Senate Floor
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Quorum is present. Colleagues, if we could return to our desk and please rise. We will be led in prayer by Sister Michelle Gorman. After which, please remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance. Sister.
- Michelle Gorman
Person
So we gather in God's presence again. In her poem, A Brave and Startling Truth, Maya Angelou tells us a startling truth about ourselves as humans. That we have the ability to create peace and freedom for all.
- Michelle Gorman
Person
We this people on this minuscule and kithless globe who daily reach for the bomb, the blade and the dagger, yet who petition in the dark for tokens of peace. Out of such chaos, of such contradiction, we learn that we are neither devils nor divines.
- Michelle Gorman
Person
And when we come to it, we this people, on this wayward floating body have the power to fashion for this earth a climate where every man and every woman can live freely without sanctimonious piety, without crippling fear.
- Michelle Gorman
Person
And when we come to it, we must confess that we are the possible, we are the miraculous, the true wonder of this world. That is when and only when we come to it. So gracious God give us the courage to trust in our ability to create peace and may we all take the steps necessary to achieve it.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Please join me in the pledge. I pledge allegiance. Senators, before we begin, we have a message from our pro temple.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Thank you so much, Madam President. Good morning. And grateful for all the work that has been going in here in this final week and what I'd like to be able to do for the body and for all of those in the gallery, talk a little bit about a run of show for the rest of the week and making sure that we're on the same page and just happy to have conversation as well.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Today is going to be another busy day as we look towards the end of the week. We have a lot of work to do here on the floor and then of course, as we go into after hours. So here is the schedule for today. We'll work till lunch, take a short lunch break. We'll then work till dinner.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Dinner we will have committees, a few committees that will be happening during the dinner hour. We will then come back after dinner to to be able to complete our daily business.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
It is going to be a long day today and we are sincerely grateful to all of your work and to the work of the Senate staff who are working overtime making sure that this body is moving smoothly. Tomorrow we will reconvene at 10am we will have our lunch break.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Then we are going to have committees during the dinner hour. We may reconvene depending on the Bill low that we're able to get through here today. Would expect, ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, that we are going to be going late tonight and would expect that we'll be going late tomorrow night.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
But if we can get a lot of work done today, that may save us from coming back after committees. But if it's all right with the body, we'll also work with a Republican leader as well and that we'll get back to you in regards to the evening schedule after committees tomorrow. Then we'll look at Friday.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Friday will have a 10am start and would expect folks to be able to pack extra socks because we are going to be working late, ladies and gentlemen, here into the evening on Friday. I would anticipate, I would anticipate that we are going to be working into the morning hours of Saturday.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
I will also give a flag to this entire body that we will most likely be coming in on Saturday morning to be able to complete our business Saturday morning. More to come on that. But I would anticipate that this body will be reconvening Saturday morning to be able to complete our business in a specific schedule.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Will be sent out to this body and to all the offices here within the next day about Saturday. We've got a lot of work in front of us and I want to end it with this. Thank you. Thank you for your diligence. Thank you for your hard work. Thank you for your focus.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
We have dispensed with a few hundred bills thus far and I also want to say thank you to our partners in the Assembly as we are moving forward and transferring bills back and forth and very grateful to Speaker Rivas, his team for the partnership as well, Madam President.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Really appreciate the opportunity to be able to do a look ahead. And Madam President, I know what you had said to me this morning. Is there a way that we can see each other over the weekend? This entire group and dreams do come true. So I'm sure we'll be back together on Saturday. Saturday morning. Madam President, I'll turn it over to you. I yield my time
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Members, we are on motions, resolutions and notices. Any Member wish to be recognized during this time. Pursuant To Senate Rule 29.10 D, the following bills are referred to the Committee on Rules 5. File item 78, which is SB 627. File item 84, SB 663 and file item 93, SB 805. Senator Cabaldon is recognized.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. I request that AB 1246 file item 262 be removed from the special consent. Calendar and return to third reading.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
Yes. Thank you, Madam President. I to pull AB929 Connolly and move it to the inactive file. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The desk is noted. Thank you. Senator. We do have to recognize one more request, but we need a little bit of time. Take a quick pause it. We will now recognize Senator Gonzalez.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. There is a resolution at the desk. Requesting permission to suspend Joint Rules 61. And 62A, to allow AB 825 and. AB 1207 to be amended on third. Reading past the deadline and to be heard in Committee's passed the deadlines during. The blackout and without sufficient notice. This request has been approved by the Rules Committee.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, respectfully object and urge a no vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you. Senator Valldares is asking for a no vote. Senator Gonzalez is asking for an aye vote. Secretary, please read
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes, 30, noes. Eyes. The joint rules are suspended. Eyes, 30 noes, 8. The joint rules are suspended. There are four amendments at the desk without objection, they will be deemed read and Adopted. Moving into consideration of the daily file, we have items 1 through 10 under second reading. File Secretary, please read ...Reading will be deemed read.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Moving on to unfinished business. Colleagues, we are starting off with bills that do not enjoy support. Support. Just for your awareness, Starting off with file item 30, S.B. 369. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 369 by Senator Padilla an act relating to the Salton Sea.
- Steve Padilla
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB369 is back on. Concurrence amendments in the Assembly Apply this. Bill to projects in excess of $1 million. The Bill has received bipartisan support. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I see no mics up on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No 0. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Senator Padilla, you have the following item SB388. Secretary, please refile item 32.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 388 by Senator Padilla an act relating to state government.
- Steve Padilla
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB388 is back on concurrence. Amendments in the Assembly reduced the term. Of a Commissioner from four to two years. Bill has no opposition, received bipartisan support. Respectfully asked for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Give us. Give the secretary one second. He's tracking all the changes right now. Who's next? We got Senator Choi.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Seeing, we've captured everything. Ayes 32, noes 8. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Senator Arreguin has filed item 37. Secretary, please read SB524,
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 524. By Senator Arreguin an act relating to law enforcement agencies.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB524 is back on concurrence. The Bill required law enforcement agency to disclose whether an official report was generated either fully or partially by artificial intelligence. Amendments taken the Assembly were in collaboration with law enforcement groups to clarify what constitutes an officer's official statement and an official report.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
The amendments also put guardrails around how this information can be used by a contracted vendor to protect sensitive personal information. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No. Mics up. This item will be placed on call. Going through the roll call just once. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Arreguin moves to call. Senator again, you have the following item as well. File item 58. S.B. 304. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 304 by Senator Arreguin and act related to public lands.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB304 is back on concurrence. This is a district Bill that would temporary lift the public trust use restrictions for specific land in Jack London Square, which will allow the Port of Oakland to lease this land for any use, but would be required to meet Certain conditions. Amendments taken.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
The Assembly represent a mutual agreement between the Port of Oakland, City of Oakland and the State Lands Commission. This Bill passed the Assembly floor unanimously. There is no opposition. Respectfully asked for an aye vote.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
Yeah. This Bill was originally supportable, but with the amendments, it will no longer be supported, supportable. Thank you, Senator.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This Bill is intended to ensure that Jack London Square, which is an important commercial district in the City of Oakland, that we can fill commercial vacancies. 54% of the ground floor space is currently vacant. And we have worked with the State Lands Commission to reach agreement.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And that's the scope of the amendments, with specific guardrails to ensure reporting to the State Lands Commission, to reactivate this space and to bring economic vitality to the City of Oakland. This is a district Bill. Respectfully asked for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Areguin moves to call. Senator Laird. You have file item 60 SB 333. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 333 by Senator Laird an act relating to taxation.
- John Laird
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. Senate Bill 333 is back on concurrence Assembly amendments at a sunset date of January 12032. I respectfully asked for an aye vote on the concurrence. The amendment.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Laird moves to call. Senator Wiener, you have file item 69 S.B. 497. Ready to go. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 497 by Senator Wiener, an act relating to healthcare and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. Colleagues, SB497 is back on concurrence. Amendments in the Assembly reflect technical assistance from CDCR, remove intent language and address chaptering issues with AB82.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
SB497 will help ensure that we protect individuals seeking medically necessary health care and health care, as well as their allies and that we protect them against hostile actors in or outside of California. The Bill is co sponsored by our LGBTQ Legislative Caucus, Planned Parenthood, Equality California Trans Family Support Services and Trans Youth Liberation. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Wiener moves to call Senator Durazo with file item 74.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 580 by Senator Durazo, an act relating to state government.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I'm back on the Senate floor for a concurrence vote. The amendments are technical and clarifying in nature. SB 580 strengthened the attorney general's model policies with clear guidance to state and local agencies on how to protect our communities when confronted with civil immigration enforcement.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Despite guidance from the Attorney General, some sectors remain without clear instructions, leaving public sector workers unprepared, sensitive data exposed, and the public at risk. During these unprecedented times, state and local agencies must follow Attorney General guidelines to protect communities, public employees, and ensure they have safe access to essential public services like schools, libraries, parks, emergency services, and hospitals. I thank you and ask you for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazo moves to call. Senator Pérez is ready to go with file item 77.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 610 by Senator Pérez, an act relating to housing.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB 610 is back from the Assembly on concurrence. This bill provides greater protections for tenants and homeowners following a disaster as part of the Senate Wildfire Golden State Promise. Amidst January 2025 wildfires, disaster impacted residents were vulnerable to manipulation and exploitation by a lack of clarity for post-disaster protections and existing law for tenants and homeowners.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
SB 610 provides this clarification by establishing a presumption that debris renders a unit uninhabitable, clarify landlord responsibility for repairing damage, and clarify tenants are not obligated to pay rent during an evacuation order.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
In addition, SB 610 requires the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation Commissioner coordinate with mortgage lenders and servicers upon an emergency declaration for a wildfire to facilitate mortgage forbearance for people financially impacted by the fire. Assembly amendments address opposition raised by the mobile home park owners and the California Apartment Association. At the appropriate time, I ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. Seeing no mics up on this matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Pérez moves the call. Senator Pérez, you have the next one, file item 80. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 634 by Senator Pérez, an act relating to local government.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB 634 is back for concurrence. SB 634, the Unhoused Service Providers Protection Act, will prohibit local and state government entities from adopting an ordinance or enforcing an existing ordinance that prohibits a person or organization from providing basic survival services or resources to an unhoused person.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Unfortunately, some local governments are pursuing ordinances to persecute and neutralize unhoused service providers with threats of fines and jail time, including the City of Fremont adopting an ordinance earlier this year that included language to make providing aid to people aiding and abetting. That language had to be pulled back due to significant public outcry. Amendments in the Assembly further refined the policy with collaboration from local cities. I respectfully ask your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Pérez moves the call. Senator... Not here. Colleagues, we're going to move into Assembly third reading. Senator Durazo, you have the first item up with file item 103, AB 1430. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1430 by Assembly Member Bennett, an act relating to local government.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB 1430 is a simple bill that helps our county recording fees catch up with inflation. This will be the first time these fees have been adjusted since 2010. Since then, we have seen 34 recorders offices have shifted to using county general funds because their fees have not kept up with rising costs.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
The work that recorders offices staff do is critical for processing documents like deeds and trusts to ensure home buyers don't have a delay in getting the keys to their home. However, unless we help these fees catch up with inflation, recorders offices will have to continue relying on general funds or begin making difficult staffing decisions while finding ways to maintain service. This bill has no opposition. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazo moves the call. Senator ArreguĂn has filed item 116, AB 632. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 632 by Assembly Member Hart, an act relating to local government.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB632 on behalf of Assemblymember Hart. AB632 will provide local governments with the authority to collect penalties through an expedited process for egregious violations. Currently, cities and counties are able to enforce local ordinances by imposing administrative fines and penalties that may be collected through property liens.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Unfortunately, the existing penalty statutes are not well suited to address serious code violations such as illegal cannabis activities, substandard housing conditions, and serious fire hazards. The Bill, AB 632, allows local governments to obtain an order for a money judgment for unpaid fines after multiple notices, a full administrative process, and various options for appeal.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This model can be effective in cases where existing code enforcement mechanisms may be insufficient, such as in the case of slumlords or illicit cannabis operations whose assets are hidden or who can move jurisdictions quickly. These safeguards strike the appropriate balance of fairness while allowing local governments to hold those who break the law accountable.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Senate amendments narrow the Bill to the most serious substandard housing and fire code violations, clarify the required completion of judicial review before the imposition of a lien, and extend the noticing period. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No mics. Senator Caballero, you're recognized on this item.
- Anna Caballero
Legislator
Thank you very much. Madam President, I just want to ask a question and my apologies for not contacting you earlier. This was one of the bills I was a little bit concerned about because what this does is it provides an opportunity, as I recall, to put liens on property because the fines haven't been paid. And part of the challenge.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator, can I first ask if the author would take a question? Would the author take a question? Please proceed.
- Anna Caballero
Legislator
Yes. Thank you. So the question, the issue I'm concerned about is many times, especially seniors, have issues with their. They own the home, they can't keep it up, it starts deteriorating. We all have seen this.
- Anna Caballero
Legislator
If we precinct walked before and there is the risk that they'll lose the house if there's a lien and the local government acts to take control of the property. And I'm wondering if there's any protections for those situations. I support what the Bill is trying to do.
- Anna Caballero
Legislator
I just want to make sure we're protecting individuals that may not be capable of handling their personal affairs and then get caught in this situation.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you for the question. A couple points. One around due process. You know, local agencies can file with Superior Court after they've exhausted the administrative review process. So they can't just go immediately to court and get a judgment.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And a proper lien requires that there's a notice of violation and that there's an opportunity for somebody to have due process through the administrative review process. With respect to the housing portion, the Committee amendments narrow the state housing law piece, so it just applies to violations of Health and safety code Section 17920.3.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
So this will ensure that this only addresses the most serious problems that endanger livability. And so I think the Bill is trying to strike a balance to ensure adequate safeguards, but create an expedited process and really just focus on the most egregious circumstances.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
In the case of somebody who just isn't properly maintaining the property, this Bill in this current form would not impact those circumstances.
