AB 1869: Theft: firearms.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-02-10
(1)The existing Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, enacted as an initiative statute by Proposition 47, as approved by the electors at the November 4, 2014, statewide general election, makes the theft of property that does not exceed $950 in value petty theft, and makes that crime punishable as a misdemeanor, with certain exceptions.
The California Constitution authorizes the Legislature to amend an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors.
This bill would amend that initiative statute by making the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases and punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or 2 or 3 years.
(2)Under existing law, a person who buys or receives property that has been stolen, knowing the property to be stolen, or who conceals, sells, withholds, or aids in concealing, selling, or withholding property from the owner, knowing the property to be stolen, is guilty of a misdemeanor or a felony, except that if the value of the property does not exceed $950. Proposition 47 makes the offense punishable as a misdemeanor if the defendant has not previously been convicted of one or more specified serious or violent felonies or of an offense requiring registration as a sex offender.
This bill would amend that initiative statute by making the buying or receiving of a stolen firearm, with knowledge that the property was stolen, or the concealing, selling, withholding, or aiding in concealing, selling, or withholding of a firearm, with knowledge that the property was stolen, a misdemeanor or a felony.
(3)This bill would call a special election to be consolidated with the November 8, 2016, statewide general election. This bill would require the Secretary of State to submit the provisions of the bill that amend the initiative statute to the electors for their approval at the November 8, 2016, consolidated election.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an act calling an election.
(a)In submitting this act to the electors, the Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The theft of firearms and receipt of stolen firearms pose dangers to public safety that are different in kind from other types of theft or the receipt of other types of stolen property.
(2)Many handguns have a value of less than $950. The threat to public safety in regard to stolen firearms goes above and beyond the monetary value of the firearm.
(3)Given the significant and particular threat to public safety in regard to stolen firearms, it is appropriate to restore the penalties that existed prior to the passage of the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act of 2014 in regard to stolen firearms.
(b)It is not the intent of the Legislature in submitting this act to the electors to undermine the voters decision to decrease penalties for low-level theft and receiving stolen property, only to give the voters the opportunity to decide whether firearm thefts and the receipt of stolen firearms should be subject to penalties that existed prior to the passage of the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act.
SEC. 2.Section 490.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:490.2.(a)Notwithstanding Section 487 or any other provision of law defining grand theft, except as provided in subdivision (c), obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real property, or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered is petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor, except that such the person may instead be punished pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 if that person has one or more prior convictions for an offense specified in clause (iv) of subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 667 or for an offense requiring registration pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290.
(b)This section shall does not be applicable apply to any a theft that may be charged as an infraction pursuant to any other provision of law.
(c)If the property taken is a firearm, the theft is grand theft in all cases, as specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 487, and is punishable pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 489.
SEC. 3.Section 496 of the Penal Code is amended to read:496.(a)(1) Every person who buys or receives any property that has been stolen or that has been obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, or who conceals, sells, withholds, or aids in concealing, selling, or withholding any property from the owner, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. However, except as provided in subdivision (e), if the value of the property does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950), the offense shall be is a misdemeanor, punishable only by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, if such the person has no prior convictions for an offense specified in clause (iv) of subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 667 or for an offense requiring registration pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290.
A
(2)A principal in the actual theft of the property may be convicted pursuant to this section. However, no a person may not be convicted both pursuant to this section and of the theft of the same property.
(b)(1) Every swap meet vendor, as defined in Section 21661 of the Business and Professions Code, and every person whose principal business is dealing in, or collecting, merchandise or personal property, and every agent, employee, or representative of that person, who buys or receives any property of a value in excess of nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) that has been stolen or obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, under circumstances that should cause the person, agent, employee, or representative to make reasonable inquiry to ascertain that the person from whom the property was bought or received had the legal right to sell or deliver it, without making a reasonable inquiry, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170.
Every
(2)Every swap meet vendor, as defined in Section 21661 of the Business and Professions Code, and every person whose principal business is dealing in, or collecting, merchandise or personal property, and every agent, employee, or representative of that person, who buys or receives any property of a value of nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) or less that has been stolen or obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, under circumstances that should cause the person, agent, employee, or representative to make reasonable inquiry to ascertain that the person from whom the property was bought or received had the legal right to sell or deliver it, without making a reasonable inquiry, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
(c)Any A person who has been injured by a violation of subdivision (a) or (b) may bring an action for three times the amount of actual damages, if any, sustained by the plaintiff, costs of suit, and reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 664, any an attempt to commit any act prohibited by this section, except an offense specified in the accusatory pleading as a misdemeanor, is punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a person who buys or receives a firearm that has been stolen or that has been obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, or who conceals, sells, withholds, or aids in concealing, selling, or withholding a firearm from the owner, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170.
SEC. 4.(a)Sections 2 and 3 of this act amend the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, Proposition 47, an initiative statute, and shall become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters at a statewide election.
(b)A special election is hereby called, to be held throughout the state on November 8, 2016, for approval by the voters of Sections 2 and 3 of this act. The special election shall be consolidated with the statewide general election to be held on that date. The consolidated election shall be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used.
(c)Notwithstanding the requirements of Sections 9040, 9043, 9044, 9061, 9082, and 9094 of the Elections Code, or any other law, the Secretary of State shall submit Sections 2 and 3 of this act to the voters for their approval at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election.
SEC. 5.This act calls an election within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 5025.) |
| Aug 11, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jun 27, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | In committee: Reconsideration of a favorable vote granted. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0.) |
| Feb 10, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| Apr 20, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 13, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 13). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E. & R. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 15). Re-referred to Com. on E. & R. |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and E. & R. |
| Feb 11, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 12. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 27, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | [06-21-2016] set for [First] hearing: Reconsideration of favorable vote granted | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2016 | AB 1869 MELENDEZ Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 13, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting |
Passed |
|
| Mar 15, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Elections and Redistricting] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 27 California Chapters of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| American Civil Liberties Union Foundation Of Southern California | * Against | Jun 21, 2016 |
| Association For Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| Burbank, City of | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California Association Of Code Enforcement Officers | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | * Against | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California College And University Police Chiefs Association | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| California District Attorneys Association | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California Peace Officers Association | * Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| California Police Chiefs Association | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California Rifle And Pistol Association, Inc. | * Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| California Right to Carry | ** Against | Mar 15, 2016 |
| California Sheriffs Association | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| California Sportsman's Lobby, Inc. | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| California Statewide Law Enforcement Association | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| City of Lodi | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Criminal Justice Legal Foundation | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Fraternal Order of Police | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Gun Owners of California | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| League Of California Cities | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Against | Mar 15, 2016 |
| Los Angeles County Professional Officers Association | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Los Angeles Police Protective League | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Marietta | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| Mayor of the City of Murrieta | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| National Rifle Association Institute For Legislative Action | * Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| National Shooting Sports Foundation, Inc. | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Outdoor Sportsmen'S Coalition Of California | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Page L | ** Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| PUB. S. | ** Against | Mar 15, 2016 |
| Riverside County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Sacramento County Sheriff Scott Jones | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Sacramento County Sheriff's Department | ** Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| Safari Club International | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| Safari Club International Foundation | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| San Bernadino Sheriffs | * Support | Jun 21, 2016 |
| San Bernardino County Sheriff-Coroner | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
| San Diego County District Attorney | ** Support | Mar 15, 2016 |
| San Diego County Office of the District Attorney | ** Support | May 31, 2016 |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 1869 (Melendez) - Theft: firearms
Version: February 10, 2016 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 6 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 27, 2016 | Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 1869 would call for a special election to amend Proposition 47 and make the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases, punishable by a state prison term, as specified. Additionally, this bill provides that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for up to one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail or state prison for 16 months, two years, or three years, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Ballot costs: One-time costs in the range of $414,000 to $552,000 (General Fund) to the Secretary of State (SOS) for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in the next statewide election.
