Assembly Select Committee on the Status of Boys and Men of Color
No Bills Identified
Speakers
This list may include AI predicted speakers. Speakers who could not be identified are not listed.
Advocate
Legislator
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
This begins the select committee on the status of boys and men of color. I wanna thank all of you for being here, especially those of you that have come from from other parts of California. We did our last hearing in Los Angeles, and I'm grateful to be here in Oakland. I wanna start by making it clear that Assembly member Bonta would be here, but she is not feeling well today. And so we send her our love and our prayers, and she's here.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
We know that she's with us in allyship always. And I wanna thank my colleagues who are here for coming up on the weekend... Or on the recess. I especially wanna thank Senator Avellino Valencia whose birthday it is. Can we give it up for the Senator?
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
The purpose of today's convening is to talk about what reimagining justice and healing for boys and men in California can look like. And we have three panels of experts from around the state and from here in Oakland in particular that are gonna be testifying before this committee. And before that, I wanna open it up to any questions, comments, or opening statements from my colleagues.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
Mister Calra. Thank you, Mister Chair. I'll be brief and just wanna express my appreciation to all the organizations that are here today. More importantly, the work that you do all throughout the year, especially when we're up in Sacramento fighting for justice. And I know many of you and many of your organizations have done that for a very long time.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
And as I enter my last couple of years, I look forward to continue to work with all of you to see how we can push back against the recent trend over the last couple of years of trying to push back against some of the gains that we've made and focus on what we know works, which is uplifting the community and working with the community. So thank you.
-
Mike Fong
Legislator
Thank you so much, Chair Brian. And thank you for your leadership and efforts on the select committee on the status of Boys and Men in Color and to my colleagues as well and to all our community leaders gathered here today. Thank you for the tremendous work and efforts around the Select Committee.
-
Mike Fong
Legislator
And we know that there's a lot more work to be done ahead around re imagining justice and healing for men in California and ways to improve transitions after incarceration, but also addressing healing and mental health needs of boys of men of color, but also looking at how we can work around youth apprenticeships, job training programs, and additional opportunities. And so really grateful to all the speakers that are gonna be here today to share insights and how we can continue to partner together.
-
Mike Fong
Legislator
I really appreciate Chair Brian again for his leadership and for his work and efforts around many, many different issues. Thank you, Chair.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, Chair Brian. Good afternoon, everyone. It's humbling to be here today considering everything that we're dealing with at the national stage across the state of California, but in particular in our immediate communities. And the timeliness of this of this hearing, couldn't be more precise. The name itself, reimagining justice and healing for men in California.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Our men and young boys are struggling across the board. And when it comes to boys and men of color, black and brown kids, it's causing extra harm. So this conversation has been one that's been taking place for a long time. The tenacity and focus of Chair Brian has moved the needle, and I look forward to those conversations to continue and moving on community ahead. Thank you.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. I also... Because I haven't seen all of you since the end of session, I wanna say how proud I am for the community that has shown up to support this select committee. One of the pieces of legislation that's a derivative of the work of this committee was AB 1646.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Before we went to Chukos Justice Center in Los Angeles, a number of my colleagues and Aye, including members of this panel, went to Los Padrinos Juvenile Hall and met with incarcerated youth in the R 1 And R 2 Units who asked us to carry legislation with them to give all youth in California the right to physical contact with their loved ones when they come to visit.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
With Gavin Newsom's signature, California is now the first state in the country where incarcerated youth have the right to physical touch, including hugs, with their visitors, and that is because of the work of this committee and because of the work of the incarcerated young people in Los Padrinos juvenile hall. So give it up for yourselves. With that, we'll go ahead and start with our first panel. If you guys would like to come down, Mister Khalid Alexander, James Birch, Rafil Way, and Sean Jones.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
With Gavin Newsom's signature, California is now the first state in the country where incarcerated youth have the right to physical touch, including hugs, with their visitors, and that is because of the work of this committee and because of the work of the incarcerated young people in Los Padrinos juvenile hall. So give it up for yourselves. With that, we'll go ahead and start with our first panel. If you guys would like to come down, Mister Khalid Alexander, James Birch, Rafil Way, and Sean Jones.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
So my name is Khalid Alexander. I'm the President of Pillars of the Community in San Diego. The point that I'm. Was tasked to talk about is Penal Code 148. In September of last year, one of our staff members was pulled over by the police after attending a football game to watch his son.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
Three of his children were in the car. He was pulled over, and when he demanded his rights and began to speak about his rights, he was removed, forcibly removed from the car and arrested. A week later, another of our members of Builders of the Community was downtown San Diego, saw a man being harassed by the police, stepped in and mentioned that person has rights too. He too was arrested.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
What did these people have in common? Both of them were black. Neither of them were breaking any laws. Both insisted on their rights, and they are both resisted. The only underlying charge that they were charged with was resisting arrest under Penal Code 148.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
These scenes, both of which happened within a couple of weeks of each other, of course, echo post slavery black codes where black men and women were harassed just for standing up for their rights and just for holding themselves with dignity.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
In San Diego, after these occurred, we pulled the the records. We did PRA requests, and we found out that black folks in San Diego are charged with Penal Code 148, four times more than others, disproportionate to their population size.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
These new era black codes are even more egregious and so egregious that the City's Attorney's Office themselves only prosecute. Actually refuses to prosecute nearly 70% of those cases that are charged because of recognizing that this is one of the.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
All of the consequences that come from this. Young men, young women who are ripped from their families, sent to the local jail, eventually booked and released.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
But the consequences as far as how much money is spent with officers that are being used, the cost of the taxpayers, the trauma and mental health of the children that are in the cars, the children that are related to these people, the impacts in jobs and child care, and the breakdown in trust for law enforcement are all reasons why Penal Code 148 is something that we've been focusing on and feel like we need to, make some policy changes.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
Penal Code 148 is essentially a resisting arrest charge. I have a longer definition if you want, but.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
No. That's perfect. We'll ask follow-up questions at the end of the panel. Mister Burch.
-
James Burch
Person
Hello. My name is James Burch. I'm the Founder & Executive Director of Black Solutions Lab. We're an Oakland based organization that supports black led community based and direct service organizations with research policy and strategy with a focus on improving public safety outcomes for black Oakland and Oakland as a whole.
-
James Burch
Person
Right now, our organization is focused on two areas, homelessness and how to better serve Oaklanders who are in crisis or witness someone in crisis.
-
James Burch
Person
With regards to, with regards to crisis response, we're leading a survey process with our partners that ask black Oaklanders what their experience is when someone is in crisis. The goal, to put it bluntly, is to determine who people are calling or not calling and why and what the outcomes are. And what we're learning is that our crisis response systems are facing great challenges to even respond to communities of color.
-
James Burch
Person
In Oakland, we have a police department with historically long response times for many low level call types with a medium of 4 hours for priority 2 calls and 8 hours for priority 3 calls.
-
James Burch
Person
Additionally, it is commonly thought and we strongly agree as men. I'm sure many of you do, that police are not the appropriate response to low level calls for service. To address this, Oakland established MACRO, a civilian response program, but people don't know it exists. So we're stuck in a situation where police aren't showing up and people don't know how to access any other option.
-
James Burch
Person
And with money tight, MACRO is fighting to maintain its staff, having 9 positions frozen in the last budget cycle, and can't currently afford the desperately needed outreach they need to let our communities know that this option is available.
-
James Burch
Person
When it comes to homelessness, our first priority is to address the immense gap between the number of shelter beds currently in Oakland. We currently have about 1,250 beds for a very conservative estimate of 4,400 homeless Oaklanders with advocates estimating that number to be in between five and six thousand.
-
James Burch
Person
We need more temporary housing options, but with extreme difficulty anticipating the future of HAPP funding and a need much greater than we currently receive, our numbers of temporary housing sites are going down, not up.
-
James Burch
Person
This means that sweep continue to push our unhoused neighbors from block to block indefinitely, costing millions in untracked overtime. Costing millions in untracked police overtime that makes it even more difficult to fund our solutions.
-
James Burch
Person
I'll conclude by making clear that it's the funding that is our primary obstacle in this moment. With Oakland, like many cities, facing a structural deficit, we're looking to the state for critical resources to support boys and men of color. Thank you.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. And Rafael Wei, before we go to you, I wanna acknowledge that Assembly member Sade El Hawari is here, and also give you an opportunity to address the members of the public who have come to join us in this committee.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And also I wanna point out, another victory for boys and men of color this year was the reauthorization and extension and funding of the Crisis Act, which was carried by Assemblymember Elhawary this year. And with that, I'll pass it over to you.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Good evening, everyone. I'm so proud to be a part of this select committee, and really grateful to our Chair and my colleagues, who are also on this select committee. It's so important that we do the work to invest in our communities. And as we recognize just what it means and what it takes to invest in boys and men of color, I am committed to this fight alongside each and every one of you. Thank you.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
Good afternoon. My name is Raffy Loewe. I'm with the Anti Police Terror Project. We're a Oakland based organization that was founded in the wake of the murder of Oscar Grant.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
I think it's really beautiful that this hearing is actually held here at the Oscar Grant Youth Empowerment Zone, which is down the street from Fruitvale BART Station, where 15 almost 16 years ago now, Oscar Grant was murdered, at the BART station leading to not just local movements organizing towards looking at alternatives to crisis response, police oversight bodies, and then what it means to invest in community, but really nationwide and internationally sweeping call for enforcement reforms.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
And so I'm here to talk to you all about what it means to have alternatives to crisis response. I want to extend a thank you to Assembly member Elhawary for their work with the Crisis Act, which is a really critical step to having states support our community based interventions.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
As the Anti Police Terror Project, we have our own programs for community servicing folks out of West Oakland through a mental health crisis line that serves all of Oakland where folks were able to call volunteers and community members, folks who are trained in crisis response, mental health crisis response, domestic violence responses, as an alternative to police.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
As we know, many of our communities may not make that phone call to police.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
As APTP, we support a number of impacted family members who lost their loved ones to extrajudicial killings of police who actually showed up oftentimes in response to the family calling themselves for support to potentially a mental health crisis or other crisis that the family was experiencing and that a person who showed up with a badge and a gun was not equipped to support them with.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
And so having more community response, programs such as MACRO, so going from the community based response to community partnership with the city, organizations like MACRO has been able to serve our particularly unhoused community, folks struggling with substance abuse, through their mobile assistance program that could use greater support.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
We know from working with MACRO that their current budget is about at half of what they truly need to be successful and even increase their service range. Right now, they're focused in Downtown Oakland.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
And that's what we know about intervention programs. It's very helpful for them to be these localized efforts such as the Family Bridges Program, which is a beneficiary of the Crisis Act 1.0 and was able to demonstrate in Chinatown what it was like to have an organization that was already working in community and already doing the work and had built in community trust, then also be able to partner with the city to expand what that looks like.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
Because our folks need wrap around services. They need the prevention piece of housing and access to health care as well as when the prevention is limited and then we have a crisis on our hands. We know crisis can look like very different things, whether it be a mental health crisis, folks are facing food insecurity, and that's leading folks to crisis. Right? Oftentimes, when we look at crime stats, the so called crime that is the highest is robbery.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
Right? When people are doing conditions based crimes because folks need to meet their needs. And so rather than policing poverty forward, policing poverty, we want to be able to actually meet people's needs. And so investing in our community further, especially when we see at the national level cuts to SNAP and other resources that benefit our folks.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
We wanna take people who are being pushed further into the margins and being criminalized out of the margins and community programs and spaces like here led by our partners at Courage, Communities United for Restorative Justice, will allow us to do that.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
So we hope for continued partnership with the state, investment for the state, as we partner locally, for the folks who are experts at what their communities needs, being able to meet their communities needs.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. I also wanna thank Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice for hosting us today. Thank you for allowing us to be in this space, and for making sure that committee members saw the Oscar Grant mural down the street and understood the significance and the history of the place that we're standing in.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Incredibly powerful. Also before I go to you, Sean or Mister Jones, I just have a question even though I said they would go to the end.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
How does MACRO work? Because two of you have now mentioned MACRO and I'm gathering it's an alternative crisis response line or something. Like, how is it? Is it a formal city program? Is it a.
