 on behalf of Senator Eloise Gómez Reyes. SB 271 will ensure that student parents are connected to vital child care and financial aid services at the financial aid offices, basic needs centers, and child development centers on their campuses and their respective communities. This bill is a Legislative Women's Caucus priority, has received bipartisan support and no no votes. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on behalf of Senator Reyes.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 61, noes zero. The measure passes. We will pass temporarily on item 30. We'll pass and retain on item 31 and item 32. Item 33, SB 613 by Senator Stern, presented by Assembly Member Zbur.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 613 by Senator Stern and others, an act relating to greenhouse gases.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. I rise today to present SB 613, a bill by Senator Stern, which addresses methane emissions from fossil fuels. Methane is a short lived climate pollutant that is 87 times more potent than carbon dioxide in the short term. California continues to be a leader in reducing methane emissions.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Over the past years, the Air Resources Board has adopted a strong oil and gas regulation that governs in state production, limiting flaring, venting, and leaking of methane. This bill looks at upstream emissions in a cost effective manner. California imports about 90% of its natural gas, mainly from Colorado, New Mexico, Texas, and Canada.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
On the petroleum side, we import about 50% of our oil from Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Ecuador, Brazil, and Canada. We are still amongst the largest users of fossil petroleum and gas in the world. This bill will move the Public Utilities Commission and other agencies to prioritize strategies to reduce methane emissions, including emissions from imported petroleum and natural gas.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This bill empowers the PUC and the Air Resources Board to assess and apply approved monitoring, measurement, reporting, and verification protocols, such as the Oil and Gas Methane Partnership or satellite trackers like Carbon Mapper to reduce emissions.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This bill will encourage natural gas procurement to shift to low leakage natural gas where feasible, cost effective, and in the best interest of ratepayers. This bill will show that California can continue to take steps to be a leader in methane reduction while prioritizing both affordability and practicality. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote on behalf of Senator Stern.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 42, noes 12. The measure passes. Without objection, immediate transmittal to the Senate. We'll pass and retain on item 34 through 37. Item 38, SB 744 by Senator Cabaldon, presented by Assembly Member Bryan. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 744 by Senator Cabaldon, an act relating to post-secondary education.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and colleagues. This bill is a proactive response to a rapidly shifting federal landscape that threatens the foundations of how our colleges and universities are recognized, funded, and allowed to function within California.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
It provides continuity by recognizing any accreditor that was federally recognized on January 1, 2025 as valid under California law through July 1, 2029 as long as the accreditor continues to operate in good faith and under existing standards. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 47, noes 16. The measure passes.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
We will pass and retain on items 39 and 40. Pardon, 39. We'll pass temporarily on item 41. We will pass and retain on items 43 and 44. We'll pass up temporarily on item 45. Pass and retain on item 46. Pass temporarily on item 47. Pass and retain on item 48 and 49.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Item 50, SB 461 by Senator Padilla, presented by Assembly Member Rubio. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 461 by Senator Padilla, an act relating to state property and making an appropriation therefore.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Today I rise to present SB 461 on behalf of Senator Padilla. Senate Bill 461 is a district bill that facilitates the transfer of a facility from CHP to the City of Imperial in order to provide a city owned space for police services.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
The City of Imperial and the police departments are in need of a property to provide adequate space for essential law enforcement functions. There is no existing city owned property that would suffice to support the demand and public safety needs.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
SB 461 resolves the issue by providing a facility to the City of Imperial to support law enforcement in the city. Thank you. The bill has no opposition and has received bipartisan support. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Jeff Gonzalez, you're recognized.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. This bill specifically deals with my district and the City of Imperial. After reading it and understanding the need and speaking to the folks down in the district, specifically to our law enforcement, I rise in support.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Rubio, all debate having ceased, would you like to close?
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. Members, this is a 54 vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will close the roll and tally of the vote. Ayes 16, noes 0. The measure passes. Item 51, SB 487 by Senator Grayson, presented by Assembly Member Gipson. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 487 by Senator Grayson and others, an act relating to workers compensation.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam Speaker and Members. I rise to present Senate Bill 487 on behalf of Senator Grayson. This bill ensure that firefighters and peace officers injured in the line of duty are made whole when the when an injury occurred by a third party. Currently, when the neglected third party injured a firefighter or police officer.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Whether it is a traffic collision or an assault or shooting, they're having the opportunity to pursue a civil claim to recover damages not covered by workman's comp. This bill include recovered lost time, special pay, missing promotion opportunities, pensions loss, pain and suffering. SB 487 strikes a balance to maximize the compensation to those injured police officers and firefighters. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 53, noes 0. The measure passes. We will pass and retain items 52 and 53.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Item 54, SB 533 by Senator Cortese, presented by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 553 by Senator Cortese, an act relating to prisons.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, I rise to present Senate Bill 553 on behalf of Senator Cortese. Currently, state officials and legal professionals undergo an extensive clearance process anytime they want to enter a California prison institution. This application can take months to process for something as simple as a tour.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
So this bill creates an expedited application process across all states institutions for elected officials, their staff, and the legal professionals. Thank you so much for allowing me to present the bill, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 63, noes 0. The measure passes. We will pass and retain on item 55. Item 56, SB 635 by Senator Durazo, presented by Assembly Member Carrillo.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 635 by Senator Durazo and others, an act relating to local government.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise today to present SB 635 on behalf of Senator Durazo. SB 635, the Street Vendor Business Protection Act, is a Latino Caucus priority, and it's important step towards ensuring street vendors receive the support and protections they deserve.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
As Co-Vice Chair of the Latino Caucus and as an immigrant myself that came to this country at a young age and has worked hard to afford a better life, not just for myself, but for my family, I know firsthand the value we bring to this state and the country.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Street vendors provide meaningful economic opportunities, especially for low income workers, women, and immigrant business owners. These vendors sell everything from handmade candles and earrings to raspados, elotes, nieves, mangonadas, and fresh fruit. Pouring their hard work and creativity into supporting their families while bringing vibrancy and community to our neighborhoods. Yet across California, street vendors remain deeply vulnerable, working in public while living in constant fear.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
And now heightened by the threat of ICE raids, their livelihoods are being targeted and their survival is under attack. As the federal government intensifies its harmful actions against our communities, this bill presents a critical opportunity to safeguard and empower vulnerable workers in California while protecting their personal information.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Recent amendments strengthen the bill by ensuring that we maintain legal defensibility, creating a Public Records Act exemption, refining contracting language, and making other clarifying changes. Members, let us continue supporting our street vendors, businesses who are business owners who contribute tremendously to this great state. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 48, noes 14. The measure passes. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow the following items on second reading to be taken up without reference to file for the purpose of a third reading today. SB 451, Archuleta, by Ahrens. SB 415, Reyes, by Carrillo. SB 53, Wiener, by Bauer-Kahan.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Up next is item 57. SB 641 by Senator Ashby, presented by Assemblymember Nguyen. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 641 by Senator Ashby and others. Backlights of professions and vocations and declaring the overseas thereof to take effect immediate.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
So Member win. You are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, I present SB641, a consumer protection and Business Recovery act bill by my Senator, Senator Ashby. This bill grants the Department of Consumer affairs and the Department of Real Estate the authority to waive specified licensing requirements during declared states of emergency due to a natural disaster.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
In the wake of the detrimental wildfires in Los Angeles, wildfire victims should never be at risk to lose their state license due to their inability to meet renewal deadlines or other requirements. These licenser licensure laws outline simply because they have the misfortune to live in a disaster zone.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
SB461 is designed to ensure that Californians receive the support and protection they need during a time of crisis, allowing them to safely rebuild their homes and communities while addressing predatory practices. This bill has passed with bipartisan support and no opposition. On behalf of Senator Ashby, I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. This is a 54 vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Aye 67, Noes 0. On the urgency.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Ayes 67, noes 0 on the measure. The measure passes. Up next, we will take up item number five, AB 779 by Assembly Member Lackey. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 779 by Assembly Member Lackey and others, an act relating to child welfare services.
- Tom Lackey
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, for allowing me to present this, AB 779. The measure is designed to protect survivors of domestic violence and strengthen our child welfare system. They need your support, so please do it.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 64, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Up next, we will take item 11, AB 978 by Assembly Member Hoover.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 978 by Assembly Member Hoover an act relating to transportation.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members 1978 is back for concurrence. The bill seeks to promote use of sustainable and cost saving recycled materials such as recycled asphalt pavement in our local road project. Senate amendments were minor and technical. Unanimous support in both houses. Respectfully request your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember. Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 64, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Next we will take item 14 A.B.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 587 by Assembly Member Davies, an act relating to student financial aid.
- Laurie Davies
Legislator
Thank you, Mrs. Speaker. Members, AB 587 is back on concurrence. Amendments in the Senate changes the bill to require a veterans benefit expert to be appointed to the California Student Aid Commission. This will be upon the next vacancy of the governor's appointed general public representative. This bill is a support support and has received no no votes. Members, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 64, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Moving on to the concurrence file item 132. AB 1005 by Assemblymember Davies. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1005 by Assembly Member Davies and others. Drowning prevention.
- Laurie Davies
Legislator
I'm back. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members AB1005 is back in concurrence. Senate amendments removed provisions of the bill to begin establishing a statewide swim lesson voucher program. Citizens the big deals in water bill deals and water safety education material being distributed to students K through 12 as well as their parents.
- Laurie Davies
Legislator
Members, this is a huge step towards ending drowning in California. And I ask that you take it with me respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 64, Noes 1. Senate amendments are concurrent it Members.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Up next we're taking item 58 by Assembly Member Arambula. Pardon me. By Senator Hurtado presented by Assemblymember Arambula. Clerk will read.
- Joaquin Arambula
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, today I rise to present Senate Bill 647 by Senator Hurtado. The Home Energy Savings. Expansions act. Senate Bill 647 improves energy assistance programs. By placing a Member of the California Energy Commission onto the Low Income Oversight Board. Thank you. On behalf of Senator Hurtado, I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember. Seeing and hearing no further debates, a Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 49, Noes 17. The measure passes item 60. SB 703 by Senator Richardson.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Senate Bill 703 by Senator Richardson an act relating to employment.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you. Madam Speaker and colleagues, I rise to present SB703 on behalf of Senator Richardson. This measure protects workers, promotes fair competition and strengthens the efficiency of our supply chains. Respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 49, Noes 8.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The measure passes. We are going to pass and retain on items 59 and 61. Item 62, SB 720 by Senator Ashby, presented by Assembly Member Pellerin. The Clerk will read
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 720 by Senator Ashby and others, an act relating to vehicles.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise to present SB720 by Senator Ashby, the Safer Streets Act. This Bill allows cities to opt into a new red light camera system for high collision zones. In 2021 alone, more than 4,000 Californians lost their lives to traffic collisions, with more than a quarter of these deaths resulting from drivers running red lights.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
The outdated and expensive structure of our current red light camera programs have proven to be ineffective and overly punitive. SB720 provides an updated framework to bring California cities on par with successful programs across the nation, including directing revenue back into local communities to fund safe, multimodal transportation projects.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
SB720 ensures that cities have tools needed to create safer streets, making this a critical step towards reducing traffic collisions in California. The Bill has received bipartisan support, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Flora, you're recognized.
- Heath Flora
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise in support of SB 720. This bill's been ran for a few different years now. And it's time that we fix this very antiquated system. Our cities, our counties, they want it, they need it. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Flora. All debate having ceased, Assembly Member Pellerin, would you like to close?
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally of the vote. Ayes 56, noes 6. The measure passes. We'll pass and retain item 63. Item 64, SB 763 by Senator Hurtado, presented by Assembly Member Kalra.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 763 by Senator Hurtado an act relating to business.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Assembly Member. Assembly Member Kalra, you're recognized.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you. Madam Speaker. I rise today on behalf of Senator Hurtado to present SB763, which increases penalties under the Cartwright act, our state's primary antitrust law. This bill is not proposing anything. Extreme penalties under the Cartwright act have. Not been updated since the 1970s.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
And SB 763 makes necessary updates so that they actually mean something in today's economic reality. It is taking the penalties from 1 million to 6 $1.0 million. Simply ensuring that violating our antitrust laws comes with real enforceable consequences. Consequences big enough to make dominant firms and individuals think twice before they rig the market.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
SB763 raises the stakes not to punish, but to determine. Because California deserves a competitive economy that works for everyone, not just those who can afford to manipulate the rules. With that, I respectfully asked for an Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 42, Noes 19. Measure passes.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Returning to item 30. SB 274 by Assembly Member by Senator Cervantes. Presented by Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. Clerk will read. We will pass temporarily on item 30.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Item 30, SB274 by Senator Cervantes, presented by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 274, by Senator Cervantes and others. An act relating to personal information.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Oh- I haven't been recognized.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members, I rise to present Senate Bill 274 on behalf of Senator Cervantes. The Bill is about one simple principle: Protecting the privacy and safety of Californians while ensuring law enforcement tools are used responsibly.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Automated license plate recognition systems are used in over 230 departments in California, with those numbers growing every day. While the systems are incredibly important to aid investigations and help solve crime in California, it also means that millions of law-abiding Californians are having their movements tracked, creating vast databases of sensitive personal information.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
The databases can reveal visits to healthcare providers, places of worship, protest sites, causing significant risk to privacy and civil liberties. In 2016, the Legislature passed SB 34 to require safeguards around ALPR use.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Yet, 2020 state auditors found widespread non-compliance. Agencies shared this data with hundreds, even thousands, of outside entities, including federal immigration authorities and other states, to track abortion patients. Many agencies failed to establish the required protocols, or some had none at all. Five years later, this issue has become more pertinent.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Just this week, San Francisco police allowed out-of-state officers to run 1.6 million illegal searches, including for ICE. When law enforcement officers misuse this data, it is dangerous.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
This Bill merely puts a 60-day limit on their retention unless they have an investigation, at which point they can keep it for as long as they need, and then says that they need to dispose of it to ensure the security and privacy of Californians. With that, I respectfully ask your aye vote on SB274.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Ortega, you're recognized.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise today in support of SB274. It is a fact that automated license plate readers are used to target communities of color. This technology has been found to be primarily located in Black and Latino neighborhoods.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
This common-sense measure helps protect our vulnerable communities while maintaining public safety and allowing law enforcement to do their jobs. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Lackey, you are recognized.
- Tom Lackey
Legislator
Well, thank you. Members, I would ask you to please, please, please consider the limits that you're posing on law enforcement by the 60-day period. We've got this great tool that will allow us to solve very serious crimes, very serious crimes. But yet we, we have some, some problems that have brought this as a concern.
- Tom Lackey
Legislator
And I don't think we dismiss those problems. But please don't take such drastic measures that are going to put us in a vulnerable position. This is a great tool, and if there are some isolated misuses, let's address that. But let's not get rid of the tool. Please vote no.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember. Assembly Member Demaio, you're recognized.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise in strong opposition to SB274. With only one exception that I can think of this year, one exception, and it was the Bill authored and brought by our colleague from across the aisle from Sacramento on child sex trafficking.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
This body continues to make it harder for law enforcement to do their job, to go after criminals, to get them off the streets, to solve crimes, to punish criminals, to protect, to protect our communities. And it's offensive to see some of you just snickering here because we're talking about people's lives that are at risk.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
We're talking about people's lives at risk. We're talking about victims of crime. The victims of crime deserve law enforcement to have all of the tools at their disposal to solve crimes, to get bad people off the streets, to bring them justice. One of our colleagues just said that these tools are used to target minority communities disproportionately.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Crime, if you look at the statistics, disproportionately impacts minority communities. So if you want to help minority communities, give them safer neighborhoods, get criminals off the streets so they can't prey on minority communities; this should not be hard. This is about making sure law enforcement has every tool at their disposal.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
One of the things that I remarked to my staff about in the wake of Charlie Kirk's assassination is that we will probably find this guy or whoever did it, because every movement on that campus is probably surveilled through some sort of electronic device, some sort of camera.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
And sure enough, in the, in the moments, the hours after the assassination, a variety of video.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Assembly Member Bryan, you're recognized for your point of order.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Asking that the Member from San Diego keep his remarks to the merits of this legislation before us.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Point well taken. Senator Demaio, please keep your comments to the Bill before us.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Oh, no, it's exactly on point. And I will not be silenced under the US Supreme Court's ruling against the State of Maine's Legislature. I will continue my remarks about why having surveillance data in the hands of law enforcement is crucial. And I'm giving in a specific example of an assassination that just occurred this week when where video footage was key.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
We don't know the full details, but I would venture to guess that when the family member saw that video footage of the suspect that was released, caught on camera, cameras that you are going to data that you're going to take out of the hands of law enforcement through this Bill, limit through this Bill.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
I would suspect that the family probably saw some of that footage and said we might have a problem here. And they, of course, did the right thing. So again, I'm asking you, don't second-guess law enforcement. If they misuse data, punish them. There are tools and accountability mechanisms in place to punish them for the misuse of data.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
But don't take the tool out of good law enforcement agents' hands to solve crimes and to protect our communities. I urge you, common sense on this one, vote no at least to perhaps send this Bill back for a little bit more refinement and consideration.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. I would like to compliment my friend, the Member from San Diego, for actually bringing up the tragedy that just occurred in Utah because there's an active investigation taking place and anybody who reads this Bill would be able to tell you that if there's an active investigation taking place, that is not subject to the limitations that the Member from San Diego is so afraid we'd be giving up.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
This Bill isn't about taking anything away from law enforcement. It's about data governance and constitutional rights. And every state grapples with this. As a matter of fact, the company that provides this technology makes recommendations to states on how long law enforcement should be able to hold onto this license plate data. And they recommend 30 days.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
And many states, many red states, have taken that upon themselves to use only 30 days. The State of New Hampshire has only three hours, with a Republican Governor, as a matter of fact. We don't see any difference in crime spiking statistically in the states that have less time than other time.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
I always thought that my friends on the other side of the aisle were concerned about big government, too big government, as a matter of fact. I'm very concerned about my data being held by law enforcement unnecessarily.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
And I know that, that if they had complete knowledge of all of our movement, there would probably be a dramatic drop in crime. If all of our movement was tracked all the time. But we don't want that.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
This is a very, very reasonable way to look at what's appropriate in terms of data governance when it comes to our freedom of movement. All of our freedom of movement. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Great, thank you. My colleague from Long Beach brought up a conflicting point that I have, which is the privacy. I do have those concerns. This went through Privacy Committee. When I'm driving around town and I got cameras everywhere and license plates and things like that, that does concern me.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
You know, let me say the police agencies did offer an amendment to this Bill that I think was very reasonable, and it wasn't accepted. And that was that it can go beyond that particular time if individuals, if it was sort of put in a lockbox where only certain people can access the information.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And I think that that's really important actually, this year, I think, and my math could be wrong. I'm sure he'll correct me. But an individual named Victor Wolf would have been celebrating his 20-year anniversary with the Sacramento Police Department. Unfortunately, he was shot in the line of duty when tracking down a murderer in Sacramento.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And he caught that murderer when he was driving through a portion of Sacramento, and the individual went through a license plate reader, and he was able to find him and track him down. And when he exited his car, he was shot by the suspect. And Victor, unfortunately, was unable to return to work for the Sacramento City Police Department.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Now, a blessing to us, he works for the California State Assembly. He works in my office. He lives in Rockland, and he has four children and a wife. I've heard the stories of him talking about what it was like, what it was like when his family had to go see him at the hospital.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Fortunately, he's with us today. But when I brought this up in Committee, it was said, well, this wouldn't really apply to him because they knew that this license plate was part of an investigation. I mean, believe it or not, there are some intelligent murderers out there.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
They do a stupid act, but they might actually switch cars, and then all of a sudden they're in a car that is not a known vehicle of on this hot list or whatnot.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
I really think that this Bill needs to be killed right now, and it needs to be start from scratch and take the amendments from law enforcement, so when instances occur in which that data needs to be accessed that there are precautions that allow that information to be used in the future.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Otherwise, you it will jeopardize lives fortunate and it will jeopardize law enforcement lives as well. And it's very serious. And we've offered these amendments; we put these proposals out there. They weren't addressed. And with that, I respectfully asked for a no vote.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. And as a trained investigator, I did in one year over 300 investigations. Out of those 300 investigations, I just want to pinpoint 11 of the investigations. And by the way, this happens all the time. The way it works is the event takes place, and you have limited information.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
You get information from people on the street, and you have to then follow every single trail in 13 different directions. That's the first piece of the puzzle. You also have what's known as time, distance, and direction. You don't know how far the person has gone in the amount of time, the distance they've gone, the direction they've gone.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
You don't know those things. They could be really close or they could be really far away. You're trying to figure all those pieces out through the information that's coming in. This specific investigation that I'm referring to, it took me about four months to get to a lead that led me down a road where, at six months, I finally got, and by the way, I'm in a foreign country, in a foreign country in Iraq. This got me all the way to Maryland.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
At that time, I had to hand it off to the FBI, and then they had to take it on from there. So as you're thinking about this, Bill, I would ask you to consider these pieces, especially when we're talking about investigations. I understand that if it's a part of an investigation, it's protected.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
But sometimes we don't know it's part of the investigation until we're way down the road because the leads had led us there. That's the challenge that we're encountering. I get that piece. But now we limit an investigator from being able to follow up on those different pieces because it was never a part of the investigation.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
It never came up. So now that it is part of the investigation and we can't touch it, there's an issue. I think there's a solution here, I really do. But to blanket, close this off at 60 days, and delete it, is not the solution.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
You have to afford the investigator the opportunity, whether it's through a lockbox or whatever that way might be. We have to inform the investigator to follow the lead. Because if it was your family member in this investigation that was raped and murdered, and they were 12 years old. Yeah, let me rephrase that for those who aren't listening.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
For the rape and murder of a 12-year-old, you'd want the investigator to follow every single lead if it led from one edge to the other edge of the Earth; that's what you would want. So I think there's a solution, we can find a solution, but this is not it. And with that, I oppose this Bill.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I think that it's easy to use anecdotes or fear rather than focus on the actual policy of what we're discussing here.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
My understanding is our, the former author of this Bill, our colleague from Long Beach had inquired with law enforcement about, okay, well, using these license plate readers, how much has that affected crime in terms of our public safety, in terms of being able to solve crimes or not over a 12 month period, they were not able to provide that data to him.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
And I think that's something that can still be helpful even if this Bill is passed, that's great data to have. Because if the reality is that there's some sense that somehow public safety or investigations are being impacted, come and show data. Because it's very easy for any one of us to speak to policy based only on anecdotes.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
In fact, it happens far too often on this floor. The anecdote referred to by from our, by our colleague from Rockland, indicates that it didn't take 60 days to be able to functionally use that match; it took 16.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Can you hold on one moment? Assembly Member Patterson, you're recognized for your order.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
I would suggest that our colleague looks up the definition of anecdote. Obviously we mention anecdotes, as other colleagues have, of things that can be very powerful, very emotional.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Kalra, I have to rule on the point of order. It is not well taken. You may continue.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you. The point I'm trying to make is that we need to make these policies based on data.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
And the reality is even the company itself keeps the data for 30 days, because when a law enforcement agency or other governmental agency is doing an investigation, once they determine a vehicle of interest through using a license plate reader, now that vehicle of interest is on a hot list. Not for 30 days or 60 days.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
It's on a hot list as long as that investigation is open, which can be a year, two years, six years, and so don't conflate the two. When you think about only 60 days, is it after 60 days, all of a sudden, we can't use license plate readers?
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
No, the point is that once that information, once that license plate number is put into that list as a vehicle of interest, at any moment that there's a hit, now law enforcement has the information it needs and can follow up and use it for as long as it needs it. As that investigation is ongoing.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
That's what this Bill is about. As someone that's trained in defending the Constitution, I strongly urge you to vote aye on SB274.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Well, here's a data point for you. Prop 36 passed by super supermajority. They asked us to prioritize taking care of this community and to make sure that we're protecting them. Law enforcement is asking us again to support them. This entire week, we have demonstrated and made their jobs harder.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
They are simply asking for more time, and as a rule representative who has departments that are extremely small, they do not have the bandwidth, with the amount of crime that has been happening when laws were passed like 47 or 47 and 57. So they need data, they need time.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
We have had a history and almost a decade of anti-law enforcement laws in. It is clear when PORAC. It is clear when the State Sheriff's Association. It is clear when so many police officers and officers' associations are asking us again to prioritize the people and to enforce crime. They need some help.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
So I currently urge you to vote no on this and let us prove that we support law enforcement. If you vote yes on this, this just shows it's another piece of a criminal first agenda coming out of this body.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Well, thank you very much Madam Speaker and colleagues. I have to respectfully disagree with my colleague from Clovis. I think if you vote yes for the Bill, it means you actually read the Bill and you understand the Bill. There are three, sorry, four points I'd like to make.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Number one, the 60-day limit set forth in the Bill applies to non-case, non-hit data. Let me say it again. Non-case, non-hit data. Number two, once a suspect vehicle or lead is identified, and I think we can all agree at least on this point, investigators can and will use and retain that data.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Third, nothing in SB 274 requires the destruction of evidence in an active investigation. And number four, long-term retention, and this is an important one, this actually, actually comes from the California State Auditor, because the problem that the author is trying to solve is not some abstract concept. It is demonstrated. It is fact.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Long-term retention of this data mostly sweeps up innocent driver movements. In fact, 99.9 of scans are unrelated to crime. So the concern about data privacy is real. In summation, I have spent 10 years, over 10 years in the courtroom as a prosecutor. I actually have worked in law enforcement.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
I know there's a few folks in the room who have as well. I believe that this Bill strikes the right balance. Investigators can and will preserve automated license plate automated license plate reader evidence once a case is opened. It balances law enforcement needs with our constitutional protections for everyday Californians.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
And the other thing I would say is that what it really is aimed to do is to prevent the stockpiling and collection of unnecessary evidence, unnecessary data about non-criminal conduct. That is what this Bill is all about. I'll be voting aye because I read the Bill.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, would you like to close?