- State prisons: To the extent the voters approve the amendments to the Proposition, significant increase in state incarceration costs potentially in the millions of dollars (General Fund) annually for (1) felony convictions for theft of a firearm, (2) felony convictions for receipt of a stolen firearm for persons with a current or prior serious or violent felony conviction, and (3) potential future violations of the lifetime firearms ban imposed for these felony convictions that otherwise may have been charged as misdemeanors. Staff notes commitments to state prison for both (1) theft of a firearm and (2) receipt of stolen property as a principal offense decreased by about 70 percent after passage of Proposition 47. To the extent some defendants continue to be committed to prison for other felony convictions, while not resulting in new commitments, this bill could result in longer prison sentences for these cases.
- County jails: To the extent the voters approve the amendments to the Proposition, potentially major increase in non-reimbursable local costs (Local Funds) for felony jail sentences for receipt of stolen property violations that previously would have been subject to misdemeanor penalties, offset in minor part due to fewer jail terms for petty theft of a firearm that would be subject to a state prison term.
- Reduction in Proposition 47 savings: Potential reduction in future funds allocated to the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Fund (SNSF) to the extent raising the criminal penalties for the specified firearm offenses results in a reduction in future calculated savings under Proposition 47 by the Department of Finance.
- Department of Justice (DOJ): Potentially significant increase in DOJ administration and enforcement costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars (Special Fund*) due to increases to the Armed Prohibited Persons System (APPS) list resulting from the expanded application of the lifetime firearms prohibition.
*Dealers Record of Sale Special Account (DROS) – Staff notes the DROS is structurally imbalanced, with less than a $1 million reserve balance projected by year-end FY 2016-17. Current revenues to the DROS Account may be insufficient to cover the costs of this bill in conjunction with the numerous other legislative measures requiring funding from the DROS Account, should they be enacted. As a result, an appropriation from an alternate fund source, potentially the General Fund, may be required to support the costs of this measure.
Background:
Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by the voters in November 2014. Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes and directed that the resulting state savings be directed to mental health and substance abuse treatment, truancy and dropout prevention, and victims’ services. The initiative reduced the penalties for theft, shoplifting, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks, and check forgery valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. The measure limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have prior convictions for serious or violent felonies and who are not required to registered sex offenders.
Grand Theft of a Firearm
Proposition 47 added Penal Code § 490.2, which by virtue of specifically defining petty theft, narrowed the pre-existing provisions that constituted grand theft, as follows: "Notwithstanding Section 487 or any other provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor ….." (PC § 490.2 (a).) In other words, Proposition 47 put in a blanket $950 threshold for conduct to be classified as grand theft. Previously, there were a number of carve-outs which constituted grand theft based on the conduct involved, the manner in which the crime was committed, or the type of property stolen, irrespective of its value. Because the new statute specifically includes the phrase, “Notwithstanding Section 487,” it supersedes all of Penal Code § 487, including subdivision (d)(2), which specifies that grand theft occurs when the property taken is a firearm.
Receipt/Purchase of a Stolen Firearm
Under existing law, knowingly purchasing or receiving any stolen property is an alternate felony-misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or by imprisonment in county jail or state prison for 16 months, two or three years. Prior to the passage of Proposition 47, in cases where the value of the property did not exceed $950, the district attorney or grand jury could specify in the accusatory pleading that the offense shall be a misdemeanor. Proposition 47 amended this section of law to specify that in all cases in which the value of the property (including a firearm) does not exceed $950, the offense shall be a misdemeanor, punishable only by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, if such person has no prior convictions for a serious or violent felony or an offense requiring registration as a sex offender.
Proposed Law:
This bill would call for a special election to amend Proposition 47 and make the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases and punishable by a state prison term. Specifically, this bill:
- Declares that the theft of a firearm is grand theft in all cases, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or two or three years.
- States that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail for 16 months, two or three years (or state prison in the defendant has a current or prior serious or violent felony conviction or a conviction for an offense requiring sex offender registration).
- Calls for a special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for voter approval of these provisions.
- Requires consolidation of the special election with the statewide general election to be held on that date. Requires the consolidated election be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used.
Related Legislation:
AB 1176 (Cooper) 2016 is substantially similar to this measure but additionally includes a provision specifying a misdemeanor firearms violation results in a 10-year prohibition from possession of a firearm. AB 1176 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 2854 (Cooper) 2016 is virtually identical to this measure. AB 2854 failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Public Safety.
Prior Legislation: AB 150 (Melendez) 2015 was virtually identical to this measure. AB 150 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 452 (Galgiani) 2015 would have clarified that theft of a firearm is grand theft and is punishable as a felony, as specified. SB 452 was not set for hearing in this Committee.
Staff Comments:
Special Election
The SOS has indicated that printing and mailing costs associated with placing a measure on the statewide ballot are approximately $69,000 per page, depending on the length of the ballot. This fiscal estimate of $414,000 to $552,000 (General Fund) reflects the costs for the addition of six to eight pages in the Voter Information Guide. Actual costs would depend upon the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
Theft of a firearm – grand theft in all cases
By specifying the theft of a firearm is grand theft in all cases, this bill could result in additional or longer commitments to state prison. Data from the CDCR indicates a reduction of over 70 percent (29 commitments in 2014, 8 commitments in 2015) in the number of commitments to state prison for theft of a firearm as a principal offense. To the extent this bill results in a comparable increase in commitments to prison over the decrease experienced post-Proposition 47, annual costs could increase by over $600,000 annually based on the contract bed rate of $29,000 per inmate. To the extent the defendants formerly committed for theft of a firearm as a principal offense continue to be committed to prison under other felony offenses would not result in new commitments but could potentially result in longer prison sentences for these cases.
Purchase or receipt of a stolen firearm
This bill increases the penalty for purchase or receipt of a stolen firearm to an alternative felony/misdemeanor offense in all cases, irrespective of the value of the stolen firearm, punishable by up to one year in county jail or by 16 months, two or three years in county jail or state prison dependent on the defendant’s criminal history. As a result, this bill could result in cost increases to both state prisons and county jails for felony convictions for violations that previously would have been subject to a misdemeanor charge should the firearm be valued under $950.
Data from the DOJ reflects a 47 percent decrease in felony arrests for receipt of stolen property from 2014 (33,310 arrests) to 2015 (17,689 arrests), and over a 100 percent increase in misdemeanor arrests over the same period. Likewise felony convictions decreased by nearly 65 percent. Data from the CDCR indicates a decrease of nearly 69 percent for commitments to state prison for receipt of stolen property as a principal offense (396 commitments in 2014, and 123 commitments in 2015). Although the number of commitments specific to receipt of a stolen firearm is unknown, it is likely some portion of these offenses would be impacted. Assuming 20 percent of the reduction in cases was attributable to stolen firearms, costs for state incarceration could increase by about $1.6 million per year. To the extent the percentage of cases is higher or lower, the impact to state prison costs could vary greatly.
Lifetime firearms ban
To the extent the two provisions above – theft of a firearm and purchase/receipt of a stolen firearm – result in additional felony convictions that otherwise would have been charged as misdemeanors, this bill could have the effect of imposing the lifetime firearms ban on a larger group of individuals. A violation of the lifetime prohibition from firearms possession is a felony.
