AB 2880: State intellectual property.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-06-21
(1)The California Public Records Act requires a state or local agency, as defined, to make public records available for inspection, subject to certain exceptions.
This bill would require a public agency to comply with a request to inspect or copy a public record that is protected by the federal Copyright Revision Act of 1976 unless the record is otherwise exempt from disclosure.
(2)
(1)Under existing law, contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by the Department of General Services. Existing law imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state. Existing law requires the department to develop factors for state agencies to consider in deciding whether to sell or license their intellectual property.
This bill would, for contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, require a state agency entering into a contract for services to consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department.
(3)
(2)Existing law exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by the Department of General Services that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill would additionally exempt those actions taken with respect to the departments above-described duties relating to the management and development of state intellectual property, as provided.
(1)The California Public Records Act requires a state or local agency, as defined, to make public records available for inspection, subject to certain exceptions.
This bill would provide that any work released into the public domain would be a public record. The bill would also prohibit a public agency from denying a request for public records under the California Public Records Act on the grounds that the information requested is protected under the federal Copyright Act of 1976, except as specified. require a public agency to comply with a request to inspect or copy a public record that is protected by the federal Copyright Revision Act of 1976 unless the record is otherwise exempt from disclosure.
(2)Existing law authorizes the Department of General Services to carry out various powers and duties relating to assisting a state agency in the management and development of intellectual property developed by state employees or with state funding, including, among other duties, developing a database of state-owned intellectual property using specified data and factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others.
This bill would authorize a state entity to own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. The bill would provide that a state entitys intellectual property rights would not preclude the state entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act.
(3)
(2)Under existing law, contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by the Department of General Services. Existing law imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state. Existing law requires the department to develop factors for state agencies to consider in deciding whether to sell or license their intellectual property.
This bill would require the department to develop factors for state agencies to consider
The bill would require a state entity that reasonably determines that a work meets the criteria for copyright protection to catalogue the work and submit the information to the department. For
This bill would, for contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, the bill would prohibit require a state agency from entering into a contract that fails to address the states for services to consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department. The bill would also require the department to develop sample language for an advisory provision stating, among other things, that an attempted waiver of intellectual property rights without the approval of the department is void. The bill would provide criteria to be considered by a state entity in pursuing an action for copyright infringement.
(4)
(3)Existing law exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by the Department of General Services that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill would additionally exempt those actions taken with respect to the departments above-described duties relating to the management and development of state intellectual property, as provided.
(5)Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing
(1)The California Public Records Act requires a state or local agency, as defined, to make public records available for inspection, subject to certain exceptions.
This bill would provide that any work released into the public domain would be a public record. The bill would also prohibit a public agency from denying a request for public records under the California Public Records Act on the grounds that the information requested is protected under the federal Copyright Act of 1976, except as specified.
(2)Existing law authorizes the Department of General Services to carry out various powers and duties relating to assisting a state agency in the management and development of intellectual property developed by state employees or with state funding, including, among other duties, developing a database of state-owned intellectual property using specified data and factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others.
This bill would authorize a public state entity to own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. The bill would provide that a public state entitys intellectual property rights would not preclude the public state entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act and that those disclosures would not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act of 1976. Act.
Under
(3)Under existing law, contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by the Department of General Services. Existing law imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state. Existing law requires the department to develop factors for state agencies to consider in deciding whether to sell or license their intellectual property.
This bill would require the department to develop factors for state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department regarding the management and development of state intellectual property. For
The bill would require a state entity that reasonably determines that a work meets the criteria for copyright protection to catalogue the work and submit the information to the department. For contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, the bill would prohibit a state agency from entering into a contract that waives fails to address the states intellectual property rights unless the agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver and would provide that a waiver of the states intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates this requirement would be deemed void as against public policy. department. The bill would also require the department to develop sample language for an advisory provision to that effect. stating, among other things, that an attempted waiver of intellectual property rights without the approval of the department is void. The bill would provide criteria to be considered by a state entity in pursuing an action for copyright infringement.
Existing
(4)Existing law exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by the Department of General Services that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill would additionally exempt those actions taken with respect to the departments above-described duties relating to the management and development of state intellectual property, as provided.
(5)Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law authorizes the Department of General Services to carry out various powers and duties relating to assisting a state agency in the management and development of intellectual property developed by state employees or with state funding, including, among other duties, developing a database of state-owned intellectual property using specified data and factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others.
This bill would authorize a public entity to own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. The bill would provide that a public entitys intellectual property rights would not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act and that those disclosures would not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act of 1976.
Under existing law, contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by the Department of General Services. Existing law imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state.
This bill would require state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department regarding the management and development of state intellectual property. For contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, the bill would prohibit a state agency from entering into a contract that waives the states intellectual property rights unless the agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver and would provide that a waiver of the states intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates this requirement would be deemed void as against public policy. The bill would also require the department to develop sample language for an advisory provision to that effect.
Existing law exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by the Department of General Services that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill would additionally exempt those actions taken with respect to the departments above-described duties relating to the management and development of state intellectual property, as provided.
Existing law requires the Department of General Services to, among other duties, track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding.
This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation related to the rights to state-owned intellectual property.
Existing law requires the Department of General Services to, among other duties, track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding.
This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation related to the rights to state-owned intellectual property.
A public agency shall comply with a request to inspect or copy a public record that is protected by the Copyright Revision Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.) to the extent permitted by this chapter, unless that public record is otherwise exempt from disclosure under any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 6254 and 6255.
SEC. 2.SECTION 1.Section 14615.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:14615.1.(a)Where the Legislature directs or authorizes the department to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties under this chapter and Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 14650) of this part, Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5, or Section 6611 of the Public Contract Code or Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, the action by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340), Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11370), Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400), and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500)). This section shall apply to actions taken by the department with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
(b)To the extent permitted by the United States and California Constitutions, subdivision (a) also applies to actions taken by the department prior to January 1, 1999, with respect to competitive procurement in the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 10335 of the Public Contract Code is amended to read:10335.(a)This article shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, whether or not the services involve the furnishing or use of equipment, materials, or supplies or are performed by an independent contractor. Except as provided in Sections 10295.6 and 10351, and paragraphs (8) and (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 10340, all contracts subject to this article are of no effect unless and until approved by the department. Each contract shall be transmitted with all papers, estimates, and recommendations concerning it to the department and, if approved by the department, shall be effective from the date of approval. This article shall apply to any state agency that by general or specific statute is expressly or impliedly authorized to enter into the transactions referred to in this section. This article shall not apply to contracts for the construction, alteration, improvement, repair, or maintenance of real or personal property, contracts for services subject to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 4525) of Division 5 of Title 1 of the Government Code, to contracts that are listed as exceptions in Section 10295, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) in amount, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) where only per diem or travel expenses, or a combination thereof, are to be paid, contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency.
(b)In exercising its authority under this article with respect to contracts for the services of legal counsel, other than the Attorney General, entered into by any state agency that is subject to Section 11042 or Section 11043 of the Government Code, the department, as a condition of approval of the contract, shall require the state agency to demonstrate that the consent of the Attorney General to the employment of the other counsel has been granted pursuant to Section 11040 of the Government Code. This consent shall not be construed in a manner that would authorize the Attorney General to establish a separate program for reviewing and approving contracts in the place of, or in addition to, the program administered by the department pursuant to this article.
(c)Until January 1, 2001, the department shall maintain a list of contracts approved pursuant to subdivision (b). This list shall be filed quarterly with the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review and the Assembly Committee on Budget. The list shall be limited to contracts with a consideration in excess of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) during the life of the contract and shall include sufficient information to identify the provider of legal services, the length of each contract, applicable hourly rates, and the need for the services. The department shall add a contract that meets these conditions to the list within 10 days after approval. A copy of the list shall be made available to any requester. The department may charge a fee to cover the cost of supplying the list as provided in Section 6253 of the Government Code.
(d)(1)In exercising its authority under this article, a state agency shall consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(2)For contracts under this article entered into on or after January 1, 2017, a state agency shall consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department.
(e)Contracts subject to the approval of the department shall also have the departments approval for a modification or amendment thereto, with the following exceptions:
(1)An amendment to a contract that only extends the original time for completion of performance for a period of one year or less is exempt. If the original contract was subject to approval by the department, one fully executed copy including transmittal document, explaining the reason for the extension, shall be sent to the legal office of the department. A contract may only be amended once under this exemption.
(2)Contracts let or awarded on the basis of a law requiring competitive bidding may be modified or amended only if the contract so provides or if authorized by the law requiring competitive bidding.
(3)If an amendment to a contract has the effect of giving the contract as amended an increase in monetary amount, or an agreement by the state to indemnify or save harmless any person, the amendment shall be approved by the department.
(a)Any work released into the public domain shall be deemed a public record.
(b)A public agency shall not deny a request for a record that is otherwise public pursuant to this chapter on grounds that the information requested is protected by the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.). A request for such a record shall be denied only if one of the following applies:
(1)The facts of the particular case demonstrate that the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record as provided in subdivision (a) of Section 6255.
(2)The record in question is exempt under express provisions of this chapter.
(c)A public agency that releases a public record that is subject to copyright protection pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 13988.3 shall issue the requesting party a license to use the record in a manner that is consistent with the rights provided under this chapter and that is considered an act of fair use under the federal Copyright Act. The license may restrict the holder from using the record for a commercial use only if such use would result in economic harm to the public agency or to the publics interest.
6253.11.A public agency shall comply with a request to inspect or copy a public record that is protected by the Copyright Revision Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.) to the extent permitted by this chapter, unless that public record is otherwise exempt from disclosure under any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 6254 and 6255.
SEC. 2.Section 13988 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The state is home to many of the worlds top research universities, national laboratories, and leading-edge high-technology companies that generate significant intellectual property.
(b)It is in the interest of the state to ensure that the results of state-funded research are promptly developed and protected and to make the research available in the public domain, where appropriate.
