AB 1336: Nonfungible token marketplaces.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-01-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires a marketplace, as defined, to ensure that its terms and conditions regarding commercial relationships with marketplace sellers meet certain criteria, including that they are drafted in plain and intelligible language.
This bill would require a nonfungible token marketplace, as defined, to disclose the terms and conditions at the time a user resident, as defined, contracts with the nonfungible token marketplace. The bill would require that disclosure to be written in a manner that is understandable to a reasonable user of resident who uses the relevant services and to include, among other things, the manner by which fees and charges imposed by the nonfungible token marketplace will be calculated if they are not identified and disclosed in advance of a transaction and the timing of the fees and charges. The bill would require a nonfungible token marketplace to develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive information security program, as specified, and to maintain a dedicated contact channel to receive legal process from law enforcement. The bill would prohibit its provisions from being construed to create a private right of action under any other law.
Existing law requires a marketplace, as defined, to ensure that its terms and conditions regarding commercial relationships with marketplace sellers meet certain criteria, including that they are drafted in plain and intelligible language.
This bill would require a nonfungible token marketplace, as defined, to disclose the terms and conditions at the time a user contracts with the nonfungible token marketplace. The bill would require that disclosure to be written in a manner that is understandable to a reasonable user of the relevant services and to include, among other things, the manner by which fees and charges will be calculated if they are not identified and disclosed in advance of a transaction and the timing of the fees and charges. The bill would require a nonfungible token marketplace to develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive information security program, as specified, and to maintain a dedicated contact channel to receive legal process from law enforcement.
Existing law governs various business practices in this state, including, among other things, requiring a hosting platform, as defined, to provide a specified notice to an offeror listing a residence for short-term rental on the hosting platform and prohibiting a food delivery platform, as defined, from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility, as defined, without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would encourage the responsible development of the Web3 economy in California.Existing law governs various business practices in this state, including, among other things, requiring a hosting platform, as defined, to provide a specified notice to an offeror listing a residence for short-term rental on the hosting platform and prohibiting a food delivery platform, as defined, from arranging for the delivery of an order from a food facility, as defined, without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would encourage the responsible development of the Web3 economy in California.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Information security program means the administrative, technical, or physical safeguards a nonfungible token marketplace uses to access, collect, distribute, process, protect, store, use, transmit, dispose of, or otherwise handle user resident information.
(b)Nonfungible token means a unique digital identifier that is recorded on a blockchain that serves as a digital record of ownership. ownership, which may provide the holder a right with respect to a digital item that is separate from the unique digital identifier.
(c)Nonfungible token marketplace means an internet website or online application platform that can be used for individuals to buy or sell, or to connect with one another to arrange for the buying or selling of, nonfungible tokens.
(d)Personal information has the same meaning as defined in Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code.
(e)Resident means any of the following:
(1)A person who is domiciled in this state.
(2)A person who is physically located in this state for more than 183 days of the previous 365 days.
(3)A person who is physically located in the state while using the nonfungible token marketplace and has a place of business in this state.
(4)A legal representative of a person that is domiciled in this state.
(e)User(f)Resident information means personal information of a user of resident engaging with a nonfungible token marketplace that is maintained by, or on behalf of, a nonfungible token marketplace or its affiliates.
20656.(a)A nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose the terms and conditions of a nonfungible token marketplace at the time a user resident contracts with the nonfungible token marketplace.
(b)The disclosure required by this section shall not contain material misrepresentations, shall be written in a manner that is understandable to a reasonable user of resident who uses the relevant services, and shall include all of the following:
(1)The manner by which fees and charges imposed by the nonfungible token marketplace will be calculated if they are not identified and disclosed in advance of a transaction and the timing of the fees and charges.
(2)If applicable, a disclosure that states that transfers of nonfungible tokens may be irrevocable.
(3)How liability for an unauthorized, mistaken, or accidental transfer of nonfungible tokens shall be apportioned.
(4)That nonfungible tokens may be subject to cybertheft and become unrecoverable and any other material risks of using the nonfungible token marketplace. unrecoverable.
(5)Whether the nonfungible token marketplace custodies any cryptocurrency or nonfungible tokens on behalf of the user, resident, or if the user resident self-custodies.