- Anna Caballero
Legislator
Understand. Thank you very much for that explanation. Thank you, Madam President.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. And Senator Arreguin, I'll give you an opportunity to close.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you to the Senator for Merced for her question. As this bill's moved through the legislative process and with the input of Members of the Senate committees that has gone through, we have narrowed the scope of it to make sure that we're really focusing on the circumstances where there are the most serious code violations.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And there have been multiple efforts through notice, through administrative processes to try to ensure compliance and to create a more expedite process for cities to impose fines and to ensure accountability. Respectfully, as for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Areguin moves a call. Senator Durazo with file item 135. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 538 by Assembly Member Berman, an act relating to public works.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. This bill continues the Legislature's commitment to prevailing wage and ensures that workers are paid what they are rightfully owed. Existing law allows the public to request certified payroll records from the awarding body to ensure compliance with prevailing wage requirements on public works projects.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
However, there have been an increasing number of instances where the awarding body has not provided payroll records simply because they do not have the records in their possession at the time of the request. In response, AB 538 would establish a process and timeline for awarding bodies to receive certified payroll records from the contractor without placing additional liability on the awarding body to ensure public works projects comply with prevailing wage requirements and main the transparency of public funds. I respectful ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No discussion on the item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazo moves the call. Senator Durazo, it's your show right now. You have file item 145. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 858 by Assembly Member Lee, an act relating to employment.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. This bill is a common sense bill that ensures that hospitality and service workers who were laid off during the COVID 19 pandemic will continue to have rehiring protections. There are no enforcement provisions in current law that allow the Labor Commissioner to continue the investigations that are still open when COVID 19 rehiring laws are sunsetted.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
This loophole could cause investigations that have not concluded by the sunset date to be dropped and laid off workers whose cases have not been closed will not receive their rightful compensation. This bill allows the Labor Commissioner more time to conclude investigations by extending the rehiring laws to December 2026 and closes this loophole by clarifying that violations will remain enforceable after the sunset date. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazo moves the call. Senator Stern is ready to go on file item 170. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 740 by Assemblymember Harabidian an act relating to Energy.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Thank you. Members, I rise to present AB740. This Bill will take advantage of the. Power that's already at our fingertips in. Our houses through our home batteries, our water heaters, our thermostats and all kinds of distributed energy supplies.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
The they can now be taken advantage of in a way that utilizes that system of distributed energy in homes and businesses. These are called virtual power plants. This Bill is a planning Bill, though it makes no regulatory changes and poses no new fees and simply is an. Effort to make sure the CEC is.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Prepared to look at this viable new technology to allow for us to unlock the grid more, not rely so much. On gas peaker plants and reduce our. Bills at the same time. Respectfully ask for your Ivo.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern moves a call. Senator Stern moves. Senator Perez. You have file item 172.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 419 by Assembly Member Connolly, an act relating to educational equity.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise today on behalf of Assembly Member Connolly to present AB 419. This bill will require schools to post the California Attorney General's Immigration Enforcement Actions at California Schools Guide for Students and Families, also known as Know Your Educational Rights, in schools and on their website and administrative buildings.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
This guide informs students and families of their educational rights and protections under law, including the right to a free public education and the confidentiality of their personal information. AB 419 would ensure protections for students, staff, and faculty by providing critical resources in the case of an ICE raid.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Recent amendments are clarifying and technical in nature as well as address chaptering out issues. This bill received bipartisan support and has no opposition. I respectfully ask for your aye vote on AB 806 or AB 419. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Pérez moves the call. Senator Cabaldon with file item 178. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 564 by Assemblymember Haney an act relating to taxation to take effect immediately. Tax levy
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. I'm here to present ABC 564 by Assembly Member Haney. This Bill defers by three years the 25% increase in the cannabis excise tax. Proposition 64 passed over by California voters tried to accomplish several things at once. Number one, make cannabis legally available and safe for Californians. Number two, shut down the illicit market.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Number three, support a wide variety of environmental, social and educational programs. That is, that deal is fraying because the market is collapsing. And today legal businesses in California capture just 40% of the cannabis market. 60% is in the illicit market, subject to no protections for consumers or orphan the environment. And California is losing ground.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Other states, Michigan, Oregon and others are raking in much more tax revenue and are doing a much better job at stopping illicit sales. And so this isn't the time to be raising the tax by 25%. So AB 564 is simply defers that tax increase that happened on July 1st to 2028. With that, ask for an aye vote.
- Jerry McNerney
Legislator
Well, I thank the President. I thank the Senator from West Sacramento. Although this Bill isn't perfect, the non profits that are depending on this tax revenue are really needing help. But even the bigger picture is that we want to control and contain and reduce the illegal market. Raising taxes right now is going to have an opposite effect.
- Jerry McNerney
Legislator
It's going to drive people into the illegal black market on cannabis, which is a bad outcome. And so therefore, I will support this Bill, look forward to improving it in the next year. I yield back.
- Tony Strickland
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Members, I rise in support of AB564. And I'm glad that my colleagues understand when you raise taxes is bad for business. I understand that. Now you understand that when you raise taxes, it's not good for the people who are actually providing the product.
- Tony Strickland
Legislator
So I hope you remember on not just cannabis, but other issues, we talking about that when you lower the tax burden, it actually is good for business and the economy of California. For those reasons, I support AB564.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Yeah. Thank you. To my colleague from Huntington Beach. I teach public economics and very much understand the argument that is made, but in this case it's actually correct. Because if we're able to capture. If we're able to capture 60% more of the market at the.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
At the current tax rate, 60% more of the market, we'll double the amount of revenue that is available to support the programs that the chair of the Revenue and Taxation Committee so eloquently described.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
And so this Bill is a common sense way to increase tax revenue, bolster the legal market, and increase our ability to tackle the illicit market. I asked for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cabaldian moves the call. Senator Wiener with file item 179. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 628 by Assemblymember McKinnor an act relating to landlords and tenants.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB628 on behalf of Assemblymember McKinnor. AB628 would require new leases on residential properties to include a refrigerator and stove in good working order. A working stove and a working refrigerator are not luxuries. They're a necessary part of modern life.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
California's rental house affordability crisis has been exacerbated by outdated laws that do not consider basic household appliances a necessary part of a rental home. While many landlords do include a working refrigerator and stove and a residential lease.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
A growing number of rental properties are not creating significant financial burdens on tenants seeking an affordable and safe place to live. This Bill is supported by Affordable Housing and Tenant Rights Organization. It is one of many bills this year focused on addressing the state's affordability crisis and will help bring down the cost of living for California residents. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. See no mics up on this item. Secretary, please call a roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Wiener moves a call Senator Perez with file item 181. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 338 by Assembly Member Solache and act relating to workforce development and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, I rise to present AB338 on behalf of Assemblymember Solache. AB338 will support workforce recovery efforts in Los Angeles and Ventura Counties following the devastating 2025 January wildfires. These wildfires caused widespread destruction at great economic toll, contributing to significant workforce disruptions and employment insecurity.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Together with an appropriation made in this year's budget, AB338 will support workforce relief, helping to ensure a skilled and sufficient workforce to meet the scale of rebuilding and other urgent economic recovery needs. AB338 represents a critical opportunity to accelerate disaster recovery and foster long term resilience in affected communities. AB338 has received bipartisan support and has no opposition. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Perez moves a call. Senator Laird with file item 185. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 93 by Assembly Member Papan an act relating to water.
- John Laird
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB93 ensures data centers operate responsibly, balancing innovation and sustainability. While they can bring major benefits to communities, they also use immense amounts of water. Up to 5 million gallons daily in some cases, which is comparable to a town of 50,000 people.
- John Laird
Legislator
AB93 is a reporting Bill that will require data centers to self certify their expected and actual water usage when applying for or renewing a business license, which empowers local governments with the information they need to plan infrastructure. I respectfully request an iPhone.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Laird moves a call. Senator Grayson, file item 188. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 610 by Assignment Member Alvarez an act relating to land use.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB610 on behalf of Assemblymember Alvarez, which seeks to strengthen compliance with housing element laws by mandating a thorough analysis of governmental constraints and requiring transparency in communicating regulations to the Department of Housing and Community Development. We know as hcd. California is in the middle of a deepening housing crisis.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
More than 2/3 of low income renters are rent burdened. Often forced to choose between paying for housing or basic needs like food and health care. One barrier to housing production has been local government constraints. Things like new fees, zoning restrictions and added procedural burdens that make it harder to build affordable homes. That is where AB610 comes in.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
The requires local governments to be more transparently to more transparently disclose any proposed regulations they anticipate adopting during the first three years of the planning period where a housing element has been deemed in compliance by HCD. By fostering transparency and accountability, AB610 aims to create a more effective framework for meeting housing needs statewide. Thank you. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call a roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves a call. Senator Grayson moves a call. Senators, this is our mandatory stretching period. We're going to take a quick pause to stretch your limbs. Stand up while we handle a tech issue. Please follow Senator Durazo. She is leading the stretches.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
While we're waiting, we're going to move to motions and resolutions. Pursuant To Senate Rule 29.10, the following bills are referred to the Committee on Rules. File item 122, AB 1207 and file item 137AB 825. Any other Member have any other item under this section. Continuing to stretch, the Senate will go into a brief recess.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Please stay in the building. Senators, it is now 11:52. We are breaking for lunch. Please return to at 12:30. The Senate has reconvened for announcements.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Thank you so much, Madam President. Rules Committee. Rules Committee will convene in five minutes. 1205 in room 113.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Room 113 for Rules Committee. Senator Strickland, you are recognized.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Republican caucus. The Senate will go back into. The Rules Committee is meeting for Executive session. The Senate now will return to a recess until 12:30 approximately.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The Senate is now back in session. So, Senators, before we move forward with the business of the day, I know during our lunch break we were made aware of some really devastating news. Political or gun violence as a whole has, or any kind of violence has no place in our world.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The California State Senate sends their thoughts and prayers to Charlie Kirk and his family. We're gonna be moving on to motions and resolutions. Senator Umberg, you're recognized.
- Thomas Umberg
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Please move File item number 118, AB54 to the inactive file at the request of the author.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The desk is noted. Would any other Member wish to be recognized under motions and resolutions now going back to Assembly, third reading. We're going to start off with file item 186 with Senator Limon.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 889 by Assembly Member Hadwick an act related to prevailing wage.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Thank you. Members, today I rise to present AB889 ensures fair, transparent and equitable fringe benefit contributions for workers on public works projects while maintaining a level playing field for employers. AB899 eliminates loopholes to ensure every worker gets the full intended value of their benefits. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. I see no mics up on this matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Limon moves the call. Senator Stern is ready to go with file item 193. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 566 by assignment Member Lowenthal an act relating to privacy.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I'm proud to present this measure from over in the Assembly.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
The amendments taken by the author recently ensure that this consumer focused privacy Bill will be focused strictly on web browsers and allow users to exercise their opt out rights across all online businesses they engage with much more efficiently and quickly than under current law.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
The recent amendments delay implementation timelines for the Bill, limit the Bill only to browsers, and add liability protections to ensure that browsers that send an Opt out preference signal won't be liable for a violation of law by a business that receives the opt out signal but doesn't honor it.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
This Bill would grant consumers greater control of their personal data and when that data is utilized online, respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I've got no mics up on this matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern moves a call. Senator Ashby has file item 200. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1445 by Senator Member Haney an act relating to local government.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and Members, I rise to present AB 1445 by Assembly Member Haney. AB 1445 would allow cities to create a downtown recovery district that will help finance office to housing conversion projects funded by property tax revenues generated by conversion projects within that district.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Downtowns matter very much to the economic recovery of our cities as a whole. However, because of sharp decline in return to office rates during the COVID 19 pandemic, downtowns remain struggling. Office vacancy rates are high in cities across the state across the state and continue to hover around 30%.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
These buildings could see a second use in our urban core. AB 1445 would provide necessary tools to to build affordable mixed use housing on former commercial spaces in downtowns across California. This Bill has been supported by a broad coalition of cities, housing organizations and labor unions who all want to see our post pandemic downtowns thrive. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I also rise in support of AB 1445. This Bill expands downtown revitalization financing districts statewide to convert underutilized office space into much needed housing. In the City of San Diego, more than one in 10 commercial offices are vacant. High vacancy rates are devastating for our downtowns.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
It drains our local governments of vital tax revenue, hurts real estate businesses, reduces the vibrancy of our city centers. At the same time, our state remains in a critical housing shortage. Colleagues, this Bill is an opportunity to, as I like to say, I love this phrase, feed two birds with one scone.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
It will give local governments a practical financing tool to support the development of affordable housing in our downtowns and it will help resuscitate our downtown economies. This is a forward looking bipartisan measure that responds to today's economic realities and helps our cities adapt, recover and grow stronger. And I respectfully ask for your aye vote Senator Ashby.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
You May now close. 1445 presents a tool to all of our cities. Respectfully ask for an aye vote. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern is up with file item 202. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 777 by Senator Member Celeste Rodriguez. An act relating to public social services.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB777 aims to strengthen communication between utilities companies and the California Department of Social Services during emergencies and disasters. Timely accurate data from utility companies is critical to ensure that Californians can access things like federal food assistance as well as disaster calfresh when our communities need them most.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
We know that when the power goes off. And those of you who've had public safety power shutoffs in your district should know this all too well. It's not just an outrage, it's life threatening. So we want to ensure that good data sharing is occurring to help the most vulnerable, especially those who are hungry, depending on medication.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Recent floor amendments move the California Municipal Utility Utilities Association and Burbank Water and Power off of opposition into neutral. This Bill supports support and respectfully. As for your eye vote, see no.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern moves the call Senator Perez with file item 203.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 851 by Senate Member McKinnor an act related to real estate and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB851 by Assemblymember McKinnor. AB851 codifies Governor Newsom's Executive order to extend homeowner protections for families impacted by the January 2025 Eaton & Palisades fires from unsolicited offers on residential properties until 202027.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Additionally, AB 851 would allow the seller of a residential property within the Eaton and Palisades declared disaster zip codes to rescind the sale of their property for four months after the close of escrow. Many homeowners were devastated by the January 2025 fires. Have reported being targeted by by unscrupulous businesses, scam artists and predatory buyers.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
These fire survivors have experienced unimaginable trauma and need additional protections and time to make an informed decision whether to rebuild or sell their property. AB851 provides important protections to all families impacted by the Eaton and Palisades fires and is an important part of LA County's efforts to rebuild from this devastating natural disaster. I respectfully ask for your aye vote on AB851. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Perez moves a call. Senator Laird with file item 205 ready to go. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1362 by Assembly Member Kalra an act relating to foreign labor contractors.
- John Laird
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB 1362 expands California's foreign labor recruiter registration requirements to include those who recruit workers under the H2A visa. SB477 Steinberg was adopted in 2014 to regulate foreign labor. It has been interpreted to be limited solely to recruiting workers. Excuse me. Under the HB2B, human traffickers have exploited this.
