AB 768: Communications: The Office of Broadband and Digital Equity.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-03-09
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes within the Department of Technology the Office of Broadband and Digital Literacy. The office oversees the acquisition and management of contracts for the development and construction of, and for the maintenance and operation of, a statewide open-access middle-mile broadband network, as defined, to provide an opportunity for last-mile providers, anchor institutions, and tribal entities to connect to, and interconnect with other networks and other appropriate connections to, the broadband network to facilitate high-speed broadband service, as specified.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law requires the commission to develop, implement, and administer the California Advanced Services Fund to encourage deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies.
This bill would establish within state government the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity. This bill would establish the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity Board with members, as specified. The bill would provide the purpose of the office is to serve as a centralized state office for broadband and digital activities within the state. The bill would also specify the office has the powers and authorities to develop and implement policies to promote broadband service and to protect consumers from unfair business practices relating to broadband services.
Existing law establishes the Department of Technology within the Government Operations Agency and sets forth its powers and duties relating to the approval and oversight of information technology projects. Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of this state are entitled to full and equal accommodations in all business establishments regardless of their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, or sexual orientation.This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to subsequently amend this bill to include provisions that would establish the Office of Digital Equity.Existing law establishes the Department of Technology within the Government Operations Agency and sets forth its powers and duties relating to the approval and oversight of information technology projects. Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of this state are entitled to full and equal accommodations in all business establishments regardless of their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, or sexual orientation.
This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to subsequently amend this bill to include provisions that would establish the Office of Digital Equity.
For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Board means the Broadband and Digital Equity Board.
(b)Office means the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity.
11549.81.There is in state government the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity.
11549.82.The office shall serve as the centralized state office for broadband and digital equity activities within the state.
11549.83.The office shall have the powers and authorities necessary to do both of the following:
(a)To develop and implement policies to promote broadband service and access throughout the state.
(b)To ensure consumers are protected from unfair business practices relating to broadband internet purchase, rental, and use.
11549.84.The office shall be administered by the board which shall consist of the following members:
(a)Five appointees by the Governor. Three appointees shall consist of the following members:
(1)A member who is a representative of a labor organization.
(2)A member who is a representative of a consumer advocacy organization.
(3)A member who is a representative of an internet service provider.
(b)One appointee by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(c)One appointee by the Senate Rules Committee.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to subsequently amend this measure to include provisions that would establish the Office of Digital Equity. CORRECTIONS: HeadingLine 1. DigestPage 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to subsequently amend this measure to include provisions that would establish the Office of Digital Equity.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2024 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 20, 2023 | Measure version as amended on March 9 corrected. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 28, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 13, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on C. & C. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Broadband & Video Association | ** Against | |
| Mission Street Neighbors | ** Support | |
| New Livable California Dba Livable California | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: March 29, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Tasha Boerner Horvath, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 768 (
Author:Boerner Horvath) – As Amended Ver:March 9, 2023
SUBJECT: Communications: The Office of Broadband and Digital Equity
SUMMARY: This bill would establish within state government the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity, to serve as a centralized state office for broadband and digital activities within the state. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity (OBDE) within state government.
- Provides that the OBDE shall serve as the centralized state office for broadband and digital equity activities within the state.
- Vests the OBDE with the powers and authorities necessary to do both of the following:
- To develop and implement policies to promote broadband service and access throughout the state.
- To ensure consumers are protected from unfair business practices relating to broadband internet purchase, rental, and use.
- Provides that the OBDE shall be administered by a board which shall consist of 7-members, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and vests the agency with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. (Article 12 of the California Constitution)
- Establishes the Public Utilities Act, which, in part, declares the finding of the Legislature that the public interest is best served by a CPUC that is appropriately funded and staffed, that can thoroughly examine the issues before it, and that can take timely and well-considered action on matters before it. Additionally, that funding the commission by means of a reasonable fee imposed upon regulated entities helps to achieve those goals and is, therefore, in the public interest. (Public Utilities Code § 401-410)
- Requires the CPUC to require telephone corporations to provide customer service to telecommunication customers that includes, but is not limited to, all the following (Public Utilities Code § 2896):
- Sufficient information upon which to make informed choices among telecommunications services and providers.