(6)That a nonfungible token may be subject to tax in certain jurisdictions, and it is the responsibility of the buyer or seller of the nonfungible token to collect and remit that tax, if applicable.
20657.(a)If a nonfungible token marketplace charges and collects a fee, the nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose the amount of the fee to the user resident that bears the fee, fee before the users residents approval of the transaction, the amount of transaction that would trigger the fee.
(b)(1)If a nonfungible token marketplace charges a fee on behalf of a third party in connection with a users residents transaction, the nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose to the user resident that bears the fee, before the users residents approval of the transaction, the amount of the fee.
(2)If the amount of the fee to be charged on behalf of the third party may vary between approval and execution of the transaction, the nonfungible token marketplace shall provide the user resident that bears the fee, before the users residents approval of the transaction, with an estimate of the third partys fee or a disclosure that the fee is not estimable or may change.
20658.A nonfungible token marketplace shall develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive information security program appropriate tailored to the sensitivity of any user resident information at issue.
20659.A nonfungible token marketplace shall maintain a dedicated contact channel to receive legal process from law enforcement.
20660.This chapter shall not be construed to create a private right of action under any other law.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Information security program means the administrative, technical, or physical safeguards a nonfungible token marketplace uses to access, collect, distribute, process, protect, store, use, transmit, dispose of, or otherwise handle user information.
(b)Nonfungible token means a unique digital identifier that is recorded on a blockchain that serves as a digital record of ownership.
(c)Nonfungible token marketplace means an internet website or online application that can be used for individuals to buy or sell, or to connect with one another to arrange for the buying or selling of, nonfungible tokens.
(d)Personal information has the same meaning as defined in Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code.
(e)User information means personal information of a user of a nonfungible token marketplace that is maintained by, or on behalf of, a nonfungible token marketplace or its affiliates.
20656.(a)A nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose the terms and conditions of a nonfungible token marketplace at the time a user contracts with the nonfungible token marketplace.
(b)The disclosure required by this section shall not contain material misrepresentations, shall be written in a manner that is understandable to a reasonable user of the relevant services, and shall include all of the following:
(1)The manner by which fees and charges will be calculated if they are not identified and disclosed in advance of a transaction and the timing of the fees and charges.
(2)If applicable, a disclosure that states that transfers of nonfungible tokens may be irrevocable.
(3)How liability for an unauthorized, mistaken, or accidental transfer shall be apportioned.
(4)That nonfungible tokens may be subject to cybertheft and become unrecoverable and any other material risks of using the nonfungible token marketplace.
(5)Whether the nonfungible token marketplace custodies any cryptocurrency or nonfungible tokens on behalf of the user, or the user self-custodies.
(6)That a nonfungible token may be subject to tax in certain jurisdictions, and it is the responsibility of the buyer or seller of the nonfungible token to collect and remit that tax, if applicable.
20657.(a)If a nonfungible token marketplace charges and collects a fee, the nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose to the user that bears the fee, before the users approval of the transaction, the amount of the fee.
(b)(1)If a nonfungible token marketplace charges a fee on behalf of a third party in connection with a users transaction, the nonfungible token marketplace shall disclose to the user that bears the fee, before the users approval of the transaction, the amount of the fee.
(2)If the amount of the fee to be charged on behalf of the third party may vary between approval and execution of the transaction, the nonfungible token marketplace shall provide the user that bears the fee, before the users approval of the transaction, with an estimate of the third partys fee or a disclosure that the fee is not estimable or may change.
20658.A nonfungible token marketplace shall develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive information security program appropriate to the sensitivity of any user information at issue.
