AB 2066: The California Food Safety Act.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-08
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Food Safety Act, prohibits a person or entity from manufacturing, selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce a food product for human consumption that contains a specified substance, including, among others, red dye 3.
This bill, commencing January 1, 2027, would require a person or entity using methylene chloride in the process of decaffeinating coffee, or selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride to label the final coffee product with a clear and conspicuous label disclosing that methylene chloride was used in the decaffeination of the product. The bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.This bill would require the Office of Environmental Health Hazzard Assessment to conduct a study on the health impacts of the consumption of methylene chloride. The bill would require the office to update its no significant risk level and its maximum allowable level of methylene chloride by January 1, 2026.
Existing law, the California Food Safety Act, prohibits a person or entity from manufacturing, selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce a food product for human consumption that contains a specified substance, including, among others, red dye 3.
This bill, commencing January 1, 2027, would prohibit require a person or entity from using methylene chloride in the process of decaffeinating coffee, or selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride. chloride to label the final coffee product with a clear and conspicuous label disclosing that methylene chloride was used in the decaffeination of the product. The bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.
Existing law, the California Food Safety Act, prohibits a person or entity from manufacturing, selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce a food product for human consumption that contains a specified substance, including, among others, red dye 3.
This bill, commencing January 1, 2027, would prohibit a person or entity from using methylene chloride in the process of decaffeinating coffee. coffee, or selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride. The bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.
Existing law, the California Food Safety Act, prohibits a person or entity from manufacturing, selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale in commerce a food product for human consumption that contains a specified substance, including, among others, red dye 3.
This bill, commencing January 1, 2027, would prohibit a person or entity from using methylene chloride in the process of decaffeinating coffee. The bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.
(a)The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment shall conduct a study on the health impacts of the consumption of methylene chloride, including in cases where elements of methylene chloride remain in decaffeinated coffee.
(b)By January 1, 2026, the office shall update its no significant risk level and its maximum allowable level of methylene chloride.
SECTION 1.Section 109027 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:109027.(a)Commencing January 1, 2027, a person or entity that uses methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, in the process of decaffeinating coffee, or sells, delivers, distributes, holds, or offers for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride, shall label the final coffee product with a clear and conspicuous label stating: Methylene chloride is used in the decaffeination of this product. (b)(1)Upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney, a person or entity that violates subdivision (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation, and not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation.(2)This section does not impair or impede any other rights, causes of action, claims, or defenses available under any other law. The remedies provided in this section are cumulative with any other remedies available under any other law.(b)(1)Upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney, a person or entity that violates subdivision (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation, and not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation.
(2)This section does not impair or impede any other rights, causes of action, claims, or defenses available under any other law. The remedies provided in this section are cumulative with any other remedies available under any other law.
(a)Commencing January 1, 2027, a person or entity shall not use do either of the following:
(1)Use methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, in the process of decaffeinating coffee.
(2)Sell, deliver, distribute, hold, or offer for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride.
(b)(1)Upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney, a person or entity that violates subdivision (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation, and not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation.
(2)This section does not impair or impede any other rights, causes of action, claims, or defenses available under any other law. The remedies provided in this section are cumulative with any other remedies available under any other law.
(a)Commencing January 1, 2027, a person or entity shall not use methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, in the process of decaffeinating coffee.
(b)(1)Upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney, a person or entity that violates subdivision (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) for a first violation, and not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each subsequent violation.
(2)This section does not impair or impede any other rights, causes of action, claims, or defenses available under any other law. The remedies provided in this section are cumulative with any other remedies available under any other law.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 9, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 8, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| May 8, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 13. Noes 3.) (April 16). |
| Apr 9, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 8, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 5, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 18, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Feb 2, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 3. |
| Feb 1, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| A Voice for Choice Advocacy | ** Support | |
| Alliance of Coffee Decaffeinators | ** Against | |
| American Beverage Association | ** Against | |
| American Chemistry Council | ** Against | |
| American College of OBGYNs | * Support | Apr 16, 2024 |
| Breast Cancer Prevention Partners | * Support | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Automatic VendorS Council | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Grocers Association | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Health Coalition Advocacy | ** Support | |
| California League Of Food Producers | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Manufacturing Technology Association | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice | ** Support | |
| California Restaurant Association | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| California Retailers Association | * Against | Apr 23, 2024 |
| Clean Label Project | * Support | Apr 23, 2024 |
| cleanearth4kids.org | ** Support | |
| Consumer Brands Association | ** Against | |
| Educate. Advocate. | ** Support | |
| Environmental Working Group | * Support | Apr 23, 2024 |
| Facts: Families Advocating for Chemical & Toxics Safety | ** Support | |
| National Automatic Merchandising Association | ** Against | |
| National Coffee Association | ** Against | |
| Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay Area Chapter | ** Support | |
| Reproductive Freedom for All | ** Support | |
| See | ** Support | |
| Social Eco Education | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2066
Author:(Reyes) – As Amended Ver:May 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 13 - 3 |
Judiciary | 7 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) to conduct a study on the health impacts of the consumption of methylene chloride and update the no “significant risk level” (NSRL) and “maximum allowable dose level” (MADL) for methylene chloride.
FISCAL EFFECT:
One-time costs of an unknown amount, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, for OEHHA to conduct the required study and update its “safe harbor” levels for methylene chloride (Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Pregnant women often switch to decaffeinated coffee due to the impacts of caffeine on their pregnancy. Many of them, however, do not know that Methylene Chloride is used prevalently in the decaffeination process despite there being two other methods available to produce decaffeinated coffee. AB 2066 asks for the California Environmental Protection Agency’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to study and update its regulations regarding the maximum level of methylene chloride allowed before a notice must be issued in order to protect pregnant women from a potentially dangerous level of exposure.