-
James Burch
Person
It's a city program. It's based in Oakland's police. Sorry. Oakland's Fire Department, and it works in two ways.
-
James Burch
Person
Increasingly, over the last year, they've started routing more 911 calls through a MACRO. So if there are low level calls of specific call types, those calls, when received by the dispatch, will go to MACRO responders who have a much lower response time as as, you know, as they're facing many fewer calls. There's also a direct line to reach for MACRO, which is what I'm talking about. And the only chance.
-
James Burch
Person
The main challenge that we're facing there is how do we get in deep communities, like in in Deep East Oakland?
-
James Burch
Person
How do we get people to know that this exists? When we're talking to folks, it's one of those things where, you know, it takes resources to get the word out. Right? And with those resources lacking, folks who we're talking to just aren't, you know, aren't aware of the program and so don't know who to call when there's a crisis of that sort.
-
Sean Jones
Person
I did a panel. I'm a little nervous. You know, it's been a minute, you know, but appreciate it. Good afternoon, everybody. My name is Sean Jones.
-
Sean Jones
Person
I'm part of SJLI, Social Justice Learning Institute. I'm an alumni. Also BSS, Business Sales Coalition. Man, it's been a minute. I work, I work and been a part of Bill of Rights, you know, with BSS.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Also did study and research with SJLI. You know, he had a class called BMYA with Black Male Youth Academy School to Prison Pipeline. And what a school to prison pipeline means is how students are being treated as prisoners in a learning environment in all schools of LAUSD. You know, as soon as, like we should be being teach and not just being treated like us, like you know, inmates and do prisons.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Like, we are school to get our education and to get, you know, what we need to know about our future and go to college or get jobs and whatnot.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Not just. And not just not for high school, but like, for junior high, not for elementary schools. And you look at our schools and the LAUSD, you do look at our schools, like how it's, like it's being, like, formed or how it's being, like. Guess like, how how it's being built as, like a prison, right? You telling students, like, to go to this class or you get in class.
-
Sean Jones
Person
You're gonna be late. You get sent to a office. It's gonna be consequences if you don't do what you're supposed to do in schools. And you look at niggas out of prison and you see inmates, like, 10 inmates to again, saw yourself, out of cell or there's gonna be consequences. You're gonna be sent to solitary confinement or protected custody, or you're gonna be sent to different yard with different people that you're not familiar with or anything like that.
-
Sean Jones
Person
So we. So I did like, when I remember, during high school and 9th grade, we just like, researched and interviewed, did a couple of surveys, you know, you know, just adding up the statistics, like getting the people voice, like what they. We heard, what they think about this issue or this topic. And some of their kids, like, they feel like they're prisoners as well. Like, they think that they're not being treated as human beings.
-
Sean Jones
Person
They're being treated like a caged animal. Now we're not caged animals. Like, we just here to be a plus student. You know? And I feel like our kids today, not just our kids, like teenagers, you know, from F to 12, like, we should not go through that.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Like, they should have education, have a future in life, and they could pass on to different generations of their kids or their families. And our schools are here to just be a learning environment, not just, like prisons of. To send people to prison is for things that they've done. Right? And as well as we can't forget about the school police, and I feel like the school police in these might be better as well.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Like, they should be, like held accountable for things that that happened to a student, like for for their mental issues or what has happened to them or check up on them, not just, like, treated. Did not just be treated as student like the one way. They should be treating students the right way as much as like, prisoners as well because prisoners, they do. They need a second chance of life as well.
-
Sean Jones
Person
So that's what I worked on research today, and I feel like our students need be.
-
Sean Jones
Person
Our students need to be better and safe and sound and get our education, and they just passed on this generation that they're here to come.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you, Mister Chair. Thank you to all the panelists. It was it was good to hear about the MACRO program. I hope the city will find ways to fund it more and especially with the outreach, it sounds like it'll be a definitely needed to let folks know about it.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
But I look forward to learning more about it. After the hearing, I'll be in touch to learn more. I had. I just wanted to thank Mister Alexander for bringing up the issue of 148, which are not just resisting delaying, or obstructing a police officer in the performance of their duties, which is, as it sounds, incredibly broad.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
I was a public defender in Santa Clara County from 1997 to 2008. Anyone from The Bay knows Santa Clara County. They would charge everything they possibly could. They would fill the sheet. So whenever we saw cases that there was a standalone 148, it was incredibly problematic.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
It would be folks that were questioning authority as you referred to. People, third parties observing or filming the police or in the most egregious situations, cover up a police abuse. And so there would literally be clients coming straight from the infirmary into the courtroom. Clearly, you know, had been abused and the only charge they would have is a 148.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
So I appreciate you raising. This has been an issue obviously for many decades. I appreciate you raising that issue and also raising the issue of being able to collect data because that's another area under the Racial Justice Act is getting resources because that's the pushback from the courts and the DAs all the time. So we don't have the resources to get the data.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
And so, you know, finding some system where the data is more easily accessible to individuals, to community organizations, to defense attorneys, what have you so that this analysis can be properly done not just in San Diego, but throughout the state.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Any other questions or comments, colleagues? What is MACRO's budget?
-
James Burch
Person
About 2,500,000. And again, we're in a position where in the last budget cycle, nine of the nine positions were frozen. And so first of all, I didn't, I didn't say. MACRO was doing a great job. I really, I really love the program.
-
James Burch
Person
I love what they're doing. You know, they lead with a with a EMT and a peer responder. Right? This is a model that's been, you know, growing across the country, and it's showing great results in not only the ability to serve the people, but to divert calls from 911 systems. Right?
-
James Burch
Person
Taking large percentages in both here and in cities across the country. And so, the challenge is just getting a program like that on its feet and growing a program like that. And I wish we did have the funds in Oakland to to pay for a service like that. But right now, with the structural deficit, we're talking about fighting to prevent things from being cut as opposed to able to grow programs.
-
James Burch
Person
And so that's why I took the advantage of being here with all you fine folks to mention that, you know, it is resources that we're looking for to be able to grow these programs. It was state funds that helped MACRO get on its feet when it was first established, thanks to our local legislators availing themselves of, I think it was Senator Nancy Skinner at the time.
-
James Burch
Person
But you know, hoping for for continued partnership with the state for not only MACRO, but programs like this that exist, you know, like the Rock Program in Richmond is another good example. There are programs throughout the state that are doing the civilian response, and and with 911 systems overloaded across the state and response times, you know a great challenge, especially for communities of color.
-
James Burch
Person
You know, it's a great, it's a great resource to be able to grow these programs, to respond to these low level calls that often have, you know, four, five, six, eight hour response times. Which just does not meet the need that our communities are facing.
-
James Burch
Person
I don't have that number. I don't have that number with me, but I know it's it's much better than eight hours. You know, it's we'll be producing a survey in the next couple months, and so I'm happy to share that with you all. That will have more data from the community who've received services, you know, from MACRO as well as others. But what we're hearing from folks is that is that MACRO is much more able to meet the need.
-
James Burch
Person
Right? You know, there's. The MACRO units are certainly always busy, right? and are overtaxed, but are are much better able to meet the need than the police who, you know, who aren't able to show up. Thank you.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
And if I may, I just wanna add. I think a large part of MACRO success is their understanding of the deep need for community partnership. Right? So Elliot, who helps lead to lead the MACRO team, is in constant conversation with their community partners across the city who are doing intervention work, who are potential pipelines.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
They're not just thinking about their initial intervention at the crisis. They're thinking about where people go afterwards. They're thinking about wrap around services. They're thinking about high priority areas. And despite the lack of the budget to do so, are doing deep community engagement to build trust, which is something you really can't put a dollar amount behind.
-
Raffy Loewe
Person
And now that they've built the trust of the community, need to build on that trust by succeeding.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you for that. Mister Alexander, I just have a question for you around PC 148. Are there any jurisdictions that have done any changes with this or any prosecutors who have decided they're not, they're not charging this or they're not, you know, pursuing cases? The abolitionist in me says get rid of PC 148.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
The pragmatist in me who recognizes the politics of things is, like, don't allow it to be a stand alone charge, but have to accompany another charge and then scrutinize it still heavily.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I'm just kinda curious. Has anybody tried to address this? Because I think Mister Kalra brings an incredible point and has seen this firsthand as a public defender where it's a stand alone charge and it's often used just because you wanted to.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
The Assemblymember might know more about this than I do because the way that he was, yeah, explaining it, not to my knowledge. The few people in policy circles that we've spoken to have recommended just putting pressure on local PD to actually not do it. So it's possible that there are some cities in California where the police department has kind of gotten rid of the culture. The concern about making it as...
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
The concern about making it that in order to charge somebody with resisting arrest, they would have to be attached and not a stand alone crime is that they would just add things to it.
-
Khalid Alexander
Person
So right now, we're just kind of really interested in collecting more information on it, but would love to work with all of you on figuring out kind of a way to discourage the abuses that we see happening really on a daily basis.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. Any other questions or comments? Mister Valencia.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, Mister Chair. To touch on the program that was just discussed here, we have a very similar program to that in Anaheim. It's called the Mobile Crisis Response Team, which serves the exact same purpose. It's done an incredible job in referring 911 calls that are nonviolent or of that caliber to a specialized team that not only addresses the immediate need at a much more rapid rate, but also provides that secondary level of support and connecting folks with the necessary resources.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
I'm encouraged to hear that other communities are doing it as well. But it would be interesting to have a statewide conversation around how we can either fund a program like that, support a program like that, right? So local municipalities can implement something that's most catered to their needs.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Our second panel is on reimagining pathways during and post incarceration. And I'd like to invite up Mister Galvez, Ortiz, Miller, and Kaneda.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you all for joining us today. We'll start with you, George.
