AB 969: Collective bargaining: Legislature.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-21
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on P.E. & R. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Freddie Rodriguez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 969 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
SUBJECT: Collective bargaining: Legislature
SUMMARY: Establishes the Legislature Employer-Employee Relations Act (LEERA) that would grant collective bargaining rights to certain employees of the Legislature; thereby, governing the employer-employee relationship, and confers certain rights to these employees regarding joining an employee organization, and rights to the employee organization representing these employees, among other provisions. Specifically, this bill:
- Is substantially and similarly modeled after provisions provided for in several existing public employer-employee relations statutes, but made applicable to each House (i.e., the Assembly and the Senate) of the Legislature.
Provisions contained in the LEERA include rights, obligations, and limitations of individuals and parties involved in a collective bargaining and representation process for the Legislature and legislative employees, as defined. More specifically, these provisions:
2) Define the following terms:
- “Board” to mean the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB).
b) “Employee of the Legislature” or “employee” to mean any employee of either House of the Legislature, but excepts from this definition, Members and appointed officers of the Legislature such as the Secretary of the Senate and the Chief Clerk of the Assembly, department or office leaders such as chiefs-of-staffs, staff directors, and chief consultants.
c) “Employee organization” to mean any organization that includes employees of the Legislature and that, among one its primary purposes, is to represent these employees in their relations with the Legislature.
d) “Legislature” or “employer” to mean the Assembly and the Senate, except that for purposes of bargaining and meeting and conferring in good faith, mean the Speaker of the Assembly and the President pro Tempore of the Senate, or their designated representatives, acting with the authorization of their respective houses.
e) “Maintenance of membership” to mean all employees who voluntarily are, or voluntarily become, members of a recognized employee organization must remain good-standing members of that organization for a period as agreed to by the parties pursuant to a memorandum of understanding (MOU), as provided. This definition also provides that a maintenance of membership provision does not apply to any employee who withdraws from the employee organization within 30 days prior to the expiration of the MOU, and sends a signed withdrawal letter to the employee organization and a copy to the State Controller’s office.
f) “Mediation” to mean effort by an impartial third party to assist in reconciling a dispute regarding wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between representatives of the public agency and the recognized employee organization or organizations through interpretation, suggestion and advice.
g) “Recognized employee organization” to mean an employee organization that has been recognized by the Legislature as the exclusive representative of the employees in an appropriate unit.
3) Provides that any person who willfully resists, prevents, impedes, or interferes with any member of the PERB or its agents in performing its duties pursuant to the LEERA, is guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction, must pay a fine not to exceed $1,000.
4) Provides the PERB exclusive jurisdiction over the initial determination as to whether charges of unfair practices are justified and the appropriate remedy except damages due to an unlawful strike, strike-preparation damages for costs, expenses, or lost revenues incurred during, or as consequence of, an unlawful strike.
Also, grants to the PERB the authority to establish procedures for investigating, hearing, and deciding cases regarding the LEERA and requires certain specified procedures regarding issuance of complaints; alleged unfair practices; grievances; and, provides that the PERB has discretionary jurisdiction to review a settlement or arbitration award, as specified.
5) Provides that the PERB does not have the authority to enforce agreements between the parties nor issue a complaint on any charge based on an alleged violation of an agreement that would not also constitute an unfair practice. However, the PERB does have power to issue a decision and order directing an offending party to cease and desist from the unfair practice and to take affirmative action, including, but not limited to, reinstatement of employees with or without backpay.
6) Grants employees of the Legislature the right to form, join, and participate in the activities of an employee organization of their own choosing for representation in employer-employee relations, including the right to refuse to join or participate in the activities of such organizations, except the parties are permitted to agree to a maintenance of membership provision pursuant to an MOU, and allows legislative employees the right to self-representation in their employment relations with the Legislature.
7) Grants employee organizations the right to represent their members in their employment relations with the Legislature until recognized as the exclusive representative of an appropriate bargaining unit. At that time, the recognized employee organization is the only organization that may represent that unit in its employment relationship with the Legislature
Also, establishes that employee organizations may establish reasonable restrictions on membership, including dismissal from membership, and that an employee is not prohibited from self-representation in his or her employment relations with the Legislature.