(c)The commercialization of technology developed with the investment of taxpayer dollars in the form of contracts, grants, and agreements could generate public benefit, including, but not limited to, state revenues, favorable pricing, revenue sharing, reinvestment into research, development of new technologies, the commercialization of the product of state-funded research, and the jobs created from these types of research.
(d)It is in the interest of the state to facilitate, promote, and enhance technology transfer programs that will facilitate the transfer of technology into the marketplace for the public benefit.
(e)The Legislature supports the use of efficient models to develop and streamline infrastructures, policies, and processes for the management of intellectual property developed under state funding in order to stimulate economic development in the state while, at the same time, minimizing costs of administering policies in this area.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature that the rights of state agencies and departments to track and manage intellectual property created with any state funds shall be interpreted so as to promote the benefit to the public and be managed in a way that encourages a release into the public domain whenever it is feasible and appropriate and does not interfere with the publics right to access to public records.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Department of General Services have access to information about intellectual property created by state employees and by state-funded research, consistent with state and federal laws and regulations governing access to this information.
(h)The Legislature recognizes that the licensing of or limitations on the use of intellectual property should accommodate free expression and, therefore, state agencies and departments should not develop policies or procedures to license or otherwise limit the use of the states intellectual property in expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
(i)The Legislature recognizes that because state agencies and departments have different intellectual property needs, a statewide and uniform approach to managing the states intellectual property should provide state agencies and departments reasonable levels of discretion that promote releasing information into the public domain and protect the state from unauthorized economic gain, but still ensure the publics right of access to public records.
SEC. 3.Section 13988.2 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.2.(a)The department shall perform all of the following functions:
(1)Commencing January 1, 2015, and every three years thereafter, track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding.
(2)Develop a database that includes, but is not limited to, tracking intellectual property by category of protection, date of creation, owner of intellectual property, grantee, state agency or granting entity, sources of funding, and status of licensing, including invention utilization updates. Failure to include an item in the database does not create any presumption regarding ownership. Prior to January 1, 2018, the database shall include the summary of state-owned intellectual property found in the California State Auditors Report 2011-106 on intellectual property. After January 1, 2018, and every three years thereafter, the database shall be updated using information collected by the department pursuant to this section.
(3)Develop a sample maintenance plan of an inventory of intellectual property.
(4)Develop factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property, make intellectual property available in the public domain, or grant the use of their intellectual property to others, including, but not limited to, the states best interest, maintaining public access, and preventing improper economic gain through the unauthorized use of state-owned intellectual property.
(5)Develop an outreach campaign informing state agencies of their rights and abilities concerning intellectual property created by their employees.
(6)Develop sample invention assignment agreements that state agencies can consider if they believe it is necessary to secure the rights to potentially patentable items created by their employees on worktime using state resources.
(7)Develop sample language for licenses or terms-of-use agreements that state agencies can use to limit the use of their intellectual property by others to only appropriate purposes.
(8)Develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the states intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of the department and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void.
(b)This section shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
SEC. 4.Section 13988.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.3.(a)To the extent not inconsistent with the rights of the public to obtain, inspect, copy, publish, and otherwise communicate information under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1), under subdivision (a) of Section 2 and subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, and under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, a state entity may own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires.
(b)(1)When a state entity creates a work that is otherwise subject to copyright protection, the work shall be released into the public domain unless the state entity reasonably determines any of the following:
(A)The work has commercial value, and the release would jeopardize the integrity of the work.
(B)The release would infringe upon the property interests of a third party.
(C)The release would detrimentally affect the states interests in its trademarks, service marks, patents, or trade secrets.
(2)If a state entity reasonably determines that a work meets the criteria described in paragraph (1), the entity shall catalog those works and submit the information to the department for the purpose of tracking intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding as provided in Section 13998.2.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, state agencies and departments may, upon request, share records and information related to intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding with the department.
(d)Any employee or former employee of the department who has access to or knowledge of the records and information described in subdivision (b), shall not divulge or make known to any person not employed by the department in any manner not expressly permitted by law any particulars of these records or information that is restricted by law from public disclosure, or represents a first publication of research results, or information pertaining to patent rights that would not otherwise be publicly available.
(e)Nothing in this section requires a state entity to own, license, or formally register intellectual property that it creates or otherwise acquires.
(f)This section shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
SEC. 5.Section 13988.35 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 13988.3, to read:13988.35.In the event that a state entity pursues an action for copyright infringement, all of the following shall apply:
(a)Prior to sending a takedown notification, a state entity shall reasonably consider in good faith whether the allegedly infringing material constituted fair use.
(b)No state entity shall elect to receive statutory damages as provided under the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 504(c)) except in cases of willful infringement where there is no evidence of fair use.
(c)Upon a courts finding that the party defending the infringement action engaged in fair use, the state shall waive statutory damages.
SEC. 6. SEC. 2.Section 14615.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:14615.1.(a)Where the Legislature directs or authorizes the department to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties under this chapter and Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 14650) of this part, Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5, or Section 6611 of the Public Contract Code or Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, the action by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340), Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11370), Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400), and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500)). This section shall apply to actions taken by the department with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
(b)To the extent permitted by the United States and California Constitutions, subdivision (a) also applies to actions taken by the department prior to January 1, 1999, with respect to competitive procurement in the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
SEC. 7. SEC. 3.Section 10335 of the Public Contract Code is amended to read:10335.(a)This article shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, whether or not the services involve the furnishing or use of equipment, materials, or supplies or are performed by an independent contractor. Except as provided in Sections 10295.6 and 10351, and paragraphs (8) and (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 10340, all contracts subject to this article are of no effect unless and until approved by the department. Each contract shall be transmitted with all papers, estimates, and recommendations concerning it to the department and, if approved by the department, shall be effective from the date of approval. This article shall apply to any state agency that by general or specific statute is expressly or impliedly authorized to enter into the transactions referred to in this section. This article shall not apply to contracts for the construction, alteration, improvement, repair, or maintenance of real or personal property, contracts for services subject to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 4525) of Division 5 of Title 1 of the Government Code, to contracts that are listed as exceptions in Section 10295, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) in amount, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) where only per diem or travel expenses, or a combination thereof, are to be paid, contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency.
(b)In exercising its authority under this article with respect to contracts for the services of legal counsel, other than the Attorney General, entered into by any state agency that is subject to Section 11042 or Section 11043 of the Government Code, the department, as a condition of approval of the contract, shall require the state agency to demonstrate that the consent of the Attorney General to the employment of the other counsel has been granted pursuant to Section 11040 of the Government Code. This consent shall not be construed in a manner that would authorize the Attorney General to establish a separate program for reviewing and approving contracts in the place of, or in addition to, the program administered by the department pursuant to this article.
(c)Until January 1, 2001, the department shall maintain a list of contracts approved pursuant to subdivision (b). This list shall be filed quarterly with the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review and the Assembly Committee on Budget. The list shall be limited to contracts with a consideration in excess of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) during the life of the contract and shall include sufficient information to identify the provider of legal services, the length of each contract, applicable hourly rates, and the need for the services. The department shall add a contract that meets these conditions to the list within 10 days after approval. A copy of the list shall be made available to any requester. The department may charge a fee to cover the cost of supplying the list as provided in Section 6253 of the Government Code.
(d)(1)In exercising its authority under this article, a state agency shall consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(2)For contracts under this article entered into on or after January 1, 2017, a state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that fails to address the issue of consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department.
(e)Contracts subject to the approval of the department shall also have the departments approval for a modification or amendment thereto, with the following exceptions:
(1)An amendment to a contract that only extends the original time for completion of performance for a period of one year or less is exempt. If the original contract was subject to approval by the department, one fully executed copy including transmittal document, explaining the reason for the extension, shall be sent to the legal office of the department. A contract may only be amended once under this exemption.
(2)Contracts let or awarded on the basis of a law requiring competitive bidding may be modified or amended only if the contract so provides or if authorized by the law requiring competitive bidding.
(3)If an amendment to a contract has the effect of giving the contract as amended an increase in monetary amount, or an agreement by the state to indemnify or save harmless any person, the amendment shall be approved by the department.
SEC. 8.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 6253.11 to the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest to be protected and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect intellectual property developed by state entities from copyright infringement, it is necessary to provide a limited exemption for these records from the provision of the California Public Records Act.
(a)Any work released into the public domain shall be deemed a public record.
(b)A public agency shall not deny a request for a record that is otherwise public pursuant to this chapter on grounds that the information requested is protected by the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.). A request for such a record shall be denied only if one of the following applies:
(1)The facts of the particular case demonstrate that the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record as provided in subdivision (a) of Section 6255.
(2)The record in question is exempt under express provisions of this chapter.
(c)A public agency that releases a public record that is subject to copyright protection pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 13988.3 shall issue the requesting party a license to use the record in a manner that is consistent with the rights provided under this chapter and that is considered an act of fair use under the federal Copyright Act. The license may restrict the holder from using the record for a commercial use only if such use would result in economic harm to the public agency or to the publics interest.
SEC. 2.Section 13988 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The state is home to many of the worlds top research universities, national laboratories, and leading-edge high-technology companies that generate significant intellectual property.
(b)It is in the interest of the state to ensure that the results of state-funded research are promptly developed and protected and to make the research available in the public domain, where appropriate.
(c)The commercialization of technology developed with the investment of taxpayer dollars in the form of contracts, grants, and agreements could generate public benefit, including, but not limited to, state revenues, favorable pricing, revenue sharing, reinvestment into research, development of new technologies, the commercialization of the product of state-funded research, and the jobs created from these types of research.
(d)It is in the interest of the state to facilitate, promote, and enhance technology transfer programs that will facilitate the transfer of technology into the marketplace for the public benefit.
