AB 2194: Video games: microtransactions.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-02-12
Existing law requires a video game retailer to post a sign providing information to consumers about a video game rating system or notifying consumers that a rating system is available to aid in the selection of a game.
This bill would require the manufacturer of a video game that is sold in California and includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction, as defined, within the video game to provide a clear disclosure that the video game includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction on the physical box the video game is sold in. The bill would make a video game manufacturer that violates this provision subject to a civil penalty of up to $1,000 per violation.
(a)The manufacturer of a video game that is sold in California and includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction within the video game shall provide a clear disclosure that the video game includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction on the physical box the video game is sold in.
(b)For purposes of this section, a microtransaction is the ability to use real-world currency, including, but not limited to, a credit card, to purchase an item or download or unlock content within the game.
(c)A video game manufacturer that violates this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of up to one thousand dollars ($1,000) per violation.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 17, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 1, 2018 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 13, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 12, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Consumers For Digital Fairness | ** Support | Apr 13, 2018 |
| Consumers Union | ** Support | Apr 13, 2018 |
| Entertainment Software Association | ** Against | Apr 13, 2018 |
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2194 (
Author:Quirk) – As Introduced Ver:February 12, 2018
SUBJECT: Video games: microtransactions
SUMMARY: This bill would require a manufacturer of a video game that is sold in California and includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction, as defined, within the video game to provide a clear disclosure that the video game includes the opportunity to engage in a microtransaction on the physical box the video game is sold in. Under this bill, a violation of this provision would be subject to a civil penalty of up to $1,000 per violation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires every video game retailer to post a sign providing information to consumers about a video game rating system or notifying consumers that a rating system is available to aid in the selection of a game. The sign must be posted within the retail establishment in a prominent area. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 20650(b).)
- Requires a video game retailer to make available to consumers, upon request, information that explains the video game rating system. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 20650(c).)
- Provides, for the above purposes, that the following terms have the following meanings:
- “Video game retailer” means a person who sells or rents video games to the public.
- “Video game” means an object or device that stores recorded data or instructions, receives data or instructions generated by a person who uses it, and, by processing the data or instructions, creates an interactive game capable of being played, viewed, or experienced on or through a computer, gaming system, console, or other technology. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 20650(a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to ensure that consumers receive disclosures regarding the inclusion of “microtransactions” in boxed video game purchases that they make, so they are aware that further purchases (beyond what is paid to purchase the boxed product off the shelf) may be necessary to download or unlock content within a game, prior to making the purchase. This bill is author-sponsored.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “Current law is silent on the issue of in-game purchases in video games, a practice which has become more popular in recent years. This is increasingly and recently becoming a problem as in-game purchases have taken on many new forms: expansions to the base content, additional costumes or items for games, randomized “loot crates”, and in some of the most egregious cases, locking content on the base disc behind paywalls. For example, it was estimated to cost players over $2,000 to unlock all the base content to a recent 2017 game. Moreover, with parents unaware of the existence of such systems, young gamers have inadvertently spent thousands of dollars on [so-called] microtransactions in games. [. . .] Microtransactions are[ ] small purchases that can be made in a video game (usually a dollar or two at a time). […] This has become an issue in the last few years for two primary reasons:
- A massive increase in microtransaction systems with little disclosure. [. . .] Furthermore, what used to be “extra” content is now becoming “required” content. That is, content that previously used to be part of the base game has now been hidden behind paywalls and microtransactions. In fact, some games feature “disc locked content”, content that is physically part of the video game’s disc data but that is locked behind a paywall.
- “Loot boxes”. In the last few years, games have introduced randomized reward systems, otherwise dubbed loot boxes. Instead of a direct transaction[ ] (I pay X dollars to receive Y), games now have randomized rewards in which gamers pay a fee to potentially receive an award, but are not guaranteed. Loot box systems have been criticized for their pseudo-gambling nature and their propensity to exploit those with addictive behaviors.
In light of the popularity of microtransactions, [it is] important that consumers are aware of what they can expect when they make a purchase, especially since the games industry has expressed an intent to double down on these systems and find new ways to monetize games that have already been purchased.
AB 2194 requires the manufacturer of a video game sold in California to post a disclosure on the physical box of a video game IF the game includes microtransactions. The bill would make a manufacturer that violates this provision subject to a civil penalty of up to $1,000 per violation. For purposes of this bill, a ‘microtransaction’ is defined as the ability to use real-world currency to purchase, download and/or unlock content within a video game.” [Emphases in original.]
