AB 2412: Healing arts: California Body Contouring Council: practitioners.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-08
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-19: In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Massage Therapy Act, regulates massage practitioners and therapists who administer massage, defined as the scientific manipulation of the soft tissues, for compensation. Existing law creates the California Massage Therapy Council. Existing law specifies that it is an unfair business practice for a person to hold oneself out or to use the title of certified massage therapist or certified massage practitioner unless that person currently holds an active and valid certificate issued by the council pursuant to these provisions.
This bill, the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act, would define body contouring as noninvasive, nonmedical treatment intended to shape or contour the fatty areas of the body, as specified. The bill would create the California Body Contouring Council (council) for the purpose of regulating the practice of body contouring. The bill would require the council to issue certificates of completion to individuals who complete a certain educational course, permits to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, permits to maintain a specified physical location, and mobile permits, as prescribed. The bill would require the council to be governed by a board of directors comprised of 4 individuals. The bill would establish an advisory board comprised of 14 members, as specified, and would make the advisory board responsible for advising the board of directors.
This bill would require the council to develop and make available to students on an internet website 5 online, 40-hour educational modules composing a 5-week, 200-hour, physician-approved course in the practice of body contouring. The bill would require a student who successfully completes the course of instruction to receive a certificate of completion issued by the council for the purpose of qualifying that person for a permit to practice body contouring. To become a practitioner of body contouring, the bill would require an applicant to submit an application of the council and provide the council with satisfactory evidence that they have met prescribed requirements, including payment of certain fees that cover the councils reasonable regulatory cots of administering the program.
This bill would require permits to practice body contouring, premises permits, and mobile permits to be renewed annually. The bill would establish fees for specified permits, including an initial fee for a permit to practice body contouring that does not exceed $495, and would require those fees to cover the councils reasonable regulatory costs of administering the program. The bill would require practitioners to comply with specified requirements, including, submitting to inspection and investigation by the council, adhering to the ethical standards prescribed by the council, and not exceeding the legal scope of their permit, among other things. The bill would make it unlawful for any person to falsely advertise that they or any other individual is a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner and deem engaging in that or other prohibited behavior unfair competition pursuant to other specified provisions of law.
Existing law, the Massage Therapy Act, regulates massage practitioners and therapists who administer massage, defined as the scientific manipulation of the soft tissues, for compensation. Existing law creates the California Massage Therapy Council. Existing law specifies that it is an unfair business practice for a person to hold oneself out or to use the title of certified massage therapist or certified massage practitioner unless that person currently holds an active and valid certificate issued by the council pursuant to these provisions.
This bill, the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act, would define body contouring as noninvasive, nonmedical treatment intended to shape or contour the fatty areas of the body, as specified. The bill would create the California Body Contouring Council (council) for the purpose of regulating the practice of body contouring. The bill would require the council to issue certificates of completion to individuals who complete a certain educational course, permits to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, permits to maintain a specified physical location, and mobile permits, as prescribed. The bill would require the council to be governed by a board of directors comprised of 4 individuals. The bill would establish an advisory board comprised of 14 members, as specified, and would make the advisory board responsible for advising the board of directors.
This bill would require the council to develop and make available to students on an internet website 5 online, 40-hour educational modules composing a 5-week, 200-hour, physician-approved course in the practice of body contouring. The bill would require a student who successfully completes the course of instruction to receive a certificate of completion issued by the council for the purpose of qualifying that person for a permit to practice body contouring. To become a practitioner of body contouring, the bill would require an applicant to submit an application of the council and provide the council with satisfactory evidence that they have met prescribed requirements, including payment of certain fees that cover the councils reasonable regulatory cots of administering the program.
This bill would require permits to practice body contouring, premises permits, and mobile permits to be renewed annually. The bill would establish fees for specified permits, including an initial fee for a permit to practice body contouring that does not exceed $495, and would require those fees to cover the councils reasonable regulatory costs of administering the program. The bill would require practitioners to comply with specified requirements, including, submitting to inspection and investigation by the council, adhering to the ethical standards prescribed by the council, and not exceeding the legal scope of their permit, among other things. The bill would make it unlawful for any person to falsely advertise that they or any other individual is a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner and deem engaging in that or other prohibited behavior unfair competition pursuant to other specified provisions of law.
This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act.
4660.1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)More than 1,000,000 people from all segments of society perform body contouring treatments to willing consumers in California and throughout the world.
(2)Currently, there is no official training, vetting, scope of practice, agency, establishment, registry, or system, and no accountability, for a person who performs body contouring treatment. Therefore, persons engaging in this type of service are using techniques that they have learned via demonstrations on the internet, YouTube, Instagram, or Facebook, or from other practitioners.
(3)Aspiring body contourists seek training from persons who claim to be experts in the field. This training can range in price from $1,500 to $2,500, or more for online or in-person instruction. Many Californians are paying for this type of training because no official training exists. Because there is no official training or defined scope of practice, persons who wish to perform these procedures are confused, and often misinformed, about what equipment or applications they can safely and effectively use. In many instances, according the Medical Board of California, contourists use medical-grade equipment and practice medicine without a license. Without clear, lawfully approved training, a place to make official inquiries, ongoing education, and a process for receipt and investigation of consumer complaints, these individuals are operating without a scope of practice or accountability through no fault of their own.
(b)By offering a standard, physician-approved curriculum, it is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council will eliminate price gouging affecting persons seeking to learn how to perform body contouring and ensure that those persons are sufficiently trained. It is the intent of the Legislature that training curriculum be developed, approved, and overseen by an advisory board.
(c)It is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council embrace this new, growing industry by providing consumer safety and specialized, all-inclusive training to ensure both clients and body contourists are working in harmony for an in-demand and marketable vocation.
(d)Job creation faces many barriers. It is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council recognize this dilemma and provide an innovative model of education, implementation, training, a clear scope of practice, and accountability.
4660.3.As used in this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Body contouring means noninvasive, nonmedical treatment intended to shape or contour the fatty areas of the body using wooden or metal tools, enzyme-based scrubs or wraps, sauna blankets, or light-emitting diodes.
(b)California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, or practitioner means a person who is permitted to operate as a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner pursuant to this chapter and who has undergone education, training, certification, and permitting as specified in this chapter.
(c)Council means the California Body Contouring Council.
4660.5.(a)The use of needles, injections, lasers, radio frequency, cavitation, electrical muscle stimulation, or any medical machine or medical instrument by a practitioner is explicitly prohibited by this chapter unless otherwise permitted pursuant to another provision of law.
(b)This chapter does not authorize a practitioner to diagnose illness or to assist or guarantee weight loss through the practice of body contouring.
4660.7.(a)The California Body Contouring Council is hereby established and shall carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in this chapter.
(b)Protection of the public shall be the highest priority of the council in exercising its certification and disciplinary authority, and any of its other functions. If the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
(c)The council may take any reasonable action necessary to carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in this chapter, including, but not limited to, hiring staff, contracting, and developing policies, procedures, rules, and bylaws to implement this chapter.
(d)The council may require background checks for all employees, contractors, volunteers, and board members as a condition of their employment, formation of a contractual relationship, or participation in council activities.
(e)The council shall issue all of the following:
(1)Certificates of completion to individuals who have successfully completed the educational course in the practice of body contouring described in Section 4660.11.
(2)Numbered permits to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner and to perform services within the designated legal scope of practice to individuals who have satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.13.
(3)Numbered premises permits to maintain a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners who perform services within the designated scope of legal practice. The owner and operator of the premises shall be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner that has satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.17.
(4)Numbered mobile permits to maintain a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners who perform services within the designated scope of legal practice. The owner and operator of the mobile unit shall be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner that has satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.19.
(f)The council may determine whether the information provided to it in connection with certification and permitting is true and correct and meets the requirements of this chapter. If the council has any reason to question whether the information provided by an applicant is true and correct, or meets the requirements of this chapter, the council may make any investigation it deems necessary in order to establish that the information received is accurate and satisfies the criteria established pursuant to this chapter. An applicant shall have the burden to prove that they are entitled to the desired certification or permit.
(g)The meetings of the council shall be subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code). The board may adopt additional policies and procedures that provide greater transparency to persons who hold certifications or permits, and members of the public, that is required by the act.
4660.9.(a)The council shall be governed by a board of directors, who shall be compensated, as determined by the council, and shall be reimbursed for necessary and reasonable expenses incurred in connection with performing board duties. The board of directors shall be comprised of all of the following:
(1)A president.
(2)A vice president.
(3)A California licensed physician, appointed by the Medical Board of California, physician who shall also perform the following functions by serving as all of the following:
(A)The councils Medical Director.
(B)A professional liaison to the Medical Board of California. California medical community.
(C)The councils curriculum adviser.
(4)A California licensed cosmetologist.
(b)The council shall be advised by an advisory board comprised of 14 members who shall represent Californias diverse communities and cultures and shall be selected for their expertise in the fields of medicine, cosmetology, personal services, personal services equipment, curriculum creation, training and education, California state law, and the practice of body contouring. Members of the advisory board of directors shall be selected, as follows:
(1)Each of the following entities shall select one member:
(A)The Department of Consumer Affairs.
(B)The Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
(C)The Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
(2)Eleven advisory board members shall be selected by the council.
(c)Members of the advisory board shall serve a term of three years.
4660.11.(a)The council shall develop and make available to students on its internet website five online, 40-hour educational modules composing a five-week, 200-hour, physician-approved course in the practice of body contouring. The course shall use narratives, videos, and multiple-choice quizzes, and be offered in multiple languages as determined by the council.