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker and Members and thank you again for the robust dialogue. And I actually appreciate what both sides are saying. I live like all of us, I think, in a community that wants to be safe, and we have license plate readers at the entrance to my community, and at times, that's helpful.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
There's no question about that. And that's why I think it's really important that we focus on the facts of this Bill, which is- And my colleague from San Diego mentioned the incredibly effective police work in the Charlie Kirk investigation that happened, where he was caught within days of the crime, which is exactly what we want.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And I think what that highlights, frankly, is effective police work, is the good men and women in our law enforcement agencies who work day in and day out to keep us safe, and frankly, do an incredible job. And 60 days will be one of the longest in the nation. As you heard, New Hampshire allows three minutes, I think it is, unless you're on the hot list, which frankly I would think was too short. But 60 days is enough time to decide this is the area where we think the investigation is occurring. Tag those license plate readers.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
You don't have to solve it even within 60 days, although as noted, many investigations are and to keep our communities safe. And would one argue that if we lived in a surveillance state where you could track every one of our movements, more crime would be solved? I don't want to live in that state.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
I want to live in a state where we have the tools to solve crimes and we also retain our privacy and our dignity, and we aren't using the surveillance tools, frankly, for what are illegal activities, which is tracking innocent people to be picked up and people who are accessing legal health care here in California.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan has requested to move the call.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Members, we are going into recess and remain under call for committees to meet for a dinner break.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
In 30 minutes, the following committees will meet in Capitol hearing rooms. Elections in room 444, rules in room 126, public safety upon adjournment of Rules Committee in room 126 and utilities and energy in room 437. Again, Members may not leave the building. Dinner will be provided. Democratic Members will be in the Members lounge.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Republican Members in the Willie Brown conference room. The plan is to reconvene in one hour.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Here we go. All right. Assembly is back in session. Members, take your desks, please. We are ready to begin. Without reference to file, we have already approved the motion on this. This is SB415 by Assemblymember Carrillo. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 415 by Senator Reyes and others snack related to land use.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. Members, for nearly a decade, the Legislature wrestled with how to protect vulnerable communities from impacts of heavy duty trucks that are necessary to service the logistics industry, which has boomed over the past 20 years as the rise of ecommerce and our collective expectations for rapid shipping has grown.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Last year, with the leadership of Speaker Rivas, Senator Reyes and I authored AB98. Finally put in place a delicate balance. Today I am presenting SB415 on behalf of Senator Reyes.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
This implementation and cleanup Bill is the product of hundreds of meetings and thousands of hours of negotiations between myself, Senator Reyes, and the huge number of stakeholders that are impacted by this important legislation. Not every issue got resolved, and there were many issues that were brought up to us that were deemed inappropriate for this cleanup process.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
But this Bill does the following. It clarifies that manufacturing facilities are not impacted by AB98. It gives local governments more time and flexibility to update their truck routes, exempts local governments that don't have logistics use facilities, protects warehouse projects that are already in the development pipeline.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
It exempts seasonal warehouses, provides a process for insurance track routes are enforced and clarifies the air quality study that is in AB98 so we can more efficiently track the progress and effectiveness of the program, along with a dozen or so other important clarifying provisions. Members. Last year, AB98 made its way through the Legislature.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
I committed to continue working on this issue to make sure we get it right. SB415 and its twin, AB735 are my first deliveries on what we promised. This Bill has enjoyed bipartisan support and has a broad coalition of labor, local government and industry. Stakeholder support. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Carrillo. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, please return to your desks. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 44, nos three. The measure passes. File item number 65. That's SB775 by Senator Ashby, presented by Assemblymember Berman. Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 775 by Senator Ashby and accolade of the Healing Arts.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, can we have decorum, please? Assemblymember Berman, you are recognized.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. SB 775 is the Sunset Extension Bill for the Board of Behavioral Sciences and the Board of Psychology, which are set to expire on January 1st. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Berman. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 67, no 0. The measure passes. File item number 66.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB776, also by Senator Ashby, also presented by Assemblymember Berman. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 776 by Senator Ashby and accolade in the Healing Arts summary.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And for the last Sunset Bill of 2025, SB776 is the Sunset Extension Bill for the California Board of Optometry, which is also set to expire on January 1st. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Berman. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the rule. Tally the votes. Ayes 64, nos 1. The measure passes by item number 67.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That is SB787 by Senator McNerney, presented by Assemblymember Petrie-Norris.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 787 by Senator McNerney and others accolade to energy.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise this evening to present SB 787 by Senator McNerney. This measure will help California develop in state supply chains for EV batteries, building decarbonization technologies and offshore wind.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
SB787 will create a unified approach to build out California's clean energy supply chains and workforce by formalizing partnerships between state agencies, labor, environmental organizations, and clean energy industries. This Bill will help California meet our clean energy goals while creating high quality good paying jobs, increasing affordability, and advancing economic development. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Petrie-Norris. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 53, nos 9. The measure passes. File item number 68. That's SB 809 by Senator Durazzo.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 809 by Senator Durazo and others. Accolade to employment.
- James Ramos
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to present SB809 on behalf of Senator Durazo. Previous law exempted construction trucking companies from classifying their drivers as employees for five years to give them time to come into compliance.
- James Ramos
Legislator
Unfortunately, despite this exemption expiring last year, many employers have continued to misclassify drivers, depriving them of basic protections like overtime pay and and workers compensation. SB809 will provide legal amnesty to employers who have misclassified these drivers as long as they reclassify them as employees and compensate them with two check system.
- James Ramos
Legislator
One check for their labor and one check for the use of their equipment. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Ramos. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 52, nos 11. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, before we go on to the next Bill, I think that we should recognize we're in the presence of greatness. Former Senate and Assembly Majority Leader Chuck Calderon is sitting right here in the front row. And you put up with our colleague. We love you. We love you. Okay, thank you. Members, File item number 69.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB 822 by Senator Becker, presented by Assemblymember Valencia. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 822 by Senator Becker and others inaccurate to unclaimed property.
- Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Buenas noche Members, as principal co author, I rise to present SB822. This Bill will update California's unclaimed property law to include digital financial assets, also known as cryptocurrency. Current law does not specifically address virtual currencies or how these assets should be reported and transferred responsibly for safekeeping.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member of Valencia. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk Will close the roll tally the votes. Ayes 67, no. 0. The measure passes. Going to pass. Retained on file item 70.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Passed temporarily on file item 71. File item 72. SB 767 by Senator Richardson, presented by Assemblymember Petrie Norris. Clerk will read.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Senate Bill 767 by Senator Richardson and others. In accolading to energy.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise to present SB767 on behalf of Senator Richardson. This measure is a simple, proactive early warning system. Californians depend on liquid fuels for commuting and goods movement even as we accelerate electrification.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Meanwhile, as we've discussed throughout this year, refining capacity is shrinking and critical crude pipelines face potential shutdowns when a pipeline supplying refineries is at risk. This Bill ensures that the Legislature is is notified in a timely manner so that we can hold oversight hearings and develop contingency plans. This is an important step for affordability and reliability.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Members, we've. We've far too often acted after a price spike. SB767 lets us act before the disruption, protecting consumers while we continue the clean energy transition. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Petrie-Norris. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 69. no 0. The measure passes. Pass through intent on file item 73.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We've already dispensed with file item 74. File item 75 is SB 351 by Senator Cabaldon, presented by Assemblymember Patel. Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 351 by Senator Cabaldon and others and accoladed to health practices.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I am proud to present SB351 on behalf of Senator Cabaldon. This Bill updates and codifies California's corporate bar on the practice of medicine, which allows the Attorney General to enforce violations by private equity involved in medical and dental practices. This Bill has no opposition and was passed previously on this floor.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
And due to late technical amendments, the Bill has to be voted here on the floor. Again, I once again respectfully ask for your aye vote on SB351.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Patel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Ayes 66, no 0. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Going to pass and retain on file item 76, 77, 78,79, 80, 81, 82, 83. Members, we're going to go backwards to File item number 71. File item 71. That's SB848 by Senator Perez. Presented by Assemblymember Wicks. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 848 by Senator Perez and others in accolading to peoples safety.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise to present SB848 on behalf of Senator Perez. Although California has taken significant steps to safeguard both students and employees and enhance transparency, the state still lacks a comprehensive, standardized approach to preventing abuse in K12 schools.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
SB848 strengthens student safety in school districts by requiring updates to comprehensive school safety plans with clear procedures for preventing, detecting, and addressing employee sexual misconduct. It also broadens mandated reporter requirements, enhances employee training, and revises relevant provisions in current law to ensure stronger protections.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
We recognize the overwhelming majority of teachers and classified staff are dedicated professionals, but even a tiny fraction of school employees engage in child abuse can cause catastrophic harm. Students cannot wait and they need this protection. Today, SB848 has bipartisan support and has received no, no votes. With that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wicks. Assemblymember Hoover, you are recognized.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise as a proud co author of this Bill would urge an aye vote. I want to make clear there's definitely been some concerns expressed and some opposition. And I just want to make clear that this is not about our teachers or our school employees.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
We love and respect the people that make our education system possible, the people that are the engine behind our schools and our students success. And nothing in this Bill calls that into question. What this Bill is about is protecting students and ensuring the safest possible learning environment for our kids. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Hoover. Assemblymember Tongipa, you are recognized.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I too rise in support of this Bill. It was great having a conversation with the author. We may not always agree on everything. That goes on, but what we do agree on is making sure that we're protecting kids in poor communities, especially when they don't have the same amount of resources and protections.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
I've had family Members that were also targeted and nothing happened, even though things were reported. So I just really wanted to rise make sure I was thanking the author. For bringing this forward. And I look forward to supporting this. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Tangipa. Assemblymember Boerner, you are recognized.
- Tasha Boerner
Legislator
Good evening, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise in support of SB848 and would like to thank Senator Perez for her leadership on this important matter. Fundamentally, this Bill is about one thing, protecting our children. As parents, it's our duty to do what's necessary to ensure that our kids can be safe from predators. And that's what this Bill does.
- Tasha Boerner
Legislator
In a perfect world, this legislation would not be necessary but to quote Madison and permission from the speaker to read.
- Tasha Boerner
Legislator
If men were angels, no government would be necessary. Regrettably, we cannot change what has happened, but we can make sure we guard against it happening again. By passing SB848, you can help us take one step closer to safer California for our children. I ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Boerner. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Wicks, do you wish to close?
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wicks. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 64, no 0. The measure passes. Okay, we're going to go ahead to the back to the beginning of the Senate third reading file the bills that we did not take up yet. Beginning with File item number 26, that's SB75 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas. Presented by Assemblymember Quirk Silva.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 75 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas an act relating to prisons.
- Sharon Quirk-Silva
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. Today I rise to present Senate Bill 75 on behalf of Senator Smallwood-Cuevas. SB 75 creates a pilot program to provide multi craft core curriculum aligned pre apprenticeship training within 24 hours of release.
- Sharon Quirk-Silva
Legislator
California has made major investments in rehabilitation, but too often incarcerated individuals, especially women, return home without the credentials or continuity of support they need to succeed. This bill is about closing that gap, ensuring equitable access to meaningful career pathways across facilities. SB75 is more than job training.
- Sharon Quirk-Silva
Legislator
It's about restoring dignity, reducing recidivism, and breaking the cycle of incarceration with real economic opportunity. The bill has a support support position and has no opposition. I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Quirk-Silva. Assemblymember Jeff Gonzalez, you are recognized.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This. This is a good bill. And my hope is that myself and my colleague from Los Angeles will take. Take more of these types of bills.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
And next year and start looking at some, some of some more ways to help our community, not only the ones that are incarcerated, but those that are recently incarcerated. So this is good and this goes along with that same package. So I appreciate that.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Summary Member Gonzalez. Summary Member Bryan, you are recognized.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. I want to thank my colleague from Orange County for floor jockeying this bill. Stand in strong support of it and grateful to my colleague from Coachella for his courage and consistency on these issues. Respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Bryan. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Quirk Silva, do you wish to close?
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Quirk Silva. Debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members voted who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally. Votes Ayes, 70, Noes . The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Members. Next item is item 41. File item 41. That's SB11 by Senator Ashby. Presented by Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Senate Bill 11 by Senator Ashby, an act relating to artificial intelligence technology.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise on behalf of Senator Ashby to present SB11, which updates California's false impersonation laws to account for AI technology capability of replicating an individual's voice or likeness. SB11 has received bipartisan support and zero no votes. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll, tally votes. Ayes 71, noes zero. The measure passes. File item number 43. File item 43.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
43. That's SB59 by Senator Wiener, presented by Assembly Member Mark Gonzales. The Clerk will read.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Senate Bill 59 by Senator Wiener and others, an act relating to vital records and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, this is a 54-vote Bill. Assembly Member Gonzalez, you are recognized.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Arise today on behalf of Senator Wiener. There is a sighting of him here today to present SB59.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
SB59 will protect the privacy and safety of transgender non-binary Californians by requiring any petition for a change of gender, sex identifier, and name, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be kept confidential automatically to be the Court.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Transgender non-binary people are particularly vulnerable to discrimination, harassment if records pertaining to their name and gender marker change are made public. SB 39 will prohibit these records from being posted publicly on the Internet or otherwise by anyone in the petitioner. These members of our community have always been a forefront of the LGBT plus movement.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Let's remember that and support their right to a private name and gender affirming legal process. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Mark Gonzalez. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 56, noes 15 on the urgency. Ayes 56, noes 15 on the measure.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
The measure passes. Going backwards to File item number 28. File item 28. That's SB245 by Senator Reyes, presented by Assembly Member Bryan.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 245 by Senator Reyes, an act relating to criminal procedure.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker and colleagues, I rise to present SB245 on behalf of our favorite Senator, Senator Reyes. Many incarcerated people face delays in certification from CDCR and encounter licensing restrictions despite meeting eligibility under current law.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
SB245 removes these barriers by requiring CDCR and counties, upon release of a defendant, to proactively certify to the courts that the individual successfully participated in fire camp. It also streamlines opportunities for defendants to pursue EMT licenses. There's no opposition to this Bill, and recent amendments from the Administration narrow the scope of the Bill. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bryan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 61, noes 3. The measure passes. Skipping ahead to file item number 44.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB 294, also by Senator Reyes, presented by Assemblymember Ortega. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 294 by Senator Reyes and others. And applicant to employment.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I rise to present SB294, the workplace know your rights act, on behalf of Senator Reyes. The bill will protect families by ensuring a worker's emergency contact is notified should they be arrested or detained by state or Federal law enforcement.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
SB294 will ask the Labor Commissioner's Office to create a template for employers to annually inform their employees about their rights both state and federal, to ensure equal and just treatment under the law.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
On behalf of the author, I would like to note that the amendments were previously taken to move the Chamber's opposition coalition to neutral and there is no longer registered opposition to the bill. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Ortega. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 62, Noes 7. The measure passes. File item 46.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB3 26 by Senator Becker, presented by Assemblymember Bryan.
- Committee Secretary
Person
The Senate Bill 326 by Senator Becker and others an accolade to wildfire safety.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. SB326 is an important step for California in terms of managing wildfire risk. California is losing too many homes and communities to wildfire. This is driving twin crises in affordability of electricity and availability and affordability of homeowners insurance. SB326 does two things to address these twin crises.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
First, it would create a framework for CAL FIRE and its contractors to systemically evaluate and quantify the risk reduction benefits of fuel management and landscape resilience investments made by government and non governmental actors. This is important because it will help us focus planning and resources on the projects with the greatest potential to reduce risk.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
SB326 would also increase early implementation of the pending Zone 0 building standards through a grant program to accelerate effective defensive space action homeowners can take to protect their homes from wildfire destruction. This bill has no opposition. Senator Becker would call it the Goat. And I respectfully ask for an Aye on this vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bryan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote. Do desire to vote? All. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 74, Noes 0. The measure passes. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
At the request of the author, please move file item 20 SB259 Wahab to the inactive file. There is a Rules Committee resolution at the desk to suspend joint rule 61A14 to extend session for the purposes of taking up bills after September 12th. I move to suspend joint rule 51A4 and joint rule 61A14.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Okay. That is seconded by Assemblymember Gipson. Mr. Flora, you are recognized.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Resolved that Joint rule 61A14 be suspended to permit bills to be taken up after midnight Friday, September 12,2025 and consider for passage
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, this rule suspension is not debatable it takes 54 votes Clerk will open the roll all those vote who desire to vote Madam, majority leaders asking for an aye vote Mr. Flora is asking for a no vote all Members vote who desire to vote Clerk will close the roll Tally the votes Ayes 56, nos.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
19 the Joint Rules are suspended hey, Members, can I have your attention please?
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, gonna read some names to you Hugh Sladen, Creston Whiting Casey Alexander Torres Tammy Eller Victoria Garduno Sakara Brewer Maria Solario Durazo Thomas Daniel Alvarez, Veronica Blevins, David Bowman Diego Mendoza, David Garcia, Steven Sepulveda, Kate Bourne and all the interns they do all the work we take all the credit the Clerk staff led by our Clerk, our chief Clerk thank you, Chief.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Next item up is File item number 52. That's SB 541 by Assembly Member. Excuse me. By Senator Becker presented by Assemblymember Schultz. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 541 by Senator Becker and others an act relating to electricity.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. I'll be brief. I rise to present SB541, a bill that will help lower electricity bills on behalf of Senator Becker. In this era of afford, a lot of the cost of running the grid is driven by meeting demand during the highest peak periods.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
But if we can spread out that demand and lower these peaks, we can save a lot of money and lower electricity bills. Two recent reports show just how much savings is possible. One estimated $550 million in consumer benefits every year from harnessing load flexibility rather than paying for more generation capacity.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Another estimated up to 13.7 billion in savings between now and 2030 from reduced spending to upgrade the Poles and wires and transformers in our distribution system. The CEC set a target of 7,000 megawatt hours of load shifting capacity by 2030. But so far we've achieved only about half of that, and progress on capturing more is slow.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
The bill asked the CEC to analyze our progress, identify how much potential each of our utilities has to capture more cost effective load shifting and how much they've done so far.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
This is purely a transparency bill, not creating any new mandates, but it will help us recognize and spread best practices and shine a light on utilities who are lagging behind. People are demanding that we do something to lower electricity bills, and reducing costs through load flexibility is one of the largest and fastest options.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
We have to help them with that. I did say I'd be brief, and I ask that y' all vote Aye.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
I politician who keeps his word. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally. The vote. Aye 46, Noes 14. The measure passes file item number 59.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB682 by Senator Allen, presented by Assemblymember Connolly. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 682 by Senator Allen an act relating to product safety.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
Thank you. Speaker and Members, I rise to present SB 682 on behalf of Senator Allen. This phases out unnecessary uses of PFAS in 6 product categories. This bill prohibits the intentional addition of PFAS in cleaning products, cookware, dental floss, ski wax, food packaging and juvenile products.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
PFAS are a large class of forever chemicals that persist, contaminate the environment and have demonstrated harms to human health even at low exposures due to their ubiquity in products. State testing has found that PFAS in water systems serving up to 25 million Californians PFAS are found in virtually all of our bodies.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
Despite what you may have heard from opponents of this bill, this only applies to product categories for which there are PFAS free alternatives on the market at reasonable prices. For example, PFAS free cookware are available on the market right now as low as 10 or $15 for a pan.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
It's based on other states with similar bans including Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington. It only applies to new sales and we have taken amendments to delay implementation of until 2028 for most product categories and 2030 for cookware Members.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
California has long been a leader in addressing the use of pfas including fire fighting foams, textiles, cosmetics, menstrual products and paper food packaging. In fact, just tonight Assemblymember Haney brought forth AB 1181 for firefighter PPE. Recent amendments on the Assembly 4 incorporate technical assistance from DTSC and the California Air Resources Board.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Connolly, Assemblymember Ellis, you are recognized Members. Decorum please.
- Stan Ellis
Legislator
Mr. Chair. Members, I don't speak very often, but I'm rising respectful and respectful opposition of 682 and I'll tell you why. Teflon has been tested with what's called a acid soluble leaching method.
- Stan Ellis
Legislator
And they take and they scrape the Teflon out of the pan and they put it in an acid solution and they leave it for an insurmountable amount of time. I don't know the exact details of the text other than they use it as called acid characteristic leaching.
- Stan Ellis
Legislator
Then they take that and they run it through spectrometry and they analyze it for anything that's soluble, anything that could go into solution from Teflon. These tests have proven that Teflon does not go into solution. You can actually even take a chip and swallow it and it goes through your body.
- Stan Ellis
Legislator
However, I would tell you that polyfluoroalkyl substances there are 12,000 to 14,000. They're carbon fluorine bonds, some are soluble and some PFAS are not good for you. But I'm telling you that the scientific data proves that acid soluble Teflon is no harm to your body. So therefore I respectfully oppose the 682. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Ellis. Assemblymember Flora, you were recognized.
- Heath Flora
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I also rise in opposition to 682 in respectful opposition. But Members, we are in affordability crisis and this measure ignores this crisis by increasing the cost of average Californians to replace their non stick cookware at really about a $300 per set. I just bought some recently and they are not cheap these days.
- Heath Flora
Legislator
We need to keep in mind these Palmer are low carbon or sorry, low concern and exhibit inherently low toxicity. But we're going to pass this measure with big financial impact to Californians. When we have an affordability crisis. Attacking how people cook their food at home is probably not the right message. I respectfully asked for no vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Flora. Assemblymember Hart, you are recognized.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. I rise in strong support of the Senate Bill 682. Speaking about affordability, California has already spent a half $1.0 billion addressing PFAS contamination with another $1.0 billion more in planned projects. Drinking water remediation alone costs $200 million a year.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
And the health care burden of PFAS exposure is estimated to be $8 million a year. $8 billion a year. Removing PFAS from drinking water is enormously expensive and it cannot undo the harm already inflicted on our soil, our food and our health. The better solution is prevention.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
By phasing out unnecessary uses of PFAS at the spores, we can protect Californians before exposure occurs. Every dollar invested in prevention saves many more and in treatment, remediation and health care down the loan. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Hart. Assembly Member Patterson, you are recognized.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Mr. Speaker, I have no idea what. My colleague from Bakersfield was saying, but. He is much smarter than me and. Because of that I'm voting no.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Patterson. Assembly Member Lee, you are recognized.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise a strong support of this bill. This bill is very simple. If you want to externalize the cost of PFAS forever chemicals, a known carcinogen that cost outweighs any cheap nonstick pan that can go lifetimes. We are detecting these forever chemicals in our water, in our soil, in our bodies.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
It freaks me out so much having served on ESTM that I have told my mom to stop using all nonstick pans altogether.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
The fact of it, the science that is that is being cited right now is that these chemicals can dissolve, can break down especially with heat and friction, and especially when you're cooking and stir frying, that is heat and friction.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Every time you see those scratches on the pan, that is a little bit more carcinogens floating into your food. This is really important to make sure that we're sending clear signals to to make sure that we have safe products on the market for our consumers. Respectfully ask your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Lee. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Connolly, do you wish to close?
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
Thank you, speaker, and appreciate the Members from Santa Barbara and Fremont kind of really setting the stage for the broader context. Just a couple quick rebuttals. One is on the cost.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
The fact remains, as I mentioned in my opening, there are PFAS free alternatives that are reasonably priced on the market right now and only becoming more available over time. And at the risk of nerding out with my distinguished colleague from Bakersfield, fluoropolymer production releases significant harmful PFAS contamination.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
So we would respectfully reject his point that it is shown to degrade into persistent terminal PFAS that are harmful to health and carry harmful non polymer PFAS impurities which shed into the environment. Bottom line is this is a measured approach that appropriately targets unnecessary uses of PFAS.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
Very consistent with a lot of the other actions that this body has taken over the last several years. If we can make PPE for firefighters without PFAS, certainly we can make a frying pan without PFAS. I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Connolly. All debate having seized. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally votes. Ayes 41, Noes 19. The measure passes. We're going to go to file item Quorum please, Members, thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, file item 47. That's SB378 by Senator Wiener, presented by our Majority Leader.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 378 by Senator Wiener an act relating to cannabis.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized. Members, can I please have decorum? Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise to present SB 378 on behalf of Senator Wiener. This bill tackles the tough issue of intoxicating hemp. I first began working on hemp because the 218. 2018 farm bill created a gap an unregulated industry that left Californians without clear protections.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
My previous legislation, AB45, was the most strict hemp law in the country when it was enacted in 2021 and was only meant to legalize non intoxicating hemp products like CBD. But today, intoxicating hemp products are widely sold online without age limits.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Working on this issue, I've heard directly from parents whose kids have been able to order these products online without any age checks. Many of the companies selling these products are intentionally breaking the law. They operate outside of the legal system, dodging taxes, ignoring regulations and creating corners excuse me, and cutting corners on safety.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
While our licensed cannabis businesses play by the rules, these illicit products often aren't tested, which means our consumers don't know what they are getting. Some of these products are far more potent than anything you can buy legally in California. In California's regulated cannabis market in 2025, research came out that showed just how bad it is.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
95% of hemp products tested contained illegal synthetics, with some carrying up to 30 times the THC allowed in legal cannabis. We need stronger enforcement tools to protect our kids from these unsafe, unregulated products to keep them off the market.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
This bill gives consumers a way to seek civil penalties against online marketplaces that advertise illicit intoxicating hemp and cannabis. Consumers will also be more informed because these platforms are will be required to post a disclaimer if they have been caught selling illegal products.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
SB378 will protect Californians, especially our kids, from illegal products and support our legal cannabis operators by holding these online marketplaces accountable for damages from unlawful paid online advertising. The author has taken amendments to the bill making such changes, which made many online marketplaces move to neutral on the bill. The takeaway is this.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
This bill is only going after bad actors. Amendments include common sense protections and affirmative defenses to protect good faith online marketplaces that act quickly to remove unlawful listings for cannabis cannabis products or intoxicating hemp products from their platforms. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 70, Noes 0. The measure passes. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan wishes to lift the call.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
On file item 30, SP274. Clerk will post. Bauer-Kahan wishes to move the car. Thank you, Members. File item number 63. SB756 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas, presented by Assemblymember Mckinnor. Members, can you show respect to the authority? Members, please folks, show respect to the authors.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 756 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas an act relating to the motion picture tax credits.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
Mr. Speaker and Members. SB756 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas directs the California Film Commission to strengthen existing reporting within the California Film and Television Tax credit program by collecting workforce, demographic and zip code specific hiring. Look, I ChatGPT it and that's just not enough.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
California invests 330 million each year in the film and television industry, yet we lack basic information about who benefits from the high wage jobs created through this important program. SB756 empowers California's film and television industries and provides important data and accountability for taxpayers across this state.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
We don't have to choose between creating jobs in the film and television industry and making sure all Californians are benefiting from these job opportunities. ChatGPT just won't do it. We can and must do both. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Mckinnor. All debate having cease. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 72, Noes 1. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, we are going to be going back to the supplemental file. Before we do that, some more names I'd like to read to you in this very very difficult climate with all the political violence around us, the very people that are here to protect us.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Under our chief, Cheryl Craft, Member services Harrison Giroux, Ron Neely, Phil DeFazio, Nate Goodnight, Stefania Salazar, Will Bratton, Grant Bird, Edwin Garcia, Andrew Mcgee, Todd Tan, Kenya Broadway Judith Lester, LaShawn Mims, John Blanchard, Vinnie Shiro, Mario Cano, Dylan West, Jaime Hernandez and their interns. All under Chief Cheryl Craft.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
And of course Members, even more applause to our security sergeants whose names we do not put out there. Let's thank them all. Thank you. Tough to articulate how grateful we are. Back to our supplemental file. Members File item number 142. 142. That's AB 1288 by Assembly Member Addis.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1288 by Assembly Member Addis and others. An act relating to public health.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. 1288 is back on concurrence and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Addis. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the Roll tally the votes. Ayes, 69. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1293 by Assembly Member Wallis an act relating to workers compensation.
- Greg Wallis
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members AB 1293, which improves the workers comp QME process is back from the Senate on concurrence. Bipartisan, no opposition, no no votes. Respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wallis. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 64, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in file item number 144. That's AB 1327 by our majority leader.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1327 by Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry. An act relating to contracts.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 70 is back on concurrence. Senate amendments clarify the intent of the bill and resolve chaptering conflicts in more ways than one. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Majority Leader. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 68. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, as I looked over to my left, to your right, I see our old friend, retired Assembly Member Freddie Rodriguez. Welcome back, Freddie. We're going to pass and retain on file item 145. File item number 146. Thank you, Members. Decorum. File item 146. That's AB 1363 by Assembly Member Stefani
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1363 by Assembly Member Stefani and others. An act relating to protective orders.
