AB 925: Intentional recording of telephonic communication.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-05-11
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine not to exceed $2,500, by imprisonment in county jail for not more than one year or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment, to intercept or receive and intentionally record, or assist in the interception or receipt and intentional recording of, a communication transmitted between 2 telephonic devices, without the consent of all parties to the communication. Existing law exempts from these provisions a public communications utility when the acts are for the construction, maintenance, or operation of the services of the public utility or are pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility, and also exempts telephonic communication systems used exclusively within a correctional facility, as specified.
This bill would additionally exempt from that prohibition a nonconfidential the first 20 seconds of a telephonic communication between a person or business and a current or former customer, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer, regarding their business relationship, including communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business. customer. The bill would also require the Department of Justice to annually report to the Legislature the number of people charged under these provisions.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine not to exceed $2,500, by imprisonment in county jail for not more than one year or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment to, without the consent of both parties, imprisonment, to intercept or receive and intentionally record, or assist in the interception or receipt and intentional recording of, a communication transmitted between 2 telephonic devices, including cordless telephones and cellular radio telephones. without the consent of all parties to the communication. Existing law exempts from these provisions a public communications utility when the acts are for the construction, maintenance, or operation of the services of the public utility or are pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility, and also exempts telephonic communication systems used exclusively within a correctional facility, as specified.
This bill would increase the fine for this crime to not more than $3,500. additionally exempt from that prohibition a nonconfidential communication between a person or business and a current or former customer, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer, regarding their business relationship, including communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine not to exceed $2,500, by imprisonment in county jail for not more than one year or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment to, without the consent of both parties, intercept or receive and intentionally record, or assist in the interception or receipt and intentional recording of, a communication transmitted between 2 devices, including cordless telephones and cellular radio telephones.
This bill would increase the fine for this crime to not more than $3,500.
Existing law makes it a crime to intentionally and without consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrop upon or record the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device, except a radio. Existing law also makes evidence obtained as a result of eavesdropping upon or recording a confidential communication inadmissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding.
This bill would make nonsubstantive, technical changes to those provisions.
Existing law makes it a crime to intentionally and without consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrop upon or record the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device, except a radio. Existing law also makes evidence obtained as a result of eavesdropping upon or recording a confidential communication inadmissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding.
This bill would make nonsubstantive, technical changes to those provisions.
(a)Every person who, without the consent of all parties to a communication, intercepts or receives and intentionally records, or assists in the interception or reception and intentional recordation of, a communication transmitted between two cellular radio telephones, a cellular radio telephone and a landline telephone, two cordless telephones, a cordless telephone and a landline telephone, or a cordless telephone and a cellular radio telephone, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If the person has been convicted previously of a violation of this section or of Section 631, 632, 632.5, 632.6, or 636, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)A public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees, or agents thereof, when the acts otherwise prohibited are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct, or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility.
(2)The use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility.
(3)A telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
(4)A nonconfidential communication between a person or business and a current or former customer of the person or business, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer, regarding their business relationship, including, but not limited to, communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business.
(4)The initial 20 seconds of a telephonic communication between a business and a current or former customer, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer.
(c)As used in this section, each of the following terms have the following meaning:
(1)Cellular radio telephone means a wireless telephone authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidth reserved for cellular radio telephones.
(2)Cordless telephone means a two-way, low power communication system consisting of two parts, a base unit which connects to the public switched telephone network and a handset or remote unit, that are connected by a radio link and authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidths reserved for cordless telephones.
(3)Communication includes, but is not limited to, communications transmitted by voice, data, or image, including facsimile.
SEC. 2.Section 632.8 is added to the Penal Code, to read:632.8.(a)On January 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, the Department of Justice shall report to the Legislature the number of people charged with a crime under Section 632.7 during the preceding year.
(b)The report to the Legislature pursuant to this section shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(a)Every person who, without the consent of all parties to a communication, intercepts or receives and intentionally records, or assists in the interception or reception and intentional recordation of, a communication transmitted between two cellular radio telephones, a cellular radio telephone and a landline telephone, two cordless telephones, a cordless telephone and a landline telephone, or a cordless telephone and a cellular radio telephone, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding three two thousand five hundred dollars ($3,500), ($2,500), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If the person has been convicted previously of a violation of this section or of Section 631, 632, 632.5, 632.6, or 636, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)A public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees, or agents thereof, where when the acts otherwise prohibited are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct, or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility.
