SB 785: Consumer protection: ticket sellers.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-08-21
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-26: Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law regulates ticket sellers, as defined. Existing law prohibits a ticket seller from contracting for the sale of tickets or accepting consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of tickets unless the ticket seller has possession of the ticket or meets a specified exception. Existing law imposes conditions on accepting a deposit from a prospective purchaser to obtain a ticket, as specified. Existing law generally makes a violation of these provisions a misdemeanor and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions, including, among other things, prohibiting a ticket seller from advertising, offering for sale, or contracting for the sale of a ticket, or accepting consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, have constructive possession, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace, as defined, to comply with specified requirements in order to offer a service to obtain a ticket on behalf of a purchaser. The bill would also prohibit a ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace from selling more than one copy to a live entertainment event and would prohibit a ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace from displaying specified content on an internet website with intent to mislead if the content is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, as specified. By imposing new requirements on ticket sales, the violation of which is a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces, as defined, and to require original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket resale marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would also prohibit a ticket reseller, ticket resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace from doing specified acts, including employing another person to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit a ticket reseller from using certain internet website displays that are substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without their written consent.The bill would revise and recast various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket resale marketplaces to disclose the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the consumer to occupy. The bill would delete the requirement that a ticket seller disclose that a service charge is added to the price of the ticket.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces, as defined, and to require original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket resale marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would also prohibit a ticket reseller, ticket resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace from doing specified acts, including employing another person to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit a ticket reseller from using certain internet website displays that are substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without their written consent.
The bill would revise and recast various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket resale marketplaces to disclose the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy. The bill would delete the requirement that a ticket seller disclose that a service charge is added to the price of the ticket.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined, and to require original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain internet website displays that are substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without their written consent.
The bill would revise and recast various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the location within the venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser to occupy. The bill would delete the requirement that a ticket seller disclose that a service charge is added to the price of the ticket.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined, and to require original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission, as specified. if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain internet website displays that are substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without their written consent.
The bill would impose revise and recast various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the face price of the original ticket. location within the venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser to occupy. The bill would delete the requirement that a ticket seller disclose that a service charge is added to the price of the ticket.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined. defined, and to require original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission, as specified.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain internet website displays that are substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without their written consent.
The bill would impose various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the face price of the original ticket.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would also increase the fines that may be imposed for violations of these provisions.
The bill would require an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission, as specified.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain website displays that are substantially similar to the website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without their written consent.
The bill would impose various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket, and purchase that ticket.
The bill would authorize an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of these provisions to bring a civil action against that person and recover damages for the injury plus additional sums, as specified, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would also increase the fines that may be imposed for violations of these provisions.
The bill would require a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission, as specified.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain website displays that are substantially similar to the website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without their written consent.
The bill would impose various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket, and purchase that ticket.
The bill would authorize an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of these provisions to bring a civil action against that person and recover damages for the injury plus additional sums, as specified, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers, defined as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event. In this regard, existing law, among other things, prohibits specified ticket selling practices and imposes certain recordkeeping and disclosure requirements. Existing law makes a violation of those provisions a misdemeanor, and imposes civil penalties for certain violations.
This bill would revise and recast those provisions to impose similar requirements, as applicable, to original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined. By expanding the scope of certain requirements related to selling those tickets, the violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would also increase the fines that may be imposed for violations of these provisions.
The bill would require a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. The bill would require a ticket marketplace to impose a similar requirement before accepting a ticket listing, as specified. The bill would also make it unlawful for a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission, as specified.
The bill would make certain intentional acts unlawful, including purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale and circumventing or disabling certain sales volume limitation systems. The bill would also prohibit certain website displays that are substantially similar to the website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without their written consent.
The bill would impose various disclosure requirements on the advertisement of tickets for sale, including requiring ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket, and purchase that ticket.
The bill would authorize an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of these provisions to bring a civil action against that person and recover damages for the injury plus additional sums, as specified, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sell admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Violations of these provisions is a misdemeanor.This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that would modernize the current statutes regarding sales of tickets to live entertainment events. The bill would make related findings and declarations.Existing law provides comprehensive regulation of ticket sellers who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sell admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Violations of these provisions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that would modernize the current statutes regarding sales of tickets to live entertainment events. The bill would make related findings and declarations.
(a)It shall be unlawful for a ticket seller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of tickets a ticket or accept consideration for payment in full or for a depositfor deposit for the sale of tickets unless the ticket seller meets one or more of the following requirements: a ticket if they do not own, possess, have constructive possession, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)Nothing in this section shall prohibit a ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace from offering a service to obtain a ticket on behalf of a purchaser if the ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace complies with all of the following:
(1)Does not market or list the service as a ticket.
(2)Maintains a clear, distinct, and easily discernible separation between the service and tickets through unavoidable visual demarcation that persists throughout the entire service selection and purchasing process.
(3)Clearly and conspicuously discloses before selection of the service that the service is not a ticket and that the purchase of the service does not guarantee a ticket.
(4)In the event the service is unable to obtain the specified ticket purchased through the service for the consumer, provides the purchaser, within a reasonable amount of time, either of the following:
(A)A full refund for the total cost of the service to obtain a ticket on behalf of the purchaser.
(B)Subject to availability, a replacement ticket in the same or a comparable location with the approval of the purchaser.
(5)Does not obtain more tickets in each transaction than the numerical limitations for tickets set by the event presenter or original seller for each respective event.
(c)For purposes of this section, ticket resale marketplace means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, including a site operated by a ticket seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
SEC. 3.Section 22502.4 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.4.(a)A ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace shall not intentionally sell or resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
(b)For purposes of this section, ticket resale marketplace has the same definition as that term is defined in Section 22502.1.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.5.(a)A ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display, without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead.
(b)For purposes of this section, ticket resale marketplace has the same definition as that term is defined in Section 22502.1.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year after the initial sale.SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)An original seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.(b)An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within that entertainment venue.SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.(b)A ticket reseller, a ticket resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace shall not do either of the following:(1)Resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.(2)Employ another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)(1)A ticket resale marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the consumer.(2)By allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its internet website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.(b)A ticket resale marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within an entertainment venue.SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)An artist means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.(b)A consumer, as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.(c)An entertainment venue means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission. (d)An event, as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.(e)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.(f)A live entertainment event means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport. (g)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.(h)A rights holder means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.(i)A ticket means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket. (j)A ticket resale marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, including a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.(k)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.(l)A venue operator means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.SEC. 9.Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 10.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.SEC. 11.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.(a)A ticket reseller shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:(1)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.(2)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller.(b)A ticket reseller shall not represent that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term sold out when tickets are still available on the original sellers website.SEC. 12.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenters, rights holders, and venue operators posted terms and conditions.(e)Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple consumer accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.SEC. 13.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the consumer by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the consumer, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the consumer by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the consumer is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.(d)A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.SEC. 14.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 15.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.SEC. 16.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c)For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A district attorney.
(3)A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000. attorney.
(4)A county counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000. county.
(5)A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney. prosecutor.
(d)In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. Additionally, the court shall award a prevailing public prosecutor reasonable costs and attorneys fees. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2)The number of violations.
(3)The persistence of the misconduct.
(4)The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5)The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6)The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year. year after the initial sale.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a that entertainment venue.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)A ticket reseller, a ticket resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace shall not do either of the following:
(1)Resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
(2)Employ another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)(1)A ticket resale marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer. consumer.
(2)By allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its internet website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
(b)A ticket resale marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a an entertainment venue.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)A An artist means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
(b)A consumer, as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(c)An entertainment venue means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
(b)(d)An event, as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(c)(e)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(f)A live entertainment event means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
(d)(g)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter. presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
(h)A rights holder means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
(i)A ticket means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
(e)(j)A ticket resale marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale. event, including a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
(f)(k)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
(l)A venue operator means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
SEC. 9.Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 10.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 11.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.(a)A person ticket reseller shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)(1)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)(2)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter presenter, rights holder, or original seller.
(b)A ticket reseller shall not represent that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term sold out when tickets are still available on the original sellers website.
SEC. 12.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenters presenters, rights holders, and venue operators posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser consumer accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 13.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser consumer by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, consumer, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser consumer by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser consumer is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 14.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 15.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.
SEC. 16.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c)For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A district attorney.
(3)A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4)A county counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5)A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d)In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2)The number of violations.
(3)The persistence of the misconduct.
(4)The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5)The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6)The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a venue.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
(b)A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a venue.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)A consumer, as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(b)An event, as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(c)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(d)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
(e)A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
(f)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 9.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.SEC. 10.SEC. 9.Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 11.SEC. 10.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 12.SEC. 11.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 13.SEC. 12.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 14.SEC. 13.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 15.SEC. 14.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 16.SEC. 15.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.
SEC. 17.SEC. 16.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c)For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A district attorney.
(3)A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4)A county council counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5)A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d)In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2)The number of violations.
(3)The persistence of the misconduct.
(4)The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5)The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6)The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds. refunds for at least a period of one year.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle permit the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale. unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a venue.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless either of the following requirements is met: ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(1)The original seller or a ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession.(2)The original seller or a ticket reseller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the event presenter.(b)In addition to the requirements of subdivision (a), it shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the original seller or ticket reseller to do so.SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
(b)A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle permit the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket. ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a venue.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)22503.(a)A consumer, as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(b)An event, as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(c)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(b)(d)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
(c)(e)A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
(d)(f)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 9.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
SEC. 10.Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 11.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 12.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 13.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 14.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 15.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 16.Section 22508 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22508.(a)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall not advertise, display, or offer a price for a ticket that does not include all fees or charges that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket other than taxes or fees imposed by a government on the transaction. (b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces may separately state any fees or charges included in the price of a ticket only if the disclosure is not false or misleading, including, but not limited to, by bundling government taxes or fees with any component of the price, and shall not present those fees charges more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the price of the ticket.(c)The total cost of the ticket shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed, from the first time pricing is displayed and anytime thereafter, except that a reasonable fee may be charged for the delivery of a nonelectronic ticket if multiple delivery options are presented to the purchaser for selection and the delivery fee is disclosed to the purchaser before payment is accepted.(d)The total cost shall be displayed in any price quote or advertisement that includes pricing. (e)Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket.SEC. 17.SEC. 16.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge, or to any nonprofit, charitable, tax-exempt organization that sells tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. charge.
SEC. 18.SEC. 17.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold, that shall be included in any advertisement or solicitation, and that shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c)For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A district attorney.
(3)A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4)A county council of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5)A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d)In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2)The number of violations.
(3)The persistence of the misconduct.
(4)The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5)The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6)The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless either of the following requirements is met:
(1)The original seller or a ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession.
(2)The original seller or a ticket reseller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the event presenter.
(b)In addition to the requirements of subdivision (a), it shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the original seller or ticket reseller to do so.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
(b)A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(b)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
(c)A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
(d)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 9.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
SEC. 10.Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.22503.5.This chapter does not apply to any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor.Primary contractor means the person or organization who is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold.SEC. 10. SEC. 11.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 11. SEC. 12.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 12. SEC. 13.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22503.5, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 13. SEC. 14.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 14. SEC. 15.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 15. SEC. 16.Section 22508 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22508.(a)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees not advertise, display, or offer a price for a ticket that does not include all fees or charges that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase. ticket other than taxes or fees imposed by a government on the transaction.
(b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser. (c)(b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall not make a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components may separately state any fees or charges included in the price of a ticket only if the disclosure is not false or misleading, including, but not limited to, by bundling government taxes or fees with any component of the price, and shall not present those fees charges more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
(c)The total cost of the ticket shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed, from the first time pricing is displayed and anytime thereafter, except that a reasonable fee may be charged for the delivery of a nonelectronic ticket if multiple delivery options are presented to the purchaser for selection and the delivery fee is disclosed to the purchaser before payment is accepted.
(d)The total cost shall be displayed in any price quote or advertisement that includes pricing.
(d)(e)Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket.
SEC. 16. SEC. 17.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge, or to any nonprofit, charitable, tax-exempt organization that sells tickets to an event sponsored by the organization.
SEC. 17. SEC. 18.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold, that shall be included in any advertisement or solicitation, and that shall be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c)Any person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this chapter shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each violation, and two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) for each continuing violation, which may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, or a district attorney, or a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, and, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city, county, or city and county having a full-time prosecutor in any court of competent jurisdiction. Payment of the civil penalty shall be made pursuant to the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 17206. (d)(c)For the purposes of this section, chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this section chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A district attorney.
(3)A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4)A county council of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5)A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d)In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2)The number of violations.
(3)The persistence of the misconduct.
(4)The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5)The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6)The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)A An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)A An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket reseller meets either of the following requirements: either of the following requirements is met:
(1)The original seller or a ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession.
(2)The original seller or a ticket reseller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the event presenter.
(b)In addition to the requirements of subdivision (a), it shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the original seller or ticket reseller to do so.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.(a)A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
(b)A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for a ticket reseller or an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.2.A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.SEC. 8. SEC. 7.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, a ticket reseller or an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1, 22502.2, 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 9.Section 22502.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.6.An original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of this chapter may bring a civil action against that person and may recover from that person damages for the injury plus any additional damages a court may determine to be appropriates, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.SEC. 10. SEC. 8.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.(a)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(b)An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
(c)A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
(d)A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 11.Section 22503.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.1.An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, on behalf of an event presenter, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.SEC. 12.Section 22503.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.2.A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means a person, except the event presenter or original seller, who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, or on behalf of, a ticket reseller to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event.SEC. 13. SEC. 9.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.(a)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.(b)22503.3.Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
SEC. 14. SEC. 10.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 15. SEC. 11.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 16. SEC. 12.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22503.5, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple ISP addresses, Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 17. SEC. 13.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require a ticket seller an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 18. SEC. 14.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 19. SEC. 15.Section 22508 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22508.(a)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase.
(b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser.
(c)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall not make a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
(d)Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket and purchase that ticket.
SEC. 20. SEC. 16.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge, or to any nonprofit, charitable, tax-exempt organization that sells tickets to an event sponsored by the organization.
SEC. 21. SEC. 17.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold, and that address shall be included in any advertisement or solicitation, and that shall be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by fine not exceeding twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) or by both.
(c)Any person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this chapter shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each violation, and two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) for each continuing violation, which may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, or a district attorney, or a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, and, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city, county, or city and county having a full-time prosecutor in any court of competent jurisdiction. Payment of the civil penalty shall be made pursuant to the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 17206.
(d)For the purposes of this section, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this section shall constitute a separate violation.
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)A ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)A ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket reseller meets either of the following requirements:
(1)The ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession.
(2)The ticket reseller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the event presenter.
(b)In addition to the requirements of subdivision (a), it shall be unlawful for a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the ticket reseller to do so.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.4.It shall be unlawful for a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.2.A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
SEC. 8.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.5.In addition to other remedies, a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1, 22502.2, or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 9.Section 22502.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.6.An original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of this chapter may bring a civil action against that person and may recover from that person damages for the injury plus any additional damages a court may determine to be appropriates, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
SEC. 10.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.A ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 11.Section 22503.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.1.An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, on behalf of an event presenter, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
SEC. 12.Section 22503.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.2.A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means a person, except the event presenter or original seller, who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, or on behalf of, a ticket reseller to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event.
SEC. 13.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.(a)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(b)Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
SEC. 14.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 15.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 16.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22503.5, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple ISP addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 17.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require a ticket seller to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 18.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 19.Section 22508 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22508.(a)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase.
(b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser.
(c)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall not make a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
(d)Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket and purchase that ticket.
SEC. 20.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge, or to any nonprofit, charitable, tax-exempt organization that sells tickets to an event sponsored by the organization.
SEC. 21.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)A ticket seller Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold sold, and that address shall be included in any advertisement or solicitation, and shall be duly licensed licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b)A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) or by both.
(c)Any person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this section chapter shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each violation, and two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) for each continuing violation, which may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, or a district attorney, or a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, and, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city, county, or city and county having a full-time prosecutor in any court of competent jurisdiction. Payment of the civil penalty shall be made pursuant to the provisions of subdivision (b) of Section 17206. For
(d)For the purposes of this section, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this section shall constitute a separate violation. The
(e)The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2.Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22501.A ticket seller Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
SEC. 3.Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22502.(a)A ticket seller shall, prior to sale, disclose reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b)A ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser purchaser, by means of a description or a map map, the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets. within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
SEC. 4.Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.1.22502.3.(a)It shall be unlawful for a ticket seller to reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of tickets a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of tickets a ticket, unless the ticket seller meets one or more reseller meets either of the following requirements:
(a)(1)The ticket seller reseller has the ticket in his or her their possession.
(b)(2)The ticket seller reseller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the primary contractor. event presenter.
(c)The ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two business days, that the seller does not have possession of the tickets, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person who has a contractual right to obtain the ticket from the primary contractor, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price or range of prices.Nothing in this section shall prohibit a ticket seller from accepting a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two days, of the terms of the deposit agreement, and includes in the oral and written notice the disclosures otherwise required by this section.(b)In addition to the requirements of subdivision (a), it shall be unlawful for a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the ticket reseller to do so.
SEC. 5.Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.1.A ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
SEC. 6.Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.2.22502.4.It shall be unlawful for a ticket seller reseller or ticket marketplace to represent that he or she can deliver they can deliver or cause to be delivered delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time time, or by a contracted time the tickets time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7.Section 22502.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.2.A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
SEC. 8.Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22502.3.22502.5.In addition to other remedies, a ticket seller who reseller or ticket marketplace that violates Section 22502.1 or 22502.2 and fails to supply a ticket at or below a contracted price or within a contracted price range 22505.1, 22502.2, or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending attending, or attempting to attend attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys fees and court costs.
SEC. 9.Section 22502.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22502.6.An original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another persons violation of this chapter may bring a civil action against that person and may recover from that person damages for the injury plus any additional damages a court may determine to be appropriates, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
SEC. 10.Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22503.A ticket seller, ticket reseller, as used in this chapter, means any a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission tickets ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
SEC. 11.Section 22503.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.1.An original seller, as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, on behalf of an event presenter, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
SEC. 12.Section 22503.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.2.A ticket marketplace, as used in this chapter, means a person, except the event presenter or original seller, who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, or on behalf of, a ticket reseller to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event.
SEC. 13.Section 22503.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22503.3.(a)An event presenter, as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(b)Nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
SEC. 14.Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22503.6.22503.4.This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier carrier, or motor coach carrier who that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter or his or her agent promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 15.Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22505.2.A person shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a)A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b)Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
SEC. 16.Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:22505.5.(a)Notwithstanding 22505.1.Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22503.5, 22503.6, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees. do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a)Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b)Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c)Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d)Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenters posted terms and conditions.
(e)Utilize multiple ISP addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
(b)For purposes of this section:(1)Event attendee means a person who purchases one or more tickets with the intent to attend the event for which the ticket or tickets are purchased. An event attendee does not include a ticket seller.(2)A control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process includes limits on the number of tickets that a person can purchase.SEC. 17.Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22507.(a)The ticket price of an event which that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b)The ticket price of an event which that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded to or credited to the account of the purchaser by the ticket seller person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c)For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event event, at a different date or time.
(d)A local jurisdiction may require a ticket seller to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide for any refunds that may be required by pursuant to this section.
SEC. 18.Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.22508.A ticket seller shall disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller.SEC. 19.Section 22508 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:22508.(a)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase.
(b)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser.
(c)Original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces shall not make a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
(d)Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces shall include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenters website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket and purchase that ticket.
SEC. 20.Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22511.This chapter does not apply to any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling event for which tickets are distributed free of charge, or to any nonprofit, charitable, tax-exempt organization that sells tickets to an event sponsored by the organization.
SEC. 21.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares the following:(1)The Legislature has long considered consumer protection to be a matter of high importance.(2)State law is replete with statutes aimed at protecting California consumers from unfair, dishonest, or harmful market practices.(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that would modernize the current statutes regarding sales of tickets to live entertainment events.(a)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)The Legislature has long considered consumer protection to be a matter of high importance.
(2)State law is replete with statutes aimed at protecting California consumers from unfair, dishonest, or harmful market practices.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that would modernize the current statutes regarding sales of tickets to live entertainment events.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 26, 2024 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 21, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 27, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Jun 12, 2024 | June 18 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Jun 28, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on A., E., S., & T. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on A., E., S., & T. and P. & C.P. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 34. Noes 0. Page 1351.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 1183.) (May 18). |
| May 16, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 15, 2023 | May 15 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 5, 2023 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| May 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0. Page 895.) (April 25). |
| Apr 17, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 1. Page 747.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 14, 2023 | Set for hearing April 25 in JUD. pending receipt. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Coms. on B., P. & E. D. and JUD. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 21, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, and Tourism |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB785 Caballero et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| access tickets | * Support | Apr 17, 2023 |
| Aeg | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| American Association of Independent Music | ** Support | |
| Anaheim Ducks Hockey Club | * Support | Apr 25, 2023 |
| August Hall | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Axiom Advisors | * Support | Apr 25, 2023 |
| Axs | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Council | ** Support | |
| Black Music Action Coalition | ** Support | |
| CA League of United Latin American Citizens | ** Against | |
| Cafe Colonial | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Arts Advocates | ** Support | |
| California Arts Advocates | * Indeterminate | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Black Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Hispanic Chambers Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California LULAC | ** Against | |
| California Urban Partnership | ** Against | |
| Central Valley Latino Mayors and Elected Officials Coalition | ** Against | |
| Central Valley Yemen Society | ** Against | |
| Chamber Of Progress | ** Against | |
| Chamber Of Progress | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| City of Thousand Oaks | ** Support | |
| Coalition For Ticket Fairness | ** Against | |
| Consumer Federation Of California | ** Against | |
| Consumer Federation Of California | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| ENT Legends | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Forty Niners Football Company LLC A Delaware Limited Liability Company | ** Support | |
| Future of Music Coalition | ** Support | |
| Gametime | ** Against | |
| Golden State Warriors | ** Support | |
| Golden State Warriors | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Hispanic 100 | ** Against | |
| Hispanic 100 Foundation | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Honda Center | * Support | Apr 25, 2023 |
| HopMonk | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| International Association of Venue Managers | ** Support | |
| Latin Business Association | ** Against | |
| Latin Business Association | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| LENUSA | ** Against | |
| Live Nation Entertainment Inc | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Live Nation Entertainment, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Rams | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Los Angeles Rams | ** Support | |
| Multicultural Business Alliance | ** Against | |
| Music Artists Coalition | ** Support | |
| Music Artists Coalition | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Music Workers Alliance | ** Support | |
| National Action Network Sacramento Chapter | ** Against | |
| National Consumers League | * Against | Apr 17, 2023 |
| National Consumers League | ** Against | |
| National Football League | ** Support | |
| National Independent Venue Association Of California | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| National Independent Venue Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Nederlander Concerts | ** Support | |
| NetChoice | ** Against | |
| NIVA California | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| NIVA California | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Orange County Business Council | ** Support | |
| Ovg360 | ** Support | |
| Platinum Advisors LLC | * Support | Apr 25, 2023 |
| Progressive Policy Institute | ** Against | |
| Progressive Policy Institute | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Protect Ticket Rights | ** Against | |
| Recording Academy | ** Support | |
| Recording Industry Association Of America | ** Support | |
| SAG-AFTRA | ** Support | |
| San Francisco 49ers | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| San Francisco 49ers | ** Support | |
| San Jose Sharks | ** Support | |
| San Jose Sharks LLC | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| SeatGeek | * Against Unless Amend | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Seatgeek, INC. | ** Against | |
| Si Se Puede | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Si Se Puede Fresno, Tulare, Kings & Kern | ** Against | |
| Songwriters of North America | ** Support | |
| Sports Fan Coalition | * Against | Apr 17, 2023 |
| Sports Fans Coalition | ** Against | |
| StubHub | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Stubhub, INC. | ** Against | |
| ticket network | * Against | Apr 17, 2023 |
| TickPick | * Against Unless Amend | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Tickpick | ** Against | |
| Tickpick, LLC | ** Against | |
| Union of Musicians and Allied Workers | ** Support | |
| Vivid Seats | * Against Unless Amend | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Vivid Seats LLC | ** Against | |
| Women Veterans Alliance | ** Against |
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero)
As Amended Ver:August 21, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
The bill makes various changes to how a ticket seller may advertise, list, or sell a ticket for an entertainment event.
Major Provisions
- Revises the civil penalties that may be imposed on ticket sellers, increasing the maximum penalty from $2,500 to $10,000, for each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter, and requires the court to consider relevant circumstances when determining the civil penalty, including but not limited to all of the following:
- The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
- The number of violations.
- The persistence of the misconduct.
- The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
- The willfulness of the misconduct.
- The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
- Prohibits ticket sellers from advertising, offering for sale, contracting for the sale of a ticket, or accepting consideration for payment in full or a deposit for the sale of a ticket, if the ticket seller does not own, possess, have constructive possession, or have the contractual right to sell a ticket.
- Allows for ticket sellers and ticket resale marketplaces to offer services to obtain tickets on behalf of a purchaser, as long as this service is not marketed or listed as a ticket, and they maintain clear, distinct, and easily discernible separation between the service and a ticket through unavoidable visual demarcation throughout the entire service selection and purchasing process. The service must offer a full refund, or a replacement ticket in the same or a comparable location, if the service is unable to obtain the specified ticket, and the service is prohibited from obtaining more tickets in each transaction than the numerical limitations for tickets set by the event presenter or original seller for each respective event.
- Prohibits ticket sellers or ticket resale marketplaces from using a website to display any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that are substantially similar to the websites of an events presenter, rights holder, or original seller, without their written consent, with the intention to mislead.
COMMENTS
Background. In response to massive customer service issues involving ticket sales for Taylor Swift's 2023 Eras Tour, where tickets were being sold by Ticketmaster in November 2022, three bills were introduced in the California legislature during the 2023 session intended to address the ticket selling ecosystem. The identified issues included the relationship between primary ticket sellers and venues, the secondary market for tickets to entertainment events, and the rights of consumers after purchasing a ticket.
AB 8 (Friedman) would have required all-in ticket pricing and transparency on the fees, and would have required ticket sellers to allow for the transferability of tickets. This transferability was to allow a purchaser that is unable to attend the event the ability to transfer or sell that ticket to another individual, and would ensure that the individual with a resold ticket would be able to use that ticket to enter the event. Transferability is what enables the secondary or resale ticket seller marketplace. In the meantime, following pressure from the federal government, primary and secondary ticket selling platforms agreed to abolish junk fees and to show consumers all fees upfront.
SB 829 (Wilk) would have prohibited exclusive agreements between primary ticket sellers and venue operators. These exclusive agreements with entertainment facilities are common, and are viewed by professional sports teams, arenas and stadiums, and independent venues as being a way to ensure safety and security at events, as well as being a deterrent from fake or counterfeit tickets.
This bill, SB 785 (Caballero), as originally introduced, would have limited the transferability of tickets on the secondary market, by requiring ticket sellers and ticket reseller to own or possess a ticket prior to listing it for sale. Later versions of the bill also included language meant to disallow bots or brokers from using software to circumventing security measures and queues on primary ticket seller websites, to jump ahead in line or purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
Of these ticket seller bills, as well as additional bills on this topic that were introduced in the 2024 legislative session, only SB 785 has made it to third reading of the opposite house from where it was introduced. Additionally, the Assembly's Committees on Privacy & Consumer Protection and Arts, Entertainment, Sports, & Tourism held an informational hearing about online ticketing and access to live entertainment in February 2024.
SB 785, by limiting the transferability of tickets, would in effect have addressed the practice of speculative ticket sales. A speculative ticket refers to instances in which a seller offers a ticket for sale on a secondary ticket exchange before the seller actually possesses the ticket. In some cases, secondary sellers may not disclose the fact that they are selling speculative tickets. These practices harm consumers who either do not receive the tickets they purchased or receive tickets that differ from the ticket or seat advertised. Even if a consumers receive refunds for the ticket price, they may have already incurred nonrefundable costs to attend the event, such as travel or hotel expenses.
For over a decade, secondary resale markets have allowed the sale of tickets that sellers do not actually possess. Specifically, speculative ticket sales work as follows, according to the Center for Investigative Reporting:
"Brokers advertise inventory – sometimes a specific seat, sometimes a seating area – on a resale site, often at a price significantly higher than face value. When a customer selects tickets and checks out, [the site] prompts the broker to then attempt to acquire those tickets elsewhere at a lower price. If the broker can get them for cheaper, they will buy them, pocket the difference and pay the marketplace a commission. If they can't, the broker will either have to make good on the initial offer and take a loss or renege on the sale."
Ticket brokers often refer to this practice as the equivalent of agreeing to stand in line for someone at the box office. They will buy tickets when they go on sale, so that the consumer does not have to wait in front of their computer, constantly refreshing their web browser. However, the consumer is often not aware that they are buying a ticket that the seller does not possess, nor do they realize they are paying a premium price, significantly above the face value, for a ticket that they may or may not receive.
This practice creates considerable confusion for consumers who cannot purchase tickets from the primary box office because they have not gone on sale yet, but are able to purchase tickets for a premium price on the secondary market.
As amended leaving the Assembly Appropriations Committee, SB 785 continues to address speculative ticket sales by maintaining the prohibition on ticket sellers from advertising, offering for sale, and receiving payment for a ticket that they do not own, possess, or have a contractual right to sell, and the increased maximum civil penalty of $10,000 for each ticket sold in violation.
