AB 1987: Protective orders.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-03-04
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Mar 10, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (March 10). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 6, 2020 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and P. & C.P. |
| Jan 24, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 23. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 10, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 10, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1987
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:March 4, 2020
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: DOMESTIC VIOLENCE PROTECTIVE ORDERS: CONNECTED DEVICES
KEY ISSUE: Should A COURT BE PERMITTED TO issue A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE RESTRAINING ORDER that prevents an abuser from remotely controlling a connected device AFFECTING THE HOME, VEHICLE, OR PROPERTY OF THe victim in order TO PREVENT an abuser from harassing THe victim by means of the device?
SYNOPSIS
This bill expands the range of behaviors that can be prohibited by a court-issued domestic violence protective order to include restrictions on the remote control of connected devices that affect the home, vehicle, or property of the victim. Current law allows courts to issue protective orders to enjoin an abuser from engaging in certain behaviors, including harassing, contacting, threatening, stalking, destroying personal property of, coming within a specified distance of, or disturbing the peace of the victim if the victim is related to, or has lived with or dated, the abuser. Today, there is an emerging form of abuse by which abusers can harass, abuse, surveil, or otherwise exert control over victims through remote control of internet-enabled “smart” devices including thermostats, door locks, speakers, sprinklers, lights, and security cameras designed to facilitate one’s daily life. These devices are becoming increasingly prevalent in homes, with nearly 30 million homes in the United States incorporating some form of smart technology. Protective orders can exclude abusers from the dwelling of their victims, keep an abuser a specified distance away from their victim, and prohibit certain actions by which an abuser can molest a victim, but the ability to remotely control these connected devices is not tethered to the physical location of the abuser, making their control a unique form of abuse that, according to the author and bill supporters, justifies explicit authorization for courts to enjoin. By permitting courts to issue orders to enjoin remote control of devices affecting the home, vehicle, or property of another party, this bill addresses an emerging form of abuse that is of growing public concern, prudently including possible smart technologies that have not yet been developed in its broad scope. This bill is very similar to AB 455 (Kiley) from last year which did not move.
This bill is supported by the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists, who argues that “[r]emotely controlling connected devices in the home of the other party can be a way for a perpetrator of abuse to use modern technology to engage in domestic abuse against his or her victim, especially if the perpetrator of abuse is ordered to move out of the house.” However, while this bill rightly can prevent an abuser from controlling a connected devise, if the device is solely controlled or operated by the abuser, the victim may be unable to control the device on their own even when it is in their home or car. The author may be able to address this concern, as the bill moves forward, by, among other things, permitting the court to require the maker of the device to allow the victim to change the device’s password.
The bill is also supported by the California State Sheriffs’ Association, which writes that “law enforcement has seen a number of cases in which alleged domestic abusers manipulate smart devices in the homes of their victims, ranging from remotely opening garage doors to turning up thermostats to unbearable temperatures,” and this bill is necessary to better protect domestic violence survivors. There is no reported opposition to the bill.
SUMMARY: Allows a party to request that a court issue a restraining order to prohibit another party from remotely controlling connected devices affecting the protected party’s home, vehicle, or property. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits a court to issue an ex parte order enjoining a party from remotely controlling any connected devices, as defined, affecting the home, vehicle, or property of the victim.
- Requires Judicial Council to develop or update any forms or rules of court that are necessary to implement 1), above, by January 1, 2022.
- Declares that:
- The political climate resulting from federal policies and rhetoric targeting immigrants has discouraged immigrants from seeking critical legal protections for fear of immigration authorities targeting them or their families;
- The legal protections provided by the State of California are intended to protect all residents of California, regardless of their immigration status;
- Domestic violence threatens the safety and well-being of victims and their families and protective orders are often necessary to protect victims from their abusers, regardless of the immigration status of the victim or the abuser; and
- The Domestic Violence Protection Act, like all of the Family Code, has always applied to all Californians without regard to immigration status, and continues to do so.
EXISTING LAW:
- Permits a court to issue a domestic violence protective order enjoining a party from molesting, attacking, striking, stalking, threatening, sexually assaulting, battering, credibly impersonating, falsely personating, harassing, telephoning, destroying personal property, contacting, coming within a specified distance of, or disturbing the peace of the other party. (Family Code Section 6200 et seq., Section 6320. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
- Allows a domestic violence protective order to be issued ex parte and after notice and a hearing. (Sections 6320, 6340.)
- Permits a court to issue an ex parte order excluding a party from the family dwelling, the dwelling of the other party, the common dwelling of both parties, or the dwelling of the person who has care, custody, and control of a child to be protected from domestic violence. (Section 6321.)
- Permits a court to issue an ex parte order determining the temporary use, possession, and control of real or personal property of the parties. (Section 6324.)
