AB 1602: Use of firearm insurance.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 4.) (April 24). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 9, 2019 | AB 1602 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Senator Susan Rubio, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1602 Hearing Date: July 10, 2019
Author: | Low | ||
Version: | July 2, 2019 As amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brian Flemmer | ||
SUBJECT: Use of firearm insurance.
DIGEST:
Prohibits issuance of an insurance policy covering loss related to firearm use, subject to several exceptions.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides broadly for the regulation of insurance and insurance companies by the Department of Insurance (CDI) headed by the Insurance Commissioner (commissioner).
- Requires that all property-casualty insurance is subject to both rate and policy form approval by CDI.
- Provides that an insurer is not liable for a loss caused by the willful act of the insured, including murder. (Ins. Code § 533)[1]
- Prohibits soliciting contracts of insurance unless the person holds a valid license. (Ins. Code § 1631)
- Authorizes the CDI to enforce the insurance laws of this state by various means, including the issuance of a cease and desist order when a license from the commissioner is required but not possessed. (Ins. Code § 12921.8(a))
This bill:
- Provides that a policy of insurance issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, shall not cover a loss related to the use of a firearm.
- Provides that this rule does not apply to:
- Loss of or damage to property;
- An automobile liability insurance policy;
- A homeowners insurance policy; and
- A commercial insurance policy, including umbrella, excess liability, and excess property insurance policies.
- Provides an exception that commercial insurance may be issued to a licensed firearms dealer that insures against liability for either property damage or bodily injury as a result of the sale, theft, lease or transfer of a firearm or ammunition or other operations of the dealer’s business.
- Provides that a surplus line broker shall not place any prohibited firearm policies with nonadmitted insurers.
Background
According to the author, “Gun owners should not be allowed to shoot first and have their criminal legal fees covered. AB 1602 prevents the [National Rifle Association] from selling ‘murder insurance’ in California. This bill will hold gun owners accountable when they pull the trigger.”
Carry Guard Membership. In April 2017, the National Rifle Association (NRA) introduced “Carry Guard,” a membership program offering “comprehensive coverage and training” for those who carry a gun. On the NRA Carry Guard website, NRA CEO Wayne LaPierre states the program offers “the most comprehensive training curriculum ever developed for men and women who carry firearms.”
The program is available in 48 states, includes hands on training for weapon-handling proficiency, and contains a video series that focuses at least in part on navigating the “legal procedural considerations that often have no apprehension of the realities of violence.” This training highlights the difference between legal self-defense and retribution, and provides tips on how to use the legal concept of the totality of circumstances to “articulate the threat,” presumably when discussing the shooting with the police or in court.
Similarly, the NRA offers a free guide online that offers advice on what to do and how to act after a shooting, including advice on talking to police and preparing for a legal battle. Carry Guard’s website states that it is far too easy for an innocent person to be convicted of a crime and therefore, “knowing in advance what to say and do gives you the best chance for avoiding extensive legal proceedings and even prison.”
Policy Details. The “Carry Guard Personal Firearms Liability Including Self Defense Insurance Policy” included with membership covers legal damages from bodily injury or property damage arising out of use of a firearm, air gun, bow and arrow, or trapping equipment if the injury or damage occurred during certain activities. The qualifying activities are self-defense (including self-defense by a resident family member while at home), hunting, shooting at competitions or for recreation, and accidental discharge.
Policy benefits include defense of a civil suit and indemnification of a civil judgment or settlement, as well as reimbursement of costs of a criminal proceeding that does not result in a conviction or guilty plea. In this sense, the moniker “murder insurance” is inaccurate as someone convicted of murder (or manslaughter) would not be able to have their criminal defense costs reimbursed. If innocent, qualifying criminal proceeding costs include attorney consultation and retainer, bail, psychological counseling support, biohazard cleanup, and confiscated firearm replacement. Four levels of coverage are available, with ranges of $250,000 to $1.5 million for civil defense benefits, and $50,000 to $250,000 in criminal defense benefits. As of July 26, 2018, there were 2,397 California resident policyholders.
Program Partners and Regulatory Setbacks. Carry Guard was developed by the NRA in partnership with a large insurance brokerage firm located in New York, Lockton Affinity (the program’s administrator), and the world’s largest publicly traded property and casualty insurer, Chubb Ltd. (the program’s underwriter). The NRA receives a royalty fee for the licensing of its name and trademarks as part of the insurance program offered to NRA Carry Guard members. The NRA employed an email marketing campaign to promote the insurance product, including sending emails to its national mailing list that featured the spokesperson or CEO asking the recipient to “sign up for NRA Carry Guard today!” and explaining the program benefits, including insurance.
