AB 1232: Insurance Commissioner: administrative hearings.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-09-03
Existing law grants the Insurance Commissioner certain powers and duties. Existing law prohibits the commissioner from denying an insurance agent or broker license to an applicant without an opportunity to be heard. The hearing is required to be conducted in accordance with specified provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
This bill would, if the applicant or permanent licensee is a natural person and requests a hearing, authorize the person, at his or her option, to have the hearing held by either the Office of Administrative Hearings, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. If the natural person does not indicate a preference of forum when requesting that hearing, the bill would authorize the commissioner to refer the matter for hearing to either the Office of Administrative Hearings, or to an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
Existing law also requires the commissioner to make an annual report to the Governor, the Legislature, and the committees of the Senate and Assembly having jurisdiction over insurance showing, generally, the condition of the insurance business and interests in this state, and other matters concerning insurance, as specified.
This bill would require the commissioner, for 3 calendar years, to include in the report described above specified information regarding those cases in which a hearing was held, including the total number of cases in which a hearing was held and the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge.
Existing law grants the Insurance Commissioner certain powers and duties. Existing law prohibits the commissioner from denying an insurance agent or broker license to an applicant without an opportunity to be heard. The hearing is required to be conducted in accordance with specified provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
This bill would require, if the applicant or permanent licensee is a natural person and requests a hearing, the commissioner to select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to the act, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. authorize the person, at his or her option, to have the hearing held by either the Office of Administrative Hearings, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. If the natural person does not indicate a preference of forum when requesting that hearing, the bill would authorize the commissioner to refer the matter for hearing to either the Office of Administrative Hearings, or to an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
Existing law also requires the commissioner to make an annual report to the Governor, the Legislature, and the committees of the Senate and Assembly having jurisdiction over insurance showing, generally, the condition of the insurance business and interests in this state, and other matters concerning insurance, as specified.
This bill would require the commissioner, for 3 calendar years, to include in the report described above specified information regarding those cases in which a hearing was held, including the total number of cases in which a hearing was held and the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge.
Existing law grants the Insurance Commissioner certain powers and duties. Existing law prohibits the commissioner from denying an insurance agent or broker license to an applicant without an opportunity to be heard. The hearing is required to be conducted in accordance with specified provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
This bill would require, if the applicant or permanent licensee is a natural person and requests a hearing, the commissioner to select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to the act, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
Existing law also requires the commissioner to make an annual report to the Governor, the Legislature, and the committees of the Senate and Assembly having jurisdiction over insurance showing, generally, the condition of the insurance business and interests in this state, and other matters concerning insurance, as specified.
This bill would require the commissioner, for 3 calendar years, to include in the report described above specified information regarding those cases in which a hearing was held, including the total number of cases in which a hearing was held and the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge.
Existing law grants the Insurance Commissioner certain powers and duties. Existing law prohibits the commissioner from denying an insurance agent or broker license to an applicant without an opportunity to be heard. The hearing is required to be conducted in accordance with specified provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
This bill would require, if the applicant or permanent licensee is a natural person and the hearing is contested, that the hearing be conducted by an administrative law judge chosen in accordance with specified provisions of the act or appointed by the commissioner. requests a hearing, the commissioner to select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to the act, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
Existing law also requires the commissioner to make an annual report to the Governor, the Legislature, and the committees of the Senate and Assembly having jurisdiction over insurance showing, generally, the condition of the insurance business and interests in this state, and other matters concerning insurance, as specified.
This bill would require the commissioner, for 3 calendar years, to include in the report described above specified information regarding those cases in which a hearing was held, including the total number of cases in which a hearing was held and the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge.
Existing law grants the Insurance Commissioner certain powers and duties. Existing law prohibits the commissioner from denying an insurance agent or broker license to an applicant without an opportunity to be heard. The hearing is required to be conducted in accordance with specified provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
This bill would require, if the applicant or permanent licensee is a natural person and the hearing is contested, that the hearing be conducted by an administrative law judge chosen in accordance with specified provisions of the act or appointed by the commissioner.
(a)Except as provided in Section 1669, a license shall not be denied without an opportunity for the applicant to be heard in support of his or her application. When a hearing is held, the proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) of Section 11502 of the Government Code, when a natural person requests a hearing pursuant to Section 11506 of the Government Code, he or she may, at his or her option, have the hearing held by either the Office of Administrative Hearings pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. If the natural person does not indicate a preference of forum when requesting that hearing, the commissioner may refer the matter for hearing to either the Office of Administrative Hearings pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or to an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
(c)The commissioner shall include, in the report required pursuant to Section 12922, in each calendar year from 2017 to 2019, inclusive, the total number of cases in which a hearing was held, the number of those cases heard by an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner, the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge, and the outcome of the cases.
