SB 995: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-25
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 62. Noes 4. Page 5510.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 26, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (August 20). |
| Aug 18, 2020 | August 18 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Aug 12, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 11, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (August 6). |
| Jul 27, 2020 | July 29 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 4. Page 3849.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 22, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | June 18 hearing: Reconsideration granted. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3768.) (June 18). |
| Jun 11, 2020 | Set for hearing June 18. |
| Jun 9, 2020 | June 9 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 4, 2020 | Set for hearing June 9. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 29, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 3621.) (May 29). |
| May 19, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| May 13, 2020 | Set for hearing May 29. |
| Mar 18, 2020 | April 1 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 13, 2020 | Set for hearing April 1. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Feb 13, 2020 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2020 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | SB 995 Atkins Senate Third Reading By Gonzalez | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2020 | SB 995 Atkins Senate Third Reading By Gonzalez Move Previous Question By CALDERON | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 6, 2020 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2020 | Senate 3rd Reading SB995 Atkins et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2020 | [06-18-2020] set for [First] hearing: Reconsideration of favorable vote granted | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 9, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2020 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 995 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 995
Author: Atkins (D), Caballero (D), Rubio (D) and Wiener (D), et al.
Amended: 8/25/20
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 5/29/20
AYES: Allen, Hertzberg, Hill, McGuire, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dahle
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 32-4, 6/25/20
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Melendez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Not available
SUBJECT: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends for four years the expedited California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) administrative and judicial review procedure established by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act for “environmental leadership development projects” (ELDP) and expands the Act’s eligibility to include smaller housing projects.
Assembly Amendments
prohibit any part of a housing project that is seeking eligibility under the Act from being used for a rental unit, from being designated for hotel, motel, bed and breakfast inn, or other transient-lodging use, or from being used for manufacturing or industrial uses; specify procedures for the quantification and mitigation of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions for eligible projects, except for the smaller housing projects; and prioritize on-site and local direct GHG emissions reductions over offsets.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law, under CEQA:
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code §21000 et seq.). If there is substantial evidence, in light of the whole record before a lead agency, that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a draft EIR (CEQA Guidelines §15064(a)(1), (f)(1)).
- Allows lead agencies to prepare master environmental impact reports (master EIRs) for specified projects that include smaller, individual subsequent projects. Prescribes information included in a master EIR, including a description of anticipated projects that would be within the scope of the master EIR and a description of potential impacts of the anticipated subsequent projects (PRC §21157).
- Establishes the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900, Buchanan, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011), which established CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures for an "environmental leadership" project (PRC §21178 et seq.).
This bill:
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
- Extends the Governor’s authority to certify a leadership project to January 1, 2024, and repeals AB 900 on January 1, 2025.
- Makes infill housing development projects that meet certain requirements, including a minimum investment of $15,000,000 in California, at least 15 percent of the project is dedicated to housing that is affordable to lower income households, and labor requirements, eligible for certification.
- Prohibits any part of the housing project from being used for manufacturing or industrial uses, a rental unit for a term shorter than 30 days, or designated for hotel, motel, bed and breakfast inn, or other transient-lodging use.
- Specifies that if a local agency has adopted an inclusionary zoning ordinance that establishes a minimum percentage for affordable housing within the jurisdiction that is higher than the 15 percent required by the bill, that the ordinance shall be used.
- Specifies that a housing development project is a project for residential units only, mixed use development with at least two-thirds of the square footage dedicated to residential use, or transitional or supportive housing.
- Specifies procedures for the quantification and mitigation of GHG emissions that would apply to ELDPs, except for the smaller housing projects, and prioritizes on-site and local direct GHG emissions reductions over offsets.
- Requires the project applicant to agree to pay the costs of the trial court, in addition to the existing requirement to pay for the costs of the court of appeal.
- Authorizes the Office of Planning and Research to charge a fee to an applicant seeking certification pursuant to the Act for costs incurred by the Governor’s Office in implementing the Act.
Background
- Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011. Existing law provides a framework for expediting CEQA review of major projects. The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (hereafter AB 900 or Act), established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for the review of the environmental review documents and public agency approvals granted for designated residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects, known as Environmental Leadership Development Projects (ELDP). To qualify as an ELDP, the project must meet specified objective environmental standards. The Legislature has also applied similar expedited frameworks for specific sports stadiums that meet certain objective environmental standards.
- Review of ELDPs. In April 2019, the Senate Office of Research (SOR) released a report describing projects that have qualified for expedited CEQA judicial review pursuant to AB 900 and statutes similar to AB 900. In addition to analyzing the estimated benefits derived from ELDPs, the report also examined the legal challenges faced by three projects: the Sacramento Kings Arena, the Golden State Warriors arena, and the 8150 Sunset Boulevard mixed-use development project; each discussed in more detail below. The report also included some recommendations to the Legislature that would provide clarity to the act, increase reporting requirements, and strengthen environmental attributes of the ELDPs.
- ELDPs and housing. According to the SOR report, 10 of the 19 ELDPs have included a housing component. As of the date of the SOR report, none of the projects have been completed. Below is a summary of housing projects and their proposed housing units.
Project Name | Description | Proposed Housing Units |
8150 Sunset Boulevard | Residential housing, retail, and restaurant redevelopment on a 2.56-acre site | 249 residential units, 28 of which will be affordable housing (approx. 11%) |
Crossroads Hollywood | Residential housing units and hotel rooms | 950 residential |
6220 West Yucca | Residential housing and hotel redevelopment on a 1.16-acre site | 210 residential |
Potrero Power Station | Convert a closed power station to housing, commercial, community facilities, and entertainment/assembly uses on a 29-acre lot | 2,400 to 3,000 residential |
Hollywood Center | Residential housing and usable open space development on a 4.46-acre site | 872 residential, 133 of which will be affordable senior housing (approx. 15%) |
1045 Olive Street | Residential housing and commercial redevelopment on a 0.96-acre site | 974 residential |
10 South Van Ness Avenue | Residential housing, public space, and business redevelopment on a 1.17-acre site | 980 residential |
Hollywood & Wilcox | Develop a mixed-use project composed of multifamily residential dwelling units and retail, office, and restaurant uses. | 260 multifamily residential, up to 10% of which would be workforce housing |
3333 California Street | Create new residential housing and retail, office, and childcare uses | 558 residential, some of which would be affordable housing |
Oakland Athletics Stadium (AB 734) | Baseball stadium, residential housing, hotel, entertainment, office, retail, and open space redevelopment on a 55-acre site | 3,000 residential |
Comments
- AB 900 lawsuits. Of the projects that have been subject to AB 900, or similar expedited judicial review, four projects have been challenged under CEQA: (1) the Sacramento Kings Arena (Adriana Gianturco Saltonstall et al. v. City of Sacramento), (2) the Golden State Warriors Arena (Mission Bay Alliance et al. v. Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure and a separate non-CEQA lawsuit), (3) 8150 Sunset Boulevard Mixed Use Development which had 4 CEQA challenges to the project (Los Angeles Conservancy v. City of Los Angeles; Fix the City, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles; JDR Crescent v. City of Los Angeles; and Manners v. City of Los Angeles), and (4) the Los Angeles Clippers Arena (Saulo Eber Chan; MSG Forum, LLC v. Gavin C. Newsom; Joint Legislative Budget Committee). The first three challenges have demonstrated that expedited judicial review does not always guarantee a 270 day timeframe and cases can take longer to resolve due to, among other reasons, (1) ambiguity if the 270 days applies to business days or calendar days and if it includes appeals to the Supreme Court, (2) non-CEQA related actions which are not subject to the 270 day timeframe that are filed in addition to CEQA actions, or (3) consolidation of many, and sometimes complicated, actions. The fourth action, against the Los Angeles Clippers Arena, is still pending.
- Guaranteed Time Frames. Current law requires the courts to give CEQA-related cases preference over “all other civil actions… so that the action or proceeding shall be quickly heard and determined” (PRC §21167.1). In addition to this existing mandate, the AB 900 process provides that the courts, to the extent feasible, must complete the judicial review process in a given time frame for certain CEQA-related actions or proceedings. As a consequence, such mandates on a court delay access for other, unknown cases such as medical malpractice suits, wrongful death suits, or contract disputes. Calendar preferences and guaranteed time frames create additional demands and burden on our courts that have very limited resources and a never-ending supply of cases to hear.
- Ensuring the “Leadership” in Environmental Leadership Development Project. As originally enacted in 2011, AB 900 required ELDPs to, among other things, be certified as LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) silver or better, achieve a 10 percent greater standard for transportation efficiency for comparable projects, and not result in any net additional emission of greenhouse gases. Over the last nine years, those environmental standards have been strengthened to require LEED Gold certification and increase the transportation efficiency to 15 percent. As society continues to battle environmental impacts such as climate change, the standard of what is considered to be environmental leadership should also progress. Providing an expedited judicial review is a substantial benefit for developers and the requirements should ensure that these projects are exemplary examples of environmental leadership and deserving of the preferential treatment they would receive in the judicial system.
- ELDPs and affordable housing. SB 995 adds a new category of projects eligible for AB 900 certification - affordable housing projects. To qualify, the project must be located on an infill site, be consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or alternative planning strategy, have at least 15% of the project be dedicated to affordable housing, and must result in a minimum investment of $15 million in California. In comparison, current ELDP residential projects are subject to LEED Gold, do not have a minimum affordable housing requirement, and are required to result in $100 million investment in California. By lowering the investment requirement, removing the LEED component, and imposing a minimum affordable housing requirement, SB 995 provides an incentive for the development of affordable housing projects.
- Diminishing returns. In the almost 10 years since AB 900’s enactment, 19 ELDPs have been certified. Presumptively, this is due to the high standards a project must meet in order to qualify, such as resulting in a $100 million dollar investment in California and LEED-Gold certification. The proposed category for affordable housing has a considerably lower threshold to meet - $15 million investment and no LEED certification requirement. The intent being to provide incentive for the construction of these projects and to increase housing in California.
Although it is difficult to estimate how many projects could ultimately qualify under this new category, if numerous projects are fast-tracked to the front of judicial calendars, courts may be forced to repeatedly miss the 270 day deadline. In a sense, adding this new category could be a victim of its own success: at some point, the more projects that are eligible to benefit from accelerated judicial review, the smaller the impact of that benefit.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 757 (Allen) makes zero-emission, fixed guideway transit projects eligible for expedited CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures established by AB 900, subject to the enactment this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual General Fund costs of $875, 000, over the next four years, for Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to assist the Governor's office in the review of leadership projects, including the quantification of GHG emissions, and to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects, as necessary.