-
George Galvis
Person
Oh, there we go. First of all, I just wanna welcome the esteemed members of the select committee here to community justice and, of course, also Senator Valencia Feliz Campanos. Honored that you're spending your birthday here with us to be in deep conversation. And I also wanna just acknowledge, and and the pun is intended, that it takes courage to actually host these kinds of events outside of the typical halls in which these conversations happen when we're discussing state policy.
-
George Galvis
Person
And so coming here in the heart of East Oakland that represents the frontline communities impacted by the issues that we're discussing, is commendable.
-
George Galvis
Person
So thank you for that. My name is George Galvez. I am cofounder and executive director of Courage, commision added for Story of View Justice. And we were... I have the distinct privilege of working with young people with very similar lived experiences myself.
-
George Galvis
Person
And so at the age of 17, I was arrested. I was charged with multiple felonies. I was very, very fortunate not to be charged as an adult. I was charged as a youth, which allowed me to begin my healing journey at the age of 19 and find my way into community college where I was able to transform my life. You know, I'd link up with mentors, got involved in community organizing, and also really saw a pathway of education as part of my liberation.
-
George Galvis
Person
Right? You Communities United for Stories, U Justice was born out of the gang injection organizing here in Oakland. And my cofounders were defendants in in the Fruitvale gang injunction. And at the time, they were being criminalized, and they were being labeled as sociopaths and all the other kinds of tropes that you can sort of imagine. And no one was actually engaging with the defendants in the...
-
George Galvis
Person
Of the of the Fruvail gang injunction to actually ask them what was their vision for the community, what were their needs. And that's how we began. And when you actually have a conversation with them, they had a very clear and articulate idea of what they wanted to improve outcomes for their community. They identified some spaces that... In which blight had been occurring, illegal dumping had been occurring.
-
George Galvis
Person
We tested the soil. We found that the soil was safe. It wasn't toxic, but they had weeds as tall as me. There was old refrigerators, tires, mattresses, and all that kind of stuff, and we cleaned it up through community effort and struggle at our own expense. And when we did the research to identify who...
-
George Galvis
Person
Well, who's the slumlord that I I allowed this blight to occur in the gang injection zone, it turned out it was the city of Oakland. It was the city of Oakland, the same city that at the time was wagging their finger and calling these guys the worst of the worst. And so our relationship with the city has transitioned. We are now a recipient of Department of Violence Prevention funding to support this work. At COURAGE, we know that every young person is a blessing.
-
George Galvis
Person
Every young person has a sacred purpose. And if they don't identify, if they don't fulfill their sacred purpose, that's not their failure. That's our failure. Right? So we start with the healing foundation, recognizing that many of the young people we're dealing with have experienced trauma.
-
George Galvis
Person
And how are we supporting them in moving from their traumatized self to their authentic self so that we can elevate their voice and power to be the authentic leaders that we know they are?
-
George Galvis
Person
We believe those who are close to the pain are close to the solution and that the young people are the experts of their own lives, and we have some of these young people actually here in the audience today, some of our Homies for Justice interns, if y'all wanna make a little bit of noise for Homies for Justice, y'all. And you also see that those who facilitated lead that program are also folks who've been there, done that.
-
George Galvis
Person
So I wanna just lift up Xochitladeus, who I met when she was 16 years old and incarcerated in the juvenile justice center. She'd been incarcerated for nearly a year.
-
George Galvis
Person
And since that time, she's been a recipient of the California Endowment Youth Power Award. She's a recipient of the Soros Justice Fellowship, and she is getting ready to graduate from college from Cal State East Bay, y'all. You know what I mean? And has been a phenomenal mentor and leader.
-
George Galvis
Person
So the fundamental point, and I'm gonna kinda summarize right now, is that it costs nearly 600,000 to $1,000,000 depending on what the average daily attendance is at any given time to incarcerate one young person here in Alameda County.
-
George Galvis
Person
And those numbers don't necessarily change radically regardless of what county that you look at. And we're talking about young people who come from the most vulnerable families in our communities. Right? So imagine if we simply shifted those resources to actually support them. There's about three things that we could accomplish.
-
George Galvis
Person
One, we address the root causes of crime. Something that, you know, the safest communities don't have the most jails or prisons. They actually have the most resources. Right? Two, it's more cost efficient.
-
George Galvis
Person
It would cost a fraction that we don't need to spend a million dollars a year on one young person. You know what I'm saying? To change their life. And... Damn, I forgot my third point.
-
George Galvis
Person
any case in any case, what we've seen is a lack of investment. You know, budgets are reflections of our values. And when there have been opportunities, we haven't necessarily seen those investments occur in... From the ground up in supporting frontline communities and in supporting credible messengers. And because those of us who's overcome the challenges that these young people are confronted with are oftentimes the best ones...
-
George Galvis
Person
With the ones who are best equipped to actually support them in making life affirming decisions. So thank you. Thank you, sir.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
Thank you so much. Hello, everybody. Nice to see you. My name is Brian Kaneda. I'm the deputy director of CURB, Californians United for a Responsible Budget.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
We are a coalition of more than a 100 organizations that are working to reduce the number of prisons and jails, reduce the number of people in them, and shift wasteful spending towards the things that most of us know actually keep people safe. Housing, jobs, all the important stuff that we know communities need. CURB has been in coalition for about twenty five years, and we do public education and also work on legislative stuff. Coordinator.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
We're a co founder of, Justice LA, which helps stop, LA County's $3,600,000,000 jail plan.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
We also, as part of Reimagine LA County, helped pass, Measure J in 2020, which Assemblymember Brian was, an architect, and defended that one just recently bypassing Measure E in LA County, which, fixed the county's mistake, by erasing, measure j, driving 10% of, net county cast to, community investment. So, yeah, we're we're super proud, of that and and to be here.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
There's so much to focus on right now, and we know just the level of need that we're inundated with both federally and at the state level and locally. And so I think these types of conversations are just really helpful to reground all of us in our respective values and where they intersect and what we can do together. And the big one, I think, and this is a great place to talk about it, is racial justice.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
Probably one of the few groups of people that I don't have to make like that pitch to of why it's important, especially when we have, you know, 27% of, the prison population being black folks, when only six to 10 pop... Percent of the population is is, black here in California, and how Latinx indigenous people, Asian folks are also, horribly, overrepresented.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
That being said, in this blue wave that we've seen and in this push towards organizations like the DSA, I see two groups really being thrown under the bus or forgotten about, and that's black folks and trans people. And I think that, you know, as we celebrate some of these wins, we have to remember that there is a group of people who are being ignored or left behind.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And I remember hearing AOC make remarks I don't know if you all heard that configuration and how it was, you know, maybe we went too far.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And when people are saying that, they're talking about trans rights and they're talking about Black Lives Matter. And so I just want us to remember as we, like, embrace this moment that there's actually, like, a lot of work still to do for a really inclusive cross sector movement towards, racial justice here. And on that note, strengthening those laws, I think are really, really important right now.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And we want to thank Assembly Member Kalra who helped author the Racial Justice Act, which is a really, really huge deal. And strengthening the Racial Justice Act going forward and ensuring that similar laws are passed, I think is really, really essential to sort of, ensuring that black folks and people of color aren't left behind in a lot of the conversations that we're having.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
The other piece around sentencing too is I hear a lot about, you know, Norway. Lots of people have visited Norway and wanna talk about the California model. They wanna talk about prisons make them versions of that by creating shiner, nicer cages for people to be in.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And it's interesting to me whenever I hear people talk about Norway, because they're never talking about the sentencing, guidelines that happen in Norway, where people, like, receive a maximum of twenty years for even some of the worst, crimes that people can be convicted for. They never talk about expanding the social safety net the way Norway interrogate the Norway system itself, which is actually incredibly racist towards migrants, and has a lot of issues on its own that a lot of really smart people have written about.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So it's something that I think needs to be unpacked a little bit that's kind of just taken for granted by folks, who are well meaning and intend for things to be less bad, in a prison and conditions of confinement. But, you know, let's be careful with what we're talking about. So I really encourage people to listen to some other critiques that are coming out around the California model and initiatives like that. Two pieces around that, especially the first is around elders.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
There are, about 19,000 people who are age 55 and older in the California prison system. And right now, what we're seeing as part of CDCR's $73,000,000,000 twenty year master infrastructure plan is this movement towards making some prisons into basically like expensive old age. And, you know, the average cost of keeping someone in prison is about $133,000 a year. But a lot of you might know, and we're talking about elders or people who are medically compromised, $300,000 $400,000 a year.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
With cancer, in a prison. Even along those lines, the more, evolved version of that that people are starting to get behind are MCRPs and FCRPs. So those are community... They're called community reentry programs. But really what they are are just miniature prisons.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
Excited about this idea of, like, figuring out a way to make incarceration somehow less harmful. We have to figure out how to do that without actually expanding the system of incarceration and investing billions of dollars. Expanding the system of incarceration and investing billions of dollars into what is essentially many prisons in people's communities. So we're really excited to be, like, in deep with our reentry partners. Two presentations to LARP about, Measure E really recently.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And I think, like, that's really key is, like, how do we do reentry that's community led and doesn't actually expand the system of incarceration that we know that's so harmful to people. And so a lot of this stuff is like wolf in sheep's clothing. And there are a lot of people that I respect that are involved in like CRPs and and thinking about moving them forward and people who were really values aligned with.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So figuring out like for those people who going forward with that, how to push back against people who want to make what already exists worse, less attractive option for people versus just releasing them. Most people who are in CRPs, they have about two years left on their sentence, ankle monitors and in community and seeing their families.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And we're a little confused as to if someone is safe enough to be out in the world, out in the community, why they're not just safe enough to be released early. So that's something we really want to explore, and unpack. The other piece is prison closures. Both the House and the, Assembly, for the first time, passed a recommendation to close prisons, which is supported by the state's own legislative analyst office. Of the final budget.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
There's a, a new administration in town. And historically, the legislature, has been very responsive to us and having conversations about what matters. It is a a black hole of knowledge and information when it comes to the administration. So really figuring out how we can be in partnership with the legislature to better communicate figure out, like, how we can all better work together.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So all of the efforts that the legislature undertakes, the community undertakes during the budget process doesn't just, like, get the heave ho as soon as, like, you know, three people get into a smoke filled room together.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So we really appreciate everyone's continued efforts toward decarceration and just, like, the true understanding that California, for all of our, you know, vaunted progressiveness, incarcerates more people than most countries. And so, you know, it wasn't controversial to say a few years ago, oh, prior to 2016, prison, even Republicans agree with that. So I'd like to get us back to a place where we, just as a society, understand that, you know, prisons aren't making us safer.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. Also, I should point out that in Norway, you're allowed to vote in prison.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
Hello. How are you guys doing? And thank you for having me. My name is Nedrick Miller. I'm the policy analyst for legal services of prisoners with children and all of us are none.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
I come to you today because I'm worried. So this is something that's unspoken of, and it comes from all of our communities, especially when you're impacted. So I grew up in LA. I had the ability to come to Sacramento State and change my life, but it was through steps and just me recognizing that there's pitfalls. So my worry is those that are formerly incarcerated come out, and there's like a plateau phase.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
We're not allowed to pursue career based opportunities. It seems like everything is cut off. There's federal regulations. If not federal regulations, there's society stigma. We're expected after long periods of time.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
I did eighteen years. We're expected after this time to come out and just be happy. Happy is not success. Happy is not living your life. The fact that we're not allowed to pursue things that fit our interests so we can be members of society and contribute, it kinda...
