Assembly Floor
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members. The Assembly is now in session. Assembly Members notice is an absence of a quorum. The sergeant of arms will appear at the chamber and bring the absent Members. The Clerk will call the roll
- Committee Secretary
Person
[Roll Call]
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members, a quorum is present. We ask our guests and visitors in the rear of the chamber and the gallery to please stand for the prayer and flag salute. Today's prayer will be offered by our Assembly Chaplain, Imam Yasir Khan. Imam Yasir.
- Mohammad Khan
Person
In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merciful. Almighty God, look with favor upon us. Guide these important decision makers with your divine light. Be their source of strength and comfort. Enable them to serve you and glorify your name by serving the people of this great state, regardless of their gender, ethnicity, or religion. Make them your instruments to deliver your divine mercy and compassion. Bless them with openness and humility.
- Mohammad Khan
Person
Fill their hearts and minds with passion and determination to improve the quality of life of their fellow human beings. Grant them success in their efforts to wipe out poverty, ignorance, and hatred. Make these Assembly Members peacemakers, healers, and bridge builders, so urgently needed in our wounded and broken times. Give them the strength that they need to keep what needs to be kept. Give them the courage that they need to change what needs to be changed. Give them the wisdom they need to distinguish one from the other. Amin.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
We ask that you please remain standing as Assembly Member Addis leads us in the flag salute.
- Dawn Addis
Legislator
Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
You may be seated. Thank you, Assembly Member Addis. Reading of the previous day's journal.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Chamber, Sacramento, Tuesday, March 14, 2023 the Assembly met at 7:00 AM.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Ms. Reyes moves, Mr. Gallagher seconds that the reading of the previous day's journal be dispensed with. Presentations and petitions, there are none. Introduction and reference of bills will be deferred. Reports of committees will be deemed read and amendments deemed adopted. Messages from the Governor, there are none. Messages from the Senate, there are none. Moving to motions and resolutions, the absences for the day will be deemed read and printed in the journal. Mr. Hart, you are recognized for your procedural motions.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I request unanimous consent to suspend Assembly Rule 118 A to allow Assembly Member Haney to have guests and photographers on the floor and for Assembly Members Boerner Horvath and Weber to have guests seated at their desks.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Without objections, such shall be the order.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
Pursuant to Assembly Rule 96, I request unanimous consent to rerefer the following bills to Committee: AB 36 Gabriel from the Public Safety Committee to the Judiciary Committee, and then back to the Public Safety Committee. AB 1000 Reyes from the Local Government Committee to the Natural Resources Committee and then back to the Local Government Committee. And AB 1713, Gipson, from the Local Government Committee to the Accountability and Administrative Review Committee.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Without objections, such shall be the order.
- Gregg Hart
Legislator
And finally, I request unanimous consent to allow measures that are being reported out of Committee and submitted to the desk during spring recess with authors' amendments or the recommendation do pass as amended and do pass as amended and be rereferred, will be given their second reading upon being reported and rereferred to Committee, or return to second reading.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
And without objection, such shall be the order. Members, I ask that you please all stand and allow Assembly Member Gipson to lead us in a moment of silence for the victims of the Covenant School shooting in Nashville, Tennessee, on Monday, March 27. Assembly Member Gipson, you are recognized.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam Speaker and Members. We ask that all Members rise to bring attention to the tragedy that took place this past Monday, March 27, at Covenant School in Nashville, Tennessee. The shooting resulted in six deaths. These victims include staff and three, excuse me, three nine year old children. I am saddened that we still live in a country where these shootings are still taking place.
- Mike Gipson
Legislator
We stand together today to mourn the life of those who've lost their lives due to this horrific shooting that took place on Monday. Let me read the names. Michael Hill, 61 years of age. Katherine Koonce, 60. Cynthia Peak, 61. Hallie Scruggs, nine years old. Evelyn Dieckhaus, nine years old. And William Kinney, nine years old. Members, I ask that we stand in a moment of silence for those who've lost their lives on Monday in Nashville, Tennessee. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members, you may be seated. Without objection, we will be moving to business on the daily file. Members, we will go to file item 44, AB 957 by Assembly Member Wilson. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 957 by Assembly Member Wilson and others, an act relating to family law.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Wilson, you are recognized.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, Members. I am here to present AB 957, a bill that would require a court to consider a parent's affirmation of the child's identity, gender identity, when determining the best interest of a child. AB 957 would also require a court to strongly consider that affirming the gender identity of a minor is in the best interest of the child if a non-consenting parent objects to a name changed to confirm to the minor's gender identity.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
I understand many of my colleagues are absent today, but I'm bringing up this bill today in particular, because tomorrow, March 31, is International Transgender Day of Visibility. This is an important week, and I want to take the time to highlight the Legislature's affirmation that we see this community and will fight for equality for all transgender people.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Members, currently, when parents do not agree on affirming a TGI, which stands for transgender, gender diverse, intersex, when parents do not agree on affirming a TGI child's gender identity, the family code does not specify how a judge should determine the best interest of a TGI child. TGI youth are at a higher risk of depression, mental health crisis, self harm, and suicide than their cis peers. Having at least one adult in a child's life who affirms their gender identity decreases their chance of attempting suicide significantly.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
82% of transgender individuals experience suicide ideation, and 40% make a suicide attempt in their lifetime. Research demonstrates that a family acceptance of LGBTQ plus youth is a crucial protective factor in combating depression and substance abuse and can dramatically reduce rates of suicide by half. Furthermore, many TGI children are not safe in their own homes because of non-affirming or abusive caretakers. This leads many TGI youth to run away from home, leaving them vulnerable to housing instability, exploitation, and further abuse.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Well rounded social support from friends and family members is strongly associated with positive mental development, physical health, and overall well being. AB 957 would center the health and welfare of a TGI youth by acknowledging that their affirming gender identity is in their best interest. It would allow them to be seen in our court system. Please join me in supporting this bill and demonstrating the Assembly's support for this important issue. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry, you are recognized.