However, the amendments reverse the direction of the bill by removing definitions contained in the previous version and codify a "service" that may be offered by ticket sellers or ticket resale marketplaces to obtain a ticket on behalf of a purchaser. This service, in practice similar to the "Seat Saver" program offered by resale ticket platform Vivid Seats, cannot be marketed or listed as an actual ticket, and must clearly and conspicuously disclose to the purchaser that the service is not a ticket and that purchasing the service does not guarantee a ticket. The amendments require there to be a clear and easily discernible distinction between the service and an actual ticket, with unavoidable visual demarcation that persists throughout the entire service selection and purchasing process.
If this service is unable to obtain the ticket specified by the consumer, the ticket seller or ticket resale marketplace will be required to either offer a full refund or, subject to availability, a replacement ticket in the same or a comparable location with the approval of the purchaser. Although this service can be offered to consumers prior to a ticket going on general sale, the service may not obtain more tickets in each transaction than the numerical limitations for tickets set by the event presenter or original seller for each respective event.
According to the Author
The author has chosen not to provide a statement on the current version of the bill.
Arguments in Support
None on file for the current version of the bill.
Arguments in Opposition
None on file for the current version of the bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS
Ongoing General Fund and special fund costs, of an unknown but potentially significant amount, for staff costs at the Department of Justice (DOJ) associated with this bill.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 34-0-6
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Min, Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood‑Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jones, Menjivar, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto, Wilk
ASM ARTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SPORTS, AND TOURISM: 5-0-2
YES: Quirk-Silva, Mike Fong, Friedman, Hart, Valencia
ABS, ABST OR NV: Wallis, Lackey
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Dixon, Hoover, Irwin, Lowenthal, Ortega, Ward, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Joe Patterson, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: August 21, 2024
CONSULTANT: Brian V. Anderson, Jr. / A.,E.,S., & T. / (916) 319-3450 FN: 0004535
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero) – As Amended Ver:July 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Arts, Entertainment, Sports, and Tourism | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 9 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
The bill makes various changes to how a ticket seller, ticket reseller, and ticket resale marketplace may advertise, list, or sell a ticket for an entertainment event.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State.
- Requires an original ticket seller, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell a ticket before advertising, listing, marketing, or selling the ticket.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller, a ticket resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace from reselling more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event or from employing another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from (a) representing that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website, (b) using on its website trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the holder, and (c) using on its website any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller.
- Declares it unlawful for a person to circumvent restrictions on primary sale tickets. Specifically, prohibits a person, among other prohibitions, from (a) circumventing or disabling an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale, or (b) utilizing multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Increases the current fine of $2,500 to a fine of up to $10,000 for each ticket that is sold or offered for sale in violation of this bill’s chapter.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Ongoing General Fund and Unfair Competition Law Fund costs of about $1 million for staff costs at the Department of Justice (DOJ) associated with this bill.
Specifically, DOJ indicates it will requires three ongoing staff and one limited-term staff in its Antitrust Law Section to handle the litigation impacts and address the increased difficulty of existing litigation. Additional work will include handling consumer complaints, evaluating, and investigating the complaints to determine if they are Antitrust related. These positions would require General Fund support.
DOJ also indicates it will require two ongoing staff in its Consumer Protection Section who would be responsible for enforcement of this bill’s provisions. These positions would require Unfair Competition Law Fund support.
Finally, DOJ indicates that because this bill establishes and expands the scope of a crime, it would result in an increase in arrest prints, which would require overtime for staff at DOJ’s California Justice Information Services. In addition, the bill will require overtime for staff in the Record Management Branch for workload associated with various crime record-related tasks, including coordinating with the Criminal Justice Statistics Center for National Incident-Based Reporting System and Bureau of Criminal Statistics codes, among other duties. This overtime pay would require General Fund support.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Current law regulates ticket brokers but does not apply to the resale platforms where consumer deception and price gouging occurs. This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues. SB 785 will protect consumers, artists, teams, and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently harms consumers and the event presenters who bring live entertainments their fans.
- Background. Recent events related to online ticket sales have drawn criticism by consumers and led to a recent hearing in Congress to probe online ticket retail practices and competition within the ticket market. Specifically, the congressional hearing focused on the company Live Nation/Ticketmaster and how competition can be stifled when a primary ticket seller (Ticketmaster) enters into an exclusive contract with an entertainment venue (Live Nation) to sell tickets to events at the venue.
On May 23, 2024, the United States Department of Justice and 30 state and district attorneys general, including California, filed an anti-trust lawsuit against Live Nation/Ticketmaster.
Existing law regulates various aspects of ticket sales, including requirements around ticket sellers, and contains various penalties, constituting misdemeanors and fines, to ticket sellers who violate ticket retail law. Current law defines “ticket seller” as any person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event.
This bill clarifies and expands existing law to apply to original ticket sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces. The bill has particular focus on ticket resellers and resale marketplaces. (Some examples of ticket resellers include Ticketmaster, StubHub, SeatGeek, and Vivid Seats.) Many of the bill’s provisions related to resellers are in reaction to shifts in how tickets are procured by resellers and then resold. Specifically, certain resale practices have frustrated and led to financial losses to consumers, venues, artists, and other live entertainment stakeholders. These practices include speculative ticketing (reselling a ticket before the reseller possesses the ticket), deceptive marketing practices, and the use of online bots, among others. This bill prohibits or regulates these practices and further seeks to deter violations of ticket retail law by increasing fines.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by various organizations, including several major leagues sports teams, SAG-AFTRA, the National Independent Venue Association of California, and others. The National Independent Venue Association of California writes:
This measure is in no way, shape, or form a giveaway to LiveNation/Ticketmaster as the opponents suggest. Independent venues and promoters have been advocating across the nation for reforms contained in this bill because of the flood of fake tickets we see at our doors night after night that hurt our small businesses…This measure addresses the major challenges independent venues and promoters face with regard to fraudulent tickets or massively overpriced tickets on third-party platforms that hurt our reputations.
This bill is opposed by various organizations, including consumer rights groups, Stubhub, Vivid Seats, and others. A coalition representing consumers, civil justice advocates, non-profits, and businesses write in opposition:
Unfortunately, as currently written, SB 785 enables Live Nation/Ticketmaster to manipulate primary and resale ticketing in anti-competitive ways to grow their monopoly at the expense of consumer…Live Nation/Ticketmaster controls 80% of primary ticket sales in the US…now they want to eliminate relate competition that benefits consumer and force them to resell only through [their] platform.
- Related Legislation. AB 2203 (McCarty) requires a ticket seller to provide an immediate proof of purchase to a consumer and requires a venue operator to honor a proof of purchase for a ticket for entrance to an entertainment venue, if a consumer does not have access to the ticket at the time of the event. A hearing of AB 2203 in the Senate was canceled at the request of author.
AB 2808 (Wicks) prohibits certain entertainment venue operators from entering into an exclusive contract with a primary ticket seller, among other requirements. AB 2808 was held on this committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2024
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SENATE VOTE: 34-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protection: ticket sellers
SYNOPSIS
Taylor Swift fans are flocking to Europe this summer to attend her concerts. Why? For many in the United States, it is cheaper to travel to Paris for a vacation that includes the concert than it is to purchase tickets in their own home towns. The average get-in-the-door price for the upcoming fall concerts in the United States — the lowest price available — are hovering around $2,600 per ticket. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift. In Europe, however, tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States.
This Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee held an informational hearing earlier this year focused on understanding the high price of live entertainment tickets and what action should be taken to rein them in. The Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. In addition to Ticketmaster’s well-known monopolistic control of the primary market, another key pain point in the ticketing business became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California, and throughout much of the country, is fundamentally broken.
Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce explains how turbocharged scalping ruins the fan experience:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice, it continues because the profits are too substantial. This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
Indeed, one of the key reasons that many European countries have vastly cheaper tickets is that these countries extensively regulate the secondary market.
As a long overdue anti-trust lawsuit against Ticketmaster unfolds at the federal level, this bill seeks to complement these efforts by addressing problems in the secondary market by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms. In doing so, the bill enacts meaningful protections for the real consumers of event ticketing—the fans.
Along with the California Chamber of Commerce, this bill is supported by the Future of Music Coalition, the National Football League, the Gold State Warriors, SAG-AFTRA, the National Independent Venue Association, and over a dozen other organizations. In opposition are the Consumer Federation of California, StubHub, Vivid Seats, Seat Geek, and the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, among a number of other organizations.
This bill passed the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee in June 2023 on a 5-0-2 vote. The proposed Committee amendments are minor and clarifying in nature. Because of the number of amendments, a mockup of the bill is included at the end of this analysis.
SUMMARY: Revises and recasts California’s entertainment ticket statutes, particularly as it pertains to reselling tickets. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
- “Consumer” means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
- “Entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
- “Event” means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
- “Event presenter” means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- “Live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
- “Original seller” means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
- “Rights holder” means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
- “Ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
- “Ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, including a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
- “Ticket reseller” means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- “Venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
- If required by a local jurisdiction, original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces must register with the Secretary of State and obtain a license.
- Eliminates the requirement that a ticket seller have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation.
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter will constitute a separate violation which may be brought only by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, a county council or a city prosecutor and requires the court to impose a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 for each violation of the law, along with awarding the prevailing prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney fees. The level of the penalty must be based on the prevailing circumstances and the seriousness of the violation.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller to own, possess, or have a contractual right to a ticket before listing, marketing, or selling the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller at the time of listing or marketing a ticket to disclose to the consumer the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat in the venue, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Eliminates the exemption in current law that allows a ticket seller to market, advertise or sell a ticket if they inform the purchaser orally at the time of contract or receipt of consideration, and within two business days, that the seller does not have possession of the ticket, a contract to obtain the ticket and may not be able to obtain the ticket.
- Prohibits a reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate from doing either of the following:
- Reselling more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employing another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling those tickets.
- Requires that ticket resale marketplaces, before accepting a listing to sell a ticket, require that the person listing the ticket has a right to sell the ticket and is able to deliver it to the consumer.
- States that by allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
- Requires a ticket resale marketplace to disclose on its internet website in each ticket listing the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Repeals a provision of existing law that states that certain ticketing laws do not apply to any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor, with “primary contractor,” defined as the person or organization who is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from using an internet website, or causing an internet website to be used, that displays a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder, or any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
- Prohibits a person from intentionally using, causing to be used, or selling software or services that do any of the following:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rightsholder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Removes the ticketing exemption in current law for non-profit charitable tax-exempt organizations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a “ticket seller” as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22503.)
- Clarifies that the following are not ticket sellers for purposes of existing law:
- An officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package.
- Any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the event premises, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- The person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold, or a seller of tickets operating under a written contract with this person or organization.
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22503.5, 22503.6, 22504, 22511.)
- Requires that ticket sellers:
- Maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22501.)
- Prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.)
- Make any partial or full deposit refundable if received on a future event for which tickets are not available, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent, until such time as tickets for the event are actually available. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22506.)
- Provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event that is canceled. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(a).)
- Provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(b).)
- Provide that a local jurisdiction may require a bond of not more $50,000 to cover required refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(d).)
- Disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22508.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller:
- Has lawful possession of the ticket;
- Has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or
- Informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, that it does not have possession of the ticket, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, of the terms of the deposit agreement and makes required disclosures. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that it can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver the ticket a) within a reasonable time and b) below or within the price and range of prices stated. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.2.)
- Provides a private right of action to ticket purchasers for violations of 5) and 6). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.3.)
- Declares it unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell software or services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure (including limits on the number of tickets a person can purchase) that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.5.)
- Deems a violation of the chapter of the Business and Professions Code containing the provisions above to be a misdemeanor. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22505.)
- Requires a ticket seller to have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation. Makes a violation of this requirement a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both, and provides for civil penalties of up to $2,500 for violations. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22500.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print, this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
1) Background. Gone are the days of camping out overnight in line at a box office hoping to get tickets to a Van Halen, Madonna, or Michael Jackson concert or to one of your favorite team’s games. In that pre-internet era, if overnight camping was not an option, a person could try calling the box office over and over, hoping to break through the busy signal to get an actual person who can sell tickets over the phone if the tickets have not sold out already. If those efforts failed, a fan could listen to their favorite radio station for hours at a time hoping to score free tickets through a call-in giveaway contest. Finally, if nothing else worked and the day of the concert or game arrived, they could take the chance of going to the venue in the hopes of finding a scalper standing in the parking lot, or near the entrance to the venue, holding up a couple of tickets for sale at a premium cash price. Of course, this last-ditch effort meant that fans ran the risk of being ripped off by a scalper selling fake tickets. But diehard fans often considered it a chance worth taking.
Buying tickets online. While some things remain unchanged for the music and sports fan, technology and the internet have profoundly changed the experience of ticket buying. The live entertainment ticket ecosystem is now simultaneously much more complicated and much more convenient. Largely gone are the days of box offices and paper tickets. Now, in theory, when tickets go on sale for a concert or a game, fans go to the online ticket platform that is selling those tickets (often Ticketmaster) to purchase them and then have them delivered electronically. However, the reality is more complicated, depending how the consumer enters the online marketplace.
Today, the ticket market is broken down into on-sale primary vendors—comprised of venues and online primary ticket platforms—and the secondary (or resale) market, which is made up of ticket brokers and resale marketplace platforms, such as StubHub, SeatGeek, and Vivid Seats. Adding to the confusion, there is significant crossover between the two markets. For example, Ticketmaster operates a resale platform and SeatGeek operates as both a primary and secondary platform. When multiple secondary platforms and the on-sale primary vendor are all competing for ticket buyers, it can be very difficult for consumers to know where to buy tickets or even whether or not they are getting an actual ticket.
The primary market. The primary market is one in which event organizers control the ticket price, the sharing of the revenue between the artist, venue operator, and ticket company, and the decision as to which platform will sell the tickets. The prices set in the primary market heavily affect the volume and value of tickets in the secondary market. In general, it is most common to find underpriced tickets—tickets that sell on the primary market with a face value that is below their market value—so that event organizers can maximize the attendance of their target audience in order to increase customer loyalty, and merchandise sales.[1] To complicate ticket selling in the primary market, some artists have been known to hold back a portion of tickets to sell on the resale market in order to take advantage of the higher prices while still maintaining fan loyalty by offering the initial tickets at a low price.[2]
The secondary market. The secondary market is where tickets purchased on the primary market are resold. Ticket prices are usually significantly higher when purchased from someone in the secondary market. A study conducted by the National Independent Talent Organizations (NITO) analyzed data from 65 different shows around the country in 2023 where artists represented by NITO members performed. According to their findings, on average, ticket buyers were charged twice as much when buying tickets in the secondary market.[3] Secondary market platforms not only serve as a way for professional ticket brokers (i.e. businesses that purchase event tickets solely for the purpose of reselling them for a profit) to sell tickets, they also play an important role by providing consumers who can no longer use their tickets a relatively simple way of recouping their money and perhaps making a profit by reselling them to someone else.
The platforms, for a fee, provide the infrastructure and technology that make up the marketplace for brokers and individuals to resell their tickets. Professional ticket brokers either enter into agreements with sports teams and promoters to have access to tickets for resale or they compete with consumers in the primary marketplace to purchase tickets that they intend to resell at a profit on the platforms. Generally speaking, these secondary market platforms, such as StubHub, Vivid Seats, TickPicks, SeatGeek, and the secondary platforms run by Ticketmaster and their main competitor AXS, are similar to eBay (the former parent company for StubHub) or Etsy. This means that individual entities, who are generally not associated with the platform, are the ones selling the merchandise – tickets, in this case.
Speculative ticket sales. A speculative ticket refers to instances in which a seller offers a ticket for sale on a secondary ticket exchange before the seller actually has the ticket. In some cases, secondary sellers may not disclose the fact that they are selling speculative tickets. These practices harm consumers who either do not receive the tickets they purchased or receive tickets that differ from the ticket or seat advertised. Even if consumers receive refunds for the ticket price, they may have already incurred nonrefundable costs to attend the event, such as travel or hotel expenses.[4]
For over a decade, secondary resale markets have allowed the sale of tickets that sellers do not actually possess. Specifically, speculative ticket sales work as follows, according to the Center for Investigative Reporting:
Brokers advertise inventory – sometimes a specific seat, sometimes a seating area – on a resale site, often at a price significantly higher than face value. When a customer selects tickets and checks out, [the site] prompts the broker to then attempt to acquire those tickets elsewhere at a lower price. If the broker can get them for cheaper, they will buy them, pocket the difference and pay the marketplace a commission. If they can’t, the broker will either have to make good on the initial offer and take a loss or renege on the sale.[5]
Ticket brokers often refer to this practice as the equivalent of agreeing to stand in line for someone at the box office. They will buy tickets when they go on sale, so that the consumer does not have to wait in front of their computer, constantly refreshing their web browser. However, the consumer is often not aware that they are buying a ticket that the seller does not possess, nor do they realize they are paying a premium price, significantly above the face value, for a ticket that they may or may not receive.
This practice creates considerable confusion for consumers who cannot purchase tickets from the primary box office because they have not gone on sale yet, but are able to purchase tickets for a premium price on the secondary market. As a recent example, before the tickets for a Justin Timberlake concert scheduled for May in San Jose were officially on sale through Ticketmaster, they were advertised for sale on a number of secondary platforms. In fact, the first three websites at the top of an internet search were already selling tickets. The first website, StubHub, offered tickets for sale and nothing easily identifiable on the platform suggested that the tickets were speculative. The next website, VividSeats, indicated in the “notes” section that the tickets being purchased were a “seat saver” listing and that the purchaser will either receive the tickets or a full refund. The third website, “TicketsOffice.org” also did not advertise the tickets as speculative.
2) Live Nation/Ticketmaster anti-trust lawsuit. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and 30 state and district attorneys general filed an anti-trust lawsuit against Live Nation Entertainment on May 23, 2024. In the suit, the US government asks the courts to break up Live Nation, or at the very least separate Ticketmaster from the conglomerate. The US DOJ accuses Live Nation of leveraging its power in the entertainment industry to dominate the industry by locking venues into exclusive ticketing contracts, pressuring artists to use its services and threatening its rivals with financial retribution.
California Attorney General, Rob Bonta, joined the suit. According to the Attorney General’s office:
The lawsuit alleges Live Nation violated Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, which prohibits anticompetitive agreements, monopolization, and attempted monopolization. Monopolization offenses occur when a single firm maintains a monopoly unlawfully, by using its control of the market to exclude rivals and harm competition. In addition, the complaint alleges violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law.
The complaint filed today alleges that Live Nation protects its monopoly by using both exclusive contracts with promoters and venues to protect its dominant position in the live music industry to force artists and venues to use both its ticketing and concert promotion services. Live Nation uses their market dominance to leverage its power over all other aspects of the live music entertainment industry: from artist management, to ticketing, and promotions. For example, Live Nation has used their dominance in promotions to force venues to use Ticketmaster’s ticketing services, thereby blocking innovation and unfairly competing with competitors in the music concert business.
In the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta, U.S. DOJ, and coalition states allege that Live Nation has:
- Harmed fans through higher fees. Fans’ ticketing experience — from buying a ticket to showtime — is also worse than it would be if the industry was competitive.
- Maintained its monopoly in ticketing markets by locking up venues through restrictive long-term, exclusive agreements and threats that venues will lose access to Live Nation-controlled tours and artists if they sign with a rival ticketer.
- Leveraged its extensive network of venues to force artists to select Live Nation as a promoter instead of its rivals, maintaining its promotions monopoly.
In filing the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta joins the U.S. Department of Justice and the attorneys general of Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming, and the District of Columbia. [6]
According to the judge recently assigned to the case, the trial could begin as early as March 2026.[7]
3) How is the ticket buying experience different in other countries? It is in large part due to Taylor Swift, arguably the most popular musical artist in history, that the cost of live entertainment tickets and the difficulties in the market continue to be top of mind for lawmakers and entertainment and business journalists. Originally, Swifties were outraged in November 2022 when millions flocked to Ticketmaster.com to grab tickets to see her perform for the first time since 2018 and the website crashed. The long wait lines and frozen screens sparked an uproar with fans blaming Ticketmaster for ruining their chances to see the pop star. While the initial anger reportedly stemmed from the Ticketmaster platform being unable to handle that volume of activity, the larger, on-going outrage stems from consumers discovering that tickets are instantly sold out, but within minutes are offered on secondary resale marketplaces for thousands of dollars. According to the Los Angeles Times, the face value of the tickets for Swift’s concert at SoFi Stadium ranged from $49 to $449. However, tickets on StubHub were quickly being sold for around $800 up to $11,000.[8]
Billboard recently reported:
Prices to see [Taylor] Swift at one of her final nine shows in the United States have increased following the release of the album April 19, with the average get-in-the-door price — the lowest price available — hovering around $2,600 per ticket, according to data from TicketIQ. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift in Miami . . , New Orleans . . . and Indianapolis . . . this fall.
In Europe, however . . . tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States. . . . That means a fan in Miami could fly to Paris for about $900 a person . . . spend two nights at a four-star hotel at $250 a night and purchase a $340 concert ticket for a grand total of $1,740 — which is still $760 less than the cheapest tickets currently available for her Miami shows.
Tickets to see Swift in Stockholm . . . are even cheaper, at $312 for the cheapest tickets, while tickets for her show in Portugal . . . start at $336 and in Spain . . . start at $324.[9]
Opponents of this bill have argued that one of the reasons that Swift tickets remain so much lower is because Ticketmaster does not have the same control over the market in other countries. Policymakers in the state and federal government have agreed that Live Nation Entertainment/Ticketmaster’s oversized market share represents a significant problem. However, as noted above, the face value price of Taylor Swift tickets during the United States leg of her tour, particularly here in California, were in a similar range as those in Europe. So, it is unclear what impact their domination in the primary market played in this case.
The opposition has also posited that another reason for the difference in ticket prices is that Swift is not as popular in Europe, so the demand is not as great. However, Swift fans at her recent sold-out concerts in Edinburgh, Scotland may beg to differ. According to reports from the British Geological Survey, Swift’s fans caused an actual earthquakes during her concerts. Seismic readings were detected almost 4 miles away from the stadium.[10]
While this bill is not about or for Ms. Swift, her popularity, the interest of the media, and the loud voices and devotion of her fans provide an opportunity to clearly observe the problems in the United States’ entertainment ticket market and compare it to ticket markets in other countries.
4) European countries’ continue to distrust “touts.” Despite the fact that ticket brokers and other secondary resellers are directly competing with consumers in the primary ticket market and may be the reason they cannot find tickets, people in the United States have embraced the resale ticket market as a valid business model that provides consumers with the ability to purchase tickets to events that they could not otherwise attend, albeit at a premium price. This is not the case in many European countries where consumers, policymakers, and mainstream media have remained wary of the practice of purchasing tickets in order to resell them at an inflated price, which the U.K. refers to as “touting.”
Ticket market experts point to this general distrust as one of the reasons for the difference in ticket prices between the United States and Europe, while the United States has turned its attention to the domination of Live Nation Entertainment, the parent company for Ticketmaster, as the main driver behind skyrocketing ticket prices.[11] Policymakers in other countries have taken concerns related to the price of tickets and the resale market so seriously that one of the planks that the Labour party in Britain is running on for the upcoming July 4th election is a commitment to cap the price of resale tickets. According to the Change Labour Party Manifesto 2024:
With Labour, the arts and music will no longer be the preserve of a privileged few. Culture is an essential part of supporting children and young people to develop creativity and find their voice. . . . Access to music, drama and sport has become difficult and expensive because of ticket touting. Labour will put fans back at the heart of events by introducing new consumer protections on ticket resales.[12]
In reporting on the commitment to regulate the resale market, the BBC reports, “Labour will cap the resale prices of tickets and regulate resale platforms if the party wins the next general election, Sir Keir Starmer has said. The plans will clamp down on ticket touts who rip off music and sports fans going to live events, Sir Keir said.”[13]
4) Joint Informational Hearing: Online Ticketing and Access to Live Entertainment (Feb. 13, 2024). During a joint informational hearing earlier this year between this Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee, the Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. One thing became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California is fundamentally broken.
It has become virtually impossible for average consumers to find tickets for sale from the primary online box office for a myriad of reasons: popular events are immediately sold out within seconds of the tickets going on sale, while they simultaneously pop up on resale marketplaces at significantly inflated prices; a simple Google search for tickets presents consumers with link after link to resale marketplaces because the company has paid to boost their site on the search engine; a website that appears to be the official site for the event (i.e. muppetslivetickets.com) is actually a white label site that links to a secondary market place platform; or the tickets being advertised for sale are actually speculative tickets because even though the event has been announced, the actual tickets have not gone on sale yet.
During the hearing, venue operator after venue operator expressed frustration with having to deal with angry and frustrated fans who showed up at the venue with tickets that were fake. According to their testimony, this is a growing problem and for many of them it is happening every night that there is a show at their venue.
These small business owners told of shows that were sold out and the venue purchased food and beverages and staffed the venue for a large crowd, only to find that the venue ended up being half empty because a ticket broker had purchased all of the tickets to the event but had been unable to resell them. This particular problem does not initially seem like a significant one for venues because they have sold all of the available tickets. However, venues generally do not make their revenue from the sale of tickets that revenue goes to the artist. The primary revenue for the venue comes from selling food, beverages, and merchandise. So, when a venue has staffed up and ordered enough supplies for a sold out crowd and they do not show up, the venue ends up losing money on the show.
Similarly, representatives for artists spoke of the importance of the relationship between artists and their fans. Artists often price tickets in a reasonable range that will allow their fans to afford to attend. When those tickets are purchased by scalpers or ticket brokers, in violation of the posted terms and conditions, and resold for several times the original price, not only do the artists and venues not make any increased revenue from the higher prices but the artist’s fans often become upset and blame the artist for the high price of the tickets.
All of this is not to suggest that the Committee does not believe that there are also major problems in the primary marketplace related to the fact that Ticketmaster enjoys a monopoly by controlling 80 percent of ticket sales. But the artists, their managers, the venue operators, and the consumer experts all overwhelmingly agreed that the largest and most immediate problems they faced were due to an out-of-control secondary market where the primary business model involves competing with actual consumers in the primary market in order to then turn around and sell the tickets to the same consumers at greatly inflated prices.[14]
5) Purpose of this bill. Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce states these reasons why this bill is needed:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice,[15] it continues because the profits are too substantial.[16] This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans[17] and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.[18]
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
It is these problems in the secondary market that this bill seeks to address by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms.
6) Author’s statement. According to the author:
SB 785 will reform the laws governing the purchase and sale of tickets to live entertainment and sporting events in California, and create meaningful protections for consumers, artists, teams, and local venues.
Current law regulates ticket brokers but does not apply to the resale platforms where consumer deception and price gouging occurs. This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues.
SB 785 will protect consumers, artists, teams, and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently harms consumers and the event presenters who bring live entertainments their fans. Specifically, this bill will:
- Impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at checkout.
- End the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.
- Establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.
- Establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.
This bill puts fans and live entertainment creators—rather than scalpers who prey on fans--first. In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the rights of the artists, entertainers, and teams to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to ensure the availability of face values
7) What this bill does. This bill includes the following significant changes to current entertainment ticket law:
Prohibits speculative tickets sales. Ends speculative ticket sales, except in instances where a ticket seller has a contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket must own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or a ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing, and before selling, disclose to the purchaser the specific seat within the venue that the purchaser is entitled to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have a contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, to disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
Restricts ticket purchases from the primary box office. Declares if unlawful for a person to do the following in order to circumvent restrictions on primary sale tickets:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined posted terms and conditions of the rights holder, event presenter, and venue operator.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
Prohibits deceptive marketing practices. Prohibit using a box office website that looks substantially similar to the venue or primary seller’s website in order to direct sales to the resale market. Specifically prohibits the following:
- A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
- Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available from the original seller.
Increases penalties. Increases the current fine of $2,500 to a fine of up to $10,000 for each ticket that is sold or offered for sale in violation of the chapter.
- Action may be brought by:
- The Attorney General.
- A district attorney.
- A city attorney.
- A county council of a county.
- A city prosecutor in a city.
- In addition to the fines, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates the sections of this bill related to speculative tickets, deceptive marketing, or prohibited purchasing practices is civilly liable to the consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending.
8) Analysis. As discussed throughout this analysis, the conditions in the ticket resale market have not only caused prices to skyrocket, but have also allowed unscrupulous ticket resellers to mislead consumers who are attempting to purchase tickets to attend a live entertainment event. This bill seeks to prohibit some of the most deceptive practices and addresses a number of the concerns raised during this Committee’s informational hearing.
Among their other concerns, opponents of this bill have consistently pointed to two issues related to this bill. First, the inclusion of broad terms and conditions for event presenters. On this topic, StubHub, in an “oppose unless amended” position, writes:
Sec 9. 22503.3 endorses an event presenter’s (i.e. LNE) ability to unilaterally set, impose, and enforce terms and conditions on ticket sales, ticket pricing, the transfer or resale of tickets sold, as well as the technologies used to sell tickets. This effectively endorses anticompetitive terms and conditions and restrictive technologies that limit consumer choice and further engrains a monopoly that is alleged by the DOJ and Attorney General Bonta to use anti-competitive tactics to disadvantage artists, venues, consumers, and competitors. We respectfully request that this committee remove Sec. 9 from the bill to protect consumers, the broader industry and competition in the live event space.