(b)A student shall have five weeks to complete all five educational modules, successfully complete five corresponding module tests, and successfully complete a final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules in order to be eligible to receive certification. A student shall be permitted to review each module, to retake the test for each module, and to retake the final comprehensive examination an unlimited number of times during the five-week period. If a student does not complete the course, does not pass a module test, or does not pass the final comprehensive examination within the five-week period, they shall be required to reregister for, and retake, the course.
(c)The registration fee for the five-week course shall be an amount sufficient to support the functions of the council and to cover the reasonable regulatory cost of administering this chapter, but shall not exceed one hundred twenty five twenty-five dollars ($125). This fee shall apply each time a student registers or reregisters for the course. The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation.
(d)The course in body contouring shall include each of the following 40-hour modules:
(1)Introduction to California body contouring, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)What is California body contouring.
(B)The councils scope of practice.
(C)The legalities of California body contouring.
(D)The councils code of ethics and contract for success.
(E)Permitted tools, equipment, and machines.
(2)Understanding the human body and client safety, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)Anatomy and adipose tissue.
(B)The councils contraindications, medical history, consent, and precare and postcare.
(C)Body contouring table setup.
(D)Clear, understandable treatment pricing, and length of service.
(E)Demonstration of tools, modalities, and equipment.
(3)Disinfection and sanitation.
(4)Client treatment and safety, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)Emergency protocols in the treatment room.
(B)Mandatory client recordkeeping and incident reporting.
(C)Use of hands-only cardiopulmonary resuscitation, the Heimlich maneuver, epinephrine auto-injectors, and automated external defibrillators.
(D)Division of Occupational Safety and Health (OSHA) Bloodborne Pathogen Training.
(5)California business setup and laws, which shall include instruction on all of the following:
(A)Sole proprietor, limited liability company, or corporation.
(B)Paying taxes and the Franchise Tax Board.
(C)Doing business in different cities.
(D)Social media legalities.
(E)Using artificial intelligence in your business and integrating artificial intelligence for client communication.
(F)Your business reputation and how to protect it.
(e)The assistance of a translator may be used in order for an applicant who primarily speaks a language other than English to successfully complete the curricula
(f)Successful passage of the final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules shall demonstrate that a student has the requisite knowledge and skill in order to engage in the practice of body contouring. The examination shall be offered in multiple languages in order to accommodate students who primarily speak a language other than English as determined by the council.
(g)A student who successfully completes the course of instruction described in this section shall receive a certificate of completion issued by the council solely for the purpose of qualifying the individual for a permit to practice body contouring pursuant to Section 4660.13. The certificate shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(h)The council shall also make available to practitioners via its internet website, in the same manner described in subdivision (a), continuing education short courses in the practice of body contouring covering the topics described in subdivision (d).
4660.13.(a)To become a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, an applicant shall submit a digital application to the council and provide the council with satisfactory evidence that they have met all of the following requirements:
(1)Successful completion of the course in the practice of body contouring described in Section 4660.11, evidenced by a certificate of completion issued by the council.
(2)Evidence of Live Scan fingerprint clearance that does not report charges of felony rape or domestic abuse.
(3)The applicant is 18 years of age or older.
(b)The initial fee for a permit to practice body contouring shall be an amount sufficient to cover the reasonable regulatory cost of administering this chapter and supporting the functions of the council, but shall not exceed four hundred ninety-five dollars ($495). The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation.
(c)A permit to practice body contouring shall be subject to renewal each year. The fee to renew a permit to practice body contouring shall be an amount sufficient to cover the reasonable cost of administering this chapter and supporting the functions of the council, but shall not exceed two hundred ninety-five dollars ($295). The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation. The council may provide for late renewal. If a permit is not renewed annually within one year of the date of its initial issuance, a twenty-five-dollar ($25) penalty shall be charged for every month that it is not renewed.
(d)In order to renew a permit to practice body contouring, a practitioner shall provide the council evidence of successful completion of a continuing education short course, offered by the council pursuant to Section 4660.11, covering one topic of their choice.
(e)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
4660.15.(a)A California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner shall do all of the following:
(1)Complete the annual continuing education requirement described in Section 4660.13.
(2)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(3)Possess a working, cellular smartphone with them when they are performing body contouring.
(4)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
(5)Clearly display an active establishment permit or mobile permit, if applicable, and their individual practitioner permit at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
(6)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of their permit.
(b)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that may include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with the provisions of this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.17.(a)An individual who is a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner may apply to the council for a premises permit authorizing the practice of body contouring at a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council.
(b)A premises permit shall be subject to renewal each year.
(c)The holder of a premises permit shall do all of the following:
(1)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(2)Maintain a working, cellular smartphone on the premises during business hours.
(3)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the premises.
(4)Clearly display the permit at the premises.
(5)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of the permit.
(d)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(e)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that can include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.19.(a)An individual who is a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner may apply to the council for a mobile permit authorizing the practice of body contouring within a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council.
(b)A premises permit shall be subject to renewal each year.
(c)The holder of a premises permit shall do all of the following:
(1)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(2)Maintain a working, cellular smartphone within the mobile unit during business hours.
(3)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council within the mobile unit.
(4)Clearly display the permit within the mobile unit.
(5)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of the permit.
(d)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(e)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that may include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.21.(a)It is unlawful for any person to state or advertise or put out any sign or card or other device, or to falsely represent to the public through any print or electronic media that they or any other individual is a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, or is certified, permitted, licensed, or registered by a governmental agency as a body contouring practitioner, sculptor, or specialist.
(b)In addition to any other available remedies, engaging in any of the prohibited behaviors described in subdivision (a) constitutes unfair competition pursuant to Section 17200.
4660.23.The council shall maintain an internet website for purposes of providing information to the public about the council and California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners that does all of the following:
(a)Provides consumers access to a council email address for filing complaints related to a practitioner and that facilitates submission of digital images in connection with a complaint.
(b)Provides a clear and direct message to the consumer about the legal scope of practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
(c)Displays the councils code of ethics and scope of legal practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
(d)Maintains a free registry for consumers and employers to search for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners and businesses that have a premises permit for the practice of body contouring.
(e)Makes available to students and practitioners the educational courses described in Section 4660.11.
(f)Makes available free, voluntary continuing education classes for body contouring practitioners.
(g) Maintains a free listing service for employers that hold a premises permit to post available jobs for California Certified Body Contouring Practitioners and for spaces, shops, and rooms to rent or to share where body contouring may be practiced.
This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act.
4660.1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)More than 1,000,000 people from all segments of society perform body contouring treatments to willing consumers in California and throughout the world.
(2)Currently, there is no official training, vetting, scope of practice, agency, establishment, registry, or system, and no accountability, for a person who performs body contouring treatment. Therefore, persons engaging in this type of service are using techniques that they have learned via demonstrations on the internet, YouTube, Instagram, or Facebook, or from other practitioners.
(3)Aspiring body contourists seek training from persons who claim to be experts in the field. This training can range in price from $1,500 to $2,500, or more for online or in-person instruction. Many Californians are paying for this type of training because no official training exists. Because there is no official training or defined scope of practice, persons who wish to perform these procedures are confused, and often misinformed, about what equipment or applications they can safely and effectively use. In many instances, according the Medical Board of California, contourists use medical-grade equipment and practice medicine without a license. Without clear, lawfully approved training, a place to make official inquiries, ongoing education, and a process for receipt and investigation of consumer complaints, these individuals are operating without a scope of practice or accountability through no fault of their own.
(b)By offering a standard, physician-approved curriculum, it is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council will eliminate price gouging affecting persons seeking to learn how to perform body contouring and ensure that those persons are sufficiently trained. It is the intent of the Legislature that training curriculum be developed, approved, and overseen by an advisory board.
(c)It is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council embrace this new, growing industry by providing consumer safety and specialized, all-inclusive training to ensure both clients and body contourists are working in harmony for an in-demand and marketable vocation.
(d)Job creation faces many barriers. It is the intent of the Legislature that the California Body Contouring Council recognize this dilemma and provide an innovative model of education, implementation, training, a clear scope of practice, and accountability.
4660.3.As used in this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Body contouring means noninvasive, nonmedical treatment intended to shape or contour the fatty areas of the body using wooden or metal tools, enzyme-based scrubs or wraps, sauna blankets, or light-emitting diodes.
(b)California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, or practitioner means a person who is permitted to operate as a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner pursuant to this chapter and who has undergone education, training, certification, and permitting as specified in this chapter.
(c)Council means the California Body Contouring Council.
4660.5.(a)The use of needles, injections, lasers, radio frequency, cavitation, electrical muscle stimulation, or any medical machine or medical instrument by a practitioner is explicitly prohibited by this chapter unless otherwise permitted pursuant to another provision of law.
(b)This chapter does not authorize a practitioner to diagnose illness or to assist or guarantee weight loss through the practice of body contouring.
4660.7.(a)The California Body Contouring Council is hereby established and shall carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in this chapter.
(b)Protection of the public shall be the highest priority of the council in exercising its certification and disciplinary authority, and any of its other functions. If the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
(c)The council may take any reasonable action necessary to carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in this chapter, including, but not limited to, hiring staff, contracting, and developing policies, procedures, rules, and bylaws to implement this chapter.
(d)The council may require background checks for all employees, contractors, volunteers, and board members as a condition of their employment, formation of a contractual relationship, or participation in council activities.
(e)The council shall issue all of the following:
(1)Certificates of completion to individuals who have successfully completed the educational course in the practice of body contouring described in Section 4660.11.