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry
Legislator
Ms. Speaker and colleagues, I am proud to support AB 957 and thank my dear friend from Suisun City for her work on this important issue. Everyone should be able to have a name that reflects their gender identity and a home that allows them to feel comfortable in their own skin. This bill is an important step to protecting transgender, gender diverse, and intersex youth. I ask for your aye vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry. Assembly Member Zbur, you are recognized.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you. I want to rise today in support of AB 957 and I want to thank the author and the co-authors for this very important bill. As one of the Members of this body who has TGI members, family members, in my family, this is a really important bill. And we know from medical experts and experts that the thing that is most important to care for these kids is making sure that we support them and that we affirm them.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
This bill is an important tool that gives parents the tools they need to do exactly what we need to do for these kids, support them, affirm them, and love them. I ask for an aye vote. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Zbur. Assembly Member Haney, you are recognized.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, I rise in support of AB 957, and thank the Member from Suisun City for your leadership. This is a very scary, dangerous time for transgender youth. We're seeing all over the country and, sadly, all over our state, attacks on young people, attacks on their identity, attacks on them just being able to live as who they are. And here in California, we know that the best way that we can provide for all of our young people is through compassion.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
It's through affirmation, and it's through support. And this bill, I think, is such an important statement for who we are, and I have no doubt that it will save lives. I represent the Transgender Cultural District in San Francisco, and what we've seen is, when we embrace people's identity, especially young people, that their mental health, their physical health, their emotional health improves and has support as well. I very strongly support this bill and encourage an aye vote. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Haney. Assembly Member Cervantes, you are recognized.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. Today I rise in support for AB 957, and thank my colleague from Suisun City, my former seatmate, for bringing this bill up. Unfortunately, this bill deals with a scenario that is all too common for our community. Our families do not often accept us when we are brave enough and vulnerable enough to come out and be our true, authentic selves.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
This is true especially for our trans siblings, who have recently faced an increase of discrimination and violence for no other reason than being themselves. I am proud to see this bill on the Assembly floor today. I want to thank the author as an ally and as someone in our family, in our community, for bringing forth a piece of this legislation that actually helps protect the rights and dignity of transgender individuals.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
This has not been the case in other legislative bodies, as we've seen across our country, where legislation is targeting, discriminating against our transgender siblings. And we need to stand up here in California. Let me be clear. This bill is essential to California values. Dignity, diversity, acceptance, and willingness to protect the rights of all.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
As a member of the California LGBTQ Caucus, I want our transgender siblings to know we stand with you every single day, and we will make sure that in the Legislature, you hear it loudly and clearly from Sacramento. Please know that we believe that our transgender siblings' rights are going to be protected because they are human rights. And so, again, thank you to our colleague, and I hope you will join us in supporting AB 957.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Cervantes. Assembly Member Jones-Sawyer.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
And I want to thank Assembly Member Wilson for bringing this forward. I had a cousin that's transgender. Unfortunately, I'm using the word "had." As an African American in an African American community growing up, we weren't the most accepting. Matter of fact, we were probably hostile to transgender people when I was growing up and when we were kids. And some of the things that we used to do were horrific, even just the verbal things we said to my cousin.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
My cousin eventually was so distraught because he couldn't come to family functions, he wasn't really accepted, that he got hooked on drugs. He eventually died in San Francisco of a drug overdose, homeless, alone. It took about three months before the coroner's office was able to find my aunt and his mother so that we could bury him. That's my cousin. He should have not gone through that.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
And the torture he went through as a kid will always burn in my heart, will always burn in my memory, and I wish I had done more. And so I'm so grateful to you for doing this moving forward that we're able to do something for individuals that are in that dilemma, especially in our community, especially in the black community, we got to do more. So thank you, Assembly Member Wilson.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Jones-Sawyer. Assembly Member Mathis, you are recognized.
- Devon Mathis
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, this is a very difficult and touchy subject, and I truly appreciate the author's really trying to wrap her arms and her mind around what's happening with our transgendered youth. It's very touchy. And I think for parents because I have friends and family that have gone through this and have gone through the transitioning process. And these are those things that a lot of us don't really talk about because we don't really necessarily even know how to talk about them.
- Devon Mathis
Person
My one concern and the reason why I'll be laying off today and that I trust the author will be looking at moving forward, is we have to be very careful that we're not splitting parents who are trying to work through this together to split them apart on decisions. So I'm looking forward to seeing some of that being addressed in the future because we need to make sure that we're not dividing families during these touchy times. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Mathis. Assembly Member Wilson, seeing and hearing no others wishing to speak on this. Would you like to close?
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Thank you to all of my fellow colleagues across California who stood up to speak on this particular issue and ensure that transgender youth, adults, individuals are seen by the California Legislature. That is so important. At the very core of who we are, we all desire, no matter who we are, to be seen by people. And with your aye vote, you are doing that today.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
And I am so thankful to my colleague who sits next to me for speaking out, because that is part of the democratic process. Sometimes it looks messy. Sometimes we don't agree, but somehow, some way, we can get to where we need to do to make sure that every single Californian, no matter who they are, are taken care of. And that's what this bill does today.
- Lori Wilson
Legislator
It allows our court system to see TGI individuals, children, for who they are and allow that to be taken into consideration as a part of their discretionary role as a judge, as a part of their toolkit. And that's what this does. And so with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member. The Clerk will open the roll. All those who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote. All those vote who desire to vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Ayes, 51, Nos 16. The measure passes. Moving back to motions and resolution. Members, we have some guest introductions. Assembly Member Lowenthal, you are recognized for your guest introduction.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Before I go on, I would like to thank my colleague from Fairfield for that very, very important action here on the floor. And especially like to thank my colleague from Los Angeles for sharing that very personal story that I will never forget.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to recognize some of my constituents and members from the first congregational church of Long Beach in the gallery today. Would you please stand up? They are here to receive the governor's 2022 Historic Preservation Award for the very incredible work that they have done to preserve their beautiful church in downtown Long Beach. I can say as a member of the Jewish community in Long Beach, we have very fond connection with the people of the first congregational church.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
As a matter of fact, during high holiday services growing up, we were not able to meet in our temple because we didn't have enough people. And of course, the first congregational church very warmly welcomed us for high holiday services. So I personally have such fond memories. Originally built in 1914, this iconic building and congregation continues to bring people together, regardless of religion, sexual orientation, race, class or gender. To fully celebrate the intersection of arts and justice.
- Josh Lowenthal
Legislator
I want to congratulate them for this prestigious award and thank them for their tireless dedication to historic preservation. Please join me, members, in congratulating them on this great award.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. Lowenthal. And we are going to be moving back to business. On the daily file, the clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly bills 1043, 968, 1179, 435 with amendments, 555 with amendments, 963 with amendments, 1344 with amendments 77 with amendments, 839 with amendments, 1110 with amendments, 1079 with amendments, 425 with amendments, 43 with amendments, 99 with amendments, 242, 307, 314, 349, 387, 454, 507, 559, 705, 398, 63 with amendments, 1219 with amendments, 565, 318 with amendments, 319 with amendments, 1053 with amendments, 1215 with amendments, 529 with amendments, 988 with amendments, 837 with amendments, 1308 with amendments, 722 and Assembly Bill 759 with amendments.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you. All bills will be deemed read and all amendments will be deemed adopted. We will pass and retain file items 38 through 43. We have dispensed with file item 44. Pass and retain on file items 45 through 52. Moving to file item 53. HR 25. Regarding Caesar Chavez Day, the clerk will.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Read House Resolution 23. By Assembly Member Soria and others relative to Caesar Chavez Day.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Soria, you are recognized.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Thank you. Speaker and members, thank you for the opportunity to present House Resolution 23 commemorating Cesar Chavez Day on behalf of the California Latino Legislative Caucus. 96 years ago, Cesar Chavez was born. His impact on civil rights, community organizing, and the labor movement across the United States and the globe has been invaluable. In El Dia De Cesar Chavez, celebramos el legado de un campion de la justicia social. Y reconosemos la determincion de aquellos que continuan realizando su trabajo hoy en dia. It is an honor to introduce HR 23.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
As a daughter of farm workers and a Central Valley native. I worked alongside my parents in the Central Valley fields throughout my childhood and my family, and I recognized the legacy and opportunities that Cesar Chavez created not only for my family, but for others across this nation. Cesar Chavez is one of the country's most influential civil rights and labor movement leaders. In the face of adversity and injustice, Chavez fought against discrimination and blame inhumane practices.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
His rallying cry of "Si Se Puede" still rings true and serves as an incredible reminder of the strength in each of us and our entire Latino community when we join together and make our voices heard. On Cesar Chavez birthday and a holiday named in his honor, which was made happen on this floor, the Latino caucus celebrates his legacy. It encourages others, inspired by his leadership, to continue to build on the foundation he has laid before all of us.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Working alongside a number of different races and ethnicities, Chavez learned stories of other cultures and learned that the strength of a democracy comes from all of our cultures and backgrounds, working together. Cesar Chavez led countless peaceful strikes, boycotts and marches and gained respect from some of our greatest political and civil rights leaders, including Martin Luther King, Jr and Robert Kennedy. In 1962, Chavez and Dolores Huerta organized the Farm Workers Association, which would later become the United Farm Workers, the UFW.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Together, they advanced La Causa into a national movement. Chavez and USW led a 10,000 person march from Delano to Sacramento and organized a great boycott, ultimately leading to farm workers dignity, formally recognized by growers through the first farm workers contracts in California history. Last year, this body, and with the hard work of the United Farm Workers, fought to get AB 2183 signed to expand farm worker union rights and advance workplace safety.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Pero la lucha sigue. Let us all learn from Cesar Chavez's life and mission of nonviolence, social justice, and selfless service to others. Si se puede, y que viva Cesar Chavez. So, in closing, I respectfully ask for your aye vote on HR 23.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Members Soria. Assembly Members Zbur, you are recognized.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker, I rise on behalf of the California Legislative LGBTQ caucus in support of HR 23. While Cesar Chavez is primarily known for his work as a civil rights and labor leader and founder of United Farm Workers, he believed in social justice and fighting for the rights of all marginalized communities. He was an ally of the LGBTQ plus community. In 1987, Chavez attended and spoke at the second National March on Washington for gay and lesbian Rights.