Methylene Chloride is a Proposition 65 notice triggering substance that can be contracted by inhaling it or close contact with it. During pregnancy, it can be passed from a mother to their unborn child. Despite these known risks its risk levels have not been reevaluated in over two decades. In April of 2024, the U.S. EPA finalized a ban on most uses of methylene chloride further justifying the need to reevaluate the use of this chemical and the harm it can cause.
- Background. Methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, is a volatile chemical compound with a range of industrial uses, including extracting flavorings and decaffeinating coffee and tea. Methylene chloride makes it easier to extract caffeine from the bean prior to roasting. However, according to OEHHA, methylene chloride can cause cancer and damage to the cardiovascular and nervous systems. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency banned the chemical’s use in paint products for consumer use in 2019, based on the significant risk of lung damage posed to painters who inhale the product in large concentrations.
For decaffeinating coffee, methylene chloride is used to open the pores of green coffee beans, allowing the manufacturer to remove caffeine before roasting the bean. According to the sponsor of this bill, Japan and Korea have banned coffee that is decaffeinated using methylene chloride and Canada requires such coffee to be labeled.
Proposition 65. Proposition 65, the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, was enacted as a ballot initiative in November 1986 to protect the state's drinking water sources from being contaminated with chemicals known to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. Proposition 65 requires the state to maintain and update a list of chemicals known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity. Proposition 65 also requires businesses to inform Californians about exposures to such chemicals. OEHHA evaluates chemicals for inclusion on the Proposition 65 list and develops the safe harbor levels for listed chemicals -- NSRLs for chemicals known to cause cancer, and MADLs for chemicals known to cause reproductive toxicity.
OEHHA placed methylene chloride on its Proposition 65 list of “Chemicals Known to the State to Cause Cancer or Reproductive Toxicity” in April 1988, with cancer as the type of toxicity and an NSRL of 50 micrograms/day, or 200 micrograms/day for inhalation. Because methylene chloride is not listed as a reproductive and developmental toxicant, OEHHA does not have a MADL for it.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2066
Author:(Reyes) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 13 - 3 |
Judiciary | 7 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a person or entity that uses methylene chloride to decaffeinate coffee, or sells or distributes coffee that was decaffeinated using methylene chloride, to clearly disclose the chemical’s use on the coffee’s label. The bill imposes civil penalties ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 for violations of this labeling requirement, enforceable through a civil action brought by government civil prosecutors.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No costs to CDPH. The Department of Justice anticipates no significant costs.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the Clean Label Project. According to the author:
Pregnant women often switch to decaffeinated coffee due to the impacts of caffeine on their pregnancy. AB 2066 requires that a clear label identifies when methylene chloride, a known carcinogen, is used to decaffeinate a coffee product. Methylene Chloride [exposure occurs by inhalation] or …contact and during pregnancy can be passed from a mother to their unborn child, making it potentially dangerous to pregnant women. In 2023, this substance was banned from industrial uses like metal cleaning and degreasing due to its impacts. This method of decaffeination is one of three frequently used methods for decaffeination, and the only one linked to a cancer causing substance. This mandate will provide clarity to consumers, allowing them to make a decision that is in the best interest of their health.
Background. Methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, is a volatile chemical compound with a range of industrial uses, including extracting flavorings and decaffeinating coffee and tea. Methylene chloride makes it easier to extract caffeine from the bean prior to roasting. However, according to the state Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, methylene chloride can cause cancer and damage to the cardiovascular and nervous systems.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency banned the chemical’s use in paint products for consumer use in 2019 based on the significant risk of lung damage posed to painters who inhale the product in large concentrations.
For decaffeinating coffee, methylene chloride is used to open the pores of green coffee beans, allowing the manufacturer to remove caffeine before roasting the bean. According to the sponsor of this bill, Japan and Korea have banned coffee decaffeinated using methylene chloride and Canada requires such coffee to be labeled.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2066
Author:(Reyes) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
SUBJECT: The California Food Safety Act
KEY ISSUE: should coffee decaffeinated using methylene chloride be required to have a label on the final product, noting the use of methylene chloride in the production process?
SYNOPSIS
Decaffeinated coffee is a popular beverage of choice for millions of Americans who enjoy the taste or health benefits of coffee but prefer to do without the jolt of caffeine that accompanies a cup of a person’s favorite brew. Presently, three primary methods exist for removing the caffeine that naturally occurs in coffee beans. One method involves using methylene chloride to open the pores of an unroasted green coffee bean so that the caffeine can be removed. Unfortunately, methylene chloride has been determined to pose significant health risks in some settings. Notably, the chemical has been added to the list of chemicals that must include a Proposition 65 warning, and in 2019, the United States Environmental Protection Agency banned its use in some consumer paint products.
This bill would require all decaffeinated coffee sold in California that is decaffeinated using methylene chloride to disclose the chemical’s use in the decaffeination process. The bill would impose civil penalties ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 for violations of this labeling requirement. This measure would be enforceable though a civil action brought by government civil prosecutors.
This bill is sponsored by the Clean Label Project and is supported by a number of public health advocates. The proponents of this measure note that methylene chloride poses health risks and contend that consumers should know what they are ingesting with their coffee. This measure is vehemently opposed by the coffee-manufacturing industry, including the National Coffee Association, Alliance of Coffee Decaffeinators, and the American Beverage Association. The opposition contends that the science regarding the use of methylene chloride in the decaffeination process is unclear and that any risk posed by decaffeinated coffee is outweighed by the health benefits of consuming coffee. The opposition also contends that the labeling requirements are needlessly vague and confusing. This measure was previously heard and approved by the Assembly Health Committee by a vote of 13 to 3.