(e)The Legislature supports the use of efficient models to develop and streamline infrastructures, policies, and processes for the management of intellectual property developed under state funding in order to stimulate economic development in the state while, at the same time, minimizing costs of administering policies in this area.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature that the rights of state agencies and departments to track and manage intellectual property created with any state funds shall be interpreted so as to promote the benefit to the public. public and be managed in a way that encourages a release into the public domain whenever it is feasible and appropriate and does not interfere with the publics right to access to public records.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Department of General Services have access to information about intellectual property created by state employees and by state-funded research, consistent with state and federal laws and regulations governing access to this information.
(h)The Legislature recognizes that the licensing of or limitations on the use of intellectual property should accommodate free expression and, therefore, state agencies and departments should not develop policies or procedures to license or otherwise limit the use of the states intellectual property in expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
(i)The Legislature recognizes that because state agencies and departments have different intellectual property needs, a statewide and uniform approach to managing the states intellectual property should provide state agencies and departments reasonable levels of discretion that promote releasing information into the public domain and protect the state from unauthorized economic gain, but still ensure the publics right of access to public records.
SECTION 1. SEC. 3.Section 13988.2 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.2.(a)The department shall perform all of the following functions:
(1)Commencing January 1, 2015, and every three years thereafter, track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding.
(2)Develop a database that includes, but is not limited to, tracking intellectual property by category of protection, date of creation, owner of intellectual property, grantee, state agency or granting entity, sources of funding, and status of licensing, including invention utilization updates. Failure to include an item in the database does not create any presumption regarding ownership. Prior to January 1, 2018, the database shall include the summary of state-owned intellectual property found in the California State Auditors Report 2011-106 on intellectual property. After January 1, 2018, and every three years thereafter, the database shall be updated using information collected by the department pursuant to this section.
(3)Develop a sample maintenance plan of an inventory of intellectual property.
(4)Develop factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it property, make intellectual property available in the public domain, or grant the use of their intellectual property to others, including, but not limited to, the states best interest, maintaining public access, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain. preventing improper economic gain through the unauthorized use of state-owned intellectual property.
(5)Develop an outreach campaign informing state agencies of their rights and abilities concerning intellectual property created by their employees.
(6)Develop sample invention assignment agreements that state agencies can consider if they believe it is necessary to secure the rights to potentially patentable items created by their employees on worktime using state resources.
(7)Develop sample language for licenses or terms-of-use agreements that state agencies can use to limit the use of their intellectual property by others to only appropriate purposes.
(8)Develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the states intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of the department and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void as against public policy. void.
(c)
(b)This section shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
SEC. 2. SEC. 4.Section 13988.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.3.(a)A public To the extent not inconsistent with the rights of the public to obtain, inspect, copy, publish, and otherwise communicate information under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1), under subdivision (a) of Section 2 and subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, and under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, a state entity may own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. A public entitys intellectual property right shall not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1). A disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1) shall not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.).
(b)(1)When a state entity creates a work that is otherwise subject to copyright protection, the work shall be released into the public domain unless the state entity reasonably determines any of the following:
(A)The work has commercial value, and the release would jeopardize the integrity of the work.
(B)The release would infringe upon the property interests of a third party.
(C)The release would detrimentally affect the states interests in its trademarks, service marks, patents, or trade secrets.
(2)If a state entity reasonably determines that a work meets the criteria described in paragraph (1), the entity shall catalog those works and submit the information to the department for the purpose of tracking intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding as provided in Section 13998.2.
(b)
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, state agencies and departments may, upon request, share records and information related to intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding with the department.
(c)
(d)Any employee or former employee of the department who has access to or knowledge of the records and information described in subdivision (b), shall not divulge or make known to any person not employed by the department in any manner not expressly permitted by law any particulars of these records or information that is restricted by law from public disclosure, or represents a first publication of research results, or information pertaining to patent rights that would not otherwise be publicly available.
(e)Nothing in this section requires a state entity to own, license, or formally register intellectual property that it creates or otherwise acquires.
(f)This section shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
SEC. 5.Section 13988.35 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 13988.3, to read:13988.35.In the event that a state entity pursues an action for copyright infringement, all of the following shall apply:
(a)Prior to sending a takedown notification, a state entity shall reasonably consider in good faith whether the allegedly infringing material constituted fair use.
(b)No state entity shall elect to receive statutory damages as provided under the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 504(c)) except in cases of willful infringement where there is no evidence of fair use.
(c)Upon a courts finding that the party defending the infringement action engaged in fair use, the state shall waive statutory damages.
SEC. 3. SEC. 6.Section 14615.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:14615.1.(a)Where the Legislature directs or authorizes the department to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties under this chapter and Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 14650) of this part, Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5, or Section 6611 of the Public Contract Code or Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, the action by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340), Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11370), Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400), and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500)). This section shall apply to actions taken by the department with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
(b)To the extent permitted by the United States and California Constitutions, subdivision (a) also applies to actions taken by the department prior to January 1, 1999, with respect to competitive procurement in the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
SEC. 4. SEC. 7.Section 10335 of the Public Contract Code is amended to read:10335.(a)This article shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, whether or not the services involve the furnishing or use of equipment, materials, or supplies or are performed by an independent contractor. Except as provided in Sections 10295.6 and 10351, and paragraphs (8) and (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 10340, all contracts subject to this article are of no effect unless and until approved by the department. Each contract shall be transmitted with all papers, estimates, and recommendations concerning it to the department and, if approved by the department, shall be effective from the date of approval. This article shall apply to any state agency that by general or specific statute is expressly or impliedly authorized to enter into the transactions referred to in this section. This article shall not apply to contracts for the construction, alteration, improvement, repair, or maintenance of real or personal property, contracts for services subject to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 4525) of Division 5 of Title 1 of the Government Code, to contracts that are listed as exceptions in Section 10295, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) in amount, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) where only per diem or travel expenses, or a combination thereof, are to be paid, contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency.
(b)In exercising its authority under this article with respect to contracts for the services of legal counsel, other than the Attorney General, entered into by any state agency that is subject to Section 11042 or Section 11043 of the Government Code, the department, as a condition of approval of the contract, shall require the state agency to demonstrate that the consent of the Attorney General to the employment of the other counsel has been granted pursuant to Section 11040 of the Government Code. This consent shall not be construed in a manner that would authorize the Attorney General to establish a separate program for reviewing and approving contracts in the place of, or in addition to, the program administered by the department pursuant to this article.
(c)Until January 1, 2001, the department shall maintain a list of contracts approved pursuant to subdivision (b). This list shall be filed quarterly with the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review and the Assembly Committee on Budget. The list shall be limited to contracts with a consideration in excess of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) during the life of the contract and shall include sufficient information to identify the provider of legal services, the length of each contract, applicable hourly rates, and the need for the services. The department shall add a contract that meets these conditions to the list within 10 days after approval. A copy of the list shall be made available to any requester. The department may charge a fee to cover the cost of supplying the list as provided in Section 6253 of the Government Code.
(d)(1)In exercising its authority under this article, a state agency shall consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(2)For contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, both of the following shall apply:
(A)A a state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that waives the states fails to address the issue of intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver. department.
(B)An attempted waiver of the states intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates subparagraph (A) shall be deemed void as against public policy.
(e)Contracts subject to the approval of the department shall also have the departments approval for a modification or amendment thereto, with the following exceptions:
(1)An amendment to a contract that only extends the original time for completion of performance for a period of one year or less is exempt. If the original contract was subject to approval by the department, one fully executed copy including transmittal document, explaining the reason for the extension, shall be sent to the legal office of the department. A contract may only be amended once under this exemption.
(2)Contracts let or awarded on the basis of a law requiring competitive bidding may be modified or amended only if the contract so provides or if authorized by the law requiring competitive bidding.
(3)If an amendment to a contract has the effect of giving the contract as amended an increase in monetary amount, or an agreement by the state to indemnify or save harmless any person, the amendment shall be approved by the department.
SEC. 8.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 6253.11 to the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest to be protected and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect intellectual property developed by state entities from copyright infringement, it is necessary to provide a limited exemption for these records from the provision of the California Public Records Act.
(a)The department shall perform all of the following functions:
(1)Commencing January 1, 2015, and every three years thereafter, track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding.
(2)Develop a database that includes, but is not limited to, tracking intellectual property by category of protection, date of creation, owner of intellectual property, grantee, state agency or granting entity, sources of funding, and status of licensing, including invention utilization updates. Failure to include an item in the database does not create any presumption regarding ownership. Prior to January 1, 2018, the database shall include the summary of state-owned intellectual property found in the California State Auditors Report 2011-106 on intellectual property. After January 1, 2018, and every three years thereafter, the database shall be updated using information collected by the department pursuant to this section.
(3)Develop a sample maintenance plan of an inventory of intellectual property.
(4)Develop factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others. others, including, but not limited to, the states best interest, maintaining public access, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain.
(5)Develop an outreach campaign informing state agencies of their rights and abilities concerning intellectual property created by their employees.
(6)Develop sample invention assignment agreements that state agencies can consider if they believe it is necessary to secure the rights to potentially patentable items created by their employees on worktime using state resources.
(7)Develop sample language for licenses or terms-of-use agreements that state agencies can use to limit the use of their intellectual property by others to only appropriate purposes.
(8)Develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the states intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of the department and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void as against public policy.
(b)
(c)This section shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
SEC. 2.Section 13988.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:13988.3.(a)Notwithstanding A public entity may own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. A public entitys intellectual property right shall not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1). A disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1) shall not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 U.S.C. Sec. 101 et seq.).
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, state agencies and departments may, upon request, share records and information related to intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding with the department.
(b)
(c)Any employee or former employee of the department who has access to or knowledge of the records and information described in subdivision (a), (b), shall not divulge or make known to any person not employed by the department in any manner not expressly permitted by law any particulars of these records or information that is restricted by law from public disclosure, or represents a first publication of research results, or information pertaining to patent rights that would not otherwise be publicly available.
