AB 1366: Office of Emergency Services: coordination of communications.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-04-06
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 6, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | In committee: That the measure be held in committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (July 10). |
| Jun 27, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| May 30, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | That the measure be held in committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10 | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2019 | AB 1366 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 9/10/2019
Author: | |||
Version: | As Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT: Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled communications services: Next Generation 911 emergency communications system: reporting requirements
DIGEST: This bill extends the sunset date on prohibitions against the regulation of Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and other internet protocol (IP) enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2022.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to fix rates, establish rules, examine records, issue subpoenas, administer oaths, take testimony, punish for contempt, and prescribe a uniform system of accounts for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution, Article XII, §6)
- Defines the term “public utility” and includes common carriers in the definition of a public utility. (Public Utilities Code §216)
- Defines VoIP as a communications service that does all the following:
- Uses an IP system to enable real-time, two-way voice communication;
- Requires a broadband connection from the user’s location; and,
- Allows a user to receive and terminate a call over the public switched telephone network.
A service that uses ordinary equipment with no enhanced functionality and does not undergo an IP conversion process is not a VoIP service. (Public Utilities Code §239(a))
- Defines an IP enabled service as any service, capability, function, or application using an IP system to send or receive communication through a broadband connection, regardless of whether the communication is voice, data, or video. (Public Utilities Code §239(b))
- Gives the CPUC the authority to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state and do all things necessary and convenient in the exercise of such power and jurisdiction. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Prohibits until January 1, 2020, the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services unless required or expressly delegated by state or federal law. Any delegation or express requirement does not expand the jurisdiction of the CPUC, department, agency, or subdivision beyond the scope of that requirement or delegation. (Public Utilities Code §710 (a-b))
- Exempts the following from the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-based services:
- The collection of surcharges to fund basic 911 service and the state’s universal service programs.
- Cable franchising duties specified in the Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act (DIVCA).
- The CPUC’s authority to implement and enforce interconnection and arbitration requirements for telecommunications providers classified as common carriers pursuant to Title II of the Federal Communications Act of 1934.
- The CPUC’s authority to make data requests regarding market competition proceedings at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
- The CPUC’s authority to address disputes between carriers regarding compensation for the exchange of traffic over an IP network.
- The CPUC’s authority to enforce requirements in CPUC Decision 10-01-026 regarding consumer education programs about the availability and limitations of backup power for VoIP systems.
- The CPUC’s authority to address pole attachment disputes.
- The Warren 911 Emergency Assistance Act. (Public Utilities Code §710 (c))
- Specifies that the restrictions on government regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services does not affect the following:
- Enforcement of state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Existing regulation, proceedings, or existing CPUC authority over non-IP wireline and wireless service, including universal, basic, and lifeline service requirements.
- The CPUC’s ability to monitor and discuss VoIP services, track and report to the FCC and Legislature.
- The CPUC’s authority to report to the Legislature annually on the number and types of complaints received by the CPUC from VoIP customers and respond informally to complaints with information about potential remedies under state and federal law.
- The establishment and enforcement of policies regarding intellectual property protection. (Public Utilities Code §710 (d-f))
- Requires the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to develop a plan and timeline for testing, implementing, and operating a Next Generation 911 (NG 911) System. Existing law specifies steps for maximizing the efficiency and containing the costs of the NG 911 system. (Government Code §53121)
This bill:
- Extends the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2022, and establishes a two-year sunset for consumer protection portions of the bill.
- Extends existing limitations on state regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services by prohibiting the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services except in accordance with the following:
- As required or expressly delegated by federal law.
- As expressly directed by statute or pursuant to exemptions established in this bill.
- As expressly and specifically directed by the Legislature in the interest of public safety, cybersecurity, or consumer protection.
- Adds the following to the list of exemptions to the prohibition on the government authority over VoIP and IP-enabled services:
- The CPUC’s authority over wireless, non-IP, and non-VoIP telecommunications.
- The CPUC’s authority over basic service and the Lifeline program.
- The CPUC’s authority over carriers of last resort, regardless of the technology used to provide basic telephone service.
- The CPUC’s existing statutory authority to enforce requirements regarding backup power for telecommunications systems.
- The CPUC’s authority to establish utility facility safety requirements.
- The OES’s authority related to 911 emergency services, including OES’s duties pursuant to the Warren-911 Emergency Assistance Act and OES’s authority to direct the CPUC to implement NG 911 terms of service requirements adopted by OES.
- Federal outage reporting requirements for facilities based VoIP service providers.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill limits the Attorney General or other applicable entity from enforcing state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, cybersecurity, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Requires the CPUC to provide a copy of its annual report to the Attorney General and forward to the Attorney General any customer complaint the CPUC receives regarding VoIP.
- Requires the CPUC to include the following in its annual report to the Legislature:
- The number, type, and outcomes of complaints received by the CPUC regarding VoIP.
- Recommendations based on customer complaint and resolution data.
Information reported by the CPUC must be aggregated and de-identified to remove any personally identifiable information.
- Requires providers of residential interconnected VoIP service to disclose any backup power requirements in state and federal law to each new customer. The disclosure must notify new customers that customers may contact the CPUC to submit a complaint regarding their VoIP services and obtain additional information about alternative communications services, including basic telephone service.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to update their terms of service to state that the provider will offer a bill credit for outages lasting longer than 24 hours upon request. This credit does not apply to outages on Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to start restoring service within 24 hours or receiving an outage report and restore service within 72 hours of receiving the report. This service restoration period does not apply to Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Defines “circumstances beyond the provider’s control” as any of the following:
- Electrical outages
- Catastrophic events
- Natural disasters
- Emergencies proclaimed by the governor
- Cable theft
- Third-party cable cuts
- A lack of access to the premises
- Absence of customer support to test the facilities
- Exempts any residential interconnected VoIP provider from the bill credit and service restoration requirements if it is subject to the same or similar standards in federal or state law for the facilities over which it provides VoIP services.
- Exempts VoIP providers that use a wireless broadcast connection from the bill credit and service restoration requirements.
- Authorizes OES to establish terms of service requirements for an NG 911 emergency communications system, including the costs, services, terms and conditions for contractors providing NG 911 services. OES is authorized to direct the CPUC to implement the terms of services requirements adopted by OES.
Background
What are VoIP and IP-enabled services? VoIP is a telecommunications technology that transfers calls as data packets over an internet connection. VoIP may initiate a call over the internet; however, it can also carry and complete calls over the traditional copper network. VoIP services may be provided with a fixed or mobile connection. Generally, fixed VoIP products are offered by internet service providers (ISPs) in lieu of a traditional telephone connection. Mobile VoIP generally provides voice service through an application downloaded to a device, including wireless devices. Fixed VoIP products more closely resemble traditional home phone service, and IP-enabled services are any services delivered over an internet network. This bill restricts the state from regulating VoIP and any IP-enabled service.
A brief history of the deregulation of the telecommunications sector. This bill extends current deregulation of internet-based telecommunications from 2020 to 2030. This bill applies to VoIP and all other IP-based services, which may include any service delivered over the internet. Deregulation of the telecommunications sector has ebbed and flowed in California since 1995. During the 1990s, federal and state governments initiated a number of market changes to increase competition and reduce regulations for the telecommunications sector. The CPUC issued a decision opening California’s local exchanges to competition between companies in 1995. Prior to this decision, local telephone service was generally provided by one telephone utility in each service territory. Federal and state agencies opened telephone service territories and lowered regulatory barriers with the intention of encouraging competition, which agencies hoped would lead to lower prices and higher investment in advanced telecommunications services, including broadband internet. While some communities benefited from increased competition, other communities have not experienced a commensurate amount of telecommunications investment and still lack broadband connections as their wireline services age. Deregulation also led some telecommunications companies to accrue a significant amount of debt and engage in unsustainable expansion. By the end of 2001, multiple telecommunications providers initiated bankruptcy proceedings and subsequently ceased operations. Several of these bankruptcies remain among the largest bankruptcies in United States history.
Changes since 2012. When legislation establishing VoIP and IP-based regulatory prohibitions (SB 1161, Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) passed the Legislature, most telephone lines were wireline service. However, data from the FCC shows that in 2016, the number of VoIP lines exceeded the number of regulated wireline telephone lines. At current rates of VoIP adoption, VoIP may comprise up to 94 percent of all home telephone lines by 2030. With the expansion of other IP-enabled communications, most telephone services are now IP-based services. Additionally, in 2012, the FCC played a more active role in regulating IP-based telecommunications. Since the enactment SB 1161 in 2012, the FCC has largely deregulated IP-based communications at the federal level and at least 35 other states have also adopted laws limiting the regulation of IP-based telecommunications. As a result, most telecommunications have limited federal and state regulation.
This bill extends limitations on service quality oversight. Under this bill, VoIP is not subject to service quality requirements established by the CPUC unless the provider is offering VoIP as basic telephone service or using VoIP to meet Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) obligations. At this time, no carrier is providing basic services through VoIP. However, if 94 percent of telephone lines become VoIP or IP-based in the near future, it is likely that at least some carriers will use IP-based technology to meet COLR obligations. Since limited public information exists about VoIP’s service quality, it is difficult to evaluate its performance against other communication technologies.
COLR service is an obligation of certain telecommunications companies to provide basic telephone service within certain regions of the state. These requirements are generally analogous to Provider of Last Resort (POLR) requirements in the electricity sector; however, telecommunications COLR duties are less extensive than electricity POLR duties. COLR services are considered a “basic service” under existing regulations, and they are subject CPUC regulatory oversight to ensure that the service is sufficient. Maintaining the integrity of this service is critical to ensuring that consumers have a reliable method for making necessary calls, including 911 calls.
The CPUC has established metrics for determining whether a provider meets basic service quality requirements through General Order 133-D (GO 133D). These metrics include information about the rate of customer service requests, the speed at which those requests are resolved, outage rates, service restoration rates, and installation speed. To obtain sufficient information to evaluate these metrics, the CPUC requires carriers to report customer service information on a regular basis. Companies that do not meet service quality requirements for basic telephone service can be fined based on the rate of violations. In lieu of paying fines, service quality violators may be permitted to re-invest the funds in services that remediate the service quality issues. Several companies that operate both traditional phone service and VoIP have received fines for failing to meet service quality standards with their traditional telephone service.
This bill attempts to establish new consumer protections, but enforcement mechanisms are limited. This bill contains provisions that establish some requirements for backup power notifications, service restoration, and customer bill credits that appear to be based on requirements established by the CPUC in regulatory proceedings regarding service quality. However, this bill places these provisions in a portion of the Business and Professions Code over which no board at the Department of Consumer Affairs has oversight. The bill exempts providers of wireless residential VoIP services from the service restoration and bill credit requirements. This bill also specifies that the CPUC is prohibited from enforcing these protections. As a result, lawsuits brought by the Attorney General may be the only mechanism to enforce these provisions.
This bill extends limitations on the CPUC’s ability to formally address consumer complaints through administrative actions, including the ability to request data regarding customer complaints from the telecommunications providers. While most of this bill relies on the FCC and litigation to enforce consumer protections, it is not clear that consumers can currently rely on the FCC and individual litigation to remedy their concerns, including unfair business practices. In the 2011 case AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, the United States Supreme Court determined that California statutes prohibiting the use of coercive clauses are pre-empted by the Federal Arbitration Act. Many companies, including telecommunications providers, include arbitration clauses in their contracts that limit a consumer’s ability to form a class with other consumers to seek remedies for unfair business practices related to contracts. These clauses frequently limit consumers to a specified arbitration process that limits the types of remedies consumers can obtain for unfair business practices.
Prior to the enactment of SB 1161, the Obama FCC took a number of steps to exercise more oversight on IP-enabled services. Between 2010 and 2015, the Obama FCC also adopted two orders to establish net neutrality requirements, which included re-classifying IP-based telecommunications as common carriers. This reclassification provided the FCC with much greater authority to enforce requirements on IP-based services and regulate those services in a manner similar to other telecommunications utilities. However, in 2017, the Trump FCC reversed the FCC’s net neutrality requirements, and the FCC has since deregulated additional services that may not be entirely IP-based. To the extent that consumers submit complaints to the FCC regarding VoIP and IP-enabled services, it is unclear what kind of remedy consumers can obtain since the FCC has adopted an order limiting its own ability to establish requirements for these services.
Consumer complaints exist, but the analysis is incomplete. This bill addresses a gap in information regarding consumer complaints for VoIP by requiring the CPUC to report to the Legislature and Attorney General on complaints it receives regarding VoIP services and requiring the CPUC to forward those complaints to the Attorney General.
In a 2017 report on the status of state-level oversight of telecommunication, researchers from the National Regulatory Research Institute identified areas for states to focus their efforts in the face of VoIP deregulation and the transition to broadband communication networks. The report recommended focusing on the following steps:
- Gaining customer-driven insights such as crowd sourcing information to track service accessibility and reliability.
- Broadening outage reporting.
- Collect and evaluate consumer complaints.
The CPUC operates the Broadband Map, which includes an opportunity to gain crowdsourced information on broadband reliability and accessibility. Additional bills pending in the Legislature broaden outage reporting. However, increasing access to customer complaint data and establishing mechanisms to resolve these complaints has not been addressed at this time.
While the CPUC has not reported on customer complaints specific to VoIP, the CPUC’s Customer Affairs Branch regularly reports on customer complaints received by the CPUC. These reports are broken down by utility sector and month and they include a discussion of the nature of the reports. The chart below shows the number of complaints received by the CPUC between November 2018 and January 2019 for the energy, communications, and water utilities regulated by the CPUC.
November 2018 | December 2018 | January 2019 | |
Energy | 687 | 661 | 677 |
Communications | 904 | 974 | 1,087 |
Water | 39 | 39 | 53 |
Despite the occurrence of wildfires in which utility infrastructure was implicated, complaints regarding energy utilities remained largely consistent between November 2018 and January 2019. In January 2019, the energy utilities regulated by the CPUC generated a total of 677 complaints and 49 (approximately seven percent) of these complaints were classified as pertaining to issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. During the same month, the telecommunications sector generated 1,087 consumer complaints, and 205 (approximately 19 percent) of those complaints were classified as issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. This data indicates that the communications sector generates a greater number of complaints to the CPUC than other utility sectors on average, and a much greater percentage of those complaints are for customer issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction.
It is likely that VoIP and IP-enabled services would be classified as issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction; however, the CPUC does not currently identify which complaints may be related to VoIP. The CPUC data on VoIP customer complaints does not include information regarding the extent to which complaints are resolved and whether those resolutions are timely. This bill would require the CPUC to report on VoIP complaints and the outcomes of those complaints. This reporting requirement is intended to ensure that the Legislature has sufficient information on consumer issues regarding VoIP when considering policy changes in the future.