(a)Except as provided in Section 1669, a license shall not be denied without an opportunity for the applicant to be heard in support of his or her application. When a hearing is held, the proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) of Section 11502 of the Government Code, when a hearing is requested pursuant to subdivision (a) by a natural person who is subject to this section, the commissioner may select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. natural person requests a hearing pursuant to Section 11506 of the Government Code, he or she may, at his or her option, have the hearing held by either the Office of Administrative Hearings pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing. If the natural person does not indicate a preference of forum when requesting that hearing, the commissioner may refer the matter for hearing to either the Office of Administrative Hearings pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or to an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
(c)The commissioner shall include, in the report required pursuant to Section 12922, in each calendar year from 2017 to 2019, inclusive, the total number of cases in which a hearing was held, the number of those cases heard by an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner, the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge, and the outcome of the cases.
(a)Except as provided in Section 1669, a license shall not be denied without an opportunity for the applicant to be heard in support of his or her application. When a hearing is held, the proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) of Section 11502 of the Government Code, when a hearing is requested pursuant to subdivision (a) by a natural person who is subject to this chapter, section, the commissioner may select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
(c)The commissioner shall include, in the report required pursuant to Section 12922, in each calendar year from 2017 to 2019, inclusive, the total number of cases in which a hearing was held, the number of those cases heard by an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner, the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge, and the outcome of the cases.
(a)Except as provided in Section 1669, a license shall not be denied without an opportunity for the applicant to be heard in support of his or her application. When a hearing is held, the proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, except a hearing with respect to a natural person subject to this chapter shall be conducted by an administrative law judge for purposes of Sections 11512 and 11517 of the Government Code, chosen under Section 11502 of the Government Code or appointed by the commissioner. Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) of Section 11502 of the Government Code, when a hearing is requested pursuant to subdivision (a) by a natural person who is subject to this chapter, the commissioner may select either an administrative law judge appointed pursuant to Section 11502 of the Government Code, or an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner to conduct the hearing.
(c)The commissioner shall include, in the report required pursuant to Section 12922, in each calendar year from 2017 to 2019, inclusive, the total number of cases in which a hearing was held, the number of those cases heard by an administrative law judge appointed by the commissioner, the average number of days that elapsed between the referral of a case to an administrative law judge and a proposed decision by that administrative law judge, and the outcome of the cases.
Except as provided in Section 1669, a license shall not be denied without an opportunity to for the applicant to be heard in support of his or her application. When a hearing is held, the proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code Code, except a hearing with respect to a natural person subject to this chapter shall be conducted by an administrative law judge for purposes of Sections 11512 and 11517 of the Government Code, chosen under Section 11502 of the Government Code or appointed by the commissioner.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 29, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Jan 15, 2016 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Sep 30, 2015 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 80. Noes 0.). |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 2744.). |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Page 2729.) |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2294.). |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 2 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 18, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2015 | From committee: Be placed on second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 8, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
| May 21, 2015 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| May 7, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 77. Noes 0. Page 1350.) |
| May 7, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 7, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 4, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (April 29). |
| Apr 22, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 14, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Apr 13, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2015 | AB 1232 GARCIA, C. Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2015 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1232 Cristina Garcia By Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
|
| May 7, 2015 | AB 1232 GARCIA, C. Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2015 | Do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Department of General Services | ** Against | Aug 31, 2015 |
| California Department of Insurance | ** Support | Aug 31, 2015 |
| Department of Insurance | ** Support | Aug 31, 2015 |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
AB 1232
(Cristina Garcia)
As Enrolled September 3, 2015
2/3 vote
ASSEMBLY: |
77-0 |
(May 7, 2015) |
SENATE: |
40-0 |
(August 31, 2015) |
ASSEMBLY: |
80-0 |
(September 1, 2015) |
|
|
|
Original Committee Reference: INS.
SUMMARY: Permits administrative law judges (ALJs) at the Department of Insurance (department) to hear the appeal of individuals who are denied a license by the department.
The Senate amendments make minor technical amendments.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires insurance agents/brokers and other "producers" to be licensed by the department.
Establishes the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) to perform the administrative adjudication function for other state agencies.
Establishes the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) to define the process by which administrative complaints are resolved.
Permits the department to hire ALJs to hear rate setting cases under Proposition 103 (1988).