The most recent author’s amendments (as amended June 27, 2024) removed this section from the bill.
Secondly, opponents have expressed concern related to requirements that the original face value of a ticket be included in any resale posting. On this point, the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, an association of ticket brokers and secondary platforms, notes:
. . . [T]he bill uses the guise of “transparency” to further suffocate competition from the secondary market by imposing requirements on resellers that in many instances would be impossible to meet, such as listing the face value of tickets that are resold or requiring a specific seat location for tickets that consumers purchase in a particular “zone” of a venue. The so called “transparency” proponents request in SB 785 has no public policy benefit and is merely intended to further stifle the secondary market.
In a world of dynamic primary pricing, the “face value” of a ticket is difficult if not impossible to verify, and can lead to confusion that may encourage consumers make a poor financially decision. It is very common for a primary seller to drip supply into the market at a given price, for example $50. If those tickets sell “too fast”, they may sell the row in front or behind (or the seats next to) the $50 seats at $75, then when those sell, at $100 and so on… A consumer given the face value information buying a $50 ticket on the secondary market might balk at a price of $80, when an almost identical seat with a face value of $100 might be sold at $90. Simply because someone is losing money on a $100 ticket does not mean the consumer is better off paying $90 vs $80 for identical tickets. What someone paid at one point in time is not relevant to the consumer’s buying decision, but knowing how many tickets were sold and if more tickets may become available would be.
Author’s amendments, taken on June 24, 2024, remove the requirement that tickets being resold contain information related to the original face price of the ticket.
9) What remains to be done? While more remains to be done in both the primary and secondary markets, this bill addresses some of the most significant problems in the secondary market and significantly increases the consumer protections for fans who are purchasing tickets in order to attend live events. Based on discussions with artists, consumers, venue operators, and talent organizations and research into ticketing practices in other states and other countries, legislators may want to consider the following policies in future legislation:
Price caps. Likely the single most impactful policy for controlling the price of tickets is a cap both on the resale price and on the amount of fees secondary marketplaces can charge for allowing the tickets to be sold on their platforms. The primary driver between the price of tickets in California and the prices in other countries can be traced to capping the amount someone is allowed to resell a ticket for. In Europe, prices are kept low thanks to laws limiting how high tickets can be marked up over face value. In countries like France, Germany and the Netherlands, ticket resellers face limits on how much tickets can be marked up on secondary sites — typically 20 percent over face value. Since 2021, Ireland has capped the resale price of a ticket at what it originally sold for in the primary market. Maryland, in its recent legislation was considering a ten percent cap on resale tickets.[19]
While generally limiting prices in most markets could be seen as something to be leery of, this market is the rare exception where there is a justification to limit resale prices given all of the abuses detailed throughout this analysis.
In addition to capping the resale price, legislators should also consider capping the fees that can be charged by resale platforms. Unlike the primary ticket fees, which are generally shared between the ticket seller and the venue operator, resale fees, in most cases, solely benefit the resale platform.
The rights of artists. While the author has removed the language in the bill allowing for event presenter’s to exercise sweeping authority over the way in which tickets are priced, transferred, sold, and resold, there is a strong argument for enshrining in state law the rights of artists to establish terms and conditions and maintain control over their own work product.
Enumerating a limited range of terms and conditions turned over to artists allows clear artist control over the provisions that matter most to them like restricting resale to face value, using adjusted pricing, or making tickets available to fan club members. All of these choices are examples of decisions that artists should be allowed to control.
Protecting a consumers’ ability to either resell or give away a ticket they cannot use. Equally important in the policies that should be considered is the question of what someone should be able to do with a ticket they are unable to use. The most consumer-protective approach is to require that ticket sellers ensure that consumers can exchange a ticket at face value to recoup their money, give the ticket away to someone of their choosing, or be able to try to resell it on the secondary marketplace for a capped amount. This would ensure that the ticket will not go unused.
Exploring exclusivity contracts. Small venue operators have been very clear that exclusive contracts with primary ticket sellers is a critical part of their business model. However, given Live Nation’s dominance, while the anti-trust lawsuit is being decided at the federal level, lawmakers may want to consider limiting exclusive contracts when the venue operator, the event promoter, and the primary ticket seller are all part of the same company. This approach, arguably, would provide openings in the primary ticket market for other companies to gain a larger market share and it would eliminate some of the most egregious practices in the primary market.
10) Suggested Committee amendments. Though primarily clarifying in nature, the suggested Committee amendments are spread throughout the bill. A complete mock-up is included as an attachment at the end of this analysis.
11) Related legislation. AB 2203 (McCarty, 2024) requires ticket sellers that sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event, to immediately deliver a proof of purchase to a consumer, and would require a venue operator to honor that proof of purchase in lieu of the ticket if specified conditions are met. This bill is currently awaiting hearing in the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee.
AB 2808 (Wicks, 2024) prohibited certain entertainment venue operators from entering into an exclusive contract with a primary ticket seller. That bill was held on the Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) requires a ticket seller to disclose to a purchaser the total price of the ticket and the portion of that price that represents any fees or surcharges. The seller must also provide a link to an internet webpage that includes certain refund requirements, as specified. This bill is currently on the suspense file in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits the operator of an entertainment facility and a primary ticket seller from entering into a contract that provides for the primary ticket seller to be the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. SB 829 is currently in this Committee.
SB 478 (Dodd; Ch. 400, Stats. of 2023) makes it an unlawful business practice pursuant to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act to advertise, display, or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than taxes imposed by a government.
AB 1556 (Friedman, Ch. 180, Stats. 2021) requires for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation; and requires a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
AB 329 (Pan, Ch. 325, Stats. 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Writing in support of the bill, the National Independent Venue Association (NIVA) states:
I want to be clear: this measure is in no way, shape, or form a giveaway to LiveNation/Ticketmaster as the opponents suggest. Independent venues and promoters have been advocating across the nation for reforms contained in this bill because of the flood of fake tickets we see at our doors night after night that hurt our small businesses. Taylor Swift does not grace our stages but we unfortunately see fake tickets night after night and often look on the secondary platform sites to see our $30 tickets priced at $150 when we have inventory available on our websites.
Just last week on June 8th, the Sonoma Press-Democrat published an article, entitled “Sonoma, Napa county venues are warning concertgoers about uptick in inflated, fake tickets,” that offers a snapshot of what our member venues deal with night after night. Certain deceptive websites, appearing to be affiliated with venues, are actually third-party vendors with no connection to the venue. These sites often rank highly in search engine results for tickets, presenting themselves as official outlets, yet they charge inflated prices, sometimes up to triple the face value of the ticket.
The opposition to this measure would argue this proposal strengthens a monopoly’s hold on the industry. This is not true. This measure addresses the major challenges independent venues and promoters face with regard to fraudulent tickets or massively overpriced tickets on third-party platforms that hurt our reputations.
Opponents would also have you believe that empowering the secondary market will “increase competition” and promote “ticket freedom.” This is also not true and doing so as they articulate will increase the likelihood of predatory practices thus diminishing the fan experience at a show. Without banning speculative and predatory ticketing practices, fans may have more places to purchase tickets, but will have less guarantees that the ticket is real/valid, resulting in a terrible experience when they arrive and find out their ticket is fake and they can’t get into the show. SB 785 takes these necessary steps to truly protect not only the consumer (fans), but the artists and the venues who depend on the trust and engagement of the fans.
By considerately putting the fan first, SB 785 will help to ensure that fans get valid tickets, artists perform to more fans at their shows, and venues will have a better chance of protecting their businesses and reputations. There have been many bills in California, and around the country, that have attempted to reshape and reform ticketing but SB 785 has the most potential to simultaneously protect fans, artists and venues from deceptive, inflammatory and predatory ticket resellers in a model for the rest of the country.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Echoing the concerns raised by several groups the Consumer Federation of California, writes:
On May 23rd of this year the federal Department of Justice, joined by 29 states and the District of Columbia, [sued the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly] for violating antitrust law and urged that it be broken up. The 29 states that joined in the lawsuit included California and our Attorney General as well as the following states: Arkansas, Florida, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia, and Wyoming, to just name a few. This speaks to the overwhelming bipartisan nature of legal concern with the monopolistic actions of Live Nation/Ticketmaster ever since their merger in 2010.
[ . . .]
The lawsuit filed by the federal DOJ plus 30 jurisdictions serves, among other things, as an invitation to the federal government and the states to take stronger action on behalf of consumers to limit the destructiveness of the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly while the case attempting to break it up winds its way slowly through the U.S. court system. Historically antitrust cases like this have taken numerous years to adjudicate, so the California Legislature should act now to significantly trim the wings of the monopoly.
Instead, respectfully, SB 785 aims its sights squarely on what limited competition there is in the marketplace against the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly. SB 785’s general approach is to make things worse for consumers by making things better for the monopoly as they fight the lawsuit striking at the heart of their corporate practices. This is misguided.
That is not to say that there aren’t productive conversations to be had about so-called speculative ticketing, where consumers think they have a ticket to a show but the entity they “bought” it from has to go out and secure that ticket after the consumer has paid, or deceptive websites that fool consumers into thinking they are interacting with the actual concert venue only to find out that they’ve been defrauded. But these issues pale in comparison to the larger problems directly foisted upon consumers by the monopoly and the various issues that would help consumers by legislatively limiting monopoly power. Taking on the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly seems to be later on the legislative priority list than helping the monopoly harm consumers by forcing their competition to take a haircut while the monopoly, their apologists and allies egg them on.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of Independent Music
Axs
Bay Area Council
Black Music Action Coalition
California Arts Advocates
California Chamber of Commerce
City of Thousand Oaks
Forty Niners Football Company Llc, a Delaware Limited Liability Company
Future of Music Coalition
Golden State Warriors
International Association of Venue Managers
Live Nation Entertainment, INC.
Los Angeles Rams
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
National Football League
National Independent Venue Association of California
Nederlander Concerts
Orange County Business Council
Ovg360
Recording Academy
Recording Industry Association of America
SAG-AFTRA
San Francisco 49ers
San Jose Sharks
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
Opposition
Coalition for Ticket Fairness
Consumer Federation of California
Netchoice (UNREG)
Progressive Policy Institute
Protect Ticket Rights
Sports Fans Coalition
Vivid Seats LLC
Oppose Unless Amended
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Lulac
California Urban Partnership
Central Valley Latino Mayors and Elected Officials Coalition
Central Valley Yemen Society
Chamber of Progress
Gametime
Hispanic 100
Latin Business Association
Lenusa
Multicultural Business Alliance
National Action Network - Sacramento Chapter
National Consumers League
Seatgeek, INC.
Si Se Puede Fresno, Tulare, Kings & Kern
Stubhub, INC.
Tickpick
Tickpick, LLC
Women Veterans Alliance
SUGGESTED COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 22500 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22500. (a) Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b) A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c) For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1) The Attorney General.
(2) A district attorney.
(3) A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4) A county counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5) A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d) In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. Additionally, the court shall award a prevailing public prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney’s fees. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1) The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2) The number of violations.
(3) The persistence of the misconduct.
(4) The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5) The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6) The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e) The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2. Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22501. Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year after the initial sale.
SEC. 3. Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22502. (a) An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a that entertainment venue.
SEC. 4. Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.3. (a) It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) A reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a reseller or resale marketplace shall not do either of the following:
- Resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employ another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
SEC. 5. Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22502.1. (a) (1) A ticket resale marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer consumer.
(2) By allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
(b) A ticket resale marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within an entertainment venue.
SEC. 6. Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.4. I It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7. Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.5. In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs.
SEC. 8. Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22503. (a) An “artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
(b) A “consumer,” as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(c) An “entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
(d) An “event,” as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(e) An “event presenter,” as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(f) A “live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
(g) An “original seller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
(h) A “rights holder,” as used in this chapter, means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
(i) A “ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
(j) A “ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resaleincluding a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
(k) A “ticket reseller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
(l) A “venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
SEC. 9. Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 10. Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22503.4. This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 11. Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22505.2. (a) A person ticket reseller shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a) (1) A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b) (2) Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller.
(b) A ticket reseller shall not represent that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term sold out when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
SEC. 12. Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22505.1. Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a) Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b) Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c) Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d) Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rights holder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
(e) Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 13. Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22507. (a) The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser consumer by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser consumer, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b) The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser consumer by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c) For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser consumer is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d) A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 14. Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 15. Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22511. This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.
SEC. 16. No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
Analysis Prepared by: Julie Salley / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
The Event Ticketing Industry is Broken and in Need of Disruption, Aventus Network (May 19, 2017). ↑
Tyler Jenke, “Ed Sheeran’s manager has admitted to selling tickets to resale services,” The Music Network (Jun 3, 2018) available at https://themusicnetwork.com/ed-sheeran-manager-sold-tickets-resale/. ↑
NITO Ticket Resale Study. National Independent Talent Organization (Jul 2023) ↑
Ibid. ↑
Duncan, Byard. “How is this Legal?” The Center for Investigative Reporting, March 8, 2021, available at https://revealnews.org/article/how-is-this-legal/. ↑
California Department of Justice. Attorney General Bonta Files Lawsuit Against Live Nation, Ticketmaster (May 23, 2024) https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-files-lawsuit-against-live-nation-ticketmaster. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Judge in Live Nation Antitrust Case Indicates Possible Start Date for Blockbuster Trial,” Billboard (Jun. 28. 2024) https://www.billboard.com/pro/live-nation-antitrust-case-judge-possible-trial-start-date/, ↑
Fox, Emma. “$11,000 to see Taylor Swift? How concert tickets got so expensive,” The Los Angeles Times (July 27, 2023) https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2023-07-27/explaining-the-complicated-world-of-ticketing. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Why Are Taylor Swift Eras Tour Tickets So Much Cheaper in Europe?” Billboard (May 2, 2024) https://www.billboard.com/business/touring/taylor-swift-eras-tour-tickets-cheaper-europe-1235671760/. ↑
Melnick, Kyle. “Swifties set off earthquake sensors again. These songs made the biggest stir.” The Washington Post (Jun. 13, 2024) https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/2024/06/13/taylor-swift-concert-fans-dance-earthquake-sensors/. ↑
While Ticketmaster’s domination is a legitimate concern, as discussed earlier in this analysis, the available data does not support the fact that primary market prices account for the high price of tickets. ↑
Geiger, Chas. “Keir Starmer vows to cap resale music and sport ticket prices,” BBC (Mar. 14, 2024) https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-68563793. ↑
Ibid. ↑
For additional information, a detailed background paper and a video link to the hearing is available at https://apcp.assembly.ca.gov/hearings/2023-24-informationaloversight-hearings. ↑
President Obama signed the Better Online Ticket Sales (BOTS) Act in December of 2016. Discussed here: https://www.westarts.org/news-updates/the-battle-between-bots-and-the-ticket-industry-continues, and here https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/president-obama-signs-bots-act-law-7625257/. ↑
As an example, the Federal Trade Commission Action against three scalpers for $3.7 million for buying over 150,000 tickets and re-selling them. https://www.pcmag.com/news/3-scalpers-fined-for-using-bots-to-scoop-up-tickets-on-ticketmaster ↑
https://www.npr.org/2021/12/10/1063237219/olivia-rodrigo-sour-tour-tickets ↑
https://themanc.com/audio/fans-fume-as-taylor-hawkins-tribute-concert-tickets-appear-on-resale-sites-for-four-times-the-price/ ↑
While the final version of Maryland’s ticketing reform bill did not include caps, it is expected that caps will be reintroduced in their next legislative session. ↑
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2024
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SENATE VOTE: 34-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protection: ticket sellers
SYNOPSIS
Taylor Swift fans are flocking to Europe this summer to attend her concerts. Why? For many in the United States, it is cheaper to travel to Paris for a vacation that includes the concert than it is to purchase tickets in their own home towns. The average get-in-the-door price for the upcoming fall concerts in the United States — the lowest price available — are hovering around $2,600 per ticket. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift. In Europe, however, tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States.
This Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee held an informational hearing earlier this year focused on understanding the high price of live entertainment tickets and what action should be taken to rein them in. The Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. In addition to Ticketmaster’s well-known monopolistic control of the primary market, another key pain point in the ticketing business became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California, and throughout much of the country, is fundamentally broken.
Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce explains how turbocharged scalping ruins the fan experience:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice, it continues because the profits are too substantial. This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
Indeed, one of the key reasons that many European countries have vastly cheaper tickets is that these countries extensively regulate the secondary market.
As a long overdue anti-trust lawsuit against Ticketmaster unfolds at the federal level, this bill seeks to complement these efforts by addressing problems in the secondary market by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms. In doing so, the bill enacts meaningful protections for the real consumers of event ticketing—the fans.
Along with the California Chamber of Commerce, this bill is supported by the Future of Music Coalition, the National Football League, the Gold State Warriors, SAG-AFTRA, the National Independent Venue Association, and over a dozen other organizations. In opposition are the Consumer Federation of California, StubHub, Vivid Seats, Seat Geek, and the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, among a number of other organizations.
This bill passed the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee in June 2023 on a 5-0-2 vote. The proposed Committee amendments are minor and clarifying in nature. Because of the number of amendments, a mockup of the bill is included at the end of this analysis.
SUMMARY: Revises and recasts California’s entertainment ticket statutes, particularly as it pertains to reselling tickets. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
- “Consumer” means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
- “Entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
- “Event” means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
- “Event presenter” means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- “Live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
- “Original seller” means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
- “Rights holder” means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
- “Ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
- “Ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, including a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
- “Ticket reseller” means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- “Venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
- If required by a local jurisdiction, original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces must register with the Secretary of State and obtain a license.
- Eliminates the requirement that a ticket seller have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation.
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter will constitute a separate violation which may be brought only by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, a county council or a city prosecutor and requires the court to impose a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 for each violation of the law, along with awarding the prevailing prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney fees. The level of the penalty must be based on the prevailing circumstances and the seriousness of the violation.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller to own, possess, or have a contractual right to a ticket before listing, marketing, or selling the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller at the time of listing or marketing a ticket to disclose to the consumer the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat in the venue, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Exempts from 6) flexible series ticket options that allow consumers to commit to a number of performances in a season in advance, while choosing the specific performances at a later date.
- Eliminates the exemption in current law that allows a ticket seller to market, advertise or sell a ticket if they inform the purchaser orally at the time of contract or receipt of consideration, and within two business days, that the seller does not have possession of the ticket, a contract to obtain the ticket and may not be able to obtain the ticket.
- Prohibits a reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate from doing either of the following:
- Reselling more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employing another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling those tickets.
- Requires that ticket resale marketplaces, before accepting a listing to sell a ticket, require that the person listing the ticket has a right to sell the ticket and is able to deliver it to the consumer.
- States that by allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
- Requires a ticket resale marketplace to disclose on its internet website in each ticket listing the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Repeals a provision of existing law that states that certain ticketing laws do not apply to any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor, with “primary contractor,” defined as the person or organization who is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from using an internet website, or causing an internet website to be used, that displays a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder, or any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
- Prohibits a person from intentionally using, causing to be used, or selling software or services that do any of the following:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rightsholder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Removes the ticketing exemption in current law for non-profit charitable tax-exempt organizations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a “ticket seller” as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22503.)
- Clarifies that the following are not ticket sellers for purposes of existing law:
- An officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package.
- Any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the event premises, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- The person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold, or a seller of tickets operating under a written contract with this person or organization.
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22503.5, 22503.6, 22504, 22511.)
- Requires that ticket sellers:
- Maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22501.)
- Prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.)
- Make any partial or full deposit refundable if received on a future event for which tickets are not available, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent, until such time as tickets for the event are actually available. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22506.)
- Provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event that is canceled. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(a).)
- Provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(b).)
- Provide that a local jurisdiction may require a bond of not more $50,000 to cover required refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(d).)
- Disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22508.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller:
- Has lawful possession of the ticket;
- Has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or
- Informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, that it does not have possession of the ticket, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, of the terms of the deposit agreement and makes required disclosures. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that it can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver the ticket a) within a reasonable time and b) below or within the price and range of prices stated. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.2.)
- Provides a private right of action to ticket purchasers for violations of 5) and 6). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.3.)
- Declares it unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell software or services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure (including limits on the number of tickets a person can purchase) that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.5.)
- Deems a violation of the chapter of the Business and Professions Code containing the provisions above to be a misdemeanor. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22505.)
- Requires a ticket seller to have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation. Makes a violation of this requirement a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both, and provides for civil penalties of up to $2,500 for violations. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22500.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print, this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
1) Background. Gone are the days of camping out overnight in line at a box office hoping to get tickets to a Van Halen, Madonna, or Michael Jackson concert or to one of your favorite team’s games. In that pre-internet era, if overnight camping was not an option, a person could try calling the box office over and over, hoping to break through the busy signal to get an actual person who can sell tickets over the phone if the tickets have not sold out already. If those efforts failed, a fan could listen to their favorite radio station for hours at a time hoping to score free tickets through a call-in giveaway contest. Finally, if nothing else worked and the day of the concert or game arrived, they could take the chance of going to the venue in the hopes of finding a scalper standing in the parking lot, or near the entrance to the venue, holding up a couple of tickets for sale at a premium cash price. Of course, this last-ditch effort meant that fans ran the risk of being ripped off by a scalper selling fake tickets. But diehard fans often considered it a chance worth taking.
Buying tickets online. While some things remain unchanged for the music and sports fan, technology and the internet have profoundly changed the experience of ticket buying. The live entertainment ticket ecosystem is now simultaneously much more complicated and much more convenient. Largely gone are the days of box offices and paper tickets. Now, in theory, when tickets go on sale for a concert or a game, fans go to the online ticket platform that is selling those tickets (often Ticketmaster) to purchase them and then have them delivered electronically. However, the reality is more complicated, depending how the consumer enters the online marketplace.
Today, the ticket market is broken down into on-sale primary vendors—comprised of venues and online primary ticket platforms—and the secondary (or resale) market, which is made up of ticket brokers and resale marketplace platforms, such as StubHub, SeatGeek, and Vivid Seats. Adding to the confusion, there is significant crossover between the two markets. For example, Ticketmaster operates a resale platform and SeatGeek operates as both a primary and secondary platform. When multiple secondary platforms and the on-sale primary vendor are all competing for ticket buyers, it can be very difficult for consumers to know where to buy tickets or even whether or not they are getting an actual ticket.
The primary market. The primary market is one in which event organizers control the ticket price, the sharing of the revenue between the artist, venue operator, and ticket company, and the decision as to which platform will sell the tickets. The prices set in the primary market heavily affect the volume and value of tickets in the secondary market. In general, it is most common to find underpriced tickets—tickets that sell on the primary market with a face value that is below their market value—so that event organizers can maximize the attendance of their target audience in order to increase customer loyalty, and merchandise sales.[1] To complicate ticket selling in the primary market, some artists have been known to hold back a portion of tickets to sell on the resale market in order to take advantage of the higher prices while still maintaining fan loyalty by offering the initial tickets at a low price.[2]
The secondary market. The secondary market is where tickets purchased on the primary market are resold. Ticket prices are usually significantly higher when purchased from someone in the secondary market. A study conducted by the National Independent Talent Organizations (NITO) analyzed data from 65 different shows around the country in 2023 where artists represented by NITO members performed. According to their findings, on average, ticket buyers were charged twice as much when buying tickets in the secondary market.[3] Secondary market platforms not only serve as a way for professional ticket brokers (i.e. businesses that purchase event tickets solely for the purpose of reselling them for a profit) to sell tickets, they also play an important role by providing consumers who can no longer use their tickets a relatively simple way of recouping their money and perhaps making a profit by reselling them to someone else.
The platforms, for a fee, provide the infrastructure and technology that make up the marketplace for brokers and individuals to resell their tickets. Professional ticket brokers either enter into agreements with sports teams and promoters to have access to tickets for resale or they compete with consumers in the primary marketplace to purchase tickets that they intend to resell at a profit on the platforms. Generally speaking, these secondary market platforms, such as StubHub, Vivid Seats, TickPicks, SeatGeek, and the secondary platforms run by Ticketmaster and their main competitor AXS, are similar to eBay (the former parent company for StubHub) or Etsy. This means that individual entities, who are generally not associated with the platform, are the ones selling the merchandise – tickets, in this case.
Speculative ticket sales. A speculative ticket refers to instances in which a seller offers a ticket for sale on a secondary ticket exchange before the seller actually has the ticket. In some cases, secondary sellers may not disclose the fact that they are selling speculative tickets. These practices harm consumers who either do not receive the tickets they purchased or receive tickets that differ from the ticket or seat advertised. Even if consumers receive refunds for the ticket price, they may have already incurred nonrefundable costs to attend the event, such as travel or hotel expenses.[4]
For over a decade, secondary resale markets have allowed the sale of tickets that sellers do not actually possess. Specifically, speculative ticket sales work as follows, according to the Center for Investigative Reporting:
Brokers advertise inventory – sometimes a specific seat, sometimes a seating area – on a resale site, often at a price significantly higher than face value. When a customer selects tickets and checks out, [the site] prompts the broker to then attempt to acquire those tickets elsewhere at a lower price. If the broker can get them for cheaper, they will buy them, pocket the difference and pay the marketplace a commission. If they can’t, the broker will either have to make good on the initial offer and take a loss or renege on the sale.[5]
Ticket brokers often refer to this practice as the equivalent of agreeing to stand in line for someone at the box office. They will buy tickets when they go on sale, so that the consumer does not have to wait in front of their computer, constantly refreshing their web browser. However, the consumer is often not aware that they are buying a ticket that the seller does not possess, nor do they realize they are paying a premium price, significantly above the face value, for a ticket that they may or may not receive.
This practice creates considerable confusion for consumers who cannot purchase tickets from the primary box office because they have not gone on sale yet, but are able to purchase tickets for a premium price on the secondary market. As a recent example, before the tickets for a Justin Timberlake concert scheduled for May in San Jose were officially on sale through Ticketmaster, they were advertised for sale on a number of secondary platforms. In fact, the first three websites at the top of an internet search were already selling tickets. The first website, StubHub, offered tickets for sale and nothing easily identifiable on the platform suggested that the tickets were speculative. The next website, VividSeats, indicated in the “notes” section that the tickets being purchased were a “seat saver” listing and that the purchaser will either receive the tickets or a full refund. The third website, “TicketsOffice.org” also did not advertise the tickets as speculative.
2) Live Nation/Ticketmaster anti-trust lawsuit. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and 30 state and district attorneys general filed an anti-trust lawsuit against Live Nation Entertainment on May 23, 2024. In the suit, the US government asks the courts to break up Live Nation, or at the very least separate Ticketmaster from the conglomerate. The US DOJ accuses Live Nation of leveraging its power in the entertainment industry to dominate the industry by locking venues into exclusive ticketing contracts, pressuring artists to use its services and threatening its rivals with financial retribution.
California Attorney General, Rob Bonta, joined the suit. According to the Attorney General’s office:
The lawsuit alleges Live Nation violated Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, which prohibits anticompetitive agreements, monopolization, and attempted monopolization. Monopolization offenses occur when a single firm maintains a monopoly unlawfully, by using its control of the market to exclude rivals and harm competition. In addition, the complaint alleges violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law.
The complaint filed today alleges that Live Nation protects its monopoly by using both exclusive contracts with promoters and venues to protect its dominant position in the live music industry to force artists and venues to use both its ticketing and concert promotion services. Live Nation uses their market dominance to leverage its power over all other aspects of the live music entertainment industry: from artist management, to ticketing, and promotions. For example, Live Nation has used their dominance in promotions to force venues to use Ticketmaster’s ticketing services, thereby blocking innovation and unfairly competing with competitors in the music concert business.
In the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta, U.S. DOJ, and coalition states allege that Live Nation has:
- Harmed fans through higher fees. Fans’ ticketing experience — from buying a ticket to showtime — is also worse than it would be if the industry was competitive.
- Maintained its monopoly in ticketing markets by locking up venues through restrictive long-term, exclusive agreements and threats that venues will lose access to Live Nation-controlled tours and artists if they sign with a rival ticketer.
- Leveraged its extensive network of venues to force artists to select Live Nation as a promoter instead of its rivals, maintaining its promotions monopoly.
In filing the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta joins the U.S. Department of Justice and the attorneys general of Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming, and the District of Columbia. [6]
According to the judge recently assigned to the case, the trial could begin as early as March 2026.[7]
3) How is the ticket buying experience different in other countries? It is in large part due to Taylor Swift, arguably the most popular musical artist in history, that the cost of live entertainment tickets and the difficulties in the market continue to be top of mind for lawmakers and entertainment and business journalists. Originally, Swifties were outraged in November 2022 when millions flocked to Ticketmaster.com to grab tickets to see her perform for the first time since 2018 and the website crashed. The long wait lines and frozen screens sparked an uproar with fans blaming Ticketmaster for ruining their chances to see the pop star. While the initial anger reportedly stemmed from the Ticketmaster platform being unable to handle that volume of activity, the larger, on-going outrage stems from consumers discovering that tickets are instantly sold out, but within minutes are offered on secondary resale marketplaces for thousands of dollars. According to the Los Angeles Times, the face value of the tickets for Swift’s concert at SoFi Stadium ranged from $49 to $449. However, tickets on StubHub were quickly being sold for around $800 up to $11,000.[8]
Billboard recently reported:
Prices to see [Taylor] Swift at one of her final nine shows in the United States have increased following the release of the album April 19, with the average get-in-the-door price — the lowest price available — hovering around $2,600 per ticket, according to data from TicketIQ. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift in Miami . . , New Orleans . . . and Indianapolis . . . this fall.
