AB 2726: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: consumption-based accounting.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-02
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases.
This bill would require the state board to establish and maintain an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis, as specified.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases.
This bill would require the state board to establish and maintain an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis. basis, as specified.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases.
This bill would require the state board to establish and maintain an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis.
Existing law provides for the establishment of an Independent System Operator (ISO) as a nonprofit public benefit corporation, and requires the ISO to ensure efficient use and reliable operation of the electrical transmission grid consistent with achieving planning and operating reserve criteria no less stringent than those established by the Western Electricity Coordinating Council and the North American Electric Reliability Council. Existing law requires the ISO to conduct its operations consistent with applicable state and federal laws and consistent with the interests of the people of the state. Existing law additionally requires the ISO to manage the transmission grid and related energy markets in a manner that is consistent with specified principles.This bill would require the ISO to develop and administer dispatch rules that apply the cost of compliance with Californias market-based compliance mechanism for limiting emissions of greenhouse gases to all electrical generation located outside of California that serves the demand of customers in California.Existing law requires the ISO to consult and coordinate with appropriate state and local agencies to ensure that it operates in furtherance of state law regarding consumer and environmental protection.This bill would require the ISO to consult and coordinate with the State Air Resources Board in the development and implementation of the dispatch rules.Existing law provides for the establishment of an Independent System Operator (ISO) as a nonprofit public benefit corporation, and requires the ISO to ensure efficient use and reliable operation of the electrical transmission grid consistent with achieving planning and operating reserve criteria no less stringent than those established by the Western Electricity Coordinating Council and the North American Electric Reliability Council. Existing law requires the ISO to conduct its operations consistent with applicable state and federal laws and consistent with the interests of the people of the state. Existing law additionally requires the ISO to manage the transmission grid and related energy markets in a manner that is consistent with specified principles.
This bill would require the ISO to develop and administer dispatch rules that apply the cost of compliance with Californias market-based compliance mechanism for limiting emissions of greenhouse gases to all electrical generation located outside of California that serves the demand of customers in California.
Existing law requires the ISO to consult and coordinate with appropriate state and local agencies to ensure that it operates in furtherance of state law regarding consumer and environmental protection.
This bill would require the ISO to consult and coordinate with the State Air Resources Board in the development and implementation of the dispatch rules.
Existing law, the Transit District Law, authorizes the establishment of the Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District. This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.Existing law, the Transit District Law, authorizes the establishment of the Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that recent academic studies have shown that measures of carbon dioxide accounting differ substantially when computed on a consumption basis, which takes into account emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within a region rather than on a production basis, giving a more accurate picture of a regions contribution to the emissions of greenhouse gases.
(b)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to provide the state with a more accurate picture of emissions of greenhouse gases attributable to California by requiring the State Air Resources Board to establish and update an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis.
(2)It is not the intent of the Legislature to require the use of the consumption-based accounting basis to establish the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limits pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code) or any enforceable standards for emissions of greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 38511 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:38511.(a)To provide the state with more accurate information on the states effort in reducing its contribution to the global emissions of greenhouse gases, the state board shall establish, and update every three years, an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis that accounts for emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within the state and excludes emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products produced in the state that are consumed outside the state.
(b)The state board shall not use the inventory of greenhouse gas emissions required pursuant to subdivision (a) for the purposes of subdivision (c) of Section 38562. any of the following:
(1)Subdivision (c) of Section 38562.
(2)Section 398.4 of the Public Utilities Code.
(3)For any purpose relating to ensuring compliance with Section 399.15 or Section 454.52 of the Public Utilities Code.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that recent academic studies have shown that measures of carbon dioxide accounting differ substantially when computed on a consumption basis, which takes into account emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within a region rather than on a production basis, giving a more accurate picture of a regions contribution to the emissions of greenhouse gases.
(b)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to provide the state with a more accurate picture of emissions of greenhouse gases attributable to California by requiring the State Air Resources Board to establish and update an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis.
(2)It is not the intent of the Legislature to require the use of the consumption-based accounting basis to establish the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limits pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code) or any enforceable standards for emissions of greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 38511 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:38511.(a)To provide the state with more accurate information on the states effort in reducing its contribution to the global emissions of greenhouse gases, the state board shall establish, and update every three years, an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis that accounts for emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within the state and excludes emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products produced in the state that are consumed outside the state.
(b)The state board shall not use the inventory of greenhouse gas emissions required pursuant to subdivision (a) for the purposes of subdivision (c) of Section 38562.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that recent academic studies have shown that measures of carbon dioxide accounting differ substantially when computed on a consumption basis, which takes into account emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within a region rather than on a production basis, giving a more accurate picture of a regions contribution to the emissions of greenhouse gases.