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Today, the United Farm Workers continue the fight and many of his civil rights colleagues like Dolores Huerta, continues that as a member of the board of Equality California and as a strong advocate for the LGBTQ plus civil rights and social justice, Helen Chavez, his wife, once said, quote, "my husband spent his life fighting for dignity for all people."
- Rick Chavez Zbur
Legislator
Cesar was one of the first civil rights leaders to speak out for gays and lesbians because he understood that you can't demand equality for your own people while tolerating discrimination against anyone else. The efforts of Cesar Chavez are a reminder that together we can break down barriers, for it is only in unity that we may work towards equity and inclusion for all people. On behalf of the members of the LGBTQ Legislative caucus, I hope you will join us today in supporting HR 23. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Zebra. Assembly Member Ramos, you are recognized.
- James Ramos
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker, today I rise on behalf of the California Native American Legislative Caucus to join in celebrating the life, achievements, and example of Caesar Chavez. His paternal grandmother was an Indian from the mexican State of Chihuahua. During the early 1880s, family stories says his grandparents fled Mexico for Arizona to avoid being forced to join a posse hunting and killing Apache Indians. Caesar honored and cherished his grandmother's native roots.
- James Ramos
Legislator
When he passed away of natural causes in April of 1993, he was holding a book of Native American art. We celebrate his commitment to service, to justice, to learning and nonviolence, and the fierce pride he took in his roots. He respected the value of collaboration and knew what a united group of people could accomplish. Caesar was successful because of his willingness to work with others and the respect he gave to all.
- James Ramos
Legislator
From the Filipino workers he worked with to form the first farm worker union, to a multi faith group of leaders who gave their support to his cause, to fellow labor leaders in cities across the United States and the world. His work inspired hundreds and hundreds of people from all ages and walks of life to believe in themselves, to seek acknowledgment of their rights to decent working conditions such as water, shade, and toilets and the elimination of the shorthandled hole that left many crippled.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Ramos. Dr. Bains, you are recognized.
- James Ramos
Legislator
In his 1984 speech to the San Francisco Commonwealth Club, he reminded us why we must all remember that service to others, respect towards others, pushes the arc of justice forward. And I quote, once social change begins, it cannot be reversed. You cannot uneducate the person who has learned to read. You cannot humiliate the person who feels pride. And you cannot oppress the people who are not afraid anymore. I ask for your support of HR 23.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
Good morning, Madam Speaker. I rise on behalf of the Asian American Pacific island caucus in support of Cesar Chavez Day. What an amazing day it is today. Delano is now at the table. They marched from my hometown of Delano to Sacramento and they were denied to be seen by the Governor. He refused to leave this Ivory Tower and meet these people that had marched all the way from Delano to Sacramento. Now I proudly represent Delano as my hometown. We are now at the table.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
The work that was done with Cesar Chavez, along with Larry Itlong, Dolores Huerta, Esther Monsano, these were the people of my hometown. They marched recently and I was a Doctor in the City of Delano. There was an elderly man at that time that was marching in the over 100 degree weather. He passed out and he came to my clinic. And I asked him, I said, sir, as your Doctor, happy National Doctor's Day, by the way. As your Doctor, I am concerned about your health.
- Jasmeet Bains
Legislator
Marching in this extreme temperature. And you know what he told me? Dr. Bains? I'll do it again. This is the voice of Delano. In the State of California, there was one city that not just spoke, but rose altogether. They were not alone. They rose together to bring awareness to what was happening. Equal rights, equal pay, access to health care. And the struggle is not over. I proudly rise today in support and ask for your. I vote for Cesar Chavez Day.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Dr. Baines. Assembly Member Juan Carrillo, you are recognized.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Good morning, Mr. Speaker and members. Today I rise in support of HR 23 by Assembly Member Soria of serving March 31 as Cesar Chavez's birthday and as a day of public service. As I stand here on the assembly floor today, I am filled with deep sense of gratitude and honor to commemorate the life of legacy of El Gran Cesar Chavez.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
As an immigrant who came to this country at the age of 15, I never imagined ,nunca me imagine, that I would one day become a proud citizen of this great nation, raise a beautiful family, speak English and let alone serve as an Assembly Member. Proudly representing the 39th district of California. But here I am, aqui estoy, standing before you today. A testament to the American dream, El Sueno Americano, that Cesar Chavez worked hard to uphold.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Cesar Chavez was a visionary, a tireless advocate for farm workers, and a champion for social justice. He fought against discrimination and inequality, and his unwavering commitment to his cause inspired millions worldwide. As we commemorate Cesar Chavez on this day, we must remember that his legacy is not just a historical footnote, it is a call to action, es un compromiso. We must renew our commitment to the values he held dear. Justice, equality and opportunity. No es facil, it's not easy. It takes greed, determination, relentless spirit.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
But as Cesar Chavez once said, "we cannot seek achievement for ourselves and forget about progress and prosperity for our community." Our ambitions must be broad enough to include the aspirations and needs of others for their sakes in our own. We stand on the shoulders like Cesar Chavez, who paved the way for us to have a voice and make a difference for all. A que ser escuchar nuestra voz. As we remember his legacy, let us work together to build a California that reflects these values.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
A state where todos, everyone has a chance to succeed, no matter their background or circumstances. Let us stand in solidarity with our brothers and sisters fighting for the rights and dignity such as Cesar Chavez did. And let us never forget that our struggles and successes are intertwined. We are in this together. Recurda la union hace la fuerza. Thank you, Cesar Chavez, for preparing us to be the change we want to see in the world.