- Catherine Stefani
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, AB 1363, also known as Wyland's law, is back on concurrence. Amendments taken in the Senate narrowed the. Bill and added co authors. I respectfully asked for your aye vote in honor of Wylan Thomas Gomes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Stefani. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 65. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 147 AB 1373 by Assembly Member Soria.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1373 by Assembly Member Soria. An act relating to water.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. AB 1373 is back for concurrence. Senate amendments allow the Water Board to integrate the hearings and vote allowed for by the bill in a regular meeting of the board. I respectfully ask for your aye vote. [Spanish]
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Soria. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 60. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. We're going to pass temporarily on file item148, file item149 is AB 1441. Also by Assembly Member Soria. She was just there a second ago. We're going to pass temporarily on file item 149. File item 150. That's AB 1476 by Assembly Member Wallis. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1476 by Assembly Member Wallis and others. An act relating to nutrition.
- Greg Wallis
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today to ask you to concur in Senate amendments. AB 1476, a bill that makes it easier for seniors to obtain meals to go. Members don't be sus please vote yes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Wallis. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 66. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. We're going to pass and retain on file Item 151. Brings us to file Item 152, AB 1524 by the Committee on Judiciary. The Clerk will read.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assembly Bill 1524 by the Committee on Judiciary. An act relating to courts.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB 1524 helps protect public access to court services and products. AB 1524 has a support of organizations that advocate for open government and journalism. It has no opposition and received no, no votes. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Kalra. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes, 69. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. File item 153 that's AB 290 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 290 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan and others an act relating to insurance.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. You'll be happy to hear this is not a CEO streamlining bill, but it is a bill that allows people like me on the fair plan to get automatic payments. It took amendments to clarify in the Senate and I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally. The votes Ayes 70, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in file item 154. AB394 by Assemblymember Wilson.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 394 by Assemblymember Wilson and others an act relating to public transportation.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members AB 394 is back from the Senate on concurrence with clarifying amendments. I ask that you vote Aye.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wilson. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally votes. Ayes 62, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We're going to go backwards to the Senate. Third reading. File file item number 24, file 1124. That's SB42 by Senator Umberg, presented by some. Member Lee. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 42 by Senator Umberg and others an act relating to the Political Reform act of 1974.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues, tonight I present SB42, which will empower voters and restore control to local governments by giving them the same option that charter cities currently have to enact public financing of campaigns.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Currently, five charter cities offer campaign public financing options, and whenever the voters have had the chance to vote for it from their city, the voters have approved it overwhelmingly, including 74% of the voters in 2022 in the City of Oakland.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Unfortunately, voters and elected officials in counties, districts, General law cities cannot currently be given the same opportunity to enact such policies.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Under a provision enacted by Proposition 73 in 1988, SB 42 will enact local control to local governments by placing a measure on the November 2026 ballot to repeal the ban on campaign public financing, while adding basic requirements that public financing systems and candidates use public funding must follow to protect taxpayers and maximize benefit to voters.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
It would simply remove the ban and allow local governments local governments or the state the option to enact laws that create programs for public financing of campaigns while requiring basic protections for fairness, accountability, and where the money can come from. States are often called the laboratories of democracy.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
With this bill, state cities and counties could be laboratories addressing the influence of big money and politics. Respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Lee. Assemblymember Pellerin, you are recognized.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise in support of SB42. Public financing programs can be powerful tools for strengthening our democracy. We've already seen success in places like Los Angeles, San Francisco and Berkeley, where these programs have helped empower voters and broaden participation. But here's the problem.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Under a 37 year old ballot measure, most of which has been struck down by the courts, public financing programs are banned everywhere except in charter cities. SB42 fixes this. It doesn't create a single program. It simply gives voters the right to decide whether their city or county should be allowed to adopt one.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
The bill also has strong guardrails. Any future program would require candidates to meet strict qualifications before receiving public funds, and it would prohibit using those funds for things like legal defense fees, fines, or paying back personal campaign loans. Even if voters approve SB 42, no city or county is required to adopt public financing.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Many likely won't, just as some charter cities have chosen not to. But every jurisdiction should have the same option if their voters want it. That's what fairness and local control look like. This bill is the goat and I ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Pellerin. Assemblymember Demaio, you are recognized.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in strong opposition to SB 42. The voters have been quite clear they don't want taxpayer money being used for politics. Unfortunately, politicians simply can't take no for an answer.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Just like the same way they don't want to take no for an answer when the citizens say we don't want politicians drawing election lines. We already have a lot of taxpayer money going into politics.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
It's laundered through a variety of government contracts and grants that are dressed up to look like, therefore, public outreach for other legitimate public purpose programs like workplace safety or trying to engage people on environmental advocacy. The Governor has a whole canvassing program that he funds on a variety of so called public interest causes.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
But it all boils down to politics. The public doesn't want limited, scarce tax dollars going into politics, particularly when you're telling them we have to raise taxes and cut important government services. I value the First Amendment. The First Amendment is not just about speech that you can speak physically.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
It is about how you invest your dollars, your campaign contributions, Grassroots campaign contributions, and yes, sadly, large contributions are protected speech. The US Supreme Court has ruled that it's not a perfect system, but it is a fair system and it is a system that the American people support. Please listen to them.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
They've already spoken through the ballot measure some almost four decades ago. Respect the vote of the people and stop trying to manipulate the process. Vote no on SB42 and let's cut the state taxpayer funds going into politics under our watch.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Demaio. Assemblymember Wicks, you are recognized.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise in support of SB42. I think we all know how corrosive money can be in politics. We all know it, we all deal with it. Every elected official in America has to deal with it. And it is the worst part of this job. And people get compromised.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
And we see it all the time from all sides. I have two cities, Oakland and Berkeley in my district that have public financing of campaigns. And what we see in those cities is more equity in terms of who gets to run for office and more genuine grassroots support. So I'm a strong supporter of this.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
I've seen it work in my cities and this will allow the voters to decide that is what we're talking about here. I think this is critical, particularly given the crisis our democracy is in right now. And with that, I stand proud to support this and humbly ask my colleagues to do the same.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Wicks. Assemblymember Bennett, you are recognized.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. If we're so certain that the voters will reject this, then why would we be worried about putting it on the ballot? To confirm that things have changed dramatically since 1988. The sense that big money is corrupting politics is certainly becoming more pervasive. Let's find out if the voters have an opinion about this.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Thank you very much. I encourage an Aye vote and I appreciate the author pushing on this.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bennett. Assembly Member Berman, you are recognized.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I want to thank my colleague from San Jose for floor managing this bill and being a principal co author from the very beginning.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I mentioned in the Elections Committee that every so often in my nine years in the Assembly, I see somebody introduce a bill and I think, dang, I wish I introduced that before they did. And this is one of those bills.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I the first time I ran for office and the local level was for Palo Alto City Council in 2012, and we had sort of an informal agreement that nobody would raise money in amounts greater than $500 and no one would spend more than $35,000 total. And it wasn't a law, but it was followed by all the candidates.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Four years later, six wealthy families in Palo Alto spent $20,000 each to try to influence the local City Council elections in Palo Alto. And I know that that's happened in too many communities across California. We've just seen an explosion in. Huge.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Amounts of money being spent on our campaigns all the way up, you could argue, to the state Legislature. And so, as my colleagues have mentioned, this is just giving voters the opportunity to decide whether or not we should then let local governments decide whether or not they want to have these systems.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
So it is, you know, it's the epitome of local control. It's the epitome of respecting voters and whether or not voters want us to do this. And I think it's an area that is really ripe for exploration across California and looking at what other communities across the country have done for best practices.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assemblymember Berman, seeing and hearing no further debate. Assemblymember Lee, do you wish to close?
- Alex Lee
Legislator
I'd like to thank my colleagues for being strong co authors and supporters of this bill. Look, today in our election system we take for granted public finance disclosures, disclosures on advertising, voluntary expenditure limits that allow you to be on the booklet that sent out. These are all newer inventions in our California democracy.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
But we are paving the day. So to colleagues, I would ask you to support this Bill because you don't want to look back and say back in my day I missed the chance to reinvent and strengthen democracy for the rest of the country.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
And it is honestly if we look at all the cities that have passed and support public finance selections from New York, Seattle, Los Angeles, Berkeley, Oakland and soon San Jose. The voters of today are saying they support grassroots powered campaigns that to represent their cities respectfully.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
In 1988 the electorate was very different and I was negative several years old, so I was not even alive at that time. So we need to be with the people and say back in my day we supported public finance elections. Respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Lee. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 50, Noes 18. The measure passes. File item number 27. That's SB80 by Senator Caballero.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 80 by Senator Caballero and other an accolade to energy.
- John Harabedian
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise to present SB80 on behalf of Senator Caballero. SB80 would would establish the Fusion Research Development Innovation Initiative which would allow the California Energy Commission to award funds to public laboratories and other entities for fusion research and development. Upon legislative appropriation.
- John Harabedian
Legislator
This bill will facilitate the funding necessary to give California a more active role in fusion energy. The bill has no opposition. No. No votes. Respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Harabedian. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tallied votes. Aye 63, Noes 0. The measure passes. File item 35. That's SB 638 by Senator Padilla.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 638 by Senator Padilla and others an act relating to career technical education.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Members, I rise to present SP638 on behalf of Senator Padilla SP638 helps establish the California Education Interagency Council comprised of the heads of K12 higher education workforce and labor agencies along with the Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities to serve as a statewide planning and coordinating body for CTE career pathways and workforce development beginning June 1, 2026.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
The bill modifies the CTE Incentive Grant program to better reduce disparities across regions by providing local educational agencies with funding opportunities to expand and develop programs that will provide Californians with the skills they need to access high quality employment.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
The modifications will require applicants to show a commitment to ensuring placement and job opportunities, support underrepresented populations and provide holistic support to students and prioritize tracking outcomes. California's allocated billions of dollars for TT programs and over the years each has operated independently.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
This Council brings together all the different entities that have a role in education politics of funding folks on jobs and careers to improve cross sector collaboration.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Together with my bill, Assembly Bill 1098, this council will help ensure that our policies, programs, funding and agencies operate in a coordinated strategic fashion so that all K12 and higher education Institute students are able to secure good paying jobs. I strictly ask for an Aye vote on behalf of Senator Padilla.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Fong. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 56, Noes 7. The measure passes, skipping ahead to file item 55. File item 55.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB629 by Senator Durazo. Presented by Assembly Members Zbur. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 629. By Senator Durazo and others an act relating to Wildfires.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise to present SB629 on behalf of Senator Durazzo. SB629 is one of the 13 bills in the Senate's Fire Response, Recovery, Rebuilding and Prevention package. Following the devastating Los Angeles firestorm and as California continues to face a year round fire season, it's clear that we must harden California's defenses against future disasters.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
To that end, SB 625 does the following first, it requires the State Fire Marshal to consider urban conflagration risks when updating fire hazard severity zone maps. Current fire maps only cover the risk of ember cast into an urban area.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
They do not consider the risk associated with that fire moving further through a community and as it consumes homes for fuel Second, it designates areas that recently burned in a significant wildfire as post wildfire safety zones, which are those burning 1,000 or more acres, destroying 10 or more structures, or causing a fatality.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
3 While the state Fire Marshal goes through a more lengthy review process of updating fire hazard severity zones, it requires state fire prevention standards, including Woodland Urban Interface Building Code standards, to be applied in these post wildfire safety zones.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Fourth, it also requires a city or county with territory in a post wildfire safety area to review and update the safety element of its General plan to address the risk of fire in post wildfire safety zones. In January of this year, wildfires in Los Angeles County burned a combined 37,469 acres.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
The fires leveled entire communities in the Pacific Palisades and the Altadena neighborhoods of LA County. The Eaton fire became the second most destructive fire in the state's history and the Palisades fire became the third most destructive. This is no time for inaction. We must do all do our part to protect our communities from future harm.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Amendments in the Assembly removed all opposition to this measure and I respectfully ask your Aye vote on behalf of Senator Durazo.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Members Zbur. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll tally the vote. Ayes 45, Noes 17. The measure passes. File item 73. That's SB 404 by Senator Caballero, presented by Assemblymember Rubio. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 404 by Senator Caballero and others an act relating to hazardous waste.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I have a big personal announcement. I'm really tired because it's getting really late, but I do have to present SB404 on behalf of Senator Caballero. SB404 creates a clear regulatory framework for California's metal trading facilities, which recycle millions of vehicles, appliances and other metals each year.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
These facilities prevent landfill overflow and supply valuable materials, but also pose risks like fires and airborne pollutants. Currently, they are not regulated under DTSC's hazardous waste laws, leading to inconsistent oversight and litigation. The Bill requires all shredders to obtain DTSC permits, meet strict safety and environmental standards, undergo CEQA review and pay FEES for enforcement.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
SB404 incorporates stakeholder input, civil rights protections, public appeals, and flexibility for small operators. Senator Caballero worked extensively with the Department, and it's supported by labor recyclers, waste managers and firefighters. This bill ensures safe oversight and strengthens California recycling leadership.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Rubio. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open. Excuse me. Assembly Member Rubio, you're recognized.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Yes. Sorry about that. I respectfully asked for an Aye vote and asked for immediate transmutal to the Senate.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 47, Noes 1. The measure passes. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker. There are letters of legislative intent at the desk. I request unanimous consent to print the following letters in the Journal. Pursuant to Assembly Rule 42C. AB8, Aguiar Curry, AB 592, Gabriel.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Without objection, the letter will be published in the Journal.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There is a message from the Senate at the desk. I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow Assemblymember Gabriel to take up AB154 without reference to file. For the purpose of concurrence. Senate amendments that.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Objection. Okay. File item number 77. That's SB63 by Senator Wiener. Presented by Assemblymember Wilson.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 63 by Senator Wiener and others, and act related to transportation.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Good evening, members. I rise to present SB 60, on behalf of Senator Wiener and Arreguín. This is a critical bill for the future of the Bay Area. SB 63 authorizes a 14-year sales tax measure to go on the ballot in November 2026.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
It will let Alameda, Contra Costa, San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara County voters decide whether or not they should fund public transit. The authorization requires a half cent rate, except in San Francisco where the rate is required to be one cent. Our major Bay Area public transit systems are at historic crossroads.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
For decades we've underfunded these agencies, making them over-reliant on fares. The Coronavirus pandemic exposed this weakness. Significant changes in commute patterns reduced fare revenues and exacerbated operating shortfalls. While emergency federal and state aid helped maintain service, it's temporary, and a sustainable funding source is needed.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
If we don't act, transit systems like BART, Caltrain, AC Transit, and Muni must drastically cut service. BART may close ten stations and move to hourly headways. Muni may eliminate 20 bus lines. The consequences of such severe--so severe would be extreme: dramatically increased traffic congestion, people stranded and unable to get to work or school, reduced economic activity, and a halted recovery.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Furthermore, a state emergency transit loan being finalized over the fall that is critical is a critical bridge to a ballot measure--excuse me--to a ballot measure, is contingent on operators demonstrating the ability to pay back that loan. A revenue measure authorized by SB 63 is a critical means of repayment. The authors have worked extensively with all five tax counties to establish an expenditure plan. No negotiation is perfect and no entity got everything they wanted.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
However, in August, transportation boards for the two counties designated as opt-in counties, San Mateo and Santa Clara, voted overwhelmingly to request their counties be included in this measure.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Key transportation entities and other stakeholders in every participating county are in support of SB 63 because they believe that the benefits of joining the measure far outweigh potential drawbacks and that we must save transit. Accountability is an important component of SB 63. Permission to read, Speaker?
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
This is a letter addressed to the authors from 31 elected officials in Solano County regarding the support for San Mateo County opt-in commitment. It's dated September 11th. 'We write to express our support for San Mateo County's continued inclusion in SB 63.'
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
'The regional transit measure enabled by SB 63 is urgently needed for San Mateo County to preserve and improve our local transit service. The strong accountability provisions included in the most recent draft of SB 63 are tough, unprecedented, and responsive to prior input from San Mateo County elected officials and transit agency staff.'
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
'We thank the bill authors for including the components in SB 63 that address San Mateo's County's concerns and requests. These significant accountability concessions were made as a direct result of Assembly Member Papan's pressure and negotiations.'
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
'The accountability structure is extremely strict, not only in relation to earlier versions of the SB 63 but in relation to other tax measures more broadly. So we urge you to support San Mateo County's continued inclusion, SB 63, and thank you for your continued leadership advocating for the needs of San Mateo County.' With that, Mr. Speaker, members, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Wilson. Assembly Member Avila Farias, you are recognized.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in strong support of SB 63. It is no secret that the Bay Area public transit is facing imminent financial need. While the legislature has authorized an emergency loan, it is only a temporary patch and a band-aid. For Contra Costa County, my county in particular, a reliable and well-funded transit system is not just a convenience, it's a lifeline.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Our buses, BART, ferries, connect workers to jobs, students to school, seniors to essential services, and families to opportunities throughout the Bay Area. SB 63 not only places critical question before the voters, it also builds a real accountability to ensure that our transit systems are well-funded, protected in a vital, regional asset. This serves riders fairly consistently across all counties in the Bay Area.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
This is especially important for low-income riders, many of whom depend on affordable transit to access employment and healthcare. Without immediate action, service will be cut, jobs will be lost, and our most vulnerable neighbors will be left stranded.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Protecting and strengthening the Bay Area transit keeps Contra Costa County and the entire region connected, equitable, and economically vibrant. Let's put transit back on track where it belongs. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Avila Farias. Assembly Member DeMaio, you are recognized.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in strong opposition to SB 63. You know, California, state government, local government, the poster child of some of the worst government programs in the nation, and that's saying a lot because there's some good competition out there, but I can't think of perhaps a more failed and dysfunctional program example than Bay Area transit.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
We have a system that has absolute cost overruns, and if you want to look at some of the problems, you can go to a handy website, transparentcalifornia.org, where you can actually search for the transit agency in the Bay Area and look up the salaries and the pension payouts for the government employees that are largely, you know, managing empty transit cars.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
It's indefensible what we're spending in this system. On top of that, the utilization has plummeted. The market is telling you they're not comfortable with transit. It's not safe. We see the pictures all over the country but people don't feel that transit is safe or convenient. Your revenues have plunged as a result.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
So instead of dealing with your cost overruns and the fact that people don't feel that transit is an acceptable alternative for them, you fashion a bailout. You put all of California taxpayers on the hook. In this state budget--what is it now, three quarters of billion dollars?
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
We have a ten to $20 billion budget deficit and we're going to have a bailout of $750 million, and admittedly, the people in the Bay Area say this is just to keep us through when the voters hopefully will throw us a lifeline with this tax increase authorized by this bill.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
I understand that the governor has gone along with a three-quarter billion dollar subsidy or bailout. Guess the former speaker, according to media reports, gave him a telephone call and we know how influential she can be, but this is not a solution. And worse, you're banking with this bill, SB 63, on voters being duped into raising taxes.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Sales taxes are the most regressive form of taxation. It hurts working people the hardest. In December, we were sworn in and the speaker promised us we would deal with cost of living. I didn't realize what he was suggesting is that we were going to make cost of living more expensive in California but that's what most of the legislation we voted on has resulted in.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
So please, let's not add to the cost of living in the Bay Area--it's already too high--with a regressive tax, don't throw the good money after bad, vote no on SB 63, and let's force the Bay Area transit system to actually make some tough decisions and provide a quality service at an affordable price.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member DeMaio. Assembly Member Haney, you are recognized.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Thank you, Speaker and members. I appreciate the concern from the member from San Diego about the Bay Area and our affordability, but what I want to be clear about is that this is a Bay Area Caucus priority because the Bay Area doesn't run without transit and there is no more affordable, effective way for working people to be able to get to their jobs, for families to be able to take their kids to school, for elderly folks to be able to get to the doctor's appointment.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
In fact, for many people, this is what they rely on because they have no other way to get there. So this is an affordability crisis. If we cut and slash transit in the Bay Area, folks won't have any way to get there. They'll have to either take a taxi or an Uber or take the burden of being unable to go to the way that they live, the way that they gain employment, and their ability to advance themselves, to go to school, to go to college, to get a different job will be much harder if our transit system is slashed, and that's really what is at stake here.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
If we do not have the ability to, again, have the local authority, the autonomy to tax ourselves, that's what we're asking for here, the opportunity to let voters weigh in as to whether they want to do this. So you can say, 'oh, they shouldn't do it.' Let them decide if they want to fund their transit systems.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And what we've done is we've come together across Bay Area counties. The MTC, which manages $4 billion annually, is fully capable of doing this and doing it effectively with accountability. Over a million trips every single year on Bay Area transit--we rely on it, we don't run without it, and it's not just the people who live in the Bay Area.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
There are also many Dodgers fans who tonight are going to see an incredible game. It's one to one. Last I saw was bottom of the ninth. Did they score? Dang, they didn't score. See, but they're going to see extra innings.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
People from all over the world rely on Bay Area transit when they visit. It's billions of dollars in revenue. We just are asking for your support in allowing us to put this on the ballot so that we can support our system and support our people. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Haney. Assembly Member Wicks, you are recognized.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and members. I too, rise in support of SB 63, and while I appreciate my colleague from San Diego opining about what the Bay Area should or shouldn't do, as a representative from the Bay Area, I can assure you we need this to go on the ballot. Public transportation, particularly in my district, it's the backbone, it's the heartbeat, it's the infrastructure of our communities.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
It's what connects us. It's what allows our bussers to get to their restaurants, our nurses to get to the hospitals, our tech workers to get to their offices, and if we don't have the funding to support that, it's going to mean service cuts, layoffs, additional traffic congestion.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
So this is critical for the Bay Area, for the Bay Area economy, for, for all of the workers in our districts, rich and poor, use public transportation, and again, this is, as my colleague from San Francisco said, this is allowing the voters to decide. And so that is what this is about.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
This would--obviously if this goes onto the ballot, it will be critically needed funding for public transportation with strong accountability measures, and for those of you not in the Bay Area, would humbly ask for you to support our Bay Area needs here and obviously same with our Bay Area colleagues. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Wicks. Assembly Member Kalra, you are recognized.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and members. SB 63 is critical to the future of the nine-county Bay Area, and our colleague from San Francisco mentioned a million trips. I think he said a million trips a year. It's actually a million trips a day. I wanted to--I know he would want me to correct him on that.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
A million trips, about a million trips a day are taken every day on Bay Area transit systems. It's that transit that connects people to jobs, the doctor, their families, recreation, and we know that if we don't help secure new self-help local funds to sustain service on BART, Muni, Caltrain, and AC Transit, pressure will grow to divert other funding sources away from the North Bay. This measure is about growing the pie and that's what's needed for my Southern California colleagues.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
You can also look at this in the same way. Helping with self-help for these operators reduces the chances that they're going to come back to the legislature to address their budget gaps. I want to talk for a second about the South Bay. I'm a former chair of our Valley Transit Authority.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
For our folks that are not from the Bay, that's Santa Clara County's transit system: bus, light rail, congestion management, the most populated county in the West Coast, north of Los Angeles.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
I also used to be on the Caltrain board, and the Caltrain for those who don't know, connect from Gilroy through San Jose all the way up to San Francisco. It's a critical portion of the commute, especially in the tech sector as it runs parallel to 101 and 280.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
It would be devastating for those two agencies in particular that I know very well. If we don't find a way for these self-help operators, to go to the voters to ask them if this is something that they want, and contrary to the belief of others, people do use transit. In fact VTA has one of the strongest post-pandemic recoveries in the nation.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Its bus ridership is back to pre-pandemic levels, 100%, and Caltrain has seen a 41% increase in ridership since its recent electrification, which is an investment that we as a state put in to that system to increase the speed and the number of trains, thereby getting more people out of their cars and choosing transit.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
I want to thank the bill authors for listening to the South Bay and working closely with local elected officials and VTA to ensure that our needs are met and giving us the time to opt in to the measure. As our Transportation chair said initially, VTA wasn't part of it, but they are now because of those, of that dialogue and because of being listened to. The VTA board ultimately voted unanimously to join the measure. Ensuring reliable funding for BART is critical to Santa Clara County as we work to complete the BART extension to Silicon Valley.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Additionally, this measure is critical to Caltrain, as I mentioned, but just seeing a surge in ridership since its electrification. So I urge my colleagues to vote yes to allow us to go to the voters to make our case as to why this is critical, and I believe when we get the opportunity to do that, the voters will support this measure in order to ensure that our transit systems survive into the next decade.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Kalra. Assembly Member Bonta, you are recognized.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and members. I rise today as a proud co-author of SB 63 by Senator Wiener, and I want to thank our colleague from Suisun for bringing this forward as Transportation chair, making sure that we have an opportunity as the Bay Area Caucus to really focus on such a critical service and essential service for millions of Bay Area residents who depend every day to get to work, to school, on their healthcare visits, and on vital destinations.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
I represent Oakland, Alameda, and Emeryville, and BART, Muni, Caltrain, AC Transit, and even WETA, our ferry service, are incredibly dependent on making sure that we have this opportunity to be able to present to the voters in our region the ability to decide on November 20th--in November 2026 whether we should provide a sustainable funding source for the region and for public transit. We talk a lot about building housing.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
We talk a lot of doing that within transit-oriented development. We have to make sure that our trains, buses, ferries, and go-rounds are all operating to ensure that we have the ability to have a thriving Bay Area. The Bay Area is the economic life force of California and it deserves to be funded. With that, I respectfully request your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bonta. Assembly Member Papan, you are recognized.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Thank you so much, Mr. Speaker. Well, I rise in opposition, respectful opposition to SB 63. Let me be clear: this is not opposition to regional transit, nor the goal of long-term stability. We can all stipulate that there's a need here. But for years, Bay Area Transit has failed its riders miserably: unsafe stations, broken elevators, basic requests have been ignored, and that says nothing of losing $30 million a year in fare gate evasions, which took them years to fix, or the inability to run an efficient transit system for riders.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Yes, there's a concern about a fiscal cliff. Without intervention, our metropolitan areas will face gridlock and chaos, but why must funding come at the expense of accountability?
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Why are they treated as being mutually exclusive? This bill misses our opportunity to put our foot down with those driving us right off the fiscal cliff. We've had enough. We are told this bill contains the strongest accountability measures ever. If that is true, then it only proves why we're in this mess: because strongest ever means the following.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
We will let tax counties make a complaint once a year. That is not proactive oversight. That's reactive management, which is business as usual. It sort of reminds me of that definition of insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
The author will tell you that the Regional Management Commission dispensing this tax has tools to hold operators accountable, but the truth is they don't use them. Instead of course-correcting with SB 63, it preserves the same fiefdom that has failed us for years and it's deeply disappointing.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
San Mateo asked me to secure the best deal possible for oversight because we're asking our constituents to ultimately vote for this regressive tax. That means fair representation, strong proactive oversight by the tax counties, and real consequences when agencies fail to perform. This bill doesn't deliver that deal. Permission to read, Mr. Speaker?
- Diane Papan
Legislator
This is a letter from C/CAG, which is a city and county association of governments in San Mateo County. It includes all 20 cities. 'Rigorous and enforceable accountability measures are necessary to ensure that San Mateo County taxpayers and riders receive the level of service and benefit that it should company such a significant financial contribution as billions of dollars.'
- Diane Papan
Legislator
'The C/CAG's board recommendations to opt in was predicated on the inclusion of a rigorous and enforceable accountability provision. As currently written, the proposed accountability framework does not include the enforceable accountability provisions and vision, nor does it include equivalent measures, including sufficient financial penalties for noncompliance. Moreover, the sales tax burden in San Mateo is already aggressive.'