(2)Numbered permits to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner and to perform services within the designated legal scope of practice to individuals who have satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.13.
(3)Numbered premises permits to maintain a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners who perform services within the designated scope of legal practice. The owner and operator of the premises shall be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner that has satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.17.
(4)Numbered mobile permits to maintain a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners who perform services within the designated scope of legal practice. The owner and operator of the mobile unit shall be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner that has satisfied the requirements described in Section 4660.19.
(f)The council may determine whether the information provided to it in connection with certification and permitting is true and correct and meets the requirements of this chapter. If the council has any reason to question whether the information provided by an applicant is true and correct, or meets the requirements of this chapter, the council may make any investigation it deems necessary in order to establish that the information received is accurate and satisfies the criteria established pursuant to this chapter. An applicant shall have the burden to prove that they are entitled to the desired certification or permit.
(g)The meetings of the council shall be subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code). The board may adopt additional policies and procedures that provide greater transparency to persons who hold certifications or permits, and members of the public, that is required by the act.
4660.9.(a)The council shall be governed by a board of directors, who shall be compensated, as determined by the council, and shall be reimbursed for necessary and reasonable expenses incurred in connection with performing board duties. The board of directors shall be comprised of all of the following:
(1)A president.
(2)A vice president.
(3)A California licensed physician, appointed by the Medical Board of California, who shall also perform the following functions by serving as all of the following:
(A)The councils Medical Director.
(B)A professional liaison to the Medical Board of California.
(C)The councils curriculum adviser.
(4)A California licensed cosmetologist.
(b)The council shall be advised by an advisory board comprised of 14 members who shall represent Californias diverse communities and cultures and shall be selected for their expertise in the fields of medicine, cosmetology, personal services, personal services equipment, curriculum creation, training and education, California state law, and the practice of body contouring. Members of the board of directors shall be selected, as follows:
(1)Each of the following entities shall select one member:
(A)The Department of Consumer Affairs.
(B)The Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
(C)The Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
(2)Eleven advisory board members shall be selected by the council.
(c)Members of the advisory board shall serve a term of three years.
4660.11.(a)The council shall develop and make available to students on its internet website five online, 40-hour educational modules composing a five-week, 200-hour, physician-approved course in the practice of body contouring. The course shall use narratives, videos, and multiple-choice quizzes, and be offered in multiple languages as determined by the council.
(b)A student shall have five weeks to complete all five educational modules, successfully complete five corresponding module tests, and successfully complete a final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules in order to be eligible to receive certification. A student shall be permitted to review each module, to retake the test for each module, and to retake the final comprehensive examination an unlimited number of times during the five-week period. If a student does not complete the course, does not pass a module test, or does not pass the final comprehensive examination within the five-week period, they shall be required to reregister for, and retake, the course.
(c)The registration fee for the five-week course shall be an amount sufficient to support the functions of the council and to cover the reasonable regulatory cost of administering this chapter, but shall not exceed one hundred twenty five dollars ($125). This fee shall apply each time a student registers or reregisters for the course. The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation.
(d)The course in body contouring shall include each of the following 40-hour modules:
(1)Introduction to California body contouring, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)What is California body contouring.
(B)The councils scope of practice.
(C)The legalities of California body contouring.
(D)The councils code of ethics and contract for success.
(E)Permitted tools, equipment, and machines.
(2)Understanding the human body and client safety, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)Anatomy and adipose tissue.
(B)The councils contraindications, medical history, consent, and precare and postcare.
(C)Body contouring table setup.
(D)Clear, understandable treatment pricing, and length of service.
(E)Demonstration of tools, modalities, and equipment.
(3)Disinfection and sanitation.
(4)Client treatment and safety, which shall include instruction on all of the following topics:
(A)Emergency protocols in the treatment room.
(B)Mandatory client recordkeeping and incident reporting.
(C)Use of hands-only cardiopulmonary resuscitation, the Heimlich maneuver, epinephrine auto-injectors, and automated external defibrillators.
(D)Division of Occupational Safety and Health (OSHA) Bloodborne Pathogen Training.
(5)California business setup and laws, which shall include instruction on all of the following:
(A)Sole proprietor, limited liability company, or corporation.
(B)Paying taxes and the Franchise Tax Board.
(C)Doing business in different cities.
(D)Social media legalities.
(E)Using artificial intelligence in your business and integrating artificial intelligence for client communication.
(F)Your business reputation and how to protect it.
(e)The assistance of a translator may be used in order for an applicant who primarily speaks a language other than English to successfully complete the curricula
(f)Successful passage of the final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules shall demonstrate that a student has the requisite knowledge and skill in order to engage in the practice of body contouring. The examination shall be offered in multiple languages in order to accommodate students who primarily speak a language other than English as determined by the council.
(g)A student who successfully completes the course of instruction described in this section shall receive a certificate of completion issued by the council solely for the purpose of qualifying the individual for a permit to practice body contouring pursuant to Section 4660.13. The certificate shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(h)The council shall also make available to practitioners via its internet website, in the same manner described in subdivision (a), continuing education short courses in the practice of body contouring covering the topics described in subdivision (d).
4660.13.(a)To become a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, an applicant shall submit a digital application to the council and provide the council with satisfactory evidence that they have met all of the following requirements:
(1)Successful completion of the course in the practice of body contouring described in Section 4660.11, evidenced by a certificate of completion issued by the council.
(2)Evidence of Live Scan fingerprint clearance that does not report charges of felony rape or domestic abuse.
(3)The applicant is 18 years of age or older.
(b)The initial fee for a permit to practice body contouring shall be an amount sufficient to cover the reasonable regulatory cost of administering this chapter and supporting the functions of the council, but shall not exceed four hundred ninety-five dollars ($495). The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation.
(c)A permit to practice body contouring shall be subject to renewal each year. The fee to renew a permit to practice body contouring shall be an amount sufficient to cover the reasonable cost of administering this chapter and supporting the functions of the council, but shall not exceed two hundred ninety-five dollars ($295). The council may increase the fee no more frequently than every four years based upon the rate of inflation. The council may provide for late renewal. If a permit is not renewed annually within one year of the date of its initial issuance, a twenty-five-dollar ($25) penalty shall be charged for every month that it is not renewed.
(d)In order to renew a permit to practice body contouring, a practitioner shall provide the council evidence of successful completion of a continuing education short course, offered by the council pursuant to Section 4660.11, covering one topic of their choice.
(e)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
4660.15.(a)A California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner shall do all of the following:
(1)Complete the annual continuing education requirement described in Section 4660.13.
(2)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(3)Possess a working, cellular smartphone with them when they are performing body contouring.
(4)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
(5)Clearly display an active establishment permit or mobile permit, if applicable, and their individual practitioner permit at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
(6)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of their permit.
(b)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that may include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with the provisions of this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.17.(a)An individual who is a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner may apply to the council for a premises permit authorizing the practice of body contouring at a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council.
(b)A premises permit shall be subject to renewal each year.
(c)The holder of a premises permit shall do all of the following:
(1)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(2)Maintain a working, cellular smartphone on the premises during business hours.
(3)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the premises.
(4)Clearly display the permit at the premises.
(5)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of the permit.
(d)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(e)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that can include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.19.(a)An individual who is a Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner may apply to the council for a mobile permit authorizing the practice of body contouring within a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council.
(b)A premises permit shall be subject to renewal each year.
(c)The holder of a premises permit shall do all of the following:
(1)Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
(2)Maintain a working, cellular smartphone within the mobile unit during business hours.
(3)Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council within the mobile unit.
(4)Clearly display the permit within the mobile unit.
(5)Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of the permit.
(d)A permit shall not be transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
(e)The council shall have the authority to determine disciplinary actions that may include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with this chapter or the rules and regulations established by the council.
4660.21.(a)It is unlawful for any person to state or advertise or put out any sign or card or other device, or to falsely represent to the public through any print or electronic media that they or any other individual is a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, or is certified, permitted, licensed, or registered by a governmental agency as a body contouring practitioner, sculptor, or specialist.
(b)In addition to any other available remedies, engaging in any of the prohibited behaviors described in subdivision (a) constitutes unfair competition pursuant to Section 17200.
4660.23.The council shall maintain an internet website for purposes of providing information to the public about the council and California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners that does all of the following:
(a)Provides consumers access to a council email address for filing complaints related to a practitioner and that facilitates submission of digital images in connection with a complaint.
(b)Provides a clear and direct message to the consumer about the legal scope of practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
(c)Displays the councils code of ethics and scope of legal practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
(d)Maintains a free registry for consumers and employers to search for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners and businesses that have a premises permit for the practice of body contouring.
(e)Makes available to students and practitioners the educational courses described in Section 4660.11.
(f)Makes available free, voluntary continuing education classes for body contouring practitioners.
(g) Maintains a free listing service for employers that hold a premises permit to post available jobs for California Certified Body Contouring Practitioners and for spaces, shops, and rooms to rent or to share where body contouring may be practiced.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 19, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Apr 8, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Consumer Protection Policy Center | ** Against |
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2412
Author:(Reyes) – As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
SUBJECT: Healing arts: California Body Contouring Council: practitioners.
SUMMARY: Establishes the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act, which would require any individual who wishes to engage in the practice of body contouring, as defined, to meet specified requirements and obtain a permit from a private California Body Contouring Council.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Massage Therapy Act to provide for the voluntary certification of massage therapists by the California Message Therapy Council. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 4600 et seq.)