- Juan Carrillo
Legislator
Our pledge to continue fighting for our shared values and vision for a better future for all para todos. I also want to acknowledge the work of the Dolores Huerta along Cesar Chavez's side. Si se puede. Thank you m1embers.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Juan Carrillo. Assembly Member Cervantes, you are recognized.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members, today I rise as a proud co author, joint author and chair of the Latino Legislative Caucus in support of HR 23. The principles, the struggles and the values that motivated Cesar Chavez has inspired and motivated the members of the Latino caucus for the last 50 years.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Honoring Cesar Chavez cannot be timelier as many of the Latino caucus Members in the caucus seek support for the recently flooded regions of Santa Cruz and Monterey County, including the inundated farm worker town of Bajaro. Due to the current rains and floods, whether it's fighting for better jobs or better working conditions, improving access to healthcare, access to education, providing services to others, or simply having the respect and dignity of others, Cesar Chavez is a selfless example in the standard we all strive to follow.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
When my own father served as the mayor of the City of Coachella, he gave Cesar Chavez the first key to the city, and as a young child, that left a lasting impression on me. Cesar Chavez was and is a symbol of strength and hope in the central valley communities and across our country. Cesar Chavez the farm worker movement the fight for civil rights is deeply rooted in the history of Riverside County in the eastern CoachelLA Valley.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
In 1990, my father led the effort to name the Cesar Chavez Elementary School in Coachella. It was the first school in the state to be named in his honor. Cesar Chavez had a tremendous impact in advancing the united farm workers efforts and working to support farm worker rights. During the Delano grape strikes in 1965, Cesar Chavez came to Coachella, where my family joined the boycott and marched alongside and protested for better working conditions for all farm workers.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Chavez reminds us that social responsibility to serve our communities and ensure dignity and respect for all, especially for our most vulnerable, let us continue to honor his legacy by heeding the call to support our most vulnerable demand human dignity for all of our communities. La lucha continua for these reasons, colleagues are respectfully asked for an aye vote for HR 23.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Cervantes. Assembly Member Rubio, you are recognized.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members, I rise on behalf of the California Legislative Jewish Caucus in support of HR 23. Celebrating the legacy of Caesar Chavez Caesar Chavez worked every day to fight for the dignity of California farm workers. He has endowed California with a robust labor movement and taught us all ideas of great importance in community organizing and supporting our fellow workers. There is a strong Jewish connection to labor movement.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Caesar Chavez and farm workers Jewish trade workers played an integral role in the rise of labor in the late 19th and 20th and the early 20th century. When Caesar Chavez started organizing to fight the oppression of Latino farm workers, many Jewish leaders rose to his side in solidarity. Several orthodox rabbis urged their congregations not to buy nine union grapes, declaring them Oshek unclean because they came from exploited labor.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
Rabbi Joseph Glazer, Executive Vice President of Central Conference of American Rabbis, said, until the people who stoop and squat and go through all kinds of hell out there in the fields are treated right, those grapes are trafe, meaning not kosher. Chavez's wife, Helen, once shared a story from when the union was gaining momentum. After opening several donation checks, her sister turned to her and said, hey, sister, look. All these people have the same first name. Rabbi.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
The voice of Jewish community leaders were so prevalent in the farm worker movement that Caesar Chavez even began hosting annual Passover seders. Tragically, 17 year old Nan A. Freeman, was the first person to lose their life on a farm worker picket line. A college student from Boston, she traveled to Florida to join a strike and was killed by a truck crashing into the picket line. The Jewish value of fighting for justice has never stopped at the gates of the community.
- Blanca Rubio
Legislator
As we honor Cesar Chavez, we recognize this longstanding Jewish and Latino partnership and commit to continuing to strengthen this coalition in the fight against all oppression. In that spirit, and on behalf of the Jewish caucus, I respectfully urge an aye vote on HR 23.
- Marie Waldron
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members. I proudly rise to support HR 23, recognizing March 31 as Cesar Chavez Day.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Rubio. Assembly Member Waldron, you are recognized.
- Marie Waldron
Person
It is on this day that we recognize the hard work and self sacrifice farm workers go through to feed all the families in our state. We also look back and see the struggle these farm workers faced with discrimination and harsh work environments. Cesar Chavez led the way to bring dignity and protections to our farm workers. In his own words, he said, "we draw our strength from the very despair in which we have been forced to live. We shall endure."
- Marie Waldron
Person
San Diego County, which is home to my district, is the number one producer of avocados in the state and has more small family farms than any other county in the nation. We have many farm workers to thank. Cesar Chavez was a historic leader, and his legacy will live on for decades to come. I urge an aye vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Waldron. Assembly Member Jones-Sawyer, you are recognized.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
Thank you, Madam Chair. On behalf of the California Legislative Black Caucus, we proudly support HR 23.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
When you think about the legacy of Cesar Chavez, and most important, the legacy of black and brown alliance, when you think about Cesar Chavez on the West Coast and a Martin Luther King on the East Coast, the fact that the two never met, but they both had shared values, very important shared values that came from the teachings of Mahatma Gandhi, those teachings of nonviolence, those teachings of peaceful resistance, and those teachings of fasting.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
And during one of the fasts that Cesar Chavez was doing in 1968 for nonviolence, Martin Luther King wrote him a letter, which is probably the only communication they had. Think about it. Two of the most powerful civil rights leaders we probably ever had in our time only communicated once. And that's a letter from Martin Luther King to Cesar Chavez. And I'll read it to you. "I am deeply moved by your courage and fasting.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
As your personal sacrifice for justice through nonviolence, your past and present commitment is eloquent testimony to the constructive power of nonviolent action and the destructive impotence of violent reprisal. Your stand today is as a living example of the Mahatma Gandhi tradition with its great force for social progress and its healing spiritual powers. My colleagues and I commend you for your bravery, salute you for your work against poverty and injustice, and pray for your health and your continuing service as one of the outstanding men of America.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
The plight of your people and ours is so grave that we all desperately need the inspiring example and effective leadership you have given. Martin Luther King, Jr. President, Southern Christian Leadership Conference." Just shows you what you can do when you have shared value, when you believe in the same thing, but most important, when you know what you believe in is right. Those two men are shining examples of the power of what communities can do when they come together and move forward.
- Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer
Person
And so that's why we need to salute Cesar Chavez every day, in every way. Respectfully ask that we pass HR 23.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Joan Sawyer. Assembly Member Pacheco, you're recognized.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
Good morning, Madam Speaker and members. Today I rise on behalf of the Legislative Women's Caucus to speak in support of House Resolution 23 relative to Caesar Chavez Day. Caesar Chavez worked to create a farm workers union that changed the lives of thousands of workers in the United States. My grandfather being one of those workers who immigrated to the United States as part of the brasero program.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
This is something that is near and dear to my heart. I would like us to take a moment to also acknowledge the work of women such as Dolores Huerta, who tirelessly fought alongside Cessa Chavez. Her organizing skills were essential to the growth of the United Farm Workers Union. She negotiated contracts and advocated for safer working conditions. Thanks to their great work, we adopted the slogan "si se puede." The phrase was widely adopted and is still used other movements and in campaigns.
- Blanca Pacheco
Legislator
Cesar Chavez increased public awareness of farm worker working conditions today, Dolores continues being a living civil rights icon, fighting for better working conditions for farm workers, organizing people to run for office, and advocating on issues of health, education and economic development. For these reasons, I am pleased to proclaim Cesar Chavez Day and its recognition of the importance in some of our most vulnerable communities. And I therefore respectfully ask for your. aye vote in HR 23.
- Al Muratsuchi
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Pacheco.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Seeing and hearing no others who wish to speak on this. Assembly Member Soria, would you like to close.