- Diane Papan
Legislator
'It's the third highest sales tax in the State of California, and Alameda County that's also included in this regressive tax, it has the highest sales tax in the state.'
- Diane Papan
Legislator
If we're going to ask folks to dig in their pockets, many of whom are already cash-strapped, to give us more money, by God, the least we can do, the least we can do for them is be accountable with their money. Colleagues, this is a missed opportunity to solve two problems: a funding shortage, which nobody disputes, and responsible spending. And because we failed to seize it, I simply cannot support this bill today. We should have done better. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Papan. Assembly Member Berman, you are recognized.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in support of SB 63 as a resident of San Mateo County, representing 150,000 constituents in San Mateo County, and I know how important this measure and this effort would be to public transit in San Mateo County, and then obviously, as we've heard from colleagues, across the Bay Area, and I know that, you know, this, this, this, this bill might not be perfect. This effort might not be perfect.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I think the effort has been made significantly stronger by my colleague from San Mateo, notwithstanding--even though she, she still opposes this effort, I want to thank her because her work made this effort better, and, you know, I know that this has incredibly strong support from local elected officials in my district.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
It was approved eight to one by the SamTrans Board of Directors just a little bit over a month ago. So I, I know that there's still more work to be done, I know there are more conversations that will happen to make sure that we have the strongest accountability possible and that every county that's a part of the effort, you know, feels like they're getting their fair share and that they're getting their equal voice, but I think it's really important that SB 63 passes tonight and moves forward for the sake of San Mateo County and the Bay Area's public transit. So I strongly support and encourage you to support SB 63. Thanks.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Berman. Assembly Member Gallagher, you are recognized.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and members. I didn't plan on speaking on this bill because, you know, yeah, I'm not from the Bay Area, and I get that this is sort of a Bay Area thing. I do like to visit. You know, I do like to come down occasionally for a game and, you know, visit the city by the bay and all that kind of stuff, right? And I mean, look, you know, you guys want us to build a train that we don't want. You guys like to tell us how to farm.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
So, hey, I guess maybe I could have an opinion on what you guys should do on BART. So, thought maybe now is a good time for that. Look, I think the issue here is, what about the reforms? And did the Giants just score? Okay. Grand slam. Okay. I mean, look at that, right?
- James Gallagher
Legislator
If I hadn't gotten up to speak, if I hadn't got up to speak, would the Giants win the game? I don't know. I mean, I'm just saying. I realize this is an important issue, and in all seriousness, I think what people are getting at is that there needs to be reforms to the system, and is there enough accountability? And I think, you know, my colleague from San Mateo, right--I wasn't going to say Redwood City because that would be like insulting or something, right?
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Okay, so I said San Mateo. It's all the same. It's all in the Bay Area, right? Yeah. On that note, I had a colleague last year. He's no longer here. The gentleman from Coachella now represents the district, but--I had a little something to do with that, too--but, you know--
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Leader Gallagher, are you going to speak to the merits of this bill, sir?
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Yes, I'm getting there. He once referred to me as the gentleman from parts unknown. Well, I happen to be from East Nicolaus, okay, and as Alex Vassar pointed out, I think there's been five members from East Nicolaus--sorry, from Nicolaus, the town of Nicolaus--and so, you know, we punch above our weight.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
So getting to the point, getting to the point, we need reforms. We need to make sure that mass transit is actually workable and safe, right, before we just put more money into it. But I'll end on this note. Look, I don't want to opine on your guys' issues.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
I don't want to have control over what the Bay Area decides to do. If you guys want to tax yourselves, go for it, right? But that should be--and that should be your decision. And likewise, can we be left out of it because I'm tired of getting taxed for a lot of stuff that I don't want to pay for in East Nicolaus, California. And, you know, I've got a solution to that, too, a new resolution, and we would be happy to just let us go. Okay?
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Our taxes will be lower, we'll pay for services that we actually want, not trains to nowhere, and you guys can pay for your BART system. God bless you. That's all I have to say, Mr. Speaker. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Leader Gallagher. Okay, members, seeing and hearing no--thank you, members--seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Wilson, do you wish to close?
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
I do. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First, I'd like to thank my colleagues from Martinez, San Francisco, the members from Oakland, San Jose, and Menlo Park for speaking to the merits of this bill and lending their voice to the support of so many from the Bay Area Caucus.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
And I appreciate the comments from my colleagues from San Diego, San Mateo, and even East Nicolaus, and being a part of a healthy debate which occurs regularly on this floor and is a part of our own accountability to our members. And I will say to you that accountability is an absolute, important, and critical component of SB 63.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
This bill requires BART, Muni, Caltrain, and AC Transit to tighten their belts by submitting to a comprehensive financial efficiency review with required implementation of cost-saving measures. These operators must adhere to their implementation plans in order to receive funding.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
The bill also requires most transit operators to maintain other operating funding effort from other sources in order to continue to receive funding, ensuring that operators will not supplant operating funding except for State of Good Repair or other narrow exceptions.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
And transportation, in my Transportation Committee, we took some recent amends that require even enhanced local accountability for BART, Muni, Caltrain, and AC Transit. Counties who feel that one of those operators is inconsistently applying standards in their county may petition special ad hoc adjudication committees composed solely of representatives from those counties funding those systems.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
These ad hoc committees will have full decision-making authority over whether to withhold or release up to seven percent of annual funding from the operator as a result of the county's petition. This is in the tens of millions of dollars annually withheld.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
These unprecedented and tough accountability mechanisms are an essential component of a tax measure authorized to go before the voters. Bay Area residents rely on public transit and they deserve the opportunity to make their voices heard on whether the region should invest in safer, cleaner, more reliable, and more integrated public transit system. With that, members, I thank you, and respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Wilson. All debate having ceased, clerk will open the roll. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote. All members vote who desire to vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Ayes 41, noes 19. The measure passes. I believe it would have passed quicker if the Dodgers had won. Okay, Members, we are going to take up AB 154 without reference to file. AB 154 without reference to file. Thank you, Members. Presented by Assembly Member Gabriel.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 154 by the Committee on Budget an act relating to greenhouse gases and making an appropriation, therefore to take effect immediately. Bill related to the budget.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. AB54 is a support support bill without a three minute speech. It clarifies that two recent admissions disclosure laws are exempt from CEQA. Thank you. Respectfully request an Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gabriel. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 58, Noes 0. The measure pass. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, we are now taking up file item number 45. Thank you. File item 45. That's SB 295 by Senator Hurtado, presented by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 295 by Senator Hurtado and others, an act relating to business regulations.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise on behalf of Senator Hurtado to present SB 295, which updates California's antitrust laws to account for algorithms that use confidential competitor data to set prices. This bill applies to algorithms that use non-public competitor data and those that are knowingly distributing or using competitors knowingly using data used by competitors in the same market.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Businesses that take reasonable steps to avoid using unfair pricing algorithms cannot be held liable under the bill. Existing antitrust laws were written to address human conspiracies, not artificial intelligence. SB 295 closes that enforcement gap. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Members, can I have decorum, please? Shhhh. Assembly Member Macedo, you are recognized.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise to oppose SB 295. This measure will further harm farmers and their ability to earn a living. And like I said, I really applauded my colleague that took ag into consideration when drafting his legislation. And unfortunately, ag severely opposes this bill. Devastated by the lack of water and burdensome regulations.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
This measure is another layer of regulations that undermines their ability to farm to put food on every single one of our tables. This bill overturns 100-year-old laws like the Bargaining Act of 1937, Marketing Act of 1937, the Capper-Volstead Act of 1922 that have all helped small farms.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
SB 295 creates significant obstacles and prevents the publication of reports and data. Wine grape growers, for example, publish the Grape Crush Report. The seminal information is used for property appraisals, crop insurance claims, planting and varietal decisions, acreage removal, and much more. This bill would make that report illegal. Workable amendments were proposed to the author but were rejected.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
Agriculture is not just an industry. It is the foundation of food security, rural livelihood, ecological stewardship. We ask for fairness, sustainability, and equity. And when it comes to minority farmers, I asked for my colleagues to look at the opposition that includes the... Let me find it. The African American Farmers of California.
- Alexandra Macedo
Legislator
On behalf of California's farmers and ranchers that include blueberries, citrus, rice, apples, cotton, strawberries, tomatoes, wine grapes, walnuts, pears, pistachios, dates, dairy, agave, olive oil, and so much more, I ask you that if you truly respect ag, you want to keep the cost of food down and want to continue to be farming in California that I urge a no vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Macedo. Assembly Member Tangipa, you are recognized.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I too rise in opposition to this bill. We talked about how cost of living was going to be our number one priority issue. CalChamber has stated that this is a cost driver. We are changing the laws in in how we set pricing for a lot of our food and commodities.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
This will not work. This is a fundamental change and it is very rare that we get to see a large scale coalition actually work together to say this will hurt so many Californians and they are asking you not to fundamentally dismantle something that is in place for almost 100 years simply under the word algorithm. So for those reasons, I respectfully ask you to vote no.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Tangipa. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, do you wish to close?
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. And I appreciate the dialogue with my colleagues from the part of our state that grow... Well I was just say the part of our state that grows much of our food. And I I do appreciate that. I think I share my colleague from Clovis perspective that affordability has to be our top concern.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And one thing that is critical is that we do address the issue with algorithms that are price fixing with non-public data. We don't allow for it to happen in back smoky rooms and we shouldn't allow for it to happen in algorithms. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan has moved the call. Okay, Members, permission was already granted today to take up SB 451 without reference to file.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 451 by Senator Archuleta and others an act relating to gambling.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I'm presenting SB451 on behalf of Senator Archuleta, which provides important clarity around the DOJ's investigatory authority to investigate illegal gambling outside of a licensed gambling establishment, as well as authorize a 50/50 raffle for the Super Bowl.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
This is a technical fix in California's existing code section surrounding 50/50 raffles in regards to our upcoming Super Bowl.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
DOJ has cautioned that without this statutory clarity provided in this bill, the San Francisco 49ers, which I am proud to represent at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara in my Assembly District, and the LA Rams will not be able to host 50/50 raffles at Super Bowls 60 and 61. Members, I respectfully request your Aye vote.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I didn't. I wasn't expecting to speak on this. But. The Member should be ashamed of himself. Gambling cars, heathen stuff. So I respectfully ask the Member to either cry or swear in his remarks.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Jackson. Assembly Member Nguyen, you are recognized.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank the Member from San Jose for speaking on this bill. The fact that we have to discuss this important bill after 10pm is so Ohio. And the way he presented it, though, was so awesome that you slayed it. And with that, I respectfully asked for your Aye vote. And Bingo.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
We all want to get out of here, don't we? We'll keep this lecture short. The faster we get to business, the faster we get out. Thank you, Members. Thank you. Thank you, Members. Thank you, staff. Assemblymember Ahrens, you may close.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill is hella cool. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Ahrens. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes. 58, no 0. The measure passes without reference to file SB53 by Senator Wiener.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 53 by Senator Wiener and others, an act relating to artificial intelligence.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise to present Senate Bill 53 on behalf of Senator Wiener. The bill creates transparency standards for the developers of the most advanced AI systems. Leading AI scientists and AI companies themselves have warned that advanced AI systems could provide expert level advice in designing weapons of mass destruction and in the near future could potentially autonomously take action and endanger life and property.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Many AI companies have already voluntarily committed to handling these risks and several have taken admirable steps to put safeguards in place. But adherence to these commitments has been patchy and there are no legal requirements in place to ensure companies act responsibly.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Last year Governor Newsom created a working group of world leading experts to study a path forward for California. The group produced the California Report on Frontier AI Policy. The report recommended policies that boost transparency into safety practices, pre-deployment testing, requiring incident reporting, and protecting whistleblowers.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
SB 53 is focused only on very large scale risks for the largest of models. They have to create more than $1 billion in damages or cause more than 50 deaths or injuries in a single incident. These are the very risks the report said there was growing evidence for.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
The bill would require companies with very high revenue, 500 million or more, to have trained certain extremely powerful AI models to do four simple things. Have and follow a frontier AI framework, a plan for how to manage catastrophic risks that the company themselves will create. Report on their implementation of that framework.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
For example, by publishing the results of pre-deployment safety tests. Report serious incidents so that we, the government and OES, can react to serious incidents. And protect whistleblowers who come forward to share evidence of dangers.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
This is what the report recommended. This bill has been a heavily negotiated bill by Senator Wiener and has the support of Anthropic and many good AI governance groups. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Assembly Member Ahrens, you are recognized.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in support of my colleague. As the Co-Chair of the Technology and Innovation Caucus, our first duty in legislating on this technology is to ensure that we both protect and drive forward the innovation that makes California special.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
The worst thing that we can do as legislators would be to stifle innovation, and this light touch transparency focused approach that SB 53 takes to AI will not only protect our innovators from burdensome regulations, but actually drive forward development in our state by providing them access to resources through CalCompute. This again, light touch model was not created overnight.
- Patrick Ahrens
Legislator
It took intense scrutiny by the largest tech companies, startups, and our state's brightest academics for the bill to get to this point. There's now the support of large companies like Anthropic and some of the smartest AI engineers and scientists on the planet. I am a yes vote on this bill because it will protect both everyday people and innovators and that we are all proud to call California their home. I respectfully rise in support of SB 53.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Ahrens. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. Do you wish to close?
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I thank my colleague from San Jose for his comments. Are you from San Jose? No. Sorry about that. I don't even know where the Bay Area Members are from, y'all. But I thank you for his comments and I think this is an important measure. I will note that although OpenAI is opposed, their own model recommends an aye vote on this bill. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. I'm going to... All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Excuse me. Excuse me. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll, tally the votes. Ayes 45, noes seven. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, stay with me. File item 156 backs to concurrence AB 531 by Assembly Member Rogers. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 531 by Assembly Member Rogers and others an act relating to energy.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Thanks much, Mr. Speaker. When last this body saw AB 531, we voted on it 79 to 0. The only changes in the Senate were conflicting out language in case Senator Becker's bill ate our bill.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
But other than that, the same policy, the same implementation as when every single person except our newest Member voted for it. To quote my colleague from Indio and from San Mateo from just the other day, geothermal is the future. With that I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Rogers. Assemblymember Hadwick, you are recognized.
- Heather Hadwick
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With respect to my colleague from Santa Rosa, I rise in respectful opposition to AB531. I fully appreciate the intent of this bill and the need to expand geothermal energy in California. Geothermal energy is reliable renewable base food baseload power that is critical to an all of the above energy policy.
- Heather Hadwick
Legislator
Unfortunately, this bill strips meaningful local input away from my communities and hands land use authority to the California Energy Commission. Modoc county and Siskiyou county are home to many sensitive natural and tribal resources. Geothermal projects should be streamlined, but they should not move forward without the support of local decision makers who know their communities best.
- Heather Hadwick
Legislator
Unfortunately, the amendments that we requested to allow a project to be streamlined if it receives a support letter from the local county was not taken and I must respectfully vote no on AB531. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Hadwick seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Member Rogers, do you wish to close?
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Just respectfully disagree. This just adds geothermal projects under 50 megawatts to what we already streamlined for geothermal projects over 50 megawatts, which means that the impact is actually less than if people are forced to take more time and build bigger projects. This allows for renewable energy that doesn't require the sun or wind. It is a 24,7 resource.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Rogers. I'll debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally votes. Ayes 51, Noes 5. Senate amendments are concurred in file item 157. That's A.B.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 630 by Assembly Member Mark González and others, an act relating vehicles.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is my last one. You're welcome. AB 630 is back on concurrence. I hope you've all had a chance to read the bill. This bill seeks to aid local governments in addressing the complicated issue of inoperable RVs that often present significant public health and safety risk.
- Mark Gonzalez
Legislator
The Senate amendments limit the bill to LA and Alameda County, expand the existing notification requirements, and provide towing and storage fees relief for RVs that are wrongfully impounded. This bill has received bipartisan support. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member González. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 65, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There is a message from the Senate at the desk. I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow Assembly Members of the to take up AB 715 without reference to file. For the purpose of concurrence in Senate amendments that objection. There is a Committee report at the desk.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow Assemblymember Fong to take up SB48 Gonzales without reference to file. For the purposes of a third reading today that objection.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Okay. Members, without reference to file. We will be taking up AB 715 by Assembly Members Zbur. The Clerk will read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 715 by Assembly Members Zbur and others an act relating to education
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, please ask for decorum. Thank you. Members, please take your conversations off the floor. Thank you, Members.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, AB 715 is back on concurrence. This bill is jointly authored with our colleague from Morro Bay. It is the only priority bill for the Jewish Caucus this year. And I want to thank Members of the Senate who just passed this bill out of the Senate on a 35-0 vote.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
There's been a massive 893% increase in antisemitic hate crimes in the United States over the past 10 years, and California schools are not immune to this. And it's accelerated since the October 7th massacre. Jewish students and families are facing a crisis of hate in California schools. In Manhattan Beach, a swastika and antisemitic slurs were spray painted on an elementary school playground.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
In San Francisco Unified School District, teachers were provided materials that justified Hamas's October 7 attack. In Tarzana, swastikas were painted on a fence banner outside an elementary school. The parents, not wanting their kids to see the swastikas, painted over them with hearts. But then the people came back a few days later and painted them so big that they couldn't be covered up.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
When they notified the school, the school did nothing. And it wasn't until local elected officials raised a fuss that the school did anything to act to prevent these kids from having to see the swastikas as they started school. In the Santa Ana Unified School District, a curriculum committee debated the so called Jewish question.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Committee members refused to acknowledge Hamas as a terrorist organization, and the administration scheduled public meetings on Jewish holidays to discuss curriculum that they knew would be objectionable to the Jewish community. In Mount Tamalpais School District, students were told that there were too many Jews in the district.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
At Menlo Park Atherton High School, lessons were taught that minimized and shared incorrect information about the Holocaust, contained stereotypical images of Jews, and showed antisemitic tropes of Jews as controlling world events with puppet strings.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
In Hayward, a teacher taught an antisemitic document that alleges Jewish control of foreign affairs through satanic powers, titled the Hidden Tyranny, and subtitled, quote, the Satanic power which promotes and directs chaos in order to lay low all civilization in preparation for a well outlined plan of world dictatorship.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
As an introduction to a required unit about Night by Elie Wiesel. The same teacher did the Nazi salute multiple times in class. Multiple students and teachers complained multiple times and yet the teacher remained teaching in the class for over two months after the initial complaint was logged. Even then, the teacher was never fired.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Rather, he was placed on administrative leave, given the opportunity to resign, reached a settlement that did not find the teacher to have engaged in misconduct, and paid through until almost a full year after he was first placed on leave. All of this was done under the guise of academic freedom and teaching students to think critically. These are not isolated incidents. They're becoming more frequent and widespread.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And not a week goes by that I don't hear about more incidents from my own constituents. When I served as Executive Director of Equality California, we worked alongside educators, parents, and many colleagues here in this room to pass laws to protect LGBTQ students from bullying, harassment, and discrimination and to ensure that every child could learn in a safe and supported environment.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
During my first year in the Legislature, I authored AB 5, which gave educators the tool they need to help foster inclusive classroom environments and appropriately address the unique challenges that the LGBTQ students and all students face. When vulnerable communities are facing discrimination, the Legislature has always acted quickly and decisively to protect them.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
AB 715 acknowledges that Jewish students are facing an acute problem while also fighting discrimination against other communities. I'm proud to say that this landmark bill creates an Office of Civil Rights, which will include multiple coordinators who will serve and benefit not only the Jewish community, but all of the communities we must protect under our anti-discrimination laws.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
These coordinators will focus on assessing discrimination that's occurring in schools, providing recommendations to the Legislature, the Governor, and school districts, and providing our educators and administrators with the tools they need to uplift all students. This bill should not be controversial. This bill is about values we all share. Safety, dignity, and equality for all of our students.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
We have a responsibility to make sure that every child in California can attend a school that is safe, respectful, and affirming. AB 715 will get us closer to achieving that. Thank you very much. And I'd like to respect an aye vote at the appropriate time.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Zbur. Assembly Member Addis, you are recognized.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise on behalf of the California Legislative Jewish Caucus and as joint author of AB 715, a bill that just left the Senate with 35 votes. As most of you know, I spent 21 years of my career as a classroom teacher, both as a teacher, a teacher leader, a CTA member, a CTA member of my local school district, a site rep, and executive board member.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And during my career, I fought for teachers. We made huge gains in working conditions and wages. And during that same career, I got to teach hundreds and hundreds of students. Students with special needs and neurotypical students, students who are primary English speakers and those who are learning English as an additional language.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
I taught students in poverty and students from wealthy backgrounds, as well as students who are housed and unhoused, and from a variety of family structures and beliefs and perspectives. And I also taught students at every single grade level, 1st through 12th, across English and math and history, social science and science.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And in many of my positions, I was the singular person who was teaching a child to do something for the very first time, helping them step beyond what they believed that they could do, as their skills grew academically and socially and emotionally.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And what I know to be true is that each time I set foot on a school campus or in a classroom, I was there for one singular reason, and that was to ensure that students left their time with me having learned. And what the data says about learning is that it happens best when students have two things.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
When they have a trusted adult in the school environment, and when they have a classroom and a school community that is safe, that is supportive, welcoming, and affirming. And when those two things are in place, learning is unleashed and we allow children to become the very best of who they are.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
But unfortunately, the picture I've tried to paint for you here is simply not the reality for too many Jewish students who today face increasingly dangerous antisemitic rhetoric, tropes, discrimination, and even physical attacks in our public schools. And I'd like to share just one of those stories this evening. Mr. Speaker, may I have permission to read?
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
My name is Ella. I'm a Bay Area native and have been living there all my life. When I was a seventh grader in a public middle school in San Jose, I learned firsthand about antisemitism. It had changed my life. From a happy middle schooler with many friends, I was reduced to loneliness and abuse.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
All of my friends turned their backs on me. They called me the Jew. They yelled at me that I am a murderer and that Jews are terrorists. I was made fun of, harassed, and followed around when I spoke in Hebrew. None of this was something that I did.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
I was the same child as before when they were my friends. They hated me just because of my identity, my religion, my parents' nationality. I did not say or do anything to deserve this. At first, I hoped that the school staff would help and protect me.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
But some teachers and board members continued to say and do biased things that made it seem like Jews are bad people, giving additional fuel to the students who said awful things about me. With my parents, we attempted to ask for help to stop the harassment. We tried the counselor, the assistant principal, the principal.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And they did not take action. And as the weeks went by, the situation only got worse. And some days I had to stay home. I couldn't stand it and feared for my own safety. And finally, at the end of the semester, my parents withdrew me from the public school school and enrolled me in a private Jewish school.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
I was 12 years old when I lost trust in peers, friendship, adults, and good intentions. And I ask you today to ensure no other student goes through the pain I went through and still carry with me. So, colleagues, we ask ourselves tonight on this floor what we can do.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And what we can do is start with a common sense bill, AB 750, that recognizes our need to address antisemitism in schools. It creates an Office of Civil Rights within the Office of Government Operations that will house an antisemitism coordinator along with other coordinators that you'll learn about in a separate bill tonight.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
It also offers tools for prevention like a website to access resources about antisemitism prevention and helps define pathways to respond when antisemitism arises. And I'll say the prevention and education in this bill are vital because Jewish people make up only 2 to 3% of the population.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
But discrimination and violence against Jewish people is in the double digits. And many do not know how to recognize antisemitism when it occurs. And we do want to make one clarification about the Office of Civil Rights and why it's placed in the Gov Ops. AB 715 originally was proposed as being placed under the State Board of Education.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
However, the administration made it clear that the SBE as an 11 member policy making board with a small staff would be an inappropriate location for the OCR because it was inconsistent with the long standing role and purpose of the SBE, among other reasons.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And so we ultimately agreed that the work of the OCR is not consistent with the State Board of Education's role or function and should not be housed there. And the administration expressed openness to housing the OCR at Gov Ops after being made to understand that the caucus, Senate leadership, and diverse stakeholders had considered and set aside other options.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
So the caucus believes that Gov Ops is a good and workable option. So colleagues, in closing, AB 715 is about ensuring that every student, Jewish students and others, have the best learning environment that the Golden State has to offer. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Addis. Assembly Member Carrillo, you are recognized.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise on behalf of the California Latino Legislative Caucus in support of AB 715. This important bill reflects collaboration and partnership between our caucuses to help protect against antisemitism and discrimination in schools across California. As a proud Latino, I know that our cultures share the same deep values of family, tradition, and resiliency.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
And our struggles, as well as the struggles of those who came before us, are core pieces of our cultural identity. I also know that a threat of hatred to any one community is a threat to all and to the values of our communities we hold dear. Because of this, I am proud to stand in solidarity with my colleagues today to condemn antisemitism and support AB 715. And I want to share with you a personal experience that happened to me in a classroom.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
And by no means am I comparing my experience to what Jewish students have experienced in a classroom. This was during Proposition 187. I was in community college, early 90s, mid-90s. And in the middle of a lecture, one of my colleagues in the classroom, one of my classmates, excuse me. He made a comment. He said that he wished I was here legally. This was in the middle of Proposition 187. I experienced that in a classroom.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
And again, by no means am I comparing that experience with what our Jewish community experiences in the classroom. That is one reason why I stand here united. Because again, I don't know what experiences, what it feels like to be in a classroom as a child and being discriminated just because of where you come from or what your culture is.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
That's why I'm here in solidarity with you. Because I know what it's like to be pointed in the middle of a class and a classmate wishing that I was there legally as a student. Again, Proposition 187, I'm sure you guys remember that. With that, I respectfully asked for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Carrillo. Assembly Member Gipson, you are recognized.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise also to lend my voice in support of AB 715 and thank the author from Los Angeles, Member Zbur, for one, working the long hours and days and years putting this together and collaborating with so many people. And also to the Jewish Caucus for making this their number one priority and bringing in all the diversity caucuses that exist in this institution together and collaborating, trying to find a yes.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Trying to find the middle ground that we can all come together around your priority caucus. So I appreciate the work that has gone into this measure. As the author has stated, this bill makes it necessary to step to a step to protect our children from attacks in the classroom here in California and create an Office of Civil Rights. You know, can you imagine we have to do this here in California?
