AB 66: Police: use of force.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-25
Existing sales and use tax laws impose a tax on retailers measured by the gross receipts from the sale of tangible personal property sold at retail in this state, or on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of tangible personal property purchased from a retailer for storage, use, or other consumption in this state. That law provides various exemptions from those taxes.
This bill would exempt from those taxes the gross receipts from the sale in this state of, and the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of, diapers for infants and toddlers, designated size 3 or under.
The Bradley-Burns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Law authorizes counties and cities to impose local sales and use taxes in conformity with the Sales and Use Tax Law, and existing laws authorize districts, as specified, to impose transactions and use taxes in accordance with the Transactions and Use Tax Law, which generally conforms to the Sales and Use Tax Law. Amendments to the Sales and Use Tax Law are automatically incorporated into the local tax laws.
Existing law requires the state to reimburse counties and cities for revenue losses caused by the enactment of sales and use tax exemptions.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2230 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse any local agencies for sales and use tax revenues lost by them pursuant to this bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy, but its operative date would depend on its effective date.
There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the gross receipts from the sale in this state of, and the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of, diapers designed, manufactured, processed, fabricated, or packaged for use by infants and toddlers, designated size 3 or under.
SEC. 2.Notwithstanding Section 2230 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any sales and use tax revenues lost by it under this act.
SEC. 3.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. However, the provisions of this act shall become operative on the first day of the first calendar quarter commencing more than 90 days after the effective date of this act.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2020 | Ordered to inactive file by unanimous consent. |
| Aug 26, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 20). |
| Aug 17, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 8, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (August 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 21, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 17, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 28, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 3888.) |
| Jan 23, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jan 8, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 7, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| May 7, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (May 6). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Measure version as amended on April 22 corrected. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 5, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 4, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 17, 2019 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 17, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 7, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jan 27, 2020 | AB 66 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 66 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 66
Author: Gonzalez (D), Cristina Garcia (D) and Kalra (D), et al.
Amended: 8/25/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/7/20
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Police: use of force
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill limits the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents to disperse lawful assemblies, enforce curfews, in response to verbal threats, or to enforce mere non-compliance with law enforcement directives.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/25/20 clarify that the information reported to the Department of Justice includes incidents involving shootings of a civilians, the shootings of peace officers by civilians, and incidents involving great bodily injury or death.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines a "less lethal weapon" as any devise that propels ammunition that is designed to immobilize, or incapacitate, or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(a).)
- Defines “less lethal ammunition” as any ammunition that:
- Is designed to be used in any less lethal weapon or any other kind of weapon (including, but not limited to, firearms, pistols, revolvers, shotguns, rifles, and spring, compressed air, and compressed gas weapons); and
- When used in the less lethal weapon or other weapon is designed to immobilize or incapacitate or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function, or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(b).)
This bill:
- Defines “kinetic energy projectiles” as any type of device designed as less lethal, to be launched from any device as a projectile that may cause bodily injury through the transfer of kinetic energy and blunt force trauma. For purposes of this bill, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as rubber bullets, plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam tipped plastic rounds.
- Defines “chemical agents” as any chemical which can rapidly produce sensory irritation or disabling physical effects in humans, which disappear within a short time following termination of exposure. For purposes of this bill, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as pepper balls, pepper spray or oleoresin capsicum, and CN tear gas or CS gas.
- Bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering unless all of the following conditions are met:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual;
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST); and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
- Bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency solely due to a violation of an imposed curfew, verbal threat, or mere noncompliance with a law enforcement directive.
- Specifies that despite the exceptions for the use of chemical agents, “chloroacetophenone tear gas” commonly known as CN tear gas, or 2-chlorobenzalmalononitrile gas, commonly known as CS gas, shall not be used by any law enforcement agency to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering of people.
- Provides that kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents shall only be deployed and used by officers trained on the proper use of those weapons by the POST.
- Directs that if a federal law enforcement agency is operating in the jurisdiction of any city, that city shall request that federal law enforcement agency refrain from the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disperse a lawful assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering to engage in conduct protected by the First Amendment to the United States and California Constitution.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill prevents a law enforcement agency from adopting more stringent policies.
- Requires that beginning January 1, 2023, law enforcement agencies shall begin to report to the Department of Justice (DOJ) incidents of use of less-lethal weapons, as specified.
- Creates new reporting requirements to DOJ for all of the types of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents used, the quantity, the justification for use, and whether there were injuries.
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that peace officers shall be accountable at all times to uphold their oath, and are held to the highest standards of conduct, pursuant to California Constitution Article XX, Sec. III and existing law, to support and defend the Constitutions of the United States of America and of the State of California, including the rights of the people to safely and freely speak and assemble.
- Requires every law enforcement agency shall adopt, by 2022, guidelines that shall include the following:
- A protocol for the effective deployment, rotation, and removal of officers assigned to a skirmish line to minimize the potential of officers becoming stressed, fatigued, frustrated, or visibly agitated.
- A policy that encourages officers to speak to individuals with respect and discourages the use of harsh or offensive language.
- Specifies that specified provisions of this bill do not apply within California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facilities.
- Finds and declares the following:
- Beginning the week of May 25, 2020, there have been numerous reports of peaceful protestors, along with countless other bystanders and reporters, maimed by rubber bullets and other projectiles by law enforcement.
- Kinetic energy projectiles, such as rubber or plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam rounds, and chemical agents, including pepper balls, pepper spray, and tear gas, have been increasingly used as crowd control weapons or less lethal weapons to respond to protests and are designed to incapacitate individuals by inflicting pain or sublethal injury.
- A 2017 British Medical Journal study found that 3% of people hit by rubber bullets died of their injuries and 15% were permanently injured.
- Researchers and medical professionals have called for an end of the use of rubber bullets on peaceful protestors because of their potential to cause serious injury, disability, or death.
- The 1925 Geneva Protocol categorized tear gas as a chemical warfare agent and banned its use in war. The Chemical Weapons Convention outlawed the use of tear gas in 1997, but still made it legal for law enforcement to use.
- Health experts have warned that the use of tear gas could help with the spread of COVID-19 because it irritates the lungs and makes persons cough.
- While most police departments have their own policies on their use of force and less lethal weapons, there are no statewide or national standards.
- It is the intent of this act to establish clear minimum standards for policies and reporting procedures regarding California law enforcement agencies’ use of less lethal kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents.
Background
Policymakers must consider when officers may utilize weapons that can be very dangerous to the public, but are not as lethal as the usage of fully armed firearms. Having alternatives such as electronic stun weapons, batons, shields, chemicals, and kinetic energy projectiles can limit incidents when firearms are used in a manner which could result in death or serious bodily injury more frequently.
This bill seeks to limit the usage of less-lethal weapons by law enforcement agencies. This bill specifies that kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents shall not be used to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering absent first engaging in a series of actions. The requirements to engage in the usage of kinetic energy weapons or chemical agents are outlined here. In order to use the weapons, all of these categories must be satisfied:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual,
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the POST; and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
These categories factor in the safety of officers, the public, and persons who may be in distress at the time the weapons are deployed. Additionally, as in much legislation advanced in recent years, these provisions require officers to factor in the reasonability of the usage of the weapons, as well as require notice be given when possible and that de-escalation techniques are employed. Finally, the requirements mandate that the weapons are used in a safer manner, and should not be deployed at persons who are running away from officers.
