AB 2101: Sanctions: jurors.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-01
Existing law authorizes a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For purposes of this provision, the term person includes a witness, a party, or a partys attorney.
Existing law requires that certain fees and fines collected by superior courts, including the money sanctions described above, be deposited into a bank account established by the Administrative Office of the Courts for distribution, as specified, with the balance transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law.
This bill would require the Judicial Council to solicit courts for participation in a pilot project in which judicial officers of participating counties would be authorized by the bill to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order, done without good cause or substantial justification, that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. The bill would require that these monetary sanctions be deposited into a bank account for distribution, as described above, with the balance deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds. The bill would require the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results to the Governor and the Legislature on or before January 1, 2021. The bill would repeal these provisions on January 1, 2022.
Existing law authorizes a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For purposes of this provision, the term person includes a witness, a party, or a partys attorney.
Existing law requires that certain fees and fines collected by superior courts, including the money sanctions described above, be deposited into a bank account established by the Administrative Office of the Courts for distribution, as specified, with the balance transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law.
This bill would require the Judicial Council to solicit courts for participation in a pilot project in which judicial officers of participating counties would be authorized by the bill to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order order, done without good cause or substantial justification justification, that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. The bill would require that these monetary sanctions be deposited into a bank account for distribution, as described above, with the balance deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds. The bill would require the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results to the Governor and the Legislature on or before July January 1, 2021. The bill would repeal these provisions on January 1, 2022.
Existing law authorizes a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For purposes of this provision, the term person includes a witness, a party, or a partys attorney.
This bill would provide that the term person also includes a juror. The bill would make other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
This bill would require the Judicial Council to solicit courts for participation in a pilot project in which judicial officers of participating counties would be authorized by the bill to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. The bill would require the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results to the Governor and the Legislature on or before July 1, 2021. The bill would repeal these provisions on January 1, 2022.
Existing law authorizes a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For purposes of this provision, the term person includes a witness, a party, or a partys attorney.
This bill would provide that the term person also includes a juror. The bill would make other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a judicial officer of a court selected pursuant to subdivision (c) for participation in the pilot project established pursuant to this section may impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed one thousand five hundred dollars ($1,500), payable to the court, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order, done without good cause or substantial justification, that is supported by clear and convincing evidence.
(b)Sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section except on notice contained in a partys moving or responding papers, or on the courts own motion, after notice and an opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
(c)On or before July 1, 2017, the Judicial Council shall solicit the participation of a representative sample of courts, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by the council, for participation in a pilot project to evaluate the effectiveness of this section. This section applies only to those courts participating in the pilot project.
(d)The Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project established pursuant to this section and shall report the results of the pilot project to the Governor and the Legislature on or before January 1, 2021. The report shall also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2022, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 68085.1 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 19 of Chapter 41 of the Statutes of 2012, is amended to read:68085.1.(a)This section applies to all fees and fines that are collected on or after January 1, 2006, under all of the following:
(1)Sections 177.5, 177.6, 209, 403.060, 491.150, 631.3, 683.150, 704.750, 708.160, 724.100, 1134, 1161.2, 1218, and 1993.2 of, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20 and subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 411.21 of, subdivision (b) of Section 631 of, and Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 116.110) of Title 1 of Part 1 of, the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)Section 3112 of the Family Code.
(3)Section 31622 of the Food and Agricultural Code.
(4)Subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, Sections 68086 and 68086.1, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3, Sections 68926.1 and 69953.5, and Chapter 5.8 (commencing with Section 70600).
(5)Section 103470 of the Health and Safety Code.
(6)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 166 and Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code.
(7)Sections 1835, 1851.5, 2343, 7660, and 13201 of the Probate Code.
(8)Sections 14607.6 and 16373 of the Vehicle Code.
(9)Section 71386 of this code, Sections 304, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, and Section 1513.1 of the Probate Code, if the reimbursement is for expenses incurred by the court.
(10)Section 3153 of the Family Code, if the amount is paid to the court for the cost of counsel appointed by the court to represent a child.
(b)On and after January 1, 2006, each superior court shall deposit all fees and fines listed in subdivision (a), as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis, into a bank account established for this purpose by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Upon direction of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the county shall deposit civil assessments under Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code and any other money it collects under the sections listed in subdivision (a) as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis into the bank account established for this purpose and specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The deposits shall be made as required by rules adopted by, and financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council under subdivision (a) of Section 77206. Within 15 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected, each court, and each county that collects any fines or fees under subdivision (a), shall provide the Administrative Office of the Courts with a report of the fees by categories as specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The Administrative Office of the Courts and any court may agree upon a time period greater than 15 days, but in no case more than 30 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected. The fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) shall be distributed as provided in this section.
(c)(1)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall make the following distributions:
(A)To the small claims advisory services, as described in subdivision (f) of Section 116.230 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)To dispute resolution programs, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4.
(C)To the county law library funds, as described in Sections 116.230 and 116.760 of the Code of Civil Procedure, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4, and Section 70621 of this code, and Section 14607.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)To the courthouse construction funds in the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Francisco, as described in Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625.
(2)If any distribution under this subdivision is delinquent, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall add a penalty to the distribution as specified in subdivision (i).
(d)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the amounts remaining after the distributions in subdivision (c) shall be transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law. This remittance shall be accompanied by a remittance advice identifying the collection month and the appropriate account in the Trial Court Trust Fund or other fund to which it is to be deposited. Upon the receipt of any delinquent payment required under this subdivision, the Controller shall calculate a penalty as provided under subdivision (i).
(e)From the money transmitted to the State Treasury under subdivision (d), the Controller shall make deposits as follows:
(1)Into the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, the Judges Retirement Fund, and the Equal Access Fund, as described in subdivision (c) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (c) of Section 68085.4.
(2)Into the Health Statistics Special Fund, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 70670 of this code and Section 103730 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Into the Family Law Trust Fund, as described in Section 70674.
(4)Into the Immediate and Critical Needs Account of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, established in Section 70371.5, as described in Sections 68085.3, 68085.4, and 70657.5, and subdivision (e) of Section 70617.
(5)The remainder of the money shall be deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund.
(f)The amounts collected by each superior court under Section 116.232, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20, and subdivision (g) of Section 411.21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Sections 304, 3112, 3153, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3 and Sections 68926.1, 69953.5, 70627, 70631, 70640, 70661, 70678, and 71386 of this code, and Sections 1513.1, 1835, 1851.5, and 2343 of the Probate Code shall be added to the monthly apportionment for that court under subdivision (a) of Section 68085.
(g)If any of the fees provided in subdivision (a) are partially waived by court order or otherwise reduced, and the fee is to be divided between the Trial Court Trust Fund and any other fund or account, the amount of the reduction shall be deducted from the amount to be distributed to each fund in the same proportion as the amount of each distribution bears to the total amount of the fee. If the fee is paid by installment payments, the amount distributed to each fund or account from each installment shall bear the same proportion to the installment payment as the full distribution to that fund or account does to the full fee. If a court collects a fee that was incurred before January 1, 2006, under a provision that was the predecessor to one of the paragraphs contained in subdivision (a), the fee may be deposited as if it were collected under the paragraph of subdivision (a) that corresponds to the predecessor of that paragraph and distributed in prorated amounts to each fund or account to which the fee in subdivision (a) must be distributed.
(h)Except as provided in Sections 470.5 and 6322.1 of the Business and Professions Code, and Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625 of this code, no agency may take action to change the amounts allocated to any of the funds described in subdivision (c), (d), or (e).
(i)The amount of the penalty on any delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) shall be calculated by multiplying the amount of the delinquent payment at a daily rate equivalent to 11/2 percent per month for the number of days the payment is delinquent. The penalty shall be paid from the Trial Court Trust Fund. Penalties on delinquent payments under subdivision (d) shall be calculated only on the amounts to be distributed to the Trial Court Trust Fund and the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, and each penalty shall be distributed proportionately to the funds to which the delinquent payment was to be distributed.
(j)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a superior court under subdivision (b), the court shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. Notwithstanding Section 77009, any penalty on a delinquent payment that a court is required to reimburse pursuant to this section shall be paid from the court operations fund for that court. The penalty shall be paid by the court to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated. If the penalty is not paid within the specified time, the Administrative Office of the Courts may reduce the amount of a subsequent monthly allocation to the court by the amount of the penalty on the delinquent payment.
(k)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a county in transmitting fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) to the bank account established for this purpose, as described in subdivision (b), the county shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. The penalty shall be paid by the county to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated.
