AB 812: Auditors: investigators.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-04-04
Existing law authorizes persons employed as investigators of an auditor-controller or director of finance of any county or persons employed by a city and county who conduct investigations under the supervision of the controller of the city and county, as specified, to serve warrants and access criminal history information. Existing law authorizes specified persons to inspect a juvenile case file.
This bill would permit these investigators to inspect and copy juvenile case files when conducting an investigation within the scope of their duties if it is reasonably believed that the information contained in the juvenile case file may be relevant to an investigation of waste, fraud, or abuse, as specified.
Existing law establishes, among other offices of county government, the office of county auditor and prescribes the duties of the county auditor. Existing law requires that the county auditor or, in counties that have the office of controller, the auditor-controller be the chief accounting officer of the county.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would allow employees of the county auditor or county auditor-controllers office, as applicable, to investigate cases of alleged fraud and abuse by county employees.Existing law establishes, among other offices of county government, the office of county auditor and prescribes the duties of the county auditor. Existing law requires that the county auditor or, in counties that have the office of controller, the auditor-controller be the chief accounting officer of the county.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would allow employees of the county auditor or county auditor-controllers office, as applicable, to investigate cases of alleged fraud and abuse by county employees.
(a)The following persons are not peace officers but may exercise the power to serve warrants as specified in Sections 1523 and 1530 during the course and within the scope of their employment, if they receive a course in the exercise of that power pursuant to Section 832. The authority and power of the persons designated under this section shall extend to any place in the state:
(1)Persons employed as investigators of an auditor-controller or director of finance of any county or persons employed by a city and county who conduct investigations under the supervision of the controller of the city and county, who are regularly employed and paid in that capacity, provided that the primary duty of these persons shall be to engage in investigations related to the theft of funds or the misappropriation of funds or resources, or investigations related to the duties of the auditor-controller or finance director as set forth in Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 26880), Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 26900), Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 26970), and Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 26980) of Part 3 of Division 2 of Title 3 of the Government Code.
(2)Persons employed by the Department of Justice as investigative auditors, provided that the primary duty of these persons shall be to investigate financial crimes. Investigative auditors shall only serve warrants for the production of documentary evidence held by financial institutions, Internet service providers, telecommunications companies, and third parties who are not reasonably suspected of engaging or having engaged in criminal activity related to the documentary evidence for which the warrant is requested.
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, persons designated pursuant to this section shall not carry firearms.
(c)Persons designated pursuant to this section shall be included as peace officers of the state under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 11105 for the purpose of receiving state summary criminal history information and shall be furnished that information on the same basis as peace officers of the state designated in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 11105.
(d)Unless otherwise specifically provided, this section confers to persons designated in this section the same authority and power to serve warrants as conferred by Section 830.11.
(e)Notwithstanding any other law, including Sections 827 and 10850 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, a person described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), may access, inspect, and copy a juvenile case file, or portions thereof, in the same manner as the individuals listed in subparagraph (H) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 827 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, only when conducting an investigation within the scope of his or her duties, and when it is reasonably believed that information contained in the juvenile case file may be relevant to an investigation of waste, fraud, or abuse, which may include, but is not limited to, acts of misuse of personally identifiable information or protected health information, and only if prior notice is given to the director of the county child welfare agency and the county probation department. Juvenile case file information obtained pursuant to this subdivision may only be disclosed in the same manner as authorized by Section 827 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or to the appointing authority of the county child welfare agency or the county probation department for the purposes of taking corrective or disciplinary action, or to the district attorney.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would allow employees of the county auditor or county auditor-controllers office, as applicable, to investigate cases of alleged fraud and abuse by county employees.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would allow employees of the county auditor or county auditor-controllers office, as applicable, to investigate cases of alleged fraud and abuse by county employees.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2018 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2018 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 25, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 4, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 3, 2017 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | Apr 24, 2017 |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Support | Apr 24, 2017 |
Date of Hearing:
Counsel: Gabriel Caswell
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 812
Author:(Chen) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2017
SUMMARY:
Permits investigators of an auditor-controller or a director of finance to inspect and copy juvenile files when conducting an investigation within the scope of their duties if it is reasonably believed that the information contained in the juvenile case file may be relevant to an investigation of waste, fraud, or abuse.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the following persons (who are not peace officers) may exercise the power to serve warrants, as specified, during the course and within the scope of their employment, if they receive a course of an investigation in the course of their duties, as specified: (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd.(a).)
- Persons employed as investigators of an auditor-controller or director of finance of any county or persons employed by a city and county who conduct investigations under the supervision of the controller of the city and county, who are regularly employed and paid in that capacity, provided that the primary duty of these persons shall be to engage in investigations related to the theft of funds or the misappropriation of funds or resources, or investigations related to the duties of the auditor-controller or finance director as set forth; or (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd. (a)(1).)
- Persons employed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) as investigative auditors, provided that the primary duty of these persons shall be to investigate financial crimes. Investigative auditors shall only serve warrants for the production of documentary evidence held by financial institutions, Internet service providers, telecommunications companies, and third parties who are not reasonably suspected of engaging or having engaged in criminal activity related to the documentary evidence for which the warrant is requested. (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd.(a)(2).)