8) Grants employee organizations the right to have membership dues, initiation fees, membership benefit programs, and general assessments deducted, as specified, until an employee organization is recognized as the exclusive representative, and upon such recognition, any deductions as to any employee in the negotiating unit are not permissible, except to the exclusive representative.
Also provides that an employee organization recognized as the exclusive representative of an appropriate unit may enter into an agreement with the Legislature providing for organizational security in the form of maintenance of membership deduction, and requires the Legislature to provide the recognized employee organization with sufficient employment data that would allow the organization to calculate membership fees which are to be deducted from the salary or wages of every employee for the membership fee. Fees are to be remitted monthly to the recognized employee organization along with an itemized record of the deductions, as provided.
- Establishes that the scope of representation is limited to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, except consideration of the merits, necessity, or organization of any service or activity provided by law.
- Provides, except in cases of emergency, procedures regarding notice from the employer to, and the meet and confer process with, each recognized employee organization when a law, rule, or resolution directly relates to matters within the scope of representation proposed to be adopted by the Legislature. Establishes the “meet and confer in good faith” process between the Speaker of the Assembly, President pro Tempore of the Senate, or their respective designees, and the exclusive representative relating to the scope of representation, approval of a signed writing that evinces an agreement reached by the parties pursuant to the meet and confer in good faith process, including appropriation of monies and other related to statutes and other necessary writings, as specified, therefore, to effectuate the agreement.
For these purposes, “meet and confer in good faith” means the Speaker of the Assembly and the President pro Tempore of the Senate, or their designated representatives, and the representatives of exclusive employee organizations to have a mutual obligation to personally meet and confer for a reasonable period of time to exchange freely information, opinions, and proposals, and to endeavor to reach agreement on maters within the scope of representation prior to adoption by the state of its final budget for the ensuring year. The process should include adequate time for the resolution of impasses. In addition, the process relating to an expired MOU, including impasse, last, best and final offer, and mediation also are provided.
- Provides a reasonable number of employees who are members of the recognized employee organization release time without loss of compensation or other benefits for purposes of meeting and conferring with the Legislature on matters within the scope of representation, except that such time only applies for periods when a MOU is not in effect.
- Prescribes specified unlawful actions or activities by the Legislature and recognized employee organizations relating to the purposes of the LEERA.
- Provides for, and permits judicial review of a unit determination under specified circumstances, and establishes the process of, and for, judicial review of an unfair practice charge.
- Requires the Legislature to grant exclusive recognition to employee organizations designated or selected pursuant to PERB rules for employees of the Legislature or an appropriate unit thereof, subject to the right of self-representation by an employee; requires the PERB to establish reasonable procedures for petitions and for holding elections and determining appropriate units; and, prohibits the PERB from including employees in a bargaining unit that includes nonlegislative employees.
- Requires the Legislature to adopt reasonable rules regarding registering employee organizations; determining the status of organizations and associations as employee organizations or bona fide associations; and, identifying the officers and representatives who officially represent such organizations or associations.
- Provides that if the decision of an administrative law judge regarding the recognition or certification of an employee organization shall be deemed PERB’s final order if the decision is appealed, the decision must be deemed the final order of the PERB if the board does not issue a ruling that supersedes the decision on or before 180 days after the appeal is filed.
- Requires the PERB to be governed by specified criteria in determining an appropriate bargaining unit, except that the PERB shall not direct an election in a unit unless one or more of the employee organizations involved in the proceeding is seeking or agrees to an election in such a unit.
- Requires all initial meet and confer proposals of recognized employee organizations to be presented to the employer at a public meeting, and the proposals or counterproposals thereafter to be a public record, and in cases of emergency, establishes that no meeting and conferring are to occur on a proposal until a period for public review and comment, as specified, has elapsed. This includes any proposal that includes any substantive subject that was not first presented as proposals offered during any meet and confer session for public reaction. Those proposals and the position, if any, taken by the representatives of the employer must also be a public record.
Also provides specified instances in which the public review and comment period is not applicable, but must be made public as soon as reasonably possible.