Permits the department to deny a license to an applicant for a range of reasons including:
Absence of qualifications
Lying on an application
Conviction of a felony
Conviction of a misdemeanor related to insurance
Unlicensed activity
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, existing law does not provide the commissioner the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases. As a result, an overwhelming majority of the hearings are heard by OAH. OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which makes it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely and expeditious manner. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. The department sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the commissioner does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) within the department. However 60% (or roughly 100) of those cases are new licensee applicant cases that could be heard by the AHB. It is not uncommon for more than a year to pass before an ALJ in OAH is able to hear a case. This bill will provide governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and consumers protected.
Administrative Hearing Bureau. The department employs four ALJs in its AHB. These ALJs are hired to hear insurance rate cases under Proposition 103 which requires property/casualty insurers to submit their proposed rating plans to the commissioner for approval. Because the flow of proposed rating plans is irregular, these ALJs have time available for other duties. Presently, the department assigns other legal work to the ALJs when they have available time, but the department would prefer to use available ALJ time to speed up the process for license applicant cases. Applicant cases would continue to be referred to OAH when AHB does not have the time available to handle the cases.
License Denial Process. Insurance agents must obtain a license in order to practice and this license must be renewed every two years by the department. Every new applicant must complete a background check prior to receiving a license as a part of the application and examination process. If the background check is cleared and the applicant has successfully passed the examination a license is granted. However, in certain cases, based on an applicant’s background check, the department may deny or grant a license with restrictions. When this occurs applicants may request to have their case heard by an ALJ, who in turn gives a proposed decision on the case at the hearing. The commissioner then upholds, denies, or modifies this decision.
This bill provides a person who has been denied a license as an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor an additional option to request a hearing from the Department of Insurance Administrative Hearing Bureau.
This bill would create a redundancy in government and removes an impartial body from the appeal process when no demonstrable problem has been proven to exist. The current process, which allows an applicant to request a specific hearing date from the Office of Administrative hearing, appears to be sufficient.
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0002514
AB 1232
Page 2
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
AB 1232
(Cristina Garcia)
As Amended June 29, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: |
77-0 |
(May 7, 2015) |
SENATE: |
40-0 |
(August 31, 2015) |
Original Committee Reference: INS.
SUMMARY: Permits administrative law judges (ALJs) at the Department of Insurance (department) to hear the appeal of individuals who are denied a license by the department.
The Senate amendments make minor technical amendments.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires insurance agents/brokers and other "producers" to be licensed by the department.
Establishes the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) to perform the administrative adjudication function for other state agencies.
Establishes the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) to define the process by which administrative complaints are resolved.
Permits the department to hire ALJs to hear rate setting cases under Proposition 103 (1988).
Permits the department to deny a license to an applicant for a range of reasons including:
Absence of qualifications
Lying on an application
Conviction of a felony
Conviction of a misdemeanor related to insurance
Unlicensed activity
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, existing law does not provide the commissioner the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases. As a result, an overwhelming majority of the hearings are heard by OAH. OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which makes it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely and expeditious manner. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. The department sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the commissioner does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) within the department. However 60% (or roughly 100%) of those cases are new licensee applicant cases that could be heard by the AHB. It is not uncommon for more than a year to pass before an ALJ in OAH is able to hear a case. This bill will provide governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and consumers protected.
Administrative Hearing Bureau. The department employs four ALJs in its AHB. These ALJs are hired to hear insurance rate cases under Proposition 103 which requires property/casualty insurers to submit their proposed rating plans to the commissioner for approval. Because the flow of proposed rating plans is irregular, these ALJs have time available for other duties. Presently, the department assigns other legal work to the ALJs when they have available time, but the department would prefer to use available ALJ time to speed up the process for license applicant cases. Applicant cases would continue to be referred to OAH when AHB does not have the time available to handle the cases.
License Denial Process. Insurance agents must obtain a license in order to practice and this license must be renewed every two years by the department. Every new applicant must complete a background check prior to receiving a license as a part of the application and examination process. If the background check is cleared and the applicant has successfully passed the examination a license is granted. However, in certain cases, based on an applicant's background check, the department may deny or grant a license with restrictions. When this occurs applicants may request to have their case heard by an ALJ, who in turn gives a proposed decision on the case at the hearing. The commissioner then upholds, denies, or modifies this decision.
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0001357
AB 1232
Page 6
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1232
Amended: 6/29/15 in Senate
SENATE INSURANCE COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/8/15
AYES: Roth, Gaines, Berryhill, Glazer, Hall, Hernandez, Liu, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Mitchell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/7/15 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Insurance Commissioner: administrative hearings
SOURCE: California Department of Insurance
DIGEST: This bill provides an applicant whose license to act as an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor has been denied by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) the option to request a hearing in front of an administrative law judge (ALJ) from CDI’s Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) or the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), or permits the Insurance Commissioner (IC) to assign the case if the applicant fails to select a preference.
