Hearings

Assembly Select Committee on Youth Mental Health and Treatment Accessibility

December 2, 2025
  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you everyone for joining. We're going to go ahead and get started. Thank you everyone for being with us. Good afternoon and welcome to this formal hearing of the California State Assembly Select Committee on Youth Mental Health and Treatment Access. Thank you all for joining us today, whether you're here in person or watching online.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I want to begin by thanking the North Inland livewell Center for hosting us today and by recognizing our panelists and community leaders, educators, youth advocates, county partners, organizational representatives and students who have taken time for their busy schedules to participate in this discussion.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I also want to express my deep appreciation to my staff, the Legislative Analyst's Office, and the Assembly Office of Policy and Research, whose preparation and coordination made today's hearing possible. Thank you also to my Assembly colleague, Assemblymember Laurie Davies.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I will offer my Assembly colleagues an opportunity to make opening remarks once I get through the housekeeping items and my remarks as for reviewing housekeeping items so that everyone knows how the hearing will proceed, we will hear from four panel segments today.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Panel 1, Panel 2A, Panel 2B, and Panel 3 each will have five to seven minutes for their remarks, and we ask that all comments be directed towards the Committee rather than to the audience. Following each panel's presentations, Committee Members will have the opportunity for questions and answers.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    After all panelists conclude, we will open the floor for public comment. Public comment will last 30 minutes, with each speaker receiving up to two minutes, time permitting. If you would like to speak, please submit a comment card to our staff Members who will raise their hands in the back.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    There they are back there, Tracy and Caleb, and you will be able to line up at the end of the panel sessions to put in your public comment. Today's hearing is being recorded, transcribed and televised, and all testimony becomes part of the public record.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    To ensure that every voice can be heard clearly, we ask that the audience refrain from interruptions or loud reactions during testimony.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    As chair of this Select Committee, I convene today's hearing because youth mental health in California is at a critical inflection point statewide and national data show that behavioral health needs among children and young people remain significantly elevated above pre pandemic levels.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    According to the Legislative Analyst Office or the lao, the share of youth experience serious psychological distress rose from 19% in 2018 to nearly 30% in 2024. We also know that far too many young people reach crisis points before receiving help.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    In 2023, youth ages 15 to 24 had the highest rate of emergency Department visits and hospitalizations related to self harm harm. Although those numbers have declined slightly from their pandemic peak, they remain well above pre pandemic levels. Even when young people are ready to seek help, they often cannot access it.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    In 2023, more than half of California's children reported difficulty obtaining mental health treatment and only 29% received the level of care that they believe they needed. Additionally, these needs are not evenly distributed. Data show persistent and deeply concerning disparities, with historically underserved students continuing to face significant gaps in access to mental health support.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Workforce shortages remain one of the largest structural barriers. California currently faces a 30% shortfall in behavioral health providers trained to serve children and adolescents, a gap projected to grow to nearly 38% by 2033. Youth serving specialists, school based providers, and child and adolescent psychiatrists are in critically short supply across many counties in California.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    While these challenges are significant, the state has also made historic investments to improve youth behavioral health.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Beginning in 2021, California initiated allocation of more than $4 billion for $4 billion over a five year period through the California and Youth Behavioral Health Initiative to ensure young people can access mental health and substance use support where, when, and in the way they need it most. That was the intention.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    The state also invested nearly 1.4 billion across the last three fiscal years in school based mental health services and more than 700 youth wellness coaches were set certified in 2024 alone, helping expand the workforce in school and community settings.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    These efforts represent meaningful progress, but significant implementation challenges remain, including uneven regional capacity, workforce constraints, and sustainability concerns for programs funded with one time dollars. Here in San Diego, county, the statewide trends are acutely felt. San Diego has one of the largest populations of youth with serious emotional disturbances in the state.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    The LAO identifies San Diego, along with Los Angeles and Riverside, as having some of the highest numbers of youth experiencing significant behavioral health needs. The LAO also found that San Diego historically received fewer behavioral health infrastructure awards than its modeled need would suggest.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    In other words, the scale of youth mental health needs in San Diego has not always been matched with proportional investments from the state. San Diego's size and diversity make it a unique case within California.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    With more than half a million children and youth spread across urban, suburban and rural communities, the county must balance geographical, cultural, and linguistic factors that influence access to timely and appropriate behavioral health care.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    These county specific challenges mirror statewide landscape, high and rising youth mental health needs, difficulty accessing care, and persistent workforce shortages that limit the availability of specialized services for children and adolescents.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    This underscores the importance of today's hearing and the need for sustained investment, coordination, and policy attention to support youth mental health in both the San Diego region and across the state.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    The structure of today's hearing is designed to build a comprehensive understanding of this issue from multiple critical perspectives from our system leaders to providers on the ground and most importantly, to the students themselves. Panel 1 Our opening panel will provide a system level view.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    This panel will offer insight into how our county and school systems are implementing these state initiatives and confronting the daily realities of student needs. Panel 2, including 2A and 2b, will be the provider and community provider perspective.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    This panel will offer on the ground perspective of service delivery and illuminate real world challenges in workforce capacity, treatment access and community engagement. And we will conclude with Panel three, the Lived Experience. Finally, and most critically, we will hear directly from middle and high school students from our local districts as well as one recent graduate.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Their testimony provides the essential, unified, the essential unfiltered view into navigating mental health challenges and attempting to access a system that all too often was not built with their needs in mind.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We are here today to better understand these realities from those on the front lines as we work towards policy, budget and administrative solutions that meet the needs of California's young people. This Committee is not here to simply listen.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We are here to act and we're here to learn from the lived experiences, elevate the realities of our youth and families, and shape solutions that strengthen access, prevention, coordination and care across California.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I want to welcome Assemblymember Laurie Davies, who's here with us, to the hearing and I now open the floor for you to make some opening remarks if you would like.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Good afternoon everyone. I appreciate it and I want to thank everyone that's here. Obviously we have incredible experts. You are working, you are living the information that we need. Our job right now is we are in the district and our job is to learn from you.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And when we go back in January, we start the budget and also we talk about legislation that will be going forward. And so it's really important because we get our legislation from you. You know what the concerns are, you know what the problems are and you're best at letting us know.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And our job is to hopefully fulfill that and move forward. And I can tell you I've had the opportunity to serve since 2020 up in the state and my district is both south Orange County and North San Diego. So I'm just grateful to the Assembly women here for partnering and bringing up such an important subject.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    It's something I've dealt with when I was on City Council for eight years and did a lot with fentanyl, did a lot with parents that have lost their kids to suicide as well as drug overdose. And so I was up in Sacramento during COVID and obviously we really saw what was happening to our kids.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I was getting calls from my friends saying, I don't know what to do. The kids don't want to go back. They can't learn. They're staying in their clothes all day long. There's no motivation. And I don't think people realize, you do, how much damage that had on them and their self esteem along with their social skills.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And so when we had $100 billion surplus in 2020, I was really disappointed. The fact that we got very little and we fought for that, saying if there was ever any time that we need this money to not only bring in more health care providers to bring more into the schools, it's now.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    So I can tell you, very, very frustrated with that. And the other thing is, every year because of our budget now, as it stands, everyone comes up and it's a one time funding and that is not appropriate, not when you have issues like this. This isn't putting on a nice, you know, nonprofit program that is great.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    But we're talking mental health, we're talking the lives of our teens.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And so you have to have the security of knowing that not only do you have a job, but how are you going to get people to want to get into this industry if you're waiting every year until June to find out if we've actually given you funding?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I mean, to me it's ridiculous and it's frustrating and I'm sorry for your hearing, but this is the way I just kind of say it as it is. But know that we are fighting for you. And so whatever we can do, we will be your strong audience, we will be your voice up there.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And I would love to have all of you come up there for a day so that we can do little advocacy with the other Members so they can understand, especially those that are on budget and health budget, so that we can really let them know this is important.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you. Thank you for your comments. We will now move on to panel one. So we have today Nadia Pravara, Mara Madrigalwees, Christine Frias and Carol Ochoa. And we will start with Nadia.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    Thank you. And I have.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Is it working?

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    Okay, there we go. And I have a couple of my colleagues too. So Dr. Laura Vlegels and then Yale Koenig from County Behavioral Health. So thank you all for having us here today. I so appreciate you two for saying that one time funding should not be used for services and treatment. It is, it is very true.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And we struggle on, on the daily to make it work, knowing that people need these things long term. And we're expected to sort of just figure it out after the funding runs out. So I really appreciate that. So you can go to the next slide.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So County Behavioral Health, just to level set, is responsible for providing specialty, specialty mental health and substance use care for people who are medi Cal eligible with serious mental illness or serious emotional disturbance.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And so there's sort of the large population of San Diego, there's the medi Cal population and we are the specialty provider for both children, adults, everybody of all ages. So there's a lot of change happening in this space, not only for other medical providers, but us.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    If anybody's read the news or seen any of the things happening, there are many changes occurring simultaneously for us. So I'm just going to highlight a couple because they're really opportunities for us. But even though these are sort of coming around, we still need more opportunities. As the Assembly Members were speaking to.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So we implemented payment reform in 2023, which is not probably very exciting for many people, but for us it's very exciting. This changes the way we reimburse providers. And so it changes from sort of a line item budget where you kind of pick and choose every little dollar and you get reimbursed to a rate for each item.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    Sorry. For each service. And it's going to allow both simplification for providers across our children and adult networks, but also it's going to be bringing more money into our network. So this allows us to reinvest to grow our services for children's programs as well as do things like incentive payments related to health care.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So it's really important for us to be able to grow our network to be able to meet the need and regionally distribute services across our county. Payment reform is going to be a big opportunity. We're already seeing some of the impacts and we are going to continue to grow.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    The other thing is BH Connect, which is also a waiver. We opted in. Some counties aren't doing it. We opted in. It's going to be very big for us. So in June of this year, this allows us to again improve the care that we're providing.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    We will be implementing new evidence based practices, but also on the reimbursement side. So as you can tell, I'm sort of always on the finance side thinking about how we can grow things. On the reimbursement side, it's going to allow us to receive reimbursement in several of our hospitals which could not prior to this receive reimbursement.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    They were considered institutions of mental disease that had more than 16 beds. So we have many, many bed days in those hospitals and we could not, it was all county funded. This allows us to now receive reimbursement for us which is going to then free up money for us to reinvest into our system.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So really, really big deal for us. We're also with all these new opportunities, reinvesting, redesigning our services to make them reimbursable.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So there's a lot of new opportunity where, you know, it could have been county funded or MHSA funded where we're redesigning services to align them with medi Cal reimbursable services and we then are able to then sustain them and then grow our system.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So on the other side, in terms of the one time funds, our county has been awarded a lot of funding recently for related to like the bond infrastructure grant, funding to grow community, community based care, things like that within children's services. Specifically we were awarded funding to.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    We are going to be building the first children's crisis residential facility around in the Kearney Mesa area where Polinski is. So within an empty site in there, 16 bed facility which is going to establish new children's crisis services for our continuum.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So we know it's a service that we need and I think as both of them were speaking, there's many children, children in crisis. So this will offer a new pathway for those children to come in and receive care and then get connected to longer term care.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    We also, one of our local providers, local partners, was awarded $20 million to build a psychiatric residential treatment facility up here in North County in San Marcos.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And so we'll be partnering with them as they move along on that facility to partner with them to again have another location, a new service for us where children have better access to care. One other thing that they both highlighted is the mental health workforce needs.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So in 2022 there was this report that came out that we participated in noting that San Diego County needs about 17,000 new behavioral health workers. Which is like mind blown. You think about how many is that? Like twice as many as we currently have.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So one of the things we are doing is investing in recruiting, retaining and advancing, sort of allowing folks to move up the ladder, if you will, within the mental health system. So $15 million a year has been allocated.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    We are working with the Policy and Innovation center, who's the administrator and then a lot of the local universities, community college districts and other CBOs where folks can, can. There's a range of things.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So it could be from apprenticeships for peer support workers or substance use counselors, all the way up to, you know, training for psychiatry, getting your clinical hours, stipends for folks who need hours where they're not going to get compensated. Like who can work for free in San Diego? Nobody can.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So we are going to come in and fill the gap for those folks. And in fact, it launched in September, the first cohort. And many of the students that are participating couldn't believe that there are not many strings attached to it. It's really meant to complement any other sort of resources that they might get.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And then in turn, they either pay back their loan or their loans are forgiven through working for one of our local CBOs for five years. So it's a really nice partnership where we grow our network, but also gives opportunity. Next slide forward. So this is, I think, on everybody's mind right now, the Behavioral Health Services Act.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    This is a huge, as I was speaking to policy changes. So it does. It will start July 1st. It's going to shift prevention funds. Many of our children's programs right now are funded through prevention funds. It's going to shift the funding to the State of California Department of Public Health. So it means it's eliminated locally.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    So we're walking through that process right now, which has been very challenging with our CBOs. It's probably the least favorite part of the work that we do is having to really look at what sort of meets specialty care and what's eligible for BHSA and what is not any longer.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    We are also in the midst of the community program planning. This is gathering community input, feedback through different engagement opportunities to inform our integrated plan. And with the focus on children's services, there's many different cohorts of folks that we will need to focus on. So we invite you all to participate in that process as well.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And then, as you can see, the integrated plan is going to be due as a draft in March and then due in June, the final one. And then lastly, I'd like to highlight before I hand it off to Yale, we're developing an optimal care pathways model.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And so we've done two models of this previously for mental health and substance use. This is really meant to develop a framework for our children's system where we all partner together. What are the capacity of services we need, what are obtainable sort of levels of service that we can actually achieve through reimbursement.

  • Nadia Pravara

    Person

    And it really is going to allow us a frame framework to help give us concrete goals over the next five years to work towards and be able to sustain financially. So I'll hand it off to Yale right now. Go ahead.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    Thank you so much, Nadia. So we're very focused on the need, but I just want to briefly start with some information from the CDC where they offer indicators of positive mental health for kids. And they really call out with data on how kids are flourishing.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    So for example, for young kids, they talk about how smiling and laughter are indicators, how connecting and showing affection to a caregiver is something that we see in most of our kids. How when they are faced with frustrating moments, they're able to recover and move forward. For older kids, they're curious, they're interested in learning.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    When they're challenged, they're also able to calmly move through that challenge again. So many positive indicators that are also taking place for our kids. And when they do face adversities, they also show a lot of resilience, which is so important because it's those protective factors that helps them move forward in life.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    They help all of us move forward in life. The CDC also of course offers rates around anxiety, depression, suicide, ideation and thoughts, which is of course something that we've all become so much more aware of since the pandemic in California.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    There is the California Healthy Kids data, the CHICKS data, and the CHICKS data is really looking at our local students for us and showing us that there are still rates of feeling hopeless and persistent sadness, isolation, suicidal thoughts. But we're starting to see some trending down in that data, which is really encouraging and hopeful.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    There was mention around access to care and it is absolutely something that we are aware of and needing to address together. Access to care can take on different forms. Sometimes it's about not having funding for services, and sometimes it's about not having the workforce to do the work.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    Even when the funding is there are kids in General and the generation is comfortable with mental health. Typically they know the language, they know how to ask for help. But there's still stigma and people are still facing and needing to address stigma. And it does prevent some people from gaining access to services.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    Sometimes access is impacted because people don't know where to go or what to ask for, what to get. And as again was mentioned, not everybody is impacted about access equally. There are communities that face additional barriers and there are subgroups within our communities that struggle with access even more.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    I think Nadia mentioned the county behavioral health target population for kids. Mental health is being the specialty mental health provider. So the kids that have Medi Cal, we are responsible to provide their services. Kids with Medi Cal that have mild or moderate needs can access those services through through their managed care plan.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    And there's four of those in San Diego. So it's not an easy landscape. The county is also the safety net. So we are also there to provide services for those who are unfunded or underinsured. And that's certainly important for us to attend to.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    And the landscape is complicated and there is so much that is available, but needing to navigate all of it is difficult even when you're in it and helping families navigate through it.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    One of the things that again was mentioned is the Children Youth Behavioral Health Initiative or cybhi and that is something that is relatively new to the landscape. It's about four years in, but it is a tremendous influx of resources and funding that has been made available for kids and families in California.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    So for example, under that umbrella there are digital platforms like Saluna and Bright Life for Kids, which are apps directly available for kids to use to support their mental health. There's also various campaigns that were launched under the umbrella of cybhi like It's Never a Bother, which is focused on suicide prevention and workforce.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    There's so many different ways in which CYBHI is addressing short term and long term strategies strategies. And there is the fee schedule. This is the school based fee schedule where school districts that opt in are able to, with considerable investment in work able to directly provide mild and moderate mental health services to all students.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    So regardless of payer. So again, the landscape is always shifting and we all always have to be working together and know what's happening over here so we can adjust over here as well. So let's take a minute and dive in into the county behavioral health continuum of care.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    We have roughly 350,000 kids with Medi Cal in San Diego. And again, we are the specialty mental health provider for those kids. We have roughly 100 contracts that we Fund to do this work.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    So community based organizations that we partner with and they are the ones that serve roughly 12,000 kids annually, providing them with specialty mental health services. So on the one end of the continuum we do a lot of population health work. So for example, the county has the it's up to Us campaign.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    This is a media campaign that is local and is really about creating awareness around mental health. We also have the. Suicide Prevention Council where we bring together leaders throughout the county and collectively we work towards zero suicides moving down the continuum.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    We have early intervention services, things like Friday Night Live and Club Life where we focus with students on school campuses to really build their leadership skills and again going towards building that resiliency and protective factors. Outpatient clinics. We have clinics throughout the county with so many access points for families to come in.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    And there they would meet with a multidisciplinary team of Clinicians that can offer individual family group work. Psychiatrists that when medications are needed, that can be offered. Case manager, peer support specialist. All of that can happen in an outpatient outpatient clinic. We also have school based programs.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    There's about 25 contractors that deploy Clinicians to about 400 of the schools in San Diego. And those Clinicians are able to work one on one or in group setting with students on those campuses. It's about half of the campuses in San Diego. We also have sports specialty programs.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    So for example, we know that in our community there are kids who've been commercially sexually exploited. We have programs that are specifically focused on being able to support those children. We have intensive services. This is one of our newest level of care. Intensive outpatient and partial hospitalization.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    For many years that was available in the community for commercial insurance, but Medi Cal system was not able to offer it. We've recently, due to some changes at the state level, have been able to stand up an IOP and a PHP with community based organization. We also have our residential treatment.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    You may have heard of strtps or short term residential therapeutic programs where we're able to care for children. And we have an array of crisis services. We have crisis stabilization units. We have pert where a clinician and a law enforcement officer can deploy to the community when there is a psychiatric crisis.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    And more recently the NCRT or Mobile Crisis Response Team. And in the PATH year, in partnerships with county office of Ed and school districts, we've been able to actually launch a component of MCRT that's focused on deploying support on school campuses for those students that are experiencing a crisis.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    And then all the way up to acute care services. We are very fortunate in San Diego. We actually are very rich Wood resources. We can always do more. There's always need for new levels of care. Things are always changing.

  • Yale Koenig

    Person

    But there are three local psychiatric hospitals that we partner with to ensure that kids get the care that they need. And with that I'd love to turn it over to Dr. Vlegels.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I do need to remark that we are running significantly over time for our panel. So. So please keep your. It was supposed to be five minutes per panelist. So I just wanna make sure we keep on our time.