- Unknown General Fund administrative costs for the Governor's legal office to continue and expand its Leadership Act operations for four more years to include housing and alternative projects.
- OPR and Governor's Office costs will be offset by the applicant fee should one be established.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/30/20)
1hwy1
Associated Builders and Contractors Northern California Chapter
Bay Area Council
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
City of San Diego
City of San Jose
Civil Justice Association of California
Council President Georgette Gómez, City of San Diego
Downtown San Diego Partnership
Habitat for Humanity California
Los Angeles Business Council
Riley Realty, LP
San Diego Board of Supervisors, 4th District, Nathan Fletcher
San Diego County Board of Supervisors, Greg Cox, Chairman
San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Schneider Electric
Southern California Leadership Council
Yimby Law
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/31/20)
Angeles Mesa Homeowners Community Group
Associated Builders and Contractors - Southern California Chapter
California Judges Association
City of Hidden Hills
City of Malibu
City of Torrance
Communities United Cd7
Friends of Sunset Park
Riviera Homeowners Association
Shadow Hills Property Owners Association
Sustainable Tamalmonte
Tamalpais Design Review Board
Victoria/54th Ave Block Club
View Heights Block Club
WCH Association
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Prepared by: Genevieve M. Wong / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/31/20 23:59:11
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 995
Author:(Atkins, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends for four years the expedited California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) administrative and judicial review procedures established by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act [AB 900 (Buchanan), Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011] for "environmental leadership development projects" (ELDPs). Expands AB 900 eligibility to include smaller housing projects.
Major Provisions
- Extends AB 900's certification deadlines and sunset for four years, as follows:
- ELDP must be certified by the Governor before January 1, 2024.
- ELDP must be approved by the lead agency before January 1, 2025.
- AB 900 chapter sunsets January 1, 2025.
- Extends eligibility to housing projects that will result in a minimum investment of $15 million, but less than $100 million, provided at least 15% of project is affordable to lower income households and the project is not used as a short-term rental.
- Adds additional construction labor requirements to the existing prevailing wage/project labor agreement requirements, requiring eligible projects to use a "skilled and trained" workforce for all construction work.
- Requires project applicants to pay the costs of the trial court, in addition to the court of appeal, in hearing and deciding any case.
- Clarifies that the 270-day judicial review deadline is counted in business days and includes appeals to the court of appeal or Supreme Court.
- Specifies procedures for the quantification and mitigation of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions for eligible projects, except for housing projects from $15-100 million. Requires the baseline for GHG emissions be established based upon the physical conditions at the project site at the time the application is submitted. Prioritizes on-site and local direct GHG emissions reductions over offsets.
- Authorizes the Governor, before a lead agency's approval of a ELDP, to certify a project alternative if the alternative also complies with AB 900's statutory conditions at the time of the Governor's original certification.
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
COMMENTS:
In 2011, AB 900 and SB 292 (Padilla), Chapter 353, Statutes of 2011, established expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for a limited number of projects. For AB 900, it was large-scale projects meeting extraordinary environmental standards and providing significant jobs and investment. For SB 292, it was a proposed downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center project achieving specified traffic and air quality mitigations. For these eligible projects, the bills provided for original jurisdiction by the Court of Appeal and a compressed schedule requiring the court to render a decision on any lawsuit within 175 days. This promised to reduce the existing judicial review timeline by 100 days or more, while creating new burdens for the courts and litigants to meet the compressed schedule. AB 900's provision granting original jurisdiction to the Court of Appeal was invalidated in 2013 by a decision in Alameda Superior Court in Planning and Conservation League v. State of California. AB 900 was subsequently revised to restore jurisdiction to superior courts and require resolution of lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible.
Of the 17 projects certified in eight years of AB 900, only two projects have been built to date, and neither includes housing.
The two completed projects are the Apple Campus in Cupertino and the Golden State Warriors arena (Chase Center) in San Francisco. These two projects took different approaches to "environmental leadership" and mitigating project GHG emissions.
The Apple project, a large, ring-shaped office building, was designed and built consistent with Apple's corporate sustainability goals. The zero-net-energy building reduced GHG compared to the prior office buildings. Apple further committed to extraordinary measures to encourage employees to use bicycles, transit, and electric vehicles to reduce vehicle emissions. Construction emissions were offset by committing to purchase 100% renewable energy.
The Warriors project deducted the baseline GHG emissions from its prior arena in Oakland to reduce its GHG mitigation obligation, then committed to mitigate remaining GHG emissions by purchasing voluntary offsets. (This is consistent with the approach proposed by many other AB 900 projects.)
Though the Chase Center was certified by the Governor in 2015 and opened in August 2019, the Warriors first offset purchase was not executed until March 26, 2020. To offset its construction emissions, the Warriors purchased offsets sourced from the Hernando County Landfill in Florida at a cost of $3.50/ton. The total cost of offsetting construction emissions for the $1.4 billion Chase Center was $39,869. The cost of a single courtside season ticket in the 18,064-seat Chase Center is $52,800.
Many infill housing projects consistent with the applicable SCS are eligible for existing statutory or categorical exemptions under CEQA, without having to meet the additional conditions, process, and expense associated with AB 900 or master EIR certification.
The master EIR process has had limited use by local governments to plan for housing because a master EIR expires after five years and does not offer the longevity of a program EIR or the streamlining benefits of a specific plan EIR, which enables a full CEQA exemption for subsequent residential projects.
The AB 900 process requires a project applicant to meet AB 900's environmental and labor conditions, complete an EIR, prepare for an expedited trial in the event of litigation, and pay agency and court costs. It may be more suited for large projects with teams of attorneys and consultants, rather than smaller housing projects that may be exempt from CEQA or eligible for a negative declaration, and not required to prepare an EIR, under current law.
According to the Author:
No statement provided.
Arguments in Support:
According to the Home Building Alliance, SB 995 is an important tool to help address California's increasing need for additional housing units.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to Judicial Council, imposing a 270-day timeline for the review of potentially hundreds of housing projects, on top of existing CEQA calendar preferences, is an arbitrary and unrealistically short timeframe for California's trial courts to address all of the issues each CEQA case is likely to present.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual General Fund costs of $875, 000, over the next four years, for Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to assist the Governor's office in the review of leadership projects, including the quantification of GHG emissions, and to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects, as necessary.
- Unknown General Fund administrative costs for the Governor's legal office to continue and expand its Leadership Act operations for four more years to include housing and alternative projects.
- OPR and Governor's office costs will be offset by the applicant fee should one be established.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 32-4-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Melendez
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 8-1-2
YES: Friedman, Flora, Chau, Eggman, Luz Rivas, Mathis, McCarty, Cunningham
NO: Mark Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cristina Garcia, Muratsuchi
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-0-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Megan Dahle, Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0003377
Date of Hearing: August 18, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 995
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:August 12, 2020
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 8 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the expedited California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) administrative and judicial review procedures established by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act (Leadership Act) for “environmental leadership development projects” (Leadership Projects) for four years. Additionally, this bill expands the Leadership Act to include smaller housing projects. Among other provisions, this bill:
- Extends eligibility to any housing project that will result in a minimum investment of $15 million, provided at least 15% of the project is affordable to lower income households and the project is not used as a short-term rental. Clarifies that where a jurisdiction has an inclusionary ordinance requiring more than 15% affordable housing, the higher inclusionary requirement applies.
- Adds additional construction labor requirements for all eligible projects and requires certification by the Governor.
- Clarifies that the 270-day judicial review deadline is counted in business days and includes appeals to the court of appeal or Supreme Court.
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan elements, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
- Establishes guidelines for baseline quantification and mitigation of GHG emissions, as specified, to be certified by the Governor.
- Requires an applicant to pay costs of the superior court, as well as the Court of Appeal, in hearing and deciding any case.
- Establishes a process for the certification of an alternative project, as defined, by the Governor.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual General Fund costs of $875, 000, over the next four years, for the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to assist the Governor’s office in the review of leadership projects, including the quantification of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects, as necessary.
- Unknown General Fund administrative costs for the Governor’s legal office to continue and expand its Leadership Act operations for four more years to include housing and alternative projects.
COMMENTS:
- Background and Purpose. In 2011, AB 900 (Buchanan) and SB 292 (Padilla), Chapters 353 and 354 respectively, Statutes of 2011, established expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for a limited number of projects. For AB 900, it was large-scale projects meeting extraordinary environmental standards and providing significant jobs and investment. For SB 292, it was a proposed downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center project achieving specified traffic and air quality mitigations.
For the eligible projects, the bills provided for original jurisdiction by the Court of Appeal and a compressed schedule requiring the court to render a decision on any lawsuit within 175 days. This promised to reduce the existing judicial review timeline by 100 days or more, while creating new burdens for the courts and litigants to meet the compressed schedule.
AB 900's provision granting original jurisdiction to the Court of Appeal was invalidated in 2013 by a decision in Alameda Superior Court in “Planning and Conservation League v. State of California.” AB 900 was subsequently revised to restore jurisdiction to superior courts and require resolution of lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible.
This bill updates and extends the Leadership Act for four years and expands eligibility to include smaller housing units.
- Leadership Act. To date, 17 projects have been certified by the Governor under the Leadership Act. Conditions for certification include Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) gold-certified infill site projects, clean renewable energy projects, and clean energy manufacturing projects. The Leadership Act sunsets January, 1, 2021.
- Lawsuits. Of the projects that have been subject to AB 900, or similar expedited judicial review, four projects have been challenged under CEQA. Expedited judicial review does not always guarantee a 270 day timeframe and cases can take longer to resolve due to, among other reasons, (a) ambiguity if the 270 days appy to business days or calendar days and if it includes appeals to the Supreme Court, (b) non-CEQA related actions that are not subject to the 270 day timeframe and are filed in addition to CEQA actions, or (c) consolidation of many, and sometimes complicated, actions.
- Related Legislation. SB 757 (Allen) expands eligibility for CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures established by Leadership Act to allow zero-emission rail transit projects to be considered as leadership projects. SB 757 is single-joined to this bill and is pending is this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: August 6, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 995
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 32-4
SUBJECT: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
SUMMARY: Extends for four years the expedited California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) administrative and judicial review procedures established by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act [AB 900 (Buchanan), Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011] for “environmental leadership development projects” (ELDPs). Expands AB 900 eligibility to include smaller housing projects.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to CEQA, requires a lead agency with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to evaluate the environmental effects of its action and prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR). If an initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR. CEQA authorizes judicial review of the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR does not comply with CEQA, must be filed in the superior court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions.