SEC. 3.Section 14615.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:14615.1.(a)Where the Legislature directs or authorizes the department to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties under this chapter, chapter and Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 14650), 14650) of this part, Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5, or Section 6611 of the Public Contract Code, Code or Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, the action by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340), Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11370), Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400), and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500)). This section shall apply to actions taken by the department with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
(b)To the extent permitted by the United States and California Constitutions, subdivision (a) also applies to actions taken by the department prior to January 1, 1999, with respect to competitive procurement in the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual.
SEC. 4.Section 10335 of the Public Contract Code is amended to read:10335.(a)This article shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, whether or not the services involve the furnishing or use of equipment, materials, or supplies or are performed by an independent contractor. Except as provided in Sections 10295.6 and 10351, and paragraphs (8) and (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 10340, all contracts subject to this article are of no effect unless and until approved by the department. Each contract shall be transmitted with all papers, estimates, and recommendations concerning it to the department and, if approved by the department, shall be effective from the date of approval. This article shall apply to any state agency that by general or specific statute is expressly or impliedly authorized to enter into the transactions referred to in this section. This article shall not apply to contracts for the construction, alteration, improvement, repair, or maintenance of real or personal property, contracts for services subject to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 4525) of Division 5 of Title 1 of the Government Code, to contracts that are listed as exceptions in Section 10295, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) in amount, contracts of less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) where only per diem or travel expenses, or a combination thereof, are to be paid, contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency.
(b)In exercising its authority under this article with respect to contracts for the services of legal counsel, other than the Attorney General, entered into by any state agency that is subject to Section 11042 or Section 11043 of the Government Code, the department, as a condition of approval of the contract, shall require the state agency to demonstrate that the consent of the Attorney General to the employment of the other counsel has been granted pursuant to Section 11040 of the Government Code. This consent shall not be construed in a manner that would authorize the Attorney General to establish a separate program for reviewing and approving contracts in the place of, or in addition to, the program administered by the department pursuant to this article.
(c)Until January 1, 2001, the department shall maintain a list of contracts approved pursuant to subdivision (b). This list shall be filed quarterly with the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review and the Assembly Committee on Budget. The list shall be limited to contracts with a consideration in excess of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) during the life of the contract and shall include sufficient information to identify the provider of legal services, the length of each contract, applicable hourly rates, and the need for the services. The department shall add a contract that meets these conditions to the list within 10 days after approval. A copy of the list shall be made available to any requester. The department may charge a fee to cover the cost of supplying the list as provided in Section 6253 of the Government Code.
(d)(1)In exercising its authority under this article, a state agency shall consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by the department pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 13988) of Part 4.5 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(2)For contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2017, both of the following shall apply:
(A)A state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that waives the states intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver.
(B)An attempted waiver of the states intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates subparagraph (A) shall be deemed void as against public policy.
(d)
(e)Contracts subject to the approval of the department shall also have the departments approval for a modification or amendment thereto, with the following exceptions:
(1)An amendment to a contract that only extends the original time for completion of performance for a period of one year or less is exempt. If the original contract was subject to approval by the department, one fully executed copy including transmittal document, explaining the reason for the extension, shall be sent to the legal office of the department. A contract may only be amended once under this exemption.
(2)Contracts let or awarded on the basis of a law requiring competitive bidding may be modified or amended only if the contract so provides or if authorized by the law requiring competitive bidding.
(3)If an amendment to a contract has the effect of giving the contract as amended an increase in monetary amount, or an agreement by the state to indemnify or save harmless any person, the amendment shall be approved by the department.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation related to the rights to state-owned intellectual property.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation related to the rights to state-owned intellectual property.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 3. Page 5175.) |
| Aug 29, 2016 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Monning. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Be placed on second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 28, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on G.O. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on G.O. |
| Jun 20, 2016 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jun 20, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 16, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 6, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 3.) |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 5012.) |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 12, 2016 | Ordered to third reading. |
| May 12, 2016 | From Consent Calendar. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 4, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (May 4). |
| Apr 19, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 16, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 14, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 26, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 27. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governmental Organization |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2016 | AB 2880 JUD. Assembly Third Reading By STONE | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 4, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Electronic Frontier Foundation | ** Against | May 31, 2016 |
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2880
:
SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORG. COMMITTEE: 10-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Hall, Berryhill, Block, Gaines, Glazer, Hill, Hueso, Lara, McGuire, Vidak
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Galgiani, Hernandez
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-3, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by the Department of General Services (DGS) on intellectual property. This bill also provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, a state agency must consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by DGS.
- Imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state.
- Requires DGS to develop factors for state agencies to consider in deciding whether to sell or license their intellectual property.
- Exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by DGS that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill:
- Requires all state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by DGS relating to intellectual property, as provided.
- Provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, a state agency shall consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS.
- Provides that the maintenance and development of processes, procedures, or policies in connection with DGS' duties relating to intellectual property, as provided, shall be exempt from California's Administrative Procedure Act, similar to other DGS contracting rules.
Background
Intellectual property. The term “intellectual property” describes products of the
mind, such as ideas, inventions, and creations. Unlike real property such as land, intellectual property is intangible. As a type of personal property, however, intellectual property is protected by law. There are four primary types of intellectual property: copyrights, trademarks, patents, and trade secrets. Taken as a whole, federal, state, and common law provide intellectual property owners with an extensive legal tool bag to protect the items they create. It is important to note that intellectual property laws enable an owner to pursue legal remedies against any person or entity that infringes on the owner’s rights; they do not always give the owner the right to manufacture or produce a product. Infringement includes making unauthorized versions of the intellectual property or using it against the owner’s wishes.
Purpose of AB 2880. According to the Assembly Judiciary Committee, this bill stems from a trademark dispute that arose last year between the National Park Service (the federal entity that manages federal parks) and Delaware North (the departing Yosemite concessioner) over the ownership of trademarks associated with attractions and facilities in Yosemite National Park. This trademark dispute put a spotlight on governmental intellectual property rights, and posed the following question for the state: does a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquire any intellectual property rights over products and services it creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires?
Some state agencies, including California State Parks, have taken steps to develop policies and procedures to protect the intellectual property rights of the state and the public. Unfortunately, most state agencies have not established such policies or procedures. In 2000, the State Auditor issued a report with recommendations to the Legislature to take steps to help state agencies manage and protect the State’s intellectual property. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez, Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012) which requires DGS to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. The guidance is developed by an advisory group of attorneys from various state agencies who have expertise in intellectual property. Nothing under the law requires a state agency to review or even consider the guidance developed by the advisory group. Yet, despite these efforts to protect the intellectual property rights of the state, not all of the recommendations suggested by the Auditor have been enacted. For example, the State Contract Manual (SCM), a document that provides guidance to state agencies on rules and procedures for state contracting, does not provide guidance on how a state agency should manage its intellectual property.
This bill attempts to correct these deficiencies as follows: (1) By enabling DGS to include the intellectual property guidelines that it has developed in its State Contracting Manual in order to assist state agencies manage contracts that involve intellectual property; (2) By requiring state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and, (3) By requiring all state contracts to address the issue of intellectual property rights unless DGS provides otherwise.
State Auditor’s Report. In November 2000, a report by the Bureau of State Audits on State-Owned Intellectual Property concluded:
“[M]any state agencies are not sufficiently knowledgeable about the intellectual property they own. Lacking adequate knowledge of their intellectual property ownership and rights, state agencies could fail to act against those who use the State’s intellectual property inappropriately. Inappropriate use includes unauthorized use of state trademarks and improperly profiting on products developed at state expense. Further . . . state-level direction for administering intellectual property is limited. The few state laws that address intellectual property do so in a piecemeal fashion . . . [and] state agencies have either no or incomplete written policies for managing their intellectual property.”
That report further noted that although more than 113,000 items of state-owned intellectual property were identified, the state likely owns more. Finally, the report contained several recommendations:
- The Legislature should clarify state law to specifically allow all state agencies to own and, if necessary, formally register intellectual property they create or otherwise acquire when it is deemed to be in the public’s best interest.
- The Legislature should designate a single state agency as the lead for developing overall policies and guidance related to state-owned intellectual property.
- Finally, the Legislature should consider whether the interest of the public is best served when the State uses standard contract language that essentially gives contractors a free license to use and sell intellectual property they develop for the State.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 744 (John Perez, Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012), among other things, authorized DGS to carry out various powers and duties relating to assisting a state agency in the management and development of intellectual property developed by state employees or with state funding.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/1/16)
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/1/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-3, 6/2/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Travis Allen, Harper, Maienschein
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hadley
8/3/16 19:11:09
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
Senator Isadore Hall, III
Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 6/28/2016
Author: | Committee on Judiciary | ||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by the Department of General Services (DGS) on intellectual property. This bill also provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, a state agency must consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that contracts by state agencies for services rendered to the state are, with certain exceptions, of no effect unless and until approved by DGS.
- Imposes various requirements with respect to contracts for services rendered to the state.
- Requires DGS to develop factors for state agencies to consider in deciding whether to sell or license their intellectual property.
- Exempts from the Administrative Procedure Act certain actions to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies by DGS that are required or authorized by the Legislature with respect to the general operations of the department or the awarding of state contracts.
This bill:
- Requires all state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by DGS relating to intellectual property, as provided.
- Provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, a state agency shall consider the intellectual property rights of both the state and the contracting party unless the state agency prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS.
- Provides that the maintenance and development of processes, procedures, or policies in connection with DGS' duties relating to intellectual property, as provided, shall be exempt from California's Administrative Procedure Act, similar to other DGS contracting rules.
Background
Intellectual property. The term “intellectual property” describes products of the
mind, such as ideas, inventions, and creations. Unlike real property such as land, intellectual property is intangible. As a type of personal property, however, intellectual property is protected by law. There are four primary types of intellectual property: copyrights, trademarks, patents, and trade secrets. Taken as a whole, federal, state, and common law provide intellectual property owners with an extensive legal tool bag to protect the items they create. It is important to note that intellectual property laws enable an owner to pursue legal remedies against any person or entity that infringes on the owner’s rights; they do not always give the owner the right to manufacture or produce a product. Infringement includes making unauthorized versions of the intellectual property or using it against the owner’s wishes.
