AB 1998: Dental Practice Act: unprofessional conduct.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-06-03
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 8, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 69. Noes 1. Page 4821.) |
| Jun 4, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 3, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (June 2). |
| May 22, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 14. Noes 1.) (May 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 6, 2020 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jan 28, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 27. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 8, 2020 | [First] hearing set for [08-10-2020]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| Aug 8, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| Jun 11, 2020 | AB 1998 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: August 8, 2020
Author: | |||
Version: | June 3, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Dana Shaker | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Clarifies requirements under existing law related to review of diagnostic imagery for the use of orthodontic appliances, requires patients to be provided specified information in a dental treatment plan, and specifies that dental care providers are not required to sign an agreement that limits their ability to file a complaint or provide information to the board.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Dental Board of California (DBC) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- Establishes the Dental Practice Act, providing for licensure and regulation for dentists and dental assistants by the Dental Board of California. (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- States that protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the DBC in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions, and that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (BPC § 1601.2)
- Defines “dentistry” as the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation. (BPC § 1625)
- Provides that a dentist may have their license revoked or suspended or be reprimanded or be placed on probation by the DBC for unprofessional conduct, or incompetence, or gross negligence, or repeated acts of negligence in their profession. (BPC § 1670)
- Enumerates various acts constituting unprofessional conduct by licensed dentists, which includes failure by the treating dentist, prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances, to perform an examination to establish a patient of record, including the review of the patient’s most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia; new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging are required to be ordered if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist. (BPC § 1680)
- Specifies unprofessional conduct by a licensee to include, among other things, the failure by a treating dentist, prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or the initial use of orthodontic appliances, to perform an examination pursuant to that required of a patient of record, including the review of the patient’s most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia. The act requires new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging to be ordered if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist. (BPC § 1680)
- Defines “patient of record” as a patient who has been examined, has had a medical and dental history completed and evaluated, and has had oral conditions diagnosed and a written plan developed by the licensed dentist. (BPC § 1684.5)
- Specifies unprofessional conduct by a licensee to include the advertising of either professional superiority or the advertising of performance of professional services in a superior manner. (BPC § 1680)
- Requires an individual, partnership, corporation, or other entity providing dental services through telehealth, prior to the rendering of services and when required by a patient, to make available the name, telephone number, practice address, and California state license number of any dentist who will be involved in the provision of services to a patient, and makes a violation of that provision unprofessional conduct. (BPC § 1683.1)
- Prohibits a provider of dental services from requiring a patient to sign an agreement limiting the patient’s ability to file a complaint with the board. (BPC § 1683.2)
- Requires a licensee who fails or refuses to comply with a request for the dental records of a patient, that is accompanied by the patient’s written authorization for release of record to the board, within 15 days of receiving the request and authorization, to pay the board a civil penalty of $250 per day for each day that the documents have not been produced after the 15th day, up to a maximum of $5,000, unless the licensee is unable to provide the documents within this time period for good cause. (BPC § 1684.1)
- Defines “telehealth” as a mode of delivering health care services and public health via information and communication technologies to facilitate the diagnosis, consultation, treatment, education, care management, and self-management of a patient's health care while the patient is at the originating site and the health care provider is at a distant site. Telehealth facilitates patient self-management and caregiver support for patients and includes synchronous interactions and asynchronous store and forward transfers. (BPC § 2290.5(a)(6))
- Requires notice of a practitioner’s licensed status in the state be available to telehealth patients. (BPC § 1611.3)
- Requires any individual, partnership, corporation, or other entity that provides dental services through telehealth to make available the name, telephone number, practice address, and California state license number of any dentist who will be involved in the provision of services to a patient prior to the rendering of services and when requested by a patient. (BPC § 1683.1)
- Permits a dentist to require or permit a dental assistant in extended functions, a registered dental hygienist, or a registered dental hygienist in alternative practice, to determine and perform radiographs for the specific purpose of aiding a dentist in completing a comprehensive diagnosis and treatment plan for a patient using telehealth. A dentist is not required to review patient records or make a diagnosis using telehealth. (BPC § 1684.5)
- Permits a dental assistant in extended functions and a dental hygienist to perform additional duties, including determining which radiographs to perform on a patient who has not received an initial examination by the supervising dentist for the specific purpose of the dentist making a diagnosis and treatment plan for the patient. In these circumstances, the dental assistant in extended functions shall follow protocols established by the supervising dentist. This only applies in a dental office or in public health settings using telehealth for the purpose of communication with the supervising dentist, including, but not limited to, schools, head start and preschool programs, and community clinics, under the general supervision of a dentist. (BPC §§ 1753.55; 1910.5(a))
- Requires placing protective restorations, which for this purpose are identified as interim therapeutic restorations, and defined as a direct provisional restoration placed to stabilize the tooth until a licensed dentist diagnoses the need for further definitive treatment. An interim therapeutic restoration consists of the removal of soft material from the tooth using only hand instrumentation, without the use of rotary instrumentation, and subsequent placement of an adhesive restorative material. Local anesthesia shall not be necessary for interim therapeutic restoration placement. Interim therapeutic restorations shall be placed in public health settings, among others, for the purpose of communication with the supervising dentist, including, but not limited to schools, head start and preschool programs, and community clinics, under the general supervision of a dentist. (BPC § 1753.55; 1910.5(a))
This bill:
- Revises unprofessional conduct provisions under current law that makes failure to review diagnostic imaging a cause for discipline against a dentist by striking “if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist” and inserting “if no radiographs are available for diagnostic review.”
- Specifies unprofessional conduct by a licensee to include the destruction of patient records before 10 years have elapsed from the date a dental service was last provided if the patient is an adult or 7 years have elapsed from the patient’s 18th birthday, whichever is longer, if the patient is a minor.
