AB 2149: Food delivery platforms.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-24
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 24, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 125, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 24, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 65. Noes 6. Page 5348.). |
| Aug 28, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 28, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 34. Noes 2. Page 4399.). |
| Aug 20, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (August 18). |
| Aug 14, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 10, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 68. Noes 5. Page 4750.) |
| May 13, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 12, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 11, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (May 5). |
| Feb 27, 2020 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 11, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 12. |
| Feb 10, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | AB 2149 Gonzalez Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2149 Gonzalez By Stern | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 18, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 10, 2020 | AB 2149 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 5, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2149
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:August 14, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a food delivery platform, as defined, from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.
The Senate Amendments:
Require an express agreement between a food delivery platform and a food facility to authorize the platform to arrange for the delivery of an order, rather than requiring express written consent for the use of the food facility's menu, likeness, trademark, or intellectual property by the platform.
COMMENTS:
This bill identifies a problem that has arisen in the relationship between food delivery platforms and restaurants, which has been exacerbated by the COVID-19 crisis. As the application-based food delivery platform space becomes more competitive, many platforms have sought to expand their consumer engagement by increasing the listed establishments from which they deliver. However, many of these platforms do not establish any sort of business contract or agreement with that establishment prior to listing it, and many fail to even inform the establishment that they've been listed. These practices have resulted in several lawsuits alleging trademark infringement, most of which have been settled out of court.
Food delivery platforms argue that such listings are mutually beneficial, both driving up consumer engagement with the platform and providing free advertising and additional business to restaurants. This is undoubtedly true in some circumstances. However, this practice also creates significant accountability issues, as consumers are often unaware of whether an issue with their order results from the restaurant or the delivery service, and may not even know which one they are ordering from.
This is particularly true in light of the COVID-19 crisis, as many restaurants are either forming new relationships with platforms or are transitioning to in-house food delivery, pitting less known or accessible in-house delivery against well-known platforms who offer the same service at different prices. Facing severe economic hardship, many small restaurants lack the staff capacity and logistical resources to transition from primarily dine-in operations to in-house managed delivery services. Nonetheless, with dine-in service at most establishments on indefinite hiatus, restaurants and food delivery platforms are competing to provide increasingly similar services. This coalescence limits the ability of consumers to determine whether a delivery order is being fulfilled by the restaurant or by a delivery platform, rendering it essential to clarify the relationship, or lack thereof, between the two. An equitable and mutually beneficial relationship between food facilities and food delivery platforms is critical for the recovery of the foodservice industry following the COVID-19 crisis. This bill seeks to mitigate allegedly misleading tactics by food delivery platforms that may harm the restaurant industry.
By requiring a food delivery platform to secure the food facility before arranging for the delivery of an order from that food facility, this bill would likely reduce consumer confusion over business relationships between restaurants and platforms, since a listing would imply that a relationship exists.
According to the Author:
At a time when small restaurants are facing severe financial constraints, food delivery companies appear to be capitalizing on the COVID-19 crisis for their own gain. […] [T]his bill would require food delivery companies to have an agreement in place with a restaurant prior to listing them on their platforms. Restaurants that would like to engage in business with these delivery companies would do so on a level playing field, as opposed to the current practice where they compete with other restaurants that do not pay commissions or other fees as a result of a lack of an agreement. Furthermore, those restaurants that do not wish to engage in business with delivery companies will not have their restaurants listed on a platform without their consent, which prevents restaurants from connecting with their customers and ensuring the quality of the service the restaurant provides.
Arguments in Support:
The California Restaurant Association, which represents the restaurant and foodservice industry, argues:
Over the past couple of years there has been an alarming trend of food delivery platforms listing a restaurant's logo or menu without permission from the restaurant. This type of business practice may help food delivery apps drive traffic to their platform and generate commissions but for restaurants it creates confusion, hurts their brand, and disrupts operations. […] When a food delivery platform uses a restaurant's logo or menu it implies to the consumer that a partnership exists between the two entities. […] We believe all food delivery platforms should commit to partnerships that are mutually beneficial. When a food delivery platform uses a restaurant's logo or menu without their permission the benefit to the food delivery platform outweighs any potential benefit of expanding a restaurant's customer base. This bill will help restore equity back into the relationship.
The California Labor Federation adds:
Most third-party delivery companies are large, well-capitalized and national, which forces small, local restaurants to agree to their conditions. Restaurants have to agree to pay the delivery company a commission on the sale – often up to 30-percent of the sales price […] Additionally…some restaurants are listed by a food delivery platform without their knowledge.
While restaurants employ staff directly, providing benefits and protections such as workers' compensation, paid sick days, unemployment insurance, minimum wage, and many more, many third-party delivery platforms misclassify their workers as independent contractors, further rigging the playing field in their favor. Delivery companies shirk their responsibility, increasing their profits and market share, while shifting the cost of benefits onto employers and taxpayers. This is just one of the many tools they use to take advantage of restaurants, who provide jobs with actual protections to their workers. […] AB 2149 takes steps to start to level the playing field by prohibiting delivery companies from listing restaurants on their platform without an existing agreement.
Arguments in Opposition:
Internet Association and TechNet, two organizations representing the interests of businesses in the tech industry, argue:
AB 2149 will harm restaurants, consumers, and food delivery platforms at a time when more customers and restaurants need these platforms to safely weather the COVID-19 global pandemic. […] The requirements of AB 2149 could cut many struggling family-operated restaurants off from delivery as restaurants will be removed from platforms until an affirmative contract can be signed. This lapse could be disastrous for restaurants simply trying to keep the doors open by offering take-out as frustrated customers may permanently turn to competitors while contract details get negotiated.
Furthermore, as restaurants across California closed their doors to dine-in customers, many turned to food delivery platforms to offer delivery service, maintain operations, and make payroll. Some restaurants prefer the flexibility of their current arrangements with food delivery platforms as the advertising exposure and the increased business the platforms provide is highly valuable without having to be locked into a contract. Our platforms have provided critical lifelines, connecting customers with their restaurant of choice.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-2-0
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Medina, Carrillo, Mullin, Gallagher, Irwin, Wicks
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-5-6
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Choi, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Chen, Megan Dahle, Flora, Gray, Quirk
SENATE FLOOR: 34-2-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Melendez, Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Galgiani, Jones, Nielsen, Umberg
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 14, 2020
CONSULTANT: Landon Klein / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0003579
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2149 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2149
Author: Gonzalez (D)
Amended: 8/14/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-1, 8/18/20
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Melendez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-5, 6/10/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Food delivery platforms
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a food delivery platform from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which provides a statutory cause of action for any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, including over the internet. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Retail Food Code (Health & Saf. Code § 113700 et seq.) to safeguard public health and provide to consumers food that is safe, unadulterated, and honestly presented through adoption of science-based standards. (Id. at § 113703.)
This bill:
- Establishes the Fair Food Delivery Act of 2020.