The language provides that less-lethal force may be used when “objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual” but not in defense of property. Presumably, the intent of this is to limit the usage of these methods to the prevention of physical harm to persons. However, this language would prevent the usage of less-lethal methods to prevent the harm to property.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Training and policy revisions: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs likely in the tens of thousands for all state (and local) law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with the restrictions in AB 66. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. Actual costs to each agency would vary depending on how aligned their current policies are with this bill. (General Fund, various funds). Additionally, some state (and local) law enforcement agencies may have to retrain their officers on new tactics and responses related to dispersing gatherings to the extent that the current practices of their departments are different from the provisions of this bill. The costs to retrain state law enforcement officers is unknown. Although, for context on the cost of officer training, it would cost the California Highway Patrol (CHP) $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. Related to AB 66, however, CHP has reported that there would be no additional training costs, as it already holds civil disturbance training into which the reforms proposed by this measure could be incorporated.
- Database upgrade: Unknown, one-time costs likely in the low-to-mid tens of thousands of dollars for the DOJ to upgrade information technology systems to collect and store the additional information. (General Fund)
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
AAUW – San Jose
Alliance San Diego
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Asian Law Alliance
Brady California United Against Gun Violence
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Psychological Association
California Public Defenders Association
California Teachers Association
Californiahealth+ Advocates
Californians for Safety and Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
InnerCity Struggle
National Association of Social Workers – California
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Showing Up for Racial Justice – Sacramento
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
UDW/AFSCME Local 930
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California State Sheriffs’ Association
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to Disability Rights California, “Chemical agents also have significant health impacts. Tear gas irritates cells, but also activates pain receptors, which leads to intense burning pain in the eyes, throat, lungs, skin and mucous membranes. In addition, a 2014 study from the U.S. Army found that recruits who were exposed to tear gas as part of a training exercise were more likely to get sick with respiratory illnesses like the common cold and flu. People with certain disabilities can react differently to the chemicals from tear gas exposure. The damage to people with disabilities can even be life threatening.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, “The legislative intent language is problematic and presumes law enforcement officers do not support citizen constitutional rights to “safely and freely assemble,” which is not correct. During unlawful protests, law enforcement officers are presented with are presented with circumstances dangerous to themselves and the community at large. Prohibiting the use of tear gas, which is used to clear areas from those who are actively committing crime, increases the possibility of physical force between officers and those criminal refusing to disperse. The effective use of tear gas in riotous situations can prevent the escalation of physical force used by and against law enforcement, which will result in a safer environment for everyone involved.”
Prepared by: Gabriel Caswell / PUB. S. /
8/26/20 14:53:00
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 66 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 66
Author: Gonzalez (D), Cristina Garcia (D) and Kalra (D), et al.
Amended: 8/20/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/7/20
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Police: use of force
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill limits the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents to disperse lawful assemblies, enforce curfews, in response to verbal threats, or to enforce mere non-compliance with law enforcement directives.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines a "less lethal weapon" as any devise that propels ammunition that is designed to immobilize, or incapacitate, or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(a).)
- Defines “less lethal ammunition” as any ammunition that:
- Is designed to be used in any less lethal weapon or any other kind of weapon (including, but not limited to, firearms, pistols, revolvers, shotguns, rifles, and spring, compressed air, and compressed gas weapons); and
- When used in the less lethal weapon or other weapon is designed to immobilize or incapacitate or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function, or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(b).)
This bill:
- Defines “kinetic energy projectiles” as any type of device designed as less lethal, to be launched from any device as a projectile that may cause bodily injury through the transfer of kinetic energy and blunt force trauma. For purposes of this bill, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as rubber bullets, plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam tipped plastic rounds.
- Defines “chemical agents” as any chemical which can rapidly produce sensory irritation or disabling physical effects in humans, which disappear within a short time following termination of exposure. For purposes of this bill, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as pepper balls, pepper spray or oleoresin capsicum, and CN tear gas or CS gas.
- Bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering unless all of the following conditions are met:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual;
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST); and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
- Bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency solely due to a violation of an imposed curfew, verbal threat, or mere noncompliance with a law enforcement directive.
- Specifies that despite the exceptions for the use of chemical agents, “chloroacetophenone tear gas” commonly known as CN tear gas, or 2-chlorobenzalmalononitrile gas, commonly known as CS gas, shall not be used by any law enforcement agency to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering of people.
- Provides that kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents shall only be deployed and used by officers trained on the proper use of those weapons by the POST.
- Directs that if a federal law enforcement agency is operating in the jurisdiction of any city, that city shall request that federal law enforcement agency refrain from the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disperse a lawful assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering to engage in conduct protected by the First Amendment to the United States and California Constitution.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill prevents a law enforcement agency from adopting more stringent policies.
- Requires that beginning January 1, 2023, law enforcement agencies shall begin to report to the Department of Justice (DOJ) incidents of use of less-lethal weapons, as specified.
- Creates new reporting requirements to DOJ for all of the types of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents used, the quantity, the justification for use, and whether there were injuries.
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that peace officers shall be accountable at all times to uphold their oath, and are held to the highest standards of conduct, pursuant to California Constitution Article XX, Sec. III and existing law, to support and defend the Constitutions of the United States of America and of the State of California, including the rights of the people to safely and freely speak and assemble.
- Requires every law enforcement agency shall adopt, by 2022, guidelines that shall include the following:
- A protocol for the effective deployment, rotation, and removal of officers assigned to a skirmish line to minimize the potential of officers becoming stressed, fatigued, frustrated, or visibly agitated.
- A policy that encourages officers to speak to individuals with respect and discourages the use of harsh or offensive language.
- Specifies that specified provisions of this bill do not apply within California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facilities.
- Finds and declares the following:
- Beginning the week of May 25, 2020, there have been numerous reports of peaceful protestors, along with countless other bystanders and reporters, maimed by rubber bullets and other projectiles by law enforcement.
- Kinetic energy projectiles, such as rubber or plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam rounds, and chemical agents, including pepper balls, pepper spray, and tear gas, have been increasingly used as crowd control weapons or less lethal weapons to respond to protests and are designed to incapacitate individuals by inflicting pain or sublethal injury.
- A 2017 British Medical Journal study found that 3% of people hit by rubber bullets died of their injuries and 15% were permanently injured.
- Researchers and medical professionals have called for an end of the use of rubber bullets on peaceful protestors because of their potential to cause serious injury, disability, or death.
- The 1925 Geneva Protocol categorized tear gas as a chemical warfare agent and banned its use in war. The Chemical Weapons Convention outlawed the use of tear gas in 1997, but still made it legal for law enforcement to use.
- Health experts have warned that the use of tear gas could help with the spread of COVID-19 because it irritates the lungs and makes persons cough.
- While most police departments have their own policies on their use of force and less lethal weapons, there are no statewide or national standards.
- It is the intent of this act to establish clear minimum standards for policies and reporting procedures regarding California law enforcement agencies’ use of less lethal kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents.
Background
Policymakers must consider when officers may utilize weapons that can be very dangerous to the public, but are not as lethal as the usage of fully armed firearms. Having alternatives such as electronic stun weapons, batons, shields, chemicals, and kinetic energy projectiles can limit incidents when firearms are used in a manner which could result in death or serious bodily injury more frequently.
This bill seeks to limit the usage of less-lethal weapons by law enforcement agencies. This bill specifies that kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents shall not be used to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering absent first engaging in a series of actions. The requirements to engage in the usage of kinetic energy weapons or chemical agents are outlined here. In order to use the weapons, all of these categories must be satisfied:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual,
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the POST; and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
These categories factor in the safety of officers, the public, and persons who may be in distress at the time the weapons are deployed. Additionally, as in much legislation advanced in recent years, these provisions require officers to factor in the reasonability of the usage of the weapons, as well as require notice be given when possible and that de-escalation techniques are employed. Finally, the requirements mandate that the weapons are used in a safer manner, and should not be deployed at persons who are running away from officers.