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
It hurts me. So coming out here, I went to community college. I graduated with natural science and mathematics degree. I went to Sacramento State. I graduated in kinesiology.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
I was pursuing my master's for biological research. With that, I was a part of project rebound. Something that... Don't get me wrong. It's an athlete.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
Policy is encouraged. Advocacy is encouraged. This seems to be the only sector where people who are formerly incarcerated can get a job to live successful. And that kinda like... It's shocking to me that 95% of the people who get out and pursue higher education can only do this because other sectors won't allow us.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
There are many just like me, though we are outliers. There's chemists. There's engineers. There's many more. And every door is closed.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
So I came here today to ask you, what is the expansion of, you know, employment sectors looking like for people that are formerly incarcerated? Because to me, when you release people and they're free, but you don't give them the ability to create a solution or have a solution, it's a problem.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
And what I think a lot of times, and nobody says this, when you block barriers and pathways and people that have the ability, not just us, but members that sit in front of us, have the ability to actually change that narrative and change that opportunity, when that's not done, you encourage your set ofism. A lot of times, we're going back into these communities where they lack resources. I grew up on 89th Of Western.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
I'm a Western of Century, baby. I'll tell you that. I've been there all my life, and that's how I grew up. We don't have it. We don't have the best education.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
I was a high school dropout. I got my GED as a new Corcoran. So a lot of us aren't succeeding, and a lot of a lot of us aren't given that ability. And one thing I used to always hear in poli Sci is we have access. Access means nothing if we don't know where it's at.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
So I sit here in front of you, and you know I love all you. I mess with all you. But it's a real need and an encouragement for people who are coming back into society to be successful. I hate hearing the narrative where they think we only wanna commit crime or we wanna stay just with the lack of. It's not that.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
When everything is closed and you're giving your best, what else do you have? Survival is your only means, and I just feel like it needs to change.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
So I'm here. Hey, everyone. Thank you. First and foremost, thank you all for this opportunity to be here before you all. My name is Efrain Ortiz.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
I'm the membership and outreach coordinator with Initiate Justice. At Initiate Justice, we fight we fight to end in mass incarceration, back... Creating the power of those directly impacted by it. As you hear before, our panelists here, many of us have been impacted by the carceral system. Many of us here in this room have been impacted by the carceral system.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
And what does this look what does this look like for initiate justice? How do we build that bet... How do we build that democracy for California that includes all of us? Right? We've had some great success in the past, cosponsoring with ASH CARRA, the RJA, and many other bills.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? We passed proposition 17, in 2020. We're a cosponsor on that, you know, restoring voting rights for those that are formerly incarcerated. You and I had a conversation earlier where it made me so proud during the... These elections to see so many formerly incarcerated people posting those I voted stickers.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? Being proud to vote, being proud to have their voices heard. You know, at initiate justice, we have this inside outside strategy approach. Many of you... I I don't have to preach to the choir.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Many of you all sitting here before me have gone inside these prisons. Right? Inside, we have a civic engagement training program where we teach people the legislative process. We teach them how to empower themselves. We teach them how to advocate for themselves.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Some of those letters have made it to the Assembly floor, to the Senate floor, to to committee hearings, right, where they testified even though they couldn't be there in person, their letters were read in these committee hearings. That's powerful. Right? Because you're hearing directly from the people that it's directly impacting. Out here, we have a program called the Institute of Impacted Leaders where we train...
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
We have trained... We have graduated over 23 cohort throughout the state of California, 450, outside organizers that have gone through that program. You know? And the numbers are amazing. Right?
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
But more than the numbers is the quality of the the people that are coming there. Right? Back when I was growing up, we talk about like when I got incarcerated, I started learning, really working on myself. I learned about the ripple effect, right? The ripple effect of our crimes, the ripple effect that we cause, the harm that we cause, and how it really go expands out into our communities, not just the direct person that we've harmed.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
This is how we're changing that. Right? Because when we're training one person, when we're... And I don't even wanna say training. I wanna say empowering.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? Teaching them that they already had this in them. Right? When we teach that one person, he's taking... They're taking it...
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
He or she, they're taking it on to their organizations. They're taking it back to their communities. They're taking it back to these prison yards. Right? These are the leaders that are changing their environment inside these prison yards.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
These are the leaders that are changing the environments in our community. And I will say that it's not just initiate justice, right? We don't do this alone. We do this with all our amazing community partners, many of you, many of who are in this room right now. And I wanna say that we know for a fact, you know, growing up, I searched for belonging, right?
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
I joined my neighborhood because I wanted to belong. I wanted to be a part of something. We know civic engagement creates that. It creates a sense of purpose. It creates a sense of belonging.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
It helps it helps us stay out of prison. In some cases, it helps create... We help create roads that don't have to lead to prison. Right? And I wanna applaud you, Isaac, Brian, and many that worked on on the HUGS Act.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? We too, we have a program currently at Pleasant Valley State Prison where we started a bill clinic with our our organizers inside. They drafted up three or four bills at the end of last year, beginning of this year, and we knew it was gonna be a tough political climate. We asked them, which one do you want us to push?
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
And it was a social emotional learning bills for all k through 12 schools, AB 1851, which sadly, you know, didn't make it through the Senate appropriations, but it was drafted by those individuals.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
When we asked them why that bill when they had other bills that could bring them home earlier or reduce their sentence or, you know, give them other options, They said because we didn't want the young ones to be in the shoes that we're at right now. And that to me is powerful. That is selfless, not selfish. Right? So we know for a fact that this works.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
We wanna continue to bring this to various communities. I wanna encourage you all here sitting before me to continue to go inside those prisons, to sit in these rooms with individuals, to go into the detention centers, because there's some people that I broke bread with in there that I'd rather have my... As my neighbors right now than some of my neighbors that I have now. I'll tell you that. Right?
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
So I wanted to say that. Right? Like... And and and, again, the whole thing, this is the power that people already have in them. We're just simply empowering them.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
We're giving them that extra little nudge. Right? Now these organizers that we have outside are leading in district visits with state representatives, with their staffers. Right? We're helping train others, but we're empowering them to actually take on that leadership role, to bring others into the fold.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? Because we belong in these tables. We know that already. We belong in that capital. I remember my first time out of prison stepping into that capital.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
It felt so weird. You know? And now I'm like, I dab every... All you up. I give you all hugs, like, because I know I belong there.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
You know? We all belong there. So I wanna say... You know, I wanna say to those listening today, to those in this room, our voices matter, our experiences matter, our past does not define us. We need to be the ones in these rooms helping shape these laws, these policies to build the California that we want.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Right? Because democracy shouldn't just work for us, it should be shaped by us.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Now turn it back to my colleagues on the dice. Any questions, comments?
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
I feel like I just got called out. A little stare down over here.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Okay. First of all, thank you all so much for sharing your perspectives and really, I think, helping us to see and dig into areas that we really do need to be thinking more about.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
I have a few questions, So I don't know if I should ask them all or try to give a little space, but, I think the first question I have is for Nedrick around recognizing what you talked about, the extent to which I sit on BMP, business and professions, and I think a lot of...
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
As we think about licensure, you know, where those barriers are as we think about chemists and engineers and, right, all these different kind of boards that we that we are ultimately, you know, continuing to support. Where have you seen opportunities if at all?
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Right? Like, have you seen any of any of these boards that have been open to shifting? Like, for instance, I feel like... I don't know if it was... Aye...
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Chair Brian or somebody else, but, like, for instance, with barbering, I feel like there's been some shifts as an example. Have there been any, successes? And maybe beyond California, have you seen that that there have been some some opportunities that we could really model ourselves after?
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
So in talking to people, including myself, actually experiencing it, of course, there's gonna be some successes, but they remain as outliers. 3% to the 97% is absolutely nothing. That just means you were right chance and opportunity. That's how it works out sometimes. In other sectors, no.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
There are regulations even when getting certification. Just like me, I was told, yeah, I could work in the medical field and get certified, but I'm not allowed to work in California. Okay. Thanks. That doesn't help me at all.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
It doesn't help anybody that's demonstrating they have the capabilities to do it. They're just not allowed to. A lot of things, like I said, society stigma actually harms us. A lot of corporations, institutions are quick to say that they're worried about, you know, your past life, you being incarcerated. I was even removed from a job.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
That was Walgreens. Nothing big. But they said the staff felt frightened by me. And this is from a manager that was only on for a week. What he didn't know is the people I was working with used to drive me to Sacramento State so I can get to class.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
So I know they didn't feel uncomfortable with me, but I couldn't pursue it. And it's just something that, like I said, it affects us. Also, I didn't know all the rules that go with it. I'm a be honest with you. I was kinda ignorant to the fact of what we do have as far as our benefits when somebody violates that or discriminates.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
But even without discrimination, like I said, you find that we're being rejected. Why? Because of our backgrounds. And and it's a constant. And even when we look at things like the fair chance, yes, we have it.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
Federal regulations, but there's no accountability. So if there's no accountability, what is it? Once again, that's that access problem. You can come in, but I don't have to guarantee you. Even though you may be overqualified, you might be qualified and just fit in that position, but I get to run a background check, and now I don't want to.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
Aye... I'm I'm scared of a lawsuit. That's not what our intention is. A lot of us that come out and pursue especially higher dimensions and careers, we're just trying to live our life. We're trying to find success and happiness and knowing the ability that we could do it, especially myself.