A two-year sunset? Recent amendments would sunset most of the bill’s provisions on January 1, 2022. The bill’s prohibitions on the regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled communications would end by 2022. Additionally, provisions of the bill requiring VoIP providers to notify new customers about backup power options and their rights to contact the CPUC to submit a complaint regarding VoIP would also sunset by 2022. Only the provisions of the bill in the Government Code authorizing OES to establish requirements for a NG 911 system would not sunset within two years. It is unclear whether the CPUC and Legislature will have sufficient consumer complaint data to identify long-term trends and necessary changes to state law after only 12 months.
Ensuring sufficient authority over 911. Recent conflicts over the implementation of NG 911 indicate that different interpretations of existing law regarding OES’s authority over NG 911 exist. Existing law within the Warren 911 Act requires OES to develop a plan and timeline for the testing, implementation and operation of NG 911 system. In April 2019, OES released a competitive request for proposal (RFP) to obtain bids for a NG 911 provider. The RFP specifies that bidders must submit tariffs, which are agreements that stipulate the terms, conditions, and prices for which services are provided. Generally, tariffs are filed with the CPUC, and the CPUC has historically required tariffs for 911 service. The use of tariffs can help ensure that adequate infrastructure is used in the development and maintenance of 911 systems, including the use of appropriate router technology that routes calls to public safety answering points.
Several telecommunications companies have objected to the inclusion of a tariff in the NG 911 contract because they claim that tariffs are unnecessary for a competitively bid contract and the contract can include terms, conditions, and price disclosures without a tariff. As a complaint to the RFP, AT&T submitted a petition in California Superior Court requesting the following:
- A writ of mandate requiring OES to withdraw the current NG 911 RFP and specifying that any new RFP must not include a tariff or “not to exceed” provisions that prohibits costs from exceeding a certain level. The request also requests that any “not to exceed” cap include information specifying how the amount is calculated and related to the scope of the RFP.
- A declaration exempting AT&T from the NG 911 tariff and that the “not to exceed” provisions of the contract are unenforceable.
- An injunction preventing the implementation of the RFP.
- Other legal remedies.
Carriers claim that the tariff, cost restrictions, and certain price disclosures constitute regulation prohibited by Public Utilities Code §710, regardless of the 911 exemption in statute. The Attorney General’s argument in response notes that 911 services are critical needs that require tariffs as a means of ensuring that services are provided in a manner consistent with established requirements because contracts for 911 services cannot be terminated in the event that a party breaches its terms. Since NG 911 services are provided over a largely unregulated network, the tariffs and price caps are likely some of the only enforcement mechanisms available to ensure that costs are competitive, prevent unreasonable charges, and ensure that the system is established and maintained properly.
Effective maintenance of the system is critical for relaying 911 calls and protecting the system from hazards that could endanger the 911 system, including cyberattacks. While there may be mechanisms for OES to obtain price disclosures from bidders through the contracting process, it is unclear how OES would enforce those prices or verify that they are accurate without some additional enforcement mechanism. This bill clarifies OES’s authority to establish requirements for the NG 911 system, including requiring tariffs for any winning bidder to NG 911 RFP. The bill specifies that OES may direct the CPUC to implement tariffs adopted as requirements for the NG 911 contract; however, the bill does not require a telecommunications provider that is not a party to the RFP to submit a tariff. Under the bill, the authority of OES to administer 911 emergency communications and establish requirements for the NG 911 system are exempt from this bill’s prohibitions on state authority over VoIP and IP-based communications.
The law of unintended consequences. Existing law and this bill contain broad prohibitions against regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services with narrow exemptions. The deregulation of VoIP has had a variety of unintended consequences for privacy, civil rights, and portions of law that have not been substantially updated since IP-enabled telecommunications have become the dominant form of communications services.
Following the catastrophic wildfires of 2017, the CPUC adopted several resolutions requiring energy utilities and certain telecommunications providers to implement certain consumer protections in the affected communities. In July 2018, the CPUC moved to extend these protections until permanent rules for consumers affected by catastrophic disasters could be adopted. The CPUC’s 2018 decision applied to COLRs and “residential communications companies.” In response to stakeholder comments, the CPUC clarified that “residential communications companies” includes facilities-based interconnected VoIP providers. While many telecommunications providers already provide some of the consumer relief that the CPUC required as part of its decision, a coalition of VoIP providers objected to the decision. In filings to the CPUC, the coalition stated that Public Utilities Code §710 prohibited the CPUC from requiring these telecommunications providers to comply with these protections. Some of the protections may help limit the degree to which consumers are billed for services that can only be delivered at addresses from which they have been evacuated and may not re-enter for an extended period of time. A number of IP-based services are established on contracts that last for at least a year and include early termination fees. News reports following the 2017 North Bay fires indicate that some telecommunications continued billing accounts for individuals that lost their lives in the fire. While these billing issues may have been errors, effective customer relief protocol may help prevent these errors in the future.
In a recent San Francisco Superior Court decision for Gruber v. Yelp, a judge ruled that the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) does not apply to VoIP calls. While the judge did not specifically cite a specific bill or statute, the judge concurred with the argument that since the CPUC does not regulate VoIP, and VoIP cannot be considered a cordless, cellular, landline phone, it cannot be treated as one of the technologies to which CIPA expressly applies.
In 2013, the Obama FCC took action to cap prison inmate calling costs following a class action lawsuit initiated by Martha Wright-Reed, the grandmother of an Arizona prison inmate. Wright-Reed sought the lawsuit after paying approximately $100 a month to call her grandson through an inmate calling service. A 2017 federal appellate court decision determined that the FCC had overstepped its authority to establish price caps on in-state calls. The Trump FCC abandoned attempts to appeal the decision and has declined to enforce caps on in-state calls transacted through an inmate calling system. Studies indicate that in-state calls comprise approximately 92 percent of all inmate calling system calls. Inmate calling systems do not exist in a competitive environment and the price terms are entirely controlled by the prison and the service contractors. A number of California inmate calling systems are strictly VoIP providers. Prison authorities can be prohibited from taking a cut of inmate calling system contracts and are authorized to establish contracts that limit inmate calling costs. However, under this bill, government agencies may be limited in their ability to exercise regulatory authority over VoIP inmate calling systems, including the establishment of price caps.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 822 (Weiner, Chapter 976, Statutes of 2018) established net neutrality requirements in California by prohibiting internet service providers from taking certain actions that interfere with consumers’ ability to lawfully access internet content. The bill prohibited intentionally blocking content, speeding up or slowing down traffic, engaging in paid-prioritization, requiring consideration from edge providers for access to an ISP’s end users, and selectively zero-rating certain content.
AB 2395 (Low, 2016) would have established a process by which telecommunications providers could cease to provide basic telephone service and meet COLR obligations. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1161 (Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) established prohibitions on the regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services in California.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- The Department of Justice estimates costs of $1.2 million in fiscal year 2019-20 and $2.1 million ongoing (Unfair Competition Law Fund) due to new enforcement obligations.
- The CPUC estimates costs of $372,000 ongoing to implement this bill.
SUPPORT:
100 Black Men of Long Beach Inc.
African American Male Education Network & Development
Alliance for Community Development
Asian Business Association of San Diego
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association
Asian Resources, Inc.
AT&T
Bay Area Council
Black Business Association
Black Women Organized for Political Action Political Action Committee
Boys & Girls Club of the North Valley
Brotherhood Crusade
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Cattlemen’s Association
California Latino Leadership Institute
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Rangeland Trust
California Urban Partnership
California-Hawaii State Conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Center for Fathers and Families
Chambers of Commerce: Black Chamber of Orange County, California Asian Pacific, California Black, California, California Hispanic, Carmel Valley, Chino Valley, Fontana, Fresno Metro Black, Glendale, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater Los Angeles African American, Greater Riverside, Hesperia, Hollywood, Los Angeles Latino, Murrieta/Wildomar, Orange County Hispanic, Pacific Grove, Pasadena, Rancho Cucamonga, Redlands, Sacramento Asian Pacific, Sacramento Black, Sacramento Hispanic, Slavic-American, Upland, and Victor Valley
Chicano Federation of San Diego County, Inc.
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Women Vital Voices
Computers 2 Kids
Computing Technology Industry Association
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Congress of California Seniors
Consolidated Communications Inc.
Consumer Advocates for RCFE Reform
CTIA
dev/Mission
Disability Action Center
East Oakland Youth Development Center
Fresno Area Hispanic Foundation
Frontier Communications
Frontier Senior Center
Gamma Zeta Boulé Foundation
Greater Ontario Business Council
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Hispanic 100 Policy Committee
Hispanic Foundation of Silicon Valley
Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center
In Biz Latino
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Invest in Women Entrepreneurs Initiative
Janet Goeske Foundation
Kings/Tulare Homeless Alliance
Krimson and Kreme Foundation
Latino Education & Advocacy Days
Lighthouse Counseling and Family Resource Center
MAAC
Macedonia Community Development Corp
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Music Changing Lives
National Diversity Coalition
North San Diego County NAACP
Oasis Center International
Orange County Business Council
Organization of Chinese Americans, East Bay
Organization of Chinese Americans, Greater Sacramento
Oroville Rescue Mission
Partners in College Success
Prancing Ponies Foundation
Riverside National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Roberts Family Development Center
Russian American Media, Inc.
Salvadoran American Leadership & Education Fund
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Oasis
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Barbara Partners in Education
Sentinels of Freedom
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Society for the Blind
South Bay Community Services
TechNet
TELACU
The Arc Butte County
The Fresno Center
The Nonprofit Alliance
The Village Project, Inc.
United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 648
United Women’s Organization
Urban Corps of San Diego County
Verizon
Veterans Association of North County
World Institute on Disability
Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
OPPOSITION:
AARP California
Access Humboldt
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Bay Area Christian Connection
Beth Eden Baptist Church
Broadband Institute of California
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Emerging Technology Fund
California Labor Federation
California Public Utilities Commission
Center on Race, Leadership and Social Justice
Central Coast Broadband Consortium
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
City Heights Community Development Corp
City of Santa Monica
Common Cause
Common Networks
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports
County of Santa Clara
Courage Campaign
Demand Progress
Digital Privacy Alliance
El Concilio of San Mateo County
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Emerging Leaders Program of the Leadership Institute at Allen Temple
Engine
Fight for the Future
Free Press Action
Housing Long Beach
Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Interdenominational Ministerial Alliance
League of California Cities
Media Alliance
MediaJustice
Mendocino County Board of Supervisors
Mission Asset Fund
Monkeybrains
Mono County Board of Supervisors
Mono County Sheriff’s Office
National Consumer Law Center
New America’s Open Technology Institute
New Media Rights
North Bay North Coast Broadband Consortium
Oakland Privacy
Omsoft and Davis Community Network
One Million New Internet Users
Poverello House
Prison Policy Initiative
Public Advocates Office (formerly Office of Ratepayer Advocates)
Public Citizen, Inc.
Public Knowledge
San Joaquin Valley Regional Broadband Consortium
Santa Clara County Fire Department
Southern Border Broadband Consortium
Southern California Tribal Digital Village Network
The Center for Media Justice
The Greenlining Institute
The Herald Fire Protection District
The Last Trump of Zion
The Utility Reform Network
True Faith Community Baptist Church
United Church of Christ, OC Inc.
Utility Consumers’ Action Network
Several Hundred Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
In 2012, the Legislature reserved the authority to regulate VoIP and IP-enabled services. Since then, Californians from different backgrounds and socioeconomic communities have benefitted greatly from these services. These Internet-based apps and technologies help keep people connected at home and abroad, communicate with healthcare providers and provide easier access to take care of other important obligations.
Current law is set to expire on January 1, 2020. Allowing this to happen will create uncertainty surrounding this technology and jeopardize the widespread access currently enjoyed by all Californians. Along with a two-year sunset extension, AB 1366 provides more robust consumer protections and greater reporting requirements, allowing our state to continue reaping the benefits of these services.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents claim that the continued deregulation of VoIP will result in fewer consumer protections for the majority of Californians because VoIP lines now exceed traditional telephone lines. Opponents also argue that this bill goes beyond prohibiting CPUC regulation of VoIP by prohibiting any governmental entity’s exercise of duty over VoIP and IP-based services, including the collection of data necessary for effectively deploying broadband in underserved communities. Opponents also claim that the current regulatory environment at the federal level necessitates more state oversight on telecommunications issues, which includes the resolution of safety and customer service concerns. In opposition, the Communication Workers of America (CWA) state:
Our workers are on the frontlines and hear directly from consumers about their problems with telephone services, without the ability to have a state commission or entity address these concerns. Our members also witness safety issues with phone lines that are exacerbated by the lack of proper oversight or regulation due to the passage of AB 1161. CWA has long supported policies that protect consumers and hold telecommunications service providers accountable for their infrastructure and service. AB 1366 would further entrench all the issues that SB 1161 caused by extending its provisions until 2030. As customers continue to be switched from traditional phone service to VoIP, a growing majority of Californians will lose the protections they previously enjoyed and still deserve.
-- END --
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1366 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1366
Amended: 8/13/19 in Senate
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 9-3, 7/10/19
AYES: Hueso, Moorlach, Bradford, Chang, Dodd, Hertzberg, Rubio, Stern, Stone
NOES: Hill, McGuire, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-6, 5/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled communications services
DIGEST:
This bill extends the sunset date on prohibitions against the regulation of Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and other internet protocol (IP) enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2025.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to fix rates, establish rules, examine records, issue subpoenas, administer oaths, take testimony, punish for contempt, and prescribe a uniform system of accounts for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution, Article XII, §6)
- Defines the term “public utility” and includes common carriers in the definition of a public utility. (Public Utilities Code §216)
- Defines VoIP as a communications service that does all the following:
- Uses an IP system to enable real-time, two-way voice communication;
- Requires a broadband connection from the user’s location; and,
- Allows a user to receive and terminate a call over the public switched telephone network.
A service that uses ordinary equipment with no enhanced functionality and does not undergo an IP conversion process is not a VoIP service. (Public Utilities Code §239(a))
- Defines an IP enabled service as any service, capability, function, or application using an IP system to send or receive communication through a broadband connection, regardless of whether the communication is voice, data, or video. (Public Utilities Code §239(b))
- Gives the CPUC the authority to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state and do all things necessary and convenient in the exercise of such power and jurisdiction. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Prohibits until January 1, 2020, the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services unless required or expressly delegated by state or federal law. Any delegation or express requirement does not expand the jurisdiction of the CPUC, department, agency, or subdivision beyond the scope of that requirement or delegation. (Public Utilities Code §710 (a-b))
- Exempts the following from the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-based services:
- The collection of surcharges to fund basic 911 service and the state’s universal service programs.