- Additionally specifies that unprofessional conduct by a licensee include the advertising of performance of professional services in a more expeditious manner.
- Requires information to be provided to a patient at the time that the patient receives the recommended treatment plan for services involving the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances, as specified.
- Prohibits a licensed dentist, dental assistant, registered dental assistant, registered dental assistant in extended functions, dental sedation assistant permit holder, orthodontic assistant permit holder, registered dental hygienist, registered dental hygienist in alternative practice, registered dental hygienist in extended functions, or other person from being required to sign an agreement that limits the signatory’s ability to file a complaint or provide information to the board.
- Specifies unprofessional conduct by a licensed dentist to include failure to comply with a written request of a patient to receive a copy of any patient-signed documents within 15 days of receiving the request.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in minor and absorbable costs to the DBC to enforce the new requirements and to the DCA to make technology changes.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “AB 1998 bans dangerous and harmful teleorthodontics by effectively prohibiting direct-to-consumer dental aligner products until legislation is passed to inform consumers and establish parameters for how teleorthodontics companies may operate. California is proud to be the incubator of innovation—but we cannot sacrifice patient health and safety in exchange for making billionaires out of tech bros. The industry should view AB 1998 as a sign that the Legislature is serious about requiring meaningful safeguards if these questionable and controversial business practices are allowed to continue.”
- DBC. The DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements. The DBC’s regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
- Sunset Review, Resulting Legislation, and Consumer Protection. Beginning in 2018, the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions (Committees) began their comprehensive sunset review oversight of 10 regulatory entities and the DCA including DBC. AB 1519 (Low, Chapter 865, Statutes of 2019) made changes to the DBC and Act as a result of the DBC’s 2018 sunset review report and its subsequent participation in a sunset review oversight hearing.
One issue outlined in the background paper for the DBC review focused specifically on whether certain self-applied; dentistry consumer products raise consumer and public protection concerns. The background paper highlighted that
“Within the many professions and occupations regulated in California, the advent of new technologies has enhanced access and ease for service to consumers. Dentistry and oral health is no exception, and individuals seeking a “better smile” are able to participate in a growing marketplace for products enabling consumers to improve their oral health and appearance from the comfort of their homes. Like with all services contained within the scope of a profession licensed by the state, however, there is benefit to analyzing the balance of convenience and any potential risk of consumer harm…Another growing market for self-applied dental treatments is in the field of orthodontia. Several companies offer aligners that can be customized for the consumer either at a boutique storefront or through an at-home kit mailed to the customer. Through these products, an individual is able to realign the positioning of their teeth into what they believe will be a straighter smile. While companies offering such products describe the mailed aligners as being “reviewed” by a dental professional through the use of remote teledentistry, it is possible for a consumer to go through the realignment process without ever actually consulting with a licensed dentist. This may be cause for some concern in light of reported incidents where teeth have been misaligned when using at-home aligners. Dental boards in other states have begun to take action against the marketers of such products, and ongoing litigation has resulted.
Veneers are another product that can be purchased outside of a dental office. Companies offering clip-on veneers allow consumers to improve their oral aesthetics by masking their real teeth with a more attractive surface. These products can also be ordered online and created through at-home impression kits. While companies offering these kinds of veneers will not sell to consumers who self-report the presence of health issues affecting their teeth, there may still be questions of whether any potential harm could result for consumers who do not speak to a licensed dentist before applying such products.
The DBC has stated that it will be ‘looking closely at teledentistry statutes to determine if corporations are interpreting the law too broadly, or whether the DBC should seek statutory language to narrow the application of teledentistry in order to ensure public protection.’ The DBC has also stated that it will be ‘gathering background information on the newly recognized specialty of dental radiology to determine whether utilizing dental radiologists, outside the state, would be considered unlicensed activity.’ These inquiries by the DBC may ultimately resolve questions about self-applied treatments.”
The committees ultimately determined that one significant public protection would be to require a treating dentist, prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances, to perform an examination – failure to do so would result in unprofessional conduct enforcement by DBC against that dentist. AB 1519 specified that the examination includes the review of the patient’s “most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia.” The bill also required dentists to order new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging if the dentist deemed that order appropriate
AB 1519 additionally addressed growing concerns raised that telehealth companies offering dental services were requiring consumers to sign an agreement waiving their ability to file a complaint of any kind, which was interpreted to include complaints to regulatory boards.
This bill proposes to update the changes that were made last year by specifying that instead of ordering new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging if the dentist deems the order appropriate, new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging would have to be ordered if no radiographs are available for review. Notably, the absence of only radiographs, and not the absence of radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging for review, would trigger the need to order new images.
- News Investigations and Disciplinary Action. In early 2020, news outlets began investigating companies providing telehealth dentistry services. The New York Times discovered that the largest company providing orthodontics through telehealth—and the primary opposition to the DBC sunset provisions codified above—“has been the subject of more than 1,670 Better Business Bureau complaints since 2014,” a number overwhelmingly larger than similarly situated aligner companies operating outside of the telehealth market. Complaints feature stories of cracked teeth, migraines, jaw pain, improper bites, and other treatment issues. The story also revealed that the company required patients to sign a confidentiality agreement as a condition of receiving a refund. This agreement generally prohibited the patient from posting negative social media comments or other public criticisms. Even more alarmingly, the agreement required the patient to pledge that they would not file a complaint of any kind, which was interpreted to include complaints to regulatory boards.” The Los Angeles Times, Fox Business, and NBC News Investigates all ran stories or segments on the industry. The NBC News Investigates work exposed numerous complaints lodged against one of the companies, and highlighted that nine members of Congress asked the Federal Food and Drug Administration and the Federal Trade Commission to investigate the company “the ensure that it is not misleading consumers or causing patient harm.” NBC News also interviewed employees of the company who admitted on camera that ‘anything could go wrong’ as a result of treatment plans being based on nonprofessionally taken home impression kits, and aired footage showing that technicians available at retail locations informed patients that they had no need to see a dentist before undergoing treatment.”