-
Nedrick Miller
Person
For me, I was like, I'm never gonna do nothing. I'm just gonna gang bang, die, sit in prison. So understand that I actually have that talent and that ability and seeing others as well that are way beyond me. It should be no need why regulations hinder us and why being released is a continuous punishment. A lot of us have done our time.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Thank you. And I did wanna say congratulations too because it's a big deal to be able to get a degree in chemistry and mathematics and biological science. Like, I just... I feel like that's always next level when you do hard sciences. So daddy.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Also, just just to respond, I do think that sitting on BNP, there's an opportunity for us to build those relationships with those various kind of govern and really think about what those regulations are so that we can figure out where can we push in, why were some of these created, how much of it is federal versus state, and how can we ensure that we're actually helping to shift that. So thank you for bringing it up. And it looks like you wanted to chime in.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
I I I think... I have other questions, but I think I'm gonna pass it to my colleagues and then come back around.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
It's... I... Thank you, Mister Chair. Samuel, I already asked the question of of Mister Miller, and I just... Following up on a...
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
Not gonna ask a question because she already asked it, but on a comment. I I think the one thing that you raised, which is so important is that I think just the idea that freedom goes beyond relieving someone of their physical condition of incarceration if we don't give them the freedom of self determination. And so, you know, and it doesn't just benefit the individual.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
If someone's passionate about being an architect or a software engineer or a teacher, we should want them to be in the field they're passionate about because that's also a greater contribution to society. So like the Assembly member said and and you also referred to the...
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
Just looking at licensures and certificate... Certifications, but it's also a behavior change. We have to get folks to get out of the mentality of of being fearful of hiring folks that were formerly incarcerated. And there's different ways to do it. You you can't necessarily...
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
You know, we have fair housing laws. It doesn't mean that people of color don't get discriminated against when it comes to rental housing or sales or housing for sale. But I think part of it is putting things on the book. The other part is a behavior change. You can use incentivizing folks to to hire folks.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
We do have some of those programs. I know the trade certainly has some of those programs as well. But, you know, we're... I'm open and I think all of us will be open to more ideas. So in the weeks and months ahead, as we head back to Sacramento, that there are very specific things we can do either in BMP or other areas.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
I know that, you know, Senator Reyes, obviously, our Chair, Brian, and others have done a lot of work in the firefighter space. I still don't know if folks are actually getting hired as firefighters though. Right? And so we can make all the laws. We can pay them, certainly more adequately than we had been traditionally.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
But when they get out, our fire department is actually hiring them. And so if that's not the case, what do we need to do to bridge that gap? And that's, I think, the tough part of of this conversation.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I've got one question, and we're gonna get to our final panel in the in the interest of of time. I know some of my colleagues have flights they have to catch. Brian, y'all probably don't know this. I'm not sure if I'm supposed to say this. I'm gonna say it anyway, and our budget Chair can come and get me if he wants to.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
But we have done surveys of the Assembly Democratic Caucus asking about prison closure amongst Assembly members. And the last time that we did it, over 50% of the Democratic Caucus believed that we should help solve some of our budget deficit concerns by closing more prisons based on the ratio of beds to people incarcerated even without letting peep... More people out. Although, I'm definitely in favor of more people coming home.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
My concern with some of that and and curious your thoughts is we often have that conversation in response to a tight budget deficit Which means we lose the reinvestment conversation.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Yeah. Because these dollars then just end up part of a larger budget deep. Is that the way we should be doing it where, you know, by any means necessary, close more prisons? Or should these should these dollars be reinvested in specific ways and pathways to reentry? And curious what what you would do if you were in charge of of this process?
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
Yes. That's the first answer to your question. God. What would I do? Well, I think something that would be really important...
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And it's challenging you all have interactions with the budget and run some budget committees, I'm sure. Like, because if we close our prison, that money just doesn't directly go to communities. You know, I think that would be really powerful as part of a road map to prison closure, and that's what the state is lacking. Like, an actual concrete comprehensive vision to close prisons in California that includes community reinvestment.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And so I think that is one of the big pieces, that a comprehensive road map to safe prison closures would include.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And, you know, you all know this. A lot of people don't care about racial justice. And the truth of this matter is that it's a budget issue. We have a structural deficit in California, and prison closure is one of the only ways to reduce year over year savings. You save a 150,000,000 annually every time a prison closes, not to mention billions in infrastructure costs that are saved by shutting down these truly ancient aging facilities.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
And I think that that's really important to understand too. To Isaac's point, you know, you can close a prison and save money, but CDCR's budget keeps going up. And I don't think there's a full understanding of, like, where all those dollars are actually going to because it's not going to, quote unquote, rehabilitation.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
CDCR's budget is about $14,500,000,000 The overall corrections budget is nearing $20,000,000,000 And I think that, you know, really thinking about this as a budget issue for maybe people who don't care about all the things that we care about, is really is really key.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So I think that that's actually really important is figuring out, like, what a comprehensive road map for prison closure looks like that does have something to do with releases, that does, ensure that the dollars that are saved by prison closure are driven back into the community.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
That there's actually a long term plan for prison closure because the LAO has done the analysis. Like, our prison population will continue to be reduced, and CDCR's twenty year plan doesn't seem to really take any of that into account. Ensuring that closed prison stay closed, a lot of folks know we help pass a bill that stopped the closed state prisons from becoming ICE detention centers, like California City.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So ensuring that closed prisons stay closed and figuring out how we can repurpose these prisons in the communities to ensure, like, they actually serve them, because prisons were sold as an economic engine to all of these communities. And last I checked, most of them were still, like, under the poverty line.
-
Brian Kaneda
Person
So, yeah, I think that that's, you know, if I were to be Assembly person for the day, Prison closure road map. Like, what does it actually mean to think about the future and how to do this in a way that's intelligent, that doesn't cost the taxpayers money, like spending millions of dollars on a roof of a prison, which is what happened, to only close it a couple years later.
-
George Galvis
Person
Can I piggyback on that real quickly? Because California did shut down its youth prison system.
-
George Galvis
Person
So in, the May budget revised of 2020, governor Newsom shut down DJJ. The problem with that was there wasn't an initiate plan. So there was a high risk of there being a net whiting effect and more young people being charged as adults going to adult prison with adult sentences. And so SBA 23 was just sort of a way that advocates, many of whom are in this room, scrambled as just a Band Aid to try to address that.
-
George Galvis
Person
But the challenges, like, just an example of Alameda County is we spent thousands and thousands of hours through the juvenile justice coordinating committee to actually put together an SBA 22 plan.
-
George Galvis
Person
We presented it to our board of supervisors. Part of that plan actually included a guaranteed base income for young people while they're incarcerated so they'd have a safety net. Because a lot of our young people don't necessarily have stability. They don't necessarily have a a a stable family to come home to or or or housing or any of those things. So we we wanted to make sure we were preparing them for success.
-
George Galvis
Person
And so when we submitted it to the county board of supervisors, we forgot that we had not read the fine print of our own bill and that all they needed to do is merely accept receipt of it, and they had no accountABility to actually implement it. We've seen that happen also with AB 109 and realignment. We continue to see examples of where...
-
George Galvis
Person
To your point, Assembly member Brian, there's cost savings, but they're not necessarily operating in the benefit of community and addressing root causes of these issues. So that, I think, is critical with the closure of these DJJ's.
-
George Galvis
Person
We can look at examples from New Jersey in which they've been repurposed for public benefit or even Chukul's Justice Center in Los Angeles where the youth justice coalition is serving, you know, many impacted young people in frontline communities.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you. We're gonna go to the final panel, but our first committee hearing was at Chukos Justice Center, and we made it clear to the committee members that was a former site of incarceration for young people, now turned into a community center where healing work is taking place and education is taking place and empowerment and development is taking place. So thank you for that, reminder. Yes, sir.
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Just wanna add one thing. Just thinking about, like, building the democracy that California needs at once, With Prop 17, the passing of Prop 17, we take on onus. It's on us as a community member to educate our folks that they have the right to vote. But also, I think we need to continue the conversation of restoring voting rights for all. Right?
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
Even those that are incarcerated because it's a right. It's not a privilege. When we get incarcerated, our privileges are removed. Right? But it's not...
-
Efrain Ortiz
Person
It's our right. There's still Californians. We have a report out the road to a democracy report, which over a thousand people inside were were interviewed and challenges the stigma that people incarcerated don't care about voting. Right? So definitely, if you...
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I appreciate that. And we'll go to the final panel, but also pulling in my heartstrings because ACA 4 did exist, and I have tried to make this happen. We also know that when people who are incarcerated get to participate civically even while incarcerated, increases their connections to society, their feeling of participation in society, and reduces the chance of recidivating when they come home. So thank you for that. Thank you to the second panel.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Can we give it up for them? Our final panel is on from violence to safety, healing harms and mental health pathways for boys and men of color. We have doctor Serrano, Christian, and Baba Hodge. I wanna come down. Man, I like calling you doctor now.
-
George Galvis
Person
Yeah. You can better than that. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. Thank you.
-
Unidentified Speaker
First of all, thank you so much to everybody involved in in making today possible in in this, allowing us to have this conversation and gathering a really dope group of people, right, to think about many topics. And so our panel, we're tasked with thinking about, what does healing look like. Right? And how does healing function as an alternative? I was specifically asked to think about what does healing look like when when it's community centered.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And I think I wanna say a couple things. The first, I think, is just recognizing and naming that black, brown, boys, and young people of color are deserving of healing. Right? And what I mean by that is that oftentimes, so many of our institutions, from social welfare institutions, from our schools, from social work, right, don't think of black and brown youth as deserving of healing, of, mental health resources, of joy, of fun, and second, third, fourth, fifth opportunities. Right?
-
Unidentified Speaker
And so while I was asked to think about healing, I also wanna say that part of why I I've been thinking about healing for the last decade is is because I've also been thinking heavily about policing. Thank you. And so I really appreciate this opportunity to think about healing because I spent the last two years thinking about what healing looks like, why we need healing programming, and what benefits of community center healing are there for young people, specifically for boys and young men of color.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And so to answer these questions, I've met with young people from all over LA County.
-
Unidentified Speaker
So I spent the last decade talking to black Latinx boys and really hearing gut wrenching stories of how policing, and and not just policing in a blue uniform, right, but also teachers and other folks in and out of schools, threaten their safety and emotional wellbeing. And so, in fact, I've published articles that show that black and Latinx boys experience policing as early as six years old, and that continues throughout their young lives.
-
Unidentified Speaker
So oftentimes, when they're entering adulthood, they've already experienced the harms of police violence and inequality, but are also witnessing the policing, deportation, and incarceration of their loved ones, and have firsthand accounts, right, of how shifting, how the shifting political and economic landscape is hurting them at multiple levels.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And so there's another important thing that I've learned throughout this work, and that is that boys and young men of color have very few spaces to actually heal, but also process, right, the harms of policing, incarceration, deportation, inequality, and other forms of violence.