The language provides that less-lethal force may be used when “objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual” but not in defense of property. Presumably, the intent of this is to limit the usage of these methods to the prevention of physical harm to persons. However, this language would prevent the usage of less-lethal methods to prevent the harm to property.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Training and policy revisions: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs likely in the tens of thousands for all state (and local) law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with the restrictions in AB 66. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. Actual costs to each agency would vary depending on how aligned their current policies are with this bill. (General Fund, various funds). Additionally, some state (and local) law enforcement agencies may have to retrain their officers on new tactics and responses related to dispersing gatherings to the extent that the current practices of their departments are different from the provisions of this bill. The costs to retrain state law enforcement officers is unknown. Although, for context on the cost of officer training, it would cost the California Highway Patrol (CHP) $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. Related to AB 66, however, CHP has reported that there would be no additional training costs, as it already holds civil disturbance training into which the reforms proposed by this measure could be incorporated.
- Database upgrade: Unknown, one-time costs likely in the low-to-mid tens of thousands of dollars for the DOJ to upgrade information technology systems to collect and store the additional information. (General Fund)
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
AAUW – San Jose
Alliance San Diego
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Asian Law Alliance
Brady California United Against Gun Violence
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Psychological Association
California Public Defenders Association
California Teachers Association
Californiahealth+ Advocates
Californians for Safety and Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
InnerCity Struggle
National Association of Social Workers – California
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Showing Up for Racial Justice – Sacramento
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
UDW/AFSCME Local 930
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California State Sheriffs’ Association
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to Disability Rights California, “Chemical agents also have significant health impacts. Tear gas irritates cells, but also activates pain receptors, which leads to intense burning pain in the eyes, throat, lungs, skin and mucous membranes. In addition, a 2014 study from the U.S. Army found that recruits who were exposed to tear gas as part of a training exercise were more likely to get sick with respiratory illnesses like the common cold and flu. People with certain disabilities can react differently to the chemicals from tear gas exposure. The damage to people with disabilities can even be life threatening.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, “The legislative intent language is problematic and presumes law enforcement officers do not support citizen constitutional rights to “safely and freely assemble,” which is not correct. During unlawful protests, law enforcement officers are presented with are presented with circumstances dangerous to themselves and the community at large. Prohibiting the use of tear gas, which is used to clear areas from those who are actively committing crime, increases the possibility of physical force between officers and those criminal refusing to disperse. The effective use of tear gas in riotous situations can prevent the escalation of physical force used by and against law enforcement, which will result in a safer environment for everyone involved.”
Prepared by: Gabriel Caswell / PUB. S. /
8/25/20 14:37:49
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 66 (Gonzalez) - Police: use of force
Version: July 21, 2020 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 20, 2020 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 66 would limit the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents, as those terms are defined, by law enforcement.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 20, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
- Training and policy revisions: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs likely in the tens of thousands for all state (and local) law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with the restrictions in AB 66. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. Actual costs to each agency would vary depending on how aligned their current policies are with this bill. (General Fund, various funds)
Additionally, some state (and local) law enforcement agencies may have to retrain their officers on new tactics and responses related to dispersing gatherings to the extent that the current practices of their departments are different from the provisions of this bill. The costs to retrain state law enforcement officers is unknown. Although, for context on the cost of officer training, it would cost the California Highway Patrol (CHP) $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. Related to AB 66, however, CHP has reported that there would be no additional training costs, as it already holds civil disturbance training into which the reforms proposed by this measure could be incorporated.
- Database upgrade: Unknown, one-time costs likely in the low-to-mid tens of thousands of dollars for the Department of Justice (DOJ) to upgrade information technology systems to collect and store the additional information. (General Fund)
Author Amendments:
- Require law enforcement agencies to include in its policy, by January 1, 2022, guidelines on deployment to protests, demonstrations, assemblies, and similar gatherings of people, as specified.
- Strike the change to monthly reporting by law enforcement agencies.
- Clarify what information would be required to be reported to DOJ with respect to incidents involving kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents.
- Specify that CN tear gas or CS gas are not to be used by any law enforcement agency to disperse any assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering.
- Exempt correctional facilities within the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation from the provisions of this bill.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 66 (Gonzalez) - Police: use of force
Version: July 21, 2020 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 17, 2020 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 66 would limit the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents, as those terms are defined, by law enforcement.
Fiscal Impact:
- Training and policy revisions: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs likely in the tens of thousands for all state (and local) law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with the restrictions in AB 66. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. Actual costs to each agency would vary depending on how aligned their current policies are with this bill. (General Fund, various funds)
Additionally, some state (and local) law enforcement agencies may have to retrain their officers on new tactics and responses related to dispersing gatherings to the extent that the current practices of their departments are different from the provisions of this bill. The use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents by Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) officers in dispersing a gathering of people is not uncommon. Considering the department’s current reliance on the practice, there could be significant-to-major costs for CDCR to develop and implement an alternative tactic. The costs to retrain CDCR officers is unknown. Although, for context on the cost of officer training, it would cost the California Highway Patrol (CHP) $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. Related to AB 66, however, CHP has reported that there would be no additional training costs, as it already holds civil disturbance training into which the reforms proposed by this measure could be incorporated.
- Monthly data reporting & collecting: Unknown, potentially-significant costs in the thousands of dollars to law enforcement agencies to shift the reporting of use of force data from annually to monthly. Local costs to comply with this change would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. Considering that there are over 500 local law enforcement agencies across the state, costs to implement this measure could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars in the high end. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
The Department of Justice (DOJ) reports one-time costs of $62,000 for an external consultant to upgrade the California Justice Statistics Center to collect and store the data reported by law enforcement agencies as prescribed by this measure. (General Fund)
Background:
A peace officer may use reasonable force to effect an arrest, to prevent escape, or to overcome resistance. Law enforcement agencies are required to maintain a policy on the use of force, as specified. Existing law requires each law enforcement agency to report annually to DOJ specified use of force incidents. The department, in turn, must publish annually a summary of those incidents, as specified.
Existing law defines a "less lethal weapon" as any devise that propels ammunition that is designed to immobilize, incapacitate, or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function, or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. Existing law defines “less lethal ammunition” as any ammunition that (i) is designed to be used in any less-lethal weapon or any other kind of weapon (including firearms, pistols, revolvers, shotguns, rifles, and spring, compressed air, and compressed gas weapons) and (ii) when used in the less lethal weapon or other weapon is designed to immobilize, incapacitate, or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function, or senses, including physical pain or discomfort.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Prohibit the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents, as defined, by any law enforcement agency to disperse any assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering of persons, except as specified by this measure.
- Prohibit the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents solely due to a violation of an imposed curfew, verbal threat, or noncompliance with a law enforcement directive.
- Prohibit the use of chloroacetophenone tear gas (CN tear gas) or 2-chlorobenzalmalononitrile gas (CS gas) by law enforcement agencies.
- Allow kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents to be deployed to disperse gatherings an assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering of people only in accordance with specified requirements, including, among other things, those weapons only be fired at a specific target who presents a clear and imminent threat to themselves, the officers, or other persons and that the officers who deploy these weapons have received training on their proper use that is approved by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST).
- Require law enforcement agencies to make their report to DOJ on specified use of force incidents on a monthly basis.
- Require each law enforcement agency, beginning on January 1, 2023, to report any incident in which a kinetic energy projectile or chemical agent is used against a person resulting in a reported injury.
- Require law enforcement agencies, beginning on March 31, 2024, to publish annually a report on their use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents.
- Require a city in which federal law enforcement is operating to request that the federal law enforcement agency refrain from the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disperse any assembly, protest, demonstration, or other gathering, except as specified by this measure.
- Define “kinetic energy projectiles” as any type of device designed as less lethal, to be launched from any device as a projectile that may cause bodily injury through the transfer of kinetic energy and blunt force trauma. The term would include items commonly referred to as rubber bullets, plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam tipped plastic rounds.