Existing law:
Requires a person acting in the capacity of an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor to hold a license issued by CDI.
Permits the IC to deny a license to an applicant for a range of reasons including a lack of qualification, conviction of any felony or a misdemeanor related to insurance, or for prior unlicensed activity.
Prohibits the IC from denying a license without providing the applicant a hearing held pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).
Requires that most hearings of state agencies conducted pursuant to the APA be presided over by OAH ALJs.
This bill:
Permits the applicant to choose, at the time a hearing is requested, whether to have an ALJ from CDI or from the OAH hear the appeal.
Permits the IC to refer the matter for hearing to either the OAH or to a CDI ALJ if the applicant does not indicate a preference.
Requires the IC to annually report for three years on the total number of hearings and the number of those cases heard by CDI ALJs, average number of days between case referral and when the ALJ issues a proposed decision, and outcome of the cases.
Background
The IC issues licenses and takes disciplinary actions, such as suspension or revocation, against a person who already holds a license (“licensees”). This bill would only impact a person that the IC has initially denied a license as an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor (“applicant”) and who has requested a hearing to challenge the reason for the denial.
Every applicant must complete a background check prior to receiving a license as a part of the application and examination process. If the background check is cleared and the applicant has successfully passed the examination, a license is granted. However, for a variety of reasons, the IC may deny the license or grant a license with restrictions. The IC may deny the license without a hearing on certain grounds (such as conviction for any felony), but usually must give the applicant an opportunity to make a case for licensure.
The hearing is the applicant’s opportunity to prove that alleged facts or reasons for the denial are untrue, invalid, or should be considered along with mitigating factors. Unlike criminal and licensee discipline cases, the burden is on the applicant to show that he or she is fit for the license. The agency retains the burden of proving wrongdoing for which the applicant has not already been convicted, but only by a preponderance of the evidence or “more likely than not” standard. An adverse decision may brand the applicant as dishonest or untrustworthy and the applicant will have to disclose the decision anytime he or she applies for another professional license or some types of employment. Documents related to the case are usually public records and pleadings and final decisions are posted on the CDI website.
The Hearing Process. When the applicant requests a hearing, CDI must serve a “statement of issues” explaining the basis of the denial. Once CDI mails the statement of issues, the applicant has 15 days to file a “notice of defense” that requests a hearing and notes any special objections. Once a hearing is requested, CDI will file the case with OAH to start the formal process and request OAH to set a hearing give the availability of the parties.
This bill would allow the applicant to request a hearing with either the OAH or AHB when filing the notice of defense. If the applicant fails to select a preference, the IC could select the forum.
The agency and applicant will attempt to work out a settlement before the hearing that may include probationary terms. Often the applicant may want the license as soon as possible, but not always. An applicant may need time to establish a history of employment, advance professional training, sobriety (if the cause for denial involved drug or alcohol-related conduct) or other factor that favors licensure. At the hearing, the applicant may present witnesses, such as therapists, employers, friends, and others, who will testify on his or her behalf. CDI, on the other hand, will present witnesses and documents supporting a conclusion that the applicant is unfit for the license including witnesses or victims of a wrongful act.
An ALJ from OAH presides over the hearing, accepts evidence, rules on legal questions, resolves discovery disputes, and submits a proposed decision to the IC. The ALJ is the guardian of the record that serves as the basis for the ultimate decision and any subsequent review. The IC, however, retains ultimate authority to make the decision and may adopt an ALJ’s proposed decision entirely or adopt it with a reduced restrictions or probationary terms. To increase the restrictions or probationary terms, IC must reject the proposed decision and either decide the case on the existing record or refer it back to take additional evidence.
Due Process Considerations. Due process demands a careful balancing of administrative efficiency and separation of powers. The roles played by a state agency become critical elements in the due process analysis. Some agencies serve as either prosecutor or judge and pose little to no risk of an unconstitutional consolidation of power. For example, the Department of Fair Employment and Housing investigates discrimination cases but prosecutes them in superior court. (Prior to 2012, the Fair Employment and Housing Commission would hear and decide those cases.) Other agencies, however, serve as prosecutor and judge, an arrangement that raises the risks of potential due process violations such as those involving improper ex parte contact or pro-agency bias by the decision-maker or hearing officer.
In order to protect due process rights, agencies that exercise prosecutorial and adjudicatory powers must internally separate those functions; for instance, staff involved in the investigation or prosecution of a matter may not advise the decision-maker on that matter. The APA regulates some internal agency conduct, such as ex parte communications, and requires that most cases be heard by an ALJ employed by OAH. Since OAH ALJs are exposed to a variety of regulations and agency practices, OAH judges may be less likely to establish practices and biases that favor the agency, especially when an ALJ is asked to rule on whether an agency has engaged in improper conduct or exceeded its authority.