  • Laura Vlegels

    Person

    Thank you, Dr. Patel. I am going to pass it off to our next panelist. I came prepared today with three clinical vignettes. I am more than happy to share kids stories with you, either if we have additional time or if guests here want to connect with me afterwards. But I'll pass it, I think, to Mara. Next.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Thank you. Could we just queue up the slides, please? Please. Thank you so much.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you. I appreciate that.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Yeah.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Thank you, Dr. Vlegels.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    All right, I'm just going to go ahead and go through. I'll skip around. There's additional slides for more information, so just feel free to review those. I am going to highlight the cybhi, a couple of programs through CYBHI just to really highlight what's going on in San Diego. County.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And the two that I want to highlight are the capacity building grant and the multi payer fee schedule. And I want to start with just the acknowledgement that schools are not just places of learning, they are community hubs where children spend a third of their waking hours and where trusting relationships with adults and peers can form.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Which really makes schools places that are powerful and practical for early identification and support. Integrating mental health services on campus helps lower barriers like transportation, time and stigma. And more importantly, it promotes more equitable access for services, especially for those who might otherwise fall through the cracks.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And this is why for the San Diego County Office of Education, it was really important for us to lift this capacity building grant. Especially we put out invitations for all 43 of our schools, school districts and all of our charters across the county.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And very excited to note that there was a total of 173 eligible LEAs in our county for the capacity grant. And right off we had 87 who participated, which is one of the better rates across the state. So that really is just speaking to the level of trust that our LEAs have in wanting to partner on this.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    It's not to say that we won't have more. We are currently looking at how we can engage our other LEAs to build their capacity in preparation for the multi payer schedule. And that's essentially what that capacity building grant was. It was to get them ready to be able to swiftly move over to the multi payer fee schedule.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So we're really excited. We are in the middle of this process now. And what this is going to allow us to do is the following. If I can switch slides, oops, I'm going backwards. Okay, so these are the options. This is a technical assistance that the San Diego County office offers.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    But the fee schedule provides sustainable reimbursement for school linked behavioral health services. So there's no out of pocket cost for our families. It enhances behavioral health services and school hours for California students, for all students across California. And so it really does allow for students to receive care at school sites. So again, it goes to that thing.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Oftentimes some of the barriers where parents didn't have time to take their students go to a place of where they would receive services, but it's now happening at their school site. So so many different things that it really allows the access is just so more readily available on school sites.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Some of the services that are eligible for providers to be able to account for is psychoeducation, including classrooms wide social, emotional learning, screenings, assessments, treatment counseling, case management. And then the practitioners, it's licensed psychologists, marriage and family therapists, our PPs, school counselors, nurses, community health workers, physicians, nurse practitioners.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And now of course we've talked about this, it's been mentioned before, our certified wellness coaches. The real important message here is that what we tell our schools is that you're able to now Bill for services that you already do. It's not new. And this was the real important message because our schools were already tapped.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Our staff are tired going through the pandemic. Everything that brought on the needs that our students had, it also affects the staff. Our staff have children too. They're going through it as well. There's so much happening. And so to say here's one more thing. And we're saying it's not one more thing.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    You're already doing this and now we can Bill for your time and your services. So it's really the messaging and we go slow to go, right? That's how we do this. And we walk them, you know, we really hold their hand through the way.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So while the state was having, you know, changing deadlines on us, reports are due here now, they're due next. I mean, it really was challenging, but we pushed back and we communicated very clearly. Your due dates for these reports are when schools are out. They're due in July. That's not going to happen.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So there's a lot of communication. We're really trying to integrate two very different systems with two very different languages. And so it's slow go, but it's going to start coming together. It's starting to come together. It's not going to start. It's starting to come together. And it's all because it's about students first.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And we keep that message going forward. We partner with county behavioral health all the time. We're constantly talking about how can we do this better. And so that really helps because we have a unified message not only here in San Diego, county, but that transfers up to the state. So that's just really important to know as well.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So other things that I wanted to share with you about this is keep going. I just need to read the sign. So. Not even raining still. The other thing is we also, what was really important is as we engaged Our districts was we provided sample crosswalks. So as a sample. And again, this is just an example.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So for things that they're already doing. So for example, a suicide risk screening, we looked at the reimbursable amounts that the state provided, and then we showed them. So these are dollar amounts for things, again, that you're already doing. Safety plans, parent information sharing. And this was just a sample so they could see your time.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    This is what we start to be able to Bill for, again, for things already done. So we provided things like this, not just for suicide risk screening, but also for social emotional learning classes, what their time would look like and how much the reimbursement would be.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So as an example, again, average day of a PPS school counselor, assuming if they're doing an SEL presentation, this is the amount that they could get back. Suicide screening, individual counseling. And again, it was just a sample so that they could see, you know, yes, it's not more.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    I mean, they're putting into platforms, but this, again, is additional dollars that could be bringing back. And what's phenomenal about this is that it could be used toward any programming that they want at their school site. So it could pay for a counselor's time? Yes, it could pay for another school member's time.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    It could pay for peer programming. We've invested a lot of dollars in peer programming in our schools because one thing we do know, and it was mentioned before, that our students are very much invested in their own mental health and they want to do more peer programming.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    They've often said to us, don't do it to us and for us, but really give us the information because we're talking to one another. And. And they are the future of the workforce. They're very much involved.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And they also say, I want people who look like me, who understand who I am, who, you know, really understand my life experiences. And so they are the future of our mental health force. And so more peer programming around mental health is so critically important. And these dollars could go towards funding more peer programming, which is phenomenal.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    So these are some of the cohorts that we have going on now. These are cohorts. Cohorts within our county. So, as you can see, we started with two cohorts, which are different LEAs. Moving into the different cohorts that go. We. We had a slow go. Two in the beginning, then nine.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Our last cohort, which was five, we had 28 new LEAs coming on board. They just opened up cohort six. And we're hoping to see more than the 28. So we're really excited about this. There's a large, extensive cohort onboarding progress, so it's not easily done.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    But the fact that we have more cohort, more LEAs coming on board with each cohort, again, is really excited. And I think it just speaks to the team that we have.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    We have expert consultants, our SDCOE team, and then we have a strong vendor that has been working with us that really gets our LEAs comfortable with the process. So these are currently who's in our cohorts. And we have highlighted Santee and La Mesa, Spring Valley, because again, just like the process is long, so is the reimbursements.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    But those are two of our districts that have been successfully reimbursed. Hopefully we'll see more coming along. So very excited about that. And then charters as well. So this is eligible for all districts and every single charter in our county. So we just wanted to highlight that we support our charters, of course, as well.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    And this is across the state. We are seeing that the PPS staff Members who are most billing and most reimbursed are licensed clinical social workers, marriage family therapists and our pupil personnel counselors. And these are different categories that are most billed for. Just wanted to share that with you.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    Treatment, and there's a whole many different treatment is defined a whole host of ways and then psychoeducation. So we wanted to share that. And this is across the state. So these are the reimbursed dollars that have been provided across the state so far. So hopefully we'll see that continuing to grow as we go. We stay tuned.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    We will have a SDCOE webpage on CYBHI capacity grant and we will have. Oops, sorry. Well, we will have increase. There's an email dedicated just for questions around this that anybody can tap into and we will happily answer your questions. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you for that presentation. We can move on to Christine.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Good afternoon and thank you so much for allowing me to be part of this critical conversation. I am super privileged to be the Director of student services for the San Marcos Unified School District. Waiting for my slides. There it is.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    All right, so again, Director of student services for the San Marcos Unified School District, where We serve over 18,000 students at 19 schools. My team oversees mental health crisis response, student supports and coordinated health services.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Like many districts, we've seen a dramatic increase in youth mental health since the pandemic, particularly anxiety, depression and significant spikes in suicidal and even homicidal ideation. Schools have become the front line for youth mental health intervention. SMUSD is in Cohort 5 for Cybhi.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    As Mara said, we are already providing many of these services intended for reimbursement, but billing has not started. The biggest hurdle we face is the requirement to collect student insurance information. Many families fear government overreach, have privacy concerns or worry about immigration consequences.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Our challenge is that we are already delivering this care, but without insurance data there is no path to reimbursement. This creates a real sustainability issue. CYBHI has enormous potential, but families fears about sharing insurance information must be addressed through clear statewide messaging and supportive policies.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    We're hearing from early cohorts that reimbursement is slow, difficult or in some cases not happening at all because without insurance information we simply cannot Bill. Without upfront support, districts bear the full cost of launching CYBHI infrastructure. The administrative burden of preparing for billing with documentation, training and compliance is significant.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Without stable funding, the mental health workforce we've built is at risk. We're incredibly proud of the student support team we have. We have 14 school social workers, 11 of them licensed clinical social workers, 36 school counselors, seven registered nurses. These professionals are the heart of our school district's mental health ecosystem.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Most of these positions are funded through soft or grant dependent sources. Every year many receive layoff notices because their funding is uncertain. The demand for mental health support is rising sharply and without more stable funding structures we cannot meet that need. The acuity of cases on our campuses has changed dramatically.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    We're seeing more self harm, more eating disorders, more students presenting with suicidal or homicidal ideation and a dramatic rise in students experience experiencing anxiety and depression. Schools are now functioning as first responders for youth mental health and the needs are continuing to increase.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    We rely on strong partnerships with the San Marcos Sheriff's Department, Rady's Children's, Behavioral Health, North County Lifeline, Palomar Health, just to name a few. And we also use the technology that flags concerning content that is typed on any of our district devices and it enables rapid intervention. Additionally, we receive anonymous data from our crisis text line.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    One of the most impactful initiatives that we have had was a partnership we had with the City of San Marcos called the let's Face It Together Mental Health Campaign. It received national recognition for innovation and creativity and the goal was simple make mental health support visible, accessible and stigma free. Students could text SMUSD to 741741 for 24.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    7 crisis support. We had wellness teams that conducted hundreds of consultations, home visits, referrals and linkages and students came forward who likely would not have before. Unfortunately, despite its success, we could not sustain the program in its entirety due to a lack in funding.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    At Mission Hills High School we launched a state funded $1.5 million peer to peer mental health pilot through the Children's Partnership in California. DHCS students complete a formal peer counseling curriculum, then serve as trained, certified and even paid peer counselors working in a wellness center. The center provides a safe, stigma free space.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    Peer counselors support students throughout the day and refer immediately to adults when risk is identified. This model is working and it is shifting culture. Our Superintendent's vision is to bring a wellness center just like this to all 19 of our campuses.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    To strengthen California's youth mental health systems, we need improved coordinations between schools and county health, streamlined warm handoffs, clearer data pathways and just more joint crisis training between counties and the state. We need unified messaging explaining why the insurance information matters. Families trust schools, but they need to hear from the state as well.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    And most importantly, we need stable or sustainable funding for mental health staff. We cannot continue depending on grants or one time allocations to maintain the workforce that is keeping our children safe. And in closing, youth mental health needs have reached a crisis point.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    We have strong systems, strong partnerships and in San Marcos we have proven programs like the let's Face It Together campaign and our Peer to Peer Wellness Center. But none of this is sustainable without stable funding and practical solutions to CYBHI implementation barriers. Our students need us.

  • Christine Frias

    Person

    They are asking for our help and with the right support from the state we can continue building a school based mental health system that truly will save lives.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you for that presentation. Next we'll move on to Carol.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Hi, I'm Carol Ochoa and I am a school counselor. I've been a school counselor since 2003 starting my career creating a counseling program from the ground up which was super exciting.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    I worked for a K8 San Diego school district that had not had counselors before on its site and they decided to write a grant, a federal grant for three years after a tragedy at a local high school.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    So my school counselor colleagues and I were able to create a mental health support program systems to address social, emotional, academic and post secondary exploration needs with systems and supports that are still used to date. In 2006 I started in the Poway Unified School District and was hired under an Educational Assembly Bill called AB 1802.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    There was an emphasis at that time for individual parents, students and counselors to meet at Grade 7 and 10 with the making sure we were making an impact on students passing the California High School exit exam.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    At the point that I was hired, each middle school in our district was given two and a half counselors per site regardless of enrollment size of the school. During my time in pusd, I have seen tremendous changes in counselor ratios over the years as the state budget fluctuates.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    At my school we have a student enrollment of over 1500 kids and before I started there were two counselors. It's varied from two and a half counselors to our lowest at one and a half counselors. We remained at two counselors for years and my partner and I had a caseload at 1.0 of 770 each.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    For reference, the national standard for counselor to student ratio is 250. With COVID funds we were able to increase to three counselors five years ago and we are now up to four counselors at my school site. As our district is now staffing counselors based on enrollment versus every school gets the same.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    We have middle schools ranging from 900 plus to 1500 plus. So now our caseloads are more comparable to one another. Currently at my site our student counselor ratio is 375, so it's still above the national standard.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    School counselors play a tremendous role in early mental health identification and as links to additional community resources for students needing more intensive supports. Post Covid, we are fortunate in our district to have contracted with an organization called Mending Matters that provides on site therapy for a limited number of students.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Each secondary campus in our district has one provider and they are a part of our school staff and are there daily with us.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Another important part of our comprehensive school counseling mental health support team are our student support specialists who provide additional support for students in a variety of way with students individually, peer mediation groups as well as whole school programming.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Again, another critical member of our staff post Covid School counselors in PUSD have received district supported universal screeners which allow us to survey all students to make data informed decision on what student need supports and what and who we are able to support.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    And so this way we're able to capture a lot more students that may have gone unidentified. We also utilize research based social emotional learning curriculum. Counselors at our sites use them for classroom lessons or targeted group interventions based on universal screening. Your data.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    School counselors pay an irreplaceable role as first responders to students who may have thoughts of suicide. Students sometimes self refer friends or family may refer them or teachers may notice cues in their writings or comments in class that warrants counselors to do an assessment to determine level of risk and follow protocols for best next steps.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Each case is unique and delicate and can sometimes take multiple hours to adequately address the student needs. Moving forward in the last two years, school counselors in our district now have an important role in threat assessments.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    If a student has been deemed a potential threat through words, writing or Internet searches, counselors collaborate with administrators to determine level of risk and follow protocols for next best steps.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    With more counselors, we have been able to focus on aligning our program with the asca, which is the American School Counselor Association, which are the national standards set for counselors and we are able to analyze student needs through data to be more reflective and create proactive, intentional work supports and intervention.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Our site has been able to become a recognized ASKA Model Program or RAMP Certified School which shows that our program aligns with standards based on counseling practices and uses data informed decisions to drive our programming.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    This is a huge accomplishment for our district and Bernardo Heights Middle School became the fifth school in San Diego to receive this recognition. One area of youth mental health that is particularly near and dear to my heart is the Mental Health Awareness Club that I advise on my campus. In 2018 I had a student approach me.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Her name was Lauren and she saw a need within our school community. She said she had a diagnosis of depression and anxiety and had a rough summer.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    She knew statistically there were many others on campus who had mental health issues or kids who have family or friends with mental health concerns and she wanted to provide a space to openly talk about mental health issues and supports.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    It was important to Lauren to have the word mental health in the title of her club to bring awareness forward and to reduce the stigma around mental health. Our students take a climate survey through our Mending Matters provider annually since 2021 which focus on a variety of mental health topics.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    While the mental health awareness club can't take all the credit, we feel that through school wide activities and purposeful use of advertising mental health we've helped reduce the stigma at our school site.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    When the students first took the survey in 202149% of students stated that they did not seek mental health support when they needed it because of the stigma around mental health. It was the number one reason students cited for not seeking support.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Seeing that number, the club became more intentional with having the word mental health awareness as a norm on our campus. Since the original survey, that statistic went down from 49% to 30% of students feeling this way and it went down from the number one reason to the number nine reason.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Lower counselor ratios have allowed us the opportunity to showcase our work and teach other professionals about the work we are doing on my campus Focused on Youth Mental health.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    My co club advisor and I have presented at the San Diego County Office Equity Conference the last two years and we were proudly the only school counselors at the conference.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Our presentation was titled Reducing the Stigma of Mental Health in Schools and focused on data, results and activities regarding the club as well as step by step on how to duplicate this club on other campuses. This is just one of many ways school counselors can positively impact mental health on campuses.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    I am proud of the significant daily impact school counselors have on students, academically, social, emotionally and in college and career preparation. While we continue to champion mental health and learning, greater resources are necessary to ensure that we can effectively and efficiently serve every student.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    As I have mentioned, many of these new systems, programs and staffing were put in place post Covid and those funds have since gone away. But the needs have not. Last spring our district had to make hard decisions of how to cut budgetary funds. This is an unfortunate familiar cycle in the world of education.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    Unfortunately, mental health supports and school counselors are considered line items when looking to reduce a school budget. We are still currently facing budgetary cuts for the upcoming school year. We cannot as a community afford to lose any more school counselors or mental health supports in our school. We are the front line.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    We spend six and a half hours a day, five days a week, we with these students, with our youth and kids and they know that we are the trusted adults and they will they know that we are there to support them and their friends.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    We need to be well staffed, well trained and well equipped with up to date screeners and curriculum so that we can support each and every student on our campus. We need the funds to reflect the national standard of 250 to 1 school counselors to student ratio.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    California student to student counselor ratio is consistently among the highest in the Nation and in 2324 California was the 42nd ranked school counselor to student ratio.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    We need to improve this statistic so that school counselors can expand on our supports for all students and continue to do the good work we passionately deliver to our students on a daily basis. I appreciate you taking the time to listen to my journey as a school counselor and I welcome any opportunity to continue the conversation.

  • Carol Ochoa

    Person

    I appreciate your dedication for our youth and your support for their overall well being and mental health supports. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you so much for your presentations. It's given us so much to think about. I have several questions but I'd first like to offer it up to my colleague.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    I'm not sure if there's enough time.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We do have three more panels.