Purpose of AB 2880. According to the Assembly Judiciary Committee office, this bill stems from a trademark dispute that arose last year between the National Park Service (the federal entity that manages federal parks) and Delaware North (the departing Yosemite concessioner) over the ownership of trademarks associated with attractions and facilities in Yosemite National Park. This trademark dispute put a spotlight on governmental intellectual property rights, and posed the following question for the state: does a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquire any intellectual property rights over products and services it creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires?
Some state agencies, including California State Parks, have taken steps to develop policies and procedures to protect the intellectual property rights of the state and the public. Unfortunately, most state agencies have not established such policies or procedures. In 20000, the State Auditor issued a report with recommendations to the Legislature to take steps to help state agencies manage and protect the State’s intellectual property. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez, Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012) which requires DGS to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. The guidance is developed by an advisory group of attorneys from various state agencies who have expertise in intellectual property. Nothing under the law requires a state agency to review or even consider the guidance developed by the advisory group. Yet, despite these efforts to protect the intellectual property rights of the state, not all of the recommendations suggested by the Auditor have been enacted. For example, the State Contract Manual (SCM), a document that provides guidance to state agencies on rules and procedures for state contracting, does not provide guidance on how a state agency should manage its intellectual property.
This bill attempts to correct these deficiencies as follows: (1) By enabling DGS to include the intellectual property guidelines that it has developed in its State Contracting Manual in order to assist state agencies manage contracts that involve intellectual property; (2) By requiring state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and, (3) By requiring all state contracts to address the issue of intellectual property rights unless DGS provides otherwise.
State Auditor’s Report. In November 2000, a report by the Bureau of State Audits on State-Owned Intellectual Property concluded:
“[M]any state agencies are not sufficiently knowledgeable about the intellectual property they own. Lacking adequate knowledge of their intellectual property ownership and rights, state agencies could fail to act against those who use the State’s intellectual property inappropriately. Inappropriate use includes unauthorized use of state trademarks and improperly profiting on products developed at state expense. Further . . . state-level direction for administering intellectual property is limited. The few state laws that address intellectual property do so in a piecemeal fashion . . . [and] state agencies have either no or incomplete written policies for managing their intellectual property.”
That report further noted that although more than 113,000 items of state-owned intellectual property were identified, the state likely owns more. Finally, the report contained several recommendations:
- The Legislature should clarify state law to specifically allow all state agencies to own and, if necessary, formally register intellectual property they create or otherwise acquire when it is deemed to be in the public’s best interest.
- The Legislature should designate a single state agency as the lead for developing overall policies and guidance related to state-owned intellectual property.
- Finally, the Legislature should consider whether the interest of the public is best served when the State uses standard contract language that essentially gives contractors a free license to use and sell intellectual property they develop for the State.
Comments. The most recent amendments (June 21) narrowed the scope of this bill significantly and removed the concerns that had been expressed by numerous entities and organizations. However, Assembly Judiciary Committee staff indicates that they cannot confirm that all entities have removed their opposition.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 2249 (Cooley, 2016) establishes the California Heritage Protection Act which would prohibit a concession contract from providing a contracting party with a trademark or service mark of the names associated with a state park. (Pending in Senate Judiciary Committee)
AB 744 (John Perez, Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012) among other things, authorized DGS to carry out various powers and duties relating to assisting a state agency in the management and development of intellectual property developed by state employees or with state funding.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT:
None received
OPPOSITION:
None received
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2880
Author:(Committee on Judiciary)
As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, Ting | > |
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, McCarty, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood | > |
SUMMARY: Strengthens the statutory framework on rules, processes, and procedures relating to state intellectual property and provides additional guidance to state agencies to manage and protect the state's intellectual property while still protecting public access under the Public Records Act. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Department of General Services (DGS), when developing factors on the state's consideration of its intellectual property, to also develop factors about making intellectual property available in the public domain, or granting the use of their intellectual property to others, including but not limited to, the state's best interest, maintaining public access, and preventing improper economic gain through the unauthorized use of state owned intellectual property.
- Requires DGS to develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the state's intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of DGS and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void.
- Provides that to the extent not inconsistent with the rights of the public to obtain, inspect, copy, publish and otherwise communicate information under the California Public Records Act, the California Constitution as provided, and under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, a state entity may own, license, and if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires.
- Provides that the maintenance and development of processes, procedures, or policies in connection with DGS' duties relating to intellectual property, as provided, shall be exempt from California's Administrative Procedure Act, similar to other DGS contracting rules.
- Requires all state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by DGS relating to intellectual property, as provided.
- Provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, a state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that fails to address the issue of intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the Department of General Services.
- Provides that when a state entity creates a work that is otherwise subject to copyright protection, the work shall be deemed to be released into the public domain unless the state entity reasonably determines any of the following:
- The work has commercial value and the release would jeopardize the integrity of the work.
- The release would infringe upon the property interests of a third party.
- The release would detrimentally affect the state's interests in its trademarks, service marks, patents, or trade secrets.
- Provides that if a state entity reasonably determines that a work shall not be released into the public domain as provided, the entity shall catalog those works and submit the information to the department for the purpose of tracking intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding as provided.
- States that nothing in this bill requires a state entity to own, license, or formally register intellectual property that it creates or otherwise acquires.
- Provides that provisions of the bill shall not apply to the use of expressive works created by nonstate employees or without state funding.
- Requires a state entity to do the following if the entity pursues an action for copyright infringement:
- Prior to sending a takedown notification, a state entity shall reasonably consider in good faith whether the allegedly infringing material constituted fair use.
- No state entity shall elect to receive statutory damages as provided under the federal Copyright Act of 1976 (17 United States Code (U.S.C.) Section 504(c)) except in cases of willful infringement where there is no evidence of fair use.
- Upon a court's finding that the party defending the infringement action engaged in fair use, the state shall waive statutory damages.
- Establishes that any work released into the public domain shall be deemed a public record.
- Prohibits a public agency from denying a public records request for a record that is otherwise public on grounds that the information requested is protected by federal Copyright Act. A request for such a record shall only be denied if one of the following applies:
- The public interest in disclosure is clearly outweighed by the facts of the particular case demonstrate that the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record as provided in the Public Records Act.
- The record in question is exempt under express provisions of the Public Records Act.
- Provides that a public agency that releases a public record that is subject to copyright protection as provided shall issue the requesting party a license to use the record in a manner that is consistent with the rights provide under the Public Records Act and that is considered acts of fair use under the federal Copyright Act. The license may restrict the holder from using the record for a commercial use only if such use would result in economic harm to the public agency or to the public's interest.
- Makes various findings concerning the management of intellectual property and the Legislature intends for the state's intellectual property to be managed in a way that encourages a release into the public domain whenever it is feasible and appropriate and does not interfere with the public's right to access records.
- States that the Legislature recognizes that state agencies and departments have different intellectual property needs, and finds that a statewide and uniform approach to manage the state's intellectual property should provide state agencies and departments reasonable levels of discretion that promote releasing information into the public domain, and protect the state from unauthorized economic gain, but still ensure the public's right of access to public records.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- DGS leads the state's Intellectual Property Work Group, which is developing policies, procedures, and processes to implement existing law regarding intellectual property. The incremental workload associated with implementing this bill will therefore be minor and absorbable.
- DGS's costs to review proposed agency contract provisions waiving intellectual property rights would be reimbursed by the contracting agency. These costs should not be significant for any single agency.
COMMENTS: In 2000 and 2011, the State Auditor issued recommendations to the Legislature to take steps to help state agencies manage and protect the State's intellectual property. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez), Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012, which requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. The guidance is developed by a working group consisting of attorneys from various state agencies who have expertise in intellectual property. Under current law, nothing requires a state agency to review, comply with, or even consider the guidance of the working group.
Some state agencies, including California State Parks, have taken steps to develop policies and procedures to protect the intellectual property rights of the state and the public; however, most state agencies have not done so. Indeed, the lack of a robust intellectual property framework has led to confusion among state agencies, loose and informal practices, and possibly confusion among state and federal courts. Indeed, recent court decisions have stated that public agencies need express legislative authority to hold intellectual property rights which is inconsistent with current practice.
Summary of the bill: In summary, this bill does all of the following: 1) clarifies existing law that state agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property to the extent not inconsistent with the rights of the public to obtain, inspect, copy, publish and otherwise communicate information under the California Public Records Act, the California Constitution as provided, and under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution; 2) provides policy guidance to DGS on factors state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell or license state-owned intellectual property, including making intellectual property available in the public domain, granting the use of its intellectual property; 3) provides that when a state entity creates a work that is otherwise subject to copyright protection, the work shall be deemed to be released into the public domain unless the state entity reasonably determines specific criteria as provided; 4) provides that if a state entity reasonably determines that a work shall not be released into the public domain as provided, the entity shall catalog the works and submit the information to DGS for the purpose of tracking intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funds; 5) enables DGS to include guidelines in its State Contracting Manual on how state agencies should manage its intellectual property; 6) requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and 7) prohibits a state agency from entering into a contract as provided that fails to address the issue of intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS.
This bill clarifies existing law to allow public entities to own and hold intellectual property, while maintaining the public's protection under the California Public Records Act. Several recent court cases have held that state agencies cannot own or hold intellectual property rights unless the Legislature provides the agency with that explicit authority ("in the absence of an affirmative grant of authority to obtain and hold copyrights, a California public entity may not do so" (City of Inglewood v. Teixeira (C.D.Cal. 2015), relying on County of Santa Clara v. Superior Court (2009) 170 Cal.App.4th 1301).
Although it has always been the intent of the Legislature to ensure that state agencies can own, hold, and acquire intellectual property, this bill clarifies existing law by explicitly providing that a California public entity may own, license, and if deemed appropriate, register intellectual property. In order to maintain the public's right to information, this bill also provides that the state's intellectual property authority only to the extent that it is not inconsistent with the California Public Records Act, the California Constitution, or the First Amendment of the United States Constitution.