Disciplinary action taken against dentists in the telehealth world and action one company took against its own board members was also a focus of reporting. An article published by Reuters revealed that the largest telehealth orthodontics company’s lead dentist was at risk of losing his California license following a two-year state dental board investigation. A formal 24-page complaint filed by the DBC accused the lead dentist of ‘violating state law, defrauding state dental regulators and acting with gross negligence toward patients while helping [the company] grow its business.’ Nine causes for discipline were cited, including fraud, aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of dentistry, use of advertisements to deceive or mislead the public, treatment of patients not of record, and violations of telehealth statutes. Prior to the DBC’s accusation, the company filed a lawsuit against its board members, arguing that its investigation into the company’s practices constituted ‘harassment.’ This lawsuit followed numerous other litigious actions filed by the company, including accusations filed against other state dental boards and professional associations. In April of 2020, a federal judge dismissed the company’s complaint; the company has indicated it intends to re-file and resume its case against the DBC.”
- Current Dental Review Standards, Changes to AB 1998, and Mandating Diagnostic Imagery. Existing law and existing practice acknowledge that appropriate review and/or new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging be ordered by a dental professional if that dental professional deems it necessary before beginning any kind of treatment. Without a review or radiographs, any number of maladies can remain undiscovered, including loose or cracked teeth, gum recession, bone loss, or even oral cancer. In a 2018 review of 21 studies on the association between dental X-rays and health risk, researchers found a statistically significant association between dental X-ray exposure and various forms of cancer. Specifically, studies show:
- the statistically significant association between dental X-ray exposure and meningioma in 5 out of 7 studies examined;
- the statistically significant correlation in 4 out of 5 thyroid-related studies and dental diagnostic X-rays
- the statistically significant correlation between full-mouth X-rays and salivary gland cancer, but not parotid gland cancer
The review also noted health outcomes such as leukemia, low birth weight, cataracts, and thumb carcinomas were also reported.
The FDA and ADA concluded in 2012 that the decision to use X-rays should be one between dentist and patient based on the patient’s oral and medical histories, and that “[r]adiographs should be taken only when there is an expectation that the diagnostic yield will affect patient care.” Updated guidelines also state that dentists “should develop and implement a radiation protection program in their offices.”
Finally, this bill would prohibit a dental professional from signing an agreement that limits that professional’s ability to file a complaint or provide information to the DBC. This provision adds to the existing requirement that a provider of dental services is prohibited from requiring a patient to sign an agreement limiting the patient’s ability to file a complaint with the board.
- Arguments in Support. The California Association of Orthodontists (CAO) and the American Association of Orthodontists (AAO) argue in support that the current text of AB 1998 provides additional patient protections, including the prohibition for any person to enter into a contract that limits their ability to submit complaints to a regulator, and the requirement that a treating dentist order radiographs or equivalent bone imaging if none are available to review, is an important step in the right direction to protect the health and safety of California patients.
In its original version, AB 1998 included language to require an in-person examination prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances. The CAO and AAO believe that the in-person provision is essential to any future legislation and is in the best interest of the health and safety of California patients. While the CAO is supportive of AB 1998, we would like to see this discussion continued in future legislation.
- Arguments in Opposition. Generally opposition argues that the language the
author contends is clarifying to existing law is new language requiring dentists to order new radiographs if no pre-existing ones are available. They also argue that a blanket mandate for radiographs is contrary to the standard of care for dentistry and preempts a dentist’s judgement in the care for his or her patient is both dangerous and bad public policy. Finally, opposition states that this bill would hinder access to care for underserved populations by requiring X-rays, given that they contend the law does not require this at this time.
Smile Direct Club writes that “our industry agrees on and has submitted proposed amendments which attempt to restore the intent of the original provisions included in AB1519 and embrace the additional consumer protections proposed in AB1998. To that end, our industry strongly supports language that keeps the treating dentist or orthodontist in charge of decisions involving patient care, including when to order diagnostic tests in order to meet the standard of care. Mandating through legislation a standing order for radiographs for any medical or dental procedure has no basis in sound clinical practice, is potentially harmful to patients and considered unethical and wasteful by clinical guidelines....
Our concerns regarding the consumer protection provisions in AB1998 are easily addressed. California statute already provides advertising restraints in §651(b)(6) of the General Provisions of the Healing Arts. This should be the same standard used for dentistry as it does not restrict a licensed dentist from making a statement backed by scientific evidence. The current law strikes the proper balance between consumer protection and a dentist’s First Amendment right to advertise. In addition, the proposed “whistleblower” language is overly broad and inhibits a dental office from establishing effective protocols for protecting patient and proprietary information. Our industry has suggested an amendment that incorporates the current California “whistle blower” statute.”
According to the Black Chamber of Commerce: “Unfortunately, AB 1998 would stop and reverse this progress by unnecessarily creating arbitrary barriers to care. The proposed language substitutes for and preempts a dentist’s professional discretion in the appropriate care of a patient with a legislative mandate for a standing order for x-rays. The language also deletes current code language, which states that new radiographs should only be ordered if “deemed appropriate by the treating dentist,” effectively removing the dentist’s education, professionalism, and discretion from patient care. This language will also expose patients to unwarranted, unnecessary, and harmful radiographs that have been directly linked to causing brain, thyroid, and meningioma cancer for no legitimate clinical purpose.”