- Pursuant to AB 900, establishes procedures for expedited administrative and judicial review (i.e., limiting public comments, requiring preparation of the record concurrently with the administrative process, and requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits challenging CEQA or other approvals within 270 days from the date the certified record is filed with the court, to the extent feasible) for ELDPs certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions, including Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) gold-certified infill site projects, clean renewable energy projects, and clean energy manufacturing projects.
- Defines ELDP as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Requires that these projects be located on an infill site.
- Requires a project that is within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy (SCS) or alternative planning strategy (APS) is in effect, to be consistent with specified policies in either the SCS or APS.
- A clean renewable energy project that generates electricity exclusively through wind or solar, but not including waste incineration or conversion.
- A clean energy manufacturing project that manufactures products, equipment, or components used for renewable energy generation, energy efficiency, or for the production of clean alternative fuel vehicles.
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Allows a person proposing to construct an ELDP to apply to the Governor for certification that the ELDP is eligible for streamlining. Requires the person to supply evidence and materials that the Governor deems necessary to make a decision on the application. Requires any evidence or materials be made available to the public at least 15 days before the Governor certifies a project pursuant to AB 900.
- Authorizes the Governor to certify an ELDP if the Governor finds the project meets all of the following conditions:
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- The project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages, provides construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment.
- Requires contractors and subcontractors to pay to all construction workers employed in the execution of the project at least the general prevailing rate of per diem wages.
- Provides that this obligation may be enforced by the Labor Commissioner through the issuance of a civil wage and penalty assessment pursuant to relevant provisions of the Labor Code, unless all contractors and subcontractors performing work on the project are subject to a project labor agreement that requires the payment of prevailing wages and provides for enforcement through an arbitration procedure.
- The project does not result in any net additional greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the Air Resources Board (ARB).
- A multifamily residential project provides unbundled parking, such that private vehicle parking spaces are priced and rented or purchased separately from dwelling units, except for units subject to affordability restrictions in law that prescribe rent or sale prices, where the cost of parking spaces cannot be unbundled from the cost of dwelling units.
- The project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required under CEQA shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case, including payment of the costs for the appointment of a special master if deemed appropriate by the court, in a form and manner specified by the Judicial Council.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the administrative record for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to CEQA, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project.
- Requires the Governor, prior to certifying a project, to make a determination that each of the conditions specified above has been met. These findings are not subject to judicial review.
- If the Governor determines that an ELDP is eligible for streamlining, requires the Governor to submit that determination, and any supporting information, to the Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) for review and concurrence or non-concurrence.
- Requires the JLBC to concur or non-concur in writing within 30 days of receiving the Governor's determination.
- Deems the ELDP certified if the JLBC fails to concur or non-concur on a determination by the Governor within 30 days of the submittal.
- Authorizes the Governor to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects pursuant to AB 900. These guidelines are not subject to the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures that require resolution, to the extent feasible, within 270 days, including any appeals, of a lawsuit challenging the certification of the EIR or any project approvals for a certified ELDP.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to an ELDP if the applicant fails to notify a lead agency prior to the release of the draft EIR for public comment.
- Requires the draft and final EIR to include a specified notice in no less than 12-point type regarding the draft and final EIR being subject to AB 900.
- Provides that provisions of AB 900 are severable.
- Provides that nothing in AB 900 affects the duty of any party to comply with CEQA, except as otherwise provided in AB 900.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to a project if the Governor does not certify the project prior to January 1, 2020.
- Provides that certification of the ELDP expires and is no longer valid if the lead agency fails to approve the project prior to January 1, 2021.
- Sunsets January 1, 2021.
- Defines ELDP as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
- Exempts from CEQA any residential development project, including any subdivision, or any zoning change that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with a specific plan for which an EIR has been certified after January 1, 1980, unless substantial changes or new information require the preparation of a supplemental EIR for the specific plan, in which case the exemption applies once the supplemental EIR is certified.
- Exempts from CEQA specified residential housing projects which meet detailed criteria established to ensure the project does not have a significant effect on the environment. [SB 1925 (Sher), Chapter 1039, Statutes of 2002] The SB 1925 exemptions are available to:
- Affordable agricultural housing projects not more than 45 units within a city, or 20 units within an agricultural zone, on a site not more than five acres in size;
- Urban affordable housing projects not more than 100 units on a site not more than five acres in size; and,
- Urban infill housing projects not more than 100 units on a site not more than four acres in size which is within one-half mile of a major transit stop.
- Affordable agricultural housing projects not more than 45 units within a city, or 20 units within an agricultural zone, on a site not more than five acres in size;
- Requires metropolitan planning organizations to include an SCS or APS in their regional transportation plans for the purpose of reducing GHG emissions, aligns planning for transportation and housing, and creates specified incentives for the implementation of the strategies, including CEQA exemption or abbreviated review for residential or mixed-use residential "transit priority projects" if the project is consistent with the use designation, density, building intensity, and applicable policies specified for the project area in either an approved SCS or APS. [SB 375 (Steinberg), Chapter 728, Statutes of 2008]
- Establishes abbreviated CEQA review procedures for specified infill projects, where only specific or more significant effects on the environment which were not addressed in a prior planning-level EIR need be addressed. An EIR for such a project need not consider alternative locations, densities, and building intensities or growth-inducing impacts. Infill projects may include residential, retail, commercial, transit station, school, or public office building projects located within an urban area. [SB 226 (Simitian), Chapter 469, Statutes of 2011]
- Exempts from CEQA residential, mixed-use, and "employment center" projects, as defined, located within "transit priority areas," as defined, if the project is consistent with an adopted specific plan and specified elements of an SCS or APS adopted pursuant to SB 375. [SB 743 (Steinberg), Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013]
- Establishes a ministerial approval process (i.e., not subject to CEQA) for certain multifamily affordable housing projects that are proposed in local jurisdictions that have not met regional housing needs. [SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017]
- Authorizes a city or county to establish a Workforce Housing Opportunity Zone (WHOZ) by preparing an EIR and by adopting a specific plan. Once a WHOZ is established, and for five years thereafter, requires approval of eligible housing developments within a WHOZ within 60 days without requiring the preparation of an EIR or negative declaration under CEQA. [SB 540 (Roth), Chapter 369, Statutes of 2017]
- Authorizes a city or county to create a "housing sustainability district" (HSD) to complete upfront zoning and environmental review in order to receive incentive payments for residential and mixed-use development projects with an affordable housing component. Requires the city or county to prepare an EIR when designating an HSD, then "housing projects" within, and consistent with, a designated HSD are exempt from CEQA. [AB 73 (Chiu), Chapter 371, Statutes of 2017]
- Exempts from CEQA multifamily residential and mixed-use housing projects on infill sites within cities and unincorporated areas that are within the boundaries of an urbanized area or urban cluster. [AB 1804 (Berman), Chapter 670, Statutes of 2018]
THIS BILL:
- Extends AB 900’s certification deadlines and sunset for four years, as follows:
- ELDP must be certified by the Governor before January 1, 2024.
- ELDP must be approved by the lead agency before January 1, 2025.
- AB 900 chapter sunsets January 1, 2025.
- Extends eligibility to housing projects that will result in a minimum investment of $15 million, provided at least 15% of project is affordable to lower income households and the project is not used as a short-term rental.
- Adds additional construction labor requirements to the existing prevailing wage/project labor agreement requirements, requiring eligible projects to use a “skilled and trained” workforce for all construction work.
- Clarifies that the 270-day judicial review deadline is counted in business days and includes appeals to the court of appeal or Supreme Court.
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- ARB estimates ongoing costs of $384,000 (special fund) annually to determine within 60 days whether a project will result in a net increase of GHG emissions.
- Unknown costs (General Fund) to the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research to review and certify ELDPs and, potentially, to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of ELDPs.
- Potential unknown cost pressure (General Fund) to the state-funded court system to process and hear challenges to the project's environmental review within the timeframes prescribed by the bill.
- Unknown but likely minor costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to adopt rules of the court to guide implementation of the provisions of this bill and to report to the Legislature.
COMMENTS:
- Background. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
CEQA actions taken by public agencies can be challenged in superior court once the agency approves or determines to carry out the project. CEQA appeals are subject to unusually short statutes of limitations. Under current law, court challenges of CEQA decisions generally must be filed within 30 to 35 days, depending on the type of decision. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. The petitioner must request a hearing within 90 days of filing the petition and, generally, briefing must be completed within 90 days of the request for hearing. There is no deadline specified for the court to render a decision.
In 2011, AB 900 and SB 292 (Padilla), Chapter 353, Statutes of 2011, established expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for a limited number of projects. For AB 900, it was large-scale projects meeting extraordinary environmental standards and providing significant jobs and investment. For SB 292, it was a proposed downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center project achieving specified traffic and air quality mitigations. For these eligible projects, the bills provided for original jurisdiction by the Court of Appeal and a compressed schedule requiring the court to render a decision on any lawsuit within 175 days. This promised to reduce the existing judicial review timeline by 100 days or more, while creating new burdens for the courts and litigants to meet the compressed schedule. AB 900's provision granting original jurisdiction to the Court of Appeal was invalidated in 2013 by a decision in Alameda Superior Court in Planning and Conservation League v. State of California. AB 900 was subsequently revised to restore jurisdiction to superior courts and require resolution of lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible.
To date, 17 projects have been certified under AB 900:
- McCoy Solar Energy Project in Riverside County.
- Apple Campus 2 in Cupertino.
- Soitec Solar Energy Project in San Diego County.
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard, a mixed-use commercial and residential project in Hollywood.
- Event Center and Mixed-Use Development at Mission Bay Blocks (i.e., Warriors arena) in San Francisco.
- Qualcomm Stadium Reconstruction Project in San Diego.
- 6701 Sunset/Crossroads, a mixed-use residential, hotel, and commercial project in Hollywood.
- Yucca-Argyle Project, a mixed-use residential, hotel, and commercial project in Hollywood.
- 10 Van Ness Avenue, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in San Francisco.
- 1045 Olive Street Project, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in downtown Los Angeles.
- Hollywood Center Project, a mixed-use project in Hollywood.
- Potrero Power Station Mixed-use Project in San Francisco.
- 3333 California Street Project, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in San Francisco.
- Hollywood & Wilcox Mixed-Use Project, a residential/retail/office project in Hollywood.
- Balboa Reservoir, a mixed-income housing/retail project in San Francisco.
- Downtown West Mixed Use Plan, an office/retail/hotel/events/housing/utility project in San Jose.
- California Northstate University Medical Center Project, a hospital/medical office project in Elk Grove.