  • Mara Madrigalwees

    Person

    I'll be quick. You talk about the stigma for youth. How much of it is?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, on our school site, we can talk to students, you know, without, without having parent permission initially. So, we go out to every single classroom. We do this in every 6th, 7th, and 8th grade homeroom, and introduce ourselves as school counselors, our mending matters provider, our student support specialists.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And we talk about the whole variety of reasons that students may see a counselor all the way from schedule to organization, you know, to talking to a teacher, to friends, to parents, to mental health, and bigger concerns. And so, we do try to be that friendly face out on campus.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We do supervision, so we're there before school, after school, or they're at lunch. So, it's a very, you know, casual opportunity for students to approach us and see us as staff that, you know, they feel safe with.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, I'm hoping that that helps to reduce knowing that we are those staff members that are there and are safe to talk to, regardless of what, you know, they may be hearing at home.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I would just add that I think—am I on? Okay. Sorry. I think that post pandemic, just in general, there is a reduced stigma around how, how exacerbated the mental health needs are. I think as adults, we feel that. And so, I believe that where we were pre pandemic was we were in a lot—it was a lot more difficult to get parents to engage in that conversation.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think we have a big opportunity now because people are more willing to hear it. That's why within San Marcos, we did the campaign we did to help people understand that help was available on our campuses.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I do believe, though, that there is still a lot of stigma for the adults because they don't want people to believe. And it spans the socioeconomic gamut. It is not just one or the other. It is all throughout. We don't want people to know what's going on in our home. That's not happening to us.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We can take care of that. The school doesn't need to know about what we're dealing with.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And so, while I think people are far more open to that conversation when they have trusted folks on campus that they've built that relationship with, I do believe we still have some work to do with our parents to help them understand why it is critical for their kids to be able to access this care at school. What we hear a lot is, well, we didn't need that when I was in school, so why do they need it now?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We had to go outside for that. And the world has changed. And so, that's kind of an ongoing conversation that we continue to have about whole child wellness, and for them to be academically ready, they have to be socially, emotionally ready as well.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, yes, there is still a segment of folks that I believe there's some work to be done with.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Thank you. And I'll just ask one more question. We talk about the reimbursement. What is the timeline on there, if you actually get it?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, it just really—it's depending right about now. It takes—we only have two districts of all the cohorts that have built because it takes such a while to amp up to that. So, depending on, both districts have received it within months. So, it's about that long.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    It's not years, it's within months, but it's the ramp up to that that's taking the longer amount of time.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And we would love—not today—we would love to see how we could streamline that for us. Again, this is policy that we can actually put together and discussing auditing to see where the money's actually going, why isn't it being refunded when it should be at a certain time?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    But basically, what can we do to make it easier for you? Thank you. I appreciate all of your comments.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Can I just comment, too, on reimbursement? So, we receive reimbursement different way, but it's also an incredibly tedious process that. I mean, there were points where it's like six months behind. We had several of our hospital providers who were supposed to get reimbursed in, like, June. They finally just got reimbursement like, two weeks ago.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, they could not—one of them could barely make payroll. It's just—it's wild. They've provided the service. It's expensive. Yeah. So, thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    When we talk about June to now, those are two different budget cycles. And so, it also makes it difficult for our entities to budget appropriately and to stay on budget. So, very interested in your comments, in looking at what can we do to streamline the process.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Do we need to call for an audit in order to get to that? Those are definitely questions that are out there. Looking at Carillon as a reimbursement partner, I have heard anecdotally that there has been some struggle with receiving training on filing those reimbursement requests.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And that could be leading to why about 50% of them are being rejected, it looked like from your own slide. And do you have any thoughts around improvements to that reimbursement process or what we can do to lower the administrative cost of the school districts having to, you know, file that reimbursement paperwork?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yeah, Mara.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, I think it's gotten better from where we were, I think from what we've heard and the feedback that they got, because the initial, those first districts that were going for reimbursement, there was a lot of everybody was hearing how it was not running smoothly.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think there was an outcry from the districts, like, you're not making it easy. We've been sitting here, you know, on the runway for a very long time. And so, there were discussions with DHCS and Carillon, and so, now there is ongoing training, like it, it's on a frequent basis, so you can jump right in.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And so, the trainings, they have changed the pattern. It is much more readily available. Now, vendors are even getting trained. There's ongoing communications between the vendors and Carillon, who are—and the vendors are the ones who are working directly with the districts. So, it has changed.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And now, again, though, it's still the process of amping up to get ready so now, but it has become more streamlined. It's just still slow going to get into the cohorts.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But I've understood that there is a better process that Carillon has heard loud and clear that it needs to move because of the outcry that happened initially. So, where we were, from where we are, has changed. So, I want to be clear with that.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    That, that's great to hear. That's the kind of progress we want to hear so that we know that the system is working. As I said in the opening, $4 billion is a lot of money. Our taxpayers want to know where their money is going and that it's actually delivering the care that they want to deliver.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    The taxpayers voted for Prop 1. We want—the voters voted for Prop 1. We want to see our young people and our people in general receive the care that they need.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We just want to make sure it's going to the right place and that it's not creating new systems of bureaucracy and administrative cost that isn't covered in those reimbursement costs. Specific question to Nadia—is there an opportunity for open dialogue on what meets the standard of care that the state will reimburse?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Because from what I heard in your opening, or in your statement, that there seems to be some back and forth onto what is covered, what is not covered, what qualifies. Are you able to provide feedback and open the door to expand what is covered?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, are you speaking to, like, the specialty care versus others? So, I think, you know, several folks have talked about how complicated the system is, so everybody has their piece. But I think the complexity is how those pieces work together and people bounce around between those things.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, you could be mild to moderate, then you're bouncing into specialty care, then you're back out. We don't have data across all those, so we see when somebody's in our system that we don't see what happens when they're out. There's also, you know, this sort of crossover often with justice and we don't see their data necessarily either.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, I think, you know, it's all driven by funding streams right now and rather than what is the best need to wrap around a child or a youth, it's about where the funding is and who gets reimbursed for those things.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, I think, you know, this is just my humble opinion, until we figure out a way where we can serve the person, both mind, body, physically whole and provide reimbursement that serves that person versus, you know, you get a piece, you get a piece and then you guys all have to figure it out and let the, you know, every parent's own adventure when they're trying to navigate the system, it's going to remain challenging.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And certainly inefficient, it sounds like. Right? People aren't getting the care they need quickly. There's redundancies in billing. It seems like there's a huge opportunity, if there was better coordinated efforts, as you all have touched upon, that maybe we could deliver care a little bit more effectively.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    But it sounds like that coordinated effort between agencies and levels of provider, maybe something that we need to work on going forward. Huge undertaking. State of California is doing a huge undertaking here. So, definitely. And then, a question about, Christine, for screening tools. Is that something that's reimbursable?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Do you know? You mentioned that there are screening tools on the Internet. I know former school district, I was part of Powell Unified, we had those similar screening tools that would capture trigger words.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, my understanding is for that particular system that is highlighting the, the concern, we wouldn't be able to bill for that. But once we bring that child in to assess what's going on that is billable. So, if it is a, if a, if a student types in something about self-harm, they would then be—it'll initiate a counselor or social worker to calm them down. They would then do the Columbia risk assessment with them and that is billable.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Okay, thank you. I mean, like my colleague said, there's so many things that I would love to chat with you about, but we do have to stick to time and respect our other panelists. Thank you for your presentations, presentations today. Appreciate it.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I look forward to working with you in the future as we look at what we can do better for the State of California. Thank you. Next up is our provider perspective. Panel 2A will be Dr. Scott Kane, Pyle Beam, and Susan Ryder—Dr. Susan Ryder.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And we will just go in order that you are listed on the agenda. So, Dr. King, you're first up.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Good afternoon, Dr. Patel.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Can you guys hear me? Okay, push the button. That always works. All right, thank you, Dr. Patel. Thank you so much for inviting me. It's really an honor to be here. Thank you to all the government agency folks who gave that wonderful discussion of the work they do.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We really rely on many of those programs, and it makes a big difference to have those programs so fully funded. I want to talk a little bit about my background. I'm a child and adolescent psychiatrist. I've been doing child and adolescent psychiatry about 25 years. Most of that was with the Navy.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Before I went to medical school, I was a high school teacher for two years. So, a shout out to our educators. I am currently working at Sharp Mesa Vista Hospital as their Director of Outpatient and Intake Services. Sharp Mesa Vista has about 150 beds across all the age groups. We have about 20 beds for adolescents and children.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We also have six different programs—intensive outpatient, partial hospitalization programs. We can talk about those a little bit later because those represent discrepancy in health care because they're not often eligible for Medi Cal patients to see. I worked in the corrections facility at Donovan State Hospital for about six months. Very interesting experience doing that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And then, currently, I'm on the board of directors for NAMI San Diego, National Alliance for Mental Illness. They have like over 600 affiliations across the nation, and San Diego has the largest affiliation, which I'm really proud of, the work they do. They work in 15 different locations, 36 different programs.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And then, I'm also the father of three who have graduated from Poway Unified School District, ages 19 to 25. Gives me an interesting perspective on what our kids get to go through. And then as a parent, I was fortunate to set up a parent wellness program. We call it the Mental Wellness Committee at Westview High School.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    That's still going on now. It really aims at parent support as well as teacher and student education. So, again, thank you for letting me talk here. I was thinking about what perspective to bring. I really want to get away from what happens on the individual patient basis.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Actually, I don't know that we need a lot of support on that—the medications and the therapy. There's a lot of research and interest in that. I'd be happy to talk about that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Instead, I wanted to talk about this question I think we all have, which is how do we go from the one patient model at a time to really managing mental health for our youth across the entire county. That's really a huge challenge.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I thought I would start filling in where Dr. Vogels said she was going to give a little bit of a vignette. So, I'm going to take you through what an experience is like being a child and adolescent psychiatrist. So, seeing a teenager in the emergency room, this is more of an amalgam of patients, not one patient in particular.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But a typical patient I might get called to see in the emergency room—it's a very busy place. A 14-year-old girl who was in high school, went to the counselor's office, said she was cutting the night before and was having suicidal thoughts. That usually triggers a necessary evaluation.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    The school typically will call 911. Typically, there will be a police response. It may or may not be PERT. In those cases, they typically will bring the patient to the hospital. The parents may or may not be called at that moment. Typically, the patient is transported in handcuffs in a police squad car.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And then, they come to this really busy emergency room. We try to reach the parents; they come frantically to see us. And that patient typically talks about having some depression and some anxiety. They'll typically talk about some parental conflict going on. They'll talk about maybe being bullied by peers on social media.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    They may have some uncertainty about gender identity. I might suspect that they're using substances. They may be evasive about any kind of sexual assault history. And you can imagine that's not the environment where they're going to just open up and start talking to you.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    They're really wanting to not give information to me that's just going to turn around and go right to their parents. That dynamic has a lot to do with why they're presenting in a crisis. They're feeling isolated from friends and honestly oftentimes never seen a therapist or a psychiatrist before.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And you would think—now, my job in the emergency room is to put all that back together like Humpty Dumpty, right? But the reality is that my main decision factor there is do I admit them to an inpatient psychiatric unit, or do I discharge them back to these overwhelmed parents?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I just want to emphasize how inadequate those two choices are. And they're basically all I get at this really critical time for this young person. So, what's the problem with acute inpatient stay? It's wonderful. It guarantees the patient will be safe for typically 72 hour period, but it's a scary time.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    It, as a result, can be traumatic. Parents are usually not allowed to visit except maybe one or two hours during the day. It's traumatic for the parents and it raises the question, well, what happens at the end of that 72 hours or week long process?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Because we know that all those issues I raised are not going to get fixed in such a short amount of time. We could start medications. They typically take weeks to really have a benefit. And then, in 72 hours, what are we doing with therapy? So, let's look at the other option, discharging the patient.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Well, what message does that send? This kid who was brought to the hospital and we gave their whole story that they didn't want to tell anybody and we say, well, okay, you can go now. And here is a six page handout with all the resources that you can look up. There's no warm handoff in that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    The other thing that's just an awful experience for me as a parent is to look those parents in the eye and try to explain all the issues that are going on while protecting their child's confidentiality and explaining, well, what's really going to help is if this person develops a therapeutic alliance with this person you don't even know.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Right? It's just more than they can really manage. And so, that really led to a lot of my thoughts about how we could do better in that circumstance. One common thing is they'll get referred back to primary care.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I know in other states, we do have, other states will put together a network of consultants to talk to pediatricians, right?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, when they are in their office and they have somebody there and they feel overwhelmed, they can activate this consultation service that's paid for by the state and it is a program that would be, I think, really useful for us to do. The next thing is, of course, we talked about access to outpatient therapy.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    It's almost impossible to get that coming out of the emergency room.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, if, in the old days when I was in training, that was a requirement, they came into the emergency room, they didn't leave the emergency room unless you had a therapy appointment within seven days, preferably the next day, and then, there's really no connection back to the school.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    This is the system that identified the patient and sent them to us. Now, that would be unacceptable—if it was a therapist who was sending a patient to me, I would call the therapist and explain what's going on to close the loop.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But the school system, we just don't have any partnership because there's so much anxiety about confidentiality, despite us all knowing the critical emergency nature of the situation. So, I think there's a lot we could do better and hopefully not taking up too much of your time.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I'm going to go through a couple of my visions for how we could do that better. And it really does start in the high school. So, first of all, this probably started back before high school even started.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I really think a lot of the anxiety that the kids feel has to do with how to transition to high school, so we could do a better job and I know a lot of the schools do a nice job of orienting from 8th grade into the freshman year.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think schools should dedicate some time and space to student wellness. I have school systems where they actually will have wellness days, and these are college students who now say that really made a difference to my well being after leaving the school. So, I think that's worth thinking about. We've talked about counselors, teacher.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I love the peer support programs that were identified. This is teaching people the language that we need for our young people to feel comfortable talking within their own space as opposed to waiting to come to an emergency room and talk to a total stranger.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think we really want to encourage the testimony of our parents, teachers, coaches, peers, about their mental wellness experience, and so, it takes courage, right? I'm fine to say in public that I've done my own therapy; I've gone through taking medications.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    You want to feel comfortable standing up as leaders to say this is okay, this works, doesn't have to be the way forward, but we all need some kind of connections. We all need to make some special effort. And so, there's no exceptions to that. Everybody's going to be involved in connecting with other people feeling down.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We've got to make sure that they hear that message, that this happens to everybody at all age levels. I think also we need to, and you guys know this, we need to encourage connectedness over social media. Lots of times, kids think they're connected because they're on social media.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And this is an old school concept, but I call it empty calories. Right? It's like eating celery. You're not getting any energy out of that. The connectedness really depends on physical presence, connection with another human being, and we need to really emphasize that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, in school counseling and parent education, collaboration with the county, other not for profit organizations—I mentioned NAMI for example—one program, I know Aaron's going to talk a little bit late about this, mental health first aid for youth and parents. Right?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We all are familiar with CPR and yet nobody does mental health training which is going to be able to—all of us would be able to utilize that in our own lives. So, I think that should be part of the educational curriculum on some level. I love the county's mobile crisis response team. What a new vision.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Instead of calling 911 and getting police, you get therapists to come and they talk to you. When I was working at the Palomar Crisis Stabilization Unit, they told me that it was about for every 10 calls they got, they would bring us maybe one or two. And I was always impressed by that number.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    They're doing therapeutic interventions at the person's home. I think most of the community doesn't understand that that's available simply by calling 988. I'm amazed that, you know, half the patients and families I talk to have never heard of 988. Right? So, I think we can do a better job advertising that and encouraging that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And people will learn more about it and it'll get better over time. I'd like us to see if we can somehow expand the Youth Crisis Stabilization Program. Right now, I think we only have the one, and it's such a wonderful model. There may need to be some tweaks done.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But other locations around the county would help avoid needing to do that whole emergency evaluation. Timely assessments that allows for the development of the therapeutic alliance. So, the way I teach my residents is the most important thing you're doing when you're doing assessment is safety.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But the second most important thing you're doing is you're connecting with that person in front of you. You know this. That takes time, that takes listening, that takes acknowledgement, and that comes back to resources. So, the more people that are familiar with how to develop a therapeutic alliance, the more effective we're going to be as a community.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And we can leave our top end level providers to deal with the severe mental illness as opposed to all of the community's anxieties in different areas. I tried to get at this before. I think we just need to collaborate with parents and schools, especially the counselors, on a regular basis. These are experts.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    They know about the kids and what they're going through. They need to hear what we think. I know there's an issue about confidentiality. It just does not make sense to me when we have such a mental health crisis among our youth that we don't have a mechanism to communicate.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Perhaps there's a way for parents to consent to that from the beginning. Perhaps it could be on like the student card, like an organ donor card. Right? Just something where we are okay to do what we know is important and what any small town community would be doing to communicate because the enemy is isolation and loneliness. Right?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    It's not the privacy of the kids—that's important, don't get me wrong—but we've got to make sure they walk away knowing that the people in the community know about them, care about them, and value them. I think we have—I did want to talk a little bit about intensive outpatient programs.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I'm sure a lot of our experts understand this. It's a much better model for care after a crisis than an acute inpatient stay. So, I went through what it's like on an acute inpatient unit. Intensive outpatient program is just as it sounds like.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    You're going 3-4 days a week, maybe half a day, but at the end of the day, you're maybe going back to school, you're going home at night, and you sleep in your bed, you sleep on the weekends, and you come back, you're dealing with real world problems.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And what you're doing is you're practicing what you were guided to do the day before and you come back the next day and say, well, that didn't work. I need another strategy. When you're on the inpatient unit, you're not practicing any of that. You're just worried about what you're going to do when you get out.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    The issue is we're so worried about safety, we tend not to refer out of these crises to an outpatient, intensive outpatient, or partial hospitalization program. At Sharp Mesa Vista, I've been amazed. One of the things they do is a lot of means restriction with parents at night.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And they do a wonderful job and have phenomenal results with keeping kids out of the acute inpatient unit and into some of these other programs. So, I think that's another piece that we could be trying to emphasize. Partnerships for other organizations and the in peer—sorry, the in-school peer support model.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I want you to think a little bit more about what that means. These are kids who feel the need to reach out and connect with others who are struggling.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    If we can connect kids in need with these ones, be able to reach out, not only does that make the connection, but it models for them how to do it for the next person. It's a pay it forward model.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And instead of trying to create always a safety net where you need our support, if we can show the kids that they actually can do this themselves for the next person, that's more empowering than anything. So, I'd love to see us continue to encourage that. All right, so thank you for listening to all of my spiel.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I've got more ideas that we could talk about. But, you know, when I think about this, I mentioned the safety net concept. My vision is for us to change that to more like an engagement trampoline. Right? Kids come in, we engage with them, and then we send them back out to succeed and develop.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    They don't all need psychiatrists and therapists and medication. Some do, but not all. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you so much. Yep, go ahead. Thank you.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    Okay, can everyone hear me? Oh, thank you. Yes, I do have slides. I think I'm the only one on this panel who did. So, my name is Payal Beam. I have the privilege of serving as the Vice President for Mental, Behavioral, and Developmental Services at Rady Children's Hospital, San Diego. Rady Children's has been around since 1954.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    It is a large safety net for many of the children, probably over 90% of the children in our community. And so, that's not right. S, I just, I wanted to share a little bit about who we are, what we do. Do I have my—hold on? Okay, no problem. I can get started, though.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, we are, like I said, we serve over 90% of the children in our community. And let's see. It's not forwarding. There we go. Okay. As you can see, we have over 2,000 staff, over 900 patient beds. This is combining our recent merger with Orange County. And we are in six different counties, over 12,000 employees.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, we're a very large network of inpatient and outpatient level services, including the two trauma centers in Southern California. That's—here we go.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, in 2015, our board really set out on this vision to look at the whole child care, not separate, you know, physical health from behavioral health, mental health, and really look at the whole child as—and the reason for that was the strong belief that there is no health without mental health.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, this is something we strongly believe in. We've been working towards that for a very long time. Back in, you know, the driving force behind it, I mean, I know we talked a little bit about COVID numbers and beyond, but between 2012 and 2022, we saw over a 1,200% increase in behavioral health issues in our emergency room. 1,200% increase. 2022 was the peak, but the numbers, it's been continuing for a lot longer for the previous decade.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, we really started out at that point. You know, our board decided we have to do something about it. This next slide is more a continuum. That was our conversation about what we're going to do and what we're not going do as an organization.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    But since 2016, we've been adding on to the levels of services, the layers that we've been providing. And so, in 2016, we started depression screenings across our continuum, so whether you go in for a neurology visit or primary care or physical therapy, like we really started those across the board.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And I think since 2020, we've done over 1.3 million depression screenings so far. After that, we added a behavioral health urgent care in mid-city that was funded by Price Philanthropies and now it's running independently. Also, we added a psych emergency department, so six bays connected to—in our main hospital.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, children can actually go there and either get admitted to inpatient or they can be released home or to other community providers. We also added, during the COVID 19 Pandemic, we added mental health integration programs. So, we have mental health therapists embedded within our primary care practices across the county.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    Actually, this goes from Hemet all the way to Chula Vista. And it's been an incredible program, with its challenges, but we trained over 200 primary care physicians in addressing some of the low level issues. So, depression, anxiety, ADHD, everyone's coming in with that.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, our primary care doctors now have more confidence and competence in addressing these issues in house. And they can also connect with the in-house therapist and also refer to psychiatry as needed.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, in 2025, January of this year, we brought all of these services together under one single umbrella, forming the Mental Behavioral Health Institute, which now rolls up to me, so that's how my job became available. These are a lot of the programs that we currently have.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And again, you know, we were talking about prevention and early intervention. The early intervention piece is really what we're seeing in our primary care integration and healthy steps programs. We're doing those depression screenings I mentioned. We have a lot of partnerships. No one can do it by themselves.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    We really need to be working with our community partners, our county partners, like Nadia was mentioning earlier. Right? Like whether it's the Regional Center or justice involved, I mean we should be collaborating so we know what's happening so we can make adjustments, because no one needs to be doing everything. We don't have that kind of bandwidth.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, we have this continuum of entry like outpatient programs, emergency services, acute care, and also education and training because workforce has already been talked about quite a bit. Where I want to spend some time is our systemic barriers. So, early identification and access are critical. We continue to have such long wait times across the board.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    I mentioned our mental health integration program. It's an amazing program because you go to your primary care physician, there's no stigma. Everyone goes to their primary care doctor. You can see a therapist right there. The challenge with us is you can only go to that provider as long as that person's embedded within your primary care doctor's office.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    Right? You can't just go. It's not something that everyone has available. And so, that's a barrier. Whether it's age, geography, insurance, you know, these are all barriers that we experience on a daily basis, and I think everyone in this room can attest to that. Mental health parity has been the law.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    But in reality, the reimbursements continue to be ridiculously low. We talked about the timeliness of reimbursement. You know, large organization like ours, we can sustain a few months, but smaller organizations, they're struggling to make payroll.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, when you know you have the qualified provider, when you know you have the service that's been delivered, what are the reasons for it to take 90 to 120 days? Especially because on the flip side, access is an issue.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And so, when we know that an access continues to get delayed because we're not getting reimbursed in an accurate or timely manner—someone else had a slide earlier about the 50% denial rate. That's unacceptable. If you're doing everything to be a qualified provider, you shouldn't be having denials at that rate. Mental health services.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    There was a question earlier about stigma with children or parents. Children don't have the stigma anymore. Our kids are asking for the help. They are very comfortable asking for help. Our parents are getting more and more on board. But I don't know that our insurers are necessarily valuing mental health services or the complexity of it.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    You know, we still have the same reimbursement model from, I don't know how long ago. But when you're looking at outpatient level, you know, weekly therapy versus psychiatry, those are reimbursed at different rates. But what about integrated models? Are those reimbursed, you know, the same way by the minute?