- Permits a court to issue an ex parte order enjoining a party from specified behavior that the court determines is necessary to effectuate orders listed in 1) and 3), above. (Section 6322.)
- Allows a court in a Domestic Violence Prevention Act proceeding, after notice and a hearing, to issue an order directing a wireless telephone service provider to transfer billing responsibility and rights to a wireless phone number to a requesting party, if the requesting party is not the accountholder. Requires that the order be made to the wireless provider, served as specified, and contain specified information. Provides a process for the wireless telephone service provider to make the transfer, as appropriate. (Section 6347.)
- Defines “connected device” as any device, or other physical object that is capable of connecting to the internet, directly or indirectly, and that is assigned an Internet Protocol address or Bluetooth address. (Civil Code Section 1798.91.05 (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: To provide for the safety and security of victims or those at immediate risk of domestic violence, courts are permitted to issue protective orders to prohibit an abuser from engaging in several specified behaviors, including striking, threatening, stalking, contacting, harassing, destroying the property of, or coming within a specified distance of, the party requesting the order. If the victim is in immediate danger, these orders can be issued, temporarily on an ex parte basis, meaning the party against whom the order is issued need not be present or heard at the proceedings approving the petition for the protective order. However, current law lacks provisions authorizing a court to enjoin the remote control of so-called “smart” devices such as thermostats, cameras, locks, lights, and speakers, the unwanted control or operation of which can severely affect the psychological and physical well-being of a victim. As modern technology moves toward automation, “smart” or “connected” technologies that are capable of remotely controlling devices and conditions in the home and vehicle are increasingly ubiquitous. Several reports suggest these devices have been used malevolently to abuse and exert control over victims of domestic violence. This bill, similar to last year’s AB 455 (Kiley), explicitly endows courts with the authority to issue protective orders to enjoin abusers from remotely controlling connected devices affecting the home, vehicle, or property victims in order to provide victims of domestic violence with legal protection from this emerging form of domestic abuse.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
More than 1 in 3 women and more than 1 in 4 men in the United States experience a form of domestic violence in their lifetime. [https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/nisvs_report2010-a.pdf.] Domestic violence protective orders can be an important tool in protecting victims from further abuse, but as the ways that abuse change[s] we need to make sure our tools of protection adapt as well.
AB 1987 would expand the behaviors that can be controlled by a court-issued domestic violence protective order to explicitly include remote control of connected devices in the home, vehicle, or property of the victim in order to address an emerging form of abuse. This would help highlight the potential for abuse through these venues to both victims and judges, and provide clarity that the restrained party cannot remotely control these devices to monitor or harass a victim. The bill would also require the Judicial Council to update any relevant forms in order to implement this.
Additionally, in order to address implications by some that these protections may not apply to all Californians and help clarify that this recourse exists for all victims, AB 1987 would also declare legislative findings that the Domestic Violence Protection Act, like all of the Family Code, has always applied to Californians regardless of immigration status and continues to do so.
Technology and Domestic Violence. In the fall of 2018, the Assembly Committee on Privacy & Consumer Protection and the Select Committee on Domestic Violence held a joint informational hearing to discuss “the intersection between technology and domestic violence.” Several personal stories and expert testimonies indicated that emerging technologies provide new avenues for domestic abuse, and that our existing legal framework concerning domestic violence is ambiguous at best and negligent at worst with respect to these modern forms of abuse. This bill (and its predecessor, AB 455 (Kiley)) was inspired by the recommendations prescribed by experts testifying at that hearing. An article in the New York Times from June 23, 2018, entitled “Thermostats, Locks and Lights: Digital Tools of Domestic Abuse,” further illuminates the threats associated with new technology, namely smart devices, in domestic violence situations. That article described a number of situations in which abusers exerted remote control over the lives of their victims via connected devices, including the following examples:
One woman had turned on her air-conditioner, but said it then switched off without her touching it. Another said the code numbers of the digital lock at her front door changed every day and she could not figure out why. Still another told an abuse help line that she kept hearing the doorbell ring, but no one was there.
Their stories are part of a new pattern of behavior in domestic abuse cases tied to the rise of smart home technology. Internet-connected locks, speakers, thermostats, lights and cameras that have been marketed as the newest conveniences are now also being used as a means for harassment, monitoring, revenge and control.
In more than 30 interviews with The New York Times, domestic abuse victims, their lawyers, shelter workers and emergency responders described how the technology was becoming an alarming new tool. Abusers — using apps on their smartphones, which are connected to the internet-enabled devices — would remotely control everyday objects in the home, sometimes to watch and listen, other times to scare or show power. Even after a partner had left the home, the devices often stayed and continued to be used to intimidate and confuse.