(b)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to provide the state with a more accurate picture of emissions of greenhouse gases attributable to California by requiring the State Air Resources Board to establish and update an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis.
(2)It is not the intent of the Legislature to require the use of the consumption-based accounting basis to establish the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limits pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code) or any enforceable standards for emissions of greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 38511 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:38511.To provide the state with more accurate information on the states effort in reducing its contribution to the global emissions of greenhouse gases, the state board shall establish, and update every three years, an inventory of emissions of greenhouse gases on a consumption-based accounting basis that accounts for emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products consumed within the state and excludes emissions of greenhouse gases associated with products produced in the state that are consumed outside the state.
SECTION 1.Section 351 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:351.(a)The Independent System Operator shall develop and administer dispatch rules that apply the cost of compliance with Californias market-based compliance mechanism for limiting emissions of greenhouse gases to all electrical generation located outside of California that serves the demand of customers in California. The rules shall do all of the following:(1)Apply to any generation directly dispatched by the Independent System Operator through wholesale markets it manages, including the energy imbalance market.(2)Prevent leakage and resource shuffling by capturing the impacts of any secondary dispatch of resources attributable to electricity usage by customers in California.(3)Be consistent with the accounting and compliance requirements administered by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code).(b)The Independent System Operator shall consult and coordinate with the State Air Resources Board in the development and implementation of the dispatch rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (a).(a)The Independent System Operator shall develop and administer dispatch rules that apply the cost of compliance with Californias market-based compliance mechanism for limiting emissions of greenhouse gases to all electrical generation located outside of California that serves the demand of customers in California. The rules shall do all of the following:
(1)Apply to any generation directly dispatched by the Independent System Operator through wholesale markets it manages, including the energy imbalance market.
(2)Prevent leakage and resource shuffling by capturing the impacts of any secondary dispatch of resources attributable to electricity usage by customers in California.
(3)Be consistent with the accounting and compliance requirements administered by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)The Independent System Operator shall consult and coordinate with the State Air Resources Board in the development and implementation of the dispatch rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (a).
SECTION 1.Section 24503 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:24503.District means a transit district formed under this part. Board means the board of directors of a district.District means a transit district formed under this part; board part. Board means the board of directors of a district.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 25, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 2, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 24, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Apr 17, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Apr 5, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on U. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 4, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 21, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Mar 20, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on U. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on U. & E. and NAT. RES. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Bay Area Air Quality Management District | * Support | Apr 23, 2018 |
| Cal CCA | * Against | Apr 23, 2018 |
| The Utility Reform Network | ** Support | Apr 3, 2018 |
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2726
Author:(Levine) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2018
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 7 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to establish, and update every three years, a "consumption-based" inventory of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires ARB to establish an inventory of GHG emissions on a consumption-based accounting basis that accounts for GHG emissions associated with products consumed within the state and excludes GHG emissions associated with products produced in the state that are consumed outside the state.
- Prohibits ARB from using this consumption-based inventory for:
- Establishing the GHG emissions limits under AB 32, (Núñez and Pavley), Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006.
- The state’s current GHG inventory developed under AB 32.
- The renewable portfolio standard.
FISCAL EFFECT:
First-year ARB costs of approximately $3 million (including 12 PY and $750,000 in contracts) to begin inventory development and accounting methods for different product types. Second-year and third-year costs of approximately $5 to $5.9 million (27 PY and $800,000 in contracts) and ongoing annual costs of $300,000 in contracts.
ARB anticipates a heavier workload after the first year, which will be spent gaining an understanding of the lay of the land with respect to quantification methodologies, data sources on imports, exports, relationships with other agencies that hold the relevant data, public workshops, and oversight of the initial contracts. This estimate is based on primarily on ARB’s experience implementing the Low Carbon Fuel Standard, which is a life-cycle for imports and produced fuels.
COMMENTS:
Background and Purpose. There are two conflicting ways of measuring GHG emissions: production-based (sometimes referred to as territorial-based) or consumption-based. For California, production-based emissions take place within state territory. Consumption-based emissions encompass those emissions from final consumption and those caused by the production of the state’s imports. This means the importing state takes responsibility for emissions related to production of the exports.
ARB's cap-and-trade regulation applies to large industrial facilities and electricity generators emitting more than 25,000 metric tons of CO2 equivalent per year, as well as distributors of fuels, including gasoline, diesel, and natural gas. Large emitters of GHG are required to report emissions annually to ARB under the mandatory reporting requirement (MRR). The MRR supports ARB's GHG emissions inventory and AB 32 regulatory programs. ARB's emissions inventory corresponds to its regulatory authority. ARB has no direct authority to regulate emissions from sources outside California.