- John Laird
Legislator
This would expand the current registration requirements to those recruiting workers under H2A visa. It also requires the Department of Industrial Relations to submit a study to the Legislature by January 1st in 2028 to determine how to extend the registration program so that it can cover all the temporary work visa categories. With that, I respectfully request an iPhone.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up on this issue. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Laird moves a call. Senator Grayson. Ready with file item 219. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1050 by Assembly Member Schultz an act relating to real property.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I. Rice to present AB 1050 on behalf of Assemblymember Nick Schultz. AB 1050 is part of the Assembly's fast track housing legislative package which advances smart reforms to restream housing approvals and address California's ongoing housing crisis.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
The COVID 19 pandemic and inflation have accelerated shifts in the economy and consumer behavior leading to the closure of many commercial spaces. While the need for housing across our state continues to grow.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
AB 1050 supports the redevelopment of vacant commercial centers by allowing property owners to request money modifications to to old and burdensome restrictive covenants that currently prohibit residential development. This Bill responds to the urgent need for more housing in California and AB 1050 delivers a clear targeted solution. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves the call Senator Perez with file item 220. Senator Perez has been your show today, Secretary Please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 692 by Assembly Member Kalra and act related to employment.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB692 will end export exploitative practice of trapping workers into debt agreements, also known as stay or pay contracts, which oftentimes are disguised as basic on the job training orientation or other educational programs. Under current law, workers are protected from being forced to pay for employer mandated training.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
However, stay or pay contracts have created a situation where workers are locked into their jobs because they are being required to repay the cost of an educational course or training when they leave their job, are fired or are laid off.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
This has had a chilling effect on workplaces, discouraging workers from speaking out against unsafe or unfair working conditions for fear of being fired and forced to pay off the debt. This practice is especially prominent in the transportation, healthcare, retail, aviation and tech industries.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
AB692 will end these debt traps by prohibiting employer debt agreements that require workers to pay their employees and a debt if they leave their job regardless of how and would avoid those agreements as unlawful contracts. To be clear, this Bill does not apply to government sponsored loan forgiveness programs and does not prohibit employers from offering bonuses.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Additionally, after feedback from stakeholders, the Bill exempts employers who cover the cost of tuition for transferable credentials from third party accredited institutions, Discretionary or unearned monetary payments like bonuses and monetary incentives if the specified conditions are met and employment housing workers should be able to decide where they want to work and not be afraid to speak out without the fear of financial debt or retaliation. I respectfully ask your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. Seeing no mics up on this matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Perez moves to call. Senator Wiener has file item 224.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 507 by Assembly Member Haney an act relating to housing.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Madam President. Colleagues, I rise today to present AB507, the office to Housing Conversion act on behalf of Assemblymember Haney. The Bill will accelerate adaptive reuse projects of historic office buildings statewide.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
The Bill will respond to high vacancies and help downtowns recovering from pandemic shifts and commute patterns to convert underutilized office buildings within proximity to jobs, transit and businesses into new housing. AB507 creates a pathway for buy right ministerial approval of office conversion projects ensuring more predictability and fewer barriers to an already difficult building process.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
It also provides flexibility needed to ensure that historic buildings are more economically feasible for conversion so that we can preserve our buildings for housing while making sure the downtown's diverse characteristics are kept intact.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
I want to note that the labor standards in this Bill are a direct result of a years long negotiation among Assemblymember Haney, Assembly leadership, the State building trades and the Norcal carpenters. The Bill states that the standard does not set a precedent for ground up construction as is clearly stated in the Bill. I ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you Senator. No discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Senator Wiener moves the call. And we are Moving to items 83. SB 660. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 660 by Senator Menjivar an act relating to the California Health and Human Services data exchange framework.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Senator Menjivar, you are recognized for item 83, SB660, when you are ready.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Mr. President. Colleagues, SB660 is back on concurrence. A lot of amendments. I'll try to go over just some of them. It completely eliminated the Data Exchange board and transferred the responsibility of everything under the Bill to a new Department, hci. It requires the advisory group to ensure there's a balance of perspectives participating.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
It authorizes the group to consider and vote on recommendations for the data sharing agreement and aligns requirements for medical foundations and emergency medical services to execute the data sharing agreement by July 1202026. And it delays a requirement until January 2027 that publishes the names of entities that HCAI knows are not in compliance.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
And it completely eliminates the requirement for HCAI to be responsible for dispute resolutions and grievances. Respectfully asking for an aye vote to move forward with this very important Bill that it allows for individuals for providers to share information and provide the correct care for our patients.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Seeing no discussion or debate on this item, Secretary, please call roll.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Senator Menjivar moves the call. We are going to go back in the file all the way to the beginning.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 499 by Senator Stern an act relating to land use.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise present 499 back on concurrence. This Bill is essential to provide residences, emergency services and public safety infrastructure without delay. We clarify in this Bill some conflicts with AB121. Clarify the non deferred fee eligibility for water utilities by cross referencing existing law and remove a sunset date used on mitigation planning. With that, I respectfully asked for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. We have no discussion on this item. Let's call the roll. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern moves the call. Senator Ochoa Bogh is up with file item 18.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 250 by Senator Ochoa Bogh, an act relating to Medi-Cal.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. Senator Bill 250 is back on concurrence. Assembly amendments simply added requirement for the Department of Health Care Services to annually update their provider directory to ensure that information is accurate and readily accessible to the public. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Ochoa Bogh moves the call. Senators, all these bills, while they do enjoy support support, we do not have unanimous roll call. Just letting you know that. Senator Niello is up with file item 29.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 359 by Senator Niello and act relating to taxation to take effect immediately. Tax levy.
- Roger Niello
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. I rise to present SB 359 which aims to create parity within county operated public transit. Clarifying amendments were taken in the Assembly and this Bill has received bipartisan support in both houses and has received no no votes. That's not a no no vote. It has not received any no votes. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Niello moves a call. Senator Grayson with file item 34, SB 410. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 410 by Senator Grayson, an act relating to common interest developments.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Madam President and Members. I rise to present SB 410, which is back on concurrence. SB 410 is a simple bill that would clarify that HOAs must provide balcony inspection reports in the suite of documents provided to prospective home buyers during a potential sell. The Assembly amendments are technical in nature. This bill has had zero no votes, bipartisan support. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves the call. Senator Stern has file item 39. He's ready to go.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 582 by Senator Stern, an act relating to healthcare. An act relating to health and care facilities.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Thank you, Members. I rise to present SB 582, back on concurrence. This build supports disaster struck communities by allowing relevant departments the ability to issue an inactive license status for health care, health and care facilities like nursing homes.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
By changing the phrasing from disaster suspension of license to inactive license status, we're going to ensure that folks can get back on their feet more quickly. And that the most vulnerable, the elderly and the young in our communities, when disaster hits, won't be left behind. Bill enjoys bipartisan support. No opposition. Respectfully asked for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No Member wishes to discuss this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Stern moves a call. Senator Wiener, you have the next two items, file item 50 and file item 51. Secretary, please read SB 41.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 41 by Senator Wiener, an act relating to pharmacy benefits.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President and colleagues. SB 41 is back on concurrence. This bill will require transparency and reign in abusive behavior by pharmacy benefit managers, which is contributing to rising prescription drug costs. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Wiener moves a call. Senator Wiener with file item 51. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 71 by Senator Wiener, an act relating to environmental quality.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Colleagues, SB 71 is back on concurrence. The Assembly amendments include extending the existing 2030 sunset date to 2040 while preserving the 2032 sunset for certain types of projects that were worked out in Senate Environmental Quality Committee clarifying that Tier 4 diesel train exemption only applies in certain areas and reverting the application of the bill's right of way provisions to existing law while adding additional guard rails around property owned by utilities. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Wiener moves a call. Senator Gonzalez with file item 55.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 263 by Senator Gonzalez, an act relating to international trade.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and Members. I rise today to present Senate Bill 263, which is back on concurrence. Assembly amendments assigned the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development to conduct the study on tariffs, removes the appropriation and extends the deadline for the study, makes technical and clarifying changes. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on SB 263.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Gonzalez moves a call. Senator Laird with file item 56 is ready to go.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 283 by Senator Laird, an act relating to energy.
- John Laird
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. Senate Bill 283 is back for concurrence. It relates to battery storage safety. Assembly amendments include clarifying changes that conform the building code standard and processes and add specified timelines. At the request of the administration, they're support support, I request, respectfully request an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Laird moves to call. Senator Allen has filed item 63. We're going to give him a moment. We're used to this, Senator. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 413 by Senator Allen an act relating to juveniles.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
So this Bill streamlines case resolution by allowing attorneys representing a party in a civil case to access and use juvenile case files and proceedings initiated by individuals who are the subject of those juvenile case files.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
The amendments taken in the Assembly clarify which civil cases qualify for this new process, and they ensured that immigration status and any information on other minors would be redacted from juvenile case files before they're accessed. With that, I respect your ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up on this issue. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Allen moves a call. Up next is file item 79 by Senator Richardson.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 631 by Senator Richardson an act relating to charter schools.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB631 has to do with the charter schools revolving Fund. We're doing this in conjunction with the treasurer, and essentially what it does is it gives the charter schools access to. Funds that are already allocated. This is not a new item for charter schools. I respectfully, respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator Richardson. I see no discussion on this item. Secretary, please read, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
We have file item 169 with Senator Hurtado. She's ready to go. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 422 by Assembly Member Jackson an act relating to pupil instruction.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB422, which would update the criteria for the state Seal of Civic Engagement by incorporating a deeper understanding of democracy into the criteria and requiring students to show a demonstrated understanding of the importance of preserving democracy. This Bill would also require the Superintendent of Instruction to recommend additional award criteria.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
When the Board of Education next revises that criteria for the seal. It's imperative that our students understand the institutions and maintain our democracy. And the differences between government and democracy. These challenges highlight a gap in civic education.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
Without an explicit emphasis on the importance of democratic institutions, the states here Seal of Civic Engagement fails to full equip students with the necessary knowledge to protect and sustain democracy. This Bill ensures that students earning the seal gain deeper understanding of democracy's key institutions. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator Hurtado. No mics up on this. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Allen. Aye. Al Gil. Archuletta I. Araguin. Ashby, I. Becker. Blakesphear I. Cabaldin. Caballero, I. Cervantes, I. Choi, I. Cortese, Dali, I. Durazo. Gonzalez, I. Grayson, I. Grove, I. Hurtado, I. Jones, I. Laird, I. Limon. Mcguire I. McKearney I. Menjibar, I. Niello, I. Ochoa. Bog, I. Padilla. Perez, I. Reyes. Richardson, I. Rubio. Aye. Sierto. Aye. Smallwood. Cuevas. Stern. Strickland. I. Umberg. Baladers. Aye. Wahab, I. Weber. Pearson. Wiener. Aye.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Hurtado moves the call. Senator Laird, you have file item 174 AB 1466. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1466 by Assembly Member Hart an act relating to Groundwater Adjudication.
- John Laird
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. This Bill has to do with the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. It deals with streamlining adjudication and protects small and disadvantaged farmers from being dragged into lengthy processes. It'll also require groundwater sustainability agencies to provide a technical report to quantify and describe all water users to the court.
- John Laird
Legislator
Recent amendments moved Western Growers and Cal Chamber to support and removed ACWA's opposition, their support on both sides. Now I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator Laird. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Lard moves a call. Senator Grayson, you have the following three items. They're going to be file item 183201 and 208. Secretary, please read file item 183. Please read. Secretary, please read file item 193.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 70 by assignment Member Agguiar Curry an act relating to solid waste.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and Senators, I rise to present AB70 on behalf of Assemblymember Aguiar Curry. Today, almost 90% of California's methane emissions come from organic waste, including organic waste sent to landfills. To address this, SB 1383 set methane reduction goals in 2016. But. But communities across California have been struggling to find ways to divert organic waste.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
The goal of this Bill is to help provide certainty to communities and projects as they look for ways to put their organic waste to beneficial use. First, because confusion has resulted from the absence of a definition in the code, this Bill codifies the definition of pyrolysis. This Bill does not change how it is permitted or regulated.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
It simply helps communities and companies know what projects count as these kind of projects. So second, this Bill also allows communities to get procurement credit for projects that use exclusively organic waste to generate pipeline biomethane. This is important for communities that need more options for meeting their SB 1383 goals.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
This Bill will help future reduce future emissions by helping divert organic waste from landfills, and it will help increase energy reliability and and resiliency in those communities. I respectfully ask for and I vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No mics up on this issue. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves a call. Senator Grayson, file item 201 enjoys support. Support. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 961 by Senate Member Avila Farias an act relating to hazardous materials.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Colleagues, I rise to present AB961 on behalf of Assembly Member Avila Farias. This Bill seeks to extend the California Land Reuse and revitalization act of CLRA for 10 years. If this law is allowed to sunset, we risk delaying or derailing critical redevelopment projects. AB961 has received unanimous support. I respectfully asked for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No discussion on the item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves the call. Senator Grayson with file item 208. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1172 by Assembly Member Min an act relating to health and care facilities.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Madam President. Members, I rise today to present AB 1172 on behalf of Assembly Member Min. This Bill improves access to inhalable anti seizure medication for individuals within adult residential facilities and community care license day programs. 1172 enables trained volunteer staff to administer inhalable anti seizure medication. This Bill has bipartisan support. No opposition. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
We have no discussion on the item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Grayson moves a call. Senator Perez has file item 218.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 247 by Assembly Member Bryan an act relating to inmate firefighters and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. I rise to present AB247 on behalf of Assembly Member Bryan AB247 will ensure incarcerated hand crew Members who are actively fighting wildfires receive fair compensation for their invaluable service during their life saving work. Incarcerated people have long been a part of the state's firefighting force.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
More than a century ago, CDCR created a conservation camp program to train incarcerated people to help fight fires throughout California's fire season. There are now 35 conservation camps in the state. Earlier this year, my home County of Los Angeles experienced a devastating and heartbreaking loss due to two out of the three worst wildfires in our state's history.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
In this time of crisis, incarcerated people who were on the fire line actively fighting the fire played a crucial and invaluable role in protecting our homes and and our region. Incarcerated people who bravely stepped forward to fight our state's wildfires are severely underpaid.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
They currently receive a mere $5 to $10 a day with a $1 kicker when they are actively fighting. This is unacceptable.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
A 2018 report discovered that incarcerated hand crew Members more than eight times more likely to to be injured after inhaling smoke and particulate matter compared to professional firefighters because of where and how they worked during these wildfires.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Additionally, they were four times more likely to experience object induced injuries such as cuts, bruises, dislocations and fractures compared to professional firefighters working on the same fires. Unfortunately, these fires can also be fatal. From early 2017 to late 20183 incarcerated hand crew Members passed in the field, putting their lives on the line in service of others.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
This Bill isn't just about fair pay. It's about dignity, equity, and recognizing all of our heroes, all of our first responders when they step up in a time of crisis. This Bill has received bipartisan support and I respectfully ask you all for your aye vote. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Perez moves a call. We're going to be moving back to unfinished business. Senator Cervantes has filed item 20 and 25. She is ready to go. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 3 by Senator Cervantes an act relating to elections.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Today I rise to present Senate Bill 3 for concurrence and Assembly amendments. The reforms in Senate Bill 3 will ensure that the signature carrying process becomes a trusted, better understood and increasingly reliable part of the our elections in future years. Amendments make minor and clarifying changes and add a co author.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
I respectfully ask for an aye vote on concurrence and Assembly amendments on SB3.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cervantes moves to call Secretary, please read file item 25.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 241 by Senator Cervantes, an act relating to community colleges.