20659.A nonfungible token marketplace shall maintain a dedicated contact channel to receive legal process from law enforcement.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would encourage the responsible development of the Web3 economy in California.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would encourage the responsible development of the Web3 economy in California.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2024 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Jan 5, 2024 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jan 4, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | (Pending re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P.) |
| Jan 3, 2024 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. (Page 3766.) |
| Jan 3, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & F. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 21, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | (Pending re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P.) |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. (Page 1167.) |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Coms. on B. & F. and P. & C.P. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on P. & C.P. and B. & F. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Opensea | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: January 8, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Timothy Grayson, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1336 (
Author:Low) – As Amended Ver:January 3, 2024
SUBJECT: Nonfungible token marketplaces
SUMMARY: Requires a nonfungible token (NFT) marketplace to maintain an information security program and to provide specified disclosures, including information related to fees and taxes, to California residents engaging with the NFT marketplace. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes assorted definitions, including:
- “Information security program” means the administrative, technical, or physical safeguards an NFT marketplace uses to access, collect, distribute, process, protect, store, use, transmit, dispose of, or otherwise handle resident information.
- “NFT” means a unique digital identifier that is recorded on a blockchain that serves as a digital record of ownership which may provide the holder a right with respect to a digital item that is separate from the unique digital identifier.
- “NFT marketplace” means an internet website or online platform that can be used for individuals to buy, sell, or to connect with one another to arrange the buying or selling of an NFT.
- Requires an NFT marketplace to maintain an information security program and to disclose the terms and conditions of an NFT marketplace at the time a resident contracts with the NFT marketplace. The disclosure must include the following information:
- The manner by which fees and charges imposed by the NFT marketplace will be calculated if they are not identified and disclosed in advance of a transaction, as well as the timing of those fees and charges.
- That the transfer of an NFT may be irrevocable.
- How liability for an unauthorized, mistaken, or accidental transfer of an NFT shall be apportioned.
- That an NFT may be subject to cyber theft and become unrecoverable.
- Whether the NFT marketplace custodies any cryptocurrency or NFTs on behalf of the resident, or the resident self-custodies.
- That the NFT may be subject to tax in certain jurisdictions.
- Requires an NFT marketplace to additionally do the following:
- Disclose to a resident the amount of a fee charged on behalf of a third party in connection to a transaction, if such a fee is charged
- Requires an NFT marketplace to maintain a dedicated contact channel to receive legal process from law enforcement.
- Specifies the new chapter created by this bill shall not be construed to create a private right of action under any other law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides the Digital Financial Asset Law (DFAL), administered by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), which requires licensure of persons engaged in the business of digital financial business activity beginning on July 1, 2025, unless the person is exempt. (Financial Code Section 3100 et seq.)
- Defines “digital financial asset” a digital representation of value that is used as a medium of exchange, unit of account, or store of value, and that is not legal tender, whether or not denominated in legal tender.
- Defines “digital financial asset business activity” to include exchanging, transferring, or storing a digital financial asset or engaging in digital financial asset administration, whether directly or through an agreement with a digital financial asset control services vendor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed Nonfiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose.
According to the author:
I introduced AB 1336 with the goal of creating clarity around NFT marketplaces. The bill creates a simple, baseline regulatory structure for NFT marketplaces – not NFTs nor digital financial products… This bill is just a start and my hope is that it initiates a dialogue that will continue to be had this year and in coming years to maintain our state’s global prominence as a home for innovation.
- Blockchain technology and NFTs
Blockchain technology is a form of distributed ledger technology which allows for network participants to add a new group of transactions (a “block”) to the database. By linking the blocks together in order from the oldest blocks to the newest block, one can create a “ledger” that shows the current balances of all the accounts that have engaged in transactions. Blockchain technology replaces the functions of a centralized bookkeeper, like a bank or money transmitter, who records how money changes hands. In doing so, blockchain technology may allow the sharing or recording of data across a network in a way that increases trust, security, and transparency.
An NFT is a blockchain-based token that represents a unique asset or right like digital art, digital music, or access to a sporting event. At a high level, an NFT is meant to be an irrevocable certificate of ownership and authenticity that can be verified on the blockchain. In recent years, NFTs have primarily been used to represent unique ownership of so-called “digital collectibles,” such as digital drawings or digital trading cards, and these NFTs are often bought and sold on marketplaces such as OpenSea. Popular NFT brands include BoredApes, NBA Topshot, and Cryptopunks. Similar to the traditional art marketplace, consumers typically purchase an NFT digital collectible because of the satisfaction of owning a rare item and because they hope the NFT will become more valuable over time.