To prevent public agencies from using copyright law to circumvent the spirit and purpose of the California Public Records Act, this bill prohibits a public agency from denying a public records request for a record that is otherwise public on grounds that the information requested is protected by federal Copyright Act; public agencies may only use existing exemptions under the Public Records Act.
This bill also recognizes that there might be instances when an unscrupulous party will use the Public Records Act to circumvent rights provided under federal copyright law. This bill provides that a public agency that releases a public record that the state seeks to protect under copyright law shall issue the requesting party a license to use the record in a manner that is consistent with the rights provide under the Public Records Act and that is considered acts of fair use under the federal Copyright Act; however, the license may restrict the holder from using the record for a commercial use only if such use would result in economic harm to the public agency or to the public's interest.
To further promote the state's policy of open government and to allow the public to continue to use information produced by California government without the fear violating copyright law, this bill requires a state entity—prior to sending a takedown notification—to reasonably consider in good faith whether the allegedly infringing material constituted fair use. Moreover, no state entity shall elect to receive statutory damages in a copyright infringement case except in cases of willful infringement. And even at the end of any potential litigation a court finds that the party defending the infringement action engaged in fair use, the state shall waive statutory damages.
This bill provides DGS with additional policy guidance and factors that state agencies should consider when they decide to sell or license state-owned intellectual property. In order to provide the Intellectual Property Advisory Group with additional policy guidance in crafting the plan, this bill requires state agencies to also consider the following factors: the state's best interest, public access to information, and the preventing improper economic gain through the unauthorized use of state owned intellectual property. Additionally, to ensure that the work done by the Intellectual Property Advisory Group is not done for naught, this bill requires a state agency to consider the guidelines developed by DGS when the state agency enters into a contract.
This bill makes it easier for DGS to adopt rules relating to intellectual property to be included in the State Contract Manual. According to the State Auditor, the State Contract Manual (SCM), a document that provides guidance to state agencies on rules and procedures for state contracting, does not provide any guidance on how a state agency should manage its intellectual property. This bill clarifies the statutory authority for DGS to adopt rules and procedures in its SCM to include guidance to state agencies about how to manage intellectual property.
This bill strengthens California's contracts in order to protect the State's intellectual property. To ensure that the State is acting properly to protect its rights, and to allow the State to have some flexibility and discretion when it is appropriate, this bill requires a state entity, when entering into a contract, to address the issue of intellectual property unless DGS has provided consent to the contracting state agency.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003277
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2880
Author:(Committee on Judiciary)
As Amended Ver:March 15, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, Ting | |
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, McCarty, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
SUMMARY: Strengthens the statutory framework on rules, processes, and procedures relating to state intellectual property and provides additional guidance to state agencies to manage and protect the state's intellectual property. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to include the factors of the state's best interest, maintaining public access, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain when developing factors for state agencies that decide to sell or license intellectual property.
- Requires DGS to develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the state's intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of DGS and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void as against public policy.
- Provides that a public entity may own, license, and if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise requires. Further provides that a public entity's intellectual property right shall not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). Further provides that a disclosure under the CPRA shall not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act.
- Provides that the maintenance and development of processes, procedures, or policies in connection with DGS' duties relating to intellectual property, as provided, shall be exempt from California's Administrative Procedure Act, similar to other DGS contracting rules.
- Requires all state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by DGS relating to intellectual property, as provided.
- Provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, all of the following shall apply:
- A state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that waives the state's intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver.
- An attempted waiver of the state's intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates 6) a) above, shall be deemed void as against public policy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Declares that the Legislature supports the use of efficient models to develop and streamline infrastructures, policies, and processes for the management of intellectual property developed under state funding in order to stimulate economic development in the state while, at the same time, minimize the costs of administering policies in this area. (Government Code Section 13988. All further statutory references are to the Government Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that the rights of state agencies and departments to track and manage intellectual property created with any state funds shall be interpreted as to promote the benefit of the public. Further states that it is the intent of the Legislature that DGS have access to information about intellectual property created by state employees and by state-funded research, consistent with state and federal laws and regulations governing access to this information. (Ibid.)
- Requires DGS to track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding. (Government Code Section 13988.2.)
- Requires DGS to develop a database that includes, but is not limited to, tracking intellectual property, as described. The database shall be updated every three years after its commencement in 2015. (Ibid.)
- Requires DGS to do all of the following:
- Develop factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others.
- Develop an outreach campaign informing state agencies of their rights and abilities concerning intellectual property created by their employees.
- Develop sample invention assignment agreements that state agencies can consider if they believe it is necessary to secure the rights to potentially patentable items created by their employees on worktime using state resources.
- Develop sample language for licenses or terms-of-use agreements that state agencies can use to limit the use of their intellectual property by others to only appropriate purposes. (Ibid.)
- Authorizes state agencies and departments to share records and information related to intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding with the department. (Government Code Section 13988.3.)
- Provides that where the Legislature directs or authorizes DGS to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties, as provided, the actions by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act, as described. Further provides that these provisions shall apply to actions taken by DGS with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual. (Government Code Section 14615.1.)
- Establishes specific rules that shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, as provided. (Public Contract Code Section 10335.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- DGS leads the state's Intellectual Property Work Group, which is developing policies, procedures, and processes to implement existing law regarding intellectual property. The incremental workload associated with implementing this bill will therefore be minor and absorbable.
- DGS's costs to review proposed agency contract provisions waiving intellectual property rights would be reimbursed by the contracting agency. These costs should not be significant for any single agency.
COMMENTS: Last year, a well-publicized trademark dispute arose between the National Park Service (the federal entity that manages federal parks) and Delaware North Company (the departing Yosemite concessioner) over attractions and facilities in Yosemite National Park. The trademark dispute between the National Park Service and Delaware North put a spotlight on governmental intellectual property rights, and posed the following question for the state: does a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquire any intellectual property rights over products and services a contractor creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires? In 2000 and 2011, the State Auditor issued recommendations to the Legislature to take steps to help state agencies manage and protect the State's intellectual property. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez), Chapter 463, Statutes of 2012, which requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. The guidance is developed by a working group consisting of attorneys from various state agencies who have expertise in intellectual property. Under current law, nothing requires a state agency to review, comply with, or even consider the guidance of the working group.
Some state agencies, including California State Parks, have taken steps to develop policies and procedures to protect the intellectual property rights of the state and the public; however, most state agencies have not done so. Indeed, the lack of a robust intellectual property framework has led to confusion among state agencies, loose and informal practices, and possibly confusion among state and federal courts. Several recent court decisions have held that state agencies need legislative authority to hold intellectual property rights. In light of the recent Yosemite trademark issue and the recent court decisions, this bill builds on the framework established by AB 744 in order to assist state agencies manage and protect the state's intellectual property rights, particularly in state contracts where state-owned intellectual property is at stake.
Summary of the bill: In summary, this bill does all of the following: 1) clarifies existing law that public agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property; 2) provides policy guidance to the DGS on factors state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell or license state-owned intellectual property; 3) enables DGS to include guidelines in its State Contracting Manual on how state agencies should manage its intellectual property; 4) requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and 5) prohibits a state contract that waives the state's intellectual property unless DGS has consented to the waiver.
This bill clarifies existing law to allow public entities to own and hold intellectual property, while maintaining the public’s protection under the California Public Records Act. Several recent court cases have held that state agencies cannot own or hold intellectual property rights unless the Legislature provides the agency with that explicit authority ("in the absence of an affirmative grant of authority to obtain and hold copyrights, a California public entity may not do so" (City of Inglewood v. Teixeira (C.D.Cal. 2015), relying on County of Santa Clara v. Superior Court (2009) 170 Cal.App.4th 1301)).
Although it has always been the intent of the Legislature to ensure that California agencies can own, hold, and acquire intellectual property, this bill clarifies existing law by explicitly providing that a California public entity may own, license, and if deemed appropriate, register intellectual property. In order to maintain the public's right to information and to allow for use, this bill also provides that the state's intellectual property rights do not preclude a public entity from disclosing information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act – consistent with the State Auditor’s recommendation.
This bill provides DGS with additional policy guidance and factors that state agencies should consider when they decide to sell or license state-owned intellectual property. In order to provide the Intellectual Property Working Group with additional policy guidance in crafting the plan, this bill requires state agencies to also consider the following factors: the state's best interest, public access to information, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain. Additionally, to ensure that the work done by the Intellectual Property Working Group is not done for naught, this bill requires a state agency to consider the guidelines developed by DGS when the state agency enters into a contract.
This bill makes it easier for DGS to adopt rules relating to intellectual property to be included in the State Contract Manual. According to the State Auditor, the State Contract Manual (SCM), a document that provides guidance to state agencies on rules and procedures for state contracting, does not provide any guidance on how a state agency should manage its intellectual property. This bill clarifies the statutory authority for DGS to adopt rules and procedures in its SCM to include guidance to state agencies about how to manage intellectual property.
This bill strengthens California's contracts in order to protect the State's intellectual property. To ensure that the State is acting properly to protect its rights, and to allow the State to have some flexibility and discretion when it is appropriate, this bill prohibits any contract that waives the state's intellectual property unless DGS has provided consent to the contracting state agency. To ensure that parties that contract with the state have notice of these waiver provisions, this bill also requires DGS to develop sample language advising a party what happens if a state agency waives its intellectual property rights.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002969
Date of Hearing: May 4, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2880
Author:(Committee on Judiciary) – As Amended Ver:March 15, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill enhances the state's existing rules, processes, and procedures related to state-funded intellectual property and provides additional guidance to state agencies to manage and protect the state’s intellectual property. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Department of General Services (DGS), when developing factors for state agencies that decide to sell or license intellectual property, to include considerations of the state’s best interest, maintaining public access, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain.