- Persons employed as investigators of an auditor-controller or director of finance of any county or persons employed by a city and county who conduct investigations under the supervision of the controller of the city and county, who are regularly employed and paid in that capacity, provided that the primary duty of these persons shall be to engage in investigations related to the theft of funds or the misappropriation of funds or resources, or investigations related to the duties of the auditor-controller or finance director as set forth; or (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd. (a)(1).)
- Provides that the investigators and auditors referenced above shall be subject to the following provisions and limitations:
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, persons designated as investigators pursuant to these provisions shall not carry firearms; (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that these auditors and investigators shall be included as “peace officers of the state” for the limited purpose of receiving state summary criminal history information and shall be furnished that information on the same basis as peace specified officers of the state; and (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd.(c).)
- Permits limited powers to serve warrants for investigative reasons. (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd.(d).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, persons designated as investigators pursuant to these provisions shall not carry firearms; (Pen. Code, § 830.13, subd. (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "AB 812 would help to expedite investigations of alleged fraud and misconduct by county employees or contractors by authorizing county auditor investigators access to the juvenile case files of children in foster care or probation, within the scope of their investigation."
- Current Law Permits Judges to Review Requests and Control the Release of Highly Confidential Information About Juveniles to Investigators: Under current law, auditor-investigators and all other investigating parties must petition a juvenile court judge or magistrate for the release of information from a juvenile case file. Juvenile court files are confidential for a reason. Information contained in a juvenile's dependency or delinquency case file is personal information about a juvenile. Particularly in the case of a juvenile dependency case file, the juvenile is in the system through no fault of their own. The information contained in these files can be personal information related to physical, emotional or sexual abuse, medical information, mental health information, or any number of highly personal areas. In dependency matters, the juvenile court is acting as the de facto parent for many of these children. In the place of the parent, the court receives reports from a variety of sources, including doctors, mental health professionals, social workers, schools, law enforcement if the child has been abused/neglected/a crime victim, and more. The reports and related items in the file contain the very most intimate and sensitive information about not only the youth but the youth’s parents, siblings, half-siblings and perhaps others with whom the youth has a relationship.
The current system allows courts to review the information in the case file for relevant information prior to the disclosure to an investigator. Inquiries must go through the court in a petition process that includes notice being given to the youth, parents, and others, and not just a notice but an opportunity for those parties who are entitled to respond, object, or otherwise to be heard by the court. The court then has the ability to grant the request in full, or more importantly and as is often the case, place limitations on the request. These limitations may include redaction of some information if it is not needed by the requester, such as information about others named in the file, personally identifying information (such as a social security number), limiting information to a specified period of time, requirements on what the requestor does with the data when done.
- History of Permitting Investigators for Auditor-Controllers to Conduct Investigations Utilizing Search Warrants and Subpoenas: AB 433 (Hertzberg), Chapter 170, Statutes of 1997 first authorized investigators of county auditor-controller offices to serve search warrants and subpoenas, obtain summary criminal history information, or obtain other financial records to prevent loss of public funds. The bill was originally brought by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors. At the time they argued that at the time, "only peace officers and specifically designated employees of State agencies have the authority to serve search warrants and to obtain financial, criminal, motor vehicle and other information during investigations. Assembly Bill 433 authorized investigators of county auditor-controller offices to receive information from financial institutions during fraud investigations and to serve warrants or receive criminal information during investigations of theft of funds or misappropriation of funds. Unlawful disclosure of any investigative information would be punished as a misdemeanor." Proponents of AB 443 further argued that auditor-controller investigators generally work on matters involving theft or embezzlement of county funds. The change brought by AB 433 permitted access by auditor-controller investigators without having to go through their local law enforcement and district attorney.
SB 1164 (Scott), Chapter 81, Statutes of 2008 added DOJ investigative auditors to the list of persons who, although not peace officers, are authorized to serve search warrants and receive state summary criminal history information. The stated need for this expansion to DOJ investigative auditors was in order to expedite elder financial abuse and Medi-Cal fraud investigations. The provisions of SB 1164 gave investigative auditors the ability to serve search warrants on financial institutions and other entities for the production of documentary evidence.
- Expansion of the Authority of County Auditor-Controller or Director of Finance to Inspect Juvenile Case Files: This bill expands the powers of a county auditor-controller to investigate juvenile case files. The expanded powers will allow auditor-controllers to access, inspect, and copy a juvenile case file, or portions thereof, in the same manner as court personnel, parties to juvenile proceedings, and other specified persons. The access is limited to the conduction of an investigation within the scope of the auditor-controller's duties, and when it is reasonably believed that information contained in the juvenile case file may be relevant to an investigation of waste, fraud, or abuse. Additionally, prior notice must be given to the director of the county child welfare agency and the county probation department. Juvenile case file information obtained may only be disclosed in a limited investigative manner or to the appointing authority of the county child welfare agency or the county probation department for the purposes of taking corrective or disciplinary action, or to the district attorney.