Local jails and state prisons will potentially incur cost increases under the firearm prohibition provisions of this measure to the extent new commitments to county jail and state prison result from a greater number of felony violations of the lifetime firearms ban in the future. Additionally, the DOJ will incur administrative and enforcement costs to add and monitor new cases to be added to the APPS list resulting from persons convicted of felony offenses that would subsequently be subject to a lifetime ban on firearms possession/ownership.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1869 Hearing Date: June 21, 2016
Author: | Melendez | ||
Version: | February 10, 2016 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | JRD | ||
Subject: Theft: Firearms
HISTORY
Source: California District Attorneys Association; California Peace Officers Association; California State Sheriffs' Association
Prior Legislation: SB 452 (Galgiani) – died Senate Appropriations, 2015
AB 150 (Melendez)—died Assembly Appropriations, 2015
Support: California Association of Code Enforcement Officers; California Chapters of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence; California College and University Police Chiefs; California Narcotics Officers; California Police Chiefs Association; California Sportsman's Lobby; California Statewide Law Enforcement Association; City of Burbank; City of Canyon Lake; City of Lodi; City of Indian Wells; City of Murietta; City of Palm Desert; City of Riverside; Criminal Justice Legal Foundation; Fraternal Order of Police; Gun Owners of California; League of California Cities; Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs; Los Angeles County District Attorney; Los Angeles Police Protective League; Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association; National Rifle Association; National Shooting Sports Foundation; Outdoor Sportsmen's Coalition of California; Riverside County Board of Supervisors; Riverside Sheriffs’ Association; Rural County; Representatives of California; Sacramento County Sheriff's Department; San Bernardino County Sheriff-Coroner; San Diego County District Attorney; Safari Club International
Opposition: American Civil Liberties Union; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Assembly Floor Vote: 79 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this legislation is to: (1) clarify that theft of a firearm is grand theft and is punishable as a felony, as specified; (2) and provide that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense, as specified.
This bill would provide that it would become effective only upon approval of the voters, and would provide for the submission of this measure to the voters for approval at the next statewide general election.
This bill provides that the provisions of this legislation that amend Proposition 47 (the firearm theft and receipt of a stolen firearm penalty provisions) shall become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters at a statewide election. This legislation further provides that a special election is hereby called, to be held throughout the state on November 8, 2016. The special election shall be consolidated with the statewide general election to be held on that date. The consolidated election shall be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used. This legislation additionally provides that the Secretary of State shall submit the specified portions of this legislation to the voters for their approval at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election.
This bill calls an election within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and states that it goes go into effect immediately.
Firearm Theft
Existing law provides that every person who feloniously steals, takes, carries, leads, or drives away the personal property of another is guilty of theft, as specified. (Penal Code § 484.)
Existing law defines “grand theft” as any theft where the money, labor, or real or personal property taken or when the property is taken from the person of another is of a value exceeding $950. (Penal Code §§ 487(a) and (c).)
Existing law provides that grand theft is committed when the money, labor, or real or personal property taken is of a value in excess of $950, except as specified. (Penal Code § 487(a).)
Existing law provides that, notwithstanding the default value of $950 to establish grand theft, grand theft is committed in any of the following cases:
- When domestic fowls, avocados, or other farm crops are taken of a value exceeding $250;
- When fish or other aqua-cultural products are taken from a commercial or research operation that is producing that product of a value exceeding $250;
- Where money, labor or property is taken by a servant or employee from his or her principal and aggregates $950 or more in any consecutive 12-month period;
- When the property is taken from the person of another;
- When the property taken is an automobile, firearm, horse, mare, gelding, bovine animal, caprine animal, mule, jack, jenny, sheep, lamb, hog, sow, boar, gilt, barrow, or pig;
- When the property is taken from the person of another; or
- When the property taken is an automobile and firearm.
(Penal Code § 487(b) through (d).)
Existing law states that if the grand theft involves the theft of a firearm, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or two or three years. (Penal Code § 489(a).)
Existing law provides that grand theft is an alternate felony-misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for up to one year, a fine of up to $1,000, or both, or by a felony jail sentence of 16 months, two years or three years pursuant to Penal Code Section 1170, subdivision (h), and a fine of up to $10,000. (Penal Code § 489(b).)
Existing law provides that, notwithstanding Section 487, or any other provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor, except that such person may instead be punished pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 if that person has a prior conviction for a serious or violent felony or an offense requiring registration pursuant to 290, as specified. (Penal Code § 490.2(a).)
This bill would make the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or 2 or 3 years.
Receipt of Stolen Firearm
Existing law provides that any person who buys or receives any property that has been stolen or that has been obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, or who conceals, sells, withholds, or aids in concealing, selling, or withholding any property from the owner, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. However, if the value of the property does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950), the offense shall be a misdemeanor, punishable only by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, if such person has no prior convictions for an offense specified in clause (iv) of subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 667 or for an offense requiring registration pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290.
A principal in the actual theft of the property may be convicted pursuant to this section. However, no person may be convicted both pursuant to this section and of the theft of the same property. (Penal Code § 496 (a).)
This bill provides that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment, as specified.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past several years this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
- 143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
- 141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
- 137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In December of 2015 the administration reported that as “of December 9, 2015, 112,510 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.0% of design bed capacity, and 5,264 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. The current population is 1,212 inmates below the final court-ordered population benchmark of 137.5% of design bed capacity, and has been under that benchmark since February 2015.” (Defendants’ December 2015 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).) One year ago, 115,826 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounted to 140.0% of design bed capacity, and 8,864 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. (Defendants’ December 2014 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).)
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
- Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
- Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
- Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
- Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
- Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
- Need for Legislation
According to the author:
Proposition 47 lessened the penalties for the theft of firearms. Prior to the passage of Proposition 47, the penalty would be imprisonment in state prison for 16 months, 2, or 3 years. Under current law, the theft of a firearm (not exceeding $950) is a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in county jail for up to six months and/or a fine of up to $1,000 – the standard penalty for petty theft under the provisions of Penal Code § 490.
In addition, current law dictates that gun trafficking related crimes (receiving/selling stolen firearms) will only be considered a misdemeanor so long as the property is not valued more than $950. This crime would be punishable by imprisonment in county jail for up to six months and/or a fine of up to $1,000 (subject to realignment rules).
The majority of handguns and most rifles and shotguns are valued under $950. This would make current law, as written in Proposition 47, ineffective in curtailing gun theft and gun trafficking.
- Proposition 47: Effect of this Legislation
Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by the voters in November 2014. Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes and directed that the resulting state savings be directed to mental health and substance abuse treatment, truancy and dropout prevention, and victims’ services. The initiative reduced the penalties for theft, shoplifting, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks, and check forgery valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. The measure limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have prior convictions for serious or violent felonies and who are not required to registered sex offenders. (See Legislative Analyst's Office analysis of Proposition 47, http://www.lao.ca.gov/ballot/2014/prop-47-110414.pdf.)
Grand Theft of a Firearm
Proposition 47 added Penal Code section 490.2 which provides a new definition for grand theft: "Notwithstanding Section 487 or any other provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor ….." (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (a), emphasis added.) In other words, Proposition 47 put in a blanket $950 threshold for conduct to be grand theft. Previously, there were a number of carve-outs which made conduct grand theft based on the conduct involved or the manner in which the crime is committed or based on the value being less than $950.
Because the new statute specifically states “notwithstanding Section 487,” it supersedes all of Penal Code section 487, including subdivision (d)(2), which says that grand theft occurs when the property taken is a firearm. The question becomes whether, notwithstanding newly-created Penal Code section 490.2, theft of a firearm remains a felony.
The drafters of Proposition 47 state that they did not intend to reduce the penalty for theft of a firearm and explain:
Proposition 47 maintained California’s numerous gun laws—the strictest in the country—enabling felony prosecution for any and all criminal activity related to guns. This includes gun thefts regardless of the value of the gun. Gun crimes are, by definition, serious crimes. Proposition 47 is exclusively limited to non-serious and nonviolent crimes. Additionally, dozens of felony provisions related to gun crimes are maintained by Proposition 47, including (but not limited to): possession of a concealed stolen gun or possession of a loaded stolen gun; use of a firearm to facilitate any crime (including when the gun involved is being stolen and theft is crime in question); stealing guns from residences, stores during non-business hours, or locked automobiles; taking a firearm from the person of another with force or fear; or possession of a concealed stolen weapon by a gang member or possession of a gun by a felon.
(http://www.safeandjust.org/prop47faq.)