- Senate review of ELDPs. In April 2019, the Senate Office of Research (SOR) published a review of ELDPs certified under AB 900 (https://sor.senate.ca.gov/environmentalquality).
One key finding from the report is that the benefits of achieving zero-net additional GHG emissions and the transportation efficiency requirements, as well as the benefits from jobs and housing creation, are largely unknown and uncertain. The unknown benefits from jobs and housing creation are simply due to not having any requirements for the project developers to report these statistics. However, the uncertainty from the GHG emissions and transportation efficiency requirements is primarily due to the problematic use of a baseline to measure current existing conditions. The report found that ELDPs appear to have much discretion in choosing various assumptions to determine their baselines and a lack of guidance and ambiguity presents verification challenges during the certification process. To resolve this issue, the SOR report provided recommendations for the Legislature to consider that would eliminate the use of a baseline and provide more robust upfront and locally-specific environmental benefits. These options included requiring upfront traffic and air pollution impact fees, a vehicle miles traveled threshold, and site-specific clean energy requirements.
To date, two ELDPs, the Warriors arena and 8150 Sunset Boulevard projects (as well as Sacramento’s Golden One Center project subject to similar procedures) have been challenged in court and received expedited judicial review. Although the shortened judicial review timeline of 270 days was not always met for these projects, the SOR report found that these projects have moved through the litigation process much faster than normal timelines. The ELDPs have likely received a significant streamlining benefit largely due to the concurrent preparation of the administrative record, as well as the judges’ deference to meeting the timeline and establishing streamlined court procedures. Additionally, the report found that all of the petitioners for the three ELDP CEQA cases stated that the shortened judicial review timeline did not adversely affect their ability to present their issues before the court. Recommendations from the SOR report related to the expedited judicial review process includes extending and clarifying the 270-day timeline and reducing adverse impacts on lead agencies when concurrently preparing the administrative record by extending some requirements.
- Is AB 900 keeping pace with environmental leadership on GHG mitigation and clean air? Following the enactment of AB 32 in 2006, SB 97 was enacted in 2007 to confirm the requirement to address environmental impacts of GHG emissions under CEQA and require the adoption of CEQA Guidelines for the mitigation of GHG emissions or the effects of GHG emissions, including effects associated with transportation or energy consumption. SB 97 requires the CEQA Guidelines to be periodically updated to incorporate new information or criteria established by ARB pursuant to AB 32.
Under CEQA Guidelines adopted pursuant to SB 97, a project’s GHG emissions can be reduced by “off-site measures, including offsets that are not otherwise required” and “measures that sequester greenhouse gases.” The CEQA Guidelines allow projects to reduce GHG emissions by relying on voluntary market offsets that are not otherwise required as well as other offsite and sequestration measures that result in GHG reductions.
When it was enacted in 2011, AB 900 required projects to achieve GHG neutrality, without specifying how. In practice, the AB 900 projects have relied heavily on voluntary offsets. Meanwhile, California's climate policy has focused increasingly on achieving local clean air co-benefits and reducing the reliance on offsets. In 2017, the Legislature's extension of the cap-and-trade program, AB 398, included a reduction in total amount of offsets that may be used for compliance, coupled with a requirement that at least half of offsets result in environmental benefits within California. A companion measure, AB 617, focused on improving local air quality by updating pollution controls at large industrial facilities in the cap-and-trade program and implementing community-based emission reduction programs in the most pollution-burdened communities.
Over the same time period, CEQA practice has demonstrated the feasibility of GHG mitigation plans that incorporate significant on-site and local direct GHG reduction measures, rather than relying entirely on offsets to mitigate projects' GHG emissions. For example, Newhall Ranch, a large project of over 20,000 homes and related development in Los Angeles County near Santa Clarita, was approved in 2017 with the developer’s commitment to "achieve zero net GHG emissions using feasible and reliable emission-reduction actions related to the land development project, the implementation of direct measures to reduce GHG emissions offsite, and the procurement of GHG offsets." To achieve net zero GHG, 13 mitigation measures were adopted for Newhall Ranch, including on-site, off-site and offsets. In total, approximately 55% of the GHG reductions are from on-site and local direct reduction measures, with the balance from offset projects, including some located in California.
In 2018, the Legislature passed AB 734 (Bonta) and AB 987 (Kamlager) to provide expedited judicial review for the Oakland A’s and Los Angeles Clippers projects respectively. AB 734 and AB 987 required at least 50% of GHG mitigation from on-site and local direct GHG reduction measures, and limited the use of offsets to 50% of GHG mitigation.
- AB 900’s real world performance. Of the 17 projects certified in eight years of AB 900, only two projects have been built to date, and neither includes housing.
The two completed projects are the Apple Campus in Cupertino and the Golden State Warriors arena (Chase Center) in San Francisco. These two projects took different approaches to “environmental leadership” and mitigating project GHG emissions.
The Apple project, a large, ring-shaped office building, was designed and built consistent with Apple’s corporate sustainability goals. The zero-net-energy building reduced GHG compared to the prior office buildings. Apple further committed to extraordinary measures to encourage employees to use bicycles, transit, and electric vehicles to reduce vehicle emissions. Construction emissions were offset by committing to purchase 100% renewable energy.
The Warriors project deducted the baseline GHG emissions from its prior arena in Oakland to reduce its GHG mitigation obligation, then committed to mitigate remaining GHG emissions by purchasing voluntary offsets. (This is consistent with the approach proposed by many other AB 900 projects.)
Though the Chase Center was certified by the Governor in 2015 and opened in August 2019, the Warriors first offset purchase was not executed until March 26, 2020. To offset its construction emissions, the Warriors purchased offsets sourced from the Hernando County Landfill in Florida at a cost of $3.50/ton. The total cost of offsetting construction emissions for the $1.4 billion Chase Center was $39,869. The cost of a single courtside season ticket in the 18,064-seat Chase Center is $52,800.
- Bill adds housing streamlining options to the many available under current law. Many infill housing projects consistent with the applicable SCS are eligible for existing statutory or categorical exemptions under CEQA, without having to meet the additional conditions, process, and expense associated with AB 900 or master EIR certification.
The master EIR process has had limited use by local governments to plan for housing because a master EIR expires after five years and does not offer the longevity of a program EIR or the streamlining benefits of a specific plan EIR, which enables a full CEQA exemption for subsequent residential projects.
The AB 900 process requires a project applicant to meet AB 900’s environmental and labor conditions, complete an EIR, prepare for an expedited trial in the event of litigation, and pay agency and court costs. It may be more suited for large projects with teams of attorneys and consultants, rather than smaller housing projects that may be exempt from CEQA or eligible for a negative declaration, and not required to prepare an EIR, under current law.
- Suggested amendments. The author and the committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Establish a definition for “housing project,” including clarifying whether the project must be entirely residential; whether it may be single-family houses, multi-family, or both; and what percentage of non-residential uses may be included if mixed-use is permitted.
- Clarify that the housing project category added by the bill applies to projects from $15 million to $100 million, while residential projects over $100 million remain subject to the conditions applicable to larger ELDPs, including LEED Gold certification and traffic efficiency.
- Clarify that where a jurisdiction has an inclusionary ordinance requiring more than 15% affordable housing, the higher inclusionary requirement applies.
- Establish guidelines for quantification and mitigation of GHG emissions, as follows:
- Clarify that the baseline for quantifying a project’s GHG emissions shall be based on existing physical conditions at the project site at the time of the application, shall not include hypothetical conditions, and otherwise shall be consistent with Section 15125 of the CEQA Guidelines as those regulations existed on January 1, 2020.
- Require mitigation of GHG emissions be achieved by direct emissions reduction measures to the extent feasible. Direct emissions reductions shall result from the project through implementation of project features, project design, or other measures, such as energy efficiency, installation of renewable energy electricity generation, and reductions in vehicle miles traveled.
- Require any offsets used for GHG mitigation be consistent with AB 32, including that the GHG emissions reductions achieved are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable; be implemented in adjacent and surrounding communities, to the extent feasible; and reduce emissions in California.
- Replace 15% transportation efficiency requirement – in subdivision (b) of Section 21180 – with the following:
21183 (h). The project achieves a 20% reduction in vehicle miles traveled per capita compared to existing development, as determined by the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research.
- Amend subdivision (f) of Section 21183 to require the applicant to pay costs of the superior court, as well as the Court of Appeal, in hearing and deciding any case.
- Amend subdivision (b) of Section 21184 to eliminate JLBC concurrence.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Association of Bay Area Governments
Bay Area Council
Bay Area Housing Advocacy Coalition
Bridge Housing Corporation
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Chamber of Commerce
California State Council of Laborers
California Yimby
City of San Diego
Civil Justice Association of California
Council of Infill Builders
Downtown San Diego Partnership
Facebook
Habitat for Humanity California
Hollywood Chamber of Commerce
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
San Diego County Supervisor Greg Cox
San Diego County Supervisor Nathan Fletcher
San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Schneider Electric
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Silicon Valley at Home
The Two Hundred
Unite Here
Up for Growth
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Yucca Argyle Project
Opposition
Angeles Mesa Homeowners Community Group
Associated Builders and Contractors - Northern California Chapter (unless amended)
Associated Builders and Contractors - Southern California Chapter
By the Beach Tamarack Group
California Environmental Justice Alliance (unless amended)
California League of Conservation Voters (unless amended)
Center for Biological Diversity (unless amended)
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment (unless amended)
Cherrywood Leimert Park Block Club
Citizens Preserving Venice
Citizens Protecting San Pedro
City of Hidden Hills
City of Redondo Beach
Communities United CD7
Comstock Hills Homeowners Association
Families of Park Mesa Heights
Federation of Hillside and Canyon Associations
Franklin Corridor Coalition
Friends of Sunset Park
Graylawn Neighbors for Quality of Life
Hyde Park Organizational Partnership for Empowerment
Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability (unless amended)
Leimert Park - Edgehill Drive Residents Association
Livable Riverside & Moreno Valley
Mission Street Neighbors
New Livable California
North Santa Ana Preservation Alliance
Northeast San Fernando Valley Activists
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles (unless amended)
Planning and Conservation League (unless amended)
Preserve Saratoga
Protecting our Foothill Community
Riviera Homeowners Association
Shadow Hills Property Owners Association
Sierra Club California (unless amended)
Southeast Torrance Homeowners' Association
Sunset-Parkside Education and Action Committee (SPEAK)
Sustainable Tamalmonte
Tamalpais Design Review Board
Tarzana Property Owners Association
Victoria/54th Avenue Block Club
View Heights Block Club
WCH Association
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Western Quadrant of North Leimert Park
Wilshire Montana Neighborhood Coalition
26 individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 995 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 995
Author: Atkins (D), Caballero (D), Rubio (D) and Wiener (D), et al.