- Reasonable statewide service quality standards, including, but not limited to, standards regarding network technical quality, customer service, installation, repair, and billing.
- Information concerning the regulatory process and how customers can participate in that process, including the process of resolving complaints.
- Establishes the Video Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 (DIVCA), establishing the CPUC as the sole franchising authority in the state, and establishes the finding of the legislature that increasing competition for video and broadband services is a matter of statewide concern. (Public Utilities Code § 5800 et. seq.)
- Requires the CPUC to adopt customer service requirements for a holder of a state franchise and adjudicate any customer complaints. (Public Utilities Code § 5800 et. seq.)
- Requires the CPUC to develop, implement, and administer the California Advanced Services Fund (CASF) program to encourage deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, as provided in specific decisions of the CPUC and in the CASF statute. (Public Utilities Code § 281)
- Establishes the Office of Broadband and Digital Literacy (OBDL) within the Department of Technology (CDT) to oversee the acquisition and management of contracts for the development and construction of a statewide open-access middle-mile broadband network, colloquially known as the middle-mile broadband initiative (MMBI). (Government Code § 11549.50)
- Requires CDT to establish the Middle-Mile Advisory Committee (MMAC) to monitor the construction and establishment of the MMBI. (Government Code § 11549.58)
- Establishes the California Broadband Council (CBC) in state government for the purpose of promoting broadband deployment in unserved and underserved areas of the state, as defined by the Public Utilities Commission, and broadband adoption throughout the state for the benefit of all Californians. (Government Code § 8885)
- Establishes internet neutrality requirements for internet service providers (ISPs) providing broadband internet access service to customers in California. The requirements prohibit ISPs from taking certain actions that interfere with consumers’ ability to lawfully access internet content. (Civil Code § 3100 et. seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill. The purpose of the bill is to establish the OBDE within state government to serve as the centralized state office for broadband and digital equity activities within the state. According to the author, “Broadband policy in California is a complicated web of different policies and programs that are failing consumers and leaves broadband providers with unequal levels of regulatory oversight. The OBDE will bring ALL of the state’s broadband initiatives – infrastructure grant making, consumer protection, and digital equity - under one structure of governance to achieve better outcomes for consumers by addressing the state’s broadband challenges head-on from a centralized office.”
- Overview of California’s Broadband Policies and Programs. California has various programs and policies for broadband to address the various facets of connecting users to a high-speed internet connection. Generally speaking, the state’s policies and programs are intended to address broadband in one of two ways: broadband as infrastructure and broadband as a service. For example, to encourage the deployment of broadband infrastructure in areas of the state where it does not exist, the CASF program was established to provide financial incentives to providers for constructing new infrastructure in unserved areas of the state. In that regard, CASF is a program that addresses broadband as infrastructure. The state also has established limited programs to address broadband as a service, such as the affordability aspect through the California Lifeline program.
The state has recently redoubled its commitment to addressing the broadband infrastructure problem with the passage of SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review. Chapter 112 of 2021). Pursuant to SB 156 the state invested billions into expanding broadband infrastructure, including $2-billion in additional funding for the CASF and taking the novel step of entering the broadband market with a commitment to build a state-owned middle-mile broadband network[1], or MMBI. However, the state’s two biggest broadband infrastructure initiatives are currently administered by separate agencies, with the CPUC continuing to administer the CASF, but the newly established OMBL of the California Department of Technology overseeing the construction of the MMBI. As a result, the implementation of both investments has not been as coordinated as was intended, which potentially minimizes the impact of the state’s investment in either program. Despite the disjointed bureaucratic structure created to address the broadband infrastructure problem, California has certainly taken a robust approach to expanding broadband infrastructure across the state.