- What is a microtransaction? Under this bill, a microtransaction is defined as the ability to use real-world currency, including, but not limited to, a credit card, to purchase an item or download or unlock content within the game.
The issue, while new in terms of legislation (not surprising given the very little amount of regulation in statute around video games and video game retailers), has been a significant issue and topic of debate within the video game industry among consumers.
Staff notes that it is not entirely clear whether cryptocurrency such as “bitcoin” would qualify under this definition as “real-world” currency (most articles online appear to indicate not it is not a global or stable currency this time) or whether it could one day qualify. This terminology could arguably be further refined, however.
- The Entertainment Software Rating Board: In 1994, the Entertainment Software Association (ESA; formerly, the Interactive Digital Software Association) created a self-regulatory body known as the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) to independently apply and enforce ratings, advertising guidelines, and online privacy principles adopted by the computer and video game industry. The ESRB ratings system is seemingly similar in its structure and operation to the ratings system developed by the well-known Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), which has now become a mainstay of the theater-going marketplace.
The ESRB ratings for many years had two parts: Rating symbols, such as “M” for mature, that suggest what age group the game is best for; and, content descriptors that indicate elements in a game that may have triggered a particular rating and/or may be of interest or concern (e.g., blood, blood and gore, use of alcohol, animated blood, strong language, crude humor, fantasy violence, intense violence, etc.). There are approximately 31 content descriptors in use by ESRB as well as six rating categories (“E” for everyone, “E 10+” for everyone age 10 and up, “T” for teen, “M” for mature, “AO” for adults only,” and “RP” for rating pending). Today, the ratings also have a third part: interactive elements, which highlight interactive or online features of a product, including users’ ability to interact with each other, the sharing of users’ location with other users, if purchases of digital goods or services are offered, and/or if unrestricted internet access is provided. Of relevance to this bill are “In-Game Purchases” which indicates in-game offers to purchase digital goods or premiums with real world currency, including but not limited to bonus levels, skins, surprise items (such as item packs, loot boxes, mystery awards), music, virtual coins and other forms of in-game currency, subscriptions, season passes and upgrades (e.g., to disable ads).
- ESRB enforcement: Staff notes that the ratings system of the ESRB is a voluntary system. With respect to enforcement, the ESRB website notes that “[w]hile the ESRB does not have the ability to enforce its ratings at the retail level, it does work closely with retailers to display information that explains to customers how the rating system works. Moreover, major retailers have established their own store policies requiring age verification for the sale or rental of M (Mature) and AO (Adults Only) rated games, and ESRB actively encourages and supports these efforts.” The ESRB also notes that virtually all major national retailers and countless independent retailers are working with the ESRB to educate their customers and employees about ESRB ratings and store policies regarding the sale or rental of M (Mature) and AO (Adults Only) rated games.
With respect to “Game Rating Enforcement” the ESRB website specifically states:
Just as ESRB’s rating processes are designed to deal most effectively with the differing environments through which video games and apps are made available to consumers, so too are the enforcement mechanisms used to ensure that consumers receive complete and reliable rating information and there are effective disincentives for developer noncompliance with ESRB requirements. For instance, with digitally delivered games and apps, the prompt correction of an inappropriate rating is technically feasible and serves as an effective enforcement mechanism. However, this and other remedies are less readily applied with respect to physical (e.g., boxed) video game products, where the ESRB enforcement system allows for the imposition of harsh sanctions (e.g., fines up to $1 million, product recall, the stickering of product throughout all retail outlets) for instances of significant or egregious content non-disclosure. Less serious violations of ESRB content disclosure guidelines can result in the assignment of points, fines, and mandated corrective actions.
With respect to advertising enforcement, the ESRB website states that:
Publishers of physical (e.g., boxed) video games carrying an ESRB rating are contractually bound to follow the industry-adopted Principles and Guidelines for Responsible Advertising Practices and comply with numerous requirements addressing how rating information must be displayed on game packaging and in advertising, what type of content can be presented and where ads for Teen-rated, Mature-rated and Adults Only-rated games may appear. ESRB’s Advertising Review Council (ARC) diligently monitors a variety of media, including TV, print and online, to ensure compliance with these requirements and is empowered to compel corrective actions and impose a wide range of sanctions, including monetary fines.
While digitally-distributed games and apps are not necessarily subject to the same set of requirements or enforcement measures, ESRB strongly encourages the use of the assigned rating information wherever these products are made available and urges that all advertising and materials adhere to industry-adopted guidelines.