- Cable franchising duties specified in the Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act (DIVCA).
- The CPUC’s authority to implement and enforce interconnection and arbitration requirements for telecommunications providers classified as common carriers pursuant to Title II of the Federal Communications Act of 1934.
- The CPUC’s authority to make data requests regarding market competition proceedings at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
- The CPUC’s authority to address disputes between carriers regarding compensation for the exchange of traffic over an IP network.
- The CPUC’s authority to enforce requirements in CPUC Decision 10-01-026 regarding consumer education programs about the availability and limitations of backup power for VoIP systems.
- The CPUC’s authority to address pole attachment disputes.
- The Warren 911 Emergency Assistance Act. (Public Utilities Code §710 (c))
- Specifies that the restrictions on government regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services does not affect the following:
- Enforcement of state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Existing regulation, proceedings, or existing CPUC authority over non-IP wireline and wireless service, including universal, basic, and lifeline service requirements.
- The CPUC’s ability to monitor and discuss VoIP services, track and report to the FCC and Legislature.
- The CPUC’s authority to report to the Legislature annually on the number and types of complaints received by the CPUC from VoIP customers and respond informally to complaints with information about potential remedies under state and federal law.
- The establishment and enforcement of policies regarding intellectual property protection. (Public Utilities Code §710 (d-f))
- Requires the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to develop a plan and timeline for testing, implementing, and operating a Next Generation 911 (NG 911) System. Existing law specifies steps for maximizing the efficiency and containing the costs of the NG 911 system. (Government Code §53121)
This bill:
- Extends the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2025.
- Extends existing limitations on state regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services by prohibiting the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services except in accordance with the following:
- As required or expressly delegated by federal law.
- As expressly directed by statute or pursuant to exemptions established in this bill.
- As expressly and specifically directed by the Legislature in the interest of public safety or consumer protection.
- Adds the following to the list of exemptions to the prohibition on the government authority over VoIP and IP-enabled services:
- The CPUC’s authority over wireless, non-IP, and non-VoIP telecommunications.
- The CPUC’s authority over rules governing universal service programs, including the Lifeline program.
- The CPUC’s authority over rules governing basic telephone service.
- The CPUC’s authority over carriers of last resort, regardless of the technology used to provide basic telephone service.
- The CPUC’s existing statutory authority to enforce requirements regarding backup power for telecommunications systems.
- The CPUC’s authority to establish utility facility safety requirements.
- The OES’s authority related to 911 emergency services, including OES’s duties pursuant to the Warren-911 Emergency Assistance Act and OES’s authority to direct the CPUC to implement NG 911 terms of service requirements adopted by OES.
- Federal outage reporting requirements for facilities based VoIP service providers.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill limits the Attorney General or other applicable entity from enforcing state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, federal enhanced 911 requirements, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Requires the CPUC to annually report the number of type of consumer complaints it receives regarding VoIP service to the Attorney General and forward to the Attorney general any customer complaint the CPUC receives regarding VoIP and IP-enabled services.
- Requires the CPUC to include the following in its annual report to the Legislature:
- The number and type of complaints received by the CPUC regarding VoIP and IP-enabled services.
- The number of complaints resolved and the average duration for resolution based on reports by service providers.
- Recommendations based on customer complaint and resolution data.
- Requires providers of residential interconnected VoIP service to disclose any backup power requirements in state and federal law to each new customer. The disclosure must notify new customers that customers may contact the CPUC to submit a complaint regarding their VoIP services and obtain additional information about alternative communications services, including basic telephone service.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to update their terms of service to state that the provider will offer a bill credit for outages lasting longer than 24 hours upon request. This credit does not apply to outages on Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to start restoring service within 24 hours or receiving an outage report and restore service within 72 hours of receiving the report. This service restoration period does not apply to Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Defines “circumstances beyond the provider’s control” as any of the following:
- Electrical outages
- Catastrophic events
- Natural disasters
- Emergencies proclaimed by the governor
- Cable theft
- Third-party cable cuts
- A lack of access to the premises
- Absence of customer support to test the facilities
- Exempts any residential interconnected VoIP provider from the bill credit and service restoration requirements if the same or similar bill credit and service restoration standards are established in state or federal statute or regulations.
- Authorizes OES to establish terms of service requirements for an NG 911 emergency communications system, including the costs, services, terms and conditions for contractors providing NG 911 services. OES is authorized to direct the CPUC to implement the terms of services requirements adopted by OES.
Background
What are VoIP and IP-enabled services? VoIP is a telecommunications technology that transfers calls as data packets over an internet connection. VoIP may initiate a call over the internet; however, it can also carry and complete calls over the traditional copper network. VoIP services may be provided with a fixed or mobile connection. Generally, fixed VoIP products are offered by internet service providers (ISPs) in lieu of a traditional telephone connection. Mobile VoIP generally provides voice service through an application downloaded to a device, including wireless devices. Fixed VoIP products more closely resemble traditional home phone service, and IP-enabled services are any services delivered over an internet network. This bill restricts the state from regulating VoIP and any IP-enabled service.
Changes since 2012. When legislation establishing VoIP and IP-based regulatory prohibitions (SB 1161, Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) passed the Legislature, most telephone lines were wireline service. However, data from the FCC shows that in 2016, the number of VoIP lines exceeded the number of regulated wireline telephone lines. At current rates of VoIP adoption, VoIP may comprise up to 94 percent of all home telephone lines by 2030. With the expansion of other IP-enabled communications, most telephone services are now IP-based services. Additionally, in 2012, the FCC played a more active role in regulating IP-based telecommunications. Since the enactment SB 1161 in 2012, the FCC has largely deregulated IP-based communications at the federal level and at least 35 other states have also adopted laws limiting the regulation of IP-based telecommunications. As a result, most telecommunications have limited federal and state regulation.
This bill extends limitations on service quality oversight. Under this bill, VoIP is not subject to service quality requirements established by the CPUC unless the provider is offering VoIP as basic telephone service or using VoIP to meet Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) obligations. At this time, no carrier is providing basic services through VoIP. However, if 94 percent of telephone lines become VoIP or IP-based in the near future, it is likely that at least some carriers will use IP-based technology to meet COLR obligations. Since limited public information exists about VoIP’s service quality, it is difficult to evaluate its performance against other communication technologies.
COLR service is an obligation of certain telecommunications companies to provide basic telephone service within certain regions of the state. These requirements are generally analogous to Provider of Last Resort (POLR) requirements in the electricity sector; however, telecommunications COLR duties are less extensive than electricity POLR duties. COLR services are considered a “basic service” under existing regulations, and they are subject CPUC regulatory oversight to ensure that the service is sufficient. Maintaining the integrity of this service is critical to ensuring that consumers have a reliable method for making necessary calls, including 911 calls.
The CPUC has established metrics for determining whether a provider meets basic service quality requirements through General Order 133-D (GO 133D). These metrics include information about the rate of customer service requests, the speed at which those requests are resolved, outage rates, service restoration rates, and installation speed. To obtain sufficient information to evaluate these metrics, the CPUC requires carriers to report customer service information on a regular basis. Companies that do not meet service quality requirements for basic telephone service can be fined based on the rate of violations. In lieu of paying fines, service quality violators may be permitted to re-invest the funds in services that remediate the service quality issues. Several companies that operate both traditional phone service and VoIP have received fines for failing to meet service quality standards with their traditional telephone service.
This bill attempts to establish new consumer protections, but enforcement mechanisms are limited. This bill contains provisions that establish some requirements for backup power notifications, service restoration, and customer bill credits that appear to be based on requirements established by the CPUC in regulatory proceedings regarding service quality. However, this bill places these provisions in a portion of the Business and Professions Code over which no board at the Department of Consumer Affairs has oversight. This bill also specifies that the CPUC is prohibited from enforcing these protections. As a result, lawsuits brought by the Attorney General may be the only mechanism to enforce these provisions.
This bill extends limitations on the CPUC’s ability to formally address consumer complaints through administrative actions, including the ability to request data regarding customer complaints from the telecommunications providers. While most of this bill relies on the FCC and litigation to enforce consumer protections, it is not clear that consumers can currently rely on the FCC and individual litigation to remedy their concerns, including unfair business practices. In the 2011 case AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, the United States Supreme Court determined that California statutes prohibiting the use of coercive clauses are pre-empted by the Federal Arbitration Act. Many companies, including telecommunications providers, include arbitration clauses in their contracts that limit a consumer’s ability to form a class with other consumers to seek remedies for unfair business practices related to contracts. These clauses frequently limit consumers to a specified arbitration process that limits the types of remedies consumers can obtain for unfair business practices.
Prior to the enactment of SB 1161, the Obama FCC took a number of steps to exercise more oversight on IP-enabled services. Between 2010 and 2015, the Obama FCC also adopted two orders to establish net neutrality requirements, which included re-classifying IP-based telecommunications as common carriers. This reclassification provided the FCC with much greater authority to enforce requirements on IP-based services and regulate those services in a manner similar to other telecommunications utilities. However, in 2017, the Trump FCC reversed the FCC’s net neutrality requirements, and the FCC has since deregulated additional services that may not be entirely IP-based. To the extent that consumers submit complaints to the FCC regarding VoIP and IP-enabled services, it is unclear what kind of remedy consumers can obtain since the FCC has adopted an order limiting its own ability to establish requirements for these services.
Consumer complaints exist, but the analysis is incomplete. This bill addresses a gap in information regarding consumer complaints for VoIP by requiring the CPUC to report to the Legislature and Attorney General on complaints it receives regarding VoIP services and requiring the CPUC to forward those complaints to the Attorney General.
In a 2017 report on the status of state-level oversight of telecommunication, researchers from the National Regulatory Research Institute identified areas for states to focus their efforts in the face of VoIP deregulation and the transition to broadband communication networks. The report recommended focusing on the following steps:
- Gaining customer-driven insights such as crowd sourcing information to track service accessibility and reliability.
- Broadening outage reporting.
- Collect and evaluate consumer complaints.
The CPUC operates the Broadband Map, which includes an opportunity to gain crowdsourced information on broadband reliability and accessibility. Additional bills pending in the Legislature broaden outage reporting. However, increasing access to customer complaint data and establishing mechanisms to resolve these complaints has not been addressed at this time.
While the CPUC has not reported on customer complaints specific to VoIP, the CPUC’s Customer Affairs Branch regularly reports on customer complaints received by the CPUC. These reports are broken down by utility sector and month and they include a discussion of the nature of the reports. The chart below shows the number of complaints received by the CPUC between November 2018 and January 2019 for the energy, communications, and water utilities regulated by the CPUC.
November 2018 | December 2018 | January 2019 | |
Energy | 687 | 661 | 677 |
Communications | 904 | 974 | 1,087 |
Water | 39 | 39 | 53 |
Despite the occurrence of wildfires in which utility infrastructure was implicated, complaints regarding energy utilities remained largely consistent between November 2018 and January 2019. In January 2019, the energy utilities regulated by the CPUC generated a total of 677 complaints and 49 (approximately seven percent) of these complaints were classified as pertaining to issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. During the same month, the telecommunications sector generated 1,087 consumer complaints, and 205 (approximately 19 percent) of those complaints were classified as issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. This data indicates that the communications sector generates a greater number of complaints to the CPUC than other utility sectors on average, and a much greater percentage of those complaints are for customer issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction.
It is likely that VoIP and IP-enabled services would be classified as issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction; however, the CPUC does not currently identify which complaints may be related to VoIP. The CPUC data on VoIP customer complaints does not include information regarding the extent to which complaints are resolved and whether those resolutions are timely. This bill would require the CPUC to report on VoIP complaints, outcomes of those complaints, and the timeliness of those outcomes to ensure that the Legislature has sufficient information on consumer issues regarding VoIP when considering policy changes in the future.
Ensuring sufficient authority over 911. Recent conflicts over the implementation of NG 911 indicate that different interpretations of existing law regarding OES’s authority over NG 911 exist. Existing law within the Warren 911 Act requires OES to develop a plan and timeline for the testing, implementation and operation of NG 911 system. In April 2019, OES released a competitive request for proposal (RFP) to obtain bids for a NG 911 provider. The RFP specifies that bidders must submit tariffs, which are agreements that stipulate the terms, conditions, and prices for which services are provided. Generally, tariffs are filed with the CPUC, and the CPUC has historically required tariffs for 911 service.
Several telecommunications companies have objected to the inclusion of a tariff in the NG 911 contract because they claim that tariffs are unnecessary for a competitively bid contract and the contract can include terms, conditions, and price disclosures without a tariff. As a complaint to the RFP, AT&T submitted a petition in California Superior Court requesting the following:
- A writ of mandate requiring OES to withdraw the current NG 911 RFP and specifying that any new RFP must not include a tariff or “not to exceed” provisions that prohibits costs from exceeding a certain level. The request also requests that any “not to exceed” cap include information specifying how the amount is calculated and related to the scope of the RFP.
- A declaration exempting AT&T from the NG 911 tariff and that the “not to exceed” provisions of the contract are unenforceable.
- An injunction preventing the implementation of the RFP.
- Other legal remedies.
Carriers claim that the tariff, cost restrictions, and certain price disclosures constitute regulation prohibited by Public Utilities Code §710, regardless of the 911 exemption in statute. The Attorney General’s argument in response notes that 911 services are critical needs that require tariffs as a means of ensuring that services are provided in a manner consistent with established requirements because contracts for 911 services cannot be terminated in the event that a party breaches its terms. Since NG 911 services are provided over a largely unregulated network, the tariffs and price caps are likely some of the only enforcement mechanisms available to ensure that costs are competitive, prevent unreasonable charges, and ensure that the system is established and maintained properly. Effective maintenance of the system is critical for relaying 911 calls and protecting the system from hazards that could endanger the 911 system, including cyberattacks. While there may be mechanisms for OES to obtain price disclosures from bidders through the contracting process, it is unclear how OES would enforce those prices or verify that they are accurate without some additional enforcement mechanism. This bill clarifies OES’s authority to establish requirements for the NG 911 system, including requiring tariffs for any winning bidder to NG 911 RFP. The bill specifies that OES may direct the CPUC to implement tariffs adopted as requirements for the NG 911 contract; however, the bill does not require a telecommunications provider that is not a party to the RFP to submit a tariff. Under the bill, the authority of OES to administer 911 emergency communications and establish requirements for the NG 911 system are exempt from this bill’s prohibitions on state authority over VoIP and IP-based communications.