- Provides that the LEERA is not to be construed to apply Section 923 of the Labor Code to employees of the Legislature.
Section 923 of the Labor Code provides it is necessary that the individual working have full freedom of association, self-organization and designation of representatives of his own choosing, to negotiate the terms and conditions of his employment, and shall be free from the interference, restraint or coercion of employers of labor, or their agents, in the designation of such representatives or in self-organization or in other concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection.
- Includes a severability clause.
- Provides that nothing in the LEERA is to be construed as modifying or eliminating any existing wages, hours, or terms and conditions of employment for employees of the Legislature, and that all existing wages, hours, and terms and conditions of employment for employees of the Legislature remain in effect unless and until changed in accordance with the Legislature’s procedures or pursuant to a MOU between the Legislature and a recognized employee organization.
- Includes provisions relating to reimbursement, crimes, infractions and penalties pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
- Includes legislative findings and declarations in support of its operative provisions.
EXISTING LAW:
- Exempts, pursuant to Section 4 of Article VII of the California Constitution, officers and employees appointed or employed by the Legislature, either House, or legislative employees from the civil service.
- Establishes several statutory frameworks which provide for state and local public employer-employee relations by providing a reasonable method of resolving disputes regarding wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between public employers and recognized employee organizations or their exclusive representatives.
- Delegates jurisdiction over the public employer-employee relationship to the PERB and charges PERB with resolving disputes and enforcing statutory duties and rights of state and local public agency employers and employee organizations, but provides the City and County of Los Angeles a local alternative to PERB oversight.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has been flagged as fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: According to the author, “[c]ollective bargaining opens the door for employees to come together and let their voices be heard in the workplace. Employees of the Legislature deserve the same right to collectively bargain over workplace issues with their employer that private-sector employees and public employees in the state’s executive and judicial branches already enjoy.
‘Collective bargaining provides a forum where employers and employees can join together to tackle problems. It is a two-way street that does not require the Legislature, or its employees, to agree to any terms and conditions they cannot live with. Bargaining brings consistency to personnel issues and most importantly, provides fairness and well overdue protections in the workplace through mutually agreed upon rights and obligations. At the very least, employees of the Legislature deserve to have the choice to elect this forum to address workplace issues that they face on the job each day.
‘In any workplace, when there’s an imbalance of power, workers have little to no recourse. Last year, the #MeToo movement made this evident when it shed a spotlight on legislative employees’ lack of tangible workplace protections in statute due to their at-will status. While there have been substantial steps taken to strengthen workplace policies for legislative employees, there’s no replacement for the value that comes from workers joining together to have a collective voice. Collective bargaining empowers employees to have a hand in determining protocols for a safe work environment and protections against workplace harassment, bullying, and retaliation.
‘Assembly Bill 969 extends to legislative staff the same rights that private employers and other branches of our government are expected to provide their employees: the choice of whether they want to form and join a union to bargain for clear workplace standards, improved conditions, fairness and a voice on the job. Employees ought to be respected enough to have the opportunity to make this critical decision on their own.”
1) Prior and Current Efforts to Offer Representation and Collective Bargaining Rights to Legislative Employees in California
As stated under “Prior or Related Legislation” below, Assembly Bill 2350 (Floyd, 2000) would have afforded legislative employees representation and collective bargaining rights pursuant to the Dills Act which governs the employer-employee relationship for state employees. However, the Dills Act covers specified state employees who are member of the civil service; whereas, legislative employees are expressly exempted from state civil service pursuant to the California Constitution. Thus, if enacted and signed into law, that measure likely would have been deemed ineffective because its provisions were in violation of, and prohibited by, the California Constitution.
Assembly Bill 2048 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) sought to establish a separate statutory framework, similar to other existing statutory collective bargaining frameworks under the jurisdiction of the PERB, for representation and collective bargaining for specified employees of the Legislature. The statutory construction of this measure was external to, and independent of, the state’s statutes and constitutional provisions governing the civil service, unlike Assembly Bill 2350 (Floyd).