- Esmeralda Soria
Legislator
Madam Speaker, first, I want to thank all my colleagues who rose in support today of House Resolution 23. I'd like to ask to open the roll first for co authors, and respectfully ask everyone for an I vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Soria. The clerk will open for co authors. All members vote who desire to vote. Members, this is for co authors. All members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The clerk will close the roll. There are 58 co authors. Without objection, we will now take a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. Yes. Absolutely. Assembly Member Cervantes, you are recognized for your remarks.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Madam Speaker and members, on behalf of the California Latino Legislative Caucus, you will find on your desk a beautiful piece of art and inspiration that reads, "preservation of one's own culture does not require contempt or disrespect for other cultures.' In honor of Cesar Chavez, on this consequential 50th anniversary year for our caucus, thank you so much.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Members. We're going to go back to guest introductions, and Assembly Member Chen, you are recognized for your guest introduction.
- Phillip Chen
Legislator
Thank you. Madam Speaker. I want to welcome the Orange County Classical Academy. We're sitting up in the gallery today with us. The Orange County Classical Academy is Orange County's only tuition free K through 12 education system and a charter school located in Orange, California. Classical Academy's goal is preparing future citizens through content rich education center in classics and great mentors. Students enjoy classical liberal arts curriculum encompassing history, english, math, visual and performing arts, laboratory, sciences, foreign language, and college prep electives.
- Phillip Chen
Legislator
My friends and my colleagues, please welcome our friends from Orange County Classical Academy to the California State Assembly. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Welcome and thank you, Assembly Member Chen. Moving back to business on the daily file, members, without objection, we are now moving to file item 66, SCR 6 by Assembly Member Petrie-Norris regarding the protest in Iran. Sorry, my apologies. We are actually going to move to Mr. Holden item number 60. Mr. Holden, you are recognized. The Clerk will read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly joint resolution one by Assembly Member Holden and others relatives to the Republic of Arctics.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Mr. Holden, you're recognized.
- Chris Holden
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members, I rise today to present AJR 1 which condemns Azerbaijan's blockade of Artsakh, also known as Nagorno Karabakh, and urges the United States government to take immediate action to assist the Armenians of Artsakh. The blockade of the Lashin Corridor, the only road connecting Artsakh to Armenia, began in December 12 2022. It has been more than 100 days where 120,000 Armenians, including 30,000 children, have faced life threatening shortages of vital provisions.
- Chris Holden
Person
I stand with the 120,000 Armenians of Artsakh. The 205,000 Armenians in California and all the members of the Armenian diaspora and request immediate humanitarian assistance to our sisters and brothers in Artsakh. This resolution has bipartisan support, and I urge your I vote on AJR 1 and the role be open for co authors.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Holden. Assemblymember Friedman, you're recognized.
- Laura Friedman
Person
Thank you. Madam Speaker and members, I rise today in strong support of AJR 1. I am very proud to represent the largest community of diaspora Armenians in the world, and I want to express to you how important this resolution and how deeply upsetting this issue is to the people in my community. Artsakh has been a traditional part of Armenia going back thousands of years, the churches bear ancient Armenian script. Armenians have lived in this region for thousands of years. Azerbaijan has mounted an unprovoked war against the Armenian people, using the civilians in Artsakh as cannon fodder.
- Laura Friedman
Person
And by cutting off a road, which is the primary way to get all manner of supplies between the mainland and Armenia and into the Armenians living in Artsakh. They have caused a humanitarian crisis in the region for no reason other than to try to remove the Armenians from this area, this historic area. It is a literal war of terror that is happening in this region against civilians.
- Laura Friedman
Person
My community has relatives, family members, people who live part of the time in Artsakh or Armenia, and part of the time in Glendale, Sherman Oaks, Hollywood, all over Los Angeles. And I would say that for those of you who represent areas like Fresno, it's the same situation. So to know that your family members right now are cut off from aid children, literally cut off from being able to be accessed by their parents, you can imagine how incredibly upsetting and tragic this is for so many Californians.
- Laura Friedman
Person
We in California and the United States need to send a very strong message to Azerbaijan and to the world community that this kind of terror against civilians will not be tolerated. With that, I urge an aye vote on AJR 1. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Friedman. Assembly Member Papan, you are recognized.
- Diane Papan
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I just want to thank the author for carrying this. As the only Greek American in this Legislature, Greeks have stood with the Armenians for a long time, and I concur with Assemblymember Friedman. This cannot be tolerated. I thank you for carrying it. Let's send a strong message that this is not acceptable. We cannot oppress our Armenian friends. Thank you for doing it.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Rivas, you're recognized.
- Luz Rivas
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker and members. I stand in strong support of AJR 1. As someone that represents a large Armenian community in the San Fernando Valley, I support this measure and urge the US government to take immediate action to help the Armenians in Artsakh. Thank you to the Member from Pasadena for introducing this measure, and I urge an aye vote.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Patterson, you are recognized.
- Jim Patterson
Person
Thank you very much. Members. I stand in strong support of AJR 1 and thank the member from Pasadena for bringing it forward. As was mentioned earlier by another member of the Legislature, Fresno is home of a huge number of Armenians, many from the diaspora, and it has been my joy to represent them both up here in the Legislature, but also for eight years as mayor of Fresno. And this is an outrage. It needs to be brought to the attention that it is given.
- Jim Patterson
Person
And I stand strongly not only with the author and others who have raised their microphones, but with the hundreds of thousands of Armenians that reside in Central California and in Fresno. This is something vital to them, very important, not only because of what's happening in the country, but it's what is happening in the hearts and the souls of Armenians in Fresno, in Central California. This touches them deeply as well, and it hurts. So thank you for the recognition. I strongly support it.
- Laura Friedman
Person
Thank you very much. Seeing and hearing no further debate. Mr. Holden, would you like to close?
- Chris Holden
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would just say appreciation to my colleagues who rose to speak in favor of this AJR 1. As what's been pointed out, so many people who live in California who are Armenian descent continue to feel the pressure and pain of a genocide that continues to go on even today, who have family members who are in Armenia and in this region that are hurting.
- Chris Holden
Person
And it has risen to the level where the world community needs to speak out. And not just speak out, but take action. And so this resolution calls on our Administration, our President, to vigorously intercede and ensure that humanitarian aid is delivered to the people of Artsakh.
- Laura Friedman
Person
Thank you. Clerk. Please open the roll for co authors. All members wishing to be, to co author the resolution, please indicate by voting aye. All those wishing to be added as a co author, please indicate by voting aye. All those wishing to be a co author, please vote aye. Okay, the Clerk will close the roll. There are 58 co authors. We'll now open the roll to vote for the resolution. All those wishing to vote, please vote. All those wishing to vote, please vote. All those wishing to vote, please vote. The Clerk will close the roll. There are 59. The vote is 59 to zero. The resolution is adopted.
- Chris Holden
Person
This has been going on for over 100 days, and you're talking about children who aren't being able to get educated, power being shut off during the harshest time of winter, supplies that need to get in to keep people alive and healthy and vibrant. And they are hurting.
- Chris Holden
Person
We are saying with this resolution today that we see you, that we're going to step forward and take this resolution action, as California has done for a very long time, standing with the Armenian community here in California and around the world. So I thank my colleagues for the strong voice of support, and I ask for your aye vote on AJR 1 and that the first roll be open for co authors.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Members, without objection, we're now moving to file item 66, SCr six, by Assemblymember Petrie Norris, regarding the protests in Iran. Assembly Member Petrie Norris, you are recognized.