A recent appellate court decision concluded otherwise in dicta. (People v. Perkins (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 129.) In People v. Perkins, supra, the defendant was convicted of burglary, receiving stolen property, three counts of grand theft of a firearm, and several other offenses. He was sentenced to state prison. After California voters passed Proposition 47, the defendant filed a petition for resentencing to convert some of his offenses to misdemeanors. (Id. at p. 132-133.) The petition was denied and he appealed. The Court of Appeal did not squarely address the issue of whether Proposition 47 reduced the theft of a firearm to a misdemeanor when its value is less than $950. Rather, what was at issue in the case was the adequacy of the petition. The defendant actually had petitioned only for resentencing on the receiving stolen property count because the form provided by the superior court excluded the option of petitioning for resentencing grand theft offenses. (Id. at p. 136.) In affirming denial of the petition without prejudice, the court noted, “Proposition 47 added a new provision, section 490.2, subdivision (a), which reclassifies felony section 487, subdivision (d)(2) grand theft violations into misdemeanors. Thus, petitioner would be entitled to resentencing on each conviction, provided he can meet his burden of showing, separately for each firearm, that its value does not exceed $950.” (Id. at p. 141.)
Whether Proposition 47 made theft of a firearm a misdemeanor appears to be subject to interpretation and debate. Given that the proponents contend that Proposition 47 did not change the penalties for gun theft, clarifying the intent of the proponents by stating that theft of a firearm remains a felony is seemingly innocuous.
SHOULD THE LAW BE CLARIFIED TO EXPLICITLY STATE THAT THEFT OF A FIREARM IS A FELONY?
Receipt of Stolen Property: Firearm
Proposition 47 amended Penal Section 496 to state: “Every person who buys or receives any property that has been stolen or that has been obtained in any manner constituting theft or extortion, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, or who conceals, sells, withholds, or aids in concealing, selling, or withholding any property from the owner, knowing the property to be so stolen or obtained, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. However, if the district attorney or the grand jury determines that this action would be in the interests of justice, the district attorney or the grand jury, as the case may be, may, if the value of the property does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950), specify in the accusatory pleading that the offense shall be a misdemeanor, punishable only by imprisonment in a
county jail not exceeding one year, if such person has no prior convictions for an offense specified in clause (iv) of subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 667 or for an offense requiring registration pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290.” Unlike theft of a firearm, pre-Proposition 47 receipt of a stolen firearm was not a felony (it was a wobbler) and, thus, was not a serious felony. (See Penal Code § 1192.7.)
The court explains how Proposition 47 changed the receipt of stolen property provision in the Penal Code,
Receiving Stolen Property [punishment: up to one year in jail]. If the value of the property received does not exceed $950, section 496(a) specifies the crime is a misdemeanor. Previously section 496(a) gave the district attorney the discretion to charge the crime as a misdemeanor if the property did not exceed $950; now the district attorney must charge the crime as a misdemeanor if the value of the property does not exceed $950.
(http://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/Prop-47-Information.pdf)
This legislation would add a provision to the Penal Code making receipt of a stolen firearm a wobbler.
SHOULD RECEIPT OF A STOLEN FIREARM BE A WOBBLER?
3. California Constitutional Limitations on Amending a Voter Initiative
Because Proposition 47 was a voter initiative, the Legislature may not amend the statute without subsequent voter approval unless the initiative permits such amendment, and then only upon whatever conditions the voters attached to the Legislature’s amendatory powers. (People v. Superior Court (Pearson) (2010) 48 Cal.4th 564, 568; see also Cal. Const., art. II, § 10, subd. (c).) The California Constitution states, “The Legislature may amend or repeal referendum statutes. It may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without their approval.” (Cal. Const., art. II, § 10, subd. (c).) Therefore, unless the initiative expressly authorizes the Legislature to amend, only the voters may alter statutes created by initiative.
As to the Legislature’s authority to amend the initiative, Proposition 47 states: “This act shall be broadly construed to accomplish its purposes. The provisions of this measure may be amended by a two‑thirds vote of the members of each house of the Legislature and signed by the Governor so long as the amendments are consistent with and further the intent of this act. The Legislature may by majority vote amend, add, or repeal provisions to further reduce the penalties for any of the offenses addressed by this act.” (http://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2014/general/pdf/text-of-proposed-laws1.pdf#prop47.)
This bill provides that the Proposition 47 provisions go to the voters for ratification.
4. Argument in Support
The California District Attorneys Association states:
As we have seen many times over the last year, and as it was plainly put by the 4th District Court of Appeal earlier this year, Proposition 47 “converted receipt of stolen property and grand theft of a firearm into misdemeanors where the value of the stolen property does not exceed $950.” People v. Perkins (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th __ (E062878). Despite assertions to the contrary from the proponents of Proposition 47, it has become quite clear that this was one of the greatest unintended consequences of that initiative.
Stolen firearms are often used in other serious and violent crimes because they are difficult to trace back to the perpetrator. The Legislature recognized this inherent threat posed by firearms in the hands of criminals, which was why, prior to Prop 47, theft of a firearm was always treated as a felony.
Under current law, the penalty for stealing a firearm is based wholly on value – as if stealing a $300 gun is somehow ultimately less dangerous than stealing a $951 gun – and thus fundamentally misunderstands why theft of a firearm was ever treated as grand theft in the first place.
5. Argument in Opposition
The American Civil Liberties Union states:
The voters made their decision after being fully apprised of the arguments now being raised in support of AB 1869. The Official Voter Information Guide, published by the Secretary of State and mailed to every voter in California, specifically explained the following arguments in opposition to the ballot initiative:
• “Stealing any handgun valued at less than $950 will no longer be a felony.”
- “Prop. 47 would eliminate automatic felony prosecution for stealing a gun. Under current law, stealing a gun is a felony, period. Prop. 47 would redefine grand theft in such a way that theft of a firearm could only be considered a felony if the value of the gun is greater than $950. Almost all handguns (which are the most stolen kind of firearm) retail for well below $950. People don’t steal guns just so they can add to their gun collection. They steal guns to commit another crime. People stealing guns are protected under Proposition 47.”
- “Reduces penalties for stealing guns.”
In response to the arguments against Proposition 47, the Guide provided voters with the following rebuttal argument:
• “Proposition 47 maintains penalties for gun crimes. Under Prop. 47, possessing a stolen concealed gun remains a felony. Additional felony penalties to prevent felons and gang members from obtaining guns also apply.”
After reviewing the arguments both in favor and against the ballot initiative, the majority of California voters chose to approve Proposition 47. The arguments in favor of the initiative were true in 2014 and remain true today: there are already numerous state and federal laws that impose felony penalties on those who steal guns or use stolen guns to commit crimes. Proposition 47 did nothing to change those laws. California voters understood the decision they made when they approved Proposition 47, and there is no justification for nullifying their decision.
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1869
Author:(Melendez and Gray)
As Introduced Ver:February 10, 2016
Majority vote. Urgency
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Public Safety | 7-0 | Jones-Sawyer, Melendez, Lackey, Lopez, Low, Quirk, Santiago | |
Elections | 6-1 | Harper, Travis Allen, Gordon, Low, Mullin, Nazarian | Weber |
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY:
Calls for a special election to amend Proposition 47 and make the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases and punishable by a state prison term. Specifically, this bill:
- Declares that the theft of a firearm is grand theft in all cases, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or two or three years.
- States that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment.
- Provides that this bill amends Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, and shall become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters.
- Calls for a special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for voter approval of these provisions.
- Requires consolidation of the special election with the statewide general election to be held on that date.
- Requires the consolidated election be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used.
EXISTING LAW:
- Divides theft into two degrees, petty theft and grand theft.
- Defines grand theft as when the money, labor, or real or personal property taken is of a value exceeding $950 dollars, except as specified.
- States that notwithstanding any provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed $950 shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor, except in the case where a person has prior serious, violent, or sex convictions, in which case the offense is punished as a felony by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment.
- Prohibits carrying a concealed firearm upon the person or in a vehicle, and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen.
- Prohibits carrying a loaded firearm on the person or in a vehicle while in any public place or on any public street and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen.