According to the Black Small Business Association, “Teledentistry expands access to care for millions of people that cannot travel to traditional dentist and orthodontal appointments due to lack of public transportation options and lack of dental health professionals in rural areas. Teledentistry and alternative oral treatments like clear aligner therapy are solutions to the lack of access to dental care. In fact, over 50 percent of dentists with California licenses reside in five of the 58 California counties. The dentists in these five counties have a combined total close to 19,000 while the total in five rural counties in Northern California total 17 dentists.
If AB 1998 passes, it would reverse the gains we have made by necessarily creating arbitrary barriers to care; and millions of underserved Californians will once again be excluded from the market, by requiring an unnecessary in-person visit before receiving clear aligner therapy service through teledentistry platforms with licensed dentists and orthodontists.”
- Policy Considerations.
Access to Care. Even without the concerns of COVID-19, telehealth companies offering orthodontic services have argued that they provide increased access to care at better pricing, and that in this way, they provide viable dental care alternatives to underserved populations. Regardless of whether they increase access to care, the quality of care they may, in some cases, range from lacking to harmful to the patients. Additionally, there is a question as to whether the services they provide actually meet the needs of underserved community consumers.
As with any medical area, there is a difference between elective dentistry and necessary dental procedures. For instance, Denti-Cal, the dental care healthcare plan provided through the state’s Medi-Cal, covers the following procedures: cleanings and routine check-ups; fillings; root canals; fluoride treatments; diagnostic imaging; root canals; prefabricated crowns; and full dentures. The rationale for all of these existing treatments is that they somehow contribute to the overall use and functional health of the teeth, either by preventing cavities, stopping tooth loss, making the teeth more resistant against plaque or sugar, and increasing the structural health of the teeth.
While it is true that teeth-straightening services can significantly impact the overall health of the teeth and mouth and may in some cases be necessary, this is not always the case. Denti-Cal generally does not cover cosmetic dental procedures such as those offered by the companies above. Moreover, there are a number of over-the-counter products at local drug stores that provide cosmetic benefits for teeth.
If telehealth companies offering orthodontic services generally think it best for consumers to see a dentist before using their products, and consumers in underserved health area are unable to see an orthodontic or dental care provider due to access barriers, it is not clear if telehealth dentistry products really solve problems around lack of access to quality and medically necessary care.
COVID-19 and the rise of telehealth. COVID-19 has dramatically shifted policy priorities at the local, state, federal, and global levels. Healthcare practices such as dentistry that require in-person interaction—literally having one person open their mouth routinely during dental procedures—have required intense change, including increased and upgraded sanitation practices, appropriate masks, patient screenings, among other things. Under these conditions, one might argue that telehealth dental services are necessary tools, a viable alternative to providing orthodontic care while also slowing the spread of COVID-19. While the telehealth dental services industry absolutely has the potential to serve patients in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, it can only do so as long as it ensures safe and effective methods and procedures for patients. Therefore, while COVID-19 sheds light on the potential for what telehealth dental services can be, it does not eliminate the problems that exist in the industry today. For the telehealth dental services industry to be effective, it must fully address those problems in the future.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of Orthodontists
California Dental Association
California Society of Pediatric Dentistry
California Society of Periodontists
Opposition
African American Christian Publishing and Communications Company
American Teledentistry Association
Assistance League of Redlands
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Orange County
Black Small Business Association of California
Brotherhood Crusade
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Community Economic Development Association
California Hispanic Chamber of COmmerce
California State Conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored
People
Candid Care Co.
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Icon CDC
KW Inc.
Learning Lab
Latin Business Association
Latino Chamber of Commerce
Marea Partners
Mariabandit LLC
The Midnight Mission
National Asian American Coalition
National Diversity Coalition
Northeast Graffiti Busters
Pacoima Beautiful
Prostate Cancer Research Institute
Smile Brands INC.
Smile Direct Club
Straight Smile, LLC
Technet
Urbam Outreach Foundation
Urban Ministries, INC.
Urban Outreach Foundation
Two individuals
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1998
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:June 3, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes new consumer protections and makes clarifications to the Dental Practice Act regarding orthodontic services, including services provided via technology platforms.
Major Provisions
- Clarifies when new radiographs must be ordered prior to initial use of orthodontic appliances.
- Specifies how long patient dental records must be retained.
- Requires an entity that provides specified dental services through telehealth to provide the patient the name, practice address, telephone number and California license number of the treating dentist.
- Prohibits a provider of dental services from requiring a specified dental professional to sign an agreement that limits a signatory's ability to file a complaint or provide information to the licensing board.
- Specifies is unprofessional conduct the failure of a licensed dentist to comply with a written request of a patient to receive a copy of any patient-signed documents within 15 days of receiving the request.
COMMENTS:
During the Dental Board of California's (DBC's) comprehensive sunset review, which began in late 2018, the Assembly and Senate Business and Professions committees uncovered troubling practices within the growing field of direct-to-consumer orthodontics. The DBC's sunset background paper discussed the issue of whether certain self-applied consumer products relating to dentistry raise any public protection concerns.
Over the months that followed the publication of the DBC's sunset background paper, the committees held public hearings and consulted with regulators and health experts to determine whether the risks associated with arms-length treatment of malalignment outweighed the benefits to consumers to an extent that statutory change was warranted. The committees ultimately determined that one significant public protection would be codifying the requirement that a patient's radiographs (or x-rays) be reviewed by the treating dentist prior to approving a treatment plan for corrective aligners.
Prior to the advent of telehealth technologies, there had never been any question that appropriate orthodontic treatment include diagnostic review of a patient's teeth. Even mild adjustment can result in serious harm if there is insufficient examination of a patient's oral health and bone structure. For example, loose or cracked teeth, shortening of roots, gum recession and bone loss, a misaligned bite, and tooth loss can all result from orthodontic care provided without adequate review. The evaluation of radiographs may reveal serious conditions like periodontal disease, root issues, and oral cancer that can make any degree of alignment exceptionally hazardous.