- Defines “massage” as the scientific manipulation of the soft tissues. (BPC § 4601(e))
- Establishes the Tax Preparation Act to provide for the registration of paid tax preparers by the California Tax Education Council. (BPC §§ 22250 et seq.)
- Provides for the voluntary certification of interior designers by the California Council for Interior Design Certification. (BPC §§ 5800 et seq.)
- Establishes the Barbering and Cosmetology Act to provide for the licensing of barbers, cosmetologists, hairstylists, electrologists, estheticians, and manicurists by the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology (BBC) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA). (BPC §§ 7301 et seq.)
- Provides that the BBC shall maintain a program of random and targeted inspections of establishments to ensure compliance with applicable laws relating to the public health and safety and the conduct and operation of establishments. (BPC § 7313)
- Defines the practice of cosmetology as all or any combination of the following:
- Arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, shampooing, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating by any means the hair of any person.
- Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
- Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
- Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
- Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails.
- Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet.
- Tinting and perming of the eyelashes and brows, or applying eyelashes.
(BPC § 7316(b))
- Requires courses in cosmetology to consist of not less than 1,000 hours of practical and technical instruction. (BPC § 7362.5)
- Defines the practice of skin care as all or any combination of the following:
- Giving facials, massaging, stimulating, exfoliating, cleansing, or beautifying the face, scalp, neck, hands, arms, feet, legs, or upper part of the human body by the use of hands, esthetic devices, cosmetic products, antiseptics, lotions, tonics, or creams for the purpose of improving the appearance or well-being of the skin that do not result in the ablation or destruction of the live tissue.
- Tinting and perming of the eyelashes and brows, or applying eyelashes to any person.
- Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by use of depilatories, tweezers, sugaring, nonprescription chemical, or waxing, or by the use of devices and appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of lasers or light waves, which are commonly known as rays.
(BPC § 7316(c))
- Allows an applicant to take the examination for a license as an esthetician if the applicant:
- Is not less than 17 years of age.
- Has completed the 10th grade in a public school.
- Is not subject to denial based on prior criminal history or disciplinary action.
- Has done any of the following:
- Completed a course in skin care from a school approved by the BBC.
- Practiced skin care outside of California for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a qualified person who has completed a course in skin care from a school approved by the BBC.
- Completed a specified apprenticeship program in skin care.
(BPC § 7324)
- Exempts from licensing requirements under the Barbering and Cosmetology Act all persons authorized to practice medicine, surgery, dentistry, pharmacy, osteopathic medicine, chiropractic, naturopathy, podiatry, or nursing and acting within the scope of practice for which they are licensed. (BPC § 7319)
- Expressly provides that the Barbering and Cosmetology Act confers no authority to practice medicine or surgery, and that the practice of medicine shall not be performed by, or offered by, a licensee of the BBC without being authorized and licensed to perform that act; additionally provides that the Barbering and Cosmetology Act shall not be interpreted to grant any privileges reserved for certified massage therapists. (BPC § 7320)
- Authorizes the BBC to inspect tanning facilities operated in conjunction with, or at the same location as, an establishment licensed by the BBC. (BPC § 7414.5)
- Establishes the Medical Practice Act, which provides for the licensing of physicians by the Medical Board of California (MBC) within the DCA. (BPC §§ 2000 et seq.)
- Prohibits the unlicensed practice of medicine, including any system or mode of treating the sick or afflicted, or diagnosis, treatment, operation for, or prescription for any ailment, blemish, deformity, disease, disfigurement, disorder, injury, or other physical or mental condition of any person. (BPC § 2052)
- Prohibits unfair, dishonest, deceptive, destructive, fraudulent, or discriminatory practices under the Unfair Practices Act. (BPC §§ 17000 – 17101)
- Establishes a “sunrise review” process for the Legislature to evaluate proposals to create any state board or category of licensed professional. (Government Code (GOV) §§ 9148 et seq.)
- Places specific requirements and restrictions on contracts for weight loss services. (Civil Code §§ 1694.5 – 1694.9)
- Provides that “state board” includes any administrative or regulatory board, commission, committee, council, association, or authority. (GOV § 9148.2)
- Requires a plan for the establishment and operation of any proposed state board or new category of licensed professional to be developed by the author or sponsor of the legislation prior to consideration by the Legislature, including, but not limited, to all of the following:
- A description of the problem that the creation of the specific state board or new category of licensed professional would address, including the specific evidence of need for the state to address the problem.
- The reasons why this proposed state board or new category of licensed professional was selected to address this problem, including the full range of alternatives considered and the reason why each of these alternatives was not selected, including no action, the use of a current state board or agency or the existence of a current category of licensed professional to address the problem, existing regulation or administration, and addressing the problem by federal or local agencies.
- The specific public benefit or harm that would result from the establishment of the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional, the specific manner in which the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional would achieve this benefit, and the specific standards of performance which shall be used in reviewing the subsequent operation of the board or category of licensed professional.
- The specific source or sources of revenue and funding to be utilized by the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional in achieving its mandate.
- The necessary data and other information required shall be provided to the Legislature with the initial legislation and forwarded to the policy committees in which the bill will be heard.
(GOV § 9148.4)
THIS BILL:
- Establishes the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act and makes various legislative findings and declarations.
- Defines “body contouring” as noninvasive, nonmedical treatment intended to shape or contour the fatty areas of the body using wooden or metal tools, enzyme-based scrubs or wraps, sauna blankets, or light-emitting diodes.
- Provides that a person who has undergone education, training, certification, and permitting under the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act is known as a certified and permitted body contouring practitioner.
- Prohibits the use of needles, injections, lasers, radio frequency, cavitation, electrical muscle stimulation, or any medical machine or medical instrument by a body contouring practitioner unless otherwise permitted pursuant to another law.
- Provides that the bill does not authorize a practitioner to diagnose illness or to assist or guarantee weight loss through the practice of body contouring.
- Establishes the California Body Contouring Council to carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in the California Body Contouring Practitioner Act.
- Provides that protection of the public shall be the highest priority of the council in exercising its certification and disciplinary authority, and any of its other functions.
- Authorizes the council to take any reasonable action necessary to carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in the bill, including, but not limited to, hiring staff, contracting, and developing policies, procedures, rules, and bylaws.
- Authorizes the council to require background checks for all employees, contractors, volunteers, and board members as a condition of their employment, formation of a contractual relationship, or participation in council activities.
- Requires the council to issue all of the following:
- Certificates of completion to individuals who have successfully completed the required educational course in the practice of body contouring.
- Numbered permits to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner and to perform services within the designated legal scope of practice to individuals who have satisfied the requirements for applicants.
- Numbered premises permits to maintain a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners who perform services within the designated scope of legal practice; requires the owner and operator of these premises to be a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner that has met specified requirements.
- Numbered mobile permits to maintain a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council and where body contouring may be practiced by California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners, in the same fashion as physical location premises requirements.
- Provides that the council shall be governed by a board of directors, who shall be compensated, as determined by the council, and shall be reimbursed for necessary and reasonable expenses incurred in connection with performing board duties.
- Provides that the council’s board of directors shall be comprised of all of the following:
- A president.
- A vice president.
- A California-licensed physician, who serves as medical director, professional liaison to the California medical community, and the council’s curriculum adviser.
- A California licensed cosmetologist.
- Establishes an advisory board comprised of 14 members, who are required to represent California’s diverse communities and cultures and who are to be selected for their expertise in the fields of medicine, cosmetology, personal services, personal services equipment, curriculum creation, training and education, California law, and the practice of body contouring.
- Provides that members of the advisory board shall be selected, as follows:
- Each of the following entities shall select one member:
- The Department of Consumer Affairs.
- The Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
- The Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
- Eleven advisory board members shall be selected by the council.
- Each of the following entities shall select one member:
- Provides that members of the advisory board shall serve a term of three years.
- Requires meetings of the council to comply with the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and authorizes the council to adopt additional policies and procedures that provide greater transparency to persons who hold certifications or permits, and members of the public.
- Requires the council to develop and make available to students on its internet website five online, 40-hour educational modules composing a five-week, 200-hour, physician-approved course in the practice of body contouring.
- Requires the course to use narratives, videos, and multiple-choice quizzes, and be offered in multiple languages as determined by the council.
- Provides students with five weeks to complete all five educational modules, successfully complete five corresponding module tests, and successfully complete a final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules in order to be eligible to receive certification.
- Allows students to review each module, to retake the test for each module, and to retake the final comprehensive examination an unlimited number of times during the five-week period.
- Provides that if a student does not complete the course, does not pass a module test, or does not pass the final comprehensive examination within the five-week period, they shall be required to reregister for, and retake, the course.
- Sets the registration fee for the five-week course at an amount not to exceed $125, which the council may increase no more than once every four years based on the rate of inflation.
- Specifies that the course in body contouring must include the following 40-hour modules:
- “Introduction to California body contouring,” with required instruction on all of the following topics:
- What is California body contouring.
- The council’s scope of practice.
- The legalities of California body contouring.
- The council’s code of ethics and contract for success.
- Permitted tools, equipment, and machines.
- “Understanding the human body and client safety,” with required instruction on all of the following topics:
- Anatomy and adipose tissue.
- The council’s contraindications, medical history, consent, and precare and postcare.
- Body contouring table setup.
- Clear, understandable treatment pricing, and length of service.
- Demonstration of tools, modalities, and equipment.
- “Disinfection and sanitation.”
- “Client treatment and safety,” with required instruction on all of the following topics:
- Emergency protocols in the treatment room.
- Mandatory client recordkeeping and incident reporting.