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And if you're looking at, you know, meeting your payroll because people have to bill so many minutes to get that much reimbursement, that's not necessarily—you're not necessarily looking at the value. Right? And so, just the different levels of services that we do have, we do continue to add them.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    But we're also really reliant on how we're getting reimbursed and the sustainability of it. Many, many, many of our services continue to be supported through philanthropy, through short term grants.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And like someone said earlier in the school panel, you know, having to serve notices, I mean, of course that's going to add to the workforce shortage because people are looking for stability. If you're planning to stay in San Diego, you know, you got to have a job, you're not going to be able to do it for free.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    And then, the administrative burden, so even building up billing in any of these programs, the administrative burden, because not only is mental health reimbursed at a lower rate, you have the burden of the—it's more complex.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, someone who can bill physical health services, I don't know, maybe they can Bill 100, 150 encounters a da. For mental health, they're probably able to build 35 encounters a day. And so, those are all of the things that they're really worth talking about when we look at systemic barriers.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, my personal stance needs to be more transparency in how people can bill for services and how we can sustain those programs, because if we have transparency and you know, this is what your reimbursement is going to look like, then it's a whole lot easier to make those services happen.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    Workforce shortage is very much directed to reimbursement because when we have new graduates working with severe populations, the more complex, these are the folks we should have people with 8, 10, 20 years of experience working with and we have instead brand new graduates who are being traumatized working through this.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    So, and that adds to the administrative burden because you have to do it differently depending on the payer, because payers don't necessarily want the same information before they reject your claim. So, just a little bit on systemic barriers. But that being said, we are continuing to provide more services because we know there's a need.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    I'm very excited about this. We are building a new campus and that's going to be coming up in about three years. It's going to increase our capacity, inpatient capacity, to 48 beds. It's going to increase our crisis stabilization from 6 to 24. We are adding intensive outpatient and partial hospitalization programs which we don't currently have.

  • Payal Beam

    Person

    We'll have 20 slots for those. And you know, continuing to partner with our partners just in the community so we can serve our children together because we just can't leave them hanging. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you for bringing forward that insightful information. We'll definitely take it with us. I have so many questions, but we do have one more panelist for this section, Dr. Reiter.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    So, thank you for having me today. I'm Dr. Susan Reiter. I am the Director of Business Development and Psychoeducation for Aurora Behavioral Health.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    So, we are probably, in this room, one of the only private for-profit health care programs, which actually puts us in a very interesting and unique position because despite the fact that we are private and for profit, we still see as many underserved patients in high priority areas in high priority communities as everyone else in this room.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And yet, our ability to get reimbursed and the ability, the effect that it has on workforce and is tremendously different. So, I want to kind of speak to that a little bit.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Dr. Kane did an amazing job of talking about what it looks like when someone comes into an emergency room and how short the length of stay is for acute care. 20 years ago, when I started in this role, acute care was longer for youth.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    It was about 10 days length of stay and 20 years prior to that, it was 30 days. Essentially, it was residential treatment.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And so, the parental expectation that my child is going to go into your services, they're going to feel better when they come out, was a realistic expectation because we know that, for example, an antidepressant takes four to six weeks to kick in.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Well, if they're with us for 72 hours with the likelihood that that antidepressant has kicked in, we know what their side effects are. We don't even know if it's the appropriate therapeutic level. Unfortunately, our, like, our definition of medical necessity for acute care has shrunk.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    But the societal expectation of what our level of care is supposed to do has changed, has not changed. I can't tell you how many parents I meet with who are like, well, you must have just gotten so much better at your job. What you used to do in 30 days you can now do in three.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    I'm like, no, we can still only do it in 30 days, we just only have your child for three. So, imagine being a parent or being a child, a youth, a student who is at the premier crisis point in their life. They're at their lowest point and they are finally reaching out for help.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    They've not reached out previously, they've not sought other services and they're like, I'm going inpatient. This is, I mean, I'm at the bottom. I have hit rock bottom. And then, three days later, they don't feel that much better than when they started.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    What they do is they lose faith in the healthcare system altogether because they feel like, well, it didn't help. If this is supposed to be the best level of care, this is supposed to be the highest level of care.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And three days later, I still feel horrible, and families are still in a whirlwind, and we're trying to piece together, in this very siloed system, after care for the individual. It becomes a tremendous barrier for the families because they're like, well, inpatient didn't help. Oh, and wait a minute.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    I don't have the right insurance in order to access intensive outpatient programming. I mean, ideally it would go inpatient, partial hospitalization, intensive outpatient programming, and then, once a week, therapeutic care with an outpatient provider. Or if, if individuals need a higher level after inpatient, they would go to residential and then PHP and then IOP.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Well, unfortunately, not all providers cover PHP or IOP and there are very limited resources for our Medi Cal kiddos with regard to IOP. We have our first IOP level of care at San Diego Center for Children here in San Diego, but their slots are highly limited, and the wait list for that is beyond measure.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    So, we have kids who have this need, and we tell parents, this is the best step down for you, and they go, well, but I can't get them in. And the schools are then left to fill that gap and fill that burden. When I started 20 years ago, counselors did academic counseling.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Now, they are tasked with behavioral health counseling. They are supposed to be substance use counselors, mental health counselors, sex ed counselors, HIV counselors, gender identity counselors, you name it.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    They're supposed to pick up every social, emotional, learning component of a child's life that was previously covered in a village that surrounded our youth, often in faith communities, often in large congregational families and extended families. And it's now being kind of dumped on the schools. And the schools have stepped up in a massive, massive way.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Unfortunately, there is that gap between inpatient care and the school in terms of us being able to get information to them.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    All too frequently, I will have a family admit their child on a Friday night, knowing that they will discharge on a Sunday, and then tell us we will not sign a release of information because we don't want the school knowing that our kid was there.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Because the stigma is very real still when it comes to our level of care, when it comes to inpatient acute care. The assumption is that other parents are going to go, oh, that apple didn't fall far from that tree, and if that kid has problems, it's the parent's fault, and it's a lack of parental guidance or maybe the parents have drug use or maybe the parents have mental health issues, and we're not going to talk about that.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And so, as opposed to talking about and normalizing mental health and mental illness as a normative medical issue and not judging it the way that we do currently, we don't judge someone who has diabetes and whose family has diabetes, but we judge plenty of people who have depression.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And it's genetic and it's heritable throughout the ages or any sort of substance use the same way because we don't understand them as brain diseases. One of the things I'm always saying to family members is, for a long time, we didn't understand dementia and Alzheimer's on the other end of the spectrum.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    But today, we would never consider saying to someone who has Alzheimer's or dementia, why don't you remember who I am? How come you can't remember my name? Why don't you remember the history that we had? And we don't go through that and then blame the patient and then blame the family for the loved one having Alzheimer's disease.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    But when it comes to depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, ADHD, spectrum disorder, any eating disorder, any disorder that's in the DSM other than the dementia diagnoses and other neurocognitive disorders, we tend to blame the family and blame the patient. Well, why can't you just pick yourself up and get out of bed and go to school?

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Well, I can barely remember to brush my teeth. Right? We expect them to make these huge gains when they get to acute care. They don't make the huge gains.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    They don't have the option to go to partial or IOP or if they do, it's so stigmatized because, well, what is my kid going to do if they go to your IOP program? Then they're not going to be able to school them and then they're going to fall back in school.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And just having that conversation with families when they're in crisis and their frontal lobe is not activated because they are in fight, flight, freeze, fawn, and fold.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    You have a family in crisis and you're trying to go through the litany of resources and all of these options with them and have them understand logically and rationally what this looks like when they're just trying to make sure their kid is still alive. It's really, really, really hard.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    It also doesn't help that, for the last 10 years, we've associated the term active shooter with mental illness. What it has done is made families really shy away from wanting to talk about mental illness, because, uh oh, now my kid's an active shooter. No, your kid has mental illness.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    They have depression, they have anxiety, they have eating disorder. You know, a very small percentage of individuals who have mental health diagnoses then go on to become active shooters. Right? And so, we have this gap in parental awareness, parental understanding, as well as within the system itself.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    One of the things I would love to see is, you know, parents to become more aware of early warning signs. All too frequently it's coming to the school's attention because the parents don't know the warning signs.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Because contrary to popular belief, unlike the driving test, we don't get a manual when kids are born that tell us what warning signs to look for.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And I can guarantee if you got it at the time the kid was born, by the time the time the kid is a teenager, it's going to be outdated and it would probably be written like Ikea instructions anyhow, and no one would know how to use it. So, we focus so much on reactivity as opposed to proactivity.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And if we took a more proactive approach to making sure that parents saw those early warning signs so that they could get their child into mental health services so that they're not stigmatized, so that they haven't had to wait to crisis and then be let down by the system, I think it would really, really create an opportunity for our families.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    The last piece that I want to speak to is workforce. One of the things that hasn't been brought up in this Committee has to do with the PSLF grants. So, PSLF is a student loan reimbursement and forgiveness program that is for individuals who are in health care fields.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    But the only individuals who are eligible for that are people that work for nonprofits or governmental organizations. So, I'm in a for profit hospital. Over 50% of my kids that come in to see me are Medi Cal recipients, tribal kids from the reservations, or dependents for Tricare.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And yet, none of my staff are eligible for loan forgiveness because we're considered a for profit agency. And so, therefore they're not eligible for this forgiveness because theoretically we don't serve underserved populations.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    This is a huge problem because it creates a workforce problem in all of the private hospitals because unless we're willing to pay double, they're not willing to stay. They'll cut their teeth at the for profit organizations, whether it's a hospital or another organization, an agency in the community.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And then they realize, wait a minute, If I work 10 years at a nonprofit, I can get my loans for my six-figure mind mortgage forgiven. But if I stay here, even though I really like it, I'm not going to have that happen. Well, in San Diego, that's a very simple calculus.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And unless you come from an affluent family or you have a heart of gold, you leave the for profit organization, which leads to increased turnover, which leads to poorer outcomes because you don't have the ability to have the continuity of care, even within your own staff.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Because as, you know, Dr. Kane talked about, we have to build rapport and that takes time, and part of that is learning from one another and learning from seasoned professionals in the field. If we don't have those seasoned professionals because they're flying away, it creates a huge problem. And this is, in some ways, a very simple solution.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    Right? And I would be—it would not be in my interest to point out that if we could fix these problems, my hospital would be obsolete. Right? My CEO often says to me, don't, don't, don't push the, you know, your business development. You're supposed to make sure we have patients in the hospital.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And my goal is to keep people out of the hospital and not needing my services. Because at the end of the day, there are always going to be crises, right?

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    There are going to be circumstances where we don't see warning signs, where the kid has hidden this, where there's been so much stigma in the family system or so much hatred or retribution or denial, especially for like our trans kids, for, for example, where they need crisis intervention.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    But from a clinical perspective, my heart breaks for these families that could avoid seeking crisis services because they would be able to seek services at a lower level of care that just aren't available to them.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you, panel, for your remarks. I will open it up to questions. Assemblymember Davies, I'll let you go first.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Really great information, all of you. I really appreciate it and I really like the information you were telling us. What can we do, because that's really what we're here, we're problem solvers. And so, that's what we want to do, is tell us what we can do at a state level.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And so, obviously, I'm not going to go down and ask question after question, but I would love to see if we can get follow up information from you.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And you know, it's so true when you're talking about the loan forgiveness because a lot of different medical associations, you know, you can sit there and work your loan off and there's no reason why, just because you're a private hospital for profit, it should change.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    We need to have professionals that are everywhere with that and the opportunity and the more places that we offer it, the more people that would actually go into the business, I believe, and into the industry. So, it'll be interesting to see what we can do. And have you looked at a federal level at all on that?

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    We have. I know that San Diego Psych Association and a lot of the other, like BBS and a lot of the other organizations, have as well, to talk to our congressmen and women and state senators or state senators at the congressional level, but it's a hard sell, especially when there's a lot of pushback around forgiveness at all.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    It's been a rough handful of years with regard to forgiveness because there's still often a belief system that, oh, so you want to not have to pay for the work that for what you received. Right?

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    As opposed to an awareness that like, for example, I could become a lawyer and make four times my pay and pay off my student loan very easily. But I chose to go into this work not because I was going to become wealthy, but it would be nice if I didn't become homeless in the process.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And I mean that very literally. We have students who move out of the field of mental health because they cannot afford their apartment in San Diego, they cannot afford housing in California. So, if we're looking to workforce, we have to find a way to support them.