- Prohibits any person previously convicted of a felony from owning, purchasing, receiving, possessing, or having in his or her custody a firearm, and punishes that offense as a felony.
- Deems grand theft involving a firearm to be a serious felony.
- States that a felony is a crime that is punishable with death, imprisonment in the state prison, or in the county jail under the provisions of Penal Code Section 1170(h). All other crimes are misdemeanors, except those classified as infractions.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time General Fund (GF) costs of at least $220,000 to include a measure on the statewide ballot. The current estimate for including a measure on the ballot is approximately $55,000 per page and this measure will require at least four pages, in the voter information guide.
- Likely minor ongoing GF costs for increased state prison commitments for persons with a current or prior violent felony conviction who are convicted of buying or receiving a stolen firearm. The universe of these individuals is expected to be very small, there are several statutes providing for conduct related to firearm possession.
COMMENTS:
According to the author, "The vast majority of handguns, rifles, and shotguns are valued under $950. By reducing penalties, this would make current law ineffective in curtailing gun theft and gun trafficking. This change in law has put the safety of our constituents at risk. Not only will it be harder to prosecute gun theft, we are essentially giving criminals the green light by lessening the penalty. A criminal doesn't steal a gun to go duck hunting, they steal a gun to commit crimes.
"It is important that California continues to enforce a strong stance against the illegal acquisition and use of firearms."
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe/ PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0003124
Date of Hearing: April 20, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1869
Author:(Melendez) – As Introduced Ver:February 10, 2016
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Elections and Redistricting
| 6 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires an initiative statute be put before the voters to amend Proposition 47 to make the theft of a firearm, valued at $950 or less, a felony. Specifically, this bill:
- Includes theft of a firearm, without regard to dollar value, in the definition of grand theft, and makes the crime punishable in state prison for 16 months, or two or three years.
- States that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment.
- Provides that this bill amends Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, and shall become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time General Fund (GF) costs of at least $220,000 to include a measure on the statewide ballot. The current estimate for including a measure on the ballot is approximately $55,000 per page and this measure will require at least four pages, in the voter information guide.
- Likely minor ongoing GF costs for increased state prison commitments for persons with a current or prior violent felony conviction who are convicted of buying or receiving a stolen firearm. The universe of these individuals is expected to be very small, there are several statutes providing for conduct related to firearm possession.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by the voters in November 2014. Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes. Specifically, the initiative reduced the penalties for theft, shoplifting, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks, and check forgery valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. However, the measure limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have prior convictions for serious or violent felonies and who are not required to register as sex offenders.
Proposition 47 put in a blanket $950 threshold for conduct to be considered grand theft. Previously, there were a number of carve-outs which made conduct grand theft based on the conduct involved or the manner in which the crime is committed or based on the value being less than $950. However, the drafters of Proposition 47 stated that they did not intend to reduce the penalty for the theft of a firearm. The rebuttal to the argument against Proposition 47 contained in the ballot arguments stated: "Proposition 47 maintains penalties for gun crimes. Under Prop. 47, possessing a stolen concealed gun remains a felony. Additional felony penalties to prevent felons and gang members from obtaining guns also apply."
- Purpose. This bill restores the penalties that were in place prior to the passage of Proposition 47 by making theft of a firearm a felony grand theft in all cases, and making buying or receiving a stolen firearm a felony/misdemeanor offense. However, the proposed amendments to statute do require a simple majority of the electorate at the next statewide election, after enactment of this measure.
- Support. A co-sponsor, the California District Attorneys Association, argues stolen firearms are often used in other serious and violent crimes because they are difficult to trace back to the perpetrator. The penalty for the theft of a gun should be the same, regardless of dollar value of the firearm.
- Opposition. According to The American Civil Liberties Union, “The arguments in favor of the initiative [Proposition 47] were true in 2014 and remain true today: there are already numerous state and federal laws that impose felony penalties on those who steal guns or use stolen guns to commit crimes. Proposition 47 did nothing to change those laws. California voters understood the decision they made when they approved Proposition 47, and there is no justification for nullifying their decision."
- Related Legislation:
- AB 2369 (Patterson) authorizes the prosecutor to charge a defendant with a felony if the person has been convicted twice or more in a 12-month period of the crimes reduced to a misdemeanor by Proposition 47. AB 2369 also makes it a felony when stolen items include a firearm. AB 2369 is pending referral.
- AB 2854 (Cooper) is substantially similar to this bill, but calls for a special election to be held in June 2016. AB 2854 is pending referral.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 150 (Melendez) of the 2015 Legislative session, which was substantially similar to this bill, was held on this Committee's Suspense file.
- Proposition 47 of the November 2014 general election, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes.
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 13, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
Shirley Weber, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1869 (
Author:Melendez) – As Introduced Ver:February 10, 2016
SUBJECT: Theft: firearms.
SUMMARY: Calls for a special election to amend Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, an initiative statute that was approved by the voters at the November 4, 2014 statewide general election. Makes the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases and punishable by a state prison term, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Contains the following Legislature findings and declarations:
- The theft of firearms and receipt of stolen firearms pose dangers to public safety that are different in kind from other types of theft or the receipt of other types of stolen property.
- Many handguns have value of less than $950. The threat to public safety in regard to stolen firearms goes above and beyond the monetary value of the firearm.
- Given the significant and particular threat to public safety in regard to stolen firearms, it is appropriate to restore the penalties that existed prior to the passage of the Safe Neighborhoods and School Act of 2014 in regard to stolen firearms.
- It is not the intent of the Legislature in submitting this act to the electors to undermine the voters’ decision to decrease penalties for low-level theft and receiving stolen property, only to give voters the opportunity to decide whether firearm thefts and the receipt of stolen firearms should be subject to penalties that existed prior to the passage of the Safe Neighborhood and School Act.
- The theft of firearms and receipt of stolen firearms pose dangers to public safety that are different in kind from other types of theft or the receipt of other types of stolen property.
- Provides that the theft of a firearm is grand theft in all cases, punishable by imprisonment in state prison for 16 months, or two or three years.
- Provides that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm, as specified, is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to the Criminal Justice Realignment Act of 2011.
- Provides for this bill to become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters at a statewide election.
- Calls for a statewide special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for voter approval of these provisions and requires the special election to be consolidated with the statewide general election to be held on that date. Requires the special election to be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and provides that only one form of ballot shall be used.
EXISTING LAW:
- Divides theft into two degrees, petty theft and grand theft.
- Defines grand theft to mean when money, labor, or real or personal property taken is of a value exceeding $950 dollars, except as specified.
- Provides that notwithstanding any provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed $950 shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor, except in the case where a person has prior serious, violent, or sex convictions, in which case the offense is punished as a felony by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment.
- Prohibits carrying a concealed firearm on the person or in a vehicle, and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen.
- Prohibits carrying a loaded firearm on the person or in a vehicle while in any public place or on any public street and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen.
- Prohibits any person previously convicted of a felony from owning, purchasing, receiving, possessing, or having in his or her custody a firearm, and punishes that offense as a felony.
- Deems grand theft involving a firearm to be a serious felony.
- Provides that a felony is a crime that is punishable with death, imprisonment in the state prison, or in the county jail in accordance with existing law. Provides that all other crimes are misdemeanors, except those classified as infractions.
- Provides that statutes calling elections to go into effect immediately upon their enactment.
- Permits the Legislature to amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without voter approval.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
The vast majority of handguns, rifles, and shotguns are valued under $950. By reducing penalties, this would make current law ineffective in curtailing gun theft and gun trafficking. This change in law has put the safety of our constituents at risk. Not only will it be harder to prosecute gun theft, we are essentially giving criminals the green light by lessening the penalty. A criminal doesn’t steal a gun to go duck hunting, they steal a gun to commit crimes.
It is important that California continues to enforce a strong stance against the illegal acquisition and use of firearms.