NFTs are often lumped in with other blockchain-based digital assets such as cryptocurrencies, but NFTs have a different function and use case. Cryptocurrencies (also referred to as virtual currencies, crypto assets, or digital financial assets) are fungible, meaning they are mutually interchangeable. For example, a person who owns one Bitcoin, the most popular cryptocurrency, can trade that Bitcoin for another Bitcoin, and that person’s economic situation will not change. Even if the Bitcoin itself can be uniquely identified, its value and use are the same as another Bitcoin. This is similar to how one paper dollar, which has a numeric identifier printed on it, is the same as another paper dollar. In contrast, an NFT digital collectible is not interchangeable, similar to how trading cards, pieces of art, or music tickets to different bands are not easily traded for one another.
- Ok, but are NFTs really just collectibles?
Since their emergence, there has been significant debate over how to classify NFTs. Because they are so often today used to convey ownership of digital collectibles such as art, music, and trading cards, commentators, journalists, and policymakers have tended to focus on those characteristics. For example, in 2023, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) sought feedback on proposed guidance regarding the taxation of NFTs as a “collectible” under tax law, a sign that policymakers are starting to seriously think through the policy implications of digital collectible NFTs.
However, in theory, NFTs can represent ownership or a right to pretty much anything. If an NFT is merely the packaging that signals, though a digital token, ownership of some other thing or right, then the NFT itself does not have any inherent quality and does not fall into some simple categorization. In the proposed guidance mentioned above, the IRS gives the following analysis of how to determine if an NFT is a collectible: Under tax law, a gem is considered a collectible, and an NFT conferring ownership of a gem is similarly considered a collectible.[1] That same analysis can be applied to a range of other products or services that are not a collectible, including real estate, video game assets, or possibly even new financial products. The use case of NFTs – if they are actually as helpful, efficient, and functional as promised – is expansive.
- Recent industry struggles and consumer risks
The past two years in the NFT industry have been tumultuous. Like the broader crypto ecosystem, NFTs have been subject to market volatility, firm closures, enforcement actions from regulators (see Comment #5), and reputational damage from ongoing reporting on consumer harm. According to a report from Bloomberg using data from DappRadar, monthly NFT trading volume plummeted 81% between January 2022 and July 2023, leading to failures of NFT marketplaces such as Recur and Nifty.[2] And in November 2023, prominent NFT marketplace OpenSea announced sweeping layoffs affecting up to 50% of its staff.[3]
As the market weakness persists, so do the concerns about the risks consumers face when buying and selling NFTs. Those risks include:
- Security risks. Consumers are exposed to a variety of security risks associated with NFTs, such as phishing scams, hacks, and other types of security breaches. According to Elliptic, a blockchain analytics firm, around 4,600 NFTs were reported as stolen between 2021 and 2022.[4]
Security risks are common across industries deploying blockchain technology. Part of these risks stem from the relative newness of the industry, its “wild west” nature, and the lack of resources these newer companies have devoted to security issues. Other risks stem from how digital assets work behind the scenes as well as the speed and irrevocability of transactions, making them attractive to hackers and scammers.[5]
- Insider trading. Insider trading occurs when someone uses confidential information to their advantage in a transaction or trade. In the NFT market, insider trading can occur when an NFT marketplace employee purchases an NFT before it is available to the public, and then that employee sells the NFT once its price increases after its listing. For example, in June 2022 the Department of Justice indicted an NFT marketplace employee for money laundering and wire fraud in connection to insider trading, alleging that the employee used “confidential business information about what NFTs were going to be featured on its homepage to secretly purchase dozens of NFTs shortly before they were featured,” and then selling them at profits of two-to-five-times his initial purchase price.[6]
- Wash trading. Wash trading is when buyers and sellers collude to inflate the market price of the NFT. In some cases, the buyer and the seller are the same person, and that person is simply trading the NFT between accounts to give a false sense of demand. A 2022 Chainalysis report identified a wide variety of wash trading or attempts at wash trading. While Chainalysis notes that many wash trading efforts failed, the successes led to significant gains for the traders, at the expense of other, unaware buyers:
The 110 profitable wash traders have collectively made nearly $8.9 million in profit from this activity, dwarfing the $416,984 in losses made by the 152 unprofitable wash traders. Even worse, that $8.9 million is most likely derived from sales to unsuspecting buyers who believe the NFT they’re purchasing has been growing in value, sold from one distinct collector to another.[7]
- Application of securities laws to NFTs
NFTs have also been scrutinized by federal regulators as possible securities under federal securities laws. Securities laws require companies to register an offering of a security, such as a stock, bond, or investment contracts, and prohibit fraudulent activities of any kind in connection with the offer, purchase, or sale of that security.