Similar to Assembly Bill 2048, the current measure offers similar rights and obligations governing employer-employee relations among the Legislature and its employees, as defined. Because this measure also is external to, and independent of, the state’s statutes and constitutional provisions governing state civil service, it also could be construed to be permissible under law.
- Key Differences Between Assembly Bill 969 and Assembly Bill 2048
The underlying differences between Assembly Bill 2048 and the current measure are, notwithstanding the dates of introduction of each measure, that the current measure does not include provisions relating for fair share fees, conscientious objectors, and suitably minor variations.[1]
3) At-Will Employment of Legislative Employees
The respective Rules of the Assembly and Senate are memorialized by the action of, and for, the respective house by Resolution. Generally, provisions regarding the employment status of legislative employees remain the same among the successive Regular Sessions of the Legislature.
Pursuant to House Resolution 1 (Cooley) for the 2019-20 Regular Session, Assembly Rule 24 of the Standing Rules of the Assembly provide in part, that “[e]very employee who works for a committee of the Assembly or a subcommittee of a committee, for a Member of the Assembly, for the Chief Clerk’s office, or for the Sergeant at Arms, is an employee of the Assembly. All employees of the Assembly serve at the pleasure of the Assembly and the terms and conditions of their employment may be modified, or their employment may be terminated at will, at any time and without notice, by the Committee on Rules.”
Pursuant to Senate Resolution 4 (Atkins) for the 2019-20 Regular Session, Senate Rule 13(e)(1) of the Standing Rules of the Senate provides that, “[a]ll employees on the payroll of the Senate are employees of the Senate and not of individual members, and they are under the direct control of the Committee on Rules. The Committee on Rules has general supervision over all employees of the Senate and the powers and duties to suspend, discipline, or discharge any employees when necessary. Any insubordination or inefficiency on the part of any employee shall be reported to the Committee on Rules.”
The Rules of the Senate do not explicitly state that employees of the Senate are “at-will” as stated in the Rules of the Assembly. Nevertheless, context and construction of the applicable Senate Rule relating to employment is not ambiguous. Here, the essence of the phraseology used to describe employment in Senate Rule (e)(1) clearly provides that the Senate may take actions to “suspend, discipline, or discharge any employee when necessary.” Thus, a plain reading of this language is that employment in the Senate also is based on an “at-will” employment relationship.
- The Purposes and Core Mechanics of Public Employee Collective Bargaining
The purposes of collective bargaining statutes governing public employer-employee relations in California are to limit labor strife and economic disruption in the public sector through a reasonable method of resolving disputes regarding wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment between public employers and their employees or their exclusive representatives.
The core mechanics of collective bargaining are twofold – “give” and “take” – between the employer and recognized employee organization on behalf of the represented employees. In sum, this process involves the negotiating parties giving something away in exchange for concessions from the other (i.e., “take”). An alternative view may be that the negotiating parties want to “obtain” something from the other, but to do so, must “give” something in return to reach an agreement.
The following is a simple, but general example to illustrate this process: Collectively, employees desire a certain increase in wages (“take” or “obtain”). However, because the wage increase is a cost to the employer, the employees must ascertain what they are willing to offer (“give”) in exchange, if anything. The employer is willing to compromise on providing (“give”) a wage increase, but in exchange, the employer requires that its employees pay for some portion of the employer’s costs for providing healthcare, dental or vision coverage that employees currently are not required to pay, or perhaps the employer no longer wants to offer reimbursement or subsidies for other benefits provided, or a combination of both (“take” or “obtain”). In short, the necessity of a cost-benefit analysis exists relative to this “give” and “take/obtain” and is similar to considerations that individuals engage in on an almost daily basis throughout their lives, but in the employment relations setting.
For each party, the evolving nature and purpose of this “give” and “take/obtain” in the collective bargaining setting is to achieve the desired objective – the manifestation of the art of compromise represented by a written and signed agreement by the involved parties. This assumes that the collective bargaining process and negotiation strategy or tactics used are in good faith, and not to reach impasse or unilaterally impose what might be considered by the other party as a reasonably unfair or objectionable contract.