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
I mean, it's like we are the fourth largest economy and we're talking about 2025 creating the Office of Civil Rights here in California. Things must be absolutely bad, but we have to do this. Oh, we just had someone get assassinated. We just had a shooting that took place in a school here in this country. You know, we're talking about people being kidnapped in United States of America. But we have to do all these things that we didn't have to do, but we have to.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
We find ourselves in this space right now. We have to do it. And to be a child in a school, that's a place for kids to go and learn. They didn't come into this world hating people. They didn't come into this world feeling like, you know, knowing discrimination. That's a learned behavior where they're getting this stuff from adults. Children should be going to school, being children and learning and not picking up and being bullied.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
That's the place that it should not be. That should be a safe place. Now, I don't know what it means to feel like being a Jewish child and being and coming home and feeling the way they're feeling. But it's our responsibility to make sure as lawmakers that we have our schools to be a place where these children can learn and grow and not feel intimidated and not feel least and not feel less than.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
So this bill creates this Office of Civil Rights to engage and seek the kind of advice from the discrimination and prevention coordinator that's necessary to step in and protect our students as well as our teachers. And let me just also simply say this again, my gratitude, my thanks to those who put this together.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
I heard the debates and listened attentively, the dialogue that went on in the Senate, 35 to 0. And that's a great thing. And I hope that we can also support our colleagues, our brothers and sisters, by having this bill passed today because I believe it's the right thing to do.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
But people are looking at what we do here today, and I'm hoping that we can, one, rally and send a strong message of not only solidarity, but we need to also show that we can be together in the midst of adversity. We can be together and also show the rest of the world how we can come together around something that is so difficult, even when it comes down to our schools, something that our children are going through.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Again, our children should go to be able to go to school and in a safe environment, not only from gun violence, but also from bullying, hate, like what's taking place today in our schools. So Members, I respectfully ask for an aye vote and thank the Jewish Caucus for bringing this sensible measure before us today.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gipson. Assembly Member Fong, you are recognized.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. As a co-author and as Chair of the AAPI legislative caucus, I rise in support of AB 715. I want to thank my colleagues from Los Angeles and San Luis Obispo and the Jewish Caucus and colleagues in diversity caucuses for the collaborative work and efforts on this bill.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
A firm commitment to combat antisemitism and all forms of discrimination and hate, to uplift classroom environments, ensuring that all students and teachers have an opportunity to thrive. The COVID 19 pandemic gave rise to thousands of acts of hate towards the AAPI community, and I appreciate the solidarity during those challenging times. And we know all too well the impact of hate violence on our community and our students.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Continue to stand in solidarity with any community targeted by hate, racism, and bigotry. AB 715 will create an Office of Civil Rights that allows civil rights coordinators to receive guidance and assistance for discrimination cases brought under violations of the Education Code. Children and students should feel safe and supported in our schools. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on AB 715. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Fong. Assembly Member Muratsuchi, you are recognized.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I regretfully rise to raise serious concerns about this measure. And I want to first start off by thanking the authors of AB 715, who have worked tirelessly for the last more than two years to fight antisemitism not only in our public schools, but across the State of California and across the country.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
I have been proud to work with my Jewish communities in the Los Angeles area for over 30 years to fight hate, to fight antisemitism. Going back to the 1990s when I was the regional director of the Japanese American Citizens League, and we saw a dramatic rise in anti-Asian hate.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
And I reached out to groups like the Anti Defamation League, the Jewish Federation of Los Angeles, and others in the Los Angeles area Jewish community to join together to fight our common enemy of hate in our communities. And I know I did the same thing during the COVID pandemic when we saw the dramatic rise in anti-Asian hate again during the COVID pandemic.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
Who did I reach out to? I reached out to the ADL because, as I said then and I'll say now, you know, unfortunately, the Jewish community knows hate as well as any community. But we cannot and should not advance a measure that comes at the expense of of public education.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
Especially in these times when we need to create environments, classrooms where our students can have safe and supportive environments to be able to engage in the most difficult conversations on the most controversial topics. As Chair of the Education Committee, I can tell all of you that it is extremely rare when both when all of the education advocacy, the statewide education advocacy organizations in the State of California rise together in opposition to a bill.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
These organizations include the Association of California School Administrators, representing our superintendents and our principals, the California County Superintendents, the California School Boards Association, the California Federation of Teachers, the California Faculty Association, and of course, the California Teachers Association. All of these groups have taken the position of opposition to this measure. And they all, if you look at their opposition letters, they all talk about a common theme. Permission to read, Mr. Speaker?
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
For example, I'm looking at the letter from the California School Boards Association. And they state that while California schools and county offices of education are committed to creating and maintaining environments where students can learn and explore complex and sometimes controversial topics in a safe and supportive environment.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
AB 715 will have a chilling effect on classroom instruction. We firmly believe that AB 715 will instead create an environment that discourages open inquiry and critical thought. Its provisions will make it more difficult for educators to deliver nuanced instruction on complex and timely issues.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
It goes on to state that the threat of complaints and investigations that would follow the implementation of this measure may lead educators to avoid controversial subjects altogether, which would ultimately narrow the curriculum and undermine student learning.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
So we had a long and thoughtful hearing in the Education Committee on AB 715 today. And I asked the authors, we have this bill that I completely support the intent to fight antisemitism, to make sure that every child, including Jewish children, feel safe in our California schools. Let's fix this bill.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
I asked for it to be made into a two year bill so that we can address all of these concerns being raised by the statewide education organizations. And so I continue to ask the authors, we need to... I think there is a consensus that we need to fix the bill. Unfortunately, we've heard that too many times.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
And so, unfortunately, I am not able to support this measure today.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, you are recognized.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise in support of AB 715. And I want to begin by thanking our colleague from Torrance for highlighting the numerous ways that the Jewish community has stood with our brother and sisters that sit on this floor and outside this building when they have experienced hate.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Because, as he said, our community knows just as well as most what it means to feel hate and discrimination and bias. And so we have at every turn stood with anybody who's experiencing hate because we know that hate against one is hate against all.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And so when we brought this bill, I never imagined in a million years the two years of fights we would have to try to bring a bill to this floor to protect our children. I just imagined that just like I had stood with my colleagues and their children and grandchildren, they would stand with mine.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And last May, after I came home from a hard day, hearing about the hard meetings where people were still pushing back on us. And my daughter walks into the kitchen and says mom, my teacher came in and said, don't go in the bathroom because you'll find swastikas all over it at our school. I had to reckon with the fact that there were people inside and outside this building that didn't understand or frankly care to protect my child.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Shame on you. You all know my story. I was raised by amazing women who had to flee the only country they knew because otherwise they would have been gassed and burned in crematoriums. My grandmother would talk, always start her story with her charmed childhood. Playing tennis, dancing, her beloved dog, trips to the mountains in Austria.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And then she would turn to her classroom and she would talk about what happened after the Nazis came to occupy Austria till the day she was kicked out of school. She never graduated from high school because the Nazis wouldn't let her continue school. And then she came to this country.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
She watched a perfect childhood turn into everyone's worst nightmare. She lost her own beloved grandmother in the Holocaust. And so, as I see my daughter having to face swastikas, the flags that were raised to begin the death of my relatives, in her own California classroom, I refused to sit here and let you talk about this not being a crisis and asking us to wait a third year to do something to protect our children.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
They deserve better from their representatives. They deserve to be protected. They deserve to be safe and to learn. And I don't know how many bills on this floor in the last seven days you voted on that weren't perfect, but I bet there were a lot of them. But you believed it was a problem worth solving.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
You believed it was something to work on, and so you voted for them. This deserves your vote because our children deserve to be safe. My children deserve to show up at school and not have to face hate crimes in their building, to face the symbols that represented the end of their relatives.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
But I also want to talk about my friends, so many whom have spoken here, so many who care so deeply about my children and everybody's children, who have stood with us without equivocation, who have given us their word that they would protect our children and are today.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And I want to thank every single one of you because I get to go home tomorrow, look my children in the eye, and tell them that the vast majority of the California Legislature cares about them and wants them to be safe and is willing to stand up even when it's hard.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
And the other day, as I had to sit in the education Committee and listen to one of the teachers union advocates talk about how he opposed this Bill because it represents the supremacy of the Jewish people, the anti Semitism was dripping off of him, and yet many of you seem compelled by that.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Every single one of you needs to look in the mirror and stand up for every child in California, including mine.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, Assemblymember Patel, you are recognized.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Today I rise in support of AB750. You've all heard me talk about my experience as a school board trustee, and those years often inform how I approach problems and challenges that we face at home and here in the state Legislature.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
At the beginning of my school board journey, the guiding light I was given by a more experienced trustee than me was that our primary job was to ensure the safety of all of our children, because if children aren't safe, they're not learning. Similarly, in California, if our civil rights are not protected, we are not thriving.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
We are seeing on the ground right now a real need from our children, a need that we have not yet met.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
We are seeing anti Semitism continue to proliferate and grow without instituting the change that is necessary to ensure that the Jewish community understands that they are valued, that they are safe, and that antisemitism does not have a place in California.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
It's important to recognize that the Jewish Caucus worked very hard and in good faith to incorporate the diverse perspectives and move towards a more workable version of this bill. And as I've learned, this has been a very long journey. It started even before I got here, not just this year.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I also want to acknowledge that the diversity caucuses and leaders, as well as key stakeholders, have put in a substantial amount of collaborative effort. And trust me, I understand there are concerns about this bill still. I have concerns about oversight and implementation.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I have concerns additionally that we are not able to effectively use our uniform complaint process and are in this difficult position now where we must consider different pathways to ensure timely action to combat anti Semitism and frankly, all kinds of hate that are going on right now in our classrooms and on our school grounds.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
Like many of the bills we pass, neither the process nor the outcome have been perfect. I've learned that very quickly as a freshman here. But because so much harm persists among our children, we cannot let the perfect be the enemy of good and we can no longer delay.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I look forward to engaging with all relevant stakeholders and to be a good faith collaborator to work on future legislation and improvements upon this one to ensure that all kids feel safe in school so they can learn and thrive. What I don't often share on this ground, on this floor is my own personal experience.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
A lot of it was very warm. But I'm going to share a little hard story, one that I don't often talk about. When I was in elementary school, I thought I fit in. I did well in school and I had friends.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I didn't know any different until a new kid came into the school and repeatedly open over several weeks called me a pagan. I didn't know what a pagan was. It wasn't a word we used at home. I had never heard it before. And then repeatedly I was called a greasy Indian. I never saw myself as other.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
In fact, I was the only person of color in my grade level at that elementary school, four classrooms, the only person of color. I never saw myself as other until others said hateful things to me. But the really sad thing is I never told my parents.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I never told my family, because as immigrants, we didn't think we could question the system or raise complaints. We didn't even know how. By having this conversation, we start to share with people that there is a process and that process just might work.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
We've come a long way since then and certainly we really have a long way to go. But with all of this before you, I can't help but respectfully ask for an Aye vote on AB17. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Patel, Assembly Member Lee, you are recognized.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Anti Semitism has no place in the civilized world. It is disgusting, it is vile, and unfortunately it is too much fueled by the modern alt right that is inspired by the same symbols of hate that inspired the same fascists over 100 years ago.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
I would never say anything but the best of intentions from the authors and the Jewish Caucus who worked tirelessly in so many different meetings and so much to try to make a workable bill to address the very real issue of anti Semitism in our schools, just as every other hate that exists on our campuses.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
And I know that a lot of the outcome of processes was out of your hands and it was not the Bill that you wanted and envisioned at the end of the day.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
But there still are many outstanding issues that have been brought up in Committee on the Senate Floor and even this floor today that make me seriously uncomfortable, especially pointing to the part where they talk about factually accurate.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
I have many teachers, many friends, sorry, many friends who are teachers, and they tell me all the time how kids say the darndest things. They are very much on social media and TikTok and very much influenced by what's happening there. And they say some of the craziest things about modern society.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
And I wonder, in this framework, this bill, how does a teacher going forward talk about the Russian invasion, Ukraine? How do they talk about the racist kidnappings and Ayes deportations that are happening on our streets, which we have even heard disputed facts on the streets? And how do they go about talking about that?
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Multiple Israeli human rights organizations have called what's happening in Gaza a genocide. How did they talk about the ICC courts issuing war criminal warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu? These are things that have happened in real life.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
And I fear that our children are not in a place where they can discuss with an adult, an educated adult, about complex things, or else they turn to places that fuel extremism, that fuel misinformation and disinformation. So I think about lots of these times, these bills, how will they translate into the classroom?
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Like my friends who are teachers, I think that all the work, and I appreciate all the work that the authors of Los Angeles and Morro Bay and the caucus have done are very important work. But there's still so many outstanding questions that I cannot support the bill today.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
So I really hope that we'll continue, and I understand there will be a cleanup Bill Later on, that we continue to get those issues that we've acknowledged that need to be worked on. Right?
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Because it is so important that we balance making sure that, yes, hateful teachers and neo Nazis are punished and held accountable, but we have to make sure our kids are able to talk about complex things with the responsible adults as well.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
So I appreciate all the input and all the meetings that even some that I've been part of, that you have all worked very hard in this field.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
And I acknowledge that your motivations have always been pure, that you have always sought to protect every single kid, no matter what kind of Semitism and conspiracy theories that even my colleagues have been thrown at them. I totally respect the incredible work you've been doing, but just today, I cannot support the bill. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Lee. Assemblymember Bryan, you are recognized
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues. This is probably the most difficult bill for me to talk on this entire session. If you know the neighborhoods I represent in the district I come from, we are one of the most diverse districts in the State of California.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In fact, the most densely populated Jewish neighborhood on the West Coast is in my district. And it's special. And I want to thank some of my mentors and friends, my rabbis Kunowski, Joel Braus, Irving, so many folks who have talked to me in the last several months.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Before I talk about the bill specifically, I want to talk about some of the things that were said on this floor that I slightly disagree with, and nobody back home would be upset with me for speaking truth. When there is a crisis, we don't actually always respond and solve it.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
If we did, there would be no more black men killed by police. In fact, for 45 years, we've been trying to convince folks that criminalizing poverty is more expensive, more harmful and more dangerous than putting resources into communities that would alleviate it.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
For the Black Caucus and for black folks in this country, nothing that is a crisis for us is ever solved very quick.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And almost every time we are fighting by ourselves an uphill battle with our friends and allies, finding reasons not to support us in this one moment, and yet we stand in allyship and solidarity because that is who we are. That is the best of who we should all be.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
There's a couple of things that this bill is not. This bill is not a proxy for the over 1200 people who lost their lives on October 7th. It is not a proxy for the nearly 300 hostages who were taken, many of whom who still haven't been returned.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
This bill is also not a proxy for the most disproportionate war response I've ever seen in my lifetime that has destroyed basic survival infrastructure for tens of thousands of people in Gaza. This bill is not a proxy for either of those things. This bill also won't solve antisemitism.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In fact, my good neighbor to the west of me mentioned painting swastikas on the side of schools. This will not solve that kind of hate. Scheduling meetings on Jewish holidays. This will not solve that kind of ignorance. In fact, even here in the Legislature, we have had to adjust our scheduling to that recognition in recent years.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
We all can and should do better to be more conscious, to be more aware and to root out anti Semitism wherever we see it. And we cannot legislate that away. That is something each of us individually has to commit to doing.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
What this bill is looking to do is address the anti Semitism that is occurring in our classrooms, the unwelcoming and unsafe place that so many students feel. And I've seen what that feels like.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
When things were going down on the number one public University in our state, UCLA, I took my colleague from San Francisco and my colleague from San Jose. We met with students in the encampment and then we went to the Hillel and the same day and talked to everybody who was involved.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
We didn't tell folks we were talking to everybody, but that's what we did. And we saw and we heard and we witnessed what hate, what intolerance, what antisemitism, what bigotry, what violence looked like to all of the students. And all of those experiences were very valid and real.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I can only imagine what it feels like for kids in our primary schools and middle schools. This bill also didn't happen overnight. When the Jewish Caucus approached many of us in the other caucuses, we sat down and we had very honest and Frank and direct conversations.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I can't tell you how many hours, including my wedding anniversary recently, I spent late at night with my colleagues talking about these circumstances. And when we said, no, ethnic studies is not the problem. It is not a problem.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Learning the histories of of black and Brown and API and indigenous people in this state, that is not the problem, the Jewish Caucus pivoted. And when we said, you can't define an antisemitic learning environment that fast, that is a very complicated endeavor. It involves a lot of consideration. The Jewish Caucus pivoted.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Even now as we raise final questions and concerns with things like teachings that are factually accurate when we're talking about history, because we know history is told by the victors. Old African proverb, until the lion learns to read and write, the story will always glorify the hunter.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
A good mentor of mine, Professor at UCLA, David Myers, who I go to Shabbat service often at B' Nai David Judea back in my district, talks about the joint scholarship between Palestinian scholars and Israeli scholars telling the shared histories of the same events and how neither universities in Gaza or universities in Israel would share those texts as factually accurate.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Recognizing that these are the challenges and concerns in the learning environment and how we still have work to do. Again, the Jewish Caucus has stepped up to that moment and been willing to have these hard conversations.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And for all of that work and all of that labor, I could not sit here and not vote for this bill. Solidarity and allyship isn't just a set of words. It is a set of actions. And today I'm going to vote for this measure.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And I have full confidence and trust in my colleagues that we can navigate this. We can root out anti Semitism everywhere else we see it, and we can take on all of the challenges that impact struggling people and vulnerable people and. And targeted people in California whenever we see it. And I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Bryan. Assemblymember Haney, you are recognized.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Like my colleagues who are part of the Jewish Caucus, I was raised in a Jewish family. And like I'm sure all of them, my Jewish identity has always guided me. It is in many ways the reason why I stand here today on this floor.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
It taught me to stand up for those who are targeted because of who they are, to speak against injustice and to never remain silent in the face of hate. The experience of Jewish people in this country and around the world and across history is what gives many of us our commitment to fight for fairness and against injustice.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I think often of my grandfather, who many of you, if not all of you, have met. 97 years old, a World War II veteran, he grew up in Minnesota in the 1930s at a time when being Jewish made you a target.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
He would tell me stories of walking home from school as a little boy and being chased, harassed, beaten up simply for being Jewish. He remembered the bruises, the blood, the fear, and he carried that pain with him his entire life. And he would say to me, we can never go back to a world like that.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And yet, Members, we see the dangerous signs all around us that anti Semitism again is rising, not in faraway places, but here, in our neighborhoods, in our communities, online, and in our schools. Jewish students who I have heard from directly, who we have met with directly, are being taunted, harassed, excluded, teachers reporting hateful incidents, statistics going up.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
But behind every number is a child, just like my grandfather was, who deserves to be safe when they walk into school. Antisemitism is a scourge, not just because of the individuals who it targets, but because we know that it is one of the oldest and most poisonous hatreds on Earth. It fuels violence, division and fear.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And it is an attack not only on Jews, but it is an attack on the very idea of pluralism, of democracy, of community. History has taught us again and again that when anti Semitism grows, it it never stops with the Jewish community. It spreads, it corrodes, it puts every minority at risk.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
That is why we cannot and must not ignore it. We must confront it. I've heard from many about this bill. I've heard that it is not perfect. And I would agree. I think we would all agree that. I heard there's more work to do, and I agree with that. But this bill will provide us with a framework.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
It will put a stake in the ground that we are committed to providing the tools, the training, the supports and the accountability that are needed to protect Jewish students, to identify and prevent anti Semitism, and to create classrooms where every child, no matter who they are, can learn in safety and dignity.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
But I do want to pause and recognize some of the particular concerns that I've heard that I think we do need to take seriously and we need to ensure do not come to pass.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I've heard from many who worry that this bill will be misused to police legitimate and important conversations about Israel and to conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism, to stifle debate or critical thinking. And I want to say very clearly that those concerns are real, and I also share many of them.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Our classrooms must remain places of dialogue, of debate, of inquiry. Students and teachers must feel free to ask hard questions, to challenge, to criticize, including to criticize Israel, as I have done, as many in the Jewish Caucus have done, as many on this floor have done. That is not anti Semitism. That is democracy.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Our classrooms must be places where young people are encouraged to think critically, to wrestle with history, to test ideas, to confront injustice, and, yes, to disagree with each other. This law must never be used to silence criticism of Israel or to have honest, sometimes difficult conversations about Israel's history.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Nor should it be used to shut down dialogue about Palestine, war crimes in Gaza, or even Zionism. That kind of critical debate is not only acceptable, it is essential to education.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And I know that for those of us who are going to support this bill today, there is much work to do, including to ensure that this law is not misused, that we stand against antisemitism, we, while also protecting open dialogue. Those are not contradictions. We can and must do both.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
That's how we best protect Jewish students and all students and protect our democracy. We are committed today to confronting antisemitism and supporting a safe environment in our schools. And also always standing with open dialogue, with the ability to criticize, because that's what a democracy is all about.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I support this bill today for my grandfather, who endured a childhood of discrimination and exclusion like millions and millions of Jews before and after him.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
For the Jewish students in our schools today who deserve to be safe and valued for who they are, and for every child in California who should walk into a classroom knowing they are protected, respected and free to learn. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Haney. Assembly Member Garcia, you are recognized.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank the author for bringing AB17 to us here on the floor today and to Committee earlier. And first, I want to acknowledge Mr. Speaker and your comments.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
It is a very real crisis, as he said, and there's rising anti Semitism and there is definitely harm and a lot of fear and a lot of hurt. But I don't believe that you fix a very real problem with policy that is rushed that we haven't seen and that would have very real unintended consequences.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
I do support the bill's core values to foster a safe and more inclusive learning environment for students. But I have concerns like or just shared about the massive oversight and censorship and it will have on our teachers and the threat it imposes on academic freedom.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
In its current form, this bill only reinforces broader national trends of silencing constitutionally protected speech, erasing historically relevant curriculum, and persecuting anyone who expresses even the slightest opposition to the federal Administration. As other states continue to implement legislation that aligns closely with that of the Administration, California must do better.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
Unfortunately, this resembles the types of book bans we're seeing throughout the country. Like in Florida, where they passed the law to restrict discussions of race or sexism in the classroom, Trump's Administration aims to pass curriculum that would systemically remove the realities of white supremacy and slavery that has permeated throughout this country.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
These conversations have all been considered controversial. Avoiding them has not solved the problem. It has only permeated the division we are seeing now.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
The classroom is precisely the place where difficult conversations should take place so our students can begin to develop the necessary skills and resources they need to navigate controversy and understand the complex world we live in.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
Unfortunately, the broad language and use of vague, undefined terms throughout the bill will likely create an environment of fear, scrutiny, and confusion for many teachers, forcing them to avoid introducing complex discussions and materials into the classroom at all.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
Instead, we should provide our teachers and counselors with the tools they need to help facilitate controversial discussions, especially at a time when public education is under attack from the Current Federal Administration and the Department of Education is being defunded. Again, I appreciate the intent and the work that has gone into this bill.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
I know it has been said that it's over two years. However, I have only been here eight and a half months and I know that it was only until three days ago that we got to see the bill that we're going to be voting on today. We cannot use a one size fits all approach.
- Robert Garcia
Legislator
And unfortunately this bill does not live up to the standards of fairness and equity in the classroom. And for these reasons, I respectfully oppose this bill.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Garcia, Assemblymember Gallagher, you are recognized.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, Members. You know, this really shouldn't be that hard. When you read the bill and what it actually does.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
I hear this discussion and I think it's worth having that discussion about speech and about school children and in the public space being able to have a civil discussion about world issues, about what's going on in Israel and in Gaza. This bill doesn't affect any of that.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
It actually says when you're going to be providing instruction or when you're going to have school sponsored activities that you don't discriminate, you don't have discriminatory instruction in those schools. That's what it focuses on.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And that is a real issue because I think we all know, and we saw it firsthand, that we had people who celebrated what happened on October 7, and some of those people are in our schools and actually did get into our schools and actually did do instruction those schools and brought in instructional materials that absolutely were anti Semitic.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And that's the reason why we have to have this bill so that we ensure that in our schools we don't have agendas, hateful agendas, being taught to our kids. And again, time and time again in this bill, in this legislation, that's what it focuses on, that's what it tries to regulate.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
I unfortunately have a teacher in Reading that just was saying that it was okay what happened to Charlie Kirk, that he deserved it. That's the kind of crap that we're talking about that has no place in our I don't want your opinion, I don't want the teacher's opinion, political views, agendas in our classroom. They don't belong there.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
I want factually accurate information. And that is also sort of part of the problem that we've had. When we talk about history or when we talk about world events, there's a lot of nuance there. We do, when we talk about history, have to talk about the good, the bad and the ugly.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Unfortunately, in recent times, instead of doing that, we've tried to advance these pedagogies of oppressor versus oppressed and put different people groups into one category or the other. And it's wrong. It's not accurate. Number one.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And it causes the kind of discriminatory instruction that has occurred either based on race, based on religion and yes, anti Semitism in the classroom. That's why this Bill is needed. So to me that's not really hard. And I think we're talking about things that actually aren't the case. Nobody's talking about shutting down people's views on world events.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
They're saying that when we have instruction and we have school sponsored events, they need to be factually accurate. I don't think that's too much to ask. And to my colleague across the aisle who tried to make this about the alt right and that anti Semitism only exists on the right. Give me a break, man.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
Where we've seen some of the most vile anti Semitism lately has been on the left. It's been among the progressives, so called progressives who have been not allies in any way. But I'm not trying to make it about right or left. Antisemitism is an ugly thing that has existed on both sides of the political spectrum at times.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
I don't need to remind you of the antisemitism in the Communist party in Russia. Or in more recent times at the California Democratic Party convention. And I'm sorry, but I'm going to say what's true and what's factual. It needs to be called out on both sides when we see it.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And again, another reason for this Bill because when it starts to creep in into our establishments, into our schools, it needs to be called out. It needs to be rooted out. It needs to be stopped. That's why we need this Bill. That's why I'm supporting it.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And you know, we do need to go a little bit further and really assess what are we teaching in our schools. We need to treat the true history, the good, the bad and the ugly and not agendas. And unfortunately there's a whole lot of agendas in our classroom these days, too many.
- James Gallagher
Legislator
And this could be the first step towards fixing that problem. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assemblymember Gallagher, Assemblymember McKinnor, you are recognized.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise to support AB 715. I support this Bill because I believe in schools being safe for kids. I believe in our kids being safe. When I close my eyes and I listen to the stories tonight, I could have swore we were talking about black folks experience here in America.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
And I feel for my sister from Orendo, I was going to say Bakersfield, but Orendo because last year I stood on the same floor as we voted on a Bill AB 1990, a warrantless arrest. And I felt that pain. So I know the pain of asking people to take care of my babies.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
This is going to harm my babies. I know what that feels like. I cried. I did the same thing. We have so much in common because we are very passionate about our kids and about our families. And so I know and I stand here and I'm going to vote for this Bill because I care about kids.
- Tina McKinnor
Legislator
I don't want any kid harmed. So I get that. So I look forward to the rest of the time here on this green carpet to work with everybody on antisemitism and anti blackness. And with that, I will be voting for this Bill tonight.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Mckinnor. Assemblymember Bennett, you are recognized.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. You know, as a public high school teacher for decades, I can't have taught world history, the Holocaust, Middle East, racism, and anti Semitism more times than I could count. And I just hope that we would all approach this with some humility.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
And so when my colleague said this shouldn't be so hard, I think it's very clear this is one of the hardest things that you do. Write legislation that deals with the most sensitive topic possible in our school system, in our public school system in particular.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
The challenge of a professional teacher to try to teach these topics is enormous. A professional teacher is trying to navigate the great sensitivity you have to have that's been expressed on this floor so eloquently by so many of you.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
The nuances, the sensitivity, the personal concerns, the threats, the insecurity somebody may feel, while at the same time you have the responsibility to challenge students to think and to think critically. And so do you do a role playing incident here? Right. Do you allow people to present different points of view? How do you do all of that?