A month after language requiring the review of radiographs was amended into the DBC's sunset vehicle as part of the standard sunset process, several major companies came out in opposition to the bill. One in particular, which represented the largest market share and was anticipating the launch of its Initial Public Offering, indicated that its business model relied heavily on limited examination of a patient by its treating dentists. Instead of conducting any of its own clinical evaluations, this company required each of its customers to sign a "Healthy Teeth & Gums Acknowledgement" as part of a lengthy informed consent agreement, with the patient making various self-certifications including the following:
- "My dentist took x-rays of my teeth."
- "My dentist checked my x-rays and I have no shortened or resorbed roots."
- "My dentist checked my x-rays I have no impacted teeth."
In essence, the company relies on its patients to affirm that a different, unaffiliated dentist had performed an examination and determined that none of the risk factors associated with orthodontia were present. The company never engages directly with any dentist who had evaluated the patient's health. Instead, it states in its acknowledgement that "it is your responsibility to see a dentist to verify that your teeth and gums healthy" prior to using the company's aligners.
Ironically, the company's core argument against the provisions in the DBC sunset were assertions that it would result in excessive radiographs being taken. Nothing in the bill required practices beyond what the company already required in its informed consent agreement – that a dentist take x-rays of the patient's teeth prior to treatment. The only new requirement would be that the x-rays would have to be provided to the company's treating dentist for review to confirm that none of the risk conditions were present.
The DBC's sunset bill was ultimately passed unanimously and signed into law with radiograph requirements included. However, it immediately became apparent that more reform was potentially necessary. In the months following the DBC's sunset review, various investigative reports were published shining light onto additional practices by teleorthodontics companies.
In January of 2020, the New York Times published a lengthy exposé titled "This Company Says It Will Fix Your Smile. It May Shush You if It Doesn't." The article revealed that the largest teleorthodontics company – and the primary opposition to the DBC sunset bill provisions – "has been the subject of more than 1,670 Better Business Bureau complaints since 2014," a number overwhelmingly larger than similarly situated aligner companies operating outside of the telehealth market. Complaints feature stories of cracked teeth, migraines, jaw pain, improper bites, and other treatment issues.
Another article published by Reuters revealed that the largest teleorthodontics company's lead dentist "is at risk of losing his California license following a two-year state dental board investigation." A formal 24-page complaint filed by the DBC accused the lead dentist of "violating state law, defrauding state dental regulators and acting with gross negligence toward patients while helping [the company] grow its business." Nine causes for discipline were cited, including fraud, aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of dentistry, use of advertisements to deceive or mislead the public, treatment of patients not of record, and violations of telehealth statutes.
Prior to the DBC's accusation, the company filed a lawsuit against its board members, arguing that its investigation into the company's practices constituted "harassment." This lawsuit followed numerous other litigious actions filed by the company, including accusations filed against other state dental boards and professional associations. In April of 2020, a federal judge dismissed the company's complaint; the company has indicated it intends to re-file and resume its case against the DBC.
The author argues that the repeated bad faith on behalf of the companies involved with direct-to-consumer orthodontic products and the reports of serious patient harm require policymakers to pause and consider what additional consumer safeguards are necessary to allow these companies to continue. This bill establishes several new protections for consumers of teleorthodontic services. It also clarifies statutory requirements enacted through the DBC's sunset bill.
First, existing law requires a dentist to review a patient's "most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia" prior to approving a treatment plan. Statute provides that "new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging shall be ordered if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist." Concerns have been expressed by the teleorthodontic companies and other stakeholders that this language is too vague. This bill would clarify that the statutory mandate for ordering new radiographs is when there are existing radiographs to review. Dentists would still be held to professional standards when determining whether existing radiographs are not recent enough to rely upon; this bill simply confirms that if there is no radiograph for the dentist to review per existing requirements, they must order one.
This bill additionally clarifies when a patient must be provided information about their treating dentist. Existing law already requires that when dental services are delivered through telehealth, the dentist's name and contact information must be provided. This bill clarifies that for orthodontics, the patient must receive that information at the time they receive their treatment plan. Currently, patients using teleorthodontics products often do not learn who their treating dentist is until their aligners arrive and they have agreed to the treatment plan.
This bill also extends existing rights for dental patients to receive copies of their health documents to include all signed documents. This would include financial contracts entered into by the patient. Currently, some companies do not make copies of these documents available. Additionally, the bill requires records to be retained by dentists for a specified number of years, which was not previously in need of codification but is now justified by the indirect relationship between treating dentists and patients with whom they interact through a technology platform.
Finally, this bill would prohibit a provider of dental services from requiring a dental professional to sign an agreement that limits a signatory's ability to file a complaint or provide information to the licensing board. The New York Times found that one company required patients to sign a confidentiality agreement as a condition of receiving a refund. This agreement required the patient to pledge that they would not file a complaint of any kind, which was interpreted to include complaints to regulatory boards. These kinds of limitations on complaints to the DBC were banned by additional language in the DBC's sunset bill. This bill would extend similar prohibitions against "gag clauses" limiting participation in board investigations to dental professionals in addition to patients.
According to the Author:
"AB 1998 protects patients from dangerous and harmful teleorthodontics building upon regulations passed last year as a result of the Dental Board of California's sunset review. California is proud to be the incubator of innovation – but we cannot sacrifice patient health and safety in exchange for making billionaires out of tech bros. The industry should view AB 1998 as a sign that the Legislature is serious about requiring meaningful safeguards if these questionable and controversial business practices are allowed to continue."