- Define “chemical agents” as any chemical which can rapidly produce sensory irritation or disabling physical effects in humans, which disappear within a short time following termination of exposure. The term would include items commonly referred to as pepper balls, pepper spray or oleoresin capsicum, and CN tear gas or CS gas.
- State legislative intent language.
Related Legislation:
SB 1347 (Leno, 2009-2010 Reg. Sess.) would have limited the use of electronic control weapons by law enforcement. SB 1347 failed passage on the Senate floor.
AB 1237 (Leno, 2005-2006 Reg. Sess.) would have, in part, required law enforcement agencies that use tasers (also known as stun guns) to report the use of that less-lethal weapon to DOJ for one year and for the department to report the data to the Legislature. AB 1237 failed passage on the Assembly floor.
Staff Comments:
AB 66 would allow the deployment of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disburse gatherings if specified conditions are satisfied, including that the peace officers who deploy these weapons have received training on their proper use that is approved by POST. Correctional officers within CDCR are peace officers who use these weapons to, among other incidents, disburse inmates during a riot. These peace officers, however, do not attend POST-certified training but rather attend training approved by the Commission on Correctional Peace Officer Standards and Training (CPOST). Absent likely substantial change in correctional officer training (to have them attend POST-approved training), CDCR officers would not be able to deploy kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disburse gatherings under this measure, despite attending arguably equivalent CPOST-approved training on the use of these weapons.
Recommended Amendments:
This bill mislabels proposed Penal Code section 832.14, subdivision (c) as a second subdivision (b). The author may wish to correct this error.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 66 Hearing Date: August 7, 2020
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | July 21, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | GC | ||
Subject: Police: Use of Force
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: AB 392 (Weber), Ch. 170, Stats. of 2019
SB 230 (Caballero), Ch. 285, Stats. of 2019
SB 1347 (Leno), 2009, failed passage on the Senate floor
AB 2973 (Soto), Ch. 556, Stats. of 2008
AB 1237, (Leno), 2005, failed passage on the Asm. floor
Support: AAUW – San Jose; Alliance San Diego; Asian Americans Advancing Justice - California; Asian Law Alliance; Brady California United Against Gun Violence; California Academy of Family Physicians; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Civil Liberties Advocacy; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Labor Federation; California Nurses Association; California Psychological Association; California Public Defenders Association; California Teachers Association; Californiahealth+ Advocates; Californians for Safety and Justice; Consumer Attorneys of California; Disability Rights California; InnerCity Struggle; National Association of Social Workers – California; Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California; Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) – Sacramento; Silicon Valley Leadership Group; UDW/AFSCME Local 930
Opposition: California Association of Highway Patrolmen; California State Sheriffs’ Association; California Statewide Law Enforcement Association; Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department; Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC); Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
Assembly Floor Vote: Not relevant
PURPOSE
The purpose of this legislation is to limit the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents to disperse lawful assemblies, enforce curfews, in response to verbal threats, or to enforce mere non-compliance with law enforcement directives.
Existing law defines a "less lethal weapon" as any devise that propels ammunition that is designed to immobilize, or incapacitate, or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(a).)
Existing law defines “less lethal ammunition” as any ammunition that:
- Is designed to be used in any less lethal weapon or any other kind of weapon (including, but not limited to, firearms, pistols, revolvers, shotguns, rifles, and spring, compressed air, and compressed gas weapons); and
- When used in the less lethal weapon or other weapon is designed to immobilize or incapacitate or stun a human being through the infliction of any less than lethal impairment of physical condition, function, or senses, including physical pain or discomfort. (Penal Code, § 12601(b).)
This bill defines “kinetic energy projectiles” as any type of device designed as less lethal, to be launched from any device as a projectile that may cause bodily injury through the transfer of kinetic energy and blunt force trauma. For purposes of this section, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as rubber bullets, plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam tipped plastic rounds.
This bill defines “chemical agents” as any chemical which can rapidly produce sensory irritation or disabling physical effects in humans, which disappear within a short time following termination of exposure. For purposes of this section, the term includes, but is not limited to, items commonly referred to as pepper balls, pepper spray or oleoresin capsicum, and CN tear gas or CS gas.
This bill bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering unless all of the following conditions are met:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual;
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training; and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
This bill bans the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents by any law enforcement agency solely due to a violation of an imposed curfew, verbal threat, or mere noncompliance with a law enforcement directive.
This bill specifies that despite the exceptions for the use of chemical agents, “chloroacetophenone tear gas” commonly known as CN tear gas, or 2-chlorobenzalmalononitrile gas, commonly known as CS gas, shall not be used by any law enforcement agency.
This bill provides that kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents shall only be deployed and used by officers trained on the proper use of those weapons by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST).
This bill directs that if a federal law enforcement agency is operating in the jurisdiction of any city, that city shall request that federal law enforcement agency refrain from the use of kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents to disperse a lawful assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering to engage in conduct protected by the First Amendment to the United States and California Constitution.
This bill clarifies that nothing in this section prevents a law enforcement agency from adopting more stringent policies.
This bill requires that beginning January 1, 2023, law enforcement agencies shall begin to report to the Department of Justice incidents of use of less-lethal weapons, as specified.
This bill states that it is the intent of the Legislature that peace officers shall be accountable at all times to uphold their oath, and are held to the highest standards of conduct, pursuant to California Constitution Article XX, Sec. III and existing law, to support and defend the Constitutions of the United States of America and of the State of California, including the rights of the people to safely and freely speak and assemble.
This bill finds and declares the following:
- Beginning the week of May 25, 2020, there have been numerous reports of peaceful protestors, along with countless other bystanders and reporters, maimed by rubber bullets and other projectiles by law enforcement.
- Kinetic energy projectiles, such as rubber or plastic bullets, beanbag rounds, and foam rounds, and chemical agents, including pepper balls, pepper spray, and tear gas, have been increasingly used as crowd control weapons or less lethal weapons to respond to protests and are designed to incapacitate individuals by inflicting pain or sublethal injury.
- A 2017 British Medical Journal study found that 3% of people hit by rubber bullets died of their injuries and 15% were permanently injured.
- Researchers and medical professionals have called for an end of the use of rubber bullets on peaceful protestors because of their potential to cause serious injury, disability, or death.
- The 1925 Geneva Protocol categorized tear gas as a chemical warfare agent and banned its use in war. The Chemical Weapons Convention outlawed the use of tear gas in 1997, but still made it legal for law enforcement to use.
- Health experts have warned that the use of tear gas could help with the spread of COVID-19 because it irritates the lungs and makes persons cough.
- While most police departments have their own policies on their use of force and less lethal weapons, there are no statewide or national standards.
- It is the intent of this act to establish clear minimum standards for policies and reporting procedures regarding California law enforcement agencies’ use of less lethal kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Kinetic energy projectiles or kinetic impact projectiles (KIPs), along with chemical agents such as pepper spray and tear gas, are used by law enforcement for crowd control during protests as “less lethal” weapons compared to live bullets. They include rubber bullets, beanbag, and foam rounds. Rubber bullets are rubber on the outside, but often contain a metal center. While the U.S. stopped using rubber bullets for crowd control after a fatality in 1971, they were reintroduced in the early 1980s.
The use of these weapons can cause serious injury and long-term health impacts when used by law enforcement. When fired at a closer range, as seen in many of the recent protests, rubber bullets can penetrate the skin, break bones, fracture the skull, explode the eyeball, cause traumatic brain injuries, serious abdominal injury, internal bleeding and spleen, bowel, and major blood vessel injuries. At longer distances, they can unintentionally injure bystanders and non-violent demonstrators. A 2017 British Medical Journal study found that 3% of people hit by rubber bullets died of their injuries, and 15% were permanently disabled. Over 85% of all eye injuries resulted in permanent blindness and 91.5% of head and neck, eye, nervous, cardiovascular, pulmonary, and thoracic and urogenital injuries were severe.