- Proposition 47: Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by voters at the November 4, 2014 statewide general election. Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes and provided that the resulting state savings be directed to mental health and substance abuse treatment, truancy and dropout prevention, and victims' services. Specifically, the initiative reduced the penalties for possession for personal use of most illegal drugs to misdemeanors. Additionally, the initiative reduced the penalties for theft, shoplifting, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks, and check forgery valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. The measure, however, limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have prior convictions for serious or violent felonies and who are not required registered sex offenders.
- Proposition 47 As it Relates to the Theft of a Gun: Proposition 47 added Penal Code Section 490.2 which provides a new definition for grand theft: "Notwithstanding Section 487 or any other provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor ….." (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (a), emphasis added.) In other words, Proposition 47 put in a blanket $950 threshold for conduct to be grand theft. Previously, there were a number of carve-outs, which made conduct grand theft based on the conduct involved or the manner in which the crime is committed or based on the value being less than $950.
Because the new statute specifically states "notwithstanding Section 487," it trumps all of Penal Code Section 487, including subdivision (d)(2), which says that grand theft occurs when the property taken is a firearm. The question becomes whether notwithstanding newly-created Penal Code Section 490.2, another provision of law deems this conduct to be a felony.
Penal Code Section 1192.7, states that grand theft involving a firearm is a serious felony. Some argue that this is a "provision of law defining grand theft" because of how it characterizes the crime. But not every description in Section 1192.7 is coextensive with the statutory definition of a specific crime. The general purpose of Section 1192.7 is to prohibit plea bargaining in cases arising out of the listed offenses, and to enumerate crimes for sentence enhancements under other statutory schemes.
The drafters of Proposition 47 stated that they did not intend to reduce the penalty for the theft of a firearm. The rebuttal to the argument against Proposition 47 contained in the ballot arguments stated: "Proposition 47 maintains penalties for gun crimes. Under Prop. 47, possessing a stolen concealed gun remains a felony. Additional felony penalties to prevent felons and gang members from obtaining guns also apply." The ballot argument by itself does not mean that they did not inadvertently do so.
Notably, a recent appellate court decision concluded otherwise in dicta. (People v. Perkins (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 129.) In People v. Perkins, supra, the defendant was convicted of burglary, receiving stolen property, three counts of grand theft of a firearm, and several other offenses. He was sentenced to state prison. After California voters passed Proposition 47, the defendant filed a petition for resentencing to convert some of his offenses to misdemeanors. (Id. at p. 132-133.) The petition was denied and he appealed. The Court of Appeal did not squarely address the issue of whether Proposition 47 reduced the theft of a firearm to a misdemeanor when its value is less than $950. Rather, what was at issue in the case was the adequacy of the petition. The defendant actually had petitioned only for resentencing on the receiving stolen property count because the form provided by the superior court excluded the option of petitioning for resentencing grand theft offenses. (Id. at p. 136.) In affirming denial of the petition without prejudice, the court noted, "Proposition 47 added a new provision, section 490.2, subdivision (a), which reclassifies felony section 487, subdivision (d)(2) grand theft violations into misdemeanors. Thus, petitioner would be entitled to resentencing on each conviction, provided he can meet his burden of showing, separately for each firearm, that its value does not exceed $950." (Id. at p. 141.) - California Constitutional Limitations on Amending a Voter Initiative: Article II, Section 10 of the California Constitution states, “The Legislature may amend or repeal referendum statutes. It may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without their approval." In other words, unless an initiative expressly authorizes the Legislature to amend an initiative, only the voters may alter statutes created by initiative.
Consequently, because Proposition 47 was a voter initiative, the Legislature does not have the authority to amend the statute without subsequent voter approval unless the initiative specifically permits such amendment, and then only upon whatever conditions the voters attached to the Legislature's amendatory powers. (People v. Superior Court (Pearson) (2010) 48 Cal.4th 564, 568; see also Cal. Const., art. II, § 10, subd. (c).)
The purpose of California's constitutional limitation on the Legislature's power to amend initiative statutes is to protect the people's initiative powers by precluding the Legislature from undoing what the people have done, without the electorate's consent. Courts have a duty to jealously guard the people's initiative power and, hence, to apply a liberal construction to this power wherever it is challenged in order that the right to resort to the initiative process is not improperly annulled by a legislative body. (Proposition 103 Enforcement Project v. Quackenbush (1998) 64 Cal.App.4th 1473.)
Proposition 47 states, "This act shall be broadly construed to accomplish its purposes. The provisions of this measure may be amended by a two‑thirds vote of the members of each house of the Legislature and signed by the Governor so long as the amendments are consistent with and further the intent of this act. The Legislature may by majority vote amend, add, or repeal provisions to further reduce the penalties for any of the offenses addressed by this act."
If Proposition 47 is deemed not to have changed the punishment for the theft of a firearm, then the provisions of this bill do not amend the initiative, but rather would be consistent with the language and intent of the initiative. On the other hand, if Proposition 47 is interpreted as having reduced the punishment for the theft of a firearm valued at $950 or less, as well as the receipt or purchase of a stolen firearm with the same value, then the change will have to go before the voters for ratification. - Legislative Deadlines for Placing a Measure on the Ballot: Current law requires every constitutional amendment, bond measure, or other legislative measure submitted to the people by the Legislature to appear on the ballot of the first statewide election occurring at least 131 days after the adoption of the proposal by the Legislature. The statutory deadline to place a measure on the ballot for the November 8, 2016 statewide election is June 30, 2016.
This bill calls for a statewide special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for voter approval of the provisions of this bill. Additionally, this bill requires the special election to be consolidated with the statewide general election to be held on that date and requires the special election to be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used. If this bill is approved by the Legislature and signed by the Governor by June 30, it will be placed on the November 8, 2016 ballot. - Bill Calling an Election: Because this bill calls an election within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution, it would go into immediate effect if signed by the Governor.
- Arguments in Support: One of the sponsors of this bill, California State Sheriffs' Association writes:
As we have seen many times over the last year, and as it was very plainly put by the 4th District Court of Appeal earlier this year, Proposition 47 "converted receipt of stolen property and grand theft or a firearm into misdemeanors where the value of the stolen property does not exceed $950." People v Perkins (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th_(E062878). Despite assertions to the contrary from the proponents of Proposition 47, it has become quite clear that this was one of the greatest unintended consequences of that initiative.
Stolen firearms are other used in other serious and violent crimes because they are difficult to trace back to the perpetrator. The Legislature recognized this inherent threat posed by firearms in the hands of criminals, which is why prior to Prop 47, theft of a firearm was always treated as grand theft…
- Arguments in Opposition: In opposition, the American Civil Liberties Union of California, writes:
The changes proposed in AB 1869 are both unnecessary and contrary to the will of California voters.
On November 4, 2014, in our statewide general election, California voters approved Proposition 47, which, among other things, reduced the classification of certain nonviolent felonies and wobblers to misdemeanors. The voters made their decision after being fully apprised of the arguments now being raised in support of AB 1869…
After reviewing arguments both in favor and against the ballot initiative, the majority of California voter chose to approve Proposition 47. The arguments in favor of the initiative were true in 2014 and remain true today: there are already numerous state and federal laws that impose felony penalties on those who steal guns or use stolen guns to commit crimes. Proposition 47 did nothing to change those laws. California voters understood the decision they made when they approved Proposition 47, and there is no justification for nullifying their decision…
- Related Legislation: AB 2369 (Patterson), authorizes the prosecutor to charge a defendant with a felony if the person has been convicted twice or more in a 12-month period of the crimes reduced to a misdemeanor by Proposition 47. AB 2369 also makes it a felony when stolen items include a firearm. AB 2369 failed passage in the Assembly Public Safety Committee on a vote of 2-4.
AB 2854 (Cooper), is substantially similar to this bill, except that it calls for a special election to be held on June 7, 2016, as specified. AB 2854 is pending in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- Prior Legislation: AB 150 (Melendez) of 2015, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 150 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's suspense file.