In Europe, however . . . tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States. . . . That means a fan in Miami could fly to Paris for about $900 a person . . . spend two nights at a four-star hotel at $250 a night and purchase a $340 concert ticket for a grand total of $1,740 — which is still $760 less than the cheapest tickets currently available for her Miami shows.
Tickets to see Swift in Stockholm . . . are even cheaper, at $312 for the cheapest tickets, while tickets for her show in Portugal . . . start at $336 and in Spain . . . start at $324.[9]
Opponents of this bill have argued that one of the reasons that Swift tickets remain so much lower is because Ticketmaster does not have the same control over the market in other countries. Policymakers in the state and federal government have agreed that Live Nation Entertainment/Ticketmaster’s oversized market share represents a significant problem. However, as noted above, the face value price of Taylor Swift tickets during the United States leg of her tour, particularly here in California, were in a similar range as those in Europe. So, it is unclear what impact their domination in the primary market played in this case.
The opposition has also posited that another reason for the difference in ticket prices is that Swift is not as popular in Europe, so the demand is not as great. However, Swift fans at her recent sold-out concerts in Edinburgh, Scotland may beg to differ. According to reports from the British Geological Survey, Swift’s fans caused an actual earthquakes during her concerts. Seismic readings were detected almost 4 miles away from the stadium.[10]
While this bill is not about or for Ms. Swift, her popularity, the interest of the media, and the loud voices and devotion of her fans provide an opportunity to clearly observe the problems in the United States’ entertainment ticket market and compare it to ticket markets in other countries.
4) European countries’ continue to distrust “touts.” Despite the fact that ticket brokers and other secondary resellers are directly competing with consumers in the primary ticket market and may be the reason they cannot find tickets, people in the United States have embraced the resale ticket market as a valid business model that provides consumers with the ability to purchase tickets to events that they could not otherwise attend, albeit at a premium price. This is not the case in many European countries where consumers, policymakers, and mainstream media have remained wary of the practice of purchasing tickets in order to resell them at an inflated price, which the U.K. refers to as “touting.”
Ticket market experts point to this general distrust as one of the reasons for the difference in ticket prices between the United States and Europe, while the United States has turned its attention to the domination of Live Nation Entertainment, the parent company for Ticketmaster, as the main driver behind skyrocketing ticket prices.[11] Policymakers in other countries have taken concerns related to the price of tickets and the resale market so seriously that one of the planks that the Labour party in Britain is running on for the upcoming July 4th election is a commitment to cap the price of resale tickets. According to the Change Labour Party Manifesto 2024:
With Labour, the arts and music will no longer be the preserve of a privileged few. Culture is an essential part of supporting children and young people to develop creativity and find their voice. . . . Access to music, drama and sport has become difficult and expensive because of ticket touting. Labour will put fans back at the heart of events by introducing new consumer protections on ticket resales.[12]
In reporting on the commitment to regulate the resale market, the BBC reports, “Labour will cap the resale prices of tickets and regulate resale platforms if the party wins the next general election, Sir Keir Starmer has said. The plans will clamp down on ticket touts who rip off music and sports fans going to live events, Sir Keir said.”[13]
4) Joint Informational Hearing: Online Ticketing and Access to Live Entertainment (Feb. 13, 2024). During a joint informational hearing earlier this year between this Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee, the Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. One thing became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California is fundamentally broken.
It has become virtually impossible for average consumers to find tickets for sale from the primary online box office for a myriad of reasons: popular events are immediately sold out within seconds of the tickets going on sale, while they simultaneously pop up on resale marketplaces at significantly inflated prices; a simple Google search for tickets presents consumers with link after link to resale marketplaces because the company has paid to boost their site on the search engine; a website that appears to be the official site for the event (i.e. muppetslivetickets.com) is actually a white label site that links to a secondary market place platform; or the tickets being advertised for sale are actually speculative tickets because even though the event has been announced, the actual tickets have not gone on sale yet.
During the hearing, venue operator after venue operator expressed frustration with having to deal with angry and frustrated fans who showed up at the venue with tickets that were fake. According to their testimony, this is a growing problem and for many of them it is happening every night that there is a show at their venue.
These small business owners told of shows that were sold out and the venue purchased food and beverages and staffed the venue for a large crowd, only to find that the venue ended up being half empty because a ticket broker had purchased all of the tickets to the event but had been unable to resell them. This particular problem does not initially seem like a significant one for venues because they have sold all of the available tickets. However, venues generally do not make their revenue from the sale of tickets that revenue goes to the artist. The primary revenue for the venue comes from selling food, beverages, and merchandise. So, when a venue has staffed up and ordered enough supplies for a sold out crowd and they do not show up, the venue ends up losing money on the show.
Similarly, representatives for artists spoke of the importance of the relationship between artists and their fans. Artists often price tickets in a reasonable range that will allow their fans to afford to attend. When those tickets are purchased by scalpers or ticket brokers, in violation of the posted terms and conditions, and resold for several times the original price, not only do the artists and venues not make any increased revenue from the higher prices but the artist’s fans often become upset and blame the artist for the high price of the tickets.
All of this is not to suggest that the Committee does not believe that there are also major problems in the primary marketplace related to the fact that Ticketmaster enjoys a monopoly by controlling 80 percent of ticket sales. But the artists, their managers, the venue operators, and the consumer experts all overwhelmingly agreed that the largest and most immediate problems they faced were due to an out-of-control secondary market where the primary business model involves competing with actual consumers in the primary market in order to then turn around and sell the tickets to the same consumers at greatly inflated prices.[14]
5) Purpose of this bill. Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce states these reasons why this bill is needed:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice,[15] it continues because the profits are too substantial.[16] This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans[17] and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.[18]
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
It is these problems in the secondary market that this bill seeks to address by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms.
6) Author’s statement. According to the author:
SB 785 will reform the laws governing the purchase and sale of tickets to live entertainment and sporting events in California, and create meaningful protections for consumers, artists, teams, and local venues.
Current law regulates ticket brokers but does not apply to the resale platforms where consumer deception and price gouging occurs. This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues.
SB 785 will protect consumers, artists, teams, and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently harms consumers and the event presenters who bring live entertainments their fans. Specifically, this bill will:
- Impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at checkout.
- End the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.
- Establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.
- Establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.
This bill puts fans and live entertainment creators—rather than scalpers who prey on fans--first. In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the rights of the artists, entertainers, and teams to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to ensure the availability of face values
7) What this bill does. This bill includes the following significant changes to current entertainment ticket law:
Prohibits speculative tickets sales. Ends speculative ticket sales, except in instances where a ticket seller has a contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket must own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or a ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing, and before selling, disclose to the purchaser the specific seat within the venue that the purchaser is entitled to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have a contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, to disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
Restricts ticket purchases from the primary box office. Declares if unlawful for a person to do the following in order to circumvent restrictions on primary sale tickets:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined posted terms and conditions of the rights holder, event presenter, and venue operator.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
Prohibits deceptive marketing practices. Prohibit using a box office website that looks substantially similar to the venue or primary seller’s website in order to direct sales to the resale market. Specifically prohibits the following:
- A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
- Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available from the original seller.
Increases penalties. Increases the current fine of $2,500 to a fine of up to $10,000 for each ticket that is sold or offered for sale in violation of the chapter.
- Action may be brought by:
- The Attorney General.
- A district attorney.
- A city attorney.
- A county council of a county.
- A city prosecutor in a city.
- In addition to the fines, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates the sections of this bill related to speculative tickets, deceptive marketing, or prohibited purchasing practices is civilly liable to the consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending.
8) Analysis. As discussed throughout this analysis, the conditions in the ticket resale market have not only caused prices to skyrocket, but have also allowed unscrupulous ticket resellers to mislead consumers who are attempting to purchase tickets to attend a live entertainment event. This bill seeks to prohibit some of the most deceptive practices and addresses a number of the concerns raised during this Committee’s informational hearing.
Among their other concerns, opponents of this bill have consistently pointed to two issues related to this bill. First, the inclusion of broad terms and conditions for event presenters. On this topic, StubHub, in an “oppose unless amended” position, writes:
Sec 9. 22503.3 endorses an event presenter’s (i.e. LNE) ability to unilaterally set, impose, and enforce terms and conditions on ticket sales, ticket pricing, the transfer or resale of tickets sold, as well as the technologies used to sell tickets. This effectively endorses anticompetitive terms and conditions and restrictive technologies that limit consumer choice and further engrains a monopoly that is alleged by the DOJ and Attorney General Bonta to use anti-competitive tactics to disadvantage artists, venues, consumers, and competitors. We respectfully request that this committee remove Sec. 9 from the bill to protect consumers, the broader industry and competition in the live event space.
The most recent author’s amendments (as amended June 27, 2024) removed this section from the bill.
Secondly, opponents have expressed concern related to requirements that the original face value of a ticket be included in any resale posting. On this point, the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, an association of ticket brokers and secondary platforms, notes:
. . . [T]he bill uses the guise of “transparency” to further suffocate competition from the secondary market by imposing requirements on resellers that in many instances would be impossible to meet, such as listing the face value of tickets that are resold or requiring a specific seat location for tickets that consumers purchase in a particular “zone” of a venue. The so called “transparency” proponents request in SB 785 has no public policy benefit and is merely intended to further stifle the secondary market.
In a world of dynamic primary pricing, the “face value” of a ticket is difficult if not impossible to verify, and can lead to confusion that may encourage consumers make a poor financially decision. It is very common for a primary seller to drip supply into the market at a given price, for example $50. If those tickets sell “too fast”, they may sell the row in front or behind (or the seats next to) the $50 seats at $75, then when those sell, at $100 and so on… A consumer given the face value information buying a $50 ticket on the secondary market might balk at a price of $80, when an almost identical seat with a face value of $100 might be sold at $90. Simply because someone is losing money on a $100 ticket does not mean the consumer is better off paying $90 vs $80 for identical tickets. What someone paid at one point in time is not relevant to the consumer’s buying decision, but knowing how many tickets were sold and if more tickets may become available would be.
Author’s amendments, taken on June 24, 2024, remove the requirement that tickets being resold contain information related to the original face price of the ticket.
9) What remains to be done? While more remains to be done in both the primary and secondary markets, this bill addresses some of the most significant problems in the secondary market and significantly increases the consumer protections for fans who are purchasing tickets in order to attend live events. Based on discussions with artists, consumers, venue operators, and talent organizations and research into ticketing practices in other states and other countries, legislators may want to consider the following policies in future legislation:
Price caps. Likely the single most impactful policy for controlling the price of tickets is a cap both on the resale price and on the amount of fees secondary marketplaces can charge for allowing the tickets to be sold on their platforms. The primary driver between the price of tickets in California and the prices in other countries can be traced to capping the amount someone is allowed to resell a ticket for. In Europe, prices are kept low thanks to laws limiting how high tickets can be marked up over face value. In countries like France, Germany and the Netherlands, ticket resellers face limits on how much tickets can be marked up on secondary sites — typically 20 percent over face value. Since 2021, Ireland has capped the resale price of a ticket at what it originally sold for in the primary market. Maryland, in its recent legislation was considering a ten percent cap on resale tickets.[19]
While generally limiting prices in most markets could be seen as something to be leery of, this market is the rare exception where there is a justification to limit resale prices given all of the abuses detailed throughout this analysis.
In addition to capping the resale price, legislators should also consider capping the fees that can be charged by resale platforms. Unlike the primary ticket fees, which are generally shared between the ticket seller and the venue operator, resale fees, in most cases, solely benefit the resale platform.
The rights of artists. While the author has removed the language in the bill allowing for event presenter’s to exercise sweeping authority over the way in which tickets are priced, transferred, sold, and resold, there is a strong argument for enshrining in state law the rights of artists to establish terms and conditions and maintain control over their own work product.
Enumerating a limited range of terms and conditions turned over to artists allows clear artist control over the provisions that matter most to them like restricting resale to face value, using adjusted pricing, or making tickets available to fan club members. All of these choices are examples of decisions that artists should be allowed to control.
Protecting a consumers’ ability to either resell or give away a ticket they cannot use. Equally important in the policies that should be considered is the question of what someone should be able to do with a ticket they are unable to use. The most consumer-protective approach is to require that ticket sellers ensure that consumers can exchange a ticket at face value to recoup their money, give the ticket away to someone of their choosing, or be able to try to resell it on the secondary marketplace for a capped amount. This would ensure that the ticket will not go unused.
Exploring exclusivity contracts. Small venue operators have been very clear that exclusive contracts with primary ticket sellers is a critical part of their business model. However, given Live Nation’s dominance, while the anti-trust lawsuit is being decided at the federal level, lawmakers may want to consider limiting exclusive contracts when the venue operator, the event promoter, and the primary ticket seller are all part of the same company. This approach, arguably, would provide openings in the primary ticket market for other companies to gain a larger market share and it would eliminate some of the most egregious practices in the primary market.
10) Suggested Committee amendments. Though primarily clarifying in nature, the suggested Committee amendments are spread throughout the bill. A complete mock-up is included as an attachment at the end of this analysis.
11) Related legislation. AB 2203 (McCarty, 2024) requires ticket sellers that sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event, to immediately deliver a proof of purchase to a consumer, and would require a venue operator to honor that proof of purchase in lieu of the ticket if specified conditions are met. This bill is currently awaiting hearing in the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee.
AB 2808 (Wicks, 2024) prohibited certain entertainment venue operators from entering into an exclusive contract with a primary ticket seller. That bill was held on the Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) requires a ticket seller to disclose to a purchaser the total price of the ticket and the portion of that price that represents any fees or surcharges. The seller must also provide a link to an internet webpage that includes certain refund requirements, as specified. This bill is currently on the suspense file in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits the operator of an entertainment facility and a primary ticket seller from entering into a contract that provides for the primary ticket seller to be the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. SB 829 is currently in this Committee.
SB 478 (Dodd; Ch. 400, Stats. of 2023) makes it an unlawful business practice pursuant to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act to advertise, display, or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than taxes imposed by a government.
AB 1556 (Friedman, Ch. 180, Stats. 2021) requires for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation; and requires a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
AB 329 (Pan, Ch. 325, Stats. 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Writing in support of the bill, the National Independent Venue Association (NIVA) states:
I want to be clear: this measure is in no way, shape, or form a giveaway to LiveNation/Ticketmaster as the opponents suggest. Independent venues and promoters have been advocating across the nation for reforms contained in this bill because of the flood of fake tickets we see at our doors night after night that hurt our small businesses. Taylor Swift does not grace our stages but we unfortunately see fake tickets night after night and often look on the secondary platform sites to see our $30 tickets priced at $150 when we have inventory available on our websites.
Just last week on June 8th, the Sonoma Press-Democrat published an article, entitled “Sonoma, Napa county venues are warning concertgoers about uptick in inflated, fake tickets,” that offers a snapshot of what our member venues deal with night after night. Certain deceptive websites, appearing to be affiliated with venues, are actually third-party vendors with no connection to the venue. These sites often rank highly in search engine results for tickets, presenting themselves as official outlets, yet they charge inflated prices, sometimes up to triple the face value of the ticket.
The opposition to this measure would argue this proposal strengthens a monopoly’s hold on the industry. This is not true. This measure addresses the major challenges independent venues and promoters face with regard to fraudulent tickets or massively overpriced tickets on third-party platforms that hurt our reputations.
Opponents would also have you believe that empowering the secondary market will “increase competition” and promote “ticket freedom.” This is also not true and doing so as they articulate will increase the likelihood of predatory practices thus diminishing the fan experience at a show. Without banning speculative and predatory ticketing practices, fans may have more places to purchase tickets, but will have less guarantees that the ticket is real/valid, resulting in a terrible experience when they arrive and find out their ticket is fake and they can’t get into the show. SB 785 takes these necessary steps to truly protect not only the consumer (fans), but the artists and the venues who depend on the trust and engagement of the fans.
By considerately putting the fan first, SB 785 will help to ensure that fans get valid tickets, artists perform to more fans at their shows, and venues will have a better chance of protecting their businesses and reputations. There have been many bills in California, and around the country, that have attempted to reshape and reform ticketing but SB 785 has the most potential to simultaneously protect fans, artists and venues from deceptive, inflammatory and predatory ticket resellers in a model for the rest of the country.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Echoing the concerns raised by several groups the Consumer Federation of California, writes:
On May 23rd of this year the federal Department of Justice, joined by 29 states and the District of Columbia, [sued the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly] for violating antitrust law and urged that it be broken up. The 29 states that joined in the lawsuit included California and our Attorney General as well as the following states: Arkansas, Florida, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia, and Wyoming, to just name a few. This speaks to the overwhelming bipartisan nature of legal concern with the monopolistic actions of Live Nation/Ticketmaster ever since their merger in 2010.
[ . . .]
The lawsuit filed by the federal DOJ plus 30 jurisdictions serves, among other things, as an invitation to the federal government and the states to take stronger action on behalf of consumers to limit the destructiveness of the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly while the case attempting to break it up winds its way slowly through the U.S. court system. Historically antitrust cases like this have taken numerous years to adjudicate, so the California Legislature should act now to significantly trim the wings of the monopoly.
Instead, respectfully, SB 785 aims its sights squarely on what limited competition there is in the marketplace against the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly. SB 785’s general approach is to make things worse for consumers by making things better for the monopoly as they fight the lawsuit striking at the heart of their corporate practices. This is misguided.
That is not to say that there aren’t productive conversations to be had about so-called speculative ticketing, where consumers think they have a ticket to a show but the entity they “bought” it from has to go out and secure that ticket after the consumer has paid, or deceptive websites that fool consumers into thinking they are interacting with the actual concert venue only to find out that they’ve been defrauded. But these issues pale in comparison to the larger problems directly foisted upon consumers by the monopoly and the various issues that would help consumers by legislatively limiting monopoly power. Taking on the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly seems to be later on the legislative priority list than helping the monopoly harm consumers by forcing their competition to take a haircut while the monopoly, their apologists and allies egg them on.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of Independent Music
Axs
Bay Area Council
Black Music Action Coalition
California Arts Advocates
California Chamber of Commerce
City of Thousand Oaks
Forty Niners Football Company Llc, a Delaware Limited Liability Company
Future of Music Coalition
Golden State Warriors
International Association of Venue Managers
Live Nation Entertainment, INC.
Los Angeles Rams
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
National Football League
National Independent Venue Association of California
Nederlander Concerts
Orange County Business Council
Ovg360
Recording Academy
Recording Industry Association of America
SAG-AFTRA
San Francisco 49ers
San Jose Sharks
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
Opposition
Coalition for Ticket Fairness
Consumer Federation of California
Netchoice (UNREG)
Progressive Policy Institute
Protect Ticket Rights
Sports Fans Coalition
Vivid Seats LLC
Oppose Unless Amended
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Lulac
California Urban Partnership
Central Valley Latino Mayors and Elected Officials Coalition
Central Valley Yemen Society
Chamber of Progress
Gametime
Hispanic 100
Latin Business Association
Lenusa
Multicultural Business Alliance
National Action Network - Sacramento Chapter
National Consumers League
Seatgeek, INC.
Si Se Puede Fresno, Tulare, Kings & Kern
Stubhub, INC.
Tickpick
Tickpick, LLC
Women Veterans Alliance
SUGGESTED COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 22500 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22500. (a) Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b) A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c) For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1) The Attorney General.
(2) A district attorney.
(3) A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4) A county counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5) A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d) In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. Additionally, the court shall award a prevailing public prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney’s fees. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1) The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2) The number of violations.
(3) The persistence of the misconduct.
(4) The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5) The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6) The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e) The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2. Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22501. Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year after the initial sale.
SEC. 3. Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22502. (a) An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a that entertainment venue.
(c) Subdivision (b) shall not apply to flexible series ticketing options that allow attendees to commit to a number of performances in advance, while choosing the specific performances at a later date.
SEC. 4. Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.3. (a) It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) A reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a reseller or resale marketplace shall not do either of the following:
- Resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employ another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
SEC. 5. Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22502.1. (a) (1) A ticket resale marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer consumer.
(2) By allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
(b) A ticket resale marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within an entertainment venue.
SEC. 6. Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.4. I It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7. Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.5. In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs.
SEC. 8. Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22503. (a) An “artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
(b) A “consumer,” as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(c) An “entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
(d) An “event,” as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(e) An “event presenter,” as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(f) A “live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
(g) An “original seller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
(h) A “rights holder,” as used in this chapter, means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
(i) A “ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
(j) A “ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resaleincluding a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
(k) A “ticket reseller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
(l) A “venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
SEC. 9. Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 10. Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22503.4. This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 11. Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22505.2. (a) A person ticket reseller shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a) (1) A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b) (2) Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller.
(b) A ticket reseller shall not represent that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term sold out when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
SEC. 12. Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22505.1. Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a) Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b) Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c) Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d) Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rights holder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
(e) Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 13. Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22507. (a) The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser consumer by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser consumer, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b) The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser consumer by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c) For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser consumer is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d) A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 14. Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 15. Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22511. This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.
SEC. 16. No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
Analysis Prepared by: Julie Salley / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
The Event Ticketing Industry is Broken and in Need of Disruption, Aventus Network (May 19, 2017). ↑
Tyler Jenke, “Ed Sheeran’s manager has admitted to selling tickets to resale services,” The Music Network (Jun 3, 2018) available at https://themusicnetwork.com/ed-sheeran-manager-sold-tickets-resale/. ↑
NITO Ticket Resale Study. National Independent Talent Organization (Jul 2023) ↑
Ibid. ↑
Duncan, Byard. “How is this Legal?” The Center for Investigative Reporting, March 8, 2021, available at https://revealnews.org/article/how-is-this-legal/. ↑
California Department of Justice. Attorney General Bonta Files Lawsuit Against Live Nation, Ticketmaster (May 23, 2024) https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-files-lawsuit-against-live-nation-ticketmaster. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Judge in Live Nation Antitrust Case Indicates Possible Start Date for Blockbuster Trial,” Billboard (Jun. 28. 2024) https://www.billboard.com/pro/live-nation-antitrust-case-judge-possible-trial-start-date/, ↑
Fox, Emma. “$11,000 to see Taylor Swift? How concert tickets got so expensive,” The Los Angeles Times (July 27, 2023) https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2023-07-27/explaining-the-complicated-world-of-ticketing. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Why Are Taylor Swift Eras Tour Tickets So Much Cheaper in Europe?” Billboard (May 2, 2024) https://www.billboard.com/business/touring/taylor-swift-eras-tour-tickets-cheaper-europe-1235671760/. ↑
Melnick, Kyle. “Swifties set off earthquake sensors again. These songs made the biggest stir.” The Washington Post (Jun. 13, 2024) https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/2024/06/13/taylor-swift-concert-fans-dance-earthquake-sensors/. ↑
While Ticketmaster’s domination is a legitimate concern, as discussed earlier in this analysis, the available data does not support the fact that primary market prices account for the high price of tickets. ↑
Geiger, Chas. “Keir Starmer vows to cap resale music and sport ticket prices,” BBC (Mar. 14, 2024) https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-68563793. ↑
Ibid. ↑
For additional information, a detailed background paper and a video link to the hearing is available at https://apcp.assembly.ca.gov/hearings/2023-24-informationaloversight-hearings. ↑
President Obama signed the Better Online Ticket Sales (BOTS) Act in December of 2016. Discussed here: https://www.westarts.org/news-updates/the-battle-between-bots-and-the-ticket-industry-continues, and here https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/president-obama-signs-bots-act-law-7625257/. ↑
As an example, the Federal Trade Commission Action against three scalpers for $3.7 million for buying over 150,000 tickets and re-selling them. https://www.pcmag.com/news/3-scalpers-fined-for-using-bots-to-scoop-up-tickets-on-ticketmaster ↑
https://www.npr.org/2021/12/10/1063237219/olivia-rodrigo-sour-tour-tickets ↑
https://themanc.com/audio/fans-fume-as-taylor-hawkins-tribute-concert-tickets-appear-on-resale-sites-for-four-times-the-price/ ↑
While the final version of Maryland’s ticketing reform bill did not include caps, it is expected that caps will be reintroduced in their next legislative session. ↑
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2024
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SENATE VOTE: 34-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protection: ticket sellers
SYNOPSIS
Taylor Swift fans are flocking to Europe this summer to attend her concerts. Why? For many in the United States, it is cheaper to travel to Paris for a vacation that includes the concert than it is to purchase tickets in their own home towns. The average get-in-the-door price for the upcoming fall concerts in the United States — the lowest price available — are hovering around $2,600 per ticket. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift. In Europe, however, tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States.
This Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee held an informational hearing earlier this year focused on understanding the high price of live entertainment tickets and what action should be taken to rein them in. The Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. In addition to Ticketmaster’s well-known monopolistic control of the primary market, another key main point in the ticketing business became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California, and throughout much of the country, is fundamentally broken.
Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce explains how turbocharged scalping ruins the fan experience:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice, it continues because the profits are too substantial. This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
Indeed, one of the key reasons that many European countries have vastly cheaper tickets is that these countries extensively regulate the secondary market.
As a long overdue anti-trust lawsuit against Ticketmaster unfolds at the federal level, this bill seeks to complement these efforts by addressing problems in the secondary market by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms. In doing so, the bill enacts meaningful protections for the real consumers of event ticketing—the fans.
Along with the California Chamber of Commerce, this bill is supported by the Future of Music Coalition, the National Football League, the Gold State Warriors, SAG-AFTRA, the National Independent Venue Association, and over a dozen other organizations. In opposition are the Consumer Federation of California, StubHub, Vivid Seats, Seat Geek, and the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, among a number of other organizations.
This bill passed the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee in June 2023 on a 5-0-2 vote. The proposed Committee amendments are minor and clarifying in nature. Because of the number of amendments, a mockup of the bill is included at the end of this analysis.
SUMMARY: Revises and recasts California’s entertainment ticket statutes, particularly as it pertains to reselling tickets. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
- “Consumer” means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
- “Entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
- “Event” means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
- “Event presenter” means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- “Live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
- “Original seller” means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
- “Rights holder” means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
- “Ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
- “Ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, including a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
- “Ticket reseller” means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- “Venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
- If required by a local jurisdiction, original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces must register with the Secretary of State and obtain a license.
- Eliminates the requirement that a ticket seller have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation.
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter will constitute a separate violation which may be brought only by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, a county council or a city prosecutor and requires the court to impose a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 for each violation of the law, along with awarding the prevailing prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney fees. The level of the penalty must be based on the prevailing circumstances and the seriousness of the violation.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller to own, possess, or have a contractual right to a ticket before listing, marketing, or selling the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or ticket reseller at the time of listing or marketing a ticket to disclose to the consumer the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat in the venue, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Exempts from 6) flexible series ticket options that allow consumers to commit to a number of performances in a season in advance, while choosing the specific performances at a later date.
- Eliminates the exemption in current law that allows a ticket seller to market, advertise or sell a ticket if they inform the purchaser orally at the time of contract or receipt of consideration, and within two business days, that the seller does not have possession of the ticket, a contract to obtain the ticket and may not be able to obtain the ticket.
- Prohibits a reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate from doing either of the following:
- Reselling more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employing another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling those tickets.
- Requires that ticket resale marketplaces, before accepting a listing to sell a ticket, require that the person listing the ticket has a right to sell the ticket and is able to deliver it to the consumer.
- States that by allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
- Requires a ticket resale marketplace to disclose on its internet website in each ticket listing the exact location of the seat in the entertainment venue, unless the ticket is not associated with occupying a specific seat, such as general admission or standing room only tickets.
- Repeals a provision of existing law that states that certain ticketing laws do not apply to any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor, with “primary contractor,” defined as the person or organization who is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from using an internet website, or causing an internet website to be used, that displays a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder, or any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Prohibits a ticket reseller from representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
- Prohibits a person from intentionally using, causing to be used, or selling software or services that do any of the following:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rightsholder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Removes the ticketing exemption in current law for non-profit charitable tax-exempt organizations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a “ticket seller” as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22503.)
- Clarifies that the following are not ticket sellers for purposes of existing law:
- An officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package.
- Any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the event premises, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- The person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold, or a seller of tickets operating under a written contract with this person or organization.
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22503.5, 22503.6, 22504, 22511.)
- Requires that ticket sellers:
- Maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22501.)
- Prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.)
- Make any partial or full deposit refundable if received on a future event for which tickets are not available, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent, until such time as tickets for the event are actually available. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22506.)
- Provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event that is canceled. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(a).)
- Provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(b).)
- Provide that a local jurisdiction may require a bond of not more $50,000 to cover required refunds. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22507(d).)
- Disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22508.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller:
- Has lawful possession of the ticket;
- Has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or
- Informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, that it does not have possession of the ticket, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser, in a specified manner, of the terms of the deposit agreement and makes required disclosures. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that it can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver the ticket a) within a reasonable time and b) below or within the price and range of prices stated. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.2.)
- Provides a private right of action to ticket purchasers for violations of 5) and 6). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.3.)
- Declares it unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell software or services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure (including limits on the number of tickets a person can purchase) that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.5.)
- Deems a violation of the chapter of the Business and Professions Code containing the provisions above to be a misdemeanor. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22505.)