  • Susan Reiter

    Person

    And loan forgiveness is a great way because it encourages them to stay in the field.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Maybe what we need to do is label the field and that's, you know, then exactly what the job is or the private part is, you know, if you're doing something in mental illness, you know, whatever it may be, this is then going into that category. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    While we're waiting for Assemblymember Boerner to come back, I'll throw in some questions. Payal, you talked a little bit about integrated models and how the reimbursement rates are different.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I know it's come up to me before by a member who's sitting, a constituent who's sitting in the office here today, who spoke with me at length about reimbursement rates and then insurance clawing back reimbursements that have already been issued and that causing some instability for professionals to practice and even accept insurance in general, whether, you know, they're in private practice or with an institution.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Do you have any—and I'm asking a lot—solutions that you might be willing to offer approaches that we could use to correct some of that?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think going back to just that transparency on reimbursements, right. When you're looking at, I mean like the dyadic care code, you know, it's something. But I remember we had to spend a lot of time educating the payers on, you know; yes, this is approved; yes, this is law; yes, this is what we did.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And so that adds to the administrative burden. And so when you're looking at like small, smaller organizations being able to apply for reimbursement, it's that administrative burden that keeps adding to it. You know, oftentimes we get an auth approved for treatment but not for evaluation, or we get approval for evaluation but not treatment.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Silliness like that "delays". Exactly, it adds time, you know, and also when you're looking at, if you're billing by the minute, you need to have your teams, your patient facing providers booked for a certain number of hours in a day in order to be sustainable.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So what does that do for the people that need to walk in, because you need to have that availability. And so I think really just looking at impact, and I don't have a single soundbite answer, but I think there's definitely more to speak on the transparency of that, you know, what are the delays, what are the denials.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Because if you're doing everything up front to be credentialed, then it should be a no brainer. I mean, like, you know, you go buy a tire, you know how much it costs, you walk out with a new tire. You don't have to figure out like, so not to simplify, you know, mental health services to that level.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But if you have done the work up front, you should get your reimbursement without those challenges.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Well, and certainly I appreciate that it's a very complex issue and not really expecting you to have an answer, but I do want to tackle this. I think there's an absolute need, it's our obligation, our responsibility as legislators to look at this very seriously.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I'm wholeheartedly in agreement with you that mental health and physical health are a continuum of the same body. We are one body. And mental health issues create physical health issues which create new mental health issues.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    It's cyclical because we are one person and I frankly don't understand why health, mental health reimbursement rates are so different from physical health reimbursement rates. And with the billing to the minutes, again, I'm not fully understanding why we don't have more time to see patients.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Because if a patient presents with a crisis and you're in a billable by minute situation, you might want to push that patient out because it's a perverse incentive at that point.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Correct. And oftentimes you're, you know, spending as much time doing the documentation as you are providing services.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And so they're just, I mean, the administrative burden is real and it's significant and it impacts our access and, you know, so all the solutions we're looking at we really focus on, you know, how can we provide more face to face time, how can we see more kids, how can we do more of that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    But it's the noise of the administrative burden that keeps us from doing more.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yep, understood. Dr. Kane, quick question for you. This is something that had come up when I was a school board Trustee with those 51/50 calls. Our students being taken out in a police vehicle with handcuffs is a very tragic situation. They're already feeling they're at their bottom, their worst.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And then we're adding to the stigma of that by handling our children this way, especially in their most vulnerable state. Have you seen an opportunity for us to do that differently with an MCRT or something like that.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    Well, yes, thank you for the question. It's not done this way in every county and every state. And I understand the need for our first responders to maintain a level of safety and that this is outside of their experience.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    But I do think the Mobile Crisis Response Team really does give us an opportunity to see a different way to tackle the problem. Those guys go out with therapists who are trained to have the discussion. We call it motivational interviewing.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    Right where you are, you're talking to the person, they're complaining about what's bothering them and you sort of pivot all that energy into, well, let's go get you some help. That takes some experience and training. I would not expect our police force to know how to do that. I call them for other reasons.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    So we're going the fact that nationally and California and here in San Diego has a parallel program, right. From 988, the mobile crisis response team to the CSUs. I think it's underutilized, but it's mostly aimed at the adult population.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    So if you're looking for an opportunity, there's an opportunity to expand how we think of those three programs, 988, the Mobile Crisis Response Team and the CSU's, to a youth or a transitional age youth program that I think could be very effective.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    That sounds great. Thank you, Assembly Member Boerner.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Yeah, I think both my colleagues covered a lot of what I want I was going to ask. I want to thank you for. First of all, I didn't say opening remarks. I'm Assembly Member Tasha Burner. I represent the Coast. So we basically have all of North County here accounted for.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And I want to thank Assembly Member Dr. Patel for putting this together. I have two teenagers myself, and I think somebody mentioned, I can't remember which one of the women mentioned. Normalizing mental health, last year was my worst mental health year of my life, and this year it's my best mental health year of my life.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And I tell that to people. People are always shocked. It was like, yeah, life is hard. Perimenopause is the worst. We thought puberty was bad. Then you get perimenopause and you're like, never ends. But I'm on the, you know, not quite on the other side, but I'm in a good place now, unfortunately. It's awesome.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    See, we all represent the spectrum. It's all a spectrum. But I think normalizing it is really hard. And what you were saying about the interactions with schools really hit home. You saw I only cry about children and the planet. Those are the two things I cry about.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And, you know, you brought tears to my eyes thinking about that kid in crisis and the fact that we don't have 30 day stays and I can't. I was just imagining if my kids were in crisis, how would I handle that. And I still have a job and I still have to put food on the table.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I still have to cook for the other one. And how do you do with this. You know, we have what I see in the mental health space and this, I've probably served the longest in the state Legislature. So I was pre Covid, Covid, post Covid. I've seen it all.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And we had a problem pre Covid with mental health, and that was when I had the southern part of what's now, Laurie Davies District and really people who have multiple access to barriers, barriers to access on mental health issues and how to get it to them.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And you have these layers of government and we give money at layers of government and we expect them to work together and. And they don't work together. And then we expect different hospital systems to come in.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And I don't think, you know, I have advanced degrees and I don't think I barely could, you know, sign up my kids for high school because that takes a PhD in education.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    But to bring that together with a family in need, what is it that we could do that would Streamline and integrate both the private sector, the public sector, the different layers of government we have, you know, in Vista, we had school districts, we had the county, we had private providers, we had health clinics.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    You have all these things. It's not a navigable system, you know, and that's the barrier that we can solve. That's the barrier we can solve. There are lots of things we can't solve, but the coordination we could solve.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    How do, what would your advice be, each of the panelists on how do we like remove those barriers of coordination so that we. Cause I think often we think of government in terms of like how we do budgeting. The county gets this much money. This gets this much money.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    This is how we do medical, Medicare, reimbursements, whatever. That's not how a person experiences a system. So we don't do it from a person centered perspective. So how do we change that so that we're integrating the services.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And before the pandemic, we were actually at the cusp of doing this with Vista unified, the City of Vista and the county. And the pandemic happened and blew everything up on multiple levels. But I would love to hear your perspective.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    Happy to go. I had to struggle with this when I was in the Navy up at Camp Pendleton. I was Director of mental health. So 50,000 Marines and their families. And when I was up there, found that there was a multitude of resources, all funded through disparate ways.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    And as I went around the community, I found out that each of the commanding officers had found one or two of them. And so that was their go to program. And what happened is if a person didn't fit into that program, they would educate the commanding officers.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    Well, if it's this kind of a problem, you go to that program. If it's that kind of this one. And so the commanding officers were keeping track of a huge diagram of where to go for different programs. And so it wasn't my idea. We took it from another base. But the idea was no wrong door, right.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    So it was to reverse the education process. So we went to all the commanding officers. We started by going to all the different agencies and said, let's partner, let's tell all the commanding officers. It doesn't matter which program you go to, because we all have the same goal in mind.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    And, and we will work behind the scenes to streamline all the communication and passing out. You're in this zip code, you're at this stage, we'll sort it out. And that is so reassuring to recognize. We have all these programs, but it doesn't matter which one I go to, I'm going to be able to access it.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    So how do you do that. What you need is, and we have a model here based on domestic violence, the one safe place. If you haven't been to that organization, you should go. It was funded by our DA, Stephan Sommers. And what it is, is all the organizations come into one place, all part of that program.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    And we know in North County if you need access for domestic violence, you go there and you'll get referred to the correct place. You don't have to know all 80 different programs. You mentioned navigation, right. When I started working at Palomar Health in the ed we had substance use navigators.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    I'd never heard of that before, became incredibly effective. We're using them all the time. I can't solve your opioid problem, but this substance use navigator can create a path for you to go.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    So if we had a mental health navigator, a youth mental health navigator who just plugs into that one organization that gets all the resources and quickly links you to the right place, you would have something that's very effective. The other secret for you to understand is mental health is a build it and they will come model. Right.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    In other words, we all think we need more mental health and more mental health. It's an anxiety. When I was in the navy, we built a mental health walk in clinic. And I know we have them in the county, but we didn't have something like that in the local navy.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    And people thought I was crazy because they're like, you're gonna have like 100 people lined outside the door. But this is a secret to access. If you don't think you have access, you're banging on doors because you think you have to to get in.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    If it's going to take me seven weeks to get in, I better start now. Everybody's banging. We opened the walk in center and you know, we had 10 people in line and we took care of them. What happens is once people know they can get in, they don't actually want to come see me.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    They just want to know they can in the middle of the night when they really need to. And so that's why it's so critical to have a 988 program. You know, I mentioned NAMI. We have, we locally have the contract for the Warmline. It's a California program.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    It's an example of programs that are getting defunded because we're losing money. But to me it's an example of easy access to gain connection to navigate system that just doesn't cost very much money. So again, to address these issues, we need straightforward, easy places to go where people know how to navigate.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    And you know, the other thing you do is you just ask somebody on the phone, is this a today problem or like a two day problem or like a two week problem. And again, if they're panicked, they're not thinking that. But if you're just asking that question, I could wait two weeks. Awesome, outpatient mental health.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    You just triaged to the right place. I can wait two days. That's an IOP level problem. So we sometimes get carried away with needing to do this really fancy triage process when people just need to know that when they need it, they can get care. Again, I'm sorry for talking too long.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Good stuff there. I would completely agree with the no wrong door process because that's what we need. We should be able to, it shouldn't be up to the patient, family who's in crisis to navigate the age, the geography, the insurance. You should be able to go anywhere and then we figure it out at the back end.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think one of the things I've seen now in San Diego for 15 years is we tend to be a very collaborative community. And so, you know, I mean, I walked in, it's like, yeah, I know half the people here.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And because for that reason, right, because we work together and say, like, this is at my level, this should be at your level.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I mean, as a hospital, if it's not meeting the complexity or acuity, we shouldn't be having kids to come to us, you know, and I'll say that openly and anywhere, whether it's with my leadership or, you know, with our community partners, like, we should be supporting each other in being successful so we can serve the needs of all the kids.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    I think one of the things that we've seen historically is that it's not no wrong door, it's all wrong door in our county. You're not in this zip code. You were in this zip code for this program, but you're still in that zip code. But this program doesn't cover that zip code.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    We have such fragmentation in the way that our RFPs go out and our contracts go out that, you know, families don't know how to navigate that. And they also don't know how to navigate when they go from one payer to another.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    We have patients that had been in a managed care program and now they're in a Different managed care program, or maybe now they're in the county, or maybe they started an FQHC which had integrated care on site, where you had primary care and you had a navigator and you had a mental health clinician right on site.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And they just said, you're having a, let me have you walk over here. And now they're in a siloed system where you need to get a referral in order to go see someone to do an assessment. And it's six weeks out to get that assessment.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And then by the time you get that assessment, you've either forgotten about it, resolved it yourself, or gotten to a crisis and you've now landed in a hospital. Right. So we don't do a very good job on the preventative side by doing that real integrative model. And the FQHC's do an amazing job of that. Right.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    Because it is an integrated model. It literally is. Let me walk you down here and you can talk to the mental health clinician. And it normalizes mental health, right. We also need to talk about it in terms of mental health as opposed to only talking about it in terms of mental illness.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And we also need to include our partners at the Regional Center and our folks that work with developmental disabilities and spectrum disorders, because I know that all of us are seeing more and more what we used to call years ago, dual diagnosis, which was before we called dual diagnosis, you know, having substance use and mental health issues.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    It was individuals that had intellectual disability or developmental delay as well as mental health, psychiatric issues. More and more we're seeing kids, especially coming in who are on the spectrum and also have psychiatric illness or they're coming in for behavioral issues as a result of their spectrum diagnosis. That's not psychiatric.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    Psychotropic medication is not going to help them. Right. They need ADA, they need to have therapy. One of the things that I think is really, really imperative in the context of mental health is for us to recognize that both of my fellow panelists have talked about the fact that this is not a short term fix.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And all too frequently we think of mental health and mental illness as acute in nature as opposed to chronic. And the thing that's interesting about chronic illness is that we forget there's something called remission. We assume that if someone has a chronic illness that they're always going to be symptomatic, they're always going to have to manage everything.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    Every day is going to be a burden, as opposed to reminding them that chronic illness has periods of remission.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    But we need to stay on top of it with whole body wellness, with looking at mind body integrated care, with being able to address those warning signs early on and having a no wrong door, where if you go to your primary care physician, they know, you know what, this is outside of my scope, but I know who to refer you to.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And it doesn't have to be the hospital, right. It can be a clinician in the community or IOP or PHP, but all too frequently they don't even know that they can refer to IOP or therapists don't know that they can refer to IOP and still keep their patient.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    They're like, if they go to IOP, I lose my patient for eight weeks. No, that's not true. And so, you know, when we look at graduate education as well, the education's on the clinical side, but not the business side of the house.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    You know, I can't tell you how many new grads don't even know what 988 is. New grads, they don't know what 211 is. So they're not learning this in graduate school. Right.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And that's a problem because if our new graduates don't know what 988 and 211 are, how can they educate their patients and the communities that they serve with that information to find that no wrong door. Because the beauty of the access and crisis line is they have those connections, they can pull it up.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    It would be lovely if we had that rubric right, where we all know and luckily with the relationships that we have, we can do that.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    I just wish it wasn't so difficult because one of the things that also happens with the siloing process is Medi-Cal patients have to be seen in Medi-Cal clinics and managed care patients can be seen in managed care clinics. So you see fragmentation outside of hospital and emergency care.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    This fragmentation where, if you're going to see this type of patient, you have to be in this physical setting and if you're going to see this patient, you have to be in this type of physical setting. And yet the two patients are identical in presentation, but we're treating them very differently just because of their payer stream.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    And that's a problem. And that is something that can get addressed at, you know, at a state level with regard to, you know, being able to see these medi-Cal patients at the same time that they can be seen in a managed care situation, not just in a hospital or a crisis situation.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I've gotten permission from Dr. Patel to ask one question, but you have to answer in one sentence less than 10 words. What can the state do to address the issue with mental health stigma? 10 words, 1 sentence.

  • Susan Ryder

    Person

    Remind people that mental health is not a characterological flaw.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Along those lines it impacts everyone. Everyone has every single person family has been touched by mental illness or mental disease mental illness and needs support at some point in their life.

  • Scott Kane

    Person

    Help teachers, parents, school systems understand that their kids are going to be okay and that they can do this and encourage them as opposed to finding flaws.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you for closing out this panel with some optimism. Appreciate that heavy topic. I'm pretty sure we all have a thousand things we could have asked you in addition so you will be having follow up from us. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And we will have our panel 2B panelists please come up. Thank you.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Oh, you are? Yep. Okay, here we are. Here we are. We're all together first, right? Yes.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Thanks, Caleb.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you. We will go in order of the agenda. Karen, you can go first.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Thank you for being here. Yes. I'm Karen Ogden and my husband and I have a nonprofit and it's Solifex. It's a youth leadership and wellness organization. So 30 years I've spent as a teacher and my husband 36, working mostly as a school principal. Can you hear me? Okay? Okay.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Who now works in the charter world working with dropout recovery students. You can find most of our information on our website. So if I don't cover what you want, most of it is there.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So year after year, we'd witnessed the growing social emotional challenges our kids were facing a lot dealing with unrealistic performance, pressure creating anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation. So when learning that there were seven suicides in four years at our local high school and those are the ones we heard about, I knew I needed to do something.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Our community in Poway formed what I Wish my parents knew, a Committee with a lot of leaders in the community, and I was a part of that. But what I really wanted to address is what is our community doing for prevention? How are our students getting to this point? Right. So in 2013, it's been a while.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    I retired early so that I could devote myself full time to youth mental well being and began doing research with mostly Cal State San Marcos teams, healthcare professionals and a suicide prevention specialist. So our nonprofit, Soul Effects stands for Step Out, Lead Every Day and the effects it has on our lives and others.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    And it was launched in 2015. Our mission is to empower youth to become confident, purpose driven leaders. I'm assuming I go here? Whoops. There we go. For three years, we worked with high school focus groups led by college students.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Then for eight years, our team took 25 to 30 college interns into Powell Unified School District middle and high schools as they mentored students over 91 hour sessions every spring.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    With the guidance and direction of our team of professionals, these interns, through trial and error of different strategies and methods, together we came up with best practices for the greatest impact. I'd like to say pickleball would be the answer to everything, but there is. There was so much that we learned.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So we created a Youth Our solopex Journey program, which we refer to as a Youth Leadership and Wellness. I think I mentioned that and you can understand it much better on our website. What an adventure. We don't use the word lesson looks like. And what it entails.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    We have clear evidence that near peers have most of the answers. With a constantly changing world of media, our youth listen to them as they share their own personal challenges and strategies on how they overcame these. Dr. Patel attended our sessions in the high schools and was always very, very supportive of our work.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    As I was telling Tiffany Campbell, she was always in the weeds and I just really respected that about Dr. Patel. Because organizations saw that lives were not only being changed and several lives saved, many came alongside us.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    We received 36 grants over the years and the most impactful have been RV Sunrise, Rotary Assembly Member Kristen Gaspar, Joel Anderson and our last grant provided us with a half $1.0 million, which is Brian Maienschein Assembly. Brian Maienschein is a huge proponent of youth mental health and we'll be forever grateful for his work.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Brian wanted to ensure that our program was going to not only significantly impact hundreds of thousands more students, but it would truly be life changing for each of them and that he wanted to see sustainability. So right here it shows the numbers, I believe. Sorry. Sorry.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    Right here it shows the numbers and that top is actually doubled since then. So I'm going to go back to right, right here. Because of Brian's support, we created 10 very impactful videos. We hired a producer, Director and a diverse team of five online college influencers who we knew would be extremely positive role models for students.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    These influencers are the ones who teach the lessons and provide specific strategies for each of the lessons you can see here and achieving our goal of making it as easy as possible for teachers and for implementers.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    We never thought we could replace in person mentoring from college students, but we have a training for peer students to be the guides or the mentors.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    That actually has been more impactful because they used to try to want to impress the college students and now they're working with their peers and who step who are stepping up and leading their small teams of students in discussions. So students are able to set goals each week. Their team provides accountability and support from them.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    This funding of Brian's allowed US to impact 7,500 high school students in Poway Unified, Escondido Union High School and San Marcos Unified. So and I could not believe there's paid counselors, peer counselors in San Marcos. I was just so amazed with that, learned so much here.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So in 20221 of the largest and most successful educational organizations in our country, AVID was very interested in our program at that time. Following the social and emotional impact Covid had on students, they were looking to create exactly what we have in our Journey program.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So we met with avid's Vice President, their curricular team and business team, and they ended up acquiring our program. They have taken our journey to their seventh and 10th grade students nationwide, as well as Canada and Australia. So we're thrilled about that, especially as retirees. Today.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    SOL Effects is able to provide our program to any youth organization outside of all K12 public and private schools because of AVID owning that Cal State University has implemented. Cal State San Marcus has implemented our program and their leadership programs for three years now. And it's relevant for seventh grade through young adults.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So so many students would come to us and say, we're so tired of people coming in and lecturing to us and telling us what to do. We know what to do and we just need to be able to talk.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    And, and that's what they said was different about SOL Effects is that they could have conversations, honest conversations with each other in small groups, realizing that they are not alone.