Generally, a license is required to engage in marketing insurance products, and several states have or are investigating the NRA’s marketing push. Notably, New York State set their sights on Lockton and Chubb in 2018, fining them $7 million and $1.3 million respectively, for unlawfully providing liability coverage to gun owners, citing lack of licensing and public policy considerations. In consent agreements related to the fines, Chubb agreed not to provide Carry Guard in New York State and Lockton agreed not to participate in Carry Guard or any other NRA-endorsed programs in New York. Additionally, the State of Washington deemed the program illegal in January 2019, and New Jersey is currently investigating.
In February 2018, Lockton announced by tweet that it would discontinue providing brokerage services for the NRA under the terms of its contract. Also in February, Chubb announced that it had provided notice to the NRA of its intent to discontinue participation in Carry Guard three months earlier. The NRA has since filed and settled breach of contract suits with both companies, but details of any resolution are unknown. It is unclear whether the companies have followed through with their original announcements; Lockton Affinity still maintains a program administrator website, where it lists Illinois Union Insurance Company, a Chubb group member, as the Carry Guard underwriter.
Cease and Desist. In May 2018, Commissioner Dave Jones issued a cease and desist order to the Carry Guard managing agent. The order did not claim that coverage itself was illegal, like Washington, but took issue with the NRA improperly marketing Carry Guard as the NRA is not nor has ever been licensed to transact insurance in California. The underlying insurance program may still be sold in California if licensed agents market the policy. For this reason, the author believes last year’s cease and desist order is not strong enough and an outright prohibition is in order.
Enumerated Exceptions. The primary goal of the bill is to prohibit the specific limited scope policy such as the Carry Guard program. In an effort to avoid disruptions in the mainstream property and liability markets, the bill specifies several types of policies that cover firearm related losses that are excluded from the rule adopted by the bill.
- Homeowners insurance, excepted from the prohibition, will typically cover true accidents, including an accidental discharge of a firearm in the home, as long as the incident is not deemed criminal. For instance, the all too common scenario where a toddler finds a loaded gun and shoots someone may not be covered by homeowners liability insurance, as California Penal Code 25100 applies criminal penalties for unsafe storage of firearms.
Homeowners liability coverage is also not limited to events occurring in the home, but covers the insured outside the home as well. An accidental discharge resulting in injury at a restaurant or bar while a concealed weapons holder has their weapon properly holstered, for example, would likely be covered. But, most homeowners (and auto) policies exclude intentional injury from liability coverage. Courts nationally are split, but many courts have held that self-defense is an exception to this exclusion; insurers in turn often write a “reasonable force” requirement into their policies to temper the scope of the self-defense exception.
A typical homeowners policy includes $100,000 to $300,000 of liability insurance, well below the $1.5 million Carry Guard offers for civil defense, but may not include additional costs a homeowner would pay under its duty to defend because the insurer's obligation to defend is separate from its duty to indemnify, which is limited by the policy. The insurer has a duty to pay damages that result from a covered claim even if no defense is required. The reverse is also true. The insurer may be obligated to defend their client even if it has no duty to pay damages. If AB 1602 becomes law, Carry Guard members who wish to maintain a higher level of coverage for indemnity from civil actions relating to firearm accidents will be able to purchase higher liability coverage limits through their homeowners insurer.
- Commercial insurance, including multiperil, property, liability, umbrella and excess liability are all exempt from the provisions of AB 1602. The effect of such exception will allow businesses such as shooting ranges and firearm dealers to maintain coverage to properly protect against liability that may result from firearm related injury or death on their premises.
- Recent amendments include an insurer request that automobile liability insurance policies be exempted. Like homeowners insurance, auto policies may cover liability resulting from firearm use, including in self-defense. Similar safe-storage laws apply to vehicles, and may affect claims determination if not followed.
- In addition to the general commercial insurance exception, AB 1602 provides that firearms dealers may purchase insurance to protect themselves from liability caused by a third party inflicted firearm injury or death, whether the firearm is sold, leased, or stolen. The Federal Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (FPLCAA) generally bars lawsuits in federal or state court against firearm manufacturers, distributors, and dealers when a third party acquires a firearm and uses it for criminal ends, subject to exceptions. The Connecticut Supreme Court ruled one such exception allowed a wrongful death lawsuit go forward against the manufacturer, distributor, and dealer of the rifle used by the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooter. If other courts follow suit to open up the liability that may be assigned under the FPLCAA, and given the propensity for high casualty shootings throughout America, firearms dealers may have a greater need for this type of insurance in the future. Without such insurance, victims of gun violence may be limited in their recovery from wrongful death suits.
Questions
Will banning the Carry Guard and like policies in California cause gun owners to think twice about pulling the trigger? The author asserts that having a Carry Guard policy allows a gun owner to pull the trigger without accountability. Given the homeowners and auto insurance liability exceptions that will provide some protection in civil matters, the largest impact of AB 1602 will be in the criminal defense space. Since Carry Guard only reimburses criminal costs if the shooter is not guilty of a crime, it is questionable whether a Carry Guard membership translates into an incentive for gun owners to commit crimes with their weapons.