In recent weeks, there have been numerous reports of peaceful protestors, bystanders, health care professionals, and reporters seriously injured by KIPs fired by law enforcement and chemical agents used against protesters. In La Mesa, CA, a grandmother was hospitalized in an intensive care unit after being hit between the eyes with a beanbag round. A San Jose community activist was hit in the groin by a rubber bullet and doctors are unsure if he will ever be able to have children. A photojournalist was shot in the eye by what she believed to be a rubber bullet while covering an anti-police brutality protest in Minneapolis, and was left permanently blind in the left eye.
Tear gas is also still allowed to be used by law enforcement, despite having serious health impacts. In 1925, the Geneva Protocol categorized tear gas as a chemical warfare agent and banned its use in war shortly after World War 1; and in 1997, the Chemical Weapon Convention outlawed the use of riot control agents such as tear gas in warfare, but still allowed the law enforcement to use it. A 2014 study from the U.S. Army found that recruits who were exposed to tear gas as part of a training exercise were more likely to get sick with respiratory illnesses like the common cold and flu. At least 98 law enforcement agencies across the country, including 11 in California, used some form of tear gas against civilians protesting police brutality and racism. There have also been reports of injuries from tear gas canisters fired by police, including a 21 year old who lost an eye after being hit by a tear gas canister.
Medical professionals have called for an end to the use of rubber bullets and tear gas on peaceful protestors due to their potential to cause serious injury, disability, or death. It is clear that these “less lethal” weapons are inappropriate for crowd control as Californians are exercising their rights to assemble and peacefully protest.
While most police departments have their own policies on their use of force of less lethal devices, there are no statewide or national standards. In order to increase the safety of Californians exercising their right to assemble and protest, Assembly Bill 66 would prohibit the use of kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents by law enforcement on peaceful protestors or to facilitate curfews. It would also prohibit the use of tear gas by police, set clear minimum standards for use of these “less lethal” weapons by law enforcement, and require data on the use of and any resulting injuries from these weapons.
2. Less Lethal Weapons and Law Enforcement
Policymakers must consider when officers may utilize weapons that can be very dangerous to the public, but are not as lethal as the usage of fully armed firearms. Having alternatives such as electronic stun weapons, batons, shields, chemicals, and kinetic energy projectiles can limit incidents when firearms are used in a manner which could result in death or serious bodily injury more frequently.
This bill seeks to limit the usage of less-lethal weapons by law enforcement agencies. The bill specifies that kinetic energy projectiles and chemical agents shall not be used to disperse an assembly, protest, demonstration, or gathering absent first engaging in a series of actions. The requirements to engage in the usage of kinetic energy weapons or chemical agents are outlined here. In order to use the weapons, all of these categories must be satisfied:
- It is objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual, including peace officers;
- Where objectively reasonable, de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to force have been attempted, and have failed;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable attempts to audibly and repeatedly announce the intent to use kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents;
- The crowd is given an objectively reasonable opportunity and ability to leave the scene;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to first identify individuals engaged in violent acts and those who are not, and only target kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents towards those individuals engaged in violent acts against any other individual,
- Peace officers consider the increased risk of hitting an unintended target due to unexpected movement of members of the crowd;
- Peace officers have made objectively reasonable efforts to extract individuals in distress;
- The kinetic energy projectiles or chemical agents are used only with the frequency, intensity, and in the manner that is objectively reasonable and proportional;
- Peace officers promptly provide or procure medical assistance for injured persons;
- Peace officers are trained on the proper use of those weapons by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST); and
- Peace officers only aim at or below an individual’s navel or belt line first, not at an individual’s head or neck, or at individuals running away.
These categories factor in the safety of officers, the public, and persons who may be in distress at the time the weapons are deployed. Additionally, as in much legislation advanced in recent years, these provisions require officers to factor in the reasonability of the usage of the weapons, as well as require notice be given when possible and that de-escalation techniques are employed. Finally, the requirements mandate that the weapons are used in a safer manner, and should not be deployed at persons who are running away from officers.
The language provides that less-lethal force may be used when “objectively reasonable to defend against injury to any individual” but not in defense of property. Presumably, the intent of this is to limit the usage of these methods to the prevention of physical harm to persons. However, this language would prevent the usage of less-lethal methods to prevent the harm to property.
3. Ban on Chloroacetophenone
This bill limits the usage of chemical agents by law enforcement, but the bill bans completely the usage of phenacyl chloride, or “chloroacetophenone” which is commonly referred to as “tear gas.” Due to the level of toxicity, phenacyl chloride has been replaced with the less toxic “CS gas” or chlorobenzakononitrile as a riot control agent. Exposure to CS gas still causes a burning sensation and tearing of the eyes and a burning sensation to the nose, mouth and throat. Law enforcement and paramilitary forces also have the alternative of pepper spray which is also less toxic and dangerous than phenacyl chloride as the latter can result in corneal epithelial damage, chemosis, pulmonary injury, asphyxia, and death.
4. Argument in Support
According to Disability Rights California:
While most police departments have their own policies on their use of force of these “less lethal” weapons, there are no statewide or national standards. Over the past several weeks, we have seen numerous reports of peaceful protestors, bystanders, and reporters seriously injured by projectiles fired by law enforcement and chemical agents used against protesters.
The use of these “less-lethal” weapons can cause serious injury and long-term health impacts when used improperly by law enforcement. When fired at a closer range, as seen in many of the recent protests, rubber bullets can penetrate the skin, break bones, fracture the skull, explode the eyeball, cause traumatic brain injuries, serious abdominal injury, internal bleeding and spleen, bowel, and major blood vessel injuries. At longer distances, they can unintentionally injure bystanders and non-violent demonstrators instead. “Less lethal” does not mean not lethal. In fact, a 2017 British Medical Journal study found that 3% of people hit by rubber bullets died of their injuries, and 15% were permanently disabled.
San Jose Mayor, city council and police chief are working to move forward with a ban on the use of rubber bullets by police officers in their city’s police department. San Jose is one of the largest cities in the state and has taken a step forward to making sure that those who are peacefully exercising their First Amendment rights are safe.
Chemical agents also have significant health impacts. Tear gas irritates cells, but also activates pain receptors, which leads to intense burning pain in the eyes, throat, lungs, skin and mucous membranes. In addition, a 2014 study from the U.S. Army found that recruits who were exposed to tear gas as part of a training exercise were more likely to get sick with respiratory illnesses like the common cold and flu. People with certain disabilities can react differently to the chemicals from tear gas exposure. The damage to people with disabilities can even be life threatening.
People with disabilities are especially at risk for severe injury from “less-lethal” force. People with multiple chemical sensitivity, sensory disabilities, and mental health disabilities, in particular can have devastating reactions to being tear gassed or hit with rubber bullets. California needs to be a leader and protect people by eliminating the use of rubber bullets, tear gas and other “non-lethal” force by law enforcement. This would help protect people with disabilities in California who could be severely harmed when this type of force is used.
5. Argument in Opposition
According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department:
The legislative intent language is problematic and presumes law enforcement officers do not support citizen constitutional rights to “safely and freely assemble,” which is not correct. During unlawful protests, law enforcement officers are presented with are presented with circumstances dangerous to themselves and the community at large. Prohibiting the use of tear gas, which is used to clear areas from those who are actively committing crime, increases the possibility of physical force between officers and those criminal refusing to disperse. The effective use of tear gas in riotous situations can prevent the escalation of physical force used by and against law enforcement, which will result in a safer environment for everyone involved.