- Defines a “food delivery platform” as an online business that acts as an intermediary between consumers and multiple food facilities to submit food orders from a consumer to a participating food facility, and to arrange for the delivery of the order from the food facility to the consumer.
- Incorporates the existing definition of “food facility” in Health and Safety Code section 113789, which generally defines that term as an operation that stores, prepares, serves, vends, or otherwise provides food for human consumption at the retail level, including (1) an operation where food is consumed on or off the premises, regardless of whether there is a charge for the food, and (2) a place used in conjunction with the operations described in the subdivision, including storage facilities for food-related utensils, equipment, and materials.
- Prohibits a food delivery platform from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.
Background
- Food delivery services. Shelter-in-place orders and social distancing practices in response to the COVID-19 pandemic have devastated the restaurant industry and made consumers increasingly reliant on food delivery options. The California Restaurant Association, which supports the bill, writes:
Restaurants are facing an unprecedented crisis. According a recent survey, the National Restaurant Association estimates that more than 1 million restaurant employees in California have been laid off or furloughed since the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak in March. In the month of April, estimated revenue losses for the food service industry is over $6 billion. At the same time food delivery platforms are experiencing unprecedented growth as consumers are required to stay at home as a matter of public health.
Third party app-based food delivery companies, such as DoorDash, PostMates, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, offer the promise of convenient access to a variety of restaurants through a single service. This service can help restaurants by increasing sales, notoriety, and customer bases.
However, many restaurateurs, particularly proprietors of small independent restaurants, claim that food delivery companies have added to their struggles. Food delivery services typically charge restaurants a hefty commission—often up to 30 percent of the sales price—and may also charge the customer service fees.[1] In an industry known for its thin profit margins, this impact to revenues can be a formidable barrier to sustained financial viability. Many restaurants use their own online ordering and delivery systems to ensure quality control and cost-effectiveness. Boutique restaurants may lack the capacity to absorb extra orders and may be unwilling to risk entrusting an unknown, unregulated third party to handle an order properly and deliver it promptly.
In some cases, food delivery services have included menus on their apps without the restaurant’s consent or knowledge.[2] “[I]n those situations the company tasks the driver with ordering food ahead of time or at the restaurant before delivery.”[3] The California Travel Association, in support, writes that if a restaurant is not aware that their food is being offered for delivery via a third-party app, it “can lead to an array of problems—long delivery times, diminished food quality, and potential food safety impacts—that all reflect back on the restaurant.”
Some jurisdictions have taken action to regulate food delivery companies. Seattle, Washington D.C., and New York limit the commissions that food delivery platforms may charge.[4] Rhode Island’s legislature introduced a bill that would provide a private right of action for a merchant whose likeness, registered trademark, or intellectual property is used by a third-party delivery service without express written consent of the merchant. The House Corporations Committee has held that bill for further study.
In California, AB 1360 (Ting, 2019) and AB 3336 (Carrillo, 2020) would establish food-handling requirements for people who provide food delivery services. AB 1360 is on the Senate inactive file; AB 3336 is pending on the Senate Floor.
- Unlawful business practice. Business and Professions Code section 17200 prohibits unfair competition, including unlawful, unfair, and fraudulent business acts. The UCL covers a wide range of conduct, making any business practice prohibited by law independently actionable as an unfair competitive practice. (Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. ProjectCBD.com (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 869, 896, citing Korea Supply Co. v. Lockheed Martin Corp. (2003) 29 Cal.4th 1134, 1143.) However, “a practice may violate the UCL even if it is not prohibited by another statute. Unfair and fraudulent practices are alternate grounds for relief.” (Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. ProjectCBD.com, supra, 46 Cal.App.5th at 896, quoting Zhang v. Superior Court (2013) 57 Cal.4th 364, 370 [citations and nested quotation marks omitted].)
The UCL provides that a court “may make such orders or judgments . . . as may be necessary to restore to any person in interest any money or property, real or personal, which may have been acquired by means of such unfair competition.” (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17203.) The law also permits courts to award injunctive relief and, in certain cases, to assess civil penalties against the violator. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17203, 17206.) Pursuant to Proposition 64 (2004), the UCL provides that a person may bring an action for an injunction or restitution if the person “has suffered injury in fact and has lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition.” (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17204.)
This bill requires that food delivery platforms—defined as online businesses that act as intermediaries between consumers and food facilities to submit food orders and arrange for their delivery—obtain an express written agreement with a restaurant before arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility. This is not a requirement that a contract be executed; it is simply a requirement that consent be obtained and documented. No particular formalities are required. A violation of the bill’s requirements would constitute an unlawful business practice for purposes of the UCL.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Labor Federation
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association
Small Business Majority
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
Internet Association
TechNet
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author argues that the bill will level the playing field for mom-and-pop restaurants that risk losing their customers if they do not agree to the conditions of large tech companies.
The Small Business Majority writes:
AB 2149 will benefit California small business owners during this difficult time by requiring food delivery companies to enter into an agreement with the restaurant owner that clearly and transparently outlines the terms and fees associated with being listed on the platform without the owner’s consent. This bill will protect California’s restauranteurs from the “race to the bottom approach typically associated with agreements not made in good faith.
The California Restaurant Association writes:
In some cases, restaurants already have a delivery system in place operated by their own employees. If their menu is listed on an unauthorized food delivery platform, then it creates massive confusion for both the restaurant and the delivery driver who shows up. The customer, driver, and restaurant end up losing because the customer does not get their food, the driver does not get paid, and the restaurant’s reputation is damaged.
They continue:
[…] Not all food delivery platforms are taking such aggressive tactics to grow their business. Some food delivery platforms are true partners with restaurants. We believe all food delivery platforms should commit to partnerships that are mutually beneficial. … This bill will help restore equity back into the relationship.
The California Labor Federation writes that “[m]ost third party delivery companies are large, well-capitalized and national, which forces small local restaurants to agree to their conditions.” They continue:
While restaurants employ staff directly, providing benefits and protections such as workers’ compensation, paid sick days, unemployment insurance, minimum wage, and many more, many third-party delivery platforms misclassify their workers as independent contractors, further rigging the playing field in their favor. Delivery companies shirk their responsibilities, increasing profits and market share, while shifting the cost of benefits onto employers and taxpayers. This is just one of the many tools they use to take advantage of restaurants, who provide jobs with actual protections to their workers.
This imbalance creates problems for restaurants. Restaurants lose contact with their customers and the opportunity to market to them, solicit feedback, or address issues. Some restaurants do not even know they are listed on a delivery platform and have no way to connect with customers or track their business. In the event a restaurant objects to commission increases, or stops doing business with a delivery company, these food delivery platforms can undercut restaurants by re-directing customers to a competing business or “ghost kitchen.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Internet Association and TechNet jointly write:
AB 2149 will harm restaurants, consumers, and food delivery platforms at a time when more customers and restaurants need these platforms to safely weather the COVID-19 global pandemic. As currently drafted, AB 2149 would require restaurants to enter into a contract with a food delivery platform before they can offer delivery through the platform. But today, many restaurants prefer to have options when it comes to food delivery platforms; AB 2149 would limit those choices.