- Double-Referral: This bill passed out of the Assembly Public Safety Committee on a 7-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association (co-sponsor)
California Peace Officers' Association (co-sponsor)
California State Sheriffs' Association (co-sponsor)
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
California Association of Code Enforcement Officers
California College and University Police Chiefs Association
California Narcotic Officers Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Sportsman's Lobby
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
City of Burbank
City of Canyon Lake
City of Indian Wells
City of Lodi
Criminal Justice Legal Foundation
Fraternal Order of Police
Gun Owners of California
League of California Cities
Los Angeles County Professional Officers Association
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association
Mayor of the City of Murrieta
National Rifle Association
National Shooting Sports Foundation
Outdoor Sportsmen's Coalition of California
Riverside County Board of Supervisors
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
Rural County Representatives of California
Sacramento County Sheriff Scott Jones
Safari Club International
Safari Club International Foundation
San Bernardino County Sheriff-Coroner
San Diego County Office of the District Attorney
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Becker / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094
Date of Hearing: March 15, 2016
Counsel: Sandra Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Calls for a special election to amend Proposition 47 and make the theft of a firearm grand theft in all cases and punishable by a state prison term. Specifically, this bill:
- Declares that the theft of a firearm is grand theft in all cases, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 16 months, or two or three years.
- States that every person who buys or receives a stolen firearm is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor offense punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment.
- Provides that this bill amends Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, and shall become effective only when submitted to and approved by the voters.
- Calls for a special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for voter approval of these provisions.
- Requires consolidation of the special election with the statewide general election to be held on that date.
- Requires the consolidated election be held and conducted in all respects as if there were only one election, and only one form of ballot shall be used.
EXISTING LAW:
- Divides theft into two degrees, petty theft and grand theft. (Pen. Code, § 486.)
- Defines grand theft as when the money, labor, or real or personal property taken is of a value exceeding $950 dollars, except as specified. (Pen. Code, § 487.)
- States that notwithstanding any provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed $950 shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor, except in the case where a person has prior serious, violent, or sex convictions, in which case the offense is punished as a felony by imprisonment in the county jail pursuant to realignment. (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (a).)
- Prohibits carrying a concealed firearm upon the person or in a vehicle, and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen. (Pen. Code, § 25400.)
- Prohibits carrying a loaded firearm on the person or in a vehicle while in any public place or on any public street and punishes that crime as a felony under certain circumstances, including if the person is an ex-felon or a gang member, or if the firearm was stolen. (Pen. Code, § 25850.)
- Prohibits any person previously convicted of a felony from owning, purchasing, receiving, possessing, or having in his or her custody a firearm, and punishes that offense as a felony. (Pen. Code, § 29800, subd. (a)(1).)
- Deems grand theft involving a firearm to be a serious felony. (Pen. Code, § 1192.7, subd. (c)(26).)
- States that a felony is a crime that is punishable with death, imprisonment in the state prison, or in the county jail under the provisions of Penal Code section 1170, subdivision (h). All other crimes are misdemeanors, except those classified as infractions. (Pen. Code, § 17, subd. (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "The vast majority of handguns, rifles, and shotguns are valued under $950. By reducing penalties, this would make current law ineffective in curtailing gun theft and gun trafficking. This change in law has put the safety of our constituents at risk. Not only will it be harder to prosecute gun theft, we are essentially giving criminals the green light by lessening the penalty. A criminal doesn't steal a gun to go duck hunting, they steal a gun to commit crimes.
"It is important that California continues to enforce a strong stance against the illegal acquisition and use of firearms." - Proposition 47: Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by the voters in November 2014. Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes and directed that the resulting state savings be directed to mental health and substance abuse treatment, truancy and dropout prevention, and victims' services. Specifically, the initiative reduced the penalties for possession for personal use of most illegal drugs to misdemeanors. The initiative also reduced the penalties for theft, shoplifting, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks, and check forgery valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. However, the measure limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have prior convictions for serious or violent felonies and who are not required to registered sex offenders. (See Legislative Analyst's Office analysis of Proposition 47 <http://www.lao.ca.gov/ballot/2014/prop-47-110414.pdf>.)
- Proposition 47 As it Relates to the Theft of a Gun: Proposition 47 added Penal Code section 490.2 which provides a new definition for grand theft: "Notwithstanding Section 487 or any other provision of law defining grand theft, obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed nine hundred fifty dollars ($950) shall be considered petty theft and shall be punished as a misdemeanor ….." (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (a), emphasis added.) In other words, Proposition 47 put in a blanket $950 threshold for conduct to be grand theft. Previously, there were a number of carve-outs which made conduct grand theft based on the conduct involved or the manner in which the crime is committed or based on the value being less than $950.
Because the new statute specifically states "notwithstanding Section 487," it trumps all of Penal Code section 487, including subdivision (d)(2), which says that grand theft occurs when the property taken is a firearm. The question becomes whether notwithstanding newly-created Penal Code section 490.2, another provision of law deems this conduct to be a felony.
Penal Code section 1192.7, states that grand theft involving a firearm is a serious felony. Some may argue that this is a "provision of law defining grand theft" because of how it characterizes the crime. But not every description in section 1192.7 is coextensive with the statutory definition of a specific crime. The general purpose of section 1192.7 is to prohibit plea bargaining in cases arising out of the listed offenses, and to enumerate crimes for sentence enhancements under other statutory schemes.
The drafters of Proposition 47 stated that they did not intend to reduce the penalty for the theft of a firearm. The rebuttal to the argument against Proposition 47 contained in the ballot arguments stated: "Proposition 47 maintains penalties for gun crimes. Under Prop. 47, possessing a stolen concealed gun remains a felony. Additional felony penalties to prevent felons and gang members from obtaining guns also apply." <(http://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2014/general/pdf/proposition-47-arguments-rebuttals.pdf.>) The ballot argument by itself does not mean that they did not inadvertently do so.
Notably, a recent appellate court decision concluded otherwise in dicta. (People v. Perkins (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 129.) In People v. Perkins, supra, the defendant was convicted of burglary, receiving stolen property, three counts of grand theft of a firearm, and several other offenses. He was sentenced to state prison. After California voters passed Proposition 47, the defendant filed a petition for resentencing to convert some of his offenses to misdemeanors. (Id. at p. 132-133.) The petition was denied and he appealed. The Court of Appeal did not squarely address the issue of whether Proposition 47 reduced the theft of a firearm to a misdemeanor when its value is less than $950. Rather, what was at issue in the case was the adequacy of the petition. The defendant actually had petitioned only for resentencing on the receiving stolen property count because the form provided by the superior court excluded the option of petitioning for resentencing grand theft offenses. (Id. at p. 136.) In affirming denial of the petition without prejudice, the court noted, "Proposition 47 added a new provision, section 490.2, subdivision (a), which reclassifies felony section 487, subdivision (d)(2) grand theft violations into misdemeanors. Thus, petitioner would be entitled to resentencing on each conviction, provided he can meet his burden of showing, separately for each firearm, that its value does not exceed $950." (Id. at p. 141.) - Practical Considerations: Assuming arguendo that Proposition 47 reduced the theft of a firearm to a misdemeanor offense, the theft of a firearm or receipt or purchase of a stolen firearm will not usually happen in isolation. That single act will often involve violations of multiple criminal statutes, many of which are felonies.
For example, if a firearm is stolen from a home, the defendant could be charged with residential burglary, which is a felony and a strike. (See Pen. Code, §§ 460, 461, and 1192.7, subd. (c)(18).) If a firearm is stolen from a commercial establishment, the defendant can be charged with second-degree burglary, which can be punished as a felony (second-degree burglary is an alternate felony/misdemeanor). (See Pen. Code, §§ 460 and 461, subd. (b).) If a firearm is stolen from a locked vehicle, the defendant can be charged with auto burglary, which can be punished as a felony (auto burglary is an alternate felony/misdemeanor). (See Pen. Code, §§ 459, 460, and 461, subd. (b).) If the firearm is taken from another person by force or fear, then the defendant can be charged with robbery, which is a felony and a strike. (See Pen. Code, §§ 211, 213 and 1192.7, subd. (19).) Proposition 47 did nothing to changes these laws.