(2)The use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility.
(3)A telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
(4)A nonconfidential communication between a person or business and a current or former customer of the person or business, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer, regarding their business relationship, including, but not limited to, communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business.
(c)As used in this section, each of the following terms have the following meaning:
(1)Cellular radio telephone means a wireless telephone authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidth reserved for cellular radio telephones.
(2)Cordless telephone means a two-way, low power communication system consisting of two parts, a base unit which connects to the public switched telephone network and a handset or remote unit, that are connected by a radio link and authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidths reserved for cordless telephones.
(3)Communication includes, but is not limited to, communications transmitted by voice, data, or image, including facsimile.
(a)Every person who, without the consent of all parties to a communication, intercepts or receives and intentionally records, or assists in the interception or reception and intentional recordation of, a communication transmitted between two cellular radio telephones, a cellular radio telephone and a landline telephone, two cordless telephones, a cordless telephone and a landline telephone, or a cordless telephone and a cellular radio telephone, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two three thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), ($3,500), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If the person has been convicted previously of a violation of this section or of Section 631, 632, 632.5, 632.6, or 636, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)Any A public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees, or agents thereof, where the acts otherwise prohibited are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct, or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility.
(2)The use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility.
(3)Any A telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
(c)As used in this section, each of the following terms have the following meaning:
(1)Cellular radio telephone means a wireless telephone authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidth reserved for cellular radio telephones.
(2)Cordless telephone means a two-way, low power communication system consisting of two parts, a base unit which connects to the public switched telephone network and a handset or remote unit, that are connected by a radio link and authorized by the Federal Communications Commission to operate in the frequency bandwidths reserved for cordless telephones.
(3)Communication includes, but is not limited to, communications transmitted by voice, data, or image, including facsimile.
SECTION 1.Section 632 of the Penal Code is amended to read:632.(a)(1)A person who, intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrops upon or records the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device, except a radio, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or imprisonment in county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(2)If the person has previously been convicted of a violation of this section or Section 631, 632.5, 632.6, 632.7, or 636, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)For purposes of this section person means an individual, business entity, or other legal entity, and an individual acting, or purporting to act, for or on behalf of a government or subdivision of a government, whether federal, state, or local. Person excludes an individual known by all parties to a confidential communication to be overhearing or recording the communication.
(c)For purposes of this section Confidential communication means a communication carried on in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that a party to the communication desires the communication to be confined to the participating parties. Confidential communication excludes a communication made in a public gathering or in a legislative, judicial, executive, or administrative proceeding open to the public, or in any other circumstance in which the parties to the communication may reasonably expect that the communication may be overheard or recorded.
(d)Except as proof in an action or prosecution for violation of this section, no evidence obtained as a result of eavesdropping upon or recording a confidential communication in violation of this section shall be admissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding.
(e)This section does not apply (1) to any public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees or agents thereof, where the acts otherwise prohibited by this section are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility, or (2) to the use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of a public utility, or (3) to any telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
(f)This section does not apply to the use of hearing aids and similar devices, by a person afflicted with impaired hearing, for the purpose of overcoming the impairment to permit the hearing of sounds ordinarily audible to the human ear.
(a)Every (1)A person who, intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrops upon or records the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device, except a radio, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If
(2)If the person has previously been convicted of a violation of this section or Section 631, 632.5, 632.6, 632.7, or 636, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)The term person includes For purposes of this section person means an individual, business association, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, entity, or other legal entity, and an individual acting acting, or purporting to act act, for or on behalf of any a government or subdivision thereof, of a government, whether federal, state, or local, but local. Person excludes an individual known by all parties to a confidential communication to be overhearing or recording the communication.
(c)The term confidential For purposes of this section Confidential communication includes any means a communication carried on in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that any a party to the communication desires it the communication to be confined to the parties thereto, but participating parties. Confidential communication excludes a communication made in a public gathering or in any a legislative, judicial, executive executive, or administrative proceeding open to the public, or in any other circumstance in which the parties to the communication may reasonably expect that the communication may be overheard or recorded.
(d)Except as proof in an action or prosecution for violation of this section, no evidence obtained as a result of eavesdropping upon or recording a confidential communication in violation of this section shall be admissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding.