(l)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.Section 68085.1 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 22 of Chapter 913 of the Statutes of 2014, is amended to read:68085.1.(a)This section applies to all fees and fines that are collected on or after January 1, 2006, under all of the following:
(1)Sections 177.5, 177.6, 209, 403.060, 491.150, 631.3, 683.150, 704.750, 708.160, 724.100, 1134, 1161.2, 1218, and 1993.2 of, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20 and subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 411.21 of, subdivision (b) of Section 631 of, and Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 116.110) of Title 1 of Part 1 of, the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)Section 3112 of the Family Code.
(3)Section 31622 of the Food and Agricultural Code.
(4)Subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, Sections 68086 and 68086.1, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3, Sections 68926.1 and 69953.5, and Chapter 5.8 (commencing with Section 70600).
(5)Section 103470 of the Health and Safety Code.
(6)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 166 and Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code.
(7)Sections 1835, 1851.5, 2343, 7660, and 13201 of the Probate Code.
(8)Sections 14607.6 and 16373 of the Vehicle Code.
(9)Section 71386 of this code, Sections 304, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, and Section 1513.1 of the Probate Code, if the reimbursement is for expenses incurred by the court.
(10)Section 3153 of the Family Code, if the amount is paid to the court for the cost of counsel appointed by the court to represent a child.
(b)On and after January 1, 2006, each superior court shall deposit all fees and fines listed in subdivision (a), as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis, into a bank account established for this purpose by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Upon direction of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the county shall deposit civil assessments under Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code and any other money it collects under the sections listed in subdivision (a) as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis into the bank account established for this purpose and specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The deposits shall be made as required by rules adopted by, and financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council under subdivision (a) of Section 77206. Within 15 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected, each court, and each county that collects any fines or fees under subdivision (a), shall provide the Administrative Office of the Courts with a report of the fees by categories as specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The Administrative Office of the Courts and any court may agree upon a time period greater than 15 days, but in no case more than 30 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected. The fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) shall be distributed as provided in this section.
(c)(1)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall make the following distributions:
(A)To the small claims advisory services, as described in subdivision (f) of Section 116.230 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)To dispute resolution programs, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4.
(C)To the county law library funds, as described in Sections 116.230 and 116.760 of the Code of Civil Procedure, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4, and Section 70621 of this code, and Section 14607.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)To the courthouse construction funds in the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Francisco, as described in Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625.
(E)Commencing July 1, 2011, to the Trial Court Trust Fund, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 70626, to be used by the Judicial Council to implement and administer the civil representation pilot program under Section 68651.
(2)If any distribution under this subdivision is delinquent, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall add a penalty to the distribution as specified in subdivision (i).
(d)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the amounts remaining after the distributions in subdivision (c) shall be transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law. This remittance shall be accompanied by a remittance advice identifying the collection month and the appropriate account in the Trial Court Trust Fund or other fund to which it is to be deposited. Upon the receipt of any delinquent payment required under this subdivision, the Controller shall calculate a penalty as provided under subdivision (i).
(e)From the money transmitted to the State Treasury under subdivision (d), the Controller shall make deposits as follows:
(1)Into the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, the Judges Retirement Fund, and the Equal Access Fund, as described in subdivision (c) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (c) of Section 68085.4.
(2)Into the Health Statistics Special Fund, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 70670 of this code and Section 103730 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Into the Family Law Trust Fund, as described in Section 70674.
(4)Into the Immediate and Critical Needs Account of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, established in Section 70371.5, as described in Sections 68085.3, 68085.4, and 70657.5, and subdivision (e) of Section 70617.
(5)The remainder of the money shall be deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund.
(f)The amounts collected by each superior court under Section 116.232, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20, and subdivision (g) of Section 411.21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Sections 304, 3112, 3153, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3 and Sections 68926.1, 69953.5, 70627, 70631, 70640, 70661, 70678, and 71386 of this code, and Sections 1513.1, 1835, 1851.5, and 2343 of the Probate Code shall be added to the monthly apportionment for that court under subdivision (a) of Section 68085.
(g)If any of the fees provided in subdivision (a) are partially waived by court order or otherwise reduced, and the fee is to be divided between the Trial Court Trust Fund and any other fund or account, the amount of the reduction shall be deducted from the amount to be distributed to each fund in the same proportion as the amount of each distribution bears to the total amount of the fee. If the fee is paid by installment payments, the amount distributed to each fund or account from each installment shall bear the same proportion to the installment payment as the full distribution to that fund or account does to the full fee. If a court collects a fee that was incurred before January 1, 2006, under a provision that was the predecessor to one of the paragraphs contained in subdivision (a), the fee may be deposited as if it were collected under the paragraph of subdivision (a) that corresponds to the predecessor of that paragraph and distributed in prorated amounts to each fund or account to which the fee in subdivision (a) must be distributed.
(h)Except as provided in Sections 470.5 and 6322.1 of the Business and Professions Code, and Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625 of this code, an agency shall not take action to change the amounts allocated to any of the funds described in subdivision (c), (d), or (e).
(i)The amount of the penalty on any delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) shall be calculated by multiplying the amount of the delinquent payment at a daily rate equivalent to 11/2 percent per month for the number of days the payment is delinquent. The penalty shall be paid from the Trial Court Trust Fund. Penalties on delinquent payments under subdivision (d) shall be calculated only on the amounts to be distributed to the Trial Court Trust Fund and the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, and each penalty shall be distributed proportionately to the funds to which the delinquent payment was to be distributed.
(j)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a superior court under subdivision (b), the court shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. Notwithstanding Section 77009, any penalty on a delinquent payment that a court is required to reimburse pursuant to this section shall be paid from the court operations fund for that court. The penalty shall be paid by the court to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated. If the penalty is not paid within the specified time, the Administrative Office of the Courts may reduce the amount of a subsequent monthly allocation to the court by the amount of the penalty on the delinquent payment.
(k)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a county in transmitting fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) to the bank account established for this purpose, as described in subdivision (b), the county shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. The penalty shall be paid by the county to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated.
(l)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 68085.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:68085.1.(a)This section applies to all fees and fines that are collected on or after January 1, 2006, under all of the following:
(1)Sections 177.5, 177.6, 209, 403.060, 491.150, 631.3, 683.150, 704.750, 708.160, 724.100, 1134, 1161.2, 1218, and 1993.2 of, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20 and subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 411.21 of, subdivision (b) of Section 631 of, and Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 116.110) of Title 1 of Part 1 of, the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)Section 3112 of the Family Code.
(3)Section 31622 of the Food and Agricultural Code.
(4)Subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, Sections 68086 and 68086.1, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3, Sections 68926.1 and 69953.5, and Chapter 5.8 (commencing with Section 70600).
(5)Section 103470 of the Health and Safety Code.
(6)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 166 and Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code.
(7)Sections 1835, 1851.5, 2343, 7660, and 13201 of the Probate Code.
(8)Sections 14607.6 and 16373 of the Vehicle Code.
(9)Section 71386 of this code, Sections 304, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, and Section 1513.1 of the Probate Code, if the reimbursement is for expenses incurred by the court.
(10)Section 3153 of the Family Code, if the amount is paid to the court for the cost of counsel appointed by the court to represent a child.
(b)On and after January 1, 2006, each superior court shall deposit all fees and fines listed in subdivision (a), as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis, into a bank account established for this purpose by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Upon direction of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the county shall deposit civil assessments under Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code and any other money it collects under the sections listed in subdivision (a) as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis into the bank account established for this purpose and specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The deposits shall be made as required by rules adopted by, and financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council under subdivision (a) of Section 77206. Within 15 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected, each court, and each county that collects any fines or fees under subdivision (a), shall provide the Administrative Office of the Courts with a report of the fees by categories as specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The Administrative Office of the Courts and any court may agree upon a time period greater than 15 days, but in no case more than 30 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected. The fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) shall be distributed as provided in this section.
(c)(1)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall make the following distributions:
(A)To the small claims advisory services, as described in subdivision (f) of Section 116.230 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)To dispute resolution programs, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4.
(C)To the county law library funds, as described in Sections 116.230 and 116.760 of the Code of Civil Procedure, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4, and Section 70621 of this code, and Section 14607.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)To the courthouse construction funds in the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Francisco, as described in Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625.
(E)Commencing July 1, 2011, to the Trial Court Trust Fund, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 70626, to be used by the Judicial Council to implement and administer the civil representation pilot program under Section 68651.
(2)If any distribution under this subdivision is delinquent, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall add a penalty to the distribution as specified in subdivision (i).