- Sabrina Cervantes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise on Senate Bill 241, which is back for concurrence. Amendments taken in the Assembly preserve the ability for community colleges to use artificial intelligence in their operations. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on concurrence and Senate amendments.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cervantes moves the call. Moving into file item 35, Senator Ashby. Secretary, please read.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
SB 516 is back on concurrence. Assembly amendments deal with Bill conflicts. The Bill has bipartisan support, has received no no votes. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Ashby moves the call. Moving on to file item 54, Senator Wahab.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 257 by Senator Wahab, an act relating to healthcare coverage.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
Thank you. I rise today to present SB 257, the Parent Act, which designates pregnancy as a qualifying life event for health insurance enrollment. These amendments taken in the Assembly narrow the scope of the bill. Previously, SB 257 would have also allowed banned health insurers from requiring gestational carriers to reimburse them for covered maternity services. The bill is now focused on creating a special enrollment period for pregnancy, removing the provisions related to surrogacy. It has received strong bipartisan support across both houses. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Senator Wahab moves the call. We will move to item 65, SB 471.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 471 by Senator Menjivar and act relating to Developmental Services and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Mr. President, colleagues, thank you. SB471 is back on concurrence. The amendment second in Assembly will were technical, as in conversations with the Department, and it added an urgency clause, respectively asking for an aye vote, seeing no.
- Timothy Grayson
Legislator
Microphones raised for discussion or debate. Secretary, please call roll.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 576 by Senator Umberg, an act relating to video streaming.
- Thomas Umberg
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and colleagues. This Bill is a Bill that improves the quality of life by ensuring that while you are viewing streaming entertainment that the volume is not increased exponentially. It is named after Samantha Keller, who was a small child awakened repeatedly and every parent knows how irksome that is. I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No discussion on the matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Umberg moves, moves the call. Senator Umberg, you have three items back to back, file item 26, 27, and 33. Secretary, please read file item 26.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 253 by Senator Umberg, an act relating to attorneys.
- Thomas Umberg
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and colleagues. This is the state bar fee bill. Last year, fees were increased by $88. They are not increased this year. The State Bar has had a number of challenges with respect to discipline and the debacle in the February administration of the Bar Exam. I am certainly hopeful that the bars on the right trajectory and I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No discussion on the item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Umberg moves a call. Senator Umberg with file item 27. Secretary, please read.
- Thomas Umberg
Legislator
Thank you. This is a measure concerning dogs. It is on concurrence. It removes the public facing website. That's what the amendments do on the California Department of Agriculture's website. Change the word accredited to license with respect to veterinarians and change the time CDFA is required to retain certificates from 10 years to 5 years. I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Umberg moves a call. Secretary, please read file item 33.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 398 by Senator Umberg, an act relating to elections.
- Thomas Umberg
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and colleagues. This is back to us on concurrence. What this bill originally did and still does is it criminalizes certain election lotteries as existed in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin during the 2024 election. What the amendments do is they changed it such that the bill does not apply to transportation to or from a voting location, compensated provided to an individual by a governmental entity, and granting time off to an employee to vote. I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Umberg moves a call. Moving on to file item 43, Senator Cortese. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 791 by Senator Cortese, an act relating to vehicles.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and colleagues. This is back on concurrence, SB 791. The bill would update the document processing charge that dealers or legislators to be authorized to collect to cover the cost of vehicle transaction process.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
And the amendments, the significant amendments that were taken were to reduce the cap, which is a cap against 1% of the purchase price to $260. You may recall it was originally written at $500 in the bill. It's at 260 at what's in front of you and what's amended is at 260.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
And there are also amendments requiring dealers to disclose the charge to the consumer at the time the vehicle is advertised. And probably most of interest is a sunset date of January 1, 2031. Well, with that, I'd respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No mics up on this issue. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cortese moves a call. Senator Becker has filed item 61. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 338 by Senator Becker an act relating to Public Social Services.
- Josh Becker
Legislator
I thank you. This bill creates the mobile virtual health hub for rural communities pilot program bringing. Telehealth services directly to underserved rural areas. The Assembly amendments create a sunset clause. If the fund balance has not been met by December 31, 2030 I humbly. Ask for your Aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up on this matter. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
We will now move to file item 68, SB 486. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 486 by Senator Cabaldon an act relating to Land use.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to ask for concurrence in Senate in Assembly amendments on SB486. This Bill makes it easier for our public institutions of higher education to grow enrollment to meet their obligations on their master plan for higher education, while also strengthening the regional capacity to assure that enrollment growths are sustainable.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
The Assembly amendments reconfigure the relationship between the regions and the no project alternatives, and they remove all opposition and ask for an aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Saying no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Cabaldon moves the call. We'll now move to file item 76, SB590. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 590 by Senator Durazzo. An act relating to disability compensation and making an appropriation Therefore
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Ms President. SB590 updates California's paid family leave law so that workers can care for a designated person who is a Member of their chosen or extended family.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Assembly amendments include delaying the operative date from July 1, 2027 to July 1, 2028 at a requirement for the individual to identify the designated person they are caring for and under penalty of perjury, attest to how the individual is related by blood or how the relationship is the equivalent to a family relationship.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
The measure has no opposition and has received broad partisan bipartisan support in the Assembly and Senate. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Saying no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Durazo moves the call. We will now move to file item 81, SB640. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 640 by Senator Cabaldon an act relating to public post secondary education.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to ask for concurrence in Assembly amendments for SB640. SB 640 is the groundbreaking Bill that will send a letter of admission to the California State University to its under enrolled campuses to every single graduating high school California graduating high school student in California, regardless of whether they have applied.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
And they will receive that letter before the application deadline and open it up in the afternoon when they get home from school or if grandma's open it up or their parents have opened up. Knowing that the California State University and its campuses are open to them. They don't simply have to enroll to go.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
It builds on years of data sharing partnerships that make this possible so we can close the gap between 12th grade and future opportunities for our students. The Assembly amendments remove unrelated provisions and then also add provisions to facilitate implementation by the California State University. I vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Seeing no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Cabaldon moves the call. We will now move to file item 148. We're back on Assembly. Third reading. AB858.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1332 by Assembly Member Ahrens an act relating to cannabis.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
I apologize. That was 148. AB 1332. Senator Stern, you are recognized.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
Okay, thank you. Madam President, please present AB 1332 on behalf of Assembly Member Erin. There's a small population in California of seriously ill patients with advanced cancers, dementia, people with epilepsy. Severe autism, rare genetic syndromes, and in many of these cases, medical cannabis can be a really important part of their care and comfort.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
I know this myself, taking care of my in laws and watching the power of this medicine actually deal with things like dementia and trauma and a very important part of life. Right now the retail market means that there's limited access to this care for many patients.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
And this Bill would provide a narrow authorization for outdoor cultivation micro businesses to ship medicinal cannabis directly to patients homes through an intrastate common carrier only after they've received valid medical documentation for that patient from a physician.
- Henry Stern
Legislator
This should make it easier for families and caregivers to spend more time with their loved ones and less on sorting out the ins and outs of how to access these very effective products that are often new for them and that take learning on their own. Thank you. Members, I respectfully ask your aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Seeing no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Stern moves the call. We will now move to file item 161 AB 678
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 678 by Assembly Member Lee an act relating to homelessness.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President and Members, I rise on behalf of Assemblymember Lee to present AB678, the LGBTQ+ Safe and Inclusive Housing Act. AB678 will require the California Interagency Council on Homelessness to develop and recommend best practices and policies for ensuring LGBTQ individuals receive culturally competent, inclusive and affirming services when accessing state funded housing and homelessness programs.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And we know that a growing number of people experiencing homelessness, including youth, identify as lgbtq. As a former mayor, I can certainly attest to the fact that many young people who are fleeing violence or fleeing discrimination, may end up living on the streets.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And so it's important that we align our state's policies and funding investments to help support the needs of this particular population. This Bill is sponsored by Equality California and Sage and is an LGBTQ caucus priority Bill. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Seeing no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Arreguin moves the call. We will move to file item 213 ab 650. Secretary, please call the roll. I'm sorry. Please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 650 by Senator Member Papan an act relating to land use.
- Josh Becker
Legislator
Thank you. Friends, I think one thing many of us can agree on is that the current arena housing element process has become extremely complex and burdensome, and that has taken a real toll.
- Josh Becker
Legislator
Many cities acting in good faith are doing the work, but they're stuck in cycles of revisions and resubmissions, often with moving targets and end up in HCD purgatory. These delays are slowing down housing production and draining local resources. This Bill addresses these challenges in two ways.
- Josh Becker
Legislator
Number one, it allows the arena process to start earlier, giving cities six months of more time. Number two, requires clear and actionable feedback from HCD identifying problems with clarity, identifying the required remedy with clarity. These requirements will help cities avoid confusion and costly delays that result from the current inconsistent and often unclear guidelines. Respectfully, as for an aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Saying no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Senator Becker moves the call. We will now move to file item 226ab495. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 495. By Assembly Member Celeste Rodriguez an act relating to immigration.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
We will hold off on that. We will move to file item 44, SB 800. Secretary, please read under unfinished business.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 800, by Senator Reyes, an act relating to streets and highways.
- Eloise GĂłmez Reyes
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present SB 800, which is a district bill that requires Caltrans, in consultation with the Department of Public Health and in collaboration with impacted local governments, to incorporate countermeasures for suicide attempts on bridges and overpasses on the state highway system.
- Eloise GĂłmez Reyes
Legislator
This bill is in response to a heartbreaking scenario in my district last year where our community lost two high school students to suicide at the same location in the City of Rancho Cucamonga within a week and a half of each other. The bill will give Caltrans the relevant guidance to incorporate the appropriate suicide deterrents.
- Eloise GĂłmez Reyes
Legislator
These may include the design, placement, and modification of barriers, fencing, and other infrastructure. Preventative measures like SB 800 are critical to ensuring similar situations will not occur in the future. The bill is being sponsored by the City of Rancho Cucamonga and has no opposition and has received bipartisan support. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. Seeing no further discussion or debate. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
We will now move back to Assembly third reading, file item 226, AB 295. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 495 by Assemblymember Celeste Rodriguez, an act relating to immigration.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I'm proud to present Assembly Bill 495, the Family Preparedness Plan Act, on behalf of Assemblymember Celeste Rodriguez, that strengthens policies to keep families together in the face of mass immigration actions. One million children in California have at least one undocumented parent, and over 100,000 children in our schools are undocumented themselves.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Assembly Bill 495 provides families with education options and support in the case of family separation. This Bill creates joint guardianship in the probate court that would allow a parent to preserve their paternal rights or granting joint guardianship to another person to care for their child in the event of a parent's absence.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Assembly Bill 495 strengthens parental rights by ensuring that a person's guardianship nomination is given due weight in court. Assembly Bill 495 requires the Attorney General to publish model policies limiting assistance with immigration enforcement at daycare centers and preschool facilities. This currently exists for hospitals in K-12 schools but does not exist for childcare centers and preschools.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
AB 495 was drafted with immigrant families' unique hardship in mind. Families are scared to drive their kids to school at risk of being detained by immigration enforcement. And just to put this in context, we know what's been happening in our state over the past several months, where parents have been arrested and separated from their kids.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And we also know that this Administration has had a policy of separating kids from families, including locking them in cages along the border.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And so, this is about making sure that if parents are separated from their kids, that there is somebody who can step in, who they have designated to provide care and custody of those people, until such time that the parents are unified with their kids.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This Bill empowers these at-risk families with options and tools to ensure that their children are protected from adverse immigration enforcement action, and I have to address what I think has been glaring and intentional misinformation that's been put out on this Bill throughout the discussion of this Bill through the legislative process.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
First of all, there already is a process where somebody can do a caregiver affidavit. That is existing law in California. Unfortunately, because of the misinformation and opposition that's been stirred up on this Bill, the author took that out of the Bill. So, let me just put this on—make this very clear.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
The Senate amendments removed the provisions in this Bill that would have allowed a non-relative extended family member to utilize a caregiver's affidavit authorization. So, in the course of the debate today, if people bring that up, that's not in the Bill anymore. So, the most controversial piece of this Bill is off the table.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
What this Bill does is nearly focuses on, one, making sure there are model policies for preschools and, two, making sure that we are building on the existing network of laws to provide families the tools in the case that parents are not able to care for their kids because they've been arrested and detained and deported and not able to care for their kids.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
So, once again, this Bill was recently amended to address opposition's concerns and incorporate technical assistance from the Department of Social Services. At the core of this, this is not about, you know, creating a situation where strangers can take custody of kids and put kids in harm's way, contrary to what opponents have said.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This is about building on the existing tools and network of laws that exist in California to ensure that immigrant parents, who are cruelly being separated from their kids and being arrested and deported because of this administration's immigration policy, and let's talk about that in the course of this debate as well, that they have tools to make sure their kids are cared for.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This Bill is a Latino Caucus and Legislative Women's Caucus priority bill. It is sponsored by immigrant rights groups, legal public aid organizations, family and children's rights advocates. At the appropriate time, I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President, and ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. Thank you very much to representing Senator Arreguin, who made some comments and clarifications to that, and hopefully, I will be able to address some of the concerns as well.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
We had a very close eye at this particular bill, and I do rise in opposition to Assembly Bill 495 for the following reasons. And though I appreciate the author's work on these most recent amendments, I still believe that the bill still misses the mark when it comes to protecting California's children.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
In conversations with my constituents, I learned that many of them weren't aware of the caregiver authorization affidavit process until they heard about AB 495. This Bill, in its amended form, has brought forth a magnifying glass to the existing law and exposed the massive safety risk our current caregiver authorization affidavit process poses.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
To be clear, I'm absolutely in alignment with with the author's desire to ensure that all families have a plan for unexpected circumstances and that a reliable and trusted relative can step in to care for a child in that instance.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
But I speak from a perspective of a mother, a former educator, and school board member, when I say that the amendments to this Bill still do not adequately address the lack of accountability in existing law when it comes to verifying the identity or suitability of a potential caregiver.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
It seems unbelievable that an individual could assume care of a child and make medical decisions for them without parents' consent.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
And all it takes is simply filling out an eight-question form that is not required to be notarized, checking a box to indicate that they are a relative, and presenting a form of ID that is never verified for authenticity.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
And in the case of using a Social Security or MediCal card could be used—could be an ID without a photo. And yet, even in its amended form, this bill still allows just that.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
I will not be supporting this Bill today because I believe that if we're going to update existing law at all, we should be strengthening accountability for caregivers, enhancing oversight of this process with thorough identity verification measures, and creating a system that puts the safety of our children above all else.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. In today's America, we have a President who takes parents from their children. Think about that. A President who takes parents from their children. And all that they are asking is to be able to prepare for the unexpected.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
They live with the fear that when they walk the child to their first day of school or go to the grocery store or head to work in the morning, they may never return. Who here has to face that fear?