- Use of hands-only cardiopulmonary resuscitation, the Heimlich maneuver, epinephrine auto-injectors, and automated external defibrillators.
- Division of Occupational Safety and Health (OSHA) Bloodborne Pathogen Training.
- “California business setup and laws,” with required instruction on all of the following topics:
- Sole proprietor, limited liability company, or corporation.
- Paying taxes and the Franchise Tax Board.
- Doing business in different cities.
- Social media legalities.
- Using artificial intelligence in your business and integrating artificial intelligence for client communication.
- Your business reputation and how to protect it.
- “Introduction to California body contouring,” with required instruction on all of the following topics:
- Allows for the assistance of a translator to be used in order for an applicant who primarily speaks a language other than English to successfully complete the curricula.
- Provides that successful passage of the final, 25-question comprehensive test covering the curriculum in all five modules shall demonstrate that a student has the requisite knowledge and skill in order to engage in the practice of body contouring.
- Requires the council to offer the examination in multiple languages in order to accommodate students who primarily speak a language other than English as determined by the council.
- Provides that a student who successfully completes the course of instruction shall receive a certificate of completion issued by the council solely for the purpose of qualifying the individual for a permit to practice body contouring.
- Prohibits certificates of completion from being transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
- Requires the council to make continuing education short courses in the practice of body contouring available to practitioners on its website.
- Requires applicants seeking to become a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner to submit a digital application to the council and provide the council with satisfactory evidence that they have met all of the following requirements:
- Successful completion of the required course in the practice of body contouring, evidenced by a certificate of completion issued by the council.
- Evidence of Live Scan fingerprint clearance that does not report charges of felony rape or domestic abuse.
- The applicant is 18 years of age or older.
- Provides the council with discretion to determine whether the information provided to it in connection with certification and permitting is true and correct and meets the requirements; if the council has any reason to question whether the information provided by an applicant is true and correct, or meets the specified requirements, the council may make any investigation it deems necessary in order to establish that the information received is accurate and satisfies the criteria to receive a permit.
- Places the burden of proof on the applicant to prove that they are entitled to the desired certification or permit.
- Establishes the maximum initial fee that the council may charge for a permit to practice body contouring at $495.
- Requires permits to be renewed each year and provides that the maximum renewal fee that the council may charge is $295, with a $25 penalty per month of delinquency for late renewals.
- Prohibits practitioner permits from being transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
- Requires practitioners to provide the council with proof that they have completed a continuing education short course, offered by the council, covering a topic of their choice, as a condition of permit renewal.
- Requires a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner to do all of the following:
- Complete the annual continuing education requirement.
- Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
- Possess a working, cellular smartphone with them when they are performing body contouring.
- Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
- Clearly display an active establishment permit or mobile permit, if applicable, and their individual practitioner permit at the location where body contouring is performed for compensation.
- Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of their permit.
- Empowers the council to determine disciplinary actions that may include nonrenewal of a permit and revocation of an existing permit due to noncompliance with the provisions of the law or the rules and regulations established by the council.
- Authorizes Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners to apply for a premises permit authorizing the practice of body contouring at a specified physical location that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council, subject to renewal each year.
- Requires holders of a premises permit to do all of the following:
- Submit to inspection and investigation by the council at both random and predetermined times.
- Maintain a working, cellular smartphone on the premises during business hours.
- Clearly display any consumer protection notices mandated by the council at the premises.
- Clearly display the permit at the premises.
- Adhere to the ethical standards prescribed by the council and not exceed the legal scope of the permit.
- Prohibits premises permits from being transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
- Authorizes Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners to apply for a mobile permit authorizing the practice of body contouring within a self-contained, self-supporting, enclosed mobile unit that complies with all health and safety regulations established by the council, subject to renewal each year, subject to the same inspection requirements and disciplinary authority as premises permits.
- Prohibits mobile permits from being transferred, sold, or assigned in any way to any other person or entity for any reason at any time.
- Makes it unlawful for any person to state or advertise or put out any sign or card or other device, or to falsely represent to the public through any print or electronic media that they or any other individual is a California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioner, or is certified, permitted, licensed, or registered by a governmental agency as a body contouring practitioner, sculptor, or specialist.
- Provides that engaging in any of the bill’s prohibited behaviors constitutes unfair competition.
- Requires the council to maintain an internet website for purposes of providing information to the public about the council and California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners that does all of the following:
- Provides consumers access to a council email address for filing complaints related to a practitioner and that facilitates submission of digital images in connection with a complaint.
- Provides a clear and direct message to the consumer about the legal scope of practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
- Displays the council’s code of ethics and scope of legal practice for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners.
- Maintains a free registry for consumers and employers to search for California Certified and Permitted Body Contouring Practitioners and businesses that have a premises permit for the practice of body contouring.
- Makes available to students and practitioners educational courses.
- Makes available free, voluntary continuing education classes for body contouring practitioners.
- Maintains a free listing service for employers that hold a premises permit to post available jobs for California Certified Body Contouring Practitioners and for spaces, shops, and rooms to rent or to share where body contouring may be practiced.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the California Body Contouring Council. According to the author:
“AB 2412 would create the California Body Contouring Council (CABCC) to license and to regulate the body contouring industry. It would provide consumer protection by establishing a vetting, training, and monitoring process that will protect consumers from injury, malpractice and or practitioner misrepresentation. As an emerging industry there is a need to educate, train, and monitor the profession of body contouring so that consumers feel safe when pursuing these services. Currently many of the practices in body contouring are being performed by untrained, non-medical individuals. This has enabled manufacturers of body contouring products to flood the market with devices that are labeled "noninvasive" and are assumed to be consumer safe. Being able to protect consumers and bring into regulatory compliance body contouring by granting an annual certification permit to legally perform noninvasive, non-medical body contouring treatments under California Law and within the defined legal scope of practice will help address the proliferation of the practice in a safe manner.”
Background.
Body Contouring. The term “body contouring” is commonly used to refer to a wide range of cosmetic procedures designed to enhance the shape, tone, and proportion of various areas of the body. Body contouring can include surgical techniques aimed at removing excess fat, tightening sagging skin, and sculpting specific body parts for a more aesthetically pleasing appearance. Common procedures include liposuction, abdominoplasty (tummy tucks), breast lifts or augmentations, thigh lifts, and arm lifts. According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, these procedures have seen a steady increase in popularity over the years, driven by advancements in surgical techniques and a growing societal emphasis on physical appearance.
Body contouring can also refer to noninvasive techniques designed to sculpt and define the body without surgery, also commonly referred to as “body sculpting.” These techniques typically utilize technologies such as laser therapy, radiofrequency energy, ultrasound, or cryolipolysis to target fat cells, tighten skin, and contour the body. Even less invasive are additional body contouring techniques that apply products and tools to a customer’s body to shape or contour fat. For example, wood therapy, also known as madero therapy, utilizes wooden tools from hardwood such as rosewood or bamboo that are used to manipulate the skin to stimulate circulation, break down cellulite, and promote lymphatic drainage. This can result in smoother, firmer skin and improved body contours over time. Similarly, the traditional Chinese medicine technique of Gua Sha utilizes tools made from smooth metal, such as jade or stainless steel, to scrape the skin. Both wooden and metal tool techniques stimulate circulation, break down cellulite, and promote lymphatic drainage, and are often used in conjunction with other body contouring techniques to enhance their effectiveness.
The federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved some forms of body contouring, both surgical and noninvasive. Surgical body contouring procedures are approved by the FDA for specific purposes—for example, liposuction is approved for the removal of excess fat in specific areas of the body, while tummy tucks are approved for addressing excess skin and tightening abdominal muscles. Non-surgical body contouring procedures also have FDA approval for certain indications. For example, CoolSculpting, a noninvasive fat reduction treatment, is FDA-approved for targeting and reducing fat in specific areas of the body using cryolipolysis. Similarly, other non-surgical techniques like radiofrequency therapy and laser therapy have received FDA clearance for body contouring purposes.
According to the FDA, noninvasive body contouring procedures may improve a consumer’s appearance, but are often less effective or permanent than surgical body contouring:
“Body contouring procedures may not always result in your desired effect, or your result may only be temporary. Non-invasive body contouring describes non-surgical procedures that do not remove any tissue (fat or skin) from the body. It is different from a surgical body contouring procedure, like tummy-tuck surgery, which cuts out excess skin, or liposuction, which uses a narrow vacuum-type device to pull fat out through a small incision. Non-invasive body contouring does not treat obesity or improve your health. It will not result in weight loss or contribute to the health benefits associated with weight loss.”[1]
Because the practice of body contouring encompasses a broad spectrum of services involving significantly different risks of harm to consumers, there have historically been issues with practitioners failing to identify and adhere to the line of what they are permitted by law to perform. On one end of the spectrum, body contouring is considered invasive enough to constitute the practice of medicine, requiring licensure as a physician and surgeon by the MBC or other authorization within the healing arts professions. On the opposite end of the spectrum, body contouring is considered incredibly low risk (though correspondingly less effective) and can be performed by anyone regardless of licensure or training.
This lack of clarity has led to issues where body contouring procedures and similar services are provided in spa establishments licensed under the Barbering and Cosmetology Act that exceed the scope of what a practitioner is authorized to do under their license from the BBC. In 2015, the BBC convened a Medical Services Task Force in response to issues raised in the BBC’s prior sunset review. The Task Force included representatives of the BBC, the FDA, the MBC, the California Department of Public Health, and industry stakeholders. These meetings resulted in the development of an Industry Bulletin, “Skin Care Machines/Devices,” and an Equipment Evaluation Binder.