SUMMARY: Requires decaffeinated coffee that utilized methylene chloride in the decaffeination process to have clear labeling on the product, noting that methylene chloride was used in the creation of the product. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, commencing January 1, 2027, a person or entity that uses methylene chloride, also known as dichloromethane, in the process of decaffeinating coffee, or sells, delivers, distributes, holds, or offers for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using methylene chloride, to label the final coffee product with a clear and conspicuous label stating: “Methylene chloride is used in the decaffeination of this product.”
- Authorizes the imposition of a civil penalty of $5,000 for a first violation of 1) and $10,000 for all subsequent violations.
- Provides that the civil penalties provided in 2) may be sought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.
- Provides that nothing in the bill impairs or impedes any other rights, causes of action, claims, or defenses available under any other law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the Department of Public Health to administer the Sherman Food, Drug and Cosmetics Law which regulates the packaging, labeling, and advertising of drugs and devices, including dietary supplements. (Health and Safety Code Section 109875 et seq.)
- Requires, pursuant to the Sherman Food, Drug and Cosmetics Law, the Department of Public Health to adopt regulations that prescribe tolerances, included but not limited to zero tolerances, for poisonous or deleterious substances, food additives, pesticide chemicals, or color additives, as specified. (Health and Safety Code Section 110070.)
- Requires the Department of Public Health in promulgating the regulations pursuant to 2) to consider specified factors, including the probable consumption and effect of the substance in the diet of man or any other animal and safety factors. (Health and Safety Code Section 110075.)
- Establishes the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, also known as Proposition 65, which requires businesses to provide warnings to Californians about significant exposures to chemicals that cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.5 et seq.)
- Prohibits, pursuant to Proposition 65, a person in the course of doing business from knowingly discharging or releasing a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity into water or onto or into land where such chemical passes or probably will pass into any source of drinking water, except as provided. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.5.)
- Prohibits, pursuant to Proposition 65, a person in the course of doing business from knowingly and intentionally exposing any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving clear and reasonable warning to such individual. (Health and Safety Code Section 25249.6.)
- Provides, in accordance with federal law, methylene chloride may be present in food under the following conditions:
- In spice oleoresins as a residue from the extraction of spice, at a level not to exceed 30 parts per million, as specified;
- In hops extract as a residue from the extraction of hops, at a level not to exceed 2.2 percent, as specified; and
- In coffee as a residue from its use as a solvent in the extraction of caffeine from green coffee beans, at a level not to exceed 10 parts per million in decaffeinated roasted coffee and in decaffeinated soluble coffee extract. (21 C.F.R. Section 173.255.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Methylene chloride is a volatile chemical compound with a range of industrial uses. One use of the chemical is to assist in the process of decaffeinating coffee; the chemical makes it easier to extract caffeine from the bean prior to roasting. However, some evidence suggests that the chemical may cause cancer and that exposure to the chemical in aerosol form may result in significant lung damage and death. Seeking to better alert Californians to the presence of the chemical in decaffeinated coffee, this bill would require products decaffeinated utilizing methylene chloride to be labeled as such. In support of the bill, the author states:
Pregnant women often switch to decaffeinated coffee due to the impacts of caffeine on their pregnancy. AB 2066 requires that a clear label identifies when methylene chloride, a known carcinogen, is used to decaffeinate a coffee product. Methylene Chloride can be contracted by inhaling or close contact and during pregnancy can be passed from a mother to their unborn child, making it potentially dangerous to pregnant women. In 2023, this substance was banned from industrial uses like metal cleaning and degreasing due to its impacts. This method of decaffeination is one of three frequently used methods for decaffeination, and the only one linked to a cancer causing substance. This mandate will provide clarity to consumers, allowing them to make a decision that is in the best interest of their health.
The uses and risks of methylene chloride. Like many chemicals used in manufacturing processes, methylene chloride is a highly volatile chemical compound that must be handled with caution. However, due to the diversity of uses, the United States Environmental Protection Agency notes that approximately 260 million pounds of the product are manufactured or imported into the United States annually. Methylene chloride can be utilized in paint products, building materials, furniture, and some aerosols. However, these manufacturing and importation statistics represent the use of the chemical before the United States Environmental Protection Agency banned the chemical’s use in paint products for consumer use in 2019. The 2019 prohibition was based on the significant risk of lung damage posed to painters who inhale the product in large concentrations.
However, outside of the paint context, most uses of the chemical are purely industrial. When proper protective equipment and handling rules are followed, there does not appear to be an undue risk as a result of significant exposure. These manufacturing processes include the process of decaffeinating coffee. Methylene chloride is used to open the pores of green coffee beans, thereby allowing manufacturers to better access the bean and remove caffeine before roasting the bean. Because the chemical is not used in the roasting or brewing processes by the time a person drinks a cup of decaffeinated coffee, the presence of methylene chloride is extremely low.
Nonetheless, the state Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment recently added methylene chloride, in all uses, to the list of chemicals requiring a Proposition 65 warning because of the chemical’s potential to increase the risk of cancer and reproductive issues. However, as noted in the analysis of this bill by the Committee on Health, more research as to the risks of methylene chloride in coffee is needed, especially in light of the growing body of scientific evidence that drinking coffee (decaffeinated or otherwise) is actually associated with a lower risk of cancer and other harms.
This bill seeks to ensure that Californians are aware of the chemicals used to process decaffeinated coffee that they may be ingesting when consuming the coffee. This bill would require all decaffeinated coffee that was decaffeinated utilizing methylene chloride to contain a notice on the packaging, stating that the chemical was used in the manufacturing process. This notice differs from the Proposition 65 warnings in that this notice must be added to the product whether or not methylene chloride is actually present in the product. This bill would be enforced via a civil penalty regime that imposes a $5,000 civil penalty for a first violation and a $10,000 penalty for subsequent violations. The penalty provisions of this bill could be enforced by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or a district attorney. The measure also adopts a savings clause noting that it does not impact any other legal rights.