The requirements of AB 2149 could cut many struggling family-operated restaurants off from delivery as restaurants will be removed from platforms until an affirmative contract can be signed. This lapse could be disastrous for restaurants simply trying to keep the doors open by offering take-out as frustrated customers may permanently turn to competitors while contract details get negotiated.
Furthermore, as restaurants across California closed their doors to dine-in customers, many turned to food delivery platforms to offer delivery service, maintain operations, and make payroll. Some restaurants prefer the flexibility of their current arrangements with food delivery platforms as the advertising exposure and the increased business the platforms provide is highly valuable without having to be locked into a contract. Our platforms have provided critical lifelines, connecting customers with their restaurant of choice.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-5, 6/10/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Choi, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chen, Megan Dahle, Flora, Gray, Quirk
Prepared by: Josh Tosney / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/21/20 18:16:30
**** END ****
For the top five food delivery platforms, total markups range from 17 percent to 40.5 percent of the restaurant’s list price. (Noah Lichtenstein, The hidden cost of food delivery, TechCrunch (Mar. 16, 2020) https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/16/the-hidden-cost-of-food-delivery/
(as of Aug. 14, 2020).) ↑
Janelle Bitker & Shwanika Narayan, Grubhub, DoorDash rush to add restaurants. Customers and drivers pay the price (Feb. 2, 2020) San Francisco Chronicle, available at https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Grubhub-DoorDash-rush-to-add-restaurants-15023372.php (as of Aug. 2, 2020). ↑
Garrett Snyder, Grubhub and other delivery apps face backlash over unauthorized restaurant listings (March 11, 2020) Los Angeles Times, available at https://www.latimes.com/food/story/2020-03-11/grubhub-delivery-app-backlash (as of Aug. 14, 2020). ↑
Bobby Allyn, Restaurants Are Desperate—But You May Not Be Helping When You Use Delivery Apps (May 14, 2020) NPR website, available at https://www.npr.org/2020/05/14/856444431/cities-crack-down-on-food-delivery-app-fees-as-restaurants-struggle-to-survive (as of Aug. 2, 2020). ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2149 (Author:Gonzalez)
Version: August 14, 2020
Hearing Date: August 18, 2020
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Food delivery platforms
DIGEST
This bill prohibits a food delivery platform from arranging for delivery of an order from a food facility without the food facility’s consent.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The COVID-19 pandemic has decimated the restaurant industry. Approximately four in 10 restaurants have closed, and it is estimated that anywhere from 20 to 80 percent will close permanently.[1] Although third party app-based food delivery companies such as DoorDash, PostMates, Uber Eats, and Grubhub can conveniently connect restaurants with customers who shelter at home, they can be costly and a poor fit for some restaurants. But some restaurants that have refused to enter into agreements with food delivery companies have discovered that they are listed regardless, overwhelming their operations, creating quality and safety problems, and eroding their customer bases.
This bill would prohibit a food delivery platform from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility. The author argues that this will level the playing field for mom-and-pop restaurants that risk losing their customers if they do not agree to the conditions of large tech companies. The bill is author-sponsored and supported by California Labor Federation, California Restaurant Association, California Travel Association, and Small Business Majority. It is opposed by Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Internet Association, and TechNet.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which provides a statutory cause of action for any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, including over the internet. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Retail Food Code (Health & Saf. Code § 113700 et seq.) to safeguard public health and provide to consumers food that is safe, unadulterated, and honestly presented through adoption of science-based standards. (Id. at § 113703.)
This bill:
- Establishes the Fair Food Delivery Act of 2020.
- Defines a “food delivery platform” as an online business that acts as an intermediary between consumers and multiple food facilities to submit food orders from a consumer to a participating food facility, and to arrange for the delivery of the order from the food facility to the consumer.
- Incorporates the existing definition of “food facility” in Health and Safety Code section 113789, which generally defines that term as an operation that stores, prepares, serves, vends, or otherwise provides food for human consumption at the retail level, including (1) an operation where food is consumed on or off the premises, regardless of whether there is a charge for the food, and (2) a place used in conjunction with the operations described in the subdivision, including storage facilities for food-related utensils, equipment, and materials.
- Prohibits a food delivery platform from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.
COMMENTS
- Food delivery services
Shelter-in-place orders and social distancing practices in response to the COVID-19 pandemic have devastated the restaurant industry and made consumers increasingly reliant on food delivery options. The California Restaurant Association, which supports the bill, writes:
Restaurants are facing an unprecedented crisis. According a recent survey, the National Restaurant Association estimates that more than 1 million restaurant employees in California have been laid off or furloughed since the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak in March. In the month of April, estimated revenue losses for the food service industry is over $6 billion. At the same time food delivery platforms are experiencing unprecedented growth as consumers are required to stay at home as a matter of public health.
Third party app-based food delivery companies, such as DoorDash, PostMates, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, offer the promise of convenient access to a variety of restaurants through a single service. This service can help restaurants by increasing sales, notoriety, and customer bases.
However, many restaurateurs, particularly proprietors of small independent restaurants, claim that food delivery companies have added to their struggles. Food delivery services typically charge restaurants a hefty commission—often up to 30 percent of the sales price—and may also charge the customer service fees.[2] In an industry known for its thin profit margins, this impact to revenues can be a formidable barrier to sustained financial viability. Many restaurants use their own online ordering and delivery systems to ensure quality control and cost-effectiveness. Boutique restaurants may lack the capacity to absorb extra orders and may be unwilling to risk entrusting an unknown, unregulated third party to handle an order properly and deliver it promptly.
In some cases, food delivery services have included menus on their apps without the restaurant’s consent or knowledge.[3] “[I]n those situations the company tasks the driver with ordering food ahead of time or at the restaurant before delivery.”[4] The California Travel Association, in support, writes that if a restaurant is not aware that their food is being offered for delivery via a third-party app, it “can lead to an array of problems—long delivery times, diminished food quality, and potential food safety impacts—that all reflect back on the restaurant.”
Some jurisdictions have taken action to regulate food delivery companies. Seattle, Washington D.C., and New York limit the commissions that food delivery platforms may charge.[5] Rhode Island’s legislature introduced a bill that would provide a private right of action for a merchant whose likeness, registered trademark, or intellectual property is used by a third-party delivery service without express written consent of the merchant. The House Corporations Committee has held that bill for further study.