Despite the general trend to transfer cases to OAH, many agencies have kept their in-house ALJs. Some agencies use in-house ALJs to determine eligibility for public benefits or decide disputes between private parties (such as an employer and an employee). The Department of Social Services hears cases before in-house ALJs that involve the denial of benefits for several social assistance programs but it prosecutes actions against day care or residential facilities in front of OAH. Entities within the Department of Consumer Affairs, such as the Medical Board and Bureau of Automotive Repair, hear licensing disputes before OAH. The Public Utilities Commission (PUC) is a notable exception; the PUC needs its own expert ALJs given the complexity and unique nature of the issues and laws related to utility regulation. This is one reason why CDI uses its own ALJs to hear insurance rating matters.
CDI is a state agency directed by the IC, a statewide elected official that holds quasi-legislative, prosecutorial, and quasi-judicial powers that are not subject to an administrative appeal process. AHB ALJs are appointed by the IC pursuant to civil service rules and may not be supervised directly by the IC or supervised directly or indirectly by an employee in the legal branch. A deputy commissioner writes the performance reviews of the Chief ALJ who writes the performance reviews and assigns the cases and other work to the other ALJs.
Length of Time to Resolve a Case. CDI data shows that for 2013 and 2014, it has taken, on average, 188.41 days from the date a Request to Set a Hearing was sent to OAH until CDI received the proposed decision from OAH. According to CDI, previous OAH data showed an average number of days to hear cases (start to finish) was approximately 162 days. CDI claims that it would be able to hear these cases within 30 days.
According to OAH, it has taken 111 days from when OAH receives a Request to Set form, but notes that this time frame fits within two weeks of the parties’ typical availability. OAH explains that CDI attorneys often indicate that they are unavailable for weeks or months.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Department of Insurance (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/18/15)
California Department of General Services
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: CDI has sponsored this bill because existing law does not provide the IC the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases unlike many other entities in the state. Currently the hearings are heard by OAH within the Department of General Services with only a handful of exceptions. OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which can make it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely manner. This has led to a hearing process that can be lengthy for new licensee applicants and consumers, as well as being costly to CDI. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. In many cases insurers and other related employers have significantly invested in these potential new agents, making delays extremely costly. Out of 370,000 licenses, CDI sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the IC does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the AHB within CDI. Sixty percent (or roughly 100) of those cases are new licensee applicant cases that could be heard by the AHB. This bill will enhance governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new CDI licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and keeps consumers protected.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Department of General Services opposes this bill it seeks to remove an unknown number of cases from OAH, which was established as the state’s independent and neutral adjudicatory body, and place them under the jurisdiction of the AHB of the prosecutorial agency, the CDI. It also asserts that there is no data supporting the CDI’s premise that this change would increase the efficiency of the hearing process.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/7/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Campos, Roger Hernández, Steinorth
Prepared by: Erin Ryan / INS. / (916) 651-4110
8/18/15 15:52:34
**** END ****
AB 1232 (Cristina Garcia) Page 6 of 6
SENATE COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1232 Hearing Date: July 8, 2015
Author: |
Cristina Garcia |
||
Version: |
June 29, 2015 Amended |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Hugh Slayden |
||
Subject: Insurance Commissioner: administrative hearings.
SUMMARY
Provides an applicant whose license to act as an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor has been denied by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) the option to request a hearing in front of an administrative law judge (ALJ) from CDI’s Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) or the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), or permits the Insurance Commissioner (IC) to assign the case if the applicant fails to select a preference.
DIGEST
Existing law
Requires a person acting in the capacity of an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor to hold a license issued by CDI.
Permits the IC to deny a license to an applicant for a range of reasons including a lack of qualification, conviction of any felony or a misdemeanor related to insurance, or for prior unlicensed activity.
Prohibits the IC from denying a license without providing the applicant a hearing held pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).
Requires that most hearings of state agencies conducted pursuant to the APA be presided over by OAH ALJs.
This bill
Permits the applicant to choose, at the time a hearing is requested, whether to have an ALJ from CDI or from the OAH hear the appeal.
Requires the IC to annually report on the total number of hearings and the number of those cases heard by CDI ALJs, average number of days between case referral, and when the ALJ issues a proposed decision, and outcome of the cases.