The issue was discussed again during the BBC’s most recent sunset review as Issue #4 of the background paper published by the Senate Committee on Business, Professions, and Economic Development and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions. Specifically, the background paper posed the question: “Are clarifications necessary to specify that BBC-regulated beautification services do not constitute the practice of medicine?” The paper then went on to explain:
“Current law specifies that the Act does not confer authority to practice medicine or surgery. The rise of medical spas has long been a concern for the Medical Board of California and efforts there have been efforts to establish clear lines between beautification services and treatments that constitute the practice of medicine, particularly in light of the significant growth in the beauty and wellness industry, and the availability of approved products and devices. Lasers and medical-level skin treatments are only allowed to be provided by a physician and surgeon licensed by the MBC, registered nurse licensed by the Board of Registered Nursing, or physician assistants licensed by the Physician Assistant Board when those individuals are practicing according to the practice agreement with a supervising physician.
“BBC reports that licensees are often providing services that are technically considered the practice of medicine. Inspectors routinely enter establishments to find products, devices, and treatment offerings that are beyond the authority of a BBC license. BBC is concerned that the Act limits its authority by referring to “practicing” which allows establishments to skirt the law by ‘offering’ certain services. BBC requests to amend the Act to include language specifying that the practice of medicine shall not be performed or offered by a licensee without being authorized and licensed to perform the service pursuant to a certificate obtained in accordance with another provision of law.”
In response to this sunset issue, the BBC’s sunset bill was amended to even more expressly provide that “the practice of medicine shall not be performed by, or offered by, a licensee under [the Barbering and Cosmetology Act] without being authorized and licensed to perform that act pursuant to a license obtained in accordance with some other provision of law.”
Sunrise Review. This bill proposes to establish a new regulatory entity, the California Body Contouring Council, which would be responsible for issuing permits that individuals would be required to obtain in order to engage in the practice of body contouring, as defined. As such, this bill is required to undergo what is known as the “sunrise process.” As laid out in Section 9148.4 of the Government Code, sunrise review is required prior to consideration by the Legislature of legislation creating a new state board or legislation creating a new category of licensed professional, which includes nongovernmental councils empowered to impose and enforce permitting, certification, or licensing programs required by state law. The process includes a questionnaire and a set of evaluative scales to be completed by the group supporting regulation. The questionnaire is an objective tool for collecting and analyzing information needed to arrive at accurate, informed, and publicly supportable decisions regarding the merits of regulatory proposals.
New regulatory and licensing proposals are generally intended to assure the competence of specified practitioners in different occupations. However, these proposals have resulted in a proliferation of licensure and certification programs, which are often met with mixed support. Proponents argue that regulation benefits the public by assuring competence and an avenue for consumer redress. Critics argue that regulation benefits a profession more than it benefits the public. Sunrise helps distill those arguments by: (1) placing the burden of showing the necessity for new regulations on the requesting groups; (2) allowing the systematic collection of opinions both pro and con; and (3) documenting the criteria used to decide upon new regulatory proposals.
Levels of Regulation. If a review of the proponents’ case indicates that regulation is necessary to protect public health, safety, and welfare, then a determination must be made regarding the appropriate level of regulation. The public is often best served by minimal government intervention. The definitions and guidelines below are intended to facilitate the selection of the least restrictive level of regulation that will adequately protect the public interest.
Level I: Strengthen existing laws and controls. The choice may include providing stricter civil actions or criminal prosecutions. It is most appropriate where the public can effectively implement control.
Level II: Impose inspections and enforcement requirements. This choice may allow inspection and enforcement by a state agency. These should be considered where a service is provided that involves a hazard to the public health, safety, or welfare. Enforcement may include recourse to court injunctions and should apply to the business or organization providing the service, rather than the individual employees.
Level III: Impose registration requirements. Under registration, the state maintains an official roster of the practitioners of an occupation, recording also the location and other particulars of the practice, including a description of the services provided. This level of regulation is appropriate where any threat to the public is small.
Level IV: Provide an opportunity for certification. Certification is voluntary; it grants recognition to persons who have met certain prerequisites. Certification protects a title: non-certified persons may perform the same tasks but may not use “certified” in their titles. Usually, an occupational association is the certifying agency, but the state can be one as well. Either can provide consumers a list of certified practitioners who have agreed to provide services of a specified quality for a stated fee. This level of regulation is appropriate when the potential for harm exists and when consumers have a substantial need to rely on the services of practitioners.
Level V: Impose licensure requirements. Under licensure, the state allows persons who meet predetermined standards to work at an occupation that would be unlawful for an unlicensed person to practice. Licensure protects the scope of practice and the title. It also provides for a disciplinary process administered by a state control agency. This level of regulation is appropriate only in those cases where a clear potential for harm exists and no lesser level of regulation can be shown to adequately protect the public. Note that while terms “permit” or “certificate” may be substituted for the term “license,” a requirement is effectively the same as licensure if it made mandatory by law to perform the specified scope of practice.
Central to the sunrise process are nine sunrise criteria, which were developed in coordination with the DCA to provide a framework for evaluating the need for regulation. These criteria are:
- Unregulated practice of the occupation in question will harm or endanger the public health, safety or welfare.
- Existing protections available to the consumer are insufficient.
- No alternatives to regulation will adequately protect the public.
- Regulation will alleviate existing problems.
- Practitioners operate independently, making decisions of consequence.
- The functions and tasks of the occupation are clearly defined.
- The occupation is clearly distinguishable from other occupations that are already regulated.
- The occupation requires knowledge, skills, and abilities that are both teachable and testable.
- The economic impact of regulation is justified.
The criteria were used to develop the sunrise questionnaire noted above and help legislators and administrators answer three policy questions:
- Does the proposed regulation benefit the public health, safety, or welfare?
- Will the proposed regulation be the most effective way to correct existing problems?
- Is the level of the proposed regulation appropriate?
Sunrise Analysis. The following sunrise analysis is based on the above criteria and corresponding questions and answers provided by the author and the sponsor of the bill, the California Body Contouring Council, referred to collectively as the applicant group.
Criterion 1. Unregulated practice of body contouring will harm or endanger the public health, safety, or welfare.
The applicant group argues that “the public is operating under a false premise that body contouring can be performed by anyone wishing to offer it. It is a tremendously popular treatment and is continually sought out. Since there is no real scope of practice, no regulatory agency and no boundaries, many practitioners are testing the limits of devices, treatments and safety without being a physician.” The applicant group points to harm caused primarily by practitioners who are using medical grade machines or engaging in services that are arguably within the practice of medicine.
It should be noted, however, that this bill specifically prohibits these types of services. Therefore, most of the arguments made by the applicant group regarding the potential for consumer harm are not the risks associated with the practice actually being regulated through this bill under its permit requirements. Rather, the risk results from untrained practitioners not understanding the boundaries of their noninvasive scope of practice.
Criterion 2. Existing protections available to the consumer are insufficient.
The applicant group states that “presently consumers control their exposure to risk based purely on gut instincts or a personal referral from a friend or associate.” The applicant group believes that many “unqualified or ill informed practitioners lure the consumer into a false sense of expertise” through the use of certificates of training that do not actually guarantee any level of competence. The applicant group argues that “since there is no overseeing agency, the consumer must make a personal decision in order to obtain services and hope for the best outcome.” The applicant group further argues that there is no immediate form of recourse for consumers who are harmed by body contouring practitioners, and must rely on civil litigation to seek redress.
Criterion 3. No alternatives to regulation will adequately protect the public.
The applicant group does not suggest any other form of regulation that would be sufficient to protect the public beyond what is contained in this bill. The applicant group acknowledges that body contouring is not regulated in any other state, that there are no relevant federal laws, and that there are no national accrediting organizations for the profession. The applicant argues that “the marketplace demand is high, creating a lucrative service, but with untrained persons in this unregulated industry that are administering these treatments thus creating ‘the wild west of body contouring.’”
The sunrise questionnaire by the applicant group does not speak to any of the lower levels of regulation that could be considered, but instead refers to the lack of any other form of regulation currently imposed on the industry in California or elsewhere in the country. However, other alternatives to regulations should still be considered. Because the risk to the consumer appears to be based primarily on a lack of ability to discern the training and competence of a practitioner, title protection may be an appropriate solution that has not yet been fully considered.
Criterion 4. Regulation will mitigate existing problems.
The applicant group argues that the public will benefit from the regulation of body contouring in the following ways:
1-The consumer will be aware of the many educated and trained practitioners to choose from leading to healthy competition and high standards from the CABCC practitioners.
2-The consumer will be able to check the qualifications and the fingerprint clearance of their practitioner in the CABCC data base before consenting to a treatment.
3-The consumer will become educated and aware of the health benefits of Body Contouring and have options other than invasive, expensive procedures to choose from.
4-The consumer will have a serious, bonafide complaint vehicle on the CABCC website that will be available to them. The practitioner will be regulated and know that the consumer has a way to lodge a complaint and be compelled to comply with the standards set forth by the CABCC.
5-The consumer will be treated with safe, non invasive procedures clearly defined in the CABCC practitioner’s scope of legal practice.
6-The consumer will have a mandated consultation, a legal consent form, a medical history form and pre and post care instructions with transparent pricing.
Criterion 5. Practitioners operate independently, making decisions of consequence.