Moreover, one cannot steal a firearm, or receive or purchase a stolen firearm without also possessing it. There are several other statutes providing for felony punishment for conduct related to firearms possession. For example, felons, narcotic addicts, and those convicted of certain crimes of violence can be prosecuted for a new felony if they own, purchase, receive, possess or have a firearm in their custody or control. (Pen. Code, §§ 29800, subd. (a), and 29900, subd. (a).) Since an ex-felon is prohibited from possessing a firearm, presumably that person would carry it in a concealed manner, either on the person or in a vehicle, thereby committing a separate felony. (Pen. Code, § 25400.) Additionally, if the firearm was loaded and carried on the person or in a vehicle while in any public place or on any public street, that conduct would be punishable as a felony. (Pen. Code, 25850.) Thus, many of the individuals convicted of stealing a firearm, or receiving or purchasing a stolen firearm will also violate another section in the Dangerous Weapons Control Act.[1]
Last year, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) informed the committee that in Fiscal Year 2013/14 the numbers of new admissions with grand theft of a firearm as the principal controlling offense was 37. - California Constitutional Limitations on Amending a Voter Initiative: Because Proposition 47 was a voter initiative, the Legislature may not amend the statute without subsequent voter approval unless the initiative permits such amendment, and then only upon whatever conditions the voters attached to the Legislature's amendatory powers. (People v. Superior Court (Pearson) (2010) 48 Cal.4th 564, 568; see also Cal. Const., art. II, § 10, subd. (c).) The California Constitution states, "The Legislature may amend or repeal referendum statutes. It may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without their approval." (Cal. Const., art. II, § 10, subd. (c).) Therefore, unless the initiative expressly authorizes the Legislature to amend, only the voters may alter statutes created by initiative.
The purpose of California's constitutional limitation on the Legislature's power to amend initiative statutes is to protect the people's initiative powers by precluding the Legislature from undoing what the people have done, without the electorate's consent. Courts have a duty to jealously guard the people's initiative power and, hence, to apply a liberal construction to this power wherever it is challenged in order that the right to resort to the initiative process is not improperly annulled by a legislative body. (Proposition 103 Enforcement Project v. Quackenbush (1998) 64 Cal.App.4th 1473.)
As to the Legislature's authority to amend the initiative, Proposition 47 states: "This act shall be broadly construed to accomplish its purposes. The provisions of this measure may be amended by a two‑thirds vote of the members of each house of the Legislature and signed by the Governor so long as the amendments are consistent with and further the intent of this act. The Legislature may by majority vote amend, add, or repeal provisions to further reduce the penalties for any of the offenses addressed by this act." (<http://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2014/general/pdf/text-of-proposed-laws1.pdf#prop47>.)
If Proposition 47 is deemed not to have changed the punishment for the theft of a firearm, then the provisions of this bill do not amend the initiative, but rather would be consistent with the language and intent of the initiative. On the other hand, if Proposition 47 is interpreted as having reduced the punishment for the theft of a firearm valued at $950 or less, as well as the receipt or purchase of a stolen firearm with the same value, then the change will have to go before the voters for ratification.
This bill, upon its approval by the Legislature, calls for a special election to be held on November 8, 2016, for the voters of California to approve its provisions. - Argument in Support: The California District Attorneys Association, a co-sponsor of this bill, writes, "As we have seen many times over the last year, and as it was plainly put by the 4th District Court of Appeal earlier this year, Proposition 47 'converted receipt of stolen property and grand theft of a firearm into misdemeanors where the value of the stolen property does not exceed $950.' People v. Perkins (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th __ (E062878). Despite assertions to the contrary from the proponents of Proposition 47, it has become quite clear that this was one of the greatest unintended consequences of that initiative.
"Stolen firearms are often used in other serious and violent crimes because they are difficult to trace back to the perpetrator. The Legislature recognized this inherent threat posed by firearms in the hands of criminals, which was why, prior to Prop 47, theft of a firearm was always treated as a felony.
"Under current law, the penalty for stealing a firearm is based wholly on value – as if stealing a $300 gun is somehow ultimately less dangerous than stealing a $951 gun – and thus fundamentally misunderstands why theft of a firearm was ever treated as grand theft in the first place." - Argument in Opposition: The American Civil Liberties Union states, "The voters made their decision after being fully apprised of the arguments now being raised in support of AB 1869. The Official Voter Information Guide, published by the Secretary of State and mailed to every voter in California, specifically explained the following arguments in opposition to the ballot initiative:
• “Stealing any handgun valued at less than $950 will no longer be a felony.”
• “Prop. 47 would eliminate automatic felony prosecution for stealing a gun. Under current law, stealing a gun is a felony, period. Prop. 47 would redefine grand theft in such a way that theft of a firearm could only be considered a felony if the value of the gun is greater than $950. Almost all handguns (which are the most stolen kind of firearm) retail for well below $950. People don’t steal guns just so they can add to their gun collection. They steal guns to commit another crime. People stealing guns are protected under Proposition 47.”
• “Reduces penalties for stealing guns.”
“In response to the arguments against Proposition 47, the Guide provided voters with the following rebuttal argument:
- “Proposition 47 maintains penalties for gun crimes. Under Prop. 47, possessing a stolen concealed gun remains a felony. Additional felony penalties to prevent felons and gang members from obtaining guns also apply.”
"After reviewing the arguments both in favor and against the ballot initiative, the majority of California voters chose to approve Proposition 47. The arguments in favor of the initiative were true in 2014 and remain true today: there are already numerous state and federal laws that impose felony penalties on those who steal guns or use stolen guns to commit crimes. Proposition 47 did nothing to change those laws. California voters understood the decision they made when they approved Proposition 47, and there is no justification for nullifying their decision."
- Related Legislation:
- AB 2369 (Patterson) authorizes the prosecutor to charge a defendant with a felony if the person has been convicted twice or more in a 12-month period of the crimes reduced to a misdemeanor by Proposition 47. AB 2369 also makes it a felony when stolen items include a firearm. AB 2369 is pending referral.
- AB 2854 (Cooper) is substantially similar to this bill, but calls for a special election to be held in June 2016. AB 2854 is pending referral.
- AB 2369 (Patterson) authorizes the prosecutor to charge a defendant with a felony if the person has been convicted twice or more in a 12-month period of the crimes reduced to a misdemeanor by Proposition 47. AB 2369 also makes it a felony when stolen items include a firearm. AB 2369 is pending referral.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 150 (Melendez) of the 2015 Legislative session was substantially similar to this bill. AB 150 was held on the Assembly Appropriation Committee's suspense file.
- Proposition 47 of the November 2014 general election, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes.
- AB 150 (Melendez) of the 2015 Legislative session was substantially similar to this bill. AB 150 was held on the Assembly Appropriation Committee's suspense file.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association (Co-Sponsor)
California Peace Officers Association (Co-Sponsor)
California Police Chiefs Association
California Sportsman's Lobby
California State Sheriffs' Association
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
City of Burbank
City of Indian Wells
Fraternal Order of Police
Gun Owners of California
League of California Cities
Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association
National Rifle Association
National Shooting Sports Foundation
Outdoor Sportsmen's Coalition of California
Riverside County Board of Supervisors
Rural County Representatives of California
Sacramento County Sheriff's Department
San Diego County District Attorney
Safari Club International
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Right to Carry
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Analysis Prepared by:
Under Penal Code section 654, a defendant can be punished only once for multiple convictions involving a single act or omission. (People v. Jones (2012) 54 Cal.4th 350, 358.) However, Penal Code section 654 does not bar multiple punishment for multiple violations of the same criminal statute. (People v. Correa (2012) 54 Cal.4th 331, 334.) ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):