Currently, LASD does not allow kinetic energy projectiles to be used on persons who are only in violation of a curfew, making verbal threats, or those who do not comply with law enforcement directives. Persons who do not comply with law enforcement directives, presuming the officer has legal standing, are always subject to arrest, and that arrest must be made pursuant to California law (AB 392), which was just codified less than one-year-ago.
Finally, a blanket prohibition on law enforcement’s use of tear gas is problematic in instances where there are armed barricaded subjects, who in many cases are wanted for serious violent felonies. Taking this tool away from law enforcement’s special weapons teams would be harmful and almost certainly injurious to those officers charged with dangerous operational duties.
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 66
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:January 7, 2020
Majority vote. Tax Levy
SUMMARY:
Extends, until January 1, 2027, the existing sales and use tax (SUT) exemption for diapers for infants, toddlers, and children.
Major Provisions
- Extends the sunset date for the existing SUT exemption for diapers from January 1, 2022, to January 1, 2027.
- Contains legislative findings and declarations in compliance with Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) section 41.
- Provides that this bill's objectives are to:
- Correctly treat diapers as necessary health products under the SUT laws, which exempt items deemed "necessities of life," such as food and medicine; and,
- Promote public health by expanding access to diapers, which, if left on a child when dirty, can cause painful diaper rash, blisters, skin infections, and infections.
- Specifies that, to measure these goals, the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and any other relevant state government entity.
- Provides that, on or before January 1, 2026, the LAO shall submit a report of this review to the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation and to the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance. The report shall include, without limitation, all of the following:
- A recommendation on whether the exemption should be modified, extended, or allowed to become inoperative; and,
- An assessment on whether more targeted approaches to providing families in need with adequate access to diapers are available.
- Provides that, notwithstanding R&TC section 2230, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any SUT revenues lost as a result of this exemption.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
COMMENTS:
The SUT Law imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling tangible personal property (TPP), absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
On June 27, 2019, Governor Newsom signed into law SB 92 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 34, Statutes of 2019. Among other things, this tax-related trailer bill provided a complete SUT exemption for diapers for infants, toddlers, and children. The exemption, however, only lasts two years and is scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2022. SB 92 also called for the automatic backfilling of the Local Revenue Fund 2011 for exemption-related revenue losses. Finally, SB 92 called for the LAO to prepare a report by January 1, 2021 on, among other things, whether the exemption should be modified, extended, or allowed to sunset.
This bill, in turn, would extend the diaper exemption an additional five years, from January 1, 2022, to January 1, 2027. This bill would also require the LAO to prepare a second report, by January 1, 2026. The subject of the report would be similar to that of the report required by existing law to be issued on or before January 1, 2021.
According to the Author:
"It is time for California's tax code to reflect the fact that diapers are an absolute health necessity for young children. By updating our tax code to accurately identify diapers as a necessity of life we can also make them more affordable. The high price of diapers has a cost for public health and our economy. Diaper need puts families in the position of changing their children's diapers less often which has unhealthy consequences ranging from diaper rash to infections requiring medical treatment. It also creates a barrier between parents and gainful employment when families cannot afford the number of diapers required by childcare providers."
Arguments in Support:
This bill is supported by the National Diaper Bank Network, which notes:
Diapers are critical to the health of infants and toddlers, as well as the economic and emotional well-being of families. Children go through six-12 diapers each day during the two to three years they wear diapers. Without enough diapers, infants and toddlers are at risk of skin infections, open sores, urinary tract infections, and other conditions that may require medical attention. While diapers are a recognized necessity, one in three mothers reports struggling to provide enough diapers for her child—a condition known as diaper need.
Arguments in Opposition:
No opposition on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- Annual General Fund revenue loss in excess of $30 million beginning in 2022.
- Annual General Fund cost pressures of approximately $10 million to backfill 2011 Local Revenue Fund.
VOTES:
ASM REVENUE AND TAXATION: 11-0-0
YES: Burke, Brough, Chu, Gray, Mayes, Melendez, Mullin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Luz Rivas, Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: January 7, 2020
CONSULTANT: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0002639
Date of Hearing: January 23, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 66
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:January 7, 2020
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends, for years 2022 through 2026, the sales and use tax (SUT) exemption for diapers and requires the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO), by January 1, 2026, to submit to the Legislature a report evaluating the effectiveness of the diaper SUT exemption.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual General Fund revenue loss in excess of $30 million beginning in 2022.
- Annual General Fund cost pressures of approximately $10 million to backfill 2011 Local Revenue Fund.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. Existing law exempts a number of products from California’s sales and use tax. Many types of food and prescription medicines, as well as utilities such as gas, water and electricity, are all exempt. These exempted products are typically referred to as “necessities as life,” but this type of exemption is not applied consistently. To address these inequities, SB 92 (Chapter 34, Statutes of 2019) created a two-year SUT exemption for both diapers and tampons and other menstrual products. SB 92 followed a multi-year effort to create an SUT exemption for these products through the policy committee process. The existing SUT exemption expires at the end of 2021, and AB 66 further extends the SUT exemption for diapers through 2026.
- Proposed budget action. The Governor’s proposed 2020-21 budget includes an 18-month extension of the diaper SUT exemption.
- 2011 Revenue Fund. One component of California’s 7.25% sales tax rate is a 1.0625% rate to support the 2011 Local Revenue Fund, which provides moneys to local governments for implementing public safety realignment. Proposition 30 of 2012 added additional protections to this fund by ensuring that, in the event that the 1.0625% component is reduced or eliminated, local governments receive the same level of funding they would have otherwise received.
While SB 92 included provisions aiming to backfill local governments as a result of the diaper SUT exemption, this bill does not contain such provisions. The author may wish to consider adding this backfill provision to align the diaper SUT exemption with the existing exemption created under SB 92.
- LAO reports. Because this committee does not wish to undermine policy committee’s actions, the most recent author amendments retain the LAO reporting requirements requested by the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation back in May 2019. As a result, LAO would need to conduct two separate evaluations of the diaper SUT exemption: a review required by SB 92 by January 1, 2021, and a review required by AB 66 by January 1, 2026. As this bill moves through the committee process, the author may wish to work with the policy committee and the budget committee to consolidate and harmonize LAO reporting requirements.
- Cost differences. Current revenue loss estimates for AB 66 are significantly higher than previous proposals because the bill applies the SUT exemption to diapers for children as well as diapers for infants and toddlers. In contrast, AB 717 (Gonzalez), of the 2015-16 Legislative session, proposed SUT exemption or diapers for infants and toddlers only, and annual GF revenue losses were estimated to be approximately $15 million annually.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 6, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 66 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
FOR VOTE ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: exemption: diapers
SUMMARY: Provides a complete sales and use tax (SUT) exemption for diapers designed, manufactured, processed, fabricated, or packaged for use by infants and toddlers. Specifically, this bill:
- Sunsets the exemption on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that notwithstanding existing law, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for SUT revenues lost as a result of this exemption.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy but only becomes operative on the first day of the first calendar quarter beginning more than 90 days after this bill's effective date.
- Contains the following legislative findings and declarations:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
- To correctly treat diapers as necessary health products under the SUT laws, which exempt items deemed "necessities of life," such as food and medicine; and,
- To promote public health by expanding access to diapers, which, if left on a child when dirty, can cause painful diaper rash, blisters, skin infections, and infections.
- To measure the goals set forth above, the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any other relevant state government entity; and,
- CDTFA and any other relevant state government entity shall provide to the LAO any data requested by the LAO pursuant to this bill.
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
- Provides that on or before January 1, 2024, the LAO shall submit a report of this review to the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance. This report shall include, without limitation, the following:
- A recommendation on whether the exemption should be modified, extended, or allowed to become inoperative; and,
- An assessment on whether more targeted approaches to providing families in need with adequate access to diapers are available.