The law of unintended consequences. Existing law and this bill contain broad prohibitions against regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services with narrow exemptions. The deregulation of VoIP has had a variety of unintended consequences for privacy, civil rights, and portions of law that have not been substantially updated since IP-enabled telecommunications have become the dominant form of communications services.
Following the catastrophic wildfires of 2017, the CPUC adopted several resolutions requiring energy utilities and certain telecommunications providers to implement certain consumer protections in the affected communities. In July 2018, the CPUC moved to extend these protections until permanent rules for consumers affected by catastrophic disasters could be adopted. The CPUC’s 2018 decision applied to COLRs and “residential communications companies.” In response to stakeholder comments, the CPUC clarified that “residential communications companies” includes facilities-based interconnected VoIP providers. While many telecommunications providers already provide some of the consumer relief that the CPUC required as part of its decision, a coalition of VoIP providers objected to the decision. In filings to the CPUC, the coalition stated that Public Utilities Code §710 prohibited the CPUC from requiring these telecommunications providers to comply with these protections. Some of the protections may help limit the degree to which consumers are billed for services that can only be delivered at addresses from which they have been evacuated and may not re-enter for an extended period of time. A number of IP-based services are established on contracts that last for at least a year and include early termination fees. News reports following the 2017 North Bay fires indicate that some telecommunications continued billing accounts for individuals that lost their lives in the fire. While these billing issues may have been errors, effective customer relief protocol may help prevent these errors in the future.
In a recent San Francisco Superior Court decision for Gruber v. Yelp, a judge ruled that the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) does not apply to VoIP calls. While the judge did not specifically cite a specific bill or statute, the judge concurred with the argument that since the CPUC does not regulate VoIP, and VoIP cannot be considered a cordless, cellular, landline phone, it cannot be treated as one of the technologies to which CIPA expressly applies.
In 2013, the Obama FCC took action to cap prison inmate calling costs following a class action lawsuit initiated by Martha Wright-Reed, the grandmother of an Arizona prison inmate. Wright-Reed sought the lawsuit after paying approximately $100 a month to call her grandson through an inmate calling service. A 2017 federal appellate court decision determined that the FCC had overstepped its authority to establish price caps on in-state calls. The Trump FCC abandoned attempts to appeal the decision and has declined to enforce caps on in-state calls transacted through an inmate calling system. Studies indicate that in-state calls comprise approximately 92 percent of all inmate calling system calls. Inmate calling systems do not exist in a competitive environment and the price terms are entirely controlled by the prison and the service contractors. A number of California inmate calling systems are strictly VoIP providers. Prison authorities can be prohibited from taking a cut of inmate calling system contracts and are authorized to establish contracts that limit inmate calling costs. However, under this bill, government agencies may be limited in their ability to exercise regulatory authority over VoIP inmate calling systems, including the establishment of price caps.
NOTE: [For more background on this bill, please see the Senate Energy, Utilities & Communications Committee analysis.]
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 822 (Weiner, Chapter 976, Statutes of 2018) established net neutrality requirements in California by prohibiting internet service providers from taking certain actions that interfere with consumers’ ability to lawfully access internet content. The bill prohibited intentionally blocking content, speeding up or slowing down traffic, engaging in paid-prioritization, requiring consideration from edge providers for access to an ISP’s end users, and selectively zero-rating certain content.
AB 2395 (Low, 2016) would have established a process by which telecommunications providers could cease to provide basic telephone service and meet COLR obligations. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1161 (Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) established prohibitions on the regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services in California.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- The Department of Justice estimates costs of $1.2 million in fiscal year 2019-20 and $2.1 million ongoing (Unfair Competition Law Fund) due to new enforcement obligations.
- The CPUC estimates costs of $372,000 ongoing to implement this bill.
100 Black Men of Long Beach Inc.
African American Male Education Network & Development
Alliance for Community Development
Asian Business Association of San Diego
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association
Asian Resources, Inc.
AT&T
Bay Area Council
Black Business Association
Black Women Organized for Political Action Political Action Committee
Boys & Girls Club of the North Valley
Brotherhood Crusade
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Cattlemen’s Association
California Latino Leadership Institute
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Rangeland Trust
California Urban Partnership
California-Hawaii State Conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Center for Fathers and Families
Chambers of Commerce: Black Chamber of Orange County, California Asian Pacific, California Black, California, California Hispanic, Carmel Valley, Chino Valley, Fontana, Fresno Metro Black, Glendale, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater Los Angeles African American, Greater Riverside, Hesperia, Hollywood, Los Angeles Latino, Murrieta/Wildomar, Orange County Hispanic, Pacific Grove, Pasadena, Rancho Cucamonga, Redlands, Sacramento Asian Pacific, Sacramento Black, Sacramento Hispanic, Slavic-American, Upland, and Victor Valley
Chicano Federation of San Diego County, Inc.
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Women Vital Voices
Computers 2 Kids
Computing Technology Industry Association
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Congress of California Seniors
Consolidated Communications Inc.
Consumer Advocates for RCFE Reform
CTIA
dev/Mission
Disability Action Center
East Oakland Youth Development Center
Fresno Area Hispanic Foundation
Frontier Communications
Frontier Senior Center
Gamma Zeta Boulé Foundation
Greater Ontario Business Council
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Hispanic 100 Policy Committee
Hispanic Foundation of Silicon Valley
Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center
In Biz Latino
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Invest in Women Entrepreneurs Initiative
Janet Goeske Foundation
Kings/Tulare Homeless Alliance
Krimson and Kreme Foundation
Latino Education & Advocacy Days
Lighthouse Counseling and Family Resource Center
MAAC
Macedonia Community Development Corp
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Music Changing Lives
National Diversity Coalition
North San Diego County NAACP
Oasis Center International
Orange County Business Council
Organization of Chinese Americans, East Bay
Organization of Chinese Americans, Greater Sacramento
Oroville Rescue Mission
Partners in College Success
Prancing Ponies Foundation
Riverside National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Roberts Family Development Center
Russian American Media, Inc.
Salvadoran American Leadership & Education Fund
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Oasis
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Barbara Partners in Education
Sentinels of Freedom
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Society for the Blind
South Bay Community Services
TechNet
TELACU
The Arc Butte County
The Fresno Center
The Nonprofit Alliance
The Village Project, Inc.
United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 648
United Women’s Organization
Urban Corps of San Diego County
Verizon
Veterans Association of North County
World Institute on Disability
Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
AARP California
Access Humboldt
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Bay Area Christian Connection
Beth Eden Baptist Church
Broadband Institute of California
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Emerging Technology Fund
California Labor Federation
California Public Utilities Commission
Center on Race, Leadership and Social Justice
Central Coast Broadband Consortium
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
City Heights Community Development Corp
City of Santa Monica
Common Cause
Common Networks
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports
County of Santa Clara
Courage Campaign
Demand Progress
Digital Privacy Alliance
El Concilio of San Mateo County
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Emerging Leaders Program of the Leadership Institute at Allen Temple
Engine
Fight for the Future
Free Press Action
Housing Long Beach
Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Interdenominational Ministerial Alliance
League of California Cities
Media Alliance
MediaJustice
Mendocino County Board of Supervisors
Mission Asset Fund
Monkeybrains
Mono County Board of Supervisors
Mono County Sheriff’s Office
National Consumer Law Center
New America’s Open Technology Institute
New Media Rights
North Bay North Coast Broadband Consortium
Oakland Privacy
Omsoft and Davis Community Network
One Million New Internet Users
Poverello House
Prison Policy Initiative
Public Advocates Office (formerly Office of Ratepayer Advocates)
Public Citizen, Inc.
Public Knowledge
San Joaquin Valley Regional Broadband Consortium
Santa Clara County Fire Department
Southern Border Broadband Consortium
Southern California Tribal Digital Village Network
The Center for Media Justice
The Greenlining Institute
The Herald Fire Protection District
The Last Trump of Zion
The Utility Reform Network
True Faith Community Baptist Church
United Church of Christ, OC Inc.
Utility Consumers’ Action Network
Several Hundred Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
The Legislature has granted the CPUC and other agencies authority over VoIP and IP-enabled services in some circumstances- such as requiring payment of fees for 911 service and state universal service programs, adopting consumer education requirements related to backup power, and obtaining specific data from VoIP providers. These regulations of the industry are necessary for both consumer protection and public safety.
However, for issues that have been identified as in need of regulation with VoIP- and IP-enabled services, it is obvious that the Legislature is best poised to act. For instance, from the time the CPUC directed staff to add new smartphone technology to the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program, it has been 9 years and the rule-making process is still not finalized. These delays can mean consumers lose out on the benefits of technological innovation or expanded services, such as Lifeline program savings for cellphone service.
AB 1366 would extend the sunset of provisions prohibiting state regulation of VoIP and IP enabled services except as specified by the Legislature for another 10 years, as well as put in place new customer protections regarding service restoration and disclosures. This would allow for continued legislative action on issues that may arise, particularly regarding consumer protection and public safety, while still allowing these services regulatory clarity.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents claim that the continued deregulation of VoIP will result in fewer consumer protections for the majority of Californians because VoIP lines now exceed traditional telephone lines. Opponents also argue that this bill goes beyond prohibiting CPUC regulation of VoIP by prohibiting any governmental entity’s exercise of duty over VoIP and IP-based services, including the collection of data necessary for effectively deploying broadband in underserved communities. Opponents also claim that the current regulatory environment at the federal level necessitates more state oversight on telecommunications issues, which includes the resolution of safety and customer service concerns. In opposition, the Communication Workers of America (CWA) state:
Our workers are on the frontlines and hear directly from consumers about their problems with telephone services, without the ability to have a state commission or entity address these concerns. Our members also witness safety issues with phone lines that are exacerbated by the lack of proper oversight or regulation due to the passage of AB 1161. CWA has long supported policies that protect consumers and hold telecommunications service providers accountable for their infrastructure and service. AB 1366 would further entrench all the issues that SB 1161 caused by extending its provisions until 2030. As customers continue to be switched from traditional phone service to VoIP, a growing majority of Californians will lose the protections they previously enjoyed and still deserve.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-6, 5/29/19
AYES: Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Rendon
NOES: Levine, Muratsuchi, Ramos, Mark Stone, Wicks, Wood
NO VOTE RECORDED: Aguiar-Curry, Bloom, Chu, Cooley, Dahle, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Kalra, Reyes, Ting
Prepared by: Sarah Smith / E., U., & C. / (916) 651-4107
9/1/19 9:56:45
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1366 (Gonzalez) - Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled communications services
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would extend the sunset date on prohibitions against the regulation of Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and other internet protocol (IP) enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2030.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) estimates costs of $1.2 million in fiscal year 2019-20 and $2.1 million ongoing (Unfair Competition Law Fund) due to new enforcement obligations.
- The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) estimates costs of $372,000 ongoing to implement this bill.
Background:
VoIP is a telecommunications technology that transfers calls as data packets over an internet connection. VoIP may initiate a call over the internet; however, it can also carry and complete calls over the traditional copper network. VoIP services may be provided with a fixed or mobile connection. Generally, fixed VoIP products are offered by internet service providers (ISPs) in lieu of a traditional telephone connection. Mobile VoIP generally provides voice service through an application downloaded to a device, including wireless devices. Fixed VoIP products more closely resemble traditional home phone service, and IP-enabled services are any services delivered over an internet network. This bill restricts the state from regulating VoIP and any IP-enabled service.
When legislation establishing VoIP and IP-based regulatory prohibitions (SB 1161, Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) passed the Legislature, most telephone lines were wireline service. However, data from the FCC shows that in 2016, the number of VoIP lines exceeded the number of regulated wireline telephone lines. At current rates of VoIP adoption, VoIP may comprise up to 94 percent of all home telephone lines. With the expansion of other IP-enabled communications, most telephone services are now IP-based services. Additionally, in 2012, the FCC played a more active role in regulating IP-based telecommunications. Since the enactment SB 1161 in 2012, the FCC has largely deregulated IP-based communications at the federal level and at least 35 other states have also adopted laws limiting the regulation of IP-based telecommunications. As a result, most telecommunications have limited federal and state regulation.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Extend the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2030.
- Extend the existing limitations on state regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services by prohibiting the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services except in accordance with the following:
- As required or expressly delegated by federal law.
- As expressly directed by statute or pursuant to exemptions established in this bill.
- As expressly and specifically directed by the Legislature in the interest of public safety or consumer protection.
- Add the following to the list of exemptions to the prohibition on state regulation of VoIP:
- Federal outage reporting requirements for facilities based VoIP service providers, and
- Lifeline Program requirements as established in CPUC Decision 16-01-039, which allowed fixed location VoIP providers to participate in the program.
- Specify that nothing in this bill limits the Attorney General or other applicable entity from enforcing state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, federal enhanced 911 requirements, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Require the CPUC to annually report the number of type of consumer complaints it receives regarding VoIP service to the Attorney General and the Legislature.
- Require providers of residential interconnected VoIP service to disclose any backup power requirements in state and federal law to each new customer. The disclosure must notify a customer that the customer may contact the CPUC for additional information about alternative communications services, including basic telephone service.
- Require residential interconnected VoIP service providers to update their terms of service to state that the provider will offer a bill credit for outages lasting longer than 24 hours upon request. This credit does not apply to outages on Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Require residential interconnected VoIP service providers to start restoring service within 24 hours or receiving an outage report and restore service within 72 hours of receiving the report. This service restoration period does not apply to Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Define “circumstances beyond the provider’s control” as any of the following:
- Electrical outages
- Catastrophic events
- Natural disasters
- Emergencies proclaimed by the governor
- Cable theft
- Third-party cable cuts
- A lack of access to the premises
- Absence of customer support to test the facilities
- Any other circumstance.
- Exempt any residential interconnected VoIP provider from the bill credit and service restoration requirements if the provider is subject to any other law or regulation regarding outage response or service restoration.
Staff Comments:
According to the DOJ, the Consumer Law Section within DOJ’s Public Rights Division anticipates an increase in workload due to new enforcement obligations imposed by AB 1366, which would require the CPUC to report VoIP-related consumer complaints to the Attorney General. AB 1366 would add provisions to the Business and Professions Code, related to VoIP service outages, that expands the Section’s purview in enforcing Unfair Competition Laws. In order to address the additional workload, the Section would require 1.0 additional Supervising Deputy Attorney General (SDAG), 3.0 Deputy Attorneys General (DAG), 2.0 Associate Governmental Program Analysts, the legal complement of 3.0 Legal Secretaries, and an additional $300,000 annually for legal expert witness fees, beginning in FY 2019-20 and ongoing. This bill would have an impact on the Unfair Competition Law Fund.