In California, AB 1360 (Ting, 2019) and AB 3336 (Carrillo, 2020) would establish food-handling requirements for people who provide food delivery services. AB 1360 is on the Senate inactive file; AB 3336 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- Unlawful business practice
Business and Professions Code section 17200 prohibits unfair competition, including unlawful, unfair, and fraudulent business acts. The UCL covers a wide range of conduct, making any business practice prohibited by law independently actionable as an unfair competitive practice. (Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. ProjectCBD.com (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 869, 896, citing Korea Supply Co. v. Lockheed Martin Corp. (2003) 29 Cal.4th 1134, 1143.) However, “a practice may violate the UCL even if it is not prohibited by another statute. Unfair and fraudulent practices are alternate grounds for relief.” (Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. ProjectCBD.com, supra, 46 Cal.App.5th at 896, quoting Zhang v. Superior Court (2013) 57 Cal.4th 364, 370 [citations and nested quotation marks omitted].)
The UCL provides that a court “may make such orders or judgments . . . as may be necessary to restore to any person in interest any money or property, real or personal, which may have been acquired by means of such unfair competition.” (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17203.) The law also permits courts to award injunctive relief and, in certain cases, to assess civil penalties against the violator. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17203, 17206.) Pursuant to Proposition 64 (2004), the UCL provides that a person may bring an action for an injunction or restitution if the person “has suffered injury in fact and has lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition.” (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17204.)
This bill would require that food delivery platforms—defined as online businesses that act as intermediaries between consumers and food facilities to submit food orders and arrange for their delivery—obtain the express written consent of a restaurant before arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility. A violation of the bill’s requirements would constitute an unlawful business practice for purposes of the UCL.
The author argues that the bill will level the playing field for mom-and-pop restaurants that risk losing their customers if they do not agree to the conditions of large tech companies. In support, the Small Business Majority writes:
AB 2149 will benefit California small business owners during this difficult time by requiring food delivery companies to enter into an agreement with the restaurant owner that clearly and transparently outlines the terms and fees associated with being listed on the platform without the owner’s consent. This bill will protect California’s restauranteurs from the “race to the bottom approach typically associated with agreements not made in good faith.
- Support
The California Restaurant Association writes:
In some cases, restaurants already have a delivery system in place operated by their own employees. If their menu is listed on an unauthorized food delivery platform, then it creates massive confusion for both the restaurant and the delivery driver who shows up. The customer, driver, and restaurant end up losing because the customer does not get their food, the driver does not get paid, and the restaurant’s reputation is damaged.
They continue:
[…] Not all food delivery platforms are taking such aggressive tactics to grow their business. Some food delivery platforms are true partners with restaurants. We believe all food delivery platforms should commit to partnerships that are mutually beneficial. … This bill will help restore equity back into the relationship.
The California Labor Federation writes that “[m]ost third party delivery companies are large, well-capitalized and national, which forces small local restaurants to agree to their conditions.” They continue:
While restaurants employ staff directly, providing benefits and protections such as workers’ compensation, paid sick days, unemployment insurance, minimum wage, and many more, many third-party delivery platforms misclassify their workers as independent contractors, further rigging the playing field in their favor. Delivery companies shirk their responsibilities, increasing profits and market share, while shifting the cost of benefits onto employers and taxpayers. This is just one of the many tools they use to take advantage of restaurants, who provide jobs with actual protections to their workers.
This imbalance creates problems for restaurants. Restaurants lose contact with their customers and the opportunity to market to them, solicit feedback, or address issues. Some restaurants do not even know they are listed on a delivery platform and have no way to connect with customers or track their business. In the event a restaurant objects to commission increases, or stops doing business with a delivery company, these food delivery platforms can undercut restaurants by re-directing customers to a competing business or “ghost kitchen.”
- Opposition
The Internet Association and TechNet jointly write:
AB 2149 will harm restaurants, consumers, and food delivery platforms at a time when more customers and restaurants need these platforms to safely weather the COVID-19 global pandemic. As currently drafted, AB 2149 would require restaurants to enter into a contract with a food delivery platform before they can offer delivery through the platform. But today, many restaurants prefer to have options when it comes to food delivery platforms; AB 2149 would limit those choices.
The requirements of AB 2149 could cut many struggling family-operated restaurants off from delivery as restaurants will be removed from platforms until an affirmative contract can be signed. This lapse could be disastrous for restaurants simply trying to keep the doors open by offering take-out as frustrated customers may permanently turn to competitors while contract details get negotiated.
Furthermore, as restaurants across California closed their doors to dine-in customers, many turned to food delivery platforms to offer delivery service, maintain operations, and make payroll. Some restaurants prefer the flexibility of their current arrangements with food delivery platforms as the advertising exposure and the increased business the platforms provide is highly valuable without having to be locked into a contract. Our platforms have provided critical lifelines, connecting customers with their restaurant of choice.
The requirement that the restaurant’s consent be granted in writing is not a requirement that an actual binding contract be executed. It is simply a requirement that the platform, before profiting off a restaurant’s business, get its consent and document it. This is a common requirement that is generally not viewed as onerous. A one-line email could suffice. And while a mass removal of restaurants from food delivery platforms is technically possible, the bill, should it become law, would likely be signed in September but would not become effective until January 1, 2021. This provides three months for delivery platforms, as well as restaurants that want to continue using their services, to proactively address the issue. In fact, nothing prevents the platforms from seeking consent now; some platforms already do this. Furthermore, given their penchant for dynamic and creative use of technology, the delivery platforms may be especially well suited to the task. That said, going forward the author may wish to consider expressly addressing what happens when a restaurant wishes to revoke its consent; if they can do so at any time, then a reasonable grace period for compliance may be appropriate.
The Internet Association and TechNet additionally write that the bill’s incorporation of the definition of “food facility” in Health and Safety Code section 113789 will cause it to apply to a broader array of entities than intended. That provision generally defines that term as an operation that stores, prepares, serves, vends, or otherwise provides food for human consumption at the retail level, including (1) an operation where food is consumed on or off the premises, regardless of whether there is a charge for the food, and (2) a place used in conjunction with the operations described in the subdivision, including storage facilities for food-related utensils, equipment, and materials. Going forward, the author may wish to ensure this definition fits the bill’s aims.
Finally, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, writing about the prior version of the bill, raises concerns relating to trademark, copyright, and freedom of speech. The prior version of the bill would have prohibited a food delivery platform from posting a menu of, or otherwise using the likeness, registered trademark, or intellectual property belonging to, a food facility without the express written consent of the food facility. However, the author recently amended the bill to omit aspects relating to intellectual property and instead directly prohibit platforms from arranging for the delivery of orders from a restaurant without its consent. Thus the bill is now a straightforward regulation of an abusive business practice and no longer implicates the issues raised by Electronic Frontier Foundation.