- Reading Clerk
Person
The Clerk will read Senate Concurrent Resolution six by Senator Umberg and others relative to Iranian protests.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, today I rise to present SCR six, which proclaims the Legislature's solidarity with the people of Iran. In honor of Women's History Month and no ruse, the persian new year, I want to recognize the extraordinarily brave and remarkable women of Iran who have continued to risk their lives to protest the brutality of the Iranian government and their repression of basic human rights.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
On September 16 of last year, 21 year old Masa Amini arrived in Tehran to visit her family, but was subsequently arrested by the Iranian regime's morality police for allegedly wearing her hijab improperly. She was viciously beaten by the police and died while in custody. Masa's murder sparked an incredible uprising involving thousands and thousands of Iranians from all walks of life, teenagers, students, men and women of all ages, taking to the streets to protest the Iranian regime. Iranian government authorities responded with violence.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
According to the United Nations, at a minimum, hundreds of people have been killed while protesting. Thousands more have been arrested, many of whom are facing barbaric punishment. But that has not stopped the people of Iran from risking death or imprisonment every day to fight for a better and brighter future. I am really and truly in awe of their bravery. Their courage has inspired people all across the world to protest in solidarity.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Many of these demonstrations of support have taken place right here in California, which has the largest Iranian American population in the nation. I respectfully ask for your. I vote on this important measure and that the first roll be open for co authors today.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Petrie Norris. Seeing no others. I'm sorry, Mr. Patterson. Assembly Member Patterson.
- Jim Patterson
Person
Thank you. It's Jim Patterson, not Joe. Just. We get confused, apparently, but that's okay. It seems like today this body has stood to touch significant populations in Central California. First the Artsak and now the Iranian. We have a substantial and significant Iranian population.
- Jim Patterson
Person
I know many of them as friends, and they tell the stories of escaping and coming to the United States, and they look wistfully back to the homeland, hoping and praying that the spark of freedom that is the Iranian people's response to this brutality is the beginning of something significant. There is a significant Iranian population that really are hopeful and see perhaps a day when freedom, democracy, and the opportunity to live their lives as they see fit and so I stand in strong support.
- Jim Patterson
Person
This is an encouragement to the Iranians in California, as was mentioned, a significant population here. And we stand with them not only in their objection to the brutality, but we stand also with them in almost a revolutionary approach to standing for liberty and for freedom, and doing so at the risk of their life. That is heroic. And we stand with them.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Patterson, seeing no others wishing to speak, would you like to close?
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. And thank you to my colleagues who spoke in support of this measure. And thank you to all of my colleagues in the Assembly for standing today in solidarity with the people of Iran in their fight for freedom, for justice, for liberty, and for fundamental human rights. With that, I respectfully ask for your. aye vote on ser six, and that the first role be open for co authors.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will open for co authors. Members, this is for co authors. The Clerk will close and tally the votes. We have 64 co authors added without objection. We will now take a voice vote on resolution. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. The eyes have it. The resolution is adopted. Assemblymember Petrie Norris, you are recognized for your guest introduction.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you. Members, please join me today in welcoming Members of the Iranian American community who are here in the gallery for today's presentation. I want to thank our guests for your leadership all across California and all across our country. Please know that we stand with you. We stand with you in solidarity in support of the people of Iran as they fight for freedom and for fundamental human rights. Thank you for being here.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Now moving to file item 67, ScR 41 by Assembly Member Petrie Norris. Regarding Justice Ginsburg, the Clerk will read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate concurrent Resolution 41 by Senator Rubio and others relative to Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg Day.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Petrie Norris, you're recognized.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Good morning, Members. Today, I am very pleased to present SCR 41, which honors the life and legacy of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Today we remember, honor, and celebrate a wonderful role model, a pioneering jurist, and a truly phenomenal woman. As we celebrate women's history month, this is an opportunity to lift up those women whose shoulders that we all stand on.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Justice Ginsburg once said women belong in all places where decisions are being made, and I think she would be incredibly proud to see the record number of women serving in this body today. I sometimes think that the legend of the notorious RBG can obscure just how much Justice Ginsburg had to overcome the obstacles that she had to navigate and surmount in order to leave us with this profound legacy.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
RBG came of age in a time when women were rarely, rarely, if ever, part of the sphere where laws were made and adjudicated. A time when women were rarely, if ever, seen in the halls of the Capitol. A time when women were rarely, if ever, seen in the halls of the Capitol, sitting around a corporate boardroom or sitting on the federal bench. She was a trailblazer in the truest sense of the word. She graduated first in her class from Columbia Law School in 1959.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
She then became the first female Professor to earn tenure at her Alma mater and served as the first female Member of the Harvard Law Review and Columbia Law Review. She was a tenacious attorney dedicated to empowering women who face discrimination, harassments, and barriers to equality and equal participation. She went on to become the second woman appointed to the United States Supreme Court.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
She would serve there for 27 years and help shape American law and pave the path for civil and equal rights for women and for all Americans. We all owe her a tremendous debt of gratitude, particularly in light of the last year where we have seen women's fundamental freedoms come under assault across the world and right here in our own country. We must never take for granted the progress that we've made or the gains that we have won. We must continue to fight.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
We will not go back. We will not let RBG down. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your I vote on SCR 41.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Madam Majority Leader Reyes, you are recognized.
- Eloise Gómez Reyes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Members, today I rise on behalf of the California Latino Legislative Caucus in support of Senate concurrent Resolution 41. It is an honor to rise and celebrate the legacy of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a pioneer in some of the most important Supreme Court decisions, from LGBTQ rights to women's rights to Latino rights to human rights.
- Eloise Gómez Reyes
Legislator
Justice Ginsburg was the first female Member of the Harvard Law Review, completed law school with a child, co founded the ACLU Women's Rights Project, and was the second woman to ever be appointed to the US Supreme Court. Her legacy is not unlike many Latina attorneys in a male dominated field, oftentimes having to be the first. For many Latina attorneys like myself, prospective lawyers and law students, Justice Ginsburg was and is an inspiration.
- Eloise Gómez Reyes
Legislator
Some of Justice Ginsburg's efforts to protect our Latino community occurred in 2019, when she was an important vote in a 54 decision that blocked the Trump Administration from adding citizenship status to the 2020 census. In fact, she was a decisive vote and voice on issues like the Affordable Care Act and same sex marriage, the two landmark decisions that positively impacted millions of Latinos.
- Eloise Gómez Reyes
Legislator
One of her most recent efforts before her unfortunate passing included DHS v. Regents of the University of California, where she countered another attack on undocumented students. Ginsburg voted with a majority to impede the Trump administration's efforts to exterminate the DACA program. Her impact on U. S. Law through her opinions and voting record as a Supreme Court justice has benefited the lives of countless Latinos, people of color, women, and our marginalized communities. Her legacy will live on forever. For these reasons, colleagues, I respectfully ask.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
For your ivote seeing and hearing no others wishing to speak, Assembly Member Petrie Norris, you may close.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
Thank you. And thank you to our majority leader for those comments. Justice Ginsburg left us with so much inspiration and so many words of wisdom. One of my favorite quotes from Justice Ginsburg, she said, whatever you choose to do, leave tracks, leave the world a little bit better for your having been there. Members, I respectfully ask for your I vote today on SCR 41 as we honor the life and legacy of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
- Cottie Petrie-Norris
Legislator
And I respectfully ask that the first role be open for co authors.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will open the role for co authors. All Members, votes who desire to vote. All Members vote to desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. Members, this is for co authors. The Clerk will close the roll. There are 65 co authors added. Without objection, we will now take up a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members, the Women's Caucus, please Members of the Women's Caucus, please retire to the rear of the chamber for a brief photo in honor of Justice Ginsburg. Members moving back to file item 54, HR 24 by Assembly Member Wendy Carillo relating to Major League Baseball opening day.