-
Unidentified Speaker
But fortunately, I've also learned from over a 100 community organizers in California and across the country who have developed and are implementing approaches to healing that in many ways, the secret sauce in this work and this approach is that there are alternatives to usual punitive or hostile context you always young boys of color navigate. So instead, these community center approaches center collective healing through programming that integrates art, culture, political education, and programming that discusses everything from gender, masculinity, sexuality, history, history, and so much more.
-
Unidentified Speaker
They often provide access to resources and tools that schools fail to provide.
-
Unidentified Speaker
In fact, I would argue, right, that the healing for boys and young men of color depends on fostering spaces where they can ask questions, learn, feed their curiosities about identity, difference, and power. But what does that look like? It can look like carefully planned programming offered after school, a healing retreat.
-
Unidentified Speaker
If any of you have been long enough here around long enough, there used to be a Sunson Brothers camp where a lot of us, when we were young, used to go to participate in healing circ... I used to. Yes. That's where I met Sean for the first time. But he's much younger than I am.
-
Unidentified Speaker
We're up in the Northern California Mountains. Right. So I was saying that feeds our curiosities of identity, difference in power. But it could also look like carefully planned programming after school.
-
Unidentified Speaker
But in some cases, in recognizing the nature of the violence of policing in this country, the violence of inequality, the violence of state sanctioned abandonment, it also must be practitioners ready to facilitate and supported by people in power to facilitate spontaneous gatherings, sessions, programmings where boys are provided time together for collective mourning and joy, for laughter, play, love, good food, always good food, fun activities, and most importantly, a space where they are allowed to be vulnerable, free of judgment, and free of criminalization.
-
Unidentified Speaker
I think that's also key to a lot of this work is that oftentimes, schools and other places are not places where boys and young men like color could be vulnerable, are not places where they can ask questions, free of judgment or free criminalization. And I would argue that's also true for a lot of young, girls of color too. Right? You know, I'll end with a couple, with one thing.
-
Unidentified Speaker
I I'm working with the sons. No. The Brothers on Sales Coalition on a survey that they collected with over, they surveyed over a 100 young people in LA County.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And we're in the process of writing a report and thinking about campaigns and so forth using that. But there was one question that I asked the young people to if they have adults that care for them and that they trust it, only half of survey respondents, about 50%, reported they have an adult that cares for them and that they trust in and out of schools.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And so I wanna leave us to that to also contextualize the current state of things, but also why it's important to reimagine safety and healing, alternatives that are not rooted in more police, incommunization, surveillance, and so on.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
That was great. Glad I'm coming after you. Can build off a little bit of what you were saying. But, hello, everyone. My name is Christian Beauvoir.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
I use he/him pronouns. I'm with the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color. We're a network of over 200 organizations from across the state that work on racial and gender justice issues. I'm the lead organizer on our Healing Together campaign where we do the work to end gender based violence and really think about what is the role that men and masculine identified folks play in disrupting gender based violence and disrupting patriarchy.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
And thinking about that at a systemic level, but also thinking about that on the interpersonal level.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
You know, we look at the ways. Uria was talking about how, like, young boys and men need to to heal from the harms that have happened, but also think about, like, what does accountability look like in our lives? Making sure that our healing is not and our safety is not at the cost of other people in our communities, but thinking about, like, are there opportunities for healing and accountability that are rooted in compassion and dignity rather than shame, harm, further criminalization.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
Earlier, the question was asked about OPD's response time versus macro response time, and it just made me think that it's it's not really about, like, how fast sometimes. It's about who are the people that are responding. Is this a person that makes you feel safe? And the research shows that in our communities, oftentimes, police are not called because it makes a person feel safer. It's because there's not another option that is available.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
So we're trying to do this work to create more options so that survivors have options, so that people who were, raised in an environment that taught them that domination was okay in their relationships, that this is actually the way that I interact with my partner and the other people that I care about, have resources that can can work with them to find something different.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
There's a a call for change helpline is is an organization we work with, and it's a completely anonymous confidential helpline for people who are doing harm in their relationships.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
And it's this idea that actually, like, before a person is arrested, are there resources we can get to this person before it before it turns into a a battle intervention program, before survivors have to deal with the process of testifying in court, worried about failure to protect laws where they might lose their children, where their housing is at risk, if they have precarious immigration statuses where those things are they're more at risk, they can say, this person I love is doing this thing, and they need some support doing something different. Even if it's not with me, who can support them in doing something different?
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
So so these are the types of solutions that we're really trying to to to continue to build out things that are rooted in community. Earlier, in the last panel, we talked about closing prisons and and making sure that those funds are directed back into communities in these specific ways.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
And folks have, I've been hearing talk about, like, the importance of reinvesting that into higher education, but also reinvesting into these really beautiful culturally rooted programs that folks have been doing without any funding for generations and generations and generations. Like, bringing young men in when harm happens and saying, you messed up. You are not the worst thing you've ever done, and we're gonna have an accountability process right now.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
And the person that experienced from you. The experiences from you also has agency in what this process looks like. And there's these beautiful organizations across the state, like the CHAPP Project, like this helpline, like RISE, that that build out these beautiful programs in spite of the lack of funding, in spite of the lack of resources. And that's something we really wanna change as we're thinking about, like, what funding to and what resources and what bills to pass, we really think about, like, what are the underlying values of these solutions.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
One of our one of our partners at Growing a New Heart, who leads the Call for Change helpline, tells us. Her name is Jack Patrice. She tells us that, actually, like, the underlying value systems that you've gotten, the things that tell you that, like, domination and control are the ways that you are supposed to interact with people. Like, those are the ways to be.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
Like, those, when we address those values, and then we address the additional stressors that people are experiencing, there are massive impacts and transformation that's impossible. She has a quote that says, compassion without accountability is collusion, and accountability without compassion is domination. And we wanna make sure that we are not recreating the same domination that people are already experiencing, that we are not trying to violence people out of their violence, dominate people out of their domination. Yeah. So thank you very much.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you. And before we go to you, Baba Hodge, I just wanna point out that Senator Valencia has previously had a select committee and hopefully will continue to have a select committee that is complimentary to this work that talks a lot about least one of the hearings I participated in talked about the role that social media has in perpetuating that culture for our young boys, and how difficult it is to break these ideas that dominance and red pill behavior are are the way to a society rooted in compassion and healing.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And so, hopefully, there's opportunities for further connection here because I think there might be some things that could be helpful. Absolutely.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, mister chair. Not to deviate from the panel, but that point, it's hitting on such a macro level. And these new terminologies about toxic masculinity and the worst traits that men can exert. Right? I think we need to redefine them and separate them.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
I go out on the ledge sharing with folks in these conversations that men can exert the most toxic of traits, but masculinity in and of itself, to your point, should be the best of what men can provide to society. And through guidance and mentorship, we can achieve that and set those parameters. So I think these conversations intersect, and that's why it's so important to keep these conversations alive. So thank you for that work.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Cool. Good afternoon, everybody. The first thing I wanna do is just acknowledge that everybody in this room has said something important, and everybody who's sitting here, give yourselves a big round of applause because... Come on. Y'all do better than that.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
You're in the town now. And and the reason I do that is because all of this work matters. I wanna thank you all for being here, and I have a trivia question. When did this committee start? Nope.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Assemblymember Perez and our representative, Sandra Swanson, started this work. And the reason I get to bring that up is because I think I'm the OG in the room on the panels.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
I might not be the OG OG in the room, but I'm with the Brotherhood of Elders Network. We're an intergenerational network of African American men who've been doing work for the last little bit more than a decade formally. And the things I wanna talk about are really gonna be centered on if I think about the Assembly Select Committee on boys and men of color, first of all, boys and men of color grow up in community. They don't grow up in programs.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
They don't grow up in carceral situations. They grow up in community. So whatever we can do around the three things, I'm going to just throw a couple of themes out: repair, reinvest and reimagine. So repair, reinvest and imagine. The reparations bills that you've been working on and others have been working on for the last eight years, nine years or so are really important.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
That work to actually undo redlining, to undo Jim Crow, to undo all the system systemic things that have happened to boys men of color over the last four hundred years are, is really important. To reinvest, to invest in schools, to invest in food systems, to invest in things other than incarceration are really gonna make a difference. So of the eleven.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Since 2011, you've collected, if not thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of pages of testimony from the various communities around the state of California. The first assembly select committee hearing was in Oakland. And I know you've come back a few times. Your predecessors on this body have come back a few times. I know that there has been that moment where when we, those of us in the community doing the work started calling them the boys and men of color bills.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Like, there were enough bills coming through your assembly process that made us start thinking, oh, things are actually gonna get better. And we've seen the ebbs and flows, you know, of all of that. When I think about reimagining, I think about, like, how do we reimagine the systems of care along the lines of what my friend here talked about in terms of culturally based healing practices. We're working.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We being the National Compadres Network and Hector Sanchez Flores, who leads that organization along with Jerry Teo, he's here. We've been doing work with the Office of Youth and Community Restoration and the staff there to actually work with culturally based healing practices that go beyond your typical mental health services and mental health interventions. We know that one of the leading causes of death now in our community is suicide. It's isolation. It's loneliness.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
It's depression. It's too much screen time in social media. It's the social media bullying. All of those thing things make a difference.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We've also been working in our own ways around diversion. So we have something called the Endava Court. We're partnering with the county probation with Positive Minds Group, group led by Shani Shea, Kelvin Potts, and Hakeem Owens to do a model that we've learned about in New Zealand. It goes kinda beyond restorative justice, but we're holding court for low level offenses that in every week, every month, we have several court sessions.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
And, essentially, it's community elders and parents and community healers who are working with kids to make sure that they get a plan so that they can do the kind of things that we've been talking about.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Others have talked about on this panel. The other things that we've been doing have been around the work in East Oakland, a place based initiative called the forty by forty. A month ago, Senator Arreguin came in and he spent a little time with us to learn more about that place based work. We had a national funder give us $50 million investment to match locally with $50 million from local philanthropy over the next five years to do a range of things.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Roots Community Health has been doing mental health first aid training. So to work with everyday people in the neighborhood who could recognize, understand, support people who are going through mental health crisis even before they get to macro, because we we really support the idea of macro. Macro needs to be funded three, four, five times greater than it has been based on the the earlier testimony here. That's another thing that we're involved in. We're also involved in a statewide coalition around improving the African American educator pipeline.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
The coalition is called AYA. We have partners down in Los Angeles with the Black Educator Action Network, which is Lisa Evans. We're working here locally. Back in April, we did a legislative, it wasn't advocacy day because we're all 501(c)(3)s.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We can't advocate for anything other than policy. You know, I'm giving the disclaimer. Right? The but that work involved going around the state and listening to what African American educators are saying about recruitment, retention, people who can stay involved in in educational process.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
So with that, you know, I'm gonna, stop there and and just say that the moment that we're in is really important for your leadership. What the counties are experiencing starting January 1 is gonna be significant cuts to mental health services, significant cuts to food security based on the, quote, big, beautiful bill that is not so big and beautiful. It's just big. It's not beautiful at all when it comes down to who can eat every day.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
The last thing I wanna say is just know that you are a part of history.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Last night in Mississippi, we saw history being made. I grew up in Arkansas. I didn't grow up in California. I've been in California longer than some of y'all been alive maybe, but I've been here since the eighties. And.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
But I grew up in Arkansas in a state where I grew up under segregated theaters, segregated schools, segregated swimming pools. I'm only 66 years old. This is not ancient history. But sixty years from yesterday, Megha Evers, or thereabouts, was shot and killed on his driveway as NAACP leader for trying to get people to register to vote.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
For Mississippi, goddamn. And I'm just quoting Nina Simone's song. From Mississippi to move in that way, it is it is a challenge now to the state of California and our leadership to move in some very amazing, interesting, radical ways. We cannot keep doing business as usual.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We cannot keep doing the same old, same old. Folks have to take risks that are politically sometimes risky, sometimes politically risky, but it's gonna matter in terms of the reparations, the repair, the reinvestment, and the resilience that we need to see in our community. So thank you all very much for being here, and thanks for listening.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. Now turning back to the dais. Any questions or comments, colleagues? Mister Valencia?