When it comes to regulating broadband as a service, California has a less robust approach. Take, for example, the California Lifeline program, which is administered by the CPUC. The Lifeline program is intended, in part, to help low-income families access broadband service. However, the subsidies the program provides are specifically for mobile broadband service accessed via a cellular device. Fixed broadband services, a connection that is accessible at a fixed location like a residence, are not eligible for a California Lifeline subsidy[2]. Ironically, it is well known that broadband affordability is one of the leading reasons households do not subscribe to broadband service. Due to the limited scope of broadband affordability that California Lifeline is intended to address, some advocates have argued that the California Lifeline program is insufficient to meet the communications needs of the 21st century, which relies more heavily on broadband services than tradition voice service.
In addition to the limited programs and policies to address broadband service affordability, California also has limited consumer protections for broadband service subscribers. There are, of course, consumer privacy and fair business practice laws that apply to businesses operating in the state generally, but almost none that apply to ISPs specifically. California is not unique in this regard though, most states do not have basic customer service laws for ISPs. The hands-off policy approach to broadband service took a turn in 2018, when California was the first state to address broadband service consumer protection through the passage of the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018 (“Net Neutrality Act”) via SB 822 (Wiener. Chapter 976, Statutes of 2018).
The Net Neutrality Act prohibits ISPs from taking certain actions that interfere with consumers’ ability to lawfully access internet content, such as by slowing accessing to particular websites or engaging in paid-prioritization for accessing particular content. The law was immediately challenged in court, but most recently was upheld in 2022 by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in ACA Connects v. Bonta[3]. The result of this ruling suggests that federal preemption of broadband service regulation is not strictly preempted by federal law or policies, as was argued by the industry petitioners. If states are not preempted by federal law, this leaves open the possibility that California could move to adopt consumer protections laws that cover additional aspects of broadband service. For example, the state could require the adoption of service quality standards that ensure consumers reliably receive the maximum broadband speeds they subscribe to or protect consumers from unreasonable overage charges if they exceed data caps. This work could potentially happen through the Office of Broadband and Digital Equity (OBDE).
Although this bill in its current form does not provide much detail on the particular scope of the OBDE as it relates to broadband infrastructure and broadband service, those details will need to be fleshed out. For example, at its broadest scope the OBDE could be a full regulatory agency, similar to the CPUC, that has authority to adopt regulations and pursue enforcement actions for violations. On the other hand, without robust authority and an ongoing source of funding to employ full-time professional staff, the OBDE is likely to fall short of its intended goals to promote broadband service and protect consumers.
- Different internet service providers have different regulatory frameworks. This bill, broadly, has the purpose of bringing the entire broadband industry under one government entity. Although it is not stated explicitly, the author has stated her intention that some existing programmatic and regulatory functions would be brought under the umbrella of the OBDE. That could be beneficial, but it would also be complicated because of the various laws governing different providers. California consumers subscribe to broadband services from a variety of internet service providers (ISPs) utilizing various types of technologies. For example, AT&T, a legacy telephone company, has the single largest broadband service area footprint in the state; although a significant number of households in that territory may only have access to slowest speeds of service[4]. Many Californians also subscribe to broadband service from a legacy cable video company (ie; Comcast, Charter, or Cox). According to the California Broadband & Video Association, an industry trade association, cable broadband operators offer broadband service to 97% of California homes and business.[5] Some Californians have cut the cord all together, assuming one is available, and subscribe to fixed-wireless service at home from satellite companies or legacy mobile telephone companies that are beginning to compete in the fixed-broadband market. Interestingly, in recent years the growth of subscribers to fixed-wireless service has outpaced the growth of a traditional home wireline connection.