Notwithstanding the establishment of the Workplace Conduct Unit (WCU) by the Legislature, as discussed in “Comment 7” below, other matters that may warrant collective bargaining rights for certain legislative employees relating to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment are presently unknown to this committee.
- Whether Legislative Employees Favor Organizing for Purposes of Collective Bargaining
In relation to “Comment 4” above, it is unknown to the committee whether employees of the Legislature desire collective bargaining rights, and if so, how many such employees that would be covered by this measure affirmatively express this desire.
Nevertheless, it is not within the jurisdiction of this committee to determine whether employees of the Legislature are interested in employee representation as those matters, generally, are likely subject to the jurisdiction of the respective Human Resources department or division of each House of the Legislature, and perhaps, through the governing committee or ultimate lead authorities responsible for matters relating to human resources.
- Constitutional Implications Relating to Proposition 140 and the Operating Budget of the Legislature
Proposition 140, also known as “Legislative Term Limits, Legislators’ Retirement and Legislative Operating Costs Amendment,” was passed by voters (over 52 percent). Proposition 140 amended the California Constitution and, among other things, reduced the operating budget of the Legislature by placing a “cap” on the budget.
If over time, wages or other benefits increase as a result of collective bargaining rights granted pursuant to the provisions of Assembly Bill 969, reach or exceed the mandated “cap” of the Legislature’s operating budget, the Legislature would not be in compliance with the express “will” of the voters in passing the measure. As a result, unknown and unintended consequences, including legal or other, may ensue.
In addition, should the “cap” be reached or exceed as a result of collective bargaining efforts where negotiated salary or benefit increases exceed the rate of Proposition 140 appropriation growth, there may be unintended consequences that necessitate reductions to remain within the operational budget mandate. Actions to reduce the operating budget may include, but not be limited to, reduction in services provided to the public, positions, staff and budgets of Members of the Legislature (including for district offices), all or some of which may negatively affect the normal business activities and operations of the Legislature in serving Californians.
7) Efforts by the Legislature Regarding Rights of its Employees
Recently effective, Chapter 2, Statutes of 2018 (AB 403, Melendez) establishes the Legislative Employee Whistleblower Protection Act that protects legislative employees who make disclosures about specified misconduct by Members and fellow employees of the Legislature by prohibiting interference with an employee making a “protected disclosure,” as defined, and prohibiting retaliation in response to such a disclosure.
The Legislature also adopted a policy in 2018 prohibiting inappropriate workplace conduct for all employees and Members in the Senate and Assembly. In addition, Members of the Legislature and legislative employees must attend periodic training relating to workplace conduct.
In furtherance of fostering a culture of respect, dignity and professionalism in the workplace, the Legislature established the WCU – an external division apart from the Legislature and situated in the Office of Legislative Counsel – to accept and investigate inappropriate workplace conduct, including, but not limited to, harassment, discrimination and retaliation within the Legislature.
The duties of the WCU are to confidentially assess complaints and conduct prompt, independent, and objective investigations of allegations of inappropriate conduct by legislative employees, Members of the Legislature, or third parties, based upon a person’s protected class.
As previously stated, notwithstanding the establishment of the WCU by the Legislature, other matters that may warrant collective bargaining rights for certain legislative employees relating to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment are presently unknown to this committee.
8) Comments by Supporters
Supporters generally state that, the privilege of collective bargaining afforded to other employees should be extended to employees of the Legislature.
9) Prior or Related Legislation
Assembly Bill 2048 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) sought to establish a separate statutory framework, similar to other existing statutory collective bargaining frameworks under the jurisdiction of the PERB, for representation and collective bargaining for specified employees of the Legislature. This measure failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security.
Assembly Bill 2350 (Floyd, 2000) would have included nonsupervisory employees of the Legislature as "state employees" for purposes of the Dills Act. This measure failed passage by the Assembly Committee on Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Federation of Teachers, AFT, AFL-CIO
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Teachers Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
City of Berkeley
International Union of Elevator Constructors, Local 18
International Union of Elevator Constructors, Local 8
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957
Removal of provisions relating to fair share or “agency” fees likely prompted by Janus v. AFSCME, Council 31, 138 S. Ct. 2448 (2018). ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):