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Thank you, mister chair. And on that note, one of the bills that we worked on last year and I had the opportunity to author, which was a shock to me, was AB 1956. Come to find out, suicide rates for young men and boys are not tracked in the state of California. And we're such a data driven state, and often create policies around data. We pride ourselves in that.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
And despite four out of five suicides being men, we don't collect that data. So it's a stepping stone to where we need to be around the mental health issues that we're having as a society and the impact that those individuals are having on society. Right? So we definitely have to start thinking outside the box, very much appreciate the tenacity and the work over the years, but I do think that structural change is needed.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Resources go a long way, but we've also discussed how resources are either shifted or augmented, yet the problem is more severe now.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
So in addition to the resources, we really do have to have some fundamental changes to how society operates in order to have these impactful changes long term. So thank you for that.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
I'm really interested in learning a little bit more about the culturally based healing practices that you both mentioned. I think you talked a little bit a little bit about them, but I'm just wondering, because oftentimes we're talking about these, like, evidence based practices. It feels sometimes like it's kinda up against each other when the reality is we know what works for our communities and oftentimes evidence based means that they didn't really use us for evidence.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
And so just wondering if you all can share a little bit more about some examples and opportunities to even learn more or connect beyond today.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Yeah. So this this is great because my friend. I'm sorry. What's your name again? Yes.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Riel, you were at Sons and Brothers camp. I was at Sons and Brothers camp. We were doing... At that time, we were doing healing circles. So every night at this camp, we had a 125 young people there.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We break them up into groups of 20 or so, and we essentially had talking circles. We had circles that were young folks got a chance to, like, really we open with ritual. We open with libation of ancestors. We open with land acknowledgment to get it rooted culturally.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
But then, essentially, we were listening to what young people had to say. Some of it is is low level as just listening. A lot of times, adults aren't listening to what young people are saying. So they're listening. And then what happened at that camp was we heard a lot about the conditions that were facing young people in the community.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We took that work and built on six years of that camp. We've now been doing listening sessions around the state and listening to what young people are saying and what providers are saying about needing spaces that are consistent. A lot of times, you're in a in a room after school hours. You don't have the, you have to get out of the room by 05:00, whatever, to have dedicated spaces, to have people who are actually trained.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We're working with those our state partners to make sure that we understand that we can get community health worker certification for those culturally based practices so that organizations like ours and others can actually build for those services for from the state to be able to do the same kinds of work that other providers are doing, other mental health providers are doing. We talk about, and I'll I'll yield the mic to somebody else.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
But but, you know, I laugh about this evidence based practice. I have I've been, we've been flipping and saying practice based evidence. We know what works in our communities.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
We don't need necessarily to have folks from academia come in, tell us what study us and then say back to us what we know works. All of us, I'm a lawyer by training. We got social workers in our midst.
-
Baba Hodge
Person
There are folks that know know the work, but, essentially, we're saying we've seen generationally how those culturally based practices work. It's the same thing your grandmama was doing. She was holding your hand and saying, baby, tell me about it. Sit down, and we're gonna eat some good food. We're gonna make...
-
Baba Hodge
Person
Some of it is simple. Some of it is more complex. And we're not saying that we can do away with the licensed practitioners, the social health workers, the social workers, the mental health workers, those practitioners, they're all part of a continuum.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
I wanna first say that this is the model. Right? So me coming after him is wild. I won't forgive you for this. Yeah.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
But I think it's true. I really feel that right now. But Brotherhood of Elders and NCN have combat this idea in patriarchy that, like, you are an individual, that you have to deal with this thing on your own, that there is not a community that is connected to you, when the... In moments of accountability that your community is not also accountable to you. So it it really has a...
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
There's a collectivism that is part of these models that's really essential. One of one of the organizations we work with, Brown Boy Project, works specifically with transgender, nonconforming folks, and they think about, like, what does masculinity look like in our community? That, like, we have elders in our community that have been doing this work that have been caring for folks for, again, generations and came up with this model called liberatory masculinity.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
So instead of thinking again of of masculinity as this is my own thing that lives within me, I have to deal with all my emotions by myself, how do I think about my masculinity as rooted in my community, as connected to the liberation of all the people around me? And that also helped was was the foundation for us building out our power beyond patriarchy program.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
So we had a a program with, 20 young black men and masculine identified folks in a older group of black organizers. So this multi generational group that was thinking about, like, how do we internally interrogate how patriarchy is showing up in our lives, but also use this as part of our power building strategies? So thinking about, like, undoing the patriarchy that lives in us also as a power building organizing strategy.
-
Christian Beauvoir
Person
Because we also know that sometimes patriarchy is what keeps people out of movement, that people have experiences in movement where they don't feel safe, where they feel othered, where they feel like they need to be isolated, or they need to be the, they don't know how to be any position but the number one person instead of, like, a part of a collective. So that's really where where some of that stuff is coming from. But but really over here is here's the model.
-
Israel Villa
Person
I'm sorry because I know we gotta move to public comment, but I wanna share a story about the sons and brothers camp. There's a video out there of four young men reflecting out their time at one of these camps. And about the camp, right, we all would get there on a Sunday. We leave on a Saturday morning. So it's about five days of us doing the healing circles, the retreats.
-
Unidentified Speaker
One time they're trying to make us climb a wall, not the organizers, the staff. Didn't work well. Well, we crossed it. We did jump in really well. But in that video where they asked four young men, and, unfortunately, one of them is no longer with us.
-
Unidentified Speaker
Right? They're, like, asking about the impact of this camp. And for many of them, this is the first time they're at this camp. Right? This is the first time they participate in a healing reprogramming.
-
Unidentified Speaker
And I have an itch in my head right where they say, we got here from all over parts of California, Fresno, Inglewood, all these different places, and the organizers poured so much love into us. And then one of them says, this is the shit that people think is impossible, and they did it in five days. Right?
-
Unidentified Speaker
And so I I I I carry that so much with me, right, to to also kinda guide and motivate how we think about programming and at what levels and multiple levels that it's required, that is everything from the interactional to the more structural way. And then they end the video where I like, oh, I love you so much.
-
Unidentified Speaker
I'm gonna take care of your kids. And one was like, I won't take care of your kids. But I do love you.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Well, I wanna thank this panel and all the panelists so far. Also, I love doing hearings in community because I'm definitely not about to police your testimony in the same way we would in a hearing room in Sacramento. I think the richness and the authenticity that comes from being in spaces like this, is what grounds good policy making. So I'm I'm grateful for you all. And I'm thinking about what you said about rooting our masculinity as in the liberation of all around us, but also as an organizing tool.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And for folks who haven't seen the feminist in Cellblock, why? Richie Rasita, you should. Songs from the Whole, all of the above. But thank you all for being here.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
It's not super customary for select committees to have public comment, but I saw young people come in. No. You're good. We're gonna do it anyway. I saw young people come in.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I saw some young boys and men come in. In. I saw some young girls come in. And also, I think it's very powerful. You can tell the status of boys and men of color by the status of women in our communities.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
They're inextricably linked. And so we're gonna open that microphone up there for thirty second public comment for anybody who wants to come up and give thirty seconds, including our San Francisco public defender. I'm not sure if he is still in the room, but I saw you, brother. You you you've been seen, but thank you to panel three.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
So anybody who would like to give a thirty second public comment, please come up to the microphone. Tell us who you are and. Yes, sir. And remind us that you're from Salinas.
-
Israel Villa
Person
Alright. I haven't worked with you yet, sir, but if you're here, I'm sure you're on the you're on the right side. But I really appreciate y'all. When this Vato Trump won the president a couple years ago, I was kinda sad like other folks and mad and things like that. But then I was excited because I've been hearing about the super blue majority over here in California that they talk about, right?
-
Israel Villa
Person
And and I was excited because I thought we were gonna go harder and stronger, right? But what we've seen these last couple years is very disheartening. You know what I mean? I don't know whether this. Well, maybe now this have this suit blue wave.
-
Israel Villa
Person
I guess, can y'all help, inspire and empower your colleagues? I'm with CYCJ, the California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice. And, every single bill for the last, I've been home over twelve years now, it is difficult as hell to pass every single bill. And I don't understand why, because all youth are sacred. And I think we can all agree on that, right? I guess the question is what what can we anticipate after this so called blue wave, you know, because, we don't beat around the bush, we trim it, and there's clear forces and resources attempting to take over ten years of work away from us, right? And it's frustrating.
-
Israel Villa
Person
And so I guess it's a question or a challenge or what are we gonna do different so that we don't have to be scrambling at the midnight hour for the 40 one's goddamn vote. You know what I mean? It's BS. These are our children. And if we close down the prisons, we gotta dismantle that pipeline.
-
Israel Villa
Person
We gotta starve the whole stuff from saving our children. The bottom line is Wayne going backwards, and it's very difficult, and it shouldn't be like that. And so I think we need, I know you all are our strongest ones up there, some of them, if not the strongest, but we need more because it's BS, and we don't got time to play. You know what I mean?
-
Israel Villa
Person
I think it's a good time to show folks that might be confused or or or that feel that all of our kids are just evil. You know? Or and it's also time to right side start talking about pulling down juvenile facilities. They're all empty.