The current inventory and regulatory measures are generally production-based. However, ARB does account for GHG emissions associated with electricity and transportation fuels imported into California. For unspecified sources of electricity delivered to California, the MRR includes a default formula for estimating GHG emissions. If imported electricity is not directly delivered to California or cannot be tied via ownership or contract rights to a specified source, the importer must use ARB’s unspecified electricity emission factor to estimate GHG emissions. GHG emissions associated with transportation fuels are subject to a more specific and complex carbon- intensity rating under the LCFS regulation, which includes direct and indirect GHG emissions, including land use changes caused by production of biofuels.
According to the author:
We should create a full-economy consumption-based accounting of California's GHG emissions. This would include sectors that are not part of the cap and trade program, such as agriculture, as well as out-of-state production in sectors that are under cap and trade, such as oil refining. This measure would include all imports, and would exclude all exports. It would not be intended to be a device for enforcing policy, but rather a scorecard for honestly assessing how well the state is reducing its overall contribution to climate change.
This bill requires ARB to develop the consumption-based information, but is unclear if there is a current demand for the information.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Al Muratsuchi, Acting Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2726 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 5, 2018
SUBJECT: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: consumption-based accounting
SUMMARY: Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to establish a "consumption-based" inventory of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires ARB to adopt a statewide GHG emissions limit equivalent to 1990 levels by 2020 and to adopt rules and regulations to achieve maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective GHG emission reductions.
- Requires ARB, in adopting rules and regulations to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective GHG emissions reductions, to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 2020 statewide limit no later than December 31, 2030.
- Requires ARB to adopt regulations to require the reporting and verification of statewide GHG emissions, including monitoring and annual reporting of GHG emissions sources, beginning with the sources that contribute most to statewide emissions. ARB has adopted a Mandatory Reporting Regulation (MRR) for operators of certain facilities that directly emit GHGs, suppliers of certain fuels and carbon dioxide, electric power entities, verifiers of GHG emissions data reports and offset project data reports submitted pursuant to the cap-and-trade regulation, and verification bodies.
- Authorizes ARB to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emission limits for sources or categories of sources that emit GHG emissions, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, to comply with GHG reduction regulations, once specified conditions are met. Pursuant to this authority, ARB has adopted a cap-and-trade regulation which applies to large industrial facilities and electricity generators emitting more than 25,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent per year, as well as distributors of fuels, including gasoline, diesel and natural gas.
- Pursuant to Executive Order S-01-07, sets a statewide goal to reduce the carbon intensity (CI) of California's transportation fuels by at least 10% by 2020. Pursuant to AB 32, ARB adopted a Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) regulation in 2009 to implement this goal. The LCFS attributes CI values to a variety of fuels based on direct and indirect GHG emissions, including land use changes caused by production of biofuels.
- Requires the CEC, in consultation with ARB, to adopt a methodology for the calculation of GHG emissions intensity for each purchase of electricity by a retail supplier to serve its retail customers, and requires each retail supplier, including an electrical corporation, local publicly-owned electric utility, electric service provider, and community choice aggregator, to disclose both the GHG emissions intensity of any electricity portfolio offered to its retail customers and the CEC's calculation of the GHG emissions intensity associated with all statewide retail electricity sales.
- Requires ARB to prepare and approve a scoping plan, on or before January 1, 2009, and once every five years thereafter, for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions from sources or categories of sources of GHGs by 2020.
THIS BILL requires ARB to establish, and update every three years, an inventory of GHG emissions on a consumption-based accounting basis that accounts for GHG emissions associated with products consumed within the state and excludes GHG emissions associated with products produced in the state that are consumed outside the state.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's statement:
Reducing California's contribution to climate change requires more than reducing GHG emissions from inside California. We buy all sorts of goods from out of state whose production generates GHGs. While an effort is made to account for emissions from out-of-state electricity (and, to some extent, transportation fuels), the GHG impact of imported goods are not counted in the state’s reduction goals. Just as with carbon offsets, real change depends on “additionality”, or in this case what might be called “subtractionality”: is a reduction of GHG emissions from one source actually reducing worldwide GHG emissions or is it just moving emissions to another location?