According to the information provided by the applicant group in its sunrise questionnaire, “current practitioners work independently, yet unfortunately they are untrained.” The applicant group states that “the skill and knowledge needed for non invasive, non medical body contouring is that of a trained technician, similar to a Licensed Manicurist or a Licensed Esthetician. Any profession that deals with other humans that are physically touched needs education and training for consumer and practitioner safety. While the degree of training is not excessively intense, education and training is vitally necessary for prevention of consumer harm and practitioner malpractice.”
Criterion 6. Functions and tasks of the occupation are clearly defined.
The applicant group believes that it has adequately defined the scope of practice for body contouring practitioners within this bill, including through the prohibition of “the use of machines that administer lasers, frequencies, excessive heat or manufactured cold devices.” The applicant group further argues that competence can be measured by objective standards through “an annual self check assessment submitted at the time of annual recertification made by the practitioner and submitted as an attestation of adequate compliance of operational duties.”
Criterion 7. The occupation is clearly distinguishable from other occupations that are already regulated.
Here, the applicant group notes that certified massage therapists and licensed estheticians possess similar scope to what is being proposed for body contouring. The applicant groups state that “licensed estheticians are one of the biggest groups of Body Contourers currently. However, it is definitely not in their scope of practice in California. In fact, estheticians are not allowed to work on the body past the shoulders except for waxing.” The applicant group argues, however, that if the Legislature were to add body contouring practices to the scope for a licensed esthetician, “cost would be prohibitive and unfair to pay considering someone just wanted to be a Body Practitioner.”
The applicant group does not discuss in the context of this criterion the fact that licensed physicians and other health professionals often provide invasive services that are commonly referred to as body contouring. As previously discussed, those would not be included in the scope of practice established under this bill.
Criterion 8. The occupation requires possession of knowledge, skills, and abilities that are both teachable and testable.
The applicant group argues that the generally accepted core set of knowledge, skills and abilities that should be in every practitioner’s skill set should be:
- Sanitation and Disinfection
- Education of Basic Body Functions and Contraindications
- Body Contouring Safe Procedures
- Hands On CPR Training
- California Business Law are all categories of expertise that every Body Art Practitioner should possess.
The majority of these areas of knowledge, skills, and abilities do not relate to body contouring itself, but to general health that the applicant group believes are important for body contouring practitioners to know. This bill also includes numerous areas of training related to the operation of a business, which is included in the applicant group’s sunrise questionnaire. This type of education is typically not considered an appropriate reason to establish education or training requirements prior to entry into a profession.
Criterion 9. The economic impact of regulation is justified.
According to the applicant group, “regulation will not affect the price for the treatment. It is a personal service that requires effort on a one to one basis. Location and services offered are all part of the cost analysis.” As for the cost to the state, the applicant group argues that “as the CABCC is a self funded, private council, there will be no governmental monies requested or needed to develop this new vocational program.” The council would be entirely funded through the collection of fees from practitioners and premises owners.
The sunrise questionnaire does not go into detail in this section in regards to the cost to practitioners. It should be noted, however, that the initial license fee for a licensed esthetician is $115 including examination and licensing costs, as compared to the $125 education fee and $495 initial license fee proposed for body contouring practitioners in this bill.
Current Related Legislation.
AB 2231 (Gipson) would establish a California Pawnbrokers Education Council. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
None on file.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The Consumer Protection Policy Center (CPPC) opposes this bill, writing: “Instead of creating a new regulatory council for body contouring practitioners, the legislature should instead focus on how to improve enforcement within existing regulatory agencies to help better protect the public. It is well known that enforcement proceedings are time and cost consuming, and only hinder the public safety as it exists today. The creation of a new regulatory agency would not improve the safety of the public without the improvement of existing enforcement proceedings. Improving enforcement proceedings within the Medical Board of California and California Board of Barbering and Cosmetology would better protect consumers and is more suitable for this bill’s intent.”
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
Sunrise Review. As previously discussed, the sunrise criteria and questionnaire are intended to assist policy makers in answering the following questions:
- Does the proposed regulation benefit the public health, safety, or welfare? As previously discussed in the sunrise analysis for this bill, the majority of the potential consumer harm that the author seeks to address through this bill is unrelated to the practice of body contouring as defined in the bill. The applicant group repeatedly refers to the risks associated with untrained use of medical grade machines and other procedures such as such as radio frequency, lasers, ultrasound, cavitation and cryotherapy. However, this bill provides for a narrow definition of “body contouring” that specifically means “noninvasive, nonmedical treatment” using “wooden or metal tools, enzyme-based scrubs or wraps, sauna blankets, or light-emitting diodes.” No evidence has been provided that consumers are at any risk of harm from untrained use of these services.
Further, the bill’s definition of the term “body contouring” has the potential to cause confusion. While the bill does not intend to allow permitted practitioners to provide invasive services like lipsuction or tummy tucks, these are frequently referred to as “body contouring.” Utilizing an existing definition that is commonly understood to have broad applicability to describe a narrower collection of services could actually have the opposite effect of the author’s stated goal, as consumers may be unclear about what someone in possession of a permit to engage in the practice of body contouring is actually authorized to offer or perform. This confusion has the potential to be exploited by bad actors. There could also be unintended consequences to prohibiting plastic surgeons and other medical providers from implying that they are licensed as a body contouring practitioner, sculptor, or specialist, as this bill would do, when in fact those individually are in fact arguably licensed as such.
In addition, it is worth questioning whether all the requirements in this bill are for the benefit of the public. The bill would require permit applicants to complete specified education provided by the council, which includes topics within the category “California business setup and laws” such as paying taxes, doing business in different cities, social media legalities, and “your business reputation and how to protect it.” While courses of this nature may very well be advisable for any business owners, including those engaged in body contouring, it is not clear why they would be required as a condition of receiving a permit, as they serve to benefit the business and not the consumer. Similarly, it is unclear how requiring permit holders to “maintain a working, cellular smartphone on the premises during business hours” is a necessary requirement to ensure the protection of consumers of body contouring services.
- Will the proposed regulation be the most effective way to correct existing problems? As discussed above, existing practices referred to as “body contouring” that are considered invasive or within the practice of medicine are already regulated by the state. Any practice considered within the scope of a physician or similarly empowered health professional is already reserved for those with education and training, and a state license is required for those practitioners. The author’s purpose in citing the potential harm caused by these services is therefore not to propose including them in the scope of the permit being created by the bill, but rather to suggest that the permit is needed to ensure that unlicensed practitioners are educated about the fact that they cannot provide those invasive services under existing law. There could potentially be alternative ways of achieving this goal.
As pointed out by opposition to this bill, a better solution to the potential harm caused by the unlicensed practice of medicine by unregulated body contouring practitioners would arguably be enhanced enforcement by the MBC, which is the primary entity responsible for taking action for these sorts of violations. The BBC already regularly refers complaints to the MBC when its own licensees are found to be exceeding their scope of practice and utilizing more invasive tools or techniques in salons or similar settings. Presumably, the council created by this bill would ultimately still have to rely on the MBC to enforce the provisions of the Medical Practice Act, which prompts a question as to whether a council is necessary or if existing regulatory entities should be empowered to take action.
- Is the level of the proposed regulation appropriate? This bill proposes the highest level of regulation for purposes of a sunrise analysis, as a permit would be mandatory for those seeking to provide services that are currently not within any protected scope of practice. However, there may be more appropriate levels of regulation that still accomplish the goals of this bill:
- Level I: Strengthen existing laws and controls. As previously discussed, existing law already prohibits untrained, unregulated individuals from providing the types of invasive services that this author cites as having the potential to cause harm. Enhancing existing efforts by the MBC, BBC, and other regulatory stakeholders to enforce against the unlicensed practice of medicine may be an adequate solution to this concern. Further, there could be some consideration of expanding the scope of practice and training requirements for licensees of the BBC, such as cosmetologists or estheticians, to include some of the noninvasive practices identified in this bill, allowing that existing regulatory structure to be utilized to protect consumers without creating a new entity or permitting framework specifically for body contouring.
- Level IV: Provide an opportunity for certification. Many of the author’s arguments in favor of this bill, as outlined in the sunrise questionnaire, relate to a need for consumers to be able to trust that body contouring practitioners from whom they receive services are sufficiently trained and educated. Because the actual services within the bill’s defined scope of body contouring present such a low risk, it is less likely that those without this level of education could cause harm—however, consumers may nevertheless wish to identify which practitioners do have training, both to better predict the quality of the services they receive and to ensure that their practitioner does not exceed the bounds of what they are allowed to practice.
These goals could arguably be met through certification, which reserves the use of certain titles for those who meet certain prerequisites. Non-certified persons may perform the same tasks but may not use “certified” in their titles. If the goal is to provide individuals who have received a substantial amount of education to have an advantage in the marketplace over those who have not received that level of education, then voluntary certification through the council or another entity could successfully make this distinction. These practitioners could be identifiable to consumers through the use of protected terms in advertisements, or through a searchable database such as the one already envisioned in this bill. Finally, while certification is voluntarily obtained, it may still be suspended or revoked following misconduct by a practitioner, allowing for additional options for enforcement.
Issues Relating to Nongovernmental Councils. There are currently three councils that to varying degrees serve regulatory functions pursuant to California law. The California Council for Interior Design Certification (CCIDC) was created in 1991 by Senate Bill 153 (Craven) to provide title protection for voluntarily certified interior designers. The California Tax Education Council (CTEC) was created in 1997 by Senate Bill 1077 (Greene), which replaced a prior licensing program for tax preparers under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) with a less onerous registration program under a private nonprofit. Finally, the California Massage Therapy Council (CAMTC) was created in 2009 after multiple failed attempts to establish licensure of massage therapists by a state licensing board. While certification by CAMTC is voluntary under state law, it is frequently required as part of local ordinances, making it function similarly to a license.