According to the CPUC, AB 1366 would direct the CPUC to address backup power requirements for service providers. With catastrophic wildfires ravaging the state over the past two years, there is increased scrutiny by the public, legislators, and first responder community on improving resiliency for communication provider networks. This includes:
- Coordinating with the CalOES and the CPUC Office of the Safety Advocate (OSA) to research backup power standards, such as those developed by the FCC’s Network Reliability and Interoperability Council.
- Determining updated performance criteria for backup power systems.
- Developing and implementing updated standards for backup power.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 7/10/2019
Author: | |||
Version: | As Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill extends the sunset date on prohibitions against the regulation of Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and other internet protocol (IP) enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2030.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to fix rates, establish rules, examine records, issue subpoenas, administer oaths, take testimony, punish for contempt, and prescribe a uniform system of accounts for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution, Article XII, §6)
- Defines the term “public utility” and includes common carriers in the definition of a public utility. (Public Utilities Code §216)
- Defines VoIP as a communications service that does all the following:
- Uses an IP system to enable real-time, two-way voice communication;
- Requires a broadband connection from the user’s location; and,
- Allows a user to receive and terminate a call over the public switched telephone network.
A service that uses ordinary equipment with no enhanced functionality and does not undergo an IP conversion process is not a VoIP service. (Public Utilities Code §239(a))
- Defines an IP enabled service as any service, capability, function, or application using an IP system to send or receive communication through a broadband connection, regardless of whether the communication is voice, data, or video. (Public Utilities Code §239(b))
- Gives the CPUC the authority to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state and do all things necessary and convenient in the exercise of such power and jurisdiction. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Prohibits until January 1, 2020, the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services unless required or expressly delegated by state or federal law. Any delegation or express requirement does not expand the jurisdiction of the CPUC, department, agency, or subdivision beyond the scope of that requirement or delegation. (Public Utilities Code §710 (a-b))
- Exempts the following from the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-based services:
- The collection of surcharges to fund basic 911 service and the state’s universal service programs.
- Cable franchising duties specified in the Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act (DIVCA).
- The CPUC’s authority to implement and enforce interconnection and arbitration requirements for telecommunications providers classified as common carriers pursuant to Title II of the Federal Communications Act of 1934.
- The CPUC’s authority to make data requests regarding market competition proceedings at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
- The CPUC’s authority to address disputes between carriers regarding compensation for the exchange of traffic over an IP network.
- The CPUC’s authority to enforce requirements in CPUC Decision 10-01-026 regarding consumer education programs about the availability and limitations of backup power for VoIP systems.
- The CPUC’s authority to address pole attachment disputes.
- The Warren 911 Emergency Assistance Act. (Public Utilities Code §710 (c))
- Specifies that the restrictions on government regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services does not affect the following:
- Enforcement of state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Existing regulation, proceedings, or existing CPUC authority over non-IP wireline and wireless service, including universal, basic, and lifeline service requirements.
- The CPUC’s ability to monitor and discuss VoIP services, track and report to the FCC and Legislature.
- The CPUC’s authority to report to the Legislature annually on the number and types of complaints received by the CPUC from VoIP customers and respond informally to complaints with information about potential remedies under state and federal law.
- The establishment and enforcement of policies regarding intellectual property protection.
This bill:
- Would extend the prohibition on regulating VoIP and IP-enabled services from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2030.
- Extends the existing limitations on state regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services by prohibiting the CPUC and any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory authority over VoIP and IP enabled services except in accordance with the following:
- As required or expressly delegated by federal law.
- As expressly directed by statute or pursuant to exemptions established in this bill.
- As expressly and specifically directed by the Legislature in the interest of public safety or consumer protection.
- Adds the following to the list of exemptions to the prohibition on state regulation of VoIP:
- Federal outage reporting requirements for facilities based VoIP service providers, and
- Lifeline Program requirements as established in CPUC Decision 16-01-039, which allowed fixed location VoIP providers to participate in the program.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill limits the Attorney General or other applicable entity from enforcing state or federal criminal or civil law or any local ordinances of general applicability, including, but not limited to: consumer protection and unfair business or deceptive trade practice laws and ordinances, California Environmental Quality Act requirements, local utility user taxes, federal enhanced 911 requirements, and laws regarding public rights of way.
- Requires the CPUC to annually report the number of type of consumer complaints it receives regarding VoIP service to the Attorney General and the Legislature.
- Requires providers of residential interconnected VoIP service to disclose any backup power requirements in state and federal law to each new customer. The disclosure must notify a customer that the customer may contact the CPUC for additional information about alternative communications services, including basic telephone service.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to update their terms of service to state that the provider will offer a bill credit for outages lasting longer than 24 hours upon request. This credit does not apply to outages on Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Requires residential interconnected VoIP service providers to start restoring service within 24 hours or receiving an outage report and restore service within 72 hours of receiving the report. This service restoration period does not apply to Sundays, federal holidays, or outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control.
- Defines “circumstances beyond the provider’s control” as any of the following:
- Electrical outages
- Catastrophic events
- Natural disasters
- Emergencies proclaimed by the governor
- Cable theft
- Third-party cable cuts
- A lack of access to the premises
- Absence of customer support to test the facilities
- Any other circumstance.
- Exempts any residential interconnected VoIP provider from the bill credit and service restoration requirements if the provider is subject to any other law or regulation regarding outage response or service restoration.
Background
What are VoIP and IP-enabled services? VoIP is a telecommunications technology that transfers calls as data packets over an internet connection. VoIP may initiate a call over the internet; however, it can also carry and complete calls over the traditional copper network. VoIP services may be provided with a fixed or mobile connection. Generally, fixed VoIP products are offered by internet service providers (ISPs) in lieu of a traditional telephone connection. Mobile VoIP generally provides voice service through an application downloaded to a device, including wireless devices. Fixed VoIP products more closely resemble traditional home phone service, and IP-enabled services are any services delivered over an internet network. This bill restricts the state from regulating VoIP and any IP-enabled service.
A brief history of the deregulation of the telecommunications sector. This bill extends current deregulation of internet-based telecommunications from 2020 to 2030. This bill applies to VoIP and all other IP-based services, which may include any service delivered over the internet. Deregulation of the telecommunications sector has ebbed and flowed in California since 1995. During the 1990s, federal and state governments initiated a number of market changes to increase competition and reduce regulations for the telecommunications sector. The CPUC issued a decision opening California’s local exchanges to competition between companies in 1995. Prior to this decision, local telephone service was generally provided by one telephone utility in each service territory. Federal and state agencies opened telephone service territories and lowered regulatory barriers with the intention of encouraging competition, which agencies hoped would lead to lower prices and higher investment in advanced telecommunications services, including broadband internet. While some communities benefited from increased competition, deregulation also led some telecommunications companies to accrue a significant amount of debt and engage in unsustainable expansion. By the end of 2001, multiple telecommunications providers initiated bankruptcy proceedings and
subsequently ceased operations. Several of these bankruptcies remain among the largest bankruptcies in United States history.
Changes since 2012. When legislation establishing VoIP and IP-based regulatory prohibitions (SB 1161, Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) passed the Legislature, most telephone lines were wireline service. However, data from the FCC shows that in 2016, the number of VoIP lines exceeded the number of regulated wireline telephone lines. At current rates of VoIP adoption, VoIP may comprise up to 94 percent of all home telephone lines. With the expansion of other IP-enabled communications, most telephone services are now IP-based services. Additionally, in 2012, the FCC played a more active role in regulating IP-based telecommunications. Since the enactment SB 1161 in 2012, the FCC has largely deregulated IP-based communications at the federal level and at least 35 other states have also adopted laws limiting the regulation of IP-based telecommunications. As a result, most telecommunications have limited federal and state regulation.
COLR = POLR. This bill has implications for basic telephone service in the event that wireline retirement and VoIP adoption continue at current rates. Both the electricity and telecommunications sectors have requirements that ensure that an entity exists to provide customers with service in the event that other providers either cannot or will not serve those customers. In the electricity sector, these requirements establish provider of last resort (POLR) duties. In the telecommunications sector, these requirements are known as carrier of last resort (COLR) duties. In 1996, the CPUC adopted COLR requirements through D. 96-10-066 to ensure that consumers always have a provider of last resort to supply basic telephone service as competition between carriers increased and oversight decreased. The CPUC’s COLR requirements are technology neutral; a COLR can provide basic telephone service through wireline telephone service or other technologies, including VoIP. COLR duties are generally less extensive than POLR requirements because they do not require the provider to supply all telecommunications services in the event that no other party exists. Instead, COLRs only have to provide basic telephone service, which does not include internet or cable services. Companies that only provide IP-enabled services generally are not considered COLRs. Unlike investor-owned utilities that provide POLR services, providers that operate as COLRs are not necessarily regulated in any other area beyond their COLR service.
This bill extends limitations on service quality oversight. COLR service is considered a “basic service” under the CPUC’s decision, and it is subject CPUC regulatory oversight to ensure that the service is sufficient. The CPUC has established these requirements and metrics for determining whether a provider meets basic service quality requirements through General Order 133-D (GO 133D). These metrics include information about the rate of customer service requests, the speed at which those requests are resolved, outage rates, service restoration rates, and installation speed. To obtain sufficient information to evaluate these metrics, the CPUC requires carriers to report customer service information on a regular basis. Companies that do not meet service quality requirements for basic telephone service can be fined based on the rate of violations. In lieu of paying fines, service quality violators may be permitted to re-invest the funds in services that remediate the service quality issues. Several companies that operate both traditional phone service and VoIP have received fines for failing to meet service quality standards with their traditional telephone service.
COLR and service quality requirements are established by the CPUC through its regulatory jurisdiction, and neither of these requirements are expressly established in statute. The creation and enforcement of both are the result of regulatory action and interpretation. This bill prohibits the CPUC from exercising any regulatory jurisdiction over VoIP and IP-enabled telecommunications unless an exemption to this prohibition is expressly stated. To the extent that this bill prohibits the CPUC from using its general regulatory powers to enforce requirements on VoIP and IP-enabled telecommunications, this bill may lead to a lack of clarity about the CPUC’s authority to enforce COLR and basic service requirements. At this time, no carrier is providing basic service through VoIP. However, if 94 percent of telephone lines become VoIP or IP-based by this bill’s 2030 sunset date, it is likely that at least some carriers will IP-based technology to meet COLR obligations. Under existing law, the CPUC is prohibited from requesting certain customer service data, establishing service quality metrics, or enforcing service quality requirements for VoIP or IP-enabled telecommunications unless the carrier is using VoIP to meet basic service obligations. Some carriers assert that the CPUC’s basic service requirement would apply to any COLR using VoIP as a basic service. However, carriers generally also assert that existing law and this bill would prohibit the CPUC from establishing service quality standards for VoIP broadly. Since limited public information exists about VoIP’s service quality, it is difficult to evaluate its performance against other communication technologies. Existing law and this bill may not sufficiently provide the CPUC with the authority to ensure that basic service and COLR requirements are established and enforced in a technology neutral manner.
Remedies for consumers remain limited under this bill. This bill extends limitations on the CPUC’s ability to formally address consumer complaints through administrative actions, including the ability to request data regarding customer complaints from the telecommunications providers. While most of this bill relies on the FCC and litigation to enforce consumer protections, it is not clear that consumers can currently rely on the FCC and individual litigation to remedy their concerns, including unfair business practices. In the 2011 case AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, the United States Supreme Court determined that California statutes prohibiting the use of coercive clauses are pre-empted by the Federal Arbitration Act. Many companies, including telecommunications providers, include arbitration clauses in their contracts that limit a consumer’s ability to form a class with other consumers to seek remedies for unfair business practices related to contracts. These clauses frequently limit consumers to a specified arbitration process, which may limit their remedies to individual small claims proceedings.
Prior to the enactment of SB 1161, the Obama FCC took a number of steps to exercise more oversight on IP-enabled services. Between 2010 and 2015, the Obama FCC also adopted two orders to establish net neutrality requirements, which included re-classifying IP-based telecommunications as common carriers. This reclassification provided the FCC with much greater authority to enforce requirements on IP-based services and regulate those services in a manner similar to other telecommunications utilities. However, in 2017, the Trump FCC reversed the FCC’s net neutrality requirements, and the FCC has since deregulated additional services that may not be entirely IP-based. To the extent that consumers submit complaints to the FCC regarding VoIP and IP-enabled services, it is unclear what kind of remedy consumers can obtain since the FCC has adopted an order limiting its own ability to establish requirements for these services.
Consumer complaints exist, but the analysis is incomplete. In a 2017 report on the status of state-level oversight of telecommunication, researchers from the National Regulatory Research Institute identified areas for states to focus their efforts in the face of VoIP deregulation and the transition to broadband communication networks. The report recommended focusing on the following steps:
- Gaining customer-driven insights such as crowd sourcing information to track service accessibility and reliability.
- Broadening outage reporting.
- Collect and evaluate consumer complaints.
The CPUC operates the Broadband Map, which includes an opportunity to gain crowdsourced information on broadband reliability and accessibility. Additional bills pending in the Legislature broaden outage reporting. However, increasing access to customer complaint data and establishing mechanisms to resolve these complaints has not been addressed at this time.
While the CPUC has not reported on customer complaints specific to VoIP, the CPUC’s Customer Affairs Branch regularly reports on customer complaints received by the CPUC. These reports are broken down by utility sector and month and they include a discussion of the nature of the reports. The chart below shows the number of complaints received by the CPUC between November 2018 and January 2019 for the energy, communications, and water utilities regulated by the CPUC.
November 2018 | December 2018 | January 2019 | |
Energy | 687 | 661 | 677 |
Communications | 904 | 974 | 1,087 |
Water | 39 | 39 | 53 |
Despite the occurrence of wildfires in which utility infrastructure was implicated, complaints regarding energy utilities remained largely consistent between November 2018 and January 2019. In January 2019, the energy utilities regulated by the CPUC generated a total of 677 complaints and 49 (approximately seven percent) of these complaints were classified as pertaining to issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. During the same month, the telecommunications sector generated 1,087 consumer complaints, and 205 (approximately 19 percent) of those complaints were classified as issues over which the CPUC does not have regulatory jurisdiction. This data indicates that the communications sector generates a greater number of complaints to the CPUC than other utility sectors on average, and a much greater percentage of those complaints are for customer issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction.
It is likely that VoIP and IP-enabled services would be classified as issues over which the CPUC has no regulatory jurisdiction. However, additional data on informal complaints indicates that service quality is a significant portion of complaints. A portion of the total number of complaints are classified as “informal complaints,” which the CPUC sends to the telecommunications provider for follow-up. In January 2019, the CPUC reported 291 informal complaints to telecommunications providers. Approximately one third of these 291 complaints were classified as service quality issues. For some companies with larger complaint volumes, service quality comprised almost half of their informal complaints. The CPUC data on VoIP customer complaints does not include information regarding the extent to which complaints are resolved and whether those resolutions are timely.