We should create a full-economy consumption-based accounting of California's GHG emissions. This would include sectors that are not part of the cap and trade program, such as agriculture, as well as out-of-state production in sectors that are under cap and trade, such as oil refining. This measure would include all imports, and would exclude all exports. It would not be intended to be a device for enforcing policy, but rather a scorecard for honestly assessing how well the state is reducing its overall contribution to climate change. Ideally, such as scorecard would be calculated by an entity that is not politically invested in the answer – the equivalent of the Congressional Budget Office for California's climate policy.
- Consumption-based vs. production-based. ARB's cap-and-trade regulation applies to large industrial facilities and electricity generators emitting more than 25,000 metric tons of CO2 equivalent per year, as well as distributors of fuels, including gasoline, diesel, and natural gas. Large emitters of GHG are required to report emissions annually to ARB under the MRR. The MRR supports ARB's GHG emissions inventory and AB 32 regulatory programs. ARB's emissions inventory corresponds to its regulatory authority. ARB has no direct authority to regulate emissions from sources outside California.
The current inventory and regulatory measures are generally production-based. However, ARB does account for GHG emissions associated with electricity and transportation fuels imported into California. For unspecified sources of electricity delivered to California, the MRR includes a default formula for estimating GHG emissions. If imported electricity is not directly delivered to California and/or cannot be tied via ownership or contract rights to a specified source, the importer must use ARB’s unspecified electricity emission factor to estimate GHG emissions. GHG emissions associated with transportation fuels are subject to a more specific and complex carbon intensity rating under the LCFS regulation, which includes direct and indirect GHG emissions, including land use changes caused by production of biofuels.
This bill calls for a consumption-based inventory, apparently as an additional informational tool, outside of the regulatory structure of AB 32. Accounting for GHG emissions according to consumption involves some technical challenges, as illustrated by ARB's work to account for imported electricity and transportation fuels. The bill asks for accounting for "products" consumed within California. While the bill does not specify the scope of emission sources or level of detail required, accurately rating all products seems a very complex undertaking. For example, consumer electronics and appliances are a significant fraction of products imported from Asia. An accurate accounting would consider not only final production, but also the origin and production of parts, which may be difficult to identify, and transportation emissions, which would vary by method and destination. Averages and estimates could be used, at the expense of accuracy, to make preparing the inventory more feasible.
If, as the author and proponents indicate, the consumption-based inventory is intended to be independently-prepared and is not intended for enforcement purposes or to replace ARB's current inventory, it may be more appropriate for the Legislative Analyst's Office or an academic institution prepare the inventory.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Severin Borenstein, Professor, Haas School of Business, UC Berkeley
Opposition
California Community Choice Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: April 4, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2726 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2018
SUBJECT: Independent System Operator: dispatch rules
SUMMARY: Requires the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) to develop and administer dispatch rules that apply the cost of compliance with California’s market-based compliance mechanism for limiting emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) to all electrical generation located outside of California that serves the demand of customers in California. Specifically, this bill directs CAISO dispatch rules to:
- Apply to any generation directly dispatched by the CAISO through wholesale markets it manages, including the energy imbalance market;
- Prevent leakage and resource shuffling by capturing the impacts of any secondary dispatch of resources attributable to electricity usage by customers in California; and
- Be consistent with the accounting and compliance requirements administered by the State Air Resources Board (CARB) under AB 32.
EXISTING LAW:
- Recognizes the CAISO as a nonprofit, public benefit corporation; directs the governor to appoint its five-member governing board subject to confirmation by the Senate; and requires the CAISO to:
- Ensure efficient use and reliable operation of the transmission grid consistent with achievement of planning and operating reserve criteria no less stringent than those established by the Western Electricity Coordinating Council and the North American Electric Reliability Council; and
- Conduct its operations consistent with applicable state and federal laws and to manage the transmission grid and related energy markets consistent with the interests of the people of the state. (Public Utilities Code 345 et seq.)
- Ensure efficient use and reliable operation of the transmission grid consistent with achievement of planning and operating reserve criteria no less stringent than those established by the Western Electricity Coordinating Council and the North American Electric Reliability Council; and
- Requires CARB to account for GHG from all electricity consumed in the state, including transmission and distribution line losses from electricity generated within the state or imported from outside the state and specifically applies the requirement to all retail sellers of electricity, including load-serving entities. (Health & Safety Code § 38530 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal and will be referred to the Appropriations Committee for its review of the fiscal effect of this bill. It is important to note however that the Appropriations Committee limits its analysis to the impact on overall state agency impacts and cannot assess the impacts of policy on the costs of electricity or gas service to ratepayers.