(d)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the amounts remaining after the distributions in subdivision (c) shall be transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law. This remittance shall be accompanied by a remittance advice identifying the collection month and the appropriate account in the Trial Court Trust Fund or other fund to which it is to be deposited. Upon the receipt of any delinquent payment required under this subdivision, the Controller shall calculate a penalty as provided under subdivision (i).
(e)From the money transmitted to the State Treasury under subdivision (d), the Controller shall make deposits as follows:
(1)Into the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, the Judges Retirement Fund, and the Equal Access Fund, as described in subdivision (c) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (c) of Section 68085.4.
(2)Into the Health Statistics Special Fund, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 70670 of this code and Section 103730 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Into the Family Law Trust Fund, as described in Section 70674.
(4)Into the Immediate and Critical Needs Account of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, established in Section 70371.5, as described in Sections 68085.3, 68085.4, and 70657.5, and subdivision (e) of Section 70617.
(5)The remainder of the money shall be deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund.
(f)The amounts collected by each superior court under Section 116.232, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20, and subdivision (g) of Section 411.21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Sections 304, 3112, 3153, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3 and Sections 68926.1, 69953.5, 70627, 70631, 70640, 70661, 70678, and 71386 of this code, and Sections 1513.1, 1835, 1851.5, and 2343 of the Probate Code shall be added to the monthly apportionment for that court under subdivision (a) of Section 68085.
(g)If any of the fees provided in subdivision (a) are partially waived by court order or otherwise reduced, and the fee is to be divided between the Trial Court Trust Fund and any other fund or account, the amount of the reduction shall be deducted from the amount to be distributed to each fund in the same proportion as the amount of each distribution bears to the total amount of the fee. If the fee is paid by installment payments, the amount distributed to each fund or account from each installment shall bear the same proportion to the installment payment as the full distribution to that fund or account does to the full fee. If a court collects a fee that was incurred before January 1, 2006, under a provision that was the predecessor to one of the paragraphs contained in subdivision (a), the fee may be deposited as if it were collected under the paragraph of subdivision (a) that corresponds to the predecessor of that paragraph and distributed in prorated amounts to each fund or account to which the fee in subdivision (a) must be distributed.
(h)Except as provided in Sections 470.5 and 6322.1 of the Business and Professions Code, and Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625 of this code, an agency shall not take action to change the amounts allocated to any of the funds described in subdivision (c), (d), or (e).
(i)The amount of the penalty on any delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) shall be calculated by multiplying the amount of the delinquent payment at a daily rate equivalent to 11/2 percent per month for the number of days the payment is delinquent. The penalty shall be paid from the Trial Court Trust Fund. Penalties on delinquent payments under subdivision (d) shall be calculated only on the amounts to be distributed to the Trial Court Trust Fund and the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, and each penalty shall be distributed proportionately to the funds to which the delinquent payment was to be distributed.
(j)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a superior court under subdivision (b), the court shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. Notwithstanding Section 77009, any penalty on a delinquent payment that a court is required to reimburse pursuant to this section shall be paid from the court operations fund for that court. The penalty shall be paid by the court to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated. If the penalty is not paid within the specified time, the Administrative Office of the Courts may reduce the amount of a subsequent monthly allocation to the court by the amount of the penalty on the delinquent payment.
(k)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a county in transmitting fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) to the bank account established for this purpose, as described in subdivision (b), the county shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. The penalty shall be paid by the county to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a judicial officer of a court selected pursuant to subdivision (c) for participation in the pilot project established pursuant to this section may impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed one thousand five hundred dollars ($1,500), payable to the court, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order order, done without good cause or substantial justification justification, that is supported by clear and convincing evidence.
(b)Sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section except on notice contained in a partys moving or responding papers, or on the courts own motion, after notice and an opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
(c)On or before July 1, 2017, the Judicial Council shall solicit the participation of a representative sample of courts, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by the council, for participation in a pilot project to evaluate the effectiveness of this section. This section applies only to those courts participating in the pilot project.
(d)The Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project established pursuant to this section and shall report the results of the pilot project to the Governor and the Legislature on or before July January 1, 2021. The report shall also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2022, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 68085.1 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 19 of Chapter 41 of the Statutes of 2012, is amended to read:68085.1.(a)This section applies to all fees and fines that are collected on or after January 1, 2006, under all of the following:
(1)Sections 177.5, 177.6, 209, 403.060, 491.150, 631.3, 683.150, 704.750, 708.160, 724.100, 1134, 1161.2, 1218, and 1993.2 of, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20 and subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 411.21 of, subdivision (b) of Section 631 of, and Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 116.110) of Title 1 of Part 1 of, the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)Section 3112 of the Family Code.
(3)Section 31622 of the Food and Agricultural Code.
(4)Subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, Sections 68086 and 68086.1, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3, Sections 68926.1 and 69953.5, and Chapter 5.8 (commencing with Section 70600).
(5)Section 103470 of the Health and Safety Code.
(6)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 166 and Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code.
(7)Sections 1835, 1851.5, 2343, 7660, and 13201 of the Probate Code.
(8)Sections 14607.6 and 16373 of the Vehicle Code.
(9)Section 71386 of this code, Sections 304, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, and Section 1513.1 of the Probate Code, if the reimbursement is for expenses incurred by the court.
(10)Section 3153 of the Family Code, if the amount is paid to the court for the cost of counsel appointed by the court to represent a child.
(b)On and after January 1, 2006, each superior court shall deposit all fees and fines listed in subdivision (a), as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis, into a bank account established for this purpose by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Upon direction of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the county shall deposit civil assessments under Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code and any other money it collects under the sections listed in subdivision (a) as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis into the bank account established for this purpose and specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The deposits shall be made as required by rules adopted by, and financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council under subdivision (a) of Section 77206. Within 15 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected, each court, and each county that collects any fines or fees under subdivision (a), shall provide the Administrative Office of the Courts with a report of the fees by categories as specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The Administrative Office of the Courts and any court may agree upon a time period greater than 15 days, but in no case more than 30 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected. The fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) shall be distributed as provided in this section.
(c)(1)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall make the following distributions:
(A)To the small claims advisory services, as described in subdivision (f) of Section 116.230 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)To dispute resolution programs, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4.
(C)To the county law library funds, as described in Sections 116.230 and 116.760 of the Code of Civil Procedure, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4, and Section 70621 of this code, and Section 14607.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)To the courthouse construction funds in the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Francisco, as described in Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625.
(2)If any distribution under this subdivision is delinquent, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall add a penalty to the distribution as specified in subdivision (i).
(d)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the amounts remaining after the distributions in subdivision (c) shall be transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law. This remittance shall be accompanied by a remittance advice identifying the collection month and the appropriate account in the Trial Court Trust Fund or other fund to which it is to be deposited. Upon the receipt of any delinquent payment required under this subdivision, the Controller shall calculate a penalty as provided under subdivision (i).
(e)From the money transmitted to the State Treasury under subdivision (d), the Controller shall make deposits as follows:
(1)Into the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, the Judges Retirement Fund, and the Equal Access Fund, as described in subdivision (c) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (c) of Section 68085.4.
(2)Into the Health Statistics Special Fund, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 70670 of this code and Section 103730 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Into the Family Law Trust Fund, as described in Section 70674.
(4)Into the Immediate and Critical Needs Account of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, established in Section 70371.5, as described in Sections 68085.3, 68085.4, and 70657.5, and subdivision (e) of Section 70617.
(5)The remainder of the money shall be deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund.
(f)The amounts collected by each superior court under Section 116.232, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20, and subdivision (g) of Section 411.21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Sections 304, 3112, 3153, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3 and Sections 68926.1, 69953.5, 70627, 70631, 70640, 70661, 70678, and 71386 of this code, and Sections 1513.1, 1835, 1851.5, and 2343 of the Probate Code shall be added to the monthly apportionment for that court under subdivision (a) of Section 68085.
(g)If any of the fees provided in subdivision (a) are partially waived by court order or otherwise reduced, and the fee is to be divided between the Trial Court Trust Fund and any other fund or account, the amount of the reduction shall be deducted from the amount to be distributed to each fund in the same proportion as the amount of each distribution bears to the total amount of the fee. If the fee is paid by installment payments, the amount distributed to each fund or account from each installment shall bear the same proportion to the installment payment as the full distribution to that fund or account does to the full fee. If a court collects a fee that was incurred before January 1, 2006, under a provision that was the predecessor to one of the paragraphs contained in subdivision (a), the fee may be deposited as if it were collected under the paragraph of subdivision (a) that corresponds to the predecessor of that paragraph and distributed in prorated amounts to each fund or account to which the fee in subdivision (a) must be distributed.