Connected smart devices are increasingly present in the home and elsewhere. The role of “connected devices,” or devices that can connect to the internet and have an Internet Protocol or Bluetooth Address (as defined in Civil Code Section 1798.91.05 (b)) in the daily lives of Americans has skyrocketed in recent years with the emergence of smart technologies designed to increase personal comfort, convenience, and efficiency. These devices are varied in nature, and include wi-fi enabled thermostats, speakers, door locks, cameras, lights, security systems, sprinklers, and refrigerators, all of which can be operated remotely from smartphone apps, computer programs, or internet websites. According to a 2017 report by McKinsey, 29 million homes in the United States have some form of smart technology, and this number has been growing at an average rate of 31% percent per year. (K. Ahuja & M. Patel, There’s No Place Like [A Connected] Home, McKinsey & Company (2017).)
Given this rate of growth, it is reasonable to expect that the diversity of smart technology in homes will only increase over time, and as a result, the pervasiveness of connected devices with the capacity to affect lives in the home, automobile, and otherwise is also likely to increase. Unfortunately, with the possibility for such innovation to improve our lives comes the capacity for malicious use of these devices, as described above and in ways not yet conceived. The ability to harass, abuse, or exert control over another person from anywhere in the world by blasting loud noise through speakers, turning the thermostat up or down to uninhabitable temperatures, denying access to the home or car by changing codes on smart locks, or surveilling activity through smart cameras, lends itself to abuse that can deny victims of these attacks the safe, comfortable lives all humans deserve.
Domestic violence is a frequent occurrence requiring unique opportunities for legal recourse. According to the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey, about one in every three individuals in the United States has experienced rape, physical violence, and/or stalking by an intimate partner in their lifetime. (Sharon Smith, et al., The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2015 Data Brief – Updated Release, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, pp. 8-9 (Nov. 2018).) Over a third of all women in the U.S. have experienced some form of psychological aggression by an intimate partner during their lifetime, including 31 percent who experience some form of coercive control. (Id. at 21.) These abuses take various forms, but all of them exert a severe negative impact on the psychological and/or physical health of the victim. To protect those most at risk of suffering the adverse consequences of domestic abuse, courts are permitted to issue domestic violence protective orders that prohibit abusers or potential abusers, who have certain specified relationships with their victims, such as family, cohabitants, or those in dating relationships, from engaging in specified behaviors that put the safety of their victims at risk. These behaviors include molesting, attacking, striking, stalking, threatening, sexually assaulting, battering, credibly impersonating, falsely personating, harassing, telephoning, destroying personal property, contacting, coming within a specified distance of, or disturbing the peace of the victim. (Family Code Section 6320.)
However, as modern and accelerating advances in technology continue to reshape the nature of our everyday activities and social engagements, the litany of behaviors that could pose a threat to the security and well-being of a victim in an abusive domestic relationship similarly expands. This bill seeks to address one symptom of modern technology’s potential to facilitate domestic abuse by permitting courts to issue domestic violence restraining orders to prohibit remote control of connected devices that affect the home, vehicle, or property of the victim to more appropriately address this new avenue for domestic abuse.
This bill will enjoin an abuser from controlling a connected device, but does not yet provide a way for the victim to control the device. Supporters of last year’s AB 455 (Kiley) raised the unaddressed issue of needing to provide victims with the means to control connected devices following enjoinder of the restrained party’s control of the devices. While this bill permits a court to prevent an abuser from controlling connected devices affecting the home, vehicle, or property of the victim, it does not explicitly provide a process for how to prevent the abuser from denying the victim use of these devices by changing passwords, not providing access information, etc. This may result in, for instance, the inability of a victim to adjust the thermostat or to lock the doors to their house. This issue is worth noting and the author may wish to consider, as the bill moves forward, amending the bill to create a process for transferring control of connected devices to the petitioner, similar to the transfer to a victim of domestic violence of a cell phone by a wireless service provider, set out in AB 1407 (Atkins), Chap. 415, Stats. 2015, adding Section 6347 to the Family Code.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by the California Association of Certified Family Law Specialists, who write:
Remotely controlling connected devices in the home of the other party can be a way for a perpetrator of abuse to use modern technology to engage in domestic abuse against his or her victim, especially if the perpetrator of abuse is ordered to move out of the house. This Bill updates the domestic violence statute to address new methods of abusive conduct as society evolves technologically.
Adds the California State Sheriffs’ Association:
In recent years, law enforcement has seen a number of cases in which alleged domestic abusers manipulate smart devices in the homes of their victims, ranging from remotely opening garage doors to turning up thermostats to unbearable temperatures. Current law protects domestic violence survivors, in that the abuser must physically be a specified distance away from the victims, however, even with a court-issued domestic violence restraining order, the order does not prevent perpetrators of domestic abuse from accessing the devices in the homes of their victims.
AB 1987 would authorize the courts to issue an ex parte order to prevent a person from remotely controlling any smart device or connected device in the home of another party.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Certified Family Law Specialists
California State Sheriffs’ Association
Change for Justice
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):