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association
Small Business Majority
OPPOSITION
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Internet Association
TechNet
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 3336 (Carrillo, 2020) revises the California Retail Food Code to require a person who delivers food for a third-party delivery system to obtain a food handler card and to comply with specific requirements when delivering ready-to-eat food from a food facility to a consumer. The bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1360 (Ting, 2019) would have required food delivery platforms to ensure that their drivers had training relating to maintaining potentially hazardous foods at required temperatures and maintained liability insurance covering liabilities arising from the use of a vehicle in connection with providing food delivery services. This bill is currently on the inactive file on the Senate Floor.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 68, Noes 5)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 2)
**************
National Restaurant Association, Letter to Congress (Apr. 20, 2020), available at https://restaurant.org/downloads/pdfs/business/covid19-letter-to-house-senate-leaders.pdf (as of Aug. 14, 2020); Matt Goulding, An Extinction Event for America’s Restaurants (June 19, 2020) The Atlantic, available at https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2020/06/what-will-happen-restaurants/613141/ (as of Aug. 2, 2020). ↑
For the top five food delivery platforms, total markups range from 17 percent to 40.5 percent of the restaurant’s list price. (Noah Lichtenstein, The hidden cost of food delivery, TechCrunch (Mar. 16, 2020) https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/16/the-hidden-cost-of-food-delivery/
(as of Aug. 14, 2020).) ↑
Janelle Bitker & Shwanika Narayan, Grubhub, DoorDash rush to add restaurants. Customers and drivers pay the price (Feb. 2, 2020) San Francisco Chronicle, available at https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Grubhub-DoorDash-rush-to-add-restaurants-15023372.php (as of Aug. 2, 2020). ↑
Garrett Snyder, Grubhub and other delivery apps face backlash over unauthorized restaurant listings (March 11, 2020) Los Angeles Times, available at https://www.latimes.com/food/story/2020-03-11/grubhub-delivery-app-backlash (as of Aug. 14, 2020). ↑
Bobby Allyn, Restaurants Are Desperate—But You May Not Be Helping When You Use Delivery Apps (May 14, 2020) NPR website, available at https://www.npr.org/2020/05/14/856444431/cities-crack-down-on-food-delivery-app-fees-as-restaurants-struggle-to-survive (as of Aug. 2, 2020). ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2149
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:May 12, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a food delivery platform from posting a menu of, or otherwise using the likeness, registered trademark, or any intellectual property belonging to, a food facility without the express written consent of the food facility.
COMMENTS:
This bill identifies a problem that has arisen in the relationship between food delivery platforms and restaurants, which has been exacerbated by the COVID-19 crisis. As the application-based food delivery platform space becomes more competitive, many platforms have sought to expand their consumer engagement by increasing the listed establishments from which they deliver. However, many of these platforms do not establish any sort of business contract or agreement with that establishment prior to listing it, and many fail to even inform the establishment that they've been listed. These practices have resulted in several lawsuits alleging trademark infringement, most of which have been settled out of court.
Food delivery platforms argue that such listings are mutually beneficial, both driving up consumer engagement with the platform and providing free advertising and additional business to restaurants. This is undoubtedly true in some circumstances. However, this practice also creates significant accountability issues, as consumers are often unaware of whether an issue with their order results from the restaurant or the delivery service, and may not even know which one they are ordering from.
This is particularly true in light of the COVID-19 crisis, as many restaurants are either forming new relationships with platforms or are transitioning to in-house food delivery, pitting less known or accessible in-house delivery against well-known platforms who offer the same service at different prices. Facing severe economic hardship, many small restaurants lack the staff capacity and logistical resources to transition from primarily dine-in operations to in-house managed delivery services. Nonetheless, with dine-in service on indefinite hiatus, restaurants and food delivery platforms are competing to provide increasingly similar services. This coalescence limits the ability of consumers to determine whether a delivery order is being fulfilled by the restaurant or by a delivery platform, rendering it essential to clarify the relationship, or lack thereof, between the two. An equitable and mutually beneficial relationship between food facilities and food delivery platforms is critical for the recovery of the foodservice industry following the COVID-19 crisis. This bill seeks to mitigate allegedly misleading tactics by food delivery platforms that may harm the restaurant industry.
By requiring a food delivery platform to obtain the express written consent of a food facility before using its menu, likeness, trademark, or other intellectual property, this bill would likely reduce consumer confusion over business relationships between restaurants and platforms, since a listing would imply that a relationship exists.
According to the Author:
At a time when small restaurants are facing severe financial constraints, food delivery companies appear to be capitalizing on the COVID-19 crisis for their own gain. […] [T]his bill would require food delivery companies to have an agreement in place with a restaurant prior to listing them on their platforms. Restaurants that would like to engage in business with these delivery companies would do so on a level playing field, as opposed to the current practice where they compete with other restaurants that do not pay commissions or other fees as a result of a lack of an agreement. Furthermore, those restaurants that do not wish to engage in business with delivery companies will not have their restaurants listed on a platform without their consent, which prevents restaurants from connecting with their customers and ensuring the quality of the service the restaurant provides.
Arguments in Support:
The California Restaurant Association argues:
Over the past couple of years there has been an alarming trend of food delivery platforms listing a restaurant's logo or menu without permission from the restaurant. This type of business practice may help food delivery apps drive traffic to their platform, but for restaurants it creates confusion, hurts their brand, and disrupts operations.
In some cases, restaurants already have a delivery system in place operated by their own employees. If their menu is listed on an unauthorized food delivery platform, then it creates massive confusion for both the restaurant and the delivery driver who shows up. The customer, driver, and restaurant end up losing because the customer does not get their food, the driver does not get paid, and the restaurant's reputation is damaged. In other instances, a food delivery platform might post an outdated menu or logo. The chances are if a customer is using an outdated menu, then there will be issues with the food order leading to more confusion with the customer and restaurant.
Arguments in Opposition:
The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which has adopted an "oppose unless amended position," argues:
This [bill] raises significant legal issues. With respect to trademark use, the requirement of "express written consent" clearly conflicts with Ninth Circuit case law that authorizes "nominative fair use." In general, such use is permitted if using the trademark is reasonably necessary to identify the products, services, or company that one is talking about, and the user doesn't use the mark to suggest the company endorses the user.
It also presents preemption problems. The Copyright Act expressly provides that "the fair use of a copyrighted work…is not an infringement of copyright." 17 U.S.C. § 107. To the extent your amendment would require "express written consent" for the use of any work protected by copyright held by a food facility, is [sic] would be preempted by federal law.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None. This bill has been keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-2-0
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Medina, Carrillo, Mullin, Gallagher, Irwin, Wicks
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 12, 2020
CONSULTANT: Landon Klein / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0002758
Date of Hearing: May 5, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2149 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 10, 2020
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SUBJECT: Food delivery platforms
SUMMARY: The bill in print would require a food delivery platform, upon request, to share the contact information of consumers that have purchased food from a food facility with that facility. As proposed to be amended, this bill would prohibit a food delivery platform from posting a menu, likeness, trademark or other intellectual property of a food facility without the express written consent of that facility. Specifically, as proposed to be amended, this bill would:
- Provide that a food delivery platform shall not post a menu of, or otherwise use the likeness, registered trademark, or any intellectual property belonging to, a food facility without the express written consent of the food facility.