(h)Except as provided in Sections 470.5 and 6322.1 of the Business and Professions Code, and Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625 of this code, no agency may take action to change the amounts allocated to any of the funds described in subdivision (c), (d), or (e).
(i)The amount of the penalty on any delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) shall be calculated by multiplying the amount of the delinquent payment at a daily rate equivalent to 11/2 percent per month for the number of days the payment is delinquent. The penalty shall be paid from the Trial Court Trust Fund. Penalties on delinquent payments under subdivision (d) shall be calculated only on the amounts to be distributed to the Trial Court Trust Fund and the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, and each penalty shall be distributed proportionately to the funds to which the delinquent payment was to be distributed.
(j)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a superior court under subdivision (b), the court shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. Notwithstanding Section 77009, any penalty on a delinquent payment that a court is required to reimburse pursuant to this section shall be paid from the court operations fund for that court. The penalty shall be paid by the court to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated. If the penalty is not paid within the specified time, the Administrative Office of the Courts may reduce the amount of a subsequent monthly allocation to the court by the amount of the penalty on the delinquent payment.
(k)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a county in transmitting fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) to the bank account established for this purpose, as described in subdivision (b), the county shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. The penalty shall be paid by the county to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated.
(l)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.Section 68085.1 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 22 of Chapter 913 of the Statutes of 2014, is amended to read:68085.1.(a)This section applies to all fees and fines that are collected on or after January 1, 2006, under all of the following:
(1)Sections 177.5, 177.6, 209, 403.060, 491.150, 631.3, 683.150, 704.750, 708.160, 724.100, 1134, 1161.2, 1218, and 1993.2 of, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20 and subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 411.21 of, subdivision (b) of Section 631 of, and Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 116.110) of Title 1 of Part 1 of, the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)Section 3112 of the Family Code.
(3)Section 31622 of the Food and Agricultural Code.
(4)Subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, Sections 68086 and 68086.1, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3, Sections 68926.1 and 69953.5, and Chapter 5.8 (commencing with Section 70600).
(5)Section 103470 of the Health and Safety Code.
(6)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 166 and Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code.
(7)Sections 1835, 1851.5, 2343, 7660, and 13201 of the Probate Code.
(8)Sections 14607.6 and 16373 of the Vehicle Code.
(9)Section 71386 of this code, Sections 304, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, and Section 1513.1 of the Probate Code, if the reimbursement is for expenses incurred by the court.
(10)Section 3153 of the Family Code, if the amount is paid to the court for the cost of counsel appointed by the court to represent a child.
(b)On and after January 1, 2006, each superior court shall deposit all fees and fines listed in subdivision (a), as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis, into a bank account established for this purpose by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Upon direction of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the county shall deposit civil assessments under Section 1214.1 of the Penal Code and any other money it collects under the sections listed in subdivision (a) as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis into the bank account established for this purpose and specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The deposits shall be made as required by rules adopted by, and financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council under subdivision (a) of Section 77206. Within 15 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected, each court, and each county that collects any fines or fees under subdivision (a), shall provide the Administrative Office of the Courts with a report of the fees by categories as specified by the Administrative Office of the Courts. The Administrative Office of the Courts and any court may agree upon a time period greater than 15 days, but in no case more than 30 days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines are collected. The fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) shall be distributed as provided in this section.
(c)(1)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall make the following distributions:
(A)To the small claims advisory services, as described in subdivision (f) of Section 116.230 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)To dispute resolution programs, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4.
(C)To the county law library funds, as described in Sections 116.230 and 116.760 of the Code of Civil Procedure, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.3, subdivision (b) of Section 68085.4, and Section 70621 of this code, and Section 14607.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)To the courthouse construction funds in the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Francisco, as described in Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625.
(E)Commencing July 1, 2011, to the Trial Court Trust Fund, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 70626, to be used by the Judicial Council to implement and administer the civil representation pilot program under Section 68651.
(2)If any distribution under this subdivision is delinquent, the Administrative Office of the Courts shall add a penalty to the distribution as specified in subdivision (i).
(d)Within 45 calendar days after the end of the month in which the fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) are collected, the amounts remaining after the distributions in subdivision (c) shall be transmitted to the State Treasury for deposit in the Trial Court Trust Fund and other funds as required by law. This remittance shall be accompanied by a remittance advice identifying the collection month and the appropriate account in the Trial Court Trust Fund or other fund to which it is to be deposited. Upon the receipt of any delinquent payment required under this subdivision, the Controller shall calculate a penalty as provided under subdivision (i).
(e)From the money transmitted to the State Treasury under subdivision (d), the Controller shall make deposits as follows:
(1)Into the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, the Judges Retirement Fund, and the Equal Access Fund, as described in subdivision (c) of Section 68085.3 and subdivision (c) of Section 68085.4.
(2)Into the Health Statistics Special Fund, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 70670 of this code and Section 103730 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Into the Family Law Trust Fund, as described in Section 70674.
(4)Into the Immediate and Critical Needs Account of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, established in Section 70371.5, as described in Sections 68085.3, 68085.4, and 70657.5, and subdivision (e) of Section 70617.
(5)The remainder of the money shall be deposited into the Trial Court Trust Fund.
(f)The amounts collected by each superior court under Section 116.232, subdivision (g) of Section 411.20, and subdivision (g) of Section 411.21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Sections 304, 3112, 3153, 7851.5, and 9002 of the Family Code, subdivision (d) of Section 6103.5, subdivision (d) of Section 68511.3 and Sections 68926.1, 69953.5, 70627, 70631, 70640, 70661, 70678, and 71386 of this code, and Sections 1513.1, 1835, 1851.5, and 2343 of the Probate Code shall be added to the monthly apportionment for that court under subdivision (a) of Section 68085.
(g)If any of the fees provided in subdivision (a) are partially waived by court order or otherwise reduced, and the fee is to be divided between the Trial Court Trust Fund and any other fund or account, the amount of the reduction shall be deducted from the amount to be distributed to each fund in the same proportion as the amount of each distribution bears to the total amount of the fee. If the fee is paid by installment payments, the amount distributed to each fund or account from each installment shall bear the same proportion to the installment payment as the full distribution to that fund or account does to the full fee. If a court collects a fee that was incurred before January 1, 2006, under a provision that was the predecessor to one of the paragraphs contained in subdivision (a), the fee may be deposited as if it were collected under the paragraph of subdivision (a) that corresponds to the predecessor of that paragraph and distributed in prorated amounts to each fund or account to which the fee in subdivision (a) must be distributed.
(h)Except as provided in Sections 470.5 and 6322.1 of the Business and Professions Code, and Sections 70622, 70624, and 70625 of this code, an agency shall not take action to change the amounts allocated to any of the funds described in subdivision (c), (d), or (e).
(i)The amount of the penalty on any delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) shall be calculated by multiplying the amount of the delinquent payment at a daily rate equivalent to 11/2 percent per month for the number of days the payment is delinquent. The penalty shall be paid from the Trial Court Trust Fund. Penalties on delinquent payments under subdivision (d) shall be calculated only on the amounts to be distributed to the Trial Court Trust Fund and the State Court Facilities Construction Fund, and each penalty shall be distributed proportionately to the funds to which the delinquent payment was to be distributed.
(j)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a superior court under subdivision (b), the court shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. Notwithstanding Section 77009, any penalty on a delinquent payment that a court is required to reimburse pursuant to this section shall be paid from the court operations fund for that court. The penalty shall be paid by the court to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated. If the penalty is not paid within the specified time, the Administrative Office of the Courts may reduce the amount of a subsequent monthly allocation to the court by the amount of the penalty on the delinquent payment.
(k)If a delinquent payment under subdivision (c) or (d) results from a delinquency by a county in transmitting fees and fines listed in subdivision (a) to the bank account established for this purpose, as described in subdivision (b), the county shall reimburse the Trial Court Trust Fund for the amount of the penalty. The penalty shall be paid by the county to the Trial Court Trust Fund no later than 45 days after the end of the month in which the penalty was calculated.
(l)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a judicial officer of a court selected pursuant to subdivision (c) for participation in the pilot project established pursuant to this section may impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed one thousand five hundred dollars ($1,500), payable to the court, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence.
(b)Sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section except on notice contained in a partys moving or responding papers, or on the courts own motion, after notice and an opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
(c)On or before July 1, 2017, the Judicial Council shall solicit the participation of a representative sample of courts, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by the council, for participation in a pilot project to evaluate the effectiveness of this section. This section applies only to those courts participating in the pilot project.
(d)The Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project established pursuant to this section and shall report the results of the pilot project to the Governor and the Legislature on or before July 1, 2021. The report shall also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2022, deletes or extends that date.