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling tangible personal property (TPP), absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
- Imposes a complimentary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption of TPP purchased out-of-state and brought into California. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser; and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to an out-of-state retailer registered to collect California's use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the CDTFA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Estimated annual revenue losses of approximately $35 million.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
It is time for California's tax code to reflect the fact that diapers are an absolute health necessity for young children. By updating our tax code to accurately identify diapers as a necessity of life we can also make them more affordable. The high price of diapers has a cost for public health and our economy. Diaper need puts families in the position of changing their children's diapers less often which has unhealthy consequences ranging from diaper rash to infections requiring medical treatment. It also creates a barrier between parents and gainful employment when families cannot afford the number of diapers required by childcare providers.
- This bill is supported by the Western Center on Law and Poverty, which notes:
The need for diapers, particularly in low-income families, is real and tangible. Insufficient supply of clean diapers, referred to as "diaper need," is experienced by one in three families nationwide. It is well-documented that an insufficient supply of diapers puts parents in the position of changing diapers less often than needed. Over 42,000 cases of diaper dermatitis, urinary tract infection, and the related bacterial infection candidiasis were seen throughout California in 2015. More than 75% of these medical visits took place in an emergency room. These preventable and stressful ailments cause additional expenses for families and the health care system, including Medi-Cal. Incidences of diaper rash decline 33% among children whose families received supplies of clean diapers and babies experienced 77% fewer days of diaper rash, while millions of dollars in medical costs are avoided.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- An overview of the SUT Law: The SUT represents the state's second largest source of General Fund (GF) revenues. Nevertheless, the past 70 years have seen a dramatic reduction in the state's reliance on the SUT and a corresponding increase in its reliance on personal income tax revenues. In FY 2019-20, SUT revenues are estimated to comprise only 19% of the state's GF revenues, down from nearly 60% in FY 1950-51.
- What accounts for the state's reduced reliance on SUT revenues? The SUT Law was enacted in a very different era. In the 1930s, California's economy was largely dominated by manufacturing, and residents mostly bought and sold tangible goods. Thus, in establishing the base for a new consumption tax, it made sense to impose the tax on sales of TPP, defined as personal property that may be "seen, weighed, measured, felt, or touched." Over the past 80 years, however, California's economy has seen dramatic growth in the service and information sectors, resulting in a significant erosion of the SUT base. For example, the Commission on the 21st Century Economy noted that spending on taxable goods represented 34.6% of personal income in 2008, down from 55.4% in 1980. As a result, tax experts and economists from across the political spectrum argue that California should expand its SUT base.
It could be argued that, while well-intentioned, additional SUT exemptions further erode an already shrinking SUT base. This, in turn, increases fiscal pressures to maintain or even increase California's relatively high SUT rate. High rates arguably promote non-compliance and encourage out-of-state purchases, placing California retailers at a competitive disadvantage. High rates also risk impacting consumer decision-making, which runs counter to widely accepted principles of sound tax policy.
- What would this bill do? This bill would provide a complete SUT exemption for all diapers made for infants and toddlers. The proposed exemption would apply to both disposable and non-disposable diapers alike.
- The diaper dilemma: By some estimates, up to 95% of U.S. families use disposable diapers. Nevertheless, environmental and health concerns have persuaded some parents to purchase cloth diapers that can be reused. Experts, however, are divided on whether reusable diapers are more environmentally friendly. According to WebMD, research suggests that both disposable and cloth diapers impact the environment negatively – albeit in different ways. Disposable diapers require more raw materials to manufacture and generate more solid waste for landfills. Cloth diapers, on the other hand, use up large amounts of electricity and water for laundering. Thus, the American Academy of Pediatrics takes no position in the ongoing debate regarding the relative merits of cloth versus disposable diapers.
- How are diapers currently taxed? Current law does not provide a SUT exemption for diapers. The CDTFA has noted, however, that businesses providing diaper services, where cloth diapers are furnished in connection with the recurring service of laundering the diapers, are considered "consumers" of the diapers they provide. Thus, the tax applies only to the diaper service's purchases, and the business's diaper rental receipts are not subject to SUT.
- An inherently regressive tax: The SUT has been widely criticized as a regressive exaction that most heavily impacts those least able to pay. For example, a survey by the Nevada Legislative Counsel Bureau long ago concluded that in the case of a retail sales tax with food exempt, "the lowest income group would experience the highest ratio of tax to income . . . ." (Survey of Sales Taxes Applicable to Nevada 59 (Bull. No. 3, May, 1948).) Others, however, contend that a degree of progressivity is provided via the various exemptions built into most state SUT laws (i.e., for certain necessities of life such as food, housing, and medical care).
Proponents of this bill might argue that an exemption for diapers would further promote a degree of progressivity in an already regressive tax regime. Critics, however, might contend that SUT exemptions are a blunt instrument for affecting social policy. While this bill would provide meaningful financial relief to low-income parents struggling to make ends meet, it would also provide relief indiscriminately to wealthy consumers who might not even notice the exemption. In addition, critics might question why diapers are being singled out for preferential tax treatment as opposed to other items of TPP indispensable to raising a child (e.g., car seats, cribs, baby clothes, bottles, strollers, etc.).
- A more targeted approach? To better target low-income parents, the Committee may wish to consider whether a slightly more tailored approach would be preferable. Specifically, if the Legislature chooses to dedicate a certain amount of money (e.g., $30 million annually) to help parents purchase diapers, it might be preferable to channel this money directly and exclusively to needy families. For example, the Committee may wish to consider whether it would be preferable to provide a SUT exemption for diapers sold directly to nonprofit entities that, in turn, provide free diapers to low-income and homeless families. The nonprofit Help a Mother Out organization notes that it has provided diapers to low-income and homeless families through a network of social service partners since 2009.
- Filling in the details: As noted above, this bill would establish a SUT exemption for diapers for "infants and toddlers". This bill, however, lacks definitions for these terms. Thus, it might be challenging for retailers to determine with any degree of precision which specific products qualify for the exemption and which do not. The author may wish to consider whether it would be beneficial to provide greater definitional clarity through references to specific age or weight ranges.
- Policy on tax expenditures: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure proposals (including SUT exemptions) comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements. This bill fully adheres to this Committee's policy requiring compliance with R&TC Section 41.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to the new policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean ten years. This bill has been amended to add a five-year sunset. - Prior legislation:
- AB 717 (Gonzalez), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, would have provided a temporary SUT exemption for diapers for infants and toddlers, designated size 3 or under. AB 717 was vetoed.
- AB 1291 (Hollingsworth), of the 2001-02 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for diapers. AB 1291 was held on this Committee's Suspense File.
- AB 5 (Battin), of the 1999-2000 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for baby diapers, whether disposable or not, and over-the-counter, nonprescription drugs. AB 5 was never heard by this Committee.
- AB 13 (Dickerson), of the 1999-00 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for, among other things, products for incontinence, including disposable and reusable diapers, pads, and briefs. AB 13 was never heard by this Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Grocers Association
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
Junior League of Riverside
Junior Leagues of California State Public Affairs Committee
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Diaper Bank Network
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 66 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: exemption: diapers
SUMMARY: Provides a complete sales and use tax (SUT) exemption for diapers designed, manufactured, processed, fabricated, or packaged for use by infants and toddlers. Specifically, this bill:
- Sunsets the exemption on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that notwithstanding existing law, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for SUT revenues lost as a result of this exemption.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy but only becomes operative on the first day of the first calendar quarter beginning more than 90 days after this bill's effective date.
- Contains the following legislative findings and declarations:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
- To correctly treat diapers as necessary health products under the SUT laws, which exempt items deemed "necessities of life," such as food and medicine; and,
- To promote public health by expanding access to diapers, which, if left on a child when dirty, can cause painful diaper rash, blisters, skin infections, and infections.