Technical Amendment:
AB 1602’s exclusion states in Ins. Code § 12130(a), “A policy of insurance issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, shall not cover a loss related to the use of a firearm, except for loss of, or damage to, property.” The committee recommends a technical amendment that would clarify the restriction established by this bill does not apply to life insurance. Generally, life insurance benefits will be paid after suicide, including by firearm, if it occurs 2 years or more after the issuance of the policy. As currently written, this bill might unintentionally harm the beneficiaries of life insurance policies by restricting their access to the benefit payment.
Therefore, the Committee recommends amending Ins. Code § 12130(a) to read, “A policy of liability insurance issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, shall not cover a loss related to the use of a firearm, except for loss of, or damage to, property.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 231 (Ting, Chapter 730, Statutes of 2013) established the offense of criminal storage of a firearm in the 3rd degree. However, a previous version of the bill than the one enacted would have removed the dollar limitations put on parental liability for the acts of a minor with a firearm, and would have extended the liability limitations as to the insurer for liability arising out of the discharge of a firearm by a minor.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Bay Area Student Activists argues this type of policy gives gun owners a false sense of security, and that gun owners should not be able to shoot first and have criminal fees covered.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The NRA writes, “This legislation is just one more attack on the law-abiding gun owners of California, eliminating the ability to secure insurance that may provide protections in any number of circumstances including self-defense, hunting accidents or other circumstances. It’s important to keep in mind that criminals are not out securing insurance for their misdeeds, nor would any insurance policy cover criminal acts.”
The Outdoor Sportsmen’s Coalition of California argues that AB 1602 would violate equal protection under the law and may be unconstitutional because it would “statutorily discriminate against an individual because they lawfully own specified types of consumer products.” They note the bill would deny liability coverage to firearms owners, but not to owners of other kinds of property such as automobiles, sporting goods equipment like golf clubs or baseball bats, kitchen knives, or most power tools.
SUPPORT:
Bay Area Student Activists
OPPOSITION:
California Sportman’s Lobby
Gun Owners of California
National Rifle Association
National Shooting Sports Foundation
Outdoor Sportsmen’s Coalition of California
Safari Club International
-- END --
Studley v. Benecia Unified Sch. Dist. (1991) 230 Cal. App 3d 454, 459, 281 Cal Rptr. 631. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1602
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a policy of insurance, subject to exceptions, from providing coverage for a loss related to the use of a firearm.
Major Provisions
Prohibits the sale of stand-alone so-called "murder insurance" while at the same time ensuring that traditional liability insurance contained in homeowners', umbrella, and commercial liability policies that cover firearm-related liability claims is not impacted.
COMMENTS:
Background: The insurance policy at issue with this bill covers legal expenses for both criminal and civil defense costs, as well as indemnification of a civil judgment or settlement of any matter that involves the use of a firearm causing bodily injury or death. Attorneys' fees, bail costs, and lost income (while incarcerated or otherwise unable to work due to the use of a firearm incident) are among the costs that the policy covers. It is sold through a managing general agent located in another state, and underwritten by Chubb – one of the largest insurance companies in the world – under the marketing label "Carry Guard" program. It provides up to $1.5 million of coverage.
Last year, Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones issued a cease and desist order to the managing agent that was marketing the Carry Guard program. However, that order did not purport to characterize the coverage itself as illegal in California – unlike some states such as Washington that has issued an order declaring the policy itself to be a violation of Washington state law. Rather, the 2018 cease and desist order was directed at the improper marketing without a valid license to transact this insurance in California. As a result, the underlying insurance program could still be sold in California if proper licensing is obtained, or other agents that are duly licensed market the policy. For this reason, the author believes last year's cease and desist order is not strong enough, and an outright prohibition is in order.
According to the Author:
According to the author, gun owners should not be allowed to shoot first, and then have their legal fees covered if they are charged with a crime. This bill is intended to prohibit the National Rifle Association (NRA) and others from selling "murder insurance" in California. It will hold gun owners responsible and accountable when they pull the trigger.