(e)This section does not apply (1) to any public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees or agents thereof, where the acts otherwise prohibited by this section are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility, or (2) to the use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of a public utility, or (3) to any telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
(f)This section does not apply to the use of hearing aids and similar devices, by persons a person afflicted with impaired hearing, for the purpose of overcoming the impairment to permit the hearing of sounds ordinarily audible to the human ear.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 28, 2015 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 28, 2015 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| May 11, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 11, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Assembly Rule 97. |
| May 7, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (May 5). |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 14, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 13, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 29. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 5, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 925
Page 2
Date of Hearing: May 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 925
(Low) – As Amended May 11, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Public Safety |
Vote: |
5 - 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill exempts the first 20 seconds of a telephonic communication between a person or business and a current or former customer from any illegal non-consensual recording prohibitions. Also requires the Department of Justice (DOJ), by January 1, 2017, to report to the Legislature the number of people charged with violating this section of law during the preceding year.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Moderate costs to DOJ in excess to $150,000 (GF) to capture this civil action from 58 different counties; the required information is not currently reported by local law enforcement agencies.
Potential reimbursable state mandated cost (GF) on county district attorneys to report the number of people charged with violating the law in a format yet to be developed by DOJ. If the cost of submitting the information by a county exceeds $10,000 in the largest 15 counties, this mandated cost will exceed $150,000.
COMMENTS:
Purpose
According to the author, "The legislature initially enacted
[the California Invasion of Privacy Act] CIPA in 1967 and amongst its
provisions, made it illegal to intentionally intercept or record
confidential communications by means of a telegraph, telephone or
other device under Penal Code 632. With the advent and
proliferation of cellular and cordless telephones, the legislature
updated CIPA by enacting Penal Code 632.7 which applies to mobile
phones. Specifically, it ensured that communications conducted
with a cellular device are not intentionally recorded without consent
of the parties. But unlike Penal Code 632, this section does
not distinguish between confidential and non-confidential calls.
As such, courts have been compelled by the plain language of Penal
Code 632.7 to require consent prior to recording any portion
of all calls made to persons on a mobile phone, regardless of
whether confidential information is discussed."
"Unfortunately,
this has led to illogical outcomes where calls to customers are legal
if they are on a land line but not if they’re on a mobile phone.
We have recently seen a number of examples of lawsuits filed based on
entirely routine and benign conduct. For example, one class action
alleged a violation of 632.7 based on the recording of a conversation
where the answering party stated that the caller had dialed the wrong
number and the call ends before any recording disclosure is given.
Although the conversation lasted only a few seconds and contained
no confidential or private information, plaintiffs sought
extensive damages under Section 632.7.
"AB
925 seeks to harmonize Penal Code 632 and 632.7 by creating a very
narrow exception for these non-confidential calls. It only
intends to capture the brief non-confidential communication between a
business and a customer prior to providing the recording disclosure.
Practically, this would include an introductory conversation to
identify the parties and purpose of the call."
"This bill will not remove the CIPA requirement to obtain the consent of a party prior to recording a confidential communication. AB 925’s limited language cleans up the arbitrary distinction between land lines and mobile phones for a very distinct type of call."
The committee may wish to delay date of the report to July 1, 2017 to allow ample time for local agencies to submit the necessary information to DOJ.
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro R. Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 925
Page 8
Date of Hearing: May 5, 2015
Counsel: Gabriel Caswell
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Bill Quirk, Chair
AB 925
(Low) – As Amended April 13, 2015
SUMMARY:
Exempts non-confidential communications between a person or business and a current or former customer regarding their business relationship from any illegal non-consensual recording prohibitions. Specifically, this bill: Provides an exception to the prohibition of calling a mobile phone and intentionally recording a telephonic communication without the consent of both parties for all non-confidential communications between a person or business and a current or former customer of the person or business, or a person reasonably believed to be a current or former customer, regarding their business relationship, including, but not limited to, communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business.
EXISTING LAW:
States that the Legislature hereby declares that advances in science and technology have led to the development of new devices and techniques for the purpose of eavesdropping upon private communications and that the invasion of privacy resulting from the continual and increasing use of such devices and techniques has created a serious threat to the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot be tolerated in a free and civilized society. The Legislature by this chapter intends to protect the right of privacy of the people of this state. The Legislature recognizes that law enforcement agencies have a legitimate need to employ modern listening devices and techniques in the investigation of criminal conduct and the apprehension of lawbreakers. Therefore, it is not the intent of the Legislature to place greater restraints on the use of listening devices and techniques by law enforcement agencies than existed prior to the effective date of this chapter. (Pen. Code, § 630.)