- To measure the goals set forth above, the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any other relevant state government entity; and,
- CDTFA and any other relevant state government entity shall provide to the LAO any data requested by the LAO pursuant to this bill.
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling tangible personal property (TPP), absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
- Imposes a complimentary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption of TPP purchased out-of-state and brought into California. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser; and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to an out-of-state retailer registered to collect California's use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the CDTFA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Estimated annual revenue losses of approximately $35 million.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
It is time for California's tax code to reflect the fact that diapers are an absolute health necessity for young children. By updating our tax code to accurately identify diapers as a necessity of life we can also make them more affordable. The high price of diapers has a cost for public health and our economy. Diaper need puts families in the position of changing their children's diapers less often which has unhealthy consequences ranging from diaper rash to infections requiring medical treatment. It also creates a barrier between parents and gainful employment when families cannot afford the number of diapers required by childcare providers.
- This bill is supported by the Western Center on Law and Poverty, which notes:
The need for diapers, particularly in low-income families, is real and tangible. Insufficient supply of clean diapers, referred to as "diaper need," is experienced by one in three families nationwide. It is well-documented that an insufficient supply of diapers puts parents in the position of changing diapers less often than needed. Over 42,000 cases of diaper dermatitis, urinary tract infection, and the related bacterial infection candidiasis were seen throughout California in 2015. More than 75% of these medical visits took place in an emergency room. These preventable and stressful ailments cause additional expenses for families and the health care system, including Medi-Cal. Incidences of diaper rash decline 33% among children whose families received supplies of clean diapers and babies experienced 77% fewer days of diaper rash, while millions of dollars in medical costs are avoided.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- An overview of the SUT Law: The SUT represents the state's second largest source of General Fund (GF) revenues. Nevertheless, the past 70 years have seen a dramatic reduction in the state's reliance on the SUT and a corresponding increase in its reliance on personal income tax revenues. In FY 2019-20, SUT revenues are estimated to comprise only 19% of the state's GF revenues, down from nearly 60% in FY 1950-51.
- What accounts for the state's reduced reliance on SUT revenues? The SUT Law was enacted in a very different era. In the 1930s, California's economy was largely dominated by manufacturing, and residents mostly bought and sold tangible goods. Thus, in establishing the base for a new consumption tax, it made sense to impose the tax on sales of TPP, defined as personal property that may be "seen, weighed, measured, felt, or touched." Over the past 80 years, however, California's economy has seen dramatic growth in the service and information sectors, resulting in a significant erosion of the SUT base. For example, the Commission on the 21st Century Economy noted that spending on taxable goods represented 34.6% of personal income in 2008, down from 55.4% in 1980. As a result, tax experts and economists from across the political spectrum argue that California should expand its SUT base.
It could be argued that, while well-intentioned, additional SUT exemptions further erode an already shrinking SUT base. This, in turn, increases fiscal pressures to maintain or even increase California's relatively high SUT rate. High rates arguably promote non-compliance and encourage out-of-state purchases, placing California retailers at a competitive disadvantage. High rates also risk impacting consumer decision-making, which runs counter to widely accepted principles of sound tax policy.
- What would this bill do? This bill would provide a complete SUT exemption for all diapers made for infants and toddlers. The proposed exemption would apply to both disposable and non-disposable diapers alike.
- The diaper dilemma: By some estimates, up to 95% of U.S. families use disposable diapers. Nevertheless, environmental and health concerns have persuaded some parents to purchase cloth diapers that can be reused. Experts, however, are divided on whether reusable diapers are more environmentally friendly. According to WebMD, research suggests that both disposable and cloth diapers impact the environment negatively – albeit in different ways. Disposable diapers require more raw materials to manufacture and generate more solid waste for landfills. Cloth diapers, on the other hand, use up large amounts of electricity and water for laundering. Thus, the American Academy of Pediatrics takes no position in the ongoing debate regarding the relative merits of cloth versus disposable diapers.
- How are diapers currently taxed? Current law does not provide a SUT exemption for diapers. The CDTFA has noted, however, that businesses providing diaper services, where cloth diapers are furnished in connection with the recurring service of laundering the diapers, are considered "consumers" of the diapers they provide. Thus, the tax applies only to the diaper service's purchases, and the business's diaper rental receipts are not subject to SUT.
- An inherently regressive tax: The SUT has been widely criticized as a regressive exaction that most heavily impacts those least able to pay. For example, a survey by the Nevada Legislative Counsel Bureau long ago concluded that in the case of a retail sales tax with food exempt, "the lowest income group would experience the highest ratio of tax to income . . . ." (Survey of Sales Taxes Applicable to Nevada 59 (Bull. No. 3, May, 1948).) Others, however, contend that a degree of progressivity is provided via the various exemptions built into most state SUT laws (i.e., for certain necessities of life such as food, housing, and medical care).
Proponents of this bill might argue that an exemption for diapers would further promote a degree of progressivity in an already regressive tax regime. Critics, however, might contend that SUT exemptions are a blunt instrument for affecting social policy. While this bill would provide meaningful financial relief to low-income parents struggling to make ends meet, it would also provide relief indiscriminately to wealthy consumers who might not even notice the exemption. In addition, critics might question why diapers are being singled out for preferential tax treatment as opposed to other items of TPP indispensable to raising a child (e.g., car seats, cribs, baby clothes, bottles, strollers, etc.).
- A more targeted approach? To better target low-income parents, the Committee may wish to consider whether a slightly more tailored approach would be preferable. Specifically, if the Legislature chooses to dedicate a certain amount of money (e.g., $30 million annually) to help parents purchase diapers, it might be preferable to channel this money directly and exclusively to needy families. For example, the Committee may wish to consider whether it would be preferable to provide a SUT exemption for diapers sold directly to nonprofit entities that, in turn, provide free diapers to low-income and homeless families. The nonprofit Help a Mother Out organization notes that it has provided diapers to low-income and homeless families through a network of social service partners since 2009.
- Filling in the details: As noted above, this bill would establish a SUT exemption for diapers for "infants and toddlers". This bill, however, lacks definitions for these terms. Thus, it might be challenging for retailers to determine with any degree of precision which specific products qualify for the exemption and which do not. The author may wish to consider whether it would be beneficial to provide greater definitional clarity through references to specific age or weight ranges.
- Policy on tax expenditures: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure proposals (including SUT exemptions) comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements.
This bill has been amended to specify the goals being advanced by providing a SUT exemption for diapers. This bill also tasks the LAO with reviewing the effectiveness of the tax exemption. In its current form, however, this bill does not require the LAO to report the findings of its review to the Legislature. The Committee may wish to consider amending this bill to require an LAO report be issued by January 1, 2024 – one year before the exemption is set to expire. This report could include, among other things, recommendations on: (i) whether the exemption should be modified, extended, or allowed to sunset; and, (ii) whether there are more targeted approaches to providing families in need with adequate access to diapers.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to the new policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean ten years. This bill has been amended to add a five-year sunset.
- Prior legislation:
- AB 717 (Gonzalez), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, would have provided a temporary SUT exemption for diapers for infants and toddlers, designated size 3 or under. AB 717 was vetoed.
- AB 1291 (Hollingsworth), of the 2001-02 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for diapers. AB 1291 was held on this Committee's Suspense File.
- AB 5 (Battin), of the 1999-2000 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for baby diapers, whether disposable or not, and over-the-counter, nonprescription drugs. AB 5 was never heard by this Committee.
- AB 13 (Dickerson), of the 1999-00 Legislative Session, would have provided a SUT exemption for, among other things, products for incontinence, including disposable and reusable diapers, pads, and briefs. AB 13 was never heard by this Committee.
- Prior legislation:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Grocers Association
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
Junior League of Riverside
Junior Leagues of California State Public Affairs Committee
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Diaper Bank Network
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):