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Children are left crying at the school drop offs, unsure if they will be there—if their parents will be there—when the bell rings. Members, with our communities under serious, violent, evil attacks, it is our responsibility to ensure students and families are prepared and protected. This gives the families some security.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
So, would you rather care about the suitability of a caregiver wording on a form, or would you rather have a child end up in a cage? Would you rather have a child end up not with the mother's choice of who should take care of that child? Let's talk about the child's well being.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Let the mother decide today who she chooses is the best person to take care of her child, if, unfortunately, if, she is picked up and detained and arrested and deported. Let her have the right to pick who will take care of her child. And none of us has the right to take that away from that mother.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
Thank you. Thank you, Madam President and ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. I rise in strong support of AB 495, and I also want to highlight some of the misinformation that's happening because I think I heard it on the floor once again. You know, I keep getting calls from my community saying that it's inappropriate for a person, a stranger, to just go in front of a child and say, I want that child and that child.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
That is not what the Bill does. It's so unfortunate that people are hearing things that are not accurate. You know, I want to agree with my great colleague from Los Angeles.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
What she stated right now is really important because when children are being taken away to strangers after parents are deported, we don't care where the child lands. So, shouldn't we be caring about what happens to child before the parent is taken away? The parent here is the one that's making the decision.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
The parent is the one that's saying, I trust that person. It's not a stranger. And we just heard the great Senator who presented the Bill very clearly state that the provision that allows the stranger to take the child is no longer in the Bill.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
And I also believe that family members, mothers, do have, you know, someone other than a family member that they trust. But again, because of the controversy, it was taken out. So, right now, we only have in this Bill the ability for a family member to take care of a child.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
And so, it really baffles me that we're okay with families being taken away on the street, children being left alone, and we're not making a big deal out of that. Children end up in foster homes with strangers, end up in foster care with strangers, and we're not concerned with that.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
In this particular instance, we want a parent to be able to choose that loved one, that family member, that best knows the child, to take care of their child. You know, we often have power of attorney when someone cannot make decisions for themselves. I equate this to this. We give the person the ability to make that decision.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
When they're not able to, then that person takes care of that child. I just want to say, I want to be clear, and I don't—I hear it again, that strangers are just picking up the children. That's not the case. It is a process that is authorized, that it's legal.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
And in this case, we see so many children struggling with strangers because they're left alone after these raids happen. So, again, I'm just really concerned that we're not concerned with the children being left with strangers in homes alone, being left at schools without a parent coming home. But now we're concerned about questions on a questionnaire.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
Let's be a little bit more sympathetic to what's happening, and I ask for an aye vote. Thank you.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. And colleagues, I rise in opposition to AB 495. This Bill imposes sweeping new mandates on schools, childcare providers, and courts that are costly and duplicative and problematic in their execution. AB 495 significantly expands the caregiver's authorization affidavit process by redefining "relative" and allowing individuals to use these affidavits without a parent signature, court seal, or notarization.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
Eliminating these verification requirements weakens parental rights and creates the risk that someone could improperly assume authority over a child's medical or educational decisions without a parent's knowledge. And I understand they said this part has been taken out.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
Well, if that part has been taken out, the current law already provides adequate tools for parents to designate guardians or caregivers. AB 495 instead lowers safeguards that protect children and families. And let's talk about that current law. I've raised three daughters. We've enrolled them in schools.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
You go through a process when you enroll your children in schools of identifying not only who the parents are, but but who the backup parents are, who the grandparents are, who's supposed to be called in the event of an accident or something else. Because parents aren't always just separated from their kids from immigration issues.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
And in fact, I would offer that parents are often separated from their children from other things. Like a parent gets in an accident or parents get into an accident and they're unable to, to get to their children, perhaps they're dead. That happens. That happened to me.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
So, there's a lot of reasons outside of immigration that kids get separated, and that's why there's already measures in place. And if that's not happening, that's an education problem. Schools should be making sure that this process gets done when kids are enrolled.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
And if they're mass enrolling kids and not getting this information from whoever it is, whether it's somebody that's not a legal resident and they're enrolling their kids or somebody that is, they have to know who to call and they have to be able to be checked out.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
They have to have a license when they get there and say, yes, this is me. And if there is no one, we have a process for that, too. The police do take them in custody. They don't throw them into a cage. They become wards of a court.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
And the court has to determine who it is, is the next of kin. Who it is is the next person to call, who's the aunt, who's the uncle, and if it's a funny uncle, maybe not him, right? That's what the court's job is.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
So, this, if this is, this Bill is not doing anything that we already don't have in place. And the reason we have it is because people aren't taking advantage of the authorization process that already exists. I say we go back to being that's an education problem, not a problem for us to solve here in the Legislature.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
In reaction to some of the hyperbole about some of the immigration issues that are out there. Now, I'm not saying they're not happening, but I am saying that a lot of instances are making it sound like it's happening all the time, everywhere, and it's just not.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
So, this Bill also imposes significant new costs on the state and local governments, and it does not provide the resources to pay for them. The Department of Social Services estimates that more than $5 million annually in new staffing will be needed while courts and schools face millions more in workload and policy mandates.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
These dollars would be spent on bureaucracy and compliance rather than on classrooms and families. AB 495 takes the decisions that rightfully belong to parents and weaken their authority, leaving families vulnerable. I respectfully ask for your no vote.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you very much, Madam President. Colleagues, I rise in strong support of AB 495. And first of all, I want to thank and acknowledge the author who has put up with quite a bit of personal abuse relating to this very righteous bill because of misinformation and some conspiracy theories that were circulating out in the community.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
And it's really unfortunate and tragic because this is a really important Bill and fundamentally, what this Bill is about, because this original law was created in the 90s, because anytime you have parents and children who are separated, whether it's because of incarceration or deportation or whatever the case may be, that parent should be able to plan in advance for what happens with that child in order to ensure stability and continuity for that child.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
And what we don't want is for these kids to be just routed into the foster care system. That should be a last resort. And it's an incredibly important system.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
But if there's a way to avoid having the child go into the foster care system, and we know that kids don't always do well in the foster care system, if there's a way of avoiding that, we should do it, and we should empower parents to do that. And this Bill is particularly salient now.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
The Senator from Los Angeles and the floor manager described it, I think very well, that we have a situation where people in this country are being just snatched by ICE and bounty hunters and whoever else just taken, and we don't always know where and disappeared.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
And can you even imagine in a family, it's hard to even wrap your head around what that means, that a parent has just disappeared and what's supposed to happen with that kid?
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
And if we have a way of avoiding that and planning in advance and making it easier for parents to plan in advance, why on earth would we not do that? So, I ask for an aye vote.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you, Madam Chair. So, as both a parent and a child care provider, having ran a preschool for years and years, I have one overriding responsibility. That's to keep kids safe. And that means protecting them not only from obvious dangers, but but also from policies that could unintentionally put them at risk.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
And that's why I have deep concerns about AB 495. On the surface, it is framed as giving families more options in emergencies. But here's the problem.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Under this Bill, someone can sign as a caregiver's authorization—can sign a caregiver's authorization affidavit—claiming to be an extended family member, and the schools and doctors are told they can rely on that form without any further investigation.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
In other words, a person could lie and with nothing more than a piece of paper, gain temporary access to a child. They can enroll them in school, take them to a doctor, or consent to medical care, all without true parental knowledge or consent. Now, as a parent, that terrifies me.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
And as a childcare provider, it aligns—it really alarms me—because in my work, I have to know exactly who I am releasing children to. I have to ask for copies of custody agreements. I've had to look a parent in the eye to and say, you can't pick up your child today because it's not your day.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
That's my responsibility. And you are putting huge liability on childcare providers in a time where it's already a challenging time to find childcare. This Bill undermines that. It creates confusion and it puts providers in the middle of disputes that should never hinge on a flimsy affidavit.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Instead of clarity, we're creating huge liability on those who are entrusted with other people's children. Yes, the affidavit carries a penalty for perjury, but a penalty after the fact doesn't protect the child in that moment. And once harm is done, no fine or jail sentence can do that.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
We should be strengthening safeguards, not lowering the bar for who can step in and make decisions for our kids. Our children deserve airtight protections, not loopholes that can be exploited. For me, this isn't about politics. It's about safety.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
And as a mom, as a provider, as someone entrusted with the most precious lives in our community, I cannot risk supporting a policy that could put children in harm's way. I respectfully ask for a no vote.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Colleagues, I could not agree more with my good colleague from Los Angeles and San Francisco regarding their statements, or some of their statements, on this floor.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Every single one of us as human beings, regardless of party or what part of the state we represent, should deeply care what happens to a child if they are dropped off at school or preschool and their parents are caught up in a deportation or immigration circumstance or any other circumstance, but specifically to this Bill, and that kindergartener or that child is standing out on the street corner waiting for their parent to come back and not have a place for them.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
The spirit of this law is real and needs to be addressed. My good colleague from Los Angeles said it should be the parents' right. The parents' signature. The mom should decide. The mother should make that choice in her direct comments. I wholeheartedly agree with my colleague, but that's not what this Bill says.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
This Bill does not say that. I need your computer. Mine's dead. Something happened. Sorry. I need the language. I want to read the definition of the language. My computer went down and I'm sorry, so I can't get you the language right in front of it. The computer in this—the language in this computer.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
I actually have it on my phone, too. The definition of a relative—someone who can self-identify under the penalty of perjury, which is an AB 109 crime. There's no penalty, no jail time. There's a veiled threat that you might get in trouble, but you self-identify. An individual can self-identify and claim, right? Thank you.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
And claim that they are a relative for the purposes of signing this caregiver affidavit. The relative definition, the purposes of item five, permission to read?
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including step parents, siblings, and all relatives with a status preceding the words great, great, great, grand spouse of any of these persons, any of the ones I just listed, even if the marriage was terminated, death, or disillusioned.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
If I was in this situation, my ex-husband's second wife and her four cousins in the fifth degree could go and pick up my granddaughter with a self-certified affidavit. Now let's go to the affidavit. The affidavit itself says—I don't have my laptop, so you have to forgive me.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
The affidavit itself, you have to go in to the fifth degree of a self-determined applicant for a caregiver, in everything that I just identified, and it says the minor lives at home and is one—and I am 18 years of old. I'm the caregiver applying for this.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
The name of the minor, the minor's birth date, my name, and my home address, that's it. And then they say nothing else. And the facilities are held harmless. There is an affidavit in here and that was the big issue on the affidavit is it did not allow a parent's signature.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
If you go to the section where it says warning, it's a warning to the person applying to be the caregiver. Somebody that says there's someone related to the fifth degree of a divorce or delusion or death of a family member, step or otherwise.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
That person can go in and say I, under penalty of perjury, I'm here to pick up so and so, this child, and my name is, and my address is. You sign under penalty, perjury, which is like I said, an AB 109 crime, and then it says warning, educational ed—educational agencies—and healthcare service providers, okay, and the parent signature, it's in red, it was amended out.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
There is no parent signature required. My good colleague from San Francisco said parents should have the opportunity to pre-plan. My good colleague from Los Angeles said it should be the mother's choice. Wholeheartedly agree. The mother, the parent.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
When I go pick up my granddaughter from childcare, I have to stick my face in a screening camera, show my ID, they print out a ticket, and I can go get her.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
It shouldn't be a self-identified person that walks in with a caregiver application and that you can get online that says that I am entitled to pick up this child.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
The parent should decide that. The Parent should say, if something happens to me, regardless if it's a deportation circumstance or any other reason, the parent should say, I want these five people to be called, these eight people to be called, or whatever, to make sure that my child is taken care of.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Again, the essence and the spirit of this Bill needs to be addressed. No one, no one, not anybody on your side of the aisle or on our side of the aisle, wants a child left. Could you imagine the trauma being left and not even know where your parents are?
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
There are things going on in this world that not everybody agrees with, I being one of them in certain circumstances. But the bottom line is that this law exacerbates the situation. It also says, it also says in this particular, it doesn't require a notary, no court, and not even a parent signature.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
The only safeguard offered is a threat of committing perjury, which is AB 109 crime, which doesn't even carry consequences. And this is the only section, the 4660 or whatever it is, I'm sorry, I don't have it up on my laptop because mine is down. But that section, every section of this Bill talks about an immigration and deportation circumstance except that section of the Bill which would include all children in the State of California.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
But in this particular case that I'm talking about, this Bill, all children should be created equally. All of them. Whether you're undocumented, illegal, whatever word you want to use, it doesn't matter.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
All children should be protected in this state by all of us, and this Bill is not protecting those children. I worked four years on human trafficking fighting this body to protect these children. You don't think these perpetrators are ahead of us, like no tomorrow? No tomorrow. They are so ahead of us.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
You don't think you can get those kids names online that go to that school? I'm asking you to protect these children. Have the parents decide. Fund the schools. I'll help you. I'll make a—I'll join you to fund the schools to educate children to parents, to say, listen and don't—and nobody wants to expose somebody here who's illegal or undocumented, right?
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
So, make sure all parents, every parent, has a preauthorized plan, like my colleague from San Francisco said, and my colleague from Los Angeles said, preauthorized plan to have your child pick up if something happens to you. A preauthorized plan.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Don't let someone come in and say that they are a caregiver. They pulled this information online. They filled it out themselves and all they had to do was put their name, the child's name, the child's birth date, the person's name, and their address.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
You don't even ask for a phone number on items one through four that's required by this affidavit. Respectfully ask for a no vote. Fix this Bill. We will help you. None of us want a child left behind. Not one of—not one. We want that child taking care of them. We want that child with grandma and grandpa.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
We want that child with the neighbor they grew up with. We want that. We want the child with the parent. But if something happens, we want that child taken care of and not left at the hands of strangers that somebody else made a determination for a parent. Respectfully ask for a no vote. And let's fix this.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise today to express my firm opposition to the Assembly Bill 495.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
And I also want to say how disrespectful it is that on such an important bill for debate that so many of our colleagues have left the hall today. Every single person on this side of the aisle is mourning the loss of a great figure in conservative policies and education for children.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
But yet, we are here. In today's America, and for decades, minor children have been trafficked across our borders, oftentimes by the very family members paying thousands of dollars to a coyote or a smuggler to bring their children to America. Who is responsible for separating that family? Who is responsible for putting that child's safety at risk?
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
Enough with the hateful rhetoric. Enough. This Bill is a direct assault on parent rights and puts children in harm's way. This Bill is not about protecting kids that is portrayed to do, but it's about removing the safeguards that keep them safe.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
As written, the Bill would essentially allow a non-parent to claim guardianship over a child at their school.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
It permits these caregivers to perform functions that parents normally would, such as enrolling children in school and consenting to all forms of medical, dental, or mental health care, even some of the serious treatments that we debate here on this floor, such as sex trait modification, all without parental consent or court oversight.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
The burden is on schools and daycare centers to verify the identity and the relationship and the legitimacy of the adult presenting the authorization affidavit. And although they—schools—would be protected from liability if a child is handed over to a stranger or trafficker, who then will be responsible for the potential harm of that child?