- Argument in Support: According to The County of Los Angeles, "Current law, Penal Code 380.13 and Government Code 53087.6, authorizes certified investigators of county auditor-controllers ("auditor investigators") to conduct investigations of alleged waste, fraud or abuse by county employees or contractors for all county programs and departments, including the theft, misuse, and the unlawful distribution of child welfare case information. These auditor investigators also investigate theft of government funds paid to provide care and services to dependent children and their families, fraudulent claims for services and care, and the misuse of dependent children's personal information, including, but not limited to, identity theft, tax, and insurance fraud.
"Investigating the theft, misuse and/or unlawful distribution of children's case information requires auditor investigators to inspect and to copy juvenile case files. Welfare and Institutions Code Section 827, which was enacted prior to Penal Code Section 830.13, restricts the access to juvenile case files to limited persons, such as the district attorney or special investigators with the Department of Social Services. For all other persons not specified, such as the general public and the media, as well as county auditor investigators, they are required to publicly petition the juvenile court for access to children's case files…
"The personal identifying information of children in foster care is susceptible to loss, theft and to the misuse by the various entities and individuals that have access to it. An August 2011 California Office of Privacy Protection Report recommended investigations to reduce the potential fraudulent activity. The report states that after reviewing the records of 2,110 foster children in Los Angeles County, 104 children had 247 separate accounts, with an average account balance of $1,811, and the largest being a home loan of over $200,000.
"A mechanism for promptly investigating and resolving fraud allegations is critical to limiting the duration of the fraud, and the total loss, as well as maintaining the confidentiality and integrity of pending investigations. Investigating the misuse of child welfare case information conducted by investigators is a critical component to further strengthening the protection of the State's most vulnerable children. However, the time it takes to initiate an authorized investigation for vulnerable children in the County's care exposes the child to financial abuse, the potential dissemination and misuse of their personal data, and impairs the County's ability to gather evidence through a confidential investigation. Additionally, providing notice of the request increases the possibility that the investigation may be compromised, and that individuals involved in related misconduct might have the opportunity to destroy evidence or to engage in additional improprieties."
- Argument in Opposition: According to the California Public Defenders Association, "AB 812 would compromise the privacy and confidentiality rights of system-involved youth by allowing employees of the county auditor-controller or finance departments to access confidential juvenile court records. In enacting subdivision (b) of Welfare and Institutions Code section 827, the Legislature 'reaffirmed its belief that juvenile court records, in general, should be confidential.' Also, the 'strong public policy of confidentiality of juvenile proceedings and records has long been recognized' by the courts.' (In re Keisha T. (1995) 38 Cal.App.4th 220, 231.) Current policy encourages candor in the courts by system-involved youth and families, and protects youth from social stigma associated with being a dependent or ward of the court. Importantly, courts are often called on to make decisions regarding a youth’s medical care, educational issues, placement, psychotropic medication and therapy. The policy of confidentiality ensures that those orders and reasons underlying them remain private.
"As indicated, the confidentiality of juvenile court records is codified in Welfare and Institutions Code section 827. Even law enforcements access to these records is limited, and access is only available to those 'officers who are actively participating in criminal or juvenile proceedings involving the minor.' (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 827, subd. (a)(1)(E).) AB 812 seeks to provide employees of county controllers, auditors and departments of finance access to juvenile court records when it is reasonable to believe the records contain evidence of fraud, waste and abuse. The bill would provide the same right of access to the records as social workers, who are charged with ensuring the welfare of the children before the court. The narrow scope of the information sought by auditors should not allow a right of access to the entire file.
"For example, if an auditor is looking for evidence in an individual child’s file that a group home has been overbilling the county, there is no reason to allow that employee access to those portions of the file that discuss the circumstances that brought the child into the system, the child’s social history, familial history, mental health issues, medical issues and educational history. Under such circumstances, the auditor should file a petition under existing law requesting the court grant access only to the relevant portions of the file. The statute provides the court with authority to permit persons to petition the court for access to juvenile court records. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 827, subd. (a)(1)(P); Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.552.) This balancing allows the court 'to safeguard the privacy of minors in order to protect their best interests and to control access to juvenile case files.' (In re Gina S. (2005) 13 Cal.App.4th 1074, 1084, Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.552(e)(4) & (5).) It recognizes that the analysis needs to be conducted on a case by case basis so that the juvenile court can exercise its 'sensitivity and expertise to make decisions about access to juvenile court records.' (J.E v. Superior Court (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 1329, 1337.) Allowing juvenile information to be disseminated en masse to auditors is irreconcilable with the court’s obligation to protect the confidentiality of system-involved children and to only allow limited access to those records on a particularized showing of need in individual cases."
- Prior Legislation: AB 433 (Hertzberg), Chapter 170, Statutes of 1997 first authorized investigators of county auditor-controller offices to serve search warrants and subpoenas, obtain summary criminal history information, or obtain other financial records to prevent loss of public funds.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
County of Los Angeles (Sponsor)
Opposition
California Public Defenders Association
Analysis Prepared by:
Gabriel Caswell / PUB. S. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):