For all the various different providers of broadband service there are different regulatory frameworks that govern those companies operations in California, which is based on their legacy business service (ie; landline telephone, mobile telephone, cable television). Take, for example, legacy telephone companies; for most of the 20th century, home telephone service operated as a monopoly and rates were strictly regulated by the CPUC. As a public utility, telephone companies were required to serve all households in their service territories. Additionally, pursuant to state law, telephone corporations are still required to maintain minimum service quality standards for their voice services. Over time, as the internet was invented, selling broadband service has become a core part of telephone company business models. Nonetheless, those companies continue to regulate as telephone companies.
There are also legacy cable companies that historically provided video programing as their primary business service. Unlike telephone companies, cable system operators were never considered to be a public utility, and thus have not been subject to an obligation to serve all households or rate regulation. In California, cable system franchising, or licensing, has been most recently governed by the Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006. The law established a ministerial review process for the CPUC to approve state video franchises, and applies specifically to video service. Since the passage of DIVCA cable companies have become among the most prevalent providers of broadband service in the state, yet their regulatory framework is still based on the previous video franchises.
In some instances the different regulatory frameworks can put the different companies at a competitive disadvantage. For example, legacy telephone companies are considered carriers of last resort, and must maintain voice service for all households in their service territory. As a result, those companies must use resources to maintain a sometimes outdated network to meet those regulatory requirements. The same requirement does not exist for cable companies, or mobile providers. Nonetheless, because the state has not regulated broadband as a service directly, the broadband market is able to operate with little government intervention, which the providers tend to favor. Although this bill does not specify the extent to which the OBDE would have the authority to adopt a regulatory framework for broadband specifically, giving the office that authority could level the playing field among providers and benefit consumers.
- The California Constitution poses challenges to implementation of this bill. Colloquially speaking, most people might consider broadband service to be a telecommunications service; however, from a strictly legal perspective, this is not exactly the case. California law, for example, generally defines telecommunications service as voice service provided by a telephone corporation. Pursuant to the California Constitution, telephone corporations are public utilities regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC). Although voice service is different than broadband service, as explained above, telephone corporations provide both services and are among the most prevalent providers of broadband service. In that regard, the California Constitution creates potential challenges with moving broadband related programs and policies from the CPUC, as the author has stated is her intention. While the author could amend this bill to ensure there is not overlapping authority over broadband service in particular, without constitutional changes the CPUC would retain their authority over telephone corporations as public utilities. For better or for worse, a clean break from the CPUC is no simple matter as it relates to telephone corporations.
Furthermore, there is also an interplay between broadband policy, the California Constitution, and federal law. Under federal policy set by the Federal Communications Commission, broadband is also not considered a telecommunications service. Pursuant to the Restoring Internet Freedom Order[6], a rule adopted by a Trump-appointed majority, the FCC reclassified broadband internet service as a lightly-regulated “information service”. The category of an information service comes from the Federal Communications Act of 1996, which establishes different categories of regulated communications services. Whereas Title I are lightly-regulated information services, Title II services are more heavily regulated “common carriers”. Common carriers, like public utilities, have more legal obligations to consumers and are more heavily regulated. Prior to the Restoring Internet Freedom Order, broadband had been considered a Title II common carrier under the then Obama-appointed majority. It is likely that with changes in federal administrations there will be changes in the classification of broadband under the Federal Communications Act of 1996. This is important to note because it too has relevance to the CPUC’s authority. In particular, the California Constitution also gives the CPUC authority over common carriers within the state. Although the author could amend this bill to give centralized regulatory authority over broadband to the OBDE, the California constitution once again could pose a challenge. Should this bill become law and the FCC were to reclassify broadband services providers as common carriers, there would in effect be two agencies with legal authority over broadband policy in the state. That potential unintended consequence seems to be the opposite of the intent of this bill, which is centralize broadband authorities under a single office. While this scenario is speculative, it is a possibility that ought to be addressed.