  • Karen Ogden

    Person

    So we're firm believers that all students are in need of communities, safe places like we all do, where they feel they're not the only ones with their challenges, but a place they can express themselves and feel that they belong. And our SoloFX journey is meeting this need. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Christa, go ahead.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Hi. Thanks so much for having us. I'm Krista Esquivel. I'm Vice President at the YMCA here in San Diego County and I'm a social worker. I've been a social worker for 20 years. I'm here with my colleague Kristina Halmai, who's a therapist. And number one, we're very happy to be here.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Number two, the YMCA sits in a very unique place here in San Diego. County. We have the opportunity to serve lots of children, families through our child care, amazing enrichment programs. But we also have a continuum of clinical treatment programs here in San Diego at ry.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And we have the enjoyment of being funded by the County of San Diego Behavioral Health Services, also cybhi, also samhsa at the federal level, also fee based, also Medi Cal.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So we really see the gamut of the challenges that exist and that Ms. Pravara, with the county Behavioral Health brought up in terms of the interconnectedness but also the disconnection between these funding sources. And I think you said it very well, Assemblymember.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    When our families and our children, they don't know what they're funded by and they're seeking services and as a provider who has to use multiple lines of funding to do that with a family and to make it feel seamless is almost impossible.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And we see that, you know, young people and families have multiple barriers to accessing mental health. There's long wait times for clinical care, there's inequities for under resourced communities and populations. And of course, as everyone has already talked about, the demand is outpacing the workforce.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    But like I said, we have a really unique perspective as the YMCA because we are serving families. We have infants to older young people, right. Transition age youth.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And this led us to think about mental health in a different way and to try something different and new in our community based on the fact that we have this really again unique perspective, this very unique geographic so sort of spread in the county as well.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And so we are evaluating a positive youth development based model embedding mental health promotion into everyday environments like our sports, our camps, our after school programs.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Again, like many of the panelists have already talked about, really thinking about how we can connect mental health into these touch points that help build wellness, but more specifically how we're helping to build stress tolerance in kids and how we're helping them develop those skills. They were described as protective factors.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    But to second Dr. Kane's comments and Dr. Reiter's comments and Dr. Beam's, keeping kids out of intensive treatment options is our goal. It's our goal to not have residential facilities. It's our goal to not have children.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Have to be in these very high intensity traumatic experiences and have families experience what happens in situations like what Dr. Kane described. And that does happen. We see that happen. It is. I also didn't know I'm a parent. I have the most spirited and wonderful nine year old who I'm extremely worried about.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    She's going to be okay and I've got to pay attention. And I feel so lucky to have the perspective that I have. But it also makes me just as worried as every single parent here in San Diego. County.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    The most recent community needs assessments out of our nonprofit hospitals have all settled again on the same same worry that parents have about their kids. And it's mental health and it's, it's, it's a really important and reasonable concern.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So thinking about how we can really continue from the state level and the local level, continue to think about how we scale investment in prevention oriented models alongside clinical care. So I believe.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Doctor Weiss from the office of the San Diego County Office of Education and a couple of our other colleagues on the panels before talking about these integrated approaches. So something that we've been working on at the Y is really how we Talk about it. And Christina will talk a little bit more about it as well.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Democratizing therapeutic and clinical care and putting it in the hands of the people who are closest to our kids, who our kids feel most comfortable with. Their coaches, their teachers, their after school counselors at the Y, the swimming coach that they have, the folks that they're spending the most time with and really helping to upskill those folks.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Not to necessarily provide clinical treatment, obviously, but to be with kids and families in a way that's truly building those protective factors and building those stress tolerance skills so that young people have the skills they need to navigate the world the way that it is. The world is hard. It's difficult, it's scary.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And when we have our ability to tolerate stress and recover is like the most important definition of positive mental health. It's not about being happy all the time. It's not about waking up in a good mood every single day. It's our ability to meet the natural obstacles that we are all going to face.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Unfortunately, some of us will face more difficult ones than others. But facing those obstacles, being able to navigate them and being able to recover, those are the skills we want to teach our kids.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    Those are the things we want our villages to be helping support our kids with, whether it's at school, whether it's in after school programs, whether it's in sports programs, wherever it is.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So if we can start to spread these more preventive practices in and alongside clinical programs and clinical services, we're going to be able to use those resources in such a highly effective way. I do want to also second a couple of the logistic issues that our colleagues before us on the panel presented.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    We're also developing a nature informed IOP and partial hospitalization program. We have invested almost $1.0 million in that particular development of that program from philanthropy, from other sources, getting that money to invest in that. And we're not there. We are not there.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So the challenges that have to be overcome to build capacity to even start to think about creating more services, they're astronomical. They're astronomical. What you have done, Amazing. It's amazing. When community based organizations or hospitals even are able to stand these things up. We take them for granted. We think that they're easy.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    We think it's easy to just get on a panel, an insurance panel, and start billing for your 30 minutes. It's not easy. Our friends at Radies are definitely like, no way. It is not an easy thing to do. It is very, very difficult. You need a PhD to read billing codes. This stuff is hard.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    It is very hard. And you're under reimbursed, you're undervalued for how difficult those things are. So I just want to second all of that. And it is a really difficult thing to do.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So if it's possible for us to invest in capacity building in those areas as well, that would frankly take some of the burden and the pressure off of some of our institutions, be it our school settings, our community based organizations, our hospitals even, to be able to have some breathing room, some space to figure out the logistics of this and get through the bureaucracy and the administrative burden to make some progress in those areas.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And then the again the increasing our ability to have naturally occurring supports for children in more organic ways. Kristina will talk further about that and what young people are asking for. Dr. Patel, you talked about meeting young people where they are in a way that works for them.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    That's what we need to do and we need to be able to have funding for that. Not our traditional and please don't get me wrong, evidence based practices are extremely important, but the ones that are on the clearinghouse are typically ones that were tested rigorously 2030 years ago with very specific populations.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    And we need to have some more flexibility in how we can use our funds to be able to have access to community defined interventions and also more innovative interventions that aren't just pilots that last for 18 months, though it takes, like I said, it takes probably 17 months to get through the papers and then you have the one month where you can provide the service and then the program's over.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    These are all very real things. They're very challenging and we've got to be able to get through some of those policy barriers to get us anywhere. And Christina will talk a little bit about what we've heard from young people, specifically about how they want us to show up in clinical settings.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Hello. Hi. Hi. I'm Kristina Halmai-Gillan. I am a licensed marriage and family therapist and serving in the role as Director of Service Innovation with YMCA here in San Diego. Everybody has really covered so much that is valid and true and urgent.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    I won't say much and I certainly won't steal from the young people that I know are going to speak. But I would like to really raise up that we need innovative practices. Young people are asking for innovative practices. In one line.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Youth want mental health access that feels relational, culturally relevant, activity based and embedded in safe places within their communities, not just in clinical offices. There is a time and place and need for that, but that is not for everybody.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    They identify as a generation and a generation who quite frankly, has experienced things that we have not all grown up with yet. We are still resorting to the things that we know that have worked in the past, particularly social media. There are strengths and deficits within social media. I also am a parent of teens.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    I'm not fighting against, I'm fighting with. But I have a real concern around the amount of young people who are resorting to AI for mental health support. We've heard the horror stories.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    So, you know, I won't go there, but I do think we need to really be talking about it and talking with them about it and getting ahead of it because it's dangerous to become reliant on that.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    We know that, you know, because there's so much screen time that there's less time outdoors and there's less time in person and they have lost access to community places. Right.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    I mean, frankly, there's a lot of adults who have perspectives and attitudes towards youth that are not friendly and when they congregate and they're in person, they get shushed away when those kinds of things are important and to have access to each other and to a park or to a parking lot even, or to a sports field or court or what have you.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Those are all really important things that we need to prioritize and put up front just as much as we do the clinics and the offices and the higher levels of care. Also, as everybody else has said and Krista was getting to, none of those things are reimbursable. Field trips are not reimbursable.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Week long, two week long IOP programs that are outdoors at a beach or in the mountains are not reimbursable. Currently.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    If we can figure out how to reimburse for those types of activities, I think we could really, you know, shine a light on what's possible and really, you know, kind of navigate what mental health, what mental well being and what mental health care looks like going forward. I'll be done now.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yeah, thank you for that. And our final panelist, Erin.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    Hi. I just wanted to make sure I was close enough to it. Hi, I'm Erin Langs and I am the founder of CARES Advocacy.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I am a certified mental health first aid instructor through the National Council on Mental Wellness of Washington D.C. my CARES advocacy organization also has mental health education curriculum that I developed after unfortunately in the spring, the National Council removed several groups out of my curriculum that I still currently teach on public school campuses.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    My experience since being on four different high school campuses here in San Diego in the past 14 months is my first school was Westview and I was actually introduced to the parent wellness group at Westview High School through Scott Keane and a couple other individuals here in this meeting.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And they were my first mental health first aid class. So mental health first aid. I will echo a lot of what you said because you've obviously had mental health first aid or you know about it. Mental health first aid on high school campuses is teen mental health first aid.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And what the teens are informed and taught is how to safely identify and support each other in challenges and even crisis. But what we do talk about are challenges don't always have to turn in to a crisis if we start paying attention early. The National Council only has this curriculum through 9 through 12th grade.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So 14 to 18 years old. They have not addressed, unfortunately, elementary or middle school. I think we need to focus on education much earlier around this. It not only is helpful for the students, but it is helpful for families. It's helpful for parents. I do have.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    There is a student who will be on the panel after us who was in one of my classes at Torrey Pines High. I also have another student. I believe he's coming for the next to watch the next panel and give feedback. He was in my class two weeks ago at Scripps Ranch High.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I've also taught at Canyon Crest Academy and I'm drawing a blank what my other Torrey, Westview, Canyon Crest and Scripps Ranch High. I've also trained at multiple nonprofits in San Diego, county, both for youth and adult students. If you walk away from this, the one thing I want you to remember me saying, students are craving this information.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I cannot tell you how many young women and young men come up to me after each class wanting to just talk. I have students personally asking to have an in person meeting or a FaceTime with me because they don't want to be on Zoom. They don't want to talk on the phone to me.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    They want to see my face and they want to be right here. So FaceTime on an iPhone is much better for them. They don't want to be online learning this. They don't want therapy online. I mean, I'm gonna. The feedback I keep getting.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I was at the behavioral health tech conference downtown two weeks ago for three days and there was a student panel there. And there were five students who kept talking about how terrible AI is for mental health support and how much they can't stand it. And they do want things in person.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So this education at the school level, at school, I just I can't stress it enough. We talk a lot about stigma and again I'm going to echo what has been said before these students. I have students, first day of class will talk about their own personal self harm to an entire class of students.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    They don't know all of them. At Scripps Ranch High School it was grades nine through 12 that were allowed to sign up for this class. They didn't all know each other and they are being vulnerable and sharing in a room because they feel safe.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And then we talk about how this young person evolved and got over it or maybe they're still struggling with it. So I just keep going back to this is a community concern. We have to circle around our families, we have to circle around these students and the earlier the better.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I am the mother to a 24 year old and a 21 year old, both boys. I've been to the emergency room with both my boys suicidal.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    My first time was with my son when he was in fifth grade and he told me how he was going to slit his throat because he was being tortured at school for being chubby. We didn't know he'd been in a fight. School never called us. I have lived experience with this.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So I know what it's like to walk into an emergency room. They put a security guard right on you. If nobody here has been to the hospital with a student, a security guard's with you the second you walk in and you say my son just told me how he's going to kill himself.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So we need this, we need this community support. It needs to be earlier. I'd like to speak to the 988 and the crisis response team that we are so lucky to have here in San Diego. I bring that up at every single school.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I train teachers on these campuses before I'm allowed to teach teen mental health first aid. And I will tell you most of the teachers aren't aware that there is this crisis response team. These students, before they walk out of my last class, they all are able to answer to me, what do you do?

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    What do you do in a crisis when you call 911? What do you say if they call 911? Each one says to me before they walk out of the room, I ask for mental health support with the response team because how beautiful is that?

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I've met two families who lost their sons to suicide because their sons were arrested and put in police cars. And they went and we're checked on a 5150 and they thought if this is what's going to happen to me when I'm having mental health crisis or challenge? I don't want to be here and they're not here.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So that response, I talk about that constantly. It should be in every single high school. On a poster. 988,911Ask for mental health support on a 911 call in San Diego. County. We're so fortunate to have it. So it's a privilege for me to be here. Thank you.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And it's a privilege for me to share what I am hearing. Boots on the ground from these students. They are craving this and every single student should be able to have this education. I've educated probably about 150 students in county because each school I go to the maximum that could sign up for the class.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    30 kids, 30 students. Because it was paid for through like foundation, Money Cares Advocacy. My organization. It's privately funded by me. I can't, I can't apply for federal grants because then they're going to tell me I have to exclude people out of my curriculum and I refuse to do that.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    My 24 year old is incredibly high functioning neurodiverse. Graduated from Vanderbilt University, works in wealth management in San Francisco. He is extremely neurodiverse. I'm well educated in this. My degree is from UC San Diego Ravel College and psychology, specializing in autism. I'm not a therapist.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I tell students I'm not a mandated reporter oftentimes, which is why they want to come to me and say, how do I talk to my mom about getting some help, those kinds of things. But the students are craving this and they should all have it. It's going to help all of us if we start early.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thanks. Thank you for your insightful comments. Once again, I think when we bring in our nonprofits, we can see what breaking down barriers and breaking down stigma looks like because that's what our nonprofits do. They come into the community, they work directly with our students, they build up capacity within our young people.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I definitely applaud your work and would love to find ways to make it more sustainable. The funding models definitely make it challenging on, off, up, down.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    It's very challenging to create robust programs that help build capacity when you don't know whether you're going to be reimbursed, how much you're going to be reimbursed for, whether that philanthropist will continue to give or not. So appreciate you coming here today. I'll open it up to my colleagues for questions. Laurie. Sorry, Assemblymember Davies, that's all right.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I only make my husband call me honorable so anyways, thank you so much. And again I think like myself, my brain is just going. There's so much that needs to be done. And when you started talking about, which I just thought that was so true is you know what?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    It's teachers, coaches, girls scout leaders, boys scout leaders, all of them. Where there's a trust there with our kids when they're with them, a lot of times they're with them a lot more than they are with the parent. How can I put something together?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Because when I dealt a lot with fentanyl in doing programs to educate the family and signs to look for. How can I go ahead and get someone like that if I do a big program and you know what, and we'll pay for it, I mean we'll figure that out.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    But how do I go and find someone like that where I can start having programs so that the kids parents can come. It should be part of an orientation. And I can tell you that was the hardest thing when I was dealing with fentanyl.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Why is this not being part of the orientation when I believe every parent has to be there? Is it 9th grade or one of those grades? But isn't there a grade where it is mandatory that a parent has to go through that first or not anymore? Okay, but I mean I think that yeah, that was 1970.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    But anyways, sorry it's getting later here, but it's almost wine time.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    I might be able to speak a teeny bit to that. So I think my concern has been when I show up to train.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So the National Council has a rule around all their classes which also makes it harder when I'm teaching for them because they have very strict policies about how long you can teach the class, what days and so forth.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And they also require that a certain percentage of staff are trained in this youth mental health first aid or the teen mental health first aid before you can teach the teens. My experience has been that at almost every single school the teachers are, they don't, they don't want to give up their time to do it.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    They one school the teachers not only were. Did they obviously have to have subs that the school paid for while they were doing, you know, whatever the six hour one day training with me. But they required to be paid extra in order to have this training.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So I think my suggestion would be if your going to implement a program, it's not optional, it's mandatory, it's not a choice. And this actually will help them support And I get it. Teachers are burned out. They are over it. Like asking them to do a six hour class on something and they're burned out. I get it.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    So I think it just. It has to be mandatory and not optional for everyone. And I feel like it needs to be. I hate saying mandatory for students. Every single student should have the opportunity for this education. The fact that only some students have had it.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    No, I agree with you. And that's where I wanted to start out with the parents and maybe have a few nights that they can make it. But that's where I'm trying to figure out who do I find then to actually do the training to the parents. Okay, I'll find you people. Okay, great.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    If I can do it, I'll find you people. That's not a problem.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Can I add? I have teens. As I said. Health Health class that's required in ninth grade is tied into pe. It's online. It's delivered online during pe. There are components. Nosy mom who wanted to know what they're talking about. Particular around mental health and modules with some outdated information. Don't use the kind of language that we want.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    Would prefer them to be using. Not strengths based. There's real opportunity there. Where there's already a captive audience. Right. To update and improve what information is being delivered. And I agree because we do have a SAMHSA funded youth mental health first aid. There are barriers to delivering it with fidelity the way that they want you to.

  • Kristina Halmai-Gillan

    Person

    There needs to be some freedom there.

  • Erin Langs

    Person

    And I'll speak. Yeah, the freedom part. The National Council and I've talked to them. The National Council knows this. I spoke with the medical Director of the National Council out of D.C. at that conference and yeah.

  • Krista Esquivel

    Person

    So I really appreciate this panel. Obviously as a mother hits home so.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I know it. That's why they gave me the box of tissues.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I'm actually glad you're crying so much because I'm usually the one constantly crying, and I think because you're upset--

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I usually don't cry--

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think we're all gonna cry.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    No, we're all gonna cry. I actually was going to ask you for the tissues. So, it's a very emotional issue. It's emotional.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We share tissues.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So this-- I will tell you what I think the tension is, and then we can talk about solutions within that tension. The tension is, what I heard you say is the people closest to the kids, the coaches, the teachers, the Girl Scout leaders, whatever group you want, the YMCA camp leaders, whatever, the tension is between, that's not their primary job, but they're the ones the people go to.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And you have this tension that we're asking-- do you know what we ask community colleges now to do? And we ask community colleges and schools to do all this stuff because they're the ones that have access to the kids and trust with the kids, and yet we ask them to do so much. We had an audit of the community colleges, a couple last year or the year before, I don't remember.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And so much-- and they were these extra mandates that the Legislature has continued to put on them because they are the best delivers, but it's not their primary goal. That's the problem with the teachers. That's the problem with all these things. And so, that's the tension that we have to mandate teachers take an extra class. Yes, they're the providers. That's not why people often went into teaching. And so that's the tension that we have, and I don't know how we resolve that tension.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    It's a-- you are bringing up one of the most important points that we see, and it's why we see a lot of the, like, segregation and the disconnectedness, right? Because, okay, in the school system, we're going to put the clinician inside the school, so then when the teacher sees that something's kind of wrong, they're going to send them to the clinician.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    What we're talking about is a more integrated approach that removes those very clear-- you know, Dr. Kane talked about it as well. It's this-- even if you're in the same space, there is a very clear differentiation between who the therapist is and who the teacher is and who the student is. And there's a hierarchy there, right?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    What we're talking about is really trying to dismantle a little bit of that, of that hierarchy, provide more opportunity for folks to understand how the thing they do that is their primary responsibility, their primary thing that they went to do, how they can do that in a way that can actually be healing.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Oh, I-- I agree with it.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And pay them more, also, just FYI. We're talking about paying people more as well.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    We have a structural budget deficit, yeah, so. My chief told me I'm not supposed to say that anymore, but we do. So that's-- you know--

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    But there's-- that's the-- that's what I see the tension is, is like, you're gonna go, and we've done that with community colleges, right? We said, you need to help with homelessness, because we know so many community college students are homeless. So we're going to saying, you have to have the homeless navigators, you have to have mental health navigators, you have to have healthcare navigators, you have to have these navigators.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We won't tell.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So much of their portion of their budget is now going to these additional requirements that they are best made to do, that they're now violating other state laws in how they apportion education funding. So that's attention that we have to probably talk to head-on. Even though I'm hearing from you that system is outdated and old, yet that's the system we work in, so there's an update to the higher education system that needs to happen.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And a lot of what you're asking for in flexibility and freedom providing services, I bet you if you go back and see why all those things went in there, it was to prevent fraud.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Yeah.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So when we think about solutions for integrating the outdoors-- I didn't know about the camps. Darshana was telling me about camps. I was like, are we going camping? Is that what they're talking about? We're going to go camping with the therapist? I'll go camping with the therapist. That's fine.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Therapy camp.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    You know, but for-- for that, how do you differentiate between true provision of services to kids who need it, or youth who need it, let's say youth, and the fraud that will happen? Because that's what we see. And I was just at a community coffee in Carlsbad this morning, and they were asking about EDD fraud. And that's what we are held accountable to, this fraud.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So it's-- when we talk about being flexible, we have to remember in the back of our mind, we are the good actors here, and there are people out there who just want to extract money. So how do you differentiate that in the two things?

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    But I appreciate it, and I appreciate, like, saying that kids, or youth, want it online or don't want it online is true. I've sat-- I've chaired Communications and Conveyance, and I used to chair Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism because, back when I was married, they wanted to give me a title that was longer than my actual name.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And so I had a joint oversight hearing on social media and children and youth, and it's horrific what it does. And so, I'm not sure it's just AI, but the algorithms in social media are not built for malleable brains that are still developing and can't distinguish what is valuable recommendations and not valuable recommendations.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So-- and Laurie, or Assembly Member Davies, there was no-- I had no mandatory parent orientation that I have attended. I don't know. I know, Kristin, did we have to do one at Paul Ecke? We didn't have to do one at Paul Ecke, did we?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    High school sports. If your child plays sports, there's a mandatory meeting.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Oh, and if you place a-- use-- if your kid plays high school sports, there's a mandatory meeting. Mine did ISP, and they had to do the online health thing in the summer, and-- which is not helpful. It's not. We should update the health curriculum. Every time we gotta update the health curriculum, though, it's like a huge fight. You'd think we were fighting over something more than just healthy children, but it becomes--

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    You know the principal probably just lied to my parents and told them it was mandated, so--

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Yeah. There you go.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    They're like, you deal with that, girl.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Yeah, but I don't-- I mean, we do webinars as Assembly Members. I've done them on menopause, we do them on mental health. I think there's a way we could do that individually. We get really good responses with that. That's-- but that's not a systemic way.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So one of the things maybe we can think about coming out of this is how do we have a more systemic way to talk to parents? Because I probably suspect we don't think mental health is an issue until it's an issue, and then we don't know what to do. That's what I assume most parents go through.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Like, I want-- if there was a mandatory thing, I'd probably-- my son was in 9th grade. I probably was like, whatever. I don't need-- it wasn't mandatory. But like, if there was a mental health webinar, I was like, I don't have time for that. I'm at an event. Whatever. Except maybe five years later, I need it.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And so having access to information when you need it is probably more critical than having something, because who said-- who had the IKEA example? That was you. IKEA example. Like when I get it, if you don't have a context for needing it, we don't absorb and retain information because we get so much information.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And so, anyways, that's a long thought about all those things. But there's that tension between what we mandate and what they're qualified to do, and how do we change the system knowing that tension exists? And then when we look at funding mechanisms, how do we prevent fraud and allow that freedom?