- Define “food delivery platform” to mean an online business that acts as an intermediary between customers and multiple food facilities to submit food orders from a consumer to a participating food facility, and to arrange for the delivery of the order from the food facility to the consumer.
- Define “food facility” as it is defined in Section 113789 of the Health and Safety Code, i.e., to mean an operation that stores, prepares, packages, serves, vends, or otherwise provides food for human consumption at the retail level.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to federal law, provides that the United States Congress shall have power to promote the progress of science and useful arts by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries. (U.S. Const., art. I, sec. 8, cl. 8.)
- Pursuant to federal law, establishes the Lanham Act, which, inter alia, prohibits the use in commerce, without the consent of the registrant, of any reproduction, counterfeit, copy, or colorable imitation of a registered mark in connection with the sale, offering for sale, distribution, or advertising of any goods or services if such use is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive. (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1114(1)(a).)
- Prohibits a person from using, without the consent of the registrant, any reproduction, counterfeit, copy, or colorable imitation of a mark registered under the Model State Trademark Law in connection with the sale, distribution, offering for sale, or advertising of goods or services if such use is likely to cause confusion or mistake, or to deceive as to the source of origin of the goods or services. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 14245(a)(1).)
- Requires a publisher, prior to including a telephone number for a facsimile machine in any commercial directory of telephone numbers, to obtain the written consent of the subscriber who has been assigned the number. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22600(a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill: This bill, as proposed to be amended, seeks to prevent food delivery platforms from listing food facilities without the consent of that facility. The bill aims to rectify consumer confusion and reputational harm that a restaurant may suffer from a consumer’s mistaken inference of a business relationship between the restaurant and the platform. This bill is author sponsored.
- Author’s Statement of Criticality: In response to the unique constraints the COVID-19 crisis has placed on the legislative process, this Committee elected to focus attention this session on bills that address urgent issues and issues critical for an efficient recovery from the pandemic. In order to prioritize bills that require immediate attention, the Committee asked the author of each bill to provide a Statement of Criticality explaining the applicability of one or more of the following criteria to that bill:
- the bill addresses a problem that was created by, or has been significantly exacerbated by, the ongoing public health crisis due to COVID-19, or the response thereto;
- the bill addresses an urgent problem that presents a threat to the safety and security of Californians and must be resolved immediately; or
- the bill makes a technical change to an existing program or function that must be immediately adopted to preserve the utility of that program or function.
In response, the Author writes:
AB 2149 seeks to protect small restaurants from being undercut and exploited by food delivery platforms by establishing clear rules and guidelines that govern that relationship. In light of the statewide Stay-At-Home orders, many Californians are transitioning to online delivery in order to access food from their local, small restaurants. Prior to the COVID-19 outbreak, an increasing number of restaurants were reporting dissatisfaction and troubles in their interactions with these emerging platforms. Many small restaurants reported unauthorized listing of their business on platforms, the lack of an ability to connect with their customers and difficulty with ensuring quality of service. COVID-19 has only exacerbated these issues, with news reports demonstrating restaurants are actively rethinking their relationship with these delivery platforms.
At a time when small restaurants are facing severe financial constraints, food delivery companies appear to be capitalizing on the COVID-19 crisis for their own gain. […] [T]his bill would require food delivery companies to have an agreement in place with a restaurant prior to listing them on their platforms. Restaurants that would like to engage in business with these delivery companies would do so on a level playing field, as opposed to the current practice where they compete with other restaurants that do not pay commissions or other fees as a result of a lack of an agreement. Furthermore, those restaurants that do not wish to engage in business with delivery companies will not have their restaurants listed on a platform without their consent, which prevents restaurants from connecting with their customers and ensuring the quality of the service the restaurant provides. (Internal citations omitted.)
The Committee agrees that the issue addressed by this bill is timely and critical under the current circumstances. According to the California Restaurant Association, the restaurant industry has suffered the most significant sales and job losses of any industry since the COVID-19 outbreak began.[1] More than 8 million restaurant employees have been laid off or furloughed, and the industry lost approximately $80 billion in sales as of the end of April.[2] Coincident with the hardship faced by the restaurant industry, the use of food delivery platforms, which facilitate food orders, pick-up, and delivery from restaurants and other food facilities, has seen a marked increase as food delivery continues to accommodate a population sheltering-in-place. According to the market research firm Edison Trends, in the first week after several major cities initiated stay-at-home orders, United States consumer spending on food orders via DoorDash, UberEats, Grubhub, and Postmates, four of the top competitors in the increasingly competitive food delivery platform industry, increased by more than 10 percent relative to the previous week.[3]
Facing severe economic hardship, many small restaurants lack the staff capacity and logistical resources to transition from primarily dine-in operations to in-house managed delivery services. Nonetheless, with dine-in service on indefinite hiatus, restaurants and food delivery platforms are competing to provide increasingly similar services. This coalescence limits the ability of consumers to determine whether a delivery order is being fulfilled by the restaurant or by a delivery platform, rendering it essential to clarify the relationship, or lack thereof, between the two. The Committee recognizes that an equitable and mutually beneficial relationship between food facilities and food delivery platforms is critical for the recovery of the foodservice industry following the COVID-19 crisis. This bill, which seeks to mitigate allegedly misleading tactics by food delivery platforms that may harm the restaurant industry, thus meets the criteria of this Committee as immediately relevant to the needs of California’s businesses and residents.
- The bill in print raises significant privacy concerns: As currently in print, this bill requires a food delivery platform to, upon request, share with a food facility certain information about consumers that have purchased food from that facility through the platform, including a consumer’s email address, telephone number, and delivery address, as well as that consumer’s purchasing history with the requesting food facility. The author contends that sharing this information with the food facility is critical to permit the food facility to notify consumers of possible public health issues, to follow up with consumers for quality control, and to improve targeted consumer outreach.
Though the bill in print specifies that this data sharing provision shall not apply to the personal information (PI) of a consumer who has exercised their right to opt-out of the sale of personal information by the food delivery platform pursuant to the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (hereinafter “CCPA”; Civ. Code Sec. 1798.120), it nonetheless runs counter to the intent of the CCPA to protect consumer data from unexpected disclosure and poses significant issues for workability within the CCPA framework. Under the provisions of the bill in print, the breadth of distribution of PI that a purchase through a food delivery platform entails would be dramatically expanded. While the information shared is limited to contact information and purchasing history, these data, especially when viewed en masse, can paint a surprisingly intimate portrait of behavior presumed to be private. For instance, access to delivery address information for a specific consumer over the course of a year can potentially be used to infer the home address, workplace, and even social relationships of that consumer.
Rather than providing this sensitive information only to the platform, whose uses and sharing practices must be disclosed to the consumer pursuant to CCPA with the opportunity to opt-out, a customer utilizing a food delivery platform is instead providing their PI to the platform and every entity that platform interacts with to fulfill that customer’s order. Put simply, the customer’s information is in the hands of more entities, with little additional benefit to the consumer. Notably, this type of personal contact information is not required to be provided in the course of a normal in-person transaction with a business.