- Reading Clerk
Person
The Clerk will read House Resolution 24 by Assembly Member Wendy Carillo and others relative to Major League Baseball opening day 2023.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Carillo, you are recognized.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
Okay, it's my Prop. Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, I am so proud to rise and present HR 24, commemorating Major League Baseball's 65th opening day in California.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
It was in 1958 that the New York Giants and the Brooklyn Dodgers, already linked through over half a century of history, took the leap and began their seasons in the West coast together for the first time in the decades before their arrival, the teams of the Pacific Coast League would play as long as the weather permitted, sometimes from late February to early December. But the arrival of those two teams in 1958 was a critical milestone.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
California was finally linked to the rest of the nations in America's favorite pastime it was only four years later when California would become America's most populous state. Today, Major League Baseball teams call California home than any other state. We have five teams that are points of civic pride, bring fans together and inspire young people in our communities. In the north, the teams are the San Francisco Giants and the Oakland Athletics.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
In southern Cali, it is home to the Los Angeles Dodgers, the Los Angeles Anaheim Angels, and, way down south, the San Diego Padres. These teams generate billions of dollars to our local and state economy, employ thousands of Californians across our state, sell millions of hot dogs, nachos, peanuts, Micheladas and give back to our communities in multiple ways, including philanthropy, efforts in education, youth sports and little leagues across the state.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
Their achievements have contributed to our culture, our californian identity, and countless arguments on where exactly is the divide between northern and Southern California. Often landing somewhere in Fresno, we're all looking at the Central Valley Members. While we may differ on our favorite teams, we can all recognize what they mean to our constituents. I'm very proud that the oldest ballpark west of the Mississippi is Dodger Stadium in my district.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
As a little girl from my parents'home in Boyle Heights, I would watch the colors of the sky amid California palm trees, change from hues of pink and orange and blues as the lights of Dodger Stadium turned on. I would listen to the voices of Jaime Harin and Vin Scully and hear the roar of the stadium. Those are the memories that continue to be built for many young people across our state. Throughout the years, California teams have achieved incredible feats, winning 14 World Series championships.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
Most recent amid Covid were our boys in blue, the Dodgers in 2020. California teams have also had 37 most valuable player awards and countless all star selections. So today, Members on opening day for America's favorite pastime, we recognize not only those achievements on the field, but baseball fans across our state, those who have invested in our California teams, and the thousands of players, coaches and staff Members who were born in, live in or realize their California dream.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
I respectfully ask for an aye vote and the first role be open for co authors. Let's play ball.
- Tasha Boerner
Legislator
Thank you, assemblymember Wendy Carillo. Assembly Member Boerner Hovath, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members. And good morning. I wanted to touch base with you all today because it's been a great week for San Diego sports fans. The Padres have started off with a great season, and the SDSU Aztecs are headed to the final four. At this rate, it won't be a curveball to see that the Padres secure a historic victory for the city with a World Series win.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
I want to remind my colleagues that you can't reign on our Padres parade. I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you Assembly Member Wicks. You are recognized.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
Thank you Madam Speaker and Members. As a fan and supporter of the Oakland A's, I rise in support of HR 24. I also want to take a few moments to share some interesting facts about my favorite team. The A's were one of the 8th original American League franchise when the league was born in 1901. Of the 30 teams that make up Major League Baseball, the A's have the third most World Series titles and one of the longest records of success.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
The team was founded in Philadelphia in 191 as the Philadelphia Athletics. They moved to Oakland in 1968 and have since been known as the Oakland Athletics. The Oakland A's are simply the A's. In 2002, the A's set the record for most consecutive wins in a single season with 20 and an event that would go on to be pioneering step in the application of saber metrics, aka moneyball, in baseball.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
The A's have never been afraid to innovate from moneyball to the first fan wave at a sporting event, drummers and the bleachers and inventing the pitcher closer role. A's hosted the first free game in Major League Baseball, welcoming more than 50,000 fans to the ballpark in 2018 to celebrate the team's 50th anniversary in Oakland. They donate more than $2 million annually back to the community and today at A's season begins. The first pitch of the season marks hope, enthusiasm and team spirit.
- Buffy Wicks
Legislator
I invite and encourage you all to attend an A's game. It's really easy to get there. You can take public transportation. Los Angeles, we will welcome you with open arms and the fans with a tailgater too. There are magnetic pins for each of you. Lastly, take me out to the ballpark. Let's go Oakland A's and join me in supporting HR 24.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Joe Patterson, you are recognized.
- Joe Patterson
Legislator
Thank you very much, Members. I know my colleagues from San Francisco like to take credit for the success of the San Francisco Giants, but I'd like everybody to know that the starting pitcher today for the Giants'first home game is Rockland hero and legend, Logan Webb. Thank you for an I vote on this resolution.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member Haney, you are recognized.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I rise today as the proud representative of the home of the San Francisco Giants, Oracle park, and the city and County of San Francisco, which I share with my friend Mr. Ting and a Member of the bipartisan San Francisco Giants caucus I want to thank my colleague from Los Angeles for her leadership and for all of the representatives of the five teams across our state and for reminding everyone that California is truly a baseball state. I also grew up playing baseball.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I played like so many young people across our state. Little league. I actually played on a little league team with my sister that my mom coached and then went on to go to hundreds of games. As a lifelong fan of the San Francisco Giants, I remember one of my fondest memories as a young person was going with my dad and my sister to the World Series, the battle of the Bay at a game before the 1989 earthquake.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
The San Francisco Giants are a quintessential San Francisco team, but they have fans that stretch throughout California and beyond. Part of that is because they've demonstrated a commitment to California. The Giants are the only major league team with two minor league affiliates in California, and I want to give a shout out to our AAA Sacramento Rivercats as well as the Single A San Jose Giants.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And though the San Francisco Giants open today in New York, the San Jose Giants open their season at home April 6 against the Fresno Grizzlies, and the Sacramento RiverCats open their season April 4 against the El Paso Chihuahuas. Without a doubt, the Giants are a historic and accomplished team, not only in Major League Baseball, but in all major American sports.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
As you heard, they were founded in the late 18 hundreds alongside the Brooklyn Dodgers, and they both came here to California at a time when California was growing. And they put a flag in the ground not only for the future of baseball in our state, but the future of one of the most historic rivalries. This is the 66th year that the Giants have been playing in San Francisco, and over those 65 seasons, more than 125,000,000 fans have attended games at Candlestick Seals Stadium and Oracle park.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
One thing that I learned in preparation, and I did not even know this as a Giants fan, the Giants have more wins than any team in the history, not only of baseball, but of all professional sports. They also hold the second highest winning percentage of any major League baseball team. They have the most players who've been inducted to the hall of Fame and some of the most iconic trailblazing players, Orlando Cepeda, Willie Mays, Juan Marishaw, Willie McCovey and Barry Bonds rank as some of our greats.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
I should note, and I'm sure my colleague will have a rebuttal here. I also checked our lifetime history of wins and losses against all of the other teams in California. And yes, the Giants do have a lifetime winning record against the Dodgers, a lifetime winning record against the Padres and the Angels. The only team that has us beat is the A's. So the A's have a better record. We won three championships, which brought incredible joy in 20102012 and 2014.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And I also want, and this is true for all of our teams, an incredible commitment to the community. The junior Giants, 23,000 young people participating in their program, including youth scholarships, the Willie Mays scholar program benefiting African American youth in San Francisco. Baseball is truly an American pastime. It's a California pastime.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And thanks to the incredible contributions of the Giants and also the A's, and also the Angels and Padres, and yes, even the Dodgers, we are blessed to have such a strong, successful and enduring baseball state. Happy Baseball day. Opening day. Let's play ball. Thank you again to my colleague. I look forward to having a better record against the Dodgers this year than last year.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Luis Rievis. You're recognized.