Amended: 6/18/20
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 5/29/20
AYES: Allen, Hertzberg, Hill, McGuire, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dahle
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SUBJECT: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends for four years the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 until 2025; and makes housing projects that meet certain requirements, including specified affordable housing requirements and labor requirements, eligible for certification under the Act.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA):
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code §21000 et seq.). If there is substantial evidence, in light of the whole record before a lead agency, that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a draft EIR (CEQA Guidelines §15064(a)(1), (f)(1)).
- Allows lead agencies to prepare master environmental impact reports (master EIRs) for specified projects that include smaller, individual subsequent projects. Prescribes information included in a master EIR, including a description of anticipated projects that would be within the scope of the master EIR and a description of potential impacts of the anticipated subsequent projects (PRC §21157).
- Establishes the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900, Buchanan, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011), which established CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures for an "environmental leadership" project (PRC §21178 et seq.).
This bill:
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
- Extends the Governor’s authority to certify a leadership project to January 1, 2024, and repeals AB 900 on January 1, 2025.
- Makes infill housing projects that meet certain requirements, including a minimum investment in California, affordable housing requirements, and labor requirements, eligible for certification.
Background
- Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011. Existing law provides a framework for expediting CEQA review of major projects. The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (hereafter AB 900 or Act), established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for the review of the environmental review documents and public agency approvals granted for designated residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects, known as Environmental Leadership Development Projects (ELDP). To qualify as an ELDP, the project must meet specified objective environmental standards. The Legislature has also applied similar expedited frameworks for specific sports stadiums that meet certain objective environmental standards.
- Review of ELDPs. In April 2019, the Senate Office of Research (SOR) released a report describing projects that have qualified for expedited CEQA judicial review pursuant to AB 900 and statutes similar to AB 900. In addition to analyzing the estimated benefits derived from ELDPs, the report also examined the legal challenges faced by three projects: the Sacramento Kings Arena, the Golden State Warriors arena, and the 8150 Sunset Boulevard mixed-use development project; each discussed in more detail below. The report also included some recommendations to the Legislature that would provide clarity to the act, increase reporting requirements, and strengthen environmental attributes of the ELDPs.
- ELDPs and housing. According to the SOR report, 10 of the 19 ELDPs have included a housing component. As of the date of the SOR report, none of the projects have been completed. Below is a summary of housing projects and their proposed housing units.
Project Name | Description | Proposed Housing Units |
8150 Sunset Boulevard | Residential housing, retail, and restaurant redevelopment on a 2.56-acre site | 249 residential units, 28 of which will be affordable housing (approx. 11%) |
Crossroads Hollywood | Residential housing units and hotel rooms | 950 residential |
6220 West Yucca | Residential housing and hotel redevelopment on a 1.16-acre site | 210 residential |
Potrero Power Station | Convert a closed power station to housing, commercial, community facilities, and entertainment/assembly uses on a 29-acre lot | 2,400 to 3,000 residential |
Hollywood Center | Residential housing and usable open space development on a 4.46-acre site | 872 residential, 133 of which will be affordable senior housing (approx. 15%) |
1045 Olive Street | Residential housing and commercial redevelopment on a 0.96-acre site | 974 residential |
10 South Van Ness Avenue | Residential housing, public space, and business redevelopment on a 1.17-acre site | 980 residential |
Hollywood & Wilcox | Develop a mixed-use project composed of multifamily residential dwelling units and retail, office, and restaurant uses. | 260 multifamily residential, up to 10% of which would be workforce housing |
3333 California Street | Create new residential housing and retail, office, and childcare uses | 558 residential, some of which would be affordable housing |
Oakland Athletics Stadium (AB 734) | Baseball stadium, residential housing, hotel, entertainment, office, retail, and open space redevelopment on a 55-acre site | 3,000 residential |
Comments
- AB 900 lawsuits. Of the projects that have been subject to AB 900, or similar expedited judicial review, four projects have been challenged under CEQA. Expedited judicial review does not always guarantee a 270 day timeframe and cases can take longer to resolve due to, among other reasons, (a) ambiguity if the 270 days applies to business days or calendar days and if it includes appeals to the Supreme Court, (b) non-CEQA related actions which are not subject to the 270 day timeframe that are filed in addition to CEQA actions, or (c) consolidation of many, and sometimes complicated, actions.
- Sacramento Kings Arena. Several CEQA lawsuits were filed against the Sacramento Kings Arena and were consolidated into Adriana Gianturco Saltonstall et al. v. City of Sacramento. The overarching claim was that the city prematurely approved the arena project because the EIR process (1) did not study an alternative area that would have involved remodeling an existing arena, (2) was deficient in analyzing traffic congestion on an interstate freeway, and (3) misrepresented the size of crowds inside and around the downtown area. The Sacramento Kings Arena was not certified pursuant to AB 900, but SB 743, which authorized the streamlining of the Arena, required that any CEQA-related judicial review, including appeals, be resolved within 270 days from the certification of the administrative record.
The SOR report notes that neither AB 900 nor SB 743 specified whether the 270-day limitation applies to calendar days or business days. Additionally, it is unclear whether appeals to the Supreme Court are included in the timeframe. When including the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline between certification of the record and the Supreme Court denial for the Sacramento Kings Arena was 243 business days or 352 calendar days.
SB 955 clarifies this ambiguity in the AB 900 process by specifying that the timeframe is in business days and includes any appeals to the Supreme Court.
- Golden State Warriors Arena and two lawsuits. The AB 900 process cannot expedite or insulate a project from non-CEQA-related litigation and cannot ensure that a project will be completed faster.
- Golden State Warriors Arena and two lawsuits. The AB 900 process cannot expedite or insulate a project from non-CEQA-related litigation and cannot ensure that a project will be completed faster.
In Mission Bay Alliance et al. v. Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure, Mission Bay Alliance, which is a coalition of University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) stakeholders, donors, faculty, and physicians, argued that (1) the 18,500-seat arena would congest area streets with traffic, slowing down access to the UCSF Medical Center at Mission Bay, which is located across the street from the proposed arena and (2) the arena is at odds with the life science research and health care facilities that have been built in the neighborhood.
The case was initially filed on January 7, 2016, in Sacramento County Superior Court. After a change in venue to the San Francisco Superior Court, the trial court, on July 18, 2016, ruled in favor of the project sponsor, the Warriors. On November 29, 2016, the Court of Appeal issued its decision on the case. The decision was appealed; and ultimately, in January 2017, the California Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
In the second lawsuit, the plaintiffs sought to invalidate an agreement between UCSF and the Warriors, which included a $10 million Mission Bay Transportation Improvement Fund for controlling traffic flow in the area. Although the CEQA case had concluded as of January 2017, the second, non-CEQA-related case in Alameda was still pending at that time.
The Warriors team has stated that the lawsuits delayed the opening of the arena by one year, to 2019. One lawsuit had special, fast-tracking CEQA-related litigation privileges and the other did not.
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard Mixed-Use Development. Four separate CEQA cases were filed on December 1, 2016, challenging approval of the 8150 Sunset Boulevard project: Los Angeles Conservancy v. City of Los Angeles; Fix the City, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles; JDR Crescent v. City of Los Angeles; and Manners v. City of Los Angeles. The trial court ordered the four cases to coordinate and consolidate their arguments as much as possible, delaying initial hearing of the case. The Los Angeles Conservancy (LAC) petitioned the Superior Court to prevent the destruction of a bank building (the Lytton Building) that it stipulated had historical significance, while the other petitioners presented 24 allegations of CEQA noncompliance. The trial court granted the LAC’s petition in full on July 21, 2017, while denying the claims of the other parties on all other issues. The decision allowed the project to proceed but barred the proposed destruction of the Lytton Building. The subsequent Court of Appeal ruling was issued on March 23, 2018, with a modified opinion and denial of the request for a rehearing finalized on April 19, 2018. The Court of Appeal agreed with the city’s claim that the trial court erred in finding it failed to comply with CEQA and rejected all cross-appeals from the petitioners except for one related to the conversion of a traffic lane. An appeal to the Supreme Court was denied on June 13, 2018.
When excluding the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline between the administrative record certification and the final Court of Appeal’s modified decision was 357 business days or 523 calendar days. When including the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline was 395 business days or 578 calendar days.
- Guaranteed Time Frames. Current law requires the courts to give CEQA-related cases preference over “all other civil actions… so that the action or proceeding shall be quickly heard and determined” (PRC §21167.1). In addition to this existing mandate, the AB 900 process provides that the courts, to the extent feasible, must complete the judicial review process in a given time frame for certain CEQA-related actions or proceedings. As a consequence, such mandates on a court delay access for other, unknown cases such as medical malpractice suits, wrongful death suits, or contract disputes. Calendar preferences and guaranteed time frames create additional demands and burden on our courts that have very limited resources and a never-ending supply of cases to hear.
- Ensuring the “Leadership” in Environmental Leadership Development Project. As originally enacted in 2011, AB 900 required ELDPs to, among other things, be certified as LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) silver or better, achieve a 10 percent greater standard for transportation efficiency for comparable projects, and not result in any net additional emission of greenhouse gases. Over the last nine years, those environmental standards have been strengthened to require LEED Gold certification and increase the transportation efficiency to 15 percent. As society continues to battle environmental impacts such as climate change, the standard of what is considered to be environmental leadership should also progress. Providing an expedited judicial review is a substantial benefit for developers and the requirements should ensure that these projects are exemplary examples of environmental leadership and deserving of the preferential treatment they would receive in the judicial system.
- ELDPs and affordable housing. SB 995 adds a new category of projects eligible for AB 900 certification - affordable housing projects. To qualify, the project must be located on an infill site, be consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or alternative planning strategy, have at least 15% of the project be dedicated to affordable housing, and must result in a minimum investment of $15 million in California. In comparison, current ELDP residential projects are subject to LEED Gold, do not have a minimum affordable housing requirement, and are required to result in $100 million investment in California. By lowering the investment requirement, removing the LEED component, and imposing a minimum affordable housing requirement, SB 995 provides an incentive for the development of affordable housing projects.
This bill does not specify what ratio of housing a project must provide to be considered a “housing project” eligible for AB 900 certification. As such, the bill could potentially allow a project that offers a minimal amount of housing to be certified as long as 15% of the housing is affordable housing.