SECTION 1.Section 177.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:177.5.(a)A judicial officer shall have the power to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed fifteen hundred dollars ($1,500), notwithstanding any other provision of law, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. This power shall not apply to advocacy of counsel before the court. For the purposes of this section, the term person includes a witness, a juror, a party, or a partys attorney.
(b)Sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section except on notice contained in a partys moving or responding papers, or on the courts own motion, after notice and opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
(a)A judicial officer shall have the power to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed fifteen hundred dollars ($1,500), notwithstanding any other provision of law, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. This power shall not apply to advocacy of counsel before the court. For the purposes of this section, the term person includes a witness, a juror, a party, or a partys attorney, or both. attorney.
Sanctions
(b)Sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section shall not be imposed except on notice contained in a partys moving or responding papers; papers, or on the courts own motion, after notice and opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 28, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 14). |
| May 5, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 28, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0.) |
| Apr 28, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 4594.) |
| Feb 17, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
| Apr 28, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 21, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 20). |
| Apr 5, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 5). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 4, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 31, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 29, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 1, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 28, 2016 | AB 2101 GORDON Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 20, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 5, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Judicial Council of California | ** Support | Apr 5, 2016 |
| Placer County | * Support | Apr 5, 2016 |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2101 (Gordon) - Sanctions: jurors
Version: August 1, 2016 | Policy Vote: JUD. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 1, 2016 | Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 2101 would establish a five-year pilot project authorizing a judicial officer of a participating court, as specified, to impose reasonable monetary sanctions of up to $1,500 on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order, as specified. This bill would require the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results of the pilot to the Governor and the Legislature on or before January 1, 2021. The report shall also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty.
Fiscal Impact:
- Pilot courts: Potential minor administrative costs to administer the monetary sanction policy. Potential future cost savings (General Fund*) to the participating courts to the extent courts impose monetary sanctions in lieu of initiating actions against jurors through civil contempt proceedings.
- Pilot project evaluation: One-time costs to the Judicial Council potentially in excess of $50,000 (General Fund*) to solicit program participants, collect pilot project data, evaluate the pilot project, and report to the Legislature and the Governor, including an evaluation of whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. As the bill does not effectively limit the number of courts or the number of counties participating in the pilot, the workload required to evaluate the “pilot” project could vary widely.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Existing law provides, generally, that a judicial officer has the power to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For these purposes, “person” includes a witness, a party, a party’s attorney, or both. Existing law provides that such sanctions shall not be imposed except on notice contained in a party’s moving or responding papers; or on the court’s own motion, after notice and opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order. (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) § 177.5.)
Notwithstanding the judicial officer authority to impose monetary sanctions for violations of a lawful court order by a person, the definition of “person” under existing law does not include an impaneled juror.
Juror misconduct constitutes numerous activities that take place during a trial, including but not limited to discussing a case with other jurors, talking with members of either party of a case, researching evidence outside of the court, and utilizing social media to discuss the case. Under existing law, accountability for juror misconduct may be addressed by holding the juror in civil contempt of the court.
With respect to juror misconduct, existing law provides the following acts or omissions in respect to a court of justice, or proceedings therein, are contempts of the authority of the court:
- Willful disobedience by a juror of a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research.
- When summoned as a juror in a court, neglecting to attend or serve as a juror, or improperly conversing with a party to an action to be tried at the court, or with any other person, in relation to the merits of the action, or receiving a communication from a party or other person in respect to the action, without immediately disclosing the communication to the court. (CCP § 1209 (a)(6), (a)(11).)
Under existing law, the court or judge determines whether the person proceeded against is guilty of the contempt charged, and if it be adjudged that he or she is guilty of the contempt, a fine may be imposed on him or her not exceeding $1,000, payable to the court, or he or she may be imprisoned not exceeding five days, or both. (CCP § 1218 (a).)
Proposed Law:
This bill would authorize a judicial officer of a court in a pilot established pursuant to this section to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order, done without good cause or substantial justification, that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. This bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2017, to solicit the participation of a representative sample of courts, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by the Council, for participation in a pilot project to evaluate the effectiveness of this bill. This bill would specify that it applies only to those courts participating in the pilot project.
- Provides that sanctions shall not be imposed pursuant to this section except on notice contained in a party’s moving or responding papers, or on the court’s own motion, after notice and an opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
- Requires the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results of the pilot project to the Governor and the Legislature on or before January 1, 2021. The report shall also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty.
- Sunsets the bill’s provisions on January 1, 2022.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2683 (Cooley) Chapter 99/2014 deleted the Penal Code provision that made it a criminal contempt of court (a misdemeanor) for a juror to willfully disobey a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research.
AB 141 (Fuentes) Chapter 181/2011 made the willful disobedience by a juror of a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research, punishable as either a civil or criminal contempt of court pursuant to those provisions.
AB 2217 (Fuentes) 2010 was substantially similar to AB 141. This bill was vetoed by the Governor will the following message:
I am returning Assembly Bill 2217 without my signature. This bill would require courts to provide specific admonishments to jurors about communication through electronic and wireless devices. This bill is unnecessary. Existing law already sufficiently deals with communications among jurors. Moreover, this type of admonishment is better handled through court rules rather than by statute.
Recommended Amendments:
To limit the size of the pilot project and the potential workload to the Judicial Council to evaluate the project, the author may wish to consider an amendment to limit the number of pilot counties or more clearly specify the representative sample of courts eligible to participate in the pilot project.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2101 (Author:Gordon)
Version: March 31, 2016
Hearing Date: June 14, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: RD
SUBJECT
Sanctions: jurors
DESCRIPTION
This bill would allow judicial officers from a representative sample of courts participating in a pilot project by the Judicial Council, as specified, to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, as specified, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. This bill would also require the Judicial Council to report to the Governor and the Legislature the results of its evaluation of the pilot project, on or after July 1, 2021. This bill would sunset on January 1, 2022.
BACKGROUND
American jurisprudence provides for an adversarial system that turns on ensuring that both sides of a matter have an opportunity to scrutinize, challenge, and argue the facts and evidence upon which a jury is to determine the outcome of the case. The system is fundamentally undermined when a juror draws upon his or her own bias, prejudice, experience or knowledge, or otherwise brings in outside information into the deliberations of that case.
The potential for jury misconduct, while not a new issue, has been magnified by advancements in technology. In recent years, with the technological advances made and the widespread use of social media and Internet on electronic and wireless devices, the legal system has become increasingly threatened by such “outside factors” entering the jury room. Numerous cases have been cited in the news in which improper jury conduct arising out of the use of social media during trial or jury deliberations has led to mistrials, if not verdicts that were challenged or overturned, costing government time and taxpayer money.
As early as 2009, a New York Times article noted that “[t]he use of BlackBerries and iPhones by jurors gathering and sending out information about cases is wrecking havoc on trials around the country, upending deliberations and infuriating judges.” (Schwartz, New York Times, As Jurors Turn to Web, Mistrials are Popping Up (Mar. 18, 2009) <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/18/us/18juries.html> [as of May 17, 2016].) The article describes the multiple ways in which jurors can use electronic or wireless devices to allow for outside information to improperly supplement their understanding or perception of a case: “. . . using their cellphones, they can look up the name of a defendant on the Web or examine an intersection using Google Maps, violating the legal system’s complex rules of evidence. They can also tell their friends what is happening in the jury room, though they are supposed to keep their opinions and deliberations secret. A juror on a lunch or bathroom break can find out many details about a case. Wikipedia can help explain the technology underlying a patent claim or medical condition, Google Maps can show how long it might take to drive from Point A to Point B, and news sites can write about a criminal defendant, his lawyers or expert witnesses.”
Recognizing that jury misconduct can be an issue that has severe consequences for the integrity and outcome of a trial, California law provides for jury admonitions that inform jurors of their duty not to converse with, or permit themselves to be addressed by, any other person on any subject of the trial. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 611; see also Pen. Code Sec. 1122 which contains similar language.) Moreover, California law further requires that the officer charged with guarding the jury during deliberations must not allow any communication to be made to the jurors, or make any communication with the jurors himself or herself, except to ask them if they or three-fourths of them are agreed upon a verdict, or otherwise communicate to any person the state of their deliberations, or verdict agreed upon before the verdict is rendered. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 613; see also Pen. Code Sec. 1128, which contains substantially similar requirements.) In 2011, AB 141 (Fuentes, Ch. 181, Stats. 2011) was enacted to curb the improper use of electronic and or wireless communications, research, and dissemination of information and to provide courts with the tools that were necessary to enforce those rules (such as the ability to hold a juror in contempt of court). Specifically, AB 141 updated these existing statutes to require the jury admonition to inform jurors of their duty not to conduct research or disseminate information, and to require that the court clearly explain, as part of the admonishment, that the prohibition on research, dissemination of information, and conversation applies to all forms of electronic and wireless communication. AB 141 also clarified that the officer guarding the jury must not allow any electronic or wireless communications to be made to jurors.