Each of the three nongovernmental councils currently established under the Business and Professions Code is subject to the Legislature’s sunset review process. In recent years, a number of issues have been raised in the respective background papers for each entity highlighting identified deficiencies that are arguably intrinsic to the nongovernmental council model. Many of these issues relate to the inapplicability of various “good government” laws to private councils that while nongovernmental, effectively serve functions traditionally administered by government agencies in regards to licensure and oversight.
For example, an issue raised in multiple sunset background papers is that none of the three existing nonprofit councils are required to comply with the California Public Records Act (PRA). The PRA generally provides that “public records are open to inspection at all times during the office hours of the state or local agency and every person has a right to inspect any public record.” The PRA defines “state agency” as “every state office, officer, department, bureau, board, and commission or other state body or agency.” This definition almost certainly does not apply to private councils, as confirmed in relevant court decisions related to similar entities.
Another law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, requires meetings of regulatory bodies to be noticed and to allow for participation by members of the public. The intent of Bagley-Keene is “that actions of state agencies be taken openly and that their deliberation be conducted openly.” The law defines “state bodies” as “a board, commission, committee, or similar multimember body that exercises any authority of a state body delegated to it by that state body.” Because this definition does not expressly apply to councils, sunset bills for each of the existing councils have expressly required compliance with Bagley-Keene, and this bill would establish a similar requirement for the California Body Contouring Council. However, there have been difficulties with several of the current entities demonstrating compliance with those requirements.
Similarly, the Office of State Audits and Investigations at the Department of Finance generally has broad authority to inquire into the budgets of state entities. However, this authority is based on the definition of “state agency” as codified in Section 11000 of the Government Code, which includes “every state office, officer, department, division, bureau, board, and commission.” A private council is not included among the specified entities falling under this definition.
It also appears that not all of the state’s whistleblower laws apply to private councils. Both the California Whistleblower Protection Act and the Whistleblower Protection Act utilize the limited definition in Section 11000 of the Government Code. These laws, which protect employees and other persons who disclose improper activities by public bodies, would therefore likely also not apply to statutorily created private councils.
California’s Administrative Procedure Act (APA) includes a variety of additional laws aimed at preserving transparency in rulemaking and due process administrative hearings by state agencies. Provisions of the APA establish entities such as the Office of Administrative Law (OAL), which oversees public participation in agency regulations, and the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), which adjudicates administrative disputes. The portions of the APA relating to OAL and rulemaking again utilize the Section 11000 definition of “state agency,” likely its provisions inapplicable to private councils; it is unclear to what extend provisions relating to OAH would apply absent express preemption or adoption in statute.
Finally, the Political Reform Act of 1974 enacted a number of safeguards to hold public decision-makers accountable and ensure that they “perform their duties in an impartial manner, free from bias caused by their own financial interests.” The California Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) has relatively broad authority to determine who is subject to the requirements imposed by the Act. It is not entirely clear whether a private council would be considered applicable. An FPPC advisory letter (referred to as the Siegel Letter) lays out four factors in determining whether an entity must comply with the Act: (1) Whether the impetus for the formation of the entity originated with a government agency; (2) Whether the entity is substantially funded by a government agency; (3) Whether one of the entity’s principle purposes is rendering services typically performed by public agencies; and (4) Whether the entity is otherwise treated as a public entity by statute. Absent further guidance by the FPPC, it is possible that because private councils likely do not fulfil each of the Siegel Letter’s four factors, they would likely be ruled inapplicable to the Act.
While the potential inapplicability of each of these laws may be viewed as a substantial flaw in the private council model, it was also arguably part of the Legislature’s intent in creating it. The fact that nongovernmental councils do not have to comply with various bureaucratic processes and requirements allows for more flexibility and efficiency. It has been argued that this results in those bodies operating more expeditious and at less cost to fee payers.
These potential advantages must then be weighed against the disadvantages. An essential component of this equation is whether professionals are required to receive permission from a council to engage in providing services, as opposed to receiving some other competitive advantage, such as title protection or the marketing advantages of certification. If a nongovernmental entity is responsible for determining whether an individual is afforded the property right of their ability to earn a living through their profession or trade, it can be argued that this responsibility is carried out with the accountability and transparency required of government agencies.
While this bill does not specify that the California Body Contouring Council is to be organized as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, the intent of the author appears to be to mirror the structure of the three existing nongovernmental councils. In particular, CAMTC has been cited as an analogous entity to what is envisioned in this bill. However, while certification of massage therapists is technically voluntary at the state level under the Massage Therapy Act unless required by local ordinance, this bill would require individuals to receive a permit from the California Body Contouring Council. Given that a mandatory permit has the same practical effect as a license, the myriad accountability and transparency issues that come with private councils arguably raises important considerations regarding the appropriateness of vesting such authority in a nonstate entity.
Lack of a Sunset Date. While this bill would provide for the creation of a new category of professional under a new regulatory entity through the sunrise process, it does not correspondingly allow for that professional category or entity to be subsequently evaluated through the sunset process. In order to ensure that California’s myriad professional boards, bureaus, and other entities (including councils) are meeting the state’s public protection priorities, authorizing statutes for these regulatory bodies are subject to statutory dates of repeal, at which point the entity “sunsets” unless the date is extended by the Legislature. The sunset process provides a regular forum for discussion around the successes and challenges of various programs and the consideration of proposed changes to laws governing the regulation of professionals. Currently, the sunset review process applies to approximately three dozen different boards and bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs, as well as the Department of Real Estate and each of the three existing nongovernmental councils.
On a schedule averaging every four years, each entity is required to present a report to the Legislature’s policy committees, which in return prepare a comprehensive background paper on the efficacy and efficiency of their licensing and enforcement programs. Both the Administration and regulated professional stakeholders actively engage in this process. Legislation is then subsequently introduced extending the repeal date for the entity along with any reforms identified during the sunset review process. This process has been proven to provide for both robust oversight of the Legislature as well as necessary evaluation of the continued need for barriers to entry into professions currently subject to state requirements. A sunset date should thus be added to this bill should it move forward.
Criminal History Disqualification. This bill would require applicants for a permit to practice body contouring to undergo a Live Scan fingerprint background check. However, only two offenses are specified as eligible to disqualify applicants: “charges of felony rape or domestic abuse.” For most regulatory entities, including those under the DCA, applicants may be denied based on convictions of offenses considered “substantially related” to the privileges being sought. Under Assembly Bill 2138 (Chiu/Low, Chapter 995, Statutes of 2018), an application may only be denied on the basis of prior misconduct if the applicant was formally convicted of a substantially related crime or was subject to formal discipline by another regulatory entity. Similar language should be included to disqualify those seeking privileges to practice body contouring, and the bill should specify that only unexpunged, undismissed convictions of offenses are disqualifying, rather than charges, consistent with AB 2138.
Board of Directors Composition. This bill would provide that the council is governed by a board of directors, which is similar to how other existing private councils operate. However, the way that the board of directors is structured is peculiar. First, there is no specification as to how directors are appointed; appointing authorities are provided for the council’s advisory board, but directors are simply presumed to exist. Further, the bill provides that of the four members, one is the board’s president and another is its vice president; this is also odd, as typically leadership positions on a board are elected from among its members, making the lack of an identified appointing authority more significant. The author may also wish to rethink providing for a four-member board of directors, since having a small, even-numbered composition could lead to quorum or voting issues. Finally, this bill does not require any directors to represent the body contouring profession. While the Legislature has been thoughtful in recent years about affording too much influence to regulated stakeholders on regulatory bodies, this bill arguably does not allow for enough of a professional perspective in board deliberations. The author may therefore wish to expand and clarify the composition of the council’s board of directors.
Fee Amounts. As previously discussed, this bill would provide that the council may charge an initial permit fee of $495, and an annual renewal fee of $295. While the intent of the author in establishing a council rather than a state board is to provide for an efficient, low-cost entity, this is actually a rather high fee amount. The biannual cost for body contouring practitioners under the council would be $590, as opposed to just $50 for cosmetologists under the BBC or $300 for certified massage therapists under CAMTC. It is unclear why the council established in this bill would need such a high cap on the amount it charges to permit holders in fees given that the profession being overseen does not pose a significant risk to consumers when acting within the provided scope of practice.
Compensation Issues. This bill would provide that the council is authorized to take “any reasonable action necessary to carry out the responsibilities and duties set forth in this chapter, including, but not limited to, hiring staff. Because the council would not be part of state government, laws establishing hiring processes and compensation ranges under California’s civil service laws would not apply. This has led to issues with other councils where staff compensation has been very high and subject to regular increase. Similarly, this bill would provide that the council’s board of directors “shall be compensated, as determined by the council, and shall be reimbursed for all necessary and reasonable expenses incurred in connection with performing board duties.” While many regulatory boards and other entities provide voting members with per diem compensation and reimbursement, it is unusual to provide undefined authority for them to be compensated outside that context. Considering that the council’s revenue will be entirely obtained from permit fees, the author may wish to refine these provisions to ensure only reasonable compensation for both council staff and directors.
AMENDMENTS:
In recognition of the issues raised in this committee’s sunrise analysis and the preference for imposing a lower level of regulation sufficient to protect the public, specifically through strengthening existing laws and controls: Strike the contents of this bill and instead add the practice of body contouring, as defined, to the scope of license requirements under the Barbering and Cosmetology Act.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
None on file.
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Consumer Protection Policy Center
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/aesthetic-cosmetic-devices/non-invasive-body-contouring-technologies ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):