- Diminishing returns. In the almost 10 years since AB 900’s enactment, 19 ELDPs have been certified. Presumptively, this is due to the high standards a project must meet in order to qualify, such as resulting in a $100 million dollar investment in California and LEED-Gold certification. The proposed category for affordable housing has a considerably lower threshold to meet - $15 million investment and no LEED certification requirement. The intent being to provide incentive for the construction of these projects and to increase housing in California.
Although it is difficult to estimate how many projects could ultimately qualify under this new category, if numerous projects are fast-tracked to the front of judicial calendars, courts may be forced to repeatedly miss the 270 day deadline. In a sense, adding this new category could be a victim of its own success: at some point, the more projects that are eligible to benefit from accelerated judicial review, the smaller the impact of that benefit.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The California Air Resources Control Board estimates ongoing costs of $384,000 (special fund) annually to determine within 60 days whether a project will result in a net increase of greenhouse gas emissions.
- Unknown costs (General Fund) to the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research to review and certify "leadership projects" and, potentially, to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects.
- Potential unknown cost pressure (General Fund) to the state-funded court system to process and hear challenges to the project's environmental review within the timeframes prescribed by the bill.
- Unknown but likely minor costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to adopt rules of the court to guide implementation of the provisions of this bill and to report to the Legislature.
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/18/20)
1HWY1
Associated Builders and Contractors Northern California Chapter
Bay Area Council
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
Central City Association of Los Angeles
City of San Diego
Civil Justice Association of California
Council President Georgette Gómez, City of San Diego
Downtown San Diego Partnership
Habitat for Humanity California
Los Angeles Business Council
Riley Realty, LP
San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Schneider Electric
Supervisor Greg Cox, Chairman, San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Supervisor Nathan Fletcher, 4th District, San Diego County Board of Supervisors
YIMBY Law
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/20)
City of Torrance
Livable California
Southern California Chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors
Sustainable Tamalmonte
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Prepared by: Genevieve M. Wong / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
6/25/20 12:39:00
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 995 (Atkins) - Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
Version: June 2, 2020 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 18, 2020 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would extend the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 until 2025, and would make housing projects that meet certain requirements eligible for certification under the Act.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on June 18, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Air Resources Control Board (CARB) estimates ongoing costs of $384,000 (special fund) annually to determine within 60 days whether a project will result in a net increase of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
- Unknown costs (General Fund) to the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research to review and certify "leadership projects" and, potentially, to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects.
- Potential unknown cost pressure (General Fund) to the state-funded court system to process and hear challenges to the project's environmental review within the timeframes prescribed by the bill. (See staff comments.)
- Unknown but likely minor costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to adopt rules of the court to guide implementation of the provisions of this bill and to report to the Legislature.
Author Amendments:
The author’s amendments would make technical clarifications and strengthen labor requirements for new construction.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 995 (Atkins) - Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
Version: June 2, 2020 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 9, 2020 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would extend the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 until 2025, and would make housing projects that meet certain requirements eligible for certification under the Act.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Air Resources Control Board (CARB) estimates ongoing costs of $384,000 (special fund) annually to determine within 60 days whether a project will result in a net increase of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
- Unknown costs (General Fund) to the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research to review and certify "leadership projects" and, potentially, to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects.
- Potential unknown cost pressure (General Fund) to the state-funded court system to process and hear challenges to the project's environmental review within the timeframes prescribed by the bill. (See staff comments.)
- Unknown but likely minor costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to adopt rules of the court to guide implementation of the provisions of this bill and to report to the Legislature.
Background:
The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900). AB 900 established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for the review of the environmental review documents and public agency approvals granted for designated residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects, known as Environmental Leadership Development Projects (ELDP). To qualify as an ELDP, the project must meet specified objective environmental standards. The Legislature has also applied similar expedited frameworks for specific sports stadiums that meet certain objective environmental standards.
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) proceedings. Current law requires the courts to give CEQA-related cases preference over “all other civil actions… so that the action or proceeding shall be quickly heard and determined” (PRC §21167.1). In addition to this existing mandate, the AB 900 process provides that the courts, to the extent feasible, must complete the judicial review process in a given timeframe for certain CEQA-related actions or proceedings. As a consequence, such mandates on a court delay access for other, unknown cases such as medical malpractice suits, wrongful death suits, or contract disputes, as well as potentially exacerbating a court’s backlog on civil documents such as filing a new civil complaint, processing answers and cross complaints, or processing a demurrer or summary judgement. Calendar preferences and guaranteed time frames create additional demands and burden on our courts that have very limited resources and a never-ending supply of cases to hear.
AB 900 lawsuits. Of the projects that have been subject to AB 900, or similar expedited judicial review, four projects have been challenged under CEQA. Expedited judicial review does not always guarantee a 270 day timeframe and cases can take longer to resolve due to, among other reasons, (1) ambiguity if the 270 days applies to business days or calendar days and if it includes appeals to the Supreme Court, (2) non-CEQA related actions which are not subject to the 270 day timeframe that are filed in addition to CEQA actions, or (3) consolidation of many, and sometimes complicated, actions.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
- Extend the Governor’s authority to certify a leadership project to January 1, 2024, and repeal AB 900 January 1, 2025.
- Make housing projects that meet certain requirements eligible for certification, including:
- The project is located on an infill site.
- For a project located within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy or alternative planning strategy is in effect, the project is consistent with the general use designation, density, building intensity, and applicable policies specified in either a sustainable communities strategies or an alternative planning strategy, as specified.
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $15 million in California upon completion.
- At least 15 percent of the housing project is affordable housing.
Related Legislation:
AB 2991 (Santiago) extends the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act for five years, and makes various changes to the requirements of the Act. AB 2991 is in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 25 (Caballero, 2019) provides qualified projects, which includes housing projects that will obtain LEED Gold certification and with a minimum 40% affordable housing, with expedited judicial review. SB 25 is in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 621 (Glazer, 2019) provides affordable housing projects that meet certain requirements, including LEED Gold certification and a minimum 30% of the housing units be affordable housing, with expedited judicial review. SB 621 is in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
Staff Comments:
CARB costs. CARB notes that it did not receive any additional resources to complete the additional analyses required under AB 900. It is resource intensive for CARB to determine within 60 days whether a project will result in a net increase of greenhouse gas emissions, as application materials and calculation methodologies often exceed thousands of pages. To cover this workload, CARB has had to divert staff from other core program areas, which is no longer sustainable.
In 2019, CARB worked on nine projects under the AB 900 program and made GHG emissions determinations for eight of the nine projects, six of which were undergoing simultaneous review. Based on this bill’s authorization allowing residential projects of only $15 million or more to qualify and the recent trend of increasing project applications of greater complexity, CARB anticipates that its workload could continue to increase if this bill is enacted.
Court costs. This bill would result in potential cost pressure of an unknown amount to the state-funded court system to process and hear challenges to a project's environmental review within the timeframes prescribed by the bill. It is possible that, absent this bill, the state would face similar costs resulting from challenges to a project that would occur over a period longer than timeframes prescribed by this bill. However, the acceleration of some cases due to this bill could result in the need for extra personnel and resources in order for the courts to hear them within the required period.
The Governor’s May Revision of the state budget includes significant proposed cuts to trail court operations that increase the likelihood that this bill could result in cost pressure. Specifically, the May Revision withdraws a January budget proposal of $107.6 million (General Fund) ongoing to support trial court operations, and instead proposes a reduction of $206.2 million (General Fund) ongoing in order to balance the state budget.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 995
Author: | Atkins | ||
Version: | 5/19/2020 | Hearing Date: | 5/29/2020 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Genevieve M. Wong | ||
SUBJECT: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: housing projects
DIGEST: Extends for four years the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 until 2025; and makes housing projects that meet certain requirements, including specified affordable housing requirements, eligible for certification under the Act.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA):
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code §21000 et seq.). If there is substantial evidence, in light of the whole record before a lead agency, that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a draft EIR. (CEQA Guidelines §15064(a)(1), (f)(1)).
- Allows lead agencies to prepare master environmental impact reports (master EIRs) for specified projects that include smaller, individual subsequent projects. Proscribes information included in a master EIR, including a description of anticipated projects that would be within the scope of the master EIR and a description of potential impacts of the anticipated subsequent projects (PRC §21157).
- Sets requirements relating to the preparation, review, comment, approval and certification of environmental documents, as well as procedures relating to an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul various actions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA (PRC §§21165 et seq.) .
- Establishes the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900, Buchanan, Gordon, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011), which establishes CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures for an "environmental leadership" project. Among the provisions of AB 900 (PRC §21178 et seq.):
- Establishes procedures for expedited judicial review (i.e. requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits within 270 days) for “environmental leadership” projects certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions.
- Defines “environmental leadership” project as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council, that is located on an infill site, and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Requires a project that is within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy (SCS) or alternative planning strategy (APS) is in effect, to be consistent with specified policies in either the SCS or APS, which, if implemented, would achieve greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction targets.
- Requires a project that is within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy (SCS) or alternative planning strategy (APS) is in effect, to be consistent with specified policies in either the SCS or APS, which, if implemented, would achieve greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction targets.
- A clean renewable energy project that generates electricity exclusively through wind or solar, but not including waste incineration or conversion.
- A clean energy manufacturing project that manufactures products, equipment, or components used for renewable energy generation, energy efficiency, or for the production of clean alternative fuel vehicles.
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council, that is located on an infill site, and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Allows a person proposing to construct a leadership project to apply to the Governor for certification that the leadership project is eligible for streamlining.
- Authorizes the Governor to certify a leadership project if the Governor finds the project meets all of the following conditions:
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- The project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages, provides construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment.
- The project does not result in any net additional GHG emissions, including emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the Air Resources Board pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006.
- The project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required under CEQA shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the administrative record for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to CEQA, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project.
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures that require resolution within 270 days, including any appeals, of a lawsuit challenging the certification of the EIR or any project approvals for a certified environmental leadership project.
- Sets requirements for preparation and certification of the administrative record for a leadership project certified by the Governor.
- Required the Judicial Council to report to the Legislature on or before January 1, 2017, on the effects of AB 900 on the administration of justice.
- Establishes procedures for expedited judicial review (i.e. requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits within 270 days) for “environmental leadership” projects certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions.
This bill:
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a master EIR for a general plan, plan amendment, plan element, or specific plan for housing projects where the state has provided funding for the preparation of the master EIR.
- Extends the Governor’s authority to certify a leadership project to January 1, 2024, and repeals AB 900 January 1, 2025.
- Makes housing projects that meet certain requirements eligible for certification, including:
- The project is located on an infill site.