- Requires a ticket seller to have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation. Makes a violation of this requirement a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both, and provides for civil penalties of up to $2,500 for violations. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22500.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print, this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
1) Background. Gone are the days of camping out overnight in line at a box office hoping to get tickets to a Van Halen, Madonna, or Michael Jackson concert or to one of your favorite team’s games. In that pre-internet era, if overnight camping was not an option, a person could try calling the box office over and over, hoping to break through the busy signal to get an actual person who can sell tickets over the phone if the tickets have not sold out already. If those efforts failed, a fan could listen to their favorite radio station for hours at a time hoping to score free tickets through a call-in giveaway contest. Finally, if nothing else worked and the day of the concert or game arrived, they could take the chance of going to the venue in the hopes of finding a scalper standing in the parking lot, or near the entrance to the venue, holding up a couple of tickets for sale at a premium cash price. Of course, this last-ditch effort meant that fans ran the risk of being ripped off by a scalper selling fake tickets. But diehard fans often considered it a chance worth taking.
Buying tickets online. While some things remain unchanged for the music and sports fan, technology and the internet have profoundly changed the experience of ticket buying. The live entertainment ticket ecosystem is now simultaneously much more complicated and much more convenient. Largely gone are the days of box offices and paper tickets. Now, in theory, when tickets go on sale for a concert or a game, fans go to the online ticket platform that is selling those tickets (often Ticketmaster) to purchase them and then have them delivered electronically. However, the reality is more complicated, depending how the consumer enters the online marketplace.
Today, the ticket market is broken down into on-sale primary vendors—comprised of venues and online primary ticket platforms—and the secondary (or resale) market, which is made up of ticket brokers and resale marketplace platforms, such as StubHub, SeatGeek, and Vivid Seats. Adding to the confusion, there is significant crossover between the two markets. For example, Ticketmaster operates a resale platform and SeatGeek operates as both a primary and secondary platform. When multiple secondary platforms and the on-sale primary vendor are all competing for ticket buyers, it can be very difficult for consumers to know where to buy tickets or even whether or not they are getting an actual ticket.
The primary market. The primary market is one in which event organizers control the ticket price, the sharing of the revenue between the artist, venue operator, and ticket company, and the decision as to which platform will sell the tickets. The prices set in the primary market heavily affect the volume and value of tickets in the secondary market. In general, it is most common to find underpriced tickets—tickets that sell on the primary market with a face value that is below their market value—so that event organizers can maximize the attendance of their target audience in order to increase customer loyalty, and merchandise sales.[1] To complicate ticket selling in the primary market, some artists have been known to hold back a portion of tickets to sell on the resale market in order to take advantage of the higher prices while still maintaining fan loyalty by offering the initial tickets at a low price.[2]
The secondary market. The secondary market is where tickets purchased on the primary market are resold. Ticket prices are usually significantly higher when purchased from someone in the secondary market. A study conducted by the National Independent Talent Organizations (NITO) analyzed data from 65 different shows around the country in 2023 where artists represented by NITO members performed. According to their findings, on average, ticket buyers were charged twice as much when buying tickets in the secondary market.[3] Secondary market platforms not only serve as a way for professional ticket brokers (i.e. businesses that purchase event tickets solely for the purpose of reselling them for a profit) to sell tickets, they also play an important role by providing consumers who can no longer use their tickets a relatively simple way of recouping their money and perhaps making a profit by reselling them to someone else.
The platforms, for a fee, provide the infrastructure and technology that make up the marketplace for brokers and individuals to resell their tickets. Professional ticket brokers either enter into agreements with sports teams and promoters to have access to tickets for resale or they compete with consumers in the primary marketplace to purchase tickets that they intend to resell at a profit on the platforms. Generally speaking, these secondary market platforms, such as StubHub, Vivid Seats, TickPicks, SeatGeek, and the secondary platforms run by Ticketmaster and their main competitor AXS, are similar to eBay (the former parent company for StubHub) or Etsy. This means that individual entities, who are generally not associated with the platform, are the ones selling the merchandise – tickets, in this case.
Speculative ticket sales. A speculative ticket refers to instances in which a seller offers a ticket for sale on a secondary ticket exchange before the seller actually has the ticket. In some cases, secondary sellers may not disclose the fact that they are selling speculative tickets. These practices harm consumers who either do not receive the tickets they purchased or receive tickets that differ from the ticket or seat advertised. Even if consumers receive refunds for the ticket price, they may have already incurred nonrefundable costs to attend the event, such as travel or hotel expenses.[4]
For over a decade, secondary resale markets have allowed the sale of tickets that sellers do not actually possess. Specifically, speculative ticket sales work as follows, according to the Center for Investigative Reporting:
Brokers advertise inventory – sometimes a specific seat, sometimes a seating area – on a resale site, often at a price significantly higher than face value. When a customer selects tickets and checks out, [the site] prompts the broker to then attempt to acquire those tickets elsewhere at a lower price. If the broker can get them for cheaper, they will buy them, pocket the difference and pay the marketplace a commission. If they can’t, the broker will either have to make good on the initial offer and take a loss or renege on the sale.[5]
Ticket brokers often refer to this practice as the equivalent of agreeing to stand in line for someone at the box office. They will buy tickets when they go on sale, so that the consumer does not have to wait in front of their computer, constantly refreshing their web browser. However, the consumer is often not aware that they are buying a ticket that the seller does not possess, nor do they realize they are paying a premium price, significantly above the face value, for a ticket that they may or may not receive.
This practice creates considerable confusion for consumers who cannot purchase tickets from the primary box office because they have not gone on sale yet, but are able to purchase tickets for a premium price on the secondary market. As a recent example, before the tickets for a Justin Timberlake concert scheduled for May in San Jose were officially on sale through Ticketmaster, they were advertised for sale on a number of secondary platforms. In fact, the first three websites at the top of an internet search were already selling tickets. The first website, StubHub, offered tickets for sale and nothing easily identifiable on the platform suggested that the tickets were speculative. The next website, VividSeats, indicated in the “notes” section that the tickets being purchased were a “seat saver” listing and that the purchaser will either receive the tickets or a full refund. The third website, “TicketsOffice.org” also did not advertise the tickets as speculative.
2) Live Nation/Ticketmaster anti-trust lawsuit. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and 30 state and district attorneys general filed an anti-trust lawsuit against Live Nation Entertainment on May 23, 2024. In the suit, the US government asks the courts to break up Live Nation, or at the very least separate Ticketmaster from the conglomerate. The US DOJ accuses Live Nation of leveraging its power in the entertainment industry to dominate the industry by locking venues into exclusive ticketing contracts, pressuring artists to use its services and threatening its rivals with financial retribution.
California Attorney General, Rob Bonta, joined the suit. According to the Attorney General’s office:
The lawsuit alleges Live Nation violated Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, which prohibits anticompetitive agreements, monopolization, and attempted monopolization. Monopolization offenses occur when a single firm maintains a monopoly unlawfully, by using its control of the market to exclude rivals and harm competition. In addition, the complaint alleges violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law.
The complaint filed today alleges that Live Nation protects its monopoly by using both exclusive contracts with promoters and venues to protect its dominant position in the live music industry to force artists and venues to use both its ticketing and concert promotion services. Live Nation uses their market dominance to leverage its power over all other aspects of the live music entertainment industry: from artist management, to ticketing, and promotions. For example, Live Nation has used their dominance in promotions to force venues to use Ticketmaster’s ticketing services, thereby blocking innovation and unfairly competing with competitors in the music concert business.
In the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta, U.S. DOJ, and coalition states allege that Live Nation has:
- Harmed fans through higher fees. Fans’ ticketing experience — from buying a ticket to showtime — is also worse than it would be if the industry was competitive.
- Maintained its monopoly in ticketing markets by locking up venues through restrictive long-term, exclusive agreements and threats that venues will lose access to Live Nation-controlled tours and artists if they sign with a rival ticketer.
- Leveraged its extensive network of venues to force artists to select Live Nation as a promoter instead of its rivals, maintaining its promotions monopoly.
In filing the lawsuit, Attorney General Bonta joins the U.S. Department of Justice and the attorneys general of Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming, and the District of Columbia. [6]
According to the judge recently assigned to the case, the trial could begin as early as March 2026.[7]
3) How is the ticket buying experience different in other countries? It is in large part due to Taylor Swift, arguably the most popular musical artist in history, that the cost of live entertainment tickets and the difficulties in the market continue to be top of mind for lawmakers and entertainment and business journalists. Originally, Swifties were outraged in November 2022 when millions flocked to Ticketmaster.com to grab tickets to see her perform for the first time since 2018 and the website crashed. The long wait lines and frozen screens sparked an uproar with fans blaming Ticketmaster for ruining their chances to see the pop star. While the initial anger reportedly stemmed from the Ticketmaster platform being unable to handle that volume of activity, the larger, on-going outrage stems from consumers discovering that tickets are instantly sold out, but within minutes are offered on secondary resale marketplaces for thousands of dollars. According to the Los Angeles Times, the face value of the tickets for Swift’s concert at SoFi Stadium ranged from $49 to $449. However, tickets on StubHub were quickly being sold for around $800 up to $11,000.[8]
Billboard recently reported:
Prices to see [Taylor] Swift at one of her final nine shows in the United States have increased following the release of the album April 19, with the average get-in-the-door price — the lowest price available — hovering around $2,600 per ticket, according to data from TicketIQ. That means it would cost a couple more than $5,000 just to be in the same building as Swift in Miami . . , New Orleans . . . and Indianapolis . . . this fall.
In Europe, however . . . tickets cost only a fraction of that. Right now, the get-in-the door price to see the opening of the European leg of the Eras Tour is $340 a ticket — 87% cheaper than the average price in the United States. . . . That means a fan in Miami could fly to Paris for about $900 a person . . . spend two nights at a four-star hotel at $250 a night and purchase a $340 concert ticket for a grand total of $1,740 — which is still $760 less than the cheapest tickets currently available for her Miami shows.
Tickets to see Swift in Stockholm . . . are even cheaper, at $312 for the cheapest tickets, while tickets for her show in Portugal . . . start at $336 and in Spain . . . start at $324.[9]
Opponents of this bill have argued that one of the reasons that Swift tickets remain so much lower is because Ticketmaster does not have the same control over the market in other countries. Policymakers in the state and federal government have agreed that Live Nation Entertainment/Ticketmaster’s oversized market share represents a significant problem. However, as noted above, the face value price of Taylor Swift tickets during the United States leg of her tour, particularly here in California, were in a similar range as those in Europe. So, it is unclear what impact their domination in the primary market played in this case.
The opposition has also posited that another reason for the difference in ticket prices is that Swift is not as popular in Europe, so the demand is not as great. However, Swift fans at her recent sold-out concerts in Edinburgh, Scotland may beg to differ. According to reports from the British Geological Survey, Swift’s fans caused an actual earthquakes during her concerts. Seismic readings were detected almost 4 miles away from the stadium.[10]
While this bill is not about or for Ms. Swift, her popularity, the interest of the media, and the loud voices and devotion of her fans provide an opportunity to clearly observe the problems in the United States’ entertainment ticket market and compare it to ticket markets in other countries.
4) European countries’ continue to distrust “touts.” Despite the fact that ticket brokers and other secondary resellers are directly competing with consumers in the primary ticket market and may be the reason they cannot find tickets, people in the United States have embraced the resale ticket market as a valid business model that provides consumers with the ability to purchase tickets to events that they could not otherwise attend, albeit at a premium price. This is not the case in many European countries where consumers, policymakers, and mainstream media have remained wary of the practice of purchasing tickets in order to resell them at an inflated price, which the U.K. refers to as “touting.”
Ticket market experts point to this general distrust as one of the reasons for the difference in ticket prices between the United States and Europe, while the United States has turned its attention to the domination of Live Nation Entertainment, the parent company for Ticketmaster, as the main driver behind skyrocketing ticket prices.[11] Policymakers in other countries have taken concerns related to the price of tickets and the resale market so seriously that one of the planks that the Labour party in Britain is running on for the upcoming July 4th election is a commitment to cap the price of resale tickets. According to the Change Labour Party Manifesto 2024:
With Labour, the arts and music will no longer be the preserve of a privileged few. Culture is an essential part of supporting children and young people to develop creativity and find their voice. . . . Access to music, drama and sport has become difficult and expensive because of ticket touting. Labour will put fans back at the heart of events by introducing new consumer protections on ticket resales.[12]
In reporting on the commitment to regulate the resale market, the BBC reports, “Labour will cap the resale prices of tickets and regulate resale platforms if the party wins the next general election, Sir Keir Starmer has said. The plans will clamp down on ticket touts who rip off music and sports fans going to live events, Sir Keir said.”[13]
4) Joint Informational Hearing: Online Ticketing and Access to Live Entertainment (Feb. 13, 2024). During a joint informational hearing earlier this year between this Committee and the Arts, Entertainment, Sports and Tourism Committee, the Assemblymembers and public heard from an economist with expertise in online marketplaces, independent venue operators, representatives of artists, Consumer Reports, primary ticket sellers, and a resale marketplace platform. One thing became clear during the testimony of experts and those working in the field: the secondary resale market in California is fundamentally broken.
It has become virtually impossible for average consumers to find tickets for sale from the primary online box office for a myriad of reasons: popular events are immediately sold out within seconds of the tickets going on sale, while they simultaneously pop up on resale marketplaces at significantly inflated prices; a simple Google search for tickets presents consumers with link after link to resale marketplaces because the company has paid to boost their site on the search engine; a website that appears to be the official site for the event (i.e. muppetslivetickets.com) is actually a white label site that links to a secondary market place platform; or the tickets being advertised for sale are actually speculative tickets because even though the event has been announced, the actual tickets have not gone on sale yet.
During the hearing, venue operator after venue operator expressed frustration with having to deal with angry and frustrated fans who showed up at the venue with tickets that were fake. According to their testimony, this is a growing problem and for many of them it is happening every night that there is a show at their venue.
These small business owners told of shows that were sold out and the venue purchased food and beverages and staffed the venue for a large crowd, only to find that the venue ended up being half empty because a ticket broker had purchased all of the tickets to the event but had been unable to resell them. This particular problem does not initially seem like a significant one for venues because they have sold all of the available tickets. However, venues generally do not make their revenue from the sale of tickets that revenue goes to the artist. The primary revenue for the venue comes from selling food, beverages, and merchandise. So, when a venue has staffed up and ordered enough supplies for a sold out crowd and they do not show up, the venue ends up losing money on the show.
Similarly, representatives for artists spoke of the importance of the relationship between artists and their fans. Artists often price tickets in a reasonable range that will allow their fans to afford to attend. When those tickets are purchased by scalpers or ticket brokers, in violation of the posted terms and conditions, and resold for several times the original price, not only do the artists and venues not make any increased revenue from the higher prices but the artist’s fans often become upset and blame the artist for the high price of the tickets.
All of this is not to suggest that the Committee does not believe that there are also major problems in the primary marketplace related to the fact that Ticketmaster enjoys a monopoly by controlling 80 percent of ticket sales. But the artists, their managers, the venue operators, and the consumer experts all overwhelmingly agreed that the largest and most immediate problems they faced were due to an out-of-control secondary market where the primary business model involves competing with actual consumers in the primary market in order to then turn around and sell the tickets to the same consumers at greatly inflated prices.[14]
5) Purpose of this bill. Arguing in support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce states these reasons why this bill is needed:
Imagine waiting for tickets for your favorite musical artist to go on sale – sitting at your computer or phone, ready to click buy when they go on sale for $85 per seat. Then, the moment comes … and they are already sold out. Somehow, they sold out instantly. Then, within an hour, those same tickets are being sold on other ticket re-sale websites … for 200% or 300% more. And when the next concert is announced, tickets are being sold before they go online, again at inflated prices.
That has been the reality of ticket sales. Scalpers are able to use computer programs (bots) to purchase large volumes of tickets, then re-sell them for considerable profits to the desperate fans who cannot compete with the scalpers’ bots. Though President Obama outlawed the practice,[15] it continues because the profits are too substantial.[16] This abusive process by scalpers and secondary re-sellers has angered both fans[17] and artists.
One emotional example was a concert given by the Foo Fighters as a benefit for their late former drummer. Tickets were put online for $89 for their fans – but within an hour of sale, had popped up on re-sale websites and were being sold for over $400.[18]
These predatory practices provide no market value to fans, venues, or artists – they simply drive-up ticket costs and profit scalpers.
It is these problems in the secondary market that this bill seeks to address by banning the practice of selling speculative tickets; banning the use of deceptive websites; prohibiting the technology and activities that allow scalpers and ticket brokers to acquire large numbers of tickets in the primary market; significantly increasing the penalties for violating the state’s ticketing laws; and, ensuring that the resale marketplaces that facilitate these practices take responsibility for the tickets that are being sold on their platforms.
6) Author’s statement. According to the author:
SB 785 will reform the laws governing the purchase and sale of tickets to live entertainment and sporting events in California, and create meaningful protections for consumers, artists, teams, and local venues.
Current law regulates ticket brokers but does not apply to the resale platforms where consumer deception and price gouging occurs. This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues.
SB 785 will protect consumers, artists, teams, and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently harms consumers and the event presenters who bring live entertainments their fans. Specifically, this bill will:
- Impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at checkout.
- End the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.
- Establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.
- Establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.
This bill puts fans and live entertainment creators—rather than scalpers who prey on fans--first. In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the rights of the artists, entertainers, and teams to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to ensure the availability of face values
7) What this bill does. This bill includes the following significant changes to current entertainment ticket law:
Prohibits speculative tickets sales. Ends speculative ticket sales, except in instances where a ticket seller has a contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket must own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
- Requires an original seller or a ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing, and before selling, disclose to the purchaser the specific seat within the venue that the purchaser is entitled to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have a contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, to disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
Restricts ticket purchases from the primary box office. Declares if unlawful for a person to do the following in order to circumvent restrictions on primary sale tickets:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the combined posted terms and conditions of the rights holder, event presenter, and venue operator.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
Prohibits deceptive marketing practices. Prohibit using a box office website that looks substantially similar to the venue or primary seller’s website in order to direct sales to the resale market. Specifically prohibits the following:
- A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
- Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Representing that a live entertainment event is sold out or use the term “sold out” when tickets are still available from the original seller.
Increases penalties. Increases the current fine of $2,500 to a fine of up to $10,000 for each ticket that is sold or offered for sale in violation of the chapter.
- Action may be brought by:
- The Attorney General.
- A district attorney.
- A city attorney.
- A county council of a county.
- A city prosecutor in a city.
- In addition to the fines, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates the sections of this bill related to speculative tickets, deceptive marketing, or prohibited purchasing practices is civilly liable to the consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending.
8) Analysis. As discussed throughout this analysis, the conditions in the ticket resale market have not only caused prices to skyrocket, but have also allowed unscrupulous ticket resellers to mislead consumers who are attempting to purchase tickets to attend a live entertainment event. This bill seeks to prohibit some of the most deceptive practices and addresses a number of the concerns raised during this Committee’s informational hearing.
Among their other concerns, opponents of this bill have consistently pointed to two issues related to this bill. First, the inclusion of broad terms and conditions for event presenters. On this topic, StubHub, in an “oppose unless amended” position, writes:
Sec 9. 22503.3 endorses an event presenter’s (i.e. LNE) ability to unilaterally set, impose, and enforce terms and conditions on ticket sales, ticket pricing, the transfer or resale of tickets sold, as well as the technologies used to sell tickets. This effectively endorses anticompetitive terms and conditions and restrictive technologies that limit consumer choice and further engrains a monopoly that is alleged by the DOJ and Attorney General Bonta to use anti-competitive tactics to disadvantage artists, venues, consumers, and competitors. We respectfully request that this committee remove Sec. 9 from the bill to protect consumers, the broader industry and competition in the live event space.
The most recent author’s amendments (as amended June 27, 2024) removed this section from the bill.
Secondly, opponents have expressed concern related to requirements that the original face value of a ticket be included in any resale posting. On this point, the Coalition for Ticket Fairness, an association of ticket brokers and secondary platforms, notes:
. . . [T]he bill uses the guise of “transparency” to further suffocate competition from the secondary market by imposing requirements on resellers that in many instances would be impossible to meet, such as listing the face value of tickets that are resold or requiring a specific seat location for tickets that consumers purchase in a particular “zone” of a venue. The so called “transparency” proponents request in SB 785 has no public policy benefit and is merely intended to further stifle the secondary market.
In a world of dynamic primary pricing, the “face value” of a ticket is difficult if not impossible to verify, and can lead to confusion that may encourage consumers make a poor financially decision. It is very common for a primary seller to drip supply into the market at a given price, for example $50. If those tickets sell “too fast”, they may sell the row in front or behind (or the seats next to) the $50 seats at $75, then when those sell, at $100 and so on… A consumer given the face value information buying a $50 ticket on the secondary market might balk at a price of $80, when an almost identical seat with a face value of $100 might be sold at $90. Simply because someone is losing money on a $100 ticket does not mean the consumer is better off paying $90 vs $80 for identical tickets. What someone paid at one point in time is not relevant to the consumer’s buying decision, but knowing how many tickets were sold and if more tickets may become available would be.
Author’s amendments, taken on June 24, 2024, remove the requirement that tickets being resold contain information related to the original face price of the ticket.
9) What remains to be done? While more remains to be done in both the primary and secondary markets, this bill addresses some of the most significant problems in the secondary market and significantly increases the consumer protections for fans who are purchasing tickets in order to attend live events. Based on discussions with artists, consumers, venue operators, and talent organizations and research into ticketing practices in other states and other countries, legislators may want to consider the following policies in future legislation:
Price caps. Likely the single most impactful policy for controlling the price of tickets is a cap both on the resale price and on the amount of fees secondary marketplaces can charge for allowing the tickets to be sold on their platforms. The primary driver between the price of tickets in California and the prices in other countries can be traced to capping the amount someone is allowed to resell a ticket for. In Europe, prices are kept low thanks to laws limiting how high tickets can be marked up over face value. In countries like France, Germany and the Netherlands, ticket resellers face limits on how much tickets can be marked up on secondary sites — typically 20 percent over face value. Since 2021, Ireland has capped the resale price of a ticket at what it originally sold for in the primary market. Maryland, in its recent legislation was considering a ten percent cap on resale tickets.[19]
While generally limiting prices in most markets could be seen as something to be leery of, this market is the rare exception where there is a justification to limit resale prices given all of the abuses detailed throughout this analysis.
In addition to capping the resale price, legislators should also consider capping the fees that can be charged by resale platforms. Unlike the primary ticket fees, which are generally shared between the ticket seller and the venue operator, resale fees, in most cases, solely benefit the resale platform.
The rights of artists. While the author has removed the language in the bill allowing for event presenter’s to exercise sweeping authority over the way in which tickets are priced, transferred, sold, and resold, there is a strong argument for enshrining in state law the rights of artists to establish terms and conditions and maintain control over their own work product.
Enumerating a limited range of terms and conditions turned over to artists allows clear artist control over the provisions that matter most to them like restricting resale to face value, using adjusted pricing, or making tickets available to fan club members. All of these choices are examples of decisions that artists should be allowed to control.
Protecting a consumers’ ability to either resell or give away a ticket they cannot use. Equally important in the policies that should be considered is the question of what someone should be able to do with a ticket they are unable to use. The most consumer-protective approach is to require that ticket sellers ensure that consumers can exchange a ticket at face value to recoup their money, give the ticket away to someone of their choosing, or be able to try to resell it on the secondary marketplace for a capped amount. This would ensure that the ticket will not go unused.
Exploring exclusivity contracts. Small venue operators have been very clear that exclusive contracts with primary ticket sellers is a critical part of their business model. However, given Live Nation’s dominance, while the anti-trust lawsuit is being decided at the federal level, lawmakers may want to consider limiting exclusive contracts when the venue operator, the event promoter, and the primary ticket seller are all part of the same company. This approach, arguably, would provide openings in the primary ticket market for other companies to gain a larger market share and it would eliminate some of the most egregious practices in the primary market.
10) Suggested Committee amendments. Though primarily clarifying in nature, the suggested Committee amendments are spread throughout the bill. A complete mock-up is included as an attachment at the end of this analysis.
11) Related legislation. AB 2203 (McCarty, 2024) requires ticket sellers that sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theater, or any other entertainment event, to immediately deliver a proof of purchase to a consumer, and would require a venue operator to honor that proof of purchase in lieu of the ticket if specified conditions are met. This bill is currently awaiting hearing in the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee.
AB 2808 (Wicks, 2024) prohibited certain entertainment venue operators from entering into an exclusive contract with a primary ticket seller. That bill was held on the Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) requires a ticket seller to disclose to a purchaser the total price of the ticket and the portion of that price that represents any fees or surcharges. The seller must also provide a link to an internet webpage that includes certain refund requirements, as specified. This bill is currently on the suspense file in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits the operator of an entertainment facility and a primary ticket seller from entering into a contract that provides for the primary ticket seller to be the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. SB 829 is currently in this Committee.
SB 478 (Dodd; Ch. 400, Stats. of 2023) makes it an unlawful business practice pursuant to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act to advertise, display, or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than taxes imposed by a government.
AB 1556 (Friedman, Ch. 180, Stats. 2021) requires for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation; and requires a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
AB 329 (Pan, Ch. 325, Stats. 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Writing in support of the bill, the National Independent Venue Association (NIVA) states:
I want to be clear: this measure is in no way, shape, or form a giveaway to LiveNation/Ticketmaster as the opponents suggest. Independent venues and promoters have been advocating across the nation for reforms contained in this bill because of the flood of fake tickets we see at our doors night after night that hurt our small businesses. Taylor Swift does not grace our stages but we unfortunately see fake tickets night after night and often look on the secondary platform sites to see our $30 tickets priced at $150 when we have inventory available on our websites.
Just last week on June 8th, the Sonoma Press-Democrat published an article, entitled “Sonoma, Napa county venues are warning concertgoers about uptick in inflated, fake tickets,” that offers a snapshot of what our member venues deal with night after night. Certain deceptive websites, appearing to be affiliated with venues, are actually third-party vendors with no connection to the venue. These sites often rank highly in search engine results for tickets, presenting themselves as official outlets, yet they charge inflated prices, sometimes up to triple the face value of the ticket.
The opposition to this measure would argue this proposal strengthens a monopoly’s hold on the industry. This is not true. This measure addresses the major challenges independent venues and promoters face with regard to fraudulent tickets or massively overpriced tickets on third-party platforms that hurt our reputations.
Opponents would also have you believe that empowering the secondary market will “increase competition” and promote “ticket freedom.” This is also not true and doing so as they articulate will increase the likelihood of predatory practices thus diminishing the fan experience at a show. Without banning speculative and predatory ticketing practices, fans may have more places to purchase tickets, but will have less guarantees that the ticket is real/valid, resulting in a terrible experience when they arrive and find out their ticket is fake and they can’t get into the show. SB 785 takes these necessary steps to truly protect not only the consumer (fans), but the artists and the venues who depend on the trust and engagement of the fans.
By considerately putting the fan first, SB 785 will help to ensure that fans get valid tickets, artists perform to more fans at their shows, and venues will have a better chance of protecting their businesses and reputations. There have been many bills in California, and around the country, that have attempted to reshape and reform ticketing but SB 785 has the most potential to simultaneously protect fans, artists and venues from deceptive, inflammatory and predatory ticket resellers in a model for the rest of the country.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Echoing the concerns raised by several groups the Consumer Federation of California, writes:
On May 23rd of this year the federal Department of Justice, joined by 29 states and the District of Columbia, [sued the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly] for violating antitrust law and urged that it be broken up. The 29 states that joined in the lawsuit included California and our Attorney General as well as the following states: Arkansas, Florida, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia, and Wyoming, to just name a few. This speaks to the overwhelming bipartisan nature of legal concern with the monopolistic actions of Live Nation/Ticketmaster ever since their merger in 2010.
[ . . .]
The lawsuit filed by the federal DOJ plus 30 jurisdictions serves, among other things, as an invitation to the federal government and the states to take stronger action on behalf of consumers to limit the destructiveness of the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly while the case attempting to break it up winds its way slowly through the U.S. court system. Historically antitrust cases like this have taken numerous years to adjudicate, so the California Legislature should act now to significantly trim the wings of the monopoly.
Instead, respectfully, SB 785 aims its sights squarely on what limited competition there is in the marketplace against the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly. SB 785’s general approach is to make things worse for consumers by making things better for the monopoly as they fight the lawsuit striking at the heart of their corporate practices. This is misguided.
That is not to say that there aren’t productive conversations to be had about so-called speculative ticketing, where consumers think they have a ticket to a show but the entity they “bought” it from has to go out and secure that ticket after the consumer has paid, or deceptive websites that fool consumers into thinking they are interacting with the actual concert venue only to find out that they’ve been defrauded. But these issues pale in comparison to the larger problems directly foisted upon consumers by the monopoly and the various issues that would help consumers by legislatively limiting monopoly power. Taking on the Live Nation/Ticketmaster monopoly seems to be later on the legislative priority list than helping the monopoly harm consumers by forcing their competition to take a haircut while the monopoly, their apologists and allies egg them on.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of Independent Music
Axs
Bay Area Council
Black Music Action Coalition
California Arts Advocates
California Chamber of Commerce
City of Thousand Oaks
Forty Niners Football Company Llc, a Delaware Limited Liability Company
Future of Music Coalition
Golden State Warriors
International Association of Venue Managers
Live Nation Entertainment, INC.