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
This Bill is washing the hands of liabilities from our schools, but yet putting them on the front line to make decisions about who they would hand my child over to.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
Without proof, without background checks, without court review, this Bill essentially opens the door for abusers and traffickers to gain legal authority over a child, effectively cutting parents out of their life changing decisions about education and medical care. And that the trust and security of children, their needs, could be replaced with tragedy and a future of trauma.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
I wonder, we can all see this as a public safety risk, both those who are on the other side of the aisle and here. But yet, looking at this as a public safety bill, why was it never heard in the Public Safety Committee? I'm baffled by that.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
In order for us to board an airplane, we must have a federal form of ID. We must have our biometrics checked, we must have a boarding pass that checks all of our documentation to make sure we are who we say we are to get onto that plane.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
We have to take out things from our pockets, pour out our liquids, take out our electronics. Gratefully, we can keep our shoes on now, but that's just to board a plane. Yet we are saying to take a child in this state, we are going to have less regulations to protect the fate of a child.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
These are not hypothetical risks. These are real loopholes that invite the exploitation of children. We must do everything possible to protect the vulnerability of our children and not make it easier for bad actors to take power over them.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
Parents are the first and most important defenders of their children. I made three children in this body, and every day that they grew in my body, I feared of what decisions I needed to make to protect them and to guide them and to educate them.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
No one can take ownership of my children and be able to make the decisions that I, as a parent, can make for them. This Bill pushes aside parents and opens the door to danger. For the sake of our children and the safety of American families, I urge you to rethink your position today.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
I ask you to say no and say enough of government overreach into the nuclear core of the American family. We don't know who drew the maps, but we know who built the cages and it was not President Trump because Biden admitted to it under the Obama Administration.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Can we please stick to the merits of the Bill? Thank you.
- Marie Alvarado-Gil
Legislator
Madam President, I am responding to cages that were brought up in a previous floor discussion.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Like I stated. Senator, please stick to the merits of the bill.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yes. Madam President, ask asking you kindly to acknowledge that the topic of cages was brought up in this floor debate. And I was simply responding to that.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you. You, you have responded. Can you please stick to the merits of the bill?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Thank you. I think with that, I'm going to mic down and ask for a no vote. Thank you.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
Thank you. I rise in support of this bill not only as a co author, but as a former foster youth as well as an individual who has a Doctor in social work. And I want to highlight that the conversations around this bill has largely been around fear mongering. It is nothing more than that.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
This bill allows for parents and families to make a decision in case something happens to them. And I want to highlight that this bill is about a temporary request for the child that the parents choose, that the parents decided and signed off on and the courts approved. And it is for the stability of a child.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
When we talk about children, everyone is talking again about fear mongering and this and that. It is not about that. It is about the dignity and the safety and the stability of a child. I have often said that schools are one of the most stable places for children, including kids in foster care.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
When they move from home to home to home and they have a different experience than many of their colleagues, school is one of the safe choices. We want to provide more stability to the child when their family may take a hit. For example, my father was murdered. What does a family do?
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
A car accident, let alone a raid, immigration concerns, deportation, missing family Members, what happens? This is long overdue. This is very much needed for families to make a choice for the best interest of their child. When something bad happens. And I want to be very clear and I often try to rebut what is being said.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
Some have said that strangers or traffickers will take a kid because there's no oversight. Again, a caregiver's authorization affidavit does not grant legal custody. It does not. It only allows for temporary decisions like school enrollment and routine medical care. Again, supported by the courts.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
After an investigation and the courts deem it appropriate, some will say the bill creates a non relative extended family Member category. That's too vague and unsafe. This category has existed in California law for decades. Parents lose control over who cares for their child. Again, this empowers parents to make the choice for their family.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
We are not stripping a single parent away from their rights. We're enhancing their rights. It is the right thing to do for all families, whether they choose to utilize this law as something that helps their family or not. Again, I believe in giving families the choice to do what's best for their children.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Madam President and colleagues, I stand with great pride to support my Assembly Member from the San Fernando Valley, where we represent an area that is the number one targeted location in all of LA County where just yesterday individuals from the Valley were held at gunpoint, pulled from cars, you kidnapped from four different locations in the district that we both proudly represent.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I am astonished to hear on the other aisle this uproar that the concern, the I think invalidated concern regarding what is happening. Yet this is a response to the attacks that we're seeing in our community. It is not a concern to the actual cause of this bill.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
This bill wouldn't have needed to be necessary if none of this was happening in our communities. My fellow Assembly Member wouldn't have had to jump to the call if our constituents were not being kidnapped in our backyards. This is a response.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
It clearly states in the analysis that is at the discretion of the court to deem this individual as the caretaker of the kid. In the San Fernando Valley, we are hearing concerns from caregivers who their kids are.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The kids that they care for are telling them, my mom said that we need to find someone in case they're not home when we get out of childcare.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Where parents are talking to child care providers saying we're looking to figure out who we're going to leave our kids with if we are taken and kidnapped because they are kidnapped. And oftentimes it takes weeks for legal representation to actually be allowed to talk to them.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
This bill was thoughtfully thought out and it only enhanced what is currently in statute right now. I am not a parent. I can only imagine what it would feel like if I was taken from my home, not knowing who was going to pick up my kid from school.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I can only imagine as a kid what it would feel like if I was abandoned or felt abandoned at school because I wasn't picked up, not knowing that my mom or parent was taken. The Assembly Member has a personal connection to this.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Having seen her father or having heard her father experience his mom be kidnapped in front of him. These are the stories of so many immigrants, Latinos, and this not just in the San Fernando Valley, in the State of California. I am proud to stand with her. I thank my colleagues who. Who are helping with this.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
We need this additional protection because families are being broken up. Respectfully asking for an Aye vote.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Just one. One notation on this debate, which is that the. The law that is at issue here, the caregiver authorization form statute that this bill amends and makes minor updates to, was carried in 1994 by Senator Newton Durazo, Republican from the Glendale area, before he was replaced by Adam Schiff.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
This is a bipartisan issue, a bipartisan approach to assuring that families are kept together and served properly. So I believe Newton Durazo was right when he sponsored this legislation and received overwhelming bipartisan support and urgent I vote on this bill as well.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. And thanks to my colleague from Napa, because I actually just looked that up as well and was very astounded to find this information out. So very good job there.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
And I want to just say thank you so much as Chair of the Latino Caucus, to the good Assembly Member for bringing this forward who has worked so very hard. We know that this family preparedness is so very important as the President Trump's Administration is literally separating our families. When you go on.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
I hate to even go on Instagram because I've seen the stories of. I saw one story yesterday where a child was literally hugging his mom so hard, crying. He said, please, please. And he was praying, do not take my mommy away, Please, please. And he's pleading.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
And if you just watch this and you think, zero, my gosh, this child is pleading. He hugged her so hard, she was crying and pleading with him. And they stuffed both of them in the car. And then they ripped him apart, ripped him apart from his mother. I can't even imagine, as a mom, how that would feel.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
And what happens with that child? What happens? Do we just let them fall by the wayside, or do we have a plan in place? And again, let's not go on with misinformation. It's very dangerous to say that there are. I'm not even going to address it because, honestly, it's so dangerous to even repeat what the Republican colleague.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
My Republican colleagues are saying. Again, it tasked the Attorney General to create model policies for child care providers to ensure they have the tools and information they need to respond to Ayes raids.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Second, it creates a new temporary, which is not being talked about by my colleagues on the other side of the aisle, a temporary joint guardianship process that allows parents to designate a guardian.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
In fact, I use that often because I actually am up here seven months out of the year and I have to designate my really close family friend to go pick up my child oftentimes. Yes.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
And third, it prohibits licensed child daycare facilities and license exempt state preschool program facilities from collecting information, as we all have agreed is so very important. But it her bill establishes the joint guardianship process that allows parents, once again parents to designate a guardian in cases of egregious immigration enforcement.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
I ask my Republican colleagues to please urge you all to not spread misinformation. It's dangerous. The rhetoric is not okay in these circumstances. And I ask Members to join me in supporting AB495.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Seeing no other Member wishing to speak. Senator Arreguin, you may now close.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I want to thank my colleagues for the very robust debate and I want to particularly thank the Senator from Bakersfield for her comments and I think her sincere concern for the well being of children in California.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
But I just want to reiterate that this bill has been amended to I think, address the overarching issue that has come up in the debate by the Republican Members. So I want to cut through the noise and really focus on what this bill does and perhaps maybe people wrote their talking points before the bill was amended.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
I certainly understand that. But I want to address what the bill does currently and I just want to put this in context why we need this bill. As was stated, the caregiving affidavit is already existing law in California.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
The only change that this bill does with the amendments is to amend the definition of relative to be more inclusive of the type of familial relationships that people have in California, blood relatives and other types of familial relationships.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And to also say that a consular card can be a form of identification to satisfy the requirements of the affidavit. Those are the only substantive changes to Section 4 and 5 of the bill which amend the provisions of the caregiving affidavit. The references to non relative extended family Member, those have been stricken from the bill.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
That's no longer in the legislation that's before us today. And if Members have concerns about the affidavit process that would be more appropriately focused through separate legislation that could be considered by this body next year. So just put this in context.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
What we are seeing in California are parents being taken off the streets and separated from their children, and their children don't know where their parents are and they may never even come back. And so I wish this bill Wasn't needed, but it is.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And so what this does is build on the existing framework to one, ensure that there is a joint guardianship process. So references the fact that you can sign a piece of paper and there's no notarization, or the court doesn't have to verify that and they could take custody of the person that's not true custody of the.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
Of the minor. That's an issue that's addressed through a separate legal process. And what this bill does is expand upon that to create a process where the parent can request a joint guardian, a person that they designate. The court will review and approve that request, and there's an annual process to verify that request.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
So, yes, the parent will be involved in determining who. Who that guardian is to have custody over that kid. Moreover, the bill also ensures that, like with hospitals and churches and schools, that we have model policies around what happens if immigration comes into a daycare facility or preschool.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
I think we can all agree that I should never have to go into a daycare or preschool and to arrest parents or terrorize kids. But that's a sad reality now in California.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
And so if that is going to happen because this Administration has rescinded the previous federal policy to say that sensitive areas like schools and hospitals and preschools, places that were safe havens for people, that that's fair game for immigration enforcement, that those facilities, those preschools and those childcare facilities should know what to do in the case of immigration coming into those facilities.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
I think that's fair. Like we're requiring other industries, like whether it's hospitals or schools, to implement similar policies and protocols. So that's all that the bill does. This is not about stranger danger and allowing random people to take kids and to, you know, put kids in harm's way. That's not what this bill does.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
This bills on existing law that exists in our state, existing legal processes, and says in the case if somebody is deported or separated from their kid, that they are designating a person to take custody of that kid so that those kids are not being left behind.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
We cannot leave immigrant children and children in California behind with nobody to take custody, custody of those kids. That's what this bill seeks to address.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
I want to thank the sponsor for her courage and leadership and bring this forward, who's faced enormous harassment, misinformation, but who's doing the right thing to stand up for her, her families in her district, and families all over the State of California. Let's cut through the noise and let's do what's right.
- Jesse Arreguin
Legislator
For our kids and families in California. I respectfully ask for an Aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Arreguin moves call. Moving. Moving on to file item 42. Senator Richardson.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 748 by Senator Richardson an act relating to Housing.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
Good afternoon, Madam President. SB748 expands the use of encampment resolution funding programs to local jurisdictions for operating safe parking sites while locating interim or permanent housing for people experiencing homelessness living in their cars or recreational vehicles.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
This includes the acquisition of sites for safe parking, operation of the site, services to the parking site and increasing safe parking site hours.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
The Assembly amendments included the requirements for describing how local jurisdictions plans need to be listed that include how the funds will be used for safe parking sites and then secondly reducing the cost by removing the California Interagency Council on Homelessness quarterly reporting and instead requiring the information to be included in the annual report by HCD. With that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No. Mics up for discussion. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Richardson moves a call. Senator Cabaldon is ready to go on file Item 46. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 371 by Senator Cabaldon an act relating to Transportation.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. When SB371 left this house with overwhelming support, the message was clear. We needed to significantly reform the outdated insurance requirements that we had placed on rideshare when that service first began a little over a decade ago, when we had no evidence, no data, no studies to back up a number.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
But we chose the uninsured and uninsured motorist coverage level that was currently in existence. That number has not changed. It's $1.0 million. It is extraordinarily high and it is not required of anyone else. Not only $1.0 million, but nothing iis required of taxicabs or Turo or limos or even Uber Black.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
And so we indicated at that time our intent to reform that insurance requirement. And the opposition also signaled the same thing. The amendments coming back from the Assembly make that real. They modify those insurance limits to 60,000 per individual and 300,000 per vehicle. That will allow the rate fares to come down for California.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Not in some abstract way. If you look at your Uber or your Lyft receipts and you look at the booking fee or the government mandated insurance cost, it will be a direct reduction in the fares for Californians all over the state. This will be one of the most significant affordable, direct, immediate affordability wins for Californians.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
At the same time, the Assembly amendments also link this Bill to the Bill that we took up earlier in the week that assured that drivers get appropriate compensation rights, the right to collective bargaining to assure that they are treated fairly as they move other Californians and their neighbors around, but also that more Californians agree to do driving in these services.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
Because the second most important thing that we can do to make fares more affordable and service more reliable and more frequent is to make sure that there are enough excited drivers in California ready to sign up and be on the app. So that's the full scope of the Assembly amendments.
- Christopher Cabaldon
Legislator
They also provide for additional reporting so we'll be able to hold ourselves and the companies accountable for both fares and for driver compensation. With that, I would urge an aye vote on the Assembly amendments.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cabaldon moves a call. Senator Cortese has file item 48. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 30 by Senator Cortese, an act relating to transportation.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Colleagues, SB 30 is back on concurrence. The bill establishes guardrails for how California public entities dispose of old, dirty diesel rail engines when they transition to newer or rather cleaner equipment. The Assembly amendments now permit the transfer of tier one and older equipment if the engine is removed.