- For a project located within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy or alternative planning strategy is in effect, the project is consistent with the general use designation, density, building intensity, and applicable policies specified in either a sustainable communities strategies or an alternative planning strategy, as specified.
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $15 million in California upon completion.
- At least 15 percent of the housing project is affordable housing.
Background
- California’s housing shortage. California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis. California is home to 21 of the 30 most expensive rental housing markets in the country, which has had a disproportionate impact on the middle class and the working poor. Housing units affordable to low-income earners, if available, are often in serious states of disrepair. The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates that approximately 2.7 million lower-income households are rent-burdened (meaning they spend at least 30% of their income on rent), 1.7 million of which are severely rent-burdened (spending at least 50% of their income on rent). Not a single county in the state has an adequate supply of affordable homes. According to a 2015 study by the California Housing Partnership Corporation, California has a shortfall of 1.5 million affordable homes and 13 of the 14 least affordable metropolitan areas in the country.
A major factor in this crisis is the state’s housing shortage. From 1954-1989, California constructed an average of more than 200,000 new homes annually, with multifamily housing accounting for the largest share of housing production. Since then, however, construction has dropped significantly. HCD estimates that approximately 1.8 million new housing units – 180,000 new homes per year, are needed to meet the state’s projected population and housing growth by 2025.
- Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011. Existing law provides a framework for expediting CEQA review of major projects. The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (hereafter AB 900 or Act), established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for the review of the environmental review documents and public agency approvals granted for designated residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects, known as Environmental Leadership Development Projects (ELDP). To qualify as an ELDP, the project must meet specified objective environmental standards. The Legislature has also applied similar expedited frameworks for specific sports stadiums that meet certain objective environmental standards.
- ELDP Projects to Date. According to the Office of Planning and Research, the following projects have had AB 900 applications submitted:
- McCoy Solar Energy Project (January 12, 2012);
- Apple Campus 2 (April 19, 2012);
- Soitec Solar Energy Project (January 7, 2013);
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard (January 31, 2014);
- Event Center and Mixed-Use Development at Mission Bay Blocks (The Golden State Warriors Arena) (February 17, 2014);
- Qualcomm Stadium Reconstruction Project (August 25, 2015);
- Crossroads Hollywood (August 29, 2016);
- 6220 West Yucca Project (April 17, 2017);
- 1045 Olive Street Project (December 19, 2017);
- Hollywood Center Project (May 2, 2018);
- Potrero Power Station Mixed-use Project (July 18, 2018);
- 10 Van Ness Avenue Mixed-Use Project (August 8, 2018);
- 3333 California Street Project (August 24, 2018);
- Inglewood Basketball and Entertainment Center (AB 987) (January 3, 2019);
- Hollywood & Wilcox Mixed-Use Project (February 5, 2019);
- Oakland Sports and Mixed-Use Project at Howard Terminal (March 20, 2019 – not yet certified);
- Balboa Reserve (June 25, 2019);
- Downtown West Mixed Use Plan (September 3, 2019);
- California Northstate University Medical Center Project (September 24, 2019).
This does not include specified projects to which the Legislature has applied AB 900-like procedures. These projects are:
- SB 292 (Padilla, Chapter 353, Statutes of 2011) which proposed a downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center that would achieve specified traffic and air quality mitigations. This project has not proceeded.
- SB 743 (Steinberg, Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013) established special CEQA procedures modeled after SB 292 for the Sacramento Kings arena project and included specified traffic and air quality mitigations.
- AB 734 (Bonta, Chapter 959, Statutes of 2018) established special CEQA procedures modeled after AB 900 for the Oakland Sports and Mixed-Use Project. Unlike AB 900, AB 734 required that 50% of the GHG emissions reductions necessary to achieve the zero-net additional GHG emissions requirement be from on-site and local reduction measures, limited the type of GHG offset credits that can be purchased to achieve the other 50% of the necessary GHG emissions reductions, and required a transportation demand management plan that achieves a 20% reduction in vehicle trips.
- AB 987 (Kamlager-Dove, Chapter 961, Statutes of 2018) was similar to AB 734 but applied to a proposed basketball arena for the Los Angeles Clippers in Inglewood. AB 987 required a transportation demand management plan that achieves 15% reduction in vehicle trips by 2030 and additional reductions in local criteria pollutants.
- Review of ELDPs. In April 2019, the Senate Office of Research (SOR) released a report describing projects that have qualified for expedited CEQA judicial review pursuant to AB 900 and statutes similar to AB 900. In addition to analyzing the estimated benefits derived from ELDPs, the report also examined the legal challenges faced by three projects: the Sacramento Kings Arena, the Golden State Warriors arena, and the 8150 Sunset Boulevard mixed-use development project; each discussed in more detail below. The report also included some recommendations to the Legislature that would provide clarity to the act, increase reporting requirements, and strengthen environmental attributes of the ELDPs.
- ELDPs and housing. According to the SOR report, 10 of the 19 ELDPs have included a housing component. As of the date of the SOR report, none of the projects have been completed. Below is a summary of housing projects and their proposed housing units.
Project Name | Description | Proposed Housing Units |
8150 Sunset Boulevard | Residential housing, retail, and restaurant redevelopment on a 2.56-acre site | 249 residential units, 28 of which will be affordable housing (approx. 11%) |
Crossroads Hollywood | Residential housing units and hotel rooms | 950 residential |
6220 West Yucca | Residential housing and hotel redevelopment on a 1.16-acre site | 210 residential |
Potrero Power Station | Covert a closed power station to housing, commercial, community facilities, and entertainment/assembly uses on a 29-acre lot | 2,400 to 3,000 residential |
Hollywood Center | Residential housing and usable open space development on a 4.46-acre site | 872 residential, 133 of which will be affordable senior housing (approx. 15%) |
1045 Olive Street | Residential housing and commercial redevelopment on a 0.96-acre site | 974 residential |
10 South Van Ness Avenue | Residential housing, public space, and business redevelopment on a 1.17-acre site | 980 residential |
Hollywood & Wilcox | Develop a mixed-use project composed of multifamily residential dwelling units and retail, office, and restaurant uses. | 260 multifamily residential, up to 10% of which would be workforce housing |
3333 California Street | Create new residential housing and retail, office, and childcare uses | 558 residential, some of which would be affordable housing |
Oakland Athletics Stadium (AB 734) | Baseball stadium, residential housing, hotel, entertainment, office, retail, and open space redevelopment on a 55-acre site | 3,000 residential |
Comments
- AB 900 lawsuits. Of the projects that have been subject to AB 900, or similar expedited judicial review, four projects have been challenged under CEQA. Expedited judicial review does not always guarantee a 270 day timeframe and cases can take longer to resolve due to, among other reasons, (1) ambiguity if the 270 days applies to business days or calendar days and if it includes appeals to the Supreme Court, (2) non-CEQA related actions which are not subject to the 270 day timeframe that are filed in addition to CEQA actions, or (3) consolidation of many, and sometimes complicated, actions.
- Sacramento Kings Arena. Several CEQA lawsuits were filed against the Sacramento Kings Arena and were consolidated into Adriana Gianturco Saltonstall et al. v. City of Sacramento. The overarching claim was that the city prematurely approved the arena project because the EIR process (1) did not study an alternative area that would have involved remodeling an existing arena, (2) was deficient in analyzing traffic congestion on an interstate freeway, and (3) misrepresented the size of crowds inside and around the downtown area. The Sacramento Kings Arena was not certified pursuant to AB 900, but SB 743, which authorized the streamlining of the Arena, required that any CEQA-related judicial review, including appeals, be resolved within 270 days from the certification of the administrative record.
- Sacramento Kings Arena. Several CEQA lawsuits were filed against the Sacramento Kings Arena and were consolidated into Adriana Gianturco Saltonstall et al. v. City of Sacramento. The overarching claim was that the city prematurely approved the arena project because the EIR process (1) did not study an alternative area that would have involved remodeling an existing arena, (2) was deficient in analyzing traffic congestion on an interstate freeway, and (3) misrepresented the size of crowds inside and around the downtown area. The Sacramento Kings Arena was not certified pursuant to AB 900, but SB 743, which authorized the streamlining of the Arena, required that any CEQA-related judicial review, including appeals, be resolved within 270 days from the certification of the administrative record.
The City of Sacramento certified the administrative record on June 2, 2014. On October 17, 2014, the trial court in Sacramento issued a decision denying all of the CEQA challenges. The Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court’s decision on February 18, 2015, and the petition for review by the California Supreme Court was denied May 20, 2015.
The SOR report notes that neither AB 900 nor SB 743 specified whether the 270 day limitation applies to calendar days or business days. Additionally, it is unclear whether appeals to the Supreme Court are included in timeframe. When including the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline between certification of the record and the Supreme Court denial for the Sacramento Kings Arena was 243 business days or 352 calendar days.
- Golden State Warriors Arena and two lawsuits. The AB 900 process cannot expedite or insulate a project from non-CEQA-related litigation and cannot ensure that a project will be completed faster.
- Golden State Warriors Arena and two lawsuits. The AB 900 process cannot expedite or insulate a project from non-CEQA-related litigation and cannot ensure that a project will be completed faster.
In Mission Bay Alliance et al. v. Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure, Mission Bay Alliance, which is a coalition of University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) stakeholders, donors, faculty, and physicians, argued that (1) the 18,500-seat arena would congest area streets with traffic, slowing down access to the UCSF Medical Center at Mission Bay, which is located across the street from the proposed arena and (2) the arena is at odds with the life science research and health care facilities that have been built in the neighborhood.
The case was initially filed on January 7, 2016, in Sacramento County Superior Court. The Golden State Warriors moved for a change of venue which was granted. The CEQA case was received and filed in the San Francisco County Superior Court and on July 18, 2016, a trial court ruled in favor of the project sponsor, the Warriors. On November 29, 2016, the Court of Appeal issued its decision on the case, 225 business days or 327 calendar days after the petition was initially filed. The decision was appealed; and ultimately, in January 2017, the California Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
In the second lawsuit, the plaintiffs sought to invalidate an agreement between UCSF and the Warriors, which included a $10 million Mission Bay Transportation Improvement Fund for controlling traffic flow in the area. Although the CEQA case had concluded as of January, 2017, the second, non-CEQA-related case in Alameda was still pending at that time.
The Warriors team has stated that the lawsuits delayed the opening of the arena by one year, to 2019. One lawsuit had special, fast-tracking CEQA-related litigation privileges and the other did not. Although AB 900 expedited the litigation process for the CEQA case, the second lawsuit demonstrates that CEQA is not the only body of law subject to civil litigation and that AB 900 does not guarantee a project from being litigation-free after 270 days.