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
We should be very humble on this floor about how difficult it is to write legislation that encourages the most professional teachers out there to do this right and not get caught in some unintended consequence of legislation.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
So I would offer that just as it is very difficult to professionally teach this, it's very difficult to write this kind of legislation. But after two years of trying, I approached the authors today and I requested one thing. It is time to get started.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Because no matter where you are, I guarantee you, if we were here next year, there would be something wrong with the legislation. It's time to get started.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
But I humbly request on behalf of the professional teachers, particularly the young ones that I hired, who are still in the classroom, who are concerned about what this may do to their professional efforts. I ask us to be very sensitive to how this Bill actually gets implemented. We've had, I've watched the whole Senate debate.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
It's very clear some things have been identified. I'm much more concerned about the things that haven't been identified, about the people that will try to weaponize this legislation for their own personal agendas out there against people who are doing their best to try to give our best to our.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
So I just ask as I support this Bill that there be great sensitivity and willingness. And I know I've gotten that assurance and I feel very comfortable with that and that's why I will be voting for this.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
This is one of the noble causes out there and that is to try to make sure that we address the improper actions by some and at the same time we don't hamstring the professional actions by some of the people that today in our society have some of the most difficult jobs out there.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Be a professional teacher in a society that doesn't value teachers that much anymore, that doesn't reimburse teachers that much anymore. And yet those teachers soldier on because they care about the mission out there. Thank you very much.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assemblymember Bennett. Assemblymember Patterson, you are recognized.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I haven't used the line yet, but I wasn't planning on talking on this measure but I felt that this was pretty important one to talk about, put a lot of thought into this. One was exchanging texts with my colleagues this morning. And to be honest, I do have some concerns.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
After October 7, I was contacted by my neighbors, friends, rabbis in the community. Genuine fear and also genuine pain that many of them were feeling and, and some of them needed help getting those security grants that the state issues for their schools. For example, at the Shabbat House in my district, making sure that they could provide security.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And the bureaucracy in California slowed down the issuing of the grants and we were able to help with that. In addition to that, soon after a group of Palestinians reach out to me, some constituents as well. And one of them in particular I've struck up somewhat of a friendship with. We meet for coffee every now and then.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
We have a lot of dialogue. I'm sure he'll hear about me speaking today and he has, you know, he has family that lives in war stricken area and you know, I can also feel his pain as well.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And when we meet I don't always agree with him, but I think what he's ultimately saying is this is just as my colleagues here can criticize our current Federal Administration.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And just as I criticize on more than one occasion, maybe even this week, the governance of this state, we do have to make sure that we're allowed to criticize government and the actions of government. I think that that extends to the implementation of this Bill as well.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And so I understand the concerns about it, but after October 7th, I saw nothing like it.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And you know, listening to some of my colleagues from the Legislative Black Caucus, and, you know, I didn't have the experiences that they were mentioning or my colleague was mentioning and, but I could witness on TV with my own eyes, really an open, open, anti Semitic feeling on campuses, in the cities, everywhere.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And it was almost like it was accepted as society that and it went really unpunished. Really went unpunished. It was, it was accepted. It was, it was the craziest thing I've really, I've seen my kids witnessed. It. And it just felt like it was almost accepted by a lot of us.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And then I read the letters from the school board associations that or all the associations, the school boards, the administrators, the teachers. I want to say to those letters, first of all, the Bill contains safeguards for what's called corrective action.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
It's not like the teachers are going to get fired, but for once, for once, some of them are going to be checked for some of the stuff that they pedal into the classroom. You don't get the liberty to straddle in line with anti Semitism. You do not get that liberty.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And I wish we actually had more, more control over what teachers are allowed to teach our students. Actually, I don't think we should, we should even blink at the opportunity to say, hey, look, if there's something that straddles the line of anti Semitic, we need corrective action.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And that needs to stop right away and have a conversation about that. And for some, there will probably be consequences and you know, there could be some improper actions. I think a recent speaker talked about maybe people using this legislation to. You know, basically put a stop to discussion.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And I'm willing to take that risk and fix this down the line because we got to put an end to this now. And to be honest, one last point I want to say is we are staying late today and through tomorrow because a lot of bills, we only got three days to read a lot of impactful bills.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
And this is the one that we've chose to decide that, hey, this is out of line. We're going to be voting on the lives of millions of people on all sorts of bills. Today and tomorrow, that we only had three days.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
I think three days is enough for me to decide that I'm going to be supporting this Bill today.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Patterson. Assemblymember Gonzalez, you are recognized.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Friends, we gather today at the crossroads of conscience. We stand on the precipice of a great challenge. And in this moment, we must ask ourselves, what do we choose to be? Will we be shadows that permit darkness to persist? Or will we be a beacon of light against the encroaching nights?
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
The scourge of antisemitism is not a new enemy. It is a poison that has festered for millennia, twisting hearts and minds and leading to unimaginable suffering. It is a profound assault, not just on the Jewish people, but on the very fabric of our shared humanity. For when one thread is frayed, the entire tapestry is weakened.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
As the Apostle Paul reminds us in his letter to Corinthians, if one member suffers, all suffer together. If one member is honored, all rejoice together. This is not merely a religious teaching. It is a fundamental truth about our interconnectedness. Like Dr. King, we must understand that injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
The struggle against anti Semitism is our collective struggle. It is the fight for the soul of our world, a world where every person, regardless of their faith or heritage, can walk in safety and dignity.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
We are called to be a light, to be a city on a hill, a glowing ember, in the words of a poet that illuminates the path for all. The Bible, a book revered by billions, is replete with messages of unity and love.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
In the Book of Psalms, we are taught, behold how good and pleasant it is when brothers dwell in unity. This is the divine whisper that calls us to bridge divides, to build instead of tear down, to understand instead of condemned.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
It is a plea to open our hearts and our minds, to see the shared humanity in the face of our neighbors, and to recognize that we are all children of the same Creator. Let us therefore, not be silent in the face of prejudice. Let us not allow the venom of hatred to seep into our communities.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
Let us raise our voices loudly and clearly for justice and for peace. Let us hold up our lamps, letting our light shine, and together we will extinguish the darkness. We will become, as Dr. King dreamed, a great symphony of brotherhood, each instrument playing its part in perfect harmony, creating a melody of hope that resonates through the ages.
- Jeff Gonzalez
Legislator
And for this reason, my friends, not only do I stand in unity, but but I stand in the gap, in the fray. When I Say, if you mess with one, you mess with all. And today we will not mess with the children of God, the Jewish children. We will not do it. Not today, not ever.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Gonzalez. Assemblymember Bains, you are recognized.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
Thank you, speaker and Members. Collective punishment means punishing an entire group for the actions of a few. International humanitarian law prohibits collective punishment. And the imposition of collective punishment is a war crime. Look, whatever your perspective on international conflicts, Americans should not be engaged in collective punishment of our neighbors.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
There is no doubt that outrage at the actions of the Israeli government has been used as a permission structure to express antisemitism towards Jewish Americans. There is no doubt that inflamed passions have been weaponized to justify the harassment and punishment of American Jews for the actions of a foreign government.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
We all have constituents who would like us to use the power of our office to allow Jews to be held accountable for the actions of a country they are not from and have no control over. These extremists demand that all Jews be held accountable for Israel.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
They say now is not the time to prohibit antisemitism because Jews deserve what they're getting. We should work to prevent anti Semitism, xenophobia, racism, prejudice and discrimination Every single day. AB 715 requires classroom instruction to be factually accurate, consistent with accepted standards, and free from personal bias or partisanship. That does not sound radical or problematic.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
It sounds like what most parents think is already the law. FBI hate crime statistics continue to show that Jews, Muslims, Sikhs are the three most targeted religious groups in the United States. I myself have experienced much hate and much threats, especially since being elected. I have been called a terrorist.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
I have been told I don't belong here and to go back to where I came from. As the only Sikh American ever elected to state office in California, I am proud to embrace my Jewish and Muslim brothers and sisters. The history of our people is filled with rejection from the places that we call home.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
The collective pain is seared into our identities and has often been used to justify retribution. We can be the generation that finally breaks that dangerous instinct. And if we want peace in our lifetimes, we must be that generation. Please vote yes on this.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assembly Member Bains. Assembly Member Bonta, you are recognized. Assembly Member Avila Farias, you are recognized.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker. I rise in strong support of AB 715. It's past time to reform our education systems. Schools must be more than a place for tests. There must be a safe, inspiring sanctuary for every child that feels valued. California's rich diversity is our greatest strength.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Our classrooms should celebrate that beauty, teach self, love and respect, the journey of our ancestors. By creating inclusive, respectful learning environments, we prepare our children not just for careers, but for a lifetime of empathy and civic responsibility. Let's make every school a place where differences are treasured and every child can learn, dream and thrive.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
As a Latina and a Mexican American and where my motherland is Mexico and a country that currently has a Jewish Mexican President, I stand in solidarity with my Jewish community brothers and sisters, mis hermanos, Mis hermanas and I respectfully ask for your support and solidarity.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Avila Farias, Assemblymember Hoover, you are recognized.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you immensely for not making me go after the Reverend from Indio. I am. We had a very emotional hearing today in the Assembly Education Committee, and I'm really grateful that my colleague from San Luis Obispo shared the story that Ella shared to us in Committee.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
And I wish you all could have been there to hear it from her directly because it was truly powerful as she shared with us the experiences that she had being mistreated as a Jewish student at her school, something that no child and no student should ever have to experience in an environment that should feel safe.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
I want to commend my colleague from Los Angeles and the Jewish Caucus, who have been pouring their heart and soul into negotiating and crafting a piece of legislation that works for a majority of this body over the last two years. And let's be very clear about that.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
They have spent two years on this legislation, numerous iterations, and I certainly do appreciate, particularly as a Member of the minority party, the concerns being raised today on this floor about process.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
It is something that the minority party, the Members of the minority party often criticizes the majority party for, is that we do not have the time to truly digest some of the large policy changes that are in front of us. And yet it is a regular occurrence.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
And so for me, perhaps I'm a little less sensitive to the fact that the process in this situation is not what we would usually like it to be because it tends to happen to us quite regularly.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
But I do think it is important to recognize that while this Bill, this version of the Bill has only been in print for 3 days, the process has taken 2 years and the conversations have been robust. You may have noticed that a lot of our Members in the Republican caucus are wearing these pins.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
And I'm going to be honest with you, it has been a truly hard week for me, personally, as a father, as a conservative, to witness the violence that has taken place in our country this week.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
And it really speaks to the fact that no one, no one should ever feel targeted or threatened for their beliefs, no matter what those beliefs are. And I will acknowledge that this Bill is not perfect, but I do believe that it is necessary.
- Josh Hoover
Legislator
It is necessary to protect students like Ella who are being traumatized in learning environments that are supposed to be safe. And so I would urge my colleagues to set their concerns about process aside in this case and please vote Aye on this Bill. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Hoover. Assemblymember Demaio, you are recognized.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've digested and sat down and been moved by many comments, particularly by Members of the Jewish Caucus, expressing their frustration with how long this has taken.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
The Assembly Member from Contra Costa, I think, really hit it home when she said that she stood with so many other diversity caucuses in their fight because it was the right thing to do, and that she's frustrated and hurt that the same courtesy has not been extended to her.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
And it should extend beyond the Jewish Caucus. My colleague from Northern California, my colleague from Sacramento just referenced it.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
When you demonize people for their orientation, who they love, their religion, what sort of religious beliefs they have, for their gender, for their skin color, or, yes, for their difference of opinion on a political issue, when you do that, you are demonizing them. You are tearing them down. You're not treating them with fairness.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
People are not born with hate in their heart. Children are taught to hate. And I think that this Bill is trying to address two elements that are essential to all these conversations. Whether you're talking about religious discrimination, LGBT discrimination, or political discrimination or anti Semitism. Number one, how do we get to the Golden Rule?
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
How do we create an environment where you treat people as you would like to be treated, with fairness? Doesn't mean that you're going to agree, but you will treat them fair. And second, how do we make sure that we have the best role models in society?
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
That includes elected officials and the responsibility that we bear and may not be doing a very good job of in today's day and age. But most importantly for children, the role models that they have are not just the political leaders on TV because they're not tuning in to Fox or MSNBC or CNN very much.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Maybe their parents are. The most important role model is the coach, the teacher, the adult that they interact with in a school. Many of us have heard the comment, this Bill isn't perfect, but you have to start somewhere. And I can't think of a more clear standard than factually accurate. That's right in the Bill.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
I mean, a lot of times that's what we all say. Well, we just want the textbooks to be factually accurate without opinion. Let the kids develop their own opinions, but at least get the instruction down to be factually accurate. The representative from the Bay Area said we, we can't determine what's factually accurate.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Well, then we have a real problem. I've heard. I mean, I think you can probably figure out what a Nazi is. I think we can figure out what happened with the Holocaust. I think we can get to a factually accurate description of that. Now, I know some people in politics like to call everyone a Nazi.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
You disagree on tax rates, you're a Nazi, or immigration, you're a Nazi. I think maybe a dose of factually accurate would actually be something healthy and good.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
I think that some of the arguments made on this floor by the opponents of the Bill, I don't think it has anything to do with trying to make this happen. I don't think there's anything we can do in the next year if we delay this Bill that would satisfy their objections.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
And so what I would like to do instead is move forward with this Bill and give implementation a year or two and study it and make refinements.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
But I believe that we can come up with a factually accurate definition of what it means to be an anti Semite and a factually accurate curriculum to teach kids that you don't lash out in hate towards Jewish people. I think we can do that.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
And if we can't, we've got bigger problems in society than just this one issue. I urge a yes vote on AB 715.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember DeMaio. Assemblymember Bonta, you are recognized.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Thank you, Members. I think for those of us who were able to participate in the informational hearing we had about AB 715 and the companion Bill, which I'm sure we will hear soon you got to hear some of my wrestling with this Bill. What I am certainly resolute in is why I came to this Assembly.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
I came to this Assembly to always be child centered and child focused and to make sure that when we engaged in any kind of legislation, whether it be in the areas of criminal justice, environment or education, that we always had an opportunity to think and center our children.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And so when I hear from my colleagues like my colleague from Contra Costa or my colleague from San Luis Obispo, talk about the their experiences as mothers and as teachers, I take to heart their concern to ask to make sure that I show up for their children.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And I have, I have really thrown myself into this Bill over the last many, many months. And I've done so in the spirit of good intention and ensuring that we would come to a conclusion in this piece of legislation that would allow us to stay true to something that I fundamentally believe is incredibly important.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
First is that antisemitism has absolutely no place in our schools and that our children should be protected and feel safe in their learning environments.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And this other truth for me that one of the things that we must hold dear is to recognize the purpose of our schools is to preserve our little d democracy, to be able to create spaces and places where our children can be and they can learn and they can engage in discourse that is uncomfortable with facilitated learning in a way that ensures that they have the ability to connect to each other's humanity.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
When we don't do that in our schools, we have children who have to deal with swastikas or nooses or being called spics.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
When we don't do that, we have to deal with the level of political violence that makes every single one of us concerned because we haven't imbued in our educational system, our ability to invite rhetoric and conversation and discourse in a way that allows our children to know that they can hold each other's humanity while they can disagree.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
I've struggled with this Bill. I've said that I believe in the intent of it. I believe in the focus on ensuring that we are creating safe spaces, anti Semitic spaces, for our children. But we cannot do that at the cost of ensuring the fundamental purpose and function of our schools is achieved.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And I know that the Jewish caucus Members, and the authors in particular, have worked very hard to strike that balance. And I've worked hard, as well as many of our colleagues have in the sister caucuses to come to that balance. I don't believe that this Bill in its current form strikes that balance.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
It is certainly imperfect in that way. But I am going to move towards grace as I committed to do when this Bill was first taken up. And I'm going to hold dear the people, the hundreds of people who have contacted my office to say, I think this Bill is going to hurt me.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
I want us all to mark the fact that while we are moving forward with this Bill, in all likelihood that there are still many who feel threatened by the nature of this Bill, many people's children who still feel threatened by this Bill.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And so I ask our colleagues to continue to work with me on some of the principles that we all hold dear. Whether it be making sure that our uniform complaint process is one that we can all rely on to be able to support our children.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Whether it be making sure that we are allowing and enabling our educators to be able to be in a space of commenting and teaching our children and facilitating those learning environments that will hold and keep our democracy. And I'm going to trust my colleagues again that we will do that. This Bill is imperfect. The intention of it is righteous.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And I want to mark the fact that the next time I come forward with a Bill that says hundreds of thousands of our children are being forgotten, our black children, our Latino children, and I come forward with that imperfect Bill, I very much hope that you all will afford me as much grace as I think many of our colleagues are affording you, because we do need to get it right for our children.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
With that, I will be voting for this Bill, but I will be doing it with deliberate thought about what I expect and hope will come next.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank You, Assembly Member Bonta, Assemblymember Berman, you are recognized.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and to all my colleagues who have put a lot of time and heart into this Bill and into the comments that they made tonight. You know, I grew up in a charmed life. Growing up as a Jewish boy in Palo Alto in the 80s and 90s, I didn't experience anti Semitism.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I had some Jewish friends. I had a lot of non Jewish friends. We went to Hebrew school. We went. We had bar and bat mitzvahs that had our Jewish friends and a lot of non Jewish friends. And being Jewish wasn't stigmatized. Being Jewish didn't make you different. It was.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
It was just another kind of facet of who you were. And, and I didn't have to think about it very much. And we don't live in that time anymore. My colleague from East Nicholas is right. I've been saying for years that the thing that connects the far right and the far left is the hatred of Jews.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And a couple of years ago, somebody was kind enough to send me a picture of myself to the office with a big swastika drawn on my forehead. I don't think that came from the left. Last year, after a Bill of mine went a little viral on far right social media, somebody called my cell phone.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
When they asked, is this Marc Berman? I said yes. They said some cuss words I'm not going to repeat, then said, you kike, you little Jew boy, I'm coming over to your house. And they read me my address, that didn't come from the left.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
Less than two years ago here in Sacramento, we had a Democratic Party convention where I was charged with genocide. Berman, Berman, you can't hide. We charge you with genocide. Less than two months after the October 7 attacks in Israel, I'm not a Member of the Israeli government.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I've been criticizing the Israeli government for longer than most of those people could find Israel on a map. But I was charged with genocide because being Jewish meant that I was responsible for everything that the Israeli government did. And that's fine. I'm a public figure. We put ourselves out there and that kind of thing happens.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
But what's not fine is that happening to Ella in school, who testified this morning at the Assembly Education Committee. That's what's not fine, is that happening to Liv in school, who testified at the Senate Education Committee two nights ago. And that's happening far too often in schools across California, including schools in my district.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And I don't think all of it is intentional. I think some of it is ignorant, including from teachers, including the teacher at the high school that my 2 month old boy will go to 14 years from now who said after getting caught teaching ahistoric, factually inaccurate, totally slanted lessons, I didn't know. I didn't know.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And I wish I had better training, I wish I had better course materials because I didn't mean to do that. And I believe them completely.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And then you have some teachers in our classrooms who do know, who do know and go out of their way to ostracize Jewish children, go out of their way to make Jewish children feel guilty and responsible for something that a government 6,000 miles away is doing that they don't know anything about and obviously have no control over.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And so I understand that this Bill is not perfect, but the status quo is broken. What's happening in our schools is wrong. And my colleagues have been working tirelessly for two years to try to craft the beginning of a solution to this problem of antisemitism in our schools.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And I've been bothered by the feeling that if we create an environment in our schools that is physically and mentally and emotionally safe for Jewish students, that that will somehow harm non Jewish students. And that makes me sad. That really makes me sad.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
I totally agree with my colleagues who say that schools should be the place for rigorous debate about challenging issues. That's what I love about college, where I took classes on the Arab Israeli conflict with students from Arab countries. That's what I loved about law school.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And those debates. But those are different conversations than happen in fifth grade or seventh grade or even freshman year of high school. And we need to make that space safe for physically and mentally and emotionally for every student. Jewish, Muslim, Israeli, Palestinian, Black, Latino, Native American, AAPI, every student in California. We owe them that.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And so it seems like this Bill is going to pass out today. I hope that we can use this conversation tonight to all work together, to keep on working on that. Because not only is this Bill not perfect, but it's far from the silver bullet to solving all of our problems.
- Marc Berman
Legislator
And I but I believe that, that all of us on both sides of the aisle want to create that safe space for all of our students. Democrat, Republican, I don't care. And I think that we can make a step in the right direction by, by passing out AB 715 tonight. So I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Berman. Assemblymember Gabriel, you are recognized.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I rise today as Chair of the Legislative Jewish Caucus. But much more as a dad, as a father of three little boys in a public school here in California, three little boys that I love more than anything. And I just want to thank my colleagues for the conversation.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want to thank my colleagues who stood up and spoke in support of this Bill. I also want to thank my colleagues who stood up and raised concerns. I've had a very hard time over the past couple of weeks, and I want to thank our colleagues who really carried the water here for much of the effort here.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I got dragged into this at the end. I also had the fortune or misfortune of getting dragged into it at the very end. And it's been a very painful and difficult couple of weeks for me because it is so personal.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And this issue cuts so close to the core of my identity and who I am and what I think about the world. And I know for those of us in the Legislature, we tend to have two kinds of bills that come before us.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
They're the bills that are about commerce and business and industry and labor and things that maybe are important, but don't speak directly to who we are. Don't speak directly to the fears, to the emotional trauma that so many of us from so many different communities bring into this space. And then we have the hard bills.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Those are the bills that connect to our identities. And I just want to thank the colleagues who have been willing to engage in these conversations. I know they haven't been easy, and I haven't quite figured out how to speak about all of this.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And so I figured that the only way to do it was to authentically ground myself in Jewish values and how I would think about this. And so what I will say is, for those of you that know anything about Jewish tradition, first of all, is we revere our educators. We revere them.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
The biggest compliment that you can give to somebody in the Jewish tradition is to call them your teacher. The people that we look up to, the people that we want our kids to be, are not the rich and the powerful. We want them to be teachers. So we revere our educators.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want to thank all the education stakeholders who have been part of this conversation. We also tremendously value difference of opinion. And I know he's not in the room, but I want to thank our colleague from Ventura. We cherish the idea that people should come together with differences of opinion.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want my kids to be exposed to difficult ideas. I want them to hear perspectives that are different from their own. I mean that I want them to be challenged. That is part of what education is all about. And so the notion that we have heard from some people that somehow this Bill is about something different.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I actually, with all due respect, I don't understand some of the criticisms. I don't know what Bill people are looking at. And I would respectfully encourage my colleagues who have risen in opposition this Bill to really look at it. I'd ask you to look at it with fresh eyes, because the number.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I think our colleague from, from Los Angeles mentioned this, we have pivoted and iterated and pivoted and iterated.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I don't know what version of the Bill this is, but I do know that dozens and dozens of amendments have been taken at the request of education stakeholders, and that the final difference on policy here is a matter of a few words in a very big Bill, in a Bill that has a lot of different components to it about having people to think about the issue and coordinate this issue and help people understand their rights.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
The difference of opinion has boiled down to a few words. And the debate tonight has been over a few words. But that's maybe 2% of this Bill, maybe 5% at most. And there's been a sincere commitment to continue a conversation about that.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
So I would just respectfully suggest to my colleagues who are worried that somehow this Bill is about censorship or silencing speech or silencing. That is not it. That is not the intention. And if that was our intention, we would have never taken dozens and dozens and dozens of amendments to make sure that it wouldn't be.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I also want to ground myself in something that I think is very authentically Jewish, which is the recognition that our community is not the only one that is struggling, far from it right now.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I recognize that a lot of our communities are in pain in this moment, that there are communities that are facing challenges and struggles that are far more significant in many ways than what my family is facing, what my kids are facing.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And we don't mean to minimize or discount the struggles that any other community is facing, but at the same time, we have an obligation to our children. We have an obligation to stand up and protect them. And this Bill is driven not by this caucus.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
This Bill is driven by the moms in our community who came to us, the moms and dads, but really the moms who came to us and said we need to be doing more to protect our children.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And I want my colleagues to understand that we are not worried about what's going on in the classroom because we somehow think that our Kids aren't tough enough. That's not it. And we certainly don't want anyone to be subject to physical violence and some of the terrible things we've seen.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
But we worry about what is taught in the classroom because 2000 years of history have taught us that that is often a precursor to violence against our community. 30 seconds. And so I just want to thank all of my colleagues who have leaned into this moment.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want to lift up what I heard today in the Education Committee from our colleague from San Diego who's not here in the room.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I was profoundly moved by what he said in reflecting on this when he talked about his daughter and his kids in schools and said if Jew and talking response to our speaker, Pro Tem had mentioned the experiences of his daughters and their real and recent experiences with anti Semitism in the classroom.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
He said, if Mr. Lowenthal's kids aren't safe, my kids aren't safe. And if Mr. Lowenthal's kids can't feel comfortable and learn, then my kids can't feel comfortable and learn. And that's the essential truth, that our destinies are all interwoven.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And that is why we want to show up so desperately for you and why we have felt so incredibly blessed by those of you that have shown up and stood with us.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And so I think that our collective obligation as we move forward is to continue to show up for each other because all of our kids deserve protection, every single one of them.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And so on behalf of my three little boys, on behalf of all the Jewish students in this state, and on behalf of every kid of every background, of every orientation, of every faith and race and political party and gender and orientation, I think we can all lean into this moment.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
And so with that, I would respectfully request your aye vote on AB 715.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Gabriel. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Assembly Members Zbur, you wish to close?