According to information provided by the ESA to staff, game publishers “have no incentive to provide incomplete or false information to the ESRB. The cost of correcting that information is too high (taking down/updating ads, remanufacturing or stickering boxes, etc.). The ESRB checks advertisements and physical boxes and tests games AFTER release to make sure the rating information is accurate. If they find it is not, a Publisher is legally required to change it. (The publisher must sign a terms and conditions agreement for every physical game submitted to ESRB which binds the Publisher to compliance with ESRB guidelines and subjects them to enforcement actions in the event of non-compliance.) So, in addition to the robust tools in the enforcement system, the ESRB also has costly and burdensome corrective action tools to which the Publishers are legally bound.” Arguably, however, a game manufacturer could elect not to enter into those contract and no longer carry ESRB ratings—thus sidestepping any disclosure requirements and enforcement mechanisms.
- “In Game Purchases” designation is a very new designation by ESRB: As noted above, under the third category of ratings that the ESRB provides, are ratings related to interactive elements of a game. Most important to this bill are the new “In-Game Purchases” rating. This rating, which again, alerts consumers to the fact that there are additional costs associated with that game after purchase, is a new rating in response to a growing issue within the industry that also prompted the author to bring this legislation.
The decision to add these new ratings to video game purchases was made by ESRB at the end of February of this year, stating that “the new In-Game Purchases label will be applied to games with in-game offers to purchase digital goods or premiums with real world currency, including but not limited to bonus levels, skins, surprise items (such as item packs, loot boxes, mystery awards), music, virtual coins and other forms of in-game currency, subscriptions, season passes and upgrades (e.g., to disable ads).” (See ESRB Press Release, ESRB to Begin Assigning “In-Game Purchases” Label to Physical Video Games (Feb. 27, 2018) <https://esrbstorage.blob.core.windows.net/esrbcontent/about/news/downloads/igp-press-release-final-22718.pdf> [as of Apr. 8, 2018].)
As described in a Business Insider article:
Beyond informing parents, the move is in response to the controversy surrounding several notable video games released in 2017. The biggest most recent example is “Star Wars Battlefront 2,” which infuriated players with its choice to lock major characters behind a paywall (the move was quickly retracted).
Players were mad enough, and vocal enough, that legislators got involved at one point.
[…] Without saying as much directly, the ESRB is adding the label in an attempt to assuage the concerns of legislators. It’s a small move, but it’s one that impacts all video games published on game consoles in North America. Whether or not consumers will notice the label, or care, is another question altogether. (Gilbert, Business Insider, The video game ratings board is cracking down on microtransactions — and it could have major repercussions for the future of video games (Feb. 27, 2018) <http://www.businessinsider.com/esrb-cracks-down-on-microtransactions-what-it-means-for-you-2018-2> [as of Apr. 8, 2018].)
The question posed by this legislation, now that the ESRB has moved to enact these ratings since the bill’s introduction, is whether self-regulation by the industry is sufficient, particularly in light of the voluntary nature of compliance and lack of enforcement mechanisms by ESRB. While self-regulation has worked well in the past for this industry when it comes to age suitability and content ratings, this situation is potentially distinguishable and not as fit for self-regulation: arguably, the potential incentives to generate significant revenue from this practice, and lack of any true enforcement mechanism against a video game provider who decides to not to participate in ESRB ratings of their boxed games, increases the incentives for video game manufacturers to elect to not participate in this voluntary rating system. A consumer, importantly, would have no idea and would assume that a lack of “in-game purchase” label means there are no microtransactions in that particular game. In that regard, this bill codifies a practice that the industry believes should be happening and ensures that disclosures of these microtransactions to consumers are made. Of course, nothing in this bill precludes the practice of microtransactions; it merely requires the disclosure of the practice.
The following amendment is suggested, however, to ensure that the disclosures are only required of games that are distributed on or after January 1, 2019, so that products already on the shelf do not have to be pulled and re-boxed (but so that any new boxes produced containing that existing game have to have the new label), and to ensure that used games do not have to be re-boxed into new packaging upon re-sale by resellers:
Suggested amendment:
On page 2, line 6, after line 15, add “(d) This section shall not apply to games manufactured before January 1, 2019 or resold in their original packaging.”
An additional amendment is also suggested, to ensure that this bill applies only to physical (e.g. boxed) video games available for retail sale (as opposed to, for example, slot machines), as appears to be the intent of the author:
Suggested amendment:
On page 2, after line 12, insert “(c) “Video game” means only physical or boxed video games available for retail sale, including, but not limited to, those games that have internet connectivity.