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And then how do we provide services to parents so it's on demand when we need it, and people-- and find the right channel? Because when you're in crisis, you go-- I mean, I was in the Legislature when we passed 988. Were you already there, Laurie?

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Yeah. When we passed 988, it was a huge fight to get 988 because it didn't come with enough funding. And the only funding would have been through a tax, and it would have been an unfair distribution tax. So that's why you don't have the support.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So unless we're willing to raise taxes for this, which most people aren't willing to raise taxes, that's your problem with more flexible mental health funding behind 988.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    No, you raised some interesting points, and I think I agree that our public education system is strained on so many different levels, and if we do a better job embedding resiliency and creating that framework of challenges don't have to turn into crisis, I think I'm going to use that over and over again, if we have the skills, the mental health first aid, we're able to do that, then we can build in that competency for our young people, and frankly, for our adults.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I think being the mother of three daughters who just, you know, two are still teens and one is now a young adult, definitely they teach me a lot of things. They teach me how to use language appropriately. They have taught me about generational trauma, for example.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    So when they are learning these things, parents can become better parents as well, and I think parents need to do that listening when their kids are speaking to them. But coaching parents around that is also important, and I think PTA is one place where parents can go for training. The on-demand component is very key.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    You definitely don't think you need it until you need it. And having webinars, though, the beauty of it is most of them-- many of them are recorded now and they're archived.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And you know, a parent, when they are facing that moment, they can go back to those trainings, those parent classes that were there, that a PTA or a nonprofit offered at a school site, or like, you know, what we're doing. And I think parents could also access what the students are teaching each other through peer counseling.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I think that is also good information for parents to access, or caregivers to access. If you could do one thing, and again, I'm making it distilled to one thing to each of our panelists, to help integrate this kind of education for our young people in a better way, what system level change, state level, system level change would you recommend us to consider or think about?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Realizing, of course, that there are appropriations issues, bills get killed in Appropriations all the time because they're too expensive, or someone-- it conflicts with somebody else's perspective on how care should be delivered. So understanding that there are challenges, if you had a wand, what would you ask us to do?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Well, first of all, you know, we're firm believers of our program, but aside from that, I don't know if you have heard of a gentleman who wrote the book, The Lost Generation, but it's all about technology and what it's doing to our kids, and he is making a difference. He is actually-- I am a firm believer that we need to train our students, right?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We can't just say, you know, no phones. You know, that's-- it's our life, right? I mean, we need to integrate it in a healthy way. But there are schools who are banning cell phones now. And I just so respect that, that they're willing to do that. And so, if there's any way that can be a first step, that would be amazing.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    We all voted for this. Are we?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Yes, I think it might be 2026-- 20-- I'll find--27.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    So it was passed, I think, last year. Not-- it was before my time. I remember learning about that as a school board trustee, that we would have to begin implementation, and many school districts across the state have started early implementation. It's always an option to start implementing early. You don't have to wait for the deadline.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    So that is happening, and we are hoping to see impactful change. And that remains to be seen. There were concerns, at least in our board-- there were concerns that there are some-- July 1, 2026-- that some students have their IEP accommodations, or 504 accommodations, attached to their personal devices, and so that might immediately reveal which children have accommodations.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And so, we had raised some of those concerns. I was reassured that teachers know how to handle that and they will handle it. So-- but that is coming very soon. And if there are no further questions on this, we can move on to our final panel.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Can I ask for one thing?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yeah. Oh, sorry. Sorry. We are going--

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    One sentence, 10 words.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    --we are going through the one thing, the wand.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    The magic wand, it would actually be to listen to young people. Let's listen to them and then fund what they say works.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And maybe reimburse what they say works.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    That's what I mean. Reimburse. Fund.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So, you and I met at the delegate, the school board delegate meeting, and your first question, we were talking about the law that Governor Newsom signed in, that mental health curriculum was supposed to be implemented January 1st of 2024. And here we are. I'd like to see accountability for things that we are signing happening. I would love to see that. Yeah.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I look forward to being able to look into that.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Okay.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you. We will now have our student panelists come up.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I've got the-- here on the phone, you could ask him right now.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Where's that coming? I forgot which one it--

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We are waiting on one panelist. He may be en route, so we'll give it a minute, and maybe by that time, Assembly Member Boerner will come out too.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    To honor our students time, we will go ahead and get started. Make sure we do that. Welcome, students. This is what we've all been waiting for, I have to say. So we will go in order of how you're listed on the agenda. Izzy, would you like to go first?

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Yeah. Okay. My name is Izzy. I'm in eighth grade. I'm from San Elijo Middle School. I. I would say I kind of have. I have a lot of experience with mental health, from my own personal experiences to my peers. I'm on a special group at my school who specializes in educating ourselves in mental health and educating others.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    We're there to be support, not to be therapists, but to be kind of a step to getting further help. So I. I try to ensure that I know a lot about mental health. And, you know, I have friends who ask me for help sometimes, and I always want to make sure that I'm educated.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    So I think it's really crucial, especially to me, that my peers are getting what they need because, like, it's a really large part of our lives. So.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Hi, everybody. Sorry, can you hear me? Yeah. I'm Nathan Brisimena. I'm the student board representative over at the Escondido Union district. So as a student board Member, I speak with a lot of different people throughout the district, specifically students and my peers. And mental health is definitely one of the most pressing issues.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And I want to open this up to kind of like my own personal experiences of mental health resources that I've seen personally throughout my district, because that's always fun, right? So Escondido High, we have a wellness center, and that's also at Orange Glen High School as well. So those are two resources where we can go to.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    It's like a physical location on our campus, a building specifically dedicated for students to go in and take some time, relax. There are therapists there and psychologists there. We also don't have any issues so far with our 504 plans.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Like the things that we've been providing for people with, for example, ADHD, for our testings, for AP exams, for SATs, ACTs. We haven't been really having any issues with that. We also do have emotional support dogs coming in every now and then and emotional support ponies.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    I'm really excited to see, like the whole emotional support zoo coming soon. So exciting. And then we also do. And I want to refer back to Dr. Lang or Ms. Ling speaking about the 988. We actually do have a lot of suicide hotline stickers and almost magnets.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Around our entire campus, we do often promote that and the suicide hotline, you know, and I think that is really important. Some improvements I personally do want to see is incentivizing more therapists, because, as you know, California does have this really big issue with mental health staff shortage.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And so getting to see more of these professionals on our school campuses would definitely help us as high schoolers and definitely promote the idea of reaching out for help. Personally, my sister, I want to say, last year was diagnosed with adhd.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And up until then, I didn't even know that that was a possibility of me, like myself, having that. And so this month I'm actually getting screened for that as well. And so at school, you never really hear much about these sort of things, you know.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And I think the biggest issue right now is that even though we have the resources, we don't really have the promotion per se of going out and seeing, zero, we have this and we have this, we have so and so here to help guide and support you.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    I think having students know that there are people there and that there are resources there for them to help them is definitely one of the most important parts of having these resources to begin with. And especially increasing funding for youth programs like sports and arts, youth communities, after school communities.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Because if you're in a community, it's less likely for you to have these anxieties and depressions. And I think it's so important to build a community in General because if you have people you can relate to, then that definitely does decrease any probability of, you know, having these sort of mental issues to begin with.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And I know this was brought up as an issue before, but in an ideal world, staff would be trained at schools to recognize things such as, like Executive dysfunctions, for example. Like I said before, I didn't even know that it was a possibility for me to have adhd.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    I didn't really know much about it up until I searched up some of, like, the parallel symptoms that I have myself. And I didn't know it was a possibility until I had to go out and research that.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    So I definitely think informing students and giving them resources for that information would definitely help them, because, you know, as a student that didn't know that there was any sort of possibility for me to have that to begin with, if I had been in a classroom and someone were to tell me these symptoms or, you know, basically explain a lot of different mental illnesses on sort of that spectrum, I would have been able to catch it on earlier.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And building more wellness centers, for sure. My wellness center at my school is one of the most valuable resources that we have. A lot of people go there often and it is something that is widely promoted at my school. So building that around the entire State of California would help tremendously.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And also just having more information about digital wellness. We live in a time where social media is overtaking our entire generation. Right.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    You know, so you open your phone and you open your app and then you get a lot of these things where it's like, oh, I lost a certain amount of weight, I just got accepted into Stanford, I got accepted into Dartmouth.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    You know, there are a lot of things on social media that we see as teenagers that we begin to compare ourselves to and that causes issues within ourselves.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And I think it's so important that the government and that our schools take action specifically for, for media well being and using these apps responsibly and making sure that these students know that a lot of standards that they see online and in the media aren't realistic and that they should be content with where they are now and just to provide more resources on how they can achieve these things in a healthy way and not in a way that would detriment them.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    Hi everyone. Sorry, I'm Emma Beckwith. I'm 17 years old and I'm a junior at Torrey Pines High School from the San Dieguito School District. I'm super passionate about team mental health support, education and awareness. And I firmly believe that mental health and well being of our youth should be the topmost priority of our community and schools especially.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    So that's why I'm like the secretary of my school's Peer assistant Listeners or PALS program, where a group of student leaders who are dedicated to spreading awareness and destigmatizing mental health on campus through peer support, while also facilitating a lot of student connection. Because like Nathan said, isolationism is what exacerbates mental health conditions.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And everyone needs a strong support system, especially high school. It's a very scary time. So everyone needs that support. A lot of events that we do include our annual suicide prevention walk. We have a NEATO walk, which is like an eating disorder awareness walk.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    We have Stress Lust Week and Red Ribbon Week events and we organize many other types of events to promote student wellness and connection, spreading vital information to students about these topics, which includes like the 988 lifeline. We also have a lot of therapy dogs that come on campus and that's always really nice and fun to see.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And I really love this program because I can truly see the impact we make on bettering our school community, whether that be helping a transfer student adjust and feel supported in their new school or going to middle school, is giving presentations about tips for high school.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And today I want to especially emphasize the importance of mental health education in schools from a team perspective. So last spring, because I was in this PALS program, I was lucky enough to be able to take a team mental health first aid course along with my other fellow pals.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And Aaron Langs, who was on the panel earlier, was actually my instructor and that's how I met her. And this was definitely one of the most impactful experiences of my high school education as teens.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    Like Izzy said, it isn't our job to diagnose, but rather to connect those students who are facing challenges and crisis to the help that they need from a trusted adult and a professional. And that's really hard to do if you're not trained on how to do this, especially if it's unpressured situation.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    So this course, through a very memorable five step action plan, really helped me learn how to do this, how to support your friends in the most supportive way, look for warning signs and address misinformation.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And it gave me first hand experience with this course to let me say that now I feel much more prepared and confident in handling situations like this.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And it's made me a much better pal and even in myself, like Nathan was saying, it gives me the opportunity to allow me to see these signs, these warning signs of myself that I would not have known if I hadn't taken this course.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    So I also know as a teen that we do a really good job of hiding our struggles from parents and adults. And even with our peer PALS program, it's hard to go to talk to a peer that you might see in your next class about these really hard issues.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    It's hard to trust someone you don't know and they're not bound by like a confidentiality contract or anything. So I think the people we trust the most as teens is our friends. And that's why it's vital that every single student takes this teen mental health first aid course.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    Because every single student needs to know how to help another teen or themselves get connected to a trusted adult. So I was very lucky that in my pals class, all 30 of our students were able to take this course. But we need to have it be every student because these skills are life saving.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    I remember Dr. Kane brought this up earlier, but we all learn like CPR in middle school because that's a life saving skill that everyone needs to know. But why should mental health be any different than that?

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    An example of this is like the recovery position, which is the position you put someone in when they're in a substance use crisis and is unconscious. This is something that everyone needs to know how to do.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    We were able to practice it on each other, know how to do it properly, and we do that with cpr, so we should be able to do that with mental health as well. And I know we also brought up the health curriculum that we have to take to be able to graduate in my school district at least.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And not only was this mental health information outdated, it's also just very not memorable to learn it freshman year and never to really interact with it again. And it was also taught online completely through a platform called Engenuity, which was just a lot of videos that you just press over and over again. It was super unengaging.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    The majority of people didn't learn anything. They just would press through the videos. So what made teen mental first aid training really impactful was having Erin as our instructor in person. Because we could ask her questions, she would start meaningful conversations, we'd go around the class.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    We were all super vulnerable because she built up this safe space for us to really share, which made it super powerful and influential. And by sharing her own anecdotes as well, it really made this conversation come to life. So to have these necessary conversations, we need a humanness in these spaces that no digital source can provide solely.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    Additionally, the exit tickets that she gave at the end of the session was really important because it gave you the opportunity to ask questions anonymously, which she would address for the whole class because it is important information for everyone to know.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    But you didn't have to go through that obstacle if you're nervous about sharing your own story without having you yourself share it. So, yeah, I definitely think that having these conversations from real, in person professionals and instructors is really important.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And I definitely understand, we did talk about this as well, that it's really hard to get this training for every single student.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    But just starting by even just making it more accessible to people beyond the PALS class and beyond these student leaders, for everyone to be able to have the chance to participate in this and then eventually having it maybe be in gym classes, just like how we're taught cpr, we can have instructors come in for maybe a few days just to teach this curriculum, which would make a huge difference.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And I know we talked a lot about stigma on this panel and how we can decrease that in high schools. And if every Single student has this mental training. You're opening that conversation that would really destigmatize these topics because everyone's talking about it. And this is especially for men.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    I think in high school, especially men's mental health, there's a lot of stigma surrounding that. In our pals classroom, there's five guys compared to 30 girls. And that's more than last year. So that's a pretty crazy statistic. So we need to talk about mental health with every single teen.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And the more conversations we have, the less stigmatized it will be, the more teens we connect to help, which is ultimately what we want to do at the end of the day. And fostering that connection is invaluable to our community. So thank you guys so much for your time.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    I really appreciated this opportunity and I hope that we can make teen mental health first aid training for all students a reality. So thank you so much.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I want to thank all three of you students for coming here today, taking time out of your busy schedules to come speak with us. If you are open to it. We probably have some questions for you. I know I do. I will turn it over to my. Colleagues if you want to.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    All right, well, I have a list.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I didn't say I didn't have questions. I said you can start this then.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We talk a lot about as adults, we talk a lot about social media and the negative impacts of social media on our young people. We also, once in a while will highlight that young people also find community on social media. Right. They find their safe spaces also that that is also a realistic possibility.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    What do you think is the best approach for cell phone use on campus? I know there's a law now you're not going to have a choice pretty soon, but is there?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    How do we help young as adults, as policymakers, how do we help young people strike that right balance without sounding patronizing and immediately, you know, putting you in a position of shutting down.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    I do totally agree with you. I do think that social media can be a double edged sword. Even though we can find communities on there, it still is a detriment to a lot of people.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And I think something that the government could do is just promoting and enforcing this idea that if you are going to use cell phones, that you use them wisely and that you know what you're getting yourself in into.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    I definitely do think that we kind of graze over this topic of digital media and social media because, you know, it's a newer generation kind of thing and it's not something that we've really seen before. Usually when people think of mental health, they think of people that surround them and not the things that are.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    That they're consuming on their own. You get what I mean? Things that inspire them, whether that be for good or bad.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    That's definitely something that the government can do by, you know, kind of mandating schools to promote this kind of almost lesson on using your phones wisely and using social media wisely and just being aware of, you know, the crazy standards set, you know, especially with college applications and everything. You know, lot of things going on right now.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    It's really important to know that who you are as a person is enough. And I think, you know, again, mandating schools to tell their students that and to just enforce that and maybe have student ambassadors across California would really help.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I really agree with him. At my school, they have already banned phones completely. It was a slow start. First it was not during school, like during classes. And then it was. They fully banned it even during lunch.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And although I kind of hate to admit it, it was really helpful for my school, I think, you know, before they banned it, I would be at lunch and I would see kids just sitting at their lunch tables, not talking to each other at all.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And as someone who got her phone, I would say a little bit later than others. My first phone was a Nokia, and I got it in fifth grade, so that's later than a lot of people, which I didn't even know.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think that those few students who didn't have phones at those tables were just left out of the picture. They were kids who were, oh, look at this on my phone. Look at that on my phone.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And it's just since this is so fundamental in our culture, almost especially in school, it's like if you are left out of it, you're just left out of the loop completely. And I think that's not how it should be. Now I'm seeing a really large decrease in kids who are even using social media.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    At least in my classes, people would raise their hands on who uses TikTok, and it's five people in my class who are on it. And I think that's really important. It's because I was seeing kids recording other kids at my school and posting them online without them even knowing.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And people think this stuff is okay, it's just a private account, or no one even sees this. But if those kids go online and they see themselves on there, seeing the comments made about them, it's just so detrimental to their mental health.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think that even if social Media isn't the thing that's making them, that's causing mental issues. It's just like kids spending all their time on their phones. You know, going outside and seeing sunlight and touching grass is so important for kids. And reading books too.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I'm seeing kids who haven't read books since they were made to and I'm like, that's, that's a great hobby for you to have. But I think that social media is too, it's too fundamental in kids my age's life. It's. They should know that it's an option to step away. It's good for you to step away.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    There's other things that you can do that will be more helpful for you. You can do skills without needing your phone. You can draw without needing a reference. You can just take time away from your phone. The world won't explode. You can just be yourself. And especially he was talking about college applications at my age.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Even at my age, I was feeling so much pressure to be in a million programs start so early just so I can get ahead and just taking a few seconds to realize these are just a few people who are getting into these schools.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I can still succeed even if I just take a break and not have to join every single program. I can take time for myself and just breathe and have my own time and it'll be okay and I'll still be successful. That's what I was thinking.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    When you solved my problems.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    Yeah, I definitely agree with what my fellow panelists have said. It's definitely like a double edged sword. There are definitely good things about social media, like the connection factor of it, because it is a really nice way to find community, especially if that's something that's hard to do in person sometimes.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    What my school does is all my teachers, we have like a phone caddy and then you put your phones in there. But during breaks and lunch, everyone stalls their phones. And I don't think it's too bad. Like most of the time I do see people off their phones.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    But I do agree that we already spend so much of our lives on social media as it is. Like all our schoolwork is pretty much on Chromebooks as it is.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    So I think it is good to limit the breaks that we do have to also just be completely off our phones because it is the few times we have to be interactive with other humans and be social. So I think that's definitely very important. But I do also think you can't ban it completely.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    That's not very realistic because it is such an important part of our lives. It's so fundamental. And there are a lot of good parts of social media, like there are a lot of. One of my favorite creators is called Spencer Barbosa. I'm not sure if you guys have seen it before. Yeah.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    But I love her because she does a lot about showing what's real and fake on social media. A lot of body positivity content. So I think just explaining when you implement these bans, like the purpose of it and why it's so essential, I think that will help people really understand the reasoning behind it.