Provides that every person who, without the consent of all parties to a communication, intercepts or receives and intentionally records, or assists in the interception or reception and intentional recordation of, a communication transmitted between two cellular radio telephones, a cellular radio telephone and a landline telephone, two cordless telephones, a cordless telephone and a landline telephone, or a cordless telephone and a cellular radio telephone, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If the person has been convicted previously of a violation of specified unauthorized recording sections, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Pen. Code, § 632.7.) Exempts the following from these provisions:
Any public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees, or agents thereof, where the acts otherwise prohibited are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct, or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility.
The use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of the public utility.
Any telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
Provides that every person who, intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrops upon or records the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device, except a radio, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. If the person has previously been convicted of a violation of specified eavesdropping sections, the person shall be punished by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Pen. Code, § 632.)
Specifies that the term "person" includes an individual, business association, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, or other legal entity, and an individual acting or purporting to act for or on behalf of any government or subdivision thereof, whether federal, state, or local, but excludes an individual known by all parties to a confidential communication to be overhearing or recording the communication. (Pen. Code, § 632, subd. (b).)
States that the term "confidential communication" includes any communication carried on in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that any party to the communication desires it to be confined to the parties thereto, but excludes a communication made in a public gathering or in any legislative, judicial, executive or administrative proceeding open to the public, or in any other circumstance in which the parties to the communication may reasonably expect that the communication may be overheard or recorded. (Pen. Code, § 632, subd. (c).)
Provides that except as proof in an action or prosecution for violation of this section, no evidence obtained as a result of eavesdropping upon or recording a confidential communication in violation of this section shall be admissible in any judicial, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding. (Pen. Code, § 632, subd. (d).)
States that this section does not apply to: (Pen. Code, § 632, subd. (e).)
Any public utility engaged in the business of providing communications services and facilities, or to the officers, employees or agents thereof, where the acts otherwise prohibited by this section are for the purpose of construction, maintenance, conduct or operation of the services and facilities of the public utility; or
To the use of any instrument, equipment, facility, or service furnished and used pursuant to the tariffs of a public utility; or
To any telephonic communication system used for communication exclusively within a state, county, city and county, or city correctional facility.
Provides that this section does not apply to the use of hearing aids and similar devices, by persons afflicted with impaired hearing, for the purpose of overcoming the impairment to permit the hearing of sounds ordinarily audible to the human ear. (Pen. Code, § 632, (f).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: According to the author, "The legislature initially enacted CIPA in 1967 and amongst its provisions, made it illegal to intentionally intercept or record confidential communications by means of a telegraph, telephone or other device under Penal Code 632. With the advent and proliferation of cellular and cordless telephones, the legislature updated CIPA by enacting Penal Code 632.7 which applies to mobile phones. Specifically, it ensured that communications conducted with a cellular device are not intentionally recorded without consent of the parties. But unlike Penal Code 632, this section does not distinguish between confidential and non-confidential calls. As such, courts have been compelled by the plain language of Penal Code 632.7 to require consent prior to recording any portion of all calls made to persons on a mobile phone, regardless of whether confidential information is discussed.
"Unfortunately, this has led to illogical outcomes where calls
to customers are legal if they are on a land line but not if they’re
on a mobile phone. We have recently seen a number of examples
of lawsuits filed based on entirely routine and benign conduct. For
example, one class action alleged a violation of 632.7 based on the
recording of a conversation where the answering party stated that the
caller had dialed the wrong number and the call ends before any
recording disclosure is given. Although the conversation lasted only
a few seconds and contained no confidential or private
information, plaintiffs sought extensive damages under Section
632.7.
"AB 925 seeks to harmonize
Penal Code 632 and 632.7 by creating a very narrow exception for
these non-confidential calls. It only intends to capture the
brief non-confidential communication between a business and a
customer prior to providing the recording disclosure.
Practically, this would include an introductory conversation to
identify the parties and purpose of the call.
"This bill will not remove the CIPA requirement to obtain the consent of a party prior to recording a confidential communication. AB 925’s limited language cleans up the arbitrary distinction between land lines and mobile phones for a very distinct type of call."