This bill’s 911 exemption may not cover all 911 duties. This bill continues to exempt the Warren 911 Act from prohibitions on government regulation of VoIP; however, recent conflicts over the implementation of Next Generation 911 (NG 911) indicate that different interpretations of the exemption exist. NG 911 is intended to update the 911 system to accommodate communications delivered over an IP network, including text-to-911. Existing law within the Warren 911 Act requires the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to develop a plan and timeline for the testing, implementation and operation of NG 911 system. In April 2019, OES released a request for proposal (RFP) to obtain bids for a NG 911 provider. The RFP specifies that bidders must submit tariffs, which are agreements that stipulate the terms, conditions, and prices for which services are provided. Generally, tariffs are filed with the CPUC, and the CPUC has historically required tariffs for 911 service.
Several telecommunications companies have objected to the inclusion of a tariff in the NG 911 contract because they claim that tariffs are unnecessary for a competitively bid contract and the contract can include terms, conditions, and price disclosures without a tariff. As a complaint to the RFP, AT&T submitted a petition in California Superior Court requesting the following:
- A writ of mandate requiring OES to withdraw the current NG 911 RFP and specifying that any new RFP must not include a tariff or “not to exceed” provisions that prohibits costs from exceeding a certain level. The request also requests that any “not to exceed” cap include information specifying how the amount is calculated and related to the scope of the RFP.
- A declaration exempting AT&T from the NG 911 tariff and that the “not to exceed” provisions of the contract are unenforceable.
- An injunction preventing the implementation of the RFP.
- Other legal remedies.
Carriers claim that the tariff, cost restrictions, and certain price disclosures constitute regulation prohibited by Public Utilities Code §710 and this bill, regardless of the 911 exemption in statute. According to carriers, even if the tariff is required by OES as part of the NG 911 contract, the tariff implies that the CPUC would have a regulatory authority that is prohibited by this bill. The Attorney General has responded on behalf of the state with OES, and the lawsuit is still pending.
The Attorney General’s argument in response notes that 911 services are critical needs that require tariffs as a means of ensuring that services are provided in a manner consistent with established requirements because contracts for 911 services cannot be terminated in the event that a party breaches its terms. Since NG 911 services are provided over a largely unregulated network, the tariffs and price caps are likely some of the only enforcement mechanisms available to ensure that costs are competitive, prevent unreasonable charges, and ensure that the system is established and maintained properly. Effective maintenance of the system is critical for relaying 911 calls and protecting the system from hazards that could endanger the 911 system, including cyberattacks. While there may be mechanisms for OES to obtain price disclosures from bidders through the contracting process, it is unclear how OES would enforce those prices or verify that they are accurate without some additional enforcement mechanism.
The Legislature as regulator. This bill establishes the Legislature as the primary body for creating requirements for VoIP and IP-based telecommunications. The bill also delegates consumer protection enforcement to the Legislature and Attorney General by prohibiting agencies from requesting consumer complaint information and taking actions against VoIP and IP-based providers to remedy complaints. This bill permits the CPUC to receive complaints from customers, informally respond to those complaints, and provide customers who submit complaints with information about their options for addressing those complaints under federal and state law. However, this bill prohibits the CPUC from taking any action against a telecommunications provider to remedy consumer complaints.
While this bill requires the CPUC to submit an annual report to the Legislature and Attorney General regarding the complaints it receives about VoIP service from VoIP customers, the Legislature and Attorney General do not have any mechanism for resolving those complaints outside of legislation or litigation. It is also unclear how these complaints could be resolved in a timely manner if they are only reported on an annual basis and how the Legislature or Attorney General could remedy complaints outside a litigation process.
Even as this bill implies that it allows the Legislature to set policy for VoIP and IP-services, its provisions may impact bills currently pending in the Legislature. For example, this bill provides an exemption to the limits on CPUC’s regulatory action for requirements for any VoIP provider voluntarily participating in the Lifeline universal service program. However, it specifies that the CPUC can only exercise its authority based on requirements already established in a 2016 decision. As a result, the CPUC may be limited in its ability to establish program requirements to implement any bill modifying the Lifeline program for VoIP or IP-based services.
The bill’s backup power, service restoration, and bill credit provisions are largely unenforceable. This bill contains provisions that establish some requirements for backup power notifications, service restoration, and customer bill credits that appear to be based on requirements established by the CPUC in regulatory proceedings regarding service quality. However, this bill places these provisions in a portion of the Business and Professions Code over which no board at the Department of Consumer Affairs has oversight. As a result, these provisions may only be enforced by the Attorney General. These provisions also contain a number of exemptions and enforcement restrictions that make them largely unenforceable.
This bill requires providers of residential interconnected VoIP service to provide their customers with information about backup power; however, it does not require the provision of backup power and only allows the CPUC to enforce backup power customer notification requirements established approximately 10 years ago.
This bill also requires these providers to start restoring service within 24 hours of receiving an outage, restore service within 72 hours of the report, and update their terms of service to offer bill credits for outages lasting longer than 24 hours. However, these requirements do not apply to outages resulting from circumstances beyond the provider’s control, which is broadly defined, and may include any circumstance. This bill also exempts any residential interconnected VoIP provider from the service restoration and bill credit requirements if the provider is subject to any law or regulation related to outage response or repair time. While this exemption may be intended to prevent duplicate reporting requirements, it also could exempt all residential interconnected VoIP and IP-based service providers from the service restoration and bill credit requirements because the FCC has established regulations requiring VoIP and broadband providers to submit major outage notifications to the FCC.
The law of unintended consequences. Existing law and this bill contain broad prohibitions against regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services with narrow exemptions. The deregulation of VoIP has had a variety of unintended consequences for privacy, civil rights, and portions of law that have not been substantially updated since IP-enabled telecommunications have become the dominant form of communications services.
Following the catastrophic wildfires of 2017, the CPUC adopted several resolutions requiring energy utilities and certain telecommunications providers to implement certain consumer protections in the affected communities. In July 2018, the CPUC moved to extend these protections until permanent rules for consumers affected by catastrophic disasters could be adopted. The CPUC’s 2018 decision applied to COLRs and “residential communications companies.” In response to stakeholder comments, the CPUC clarified that “residential communications companies” includes facilities-based interconnected VoIP providers. While many telecommunications providers already provide some of the consumer relief that the CPUC required as part of its decision, a coalition of VoIP providers objected to the decision. In filings to the CPUC, the coalition stated that Public Utilities Code §710 prohibited the CPUC from requiring these telecommunications providers to comply with these protections. Some of the protections may help limit the degree to which consumers are billed for services that can only be delivered at addresses from which they have been evacuated and may not re-enter for an extended period of time. A number of IP-based services are established on contracts that last for at least a year and include early termination fees. News reports following the 2017 North Bay fires indicate that some telecommunications continued billing accounts for individuals that lost their lives in the fire. While these billing issues may have been errors, effective customer relief protocol may help prevent these errors in the future.
In a recent San Francisco Superior Court decision for Gruber v. Yelp, a judge ruled that the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) does not apply to VoIP calls. While the judge did not specifically cite a specific bill or statute, the judge concurred with the argument that since the CPUC does not regulate VoIP, and VoIP cannot be considered a cordless, cellular, landline phone, it cannot be treated as one of the technologies to which CIPA expressly applies.
In 2013, the Obama FCC took action to cap prison inmate calling costs following a class action lawsuit initiated by Martha Wright-Reed, the grandmother of an Arizona prison inmate. Wright-Reed sought the lawsuit after paying approximately $100 a month to call her son through an inmate calling service. A 2017 federal appellate court decision determined that the FCC had overstepped its authority to establish price caps on in-state calls. The Trump FCC abandoned attempts to appeal the decision and has declined to enforce caps on in-state calls transacted through an inmate calling system. Studies indicate that in-state calls comprise approximately 92 percent of all inmate calling system calls. Inmate calling systems do not exist in a competitive environment and the price terms are entirely controlled by the prison and the service contractors. A number of California inmate calling systems are strictly VoIP providers. Prison authorities can be prohibited from taking a cut of inmate calling system contracts and are authorized to establish contracts that limit inmate calling costs. However, under this bill, other government agencies in California may be restricted from exercising any authority over VoIP inmate calling systems, including the establishment of price caps.
Need for amendments. As currently drafted, this bill prohibits the CPUC from establishing regulations for VoIP and IP-based services; however, it also codifies CPUC regulations that prevent the CPUC from further refining existing requirements. This bill also appears to imply that the CPUC’s authority to establish COLR and basic service requirements are exempt from the prohibitions on regulatory action; however, this bill’s language regarding the CPUC’s authority to enforce COLR and basic service quality requirements is unclear because it implies that this authority only applies to non-IP telecommunications. This bill also continues the existing exemption for the Warren 911 Act; however, it is not clear whether this exemption is sufficiently broad to ensure that OES has the authority to administer and enforce all 911 services under this bill, including NG 911. Should this committee move this bill forward, the author and this committee may wish to clarify that OES has the authority to administer and enforce all 911 requirements to ensure that OES has sufficient authority to administer and enforce all NG 911 duties. To ensure that the CPUC has sufficient authority to administer and enforce universal service programs, COLR, and basic service requirements, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to eliminate codification of past CPUC decisions and clarify that the CPUC has the authority to set and enforce COLR and basic service requirements on a technology-neutral basis. This bill also includes provisions intended to enable VoIP obtain more information about backup power, provide bill credits for outages, and establish service restoration requirements; however, as currently drafted, these provisions are unenforceable and do not address the lack of specific information about VoIP consumer complaints and resolutions. Should this bill move forward, the author and committee may wish to consider making these requirements enforceable, improving data collection and analysis regarding VoIP and IP-enabled communications, and requiring the CPUC to make specific recommendations to the Legislature and Attorney General based on its analysis.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 822 (Weiner, Chapter 976, Statutes of 2018) established net neutrality requirements in California by prohibiting internet service providers from taking certain actions that interfere with consumers’ ability to lawfully access internet content. The bill prohibited intentionally blocking content, speeding up or slowing down traffic, engaging in paid-prioritization, requiring consideration from edge providers for access to an ISP’s end users, and selectively zero-rating certain content.
AB 2395 (Low, 2016) would have established a process by which telecommunications providers could cease to provide basic telephone service and meet COLR obligations. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1161 (Padilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012) established prohibitions on the regulation of VoIP and IP-enabled services in California.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
100 Black Men of Long Beach Inc.
African American Male Education Network & Development
Alliance for Community Development
Asian Business Association of San Diego
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association
Asian Resources, Inc.
AT&T
Bay Area Council
Black Business Association
Black Chamber of Orange County
Black Women Organized for Political Action Political Action Committee
Boys & Girls Club of the North Valley
Brotherhood Crusade
California Asian Pacific Chamber
California Black Chamber
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Cattlemen’s Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chamber
California Latino Leadership Institute
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Rangeland Trust
California Urban Partnership
Carmel Valley Chamber
Center for Fathers and Families
Chicano Federation of San Diego County, Inc.
Chino Valley Chamber
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Women Vital Voices
Computers 2 Kids
Computing Technology Industry Association
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Congress of California Seniors
Consolidated Communications Inc.
Consumer Advocates for RCFE Reform
CTIA-the wireless industry trade association
dev/Mission
Disability Action Center
East Oakland Youth Development Center
Fontana Chamber
Fresno Area Hispanic Foundation
Fresno Metro Black Chamber
Frontier Communications
Frontier Senior Center
Gamma Zeta Boulé Foundation
Glendale Chamber
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber
Greater Ontario Business Council
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Hesperia Chamber
Hispanic 100 Policy Committee
Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center
In Biz Latino
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Invest in Women Entrepreneurs Initiative
Janet Goeske Foundation
Kings/Tulare Homeless Alliance
Krimson and Kreme Foundation
Latino Education & Advocacy Days
Lighthouse Counseling and Family Resource Center
Los Angeles Latino Chamber
MAAC
Macedonia Community Development Corp
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber
Music Changing Lives
National Diversity Coalition
North San Diego County NAACP
Oasis Center International
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber
Organization of Chinese Americans, East Bay
Organization of Chinese Americans, Greater Sacramento
Oroville Rescue Mission
Pacific Grove Chamber
Partners in College Success
Pasadena Chamber
Prancing Ponies Foundation
Rancho Cucamonga Chamber
Redlands Chamber
Riverside National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Roberts Family Development Center
Russian American Media, Inc.
Sacramento Asian Pacific Chamber
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Hispanic Chamber
Salvadoran American Leadership & Education Fund
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Oasis
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Barbara Partners in Education
Sentinels of Freedom
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Slavic-American Chamber
Society for the Blind
South Bay Community Services
TechNet
TELACU
The Arc Butte County
The Fresno Center
The Nonprofit Alliance
The Village Project, Inc.
United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 648
United Women’s Organization
Upland Chamber
Urban Corps of San Diego County
Verizon
Veterans Association of North County
Victor Valley Chamber
World Institute on Disability
Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
OPPOSITION:
AARP
Access Humboldt
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Bay Area Christian Connection
Beth Eden Baptist Church
Broadband Institute of California
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Emerging Technology Fund
California Labor Federation
California Public Utilities Commission
Center on Race, Leadership and Social Justice
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
City Heights Community Development Corp
Common Cause
Common Networks
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports
County of Santa Clara
Courage Campaign
Demand Progress
Digital Privacy Alliance
El Concilio of San Mateo County
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Emerging Leaders Program of the Leadership Institute at Allen Temple
Engine
Fight for the Future
Free Press Action
Housing Long Beach
Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Interdenominational Ministerial Alliance
Media Alliance
MediaJustice
Mendocino County Board of Supervisors
Mission Asset Fund
Monkeybrains
Mono County Board of Supervisors
Mono County Sheriff’s Office
National Consumer Law Center
New America’s Open Technology Institute
New Media Rights
North Bay North Coast Broadband Consortium
Oakland Privacy
Omsoft and Davis Community Network
One Million New Internet Users
Poverello House
Prison Policy Initiative
Public Advocates Office (formerly Office of Ratepayer Advocates)
Public Citizen, Inc.
Public Knowledge
Santa Clara County Fire Department
Southern California Tribal Digital Village Network
The Center for Media Justice
The Greenlining Institute
The Herald Fire Protection District
The Last Trump of Zion
The Utility Reform Network
True Faith Community Baptist Church
United Church of Christ, OC Inc.