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard Mixed-Use Development. Four separate CEQA cases were filed on December 1, 2016, challenging approval of the 8150 Sunset Boulevard project: Los Angeles Conservancy v. City of Los Angeles; Fix the City, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles; JDR Crescent v. City of Los Angeles; and Manners v. City of Los Angeles. The trial court ordered the four cases to coordinate and consolidate their arguments as much as possible, delaying initial hearing of the case. The Los Angeles Conservancy (LAC) petitioned the Superior Court to prevent the destruction of a bank building (the Lytton Building) that it stipulated had historical significance, while the other petitioners presented 24 allegations of CEQA noncompliance. The trial court granted the LAC’s petition in full on July 21, 2017, while denying the claims of the other parties on all other issues. The decision allowed the project to proceed but barred the proposed destruction of the Lytton Building. The subsequent Court of Appeal ruling was issued on March 23, 2018, with a modified opinion and denial of the request for a rehearing finalized on April 19, 2018. The Court of Appeal agreed with the city’s claim that the trial court erred in finding it failed to comply with CEQA and rejected all cross-appeals from the petitioners except for one related to the conversion of a traffic lane. An appeal to the Supreme Court was denied on June 13, 2018.
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard Mixed-Use Development. Four separate CEQA cases were filed on December 1, 2016, challenging approval of the 8150 Sunset Boulevard project: Los Angeles Conservancy v. City of Los Angeles; Fix the City, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles; JDR Crescent v. City of Los Angeles; and Manners v. City of Los Angeles. The trial court ordered the four cases to coordinate and consolidate their arguments as much as possible, delaying initial hearing of the case. The Los Angeles Conservancy (LAC) petitioned the Superior Court to prevent the destruction of a bank building (the Lytton Building) that it stipulated had historical significance, while the other petitioners presented 24 allegations of CEQA noncompliance. The trial court granted the LAC’s petition in full on July 21, 2017, while denying the claims of the other parties on all other issues. The decision allowed the project to proceed but barred the proposed destruction of the Lytton Building. The subsequent Court of Appeal ruling was issued on March 23, 2018, with a modified opinion and denial of the request for a rehearing finalized on April 19, 2018. The Court of Appeal agreed with the city’s claim that the trial court erred in finding it failed to comply with CEQA and rejected all cross-appeals from the petitioners except for one related to the conversion of a traffic lane. An appeal to the Supreme Court was denied on June 13, 2018.
Because the project was certified as an AB 900 project , it had a required judicial review timeline, including any appeals, of 270 days from certification of the administrative record. When excluding the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline between the administrative record certification and the final Court of Appeal’s modified decision was 357 business days or 523 calendar days. When including the appeal to the Supreme Court, the timeline was 395 business days or 578 calendar days.
- Los Angeles Clippers Arena. In January 2020, a petition was filed challenging the certification of a proposed Los Angeles Clippers basketball arena in Inglewood (Saulo Eber Chan; MSG Forum, LLC v. Gavin C. Newsom; Joint Legislative Budget Committee). Similar to the Sacramento Kings Arena, AB 987 required that any CEQA-related judicial review of the Los Angeles Clippers Arena, including appeals, be resolved within 270 days from certification of the administrative record. In its complaint, the petitioners allege that AB 987 violates the California Constitution because (1) it is invalid “special legislation,” (2) it grants the Legislature power reserved for the executive and judicial branches, and (3) it curtails the judiciary’s constitutional jurisdiction to review executive action in favor of review by a single legislative committee, violating the Constitution’s separation of powers. This case is still pending.
- Los Angeles Clippers Arena. In January 2020, a petition was filed challenging the certification of a proposed Los Angeles Clippers basketball arena in Inglewood (Saulo Eber Chan; MSG Forum, LLC v. Gavin C. Newsom; Joint Legislative Budget Committee). Similar to the Sacramento Kings Arena, AB 987 required that any CEQA-related judicial review of the Los Angeles Clippers Arena, including appeals, be resolved within 270 days from certification of the administrative record. In its complaint, the petitioners allege that AB 987 violates the California Constitution because (1) it is invalid “special legislation,” (2) it grants the Legislature power reserved for the executive and judicial branches, and (3) it curtails the judiciary’s constitutional jurisdiction to review executive action in favor of review by a single legislative committee, violating the Constitution’s separation of powers. This case is still pending.
- Guaranteed Time Frames. Current law requires the courts to give CEQA-related cases preference over “all other civil actions… so that the action or proceeding shall be quickly heard and determined” (PRC §21167.1). In addition to this existing mandate, the AB 900 process provides that the courts, to the extent feasible, must complete the judicial review process in a given time frame for certain CEQA-related actions or proceedings. As a consequence, such mandates on a court delay access for other, unknown cases such as medical malpractice suits, wrongful death suits, or contract disputes, as well as potentially exacerbating a court’s backlog on civil documents such as filing a new civil complaint, processing answers and cross complaints, or processing a demurrer or summary judgement. Calendar preferences and guaranteed time frames create additional demands and burden on our courts that have very limited resources and a never-ending supply of cases to hear.
- Ensuring the “Leadership” in Environmental Leadership Development Project. As originally enacted in 2011, AB 900 required ELDPs to, among other things, be certified as LEED silver or better, achieve a 10 percent greater standard for transportation efficiency for comparable projects, and not result in any net additional emission of greenhouse gases. Over the last nine years, those environmental standards have been strengthened to require LEED Gold certification and increase the transportation efficiency to 15 percent. As society continues to battle environmental impacts such as climate change, the standard of what is considered to be environmental leadership should also progress. Providing an expedited judicial review is a substantial benefit for developers and the environmental standards required should ensure that these projects are exemplary examples of environmental leadership and deserving of the preferential treatment they would receive in the judicial system.
The Committee may wish to amend the bill to modernize and strengthen the environmental protections in the following ways:
- Require LEED Platinum instead of LEED Gold.
- Require Tier 1 energy efficiency, as described in California Green Building Standards Code.
- Replace the 15% transportation efficiency requirement with a requirement that the project achieves 20% reduction in vehicle miles traveled per capita compared to existing development, as determined by the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research.
- ELDPs and affordable housing. SB 995 adds a new category of projects that could qualify for AB 900 certification - affordable housing projects. To qualify, the project must, among other things, be located on an infill site, be consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or alternative planning strategy, have at least 15% of the project be dedicated to affordable housing, and must result in a minimum investment of $15 million in California. In comparison, ELDP residential projects currently are subject to LEED Gold, do not have a minimum affordable housing requirement, and are required to result in $100 million investment in California. By lowering the investment requirement, removing the LEED component, and imposing a minimum affordable housing requirement, SB 995 provides an incentive for the development of affordable housing projects.
As the bill proceeds, the author may want to consider the following:
- Specifying what percentage of a project shall be dedicated to housing for a project be to be considered a “housing project” and eligible for AB 900 certification. Current CEQA exemptions for residential housing projects vary for the minimum amount of housing a project can have – the affordable housing exemption (§21159.23) prohibits retail services from exceeding 15% of the total floor area of a project; whereas the exemption for infill projects prohibits retail uses from exceeding 25%. Under the Government Code, projects that are at least two-thirds residential are considered residential projects.
- Requiring the project applicant to report the actual number of housing units created once the project is completed, as recommended by the SOR report. This will help the Legislature better understand the benefits provided by ELDPs.
- Diminishing returns. In the almost 10 years since the enactment of AB 900, 19 ELDPs have been certified. Presumptively, this is because the high standards a project must meet in order to qualify, such as resulting in a $100 million dollar investment in California and LEED-Gold certification. The new proposed category for affordable housing has a considerably lower threshold to meet - $15 million investment and no LEED certification requirement. The intent of adding these projects as a new category eligible for certification is to provide incentive for the construction of these projects and to increase housing in California.
Although it is difficult to estimate how many projects could ultimately qualify under this new category, if numerous projects are fast-tracked to the front of judicial calendars, courts may be forced to repeatedly miss the 270 day deadline. In a sense, adding this new category could be a victim of its own success: at some point, the more projects that are eligible to benefit from accelerated judicial review, the smaller the impact of that benefit.
- Impact on the administration of justice. AB 900 required Judicial Council, by January 1, 2017, to submit a report to the Legislature on the impact of AB 900 on the administration of justice. At the time of the report, only eight projects had been certified, one of which had resulted in a court case subject to the timeframes of AB 900 – the Golden State Warriors Arena (described above). In its report, Judicial Council noted that “because there has been only one case subject to the requirements of [AB 900], at [that] time Judicial Council [was] unable to draw any general conclusions about the impact of [AB 900] on the administration of justice.” Since the report’s publication, 10 additional projects have been certified or made subject to AB 900-like timeframes and one project is pending certification.
Because AB 900 and similar timeframes continue to be a concern for its impact on the administration of justice, the committee may wish to amend the bill to require Judicial Council to submit another report, by January 1, 2024, on that issue, which would give the Legislature time to review the report before the repeal of AB 900 in 2025.
- Let’s be clear. The SOR report brought to light some ambiguities in the AB 900 process – (1) whether the 270 day timeframe was to be counted in calendar days or business days and (2) whether the 270 day timeframe included appeals to the Supreme Court.
The committee may wish to amend the bill to clarify that the 270 timeframe is business days and that timeframe also includes any appeals to the Supreme Court.
- Adding co-authors. The author would like to add the following Senators as joint authors, principal co-authors, and co-authors, as specified:
- Joint authors: Senators Caballero and Rubio
- Principal co-authors: Senators L. Gonzalez, Hill, and McGuire
- Co-author: Senator Roth
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2991 (Santiago) extends the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act for five years, and makes various changes to the requirements of the Act. AB 2991 is in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 25 (Caballero, 2019) provides qualified projects, which includes housing projects that will obtain LEED Gold certification and with a minimum 40% affordable housing, with expedited judicial review. SB 25 is in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 621 (Glazer, 2019) provides affordable housing projects that meet certain requirements, including LEED Gold certification and a minimum 30% of the housing units be affordable housing, with expedited judicial review. SB 621 is in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
See above, Background
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
1hwy1
Bay Area Council
California Association of Realtors
City of San Diego
Council President Georgette Gómez, City of San Diego
Downtown San Diego Partnership
Los Angeles Business Council
Riley Realty, LP
San Diego Board of Supervisors, 4th District, Nathan Fletcher
San Diego County Board of Supervisors, Greg Cox, Chairman
San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR)
Schneider Electric
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):