Creates Inconsistent Definitions of Confidential Communications: The author argues that this bill corrects an inconsistency in the law between land lines and mobile phones. California Penal Code § 632 was passed in 1967. That section specifies that confidential communications cannot be recorded without the consent of both parties to the communication. Pen. Code, § 632, subd. (c) defines a "confidential communication" as follows:
The term "confidential communication" includes any communication carried on in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that any party to the communication desires it to be confined to the parties thereto, but excludes a communication made in a public gathering or in any legislative, judicial, executive or administrative proceeding open to the public, or in any other circumstance in which the parties to the communication may reasonably expect that the communication may be overheard or recorded.
California Penal Code, § 632.7 was passed in 1992 as a companion piece to the original statute. Penal Code, § 632.7 applies generally to mobile phones, and cordless land lines. This section does not make a distinction between confidential or non-confidential communications and merely states that all communications between persons on these devices may not be recorded without the consent of both parties to the communication.
This bill seeks to apply an exception to the prohibition against eavesdropping in Penal Code, § 632.7 for communications from businesses to current and former customers which are "non-confidential." The bill applies a new definition for content to communications that are non-confidential in nature. Unlike the Penal Code § 632 definition, the proposed definition is much more specific in terms of what information is deemed non-confidential. The bill proposes the following language as non-confidential and subject to recording without the consent of consumers. The definition includes communications:
"regarding their business relationship, including, but not limited to, communications regarding billing, provisioning, maintaining, or operating the product or service provided by the person or business."
The new
definition includes quite a wide range of communications that would
likely be deemed confidential under the existing definition as
applied to wired telephones under the 1967 definition. Specifically,
communications regarding billing information would likely contain
information related to account balances, personal information, social
security numbers, account histories, and credit report information.
Additionally information regarding "provisioning, maintaining,
and operating" could easily contain information such as the
health history or customers if they are speaking with their health
insurance provider. The author and proponents have argued that the
new proposed definition is narrowly tailored, however they
specifically say that the non-confidential communication "includes"
but is "not limited to" the specific examples they provide.
Wireless Land Lines: This bill seeks to amend California Penal Code § 632.7. Pen. Code, § 632.7 not only covers mobile telephones, but it also covers all wireless telephones, including those that are connected to a land line.
Possible One-Way Application: The opponents of the proposed legislation argue that this bill is applied in a one-way fashion. The exception to the eavesdropping requirement would apply to a person or business who is contacting a current or former customer. However, the current or former customer would still be subject to criminal penalties for recording conversations with the business without the consent of both parties. Opponents have argued that businesses will be in possession of all recordings and that many businesses have selectively released recordings in the past that assist them in litigation, but withhold recordings of customers that would further the consumer's arguments. The language of the legislation is vague on this issue, and if it is not the author's intent that the bill only apply in a one-way manner then additional clarifying language should be added.
Argument in Support: According to TechAmerica, "Originally enacted in 1967, the [California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA)] made it illegal to intentionally intercept or record confidential communications by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device under Penal Code 632. However, with the advent and proliferation of cellular telephones, the legislature attempted to update the CIPA by enacting Penal code 632.7 which applies specifically to mobile phones. Unfortunately, while mobile devices were added to the Penal Code to ensure that communications conducted with a cellular telephone were applied similarly to landlines, code section 632.7 failed to distinguish between confidential and non-confidential calls. As such, courts have been compelled by the plain language of Penal Code 632.7 to require consent prior to recording "any" portion of "all" calls made to persons on a mobile phone, regardless of whether confidential information is discussed.
"As a result, this distinction has led to a number of lawsuits
based on whether an innocuous business service call is placed to a
customer on a landline or a mobile phone. AB 925 seeks to harmonize
Penal Code 632 and 632.7 by creating a very narrow exception for
non-confidential communication between a business and a customer
prior to providing the recording disclosure. This bill will not
remove the CIPA requirement to obtain the consent of a party prior to
recording a confidential communication."
Argument in Opposition: According to the Consumer Attorneys of California, "AB 925 would reverse long standing privacy protection law to allow businesses and individuals to secretly record phone conversations with current or former customers without their knowledge or consent.
"AB 925 robs California citizens of the important right to know when someone records their telephone calls. This bill extinguishes what Assemblyman Jesse M. Unruh advocated for decades ago: all party consent in California. In 1967, the California Legislature enacted a broad, protective invasion-of-privacy statute in response to what it viewed as a serious and increasing threat to the confidentiality of private communications resulting from then recent advances in science and technology that had led to the development of new devices and techniques for eavesdropping upon and recording such private communications. (Stats.1967, ch. 1509, § 1, pp. 3584–3588, enacting Pen.Code, §§ 630–637.2). In 1992, AB 2465 (Connelly) added § 632.7 to the penal code to expand these privacy protections to include cellular telephones. This legislative intent is even more applicable in today’s world as privacy and information protections are of the highest concern to consumers.