- Luz Rivas
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker and Members, I stand in strong support of HR 24 on behalf of the Los Angeles County Legislative delegation, I want to thank the Member from Boyle Heights for introducing this resolution and for sharing her memories of Dodger Stadium. And I know people may not believe it, but there are public transportation options to Dodger Stadium, especially from Union Station. You can take a shuttle, and there are other ways to get there via public transportation. I strongly urge an I vote. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Seeing and hearing no others wishing to speak, Assemblymember Wendy Carillo, you may close.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
Thank you, Madam Speaker. It's just so wonderful to see so many colleagues really celebrate our love for the sport, but really the collegiality behind what it means to truly represent California. The Members from La County wearing blue, Padres brown and yellow, angels red, and Oakland A's, green. It's just so wonderful to see it all here. And so, again, this is about enjoying a beautiful sport, but really the economic impact to our state and all of the fans across the State of California.
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
So with that, respectfully request an eye on HR 24 on today opening day of baseball. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Assembly Member, would you like the first roll call to be for co authors?
- Wendy Carrillo
Person
Yes, please.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote to desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. There are 61 co authors added without objection. We will take a voice vote on the resolution. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members, if you are interested in joining in for a photo in mark of opening day of major league Baseball, please retire to the rear of the chamber, Members. We're going to wait till the end. There's actually a few other opportunities for photos, so we'll move that all to the end. Before we move on, we've got some guest introduction. Claremont College politics class is here. I'd like to welcome them. Along with those introductions, I'd like to recognize Assembly Member Juan Alanis for his guest introduction.
- Juan Alanis
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Speaker, my fellow Members, today we will be voting on AB 1467, which would establish Navea's Youth Sports Safety act, which expands on current law to ensure our children have life saving automatic external defibrillators, or commonly known as aeDs, at all youth sports events and practices. I am proud to be the author of this Bill, which is named after Navea Johnson. Navea was a 10 year old girl from Waterford, California, who passed away tragically last year at her cheerleading practice.
- Juan Alanis
Legislator
Had a working aed been readily available, Navea might have been alive today. Today we are joined in the gallery by Navea's family, Tiana, her mother, her grandfather Chuck, her brother Gage, and her grandmother Lori. We are all grateful for your support of AB 1467 and colleagues. Please help me in welcoming them up in the gallery. Thank you.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Members, if I can ask you to please return to your desk. We are now going to move to a special recognition of the Golden State warriors, and I ask that Mr. Haney is going to be recognized at the desk of Ms. Reyes for his guest introduction. Mr. Haney.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
All right, so this has been a fun day and thank you all for your patience with this as well. As you can see, we have some very special guests here with us in the chamber, both in the back and in the front. And I want to, on behalf of the millions of warriors fans across our state and the many here in this chamber, including my colleague from San Francisco, Mr. Ting, our colleagues from Oakland, the longtime home of the Golden State Warriors.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Ms. Wicks and Ms. Bonta welcome and honor the guests representing the 2022 NBA champion Golden State warriors. We also have here with us behind me, the Larry O'Brien championship trophies from 201520172018 and most recently, 2022. The 2022 NBA championship win is the 7th championship in warriors franchise history.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
Golden State has won four NBA titles, all of them here behind us in the span of eight years, becoming the first Bay Area sports team and the fourth NBA team to win at least four championships in a span of eight years. They have the greatest shooter in basketball, Steph Curry, who I'm told wanted to be here but has to prepare for a big win tomorrow night, as well as the second best shooter in history, NBA history, Clay Thompson.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
They have incredible ownership, management and staff, and under warriors head coach Steve Kerr, they have won 22 of their 24 playoff series, the highest playoff series winning percentage for a head coach in NBA history. Though each of the four recent championships was memorable in its own right, the 2022 championship was likely the sweetest of them all. As Steph Curry said postgame after the final championship game, this one hit different. This one hit different, for sure.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
The warriors started the 202122 season with very distant odds to return to the finals, having just posted the worst record in the NBA in 2019 and still without Clay Thompson, who was injured at the start of last season. Despite all that, they absolutely crushed the competition to their fourth title in eight years, finishing with a 16 and six mark, including a four to two NBA Finals win over the Boston Celtics.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
And I hope winning against the Boston Celtics is even something that our Lakers friends here can support. The Golden State warriors are the gold standard for a professional team, and we here in the State Assembly are so proud of them and their success and congratulate them on their historic run and championships. I want to recognize our guests who are here on the floor today. Kalena Azabuke, former player and current broadcaster if you listen to the warriors, that's his voice.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
He's the one who is our broadcaster for our team now. Aaron Dangerfield, the Senior Vice President for people and culture Vanessa Gonzalez, the public affairs manager Miguel Guerrero, the senior public affairs coordinator Connor Santel, the public affairs assistant Alex Huerta, the special events representative and Kyle Jefferson, the other special events representative. If you will please give them and the Warriors a huge round of applause and our congratulations on the behalf of the State Assembly.
- Matt Haney
Legislator
For those who are interested, you can take photos, and I also want to thank them because they're making the trophies available also to all of our staff and everyone who works in the building to come and take photos with them as well. Thank you everyone. Have a great recess.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Thank you, Assembly Member Haney Assembly Members, we will now move to the second day consent calendar. Before we vote, we will first take up resolutions on the consent calendar for the purpose of adding co authors. The Clerk will read the resolution on the consent calendar.
- Reading Clerk
Person
[Resolutions on consent calendar].
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll to allow any Members to add on as co authors to the resolution. Members this is a vote for co authors. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote to desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll. There are 55 co authors Members we will pass and retain on item 87, AB 87. Moving to a vote on the consent calendar, does any Member wish to remove an item from the consent calendar?
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Seeing and hearing none. The Clerk will read the second day consent calendar.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1467 by Assembly Member Alanis an act relating to youth health.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
The Clerk will open the roll on the consent calendar. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote who desire to vote. All Members vote to desire to vote. The Clerk will close the roll and the Clerk will close the roll and tally the votes. Ayes 57 noes 23 the consent calendar is adopted. The Clerk will read the remaining items on the consent calendar.
- Reading Clerk
Person
[Consent calendar].
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Moving to announcements, Members, we have a belated birthday. Assembly Member Waldron's birthday was on Tuesday, March 28. I'm ordering the desk to remain open for Committee reports following session. Members then staff will allow to queue up for photos in the chamber with the warriors trophies. Members, please note that spring recess begins upon adjournment. The session schedule is as follows. Friday, March 31 is Sister Sabbath holiday.
- Stephanie Nguyen
Legislator
Monday, April 3 through Friday, April 7 spring recess no floor session no check in session Monday, April 10 floor session at 01:00 p.m. Seeing and hearing no further business, I'm ready to entertain a motion to adjourn. Ms. Reyes moves. Mr. Gallagher, seconds that this House stands adjourned until Monday, April 10, at 01:00 p.m. The quorum call is lifted, and pursuant to joint Rule 51, this House stands adjourned for spring recess.
No Bills Identified
Speakers
Legislator
Advocate