COMMENTS
Purpose of the bill CDI has sponsored this bill because existing law does not provide the IC the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases unlike many other entities in the state. Currently the hearings are heard by OAH within the Department of General Services with only a handful of exceptions. OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which can make it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely manner. This has led to a hearing process that can be lengthy for new licensee applicants and consumers, as well as being costly to CDI. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. In many cases insurers and other related employers have significantly invested in these potential new agents, making delays extremely costly. Out of 370,000 licenses, CDI sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the IC does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the AHB within CDI. Sixty percent (or roughly 100) of those cases are new licensee applicant cases that could be heard by the AHB. This bill will enhance governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new CDI licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and keeps consumers protected.
Background The IC issues licenses and takes disciplinary actions, such as suspension or revocation, against a person who already holds a license (“licensees”). This bill would only impact a person that the IC has initially denied a license as an insurance agent, broker, or solicitor (“applicant”) and who has requested a hearing to challenge the reason for the denial.
Every applicant must complete a background check prior to receiving a license as a part of the application and examination process. If the background check is cleared and the applicant has successfully passed the examination, a license is granted. However, for a variety of reasons, the IC may deny the license or grant a license with restrictions. The IC may deny the license without a hearing on certain grounds (such as conviction for any felony), but usually must give the applicant an opportunity to make a case for licensure.
The hearing is the applicant’s opportunity to prove that alleged facts or reasons for the denial are untrue, invalid, or should be considered along with mitigating factors. Unlike criminal and licensee discipline cases, the burden is on the applicant to show that he or she is fit for the license. (The agency retains the burden of proving wrongdoing for which the applicant has not already been convicted, but only by a preponderance of the evidence or “more likely than not” standard.) An adverse decision may brand the applicant as dishonest or untrustworthy and the applicant will have to disclose the decision anytime he or she applies for another professional license or some types of employment. Documents related to the case are usually public records and pleadings and final decisions are posted on the CDI website.
The Hearing Process. When the applicant requests a hearing, CDI must serve a “statement of issues” explaining the basis of the denial. Once CDI mails the statement of issues, the applicant has 15 days to file a “notice of defense” that requests a hearing and notes any special objections. Once a hearing is requested, CDI will file the case with OAH to start the formal process and request OAH to set a hearing give the availability of the parties.
This bill would allow the applicant to request a hearing with either the OAH or AHB when filing the notice of defense. If the applicant fails to select a preference, the IC could select the forum.
The agency and applicant will attempt to work out a settlement before the hearing that may include probationary terms. The applicant or the applicant’s attorney will be researching applicable law, talking to potential witnesses, requesting and reviewing discovery, etc.
Often the applicant may want the license as soon as possible, but not always. An applicant may need time to establish a history of employment, advance professional training, sobriety (if the cause for denial involved drug or alcohol-related conduct) or other factor that favors licensure. At the hearing, the applicant may present witnesses, such as therapists, employers, friends, and others, who will testify on his or her behalf. CDI, on the other hand, will present witnesses and documents supporting a conclusion that the applicant is unfit for the license including witnesses or victims of a wrongful act.
An ALJ from OAH presides over the hearing, accepts evidence, rules on legal questions, resolves discovery disputes, and submits a proposed decision to the IC. The ALJ is the guardian of the record that serves as the basis for the ultimate decision and any subsequent review. The IC, however, retains ultimate authority to make the decision and may adopt an ALJ’s proposed decision entirely or adopt it with a reduced restrictions or probationary terms. To increase the restrictions or probationary terms, IC must reject the proposed decision and either decide the case on the existing record or refer it back to take additional evidence.
Due Process Considerations. Due process demands a careful balancing of administrative efficiency and separation of powers. The roles played by a state agency become critical elements in the due process analysis. Some agencies serve as either prosecutor or judge and pose little to no risk of an unconstitutional consolidation of power. For example, the Department of Fair Employment and Housing investigates discrimination cases but prosecutes them in superior court. (Prior to 2012, the Fair Employment and Housing Commission would hear and decide those cases.) Other agencies, however, serve as prosecutor and judge, an arrangement that raises the risks of potential due process violations such as those involving improper ex parte contact or pro-agency bias by the decision-maker or hearing officer.
In order to protect due process rights, agencies that exercise prosecutorial and adjudicatory powers must internally separate those functions; for instance, staff involved in the investigation or prosecution of a matter may not advise the decision-maker on that matter. The APA regulates some internal agency conduct, such as ex parte communications, and requires that most cases be heard by an ALJ employed by OAH.