Ensuring that only those entities that actually control product labels are impacted by this bill. As currently in print, this measure applies to any entity that “sells, delivers, distributes, holds, or offers for sale” decaffeinated coffee. This language appears to be a holdover from a prior version of the bill that banned all coffee decaffeinated using methylene chloride. Given that methylene chloride is only one of three methods for decaffeinating coffee, this language may now be overly broad, especially as it relates to delivery operations. It is highly unlikely that a delivery company will know which method of decaffeinating coffee was used in a specific product. However, this language was the result of a compromise between the Health Committee and the author of this measure. Accordingly, this Committee will not be requiring any amendments to undo the amendments of a prior Committee. Nonetheless, the author may wish to consider amendments to narrow the entities subject to the bill to only those in the supply chain who know or should know which means of decaffeinating coffee was, in fact, used on the product in question.
By requiring product labeling, this bill implicates a coffee producer’s speech rights. By requiring various business entities to add a warning label to decaffeinated coffee products, this measure represents the government compelling corporate entities to speak, a potential violation of the First Amendment. Government compelled speech, aimed at business entities, is subject to an intermediate scrutiny level of review. (Virginia State Board of Pharmacy v. Virginia Citizens Consumer Council, Inc. (1976) 425 U.S. 748.) As it specifically relates to commercial speech the United States Supreme Court has adopted a three part test to determine the legitimacy of the government compelling a private company to place notices on products. This test, commonly referred to as the Central Hudson test, requires the government to demonstrate the following to be able to justify compelling speech: 1) the government has a substantial interest in the matter; 2) the regulation must directly and materially advance the government’s substantial interest; and 3) the government’s actions are narrowly tailored to advance that interest. (Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corp. v. Public Service Commission (1980) 447 U.S. 557.)
As it pertains to this measure, the proposed labeling requirement appears to meet the Central Hudson standard. First, the state has a substantial interest in protecting the health and safety of its residents. This interest has been recognized when upholding the validity of Proposition 65 warnings, another manner of compelled speech. (Dowhal v. SmithKline Beecham Consumer Healthcare (2004) 32 Cal. 4th 910.) Similarly, to the extent that decaffeinated coffee may expose drinkers to a potential carcinogen, the warning appears to advance this interest. Finally, warning labels have generally been held to be a narrowly tailored means of advancing that interest. Thus, it appears that this labeling requirement should pass constitutional muster.
However, it should be noted that a recent Ninth Circuit decision held that unless the science behind a warning label is “purely factual and uncontroversial,” a label may not be sufficiently narrowly tailored to withstand constitutional muster. (National Association of Wheat Growers v. Bonta (2023) 85 F.4th 1263.) As noted above, methylene chloride is on the Proposition 65 list as a known carcinogen and has been banned in some uses by the United States Environmental Protection Agency. However, United States Environmental Protection Agency regulations permit the presence of methylene chloride in decaffeinated coffee at a concentration of up to 10 parts per million. Nonetheless, given that this bill simply requires the label to note that methylene chloride was used, it appears to be factual. Given that this Committee does not have the scientific expertise to fully evaluate the science behind the various claims regarding methylene chloride, should this bill advance the author is encouraged to ensure that the labeling requirements are not expanded to encompass statements involving science that is less than clear in order to continue to ensure this bill can pass constitutional muster.
The growing number of product warning labels may be overwhelming consumers. This bill would add yet another warning label to consumer products. As discussed above, since the mid-1980s, products or places of business that may expose Californians to potential cancer causing chemicals must warn the public of the risk. As a result, warnings are now ubiquitous across California. Everything from gas pumps, to airport jet bridges, to cans of beer are now warning consumers of their potential risks. Nonetheless, it appears that customers continue to readily fill up their car’s gas tanks, travel, and have the occasional adult beverage. To the extent that this measure adds yet another warning label, especially one that does not describe the underlying risks, it is unclear how much impact this will have on consumer behavior. Nonetheless, this Committee recognizes that the labeling requirement is the result of a compromise reached in a prior policy committee, and ensuring that consumers are given sufficient information about chemicals that may be in the products they consume when making purchasing choices is prudent public policy.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the Clean Label Project and is supported by a coalition of public health advocates. In support of the bill the Clean Label Project writes:
Methylene Chloride, also known as Dichloromethane, is a volatile, nonflammable, chlorinated hydrocarbon and colorless chemical solvent. It was commonly used as a solvent in paint removers, in the manufacturing of pharmaceuticals and as a degreasing agent for industrial use.
Methylene Chloride is a carcinogen that has been banned by the US EPA for industrial uses due to adverse health impacts to workers. Japan and Korea have banned coffee decaffeinated using Methylene Chloride. Canada requires such coffee to be labeled. The US EPA has determined the use of Methylene Chloride to be hazardous. The US EPA also found Methylene Chloride to pose an unreasonable risk to human health. The CA Office of Health Hazard Assessment found Methylene Chloride to be a cancer risk and has placed it on the Prop 65 list.
It is often pregnant women and people with high blood pressure that drink decaffeinated coffee. The State of California’s evaluation of Methylene Chloride concluded that during pregnancy, Methylene Chloride can pass from mother to baby.
Safer decaffeination processes are in use today. Those processes use water or air methods to decaffeinate coffee. There is no justification for using this known carcinogen to decaffeinate coffee.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This measure is opposed by a coalition of coffee producers and business groups including the National Coffee Association, Alliance of Coffee Decaffeinators, and the American Beverage Association. In opposition to the bill, the National Coffee Association writes:
The National Coffee Association (NCA) respectfully opposes AB 2066 (Reyes), which would require European Method decaf coffee to bear a misleading warning, thereby contradicting (1) safety authorizations by the European Union, the United States, and other food safety authorities that have approved European Method decaf ; and (2) the overwhelming weight of independent scientific evidence, which demonstrates that drinking European Method decaf, like all coffee, is associated with numerous significant health benefits, including increased longevity and decreased risk of multiple cancers.