- The CPUC has a breadth of regulatory responsibility and challenges. The California Constitution gives the CPUC broad authority over public utilities. A public utility is a broad legal classification that includes investor-owned electric utilities, investor-owned water utilities, telephone corporations, railroad corporations, and common carriers transporting goods and people. While some might be surprised to learn about the CPUC’s more obscure functions, such as approving the operating permits of vessel common-carriers, in recent years the CPUC has become almost synonymous with climate change policy, energy, and wildfires. Indeed, the CPUC is playing an influential role in addressing our state’s most pressing and existential threats. Doing all that work is a lot of responsibility for ultimately five Commissioners, each of whom must lead various complex and lengthy regulatory proceedings that impact a variety of public utilities and industries classes regulated by the CPUC.
While separating broadband from the CPUC would certainly be a complex transition, for all the reasons discussed above and more, there are various reasons why doing so could be a worthwhile endeavor. To name one significant reason, it would allow the CPUC to better focus its resources into addressing the existential climate and energy threats facing our state. Whereas broadband policy is obviously important, climate change is the threat of our lifetime. Additionally, electric utility caused wildfires and safety incidents have cost the lives of a number of people over the years. Unlike broadband policy, which is a quality of life issue, climate change and effective regulation of investor-owned electric utilities can literally be a life or death issue. This does not imply that the current arrangement makes the CPUC incapable of meeting its objectives – safety, affordability, and consumer protection - but rather raises the consideration that a more narrowly focused organization may lead to better outcomes all around on the issues everyone cares about.
Separating the regulation of broadband from the CPUC’s other regulatory focus areas would be consistent with recent legislation related to energy utilities. For example, in 2019, following a string of deadly utility-caused wildfires the Legislature and Newsom Administration agreed to move the CPUC’s Wildfire Safety Division to a newly established Office of Energy Infrastructure Safety within the Natural Resources Agency. Part of the reasoning for that transition was that wildfire prevention would be better accomplished outside of the CPUC. Similarly, the implication of this bill is that outcomes for broadband would be better under administration of an outside agency. While, there is no knowing for certain whether moving broadband outside of the CPUC would lead to better outcomes, other states have begun to establish standalone offices of broadband[7].
- Related/similar legislation:
- AB 41 (Holden) implement comprehensive changes to the Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 to encourage the deployment of broadband capable infrastructure by cable operators. This bill is currently under consideration in this committee.
- AB 414 (Reyes) would establish the Digital Equity Bill of Rights, establishing the policy of the state that residents have a right to broadband and establishing a legal requirement that subscriber have a right to equal access to broadband. This bill is currently under consideration in this committee.
- AB 662 (Boerner Horvath) would establish guidelines for the CPUC to follow in administering the federal Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment funds.
- AB 1714 (Wood) would classify broadband corporations as public utilities under the Public Utilities Act. This bill is currently under consideration in this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Mission Street Neighbors
New Livable California Dba Livable California
Opposition
California Broadband & Video Association
Analysis Prepared by: Emilio Perez / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
The state-owned middle-mile broadband network project has come to be known as the Middle-Mile Broadband Initiative (MMBI). ↑
ACA Connects v. Bonta: 9th Circuit Upholds State Net Neutrality Laws. Jolt Digest - Harvard Journal of Law and Technology. https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/aca-connects-v-bonta-9th-circuit-upholds-state-net-neutrality-laws ↑
AT&T's Digital Divide in California. http://belonging.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/haas_broadband_042417-singles.pdf ↑
California Broadband & Video Association (CalBroadband). https://www.calbroadband.org/policies-and-initiatives ↑
Restoring Internet Freedom Order. 2018. Federal Communications Commission. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/02/22/2018-03464/restoring-internet-freedom ↑
Which States Have Dedicated Broadband Offices, Task Forces, Agencies, or Funds?. 2021. Pew Charitable Trusts. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2021/06/28/which-states-have-dedicated-broadband-offices-task-forces-agencies-or-funds ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):