- Is the practice in violation of existing consumer protection laws in California? Arguably, the practice of advertising a game for one price as having features it does not have unless additional in-game purchases are made without adequate or with inaccurate disclosures could already result in a violation of this state’s false advertising or false and deceptive practices statutes. (See Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 17200 et seq., 17500 et seq.; Civ. Code Sec. 1770.) As argued in one recent Venture Beat guest column by attorneys over this controversial practice, lack of regulation is not the same as lack of legal exposure:
The loot box controversy is a particularly attractive target for class action claims under consumer protection statutes in protective US states like California and Massachusetts. Statutes in such states allow class actions on allegations that the developer advertised a game as having features it did not have. These statutes are ready made for inadequate or inaccurate disclosures. So, for example, a game that overstates the odds of acquiring particular in-game features through a loot box purchase would likely violate such statutes and, if the practice is widespread and profitable enough, would likely trigger a class action complaint.
But potential exposure does not stem only from overtly false claims about game features. A class could allege that a game was advertised with footage showing features or characters locked away in loot boxes and was advertised at the shelf price, but in reality the price to unlock those advertised features was much higher and the features were not available for the advertised price.
Battlefront II drew harsh criticism for the effort necessary to unlock major characters like Darth Vader. Some estimates determined that it would take over 4,500 hours of gameplay unlock all of the game’s content. Of course, players could purchase enough credits to unlock everything – for $2,100, 35 times the cost of the game. These types of criticisms are often interlaced into class action complaints to support claims that marketing and advance promotional materials led consumers to believe they were buying more features than their purchase price covered.
The loot box controversy is an attractive class action target because civil class actions are uniquely designed to address practices that impose small pecuniary impacts on large groups of consumers. A two-dollar transaction may seem to minor to warrant a lawsuit, but dozens of two-dollar transactions with tens of thousands of consumers adds up to millions in potential exposure. When civil penalty statutes, which impose penalties (up to thousands of dollars each) on a per-transaction basis, are in play, the potential exposure can quickly approach the value of the game. (Huston & Pascucci, Venture Beat, Pandora’s loot box: the legal ramifications of microtransactions game makers (Apr. 3, 2018) <https://venturebeat.com/2018/04/03/pandoras-loot-box-the-legal-ramifications-of-microtransactions-game-makers/> [as of Apr. 8, 2018].)
Of course, this bill would not eliminate any such remedies available under existing law; rather it makes clear that consumers have a legal remedy for this exact practice and could help avoid the issue altogether by expressly incentivizing video game manufacturers to place the necessary disclosures on their physical boxes.
- Arguments in support: Consumers for Digital Fairness writes in support of this bill:
California is the hub of the video game industry and, for decades, been a leader in consumer protection. […] Over the last few years video game companies have, naturally, looked to expand their streams of revenue and the monetization of their products. To accomplish this, some have begun to embed restrictions and locks on content that can only be accessed when the player uses real money to pay for further access within the product they have already purchased. These microtransactions come in many forms, from randomized gambling systems to direct pay-to-keep-playing paywalls restricting players from accessing content that is already part of the product they purchased. Imagine purchasing a car that required you to insert your credit card and spend additional funds to access the trunk and glove box. These practices are unfair and hurt consumers. […]
- Arguments in opposition: ESA opposes this bill in light of the ESRB’s announcement over In-Game Purchase labels in February and the fact that “the industry recently took several steps to not only enhance its own, self-imposed labeling requirements for the physical sale of games, but also use this opportunity to build greater awareness of the tools available to parents to assist in managing the time and money children spend on games.” ESA writes:
The computer and video game industry is currently engaged in a valuable conversation regarding the expansion of in-game economies, particularly the increased use of in-game mechanisms, such as “loot boxes” in newer games, and the very vocal objections raised by gamers around the world in response. The industry takes its responsibility to gamers seriously, and it remains incredibly responsive to the individuals who enjoy video games as entertainment. Without gamers enjoying the games developers create, there is no video game industry.
To that end, we believe strongly that the industry’s robust self-regulatory body, the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB), in concert with the global marketplace itself, remain the most efficient and effective way to address, and respond to, important issues affecting the industry. We are of the opinion that the marketplace is reacting effectively and appropriately to these issues, and will continue to address consumers’ concerns as warranted.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumers for Digital Fairness
Consumers Union
Opposition
Entertainment Software Association (ESA)
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):