In its previous version, AB 2066 sought to outright ban European Method decaf. The lack of any evidence whatsoever supporting a ban, coupled with the overwhelming evidence showing that European Method decaf is both safe and healthy, prompted the author to abandon this baseless proposed ban and shift to now claiming consumers need to be warned about health risks that do not exist. But just as there was no evidence to support the ban, there is equally no evidence to support a shift to seeking misleading warning label.
The majority of decaffeinated coffee has been made using the European Method for more than 50 years. In this method, a mixture of water and methylene chloride is used to remove caffeine from green, unroasted coffee beans. It is not added to finished decaffeinated coffee.
Regulatory authorities around the world have approved the European Method as safe, including the European Union, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.S. FDA. As noted above, FDA has set a safe level of 10 ppm for trace amounts of methylene chloride in decaffeinated roasted coffee grounds.
The overwhelming weight of independent scientific evidence also shows that drinking European Method decaffeinated coffee, like all coffee, is associated with numerous significant health benefits and is not associated with increased cancer risk. In fact, large-scale prospective follow-up human studies suggest that decaffeinated coffee may be associated with reduced risk of multiple cancers and chronic diseases
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
Clean Label Project
Cleanearth4kids.org
Educate. Advocate.
Environmental Working Group
Facts: Families Advocating for Chemical & Toxics Safety
Physicians for Social Responsibility - San Francisco Bay Area Chapter
Reproductive Freedom for All
Social Eco Education
Opposition
Alliance of Coffee Decaffeinators
American Beverage Association
American Chemistry Council
California Automatic Vendors Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Consumer Brands Association
National Automatic Merchandising Association
National Coffee Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 16, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2066
Author:(Reyes) – As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
SUBJECT: The California Food Safety Act.
SUMMARY: Prohibits, commencing January 1, 2027, a person or entity from using methylene chloride (MC) in the process of decaffeinating coffee. Prohibits the sale, delivery, distribution, holding or offer for sale in commerce coffee that has been decaffeinated in a process using MC. Makes a violation of these provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district attorney.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Sherman Food, Drug and Cosmetics Law, administered by the California Department of Public Health (DPH), which regulates the packaging, labeling, and advertising of drugs and devices, including dietary supplements. [Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 109875-111929.4]
- Defines food as:
- Any article used or intended for use for food, drink, confection, condiment, or chewing gum by man or other animal; and,
- Any article used or intended for use as a component of any article designated in a) above. [HSC § 109935].
- Defines color additive as a substance that satisfies both of the following requirements: a) it is a dye, pigment, or other substance made by a process of synthesis or similar artifice, or extracted, isolated, or otherwise derived, with or without intermediate or final change of identity, from a vegetable, animal, mineral, or other source; and, b) when added or applied to a food, drug, device, or cosmetic, or to the human body or any part of the body, it is capable, alone or through reaction with any other substance, of imparting color to the food, drug, device, or cosmetic, or to the human body or the part of the human body, to which it is added or applied. [HSC § 109895]
- Defines food additive as any substance, the intended use of which results or may reasonably be expected to result, directly or indirectly, in the substance becoming a component of the food or otherwise affecting characteristics of the food. [HSC § 109940]
- Permits DPH whenever public health or other considerations in this state require, to adopt, upon its own motion, or upon the petition of any interested party, regulations that prescribe tolerances, included but not limited to zero tolerances, for poisonous or deleterious substances, food additives, pesticide chemicals, or color additives. Authorizes DPH to prescribe the conditions under which a food additive or a color additive may be safely used and may grant exemptions for a food additive or color additive when it is to be used solely for investigational or experimental purposes. Requires a petitioner to furnish data, as specified. [HSC § 110070]
- Requires DPH, in adopting regulations under 5) above, to consider specified factors, including the probable consumption and effect of the substance in the diet of man or any other animal and safety factors, as specified. [HSC § 110075]
- Requires all food additive regulations and any amendments to the regulations adopted pursuant to the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) in effect on November 23, 1970, or adopted on or after that date, are the food additive regulations of this state. Permits DPH, by regulation, to prescribe conditions under which a food additive may be used in this state whether or not these conditions are in accordance with the regulations adopted pursuant to the FDCA. [HSC § 110085]
- Establishes within the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) to protect and enhance the health of Californians and the state’s environment through scientific evaluations that inform, support and guide regulatory and other actions. [HSC §59000 et. seq.]
- Establishes, through the initiative process, Proposition 65, commonly known as the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, which requires businesses to provide warnings to Californians about significant exposures to chemicals that cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm. Specifies that these chemicals can be in the products that Californians purchase, in their homes or workplaces, or that are released into the environment. Prohibits California businesses from knowingly discharging significant amounts of listed chemicals into sources of drinking water. Requires California to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. Requires this list to be updated at least once a year, and now includes approximately 900. [HSC § 25249.5 - 25249.14]
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Establishes the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA), which among various functions regulates food, dietary supplements, and cosmetics. [21 United States Code (U.S.C.) §310 et.seq.]