Utility Consumers’ Action Network
Several Hundred Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
In 2012, the Legislature codified a policy of reserving any state regulation of Voice-over Internet Protocol and IP-enabled services for the Legislature. Since then, Californians have continued benefiting from these services.
For business travelers, students abroad, and Californians with family or friends in another country, IP-enabled services are an important part of staying connected without having to pay costly long distance or international telephone bills. While previously many may have relied on navigating complicated phone plans for international calling or purchased expensive international calling cards, now communities with international ties can use free and convenient services like Whatsapp or Skype to stay connected. Consumers and organizations who rely on these services have seen the average price per megabit per second has decreased 90 percent over the last decade.
However, the clarity provided with the Legislature’s exclusive authority over these services will sunset on January 1, 2020 unless legislation extends the provisions. If allowed to sunset without further legislative direction, this will create an environment of regulatory uncertainty and the potential for costly litigation on all sides, possibly delaying further expansion and innovation of these services.
The Legislature has granted the CPUC and other agencies authority over VoIP and IP-enabled services in some circumstances- such as requiring payment of fees for 911 service and state universal service programs, adopting consumer education requirements related to backup power, and obtaining specific data from VoIP providers. These regulations of the industry are necessary for both consumer protection and public safety.
However, for issues that have been identified as in need of regulation with VoIP- and IP-enabled services, it is obvious that the Legislature is best poised to act. For instance, from the time the CPUC directed staff to add new smartphone technology to the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program, it has been 9 years and the rule-making process is still not finalized. These delays can mean consumers lose out on the benefits of technological innovation or expanded services, such as Lifeline program savings for cellphone service.
AB 1366 would extend the sunset of provisions prohibiting state regulation of VoIP and IP enabled services except as specified by the Legislature for another 10 years, as well as put in place new customer protections regarding service restoration and disclosures. This would allow for continued legislative action on issues that may arise, particularly regarding consumer protection and public safety, while still allowing these services regulatory clarity.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents claim that the continued deregulation of VoIP will result in fewer consumer protections for the majority of Californians because VoIP lines now exceed traditional telephone lines. Opponents also argue that this bill goes beyond prohibiting CPUC regulation of VoIP by prohibiting any governmental entity’s exercise of duty over VoIP and IP-based services, including the collection of data necessary for effectively deploying broadband in underserved communities. Opponents also claim that the current regulatory environment at the federal level necessitates more state oversight on telecommunications issues, which includes the resolution of safety and customer service concerns. In opposition, the Communication Workers of America (CWA) state:
Our workers are on the frontlines and hear directly from consumers about their problems with telephone services, without the ability to have a state commission or entity address these concerns. Our members also witness safety issues with phone lines that are exacerbated by the lack of proper oversight or regulation due to the passage of AB 1161. CWA has long supported policies that protect consumers and hold telecommunications service providers accountable for their infrastructure and service. AB 1366 would further entrench all the issues that SB 1161 caused by extending its provisions until 2030. As customers continue to be switched from traditional phone service to VoIP, a growing majority of Californians will lose the protections they previously enjoyed and still deserve.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1366
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:May 20, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the prohibition on the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and Internet Protocol (IP) enable services except as expressly directed to do so by statute, until January 1, 2030.
Major Provisions
- Extends the prohibition on the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enable services except as expressly directed to do so by statute, until January 1, 2030, as specified.
- Requires a provider of residential interconnected VoIP service to include in its terms of service for residential customers a provision stating that the provider will provide to a customer, upon request, a bill credit when the customer experiences a service outage for more than 24 hours, as specified.
- Requires a provider of residential interconnected VoIP service to initiate steps to restore service within 24 hours of receiving a report of a service outage, as specified.
- Requires a provider of residential interconnected VoIP service to, within 72 hours of receiving a report of a residential interconnected VoIP service outage, restore service, which may include restoring service remotely, as specified.
COMMENTS:
CPUC: California Constitution Article XII established the CPUC and granted a high level of independence and authority to regulate public utilities including telephone corporations. Federal and state law differentiate regulatory authority based on the type of communications service. These services include landlines, wireless/cellular, cable/video, broadband/IP, and VoIP services.
IP and VoIP: IP enabled services are those services delivered by broadband such as instant messaging, email, web-surfing, video streaming, and voice communications. VoIP is the service that allows voice calling through a broadband connection. In simplest terms, IP services are those services delivered over the internet, while VoIP are those services that offer the same capabilities as a telephone but is delivered over the internet.
Public Utilities Code 710: SB 1161 (Padilla) Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012, prohibited the CPUC or any other state agency from regulating VoIP and IP enabled services unless expressly directed to do so by statute. SB 1161 was codified in Section 710 of the Public Utilities Code. Since the passage of SB 1161, consumers have increasingly continued to abandon landline service and opting instead for wireless and IP services. In 2013, there were over 13 million landlines in California and over 4 million VoIP subscribers. By 2018, just under 6 million customers had landlines and over 8 million had VoIP services.
Where We Stand: The debate over Public Utilities Code 710 ultimately centers around how rapidly changing technology, especially the internet, has led to a much different regulatory environment than in the days when telecommunications consisted only of landlines. The author views that the increasing adoption of VoIP services, as well as the existence of popular and useful applications, as evidence that the state's generally hands-off regulatory approach is working. Opponents contend that the increasing reliance of VoIP services make it an essential service and, therefore, in need of regulatory oversight. Opponents argue that absent the CPUC's ability to regulate and apply a new regulatory environment to these new technologies, the natural transition of customers from landline to wireless and VoIP services will slowly erode away years of safety and consumer protection telecommunications policies. The author counters that the Legislature, not the slow-moving, quasi-judicial CPUC, is the appropriate body to ensure VoIP consumers are protected.
According to the Author:
In 2012, the Legislature codified a policy of reserving any state regulation of [VoIP] and IP-enabled services for the Legislature […] However, the clarity provided with the Legislature's exclusive authority over these services will sunset on January 1, 2020 unless legislation extends the provisions. If allowed to sunset without further legislative direction, this will create an environment of regulatory uncertainty and potential for costly litigation on all sides, potentially delaying further expansion and innovation of these services.
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Cable and Telecommunications Association, "California's innovation drives demand for faster broadband networks and new IP-enabled services and applications, spurring new job creation and economic growth. This growth has been the result of government policies that promote an open and competitive internet that fosters innovation. These innovations have allowed Californians to improve their lives with greater access to education, jobs, health care, and government services, and have provided economically disadvantaged and immigrant families, an affordable way to stay connected with far-away family and friends.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to The Utility Reform Network, "The majority of telephone lines in California are now VoIP lines and much of our voice and data communication (including retail broadband) is provided over networks that at least partially rely on IP based transport. We are moving to a world where all of our phone and broadband service will be IP-based. AB 1366 would require the legislature and governor to pass a law before the [CPUC], any other state agency or the Legislature itself could take action to ensure reliable communication if it involves VoIP or IP communication […] This is not a path that the Legislature should follow."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would have no new state costs as a result of this bill's extension of the general prohibition against state regulatory action over VoIP and IP-enabled services. This bill would also have minor, absorbable costs to the CPUC to report annually to the Attorney General regarding the number and type of complaints received by the CPUC from VoIP customers about VoIP service and to include such information in its annual report to the Legislature.
VOTES:
ASM COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE: 12-0-1
YES: Santiago, Obernolte, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Gipson, Holden, Kamlager-Dove, Low, Patterson, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cervantes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-5
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 20, 2019
CONSULTANT: Edmond Cheung / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637 FN: 0000991
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1366
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2019
Policy Committee: | Communications and Conveyance | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends, until January 1, 2030, the existing general statutory prohibition on the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and any other entity or subdivision of state government to regulate Voice over Internet Protocol (VOIP) and Internet Protocol (IP) enabled services. The bill expands an area of exception to this general prohibition by specifying it does not affect the CPUC’s authority to regulate utility support structures, such as poles, whereas existing law authorizes the CPUC to regulate only the construction of such structures.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No new state costs as this bill extends a general prohibition against state regulatory action over VOIP and IP-enabled services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In 2012, the Legislature codified a policy of reserving any state regulation of [VoIP] and IP-enabled services for the Legislature. Since then, Californians have continued benefiting from these services…However, the clarity provided with the Legislature’s exclusive authority over these services will sunset on January 1, 2020 unless legislation extends the provisions. If allowed to sunset without further legislative direction, this will create an environment of regulatory uncertainty and potential for costly litigation on all sides, potentially delaying further expansion and innovation of these services…[Extension of the sunset] allow[s] for continued legislative action on issues that may arise, particularly regarding consumer protection and public safety, while still allowing these services regulatory clarity.
- Background. The California Constitution and statute charge the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) with regulating the rates and service of public utilities. This charge has included the regulation of telephone service, which was consistent with the CPUC’s regulation of natural monopolies that provide essential services. Overtime, however, the telecommunications industry has come to be less characterized by monopoly provision of service and more characterized by competition among rival service providers. Nonetheless, the CPUC regulated many aspects of the telecommunications service, mainly because the CPUC possessed the experience, expertise and regulatory framework to do so.
Earlier this century, a variety of telecommunications service providers began to offer telephone service through the use of VOIP. Through VOIP, providers could offer many more services than were available through the use of a landline-dependent telephone, such as text messages, email and web browsing. Crucially, VOIP telephone service does not require installation of a direct connection to a fixed location.
In 2012, the Legislature generally prohibited the CPUC, or any other state entity, from regulating VOIP service. (See SB 1161, (Padilla), Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012.) The bill asserted to goals of the prohibition:
- Preservation of the future of the internet by encouraging continued investment and technological advances and supporting continued consumer choice and access to innovative services that benefit California.
- Ensuring a vibrant and competitive open internet that allows California’s technology businesses to continue to flourish and contribute to economic development throughout the state.
SB 1161’s general prohibition expires on January 1, 2020.
At the time the Legislature passed SB 1161, there were 13 million landline telephones in California and over 4 million VOIP subscribers. Today, there are fewer than 6 million landlines in the state and over 8 million VOIP customers. (There are over 41 million wireless subscriptions in California, which are, for the most part, regulated by the federal government, not the state government.) The author views this increasing adoption of VOIP service, as well of the existence of popular and useful applications, such as WhatsApp, as evidence the state’s generally hands-off regulatory approach is working. Opponents contend the increasing reliance of VOIP service make it an essential service and, therefore, in need of regulatory oversight. The author counter the Legislature, not the slow-moving, quasi-judicial CPUC, is the appropriate body to ensure VOIP consumers are protected.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Miguel Santiago, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1366 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
SUBJECT: Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled communications services
SUMMARY: Extends indefinitely the prohibition on the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and Internet Protocol (IP) enable services except as expressly directed to do so by statute. Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the sunset on the prohibition on the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state to exercise regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enabled services except expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute, as specified.
- Authorizes the CPUC, or any department, agency commission, or political subdivision of the state to exercise regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enabled services if expressly and specifically directed by the Legislature in the interest of public safety or consumer protection.
- Exempts the CPUC’s authority relative to access to support structures, including pole attachments, or to the construction, safety, and maintenance of facilities pursuant to CPUC General Order 95 and General Order 128 from the specified prohibition.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state, from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enabled services except as required or expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute, as specified. Specifies that in the event of a requirement or a delegation referred to above, this statute does not expand the CPUC’s jurisdiction beyond the scope of that requirement or delegation. (Public Utilities Code (PUC) Section 710)
- Defines “Voice over Internet Protocol” or “VoIP” to mean voice communications service that does all of the following:
- Uses IP or a successor protocol to enable real-time, two-way voice communication that originates from, or terminates at, the user’s location in IP or a successor protocol;
- Requires a broadband connection from the user’s location; and,
- Permits a user generally to receive a call that originates on the public switched telephone network and to terminate a call to the public switched telephone network. (PUC Section 239)
- Defines “Internet Protocol enabled service” or “IP enabled service” to mean any service, capability, functionality, or application using existing IP, or any successor IP, that enables an end user to send or receive a communication in existing IP format, or any successor IP format through a broadband connection, regardless of whether the communication is voice, data, or video. (PUC Section 239)
- Exempts the following from the prohibition on exercising regulatory jurisdiction over VoIP and IP enabled services:
- The Emergency Telephone Users Surcharge Law and the state’s universal service programs;
- The Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 (DIVCA) or a specified franchise granted by a local franchising entity;
- The CPUC’s authority to implement and enforce specified interconnection agreements;
- The CPUC’s authority to require data and other information regarding federal forbearance petitions, as specified;
- The CPUC’s authority to address or affect the resolution of disputes regarding intercarrier compensation, including for the exchange of traffic that originated, terminated, or was translated at any point into IP format;
- The CPUC’s authority to enforce existing requirements regarding backup power systems, as specified;
- The CPUC authority relative to access to support structures, including pole attachments, or to the construction and maintenance of facilities pursuant to CPUC General Order 95 and General Order 128; and,
- The Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act. (PUC Section 710)
- Specifies that the specified prohibition on the CPUC to regulate VoIP or IP enabled services does not limit the CPUC’s ability to continue to monitor and discuss VoIP services, to track and report to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Legislature, within its annual report to the Legislature, the number and type of complaints received by the CPUC from customers, and to respond informally to customer complaints, including providing VoIP customers who contact the CPUC information regarding available options under state and federal law for addressing complaints. (PUC Section 710)
- Sunsets the specified prohibition on the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state to regulate VoIP or IP enabled services on January 1, 2020. (PUC Section 710)
- Establishes DIVCA which specifies that the CPUC is the sole franchising authority for a state franchise to provide video service. (PUC Section 5800 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has been keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Authors Statement: According to the author, “In 2012, the Legislature codified a policy of reserving any state regulation of [VoIP] and IP-enabled services for the Legislature. Since then, Californians have continued benefiting from these services […] However, the clarity provided with the Legislature’s exclusive authority over these services will sunset on January 1, 2020 unless legislation extends the provisions. If allowed to sunset without further legislative direction, this will create an environment of regulatory uncertainty and potential for costly litigation on all sides, potentially delaying further expansion and innovation of these services […] AB 1366 would delete the sunset of provisions prohibiting state regulation of VoIP and IP enabled services except as specified by the Legislature. This would allow for continued legislative action on issues that may arise, particularly regarding consumer protection and public safety, while still allowing these services regulatory clarity.”
- Background: Article XII of the California Constitution established the CPUC, as part Governor Hiram Johnson’s reform movement in the early 20th century. At the turn of the 20th century, California’s public policy was said to have been dictated primarily by the political machine of the Southern Pacific Railroad Corporation. In an effort to break the political and economic clout it held to avoid regulations and maintain its monopoly, the CPUC was granted a high level of independence to set its own procedures due in part to its unique position in the California Constitution. The CPUC is composed of five commissioners who are appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate, for six-year staggered terms to ensure that no single Governor could appoint a majority of commissioners within the Governor’s four year term. Only the Legislature has the power to remove commissioners.