Los Angeles Rams
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
National Football League
National Independent Venue Association of California
Nederlander Concerts
Orange County Business Council
Ovg360
Recording Academy
Recording Industry Association of America
SAG-AFTRA
San Francisco 49ers
San Jose Sharks
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
Opposition
Coalition for Ticket Fairness
Consumer Federation of California
Netchoice (UNREG)
Progressive Policy Institute
Protect Ticket Rights
Sports Fans Coalition
Vivid Seats LLC
Oppose Unless Amended
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Lulac
California Urban Partnership
Central Valley Latino Mayors and Elected Officials Coalition
Central Valley Yemen Society
Chamber of Progress
Gametime
Hispanic 100
Latin Business Association
Lenusa
Multicultural Business Alliance
National Action Network - Sacramento Chapter
National Consumers League
Seatgeek, INC.
Si Se Puede Fresno, Tulare, Kings & Kern
Stubhub, INC.
Tickpick
Tickpick, LLC
Women Veterans Alliance
SUGGESTED COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 22500 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22500. (a) Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
(b) A violation of this section shall constitute a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or by both.
(c) For the purposes of this chapter, each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation. An action for a violation of this chapter may be brought only by any of the following:
(1) The Attorney General.
(2) A district attorney.
(3) A city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000.
(4) A county counsel of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000.
(5) A city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney.
(d) In an action alleging a violation of this chapter, the court shall impose a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for each violation of this chapter. Additionally, the court shall award a prevailing public prosecutor reasonable costs and attorney’s fees. In determining the amount of the civil penalty, the court shall consider all of the relevant circumstances presented by any of the parties to the case, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1) The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.
(2) The number of violations.
(3) The persistence of the misconduct.
(4) The length of time during which the misconduct occurred.
(5) The willfulness of the misconduct.
(6) The assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
(e) The remedies provided by this section are cumulative to each other and to the remedies or penalties available under all other laws of this state.
SEC. 2. Section 22501 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22501. Original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket resale marketplaces shall maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds for at least a period of one year after the initial sale.
SEC. 3. Section 22502 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22502. (a) An original ticket seller or a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, shall own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) An original seller or a ticket reseller shall, at the time of listing or marketing of, and before selling a ticket, disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within a that entertainment venue.
(c) Subdivision (b) shall not apply to flexible series ticketing options that allow attendees to commit to a number of performances in advance, while choosing the specific performances at a later date.
SEC. 4. Section 22502.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.3. (a) It shall be unlawful for an original seller or a ticket reseller to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket if they do not own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket.
(b) A reseller, a resale marketplace, or any affiliate of a reseller or resale marketplace shall not do either of the following:
- Resell more than one copy of the same ticket to a live entertainment event.
- Employ another person directly or indirectly to wait in line to purchase tickets for the purpose of reselling the tickets.
SEC. 5. Section 22502.1 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22502.1. (a) (1) A ticket resale marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, shall require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer consumer.
(2) By allowing a ticket to be posted for resale on its website, a ticket resale marketplace is confirming that the ticket is being sold in compliance with all applicable state laws.
(b) A ticket resale marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, shall disclose to the purchaser consumer, by means of a description or a map, the location within the entertainment venue that the ticket will permit the purchaser consumer to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, unless that ticket is designated as standing room only or not otherwise associated with occupying a particular location within an entertainment venue.
SEC. 6. Section 22502.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.4. I It shall be unlawful for an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace to represent that they can deliver or cause to be delivered, a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range, and to fail to deliver within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, the ticket, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated.
SEC. 7. Section 22502.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22502.5. In addition to other remedies, an original seller, a ticket reseller, or a ticket resale marketplace that violates Section 22505.1 or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser consumer for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser consumer in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs.
SEC. 8. Section 22503 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22503. (a) An “artist” means an actor rendering services on the stage, musical artist, musical organization, or other performing artist rendering professional services in theatrical and other live entertainment enterprises.
(b) A “consumer,” as used in this chapter, means a natural person who purchases tickets to an entertainment event with the purpose of attending that event.
(c) An “entertainment venue” means a publicly or privately owned place that holds live entertainment events, including, but not limited to, an arena, auditorium, concert hall, live performance venue, racetrack, stadium, theater, or other place where entertainment events are presented for a price of admission.
(d) An “event,” as used in this chapter, means a live entertainment event, including a live sporting, musical, or theatre event.
(e) An “event presenter,” as used in this chapter, means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
(f) A “live entertainment event” means a scheduled live performance at a specific date, time, and location, including, but not limited to, a theatrical or operatic performance, concert, or sporting event, including, but not limited to, football, basketball, baseball, boxing, tennis, hockey, or any other sport.
(g) An “original seller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter, rights holder, or venue operator, or the sale of an event ticket that was returned to the primary seller or event organizer after its initial sale and is sold by or on behalf of the event organizer.
(h) A “rights holder,” as used in this chapter, means an artist, performing arts organization, theater or dance company, a professional sports team, professional sports league, author, lecturer, or any other persons who are the primary speakers or performers at an event for which tickets are sold.
(i) A “ticket” means a license, issued by the venue operator, for admission to the place of entertainment at the date and time specified on the ticket.
(j) A “ticket resale marketplace,” as used in this chapter, means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the resale or exchange of, or resells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resaleincluding a site operated by an original seller that allows consumers to resell tickets.
(k) A “ticket reseller,” as used in this chapter, means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
(l) A “venue operator” means any person who owns, operates, manages, or controls an entertainment venue.
SEC. 9. Section 22503.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 10. Section 22503.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22503.4. This chapter does not apply to an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier, or motor coach carrier that purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter, or their agent, by written agreement.
SEC. 11. Section 22505.2 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
22505.2. (a) A person ticket reseller shall not use an internet website, or cause an internet website to be used, to display either of the following:
(a) (1) A trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder.
(b) (2) Any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter, rights holder, or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, with the intent to mislead and without the written consent of the event presenter, rights holder, or original seller.
(b) A ticket reseller shall not represent that the live entertainment event is sold out or use the term sold out when tickets are still available on the original seller’s website.
SEC. 12. Section 22505.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended and renumbered to read:
22505.1. Notwithstanding Section 22503.4, 22504, or 22511, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a) Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b) Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c) Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d) Purchase tickets in violation of the combined event presenter’s, rights holder’s, and venue operator’s posted terms and conditions.
(e) Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
SEC. 13. Section 22507 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22507. (a) The ticket price of an event that is canceled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser consumer by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser consumer, whether an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace, within 30 calendar days of the cancellation.
(b) The ticket price of an event that is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time, shall be fully refunded or credited to the account of the purchaser consumer by the person who processed the sale of the ticket upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
(c) For purposes of this section, a rescheduled event includes a canceled occurrence of a recurring event for which the purchaser consumer is offered the opportunity to attend another, materially identical occurrence of the same event, at a different date or time.
(d) A local jurisdiction may require an original seller, ticket reseller, or ticket resale marketplace to provide a bond of not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to provide any refunds that may be required pursuant to this section.
SEC. 14. Section 22508 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.
SEC. 15. Section 22511 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:
22511. This chapter does not apply to any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge.
SEC. 16. No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
Analysis Prepared by: Julie Salley / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
The Event Ticketing Industry is Broken and in Need of Disruption, Aventus Network (May 19, 2017). ↑
Tyler Jenke, “Ed Sheeran’s manager has admitted to selling tickets to resale services,” The Music Network (Jun 3, 2018) available at https://themusicnetwork.com/ed-sheeran-manager-sold-tickets-resale/. ↑
NITO Ticket Resale Study. National Independent Talent Organization (Jul 2023) ↑
Ibid. ↑
Duncan, Byard. “How is this Legal?” The Center for Investigative Reporting, March 8, 2021, available at https://revealnews.org/article/how-is-this-legal/. ↑
California Department of Justice. Attorney General Bonta Files Lawsuit Against Live Nation, Ticketmaster (May 23, 2024) https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-files-lawsuit-against-live-nation-ticketmaster. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Judge in Live Nation Antitrust Case Indicates Possible Start Date for Blockbuster Trial,” Billboard (Jun. 28. 2024) https://www.billboard.com/pro/live-nation-antitrust-case-judge-possible-trial-start-date/, ↑
Fox, Emma. “$11,000 to see Taylor Swift? How concert tickets got so expensive,” The Los Angeles Times (July 27, 2023) https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2023-07-27/explaining-the-complicated-world-of-ticketing. ↑
Brooks, Dave. “Why Are Taylor Swift Eras Tour Tickets So Much Cheaper in Europe?” Billboard (May 2, 2024) https://www.billboard.com/business/touring/taylor-swift-eras-tour-tickets-cheaper-europe-1235671760/. ↑
Melnick, Kyle. “Swifties set off earthquake sensors again. These songs made the biggest stir.” The Washington Post (Jun. 13, 2024) https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/2024/06/13/taylor-swift-concert-fans-dance-earthquake-sensors/. ↑
While Ticketmaster’s domination is a legitimate concern, as discussed earlier in this analysis, the available data does not support the fact that primary market prices account for the high price of tickets. ↑
Geiger, Chas. “Keir Starmer vows to cap resale music and sport ticket prices,” BBC (Mar. 14, 2024) https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-68563793. ↑
Ibid. ↑
For additional information, a detailed background paper and a video link to the hearing is available at https://apcp.assembly.ca.gov/hearings/2023-24-informationaloversight-hearings. ↑
President Obama signed the Better Online Ticket Sales (BOTS) Act in December of 2016. Discussed here: https://www.westarts.org/news-updates/the-battle-between-bots-and-the-ticket-industry-continues, and here https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/president-obama-signs-bots-act-law-7625257/. ↑
As an example, the Federal Trade Commission Action against three scalpers for $3.7 million for buying over 150,000 tickets and re-selling them. https://www.pcmag.com/news/3-scalpers-fined-for-using-bots-to-scoop-up-tickets-on-ticketmaster ↑
https://www.npr.org/2021/12/10/1063237219/olivia-rodrigo-sour-tour-tickets ↑
https://themanc.com/audio/fans-fume-as-taylor-hawkins-tribute-concert-tickets-appear-on-resale-sites-for-four-times-the-price/ ↑
While the final version of Maryland’s ticketing reform bill did not include caps, it is expected that caps will be reintroduced in their next legislative session. ↑
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ARTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SPORTS, AND TOURISM
Sharon Quirk-Silva, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 785
Author:(Caballero) – As Amended Ver:June 28, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 34-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protection: ticket sellers
SUMMARY: SB 785 updates laws regulating ticket sellers and establishes various requirements on certain types of information that must be disclosed to the purchasers of tickets to events.
Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Event presenter” means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- “Original seller ” mean a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
- “Ticket marketplace” means an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
- A “ticket reseller” means a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- Requires original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to be registered with the Secretary of State and be duly licensed, as may be required by any local jurisdiction.
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter will constitute a separate violation which may be brought only by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000, a county council of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000, or a city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney, and requires the court to impose a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 for each violation of the law and circumstances that may inform the penalty.
- Prohibits event presenters, original sellers, ticket marketplaces, and ticket resellers from advertising, displaying, or offering a price for a ticket that does not include all fees or charges that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, other than taxes or fees imposed by a government on the transaction. The total cost of the ticket must be clearly and conspicuously disclosed, from the first time pricing is displayed and anytime thereafter, except that a reasonable fee may be charged for the delivery of a non-electronic ticket if multiple delivery options are presented to the purchaser for selection and the delivery fee is disclosed to the purchaser before payment is accepted.
- Prohibits original sellers and ticket resellers from advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the original seller or ticket reseller to do so.
- Requires ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces must include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket.
- Requires original sellers and ticket resellers to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell a ticket, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket. They must also disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
- Requires a ticket marketplace, before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket, to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer. A ticket marketplace, on its internet website in each ticket listing, must disclose to the purchaser, by means of a description or a map, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
- States that nothing in this chapter shall infringe upon the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
- Repeals a provision of existing law which states that this chapter does not apply to any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor, with “primary contractor” being defined as the person or organization who is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold.
- Prohibits a person from using an internet website, or causing an internet website to be used, that displays a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder, or any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Prohibits a person from intentionally using, causing to be used, or selling software or services that do any of the following:
- Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
- Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenter’s posted terms and conditions.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a ticket seller as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Clarifies that the following are not ticket sellers subject to various sections of the bill:
- An officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter or their agent by written agreement.
- Any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the premises where the event is to take place, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- Any primary contractor (defines as the person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold) or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor.
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22503.6, 22504, 22511.)
- Imposes various requirements on ticket sellers. A violation of any of these provisions constitutes a misdemeanor and may subject the ticket seller to civil liability. These requirements include that tickets sellers:
- Have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation, a violation of which constitutes a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both. Provides that a person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this specific requirement is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 for each violation;
- Maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds;
- Prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets;
- Make any partial or full deposit received on a future event for which tickets are not available refundable, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent until tickets for the event are actually available;
- Disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller;
- Provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event which is canceled;
- Provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time;
- provide a bond of not more $50,000 to provide for any refunds in a local jurisdiction that requires this; and
- Disclose in any advertisement or promotion for any event that a service charge is imposed and added to the actual ticket price. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22500-22511.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket; has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or informs the purchaser the seller does not have possession of the tickets, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price, as specified. Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two days, of the terms of the deposit agreement, and includes in the oral and written notice other required disclosures. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver within a reasonable time at or below or within the price and range of prices stated. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.2.)
- Specifies that a ticket seller who violated this prohibition and violates 3) above is civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended in trying to attend the event, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.3.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Justice reports costs of $225,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24 and $395,000 in FY 2024-25 and ongoing for increased enforcement workload and this bill will result in unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate additional misdemeanor offenses for violations of the requirements and prohibitions established by this bill (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues… This bill puts fans and live entertainment creators, rather than scalpers who prey on fans, first. In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the rights of the artists, entertainers, and teams to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to ensure the availability of face values tickets to fans, prevent fraud and deter organized scalping.”
- Background. On October 21, 2022, singer and songwriter Taylor Swift released a new album called “Midnights.” The album was an overnight success, and Taylor Swift, at 32, became the first artist ever to simultaneously capture all Top 10 spots with songs from the “Midnights” album. Days after releasing the album, Swift announced her Eras Tour, the first of her musical tours since 2018 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Tickets were set to go on sale on November 18, 2022. Pre-sale for tickets for select fans with certain corporate partnerships began as early as November 1, 2022. Ticketmaster and at least one tour date in Nashville noted that ticket prices could fluctuate based on demand at any given time. On November 15, during presale, Ticketmaster’s website crashed following millions showing up to buy Swift’s concert tickets. After Ticketmaster determined there were at least questions as to whether there were enough tickets to meet buyer demand, Ticketmaster also cancelled its general ticket sale that was supposed to open on November 18, 2022. This meant that fans who otherwise would have paid hundreds of dollars to see Swift in concert were left to purchase them off of resale websites, where they were going for thousands of dollars (some even around $20,000).
According to Forbes, Ticketmaster’s failure was caused in large part due to bot attacks, but also due to the failure of leadership to engage in meaningful practices and philosophies among employees to help them respond in a crisis.
On Tuesday, January 24, 2023, the US Senate Judiciary Committee had a hearing on the issue, focusing specifically on the Live Nation and Ticketmaster’s 2010 merger. Leading up to the hearing, Senator Klobuchar told Rolling Stone that she believed Live Nation Entertainment was a monopoly because, as a company, it has 70% of tickets for major concern venues; venue operators said that they were concerned about not getting Live Nation’s shows at their venues if they don’t use Ticketmaster; the company utilized exclusivity deals that can last three to seven years; hidden fees, some costing up to 75% of a ticket’s face value; and Live Nation is owning more and more venues, which was not the case in 2010 when the merger occurred. In the January 2023 hearing, Senators questioned Live Nation and raised potential solutions to the problems above, including non-exclusivity of contracts between venues and ticketing agents, placing price caps on tickets, and working more closely with the FTC to stop speculative ticket sales. National media has been following the story since October and November of 2022.
- The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights. Among other steps taken to drive more consumer-centric responses to the experiences highlighted above, consumer advocacy groups launched a campaign culminating in The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights. According to its website, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights “is a set of principles the nation’s leading consumer advocacy groups and others believe should serve as a framework for ticketing legislation that can improve the live events ticketing market that serves millions of fans each year. The Bill of Rights features four pillars: The Right to Transferability, where ticketholders decide how to use, sell or give away their tickets if they wish and not the entity that previously sold the tickets; The Right to Transparency, which includes all-in pricing and disclosures of relevant information for the purchasing decision; The Right to Set the Price, so that companies who originally sold the tickets cannot dictate to fans for what price they can or cannot resell their purchased tickets, and, lastly; The Right to a Fair Marketplace, where fans compete with actual humans, not illegal software bots, for tickets.”
Specifically, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights includes:
- All-in, upfront pricing – no surprise fees at checkout
- Mandating primary ticket-selling companies to report all ticket bot activity to the appropriate authorities
- Disclosure of how many tickets are available to the general public at the time of “on sale”
- Clear and conspicuous disclosure when a ticket seller does not have a ticket in their possession or contractual right
- The guarantee of unrestricted transfer of all tickets
- A prohibition on deceptive URLs and other fraudulent reseller practices
This framework is meant to provide guidance for legislative action to ensure consumer protection in ticketing sales. At the state level, legislatures have been taking action to ensure consumer protection with respect to ticket sellers, particularly Live Nation entertainment.
- President Biden and Ticketmaster. On June 15, 2023, President Biden hosted a roundtable discussion with representative from Live Nation, Ticketmaster, SeatGeek, TickPick, and others, where they pledged to give consumers the ability to see the full price of tickets up front, minimizing the frequently frustrating experience of watching additional fees add up late in the checkout process when buying online. The president has urged Congress to pass legislation targeting other hidden costs paid by consumers throughout the economy. Some of the commitments include Live Nation’s pledge that, in September, all tickets sold for its shows through Ticketmaster automatically will list all the prices up front, for all tickets to events.
- Arguments in support. According to a coalition of organizations representing musicians and recording artists, including the Screen Actors Guild - American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA), the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the Black Music Action Coalition, the Music Artists Coalition, and more:
“We represent music creators, the venues where artists play, the labels for whom they record, and labor organizations – those who create, invest in and deliver live entertainment events to our fans. No one cares more about music fans and creating a great live experience for those fans than our members. Our members are the ones who work every day to make concerts great… Simply put, artists and performers support SB 785 because it would bring existing ticket purchasing law into the digital age, applying reforms to all ticketing platforms – at source or resale. SB 785’s protections would be a boon to fans, artists, and venues alike. The undersigned organizations believe fans are best served when artists are in control, not industrial resellers.”
Additionally, according to primary market ticketing company AXS:
SB 785 will, “end the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce price gouging of our fans and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets, establish serious penalties for employing BOTS that deprive consumers of access to face value tickets, and allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large scale scalping, and establish meaningful penalties for selling tickets by engaging in the fraudulent practice of using deceptive URLs to lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.”
- Arguments in opposition. According to the Consumer Federation of California (CFC) and the Sports Fans Coalition:
“We believe that when a consumer buys a ticket the ticket is theirs. As the saying goes, ‘life happens,’ and when a consumer can’t attend a concert or sporting event for any of a myriad of reasons then they should be able to dispose of their tickets. Under the current version of SB 785 this is not the case, so consumers will be left holding the bag. This is why, especially given the monopolistic nature of the ticketing industry, transferability is an important consumer protection that currently serves as an important check against monopoly power. Artist groups that sponsor SB 785 have said that their objective is to eliminate the secondary ticket market altogether. As the market currently stands that would put even more power in the hands of the monopoly. History has shown that monopoly power harms consumers.”
Additionally, according to ticket exchange and resale companies StubHub and Vivid Seats:
“We believe that a competitive, transparent, and secure ticket marketplace unequivocally supports fans. Competition can drive affordability and an overall better consumer experience. As leading ticket resale marketplaces that provide fans with a secure, safe, and convenient place to buy and sell tickets to a wide variety of events, we are concerned that SB 785 would harm competition and extend the already immense control of one entity over the live event industry… In the U.S., primary ticket sales for an event are typically exclusive to one original ticket seller. Consumers are subject to the terms and conditions, technology, fee structure, and service provided by that original ticket seller. Due to their exclusive distribution agreements, original ticket sellers, many of which also have secondary ticketing marketplaces, are uniquely positioned to utilize technology or restrictive terms and conditions placed on the initial sale of the ticket to control consumer behavior, limit consumer choice, and thwart competition.”
- Committee comments. The following amendments were processed by the committee prior to the bill being presented in committee.
- Language proposed by the California Department of Justice on all-in-pricing
- A requirement that original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces be registered with the Secretary of State
- Striking Business and Profession Code Section 22503.5, that excludes primary contractors from the provisions of this chapter.
The committee has additionally requested that the author commit to removing the section of the bill which would codify the right of an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the transfer and resale of tickets to their events, for reasons outlined in The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights above. Due to legislative deadlines and the timing of negotiations, the proposed amendment was unable to be taken in this committee.
- Double-referral. Should this bill pass out of this committee, it will be re-referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
- Prior and related legislation:
- AB 8 (Friedman), of 2023, would require a ticket seller to disclose to a purchaser the total price of the ticket and the portion of that price that represents any fees or surcharges. The seller must also provide a link to an internet webpage that includes certain refund requirements, as specified. (Status: The bill is currently in the Senate Committee on Business, Professions, and Economic Development)
- SB 478 (Dodd), of 2023, would make it an unlawful business practice, pursuant to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, to advertise, display, or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than taxes imposed by a government. (Status: The bill is currently in the Assembly Committee on Judiciary)
- SB 644 (Glazer), of 2023, would require a hotel, third-party booking service, hosting platform, or short-term rental to allow a reservation to be canceled without penalty if the cancellation is commenced within 24 hours of the reservation being finalized so long as the reservation is made 24 hours or more prior to the day of check-in. (Status: The bill is currently in the Assembly Committee on Judiciary)
- SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits the operator of an entertainment facility and a primary ticket seller from entering into a contract that provides for the primary ticket seller to be the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. (Status: The bill is currently in the Assembly Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, and Tourism)
- AB 1556 (Friedman), Chapter 180, Statutes of 2021, requires, for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation. Requires a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
- SB 1001 (Hertzberg), Chapter 892, Statutes of 2018, prohibits a person from using of a bot to communicate or interact with another person in California online with intent to mislead the other person about its artificial identity for the purpose of knowingly deceiving the person about the content of the communication in order to incentivize a purchase or sale of goods or services in a commercial transaction or to influence a vote in an election.
- AB 329 (Pan), Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013, made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s Internet Web site that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of Independent Music
Axs
Black Music Action Coalition
City of Thousand Oaks
Future of Music Coalition
International Association of Venue Managers
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
Orange County Business Council
Ovg360
Recording Academy
Recording Industry Association of America
SAG-AFTRA
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
Opposition
Chamber of Progress (Unless Amended)
Consumer Federation of California
National Consumers League
NetChoice
Protect Ticket Rights
Sports Fans Coalition
Stubhub, INC. (Unless Amended)
Vivid Seats LLC (Unless Amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Brian Anderson / A.,E.,S., & T. / (916) 319-3450
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 785 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 785
Author: Caballero (D), et al.
Amended: 5/1/23
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-1, 4/17/23
AYES: Roth, Archuleta, Ashby, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wahab
NOES: Alvarado-Gil
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Niello, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/25/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wilk, Niello, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Seyarto
SUBJECT: Consumer protection: ticket sellers
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill updates laws regulating ticket sellers by establishing new categories of ticket sellers and establishing various requirements for certain types of ticket sellers; prohibits an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller from listing, marketing, or selling a ticket before owning, possessing, or having the contractual right to the ticket; and prohibits event presenter likeness from being used on any website.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines a ticket seller as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Clarifies that a number of entities are not a ticket seller subject to various requirements.
- Establishes various requirements for ticket sellers, a violation of which constitutes a misdemeanor.
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket; has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or informs the purchaser the seller does not have possession of the tickets, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price, as specified. Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two days, of the terms of the deposit agreement, and includes in the oral and written notice other required disclosures. (BPC § 22502.1)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver within a reasonable time at or below or within the price and range of prices stated. Specifies that a ticket seller who violated this prohibition and violates 3) above is civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended in trying to attend the event, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. (BPC §§ 22052.2 and 22052.3)
This bill updates laws regulating ticket sellers by establishing new categories of ticket sellers and establishing various requirements for certain types of ticket sellers; prohibits an original ticket seller or a ticket reseller from listing, marketing, or selling a ticket before owning, possessing, or having the contractual right to the ticket; and prohibits event presenter likeness from being used on any website. This bill also:
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate violation which may be brought only by the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city that has a population greater than 750,000, a county council of a county within which any city has a population greater than 750,000, or a city prosecutor in a city that has a full-time city prosecutor, with the consent of the district attorney. Requires the court to impose a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 for each violation of the law and circumstances that may inform the penalty.
- Specifies the following:
- An “event presenter” is he person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- An “original seller ” is a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
- A “ticket marketplace” is an entity who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
- A “ticket reseller” is a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event.
- Requires a) through d) above to disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase and disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser. Prohibits a) through d) from making a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
- Requires ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Authorizes ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to include in any listing for a resale ticket the face price of the original ticket.
Background
A Recent Catalyst: Taylor Swift. Tickets for Taylor Swift’s concert in years were set to go on sale on November 18, 2022. Pre-sale for tickets for select fans with certain corporate partnerships began as early as November 1, 2022. Ticketmaster and at least one tour date in Nashville noted that ticket prices could fluctuate based on demand at any given time. On November 15, during presale, Ticketmaster’s website crashed following millions showing up to buy Swift’s concert tickets. After Ticketmaster determined there were at least questions as to whether there were enough tickets to meet buyer demand, Ticketmaster also cancelled its general ticket sale that was supposed to open on November 18, 2022. This meant that fans who otherwise would have paid hundreds of dollars to see Swift in concert were left to purchase them off of resale websites, where they were going for thousands of dollars (some even around $20,000). According to Forbes, Ticketmaster’s failure was caused in large part due to bot attacks, but also due to the failure of leadership to engage in meaningful practices and philosophies among employees to help them respond in a crisis.
US Judiciary Committee Hearing. On Tuesday, January 24, 2023, the US Senate Judiciary Committee had a hearing on the issue, focusing specifically on the Live Nation and Ticketmaster’s 2010 merger. Leading up to the hearing, Senator Klobuchar told Rolling Stone that she believed Live Nation Entertainment was a monopoly because, as a company, it has 70% of tickets for major concern venues; venue operators said that they were concerned about not getting Live Nation’s shows at their venues if they don’t use Ticketmaster; the company utilized exclusivity deals that can last three to seven years; hidden fees, some costing up to 75% of a ticket’s face value; and Live Nation is owning more and more venues, which was not the case in 2010 when the merger occurred. In the January 2023 hearing, Senators questioned Live Nation and raised potential solutions to the problems above, including non-exclusivity of contracts between venues and ticketing agents, placing price caps on tickets, and working more closely with the FTC to stop speculative ticket sales. National media has been following the story since October and November of 2022.
Efforts to Respond to Consumer Protection Issues. Among other steps taken to drive more consumer-centric responses to the experiences highlighted above, consumer advocacy groups launched a campaign culminating in The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights. According to its website, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights “is a set of principles the nation’s leading consumer advocacy groups and others believe should serve as a framework for ticketing legislation that can improve the live events ticketing market that serves millions of fans each year. The Bill of Rights features four pillars: The Right to Transferability, where ticketholders decide how to use, sell or give away their tickets if they wish and not the entity that previously sold the tickets; The Right to Transparency, which includes all-in pricing and disclosures of relevant information for the purchasing decision; The Right to Set the Price, so that companies who originally sold the tickets cannot dictate to fans for what price they can or cannot resell their purchased tickets, and, lastly; The Right to a Fair Marketplace, where fans compete with actual humans, not illegal software bots, for tickets.”
Specifically, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights includes:
- “All-in, upfront pricing – no surprise fees at checkout;
- Mandating primary ticket-selling companies to report all ticket bot activity to the appropriate authorities;
- Disclosure of how many tickets are available to the general public at the time of “on sale”;
- Clear and conspicuous disclosure when a ticket seller does not have a ticket in their possession or contractual right;
- The guarantee of unrestricted transfer of all tickets; and
- A prohibition on deceptive URLs and other fraudulent reseller practices.”
This framework is meant to provide guidance for legislative action to ensure consumer protection in ticketing sales. At the state level, legislatures have been taking action to ensure consumer protection with respect to ticket sellers, particularly Live Nation entertainment.
In June 2022, the New York Legislature passed a bill to increase transparency in the ticket-buying process for live events like concerns and plays, whereby ticket sellers and resellers must disclose all fees upfront so that prices do not change during a transaction (for instance, in last step in checkout). Additionally, the New York Legislature introduced a bill in 2021 that would have instituted civil penalties for using ticket-purchasing software; required an online resale market to post the ticket price in advertisements or offers of resale; and required ticket prices to be disclosed prior to a customer purchasing a ticket, among other things.