- Defines food additive as any substance the intended use of which results or may reasonably be expected to result, directly or indirectly, in its becoming a component or otherwise affecting the characteristic of any food (including any substance intended for use in producing, manufacturing, packing, processing, preparing, treating, packaging, transporting, or holding food; and including any source of radiation intended for any such use); if such substance is not generally recognized as safe or sanctioned prior to 1958 or otherwise excluded from the definition of food additives, as specified. [Title 21 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) §170.3]
- Defines color additive as any material that is a dye, pigment or other substance that when added or applied to a food, drug, or cosmetic or to the human body that imparts color. [Title 21 CFR §70.3]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, this bill seeks to protect against the use of MC, a carcinogenic chemical solvent, in the manufacturing process of decaffeinated coffee. The author highlights that the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) banned the use of MC as a solvent due to its advertise impacts on workers and OEHHA includes MC on its Proposition 65 list because it can cause cancer. The author contends that this is of concern for pregnant people, who switch from caffeinated to decaffeinated coffee, assuming it is safe to consume. According to OEHHA, MC can pass from mother to baby. The author contends that there are safer methods to decaffeinate coffee, and that MC should not be ingested or utilized in the decaffeination process, due to its carcinogenic risks. The author concludes that this bill seeks to protect coffee consumers and make decaffeinated coffee safer, in particular for those who are pregnant and those with pre-existing health conditions.
- BACKGROUND.
- MC. According to the EPA, MC, which is also called Dichloromethane, is a volatile chemical that is produced and imported into the United States, with use estimated at over 260 million pounds per year. MC is a solvent used in a variety of industries and applications, such as adhesives, paint and coating products, pharmaceuticals, metal cleaning, chemical processing, and aerosols. Certain paint strippers, aerosol paints, and adhesives, as well as other metal cleaning products, can contain MC. MC is also used as solvent in the process to decaffeinate coffee.
- How does MC exposure occur? Because of its volatility, it is found mostly in air, and the predominant exposure for the general population occurs from inhalation (primarily from industrial emissions and consumer product use). In 1996, the national average concentration of MC in outdoor air was 0.47 micrograms per square meter (μg/m3). Indoor inhalation exposures can result from using consumer products containing MC such as adhesives, spray shoe polishes, paint and adhesive removers, and building materials and furnishings. Average indoor air concentrations collected from urban, suburban, and rural residences between 1990 (after the 1989 ban on hairspray) and 2005 ranged from 0.4 to 3.5 μg/m3. Concentrations of MC in food and water are small compared to concentrations in air; thus, oral exposures are low. Drinking-water mean concentrations are generally less than one part per billion (ppb), which is below the 5 ppb maximum contaminant level (MCL). MC releases to drinking-water sources are estimated to range between 0.3 and 2.4% of total environmental releases, much lower than the 86–95% estimate for atmospheric releases, with releases to land accounting for 2–12%. Dermal absorption of MC has been demonstrated in animals and in humans making this pathway another potential exposure pathway of concern, particularly in occupational settings without adequate protective gear and with improper use of consumer products (e.g., paint strippers). High indoor air concentrations of MC have been reported in occupational settings, where the largest numbers of workers are potentially exposed to the chemical during metal cleaning, industrial paint stripping, and tasks using ink solvents. Drinking-water mean concentrations are generally less than one part per billion (ppb), which is below the 5 ppb MCL.
- Links between MC and cancer. In their 2020 risk evaluation of MC, the EPA stated that most of the human data on lung cancer and MC exposure are not conclusive and most do not show an association with MC. The EPA stated that in animal studies, MC produced large, statistically significant increases in lung tumor incidences in male and female mice exposed by inhalation. When looking at ingestion of MC, there was also some evidence for production of lung tumors in mice by oral exposure to MC. Researchers reported a nonsignificant dose-related trend for higher incidences of pulmonary adenomas in male, but not female, mice in an oral gavage study that was, however, terminated at 64 weeks due to high mortality. A two-year drinking water study did not find any increase in lung tumor incidence in male or female mice. Lung tumors were not increased by MC in rats or hamsters by inhalation or oral exposure. Data from oral animal studies also identified nervous system effects that include sensorimotor and neuromuscular changes after acute and short-term exposure as well as excitability, autonomic effects, decreased activity and convulsions (one rat) after short-term exposure.
- Regulations related to MC.
- EPA regulations. In March 2019, EPA issued a final rule to prohibit the manufacture (including import), processing, and distribution of MC in all paint and coating removers for consumer use. EPA states that they took this action because of the acute fatalities that have resulted from exposure to the chemical. In November 2022, EPA released a final revised risk determination finding that MC as a whole chemical substance presents an unreasonable risk of injury to health under its conditions of use. In May 2023, the EPA proposed prohibiting manufacturing, processing, and distribution of MC for all consumer uses, prohibit most industrial and commercial uses of MC, create strict workplace protections to ensure that for the remaining uses, workers will not be harmed by MC use; and require manufacturers (including importers), processors, and distributors to notify companies to whom MC is shipped of the prohibitions and to maintain records.
- California. Recently, the OEHHA added MC to its Prop. 65 list. Per OEHHA’s website, MC exposure occurs by breathing in MC in the air and skin contact with products that contain MC. OEHHA’s website also states that during pregnancy, MC can pass from mother to baby.
- MC in decaffeinated coffee. MC is used in the process of decaffeinating green coffee and tea. Green coffee beans are steamed to open their “pores” and make caffeine more accessible. The beans are rinsed with a mixture of water and MC, which bonds to and removes caffeine. The liquid solution (now containing the caffeine originally in the beans) is removed. Caffeine is extracted from the solution for use in other products, and nearly 100% of the liquid is captured and reused to decaffeinate more coffee beans. Decaffeinated coffee beans are dried and roasted at approximately 400˚ Fahrenheit or higher, which is two to four times higher than the evaporation point of MC.
- FDA Petition.