Arguments in Support:
The California Dental Association (CDA) supports this bill, writing: "CDA has a long history of sponsoring and advocating for the expansion and funding of telehealth policies, including the implementation of the Virtual Dental Home, which established a new model of dental care through telehealth where specially trained dental auxiliaries provide care to patients under the remote supervision of licensed dentists. CDA is pleased to see amendments that ensure direct-to-consumer orthodontic business models have the same level of dentist oversight and patient safety as in-person and VDH models of dental care."
Arguments in Opposition:
The American Teledentistry Association (ATDA), a business league representing several direct-to-consumer teleorthodontics companies, writes in opposition to this bill. The ATDA states: "Teledentistry has the opportunity to deliver care to Californians who, for far too long, have been excluded from the chance to get the smile they deserve. Unfortunately, this legislation clearly is tailored at stifling competition and reducing access to care by placing unnecessary and unfounded restrictions on an effective healthcare delivery method – teledentistry. California's most vulnerable communities should not have to forgo dental care simply because the CDA wants to put the teledentistry model out of business. Technology is extending access to countless Californians in rural and low-income communities who have never been able to afford, reach, or use a dentist before. We should be doing everything in our power to make teledentistry more accessible, not less."
TechNet also opposes this bill, stating: "We believe statutes should affirmatively enable the use of technology to treat patients remotely and ensure that the physician-patient relationship can be established using technology." TechNet argues: "The efficacy of teledentistry has been proven and has been reinforced across the globe during the COVID-19 crisis. Accordingly, California should not arbitrarily limit innovation and health care options during these trying times."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs to the DBC to enforce the new requirements and to the DCA to make technology changes.
VOTES:
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 14-1-4
YES: Low, Arambula, Bloom, Chiu, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Ting
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough, Chen, Cunningham, Eggman
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-3
YES: Gonzalez, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, McCarty, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Diep, Eggman
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 3, 2020
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0002936
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1998
Author:(Low) – As Introduced Ver:January 27, 2020
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 14 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
As proposed to be amended, this bill establishes consumer protections related to orthodontics. Specifically, this bill:
- Clarifies when new radiographs (X-rays) must be ordered prior to initial use of orthodontic appliances.
- Specifies how long patient dental records must be retained.
- Requires an entity that provides specified dental services through telehealth to provide the patient the name, practice address, telephone number and California license number of the treating dentist.
- Prohibits a provider of dental services from requiring a specified dental professional to sign an agreement that limits a signatory’s ability to file a complaint or provide information to the licensing board.
- Specifies is unprofessional conduct the failure of a licensed dentist to comply with a written request of a patient to receive a copy of any patient-signed documents within 15 days of receiving the request.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor and absorbable costs to the Dental Board of California (DBC) to enforce these new requirements (Dentistry Fund).
- Minor information technology costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to create a new enforcement code (Dentistry Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, companies involved with direct-to-consumer orthodontic products have demonstrated bad-faith dealings with customers and regulators. The author contends reports of serious patient harm require policymakers to reconsider whether and under what parameters teleorthodontics should be allowable in the state.
- Background. DBC’s recent sunset review highlighted potentially troubling practices within the growing field of direct-to-consumer orthodontics. DBC has opened inquiries as to whether regulation of current practices of companies that sell self-applied teeth-straightening aligners is sufficient to protect the public. To begin to address these concerns, AB 1519 (Low, Chapter 865, Statutes of 2019) enacted the requirement that a treating dentist review radiographs or similar issues prior to approving a treatment plan for orthodontia. Last year, a number of news outlets also pursued inquiries into the practices of one large teleorthodontics company, bringing to light consumer complaints of cracked teeth, jaw pain and improper bites, as well as other issues such as confidentiality agreements that prohibit patients from complaining as a condition of receiving a refund. This bill, as amended, will clarify some of the requirements of AB 1519 and introduce other consumer protections.
- Support and Opposition. The California Dental Association supports this bill as proposed to be amended. The committee is unaware of further support and opposition to the bill as proposed to be amended.
The introduced version of this bill would have effectively banned teleorthodontic procedures in California without an in-person examination. That version of the bill was supported by the American Association of Orthodontists and the California Association of Orthodontists, who noted patient safety concerns with the current practices of some teleorthodontics companies. The introduced version of this bill was opposed by TechNet, the California Retailers Association and Black and African-American business and community associations.
- Amendments. Amendments delete the requirement to perform an in-person examination and instead insert specified consumer protections.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1998
Author:(Low) – As Introduced Ver:January 27, 2020
SUBJECT: Dental Practice Act: unprofessional conduct: patient of record.
SUMMARY: Specifies for purposes of the existing requirement that a treating dentist perform an examination of their patient prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances that the examination be conducted in-person.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Dental Board of California (DBC) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- States that protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the DBC in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions, and that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (BPC § 1601.2)
- Defines “dentistry” as the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation. (BPC § 1625)
- Provides that a dentist may have their license revoked or suspended or be reprimanded or be placed on probation by the DBC for unprofessional conduct, or incompetence, or gross negligence, or repeated acts of negligence in their profession. (BPC § 1670)
- Enumerates various acts constituting unprofessional conduct by licensed dentists, which includes failure by the treating dentist, prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances, to perform an examination to establish a patient of record, including the review of the patient’s most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia; new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging are required to be ordered if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist. (BPC § 1680)
- Defines “patient of record” as a patient who has been examined, has had a medical and dental history completed and evaluated, and has had oral conditions diagnosed and a written plan developed by the licensed dentist. (BPC § 1684.5)
THIS BILL:
- Specifies that the required examination by a treating dentist of a patient prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances must be conducted in-person.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author:
AB 1998 bans dangerous and harmful teleorthodontics by effectively prohibiting direct-to-consumer dental aligner products until legislation is passed to inform consumers and establish parameters for how teleorthodontics companies may operate. California is proud to be the incubator of innovation—but we cannot sacrifice patient health and safety in exchange for making billionaires out of tech bros. The industry should view AB 1998 as a sign that the Legislature is serious about requiring meaningful safeguards if these questionable and controversial business practices are allowed to continue.