  • Emma Beckwith

    Person

    And not just that they're having their phone taken away.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I think many schools do try to explain these things, but we're finding that the students aren't receptive to the way it's being communicated.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I think having the peer counseling groups, the student bodies, actives, youth on campus, be able to communicate with their school leaders on what is the best way to communicate to them for them would be a better approach.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And I would love to see some of that work happen because I know through my own personal experience, when I was President of the San Diego County School Boards Association, we would meet with all the school board trustees in the region and we would say, yes, we are. We partner with Common Sense Media.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We partner with this group, with that group. We're trying to teach them. They're not receiving it. And so I think part of the problem is we're not communicating in a way that you are able to receive it. And that is progress. That is work we need to put in as a priority.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I think that students also, even though some kids are still sneaking away their phones and using them, knowing that it's an option, that you don't have to be on your phone because the community is. Everyone's using it. It's normal. Everyone's using it at lunch.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    zero, you're going out and going on the field and doing a sport during lunch. What are you even doing? But the band at my school just said it's an option for you to do things other than be on your phone. You can just talk and you can just. Just like be there with other people.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think that kids don't even see that as an option. Getting home and getting immediately on your phone is like, that's just what I do every day. But knowing that there's an option to go outside, go on a walk. There's so many different options. Just understanding that you have opportunities that are right in front of you.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think if kids understand that it should be normal for them to do things other than just being on their phone is really important for kids mental health, because spending all day on a screen and just constantly being on social media, as my mom says, she says it's really, really unhealthy for you.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I believe in that. So that's just my part. Thank you.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Well, I want to thank you. I was not as eloquent as any of you are at 17, I guarantee you that. And there wasn't social media. I think I was one of the first email users in 1991 at Berkeley. So, yeah, I was ahead of the curve then, behind the curve now.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    One of the things that we have discovered through our informational hearings on social media has to do with the fact that the algorithms are not set up for minors. And so I'm not sure. I don't think I tell my kids, I never made any good decisions till I was like 27 years old.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Like, I didn't go to MIT because the boys weren't cute. That's why I went to Cal. I mean, like, I made no good decisions till I was 27. So I'm not sure this is, like, really applicable.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    But how do we communicate to youth that those algorithms aren't set up for you, they're set up for addiction, because that's what they're set up for. And so even though you might have some content creators that you like, that's not what the algorithm behind it is set up for.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    It's set up for ads, it's set up for profit, it's set up for these other things. And we've had several bills, and my staff will probably text me what happened with them. But we've tried several times to limit social media use hours, hold those companies accountable for the algorithms for the under 18s for minors.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Because what Dr. Patel is talking about is we want to balance creating community with understanding that these algorithms aren't meant for minors. I personally ban my kids from using social media, so I hope I didn't inadvertently create mental health issues through that. But I've seen the algorithms.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I had to get off TikTok myself because the algorithm works too well with my brain. And so that's the struggle, I think we find. And it would be interesting to hear your perspective, because when I hear you speak again so eloquently, like, zero, yeah, there are other things to do. Like, we only had other things to do.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And there were still bullies, people were still mean. High school, middle school's awful. High school's a little better sometimes. Not that great. People have different experiences. That part doesn't change. What I've noticed some schools do well is some schools have anti bullying programs that are really effective for mental health.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    I know EUSD School District has a really effective anti bullying program that my daughter went through. My son is four years ahead of her in school, five years ahead of her in school, and he didn't get it, but she did.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And I see the difference in how my daughter's group and cohort interact with each other for the kids that came from that elementary school district. But what would you say? How do we balance this? Because I just don't think youth really understand that these algorithms aren't meant for them. They're meant to purchase ads.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    They're meant to have a certain market purpose under the guise of connection by.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Speaking through other youth. And I say this in a very respectful way. There's only so. Sorry, no, there's only so much that the government can do about these sort of issues. You're talking a lot about these new norms or. No, these are honestly norms that have been happening forever.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    You know, when you try to connect with teenagers and the youth on these sort of topics, you will automatically approach them in a way where they feel threatened and they feel like you're coming to them with some sort of authority. And that's not what we're trying to reach here.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And of course you guys are talking to them in their best interest, but that's not always what it's perceived as. And I believe utilizing the youth themselves and having these ambassadors and speaking to other youth and their peers makes it so much more meaningful.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Because if I was approached by a Legislature versus my own friend, I would just kind of side more with my friend because who is this? You know. You know, but I think, Sorry. But. Just, but just generally speaking, I do think that the youth tends to side more with their own sort of age range.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And even though I totally agree with everything that you're saying, especially about the algorithm, because it's such a detrimental thing, it's not meant to benefit anyone. It's meant to keep them in, pull them in, keep them in there, you know, and that's all for, you know, that's, you know, that's a lot of like capitalism stuff there.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    They're just trying to make you buy things.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    But, you know, informing people about that through the youth would help you so much in a way where, for example, if I were to be educated on this through someone that I knew or someone that I knew was my age, it would be a little more meaningful to me because that's someone that's grown up in the same generation as me, that has had the same resources of technology as me.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And, and I want to put out there that this isn't something that we can change. Technology is growing exponentially. It's developing every day. And we especially see this in AI, which is its own detriment to talk about for another day.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    But just generally speaking, because it's not something that we can control, it's something that we should work towards progressing and working with instead. And definitely again, using the youth to inform other youth about these sort of issues.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    And, you know, implementing this in classrooms, you know, posters, little lessons, making programs for the youth for these sort of things and just really promoting that idea of having us talk to each other about it rather than, you know, higher up people talk about it to us, to us rather than with us.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I agree completely. I think that seeing someone who is generations before you talk about something that is so current is going to speak a little bit differently.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I know, at least for me, that it would be much more helpful for someone in my generation or in Gen Z to be talking to me about those kinds of topics because they're experiencing the same way that I am.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    People who are older are seeing different types of media, are seeing, their brains are responding differently to that type of media. They also aren't in the same culture that is cultivating this mindset of social media is normal. Addiction is normal. These algorithms are cultivating addiction in these young children.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And I think that for them to know like this, this is an addiction. This is not just a fun little habit, this is a true addiction.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And comparing that to other addictions and seeing how far down that can go is like, it's just so important because they aren't, we aren't realizing that this is not okay, this is not normal. And this is going to affect us very badly. This is going to harm us.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    And just knowing that it can be solved and it can be, your screen time can be lowered, you can get past it. It's not a permanent, it doesn't have to be a permanent part of your life. It doesn't have to be wake up and get on your phone. It can be wake up and then at noon.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    I haven't even been on my phone, I haven't even realized. And then you get. And then you maybe check your phone like twice. And I think that just knowing that it doesn't have to be such a large part of your day,

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I do think there's a component in that that schools are also responsible for. We put a lot of information out. I know school clubs use social media, and I didn't allow my children to have a phone till they had crossed a certain age and social media until they were a few years after that.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We had a trust system we needed to establish. And so that automatically excluded them from those Instagram posts about Crazy Sock Day or Funny Hat Day or whatever was going on on campus because they didn't participate. They weren't on social media until they were in high school.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And so I think there is a component that's within the school system that will now have to be resolved with this new law that's coming in place. So I do appreciate you bringing that up. And I think we'll have to rely on our youth clubs and teams and organizations on campus to help do that.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    PR campaign for Gen X. For those of you who are Gen X, you may remember, this is your brain. This is your brain on drugs. Zero, yeah. The fried egg in the frying pan. Do you guys know what we're talking about? Yeah. It'S on YouTube. I do like the idea of a public service campaign that.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    That might help spread some of that awareness and social media companies pay for it.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And yes, part of restitution. Yes, please go ahead.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So, so Nicole Sydney, who's my alleged aide up in Sacramento, is watching us right now, and she said, one, you guys are all super smart. She was very impressed with you. And two, she. I said my staff would get back to me.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So Sarah and Nicole got back to me and Bauer KN AB56 was passed and signed this year. And this is social media warning labels.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    So the Bill would enact social media warning law to require a social media platform to display a certain black box warning to a user each day when the user initially accesses the social media platform and again after three hours and thereafter at least once per hour of cumulative active use as prescribed in the Bill, not prescribed by a medical Doctor.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    And then in 24, we had SB976 from Skinner. Apparently it's facing legal challenges, but it prohibits an online platform from knowingly providing an addictive fee to a minor without parental consent. So one of the things that we have in Sacramento is how do you determine that somebody's a minor?

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Because usually you just go onto a platform when you sign up and you just say what your age is. So some kids are honest and some kids aren't. So there's like, there could be disruption.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    But I really like what you have said in terms of having youth advocates communicating this message in a PSA versus us, knowing what it does to your brain, especially evolving brains and developing brains. And this is your brain on drugs. So this has all been super helpful. And you're all super smart and you're all super articulate.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I truly just echo what the Assembly women were saying. So impressive. And I still haven't gotten to your level yet. And I'm a baby Boomer, so. Yeah. Sure, yeah, yeah, that's right. Put your glasses on. But I mean, really, really intriguing.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And I think that one thing I've been trying to teach myself is, especially when I look at Zen zers, gen zers is, you know what? We don't give you enough credit. And it's something I've realized is I went through different things when I was your age, and we can't relate, honestly. And I think so.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    So many times I hear people saying, oh, you know what? They're just not. They don't want to work. They don't want to go to school. They don't want to do this. And you know what? I apologize for that behavior because we aren't in your position. We didn't go through Covid at your age. You know what?

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Our parents were brought up differently than your parents were, and so there's nothing wrong with it. And I just want you to know that you are valued, you are heard. It's amazing what you're going to be able to do.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    And I just say thank you and know that your voice makes a huge difference and that I think it's so important for people in my generation to realize and be grateful because you've gone through and you're still going to be going through things that I never had to. And we're talking school shooters.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    I mean, all of these different things that, you know, it was an easy day as a child. So I just want to say thank you and I'm just so impressed. But do know that you are valued. You bring so much to the table. Your generation does.

  • Unidentified Speaker

    Person

    Thank you.

  • Nathan Brisimena

    Person

    Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    As with the other panelists, I probably have a hundred more questions I would want to ask you, including questions, thoughts around. If you're a peer counselor, do you worry about your peers taking on burdens and increasing their own challenges with dealing with their own mental health?

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    There's so many things I want to think about, but we are out of time. We need to wrap it up. I look forward to connecting with you in the future and tapping on you as we build new policies and explore ways that we can help our young people navigate this wild world that you're trying to navigate.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    One piece of advice for juniors out there, seniors who are now getting their applications in. It doesn't. It matters more what you do when you get there.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Yeah.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Wherever you end up, it matters what you do when you get there. And you will be fine for sure. And I will leave it with that. So thank you for your time. You were indeed very impressive. It's very clear that you have a good sense of self, and that's very important. So thank you for participating today.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    And as we wrap up this hearing, I want to see whether there are any public comments. Anyone wanting to put in a comment for the record, please step up to the mic, identify yourself, and you have two minutes.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    Hi, everybody. My name is Ali Vredenberg. Can you hear me okay? Yep. In 2020, I lost my best friend to suicide. And I have since dedicated my life to trying to end this mental health crisis.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    I am the founder of the Belonging Lab, which is an organization where we're trying to address the mental health crisis at its root. And so I thank you for organizing this. This is such an important conversation that we're having here today.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    And so what I'm seeing and hearing today is that there's a lot of amazing programs that a lot of you in this room have organized. And over and over again, the problem is about funding. Right. And so where are we finding these budgets?

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    And so what I can say is that there's also an elephant in this room that nobody mentioned. And that is something that I'm trying to do research on in my nonprofit. And one of the things that we found through preliminary numbers is that really the number one predictor of depression.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    And so I'm just talking about depression and not the other illnesses, but the number one predictor of depression that we found in this national study that we're doing is whether or not people can meet their basic needs.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    And then the second predictor that we found in the data is whether or not people feel like they belong in their community. So if we want long term stability, we need upstream, out of the box solutions. And that means prevention, belonging, and models that reduce the need for crisis care in the first, first place.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    And that's the work I do every day through my nonprofit. And I'd be happy to be a resource as you think about the sustainability of these programs. And also, I know Christina with the ymca.

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    I don't know if she's still here, but she was talking about our kids wanting these innovative solutions, and that is exactly what I'm trying to do. And I think the best thing that we can all do in this room, and I understand everyone in this room kind of has their own agenda, right?

  • Ali Vredenberg

    Person

    We all have the things we want to do with our organizations, but the best thing that we can do is uplift each other and put aside our agendas, because this is an issue that affects everybody, and we need to all partner together to make a difference. Thank you. All right. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Are there any other people that wanted to give public comment? Please step up to the mic.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    You can line up.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Yeah, you can-- you can line up if you want. Yeah.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    Hi everyone. Sorry if it's a quiet. My name is Annabelle Dorman. I'm a senior at Mission Hills High School, and me and my fellow peer counselor, Trinity, are here to represent San Marcos. And we're so grateful to have come to this Assembly today. We loved hearing everyone speak and all the amazing things that are happening.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    Last year, some of our other peer counselors were writing a grant so we could get a million dollars to fund a peer counseling program and also a wellness center at our school. We offer two courses this year, so we have Peer Counseling 1 and we have Peer Counseling 2.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    In Peer Counseling 1, you get to work, or you get to be in the classroom and you get to learn kind of that, like, mental health, first aid class that we were hearing about earlier and all of the skills needed to have active listening and to just provide peer support to students that are struggling.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    And then in Peer Counseling 2, which me and Trinity are in this year, we get to work in the Wellness Center where we offer a variety of resources to help people experiencing mental health crisis, regular stressors at school, or people that just need a place to self-regulate or a place if they need to talk to a peer counselor.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    We also have our boss/adult counselor, Ms. Charlie and Ms. Dahma who help us as well, and so if there's an issue that's too big that we can't quite handle, such as suicidal ideation, they can be there to help us and walk that student through the next steps.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    We also offer activities outside of the Wellness Center, whether it's during lunch or after-school events or before-school events. People can make cards, or just little-- we did a keychain making event with, like, little reminders during Thanksgiving Break of why they're enough, and why they matter, and that it's okay to have struggles and different ways they can show up for themselves with coping tools.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    We also have lots of 988 and other hotline awareness posters and cards and stickers and etcetera all around the school and in our Wellness Center as well. So, yeah. Having that hotline-- I really liked the idea of having the 911 poster with how you can get access to 988 and other mental health resources through that as well.

  • Annabelle Dorman

    Person

    So that's definitely something we will be working on, but we're really grateful to be here, we're so grateful for this grant, and we just have seen such a big impact we've made on students and how they truly do feel the most safe talking to their peers and, yeah. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Trevor Shuman

    Person

    Hello. My name is Trevor Shuman. I go to Scripps Ranch High School, and I was able to take the teen mental health first aid with Ms. Erin Langs last week, or three weeks we had the course, and I thought it was good because it taught me a different perspective in how people think and act.

  • Trevor Shuman

    Person

    I learned about situations with my peers through their anecdotal responses about what they've gone through and what their friends have gone through, and it taught me ways of thinking, experiences that I myself have never gone through, and it helped me to understand and to feel like I'm prepared to more better help the people in my school.

  • Trevor Shuman

    Person

    And I feel like, just like how my school requires language, it requires a performing arts and a health class to graduate, I think just a simple change to-- even if just a couple weeks of a mental health course or a couple days of mental health course, it would just help students to feel more connected and to feel more welcomed and informed on the struggles, the challenges, and just the normalities of growing up as a high schooler now. So thank you, guys.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    Hello. My name is Caitlin Hall. I wasn't expecting to come up here, but I was incredibly empowered by the youth who spoke today. In 2020, during Covid-19, I attempted suicide. It was a really difficult time with my mental health, and I struggled incredibly with depression. I'm sorry, I didn't mean to get emotional.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    From that, I learned I had incredibly important experiences. I know there's a lot of stigmatization with being in a mental hospital, but I was actually in a mental hospital during that time, and I met a variety of youth who I wouldn't have expected to have ever gotten the privilege of meeting until I entered that hospital.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    I think it's important to tell the story of one of the youths. I won't name names out of privacy for him, but he was a homeless youth. He was found on top of the building. Police officers were able to get a hold of him before he did anything bad.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    But I think it's important to tell his story because he wasn't able to continue care with me because he was on Medi-Cal, and I think it's stories like these that fuel the work that I do and I think that are important to consider. He wasn't able to continue treatment because of the insurance that he was on.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    In addition to that, I think it's also important to talk about how there isn't enough education from a young age about mental health. I know it was mentioned earlier that there is youth mental health training, and I think that's incredibly important to start at a young age, because from such a young age, we learn so much about ourselves, we contextualize the world around us, and that needs to begin from a very, very young age and it's not starting right now.

  • Caitlin Hall

    Person

    So if there's a way to anyway integrate that into the curriculums that we have in elementary schools right now, I think it's important to start young rather than to-- rather than having reactive care to what's going on, we need to have preventative care, and I think that starts at a young age. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Laurie Davies

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    Hello. My name is Diane. I work for CSU San Marcos in Community Relations and University Engagement, and I'm also a community advocate and a researcher. I do want to thank you, Dr. Patel, for allowing us to be here. And students, you are truly amazing.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    I do want to talk about how it's important also to talk about diversity, equity, and inclusivity in this realm because it is important not to aggregate different communities together and to know that we need assistance with different communities because everyone has different cultural upbringings, we have different traditional values.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    And community belongingness is very important to the community, and within these realms, within the research I've conducted, we see that a lot of these marginalized communities don't know they have access to health resources, especially mental health. Under 50% are aware that they have it, and so that's a huge discrepancy that we need to look into.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    And we also have to, like the first commenter said, we are in research, not getting the funding that we need. And so, where do we look at? Foundation. And who are we competing against? Everyone. Right? And so 20 people are competing for the same right, and just-- we're just looking for the same funding when we should be collaborating together.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    And that's something that we should look into as well, is that how can we help each other uplift our communities and bring mental health awareness? And also, you know, we need to definitely think about our workforce. We don't have the funding.

  • Diane Hoang

    Person

    Students that are looking towards these careers are now seeing that these aren't professional careers I want to get into anymore. There's not enough money that I can sustain my life. So there's so many issues within this, but I mean, again, love to collaborate with you all and we can definitely come together and seek a solution for this. And same with the youth. Come with us and tell us. Give you-- give us your ideas. It will be amazing what we can do together. Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Tasha Boerner

    Legislator

    Thank you.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    Well, this has been a very productive panel. I feel like we've gotten a lot out of it, I think not just for my Assembly colleagues here, but for those listening up in Sacramento. It's clear we have a lot of work to do, but it's also clear that there are resources if we put our minds to it.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We currently have put $4 billion towards youth mental health, so we know that there is money out there to put towards addressing some of the challenges. I think what we clearly heard today is that many of the barriers we're facing in delivering care that meets students where they are, our young people where they are, many of the barriers are around our communication and our coordination of efforts that are there.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    They're already there. We just need to coordinate and communicate a little bit better, and I think we can get there. Clearly, there are things we can do differently, and I look forward to exploring that more as chair of the Select Committee on Youth Mental Health and Treatment Access.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    I also want to briefly acknowledge that my own background as a school board trustee in Poway Unified, starting before Covid, going through Covid, and coming out of it, and seeing how mental health has become not just something that community is aware of, but something that young people want to be empowered by.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    When we say mental health, we often associate it with something bad or a problem or a challenge, but actually, we should be thinking of it as health and something that we have to maintain, and strengthen, and be very open and candid about. And I think we get to do that through work like this select committee is doing.

  • Darshana Patel

    Legislator

    We will have another select committee hearing in the spring. It will be up in Sacramento, and we hope to bring together some of our agencies up in Sacramento that are designing these programs to talk about what we could do to improve systems and structures that are helping deliver care. So thank you all for attending today. The video will be available on the website for future viewing, and look forward to you joining us for our next hearing in Sacramento. Thank you.

Currently Discussing

No Bills Identified