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Yes. So first of all, I want to thank my colleagues for the robust discussion, the comments from colleagues from San Fernando Valley, Los Angeles, San Diego, Carson, Orinda, Palmdale, San Jose, San Francisco, Ventura, Rancho Cucamonga, Nicholas, Englewood, Ventura, Rockland, Indio, Delano, Martinez, Folsom, San Diego, Oakland and Menlo Park, colleagues from across the state, every corner of the state from both parties.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
I also want to extend thanks to Members of the legislative aapi, Black, Latino, Native American and LGBT caucuses for their partnership and for their solidarity and for literally the hundreds of hours that they've spent working with us over the last two years. It really has been it's really been a commitment from all of the caucuses.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
I want to thank the teachers and the education experts and the education leaders for working with us. We haven't gone to a place where we are without daylight, but we have made many, many changes in this Bill and we've listened to them and we will continue to listen to them and work with them.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
I want to thank literally the hundreds and hundreds of Members of the Jewish community who have shared their heartbreaking stories and who have shared their support and have asked us to act today. I want to thank the Senate Pro Tem and the Assembly speaker for helping us finally address this issue after many years of trying.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
I want to thank the Members and the leadership of the Jewish Caucus for this is an amazing group of people for their courage and their empathy for others and their compassion and their resilience.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And I want to thank my co authors Member from Morro Bay, an amazing woman with passion and looks at all these issues with such clarity and Senator Becker, who is the lead co author on the Senate side.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And I want to thank so many of you in this room who have spent so many hours talking to not only me and Assembly, a colleague from Morro Bay, but to almost every Member of the Jewish Caucus. This has not been a Bill that has been brought by two people.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This is a Bill that was bought by the caucus and every Member of the caucus has worked on this. I'm not going to get into a lot of detail because I think the chair of the Caucus, I think, has summarized issues well, but we don't have a disagreement in terms of what the goals are.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
We are not trying to stifle to police teachers or stifle learning. We want our schools to be a place where complicated issues can be discussed, where different points of view are reflected in education, where there's inquiry and questioning and debate and critical thinking. We also know that this Bill isn't perfect, but this Bill is a good Bill.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
A lot of the focus in this Bill has been on literally two sentences in two different parts of the Bill. We know that the concerns are valid and we know that the concerns are important.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And we have committed to come back early next year with cleanup language to address those and continue working with the diversity, with the diversity caucuses, with Members in this room and with our education partners to address those concerns.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
So with that, I want to basically close by telling you the story of Lev, a Jewish student who was able to provide testimony in the Senate Education Committee yesterday.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Seems like it was a week ago, but I think it was only yesterday one of Lev's peers crafted a puppet of Adolf Hitler and a Nazi flag while they were in class one day. Then, in a fake gesture of friendship, he patted Lev on the shoulder and in doing so, he stuck the Nazi flag on Lev's back.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Lev walked around the school all day long, hearing his peers snicker and later found out that they even took pictures of him. But no one intervened. No kid. Until a teacher later in the day asked him about it.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Despite the horror of the symbol of the Nazi party and the Final Solution being stuck on the back of a Jewish student, the school did not take action. There was no conversation in the class, no outreach to the Jewish community. The school did not even inform the Superintendent or the school board. Stories like Lev's.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And Lev was here. He had the bravery to come here and tell that story. And I can't tell you how many kids have stories that are similar to his. Stories like Lev's are becoming more and more frequent and they're only on the rise. This is not something that's isolated. It's widespread.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
It's in many, many, many schools in every corner of the state. And while this Bill will not fix everything overnight or undo the harm that's already been done, it is the first of many steps towards a better prevention and protection of the Jewish community and Jewish families and Jewish kids.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And I'm proud that this takes steps to protect other communities that are protected under Section 220 of the Education Code. When it comes to fighting hate and discrimination, we are stronger together. And so when you vote today, I hope that you will think about Ella and Lev. I hope you will think about our colleagues children.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
And I hope that all of us will understand that our responsibility is to protect every single kid in our schools. And with that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote on AB 715.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Members Zbur. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Kirk will close the roll. Tally the votes Ayes 71 Noes 0. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, we are going to lift the call on File item number 30. Clerk will post all those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 41 Noes 28, the measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members without reference to file Senate Bill Number 8, Senate Bill 48, presented by Assemblymember Fong. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 48, by Senator Gonzalez and others, and act relating to educational equity.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I rise to present SB 48, authored by Senator Gonzalez, Senator Weber Pierson, Assemblymember Ward and myself. This Bill expands the number of coordinators within the Office of Civil Rights and a government operations agency to be established through AB 715 by Senators Zbur, Addis and others.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
While AB 715 establishes an anti Semitism coordinator, this Bill will create additional four additional discrimination Prevention Coordinators. These positions cover the areas of religious discrimination, race and ethnicity discrimination, gender discrimination and LGBTQ discrimination.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
The goal of establishing these five coordinators is for students and their families, local education agencies and educators to receive guidance and assistance navigating the existing Uniform Complaint Procedure for discrimination cases brought under violations of the Education Code.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Parents, guardians, educators and LEAs needed additional support to ensure that anyone pursuing their civil rights through a claim of discrimination have a clear understanding of what legal and bureaucratic mechanisms are in place to address the discriminatory situation at hand. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Fong. Assemblymember Ward, you are recognized.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I can speak loud on this as well too, because I feel very strongly about supporting SB48.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
I want to thank all my colleagues that were able to speak on the previous item because of course SB48 is able to build on and enhance some of the provisions that were just passed by this body under AB715 now one signature away, fortunately, from becoming law.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
I want to thank the Senate Majority Leader and all of our leadership from the Latino Caucus, the AAPI Caucus and the Black Caucus for helping to joint author this Bill because it adds a lot of value to to the cornerstone that the Jewish community here in the Jewish Legislative Caucus has been able to lay down.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
We know from a lot of data that's out there from the Anti Defamation League, from the FBI, and even from even conversations in my own districts and across the California that when you look at the community members in our schools that are most disproportionately affected on a per capita basis, the anti Semitism is rampant and it is far and above some of the greatest offenses that we are seeing in so many of our schools.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
But there are so many other community Members, as was articulated in the previous Bill, that are also feeling deeply offended and we need to take this moment and build on that cornerstone to be able to use many of the prevention coordinators that we could also use to be able to help support members of other religions, people that have a different gender identity, people of a different gender, people of a different race.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
And that's what SB48 will be able to enhance in that value. For me as the Chair of the Legislative LGBTQ Caucus, this particularly home because I know how hurt and how affected our LGBTQ students are as well. I think you all might know.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
According to the California DOJ's 2025 State of Pride report, that overall anti LGBTQ bias hate incidents rose from 13.9% in one year alone, while anti transgender bias hate incidents rose by 12.3%. Indeed, hate crimes are up across the board and I won't belabor and take a lot of time about the roots of that and why that is.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
But as was said in the previous item, we should make sure we should stand united that no one should be targeted in our schools. These are not just statistics. These are real people. These are our youth. And that makes this a call to action.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
Hate and harassment targeting for our youth is increasing and it's particularly showing up in our schools. We know schools are the third most common location for reported hate crimes nationwide, and our California Civil Rights Department found that 80% of our age youth age 12 to 17 are experiencing who are experiencing hate did so at school.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
So for me, by creating a designated LGBTQ Discrimination prevention coordinator in SB48 is a great thing to ensure that rising threats do not go unaddressed and ensure that students and their families have a trusted resource to help prevent and respond to hate. And the same goes for Members of many other communities and their youth and their students.
- Chris Ward
Legislator
This Bill strengthens California's commitment to treating every student so that they're able to learn in a safe and supportive learning environment, no matter the gender identity, sexual orientation, race, religion or background. Mr. Speaker, I respectfully request your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Ward, Assemblymember Carrillo, you are recognized.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I rise as Southern California's Vice Chair of the Latino Caucus in support of SB 48. This Bill builds upon the work of AB 715.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
While AB 715 establishes the new Office of Civil Rights within the Government Operations Agency, along with an anti Semitism Prevention Coordinator, SB48 expands its office by adding four civil rights coordinators to address critical areas of discrimination that continue to impact our communities.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
We know that many Latino families, immigrant communities and students of color often face additional barriers when attempting to advocate for their civil rights. This Bill ensures that they are not navigating that process alone.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
The coordinators created under SB 48 will help school districts, educators, parents and students better understand their rights and the avenues available to pursue justice when discrimination occurs. Thank you to the Diversity Caucus for tireless work on this proposal on AB 715 and SB 48. With that, I respectfully request your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assemblymember Carrillo, Assemblymember Patel, you are recognized Members. I just want to remind you all. Members, your attention please. I want to remind you all that the noise heard in the gallery cannot be picked up on the microphones. Please stay focused with your speeches. Let's continue the business on the file. Assemblymember Patel, you are recognized.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in support of SB 48 and would like to thank the authors for taking this critical step towards making sure no students are left behind.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
I'd like to point out that the four additional coordinators will include a coordinator that will deal with each other anti religion, anti LGBTQ, anti ethnicity or race hate, and anti gender based hate. We heard in committee this morning that there are concerns that we did not include, anti disability concerns.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
And that is one of the things we can work on going forward. An important conversation that comes up when we do raise the ability to address fears, hate and safety in our schools as we learn of others that are experiencing the same thing.
- Darshana Patel
Legislator
And we can improve our process and continue to strive to make sure all children feel safe. So with that, I respectfully ask for all my colleagues to support this Bill.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Patel, Assemblymember Gabriel, you are recognized.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I want to thank the chairs of the Diversity Caucuses for their incredible partnership and work on this effort. As I said before, every single student in California deserves to be safe and protected and welcome in their classroom.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
This Bill would make sure that all of our so many of our diverse communities have the coordinators that they need to respond to the specific needs of their communities. Thank you to our incredible joint authors. Respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Gabriel, Assemblymember Bonta, you are recognized.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Thank you. Members, I just want to also mark some concerns I've had with this Bill. I recognize that in the Assembly Education hearing that we were able to have on this Bill, I want us to all remind ourselves that we already have an Office of Civil Rights that's housed within the Department of Justice.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
We have an Office of Educational Opportunity that is housed within the Department of Education. And I'd encourage us over time to think about the best placement for these very critical functions.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Placing the Office of Civil Rights within a new arm of our government that is disconnected and not networked with our Department of Education doesn't seem like it will ultimately achieve the goal that we desire with ensuring that these coordinators to combat discrimination are fully attended to.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
And I would ask us to, over time, really consider the best placement of this as this likely legislation moves forward and this work moves forward.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Bonta, Assembly Member Addis, you are recognized.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise briefly in support of SB 48 and ask that you all vote for this measure. It is the product of months of collaboration between the Jewish, Latino, Black and AAPI caucuses.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And I want to say briefly that we know, and I think our colleague from Ventura spoke about how delicate it is to be a teacher in California's classrooms and how intentional we need to be. And we have the saying that it takes a village to raise a child. It also takes a village to support a teacher.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
And SB 48 adds to that village. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Addis. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Fong, do you wish to close?
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you so much to my colleagues for their comments and robust discussion on SB 48. And we continue to engage in meaningful discussions with stakeholders when developing subsequent legislation that details the duties and responsibility of coordinators to address all protected categories, including peoples with disabilities. I really appreciate all of my colleagues for their robust comments here today.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Robust Committee meeting earlier today. And with that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote on SB 48. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Fong. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally. The votes Ayes 49, Nos 2. The measure passes. File item number 21. Members file item number 21.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
That's SB 861 by the Committee on Business and Professions and Economic Development presented by Assembly Member Flora. Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 861 by the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development an act relating to Consumer Affairs.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Flora. I'll debate having seized. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll tally.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Tally the votes. Ayes 61, no 0. The measure passes. File item 48. File item 48 that's SB 414 by Senator Ashby, presented by Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 414. By Senator Ashby an act relating to school accountability.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members, I rise to present SB 414, the Charter School Accountability Act, on behalf of Senator Ashby. SB 414 responds to four reports and their calls for accountability of charter schools and charter school authorizers.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
It also reflects the input of broad stakeholder engagement, including over 32 meetings of 82 hours of negotiations by the Senator and many, many groups. SB 414 holds charter schools responsible for internal accounting and educational outcomes, implements new auditing standards and increases requirements for transparency and accountability.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
The Bill includes recommendations from many legislative reports that dictate that we should be having more oversight of our charter schools. It is critically important that we continue to educate California students, but do so by ensuring that all of California's dollars are spent with accountability and responsibility. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. Assemblymember Muratsuchi, you are recognized.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
I am very disappointed that this Bill is coming up for a vote now. I have been working with Senator Ashby and all of the stakeholders on this measure for months, for months. And the goal was always to reach a deal, a deal between labor and the charter schools.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
With the bringing up of this Bill, you're all going to have to go against, you know, our labor partners that have been fighting, leading the fight for strengthening charter oversight and accountability, to crack down on all the fraud and corruption in the charter industry. I ask you to vote no on this measure.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Muratsuchi. Assemblymember Johnson, you are recognized.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Today I rise for the first time in very strong support. Thank you. Of SB 414. It has been an incredible whirlwind these five days since I was sworn in. In that time, I have listened carefully to the passionate debates and heartfelt words from my colleagues.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
We heard many reminders this week that we are here to be children focused to preserve learning. In the words of my colleague from Oakland just a few minutes ago, to get it right from our, for our children. Tonight, I ask you to hear me out as both an elected official and representative and a mother of three sons.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
My youngest son is homeschooled through a charter school. That option was critical for my family, a lifeline when traditional systems failed him. He has a learning disability and struggled with debilitating anxiety. This flexibility of a charter School didn't just help him. It gave him back his confidence, his joy, and his future.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
My son Carter is living proof of why these options matter. And my story is not unique. Millions of Californian families rely on charter schools. Study after study show that charter schools, particularly those serving in high poverty student areas, are achieving higher rates of college readiness, lower dropout rates and stronger test scores that are comparable to traditional schools.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
As you know, I literally just came off the campaign trail as I knocked and talked in the district. I want to share with you that the number one question after the cost of living in California was charter schools. This is important. It's important to parents in my district and it's important to parents in yours.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
Charter systems, like any other educational system, is not flawless. That's why SB 414 seeks to address legitimate concerns raised by parents and educators by enhancing accountability and transparency in charter schools. This Bill specifically strengthens auditing requirements for all local education agencies. It establishes an independent Inspector General at the Department of Education.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
And it requires chartering authorities to publicly report suspected fraud and audit findings. While I compete with the gallery, I will say this. In short, it improves accountability and transparency without stripping away the flexibility that makes charter schools a lifeline for so many students. These reforms are common sense.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
They implement recommendations from the Legislative Analyst Office and the State Controller. And they ensure, hear me, that we allow students, regardless of their learning environment, to receive the same fair funding as their peers in traditional schools. As an Assembly woman, I will always defend the ability for parents. I want to be clear. Charter schools are Public Schools.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
They serve 700,000 students across California. They deserve our respect and the same respect and resources and opportunities every other student in this state has. I want you to hear this last part. Here's the truth. Distance does not mean disinterest. For many families, distance learning means discipline. SB 414 is the only viable path forward.
- Natasha Johnson
Legislator
And other proposals on this floor threaten to cut off educational opportunities for hundreds of thousands of kids. I urge you colleagues, please join me in supporting SB 414 and protecting California's educational freedoms.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, that was Assemblymember Johnson's first floor speech. All of our first floor speeches are exactly like this. 12:46am People screaming at us. It's always like this. Seeing and hearing. No, excuse me, I do. Is there. Assemblymember Petrie-Norris, you are recognized.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I too rise in support of SB 414. The measure before us will strengthen transparency and oversight of charter schools, while also ensuring that high quality charter schools are able to continue to serve children across California. Respectfully urge your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you. Assemblymember Petrie-Norris. Seeing and hearing no further debate, Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan, do you wish to close?
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members. I want to thank my colleagues for speaking in support of this important Bill. My district has mostly public schools, not charter schools, but we did have one prior to my taking office and it was shut down mid year because of fraud, waste and abuse.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
This Bill will help address the abuse in the system and ensure kids have access to quality education. And with that I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Bauer-Kahan. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 53, nos 3. The measure passes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized for your procedural motions.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There are measures from the Senate for Assembly bills passed by the Senate today and reports of committees for Senate bills. There is a supplemental file number two with these items so the authors may take them up today. I request unanimous consent that we suspend the rules to take up these items.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Without objection, I move to suspend Assembly Rule 63 to allow the following items to on second reading to be taken up without reference to file for the purpose of third reading today. SB237, Grayson. SB254 Becker. SB352, Reyes SB840, Limon. SB851, Cervantes.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, madam Majority Leader. Seconded by Assembly Member Garcia. Assembly Member Flora, you are recognized.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Flora. Members, this motion is not debatable. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Majority Leader is asking for an aye vote. Mr. Flora's asking for a no vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 52. Noes 20. The motion carries.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
File item number 23. File item 23 is SB 760 by. Excuse me. SB 547 by Senator Perez, presented by Assemblymember Calderon. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 547 by Senator Perez and others an act relating to insurance.
- Lisa Calderon
Legislator
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I rise to present SB 547, the Commercial Insurance Protection Act, on behalf of Senator Perez. The existing residential insurance moratorium law prohibits the cancellation or refusal to renew residential property insurance policies for residential properties located within or adjacent to a fire perimeter for one year after a State of emergency is declared.
- Lisa Calderon
Legislator
This Bill expands these protections to commercial properties, protecting small businesses, nonprofits, HOAs and more. This Bill is sponsored by Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lada and has received unanimous support thus far. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Calderon. All debate having ceased. Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 62. Noes 0. The measure passes. File item number 36.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
SB646 by Senator Weber Pearson, presented by Assemblymember Papan. Clerk will read
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 646 by Senator Weber Pearson an act relating to public health.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Members, please pay attention to the file numbers. Please stay in your desk. Be ready to present your bills. Assembly Member Papan, you're recognized.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Thank you so much, Mr. Speaker. Well, my notes say good afternoon, but I think we're ready for good morning. All right, so I rise to present SB646 on behalf of Senator Weber Pierson, which will protect maternal and fetal health by addressing toxic heavy metal contamination and prenatal vitamins. Prenatal vitamins are essential to supporting healthy pregnancies.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
They provide vital nutrients like folic acid, iron, and iodine, and are recommended by nearly every medical association for preventing birth defects and pregnancy complications. Given the importance of prenatal vitamins, we must also ensure that these vitamins do not expose pregnant individuals or their babies to toxic substances.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Unfortunately, recent studies have revealed alarming levels of heavy metals, including lead, arsenic, if you can believe that, cadmium and mercury in prenatal supplements. These toxic elements are well documented environmental contaminants.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Lead, for example, is unsafe at any level of exposure, and even low levels during pregnancy are associated with miscarriage, stillbirth, low birth weight, and long term developmental harm to the child. Despite this, there are currently no federal or state regulations requiring manufacturers to test prenatal vitamins for toxic elements or to disclose the results to consumers.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
SB646 fills the gap by requiring manufacturers to test every final batch of prenatal vitamins for lead, arsenic, Cadmium and Berg mercury and to include packaging information that directs consumers to the test results. To my colleague from San Jose on the manufacturer's website, this Bill will not ban prenatal vitamins.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
It simply ensures that all tested and Trans that all are tested and transparent. It gives consumers the information they need to choose safer options. On behalf of Senator Weber Pierson, I respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes Ayes 58 Noes 0 the measure passes file item 37 is SB 727 by Senator McGuire presented by Assemblymember Rogers.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 727 by Senator McGuire an act relating to Transportation.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Thank you so much Mr. Speaker. SB 727 strengthens the governance, accountability and funding structures of the Great Redwood Trail Agency and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Rogers. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Tally the votes Ayes 61 Noes 0, the measure passes. File item 82 SB158 by the Committee on Budget Fiscal Review presented by Assemblymember Gabriel.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 158 by the Senate Committee on Budgets and Fiscal Review an act relating to land use and making it appropriation therefore to take effect immediately be related to the budget.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. SB158 is our Housing Trailer Bill. In addition to making clarifying and technical changes, this Bill ensures that we can fully fund our HAPP program, which is outlined in the June budget agreement, to make sure that we are delivering critical homeless dollars to communities across California.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I also want to make sure that people understand that this Bill is the beginning of what we expect to be a very meaningful cleanup to SB131. This is a complex policy issue and we must invest the time to get it right.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
I want to thank our colleague from San Rafael who introduced a Bill today to start this process and I want to thank the speaker for appointing a working group to make sure that we work through the policy process with community input and in order to take action on these critical issues.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
The Assembly is committed to continuing to move this forward issue and to look closely at all of the outstanding issues. With that respectfully request an aye vote.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you Assembly Member Gabriel. All debate having ceased, Clerk will open the roll. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll. Tally the votes. Ayes 42 Noes 18. The measure passes. File item 61. File item 61.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
SB 707 by Senator Durazo Presented by Assemblymember Rubio. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 707 by Senator Durazo and others, an act relating to local government.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker and Members for the opportunity to present SB 707 by Senator Durazo. I rise as a proud co author of this Bill as it is a demonstration of a bicameral collective effort to revitalize the Ralph M. Brown act.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Members since 1954, the Brown act has served as the minimum standards for how the public can access their local meetings and for how local agencies conduct said meetings. As technology has improved, the Legislature has made careful changes to update the Brown Act.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
SB 707 will enable local governments to better serve their communities and increase the public's access, particularly for community groups that are often underrepresented in local governance, such as women, low income individuals, rural residents and caregivers. Members this is a complicated Bill. Recent concerns have arisen regarding the language access prevention provisions.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
This is an issue of the utmost importance to the author. The author has pledged to work on urgent legislation next year to ensure that we get this right. The Bill has merged with other Brown Act bills introduced this year, including AB 259 Blanca Rubio, AB 409 Arambula, AB 467 Fong, and SB 239 Arreguin.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Since the Bill's introduction, stakeholders have worked closely with the author's office to ensure a collaborative effort and a well thought out compromise. And I am proud of the results we have before us today. Thank you and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I too rise in support of this Bill. I want to thank the author for taking an amendment that actually allows some of our men and women who serve in the military to actually have an opportunity to stay and actually run for office.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
And they worked with a good friend of mine and a City Council Member for that. And I just wanted to say thank you. I think we all should look at a modernization the Brown Act and take a step into the future. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Tangipa, Assemblymember Fong, you are recognized.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker and Members. I rise as a co author in support of SB 707, which modernizes the Brown Act by increasing public participation, requiring language access, and expanding teleconferencing operations with appropriate safeguards.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
SB 707 incorporates provisions for my own Bill to extend teleconferencing for Los Angeles Neighbor Councils, a unique system of civic engagement that has been even more effective, connecting communities with government with the adoption of teleconferencing. For the first time, this Bill also includes minimal language access requirements for many legislative bodies.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
As chair of the API Legislative Caucus, one of our priorities has been language access, and as someone who's authored numerous language access bills myself, I know this Bill is not perfect in that regard, but it sets a floor that was not there before and represents an expansion of language access in the state.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
I know the author is a champion for immigrant communities and look forward to working with her to continue to work with community to find the right balance I respect to ask for an aye vote on SB 707. Thank you.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Assemblymember Fong. Assemblymember Rogers, you are recognized.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Thank you so much Mr. Speaker. I actually rise mostly just to share my experience from local government. In the City of Santa Rosa, before I got on the City Council, we had an incident where a young boy was walking around with an airsoft gun and was shot and killed by police officers who had gotten a threat.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
And that started a significant conversation in our community about how we created open government, because the city's response at the time was to shut down and to not allow for public discourse.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
So when I got on City Council, I wrote and we passed the city's Open Governments, Open Governance ordinance that included many of the variables that you see in SB 707.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Many of them have been really good for my community, although it did take about three years of implementation and reworking to try to figure out how to actually make it work.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
I have some concerns about the drafting of the Bill as a result of that experience, not the least of which is that it added about half a million dollars in costs ongoing for my city to be able to implement, particularly the video monitoring portion of the Bill.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
But I do think that there needs to be additional cleanup language that comes back next year because the experience that we saw was folks weaponizing the zoom aspect of our public discourse to be able to do zoom bombs to drop in, to-
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
They literally were naming themselves after white Supremacists who had gone on shooting sprees, and we had no mechanism by which we could prevent folks from spewing just really racist and horrible things at folks who are participating in these meetings. So overall, like I said, I think that what we're trying to do in SB 707 is very good.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
It will increase costs substantially for local governments, and I do think that it needs fine tuning. But I appreciate the work from the author.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
All debate having ceased. Assembly Member Rubio, would you like to close?
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 42, No 16. Measure passes. Item number 70, SB 839 by Senator Laird, presented by Assemblymember Colin Connolly.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Rise and present Senate Bill 839 by Senator Laird, which reduces the number of unnecessary fishery closures due to oil spills. After an oil spill, current law requires the Office of Spill Prevention and Response to immediately begin a fishery closure assessment regardless of the size of the spill.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
SB839 makes a decision to close a fishery discretionary based on field data and OSPR consultation with the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment. This Bill also removes a liability exemption for private pleasure boats or vessels causing oil spills.
- Damon Connolly
Legislator
The Bill enables data driven collective efforts to address oil spills and uphold protection of the public wildlife and environment while avoiding unnecessary impacts on commercial recreational and subsistence fishing. The Bill has no opposition, received no no votes. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 62, Noes 0. The measure passes. Item 205 by Assembly Member Pellerin and the Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 851 by Senator Cervantes and others, an act relating to elections and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Hello. Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. I rise to present SB 851 in partnership with Senator Cervantes. A key pillar of President Trump's descent into authoritarianism is his plan to undermine the cornerstone of our democracy, the right to vote.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
He is already broadcasting an attack on vote by mail ballots and voting machines, making baseless and meritless claims to cast doubt on the integrity of our electoral system. Senate Bill 851 is the first step we can take to protect the integrity of our election systems. The bill does four things.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
It requires state agencies and local governments to notify the Secretary of State and the AG if they're served with any court actions relating to elections that arise under federal law. Second, AB 851 ensures that federal agents are treated the same way as state and local law enforcement, such as hiring or arranging for any law enforcement officer to be posted at or near a voting location or a county registrar's office without authorization is a crime.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
We must protect California voters and elections workers from facing intimidation from law enforcement for simply playing their part in making our democracy work. Third, AB SB 851 ensures that voting machines in California continue to meet the highest industry standards. And finally, it makes the role of county registrars in certifying election results ministerial and non-discretionary.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
So if we lose our democracy, we lose not only a piece of what makes us fundamentally American, but also our best defense to safeguarding the freedoms that we all hold so dear. We cannot let that happen. I respectfully ask for your aye vote and instant transmittal to the Senate.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will close the roll. Ayes 54 Noes 16 on the urgency Ayes 54 Noes 16 on the measure. The measure passes. Assemblymember Bauer Kahan has requested to lift the call on item 45 SB 295. The Clerk will post all those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 12, Noes 24 the measure fails. Assembly Bauer Kahan notices reconsideration. Item 15 AB 889 by Assemblymember Hadwick.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 889 by Assembly Member Hadwick and others, an act relating to prevailing wage.
- Heather Hadwick
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 889 is back on concurrence. Amendments taken in the Senate are from the Department of Industrial Relations and are technical and clarified in nature. 889 has enjoyed bipartisan support. Thank you. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 67, noes 1. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 31, SB 495 by Senator Allen, presented by Assembly Member Harabedian.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 495 by Senator Allen and others an act relating to insurance.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 69 Noes 0. The measure passes item 148. AB 1418 by Assembly Member Schiavo.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1418 by Assemblymember Schiavo and act relating to public health.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 1418 shines a light on often overlooked gap of healthcare employees who face waiting periods before they can get employer sponsored health care that they deliver. This Bill passed policy committees with bipartisan support. No opposition and not a single no vote. Respectfully request an aye.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 55, Nos 1. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 149, AB 1441 by Assemblymember Soria. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1441 by Assembly Member Soria, an act relating to elections.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 1441 is back on concurrence, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Just briefly pointing out the hypocrisy of AB 1441. Imposing a redistricting commission done by citizens, but at the same time you're trying to get a redistricting process restored for politicians in backroom deals here in Sacramento. I will be laying off this bill.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assembly Member DeMaio. Assembly Member DeMaio. You and I have something in common. Neither of us like to interrupt your speeches. However, it is your birthday tomorrow, so I thought it might be a good idea for us to celebrate your birthday. Happy birthday, Mr. DeMaio. We love you. Happy birthday. Happy birthday.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
I think that's the first interruption of my speech that's in order. There you are. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
- David Tangipa
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise in opposition to this bill. The locals and the local supervisors, local electeds don't want this bill. This bill is being forced on them. Now that I hope some of the other Members have had time to read 1441. It is completely different than the independent redistricting commission. This has a partisan redistricting commission that does not include any minority in favor to help out with this. And I respectfully ask you to vote no.
- Alex Lee
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Just briefly. Look, if we're going to talk about consistency and hypocrisy here, if we stand for independent redistricting, we should stand for independent redistricting. And you would vote for this bill if you stand for that and you should be consistent. That is all.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. Assembly Member Soria, would you like to close?
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Yes. I appreciate the spirited debate, and I ask for your aye vote. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 55, noes 15.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The measure or Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 158, AB 699 by Assembly Member Stefani. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 699 by Assembly Member Stefani, an act relating to elections.
- Catherine Stefani
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. This is back before us on concurrence. There were clarifying amendments in the Senate, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 49, noes 17. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 159, AB 720 by Assembly Member Rogers.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 720 by Assembly Member Rogers, an act relating to beverages.
- Chris Rogers
Legislator
Thank you so much, Madam Speaker. I will spare you all the fantastic wine puns, but I do want to say thank you to our leg aide Katie Chavez for all her work on this bill. Please do not vote Chardonnay. Vote aye.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 71, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 160, AB 741 by Assembly Member Ransom.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill741 by Assembly Member Ransom an accolade to the Department of Justice.