The determination of whether a digital asset is a security often relies on the “Howey Test,” an analysis derived from a 1946 US Supreme Court ruling (SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293) about a leaseback agreement related to citrus groves. The Supreme Court, in its decision, developed the Howey Test framework, which states that a transaction is an investment contract if: (1) It is an investment of money; (2) There is an expectation of profits from that investment; (3) The investment of money is in a common enterprise; and, (4) The profit comes from the efforts of a promoter or third party.
Federal regulators have taken a number of enforcement actions against NFT companies for offering unregistered securities. For example, in August 2023 the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged Impact Theory, LLC with conducting an unregistered offering of securities in the form of NFTs. According to the order, the company offered three tiers of NFTs and encouraged potential investors to view the purchase of the NFT as an investment into the business. The SEC states that these NFTs were investment contracts, pursuant to the Howey Test, and therefore were securities.[8]
The Impact Theory, LLC order is just one of many SEC enforcement actions asserting companies offering digital assets such as NFTs or crypto assets were violating federal securities laws. In the crypto asset industry, the SEC has declared at least 55 crypto assets as unregistered securities, including nearly half of the top 20 tokens in purported market cap: BNB token (issued by Binance), XRP (issued by Ripple), Cardano, Solana, Tron, Polygon, Toncoin, Avalanche, and Binance USD.[9]
The applicability of securities laws to digital assets like NFTs is likely to continue to be litigated and argued in the courts in the years to come. While many companies settled with the federal government, some industry actors contend that the SEC analysis is flawed, and these cases are still ongoing.
- What AB 1336 does
AB 1336 establishes standardized rules and consumer disclosures for NFT marketplaces so that users have sufficient information about the relevant risks when engaging with those platforms. Under the bill, an NFT marketplace must maintain an “information security program” and must disclose to residents certain information, such as the presence of fees, the irrevocability of an NFT transfer, and a warning about the potential for cyber theft.
The requirements under AB 1336 are reasonable and would ensure that consumers have more information than they may get now, but it is unclear whether additional consumer disclosures will sufficiently address the risks consumers face when buying and selling NFTs.
As the bill advances, the author may want to consider addressing the below issues to strengthen protections for consumers:
- Lack of specific guidance on the information security program. While the requirement that an NFT marketplace maintain an information security program is a much-needed consumer protection, AB 1336 does not require any specific standards. The author may wish to consider referencing a model information security program or otherwise requiring a minimum standard so that the program is effective.
- Lack of robust cybersecurity or fraud-prevention requirements. AB 1336 imposes no real requirements for marketplaces related to cybersecurity, including their role in preventing hacks and theft. While a marketplace must warn a customer about the possibility of cyber theft, the marketplace itself is not required to take any assertive steps to help ensure a safe transaction. In some ways, this makes sense: Often, thefts happen outside of the marketplace, such as a direct attack on a consumer’s individual NFT wallet.
However, NFT marketplaces themselves are not immune to security breaches, and they can play a more assertive role in preventing bad actors from using their platforms. For example, the NFT marketplace OpenSea had to address platform vulnerabilities which would have allowed hackers to hijack accounts and steal from customers.[10] And, other types of fraud may occur on NFT marketplaces, such as fraudulent listings and unwanted transfers. The author may wish to consider requiring NFT marketplaces to develop a comprehensive cybersecurity or scam-prevention program to help safeguard users’ NFTs or to offer dedicated customer service for harmed consumers.
- Further definitional clarity around NFTs. As noted in Comment #3, there is a big difference between how NFTs typically work today and how they could be used in the future. AB 1336, as drafted, offers no guardrails around what types of NFT or NFT marketplaces would be covered by the bill. AB 1336 may be broader in scope than intended by the author.