In Colorado, a bill has been introduced this year that would prohibit “speculative ticketing,” or the process by which brokers sell tickets they do not possess. The bill would also require online companies to clearly display total, inclusive prices of all service charges and other fees included in the purchase of the ticket. According to The Denver Post, the bill also “expands the definition of deceptive trade practices to include the use of automation to buy tickets or circumvent limits, selling tickets without being upfront about all the fees, and increasing ticket prices once they have been selected.”
Comments
According to the author, “This bill modernizes our ticketing laws to reflect a rapidly changing live event ticketing ecosystem…When the statute was first enacted, internet resale ticketing platforms did not exist. Now, the resale platforms are where much of the price gouging and anti-consumer behavior occurs (such as listing speculative tickets that the seller does not possess, listing tickets without identifying a specific seat location, and often listing tickets before they have gone on sale to the general public). The resale platforms are also in the best position to police such anti-consumer activities…The need for transparent, upfront pricing was vividly demonstrated recently when Beyonce announced her upcoming tour. Within minutes of her tour announcement—and before tickets were even priced or offered for sale to the public—tickets were being advertised on resale websites for more than $22,000 per ticket. If that wasn’t scandalous enough, it wasn’t until consumers had input all their information and were ready to cart the (still unavailable) ticket at the very end of the transaction that consumers were alerted to an additional $6,400 resale platform commission fee…This bill will address the increasing problem of speculative ticketing…This bill will expressly protect the current rights of event presenters--the artists, entertainers, teams and venues that provide live entertainment to their fans--to continue to choose how tickets to their events may be priced, sold, transferred or resold. And it will continue to allow them to determine the technologies they wish to deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they may use to ensure the availability of face value tickets to their fans, to prevent fraud, to control costs for fans and to deter large scale ticket scalping.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Justice reports costs of $225,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24 and $395,000 in FY 2024-25 and ongoing for increased enforcement workload and this bill will result in nknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate additional misdemeanor offenses for violations of the requirements and prohibitions established by this bill (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).”
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/19/23)
American Association of Independent Music
AXS
Bay Area Council
Black Music Action Coalition
Future of Music Coalition
Golden State Warriors
International Association of Venue Managers
Live Nation Entertainment, Inc.
Los Angeles Rams
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
National Football League
Nederlander Concerts
Recording Academy
Recording Industry Association of America
SAG-AFTRA
San Francisco 49ers
San Jose Sharks
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/19/23)
Consumer Federation of California
Netchoice
Sports Fans Coalition
StubHub, Inc.
Vivid Seats
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters generally argue that this measure will protect consumers, artists, and venues by better regulating ticket scalping that is currently negatively affecting the ticketing industry.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opposition generally argues that there are better measures to protect consumers and address these concerns, namely AB 8 (Freidman, 2023). StubHub, Inc. and Vivid Seats write in opposition unless amended. They argue that the legislation creates a competitive advantage for particularly Ticketmaster and Live Nation Entertainment. Specifically, they say, “Unfortunately, SB 785 is not designed to empower consumers, but to enshrine the control that event presenters and original ticket sellers enjoy today. SB 785 will harm consumers by further limiting competition and do little to solve the frustrations consumers face during the ticket buying process.”
Prepared by: Dana Shaker / B., P. & E.D. /
5/20/23 13:09:34
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 785 (Caballero) - Consumer protection: ticket sellers
Version: May 1, 2023 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 9 - 1, JUD. 8 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 15, 2023 | Consultant: Janelle Miyashiro |
Bill Summary:
SB 785 revises and recasts laws regulating ticket sellers, including establishing various categories of ticket sellers with different provisions applying to each and increasing penalties for violations, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) reports costs of $225,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24 and $395,000 in FY 2024-25 and ongoing for increased enforcement workload (Unfair Competition Law Fund and General Fund).
- Unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate additional misdemeanor offenses for violations of the requirements and prohibitions established by this bill (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
Background:
The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights is a set of principles consumer advocacy groups and others believe should serve as a framework for ticketing legislation that can improve the live events ticketing market that serves millions of fans each year. The Bill of Rights features four pillars:
1. The Right to Transferability, where ticketholders decide how to use, sell or give away their tickets if they wish and not the entity that previously sold the tickets;
2. The Right to Transparency, which includes all-in pricing and disclosures of relevant information for the purchasing decision;
3. The Right to Set the Price, so that companies who originally sold the tickets cannot dictate to fans for what price they can or cannot resell their purchased tickets, and;
4. The Right to a Fair Marketplace, where fans compete with actual humans, not illegal software bots, for tickets.
Specifically, the Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights includes:
- “All-in, upfront pricing – no surprise fees at checkout.
- Mandating primary ticket-selling companies to report all ticket bot activity to the appropriate authorities.
- Disclosure of how many tickets are available to the general public at the time of “on sale.”
- Clear and conspicuous disclosure when a ticket seller does not have a ticket in their possession or contractual right.
- The guarantee of unrestricted transfer of all tickets.
- A prohibition on deceptive URLs and other fraudulent reseller practices.
This framework is meant to provide guidance for legislative action to ensure consumer protection in ticketing sales.
Various aspects of the problems consumers have encountered in their attempts to purchase tickets have been the source of a number of legislative efforts. AB 329 (Pan, Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s internet website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. In 2021, AB 1556 (Friedman, Chapter 180, Statutes of 2021) responded to concerns stemming from customer experiences with cancelled or postponed events by requiring that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation if an event is cancelled and a refund within 30 days upon the ticket purchaser’s request for postponed, rescheduled, or replaced events.
Proposed Law:
- Recasts provisions related to ticket sellers, instead applying requirements and prohibitions to original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces, as defined:
- “Original seller” means a person who, for compensation or commission, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
- “Ticket reseller” means a person who, for compensation or commission, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- “Ticket marketplace” means an entity who, for compensation or commission, advertises, lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, whether original sale or resale.
- “Event presenter” means the person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale violating specified ticket seller requirements constitutes a separate violation.
- Increases the civil penalty from $2,500 to up to $10,000 for each violation, and requires a court to consider relevant circumstances, including the nature, seriousness, persistence, duration, and willfulness of the misconduct, the number of violations, and the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the defendant.
- Requires an original ticket seller or ticket reseller to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket.
- Requires an original ticket seller or ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing before selling a ticket, to disclose the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale.
- Strikes the authorization for a ticket seller to contract for or accept consideration for payment in full for the sale of tickets if the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or in writing within two business days, that the seller does not have possession of the tickets and has no contract to obtain the offered ticket a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket.
- Prohibits an original seller or a ticket reseller from advertising, offering for sale, or contracting for the sale of a ticket, or accepting consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including and without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the original seller or ticket reseller to do so.
- Requires a ticket marketplace to require the person listing the ticket to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer before the marketplace may accept a listing to market or sell a ticket.
- Requires a ticket marketplace to disclose on its internet website in each ticket listing, the location within the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket.
- Prohibits a person from using or cause an internet website to be used to display a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder, or any combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Prohibits a person from intentionally:
- Purchasing tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
- Circumventing or disabling an electronic que, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with online ticket sales.
- Circumventing or disabling a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
- Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenter’s posted terms and conditions.
- Utilize multiple Internet Protocol addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Requires original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to make certain disclosers before the ticket is selected for purchase:
- The total cost of a ticket including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket.
- The amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser.
- For ticket resellers and marketplaces, the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter. Requires ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to include the face price of the original ticket in any listing for a resale ticket.
- Prohibits original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces from making a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
- Provides that an event presenter maintains the right to impose terms and conditions on the sale pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
- Makes other technical and conforming changes.
Related Legislation:
SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits exclusivity contracts for ticket sales between venues and ticket sellers, as specified. SB 829 is pending on the Suspense File in this committee.
AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) recasts the laws governing ticket sellers, including making changes related to pricing transparency and transferability of tickets sold for admission to sporting, musical, theatrical, or any other entertainment events. AB 8 is pending on the Suspense File in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
It is unknown how many prosecutions for misdemeanor violations will be brought as a result of this bill. However, it generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Consequently, if the additional misdemeanor cases take 50 or more hours of court involvement across the State, the cost pressures of this measure would surpass this committee’s Suspense File threshold. Misdemeanor charges carry the potential for incarceration, therefore certain defendants’ rights are attached to the proceedings. These include the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased staff time and resources may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. Numerous trial court operations are funded through the imposition and collection of criminal fines and fees. However, the Legislature has reduced and eliminated criminal fines and fees over the past decade. As a result, the 2023-24 proposed budget anticipates an ongoing annual allocation of $109.3 million from the GF to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 785 (Author:Caballero)
Version: April 10, 2023
Hearing Date: April 25, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Consumer protection: ticket sellers
DIGEST
This bill reworks the laws governing ticket sellers, including creation of various categories of ticket sellers with different provisions applying to each.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
As any self-respecting Swiftie will tell you, there are very real problems in the world of ticket buying, creating more than a little Bad Blood. In addition to more infamous ticket buying debacles such as the roll out of tickets for Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour, most consumers have faced the well-documented issues with purchasing tickets to sporting events, concerts, and other live entertainment. This includes exorbitant and hidden fees, nearly instantaneous ticket sellouts followed by price gouging on the secondary market, and websites that attempt to pass themselves off as the primary ticket seller. Fingers are pointed in all different directions as to who or what is responsible.
This bill attempts to address the consumer protection issues in this arena by amending the chapter of law governing ticket sellers. The bill establishes new categories of ticket sellers, establishes various requirements for certain types of ticket sellers, and significantly increases penalties for violations. It prohibits a subset of ticket sellers from certain practices and provides a cause of action to “original ticket sellers” and “event presenters.” While some of the provisions provide clear consumer benefits, others, such as this latter one, seem to stack the deck on one side of the industry without benefit, and possibly to the detriment of consumers.
The bill is author sponsored. It is supported by venues and other industry players, including Live Nation/Ticketmaster. It is opposed by ticket resellers and consumer groups, including the Consumer Federation of California. The bill passed out of the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee on a 9 to 1 vote.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Defines a ticket seller as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Clarifies that the following are not ticket sellers subject to various sections of the bill:
- an officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter or their agent by written agreement.
- any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the premises where the event is to take place, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- any primary contractor (defines as the person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold) or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor.
- any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22503.6, 22504, 22511.)
- Imposes various requirements on ticket sellers. A violation of any of these provisions constitutes a misdemeanor and may subject the ticket seller to civil liability. These requirements include that tickets sellers:
- have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation, a violation of which constitutes a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both. Provides that a person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this specific requirement is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 for each violation;
- maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds;
- prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets;
- make any partial or full deposit received on a future event for which tickets are not available refundable, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent until tickets for the event are actually available;
- disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller;
- provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event which is canceled;
- provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time;
- provide a bond of not more $50,000 to provide for any refunds in a local jurisdiction that requires this; and
- disclose in any advertisement or promotion for any event that a service charge is imposed and added to the actual ticket price. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 22500-22511.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket; has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or informs the purchaser the seller does not have possession of the tickets, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price, as specified. Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two days, of the terms of the deposit agreement, and includes in the oral and written notice other required disclosures. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.1.)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver within a reasonable time at or below or within the price and range of prices stated. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.2.)
- Specifies that a ticket seller who violated this prohibition and violates 3) above is civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended in trying to attend the event, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22502.3.)
This bill:
- Strikes reference to “ticket seller” throughout the chapter governing ticket sellers and instead defines the following terms:
- “original seller” means a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, on behalf of an event presenter, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter;
- “ticket reseller” as a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller;
- “ticket marketplace” means a person, except the event presenter or original seller, who advertises lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, or on behalf of, a ticket reseller to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for compensation, commission, or otherwise; and
- “event presenter” means a person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- Authorizes an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
- Requires original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to comply with requirements under current law for ticket sellers to have a permanent business address and increases the penalty for a violation of this requirement from $2,500 to $25,000 for each violation, and $250,000 for each continuing violation. Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale by an original seller, ticket reseller, and ticket marketplace that does not have a permanent business address constitutes a separate violation, and makes remedies cumulative to each other and the remedies or penalties available under all other state laws.
- Replaces reference to ticket sellers with original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces who must comply with the requirement under current law for ticket sellers to maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
- Requires only a ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing, and before selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket and to disclose to the purchaser the location in the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale at the time of listing or marketing of and before selling a ticket via a description or a map. Further requires only a ticket marketplace, in each listing on its website, to disclose this information, excluding the face price a ticket reseller must disclose, to the purchaser.
- Replaces the prohibition on a ticket seller contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket with a prohibition only on a ticket reseller from advertising, offering for sale or contracting for the sale unless the ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession and the ticket reseller has contractual authority from the event presenter to obtain it. Prohibits a ticket reseller from advertising, offering for sale, or contracting for the sale of a ticket, or accepting consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the ticket reseller to do so.
- Requires a ticket marketplace to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket.
- Replaces a ticket seller with only a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace in the prohibition under current law from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and to fail to deliver that ticket within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated. Subjects only a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace to the remedies under current law for a violation.
- Authorizes an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury from a violation of these laws to bring a civil action against that person and authorizes the original seller or event presenter to recover damages for the injury, plus any damages a court may determine to be appropriate, and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Prohibits a person from using a website to display a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder and prohibits the use of a combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Updates prohibitions on using or selling software to circumvent measures designed to ensure an equitable ticket buying process by prohibiting the purchase of tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale, prohibiting the circumventing or disabling of an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code or other sales volume limitation systems, prohibits circumventing or disabling a system used to facilitate entry into an event, prohibits purchasing tickets in violation of the event presenter’s posted terms and conditions, and prohibits the use of multiple ISP addresses, purchaser accounts, or multiple email address to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Updates provisions of the law related to refunds in the event of a cancellation by specifying that refunds must be issued by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser whether they are an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace. Requires the person who processed the sale of the ticket to provide a refund in the event of a postponement, reschedule, or replacement event.
- Requires original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase and to disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser. Prohibits original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces from making a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
- Requires ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter and requires any listing for a resale ticket to include the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenter’s website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket and purchase that ticket.
- Exempts any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge from being subject to any of the above requirements.
COMMENTS
- Ticketing woes: anti-consumer practices and antitrust issues
Ticketing for major sports events, concerts, and other live entertainment has drawn many critics for a variety of anti-consumer practices. This includes speculative sales, where ticket sellers sell tickets they do not actually have at the time of the sale.
One practice is the use of automated software or “bots” to rapidly buy up tickets to in-demand events that the person deploying the bots then turns around and sells at a hefty markup. This has been such a nefarious process that the federal government passed a law in 2016 to stop people from employing this scheme, the Better Online Ticket Sales Act (BOTS Act). The BOTS act prohibits the circumvention of a security measure, access control system, or other technological control measure used online by a ticket issuer. The Act also prohibits selling or offering to sell an event ticket obtained through such a circumvention violation if the seller participated in, had the ability to control, or should have known about the violation. The act applies to event tickets for public concerts, theater performances, sporting events, and similar activities at venues with seating capacity of over 200.
The FTC enforced the act against three New Yorkers that collectively made over $26 million in revenue over the matter of a few years:
The defendants pulled off the scheme by using bots on the Ticketmaster website. The programs—which went by the names Automatick, Tixman and Tixdrop—were capable of repeatedly searching web pages for available tickets and then automatically reserving them.
In addition, the defendants used hundreds of credit cards belonging to fake people, and routed their internet activity to the Ticketmaster page through spoofed IP addresses. “In many instances, Defendants also did not use their address as the primary address, shipping address, or billing address for their Ticketmaster accounts. Instead, they used over 550 addresses that were either fake or unrelated to their business,” the FTC alleged in a court complaint.[1]
However, as the author points out, the BOTS act lacks a consumer enforcement mechanism and is rarely enforced. In fact, this FTC enforcement action in early 2021 was the first time the FTC brought such an action.
The lack of healthy competition in the ticket selling world is also a primary concern of consumer advocates and ticket buyers. The worst culprit according to many is Live Nation Entertainment. In 2010, the company, which is a massive events promoter and venue operator, merged with Ticketmaster, a ticket sales giant. Together they control an estimated 70 percent of the ticketing and live event venues market. The merged entity was responsible for the infamous Taylor Swift ticketing debacle:
It’s no secret that Taylor Swift fans were outraged in November 2022 when millions flocked to Ticketmaster.com to grab tickets to see the heartbreak queen for the first time since 2018 and the website crashed. The long wait lines and frozen screens sparked an uproar with fans, blaming Ticketmaster for ruining their chances to see the pop star.
“As the leading player, we have an obligation to do better,” said Joe Berchtold, Live Nation Entertainment president and chief financial officer, at the hearing Tuesday.
This is not the first time consumers have called for the breakup of Ticketmaster and Live Nation. It’s also not the first time the Department of Justice has been reportedly looking into alleged misconduct by the company.
When the Live Nation and Ticketmaster merger was approved in 2010, it was under the condition of a consent decree. Among other things, the purpose of that agreement was to forbid Live Nation from retaliating against a venue for using a ticketer other than Ticketmaster. After an investigation, in 2019 the DOJ made its most significant enforcement action of an antitrust decree in 20 years when it alleged Live Nation Entertainment violated that decree. The company settled with the government.[2]
The near-monopoly power has created concerns among many that Live Nation will retaliate if you go with a ticketing company other than their Ticketmaster operation and in many cases exclusivity agreements require Ticketmaster to be used:
“In a world where the promoter and the venue are not affiliated with each other, we can trust that the promoter will look to get the best deal from the venue; however, in this case the promoter and the venue are part of the same corporate entity so the line items are essentially Live Nation negotiating to pay itself,” [one musician] said.
The band told CNBC if they want to play a certain size venue in a particular city, they are sometimes left no choice other than to use Live Nation because of the lack of competition in some regions. Then if they would like to use another ticketer other than Ticketmaster, they say that is not an option.
“Ticketmaster has created these exclusive contracts, once you sign that contract, a band is not allowed to come in and say, ‘we want to sell our tickets with X, Y, Z platform,’” said Jordan Cohen, one of the band’s eight members.
They even have a song with the lyric, “Live Nation is a monopoly.” “Due to Live Nation’s control across the industry, we have practically no leverage in negotiating,” Lawrence said.
While the company does have some competition, experts say no other firm currently stands a chance.[3]
These concerns are not just from musicians and consumer advocates. The Justice Department was reported to have opened an investigation into Live Nation, focused on whether the company has “abused its power over the multibillion-dollar live music industry”:
Members of the antitrust division’s staff at the Justice Department have in recent months contacted music venues and players in the ticket market, asking about Live Nation’s practices and the wider dynamics of the industry, said the people, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the investigation is sensitive. The inquiry appears to be broad, looking at whether the company maintains a monopoly over the industry, one of the people said.[4]
This Committee’s federal counterpart felt the issue pressing enough to hold an oversight hearing to delve into the issue, “Location Change: That’s the Ticket: Promoting Competition and Protecting Consumers in Live Entertainment.”[5] Senator Klobuchar explained the need for the hearing: “For too long, consumers have faced high fees, long waits, and website failures, and Ticketmaster’s dominant market position means the company faces inadequate pressure to innovate and improve.”[6]
The practices above leave consumers in the lurch. They are forced to pay exorbitant service fees and other charges, exacerbated by the fact that the original ticket seller faces little competition. Then, if they are not among the lucky ones who can buy quickly, they are price gouged on the secondary market. A report by the United States Government Accountability Office (GAO) confirmed these practices and outcomes:
Consumer protection issues include difficulty buying tickets at face value and the fees and marketing practices of some market participants.
- Professional resellers, or brokers, have a competitive advantage over consumers in buying tickets as soon as they are released. Brokers can use numerous staff and software (“bots”) to rapidly buy many tickets. As a result, many consumers can buy tickets only on the resale market at a substantial markup.
- Some ticket websites GAO reviewed did not clearly display fees or disclosed them only after users entered payment information.
- “White-label” resale sites, which often appear as paid results of Internet searches for venues and events, often charged higher fees than other ticket websites—sometimes in excess of 40 percent of the ticket price—and used marketing that might mislead users to think they were buying tickets from the venue.[7]
The GAO report also discussed potential solutions:
Selected approaches GAO reviewed, such as ticket resale restrictions and disclosure requirements, would have varying effects on consumers and businesses.
- Nontransferable tickets. At least three states restrict nontransferable tickets—that is, tickets whose terms do not allow resale. Nontransferable tickets allow more consumers to access tickets at a face-value price. However, they also limit consumers' ability to sell tickets they cannot use, can create inconvenience by requiring identification at the venue, and according to economists, prevent efficient allocation of tickets.
- Price caps. Several states cap the price at which tickets can be resold. But according to some state government studies, the caps generally are not effective because they are difficult to enforce.
- Disclosure requirements. Stakeholders and government research GAO consulted generally supported measures to ensure clearer and earlier disclosure of ticket fees, although views varied on the best approach (for example, to include fees in an “all-in” price or disclose them separately).
Some market-based approaches are being used or explored that seek to address concerns about secondary market activity. These approaches include technological tools and ticket-buyer verification to better combat bots. In addition, a major search engine recently required enhanced disclosures from ticket resellers using its advertising platform. The disclosures are intended to protect consumers from scams and prevent potential confusion about who is selling the tickets.
In response to growing concerns within the ticketing industry, a coalition of consumer groups, including the Consumer Federation of America, Consumer Action, and the National Consumers League published the “Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights,” which they describe as “a set of principles the nation’s leading consumer advocacy groups and others believe should serve as a framework for ticketing legislation that can improve the live events ticketing market that serves millions of fans each year.[8] The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights features five pillars:
The Right to Transferability, where ticketholders decide how to use, sell or give away their tickets if they wish and not the entity that previously sold the tickets;
The Right to Transparency, which includes all-in pricing and disclosures of relevant information for the purchasing decision;
The Right to Set the Price, so that companies who originally sold the tickets cannot dictate to fans for what price they can or cannot resell their purchased tickets;
The Right to a Fair Marketplace, where fans compete with actual humans, not illegal software bots, for tickets, and, lastly;
The Right to Recourse, where harmed fans retain the choice to seek remedies through the public court system and are not blocked by terms and conditions that force them into private arbitration.
- Addressing consumer protection issues in ticket sales
According to the author:
SB 785 will reform the laws governing the purchase and sale of tickets to live entertainment and sporting events in California, and create meaningful protections for consumers, artists, teams, and local venues.
Current law regulates ticket brokers but does not apply to the resale platforms where consumer deception and price gouging occurs. This bill will modernize California ticket purchasing laws to apply to all ticketing platforms, both original sale and resale, in order to provide comprehensive and uniform protections for fans, artists, teams, and venues.
SB 785 will protect consumers, artists, teams, and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently harms consumers and the event presenters who bring live entertainments their fans. Specifically, this bill will:
- Impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at checkout.
- End the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.
- Establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.
- Establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.
This bill puts fans and live entertainment creators—rather than scalpers who prey on fans--first. In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the rights of the artists, entertainers, and teams to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to ensure the availability of face values tickets to fans, prevent fraud and deter organized scalping.
Chapter 21 of Division 8 of the California Business and Professions Code provides a series of regulations governing “ticket sellers,” defined as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event.
This bill overhauls this entire chapter in an attempt to address the consumer protection issues identified above. The bill includes a number of new protections. For instance, it carries out a directive from the Bill of Rights above by prohibiting deceptive URLs and the use of designs, images, and internet addresses that are substantially similar to those of an event presenter or original seller. It also bolsters an existing provision and borrows from the BOTS act to go after practices that seek to vacuum up tickets. It provides:
[I]t shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use, cause to be used, or sell software or services to do, or to otherwise engage in, any of the following:
(a) Purchase tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale.
(b) Circumvent or disable an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code, or other sales volume limitation system associated with an online event ticket sale.
(c) Circumvent or disable a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to facilitate authorized entry into an event.
(d) Purchase tickets in violation of the event presenter’s posted terms and conditions.
(e) Utilize multiple ISP addresses, multiple purchaser accounts, or multiple email addresses to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
However, it is unclear if other changes made by the bill are as effective. For instance, as noted, the existing chapter regulates “ticket sellers.” This bill creates multiple additional categories, including original sellers, ticket resellers, ticket marketplaces, and event presenters. While creating additional categories may allow for more nuanced regulations, the existing law benefits from simplicity and consistency, applying a set of guidelines that apply to all ticket sellers.
The bill applies its various new or modified provisions to different categories, and not necessarily in a way that seems consistent or equitable. In fact, many of the provisions in the bill seem to go after only one side of the industry, the resellers and ticket marketplaces, the Stubhubs of the industry. And the provisions actually seem to tilt the playing field toward original sellers and event presenters, the Live Nation/Ticketmaster side of the equation, without clear consumer benefits.
For instance, existing law provides: “A ticket seller shall, prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets.” This bill amends this provision to only apply to ticket resellers and adds a provision that imposes a similar requirement on ticket marketplaces. In addition, the previous provision requires a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. As Live Nation Entertainment owns 70 percent of the ticket marketplace, having a contractual right to sell the ticket in all practicality means having a contractual right with Live Nation Entertainment or Ticketmaster, where Ticketmaster can operate as a resale platform. Furthermore, although entities like Ticketmaster operate secondary sales through its own marketplace, the definition of “ticket marketplace” specifically carves out original sellers.
In addition, the bill imposes enhanced liability provisions that only apply to ticket resellers or ticket marketplaces:
22502.5. In addition to other remedies, a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace that violates Section 22505.1, 22502.2, or 22502.4 shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending, or attempting to attend, the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs.
Exacerbating the disparity, one of the predicate violations for these enhanced penalties is the requirement discussed above to disclose the location of a seat on a map or otherwise that applies to only ticket marketplaces.
Not only are these penalties not targeted at original sellers or event presenters or the type of misconduct often found in that sphere of the market, but the bill provides specific causes of action for them.
22502.6. An original seller or event presenter who suffers injury as a result of another person’s violation of this chapter may bring a civil action against that person and may recover from that person damages for the injury plus any additional damages a court may determine to be appropriates, and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
It is no surprise then that the bill is supported by Live Nation and opposed by not only ticket resellers, such as StubHub, but also consumer groups.
A coalition of groups, including Live Nation Entertainment, write in support:
[W]e support this bill because of what it will not do. This bill will not infringe upon the rights of the teams, entertainers and venues that invest in, create and deliver live events for our fans. It will confirm our intellectual property rights in our brands and events including the determination of ticket prices and how we choose to sell our tickets, rather than turning those decisions over to third parties who have no skin in the game, little accountability and do nothing to create or enhance our fan experiences.
Consumer Federation of California writes in opposition:
Buying tickets to attend an event should be straightforward for consumers, yet the extensive use of multiple vague itemized fees by companies such as Ticketmaster (the overwhelmingly dominant player in the industry) has made this an extraordinarily expensive and frustrating process. These practices prevent consumers from comparison shopping and frequently require them to pay fees that are up to 27-30% more than the advertised price. Transparency is key when consumers engage in the purchasing of tickets to attend live events and SB 785 fails to provide adequate protection for consumers who may purchase a ticket from an original seller, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces.
SB 785, as currently drafted, does not properly define ticket seller and therefore fails to get at the heart of the issue, which is the control exercised over consumers by those marketplace participants such as the monopolistic Ticketmaster/Live Nation that control the industry. This bill also fails to provide consumers with ownership over their own purchased tickets, forcing consumers limited to no options should they need to resell their tickets.
Writing in support, the Recording Academy praises the consumer protection measures included in the bill:
SB 785 will protect consumers and artists by regulating the organized, bulk ticket reselling that currently plagues the ticketing entertainment industry. Specifically, this bill will:
- Impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at check-out.
- End the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.
- Establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.
- Establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.
StubHub and Vivid Seats jointly write in opposition, highlighting the tilt of this measure:
Enshrines Double Standards & Legislates a Competitive Advantage
SB 785 fails to include any meaningful regulation of original ticket sellers or event presenters. For example, the legislation excludes those entities from basic disclosure requirements such as the ticket’s location. Furthermore, the definitions in Sec. 12 of SB785 exempt the event presenter and original ticket seller from any regulations around the resale of tickets. The practical impact would be to exclude Ticketmaster, an active ticket resale marketplace that reported $4.5B in ticket resale revenue in 2022 alone, from any of the requirements placed on resellers or ticket resale marketplaces when they act as the original ticket seller or when their parent company LNE acts as the event presenter. Finally, SB 785 prohibits any ticket reseller or ticket resale marketplace from offering a ticket for sale prior to an event presenter’s public onsale process. This provision dismisses the fact that tickets are frequently distributed and/or acquired prior to the public on-sale process and serves to provide more control to event presenters.
In response to these concerns, the author has agreed to a fairly comprehensive set of amendments that do the following:
- reduce the civil penalties that apply to violations of the ticket seller chapter with guidance on the proper amount of the penalty and allow for public enforcement consistent with California’s Unfair Competition Law, Business and Professions Code Section 17200 et seq.;
- insert “original sellers” into the relevant section prohibiting unfair practices;
- removes the civil cause of action provided to only original sellers and event presenters;
- removes the original seller carve out from the definition of “ticket marketplace”; and
- removes the requirement for ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to provide a link to the event presenter’s website.