- Provides that state contracts entered into after January 1, 2017:
- Shall not waive the state’s intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of DGS to the waiver, and
- An attempted waiver of the state’s intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates (2)(a) shall be deemed void as against public policy.
- Provides that a public entity may own, license, and if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise requires, and provides that a public entity’s intellectual property right shall not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act (CPRA).
FISCAL EFFECT:
- DGS leads the state’s Intellectual Property Work Group, which is developing policies, procedures, and processes to implement existing law regarding intellectual property. The incremental workload associated with implementing this bill will therefore be minor and absorbable.
- DGS's costs to review proposed agency contract provisions waiving intellectual property rights would be reimbursed by the contracting agency. These costs should not be significant for any single agency.
COMMENTS:
Background and Purpose. The recent, well-publicized Yosemite National Park trademark dispute not only put a spotlight on the federal government’s intellectual property rights, but also raised questions about the State of California’s intellectual property rights, as well; specifically as to whether a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquires any intellectual property rights over products and services a contractor creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires.
This bill is the result of the Assembly Committee on Judiciary's review of the state's existing statutory framework regarding management of intellectual property, and the committee's conclusion that improvements were warranted.
This bill does the following: (1) clarifies existing law that public agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property, and provides that such intellectual property is still accessible under the California Public Records Act; (2) provides policy guidance to DGS on factors state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell or license state-owned intellectual property; (3) enables DGS to include guidelines in its State Contracting Manual on how state agencies should manage its intellectual property; (4) requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and (5) prohibits a state contract that waives the state’s intellectual property unless DGS has consented to the waiver.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2880
Author:(Committee on Judiciary) – As Amended Ver:March 15, 2016
SUBJECT: STATE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO STRENGTHEN THE STATE’S STATUTORY FRAMEWORK ON STATE-OWNED INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND TO ENSURE THAT THE RIGHTS OF THE PUBLIC ARE PROTECTED, SHOULD STATE AGENCIES BE PROVIDED with ADDITIONAL GUIDANCE IN THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE STATE’S INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, CONSISTENT WITH RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED BY THE STATE AUDITOR?
SYNOPSIS
The well-publicized Yosemite National Park trademark dispute not only put a spotlight on the federal government’s intellectual property rights, but also raised questions about the State of California’s intellectual property rights, as well. Specifically, it prompted the Committee to pose the following question: does a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquire any intellectual property rights over products and services a contractor creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires?
During this Committee’s investigation, it learned that California’s statutory framework relating to the state’s management of its intellectual property could be improved. In 2010, the State Auditor issued a report that provided recommendations to the Legislature on how it could improve its administration of copyrights, trademarks, patents, and trade secrets. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez, Chap. 463, Stats. 2012) which requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. This bill builds on the framework established by AB 744 by implementing a number of the State Auditor’s recommendations, and improving state contracts where state-owned intellectual property is at stake.
In summary, this bill does all of the following: (1) clarifies existing law that public agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property, and provides that such intellectual property is still accessible under the California Public Records Act; (2) provides policy guidance to DGS on factors state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell or license state-owned intellectual property; (3) enables DGS to include guidelines in its State Contracting Manual on how state agencies should manage its intellectual property; (4) requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and (5) prohibits a state contract that waives the state’s intellectual property unless DGS has consented to the waiver. This bill is sponsored by the Committee.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), who opposes the bill unless it is amended, believes that the bill’s provision which clarifies that public agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property would allow state and local government the power to suppress the dissemination of government-funded works for nearly a century after creation. However, given that this bill explicitly provides that a public entity’s ability to have intellectual property does not prevent that entity from disclosing the information under the California Public Records Act, EFF’s argument appears to be unpersuasive.
SUMMARY: Strengthens the statutory framework on rules, processes, and procedures relating to state intellectual property and provides additional guidance to state agencies to manage and protect the state’s intellectual property. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to include the factors of the state’s best interest, maintaining public access, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain when developing factors for state agencies that decide to sell or license intellectual property.
- Requires DGS to develop sample language for an advisory provision stating that a waiver of the state’s intellectual property rights is subject to the approval of DGS and that the lack of that approval renders an attempted waiver void as against public policy.
- Provides that a public entity may own, license, and if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise requires. Further provides that a public entity’s intellectual property right shall not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). Further provides that a disclosure under the CPRA shall not be construed as waiving any rights afforded under the federal Copyright Act.
- Provides that the maintenance and development of processes, procedures, or policies in connection with DGS’ duties relating to intellectual property, as provided, shall be exempt from California’s Administrative Procedure Act, similar to other DGS contracting rules.
- Requires all state agencies to consider the processes, procedures, or policies developed by DGS relating to intellectual property, as provided.
- Provides that for contracts entered into after January 1, 2017, all of the following shall apply:
- A state agency shall not enter into a contract under this article that waives the state’s intellectual property rights unless the state agency, prior to execution of the contract, obtains the consent of the department to the waiver.
- An attempted waiver of the state’s intellectual property rights by a state agency that violates #6a) shall be deemed void as against public policy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Declares that the Legislature supports the use of efficient models to develop and streamline infrastructures, policies, and processes for the management of intellectual property developed under state funding in order to stimulate economic development in the state while, at the same time, minimize the costs of administering policies in this area. (Government Code Section 13988. All further statutory references are to the Government Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that the rights of state agencies and departments to track and manage intellectual property created with any state funds shall be interpreted as to promote the benefit of the public. Further states that it is the intent of the Legislature that DGS have access to information about intellectual property created by state employees and by state-funded research, consistent with state and federal laws and regulations governing access to this information. (Ibid.)
- Requires DGS to track intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding. (Section 13988.2.)
- Requires DGS to develop a database that includes, but is not limited to, tracking intellectual property, as described. The database shall be updated every three years after its commencement in 2015. (Ibid.)
- Requires DGS to do all of the following:
- Develop factors that state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell their intellectual property or license it to others.
- Develop an outreach campaign informing state agencies of their rights and abilities concerning intellectual property created by their employees.
- Develop sample invention assignment agreements that state agencies can consider if they believe it is necessary to secure the rights to potentially patentable items created by their employees on worktime using state resources.
- Develop sample language for licenses or terms-of-use agreements that state agencies can use to limit the use of their intellectual property by others to only appropriate purposes. (Ibid.)
- Authorizes state agencies and departments to share records and information related to intellectual property generated by state employees or with state funding with the department. (Section 13988.3.)
- Provides that where the Legislature directs or authorizes DGS to maintain, develop, or prescribe processes, procedures, or policies in connection with the administration of its duties, as provided, the actions by the department shall be exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act, as described. Further provides that these provisions shall apply to actions taken by DGS with respect to the State Administrative Manual and the State Contracting Manual. (Section 14615.1.)
- Establishes specific rules that shall apply to all contracts, including amendments, entered into by any state agency for services to be rendered to the state, as provided. (Public Contract Code Section 10335.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Last year, a well-publicized trademark dispute arose between the National Park Service (the federal entity that manages federal parks) and Delaware North Company (the departing Yosemite concessioner) over attractions and facilities in Yosemite National Park.
Background on the Yosemite legal dispute. For the last 23 years, the Delaware North Company operated as the concessionaire in Yosemite National Park under a contract with the National Park Service. In 2015, the National Park Service rebid the contract and awarded a new 15-year concession contract to Aramark, who was the successful bidder. After the National Park Service awarded the new contract, Delaware North Company sued the National Park Service for breach of contract and asserted compensation for various trademarks associated with Yosemite National Park. It is still unclear whether Delaware North Company actually has legitimate property interests in the trademarks associated with Yosemite Park.
Delaware North’s federal complaint suggests it received its rights from the previous concessionaire, The Curry Company. In a federal complaint lodged with the United States Court of Federal Claims, Delaware North Company alleges that it acquired the trademarks and intellectual property rights from the prior concessionaire. (Complaint, DNC Parks & Resorts at Yosemite Inc., v. United States, No. 15-1034C (Ct.Cl. September 17, 2015) [herein, Complaint, supra].) Delaware North Company contends that prior to 1993, the Curry Company provided visitor services at Yosemite for more than 100 years. (Ibid.) The Curry Company built significant improvements in Yosemite with its own capital, including The Ahwahnee, Yosemite Lodge, and Curry Village. (Ibid.) The Curry Company developed and used registered and unregistered trademarks and servicemarks in its operations, including the Half-Dome logo design, “The Ahwahnee” hotel name and logo design, and “Go Climb A Rock.” (Ibid.) The Curry Company’s final concession contract included terms which provided that if there was a successor concessionaire, the Curry Company would be required to sell its possessory interest in its improvements, and all other property used or held for use in connect with its Yosemite operations. (Ibid.) Additionally, any successor concessionaire would be required to purchase the Curry Company’s possessory interests and other property for fair value. (Ibid.) And of course, that successor concessionaire was the Delaware North Company.
The United States’ Answer to the federal complaint does not dispute several of Delaware North’s allegations. In fact, in the Answer filed by the United States, the United States admits that the Curry Company registered trademarks, servicemarks, and logos in connection with its operation including the Half-Dome logo and “The Ahwahnee” hotel name. (Answer, DNC Parks & Resorts at Yosemite Inc., v. United States, No. 15-1034C (Ct.Cl. September 17, 2015) [herein, Answer, supra].) The United States also admits that the Curry Company was required to sell its possessory and property interests, and that the Delaware North Company was required to purchase those possessory and property interests. (Ibid.) Although the litigation is still pending, if the Delaware North Company’s allegations are true, the legal dispute would seem to be more about the valuation of the trademark rights, and not on the ownership. In other words, as disagreeable as it is, the Delaware North Company might have actual and legitimate property interests in certain trademarks associated with Yosemite National Park.