In recent years, due to a number of high profile incidents in which the public and the Legislature perceived the CPUC as lacking in accountability or being too cozy with the industry in which they regulated, in 2016 the Legislature passed a series of reform seeking to improve the governance of the CPUC. The reforms sought to increase transparency and accountability on the CPUC and since then, the CPUC has made substantial strides towards reform, which include a new group of commissioners. But there are still those today who question the CPUC’s abilty to effectively regulate certain industries without overreaching or prescribing overly board or burdensome regulations.
- State Regulatory Authority: Through its history, the CPUC has had certain regulatory authority over public utilities including telephone corporations. A telephone corporation is defined as every corporation or person owning, controlling, operating, or managing any telephone line for compensation within the state. A “telephone line” includes “all conduits, ducts, poles, wires, cables, instruments, and appliances, and all other real estate, fixtures, and personal property owned, controlled, operated, or managed in connection with or to facilitate communication by telephone, whether such communication is had with or without the use of transmission wires.” For the most part the CPUC has regulatory authority to regulate intrastate components of telecommunications services, whereas, interstate components of telecommunications services is regulated at the federal level.
Federal and state law differentiate regulatory authority based on the type of communications service. These services include landlines, wireless/cellular, cable/video, broadband/IP, and VoIP services. Below is a general summary on the explicit authority to regulate each service:
Landlines: The CPUC has authority under the Public Utilities Code to impose regulations and requirements on landline services. Some of these requirements include service quality, consumer protection, privacy, supplier diversity, carrier of last resort, submission of tariffs, disconnections, complaints, and user fees.
Wireless/Cellular: Federal law prohibits states from regulating wireless rates or entry into the market, but reserves to states the authority to regulate other terms and conditions of service. Generally, the CPUC has authority over the siting of cell towers. The CPUCs General Order 159-A sets out the rules governing the construction of cell towers in the State.
Cable/Video: DIVCA prevents the CPUC from regulating cable services. However, cable companies wishing to build new video and broadband infrastructure must apply for a state issued franchise from the CPUC to cover a service territory to operate. DIVCA left most standard requirements of a franchise in place and under local control, but required all video providers to offer and fund public education and government channels.
IP/Broadband: Public Utilities Code Section 710 prohibits the regulation of IP enabled services until 2020. Broadband/IP is inherently classified as an interstate service regulated at the federal level. The FCC had provided limited authority over these services to address the needs of emergency communications or law enforcement, public safety, or national security authorities, however, following the 2017 FCC Restoring Internet Freedom Order, such services were reclassified as an information service, outside the regulation of traditional telecommunications services.
VoIP: Similar to IP services, Public Utilities Code Section 710 prohibits the regulation of these services until 2020. The code offers a number of exemptions including some to ensure competition in the market and emergency services.
- IP and VoIP: IP enabled services are those services delivered by broadband which include services such as instant messaging, email, web-surfing, video streaming, and voice communications. VoIP is the service that allows voice calling through a broadband connection, such as Skype or Google Voice. Unlike traditional telephones, companies using VoIP technology to offer telephone service do not have to install or lease a direct connection to that customers home or business. Instead the customer must have a broadband internet connection provided by a third company, then the customer can use the combination of their internet connection and VoIP technology to make telephone calls anywhere. As a result of IP technology, companies are able to offer more features and services that would otherwise not be available with a traditional telephone. In simplest terms, IP services are those services delivered over the internet, while VoIP are those services that offer the same capabilities as a telephone but is delivered over the internet.
- Public Utilities Code 710: In 2012, the Legislature passed SB 1161 (Padilla) Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012, which prohibited the CPUC or any other state agency from regulating VoIP and IP enabled services unless expressly directed to do so by statute. SB 1161 was codified in Section 710 of the Public Utilities Code. At the time, proponents argued that SB 1161 would provide a platform for innovation, facilitates competition and cost savings for consumers, and will drive job growth, broadband deployment, and greater economic prosperity for the State. Opponents argued that SB 1161 would “deregulate” the telecommunications industry and eliminate laws and regulation that apply to landline services, putting at risk consumers protections that exist for landlines but not VoIP.
- Governance of VoIP vs. Landlines: When SB 1161 was passed, VoIP technology was just beginning to expand beyond a nuance technology. Since then, consumers have increasingly continued to abandon landline service and opting instead for wireless and IP services that offers a platform for integrated voice, video and data service all in one. As telecommunications providers continue to migrate customers away from landlines to VoIP, the number of subscribers to VoIP service will continue to increase dramatically. In 2013, when SB 1161 came into effect, there were over 13 million landlines in California and over 4 million VoIP subscribers. By 2018, just under 6 million customers had landlines and over 8 million had VoIP services. In addition, in 2018 the state has over 41 million wireless subscriptions.
Although SB 1161 distinguishes between IP and VoIP, much of the debate has centered on the VoIP aspect and its impact on phone service. But because VoIP is provided over an IP network, it is difficult to separate and craft separate policies between the two. Once again, much of the oppositions centers on the issue that as more people move away from landlines to VoIP, many of the protections that exist for landlines are not available for VoIP services. Hence the natural transition of customers from landline to wireless and VoIP services will slowly erode away years of safety and consumer protection telecommunications policies absent the CPUC’s abilty to regulate and apply a new regulatory environment to these new technologies.
For comparison, below are some of the regulatory requirement over telecommunications providers compared to the same such regulation on VoIP services.
Basic Service: The CPUC currently requires traditional telephone companies to provide basic service. Basic service includes: a) voice grade access to the public switched telephone network or successor network; b) real time two way communications; c) access to 911 services; d) access to residential backup power; e) access to directory services; f) billing protections; g) access to toll-free numbers; h) telephone relay service for deaf and disabled consumers; i) equal access to interexchange carriers; and j) conditions of service notification to consumers. Public Utilities Code 710 does not impact the CPUC regulation on traditional telephone service, but VoIP providers are not mandated to provide basic service but most providers generally includes most of the elements of basic service.
Service Quality: The CPUC requires traditional telephone companies to report their average out of service metrics. The standard is 90 percent outages restored within 24 hours or less. Failure to meet these standards can result in fines by the CPUC to ensure that investments are made by telephone companies to maintain their network. VoIP providers are not mandated to comply with CPUC rules dealing with service quality but they may include enforceable standards in their terms and conditions of service and can be subject to liability for missing installation and repair times.
Carrier of Last Resort: A Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) is a traditional telephone company that is required to serve, upon request, all customers within their service area to ensure that everyone has access to basic service. Once designated a COLR, the carriers must get CPUC approval to opt out of the obligation to service. VoIP service providers do not have COLR obligations.
Universal Service Programs: The CPUC implements a number of universal service programs including the California High Cost Fund-A, the California High Cost Fund-B, the California Lifeline Program, the California Teleconnect Fund, the California Advanced Services Fund, and the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program. These programs are funded through a surcharge on each customer’s phone bill for intrastate telecommunications services. VoIP service providers are required to contribute to the state’s universal service programs. Public Utilities Code 710 exempts the collection of the State 911 and universal service surcharges from its prohibition.
Tariffs: The CPUC requires basic service to be tariffed and establishes general rules for the submission of tariffs, which provides the public with transparency should prices, charges, or terms and conditions of service change. CPUC rules do not apply to VoIP services but generally applicable laws regarding contracting and customer notification apply.
Interconnection Agreements: To encourage competition in the telecommunications market, federal law establishes certain duties and obligations on incumbent local exchange carriers to provide interconnection and access to services and network elements to other telecommunications carriers. Public Utilities Code 710 exempts the CPUC’s authority to enforce interconnection agreements from its prohibitions.
Backup Battery: Power outages are less of an issue for landlines because they are powered by an independent electrical source, however, VoIP phones typically depend on a power source as well as a broadband connection. Hence, some VoIP services do not work during power outages which can be dangerous in emergency situations. Federal Rules requires VoIP providers to offer their customers the option to purchase 8 or 24 hours of backup battery power.
Complaints: The CPUC receives data on customer complaints from the companies it regulates including traditional telephone companies. However, it does not receive this information from wireless, VoIP and IP companies. Public Utilities Code 710 allows the CPUC to continue to monitor and discuss VoIP services and to report to the Legislature the number and type of complaints received by the CPUC and to respond informally to customer complaints, including providing VoIP customers who contact the CPUC with information regarding available options. Hence, the CPUC does not get customer complaint data from VoIP service providers, and customers who complain about VoIP services to the CPUC are directed to alternative options.
- Emergency Communications: The scale and frequency of recent wildfires in California has spurred a discussion on the emergency communications capabilities of our public safety officials. As more people move away from landlines to IP based systems, ensuring that the state’s emergency communications network can support this transition is critical. In April 2019, the CPUC released a white paper identifying regulatory and statutory gaps in communications that, if addressed, would significantly enhance public safety. The white paper specifically identified Public Utilities Code 710 as a significant obstacle in their ability to require communications provider to protect the public during an emergency.
The Office of Emergency Services is in the mist of transitioning the State’s existing 911 system to Next Generation 911 which is a new IP based two way communications system for public safety. Next Generation 911 would lay the groundwork for a new communications system for our first responders that has the capabilities to support advanced technologies and uses. Public Utilities Code 710 does not affect the Warren-911 Emergency Assistance Act which governs the State’s 911 system, however, ensuring that emergency communications networks are still able to work seamlessly as it also transitions to an IP based system would be critical for public safety.
- Where We Stand: The debate over Public Utilities Code 710 ultimately centers around how rapidly changing technology, especially the internet, has led to a much different regulatory environment than in the days when telecommunications consist only of landlines. When SB 1161 was passed, the question at hand was what California’s policy and government framework should be as increasing numbers of customers abandon traditional landline service and choose to subscribe to new services accessible with a broadband connection. SB 1161 included a 2020 sunset to allow the Legislature to revisit the issue. That question and debate is now being revisited.
This bill would extends indefinitely the prohibition on the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enable services except as expressly directed to do so by statute.
It is hard to quantify whether or not the regulatory environment created by Public Utilities Code 710 contributed to the growth and innovation of VoIP and other IP enabled services. Certainly since the passage of SB 1161 we have seen an expansion of internet innovation and technology. However, with that comes all the issues associated with the telecommunications industry. Arguably extension of Public Utilities Code 710 would reflect the status quo and the certainty it provides the industry. However, whether or not the status quo of today would work in the future is less then certain.
The author may wish to consider an amendment sunsetting the bill in 2030.
- Suggested Amendments:
710 (h) This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
- Arguments in Support: According to the California Cable and Telecommunications Association, “California’s innovation drives demand for faster broadband networks and new IP-enabled services and applications, spurring new job creation and economic growth. This growth has been the result of government policies that promote an open and competitive internet that fosters innovation. These innovations have allowed Californians to improve their lives with greater access to education, jobs, health care, and government services, and have provided economically disadvantaged and immigrant families, an affordable way to stay connected with far-away family and friends. Regulatory agencies, like the CPUC, do not focus on visionary innovation. They are overwhelmed by bureaucracy, with multi-year proceedings and protracted decision-making and are not equipped to regulate modern internet technology.”
- Arguments in Opposition: According to The Utility Reform Network, “AB 1366 indefinitely extends the prohibition on [CPUC] oversight of [VoIP] and IP communication services, due to sunset on January 1, 2020. The majority of telephone lines in California are now VoIP lines and much of our voice and data communication (including retail broadband) is provided over networks that at least partially rely on IP based transport. We are moving to a world where all of our phone and broadband service will be IP-based. AB 1366 would require the legislature and governor to pass a law before the [CPUC], any other state agency or the Legislature itself could take action to ensure reliable communication if it involves VoIP or IP communication. AB 1366 would indefinitely remove all state oversight of critical public communication services. This is not a path that the Legislature should follow.”
- Prior Legislation: SB 1161 (Padilla) of 2012 prohibits the CPUC, or any department, agency, commission, or political subdivision of the state, from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over VoIP and IP enabled services except as expressly directed to do so by statute until 2020. Status: Chaptered by the Secretary of State – Chapter 733, Statutes of 2012.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
African American Male Education Network & Development
Alliance for Community Development
Asian Business Association of San Diego
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association
AT&T
Bay Area Council
Black Chamber of Orange County
Black Women Organized for Political Action Political Action Committee
Boys & Girls Club of the North Valley
Brotherhood Crusade
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Cattlemen's Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Latino Leadership Institute
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
Chicano Federation of San Diego County, Inc.
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Women Vital Voices
Computers 2 Kids
Computing Technology Industry Association
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Congress of California Seniors
Consolidated Communications Inc.
CTIA - The Wireless Association
East Oakland Youth Development Center
Frontier Communications
Frontier Senior Center - AAASCO
Gamma Zeta Boule Foundation
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce
Hispanic 100
Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center
In Biz Latino
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Invest in Women Entrepreneurs Initiative
Kings/Tulare Homeless Alliance
Krimson and Kreme Foundation
Lighthouse Counseling and Family Resource Center
Los Angeles Latino Chamber of Commerce
MAAC
Macedonia Community Development Corporation
National Diversity Coalition
Nonprofit Alliance
North San Diego County NAACP
OASIS Center International
Organization of Chinese Americans - East Bay Chapter
Organization of Chinese Americans - Sacramento Chapter
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Oroville Rescue Mission
Partners in College Success
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Salvadoran American Leadership and Educational Fund
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Oasis
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Barbara Partners in Education
Sentinels of Freedom
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Society for the Blind
South Bay Community Services
TechNet
TELACU
The Fresno Center
The Village Project, Inc.
UFCW Local 648
Urban Corps San Diego County
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Verizon
Veterans Association of North County
Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
Opposition
AARP California
Access Humboldt
Bay Area Christian Connection
Beth Eden Baptist Church
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Labor Federation
Center for Media Justice
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
City Heights Community Development Corporation
Common Networks
Communications Workers of America, 9th District
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation of California
El Concilio of San Mateo County
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Emerging Leaders Program of The Leadership Institute at Allen Temple Baptist Church
Housing Long Beach
Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Interdenominational Ministerial Alliance
Media Alliance
Mission Asset Fund
Monkeybrains
National Consumer Law Center
Omsoft and Davis Community Network
One Million NIU
Poverello House
Public Advocates Office
Public Citizen, Inc.
The Center for Media Justice
The Greenlining Institute
The Utility Reform Network
True Faith Community Baptist Church
Utility Consumers’ Action Network
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):