This bill would now add the ability of certain courts participating in a Judicial Council pilot project to also impose reasonable monetary sanctions (not to exceed $1,500) on an impaneled juror who knowingly violates a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification, as specified. This pilot project (and the authority to impose sanctions by participating courts) would sunset on January 1, 2022.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law guarantees a criminal defendant’s right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defen[s]e. (U.S. Constitution, Sixth Amendment, as applied to the states through the 14th Amendment’s Due Process Clause; See Apodaca v. Oregon (1972) 406 U.S. 404.)
Existing law requires that if the jury is permitted to separate, either during the trial or after the case is submitted to them, the court must admonish the jurors that it is their duty not to conduct research, disseminate information, or converse with, or permit themselves to be addressed by, any other person on any subject of the trial, and that it is their duty not to form or express an opinion thereon until the case is finally submitted to them. The court must clearly explain, as part of the admonishment, that the prohibition on research, dissemination of information, and conversation applies to all forms of electronic and wireless communication. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 611.)
Existing law provides that when the case is finally submitted to the jury, they may decide in court or retire for deliberation. If they retire, they must be kept together, in some convenient place, until at least three-fourths of them agree upon a verdict or are discharged by the court. Existing law provides that except by order of the court, the officer having them under his or her charge must not allow any communication to be made to them, including any form of electronic or wireless communication, or make any communication himself or herself, except to ask them if they or three-fourths of them are agreed upon a verdict. Further, the officer must not, before their verdict is rendered, communicate to any person the state of their deliberations, or verdict agreed upon. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 613.) Existing law, Penal Code Section 1128, contains substantially similar requirements, and further provides that the court shall fix the time and place for deliberation and that the jurors shall not deliberate on the case except under such circumstances. If the jurors are permitted by the court to separate, the court must properly admonish them. (Pen. Code Sec. 1128.)
Existing law provides a list of acts or omissions in respect to a court of justice, or proceedings therein, that are (civil) contempts of court. For example, under this list, a person summoned as a juror is in contempt of court if the person improperly converses with a party to an action to be tried at such court, or with any other person, in relation to the merits of such action, or receives a communication from a party or other person in respect to it, and fails to immediately disclose the communication to the court. Additionally, a juror is in contempt of court if he or she willfully disobeys a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1209(a)(6), (11).)
Existing law provides that after the jury has been sworn or before the people’s opening address, the court shall instruct the jury generally concerning its basic functions, duties, and conduct. The instructions shall include, among other matters, admonitions that the jurors:
- shall not converse among themselves, or with anyone else, conduct research, or disseminate information on any subject connected with the trial;
- shall not read or listen to any accounts or discussions of the case reported by newspapers or other news media;
- shall not visit or view the premises or place where the offense or offenses charged were allegedly committed or any other premises or place involved in the case;
- shall not, within 90 days of discharge, request, accept, agree to accept, or discuss with any person receiving or accepting any payment or benefit in consideration for supplying any information concerning the trial; or
- shall promptly report to the court any incident within their knowledge involving an attempt by any person to improperly influence any member of the jury. (Pen. Code Sec. 1122(a).)
Existing law further provides with respect to the admonition in the jury instructions, above, that the jurors shall not converse, conduct research, or disseminate information on any subject connected with the trial, that the court shall clearly explain, as part of the admonishment, that the prohibition on conversation, research, and dissemination of information applies to all forms of electronic and wireless communication. (Pen. Code Sec. 1122(a)(1).)
Existing law provides that the jury shall also, at each adjournment of the court before the submission of the cause to the jury, whether permitted to separate or kept in the charge of officers, be admonished by the court that it is their duty not to conduct research, disseminate information, or converse among themselves, or with anyone else, on any subject connected with the trial, or to form or express any opinion about the case until the cause is finally submitted to them. The court shall clearly explain, as part of the admonishment, that the prohibition on research, dissemination of information, and conversation applies to all forms of electronic and wireless communication. (Pen. Code Sec. 1122(b).)
Existing law governs how reports are to be submitted to the Legislature and, among other things, requires that each report include a summary of its contents, not to exceed one page in length. If the report is submitted by a state agency, that agency must also provide an electronic copy of the summary directly to each member of the appropriate house or houses of the Legislature. Additionally, any state agency report and summary subject to these provisions must include an Internet Web site where the report can be downloaded and a telephone number to call to order a hard copy of the report. (Gov. Code Sec. 9795.)
Existing law provides, generally, that a judicial officer has the power to impose reasonable money sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, notwithstanding any other provision of law, payable to the court, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification. For these purposes, “person” includes a witness, a party, a party’s attorney, or both. Existing law provides that such sanctions shall not be imposed except on notice contained in a party’s moving or responding papers; or on the court’s own motion, after notice and opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 177.5.)
This bill would require the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2017, to solicit the participation of a representative sample of courts, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by the council, for participation in a pilot project to evaluate the effectiveness of this bill. This bill would specify that it applies only to those courts participating in the pilot project.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding any other law, a judicial officer of a court selected pursuant to the provisions below for participation in the pilot project established by this bill may impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, payable to the court, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence.
This bill would prohibit the imposition of sanctions except on notice contained in a party’s moving or responding papers, or on the court’s own motion, after notice and an opportunity to be heard. An order imposing sanctions must be in writing and must recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
This bill requires the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report the results to the Governor and the Legislature on or before July 1, 2021, as specified under existing law, above. The report must also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty.
This bill would include a January 1, 2022, sunset date.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Existing law, Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) [S]ection 177.5, authorizes a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions upon a person for violations of lawful court orders. As defined in CCP Section 177.5, the term “person” includes a witness, a party, a party’s attorney, or both. However, jurors are not included in this definition even though juror misconduct occurs.
Currently there are many forms of juror misconduct that can take place during a trial. These include discussing a case with other jurors, talking with members of either party of a case, researching evidence outside of the court, and more recently using social media to discuss the case. Social media use by jurors has been a growing phenomenon. Stories of jurors posting about their experiences in the juror box have seemingly become common place. In some instances, jurors have been found to have “friend requested” other parties of a trial via social media, while the jury was still in deliberations. Social media posts made by a juror about their specific case is not only a violation of lawful court orders, but can also jeopardize the integrity of court cases and in some instances has resulted in mistrials of cases as well as verdicts that were challenged or overturned, costing government time and taxpayer money. As it stands now, the only avenue to bring about accountability for juror misconduct is to hold the juror in civil contempt of the court.
There is a major difference between the process for imposing reasonable money sanctions and the more formal procedures required for contempt of court. Depending on the nature of the contempt, formal notice and a hearing may be needed and in the case of criminal contempt, counsel may be appointed. In contrast to these contempt procedures, which may delay a trial for hours or even days, the process for a money sanction may be resolved in a matter of minutes while still giving the juror an opportunity to explain his or her actions.
In an effort to hold jurors accountable and deter them from violating lawful court orders, AB 2101 would create a pilot program to give judicial officers in select counties the option to impose reasonable money sanctions on jurors for violations done without good cause or substantial justification. Adding jurors to the list of persons subject to reasonable money sanctions will prevent delays in cases over minor juror misconduct, while also allowing a judicial officer an additional tool to protect the integrity of the case at hand.
2. Sanctions against impaneled jurors who violate court admonitions against the use of electronic or wireless communications during trial
A 2013 American Bar Association article discusses the significant impact that social media can have on the American jury system. According to that article, in 2011, a death row inmate’s murder conviction was tossed because of a juror’s tweets during trial (Dimas-Martinez v. State (Ark. 2011) 385 S.W.3d 238, 249). Likewise, a Kentucky murder conviction was reversed when two jurors “friended” the victim’s mother on Facebook during trial (Sluss v. Commonwealth (Ky. 2012) 381 S.W.3d 215, 229). That article advocates for the bar to prepare to counter the potential adverse impact social media can have on juries in several ways. The article recommends not only prohibiting the use of social media to communicate about a case by way of frequent jury instructions, but also advocates for the implementation of additional safeguards such as the issuance of fines for violations of judicial instructions.