- The Environmental Defense Fund, Breast Cancer Prevention Partners, Center for Environmental Health, the Environmental Working Group, and Lisa Lefferts, an environmental health consultant, submitted a petition to amend food additive regulations to eliminate the agency-approved uses of MC among other solvents. Since 1958, the FDCA has stated that “no [food] additive shall be deemed to be safe if it is found to induce cancer when ingested by man or animal, or if it is found, after tests which are appropriate for the evaluation of the safety of food additives, to induce cancer in man or animal . . .” (21U.S.C. § 348(c)(3)(A)). This requirement, known as the Delaney Clause, is a bright line drawn by Congress that carcinogens are not safe to use in food. This statutory requirement has not been altered in the intervening half-century. The petitioners claim that MC as has been found to induce cancer in humans or animals, and it is not safe pursuant to the Delaney Clause.
- The National Coffee Association responded to this filing stating the following: MC used as a processing aid to decaffeinate coffee does not trigger the Delaney Clause because: (1) there is no evidence supporting the assertion that MC induces cancer when ingested in decaffeinated coffee; and, (2) experts (including FDA) have not conducted appropriate tests to evaluate whether MC is found to induce cancer when used as a food additive in decaffeinated coffee. Thus, FDA is not required to—and should not—delist MC for use as a food additive. Under the FDCA, the FDA cannot approve a food additive unless data establishes that the food additive is safe for its intended use. The FDCA requires FDA to consider, among other factors, the probable consumption of the additive, the cumulative effect the additive may have in the diet of humans or animals, and safety factors that experts recognize as appropriate for the use of animal experimentation data. If FDA determines that a food additive is safe, it means that there is a “reasonable certainty in the minds of competent scientists that the substance is not harmful under the intended conditions of use.”
- Studies on MC concentrations in decaffeinated coffee. Studies conducted in 1977, 1984, 1987, and 1989 analyzed samples of decaffeinated coffee. Collectively, these studies demonstrate that the concentration of MC in decaffeinated roasted coffee or decaffeinated instant coffee is often below the limit of detection (≤50 ppb) and, at most, is detected at ~9,000 ppb (equivalent to ~9 ppm), which remains below the FDA limit of 10 ppm. Additionally, based on the samples available, MC concentrations in decaffeinated instant coffee (maximum of 0.91 ppm) are lower than in decaffeinated roasted coffee. Clean Label Project, sponsors of this bill, conducted a study of MC levels in decaffeinated coffee samples in 2022. The samples they studied found trace amounts of MC. All test results were below the regulatory limits.
- Methods to decaffeinate coffee.
- The direct solvent method. This technique typically utilizes MC, coffee oil, or ethyl acetate. The liquid solvent is circulated through a bed of moist, green coffee beans, removing some of the caffeine; the solvent is then recaptured in an evaporator, and the beans are washed with water. Residues of the solvent are removed from the coffee to trace levels by steaming the beans. Often this process utilizes batch processing--that is, solvent is added to the vessel, circulated and emptied several times until the coffee has been decaffeinated to the desired level. Solvents are used because they are generally more precisely targeted to caffeine than is charcoal, leaving behind nearly all the non-caffeine solids. The more caffeine-specific solvents, such as MCs, can extract 96 to 97 % of the caffeine.
- The Swiss Water Process. The Swiss Water Process is based solely on water and carbon filtration. The coffee beans are first immersed in hot water to extract their caffeine and flavorful components. The initial beans are then discarded, and the resulting flavor-rich water (called “green coffee extract”) is passed through a carbon filter that is sized to capture only the large caffeine molecules. The decaffeinated green coffee extract is then used to wash and filter the next batch of beans. Caffeine is thereby filtered from the beans without recourse to chemical agents and without the beans losing many of their flavorful components. This is the primary method used to decaffeinate organic coffee beans. This method does not utilize MC.
- Supercritical Carbon Dioxide method. Finally, the supercritical carbon dioxide method uses carbon dioxide (CO2) under high temperatures and pressure to act like both a gas and a liquid. This supercritical CO2 reaches into the crevices of coffee beans like a gas but dissolves caffeine like a liquid. After the beans have been soaked in water (a process that expands cell structures and makes it easier to extract the caffeine molecules), they are exposed to supercritical CO2 for several hours. The caffeinated CO2 liquefies and evaporates, and the beans are then processed. Because this method leaves the carbohydrates and proteins intact, there is less change in taste as a result of decaffeination. This method does not utilize MC.
- MC in decaffeinated coffee. More research is needed regarding the specific health impacts of MC used in the coffee decaffeination process on human health. Generally, decaffeinated coffee is associated with a lower risk of mortality. Drinking decaffeinated coffee is not associated with an increase in the risk of cancer.
- Liver cancer and other liver diseases. Perhaps one of the most well-known and scientifically rigorous prospective cohort studies in the world is the UK Biobank Study. Comparing 384,818 coffee drinkers and 109,767 non-coffee drinkers who were followed for a median of 10.7 years, the UK Biobank Study results showed substantially lower risks of hepatocellular carcinoma (liver cancer), chronic liver diseases, and death due to chronic liver diseases among coffee drinkers. The associations for decaffeinated, instant and ground coffee individually were similar to all types combined.
- Hepatocellular carcinoma. The European Prospective Investigation into Cancer (EPIC) Study, another major prospective cohort study of nearly 500,000 individuals, also found a lower risk of hepatocellular carcinoma in those who consumed decaffeinated coffee, although this decrease was not statistically significant. In another case-control study in Italy, there were no significant associations between decaffeinated coffee intake and risk of liver cancer. A meta-analysis of 18 cohort studies and eight case-control studies found that decaffeinated coffee intake was associated with a decreased risk of hepatocellular carcinoma in humans, even when there was pre-existing liver disease.