In addition to these privacy concerns, this bill also presents significant workability issues for the CCPA, which requires businesses to disclose to the consumer how their personal data will be collected, retained, used, and shared, and to conspicuously provide the consumer the opportunity to opt-out of the sharing of their information. Because the bill in print would cause the consumer’s PI to be shared with numerous facilities with whom the consumer never interacts directly, these mandatory disclosures and rights that must be provided at the point of use under CCPA may never actually be provided to the consumer for each business receiving their information. The bill in print would also make it substantially more difficult for consumers to exercise their rights under CCPA, as rather than simply requesting the nature or deletion of information maintained and shared by the platform, the consumer must instead request deletion by the platform and the platform would then be required to communicate that request to each restaurant. Staff notes that the right to deletion in the CCPA only exists between a consumer and the business that collected the information. Thus, in the situation anticipated by this bill, a restaurant would not be required to honor a consumer’s request to delete a consumer’s PI if that PI was received from the platform. Since the sharing of information is opt-out rather than opt-in, the consumer may not even be aware that their information is being shared in this manner at the time of purchase, or recall that that restaurant now possesses their PI.
Prudently, the author has acknowledged these privacy concerns, and has agreed to amend the bill to remove this mandatory disclosure of consumer data.
- Proposed amendments prohibit listing of food facilities on platforms without consent: The proposed amendments to AB 2149 replace the consumer data sharing provisions with a provision prohibiting a food delivery platform from posting a menu of, or otherwise using the likeness, registered trademark, or any intellectual property belonging to, a food facility without the express written consent of the food facility. Arguably, these amendments move the bill beyond the jurisdiction of this Committee. Nonetheless, the bill as proposed to be amended identifies a real problem that has arisen in the relationship between food delivery platforms and restaurants, which has been exacerbated by the COVID-19 crisis. As the application-based food delivery platform space becomes more competitive, many platforms have sought to expand their consumer engagement by increasing the listed establishments from which they deliver. However, many of these platforms do not establish any sort of business contract or agreement with that establishment prior to listing it, and many fail to even inform the establishment that they’ve been listed. DoorDash, PostMates, and Grubhub, three leading delivery platforms, have been documented engaging in this practice, often to dismay of the restaurant owners.[4] These practices have also resulted in several lawsuits alleging trademark infringement, most of which have been settled out of court.[5] Grubhub has reportedly gone a step further, registering several web domains including the names of restaurants or variations on those names without informing or requesting consent from those restaurants, and using those URLs to arrange orders from those restaurants through their platform.[6]
These food delivery platforms argue that these listings are mutually beneficial, both driving up consumer engagement with the platform and providing free advertising and additional business to restaurants. This is undoubtedly true in some circumstances. However, this practice also creates significant accountability issues, as consumers are often unaware of whether an issue with their order results from the restaurant or the delivery service, and may not even know which one they are ordering from. This is particularly true in light of the COVID-19 crisis, as many restaurants are either forming new relationships with platforms or are transitioning to in-house food delivery, pitting less known or accessible in-house delivery against well-known platforms who offer the same service at different prices.
When a consumer has a bad food delivery experience, this means the restaurant may be blamed for the deficiencies of the platform, potentially damaging their reputation in the absence of any consensual arrangement between the parties. To this point, a 2019 study by the market research firm Zion & Zion found that 62 percent of consumers who receive a bad food delivery experience blame both the restaurant and the delivery company. That number increases to nearly 72 percent when food is delivered at the wrong temperature.[7] Additionally, food delivery platforms often charge customers service and delivery fees, in addition to listing higher prices for the same menu items. For the top five food delivery platforms, these markups total to increases ranging from 17 percent to 40.5 percent of list price for the same items at the restaurant.[8] Though these costs are imposed by the platform, consumers may assume the costs are the result of agreements between the restaurant and the platform, or are the typical prices for the restaurant itself, skewing the perceived value of the restaurant’s product.
By requiring a food delivery platform to obtain the express written consent of a food facility before using its menu, likeness, trademark, or other intellectual property, the proposed amendments would reduce consumer confusion over business relationships between restaurants and platforms, since a listing would imply that a relationship exists.
- Proposed amendments may be preempted by federal trademark laws relating to nominative fair use: Although AB 2149 identifies and seeks to address a real problem, the approach to resolving that problem may present some legal issues. Trademark law, which exists in both state and federal statute (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1114 et seq.; Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 14200 et seq.), generally already serves the purpose of prohibiting the unauthorized use of symbols, phrases, names, etc. that could confuse customers and harm the reputation of the represented party. In contrast to existing trademark protections under the Lanham Act and associated case law (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1114, et seq.), the protection that would be provided by this bill would not require the party infringed upon to be harmed by the use of their signifier. Arguably, if no harm has occurred, penalty may not be necessary. Nonetheless, there does appear to be significant redundancy between the protection of intellectual property this bill seeks to provide, and protections that already exist in both state and federal law, potentially obviating the need for this bill.
If, in fact, the bill is not redundant with federal trademark law, it may instead be preempted by federal law, since federal law permits so-called “nominative fair use.” Nominative fair use, which refers to the unauthorized use of a trademark, copyright, or other intellectual property in order to refer to a particular thing where the only word or icon reasonably available to describe that thing would otherwise be prohibited, is considered outside the strictures of trademark law. (New Kids on the Block v. News Am. Publ’g, Inc. (1992) 971 F.2d 302, 307-308.) Nominative fair use is considered an affirmative defense to trademark infringement, and, as was held in New Kids on the Block, is determined by meeting three requirements:
First, the product or service in question must be one not readily identifiable without use of the trademark; second, only so much of the mark or marks may be used as is reasonably necessary to identify the product or service; and third, the user must do nothing that would, in conjunction with the mark, suggest sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark holder. (New Kids on the Block v. News Am. Publ’g, Inc., supra.)
The non-consensual use of the trademark of a food facility by a platform may in some circumstances satisfy these criteria. Because the platform is using the name, likeness, logo, or other intellectual property of the food facility to represent that they are providing the service of delivering from that particular facility, the name, likeness, or logo, at minimum would be necessary to provide the service. In the event that the name only, logo only, or name and logo is used to represent that facility, this would arguably also satisfy the second prong of the test by using only marks that are reasonably necessary to identify the service.
The third requirement is likely the most debatable with respect to this relationship, since the use of this trademark or intellectual property may suggest sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark holder. If this is the case, the use of the trademark or other intellectual property would already be unlawful under federal trademark law, i.e. the Lanham Act. If it is not, the use would likely constitute nominative fair use, and would be explicitly permissible under federal law yet prohibited under this bill, resulting in conflict preemption. In light of this possibility, the author may wish to consider including a severability clause such that if any provision of the bill is unconstitutional or preempted by federal law, it can be excluded without negating the bill in its entirety.