Background.
During the DBC’s comprehensive sunset review, which began in late 2018, the Assembly and Senate Business and Professions committees uncovered troubling practices within the growing field of direct-to-consumer orthodontics. The DBC’s sunset background paper discussed the issue of whether certain self-applied consumer products relating to dentistry raise any public protection concerns. Specifically, Issue #8 of the background paper stated:
Within the many professions and occupations regulated in California, the advent of new technologies has enhanced access and ease for service to consumers. Dentistry and oral health is no exception, and individuals seeking a “better smile” are able to participate in a growing marketplace for products enabling consumers to improve their oral health and appearance from the comfort of their homes. Like with all services contained within the scope of a profession licensed by the state, however, there is benefit to analyzing the balance of convenience and any potential risk of consumer harm. …
[A] growing market for self-applied dental treatments is in the field of orthodontia. Several companies offer aligners that can be customized for the consumer at either a boutique storefront or through an at-home kit mailed to the customer. Through these products, an individual is able to realign the positioning of their teeth into what they believe will be a straighter smile. While companies offering such products describe the mailed aligners as being “reviewed” by a dental professional through the use of remote tele-dentistry, it is possible for a consumer to go through the realignment process without ever actually consulting with a licensed dentist. This may be cause for some concern in light of reported incidents where teeth have been misaligned when using at-home aligners. Dental boards in other states have begun to take action against the marketers of such products, and ongoing litigation has resulted. …
The DBC has stated that it will be “looking closely at tele-dentistry statutes to determine if corporations are interpreting the law too broadly, or whether the DBC should seek statutory language to narrow the application of tele-dentistry in order to ensure public protection.” The DBC has also stated that it will be “gathering background information on the newly recognized specialty of dental radiology to determine whether utilizing dental radiologists, outside the state, would be considered unlicensed activity.” These inquiries by the DBC may ultimately resolve questions about self-applied treatments.
Over the months that followed the publication of the DBC’s sunset background paper, the committees held public hearings and consulted with regulators and health experts to determine whether the risks associated with arms-length treatment of malalignment outweighed the benefits to consumers to an extent that statutory change was warranted. The committees ultimately determined that one significant public protection would be codifying the requirement that a patient’s radiographs (or x-rays) be reviewed by the treating dentist prior to approving a treatment plan for corrective aligners.
Prior to the advent of telehealth technologies, there had never been any question that appropriate orthodontic treatment include diagnostic review of a patient’s teeth. Even the mildest adjustment can result in serious patient harm if there is insufficient examination of a patient’s oral health and bone structure. For example, loose or cracked teeth, shortening of teeth roots, gum recession and bone loss, a misaligned bite, and tooth loss can all result from orthodontic care provided without adequate review. The evaluation of radiographs may reveal serious conditions like periodontal disease, root issues, and oral cancer that can make any degree of alignment exceptionally hazardous.
A month after language requiring the review of radiographs was amended into the DBC’s sunset vehicle as part of the standard sunset process, several major companies came out in opposition to the bill. One in particular, which represented the largest market share and was anticipating the launch of its Initial Public Offering, indicated that its business model relied heavily on limited examination of a patient by its treating dentists. Instead of conducting any of its own clinical evaluations, this company required each of its customers to sign a “Healthy Teeth & Gums Acknowledgement” as part of a lengthy informed consent agreement, with the patient making various self-certifications including the following:
- “My dentist took x-rays of my teeth.”
- “My dentist checked my x-rays and I have no shortened or resorbed roots.”
- “My dentist checked my x-rays I have no impacted teeth.”
In essence, the company relies on its patients to affirm that a different, unaffiliated dentist had performed an examination and determined that none of the risk factors associated with orthodontia were present. The company never engages directly with any dentist who had evaluated the patient’s health. Instead, it states in its acknowledgement that “it is your responsibility to see a dentist to verify that your teeth and gums healthy” prior to using the company’s aligners.
Ironically, the company’s core argument against the provisions in the DBC sunset were assertions that it would result in excessive radiographs being taken. Nothing in the bill required practices beyond what the company already required in its informed consent agreement – that a dentist take x-rays of the patient’s teeth prior to treatment. The only new requirement would be that the x-rays would have to be provided to the company’s treating dentist for review to confirm that none of the risk conditions were present.
The DBC’s sunset bill was ultimately passed unanimously and signed into law with radiograph requirements included. However, it immediately became apparent that more reform was potentially necessary. In the months following the DBC’s sunset review, various investigative reports were published shining light onto additional practices by teleorthodontics companies.
In January of 2020, the New York Times published a lengthy exposé titled “This Company Says It Will Fix Your Smile. It May Shush You if It Doesn’t.”[1] The article revealed that the largest teleorthodontics company—and the primary opposition to the DBC sunset bill provisions—“has been the subject of more than 1,670 Better Business Bureau complaints since 2014,” a number overwhelmingly larger than similarly situated aligner companies operating outside of the telehealth market. Complaints feature stories of cracked teeth, migraines, jaw pain, improper bites, and other treatment issues.
The New York Times article also investigated how the company required patients to sign a confidentiality agreement as a condition of receiving a refund. This agreement generally prohibited the patient from posting negative social media comments or other public criticisms. Even more alarmingly, the agreement required the patient to pledge that they would not file a complaint of any kind, which was interpreted to include complaints to regulatory boards. These kinds of limitations on complaints to the DBC were banned by additional language in the DBC’s sunset bill.