BACKGROUND:
The CAISO – The CAISO is one of nine independent system or regional transmission organizations (ISOs and RTOs) in North America. Although transmission in California is interconnected across 14 western states, British Columbia, Alberta, and a portion of Baja California, the CAISO is the only balancing authority (BA)[1] that operates competitive wholesale electricity markets. Its reach includes approximately 80 percent of California and a small portion of Nevada and is one of 38 BAs in the West. Except for RTOs like the CAISO, BAs are generally vertically integrated with each entity managing the electricity that flows across its transmission lines and managing generation largely through bilateral contracts.
Energy Imbalance Market – The California ISO’s Western Energy Imbalance Market (EIM) is a real-time, bulk power trading market which includes several BAs from around the west. The EIM does not manage the transmission system of participants but offers what is basically a last minute market for BAs to buy and sell surplus generation. EIM’s advanced market systems automatically find the lowest-cost energy to serve real-time customer demand across a wide geographic area. Utilities maintain control over their assets and remain responsible for balancing requirements while sharing the cost benefits the market produces for participants.
EIM Leakage – Although the EIM has enhanced grid reliability and generated cost savings for its participants, its formation has triggered a GHG compliance issue identified by CARB in 2016. The agency identified a gap in emissions reported to CARB through EIM-related reporting as compared with emissions that are actually experienced by the atmosphere due to California electricity consumption served through EIM imports. Imported power from entities identified by the CAISO model reflected only a portion of emissions associated with serving California load. This undercounting of GHG emissions is called “leakage” and meant a reduction in emissions of GHGs within the state that was offset by an increase in emissions of GHGs outside the state due to California regulation.
In 2016 CARB adopted regulations with an interim solution compliance obligation on the electric distribution utilities and generators. Work began with the CAISO to identify a long-term solution which will result in a modification of the CAISO’s FERC tariff for the EIM. The CAISO developed a policy initiative, has held workshops, and taken stakeholder comment. The process continues.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. The State of California has committed to significant reductions in GHG emissions, and achieving these reductions requires accurate accounting of GHG emissions. Any attribution of GHG emissions should reflect real-world differences in order to enable accurate compliance with regulatory requirements. This effort should include statutory requirements to optimally achieve this end, including for the Energy Imbalance Market and secondary dispatch.
- Same, But Different. For the electricity sector, responsibility for compliance with the GHG emissions compliance program falls on electricity generators. This bill however adds a somewhat redundant but distinctly different compliance requirement directly on the CAISO the necessity of which is not apparent. The CAISO facilitates compliance with AB 32 by the generators that dispatch in its markets.
The CAISO has recognized the EIM compliance issue and is working with CARB, albeit somewhat slowly, to identify a solution. Given that both entities recognize the issue and are working toward a solution, the need for this bill is not apparent.
In support of this bill TURN opines that “[E]xisting state law requires the State Air Resources Board to implement the state’s Cap-and-Trade program but does not obligate CAISO to incorporate GHG emissions into the operation of the day ahead, real-time and energy imbalance markets. AB 2726 is intended to apply this obligation to CAISO in a manner that accounts for the impact of California customer demand on total GHG emissions and prevents both leakage and resource shuffling.”
However, the impact of placing a statutory obligation directly on the CAISO is unnecessary given that acknowledge the issue and are working toward a solution with stakeholders and CARB. Moreover the mandate could have far-reaching implications on the current AB 32 regulatory framework. - Constitutional Concerns. Any state legislation directing the CAISO to modify its dispatch rules may intrude on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction over the sale of electric energy at wholesale in interstate commerce. Any state legislation requiring that first deliverers of electricity resources assume compliance responsibility for secondary emissions may raise questions about whether the state law discriminates against resources located outside of the state California in relation to resources located within the state of California. Such a requirement may also raise questions about whether the state law creates an excessive burden on interstate commerce under the dormant commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution. Thus, AB 2726 could put California’s GHG accounting and compliance rules at risk rather than preserve its integrity. Given that the CAISO and CARB are committed to resolving the issue through regulations and the FERC tariff, it seems unnecessary to create the circumstances for these issues to be raised.
- Double Referral. This bill has also been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee. Should it be approved, the committee’s action should reflect this double-referral.
- Prior Legislation. AB 79 (Levine, 2017) Required the ARB to update, by January 1, 2019, its inputs or methodology for determining the emissions associated with unspecified sources of power and distinguish between sources imported into California, and sources originating within California. Status: Vetoed.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The Utility Reform Network
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kellie Smith / U. & E. /
A balancing authority is the responsible entity that integrates electric generation plans ahead of time, maintains load-interchange-generation balance within a geographic area, and supports interconnection frequency in real time. Balancing authorities are typically a utility but can also be an RTO or a federal entity like the Bonneville Power Authority. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):