If the idea behind AB 1336 is to establish standardized rules for NFT marketplaces offering digital collectibles such as digital pieces of art, for example, then AB 1336’s definitions should be further refined.
- Interaction with the Digital Financial Asset Law (DFAL)
AB 39 (Grayson), Chapter 792, Statutes of 2023, establishes the DFAL to require the licensing of companies engaging in digital financial asset business activity, as defined, by July 1, 2025. AB 39, which was introduced in response to the widespread consumer harm stemming from the high-profile crypto failures in 2022, establishes new consumer protections for digital financial asset companies, including disclosures, policies and procedures, and financial stability requirements. DFPI will manage the program.
When AB 39 was pending in the Legislature, its applicability to NFTs was an ongoing source of debate. In public comment during legislative hearings, stakeholders requested clarity that the bill not apply to NFTs. However, the author of the bill stated that while AB 39 was not intended to regulate “digital art marketplaces” or other similar types of NFT companies offering only digital collectibles, specific language exempting these products did more harm than good, especially given the fast-evolving nature of digital assets. Because an NFT is not guaranteed to be one thing or another, the author opted to let DFPI determine the best way to determine the appropriate scope of the DFAL through the regulatory process.
DFPI is still in the early stages of implementing the DFAL, and it is possible that a company would need to comply with both AB 1336 and the DFAL based on the types of digital assets they list and how the trades are executed. For example, a crypto exchange that is licensed under the DFAL but also offers NFTs for sale would also need to comply with AB 1336. Or, an NFT marketplace that puts to market an NFT that DFPI determines is actually a digital financial asset under the definitions in the DFAL would likely need to obtain a DFAL license. Until DFPI is closer to rolling out the licensure program, it is not yet fully known how these two laws will ultimately interact.
- Support
The NFT marketplace OpenSea writes in support of AB 1336:
This bill brings clarity to the web3 ecosystem, clarity that has been called for by government and industry alike. AB 1336 takes the necessary first steps of defining key terms and requiring companies who operate NFT marketplaces to implement certain disclosure and security procedures. As a result, this bill will also provide clarity to consumers about marketplaces, thereby increasing consumer confidence and participation.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
OpenSea
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
IRS issues guidance, seeks comments on nonfungible tokens (March 21, 2023), available at: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-issues-guidance-seeks-comments-on-nonfungible-tokens ↑
Olga Kharif and James Tarmy, “NFTs, Once Hyped as the Next Big Thing, Now Face ‘Worst Moment.” Bloomberg News (September 1, 2023), available at: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-01/nft-hype-fades-in-crypto-market-as-sales-volume-plunges ↑
Elizabeth Napolitano, “NFT Marketplace OpenSea Cuts Staff,” CoinDesk (November 8, 2023), available at: https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2023/11/03/nft-marketplace-opensea-cuts-staff/ ↑
“NFTs and Financial Crime,” Elliptic, available at https://www.elliptic.co/resources/nfts-financial-crime ↑
For a description of common types of security vulnerabilities, see: https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/blockchain-security/#What%20is%20blockchain%20security? ↑
“Former Employee Of NFT Marketplace Sentenced To Prison In First-Ever Digital Asset Insider Trading Scheme,” Department of Justice (August 22, 2023), available at: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-employee-nft-marketplace-sentenced-prison-first-ever-digital-asset-insider ↑
“Crime and NFTs: Chainalysis Detects Significant Wash Trading and Some NFT Money Laundering In this Emerging Asset Class,” Chainalysis (February 2, 2022), available at:
https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2022-crypto-crime-report-preview-nft-wash-trading-money-laundering/ ↑
SEC Charges LA-Based Media and Entertainment Co. Impact Theory for Unregistered Offering of NFTs, https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2023-163 ↑
https://cointelegraph.com/news/sec-labels-61-cryptocurrencies-securities-after-binance-suit ↑
https://opensea.io/blog/articles/opensea-collaborates-with-check-point-research-to-mitigate-vulnerability#:~:text=OpenSea%20fixed%20the%20vulnerability%20within,storage.opensea.io%20domain. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):