Other news outlets pursued inquiries into the company’s practices, including the Los Angeles Times[2] and Fox Business.[3] NBC News Investigates aired a segment and published an article further questioning whether the company was harming its patients as it promised to provide alignment services at reduced costs.[4] The investigation also featured the numerous complaints lodged against the company, and noted that nine members of Congress had asked the federal Food and Drug Administration and the Federal Trade Commission to investigate the company “to ensure that it is not misleading consumers or causing patient harm.” NBC News also interviewed employees of the company who admitted on camera that “anything could go wrong” as a result of treatment plans being based on nonprofessionally taken home impression kits, and aired footage showing that technicians available at retail locations informed patients that they had no need to see a dentist before undergoing treatment.
Another article published by Reuters revealed that the largest teleorthodontics company’s lead dentist “is at risk of losing his California license following a two-year state dental board investigation.”[5] A formal 24-page complaint filed by the DBC accused the lead dentist of “violating state law, defrauding state dental regulators and acting with gross negligence toward patients while helping [the company] grow its business.” Nine causes for discipline were cited, including fraud, aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of dentistry, use of advertisements to deceive or mislead the public, treatment of patients not of record, and violations of telehealth statutes.
Prior to the DBC’s accusation, the company filed a lawsuit against its board members, arguing that its investigation into the company’s practices constituted “harassment.”[6] This lawsuit followed numerous other litigious actions filed by the company, including accusations filed against other state dental boards and professional associations. In April of 2020, a federal judge dismissed the company’s complaint; the company has indicated it intends to re-file and resume its case against the DBC.
The author argues that the repeated bad faith on behalf of the companies involved with direct-to-consumer orthodontic products and the reports of serious patient harm require policymakers to pause and reconsider if, and how, teleorthodontics should be permitted. This bill would reset California law to a presumption that alignment treatment plans may not be approved without an in-person examination by the treating dentist until an authorizing framework is negotiated that preserves patient safety. While the provisions of the bill are arguably severe in that it would effectively ban all teleorthodontic practices in California, the author contends that this represents a necessary starting point as discussions continue between regulators and companies.
Current Related Legislation. SB 1278 (Bradford) would specify that generally accepted standards of practice that apply to a health care provider under their license also apply while providing telehealth services. This bill is pending in the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 1519 (Low, Chapter 865, Statutes of 2019) enacted the requirement that a treating dentist review radiographs or similar issues prior to approving a treatment plan for orthodontia.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The American Association of Orthodontists (AAO) and the California Association of Orthodontists (CAO) support this bill. In a joint letter, the AAO and the CAO write that “the AAO supports the requirement to perform an in-person examination prior to orthodontic treatment because it would allow the treating dentist to more fully understand what is going on beneath the gums (impacted teeth, bone loss, etc.), seek to avoid complications, and determine if patients are suitable candidates for orthodontic treatment. The AAO believes there are certain diagnoses and evaluations that can only be performed in-person or are best performed in-person (x-rays, etc.) during an examination, and the AAO believes that dental treatment, especially the movement of teeth via orthodontic treatment, should not be undertaken without sufficient diagnostic information obtained during such an examination.”
The California Dental Association (CDA) has taken a “support if amended” position on the bill. The CDA states that “this bill recognizes the severity of the patient safety risks within the direct-to-consumer orthodontic business model by effectively prohibiting these businesses from providing care to Californians until proper safeguards are established.” The CDA states that it has taken a “support if amended” position in recognition of the fact that “there is still much work to be done to ensure consumer protection.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
TechNet opposes this bill. According to Technet, “we believe statutes should affirmatively enable the use of technology to treat patients remotely and ensure that the physician-patient relationship can be established using technology.” TechNet argues that “the efficacy of teledentistry has been proven and has been reinforced across the globe during the COVID-19 crisis. Accordingly, California should not arbitrarily limit innovation and health care options during these trying times.”
The Black Small Business Association of California (BSBA) opposes this bill. The BSBA states: “If AB 1998 passes, it would reverse the gains we have made by necessarily creating arbitrary barriers to care; and millions of underserved Californians will once again be excluded from the market, by requiring an unnecessary in-person visit before receiving clear aligner therapy service through teledentistry platforms with licensed dentists and orthodontists.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
American Association of Orthodontists
California Association of Orthodontists
California Dental Association (if amended)
California Society of Periodontists (if amended)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Black Small Business Association of California
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California-Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Retailers Association
TechNet
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Griffith, Erin and Eavis, Peter. “This Company Says It Will Fix Your Smile. It May Shush You if It Doesn’t.” The New York Times, 31 Jan. 2020 https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/21/technology/smiledirectclub-smile-nda.html ↑
Appleby, Julie and Knight, Victoria. “In-home teeth straightening can save thousands. But brace yourself for the risks.” LA Times, 23 Jan. 2020 https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-01-23/teeth-straightening-boom ↑
Settembre, Jeannette. “SmileDirectClub teeth-straightening kits costing consumers more.” Fox Business, 14 Feb. 2020 https://www.foxbusiness.com/lifestyle/smiledirectclub-users-report-risks-teeth-straightening-kits ↑
Nguyen, Vicky and Dunn, Lauren. “'Things didn't feel right': Some SmileDirectClub customers report problems.” NBC News, 13 Feb. 2020 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/things-didn-t-feel-right-some-smiledirectclub-customers-report-problems-n1134056 ↑
Schneyer, Joshua. “Exclusive: SmileDirectClub’s top dentist risks losing license in California crackdown.” Reuters, 19 Feb. 2020. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-smile-dentist-exclusive/exclusive-smiledirectclubs-top-dentist-risks-losing-license-in-california-crackdown-idUSKBN20D2I6 ↑
Stinnett, Joel. “SmileDirectClub sues California board following raids on stores.” BizJournals, 18 Oct. 2019. https://www.bizjournals.com/nashville/news/2019/10/18/smiledirectclub-sues-california-board-following.html ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):