"This bill contradicts well-established, decades old law that has been unanimously affirmed by the California Supreme Court. Current law requires that all parties to a phone conversation consent to the recording of the conversation. Penal Code § 632.7. This is commonly referred to as “two-party consent.” The "California Supreme Court unanimously held:
“We believe that California must be viewed as having a strong and continuing interest in the full and vigorous application of the provisions of Section 632 prohibiting the recording of telephone conversations without the knowledge or consent of all parties to the conversation.” Kearney v. Salomon Smith Barney, Inc. 39 Cal.4th 95, 125 (2006).
"Under Penal Code § 632.7, conversations can be recorded; however, a party cannot secretly record the conversation without first informing all parties that the conversation is being recorded so a person has the opportunity to end the call and avoid invasion of privacy. Businesses currently comply by simply announcing at the beginning of the call, “this call may be recorded.” This routine announcement is sufficient to establish notice and consent for the recording or monitoring of the conversation.
"AB 925 will allow businesses to secretly record telephone calls and selectively use these recordings when it benefits their business, not the consumer. In 2006, California Supreme Court discussed this very issue in Kearney.
"Companies may utilize such undisclosed recording to further their economic interests—perhaps in selectively disclosing recordings when disclosure serves the company's interest, but not volunteering the recordings' existence (or quickly destroying them) when they would be detrimental to the company." Id. at 124.
"For example, if a hotel and its guest dispute the room price or other terms of a reservation and the customer’s recollection is correct, the business could decide not to produce the recording and the customer would not object since the customer has no knowledge that the conversation was ever recorded. On the other hand, if the business’s recollection is correct, it could produce produce the recording since it now benefits the company’s financial interest.
"Lenders and debt collection companies have the most to gain as AB 925 will allow them to legally record calls, without consent, to hold customers to "their word" when it benefits them. These companies have been the subject of much of the litigation in this area. Most if not all of these calls involved personal and confidential financial information. Many debt collection companies have engaged in such practices, and under current law customers whose calls are recorded without their consent have a right bring suit. AB 925 would effectively legalize this practice leaving consumers no remedy for this invasion of privacy and at risk for additional harm that may follow.
"Without informing consumers that their conversation is recorded, consumers are left in the dark as to what personal, private information is collected or how it is used. They have no knowledge that their transactional details are being recorded, which can and often does include private financial, personal, and sometimes even HIPPA protected medical information. For example, 1-800 Contacts illegally recorded, without notification or warning, their customer’s confidential medical, financial, billing, and address information. Anyone who accessed this information would be able to access the customer’s medical record. In another similar case, the plaintiff discussed his erectile dysfunction with Humana and they secretly recorded the call without his consent. The court found that “defendant’s line of business and the sensitive medical information that is likely to be discussed between Defendant’s representatives and its customers” supported plaintiff’s claim. Perea v. Humana Pharmacy, Case No. 12-1881-JST (ANx) (C.D. Cal. 2013). Under AB 925, this practice would be legalized without any knowledge of the consumer.
"Under AB 925, not only would consumers be unaware that
the call is being recorded, but they also have no way of knowing who
would have access to their information. Although
consumers may believe that they are dealing with a business in
California, many businesses now outsource customer service functions
to third-party call centers that may be located elsewhere in the
United States or in other countries. Not only will customers
unknowingly allow their credit card or other personal information to
be recorded by the company they are doing business with, they may
also be giving their information to an unknown outsourced
third-party."
Prior Legislation: AB 2465 (Connelly), Statutes of 1992, Chapter 298, created Pen. Code, § 637.2 which prohibited the recording of communications on wireless telephones and mobile phones as specified.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Chamber of Commerce
TechAmerica
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Competes
California Federation of Teachers
California Nurses Association
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Communication Workers of America, AFL-CIO District 9
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Watchdog
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Consumers Union
Courage Campaign
Elder Financial Protection Network
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Older Women's League
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
Public Advocates Inc.
United Fruit and Commercial Workers
University of San Diego Center for Public Interest Law
Utility Reform Network
World Privacy Forum
Analysis Prepared by:
Gabriel Caswell / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):