- Rhodesia Ransom
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members AB741 is back on concern. This is the bill that keeps our kids safe. Amendments from the Senate are technical clarifications to ensure compliance. This is a support support bill. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Aye 70, Noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 162, AB 943 by Assemblymember Michelle Rodriguez.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 943 by Assembly Member Michelle Rodriguez, an act relating to insurance.
- Michelle Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Wait, that's not on my bingo card. Members, Assembly Bill 943 is back on concurrence. Amendments are simply for the purpose of chaptering out conflicts with the Assembly insurance bill. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote. And this is my last bill.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 69, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 163, AB 985 by Assembly Member Schiavo.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Assembly Bill 985 by Assemblymember Schiavo and others an accolade to the Chiquito Canyon landfill and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. One thing that is not on bingo. And should have been is Pilar Schiavo talks about Chiquita Canyon Landfill. My 90 acres of burning trash in my district making my community sick. So hence we have AB985 to give relief to residents. With this ongoing fire.
- Pilar Schiavo
Legislator
It gives financial relief granted to residents to harden their homes. And please join me in Voting Aye on AB 985.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 69, Noes 1. On the urgency. Ayes 69, Noes 1.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 164 by Assembly Member Kalra, AB 1071. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1071 by Assembly Member Kalra, an act relating to criminal procedure.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 1071 is back on concurrence. To address concerns, Senate amendments remove several elements from the bill, include that would reduce cost and increase efficiencies. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Your seatmate's bill. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 41, nos 20. Senate amendments are concurred in. Members, please return to your desk so you can vote on the items before us. Item 165, AB 1390 by Assemblymember Solache. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1390 by Assemblymember Solache and others, an act relating to public school governance.
- José Solache
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. Members, I am proud to present AB 1390 back in concurrence. Colleagues, this is a simple, simple idea. Let's compensate our local school board members and future school board members to have an opportunity. Thank you. Let's make sure they serve as dignity and some respect. I ask for an aye vote.
- José Solache
Legislator
To make sure that our children throughout California have an opportunity to have community leaders represent them with a with a good good and everything going on. Thank you. That's for his work. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 51, no 7. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 166, AB 1417 by Assemblymember Stefani.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 14 by Assembly Member Stefani and others, an act relating to offshore and wind energy development and making an appropriation therefore.
- Catherine Stefani
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 1417 is back for concurrence. Amendments were technical and added co-authors. The bill has no opposition. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 66, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 167, ACR 13 by Assembly Member Jackson.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Concurrent Resolution 13 by Assembly Member Jackson relative to International Day of Peace.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Members, please give your respectful attention to Assembly by Jackson. You are recognized.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam Speaker. The International Day of Peace was established in 1981 by the United Nations General Assembly. Two decades later, in 2001, the General Assembly unanimously voted to designate September 21 as a period of nonviolence and ceasefire.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Although we will not be in session during the actual International Day of Peace, it is extremely important that this Legislature recognizes this day. Given this time in world history, in a time of turbulence, turmoil and uncertainty, it is critical for everyone to take concrete action to mobilize for peace.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
From peacekeepers on the front lines of conflict, to community Members, to students in classrooms around the world, everyone has a role to play. We must speak up against violence, hate, discrimination and inequality, and practice, respect and embrace the diversity of our world.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
There are at least 120 ongoing armed conflicts globally, with many more instances of civil unrest, political violence and other forms of conflict contributing to heightened instability worldwide. The number of these conflicts have been steadily increasing, with a significant rise in the past five years and a proliferation of both state and non state actors involved in violence.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Many of these conflicts, colleagues, are protracted, sometimes lasting for decades, causing significant long term suffering. One in six people globally are affected by armed conflict and the number of people exposed to conflict has increased. Dear colleagues, we must not be silent as this continues to happen on our watch.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Now, I'm not naive to understand that war or military action is a necessary evil. But make no mistake about it, it is still an evil. So we must endeavor to do everything we can to prevent such evil acts and end those that continue to infect the places throughout the world with this poison.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
Last year alone, hundreds and thousands of innocent people have been murdered due to the actions of state and non state actors throughout the world, which is sending ripple effects of suffering, despair and famine around the globe that have reached the golden shores of California.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
But while we speak out, protest and even put our own bodies on the line, we must remember that this is completely appropriate and even necessary to criticize and condemn any and all governments to engage in violence and war. But we must never attack or demonize an entire people of that country. It is wrong and it is immoral.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
And we must also have peace within our own nation, within our own communities, and in our own homes as well. Because peace must be a personal commitment. The Scriptures are clear. Consider the blameless, observe the upright. A future wastes. Those who seek peace, turn from evil and do good, seek peace and pursue it.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
President Carter, in his Nobel Peace Prize, sums it up best. The unchanging principles of life predate modern times. I worship Jesus Christ, whom we Christians consider to be the Prince of Peace. As a Jew, he taught us to cross religious boundaries in service and in love.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
He repeatedly reached out and embraced Roman conquerors, other Gentiles, and even the more despised Samaritans. Despite theological differences, all great religions share common commitments that define our ideal of secular relationships. I am convinced, President Carter said, that Christians, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, Jews and others can embrace each other in common effort to alleviate human suffering, to espouse peace.
- Corey Jackson
Legislator
So, colleagues, we must Call for peace. We must work for peace. History demands it and humanity demands it. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I was going to vote no on this resolution, but the bill's sponsors lengthy explanation as well as the commentary from the gallery has moved me. As a result, I will not vote no. Instead, with the persuasion, the very effective persuasion from above, I will be laying off this bill.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Without objection, we will take a voice vote on the measure. All those in favor say Aye. Opposed say no. The measure passes. Senate amendments are concurred in item 25 SB 67 presented by Assemblymember Ta.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 67 by Senator Seyarto and others, an act relating to student financial aid.
- Tri Ta
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Honored to present SB 67 on behalf of Senator Seyarto. SB 67 will ensure that dependent of active duty military members stationed outside of California but maintaining a California residency will be eligible for Cal Rent and the Middle Class Scholarship Program.
- Tri Ta
Legislator
Military service member who are California residents may sometimes receive government order requiring them to relocate outside of the state for a standard period and their family often accompany them. SB 67 would only apply to very specific group of active duty service member. Dependent of active duty military should not be penalized for following orders. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 61, noes 0. The measure passes. Item 83, SB 733 by Senator Wahab, presented by Assembly Member Schultz.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 733 by Senator Wahab and others, an act relating to evidence.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and colleagues. I rise to present SB 733 on behalf of Senator Wahab. This bill would strengthen existing law by clarifying the protections provided to sexual assault survivors. The enactment of SB 464 established vital protections that allow survivors to request that their sexual assault kit not be tested in the Sexual Assault Survivor Bill of Rights.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
This aligned California law with best practices for trauma informed sexual assault investigations was developed by the United States Department of Justice. However, the enactment of this right has been inconsistent. SB 733 provides clarity to medical examiners and law enforcement to ensure correct implementation and strengthen the autonomy of sexual assault survivors.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
While the bill initially passed out of the Assembly on consent, it was returned to incorporate technical assistance from the California Department of Justice. On behalf of the Senator, I ask for your aye vote on SB 733 and ask for your immediate transmittal of the bill to the Senate. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 67, noes 0. The measure passes.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Item 207, AB 915 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 915 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris, an act relating to dams.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 915 is back on concurrence. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Ayes 64, noes 0. Senate amendments are concurred in. We'll pass temporarily on item 208. We'll pass temporarily on item 209. We'll pass temporarily on item 210. Item 211, AB 1392 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1392 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins and others, an act relating to elections.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Chair and Members. I rise to present Assembly Bill 1392. It is a measure aimed at protecting the personal safety of candidates for office and elected officials. Unfortunately, in this current climate, political violence is one that is on the rise, including an increase in threats and actual violence.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Just this week we were reminded of how dangerous the political environment is with the brutal assassination of political activist Charlie Kirk. But also just a few months ago, we were reminded again with the assassination of the Minnesota State Rep. Melissa Hortman and husband Mark and attempted assassination of Senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
In response to the growing threat of violence, I worked with our Secretary of State to ensure that addresses and other confidential information from candidates is kept private. In California, voter roll information is publicly accessible, so a change in state law is necessary to protect candidates and their families.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Assembly Bill 1392 simply requires county election officials to make private the residents addresses. I'm pausing because this bill is about us. This bill is about protecting us, protecting our families. In light of everything that is going on right now, this is something that is needed even more in this current time.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
This bill is about protecting and making sure that our addresses stay private, our telephone numbers, our email addresses of a candidate for state, local, and federal office here in California. Those protections will last through the duration of elected time in office or through the end of the election cycle for the unsuccessful candidate.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Amendments they were taken to remove the opposition, allowing a process for journalists and government officials, well, government offices, to access the information if needed. Look, this is a common sense bill. This bill will protect public servants and their families.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
And I'm saying this because after everything that happened this week, and I shared this earlier during the hearing, my son called me. My son called and said, mom, I'm scared of you doing your job. He said, mom, I just wanted to hear your voice to know that you are safe. Then after that, he said, I don't want you doing any more outside events, mom.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Do you know how much that hurt? My son shouldn't have to call and say these things. My daughter shouldn't have to call and text and ask various questions to make sure that her mother is okay. This bill itself is about all of us. This bill is about you. It's about your family, people who we carry with us every single day of our lives.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
I would like to thank my colleague from Lodi for authoring this bill with me. This bill is truly a bipartisan bill, and this bill is a commitment to elected office because we know that we should not be accompanied with undue threats, especially against our families. With that, I do respectfully ask for an aye vote on this bill.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you so much, Assembly Member Sharp-Collins. All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 68, noes 0.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Senate amendments are concurred in item 49, SB 429, by Senator Cortese, presented by Assembly Member Alvarez. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 429 by Senator Cortese and others, an act relating to insurance.
- David Alvarez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam Speaker. Madam Speaker, arise to present Senate Bill 429, which establishes the nation's first public wildfire catastrophe model. The catastrophe models predict the future losses of natural disasters and are often used as benchmarks to establish zones of residential and commercial risk.
- David Alvarez
Legislator
This bill equips homeowners, emergency responders, and local governments with critical planning tools while also providing consumers a clear picture of their insurance risk. Score the bill has received strong bipartisan support. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 60, Noes 0. The measure pass.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Item 212: AB 378 by Assembly Member Valencia. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 378 by Assembly Member Valencia and others, an act relating to education finance.
- Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Buenos dias, Madam Speaker and members. AB 378 is back on concurrence from the Senate. Respectfully ask for a yes vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes: 49; noes: ten. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 213: AB 572 by Assembly Member Kalra.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 572 by Assembly Member Kalra and others an act relating to criminal procedure.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB572 requires peace officers, prior to engaging with the immediate family of someone who's been killed or severely injured by a peace officer, to be transparent as to the victim's status and provide family Members information that could protect them from a course of interrogation.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
In the past few months we worked closely with the Police Chief, sheriffs and Porak on the amendments that were recently adopted in the Senate. The parameters added to the bill address many of their concerns. I really want to thank them. This bill has been introduced in prior years.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
This is the first year that we've actually all sat down and worked on language that addresses a lot of the concerns that law enforcement has in regards to being able to conduct an investigation. But I appreciate their good faith work on this and the fact that they were very sensitive to what these families are going through.
- Ash Kalra
Legislator
And so I appreciate that that good work together. AB 572 requires law enforcement agencies to maintain a policy that requires a reasonable level of transparency in these narrow situations where families of victims of police violence are most vulnerable. I respectfully request an Aye vote. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
I'll debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 41, Noes 18. Senate amendments are concurred in item 4214 A.B. set 789 by seven Member Bonta.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 789 by some Member Bonta and others an accolade to the political Reform act of 1974.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Good early morning. My colleagues, like my colleague from San Diego and Lodi I introduced AB789 in response to the continued escalation of political violence targeting elected officials, candidates or families, and our fam and our staff.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
AB 789 temporarily lifts the $10,000 lifetime cap on the use of campaign funds for elected officials, candidates, family and staff security expenses through January 1, 2029 and then returns that cap to 10,000 per calendar year post 2029, January 1. Safety is not a partisan issue.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
AB789 offers a measured, reasonable and necessary solution to a growing threat, and it does so at a minimal or absorbable cost to our state budget. I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 74, Noes 6. Senate amendments are concurred in. We'll pass temporarily on item 215.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
We'll pass temporarily on item 216. Item 217 AB1036 by Assemblymember Schultz.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1036 by Assemblymember Schultz, an act relating to the criminal procedure.
- Nick Schultz
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members. AB1036 is back in the assembly for concurrence. It increases to post-conviction discovery amendments in the Senate, Senate limited the bill's provisions to defendants who were sentenced to state prison and made other technical changes. I urge you to vote aye on concurrence with the Senate amendments. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 44, noes 1. Senate amendments are concurred in item 218 AB1084 by Assemblymember Zbur. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1084, by Assemblymember Zbur and others, an act relating to vital records.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members AB 1084 is back on concurrence with some minor changes from the Senate.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This bill will streamline and expedite the process for transgender and non binary individuals to receive a court order recognizing their gender change and changing their legal name by shortening the court processing time for uncontested uncontested petitions from a minimum of six weeks to a maximum of six weeks.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Having accurate identification documents such as a driver's license, birth certificates is vital for the health and well being of transgender and non binary individuals. 1084 will improve the ability of transgender and non binary Californians to obtain accurate identification documents and protect themselves from growing threats to their safety and well being. Thank you.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All the debate having ceased. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 43, Noes 16. Senate amendments are concurred in item 219 AB 1098 by Assembly Member Fong.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1098 by Assemblymember Fong and others, an act relating to education coordination.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members. AB1098 establishes the California Education Interagency Council, comprised of the heads of K-12, higher education workforce, and labor agencies, along with AICCU. The California has allocated billions of dollars for various CTE programs. While they have merit, each one operates independently.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
This bill and companion bill SB63 by Senator Padilla, seeks to help our students and adults secure good-paying jobs. I certainly ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 65, noes zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 220 AB1108 by Assemblymember Hart.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Assembly Bill 1108 by Assembly Member Hart and others. An Act relating to local government.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. AB 1108 is back on concurrence. The Senate amendments provide local governments with more flexibility when entering into service contracts and require independent investigations into deaths that occur in the custody of immigration enforcement. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes, 58. Noes, 0. Senate amendments are concurred in.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
We will pass temporarily on item 221. Item 222, AB 45 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 45 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan and others. An act relating to privacy.
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. I want to start by thanking my amazing team who slays every day and has gotten my amazing package out of both houses. And with that I would ask for your aye vote on AB 45 which is a bill that protects abortion privacy.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes, 49. Noes, 11. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 223, AB 695 by Assembly Member Fong.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 695 by Assembly Member Fong and others an act relating to community colleges and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. Members AB695 establishes a process for community college students who leave the country due to immigration enforcement activities to continue their education online. Cement amendments remove the requirement for the Chancellor's office to develop regulations to instead require self attestation of the student status and add energy clause and add a sunset date.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Al having seats. The Clerk will open the roll all. Those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. This requires 54 votes. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 54, no 16.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Ayes: 54; noes: 16 on the urgency. Ayes: 54; noes: 16 on the measure. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 224 has been dispensed with. Item 225: AB 808 by Assembly Member Addis. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 808 by Assembly Member Addis, an act relating to the Political Reform Act of 1974.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. 808 is back on in concurrence and it's a 54-vote, so I hope you're on the floor. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes: 66; no: zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 226: AB 847 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 847 by Assemblymember Sharp-Collins and others an act related to peace officers. Members. Please give your respectful attention to Assemblymember Sharp-Collins. You are recognized.
- Lashae Sharp-Collins
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. This is my last Bill and I would like to thank my staff for. All of their hard work. AV847 is back on concurrence Senate amendments addressed the chaptering issue and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having seats. The Clerk will open the roll all. Those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 44 noes 13 Senate amendments are concurred in item 227 AB 963 by Assemblymember Petrie-Norris.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 963 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris an act relating in the public works.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker Members AB963 is. Back from the Senate on concurrence. I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 55, Noes 6. Senate amendments are concurred in item 228 AB 1079 by Senate Member Avila Farias.
- Committee Secretary
Person
The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1079 by Assemblymember Avila Farias aan act related to civil actions.
- Anamarie Farias
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. AB 1079 is back on concurrence with technical amendments. This Bill will ensure that justice is. Not delayed and that the people of. Color are fully represented in our electoral process. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having seats. The Clerk will open the roll all. Those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 47 no 17 Senate amendments are concurred in item 229 AB 1143 by Assemblymember Bennett.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1143 by Assembly Member Bennett, an act relating to fire safety.
- Steve Bennett
Legislator
Thank you, Speaker and members. This bill has no formal opposition and received unanimous support on this floor and 33/zero vote on the Senate floor. Respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes: 70; no: zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 230: AB 1376 by Assembly Member Bonta.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1376 by Assembly Bonta an act related to juveniles.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
You're recognized. Thank you. Madam Speaker and Members, in this early morning I present AB 1376 which is back on concurrence. This Bill will help ensure accountability within the juvenile justice system by centering rehabilitation rather than endless supervision. Senate amendments strengthen the Bill considerably and do the following.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Creates a presumption that pro probation ends after a notice hearing at 12 months unless a court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that extending probation is in the best interest of the youth and the community.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
It fully excludes youth committed to secure youth treatment facilities and clarifies that this Bill does not apply to youth in a custodial setting or in out of home placements. As a result of the amendments, key stakeholders have removed their opposition.
- Mia Bonta
Legislator
Juvenile Court judges of California are Now neutral and SAU721 of Joint Council Bargaining Unit 702 and AFSCME are now in support. AB 1376 ensures youth are not left languishing in the system but are instead given a second chance. I respectfully request your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. You are recognized.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Members, please return to the floor to cast your vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 41 noes 27 amendments are concurred in item 231 AB 1388 by Assemblymember Bryan.
- Reading Clerk
Person
The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 1388 by Assemblymember Bryan an act related to law enforcement.
- Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker and colleagues. AB 1388 is back on concurrence. This Bill bans the use of non disclosure agreements for problematic officers who have been pushed out of their departments. I'm proud to have the support of both of the incredible law enforcement officers. Who have served on this floor. And I respectfully ask your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
I'll debate having seats. The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 59, no 0 Senate amendments are concurred in. Madam Majority Leader, you're recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
There are messages from the Senate for Assembly bills passed by the Senate. I request unanimous consent that we suspend the rules to take up these items without reference to file.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
At the request of the author. Please move file item 76 SB 494 Cortese to the inactive file. The Clerk will note.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Moving on to supplemental file number three. Item number 301-AB-299 by seven Member Gabriel. The Clerk will read it. There is a correction to the list. The reading Clerk will read the correct. Last Bill on the list.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Thank you. Returning to item 301-AB 299 by Assembly Member Gabriel.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 299 by Assembly Member Gabriel and others, an act relating to tenancy and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Jesse Gabriel
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam Speaker. AB 299 is back on concurrence. This bill is part of the speaker's wildfire response legislation. It has received strong bipartisan support and has no opposition. Request your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes: 65; no: zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 302: AB 366 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris.
- Reading Clerk
Person
The Clerk will read Assembly Bill 366 by Assemblymember Petrie-Norris an act related to vehicles.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker. Speaker Members A.B. 366 is back from the Senate on concurrence this measure was narrowed significantly in the Senate. Look forward to passing this Bill this evening and then continuing to work with our Senate colleagues and the Governor to improve upon this proposal in the years ahead. Thank you. Respectfully ask for your aye vote all the way having seats.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 64 no 0 Senate amendments are concurred in item 309, AB 1454 by Speaker Rivas. The Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1454 by Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas and others an act related to Pupil Literacy.
- Robert Rivas
Legislator
You're recognized, Madam Speaker. Thank you. This is an important Bill on student reading and some literacy. I would appreciate your aye vote. Thank you very much.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debates having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote aye 73 no 0. Senate amendments are concurred in item 303, AB596, by Assemblymember Ortega.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 596 by Assembly Member Ortega, an act relating to elections.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
AB 596 will allow voters to make more informed decisions and understand which entities have paid for a proposition on a ballot by requiring the ballot label to list the top three funders across all committees, the form to gather signatures for initiative or referendum.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
For decades, California's laws have required that all campaigns list their top funders prominently on every piece of mail. This bill simply puts that information on the ballot too. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise today in respectful opposition to AB 596 on behalf of California's 58 county elections officials who work diligently and professionally to ensure our elections are fair, secure, accessible, and accurate. I share the author's goal of increasing transparency around top contributors to ballot measures.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
However, earlier this year when similar legislation came before the Assembly Elections Committee, I made it clear then that I had serious concerns, particularly regarding the impact on ballot length and the strong opposition from county elections officials.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
The concerns of county elections officials have not been addressed in this bill, and they remain opposed, expressing many of the same concerns they shared in committee, and they are not alone. Let me be clear: I strongly support increasing transparency around the funding of ballot measures.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
In fact, the State Voter Guide provides links to top contributors to state candidates and ballot measures, but I cannot support printing this information directly below the ballot question. Ballot space is limited. When we add additional words that are printed on the ballot, it will make ballots longer, more complex, more confusing for voters, and will add cost to county elections officials who are charged with printing, mailing, and translating the ballot.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
This proposal risks misleading voters. The listed contributors could only reflect spending on the qualification phase, not the often much larger sum spent once the measure qualifies.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
More concerning still, only one side's contributors would be disclosed, giving voters an incomplete and unbalanced picture. The ballot is meant to provide unbiased, consistent, and factual information to voters. While I appreciate attempts to reduce the impact on ballot length, such as allowing font size as small as eight point, this is not a realistic solution.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
As elections officials have pointed out, smaller fonds significantly reduce ballot readability and accessibility. These are exactly the types of challenges that highlight why election-related legislation must be developed in close consultation with state and county elections officials, the people who must implement the laws we pass.
- Gail Pellerin
Legislator
To protect voter confidence and ensure fair decision-making, the ballot must remain straightforward and free from anything that could sway or overwhelm voters at the very moment they are casting their vote. So while I support the intent of this bill and usually agree with its supporters on policy, I regrettably cannot support AB 596 and I will be voting no.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Thank you. I rise also in opposition to AB 596 and I appreciate the very thoughtful, rationed, reasoned opposition from the chair of the Elections Committee, particularly given her experience as a county registrar or voter, an election official. This can also be manipulated.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
Again, when people say they're spending money on a ballot measure, you don't know what their purpose is, and you can have an organization try to manipulate that provision by spending a bunch of money on the qualification of a ballot measure to get their name or another type of group on the ballot that might be unfair to a ballot measure.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
So this can be abused rather than providing greater transparency and fairness, it could actually be weaponized and hurt our election process. So I think this is one of those bills that we should probably send to the Election Committee next year and have it worked on a little bit more.
- Carl DeMaio
Legislator
The intent of transparency of who's funding elections, certainly something that we should all support on a bipartisan basis, but this bill here has too many flaws in it and I urge on a bipartisan basis that we either lay off or reject the bill.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Seeing no further debate, Assembly Member Ortega, would you like to close?
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
Yeah, I'll just close with, understand the concerns that have been raised, and this bill did go through the Elections Committee as was mentioned. I worked very diligently with stakeholders to address some of the concerns that were raised in both Houses, which it is why it is here today. This will not put misleading ballot information.
- Liz Ortega
Legislator
As a matter of fact, many voters have asked for more public information and disclosures about who is funding these signature-gathering and initiative campaigns, not less. That is why I am bringing this bill forward, and respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Assembly Member take up request to move the call. We'll pass temporarily on Item 304. Item 305 AB881 by Assemblymember Petrie Norris. The Clerk will read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 881 by Assembly Member Petrie Norris and others an act relating to public resources.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Will pass and retain an item 305. Assembly Members, please return to your desk to present bills item 306 AB 1043 by Assemblymember Wicks. the Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1043 by Assemblymember Wicks and others an act related consumer protection.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Assemblymember Wicks, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members AB 1043 is back on concurrence. Has received bipartisan support. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. aye 58 no 0 .Senate amendments are concurred in. It.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Pass temporarily on item 307. Item 308 AB 1178 by Assembly Member Pacheco. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1178 by Assemblymember Pacheco and others an act relating to peace officers.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker and Members did not this morning I rise to present Assembly Bill 1178 back for concurrence Amendments taken. Return the bill to the language approved in the Assembly and resolve chaptering out issues. This measure has received bipartisan support and I respectfully ask for your Aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the Clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes 54, Noes 0.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
No: zero. Senate amendments are concurred in. Item 34: SB 616 by Senator Rubio, presented by Aguiar-Curry. The clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 616 by Senator Rubio and others, an act relating to state government.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members. I'm proud to present SB 616 on behalf of Senator Rubio. I represent a rural district that's been hit hard with by wildfires, and my communities continue to live with that threat every year.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
On top of worrying about fires, people are also struggling with sky-high insurance rates, or in some cases, not being able to get insurance at all. And as you know, this problem hits just about every part of California. That's why this bill is so important. It's a step towards making insurance more available and more affordable in California.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
SB 616 sets up an independent commission inside the Department of Insurance focused on community hardening to make our homes and neighborhoods safer from wildfire. This commission will bring together state and local governments, experts, and community members to come up with consistent, data-driven recommendations for how we can better protect our communities from fire across California.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
If we do this right, if we really strengthen our fire prevention and safety efforts, it will help to improve the availability and affordability of property insurance. Right now, the guidance on how to harden homes and communities is all over the place: different state codes, state and local regulations, and nonprofit guidelines. It's confusing and it slows progress.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
We need everyone at the table: local and state government, fire, scientists, builders, planners, insurance experts, emergency responders to collaborate so we can tackle the crisis. SB 616 has received overwhelming support.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Issues were raised by the Association of California Water Agencies, Special Districts and the Building Industry have been addressed, and these stakeholders are now in support or neutral. Members, this bill is important. It helps us protect families, communities from wildfires, helps stabilize California insurance market, and helps make sure our homeowners can actually afford coverage. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
All debate having ceased, the clerk will open the roll. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll and tally the vote. Ayes: 56; noes: four. The measure passes.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
At the request of the authors, please move the following bills to the inactive file AB 1156 Wix AB 881 Petrie Norris.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Without objection Members of assignment, we will take some vote changes from your desk. Please lift your mics to be recognized. Assembly Member Alex Lee, you are recognized.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
I want you all to know that your mics come up with a list in order, and that's the order. It's not that I don't see any of You. It's just you rose your mic after the person who's speaking. Assembly Member Aher, you're jumping the line because you have a lot of birthday credit still today. You are recognized.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Members, if you have not changed your vote in the kiosk, please do so. Assembly Member Ransom, you are recognized.
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Members, please join me in recognizing Assemblymember Josh Lowenthal for his incredible job, presiding over this floor with patience. Madam Majority Leader, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Pursuant to Assembly Rule 85, I request unanimous consent to recess until Saturday, September 13, at 10am
- Celeste Rodriguez
Legislator
Without objection, the House will stand in recess until tomorrow. At 10am the quorum call is lifted. Members, please report to session promptly at 10am to conclude our business for this year. The House will stand in recess until Saturday, September 13th at 10:00am.
No Bills Identified
Speakers
Advocate