California became the first state to establish a central panel of ALJs in 1945 based on recommendations by the Judicial Council. In its report Administrative Adjudication by State Agencies, the California Law Revision Commission (CLRC) explains that OAH was intended to create a staff of qualified hearing officers who become expert in a number of fields, yet do not have a potential conflict of interest with the agency for which they conducted hearings and would impart an appearance of fairness to the hearings. (P. 94.) Also, since OAH ALJs are exposed to a variety of regulations and agency practices, it may be argued that OAH judges are less likely to establish practices and biases that favor the agency, especially when an ALJ is asked to rule on whether an agency has engaged in improper conduct or exceeded its authority.
Despite the general trend to transfer cases to OAH, many agencies have kept their in-house ALJs. Although there is no bright line rule, the agencies follow at least one of several patterns. Some agencies use in-house ALJs to determine eligibility for public benefits or decide disputes between private parties (such as an employer and an employee). The Department of Social Services hears cases before in-house ALJs that involve the denial of benefits for several social assistance programs (but it prosecutes actions against day care or residential facilities in front of OAH). Other agencies with in-house ALJs are subject to an external appeal process. The Employment Development Department issues decisions related to unemployment insurance coverage subject to review by the Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board.
License denials and disciplinary actions taken against individuals or businesses usually involve common issues and legal questions and are mostly heard by OAH. Entities within the Department of Consumer Affairs, such as the Medical Board and Bureau of Automotive Repair, hear licensing disputes before OAH. The Public Utilities Commission (PUC) is a notable exception; the PUC needs its own expert ALJs given the complexity and unique nature of the issues and laws related to utility regulation. This is one reason why CDI uses its own ALJs to hear insurance rating matters.
CDI’s Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB). CDI is a state agency directed by the IC, a statewide elected official that holds quasi-legislative, prosecutorial, and quasi-judicial powers that are not subject to an administrative appeal process. CDI has four in-house ALJs in its AHB that hear insurance rate cases under Proposition 103 which requires property/casualty insurers to submit their proposed rating plans to the IC for approval. However, they also hear cases related to workers’ compensation rates, hearings related to persons prohibited to engage in the business of insurance under federal law, and others matters. According to CDI, the majority of cases heard by the AHB are non-Prop 103 cases and requires the ALJs to weigh the applicant’s testimony in determining his or her “fitness or character” when reaching a decision (qualifications critical to hearing applicant cases). Because of the irregular flow of cases, AHB ALJs are assigned other legal work when not hearing cases.
AHB ALJs are appointed by the IC pursuant to civil service rules and may not be supervised directly by the IC or supervised directly or indirectly by an employee in the legal branch. A deputy commissioner writes the performance reviews of the Chief ALJ who writes the performance reviews and assigns the cases and other work to the other ALJs. Deputy commissioners serve at the pleasure of the IC and possess the formal powers of the IC unless otherwise restricted.
Length of Time to Resolve a Case. CDI data shows that for 2013 and 2014, it has taken, on average, 188.41 days from the date a Request to Set a Hearing was sent to OAH until CDI received the proposed decision from OAH (based on a review of 307 cases that includes both application and licensing cases, but mostly licensing cases). CDI also notes that the ALJ has 30 days from the close of the record to issue the proposed decision. According to CDI, previous OAH data showed an average number of days to hear cases (start to finish) was approximately 162 days. CDI claims that it would be able to hear these cases within 30 days.
At the committee’s request, OAH calculated the average amount of time to set CDI cases over the last year (from April 2014 to May 2015) and determined that it has taken 111 days from when OAH receives a Request to Set form, but notes that this time frame fits within two weeks of the parties’ typical availability. OAH explains that CDI attorneys often indicate that they are unavailable for weeks or months.
Fiscal Impact. While a state agency may seek reimbursement for its pre-hearing investigation and enforcement costs, due process requires state agencies to bear the cost of the hearing. The 2014-15 rate for an OAH ALJ is $191 per hour, staff counsel costs $181 per hour, and a hearing reporter is priced at a contract rate. The analysis by the Assembly Appropriations Committee indicates a negligible state fiscal effect. Any savings to CDI under this bill will likely be shifted as losses of income to OAH.
Conflict of Interest. Occasionally, ALJs are asked to rule on the agency’s conduct or scope of authority. Such an issue may be seen as presenting a conflict of interest if raised before an in-house ALJ. These sorts of issues are far less likely to arise in license application cases, as opposed to cases involving licensees or insurers, since the issues involved tend to be narrow and straightforward and there are far fewer laws and regulations that apply. Moreover, the applicant may select OAH to hear the case when filing the notice of defense if there are any concerns about the objectivity of AHB ALJs at that time.