-
Israel Villa
Person
You know? But I don't wanna, I think I'm already on a tangent, so I'm gonna stop. And it's over thirty seconds, but you get it. You know what I mean?
-
Israel Villa
Person
And thank y'all, though. We appreciate you. I love y'all. I really appreciate y'all, and I can't say that about a lot of people up there straight up. So thank y'all.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
So we'll answer. Thank you, sir. We'll answer that question and anything else that's said in kind of our closing remarks, and we'll just let you all go.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
We are going to hold to the thirty seconds, though, just so we don't lose more committee members before you get to to be heard, but there was no way I was stopping that. Thank you so much.
-
Gabriel Garcia
Person
Somebody give me the time warning when it comes in. Good evening, everybody. My name is Gabriel Garcia. I'm the policy and advocacy director for Youth Alive, community based organization out here in Oakland. Also a sponsor of the California Violence Intervention and Prevention Grant Program.
-
Gabriel Garcia
Person
So I wanna thank you for your support of that. Oakland ended 2025 with the lowest homicide rate on record since 1967. That is in part because of the state's investment in CalVIP. So I wanna thank you because it matters. Stopping gun violence, ending gun violence makes all the other work that the incredible people in this room.
-
Gabriel Garcia
Person
It makes life worth living. Saving lives allows that work to be possible. So we all work in tandem. Appreciate you being here. Appreciate you coming out to Oakland.
-
Gabriel Garcia
Person
Love to have you continue supporting CalVIP and victim compensation reform.
-
Joshua Jacobo
Person
Good evening, folks. Josh Jacobo, out of San Francisco Mission District, cofounder of Nuestra Causa. We work with reentry folks, people incarcerated and their families as well. One thing I just wanted us to keep in mind is our newcomers that come here and are incarcerated, and the possibilities when they get out as well as their families. It's a lot to navigate for them already just being here in the country, let alone in a situation like that.
-
Joshua Jacobo
Person
But thank you for being here, and it's very commendable. Thank you.
-
Giselle Barajas
Person
I'm Giselle Barajas, and I'm a youth, a part of Homeless for Justice, which is part of courage here. And I think it was really inspiring to see people who have a position of power in this in this state who are actually willing to listen to people who are part of the community. Because sometimes I do, I will say as a youth, I do feel disheartened.
-
Giselle Barajas
Person
Well, now I feel more heartened because the blue wave, but I do feel disheartened sometimes because they're like, do these people really care? And now that I'm seeing that you guys care, I'm like, I really feel like there will be more change, especially for those who...
-
Giselle Barajas
Person
Because I personally have not experienced incarceration, but working with so many people who have experienced incarceration and, like, all these people who are talking today are, like, genuinely amazing. And I think, like, everything they said was great and also, like, reopening up closing down any prison and using that as a community space for cultural healing for, like, even just, like, just a community space where there's, like, I don't know, maybe a bowling alley. I don't know.
-
Giselle Barajas
Person
Somewhere where youth can, like, come together and also adults can come together and require those accesses and require those resources and have those spaces too. But, yeah, it was really cool sitting here and listening to everybody, and thank you.
-
Chris Nguon
Person
Good evening, everybody. Chris Nguon, executive director, Floris and Jenna. Baba Hodge and and George just really wanna commend them. We know that, but OG's in the game for a long time, so salute to y'all and everybody in the room for real. You know, the only thing I wanna lift up in this really, really important conversation is the ecosystem once our boys and men come home.
-
Chris Nguon
Person
I do work. I'm from West Oakland, do work in the acorn community. And what I hear from the youth consistently is that not only there's nothing to do, but there's no resources for them and their families once they come home. So when we think about repurposing space, repurposing prisons, right, just really rethink about investing in space to really thinking about the wrap around holistic point of view to be able to support our young people and our men when they home too. So that's my 30.
-
Mano Raju
Person
Hi, everyone. Mano Raujio. I'm the elected public defender for San Francisco. I really appreciate you all coming down to this space here to have this hearing and appreciate all the wisdom I've learned about here from spaces and people coming back home. And I just wanted a reminder that everyone who is in this system deserves more attention and more time, period.
-
Mano Raju
Person
And for that, we have a public defender underfunding problem, and that's why we're pushing for more of us, whether it's social workers, paralegals, attorneys to spend more time with each client that we represent. Because the reality is a lot of people are doing a lot more time than they should be. And if we were defending at a higher level on the front end, we can avoid that.
-
Mano Raju
Person
And that's a big part of this reentry process is preventing so much incarceration on the front end, and that's a big part of this conversation. I think we have to continue having.
-
Mano Raju
Person
So appreciate all of you, and I look forward to working with you in the next four years because I was just reelected on Tuesday. So.
-
Grecia Resendez
Person
Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Grecia Resendez. I'm a policy analyst with the Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice. I'm also a mother of two boys, a five year old and an 18 year old, and it makes me really happy just to see all the work that's being done for young men of color in this space. And I also wanted to tap in that CJCJ is pushing a bill this year to advocate for the closure of more prisons, but to redirect that money into higher education.
-
Grecia Resendez
Person
It's super important that not only we keep our young boys out, but that we give them a pathway going forward. And the CSUs are particularly struggling because they're not earmarked with any funding, so we really wanna see that. We're working with ABMOC on it and CFA which is the Teachers Union at SFSU. Thank you.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Thank you so much. With that, I'll turn it back to my colleagues for any final comments. Starting with Assemblymember Elhawary, my seatmate.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Bestie. I'm so proud to be able to be here to, be in community with you all and to hear from everybody. So thank you again, especially for those who ended us with public comment. I wanted to say a couple of things. I'm gonna be the new progressive caucus chair as of January, which is...
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
Thank you for the love. Totally not what I was doing it for. I promise. But just to say, we have a lot more progressives that are gonna be in our in our our our caucus this year. We have folks that are just finding out literally today, tomorrow that they are officially elected to the state assembly, folks who who are FTP all day.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
And so, like, just thinking about what it means for us to be able to have real conversations about how we can push, I think it's important that we don't we don't avoid the conversations to be more radical, and I think that is really important.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
We have incredible colleagues who are up here, but to know that we're bringing in more colleagues, we won't have to fight as hard for 41, which will be exciting.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
I also just wanted to say, we worked with some folks in this room on the Thrive Act, and so part of thinking about what those culturally based healing practices are as a way to be thoughtful about what it takes for us to really ultimately know that, you know, we wanna provide opportunities for mental health, for supports when folks experience gun violence in our communities because we know what that can do.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
And so being really thoughtful about the opportunities to dig deeper, especially with those of you who are already doing that work so that we can expand it. And then lastly, I wanted to say that I did go to Norway. I just went.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
And I do think that some of those pieces that were mentioned were very noticeable. We don't just wanna make these gates shinier. Right? Or or I think that's what what was said. But we do wanna be thoughtful about everything we can do.
-
Sade Elhawary
Legislator
What are the various angles from which we can attack the, ultimately, the problem of mass incarceration in this country, but in particular in this state. And what it takes for us to do that, I think, is looking at other models, looking at alternatives, reimagining what this system has already, you know, done and figuring out ways that we can can ultimately think about accountability from a perspective that still centers humanity, which I think we we've lost in our in our carceral system. Thank you.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
Thank you. Thank you, mister chair, and to everyone here. Another very productive moving, and important hearing of this of this committee. And as others have alluded to the blue wave and the kind of the political changes that have occurred in the last few days, which is a good thing. I I I think that we all feel some pressure relieved because there's a light at the end of the tunnel, but there's still folks being abducted.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
There's there's still, you know, there's still an occupant in the White House for the next couple years and a lot of work to do. That being said, it is an exciting time in California, not just because of, the the legislative changes and the increase, I believe, in looking at the new members coming in of folks that I think are gonna be part of the solution in in terms of reimagining public safety, reimagining justice and healing as we've been discussing about today.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
But I I I also think that the public is more aware now after seeing the cruelty of the last couple years. I think there's a there's a, there's more compassion amongst the general public, regardless of political persuasion, that there are different ways to do things.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
And I think that in some ways, there's been a sense that our soul has been lost last couple years as a nation, both domestically and internationally. I think people want to kinda regain that sense of what the possibility is, you know, that that what the possibilities are of us of having a kind of a healing community. Ultimately, the conversations and the dialogue and the insight that was given by the panelists today are incredibly important, but we're we're legislators and and we're we need to go back to Sacramento and legislate and actually put forward legislation, budget proposals that advance the conversations that were had today and at the other hearings we've had as well.
-
Ash Kalra
Legislator
And so I'm very excited about that to get back to work in January with each and every one of you and with my colleagues, because I I really do feel we're in a promising moment right now to do change unlike what we've seen in recent years.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
Before I pass it to Senator Valencia, I just wanna thank him and my colleagues again for being here. For those of you who know the legislative process, you know that we are in the recess right now. And sometimes that's the only time you can be with your family, or to restore your own health and wellness before you go back, for, you know, a ten month hustle in Sacramento. And and I promise you, there's a process you have to do mentally before you go back.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
And so to spend your birthday with us and be the best dressed on the panel, can we give it up one more time for Senator Valencia?
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
Mister chair, thank you for your continued work on this issue. The chair mentioned that we established a select committee called Pathways to Purpose for young men because of the more macro crisis that just men are experiencing, not only here in the state of California, but across the nation.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
The chair sits on that committee and has been such a vital contributor in bringing this perspective to that conversation to ensure that although this conversation, in my opinion, has gotten elevated for reasons that we may or may not agree with specifically in this room, the fact of the matter is at least it's getting elevated and we can continue to create nexuses and address the issues at its core.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
I really do believe that mentorship and ensuring that folks find a way to contribute back to society despite what the historical context is, is a pathway to purpose, and it helps people grow and it'll make society better. So I'm fully committed to those pathways.
-
Avelino Valencia
Legislator
I'm fully committed to figuring out how we get more resources to those that have lesser than in the past to ensure that tomorrow we have a better future. So with that, thank you for participation, and I look forward to the work ahead.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
In closing, I just wanna thank all of our panelists, for making the time to share your expertise, with the state of California. And I wanna thank all of the community who showed up. We never failed to pack a room for these hearings, whether it's in LA, in Oakland, in Sacramento, and it is because you all care and are organized, and are ready to make changes and to make a difference.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
I'm very proud of the work this committee carried on this year and the legislation we were able to get passed into law and the work that we were able to build upon, but the work is is ongoing. And change isn't a one time event.
-
Isaac Bryan
Legislator
So look for more work in the new year to come. Stay active and stay engaged, but thank you all for participating today. This concludes the hearing on the status of boys and men of color.
No Bills Identified
Speakers
This list may include AI predicted speakers. Speakers who could not be identified are not listed.
Advocate
Legislator