California law already provides for jury admonitions that inform jurors of their duty not to conduct research, disseminate information, converse with, or permit themselves to be addressed by, any other person on any subject of the trial. Additionally, under this law, the court must clearly explain, as part of the admonishment, that the prohibition on research, dissemination of information, and conversation applies to all forms of electronic and wireless communication. Separately, existing law also requires that the officer guarding the jury not allow any communication to be made to the jurors, including any electronic or wireless communications, during deliberations. (Code Civ. Proc. Secs. 611, 613; see also Pen. Code Secs. 1122, 1128.) Any juror who improperly converses with a party to an action to be tried at such court, or with any other person, in relation to the merits of such action, or receives a communication from a party or other person in respect to it, and fails to immediately disclose the communication to the court, could be held in contempt of court. Similarly, a juror can be held in contempt of court if he or she willfully disobeys a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1209(a)(6), (11).)
That being said, short of holding a juror in contempt of court, the court’s enforcement mechanisms are limited in addressing such juror misconduct. One such mechanism could, as suggested by the ABA article, above, include the ability to issue fines or sanctions. While a judicial officer generally has the authority to impose sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, for any violation of a lawful court order by a person, done without good cause or substantial justification, for these purposes, under existing law, “person” only includes a witness, a party, a party’s attorney (or both). (See Civ. Code Sec. 177.5.) In contrast, judicial officers do not have the power to impose sanctions on jurors for similar violations of court orders, including orders made in the jury admonitions against electronic or wireless communication.
Accordingly, this bill would, until January 1, 2022, allow courts in select counties to also sanction impaneled jurors who violate court orders such as those given under the jury admonition statutes. Specifically, this bill would provide that, notwithstanding any other law, a judicial officer of a court selected for participation in the pilot project, as specified, may impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500 on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence. Like the existing provision allowing for sanctions against parties, attorneys, or witnesses, this bill would ensure that the parties or court provide the juror with notice and opportunity to be heard before any sanctions can be imposed, and that an order imposing sanctions be in writing and recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order. Moreover, by operation of this bill’s sunset date and reporting requirement, this Legislature will have the opportunity to review any unintended consequences of such sanctions, including any impact that the sanctions might have on the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. In the meantime, because the bill is limited to select courts participating in this pilot program by Judicial Council, any adverse impacts would be further limited.
3. Sanctions under this bill are payable to the court
This bill currently provides that the sanction, which can be up to $1,500, is payable to the court. Arguably, though there must be clear and convincing evidence that the juror knowingly violated the lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification, this could provide a direct incentive to the participating courts to sanction jurors. Staff notes that existing law authorizes judicial officers to impose sanctions up to $1,500 against parties, attorneys, or witnesses (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 177.5), and similarly provides that the sanctions are payable to the court. However, in contrast to this bill, those sanctions must be remitted to the Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF) pursuant to a separate provision of law, “as soon as practicable after collection and on a regular basis.” (See Gov. Code Sec. 68085.1(a)(1) and (b).) To avoid any possible conflict, the author has agreed to the following amendment to ensure that the sanction is ultimately remitted to the TCTF, similar to sanctions imposed under Section 177.5.
Author’s amendment:
Amend paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 68085.1 of the Government Code to add Section 177.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, following the reference to Section 177.5.
4. Time allotted between the Judicial Council report and the bill’s sunset date
This bill currently only provides for six months between the due date of the Judicial Council report and the bill’s sunset. To allow the Legislature time to review the report before the expiration of the bill’s sunset, the author has agreed to the following amendment to require the report one year in advance of the sunset.
Author’s amendment:
On page 2, line 26, strike “July” and insert “January”
5. Clarifying amendment
The author has also agreed to the following clarifying amendment would ensure that the standard of clear and convincing evidence applies to the court’s finding of a knowing violation, done without good cause or substantial justification:
Author’s amendments:
On page 2, line 8, strike “order” and insert “order, done”
On page 2, line 9, strike “justification” and insert “justification,”
Support: None Known
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Judicial Council
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
AB 2683 (Cooley, Ch. 99, Stats. 2014) deleted a Penal Code provision that made it a contempt of court (a misdemeanor) for a juror to willfully disobey a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research.
AB 141 (Fuentes, Ch. 181, Stats. 2011), See Background.
AB 2217 (Fuentes, 2010) was substantially similar to AB 141, above. This bill was vetoed.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 16, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing: April 20, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2101
Author:(Gordon) – As Amended Ver:March 31, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill, until January 1, 2022, authorizes a pilot program allowing participating courts to impose sanctions on impaneled jurors for knowing violations of a lawful court order. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2017, to solicit a representative sample of courts to participate in the pilot project, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by Council.
- Allows a participating court to impose reasonable monetary sanctions, not to exceed $1,500, on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- Requires the Judicial Council to conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report its findings by July 1, 2021, to the Governor and the Legislature.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Administrative costs for the Judicial Council to select the pilot project counties, obtain relevant data from participating courts, and report its findings should be minor. The pilot project offers potential ongoing operational savings to participating courts from addressing juror misconduct through sanctions rather than through contempt proceedings.
COMMENTS:
- Background. In California, certain acts amount to contempt. Some examples include: “disorderly, contemptuous, or insolent behavior toward the judge while holding the court, tending to interrupt the due course of a trial or other judicial proceeding;” and “when summoned as a juror in a court, neglecting to attend or serve as a juror.” Due to the potentially severe consequences of being found in contempt, a contemnor is afforded significant due process rights. Contempt proceedings, therefore, take more time and judicial resources. As a result, courts have been authorized the power to “impose reasonable monetary sanctions for any violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification.” Current law only allows courts to sanction certain individuals—a witness, a party, or a party’s attorney. When a court seeks to discipline a juror, however, the court’s only option, generally, is contempt.
- Purpose. As introduced, this bill would have allowed the court to sanction jurors for violating any lawful order without good cause, similar to the court’s authority to sanction parties, attorneys, and witnesses. However, the original legislation raised significant questions, including (1) whether prospective jurors should be sanctioned under the same standard that applies to those other individuals; (2) whether sanctions would discourage jurors from serving on juries; and (3) whether there were sufficient due process safeguards for jurors to challenge a sanctions order.
With these issues in mind, the bill has been narrowed to a limited and temporary pilot program to authorize juror sanctions, which is intended to balance the state’s dual interests in supporting judicial economy and the due process rights for individuals who inadvertently violate court orders because they may not be familiar with the decorum expected in court.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 5, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2101
Author:(Gordon) – As Amended Ver:March 31, 2016
SUBJECT: SANCTIONS: JURORS
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO PROMOTE THE COURT’S INTEREST IN ORDERLY AND EFFICIENT PROCEEDINGS WHILE MAINTAINING DUE PROCESS PROTECTIONS FOR PERSONS SANCTIONED BY THE COURT, SHOULD SEVERAL COURTS BE AUTHORIZED, FOR A FIVE-YEAR PERIOD, TO CONDUCT A PILOT PROJECT THAT WOULD ALLOW A COURT TO SANCTION AN IMPANELED JUROR FOR A KNOWING VIOLATION OF A COURT ORDER UNDER SPECIFIED CIRCUMSTANCES?
SYNOPSIS
A court has the authority to sanction individuals engaging in misconduct in court. These individuals include litigants, attorneys, and witnesses. When it comes to jurors, however, a court’s authority is more limited. If a court seeks to discipline a juror for misconduct, the court must begin contempt proceedings. Due to the potentially severe consequences of being found in contempt, such as incarceration, anyone subject to a contempt proceeding is afforded significant due process rights, including but not limited to the right to a full and fair hearing, the right to the assistance of counsel, the right to gather evidence and prepare a defense, the right to examine witnesses, and depending on the punishment, the right to a jury trial.
As introduced, this bill would have substantially extended the court’s authority to sanction jurors, similar to its authority to sanction other individuals, such as parties and witnesses. According to the Judicial Council, the sponsor of this bill, the goal of the introduced bill was to prevent delays in cases caused by misbehaving jurors. While it is a laudable goal to provide judges with a less burdensome alternative to curb juror misconduct, the scope of the introduced version of this bill was concerning, and could potentially frustrate the goals of California’s jury system. With this caution in mind, this bill has been narrowed to more appropriately balance the state’s dual interests in supporting judicial economy and the due process rights for individuals who inadvertently violate court orders because they may not be familiar with the decorum expected in court.