- Author’s amendments: As discussed throughout this analysis, the author has, in light of privacy concerns identified by this Committee and stakeholders, agreed to remove the data sharing provisions of the bill in print, and to replace them with the proscription of unauthorized use of intellectual property of a food facility by a platform. These amendments are as follows:
On page 2, strike out lines 1 to 31, inclusive, strike out page 3, and on page 2, before line 1, insert:
SECTION 1. This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Fair Food Delivery Act of 2020.
SEC. 2. Chapter 22.4 (commencing with Section 22598) is added to Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:
Chapter 22.4. Food Delivery Platforms
22598. For the purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
- “Food delivery platform” means an online business that acts as an intermediary between consumers and multiple food facilities to submit food orders from a consumer to a participating food facility, and to arrange for the delivery of the order from the food facility to the consumer.
- “Food facility” means a food facility, as defined in Section 113789 of the Health and Safety Code.
22599. A food delivery platform shall not post a menu of, or otherwise use the likeness, registered trademark, or any intellectual property belonging to, a food facility without the express written consent of the food facility.
- Arguments in support: The California Restaurant Association, a trade organization representing businesses in the food service industry, argues:
Over the past couple of years there has been an alarming trend of food delivery platforms listing a restaurant’s logo or menu without permission from the restaurant. This type of business practice may help food delivery apps drive traffic to their platform, but for restaurants it creates confusion, hurts their brand, and disrupts operations.
In some cases, restaurants already have a delivery system in place operated by their own employees. If their menu is listed on an unauthorized food delivery platform, then it creates massive confusion for both the restaurant and the delivery driver who shows up. The customer, driver, and restaurant end up losing because the customer does not get their food, the driver does not get paid, and the restaurant’s reputation is damaged. In other instances, a food delivery platform might post an outdated menu or logo. The chances are if a customer is using an outdated menu, then there will be issues with the food order leading to more confusion with the customer and restaurant.
The California Labor Federation adds:
In recent years, technology companies, known as food delivery platforms, have grown exponentially in the food service industry by providing delivery services to restaurants. The pandemic and stay-at-home orders have fueled the expansion of these delivery services. […] The growth of delivery and the potential of a slow reopening of business may fundamentally alter the restaurant industry with a shift to more delivery for all restaurants.
Most third-party delivery companies are large, well-capitalized and national, which forces small, local restaurants to agree to their conditions.[…] Additionally, as reported by the San Francisco Chronicle, some restaurants are listed by a food delivery platform without their consent.[…] This is just one of the many tools they use to take advantage of restaurants, who provide jobs with actual protections to their workers.[…] AB 2149 takes steps to start to level the playing field by prohibiting delivery companies from listing restaurants on their platform without an existing agreement.
- Arguments in opposition: The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital privacy and civil liberties advocacy organization, argues:
This [bill] raises significant legal issues. With respect to trademark use, the requirement of “express written consent” clearly conflicts with Ninth Circuit case law that authorizes “nominative fair use.” In general, such use is permitted if using the trademark is reasonably necessary to identify the products, services, or company that one is talking about, and the user doesn’t use the mark to suggest the company endorses the user.
It also presents preemption problems. The Copyright Act expressly provides that “the fair use of a copyrighted work…is not an infringement of copyright.” 17 U.S.C. § 107. To the extent your amendment would require “express written consent” for the use of any work protected by copyright held by a food facility, is [sic] would be preempted by federal law.
This bill as amended also raises constitutional issues, because it would apparently target speech such as listing the items available on a restaurant’s menu even if that speech is truthful, factual, and not misleading. We have not yet had an opportunity to conduct a full First Amendment analysis of the provision, but we have real doubts about its constitutionality.
- Related Legislation: AB 3336 (Carrillo, 2020) would require a food handler who delivers ready-to-eat food for a third-party food delivery system to display a valid food handler card when picking up food, ensure food is protected from contamination, and maintain potentially hazardous food at required holding temperatures. This bill would also require all bags or containers in which ready-to-eat foods are transported or delivered from a food facility to a customer to be closed with a tamper-evident method prior to the food handler taking possession.
AB 1360 (Ting, 2019) would have required food delivery platforms to ensure that their drivers had training relating to maintaining potentially hazardous foods at required temperatures and maintained liability insurance covering liabilities arising from the use of a vehicle in connection with providing food delivery services. This bill was ordered to the inactive file on the Senate Floor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association (CALTIA) (to bill in print)
Oppose Unless Amended
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Oppose
Internet Association (to bill in print)
TechNet (to bill in print)
Analysis Prepared by: Landon Klein / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
California Restaurant Association, “Coronavirus Information and Resources,” Apr. 30, 2020, https://restaurant.org/Covid19. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Preetika Rana & Heather Haddon, “Coronavirus Lockdowns Prompt Smaller Restaurants to Rethink Delivery,” The Wall Street Journal, Apr. 1, 2020, https://www.wsj.com/articles/coronavirus-lockdowns-prompt-smaller-restaurants-to-rethink-delivery-11585743246/. ↑
Serena Dai, “Delivery Start-Up DoorDash Infuriates Some Restauranteurs by Working Around Them,” Eater: New York, Nov. 6, 2015, https://ny.eater.com/2015/11/6/9678206/door-dash-delivery-nyc; Sara Jones, “The Postmates Problem: Why Some Restaurants Are Forced to Fight the Delivery App,” Eater, Jul. 31, 2015, https://www.eater.com/2015/7/31/9074491/postmates-delivery-problems; Natt Garun, “Grubhub’s new growth hack is listing restaurants that didn’t agree to be listed,” The Verge, Jan. 30, 2020, https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/29/21113876/grubhub-seamless-fake-restaurant-listings-no-permission-postmates-doordash. ↑
See, e.g., Whitney Filloon, “In-N-Out Burger Sues DoorDash for Delivering Its Food Without Permission,” Eater, Nov. 11, 2015, https://www.eater.com/2015/11/11/9714840/in-n-out-doordash-delivery-lawsuit; Lily Rose, “DoorDash faces lawsuit from suburban Chicago Restaurant over trademark infringement,” Jan. 11, 2018, https://www.latimes.com/food/sns-dailymeal-1866262-eat-doordash-faces-lawsuit-suburban-chicago-restaurant-20180111-story.html. ↑
Natt Garun, “Grubhub is using thousands of fake websites to upcharge commission fees from real businesses,” The Verge, Jun. 28, 2019, https://www.theverge.com/2019/6/28/19154220/grubhub-seamless-fake-restaurant-domain-names-commission-fees. ↑
Alicia Kelso, “Study: 62% of diners blame both restaurants and delivery companies for bad service,” Restaurant Dive, March 22, 2019, https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/study-62-of-diners-blame-both-restaurants-and-delivery-companies-for-bad/551077/. ↑
Noah Lichtenstein, “The hidden cost of food delivery,” TechCrunch, Mar. 16, 2020, https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/16/the-hidden-cost-of-food-delivery/ ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):