SUPPORT
Axs
Bay Area Council
Black Music Action Coalition
Future of Music Coalition
Golden State Warriors
Live Nation Entertainment
Los Angeles Rams
Music Artists Coalition
Music Workers Alliance
National Football League
Recording Academy
Sag AFTRA
San Francisco 49ers
San Jose Sharks
Songwriters of North America
Union of Musicians and Allied Workers
OPPOSITION
Consumer Federation of California
StubHub
Vivid Seats
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 478 (Dodd, 2023) makes it an unlawful business practice pursuant to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act to advertise, display, or offer a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than taxes imposed by a government. SB 478 is set to be heard in this Committee on the same day as this bill.
SB 644 (Glazer, 2023) requires a hotel, third-party booking service, hosting platform, or short-term rental to allow a reservation to be canceled without penalty if the cancellation is commenced within 24 hours of the reservation being finalized so long as the reservation is made 24 hours or more prior to the day of check-in. The bill prescribes certain procedures for issuing the attendant refunds. It authorizes public prosecutors to bring civil actions seeking civil penalties. SB 644 is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits the operator of an entertainment facility and a primary ticket seller from entering into a contract that provides for the primary ticket seller to be the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. SB 829 is currently in this Committee and is set to be heard the same day as this bill.
AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) requires a ticket seller to disclose to a purchaser the total price of the ticket and the portion of that price that represents any fees or surcharges. The seller must also provide a link to an internet webpage that includes certain refund requirements, as specified. AB 8 is currently pending in the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1556 (Friedman, Ch. 180, Stats. 2021) requires for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation; and requires a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request.
SB 342 (Hertzberg, Ch. 162, Stats. 2020) makes it unlawful to register, traffic in, or use the name of a professional sports team or the names of professional sports leagues, among others, in a domain or subdomain name of a website to sell tickets in a fraudulent, deceptive, or misleading manner. It provides a private right of action to a person who suffers an economic injury as a result of such misconduct.
AB 329 (Pan, Ch. 325, Stats. 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 1)
**************
Michael Kan, 3 Scalpers Fined for Using Bots to Scoop Up Tickets on Ticketmaster (Jan. 22, 2021) PCMag, https://www.pcmag.com/news/3-scalpers-fined-for-using-bots-to-scoop-up-tickets-on-ticketmaster. All internet citations are current as of April 19, 2023. ↑
Emily Lorsch, Why Live Nation and Ticketmaster dominate the live entertainment industry (Jan 25, 2023) CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/25/the-live-nation-and-ticketmaster-monopoly-of-live-entertainment.html. ↑
Ibid. ↑
David McCabe & Ben Sisario, Justice Dept. Is Said to Investigate Ticketmaster’s Parent Company (Jan 24, 2023) The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/18/technology/live-nation-ticketmaster-investigation-taylor-swift.html. ↑
Video of the hearing available at: https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/committee-activity/hearings/thats-the-ticket-promoting-competition-and-protecting-consumers-in-live-entertainment. ↑
News Releases, Klobuchar, Lee Announce Date of Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing on Problems in America’s Ticketing Markets (Jan. 17, 2023) Senator Amy Klobuchar website, https://www.klobuchar.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2023/1/klobuchar-lee-announce-date-of-senate-judiciary-committee-hearing-on-problems-in-america-s-ticketing-markets. ↑
Event Ticket Sales: Market Characteristics and Consumer Protection Issues (Apr. 2018) GAO, https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-18-347.pdf. ↑
Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights, https://www.ticketbuyerbillofrights.org/#:~:text=The%20Ticket%20Buyer%20Bill%20of%20Rights%20is%20a,year.%20The%20Bill%20of%20Rights%20features%20four%20pillars%3A. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: April 17, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Updates laws regulating ticket sellers by establishing new categories of ticket sellers, establishing various requirements for certain types of ticket sellers, and increasing penalties for violations of rules governing ticket seller operations. Prohibits a certain type of ticket seller from advertising or selling or accepting payment for a ticket sale prior to the ticket being available by the event presenter, unless authorized to sell by the event presenter. Increases penalties for violations of certain requirements and prohibits event presenter likeness from being used on any website.
NOTE: This bill is double-referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, second.
Existing law:
- Defines a ticket seller as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. Clarifies that the following are not a ticket seller subject to various requirements:
- An officially appointed agent of an air carrier, ocean carrier or motor coach carrier who purchases or sells tickets in conjunction with a tour package accomplished through the primary event promoter or his or her agent by written agreement.
- Any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the premises where the event is to take place, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.
- Any primary contractor (defines as the person or organization responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold) or seller of tickets for the primary contractor operating under a written contract with the primary contractor.
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 22503.6, 225034, 22511)
- Establishes various requirements for ticket sellers, a violation of which constitutes a misdemeanor, including that they:
- Have a permanent business address from which tickets may only be sold and that the address be included in any advertisement or solicitation, a violation of which constitutes a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $2,500 or by both. Provides that a person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in a violation of this specific requirement is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 for each violation.
- Maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
- Prior to sale, disclose to the purchaser by means of description or a map the location of the seat or seats represented by the ticket or tickets.
- Make any partial or full deposit received on a future event for which tickets are not available refundable, except for a service charge of not more than 10 percent until tickets for the event are actually available.
- Disclose that a service charge is imposed by the ticket seller and is added to the actual ticket price by the seller in any advertisement or promotion for any event by the ticket seller.
- Provide a refund within 30 days for the ticket price of an event which is canceled.
- Provide a refund, upon request, within 30 days, for the ticket price of an event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time
- Provide a bond of not more $50,000 to provide for any refunds in a local jurisdiction that requires this.
- Disclose in any advertisement or promotion for any event that a service charge is imposed and added to the actual ticket price. (Business and Professions Code §§ 22500 – 22511)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket; has a contractual right to obtain the ticket; or informs the purchaser the seller does not have possession of the tickets, has no contract to obtain the offered ticket, and may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price, as specified. Authorizes a ticket seller to accept a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time, provided that the ticket seller informs the purchaser orally at the time of the contract or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier, and in writing within two days, of the terms of the deposit agreement, and includes in the oral and written notice other required disclosures. (BPC § 22502.1)
- Prohibits a ticket seller from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and fail to deliver within a reasonable time at or below or within the price and range of prices stated. Specifies that a ticket seller who violated this prohibition and violates 3) above is civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended in trying to attend the event, and reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. (BPC §§ 22052.2 and 22052.3)
This bill:
- Strikes reference to ticket seller throughout the law and instead defines the following:
- Original seller as a person who, for compensation, commission, or otherwise, on behalf of an event presenter, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for original sale as instructed by an event presenter.
- Ticket reseller as a person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise, advertises, lists, markets for sale, or sells an admission ticket to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event other than a ticket for original sale sold by an original seller.
- Ticket marketplace as a person, except the event presenter or original seller, who advertises lists, markets for sale, processes payments for, facilitates the sale or exchange of, or sells an admission ticket for, or on behalf of, a ticket reseller to a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for compensation, commission, or otherwise.
- Event presenter as a person or organization that is responsible for a sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event for which tickets are sold, including the holder of the rights to the sporting, musical, theatre, or other entertainment event, or their authorized agent.
- Authorizes an event presenter to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of tickets to their events, or on the technologies that an event presenter uses in the sale of those tickets.
- Requires original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to comply with requirements under current law for ticket sellers to have a permanent business address and increases the penalty for a violation of this requirement from $2,500 to $25,000 for each violation, and $250,000 for each continuing violation. Specifies that each ticket sold or offered for sale by an original seller, ticket reseller, and ticket marketplace that does not have a permanent business address constitutes a separate violation, and makes remedies cumulative to each other and the remedies or penalties available under all other state laws.
- Replaces reference to ticket sellers with original sellers, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces who must comply with the requirement under current law for ticket sellers to maintain records of ticket sales, deposits, and refunds.
- Requires only a ticket reseller, at the time of listing or marketing, and before selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket and to disclose to the purchaser the location in the venue that the ticket will entitle the purchaser to occupy, including the section, row, and seat number represented by each ticket, and the face price printed or displayed on the ticket that they are listing for resale at the time of listing or marketing of and before selling a ticket via a description or a map. Further requires only a ticket marketplace, in each listing on its website, to disclose this information, excluding the face price a ticket reseller must disclose, to the purchaser.
- Replaces the prohibition on a ticket seller contracting to sell or accepting payment for tickets unless the ticket seller has lawful possession of the ticket with a prohibition only on a ticket reseller from advertising, offering for sale or contracting for the sale unless the ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession and the ticket reseller has contractual authority from the event presenter to obtain it. Prohibits a ticket reseller from advertising, offering for sale, or contracting for the sale of a ticket, or accepting consideration for payment in full or for a deposit for the sale of a ticket, unless the ticket has been made available for sale on the internet to the public by the event presenter, including, without limitation, through a presale, fan club presale, or any other promotional presale event, or the event presenter or its authorized agent has otherwise provided permission to the ticket reseller to do so.
- Requires a ticket marketplace to require that the person listing the ticket own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket, and be able to deliver the ticket to the buyer before accepting a listing to market or sell a ticket.
- Replaces a ticket seller with only a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace in the prohibition under current law from representing that they can deliver or cause to be delivered a ticket at a specific price or within a specific price range and to fail to deliver that ticket within a reasonable time, or by a contracted time, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated. Subjects only a ticket reseller or ticket marketplace to the remedies under current law for a violation.
- Authorizes an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury from a violation of these laws to bring a civil action against that person and authorizes the original seller or event presenter to recover damages for the injury, plus any damages a court may determine to be appropriate and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Prohibits a person from using a website to display a trademarked or copyrighted URL, title, designation, image, mark, or other symbol without the written consent of the trademark or copyright holder and prohibits the use of a combination of text, images, web designs, or internet addresses that is substantially similar to the internet website of an event presenter or original seller, or any of their authorized agents, without the written consent of the event presenter or original seller.
- Updates prohibitions on using or selling software to circumvent measures designed to ensure an equitable ticket buying process by prohibiting the purchase of tickets in excess of posted limits for an online event ticket sale, prohibiting the circumventing or disabling of an electronic queue, waiting period, presale code or other sales volume limitation systems, prohibits circumventing or disabling a system used to facilitate entry into an event, prohibits purchasing tickets in violation of the event presenter’s posted terms and conditions, and prohibits the use of multiple ISP addresses, purchaser accounts, or multiple email address to purchase tickets in excess of posted ticket limits.
- Updates provisions of the law related to refunds in the event of a cancellation by specifying that refunds must be issued by the person who sold or facilitated the sale of the ticket to the purchaser whether they are an original seller, event presenter, ticket reseller, or ticket marketplace. Requires the person who processed the sale of the ticket to provide a refund in the event of a postponement, reschedule, or replacement event.
- Requires original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces to disclose the total cost of a ticket, including a listing of all ancillary fees that are required to be paid in order to purchase the ticket, before the ticket is selected for purchase and to disclose, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the amount of any service or other ancillary charge that is imposed and added to the actual ticket price, or any other fee, tax, or surcharge to the purchaser. Prohibits original sellers, event presenters, ticket resellers, and ticket marketplaces from making a false or misleading disclosure of subtotals, fees, charges, or any other component of the total price of a ticket, or present those fees, charges, taxes, or other components more prominently, or in the same or larger size, than the total price of the ticket.
- Requires ticket resellers and ticket marketplaces to disclose in the description of the price of a ticket that the ticket is a resale ticket that may be offered at a price that is more than the price of a ticket offered or sold by the event presenter and requires any listing for a resale ticket to include the face price of the original ticket and a link to the event presenter’s website where the purchaser can determine the availability of a face value ticket and purchase that ticket.
- Exempts any event for which tickets are distributed free of charge from being subject to any of the above requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “This bill will enact meaningful reforms that put consumers and entertainers first by: (1) Imposing true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at checkout. (2) Ending the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing by imposing easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizing ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets. (3) Establishing serious penalties for the use of deceptive URLs to lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices. (4) Establishing serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping, depriving consumers of access to face value tickets.”
- Background.
Ticket Sellers and Mergers In The Last Decade. In 2010, the Justice Department approved a merger between Ticketmaster and Live Nation, two of the biggest companies in ticket sales in the world. At the time, Ticketmaster sold 141 tickets worth $8.9 billion in 2008. At the same time, Live Nation owned 120 theaters, and the combined company stood to achieve an estimated $6 billion/year.
According to The New York Times, the conditions of the merger included Tickemaster divesting one of its ticket divisions and licensing its software to a competitor and being subject for 10 years to “‘tough antireltaliation provisions’ to prevent abuse of its power over concert tours, artist management, ticketing and theaters.” While originally the Justice Department determined that the merger was anticompetitive, these terms alleviated its concerns.
Many consumer advocates, politicians, and independent concern promoters were not in favor of the merger. In July 2010, 50 members of the House of Representatives sent a letter urging the Justice Department to oppose the deal.
According to The New York Times, “Ticketmaster and Live Nation have argued that by combining they would be able to reduce inefficiencies in the marketing and presentation of live events, which would help to revive the ailing music industry and ultimately benefit consumers.” Years later, Senator Amy Klobuchar called for the DOJ to investigate Live Nation in 2019, according to Rolling Stone.
A Recent Catalyst: Taylor Swift. On October 21, 2022, singer and songwriter Taylor Swift released an entire new album, “Midnights.” The album was an overnight success, and Taylor Swift, at 32, became the first artist ever to simultaneously capture all Top 10 spots with songs from the “Midnights” album. Days after releasing the album, Swift announced her Eras Tour, the first of her musical tours since 2018 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Tickets were set to go on sale on November 18, 2022. Pre-sale for tickets for select fans with certain corporate partnerships began as early as November 1, 2022. Ticketmaster and at least one tour date in Nashville noted that ticket prices could fluctuate based on demand at any given time. On November 15, during presale, Ticketmaster’s website crashed following millions showing up to buy Swift’s concert tickets. After Ticketmaster determined there were at least questions as to whether there were enough tickets to meet buyer demand, Ticketmaster also cancelled its general ticket sale that was supposed to open on November 18, 2022. This meant that fans who otherwise would have paid hundreds of dollars to see Swift in concert were left to purchase them off of resale websites, where they were going for thousands of dollars (some even around $20,000). According to Forbes, Ticketmaster’s failure was caused in large part due to bot attacks, but also due to the failure of leadership to engage in meaningful practices and philosophies among employees to help them respond in a crisis.
US Judiciary Committee Hearing. Following public outcry, the New York Times reported that the Justice Department opened an antitrust investigation into Ticketmaster, who merged with Live Nation Entertainment back in 2010. For her own part, Swift criticized the situation on social media, sharing with fans that she and her team asked multiple times if Ticketmaster could handle the demand of her fan base, and the company assured her it could.
On Tuesday, January 24, 2023, the US Senate Judiciary Committee had a hearing on the issue, focusing specifically on the Live Nation and Ticketmaster’s 2010 merger. Leading up to the hearing, Senator Klobuchar told Rolling Stone that she believed Live Nation Entertainment was a monopoly because, as a company, it has 70% of tickets for major concern venues; venue operators said that they were concerned about not getting Live Nation’s shows at their venues if they don’t use Ticketmaster; the company utilized exclusivity deals that can last 3-7 years; hidden fees, some costing up to 75% of a ticket’s face value; and Live Nation is owning more and more venues, which was not the case in 2010 when the merger occurred.
In the January 2023 hearing, Senators questioned Live Nation and raised potential solutions to the problems above, including non-exclusivity of contracts between venues and ticketing agents, placing price caps on tickets, and working more closely with the FTC to stop speculative ticket sales. National media has been following the story since October and November of 2022.
Efforts to Respond to Consumer Protection Issues. Among other steps taken to drive more consumer-centric responses to the experiences highlighted above, consumer advocacy groups launched a campaign culminating in The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights. According to its website, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights “is a set of principles the nation’s leading consumer advocacy groups and others believe should serve as a framework for ticketing legislation that can improve the live events ticketing market that serves millions of fans each year. The Bill of Rights features four pillars:
- The Right to Transferability, where ticketholders decide how to use, sell or give away their tickets if they wish and not the entity that previously sold the tickets;
- The Right to Transparency, which includes all-in pricing and disclosures of relevant information for the purchasing decision;
- The Right to Set the Price, so that companies who originally sold the tickets cannot dictate to fans for what price they can or cannot resell their purchased tickets, and, lastly;
- The Right to a Fair Marketplace, where fans compete with actual humans, not illegal software bots, for tickets.”
Specifically, The Ticket Buyer Bill of Rights includes:
- “All-in, upfront pricing – no surprise fees at checkout;
- Mandating primary ticket-selling companies to report all ticket bot activity to the appropriate authorities;
- Disclosure of how many tickets are available to the general public at the time of “on sale”;
- Clear and conspicuous disclosure when a ticket seller does not have a ticket in their possession or contractual right;
- The guarantee of unrestricted transfer of all tickets; and
- A prohibition on deceptive URLs and other fraudulent reseller practices.”
This framework is meant to provide guidance for legislative action to ensure consumer protection in ticketing sales.
At the state level, legislatures have been taking action to ensure consumer protection with respect to ticket sellers, particularly Live Nation entertainment.
In June 2022, the New York Legislature passed a bill to increase transparency in the ticket-buying process for live events like concerns and plays, whereby ticket sellers and resellers must disclose all fees upfront so that prices do not change during a transaction (for instance, in last step in checkout). Additionally, the New York Legislature introduced a bill in 2021 that would have instituted civil penalties for using ticket-purchasing software; required an online resale market to post the ticket price in advertisements or offers of resale; and required ticket prices to be disclosed prior to a customer purchasing a ticket, among other things.
In Colorado, a bill has been introduced this year that would prohibit “speculative ticketing,” or the process by which brokers sell tickets they do not possess. The bill would also require online companies to clearly display total, inclusive prices of all service charges and other fees included in the purchase of the ticket. According to The Denver Post, the bill also “expands the definition of deceptive trade practices to include the use of automation to buy tickets or circumvent limits, selling tickets without being upfront about all the fees, and increasing ticket prices once they have been selected.”
Moreover, Ireland’s Competition Consumer Protection Commission came to an agreement with Ticketmaster Ireland (TMI) that TMI should refrain from entering into an exclusivity clause with a venue, among other things.
Ticketing Bills In The California Legislature. Various aspects of the problems consumers have encountered in their attempts to purchase tickets have been the source of a number of legislative efforts. AB 329 (Pan, Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s internet website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. In 2021, AB 1556 (Friedman, Chapter 180, Statutes of 2021) responded to concerns stemming from customer experiences with cancelled or postponed events by requiring that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation if an event is cancelled and a refund within 30 days upon the ticket purchaser’s request for postponed, rescheduled, or replaced events.
Two other bills currently pending this year seek to address various aspects of the problems consumers have encountered in their attempts to purchase tickets. SB 829 (Wilk, 2023) prohibits an exclusivity clause in a contract between a ticket seller and primary entertainment facility operator, where the primary ticket seller is the exclusive ticket seller for the operator of the entertainment facility. AB 8 (Friedman, 2023) currently expands the definition of a ticket seller to include a primary contractor or platform, as defined, and would instead apply the refund requirement relating to the postponement or rescheduling of an event only to primary contractors. It also imposes disclosure requirements on ticket sellers relating to ticket price, including that the ticket seller would be required to display the total cost and fees for a ticket prior to the ticket being selected for purchase. It requires a primary contractor to make various disclosures regarding the total number of tickets available and the price or price range at which those tickets will be sold at least 7 days before tickets are made available, except as specified. It prohibits the resale of tickets that were initially offered at no charge and would require a ticket seller to provide printed tickets for a cellular phone-free event, as defined, at the same price that a mobile or electronic ticket is sold. Finally, it imposes various requirements on a primary contractor relating to the resale of tickets, including prohibiting a primary contractor from restricting the resale of tickets.
- Arguments in Support. The Music Artists Coalition, The International Association of Venue Managers (IAVM), The Recording Academy, and SAG-AFTRA writes in support: “SB 785 will protect consumers, artists and venues by regulating the organized ticket scalping that currently plagues the ticketing entertainment industry.” The groups state that this bill will “impose true ticket price transparency and full fee disclosures on all ticket sellers across all platforms. In other words, the first price a consumer sees will be the final price they pay – no surprises at check-out.” They write that it will “end the outrageous practice of speculative ticketing. It imposes easily enforceable rules to reduce consumer price gouging and penalizes ticket sellers and platforms who list speculative tickets.” According to supporters, this bill will “establish serious penalties for the use of deceptive websites that lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices and take money out of the pockets of hard-working musicians” and “establish serious penalties for employing bots that allow professional scalpers to hoard tickets and engage in large-scale scalping. These practices deprive consumers of access to face value tickets and keep the biggest fans from seeing their favorite artists.” The organizations state that “In addition to protecting consumers, this bill will not impinge upon the current rights of artists to choose how their tickets may be priced, sold, transferred or resold, or what technologies they deploy in the sale of their tickets, including the tools they use to control costs for fans.”
Nederlander Concerts writes in support: “SB 785 will protect consumers and event presenters by establishing meaningful penalties to disincentivize the fraudulent practices of employing bots to deprive consumers of face value tickets and using deceptive URLs to lure consumers into buying tickets at inflated prices.”
- Arguments in Opposition. Consumer Federation of California writes that “SB 785, as currently drafted, does not properly define ticket seller and therefore fails to get at the heart of the issue, which is the control exercised over consumers by those marketplace participants such as the monopolistic Ticketmaster/Live Nation that control the industry. This bill also fails to provide consumers with ownership over their own purchased tickets, forcing consumers limited to no options should they need to resell their tickets. There is a better path to protect consumers on ticketing matters, as represented by AB 8 (Freidman & Irwin).”
StubHub and Vivid Seats note that “Californians are eager to support their favorite teams, artists and performers, yet they have very little control over the tickets they have rightfully purchased or the way that tickets are sold. Unfortunately, SB 785 is not designed to empower consumers, but to enshrine the control that event presenters an original ticket sellers enjoy today. SB 785 will harm consumers by further limiting competition and do little to solve the frustrations consumers face during the ticket buying process.” According to the companies, “Technology (i.e., digital tickets with the ability to continuously rotate barcodes) has amplified primary ticket providers’ ability to engage in these anti-consumer and anticompetitive practices, including by dictating to consumers if and how they may transfer or resell their tickets to subsequent consumers. Consumers have limited control over the tickets they purchase and can be subject to retaliation by venues, teams, artists, or primary ticket sellers for transferring or reselling the tickets their tickets. Senate Bill 785 seeks to endorse this status quo where it should be disrupting it to protect consumers.” They are also concerned that the bill “takes the unprecedented approach of requiring ticket resale marketplaces to explicitly advertise for their competitors…This imbalanced provision fails to consider that many consumers actively choose to shop on ticket resale marketplaces over original ticket sellers, or that in many instances, ticket resale marketplaces offer lower prices than those offered by the event presenter and original ticket sellers themselves. Unfortunately, the intention of this provision is to discriminate against ticket resale marketplaces and legislative a competitive advantage. A similar provision was recently introduced in Colorado and failed.” According to StubHub and Vivid Seats, “Regulatory models built around “face value” are challenging given how little meaning can be applied to the concept of “face value” in today’s ticket marketplace. While “face value” used to be a static price, original ticket sellers are now regularly using dynamic or market-based pricing for primary ticket sales. This means that the “face value” or purchase price of tickets fluctuates relative to demand. Like airline tickets, this may result in two tickets next to each other being sold at varying prices by the original seller. Requiring “face value” disclosures by ticket resellers and ticket resale marketplaces gives undue significance to a value that is perpetually in flux.”
- Policy Questions and Considerations.
Ticket Seller vs. Original Seller, Ticket Reseller, Ticket Marketplaces, and Event Presenters. Current statute only references a ticket seller, and does not distinguish between ticket seller, an original seller, a ticker reseller, a ticker marketplace, or an event presenter. As written, existing law’s simplicity provides clarity – any person, including a corporate person, that sells a ticket is subject to the law. While there may be some benefit in updating the law to more appropriately reflect market players by distinguishing between these entities, this bill’s multiple definitions may cause confusion and notably are not applied equally throughout the proposed regulations. For example, this bill requires only a ticket reseller to disclose to the purchaser a description of a map, the location within the venue where the buyer would sit, including section, row, and seat number, and the face price printed on the ticket they are listing for resale, and only requires a ticket marketplace to disclose seat location. Original sellers are not required to comply with this and many other requirements contained in the bill, nor are they subject to a number of prohibitions but are expressly authorized to bring civil action against any person who violates requirements outlined for ticket selling. Why should California replace existing law with this new one, particularly if this new option relies on the current industry standard that could change in the future? Does it make sense from a consumer protection perspective to remove protections from some market players, but not others? The Author should continue working to ensure that the bill is updated to not differentiate between original sellers, ticker resellers, ticket marketplaces, and event presenters for important consumer protection provisions.
Penalties are High, Parties Not Differentiated, and Attorney’s Fees Can Only Be Collected by the Original Seller. The bill seeks to assess significant penalties for violating every provision of ticket selling laws, notably increasing current penalties from a maximum of $2,500 to $25,000 for each violation and $250,000 for each continuing violation. If the Author intends to pursue these penalties, the bill needs to be updated to correct drafting errors in the placement of this particular provision.
The measure also proposes a new, additional penalty of civil liability for only a ticket reseller and ticket marketplace that fails to comply with pricing disclosures and delivering a ticket within a specific price and time range. Under current law, ticket sellers already have to disclose a ticket’s location, and consumers have existing civil legal remedies for engaging with sellers who do not honor their agreements and contracts, as well as for thwarting a another business’s current electronic business systems.
The bill also authorizes an original seller or event presenter who suffers injury to bring a civil action against a person and collect damages and attorney’s fees, without specification that the prevailing party in that matter have the ability to recover costs. Here, the differentiation of just permitting an original seller or event presenter is curious, as companies such as Ticketmaster would oftentimes be an original seller due the fact that it owns 70% of the ticket sales marketplace and Live Nation Entertainment would oftentimes be an event presenter. More notably, this provision of the bill does nothing to protect consumers themselves. This bill will be heard in the Senate Committee on Judiciary should it be approved by this committee and the Author should continue working to develop appropriate recourse and remedies as the measure progresses.
Ticket Resellers and Secondary Market Issues. Speculative sales is an issue that certain provisions of this measure intend to address but consumer protection options beyond provisions in the bill now could assist in curbing problematic and potentially predatory actions negatively impacting consumers. Some provisions of this bill only apply to ticket resellers, rather than original sellers, event presenters, or others, where California law currently captures all players who sell tickets in the marketplace. Section 3 of the bill requires a ticket reseller, before listing, marketing, or selling a ticket, to own, possess, or have the contractual right to sell the ticket. (Because Live Nation Entertainment owns 70% of the ticket marketplace, it is notable that having a contractual right to sell the ticket means having a contractual right with Live Nation Entertainment or Ticketmaster, where Ticketmaster can operate as a resale platform.) Section 3 also requires resellers to disclose the purchase price, description of a map and location of seats, when the consumer purchases the ticket – which is required currently under California law for all ticket sellers, not just ticket resellers.
Section 4 of the bill makes it unlawful for ticket resellers to advertise, offer for sale, or contract for the sale of a ticket, or accept payment for a ticket, unless the ticket reseller has the ticket in their possession or has a contract to obtain the offered ticket at a certain price from a person in possession of the ticket or from a person. A marketplace has emerged that attempts to assist consumers in accessing tickets prior to these tickets being publicly available, with companies serving as what looks like an agent by offering options in advance for that entity to procure the tickets. Current law requires various disclosures about who may or may not be in possession of an actual ticket for prospective purchases. This measure prohibits that practice but does not address a significant issue of an original seller potentially offering their own financing to the consumer that has led consumers to be able to purchase tickets they may not otherwise be able to afford without establishing safeguards to ensure fairness in pricing and recourse for those purchasers. While it is important for companies to be held accountable to important consumer disclosures so purchasers are fully informed of the risks and obligations in various models, an outright prohibition that doesn’t take additional steps to protect consumers at the outset of the ticket buying process could be perceived as larger players attempting to assert more control of the marketplace. The bill notably offers a reseller to advertise, offer to sale, or sell a ticket prior to it being available for sale on the internet but only if they have the contractual right to obtain a ticket from the event presenter. The Author should continue working to ensure that the bill is updated to prohibit practices that may harm purchasers, like original seller-owned financing, and should establish parity in these prohibitions that are truly customer oriented.
Event Presenters and Conditions on Resale. Currently, this bill permits event presenters be able to impose terms and conditions on the sale, pricing, transfer, or resale of ticket to their events and the technologies used in the sale of these tickets. Why should this be the case? What other implications does this have and will this yield positive consumer benefits?
AB 1556 Direction Shift. AB 1556 (Friedman, Chapter 180, Statutes of 2021) required, for cancelled events, that a refund be made within 30 calendar days of the cancellation and that a ticket price at any event which is postponed, rescheduled, or replaced with another event at the same date and time be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request within 30 calendar days of the refund request. This bill now says that the person who sold the ticket has to refund the purchaser in this case. Is this feasible considering that some of the seller types might never be in control of the cancellation of tickets or events? How would this be applied practically in the case of a marketplace within which consumers themselves sell tickets for events they have no control over the cancellation of?
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
International Association of Venue Managers
Music Artists Coalition
Nederlander Concerts
Recording Academy
Sag-aftra
Opposition:
Consumer Federation of California
StubHub
Vivid Seats
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, and Tourism
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):