As amended, this bill authorizes a five-year pilot program that would allow participating courts to impose reasonable monetary sanctions on an impaneled juror for a knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification. Consistent with existing law, the bill provides that an order imposing sanctions on a person must be in writing, and that the person is provided with notice and an opportunity to be heard. To hold the court to a higher standard of proof than originally proposed, this bill now requires the court to support its sanctions order with clear and convincing evidence. Near the end of the five-year pilot, this bill requires Judicial Council to report to the Legislature and the Governor on its evaluation of the pilot, and on whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty. This bill has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Authorizes California courts, in a limited pilot, the ability to impose sanctions on impaneled jurors for knowing violations of a lawful court order. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2022, a pilot project that allows a court to impose reasonable monetary sanctions on an impaneled juror for any knowing violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification that is supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- Provides that sanctions shall not be imposed except on notice contained in a party’s moving or responding papers, or on the court’s own motion, after notice and opportunity to be heard.
- Provides that an order imposing sanctions on an impaneled juror shall be in writing and shall recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order.
- Requires the Judicial Council to solicit a representative sample of courts to participate in the pilot project, taking into account size, geography, and other factors identified by Council.
- Requires the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2021, to conduct an evaluation of this pilot project and report to the Governor and the Legislature its findings that is required to also examine whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows a judicial officer to impose reasonable money sanctions, as provided, on a person who violates any lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification. For the purposes of this section, the term “person” includes a witness, a party, a party’s attorney, or both. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 177.5. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.)
- Requires that an order imposing sanctions be in writing and recite in detail the conduct or circumstances justifying the order. (Id.)
- Prohibits sanctions from being imposed from the court’s own motion unless there is notice and opportunity to be heard. (Id.)
- Allows the court to impose reasonable monetary sanctions as provided on a prospective juror who fails to attend jury as directed or to respond to the court or jury commissioner as provided. (Section 209.)
- Provides that some of these relevant acts or omissions in respect to the court of justice, or proceedings therein, are contempts of the authority of the court:
- Disorderly, contemptuous, or insolent behavior toward the judge while holding the court, tending to interrupt the due course of a trial or other judicial proceeding.
- A breach of the peace, boisterous conduct, or violent disturbance, tending to interrupt the due course of a trial or other judicial proceeding.
- Disobedience of any lawful judgment, order, or process of the court.
- Willful disobedience by a juror of a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research.
- Unlawfully detaining a witness or party to an action while going to, remaining at, or returning from the court where the action is on the calendar for trial.
- Any other unlawful interference with the process or proceedings of a court.
- When summoned as a juror in a court, neglecting to attend or serve as a juror, or improperly conversing with a party to an action to be tried at the court, or with any other person, in relation to the merits of the action, or receiving a communication from a party or other person in respect to the action, without immediately disclosing the communication to the court. (Section 1209.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: American Origins of Contempt. The Judiciary Act of 1789 (the Act), signed by President George Washington, established the framework for our federal courts and provided for some of the federal courts’ jurisdiction and powers. Among other things, the Act grants our federal courts the “power to…punish by fine or imprisonment, at the discretion of said courts, all contempts of authority in any cause or hearing before the same.” (1 Stat. 73, 83.; See Bloom v. Illinois (1968) 391 U.S. 194, 207.)
It is safe to say that the Act arose over suspicions on the corrupting nature of power, and it was thought that the Act would provide a strong judiciary to check on the other two political branches of government. However, those suspicions weren’t limited to just Congress and the President. Around the time the Act became law, there was a lingering feeling that a federal judiciary vested with too much power could lead to tyranny. And to a certain extent, that feeling was well-placed. In 1830, the United States House of Representatives impeached federal Judge James Peck for abusing the court’s contempt authority when Judge Peck imprisoned and disbarred an individual for criticizing one of Peck’s opinions.
After the impeachment proceedings, Congress, in 1831, enacted measures to significantly curtail the court’s contempt power. (See Bloom, supra, at p. 207.) Indeed, in a reflection of that history, the United States Supreme Court stated that, “vesting the judiciary with completely untrammeled power to punish contempt…makes clear the need for effective safeguards against that power's abuse.” (Ibid.) Wisely, the laws on contempt have evolved. Today, contempt is limited to specific acts (instead of summarily contempt), and the law provides contemnors significant due process rights during contempt proceedings.
Specific Acts of Contempt in California. In California, certain acts amount to contempt. Some examples include: “disorderly, contemptuous, or insolent behavior toward the judge while holding the court, tending to interrupt the due course of a trial or other judicial proceeding;” and “when summoned as a juror in a court, neglecting to attend or serve as a juror.” (Section 1209.) In 2012, the Legislature added this modern act of contempt: “willful disobedience by a juror of a court admonishment related to the prohibition on any form of communication or research about the case, including all forms of electronic or wireless communication or research.” (Ibid.)
Due Process Rights in Contempt Proceedings. Due to the potentially severe consequences of being found in contempt, a contemnor is afforded significant due process rights. These rights include the right to a full and fair hearing, the right to the assistance of counsel, the right to gather evidence and prepare a defense, the right to examine witnesses, and depending on the punishment, potentially the right to a jury trial. Additionally, due to the quasi-criminal nature of an act of contempt, the court must prove the act beyond a reasonable doubt. An individual found in contempt may be subject to fines, incarceration, or both.
Sanctions: An Alternative to Contempt. Of course, due process is not always expedient. Since contempt proceedings provide significant and important due process to the contemnor, contempt proceedings necessarily take more time and judicial resources. As a result, courts have been authorized the power to “impose reasonable monetary sanctions for any violation of a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification.” (Section 177.5.) Currently, an order for sanctions requires notice and an opportunity to be heard—significantly less due process than what is required under contempt. It is true that the potential penalties associated with sanctions are less severe, so less due process may seem reasonable. However, the court’s authority to impose sanctions remains broad (“any violation of a lawful court order”) when it is compared to the court’s authority in finding modern-day contempt. Current law only allows courts to sanction certain individuals—a witness, a party, or a party’s attorney; accordingly, when a court seeks to discipline a juror, the court’s only option, generally, is contempt.
Author’s Statement. According to the author:
Currently there are many forms of juror misconduct that can take place during a trial. These include discussing a case with other jurors, talking with members of either party of a case, researching evidence outside of the court, and more recently using social media to discuss the case. Social media use by jurors has been a growing phenomenon. Social media posts made by a juror about their specific case is not only a violation of lawful court orders, but can also jeopardize the integrity of court cases and in some instances has resulted in mistrials of cases as well as verdicts that were challenged or overturned, costing government time and taxpayer money. As it stands now, the only avenue to bring about accountability for juror misconduct is to hold the juror in civil contempt of the court.
In contrast to these contempt procedures, which may delay a trial for hours or even days, the process for a money sanction may be resolved in matter of minutes while still giving the juror an opportunity to explain his or her actions.
In an effort to hold jurors accountable and deter them from violating lawful court orders, AB 2101 would give judicial officers the option to impose reasonable money sanctions on jurors for violations done without good cause or substantial justification.
[This bill] will prevent delays in cases over minor juror misconduct, while also allowing a judicial officer an additional tool to protect the integrity of the case at hand.
As Introduced, the Bill Would Have Substantially Extended the Court’s Authority to Sanction Jurors. According to the Judicial Council, the sponsor of this bill, the goal of the bill is to prevent delays in cases caused by misbehaving jurors. While it is a laudable goal to provide judges a less burdensome alternative to curb juror misconduct, the scope of the introduced version of this bill could potentially frustrate the goals of California’s jury system, and re-live the memory of the court’s summarily contempt power.
As introduced, this bill would have allowed the court to sanction jurors for violating any lawful order without good cause, similar to the court’s authority to sanction parties, attorneys, and witnesses. However, the original legislation raised significant questions, including (1) whether prospective jurors should be sanctioned under the same standard that applies to those other individuals; (2) whether sanctions would discourage jurors from serving on juries; and (3) whether there were sufficient due process safeguards for jurors to challenge a sanctions order.
With these issues in mind, this bill has been narrowed to more appropriately balance the state’s dual interests in supporting judicial economy and the due process rights for individuals who inadvertently violate court orders because they may not be familiar with the decorum expected in court.
As amended, this bill authorizes a five-year pilot program to allow participating courts to impose reasonable monetary sanctions on an impaneled juror who knowingly violates a lawful court order without good cause or substantial justification. Consistent with existing law, the bill provides that an order imposing sanctions on a person must be in writing, and that juror must be given notice and an opportunity to be heard. To hold the court to a higher standard of proof than what is required to sanction other parties, this bill requires the court to support its sanctions order with clear and convincing evidence. Near the end of the five-year pilot, this bill requires the Judicial Council to report to the Legislature and the Governor on its evaluation of the pilot, and on whether the imposition of sanctions affects the number of prospective jurors who report for jury duty.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Judicial Council of California (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):