To better understand the dispute, this Committee spoke with state agencies to determine the health of the state’s intellectual property. The trademark dispute between the National Park Service and Delaware North put a spotlight on governmental intellectual property rights, and posed the following question for the state: does a third-party contractor who enters into a contract with the state acquire any intellectual property rights over products and services a contractor creates and provides to the public that is funded with public dollars, even after the contract expires? In 2000 and 2011, the State Auditor issued recommendations to the Legislature to take steps to help state agencies manage and protect the State’s intellectual property. (State Auditor report 2000-110, State-Owned Intellectual Property: Opportunities Exist for the State to Improve Administration of Its Copyrights, Trademarks, Patents, and Trade Secrets.) In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 744 (Perez, Chap. 463, Stats. 2012), which requires the Department of General Services (DGS) to develop guidance to assist state agencies in managing intellectual property. The guidance is developed by a working group consisting of attorneys from various state agencies who have expertise in intellectual property. Under current law, nothing requires a state agency to review, comply with, or even consider the guidance of the working group.
This Committee has learned that some state agencies, including California State Parks, have taken steps to develop policies and procedures to protect the intellectual property rights of the state and the public; however, most state agencies have not done so. Indeed, the lack of a robust intellectual property framework has led to confusion among state agencies, loose and informal practices, and possibly confusion among state and federal courts. Several recent court decisions have held that state agencies need legislative authority to hold intellectual property rights. In light of the recent Yosemite trademark issue and the recent court decisions, this bill builds on the framework established by AB 744 in order to assist state agencies manage and protect the state’s intellectual property rights, particularly in state contracts where state-owned intellectual property is at stake.
Summary of the bill: In summary, this bill does all of the following: (1) clarifies existing law that public agencies may own, license, and register intellectual property; (2) provides policy guidance to the Department of General Services (DGS) on factors state agencies should consider when deciding whether to sell or license state-owned intellectual property; (3) enables DGS to include guidelines in its State Contracting Manual on how state agencies should manage its intellectual property; (4) requires state agencies, when entering into a contract, to consider the guidance, policies, and procedures developed by DGS on intellectual property; and (5) prohibits a state contract that waives the state’s intellectual property unless DGS has consented to the waiver.
This bill clarifies existing law to allow public entities to own and hold intellectual property, while maintaining the public’s protection under the California Public Records Act. Several recent court cases have held that state agencies cannot own or hold intellectual property rights unless the Legislature provides the agency with that explicit authority (“in the absence of an affirmative grant of authority to obtain and hold copyrights, a California public entity may not do so” (City of Inglewood v. Teixeira (C.D.Cal. 2015), relying on County of Santa Clara v. Superior Court (2009) 170 Cal.App.4th 1301)).
Although it has always been the intent of the Legislature to ensure that California agencies can own, hold, and acquire intellectual property, this bill clarifies existing law by explicitly providing that a California public entity may own, license, and if deemed appropriate, register intellectual property. In order to maintain the public’s right to information and to allow for derivative use, this bill also provides that the state’s intellectual property rights does not preclude a public entity from disclosing information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act – consistent with the State Auditor’s recommendation.
In her report, the State Auditor acknowledged the concern that allowing state ownership of intellectual property might restrict the dissemination of information; however, this concern is addressed by clarifying that information would still be subject to the California Public Records Act—which is exactly what this bill aims to do. In the 2000-110 Auditor Report, the Auditor write:
One concern arising from state ownership of intellectual property is that ownership conflicts with the principle of open government—as embodied in the California Public Records Act—by restricting the dissemination of information. The argument is that state agencies could use intellectual property laws to deny access to information they create that would otherwise be accessible. In at least one state, this threat exists because materials to which access is limited by copyright or patents can be legally withheld from the public.
However, since California does not have similar exclusions, this threat seems remote. Even so, the State can answer this concern by clarifying existing law to declare its intent that protection under intellectual property laws does not preclude state agencies from disclosing otherwise accessible information. Such a clarification, while not requiring state agencies to disclose material kept confidential under trade secret laws, would enable state agencies to provide access to material protected by other intellectual property laws.
(State Auditor report 2000-110, State-Owned Intellectual Property: Opportunities Exist for the State to Improve Administration of Its Copyrights, Trademarks, Patents, and Trade Secrets. [Emphasis added].)
This bill provides DGS with additional policy guidance and factors that state agencies should consider when they decide to sell or license state-owned intellectual property. Under current law, DGS is required to develop factors to assist state agencies that decide to sell or license state-owned intellectual property. This Committee has learned the DGS and the Intellectual Property Working Group have been working diligently in crafting an Intellectual Property Model Management Plan. In order to provide the Intellectual Property Working Group with additional policy guidance in crafting the plan, this bill requires state agencies to also consider the following factors: the state’s best interest, public access to information, and the discouragement of unauthorized economic gain. Additionally, to ensure that the work done by the Intellectual Property Working Group is not done for naught, this bill requires a state agency to consider the guidelines developed by DGS when the state agency enters into a contract.
This bill makes it easier for DGS to adopt rules relating to intellectual property to be included in the State Contract Manual. According to the State Auditor, the State Contract Manual (SCM), a document that provides guidance to state agencies on rules and procedures for state contracting, does not provide any guidance on how a state agency should manage its intellectual property. This bill clarifies the statutory authority for DGS to adopt rules and procedures in its SCM to include guidance to state agencies about how to manage intellectual property.
This bill strengthens California’s contracts in order to protect the State’s intellectual property. In light of the recent Yosemite trademark issue, this Committee is particularly concerned about the waiver of the State’s intellectual property rights. Of course, there are instances when it might be appropriate for a contractor to have certain property rights over works that a contractor creates for the state. For example, when the State commissions an artist to create a mural, the State may decide that it is appropriate for the artist to maintain certain rights over that work (e.g. right to reproduce, distribute, or sublicense).
To ensure that the State is acting properly to protect its rights, and to allow the State to have some flexibility and discretion when it is appropriate, this bill prohibits any contract that waives the state’s intellectual property unless DGS has provided consent to the contracting state agency. To ensure that parties that contract with the state have notice of these waiver provisions, this bill also requires DGS to develop sample language advising a party what happens if a state agency waives its intellectual property rights.
This bill implements several State Auditor recommendations relating to the state’s intellectual property. As previously stated, the State Auditor issued a report in 2000 that made recommendations to the Legislature about adopting policies to improve the state’s administration of its intellectual property. (State Auditor report 2000-110, supra.) While many of the Auditor’s recommendations were implemented by AB 744, this bill implements several more of the recommendations. Although the State Auditor cannot officially support or oppose legislation, at the Committee’s request, the State Auditor provided a letter to the Committee, indicating that this bill would implement several of its recommendations made in her 2000-110 report. In the letter, the State Auditor writes:
AB 2880 would, if enacted, address four key recommendations made in our audit report on intellectual property:
Our office previously recommended that the Legislature designate a lead agency to oversee intellectual property in California and require that lead agency to develop factors that should be taken into consideration when deciding how and when to protect the State’s interests in intellectual property. Prior legislation designated the Department of General Services as that lead agency and directed it to develop those factors. AB 2880 specifies what those factors should include, and is consistent with our recommendation. (AB 2880, Sec. 1).
Our office previously recommended that the Legislature clarify state law to specifically allow a public entity to own, license, and if appropriate, register intellectual property it creates or acquires. Our office also recommended that state law clarify that a public entity’s intellectual property rights would not preclude the public entity from disclosing any information otherwise accessible under the California Public Records Act. AB 2880 would implement both of those recommendations. (AB 2880, Sec. 2)
Our office previously recommended that the Legislature should consider whether the public is best served when the State uses standard contract language that essentially gives vendors the right to use and sell the intellectual property they develop under state-funded contracts. AB 2880 would address this recommendation by prohibiting a contract entered into on or after January 1, 2017 from waiving the State’s intellectual property rights unless the Department of General Services consents to that waiver. (AB 2880, Sec. 4).
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), in opposition unless amended, believes that this bill would grant state and local government the power to suppress the dissemination of government-funded works, even with the Public Record Act exemption provided in the bill. The EFF writes:
The bill represents a significant shift away from California’s role as one of the strongest state contributors to the public domain.
The purpose of copyright law is to incentivize creativity by granting a monopoly over a work for a limited time. However, such incentives are unnecessary when the resources are provided from the taxpayer. As a result, Congress has expressly excluded all work done by federal government employees from the scope of copyright, so that taxpayers can immediately benefit from new contributions to the public domain. AB 2880 would chart a different course by granting state and local governments the power to assert copyrights over taxpayer-funded work. This presents a serious issue, as it would grant state and local government the power to suppress the dissemination of government-funded works for nearly a century after creation, despite the current Public Records Act exemptions in the bill.
The legislative history on state copyright law indicates that the legislature never intended for all divisions of government to have the power to assert copyright. In fact, the legislature’s approach has favored enriching the public domain. For example, state law encourages state-funded research to be put into the public domain where appropriate. Publications involving consumer information and county created geographic information system basemaps are automatically put into the public domain under state law. In only five specific and limited circumstances has the state legislature decided to grant copyright authority to state employees. Those instances are for computer software, community colleges, county boards of education, works created by the Department of Toxic Substances Control, and works created under contract with the California Health and Human Services Agency.
While EFF’s general concern about the government holding onto information appears to be valid, to a certain extent, this bill already prevents this concern. Under the bill, a public entity’s ability to have intellectual property does not preclude that entity from making information available under California Public Records Act. As previously mentioned, this explicit California Public Records Act protection under the bill was recommended by the State Auditor.
Additionally, nothing in this bill prevents the state from releasing information into the public domain. Currently, this bill merely provides that a public entity may own, license, and, if it deems it appropriate, formally register intellectual property it creates or otherwise acquires. The example cited in EFF’s opposition about how “county created geographic information system basemaps are automatically put into the public domain under state law” is a helpful illustration of this point. EFF argues that this information is in the public domain and the public has a right to use that information for commercial purposes (i.e. to create maps for sale). However, if counties produced their own maps, on the other hand, and determine that those maps should be copyrighted, this bill merely allows the county to copyright those maps and provide the public with an unrestricted license to use those maps.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
Electronic Frontier Foundation (oppose unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):