Arguments in Support:
Critics of the insurance plan that is marketed in conjunction with NRA firearm education programs refer to the insurance as "murder insurance" because it provides coverage whether or not the insured firearm user is found criminally responsible, or it is determined that the firearm user acted in self-defense. These critics argue that a policy of this nature is an unnecessary and dangerous incentive that enables a person to "shoot first and worry about the consequences later." They believe that the burden of intentionally using a firearm against another person should not be lightened in this manner.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the opposition, the bill would "without valid or reasonable rationale, statutorily discriminate against an individual simply because they lawfully own" specified kinds of consumer products, and therefore may violate the equal protection clause of the constitution. The opponents believe the bill unjustly denies liability protection to firearm owners, but not to owners of other kinds of property, such as automobiles, golf clubs, baseball bats, power tools or kitchen knives, that can result in liability for bodily injury due to use of the property.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Undetermined
VOTES:
ASM INSURANCE: 8-4-2
YES: Daly, Berman, Calderon, Chu, Cooper, Gipson, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove
NO: Bigelow, Chen, Cooley, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mayes, Frazier
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0000278
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1602 (
Author:Low) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
SUBJECT: Use of firearm insurance
SUMMARY: Prohibits a policy of insurance, subject to exceptions, from providing coverage for a loss related to the use of a firearm. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a policy of insurance issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, shall not cover a loss related to the use of a firearm.
- Provides that this rule does not apply to:
- Loss of or damage to property;
- Homeowners’ insurance, as defined in a specific provision of the Insurance Code;
- A commercial insurance policy that covers risks described in a specific provision of the Insurance Code; or
- Umbrella, excess liability, and excess property insurance policies described in a specific provision of the Insurance Code.
- Provides that, notwithstanding the bill’s prohibition, an insurer may issue or renew a policy of commercial insurance to a licensed firearms dealer that insures against liability for either property damage or bodily injury as a result of the sale, theft, lease or transfer of a firearm or ammunition or other operations of the dealer’s business.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides broadly for the regulation of insurance and insurance companies by the Department of Insurance (DOI), headed by the Insurance Commissioner (commissioner).
- Requires that all property-casualty insurance is subject to both rate and policy form approval by the DOI.
- Authorizes the DOI to enforce the insurance laws of this state by various means, including the issuance of a cease and desist order in the case of behavior the DOI deems unlawful.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, gun owners should not be allowed to shoot first, and then have their legal fees covered if they are charged with a crime. AB 1602 is intended to prohibit the National Rifle Association (NRA) and others from selling “murder insurance” in California. It will hold gun owners responsible and accountable when they pull the trigger.
- What is covered? The insurance policy at issue with this bill covers legal expenses for both criminal and civil defense costs, as well as indemnification of a civil judgment or settlement of any matter that involves the use of a firearm causing bodily injury or death. Attorneys’ fees, bail costs, and lost income (while incarcerated or otherwise unable to work due to the use of a firearm incident) are among the costs that the policy covers. It is sold through a managing general agent located in another state, and underwritten by Chubb – one of the largest insurance companies in the world – under the marketing label “Carry Guard” program. It provides up to $1.5 million of coverage.
- “Murder insurance”. Critics of the insurance plan that is marketed in conjunction with NRA firearm education programs refer to the insurance as “murder insurance” because it provides coverage whether or not the insured firearm user is found criminally responsible, or it is determined that the firearm user acted in self-defense. These critics argue that a policy of this nature is an unnecessary and dangerous incentive that enables a person to “shoot first and worry about the consequences later.” They believe that the burden of intentionally using a firearm against another person should not be lightened in this manner.
- Cease and Desist order. Last year, Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones issued a cease and desist order to the managing agent that was marketing the Carry Guard program. However, that order did not purport to characterize the coverage itself as illegal in California – unlike some states such as Washington that has issued an order declaring the policy itself to be a violation of Washington state law. Rather, the 2019 cease and desist order was directed at the improper marketing without a valid license to transact this insurance in California. As a result, the underlying insurance program could still be sold in California if proper licensing is obtained, or other agents that are duly licensed market the policy. For this reason, the author believes last year’s cease and desist order is not strong enough, and an outright prohibition is in order.
- Constitutionality? According to the opposition, the bill would “without valid or reasonable rationale, statutorily discriminate against an individual simply because they lawfully own” specified kinds of consumer products, and therefore may violate the equal protection clause of the constitution. The opponents believe the bill unjustly denies liability protection to firearm owners, but not to owners of other kinds of property, such as automobiles, golf clubs, baseball bats, power tools or kitchen knives, that can result in liability for bodily injury due to use of the property.
- Automobile liability insurance. The primary goal of the bill is to prohibit the specific limited scope policy such as the Carry Guard program. In an effort to avoid disruptions in the mainstream property and liability markets – such as a homeowners’ insurance policy that lenders require of homeowners that includes liability protections – the bill specifies a range of multi-peril insurance that in theory could provide some liability coverage in a firearm situation that are excluded from the rule adopted by the bill. A common example would be a tragic shooting where a homeowner negligently stored a firearm, and a young child managed to either intentionally or accidentally shoot a playmate. Insurers have suggested that automobile liability insurance policies should also be included in the list of exceptions. The author may wish to evaluate this suggestion should the bill pass this Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None received
Opposition
National Rifle Association (NRA)
National Shooting Sports Foundation
Outdoor Sportsmen’s Coalition of California
Safari Club International (SCI)
The California Sportsman’s Lobby
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):