- Dave Cortese
Legislator
These amendments also remove the requirement for an environmental analysis prior to the transfer of tier 2 or newer equipment. Now an agency can simply approve it as long as they have a public hearing. Thank you, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. Seeing no discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Cortese moves the call. Senator Smallwood-Cuevas, you have file item 64.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 464 by Senator Smallwood-Cuevas, an act relating to civil rights
- Lola Smallwood-Cuevas
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President and colleagues. I am proud to lift up SB 464, which is back on concurrence. Amendments narrow the scope of the bill and expand job categories included in pay data reports. Amendments remove all opposition, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No discussion on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Smallwood-Cuevas moves the call. Senator Weber Pierson is ready to go on file item 66.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 482 by Senator Weber Pierson, an act relating to state government.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Members, I rise to present SB 482, which is back on concurrence. This bill seeks to improve the accuracy and timelines of the California Roster of public officials. Amendments in the Assembly increase the days from 90 to 120 days that city and county officials have to submit their updated list to the Secretary of State after each general election. I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Weber Pierson moves the call. Secretary, please read File Item 70.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 518 by Senators Weber Pierson, an act relating to state government.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Members, as Chair of the California Legislative Black Caucus, I rise to present Senate Bill 518, a Black Caucus priority bill which establishes the Bureau for Descendants of American Slavery. Assembly amendments moved the Bureau from the Department of Justice to the Civil Rights Department.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
The amendments also narrowed the scope of the Genealogy Division and removed the Property Reclamation Division. In addition, the amendments expanded the scope of the Education and Outreach Division, allowing the Bureau to collaborate with outside organizations and the ability to accept donations and grants. And finally, Assembly amendments removed the legislative analysis from the responsibilities of the Legal Affairs Division. Respectfully ask for an aye vote on SB 518.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Weber Pierson moves a call. Senators, we have the ability to stop putting things on call. We need all Senators to come back to the floor, all Senators to come back to the floor so we can go in a faster pace. Senator Richardson, you have File Item 71. Secretary, please read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Senate Bill 530 by Senator Richardson, and act relating to Medi-Cal.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
Good afternoon, Madam President. SB 530 is back on concurrence from the Assembly. SB 530 will strengthen access to Medi-Cal providers by enhancing alternative access standards and extend Medi-Cal plan provider standards.
- Laura Richardson
Legislator
The amendments that were taken in the Assembly will align SB 530's provisions to the federal timelines the Department of Health Care Services has to meet and therefore will reduce costs. This bill has received strong bipartisan support in both Houses, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up, secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Richardson is forced to put on call, so missing Senators, if we can get the remaining Senators back on the floor?
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazzo is ready to go on file item 90. Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 754 by Senator Durazo and accolade to public health.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. SB754 requires manufacturers of pads and tampons to report levels of lead, cadmium, cadmium, arsenic and zinc in their products to the Department of Toxic Substance Control, who can then publish those results at their discretion.
- MarĂa Elena Durazo
Legislator
It also authorizes the DTSC to publish a more extensive list of concerning chemicals in pads and tampons for manufacturers to test for Assembly. Amendments clarify that the DTSC can publish a list of acceptable testing methods to accomplish these goals and make other clarifying and technical changes. I ask for your aye on concurring in these amendments. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. No mics up. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Durazo, once again moves a call. Senator Hurtado, we're coming to you with file item 40 and 128. File item 40. Is your SB593 back on concurrence?
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 593 by Senator Hurtado an act relating to Electricity.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. 593 is back on concurrence. It was significantly amended and is now a study Bill directing the CPUC to require large electrical corporations to study significant voltage related incidents and associated consumer protections across residential, commercial and industrial customers by January 12027.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
SB593 will give us a clear picture of the scope of voltage related to incidents and ensure accountability and protections for California consumers. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Hurtado moves the call. Secretary, please read File Item 128.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1527, by Assembly Member Soria an act relating to tribal gaming and declaring the urgency thereof to take effect immediately.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. AB 1527. I'm presenting here on behalf of Assembly Member Soria. It provides a one year extension of the Chachancy Tribe's 1999 gaming compact, allowing it to remain in effect until December 312026. The Chukchansi Casino Resort, which opened in 2003, is a vital part of the Central Valley economy.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
It provides nearly 1500 jobs, more than 90% held by non tribal Members in the local community. Revenues Fund, essential health, housing and scholarship programs for the Chachenzee people. The tribe and the governor's office are currently in the midst of government to government negotiations for a compact. The existing compact is set to expire in January 2026.
- Melissa Hurtado
Legislator
And to prevent disruption of this critical economic and community resource, AB 1527 ratifies a one year extension so negotiations can continue without risk of a shutdown. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senators, we're going to establish a roll call right now. I think we have all Members on the floor. I see no debate. So, Secretary, please call the roll. This requires a 2/3 vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. noes. Zero measure passes on the urgency. Ayes. 40. No, zero. First measure of the day to pass. Senator Allen, you have filed item 132. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 268 by Assembly Member Kalra, an act relating to Diwali.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
Yeah, thank you. I rise a proud co-author of AB 268 by Assembly Member Kalra, which would establish Diwali as a state holiday in California and allow public schools the option to close in recognition of Diwali if they so choose. Diwali is called the festival of lights.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
Celebrated by Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, and Jains of all ethnic backgrounds, making it one of the most culturally significant holidays for our South Asian diaspora. An estimated 1.2 million Californians across the state will celebrate Diwali this October, connecting communities across religious and geographic lines through the immense cultural heritage of the holiday.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
AB 268 follows the example set by Pennsylvania and New York by recognizing Diwali as a state holiday, which will give California public schools the opportunity to determine in their own communities if and how to recognize Diwali. And I just want to personally thank my good friend Manju Raman who brought this issue to my attention and got me involved with getting this bill done. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 36, noes 0. The measure passes. Senator Valladares, you have file item 155. Secretary, please call the roll. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1152 by Assembly Member Patterson, an act relating to controlled substances.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB 1152 on behalf of Assemblyman Joe Patterson, which protects privacy of Californians who are combating infertility. And don't worry, members; I don't think this bill will result in any surprise pregnancies in the Senate that I'm aware of. It simply removes HCG from the controlled substance list and conforms with federal law. Respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes: 39; noes: one. The measure passes. Senator Seyarto is ready for File Item 158.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 587 by Assembly Member Davies, an act relating to student financial aid.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB 587 on behalf of Assemblywoman Davies. This bill recasts the public membership of the California Student Aid Commission to require one of the three public members to be a veteran or an expert on veteran-related issues.
- Kelly Seyarto
Legislator
The California State Student Aid Commission is a testament of our state's commitment to creating opportunities for upward social mobility. It is in that spirit that we should continue looking for ways to innovate in order to best serve all of California students. Our veterans can offer a unique perspective on their experiences traversing the financial aid system to further improve these systems in California. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you, Senator. Colleagues, while we waited till 4:00 p.m. to establish a full house, now that everyone's back, it's a little rowdy and loud. Please remember to take your conversations to the back of chambers. I see no discussion on this item. Secretary, this, this actually is eligible for unanimous roll call. Any objection? Ayes: 40; no: zero. The measure passes. Senator Wahab, File Item 165. Secretary, please read.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 243 by Assembly Member Ahrens, an act relating to postsecondary education.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
Thank you. I rise today to present AB 243 on behalf of Assembly Member Ahrens, which will reduce barriers for systems-involved youth to access higher education. Young people involved in the juvenile justice or Child Welfare systems often encounter significant obstacles when applying for college or financial aid.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
They may struggle to demonstrate that they are financially independent or justify their need for accommodations. Additionally, without a formal court order, specific information cannot be disclosed to higher education institutions, which can make it difficult to access financial aid or assistance with applications.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
AB 243 creates a simplified pathway for systems-involved youth to verify their dependency status to institutes of higher education. The language is narrowly written to protect youth's privacy, limiting what information can be shared and who can access it.
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
AB 243 will help former foster youth and those involved in the juvenile justice system access higher education and the opportunities that come with it. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No mics up. Any opposition to utilizing the unanimous roll call? See none, ayes: 40; no: zero. The measure passes. Senator Wahab--ayes: 40; noes: zero. The measure passes. Senator Wahab, you have File Item 184, which is a support-support. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assigned Bill 1529 by the Assembly Committee on Housing and Community Community Community Development and act relating to housing
- Aisha Wahab
Legislator
Senator thank you. AB 1529 is this year's Housing Committee omnibus Bill. It makes technical non controversial changes to housing statutes. I respectfully ask for your aye vote thank you Senator.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Any objection to utilizing the unanimous roll call on this item? Ayes 40. No. 0 measure passes. Right. Senator Limon, you have five items, so for the next couple of minutes, it's going to be your show. This is what we have, Senator. We have. Senator, file item ... and 199. So we're going to start with file item 86.Secretary, please read
- Committee Secretary
Person
Senate Bill 707 by Senator Limon an act relating to state government.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, SB702 requires an annual report by the governor's office on the Legislature on aggregate demographic information of individuals appointed to statewide boards and commissions. You may have heard of this Bill before. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator, this is the first time you've introduced this Bill, correct? Any discussion on this item? Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 39. No, zero. The amendments are concurred in Secretary. Please read file item 144.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 798 by Assembly Member Calderon an act relating to children's health.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. I rise to present Assembly Bill798 on behalf of Assemblymember Calderon. A Bill that adds children's diapers and wipes to the state emergency food bank Reserve program for distribution during a State of emergency. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Thank you. Senator, any objection to utilizing the unanimous roll call? I see no mics up. Ayes. 40. Eyes. 40. No. 0. The measure passes. Secretary, please read file item 204.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1069 by Assembly Member Bains, and act relating to aging.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Thank you. AB 1069 requires organizations like Area Agencies on Aging or Independent Living Centers to have access to an emergency shelter in order to ensure older adults and persons with disabilities receive continuous services and necessary support. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
No mics up on this issue, also eligible for unanimous roll call. Any objection? Ayes: 40; no: zero. The measure passes. Moving on to File Item 192. Secretary, please read.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1324 by assignment. Sharp-Collins an act relating to Public Social Services.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Senator, thank you. I rise to present AB 1324, a Bill which will increase eligibility for CalWORKS benefits by extending them to self employed workers that work over 100 hours a month while also allowing benefits for striking workers. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I got no mics up on this item. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 30, nos. 10. The measure passes. Please refile item 199.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 1319 by Assembly Member Schultz, an act relating to protect the species.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
Thank you. I rise to present AB 1319 by Assembly Member Schultz, a bill that puts into place a clear and expected process at the Fish and Game Commission to protect biodiversity when federal protections are repealed or weakened.
- Monique LimĂłn
Legislator
AB 1319 gives the state a better tool to manage petitions requesting listing of species under the California Endangered Species Act by allowing them to use a temporary provisional listing process that will save the state time and money. I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise in strong support of AB 1319 by Assembly Member Schultz. This bill is an important insurance policy that California must take to protect the more than 80 fish and wildlife species and 65 plant species that are currently covered by the Federal Endangered Species Act.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
The sad truth is that the federal government is threatening to retreat from decades-long protections of endangered species. We are talking about threatened and endangered butterflies, salmon, steelheads, sea turtles, whales, and more, some of them not currently listed under the state statute.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
Because of this, we're expecting a tsunami of single-species petitions for listing under the state's Endangered Species Act. The Fish and Game Commission and the Department of Fish and Wildlife are not designated nor are they funded to manage such a massive increase in urgent workload.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
SB 1319 is smart legislation that anticipates and creates a thoughtful and streamlined process that honors existing permits, provides appropriate public notice and participation, and expedites but does not expand in any way continued protections for our endangered native species.
- Catherine Blakespear
Legislator
AB 1319 also ensures that California can maintain our significant efforts to crack down on illicit wildlife trafficking within our state borders, such as trade in illegal ivory, sharks' fins, and pangolin products. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes: 25; noes: ten. The measure passes. Senator Ashby, you have the next two items: File Item 214 and--just one item, File Item 214.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Assembly Bill 1064 by Assembly Member Bauer-Kahan, an act relating to artificial intelligence.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senators, it's a bit too loud. A bit too loud. Senators, please take your conversations off the floor. Senator Ashby, you're recognized.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise to present AB 1064, the LEAD for Kids Act, to ensure that our children are protected from AI companion chatbots that present a grievous risk of harm. AI is becoming increasingly integrated into the lives of our children without sufficient information about how they are impacted.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Of specific concern is companion AI, which presents itself as an anthropomorphic chatbot designed to simulate a human personality. This form of AI can present as a trusted friend or even a mental health specialist or advocate.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
It can analyze the emotions and behavior of the child that it is interacting with, keeping them engaged in conversation that will seem very real and innocent to the child. In April, the Wall Street Journal published results of a months long study over several platforms that found that digital companions were easily persuaded to engage in sexually explicit discussions, even when users identified themselves as children.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Companion chatbots have been documented engaging in inappropriate and sexual conversations or encouraging children to engage in harmful behavior, such as eating disorders or even, at its worst, suicide. Sadly, these fears are not hypothetical. Children interacting with AI chatbots have indeed been harmed. Some have even died.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
We need to act with the utmost urgency to protect children from technology that was developed with profits in mind as opposed to the well being of our kids. I want to underscore that this bill's author has expressed that she is a believer in technological innovation, and we know that to be true of her.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
We know that AI holds so much promise, including for the next generation. But we cannot accept a future where children's closest friends and potentially sexual partners are algorithms manipulating them, sometimes with the most tragic of outcomes.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
There is no innovation that is more important than the health and safety of all of our children. This bill is sponsored by Common Sense Media and is supported by our own Attorney General, Rob Bonta, and a very long list of organizations who advocate for the safety of children online. I respectfully ask for your support.
- Steve Padilla
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I rise in support. Just articulate that I think the advent of companion chatbots and the algorithms are so powerful, demand so much data. This technology is evolving rapidly, and the risk to all of us, the most vulnerable among us, is substantial. Colleagues, we missed a window of opportunity with the advent of social media. This technology is global. It's integrated. It's deployed.
- Steve Padilla
Legislator
It's powerful, and it's evolving at an exponentially rapid rate. We do not have time to waste. AB 1064 provides deep and discreet protections for those most vulnerable among us, children, who do not have the capacity of discernment, who do not have the capacity of resource. And if we fail to take any action at this time, in this moment to provide protection for them, it is a moral failing.
- Steve Padilla
Legislator
I'm proud to support this bill. I will note that many of my colleagues are well aware I have a similar bill in the other house. And it is the opinion of this author and me both unequivocally make this clear that these bills are harmonious. They seek to work discreetly in separate but harmonious areas of public policy protection. This bill is worthy of support. I urge an aye vote.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
I'm talking to both sides of this issue. There is a deep concern that the bill is overly broad and it doesn't allow any child to engage in a chat box. Somebody 17, researching a high school project. Somebody 15, looking up scores and how to write a paper on basketball, whatever. Does this bill stop every child from engaging in a chat bots?
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Great. Excellent question. No, of course this doesn't prevent young people from using AI technology or chatbots or any of those programs. It is intended to put up bumpers so that they don't believe that they're speaking to a real human being as that entity tries to manipulate them or tell them how to take their own life or pretend to be their girlfriend or boyfriend, manipulating their emotions. That is what this bill does. It protects our kids. It does not ban them from using these programs.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Members, while I understand and appreciate the concerns of the opposition that this bill is overly broad and vague, the language that I have read and the conversations that I've had with the author and other individuals, I really do believe that we have to rise in support of this measure to make sure that the security and the safety of our children are protected.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Especially the interest of protecting our children that are being sexually exploited or trafficked, are vulnerable of the situation that they find themselves in. If it's depression, whatever it is. This child should know and understand that it is not a human being on the other end talking to them, giving them advice, all of those things. There should be guardrails on any new AI technology that comes out to protect these children. And I respectfully ask for an aye vote.