Hearing Location. The APA requires that hearings be held at an OAH facility in Sacramento, Oakland, Los Angeles, or San Diego, whichever is closest to the location where the transaction occurred or the respondent resides, or at place selected by agreement of the parties. CDI assures the committee that although it only has two hearing rooms in Los Angeles and San Francisco, cases can be heard in other CDI locations where conference rooms are available. CDI ALJs are physically located in San Francisco but are able to travel, as necessary, to hold a hearing and can hear cases throughout the state. For example, CDI has regional offices in San Diego and an office in Sacramento with facilities that may be used to conduct hearings.
POSITIONS
Support
Department of Insurance (sponsor)
Oppose
None received
-- END --
AB 1232
Page 2
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1232
(Cristina Garcia) – As Amended April 13, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Insurance |
Vote: |
12 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This, as proposed to be amended, bill permits administrative law judges (ALJs) at the Department of Insurance (department) to hear the appeal of individuals who are denied a license by the department.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Negligible state fiscal effect.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, existing law does not provide the commissioner the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases. As a result, an overwhelming majority of the hearings are heard by the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH). OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which makes it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely and expeditious manner. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. The department sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the commissioner does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) within the department. It is not uncommon for more than a year to pass before an ALJ in OAH is able to hear a case.
This bill will provide governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and better protects consumers.
Administrative Hearing Bureau. The department employs four ALJs in its AHB. These ALJs are hired to hear insurance rate cases under Proposition 103, which requires property/casualty insurers to submit their proposed rating plans to the commissioner for approval. Because the flow of proposed rating plans is irregular, these ALJs have time available for other duties. Applicant cases would continue to be referred to OAH when AHB staff is not available to handle the cases.
Amendments simply clarify this bill applies to persons subject to the section, not chapter.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1232
Page 2
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
AB 1232
Cristina Garcia – As Amended April 13, 2015
SUBJECT: Insurance Commissioner: administrative hearings
SUMMARY: Permits administrative law judges (ALJs) at the Department of Insurance (department) to hear the appeal of individuals who are denied a license by the department. Specifically, this bill:
Permits the Insurance Commissioner (commissioner) to select an ALJ from the department or from the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) to hear the appeal of an individual who was denied a license.
Requires the department to annually report on number of times department ALJs hear these cases and their performance when hearing these cases.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires insurance agents/brokers and other "producers" to be licensed by the department.
Establishes the OAH to perform the administrative adjudication function for other state agencies.
Establishes the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) to define the process by which administrative complaints are resolved.
Permits the department to hire ALJs to hear rate setting cases under Proposition 103.
Permits the department to deny a license to an applicant for a range of reasons including:
Absence of qualifications
Lying on an application
Conviction of a felony
Conviction of a misdemeanor related to insurance
Unlicensed activity
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, existing law does not provide the commissioner the authority to hear new licensee applicant cases. As a result, an overwhelming majority of the hearings are heard by OAH. OAH conducts hearings, mediations, and settlement conferences for more than 1,600 state, local, and county agencies, which makes it challenging to schedule hearings for all outstanding applicants in a timely and expeditious manner. Individuals with a pending application or a new licensee applicant are unable to work in a licensed capacity in the insurance industry and must wait for their case to be resolved. The department sends approximately 160 licensee cases per year to the OAH since the commissioner does not have the authority to assign licensing matters to the Administrative Hearing Bureau (AHB) within the department. However 60 percent (or roughly 100) of those cases are new licensee applicant cases that could be heard by the AHB. It is not uncommon for more than a year to pass before an ALJ in OAH is able to hear a case. This bill will provide governmental efficiency by streamlining the licensee hearing adjudication process for new licensee applicants. An administratively efficient process better serves new licensee applicants and consumers protected.
Administrative Hearing Bureau. The department employs four ALJs in its AHB. These ALJs are hired to hear insurance rate cases under Proposition 103 which requires property/casualty insurers to submit their proposed rating plans to the commissioner for approval. Because the flow of proposed rating plans is irregular, these ALJs have time available for other duties. Presently, the department assigns other legal work to the ALJs when they have available time, but the department would prefer to use available ALJ time to speed up the process for license applicant cases. Applicant cases would continue to be referred to OAH when AHB does not have the time available to handle the cases.
License Denial Process. Insurance agents must obtain a license in order to practice and this license must be renewed every two years by the department. Every new applicant must complete a background check prior to receiving a license as a part of the application and examination process. If the background check is cleared and the applicant has successfully passed the examination a license is granted. However, in certain cases, based on an applicant’s background check, the department may deny or grant a license with restrictions. When this occurs applicants may request to have their case heard by an ALJ, who in turn gives a proposed decision on the case at the hearing. The commissioner then upholds, denies, or modifies this decision.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Department of Insurance (sponsor)
Opposition
None received
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):