- Breast Cancer. Prospective epidemiologic studies have found no evidence for an increased risk of breast cancer among those who drink decaffeinated coffee. A meta-analysis of 37 studies found no association between decaffeinated coffee intake and breast cancer risk. These studies included millions of participants, tens of thousands of whom developed breast cancer. Therefore, they had ample statistical power to detect even minimal increased risks, yet none declared an increased risk of breast cancer in those who consumed decaffeinated coffee.
- Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma (NHL). The results of the Women’s Health Initiative Observational Study, a prospective study that followed more than 74,000 women for 18 years, found no association between decaffeinated coffee consumption and the risk of NHL. More than 850 women developed NHL in this study, yet there was no observable association with decaffeinated coffee intake. These results are similar to those found in a previous case-control study.
- Lung cancer. A meta-analysis of epidemiologic studies concluded that drinking decaffeinated coffee was associated with lower risk of lung cancer, although the numbers were relatively small. A 2016 study found there was a slight increase in the risk of lung cancer among both caffeinated and decaffeinated coffee drinkers, but the point estimate for this increased risk was smaller among decaffeinated coffee drinkers than among caffeinated coffee drinkers, making it unlikely that any effect was attributable to decaffeination. The authors conclude that: “it is likely that the remaining association is due to residual confounding by smoking.” Another combined analysis of prospective studies published in 2021, which including the aforementioned study, found a slightly increased risk of lung cancer among both caffeinated and decaffeinated coffee drinkers yet the authors caution that “these findings should not be assumed to be causal because of the likelihood of residual confounding by smoking, including passive smoking, and change of coffee and tea consumption after study enrollment.”
- FDA Petition.
- SUPPORT. Clean Label Project (CLP), the sponsor of this bill, states that MC is a volatile, nonflammable, chlorinated hydrocarbon and colorless chemical solvent. It was commonly used as a solvent in paint removers, in the manufacturing of pharmaceuticals and as a degreasing agent for industrial use. CLP continues that MC is a carcinogen that has been banned by the EPA for industrial uses due to adverse health impacts to workers. CLP states Japan and Korea have banned coffee decaffeinated using MC, and Canada requires such coffee to be labeled. CLP further states the EPA has determined the use of MC to be hazardous and poses an unreasonable risk to human health. CLP continues that the OEHHA found MC to be a cancer risk and has placed it on the Prop 65 list. CLP states it is often pregnant women and people with high blood pressure that drink decaffeinated coffee. CLP continues that the State of California’s evaluation of MC concluded that during pregnancy, MC can pass from mother to baby. CLP states that there are safer decaffeination processes are in use today, such as processes use water or air methods to decaffeinate coffee. CLP concludes there is no justification for using this known carcinogen to decaffeinate coffee.
- OPPOSITION. The National Coffee Association (NCA) opposes this bill. NCA argues that this bill contradicts: a) scientific determinations by the European Union, the United States, and food safety authorities around the world, all of which have authorized European Method decaf as safe; and, b) the overwhelming weight of independent scientific evidence, which demonstrates that drinking European Method decaf, like all coffee, is associated with numerous significant health benefits, including increased longevity and decreased risk of multiple cancers. The majority of decaffeinated coffee has been made using the European Method for more than 50 years. In this method, a mixture of water and MC is used to remove caffeine from green, unroasted coffee beans. It is not added to finished decaffeinated coffee. Because caffeine is removed before coffee beans are roasted at extremely high temperatures (well above the evaporation temperature for MC), data show that any minute traces of MC are either undetectable or otherwise present at infinitesimal levels, well below the safe standard of 10 ppm set by FDA. The majority of decaffeinated coffee is made using the European Method because it is safe, retains flavor, effectively removes more than 97% of caffeine, and conserves energy and water. All decaffeination methods rely on chemistry to extract caffeine naturally found in coffee beans. Other decaffeination methods are much less widely available and more expensive than the European Method. Banning European Method decaf would leave only a minority of decaffeinated coffee on the market, increase prices, and restrict Californians’ access to a safe product associated with health benefits.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 2365 (Haney) adds kratom products to the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law. Prescribes specified quantities of alkaloids present in kratom products, establishes labeling and packaging requirements, and requires that kratom products be registered with DPH annually, which would include certification by a laboratory specifying that the product meets certain qualifications. Prohibits the sale of kratom leaf and kratom products to those under 18 years of age. AB 2365 passed the Assembly Committee on Health with a 15-0 vote on April 9, 2024 and is pending in the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials.
- AB 1830 (Arambula) requires a manufacturer of corn masa flour (CMF) to add folic acid at a level not to exceed 0.7 milligrams of folic acid per pound of CMF and to include a declaration of folic acid on the nutrition label in accordance with applicable federal law. AB 1830 is on the Assembly Floor.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION. AB 418 (Gabriel), Chapter 328, Statutes of 2023, prohibits a person or entity, commencing January 1, 2027, from manufacturing, selling, delivering, distributing, holding, or offering for sale, in commerce a food product for human consumption that contains any of the following substances: Brominated vegetable oil; Potassium bromate; Propylparaben; or Red dye 3. AB 418 makes a violation of its provisions punishable by a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 for a first violation and not to exceed $10,000 for each subsequent violation, upon an action brought by the Attorney General, a city attorney, a county counsel, or a district.
- DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double-referred, upon passage of this Committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
- SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS. To allow sufficient time for manufacturers and retailers to transition, the author may wish to amend this bill to delay implementation to January 1, 2032.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Clean Label Project (sponsor)
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
Cleanearth4kids.org
Educate. Advocate.
Environmental Working Group
Facts: Families Advocating for Chemical & Toxics Safety
Physicians for Social Responsibility - San Francisco Bay Area Chapter
Reproductive Freedom for All
SEE (Social Eco Education)
Opposition
Alliance of Coffee Decaffeinators
American Beverage Association
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Consumer Brands Association
National Coffee Association
Analysis Prepared by: Eliza Brooks / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):