- Jerry McNerney
Legislator
I rise in support of AB 1064. There's a lot of talk about how powerful AI systems are, and they are. They are trained on tens of millions and billions of parameters. But the thing is that they take their instruction from all of human history. They're taking instruction from the most vile literature along with the best literature. So it's very unpredictable what they are going to tell someone to do.
- Jerry McNerney
Legislator
And if that someone is a young, impressionable person, they could be feeding them with the worst information for that person's development. They need to be protected, and this is the body that's going to do that. I don't see this happening in Washington. I don't see this happening anywhere else. It's up to us. We're the last line of defense for these children. I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Seeing no other mics up. Senator Ochoa Bogh, you're recognized.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, I wasn't prepared to make a statement on this particular bill, but I do have some concerns. I understand there's another companion bill, not a companion. But another bill addressing the issue that's coming up from the Assembly that I will be supporting.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
But at this particular bill, the concerns that I've heard from one of the sites that we've spoken to are the concerns with regards to research and data at the university level that has to do with because of the content and the data that's being being used that relates to children and to minors.
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh
Legislator
That it does pose some obstacles in being able to use that data that's child related in university studies and research. So for those reasons I will not be able to support this particular bill at this time, but I will be able to support the other bill that is coming through from the Assembly and the other side. So thank you.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
I have good news for the Senator from the desert region. That portion of this bill has been removed, so perhaps you will be able to support it at this point. That no longer exists in AB 1064. I would like to thank the Senator from Bakersfield. No one has championed kids more and their safety and protections than you, and I appreciate your support on this one.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
The Senator from Pleasanton, you also have emerged quickly as a person very keen on how we address and protect people in the artificial intelligence space and I am ever so grateful for your comments today. And to the Senator from Chula Vista, what a great partner this author has been able to work with over the last few months.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
And moving forward, the people of the State of California are quite fortunate to have so many amazing leaders representing them in this space. This bill to me is incredibly important. We need to protect our kids. There's nothing more important than that. I urge an aye vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 31, noes 6. The measure passes. Senator Dr. Weber Pierson, you are up with file item 217.
- Reading Clerk
Person
Assembly Bill 766 by Assembly Member Sharp-Collins, an act relating to state government.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. I'm here today to present AB 766, a Black Caucus priority bill. This bill builds on the governor's 2023 executive order to require state departments to review their strategic plans to ensure racial equity and respond to disparities in the organization's mission, if possible. In this way, this bill enshrines the DEIA role of state government, pushing back against the trend nationally of running from what makes us a great state and nation.
- Akilah Weber Pierson
Legislator
DEIA programs are much more than just race. They include discussions of gender, sexual identity, language, age, and disability. They also focus on leveling playing fields for those that live in rural spaces: veterans, parents, caregivers, those experiencing poverty, and first-generation professionals. Removing DEIA program turns a blind eye to all of those groups. Everyone deserves a seat at the table and DEIA programs help guarantee that. I respectfully ask for an aye vote on AB 766.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes: 30; noes: nine. The measure passes. We're going to move into motions and resolutions. Senator Gonzalez, you're recognized.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, there is a resolution at the desk requesting permission to suspend Joint Rules 61 and 62A to allow the Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications to hold an informational hearing on the contents of Senate Bill 254 during the blackout and without sufficient notice daily file. The request has been approved by the Rules Committee.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, respectfully object and Ask for a no vote.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Valaderas is asking for a no vote. Senator Gonzalez is asking for I vote. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30. No, no 9. The joint rules are suspended. Senator Gonzalez, you're recognized again.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, there is a resolution at the desk requesting permission to suspend joint rules 61 and 62A to allow the Committee on Environmental Quality to hold an informational hearing on the contents of Senate Bills 237, 352 and 840 during the blackout and without sufficient notice in the daily file. This request has been approved by the Rules Committee.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President, respectfully object and ask for. A roll call vote. No.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
I got ahead of myself. Secretary, please read the resolution first.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Valladares is asking for a no vote. Senator Gonzalez? A none recommendation. Senator Valladares has a none recommendation on this motion request. Senator Gonzalez is asking for an aye vote. Secretary. Senate Valladares, I'm going to come back to you. If you want to clarify.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Respectfully object and ask for a roll call vote with a no recommendation. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 31. noes 9. The Joint Rules are suspended. Senator Gonzalez, you're recognized.
- Lena Gonzalez
Legislator
There we go. That's right. Thank you. Madam President, there is a resolution at the desk requesting permission to suspend joint rule 60 and 62A to allow the Committee on Appropriations to Hear Assembly Bill 870 pass the deadlines during the blackout and without sufficient notice in the daily file. The request has been approved by the Rules Committee. Secretary.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you. Without objection, But I'd like to call for unanimous roll call. The previous.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
You would like the previous roll call to be implemented on this one? ...
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Do we have any objection? C. No objection. To you, Senator Rubio? No objection. Okay. All see no objection. Ayes. 40. No, zero. The joint rules are suspended. Coming back to any Member that now wishes to be recognized under motions and resolutions, Senator McNerney.
- Jerry McNerney
Legislator
Thank you, madam President. At the request of the author, please remove file item 141, AB446, and file item 150, AB864, to the inactive file on the author's request.
- Susan Rubio
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. At the request of the author, please move file item 194 AB350 Bonta to the inactive file. Thank you. The desk would note.
- Benjamin Allen
Legislator
My favorite. Madam President, I'd like to ask that we move file item 136, AB 745 by Member Irwin to the inactive file at the request of the author.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The desk has noted, Senator, see no other Member wishing to be recognized. Senators, we are preparing the paperwork to be able to lift the cause on the 5,000 bills that we went through today that are on call. Give us a couple of minutes to prepare the paperwork.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
We ask that all Senators be on the floor so we can get through this list quickly.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
As we're waiting for this paperwork once again asking all Senators to come back to the floor in your chairs. All Senators to come back to the floor.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senators, we have 73 items on call. Please do not shout out your vote. We will be going. We will get to you. And please stay on the floor so we can hear your aye vote. We're gonna start with fire. Item 37. Please open the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 28, noes 10. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 58.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 37 knows one. The Assembly Members unconcurred in. Senators, we will not be holding the roll call for you. If you missed your chance to add on, you have missed your chance to add on. Please open the roll call and file item 60.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30, noes 10. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Let's call the absent Members for file item 69.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
30 on the urgency. Ayes. 30, noes 10. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Please call the absent Members on file item 74.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30, noes 10. The Assembly Members are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 77.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30, noes 10. The Assembly Members are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 80.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 22. No. 16. The Assembly amendments are concurred in Call absent Members on file item 103.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 35. No zero. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on 116.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 28 no's 9. The measure passes. Call the absent Members on file item 145.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 30, noes nine. The measure passes. Call the absent Members for file item 145.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 29, noes 10. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on file item 170.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39 knows one. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on file item 172.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 31, noes 8. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on file item 178.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 38, noes one. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on Fire, item 179.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 24, noes 11. The measure passes. Call the absent Members on file, item 181.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
On the urgency, Ayes 37, noes 1. The measure passes. Please call the absent Members on file, item 185.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 29, nos. 10. The measure passes. Call the absent Members on file, item 188.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 38. No 0. The measure passes. Let's call the absent Members on file, item 186.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 35. No zero measure passes. Call the absent Members on file, item 193.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 30. No. 7 measure passes. Call the absent Members on file, item 200.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
\Ayes 27. No zero measure passes. Call the absent Members on item 202.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No zero measure passes. Call the absent Members on fire, item 203.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 29, nos. 8 measure passes. Call the absent Members on file item 2205 on the urgency eyes 29 nos 8, please. Please call the opposite Members and file item 205.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 29 noes 8. The measure pass. It passes. Please call the absent Members of item 219.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30, noes nine measure passes. Call the absent Members on file item 220.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 24 noes 11 measure passes. Call the absent Members on fire item 224.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 29 noes 9 measure passes. Call the absent Members on file item 83.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30 noes 55. The Assembly Members are concurred in. Call the absent Members on item 17.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 31 No one. The Assembly amendments are concurred in Call the absent Members on file item 18.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in Open the roll and file item 29 Adin.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40 no 0 the Assembly amendments are concurred in open the roll on file item 34.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40 no 0 Assembly amendments are concurred in open the row and file item 39.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40 no 0 Assembly amendments are concurred in open the roll and file item.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39 no 0. Assembly Members are concurred in. Open the roll on file item 51.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 38 no. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call on file item 55.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39 no 0. The Assembly Members. please open the roll call and file item 56.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call item 63.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39 no 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call on file item 79.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. We have 34 more items left on call. Open the roll call and file item 169.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No. 0. The measure passes. Please Open the roll and file item 174.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 35, noes 5. The measure passes. Open the roll call and file item 183.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No 0. The measure passes. Open the roll on file item 201.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No, zero. The measure passes. Please open the roll on file item 208.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No, zero. The measure passes. Open the row on file item 218.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39 on the urgency. Ayes 39. No zero. The measure passes. Open the roll call and file item 20.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No, zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll on file item 25.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No 0. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 35.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No, zero. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll and file item 54.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40 no, zero. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 65.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
On the urgency. Ayes. 40. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call on file item 19.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on fire, item 26.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll on file item 27.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. We have 20 left on the list. Please open the roll and file item 33.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No, zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 43.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 37. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file item 61.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No, zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call on file item 68.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 38. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call. Item 76.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
We're having a little bit of a hard time hearing some Senators ayes. We need Senators to be as close as possible to us physically. Please and thank you. Senators, ayes. 40. No, zero. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on fire. Item 81.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senators, we need all Senators on the floor. Ayes. 40. No, zero. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Unless you have an Umberg eye. We cannot hear you. Please call the absent Members on file item 148.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. noes 0. The measure passes. Open the roll on file item 161.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No, zero the measure passes. Open the roll call file item 213.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40. No, zero the measure passes. Open the roll call on file item 44.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 40 knows 0 the Assembly amendments are concurred in. We have 10 left on the list. Please help the roll call on fire. Item 226.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 29. noes 10. The measure passes. Open the roll call on file. Item 42.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39I 39. No. 0 the measure. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Please open the roll call file item 46.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 39. No 0. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Please open the roll and file item 48.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 29, nos. 10. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Please call the roll and file item 64 or open the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes 30. noes 10. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Open the roll call on fire. Item 66.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. The Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members on file. Item 70.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 30. noes 10. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Last three. Please call the roll on file. Item 71.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 32. No. 6. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Call the absent Members to file item 90.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. Assembly amendments are concurred in. Last one. Please open the roll on file, item 40.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Ayes. 40. No. 0. Assembly amendments are concurrent. Moving into motions and resolutions. Senator Wiener. Motions and resolutions. You're recognized, Senator.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
I thank you, Madam President. I move to suspend Senate Rule 29.3b. To allow the Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review. To cross Author amendments for AB145 after the deadline.
- Suzette Martinez Valladares
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. Respectfully object. Call for a roll call vote. Urge a no. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Senator Valladares is asking for a no vote. Senator Wiener is asking for an aye vote. Secretary, please call the roll.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Aye. 30 nos. 9. The Senate rules are suspended. Moving into Committee announcements, Senator Ashby.
- Angelique Ashby
Legislator
Business, professions and economic development will meet. In room 1122 upon adjournment. I'm sorry. Upon recess.
- Scott Wiener
Legislator
Thank you, Madam President. The Budget Committee will convene in room 1200. I want to say yes. Thank you 1200. Thank you.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Upon recess or 10 minutes after recess. 10 minutes. Thank you, Senator Peraz. You're recognized.
- Sasha Perez
Legislator
Hi. Senate Education Committee will meet in room 210010 minutes after we go into recess.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
Seeing no other Committee announcements, we have a message from the pro tem.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Thank you so much. Madam President. Just quick word of show for this evening. Making sure that we're all on the same page. Appreciate the work of our policy chairs and Public Policy Committee Members. After those committees happen, we're going to potentially come back into session.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
So here's what we'd like to be able to do and talk a little bit about line of show. We'd like to allow for those three committees to advance this evening. We anticipate at least a couple of those committees may last an hour and a half to two hours.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
What we're going to do is keep Members and all the staff in the loop working with the Republican leader's office. And it will be, we'll be in recess and upon call we'll have folks come back or if we see those committees go late into the evening, we may just reconvene in the morning.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
So here's what we're going to ask. We're going to ask all Members, all Members to be able to stay here in the Capitol or in the swing space because we may be coming back to session to continue to do some night shift work tonight. So one more time.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
We're anticipating about 90 minute to two hour recess and upon call we'll be reconvening dependent on how long those committees will be and we'll be working with the Republican leader's office. We thank you so much, Madam President. I'll yield my time.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The Senate will be in recess for Senator Grove recognized. Senator. Senator, Senators, couple more minutes.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Thank you. Madam President. Today at the Utah Valley University, the first question that Charlie Kirk received was about religion. He spent 15 minutes, the last 15 minutes of his life talking about the love of his Savior, Jesus Christ. And then he was shot.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
He spent that last 15 minutes sharing the love that he had for the person who died on the cross for us and professing to thousands of students that if you confess with your mouth and believe in your heart that Jesus is Lord, that you'll be saved. He died for what he believed in.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
Charlie's legacy will always be engaging students, asking thought provoking questions and encouraging young adults not just to accept what others tell them. He did this through inviting students to college campuses to debate in public in the public square.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
And he brought back many of the nation's greatest philosophers that engage in civilization dialogue with open discussions from both sides and got both points of view. His life was tragically and senselessly taken away. But the impact that he had for generations of youth, over a million followers, and the kids he engaged in will never be forgotten.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
One of his favorite scriptures was Romans 8:28. God works all things out together for good for those of us who love him and are called according to his purpose. I struggle with that scripture today because it seems like says all things, but sometimes it's hard to wrap your mind and heart around things that happen that are senseless.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
He also lived by Joshua 1:9. You know, have I not commanded you to, to be strong and courageous? Don't be afraid for the Lord. Your God will be with you. He loved the Lord. He loved his wife Erica and their two beautiful children. He loved this country.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
And he was taken way too young at 31 years old by senseless violence. We all have a responsibility on both sides of the aisle to respect each other's opinions, no matter how different they are. And we should honor that.
- Shannon Grove
Legislator
And I'm going to start a hashtag, livelikecharlie, because I think he did what opened up dialogue throughout our country, and he was a great human being.
- Caroline Menjivar
Legislator
The Senate will be in recess upon the call of the pro tem.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. The Senate will be reconvening. Due to the length of committees this evening, the Senate is going to be in recess. We're going to be in recess until all legislative business has been received.
- Mike McGuire
Legislator
We're going to reconvene Tomorrow, Thursday, Thursday, September 11th, at 10:00am Notices will be going out to all Senate offices in the next 10 minutes. We are going to be recessed until Thursday, September 11th, at 10am we look forward to seeing you back here for another productive day.
No Bills Identified
Speakers
Advocate